<mods xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3" version="3.3" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3 http://www.loc.gov/standards/mods/v3/mods-3-3.xsd" ID="P0b002ee1d49aaed3">
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States Government Publishing Office</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">publisher</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">pbl</roleTerm>
        </role>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">distributor</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">dst</roleTerm>
        </role>
    </name>
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
         <namePart>United States Supreme Court</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">author</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">aut</roleTerm>
        </role>
         <description>Government Organization</description>
    </name>
    <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
    <genre authority="marcgt">government publication</genre>
    <language>
         <languageTerm type="code" authority="iso639-2b">eng</languageTerm>
    </language>
    <extension>
         <collectionCode>USREPORTS</collectionCode>
         <category>Judicial Publications</category>
         <branch>judicial</branch>
         <dateIngested>2025-07-03</dateIngested>
    </extension>
    <titleInfo>
         <title>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853</title>
    </titleInfo>
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:56</classification>
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
         <namePart>Supreme Court</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">author</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">aut</roleTerm>
        </role>
    </name>
    <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56</identifier>
    <location>
         <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56</url>
         <url displayLabel="PDF rendition" access="raw object">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56.pdf</url>
         <url displayLabel="Text rendition" access="raw object">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/text/USREPORTS-56.txt</url>
    </location>
    <extension>
         <searchtitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853</searchtitle>
         <docClass>USREPORTS</docClass>
         <accessId>USREPORTS-56</accessId>
         <volume>56</volume>
         <dateIssued notSpecified="day-month">1889</dateIssued>
         <reporter abbrev="How." name="Benjamin Chew Howard" volume="15"></reporter>
         <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
    </extension>
                            
    <titleInfo>
                                    
         <title>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, 56</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo displayLabel="Some issues have title:" type="alternative">
                                    
         <title>Reports of cases argued and determined in the Supreme Court of the United States</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo displayLabel="Commonly referred to as v. 5-67 of:" type="alternative">
                                    
         <title>United States reports</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo displayLabel="Cited as:" type="alternative">
                                    
         <title>U.S</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo type="uniform">
                                    
         <title>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States (Online)</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <name type="corporate">
                                    
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart>Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                    
         <role>
                                            
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">creator</roleTerm>
                                        
        </role>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <name type="personal">
                                    
         <namePart>Cranch, William</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart type="date">1769-1855</namePart>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <name type="personal">
                                    
         <namePart>Wheaton, Henry</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart type="date">1785-1848</namePart>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <name type="personal">
                                    
         <namePart>Peters, Richard</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart type="date">1780-1848</namePart>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <name type="personal">
                                    
         <namePart>Howard, Benjamin C. (Benjamin Chew)</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart type="date">1791-1872</namePart>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <name type="personal">
                                    
         <namePart>Black, Jeremiah S. (Jeremiah Sullivan)</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart type="date">1810-1883</namePart>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                            
    <genre authority="marcgt">legal case and case notes</genre>
                            
    <genre authority="fast">Periodicals.</genre>
                            
    <originInfo>
                                    
         <place>
                                            
              <placeTerm authority="marccountry" type="code">dcu</placeTerm>
                                        
        </place>
                                    
         <place>
                                            
              <placeTerm type="text">Washington City</placeTerm>
                                        
        </place>
                                    
         <publisher>Published for John Conrad and Co.</publisher>
                                    
         <dateIssued>1889</dateIssued>
                                    
         <dateCreated encoding="marc" point="start">1803</dateCreated>
                                    
         <dateCreated encoding="marc" point="end">1862</dateCreated>
                                    
         <issuance>continuing</issuance>
                                    
         <frequency>Irregular</frequency>
                                
    </originInfo>
                            
    <language>
                                    
         <languageTerm authority="iso639-2b" type="code">eng</languageTerm>
                                
    </language>
                            
    <physicalDescription>
                                    
         <extent>1 online resource (volumes)</extent>
                                
    </physicalDescription>
                            
    <note type="date/sequential designation">Vol. 1 (Aug. and Dec. terms 1801 and Feb. term 1803)-v. 9 (Feb. term 1815) ; vol. 1 (Feb. term 1816)-v. 12 (Jan. term 1827); vol. 1 (Jan. term 1828)-v. 17 (Jan. term 1843) ; vol. 1 (Jan. term 1843)-v. 24 (Dec. term 1860) ; vol. 1 (Dec. term, 1861)-v. 2 (Dec. term, 1862).</note>
                            
