[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2005, Book I)]
[April 11, 2005]
[Pages 580-587]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]
The President's News Conference With Prime Minister Ariel Sharon of Israel in Crawford, Texas
April 11, 2005
President Bush. Mr. Prime Minister, welcome to my home. Appreciate
you coming. I appreciate our meeting. I'm looking forward to serving you
some good food for lunch. Most importantly, I'm looking forward to
driving you around the ranch; I want you to see my place. I know you
love the land. The Prime Minister was telling me he's really a farmer at
heart, and I look forward to sharing with my friend what life is like
here in central Texas. So, welcome. He invited me to his place one day,
in Israel, and it's something that I look forward to doing as well.
The United States and the State of Israel have a deep and lasting
friendship based on our shared values and aspirations for a peaceful
world. The United States is committed to Israel's security and well-
being as a Jewish state, including secure and defensible borders. We're
committed to preserving and strengthening Israel's capability to deter
its enemies and to defend itself.
Today we discussed ways to expand cooperation of our economies. The
Prime
[[Page 581]]
Minister believes that developing Negev and the Galilee regions is vital
to ensuring a vibrant economic future for Israel. I support that goal,
and we will work together to make his plans a reality.
Prime Minister Sharon is showing strong, visionary leadership by
taking difficult steps to improve the lives of people across the Middle
East, and I want to thank you for your leadership. I strongly support
his courageous initiative to disengage from Gaza and part of the West
Bank. The Prime Minister is willing to coordinate the implementation of
the disengagement plan with the Palestinians. I urge the Palestinian
leadership to accept his offer. By working together, Israelis and
Palestinians can lay the groundwork for a peaceful transition.
The Prime Minister and I discussed the important and encouraging
changes taking place in the region, including a Palestinian election. We
discussed the need for Israel to work with the Palestinian leadership to
improve the daily lives of Palestinians, especially their humanitarian
situation, so that Israelis and Palestinians can realize a peaceful
future together.
I reiterated that the United States supports the establishment of a
Palestinian state that is viable, contiguous, sovereign, and
independent. The United States will continue working with the
international community to help Palestinians develop democratic
political institutions, build security institutions dedicated to
maintaining law and order and dismantling terrorist organizations,
reconstruct civic institutions, and promote a free and prosperous
economy.
I remain strongly committed to the vision of two democratic states,
Israel and Palestine, living side by side in peace and security. The
Prime Minister and I reaffirmed our commitment to that vision and to the
roadmap as the only way forward to realize it. The roadmap has been
accepted and endorsed by both Israel and the Palestinian Authority,
along with virtually the entire international community. The Prime
Minister and I share a desire to see the disengagement from Gaza and
part of the West Bank serve to reenergize progress along the roadmap.
The United States is working with Palestinians and Israelis to
improve security on the ground. We are cooperating with the Palestinians
to help them fulfill all their obligations under the roadmap, especially
sustained, effective operations to stop terrorism and dismantle
terrorist capabilities and infrastructure. Building true security for
Israelis and Palestinians demands an immediate, strong, and sustained
effort to combat terrorism in all its forms.
I've told the Prime Minister of my concern that Israel not undertake
any activity that contravenes roadmap obligations or prejudice final
status negotiations. Therefore, Israel should remove unauthorized
outposts and meet its roadmap obligations regarding settlements in the
West Bank.
As part of a final peace settlement, Israel must have secure and
recognized borders. These should emerge from negotiations between the
parties in accordance with United Nations Security Council Resolutions
242 and 338. As I said last April, new realities on the ground make it
unrealistic to expect that the outcome of final status negotiations will
be a full and complete return to the armistice lines of 1949. It is
realistic to expect that any final status agreement will be achieved
only on the basis of mutually agreed changes that reflect these
realities. That's the American view. While the United States will not
prejudice the outcome of final status negotiations, those changes on the
ground, including existing major Israeli population centers, must be
taken into account in any final status negotiations.
I'm grateful to the Prime Minister for his friendship. I'm impressed
by his leadership. I want to thank you for coming, sir, and I look
forward to working with you in the years ahead.
