[Federal Register Volume 84, Number 98 (Tuesday, May 21, 2019)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 23274-23418]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2019-09665]
[[Page 23273]]
Vol. 84
Tuesday,
No. 98
May 21, 2019
Part III
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
12 CFR Part 1006
Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F); Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 84 , No. 98 / Tuesday, May 21, 2019 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 23274]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION
12 CFR Part 1006
[Docket No. CFPB-2019-0022]
RIN 3170-AA41
Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F)
AGENCY: Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.
ACTION: Proposed rule with request for public comment.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection (Bureau) proposes
to amend Regulation F, 12 CFR part 1006, which implements the Fair Debt
Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) and currently contains the procedures
for State application for exemption from the provisions of the FDCPA.
The Bureau's proposal would amend Regulation F to prescribe Federal
rules governing the activities of debt collectors, as that term is
defined in the FDCPA. The Bureau's proposal would, among other things,
address communications in connection with debt collection; interpret
and apply prohibitions on harassment or abuse, false or misleading
representations, and unfair practices in debt collection; and clarify
requirements for certain consumer-facing debt collection disclosures.
DATES: Comments must be received on or before August 19, 2019.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by Docket No. CFPB-2019-
0022 or RIN 3170-AA41, by any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
Email: [email protected]. Include Docket
No. CFPB-2019-0022 or RIN 3170-AA41 in the subject line of the email.
Mail: Comment Intake--Debt Collection, Bureau of Consumer
Financial Protection, 1700 G Street NW, Washington, DC 20552.
Hand Delivery/Courier: Comment Intake--Debt Collection,
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, 1700 G Street NW, Washington,
DC 20552.
Instructions: The Bureau encourages the early submission of
comments. All submissions should include the agency name and docket
number or Regulatory Information Number (RIN) for this rulemaking.
Because paper mail in the Washington, DC area and at the Bureau is
subject to delay, commenters are encouraged to submit comments
electronically. In general, all comments received will be posted
without change to http://www.regulations.gov. In addition, comments
will be available for public inspection and copying at 1700 G Street
NW, Washington, DC 20552, on official business days between the hours
of 10:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time. You can make an appointment
to inspect the documents by telephoning 202-435-7275.
All comments, including attachments and other supporting materials,
will become part of the public record and subject to public disclosure.
Proprietary or sensitive personal information, such as account numbers,
Social Security numbers, or names of other individuals, should not be
included. Comments will not be edited to remove any identifying or
contact information.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Adam Mayle, Counsel; or Dania Ayoubi,
Owen Bonheimer, Seth Caffrey, David Hixson, David Jacobs, Courtney
Jean, or Kristin McPartland, Senior Counsels, Office of Regulations, at
202-435-7700. If you require this document in an alternative electronic
format, please contact [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Summary of the Proposed Rule
The Bureau proposes to amend Regulation F, which implements the
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA),\1\ to prescribe Federal
rules governing the activities of debt collectors, as that term is
defined in the FDCPA (FDCPA-covered debt collectors). The proposal
focuses on debt collection communications and disclosures and also
addresses related practices by debt collectors. The Bureau also
proposes that FDCPA-covered debt collectors comply with certain
additional disclosure-related and record retention requirements
pursuant to the Bureau's rulemaking authority under title X of the
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank
Act).\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ 15 U.S.C. 1692-1692p.
\2\ Public Law 111-203, 124 Stat. 1376 (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 1977, Congress passed the FDCPA to eliminate abusive debt
collection practices by debt collectors, to ensure that those debt
collectors who refrain from using abusive debt collection practices are
not competitively disadvantaged, and to promote consistent State action
to protect consumers against debt collection abuses.\3\ The statute was
a response to ``abundant evidence of the use of abusive, deceptive, and
unfair debt collection practices by many debt collectors.'' \4\
According to Congress, these practices ``contribute to the number of
personal bankruptcies, to marital instability, to the loss of jobs, and
to invasions of individual privacy.'' \5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
\4\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(a).
\5\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FDCPA established certain consumer protections, but
interpretative questions have arisen since its passage. Some questions,
including those related to communication technologies that did not
exist at the time the FDCPA was passed (such as mobile telephones,
email, and text messaging), have been the subject of inconsistent court
decisions, resulting in legal uncertainty and additional cost for
industry and risk for consumers. As the first Federal agency with
authority under the FDCPA to prescribe substantive rules with respect
to the collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau proposes to
clarify how debt collectors may employ such newer communication
technologies in compliance with the FDCPA and to address other
communications-related practices that may pose a risk of harm to
consumers and create legal uncertainty for industry. The Bureau also
proposes to interpret the FDCPA's consumer disclosure requirements to
clarify how industry participants can comply with the law and to assist
consumers in making better-informed decisions about debts they owe or
allegedly owe.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ Because this is a proposed rule, the Bureau's statements
herein regarding proposed interpretations of the FDCPA or the Dodd-
Frank Act do not represent final Bureau interpretations. The Bureau
is not, through its proposed interpretations, finding that conduct
either violates or is permissible under the FDCPA or the Dodd-Frank
Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. Coverage and Organization of the Proposed Rule
The Bureau's proposed rule is based primarily on its authority to
issue rules to implement the FDCPA. Consequently, the proposal
generally would impose requirements on debt collectors, as that term is
defined in the FDCPA. However, the Bureau proposes certain provisions
of the regulation based on the Bureau's Dodd-Frank Act rulemaking
authority. With respect to debt collection, the Bureau's authority
under the Dodd-Frank Act generally may address the conduct of those who
collect debt related to a consumer financial product or service, as
that term is defined in the Dodd-Frank Act.\7\ Proposed rule
[[Page 23275]]
provisions that rely on the Bureau's Dodd-Frank Act rulemaking
authority generally would not, therefore, require FDCPA-covered debt
collectors to comply if they are not collecting debt related to a
consumer financial product or service.\8\ Such FDCPA-covered debt
collectors, however, would not violate the FDCPA by complying with any
such provisions adopted in a final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ Covered persons under the Dodd-Frank Act include persons who
are ``engage[d] in offering or providing a consumer financial
product or service''; this generally includes persons who are
``collecting debt related to any consumer financial product or
service'' (e.g., debt related to the extension of consumer credit).
See 12 U.S.C. 5481(5), (6), (15)(A)(i), (x).
\8\ These provisions appear in proposed Sec. Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii) (repeated or continuous telephone calls or
telephone conversations), 1006.30(b)(1)(ii) (prohibition on the
sale, transfer, or placement of certain debts), and
1006.34(c)(2)(iv) (certain information about the debt) and (3)(iv)
(certain information about consumer protections). Note that proposed
Sec. Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(i) and 1006.30(b)(1)(i) would prohibit the
same conduct by all FDCPA-covered debt collectors that proposed
Sec. Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) and 1006.30(b)(1)(ii) would prohibit
only for FDCPA-covered debt collectors collecting consumer financial
product or service debt. Additionally, the record retention
requirement in Sec. 1006.100 is proposed only pursuant to Dodd-
Frank Act rulemaking authority but would apply to all FDCPA-covered
debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed rule restates the FDCPA's substantive provisions
largely in the order that they appear in the statute, sometimes without
further interpretation. Restating the statutory text of all of the
substantive provisions may facilitate understanding and compliance by
ensuring that stakeholders need to consult only the regulation to view
all relevant definitions and substantive provisions. Where the Bureau
proposes to restate statutory text without further interpretation, the
relevant section-by-section analysis explains that the proposed rule
restates the statutory language with only minor wording or
organizational changes for clarity. Except where specifically stated,
the Bureau does not intend to codify existing case law or judicial
interpretations of the statute by restating the statutory text. The
Bureau requests comment on the proposed approach of restating the
substantive provisions of the FDCPA.
The proposed rule has four subparts. Subpart A contains generally
applicable provisions, such as definitions that would apply throughout
the regulation. Subpart B contains proposed rules for FDCPA-covered
debt collectors. Subpart C is reserved for any future debt collection
rulemakings. Subpart D contains certain miscellaneous provisions.
B. Scope of the Proposed Rule
Communications Proposals
Debt collection efforts often begin with attempts by a debt
collector to reach a consumer. Communicating with a debt collector may
benefit a consumer by helping the consumer to either resolve a debt the
consumer owes, or identify and inform the debt collector if the debt is
one that the consumer does not owe. However, debt collection
communications also may constitute unfair practices, may contain false
or misleading representations, or may be harassing or abusive either
because of their content (for example, when debt collectors employ
profanity) or because of the manner in which they are made (for
example, when debt collectors place excessive telephone calls with the
intent to harass or abuse).
Communication technology has evolved significantly since the FDCPA
was enacted in 1977. Today, consumers may prefer communicating with
debt collectors using newer technologies, such as emails, text
messages, or web portals, because these technologies may offer greater
efficiency, convenience, and privacy. These technologies also may allow
consumers to exert greater control over the timing, frequency, and
duration of communications with debt collectors--for example, by
choosing when, where, and how much time to spend responding to a debt
collector's email. Debt collectors also may find that these
technologies are a more effective and efficient means of communicating
with consumers.
To address concerns about debt collection communications and to
clarify the application of the FDCPA to newer communication
technologies, the Bureau proposes to:
Define a new term related to debt collection
communications: Limited-content message. This definition would identify
what information a debt collector must and may include in a message
left for consumers (with the inclusion of no other information
permitted) for the message to be deemed not to be a communication under
the FDCPA. This definition would permit a debt collector to leave a
message for a consumer without communicating, as defined by the FDCPA,
with a person other than the consumer.
Clarify the times and places at which a debt collector may
communicate with a consumer, including by clarifying that a consumer
need not use specific words to assert that a time or place is
inconvenient for debt collection communications.
Clarify that a consumer may restrict the media through
which a debt collector communicates by designating a particular medium,
such as email, as one that cannot be used for debt collection
communications.
Clarify that, subject to certain exceptions, a debt
collector is prohibited from placing a telephone call to a person more
than seven times within a seven-day period or within seven days after
engaging in a telephone conversation with the person.
Clarify that newer communication technologies, such as
emails and text messages, may be used in debt collection, with certain
limitations to protect consumer privacy and to prevent harassment or
abuse, false or misleading representations, or unfair practices. For
example, the Bureau proposes to require that a debt collector's emails
and text messages include instructions for a consumer to opt out of
receiving further emails or text messages. The Bureau also proposes
procedures that, when followed, would protect a debt collector from
liability for unintentional violations of the prohibition against
third-party disclosures when communicating with a consumer by email or
text message.
Consumer Disclosure Proposals
The FDCPA requires that a debt collector send a written notice to a
consumer, within five days of the initial communication, containing
certain information about the debt and actions the consumer may take in
response, unless such information was provided in the initial
communication or the consumer has paid the debt. To clarify the
information that a debt collector must provide to a consumer at the
outset of debt collection, including (if applicable) in a validation
notice, the Bureau proposes:
To specify that debt collectors must provide certain
information about the debt and the consumer's rights with respect to
the debt. The Bureau also proposes to require a debt collector to
provide prompts that a consumer could use to dispute the debt, request
information about the original creditor, or take certain other actions.
The Bureau also proposes to permit a debt collector to include certain
optional information.
A model validation notice that a debt collector could use
to comply with the FDCPA and the proposed rule's disclosure
requirements.
To clarify the steps a debt collector must take to provide
the validation notice and other required disclosures electronically.
A safe harbor if a debt collector complies with certain
steps when delivering the validation notice within the body of an email
that is the debt collector's initial communication with the consumer.
The Bureau also proposes to prohibit a debt collector from suing or
threatening to sue a consumer to collect a time-barred debt. The Bureau
plans to test consumer disclosures related to time-barred debt and,
after testing, will
[[Page 23276]]
assess whether a debt collector who collects a time-barred debt must
disclose that the debt collector cannot sue to collect the debt because
of its age. At a later date, the Bureau may release a report on such
testing and issue a disclosure proposal related to the collection of
time-barred debt. Stakeholders will have an opportunity to comment on
such testing if the Bureau intends to use it to support disclosure
requirements in a final rule.
Additional Proposals
The Bureau proposes to address certain other consumer protection
concerns in the debt collection market. For example, the Bureau
proposes:
To clarify that the personal representative of a deceased
consumer's estate is a consumer for purposes of proposed Sec. 1006.6,
which addresses communications in connection with debt collection. This
clarification generally would allow a debt collector to discuss a debt
with the personal representative of a deceased consumer's estate. The
Bureau also proposes to clarify how a debt collector may locate the
personal representative of a deceased consumer's estate. In addition,
the proposed rule would interpret the requirement that a debt collector
provide the validation notice to a ``consumer'' to require the notice
be provided to the person acting on behalf of a deceased consumer's
estate, i.e., the executor, administrator, or personal representative
of a deceased consumer's estate, who would have the right to dispute
the debt.
To prohibit a debt collector from furnishing information
about a debt to a consumer reporting agency before communicating with
the consumer about the debt.
To prohibit, with certain exceptions, the sale, transfer,
or placement for collection of a debt if a debt collector knows or
should know that the debt has been paid or settled or has been
discharged in bankruptcy, or that an identity theft report has been
filed with respect to the debt.
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of the proposed rule.
C. Effective Date
The Bureau proposes that the effective date of the final rule would
be one year after the final rule is published in the Federal Register.
The Bureau requests comment on this proposed effective date.
II. Background
A. Debt Collection Market Background
A consumer debt is commonly understood to be a consumer's
obligation to pay money to another person or entity. Sometimes a debt
arises out of a closed-end loan. At other times, a debt arises from a
consumer's use of an open-end line of credit, most commonly a credit
card. And in other cases, a debt arises from a consumer's purchase of
goods or services with payment due thereafter. Often there is an
agreed-upon payment schedule or date by which the consumer must repay
the debt.
For a variety of reasons, consumers sometimes are unable (or in
some instances unwilling) to make payments when they are due.
Collection efforts may directly recover some or all of the overdue
amounts owed to debt owners and thereby may indirectly help to keep
consumer credit available and more affordable to consumers.\9\
Collection activities also can lead to repayment plans or debt
restructuring that may provide consumers with additional time to make
payments or resolve their debts on more manageable terms.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Fair Debt Collection
Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2013, at 9 (Mar. 2013), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/annual-report-on-the-fair-debt-collection-practices-act/ (hereinafter 2013
FDCPA Annual Report).
\10\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The debt collection industry includes creditors, third-party debt
collectors (including debt collection law firms), debt buyers, and a
wide variety of related service providers. Debt collection is estimated
to be an $11.5 billion-dollar industry employing nearly 118,500 people
across approximately 7,700 collection agencies in the United
States.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Fair Debt Collection
Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2019, at 8 (Mar. 2019), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_fdcpa_annual-report-congress_03-2019.pdf (hereinafter 2019 FDCPA Annual Report).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Creditors
When an account becomes delinquent, initial collection efforts
often are undertaken by the original creditor or its servicer. The
FDCPA typically does not cover these first-party recovery efforts. If
these first-party recovery efforts result in resolution of the debt,
whether through payment in full or another arrangement, the consumer
typically will not interact with a third-party debt collector.
Third-Party Debt Collectors
If a consumer's payment obligations remain unmet, a creditor may
send the account to a third-party debt collector to recover on the debt
in the third-party debt collector's name. A creditor may choose to send
an account to a third-party debt collector for several reasons,
including because the third-party debt collector possesses capabilities
and expertise that the creditor lacks. Third-party debt collectors
usually are paid on a contingency basis, typically a percentage of
recoveries; debt collectors contracting with creditors on a contingency
basis generated a large majority of the industry's 2018 revenue.\12\
Contingency debt collectors compete with one another to secure business
from creditors based on, among other factors, the debt collectors'
effectiveness in obtaining recoveries.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ Id. at 10.
\13\ While third-party collection agencies have been increasing
in size in recent years, third-party debt collection continues to
include a significant number of smaller entities. See Robert M.
Hunt, Understanding the Model: The Life Cycle of a Debt, at 15, Fed.
Reserve Bank of Phila. (June 6, 2013), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_events/life-debt-data-integrity-debt-collection/understandingthemodel.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt Buyers
If contingency collections prove unsuccessful--or if a particular
creditor prefers not to use such third-party debt collectors--a
creditor may sell unpaid accounts to a debt buyer. In 2009, the Federal
Trade Commission (FTC) called the advent and growth of debt buying
``the most significant change in the debt collection business'' in
recent years.\14\ Debt buyers purchase defaulted debt from creditors or
other debt owners and thereby take title to the debt. Credit card debt
comprises a large majority of the debt that debt buyers purchase.\15\
Debt buyers generated about one-third of debt collection revenue, or
about $3.5 billion, in 2017.\16\ Creditors who sell their uncollected
debt to debt buyers receive a certain up-front return, but these debts
typically are sold at prices that are a fraction of their face value.
Debt buyers typically price their offers for portfolios based upon
their projections of the amount they will be able to collect. The debt
buyer incurs the risk of recovering
[[Page 23277]]
less than the sum of the amount it paid to acquire the debt and its
expenses to collect the debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ Fed. Trade Comm'n, The Structure and Practices of the Debt
Buying Industry, at i (2013), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/reports/structure-and-practices-debt-buying-industry/debtbuyingreport.pdf (hereinafter FTC Debt Buying Report).
\15\ Id. at 7 (citing Credit Card Debt Sales in 2008, 921 Nilson
Rep. 10 (Mar. 2009)).
\16\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Fair Debt Collection
Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2018, at 10 (Mar. 2018), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_fdcpa_annual-report-congress_03-2018.pdf (hereinafter 2018 FDCPA Annual Report) (citing
Edward Rivera, Debt Collection Agencies in the US, IBIS World (Dec.
2017)). Although debt buyers represent about one-third of industry
revenue, this overstates debt buyers' share of dollars collected,
since debt buyer revenue includes all amounts recovered, whereas the
revenue of contingency debt collectors includes only the share of
recoveries retained by the debt collector. Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Typically a debt buyer engages in debt collection, attempting to
collect debts itself. However, a debt buyer also may use a third-party
debt collector or a series of such debt collectors. If the debt buyer
is unable to collect some of the debts it purchased, the debt buyer may
sell the debt again to another debt buyer. Any single debt thus may be
owned by multiple entities over its lifetime. The price paid for a debt
generally will decline as the debt ages and passes from debt buyer to
debt buyer, because the probability of payment decreases.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ FTC Debt Buying Report, supra note 14, at 23-24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt Collection Law Firms
If debt collection attempts are unsuccessful, a debt owner may try
to recover on a debt through litigation. Most debt collection
litigation is filed in State courts. Debt owners often retain law firms
and attorneys that specialize in debt collection and that are familiar
with State and local rules. If a debt owner obtains a judgment in its
favor, post-litigation efforts may include garnishment of wages or
seizure of assets.
B. Debt Collection Methods
The debt collection experience is a common one--approximately one
in three consumers with a credit record reported having been contacted
about a debt in collection in 2014.\18\ Of those, 27 percent reported
having been contacted about a single debt over the prior year, 57
percent reported having been contacted about two to four debts, and 16
percent reported having been contacted about more than four debts.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Consumer Experience with
Debt Collection: Findings from CFPB's Survey of Consumer Views on
Debt, at 5 (2017), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/201701_cfpb_Debt-Collection-Survey-Report.pdf (hereinafter CFPB Debt
Collection Consumer Survey). This figure includes consumers
contacted only by creditors as well as those contacted by one or
more debt collection firms. Id. at 13.
\19\ Id. at 13.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A creditor typically stops communicating with a consumer once
responsibility for an account has moved to a third-party debt
collector. Active debt collection efforts typically begin with the debt
collector attempting to locate the consumer, usually by identifying a
valid telephone number or mailing address, so that the debt collector
can establish contact with the consumer. To obtain current contact
information, a debt collector may look to information that transferred
with the account file, public records, data sellers, or proprietary
databases of contact information. A debt collector may also attempt to
obtain location information for a consumer from third parties, such as
family members who share a residence with the consumer or colleagues at
the consumer's workplace.
Once a debt collector has obtained contact information for a
consumer, the debt collector typically will seek to communicate with
the consumer to obtain payment on some or all of the debt. The debt
collector may tailor the collection strategy depending on a variety of
factors, including the size and age of the debt and the debt
collector's assessment of the likelihood of obtaining money from the
consumer. For example, rather than affirmatively locating and
contacting consumers, some debt collectors collecting relatively small
debts--such as many medical, utility, and telecommunications debts--
will report the debts to consumer reporting agencies (CRAs) and then
wait for consumers to contact them after discovering the debts on their
consumer reports.\20\ Other types of debt are subject to statutory or
regulatory requirements that may affect how a debt collector tries to
recover on them. For example, privacy protections may affect how a debt
collector seeks to recover on a medical debt, and the availability of
administrative wage garnishment and tax refund intercepts may affect
how a debt collector seeks to recover on a Federal student loan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Consumer Credit Reports: A
Study of Medical and Non-Medical Collections, at 35-36 (2014),
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201412_cfpb_reports_consumer-credit-medical-and-non-medical-collections.pdf (hereinafter CFPB
Medical Debt Report).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Changes in a consumer's situation may warrant a change in a debt
collector's recovery strategy, such as when information purchased from
CRAs or other third parties indicates that the consumer has started a
new job. A debt owner also may ``warehouse'' a debt and cease
collection efforts for a significant period. A new debt collector may
later be tasked with resuming collection efforts because, for example,
the debt owner has sold the account, detected a possible change in the
consumer's financial situation, or wishes to make periodic attempts at
some recovery. Each time a new debt collector obtains responsibility
for collecting the debt, the consumer likely will be subject to
communications or communication attempts from the new debt collector.
For the consumer, this may mean contact from a series of different debt
collectors over a number of years. During this time, the consumer may
make payments to multiple debt collectors or may receive communication
attempts from multiple debt collectors that may stop and restart at
irregular intervals, until the debt is paid or settled in full or
collection activity ceases for other reasons.
C. Consumer Protection Concerns
Each year, consumers submit tens of thousands of complaints about
debt collection to Federal regulators; \21\ many of those complaints
relate to practices addressed in the proposed rule. Consumers also file
thousands of private actions each year against debt collectors who
allegedly have violated the FDCPA. Since the Bureau began operations in
2011, it has brought numerous debt collection cases against third-party
debt collectors, alleging both FDCPA violations and unfair, deceptive,
or abusive debt collection acts or practices in violation of the Dodd-
Frank Act.\22\ In these cases, the Bureau has ordered civil penalties,
monetary compensation for consumers, and other relief. In its
supervisory work, the Bureau similarly has identified many FDCPA
violations during examinations of debt collectors. Over the past
decade, the FTC and State regulators also have brought numerous
additional actions against debt collectors for violating Federal and
State
[[Page 23278]]
debt collection and consumer protection laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\ See, e.g., 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 11, at 15-
16; Fed. Trade Comm'n, 2018 Consumer Sentinel Network Databook, at
4, 7 (Feb. 2019), https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/consumer-sentinel-network-data-book-2018/consumer_sentinel_network_data_book_2018_0.pdf; 2018 FDCPA Annual
Report, supra note 16, at 14-15; Fed. Trade Comm'n, 2017 Consumer
Sentinel Network Databook, at 3, 6 (Mar. 2018), https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/consumer-sentinel-network-data-book-2017/consumer_sentinel_data_book_2017.pdf; Bureau of Consumer Fin.
Prot., 2017 Fair Debt Collection Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report
2017, at 15-16 (Mar. 2017), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/201703_cfpb_Fair-Debt-Collection-Practices-Act-Annual-Report.pdf (hereinafter 2017 FDCPA Annual Report); Fed. Trade
Comm'n, Consumer Sentinel Network Data Book for January-December
2016, at 3, 6 (Mar. 2017), https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/consumer-sentinel-network-data-book-january-december-2016/csn_cy-2016_data_book.pdf.
\22\ See, e.g., Consent Order, In re Encore Capital Grp., 2015-
CFPB-0022 (Sept. 9, 2015), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201509_cfpb_consent-order-encore-capital-group.pdf; Consent Order,
In re Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 2015-CFPB-0023 (Sept. 9,
2015), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201509_cfpb_consent-order-portfolio-recovery-associates-llc.pdf; Complaint, Consumer Fin.
Prot. Bureau v. Nat'l Corrective Grp., Inc., 1:15-cv-00899-RDB (D.
Md. Mar. 30, 2015), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201503_cfpb_complaint-national-corrective-group.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. FDCPA and Dodd-Frank Act Protections for Consumers
Federal and State governments historically have sought to protect
consumers from harmful debt collection practices. From 1938 to 1977,
the Federal government primarily protected consumers through FTC
enforcement actions against debt collectors who engaged in unfair or
deceptive acts or practices in violation of section 5 of the FTC
Act.\23\ When Congress enacted the FDCPA in 1977, it found that
``[e]xisting laws and procedures for redressing . . . injuries [were]
inadequate to protect consumers.'' \24\ Congress found that ``[t]here
[was] abundant evidence of the use of abusive, deceptive, and unfair
debt collection practices by many debt collectors,'' and that these
practices ``contribute to the number of personal bankruptcies, to
marital instability, to the loss of jobs, and to invasions of
individual privacy.'' \25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\ 15 U.S.C. 45.
\24\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(b).
\25\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FDCPA was enacted, in part, ``to eliminate abusive debt
collection practices by debt collectors, [and] to insure that those
debt collectors who refrain from using abusive debt collection
practices are not competitively disadvantaged.'' \26\ Among other
things, the FDCPA: (1) Prohibits debt collectors from engaging in
harassment or abuse, making false or misleading representations, and
engaging in unfair practices in debt collection; (2) restricts debt
collectors' communications with consumers and others; and (3) requires
debt collectors to provide consumers with disclosures concerning the
debts they owe or allegedly owe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Until the creation of the Bureau, no Federal agency was authorized
to issue regulations to implement the substantive provisions of the
FDCPA. Courts have issued opinions providing differing interpretations
of various FDCPA provisions, and there is considerable uncertainty with
respect to how the FDCPA applies to communication technologies that did
not exist in 1977. Further, to reduce legal risk, debt collectors
typically use the language of the statute in making required
disclosures, even though that language can be difficult for consumers
to understand.
The Dodd-Frank Act amended the FDCPA to provide the Bureau with
authority to ``prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts
by debt collectors.'' \27\ Section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act also
authorizes the Bureau, among other things, to prescribe rules
applicable to a covered person or service provider identifying as
unlawful unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices in connection
with any transaction with a consumer for a consumer financial product
or service, or the offering of a consumer financial product or
service.\28\ Section 1031(b) provides that rules under section 1031 may
include requirements for the purpose of preventing such unfair,
deceptive, or abusive acts or practices.\29\ Covered persons under the
Dodd-Frank Act include persons who are ``engage[d] in offering or
providing a consumer financial product or service''; \30\ this
generally includes persons who are ``collecting debt related to any
consumer financial product or service'' (e.g., debt related to the
extension of consumer credit).\31\ Covered persons under the Dodd-Frank
Act thus include many FDCPA-covered debt collectors, as well as many
creditors and their servicers, who are collecting debt related to a
consumer financial product or service.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d).
\28\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b), 12 U.S.C. 5531(b).
\29\ Id.
\30\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(6).
\31\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(5), (15)(A)(i), (x).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. The Rulemaking Process
The Bureau has conducted a wide range of outreach on the scope and
substance of this proposed rule, including by holding field
hearings,\32\ hosting two joint roundtables with the FTC,\33\ and
issuing an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) in November
2013.\34\ The Bureau has conducted several rounds of qualitative
testing of prototype debt collection disclosure forms and has conducted
formal and informal surveys over the past several years to obtain a
more comprehensive and systematic understanding of debt collection
practices. The Bureau also convened a Small Business Review Panel in
August 2016 to obtain feedback from small debt collectors. Since the
Bureau began studying this market, the Bureau has met on many occasions
with various stakeholders, including consumer advocacy groups, debt
collection trade associations, industry participants, academics with
expertise in debt collection, Federal prudential regulators, and other
Federal and State consumer protection regulators. The Bureau also
received a number of comments specific to the debt collection
rulemaking in response to its Request for Information Regarding the
Bureau's Adopted Regulations and New Rulemaking Authorities \35\ and
its Request for Information Regarding the Bureau's Inherited
Regulations and Inherited Rulemaking Authorities,\36\ and the Bureau
has considered these comments in developing the proposed rule. In
addition, the Bureau has engaged in general outreach, speaking at
consumer advocacy group and industry events and visiting consumer
organizations and industry stakeholders. The Bureau has provided other
regulators with information about the proposed rule, has sought their
input, and has received feedback that has helped the Bureau to prepare
this proposed rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\ See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Field Hearing on Debt
Collection in Seattle, WA (Oct. 24, 2012), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/events/archive-past-events/field-hearing-on-deft-collection-from-seattle-washington/; Bureau of
Consumer Fin. Prot., Field Hearing on Debt Collection in Portland,
ME (July 10, 2013), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/events/archive-past-events/field-hearing-debt-collection-portland-me/;
Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Field Hearing on Debt Collection in
Sacramento, CA (July 28, 2016), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/events/archive-past-events/field-hearing-debt-collection-sacramento-calif/.
\33\ Fed. Trade Comm'n & Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Debt
Collection and the Latino Community: An FTC-CFPB Roundtable (Oct.
23, 2014), https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events-calendar/2014/10/debt-collection-latino-community-roundtable; Fed. Trade Comm'n &
Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Roundtable on Data Integrity in Debt
Collection: Life of a Debt (July 6, 2013), https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_events/71120/life-debt-roundtable-transcript.pdf.
\34\ 78 FR 67848 (Nov. 12, 2013).
\35\ 83 FR 12286 (Mar. 21, 2018).
\36\ 83 FR 12881 (Mar. 26, 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. 2013 Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
The Bureau issued an ANPRM regarding debt collection in November of
2013. The ANPRM sought information about both first- and third-party
debt collection practices, including: Debt collectors' communication
and calling practices; the use of disclosures, such as time-barred debt
disclosures, in debt collection; the quantity and quality of
information in the debt collection system; credit reporting by debt
collectors; the prevalence and use of litigation by debt collectors,
including by debt collection attorneys; and record retention,
monitoring, and compliance issues.
The Bureau received more than 23,000 comments in response to the
ANPRM, with approximately 379 non-form comments submitted. These non-
form comments were provided by consumers, consumer advocacy groups,
[[Page 23279]]
industry participants and trade associations, legal groups including
law school clinics, State Attorneys General, and other stakeholders.
The Bureau also worked with Cornell University's Regulation Room, which
interacted with consumers to obtain their input and submitted a
consolidated comment representing views from a multitude of consumers.
Comments on the ANPRM related to both first- and third-party collection
efforts. Commenters provided significant feedback regarding debt
collector communication practices and interactions with consumers,
consumer disclosures, and the use of newer communication technologies.
Specific comments are discussed in more detail in part V where
relevant.
B. Consumer Testing
The Bureau contracted with a third-party vendor, Fors Marsh Group
(FMG), to assist with developing, and to conduct qualitative consumer
testing of, two potential consumer-facing debt collection model
disclosure forms: The validation notice and the statement of consumer
rights. The Bureau sought insight into consumers' existing
understanding of debt collection protections and how consumers would
interact with the forms if they were adopted in a final rule. Specific
findings from the consumer testing are discussed in more detail in part
V where relevant.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\ While the Bureau tested a statement of consumer rights
disclosure, this proposal would not require debt collectors to
provide such a disclosure to consumers. Instead, the Bureau proposes
to require certain debt collectors to provide on the validation
notice a statement referring consumers to a Bureau-provided website
that would describe certain consumer protections in debt collection.
See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(iv). Because the Bureau does not propose to require
debt collectors to provide consumers with a statement of consumer
rights disclosure, the Bureau does not summarize testing related to
that disclosure in this proposal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Validation Notice Testing
Focus groups. FMG facilitated five focus groups in July 2014 to
assess consumers' thoughts about debt collectors and debt collection,
to evaluate their perceptions of disclosures provided by debt
collectors, and to measure their understanding of consumers' rights in
debt collection. Two focus groups, one consisting of participants who
had been contacted by a debt collector within the previous two years
and one consisting of participants without such experience, were held
in Arlington, Virginia, on July 16, 2014. Three focus groups, two
consisting of participants with debt collection experience and one
consisting of participants without debt collection experience, were
held in New Orleans, Louisiana, on July 29, 2014. In conjunction with
the release of this proposal, the Bureau is making available a report
prepared by FMG regarding the focus group testing (FMG Focus Group
Report).\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\ See generally Fors Marsh Grp., Debt Collection Focus Groups
(Aug. 2014), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_debt-collection_fmg-focus-group-report.pdf (hereinafter FMG
Focus Group Report). The focus group testing was conducted in
accordance with OMB control number 3170-0022, Generic Information
Collection Plan for the Development and/or Testing of Model Forms,
Disclosures, Tools, and Other Similar Related Materials.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cognitive Testing. FMG also conducted 30 one-on-one interviews of
consumers to assess their perceptions, preferences, and understanding
of different validation notices and to evaluate how each of the notices
might affect consumer behavior. The interviews took place at three
locations: Arlington, Virginia, on September 23 and 24, 2014;
Minneapolis, Minnesota, on October 9 through 11, 2014; and Las Vegas,
Nevada, on October 23 and 24, 2014. At each location, FMG interviewed
10 participants, seven of whom had debt collection experience and three
of whom did not.
FMG tested three validation notices at each location. The first
form was modeled closely on validation notices commonly used by debt
collectors. The form included the disclosures specifically required by
FDCPA section 809(a), and the language on the form generally mirrored
the statutory language. The second form provided the same information
as the first form, but in plainer language. The third form used the
same language as the second form, along with additional information,
including consumer protection information, chain-of-title information
describing the history of the debt, and, for two of the testing
locations, information about time-barred debts.
FMG asked the participants to define, locate, and explain the
meaning of specific elements on each form. Participants responded to
three surveys, each with three Likert-scale questions.\39\ Participants
were asked to compare the first and second forms side-by-side and were
asked targeted questions about what they would do after reading
individual elements of each notice. In conjunction with the release of
this proposal, the Bureau is making available a report prepared by FMG
regarding the cognitive testing (FMG Cognitive Report).\40\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ A Likert-scale is a commonly used research scale that asks
respondents to specify their level of agreement or disagreement with
a series of statements.
\40\ See generally Fors Marsh Grp., Debt Collection Cognitive
Interviews (n.d.), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_debt-collection_fmg-cognitive-report.pdf (hereinafter FMG
Cognitive Report). The cognitive testing was conducted in accordance
with OMB control number 3170-0022, Generic Information Collection
Plan for the Development and/or Testing of Model Forms, Disclosures,
Tools, and Other Similar Related Materials.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Usability Testing. FMG also conducted 30 additional one-on-one
interviews of consumers to assess their perceptions, preferences, and
understanding of different model validation notices and to evaluate
what influence, if any, these forms could have on their behavior. FMG
interviewed 23 consumers who had been contacted by a debt collector
within the previous two years and seven without such experience. The
interviews took place at three locations: Arlington, Virginia, on March
31 and April 1, 2015; Minneapolis, Minnesota, on April 14 and 15, 2015;
and Las Vegas, Nevada, on April 28 and 29, 2015. During the interviews,
researchers asked participants comprehension questions to determine
their understanding of the forms and debriefing questions to establish
their reactions to and perceptions of the forms. Researchers also
engaged consumers in testing activities to assess their interactions
with the forms. In conjunction with the release of this proposal, the
Bureau is making available a report prepared by FMG regarding the
usability testing (FMG Usability Report).\41\ The Bureau also is making
available a report prepared by FMG summarizing the focus group testing,
cognitive testing, and usability testing (FMG Summary Report).\42\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\ See generally Fors Marsh Grp., Debt Collection User
Experience Study (Feb. 2016), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_debt-collection_fmg-usability-report.pdf (hereinafter
FMG Usability Report). Like the other testing, the usability testing
was conducted in accordance with OMB control number 3170-0022,
Generic Information Collection Plan for the Development and/or
Testing of Model Forms, Disclosures, Tools, and Other Similar
Related Materials.
\42\ See generally Fors Marsh Grp., Debt Collection Validation
Notice Research: Summary of Focus Groups, Cognitive Interviews, and
User Experience Testing (Feb. 2016), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_debt-collection_fmg-summary-report.pdf (hereinafter FMG Summary Report).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quantitative Testing
The Bureau plans to conduct a web survey of 8,000 individuals
possessing a broad range of demographic characteristics. The survey
will explore consumer comprehension and decision-making in response to
sample debt collection disclosures relating to time-
[[Page 23280]]
barred debts. The Bureau will use the information it gathers to help
assess how the Bureau may improve the clarity and effectiveness of debt
collection disclosures, among other things. On February 4, 2019, in
accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995,\43\ the Bureau
proposed an information collection that described the web survey and
was open for public comment for 30 days.\44\ The comment period closed
on March 6, 2019. This request is pending under OMB review and can be
viewed on OMB's electronic docket at https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/PRAViewICR?ref_nbr=201902-3170-001 (see ICR Reference Number 201902-
3170-001). Stakeholders will have an opportunity to comment on a report
describing the web survey results if the Bureau proposes to use those
results to support disclosure requirements in a final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\43\ 44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.
\44\ See Agency Information Collection Activities: Submission
for OMB Review; Comment Request, 84 FR 1430 (Feb. 4, 2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Study of Debt Collection Market Operations
To better understand the operational costs of debt collection
firms, including law firms, the Bureau surveyed debt collection firms
and vendors and published a report based on that study in July 2016
(CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study or Operations Study).\45\ The
answers to the survey questions aided the Bureau's understanding of the
compliance costs to debt collectors if the proposal were finalized. As
a qualitative study, the survey's results are not necessarily
representative of the debt collection industry as a whole, but they
provide a broad understanding of how a range of different types of debt
collectors operate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\45\ See generally Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Study of
Third-Party Debt Collection Operations (July 2016), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/documents/755/20160727_cfpb_Third_Party_Debt_Collection_Operations_Study.pdf
(hereinafter CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Operations Study focused on understanding how debt collection
firms obtain information about delinquent consumer accounts and attempt
to collect on those accounts.\46\ Between July and September 2015, the
Bureau sent a written survey to debt collection firms. The survey
focused on current practices and included questions about employees,
types of debt collected, clients, vendors, software, policies and
procedures for consumer interaction, disputes, furnishing data to CRAs,
litigation, and compliance. Between August and October 2015, the Bureau
conducted telephone interviews with a subset of survey respondents. The
interviews included several specific questions about the types of
voicemails debt collectors leave and what share of lawsuits filed
against consumers end with entry of default judgment, as well as some
open-ended questions about the costs associated with making changes to
collection management systems to address changes in State regulations.
From July to October 2015, the Bureau conducted telephone interviews
with debt collection vendors. A particular focus of these interviews
was collection management systems, including programming and consulting
services provided to system users. The Bureau also asked vendors about
print mail services, predictive dialers, voice analytics, payment
processing, and data services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\ Most respondents collected debt on behalf of clients,
rather than buying debt and collecting on their own behalf.
Respondents that bought some debt reported that the majority of
accounts they collected were for clients. As a result, the
Operations Study did not provide distinct information on debt buyers
and their operations as compared to third-party debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the Bureau constructed the survey sample to ensure
representation of debt collection firms of various sizes, the survey
was not intended to be nationally representative. Nonetheless, the
survey findings generally have informed the Bureau's understanding of
the operations and operating costs of various types of debt collection
firms. Part VI discusses the Bureau's findings from the study in
greater detail.
D. Survey of Consumer Experiences With Debt Collection
The Bureau conducted a survey of consumers' experiences with debt
collection, approved under OMB control number 3170-0047, Debt
Collection Survey from the Consumer Credit Panel, and published a
report of the findings in January 2017 (CFPB Debt Collection Consumer
Survey or Consumer Survey).\47\ Distributed to consumers in December
2014, the survey asked consumers about their experiences with creditors
and debt collectors over the prior year, including disputes and
lawsuits, and how they prefer to communicate with a creditor or debt
collector. The survey also asked for information on each consumer's
demographic characteristics, general financial situation, and credit-
market experiences. The survey sample was selected from the Bureau's
Consumer Credit Panel, which consists of a nationally representative,
de-identified set of credit records maintained by one of the three
nationwide CRAs, and responses were weighted to provide nationally
representative results. The Consumer Survey, which included survey
participants' self-reported responses, provided a more comprehensive
picture of consumers' experiences and preferences related to debt
collection than was previously available.\48\ The Bureau considered
survey responses when developing the proposal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\47\ See generally CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra
note 18.
\48\ Id. at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Consumer Survey describes in detail several key findings
relating to the prevalence of debt collection, the extent to which
consumers dispute debts, and the extent to which creditors or debt
collectors pursue the collection of debts through lawsuits. About one-
third of consumers with a credit file at one of the three nationwide
CRAs reported being contacted by a creditor or debt collector about a
debt in the prior year, and most of those consumers reported being
contacted about two or more debts.\49\ More than one-half of the
consumers who had been contacted about a debt in collection indicated
that at least one of the debts about which they had been contacted was
not theirs or was for the wrong amount. Roughly one-quarter of the
consumers who had been contacted about a debt in collection reported
having disputed a debt with their creditor or debt collector in the
past year.\50\ About one-in-seven consumers (about 15 percent) who had
been contacted about a debt in collection reported having been sued by
a creditor or debt collector in the preceding year.\51\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\ Id. at 13.
\50\ Id. at 24-25.
\51\ Id. at 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Consumer Survey also describes in detail several key findings
related to the frequency with which consumers are contacted about debts
in collection, how often consumers ask debt collectors to stop
contacting them, how consumers prefer to be contacted by debt
collectors, and the frequency with which consumers report negative
experiences with debt collectors. More than one-third of consumers (37
percent) contacted about a debt in collection indicated that the
creditor or debt collector that most recently had contacted them tried
to reach them at least four times per week. Seventeen percent reported
that the creditor or debt collector tried to reach them at least eight
times per week. Close to two-thirds of consumers (63 percent) said
[[Page 23281]]
they were contacted too often by the most recent creditor or debt
collector.\52\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\52\ Id. at 30-31. As discussed further in the Consumer Survey,
consumers' estimates of the frequency of contacts may be subject to
uncertainty because the survey does not purport to distinguish in
its questions or analysis between various factual scenarios.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers contacted at the same frequency by creditors and debt
collectors were more likely to characterize contact by a debt collector
as occurring ``too often'' than when a creditor engaged in the same
frequency of contact. In addition, 42 percent of consumers who reported
they had been contacted about a debt in collection said they had asked
at least one creditor or debt collector to stop contacting them in the
prior year, but only one in four consumers who made this request
reported that the contact stopped. Consumers contacted by debt
collectors were more likely than those contacted by creditors to report
negative experiences, such as being treated impolitely or being
threatened.\53\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\53\ Id. at 34-35, 45-46.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Almost one-half of the consumers (including those who did not
report having been contacted by a creditor or debt collector about a
debt in collection in the prior year) said they would most prefer debt
collectors to contact them by letter. When asked the way they would
least like debt collectors to contact them, consumers most commonly
indicated in-person contacts (20 percent of consumers). Nearly two-
thirds of consumers said it was ``very important'' that others not see
or hear a message from a creditor or debt collector. At the same time,
most consumers also preferred that a creditor or debt collector include
their name and the purpose of the call (i.e., debt collection) in a
voicemail or answering-machine message.\54\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\54\ Id. at 36-38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
E. Small Business Review Panel
In August 2016, the Bureau convened a Small Business Review Panel
(Small Business Review Panel or Panel) with the Chief Counsel for
Advocacy of the Small Business Administration (SBA) and the
Administrator of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs with
the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).\55\ As part of this process,
the Bureau prepared an outline of proposals under consideration and the
alternatives considered (Small Business Review Panel Outline or
Outline),\56\ which the Bureau posted on its website for review by the
small entity representatives participating in the Panel process and by
the general public.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\55\ The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of
1996 (SBREFA), as amended by section 1100G(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act,
requires the Bureau to convene a Small Business Review Panel before
proposing a rule that may have a substantial economic impact on a
significant number of small entities. See Public Law 104-121, tit.
II, 110 Stat. 847, 857 (1996) (as amended by Pub. L. 110-28, section
8302 (2007)).
\56\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Small Business Review Panel
for Debt Collector and Debt Buyer Rulemaking: Outline of Proposals
Under Consideration and Alternatives Considered (July 2016), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/20160727_cfpb_Outline_of_proposals.pdf (hereinafter Small Business
Review Panel Outline). The Bureau also gathered feedback on the
Small Business Review Panel Outline from other stakeholders, members
of the public, and the Bureau's Consumer Advisory Board and
Community Bank Advisory Council.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Panel participated in initial teleconferences with small groups
of the small entity representatives to introduce the Outline and
supporting materials and to obtain feedback. The Panel then conducted a
full-day outreach meeting with the small entity representatives in
August 2016 in Washington, DC. The Panel gathered information from the
small entity representatives and made findings and recommendations
regarding the potential compliance costs and other impacts of the
proposals under consideration on those entities. Those findings and
recommendations are set forth in the Small Business Review Panel
Report, which is part of the administrative record in this rulemaking
and is available to the public.\57\ The Bureau has considered these
findings and recommendations in preparing this proposal and addresses
many of them in greater detail in part V.\58\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\57\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., U.S. Small Bus. Admin., &
Office of Mgmt. & Budget, Final Report of the Small Business Review
Panel on the CFPB's Proposals Under Consideration for the Debt
Collector and Debt Buying Rulemaking (Oct. 2016), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_debt-collector-debt-buyer_SBREFA-report.pdf (hereinafter Small Business Review Panel
Report).
\58\ Certain proposals under consideration in the Small Business
Review Panel Outline and discussed in the Small Business Review
Panel Report are not included in this proposed rule and therefore
are not discussed in part V. For example, because this proposed rule
would apply only to FDCPA-covered debt collectors, the Bureau does
not include a discussion of proposals under consideration that would
have imposed information transfer requirements on first-party
creditors who generally are not FDCPA-covered debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. Legal Authority
The Bureau issues this proposal pursuant to its authority under the
FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank Act. As amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, FDCPA
section 814(d) provides that the Bureau ``may prescribe rules with
respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors,'' as defined in
the FDCPA.\59\ Section 1022(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that
``[t]he Bureau is authorized to exercise its authorities under Federal
consumer financial law to administer, enforce, and otherwise implement
the provisions of Federal consumer financial law.'' \60\ Section
1022(b)(1) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that the Director may
prescribe rules and issue orders and guidance, as may be necessary or
appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry out the
purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws, and to
prevent evasions thereof.\61\ ``Federal consumer financial law''
includes title X of the Dodd-Frank Act and the FDCPA.\62\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\59\ 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d). As noted, the Bureau is the first
Federal agency with authority to prescribe substantive debt
collection rules under the FDCPA. Prior to the Dodd-Frank Act's
grant of authority to the Bureau, the FTC published various
materials providing guidance on the FDCPA. The FTC's materials have
informed the Bureau's rulemaking and, if relevant to particular
proposed provisions, are discussed in part V.
\60\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(a).
\61\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1).
\62\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(12)(H), (14).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These and other authorities are discussed in greater detail in
parts IV.A through E below. Part IV.A discusses how the Bureau proposes
to interpret its authority under sections 806 through 808 of the FDCPA.
Parts IV.B through E discuss the Bureau's relevant authorities under
the Dodd-Frank Act and the Electronic Signatures in Global and National
Commerce Act (E-SIGN Act).
A. FDCPA Sections 806 Through 808
As discussed in part V, the Bureau proposes several provisions, in
whole or in part, pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA sections
806, 807, and 808, which set forth general prohibitions on, and
requirements relating to, debt collectors' conduct and are accompanied
by non-exhaustive lists of examples of unlawful conduct. This section
provides an overview of how the Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA
sections 806 through 808.
FDCPA section 806 generally prohibits a debt collector from
``engag[ing] in any conduct the natural consequence of which is to
harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the collection
of a debt.'' \63\ Then, ``[w]ithout limiting the general application of
the foregoing,'' it lists six examples of conduct that violate that
section.\64\ Similarly, FDCPA section 807 generally prohibits a debt
collector from ``us[ing] any false, deceptive, or misleading
representation or means in connection with the collection of any
debt.'' \65\ Then,
[[Page 23282]]
``[w]ithout limiting the general application of the foregoing,''
section 807 lists 16 examples of conduct that violate that section.\66\
Finally, FDCPA section 808 prohibits a debt collector from ``us[ing]
unfair or unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any
debt.'' \67\ Then, ``[w]ithout limiting the general application of the
foregoing,'' FDCPA section 808 lists eight examples of conduct that
violate that section.\68\ The Bureau interprets FDCPA sections 806
through 808 in light of: (1) The FDCPA's language and purpose; (2) the
general types of conduct prohibited by those sections and, where
relevant, the specific examples enumerated in those sections; and (3)
judicial precedent.\69\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\63\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d.
