[Federal Register Volume 86, Number 143 (Thursday, July 29, 2021)]
[Notices]
[Pages 40826-40837]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2021-16125]


=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION

[WC Docket No. 16-271; DA 21-858; FRS 39694]


Wireless Telecommunications Bureau Seeks Comment on Drive Test 
Parameters and Model for Alaska Plan Participants

AGENCY: Federal Communications Commission.

ACTION: Notice and request for comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: In the document, the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau 
(Bureau) of the Federal Communications Commission (Commission) proposes 
drive test parameters and a drive test model required of two Alaska 
Plan mobile-provider participants: General Communication Inc. (GCI) and 
Copper Valley Wireless. The Bureau seeks comment on these proposals and 
on any alternatives that it should consider.

DATES: Comments are due on or before August 12, 2021. If you anticipate 
that you will be submitting comments but find it difficult to do so 
within the period of time allowed by this document, you should advise 
the contact listed in the following as soon as possible.

ADDRESSES: Interested parties may file comments on or before the date 
indicated above and must reference WC Docket No. 16-271. Comments may 
be filed using the Commission's Electronic Filing System (ECFS) or by 
filing paper copies.
     Electronic Filers: Comments may be filed electronically 
using the internet by accessing the ECFS: http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/.
     Paper Filers: Parties who choose to file by paper must 
file an original and one copy of each filing.
     Filings can be sent by commercial overnight courier, or by 
first-class or overnight U.S. Postal Service mail. All filings must be 
addressed to the Commission's Secretary, Office of the Secretary, 
Federal Communications Commission.
     Commercial overnight mail (other than U.S. Postal Service 
Express Mail and Priority Mail) must be sent to 9050 Junction Drive, 
Annapolis Junction, MD 20701. U.S. Postal Service first-class, Express, 
and Priority mail must be addressed to 45 L Street NE, Washington, DC 
20554.
     Effective March 19, 2020, and until further notice, the 
Commission no longer accepts any hand or messenger delivered filings. 
This is a temporary measure taken to help protect the health

[[Page 40827]]

and safety of individuals, and to mitigate the transmission of COVID-
19.
    People with Disabilities: To request materials in accessible 
formats for people with disabilities (braille, large print, electronic 
files, audio format), send an email to [email protected] or call the FCC's 
Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau at (202) 418-0530 (voice).

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For additional information on this 
proceeding, contact Matthew Warner of the Wireless Telecommunications 
Bureau, Competition & Infrastructure Policy Division, 
[email protected], (202) 418-2419.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This is a summary of the Bureau's Alaska 
Plan Drive Test Public Notice, adopted on July 19, 2021, and released 
on July 19, 2021. The full text of this document is available for 
public inspection on the Commission's website at: https://www.fcc.gov/document/wtb-seeks-comment-alaska-plan-drive-testing-and-model.

