<mods xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3" version="3.3" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3 http://www.loc.gov/standards/mods/v3/mods-3-3.xsd" ID="P0b002ee1d4b881e4">
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States Government Publishing Office</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">publisher</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">pbl</roleTerm>
        </role>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">distributor</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">dst</roleTerm>
        </role>
    </name>
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
         <namePart>United States Supreme Court</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">author</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">aut</roleTerm>
        </role>
         <description>Government Organization</description>
    </name>
    <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
    <genre authority="marcgt">government publication</genre>
    <language>
         <languageTerm type="code" authority="iso639-2b">eng</languageTerm>
    </language>
    <extension>
         <collectionCode>USREPORTS</collectionCode>
         <category>Judicial Publications</category>
         <branch>judicial</branch>
         <dateIngested>2025-07-04</dateIngested>
    </extension>
    <titleInfo>
         <title>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898</title>
    </titleInfo>
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:172</classification>
    <name type="corporate">
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
         <namePart>Supreme Court</namePart>
         <role>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">author</roleTerm>
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="code">aut</roleTerm>
        </role>
    </name>
    <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172</identifier>
    <location>
         <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172</url>
         <url displayLabel="PDF rendition" access="raw object">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172.pdf</url>
         <url displayLabel="Text rendition" access="raw object">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/text/USREPORTS-172.txt</url>
    </location>
    <extension>
         <searchtitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898</searchtitle>
         <docClass>USREPORTS</docClass>
         <accessId>USREPORTS-172</accessId>
         <volume>172</volume>
         <dateIssued notSpecified="day-month">1899</dateIssued>
         <reporter name="John Chandler Bancroft Davis"></reporter>
         <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
    </extension>
                            
    <titleInfo>
                                    
         <title>United States reports, 172</title>
                                    
         <subTitle>cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at</subTitle>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo type="alternative">
                                    
         <title>Cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo displayLabel="Also known as:" type="alternative">
                                    
         <title>U.S. reports</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <titleInfo type="uniform">
                                    
         <title>United States reports (Washington, D.C.)</title>
                                
    </titleInfo>
                            
    <name type="corporate">
                                    
         <namePart>United States</namePart>
                                    
         <namePart>Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                    
         <role>
                                            
              <roleTerm authority="marcrelator" type="text">creator</roleTerm>
                                        
        </role>
                                
    </name>
                            
    <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                            
    <genre authority="marcgt">law report or digest</genre>
                            
    <genre authority="fast">Digests.</genre>
                            
    <genre authority="fast">Periodicals.</genre>
                            
    <originInfo>
                                    
         <place>
                                            
              <placeTerm authority="marccountry" type="code">dcu</placeTerm>
                                        
        </place>
                                    
         <place>
                                            
              <placeTerm type="text">Washington, D.C.]</placeTerm>
                                        
        </place>
                                    
         <publisher>U.S. Supreme Court</publisher>
                                    
         <dateIssued>1899</dateIssued>
                                    
         <dateCreated encoding="marc" point="start">1883</dateCreated>
                                    
         <dateCreated encoding="marc" point="end">9999</dateCreated>
                                    
         <issuance>continuing</issuance>
                                    
         <frequency>Irregular</frequency>
                                
    </originInfo>
                            
    <language>
                                    
         <languageTerm authority="iso639-2b" type="code">eng</languageTerm>
                                
    </language>
                            
    <physicalDescription>
                                    
         <extent>1 online resource (volumes)</extent>
                                
    </physicalDescription>
                            
    <note type="date/sequential designation">Print began with: [Vol. 108] (Oct. term 1882 ... Oct. term 1883).</note>
                            
    <subject>
                                    
         <geographicCode authority="marcgac">n-us---</geographicCode>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="lcsh">
                                    
         <name type="corporate">
                                            
              <namePart>United States.</namePart>
                                            
              <namePart>Supreme Court</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <genre>Periodicals</genre>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="lcsh">
                                    
         <topic>Law reports, digests, etc</topic>
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="lcsh">
                                    
         <topic>Constitutional law</topic>
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                    
         <genre>Digests</genre>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="lcsh">
                                    
         <topic>Judicial opinions</topic>
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <name type="corporate">
                                            
              <namePart>United States.</namePart>
                                            
              <namePart>Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <topic>Constitutional law</topic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <topic>Judicial opinions</topic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <topic>Law reports, digests, etc</topic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <subject authority="fast">
                                    
         <geographic>United States</geographic>
                                
    </subject>
                            
    <classification authority="lcc">ISSN RECORD</classification>
                            
    <classification authority="ddc" edition="14">348</classification>
                            
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:172</classification>
                            
    <relatedItem displayLabel="Print version:" type="otherFormat">
                                    
         <titleInfo>
                                            
              <title>United States reports</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <name>
                                            
              <namePart>United States. Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <identifier type="issn">0891-6845</identifier>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(DLC) 01026074</identifier>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(OCoLC)4384322</identifier>
                                
    </relatedItem>
                            
    <relatedItem displayLabel="Microfiche version:" type="otherFormat">
                                    
         <titleInfo>
                                            
              <title>United States reports</title>
                                        
        </titleInfo>
                                    
         <name>
                                            
              <namePart>United States. Supreme Court.</namePart>
                                        
        </name>
                                    
         <identifier type="local">(OCoLC)26859335</identifier>
                                
    </relatedItem>
                            
    <identifier type="sudoc-item-number">0741-A (online)</identifier>
                            
    <identifier type="issn">2150-2331</identifier>
                            
    <identifier type="lccn">2009231052</identifier>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="Vol. 502, 1991 term-" usage="primary display">https://purl.fdlp.gov/GPO/LPS30185</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="Vol. 502, 1991 term-">http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/boundvolumes.aspx</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="Vol. 502, 1991 term-vol. 552, 2007 term (UNT Digital Library)">https://purl.fdlp.gov/GPO/gpo54225</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="Vol. 502, 1991 term-vol. 552, 2007 term (UNT Digital Library)">https://digital.library.unt.edu/explore/collections/USREP/browse/</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="[Vol.] 108, Oct. term 1882-vol. 542, 2003 term (Library of Congress Digital Collections by agreement with the William S. Hein &amp; Co., Inc.)">https://purl.fdlp.gov/GPO/gpo94050</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="[Vol.] 108, Oct. term 1882-vol. 542, 2003 term (Library of Congress Digital Collections by agreement with the William S. Hein &amp; Co., Inc.)">https://www.loc.gov/collections/united-states-reports/</url>
                                
    </location>
                            
    <location>
                                    
         <url displayLabel="(online)">https://catalog.gpo.gov/fdlpdir/locate.jsp?ItemNumber=0741-A&amp;SYS=000641007</url>
                                