\64\ Id. at 1692d(1)-(6).
\65\ 15 U.S.C. 1692e.
\66\ Id. at 1692e(1)-(16).
\67\ 15 U.S.C. 1692f.
\68\ Id. at 1692f(1)-(8).
\69\ Where the Bureau proposes requirements pursuant only to its
authority to implement and interpret sections 806 through 808 of the
FDCPA, the Bureau does not take a position on whether such practices
also would constitute an unfair, deceptive, or abusive act or
practice under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act. Where the Bureau
proposes an intervention both pursuant to its authority to implement
and interpret FDCPA sections 806 through 808 and pursuant to its
authority to identify and prevent unfair acts or practices under
Dodd-Frank Act section 1031, the section-by-section analysis
explains why the Bureau proposes to identify the act or practice as
unfair under the Dodd-Frank Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interpreting General Provisions in Light of Specific Prohibitions or
Requirements
By their plain terms, FDCPA sections 806 through 808 make clear
that their examples of prohibited conduct do not ``limit[ ] the general
application'' of those sections' general prohibitions. The FDCPA's
legislative history is consistent with this understanding,\70\ as are
opinions by courts that have addressed this issue.\71\ Accordingly, the
Bureau may prohibit conduct that the specific examples in FDCPA
sections 806 through 808 do not address if the conduct violates the
general prohibitions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\70\ See, e.g., S. Rept. No. 95-382, 95th Cong., 1st Sess. 2, at
4 (1977), reprinted in 1977 U.S.C.C.A.N. 1695, 1698 (hereinafter S.
Rept. No. 382) (``[T]his bill prohibits in general terms any
harassing, unfair, or deceptive collection practice. This will
enable the courts, where appropriate, to proscribe other improper
conduct which is not specifically addressed.''). Courts have also
cited legislative history in noting that, ``in passing the FDCPA,
Congress identified abusive collection attempts as primary
motivations for the Act's passage.'' Hart v. FCI Lender Servs, Inc.,
797 F.3d 219, 226 (2d Cir. 2015).
\71\ See, e.g., Stratton v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 770
F.3d 443, 450 (6th Cir. 2014) (``[T]he listed examples of illegal
acts are just that--examples.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes to use the specific examples in FDCPA sections
806 through 808 to inform its interpretation of those sections' general
prohibitions. Accordingly, the proposal would interpret the general
provisions of FDCPA sections 806 through 808 to prohibit or require
certain conduct that is similar to the types of conduct prohibited or
required by the specific examples. For example, the proposal would
interpret the general provisions in FDCPA sections 806 through 808 as
protecting consumer privacy in debt collection in ways similar to the
specific restrictions in: (1) FDCPA section 806(3), which prohibits,
with certain exceptions, the publication of a list of consumers who
allegedly refuse to pay debts; \72\ (2) FDCPA section 808(7), which
prohibits communicating with a consumer regarding a debt by postcard;
and FDCPA section 808(8), which prohibits the use of certain language
and symbols on envelopes.\73\ The interpretative approach of looking to
specific provisions to inform general provisions is consistent with
judicial precedent indicating that the general prohibitions in the
FDCPA should be interpreted ``in light of [their] associates.'' \74\
For example, courts have held that violating a consumer's privacy
interest through public exposure of a debt violates the FDCPA, noting
that violating a consumer's privacy is a type of conduct prohibited by
several specific examples.\75\ In this way, the Bureau uses the
specific examples in FDCPA sections 806 through 808 to inform its
understanding of the general provisions, consistent with the statute's
use of the phrase ``without limiting the general application of the
foregoing'' to introduce the specific examples.\76\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\72\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d(3).
\73\ 15 U.S.C. 1692f(7)-(8).
\74\ Currier v. First Resolution Inv. Corp., 762 F.3d 529, 534
(6th Cir. 2014) (citing Limited, Inc. v. C.I.R., 286 F.3d 324, 332
(6th Cir. 2002)).
\75\ See id. at 535.
\76\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d-1692f.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Judicial Precedent
The Bureau interprets the general prohibitions in FDCPA sections
806 through 808 in light of the significant body of existing court
decisions interpreting those provisions, which provides instructive
examples of collection practices that are not addressed by the specific
prohibitions in those sections but that nonetheless run afoul of the
FDCPA's general prohibitions in sections 806 through 808.\77\ For
example, courts have held that a debt collector could violate FDCPA
section 808 by using coercive tactics such as citing speculative legal
consequences to pressure the consumer to engage with the debt
collector.\78\ Additionally, courts have held that a debt collector
could violate FDCPA sections 806 through 808 by taking certain actions
to collect a debt that a consumer does not actually owe or that is not
actually delinquent.\79\ Similarly, a debt collector could violate
FDCPA section 807 by, for example, giving ``a false impression of the
character of the debt,'' \80\ such as by failing to disclose that an
amount collected includes fees,\81\ or by failing to disclose that the
applicable statute of limitations has expired.\82\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\77\ This interpretive approach is consistent with courts'
reasoning that these general prohibitions should be interpreted in
light of conduct that courts have already found violate them. See,
e.g., Todd v. Collecto, Inc., 731 F.3d 734, 739 (7th Cir. 2013).
While judicial precedent informs the Bureau's interpretation of the
general prohibitions in FDCPA sections 806 through 808, the Bureau
does not propose to adopt specific judicial interpretations through
its restatement of the general prohibitions except where noted in
the proposal.
\78\ See, e.g., Hosseinzadeh v. M.R.S. Assocs., Inc., 387 F.
Supp. 2d 1104, 1117 (C.D. Cal. 2005) (denying debt collector's
motion for summary judgment on section 808 claim where debt
collector used false name and implied that consumer ``would have
legal problems'' if consumer did not return debt collector's
telephone call).
\79\ See, e.g., Fox v. Citicorp Credit Servs., Inc., 15 F.3d
1507, 1517 (9th Cir. 1994) (reversing grant of summary judgment to
debt collector in part because ``a jury could rationally find'' that
filing writ of garnishment was unfair or unconscionable under
section 808 when debt was not delinquent); Ferrell v. Midland
Funding, LLC, No. 2:15-cv-00126-JHE, 2015 WL 2450615, at *3-4 (N.D.
Ala. May 22, 2015) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss
section 806 claim where debt collector allegedly initiated
collection lawsuit even though it knew plaintiff did not owe debt);
Pittman v. J.J. Mac Intyre Co. of Nev., Inc., 969 F. Supp. 609, 612-
13 (D. Nev. 1997) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss claims
under sections 807 and 808 where debt collector allegedly attempted
to collect fully satisfied debt).
\80\ Fields v. Wilber Law Firm, P.C., 383 F.3d 562, 565-66 (7th
Cir. 2004) (reversing dismissal of plaintiff's claims brought under
sections 807 and 808 because dunning letter that failed to
communicate that total amount due included attorneys' fees ``could
conceivably mislead an unsophisticated consumer'').
\81\ Id.
\82\ See, e.g., Pantoja v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., 852 F.3d
679, 686-87 (7th Cir. 2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several courts have applied an objective standard of an
``unsophisticated'' or ``least sophisticated'' consumer to FDCPA
sections 807 \83\ and 808 \84\ and an
[[Page 23283]]
objective, vulnerable consumer standard to FDCPA section 806.\85\ In
determining whether particular acts violate FDCPA sections 806 through
808, the Bureau interprets those sections to incorporate ``an objective
standard'' that is designed to protect consumers who are ``of below-
average sophistication or intelligence'' or who are ``especially
vulnerable to fraudulent schemes.'' \86\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\83\ See, e.g., Hartman v. Great Seneca Fin. Corp., 569 F.3d
606, 613 (6th Cir. 2009) (applying least sophisticated consumer
standard to section 807 claim); Bentley v. Great Lakes Collection
Bureau, 6 F.3d 60, 62 (2d. Cir. 1993) (same); Swanson v. S. Or.
Credit Serv., Inc., 869 F.2d 1222, 1227 (9th Cir. 1988) (same).
\84\ See, e.g., Crawford v. LVNV Funding, LLC, 758 F.3d 1254,
1258 (11th Cir. 2014) (``[W]e have adopted a `least-sophisticated
consumer standard to evaluate whether a debt collector's conduct is
`deceptive,' `misleading,' `unconscionable,' or `unfair' under the
statute.''); LeBlanc v. Unifund CCR Partners, 601 F.3d 1185, 1200-01
(11th Cir. 2010) (applying least sophisticated consumer standard to
section 808 claim); Turner v. J.V.D.B. & Assocs., Inc., 330 F.3d
991, 997 (7th Cir. 2003) (applying unsophisticated consumer standard
to section 808 claim). Circuit courts have also held, for example,
that the least sophisticated consumer standard applies to a
consumer's understanding of a validation notice required under FDCPA
section 809 and threats to take legal action under FDCPA section
807(5). See Swanson, 869 F.2d at 1225-27; Wilson, 225 F.3d 350, 353
(3d Cir. 2000).
\85\ For example, in Jeter v. Credit Bureau, Inc., 760 F.2d
1168, 1179 (11th Cir. 1985), the court applied a standard analogous
to the ``least sophisticated consumer'' to an FDCPA section 806
claim, holding that claims under section 806 ``should be viewed from
the perspective of a consumer whose circumstances makes him
relatively more susceptible to harassment, oppression, or abuse.''
\86\ See Brief for the United States as Amicus Curiae Supporting
Respondents, Sheriff v. Gillie, 136 S. Ct. 1594 (2016) (No. 15-338),
2016 WL 836755, at * 29 (quoting Gammon v. GC Servs. Ltd. P'ship, 27
F.3d 1254, 1257 (7th Cir. 1994) and Clomon v. Jackson, 988 F.2d
1314, 1319 (2d Cir. 1993)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Courts have reasoned, and the Bureau agrees, that ``[w]hether a
consumer is more or less likely to be harassed, oppressed, or abused by
certain debt collection practices does not relate solely to the
consumer's relative sophistication'' and may be affected by other
circumstances, such as the consumer's financial and legal
resources.\87\ Courts have further reasoned that section 807's
prohibition on false, deceptive, or misleading representations
incorporates an objective, ``unsophisticated'' consumer standard.\88\
This standard ``protects the consumer who is uninformed, naive, or
trusting, yet it admits an objective element of reasonableness.'' \89\
The Bureau agrees with the reasoning of courts that have applied this
standard or a ``least sophisticated consumer'' standard.\90\ The Bureau
proposes to use the term ``unsophisticated'' consumer to describe the
standard it will apply in this proposal when assessing the effect of
conduct on consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\87\ Jeter, 760 F.2d at 1179 (``[R]ather, such susceptibility
might be affected by other circumstances of the consumer or by the
relationship between the consumer and the debt collection agency.
For example, a very intelligent and sophisticated consumer might
well be susceptible to harassment, oppression, or abuse because he
is poor (i.e., has limited access to the legal system), is on
probation, or is otherwise at the mercy of a power relationship.'').
\88\ See Brief for the United States as Amicus Curiae Supporting
Respondents, supra note 86, at *10, 27-30.
\89\ Gammon, 27 F.3d at 1257.
\90\ See, e.g., Rosenau v. Unifund Corp., 539 F.3d 218, 221 (3d
Cir. 2008) (``We use the `least sophisticated debtor' standard in
order to effectuate the basic purpose of the FDCPA: To protect all
consumers, the gullible as well as the shrewd'') (internal quotation
marks and citation omitted); Clomon, 988 F.2d at 1319 (``To serve
the purposes of the consumer-protection laws, courts have attempted
to articulate a standard for evaluating deceptiveness that does not
rely on assumptions about the `average' or `normal' consumer. This
effort is grounded, quite sensibly, in the assumption that consumers
of below-average sophistication or intelligence are especially
vulnerable to fraudulent schemes. The least-sophisticated-consumer
standard protects these consumers in a variety of ways.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FDCPA's Purposes
FDCPA section 802 establishes that the purpose of the statute is to
eliminate abusive debt collection practices by debt collectors, to
ensure that debt collectors who refrain from using abusive debt
collection practices are not competitively disadvantaged, and to
promote consistent State action to protect consumers against debt
collection abuses.\91\ In particular, FDCPA section 802 delineates
certain specific harms that the general and specific prohibitions in
sections 806 through 808 were designed to alleviate. Section 802
states: ``[T]he use of abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection
practices by many debt collectors . . . contribute[s] to the number of
personal bankruptcies, to marital instability, to the loss of jobs, and
to invasions of individual privacy.'' \92\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\91\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
\92\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Dodd-Frank Act Section 1031
Section 1031(b)
Section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides the Bureau with
authority to prescribe rules to identify and prevent unfair, deceptive,
or abusive acts or practices. Specifically, Dodd-Frank Act section
1031(b) authorizes the Bureau to prescribe rules applicable to a
covered person or service provider identifying as unlawful unfair,
deceptive, or abusive acts or practices in connection with any
transaction with a consumer for a consumer financial product or
service, or the offering of a consumer financial product or
service.\93\ Section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act further provides
that ``[r]ules under this section may include requirements for the
purpose of preventing such acts or practices'' \94\ (sometimes referred
to as prevention authority). The Bureau proposes certain provisions
based on its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\93\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(b).
\94\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act is similar to the FTC Act
provisions relating to unfair and deceptive acts or practices.\95\
Given these similarities, where the Bureau relies on Dodd-Frank Act
section 1031(b) authority to support particular provisions, the Bureau
is guided, in part, by case law and Federal agency rulemakings
addressing unfair and deceptive acts or practices under the FTC Act.
For example, case law establishes that, under the FTC Act, the FTC may
impose requirements to prevent acts or practices that the FTC
identifies as unfair or deceptive so long as the preventive
requirements have a reasonable relation to the identified acts or
practices.\96\ Where the Bureau relies on Dodd Frank Act section
1031(b) prevention authority to support particular proposals, the
Bureau explains how the preventive requirements have a reasonable
relation to the identified unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or
practices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\95\ 15 U.S.C. 45.
\96\ See Jacob Siegel Co. v. Fed. Trade Comm'n, 327 U.S. 608,
612-13 (1946) (``The Commission is the expert body to determine what
remedy is necessary to eliminate the unfair or deceptive trade
practices which have been disclosed. It has wide latitude for
judgment and the courts will not interfere except where the remedy
selected has no reasonable relation to the unlawful practices found
to exist.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1031(c)
Section 1031(c)(1) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that the Bureau
shall have no authority under section 1031 to declare an act or
practice in connection with a transaction with a consumer for a
consumer financial product or service, or the offering of a consumer
financial product or service, to be unlawful on the grounds that such
act or practice is unfair, unless the Bureau ``has a reasonable basis''
to conclude that: (A) The act or practice causes or is likely to cause
substantial injury to consumers which is not reasonably avoidable by
consumers; and (B) such substantial injury is not outweighed by
countervailing benefits to consumers or to competition.\97\ Section
1031(c)(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that, in determining whether
an act or practice is unfair, the Bureau may consider established
public policies as evidence to be considered with all other evidence.
Public policy considerations may not serve as a primary basis for such
a determination.\98\ The Bureau proposes certain interventions based in
part on its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\97\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(c)(1).
\98\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The unfairness standard under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)--
requiring primary consideration of the three elements (substantial
injury, not reasonably avoidable by consumers, and
[[Page 23284]]
countervailing benefits to consumers or to competition) and permitting
secondary consideration of public policy--is similar to the unfairness
standard under the FTC Act.\99\ Section 5(n) of the FTC Act was amended
in 1994 to incorporate the principles set forth in the FTC's
``Commission Statement of Policy on the Scope of Unfairness
Jurisdiction,'' \100\ issued on December 17, 1980. The FTC Act
unfairness standard, the FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness,
rulemakings by the FTC and other Federal agencies,\101\ and related
cases \102\ inform the scope and meaning of the Bureau's authority
under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b) to issue rules that identify and
prevent acts or practices that the Bureau determines are unfair
pursuant to Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\99\ Section 5(n) of the FTC Act, as amended in 1994, provides
that, ``The [FTC] shall have no authority . . . to declare unlawful
an act or practice on the grounds that such act or practice is
unfair unless the act or practice causes or is likely to cause
substantial injury to consumers which is not reasonably avoidable by
consumers themselves and not outweighed by countervailing benefits
to consumers or to competition. In determining whether an act or
practice is unfair, the [FTC] may consider established public
policies as evidence to be considered with all other evidence. Such
public policy considerations may not serve as a primary basis for
such determination.'' 15 U.S.C. 45(n).
\100\ Letter from the FTC to Hon. Wendell Ford and Hon. John
Danforth, Committee on Commerce, Science & Transportation, United
States Senate, Commission Statement of Policy on the Scope of
Consumer Unfairness Jurisdiction (Dec. 17, 1980), reprinted in Int'l
Harvester Co., 104 F.T.C. 949, 1070-76 (1984), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/commission_decision_volumes/volume-104/ftc_volume_decision_104__july_-_december_1984pages949_-_1088.pdf
(hereinafter FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness); see also S. Rept.
103-130, at 12-13 (1993), reprinted in 1994 U.S.C.C.A.N. 1776
(legislative history to FTC Act amendments indicating congressional
intent to codify the principles of the FTC Policy Statement on
Unfairness).
\101\ In addition to the FTC's rulemakings under unfairness
authority, certain Federal prudential regulators have prescribed
rules prohibiting unfair practices under section 18(f)(1) of the FTC
Act and, in doing so, they applied the statutory elements consistent
with the standards articulated by the FTC. See 74 FR 5498, 5502
(Jan. 29, 2009) (background discussion of legal authority for
interagency Subprime Credit Card Practices rule). The Board, FDIC,
and the OCC also previously issued guidance generally adopting these
standards for purposes of enforcing the FTC Act's prohibition on
unfair and deceptive acts or practices. See id.
\102\ See, e.g., Consumer Fin. Prot. Bureau v. NDG Fin. Corp.,
No. 15-cv-52110 CM, 2016 WL 7188792 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 2, 2016);
Consumer Fin. Prot. Bureau v. Universal Debt & Payment Sols., LLC,
No. 1:15-CV-00-859 RWS, 2015 WL 11439178 (N.D. Ga. Sept. 1, 2015);
Consumer Fin. Prot. Bureau v. ITT Educ. Servs., Inc., 219 F. Supp.
3d 878 (S.D. Ind. 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Substantial injury. The first element for a determination of
unfairness under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(1) is that the act or
practice causes or is likely to cause substantial injury to consumers.
As discussed above, the FTC Act unfairness standard, the FTC Policy
Statement on Unfairness, rulemakings by the FTC and other Federal
agencies, and related cases inform the meaning of the elements of the
unfairness standard under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(1). The FTC
noted in its Policy Statement on Unfairness that substantial injury
ordinarily involves monetary harm.\103\ The Policy Statement stated
that trivial or speculative harms are not cognizable under the test for
substantial injury.\104\ The FTC also noted that an injury is
``sufficiently substantial'' if it consists of a small amount of harm
to a large number of individuals or raises a significant risk of
harm.\105\ The FTC has found that substantial injury also may involve a
large amount of harm experienced by a small number of individuals.\106\
As described in the FTC Policy Statement, emotional effects from an act
or practice might be a basis for a finding of unfairness in an extreme
case in which tangible injury from the act or practice could be clearly
demonstrated,\107\ and the D.C. Circuit has upheld an FTC conclusion
that the demonstrated effects on consumers from threats to seize
household possessions were sufficient to form part of the substantial
injury along with financial harm.\108\ The Bureau has stated that
emotional impact and other more subjective types of harm ``will not
ordinarily amount to substantial injury'' but that, in certain
circumstances, ``emotional impacts may amount to or contribute to
substantial injury.'' \109\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\103\ See FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness, supra note 100, at
1073.
\104\ Id.
\105\ Id. at 1073 n.12.
\106\ Int'l Harvester Co., 104 F.T.C. 949, 1064 (1984).
\107\ FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness, supra note 100, at
1073 n.16 (``In an extreme case, however, where tangible injury
could be clearly demonstrated, emotional effects might possibly be
considered as the basis for a finding of unfairness'').
\108\ See Am. Fin. Servs. Assoc. v. FTC, 767 F.2d 957, 973-74
n.20 (D.C. Cir. 1985) (``the Commission found that `the threat to
seize household possessions causes `great emotional suffering,
humiliation, anxiety, and deep feelings of guilt, and this distress
can lead to physical breakdowns or illness, disruption of the
family, and undue strain on family relationships' '') (internal
citations omitted).
\109\ Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., CFPB Supervision and
Examination Process, at UDAAP 2 (Apr. 2019), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_supervision-and-examination-manual.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Not reasonably avoidable. The second element for a determination of
unfairness under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(1) is that the
substantial injury is not reasonably avoidable by consumers. As
discussed above, the FTC Act unfairness standard, the FTC Policy
Statement on Unfairness, rulemakings by the FTC and other Federal
agencies, and related case law inform the meaning of the elements of
the unfairness standard under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(1). The
FTC stated that knowing the steps for avoiding injury is not enough for
the injury to be reasonably avoidable; rather, the consumer must also
understand and appreciate the necessity of taking those steps.\110\ As
the FTC explained in its Policy Statement on Unfairness, most
unfairness matters are brought to ``halt some form of seller behavior
that unreasonably creates or takes advantage of an obstacle to the free
exercise of consumer decisionmaking.'' \111\ The D.C. Circuit has noted
that, if such behavior exists, there is a ``market failure'' and the
agency ``may be required to take corrective action.'' \112\ Assessing
whether an injury is reasonably avoidable also requires taking into
account the costs of making a choice other than the one made and the
availability of alternatives in the marketplace.\113\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\110\ See Int'l Harvester, 104 F.T.C. at 1066.
\111\ FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness, supra note 100, at
1074.
\112\ Am. Fin. Servs. Assoc., 767 F.2d at 976.
\113\ See FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness, supra note 100, at
1074 n.19 (``In some senses any injury can be avoided--for example,
by hiring independent experts to test all products in advance, or by
private legal actions for damages--but these courses may be too
expensive to be practicable for individual consumers to pursue.'');
Am. Fin. Servs. Assoc., 767 F.2d at 976-77 (reasoning that, because
of factors such as substantial similarity of contracts offered by
creditors, ``consumers have little ability or incentive to shop for
a better contract'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Countervailing benefits to consumers or competition. The third
element for a determination of unfairness under Dodd-Frank Act section
1031(c)(1) is that the act or practice's countervailing benefits to
consumers or to competition do not outweigh the substantial consumer
injury. As discussed above, the FTC Act unfairness standard, the FTC
Policy Statement on Unfairness, rulemakings by the FTC and other
Federal agencies, and related cases inform the meaning of the elements
of the unfairness standard under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(1). In
applying the FTC Act's unfairness standard, the FTC has stated that it
generally is important to consider both the costs of imposing a remedy
and any benefits that consumers receive as a result of the act or
practice. Authorities addressing the FTC Act's unfairness standard
indicate that the countervailing benefits test does not require a
precise quantitative analysis of benefits and costs, as such an
analysis may be unnecessary or, in some cases,
[[Page 23285]]
impossible; rather, the agency is expected to gather and consider
reasonably available evidence.\114\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\114\ Pa. Funeral Dirs. Ass'n v. FTC, 41 F.3d 81, 91 (3d Cir.
1994) (upholding FTC's amendments to the Funeral Industry Practices
Rule and noting that ``much of a cost-benefit analysis requires
predictions and speculation''); Int'l Harvester, 104 F.T.C. at 1065
n.59 (``In making these calculations we do not strive for an
unrealistic degree of precision. . . . We assess the matter in a
more general way, giving consumers the benefit of the doubt in close
issues. . . . What is important . . . is that we retain an overall
sense of the relationship between costs and benefits. We would not
want to impose compliance costs of millions of dollars in order to
prevent a bruised elbow.''); see also S. Rept. 103-130, at 13 (1994)
(noting that, ``[i]n determining whether a substantial consumer
injury is outweighed by the countervailing benefits of a practice,
the Committee does not intend that the FTC quantify the detrimental
and beneficial effects of the practice in every case. In many
instances, such a numerical benefit-cost analysis would be
unnecessary; in other cases, it may be impossible. This section
would require, however, that the FTC carefully evaluate the benefits
and costs of each exercise of its unfairness authority, gathering
and considering reasonably available evidence.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Public policy. As noted above, Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c)(2)
provides that, in determining whether an act or practice is unfair, the
Bureau may consider established public policies as evidence to be
considered with all other evidence. Public policy considerations,
however, may not serve as a primary basis for such a
determination.\115\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\115\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Dodd-Frank Act Section 1032
The Bureau proposes certain provisions based in part on its
authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032. Dodd-Frank Act section
1032(a) provides that the Bureau may prescribe rules to ensure that the
features of any consumer financial product or service, ``both initially
and over the term of the product or service,'' are ``fully, accurately,
and effectively disclosed to consumers in a manner that permits
consumers to understand the costs, benefits, and risks associated with
the product or service, in light of the facts and circumstances.''
\116\ Under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau is empowered to
prescribe rules regarding the disclosure of the ``features'' of
consumer financial products and services generally. Accordingly, the
Bureau may prescribe rules containing disclosure requirements even if
other Federal consumer financial laws do not specifically require
disclosure of such features.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\116\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(b)(1) provides that ``any final rule
prescribed by the Bureau under this section requiring disclosures may
include a model form that may be used at the option of the covered
person for provision of the required disclosures.'' \117\ Dodd-Frank
Act section 1032(b)(2) provides that such a model form ``shall contain
a clear and conspicuous disclosure that at a minimum--(A) uses plain
language comprehensible to consumers; (B) contains a clear format and
design, such as an easily readable type font; and (C) succinctly
explains the information that must be communicated to the consumer.''
\118\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(b)(3) provides that any such model
form ``shall be validated through consumer testing.''; \119\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\117\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(b)(1).
\118\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(b)(2).
\119\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(c) provides that, in prescribing rules
pursuant to Dodd-Frank Act section 1032, the Bureau ``shall consider
available evidence about consumer awareness, understanding of, and
responses to disclosures or communications about the risks, costs, and
benefits of consumer financial products or services.'' \120\ Dodd-Frank
Act section 1032(d) provides that ``[a]ny covered person that uses a
model form included with a rule issued under this section shall be
deemed to be in compliance with the disclosure requirements of this
section with respect to such model form.'' \121\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\120\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(c).
\121\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Other Authorities Under the Dodd-Frank Act
The Bureau proposes certain interventions based in part on its
authority under Dodd-Frank Act sections 1022 and 1024. Section
1022(b)(1) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that the Bureau's Director
``may prescribe rules and issue orders and guidance, as may be
necessary or appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry
out the purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws,
and to prevent evasions thereof.'' \122\ ``Federal consumer financial
laws'' include the FDCPA and title X of the Dodd-Frank Act.\123\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\122\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1).
\123\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(14).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1022(b)(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act prescribes certain
standards for rulemaking that the Bureau must follow in exercising its
authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1).\124\ See part VI for
a discussion of the Bureau's standards for rulemaking under Dodd-Frank
Act section 1022(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\124\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.100 concerning the retention of records would
be based in part on the Bureau's authority under Dodd-Frank Act section
1024(b)(7)(A) and (B) \125\ as applied to debt collectors who are
nondepository covered persons that the Bureau supervises under Dodd-
Frank Act section 1024(a).\126\ The section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.100 contains an additional description of the
authorities on which the Bureau relies for proposed Sec. 1006.100.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\125\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1024(b)(7)(A) authorizes the Bureau
to prescribe rules to facilitate supervision of persons identified
as larger participants of a market for a consumer financial product
or service as defined by rule in accordance with section
1024(a)(1)(B) of the Dodd-Frank Act, and Dodd-Frank Act section
1024(b)(7)(B) authorizes the Bureau to require a person described in
Dodd-Frank Act section 1024(a)(1) to retain records for the purpose
of facilitating supervision of such persons and assessing and
detecting risks to consumers.
\126\ 12 U.S.C. 5514(b)(7)(A)-(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
E. The E-SIGN Act
The E-SIGN Act provides standards for determining if delivery of a
disclosure by electronic record satisfies a requirement in a statute,
regulation, or other rule of law that the disclosure be provided or
made available to a consumer in writing. The E-SIGN Act sets forth
criteria under which Federal regulatory agencies may exempt a specified
category or type of record from the consent requirements for electronic
disclosures in the E-SIGN Act.\127\ For the reasons set forth in part
V, proposed Sec. 1006.42(c) and (d) would exempt electronic delivery
of certain required notices from the consent requirements of the E-SIGN
Act. Pursuant to E-SIGN Act section 104(b)(1), which permits the Bureau
to interpret the E-SIGN Act through the issuance of regulations,
proposed comments 6(c)(1)-1 and -2 provide an interpretation of the E-
SIGN Act as applied to a debt collector responding to a consumer's
notification that the consumer refuses to pay the debt or wants the
debt collector to cease communication; proposed comments 38-2 and -3
provide an interpretation of the E-SIGN Act as applied to a debt
collector responding to a consumer dispute or request for original-
creditor information; and proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) and proposed
comment 42(b)(1)-1 provide an interpretation of the E-SIGN Act as
applied to certain disclosures that the regulation would require debt
collectors to provide.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\127\ 15 U.S.C. 7004(d)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23286]]
V. Section-by-Section Analysis
Subpart A--General
Section 1006.1 Authority, Purpose, and Coverage
1(a) Authority
FDCPA section 817 provides that the Bureau shall by regulation
exempt from the requirements of the FDCPA any class of debt collection
practices within any State if the Bureau determines that certain
conditions have been met.\128\ Before the Bureau's creation, FDCPA
section 817 provided the same authority to the FTC, and the FTC issued
a rule to describe procedures for a State to apply for such an
exemption.\129\ After the Dodd-Frank Act granted the Bureau FDCPA
rulewriting authority, the Bureau restated the FTC's existing rule
regarding State exemptions without substantive change as the Bureau's
Regulation F, 12 CFR part 1006.\130\ Existing Sec. 1006.1(a) thus
states that the purpose of Regulation F is to establish procedures and
criteria for States to apply to the Bureau for an exemption as provided
in FDCPA section 817.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\128\ 15 U.S.C. 1692o.
\129\ See 16 CFR part 901.
\130\ 76 FR 78121 (Dec. 16, 2011).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with the Bureau's proposal to revise part 1006 to
regulate the debt collection activities of FDCPA-covered debt
collectors, the Bureau proposes to revise existing Sec. 1006.1(a) to
set forth the Bureau's authority to issue such rules. Proposed Sec.
1006.1(a) provides that part 1006 is known as Regulation F and is
issued by the Bureau pursuant to sections 814(d) and 817 of the
FDCPA,\131\ title X of the Dodd-Frank Act,\132\ and section 104(b)(1)
and (d)(1) of the E-SIGN Act.\133\ The Bureau proposes to move the
remainder of existing Sec. 1006.1(a), regarding State-law exemptions
from the FDCPA, to paragraph I(a) of appendix A of the regulation.\134\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\131\ 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d), 1692o.
\132\ 12 U.S.C. 5481 et seq.
\133\ 15 U.S.C. 7004(b)(1), 7004(d)(1).
\134\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.108 and appendix A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1(b) Purpose
Existing Sec. 1006.1(b) defines terms relevant to the procedures
and criteria for States to apply to the Bureau for an exemption as
provided in FDCPA section 817. Consistent with the Bureau's proposal to
revise part 1006 to regulate the debt collection activities of FDCPA-
covered debt collectors, the Bureau proposes to revise Sec. 1006.1(b)
to identify the purposes of part 1006. The Bureau proposes to move the
definitions in existing Sec. 1006.1(b) to paragraph 1(b) of appendix A
of the regulation.\135\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\135\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with FDCPA section 802, proposed Sec. 1006.1(b)
explains that part 1006 carries out the purposes of the FDCPA, which
include eliminating abusive debt collection practices by debt
collectors, ensuring that debt collectors who refrain from using
abusive debt collection practices are not competitively disadvantaged,
and promoting consistent State action to protect consumers against debt
collection abuses. Consistent with Dodd-Frank Act section 1032,
proposed Sec. 1006.1(b) further explains that part 1006 also
prescribes requirements to ensure that certain features of debt
collection are fully, accurately, and effectively disclosed to
consumers in a manner that permits consumers to understand the costs,
benefits, and risks associated with debt collection, in light of the
facts and circumstances. Finally, consistent with Dodd-Frank Act
sections 1022(b)(1) and 1024(b)(7), proposed Sec. 1006.1(b) explains
that part 1006 sets forth record retention requirements to enable the
Bureau to administer and carry out the purposes of the FDCPA and the
Dodd-Frank Act and to prevent evasions thereof, and to facilitate
supervision of debt collectors and the assessment and detection of
risks to consumers.
1(c) Coverage
The Bureau proposes to add Sec. 1006.1(c) to address coverage
under the proposed rule, which, with the exception of proposed Sec.
1006.108 and appendix A, would apply to FDCPA-covered debt
collectors.\136\ Proposed Sec. 1006.1(c)(1) thus provides that, except
as provided in Sec. 1006.108 and appendix A regarding applications for
State exemptions from the FDCPA, proposed part 1006 applies to debt
collectors as defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(i), i.e., debt
collectors covered by the FDCPA.\137\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\136\ Proposed Sec. 1006.108 and appendix A would apply to
States.
\137\ Section 812 of the FDCPA addresses the furnishing of
deceptive forms and applies to any person, not just to debt
collectors. Proposed 1006.30(e) would prohibit FDCPA-covered debt
collectors from furnishing deceptive forms. Other persons would
continue to be prohibited from furnishing deceptive forms under
FDCPA section 812.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.1(c)(1) also would implement FDCPA section
814(d), which provides, in part, that the Bureau may not prescribe
rules under the FDCPA with respect to motor vehicle dealers as
described in section 1029(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act.\138\ Proposed Sec.
1006.1(c)(1) would clarify that Regulation F would not apply to a
person excluded from coverage by section 1029(a) of the Dodd-Frank
Act.\139\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\138\ 12 U.S.C. 5519(a).
\139\ This proposed exclusion would apply only to Regulation F.
Any motor vehicle dealers who are FDCPA-covered debt collectors
would still need to comply with the FDCPA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes certain provisions of the proposed rule only
under sections 1031 or 1032 of the Dodd-Frank Act. Dodd-Frank Act
section 1031 grants the Bureau authority to write regulations
applicable to covered persons and service providers to identify and
prevent unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices in connection
with a transaction with a consumer for, or the offering of, a consumer
financial product or service.\140\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1032 grants
the Bureau authority to ensure that the features of any consumer
financial product or service are fully, accurately, and effectively
disclosed to consumers.\141\ Under the Dodd-Frank Act, collecting a
debt related to any consumer financial product or service generally is,
itself, a consumer financial product or service.\142\ Of primary
relevance here, a consumer financial product or service includes the
extension of consumer credit.\143\ Provisions proposed only under Dodd-
Frank Act sections 1031 or 1032, if adopted, therefore would apply to
FDCPA-covered debt collectors only to the extent that such debt
collectors were collecting a debt related to an extension of consumer
credit or another consumer financial product or service.\144\ This
would include, for example, FDCPA-covered debt collectors collecting
debts related to consumer mortgage loans or credit cards.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\140\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(b).
\141\ 12 U.S.C. 5532.
\142\ It is a financial product or service and is a consumer
financial product or service if, for example, it is delivered
offered, or provided in connection with a consumer financial product
or service. See 12 U.S.C. 5481(5)(B), 5481(15)(A)(x).
\143\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(15)(A)(i). The Dodd-Frank Act defines
credit to mean the right granted by a person to a consumer to defer
payment of a debt, incur debt and defer its payment, or purchase
property or services and defer payment for such purchase. 12 U.S.C.
5481(7).
\144\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.1(c)(2) would clarify that certain provisions
in proposed Regulation F apply to FDCPA-covered debt collectors only
when they are collecting consumer financial product or service debt, as
defined in Sec. 1006.2(f).\145\ Proposed Sec. 1006.1(c)(2) specifies
that these provisions are Sec. Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii),
1006.30(b)(1)(ii),
[[Page 23287]]
and 1006.34(c)(2)(iv) and (3)(iv). The Bureau requests comment on all
aspects of proposed Sec. 1006.1(c), including on whether additional
clarification would be helpful.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\145\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.2 Definitions
FDCPA section 803 defines terms used throughout the statute.\146\
Proposed Sec. 1006.2 would repurpose existing Sec. 1006.2 to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 803 and define additional terms
that would be used in the regulation.\147\ The Bureau proposes to move
existing Sec. 1006.2, which describes how a State may apply for an
exemption from the FDCPA, to paragraph II of appendix A of the
regulation.\148\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\146\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a.
\147\ FDCPA section 803(7) defines the term ``location
information.'' 15 U.S.C. 1692a(7). The Bureau proposes to define
that term in Sec. 1006.10, rather than in Sec. 1006.2. See the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.10(a).
\148\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.108 and appendix A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Paragraphs (c), (g), and (l) of proposed Sec. 1006.2 would
implement the FDCPA section 803 definitions of Bureau, creditor, and
State, respectively. These paragraphs generally restate the statute,
with only minor wording and organizational changes for clarity, and
thus are not addressed further in the section-by-section analysis
below. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(a) and (b), (d) through (f), and (h)
through (k) would define other terms that would be used in the
regulation, as described below. The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.2 to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 803, pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors. In addition to the specific
comment requests noted below, the Bureau generally requests comment on
whether additional clarification is needed for any of the proposed
definitions and on whether additional definitions would be helpful. For
example, the proposal uses the term ``day'' to refer to any day,
including weekends and public holidays. The Bureau requests comment on
whether adding a defined term such as ``calendar day'' and using it in
the final rule would be helpful.
2(a) Act or FDCPA
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(a) provides that the terms Act and FDCPA mean
the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.
2(b) Attempt To Communicate
Several of the proposed rule's requirements would apply not only to
communications as defined in Sec. 1006.2(d) but also to communication
attempts. For example, proposed Sec. 1006.6(b) and (c) would, among
other things, prohibit a debt collector from communicating or
attempting to communicate with a consumer at times or places that the
debt collector knows or should know are inconvenient to the consumer or
after a consumer notifies the debt collector in writing that the
consumer wishes the debt collector to cease further communication with
the consumer. In addition, proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) and (4) would
generally prohibit a debt collector from communicating or attempting to
communicate with a consumer using an email address that the debt
collector knows or should know is maintained by the consumer's employer
or by a social media platform that is viewable by a person other than
the consumer.
To facilitate compliance with the proposed provisions that apply to
attempts to communicate, proposed Sec. 1006.2(b) would define an
attempt to communicate as any act to initiate a communication or other
contact with any person through any medium, including by soliciting a
response from such person. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(b) further states that
an attempt to communicate includes providing a limited-content message,
as defined in Sec. 1006.2(j). The Bureau proposes this definition of
attempt to communicate on the basis that any outreach by a debt
collector to a consumer--whether by a telephone call, text message,
email, or otherwise--is designed to bring about a communication either
immediately (e.g., a consumer answers a debt collector's telephone call
and they engage in a conversation about the debt) or at a later point
in time (e.g., in response to a missed telephone call or a limited-
content message from a debt collector, a consumer calls or texts the
debt collector and they engage in a conversation about the debt).
As proposed, an attempt to communicate covers a broader range of
activity than a communication. As discussed in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(d), the proposed rule would define a
communication, consistent with FDCPA section 803(2), as the conveying
of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person
through any medium. The proposed definition of communication further
states that a debt collector does not convey information regarding a
debt directly or indirectly to any person if the debt collector
provides only a limited-content message, as defined in proposed Sec.
1006.2(j). The proposed definition of attempt to communicate, in
contrast, does not require the conveying of information regarding a
debt. As the examples in proposed comment 2(b)-1 illustrate, an attempt
to communicate includes leaving a limited-content message for a
consumer or placing a telephone call to a person, regardless of whether
the debt collector speaks to any person or leaves any message at the
dialed number. Proposed comment 2(b)-1 also would clarify that an act
to initiate a communication or other contact with a person is an
attempt to communicate regardless of whether the attempt, if
successful, would be a communication that conveys information regarding
a debt directly or indirectly to any person.
Although the proposed definition of attempt to communicate covers a
broader range of conduct than the proposed definition of communication,
in many circumstances the same conduct may give rise to both an attempt
to communicate and a communication. For example, a debt collector who
places a telephone call to a consumer and speaks to the consumer about
the debt has both attempted to communicate with the consumer (by
initiating the call and speaking to the consumer) and communicated with
the consumer (by conveying information about the debt). Sometimes,
however, an attempt to communicate may not give rise to a
communication. For example, a debt collector who places an unanswered
telephone call to a consumer and chooses not to leave a message has
attempted to communicate with the consumer but has not communicated
with the consumer. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.2(b) and on proposed comment 2(b)-1.
2(d) Communicate or Communication
FDCPA section 803(2) defines the term communication to mean the
conveying of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any
person through any medium.\149\ Proposed Sec. 1006.2(d) would
implement and interpret this definition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\149\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(d) first restates the statutory definition of
communication, with only minor changes for clarity. Proposed Sec.
1006.2(d) also would interpret FDCPA section 803(2) to provide that a
debt collector does not convey information regarding a debt directly or
indirectly to any person--and therefore does not communicate with any
person--if the debt collector provides only a limited-content message,
as defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(j). The section-by-section analysis
of proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)
[[Page 23288]]
regarding limited-content messages explains and requests comment both
on the proposed content of limited-content messages and on the Bureau's
proposal to interpret the term communication in Sec. 1006.2(d) as
excluding such messages.
Proposed comment 2(d)-1 notes that a communication can occur
through ``any medium'' and explains that ``any medium'' includes any
oral, written, electronic, or other medium. The proposed comment states
that a communication may occur, for example, in person or by telephone,
audio recording, paper document, mail, email, text message, social
media, or other electronic media. The Bureau proposes comment 2(d)-1 in
part to clarify that debt collectors may communicate with consumers
through newer communication media, such as electronic media. The Bureau
elsewhere proposes provisions to clarify how debt collectors may use
those media to communicate with consumers. The Bureau requests comment
on proposed Sec. 1006.2(d) and on proposed comment 2(d)-1 and on
whether additional clarification about the definition of communication
would be useful.
2(e) Consumer
FDCPA section 803(3) defines a consumer as any natural person
obligated or allegedly obligated to pay any debt.\150\ Proposed Sec.
1006.2(e) would implement this definition, interpret it to include a
deceased natural person who is obligated or allegedly obligated to pay
a debt, and cross-reference the special definition of consumer for
certain communications in connection with the collection of a debt set
forth in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\150\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As summarized in part I.B, the Bureau proposes to address several
consumer protection concerns and ambiguities in statutory language
related to the collection of debts owed by deceased consumers, also
known as decedent debt. One such issue is that the FDCPA does not
specify whether a consumer, as defined in section 803(3), includes a
deceased consumer (or whether a natural person, as that term is used in
section 803(3), includes a deceased natural person). Because the
definition of consumer in FDCPA section 803(3) is silent with respect
to deceased consumers, debt collectors may be uncertain, when
collecting a deceased consumer's debts, how to comply with FDCPA
provisions that refer to a debt collector's obligations to a consumer.
For example, certain important FDCPA disclosure requirements, such
as a debt collector's obligation to provide a validation notice and to
respond to disputes and requests for original-creditor information,
refer only to a debt collector's obligations to consumers.\151\ In the
absence of guidance, debt collectors may be uncertain who, if anyone,
should receive the validation notice and have the right to dispute the
debt if the consumer obligated or allegedly obligated to pay the debt
is deceased. Without a validation notice and an opportunity to dispute
the debt, individuals trying to resolve debts in a deceased consumer's
estate may experience difficulty because they lack information needed
to determine whether they are being asked to pay the right debt, in the
right amount, to the right debt collector, and to assert dispute
rights. To address that concern, the Bureau proposes to clarify in the
commentary to Sec. Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) and 1006.38 that a person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate, such as
the executor, administrator, or personal representative, operates as
the consumer for purposes of proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) and
1006.38.\152\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\151\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a)-(b).
\152\ See proposed comments 34(a)(1)-1, 34(d)(1)(ii)-2, and 38-
1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with those proposed clarifications, the Bureau proposes
in Sec. 1006.2(e) to interpret the definition of consumer in FDCPA
section 803(3) to mean any natural person, whether living or deceased,
who is obligated or allegedly obligated to pay any debt. The proposed
interpretation should clarify the meaning of the term consumer in the
decedent debt context and appears to be consistent with a modern trend
in the law that favors recognizing, as a default, the continued
existence of a natural person after death.\153\ Further, the Bureau
notes that debt collectors often collect or attempt to collect debts
from deceased consumers (i.e., from their estates), which presents many
of the same consumer-protection concerns as collecting or attempting to
collect debts from living consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\153\ See, e.g., Cal. Civ. Proc. Code sec. 377.20(a) (2018)
(``Except as otherwise provided by statute, a cause of action for or
against a person is not lost by reason of the person's death, but
survives subject to the applicable limitations period.''). Federal
law often provides an unclear answer about whether claims survive
the death of a natural person. Rule 25(a) of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure allows substitution ``[i]f a party dies and the
claim is not extinguished,'' but Federal statutes often do not
address whether claims extinguish upon the death of a plaintiff or
defendant and, in these cases, Federal common law generally permits
survival of claims where they are merely remedial in nature and not
penal. See Ex parte Schreiber, 110 U.S. 76, 80 (1884). Most
authority suggests that claims brought under other portions of the
Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA), of which the FDCPA is
subchapter V, likely are remedial rather than penal in nature. See,
e.g., Murphy v. Household Fin. Corp., 560 F.2d 206, 210 (6th Cir.
1977) (holding, in a widely adopted test, that double damages under
Truth in Lending Act (TILA), subchapter I of the CCPA, are remedial
rather than penal); In re Wood, 643 F.2d 188, 192 (5th Cir. 1980)
(following Murphy to conclude that trustee of debtor's estate had
standing to bring claims under TILA). On the other hand, some
courts, for example, follow the tradition of the common law and
treat a ``natural person'' as ceasing to exist at the point of
death. See, e.g., Williamson v. Treasurer, 814 A.2d 1153, 1164 (N.J.
Super. Ct. App. Div. 2003) (``We would not describe the body or
remains of a deceased person as still a human being or a natural
person.'' (interpreting the New Jersey Right to Know law and citing
Natural person, Black's Law Dictionary (7th ed. 1999))). In light of
the conflicting traditions and the FDCPA's silence, it appears
appropriate to regard the statutory term ``consumer'' as ambiguous
as to whether it includes or excludes a deceased consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to proposing to clarify the meaning of the term
consumer in the decedent debt context, the Bureau proposes in Sec.
1006.2(e) to cross-reference the special definition of consumer for
certain communications in connection with the collection of a debt in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(a). As described in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6, FDCPA section 805(d) identifies
certain persons in addition to the section 803(3) consumer as persons
with whom a debt collector may communicate in connection with the
collection of any debt without violating FDCPA section 805(b)'s
prohibition on third-party disclosures.\154\ The Bureau proposes to
implement FDCPA section 805(d) in Sec. 1006.6(a) and to cross-
reference the Sec. 1006.6(a) definition in proposed Sec. 1006.14(h).
As discussed below, proposed Sec. 1006.14(h) would prohibit a debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with a
consumer through a medium of communication if the consumer has
requested that the debt collector not use that medium to communicate
with the consumer. Accordingly, proposed Sec. 1006.2(e) provides that,
for purposes of proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.6 and 1006.14(h), the term
consumer has the meaning given to it in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a). For
further discussion, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.6(a). The Bureau requests comment on the definition of
consumer in proposed Sec. 1006.2(e), including on whether the
definition should include deceased consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\154\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2(f) Consumer Financial Product or Service Debt
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.1(c), certain proposed provisions would apply to debt collectors
only if they are collecting a debt related to a consumer
[[Page 23289]]
financial product or service, as that term is defined in section
1002(5) of the Dodd-Frank Act.\155\ Debt related to a consumer
financial product or service would include, for example, debts related
to consumer mortgage loans or credit cards. For ease of reference,
proposed Sec. 1006.2(f) would define the term consumer financial
product or service debt to mean a debt related to a consumer financial
product or service, as consumer financial product or service is defined
in section 1002(5) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\155\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(5). See the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.1(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2(h) Debt
FDCPA section 803(5) defines the term debt for purposes of the
FDCPA. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(h) would implement FDCPA section 803(5)
and generally restates the statute. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(h) also would
clarify that, for purposes of Sec. 1006.2(f), the term debt means debt
as that term is used in the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau proposes this
clarification to ensure that, when determining whether a debt is a debt
related to a consumer financial product or service for purposes of
Sec. 1006.2(f), debt collectors and other stakeholders refer to the
Dodd-Frank Act rather than the FDCPA's definition of debt.