I. Public Notice

    By this Public Notice, the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau 
(Bureau) seeks comment on proposed drive test parameters and a model 
for the drive tests required of certain mobile providers participating 
in the Alaska Plan.
    The Commission adopted the Alaska Plan Order in 2016 to address 
both fixed and mobile voice and broadband service in high-cost areas of 
the state of Alaska. Eight mobile providers chose to participate in the 
Alaska Plan and submitted performance plans in which they committed to 
specific deployment obligations and performance requirements sufficient 
to demonstrate that Alaska Plan support would be used in the public 
interest. In the performance plans, providers committed to cover a 
specified number of people by five-year (December 31, 2021) and 10-year 
(December 31, 2026) milestones at a specified minimum speed, broken 
down by each level of wireless service offered (2G/Voice, 3G, and 4G 
LTE) and each type of middle mile facility used in connection with the 
deployed mobile technology. Each participant must certify that it has 
met the reporting milestones, including minimum download and upload 
speeds set forth in its approved performance plans.
    In addition, participants that receive more than $5 million 
annually in Alaska Plan support must supplement these certifications 
with ``data received or used from drive tests analyzing network 
coverage for mobile service covering the population for which support 
was received and showing mobile transmissions to and from the . . . 
network meeting or exceeding the minimum expected download and upload 
speeds delineated in the approved performance plan[s].'' The Alaska 
Plan Order specifies that participants may demonstrate coverage of an 
area with a ``statistically significant number of tests in the vicinity 
of residences being covered.'' The Alaska Plan Order further specifies 
that, as with Tribal Mobility Fund Phase I, these drive tests may be 
conducted by means other than in automobiles on roads due to the unique 
terrain and lack of road networks in remote areas of Alaska. In the 
Alaska Plan Order, the Commission delegated to the Bureau the authority 
to ``effectuate plan implementation and administration,'' including by 
``requir[ing] additional information . . . from individual participants 
that it deems necessary to establish clear standards for determining 
whether or not they meet their five- and 10-year commitments.'' Drive 
test results confirming qualifying participants' performance 
commitments for the five-year milestone are due by March 1, 2022.
    Two participants meet the trigger for the drive test requirement: 
GCI and Copper Valley Wireless. Consistent with the Alaska Plan Order's 
delegation of authority, we propose drive test parameters and a drive 
test model to ensure that GCI's and Copper Valley Wireless's drive 
tests allow the Commission to determine whether the carriers met their 
five-year commitments. Appendix A lists the data that we propose to 
require the carriers to collect during the drive tests and the format 
in which we propose it be reported. The parameters listed in Appendix A 
are consistent with requirements the Commission has established for 
mobile speed test data collected in other contexts, and we anticipate 
that these categories of data will allow the Bureau to evaluate whether 
GCI and Copper Valley Wireless have met their deployment benchmarks. 
Appendix B sets forth a drive test model that would help to ensure that 
the two carriers conduct a ``statistically significant number of tests 
in the vicinity of residences being covered.'' This proposal uses 
stratified random sampling to provide the carriers with locations to 
test within a grid system of their reported coverage areas. A 
confidence interval would be constructed around the drive test results 
to verify that a provider's commitments have been met or determine the 
percentage by which the carrier's coverage has failed to meet its 
commitment.
    We seek comment on these proposals and on any alternatives that we 
should consider. Given that this Public Notice only affects two Alaska 
Plan participants, both of whom have been informed of this action and 
have indicated a desire to begin testing as soon as possible to 
maximize their ability to conduct drive testing during less adverse 
weather conditions, we find that a 14-day comment period will allow 
sufficient opportunity for public input and accordingly waive the 
default reply comment period.

II. Appendix A: Mobile Speed Test Data Specification

A. Overview

    The Alaska Plan requires certain plan participants to conduct and 
report speed tests of their networks, as described in this PN and 
appendices. Appendix A describes the data to be collected and the 
format in which it is to be reported.

B. Sample Data

BILLING CODE 6712-01-P

[[Page 40828]]

[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.000


[[Page 40829]]


[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.001


[[Page 40830]]


BILLING CODE 6712-01-C

C. Mobile Speed Test Data

    This section details the data structure common for all mobile speed 
test data in the Alaska Plan. This file contains records of each mobile 
speed test in JavaScript Object Notation (JSON) format matching the 
specification in the table and sections below:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
submission_type......................  Enumerated.............  Alaska Plan............  Type of data
                                                                                          submission.
                                                                                         --Value must be
                                                                                          ``Alaska Plan''.
submissions..........................  Array [Submission        .......................  List of drive test data
                                        Object].                                          submissions.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for the Submission
                                                                                          Object is described in
                                                                                          Section 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Submission Object