    <note>Title from PDF title page (viewed July 10, 2007).</note>
                            
    <note>Imprint varies.</note>
                            
    <note>Reporters: 1801-1815, William Cranch (5-13 U.S.); 1816-1827, Henry Wheaton (14-25 U.S.); 1828-1842, Richard Peters, Jr. (26-41 U.S.); 1843-1860, Benjamin C. Howard (42-65 U.S.); 1861-1862, J.S. Black (66-67 U.S.).</note>
                            
    <note type="numbering">Vol. 17 (Jan. term 1843) of Peters contains the same cases as v. 1 of Howard and was not included in the retrospective numbering of United States reports.</note>
                            
    <note type="numbering">Numbering begins with v. 1 with each reporter.</note>
                            
    <subject>
                                    
         <geographicCode authority="marcgac">n-us---</geographicCode>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="lcsh">
                                    
         <topic>Law reports, digests, etc</topic>
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <topic>Law reports, digests, etc</topic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <classification authority="lcc">KF101</classification>
                            
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:56</classification>
                            
    <relatedItem displayLabel="Print version:" type="otherFormat">
                                    
         <titleInfo>
                                            
              <title>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <name>
                                            
              <namePart>United States. Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(DLC) 91643007</identifier>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(OCoLC)7474395</identifier>
                                
    </relatedItem>
                            
    <relatedItem type="preceding">
                                    
         <titleInfo>
                                            
              <title>Reports of cases ruled and adjudged in the several courts of the United States, and of Pennsylvania</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <titleInfo type="uniform">
                                            
              <title>Reports of cases ruled and adjudged in the several courts of the United States, and of Pennsylvania (Online)</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <name>
                                            
              <namePart>Dallas, Alexander James, 1759-1817.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(DLC) 2007228602</identifier>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(OCoLC)52789526</identifier>
                                
    </relatedItem>
                            
    <relatedItem type="succeeding">
                                    
         <titleInfo>
                                            
              <title>Cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <titleInfo type="uniform">
                                            
              <title>Cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States (Online)</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <name>
                                            
              <namePart>United States. Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(DLC) 2007227675</identifier>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(OCoLC)52789834</identifier>
                                