2(i) Debt Collector
FDCPA section 803(6) defines the term debt collector for purposes
of the FDCPA. The introductory language of FDCPA section 803(6)
generally provides that a debt collector is any person: (1) Who uses
any instrumentality of interstate commerce or the mails in any business
the principal purpose of which is the collection of any debts (i.e.,
the ``principal purpose'' prong), or (2) who regularly collects, or
attempts to collect, directly or indirectly, debts owed or due or
asserted to be owed or due to another (i.e., the ``regularly collects''
prong).\156\ FDCPA section 803(6) also sets forth several exclusions
from the general definition.\157\ Proposed Sec. 1006.2(i) would
implement FDCPA section 803(6)'s definition of debt collector and
generally restates the statute, with only minor wording and
organizational changes for clarity \158\ and to specify that the term
excludes private entities that operate certain bad check enforcement
programs that comply with FDCPA section 818.\159\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\156\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a(6).
\157\ Id.
\158\ For example, to avoid obsolete language, proposed Sec.
1006.2(i) uses the term ``mail'' instead of ``the mails.''
\159\ 15 U.S.C. 1692p.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Supreme Court recently has interpreted FDCPA section 803(6). In
Henson v. Santander Consumer USA Inc., the Court held that a company
may collect defaulted debts that it has purchased from another without
being an FDCPA-covered debt collector.\160\ In so holding, the Court
decided only whether, by using its own name to collect debts that it
had purchased, Santander met the ``regularly collects'' prong of the
introductory language in FDCPA section 803(6). The Court expressly
declined to address two other ways that a debt buyer like Santander
might qualify as a debt collector under FDCPA section 803(6): (1) By
meeting the ``regularly collects'' prong by regularly collecting or
attempting to collect debts owned by others, in addition to collecting
debts that it purchased and owned; or (2) by meeting the ``principal
purpose'' prong of the definition.\161\ The Court held that Santander
was not a debt collector within the meaning of the ``regularly
collects'' prong because Santander was collecting debts that it
purchased and owned, not collecting debts owed to another.\162\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\160\ Henson v. Santander Consumer USA, Inc., 137 S. Ct. 1718
(2017). In addition to Henson, the Supreme Court also recently
interpreted FDCPA section 803(6) to hold that a business engaged in
no more than nonjudicial foreclosure proceedings is not an FDCPA-
covered debt collector, except for the limited purpose of FDCPA
section 808(6). See Obduskey v. McCarthy & Holthus LLP, 139 S. Ct.
1029 (2019).
\161\ Henson, 137 S. Ct. at 1721. The Court had not identified
these questions as being presented when it granted certiorari. Id.
\162\ Id. at 1721-22.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(i) generally would restate FDCPA section
803(6)'s definition of debt collector. Consistent with the Court's
holding in Henson, the proposed definition thus could include a debt
buyer collecting debts that it purchased and owned, if the debt buyer
either met the ``principal purpose'' prong of the definition or
regularly collected or attempted to collect debts owned by others, in
addition to collecting debts that it purchased and owned.\163\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\163\ See, e.g., Barbato v. Greystone Alliance, LLC, 916 F.3d
260 (3d Cir. 2019) (holding that a debt buyer whose principal
purpose was debt collection was an FDCPA-covered debt collector even
though the debt buyer outsourced its collection activities to third
parties).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2(j) Limited-Content Message
FDCPA section 803(2) defines the term communication to mean the
conveying of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any
person through any medium.\164\ As discussed, proposed Sec. 1006.2(d)
would implement and interpret that definition, including by specifying
that a debt collector does not engage in an FDCPA communication if the
debt collector provides only a limited-content message.\165\ Proposed
Sec. 1006.2(j) would further interpret FDCPA section 803(2) by
defining the content that a limited-content message would be required
and permitted to include. For the reasons discussed below, under the
Bureau's interpretation of the term communication, a limited-content
message would not convey information about a debt directly or
indirectly to any person, and, as a result, a debt collector could
provide such a message for a consumer without communicating with any
person for the purposes of the FDCPA or Regulation F.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\164\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a(2).
\165\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The definition of communication is central to the FDCPA's
protections, many of which regulate a debt collector's communications
with a consumer or other person. For example, FDCPA section 805 \166\
restricts when and where a debt collector may communicate with a
consumer, FDCPA sections 806 through 808 \167\ contain requirements
concerning the form and content of a debt collector's communications
with a consumer or other person, and FDCPA section 804 \168\ imposes
requirements on a debt collector communicating with any person other
than the consumer for the purpose of acquiring location information
about the consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\166\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c.
\167\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d-1692f.
\168\ 15 U.S.C. 1692b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Uncertainty about what constitutes a communication, however, has
led to questions about how debt collectors can leave voicemails or
other messages for consumers while complying with certain FDCPA
provisions. Most significantly, if a voicemail or other message is a
communication with a consumer, FDCPA section 807(11) requires that the
debt collector identify itself as a debt collector or inform the
consumer that the debt collector is attempting to collect a debt and
that any information obtained will be used for that purpose.\169\ A
debt collector who leaves a message with such disclosures, however,
risks violating FDCPA section 805(b)'s prohibition against revealing
debts to third parties if the disclosures are seen or heard by a third
party.\170\ Uncertainty about what constitutes a communication may
result in debt collectors repeatedly calling consumers
[[Page 23290]]
and hanging up rather than risking liability by leaving messages.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\169\ 15 U.S.C. 1692e(11). See also the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.18(e).
\170\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(b). See also the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Courts interpreting the FDCPA's definition of communication and the
intersection of FDCPA sections 805(b) and 807(11) have reached
conflicting results. Some courts hold that a message asking for a
return call from a consumer is a communication and that a debt
collector who leaves such a message violates FDCPA section 805(b)'s
prohibition on communicating with third parties if the message is heard
by a person other than the consumer.\171\ These courts also hold that,
because the message is a communication with the consumer, it must
include a statement pursuant to FDCPA section 807(11) that the caller
is attempting to collect a debt, which further increases the likelihood
that a third party hearing the message would know that the message
relates to debt collection.\172\ Conversely, other courts hold that a
message limited to certain content--such as the debt collector's name,
a statement that the caller is a debt collector, and a call-back
number--is not a communication and thus does not, itself, constitute a
prohibited third-party disclosure under FDCPA section 805(b) or require
an FDCPA section 807(11) disclosure.\173\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\171\ See, e.g., Cordes v. Frederick J. Hanna & Assocs., P.C.,
789 F. Supp. 2d 1173, 1177 (D. Minn. 2011) (holding that debt
collector violated FDCPA section 805(b) by leaving voicemail
messages that disclosed that the caller was a debt collector);
Marisco v. NCO Fin. Sys., Inc., 946 F. Supp. 2d 287, 289, 291-96
(E.D.N.Y. 2013) (holding that consumer stated a claim for a
violation of FDCPA 805(b) where debt collector's voicemail message
was overheard by a third party and stated, in part, ``This is an
important message from NCO Financial Systems, Inc. The law requires
that we notify that this is a debt collection company. This is an
attempt to collect a debt and any information obtained will be used
for that purpose. This is an attempt to collect a debt.''); Fed.
Trade Comm'n v. Check Enforcement, No. CIV.A. 03-2115 (JWB), 2005 WL
1677480, at *8 (D.N.J. July 18, 2005) (``[T]he record indicates that
defendants left messages on home answering machines, which were
overheard by family members and other third parties, to obtain
payments from alleged indebted consumers. Thus, defendants have . .
. engaged in prohibited communications with third parties in
violation of Section 805 of the FDCPA.''), aff'd sub nom. Fed. Trade
Comm'n v. Check Investors, Inc., 502 F.3d 159 (3d Cir. 2007); see
also Foti v. NCO Fin. Sys., Inc., 424 F. Supp. 2d 643, 655-56
(S.D.N.Y. 2006) (``Defendant's voicemail message, while devoid of
any specific information about any particular debt, clearly provided
some information, even if indirectly, to the intended recipient of
the message. Specifically, the message advised the debtor that the
matter required immediate attention, and provided a specific number
to call to discuss the matter. Given that the obvious purpose of the
message was to provide the debtor with enough information to entice
a return call, it is difficult to imagine how the voicemail message
is not a communication under the FDCPA.'').
\172\ Foti, 424 F. Supp. 2d at 657-58 (``[A] narrow reading of
the term `communication' to exclude instances such as the present
case where no specific information about a debt is explicitly
conveyed could create a significant loophole in the FDCPA, allowing
debtors to circumvent the Sec. 1692e(11) disclosure requirement,
and other provisions of the FDCPA that have a threshold
`communication' requirement, merely by not conveying specific
information about the debt . . . . Such a reading is inconsistent
with Congress's intent to protect consumers from `serious and
widespread' debt collection abuses.''); Hosseinzadeh v. M.R.S.
Assocs., Inc., 387 F. Supp. 2d 1104, 1116 (C.D. Cal. 2005)
(``Because it appears that defendant's messages are `communications'
subjecting defendant to the provisions of Sec. 1692e(11), it also
appears that defendant has violated Sec. 1692e(11) because the
messages do not convey the information required by Sec. 1692e(11),
in particular, that the messages were from a debt collector.'').
\173\ See, e.g., Zortman v. J.C. Christensen & Assocs., Inc.,
870 F. Supp. 2d 694, 701, 707-08 (D. Minn. 2012) (holding that debt
collector did not violate FDCPA section 805(b) by leaving a
voicemail message that stated, ``We have an important message from
J.C. Christensen & Associates. This is a call from a debt collector.
Please call 866-319-8619.''); Zweigenhaft v. Receivables Performance
Mgmt., LLC, No. 14 CV 01074 RJD JMA, 2014 WL 6085912, at *1
(E.D.N.Y. Nov. 13, 2014) (similar); Biggs v. Credit Collections,
Inc., No. CIV-07-0053-F, 2007 WL 4034997, at *4 (W.D. Okla. Nov. 15,
2007) (``Words matter--in this instance, the words of the voice
mails and the words of the statutory definition of a
`communication.' The transcript of the voice mail messages
demonstrates that the voice mails `convey[ed]' no `information
regarding a debt.' No amount of liberal construction can broaden the
statutory language to encompass the words recorded in these voice
mails.''); see also Consent Order at ] IV.A., Fed. Trade Comm'n v.
Expert Global Solutions, Inc., No. 3:13-cv-02611-M (N.D. Tex. July
16, 2013), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cases/2013/07/130709ncoorder.pdf (enjoining defendant debt collector from
leaving recorded messages in which defendant states both the
debtor's name and that the caller is a debt collector, unless the
recipient's voicemail greeting identifies only the debtor's first
and last name or defendant has already spoken with the debtor at the
called number).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many debt collectors state that they err on the side of caution and
make repeated telephone calls instead of leaving messages on a
consumer's voicemail or with a third party who answers a consumer's
telephone, or sending text messages.\174\ Such repeated telephone calls
may frustrate many consumers. Indeed, consumers often complain to the
Bureau about the number of collection calls they receive and, to a
lesser degree, about debt collectors' reluctance to leave
voicemails.\175\ In comments to the Bureau's ANPRM and in feedback
during the SBREFA process, many debt collectors stated that they would
place fewer telephone calls if they were confident that leaving
voicemails or other messages for consumers would not expose them to
risk of liability under the FDCPA.\176\ The FTC and the U.S. Government
Accountability Office also have previously noted the need to clarify
the law regarding debt collectors' ability to leave voicemails for
consumers.\177\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\174\ See, e.g., Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note
57, at 25-26.
\175\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2).
\176\ See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Advanced Notice of
Proposed Rulemaking, Debt Collection (Regulation F), 78 FR 67848,
67867 (Nov. 12, 2013) (noting that debt collectors believe that
recent case law presents a dilemma in which a debt collector's
voicemail for a consumer may not be able to comply with both FDCPA
sections 805(b) and 807(11)); Fed. Trade Comm'n, Collecting Consumer
Debts: The Challenges of Change, at 36 n.228 (Feb. 2009), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/reports/collecting-consumer-debts-challenges-change-federal-trade-commission-workshop-report/dcwr.pdf (hereinafter FTC Modernization Report) (summarizing
industry members' comments that conflicting case law on debt
collectors' ability to communicate by newer forms of technology
deters debt collectors from using such technologies, including
leaving voicemails); id. at 47-49 (noting industry commenters'
concerns about their ability to leave voicemails that comply with
the FDCPA and recommending that the law regarding voicemails be
clarified).
\177\ See FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at 49-50;
U.S. Gov't Accountability. Off., GAO-09-748, Credit Cards: Fair Debt
Collection Practices Act Could Better Reflect the Evolving Debt
Collection Marketplace and Use of Technology, at 47-48, 52 (Sept.
2009), http://www.gao.gov/assets/300/295588.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To address uncertainty about what constitutes an FDCPA
communication and to reduce the need for debt collectors to rely on
repeated telephone calls without leaving messages to establish contact
with consumers, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.2(j) to interpret FDCPA
section 803(2) and define a message whose content would not ``convey[ ]
information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person.''
Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) would provide that a limited-
content message means a message for a consumer that includes all of the
content described in Sec. 1006.2(j)(1), and that may include any of
the content described in Sec. 1006.2(j)(2), but does not include other
content. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.2(b) and (d), a limited-content message would not be a
communication, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(d), but would be an attempt
to communicate, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(b).
Under the proposal, a debt collector who leaves a limited-content
message for a consumer would not have communicated with the consumer or
any other person through that message. In turn, because FDCPA sections
805(b) and 807(11) both apply only to communications as defined by the
FDCPA, the requirements described in those sections would not apply to
the limited-content message. Accordingly, a limited-content message
would not be required to include a disclosure pursuant to FDCPA section
807(11) (as implemented by proposed Sec. 1006.18(e)), and a debt
collector would not risk violating FDCPA section 805(b) (as
[[Page 23291]]
implemented by proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)) if someone other than the
consumer heard or received the message.
The proposal would define a limited-content message as, in part, a
message ``for a consumer.'' As a result, any message left for a person
other than a consumer would not be a limited-content message. FDCPA
section 807(11)'s requirement that a debt collector disclose that the
purpose of a communication is to collect a debt and that any
information obtained will be used for that purpose applies only when a
debt collector is communicating ``with the consumer.'' Concerns about
the intersection of FDCPA sections 805(b) and 807(11) are thus not as
relevant when a debt collector contacts a person other than a consumer.
In addition, because debt collectors generally are prohibited from
communicating with a person other than the consumer, they generally
have no need to contact third parties, and, when such communications
are permitted for obtaining location information about a consumer,
FDCPA section 804 already provides a comprehensive disclosure regime.
Therefore, it may not be necessary to specify the content of a message
that does not constitute a communication if left by a debt collector
for a person other than the consumer.
The proposal would enable a debt collector to transmit a limited-
content message by voicemail, by text message, or orally. Debt
collectors may be most likely to use these methods to send limited-
content messages, and these methods may be most likely to generate a
response from a consumer. The proposal would not enable a debt
collector to transmit a limited-content message by email because, as
discussed below, email messages typically require additional
information (e.g., a sender's email address) that may in some
circumstances convey information about a debt, and consumers may be
unlikely to read or respond to an email containing solely the
information included in a limited-content message (e.g., consumers may
disregard such an email as spam or a security risk). In addition, other
aspects of the proposed rule (e.g., the procedures described in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) for emails and text messages) may encourage
debt collectors to send debt collection communications to consumers by
email. Accordingly, a rule that would enable debt collectors to send
limited-content messages by email might not sufficiently protect
consumers' privacy interests or be of significant benefit to debt
collectors.
Proposed comment 2(j)-1 explains that any message other than a
message that includes the content specified in Sec. 1006.2(j) is not a
limited-content message. The comment further explains that, if a
message includes any other content and such other content directly or
indirectly conveys any information about a debt, including but not
limited to any information that indicates that the message relates to
the collection of a debt, the message would be a communication, as
defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(d). Proposed comment 2(j)-2 provides
examples of limited-content messages.
Proposed comment 2(j)-3 provides examples of ways in which a debt
collector could transmit a limited-content message to a consumer, such
as by leaving a voicemail at the consumer's telephone number, sending a
text message to the consumer's mobile telephone number, or leaving a
message orally with a third party who answers the consumer's home or
mobile telephone number. Proposed comment 2(j)-3 notes, however, that
leaving a limited-content message would be subject to other FDCPA
provisions, including the prohibitions on harassing or abusive conduct
and unfair or unconscionable practices in FDCPA sections 806 and 808,
respectively.\178\ As the section-by-section analyses of proposed
Sec. Sec. 1006.2(b) and (d), 1006.6(b) and (c), 1006.14(h), and
1006.22(f)(3) and (4) explain in more detail, consumers may be harassed
or otherwise injured not only by communications, but also by attempts
to communicate, including when a debt collector conveys limited-content
messages. Accordingly, those sections propose certain restrictions on
when and how a debt collector may attempt to communicate with a person,
including by leaving a limited-content message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\178\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d, 1692f.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 2(j)-4 would clarify that a debt collector who
places a telephone call and leaves only a limited-content message for a
consumer does not, with respect to that telephone call, violate FDCPA
section 806(6)'s prohibition on the placement of telephone calls
without meaningful disclosure of the caller's identity. Under the
proposed interpretation, the content described in proposed Sec.
1006.2(j)(1) would meaningfully disclose the caller's identity. The
proposed interpretation would be limited to the narrow circumstance of
a debt collector providing only a limited-content message to a
consumer. As described below, proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) would require
a limited-content message to include the name of a natural person whom
the consumer could contact as well as a telephone number that the
consumer could use to reply to the debt collector; a limited-content
message could not contain any content that is not described in proposed
Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) or (2), and debt collectors would be prohibited from
including false or misleading statements about the caller's identity or
the purpose of the call. As a result, the message should not mislead a
consumer about the identity of the caller and the consumer could use
the contact information to call a particular employee of a debt
collector. Upon receiving such a call and engaging in a communication,
the debt collector would be required by FDCPA section 807(11) to
disclose to the consumer that the communication is from a debt
collector. This sequence of events--a limited-content message followed
by a communication in which the debt collector provides the FDCPA
section 807(11) disclosures--may benefit consumers more than the status
quo, under which many debt collectors place repeated telephone calls
without leaving any message or any contact information that the
consumer can use to reply to the debt collector.
The interpretation in proposed comment 2(j)-4 would apply only when
a debt collector places a telephone call and leaves only a limited-
content message for a consumer. It would not extend to any other
message a debt collector leaves for a consumer or other person, as such
messages might not include all of the content that must be included in
a limited-content message, might include content that is not described
in proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) or (2) and that conveys a misleading
impression about the caller's identity or purpose of the call, or might
constitute a communication that is subject to FDCPA section 807(11) or
that otherwise would need to include different disclosures about the
caller's identity and purpose in order to satisfy FDCPA section 806(6).
Similarly, the rationale in proposed comment 2(j)-4 would not extend to
a telephone call that is a live conversation with the consumer because,
again, the content of such a conversation would be different than the
content of a limited-content message.
The Bureau requests comment on whether the proposal to define a
limited-content message that a debt collector could leave for a
consumer without risking a violation of FDCPA sections 805(b) or
807(11) will enable debt collectors to establish contact with consumers
while reducing the number of telephone calls that consumers receive.
The Bureau further requests comment on the costs and benefits of
[[Page 23292]]
permitting debt collectors to leave limited-content messages for
consumers, including on whether those costs and benefits differ
depending on whether a debt collector leaves a limited-content message:
(1) In a voicemail message on a home, mobile, or work telephone; (2) in
a live conversation with a third party who answers the consumer's home,
mobile, or work telephone number; or (3) by text message. The Bureau
requests comment on whether there are other communication media, such
as email, by which debt collectors should be permitted to leave
limited-content messages, including in particular on the advantages and
disadvantages of the proposed approach, which would not permit debt
collectors to send limited-content messages by email. In addition, the
Bureau requests comment on whether a debt collector should be permitted
to leave limited-content messages with third parties only in certain
circumstances (e.g., if a third party answers the consumer's telephone
number) and whether a debt collector should be able to include
additional content in a limited-content message if leaving it with a
third party (e.g., a request that the third party take a message).
The Bureau also requests comment on the proposed commentary. In
particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether proposed comment
2(j)-4 properly interprets the requirement to ``meaningful[ly] disclose
the caller's identity'' as satisfied when a debt collector places a
telephone call and leaves only a limited-content message, and on
whether there are other disclosures that would satisfy the meaningful
disclosure requirement of FDCPA section 806(6) without causing the
message to become a communication (i.e., without conveying information
about a debt directly or indirectly to any person).
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives
overwhelmingly supported a rule clarifying how and when a debt
collector may leave a voicemail or other message for a consumer.\179\
They predicted that a rule defining a limited-content message that is
not a communication under the FDCPA would reduce the number and
frequency of collection calls as well as facilitate communications
between debt collectors and consumers. The Small Business Review Panel
Report recommended that the Bureau request comment on the costs and
benefits of any limited-content message proposal, including on the
costs and benefits of providing limited-content messages by media other
than telephone, and of any proposal that would require debt collectors
to include a toll-free callback telephone number in a limited-content
message (as the proposal then under consideration would have).\180\
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) and the requests for comment in this section
are consistent with the feedback received during the SBREFA process,
which supported a definition of limited-content message, and the Panel
Report's recommendations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\179\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 36.
\180\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2(j)(1) Required Content
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) would require that limited-content
messages include certain content to ensure that they facilitate contact
between debt collectors and consumers. In particular, proposed Sec.
1006.2(j)(1) provides that a limited-content message must include all
of the following: The consumer's name, a request that the consumer
reply to the message, the name or names of one or more natural persons
whom the consumer can contact to reply to the debt collector,\181\ a
telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to the debt
collector,\182\ and, if delivered electronically, a disclosure
explaining how the consumer can stop receiving messages through that
medium.\183\ The consumer's name and a request that the consumer reply
to the message may help to ensure that the correct person receives the
message and is prompted to respond. Including in the message a
telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to the message, as
well as the name of at least one person the consumer can speak to,
should enable the consumer to reply to the message and interact with a
debt collector's employee who has access to information about the debt
in collection. In the case of a limited-content message sent by text
message, a disclosure explaining how the consumer can stop receiving
such messages may help prevent harassment, as further explained in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(e). In addition,
the Bureau understands that the content required by Sec. 1006.2(j)(1)
often is included in a voicemail or other message for a person in a
wide variety of non-debt collection circumstances, so a third party
hearing or observing the message may not infer from its content that
the consumer owes a debt. Under this proposed interpretation, none of
the items in the limited-content message themselves individually or
collectively convey that the consumer owes a debt or other information
regarding a debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\181\ Proposed Sec. 1006.18(f) would clarify that a debt
collector's employee does not violate Sec. 1006.18 by using an
assumed name when communicating or attempting to communicate with a
person, provided that the employee uses the assumed name
consistently and that the employer can readily identify any employee
who is using an assumed name. See the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.18(f).
\182\ The proposal under consideration during the SBREFA process
would have required the telephone number to be toll-free to the
consumer (e.g., a 1-800 number). See Small Business Review Panel
Outline, supra note 56, at 24. In light of feedback from some small
entity representatives regarding the potential costs of maintaining
a 1-800 number for the sole purpose of being able to transmit
limited-content messages, the proposed rule would not require a
toll-free telephone number.
\183\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would require a debt collector
who communicates or attempts to communicate with a consumer
electronically in connection with the collection of a debt using,
among other things, a telephone number for text messages or other
electronic-medium address, to include in such communication or
attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous statement describing
one or more ways the consumer can opt out of further electronic
communications or attempts to communicate by the debt collector to
that address or telephone number. See the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 2(j)(1)(iv)-1 notes that a limited-content message
must include a telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to
the debt collector. The proposed comment explains that a voicemail or a
text message that spells out, rather than enumerates numerically, a
vanity telephone number is not a limited-content message. Spelling out
a vanity telephone number could, in some circumstances, convey
information about a debt or otherwise disclose that the message is from
a debt collector. The Bureau considered permitting such telephone
numbers to be included in limited-content messages on the condition
that they do not convey information about a debt, but such a condition
would require a case-by-case analysis to determine if a particular
vanity number conveyed information about a debt. As a result,
permitting the inclusion of a vanity number in any or all circumstances
could undermine the certainty that the limited-content message
definition is designed to provide and could increase the risk that a
third party hearing or observing the message could infer that it
relates to debt collection. Similarly, the sender's email address
could, in some circumstances, convey information about a debt. In part
for that reason, proposed Sec. 1002.2(j) would not permit a limited-
content message to include a sender's email address and, consequently,
would effectively prohibit sending a limited-content message by email.
As discussed, debt collectors also may have less of a need to send a
limited-content message by email because proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)
would clarify the procedures that a debt
[[Page 23293]]
collector could maintain to avoid incurring liability for a prohibited
third-party communication by email, thereby reducing the risk to debt
collectors of sending debt collection communications to consumers by
email.
2(j)(2) Optional Content
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(2) would permit a debt collector to
include in a limited-content message certain content that may help
prompt a consumer to reply but that, unlike the content described in
proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1), may not be necessary to enable the
consumer to reply to the message or to prevent harassment. In
particular, proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(2) provides that a limited-content
message also may include one or more of the following: A salutation,
the date and time of the message, a generic statement that the message
relates to an account, and suggested dates and times for the consumer
to reply to the message. The proposed interpretation would hold that
none of these items, individually or collectively, conveys that the
consumer owes a debt or other information regarding a debt.
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.2(j), including on the proposed interpretation that none of the
content described in proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) and (2) conveys
information regarding a debt. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether the proposal to allow a limited-content message to include a
generic statement that the message relates to an ``account'' raises a
risk that the message would convey information about a debt to a third
party hearing or observing the message, and whether there is an
alternative statement that would better minimize such risk. For
example, the Bureau considered proposing permitting a limited-content
message to state that the message relates to a ``personal,''
``business,'' ``confidential,'' ``private,'' ``important,'' or ``time-
sensitive'' matter, but each of these might, in at least certain
contexts, be misleading or confusing to a consumer. The Bureau further
requests comment on whether there is sufficient information required or
permitted in the limited-content message to prompt consumers to make a
return call or text to the included telephone number and, if not, what
additional information could be included in the message that would not
cause the message to constitute a communication. The Bureau also
requests comment on whether including a sender or recipient email
address or a vanity telephone number in a limited-content message could
convey information about a debt to a third party hearing or observing
the message and reduce the utility of a bright-line definition.
Finally, the Bureau requests comment on the media by which debt
collectors anticipate that they would send limited-content messages and
on whether additional clarification is necessary regarding sending
limited-content messages by media other than telephone.
2(k) Person
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(k) would define the term person to have the
meaning set forth in 1 U.S.C. 1, which provides that, ``in determining
the meaning of any Act of Congress, unless the context indicates
otherwise,'' the term person includes ``corporations, companies,
associations, firms, partnerships, societies, and joint stock
companies, as well as individuals.'' \184\ The FDCPA does not define
the term person, and the context does not appear to indicate that a
meaning other than the meaning in 1 U.S.C. 1 should apply. The term
person is used throughout the FDCPA and the proposed regulation. The
Bureau proposes to define this term to facilitate compliance, with only
minor wording changes from the statute.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\184\ See 1 U.S.C. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subpart B--Rules for FDCPA Debt Collectors \185\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\185\ Consistent with its proposal to amend Regulation F to
prescribe Federal rules governing the activities of debt collectors,
the Bureau proposes to move existing Sec. Sec. 1006.3 through
1006.8 regarding applications for State exemptions from the FDCPA to
appendix A of the regulation. See the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.108 and appendix A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.6 Communications in Connection With Debt Collection
FDCPA section 805 generally limits how debt collectors may
communicate with consumers and third parties when collecting
debts.\186\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6 would implement and interpret FDCPA
section 805; it also would interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to
provide certain additional protections regarding debt collection
communications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\186\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(a) Definition
FDCPA section 805(d) provides that, for purposes of section 805,
the term consumer includes certain individuals other than the person
obligated or allegedly obligated to pay the debt. Accordingly, the
protections in FDCPA section 805 apply to these individuals and the
person obligated or allegedly obligated to pay the debt. Also, debt
collectors may communicate with these individuals in connection with
the collection of any debt without violating the FDCPA's prohibition on
third-party disclosures.\187\ For example, under FDCPA section 805(d),
a debt collector may communicate not only with the consumer who owes or
allegedly owes the debt, but also with the consumer's spouse, parent
(if the consumer is a minor), guardian, executor, or
administrator,\188\ even though debt collectors generally are
prohibited from communicating in connection with the collection of a
debt with third parties.\189\ A debt collector may communicate with
third parties to seek location information about consumers, but the
debt collector may not state that the consumer owes any debt.\190\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\187\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(d).
\188\ Id.
\189\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692c(b).
\190\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692b. For additional discussion of these
provisions, see the section-by-section analyses of proposed
Sec. Sec. 1006.6(d) and 1006.10(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(a) would implement and interpret FDCPA
section 805(d) and would define consumer for purposes of proposed
Sec. Sec. 1006.6 and 1006.14(h). Consistent with proposed Sec.
1006.2(e), which, as described above, would interpret consumer to
include deceased persons, proposed comments 6(a)(1)-1 and 6(a)(2)-1
would clarify that surviving spouses and parents of deceased minor
consumers, respectively, are consumers for purposes of proposed Sec.
1006.6. Except for these clarifications, and except for the
interpretations discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(4) and (5), proposed Sec. 1006.6(a) generally
mirrors the statute. The section-by-section analysis below therefore
addresses only proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(4) and (5).
6(a)(4)
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(4) would implement FDCPA section 805(d)'s
definition of the term consumer as related to executors and
administrators. Proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(4) generally restates the
statute and its commentary also interprets FDCPA section 805(d) to
include the personal representative of the deceased consumer's estate.
As discussed above, FDCPA section 805 generally limits the
individuals with whom a debt collector may discuss the debt to those
individuals identified as consumers in FDCPA section 805(d). If the
consumer who owes or allegedly owes the debt is deceased, the
consumer's family members may find that debt collectors are reluctant
to communicate with the individuals attempting to resolve any
outstanding debts of the decedent unless they are among the individuals
identified in FDCPA section 805(d) with whom a debt collector may
generally discuss the
[[Page 23294]]
debt, i.e., individuals with the title of executor or administrator
under State law. This reluctance may delay the prompt resolution of
estates.
The Bureau understands that most States currently provide
procedures for resolving estates that are faster and less expensive
than the formal probate process that may have been more common when
Congress enacted the FDCPA more than 40 years ago. Under these
expedited State procedures, an individual with the authority to pay the
decedent's debts out of the assets of the estate may lack the
particular title of executor or administrator under State law. The
Bureau proposes to interpret the terms executor and administrator as
used in the FDCPA to include personal representatives, which is defined
in proposed comment 6(a)(4)-1 as any person who is authorized to act on
behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. These terms are not defined
in the FDCPA, and the FDCPA does not indicate that they are limited to
persons who formally have the title of executor or administrator under
State law. Rather, it is ambiguous whether the terms executor and
administrator include personal representatives of a consumer's estate,
as these persons serve the functions of executors or administrators but
do not formally have that title. Accordingly, the Bureau proposes to
interpret executor and administrator in a manner that is flexible
enough to recognize the evolution in estate resolution processes over
time, including the use of a personal representative to be the executor
or administrator of the decedent's estate.\191\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\191\ Additionally, the word ``includes'' in FDCPA section
805(d) indicates that section 805(d) is an exemplary, rather than an
exhaustive, list of the categories of individuals who are consumers
for purposes of FDCPA section 805. See 15 U.S.C. 1692c(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ability to resolve the debts of estates outside of the formal
probate process through informal processes may benefit consumers. If a
debt collector does not communicate with an estate because no executor
or administrator exists, the debt collector might force the estate into
probate, which could substantially burden the resources of the estate
and the deceased consumer's heirs or beneficiaries. These burdens may
be particularly acute for small estates and for individuals of limited
means. Probate also adds costs and delays for debt collectors. In its
Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, the FTC voiced similar concerns
about unnecessarily pushing estates into probate. In light of such
concerns, the FTC indicated that the agency would take no enforcement
action against debt collectors who communicated about a decedent's
debts with an individual who has the authority to pay the debts out of
the assets of the deceased consumer's estate.\192\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\192\ Statement of Policy Regarding Communications in Connection
with the Collection of Decedents' Debts, 76 FR 44915, 44919 (July
27, 2011) (hereinafter FTC Policy Statement on Decedent Debt).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(a)(4). The
Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(4).
Proposed comment 6(a)(4)-1 would clarify that the terms executor or
administrator include the personal representative of the consumer's
estate, and that a personal representative of the consumer's estate is
any person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased
consumer's estate. The proposed comment explains that persons with such
authority may include personal representatives under the informal
probate and summary administration procedures of many States, persons
appointed as universal successors, persons who sign declarations or
affidavits to effectuate the transfer of estate assets, and persons who
dispose of the deceased consumer's assets extrajudicially.
The term personal representative in comment 6(a)(4)-1 includes the
same individuals as those recognized by the FTC's Policy Statement on
Decedent Debt.\193\ As the FTC has noted, some of the terms used to
describe these individuals come from the Uniform Probate Code.\194\
However, proposed comment 6(a)(4)-1 adapts the general description of
the term personal representative from Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.11(c),
comment 11(c)-1 (persons ``authorized to act on behalf of the estate'')
rather than the general description found in the FTC's Policy Statement
(persons with the ``authority to pay the decedent's debts from the
assets of the decedent's estate.''). The Bureau believes that this
change is non-substantive. The description of the term personal
representative also reflects the language that a debt collector may use
to acquire location information about the executor, administrator, or
personal representative of the deceased consumer's estate, as explained
in proposed comment 10(b)(2)-1.\195\ The Bureau requests comment on the
scope of the definition of personal representative in proposed comment
6(a)(4)-1 and on any ambiguity in the illustrative descriptions of
personal representatives. The Bureau specifically requests comment on
experiences under the FTC's Policy Statement on Decedent Debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\193\ Id.
\194\ Statement of Policy Regarding Communications in Connection
with Collection of a Decedent Debt, 75 FR 62389, 62391-92 (Oct. 8,
2010) (describing the processes of informal probate and
administration and universal succession).
\195\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.10(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In its Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau stated that
it was considering limiting the definition of personal representative
to individuals recognized under State probate or estate laws.\196\
However, the Bureau received feedback from industry indicating that
many State laws define personal representative to mean an executor or
administrator. In these States, the definition of personal
representative under consideration in the Small Business Review Panel
Outline would have restricted communication to formally appointed
executors or administrators, which would not have alleviated the harms
the Bureau intended to address. Proposed comment 6(a)(4)-1, which
provides that a personal representative is any person who is authorized
to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate, is designed to
address this post-SBREFA feedback.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\196\ Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 32-
33.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(a)(5)
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(5) would interpret FDCPA section 805(d)'s
definition of the term consumer to include confirmed successors in
interest. Under Regulations X and Z, a successor in interest is a
person to whom a borrower transfers an ownership interest either in a
property securing a mortgage loan subject to subpart C of Regulation X,
or in a dwelling securing a closed-end consumer credit transaction
under Regulation Z, provided that the transfer is: (1) A transfer by
devise, descent, or operation of law on the death of a joint tenant or
tenant by the entirety; (2) a transfer to a relative resulting from the
death of a borrower; (3) a transfer where the spouse or children of the
borrower become an owner of the property; (4) a transfer resulting from
a decree of a dissolution of marriage, legal separation agreement, or
from an incidental property settlement agreement, by which the spouse
of the borrower becomes an owner of the property; or (5) a transfer
into an inter vivos trust in which the borrower is and remains a
beneficiary and which does not relate to
[[Page 23295]]
a transfer of rights of occupancy in the property.\197\ A confirmed
successor in interest, in turn, means a successor in interest once a
servicer has confirmed the successor in interest's identity and
ownership interest in the relevant property type.\198\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\197\ 12 CFR 1024.31; 1026.2(a)(27)(i).
\198\ 12 CFR 1024.31; 1026.2(a)(27)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As the Bureau explained in its Amendments to the 2013 Mortgage
Rules under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X)
and the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z) (2016 Servicing Final Rule)
\199\ and its concurrently issued FDCPA interpretive rule (2016 FDCPA
Interpretive Rule),\200\ the word ``includes'' in FDCPA section 805(d)
indicates that section 805(d) is an exemplary, rather than an
exhaustive, list of the categories of individuals who are consumers for
purposes of FDCPA section 805. The Bureau explained that FDCPA section
805 recognizes the importance of permitting debt collectors to
communicate with a narrow category of persons other than the individual
who owes or allegedly owes the debt who, by virtue of their
relationship to that individual, may need to communicate with the debt
collector in connection with the collection of the debt. The Bureau
further explained that, given their relationship to the individual who
owes or allegedly owes the debt, confirmed successors in interest are--
like the narrow categories of persons enumerated in FDCPA section
805(d)--the type of individuals with whom a debt collector needs to
communicate about the debt. The Bureau therefore interpreted the term
consumer for purposes of FDCPA section 805 to include a confirmed
successor in interest as that term is defined in Regulation X, 12 CFR
1024.31, and Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.2(a)(27)(ii).\201\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\199\ 81 FR 72160 (Oct. 19, 2016).
\200\ 81 FR 71977 (Oct. 19, 2016).
\201\ Id. at 71979; 81 FR 72160, 72181 (Oct. 19, 2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with that interpretation, and pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to write rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau proposes to
interpret FDCPA section 805(d) in Sec. 1006.6(a)(5) to provide that a
confirmed successor in interest, as defined in Regulations X and Z, is
a consumer for purposes of proposed Sec. 1006.6. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(5), including on the benefits and
risks of communications about debts between debt collectors and
confirmed successors in interest.
6(b) Communications With a Consumer--In General
FDCPA section 805(a) restricts how a debt collector may communicate
with a consumer in connection with the collection of any debt and
provides certain exceptions to these prohibitions.\202\ The Bureau
generally proposes Sec. 1006.6(b) to implement and interpret FDCPA
section 805(a) to specify circumstances in which a debt collector is
prohibited from communicating with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt. In addition, the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.6(b) to interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit a debt
collector from attempting to communicate with a consumer if FDCPA
section 805(a) would prohibit the debt collector from communicating
with the consumer. The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(b) pursuant to its
authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to
the collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\202\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a). Specifically, FDCPA section 805(a)(1)
prohibits certain communications at unusual or inconvenient times
and places, section 805(a)(2) prohibits certain communications with
a consumer represented by an attorney, and section 805(a)(3)
prohibits certain communications at a consumer's place of
employment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Attempts To Communicate
The Bureau proposes to clarify in proposed Sec. 1006.6(b) that a
debt collector is prohibited from attempting to communicate with a
consumer in the same circumstances in which FDCPA section 805(a)
prohibits the debt collector from communicating with the consumer. As
discussed, proposed Sec. 1006.2(b) would define an attempt to
communicate to mean any attempt by a debt collector to initiate contact
with any person, including by soliciting a response from such person,
regardless of whether the attempt, if successful, would be a
communication as defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(d). For example, a
debt collector who places a telephone call to the consumer that goes
unanswered has attempted to communicate with the consumer. The phrase
attempt to communicate thus appears throughout proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(1) through (4).
The Bureau proposes to limit attempts to communicate in Sec.
1006.6(b) based on interpretations of FDCPA sections 806 and 808. FDCPA
section 806 prohibits a debt collector from engaging in any conduct the
natural consequence of which is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person
in connection with the collection of a debt.\203\ FDCPA section 806(5)
provides that causing a telephone to ring repeatedly or continuously
with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person at the called number
is an example of conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass,
oppress, or abuse. FDCPA section 806(5) thus recognizes that telephone
calls may have the natural consequence of harassment, oppression, or
abuse even if no conversation ensues. A consumer who hears a telephone
ringing at an inconvenient time or place but who does not answer it may
experience the natural consequence of harassment from the telephone
ringing in much the same way as a consumer who answers and speaks to
the debt collector on the telephone. For this reason, the Bureau
proposes to interpret FDCPA section 806 as prohibiting a debt collector
from attempting to communicate at times when and places where a
communication would be prohibited as inconvenient.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\203\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FDCPA section 808 prohibits a debt collector from using unfair or
unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt.\204\ A
debt collector who places a telephone call without the intent to speak
to any person who answers the telephone (thus avoiding a communication
for purposes of FDCPA section 805) may be causing injury to persons at
the called number without any legitimate purpose, and thus may be
engaging in a prohibited unfair or unconscionable act under FDCPA
section 808. Additionally, section 808 targets practices that pressure
a consumer to pay debts the consumer might not otherwise have paid. A
debt collector's attempts to communicate at a time when or a place
where a communication would be prohibited could pressure the consumer
to pay the debt to avoid further intrusions on the consumer's privacy,
and the Bureau interprets such conduct as unfair or unconscionable
under FDCPA section 808. The Bureau requests comment on its proposed
interpretations regarding attempts to communicate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\204\ 15 U.S.C. 1692f.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(b)(1) Prohibitions Regarding Unusual or Inconvenient Times or Places
FDCPA section 805(a)(1) prohibits a debt collector from, among
other things, communicating with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt at times or places that the debt collector knows
or should know are inconvenient to the consumer, subject to certain
exceptions. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis below,
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i) and (ii)
[[Page 23296]]
generally would implement and interpret FDCPA section 805(a)(1).
Proposed comment 6(b)(1)-1 provides general interpretations and
illustrations of the time and place restrictions in proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(1). Proposed comment 6(b)(1)-1 illustrates how a debt
collector knows or should know that a time or place is inconvenient to
a consumer. The proposed comment explains that a debt collector may
know, or should know, that a time or place is inconvenient to a
consumer if the consumer uses the word ``inconvenient'' to notify the
debt collector. The proposed comment also explains that, even if the
consumer does not use the word ``inconvenient'' to notify the debt
collector, the debt collector nevertheless may know, or should know,
based on the facts and circumstances, that a time or place is
inconvenient. The Bureau proposes this interpretation because FDCPA
section 805(a)(1) refers to what is ``inconvenient to the consumer,''
without specifying that a consumer must designate communications as
inconvenient using the word ``inconvenient.'' The Bureau's proposed
interpretation also is consistent with some case law holding that a
consumer need not use the precise language of the statute to invoke the
protections of FDCPA section 805.\205\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\205\ See, e.g., Horkey v. J.V.D.B. & Assocs., Inc., 333 F.3d
769, 773 (7th Cir. 2003).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(b)(1)-1 would further clarify that, if the
consumer initiates a communication with the debt collector at a time or
from a place that the consumer previously designated as inconvenient,
the debt collector may respond once to that consumer-initiated
communication at that time or place. Because the consumer initiated the
communication, the debt collector neither knows nor should know that
responding to that specific communication is inconvenient to the
consumer. The debt collector is permitted to respond once. After that
response, the debt collector must not communicate or attempt to
communicate further with the consumer at that time or place until the
consumer conveys that the time or place is no longer inconvenient.
Proposed comment 6(b)(1)-1 also provides four specific examples of when
a debt collector knows or should know that the time or place of a
communication is inconvenient to a consumer.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1) and on
comment 6(b)(1)-1, including on whether other general clarifications
regarding inconvenient times or places would be useful or whether other
examples and illustrations would be instructive. The Bureau
specifically requests comment on whether additional clarification is
needed regarding the delivery of legally required communications at a
time or place that a debt collector knows or should know is
inconvenient to a particular consumer. The Bureau requests comment on
whether to require a debt collector to ask a consumer at the outset of
all debt collection communications whether the time or place is
convenient to the consumer. The Bureau also requests comment on what
effect a consumer-initiated communication should have on the times and
places that a debt collector knows or should know are inconvenient to
the consumer.
6(b)(1)(i)
FDCPA section 805(a)(1) provides, in relevant part, that a debt
collector may not communicate with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt at any unusual time, or at a time that the debt
collector knows or should know is inconvenient to the consumer.\206\
FDCPA section 805(a)(1) specifies that, in the absence of knowledge of
circumstances to the contrary, a debt collector shall assume that the
convenient time for communicating with a consumer is after 8:00 a.m.
and before 9:00 p.m., local time at the consumer's location.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\206\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i) would implement and interpret FDCPA
section 805(a)(1)'s prohibitions regarding unusual or inconvenient
times.\207\ The Bureau interprets the language in FDCPA section
805(a)(1) that a debt collector shall assume that the convenient time
for communicating with a consumer is after 8:00 a.m. and before 9:00
p.m. to mean that a time before 8:00 a.m. and after 9:00 p.m. local
time at the consumer's location is inconvenient, unless the debt
collector has knowledge of circumstances to the contrary. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i).\208\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\207\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b), proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i) also would
interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit a debt collector
from attempting to communicate with a consumer at a time when FDCPA
section 805(a)(1) would prohibit the debt collector from
communicating with the consumer.
\208\ In the Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau
described a proposal under consideration to define the 30-day period
after the death of a consumer as an inconvenient time for
communicating about the deceased consumer's debt with surviving
spouses or parents (in the case of deceased minor consumers) or
persons acting as executors, administrators, or personal
representatives of a deceased consumer's estate. See Small Business
Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 33. The proposed rule does
not include such a waiting period. The Bureau requests evidence of
specific consumer harm and benefits from debt collection
communications occurring within 30 days after a consumer's death.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(b)(1)(i)-1 would clarify that, for purposes of
determining the time of an electronic communication under Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(i), an electronic communication occurs when the debt
collector sends it, not, for example, when the consumer receives or
views it. Ambiguity exists about whether, for purposes of FDCPA section
805(a)(1), an electronic communication occurs at the time of sending or
at the time of receipt or viewing. A rule that clarifies that an
electronic communication occurs when the debt collector sends it makes
it possible for a debt collector to comply. A debt collector can
control the time at which it chooses to send communications, whereas it
often would be impossible for a debt collector to determine when a
consumer receives or views an electronic communication. Accordingly,
under proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i), a debt collector would be
prohibited from sending an electronic communication at a time that the
debt collector knows or should know is inconvenient to the consumer.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed comment 6(b)(1)(i)-1.
Proposed comment 6(b)(1)(i)-2 would provide a safe harbor and
illustrate how a debt collector could comply with proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(i) and FDCPA section 805(a)(1) if the debt collector has
conflicting or ambiguous information regarding a consumer's location,
such as telephone numbers with area codes located in different time
zones or a telephone number with an area code and a physical address
that are inconsistent. Proposed comment 6(b)(1)(i)-2 would clarify
that, if a debt collector is unable to determine a consumer's location,
then, in the absence of knowledge of circumstances to the contrary, the
debt collector would comply with the prohibition in Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(i) on communicating at inconvenient times if the debt
collector communicated or attempted to communicate with the consumer at
a time that would be convenient in all of the locations at which the
debt collector's information indicated the consumer might be located. A
debt collector with such conflicting information may know or should
know that it is inconvenient to contact a consumer at a time outside of
the presumptively convenient times (8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.) in any of
the time zones in which the consumer might be located. As indicated by
some industry
[[Page 23297]]
commenters in response to the Bureau's ANPRM, some debt collectors
already have adopted this proposed approach for determining the
convenient times to contact a consumer if the debt collector has
conflicting location information for the consumer. Proposed comment
6(b)(1)(i)-2 also provides two examples of how a debt collector could
comply with proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i). The Bureau requests comment
on proposed comment 6(b)(1)(i)-2.
6(b)(1)(ii)
FDCPA section 805(a)(1) provides, in relevant part, that a debt
collector may not communicate with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt at any unusual place, or at a place that the
debt collector knows or should know is inconvenient to the
consumer.\209\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(ii) would implement this
prohibition and generally restates the statute, with only minor changes
for clarity.210 211
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\209\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(1).
\210\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b), proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(ii) also would
interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit a debt collector
from attempting to communicate with a consumer at a place at which
FDCPA section 805(a)(1) would prohibit the debt collector from
communicating with the consumer.
\211\ In the Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau
described a proposal under consideration to designate four
categories of places as presumptively inconvenient. See Small
Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 29-30. In response
to feedback received during the SBREFA process, the Bureau does not
propose that intervention at this time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(b)(2) Prohibitions Regarding Consumer Represented by an Attorney
FDCPA section 805(a)(2) prohibits a debt collector from communicating
with a consumer in connection with the collection of any debt if the
debt collector knows the consumer is represented by an attorney with
respect to the debt and has knowledge of, or can readily ascertain, the
attorney's name and address, unless the attorney fails to respond
within a reasonable period of time to a communication from the debt
collector or unless the attorney consents to direct communication with
the consumer.\212\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(2) would implement this
prohibition and generally restates the statute.\213\ The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(2), including whether
additional clarification regarding this prohibition would be useful.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\212\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(2).
