[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2004, Book I)]
[January 28, 2004]
[Pages 143-150]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



Remarks on Access to Health Care
January 28, 2004

    The President. Thank you for being here. Please be seated. Thanks 
for coming. If you're wondering who these characters are behind me, 
these are people who have just shared their stories about what it means 
to be an employer or employee and facing rising costs of health care. 
The cost of health care is an issue in our country, and we must deal 
with it in a rational way. And that's what I want to discuss with you 
today.
    I want to thank those folks who are standing behind me for sharing 
their stories. I will try to do my best to share some of their stories 
with you. They come from all parts of our country. George Akers, for example, is from Naples. He's here with his boss, 
who owns the company, a small-business entrepreneur. That would be 
Naples, Florida. Joe is from Horizon Builders in 
Maryland. Pam Wimbish is from Illinois. She's 
self-employed. Rick Bezet is the pastor of the 
New Life Church in Little Rock, Arkansas. These are people who are 
working for a living, people who are employing people, people who are 
worried about health care.
    Phil Hadley is, as I told you, is George's 
boss. He's an entrepreneur. He's a--one of the great parts of America is 
the entrepreneurial spirit of our country. The fact that small 
businesses are vibrant and alive is an important part of the economic 
recovery of our country. After all, most new jobs are created by small-
business owners, people who are dreamers and hard workers. But Phil told 
me he's worried about making sure his employees are covered by good 
health care.
    Lynn Martins is with us. She's a 
restaurant owner. She is selling food and, at the same time, worried 
about whether or not the people that are waiting the tables can get 
insurance.
    The Sameses are with us, Krista and 
Ted. They're self-employed. By the way, Kris is

[[Page 144]]

a home-schooler; she home-schools her children. And they've decided to 
do something about the high cost of health care by taking an innovative 
approach to buying health care, which I'm going to describe to you here 
in a minute.
    Anyway, thank you all for coming. These are--their stories are 
typical stories. Their stories are the stories that occur every day in 
America as people make decisions about how to allocate money toward 
health care.
    Fortunately, the positive news is that we've got the best health 
care system in the world. And we need to keep it that way. We need to 
keep it that way by keeping the private market strong, by resisting 
efforts that are happening in Washington, DC, to say the Federal 
Government should be running health care. See, we don't believe that. I 
don't believe it. I believe the best health care system is that health 
care system generated in the private markets.
    And the best way to keep the private markets strong is to make sure 
we've got the best research and development, is to make sure the doctor-
patient relationship is strong, is to empower consumers to make more 
choices, is to give them more opportunities to make choices in the 
private sector.
    We're making progress in terms of the modernization of the health 
care system, starting with the Medicare bill that was passed. The 
Medicare bill said we have an obligation to our seniors in our country, 
and we need to fulfill that obligation. And for the first time since 
Medicare was founded, I had the honor of signing a bill that modernizes 
the system, which essentially says there needs to be prescription drug 
coverage for seniors; there needs to be preventive care available for 
seniors; and seniors need to be given options to choose from, to tailor 
a program that best meets their needs. The Medicare bill is a vital part 
of a vibrant health care system. I was proud to sign it, and any attempt 
by Congress to weaken it will meet my veto.
    One of the ways to help make sure health care functions better is to 
help people who can't afford health care to have access to health care, 
access other than emergency rooms and hospitals. And so I'm a big 
proponent of what's called community health centers that operate primary 
care services in rural and underserved urban areas. When I showed up 
here in Washington, there was about 3,000 of them. I vowed that we would 
expand and/or open 1,200 more. We've done 600--we've met 600--we've 
fulfilled half our obligation, as far as I'm concerned. And in the 
budget I'm submitting, we will finish the additional 600 in years 2005 
and 2006. This is a smart way to make sure that people get health care. 
It's more cost-effective that people are able to go to these centers and 
not go to an emergency room, which is by far the most expensive way for 
somebody to get health care.
    Congress needs to pass refundable tax credits to help the working 
uninsured. It's an approach that says we trust low-income Americans to 
be able to make the rational decision for their health care.
    Another thing we need to do here in Washington is to promote the--
make sure health care technology is widespread, that the--even though 
medicine is modern in the sense that we're making great new discoveries, 
it's kind of ancient when you think about how the records are kept. When 
you're still writing records down by hand and sharing information 
through files, it's not exactly a modern system. And we believe a lot of 
medical errors can be saved as a result of the use of proper technology, 
and there will be cost savings to be had as well.
    Another way to save costs, to stop the rise of the cost of health 
care, is there for to be rational laws in dealing with doctors. Our 
legal system is out of control right now. There's just too much 
litigation. There's frivolous and junk lawsuits all over the country. 
It's like there's a giant lottery, and the lawyers are the only winners. 
And

