[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: WILLIAM J. CLINTON (1999, Book II)]
[October 7, 1999]
[Pages 1709-1710]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



Remarks on House Action on Proposed Patients' Bill of Rights Legislation 
and an Exchange With Reporters in New York City
October 7, 1999

    The President. This afternoon the House of Representatives took an 
important and encouraging step in the effort to give the American people 
a real Patients' Bill of Rights. After rejecting watered-down 
legislation by substantial votes, the House voted by a large margin to 
approve a strong bipartisan Patients' Bill of Rights, sponsored by 
Congressmen Norwood and Dingell.
    The passage of this bill represents a major victory for every family 
and every health plan. It says you have the right to the nearest 
emergency room care and the right to see a specialist. It says you have 
the right to know you can't be forced to switch doctors in the middle of 
a cancer treatment or a period of pregnancy. And it says you have the 
right to hold your health care plan accountable if it causes you or a 
loved one grave harm.
    It shows that America is no longer willing to allow unfeeling 
practices of some health plans to add to the pain of injury or disease. 
It proves that America is committed to putting patients first.
    But let me be clear: We still have a lot of work to do before this 
bill becomes the law of the land. When the House and the Senate 
negotiators meet, we must be sure the bill is paid for, and when they 
meet in conference, the Republican leaders must resist the urge to 
weaken the patient protections guaranteed in the Norwood-Dingell bill, 
and they must not undo behind closed doors what has been done in the 
public. They must also resist the urge to load up the final legislation 
with poison pill provisions that they know I can't sign.
    But today, let's just congratulate the members of both parties in 
the House of Representatives for making a responsible choice in the face 
of significant pressure to do otherwise.
    I especially thank Congressman Norwood 
and Congressman Dingell for their 
leadership and for their dogged determination. We have shown once again 
that, when we work together across party lines, we can use this moment 
of prosperity to meet the greatest needs of the American people.
    Thank you very much.
    Q. Sir, what do you think made the difference? Yesterday you were 
almost conceding defeat.
    The President. I think a lot of work was done by a lot of people, 
but I think in the end, most people just went up there and voted for 
what they thought was right. Now, you know, there's kind of an unusual 
parliamentary maneuver of which you're all aware in which they've tied 
another bill to it and sent them both to conference. The other bill is 
one I don't support. It would cost an awful lot of money and help less 
than one percent of the uninsured in America, most of whom can afford 
their own health care policies anyway. And so we have to watch things 
like that being done in the final legislation. But a big majority of the 
House did

[[Page 1710]]

vote for this bill, just as it was written, and I'm very proud of them.
    This is the sort of thing America wants us to do. We can work 
together across party lines; we can get things done. There will still be 
plenty for the two parties to argue about in good conscience in the 
coming election. No matter what we do, we can deal with every challenge 
before the Congress now, and there will still be things to debate next 
November.
    So I would hope that this is an omen of more good things to come. 
And I'm certainly prepared to do my part, and I'm very grateful today. I 
talked to some Republican and Democratic House Members before the vote 
and encouraged them. And I'm very proud of all of them. And I thank 
them.

Meeting With Teamsters President

    Q. Could you tell us about your talks with Hoffa?
    The President. Excuse me?
    Q. Could you tell us about your talks with Jimmy Hoffa----
    The President. Oh, sure----
    Q. ----and did you ask him to not stand in the way of an early 
endorsement of the AFL-CIO for Gore?
    The President. Actually, we didn't talk much about that. We talked 
about--this is the first long personal visit we've had, although we've 
worked on a lot of things. He thanked me for the work that I'd done over 
the last 6\1/2\ years. We talked a little about that.
    We talked about--interestingly enough, we talked about Franklin 
Roosevelt and Frances Perkins and the rise of the American labor 
movement for some good amount of time; said he was glad I was coming 
tonight, and that President Roosevelt was the last President to talk to 
the Teamsters.
    And we talked quite a bit about trade and about his strong feeling 
that we ought to make sure that the safety provisions of NAFTA are met. 
And I assured him that we were doing everything we could to do just that 
and that we would continue to do so.
    He said he was deeply concerned that, ever since the recession in 
Mexico and then the recession in Asia, countries with whom we had had a 
balance of trade or a small surplus we now seem to be running large 
deficits with. He was concerned about the rise of protectionism in 
Europe. And we talked about that.
    And that was--most of our conversation was about that. We also 
talked about golf for probably too long. We had a good talk about golf. 
We didn't talk too much about other politics, and I said I look forward 
to seeing him tonight.
    Thank you.

Patients' Bill of Rights Legislation

    Q. Mr. President, do you have any reason to believe the Senate will 
allow the right to sue?
    The President. Sure, if they listen to the American people. That's 
what happened today. I mean, 70 percent of our citizens want it; 70 
percent of Republicans want it. And there's a way to do it. If they just 
look at their own estimates--not mine, the Congressional Budget Office--
says it will add, at the most, $2 a month a policy to have all the 
protections of the Patients' Bill of Rights. And that's a good 
investment in our future.
    Thanks.

Note: The President spoke at 5:35 p.m. at the Sheraton Towers. In his 
remarks, he referred to James P. Hoffa, general president, International 
Brotherhood of Teamsters.