\213\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b), proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(2) also would
interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit a debt collector
from attempting to communicate with a consumer who is represented by
an attorney if FDCPA section 805(a)(2) would prohibit the debt
collector from communicating with that consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(b)(3) Prohibitions Regarding Consumer's Place of Employment
FDCPA section 805(a)(3) prohibits a debt collector from
communicating with a consumer in connection with the collection of any
debt at the consumer's place of employment if the debt collector knows
or has reason to know that the consumer's employer prohibits the
consumer from receiving such communication.\214\ Proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(3) would implement this prohibition and generally restates
the statute.\215\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\214\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(3).
\215\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b), proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(3) also would
interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit a debt collector
from attempting to communicate with a consumer at the consumer's
place of employment if FDCPA section 805(a)(3) would prohibit the
debt collector from communicating with the consumer there.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even under circumstances where proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(3) may not
apply because the debt collector does not know or have reason to know
that a consumer's employer prohibits the consumer from receiving
communications in connection with the collection of a debt at the
consumer's place of employment, proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3), discussed
below, would prohibit the debt collector from communicating or
attempting to communicate with the consumer using an email address that
the debt collector knows or should know is provided to the consumer by
the consumer's employer, unless an exception under proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(3) applies (i.e., the debt collector has received directly
from the consumer either prior consent to use that email address or an
email from that email address).\216\ Proposed comment 6(b)(3)-1 cross-
references the employer-provided email rule described in proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\216\ For additional discussion of proposed work email
restrictions, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(3). The
Bureau also requests comment on whether additional clarification would
be useful with respect to a debt collector's communications or attempts
to communicate with a consumer while at work, for example, on a
consumer's non-work mobile telephone or portable electronic device.
6(b)(4) Exceptions
FDCPA section 805(a) provides certain exceptions to its limitations
on a debt collector's communications with a consumer. Proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(4) would implement and interpret the exceptions in FDCPA
section 805(a).
6(b)(4)(i)
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) would implement the text in FDCPA
section 805(a) that, in relevant part, sets forth the exception for the
prior consent of the consumer given directly to the debt
collector.\217\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) generally mirrors the
statute, except that proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) would interpret
FDCPA section 805(a) to require that the consumer's prior consent must
be given during a communication that would not violate proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(1) through (3), i.e., the prohibitions on communications with
a consumer at unusual or inconvenient times or places, communications
with a consumer represented by an attorney, and communications at the
consumer's place of employment. For example, ordinarily a debt
collector could not place a telephone call to a consumer at midnight
and obtain the consumer's prior consent for future debt collection
communications. The Bureau interprets a consumer's prior consent to be
consent obtained in the absence of conduct that would compromise or
eliminate a consumer's ability to freely choose whether to consent. A
communication that would violate proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1) through
(3) (e.g., consent obtained from a represented consumer where the
consumer's attorney is not present) is likely to compromise or
eliminate a consumer's ability to freely choose whether to consent. By
addressing only prior consent purported to be obtained during a
communication that would violate proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(1) through
(3), the Bureau does not intend to suggest that prior consent obtained
in other unlawful ways would comply with FDCPA section 805(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\217\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comments 6(b)(4)(i)-1 and -2 would clarify the meaning of
prior consent.\218\ Proposed comment 6(b)(4)(i)-1 explains that, if a
debt collector learns during a communication that the debt collector is
communicating with a consumer at an inconvenient time or place, the
debt collector cannot during that communication ask the consumer to
consent to the continuation of that debt collection communication. The
Bureau proposes this comment because consent that satisfies proposed
Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) must be ``prior'' and therefore given in advance
of a communication that otherwise would violate proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(1) through
[[Page 23298]]
(3). Additionally, permitting a debt collector to ask a consumer to
consent to a communication once the debt collector knows the
communication is occurring at an inconvenient time or place would
undermine the very protection guaranteed to the consumer under FDCPA
section 805(a)(1). Although proposed comment 6(b)(4)(i)-1 would clarify
that the debt collector would be prohibited from asking the consumer to
consent to the continuation of the communication at the inconvenient
time or place, the comment also would clarify that a debt collector may
ask the consumer what time or place would be convenient.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\218\ The interpretations and illustrations of prior consent
discussed here also apply to proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.14(b) and
1006.22(f), as discussed in the corresponding section-by-section
analyses below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(b)(4)(i)-2 restates the rule that the prior
consent of the consumer must be given directly to the debt collector
and explains that a debt collector cannot rely on the prior consent of
the consumer given to the original creditor or to a previous debt
collector. The Bureau proposes this interpretation because prior
consent given to the original creditor or to a previous debt collector
is not given ``directly'' to the debt collector, as the FDCPA expressly
requires.\219\ The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(4)(i) and its related commentary, including on whether
additional clarification regarding a consumer's prior consent for the
purposes of these rule provisions would be instructive. Additionally,
because the definition of consumer for purposes of proposed Sec.
1006.6 includes the individuals listed in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(1)
through (5) (e.g., the consumer's spouse), the Bureau requests comment
on whether additional clarification is needed regarding which
``consumer'' may give prior consent pursuant to proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(4)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\219\ This proposal is also consistent with the FDCPA's
legislative history. See H. Rept. No. 95-131, at 5 (1977) (``The
committee intends that in section [805] the `prior consent' be
meaningful, i.e., that any prior consent by a consumer is to be a
voluntary consent and shall be expressed by the consumer directly to
the debt collector. Consequently, the committee intends that any
term in a contract which requires a consumer to consent in advance
to debt collection communication would not constitute `prior
consent' by such consumer.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(b)(4)(ii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(ii) would implement the text in FDCPA
section 805(a) that, in relevant part, sets forth the exception for the
express permission of a court of competent jurisdiction.\220\ Proposed
Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(ii) generally restates the statute, with only minor
changes for clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\220\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(c) Communications With a Consumer--After Refusal To Pay or Cease
Communication Notice
FDCPA section 805(c) provides that, subject to certain exceptions,
if a consumer notifies a debt collector in writing that the consumer
refuses to pay a debt or that the consumer wishes the debt collector to
cease further communication with the consumer, the debt collector shall
not communicate further with the consumer with respect to such debt
(the ``cease communication provision'').\221\ The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.6(c) to implement and interpret FDCPA section 805(c) and pursuant
to the Bureau's authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\221\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(c)(1) Prohibitions
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(c)(1) would implement FDCPA section 805(c)'s
cease communication provision and generally restates the statute, with
only minor changes for clarity. Specifically, proposed Sec.
1006.6(c)(1) would provide that, except as provided in proposed Sec.
1006.6(c)(2), a debt collector must not communicate or attempt to
communicate further with a consumer with respect to a debt if the
consumer notifies the debt collector in writing that: (i) The consumer
refuses to pay the debt; or (ii) the consumer wants the debt collector
to cease further communication with the consumer.\222\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\222\ For the same reasons that proposed Sec. 1006.6(b) would
prohibit debt collectors from attempting to communicate with
consumers if FDCPA section 805(a) would prohibit communications with
consumers, proposed Sec. 1006.6(c) would interpret FDCPA sections
806 and 808 to prohibit a debt collector from attempting to
communicate with a consumer if FDCPA section 805(c) would prohibit
the debt collector from communicating with the consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes to interpret the applicability of the E-SIGN
Act to a consumer electronically notifying a debt collector that the
consumer wants the debt collector to cease further communication.\223\
Specifically, the Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA section 805(c)'s
writing requirement as being satisfied if a consumer notifies a debt
collector using a medium of electronic communication through which a
debt collector accepts electronic communications from consumers, such
as email or a website portal. Thus, a debt collector would be required
to give legal effect to a consumer's notification submitted
electronically only if the debt collector generally chose to accept
electronic communications from consumers. The Bureau proposes to codify
this interpretation of the E-SIGN Act in proposed comment 6(c)(1)-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\223\ Section 104(b)(1)(A) of the E-SIGN Act provides authority
for a Federal regulatory agency with rulemaking authority under a
statute to interpret section 101 of the E-SIGN Act with respect to
that statute by regulation. 15 U.S.C. 7004(b)(1)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(c)(1)-1 would implement FDCPA section 805(c)'s
provision that, if such notice is made by mail, a consumer's
notification is complete upon receipt by the debt collector.\224\
Proposed comment 6(c)(1)-1 would apply this standard to all written or
electronic forms of a consumer's notification. The Bureau notes that
FDCPA section 805(c) does not state that only mail notifications are
complete upon receipt, but rather leaves vague when other forms of
notification are complete. The Bureau proposes to clarify this
ambiguity by providing that written or electronic forms of notification
are complete upon receipt. The Bureau proposes this clarification on
the basis that, regardless of the medium, before a debt collector has
received a notification, it may not be reasonable to consider the debt
collector to have been notified. On the other hand, once the debt
collector has received a notification, the debt collector can
reasonably be considered to have been notified.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\224\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(c)(1) and on
proposed comment 6(c)(1)-1, including on: Whether additional
clarification is needed with respect to a consumer's notification
pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.6(c)(1) being complete upon receipt by
the debt collector; whether a debt collector should be afforded a
certain period of time to update its systems to reflect the consumer's
request even after the notification is received, and, if so, how long;
and whether receipt works differently for different written and
electronic communication media. Additionally, because the definition of
consumer for purposes of proposed Sec. 1006.6 includes the individuals
listed in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(1) through (5) (e.g., the consumer's
spouse), the Bureau requests comment on whether additional
clarification is needed regarding which ``consumer'' may notify the
debt collector pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.6(c)(1).
6(c)(2) Exceptions
FDCPA section 805(c) provides exceptions to the cease communication
provision. The exceptions allow a debt collector to communicate with a
[[Page 23299]]
consumer even after a consumer has notified a debt collector pursuant
to FDCPA section 805(c)'s cease communication provision: (1) To advise
the consumer that the debt collector's further efforts are being
terminated; (2) to notify the consumer that the debt collector or
creditor may invoke specified remedies which are ordinarily invoked by
such debt collector or creditor; or (3) where applicable, to notify the
consumer that the debt collector or creditor intends to invoke a
specified remedy.\225\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(c)(2) would implement
these exceptions and generally restates the statute, with only minor
changes for clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\225\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(c)(1)-(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 2016 Servicing Final Rule \226\ and the concurrently issued
2016 FDCPA Interpretive Rule,\227\ the Bureau interpreted the written
early intervention notice required in Regulation X, 12 CFR
1024.39(d)(3), to fall within the exceptions to the cease communication
provision in FDCPA section 805(c)(2) and (3). As the Bureau explained
in the 2016 Servicing Final Rule, the Bureau concluded that, because
failure to provide the written early intervention notice required by
Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.39(d)(3), is closely linked to the ability of
a mortgage servicer (who also is a debt collector subject to the FDCPA
with respect to a mortgage loan) to invoke its specified remedy of
foreclosure, the notice falls within the exceptions in FDCPA sections
805(c)(2) and (3).\228\ For a further discussion of the requirement in
Regulation X, see the 2016 Servicing Final Rule's section-by-section
analysis discussion of 12 CFR 1024.39(d)(3).\229\ The Bureau proposes
comment 6(c)(2)-1 to incorporate by reference this interpretation,
which applies to a mortgage servicer who also is a debt collector
subject to the FDCPA with respect to a mortgage loan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\226\ 81 FR 72160 (Oct. 19, 2016).
\227\ 81 FR 71977 (Oct. 19, 2016).
\228\ 81 FR 72160, 72232 (Oct. 19, 2016).
\229\ Id. at 72233-38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(d) Communications With Third Parties
FDCPA section 805(b) prohibits a debt collector from communicating,
in connection with the collection of any debt, with any person other
than the consumer or certain other persons.\230\ FDCPA section 805(b)
also identifies certain exceptions to this prohibition. Proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(1) would implement FDCPA section 805(b)'s general prohibition
against communicating with third parties, and proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(2) would implement the exceptions. Proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) would specify, for purposes of FDCPA section 813(c),
procedures that are reasonably adapted to avoid an error in sending an
email or text message that would result in a violation of FDCPA section
805(b). The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(d) pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to write rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\230\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(b). Specifically, FDCPA section 805(b)
prohibits communicating with any person other than the consumer, the
consumer's attorney, a consumer reporting agency if otherwise
permitted by law, the creditor, the creditor's attorney, or the debt
collector's attorney.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(d)(1) Prohibitions
With limited exceptions, FDCPA section 805(b) prohibits a debt
collector from communicating, in connection with the collection of any
debt, with any person other than the consumer (as defined in FDCPA
section 805(d)) or certain other persons. Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)
would implement FDCPA section 805(b) and generally restates the
statute, with minor wording and organizational changes for clarity.
Proposed comment 6(d)(1)-1 explains that, because a limited-content
message is not a communication, a debt collector does not violate Sec.
1006.6(d)(1) if the debt collector leaves a limited-content message for
a consumer orally with a third party who answers the consumer's home or
mobile telephone.\231\ The comment explains that the message would be
an attempt to communicate with the consumer (as defined in proposed
Sec. 1006.2(b)). It further explains, however, that if, during the
course of the interaction with the third party, the debt collector
conveys content other than the specific limited-content-message items
described in proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) and (2), and such other
content directly or indirectly conveys any information regarding a
debt, the message is a communication, subject to the prohibition on
third-party communications in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1). The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1) and on whether
additional clarification would be useful.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\231\ The Bureau separately requests comment in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) defining limited-
content messages on whether to permit a debt collector to leave
limited-content messages with third parties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(d)(2) Exceptions
FDCPA section 805(b) specifies exceptions to the general
prohibition against a debt collector communicating with third parties,
including that a debt collector may engage in an otherwise prohibited
communication with the prior consent of the consumer given directly to
the debt collector. Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(2) would implement the
exceptions in FDCPA section 805(b) and generally restates the statute,
with minor wording and organizational changes for clarity. Proposed
comment 6(d)(2)-1 refers to the commentary to proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(4)(i) for guidance concerning a consumer giving prior consent
directly to a debt collector. Additionally, because the definition of
consumer for purposes of proposed Sec. 1006.6 includes those
individuals listed in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a)(1) through (5) (e.g.,
the consumer's spouse), the Bureau requests comment on whether
additional clarification is needed regarding which consumer under
proposed Sec. 1006.6(a) may give prior consent pursuant to proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d).
6(d)(3) Reasonable Procedures for Email and Text Message Communications
FDCPA section 813(c) provides that a debt collector may not be held
liable in any action brought under the FDCPA if the debt collector
shows by a preponderance of evidence that the violation was not
intentional, that it resulted from a bona fide error, and that it
occurred even though the debt collector maintained procedures
reasonably adapted to avoid the error.\232\ Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)
identifies procedures that a debt collector may use to obtain a safe
harbor from civil liability for unintentionally violating the third-
party disclosure prohibition in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1) and, by
extension, FDCPA section 805(b), as a result of a bona fide error
resulting from a communication by email or text message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\232\ 15 U.S.C. 1692k(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FDCPA section 805(b) generally prohibits a debt collector from
communicating with any person other than the consumer unless the
consumer provides consent directly to the debt collector. FDCPA section
803(2), in turn, defines the term communication to include the
conveying of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any
person.\233\ In the context of oral communications, courts have found
that, if a debt collector leaves a voice message that is overheard by a
third party, the debt collector may violate FDCPA section 805(b) by
indirectly conveying information regarding a debt to a person other
than the consumer.\234\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\233\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(d).
\234\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(j).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23300]]
While nothing in the FDCPA prohibits debt collectors from
communicating using newer communication media such as email and text
messages, the case law regarding communications has given rise to
uncertainty about how FDCPA section 805(b) applies to such media,
because of the potential for inadvertent disclosure of communications
to third parties. In pre-proposal feedback, several industry
stakeholders asserted that this uncertainty, particularly about
liability for third-party disclosures, discourages the use of
electronic communications in debt collection.\235\ Consistent with this
feedback, the Bureau's Consumer Survey found that only 8 percent of
consumers contacted by a debt collector were contacted by email--even
though email is widely available and less expensive than other forms of
communication, and 15 percent of surveyed consumers said that email was
their most preferred method of being contacted about a debt in
collection.\236\ In pre-proposal feedback, industry participants
expressed interest in communicating with consumers using electronic
technologies. They therefore requested that the Bureau clarify how
FDCPA section 805(b) applies to the inadvertent disclosure of an
electronic communication to a third party not authorized to receive
it.\237\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\235\ An industry trade association commenting on the Bureau's
ANPRM surveyed its members and found that only 15 percent of
respondents communicated electronically with consumers, primarily
because of concerns about liability. A later study by a consulting
firm, released in 2017, reported that about one-third of debt
collectors communicate with consumers by email. Ernst & Young, The
Impact of Third-Party Debt Collection on the US National and State
Economies in 2016: Prepared for ACA Int'l, at 5 (Nov. 2017), https://www.acainternational.org/assets/ernst-young/ey-2017-aca-state-of-the-industry-report-final-5.pdf; see also Gov't Accountability Off.,
No. GAO-09-748, Fair Debt Collection Practices Act Could Better
Reflect the Evolving Debt Collection Marketplace and Use of
Technology, at 48 (Sept. 2009), https://www.gao.gov/assets/300/295588.pdf (``Debt collection agencies have been reluctant to use
email and faxes to communicate with debtors because of the risk that
someone other than the debtor may read the transmission, which could
violate FDCPA's prohibition on disclosure to third parties.'').
\236\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 37, 42.
\237\ For example, one industry trade association suggested that
the Bureau establish a presumption against liability when debt
collectors use consumer-provided email addresses and telephone
numbers. In addition, a Federal regulator recently recommended that
the Bureau ``codify that reasonable digital communications,
especially when they reflect a consumer's preferred method, are
appropriate for use in debt collection.'' U.S. Dept. of Treasury, A
Financial System that Creates Economic Opportunities: Nonbank
Financials, FinTech, and Innovation, at 21 (July 2018), https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm447.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In light of this feedback and evidence suggesting that some
consumers may prefer debt collectors to communicate by newer media, the
Bureau proposes to identify procedures that debt collectors may use to
reduce the risk of liability from communicating with consumers by email
or text message. Pursuant to its authority to implement and interpret
FDCPA sections 805(b) and 813(c), the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) to specify when a debt collector maintains procedures that
are reasonably adapted, for purposes of FDCPA section 813(c), to avoid
a bona fide error in sending an email or text message communication
that would result in a violation of Sec. 1006.6(d)(1). A debt
collector would maintain such procedures if, when communicating with a
consumer using an email address or, in the case of a text message, a
telephone number, the debt collector's procedures include steps to
reasonably confirm and document that the debt collector: (1) Has
obtained and used the email address or telephone number in accordance
with one of the three methods specified in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i); and
(2) has taken the additional steps specified in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii).
The procedures in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) are designed to
ensure that a debt collector who uses a specific email address or
telephone number to communicate with a consumer by email or text
message does not have a reason to anticipate that an unauthorized
third-party disclosure may occur. The FTC staff and some courts have
found that debt collectors do not violate the prohibition on third-
party disclosures unless they have reason to anticipate that the
disclosure may be heard or read by third parties.\238\ Designing the
procedures around the reason-to-anticipate standard is consistent with
these principles. A debt collector who follows the procedures in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) may not have reason to anticipate that a
disclosure may be heard or read by a third party.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\238\ See, e.g., Statements of General Policy or Interpretation:
Staff Commentary on the FDCPA, 53 FR 50097, 50104 (Dec. 13, 1988)
(``A debt collector does not violate [FDCPA section 805(b)] when an
eavesdropper overhears a conversation with the consumer, unless the
debt collector has reason to anticipate the conversation will be
overheard.''); Peak v. Prof'l Credit Serv., No. 6:14-cv-01856-AA,
2015 WL 7862774, at *5-6 (D. Or. Dec. 2, 2015); Berg v. Merchants
Ass'n Collection Div., Inc., 586 F. Supp. 2d 1336, 1342, 1345 (S.D.
Fla 2008); Chlanda v. Wymard, No. C-3-93-321, 1995 WL 17917574, at
*2 (S.D. Ohio Sept. 5, 1995).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) would not fully eliminate a debt
collector's risk of liability for third-party disclosures. To be
protected from civil liability under FDCPA 813(c), a debt collector
would need to show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the debt
collector's disclosure to the third party was unintentional and that
the debt collector, in fact, maintained the specified procedures. As
proposed, this would require a debt collector to show that the
procedures included steps to reasonably confirm and document that the
debt collector acted in accordance with proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)
and (ii). For example, procedures that permitted a debt collector to
use obviously incorrect email addresses merely because the addresses
were obtained consistent with one of the three methods would not
satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)'s reasonableness requirement.\239\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\239\ In addition, a debt collector who communicates with a
consumer consistent with proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) would not be
protected from liability for violations unrelated to third-party
disclosures (e.g., for failure to include the opt-out notice that
proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would require).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The procedures in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) address email and
text message communications only. At this time, the Bureau does not
propose procedures related to the use of less-developed and less-
widespread forms of electronic communication because consumers do not
appear accustomed to using such technologies in their financial lives.
The Bureau may revisit this conclusion if consumer use of these
technologies changes. The Bureau also does not propose procedures
related to the use of voicemails. The limited-content message described
in proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) is designed to enable debt collectors to
leave voicemails for consumers without risking third-party disclosures.
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) does not identify the only
circumstances in which a debt collector may communicate with a consumer
by email or text message, nor does it identify the only procedures that
may be reasonably adapted to avoid a violation of proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(1) and FDCPA section 805(b). Thus, a debt collector would not
necessarily violate proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1) or FDCPA section 805(b)
if the debt collector communicated with a consumer by email or text
message without following the procedures in proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3). Depending on the facts, a debt collector could show by a
preponderance of the evidence that any third-party disclosures were
unintentional and that the debt collector employed procedures
reasonably adapted to avoid them.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3). In
particular, the Bureau requests comment on the risk of third-party
disclosure and resulting consumer harm posed by debt collection
communications that take place by email or text message. The
[[Page 23301]]
Bureau is especially interested in any data or other information
bearing on the harm associated with such disclosure. The Bureau also
requests comment on whether the procedures identified in proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) are likely to increase debt collectors' use of emails and
text messages to communicate with consumers. The Bureau also requests
comment on whether additional clarification is needed about the
requirement that a debt collector's procedures include steps to
reasonably confirm and document that the debt collector acted in
accordance with proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i) and (ii). In addition,
the Bureau requests comment on whether to clarify the meaning of the
term email in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3), such as by specifying that
it includes direct messaging technology in mobile applications or on
social media platforms.
6(d)(3)(i) Method of Obtaining and Using an Email Address or Telephone
Number
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i) describes three methods of obtaining
and using an email address or, in the case of a text message, a
telephone number. As discussed below, a debt collector whose policies
and procedures include steps to reasonably confirm and document
compliance with proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i) would be entitled to a
safe harbor from liability for an unintentional third-party disclosure
resulting from use of one of the three methods, assuming the debt
collector's procedures also include steps to reasonably confirm and
document compliance with proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii).
6(d)(3)(i)(A)
A debt collector who communicates with a consumer electronically
using an email address or telephone number that the consumer recently
used to contact the debt collector electronically may not have reason
to anticipate that the communication may be read by third parties with
whom the debt collector is not otherwise permitted to communicate about
the debt. This is because, the Bureau believes, a consumer generally is
better positioned than a debt collector to determine whether third
parties have access to a specific email address or telephone number,
and a consumer's decision to communicate electronically using a
specific email address or telephone number may suggest that the
consumer has assessed the risk of third-party disclosure to be low. For
this reason, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A) provides that a debt
collector could obtain \240\ a safe harbor from liability for an
unintentional third-party disclosure if the debt collector maintained
procedures to reasonably confirm and document that the debt collector
communicated with the consumer using an email address or, in the case
of a text message, a telephone number that the consumer recently used
to contact the debt collector for purposes other than opting out of
electronic communications.\241\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\240\ To be entitled to a safe harbor, the debt collector's
procedures also would need to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(ii).
\241\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(2), if a consumer opts out of receiving
electronic communications from a debt collector, the debt collector
would be permitted to reply once to confirm the consumer's request
to opt out, provided that the reply contains no information other
than a statement confirming the consumer's request. Proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A)'s safe harbor would not be available to a debt
collector who sends the reply to an email address or, in the case of
a text message, a telephone number that the consumer used only for
purposes of opting out of electronic communications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A) would apply to any email address
or, in the case of a text message, any telephone number--including any
work email address or any work telephone number--the consumer used to
contact the debt collector for purposes other than opting out of
electronic communications. As discussed in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3), the proposed rule generally
would prohibit a debt collector from attempting to communicate with a
consumer using an email address that the debt collector knows or should
know is maintained by the consumer's employer. Work emails appear to
present a heightened risk of third-party disclosure because many
employers have a legal right to read messages sent or received by
employees on work email accounts, and some employers exercise that
right. Text messages sent to a work telephone number appear to present
a heightened risk of third-party disclosure for the same reason.
However, some consumers may be in a position to assess the risk that an
employer will read their work emails or work text messages based on,
among other things, their knowledge of work policies and practices, so
it may be reasonable for a debt collector to presume that a consumer
who initiates an electronic communication with a debt collector using a
work email address or work telephone number has assessed that risk to
be low.
In addition, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A) would apply only if
the consumer recently used the email address or telephone number to
contact the debt collector. Telephone numbers frequently are
disconnected and reassigned from one person to another. In fact,
according to a recent Federal Communications Commission (FCC) notice of
proposed rulemaking, nearly 35 million telephone numbers are
disconnected and made available for reassignment each year.\242\ Given
the frequency with which telephone numbers are reassigned, it may be
reasonable for a debt collector to anticipate that sending a text
message to a telephone number that the consumer has not recently used
could result in the disclosure of sensitive information to third
parties--namely, persons to whom the consumer's telephone number has
been reassigned. Because a telephone number the consumer recently used
may be less likely to have been reassigned than a telephone number the
consumer used in the more distant past, proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A)'s recency requirement may limit the third-party
disclosure risk posed by the reassignment of telephone numbers.
Although email addresses do not appear to carry as great a risk of
reassignment as telephone numbers,\243\ for consistency and ease of
administration of the regulation, the Bureau nevertheless proposes to
apply the same recency requirement to email addresses.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\242\ Advanced Methods to Target and Eliminate Unlawful
Robocalls, 83 FR 17631, 17632 (Apr. 23, 2018) (``Consumers
disconnect their old numbers and change to new telephone numbers for
a variety of reasons, including switching wireless providers without
porting numbers and getting new wireline telephone numbers when they
move.'').
\243\ Although email addresses can be reassigned, the Bureau has
not identified evidence suggesting that reassignment happens
frequently. For example, one of the largest email providers states
it does not reassign email addresses. See Delete Your Gmail Service,
Google Account Help, https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/61177?co=GENIE.Platform%3DDesktop&hl=en (last visited May 6, 2019).
One industry report suggests that a majority of consumers have never
deactivated an email account. Direct Marketing Ass'n, Consumer Email
Tracker 2017, at 6 (2017), https://dma.org.uk/uploads/misc/5a1583ff3301a-consumer-email-tracking-report-2017-
(2)_5a1583ff32f65.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A).
In particular, the Bureau requests comment on what, if anything, a
consumer's decision to contact a debt collector using a work email
address or, in the case of a text message, a work telephone number may
suggest about the consumer's assessment of the risk of third-party
disclosure. The Bureau also requests comment on what, if anything, a
consumer's decision to contact a debt collector using a non-work email
address or, in the case of a text message, a non-work telephone number
may suggest about the consumer's
[[Page 23302]]
assessment of the risk of third-party disclosure. In addition, the
Bureau requests comment on the third-party disclosure risks to
consumers posed by the practice of reassigning telephone numbers. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether the recency requirement in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A) adequately addresses those risks,
and, if not, on how the Bureau could address them in a final rule. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on whether to apply the recency
requirement to emails. The proposed rule does not define when a
consumer's contact would qualify as recent. The Bureau therefore also
requests comment on whether and how to define recent in the context of
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A), including on whether contact by the
consumer in the past year should qualify as recent.
6(d)(3)(i)(B)
A debt collector may not have reason to anticipate that an
electronic communication to a consumer's non-work email address or non-
work telephone number may be read by third parties with whom the debt
collector is not otherwise permitted to communicate about the debt if
the consumer has received notice and a reasonable opportunity to opt
out of such communications, but the consumer has not done so. This is
because, the Bureau believes, a consumer's failure to opt out in these
circumstances may suggest that the consumer has assessed the risk of
such a disclosure to be low. For this reason, proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B) provides that a debt collector could obtain \244\ a
safe harbor from liability for an unintentional third-party disclosure
if the debt collector maintained procedures to reasonably confirm and
document that: (1) The debt collector communicated with the consumer
using a non-work email address or, in the case of a text message, a
non-work telephone number, after the creditor or the debt collector
provided the consumer with notice that the debt collector might use
that non-work email address or non-work telephone number for debt
collection communications and a reasonable opportunity to opt out; and
(2) the consumer did not opt out.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\244\ To be entitled to a safe harbor, the debt collector's
procedures also would need to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B) would apply only to non-work
email addresses and non-work telephone numbers; it would not apply to
work email addresses or work telephone numbers. A notice-and-opt-out
process may not be reasonably designed to prevent employers from
reading electronic debt collection communications sent to work email
addresses and work telephone numbers. Unlike a consumer's affirmative
decision to contact a debt collector using a work email address or, in
the case of a text message, a work telephone number, as described in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A), a consumer's failure to opt out of
the debt collector's use of a work email address or a work telephone
number may not indicate that the consumer has assessed the risk of
third-party disclosure to be low. Instead, it may reflect an
unwillingness to engage with a debt collector in any manner--even to
opt out of further communications--using a work email address or a work
telephone number.
Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)-1 would clarify that an email address
qualifies as a non-work email address unless the debt collector knows
or should know that the email address is provided to the consumer by
the consumer's employer. The proposed comment also refers to Sec.
1006.22(f)(3) and its related commentary for further clarification
regarding whether a debt collector knows or should know that an email
address is provided by a consumer's employer. The proposed comment also
would clarify that a telephone number qualifies as a non-work telephone
number unless the debt collector knows or should know that the
telephone number is provided to the consumer by the consumer's
employer.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)
and on comment 6(d)(3)(i)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on what, if anything, a consumer's failure to opt out of a debt
collector's use of a non-work email address or, in the case of a text
message, a non-work telephone number may suggest about the consumer's
assessment of the risk of third-party disclosure. The Bureau also
requests comment on what, if anything, a consumer's failure to opt out
of a debt collector's use of a work email address or, in the case of a
text message, a work telephone number may suggest about the consumer's
assessment of the risk of third-party disclosure.
6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) describes three requirements
that a debt collector using the notice-and-opt-out approach would need
to confirm and document had been satisfied. First, the creditor or the
debt collector would need to notify the consumer clearly and
conspicuously that the debt collector might use a specific non-work
email address or a specific non-work telephone number for debt
collection communications by email or text message. The creditor or the
debt collector may provide the notice orally, in writing, or
electronically, but, if provided electronically, the notice could not
be sent to the specific non-work email address or non-work telephone
number the debt collector seeks to use for future communications. This
limitation may help avoid a third-party disclosure through the notice
itself, which could occur if the opt-out notice were sent to the email
address or telephone number identified in the notice.
Second, the creditor or the debt collector would need to provide
the notice no more than 30 days before the debt collector engages in
debt collection communications by email or text message. This timing
component is meant to ensure that the consumer has made a decision
about whether to opt out, including based on the risk of third-party
disclosure, at a time reasonably contemporaneous with the proposed
electronic communications.
Third, the notice would need to identify the legal name of the debt
collector and the non-work email address or non-work telephone number
the debt collector proposes to use, describe one or more ways the
consumer could opt out of such communications, and provide the consumer
with a specified reasonable period during which to opt out before the
debt collector would begin such communications. The content of the
notice is meant to ensure that the notice includes enough information
for the consumer to make an adequately informed decision about whether
to opt out and, should the consumer elect not to opt out, to prepare to
receive any electronic communications.\245\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\245\ As explained below, the Bureau proposes comment
6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-2 to clarify that, when an opt-out notice is
provided orally, the creditor or the debt collector may require the
consumer to make an opt-out decision during that same communication.
As also noted below, the Bureau does not propose to specify what
would qualify as a reasonable opt-out period when an opt-out notice
is provided in writing or electronically; however, the Bureau
requests comment on this issue.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the procedures described in proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B) include steps to reasonably confirm and document
that the creditor or the debt collector provided the opt-out notice
described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1), they do not include
a requirement to provide the notice itself in writing. Proposed comment
6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-1 would clarify that the opt-out notice described in
Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) may be provided orally, in writing, or
[[Page 23303]]
electronically. The proposed comment also would clarify that the opt-
out notice must be provided clearly and conspicuously, as defined in
Sec. 1006.34(b)(1), and that, if the opt-out notice is provided in
writing or electronically, it must comply with the requirements of
Sec. 1006.42(a) for providing required disclosures.\246\ The Bureau
proposes comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-1 to provide consumers, debt
collectors, and creditors with the flexibility to satisfy the proposed
notice-and-opt-out requirements orally or electronically, which may be
more convenient or efficient in some circumstances.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\246\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1), that section would apply when debt
collectors provide certain required disclosures in writing or
electronically; it would not apply when debt collectors provide
those disclosures orally.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-2 would clarify how to provide
the opt-out notice described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) to
the consumer in an oral communication, such as in a telephone or in-
person conversation. The comment explains that, if a creditor or a debt
collector provides the opt-out notice orally, the creditor or the debt
collector may require the consumer to make an opt-out decision during
that same communication. Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-2 appears
consistent with industry practice in other markets for consumer
financial products and services, where consumers may commonly make
decisions about their communication preferences at one time, often at
origination.
Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-3 would clarify that a debt
collector or a creditor may provide the opt-out notice together with
other notices required under the rule. As discussed in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii) and (d), the
proposed rule would permit a debt collector to deliver required
disclosures by hyperlink if, among other things, the debt collector or
a creditor first provided the consumer with notice and an opportunity
to opt out. Because it may be more convenient and cost effective for
consumers, debt collectors, and creditors if consumers can make their
various communication preferences known at the same time, proposed
comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-3 would clarify that a debt collector or a
creditor may include the opt-out notice described in Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) in the same communication as the opt-out notice
described in Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) or (2), as applicable.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)
and its related commentary. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on whether to limit further the email addresses or telephone numbers to
which a creditor or a debt collector may send the opt-out notice that
would be required by proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) and, if so,
what those limitations should be. The Bureau also requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)'s requirement to provide the
notification no more than 30 days before the debt collector's first
communication pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B), including
on whether the period should be shortened or lengthened. The Bureau
also requests comment on whether to clarify, for purposes of proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1), what constitutes a reasonable period
within which to opt out when an opt-out notice is not provided through
a telephone conversation. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on
whether, in other consumer financial products and services markets,
consumers commonly make decisions about their communication preferences
during a single telephone call. The Bureau also requests comment on the
benefits and risks of allowing debt collectors and creditors to include
the opt-out notice described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) in
the same communication as the opt-out notice described in proposed
Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) or (2), as applicable.
6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2)
As discussed above, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) describes
requirements that a debt collector using the notice-and-opt-out
approach would need to confirm and document had been satisfied. One
such requirement is to provide the consumer with a reasonable period
during which to opt out of receiving debt collection communications by
email or text message to the non-work email address or non-work
telephone number identified in the opt-out notice. The consumer's
failure to opt out in these circumstances may suggest that the consumer
has assessed the risk of third-party disclosure to be low.\247\ For
this reason, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2) provides that, if the
opt-out period specified in the notice has expired and the consumer has
not opted out, the debt collector may use the specific non-work email
address or non-work telephone number to send debt collection
communications by email or text message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\247\ By contrast, as explained in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B), a consumer's failure
to opt out of a debt collector's use of a work email address or, in
the case of a text message, a work telephone number may not indicate
that the consumer has assessed the risk of third-party disclosure to
be low. When it comes to a debt collector's use of a non-work email
address or non-work telephone number, a consumer likely possesses
the information necessary to assess the risk of unwanted third-party
disclosure. With respect to work email addresses and telephone
numbers, however, a consumer who receives a debt collection
communication may not wish to engage with a debt collector in any
manner--even to opt out of further communications--using a work
email address or telephone number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2)-1 would clarify how proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2) would work with proposed Sec. 1006.14(h),
which would prohibit a debt collector from communicating or attempting
to communicate with a consumer through a medium of communication if the
consumer has requested that the debt collector not use that medium to
communicate with the consumer.\248\ Proposed comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2)-1
provides that, if a consumer requests after the expiration of the opt-
out period set forth in the Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) opt-out notice
that a debt collector not use the non-work email address or non-work
telephone number specified in that notice, Sec. 1006.14(h) would
prohibit the debt collector from communicating or attempting to
communicate with the consumer using that email address or telephone
number. Likewise, if the consumer requests after the expiration of the
opt-out period that the debt collector not communicate with the
consumer by email or text message, Sec. 1006.14(h) prohibits the debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with the
consumer by email or text message, including by using the non-work
email address or non-work telephone number specified in the Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) opt-out notice. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2) and its related commentary.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\248\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(h).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6(d)(3)(i)(C)
A debt collector who communicates with a consumer electronically
using the consumer's non-work email address or non-work telephone
number recently used by the creditor or a prior debt collector may not
have reason to anticipate that the communication may be read by third
parties with whom the debt collector is not otherwise permitted to
communicate about the debt. The Bureau has not identified data
suggesting that creditors communicate with consumers at non-work email
addresses or non-work telephone numbers that are generally accessible
to
[[Page 23304]]
such individuals. Further, the Bureau believes that a consumer's
decision to communicate with a creditor or a prior debt collector using
a non-work email address or non-work telephone number may suggest that
the consumer has assessed the risk of third-party disclosure to be low.
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C) provides that
a debt collector could obtain \249\ a safe harbor from liability for an
unintentional third-party disclosure if the debt collector maintained
procedures to reasonably confirm and document that: (1) The debt
collector communicated with the consumer using a non-work email address
or, in the case of a text message, a non-work telephone number that the
creditor or a prior debt collector obtained from the consumer to
communicate about the debt; (2) before the debt was placed with the
debt collector, the creditor or the prior debt collector recently sent
communications about the debt to the non-work email address or non-work
telephone number; and (3) the consumer did not request the creditor or
the prior debt collector to stop using the non-work email address or
non-work telephone number to communicate about the debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\249\ To be entitled to a safe harbor, the debt collector's
procedures also would need to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C) would apply only to non-work
email addresses and non-work telephone numbers. As noted above, some
employers monitor work email addresses, and some employers may also
monitor text messages sent to and from work telephone numbers. A
consumer might agree to receive electronic communications from a
creditor to a work email address or work telephone number without
regard to the risk that an employer might monitor or read those
communications because a consumer may not consider communications from
a creditor to be as sensitive as communications from a debt collector.
In other words, consumer consent to a creditor's use of a work email
address or, in the case of a text message, a work telephone number
might not mean that the risk of third-party disclosure is low.
Therefore, procedures that permit a debt collector to communicate using
a work email address or work telephone number merely because the
creditor communicated using that email address or telephone number
might not prevent unintentional disclosures of debt collection
communications to employers.\250\ Nor does the Bureau propose that a
prior debt collector's use of a consumer's work email address or work
telephone number would be sufficient to justify a later debt
collector's use of that email address or telephone number. Even if a
consumer had indicated to a prior debt collector that the risk of
monitoring by an employer was low, an employer's monitoring policies
and practices can change and debt collectors may differ in their
approach to communications with consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\250\ The special sensitivity of debt collection communications
is reflected in the law: The FDCPA regulates a debt collector's
communications at the consumer's place of employment, while consumer
credit origination and servicing laws, such as the Truth in Lending
Act, generally do not. See 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C) would apply only if the creditor
or a prior debt collector recently used the non-work email address or
non-work telephone number to send communications about the debt. The
Bureau proposes this recency requirement for the same reasons that it
proposes the recency requirement in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A).\251\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\251\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C),
including on how often creditors communicate with consumers using non-
work email addresses and, in the case of text messages, non-work
telephone numbers. The Bureau also requests comment on what, if
anything, a consumer's decision to communicate with a creditor or a
prior debt collector using a non-work email address or non-work
telephone number may suggest about the consumer's assessment of the
risk of third-party disclosure. In addition, the Bureau requests
comment on the third-party disclosure risks to consumers posed by the
practice of reassigning telephone numbers. The Bureau also requests
comment on whether the recency requirement in proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C) adequately addresses these risks, and, if not, on
how the Bureau could address them in a final rule. In addition, the
Bureau requests comment on whether to apply the recency requirement to
email addresses. The proposed rule does not define when a creditor's or
a prior debt collector's communication about the debt would qualify as
recent. The Bureau therefore also requests comment on whether and how
to define recent in the context of proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(C),
including on whether a communication by the creditor or a prior debt
collector in the past year should qualify as recent.
6(d)(3)(ii) Additional Requirements
To fall within the safe harbor from liability that proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) would establish for unintentional violations of proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d)(1) and FDCPA section 805(b), a debt collector's
procedures would not only need to include steps to reasonably confirm
and document that the debt collector obtained and used an email address
or, in the case of a text message, a telephone number consistent with
one of the three methods identified in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i),
but the procedures also would need to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(ii). Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii) would require a debt
collector to take steps to prevent communications using an email
address or telephone number that the debt collector knows has led to a
disclosure prohibited by Sec. 1006.6(d)(1).\252\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\252\ As noted above, even if a debt collector selects an email
address or telephone number in accordance with the procedures in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3), the debt collector would not be
permitted to communicate or attempt to communicate with a consumer
using that email address or telephone number if doing so would
violate another provision of the proposed rule, such as the opt-out-
notice requirements of proposed Sec. 1006.6(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii) on the basis that a debt
collector whose procedures are not designed to prevent recurrence of a
known violation may intend to convey information related to the debt or
its collection to a third party. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii), including on whether the procedures
described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(ii) are reasonably adapted to
avoid a violation of the prohibition on third-party disclosures in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1) and FDCPA section 805(b).
6(e) Opt-Out Notice for Electronic Communications or Attempts To
Communicate
The Bureau's proposal includes several provisions designed to
facilitate debt collectors' use of electronic communication media, such
as emails and text messages, when collecting debts. Some consumers,
however, may not wish to receive electronic debt collection
communications because, for example, they receive too many such
communications or because such communications force them to incur
charges.\253\ To address this concern, proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would
require debt
[[Page 23305]]
collectors to notify consumers how to opt out of receiving electronic
debt collection communications or communication attempts directed at a
specific email address, telephone number for text messages, or other
electronic-medium address.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\253\ CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at
36-37 (noting that almost one-half of consumers said they would most
prefer to be reached by written letter and that the second most
common preference for contact was through some kind of telephone
other than a work telephone).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau generally believes that the use of electronic media for
debt collection communications can further the interests of both
consumers and debt collectors. But electronic communications also pose
potential consumer harms. One potential harm relates to consumer
harassment. The FDCPA recognizes this harm in section 806, which
prohibits conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass,
oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the collection of a
debt. Because communicating with consumers electronically is
essentially costless, debt collectors may have little economic
incentive to limit the number of such communications. As discussed in
the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b), however,
repeated or continuous debt collection communications may have the
natural consequence of harassing, oppressing, or abusing the recipient.
In part for this reason, the proposed rule would establish bright-line
rules limiting the frequency with which a debt collector may place
telephone calls in connection with the collection of a debt. However,
the frequency limits in the proposed rule would not apply to emails or
text messages.\254\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\254\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b). Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) provides that, subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector violates Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)
by placing a telephone call to a particular person in connection
with the collection of a particular debt either: (i) More than seven
times within seven consecutive days, or (ii) within a period of
seven consecutive days after having had a telephone conversation
with the person in connection with the collection of such debt, with
the date of the telephone conversation being the first day of the
seven-consecutive-day period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another potential consumer harm relates to communication costs. The
FDCPA recognizes this harm in section 808(5), which prohibits debt
collectors from causing charges to be made to any person for
communications by concealment of the true purpose of the communication
and specifies that such charges include, but are not limited to,
collect telephone calls. Although many consumers have unlimited text
messaging plans, some do not.\255\ Consumers without unlimited text
messaging plans may incur a charge each time they receive a text
message, or each time they receive a text message that exceeds a
specified limit.\256\ For these consumers, receiving a text message
from a debt collector may be similar to accepting a collect call from a
debt collector.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\255\ According to one 2015 estimate, approximately 10 percent
of U.S. mobile telephone numbers are not enrolled in an unlimited
text plan. See Josh Zagorsky, Almost 90% of Americans Have Unlimited
Texting, Instant Census Blog (Dec. 8, 2015), https://instantcensus.com/blog/almost-90-of-americans-have-unlimited-texting.
\256\ The FCC has found, for example, that unwanted calls and
text messages can create substantial costs for consumers when
aggregated across many contacts. See, e.g., In re Rules &
Regulations Implementing the Tel. Consumer Prot. Act of 1991, 30
F.C.C.Rcd. 7961, 8021 (2015) (``In addition to the invasion of
consumer privacy for all wireless consumers, the record confirms
that some are charged for incoming calls and messages. These costs
can be substantial when they result from the large numbers of voice
calls and texts autodialers can generate.''), set aside in part by
ACA Int'l v. Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, 885 F.3d 687 (D.C. Cir. 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One way to help consumers address potentially harassing or costly
electronic communications or communication attempts is to provide them
with a convenient way to opt out of such communications. In pre-
proposal feedback, a debt collector and several consumer advocates
supported an opt-out requirement. An opt-out requirement also would be
consistent with several established public policies protecting
consumers who receive electronic communications.\257\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\257\ For example, with respect to emails, the Controlling the
Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography and Marketing (CAN-SPAM) Act
reflects a public policy in favor of providing consumers with a
specific mechanism to opt out of certain email messages. See 15
U.S.C. 7704(a)(3) (requiring that commercial emails include a
functioning return email address or other internet-based mechanism,
clearly and conspicuously displayed, for the recipient to request
not to receive future email messages from the sender at the address
where the message was received); Fed. Trade Comm'n, CAN-SPAM Act: A
Compliance Guide for Business (Sept. 2009), https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business (explaining that messages covered by the CAN-SPAM Act
``must include a clear and conspicuous explanation of how the
recipient can opt out of getting email from [the sender] in the
future''). In addition, the FTC's regulations implementing the CAN-
SPAM Act prohibit charging a fee or imposing other requirements on
recipients who wish to opt out of certain email communications. 16
CFR 316.5; see also Definitions & Implementation Under the CAN-SPAM
Act, 73 FR 29654, 29675 (May 21, 2008) (concluding that, to
implement an unsubscribe function, requests for personal information
are unnecessary).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would require a debt
collector who communicates or attempts to communicate with a consumer
electronically in connection with the collection of a debt using a
specific email address, telephone number for text messages, or other
electronic-medium address to include in each such communication or
attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous statement describing one
or more ways the consumer can opt out of further electronic
communications or attempts to communicate by the debt collector to that
address or telephone number. Proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) also would
prohibit a debt collector from requiring, directly or indirectly, that
the consumer, in order to opt out, pay any fee or provide any
information other than the email address, telephone number for text
messages, or other electronic-medium address subject to the opt-out.
The Bureau proposes to require debt collectors to provide consumers
with opt-out instructions to help ensure that a consumer who receives
written electronic communications from a debt collector can, with
minimal effort and cost, stop the debt collector from sending further
written electronic communications or communication attempts directed at
a specific address or telephone number.\258\ Proposed comment 6(e)-1
would clarify that clear and conspicuous under Sec. 1006(e) has the
same meaning as in Sec. 1006.34(b)(1) regarding validation notices and
provides examples illustrating the proposed rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\258\ For ease of reference, throughout the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(e), the Bureau uses the phrase
``written electronic communications'' to refer to emails, text
messages, and other electronic communications that are readable. The
Bureau's use of this phrase has no bearing on the Bureau's
interpretation of the terms ``written'' or ``in writing'' under any
law or regulation, including the FDCPA or the E-SIGN Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) seeks to address a group of concerns that
are unique to written electronic communications and attempts to
communicate. With respect to concerns about harassment from excessive
communications of other types, consumers likely know how to request
debt collectors to stop placing unwanted telephone calls, and proposed
Sec. 1006.14(h) would require debt collectors to honor such requests.
In addition, the frequency limitations in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)
would apply to telephone calls. Moreover, debt collectors are unlikely
to communicate by mail repeatedly because of the cost.\259\ With
respect to concerns about costs, consumers generally do not incur costs
when they receive written letters, whereas some consumers do incur
costs when they receive text messages. Accordingly, proposed Sec.
