    [Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: William J. Clinton (1997, Book II)]
    [September 25, 1997]
    [Pages 1233-1236]
    [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]

    Remarks on the 40th Anniversary of the Desegregation of Central High
    School in Little Rock, Arkansas
    September 25, 1997

        The President. Governor and Mrs. Huckabee; Mayor and Mrs. Dailey; my
    good friend Daisy Bates; and the families of Wiley Branton and Justice
    Thurgood Marshall. To the cochairs of this event, Mr. Howard, and all
    the faculty and staff here at Central High; to Fatima and her fellow
    students; to all my fellow Americans: Hillary and I are glad to be home,
    especially on this day. And we thank you for your welcome.
        I would also be remiss if I did not say one other word, just as a
    citizen. You know, we just sent our daughter off to college, and for
    8\1/2\ years she got a very good education in the Little Rock school
    district. And I want to thank you all for that.
        On this beautiful, sunshiny day, so many wonderful words have
    already been spoken with so much conviction, I am reluctant to add to
    them. But I must ask you to remember once more and to ask yourselves,
    what does what happened here 40 years ago mean today? What does it tell
    us, most importantly, about our children's tomorrows?
        Forty years ago, a single image first seared the heart and stirred
    the conscience of our Nation, so powerful most of us who saw it then
    recall it still: a 15-year-old girl wearing a crisp black and white
    dress, carrying only a notebook, surrounded by large crowds of boys and
    girls, men and women, soldiers and police officers, her head held high,
    her eyes fixed straight ahead. And she is utterly alone.
        On September 4th, 1957, Elizabeth Eckford walked to this door for
    her first day of school, utterly alone. She was turned away by people
    who were afraid of change, instructed by ignorance, hating what they
    simply could not understand. And America saw her, haunted and taunted
    for the simple color of her skin, and in the image we caught a very
    disturbing glimpse of ourselves. We saw not ``one Nation under God,
    indivisible, with liberty and justice for all,'' but two Americas,
    divided and unequal.
        What happened here changed the course of our country here forever.
    Like Independence Hall, where we first embraced the idea that God
    created us all equal; like Gettysburg, where Americans fought and died
    over whether we would remain one Nation, moving closer to the true
    meaning of equality; like them, Little Rock is historic ground, for
    surely it was here at Central High that we took another giant step
    closer to the idea of America.

    [[Page 1234]]

        Elizabeth Eckford along with her eight schoolmates were turned away
    on September 4th, but the Little Rock Nine did not turn back. Forty
    years ago today, they climbed these steps, passed through this door, and
    moved our Nation. And for that, we must all thank them.
        Today we honor those who made it possible, their parents first--as
    Eleanor Roosevelt said of them, ``To give your child for a cause is even
    harder than to give yourself''; to honor my friend Daisy Bates and Wylie
    Branton and Thurgood Marshall, the NAACP, and all who guided these
    children; to honor President Eisenhower, Attorney General Brownell, and
    the men of the 101st Airborne who enforced the Constitution; to honor
    every student, every teacher, every minister, every Little Rock
    resident, black or white, who offered a word of kindness, a glance of
    respect, or a hand of friendship; to honor those who gave us the
    opportunity to be part of this day of celebration and rededication.
        But most of all, we come to honor the Little Rock Nine. Most of us
    who have just watched these events unfold can never understand fully the
    sacrifice they made. Imagine, all of you, what it would be like to come
    to school one day and be shoved against lockers, tripped down stairways,
    taunted day after day by your classmates, to go all through school with
    no hope of going to a school play or being on a basketball team or
    learning in simple peace.

    [At this point, there was a disturbance in the audience.]

