    [Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2006, Book II)]
    [August 31, 2006]
    [Pages 1589-1595]
    [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]

    Remarks at a Reception for Senatorial Candidate Orrin G. Hatch in Salt
    Lake City
    August 31, 2006

        Thank you all very much. Thank you all. Please be seated. Thanks for
    the warm welcome. It's great to be here in Utah. Gosh, I landed at the
    airport last night--a couple of thousand people out there to say hello.
    I just had the honor of speaking to the American Legion; then come to a
    hall filled with great citizens concerned about the reelection of Orrin
    Hatch. I'm telling--here to tell you, this guy is doing a great job and
    you need to send him back to the United States Senate.
        I'm proud to call him friend. And he's an effective person in
    Washington. I don't know if you can tell it this far away from
    Washington, but he's effective. He gets things done. People like to hear
    him; they listen to him; they trust him; they trust his judgment. And so
    do I. And every time I'm around Orrin Hatch, after he gets through
    talking about Utah, he finally gets to the country. [Laughter] In other
    words, he loves Utah, and he loves the citizens of Utah.
        And he married well. We're proud to be here with Elaine and the Hatch family. Laura
    said to me, she said, ``You get over to Utah, and you help our friends
    come back to Washington, DC.'' She sends her love. I married well, just
    like Orrin married well. It helps to have somebody you love stand by
    your side when you're in politics. There's nothing better than having a
    person that you care deeply about and--to share the experience. And
    that's the way the Hatchs have been, and they've served a great example
    for a lot of younger political families. And thank you for having the
    right priorities, faith and your family and your friends.
        And so I've come to say as best as I can and in as plain English as
    I can possibly speak--which sometimes gets a little distorted--
    [laughter]--please send Orrin Hatch back to the United States Senate.
        I want to thank the Governor and
    Mary Kaye for joining us. I appreciate
    you all taking time to come to support the senior Senator from the State
    of Utah. It's smart politics. [Laughter] You're doing a fine job, and
    the people of Utah are proud of you.
        I want to thank the other Senator, Senator Bob Bennett, for his courageous leadership and friendship. I want
    to thank Congressman Rob Bishop and
    Congressman Chris Cannon for joining
    us today and for serving the country. Glad you all are here. Cannon's
    brother is the chairman of the Republican
    Party. I like to remind the chairman that he's the cuter Cannon.
    [Laughter] Is that okay? No. [Laughter]
        I want to thank all the statehouse folks who've joined us today too.
    I appreciate John Valentine who is the
    senate president--leader, and Greg Curtis,
    the speaker. I want to thank all of you who are senators and
    representatives. I appreciate you serving your communities. I had--some
    of the greatest experiences I've ever had in politics--was working with
    our State senate and our house of representatives in the State of Texas.
    And I hope, Governor, you're having as
    much fun working with them as I had. And if not, just keep telling them
    what to do, and eventually they'll get the message. [Laughter] But thank
    you all for serving.
        I appreciate all the local folks here. I particularly want to say
    thanks to former Senator Jake Garn,
    who is with us. Senator, good to see you. I appreciate you coming. And I
    see my friend Jim Hansen is with us today.
    Congressman, good to see you, thanks for being here. And I wish LaVar
    Christensen all the best in his run for
    the congressional seat here in Utah. Good luck to you. Appreciate you.

    [[Page 1590]]