    </location>
                        
    <originInfo>
         <publisher>Banks Law Publishing Co.</publisher>
         <dateIssued encoding="w3cdtf">1899-01-01</dateIssued>
         <issuance>continuing</issuance>
         <frequency authority="marcfrequency">Completely irregular</frequency>
    </originInfo>
    <physicalDescription>
         <note type="source content type">converted</note>
         <digitalOrigin>reformatted digital</digitalOrigin>
         <extent>792 digital object pages</extent>
    </physicalDescription>
    <classification authority="sudocs">JU 6.8/1:172</classification>
    <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172</identifier>
    <identifier type="local">P0b002ee1d4b881e4</identifier>
    <identifier type="ILS system id">000641007</identifier>
    <recordInfo>
         <recordContentSource authority="marcorg">DGPO</recordContentSource>
         <recordCreationDate encoding="w3cdtf">2025-07-04</recordCreationDate>
         <recordChangeDate encoding="w3cdtf">2025-07-09</recordChangeDate>
         <recordIdentifier source="DGPO">USREPORTS-172</recordIdentifier>
         <recordOrigin>machine generated</recordOrigin>
         <languageOfCataloging>
              <languageTerm type="code" authority="iso639-2b">eng</languageTerm>
        </languageOfCataloging>
    </recordInfo>
    <accessCondition type="GPO scope determination">fdlp</accessCondition>
    <extension>
         <docClass>USREPORTS</docClass>
         <accessId>USREPORTS-172</accessId>
         <volume>172</volume>
         <dateIssued notSpecified="day-month">1899</dateIssued>
         <reporter name="John Chandler Bancroft Davis"></reporter>
         <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
    </extension>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Title Page</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd94</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Title Page</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>1</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-4.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Table of Cases Reported</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Table of Cases Reported</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>2</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-3.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Table of Cases Cited</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Table of Cases Cited</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>3</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Table of Statutes Cited</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff30</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Table of Statutes Cited</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>4</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-5.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Justices of the Supreme Court</title>
              <partName>Front Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff25</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Justices of the Supreme Court</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>FRONTMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>5</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-FrontMatter-2.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-1" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-1/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Walla Walla v. Walla Walla Water Co., 172 U.S. 1 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 1</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-1</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 1 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 1</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-1.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff13</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Fees</topic>
              <topic>Public Service</topic>
              <topic>Ordinance</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Municipalities</topic>
              <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Waste Management</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Court of Appeals Act</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Walla Walla v. Walla Walla Water Co., 172 U.S. 1 (1898);172 U.S. 1</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-1</accessId>
              <reportNumber>1</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>6</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-14</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 1</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 1 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fees</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Service</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ordinance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Municipalities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Waste Management</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Court of Appeals Act</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-016-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="Washington">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</petitioner>
              <respondent>Public utility</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Washington U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Washington</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Washington U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Washington</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-12</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Judicial review (state level)</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Constitution</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Article I, Section 10, Paragraph 1 (contract clause)</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>Municipal or other local ordinance unconstitutional</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-1</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-1.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-24" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-24/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Andersen v. Treat, 172 U.S. 24 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 24</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-24</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 24 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 24</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-24.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Constitutional Rights</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Article 6</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
              <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
              <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Homicide</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
              <topic>Police Powers</topic>
              <topic>Lawyers and Legal Services</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Maritime and Admiralty Law</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Capital Punishment</topic>
              <topic>Prisoner&apos;s Rights</topic>
              <topic>Right to Counsel (Cf. Indigents Appointment of Counsel or Inadequate Representation)</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Andersen v. Treat, 172 U.S. 24 (1898);172 U.S. 24</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-24</accessId>
              <reportNumber>24</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>7</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-14</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 24</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 24 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Article 6</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Homicide</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Police Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Lawyers and Legal Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maritime and Admiralty Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Capital Punishment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Prisoner&apos;s Rights</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Right to Counsel (Cf. Indigents Appointment of Counsel or Inadequate Representation)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-017-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Prisoner, inmate of penal institution</petitioner>
              <respondent state="United States">Governmental official, or an official of an agency established under an interstate compact</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Virginia Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Virginia Eastern U.S. District Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-11-08</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-24</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-24.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-32" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-32/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Pittsburgh &amp;c. R&apos;Y v. Board of Pub. Works, 172 U.S. 32 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 32</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-32</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 32 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 32</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-32.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff19</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Corporate Income Tax</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Code of West Virginia of 1891</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Courts</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>State Railroad Tax Cases</topic>
              <topic>Assessment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Rivers and Waterways</topic>
              <topic>Levy</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Tax-Exempt Organizations</topic>
              <topic>Board of Public Works</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Pittsburgh &amp;c. R&apos;Y v. Board of Pub. Works, 172 U.S. 32 (1898);172 U.S. 32</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-32</accessId>
              <reportNumber>32</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>8</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 32</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 32 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporate Income Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Code of West Virginia of 1891</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State Railroad Tax Cases</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Assessment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Rivers and Waterways</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Levy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax-Exempt Organizations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of Public Works</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-018-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Railroad</petitioner>
              <respondent state="West Virginia">Specified state board or department of education</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="West Virginia">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>West Virginia U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of West Virginia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>West Virginia U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of West Virginia</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Horace Gray</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-32</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-32.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-48" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-48/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Wardwell, 172 U.S. 48 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 48</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-48</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 48 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 48</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-48.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Government Cheque</topic>
              <topic>American Indians</topic>
              <topic>Crime Victims</topic>
              <topic>North America</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
              <topic>Statute of Limitations</topic>
              <topic>Treasury Notes</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>New York</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Indigenous Peoples</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Treasurer</topic>
              <topic>Comptroller</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Crimes Against Property</topic>
              <topic>Native Peoples</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Wardwell, 172 U.S. 48 (1898);172 U.S. 48</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-48</accessId>
              <reportNumber>48</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>9</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 48</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 48 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Government Cheque</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>American Indians</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crime Victims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>North America</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Statute of Limitations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treasury Notes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New York</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Indigenous Peoples</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treasurer</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Comptroller</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crimes Against Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Native Peoples</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-019-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Agent, fiduciary, trustee, or executor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Department or Secretary of the Treasury</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-20</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-48</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-48.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-58" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-58/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Green Bay &amp;c. Canal Co. v. Patten Paper Co., 172 U.S. 58 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 58</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-58</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 58 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 58</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-58.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Superior Court</topic>
              <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Dams and Canals</topic>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Privatization</topic>
              <topic>Arbitration</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Water Resources</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>Immunity</topic>
              <topic>Rivers and Waterways</topic>
              <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
              <topic>Wisconsin</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
              <topic>Armed Forces</topic>
              <topic>Deed of Trust</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Secretary of War</topic>
              <topic>Power Generation and Transmission</topic>
              <topic>National Supremacy: Natural Resources (Cf. Natural Resources - Environmental Protection)</topic>
              <topic>Federalism</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Green Bay &amp;c. Canal Co. v. Patten Paper Co., 172 U.S. 58 (1898);172 U.S. 58</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-58</accessId>
              <reportNumber>58</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>10</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 58</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 58 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Superior Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Dams and Canals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Privatization</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Arbitration</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Water Resources</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Immunity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Rivers and Waterways</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wisconsin</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Armed Forces</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Deed of Trust</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Secretary of War</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Power Generation and Transmission</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>National Supremacy: Natural Resources (Cf. Natural Resources - Environmental Protection)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federalism</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-020-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Wisconsin">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Wisconsin">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-01-13</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>George Shiras, Jr.</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-58</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-58.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-82" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-82/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Meyer v. Richmond, 172 U.S. 82 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 82</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-82</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 82 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 82</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-82.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff21</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Public Transit</topic>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Ordinance</topic>
              <topic>Torts</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Trespassing</topic>
              <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Virginia</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Pedestrians</topic>
              <topic>Transportation Safety and Security</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Meyer v. Richmond, 172 U.S. 82 (1898);172 U.S. 82</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-82</accessId>
              <reportNumber>82</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>11</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-11-28</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 82</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 82 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Transit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ordinance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Torts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trespassing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Virginia</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Pedestrians</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Transportation Safety and Security</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-021-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Virginia">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Virginia">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Virginia">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>John Marshall Harlan</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>7</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>2</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-82</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-82.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-102" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-102/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>McCullough v. Virginia, 172 U.S. 102 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 102</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-102</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 102 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 102</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-102.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff29</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Tax Reform</topic>
              <topic>Coupon Provision</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Public Debts</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Consumer Credit</topic>
              <topic>Coupon Bonds</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Acts of Assembly</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;McCullough v. Virginia, 172 U.S. 102 (1898);172 U.S. 102</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-102</accessId>
              <reportNumber>102</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>12</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-05</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 102</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 102 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Reform</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Coupon Provision</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Debts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Consumer Credit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Coupon Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Acts of Assembly</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-022-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Stockholder, shareholder, or bondholder</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Virginia">State</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Virginia">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Virginia">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-02-21</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>1</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-102</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-102.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-133" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-133/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Ranlett and Stone, 172 U.S. 133 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 133</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-133</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 133 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 133</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-133.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>England</topic>
              <topic>West Europe</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Revenue Laws</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Fraudulent Intent</topic>
              <topic>Commodities Markets</topic>
              <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
              <topic>Import and Export</topic>
              <topic>Attorney General</topic>
              <topic>Customs Administrative Act</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Harbors</topic>
              <topic>Sales and Excise Tax</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Drawbacks</topic>
