[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: George W. Bush (2001, Book II)]
[October 20, 2001]
[Pages 1273-1277]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



Remarks at the Chief Executive Officers Summit in Shanghai
October 20, 2001

    Thank you all very much. Bob, thank you 
so much for your kind words, and thank you for your great service to our 
country. Thank you, Chairman Yu, as well, for 
your good work in organizing this event.
    I want to thank our hosts. I was telling Chairman Yu that I was here in 1975 with my mother. [Laughter] 
Shanghai has finally recovered. [Laughter] I can't tell you what a 
startling difference it is--Shanghai is today than what it was in 1975. 
It's a great testimony to the Chinese people and the leadership of 
Shanghai and the leadership of this great land.
    I also want to say that I'm proud to be accompanied by our great 
Secretary of State, who is doing such a 
fantastic job for the United States of America, Colin Powell.
    We meet today with recent memories of great evil, yet great hope for 
this region and its future. The attacks of September 11th took place in 
my country, but they were really an attack on all civilized countries. 
The roll of the dead and the missing includes citizens from over 80 
nations: 96 Russians, 23 Australians, at least 30 Chinese, 24 Japanese, 
20 Malaysians, 16 Mexicans, 21 Indonesians. This was truly a crime 
against humanity, and it stands condemned by humanity.

[[Page 1274]]

    The American people are grateful for the world's sympathy and 
support following September 11th. We truly are. We won't forget the 
American Stars and Stripes flying in solidarity from every firetruck in 
Montreal, Canada, or children kneeling in silent prayer outside the 
embassy in Seoul, baseball players in Japan observing moments of 
silence, a sign handwritten in English at a candlelight vigil in Beijing 
that read, ``Freedom and justice will not be stopped.''
    I can't tell you how much I appreciate the phone calls from leaders 
from around the world. We're deeply grateful to countries, including all 
the APEC countries, that have now joined in a great coalition against 
terror.
    In our world, there is no isolation from evil. Our enemies are 
murderers with global reach. They seek weapons to kill on a global 
scale. Every nation now must oppose this enemy or be, in turn, its 
target. Those who hate all civilization and culture and progress, those 
who embrace death to cause the death of the innocent, cannot be ignored, 
cannot be appeased. They must be fought. This is my firm resolve and the 
firm resolve of my Nation. This is the urgent task of our time.
    The most visible part of our response is taking place in 
Afghanistan. The Taliban regime has allied itself with murderers. I gave 
Taliban leaders a choice: Turn over the terrorists, or face your ruin. 
They chose unwisely.
    Yet, even as we oppose the Taliban, we seek friendship with the 
Afghan people. Our military actions are accompanied by food drops. We 
have substantially increased aid to Afghanistan. My Government supports 
international efforts to bring help and stability and peace to that 
unfortunate nation.
    There's frustration about the delivery of food and medicine and help 
in Afghanistan. I share that frustration. The guilty ones are the 
Taliban. They disrupt; they steal; they prevent supplies of food from 
delivery. They starve their people, and that is another reason they must 
go.
    Our war on terror has many fronts, and military action is only part 
of our plan. This campaign will take strong diplomacy and intelligence, 
diligent law enforcement and financial cooperation. It will span every 
continent and require varied contributions from many nations.
    Tomorrow APEC leaders will pledge to work together to deny the 
terrorists any sanctuary, any funding, any material or moral support. 
Together, we will patiently and diligently pursue the terrorists from 
place to place until justice is done.
    This conflict is a fight to save the civilized world and values 
common to the West, to Asia, to Islam. Throughout the world, people of 
strong faith, of all faiths, condemn the murder of the innocent. 
Throughout the world, people value their families, and nowhere do 
civilized people rejoice in the murder of children or the creation of 
orphans. By their cruelty, the terrorists have chosen to live on the 
hunted margin of mankind. By their hatred, they have divorced themselves 
from the values that define civilization itself.
    The stakes of this fight for all nations are high: our lives, our 
way of life, and our economic future. By attacking two great economic 
symbols, the terrorists tried to shatter confidence in the world 
economic system, but they failed. The terrorists hoped world markets 
would collapse, but markets have proven their resiliency and fundamental 
strength.
    And this week in these halls, we return to the steady work of 
building the market-based economic system that has brought more 
prosperity more quickly to more people than at any time in human 
history. We know a future of greater trade and growth and human dignity 
is possible, and we will build it.
    When nations allow their citizens to exercise conscience and 
creativity, the result is economic and social progress. When nations 
accept the rules of the modern world,

[[Page 1275]]