        And most of all, thanks for helping Orrin. It takes a lot of work to
    get this many people in the room. And for those of you who organized
    this event, thank you. I know how hard you worked, and so does he. This
    is an incredibly successful fundraiser, and he deserves it.
        And for those of you involved in grassroots politics, thanks a lot
    for your hard work. Thanks for making sure that Utah was solid in 2004,
    and thank you for making sure that Utah remains solid in 2006. I
    appreciate you putting up the signs. I appreciate you making the phone
    calls. I appreciate you knocking on the doors.
        A lot of times, people kind of forget the efforts you make, but I
    don't, and I know Orrin doesn't. I know the Governor appreciates all the grassroots activists. So thanks for
    the good work you're doing here in the great State of Utah.
        These are historic times in which we're living. This generation of
    ours is being challenged, and it's a tough challenge because we're
    facing an enemy that knows no bounds of decency, an enemy that uses
    tactics that are beyond our imagination to achieve certain objectives.
    The President has to make a lot of decisions. Mine is a decisionmaking
    experience. And I just want you to know that a lot of the decisions I
    have made were based upon the experiences of the attacks on September
    the 11th. See, I vowed that day that I would never forget our most
    important duty in Washington, DC, is to protect the American people.
        And Orrin Hatch understands that. He is a strong supporter of our
    strategy to defend the country. That strategy starts with understanding
    this doctrine: One, you can't rationalize with these people; you cannot
    negotiate with these extremists, these terrorists, these people who are
    bound together by an ideology that is hateful. The only way to protect
    the American people is to stay on the offense and defeat them overseas
    so we do not have to face them here at home.
        But it's important to understand the nature of this war. This is
    more than just a military conflict. This is the decisive ideological
    struggle of the 21st century. Some would like to assign this war to
    something as simple as law enforcement. That shows a lack of
    understanding of the nature of the enemy. Law enforcement means we
    wouldn't use all assets at our disposal to protect the American people.
    This is an ideological struggle, and it's the struggle of the century.
    And it's the struggle in which we must prevail for the sake of our
    children and our grandchildren.
        On the one side of this struggle are those who believe in freedom
    and moderation, the right of people to speak, the right of people to
    worship freely--one of the great privileges in America, isn't it? I'm
    proud as the President to be able to say you're equally American if
    you're Jew, Muslim, Christian, agnostic, atheist; we're all equally
    American. And one of the great treasured rights of our society is for
    people to be able to worship freely.
        On this struggle are those who believe in the universality of
    liberty. I personally believe there's an Almighty, and I believe that
    one of the great gifts of that Almighty to every man, woman, and child
    on the face of the Earth is the desire to live in freedom.
        And on the other side of this ideological struggle are those who are
    driven by tyranny and extremism, the right of a self-appointed few to
    impose their fanatical views over the rest of us. And that's the
    struggle. And it's important that our fellow citizens understand that
    struggle.
        We didn't ask for this war, but we will answer history's call with
    confidence. And it's important to have Members of the United States
    Senate who understand the call of history and are willing to stand
    strong in the face of an enemy who is relenting. That's the challenge of
    the 21st century.
        As I told you, we'll stay on the offense. As well, I made it clear
    that if you harbor

    [[Page 1591]]