1006.6(e) would not apply to non-electronic communications and attempts
to
[[Page 23306]]
communicate with a consumer, such as letters. Nor would it apply to
telephone calls.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\259\ See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 7701(a)(1) (noting Congressional
finding, in connection with CAN-SPAM Act, that the ``low cost'' of
email makes it ``extremely convenient and efficient''); Arthur
Middleton Hughes, Why Email Marketing is King, Harv. Bus. Rev. (Aug.
21, 2012), https://hbr.org/2012/08/why-email-marketing-is-king
(``Direct mail costs more than $600 per thousand pieces. With email,
there are almost no costs at all.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While emails and text messages are common forms of written
electronic communications today, technology likely will evolve to
introduce newer forms of written electronic communications. Proposed
Sec. 1006.6(e) would apply to all written electronic communications,
regardless of whether they are specified in the rule and regardless of
whether they exist now or come to exist in the future. For example,
direct messaging communications on social media and communications in
an application on a private website, mobile telephone, or computer,
would be covered by proposed Sec. 1006.6(e).
In its Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau described a
proposal under consideration to require debt collectors, absent
consumer consent, to use free-to-end-user (FTEU) text messages so that
the debt collector, rather than the consumer, would incur any charge
for the message.\260\ On balance, however, requiring FTEU technology
may be too restrictive. FTEU technology may only be supported by
certain wireless platforms, and industry standards may only permit its
use with affirmative consumer consent.\261\ Requiring debt collectors
to use FTEU technology could therefore disadvantage some consumers by
preventing them from receiving text messages, even when text messages
are an equal or preferred medium of communication.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\260\ Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at
appendix H at 1.
\261\ According to one industry website, FTEU is supported by
six carriers (AT&T, Boost, Sprint, T-Mobile, Verizon Wireless, and
Virgin Mobile). iVision Mobile, Free to End User (FTEU), http://www.ivisionmobile.com/text-messaging-software/free-to-end-user-fteu.asp (last visited May 6, 2019); Mobile Mkt'g Ass'n, U.S.
Consumer Best Practices for Messaging: Version 7.0, at 43 (Oct. 16,
2012), https://www.mmaglobal.com/files/bestpractices.pdf (describing
FTEU ``Cross Carrier Guidelines'' as providing that ``[c]ontent
providers must obtain opt-in approval from subscribers before
sending them any SMS or MMS messages or other content from a short
code'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) and its
related commentary, including on the costs to debt collectors and
benefits to consumers. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on the
potential consumer harms posed by written electronic communications,
including the proportion of consumers in debt collection that do not
maintain unlimited text messaging plans and the cost to such consumers
of receiving text messages. The Bureau also requests comment on whether
consumers are likely to find it harassing, oppressive, or abusive to
receive written electronic communications, such as emails and text
messages, without having a simple mechanism to make them stop, and the
costs consumers incur when trying to unsubscribe from written
electronic communications that do not contain an unsubscribe option. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on whether to identify a non-
exclusive list of words or phrases that express an opt-out instruction.
In pre-proposal outreach, for example, one consumer advocate urged that
debt collectors be required to honor standard phrases, such as
``stop,'' ``unsubscribe,'' ``end,'' ``quit,'' and ``cancel.'' The
Bureau also requests comment on whether to specify the period within
which a debt collector must process a consumer's request to opt out
pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.6(e), and, if so, what that period
should be.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(e) as an interpretation of FDCPA
section 806 pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to
prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt
collectors. FDCPA section 806 prohibits conduct the natural consequence
of which is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with
the collection of a debt. It is essentially costless for debt
collectors to send written electronic communications, such as emails
and text messages, to consumers. Debt collectors may therefore have
little economic incentive to limit the number of such communications.
Individual consumers may find it harassing, oppressive, or abusive to
receive written electronic communications, such as emails and text
messages, without having a simple mechanism to make them stop. The
Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(e) to provide consumers with a way to stop
written electronic communications that they find harassing, oppressive,
or abusive.
The Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.6(e) as an interpretation of
FDCPA section 808 pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d)
to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt
collectors. FDCPA section 808 prohibits the use of unfair or
unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt. It may
be unfair or unconscionable for a debt collector to send a consumer a
written electronic communication, such as an email or text message,
without providing an unsubscribe option. Because written electronic
communications, such as emails and text messages, are essentially
costless for debt collectors, failing to provide consumers with an
unsubscribe option may lead to excessive written electronic
communications. In the absence of a convenient unsubscribe option, a
consumer who wishes to unsubscribe from written electronic
communications may incur time and cost doing so. The process may
require the consumer to write an unsubscribe request, search for and
identify the debt collector (an entity with whom the consumer may not
be familiar), obtain contact information for the debt collector, and
follow up with the debt collector if necessary. On balance, these costs
to consumers do not appear to outweigh the benefit to debt collectors
of omitting an unsubscribe option from written electronic
communications. Further, FDCPA section 808(5) specifically prohibits
debt collectors from causing charges to be incurred through the
concealment of the true purpose of a communication, and it specifies
that such charges include collect telephone calls. A debt collector who
sends a text message to a consumer who lacks an unlimited text
messaging plan may--similar to a debt collector who places a collect
call to a consumer while concealing the purpose of the call--cause the
consumer to incur communications charges that the consumer does not
wish to incur. The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.6(e) to limit written
electronic communications that cause consumers to incur such charges.
The Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.6(e) pursuant to its authority
under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to
ensure that the features of any consumer financial product or service
are fully, accurately, and effectively disclosed to consumers in a
manner that permits consumers to understand the costs, benefits, and
risks associated with the product or service, in light of the facts and
circumstances. A consumer's ability to opt out of written electronic
communications from a debt collector is a feature of debt collection,
and the opt-out instructions required by proposed Sec. 1006.6(e)
disclose that feature to consumers.
Section 1006.10 Acquisition of Location Information
FDCPA section 804 imposes certain requirements and limitations on a
debt collector who communicates with any person other than the consumer
for the purpose of acquiring location information about the
consumer.\262\ FDCPA section 803(7) defines the term location
information.\263\ The Bureau understands that there may be some
uncertainty regarding aspects of these provisions, such as how to
determine whether a debt collector who has acquired some information
about a
[[Page 23307]]
consumer's whereabouts no longer has the purpose of acquiring location
information when communicating with a person other than the consumer.
Such uncertainty may relate at least in part to broader issues
regarding the information debt collectors receive from creditors. The
Bureau will continue to consider these and other issues related to
location information communications to identify areas that pose a risk
of consumer harm or require clarification.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\262\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c.
\263\ 15 U.S.C. 1692a(7).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Accordingly, proposed Sec. 1006.10 would implement FDCPA sections
803(7) and 804 and generally mirrors the statute, with minor wording
and organizational changes for clarity.\264\ Proposed 1006.10(c),
however, would clarify that a debt collector who is subject to the
frequency restrictions in FDCPA section 804 also must comply with the
frequency restrictions in proposed 1006.14(b)--that is, the proposal's
limits on telephone calls also apply to location calls. The Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.10 pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by
debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\264\ For example, while no change in meaning is intended, the
proposal substitutes the phrase ``by mail'' for the phrase
``effected by the mails or telegram'' in FDCPA section 804(5) to
avoid obsolete language.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau also proposes two comments clarifying what is location
information in the decedent debt context. Proposed comment 10(a)-1
would clarify the definition of location information in the decedent
debt context by providing that, if a consumer obligated or allegedly
obligated to pay any debt is deceased, location information includes
the information described in proposed Sec. 1006.10(a) for a person who
is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. The
Bureau proposes this comment on the basis that, as discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(e) (definition of
consumer), the term consumer under the FDCPA includes deceased
consumers. A debt collector may obtain location information for such
consumers by obtaining location information for the person with the
authority to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. Proposed
comment 10(a)-1 would enable debt collectors who are trying to collect
a deceased consumer's debts to locate a person with the authority to
act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate, thereby facilitating
the prompt resolution of estates.
Proposed comment 10(b)(2)-1 would interpret FDCPA section 804(2) in
the decedent debt context. Proposed comment 10(b)(2)-1 explains that,
if the consumer obligated or allegedly obligated to pay the debt is
deceased, and the debt collector is attempting to locate a person with
the authority to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate, the
debt collector does not violate Sec. 1006.10(b)(2) by stating that the
debt collector is seeking to identify and locate a person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate.
In its Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, the FTC stated that it
would refrain from taking enforcement action under FDCPA section 804(2)
against debt collectors who state that they are seeking to locate a
person ``with the authority to pay any outstanding bills of the
decedent out of the decedent's estate.'' \265\ FDCPA section 804(2)
prohibits debt collectors communicating with third parties from stating
that the consumer owes any debt. The FTC believed that, unlike the word
``debts,'' a reference to ``outstanding bills'' would be unlikely to
reveal information about whether the deceased consumer was delinquent
on those bills because nearly all consumers leave some bills at the
time of their death.\266\ The Bureau is concerned that even references
to ``outstanding bills'' may convey that the consumer owes a debt
because the definition of ``debt'' in FDCPA section 803(5) broadly
includes ``any obligation or alleged obligation of a consumer to pay
money arising out of a transaction . . . primarily for personal,
family, or household purposes.'' Accordingly, the Bureau proposes to
limit debt collectors to asking for information about a person
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. However,
the FTC's phrase ``with the authority to pay any outstanding bills of
the decedent out of the decedent's estate'' may be more understandable
than the Bureau's proposed phrase ``who is authorized to act on behalf
of the deceased consumer's estate.'' The Bureau requests comment on
proposed comment 10(b)(2)-1, including on any experiences with the
language contained in the FTC's Policy Statement on Decedent Debt and
on whether the rule should follow the FTC's approach.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\265\ FTC Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, supra note 192, at
44918-23.
\266\ Id. at 44921 n.56.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.14 Harassing, Oppressive, or Abusive Conduct
FDCPA section 806 prohibits a debt collector from engaging in any
conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass, oppress, or
abuse any person in connection with the collection of a debt.\267\ It
lists six non-exhaustive examples of such prohibited conduct. Proposed
Sec. 1006.14 would implement and interpret FDCPA section 806. Except
with respect to proposed Sec. 1006.14(b) and (h), proposed Sec.
1006.14 generally restates the statute, with only minor wording and
organizational changes for clarity. Paragraph (a) and paragraphs (c)
through (g) of proposed Sec. 1006.14 are not addressed further in the
section-by-section analysis below.\268\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\267\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d.
\268\ Proposed Sec. 1006.14(a) would implement FDCPA section
806's general prohibition against conduct the natural consequence of
which is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with
the collection of a debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(c) through (g)
would implement FDCPA section 806(1) through (4) and (6) (15 U.S.C.
1692d(1)-(4), (6)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b) Repeated or Continuous Telephone Calls or Telephone Conversations
FDCPA section 806 generally prohibits a debt collector from
engaging in any conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass,
oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the collection of a
debt. FDCPA section 806(5) describes one example of conduct prohibited
by section 806: Causing a telephone to ring or engaging any person in
telephone conversation repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy,
abuse, or harass any person at the called number.\269\ Proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1) through (5) would implement and interpret FDCPA section
806(5)--and, by extension, FDCPA section 806 \270\--by restating the
language of section 806(5), with one clarification, and by proposing
numerical limits on the frequency with which a debt collector may place
telephone calls to a person. The proposed frequency limits include
certain exceptions and would establish whether a debt collector has
violated or has complied with FDCPA section 806(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\269\ 15 U.S.C. 1692d(5).
\270\ Because the conduct described in FDCPA section 806(5)
merely illustrates conduct that section 806 prohibits, proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) through (5) necessarily implements and
interprets both FDCPA section 806 and 806(5). For efficiency, the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) through
(5) focuses primarily on interpreting the language of FDCPA section
806(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For debt collectors collecting a consumer financial product or
service debt, as defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(f), proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1) through (5) also would identify an unfair act or practice
under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act and would prescribe
requirements for the purpose of preventing covered persons from
engaging in that unfair act or
[[Page 23308]]
practice.\271\ Although FDCPA section 806 and 806(5) and section
1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act define the conduct they proscribe
differently, in the interest of brevity, the discussion below generally
uses the catchalls ``harass'' and ``harassment'' to refer to the
conduct addressed by proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) through (5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\271\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1031 applies to covered persons and
service providers. Debt collectors collecting consumer financial
product or service debt are covered persons. 12 U.S.C. 5481(5), (6),
(15)(A)(x).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) through (5) pursuant to its
authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to
the collection of debts by debt collectors, as well as its authority
under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to
identify and prevent unfair acts or practices in connection with the
collection of a consumer financial product or service debt, as that
term is defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(f).
14(b)(1) In General
14(b)(1)(i) FDCPA Prohibition
FDCPA section 806(5) prohibits a debt collector from ``causing a
telephone to ring or engaging any person in telephone conversation
repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any
person at the called number.'' Since the FDCPA's 1977 enactment,
telephone-calling technology has evolved, and changes in technology may
create uncertainty about whether a debt collector has ``caus[ed] a
telephone to ring.'' It now is common to place a telephone call and be
connected to the dialed number without ever causing a traditional,
audible ring. For example, many telephones afford users the option to
have their telephones ring in the form of vibrating, visual, or
customized audio alerts. In addition, many callers, including many debt
collectors, now can bypass a person's opportunity to answer the
telephone by connecting directly to the person's voicemail. As a
result, debt collectors can place telephone calls or leave voicemail
messages for a person without ever causing a traditional, audible ring.
Such telephone calls, if made repeatedly and continuously, nonetheless
may be intended to harass or may have the effect of harassing a person
in ways that the FDCPA prohibits. For that reason, even if a debt
collector's telephone call may not cause a traditional ring, the
Bureau's proposal treats the call as within the scope of FDCPA section
806(5), or in any event within the scope of FDCPA section 806, if the
call is connected to the dialed number. Accordingly, the Bureau
proposes to interpret the prohibitions in FDCPA section 806 and 806(5)
as applying when a debt collector ``places'' a telephone call.\272\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\272\ As explained in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iii), the proposed rule also provides
that a debt collector's telephone calls that are unable to connect
to the dialed number do not count toward, and are permitted in
excess of, the frequency limits in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors, as well as pursuant to its authority to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 806 and 806(5), the Bureau
proposes to provide in Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(i) that, in connection with
the collection of a debt, a debt collector must not place telephone
calls or engage any person in telephone conversation repeatedly or
continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person at the
called number.
The Bureau proposes comment 14(b)(1)-1 to clarify that placing a
telephone call includes placing a telephone call that results in a
ringless voicemail (or ``voicemail drop'') but does not include sending
an electronic message (e.g., a text message or an email) to a mobile
telephone.\273\ The Bureau proposes this clarification because, given
the specific language of FDCPA section 806(5), the Bureau believes that
Congress may have intended for this provision to apply to
communications that present the opportunity for the parties to engage
in a live telephone conversation or that result in an audio message. In
addition, as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2), the Bureau understands that few debt collectors
contact consumers using such electronic messages and, as a result, that
debt collectors have not been sending electronic messages to consumers
repeatedly or continuously with intent to harass them or to cause
substantial injury. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) and on comment 14(b)(1)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\273\ Proposed comment 14(b)(1)-1 also would clarify that the
same interpretation of ``placing a telephone call'' applies with
respect to proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau also requests comment on whether to interpret FDCPA
section 806 and 806(5) as prohibiting debt collectors from using
communication media other than telephone calls frequently and
repeatedly with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person in
connection with the collection of any debt. For example, the Bureau
considered proposing a broader version of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) that would have prohibited repeated or continuous
attempts to contact a person by other media, such as by sending
letters, emails, or text messages. Under such an approach, contacts by
such other media also could be subject to a bright-line frequency
limit, similar to the structure for telephone calls in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2). The Bureau does not propose subjecting communication
media other than telephone calls to the prohibitions on repeated or
continuous contacts (or to bright-line limits on the number of
permissible contacts per week) primarily because the Bureau is not
aware of evidence demonstrating that debt collectors commonly harass
consumers or others through repeated or continuous debt collection
contacts by media other than telephone calls.
As to mail, the Bureau has received few complaints about debt
collectors sending excessive letters; in fact, available evidence
suggests that a significant percentage of consumers prefer to
communicate with debt collectors by mail.\274\ In addition, in feedback
to the Bureau after publication of the Small Business Review Panel
Outline, industry stakeholders and consumer advocates agreed that there
currently is not evidence of a need to regulate the frequency with
which debt collectors communicate with consumers or others by mail. The
cost of sending mail--currently about $0.50 to $0.80 cents to print and
mail a letter, as noted in part VI--is significantly greater than the
cost of making telephone calls and may deter debt collectors from
sending excessive communications by mail.\275\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\274\ Forty-two percent of respondents to the Bureau's Debt
Collection Consumer Survey who had been contacted about a debt in
the prior year identified mail as their preferred medium of
communication for debt collection. See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer
Survey, supra note 18, at 37.
\275\ The Bureau notes that the Commonwealth of Massachusetts's
debt collection regulations, which include communication frequency
limits for debt collectors and creditors, exclude postal mail from
those limits. See 209 Code. Mass. Regs 18.14(1)(d); 940 Code Mass.
Regs. 7.04(1)(f) (frequency limits apply to telephone calls and text
messages).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As to email and text messages, debt collectors generally have not
yet begun communicating with consumers using these or other newer
communication media.\276\ The Bureau thus is unaware of evidence,
including from consumer complaints or feedback from industry
stakeholders or consumer advocates, demonstrating that debt collectors
commonly use such media to contact consumers repeatedly or continuously
with intent to harass or with the effect of harassing them. Indeed,
both industry
[[Page 23309]]
stakeholders and consumer advocates have suggested that such media may
be inherently less harassing than telephone calls because, for example,
recipients may have more freedom to decide when to engage with an email
or a text message than with a debt collection telephone call.\277\
Although the Bureau currently is unaware of sufficient evidence of
consumer injury that would suggest a need for restricting the frequency
of email and text message communications, the Bureau recognizes that
the use of such media, if abused, could harass consumers in some of the
same ways as repeated or continuous telephone calls or telephone
conversations.\278\ The Bureau notes that proposed Sec. 1006.14(a)--
which generally prohibits any conduct the natural consequence of which
is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the
collection of any debt--would apply to harassment through media other
than telephone calls and could provide sufficient protection to
consumers. The Bureau requests comment on the proposed approach,
including on whether the frequency limits should apply to communication
media other than telephone calls and, if so, to which media.\279\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\276\ See generally the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d)(3).
\277\ As with mail, the Bureau notes that Massachusetts's debt
collection regulations do not limit the frequency of a debt
collector's email communications. See supra note 275.
\278\ Cf. Clements v. HSBC Auto Fin., Inc., Civ. A. No. 5:09-cv-
0086, 2011 WL 2976558, at *5 (S.D. W. Va. July 21, 2011) (``That
Plaintiffs were not at home all of the time and, therefore, could
not have heard each one of the calls is of little moment. They had
notice of every missed call through Caller ID. . . . Missed calls
communicate more than a phone number. They can, depending on volume
and frequency, communicate urgency and panic.'').
\279\ The Bureau notes in particular that the FCC has
interpreted a statutory reference to ``mak[ing] any call'' as
encompassing the sending of text messages. See In re Rules &
Regulations Implementing the Tel. Consumer Prot. Act of 1991, 18 FCC
Rcd. 14,014, 14,115 ] 165 (2003).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, the Bureau's proposal under
consideration to establish numerical limits on the frequency with which
debt collectors communicate and attempt to communicate with consumers
and others would have applied to all forms of communication media, not
just to telephone calls. Several small entity representatives suggested
that, in their experience, consumers increasingly prefer communicating
by email, and that excluding email from any frequency limits would
encourage debt collectors to use email instead of potentially more
harassing communication strategies, such as placing repeated telephone
calls. One small entity representative advised that using email to
contact consumers allowed it to greatly reduce its number of outbound
telephone calls, resulting in fewer consumer complaints and enabling it
to monitor communications for compliance with the FDCPA more easily. In
addition, small entity representatives suggested that written
correspondence (e.g., mailed letters) should be excluded from any
frequency limits. The Small Business Review Panel therefore recommended
that the Bureau consider whether the frequency limits should apply
equally to all communication channels.\280\ Limiting proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) and (2) to a prohibition against repeated and
continuous telephone calls should address small entity representatives'
concerns about a frequency limit that would apply to all types of
communication media.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\280\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(1)(ii) Identification and Prevention of Dodd-Frank Act Unfair Act
or Practice
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) to identify that a debt
collector who is engaged in the collection of a consumer financial
product or service debt, as that term is defined in proposed Sec.
1006.2(f), engages in an unfair act or practice by placing telephone
calls or engaging any person in telephone conversation repeatedly or
continuously, such that the natural consequence is to harass, oppress,
or abuse any person at the called number. The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii) on the basis that such conduct by debt collectors is
an unfair act or practice as described in Dodd-Frank Act section
1031(c) because, as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) below,\281\ the conduct causes or is
likely to cause substantial injury to consumers that consumers cannot
reasonably avoid and that is not outweighed by countervailing benefits
to consumers or to competition.\282\ The Bureau also proposes Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii) to provide requirements to prevent such an unfair act
or practice; specifically, under the proposal, a debt collector engaged
in the collection of a consumer financial product or service debt must
not exceed the calling frequency limits proposed in Sec.
1006.14(b)(2). The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) pursuant to
its authority under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe
rules to identify and prevent unfair acts or practices in connection
with the collection of a consumer financial product or service debt, as
that term is defined in proposed Sec. 1006.2(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\281\ Section 1006.14(b)(2) proposes bright-line frequency
limits that would determine whether a debt collector has violated
Sec. 1006.14(b)(1).
\282\ Section 1031(c) of the Dodd-Frank Act defines unfairness
without regard to a covered person's or service provider's intent.
For FDCPA-covered debt collectors who are collecting a consumer
financial produce or service debt, the Bureau's proposal therefore
identifies the unfair act or practice as repeated or continuous
telephone calls that have the natural consequence of harassment,
oppression, or abuse, without regard to the debt collector's intent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(2) Frequency Limits
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) sets forth bright-line frequency
limits for debt collection telephone calls. This section-by-section
analysis discusses the Bureau's proposal to establish bright-line
frequency limits generally; the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) and (ii) addresses the specific numerical
frequency limits that the Bureau proposes.
As noted, FDCPA section 806 prohibits a broad range of debt
collection communication practices that harm consumers and others, and
section 806(5) in particular prohibits debt collectors from making
telephone calls or engaging a person in telephone conversation
repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass.
Section 806(5) does not identify a specific number of telephone calls
or telephone conversations within any particular timeframe that would
violate the statute. In the years since the FDCPA was enacted, courts
interpreting FDCPA section 806(5) have not developed a consensus or
bright-line rule regarding call frequency.\283\ While several States
and localities have imposed numerical limits on debt collection
contacts, the limits vary, and the large majority of jurisdictions have
not established any numerical limits.\284\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\283\ See, e.g., Turner v. Prof'l Recovery Servs., Inc., 956 F.
Supp. 2d 573, 578 (D.N.J. 2013) (noting the lack of consensus or
bright-line rule); Neu v. Genpact Servs., LLC, No. 11-CV-2246 W KSC,
2013 WL 1773822, at *4 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 25, 2013) (same); Hicks v.
Am.'s Recovery Sols., LLC, 816 F. Supp. 2d 509, 515 (N.D. Ohio 2011)
(same).
\284\ For example, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and City of
New York generally limit debt collectors to initiating two
communications per week with a consumer. See 209 Code. Mass. Regs
18.14(1)(d) (limiting contacts by debt collectors); 940 Code Mass.
Regs. 7.04(1)(f) (limiting contacts by creditors engaged in debt
collection); N.Y.C. Admin. Code 5-77(b)(1)(iv) (limiting contacts by
debt collectors). The State of Washington generally limits debt
collectors to three total communications and one workplace
communication per week with a consumer. See Wash. Rev. Code
19.16.250(13)(a), (b). The States of New Hampshire and Oregon limit
the frequency of workplace communications. See N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann.
358-C:3(I)(c); Or. Rev. Stat. 646.639(2)(g).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also in the years since the FDCPA was enacted, technological
developments have intensified the
[[Page 23310]]
consumer-protection concerns underlying FDCPA section 806(5). In 1977,
placing a telephone call was typically a manual process that required a
caller to dial a telephone number one digit at a time. Since then, the
development of ``predictive dialers'' has enabled callers, such as debt
collectors, to load a large number of telephone numbers into a program
that automatically dials the numbers and, if the call is answered,
connects the call to a debt collector. Predictive dialers have
substantially reduced the cost to debt collectors of placing telephone
calls and have enabled debt collectors to place many more calls at a
very low cost.\285\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\285\ See In re Rules & Regulations Implementing the Tel.
Consumer Prot. Act of 1991, 30 F.C.C. Rcd. 7961, 8021 (2015)
(``Autodialers can quickly dial thousands of numbers, a function
that costs large numbers of wireless consumers money and
aggravation.''), set aside in part by ACA Int'l v. Fed. Commc'ns
Comm'n, 885 F.3d 687 (D.C. Cir. 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In light of these developments, and in the absence of a bright-line
rule about how many telephone calls is too many, numerous problems with
call frequency persist. Frequent telephone calls are a consistent
source of consumer-initiated litigation and consumer complaints to
Federal and State regulators. Consumers' lawsuits allege injuries such
as feeling harassed, stressed, intimidated, or threatened, and
sometimes allege adverse impacts on employment.\286\ In addition, from
2011 through 2018, the Bureau and the FTC received over 100,000
complaints about repeated debt collection telephone calls.\287\ Some
consumers submit narrative descriptions along with their complaints to
the Bureau, providing a window into their experiences with repeated
telephone calls. Some consumers describe being called multiple times
per day, every day of the week, for weeks or months at a time.\288\
Some consumers report that repeated calls make them feel upset,
stressed, intimidated, hounded, or weary, or that such calls interfere
with their health or sleep or--when debt collection voicemails fill
their inboxes--their ability to receive other important messages.\289\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\286\ See, e.g., Meadows v. Franklin Collection Serv., Inc., 414
F. App'x 230, 233-34 (11th Cir. 2011) (reversing district court's
dismissal of consumer's FDCPA section 806(5) claim where
``[plaintiff] testified that [the debt collector's] phone calls
eventually made her feel harassed, stressed, upset, aggravated,
inconvenienced, frustrated, shaken up, intimidated, and threatened
on occasion. And, several times the calls woke her up from sleep and
caused her difficulty sleeping.''); Roots v. Am. Marine Liquidators,
Inc., No. 0:12-CV-00602-JFA, 2012 WL 3136462, at *1-2 (D.S.C. Aug.
1, 2012) (awarding damages to consumer where, among other things,
``[p]laintiff testified that after his manager learned that
Plaintiff was getting repeated collection calls at work, they
treated him differently which caused him to seek out other
employment. Plaintiff took a new job in April, 2012, which resulted
in a pay reduction of $2.00 per hour for a period of 52 weeks. He
works 40 hours each week, for a total loss of income in the amount
of $ 4,160.'').
\287\ See 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 11, at 15-17;
2018 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 16, at 14-16; 2017 FDCPA Annual
Report, supra note 21, at 15-17; Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Fair
Debt Collection Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2016, at 18-19
(Mar. 2016), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201603_cfpb-fair-debt-collection-practices-act.pdf; Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2015, at 12-
14 (Mar. 2015), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201503_cfpb-fair-debt-collection-practices-act.pdf; Bureau of Consumer Fin.
Prot., Fair Debt Collection Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2014,
at 11-13, 19 (Mar. 2014), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201403_cfpb_fair-debt-collection-practices-act.pdf; 2013 FDCPA
Annual Report, supra note 9, at 17; Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act: CFPB Annual Report 2012, at 8
(Mar. 2012), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201203_cfpb_FDCPA_annual_report.pdf. This total reflects complaints
about all persons collecting debt, including creditors and other
first-party collectors in addition to debt collectors covered by the
FDCPA. For complaints submitted to the Bureau, complaint data
reflects the number of complaints that consumers self-identified as
being primarily about frequent or repeated debt collection
communications (consumers must choose only one topic when filing
their complaints). The Bureau has not attempted to identify the
specific number of communications-related consumer complaints that
it has received because many complaints that consumers self-identify
as being primarily about a different issue also may include concerns
about a debt collector's communication practices.
\288\ See generally Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Consumer
Complaints, https://data.consumerfinance.gov/dataset/Consumer-Complaints/s6ew-h6mp (last visited May 6, 2019).
\289\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When Congress conferred FDCPA rulemaking authority on the Bureau
through the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010, it relied, in part, on consumers'
experiences with repeated or continuous debt collection telephone calls
to observe that case-by-case enforcement of the FDCPA had not ended the
consumer harms that the statute was designed to address. In a 2010
report prepared in connection with the Restoring American Financial
Stability Act of 2010 (the Senate's predecessor bill to the Dodd-Frank
Act), the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs cited
consumer complaints to the FTC about, among other things, debt
collectors ``bombarding [them] with continuous calls'' to conclude that
abusive debt collection practices had continued to proliferate since
the FDCPA's passage.\290\ In connection with that finding, among
others, Congress granted the Bureau the authority to prescribe rules
with respect to the activities of FDCPA-covered debt collectors, as
well as to issue regulations to prevent and prohibit persons covered
under the Dodd-Frank Act from engaging in unfair, deceptive, or abusive
acts or practices.\291\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\290\ S. Rept. 111-176, at 19 (2010).
\291\ 15 U.S.C. 1692l; Dodd-Frank Act sections 1031(b), 1032; 12
U.S.C. 5531(b), 5532 (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers' experiences with, and complaints about, repeated or
continuous debt collection telephone calls do not necessarily establish
that the conduct in each instance would have violated FDCPA section
806(5). They do, however, suggest a widespread consumer protection
problem that has persisted for 40 years notwithstanding the FDCPA's
existing prohibitions and case-by-case enforcement by the FTC and the
Bureau as well as private FDCPA actions.\292\ To address this
persistent harm, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) to establish
bright-line rules for determining whether a debt collector has violated
FDCPA section 806(5) (and, in turn, FDCPA section 806), as implemented
and interpreted in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\292\ See, e.g., Complaint at ]] 63, 124-28, Fed. Trade Comm'n &
Consumer Fin. Prot. Bureau v. Green Tree Servicing LLC, No. 0:15-cv-
02064 (D. Minn. Apr. 21, 2015), https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/cases-proceedings/112-3008/green-tree-servicing-llc (alleging that
defendant violated FDCPA section 806(5) by, among other things,
having frequently called consumers between seven and 20 times per
day, every day, week after week); Complaint at ]] 20-22, 41, Fed.
Trade Comm'n v. K.I.P., LLC, No. 1:15-cv-02985 (N.D. Ill. Apr. 6,
2015), https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/cases-proceedings/152-3048/kip-llc-payday-loan-recovery-group (alleging that defendant violated
FDCPA section 806(5) by, among other things, ``call[ing] consumer
multiple times per day or night . . . over an extended period of
time''); Complaint at ]] 22, 50-53, Fed. Trade Comm'n v. Expert
Glob. Sols, Inc., No. 3-13 CV 2611-M (N.D. Tex. July 8, 2013),
https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/cases-proceedings/1023201/expert-global-solutions-inc-nco-group-inc (alleging that defendants
violated FDCPA section 806(5) by, among other things, ``call[ing]
multiple times per day or frequently over an extended period of time
[including,] for example, calling some persons three or more time
per day''); Complaint at ]] 80, 97(b), Fed Trade Comm'n v. Jefferson
Capital Sys., LLC, No. 1:08-cv-1976 BBM (N.D. Ga. June 10, 2008),
https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/cases-proceedings/062-3212/compucredit-corporation-jefferson-capital-systems-llc (alleging that
defendant violated FDCPA section 806(5) by, among other things,
``[calling] individual consumers in excess of twenty times per day,
in some cases, at intervals of only twenty to thirty minutes'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) provides that, subject to Sec.
1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector violates proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)
by placing a telephone call to a particular person in connection with
the collection of a particular debt either: (i) More than seven times
within seven consecutive days, or (ii) within a period of seven
consecutive days after having had a telephone conversation with the
person in connection with the collection of such debt, with the date of
[[Page 23311]]
the telephone conversation being the first day of the seven-
consecutive-day period.\293\ As discussed in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) and (ii), which addresses
the specific frequency limits that the Bureau proposes, the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors, its authority to implement and interpret
FDCPA section 806 and 806(5), and its authority under Dodd-Frank Act
section 1031(b) to prescribe rules to prevent Bureau-identified unfair
acts or practices in connection with any transaction with a consumer
for a consumer financial product or service.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\293\ Because proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) provides that a
debt collector engaged in the collection of a consumer financial
product or service debt must not exceed the calling frequency limits
proposed in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2), such a debt collector who exceeds
the frequency limits also would violate proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii). Separately, proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) provides
a parallel bright-line rule that debt collectors who place telephone
calls or engage in telephone conversations at or below the levels in
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) do not, based on their calling frequency,
violate the FDCPA, the Dodd-Frank Act, or Sec. 1006.14(b)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would apply not only to debt
collection calls placed to consumers who owe or are alleged to owe
debt, but to any person (with certain exceptions described below).
Congress recognized the potential harm from debt collectors placing
repeated or continuous telephone calls to persons other than consumers
when it enacted FDCPA section 806(5), which protects ``any person''
from repeated or continuous telephone calls or conversations made with
intent to annoy, abuse, or harass. Likewise, Dodd-Frank Act section
1031 applies to acts or practices ``in connection with a transaction
with a consumer for a consumer financial product or service'' (or ``the
offering of a consumer financial product or service''), provided that
``the act or practice causes or is likely to cause substantial injury
to consumers'' and meets the other criteria for unfairness. Like the
language of FDCPA section 806(5), the language of Dodd-Frank Act
section 1031 suggests that an act or practice may be unfair to
consumers generally, presumably even if the injury is to a consumer who
is not a party to the transaction creating the debt, so long as the
injury is ``in connection with'' a transaction with a consumer for a
consumer financial product or service. The frequency limits in proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) thus would apply to any person (with certain
exceptions described below), not only to the consumer who is alleged to
owe the debt.\294\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\294\ While proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would apply to ``any
person,'' the Bureau uses the term ``consumer'' throughout this
section-by-section analysis as a shorthand to refer both to
consumers, as defined by the FDCPA, and others who may be contacted
by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on the proposal to establish a bright-
line rule to determine when a debt collector's calling frequency has
violated FDCPA section 806(5) and the prohibition in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i), as well as to prevent an unfair act or practice under
Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b). As discussed, under such a bright-line
rule, a debt collector who exceeds the frequency limits would per se
violate FDCPA section 806(5) and the prohibitions in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1), while a debt collector who stays within the frequency
limits would per se comply with those provisions. In lieu of a bright-
line rule, it would be possible, for example, to have a rebuttable-
presumption rule. Under a rebuttable presumption, a debt collector who
exceeded the frequency limits presumptively would violate FDCPA section
806(5) and the prohibitions in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1), but the
debt collector would have the opportunity to rebut that presumption.
As discussed further in the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) below, the Bureau does not propose a rebuttable
presumption because the benefits of a rebuttable presumption approach
are unclear. It appears that most, if not all, of the circumstances
that might require a debt collector to exceed the frequency limits
could be addressed by specific exceptions to a bright-line rule.\295\
It thus appears that a well-defined, bright-line rule with specific
exceptions could provide needed flexibility without sacrificing the
clarity of a bright-line rule. A bright-line rule may also promote
predictability and reduce the risk and uncertainty of litigation. The
Bureau requests comment on this aspect of the proposal and on whether,
if a rebuttable presumption approach were adopted, the Bureau should
retain any of the exceptions described in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\295\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3) for a discussion of the Bureau's proposed exceptions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, the Bureau's proposal under
consideration would have applied to any of a debt collector's
communications or attempts to communicate. The Bureau's Small Business
Review Panel Outline noted that a bright-line rule could provide
exceptions for certain types of contacts, but the Outline did not
identify any particular exceptions that were under consideration.\296\
Small entity representatives suggested that contacts initiated by
consumers should not count toward the frequency limits, and the Small
Business Review Panel Report recommended that the Bureau consider
whether consumer-initiated contacts should be excluded.\297\ Proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would count only telephone calls that a debt
collector ``places'' to a person toward the frequency limits, which may
help to address small entity representatives' concerns about consumer-
initiated contacts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\296\ Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 25.
\297\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(2)(i)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) provides that, subject to the
exceptions in Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector violates Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) by placing a telephone call to a person more than
seven times within seven consecutive days in connection with the
collection of a particular debt. Under this bright-line rule, and
subject to the exceptions in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt
collector who places more than seven telephone calls to any person
within seven consecutive days about a debt would per se violate FDCPA
section 806 and 806(5) and the prohibitions in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1).\298\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\298\ Because proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) provides that a
debt collector engaged in the collection of a consumer financial
product or service debt must not exceed the frequency limits
proposed in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2), such a debt collector who places
more than seven telephone calls within seven consecutive days also
would violate Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii). Separately, under the
proposal, a debt collector who placed seven or fewer telephone calls
within a period of seven consecutive days would per se not have
placed telephone calls repeatedly or continuously to the person at
the called number. See the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's proposed frequency limits take into account a number
of competing considerations. One consideration is that, for many--
perhaps most--people, even a small number of debt collection telephone
calls may have the natural consequence of causing them to experience
harassment, oppression, or abuse, and therefore, assuming a debt
collector is aware of this effect, the debt collector's placement of
even a small number of such calls may indicate that the debt collector
has the requisite intent to annoy, abuse, or harass. In the Bureau's
Debt Collection Consumer Survey, nearly 90 percent of respondents who
[[Page 23312]]
said they were contacted more than three times per week indicated that
they were contacted too often; 74 percent of respondents who said they
were contacted one to three times per week indicated that that they
were contacted too often; and 22 percent of respondents who said that
they were contacted less than once per week indicated that even this
level of contact was too often.\299\ The effect on a consumer of a
single debt collector placing repeated or continuous telephone calls is
amplified by the fact that, according to the Bureau's research, almost
75 percent of consumers with at least one debt in collection have
multiple debts in collection, such that many consumers may receive
calls from multiple debt collectors each week.\300\ Debt collectors who
are aware that many consumers have multiple debts in collections and
that these consumers are already receiving telephone calls from other
debt collectors may be placing additional calls with intent to annoy,
abuse, or harass those consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\299\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 31. Consumers were asked ``How often did this creditor or debt
collector usually try to reach you each week, including times they
did not reach you?'' Response options included: Less than once per
week; one to three times per week; four to seven times per week;
eight to 14 times per week; 15 to 21 times per week; and more than
21 times per week. A separate question asked consumers whether the
debt collector had contacted them too often. Survey respondents had
the option of indicating that they were not sure whether contacts
had come from a debt collector, creditor, or another source. The
data reflects responses given by any respondent who reported being
contacted about a debt in collection. Limitations on the survey data
include that respondents were not asked to distinguish between
contact attempts and actual contacts and were not asked to specify
whether they already had spoken with the debt collector who was
trying to contact them. Id. at 30-31.
\300\ Id. at 13, table 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the same time, debt collectors have a legitimate interest in
reaching consumers. The FDCPA's purposes include ``eliminat[ing]
abusive debt collection practices by debt collectors'' and ensuring
that debt collectors who refrain from such practices ``are not
competitively disadvantaged.'' \301\ The FDCPA does not contemplate
that the elimination of abusive practices entails the elimination of
``the effective collection of debts.'' \302\ Communicating with
consumers is central to debt collectors' ability to recover amounts
owed to creditors. Debt collectors typically must make multiple
attempts before establishing what in industry parlance is referred to
as ``right-party contact''--that is, before they actually speak to a
consumer. Too greatly restricting the ability of debt collectors and
consumers to communicate with one another could prevent debt collectors
from establishing right-party contact and resolving debts, even when
doing so is in the interests of both consumers and debt collectors. For
example, during the SBREFA process, small entity representatives
reported that consumers who do not communicate with a debt collector
may have negative information furnished to consumer reporting agencies
or may face additional fees or a collection lawsuit, which can entail
the financial or opportunity cost of the lawsuit or subject a consumer
to wage garnishment. And as much as some consumers might prefer to
avoid speaking to debt collectors, many consumers benefit from
communications that enable them to promptly resolve a debt through
partial or full payment or an acknowledgement that the consumer does
not owe some or all of the alleged debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\301\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(e) (emphasis added).
\302\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau also has considered whether debt collectors' reliance on
making repeated telephone calls to establish contact with consumers
could be reduced by other aspects of the proposed rule that are
designed to address legal ambiguities regarding how and when debt
collectors may communicate with consumers. For example, as discussed
above, debt collectors who leave voicemails for consumers currently
face a dilemma about whether to risk liability under FDCPA sections
806(6) and 807(11) by omitting disclosures required under those
sections, or risk liability under FDCPA section 805(b) by including the
disclosures and potentially disclosing a debt to a third party who
might overhear the message. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) seeks to address
that dilemma by defining a limited-content message that debt collectors
may leave for consumers without violating FDCPA sections 805(b),
806(6), or 807(11). Permitting such messages should ensure that debt
collectors can leave voicemails with a return call number for a
consumer to use at the consumer's convenience, which may help reduce
the need for debt collectors to place repeated telephone calls to
contact consumers.\303\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\303\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(j) for a full discussion of the proposed limited-content
message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another legal ambiguity regarding how and when debt collectors may
communicate with consumers is that the FDCPA does not address how debt
collectors may use electronic communication media such as emails or
text messages to communicate. The Bureau's proposals in Sec. Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) and 1006.42 are designed to clarify that ambiguity so that
debt collectors may communicate electronically with consumers who
prefer to communicate that way. Further, for the reasons discussed in
the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1), the
Bureau does not propose subjecting email, text messages, or other
electronic communications to the proposed frequency limits.
Taking all of these factors into account, the Bureau proposes to
draw the line at which a debt collector places telephone calls
repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any
person at the called number (and the line at which such calls have the
natural consequence of harassing, oppressing, or abusing any person)
\304\ at seven telephone calls in a seven-day period about a particular
debt. The proposal would allow debt collectors to call up to seven
times per week across multiple telephone numbers (e.g., a home
landline, mobile, and work), and to leave a limited-content message
each time. It also would not limit how many mailed letters, emails, and
text messages debt collectors could send. At the same time, by making
clear that debt collectors cannot call consumers more than seven times
each week about a particular debt in collection, the proposal would
protect consumers and others from being harmed by debt collectors
making repeated or continuous telephone calls with intent to annoy,
abuse, or harass.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\304\ Litt v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs. LLC, 146 F. Supp. 3d
857, 873 (E.D. Mich. 2015) (``[W]hile the general proscription of
Sec. 1692d does not use the word `intent,' such a requirement is
inferred from the necessity to establish that the natural tendency
of the conduct is to embarrass, upset or frighten a debtor. If the
natural tendency of certain conduct is to embarrass, upset or
frighten, then one who engages in such conduct can be presumed to
have intended the natural consequences of his act.''); see also
United States v. Falstaff Brewing Corp., 410 U.S. 526, 570 n.22
(1973) (Marshall, J., concurring in result) (``[P]erhaps the oldest
rule of evidence--that a man is presumed to intend the natural and
probable consequences of his acts--is based on the common law's
preference for objectively measurable data over subjective
statements of opinion and intent.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the reasons discussed above, the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i) to provide that, subject to proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector violates proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) by placing more than seven telephone calls within
seven consecutive days to a particular person in connection with the
collection of a particular debt. Proposed comment 14(b)(2)(i)-1
provides illustrative examples of the proposed rule.\305\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\305\ The examples would clarify how the proposed rule would
apply to calls to consumers or to third parties. The Bureau
understands that debt collectors may make location calls to several
numbers, but that location calls do not generally involve frequently
calling each number. Therefore the Bureau does not expect that debt
collectors would be affected by the proposed limits as they apply to
location calls made to third parties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23313]]
Proposed comment 14(b)(2)(i)-2 would clarify how to determine the
number of telephone calls a debt collector has placed if the debt
collector learns that the telephone number that the debt collector
previously used to call a person is not, in fact, that person's number.
The comment would clarify that telephone calls placed to the wrong
number are not counted towards the frequency limit in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i) with respect to the person the debt collector is
trying to contact. The Bureau proposes this clarification because a
person is unlikely to be harassed by debt collection calls that are
placed to a number that belongs to someone else.
The Bureau requests comment on several aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i). First, the Bureau requests comment on the proposal to
set the frequency limit at seven telephone calls to a particular
consumer within seven consecutive days regarding a particular debt,
including on the harms to consumers that may be prevented by this limit
and on how such a limit may impact debt collectors. Some stakeholders
may take the position that this proposed line should be adjusted upward
or downward to account for certain concerns. Debt collectors and other
industry stakeholders have advised the Bureau that, today, they often
need to make more telephone calls than would be allowed under the
proposal in order to establish right-party contact; they have expressed
concern that a too-restrictive limit may hamper their ability to reach
consumers and collect debts. Consumer advocates have suggested that a
lower call limit is necessary to prevent harassment in part because
consumers with multiple debts in collection could receive multiple
calls about each debt each week; under the proposed limits, for
example, a consumer with four or five debts in collection could receive
up to two or three dozen telephone calls each week.\306\ Some consumer
advocates therefore have recommended that the Bureau prohibit a debt
collector from placing, for example, more than three telephone calls
per week to any one consumer, regardless of how many debts the debt
collector is trying to recover from that consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\306\ The proposed frequency limits generally would apply per
debt in collection (see proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5)), and the
Bureau's research shows that a majority of consumers who have at
least one debt in collection have multiple debts in collection. For
example, 57 percent of consumers with at least one debt in
collection reported having between two and four debts in collection.
See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at 13,
table 1. Overall, the Bureau's research shows that almost 75 percent
of consumers with at least one debt in collection have multiple
debts in collection. See id.; see also CFPB Medical Debt Report,
supra note 20, at 20 (reporting that most consumers with one
tradeline have multiple tradelines).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau encourages commenters who believe the Bureau should set
a higher or lower limit to provide data supporting any recommended
numbers, such as data regarding the frequency of calls that debt
collectors currently make and how that frequency relates to the time
needed to establish right-party contact and payments received from
consumers. The Bureau also encourages commenters to provide data
demonstrating the marginal impact on consumers and debt collectors, as
well as on competition and the cost of credit, of adjusting the weekly
limit on telephone calls from the proposed seven calls per week to a
different number. To the extent that a commenter recommends a higher
limit on telephone calls to permit debt collectors to recover more
payments from consumers, the Bureau encourages the commenter to submit
data quantifying the benefits such increased recovery would have on
competition or consumers, such as by lowering the cost of credit. The
Bureau also requests data regarding the financial, emotional, or other
impact on consumers of calls from debt collectors at varying levels of
frequency. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on whether debt
collectors currently are able to, or under the proposed rule would
expect to be able to, establish right-party contact through voicemails
or electronic media, such that debt collectors may have less of a need
to place repeated telephone calls to consumers.
Second, the Bureau requests comment on the proposal to measure the
frequency of telephone calls on a per-week basis. This framework could
result in debt collectors placing, for example, seven telephone calls
about one debt to a consumer in one day. The Bureau considered
combining a seven-day frequency limit with a per-day frequency limit
that would have prohibited, for example, more than one telephone call
to a consumer per debt per day, up to a limit of seven telephone calls
per consumer per debt every seven days. The Bureau does not propose a
combined daily and weekly limit because, while such an approach would
eliminate multiple telephone calls about a single debt on any given
day, it might not provide flexibility for unforeseen situations or the
need to attempt to contact some consumers at different telephone
numbers and at different times of the day. It also is not clear that
many debt collectors would respond to the proposed weekly limit on
telephone calls by placing all of their permitted calls in rapid
succession, thus foregoing the opportunity to call the consumer at a
different time of day or on a different day of the week for the
following seven days. Further, a rule with both daily and weekly
frequency limits would sacrifice the ease of implementing and
monitoring one frequency limit. The Bureau requests comment on its
approach and on the merits of limiting telephone calls based on a
different time period (e.g., by day, by month, or through a combination
of time periods).
Third, the Bureau requests comment on the proposal to apply
frequency limits on a per-debt, rather than on a per-consumer,
basis.\307\ As proposed, Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) could permit, for
example, a debt collector who is attempting to collect two debts from
the same consumer to place up to 14 telephone calls in one week to that
consumer without violating the FDCPA, the Dodd-Frank Act, or Regulation
F based on the frequency of its calling. The Bureau requests comment on
this aspect of the proposal, which also is discussed further in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\307\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5), with respect to student loan debts,
all debts that a consumer owes or allegedly owes that were serviced
under a single account number at the time the debts were obtained by
the debt collector would be treated as a single debt for purposes of
the frequency limits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fourth, the Bureau requests comment on the proposal to count
telephone calls placed about a particular debt to different telephone
numbers associated with the same consumer together for purposes of
determining whether a debt collector has exceeded the limit in proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) (i.e., an aggregate approach). The Bureau
considered a proposal that would have limited the number of calls
permitted to any particular telephone number (e.g., at most two calls
to each of a consumer's landline, mobile, and work telephone numbers).