Prime Minister Sharon. Thank you, Mr. President, for this important
meeting and
[[Page 582]]
for your generous hospitality. It was a pleasure to be invited to your
home here at the ranch. On behalf of the State of Israel, I wish to
thank you, your administration, and the American people for your warm
and steadfast friendship. Of course, I would be very glad, Mr.
President, to have you as a guest on our farm, not only because we are
short of labor. [Laughter]
President Bush. You're desperate for labor if you're counting on me.
[Laughter]
Prime Minister Sharon. The people of Israel dream of a peaceful life
for themselves and for all the peoples of the Middle East. We are
encouraged by many of the positive changes that we see taking place in
our region. We call upon our Palestinian neighbors to choose the path of
democracy and law and order, so that they can establish an independent
and viable state.
This is an opportunity for us to break from the continuous path of
violence and bloodshed, which has been forced upon us, particularly,
over the past, say, 4\1/2\ years. I told the Palestinian Authority
Chairman, Mr. Mahmoud Abbas, that this is a year of great opportunity to
start building a better future for our children and grandchildren and
that both our peoples must make sure that this opportunity is not
missed. But we must act now. The ongoing violence and terror must not
prevail. We should make all a commitment not to accept any temporary
solutions regarding terror but to act decisively to dismantle terrorist
infrastructure and to eliminate terrorism once and for all.
Defeating terror is the only way to build peace. The Israeli people
have no intention of missing this opportunity. That is why we are acting
quickly and with determination to improve the conditions for the
Palestinian population. We have released hundreds of Palestinian
prisoners. We are preparing to release more as the security situation
allows. We have removed many roadblocks in the West Bank to allow
greater mobility for the Palestinians. We have transferred the cities of
Jericho and Tulkarm to the security control of the Palestinian
Authority. And we will transfer more in the coming period as the
security situation allows.
Mr. President, as I said in Aqaba 2 years ago, it is not in our
interest to govern over the Palestinians. We would like the Palestinians
to govern themselves in their own state, a democratic state with
territorial contiguity in Judea and Samaria, living side by side with
Israel in peace and security. We seek to rebuild trust and respect the
dignity and human rights of all people.
Regarding the unauthorized outposts, I wish to reiterate that Israel
is a society governed by the rule of law. As such, I will fulfill my
commitment to you, Mr. President, to remove unauthorized outposts. As
for settlements, Israel will also meet all its obligations under the
roadmap, as I said also in Aqaba. We accept the principle that no
unilateral actions by any party can prejudge the outcome of bilateral
negotiations between us and the Palestinians.
The position of Israel is that in any final status agreement, the
major Israeli population centers in Judea and Samaria will be part of
the State of Israel. We seek a genuine and honest dialog with the
Palestinians so that we can transform these initial steps into a sound
basis for our relations with them in the future.
I wish to thank you, Mr. President, for the support of the
disengagement plan which I initiated. The plan is not a political one.
It was a unilateral decision driven by a need to reduce terror as much
as possible and grant Israeli citizens maximum security. The process of
this disengagement will strengthen Israel, improve the quality of life
for Israeli citizens, reduce the friction between us and the
Palestinians, and can pave the way towards the implementation of the
roadmap.
In light of the changes in the Palestinian Authority, what began as
a unilateral initiative does not have to remain so. I call upon the
Palestinians to work together with us
[[Page 583]]
and to coordinate the implementation of the disengagement plan.
I also want to thank you, Mr. President, for your intention to
support Israel's effort to develop the Negev and the Galilee. It is
important for Israel's national interest, economic strength, and social
development.
I look forward to the beginning of work by our teams. I have stated
in the past and I will say today, the roadmap based on your June 2002
speech, adopted by my Government and approved by the Palestinians and
the majority of the international community, will be the only way
forward to realizing your vision. Only full implementation of the
roadmap can lead toward security and true peace.
I wish to thank you again, Mr. President, for your hospitality and
for your friendship in support of the State of Israel. Thank you, Mr.
President.