    a terrorist, you're just as guilty as the terrorists, and you're an
    enemy of the United States, and you will be held to account. In other
    words, this is a war in which nation-states aren't necessarily in the
    league, as previous wars, in, but they provide safe haven for. It's
    important when the President speaks, he means what he says. I spoke
    clearly to the world that if you harbor a terrorist, you're equally as
    guilty as the terrorists. The Taliban didn't take our word seriously.
    And thanks to a fantastic United States military, along with allies, we
    removed the Taliban. We upheld doctrine, we freed 25 million Afghan
    citizens, and the world is better off.
        A lesson of September the 11th is that when this Nation sees a
    threat, we must take it seriously, before it fully materializes. If
    there is a threat, we must recognize that threat and deal with it before
    it comes home to hurt us. You know, the tendency in any difficult
    situation is for some to want to forget the lessons, put the past behind
    and think about a more comforting future. And I can understand that. As
    a matter of fact, part of my job is to assure the American people that
    we understand the threat and that people should go on about their lives.
    Let us worry about it. That's why I've asked to make sure we have all
    the tools necessary to protect the American people, tools like the
    PATRIOT Act, which Orrin helped get passed, tools like the capacity to
    listen to an Al Qaida phone call. If they're calling into the United
    States, we want to know why so we can protect the American people.
        I saw a threat in Iraq. As a matter of fact, members of both
    political parties in the United States Congress saw the same threat.
    Nations around the world saw the threat. And the threat was a
    tyrant who brutally murdered thousands of his
    own citizens; a tyrant who had invaded his neighbors; a tyrant who had
    used weapons of mass destruction on his people; a tyrant who previous
    administrations had declared a state sponsor of terror; a tyrant who,
    when the world spoke through the United Nations, ignored the world. I
    think when the world speaks, it must mean what it says. And so we gave
    the tyrant one last chance to disclose and disarm, or face serious
    consequences. It was his choice to make. The world is safer, the Iraqi
    people are better, the cause for liberty is more advanced because Saddam
    Hussein is no longer in power.
        Iraq is the central front in the war on terror. Usama bin Laden has made that clear. Zawahiri has made that clear; he's the number-two man in Al Qaida.
    Their mission is to drive us out of Iraq in order to achieve safe haven,
    safe haven from which to launch further attacks against moderate
    elements in the Middle East, safe haven from which to plan and plot
    attacks against the United States of America. They're not going to
    succeed.
        There are powerful forces inside Iraq that to me--causes me to be
    optimistic, starting with the Iraqi people themselves. You know, last
    December seems like an eternity, particularly to those of us in
    political office. But that's not too long in the march of history, is
    it? Last December, 12 million Iraqis, in defiance of terrorists and
    killers and suicide bombers, said loud and clear, ``We want to be free.
    We want a government of, by, and for the people.''
        And since then, under a constitution that is one of the most modern
    constitutions ever in the Middle East, a unity government has formed, a
    government desirous of responding to the people, a government working
    hard to reject the extremists who want to stop the advance of democracy
    and freedom. This is a tough war. It's a tough war because the enemy
    will use any tactic to cause the Iraqis to split apart or any tactic
    trying to drive the United States out of the Middle East. We must
    persevere. We must continue to work with this democratically elected
    Government of Iraq. We must continue to give their army the skills
    necessary to fight. And we must stay on the hunt for terrorist elements,
    which we

    [[Page 1592]]

    are doing. We'll succeed in Iraq, and when we do, this country will be
    more secure.
        I understand there's a debate, and, of course, there should be a
    debate. I mean, I welcome debates in our society. One of the great
    things about America is, people can go into the public square and
    express themselves openly without fear of the state. That's what we
    welcome. In these 2006 campaigns, there will be a lot of debate. There
    will be people--good people, decent people, patriotic people--who say,
    ``Now is the time to leave Iraq,'' and they are wrong.
        If we leave before Iraq can defend itself and govern itself and
    sustain itself, this will be a key defeat for the United States of
    America in this ideological struggle of the 21st century. If we leave
    before this young democracy has its roots firmly in place, so that an
    example of liberty flourishes in a region that's so desperate for
    something other than a society that's caused resentment and
    hopelessness, if we leave, it will embolden the enemy. The enemy has
    said this is the front in the war on terror. That's what they have
    proclaimed. They'll become even more bold. If we leave before the job is
    done, we'll help create a terrorist state in the heart of the Middle
    East that will have control of huge oil reserves. If we leave before the
    job is done, this country will have no credibility. People will look at
    our words as empty words. People will not trust the judgment and the
    leadership of the United States. Reformers will shrink from their deep
    desire to live in a free society. Moderates will wonder if their voice
    will ever be heard again. If we leave before the job will be done, those
    who sacrificed, those brave volunteers who sacrificed in our United
    States military will have died in vain. And as General Abizaid has said, if we leave before the job is done, if we
    leave the streets of Baghdad, the enemy will follow us to our own
    streets in America.
        The stakes are high. I believe the only way we can lose is if we
    leave before the job is done. That's what I believe. I'm making my
    decisions based upon the recommendations of commanders on the ground. I
    want to assure you, polls and focus groups will not decide the Iraq
    policy in the global war on terror. And when we win and when we achieve
    our stated objective, it will be a major defeat for the terrorists in
    this global war on terror. It will strengthen the spread of democracy in
    the Middle East. Imagine what the example of a democratic Iraq, a
    country that has adopted a democracy based upon its history and its
    traditions, imagine the signal it will send to those reformers in Iran
    or those hopeful Palestinians that say, ``Someday, we want a state to
    live in peace with our neighbor Israel.'' When we succeed in Iraq, we'll
    have created a valuable ally in the global war on terror.
        I don't know if you remember this, but recently I had the honor of
    and privilege of taking my friend the Prime Minister of Japan to Graceland, Elvis's place. [Laughter] I've never
    been to Graceland. I thought it would be fun to go, but more
    importantly, he wanted to go. See, he was an Elvis buff. [Laughter] I
    also thought it would send an interesting message that I hope helps
    explain the stakes of this ideological struggle we're in. Can you
    imagine somebody after World War II saying, ``I predict one day an
    American President will be going to a singer's home with the Prime
    Minister of Japan?'' They'd have thought the guy was off his rocker.
    Isn't it interesting that a son of a Navy torpedo fighter who fought the Japanese with all his soul and all his
    might, like many of your relatives did, flew down on Air Force One with
    the Prime Minister of the former enemy? I
    think it is. And I think it's an historical lesson that we all can learn
    something about.
        And by the way, when we were on the plane, guess what we talked
    about--how we can work together to keep the peace. We talked about North
    Korea. We talked about what it meant for Japan to send

