[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2008, Book II)]
[December 15, 2008]
[Pages 1462-1466]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]
The President's News Conference With President Hamid Karzai of Afghanistan in Kabul, Afghanistan
December 15, 2008
[At this point, President Karzai spoke in Dari, and no translation was
provided.]
President Karzai. Most welcome, Mr. President. Most welcome.
President Bush. Thank you, sir. Yes, thanks, Mr. President; it's
good to be with a dear friend. You and I have spent a lot of time
together, and we have done a lot of work together, all aiming to give
the people of Afghanistan a better life. And I'm proud to be with you.
I hope you understand why it is important for me to get back to
Washington, and that is because my wife expects
for me to be back in Washington. [Laughter] We have a holiday reception
at the White House, and so I'm going to have to hustle back; after all,
I did sneak out of town under the dark of night. And now I'm going to go
back home having visited this important country. So thanks for having
me. And she sends her best. As you well know, that Laura's--one of her
great passions is to stand with the courageous women in Afghanistan. And
I can assure you, Mr. President, that after our time in Washington, we
both look forward to continuing to stay in touch and to continuing to
stay engaged with the people of Afghanistan. So Laura sends her deep
respect and great affection for the people of Afghanistan.
You know, I was thinking when I--right before we landed, how much
Afghanistan has changed since I have been the President. And sometimes
it's hard when you're in the midst of a difficult situation, it's hard
to get perspective. In 2001, the Taliban were brutally repressing the
people of this country. I remember the images of women being stoned or
people being executed in the soccer stadium because of their beliefs.
There was a group of killers that were hiding here and training here and
plotting here to kill citizens in my country.
Right after the attacks, I made it abundantly clear that we would
bring people to justice for our own security and made it abundantly
clear that if a group of people harbored a terrorist, they were equally
as guilty as a terrorist. And we gave the Taliban an opportunity to
respond; they didn't. And American troops proudly liberated the people
of Afghanistan. That's what life was like.
Now we could have replaced one power person with another. That would
have been, I guess, the easy route, and then just left it behind, say
we've done our duty and we've upheld the doctrine, and said, ``Okay,
we're now going to take this group, replace them with this group,'' and
just got out of the way. But that's not--that, one, didn't learn the
lessons of the eighties and the nineties. And secondly, the interest is
to build a flourishing democracy as an alternative to an hateful
ideology. And it's not easy work. Afghanistan is a huge country. The
road system is not nearly as well developed as a lot of other countries.
You're just beginning to develop your resource base in a way that I hope
benefits the people of Afghanistan; after all, it's their resources.
It's difficult because extremists refuse to accept the beauty of
democracy. They've got a different vision, and so therefore, they're
willing to kill innocent people to achieve their objectives.
There has been a lot of progress since 2001; after all, girls are
back in school. I happen to believe that's important. As the father of
twin girls, I
couldn't imagine living in a society where my little girls couldn't have
a chance to realize their God-given potential.
President Karzai. Yes.
[[Page 1463]]
President Bush. You've got boys flying kites again in Afghanistan.
You've got health clinics up all across the country. The President was
telling me of a health clinic in the remote northeast region of
Afghanistan, a place where it had been unimaginable.
President Karzai. [Inaudible]
President Bush. Yes. The economy has more than doubled in size. It
needs to double in size again, and then double in size again, no
question. But it has doubled in size. Security forces are growing
stronger. You've got good people in Afghanistan who are--you know, want
to work to provide security so that a political process can grow behind
it.
Now there's been good progress made, but there are a lot of tough
challenges. One of the great, interesting things that I'll be watching--
since I believe so strongly in democracy--are the upcoming elections.
And I've talked to General McKiernan, he
said--who's told me that--about the strategy, along with Ambassador
Wood, about the strategy to help the
Afghan folks--the military, and political leaders--get the elections up
and running. And it's going to be an exciting time for the people of
Afghanistan, to go to the polls and be able to express their opinion.
And I'm sure the press corps, the Afghanistan press corps, is looking
forward to covering the elections. It'll give you something to do in a
very important part of your country's history.
