    [Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2004, Book II)]
    [August 18, 2004]
    [Pages 1721-1728]
    [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]

    Remarks in St. Paul, Minnesota
    August 18, 2004

        The President. Thank you all very much for coming. Thanks for having
    me. I'm glad we came, Mr. Mayor. I'm proud to
    stand by your side. I am really proud to have your endorsement. St. Paul
    has got a wise and tough and principled man as the mayor of this city. I
    appreciate him bucking the political winds to do what he thinks is right
    in the 2004 campaign.
        You know, there's a lot of differences in this campaign. The other
    day, my opponent said he thought you could find
    the heart and soul of America in Hollywood. I think you can find it
    right here in this hall. I'm proud to be with the heart and soul of
    America tonight, and thank you for coming. I'm here to ask for the vote.
    I'm in this important State to let the people know I'm asking for the
    vote. There is more to do to make America a safer place, a stronger
    place, and a better place for every single citizen.
        I'm also here to thank the grassroots activists for your support. I
    want you to work hard to put up the signs, man the phones, register your
    friends and neighbors to vote. I appreciate all your hard work, and when
    you get them headed toward the polls, remember that George Bush and Dick
    Cheney are what's best for this country.
    [Applause] Thank you. With your help, we will carry the great State of
    Minnesota. With your help, we'll achieve a great victory in November of
    this year.
        I only wish Laura could be here to see and
    hear this crowd. She's a wonderful

    [[Page 1722]]

    mother and a great wife. Listen, I'm going to give you some reasons to
    put me back in, but perhaps the most important one of all is so that
    Laura has 4 more years as the First Lady.
        I'm proud of my runningmate, Dick Cheney.
    Listen, I admit it. He's not the prettiest face in the race. [Laughter]
    I didn't pick him for his looks. [Laughter] I picked him for his
    judgment, his experience, his ability to get the job done.
        I'm proud to be up here with a great United States Senator, Norman
    Coleman. I appreciate his service. He's here
    with his dad. It's good to see you, Mr. Coleman. Thank you for being
    here. I want to thank members of the Minnesota congressional delegation
    who are here, Gil Gutknecht, John
    Kline, and Mark Kennedy, three fine Members of the House. Thank you all for coming,
    proud you're here.
        I want to thank Pat Anderson and Erik
    Paulsen for coming. I want to thank all the
    elected officials who are here. Thank you for serving your State and
    your community.
        I appreciate Laura Ingraham for being the
    emcee of this fine event. I want to thank all the veterans who are here
    tonight. I appreciate you coming. I want to thank my friend Joe
    Repya. I want to thank the Minnesota Teen
    Challenge Choir for joining us tonight. Thank you all for coming. And I
    appreciate my friend Ricky Skaggs for being
    here as well.
         Most of all, thank you all for taking time out of your day to come
    by and say hello. I appreciate it. It means a lot--it means a lot. You
    know, in the past few years we've been through a lot together. We've
    accomplished a great deal. But there's only one reason to look backward
    at the record, and that's to determine who best to lead this Nation
    forward. I'm asking for the vote because so much is at stake. We have so
    much more to do to move this Nation forward. We've got more to do to
    create jobs and to improve our schools. We've got more to do to protect
    our homeland and spread the peace. We've made much progress, and there
    is more to do.
        We have more to do to make our public schools the centers of
    excellence we all know they can be so that no child is left behind in
    America. You know, when we came to office 3\1/2\ years ago, too many of
    the children were being shuffled grade to grade, year after year,
    without learning the basics. We challenged the soft bigotry of low
    expectations. We've raised the bar. We believe in accountability so we
    know whether or not our children can read and write and add and
    subtract. We're willing to challenge the status quo if our children are
    being failed in America.
        There's more work to do. We want our high schools to issue a diploma
    that means something. We want to encourage math and science so our
    children have the schools necessary to work in the--for the jobs of the
    21st century. We'll bring the Internet to high-level--for high-level
    training in the classrooms. What I'm telling you is, after 4 more years,
    a rising generation will have the confidence and the skills necessary to
    realize the great promise of America.
        We have more to do to make quality health care available and
    affordable. You might remember the old debates on Medicare. Year after
    year, the politicians would promise you a modernized Medicare system. We
    got the job done. Beginning in 2006, all seniors on Medicare will be
    able to choose the plan that suits their needs and gives them coverage
    for prescription drugs. We've done more. We've expanded community health
    centers for low-income Americans so they can get primary care in places
    other than emergency rooms in your hospitals. We've created health
    savings accounts so families can save tax-free for their own health care
    needs. When it comes to giving Americans more choices for their own
    health care and making health care more affordable, we are moving
    America forward.

