[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: William J. Clinton (1998, Book II)]
[October 2, 1998]
[Pages 1721-1726]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]

[[Page 1721]]

Remarks at a Luncheon for Senatorial Candidate Mary Boyle in Cleveland, 
October 2, 1998

    The President. Well, let me begin by thanking you for the wonderful 
welcome, thanking you for being here for Mary. Tony and Kristine, I have 
now been in your home and Slam Jam's. [Laughter] And I like them both 
very much. Thank you so much for opening your home to a few of your 
friends today. It is a wonderful act of generosity.
    I'd like to thank all the candidates who are here. They've all been 
introduced, but I thank them for coming. I thank Mayor Coyne and David 
Leland and Mayor Starr and--Mayor Coyne, thank you for being here. I 
would like to say also a special word of appreciation to David Leland 
and the work that he has done with the Ohio Democratic Party. I think 
it's one of the best State Democratic Parties in the entire United 
States, and I thank you. And I thank all of these legislators and others 
who are here who are a part of that.
    I'd like to thank Tony and Kristine for having their family here; 
and I'd like to thank Mary for having her mother, her husband, her 
kids--her whole family here. This has turned out to be a family affair.
    I'd also like to say a special word of thanks--I always try to do 
this when I come to Ohio. You know, the press said that I would be the 
nominee of the Democratic Party when I won the Ohio primary in 1992. And 
then at the Democratic Convention in New York, Ohio's votes put me over 
the top officially. And then on election night in 1992, all the experts 
didn't predict that I was a winner until Ohio flashed on the screen for 
the Clinton-Gore ticket. And I thank you for that. And then in 1996, our 
margin of victory here was more than tripled over 1992. And I thank you 
for that. It took a lot of heartache away from me on election day, so I 
thank you for all that.
    As Tony has already said, I would like to say a special word of 
appreciation to the family of Tom Coury for continuing to sponsor and 
support this event, for the love they had for him. And I would like to 
say a special word of appreciation for the feeling he had for the First 
Lady. We talked about that a little tonight. She is down in Uruguay, 
having the second of her Vital Voices conferences. That's a group that 
she's organized all over the world--starting, I might add for the Irish 
here, in Northern Ireland--to organize women committed to peace and to 
economic development and to good family-supportive policies. So I wish 
she could be here.
    But I would like to thank Robert, Thomas, Traci, Teri, and Robert 
for being here and for what the Courys have meant in their support of 
me. And thank you for supporting Mary today. Yes, give them a hand 
again. That's good. [Applause]
    I want you to know why I came here today. I am here to support Mary 
Boyle for the Senate. I'm here to support her because she's got an 
outstanding record in public service, because she has good values and 
good positions on the issues; you just heard them. I came here because I 
like her, I have confidence in her, and because if enough of you help 
her, she can win this election in November and make a big difference to 
the future of the United States.
    Ohio in so many ways is so representative of America. And it's 
important that you understand that a Senator from Ohio, in a very 
profound sense, can represent America and the best in America and can 
have a profound impact on the future of this country, simply by doing 
what's best for you.
    John Glenn called me night before last, just to tell me to hang in 
there and expressed his support and friendship. We've had a wonderful 
relationship. But he called me also one more time to thank me for 
letting him go up in that spaceship--[laughter]--because he was going 
down to Florida to complete his last training. First of all, he told me 
he was too old to be in the Senate, and then he asked me if he could go 
into space. [Laughter] When he said that, I didn't think we could get 
anybody to run for the Senate. I thought everybody would be mortally 
terrified. [Laughter]
    But when I think about that--you should think about what kind of 
person you want to replace John Glenn, because he not only represented 
you, America looked to him--and not