The Bureau considered such a limit either instead of or in addition to
an overall limit on the frequency of telephone calls to one consumer.
The Bureau instead proposes an aggregate approach because of concerns
that a more prescriptive, per-telephone number approach could produce
undesirable results--for example, some consumers could receive (and
some debt collectors could place) more telephone calls simply based on
the number of telephone numbers that certain consumers happened to have
(and that
[[Page 23314]]
debt collectors happened to know about). Such an approach also could
incentivize debt collectors to place telephone calls to less convenient
telephone numbers after exhausting their telephone calls to consumers'
preferred numbers. The Bureau requests comment on the merits of an
aggregate versus a per-telephone number limit.
Finally, the Bureau requests comment on proposed comment
14(b)(2)(i)-2. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether
the Bureau should provide additional clarification about how a debt
collector determines that a telephone number is not associated with a
particular person, or whether, for purposes of the proposed frequency
limits, there is an alternative way to treat telephone calls
inadvertently made to the wrong person.
The Bureau's Small Business Review Panel Outline described a
proposal under consideration that would have limited a debt collector's
weekly contact attempts with consumers by any communication medium.
Before a debt collector confirmed contact with a consumer, the proposal
under consideration would have imposed weekly limits of (i) three
contact attempts per unique communication medium and (ii) six total
contact attempts. After confirming contact with the consumer, a debt
collector would have been subject to weekly limits of (i) two contact
attempts per unique communication medium and (ii) three total contact
attempts.\308\ Many small entity representatives expressed a strong
preference for bright-line, simplified rules. Many also stated that the
proposal under consideration would inhibit communications between debt
collectors and consumers and extend the time necessary to reach
consumers. In particular, small entity representatives stated that they
regularly attempt to contact consumers more than seven times per week
when trying to establish right-party contact. Small entity
representatives suggested several exceptions to the proposal under
consideration, including telephone calls about which a consumer was
unaware because, for example, the telephone number called was not, in
fact, associated with that consumer.\309\ In its report, the Small
Business Review Panel recommended, among other things, that the Bureau
consider whether the frequency limits should apply equally to all
communication media (e.g., telephone, postal mail, email, text
messages, and other newer communication media).\310\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\308\ The proposals under consideration described in the Small
Business Review Panel Outline would have applied the same limits for
contact attempts to individuals other than the consumer, except that
all third-party contact attempts would have been prohibited after
the debt collector had successfully contacted the consumer, on the
theory that the debt collector at that point would have had no
reason to continue to engage in third-party outreach. The Bureau's
proposal does not include the aspect of the Small Business Review
Panel Outline that would have prohibited third-party contact
attempts after the debt collector had successfully contacted the
consumer. Proposed Sec. 1006.10, which would implement FDCPA
section 804's general prohibition against communicating more than
once with a person to obtain location information, may provide
sufficient protection regarding the making of location information
communications when location information has already been obtained.
\309\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
36-37.
\310\ Id. at 37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau considered the small entity representatives' feedback in
developing the proposed frequency limits and believes that proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) responds to many of the small entity
representatives' concerns. In particular, proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i) would permit a debt collector to place seven telephone
calls to a consumer in a seven-day period regarding a particular debt,
without a different numerical limit on the number of calls the debt
collector could make during a seven-day period after having established
initial contact with the consumer. The proposal thus avoids potential
ambiguities regarding when a debt collector has confirmed or lost
contact with a consumer and may represent the type of bright-line,
simplified approach that small entity representatives sought. The
proposal would not limit debt collectors to sending a particular number
of letters, emails, and text messages, and proposed comment
14(b)(2)(i)-2 would clarify that a telephone call to a number that the
debt collector later determines is not associated with the consumer
does not count toward the frequency limit. As discussed in the section-
by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the Bureau
proposes several other exceptions to the frequency limits in response
to small entity representatives' feedback.
As noted above, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) and its
related commentary pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d)
to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt
collectors, and as an interpretation of FDCPA section 806(5), because a
debt collector who places more than seven telephone calls to a
particular person about a particular debt within seven consecutive days
may have the intent to annoy, abuse, or harass the person.\311\ Some
debt collectors may, in fact, place more than seven telephone calls to
a person each week precisely because they believe that additional
telephone calls may cause sufficient harassment or annoyance to
pressure the person to respond or make a payment that the person
otherwise would not have made.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\311\ Calls in excess of this limit may have the natural
consequence of harassing, oppressing, or abusing a person at the
called number, and, as noted above, the Bureau assumes that debt
collectors intend the natural consequences of their actions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer
financial product or service debt, as defined in proposed Sec.
1006.2(f), the Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) pursuant to
its authority under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe
rules applicable to a covered person or service provider that identify,
and that may include requirements to prevent, unfair acts or practices
in connection with any transaction with a consumer for a consumer
financial product or service. To identify an act or practice as unfair
under the Dodd-Frank Act, the Bureau must have a reasonable basis to
conclude that: (1) The act or practice causes or is likely to cause
substantial injury to consumers, which consumers cannot reasonably
avoid; and (2) such substantial injury is not outweighed by
countervailing benefits to consumers or to competition.\312\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\312\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c), 12 U.S.C. 5531(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) to prevent \313\ the
unfair act or practice, identified in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(ii),
of placing, in connection with the collection of a consumer financial
product or service debt, telephone calls to any person repeatedly or
continuously such that the natural consequence is to harass, oppress,
or abuse any person at the called number. The Bureau proposes to set
the frequency limit at seven telephone calls within seven consecutive
days about a particular debt because such a limit appears to bear a
reasonable relationship to preventing the unfair practice.\314\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\313\ The Bureau has not determined in connection with this
proposal whether telephone calls in excess of the limit in proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) by creditors and others generally not covered
by the FDCPA would constitute an unfair act or practice under
section 1031(c) of the Dodd-Frank Act if engaged in by those
persons, rather than by an FDCPA-covered debt collector. The
Bureau's proposal does not address, for example, whether consumers
could reasonably avoid harm from creditor contacts or whether
frequent creditor contacts provide greater benefits to consumers or
competition.
\314\ Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(c). Some courts have held that
the consumer stated a claim under FDCPA section 806(5) where the
debt collector called, on average, more than seven times per week.
See, e.g., U.S. v. Cent. Adjustment Bureau, Inc., 667 F. Supp. 370,
376, 394 (N.D. Tex. 1986), aff'd as modified, 823 F.2d 880 (5th Cir.
1987) (per curiam) (holding that debt collector violated FDCPA
section 806(5) by, among other things, placing successive telephone
calls in a single day and calling at least one consumer four-to-five
times in a single day); Schwartz-Earp v. Advanced Call Ctr. Techs.,
LLC, No. 15-CV-01582-MEJ, 2016 WL 899149, at *4 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 9,
2016) (denying debt collector's summary judgment motion where the
debt collector called the consumer ``multiple times a day, with as
many as five calls in a day,'' and remarking that ``the volume and
pattern of calls alone is sufficient to raise a genuine dispute of
material fact''); Neu v. Genpact Servs., LLC, No. 11-CV-2246 W KSC,
2013 WL 1773822, at *4 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 25, 2013) (holding that 150
telephone calls in 51 days raised a triable issue of fact as to the
debt collector's intent to harass and observing that ``[a]
reasonable trier of fact could find that [calling the consumer six
times in one day] alone, apart from the sheer volume of calls placed
by [the debt collector], is sufficient to find that [the debt
collector] had the `intent to annoy, abuse or harass' ''); Forrest
v. Genpact Servs., LLC, 962 F. Supp. 2d 734, 737 (M.D. Pa. 2013)
(holding that consumer stated a claim under FDCPA section 806(5) by
alleging that debt collector called the consumer 225 times within 54
days); Bassett v. I.C. Sys., Inc., 715 F. Supp. 2d 803, 810 (N.D.
Ill. 2010) (denying debt collector's summary judgment motion where
debt collector called the consumer 31 times in 12 days).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23315]]
Consumers may suffer or be likely to suffer substantial injury from
repeated or continuous debt collection telephone calls. Consumers have
alleged in complaints lodged with the FTC and the Bureau, and in
litigation, that such telephone calls can cause them, among other
things, to suffer great emotional distress and anxiety, and that such
calls can interfere with their health or sleep.\315\ Consumers may pay
debts that they otherwise might not have paid simply to stop the
telephone calls. For example, consumers may pay debts that they do not
owe or to which they have legal defenses; pay debts using funds that
are exempt from collection; or pay the particular debt being collected
instead of other debts or expenses that the consumer otherwise would
prioritize, such as a secured or nondischargable debt or expenses for
food, shelter, clothing, or medical treatment. A debt collector's
telephone calls also may cause some consumers to incur charges on their
mobile telephones.\316\ Although the charge for an individual call may
be minimal, the FCC has found that ``[t]hese costs can be substantial''
when aggregated across all consumers,\317\ which is consistent with the
FTC's and the Bureau's approach of aggregating all injuries (including
small injuries) caused by a practice to determine whether the practice
is unfair.\318\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\315\ See supra notes 286 and 287.
\316\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(e).
\317\ Fed. Comms. Comm'n, In re Rules & Regulations Implementing
the Tel. Consumer Prot. Act of 1991, 30 FCC Rcd. 7961, 8020 ] 118
(2015) (``In addition to the invasion of consumer privacy for all
wireless consumers, the record confirms that some are charged for
incoming calls and messages. These costs can be substantial when
they result from the large numbers of voice calls and texts
autodialers can generate.'').
\318\ Fed. Trade. Comm'n v. Pantron I Corp., 33 F.3d 1088, 1102-
03 (9th Cir. 1994) (``Both the Commission and the courts have
recognized that consumer injury is substantial when it is the
aggregate of many small individual injuries.'') (citing Orkin
Exterminating Co. v. Fed. Trade. Comm'n, 849 F.2d 1354, 1365 (11th
Cir. 1988)); FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness, supra note 100, at
1073 n.12 (``An injury may be sufficiently substantial . . . if it
does a small harm to a large number of people, or if it raises a
significant risk of concrete harm.''); Bureau of Consumer Fin.
Prot., CFPB Examination Procedures, Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive
Acts or Practices, at 2 (Oct. 2012), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/documents/4576/102012_cfpb_unfair-deceptive-abusive-acts-practices-udaaps_procedures.pdf (``An act or practice
that causes a small amount of harm to a large number of people may
be deemed to cause substantial injury.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers may not be reasonably able to avoid the substantial
injuries that could stem from frequent or repeated debt collection
telephone calls. Many consumers carry their mobile telephones at all
times to coordinate essential tasks or to be available in case of
emergency.\319\ Consumers also may share their mobile or landline
telephones with family members. For these consumers, disengaging from
all telephone calls to avoid debt collectors may not be an option.
Moreover, courts have held that the ringing or vibrating alert caused
by a debt collector's calls can contribute to harassment by conveying a
sense of urgency to the consumer,\320\ which can overwhelm some
consumers, especially those with multiple debts in collection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\319\ See, e.g., Fed. Comms. Comm'n, In re Rules & Regulations
Implementing the Tel. Consumer Prot. Act of 1991, 30 FCC Rcd. 7961,
7996 ] 61 (2015) at 7996 ] 61 (``Indeed, some consumers may find
unwanted intrusions by phone more offensive than home mailings
because they can cost them money and because, for many, their phone
is with them at almost all times.'').
\320\ See, e.g., Clements v. HSBC Auto Fin., Inc., Civ. A. No.
5:09-cv-0086, 2011 WL 2976558, at *5 (S.D. W. Va. July 21, 2011)
(noting that ``[m]issed calls communicate more than a phone number''
and ``can, depending on volume and frequency, communicate urgency
and panic,'' but nevertheless finding that, based on the facts of
the case, plaintiffs had suffered minimal emotional harm); Bassett
v. I.C. Sys., Inc., 715 F. Supp. 2d 803, 807-810 (N.D. Ill. 2010)
(denying debt collector's summary judgment motion where debt
collector placed 31 telephone calls to a consumer's blocked
telephone and explaining that, although the consumer's telephone did
not ring, the consumer could still have been harassed because the
telephone displayed the incoming calls).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FDCPA section 805(c) provides, in part, that a debt collector
generally shall not communicate further with a consumer with respect to
a debt if the consumer notifies the debt collector in writing that the
consumer wishes the debt collector to cease further communication.\321\
Section 805(c), however, may be insufficient to permit consumers to
reasonably avoid injuries from repeated or continuous telephone calls.
First, many consumers may invoke the cease communication right only
after they are harassed. Second, some consumers, even if they are aware
of their rights, may not invoke them because ceasing communication
entirely could make it more difficult to resolve the debt and, in turn,
subject the consumer to other injuries. In particular, an unresolved
debt could cause the consumer to incur additional fees, interest,
adverse credit reporting, or, in the case of secured debts, loss of a
home, automobile, or other property. Numerous debt collectors also have
reported that a consumer who ceases communications is more likely to be
sued and subjected to wage garnishment because the debt collector has
no other way to recover on the debt.\322\ Accordingly, a consumer who
is aware of these potential outcomes, even if only in the abstract, or
who wishes to resolve the debt in the future, may be reluctant to
invoke the cease communication right to prevent harassment. Moreover,
it may not be reasonable to expect a consumer to avoid harassment by
invoking the cease communication right if doing so makes it more likely
that the debt collector will sue the consumer to recover on the debt.
Third, only a consumer as defined in FDCPA sections 803(3) and 805(d)
may invoke the cease communication right, leaving other persons unable
to invoke this remedy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\321\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(c). Proposed Sec. 1006.6(c) would
implement FDCPA section 805(c).
\322\ As noted earlier in this section-by-section analysis, the
Bureau has received feedback from small entity representatives and
other industry stakeholders that overly restrictive frequency limits
could result in some of these same consumer harms, and the Bureau
requests comment on the proposed frequency limits for that reason.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i) because the injuries
described above appear not to be outweighed by the countervailing
benefits to consumers or to competition of more frequent telephone
calls from FDCPA-covered debt collectors. If the proposed limit on
telephone calls adversely affects debt collectors' ability to collect
debts, the reduction in recoveries and corresponding increases in
losses could result in an increase in the cost of credit. However, as
discussed above and more fully in part VI, debt collectors may not need
to make repeated or continuous telephone calls to collect debts
effectively, and debt collectors may face diminishing returns as they
increase the frequency of their calling. Further, the Bureau has sought
[[Page 23316]]
to mitigate concerns about increasing the cost of credit by limiting
only the number of telephone calls placed per seven days, not the total
number of telephone calls placed throughout the course of collections,
thus permitting debt collectors to continue making as many telephone
calls as needed, albeit over a longer period. Further, even if
preventing harassing or oppressive contacts did have some marginal
effect on collections success, the injuries caused by such contacts do
not appear to be outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers or
to competition.
For similar reasons, the FTC and the Bureau previously have alleged
through enforcement actions that repeated or continuous telephone calls
or telephone conversations can constitute an unfair act or practice in
violation of section 5 of the FTC Act and section 1031 of the Dodd-
Frank Act.\323\ For example, the FTC has alleged that a party engaged
in an unfair act or practice under section 5 by making repeated or
continuous telephone calls with intent to harass or abuse either
consumers who owed debts or third parties, explaining that these calls
can cause substantial injuries by, among other things, affecting the
consumer's reputation, impairing the consumer's relationship with
family, friends, and co-workers, and inducing the payment of disputed
debts.\324\ Similarly, the Bureau has alleged that a party engaged in
unfair acts or practices under section 1031 by making an excessive
number of telephone calls to consumers and by calling third parties
repeatedly even after being informed that the calls were to the wrong
person.\325\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\323\ Complaint at ]] 56-58, Fed. Trade Comm'n v. Citigroup
Inc., No. 1:01-CV-00606 JTC (N.D. Ga. Mar. 6, 2001), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cases/2001/03/citigroupcmp.pdf(alleging that defendant engaged in an unfair act or
practice under section 5 of the FTC Act by ``making repeated and
continuous telephone calls to consumers with intent to annoy, abuse,
or harass any person at the called number''); Consent Order at ]] 5,
6, 19, In re Avco Fin. Servs., 104 F.T.C. 485, 1984 WL 565343, at
*2-3 (1984) (settling FTC's allegations that defendant engaged in an
unfair act or practice under section 5 of the FTC Act by ``[m]aking
repeated or continuous telephone calls to debtors or third parties
with intent to harass or abuse persons at the called number,'' and
explaining that these ``acts and practices * * * had and now [have]
the capacity and tendency to cause substantial injury to debtors or
third parties who are contacted by [defendant] by, among other
things, adversely affecting the debtor's reputation, interfering
with the debtor's or third party's employment relations including,
but not limited to, causing warnings by employers of possible
discharge, impairing the debtor's relations with friends, relatives,
neighbors, and co-workers, and inducing the payment of disputed
debts.''); Consent Order at ]] 12, 19-23, In re Ace Cash Express,
No. 2014-CFPB-0008 (July 10, 2014), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201407_cfpb_consent-order_ace-cash-express.pdf (settling Bureau's allegations that defendant engaged in
unfair acts or practices under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act
by, among other things, ``[m]aking an excessive number of calls to
consumers' home, work, and cell phone numbers'' and ``[c]ontinuing
to call consumers with no relation to the debt after being told that
[defendant] had the wrong person''); see also Consent Order, In re
DriveTime Auto. Grp., Inc., 2014-CFPB-0017 (Nov. 19, 2014), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201411_cfpb_consent-order_drivetime.pdf
(settling Bureau's allegations that defendant engaged in unfair acts
or practices under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act ``by failing:
(A) To prevent account servicing and collection calls to consumers'
workplaces after consumers asked [defendant] to stop such calls; (B)
to prevent calls to consumers' third-party references after the
references or consumers asked [defendant] to stop calling them; and
(C) to prevent calls to people at wrong numbers after they have
asked [defendant] to stop calling'').
\324\ Avco Fin. Servs., 104 F.T.C. 485, 1984 WL 565343, at *2-3.
\325\ Ace Cash Express, No. 2014-CFPB-0008.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1031(c)(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act allows the Bureau to
``consider established public policies as evidence to be considered
with all other evidence'' in determining whether an act or practice is
unfair, as long as the public policy considerations are not the primary
basis of the determination.\326\ Established public policy appears to
support the Bureau's proposed finding that it is an unfair act or
practice for a debt collector who is collecting a consumer financial
product or service debt to place telephone calls repeatedly or
continuously such that the natural consequence is to harass, oppress,
or abuse any person at the called number. Several consumer financial
statutes and regulations, as well as industry standards,\327\ require
or recommend that debt collectors or others who are engaged in
marketing or collections limit the frequency of their telephone calls
to consumers. These include several State and local laws that limit the
number of times a debt collector or creditor may call a consumer each
week,\328\ as well as the Telemarketing and Consumer Fraud and Abuse
Prevention Act, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, and related FTC
and FCC rulemakings that establish the Do Not Call Registry, limit the
use of autodialers, and impose requirements related to Caller ID.\329\
In short, Congress, State and local legislatures, and other agencies
have found that consumers are harmed by repeated telephone calls. These
established policies support a finding that it is an unfair act or
practice for a debt collector who is collecting a consumer financial
product or service debt to place telephone calls to a person repeatedly
or continuously such that the natural consequence is to harass,
oppress, or abuse any person at the called number, and they evince
public policy that supports the Bureau's proposed frequency limits. The
Bureau gives weight to this policy and bases its proposed finding that
the identified act or practice is unfair in part on this body of public
policy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\326\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(c)(2).
\327\ Many creditors and debt collectors have found it
advantageous to adopt voluntary daily or weekly limits on telephone
calls that they or their service provider make in connection with
collecting debts. See, e.g., Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., The
Consumer Credit Card Market, at 313-14 (Dec. 2017), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_consumer-credit-card-market-report_2017.pdf. See also infra part VI.B.2.
\328\ See supra note 284.
\329\ 15 U.S.C. 6101 et seq.; 47 U.S.C. 227; 16 CFR part 310; 47
CFR 64.1200 et seq.; 47 CFR 64.1600 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(2)(ii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) would provide that, subject to the
exceptions in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector must not
place a telephone call to a person in connection with the collection of
a particular debt after already having had a telephone conversation
with that person in connection with the collection of such debt within
a period of seven consecutive days ending on the date of the call.
Proposed comment 14(b)(2)(ii)-1 provides examples of the proposed rule.
In developing this proposal, the Bureau has considered both the
legitimate interests of consumers and debt collectors in resolving
debts and the potentially harmful effects on consumers of repeated or
continuous telephone calls after a telephone conversation. A debt
collector who already has engaged in a telephone conversation with a
consumer about a debt may have less of a need to place additional
telephone calls to that consumer about that debt within the next seven
days than a debt collector who has yet to reach a consumer. As a
result, the debt collector who has already conversed with a consumer
may be more likely than the debt collector who has not conversed with a
consumer to intend to annoy, abuse, or harass the consumer by placing
additional telephone calls within one week after a telephone
conversation. At the same time, a consumer who has spoken to a debt
collector about a debt by telephone may be more likely than a consumer
who has not spoken to a debt collector about a debt by telephone to
experience annoyance, abuse, or harassment if the debt collector places
additional, unwanted telephone calls to the consumer about that debt
again within the next seven days.
A consumer may experience, and a debt collector may intend to
cause, such
[[Page 23317]]
annoyance, abuse, or harassment from a second telephone conversation
within one week even if the consumer, rather than the debt collector,
initiated the first telephone conversation. Therefore, under the
proposal, if a consumer initiated a telephone conversation with the
debt collector, that telephone conversation generally would count as
the debt collector's one permissible telephone conversation for the
next week. In some instances, a consumer might request additional
information when speaking with a debt collector and would not view a
follow-up telephone call from the debt collector as harassing. For that
reason, proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i), discussed below, would create
an exception for telephone calls that are made to respond to a request
for information from the consumer. Similarly, proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3)(ii), also discussed below, would create an exception
under which a consumer who wishes to speak to a debt collector more
than once in one week could consent, in the first telephone
conversation or by other media, to additional telephone calls from the
debt collector.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii).
The Bureau considered, but does not propose, a frequency limit that
would have limited only the total number of telephone calls that a debt
collector could place to a person about a debt during a defined time
period, regardless of whether the debt collector had engaged in a
telephone conversation with that person about that debt during the
relevant time period. The Bureau requests comment on the merits of such
an alternative approach.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) and its commentary
pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors and its
authority to interpret FDCPA section 806(5). The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(ii) on the basis that, unless an exception (such as
consent) applies, once a debt collector and a consumer engage in a
telephone conversation regarding a particular debt, a debt collector
who places additional calls to that person about that debt within the
following seven days may intend to annoy, abuse, or harass the
person.\330\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\330\ Unless an exception applies, a person who receives such a
telephone call after already having spoken to the debt collector
within the previous seven days may naturally feel harassed,
oppressed, or abused, and, as noted above, the Bureau assumes that
debt collectors intend the natural consequences of their actions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer
financial product or service debt, as defined in proposed Sec.
1006.2(f), the Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) pursuant to
its authority under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe
rules identifying and preventing unfair acts or practices.\331\
Specifically, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) to prevent
the unfair act or practice described in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii).\332\ For the reasons discussed in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i), and based on the
evidence currently available to the Bureau, the Bureau believes that,
if a debt collector places a telephone call to a particular person
about a particular debt after already having spoken to that person
about that debt within the previous seven days, the person naturally
may feel harassed by the subsequent telephone call. For the reasons
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i), the debt collector's conduct may cause or be likely
to cause the person to suffer substantial injury that is not reasonably
avoidable and is not outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers
or to competition.\333\ The Bureau thus proposes Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(ii) to establish a frequency limit that would prevent
debt collectors from engaging in this unfair act or practice and, as
detailed above, the Bureau proposes a limit of one telephone
conversation per seven days on the theory that such a limit bears a
reasonable relationship to preventing the unfair practice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\331\ The Bureau has not determined in connection with this
proposal whether telephone calls in excess of the limit in proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) by creditors and others not covered by the
FDCPA would constitute an unfair act or practice under Dodd-Frank
Act 1031(c) if engaged in by those persons, rather than by an FDCPA-
covered debt collector.
\332\ As with Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i), proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(ii) would apply when a debt collector places a
telephone call to ``a person.''
\333\ 12 U.S.C. 5531(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(3) Certain Telephone Calls Excluded From the Frequency Limits
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3) describes four types of telephone
calls that would not count toward, and that would be permitted in
excess of, the frequency limits in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2). These
are telephone calls that are: (i) Made to respond to a request for
information from the person whom the debt collector is calling; (ii)
made with such person's consent given directly to the debt collector;
(iii) unable to connect to the dialed number; or (iv) placed to a
person described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(ii) through (vi). As
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3)(i) through (iv) below, the Bureau proposes these
exclusions pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to
prescribe rules for the collection of debts by debt collectors and to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 806(5). The Bureau proposes to
exclude these telephone calls from counting toward the proposed
frequency limits because they are unlikely to be harassing to
consumers, and debt collectors are unlikely to place such calls with
intent to annoy, abuse, or harass a person. The Bureau further proposes
to exclude these telephone calls from counting toward the proposed
frequency limits because they are unlikely to contribute to substantial
injury that a person cannot reasonably avoid and that is not outweighed
by countervailing benefits to consumers or competition. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3) and its related
commentary, including on whether any other types of telephone calls
should be excluded from the frequency limits.
During the SBREFA process, the Bureau's proposal under
consideration noted that a bright-line frequency limit could except
certain types of contacts, but it did not identify any specific
exceptions. Many small entity representatives suggested exceptions,
including for: (1) Contacts that respond to a consumer's request or
question; (2) contact attempts that leave no ``footprint,'' such that
the consumer is unaware of the telephone call or other contact attempt;
(3) contacts with a consumer's attorney; and (4) contacts that are
legally required. The Small Business Review Panel Report recommended
that the Bureau consider incorporating such exceptions into the
proposal.\334\ The Panel Report also specifically recommended that the
Bureau consider whether the frequency limits should be modified for
communications that occur after a law firm files a complaint, on the
grounds that one conversation per week might not be sufficient in
various litigation situations. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3) takes into
account the small entity representatives' suggestions and the
recommendations in the Panel Report. The Bureau does not propose an
[[Page 23318]]
exception for legally required communications because the Bureau
understands that very few legally required communications must be
delivered by telephone and that, with respect to the few such
communications that must be delivered telephonically, it appears
unlikely that a debt collector would need to place more than seven
telephone calls to a consumer within a period of seven consecutive days
to deliver the required communication.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\334\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
36. Other suggested exceptions in the Small Business Review Panel
Report--including for contacts initiated by the consumer, contacts
that occur through written correspondence (e.g., letters), and
misdirected contact attempts--are addressed elsewhere in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.14(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(3)(i)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) would exclude from the frequency
limits telephone calls that a debt collector places to a person to
respond to a request for information from that person. The Bureau
proposes this exclusion because the Bureau believes that, if a person
is speaking to a debt collector and asks for information that the debt
collector does not have at the time of the telephone conversation, the
person likely would expect (and not be harassed by) a return telephone
call (or calls) from the debt collector providing the requested
information; nor would the debt collector place the return telephone
call with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass the person. Proposed
comment 14(b)(3)(i)-1 would clarify that, once a debt collector
provides a response to a person's request for information, the
exception in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) would not apply to
subsequent telephone calls placed by the debt collector to the person,
unless the person makes another request. Proposed comment 14(b)(3)(i)-2
provides an example of the rule.\335\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\335\ Some State and local laws exclude responsive
communications from their frequency limits. For example,
Massachusetts' creditor-collection law provides that ``a creditor
shall not be deemed to have initiated a communication with a debtor
if the communication by the creditor is in response to a request
made by the debtor for said communication''). 940 Code Mass. Regs.
7.04(1)(f). See also 9 Wash. Rev. Code 19.16.250(13)(a) (debt
collector may exceed the weekly contact limit when ``responding to a
communication from the debtor or spouse''); N.Y.C. Admin. Code 5-
77(b)(1)(iv) (weekly contact limit does not include ``any
communication between a consumer and the debt collector which is in
response to an oral or written communication from the consumer'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on the proposal to exclude from the
frequency limits the placement of telephone calls that are made to
respond to a request for information. The Bureau specifically requests
comment on whether there should be any separate limit on the number of
telephone calls a debt collector could place under the exception. As
proposed, Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) would permit a debt collector who
engages in a telephone conversation with a consumer to place an
unlimited number of unanswered telephone calls to the consumer during
the next seven days in an effort to provide the requested information.
As proposed, Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) also would permit the debt
collector to continue to exceed the frequency limits until the debt
collector reached the consumer to respond to the request. A debt
collector responding to a person's request for information may not need
to place repeated or continuous telephone calls to reach the consumer,
however, because such a debt collector is likely to have reliable
contact information and the consumer presumably will be expecting the
debt collector's telephone call. The Bureau requests comment on this
approach and on alternatives to it. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether additional clarification is needed on how to determine whether
a debt collector makes a particular telephone call in response to a
request for information, as opposed to for some other purpose, or on
how to determine whether the debt collector has responded to a request
for information, such that the exclusion no longer applies.
14(b)(3)(ii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(ii) would exclude from the proposed
frequency limits telephone calls that a debt collector places to a
person with the person's prior consent given directly to the debt
collector. The Bureau proposes to exclude such telephone calls from the
frequency limits because the Bureau believes that a person can
determine when additional telephone calls from, or telephone
conversations with, a debt collector would not be harassing, and that a
debt collector who has a person's consent to additional telephone calls
would not be likely to place such calls with intent to annoy, abuse, or
harass the person. The Bureau also believes that proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3)(ii) may address small entity representatives' concerns
about the frequency limits precluding necessary conversations in
various litigation contexts because it would enable a person to consent
to additional telephone calls if, for example, the parties were
negotiating a settlement or resolving a discovery dispute.
Proposed comment 14(b)(3)(ii)-1 refers to the commentary to
proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) for guidance concerning a person giving
prior consent directly to a debt collector. Proposed comment
14(b)(3)(ii)-2 provides an example of the rule. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(ii) and its related commentary,
including on whether there should be a separate limit on the number of
telephone calls that a debt collector could place under the proposed
exception or whether there should be any other type of limitation or
condition on the proposed exception.
14(b)(3)(iii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iii) would exclude from the frequency
limits telephone calls that a debt collector places to a person but
that are unable to connect to the dialed number (e.g., that result in a
busy signal or are placed to an out-of-service number). The Bureau
proposes this exclusion because a person is unlikely to know about, let
alone be harassed by, a debt collector's telephone call in response to
which the debt collector receives a busy signal or a message indicating
that the dialed number is not in service. Similarly, it appears that a
debt collector who places several calls to a person in response to
which the debt collector receives a busy signal or out-of-service
notification is likely to place additional telephone calls to the
person in an effort to contact the person and not with the intent to
annoy, abuse, or harass the person.\336\ The proposed exclusion also
responds to feedback from small entity representatives suggesting that,
for example, a telephone call met with a busy signal should not count
toward the frequency limit.\337\ Proposed comment 14(b)(3)(iii)-1 and -
2 provide examples of telephone calls that are able and unable to
connect to the dialed number. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iii), including on whether the Bureau should
include any other specific examples in commentary.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\336\ The Bureau's approach in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iii)
is informed, in part, by State and local laws that exclude
undeliverable contact attempts from their frequency limits. See
Commonwealth of Mass., Off. of the Att'y Gen., Guidance with Respect
to Debt Collection Regulations (2013), https://www.mass.gov/files/documents/2016/08/xc/debt-collection-guidance-2013.pdf
(``unsuccessful attempts . . . to reach a debtor via telephone'' do
not count toward the frequency limit in 940 Code Mass. Regs.
7.04(1)(f) ``if the creditor is truly unable to reach the debtor or
to leave a message for the debtor); N.Y.C. Admin. Code 5-
77(b)(1)(iv) (weekly contact limit does not include ``returned
unopened mail'').
\337\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(b)(3)(iv)
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iv) would exclude from the frequency
limits telephone calls that a debt collector places to the persons
described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(ii) through (vi). Proposed
Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(ii) through (vi) would implement, in part, FDCPA
section 805(b)'s exception from the general prohibition on
communicating
[[Page 23319]]
about a debt with a person other than the consumer; it would permit a
debt collector to communicate with a consumer's attorney, a consumer
reporting agency, a creditor, a creditor's attorney, or a debt
collector's attorney. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iv) would exclude
from the frequency limits telephone calls placed to such persons on the
basis that these persons are unlikely to be harassed by frequent and
repeated telephone calls from a debt collector and that a debt
collector is unlikely to place calls to such persons with intent to
annoy, abuse, or harass them. Unlike most consumers, each of these
persons has professional training and experience in, and is likely
engaging in, the debt collection process in a professional capacity.
Moreover, the Bureau is not aware of evidence that such persons receive
an excessive number of telephone calls from debt collectors.
The Bureau also proposes to exclude telephone calls to such persons
from the frequency limits because debt collectors may have non-
harassing reasons for calling these persons more often than proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would permit. For example, during litigation, a
debt collector may need to speak frequently with its own attorneys, as
well as with the creditor's or the consumer's attorneys; the Bureau's
proposal would not limit such contacts. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(iv), including on whether telephone calls
that a debt collector places to certain other persons also should be
excluded from the frequency limits and, if so, which categories of
persons should be excluded.
14(b)(4) Effect of Complying With Frequency Limits
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would clarify the effect of complying
with the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2). Under proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(4), a debt collector who complies with (i.e., does not
exceed) the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would per se comply
with Sec. 1006.14(b)(1). Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) also would
clarify that a debt collector who complies with Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)
does not violate either: (1) FDCPA section 806's general prohibition as
it applies to placing telephone calls or engaging any person in
telephone conversation repeatedly or continuously such that the natural
consequence is to harass, oppress, or abuse the person; or (2) FDCPA
section 806(5)'s specific prohibition against causing a telephone to
ring or engaging any person in telephone conversation repeatedly or
continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass the person. Based
on the evidence currently available to the Bureau, the Bureau believes
that a debt collector who places seven or fewer telephone calls to, and
engages in one telephone conversation with, a particular consumer about
a particular debt within a period of seven consecutive days, including
the additional telephone calls permitted under proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3), may not have the natural consequence of harassing,
oppressing or abusing a person; that a debt collector who places such
calls or engages in such conversations does not intend to annoy, abuse,
or harass the person; and that such a frequency of telephone calls and
conversations would not be repeated or continuous as those terms are
used in FDCPA section 806(5).
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) also would clarify the consequence
under the Dodd-Frank Act of complying with the frequency limits.
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) provides that a debt collector who
complies with Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) does not violate Dodd-Frank Act
sections 1031(c) or 1036(a)(1)(B) by engaging in the unfair act or
practice of, in connection with the collection of a consumer financial
product or service debt, placing telephone calls or engaging any person
in telephone conversation repeatedly or continuously such that the
natural consequence is to harass, oppress, or abuse the person. The
Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) on the basis that telephone calls
that do not exceed the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) do not
cause substantial injury and that any possible injury is outweighed by
the benefits to consumers or to competition. Under this interpretation,
telephone calls at or below the frequency limits are unlikely to harass
consumers and, in turn, are unlikely to cause substantial injury.
Further, under this interpretation, debt collection provides
substantial benefits to the consumer credit marketplace, and debt
collectors may need to make telephone calls up to the frequency limits
to collect debts effectively. Given these premises, any injury that
might result from telephone calls at or below the frequency limits
would be outweighed by the benefits to consumers or to competition.
The Bureau further believes that clarifying the effect of complying
with proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2), and creating a bright-line rule for
compliance with it, could benefit both consumers and debt collectors.
For debt collectors, the clarification should provide greater legal
certainty and, in turn, should reduce the costs of litigation and
threats of litigation about repeated or continuous contacts under FDCPA
section 806 and 806(5). Consistent with this view, during the SBREFA
process, small entity representatives expressed a preference for a
bright-line approach. For consumers, a bright-line rule could make it
easier to identify violations of the FDCPA. Providing a bright-line
rule for determining compliance with the FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank Act
therefore may be appropriate to advance the objectives of the FDCPA and
title X of the Dodd-Frank Act.
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would not provide a debt collector
with protection from liability as to any other provision of the
proposed rule, the FDCPA, or the Dodd-Frank Act. For example, proposed
Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would not protect a debt collector from liability
for using obscene language or false representations in connection with
collection of a debt, in violation of FDCPA sections 806 or 807 (as
proposed to be implemented by Sec. Sec. 1006.14 and 1006.18).
Similarly, proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would not protect a debt
collector from liability for communicating with a consumer in violation
of FDCPA section 805(a) or (c) (as proposed to be implemented by Sec.
1006.6(b)(1) and (c)). Nor would proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) protect a
debt collector from liability under the Dodd-Frank Act for engaging in
other unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices.
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(4). The Bureau specifically requests comment on whether
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) adequately addresses concerns about debt
collectors making telephone calls in rapid succession and, if not, what
approach would address such calling behavior without imposing undue or
unnecessary costs on debt collectors. For example, under the Bureau's
proposed approach, a debt collector would not violate Sec.
1006.14(b)(1) by placing seven or fewer telephone calls in rapid
succession, so long as the debt collector did not exceed seven
telephone calls or one telephone conversation with the same person
about the same debt during a period of seven consecutive days.
The Bureau also requests comment on whether, instead of a bright-
line rule, the Bureau should adopt a rebuttable presumption of
compliance and of a violation. Under a rebuttable presumption approach,
a debt collector who places telephone calls at or below the frequency
limits presumptively would comply with Sec. 1006.14(b)(1). Likewise, a
debt collector who exceeds the frequency limits presumptively would
violate Sec. 1006.14(b)(1). These presumptions could be rebutted based
on the facts and circumstances of a
[[Page 23320]]
particular situation. For example, a consumer could rebut the
presumption of compliance for a debt collector who stayed below the
frequency limits by showing that the debt collector knew or should have
known that telephone calls, even below the frequency limits, would have
the natural consequence of harassing, oppressing, or abusing the
consumer. Similarly, a debt collector who exceeded the frequency limits
could rebut the presumption of a violation by showing that, under the
circumstances, additional calls above the limits would not have the
natural consequence of harassing, oppressing, or abusing the consumer.
Finally, the Bureau requests comment on the alternative of adopting
only a rebuttable presumption of a violation or only a rebuttable
presumption of compliance. For example, one alternative would be to
provide a safe harbor only for telephone calls below the frequency
limits, with no provision for telephone calls above the frequency
limits. Such an approach would provide certainty to both debt
collectors and consumers about a per se permissible level of calling,
but it would leave open the question of how many telephone calls is too
many under the FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau does not
propose such an approach because it appears that it would not provide
the clarity that debt collectors and consumers have sought; nor does it
appear to provide the same degree of consumer protection as a per se
prohibition against telephone calls in excess of a specified frequency.
Another alternative that the Bureau considered is a safe harbor for
telephone calls below the limits paired with a rebuttable presumption
of a violation for telephone calls above the limits. (The Bureau also
considered the opposite: A rebuttable presumption of compliance for
telephone calls below the limits paired with a per se prohibition
against telephone calls in excess of the limits). The Bureau requests
comment on the merits of these alternative approaches and others that
the Bureau may not have considered.
14(b)(5) Definition
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5) generally would define the term
particular debt, as that term is used in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2),
to mean each of a consumer's debts in collection. With respect to
student loan debts, however, the term particular debt would mean all
debts that a consumer owes or allegedly owes that were serviced under a
single account number at the time the debts were obtained by the debt
collector. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5) would clarify how the frequency
limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would apply when a consumer has multiple
debts being collected by the same debt collector at the same time.\338\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\338\ This clarification may be necessary because most consumers
with at least one debt in collection have multiple debts in
collection. See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 13, table 1; see also CFPB Medical Debt Report, supra note 20, at
20 (reporting that most consumers with one collections tradeline
have multiple collections tradelines).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In some cases, when a consumer has multiple debts in collection,
either from one creditor or from multiple creditors, a single debt
collector will attempt to collect some or all of them. Debt collectors
in this situation typically make distinct efforts to collect each debt
rather than, for example, asking the consumer about all of the debts
during a single telephone call. One reason for this segregation is that
larger debt collectors often collect multiple debts owed by the same
consumer to different creditors, and each creditor may require its debt
collectors to keep information about its debts separate from
information about other creditors' debts. A creditor may require this
so that it can ensure that debt collectors are complying with the
creditor's specific debt collection guidelines. Consequently, some
larger debt collectors may have groups of employees dedicated to
collecting only a particular creditor's debts.
In addition, some debt collectors segregate debts because they have
employees who specialize in collecting different types of debts. In
other cases, such as with medical debts, privacy concerns or State or
Federal laws may require a debt collector to segregate information
about a particular debt from information about a consumer's other
debts. A consumer's debts also may enter collection at different points
in time and thus be at different stages of the collections process,
such that the different debts may be eligible for different types of
settlement offers. Debt collectors report that, in many cases, their
systems are not structured to consolidate information about different
debts owed by the same consumer. Finally, debt collectors may not find
it productive to discuss multiple debts on a single telephone call
because consumers may not be able or prepared to discuss more than one
debt during the telephone call or may find it overwhelming, confusing,
or simply too time consuming to discuss multiple debts, with different
related terms and offers, during a single telephone call.
The Bureau considered proposing a limit on the number of times a
debt collector could place telephone calls to any one person within
seven days (i.e., a per-person limit), regardless of how many debts the
debt collector was attempting to collect from that person. Creditors,
however, could sidestep a per-person limit by placing debts with debt
collectors who collect for only one or a limited number of creditors,
or by assigning only a single debt to any one debt collector.
Alternatively, if one debt collector were collecting multiple debts for
multiple creditors, a per-person limit could incentivize the debt
collector to discuss all of those debts with the consumer in the single
permissible telephone conversation each week. This could result in
consumers receiving an overwhelming amount of information about, for
example, different settlement or payment structures for different
creditors. This also could complicate debt collection conversations if,
for example, consumers wanted to dispute one or some, but not all, of
the debts. Alternatively, a per-person limit could encourage debt
collectors to sequence collection of a consumer's debts, thereby
prolonging the collections process for some debts. For these reasons,
and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe
rules for the collection of debt by debt collectors, the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.14(b)(5) to define the term particular debt, as
used in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2), generally to mean each of a
consumer's debts in collection.
The concerns outlined above may not apply to the collection of
multiple student loan debts that were serviced under a single account
number at the time the debts were obtained by the debt collector. In
these situations, the debt collector and consumer appear to interact as
if there were only a single debt. This would be consistent with how the
loans were likely serviced before entering collection, as multiple
student loan debts are often serviced under a single account number and
billed on a single, combined account statement, with a single total
amount due and requiring a single payment from the consumer. For this
reason, in the case of student loan debts, the Bureau proposes to
define the term particular debt to mean all such debts that a consumer
owes or allegedly owes that were serviced under a single account number
at the time the debts were obtained by the debt collector. Under
proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(5), the frequency limits in proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(2) would apply to all such debts collectively. Proposed
comment 14(b)(5)-1 provides illustrative examples.
[[Page 23321]]
The Bureau requests comment on the proposed definition of
particular debt. The Bureau specifically requests comment on the
proposal to apply the frequency limits in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)
generally on a per-debt, as opposed to per-person, basis. The Bureau
requests comment on whether, if the proposed per-debt approach is
adopted, additional clarification is needed about how to count
telephone calls when a debt collector places one telephone call to a
consumer to discuss more than one particular debt. In particular, the
Bureau requests comment on whether the rule should clarify how the
frequency limits apply when a debt collector places an unanswered
telephone call to a consumer to discuss two of the consumer's debts
(e.g., a credit card debt and a medical debt), or when a debt collector
who is collecting two such debts leaves the consumer only a general
message that does not refer specifically to either debt (e.g., ``Please
remember to pay what you owe''). The Bureau similarly requests comment
on whether clarification is needed for the situation in which a debt
collector has a telephone conversation with a consumer about more than
one debt but does not specifically refer to either debt, and on whether
the proposal appropriately counts the single conversation as having
been about all of the debts for purposes of the frequency limits.
Finally, the Bureau requests comment on: (1) The proposal to
aggregate certain student loan debts for purposes of Sec.
1006.14(b)(2), including whether some student loan debts serviced under
the same account number should be counted separately; and (2) whether
any types of debts other than student loans should be aggregated, such
that multiple debts that were serviced under a single account number at
the time the debts were obtained by the debt collector (or met other
specified conditions) would be treated as a single debt for purposes of
the frequency limits. Under such an approach, for example, multiple
medical debts could be aggregated for purposes of Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)
if they met certain conditions, such as being serviced under the same
account number at the time the debt collector obtained them. The Bureau
requests comment on such an approach, including on the possible
difficulties of aggregating accounts other than student loan accounts
given the different facts that could apply to each debt.
14(h) Prohibited Communication Media 339
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\339\ As noted above, proposed Sec. 1006.14(c) through (g)
generally mirror the statute, with minor wording and organizational
changes for clarity, and are not discussed further in this section-
by-section analysis.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(h)(1) In General
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(1) would prohibit a debt collector from
communicating or attempting to communicate with a consumer through a
medium of communication if the consumer has requested that the debt
collector not use that medium to communicate with the consumer.
Pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to write rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.14(h)(1) as an interpretation of FDCPA section 806,
which, as discussed in part IV, prohibits a debt collector from
engaging in any conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass,
oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the collection of a
debt.
Since the enactment of the FDCPA, the possible media through which
communications generally are conducted has expanded beyond telephone,
mail, and in-person conversations to include various mobile and
portable technologies that were not contemplated in 1977. For example,
with the advent of the mobile telephone, a consumer may receive a
telephone call at any time or place. As the CFPB Debt Collection
Consumer Survey indicated, consumers have varied but strong preferences
about the media that debt collectors use to communicate with them.\340\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\340\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 36-37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Once a consumer has requested that a debt collector not use a
specific medium of communication to communicate with the consumer, the
Bureau believes that the natural consequence of further communications
or attempts to communicate from the debt collector to the consumer
using that same medium likely is harassment, oppression, or abuse of
the consumer. Consistent with this interpretation, the Bureau
understands that some debt collectors currently refrain from
communicating with a consumer through a medium that the consumer has
requested that the debt collector not use to communicate with the
consumer, including, for example, specific telephone numbers that the
consumer has asked the debt collector not to call.
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(h)(1) to
provide that, in connection with the collection of any debt, a debt
collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with a
consumer through a medium of communication if the consumer has
requested that the debt collector not use that medium to communicate
with the consumer. The Bureau also proposes commentary to Sec.
1006.14(h)(1). Proposed comment 14(h)(1)-1 refers to comment 2(d)-1 for
examples of communication media. Proposed comment 14(h)(1)-2 would
clarify that, within a medium of communication, a consumer may request
that a debt collector not use a specific address or telephone number
and provides an example. The Bureau proposes this comment on the
grounds that a specific address or telephone number may be considered a
medium, and that contacting a consumer through a specific address or
telephone number that the consumer has requested the debt collector not
use may be just as harassing as contacting the consumer through a
medium of communication that the consumer has requested the debt
collector not use. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.14(h)(1) and its related commentary.
As discussed above, pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to write rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt
collectors, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.14(h)(1) as an
interpretation of FDCPA section 806, on the basis that once a consumer
has requested that a debt collector not use a specific medium of
communication to communicate with the consumer, a debt collector who
nevertheless continues to communicate or attempt to communicate with
the consumer using that medium is engaging in conduct the natural
consequence of which is to harass, oppress, or abuse. The Bureau
believes that proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(1) is consistent with this
statutory language and the purpose of the FDCPA. As FDCPA section
802(e) explains, in relevant part, the purpose of the Act is to
eliminate abusive debt collection practices by debt collectors.\341\
The Bureau interprets FDCPA section 806's general prohibition on
engaging in conduct the natural consequence of which is to harass,
oppress, or abuse in light of this purpose specified in the FDCPA, as
well as in light of similar conduct specifically prohibited by the
FDCPA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\341\ 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
14(h)(2) Exceptions
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(2) provides two exceptions to the general
prohibition in proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(1). Proposed
[[Page 23322]]
Sec. 1006.14(h)(2)(i) provides that, notwithstanding the prohibition
in Sec. 1006.14(h)(1), if a consumer opts out in writing of receiving
electronic communications from a debt collector, a debt collector may
reply once to confirm the consumer's request to opt out, provided that
the reply contains no information other than a statement confirming the
consumer's request. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(2)(ii) provides that, if
a consumer initiates contact with a debt collector using an address or
a telephone number that the consumer previously requested the debt
collector not use, the debt collector may respond once to that
consumer-initiated communication. The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.14(h)(2) because a single communication from a debt collector of
the types described likely would not have the natural consequence of
harassing, oppressing, or abusing the consumer within the meaning of
FDCPA section 806.\342\ The Bureau requests comment on the exceptions
in proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\342\ Proposed Sec. 1006.14(h)(2) also is consistent with the
regulations implementing the CAN-SPAM Act, which permit senders to
send a reply electronic message. See 16 CFR 316.5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, a consumer may request that a debt collector
not communicate with the consumer using a specific medium of
communication. However, there may be circumstances in which applicable
law requires the debt collector to communicate with the consumer only
through that specific medium and does not offer an alternative medium
for compliance (e.g., by permitting a debt collector to electronically
provide a notice that otherwise would be mailed). The Bureau requests
comment on whether there are specific laws that require communication
with the consumer through one specific medium, and if so, whether
additional clarification is needed regarding the delivery of legally
required communications through a specific medium of communication
required by applicable law if the consumer has generally requested that
the debt collector not use that medium to communicate with the
consumer.