    </relatedItem>
                            
    <identifier type="lccn">2007228603</identifier>
                        
    <originInfo>
         <publisher>Banks &amp; Brothers Law Publishing Co.</publisher>
         <dateIssued encoding="w3cdtf">1889-01-01</dateIssued>
         <issuance>continuing</issuance>
         <edition>2nd</edition>
         <frequency authority="marcfrequency">Completely irregular</frequency>
    </originInfo>
    <physicalDescription>
         <note type="source content type">converted</note>
         <digitalOrigin>reformatted digital</digitalOrigin>
         <extent>648 digital object pages</extent>
    </physicalDescription>
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:56</classification>
    <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56</identifier>
    <identifier type="local">P0b002ee1d49aaed3</identifier>
    <identifier type="ILS system id">001176055</identifier>
    <recordInfo>
         <recordContentSource authority="marcorg">DGPO</recordContentSource>
         <recordCreationDate encoding="w3cdtf">2025-07-03</recordCreationDate>
         <recordChangeDate encoding="w3cdtf">2025-07-16</recordChangeDate>
         <recordIdentifier source="DGPO">USREPORTS-56</recordIdentifier>
         <recordOrigin>machine generated</recordOrigin>
         <languageOfCataloging>
              <languageTerm type="code" authority="iso639-2b">eng</languageTerm>
        </languageOfCataloging>
    </recordInfo>
    <accessCondition type="GPO scope determination">fdlp</accessCondition>
    <extension>
         <docClass>USREPORTS</docClass>
         <accessId>USREPORTS-56</accessId>
         <volume>56</volume>
         <dateIssued notSpecified="day-month">1889</dateIssued>
         <reporter abbrev="How." name="Benjamin Chew Howard" volume="15"></reporter>
         <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
    </extension>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Title Page</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Title Page</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>1</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-5.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Proceedings</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd61</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Proceedings</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>2</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-6.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Supreme Court of the United States</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd7b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Supreme Court of the United States</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>3</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-2.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>List of Attorneys and Counsellors</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd31</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;List of Attorneys and Counsellors</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>4</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-3.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>List of Cases Reported</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;List of Cases Reported</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>5</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>A Table of Cases Cited in this Volume</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd74</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;A Table of Cases Cited in this Volume</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>6</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-FrontMatter-4.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-1" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-1/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Davenport&apos;s Heirs, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 1 (1853)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 1</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-1</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 1 (1853)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 1</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-1.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Texas</topic>
              <topic>Inchoate Rights</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Spain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. Davenport&apos;s Heirs, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 1 (1853);56 U.S. 1;15 How. 1</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-1</accessId>
              <reportNumber>1</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>7</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1853-12-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 1</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 1</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 1 (1853)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Texas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inchoate Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Spain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-003-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-07</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed and reversed (or vacated) in part</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Archibald Campbell</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-1</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-1.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-10" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-10/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Patterson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 10 (1853)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 10</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-10</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 10 (1853)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 10</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-10.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. Patterson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 10 (1853);56 U.S. 10;15 How. 10</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-10</accessId>
              <reportNumber>10</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>8</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1853-12-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 10</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 10</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 10 (1853)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-004-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-07</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Archibald Campbell</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-10</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-10.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-14" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-14/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. D&apos;Auterieve et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 14 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 14</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-14</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 14 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 14</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-14.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>France</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Heirs</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Boundaries</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Maps and Mapmaking</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
              <topic>Spain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. D&apos;Auterieve et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 14 (1854);56 U.S. 14;15 How. 14</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-14</accessId>
              <reportNumber>14</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>9</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-17</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 14</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 14</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 14 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>France</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Heirs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Boundaries</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maps and Mapmaking</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Spain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-014-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-08</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Samuel Nelson</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>5</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>4</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-14</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-14.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-31" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-31/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Roselius et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 31 (1853)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 31</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-31</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 31 (1853)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 31</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-31.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd75</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Rights</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>France</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Determination of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Claims</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. Roselius et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 31 (1853);56 U.S. 31;15 How. 31</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-31</accessId>
              <reportNumber>31</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>10</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1853-12-23</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 31</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 31</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 31 (1853)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>France</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Determination of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-001-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-06</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Catron</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-31</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-31.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-40" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-40/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>The United States v. Joseph Marcel Ducros (15 How) 37 (1853)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 40</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-40</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 40 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 40</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-40.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;The United States v. Joseph Marcel Ducros (15 How) 37 (1853);56 U.S. 40;15 How. 40</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-40</accessId>
              <reportNumber>40</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>11</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate notSpecified="day-month">1854-01-01</decisionDate>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 40</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 40</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 40 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center"></subject>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-40</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-40.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-38" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-38/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Ducros et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 38 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 38</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-38</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 38 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 38</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-38.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd73</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>France</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Determination of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. Ducros et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 38 (1854);56 U.S. 38;15 How. 38</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-38</accessId>
              <reportNumber>38</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>12</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-17</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 38</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 38</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 38 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>France</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Determination of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-015-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-12</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Robert Cooper Grier</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-38</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-38.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-42" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-42/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Eyre et al. v. Potter et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 42 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 42</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-42</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 42 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 42</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-42.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Chancery Courts</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Mental Status</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Widows and Widowers</topic>
              <topic>Deeds</topic>
              <topic>Witnesses</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Valuation</topic>
              <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Eyre et al. v. Potter et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 42 (1854);56 U.S. 42;15 How. 42</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-42</accessId>