[[Page 145]]

we're driving good docs out of business. Make no mistake about it, a lot 
of good docs are stopping to practice medicine because their premiums 
are going up because of the junk and frivolous lawsuits. And so these 
lawsuits, which are--people will settle just to get them out of the 
way--raises costs. Doctors, for fear of being sued, practice what's 
called defensive medicine. That raises the cost. As a matter of fact, 
the cost of premium increases and the cost of defensive medicine--in 
other words, prescribing too much to cover yourself so if you get sued, 
you can say, ``Well, wait a minute. I did everything I could''--costs 
the Federal Government about 28 billion a year. Think about that--$28 
billion. That means it's costly to the taxpayer.
    I view this as a national issue that requires a national solution. 
And so I proposed medical liability reform. The House passed a good bill 
which recognizes that if--by the way, if you get hurt, you ought to 
recover full economic damages. In other words, if a bad doc practices 
bad medicine, there ought to be a consequence. But there ought to be a 
cap on noneconomic damages.
    The House passed the bill. It's stuck in the Senate. Senators have 
got to understand, if they're truly worried about health care costs, we 
need medical liability reform that's fair and reasonable--fair and 
reasonable. We want health care to be affordable and accessible. When 
you drive doctors out of business and drive the cost up because of 
lawsuits, medicine becomes less affordable and less accessible.
    The Medicare bill I signed in December created an additional tool 
that will help workers lower their health care costs, and they're called 
health savings accounts. They became available on January 1st. Health 
savings accounts address a growing need in our health care system. These 
accounts will help working Americans afford health insurance that is 
growing out of their reach. They will help restrain the health care 
costs that are affecting us all.
    Right now, many insurance plans will cover virtually all of your 
health care costs in exchange for a high premium payment, which is paid 
by employers and their employees in various percentages, in different 
percentages. Under America's system of private medical care, families 
will continue to have this option, of course. We just want to provide 
additional options for families from which to choose, and the health 
savings account is one such option.
    Under the system that currently exists, consumers really don't know 
how far their health care dollars are going. You pay the premium, and 
then you just show up and collect the benefits. You have no idea what 
you're spending money on. They pay a flat rate for insurance, but they 
really don't know the true costs of medical services they receive. 
There's no demand for better prices. There's no selectivity in the 
marketplace. There's no pressure on the price structure of health care.
    When consumers don't have the incentive to get better prices, costs 
go up, and that's what's happening in America. And then when costs go 
up, insurance companies pass on those costs in the form of higher 
premiums, so everybody pays. That's the current system we have today. 
And it's those higher premiums and increasing costs that make it 
difficult for some to have health care insurance.
    The doctor-patient relationship is also a vital part of a good 
health care system. And as these folks behind me said, you know, they 
got a little tired of having bureaucracies in between the patient and 
the doc. And that's what's happened in certain segments of the health 
care industry.
    And we need a consumer-driven health care system, and we need better 
information about health care prices. And a consumer-driven health care 
system with better information will help control the cost of health 
care. That's the rationale of the health savings accounts.
    The best way to empower citizens is to let them save and spend their 
health care

