[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: William J. Clinton (1993, Book II)]
[October 25, 1993]
[Pages 1819-1823]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



The President's News Conference With President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt
October 25, 1993

    President Clinton. Good afternoon. It's a great pleasure and honor 
to welcome President Mubarak to Washington once again.
    Egypt has acted as one of our Nation's partners over a long time. 
They were actively involved in the Camp David peace process over a 
decade ago. And today, Egypt remains one of our most important global 
partners. We continue our partnership in working for peace and stability 
in the Middle East. We're also partners in a host of global efforts, 
from Operation Desert Storm to peacekeeping in Somalia today.

[[Page 1820]]

And I want to express my personal appreciation to President Mubarak for 
his commitment to enhance Egypt's effort in that difficult humanitarian 
effort as well as for his personal involvement in the recent 
developments between Israel and the PLO, which I am convinced would 
never have come about had it not been for your continuing encouragement, 
Mr. President.
    President Mubarak has proven repeatedly that he is a leader of great 
courage and determination. As he enters his third presidential term he 
has a bold vision for his nation: to reform the economy, to build a 
future of full employment and free markets. This process is vital to the 
well-being of the people of Egypt.
    The President and the government have played a crucial role in the 
Middle East peace process. As I said, President Mubarak was pivotal in 
helping Israel and the PLO reach their agreement on September 13th. And 
like the United States and others in the international community, Egypt 
has been working to help turn this agreement into reality, an effort for 
which I am also very grateful. Egypt is hosting the substantive talks 
between Israel and the Palestinians begun earlier this month, a tribute 
to the confidence and trust all sides place in Egypt's leadership for 
peace. That leadership is essential as we work for peace and as we work 
for a comprehensive peace.
    The President and I agreed in our talks this morning that we have to 
keep going in this process until all the pieces are in place, until 
there is a full and broad and comprehensive peace in the Middle East. We 
discussed the next steps in the process, including our common commitment 
to making sure that the Israel-PLO agreement is implemented properly. We 
agreed that this accord can serve as a catalyst for achieving a 
comprehensive settlement. I'm going to work with President Mubarak and 
other Arab leaders to help the Arab world follow through in creating a 
new climate of dialog and reconciliation with Israel.
    We also discussed the President's goal for his third term, and we 
discussed ways in which two nations can continue cooperating to address 
regional conflicts in Africa and elsewhere and to respond to other 
global challenges.
    Egypt will always hold a special meaning for all of us. It is the 
birthplace of much of our civilization, many of our modern arts and 
sciences. Today, Egypt has a leadership role both as it confronts the 
challenges of its own development and the challenges of building a 
better future for all the people in the Middle East.
    The historic Egyptian experience demonstrates the importance of 
moderation, of tolerance, of dialog in shaping the future of the 
Egyptian people in the Middle East, a future marked by prosperity, by 
coexistence, and by stability. President Mubarak has been an exemplar of 
that experience. It is a joy to work with him and to welcome him once 
again to Washington.
    Mr. President.
    President Mubarak. I was very pleased to meet with President Clinton 
for the second time in 6 months. And our meeting today has reinforced my 
impression of the President as a man of courage and mutual commitment. 
We discussed several issues of mutual concern, and discussions revealed 
a great similarity of views between us. President Clinton was quite 
receptive and openminded.
    On African matters, we agreed on the need to remain alert until 
apartheid is actually abolished and replaced by a democratic system of 
government. On Somalia, we concluded that the political solution lies in 
the full implementation of the resolution of Addis Ababa Conference on 
National Reconciliation. We are watching the situation there closely, 
and I am in touch with President Zenawi of Ethiopia who received a 
mandate to follow up the situation.
    The United States and Egypt have worked together on peace in the 
Middle East for almost two decades. Our joint effort has been fruitful 
and promising. The peace process was boosted dramatically when Chairman 
Arafat and Prime Minister Rabin signed an historic document on the South 
Lawn of the White House on September 13th. That was by no means a 
ceremonial function. It was a living testimony to deep commitment to 
peace and justice. It was also a personification of the generous 
contribution of the U.S. to the whole process. It would have been 
impossible to realize this great achievement without the active American 
role. We thank the American people and their energetic leadership.
    In the weeks ahead, we shall continue to work hard together in order 
to maintain a momentum and to keep the process on track. The 
Palestinian-Israeli Declaration of Principles should be implemented in 
good faith and without delay.
    On the other hand, negotiations on the other tracks must be resumed 
with full determination