              <reportNumber>42</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>13</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-10</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 42</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 42</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 42 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Chancery Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mental Status</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Widows and Widowers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Deeds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Witnesses</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Valuation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-010-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>North Carolina U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of North Carolina</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>North Carolina U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of North Carolina</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-12</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Peter Vivian Daniel</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-42</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-42.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-62" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-62/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>O&apos;Reilly et al. v. Morse et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 62 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 62</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-62</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 62 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 62</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-62.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Patentability</topic>
              <topic>Improvements</topic>
              <topic>Specificity</topic>
              <topic>Prior Art</topic>
              <topic>Telecommunications</topic>
              <topic>Point of Novelty</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Sufficiency of Disclosure</topic>
              <topic>Inventions</topic>
              <topic>Damages</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Telegraphs</topic>
              <topic>Specific</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;O&apos;Reilly et al. v. Morse et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 62 (1854);56 U.S. 62;15 How. 62</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-62</accessId>
              <reportNumber>62</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>14</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 62</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 62</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 62 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patentability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Improvements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specificity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Prior Art</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Telecommunications</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Point of Novelty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sufficiency of Disclosure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inventions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Telegraphs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specific</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-022-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</petitioner>
              <respondent>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Kentucky U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Kentucky</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Kentucky U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Kentucky</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1852-12-24</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed and reversed (or vacated) in part</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>5</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-62</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-62.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-137" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-137/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Smith v. Ely et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 137 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 137</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-137</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 137 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 137</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-137.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Patentability</topic>
              <topic>Improvements</topic>
              <topic>Specificity</topic>
              <topic>Prior Art</topic>
              <topic>Telecommunications</topic>
              <topic>Point of Novelty</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Sufficiency of Disclosure</topic>
              <topic>Inventions</topic>
              <topic>Damages</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Telegraphs</topic>
              <topic>Specific</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Smith v. Ely et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 137 (1854);56 U.S. 137;15 How. 137</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-137</accessId>
              <reportNumber>137</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>15</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-10</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 137</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 137</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 137 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patentability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Improvements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specificity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Prior Art</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Telecommunications</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Point of Novelty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sufficiency of Disclosure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inventions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Telegraphs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specific</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-031-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</petitioner>
              <respondent>Manufacturer</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Ohio U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Ohio</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Ohio U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Ohio</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-137</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-137.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-143" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-143/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Broome v. The United States, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 143 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 143</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-143</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 143 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 143</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-143.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd64</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
              <topic>Collectors</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Officials and Employees</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
              <topic>Timing</topic>
              <topic>Approval</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Broome v. The United States, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 143 (1854);56 U.S. 143;15 How. 143</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-143</accessId>
              <reportNumber>143</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>16</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-06</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 143</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 143</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 143 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Collectors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Officials and Employees</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Timing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Approval</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-007-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Debtor</petitioner>
              <respondent>United States</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Department or Secretary of the Treasury</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Florida U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Florida</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Florida U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Florida</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-14</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>James Moore Wayne</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>1</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-143</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-143.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-160" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-160/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Phelps v. Mayer, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 160 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 160</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-160</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 160 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 160</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-160.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd60</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Juries</topic>
              <topic>Inventions</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Hydraulics</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Timing</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Extra-Legal Jury Influences: Jury Instructions (Not Necessarily in Criminal Cases)</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Phelps v. Mayer, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 160 (1854);56 U.S. 160;15 How. 160</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-160</accessId>
              <reportNumber>160</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>17</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-10</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 160</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 160</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 160 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Juries</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inventions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Hydraulics</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Timing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Extra-Legal Jury Influences: Jury Instructions (Not Necessarily in Criminal Cases)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-011-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</petitioner>
              <respondent>Unidentifiable</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Indiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Indiana</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Indiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Indiana</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-15</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-160</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-160.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-162" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-162/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Bispham v. Price, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 162 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 162</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-162</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 162 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 162</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-162.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd7a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
              <topic>Statute of Limitations</topic>
              <topic>Alternative Dispute Resolution (A.D.R.)</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Tax Refunds</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
              <topic>Civil Liability</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>Partnerships</topic>
              <topic>Arbitration (In the Context of Labor-Management or Employer-Employee Relations) (Cf. Arbitration)</topic>
              <topic>Unions</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Bispham v. Price, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 162 (1854);56 U.S. 162;15 How. 162</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-162</accessId>
              <reportNumber>162</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>18</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-10</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 162</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 162</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 162 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Statute of Limitations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Alternative Dispute Resolution (A.D.R.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Refunds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Liability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Partnerships</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Arbitration (In the Context of Labor-Management or Employer-Employee Relations) (Cf. Arbitration)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Unions</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-012-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Pennsylvania U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Pennsylvania</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Pennsylvania U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Pennsylvania</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-15</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Archibald Campbell</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-162</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-162.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-179" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-179/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Bevins et al. v. Ramsey et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 179 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 179</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-179</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 179 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 179</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-179.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd68</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Duty</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