President Bush. Thank you, Prime Minister.
We'll take two questions a side, starting with Mr. Raum, Thomas Raum
[Associated Press].
Israeli-U.S. Cooperation
Q. Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, given the continuing
settlement activity on the West Bank, are you satisfied that Israel will
do enough, once they pull out of Gaza, to meet the terms of the roadmap
and put it back on track?
And Mr. Prime Minister, did you get the support you were looking for
today, or do you sometimes hear contradictory signals from the
administration?
President Bush. If he listens to what I say, he won't hear anything
contradictory. I've been very clear about, Israel has an obligation
under the roadmap. That's no expansion of settlements. I look forward to
continuing to work and dialog with Israel on this subject. We've got--
this is an ongoing process. This is a process that's going to take a lot
of work to get a democracy stood up on Israel's border, and we look
forward to working with Israel.
The thing that I want people to understand is that the Prime
Minister of Israel has made a commitment toward the vision of two states
living side by side in peace.
And I appreciate that commitment, Mr. Prime Minister, and we look
forward to continuing to work with you on it.
Prime Minister Sharon. Thank you.
Q. Mr. Prime Minister, did you get the support you were looking for
today, or do you sometimes hear contradictory messages coming from the
White House?
Prime Minister Sharon. No, I think it was a very good meeting,
beside the fact it was, as usual, a very friendly meeting. And I think
that we discussed many issues that we agreed upon and no doubt that we
will continue to work together, as we are doing in recent years.
President Bush. Do you want to call on somebody from the Israeli
press, Ariel?
Q. Thank you to you, Mr. President.
President Bush. You're welcome.
West Bank Settlements and the Roadmap
Q. Thank you. Regarding your quid pro quo letter to Prime Minister
Sharon and the statement you just stated now, do you see Ariel and
Ma'aleh Adumim as part of the major population centers, and I want to
emphasize, as they are now, as they exist now, without any extensions--
--
President Bush. No, I----
Q. ----or do you see them as an obstacle to the contiguity of a
future Palestinian state?
And for Prime Minister Sharon, please----
[At this point, the reporter continued in Hebrew, and no translation was
provided.]
Thank you.
President Bush. I don't get the second part of the question.
Interpreter. I wanted--she wanted to ask--she wanted to ask----
Prime Minister Sharon. Mr. President, I will answer the second part.
[Laughter]
President Bush. Okay. [Laughter]
[[Page 584]]
Q. The second part was for the Prime Minister.
President Bush. No, I got that part. [Laughter] I just didn't get
the last part of the second part.
Interpreter. She wanted to know if you have any objections to the
continuity of the----
President Bush. Yes, the expansion. I got that part. You asked the
same question to both of us, then. No? Okay.
Interpreter. Can she repeat----
President Bush. Never mind, that's enough. Go ahead and answer it.
Prime Minister Sharon. Thank you. I would like, first, to answer
about construction in the major blocs. It is the Israeli position that
the major Israeli population centers will remain in Israel's hands under
any future final status agreement with all related consequences.
Now, about the other question that you had, you asked what would be
the day after--that was your question. So the roadmap is the only plan
which sets the political agenda between us and the Palestinians. Only
after the Palestinians fulfill their obligations, primarily a real fight
against terrorism and the dismantling of its infrastructure, can we
proceed toward negotiations based on the roadmap.
I hope that this phase will arrive soon. Implementation of the
disengagement plan has the potential of paving the way toward the
roadmap.
[Prime Minister Sharon continued his remarks in Hebrew, some reporters
responded in Hebrew, and no translation was provided.]
Now I have to do something for all the Israelis at home.
President Bush. Okay.
[Prime Minister Sharon continued his remarks in Hebrew, and the
translation follows.]
Interpreter. The position of the Israeli is that the construction of
the blocs of settlements will remain with Israel and in all agreement
with what will happen the day after the disengagement. The roadmap is
the only plan between us and the Palestinians.
After the--we will continue to fight the terror, and after the
continued commitment to fight terror, we will continue with the
negotiations--only after the Palestinians agree to stop the terror. I
hope that this stage will happen and that we will only move to the
roadmap after this intervention by the Palestinians against terror.