[[Page 1722]]

just because he went up in space early but because of what he 
represented after he came down. And I think you need to think about 
    You know, when I ran for President in 1992, except for President 
Carter's term, we hadn't had much success at electing Presidents since 
1968. And I said to the American people and to the people of Ohio, 
``Look, I'd like to take a different approach to the country's problems. 
I'd like to put an end to a lot of this partisan bickering in Washington 
and the shouting back and forth.'' And I believe that a lot of what 
we're hearing about National Government is just flat wrong. I don't 
believe that you can help business by hurting labor. I think a good 
economic policy is pro-business and pro-labor. I don't believe you can 
grow the economy by destroying the environment. Over the long-run, 
that's a loser. I think we have to prove that we can improve the 
environment as we grow the economy. I don't believe that you can just 
jail your way out of the crime problem. Sure, people should be punished, 
but the best policy is to keep kids out of trouble in the first place 
with a sensible prevention policy.
    I don't believe people on welfare who can work should be on welfare. 
I think they ought to have to work. But I don't think when they go to 
work their children ought to be punished by losing their nutrition and 
their health care benefits. If you took a totally nonpolitical poll of 
families and you asked them what they were really worried about--working 
people with children--most people would tell you, even in upper income 
levels, that what they really worry about is how to properly balance 
their job at work and their job at home, which is still the most 
important job in America, raising your kids. Most everybody would tell 
you that. So I said, ``If you vote for me, I'll try to reform the 
welfare system to make people work who ought to work, but I'm not going 
to make them sacrifice their responsibilities to their kids. There's got 
to be a way to balance these two things.'' And that's what we've done.
    I said there was a way to bring the deficit down and continue to 
invest in education, in health care, in research, in making this country 
strong. I felt that America could be more active than we had been in 
promoting peace and freedom and prosperity around the world. And the 
American people gave me and Al Gore and Hillary and our whole team a 
chance to see whether we were right or not.
    And when we celebrated a couple of days ago the first balanced 
budget in 29 years, the biggest surplus in the history of the country, 
the biggest surplus as a percentage of our economy since the 1950's, it 
came at a time when we also had the lowest unemployment rate in 28 
years, the lowest crime rate in 25 years, the smallest percentage of 
people on welfare in 29 years, the lowest inflation rate in 32 years, 
with the smallest Federal Government in 35 years, and the highest 
homeownership in the history of the country. I am proud that we were 
able to work together to achieve those results for the United States.
    Now, let me tell you why this election is important. It's important 
for two reasons. First of all, we've got to decide what to do with this 
moment. That's the big issue. And let me say, I can't thank you enough, 
a lot of you who came by and said hello to me earlier, for the very 
kind, personal things you said to me and, through me, to my wife. But I 
want you to understand something very clearly. If I had to do it all 
over again, every day, I would do it in a heartbeat, to see America 
where it is today as compared to 6 years ago.
    I want you to understand, too, that we all have to live with the 
consequences of our mistakes in life. Most of us don't have to live with 
it in quite such a public way. [Laughter] But nobody gets out of this 
life for free--nobody does. And so that's not the real point.
    The other thing I want you to understand is that, in this election, 
all this adversity is not our enemy. The adversity is our friend. The 
mayor and Mary and I were just walking on the street not very long ago. 
We talked to a lot of people that couldn't afford to be here today, but 
they might vote now because they understand that there are big issues at 
stake. Adversity is not our enemy. Adversity is our friend. Complacency 
is our enemy.
    If you listen to people talk on the other side about why they're 
going to do well in these congressional elections, they'll tell you--I 
mean, privately--they tell me, ``Oh, we're going to do very well, Mr. 
President, in these midterms because we have so much more money than you 
do, than you Democrats, and because they're midterm elections and the 
people that came out and voted for you for President in 1996, a lot