              <topic>Clerks</topic>
              <topic>Auctions</topic>
              <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Bevins et al. v. Ramsey et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 179 (1854);56 U.S. 179;15 How. 179</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-179</accessId>
              <reportNumber>179</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>19</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-06</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 179</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 179</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 179 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Duty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Clerks</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Auctions</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-008-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Tennessee U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Tennessee</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Tennessee U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Tennessee</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Catron</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-179</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-179.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-189" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-189/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Rockhill et al. v. Hanna et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 189 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 189</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-189</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 189 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 189</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-189.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd70</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
              <topic>Seizures</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Priority of Creditors</topic>
              <topic>Liens</topic>
              <topic>Debtor&apos;s Prison</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Rockhill et al. v. Hanna et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 189 (1854);56 U.S. 189;15 How. 189</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-189</accessId>
              <reportNumber>189</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>20</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-17</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 189</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 189</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 189 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Seizures</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Priority of Creditors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Liens</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Debtor&apos;s Prison</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-016-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Unidentifiable</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Indiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Indiana</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Indiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Indiana</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Robert Cooper Grier</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-189</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-189.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-198" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-198/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Kanouse v. Martin, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 198 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 198</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-198</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 198 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 198</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-198.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Removals</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Validity</topic>
              <topic>Valuation</topic>
              <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Kanouse v. Martin, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 198 (1854);56 U.S. 198;15 How. 198</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-198</accessId>
              <reportNumber>198</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>21</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-10</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 198</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 198</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 198 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Removals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Validity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Valuation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-013-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Debtor</petitioner>
              <respondent>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="New York">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="New York">State Appellate Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Federal Statute</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Judiciary Act of 1789</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Benjamin Robbins Curtis</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-198</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-198.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-212" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-212/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Books et al. v. Fiske et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 212 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 212</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-212</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 212 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 212</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-212.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd7c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Improvements</topic>
              <topic>Specificity</topic>
              <topic>Planing Machines</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Inventions</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Forests and Timber</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Specific</topic>
              <topic>Lumber</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Books et al. v. Fiske et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 212 (1854);56 U.S. 212;15 How. 212</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-212</accessId>
              <reportNumber>212</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>22</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 212</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 212</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 212 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Improvements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specificity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Planing Machines</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inventions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forests and Timber</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specific</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Lumber</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-026-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</petitioner>
              <respondent>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Massachusetts U.S. Circuit for the District of Massachusetts</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Massachusetts U.S. Circuit for the District of Massachusetts</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-19</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Catron</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>5</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-212</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-212.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-233" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-233/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Northern Indiana Railroad Co. v. Michigan Central Railroad Co., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 233 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 233</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-233</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 233 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 233</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-233.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd69</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Local Actions</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Bills and Resolutions</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Jurisdiction or Authority of Federal Courts of Appeals</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Northern Indiana Railroad Co. v. Michigan Central Railroad Co., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 233 (1854);56 U.S. 233;15 How. 233</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-233</accessId>
              <reportNumber>233</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>23</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 233</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 233</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 233 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Local Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bills and Resolutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Jurisdiction or Authority of Federal Courts of Appeals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-023-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Railroad</petitioner>
              <respondent>Railroad</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Michigan U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Michigan</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Michigan U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Michigan</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-12-29</dateArgument>
              <dateRearg>1854-01-03</dateRearg>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John McLean</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>1</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-233</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-233.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-252" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-252/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Corning et al. v. Burden, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 252 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 252</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-252</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 252 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 252</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-252.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Processes</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Inventions</topic>
              <topic>Patentability</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Corning et al. v. Burden, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 252 (1854);56 U.S. 252;15 How. 252</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-252</accessId>
              <reportNumber>252</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>24</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-27</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 252</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 252</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 252 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Processes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inventions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patentability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-017-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Manufacturer</petitioner>
              <respondent>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-03</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Robert Cooper Grier</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-252</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-252.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-272" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-272/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Garrow et al. v. Davis et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 272 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 272</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-272</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 272 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 272</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-272.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd66</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
              <topic>Labor and Employment Law</topic>
              <topic>Agency</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Burden of Proof</topic>
              <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Intent</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Garrow et al. v. Davis et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 272 (1854);56 U.S. 272;15 How. 272</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-272</accessId>
              <reportNumber>272</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>25</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-27</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 272</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 272</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 272 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Labor and Employment Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Burden of Proof</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-018-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Buyer, purchaser</petitioner>
              <respondent>Agent, fiduciary, trustee, or executor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Maine U.S. Circuit for the District of Maine</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Maine U.S. Circuit for the District of Maine</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-06</dateArgument>