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
test_id..............................  String.................  1599236609.............  Unique identifier used
                                                                                          by the app to
                                                                                          differentiate tests.
timestamp............................  Datetime...............  2021-07-08T09:02:42-08:  Timestamp of the time
                                                                 00.                      at which the set of
                                                                                          test metrics
                                                                                          commenced.
                                                                                         --Value must match
                                                                                          valid ISO-8601 format
                                                                                          including seconds and
                                                                                          timezone offset, e.g.:
                                                                                          YYYY-MM-DD[T]hh:mm:ss<
                                                                                          plus-minushh:mm.
device_type..........................  Enumerated.............  Android................  Type of device.
                                                                                         --Value must be one of
                                                                                          the following:
                                                                                         /iOS[bond]Android/Other/
                                                                                          ;
manufacturer.........................  String.................  Google.................  Name of the device
                                                                                          manufacturer.
model................................  String.................  PIXEL 3................  Name of the device
                                                                                          model.
operating_system.....................  String.................  Android 11.............  Name and version of the
                                                                                          device operating
                                                                                          system.
app_id...............................  String.................  FCC Speed Test app.....  Name of the mobile
                                                                                          speed test app.
app_version..........................  String.................  2.0.2496...............  Version of the mobile
                                                                                          speed test app.
provider_name........................  String.................  GCI....................  Name of the mobile
                                                                                          service provider.
tests................................  Test Object............  .......................  Information about the
                                                                                          test metrics.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for the Test Object is
                                                                                          described in Section
                                                                                          0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2. Test Object

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
download.............................  Download Test Object...  .......................  Information about the
                                                                                          download test metric.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for the Download Test
                                                                                          Object is described in
                                                                                          Section 0.
upload...............................  Upload Test Object.....  .......................  Information about the
                                                                                          upload test metric.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for the Upload Test
                                                                                          Object is described in
                                                                                          Section 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

3. Download Test Object

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
timestamp............................  Datetime...............  2021-07-08T09:02:42-08:  Timestamp of the time
                                                                 00.                      at which the test
                                                                                          metric commenced.
                                                                                         --Value must match
                                                                                          valid ISO-8601 format
                                                                                          including seconds and
                                                                                          timezone offset, i.e.:
                                                                                          YYYY-MM-DD[T]hh:mm:ss<
                                                                                          plus-minushh:mm.
duration.............................  Integer................  4997185................  Duration that the test
                                                                                          metric took to
                                                                                          complete in
                                                                                          microseconds.
bytes_transferred....................  Integer................  97382448...............  Measured total amount
                                                                                          of data in bytes that
                                                                                          the test metric
                                                                                          transferred.
bytes_sec............................  Integer................  19487461...............  Measure number of bytes
                                                                                          per second that the
                                                                                          test metric
                                                                                          transferred.
locations............................  Array [Location Object]  .......................  List of geographic
                                                                                          coordinates of the
                                                                                          locations measured
                                                                                          during the speed test.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for each Location
                                                                                          Object element is
                                                                                          described in Section
                                                                                          0.

[[Page 40831]]

 
cells................................  Array [Cell Object]....  .......................  List of cellular
                                                                                          telephony information
                                                                                          measured during the
                                                                                          speed test.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for each Cell Object
                                                                                          element is described
                                                                                          in Section 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

4. Upload Test Object

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
timestamp............................  Datetime...............  2021-07-08T09:02:51-08:  Timestamp of the time
                                                                 00.                      at which the test
                                                                                          metric commenced.
                                                                                         --Value must match
                                                                                          valid ISO-8601 format
                                                                                          including seconds and
                                                                                          timezone offset, i.e.:
                                                                                          YYYY-MM-DD[T]hh:mm:ss<
                                                                                          plus-minushh:mm.
duration.............................  Integer................  5000085................  Duration that the test
                                                                                          metric took to
                                                                                          complete in
                                                                                          microseconds.
bytes_transferred....................  Integer................  15129062...............  Measured total amount
                                                                                          of data in bytes that
                                                                                          the test metric
                                                                                          transferred.
bytes_sec............................  Integer................  3025761................  Measure number of bytes
                                                                                          per second that the
                                                                                          test metric
                                                                                          transferred.
locations............................  Array..................  .......................  List of geographic
                                       [Location Object]......                            coordinates of the
                                                                                          locations measured
                                                                                          during the speed test.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for each Location
                                                                                          Object element is
                                                                                          described in Section
                                                                                          0.
cells................................  Array..................  .......................  List of cellular
                                       [Cell Object]..........                            telephony information
                                                                                          measured during the
                                                                                          speed test.
                                                                                         Note: the specification
                                                                                          for each Cell Object
                                                                                          element is described
                                                                                          in Section 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

5. Location Objects
    Each element of the ``locations'' array contains the geographic 
coordinates of the locations measured at the start and end of the speed 
test, as well as during the test (if measured).