[[Page 1821]]

to reach agreement soon. Particularly important is achievement of 
meaningful progress on the Syrian track promptly. I believe that the gap 
between the positions of the two parties can be bridged within a short 
period of time. The resumption of the Washington talks would present a 
golden opportunity for attaining this objective.
    President Clinton, our discussions of bilateral relations 
demonstrated our shared commitment, certify our cooperation in all 
fields. The U.S. support for our economic reform program has enabled us 
to carry out this reform very successfully, indeed. Your continued 
support is most needed for the continuation of the program. Each and 
every Egyptian appreciates your support and values your friendship, Mr. 
President. You have been a reliable friend and partner. You can equally 
count on our friendship and cooperation.
    I see such an opportunity to extend an invitation to President 
Clinton to visit Egypt at his earliest convenience. This would afford 
the Egyptian people an opportunity to express their appreciation and 
affinity to the President, to his great Nation.
    Thank you.

Ukrainian Nuclear Weapons

    Q. Mr. President, leaders in the Ukraine told Secretary Christopher 
today that they won't go along with the destruction of all of their 
country's long-range nuclear weapons or the signing of the Nuclear Non-
Proliferation Treaty. Do you think that that stand is justified, as they 
say, by the instability in Russia?
    President Clinton. I understand their position, but I think that it 
is not justified because we're making progress with Russia, too, in 
complying with all these agreements. And there is no evidence that any 
of the developments which they might conceive in their worst fears would 
lead to an unwillingness to cooperate in the nuclear regime.
    I think they may see that as a counterweight to nonnuclear pressures 
they might feel in the future. But I think it's very important. We've 
been very clear from the beginning with Ukraine that we want to have a 
strong partnership with them but that we expect this work of reducing 
our nuclear arsenals and complying with all the relevant treaties to go 
forward, and we'll keep trying to do that.

Middle East Peace Process

    Q. Mr. President, back on the Mideast, in your discussions with 
President Mubarak today, he mentioned the resumption of the Syrian track 
talks. What would you like to see as a concrete step forward in the 
peace process?
    President Clinton. I think it's very important that we resume the 
talks between Israel and Syria. But I also think it's important that we 
maintain a climate in which those talks can succeed. I believe that 
Prime Minister Rabin and President Asad, I believe that the people of 
Israel and the people of Syria want to see this process go forward. But 
we've got to implement the Israel-PLO agreement. We need to continue to 
make progress on the other tracks. We need to encourage a greater 
receptivity in the level of contacts between Israel and the other Arab 
states, as has already begun. And so I want to do all of that as well. 
And I think that if we do all of that, I think you will see ultimately, 
in the not too distant future, a successful conclusion.
    Could we give some--I want to give some equal time to the Egyptian 
journalists who are here. Go ahead.
    Q. Mr. President, you have been invited to come to Egypt. Will you 
be visiting other Arab countries in the area? And in the meantime, would 
you try to resume the talks between the Israelis and the Syrians and the 
Lebanese before you go, and would you send Warren Christopher to the 
area very soon?
    President Clinton. Well, I just was invited today to go, so I 
haven't worked out a schedule yet. I think it's fair to say that the 
United States and the Secretary of State will continue to be very 
involved in the region, and I'm very hopeful that we will have a 
comprehensive resumption of all the efforts in the Middle East. I think 
you know that that's our administration's position.