              <topic>Taxation of Foreign Income</topic>
              <topic>Tariff Act</topic>
              <topic>Transportation Costs</topic>
              <topic>Secretary of the Treasury</topic>
              <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
              <topic>Food Industry</topic>
              <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
              <topic>Coal</topic>
              <topic>Free Trade</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Duties</topic>
              <topic>Tariffs</topic>
              <topic>General Appraiser</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Ranlett and Stone, 172 U.S. 133 (1898);172 U.S. 133</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-133</accessId>
              <reportNumber>133</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>13</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-05</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 133</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 133 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>England</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>West Europe</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revenue Laws</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraudulent Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Commodities Markets</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Import and Export</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Attorney General</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Customs Administrative Act</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Harbors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sales and Excise Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Drawbacks</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Taxation of Foreign Income</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariff Act</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Transportation Costs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Secretary of the Treasury</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Food Industry</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Coal</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Free Trade</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Duties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariffs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>General Appraiser</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-023-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Shipper, including importer and exporter</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Cert</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Board of General Appraisers</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>No reason given</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Interpretation of administrative regulation or rule, or executive order</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-133</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-133.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-148" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-148/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Harkrader v. Wadley, 172 U.S. 148 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 148</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-148</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 148 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 148</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-148.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1d</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Embezzlement</topic>
              <topic>Bail</topic>
              <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
              <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>North Carolina</topic>
              <topic>Bail Bonds</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Corruption</topic>
              <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Detention</topic>
              <topic>Virginia</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Prisoner&apos;s Rights</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Personal Liberty</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
              <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
              <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Harkrader v. Wadley, 172 U.S. 148 (1898);172 U.S. 148</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-148</accessId>
              <reportNumber>148</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>14</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-05</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 148</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 148 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Embezzlement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bail</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>North Carolina</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bail Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corruption</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Detention</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Virginia</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Prisoner&apos;s Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Personal Liberty</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Habeas Corpus</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-024-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="Virginia">County government or county governmental unit, except school district</petitioner>
              <respondent>Arrested person, or pretrial detainee</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Virginia U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Virginia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Virginia U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Virginia</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-17</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>George Shiras, Jr.</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-148</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-148.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-171" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-171/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>New Mexico v. United States Trust Co., 172 U.S. 171 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 171</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-171</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 171 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 171</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-171.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff08</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Personal Property</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Easements</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Assessment Roll</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>California</topic>
              <topic>Right of Way</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>District Attorney</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;New Mexico v. United States Trust Co., 172 U.S. 171 (1898);172 U.S. 171</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-171</accessId>
              <reportNumber>171</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>15</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-05</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 171</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 171 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Personal Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Easements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Assessment Roll</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>California</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Right of Way</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Attorney</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-025-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="New Mexico">State</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="New Mexico">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin state="New Mexico">Territorial Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="New Mexico">Territorial Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-25</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-171</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-171.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-186" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>New Mexico v. United States Trust Co., 172 U.S. 186 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 186</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 186 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 186</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-186.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd93</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Personal Property</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Easements</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Assessment Roll</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>California</topic>
              <topic>Right of Way</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>District Attorney</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;New Mexico v. United States Trust Co., 172 U.S. 186 (1898);172 U.S. 186</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-186</accessId>
              <reportNumber>186</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>16</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-10-01</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 186</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 186 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Personal Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Easements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Assessment Roll</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>California</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Right of Way</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Attorney</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-026-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="New Mexico">State</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="New Mexico">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin state="New Mexico">Territorial Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="New Mexico">Territorial Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-186.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-186-2" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186-2/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Elfrida, The, 172 U.S. 186 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 186</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186-2</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 186 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 186</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-186-2.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff11</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Bodies of Water</topic>
              <topic>England</topic>
              <topic>West Europe</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>English Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Law of the Sea</topic>
              <topic>Salvage Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
              <topic>Import and Export</topic>
              <topic>Salvage Rates</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Harbors</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Continental System</topic>
              <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
              <topic>Maritime and Admiralty Law</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
              <topic>Rules of Oleron</topic>
              <topic>Texas</topic>
              <topic>Trade Agreements and Negotiations</topic>
              <topic>Navigation</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Elfrida, The, 172 U.S. 186 (1898);172 U.S. 186</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-186-2</accessId>
              <reportNumber>186</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>17</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>2</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-10-01</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 186</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 186 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Bodies of Water</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>England</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>West Europe</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>English Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Law of the Sea</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Salvage Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Import and Export</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Salvage Rates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Harbors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Continental System</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maritime and Admiralty Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Rules of Oleron</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Texas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trade Agreements and Negotiations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Navigation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-026-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="New Mexico">State</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="New Mexico">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin state="New Mexico">Territorial Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="New Mexico">Territorial Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-186-2</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-186-2.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-206" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-206/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Loughrey, 172 U.S. 206 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 206</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-206</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 206 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 206</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-206.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfeff</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>United States Statutes at Large</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Seizures</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Peaceable Possession</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Legal Titles</topic>
              <topic>Michigan</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Forests and Timber</topic>
              <topic>Leases</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Evidence of Title</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Right of Possession</topic>
              <topic>Homesteads</topic>
              <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Financial (Other than in Fraud or Internal Revenue)</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Loughrey, 172 U.S. 206 (1898);172 U.S. 206</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-206</accessId>
              <reportNumber>206</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>18</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-12</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 206</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 206 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>United States Statutes at Large</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Seizures</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Peaceable Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Michigan</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forests and Timber</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Leases</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence of Title</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Right of Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Homesteads</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Financial (Other than in Fraud or Internal Revenue)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-028-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Wisconsin U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Wisconsin</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-04-21</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Horace Gray</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>6</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-206</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-206.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-232" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-232/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Grant v. Buckner, 172 U.S. 232 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 232</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-232</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 232 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 232</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-232.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd90</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Titles</topic>
              <topic>Roman Law</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Louisiana</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>State Courts</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Transfer and Inheritance Tax</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Real Property</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Grant v. Buckner, 172 U.S. 232 (1898);172 U.S. 232</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-232</accessId>
              <reportNumber>232</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>19</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-19</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 232</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 232 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Roman Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Louisiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Transfer and Inheritance Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Real Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-029-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Heir, or beneficiary, or person so claiming to be</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Louisiana">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Louisiana">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-232</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-232.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-239" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-239/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Blake v. McClung, 172 U.S. 239 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 239</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-239</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 239 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 239</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-239.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Secretary of State</topic>
              <topic>States&apos; Rights</topic>
              <topic>England</topic>
              <topic>West Europe</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Scotland</topic>
              <topic>Articles of Confederation</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Tribunals</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Courts</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
              <topic>State Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
              <topic>Discrimination</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Equal Protection</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Wales</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Article IV</topic>
              <topic>Separation of Powers</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Free Trade</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Great Britain</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>Supreme Law</topic>
              <topic>Acts of Tennessee</topic>
              <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
              <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Blake v. McClung, 172 U.S. 239 (1898);172 U.S. 239</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-239</accessId>
              <reportNumber>239</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>20</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-12</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 239</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 239 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Secretary of State</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>States&apos; Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>England</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>West Europe</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Scotland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Articles of Confederation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Tribunals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Discrimination</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Equal Protection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wales</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Article IV</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Separation of Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Free Trade</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Great Britain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Supreme Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Acts of Tennessee</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-030-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Tennessee">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Tennessee">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Judicial review (state level)</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Constitution</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Article IV, Section 2, Paragraph 1 (privileges and immunities clause)</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>State or territorial law, reg, or const provision unconstitutional</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed and reversed (or vacated) in part and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Marshall Harlan</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>John Marshall Harlan</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>7</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>2</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-239</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-239.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-269" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-269/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Norwood v. Baker, 172 U.S. 269 (1898)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 269</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-269</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 269 (1898)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 269</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-269.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff31</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Bill of Rights</topic>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Public Funds</topic>