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
timestamp............................  Datetime...............  2021-07-08T09:02:58-08:  Timestamp of the time
                                                                 00.                      at which the location
                                                                                          was recorded.
                                                                                         --Value must match
                                                                                          valid ISO-8601 format
                                                                                          including seconds and
                                                                                          timezone offset, i.e.:
                                                                                          YYYY-MM-DD[T]hh:mm:ss<
                                                                                          plus-minushh:mm.
latitude.............................  Decimal (3,7)..........  63.069168..............  Unprojected (WGS-84)
                                                                                          geographic coordinate
                                                                                          latitude in decimal
                                                                                          degrees of the
                                                                                          reported location
                                                                                          where the test was
                                                                                          conducted.
                                                                                         --Value must have
                                                                                          minimum precision of 6
                                                                                          decimal places.
longitude............................  Decimal (3,7)..........  -153.248195............  Unprojected (WGS-84)
                                                                                          geographic coordinate
                                                                                          longitude in decimal
                                                                                          degrees of the
                                                                                          reported location
                                                                                          where the test was
                                                                                          conducted.
                                                                                         --Value must have
                                                                                          minimum precision of 6
                                                                                          decimal places.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

6. Cell Objects
    Each element of the ``cells'' array contains telephony information 
about the cell/carrier.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                Field                         Data type                 Example             Description/notes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cell_id..............................  Numeric................  32193025...............  Measured cell
                                                                                          identifier.
physical_cell_id.....................  Integer................  192....................  Measured Physical Cell
                                                                                          Identity (PCI) of the
                                                                                          cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for LTE
                                                                                          and 5G network
                                                                                          generations and may be
                                                                                          null for 2G/3G network
                                                                                          generations.

[[Page 40832]]

 
cell_connection......................  Enumerated.............  1......................  Connection status of
                                                                                          the cell.
                                                                                         --Value must be one of
                                                                                          the following codes:
                                                                                         0--Not Serving.
                                                                                         1--Primary Serving.
                                                                                         2--Secondary Serving.
                                                                                         Note: this value may be
                                                                                          null if connection
                                                                                          status returns
                                                                                          unknown.
network_.............................  Enumerated.............  4G.....................  String representing the
generation...........................                                                     network generation of
                                                                                          the cell.
                                                                                         --Value must be one of
                                                                                          the following:
                                                                                         {2G/3G/4G/5G/
                                                                                          Other{time}
network_subtype......................  Enumerated.............  LTE....................  String representing the
                                                                                          network subtype of the
                                                                                          cell.
                                                                                         --Value must be one of
                                                                                          the following:
                                                                                         {1X/EVDO/WCDMA/GSM/HSPA/
                                                                                          HSPA+/LTE/NR{time}
rssi.................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  -57.2..................  Measured Received
                                                                                          Signal Strength
                                                                                          Indication (RSSI) in
                                                                                          dBm of the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          required for all
                                                                                          network generations
                                                                                          and subtypes.
rsrp.................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  -92.1..................  Measured Reference
                                                                                          Signal Received Power
                                                                                          (RSRP) in dBm of the
                                                                                          cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for LTE
                                                                                          and NR subtypes, and
                                                                                          may be null for all
                                                                                          other network
                                                                                          subtypes.
rsrq.................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  -12.5..................  Measured Reference
                                                                                          Signal Received
                                                                                          Quality (RSRQ) in dB
                                                                                          of the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for LTE
                                                                                          and NR subtypes, and
                                                                                          may be null for all
                                                                                          other network
                                                                                          subtypes.
sinr.................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  21.3...................  Measured Signal to
                                                                                          Interference and Noise
                                                                                          Ratio (SINR) in dB of
                                                                                          the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for 2G,
                                                                                          LTE, and 5G network
                                                                                          generations, and may
                                                                                          be null for 3G.
ec_io................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  -8.3...................  Measured Energy per
                                                                                          Chip to Interference
                                                                                          Power Ratio in dB of
                                                                                          the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for CDMA
                                                                                          1X, EVDO, WCDMA, HSPA,
                                                                                          and HSPA+ network
                                                                                          subtypes, and may be
                                                                                          null for all other
                                                                                          network subtypes.
rscp.................................  Decimal (3,1)..........  -87.2..................  Measured Received
                                                                                          Signal Code Power in
                                                                                          dBm of the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this value is
                                                                                          only required for
                                                                                          WCDMA, HSPA, and HSPA+
                                                                                          network subtypes, and
                                                                                          may be null for all
                                                                                          other network
                                                                                          subtypes.
cqi..................................  Integer................  11.....................  Measured Channel
                                                                                          Quality Indicator
                                                                                          (CQI) of the cell.
                                                                                         Note: this field is
                                                                                          only required for
                                                                                          WCDMA, HSPA, HSPA+,
                                                                                          LTE, and NR network
                                                                                          subtypes, and may be
                                                                                          null for all other
                                                                                          network subtypes.
spectrum_bandwidth...................  Numeric................  15.....................  Total amount of
                                                                                          spectral bandwidth
                                                                                          used by the cell in
                                                                                          MHz.
arfcn................................  Integer................  66786..................  Absolute radio-
                                                                                          frequency channel
                                                                                          number, measured
                                                                                          absolute physical RF
                                                                                          channel number of the
                                                                                          cell.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