Terrorism

    Q. There is extraordinary security here today for Mr. Mubarak's 
visit. Is this a response to a specific threat? And in general, can you 
tell us if you discussed any of the terrorist issues that are troubling 
both countries and what your discussions were on that?
    President Clinton. We talked about it a little bit, and I may want 
the President to make a comment, or give him a chance to. I think he's 
made marked progress in his country in dealing

[[Page 1822]]

with these issues. The security is at the level we thought was 
appropriate because of all the obvious tensions that surround the whole 
Middle East peace process, we think the people of all of our nations are 
yearning for that peace. We consider President Mubarak a valuable asset. 
We just wanted to go out of our way to make sure that he felt secure 
here in our Nation.
    Q. On the terrorist issue in this country, is there a specific 
threat against you, sir, here----
    President Mubarak. Here in the United States, you mean?
    Q. Yes, that has prompted so much security?
    President Mubarak. Really, I didn't hear of any of that in the 
United States. If you speak about in our country, we are much, far 
better than ever before. You may hear an incident every now and then, 
but it happens everywhere in the world now. But we are in a very safe 
country. And you could come and visit our country, walk on the streets, 
and so you could evaluate yourself what is the situation.
    President Clinton. We have an Egyptian question in the back.

Somalia

    Q. Mr. President, do you have any special role from Egypt relating 
to your position in Somalia? You are asking Egypt to do any special 
role?
    President Clinton. Well, we're going to continue to discuss that 
over lunch after we have this press conference. But let me say this: I'm 
grateful for Egypt's continued involvement in Somalia, and I think that 
we agree, the President and I do, about what our common objectives 
should be there, what our hopes are. And I think we also agree that 
ultimately the Somalis are going to have to decide the future of their 
country for themselves, hopefully with the involvement of supportive 
Arab nations in the area.

Haiti

    Q. Mr. President, on the subject of Haiti, the U.N. representative, 
Mr. Caputo, has suggested that former President Carter might be a useful 
representative, and other leaders, to try to get the process moving. Do 
you think that's a good idea? Would you encourage Jimmy Carter to go? 
And what is your assessment of whatever progress may have been made over 
the weekend with General Cedras?
    President Clinton. Well, as I said earlier today, it's always 
hazardous to be hopeful about Haiti. But I do believe that some of the 
signs over the weekend were hopeful, that there was some outreach, some 
understanding that there has to be an accommodation here, and that is 
hopeful to me.
    Mr. Caputo has done a good job and has worked very closely with my 
Special Envoy there, Ambassador Pezzullo. The first I heard of this 
suggestion was this morning. I have discussed Haiti on several occasions 
with President Carter. He knows President Aristide; he did go to 
President Aristide's inaugural ceremony. He has been working with this 
administration on some other problems and some other nations. So this is 
not anything that we've ever discussed in a specific sense. I think that 
before I would make a comment on it, I'd have to see what his reaction 
was.
    I understand Mr. Caputo mentioned Michael Manley also. What they 
would do under these circumstances would be up to them. But all of these 
things I think generally are hopeful. It means everybody is trying to 
reach out and bring this matter to some resolution.
    Is there another Egyptian question in the back there?

U.S. Aid to Egypt

    Q. Mr. President, is the American aid to Egypt going to decrease 
because of the peace agreement in the Middle East?
    President Clinton. I wouldn't put it that way. I have continued to 
support strong American aid to Egypt, and I will continue to do that. 
And I think it's fair to say that our relationship in the future, 
including the aid relationship, will be a matter of close conversation 
between President Mubarak and me and will be whatever is appropriate to 
help Egypt to succeed and to lead in such a constructive manner.