I told the President that you can count on the United States; just
like you've been able to count on this administration, you'll be able to
count on the next administration as well. It's in our interest that
Afghanistan's democracy flourish. It's in America's interest that we
forever deny safe haven for people who still want to kill our citizens.
And so, Mr. President, I come bringing the greetings of the country.
It has been a privilege to work with you over these years. I have come
to admire you, I appreciate your service, and I wish you and the people
of Afghanistan all the very best.
President Karzai. Most welcome, Mr. President; it's our pleasure and
honor. Most welcome.
Presidential Transition/President-Elect Obama's
Foreign Policy
Q. My question is from His Excellency, the President of the United
States. First, if President-elect Obama brings any change in the war
against terrorism in Afghanistan or any change in the strategy to--
towards Afghanistan or in the policies? Being from the Republicans, will
your party support his plannings?
And second, regarding he said he was in Pakistan and the terrorists
in Pakistan, what's your message to Obama that how he should deal with
Pakistani Government regarding terrorists, about the diplomat--using
diplomatic ways or using military?
President Bush. Yes. Thank you. First, I am of a different political
party than President-elect Obama. But I want him to succeed. I want him
to do well. And to this end, we have worked hard to help the transition.
Secondly, I think it is interesting that he has picked Secretary
Gates, the Secretary of Defense under--the
last couple of years under my administration, who will be the Secretary
of Defense under his administration. And I think that should send a
clear signal to the people of Afghanistan that the transition will be a
smooth transition.
I expect you'll see more U.S. troops here as quickly as possible in
parts of the country that are being challenged by the Taliban. I
remember when President Karzai and President Musharraf and I had the famous dinner at the White House.
President Karzai. Yes.
President Bush. And it--you know, the discussions really are the
same today as they were then, and that is that extremists and terrorists
and people who use car bombs and suicide bombers to achieve political
objectives are a threat to all of us.
[[Page 1464]]
And that there needs to be a comprehensive strategy in helping the
Pakistan Government deal with those who bring great harm on their
citizens and bring harm on the citizens of Afghanistan.
So to answer your question, I think it's a--we need to have a
collaborative strategy. We need to work together in a constructive way.
And we are making progress along those lines. You know, I was with
President Zardari in--I think it was in New
York. And I had never met him before, and I was reminding him that I'm,
you know, a person who says that we will defend our country and defend
our people. The most important job for the President of the United
States is defend our people from attack.
He said, ``You don't have to talk to me
about extremists attacking people, extremists killed my wife.'' And so
we're--there's a lot of consultations going on with the President--I
think you're going to be meeting with President Zardari soon.
President Karzai. Yes.
President Bush. And that's good, and I appreciate that.
Olivier [Olivier Knox, Agence France-Presse].
Military Operations in Afghanistan/Troop Levels in Afghanistan
Q. Thank you, gentlemen. I have one question for the two of you.
Canada has announced it's pulling out in 2011; South Korea is already
gone. In that context are you concerned about the level of international
support for the war here, and are the 20,000 additional U.S. troops
enough to bring this conflict to a close?
President Bush. Yes. Well, first of all, as you know, I've always
relied upon our military commanders to make the recommendations
necessary to achieve the objectives we've set forth. We have added
troops during--twice during my Presidency--obviously, in the initial
move in and then we added troops to that. I've announced we're going to
send in more troops. And then, of course, the Obama administration will be analyzing the situation, and it
sounds like that they intend to expedite the--sending more troops in.
So--and why do we do that? Because this is what our generals suggest
we do. To answer your--this is just going to be a long struggle, first
of all. This doesn't end tomorrow. Ideological struggles take time. As a
civil society whose firm political institutions begin to develop,
extremism begins to wither; it gets marginalized, and then it withers
away. And so it's going to take time. I can't tell you the troop levels
we'll need; all I know is our generals said, this is what we need now.
And they--I listened to them, and I'm confident President-elect
Obama will listen to the commanders as well.
President Karzai. We are already very grateful to all those
countries, nations who have come to help Afghanistan, and who have
already helped Afghanistan. Canada is among the countries that's the
frontrunner in assistance to Afghanistan. Their plans to withdraw their
troops by 2011 or '12 is not in contradiction to the understanding that
we have with them. They will continue to assist us in various other
forms in Afghanistan.