III. Appendix B: Drive Test Procedures--Technical Appendix

A. Introduction

    This technical appendix provides information about the proposed 
mobile certification process for Alaska Plan providers subject to drive 
testing. The Alaska Plan requires such testing to include ``a 
statistically significant number of tests in the vicinity of residences 
being covered'' to demonstrate that plan participants have met the 
commitments in the performance plans approved by the Wireless 
Telecommunications Bureau (Bureau).
    Remote Alaska is extraordinarily sparsely populated; virtually all 
its county-level geographies have population densities of three or 
fewer people per square mile. Accordingly, testing every location for a 
provider's coverage would be unduly burdensome, and testing a sample of 
locations is required.
    For the sampling required to implement the testing procedures under 
the Alaska Plan, staff proposes to use stratified random sampling. When 
properly implemented, this sampling methodology can achieve an optimal 
balance between the statistical significance required by the Alaska 
Plan and the burden on providers to conduct

[[Page 40833]]

tests from a sufficient number of locations.
    The following sections describe the details of the proposed testing 
process. These technical details serve as a guide to both the Bureau 
and the providers doing the testing in determining:
     Where, within the geographic boundaries of the coverage 
map, a provider should conduct testing;
     how many locations a provider must test;
     what speed test measurements will be accepted for staff 
analysis by the Bureau; and
     how Bureau staff will evaluate the test data and 
adjudicate whether the provider has passed or failed the testing 
process.