              <dateRearg>1854-01-09</dateRearg>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Benjamin Robbins Curtis</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-272</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-272.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-281" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-281/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Magniac et al. v. Thomson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 281 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 281</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-281</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 281 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 281</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-281.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd71</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
              <topic>Debt</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Marriage and Family Status</topic>
              <topic>Death and Dying</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
              <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Magniac et al. v. Thomson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 281 (1854);56 U.S. 281;15 How. 281</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-281</accessId>
              <reportNumber>281</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>26</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 281</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 281</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 281 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Debt</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Marriage and Family Status</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Death and Dying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-024-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Pennsylvania U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Pennsylvania</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Pennsylvania U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Pennsylvania</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-11</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Peter Vivian Daniel</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-281</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-281.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-304" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-304/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Curran v. State of Arkansas, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 304 (1853)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 304</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-304</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 304 (1853)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 304</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-304.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Legislative Bodies</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Arkansas</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Government Ethics and Transparency</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Legislative Powers</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Curran v. State of Arkansas, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 304 (1853);56 U.S. 304;15 How. 304</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-304</accessId>
              <reportNumber>304</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>27</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1853-12-29</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 304</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 304</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 304 (1853)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Creditor and Debtor</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legislative Bodies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Arkansas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Ethics and Transparency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legislative Powers</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-005-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Arkansas">State</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Arkansas">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Arkansas">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1853-02-18</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>State or territorial law, reg, or const provision unconstitutional</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Benjamin Robbins Curtis</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>6</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-304</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-304.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-323" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-323/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Anderson et al. v. Bock, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 323 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 323</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-323</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 323 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 323</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-323.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Juries</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Ground Rents</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
              <topic>Jury Instructions</topic>
              <topic>Deeds</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>New Orleans</topic>
              <topic>Interest</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>Adverse Possession</topic>
              <topic>Damages</topic>
              <topic>Possession</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conveyances</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Anderson et al. v. Bock, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 323 (1854);56 U.S. 323;15 How. 323</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-323</accessId>
              <reportNumber>323</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>28</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-27</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 323</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 323</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 323 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Juries</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ground Rents</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Instructions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Deeds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New Orleans</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Interest</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Adverse Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conveyances</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-019-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Louisiana</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Louisiana</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Archibald Campbell</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-323</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-323.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-330" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-330/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Winans v. Denmead, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 330 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 330</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-330</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 330 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 330</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-330.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Natural Effects</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Juries</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Winans v. Denmead, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 330 (1854);56 U.S. 330;15 How. 330</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-330</accessId>
              <reportNumber>330</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>29</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 330</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 330</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 330 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Natural Effects</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Juries</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Patents and Copyrights: Patent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-027-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</petitioner>
              <respondent>Manufacturer</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Maryland U.S. Circuit for the District of Maryland</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Maryland U.S. Circuit for the District of Maryland</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Benjamin Robbins Curtis</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>John McLean</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>5</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>4</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-330</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-330.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-348" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-348/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Walworth v. Kneeland et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 348 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 348</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-348</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 348 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 348</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-348.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd78</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Intent</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Crime and Law Enforcement</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Walworth v. Kneeland et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 348 (1854);56 U.S. 348;15 How. 348</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-348</accessId>
              <reportNumber>348</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>30</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 348</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 348</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 348 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crime and Law Enforcement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-028-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Wisconsin">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Wisconsin">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-20</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Federal Statute</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Judiciary Act of 1789</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-348</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-348.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-354" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-354/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Carter v. Bennett, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 354 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 354</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-354</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 354 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 354</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-354.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd2d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Pleadings</topic>
              <topic>Judges</topic>
              <topic>Abatements</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
              <topic>Statutory Construction</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Carter v. Bennett, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 354 (1854);56 U.S. 354;15 How. 354</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-354</accessId>
              <reportNumber>354</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>31</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-27</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 354</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 354</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 354 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Pleadings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judges</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Abatements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Statutory Construction</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-020-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Defendant</petitioner>
              <respondent>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Florida">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Florida">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-13</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Federal Statute</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Judiciary Act of 1789</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-354</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-354.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-358" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-358/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Forsyth v. Reynolds et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 358 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 358</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-358</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 358 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 358</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-358.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd6f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>England</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Illinois</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Statutory Construction</topic>
              <topic>Wales</topic>
              <topic>Peoria</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Michigan</topic>
              <topic>Scoland</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
              <topic>Donations</topic>
              <topic>Great Britain</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Forsyth v. Reynolds et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 358 (1854);56 U.S. 358;15 How. 358</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-358</accessId>
