[Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: William J. Clinton (1993, Book II)]
[September 26, 1993]
[Pages 1608-1611]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office www.gpo.gov]



Remarks at a Fundraiser for Mayor David Dinkins in New York City
September 26, 1993

    The President. Mr. Mayor, Mrs. Dinkins, Senator Moynihan, Governor 
and Mrs. Cuomo, distinguished leaders of this magnificent city, other 
distinguished head table guests. You know, when I do a speech, because 
sometimes, as you will remember, I'm a little long-winded--[laughter]--
my acute advisers always say, ``Now, Mr. President, imagine what you 
want the headline to be.'' What is the headline? I think I've already 
heard the headline. The headline is the Mayor would very much like to 
have his job for 4 more years, and we ought to give it to him.
    I always love to come to New York, but I certainly would have come 
here tonight just to listen to my Senate Finance Committee chair and 
your brilliant Governor and the Mayor give these speeches. And now I 
feel like I did the night I gave my first speech in public life, in 
January 1977, at the Pine Bluff Rotary banquet. It started at 6:30. 
There were 500 people there. Everybody in the whole place was introduced 
except three people; they went home mad, kind of like Dave did. And I 
got introduced at a quarter to 10, and the guy that was introducing me 
was the only person in the crowd more nervous than I was. And so 
everybody got awards and the whole deal had gone on, and the first words 
out of his mouth were, ``You know, we could stop here and have had a 
very nice evening.'' [Laughter] And that's kind of how I feel. It is 
wonderful to be back in New York, wonderful to be here with all of you, 
and wonderful to be here on behalf of Mayor Dinkins.
    I do want to thank publicly in this city, I think for the first time 
I've had a chance to do it, Mario Cuomo for giving the finest speech at 
the 1992 Democratic Convention nominating me for President. And I want 
to thank----

[At this point, there was a disturbance in the audience.]

    The President. You know--let them go.
    Audience members. Four more years! Four more years! Four more years!
    The President. Actually, I had something to say about that. It's too 
bad they're going to miss it.
    I do want to thank Senator Moynihan. I want all of you to remember 
what he said tonight because he has done a magnificent job as the 
chairman of the Senate Finance Committee. And if it weren't for him, I 
wouldn't be here tonight, because if he hadn't crafted a budget we could 
pass with that great landslide in the Congress--[laughter]--I'd be home 
worrying about something else, and David Dinkins wouldn't want me here. 
So I thank you, Pat Moynihan, for doing a great job for New York.
    There was a lot of talk here tonight about the Democrat Party, and I 
want to tell you that I'm a Democrat by heritage, by instinct, by 
conviction. But I also wanted to be a part of a party that could change 
this country and

[[Page 1609]]