[[Page 1723]]

of them won't show up in 1998 because it's not a Presidential 
    The people that were good enough to serve you here at this event 
today, they've got a lot of hassles in their life. A lot of them have to 
worry about child care. A lot of them have to worry about 
transportation. They've got a lot of things on their mind. And the other 
guys say, just bluntly, you know, those people--working people on modest 
incomes, younger people with kids to deal with, along with their jobs, 
minorities who may live in inner cities that are too far away from the 
polling place to walk, and not have transportation--don't worry, they 
won't show up. Adversity is our friend, because it will focus us on what 
is at issue here.
    And what is at issue here is, what are we going to do with this 
moment of prosperity? That's why this Senate seat is so important to 
Ohio and to the country. And I want you to think about it just a minute. 
Yes, we're doing well. I said all that; I just told you. We're doing 
very well. I'm grateful for that. I had some role in it, and so did you. 
When Mary Boyle said we produced the surplus, she was not wrong. You 
paid the money into the IRS. And you got up and went to work every day. 
And a lot of you created a lot of those new jobs. I didn't do that; we 
did that. My goal in Washington was to have the policies that would 
establish the conditions and give you the tools so that you could do the 
job. That's the way America works.
    Now, I'm also gratified--and you just look around this crowd today, 
we have here at least Arab-Americans, Irish-Americans, African-
Americans, and Lord knows what else--[laughter]--Ukrainians, Slovenians. 
[Laughter] What?
    Audience member. One Ukrainian.
    The President. And one Ukrainian. [Laughter] Probably some Jewish-
Americans, probably some others. This is America. And this is what I try 
to do, not just for our party but for our country, just say, look, you 
know--you look around the world and people are so troubled because of 
their racial, their ethnic, their religious, their political 
differences. They're killing each other. If we want to be a good 
influence in the rest of the world, we have to be good at home. We have 
to prove that what we have in common is more important than our 
differences. And that's the only way we can celebrate our differences in 
a civil way.
    And I'm proud of that, of the work we've done for peace in Bosnia 
and Northern Ireland and Haiti and the Middle East. A lot of you talked 
to me about the Middle East today. We had Mr. Arafat and Mr. Netanyahu 
here a few days ago. They talked alone for the first time in a year. We 
spent an hour and a half together, and they're coming back in a few 
days--little over a week. And we're going to work and work and work and 
try to take the next big step in the peace process. These things are 
important. But what you need to understand is, in large measure, it all 
rests on you.
    Now, I have said that when things--we have two things going on. 
Number one, America is doing very well, right? Number one. Number two, 
America is doing very well in a very fast changing world, where events 
are changing every day. You see it. You see the financial crisis around 
the world. You see the troubles in Kosovo. When I was riding through the 
neighborhood, there was a young woman that had a sign that said, 
``Please help Kosovo.''
    Now, what are we going to do with this moment? I think we have to 
use it to deal with the big long-term challenges of the country. In this 
election it means, at a minimum, don't spend the surplus until we fix 
Social Security for the baby boom generation so that they can retire in 
dignity without hurting--so we, I'm one of them--[laughter]--so that we 
can retire in dignity without hurting our children and our 
grandchildren's standard of living. That is a huge issue.
    Now, members of the other party are going to fan out all across 
America and say, ``We're trying to give you an election year tax cut. I 
mean, it's just a few weeks before the election. We're trying to give it 
to you, and that mean old President and his party won't come across.'' 
But it's not very much money, and we waited 29 years and we worked hard 
for 6 years to see the red ink turn to black, and I'd kind of like to 
watch it dry for a day or two before we squander it.
    People like Mary's mother, their Social Security is secure. You're 
60 years old, now, your Social Security will be fine. But if we don't 
make some modest changes in the system, by the time all of us baby 
boomers retire and there are only two people working for every one 
person drawing, we will only have one of two bad alternatives. If you're 
between 34 and 52, you're in the baby boom generation. When you get