        The President. Speaking of simple peace, I'd like a little of it
    today.
        I want all these children here to look at these people. They
    persevered, they endured, and they prevailed. But it was at great cost
    to themselves. As Melba said years later in her wonderful memoir,
    ``Warriors Don't Cry,'' ``My friends and I paid for the integration of
    Little Rock Central High with our innocence.''
        Folks, in 1957 I was 11 years old, living 50 miles away in Hot
    Springs, when the eyes of the world were fixed here. Like almost all
    southerners then, I never attended school with a person of another race
    until I went to college. But as a young boy in my grandfather's small
    grocery store, I learned lessons that nobody bothered to teach me in my
    segregated school. My grandfather had a sixth grade education from a
    tiny rural school. He never made a bit of money. But in that store, in
    the way he treated his customers and encouraged me to play with their
    children, I learned America's most profound lessons: We really are all
    equal. We really do have the right to live in dignity. We really do have
    the right to be treated with respect. We do have the right to be heard.
        I never knew how he and my grandmother came to those convictions,
    but I'll never forget how they lived them. Ironically, my grandfather
    died in 1957. He never lived to see America come around to his way of
    thinking. But I know he's smiling down today, not on his grandson but on
    the Little Rock Nine, who gave up their innocence so all good people
    could have a chance to live their dreams.
        But let me tell you something else that was true about that time.
    Before Little Rock, for me and other white children, the struggles of
    black people, whether we were sympathetic or hostile to them, were
    mostly background music in our normal, self-absorbed lives. We were all,
    like you, more concerned about our friends and our lives, day-in and
    day-out. But then we saw what was happening in our own backyard, and we
    all had to deal with it. Where did we stand? What did we believe? How
    did we want to live? It was Little Rock that made racial equality a
    driving obsession in my life.
        Years later, time and chance made Ernie Green my friend. Good
    fortune brought me to the Governor's office, where I did all I could to
    heal the wounds, solve the problems, open the doors so we could become
    the people we say we want to be.
        Ten years ago, the Little Rock Nine came back to the Governor's
    Mansion when I was there. I wanted them to see that the power of the
    office that once had blocked their way now welcomed them. But like so
    many Americans, I can never fully repay my debt to these nine people.
    For with their innocence, they purchased more freedom for me, too, and
    for all white people--people like Hazel Brown Massery, the angry taunter
    of Elizabeth Eckford, who stood with her in front of this school this
    week as a reconciled friend. And with the gift of their innocence, they
    taught us that all too often what ought to be can never be for free.
        Forty years later, what do you young people in this audience believe
    we have learned? Well, 40 years later, we know that we all benefit--

    [[Page 1235]]

    all of us--when we learn together, work together, and come together.
    That is, after all, what it means to be an American.
        Forty years later, we know, not withstanding some cynics, that all
    our children can learn, and this school proves it. Forty years later, we
    know when the constitutional rights of our citizens are threatened, the
    National Government must guarantee them. Talk is fine, but when they are
    threatened, you need strong laws faithfully enforced and upheld by
    independent courts.
        Forty years later, we know there are still more doors to be opened,
    doors to be opened wider, doors we have to keep from being shut again
    now. Forty years later, we know freedom and equality cannot be realized
    without responsibility for self, family, and the duties of citizenship,
    or without a commitment to building a community of shared destiny and a
    genuine sense of belonging.
        Forty years later, we know the question of race is more complex and
    more important than ever, embracing no longer just blacks and whites, or
    blacks and whites and Hispanics and Native Americans, but now people
    from all parts of the Earth coming here to redeem the promise of
    America.
        Forty years later, frankly, we know we're bound to come back where
    we started. After all the weary years and silent tears, after all the
    stony roads and bitter rides, the question of race is, in the end, still
    an affair of the heart.
        But if these are our lessons, what do we have to do? First, we must
    all reconcile. Then we must all face the facts of today. And finally we
    must act.
        Reconciliation is important not only for those who practice bigotry
    but for those whose resentment of it lingers, for both are prisons from
    which our spirits must escape. If Nelson Mandela, who paid for the
    freedom of his people with 27 of the best years of his life, could
    invite his jailers to his inauguration and ask even the victims of
    violence to forgive their oppressors, then each of us can seek and give
    forgiveness.
        And what are the facts? It is a fact, my fellow Americans, that
    there are still too many places where opportunity for education and work
    are not equal, where disintegration of family and neighborhood make it
    more difficult. But it is also a fact that schools and neighborhoods and
    lives can be turned around if, but only if, we are prepared to do what
    it takes. It is a fact that there are still too many places where our
    children die or give up before they bloom, where they are trapped in a
    web of crime and violence and drugs. But we know this too can be
    changed, but only if we are prepared to do what it takes.
        Today, children of every race walk through the same door, but then
    they often walk down different halls. Not only in this school but across
    America, they sit in different classrooms. They eat at different tables.
    They even sit in different parts of the bleachers at the football game.
    Far too many communities are all white, all black, all Latino, all
    Asian. Indeed, too many Americans of all races have actually begun to
    give up on the idea of integration and the search for common ground. For
    the first time since the 1950's, our schools in America are
    resegregating. The rollback of affirmative action is slamming shut the
    doors of higher education on a new generation, while those who oppose it
    have not yet put forward any other alternative.
        In so many ways, we still hold ourselves back. We retreat into the
    comfortable enclaves of ethnic isolation. We just don't deal with people
    who are different from us. Segregation is no longer the law, but too
    often separation is still the rule. And we cannot forget one stubborn
    fact that has not yet been said as clearly as it should: There is still
    discrimination in America.
        There are still people who can't get over it, who can't let it go,
    who can't go through the day unless they have somebody else to look down
    on. And it manifests itself in our streets and in our neighborhoods and
    in the workplace and in the schools. And it is wrong. And we have to
    keep working on it, not just with our voices but with our laws. And we
    have to engage each other in it.
        Of course, we should celebrate our diversity. The marvelous blend of
    cultures and beliefs and races has always enriched America, and it is
    our meal ticket to the 21st century. But we also have to remember, with
    the painful lessons of the civil wars and the ethnic cleansing around
    the world, that any nation that indulges itself in destructive
    separatism will not be able to meet and master the challenges of the
    21st century.