    [[Page 1593]]

    1,000 troops into Iraq to help this young democracy fight off the
    ideologues of hate. We talked about our HIV/AIDS initiative in Africa.
    We talked about building roads in Afghanistan. I found it incredibly
    interesting that I was able to sit down with the Prime Minister of a
    former enemy and talk about the peace.
    Something happened between 41's time in the
    U.S. Navy and 43's time talking with the Prime Minister of Japan. Japan
    adopted a Japanese-style democracy.
        Liberty has the capacity to transform enemies into allies. One of
    these days, American Presidents will be sitting down with duly elected
    leaders of the Middle East, and they will be talking about keeping the
    peace. And this generation will be able to say, the world was safer for
    our children and grandchildren.
        And this Senator understands the stakes, and I'm proud to serve with
    him. Both of us are honored to be able to say, we're laying the
    foundation of peace for generations to come.
        He also understands this, that the more money you have in your
    pocket, the more you're going to save, invest, and spend, and the better
    our economy does. The classic debate in Washington, DC, really centers
    around this: Who best to spend your money, you or the Government?
    Senator Hatch and I believe you can spend it better than the Government,
    and therefore, we strongly believe--[applause]. And that's why, when
    things got tough, economically tough, we cut the taxes on everybody who
    paid taxes. And it worked. This economy of ours is strong. Progrowth
    economic policies work. And the way to make sure this economy remains
    strong is to make the tax relief we passed a permanent part of the Tax
    Code.
        The unemployment rate is 4.8 percent. Since August of 2005, we've
    created more than 5.5 million new jobs. Productivity is high. The
    economy has grown now for 35 straight months. It has added jobs for 35
    straight--your unemployment rate, Governor, congratulations, is 3.4 percent. People are working.
    Productivity is high. That's good; we're a productive society. We're
    constantly trying to improve. Entrepreneurship is strong. Minorities are
    owning businesses. Homeownership has been high. I mean, this is a
    productive period of time for the American people. It's because our
    philosophy works; cutting taxes, trusting people with their own money
    makes sense.
        And you know what else happens? It increases revenues for the
    Treasury. You know, there's been a lot of talk about the deficits, and
    there should be. We're concerned about the deficit. As a matter of fact,
    I said to the Congress, join us in being fiscally responsible about how
    we spend the people's money, and we can cut that deficit. The deficit is
    going to be cut in half, not by 2009 but by 2008, because progrowth
    economic policies work. The best way--and by the way, in Washington,
    you'll hear them say, ``Well, in order to balance the budget, we need to
    raise more revenues.'' But that's not the way it works in Washington.
    Yeah, they'll raise revenues; they'll increase your taxes; but they will
    figure out new ways to spend your money. The best way to balance the
    budget is to keep taxes low and be fiscally responsible with the
    taxpayers' money. And that's what we're doing.
        Orrin said, ``Keep it short.'' I obviously didn't listen very
    carefully. I want to work with him to make sure this country becomes
    less dependent on foreign sources of oil. It's in our economic interests
    that we become less dependent on foreign sources of oil, and it is in
    our national security interests. And so therefore, we will continue to
    spend money wisely on new technologies.
        We're big believers in the nuclear power industry's capacity to make
    sure that we protect the environment with renewable sources of energy. I
    see automobiles being driven by batteries that can drive the first 40
    miles on electricity. I know we got clean coal technologies that will
    eventually work. It's the calling of our time to make sure