    [[Page 1723]]

        Most Americans get their health care coverage through their work.
    Most of today's new jobs are created by small businesses, which too
    often cannot afford to provide health care. To help more American
    families get health insurance, we must allow small employers to join
    together to purchase insurance at the discounts that big companies are
    able to do.
        We'll harness technology to reduce costs and prevent mistakes. We'll
    do more to expand research and seek new cures. And to make sure we've
    got available and affordable health care, we must have medical liability
    reform. I don't think you can be pro-doctor and pro-patient and pro-
    plaintiff-attorney at the same time. I think you have to choose. My
    opponent made his choice, and he put him on the ticket. I made my choice. I stand with the
    patients and doctors. I support medical liability reform now. In all we
    do to improve health care in America, we'll make sure the health
    decisions are made by doctors and patients, not by bureaucrats in
    Washington, DC.
        And there's more work to be done to make our economy stronger. Our
    economy's been through a lot. We've been through a recession. We've been
    through a terror attack that some estimated cost us a million jobs.
    We've been through corporate scandals. But we've overcome these
    obstacles, because the spirit of America is strong. We've got great
    workers, great farmers, great small-business owners. And we've overcome
    these obstacles because of well-timed tax cuts.
        You know, we didn't pick winners or losers when it came to tax
    relief. We did it the fair way. We said, ``If you pay Federal income
    taxes, you ought to get relief.'' We helped our families with children.
    We reduced the marriage penalty. It's a bad tax system that penalizes
    marriage. We ought to be encouraging marriage in America. We helped our
    small businesses, and this time, the check actually was in the mail.
    Because we acted, our economy has--since last summer, has grown at a
    rate as fast as any in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, America has
    added 1.5 million new jobs since last August and the unemployment rate
    is down to 5.5 percent. Because we acted, Minnesota's unemployment rate
    is at 4.4 percent. When it comes to creating jobs, we're moving America
    forward, and we're not going to turn back.
        Our farm economy is strong, and I intend to keep it that way. I
    appreciate the farmers who are here today.
        There's more work to be done to make sure that we've got jobs here
    in America. Listen, we need an energy plan. I submitted a plan to the
    United States Congress nearly 2 years ago. It needs to get to my desk--
    an energy plan that encourages conservation, renewable sources of
    energy, an energy plan that encourages the exploration of natural
    resources here, close to home, in environmentally friendly ways. But one
    thing is certain: For the sake of economic security and the sake of
    national security, we must become less dependent on foreign sources of
    energy.
        We got to make sure our workers have the skills necessary to fill
    the jobs of the 21st century. That's why I'm a strong backer of lifetime
    learning for America's workers and the smart utilization of our
    community college system here in this country.
        In order to make sure we've got jobs here in America, we need
    reasonable regulations on our business creators, our job creators. We
    need tort reform. In order to keep jobs here in America, we've got to
    make sure we open up markets for Minnesota products, and reject economic
    isolationism. In order to keep jobs here in America, we've got to be
    wise about how we spend your money and keep your taxes low.
        We have a difference in opinion on this campaign about taxes. My
    opponent said that he's going to--he promised
    about over $2 trillion of new programs. And so we said, ``Well, how are
    you going to pay for it?'' He said, ``Well, I'll pay for it by taxing
    the rich.'' You've heard that before, haven't

    [[Page 1724]]