              <topic>State Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Act of Taxation</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Special Assessment</topic>
              <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
              <topic>Public Works</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Court of Equity</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>General Levy</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Legislative Powers</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Condemnation of Property</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Norwood v. Baker, 172 U.S. 269 (1898);172 U.S. 269</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-269</accessId>
              <reportNumber>269</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>21</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1898-12-12</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 269</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 269 (1898)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bill of Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Funds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Act of Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Special Assessment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Works</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Equity</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>General Levy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legislative Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Condemnation of Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-031-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="Ohio">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Ohio U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Ohio</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Ohio U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Ohio</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Judicial review (state level)</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Constitutional Amendment</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Fourteenth Amendment (due process)</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>State or territorial law, reg, or const provision unconstitutional</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Marshall Harlan</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>6</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>3</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-269</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-269.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-303" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-303/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Winston v. United States, 172 U.S. 303 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 303</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-303</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 303 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 303</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-303.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff02</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Reasonable Doubt</topic>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Crime Victims</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Homicide</topic>
              <topic>Jury Instructions</topic>
              <topic>Hard Labor</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
              <topic>Murder</topic>
              <topic>Utah</topic>
              <topic>Crimes Against Women</topic>
              <topic>Sentencing</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Capital Punishment</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Extra-Legal Jury Influences: Jury Instructions (Not Necessarily in Criminal Cases)</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Winston v. United States, 172 U.S. 303 (1899);172 U.S. 303</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-303</accessId>
              <reportNumber>303</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>22</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 303</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 303 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Reasonable Doubt</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crime Victims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Homicide</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Instructions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Hard Labor</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Murder</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Utah</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crimes Against Women</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sentencing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Capital Punishment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Extra-Legal Jury Influences: Jury Instructions (Not Necessarily in Criminal Cases)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-032-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Person convicted of crime</petitioner>
              <respondent>United States</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Cert</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Supreme Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit (includes the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia but not the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which has local jurisdiction)</caseSource>
              <certReason>No reason given</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-11-28</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Horace Gray</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>7</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>2</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-303</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-303.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-314" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-314/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Bellingham Bay &amp;c. Co. v. New Whatcom, 172 U.S. 314 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 314</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-314</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 314 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 314</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-314.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Assessment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
              <topic>California</topic>
              <topic>Reassessment</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Bellingham Bay &amp;c. Co. v. New Whatcom, 172 U.S. 314 (1899);172 U.S. 314</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-314</accessId>
              <reportNumber>314</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>23</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 314</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 314 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Assessment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>California</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Reassessment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-033-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Washington">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Washington">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Washington">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Judicial review (state level)</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Constitutional Amendment</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Fourteenth Amendment (due process)</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-314</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-314.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-320" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-320/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Bellingham Bay Improvement Company v. New Whatcom, 172 U.S. 314 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 320</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-320</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 320 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 320</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-320.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfefd</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Bellingham Bay Improvement Company v. New Whatcom, 172 U.S. 314 (1899);172 U.S. 320</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-320</accessId>
              <reportNumber>320</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>24</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 320</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 320 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center"></subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process: Takings Clause, or Other Non-Constitutional Governmental Taking of Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-034-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Washington">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Washington">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Washington">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-320</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-320.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-321" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-321/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Bliss, 172 U.S. 321 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 321</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-321</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 321 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 321</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-321.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff05</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Arms Sales</topic>
              <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Federal Government</topic>
              <topic>Defense Spending</topic>
              <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Wages and Hours</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Bliss, 172 U.S. 321 (1899);172 U.S. 321</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-321</accessId>
              <reportNumber>321</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>25</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 321</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 321 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Arms Sales</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ships and Boats</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Defense Spending</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Breach of Contract</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wages and Hours</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Liability, Governmental: Tort or Contract Actions by or Against Government or Governmental Officials Other than Defense of Criminal Actions Brought Under a Civil Rights Action.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-035-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Government contractor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-321</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-321.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-327" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-327/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Ingram, 172 U.S. 327 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 327</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-327</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 327 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 327</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-327.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff10</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Titles</topic>
              <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Desert Land Law</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Abandoned Property</topic>
              <topic>Public Lands</topic>
              <topic>Land Department</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Utah</topic>
              <topic>Privatization</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Desert Land Act</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Department of the Interior (D.O.I.)</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Ingram, 172 U.S. 327 (1899);172 U.S. 327</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-327</accessId>
              <reportNumber>327</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>26</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 327</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 327 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Desert Land Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Abandoned Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Lands</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Department</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Utah</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Privatization</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Desert Land Act</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Department of the Interior (D.O.I.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State and Territorial Land Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-036-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-09</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>David Josiah Brewer</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-327</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-327.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-334" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-334/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Clark v. Kansas City, 172 U.S. 334 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 334</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-334</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 334 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 334</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-334.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>State Statutes</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Kansas</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Farmland</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Kansas State Constitution</topic>
              <topic>Territorial Tax System</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Review of Non-Final Order</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Clark v. Kansas City, 172 U.S. 334 (1899);172 U.S. 334</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-334</accessId>
              <reportNumber>334</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>27</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 334</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 334 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Kansas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Farmland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Kansas State Constitution</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territorial Tax System</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Review of Non-Final Order</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-037-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Kansas">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Kansas">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Kansas">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-13</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-334</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-334.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-339" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-339/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Buffalo Gas Fuel Co., 172 U.S. 339 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 339</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-339</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 339 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 339</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-339.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd8f</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Oil and Gas</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Government Geological Survey</topic>
              <topic>Unmanufactured Articles</topic>
              <topic>Canada</topic>
              <topic>Import and Export</topic>
              <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
              <topic>Energy Prices</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Trade Restrictions</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>New York</topic>
              <topic>Assessment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Duties</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Duty Laws</topic>
              <topic>Tax-Exempt Organizations</topic>
              <topic>Tariff Act of 1890</topic>
              <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
              <topic>Free Trade</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Trade Agreements and Negotiations</topic>
              <topic>Tariffs</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Buffalo Gas Fuel Co., 172 U.S. 339 (1899);172 U.S. 339</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-339</accessId>
              <reportNumber>339</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>28</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 339</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 339 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Oil and Gas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Geological Survey</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Unmanufactured Articles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Canada</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Import and Export</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mixed Jurisdictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Prices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trade Restrictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New York</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Assessment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Duties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Duty Laws</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax-Exempt Organizations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariff Act of 1890</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inland Water Transportation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Free Trade</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trade Agreements and Negotiations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariffs</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-038-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent>Shipper, including importer and exporter</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Cert</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Customs Service or Commissioner or Collector of Customs</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>No reason given</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Interpretation of administrative regulation or rule, or executive order</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Rufus Wheeler Peckham</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-339</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-339.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-343" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-343/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Scott v. United States, 172 U.S. 343 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 343</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-343</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 343 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 343</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-343.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff15</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Mail Fraud</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Embezzlement</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Conspiracy</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Postal Service (U.S.P.S.)</topic>
              <topic>New York</topic>
              <topic>United States Mail</topic>
              <topic>Corruption</topic>
              <topic>Marked Currency</topic>
              <topic>Arizona</topic>
              <topic>Postal Laws and Regulations</topic>
              <topic>Decoy Letter</topic>
              <topic>White-Collar Crime</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Postal Inspectors</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
              <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
              <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Financial (Other than in Fraud or Internal Revenue)</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Scott v. United States, 172 U.S. 343 (1899);172 U.S. 343</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-343</accessId>
              <reportNumber>343</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>29</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 343</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 343 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Mail Fraud</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Embezzlement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conspiracy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Postal Service (U.S.P.S.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New York</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>United States Mail</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corruption</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Marked Currency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Arizona</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Postal Laws and Regulations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Decoy Letter</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>White-Collar Crime</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Postal Inspectors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Statutory Construction of Criminal Laws: Financial (Other than in Fraud or Internal Revenue)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-039-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Person convicted of crime</petitioner>
              <respondent>United States</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Rufus Wheeler Peckham</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-343</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-343.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-351" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-351/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Missouri, Kansas &amp;c. Trust Co. v. Krumseig, 172 U.S. 351 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 351</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-351</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 351 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 351</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-351.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff14</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Usurious Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Minnesota</topic>