    [[Page 1594]]

    that we do smart things with your money to enable us to diversify away
    from oil from countries, particularly those countries that don't like
    us. I look forward to working with Orrin to make sure that we remain
    competitive by spending money, wisely spending money on research and
    development both at the Federal level and at the private level, which is
    why we need to make permanent the research and development tax credit.
        I look forward to working with Orrin and other Members of the United
    States Senate to once and for all do something about junk lawsuits,
    particularly those that are running good doctors out of practice. People
    worry about the cost of health care. One way to deal with the cost of
    health care is to get rid of these junk lawsuits.
        It's one thing, if you got a problem, to have your day in court. But
    these junk lawsuits--you see, when I first got to Washington, I said,
    ``Well, the States can figure it out.'' Governor, you know, you all write your own laws. And then I
    realized the defensive practice of medicine costs you, the taxpayers,
    about $28 billion a year. Docs and providers providing unnecessary
    services in order to defend themselves against junk lawsuits cost the
    Federal Government--because of Medicaid, Medicare, and veterans health
    benefits--about 28 billion. I came to the conclusion, therefore, this is
    a Federal problem that requires a Federal solution.
        Congress passed--the House passed a good piece of legislation. I'm
    going to continue to work with Senators Hatch and Bennett to get good
    legislation out of the United States Senate to make sure health care is
    available and affordable for folks all across the United States of
    America.
        And speaking about health care, you did a fine job of training my
    Secretary for Health and Human Services, Leavitt. He's doing a great job. He really is. And he said he's
    down there--somebody said he was fishing with him recently. So when you
    see him again, tell him to get back to work. [Laughter]
        Finally, I want to say something about the judiciary. I've had no
    stronger ally than Orrin Hatch in making sure that we appoint judges who
    know the difference between being a judge and a legislator. One of my
    most important responsibilities is to make sure we have people on the
    Federal bench who strictly interpret the Constitution and not use the
    bench from which to legislate. And I had the honor of naming two members
    of the Supreme Court--and I took my time, and I looked at a lot of good
    folks, and I came up with some fine names. And thanks to the support and
    leadership of Senator Orrin Hatch, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Sam Alito now sit on the bench, and the United States is better off
    for it.
        He just told me, if I didn't end, he's going to make me listen to
    one of his songs. [Laughter] Actually, the man has got some talent.
    [Laughter] And he's a great songwriter but not as good a Senator--as he
    is a Senator. And that's saying a lot. You've got a fine man in the
    United States Senate in Orrin Hatch. He's decent; he's honorable; he
    gets the job done. I thank you for supporting him. Send him back to
    Washington, and Utah and America will benefit--continue to benefit from
    his service.
        I thank you for the warm welcome here. It's been such a joy to come
    back to your beautiful State. May God bless you all.

    Note: The President spoke at 11 a.m. at the Grand America Hotel. In his
    remarks, he referred to Gov. Jon M. Huntsman, Jr., of Utah, and his
    wife, Mary Kaye; Joseph A. Cannon, chairman, Utah Republican Party;
    LaVar Christensen, candidate for Congress in Utah's Second Congressional
    District; former President Saddam Hussein of Iraq; Usama bin Laden,
    leader of the Al Qaida terrorist organization; Ayman Al-Zawahiri,
    founder of the Egyptian Islamic Jihad and senior Al Qaida associate;
    Gen. John P.

    [[Page 1595]]

    Abizaid, USA, commander, U.S. Central Command; and Prime Minister
    Junichiro Koizumi of Japan.