[[Page 1724]]

into Social Security, if we don't make some changes, we'll have one of 
two alternatives: We'll either have to put a whopping tax increase on 
our kids so that we can continue to sustain the present system, 
undermining our children's ability to raise our grandchildren; or 
they'll have to put a whopping cut in Social Security benefits on us, 
undermining the security of our retirement. Not everybody is going to 
have as good a pension as I do, you know. [Laughter] And it's a serious 
thing. It's a serious thing. Half the senior citizens in this country 
today would be in poverty were it not for the Social Security system.
    Now, people say, ``Well, how can you do this, with the election 4\1/
2\ weeks away and the tax cut something you get right away, and we're 
looking to the future?'' America is around here after 220 years because 
when we needed to do it, we always looked to the future. And I trust the 
American people to say, ``We prefer to put Social Security first and to 
save it.'' I think that's the right decision.
    The second issue that's really big to me, that you can see if you 
see all this financial turmoil around the world: 30 percent of our 
growth comes from selling things to other countries, our products and 
our services. And when we can't, because they don't have any money, we 
    There are a bunch of farmers in North Dakota today, if you went up 
and told them these were America's best times, they would think that you 
needed a serious mental health examination. [Laughter] Why? Because they 
sell wheat. And we sell half our wheat overseas and 40 percent of it to 
Asia, and they don't have any money to buy their wheat. And farm income 
has dropped to nothing. We're going to lose this year, unless the 
Congress passes the emergency agricultural legislation I sent--we could 
lose 10,000 American farmers this year, family farmers.
    So I say, we've got to take the lead in trying to do the following 
things. Number one, we've got to try to limit this financial crisis in 
Asia and Russia before it spreads to Latin America where our biggest 
markets are, our fastest growing ones. Number two, we've got to try to 
help them, our friends in Latin America and Russia, if they'll do the 
right things, get back on their feet so they can grow again and 
participate with us. And number three, we've got to make some changes in 
the world financial and trade system so that it works for ordinary 
    Freedom and free enterprise will not be embraced forever around the 
world unless it works for ordinary people. The reason we've still got 
this system here is that most people, every time an election comes 
around, believe that freedom and free markets and free enterprise are 
good systems. And if they didn't, the voters would have changed them 
here a long time ago. Now, we've got to do that.
    So I never thought in my life--if anybody ever told me when I came 
to Washington that funding for the International Monetary Fund would be 
an issue in an election, I never would have believed it. Most people, if 
you talk about the IMF, most people don't know what it means. But what 
the IMF means today is continued economic opportunity for the people of 
the United States of America. Now, I have been waiting 8 months for the 
Congress to fund what we owe to the IMF. The United States has got to 
lead the world out of this financial mess, and we've go to do it before 
it bites us and our friends in Europe, and even sooner, our friends in 
Latin America.
    If you want--a lot of people here are concerned about the Middle 
East peace--one of the reasons we need to hurry up is the abject poverty 
in which too many people, not only Palestinians but others, Jordanians, 
others in the Middle East are living in. We can't help them unless there 
is a general climate of growth and investment in the world. This is a 
big deal. But it's become a partisan political issue in Washington, so 
after 8 months we still don't have it.
    So if you want to send a message that you expect your country to 
protect your jobs and your businesses and your future, then you've got 
to support our program to keep America leading the way in the world 
economy. It's very important and very simple.
    I'll just mention one other issue. I know I'm preaching to the saved 
here today, but when I leave, you're going to be here, and you've got to 
go talk to other people. The third issue is education. Now, I'm really 
proud of the fact that in the bipartisan balanced budget bill we opened 
the doors of college wider than ever before because our party's 
initiative, my administration's initiative, was embraced: tax credits 
for all 4 years of college, for graduate school; deductibility of 
interest on student loans; more

[[Page 1725]]