in the process, if necessary, change itself.
    Franklin Roosevelt revolutionized this country by committing himself 
to bold, persistent experimentation in a time of change. And a lot of 
people up here can tell you that I'm going around all the time just 
asking people for new ideas. Reverend Jackson came to see me the other 
day, and I pulled him off in the corner and tried to pick his brain 
about some new things we could do to create jobs. I called Andrew Young 
in a distant land, which I--having a good time--and asked him to help me 
to convince America to have an expansionist view of trade and how it 
could be used to create jobs. I do that a lot, and I listen a lot, and I 
tell you, my friends, it is very important that tonight we be for David 
Dinkins, not for just all our yesterdays but most importantly for all 
our tomorrows. And just once in a while I forget what this business is 
all about and then something will happen in a flash of an eye and bring 
it all back home again.
    You know, we passed the family leave law in Congress, and I signed 
it instead of vetoing it a few months ago. And I read a column the other 
day that said, ``You know, the President is up there passing laws, the 
family leave law, the earned-income tax credit, what does that mean to 
ordinary people, people can't identify with it.'' Well, let me tell you 
what happened to me today. I got up this morning, and I went for my 
customary jog on Sunday morning, and when I came back to the White House 
I entered through the ground floor as I normally do, and I looked up and 
there was a family there touring the White House on Sunday morning, a 
very unusual occurrence. And the woman who was giving them the tour 
said, ``Mr. President, this is a family with three children. One of 
these children is desperately ill and was in the Make-a-Wish Foundation, 
and her wish was to come to the White House for a tour and to see you.'' 
So I went over and I shook hands with the little girl, and I talked to 
her for quite a while and her sisters and her parents. And then I went 
up and I got ready to leave to come up here and went back to see them 
and was taking the picture, and as I walked off, that young girl's 
father grabbed me by the arm, and he said, ``You know, my daughter may 
not make it, but I've had some very important time with her because of 
that family leave law. And if it hadn't passed, I couldn't have taken 
off work. They would have taken my job away from me. And I want you to 
know what it has done.''
    And today the Mayor and I went to Queens with Claire Shulman and Tom 
Manton and Gary Ackerman and a number of the other Members of Congress 
who are here. And we listened to people talk about the changes that 
still need to come, talking about this is the United States; you know 
we're supposed to be the leader of the world. It's the end of the cold 
war. I'm going to go to the U.N. tomorrow and people will say there's 
America, the only superpower. America is not only the only superpower, 
it's got the third worst immunization rate in the Western Hemisphere and 
is the only major country that still can't figure out how to give 
affordable health care to all of its citizens. And I heard those stories 
today in Queens.
    That may sound like rhetoric here at a speech tonight, but in that 
diner in Queens today, which I visited running in the Democratic primary 
in New York, there were people talking about their lives, their jobs, 
their businesses going broke. Why were they paying 3 and 4 times the 
national average for health insurance? Why did they lose their health 
insurance because they got sick? That's what they bought the health 
insurance for. And on and on and on. And it reminded me again of why we 
are in this business. We are here because we hope that if we work 
together and we work hard and we are smart, that somehow we can enable 
people to live up to the fullest of their God-given potential and 
rebuild this fragile American community of ours. That's why I ran for 
President, and that's why I came here for David Dinkins tonight.
    Most of this has already been said, but I--you know, I left my 
speech over there. I'm just sort of talking from the heart tonight, and 
besides that, I'll be briefer if I do that. But I was thinking to myself 
on the way up here tonight--today--why do you really believe this man 
should be reelected? And there are basically three reasons I really 
believe it.
    Number one, you've already heard, under very difficult circumstances 
he's made you a good Mayor, he has been a good Mayor. I have heard all 
these stories about New York's financial problems for years. All I know 
is under difficult circumstances, with no help from Washington, you have 
produced four budgets and improved your bond rating. And that counts for 
something.
    I was so proud to hear you clap for something

[[Page 1610]]

that really to me is what government's all about, when the Mayor talked 
about leaving the libraries open 6 days a week. That's a big deal, and 
not very many cities do it.
    He started a health care program, which is consistent with what 
we're trying to do in Washington, not only to provide coverage for 
people but to guarantee access to people who need it through public 
health clinics that give primary and preventive services, not just 
expensive emergency care when it's too late and people are already sick.
    And anybody can talk tough about crime. And almost every American, I 
want to be clear about this, almost every American desperately now is 
worried about the insecurity of life, the fragility of life in all of 
our cities and our small towns and our rural areas. So I say this not 
against anybody else, but it is simply a fact that your Mayor, beginning 
with the man who is now my drug czar, who used to be your chief of 
police, started this community policing program to put more police on 
the street, in the neighborhood, knowing their friends and neighbors, to 
deploy them in a different and smarter way. And it is simply true that 
now for 2 years in a row, in the seven major categories the FBI keeps, 
New York is one of the few cities in America that has had a decline in 
the crime rate. That should be rewarded. Are you going to punish a 
person for producing the results you say you want?
    So I say to you, I was always worried that I never would quite fit 
in modern politics, which is so much television and 30 seconds and sound 
bite and look macho, whether you are or not, and all that sort of stuff. 
I hired out to do things. And here's a guy who has done things. And I 
came up here to say well done. I think you ought to be rewarded.
    The second thing I want to say to you is that the truth is that all 
of us who do a good job should not on that account alone be reelected, 
because that's what you paid us to do. So if you do a good job, it 
really only counts if it's an indication that you'll do another one if 
you get another term. And that's why I liked all the energy he put out 
tonight. He plainly wants to do it all over again in the worst way, and 
that's important.
    But secondly, I have reviewed the Mayor's ideas. He gave me a whole 
list of things today I could do to help New York fulfill its potential. 
This jobs program is a good program, and not only that, it is consistent 
with what we are doing in defense conversion, in technology policy, in 
developing community financing institutions, in working with Congressman 
Rangel for the empowerment zones to get capital, private capital, back 
into distressed areas. It will work. So you really want in the next 4 
years to have someone who will be doing things that fit with what's 
happening in Washington. Otherwise why did you vote for me in the first 
place if I can't help you?
    And the last thing I'd like to say is I think you ought to vote for 
him because he really does believe that we have to find strength and 
peace and harmony in our diversity, that we cannot become what we ought 
to be by being divided against one another. And I think that is maybe 
the most important thing of all.
    This has been 2 incredible weeks for me. I'm going to the U.N. 
tomorrow; you know, it's a bookend of that incredible day, Monday 2 
weeks ago, when Yitzhak Rabin and Yasser Arafat shook hands and riveted 
the world. And I ask you, think of it: If after all the decades of 
fighting each other they finally came to the conclusion that peace in 
their land that they love and a normal, decent future for the children 
of their people required them to seek some harmony, some accommodation, 
some working together, and when they shook hands it was so electric that 
no one in the world thought that that was an act of weakness, it was 
instead an act of strength. Can we not learn this lesson in our 
multiethnic cities? Can we not see that across the lines of race and 
religion, those people who believe in family, those people who believe 
in work, those people who believe in putting their children first, those 
people who never violate the law and always pay their taxes and always 
show up for the basic things in life, have more in common than they do 
separating themselves, and they have to learn to vote across their 
racial lines, to vote across their religious lines, to reach out and 
make alliances that will enable us to live together. If you want to deal 
with the crime problems, and I do; if you want to pass a bill making 
illegal assault weapons so they don't get in the hands of teenagers, and 
I do; if you want to pass this health care reform bill and make it a 
right for all Americans, that can never be taken away and I do; don't we 
have to begin by getting the family of this country together, the people 
who have the same values and have the same hopes for their chil-