Middle East Peace Process

    Q. I want to follow up on your answer on Syria for a second. Do you 
think the political traffic in Israel right now could bear a 
breakthrough on the Syria-Israel front? That is, do you think Prime 
Minister Rabin could sell to the Israeli public Asad back on the Golan 
and Arafat in the West Bank in the same window of time here?
    President Clinton. I don't know what the answer to that is, but I 
will say this: At least we can all count, and we know that if you look

[[Page 1823]]

at the composition of the Knesset with the Shas minority party out of 
the coalition, temporarily at least, but not yet voting against the 
peace process, it is important that the Prime Minister know that there 
is not only a lot of popular support for what is being done but that 
that popular support can be translated at least into a Knesset that does 
not attempt to tie his hands in going forward.
    Which is why the position of the United States has been, number one, 
that I believe Prime Minister Rabin wants a comprehensive peace in the 
Middle East; number two, that in order to do it he has to have the 
support of the people of Israel, which means we have to implement the 
present agreement between Israel and the PLO, we have to continue to 
make progress in opening up other Arab nations' attitudes toward Israel, 
we have to continue to make progress on the other tracks. And there has 
to be some time in which he can work out whatever his situation is with 
this parliamentary body. We don't need to have him in a position where 
he can't make peace.
    Now, I can't offer you a definitive analysis of Israeli politics or 
public opinion, but I think what I'm committed to doing is to getting 
this thing on track. Everybody in Israel has got to know in the end 
there can't be a total peace in the Middle East unless there is some 
peace with Syria. But the timing is very important, and progress on the 
things that are now at hand is very important.
    Is there another Egyptian question back here?

Russia

    Q. Mr. President, concerning the foreign aid, are democracy and 
human rights records the criteria for U.S. foreign aid? If so, was your 
support to Yeltsin as an example or an exception for that policy?
    President Clinton. Well, democracy and human rights are important, 
but I would argue that it's an example of that policy. Yeltsin is today 
the only democratically elected leader in all of Russia. He is doing his 
best to set up a constitution in which a Parliament will be elected 
democratically and it will have legitimacy, along with him. And there 
will be a lot of people who disagree with him in that Parliament, but 
they will have a legitimate base of authority under a new constitution. 
Also, I would say that, given the circumstances that he confronted, he 
responded with real restraint, I think.

NAFTA

    Q. Mr. President, can I ask a question on NAFTA?
    President Clinton. Sure.
    Q. You have less than a month now before the House is scheduled to 
vote on the North American Free Trade Agreement. How important will this 
vote be in terms of your Presidency? In other words, if you lose this 
vote and NAFTA goes down the drain, will this reflect--how seriously in 
terms of the big picture, in terms of your success or failure as 
President of the United States?
    President Clinton. Well, I think the more important thing is, how 
important is it to the United States? I think it's very important to our 
country, and I'm working very hard on it. I'm going to have a series of 
meetings and calls today, but I've already done some work on it this 
morning. And then I think, beginning along toward the end of the week 
you will see, from then until the vote, an enormous increase in the 
focus of my personal efforts along with the continued full-court press 
of the administration.
    I'm hopeful, though, I have to say. We made some good moves last 
week, and I think there will be some good movement this week. And from 
my point of view it is clearly in the interest of the United States to 
adopt this. It means more jobs. It means more access to more Latin 
markets, which means more jobs still. It means a much better climate of 
cooperation on drugs and immigration and a whole range of other issues 
with Mexico. It is a very, very important agreement.
    The thing that's most important to me is I think that we're already 
at a point where if there were a secret ballot on NAFTA, it would carry 
easily. And I think that in the end, the statesmanship urges and 
impulses of the men and women in the House of Representatives will take 
over, and I think it will prevail.
    Thank you very much.

Note: The President's 31st news conference began at 12:30 p.m. in the 
East Room at the White House. In his remarks, he referred to Lt. Gen. 
Raoul Cedras, commander of the Haitian armed forces, and Michael Manley, 
former Prime Minister of Jamaica.