              <topic>Public Policy</topic>
              <topic>Decoration of Independence</topic>
              <topic>Interstate Commerce</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Nullified Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Laws</topic>
              <topic>General Statutes of Minnesota</topic>
              <topic>English Chancery Court</topic>
              <topic>Life Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Missouri, Kansas &amp;c. Trust Co. v. Krumseig, 172 U.S. 351 (1899);172 U.S. 351</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-351</accessId>
              <reportNumber>351</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>30</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 351</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 351 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Usurious Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Minnesota</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Policy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Decoration of Independence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Interstate Commerce</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Nullified Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Laws</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>General Statutes of Minnesota</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>English Chancery Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Life Insurance</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-040-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Cert</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Minnesota U.S. Circuit for the District of Minnesota</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>No reason given</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-02</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>George Shiras, Jr.</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-351</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-351.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-361" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-361/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Washington Market Co. v. Dist. of Columbia, 172 U.S. 361 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 361</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-361</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 361 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 361</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-361.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Title by Possession</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Tolls</topic>
              <topic>Acts of Congress</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Easements</topic>
              <topic>Legislative Oversight</topic>
              <topic>Trespassing</topic>
              <topic>Board of Public Works</topic>
              <topic>Roads and Highways</topic>
              <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Municipal Governments</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Washington Market Co. v. Dist. of Columbia, 172 U.S. 361 (1899);172 U.S. 361</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-361</accessId>
              <reportNumber>361</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>31</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 361</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 361 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Title by Possession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tolls</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Acts of Congress</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Easements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legislative Oversight</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trespassing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of Public Works</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Roads and Highways</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Municipal Governments</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-041-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Business, corporation</petitioner>
              <respondent state="District of Columbia">State</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Supreme Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit (includes the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia but not the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which has local jurisdiction)</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-09</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Edward Douglass White</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-361</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-361.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-372" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-372/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Simpson v. United States, 172 U.S. 372 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 372</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-372</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 372 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 372</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-372.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd92</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Navy Department</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Military Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Harbors</topic>
              <topic>Defense Spending</topic>
              <topic>Bureau of Yards and Docks</topic>
              <topic>Virginia</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Secretary of the Navy</topic>
              <topic>Contract Extensions</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Simpson v. United States, 172 U.S. 372 (1899);172 U.S. 372</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-372</accessId>
              <reportNumber>372</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>32</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 372</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 372 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Navy Department</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Military Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Harbors</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Defense Spending</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bureau of Yards and Docks</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Virginia</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Secretary of the Navy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contract Extensions</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-042-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Government contractor</petitioner>
              <respondent>United States</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-19</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Edward Douglass White</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-372</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-372.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-383" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-383/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Home for Incurables v. Noble, 172 U.S. 383 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 383</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-383</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 383 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 383</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-383.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff22</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Testatrix</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Heirs</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Wills, Trusts, and Estates Law</topic>
              <topic>Transfer and Inheritance Tax</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Codicil</topic>
              <topic>Trials Court</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Home for Incurables v. Noble, 172 U.S. 383 (1899);172 U.S. 383</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-383</accessId>
              <reportNumber>383</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>33</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 383</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 383 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Testatrix</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Heirs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wills, Trusts, and Estates Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Transfer and Inheritance Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Codicil</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trials Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Wills and Trusts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-043-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Heir, or beneficiary, or person so claiming to be</petitioner>
              <respondent>Heir, or beneficiary, or person so claiming to be</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Supreme Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit (includes the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia but not the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which has local jurisdiction)</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-11-09</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Edward Douglass White</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-383</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-383.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-401" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-401/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Sonnentheil v. Moerlein Brewing Co., 172 U.S. 401 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 401</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-401</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 401 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 401</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-401.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff06</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Deed of Trust</topic>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Property Seizure</topic>
              <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Texas</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
              <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Sonnentheil v. Moerlein Brewing Co., 172 U.S. 401 (1899);172 U.S. 401</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-401</accessId>
              <reportNumber>401</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>34</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 401</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 401 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Deed of Trust</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Seizure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Texas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Debtors&apos; Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Rights</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-044-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Agent, fiduciary, trustee, or executor</petitioner>
              <respondent>Creditor, including institution appearing as such, e.g., a finance company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Texas U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of Texas</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-18</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-401</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-401.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-416" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-416/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Utter v. Franklin, 172 U.S. 416 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 416</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-416</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 416 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 416</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-416.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff27</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Territory Loan Commissioners</topic>
              <topic>Bondholders</topic>
              <topic>Loan Commissioners</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Congressional Act of 1878</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Arizona</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Officials and Employees</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Collateral Estoppel or Res Judicata</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Utter v. Franklin, 172 U.S. 416 (1899);172 U.S. 416</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-416</accessId>
              <reportNumber>416</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>35</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 416</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 416 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Territory Loan Commissioners</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bondholders</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Loan Commissioners</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Congressional Act of 1878</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Arizona</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Officials and Employees</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Collateral Estoppel or Res Judicata</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-045-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Stockholder, shareholder, or bondholder</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Arizona">Governmental official, or an official of an agency established under an interstate compact</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="Alabama">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin state="Arizona">Territorial Supreme Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Arizona">Territorial Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-12</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-416</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-416.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-425" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-425/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Capital Bank v. Cadiz Bank, 172 U.S. 425 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 425</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-425</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 425 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 425</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-425.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff12</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
              <topic>Bill of Exceptions</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Trust Funds</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Alaska</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Capital Bank v. Cadiz Bank, 172 U.S. 425 (1899);172 U.S. 425</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-425</accessId>
              <reportNumber>425</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>36</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 425</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 425 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bill of Exceptions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trust Funds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Alaska</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-046-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Nebraska">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Nebraska">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-02</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-425</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-425.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-434" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Capital National Bank v. Coldwater National Bank, 172 U.S. 434 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 434</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 434 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 434</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-434.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff23</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
              <topic>Bill of Exceptions</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Trust Funds</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Alaska</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Capital National Bank v. Coldwater National Bank, 172 U.S. 434 (1899);172 U.S. 434</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-434</accessId>
              <reportNumber>434</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>37</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 434</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 434 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bill of Exceptions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trust Funds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Alaska</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-047-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Nebraska">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Nebraska">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-05</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-434.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-434-2" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434-2/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Keck v. United States, 172 U.S. 434 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 434</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434-2</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 434 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 434</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-434-2.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Sales and Excise Tax</topic>
              <topic>Law of the Sea</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Clandestine Introduction</topic>
              <topic>Import and Export</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
              <topic>Acts of Congress</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Solicitor General</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Duties</topic>
              <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
              <topic>English Law</topic>
              <topic>Smuggling</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
              <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Keck v. United States, 172 U.S. 434 (1899);172 U.S. 434</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-434-2</accessId>
              <reportNumber>434</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>38</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>2</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 434</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 434 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Sales and Excise Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Law of the Sea</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Clandestine Introduction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Import and Export</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Acts of Congress</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Solicitor General</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Duties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contrary to Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>English Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Smuggling</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Law and Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Crimes Against the State</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-047-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Nebraska">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Nebraska">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-05</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-434-2</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-434-2.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-465" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-465/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co., 172 U.S. 465 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 465</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-465</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 465 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 465</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-465.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1a</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Fraudulent Testimony</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Maryland</topic>
              <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co., 172 U.S. 465 (1899);172 U.S. 465</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-465</accessId>
              <reportNumber>465</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>39</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 465</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 465 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraudulent Testimony</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maryland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-049-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Maryland">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Maryland">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-465</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-465.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-472" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-472/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co., 172 U.S. 472 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 472</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-472</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 472 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 472</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-472.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff07</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Maryland</topic>
              <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
              <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co., 172 U.S. 472 (1899);172 U.S. 472</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-472</accessId>
              <reportNumber>472</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>40</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 472</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 472 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maryland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-050-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Maryland">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Maryland">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-472</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-472.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-474" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-474/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co. (No. 3), 172 U.S. 474 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 474</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-474</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 474 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 474</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-474.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff17</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Maryland</topic>