President Bush. Israel has obligations under the roadmap. The
roadmap clearly says no expansion of settlements. And we'll continue to
work with Israel on their obligations, and the Palestinians have got
obligations. And it seems like an important role for the United States
is to remind people of the obligations and to work with people--continue
to work with people so that we can achieve the peace.
And we have a chance to achieve peace. The Prime Minister made a
very courageous decision to withdraw from Gaza, and now I would hope, as
I said in my statement, the Palestinians accept his proposal to
coordinate the withdrawal so that we can begin the stages necessary for
a viable democracy to emerge, one that will be peaceful, one that will
listen to the aspirations of the people. I'm convinced most Palestinians
want to live in peace, and they want hope, and they want a chance to
make a living, and they want to send their children to schools in a
peaceful way. And now we have an opportunity to try to achieve that
vision.
But there is a roadmap. There is a process, and we've all agreed to
it. And part of that process, no expansion of settlements.
Adam [Adam Entous, Reuters].
Israeli-Palestinian Relations
Q. Thank you. Prime Minister, considering recent Palestinian mortar
fire at Jewish settlements and what Israel sees as a
[[Page 585]]
lack of cooperation on Gaza, is Israel considering taking military
action against militants if President Abbas doesn't act?
And Mr. President, do you see a lack of progress by Abbas? Do you
expect more before you meet with him at the White House?
President Bush. Want me to go first, or do you want to go first?
Prime Minister Sharon. Please.
President Bush. Want me to go first? All right.
This is a very complicated, difficult part of the world. And I
believe President Abbas wants
there to be a state that will live at peace with Israel. Remember, we
met with him in Aqaba, Jordan, and he had a very strong statement. I
tend to take people for their word, Adam, just like I trust the Prime
Minister in his word. He's a man of his word.
And the Prime Minister of--President Abbas is, I'm told, in touch with the Prime Minister.
That's positive. I appreciate the fact that they've taken some action on
security. We want to continue to work with them on consolidating
security forces. That's why we sent a general to the region to work with
the Palestinians. I hope that he, the President, responds to the Prime
Minister's offer to coordinate the withdrawal from Gaza. To me, that's
where the attention of the world ought to be, on Gaza.
This is the opportunity for the world to help the Palestinians stand
up a peaceful society and a hopeful society. The Prime Minister has
said, ``I'm withdrawing.'' He said that, ``I want to coordinate the
withdrawal with the Palestinians.'' But he's going to withdraw,
coordination or no coordination. And I believe it's incumbent upon the
world which is desirous of peace to then step up and say to the
Palestinians, ``We want to help you.'' I think President Abbas wants that help. I know he needs that
help. He needs the help to not only help coordinate security forces and
train security forces but the help necessary to put the infrastructure
in place so a peaceful democracy can grow, and that there can be an
economy which provides hope for the Palestinian people.
And so this is a opportunity that I intend to focus my Government's
attention on, and we will work with our friends and allies around the
world to keep their attention focused on succeeding in this--in helping
Gaza become peaceful and self-governing, part of, eventually, a
Palestinian state.
Prime Minister Sharon. Thank you. The Palestinian Chairman, Abu
Mazen, started by taking some steps against terror. By now, those
steps--and we can see, as you mentioned in your questions, that terror
still continue. And therefore, I believe that in order to move forward,
in order to be able later to move to the roadmap, the Palestinians must
take more steps, because it should be completely quiet. The situation,
in order to move forward, must be full cessation of terror, hostilities,
and incitement.
So some initial steps were taken. More steps should be taken. And I
hope that Abu Mazen wants peace, and the only thing I expect now that he
will take the right steps in order to bring the situation that might
enable us to move forward to the next step.
President Bush. Final Israeli question, please, or final question
from the Israeli side.
Moving the Peace Process Forward/Implementing the Disengagement Plan
Q. Mr. President, do you support the Prime Minister position as he
stated now that after the disengagement, there will be no--any other
political steps until a final and complete dismantling of terror
organization, and only then we can proceed on the political track?