they discover the benefits of the modern world.
    This vast region and its people, 21 economies on the shores of a 
peaceful ocean, are demonstrating the power and appeal of markets and 
trade. China's per capita GDP has grown by 513 percent since 1975. 
Seventy-three percent of all South Korean households have personal 
computers. Slashing trade barriers has helped Chile raise per capita 
incomes by 53 percent over the past 10 years.
    And the wealth generated by markets and trade brings dramatic 
improvement to human lives. Indonesia has cut its infant mortality rate 
in half since 1980. Malaysia's illiteracy rate is one-third of what it 
was in 1975; Mexico is less than half.
    I'm here in Shanghai to assure our friends and to inform our foes 
that the progress of trade and freedom will continue. The ties of 
culture and commerce will grow stronger. Economic development will grow 
broader.
    The Asia-Pacific region provides the world with a model and a 
choice: Choose openness, trade, and tolerance, and you will find 
prosperity, liberty, and knowledge. Choose isolation, envy, and 
resentment, and you will find poverty, stagnation, and ignorance. Our 
nations have chosen: We have chosen freedom over fear.
    Out of the sorrow of September 11th, I see opportunity, a chance for 
nations and their leaders to strengthen and to rethink and reinvigorate 
our relationships. We share more than a common enemy; we share a common 
goal, to expand our ties of trade and trust. And now we must seize the 
opportunity.
    First, our governments must keep the path of economic progress. That 
progress begins with freer trade. Trade is the engine of economic 
advancement. On every continent, in every culture, trade generates 
opportunity, enhances entrepreneurial growth. And trade applies the 
power of markets to the needs of the poor. It has lifted countless lives 
in this region, from Asia to Australia to the Americas.
    Together, we must meet the Bogor Goals, including free trade for 
every nation in this region by 2020. The Shanghai Accord we'll sign 
tomorrow gives us new and useful tools to enhance trade and investment.
    We must also launch a new global trade round in November in Doha. 
We're committed to the goal of a world that lives and trades in freedom, 
and we must meet any challenge that stands in our way. There's much work 
to be done, and all of us, every nation, must redouble our efforts to 
see that Doha is a success. And every CEO in this room knows the strong 
case for free trade, and I urge all of you to press that case with your 
own governments.
    The United States will do its part to restore economic momentum for 
the world. We'll keep our markets open and our country open for 
business. We've already announced additional spending to assist and 
rebuild New York City, to stabilize the airline industry, and defend our 
country. Tax rebates have been arriving in America's mailboxes. Interest 
rates have been cut to historically low levels. In addition, I'm working 
with Congress to help workers who have lost their jobs and to stimulate 
the American economy with additional tax relief, relief that will 
bolster consumer spending and provide incentives for business 
investment. The economic fundamentals in America are strong, and our 
Nation will recover.
    Even before September 11th, this region faced economic uncertainty. 
The answer is more trade and openness, not less. This region needs 
regulatory systems that attract investors. Banking systems must be more 
transparent. Corporations must be more open and accountable. And as 
called for in the Shanghai Accord, we must dramatically reduce the cost 
of doing business

[[Page 1276]]

across borders by streamlining customs procedures, by harmonizing 
technology standards, and by cutting redtape.
    Even in the midst of our current slowdown, there are many 
encouraging signs. Reform programs have been put in place in Japan, the 
Philippines, and Indonesia. China and Taiwan have made great strides as 
they prepare for WTO membership. Russia and Mexico are tracking new 
sources of capital. All of this is progress, and we must build on it.
    Our second broad challenge is to fight terrorism within our 
countries without undermining the ties of commerce and friendship 
between our countries. Terrorists want to turn the openness of the 
global economy against itself. We must not let them. We need customs, 
financial, immigration, and transportation systems that make it easier 
for us to do our business and much harder for terrorists to do theirs. 
Pursuing both openness and security is difficult. But it is necessary, 
and it is the aim of the counterterror measures the APEC leaders will 
commit themselves to tomorrow.
    Our third challenge is to see to it that the benefits of prosperity 
and freedom are widely shared. The great alternative to hate is hope. 
And to seize the hopeful opportunities of markets and trade, people must 
be educated and healthy, and governments must be fair and just and 
committed to the rule of law.
    All of our citizens need basic education. The greatest resource of 
any nation is the creative energies of its people. They must gain the 
skills demanded by a new economic world. Only when literacy and learning 
are widespread will the benefits of the global economy be widely shared.
    All our citizens must have the advantage of basic health. Diseases 
such as AIDS destroy countless lives and undermine the success of many 
nations. Prosperous nations must work in partnership with developing 
nations to help remove the cloud of disease from our world's future.
    Our governments must continue to fight official corruption in every 
form. Good economies can be suffocated by bureaucrats that serve 
themselves and not the public. Corrupt officials can destroy people's 
faith in fairness and in progress.
    All nations must also realize that, in the long run, the habits of 
economic freedom will create expectations of greater democracy. All 
people, of every religious or ethnic group, have a right to participate 
in their nation's political life. No government should use our war 
against terrorism as an excuse to persecute minorities within their 
borders. Ethnic minorities must know that their rights will be 
safeguarded, that their churches and temples and mosques belong to them. 
We must respect legitimate political aspirations and, at the same time, 
oppose all who spread terror in the name of politics or religion.
    Our times present many challenges. Yet I'm confident about our 
shared future. I know that our region and our world can trade in 
freedom. I know we can bring health and education and prosperity to our 
people. And I know we can defeat terror so our children and 
grandchildren can live in peace and security.
    In the struggle of freedom against fear, the outcome is certain. We 
speak for the common hopes of mankind, to live as we choose, to follow 
our faith, to build better lives for all who follow us. These hopes have 
carried us a long way, bringing progress and prosperity to millions. And 
they carry us forward to even greater achievement.
    Now is the time to act boldly, to build and defend an age of 
liberty.
    Thank you for having me.

Note: The President spoke at 2:20 p.m. in the Grand Ballroom at the 
Pudong Shangri-La Hotel. In his remarks, he referred to Robert E. Rubin, 
chairman, executive committee, board of directors, Citigroup; and Yu

[[Page 1277]]

Xiaosong, chairman and chief executive officer, APEC CEO Summit 2001 
Organizing Committee.