              <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
              <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Chappell Chemical Co. v. Sulphur Mines Co. (No. 3), 172 U.S. 474 (1899);172 U.S. 474</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-474</accessId>
              <reportNumber>474</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>41</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 474</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 474 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Illegal Judgments</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agricultural Practices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Maryland</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Seventh Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Constitutional Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Resources and Mines</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Comity Primarily Removal Cases, Civil Procedure (Cf. Comity, Criminal and First Amendment), Deference to Foreign Judicial Tribunals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-051-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent>Business, corporation</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Maryland">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Maryland">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-16</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-474</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-474.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-475" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-475/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Water Power Co. v. Street Railway Co., 172 U.S. 475 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 475</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-475</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 475 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 475</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-475.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff16</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Bodies of Water</topic>
              <topic>Corporate Bodies</topic>
              <topic>Dams and Canals</topic>
              <topic>Board of Trustees</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Easements</topic>
              <topic>Water Resources</topic>
              <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
              <topic>Legal Titles</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Power Generation and Transmission</topic>
              <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>South Carolina</topic>
              <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Water Power Co. v. Street Railway Co., 172 U.S. 475 (1899);172 U.S. 475</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-475</accessId>
              <reportNumber>475</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>42</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 475</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 475 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Bodies of Water</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporate Bodies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Dams and Canals</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of Trustees</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Easements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Water Resources</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Power Generation and Transmission</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Treaties and International Agreements</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>South Carolina</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-052-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Electric or hydroelectric power utility, power cooperative, or gas and electric company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Electric or hydroelectric power utility, power cooperative, or gas and electric company</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="South Carolina">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin state="South Carolina">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="South Carolina">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-06</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-475</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-475.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-493" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-493/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Pittsburgh &amp;c. Railway v. Loan &amp; Trust Co., 172 U.S. 493 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 493</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-493</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 493 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 493</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-493.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff24</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Money Laundering</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Titles</topic>
              <topic>Illinois</topic>
              <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
              <topic>Civil Code</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Indiana</topic>
              <topic>Property Deeds</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Right to Claim</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Foreclosure Suits</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Ohio</topic>
              <topic>Building Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Pittsburgh &amp;c. Railway v. Loan &amp; Trust Co., 172 U.S. 493 (1899);172 U.S. 493</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-493</accessId>
              <reportNumber>493</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>43</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-09</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 493</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 493 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Foreclosure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Money Laundering</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Illinois</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Indiana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Deeds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Right to Claim</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreclosure Suits</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bankruptcy Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ohio</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Investment and Capital</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Highest State Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-053-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Railroad</petitioner>
              <respondent>Stockholder, shareholder, or bondholder</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Ohio">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Ohio">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-04-11</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Marshall Harlan</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-493</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-493.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-516" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-516/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Fitts v. McGhee, 172 U.S. 516 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 516</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-516</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 516 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 516</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-516.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff01</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Government Property</topic>
              <topic>Administrative Law</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Public Transit</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Attorney General</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
              <topic>Tolls</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
              <topic>Virginia</topic>
              <topic>Restraining Order</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Contempt of Court</topic>
              <topic>Transportation Costs</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>General Assembly</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
              <topic>Governor</topic>
              <topic>Eleventh Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Alabama</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Federal District Courts or Courts of Appeals (Cf. 753)</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Fitts v. McGhee, 172 U.S. 516 (1899);172 U.S. 516</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-516</accessId>
              <reportNumber>516</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>44</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-03</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 516</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 516 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Government Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Administrative Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Transit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Attorney General</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tolls</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Virginia</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Restraining Order</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contempt of Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Transportation Costs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>General Assembly</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Governor</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eleventh Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Alabama</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Federal District Courts or Courts of Appeals (Cf. 753)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-054-01</docketId>
              <petitioner state="Alabama">Governmental official, or an official of an agency established under an interstate compact</petitioner>
              <respondent>Person accused, indicted, or suspected of crime</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="Alabama">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Alabama U.S. Circuit Court for (all) District(s) of Alabama</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>Alabama U.S. Circuit Court for (all) District(s) of Alabama</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-26</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>John Marshall Harlan</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-516</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-516.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-534" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-534/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Washington Gas Light Co. v. Lansden, 172 U.S. 534 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 534</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-534</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 534 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 534</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-534.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfefe</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Oil and Gas</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Punitive Damages</topic>
              <topic>Torts Law</topic>
              <topic>Energy Prices</topic>
              <topic>Agency</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
              <topic>Freedom of Speech</topic>
              <topic>Libel</topic>
              <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>New York</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Congressional Committee</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
              <topic>Industrial Facilities</topic>
              <topic>Liability, Other than as in Sufficiency of Evidence, Election of Remedies, Punitive Damages</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Washington Gas Light Co. v. Lansden, 172 U.S. 534 (1899);172 U.S. 534</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-534</accessId>
              <reportNumber>534</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>45</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 534</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 534 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Oil and Gas</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Punitive Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Torts Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Prices</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Utilities and Utility Rates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Freedom of Speech</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Libel</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Energy Revenues and Royalties</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>New York</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Congressional Committee</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Criminal Intent</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Industrial Facilities</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Liability, Other than as in Sufficiency of Evidence, Election of Remedies, Punitive Damages</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-055-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Employer. If employer&apos;s relations with employees are governed by the nature of the employer&apos;s business (e.g., railroad, boat), rather than labor law generally, the more specific designation is used in place of Employer.</petitioner>
              <respondent>Employee, or job applicant, including beneficiaries of</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin>Supreme Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit (includes the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia but not the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which has local jurisdiction)</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-17</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Reversed and remanded</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Petitioning party received a favorable disposition</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Rufus Wheeler Peckham</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-534</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-534.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-557" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-557/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Orient Insurance Company v. Daggs, 172 U.S. 557 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 557</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-557</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 557 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 557</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-557.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2c</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Homeowner&apos;s Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Torts</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Agricultural Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Liability</topic>
              <topic>Connecticut</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Ex Post Facto Law</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
              <topic>Depreciation</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Orient Insurance Company v. Daggs, 172 U.S. 557 (1899);172 U.S. 557</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-557</accessId>
              <reportNumber>557</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>46</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-16</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 557</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 557 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Homeowner&apos;s Insurance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Torts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Insurance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agricultural Insurance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Liability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Connecticut</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Ex Post Facto Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporations and Associations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Depreciation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Regulation, Especially of Business (Cf. Federal Pre-Emption of State Court Jurisdiction, Federal Pre-Emption of State Legislation or Regulation)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-180-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Insurance company, or surety</petitioner>
              <respondent>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Missouri">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Missouri">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-08</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Constitutional Amendment</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Fourteenth Amendment (equal protection)</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-557</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-557.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-567" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-567/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Harsha, 172 U.S. 567 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 567</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-567</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 567 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 567</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-567.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff00</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
              <topic>Services Rendered</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Employee Hiring</topic>
              <topic>Torts</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Michigan</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Wages and Hours</topic>
              <topic>Comptroller</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>Labor and Employment Law</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Federal District Courts or Courts of Appeals (Cf. 753)</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Harsha, 172 U.S. 567 (1899);172 U.S. 567</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-567</accessId>
              <reportNumber>567</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>47</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-23</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 567</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 567 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Trials and Court Proceedings</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Services Rendered</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Claims</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Employee Hiring</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Torts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Michigan</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Wages and Hours</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Comptroller</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Department of the Treasury (D.O.T.)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Labor and Employment Law</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Administration: Supreme Court Jurisdiction or Authority on Appeal or Writ of Error, from Federal District Courts or Courts of Appeals (Cf. 753)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-056-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>United States</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Michigan">Governmental employee or job applicant</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Department or Secretary of the Treasury</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Michigan Eastern U.S. District Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Horace Gray</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-567</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-567.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-573" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-573/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Nat&apos;l Bank of Grand Forks v. Anderson, 172 U.S. 573 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 573</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-573</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 573 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 573</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-573.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff26</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>North Dakota</topic>
              <topic>Bank Notes</topic>
              <topic>Agency</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
              <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
              <topic>Collateral</topic>
              <topic>Liability</topic>
              <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Business Ethics</topic>
              <topic>Credit Markets</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>District Courts</topic>
              <topic>Securities</topic>
              <topic>Monetary Policy</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Financial Services</topic>
              <topic>United States Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Nat&apos;l Bank of Grand Forks v. Anderson, 172 U.S. 573 (1899);172 U.S. 573</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-573</accessId>
              <reportNumber>573</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>48</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-23</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 573</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 573 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>North Dakota</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bank Notes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Banks and Financial Institutions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Accounting and Auditing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Collateral</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Liability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Ethics</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Credit Markets</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>District Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Securities</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Monetary Policy</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Financial Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>United States Statutes</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Commercial Transactions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-057-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Bank, savings and loan, credit union, investment company</petitioner>