              <reportNumber>358</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>32</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-13</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 358</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 358</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 358 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>England</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Illinois</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Statutory Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wales</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Peoria</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Michigan</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Scoland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Donations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Great Britain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-032-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>General Land Office or Commissioners</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Illinois U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Illinois</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Illinois U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Illinois</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-31</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Other</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Treaty</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Catron</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-358</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-358.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-367" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-367/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Executors of McDonogh et al. v. Murdoch et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 367 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 367</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-367</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 367 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 367</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-367.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd63</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Social Welfare</topic>
              <topic>Education</topic>
              <topic>Perpetuities</topic>
              <topic>Wills, Trusts, and Estates Law</topic>
              <topic>New Orleans</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>English Law</topic>
              <topic>Charities</topic>
              <topic>Intent</topic>
              <topic>Maryland</topic>
              <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
              <topic>Donations</topic>
              <topic>Baltimore</topic>
              <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Executors of McDonogh et al. v. Murdoch et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 367 (1854);56 U.S. 367;15 How. 367</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-367</accessId>
              <reportNumber>367</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>33</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-27</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 367</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 367</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 367 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Social Welfare</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Education</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Perpetuities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wills, Trusts, and Estates Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New Orleans</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>English Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Charities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maryland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Donations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Baltimore</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-042-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Agent, fiduciary, trustee, or executor</petitioner>
              <respondent>Heir, or beneficiary, or person so claiming to be</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Louisiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Louisiana</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Louisiana U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Louisiana</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-23</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Archibald Campbell</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-367</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-367.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-415" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-415/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Wylie v. Coxe, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 415 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 415</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-415</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 415 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 415</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-415.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd72</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Mexico</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Executors</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Administrators</topic>
              <topic>Lawyers and Legal Services</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Death and Dying</topic>
              <topic>Liens</topic>
              <topic>Attorney&apos;s Fees</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Wylie v. Coxe, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 415 (1854);56 U.S. 415;15 How. 415</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-415</accessId>
              <reportNumber>415</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>34</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 415</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 415</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 415 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Mexico</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Administrators</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Lawyers and Legal Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Death and Dying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Liens</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Attorney&apos;s Fees</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-033-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Agent, fiduciary, trustee, or executor</petitioner>
              <respondent>Attorney, or person acting as such, includes bar applicant or law student, or law firm or bar association</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Circuit Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Circuit Court of the District of Columbia</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-06</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John McLean</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-415</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-415.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-421" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-421/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Murray v. Gibson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 421 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 421</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-421</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 421 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 421</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-421.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd59</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Judgments</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Mississippi</topic>
              <topic>Foreign Courts</topic>
              <topic>Pleadings</topic>
              <topic>Limitation of Actions</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Timing</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Murray v. Gibson, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 421 (1854);56 U.S. 421;15 How. 421</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-421</accessId>
              <reportNumber>421</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>35</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 421</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 421</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 421 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Judgments</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mississippi</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreign Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Pleadings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Limitation of Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Timing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-034-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Mississippi U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Mississippi</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Mississippi U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Mississippi</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-09</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Peter Vivian Daniel</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-421</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-421.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-426" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-426/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Den v. Jersey Company, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 426 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 426</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-426</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 426 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 426</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-426.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd65</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Water Law</topic>
              <topic>Reclaimed Lands</topic>
              <topic>Possession</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Conveyances</topic>
              <topic>Hudson River</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>New Jersey</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Navigation</topic>
              <topic>Real Property</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Den v. Jersey Company, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 426 (1854);56 U.S. 426;15 How. 426</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-426</accessId>
              <reportNumber>426</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>36</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 426</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 426</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 426 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Water Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Reclaimed Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conveyances</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Hudson River</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New Jersey</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Navigation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Real Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-035-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>New Jersey U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New Jersey</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>New Jersey U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New Jersey</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-07</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Roger Brooke Taney</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-426</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-426.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-433" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-433/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Foley v. Harrison et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 433 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 433</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-433</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 433 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 433</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-433.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd67</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Land Offices</topic>
              <topic>Government</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conveyances</topic>
              <topic>Bills and Resolutions</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Conclusiveness</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Foley v. Harrison et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 433 (1854);56 U.S. 433;15 How. 433</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-433</accessId>
              <reportNumber>433</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>37</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-22</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 433</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 433</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 433 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Offices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conveyances</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bills and Resolutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conclusiveness</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-039-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Louisiana">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Louisiana">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-14</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John McLean</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-433</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-433.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-451" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-451/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Corning et al. v. The Troy Iron and Nail Factory, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 451 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 451</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-451</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 451 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 451</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-451.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Chancery Courts</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