[[Page 146]]

dollars as they see fit--in other words, start to empower people to make 
the right decisions with their health care dollars; give them control 
over routine costs so that people see the doctor when they need to, 
spend their dollars wisely, and still be able to have coverage for major 
medical bills.
    The health savings account incorporates the philosophy I just 
described. There's two major features. First, to get a health savings 
account, you or your employer must obtain a separate high-deductible 
insurance policy to cover major medical expenses, such as surgery or 
hospital stays. The premiums for these high-deductible plans cost far 
less than traditional insurance. Yet the plans still cover for major 
expenses.
    Secondly--the good news, by the way, is insurance companies are now 
beginning to offer these plans more and more, along with HSAs. In other 
words, the market is demanding and the suppliers are providing these 
kinds of high-deductible catastrophic plans, I guess is the best way to 
describe them. They don't cost nearly as much as normal group plans 
cost.
    Secondly, to cover routine medical expenses--in other words, this 
part of the--this aspect of the health care system says, ``We'll cover 
major costs for you at a much reduced cost to the consumer.'' Second, to 
cover routine medical expenses such as bills for regular doctor visits 
or medicines, you can set up a health savings account with up to $2,600 
a year for an individual or up to $5,150 for a family.
    Now, contributions to these accounts are tax-free. The earnings in 
these accounts--in other words, if you don't spend all the money and you 
got that money invested, the earnings are tax-free, and when you 
withdraw them to pay for routine medical expenses, the withdrawals are 
tax-free. In other words, there's incentives built in for people to put 
money aside to meet routine medical expenses, expenses other than costly 
catastrophic expenses or high hospitalization expenses. Because the HSA 
is tax-free, it will save the Americans between 10 to 35 percent of out-
of-pocket medical expenses, depending on a person's tax bracket.
    Not only does the HSA start to empower you to make decisions; it 
actually provides tax relief at the same time. Whatever you don't spend, 
by the way, in a year--you put 2,600 in, you don't use all that money--
that can be saved for future medical bills. In other words, you start to 
save money and accumulate money. So instead of sending all your health 
dollars to an insurance company, you and your employer can use an HSA to 
lower your insurance premiums, to cover major medical bills, and to keep 
the savings to cover routine costs, and to save for future issues you 
may have to deal with.
    When more Americans sign up for these HSAs, we'll see positive 
effects for our families and the economy this way: First, many American 
families who choose HSAs will pay less overall for their health care. 
People behind me who have chosen HSAs will testify that that's the case. 
I'm going to testify on their behalf here in a minute. [Laughter] 
Insurance premiums will be lower, and people will be able to draw from 
tax-free money to pay for routine expenses.
    Secondly, HSAs will encourage people to spend wisely for their 
routine medical expenses. If you put in 2,600 tax-free, that 2,600 is 
yours, and if you spend unwisely, you're spending your own money 
unwisely, and you begin to see the consequences as the savings for that 
particular--or the contribution for that year begins to dwindle. When 
people consider the true costs of their medical care, they will push 
health care providers to offer better services and better prices. When 
it's your money you're spending, you see it; you write the check; you 
have the tendency to demand better service. If somebody else is spending 
the money for you, there's no cost control because the demand--the 
decisionmaking process has been taken out of the economic equation.

[[Page 147]]