    you? You've heard that line. That's why people hire accountants and
    lawyers, so you won't be able to tax them. You can't raise enough money
    to pay for all his spending by so-called taxing the rich. He's going to
    try to stick you with the tax bill. We're not going to let him raise
    your taxes. He's not going to win. When you put me back into office for
    4 more years, I'll continue to pursue a pro-growth, pro-entrepreneur,
    pro-farmer agenda that enables America to remain the strongest economy
    in the industrialized world.
        We have more to do to wage and win the war against terror. America's
    future depends on our willingness to lead in the world. If America shows
    uncertainty and weakness in this decade, the world will drift toward
    tragedy. This is not going to happen on my watch.
        The world changed on a terrible September morning, and since that
    day, we have changed the world. Before September the 11th, Afghanistan
    served as the home base of Al Qaida, which trained and deployed
    thousands of killers to set up terror cells in dozens of countries,
    including our own. Because we acted, Afghanistan is a rising democracy.
    Afghanistan is an ally in the war against the terrorists, and many young
    girls go to school for the first time in their lives. Because we acted,
    America and the world are safer.
        Before September the 11th, the ruler in Libya was spending millions
    to acquire weapons of mass destruction. Today, because America and our
    allies have sent a strong and easy-to-understand message, the leader of
    Libya abandoned his pursuit
    of weapons of mass destruction, and America and the world are safer.
        Before September the 11th, the ruler of Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was defying the
    world. He was firing weapons at American pilots who were enforcing the
    world's sanctions. He had pursued and used weapons of mass destruction.
    He harbored terrorists. He invaded his neighbors. He subsidized the
    families of suicide bombers. He murdered tens of thousands of his own
    citizens. He was a source of great instability in the world's most
    volatile region. Saddam Hussein was a threat.
        One of the important lessons that we must never forget is that after
    September the 11th, we must take threats seriously before they fully
    materialize. I recognized that. I realized that, and so I went to the
    United States Congress and said, ``I believe there is a threat in
    Iraq.'' Members of the Congress, the House and the Senate, members of
    both political parties, including my opponent,
    came to the same conclusion: Saddam Hussein
    was a threat. Listen, the hardest decision a President ever makes is to
    commit those who wear our uniform into combat. It's a hard decision, and
    it ought to be the last option for a President. So I went to the United
    Nations, and I said to the United Nations, I said, ``I believe there's a
    threat.'' They looked at the same intelligence; they remembered the same
    history and came to the same conclusion. They passed a resolution 15 to
    nothing that said to Saddam Hussein, ``Disclose, disarm, or face serious
    consequences.''
        The world spoke. But as he had for over a decade, Saddam
    Hussein defied the world. He wasn't about to
    disclose or disarm, because he didn't think there were serious
    consequences. As a matter of fact, we sent--we didn't--the U.N. sent
    inspectors into Iraq, but he systematically deceived the inspectors. I
    knew he was systematically deceiving the inspectors, as did others. So I
    had a choice to make: Either to forget the lessons of September the 11th
    and trust a madman who is a sworn enemy of America, or take action
    necessary to defend this country. Given that choice, I will defend
    America every time.
        Even though we did not find the stockpiles that we expected to find,
    I want you to remember that Saddam Hussein
    had the capability of making weapons, and he could have passed that
    capability on to our enemies. And that was a risk we could not afford to
    take after September the 11th.

    [[Page 1725]]

    Knowing what I know today, I would have taken the same course of action.
    America and the world are safer with Saddam Hussein sitting in a prison
    cell.
        Now, almost 2 years after he voted for the war in Iraq and 7 months
    after switching positions to declare himself the antiwar candidate, my
    opponent has found a new nuance. He now agrees it
    was the right decision to go into Iraq. After months of questioning my
    motives and even my credibility, the Massachusetts Senator now agrees
    with me that even though we have not found the stockpiles of weapons we
    all believed were there, knowing everything we know today, he would have
    voted to go into Iraq and remove Saddam Hussein from power. I appreciate him clarifying his position.
    [Laughter] There are--however, there are still 76 days left in the
    campaign for him to change his mind.
        We have more to do. I'm running because I understand there's more
    work to be done. We must continue to work with friends and allies around
    the world to aggressively pursue the terrorists in Afghanistan, Iraq,
    and elsewhere. See, you can't talk sense to these people. You can't
    negotiate with them. You cannot hope for the best. We must engage these
    enemies around the world so we do not have to face them here at home.
        America will continue to lead the world with confidence and moral
    clarity. We put together a strong coalition to join us in the defeat of
    our enemies. Listen, there's nearly 40 nations involved in Afghanistan,
    some 30 nations involved in Iraq. I appreciate the sacrifices the moms
    and dads and husbands and wives of those countries are making alongside
    those of our country to secure our freedom. We will continue to build
    alliances and work with our friends for the cause of security and peace.
    I will never turn over America's national security decisions to leaders
    of other countries.
        We will keep our commitments to help Afghanistan and Iraq become
    peaceful democratic societies. See, these two nations are now governed
    by strong leaders who believe in the hopes and aspirations of their
    people. And we have a clear goal in those two countries, peaceful and
    democratic societies which are allies of ours in the war on terror. We
    will help those people meet those goals by providing security as the
    political process moves forward. We will help them train their own
    troops, so they can step up and do the hard work necessary for a free
    society. Our military will complete this mission as quickly as possible
    so our troops do not stay a day longer than necessary.
        We have a difference of opinion as to how to handle this issue in
    Iraq. After all, my opponent said the other day
    that if he's elected, the number of troops in Iraq will be significantly
    reduced within 6 months. I don't think it's a wise statement. You see,
    it sends the wrong signal. I mean, after all, the enemy says, ``Fine,
    I'll wait 6 months and 1 day.'' It sends the wrong signal to our troops.
    It sends the wrong signal to the Iraqis. See, they're watching
    carefully. They wonder whether or not we will stand with them as they do
    the hard work for a free society to emerge. So long as I am the
    President, when America gives its word, America will keep its word.
        In these crucial times, our commitments are kept by the men and
    women that wear our uniform. I'm really proud of our military. We've got
    a fantastic military. I've traveled our country and met with our troops.
    I've seen their great decency and their unselfish courage. Ladies and
    gentlemen, I can assure you the cause of freedom is in really good
    hands.
        I have made a commitment to them and to their loved ones: Our troops
    will have the resources they need to fight and win the war against the
    terrorists. And that's why--so last September I went to the Congress,
    while our troops were in combat in Afghanistan and Iraq, and I proposed
    supplemental funding to support them in their mission. This was an
    important piece of legislation. It was money for body armor