And Mr. Prime Minister, do you really fear a civil war in Israel
over the disengagement, as you stated in NBC interview? What are you
going to do to prevent it?
[[Page 586]]
And are you disappointed with the President's declaration regarding the
expansion of settlements?
President Bush. First part of the question again? Sorry.
Q. The question was, do you support Israeli position that there will
be no--any political steps after disengagement, until the complete
dismantling of Palestinian organization----
President Bush. I got it. I got it. Yes, thanks. Sorry.
I think what is necessary to achieve the vision of two states living
side by side in peace is for there to be progress. Look, there's a lack
of confidence in the region. I can understand that. There's been a lot
of deaths; a lot of innocent people have lost their lives. And there's
just not a lot of confidence in either side.
And I think we have a chance to build confidence. The Prime Minister
is taking a bold step and a courageous step, and basically he's saying
that, you know, until he sees more progress, he doesn't have confidence.
And I suspect if we were to have a frank discussion about it, the
Palestinians would say, ``Well, we don't have confidence in Israel.''
So what's needed is confidence. And I'm convinced the place to
earn--to gain that confidence is to succeed in the Gaza. And so we're
kind of prejudging what is going to happen based upon a rather
pessimistic point of view. I'm an optimist. I believe that it is
possible to work to set up a self-governing entity in the Gaza. And I
believe a self-governing entity is one that is going to be peaceful,
because most people want there to be peace. And when that happens, then
all of a sudden I think we'll have a different frame of mind.
I suspect that the tone of your question--I'm not being critical,
but I just suspect that if there is success in the Gaza, in other words,
if there's a state that's emerging, the Prime Minister will have a
different attitude about whether or not it makes sense to continue the
process. And I suspect that people will say, you know, it is possible
for democracy to take hold.
And so there's skepticism now about the process, because as I said
earlier, it's a complicated part of the world with a lot of history. And
so I want to focus the world's attention on getting it right in the
Gaza, and then all of a sudden people will start to say, ``Gosh, well,
that makes sense.'' The Palestinians will see it's a hopeful--there's a
hopeful way forward. The Palestinian moms will say, ``Well, here's an
opportunity for my child to grow up in a peaceful world.'' And then I
think the dialog will shift. But in the meantime, there is a process to
go forward, and we're now ready to help the Palestinians seize the
moment that this Prime Minister has provided in the Gaza. So that's
where you'll see our attention focused.
Prime Minister Sharon. You asked--I think one of your two questions
were, do I see a civil war in Israel? No, I said that--and I repeat it
again--the recent atmosphere of a civil war, but I'm fully convinced
that I'll make every effort to avoid that, and I'm sure that we will be
able to implement the disengagement plan, with all its difficulties,
quietly and peacefully. So what I really mentioned, it was the
atmosphere. But I hope it will be quiet, and we will manage to do it.
You had another question.
Q. I asked if, are you disappointed with the President's position
regarding expansion of settlements, specifically about the Jewish
population center in Ma'aleh Adumim----
Prime Minister Sharon. No, I'm not disappointed. We think--both of
us are committed to the roadmap, and the roadmap says--and elaborates on
this issue.
It's about Ma'aleh Adumim. Ma'aleh Adumim is one of the blocs of
Jewish population, and our position is that they should be part of
Israel. I think I mentioned it before; it will be part of Israel. And of
course, we are very much interested that it will be contiguity between
Ma'aleh
[[Page 587]]
Adumim and Jerusalem, but I think altogether, we are too early because
everything happens there really altogether might take many years, and I
believe that we will have enough opportunities to come and continue our
talks with the United States.
President Bush. Thank you, sir. Thank you all for coming.
Note: The President's news conference began at 11:41 a.m. at the Bush
Ranch. In his remarks, he referred to President Mahmoud Abbas (Abu
Mazen) of the Palestinian Authority; and Lt. Gen. William E. Ward, USA,
Senior U.S. Security Coordinator, Department of State.