scholarships through the Pell grant program; more work-study programs. 
That's great. Everybody knows now we've done that. But what we have not 
done is made our elementary and secondary schools the best in the world, 
no matter where children live, what their race is, what their income is, 
what their circumstances are. You know that.
    Now, I gave the Congress 8 months ago an education program, fully 
paid for. Here's what it does. It would provide 100,000 teachers to take 
class size in the early grades down to an average of 18. All the 
research shows that's the most important thing you can do to give kids a 
good start in life and the benefits are permanent. That's the first 
thing it does.
    The second thing it does is provide a tax incentive program to help 
rebuild and repair or build 5,000 schools. Why is that important? I 
visited a little school district--a little school district--in Florida 
the other day where one school had 12 trailers in the back for 
classrooms. It's the biggest group of kids ever in school, the first 
group bigger than the baby boomers. In Philadelphia, where I'm going 
when I leave you, the average school building is 65 years old. I visited 
a school where the whole floor is shut down.
    We tell our kids they're the most important thing in the world; what 
do we say to them if they walk up the steps of the school and the 
windows are broken and the floors are closed and they can't even look 
out the window in a lot of these places? And they're not safe.
    This program also would provide funds to school districts who would 
do like Chicago did and say, ``We're not going to have any more social 
promotion; you've got to prove that you know what you're supposed to 
know to go to the next grade. But we will not tell you children that you 
are failures just because the system failed. So if you don't make the 
grade, we'll send you to after-school programs; we'll send you to summer 
school programs; we'll give you tutors.'' The Chicago school system's 
summer school is now the sixth biggest school district in the United 
States of America.
    And I want to do that everywhere. I think every child deserves not 
to be defrauded in education. You're not doing them a favor if you 
promote them if they don't know anything, but you're sure not doing them 
a favor if you brand them a failure because the system failed them. So 
give them the after-school programs and give them the summer school 
    Now, this program expands our efforts for safe schools, a big issue 
now. It would hook up all the classrooms in the country, no matter how 
poor or rural they are, to the Internet by the year 2000. That's what it 
does--8 months, no action.
    Now, what is the record of the other party? What have they done with 
their year in the majority? And keep in mind, I have done my best to 
work in a bipartisan way. We got a few Republicans--after no Republicans 
on our budget bill, we got a few for the Brady bill. We got a few for 
the crime bill to put 100,000 police on the street. We had a genuine 
bipartisan effort, big majorities in both parties, finally, for the 
welfare bill, after I vetoed the first two because it took the health 
and nutrition benefits away from the families. And now it's going in the 
other direction, in the wrong direction.
    What have they done? They killed the minimum wage increase for 12 
million Americans. They killed campaign finance reform. They killed the 
tobacco reform legislation that would have put in billions of dollars to 
protect our children from the danger of tobacco, still the number one 
public health problem in America today. They killed the Patients' Bill 
of Rights that says that you have a right to go to the nearest emergency 
room if you're in an accident, to see a specialist if you need one, to 
keep your doctor even if your health provider changes while you're 
pregnant or in chemotherapy or some other reason. They've actually gone 
backwards in protecting the environment; there are all kinds of assaults 
on the environment in their budget. They have gone backwards at 
protecting Social Security first with this House tax bill. And there's 
been no action on the International Monetary Fund and the education.
    And this shows a larger set of different attitudes. I believe with 
all my heart that we're up there not to fight with each other about 
where we are on the totem pole but to fight for you to make sure you and 
your children have a better, safer, freer future. That's what I think 
we're there for.
    If you want to send a message to Washington that you want your 
interests put first, that you want progress over partisanship, that you 
want people over politics, that you believe in Social Security first, 
education is our top investment priority, and keeping the economy 
going--if you

[[Page 1726]]

want to send that message, the best way in the world you could ever send 
that message is to send Mary Boyle to the United States Senate.
    Thank you, and God bless you.

Note: The President spoke at 2:35 p.m. at a private residence. In his 
remarks, he referred to luncheon hosts Tony and Kristine George; Mayor 
Thomas Coyne of Brook Park, OH; David J. Leland, State Democratic Party 
chair; Mayor Gary Starr of Middleburg Heights, OH; Mary Boyle's husband, 
Jack, and her mother, Catherine O'Boyle; event cohost Thomas R. Coury, 
who died September 28, and his brother Robert Coury, Sr., son, Thomas J. 
Coury, granddaughters Traci A. Ade and Teri Coury Strimpel, and nephew 
Robert Coury, Jr.; Chairman Yasser Arafat of the Palestinian Authority; 
and Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu of Israel.