    [[Page 1726]]

    and vital equipment, for hazard pay, for health benefits, ammunition,
    fuel, and spare parts. We received great bipartisan support. Members of
    both political parties recognized that when you had people in harm's
    way, they deserve the full support of Government. As a matter of fact,
    it was such good bipartisan support only 12 Members of the United States
    Senate voted against it, 2 of whom are my opponent and his runningmate.
        Audience members. Boo-o-o!
        The President. So they asked him to explain
    his vote. He said, ``Well, I actually did vote for the $87 billion,
    before I voted against it.'' [Laughter] I don't think they talk that way
    in St. Paul, Minnesota. They pressed him on the vote, and he said, well,
    he's proud of the vote. Then he finally said, ``The whole thing is a
    complicated matter.'' There's nothing complicated about supporting our
    troops in combat.
        In the long run, our security is not guaranteed by force alone.
    We'll work to change the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty
    and hopelessness and resentment. You see, a free and peaceful Iraq and a
    free and peaceful Afghanistan will serve as powerful examples in a part
    of the world that is desperate for freedom. Free countries do not export
    terror. Free countries do not stifle the dreams of their citizens. By
    serving the ideal of liberty, we're bringing hope to others, and that
    makes America more secure. By serving the ideal of liberty, we're
    spreading the peace that we all want. And by serving the ideal of
    liberty, we're serving the deepest ideals of America. We understand
    freedom is not America's gift to the world; freedom is the Almighty
    God's gift to each man and woman in this world.
        We have more to do to protect America. There are enemies who hate
    us, and they're still plotting. It's the reality of the world we live in
    today. We have a difference of opinion about these folks. My
    opponent says that going to war with the
    terrorists is actually improving their recruiting efforts. I think the
    logic is wrong. I think it shows a misunderstanding of the enemy we
    face. See, during the 1990s, the terrorists were recruiting and training
    for war with us long before we went to war with them. They don't need an
    excuse for their hatred. I think it's wrong to blame the actions of our
    country for the anger and evil of those killers. You don't create
    terrorists by fighting back. We defeat the terrorists by fighting back.
        We're working hard here at home to protect you. There's a lot of
    really good, decent people at the Federal level, the State level, the
    first-responders here in St. Paul, Minnesota, that are working long
    hours to do everything we can to protect the American people. This is
    our most solemn duty. It's what we're called to do. We created the new
    Department of Homeland Security. We passed the PATRIOT Act. The PATRIOT
    Act is necessary for law enforcement to be able to protect you. We're
    integrating intelligence and law enforcement better than before. I've
    already taken a lot of action on a majority of the 9/11 Commission
    recommendations. We're working hard to secure our ports and our borders,
    to train first-responders, to improve dramatically our intelligence
    gathering capability.
        We're working on reform. It's not easy in Washington to reform
    things. There's a lot of entrenched interests there. There's a lot of
    people interested in defending the status quo. You see, it's not enough
    to advocate reform. You have to be able to get the job done.
        When it comes to reforming our schools to provide excellent
    education for every child, we're getting the job done. When it comes to
    health care reforms to get families and seniors more access and more
    choices, we're getting the job done. When it comes to improving our
    economy and creating quality jobs, we're getting the job done. When it
    comes to better securing the homeland and spreading freedom and peace,
    we are getting the job done. What I'm saying to you is, when it comes to