    Third, HSAs will encourage people to save for their health care 
needs both now and in the future. We encourage people to save for their 
future retirement needs. HSAs do the same thing for medical needs. 
There's incentives built in to encourage savings, and that's important.
    Fourth, because citizens will see savings on an annual basis as a 
result of wise choices they make, there is an incentive to take care of 
their bodies and to live healthier lives. This is the beginning of, 
hopefully, what will be the next wave of medicine and the direction of 
medicine, is how do we encourage people to make right choices? How do we 
prevent disease in the first place?
    As you know, I'm an exerciser. I like to exercise. I exercised a 
little too much, and my knee hurts. [Laughter] But nevertheless, I 
feel--I made the right choice to exercise on a daily basis. I'm a 
healthier person for it. And HSA--that would show up in an HSA because 
there would be more money left over on an annual basis because I am a 
healthier person, more of my own money that will be accumulating, that 
will be being saved. The healthier your life, the more money you build 
up tax-free in your health savings account.
    Fifth, HSAs will make it easier for some people who are now 
uninsured to purchase health insurance. Low premiums mean greater 
affordability and greater accessibility, especially for small businesses 
who are having trouble paying for the health insurance for their 
employees.
    Because some people may not be able to afford these low-cost plans, 
I made a proposal to strengthen HSAs. I did so in my State of the Union. 
If your employer does not contribute to your premiums, you should be 
able to deduct from your income taxes the cost of your premiums for your 
high-deductible insurance. If you really think about what I've just 
said, it provides an interesting opportunity for small businesses who 
aren't paying for health insurance to be able to encourage an employee 
to do so.
    Much of the money you contribute to the HSA and the money you spend 
on premiums--so the money you contribute--not ``much,'' all the money 
you contribute to your HSA--and the money you spend on your premiums for 
high-deductible insurance will not be taxed. This is an incentive plan 
to encourage people to be able to have an insurance policy that's 
affordable. And it's necessary, and it's needed. And the Congress needs 
to understand how responsible the decision they made in the Medicare 
bill was. I mean, this is a major reform in a positive way for the 
American people.
    The other thing we need to do--and Congress needs to listen to--is 
the call for association health plans. What that means is small 
businesses can band together across the country to negotiate lower 
health insurance rates and cover more workers. See, State rules prevent 
many small businesses from working together to increase their buying 
power, which makes it harder for them to offer affordable coverage for 
their employees. It makes sense, when you think about it, to allow 
people from Texas and Oklahoma to bind risk, to share risk. If you're a 
restaurant owner in Texas, you ought to be able to take your employees 
and put them in the same pool as a restaurant owner in Maryland, so you 
can spread the risk.
    You'll hear a story here in a second about a restaurant 
owner that can't share risk and, 
therefore, is in a--has to buy a group plan or try to buy a group plan 
without the benefits of large purchasing power. Big companies have got 
purchasing power. Small businesses ought to be allowed to bind together 
so they've got the same purchasing power.
    And the Congress needs to act on association health plans. This is 
an important part of making sure the small-business sector of America is 
strong and vibrant. The

[[Page 148]]

bill passed the House. It's stuck in the Senate. The Senate ought to 
act. And for those of you who are concerned about health care for--the 
cost of health care for small businesses, you need to let your Senators 
know. There's no excuse for this bill not to go forward. It would be a 
major reform. It would help a lot of small-business owners in the 
country.
    Let me tell you some stories. Speaking about small businesses, I 
told you Phil Hadley is here. He's with Collier 
Pest Control out of Naples, Florida. He's got an employee with him named 
George Akers, who's with us. George is the guy 
with the flat-top, the turtleneck--[laughter]--has never seen snow 
before. [Laughter] He's the real deal. [Laughter]
    Collier was having trouble buying health insurance that the company 
could afford, the people could afford, working for them. The premiums 
were going up year after year. And George was 
getting tired of it and was contemplating not having any insurance at 
all--wanted to work but--about to try to self-insure, which would be 
highly risky. He bought him a new HSA. Phil 
found it; they worked together on it. The HSA and the lower premiums 
that he pays to cover catastrophic care saves George about $5,500 a 
month.
    George Akers. No, a year.
    The President. A year--[laughter]--5,500 a year. I meant to say $550 
a month. Five thousand, five hundred a year. Think about that. He went 
from worrying about having health insurance at all to taking a health 
savings account, and he now saves $550 a month. Actually, it's more than 
$5,500 a year. [Laughter] He's covered for catastrophic care. He's got 
incentives in his own plan to make right choices, to cover the routine 
medical costs.
    Pam Wimbish is with us from the Chicago 
area. She's self-employed. She was worried about health care. There's 
Pam. She was really worried about health care. She had a high-cost 
insurance plan, and being a self-employed person, she was kind of 
wondering what's next, what happens next year or next month, when you 
get high bills. There are a lot of self-employed people in America, by 
the way, a lot, a lot of sole proprietors, a lot of one-person shops out 
there making a huge contribution to our economy.
    She signed up for an HSA. It's made a huge 
difference, she said. She's saving money. She's saving money not only in 
the outflow; she's saving money by the account building up, the HSA 
account, which is her savings account. It's her own money available for 
health. And there's nothing like having your own--managing your own 
system, is there? I mean, there's just something inherently American 
about controlling your own destiny, and that's what these HSAs do.
    The Sameses are with 
us. I mentioned that Krista is a home-schooler. I also forgot to tell 
you she's an accountant. Ted is a doc. They're a professional family, 
just like a lot of other families in America. They purchased an HSA. 
They're using HSAs. They found that an HSA makes their life--their 
desire to make sure their family is insured so much more affordable and 
reasonable.
    Rick Bezet is with us. He's a pastor in a 
Little Rock church. You think--he's got a couple of flocks he must tend 
to--one is the people who come to church, but he's also an employer. 
He's got people working for him. He's saving about $5,000 per employee 
per year by switching to a health savings account.
    These people care deeply about their employees. They want them to be 
satisfied workers. And they're now taking advantage of new law, which 
provides interesting financial opportunities for their businesses.
    Joe Bohm is with us. Joe is a homebuilder 
from Crofton, Maryland. He's got 90 employees. Just like a lot of other 
small businesses, his premiums went up 15 percent this year, and he's 
tired of it. And he's tired of not having the capacity to bargain better 
with a group of people just