    [[Page 1236]]

        We have to decide--all you young people have to decide--will we
    stand as a shining example or a stunning rebuke to the world of
    tomorrow? For the alternative to integration is not isolation or a new
    separate but equal, it is disintegration.
        Only the American idea is strong enough to hold us together. We
    believe, whether our ancestors came here in slave ships or on the
    Mayflower, whether they came through the portals of Ellis Island or on a
    plane to San Francisco, whether they have been here for thousands of
    years, we believe that every individual possesses the spark of
    possibility, born with an equal right to strive and work and rise as far
    as they can go, and born with an equal responsibility to act in a way
    that obeys the law, reflects our values, and passes them on to their
    children. We are white and black, Asian and Hispanic, Christian and Jew
    and Muslim, Italian- and Vietnamese- and Polish-Americans and goodness
    knows how many more today. But above all, we are still Americans. Martin
    Luther King said, ``We are woven into a seamless garment of destiny. We
    must be one America.''
        The Little Rock Nine taught us that. We cannot have one America for
    free, not 40 years ago, not today. We have to act. All of us have to
    act. Each of us has to do something. Especially our young people must
    seek out people who are different from themselves and speak freely and
    frankly to discover they share the same dreams.
        All of us should embrace the vision of a colorblind society, but
    recognize the fact that we are not there yet and we cannot slam shut the
    doors of educational and economic opportunity. All of us should embrace
    ethnic pride and we should revere religious conviction, but we must
    reject separation and isolation. All of us should value and practice
    personal responsibility for ourselves and our families. And all
    Americans, especially our young people, should give something back to
    their community through citizen service. All Americans of all races must
    insist on both equal opportunity and excellence in education. That is
    even more important today than it was for these nine people, and look
    how far they took themselves with their education.
        The true battleground in education today is whether we honestly
    believe that every child can learn and we have the courage to set high
    academic standards we expect all our children to meet. We must not
    replace the tyranny of segregation with the tragedy of low expectations.
    I will not rob a single American child of his or her future. It is
    wrong.
        My fellow Americans, we must be concerned not so much with the sins
    of our parents as with the success of our children, how they will live,
    and live together, in years to come. If those nine children could walk
    up those steps 40 years ago all alone, if their parents could send them
    into the storm armed only with schoolbooks and the righteousness of
    their cause, then surely together we can build one America, an America
    that makes sure no future generation of our children will have to pay
    for our mistakes with the loss of their innocence.
        At this schoolhouse door today, let us rejoice in the long way we
    have come these 40 years. Let us resolve to stand on the shoulders of
    the Little Rock Nine and press on with confidence in the hard and noble
    work ahead. Let us lift every voice and sing, till Earth and Heaven
    ring, one America today, one America tomorrow, one America forever.
        God bless the Little Rock Nine, and God bless the United States of
    America. Thank you.

    Note: The President spoke at 11 a.m. on the front steps of Central High
    School. In his remarks, he referred to Gov. Mike Huckabee of Arkansas
    and his wife, Janet; Mayor Jim Dailey of Little Rock and his wife,
    Patti; Daisy Bates, NAACP attorney in 1957; Rett Tucker and Gail Reede
    Jones, event cochairs; Rudolph Howard, principal, and Fatima McKendra,
    student body president, Central High School; and the Little Rock Nine:
    Elizabeth Eckford, Melba Pattillo Beals, Ernest Green, Gloria Ray
    Karlmark, Carlotta Walls LaNier, Thelma Mothershed-Wair, Terrence
    Roberts, Jefferson Thomas, and Minnijean Brown Trickey.