Section 1006.18 False, Deceptive, or Misleading Representations or
Means
FDCPA section 807 generally prohibits a debt collector from using
any false, deceptive, or misleading representations or means in
connection with the collection of any debt. The section lists 16 non-
exhaustive examples of such prohibited conduct.\343\ Proposed Sec.
1006.18 would implement FDCPA section 807. Except for certain
organizational changes and interpretations in Sec. 1006.18(e) through
(g), which are discussed below, proposed Sec. 1006.18 generally
restates the statute with only minor wording changes for clarity. The
Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.18 pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\343\ 15 U.S.C. 1692e.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes to organize Sec. 1006.18 by grouping the 16
non-exhaustive examples of prohibited false or misleading
representations in FDCPA section 807 into categories of related
conduct, as follows. Proposed Sec. 1006.18(a) would implement the
general prohibition in FDCPA section 807 by prohibiting a debt
collector from using any false, deceptive, or misleading representation
or means in connection with the collection of any debt. Proposed Sec.
1006.18(b) restates FDCPA section 807's examples of false, deceptive,
or misleading representations.\344\ Proposed Sec. 1006.18(c) restates
FDCPA section 807's examples of false, deceptive, or misleading
collection means.\345\ Proposed Sec. 1006.18(d) restates the catch-all
prohibition against false representations or deceptive means as
described in FDCPA section 807(10). Proposed Sec. 1006.18(e) addresses
the disclosures required under FDCPA section 807(11). Finally, proposed
Sec. 1006.18(f) addresses the use of assumed names by debt collectors'
employees, and proposed Sec. 1006.18(g) addresses misrepresentations
of meaningful attorney involvement in debt collection litigation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\344\ Proposed Sec. 1006.18(b)(1)(i) through (viii) would
implement, respectively, paragraphs (1), (16), (3), (7), (6), (12),
(13), and (15) of FDCPA section 807, and proposed Sec.
1006.18(b)(2) would implement FDCPA section 807(2). Restating the
statutory language is not intended to suggest any particular
interpretation of that language. For example, the omission of the
words ``or imply'' from the introductory language to Sec.
1006.18(b)(2) consistent with the statutory language in FDCPA
section 807(2) is not intended to suggest that the Bureau would not
regard implied false representations as violations of FDCPA section
807 or 807(2) or proposed Sec. 1006.18(b)(2).
\345\ Proposed Sec. 1006.18(c)(1) through (4) would implement,
respectively, paragraphs (5), (8), (9), and (14) of FDCPA section
807.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
18(e) Disclosures Required
FDCPA section 807(11) requires debt collectors to disclose in their
initial communications with consumers that they are attempting to
collect a debt and that any information obtained will be used for that
purpose, and to disclose in their subsequent communications with
consumers that the communication is from a debt collector, except in a
formal pleading made in connection with a legal action.\346\ Proposed
Sec. 1006.18(e) would implement FDCPA section 807(11).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\346\ 15 U.S.C. 1692e(11).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 18(e)(1)-1 describes the circumstances in which
debt collectors would be required to provide disclosures in initial
communications under proposed Sec. 1008.18(e)(1). Proposed comment
18(e)(1)-1 specifies that a debt collector must provide the disclosures
in the debt collector's initial communication with the consumer,
regardless of whether that initial communication is written or oral,
and regardless of whether the debt collector or the consumer initiated
the communication. Proposed comment 18(e)(1)-1 also provides an example
of the rule regarding required disclosures during initial
communications.
Proposed comment 18(e)-1 provides general commentary to explain how
the disclosure requirements in proposed Sec. 1006.18(e) interact with
the proposed rule's limited-content message, a message that is not a
communication under proposed Sec. 1006.2(d). Proposed comment 18(e)-1
would clarify that, because a limited-content message is not a
communication, a debt collector who leaves only a limited-content
message for a consumer does not need to provide the disclosures
required under proposed Sec. 1008.18(e)(1) and (2). For a more
detailed discussion of the terms communication and limited-content
message, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.2(d) and (j), respectively.
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.18 and on whether additional clarification would be useful. In
particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether additional
clarification regarding false or misleading representations would be
helpful in the decedent debt context, or whether to require any
affirmative disclosures when debt collectors communicate in connection
with the collection of a debt owed by a deceased consumer. As discussed
in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.2(e) and
1006.6(a)(4), this proposal would define the term consumer to clarify
with whom debt collectors may communicate when attempting to resolve
the debts of a deceased consumer. In its Policy Statement on Decedent
Debt, the FTC expressed concern that, even absent explicit
misrepresentations, a debt collector might violate FDCPA section 807 by
communicating with such individuals in a manner that conveys the
misleading impression that the individual is personally liable for the
[[Page 23323]]
deceased consumer's debts, or that the debt collector could seek assets
outside of the deceased consumer's estate to satisfy the consumer's
debt. The FTC's Policy Statement suggested two possible disclosures
that debt collectors generally could use to avoid deceiving such
individuals about their liability for the decedent's debts.\347\ The
FTC also noted that the information that would need to be disclosed to
avoid deception would depend on the circumstances.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\347\ FTC Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, supra note 192, at
44922. The FTC's suggested disclosures were: ``(1) That the
collector is seeking payment from the assets in the decedent's
estate; and (2) [that] the individual could not be required to use
the individual's assets or assets the individual owned jointly with
the decedent to pay the decedent's debt.'' Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the Bureau believes that the FTC's suggested disclosures
generally would be sufficient to avoid deception in many circumstances,
proposed Sec. 1006.18 would not require such disclosures. Since the
FTC issued its Policy Statement in 2011, neither the FTC nor the Bureau
has brought any cases against debt collectors for making deceptive
claims in the decedent debt context, including any such claims
concerning the liability of other individuals for the decedent's debts.
Proposed Sec. 1006.18's general prohibition against false, deceptive,
or misleading representations, however, would apply to express or
implied misrepresentations that a personal representative is liable for
the deceased consumer's debts. The Bureau requests comment on whether
the general prohibition against false, deceptive, or misleading
representations in proposed Sec. 1006.18 is sufficient to protect
individuals who communicate with debt collectors about a deceased
consumer's debts, or whether affirmative disclosures in the decedent
debt context are needed.
18(f) Use of Assumed Names
Debt collectors commonly instruct or permit their employees to use
assumed names when interacting with consumers, including by telephone.
They do so for a variety of reasons. For example, some employees may
have names that are difficult for some consumers to spell or pronounce.
These employees may find that assuming a simpler name facilitates
communications with consumers. Other employees may have privacy or
safety concerns about revealing their true name and employer to a
potentially large number of consumers.
From a consumer's perspective, it may not be relevant whether
employees use true names or assumed names, provided that the name used
does not mislead the consumer about the debt at issue and who is
attempting to collect it. For example, the FTC previously issued
guidance stating that a debt collector's employee does not violate the
FDCPA by using an assumed name if the employee uses the assumed name
consistently and the debt collector can readily ascertain the
employee's identity.\348\ An employee's consistent use of that name is
not likely to affect the decisions a consumer makes about the debt.
Further, a debt collector's ability to readily ascertain the employee's
identity would enable the debt collector to monitor and address the
conduct of such employee. Therefore, an approach similar to the FTC's
prior guidance may be appropriate for the use of assumed names.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\348\ Fed. Trade Comm'n, Staff Commentary on the Fair Debt
Collection Practices Act, 53 FR 50097, 50105 (Dec. 13, 1988) (``1.
Aliases. A debt collector employee's use of an alias that permits
identification of the debt collector (i.e., where he uses the alias
consistently, and his true identity can be ascertained by the
employer) constitutes a ``meaningful disclosure of the caller's
identity.''); see also id. at 50103 (``An individual debt collector
may use an alias if it is used consistently and if it does not
interfere with another party's ability to identify him (e.g., the
true identity can be ascertained by the employer).'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.18(f) provides that nothing
in Sec. 1006.18 prohibits a debt collector's employee from using an
assumed name when communicating or attempting to communicate with a
person, provided that the employee uses the assumed name consistently
and that the employer can readily identify the employee even if the
employee is using the assumed name. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.18(f), including on the use of assumed names by
debt collectors' employees in general, as well as on whether and how
employers can readily identify their employees who are using assumed
names.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.18(f) pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors. Specifically, the Bureau
interprets FDCPA section 807's prohibition on false or misleading
representations, and 806(6)'s prohibition on placing telephone calls
without ``meaningful disclosure of the caller's identity,'' to allow a
debt collector's employee to disclose an assumed name as long as the
employee uses the name consistently and the debt collector can readily
ascertain that employee's true identity.
18(g) Safe Harbor for Meaningful Attorney Involvement in Debt
Collection Litigation Submissions
FDCPA section 807 contains certain provisions designed to protect
consumers from false, deceptive, or misleading representations made by,
or means employed by, attorneys in debt collection litigation. FDCPA
section 807(3) prohibits the false representation or implication that
any individual is an attorney or that any communication is from an
attorney. In addition, debt collection communications sent under an
attorney's name may violate FDCPA section 807(10) if the attorney was
not meaningfully involved in the preparation of the communication.\349\
The meaningful attorney involvement case law has been applied in the
specific context of debt collection litigation submissions.\350\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\349\ See, e.g., Clomon v. Jackson, 988 F.2d 1314, 1320 (2d Cir.
1993); Nielsen v. Dickerson, 307 F.3d 623, 635 (7th Cir. 2002).
Courts have found violations of other subsections of FDCPA section
807 for similar conduct. See e.g., Avila v. Rubin, 84 F.3d 222, 229
(7th Cir. 1996); Lesher v. Law Offices of Mitchell N. Kay, PC, 650
F.3d 993, 1002 (3d Cir. 2011).
\350\ See Miller v. Upton, Cohen & Slamowitz, 687 F.Supp.2d 86,
100 (applying meaningful involvement liability to, among other
actions, filing of complaint in court); Bock v. Pressler & Pressler,
30 F.Supp.3d 283, 303 (D.N.J. 2014) (``The claimed misrepresentation
here does not relate to the ultimate veracity of the numbered
factual allegations of the complaint; it concerns the veracity of
the implied representation that an attorney was meaningfully
involved in the preparation of the complaint. If, in fact, the
attorney who signed the complaint is not involved and familiar with
the case against the debtor, then the debtor has been unfairly
misled and deceived within the meaning of the FDCPA. . . .''),
reaff'd on remand, 254 F.Supp.3d 724, 729 (D.N.J. 2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It may be particularly important for consumers, attorneys, and law
firms engaged in such litigation to be protected by a clear
articulation of what meaningful attorney involvement in debt collection
litigation submissions means under FDCPA section 807, as would be
implemented by proposed Sec. 1006.18. A clear articulation of
meaningful attorney involvement also may be useful to avoid confusion
and unnecessary conflicts between State standards and Federal standards
under the FDCPA and any implementing regulations.
To provide clarity for law firms and attorneys submitting
pleadings, written motions, or other papers to courts in debt
collection litigation, proposed section Sec. 1006.18(g) provides a
safe harbor for attorneys and law firms against claims that they
violated Sec. 1006.18 due to the lack of meaningful attorney
involvement in debt collection litigation materials signed by the
attorney and submitted to the court,
[[Page 23324]]
provided that they meet the requirements in proposed Sec. 1006.18(g).
Proposed Sec. 1006.18(g) provides that an attorney has been
meaningfully involved in the preparation of debt collection litigation
submissions if the attorney: (1) Drafts or reviews the pleading,
written motion, or other paper; and (2) personally reviews information
supporting the submission and determines, to the best of the attorney's
knowledge, information, and belief, that, as applicable: The claims,
defenses, and other legal contentions are warranted by existing law;
the factual contentions have evidentiary support; and the denials of
factual contentions are warranted on the evidence or, if specifically
so identified, are reasonably based on belief or lack of information.
The factors in proposed Sec. 1008.18(g) are similar to some of the
nationally recognized standards for attorneys making submissions in
civil litigation.\351\ Because most FDCPA claims are considered by
Federal courts, and Federal court rules are adopted and apply
nationwide, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11(b)(2) through (4) as
currently adopted may provide an appropriate guide for judging whether
a submission to the court has complied with Sec. 1006.18(g). Indeed,
courts that have applied the meaningful attorney involvement doctrine
to litigation submissions have considered that standard.\352\
Accordingly, the safe harbor in proposed Sec. 1006.18(g) restates
certain provisions of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure Rule 11(b). An
attorney or law firm who establishes compliance with the factors set
forth in proposed Sec. 1006.18(g), including when a court in debt
collection litigation determines that the debt collector has complied
with a court rule that is substantially similar to the standard in
Sec. 1006.18(g), will have complied with FDCPA section 807 regarding
the attorney's meaningful involvement in submissions made in debt
collection litigation. The Bureau requests comment on whether the safe
harbor proposed for meaningful attorney involvement in debt collection
litigation submissions provides sufficient clarity for consumers,
attorneys, and law firms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\351\ The factors in proposed Sec. 1008.18(g) omit the
following two aspects of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11(b)(2)
through (4): First, that the claims, defenses, or other legal
contentions are a non-frivolous argument for extending, modifying,
or reversing existing law or for establishing new law; and second,
that the factual contentions are likely to have evidentiary support
after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or
discovery. This safe harbor is proposed in part to set clearer
standards for routine debt collection litigation cases, in which
there is unlikely to be an argument to extend, modify, or reverse
existing law or to establish new law. The Bureau also understands
that most factual contentions pled in debt collection litigation
should be supported by evidence in the creditor's or debt
collector's possession, thereby negating the need for further
investigation or discovery. Moreover, proposed Sec. 1006.18(g)
would provide a safe harbor; thus, meeting one of these omitted
aspects may permit an attorney to establish meaningful attorney
involvement even if doing so would not entitle the attorney to the
safe harbor that proposed Sec. 1006.18(g) would establish.
\352\ See, e.g., Bock v. Pressler & Pressler, 2017 WL 4711472 at
*7 n.5 (discussing initial decision at 30 F.Supp.3d 283, 299-302);
Miller, 687 F.Supp.2d at 101 (analogizing to Rule 11).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.22 Unfair or Unconscionable Means
FDCPA section 808 prohibits a debt collector from using any unfair
or unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt and
lists eight non-exhaustive examples of such prohibited conduct.\353\
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.22 to implement and interpret FDCPA
section 808 and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to
write rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\353\ 15 U.S.C. 1692f.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.22(a) would implement FDCPA section 808's
general prohibition against unfair debt collection practices, and
proposed Sec. 1006.22(b) through (f)(2) would implement the prohibited
conduct examples in FDCPA section 808.\354\ These proposed paragraphs
generally mirror the statute, with minor wording and organizational
changes for clarity. The following section-by-section analysis thus
discusses only proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) and (4) and (g).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\354\ Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.22(b) would implement
FDCPA section 808(1); proposed Sec. 1006.22(c) would implement
FDCPA section 808(2) through (4); proposed Sec. 1006.22(d) would
implement FDCPA section 808(5); proposed Sec. 1006.22(e) would
implement FDCPA section 808(6); proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(1) would
implement FDCPA section 808(7); and proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(2)
would implement FDCPA section 808(8).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
22(f) Restrictions on Use of Certain Media
Proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) and (4) would restrict a debt
collector's use of two specific types of electronic media: Work email
accounts and public-facing social media. As to electronic media more
generally, the Bureau plans to monitor their evolution and use by debt
collectors, as well as any trends in FDCPA section 808 litigation
concerning such media, to identify issues that pose a risk of consumer
harm or require clarification as part of any future rulemakings.
22(f)(3)
Proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) would prohibit a debt collector from
communicating or attempting to communicate with a consumer using an
email address that the debt collector knows or should know is provided
to the consumer by the consumer's employer, unless the debt collector
has received directly from the consumer either prior consent to use
that email address or an email from that email address.
The FDCPA contains both general and specific prohibitions intended
to protect consumers from the harms that workplace collections
communications can cause. For example, absent obtaining the consumer's
prior consent, a debt collector who discloses a debt to a consumer's
employer generally would violate FDCPA section 805(b)'s prohibition on
communicating with a third party about a debt.\355\ A debt collector
also could violate FDCPA section 805(a)(3) by communicating with the
consumer at the consumer's place of employment if the debt collector
knows or has reason to know that the consumer's employer prohibits the
consumer from receiving such communications.\356\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\355\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(b).
\356\ 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors and consumers may have questions about how the
FDCPA's protections against third-party disclosures apply to workplace
contacts by newer means of communication, such as email. Debt
collectors should be aware that many employers have a legal right to
read, and in fact frequently do read, messages sent or received by
employees on their work email accounts.\357\ Workplace emails therefore
present a particularly high risk of third-party disclosure through an
employer reading an email sent by a debt collector to a consumer's work
account. In addition, Congress and the courts have recognized that an
employer learning that an employee has a debt in collection may cause
the consumer to suffer significant harms, including loss
[[Page 23325]]
of employment.\358\ The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) on the
ground that a debt collector who sends a communication to a consumer's
work email account violates the FDCPA if the debt collector knows or
can reasonably anticipate that a communication sent to a consumer's
work email account might be opened and read by someone other than the
consumer. There is support for this interpretation in court decisions
holding that a debt collector who sends a letter to a consumer's place
of employment violates the FDCPA if the debt collector ``knew or could
reasonably anticipate that [such] a letter . . . might be opened and
read by someone other than the debtor as it made its way to [the
consumer].'' \359\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\357\ See, e.g., Am. Mgmt. Ass'n & ePolicy Inst., Electronic
Monitoring and Surveillance 2007 Survey (2008), http://www.amanet.org/training/articles/2007-electronic-monitoring-and-surveillance-survey-41.aspx (reporting that a survey of employers
conducted in 2007 found that, among other things, 43 percent of
employers monitored their employees' email accounts and 66 percent
of employers monitored their employees' internet connection, with 45
percent of employers tracking the content, keystrokes, and time
spent at the keyboard); Bingham v. Baycare Health Sys., No. 8:14-CV-
73-T-23JSS, 2016 WL 3917513, at *4 (M.D. Fla. July 20, 2016)
(collecting cases and concluding that ``the majority of courts have
found that an employee has no reasonable expectation of privacy in
workplace emails when the employer's policy limits personal use or
otherwise restricts employees' use of its system and notifies
employees of its policy'').
\358\ S. Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 1699 (``[A] debt
collector may not contact third persons such as a consumer's
friends, neighbors, relatives, or employer. Such contacts are not
legitimate collection practices and result in serious invasions of
privacy, as well as the loss of jobs.''); id. at 1696 (``Collection
abuse takes many forms, including . . . disclosing a consumer's
personal affairs to friends, neighbors, or an employer.''); 122
Cong. Rec. H730707 (daily ed. July 19, 1976) (remarks of Rep.
Annunzio on H. Rept. 13720) (Clearinghouse No. 31,059U)
(``Communication with a consumer at work or with his employer may
work a tremendous hardship for a consumer because such calls can
embarrass a consumer and can result in his losing a deserved
promotion'' and ``[i]f a consumer loses his job, he is in a worse,
not better, position to pay the debt.''); Am. Fin. Servs. Ass'n v.
Fed. Trade Comm'n, 767 F.2d 957, 974 (D.C. Cir. 1985) (upholding
provision in the FTC's Credit Practices Rule that prohibited certain
wage assignments because, among other things, the rulemaking record
showed that ``employers tend to view the consumer's failure to repay
the debt as a sign of irresponsibility. As a consequence many lose
their jobs after wage assignments are filed. Even if the consumer
retains the job, promotions, raises, and job assignments may be
adversely affected.'') (citing Credit Practices Rule, 49 FR 7740,
7758 (1984) (codified at 16 CFR 444)); Fed. Trade Comm'n v.
LoanPointe, LLC, No. 2:10-CV-225DAK, 2011 WL 4348304, at *6-8 (D.
Utah Sept. 16, 2011) (holding that ``Defendants' practice of
disclosing debts and the amount of the debts to consumers'
employers'' violated the FDCPA and ``qualifies as an unfair practice
under the FTC Act''), aff'd, 525 F. App'x 696 (10th Cir. 2013). The
State of New York prohibits a debt collector from corresponding with
a consumer by email unless, among other things, the consumer
voluntarily provided the email address to the debt collector and has
affirmed that the email is not ``furnished or owned by the
consumer's employer.'' 23 N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 23, sec.
1.6(a) (2018).
\359\ Evon v. Law Offices of Sidney Mickell, 688 F.3d 1015,
1025-26 (9th Cir. 2012) (holding that a letter addressed ``in care
of [consumer's] employer'' and delivered to her at work,
``manifestly constitutes a violation [of the FDCPA because the debt
collector] knew or could reasonably anticipate that a letter sent to
a class member's employer might be opened and read by someone other
than the debtor as it made its way to him/her. This is exactly what
happened to [the consumer], causing her stress and embarrassment,
precisely what the Act is designed to prevent.''); see also Fed.
Trade Comm'n, Staff Commentary on the Fair Debt Collection Practices
Act, 53 FR 50097-02, 50104 (Dec. 13, 1988) (``Accessibility by third
party. A debt collector may not send a written message that is
easily accessible to third parties. For example, he may not use a
computerized billing statement that can be seen on the envelope
itself. A debt collector may use an `in care of' letter only if the
consumer lives at, or accepts mail at, the other party's
address.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As suggested by numerous consumer advocacy groups and a consortium
of State attorneys general in comments to the Bureau's ANPRM, requiring
a debt collector to obtain a consumer's consent, or to have received an
email from the consumer, before sending emails to the consumer's work
account could protect the consumer's privacy interest in avoiding the
disclosure of the debt to the consumer's employer. This privacy
interest is implicated by both communications and attempts to
communicate. A debt collector's initial, unsolicited email that does
not convey information regarding a debt nonetheless may induce a
recipient such as a consumer or an employer to inquire about the
purpose of the debt collector's message. The debt collector's attempt
to communicate thus may lead to the disclosure of the debt to a third
party before the consumer has had a meaningful opportunity to provide
prior consent. A consumer who chooses to use a work email account to
contact a debt collector, or who provides prior consent for the debt
collector to use such an email account to contact the consumer,
presumably has made a determination that the benefits of communicating
with a debt collector about a debt using a work email account outweigh
the potential risks, and a debt collector who receives such an email or
prior consent from the consumer may not reasonably anticipate that its
emails to the consumer would be read by the consumer's employer.
Accordingly, after a consumer uses the work email account to contact
the debt collector or provides prior consent, it would not appear to be
an unfair or unconscionable practice under FDCPA section 808 for a debt
collector to communicate or attempt to communicate with the consumer
using an email address that the debt collector knows or should know is
provided by the consumer's employer.
For all of these reasons, pursuant to its authority to implement
and interpret FDCPA section 808 and its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to write rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt
collectors, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) to prohibit a debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with a
consumer using an email address that the debt collector knows or should
know is provided to the consumer by the consumer's employer, unless the
debt collector has received directly from the consumer either prior
consent to use that email address or an email from that email address.
Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-1 notes that, even after providing prior
consent directly to a debt collector, a consumer could opt out of
receiving emails at a work email address at any time using instructions
provided by a debt collector pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.6(e), or
otherwise request not to receive emails at that address pursuant to
proposed Sec. 1006.14(h). Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-1 also refers to
the commentary to proposed Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i) for additional
guidance on prior consent.
Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-2 would clarify that a debt collector who
receives an email directly from a consumer from an email address
provided by the consumer's employer may communicate or attempt to
communicate with the consumer at that email address, even if the
consumer's email does not provide prior consent to the debt collector.
Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-2 also provides an example of such a
situation.
Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-3 provides examples of email addresses
that a debt collector knows or should know are provided to the consumer
by the consumer's employer. Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-3 also states
that, in the absence of contrary information, a debt collector neither
would know nor should know that an email address is provided to the
consumer by the consumer's employer if the email address's domain name
is one commonly associated with a provider of non-work email addresses.
Examples of domain names that are commonly associated with a provider
of non-work email addresses would include gmail.com, yahoo.com,
hotmail.com, aol.com, or msn.com, among others.\360\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\360\ See, e.g., Email-Verify.My.Addr.com, List of Most Popular
Email Domains (By Number of Live Emails), https://email-verify.my-addr.com/list-of-most-popular-email-domains.php (last visited May 6,
2019) (listing the most popular email domain names, ranked by number
of live emails).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives sought
guidance on how they would know whether an email address is provided to
a consumer by an employer and also suggested that a consumer's consent
to use a work email should transfer from the creditor to the debt
collector.\361\ Proposed comment 22(f)(3)-3, which addresses when a
debt collector knows or should
[[Page 23326]]
know that an email address is provided by a consumer's employer, is
designed to provide such guidance. In addition, proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(3) would not apply a strict liability standard, so a debt
collector would not violate the rule if the debt collector neither knew
nor should have known that the debt collector used a consumer's work
email address. The Bureau does not propose, however, that a consumer's
prior consent to receive email on the consumer's work account from a
creditor would transfer to a debt collector. A consumer may enter into
a transaction with, and consent to receiving emails on their work
account from, a creditor based on the characteristics of that
particular creditor; in contrast, consumers generally have no ability
to choose which debt collector attempts to collect their debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\361\ These comments were similar to ANPRM comments submitted by
several industry members, who noted that debt collectors may not be
able to determine accurately whether an email address is provided by
an employer because, among other things, the domain name may not
signify that it is a work email or the consumer may consolidate
multiple email accounts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One small entity representative recommended that emails to a
consumer's work address be presumptively prohibited only if the debt
collector knows or should know that the employer prohibits such contact
(i.e., applying the FDCPA section 805(a)(3) framework to work email
accounts).\362\ As discussed above, workplace email communications
present a particularly high risk of third-party disclosure because many
employers have a legal right to read messages sent or received by
employees on their work email accounts. For this reason, the
prohibition in proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(3) does not apply the FDCPA
section 805(a)(3) framework. Rather, to protect consumers from loss of
employment and risk of embarrassment, the Bureau proposes to require
that a debt collector obtain prior consent to use that email address
directly from the consumer, or have received an email sent from the
consumer's work email account, before using the consumer's work email
account.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\362\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(3). In particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether
FDCPA section 805(a)(3)'s framework should apply to emails to a
consumer's work account, so that such emails are presumptively
prohibited only when a debt collector knows or should know that a
consumer's employer prohibits the consumer from receiving such
communications. The Bureau also requests comment on whether more
clarification is necessary regarding when a debt collector knows or
should know that the debt collector is communicating using a consumer's
work email address and, if so, what circumstances should indicate to a
debt collector that an email address is provided by a consumer's
employer. The Bureau further requests comment on the scope of proposed
Sec. 1006.22(f)(3). As proposed, it would apply only to email contacts
with the person obligated or allegedly obligated to pay a debt (i.e., a
person defined as a consumer under proposed Sec. 1006.2(e)). The
Bureau requests comment on whether it should be broadened to apply to
email contacts with a consumer as defined in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a).
22(f)(4)
Proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(4) provides that a debt collector must
not communicate or attempt to communicate with a consumer in connection
with the collection of a debt by a social media platform that is
viewable by a person other than the consumer or other person described
in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(i) through (vi).
The FDCPA contains numerous provisions that guard against the
disclosure of the consumer's financial affairs to individual third
parties or the broader public.\363\ For example, FDCPA section 805(b)
generally prohibits communicating with third parties in connection with
the collection of a debt; FDCPA section 806(3) prohibits publishing
public ``shame lists'' of consumers who allegedly refuse to pay their
debts; \364\ and FDCPA section 808(7) and (8) prohibits communicating
with a consumer regarding a debt by postcard or using most language or
symbols on the outside of an envelope. The Bureau believes that
communications or attempts to communicate by social media platforms
that are viewable by a person other than a person with whom a debt
collector may communicate under FDCPA section 805(b) similarly risk
exposing a consumer's affairs to the public. For example, a debt
collector's message to a consumer posted on a public-facing social
media page may be viewed by many of the consumer's social or
professional contacts, who may interpret a widely distributed message
asking that the consumer return a call as an indication that the
consumer is delinquent on an obligation. Accordingly, a debt collector
may engage in an unfair or unconscionable act by, in connection with
the collection of a debt, communicating or attempting to communicate
with a consumer by publicly viewable social media platform.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\363\ Invasion of individual privacy appears to have been one of
the primary harms that Congress sought to eliminate through the
FDCPA. FDCPA section 802(a), (e); 15 U.S.C. 1692(a), (e); S. Rept.
No. 382, supra note 70, at 1699 (``[A] debt collector may not
contact third persons such as a consumer's friends, neighbors,
relatives, or employer. Such contacts are not legitimate collection
practices and result in serious invasions of privacy, as well as the
loss of jobs.''); id. at 1696 (``Collection abuse takes many forms,
including . . . disclosing a consumer's personal affairs to friends,
neighbors, or an employer.''); see also Douglass v. Convergent
Outsourcing, 765 F.3d 299, 303 (3d Cir. 2014) (describing ``the
invasion of privacy'' as ``a core concern animating the FDCPA'').
\364\ S. Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 1696.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Such conduct also may have the natural consequence of harassing,
oppressing, or abusing the consumer. Although some social media
contacts, such as a limited-content message, may not convey information
regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person, given the many
other ways a debt collector could attempt to communicate with a
consumer that are not viewable by a potentially wide array of the
consumer's social or professional colleagues--such as by telephone,
text message, postal mail, email, or private message through the same
social media platform--a debt collector may have no legitimate purpose
in contacting a consumer by publicly viewable social media. As a
result, such conduct may serve only to harass, oppress, or abuse.
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) and to interpret FDCPA sections 806 and 808, proposed
Sec. 1006.22(f)(4) provides that a debt collector must not communicate
or attempt to communicate with a consumer in connection with the
collection of a debt by a social media platform that is viewable by a
person other than a person described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(i)
through (vi). Proposed comment 22(f)(4)-1 provides examples
illustrating the proposed rule.
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(4), including on whether debt collectors anticipate that
they will use social media platforms to contact consumers. The Bureau
also requests comment on whether debt collectors have any non-harassing
purpose for attempting to communicate with consumers using public-
facing social media platforms and, if so, whether proposed Sec.
1006.22(f)(4) should have an exception for attempts to communicate such
as limited-content messages. The Bureau further requests comment on the
scope of proposed Sec. 1006.22(f)(4). As proposed, it would apply only
to social media contacts with the person obligated or allegedly
obligated to pay a debt (i.e., a person defined as a consumer under
proposed Sec. 1006.2(e)). The Bureau requests comment on
[[Page 23327]]
whether it should be broadened to apply to social media contacts with
any person described as a consumer in proposed Sec. 1006.6(a).
22(g) Safe Harbor for Certain Emails and Text Messages Relating to the
Collection of a Debt
FDCPA section 808 contains certain provisions designed to protect
consumer privacy. As noted, FDCPA section 808(7) prohibits a debt
collector from communicating with a consumer regarding a debt by
postcard, and FDCPA section 808(8) generally prohibits a debt collector
from using any language or symbol, other than the debt collector's
address, on any envelope when communicating with a consumer by postal
mail. As courts have recognized, these provisions aim to protect
consumer privacy by limiting public disclosure of a consumer's
debts.\365\ The examples in FDCPA section 808(7) and (8) apply to
postal mail practices. In pre-proposal feedback, industry groups noted
that uncertainty about how similar prohibitions might be applied to
emails and text messages discourages the use of those technologies to
communicate with consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\365\ See, e.g., Douglass v. Convergent Outsourcing, 765 F.3d
299, 302 (3d Cir. 2014) (``Section 1692f evinces Congress's intent
to screen from public view information pertinent to the debt
collection.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To mitigate such uncertainty while also protecting consumer
privacy, proposed Sec. 1006.22(g) provides that a debt collector who
communicates with a consumer using an email address, or telephone
number for text messages, and follows the procedures described in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) does not violate Sec. 1006.22(a) by
revealing in the email or text message the debt collector's name or
other information indicating that the communication relates to the
collection of a debt. The procedures in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) are
designed to ensure that a debt collector who uses a particular email
address or telephone number to communicate with a consumer by email or
text message does not have a reason to anticipate that an unauthorized
third-party disclosure may occur. If the proposed procedures work as
designed, there would not be a reason to anticipate that a third party
would see the debt collector's name or other debt-collection-related
information included in a communication sent to such an email address
or telephone number. Some pre-proposal feedback raised the possibility
that a third party could read an electronic communication on, for
example, the consumer's mobile telephone by looking over the consumer's
shoulder. However, this feedback did not include any actual evidence of
the prevalence of such behavior. Moreover, consumers generally should
be able to manage over-the-shoulder risk by choosing where and when to
read electronic communications and how to configure their devices.
Proposed Sec. 1006.22(g) would provide a safe harbor only as to
claims that a debt collector violated Sec. 1006.22 by revealing in the
email or text message the debt collector's name or other information
indicating that the communication relates to the collection of a debt.
The proposed provision would not provide a safe harbor as to claims
that a debt collector's email or text message violated the FDCPA or
Regulation F in other ways. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.22(g).
In the Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau described a
proposal under consideration to prohibit a debt collector from sending
an email message to a consumer if the ``from'' or ``subject'' lines
contained information revealing that the email was about a debt.\366\
The Bureau's concern was that such information could reveal to others
that the communication related to a debt.\367\ The Bureau does not
propose this restriction described in the Small Business Review Panel
Outline. In pre-proposal feedback, debt collectors suggested that the
restriction would make electronic communication generally more
difficult. Some industry participants predicted that, if debt
collectors were required to exclude from an email's ``from'' or
``subject'' lines all information suggestive of debt collection,
consumers would be less likely to understand the email's purpose and
more likely to treat the email like spam and delete or ignore it. This
is consistent with research suggesting that the most important factors
in whether a consumer will open an email are whether they recognize the
sender and the content of the subject line.\368\ Proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3), which, as noted above, describes procedures for obtaining
and using an email address or a telephone number that is unlikely to
lead to a third-party disclosure, may be a more effective initial step
to minimize the risk of third-party disclosure.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\366\ Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at
appendix H.
\367\ Id.
\368\ Direct Marketing Ass'n, Consumer Email Tracker 2017, at 18
(2017), https://dma.org.uk/uploads/misc/5a1583ff3301a-consumer-email-tracking-report-2017-(2)_5a1583ff32f65.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.26 Collection of Time-Barred Debts
Proposed Sec. 1006.26 contains interventions related to the
collection of time-barred debts. Proposed Sec. 1006.26(a) would define
several terms, and proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) would prohibit debt
collectors from suing or threatening to sue consumers to collect time-
barred debts. The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.26 pursuant to its
authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to
the collection of debts by debt collectors.
26(a) Definitions
Proposed Sec. 1006.26(a) would define several terms used in Sec.
1006.26 but not defined in the FDCPA. These definitions would
facilitate compliance with proposed Sec. 1006.26(b), which would
interpret FDCPA section 807 to prohibit debt collectors from suing and
threatening to sue consumers to collect time-barred debts.
26(a)(1) Statute of Limitations
Proposed Sec. 1006.26(a)(2), discussed below, would define the
term time-barred debt to mean a debt for which the applicable statute
of limitations has expired. Proposed Sec. 1006.26(a)(1), in turn,
would define the term statute of limitations to mean the period
prescribed by applicable law for bringing a legal action against the
consumer to collect a debt.
Statutes of limitations typically are established by State law and
provide time limits for bringing suit on legal claims.\369\ They
reflect a public policy determination that it is unjust to subject
defendants to suit after a specified period.\370\ For debt collection
claims, the length of the applicable statute of limitations often
varies by State and, within each State, by debt type.\371\ Most
statutes of limitations applicable to debt collection claims are
between three and six years, although some are as long as 15
years.\372\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\369\ Federal law sometimes establishes the statute of
limitations. For example, legal actions to recover certain
telecommunications debt are subject to a statute of limitations set
by Federal law. See 47 U.S.C. 415(a).
\370\ See, e.g., United States v. Kubrick, 444 U.S. 111, 117
(1979) (``Statutes of limitations . . . represent a pervasive
legislative judgment that it is unjust to fail to put the adversary
on notice to defend within a specified period of time and that the
right to be free of stale claims in time comes to prevail over the
right to prosecute them.'' (internal citation and quotation marks
omitted)).
\371\ See Fed. Trade Comm'n, Repairing a Broken System:
Protecting Consumers in Debt Collection Litigation and Arbitration,
at 24 (July 2010) (hereinafter FTC Litigation Report).
\372\ See FTC Debt Buying Report, supra note 14, at 42.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23328]]
Debt collectors generally are familiar with the concept of statutes
of limitations, and the proposed definition generally should be
consistent with debt collectors' understanding of the term. The Bureau
requests comment on the proposed definition and whether any additional
clarification is needed.
26(a)(2) Time-Barred Debt
Proposed Sec. 1006.26(a)(2) would define the term time-barred debt
to mean a debt for which the applicable statute of limitations has
expired. Debt collectors generally are familiar with the concept of
time-barred debt, and the definition of time-barred debt in proposed
Sec. 1006.26(a)(2) is consistent with debt collectors' understanding
of the term.
Many debt collectors already determine whether the statute of
limitations applicable to a debt has expired. Some do so to comply with
State and local disclosure laws that require them to inform consumers
when debts are time barred.\373\ Others do so to assess whether they
can sue to collect the debt, which may affect their collection
strategy. The information that debt buyers generally receive when
bidding on and purchasing debts, and the information that other debt
collectors generally receive at placement, should allow them to
determine whether the applicable statute of limitations has
expired.\374\ The Bureau requests comment on the proposed definition
and on whether any additional clarification is needed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\373\ See, e.g., Cal. Civ. Code Sec. 1788.52(d)(3); Conn. Gen.
Stat. Sec. 36a-805(a)(14); Mass. Code Regs., tit. 940, Sec.
7.07(24); N.M. Code. R. Sec. 12.2.12.9(A); N.Y. Comp. Codes R. &
Regs., tit. 23, Sec. 1.3; New York City, N.Y., Rules, tit. 6, Sec.
2-191(a); W. Va. Code Sec. 46a-2-128(f).
\374\ See FTC Debt Buying Report, supra note 14, at 49 (``The
data the Commission received from debt buyers suggests that debt
buyers usually are likely to know or be able to determine whether
the debts on which they are collecting are beyond the statute of
limitations.''); CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note
45, at 23 (noting that the majority of respondents reported always
or often receiving, among other things, debt balance at charge off,
account agreement documentation, and billing statements).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
26(b) Suits and Threats of Suit Prohibited
Under the laws of most States, expiration of the applicable statute
of limitations, if raised by the consumer as an affirmative defense,
precludes the debt collector from recovering on the debt using judicial
processes, but it does not extinguish the debt itself.\375\ In other
words, in most States, a debt collector may use non-litigation means to
collect a time-barred debt, as long as those means do not violate the
FDCPA or other laws. If a debt collector does sue to collect a time-
barred debt and the consumer proves the expiration of the statute of
limitations as an affirmative defense, the court will dismiss the suit.
Multiple courts have held that suits and threats of suit on time-barred
debt violate the FDCPA, reasoning that such practices violate FDCPA
section 807's prohibition on false or misleading representations, FDCPA
section 808's prohibition on unfair practices, or both.\376\ The FTC
has also concluded that the FDCPA bars actual and threatened suits on
time-barred debt.\377\ In addition, at least one industry group
requires its members to refrain from suing or threatening to sue on
time-barred debts.\378\ Nevertheless, the Bureau's enforcement
experience suggests that some debt collectors may continue to sue or
threaten to sue on time-barred debts.\379\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\375\ In Mississippi and Wisconsin, debts are extinguished when
the applicable statute of limitations expires. See Miss. Code Ann.
Sec. 15-1-3 (``The completion of the period of limitation
prescribed to bar any action, shall defeat and extinguish the right
as well as the remedy.''); Wis. Stat. Ann. Sec. 893.05 (``When the
period within which an action may be commenced on a Wisconsin cause
of action has expired, the right is extinguished as well as the
remedy.'').
\376\ See, e.g., Pantoja v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC, 852
F.3d 679, 683-84 (7th Cir. 2017); McMahon v. LVNV Funding, LLC, 744
F.3d 1010, 1020 (7th Cir. 2014); Phillips v. Asset Acceptance, LLC,
736 F.3d 1076, 1079 (7th Cir. 2013); Huertas v. Galaxy Asset Mgmt.,
641 F.3d 28, 33 (3d Cir. 2011); Goins v. JBC & Assocs., P.C., 352 F.
Supp. 2d 262, 273 (D. Conn. 2005); Kimber v. Fed. Fin. Corp., 668 F.
Supp. 1480, 1487-89 (M.D. Ala. 1987).
\377\ FTC Litigation Report, supra note 371, at 23.
\378\ Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n Int'l, Receivables Management
Certification Program, at 32 (Jan. 2018), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Certification-Policy-version-6.0-FINAL-20180119.pdf (``A Certified Company shall not knowingly bring or
imply that it has the ability to bring a lawsuit on a debt that is
beyond the applicable statute of limitations, even if state law
revives the limitations period when a payment is received after the
expiration of the statute.''); see also David E. Reid, Out-of-
Statute Debt: What is a Smart, Balanced, and Responsible Approach,
at 8 (Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n Int'l, White Paper, 2015), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/RMA_Whitepaper_OOS.pdf
(``Although, as noted, the statute of limitations is an affirmative
defense that, in almost all states, must be raised by the defendant
or it is waived, it is improper to knowingly file OSD [i.e., out-of-
statute debt] suits and wait to see if the defense is pled.'').
\379\ Consent Order at ]] 65-69, In re Encore Capital Group,
Inc., No. 2015-CFPB-0022 (Sept. 9, 2015), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201509_cfpb_consent-order-encore-capital-group.pdf; Consent Order at ]] 56-59, In re Portfolio
Recovery Assocs. LLC, No. 2015-CFPB-0023 (Sept. 9, 2015), http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201509_cfpb_consent-order-portfolio-recovery-associates-llc.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A debt collector who sues or threatens to sue a consumer on a time-
barred debt may explicitly or implicitly misrepresent to the consumer
that the debt is legally enforceable, and that misrepresentation likely
is material to consumers because it may affect their conduct with
regard to the collection of that debt, including, for example, whether
to pay it.\380\ In response to the Bureau's ANPRM, some consumer
advocacy groups and State Attorneys General observed that consumers are
often uncertain about their rights concerning time-barred debt. The
Bureau's consumer testing to date is consistent with those
observations.\381\ In addition, as courts have recognized, the passage
of time ``dulls the consumer's memory of the circumstances and validity
of the debt'' and ``heightens the probability that [the consumer] will
no longer have personal records detailing the status of the debt.''
\382\ Consumers sued or threatened with suit on a time-barred debt may
not recognize that the debt is time barred, that time-barred debts are
unenforceable in court, or that generally they must raise the
expiration of the statute of limitations as an affirmative defense.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\380\ See, e.g., Kimber, 668 F. Supp. at 1489 (``By threatening
to sue Kimber on her alleged debt . . . FFC implicit[ly] represented
that it could recover in a lawsuit, when in fact it cannot properly
do so.'').
\381\ See FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 9-10; FMG
Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 36-37; FMG Summary Report, supra
note 42, at 35-36; see also FTC Litigation Report, supra note 371,
at iii, 26.
\382\ Phillips, 736 F.3d at 1079 (quoting Kimber, 668 F. Supp.
at 1487).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Suits and threats of suit on time-barred debts can harm consumers
in multiple ways. A debt collector's threat to sue on a time-barred
debt may prompt some consumers to pay or prioritize that debt over
others in the mistaken belief that doing so is necessary to forestall
litigation. Similarly, suits on time-barred debts may lead to judgments
against consumers on claims for which those consumers had meritorious
defenses, including, but not limited to, a statute-of-limitations
defense. Such judgments may be especially likely given that few
consumers sued for allegedly unpaid debts--whether time-barred or not--
actually defend themselves in court, and those who do often are
unrepresented. As a result, the vast majority of judgments on unpaid
debts, including on time-barred debts, are default judgments, entered
solely on the representations contained in the debt collector's
complaint.\383\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\383\ See FTC Debt Buying Report, supra note 14, at 45
(observing that ``90 percent or more of consumers sued in [debt
collection actions] do not appear in court to defend,'' which
``creates a risk that consumer will be subject to a default judgment
on a time-barred debt''); Peter A. Holland, The One Hundred Billion
Dollar Problem in Small Claims Court: Robo-Signing and Lack of Proof
in Debt Buyer Cases, 6 J. Bus. & Tech. L. 259, 265 (2011) (``In the
majority of debt buyer cases, the courts grant the debt buyer a
default judgment because the consumer has failed to appear for
trial. . . . Debtors who do receive notice usually appear without
legal representation.''); CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study,
supra note 45, at 18 (observing that respondents reported obtaining
default judgments in 60 to 90 percent of their filed suits); cf.
Kimber, 668 F. Supp. at 1487 (``Because few unsophisticated
consumers would be aware that a statute of limitations could be used
to defend against lawsuits based on stale debts, such consumers
would unwittingly acquiesce to such lawsuits. And, even if the
consumer realizes that she can use time as a defense, she will more
than likely still give in rather than fight the lawsuit because she
must still expend energy and resources and subject herself to the
embarrassment of going into court to present the defense; this is
particularly true in light of the costs of attorneys today.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23329]]
According to the small entity representatives who participated in
the SBREFA process, debt collectors generally do not sue on debt they
know to be time barred. Similarly, a trade association representing
debt buyers has reported that, in a poll of its members, not one
responded that they knowingly or intentionally file lawsuits after the
applicable statute of limitations has expired.\384\ During the SBREFA
process, however, several small entity representatives stated that
determining whether the statute of limitations has expired can be
complex. The determination may involve analyzing which statute of
limitations applies, when the statute of limitations began to run, and
whether the statute of limitations has been tolled or reset. The Bureau
believes that, in many cases, a debt collector will know, or can
readily determine, whether the statute of limitations has expired. In
some instances, however, a debt collector may be genuinely uncertain
even after undertaking a reasonable investigation; this could occur,
for example, when the case law in a State is unclear as to which
statute of limitations applies to a particular type of debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\384\ See David E. Reid, Out-of-Statute Debt: What is a Smart,
Balanced, and Responsible Approach, at 8, (Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n
Int'l, White Paper, 2015), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/RMA_Whitepaper_OOS.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA section
807 to provide that a debt collector must not bring or threaten to
bring a legal action against a consumer to collect a debt that the debt
collector knows or should know is a time-barred debt. FDCPA section 807
generally prohibits debt collectors from using ``any false, deceptive,
or misleading representation or means in connection with the collection
of any debt,'' and FDCPA section 807(2)(A) specifically prohibits
falsely representing ``the character, amount, or legal status of any
debt.'' The Bureau interprets FDCPA section 807 and 807(2)(A) to
prohibit debt collectors from suing or threatening to sue consumers on
debts they know or should know are time-barred debts because such suits
and threats of suit explicitly or implicitly misrepresent, and may
cause consumers to believe, that the debts are legally enforceable. In
addition, threats to sue consumers on time-barred debts are similar to
threats to take actions that cannot legally be taken, which FDCPA
section 807(5) specifically prohibits, because both involve the threat
of action to which the consumer has a complete legal defense. The
Bureau's proposed interpretation of FDCPA section 807 is generally
consistent with well-established case law holding that lawsuits and
threats of lawsuits on time-barred debt violate FDCPA section 807.\385\
The proposed rule may provide debt collectors with greater certainty as
to what the law prohibits while also protecting consumers and enabling
them to prove legal violations without having to litigate in each case
whether lawsuits and threats of lawsuits on time-barred debt violate
the FDCPA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\385\ See, e.g., Pantoja, 852 F.3d at 683; McMahon, 744 F.3d at
1020; Phillips, 736 F.3d at 1079; Kimber, 668 F. Supp. at 1488-89.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) and on
whether any additional clarification is needed. In particular, the
prohibitions in proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) would apply only if the debt
collector knows or should know that the applicable statute of
limitations has expired. It sometimes may be difficult, however, to
determine whether a ``know or should have known'' standard has been
met. Such uncertainty could increase litigation costs and make
enforcement of proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) more difficult. In part to
address this concern, the Small Business Review Panel Outline described
an alternative strict-liability standard pursuant to which a debt
collector would be liable for suing or threatening to sue on a time-
barred debt even if the debt collector neither knew nor should have
known that the debt was time barred.\386\ The Bureau specifically
requests comment on using a ``knows or should know'' standard in
proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) and on the merits of using a strict liability
standard instead.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\386\ Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
26(c) Reserved
The Bureau is likely to propose that debt collectors must provide
disclosures to consumers when collecting time-barred debts. The Bureau
currently is completing its evaluation of whether consumers take away
from non-litigation collection efforts that they can or may be sued on
a debt and, if so, whether that take-away changes depending on the age
of the debt. In many States, a consumer's partial payment on a time-
barred debt or acknowledgment of a time-barred debt in writing restarts
the statute of limitations period and ``revives'' the debt collector's
right to sue for the full amount. The Bureau is also completing its
evaluation of how a time-barred debt disclosure might affect consumers'
understanding of whether debts can be revived. The disclosures under
consideration include a disclosure that would inform a consumer that,
because of the age of the debt, the debt collector cannot sue to
recover it. They also include, where applicable, a disclosure that
would inform a consumer that the right to sue on a time-barred debt can
be revived in certain circumstances. The Small Business Review Panel
Outline discussed certain such disclosures, and the Bureau has received
feedback from stakeholders about both the need for, and the content of,
such disclosures.\387\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\387\ Id. at 20-21.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau plans to conduct additional consumer testing of possible
time-barred debt and revival disclosures, and expects this additional
testing to further inform the Bureau's evaluation of any time-barred
debt disclosures. At a later date, the Bureau intends to issue a report
on such testing and any disclosure proposals related to the collection
of time-barred debt. Stakeholders will have an opportunity to comment
on such testing if the Bureau intends to use it to support disclosure
requirements in a final rule. The Bureau reserves Sec. 1006.26(c) and
appendix B of the regulation for any such proposals.