[[Page 149]]

like--in the same situation he's in. But the law won't allow it.
    There's some--people say, ``Why won't the law? It sounds rational, 
why won't it?'' Because there are some vested interests that won't allow 
this to happen. I guess there's people not willing to allow for there to 
be competition. They don't want to give up any market share. They like 
the fact that Government won't let people compete. I don't. The more 
competition the better, particularly when it comes to making sure people 
are able to get a better deal for their health insurance.
    Lynn Martins is with us. She runs 
Seibel's Restaurant. She says it's pretty good food, if you're 
interested. [Laughter] She used to be in an association health plan in 
her State, Maryland. Then, incredibly enough, they said, ``You can't use 
those plans anymore. You can't have an association health plan.'' And 
guess what happened? The premiums went up 50 percent--because the State 
wouldn't allow for there to be association health plans, and her little 
stand-alone business doesn't have the same purchasing power in the 
marketplace, and the premiums went up. Bad law, bad decisions by 
lawmakers, ran her premiums up. And they're still going up.
    And so she, too, wants to be able 
to be in an association health plan. She wants restaurateurs to be able 
to pool and get better costs in the marketplace. She's also fascinated 
by health savings accounts. She wasn't exactly sure what they were, and 
then all of a sudden she started hearing the stories of people standing 
behind me, and it dawned on her that this is perhaps a really good way 
to make sure her employees have got health insurance.
    Imagine the combination of health savings accounts and association 
health care plans together. I mean, you're talking about providing 
interesting opportunity for the small-business sector in America. And 
remember, we're interested in job creation, and we need to make sure the 
small-business sector is as strong as possible. Tax relief is one way to 
invigorate the small-business sector. Congress needs to make all that 
tax relief permanent, by the way. And another way is to address the high 
cost of health care by rational policy. And today I described a series 
of steps of rational policy. The Congress must act on it. If they're 
truly interested in health care costs in America, I've just laid out a 
way, a strategy for them to address the costs, address the costs in a 
way that does not undermine the private sector, undermine that part of 
our health care philosophy that has made us the greatest in the world.
    We don't want the Federal Government running health care. We don't 
want the Federal Government making decisions. Private medicine needs to 
be invigorated and strengthened, and the way to do that is give people 
more options, empower consumers, protect the doctor-patient 
relationship, and allow small businesses to pool their risk so they can 
provide good insurance for their employees.
    Thank you for coming and giving me a chance to describe a vision for 
a better America when it comes to health care. Please feel free to 
contact the Members of Congress in the Senate. [Laughter]
    Again, I want to thank my fellow Americans for standing up here to 
help add some credibility to the stories I've just told you. They are 
living proof of what can happen when people are given good choices to 
make, and proof of what happened--for the need for us to make sure 
Congress continues to implement good policy.
    Appreciate you all coming. God bless. Thank you.

Note: The President spoke at 10:55 a.m. in Room 450 of the Dwight D. 
Eisenhower Executive Office Building.

[[Page 150]]