What is important here is that while we are continuing to fight
terrorism and to bring the institutional strength and stability to
Afghanistan, with an improved economy and improved governance and
service delivery by the Government, we also work on enabling Afghanistan
to eventually stand on its own feet. The Afghan people don't want to be
a burden on the international community forever. And we are grateful
already that the international community is helping us in blood and
their taxpayers' money.
We are grateful to Canada. We are grateful to all other countries,
as partners for building Afghanistan, for fighting terrorists who are
the enemies of all of us. So we are happy in any form of assistance
other countries give us and will be grateful for it.
[[Page 1465]]
One--pick up one more question, Mr. President? You'd like to
continue?
President Bush. All those who want another question, raise your
hand. [Laughter] I guess so, Mr. President.
[A reporter began to ask a question in Dari.]
President Bush. Hold on a second.
Progress in Afghanistan/Military Operations in Afghanistan
[The reporter continued his question, and no translation was provided.]
President Bush. I respectfully disagree with you. The Taliban was
brutalizing the people of Afghanistan. And they're not in power. And I
just cited the progress that is undeniable.
Now, is there more work to be done? You bet. I never said the
Taliban was eliminated; I said they were removed from power. And I said
girls are going back to school, and boys are flying kites, and health
clinics are opening, and the number of university students is
dramatically expanding, and the number of schools around the country is
growing, and there's a ring road built. Yes, there's no question there's
a Taliban that wants to fight back. Why? Because they want to regain
power. They can't stand the thought of a free society. And they're
lethal, and they are tough. No question about it, no question about it.
So therefore, is the suggestion because they're tough that we just
withdraw, that it's too hard work? Not as far as I'm concerned. I think
it's necessary work. And it's in the interest of the United States that
we not allow Afghanistan to become a safe haven again for Al Qaida. Al
Qaida is greatly weakened since 2001. As a matter of fact, they at one
point declared the most central front in the war on terror in Iraq,
where they're doing very poorly.
And they're not doing so well here either. Now, they can hide in
remote regions. They can hide, but we will stay on the hunt, and we will
keep the pressure on them, because it's in the people--the peaceful
people of Afghanistan's interest, just like it's in the interest of this
country.
And so is there still difficult days ahead? Absolutely. But are the
conditions a lot better today in Afghanistan than they were in 2001?
Unquestionably, undoubtedly, they're better.
[President Karzai spoke in Dari, and no translation was provided.]
President Karzai. Mr. President.
President Bush. Steven Lee [Steven Lee Myers, New York Times].
Troop Levels in Afghanistan
Q. Thank you, Mr. President. If I could ask President Karzai first.
We just came from Iraq, where they've signed an agreement outlining a
security arrangement, and it includes a withdrawal of American forces
within 3 years. I wonder if you envisioned a similar kind of arrangement
where--would you like to see a scheduled withdrawal or a timetable of
withdrawal for the foreign forces who are in Afghanistan? Thank you.
President Karzai. Well, sir, Afghanistan is in a cooperative
arrangement with the United States and the rest of the international
community. The decision in Afghanistan is to continue our cooperation
with the international community until we have defeated terrorism and
extremism and the threat that emanates from them to us, to our
neighbors, and to the rest of the world. And Afghanistan will not allow
the international community to leave it before we are fully on our feet,
before we are strong enough to defend our country, before we are
powerful enough to have a good economy, and before we have taken from
President Bush and the next administration billions and billions of more
dollars--[laughter]--no way that they can let you go.
President Bush. Yes, you better hurry up, in my case. [Laughter]
Thank you, sir. Thank you, all.
[[Page 1466]]
President Karzai. Most welcome, most welcome. Take care. Thanks very
much. Thank you.
Note: The President's news conference began at 7:53 a.m. at the
Presidential Palace. In his remarks, he referred to Gen. David D.
McKiernan, USA, commander, NATO International Security Assistance Force,
Afghanistan; former President Pervez Musharraf and President Asif Ali
Zardari of Pakistan; and former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto of
Pakistan, who was killed in a suicide attack in Rawalpindi, Pakistan, on
December 27, 2007. The Office of the Press Secretary also released a
Spanish language transcript of this press conference.