    [[Page 1727]]

    electing a President, put somebody back in the White House who can get
    the job done.
         You know, we live in a time of rapid change. These are exciting
    times, and times have changed. It's important for Government to help by
    standing side by side with families and workers. And a great way to do
    that is to promote an ownership society. I'll continue to promote
    ownership in America. Listen, it's important for people to own their own
    health care account so if they change jobs, they can take their own
    health care account with them. If you're a younger worker, you ought to
    be concerned about the fiscal stability of Social Security. Old baby
    boomers like me are okay, but for younger workers, there's a question
    about the fiscal solvency of Social Security, and therefore, I think you
    ought to be given the choice to have a personal savings account and
    Social Security to call your own.
        You know, one of the great--one of the heartening statistics of our
    country today is ownership rates are at an alltime high. It's a
    fantastic thought, when you think more and more Americans from all walks
    of life are opening the door, saying, ``Welcome to my home. Welcome to
    my piece of property.'' We want more people to own things. We want to
    create an environment so more people own their own business. We want the
    small-business sector of our economy to remain vibrant and strong. The
    reason why I continue to promote an ownership society in America is
    because I understand if you own something, you have a vital stake in the
    future of the United States of America.
        In changing times there's some things that won't change: Our belief
    in liberty and opportunity and the nonnegotiable demands of human
    dignity; the individual values we try to live by, courage and
    compassion, reverence and integrity; the institutions that give us
    direction and purpose, our families, our schools, and our religious
    congregations.
        We stand for institutions like marriage and family, which are the
    foundations of our society. We stand for a culture of life in which
    every person matter and every person counts. We stand for judges who
    faithfully interpret the law instead of legislating from the bench.
        We stand for a culture of responsibility in America. Listen, the
    culture of our country is changing from one that has said, ``If it feels
    good, do it,'' and ``If you've got a problem, blame somebody else,'' to
    a culture in which each of us understands we're responsible for the
    decisions we make in life. If you're fortunate enough to be a mom or a
    dad, you are responsible for loving your child with all your heart and
    all your soul. If you're worried about the quality of the education in
    your community, you're responsible for doing something about it. If
    you're a CEO in corporate America, you're responsible for telling the
    truth to your shareholders and your employees. And in a responsibility
    society, each of us is responsible for loving our neighbor just like
    we'd like to be loved ourselves.
        I'm running for 4 more years to continue to rally the armies of
    compassion all across America. See, I understand the limitations of
    Government. Government can hand out money, but Government cannot put
    love in a person's heart or a sense of purpose in a person's life. That
    happens when a loving soul puts their arm around somebody who hurts and
    says, ``I love you. What can I do to help you? I want to walk with you.
    I want to stand with you.'' You see, I believe by rallying the armies of
    compassion, we can change America one heart, one soul, one conscience at
    a time, to make sure this great American experience is available to all
    our citizens.
        For all Americans, these years in our history will stand apart.
    There are quiet times in the life of a nation when little is expected of
    its leaders. This isn't one of those times. This is a time where we need
    firm

    [[Page 1728]]

    resolve, clear vision, and a deep belief in the values that make us a
    great country.
        None of us will ever forget that week when one era ended and another
    began. On September the 14th, 2001, I stood in the ruins of the Twin
    Towers. It's a day I'll never forget. Workers in hardhats were yelling
    at me, ``Whatever it takes.'' I remember shaking people's hands and a
    guy looked me in the eye, his bloodshot eyes, he'd just come out of the
    rubble, saying, ``Do not let me down.''
        It was a powerful day. You know, I came away from that site
    recognizing that everybody there searching through the rubble took that
    day personally. My fellow citizens took it personally. I took it
    personally. I have a duty that goes on. Every day that I wake up, I
    think about how best to secure our country. I will never relent in
    defending America, whatever it takes.
        We have come through much together. We've done a lot of hard work.
    But there's more work to be done to move this country forward. During
    the next 4 years, we will spread opportunity and ownership throughout
    every corner of our country. We will pass the enduring values of our
    country to another generation. We will continue to work to spread
    freedom and peace.
        You know, when I campaigned in your State 4 years ago, I asked--when
    I was asking for the vote, I made a pledge to the people of Minnesota
    and the people of our country that if you honored me with this great
    responsibility, I would uphold the dignity and the honor of the office
    to which I had been elected. And with your help and with your hard work,
    I will do so for 4 more years.
        Thanks for coming. God bless. Thank you all.

    Note: The President spoke at 5:55 p.m. at the Xcel Energy Center. In his
    remarks, he referred to Mayor Randy Kelly of St. Paul, MN; Minnesota
    State Auditor Patricia Anderson; Minnesota State Representative Erik
    Paulsen; talk radio show host Laura Ingraham; Lt. Col. Joe Repya, USAR
    (Ret.), Bush Cheney '04 Minnesota veteran co-chair; entertainer Ricky
    Skaggs; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of Libya; former
    President Saddam Hussein of Iraq; and the National Commission on
    Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (9/11 Commission).