B. Sample Frame Construction

    To select locations for testing, one must first construct a list 
(known as a ``sampling frame'' or ``frame'') of possible locations to 
select from. The construction of this frame is a multi-part process. 
First, we propose creating a set of ``eligible populated areas.'' 
Census blocks eligible for frozen-support funding would be included, 
and these census blocks would be merged with the populated areas of the 
Alaska Population Distribution model. Second, the Form 477 reported 
coverage for which a provider committed to deploy subject to testing 
would be merged with the eligible populated areas to create a set of 
``covered populated areas.'' Third, a grid of 1 km x 1 km squares would 
be overlaid onto the covered populated areas.\1\ Due to the fact that 
the Alaska Population Distribution model uniformly distributes 
population within the populated area of a block, the covered populated 
areas of a block would likewise have a uniform population distribution. 
The total population of each grid cell is the sum of the populations of 
the covered populated areas contained within a given grid cell. For 
example, if a grid cell contains 25% of the covered populated area of a 
census block, that grid would be credited with 25% of that block's 
covered population. That same grid cell might also contain 100% of a 
second census block's covered populated area. So all of that census 
block's covered population would be credited to that grid cell, and the 
grid cell's total population would be the sum of these two populations. 
Lastly, any grid cell that contains fewer than 100,000 square meters of 
covered populated area, or 10% of the grid cell, would be excluded from 
the frame. This ensures that all grid cells have a reasonable testable 
area, reducing burden on providers. Grid cells with smaller levels of 
covered populated area were less likely to have areas that were 
publicly accessible or large enough to conduct mobile testing. Figures 
1-4 below detail this process.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \1\ Staff proposes to use this particular type of grid because 
census blocks are not of uniform geographic size, which could 
require a different number of speed tests for each block, and, in 
turn, could increase the testing burden on providers. Grids of 
smaller sizes and shapes were less likely to provide easily 
accessible areas for testing given the nature of roads and 
population distribution in remote Alaska, and grids of larger sizes 
and shapes would provide more heterogeneous wireless performance, 
which would require more cumbersome rules for actually conducting 
drive testing to ensure geographic diversity of the sample within 
each grid.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

[[Page 40834]]

[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.002

    For commitments that do not promise different speeds for different 
middle-mile technologies, the frame would utilize the most recent Form 
477 submissions from the provider, which currently is the provider's 
deployment data as of December 2020. For areas served by more than one 
technology, the area would only be included in the frame for the latest 
generation technology. For example, if an area is covered by both 2G 
and 3G, then the area would only be included in the 3G frame. As no 
commitments were made for 5G service, any 5G coverage will be included 
within the LTE frame. Where a provider has committed to different 
speeds in different areas due to different middle-mile technologies, 
the frame would rely on additional data submitted by the provider to 
differentiate the covered areas of a given technology (e.g., LTE) with 
multiple middle-mile types.
    If a provider wishes to submit data that better reflects the 
December 2021 Form 477 data that it is likely to submit in March 2022 
than the December 2020 data that the Commission currently has, then it 
should notify the Bureau within the Public Notice comment cycle and 
submit the updated coverage data within 10 days of the adoption of the 
Order. The Bureau will create a stratified random sample for the 
provider to test within 15 days of receipt of updated data, or, in the 
event of no new data submitted, 10 days of the adoption of an Order.

C. Frame Stratification

    Frame stratification is the process of dividing a frame into 
subsets of similar characteristics, called strata. This methodology 
allows fewer grid cells to be selected for testing while producing the 
same level of accuracy as sampling the entire frame, thus reducing 
testing burden.
    The number of strata for each frame depends on the number of grid 
cells in a given frame. To create the strata, the Bureau proposes to 
use the cumulative square root of the frequency (CSRF) method, based on 
grid-level estimates of covered population. CSRF is a standard 
stratification method used to define the breaks between strata. It 
creates equal intervals not on the scale along the stratification 
variable (in this case, covered population) scale, but rather on the 
scale along the cumulated square root of the count (frequency) of grid 
cells belonging to equal intervals of the stratification variable.
    Based on the data staff currently has, it is expected that each 
frame will contain between two and eight strata. Staff analysis has 
found that this stratification method produces strata of more equal 
sizes than other potential stratification methods (e.g., based on 
census tracts), which reduces the number of grid cells that need to be 
selected for testing.
    Further, staff proposes to select certain grid cells with 
probability 1 (grid cells that are called certainties) within each 
stratum. This ensures that grid cells that have a high population 
within a given stratum are tested; this should prevent the testing 
results of the stratum from being skewed by outlier results from low-
weighted grid cells.