              <topic>Judges</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Abatements</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Review of Non-Final Order</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Corning et al. v. The Troy Iron and Nail Factory, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 451 (1854);56 U.S. 451;15 How. 451</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-451</accessId>
              <reportNumber>451</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>38</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 451</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 451</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 451 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Chancery Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judges</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Abatements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Review of Non-Final Order</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-036-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Manufacturer</petitioner>
              <respondent>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-03</dateArgument>
              <dateRearg>1854-02-06</dateRearg>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Robert Cooper Grier</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-451</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-451.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-467" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-467/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Dawson et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 467 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 467</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-467</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 467 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 467</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-467.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd79</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>North America</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>American Indians</topic>
              <topic>Federal Indian and Tribal Law</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
              <topic>Indigenous Peoples</topic>
              <topic>Native Americans</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Native Peoples</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Indian Lands</topic>
              <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Miscellaneous</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;United States v. Dawson et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 467 (1854);56 U.S. 467;15 How. 467</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-467</accessId>
              <reportNumber>467</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>39</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-01-31</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 467</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 467</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 467 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>North America</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>American Indians</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Indian and Tribal Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Indigenous Peoples</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Native Americans</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Native Peoples</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Indian Lands</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Miscellaneous</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-025-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Person accused, indicted, or suspected of crime</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Arkansas U.S. Circuit Court for (all) District(s) of Arkansas</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Arkansas U.S. Circuit Court for (all) District(s) of Arkansas</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-10</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Samuel Nelson</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>1</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-467</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-467.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-494" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-494/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Kearney et al. v. Taylor et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 494 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 494</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-494</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 494 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 494</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-494.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd58</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Bidders</topic>
              <topic>Specialized Courts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Interest</topic>
              <topic>New Jersey</topic>
              <topic>Agency</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Auctioneers</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Auctions</topic>
              <topic>Real Property</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Kearney et al. v. Taylor et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 494 (1854);56 U.S. 494;15 How. 494</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-494</accessId>
              <reportNumber>494</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>40</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 494</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 494</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 494 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bidders</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Specialized Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Interest</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New Jersey</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Auctioneers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Auctions</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Real Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-037-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Buyer, purchaser</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>New Jersey U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New Jersey</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>New Jersey U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New Jersey</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-18</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Samuel Nelson</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>6</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-494</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-494.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-525" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-525/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Delauriere v. Emison, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 525 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 525</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-525</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 525 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 525</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-525.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd76</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Missouri</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Spain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Affairs</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Delauriere v. Emison, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 525 (1854);56 U.S. 525;15 How. 525</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-525</accessId>
              <reportNumber>525</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>41</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-03-01</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 525</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 525</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 525 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sovereignty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Missouri</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Spain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Affairs</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-049-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Missouri">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Missouri">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-02-22</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John McLean</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-525</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-525.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-539" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-539/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Adams v. Otterback, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 539 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 539</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-539</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 539 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 539</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-539.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd77</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Bills and Notes</topic>
              <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Currency</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Law</topic>
              <topic>Timing</topic>
              <topic>Sufficiency of Evidence: Typically in the Context of a Jury&apos;s Determination of Compensation for Injury or Death</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Adams v. Otterback, 56 U.S. (15 How.) 539 (1854);56 U.S. 539;15 How. 539</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-539</accessId>
              <reportNumber>539</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>42</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 539</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 539</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 539 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Bills and Notes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Currency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Timing</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Sufficiency of Evidence: Typically in the Context of a Jury&apos;s Determination of Compensation for Injury or Death</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-029-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Debtor</petitioner>
              <respondent>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Circuit Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Circuit Court of the District of Columbia</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-17</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John McLean</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-539</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-539.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-546" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-546/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Livingston et al. v. Woodworth et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 546 (1854)</title>
              <partNumber>56 U.S. 546</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-546</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">56 U.S. (15 How.) 546 (1854)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">56 U.S. 546</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-546.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd30</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Machinery</topic>
              <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
              <topic>Alternative Dispute Resolution (A.D.R.)</topic>
              <topic>Damages</topic>
              <topic>Equity</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Profits</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Untimely Filing</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Livingston et al. v. Woodworth et al., 56 U.S. (15 How.) 546 (1854);56 U.S. 546;15 How. 546</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-546</accessId>
              <reportNumber>546</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>43</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1854-02-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1853</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>56 U.S. 546</usCitation>
              <reporterCitation>15 How. 546</reporterCitation>
              <fullCitation>56 U.S. (15 How.) 546 (1854)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Machinery</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patent Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Joinder of Parties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Alternative Dispute Resolution (A.D.R.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Profits</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Untimely Filing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1853-038-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Manufacturer</petitioner>
              <respondent>Inventor, patent assigner, trademark owner or holder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Massachusetts U.S. Circuit for the District of Massachusetts</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Massachusetts U.S. Circuit for the District of Massachusetts</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Roger Brooke Taney</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1854-01-17</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Peter Vivian Daniel</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Roger Brooke Taney</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-546</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-546.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-56-BackMatter" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-BackMatter/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Index of the Principal Matters</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-BackMatter</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-BackMatter.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d537fd5f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>Reports of cases argued and adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, December term, 1853;Index of the Principal Matters</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-56-BackMatter</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>44</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-56/USREPORTS-56-BackMatter</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-56/pdf/USREPORTS-56-BackMatter.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
</mods>