[[Page 1611]]

dren and say we can do this together?
    You know, let's be candid. All the way up here, I said to myself, 
why has Dinkins got a race? I'm going to get in a lot of trouble for 
saying this. I read the record, and then I actually read some of his 
position papers, something I bet you haven't done, some of you. 
[Laughter] And I thought about how it would fit. I know him personally 
inside, and I said, why has this guy got a hard race?
    Let's face it. There are two reasons, I think. One is he doesn't 
give enough speeches like the one he gave here tonight, because he is a 
humble man in an age that values self-promotion. Right? Because he is a 
quietly tough man in an age that values loud and piercing rhetoric, and 
to be fair, it is sometimes necessary because so many of us are caught 
in the blur of events and the frustration of our times. It is a style 
thing, folks. Don't get the style confused with the substance. He's got 
the substance.
    And the second reason is that too many of us are still too unwilling 
to vote for people who are different than we are. This is not as simple 
as overt racism. That is not anything I would charge to anybody who 
doesn't vote for David Dinkins or Bill Clinton or anybody else. It's not 
that simple. It is this deep-seated reluctance we have, against all our 
better judgment, to reach out across these lines. It is not as simple as 
overt racism. It's this inability to take that sort of leap of faith, to 
believe that people who look different than we are really are more like 
us than some people who look just like us but don't share our values or 
our interests or our conduct.
    This is a big deal to me. I would not be here tonight; I would never 
have been reelected Governor of Arkansas in 1982; I would not have been 
elected President of the United States through all those tough primaries 
if it hadn't been for African-American and Hispanic voters and Asians 
voters, people who were different from me, voting for me. I wouldn't be 
here.
    So I read in the paper about the demographics of the Dinkins vote. 
And there will be some differences just because people think differently 
ideologically. But I want to remind you that David Dinkins, as was 
reminded to me tonight, when the Scud missiles were falling on Israel, 
went to Israel. He wants to represent all the people of New York.
    Look who he had introduce him and be a part of this program tonight. 
This a big deal, folks. This is not just New York; this is L.A., and 
this is rural South. This is everyplace. We are being tested. We are 
going through a time of profound change. And we right now don't have the 
sense of personal security to make the changes we need to make. We need 
more confidence in ourselves and confidence that we can meet all these 
challenges that are out there and confidence that the 21st century will 
also be an American century. And in order to do it, we have to get our 
act together so we can feel good about the people we elect. We have to 
make our streets safer, our families stronger. We have to make all these 
economic changes, but we first must be more secure.
    I ask you, think about the handshake between Rabin and Arafat. Think 
about what it means for the future of the Middle East if we can keep it 
going. And then ask yourselves, this man who has a good record, who has 
a good plan, who has a good heart, has earned the right to your vote, 
and you ought to make sure he gets it and is returned to city hall.
    Thank you, and God bless you.

Note: The President spoke at 9:55 p.m. at the Sheraton New York Hotel. 
In his remarks, he referred to Claire Shulman, president of the Borough 
of Queens.