[[Page 40835]]

D. Sample Size Calculation and Allocation and Sample Selection

    The Bureau proposes to decide the number of grid cells that the 
provider has to test (that is, the sample size, n), based on a set of 
statistical and logistical assumptions. The statistical assumption is 
that the variance of the desired estimate of average population served 
cannot exceed a specified value, V. The logistical assumption is that 
the cost of drive testing is constant in every grid cell selected in 
the sample. Under these assumptions, a theoretical value for the sample 
size can be calculated as detailed below.
    Let L denote the number of strata in the frame and let the index h 
distinguish these L strata. Further, denote or define the following 
quantities:
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.003

    Guided by the allocation scheme from the previous section, staff 
proposes to use geographic information systems (GIS) tools to randomly 
select grid cells in each stratum, including options within these tools 
that ensure geographic dispersion for selected grid cells within a 
stratum. The provider subject to testing would then be notified of the 
sample grid cells in which it would be required to conduct on-the-
ground speed tests.

E. Drive Testing Data Collection

    We propose that, within each selected grid cell, a carrier would 
conduct a minimum of 20 tests, no less than 50% of which are to be 
conducted while in-motion from a vehicle. This is the minimum number of 
tests to support the use of the binomial distribution to approximate 
the normal distribution that is needed in calculating the gap in 
coverage based on a one-sided 90% confidence interval, as discussed 
later in Section VII.
    To be considered valid, each test should be conducted between the 
hours of 6:00 a.m. and 10 p.m., within the selected grid cell, and 
report all relevant parameters defined in Appendix A. Each component of 
a test (i.e., download and upload speeds) should have a duration 
between 5 and 30 seconds. Mobile tests are considered to be located 
within the grid cell containing the starting location, as a tester has 
full control over the starting location of a test but may not always be 
able to control the ending location of a test.

[[Page 40836]]

Testers should, however, attempt to conduct a mobile test within a 
single grid cell as much as is reasonably and safely possible. A mobile 
test should initiate when moving away from the location of a stationary 
test after having reached the speed of the surrounding traffic, or a 
safe and reasonable operating speed in the event no traffic is present.

F. Statistical Analysis of Testing Results

    Upon receipt of drive testing submissions, the Bureau will perform 
a statistical analysis of the data to estimate the desired total 
population covered. Because the sample is selected using stratified 
random sampling, estimation techniques appropriate for this particular 
sampling method must be used.
    Stratified random sampling requires an aggregate measurement from a 
sampled grid cell that will be combined with measurements from the 
other sampled grid cells to calculate stratum-level estimates of total 
covered population. These estimates will, in turn, be combined to 
produce an overall estimate of covered population. Drive tests 
conducted in a sample grid cell will be aggregated based on the 
following rule:
    Let p be the percentage of drive tests that meet or exceed the 
applicable minimum.\2\ If p is at least 85%, then the full population 
of the sample grid cell will be deemed as covered; otherwise, 0% will 
be deemed as covered.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \2\ For 2G tests, the applicable minimum speeds would be 22.8 
kbps for both download and upload tests, as this is the minimum 
equivalent data rate for voice service, accounting for the voice 
codec rate and channel coding rate requirements. See ETSI, CODECs, 
https://www.etsi.org/technologies/codecs (last visited July 14, 
2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    To calculate the stratum-level estimates and the overall estimate 
of the covered population, the Bureau proposes to use the estimation 
method appropriate for stratified random sampling, described next.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.004

    To more accurately reflect coverage at the time of deployment and 
to fulfill the Alaska Plan's requirement to evaluate a provider's 
commitments based on December 2021 Form 477 coverage data, we propose 
to adjust the covered population of the sample frames Nh relative to 
covered population according to the December 2020 Form 477 data. For 
frames where coverage would be reduced, we would proportionally reduce 
population, and, for where coverage would increase, we would 
proportionally increase population.
    Finally, the overall covered population total, X, is estimated as
X = Nx.