              <respondent>Debtor</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="North Dakota">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="North Dakota">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Interpretation of administrative regulation or rule, or executive order</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-573</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-573.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-576" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-576/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>United States v. Duell, 172 U.S. 576 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 576</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-576</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 576 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 576</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-576.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff04</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
              <topic>Trade Secrets</topic>
              <topic>Copyright</topic>
              <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Licensing and Registration</topic>
              <topic>Department of War</topic>
              <topic>Administrative Law and Regulatory Procedure</topic>
              <topic>Trademarks</topic>
              <topic>Contempt of Court</topic>
              <topic>Commissioner of Patents</topic>
              <topic>U.S. Patent and Trademark Office</topic>
              <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
              <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
              <topic>Monopolies</topic>
              <topic>Subpoena</topic>
              <topic>Copyright Infringement</topic>
              <topic>Patents</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Review of Administrative Agency&apos;s or Administrative Official&apos;s Actions and Procedures</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;United States v. Duell, 172 U.S. 576 (1899);172 U.S. 576</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-576</accessId>
              <reportNumber>576</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>49</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-23</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 576</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 576 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Revised Statutes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trade Secrets</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Copyright</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Intellectual Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Washington, D.C.</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Licensing and Registration</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Department of War</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Administrative Law and Regulatory Procedure</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trademarks</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contempt of Court</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Commissioner of Patents</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>U.S. Patent and Trademark Office</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appellate Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Monopolies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Subpoena</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Copyright Infringement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Patents</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Review of Administrative Agency&apos;s or Administrative Official&apos;s Actions and Procedures</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-058-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Unidentifiable</petitioner>
              <respondent>Patent Office, or Commissioner of, or Board of Appeals of</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Patent Office, or Commissioner of, or Board of Appeals of</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Supreme Court of the District of Columbia</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit (includes the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia but not the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which has local jurisdiction)</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-12-01</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Melville Weston Fuller</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-576</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-576.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-589" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-589/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Northern Pacific Railway v. Myers, 172 U.S. 589 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 589</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-589</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 589 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 589</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-589.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff20</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Property Tax</topic>
              <topic>Corporate Income Tax</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Land Grants</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Mineral Rights</topic>
              <topic>Montana</topic>
              <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Tax Levies</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Land Titles</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Land Commissioners</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>General Land Office</topic>
              <topic>Secretary of the Interior</topic>
              <topic>Land Patents</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Territorial Tax System</topic>
              <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
              <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Northern Pacific Railway v. Myers, 172 U.S. 589 (1899);172 U.S. 589</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-589</accessId>
              <reportNumber>589</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>50</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-23</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 589</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 589 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Property Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Corporate Income Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Grants</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Mineral Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Montana</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Avoidance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Levies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Titles</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Commissioners</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>General Land Office</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Secretary of the Interior</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Land Patents</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territorial Tax System</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>State or Local Government Tax</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Activity</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-059-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent state="Montana">County government or county governmental unit, except school district</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction state="Montana">State Agency</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>Montana U.S. Circuit Court for (all) District(s) of Montana</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1898-10-21</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>5</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>4</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-589</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-589.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-602" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-602/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Spratley, 172 U.S. 602 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 602</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-602</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 602 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 602</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-602.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Insurance Law</topic>
              <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
              <topic>Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Widows and Widowers</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
              <topic>Agency</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Trade Restrictions</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Bonds</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Foreign Corporations</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Power of Attorney</topic>
              <topic>Connecticut</topic>
              <topic>Foreign Companies</topic>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Fifth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Kentucky</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Premiums</topic>
              <topic>Life Insurance</topic>
              <topic>Due Process: Jurisdiction (Jurisdiction over Non-Resident Litigants)</topic>
              <topic>Due Process</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Spratley, 172 U.S. 602 (1899);172 U.S. 602</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-602</accessId>
              <reportNumber>602</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>51</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 602</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 602 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Insurance Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jurisdiction and Venue</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trusts and Estates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Insurance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Widows and Widowers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Agency</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Trade Restrictions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bonds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreign Corporations</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Power of Attorney</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Connecticut</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Foreign Companies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fifth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Kentucky</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Premiums</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Life Insurance</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process: Jurisdiction (Jurisdiction over Non-Resident Litigants)</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Due Process</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-060-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Insurance company, or surety</petitioner>
              <respondent>Heir, or beneficiary, or person so claiming to be</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Tennessee">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Tennessee">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>State or local law or regulation</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>State or Local Law Regulation</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Rufus Wheeler Peckham</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-602</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-602.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-622" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-622/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Hoeninghaus v. United States, 172 U.S. 622 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 622</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-622</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 622 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 622</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-622.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcfd91</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Investment</topic>
              <topic>Import and Export</topic>
              <topic>Taxation of Foreign Income</topic>
              <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
              <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
              <topic>Tax Law</topic>
              <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
              <topic>Appraisers</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
              <topic>Police Powers</topic>
              <topic>Collector of Customs</topic>
              <topic>Smuggling</topic>
              <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
              <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
              <topic>Tariff Act</topic>
              <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
              <topic>Appraised Value</topic>
              <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
              <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
              <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
              <topic>Tariffs</topic>
              <topic>Property</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
              <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Hoeninghaus v. United States, 172 U.S. 622 (1899);172 U.S. 622</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-622</accessId>
              <reportNumber>622</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>52</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 622</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 622 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Business Investment and Capital</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Investment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Import and Export</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Taxation of Foreign Income</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Board of General Appraisers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Administration and Collection</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tax Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Circuit Courts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appraisers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Taxation</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Police Powers</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Collector of Customs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Smuggling</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Conflicts of Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Forfeiture</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariff Act</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Manufacturing</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Appraised Value</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Customs Enforcement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Excise Taxes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Goods and Services</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Tariffs</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation of Gifts, Personal, Business, or Professional Expenses</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Federal Taxation</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-061-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Shipper, including importer and exporter</petitioner>
              <respondent>United States</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Certification</jurisdiction>
              <adminAction>Customs Service or Commissioner or Collector of Customs</adminAction>
              <caseOrigin>New York U.S. Circuit for (all) District(s) of New York</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource>U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1899-01-11</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Statutory construction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>Infrequently litigated statutes</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>Infrequently litigated statutes</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Certification to or from a lower court</disposition>
              <partyWinning>Favorable disposition for petitioning party unclear</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>George Shiras, Jr.</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>8</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>1</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-622</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-622.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-630" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-630/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Marshall v. Burtis, 172 U.S. 630 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 630</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-630</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 630 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 630</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-630.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff03</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
              <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
              <topic>Evidence</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Investment</topic>
              <topic>Deeds</topic>
              <topic>Legal Age</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Business Ethics</topic>
              <topic>Property Rights</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>Women in Business</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Real Property</topic>
              <topic>Private Action</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Marshall v. Burtis, 172 U.S. 630 (1899);172 U.S. 630</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-630</accessId>
              <reportNumber>630</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>53</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 630</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 630 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Fraud and Financial Crimes</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Jury Trials</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Evidence</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Investment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Deeds</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Age</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Inheritance and Succession</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Business Ethics</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Rights</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Women in Business</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>Real Property</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Private Action</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-062-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</petitioner>
              <respondent>Owner, landlord, or claimant to ownership, fee interest, or possession of land as well as chattels</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Appeal</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="Arizona">Territorial Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="Arizona">Territorial Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <authorityDecision>Supreme Court supervision of lower federal or state courts or original jurisdiction</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Affirmed (includes modified)</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Joseph McKenna</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-630</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-630.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-636" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-636/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>McQuade v. Trenton, 172 U.S. 636 (1899)</title>
              <partNumber>172 U.S. 636</partNumber>
              <partName>Case</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-636</identifier>
         <identifier type="preferred citation">172 U.S. 636 (1899)</identifier>
         <identifier type="United States Reports citation">172 U.S. 636</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-636.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff18</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <subject>
              <topic>Public Transit</topic>
              <topic>Economic Development</topic>
              <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
              <topic>Court of Chancery</topic>
              <topic>Engineers and Engineering</topic>
              <topic>Civil Code</topic>
              <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
              <topic>Torts</topic>
              <topic>Municipal Ordinances</topic>
              <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
              <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
              <topic>Roads and Highways</topic>
              <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
              <topic>Contracts</topic>
              <topic>Railroads</topic>
              <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
              <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
              <topic>Property Damage</topic>
              <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
              <topic>Civil Liability</topic>
              <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
              <topic>Property Law</topic>
              <topic>Pedestrians</topic>
              <topic>Building Construction</topic>
              <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
              <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
              <topic>Real Estate</topic>
              <topic>Property Access</topic>
              <topic>Court of Errors and Appeals</topic>
              <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
              <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
        </subject>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;McQuade v. Trenton, 172 U.S. 636 (1899);172 U.S. 636</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>CASE</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-636</accessId>
              <reportNumber>636</reportNumber>
              <sequenceNumber>54</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
              <decisionDate>1899-01-30</decisionDate>
              <courtTerm>1898</courtTerm>
              <usCitation>172 U.S. 636</usCitation>
              <fullCitation>172 U.S. 636 (1899)</fullCitation>
              <subject authority="llc" uri="https://www.loc.gov/research-centers/law-library-of-congress/about-this-research-center">
                                        
