[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2008, Book I)]
[February 14, 2008]
[Pages 189-192]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



Remarks on Intelligence Reform Legislation and an Exchange With 
Reporters
February 14, 2008

    The President. Good afternoon. This Saturday at midnight, 
legislation authorizing intelligence professionals to quickly and 
effectively monitor terrorist communications will expire. If Congress 
does not act by that time, our ability to find out who the terrorists 
are talking to, what they are saying, and what they are planning will be 
compromised. It would be a mistake if the Congress were to allow this to 
happen.
    Members of Congress knew all along that this deadline was 
approaching. They said it themselves. They've had more than 6 months to 
discuss and deliberate, and now they must act and pass legislation that 
will ensure our intelligence professionals have the tools they need to 
keep us safe.
    Earlier this week, the Senate did act and passed a strong bill and 
did so with a bipartisan majority. The Senate bill will ensure

[[Page 190]]

that we can effectively monitor those seeking to harm our people. The 
Senate bill will provide fair and just liability protection for 
companies that assisted in the efforts to protect America after the 
attacks of September the 11th. Without this protection, without this 
liability shield, we may not be able to secure the private sector's 
cooperation with our intelligence efforts. And that, of course, would 
put the American people at risk.
    Now it's the House's turn to act. It is clear that the Senate bill 
would pass the House with bipartisan support. Republicans and Democrats 
in the Senate can put partisanship aside and pass a good bill. There's 
no reason why the House cannot do the same and pass the Senate bill 
immediately.
    Our Government has no greater responsibility than getting this work 
done, and there really is no excuse for letting this critical 
legislation expire. I urge congressional leaders to let the will of the 
House and the American people prevail and vote on the Senate bill before 
adjourning for their recess. Failure to act would harm our ability to 
monitor new terrorist activities and could reopen dangerous gaps in our 
intelligence. Failure to act would also make the private sector less 
willing to help us protect the country, and this is unacceptable. The 
House should not leave Washington without passing the Senate bill.
    Now, I am scheduled to leave tomorrow for a long-planned trip to 
five African nations. Moments ago, my staff informed the House 
leadership that I'm prepared to delay my departure and stay in 
Washington with them if it will help them complete their work on this 
critical bill.
    The lives of countless Americans depend on our ability to monitor 
terrorist communications. Our intelligence professionals are working day 
and night to keep us safe, and they're waiting to see whether Congress 
will give them the tools they need to succeed or tie their hands by 
failing to act. The American people are watching this debate as well. 
They expect Congress to meet its responsibilities before they leave town 
on a recess.
    I'll answer a few questions. Ben [Ben Feller, Associated Press], if 
you've got a question, I'll be prepared to answer.

President's Upcoming Visit to Africa/Intelligence Reform Legislation

    Q. Thank you, Mr. President. It appears with that deadline 
approaching that the House and the White House might be seen as being 
engaged in a game of chicken here, playing politics with an important 
intelligence law.
    The President Yes.
    Q. If the law expires and something happens, wouldn't you be at 
least partly to blame? And on your Africa trip, if you have to delay, do 
you think that you would be shortening your trip at all?
    The President. As to the latter, the delay depends on whether the 
House acts, of course, and they got plenty of time to get this done. But 
if we have to delay, we'll delay. But I'm going to go to the countries 
that I said I'd go to.
    And to the first case, whether or not this is politics, I certainly 
hope not. I can assure you, Al Qaida in their planning isn't thinking 
about politics. They're thinking about hurting the American people 
again.
    Who's to blame? Look, these folks in Congress passed a good bill 
last--late last summer. In other words, they analyzed the situation, 
they said there's a threat, and they agreed to give our professionals 
the tools they needed to do the job. The problem is, they let the bill 
expire.
    My attitude is, if the bill was good enough then, why not pass the 
bill again? I mean, the threat hasn't gone away. Secondly, they've had 
plenty of time to think about how to address the issue. Thirdly, the 
Senate led the way; the Senate showed how to pass a good bill with a 
bipartisan majority. And the truth of the matter is, if there was a 
willingness to get this problem solved, all the leadership would have to 
do is submit the Senate bill for a vote.

[[Page 191]]

    So we'll see what happens. My attitude is, now is the time to get 
the job done. There's been plenty of time to think about it, plenty of 
time to debate it, and there's a good way forward. And hopefully, the 
House leadership will put this bill for a vote and let the Members vote 
as they so desire.
    Mike [Mike Emanuel, FOX News].

Terrorist Surveillance Program/War on Terror

    Q. Mr. President, I realize this is a sensitive matter, but I'm 
wondering if there's a way you can spell out for the American public 
what the practical impact may be, if this law expires, on our 
intelligence professionals, say, next week.
    The President. Well, I hope it doesn't. But clearly, there will be a 
gap. And of course, we won't be able to assess that gap until the time. 
Step one is, I guess you got to come to the conclusion that there's a 
threat to America or not a threat. I mean, evidently, some people just 
don't feel that sense of urgency. I do. And the reason I do, is I firmly 
believe that there's still people out there who would do us harm.
    Secondly, I know that the tools that I've just described are 
necessary to protect us. Why? Because we need to know what people are 
saying, what they're planning, and what they're thinking. And the tool 
that I have just described has been very effective.
    Thirdly, people are wondering why companies need liability 
protection. Well, if you cooperate with the Government and then get sued 
for billions of dollars because of the cooperation, you're less likely 
to cooperate. And obviously, we're going to need people working with us 
to find out what the enemy is saying and thinking and plotting and 
planning.
    And so it's a--to me, it's a--I guess one way to look at it is, some 
may not feel that same sense of urgency I do. I heard somebody say, 
``Well, this is just pure politics.'' No, this is what is necessary to 
protect the American people from harm. And I recognize there hasn't been 
an attack on our country, but that does not mean that there's not still 
an enemy that lurks, plans, and plots.
    And one of the reasons we've been effective is because we put new 
tools in place that give our professionals that which is necessary to 
protect us. This is a different kind of threat than we've ever faced 
before. It's a different kind of war that we're fighting, and it 
requires a different approach.
    Again, I'll repeat to you that the Congress took a look at this 
issue and decided that the tools were necessary to give to our 
professionals last--late last summer. And if it was necessary late last 
summer, why is it not necessary today? What has changed? Well, the 
threat hasn't gone away. It's still there, it's still real, and we 
better be worried about it as a nation. And the House has now got time 
to go out and get the deal done.
    Yesterday, a couple of days--votes ago in the Senate made it 
abundantly clear that Republicans and Democrats can come together and 
get a--put a good piece of legislation together and get it passed. And 
the House leadership has an opportunity to do that now.
    Listen, thank you all very much.

Note: The President spoke at 1 p.m. on the South Lawn at the White 
House. In his remarks, he referred to H.R. 3773.

[[Page 192]]