G. Adjudication of the Outcome of the Testing Process

    Because the estimate of the total covered population X comes from a 
sample, direct comparison of X against the committed covered population 
is not appropriate. Instead, staff proposes to construct a confidence 
interval that takes into account the variability arising from the 
estimate X, and use this confidence interval to adjudicate the outcome 
of the testing process.
    Because the Alaska Plan calls for a tiered approach in levying 
penalties for providers failing the testing process, the Bureau 
proposes to use a one-sided 90% confidence interval for X to quantify 
the gap in coverage. In particular, the Bureau proposes to use the 
upper limit of this confidence interval, which is calculated as
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.005


[[Page 40837]]


    The gap in coverage is then calculated as:

Gap in Coverage = Total Population Coverage Commitment -
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN29JY21.006


    If the gap in coverage is no more than 5% of the total population 
of a given commitment, no penalties will apply. Otherwise, penalties 
will apply according to the tiers adopted by the Commission.
    Additionally, it is possible to have a negative gap in coverage if 
the upper limit of the confidence interval is greater than the total 
committed population. If a provider has committed to multiple tiers of 
technology (i.e., 2G, 3G, and 4G LTE), then any excess coverage, as 
defined by a negative gap in coverage, can be applied to the next 
lowest tier of technology. For example, if a provider has committed to 
cover 25,000 people with 4G LTE and the upper limit of the confidence 
interval shows adequate coverage for 30,000 people, then the remaining 
5,000 coverage can be applied to its 3G commitment. This process is 
iterative, so any further excess coverage can be applied to its 2G 
commitment. Accordingly, the formula above would be re-written as:

    Gap in Coverage = Total Population Coverage Commitment-( X + 
1.28N[radic]V(x) + Excess Coverage from Higher Technology)

    9This methodology therefore will not punish carriers for improving 
coverage beyond what they committed.

IV. Procedural Matters

    Initial Regulatory Flexibility Certification. As required by the 
Regulatory Flexibility Act, the Commission certifies that the proposals 
in this Public Notice, if adopted, will not have a significant impact 
on a substantial number of small entities. This Public Notice seeks 
comment on the drive testing proposals required by the Alaska Plan for 
those wireless participants receiving more than $5 million in annual 
Alaska Plan support, excluding the smaller wireless participants that 
receive less than that in annual support. The proposals, if adopted, 
would apply to only two entities, one of which does not qualify as a 
small entity.
    Ex Parte Presentations. This proceeding shall be treated as a 
``permit-but-disclose'' proceeding in accordance with the Commission's 
ex parte rules. Persons making ex parte presentations must file a copy 
of any written presentation or a memorandum summarizing any oral 
presentation within two business days after the presentation (unless a 
different deadline applicable to the Sunshine period applies). Persons 
making oral ex parte presentations are reminded that memoranda 
summarizing the presentation must (1) list all persons attending or 
otherwise participating in the meeting at which the ex parte 
presentation was made, and (2) summarize all data presented and 
arguments made during the presentation. If the presentation consisted 
in whole or in part of the presentation of data or arguments already 
reflected in the presenter's written comments, memoranda or other 
filings in the proceeding, the presenter may provide citations to such 
data or arguments in his or her prior comments, memoranda, or other 
filings (specifying the relevant page and/or paragraph numbers where 
such data or arguments can be found) in lieu of summarizing them in the 
memorandum. Documents shown or given to Commission staff during ex 
parte meetings are deemed to be written ex parte presentations and must 
be filed consistent with rule 1.1206(b). In proceedings governed by 
rule 1.49(f) or for which the Commission has made available a method of 
electronic filing, written ex parte presentations and memoranda 
summarizing oral ex parte presentations, and all attachments thereto, 
must be filed through the electronic comment filing system available 
for that proceeding, and must be filed in their native format (e.g., 
.doc, .xml, .ppt, searchable .pdf). Participants in this proceeding 
should familiarize themselves with the Commission's ex parte rules.
    Legal Basis. The Bureau is authorized to propose the drive test 
parameters and model pursuant to the authority delegated in the Alaska 
Plan Order, 31 FCC Rcd 10139, 10160, 10166, paras. 67, 85 (2016) and 47 
CFR 54.317, 54.320-54.321.

Federal Communications Commission.
Amy Brett,
Acting Chief of Staff, Wireless Telecommunications Bureau.
[FR Doc. 2021-16125 Filed 7-27-21; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 6712-01-P