                   <topic>Public Transit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Economic Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Executive Agencies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Chancery</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Engineers and Engineering</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Code</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Fourteenth Amendment</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Torts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Municipal Ordinances</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Public Contracts and Procurement</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Government</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Territories and Protectorates</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Roads and Highways</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Infrastructure Development</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Contracts</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Railroads</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Legal Remedies</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Surveyors and Surveying</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Damage</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Bridges and Tunnels</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Liability</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Eminent Domain</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Law</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Pedestrians</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Building Construction</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Civil Actions</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>State and Local Finance</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Real Estate</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Property Access</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Court of Errors and Appeals</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <subject authority="scdb" uri="http://scdb.wustl.edu/documentation.php?var=issue">
                                        
                   <topic>No Merits: Dismissed or Affirmed for Want of a Substantial or Properly Presented Federal Question, or a Nonsuit</topic>
                                        
                   <topic>Judicial Power</topic>
                                    
            </subject>
              <docketId>1898-063-01</docketId>
              <petitioner>Injured person or legal entity, nonphysically and non-employment related</petitioner>
              <respondent state="New Jersey">City, town, township, village, or borough government or governmental unit</respondent>
              <jurisdiction>Writ of error</jurisdiction>
              <caseOrigin state="New Jersey">State Trial Court</caseOrigin>
              <caseSource state="New Jersey">State Supreme Court</caseSource>
              <certReason>Case did not arise on cert or cert not granted</certReason>
              <chiefJustice>Melville Weston Fuller</chiefJustice>
              <dateArgument>1899-01-12</dateArgument>
              <authorityDecision>Federal common law</authorityDecision>
              <law>
                                        
                   <type>No Legal Provision</type>
                                        
                   <legalProvisions>No Legal Provision</legalProvisions>
                                    
            </law>
              <decisionType>Opinion of the court (orally argued)</decisionType>
              <unconstitutionality>No declaration of unconstitutionality</unconstitutionality>
              <disposition>Petition denied or appeal dismissed</disposition>
              <partyWinning>No favorable disposition for petitioning party apparent</partyWinning>
              <majorityOpinion>
                                        
                   <writer>Henry Billings Brown</writer>
                                        
                   <assigner>Melville Weston Fuller</assigner>
                                    
            </majorityOpinion>
              <votes>
                                        
                   <majority>9</majority>
                                        
                   <minority>0</minority>
                                    
            </votes>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-636</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-636.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Decisions without Opinions</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff1e</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Decisions without Opinions</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>55</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-2.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Decisions on Petitions for Writs of Certiorari</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff09</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Decisions on Petitions for Writs of Certiorari</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>56</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-3.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>In Memoriam</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff28</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;In Memoriam</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>57</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-5.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Appendix</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff0b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Appendix</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>58</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter-4.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
    <relatedItem type="constituent" ID="id-USREPORTS-172-BackMatter" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/metadata/granule/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter/mods.xml">
         <titleInfo>
              <title>Index</title>
              <partName>Back Matter</partName>
        </titleInfo>
         <identifier type="uri">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter</identifier>
         <relatedItem type="otherFormat" xlink:href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter.pdf">
              <identifier type="FDsys Unique ID">D09002ee1d4dcff2b</identifier>
        </relatedItem>
         <extension>
              <searchTitle>United States reports : cases adjudged in the Supreme Court at October term, 1898;Index</searchTitle>
              <granuleClass>BACKMATTER</granuleClass>
              <accessId>USREPORTS-172-BackMatter</accessId>
              <sequenceNumber>59</sequenceNumber>
              <pagePosition>1</pagePosition>
        </extension>
         <location>
              <url displayLabel="Content Detail" access="object in context">https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/USREPORTS-172/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter</url>
              <url access="raw object" displayLabel="PDF rendition">https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-172/pdf/USREPORTS-172-BackMatter.pdf</url>
        </location>
    </relatedItem>
</mods>