Section 1006.30 Other Prohibited Practices
Proposed Sec. 1006.30 contains several measures designed to
protect consumers from certain harmful debt collection practices.
Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.30(a) would regulate debt collectors'
furnishing practices under certain circumstances; proposed Sec.
1006.30(b) would limit the transfer of certain debts; and proposed
Sec. 1006.30(c), (d), and (e) would generally restate statutory
provisions regarding allocation of payments, venue, and the furnishing
of certain deceptive forms, respectively.
30(a) Communication Prior to Furnishing Information
Debt collectors may actively attempt to collect debts about which
they furnish information to consumer reporting agencies by, for
example,
[[Page 23330]]
calling or writing to consumers. However, some debt collectors engage
in ``passive'' collections by furnishing information to consumer
reporting agencies for inclusion in consumer reports without first
communicating with consumers.\388\ Debt collectors may attempt to
collect debts passively where the expected return from that technique
exceeds the cost of attempting to collect the debt by communicating
with consumers.\389\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\388\ See CFPB Medical Debt Report, supra note 20, at 36.
\389\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A consumer may suffer harm if a debt collector furnishes
information to a consumer reporting agency without first communicating
with the consumer. If debt collectors do not communicate with consumers
prior to furnishing, consumers are likely to be unaware that they have
a debt in collection unless they obtain and review their consumer
report. In turn, many consumers may not obtain and review their
consumer reports until they apply for credit, housing, employment, or
another product or service provided by an entity that reviews consumer
reports during the application process. At that point, consumers may
face pressure to pay debts that they otherwise would dispute, including
debts that they do not owe,\390\ in an effort to remove the debts from
their consumer reports and more quickly obtain a mortgage or job or
desired product or service. Consumers unaware of the debt before a
financial institution, landlord, employer, or other similar person
makes a decision also may face the denial of an application, a higher
interest rate, or other negative consequences.\391\ If the debt
collector had instead communicated with the consumer prior to
furnishing by, for example, sending the consumer a validation notice,
then the consumer would have been more likely to have information about
the debt and to have the opportunity to resolve the debt with the debt
collector by either paying or disputing it.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\390\ In some cases, the information furnished to consumer
reporting agencies may be inaccurate. See id. at 51 (``Significant
questions exist as to the accuracy of collections tradeline
reporting.'').
\391\ Such consumers generally would receive adverse action
notices alerting them to the negative item on their consumer report,
but these notices would occur too late to prevent the initial harm
from passive collection practices. See 15 U.S.C. 1681m(a). Consumers
who obtained credit from financial institutions also generally would
have received notices that the financial institutions furnish
negative information to nationwide consumer reporting agencies. See
15 U.S.C. 1681s-2(a)(7).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These consumer harms could be avoided if debt collectors
communicated with consumers before furnishing information about debts
in collection. The Bureau thus proposes Sec. 1006.30(a), which
provides that a debt collector must not furnish to a consumer reporting
agency, as defined in section 603(f) of the Fair Credit Reporting Act
(FCRA),\392\ information regarding a debt before communicating with the
consumer about the debt. Taken together with proposed Sec. 1006.34--
which generally would require debt collectors to provide consumers
important information about debts at the outset of collection,
including consumers' options for resolving them--proposed Sec.
1006.30(a) should reduce the harms that result from consumers being
unaware of or uninformed about their debts in collection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\392\ 15 U.S.C. 1681a(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives expressed
concern over the potential burden to a debt collector of documenting,
such as by using certified mail, that a consumer received a
communication. The Small Business Review Panel recommended that the
Bureau consider clarifying the type of communication that would be
sufficient to satisfy the requirement, including clarifying that debt
collectors do not need to send the validation notice by certified mail.
Proposed comment 30(a)-1 is designed to address the Panel's
recommendation. Proposed comment 30(a)-1 would clarify that a debt
collector would satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.30(a)'s requirement to
communicate if the debt collector conveyed information regarding a debt
directly or indirectly to the consumer through any medium, but a debt
collector would not satisfy the communication requirement if the debt
collector attempted to communicate with the consumer but no
communication occurred. For example, a debt collector communicates with
the consumer if the debt collector provides a validation notice to the
consumer, but a debt collector does not communicate with the consumer
by leaving a limited-content message for the consumer. Proposed comment
30(a)-1 also would clarify that a debt collector may refer to proposed
Sec. 1006.42 for more information on how to provide disclosures in a
manner that is reasonably expected to provide actual notice to
consumers. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.30(a) and
its related commentary.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.30(a) pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors; its authority to interpret
FDCPA section 806 regarding harassment, oppression, or abuse in
connection with the collection of a debt; and its authority to
interpret FDCPA section 808 regarding unfair or unconscionable means to
collect or attempt to collect any debt. As discussed in part IV, a debt
collector violates FDCPA section 806 if the debt collector engages in
conduct that has the natural consequence of harassing, oppressing, or
abusing any person in connection with the collection of a debt. A debt
collector violates FDCPA section 808 if the debt collector uses unfair
or unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt.
Courts have interpreted FDCPA sections 806 and 808 to prohibit
certain coercive collection methods that may cause consumers to pay
debts not actually owed.\393\ Passive collection practices are similar
to these other types of prohibited conduct because, as discussed above,
they exert significant pressure in circumstances that undermine the
ability of consumers to decide whether to pay debts, sometimes
resulting in them paying debts they do not owe or would have otherwise
disputed. The Bureau thus proposes Sec. 1006.30(a) to prohibit a debt
collector from furnishing information about a debt to consumer
reporting agencies prior to communicating with the consumer about that
debt, on the basis that subjecting a consumer to pressure by furnishing
information to a consumer reporting agency without first providing
notice to the consumer constitutes conduct that may have the natural
consequence of harassment, oppression, or abuse in violation of FDCPA
section 806, and that is an unfair or unconscionable means to collect
or attempt to collect a debt under FDCPA section 808.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\393\ See, e.g., Fox v. Citicorp Credit Servs., Inc., 15 F.3d
1507, 1517 (9th Cir. 1994) (reversing grant of summary judgment to
debt collector in part because ``a jury could rationally find'' that
filing writ of garnishment was unfair or unconscionable under
section 808 when debt was not delinquent); Ferrell v. Midland
Funding, LLC, No. 2:15-cv-00126-JHE, 2015 WL 2450615, at *3-4 (N.D.
Ala. May 22, 2015) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss
section 806 claim where debt collector allegedly initiated
collection lawsuit even though it knew plaintiff did not owe debt);
Pittman v. J.J. Mac Intyre Co. of Nev., Inc., 969 F. Supp. 609, 612-
13 (D. Nev. 1997) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss claims
under sections 807 and 808 where debt collector allegedly attempted
to collect fully satisfied debt).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
30(b) Prohibition on the Sale, Transfer, or Placement of Certain Debts
30(b)(1) In General
The sale, transfer, and placement for collection of debts that have
been paid or settled or discharged in bankruptcy,
[[Page 23331]]
or that are subject to an identity theft report creates risk of
consumer harm. If a debt is paid or settled, or discharged in
bankruptcy, the debt is either extinguished or uncollectible. If a debt
is listed on an identity theft report, the debt likely resulted from
fraud, in which case the consumer may not have a legal obligation to
repay it. Identity theft frequently results in fraudulent use of credit
and often is discovered only after unauthorized account activity has
occurred.\394\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\394\ In 2014, approximately 86 percent of identity theft
victims reported that their most recent incident involved
unauthorized charges on an existing credit card or bank account.
More than 60 percent of victims learned of the identity theft when
either a financial institution notified them of suspicious activity
in an account or the victim noticed fraudulent charges on an account
statement. Erika Harrell, Bureau of Justice Stats., Victims of
Identity Theft, 2014, at 2, 5, U.S. Dep't of Justice, (revised Nov.
13, 2017), https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vit14.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because debts that have been paid or settled or discharged in
bankruptcy are either extinguished or uncollectible, and because
consumers likely do not owe debts that are subject to an identity theft
report, debt collectors seeking to collect such debts almost inevitably
will make an express or implied false claim that consumers owe the
debts. For example, in response to the ANPRM, consumer advocates noted
that debt collectors who sue consumers to recover debts that were paid
or settled with previous creditors may rely on an incomplete account
history that does not reflect a consumer's prior payment or settlement.
The FDCPA in many places reflects a concern with debt collectors
collecting or attempting to collect debts that consumers likely do not
owe.\395\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\395\ See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 1692f(1) (prohibiting ``[t]he
collection of any amount (including any interest, fee, charge, or
expense incidental to the principal obligation) unless such amount
is expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or
permitted by law''); see also Jacobson v. Healthcare Fin. Servs.,
Inc., 516 F.3d 85, 89 (2d Cir. 2008) (quoting S. Rept. No. 382,
supra note 70, at 4); Fox v. Citicorp Credit Servs., Inc., 15 F.3d
1507, 1517 (9th Cir. 1994) (reversing grant of summary judgment to
debt collector in part because ``a jury could rationally find'' that
filing writ of garnishment was unfair or unconscionable under
section 808 when debt was not delinquent); Ferrell v. Midland
Funding, LLC, No. 2:15-cv-00126-JHE, 2015 WL 2450615, at *3-4 (N.D.
Ala. May 22, 2015) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss
section 806 claim where debt collector allegedly initiated
collection lawsuit even though it knew plaintiff did not owe debt);
Pittman v. J.J. Mac Intyre Co. of Nev., Inc., 969 F. Supp. 609, 612-
13 (D. Nev. 1997) (denying debt collector's motion to dismiss claims
under sections 807 and 808 where debt collector allegedly attempted
to collect fully satisfied debt).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When the FDCPA became law in 1977, debt sales and related transfers
were not common. In subsequent years, debt sales and transfers have
become more frequent.\396\ The general growth in debt sales and
transfers may have increased the likelihood that a debt that has been
paid, settled, or discharged in bankruptcy may be transferred or
sold.\397\ Moreover, identity theft, which has emerged as a major
consumer protection concern, may increase the number of debts that are
created if consumers' identities are stolen and their personal
information misused.\398\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\396\ In 2009, the FTC stated that the ``most significant change
in the debt collection business in recent years has been the advent
and growth of debt buying.'' FTC Modernization Report, supra note
176, at 4.
\397\ See, e.g., Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Supervisory
Highlights, Issue No. 12, at 6-7 (Summer 2016), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/supervisory-highlights-issue-no-12-summer-2016/ (discussing examinations finding
that debt sellers failed to code accounts to reflect that they were
in bankruptcy, the product of fraud, or settled in full).
\398\ See generally Kristin Finklea, Identity Theft: Trends and
Issues, Cong. Research Serv., RL40599 (2014), https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R40599.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Federal regulators have raised similar concerns about the
risk of consumer harm from the sale, transfer, and placement of these
categories of debt. The FTC has considerable expertise with respect to
the debt buying industry \399\ and has identified a risk of consumer
harm if a debt collector purchases and seeks to collect discharged
debt.\400\ The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) has
advised its supervised institutions that certain categories of debt--
including settled debts, debts belonging to borrowers seeking
bankruptcy protection, and debts incurred as a result of fraudulent
activity--are not appropriate for sale because of the reputational risk
and the threat of legal liability related to the unlawful tactics
employed to collect these debts.\401\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\399\ See generally, e.g., FTC Debt Buying Report, supra note
14.
\400\ FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at 64-65.
\401\ See Off. of the Comptroller of the Currency, Bulletin
2014-37, Description: Risk Management Guidance (Aug. 4, 2014),
http://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/bulletins/2014/bulletin-2014-37.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Segments of the debt collection industry also appear to recognize
the risks of transferring these categories of debt. Some debt
collectors have adopted policies to identify and exclude certain debts
from sale or transfer. For example, a trade association representing
debt buyers administers a certification program that prohibits the sale
of debts that have been settled in full, paid in full, or are the
result of identity theft or fraud.\402\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\402\ See Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n Int'l, Receivables Management
Certification Program, Certification Governance Document, at 43
(2018), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Certification-Policy-version-6.0-FINAL-20180119.pdf. A large debt
buyer also indicated in preproposal feedback that it has adopted
policies to exclude certain debts from debt sales transactions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) generally would
prohibit a debt collector from selling, transferring, or placing for
collection a debt if the debt collector knows or should know that the
debt has been paid or settled, discharged in bankruptcy, or that an
identity theft report has been filed with respect to the debt.\403\ The
Bureau understands that debt collectors may be required to sell or
transfer such debts for non-debt collection purposes and proposes
certain exceptions in Sec. 1006.30(b)(2) to accommodate those
situations. Proposed comment 30(b)(1)(i)(C)-1 provides an example
clarifying that a debt collector knows or should know that an identity
theft report was filed with respect to a debt if, for example, the debt
collector has received a copy of the identity theft report.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\403\ Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b) would define ``identity theft
report'' as defined in the FCRA, 15 U.S.C. 1681a(q)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) pursuant to its
authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to
the collection of debts by debt collectors, and pursuant to its
authority to interpret FDCPA section 808 regarding unfair or
unconscionable debt collection practices. The Bureau proposes to
prohibit the sale, transfer, or placement of such debts as unfair under
FDCPA section 808 on the basis that, because consumers do not owe or
cannot be subject to collections on alleged debts that have been paid
or settled or discharged in bankruptcy, and likely do not owe alleged
debts that are subject to identity theft reports, the sale, transfer,
or placement of such debts is unfair or unconscionable. Further, the
sale, transfer or placement of such debts is unfair under section 1031
of the Dodd-Frank Act because it is likely to cause substantial injury
to consumers that is not reasonably avoidable by consumers where the
substantial injury is not outweighed by countervailing benefits to
consumers or to competition. Prohibiting the sale, transfer, or
placement of such debts is reasonably designed to prevent this unfair
practice.
With respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer
financial product or service debt, as defined in proposed Sec.
1006.2(f), the Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) pursuant to
its authority under section 1031(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe
rules to identify and prevent the commission of unfair acts or
practices by Dodd-Frank Act covered persons, and the Bureau
[[Page 23332]]
proposes Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(ii) to identify this unfair act or
practice.\404\ As discussed in part IV.B, to declare an act or practice
unfair under Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b), the Bureau must have a
reasonable basis to conclude that: (1) The act or practice causes or is
likely to cause substantial injury to consumers which is not reasonably
avoidable by consumers; and (2) such substantial injury is not
outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers or to competition.
Selling, transferring, or placing for collection debts described in
proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) likely causes substantial injury to
consumers because the collection of such debts likely results in
deceptive claims of indebtedness and the unfair collection of amounts
not owed.\405\ Consumers cannot reasonably avoid this harm because they
have no control over debt sales, transfers, or placements or collection
activity arising subsequent to those sales, transfers or placements.
The collection of debts that are either not owed or likely not owed
does not benefit consumers or competition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\404\ See part IV.B for a discussion of the Bureau's framework
for interpreting Dodd-Frank Act section 1031(b).
\405\ Cf. Fed. Trade Comm'n v. Neovi, Inc., 604 F.3d 1150, 1157
(9th Cir. 2010) (holding that the defendant engaged in an unfair
practice by creating a website that fraudsters predictably used to
injure consumers).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on all aspects of proposed Sec.
1006.30(b)(1). In particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether
additional categories of debt, such as debt currently subject to
litigation and debt lacking clear evidence of ownership, should be
included in any prohibition adopted in a final rule. The Bureau also
requests comment on how frequently consumers identify a specific debt
when filing an identity theft report, and on how frequently debt
collectors learn that an identity theft report was filed in error and
proceed to sell or transfer the debt. The Bureau also requests comment
on any potential disruptions that proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) would
cause for secured debts, such as by preventing servicing transfers or
foreclosure activity related to mortgage loans. Finally, the Bureau
requests comment on whether any of the currently proposed categories of
debts should be clarified and, if so, how; and on whether additional
clarification is needed regarding the proposed ``know or should know''
standard.
30(b)(2) Exceptions
Allowing the sale, transfer, or placement of the debts described in
proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) for certain bona fide business purposes
other than debt collection may not create a significant risk of
deceptive or unfair collections activity. Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)
sets forth four narrow exceptions to proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1) to
accommodate such circumstances.
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(i) would allow a debt collector to
transfer a debt described in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) to the
debt's owner. This exception would permit a third-party debt collector
who identifies such a debt among its collection accounts to return that
debt to the debt's owner. Allowing a debt collector to return a debt to
the debt's owner likely would not raise the risk of deceptive or unfair
collections activity. Debts frequently are returned to a debt's owner
after unsuccessful collections efforts.\406\ Moreover, unlike a debt
collector, whose overriding economic incentive is to secure a debt's
repayment, certain debt owners may have other priorities that make it
less likely that the owner will place the debt with another debt
collector or try to collect the debt itself.\407\ For creditors in
particular, these moderating factors include general reputational
concerns and a desire to preserve the specific customer relationship.
Proposed comment 30(b)(2)(i)-1 would clarify that a debt collector may
not engage in an otherwise prohibited transfer with any other entity on
behalf of a debt's owner unless another exception applies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\406\ CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at
13.
\407\ When passing the FDCPA, Congress determined that creditors
``generally are restrained by their desire to protect their good
will when collecting past due accounts,'' unlike debt collectors. S.
Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes three additional exceptions that parallel the
exceptions in the FCRA to the prohibition on the sale, transfer, or
placement of debt caused by identity theft.\408\ Section 615(f) of the
FCRA prohibits a person from selling, transferring for consideration,
or placing for collection a debt after being notified that a consumer
reporting agency identified that debt as having resulted from identity
theft.\409\ Because proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1) also would prohibit
the sale, transfer, or placement of debts subject to an identity theft
report, the Bureau proposes to adopt the exceptions under FCRA section
615(f)(3) regarding the repurchase, securitization, or transfer of a
debt as the result of a merger or acquisition, since these exceptions
would appear to be equally relevant and provide some consistency
between proposed Regulation F and the FCRA's existing identity theft
requirements. Further, the FCRA's exceptions may provide debt
collectors with sufficient flexibility to transfer debts for bona fide
non-debt collection business purposes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\408\ See 15 U.S.C. 1681m(f)(3).
\409\ See 15 U.S.C. 1681m(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(ii) would allow a debt collector to
transfer a debt described in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) to a
previous owner if transfer is authorized by contract. Creditors may
include provisions in debt sales contracts that authorize repurchase or
transfer when certain issues, such as consumer disputes or identity
theft, surface.\410\ Such agreements may benefit debt collectors by
removing non-performing debts from collection portfolios, which allows
debt collectors to focus their efforts on accounts with higher recovery
rates. These agreements also may benefit consumers because interactions
with creditors may be less adversarial and offer speedier and fuller
resolution than interactions with debt collectors.\411\ The Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(ii) to avoid impeding these agreements in
debt sales contracts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\410\ Creditors may include such repurchase provisions in debt
sales agreements based on compliance and reputational concerns. For
national banks and Federal savings associations in particular,
regulatory guidance may incentivize this practice. See, e.g., Off.
of the Comptroller of the Currency, Bulletin 2014-37, Description:
Risk Management Guidance (Aug. 4, 2014), http://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/bulletins/2014/bulletin-2014-37.html.
\411\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 46-47 (``Consumers reported more favorable experiences with
creditors than debt collectors along many of the dimensions
surveyed. About three-quarters (77 percent) of consumers who
reported being contacted by a creditor, for example, said that the
creditor provided accurate information compared with 49 percent of
consumers contacted by a debt collector. Consumers contacted by
creditors similarly were more likely to say that the creditor
provided options to pay the debt, addressed their questions, and was
polite. Finally, those contacted by creditors were less likely than
those contacted by debt collectors to agree with less-favorable
characterization of interactions such as reporting that the creditor
threatened them.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(iii) would permit a debt collector to
securitize a debt described in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i), or to
pledge a portfolio of such debt as collateral in connection with a
borrowing. The Bureau understands that, if a debt collector securitizes
or pledges a portfolio of debt, the debt collector may be unable to
exclude the debts described in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) from the
portfolio. The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(iii) to allow a debt
collector to securitize or pledge portfolios in connection with its own
commercial borrowing without violating Regulation F.
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(iv) would allow a debt collector to
transfer a debt
[[Page 23333]]
described in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) as a result of a merger,
acquisition, purchase and assumption transaction, or transfer of
substantially all of the debt collector's assets. Transfers in these
circumstances are not likely to raise the risk of unlawful collections
activities because the transfers are for a bona fide non-debt
collection business purpose. Further, excluding the categories of debt
in proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) from a business acquisition may be
impracticable.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2),
including on whether additional exceptions are necessary to allow for
transfers of debts for non-debt collection business purposes, and on
whether the proposed exceptions should be more narrowly tailored or
clarified. The Bureau also requests comment on the costs and benefits
to consumers of allowing debts to be transferred under the proposed
exceptions.
30(c) Multiple Debts
FDCPA section 810 provides that, if any consumer owes multiple
debts and makes any single payment to any debt collector with respect
to such debts, that debt collector must not apply the consumer's
payment to any debt which is disputed by the consumer and must apply
the payment in accordance with the consumer's directions, if any.\412\
Pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.30(c) to implement FDCPA section 810. Proposed
Sec. 1006.30(c) mirrors the statute, except that minor changes have
been made for organization and clarity. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.30(c), including on whether additional
clarification is needed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\412\ 15 U.S.C. 1692h.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
30(d) Legal Actions by Debt Collectors
FDCPA section 811 restricts the venue in which a debt collector may
initiate legal action on a debt against a consumer.\413\ Pursuant to
its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with
respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.30(d) to implement FDCPA section 811. Proposed
Sec. 1006.30(d) mirrors the statute, except that minor changes have
been made for organization and clarity. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.30(d), including on whether additional
clarification is needed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\413\ 15 U.S.C. 1692i.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
30(e) Furnishing Certain Deceptive Forms
FDCPA section 812(a) prohibits any person from knowingly designing,
compiling, and furnishing any form that would be used to create the
false belief in a consumer that a person other than the consumer's
creditor is participating in the collection of, or in an attempt to
collect, a debt the consumer allegedly owes, if in fact the creditor is
not participating.\414\ Pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by
debt collectors, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.30(e) to implement
FDCPA section 812(a). Because the Bureau's rulemaking authority under
FDCPA section 814(d) is limited to debt collectors, as that term is
defined in the FDCPA, proposed Sec. 1006.30(e)'s coverage is more
limited than that of FDCPA section 812(a), which applies to any person.
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(e) would not narrow coverage under the statute.
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(e) otherwise generally mirrors the statute,
except that minor changes have been made for organization and clarity.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.30(e), including on
whether additional clarification is needed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\414\ 15 U.S.C. 1692j.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.34 Notice for Validation of Debts
FDCPA section 809(a) generally requires a debt collector to provide
certain information to a consumer either at the time that, or shortly
after, the debt collector first communicates with the consumer in
connection with the collection of a debt. The required information--
i.e., the validation information--includes details about the debt and
about consumer protections, such as the consumer's rights to dispute
the debt and to request information about the original creditor.\415\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\415\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The requirement to provide validation information is an important
component of the FDCPA and was intended to improve the debt collection
process by helping consumers to recognize debts that they owe and raise
concerns about debts that are unfamiliar. Congress in 1977 considered
the requirement a ``significant feature'' of the statute, explaining
that it was designed to ``eliminate the recurring problem of debt
collectors dunning the wrong person or attempting to collect debts
which the consumer has already paid.'' \416\ Despite the FDCPA's
requirement that debt collectors provide validation information,
Congress provided the Bureau with rulemaking authority in 2010
apparently to address inadequacies around validation and verification,
among other things.\417\ In addition, debt collectors have sought
clarification about how to provide additional information consistent
with the statute. For these reasons, and as discussed in more detail
below, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34 to require debt collectors to
provide certain validation information to consumers and to specify when
and how the information must be provided.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\416\ S. Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 4; see also Jacobson
v. Healthcare Fin. Servs., Inc., 516 F.3d 85, 95 (2d Cir. 2008)
(validation notices ``make the rights and obligations of a
potentially hapless debtor as pellucid as possible''); Wilson v.
Quadramed Corp., 225 F.3d 350, 354 (3d Cir. 2000); Miller v. Payco-
Gen. Am. Credits, Inc., 943 F.2d 482, 484 (4th Cir. 1991); Swanson
v. S. Oregon Credit Serv., Inc., 869 F.2d 1222, 1225 (9th Cir.
1988).
\417\ See S. Rept. No. 111-176, at 19 (``In addition to concerns
about debt collection tactics, the Committee is concerned that
consumers have little ability to dispute the validity of a debt that
is being collected in error.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(a)(1) Validation Information Required
FDCPA section 809(a) provides, in relevant part, that, within five
days after the initial communication with a consumer in connection with
the collection of any debt, a debt collector shall send the consumer a
written notice containing certain information, unless that information
is contained in the initial communication or the consumer has paid the
debt.\418\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) would implement and interpret
this general requirement.\419\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\418\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a). FDCPA section 809(a) provides that
a debt collector need not send the written notice if the consumer
pays the debt before the time that the notice is required to be
sent. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(2) would implement that exception.
\419\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) describes the validation
information that proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) would require debt
collectors to provide.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i) addresses situations in which the
debt collector provides the validation information in writing or
electronically.\420\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i) would clarify
that, in those situations, a debt collector may provide the validation
information by sending the consumer a validation notice either in the
initial communication or within five days of that communication.\421\
In either case,
[[Page 23334]]
the debt collector would be required to provide the validation notice
in a manner that satisfies the delivery requirements in Sec.
1006.42(a).\422\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\420\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(4) would define a validation
notice as any written or electronic notice that provides the
validation information described in Sec. 1006.34(c).
\421\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(2) provides that, with limited
exceptions, initial communication means the first time that, in
connection with the collection of a debt, a debt collector conveys
information, directly or indirectly, to the consumer regarding the
debt.
\422\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42, the proposed rule would provide a general
standard for the delivery of required disclosures, including the
validation notice, in writing or electronically, and would clarify,
among other things, how debt collectors may provide required notices
to consumers by email or text message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(ii) would clarify that a debt
collector could provide the validation information orally in the
initial communication.\423\ The Bureau requests comment on whether
clarification regarding content and formatting requirements is needed
for a debt collector who provides the validation information orally.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\423\ While FDCPA section 809(a) does not prohibit a debt
collector from providing validation information orally in the debt
collector's initial communication, it may be impractical for debt
collectors to do so given that proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) would
require a significant amount of validation information that debt
collectors may not currently provide. In addition, debt collectors
providing the validation information orally would not be able to use
Model Form B-3 in appendix B to receive a safe harbor for compliance
with Sec. 1006.34(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 34(a)(1)-1 would clarify the provision of
validation notices if the consumer is deceased. As described in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(e), the failure to
provide a validation notice to a person who is authorized to act on
behalf of the deceased consumer's estate, such as the executor,
administrator, or personal representative, may cause difficulty or
delay in resolving the estate's debts. Proposed comment 34(a)(1)-1
explains that, if the debt collector knows or should know that the
consumer is deceased, and if the debt collector has not previously
provided the deceased consumer the validation information, a person who
is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate
operates as the consumer for purposes of providing a validation notice
under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).\424\ As explained in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(e), the Bureau proposes to interpret
the term consumer to include deceased consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\424\ This interpretation is supported by the proposed
definition of consumer, which, as discussed in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(e), is defined to include
``[a]ny natural person, whether living or deceased, who is obligated
or allegedly obligated to pay any debt.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's interpretation of FDCPA section 809 in proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1) would require a debt collector to provide the validation
information when collecting debt from a deceased consumer if the debt
collector has not previously provided the consumer the validation
information. In such circumstances, under proposed comment 34(a)(1)-1,
the debt collector must provide the validation information to an
individual that the debt collector identifies by name who is authorized
to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. If a debt collector
knows or should know that the consumer is deceased, it may be unclear
whether the debt collector should continue to address the validation
notice to the deceased consumer, or whether the debt collector instead
should address the notice to the individual who is authorized to act on
behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. In light of this uncertainty,
the Bureau proposes to interpret sending the validation information to
a deceased consumer (i.e., the deceased consumer's estate) to mean
providing the validation information to an individual that the debt
collector identifies by name who is authorized to act on behalf of the
deceased consumer's estate. As explained below, this interpretation may
be preferable to addressing the validation information using the name
of the deceased consumer or using ``the estate of'' with the name of
the deceased consumer.
Accordingly, just as a debt collector attempting to collect a debt
from a living consumer generally would provide a validation notice to
the consumer within five days after the initial communication with such
consumer (where the validation information was not contained in the
initial communication), the proposal generally would require a debt
collector attempting to collect a debt from a deceased consumer's
estate to provide the validation notice to the named person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate. The
validation notice would have to be provided within five days after the
initial communication with such person.
In its Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, the FTC expressed concern
about debt collectors addressing substantive written communications to
the decedent's estate, or to an unnamed executor or administrator.\425\
In the FTC's experience, individuals who lack the authority to resolve
the estate but who wish to be helpful are likely to open these
communications, which makes such communications insufficiently targeted
to a consumer with whom the debt collector may generally discuss the
debt. Therefore, according to the FTC, ``communication[s] addressed to
the decedent's estate, or an unnamed executor or administrator, [are]
location communication[s] and must not refer to the decedent's debts.''
\426\ The FTC also noted that letters addressed to deceased consumers
raised similar concerns, although there may be circumstances where a
debt collector neither knows nor has reason to know that the consumer
has died. The Bureau agrees with these concerns. The requirement in
proposed comment 34(a)(1)-1 to send any required validation notice to a
named person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased
consumer's estate would limit the practice of addressing validation
notices to deceased consumers or unnamed executors, administrators, or
personal representatives because a debt collector would be required to
identify a person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased
consumer's estate in order to properly direct any communication to that
individual. The Bureau requests comment on the effects of any potential
inconsistency between proposed comment 34(a)(1)-1 and the consumer
protections that the FTC sought to achieve when it published its Policy
Statement on Decedent Debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\425\ FTC Policy Statement on Decedent Debt, supra note 192.
\426\ Id. at 44920.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) to implement and interpret
FDCPA section 809(a) and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by
debt collectors. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1) and its related commentary.
34(a)(2) Exception
FDCPA section 809(a) contains a limited exception that provides
that, if required information is not contained in the initial
communication, a debt collector need not send the consumer a written
notice within five days of the debt collector's initial communication
with the consumer in connection with the collection of the debt if the
consumer has paid the debt prior to the time that the notice is
required to be sent.\427\ Pursuant to its authority to implement and
interpret FDCPA section 809(a) and its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by
debt collectors, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(a)(2) to implement
this exception. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(2) provides that a debt
collector who
[[Page 23335]]
otherwise would be required to send a validation notice pursuant to
proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B) is not required to do so if the
consumer has paid the debt prior to the time that proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B) would require the validation notice to be sent.
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(2) generally restates the statute, except for
minor changes for organization and clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\427\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(b) Definitions
To facilitate compliance with Sec. 1006.34, proposed Sec.
1006.34(b) would define several terms that appear throughout the
section. Except as discussed otherwise below, the Bureau proposes these
definitions to implement and interpret FDCPA section 809(a) and
pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors.
34(b)(1) Clear and Conspicuous
To facilitate compliance with proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(1), which
would require that the validation information described in Sec.
1006.34(c) be clear and conspicuous, proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(1) would
define the term clear and conspicuous. The Bureau proposes to define
the term clear and conspicuous for purposes of Regulation F consistent
with the standards used in other consumer financial services laws and
their implementing regulations, including Regulation E, subpart B
(Remittance Transfers).\428\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(1) thus provides
that disclosures are clear and conspicuous if they are readily
understandable and, in the case of written and electronic disclosures,
the location and type size are readily noticeable to consumers. Oral
disclosures are clear and conspicuous if they are given at a volume and
speed sufficient for a consumer to hear and comprehend them. The Bureau
proposes to adopt this standard to help ensure that required
disclosures, including disclosures containing validation information,
are readily understandable and noticeable to consumers. Disclosures
that are not clear and conspicuous will not be effective, defeating the
purpose of the disclosures.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\428\ See 12 CFR 1005.31(a)(1), comment 31(a)(1)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(1),
including on whether basing the clear and conspicuous standard on
existing regulations, such as Regulation E, presents any consumer
protection or compliance issues, including for validation information
delivered electronically or orally. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether additional clarification about the meaning of clear and
conspicuous would be useful in the context of the specific information
that proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) would require.
34(b)(2) Initial Communication
As discussed above, FDCPA section 809(a) requires debt collectors
to provide consumers with certain validation information either in the
debt collector's initial communication with the consumer in connection
with the collection of the debt, or within five days after that initial
communication. FDCPA section 803(2) defines the term communication
broadly to mean the conveying of information regarding a debt directly
or indirectly to any person through any medium.\429\ FDCPA section
809(d) and (e) identifies particular communications that are not
initial communications with the consumer in connection with the debt
for purposes of FDCPA section 809(a) and that therefore do not trigger
the validation notice requirement.\430\ Pursuant to FDCPA section
809(d), an initial communication excludes a communication in the form
of a formal pleading in a civil action. Pursuant to FDCPA section
809(e), an initial communication also excludes the sending or delivery
of any form or notice that does not relate to the collection of the
debt and is expressly required by the Internal Revenue Code of 1986,
title V of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, or any provision of Federal or
State law relating to notice of a data security breach or privacy, or
any regulation prescribed under any such provision of law.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\429\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692a(2). See also the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(d).
\430\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(d), (e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(2) would implement FDCPA section 809(a),
(d), and (e) by defining the term initial communication to mean the
first time that, in connection with the collection of a debt, a debt
collector conveys information, directly or indirectly, regarding the
debt to the consumer, other than a communication in the form of a
formal pleading in a civil action, or a communication in any form or
notice that does not relate to the collection of the debt and is
expressly required by any of the laws referenced in FDCPA section
809(e).
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(2) and on
whether additional clarification about the term initial communication
would be helpful. The Bureau specifically requests comment on the
scenario in which a debt collector's first attempt to communicate with
a consumer is through an electronic communication method, such as an
email or a text message, and the consumer provides no response. For
example, as proposed, if a debt collector sends a consumer an email
notifying the consumer that a debt has been placed with the debt
collector but includes no other information, the debt collector would
be required to send the consumer a validation notice within five days,
even if the consumer did not reply to the debt collector's email. The
Bureau requests comment about the risks, costs, and benefits to
industry and consumers of treating these types of debt collection
communications as initial communications that would trigger Sec.
1006.34(a)(1).
34(b)(3) Itemization Date
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers, either in the debt collector's initial communication in
connection with the collection of the debt, or within five days after
that communication, the amount of the debt.\431\ In proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix), the Bureau would interpret the phrase
``amount of the debt'' to mean that debt collectors must disclose
information about the amount of the debt as of a particular
``itemization date.'' \432\ To facilitate compliance with Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix), proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3) would
define the term itemization date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\431\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a)(1).
\432\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) and (viii) would require
debt collectors to disclose, respectively, the itemization date and
the amount of the debt on the itemization date. Proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(ix) would require debt collectors to disclose an
itemization of the debt reflecting interest, fees, payments, and
credits since the itemization date. For additional discussion of
these provisions, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Account information available to debt collectors may vary by debt
type because some account information is not universally tracked or
used across product markets. For example, the Bureau understands that
charge off is fundamental account information for credit card debt, but
appears not to be applicable for some other debt types. To ensure that
debt collectors working in a variety of product markets can comply with
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix), the Bureau proposes to
define the term itemization date to mean any one of four reference
dates for which a debt collector can ascertain the amount of the debt:
(1) The last statement date, (2) the charge-off date, (3) the last
payment date, or (4) the
[[Page 23336]]
transaction date.\433\ As discussed further in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i) through (iv), the proposed
definition is designed to allow the use of dates that debt collectors
could identify with relative ease because they reflect routine and
recurring events and that correspond to notable events in the debt's
history that consumers may recall or be able to verify with records.
The proposed definition also is designed to include dates for which
debt collectors typically may receive account information from debt
owners and that, therefore, debt collectors should be able to use to
provide the disclosures described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(vii) through
(ix).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\433\ The four reference dates are set forth in proposed Sec.
1006.34(b)(3)(i) through (iv). See the section-by-section analysis
of proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i) through (iv).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 34(b)(3)-1 explains that a debt collector may
select any of the potential reference dates listed in proposed Sec.
1006.34(b)(3) as the itemization date to comply with Sec. 1006.34.
Once a debt collector uses one of the reference dates for a specific
debt in a communication with an individual consumer, however, the debt
collector would be required to use that reference date for that debt
consistently when providing disclosures as proposed by Sec. 1006.34 to
that consumer. If a debt collector provides the consumer with
validation information based on different reference dates for the same
debt, the consumer may have difficulty recognizing the debt and be less
likely to engage with the debt collector. Thus, a debt collector who
used reference dates inconsistently for the same debt could undermine
the purpose of proposed Sec. 1006.34.
The Bureau's Small Business Review Panel Outline described a
proposal under consideration that would have required a debt collector
to provide an itemization of the debt based on a single reference date,
the date of default.\434\ Multiple small entity representatives
expressed concern with that proposal, noting both that default has no
established definition and that the default concept may be inapplicable
to some debt types, such as medical debt.\435\ Small entity
representatives also noted that determining a date of default can
involve State law interpretations that impose significant costs.
Consistent with these concerns, the Small Business Review Panel Report
recommended that the Bureau consider alternatives to the date of
default and suggested the charge-off date, last payment date, or date
of service instead.\436\ Based in part on this feedback, the Bureau
believes that it may be difficult to identify a single reference date
that applies to all debt types across all relevant markets and, as a
result, proposes to define itemization date as one of the four
potential reference dates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\434\ See Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at
appendix F.
\435\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
18.
\436\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3) and on
comment 34(b)(3)-1, including on whether the itemization date
definition will facilitate compliance with the requirement to disclose
the validation information in Sec. 1006.34(c)(vii) through (ix), and
on whether additional clarification regarding the itemization date
definition is needed. The Bureau also requests comment on whether the
proposed itemization date definition would not capture certain debt
types, such as mortgage debt where coupon books are provided instead of
periodic statements, and on whether additional or alternative reference
dates should be considered. The Bureau also requests comment on whether
creditors' data management systems capture information related to the
reference dates that the proposed itemization date definition would
incorporate. Further, the Bureau requests comment on whether the
proposed definition should mandate a single reference date, which would
standardize validation notices across all relevant markets, and if so,
what reference date might be suitable for all types of debt. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on how the proposed definition
should function with respect to a debt that multiple debt collectors
have attempted to collect. For example, the Bureau requests comment on
whether a subsequent debt collector should be permitted to use a
different itemization date than a prior debt collector used for the
same debt.
Finally, the Bureau requests comment on whether the proposed
itemization date definition should be structured as a prescriptive
ordering of potential reference dates, such as a hierarchy. For
example, this alternative approach could require a debt collector to
determine the itemization date by identifying the first date in a
hierarchy of four reference dates set forth in proposed Sec.
1006.34(b)(3)(i) through (iv) for which a debt collector could
ascertain the amount of the debt using readily available information.
With respect to this alternative approach, the Bureau requests comment
on whether the use of any particular reference date, such as the last
statement date, is more likely than other reference dates, such as the
charge-off date, to improve consumer understanding of the required
disclosures. The Bureau also requests comment on whether, for purposes
of a hierarchy, any particular reference date would be more likely than
others to impose costs or burdens on debt collectors.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(b)(3), including the specific
dates described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i) through (iv),
pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors. The Bureau
also proposes Sec. 1006.34(b)(3) pursuant to its authority under
section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to ensure that
the features of consumer financial products and services are disclosed
to consumers fully, accurately, and effectively.
34(b)(3)(i)
When placing a debt for collection, creditors frequently may
provide debt collectors with the last periodic or written account
statements provided to consumers. Therefore, in many cases, last
statement information should be readily available to debt collectors.
In addition, many consumers may recall the amount of the debt on the
last statement because this figure may be the most recent amount of the
debt the consumer has seen, or the consumer may be able to verify that
amount with their records.
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i) would permit
debt collectors to use the last statement date as the itemization date.
Pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i), last statement date would
mean the date of the last periodic statement or written account
statement or invoice provided to the consumer. Proposed comment
34(b)(3)(i)-1 explains that a statement provided by a creditor or a
third party acting on the creditor's behalf, including a creditor's
service provider, may constitute the last statement provided to the
consumer for purposes of Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i). The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i) and on comment 34(b)(3)(i)-
1, including on how often creditors provide periodic statements,
written statements, and invoices to debt collectors, and on whether
there are specific debt types for which creditors may not provide such
statements. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on whether a
validation notice that a previous debt collector provided to the
consumer should constitute a last statement for purposes of proposed
Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i).
[[Page 23337]]
34(b)(3)(ii)
When placing credit card accounts for collection, creditors
frequently may provide debt collectors with account information at
charge off, including the charge-off date. For this reason, some small
entity representatives suggested during the SBREFA process that, for
credit card debt, the Bureau should define the itemization date to mean
the charge-off date.\437\ Charge off is relevant to debt types other
than credit cards, as well, and consumers may approximately recognize
the amount of a debt due at charge off because charge off often occurs
shortly after a last account statement is provided.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\437\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(ii) would permit
debt collectors to use the charge-off date--i.e., the date that the
debt was charged off--as the itemization date. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(ii). The Bureau generally
requests comment on how often creditors provide charge-off information
to debt collectors and on whether there are specific debt types for
which charge off is not a relevant concept. In addition, the Bureau
requests comment on whether creditors assess fees or penalties at
charge off, which would cause the amount the consumer owed at charge
off to differ significantly from the amount that appeared on the last
periodic statement, invoice, or other written statement that the
consumer received.
34(b)(3)(iii)
In some cases, creditors may provide debt collectors with account
information related to a consumer's last payment. For this reason, some
small entity representatives suggested during the SBREFA process that
the Bureau define the itemization date to mean the last payment
date.\438\ Consumers also may recognize the amount of a debt that
reflects the balance after the consumer's last payment.\439\ Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iii) thus would permit debt collectors to use the
last payment date--i.e., the date the last payment was applied to the
debt--as the itemization date. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iii), including on how often creditors provide debt
collectors with last payment date information. The Bureau also requests
comment on how proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iii) should be applied if a
third party made the last payment on the debt. For example, such a
third-party payment might include a partial payment on a consumer's
medical debt by an insurance provider.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\438\ Id.
\439\ See FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 20-21.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(b)(3)(iv)
For some debt types, including for medical debt, creditors may
provide debt collectors with account information related to the
transaction date (e.g., the date a service or good was provided to a
consumer). Some small entity representatives thus suggested during the
SBREFA process that the Bureau define the itemization date for medical
debt to mean the date of service.\440\ In addition, consumers may
recognize the amount of a debt on the transaction date, which may be
reflected in a copy of a contract or a bill provided by a creditor. For
these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iv) would permit debt
collectors to use the transaction date--i.e., the date of the
transaction that gave rise to the debt--as the itemization date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\440\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 18.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 34(b)(3)(iv)-1 explains that the transaction date
is the date that a creditor provided, or made available, a good or
service to a consumer and includes examples of transaction dates. The
comment also explains that, if a debt has more than one potential
transaction date, a debt collector may use any such date as the
transaction date but must use whichever transaction date it selects
consistently, as described in comment 34(b)(3)-1. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iv) and on comment
34(b)(3)(iv)-1, including on how often creditors provide transaction
date information to debt collectors and on whether the transaction date
concept is inapplicable to certain debt types.
34(b)(4) Validation Notice
As already discussed, FDCPA section 809(a) provides, in relevant
part, that, within five days after the initial communication with a
consumer in connection with the collection of any debt, a debt
collector shall send the consumer a written notice containing certain
information, unless that information is contained in the initial
communication or the consumer has paid the debt.\441\ If debt
collectors have provided the validation information in writing, whether
in the initial communication or within five days after that
communication, debt collectors and others commonly have referred to the
document containing the information as a ``validation notice,'' or ``g
notice.'' The Bureau understands that most debt collectors do not
currently send validation notices electronically. As discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42, the Bureau
proposes to clarify how debt collectors may send validation notices
electronically in compliance with applicable law.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\441\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To facilitate compliance with proposed Sec. 1006.34, as well as to
account for the possibility that more debt collectors may begin
providing the validation information electronically, proposed Sec.
1006.34(b)(4) would define validation notice to mean a written or
electronic notice that provides the validation information described in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c). The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.34(b)(4).
34(b)(5) Validation Period
FDCPA section 809(b) contains certain requirements that a debt
collector must satisfy if a consumer disputes a debt or requests the
name and address of the original creditor. If a consumer disputes a
debt in writing within 30 days of receiving the validation information,
a debt collector must stop collection of the debt until the debt
collector obtains verification of the debt or a copy of a judgment
against the consumer and mails it to the consumer.\442\ Similarly, if a
consumer requests the name and address of the original creditor in
writing within 30 days of receiving the validation information, FDCPA
section 809(b) requires the debt collector to cease collection of the
debt until it obtains and mails such information to the consumer.\443\
FDCPA section 809(b) also prohibits a debt collector, during the 30-day
period consumers have to dispute a debt or request information about
the original creditor, from engaging in collection activities and
communications that overshadow, or are inconsistent with, the
disclosure of the consumer's rights to dispute the debt and request
original-creditor information, which are sometimes referred to as
``verification rights.'' \444\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\442\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(b).
\443\ See id. The Bureau refers to the consumer's rights to
dispute the validity of the debt and to request original-creditor
information collectively as the consumer's ``verification rights.''
\444\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As described in the section-by-section analysis of Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(i) through (iii), the proposed rule would require debt
collectors to disclose to a consumer the date certain on which the
consumer's FDCPA section 809(b) verification rights expire. Without
additional clarification, debt collectors may be uncertain how to
calculate this
[[Page 23338]]
date certain. First, debt collectors may be unsure how to reliably
determine when a consumer has received the validation information
(i.e., the event that triggers the running of the 30-day period). In
addition, some debt collectors may honor disputes and original-creditor
information requests that a consumer provides after the 30-day period
to dispute a debt or request information about the original creditor
set forth in the FDCPA expires and may benefit from clarification about
how to specify a longer period.
To facilitate compliance with the proposed requirement to provide
the date certain on which the consumer's verification rights expire,
proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(5) would define the term validation period to
mean the period starting on the date that a debt collector provides the
validation information described in Sec. 1006.34(c) and ending 30 days
after the consumer receives or is assumed to receive the validation
information. To clarify how to calculate the end of the validation
period--including how debt collectors may disclose a period that
provides consumers additional time to exercise their validation
rights--proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(5) also would provide that a debt
collector may assume that a consumer receives validation information on
any day that is at least five days (excluding legal public holidays,
Saturdays, and Sundays) after the debt collector provides it. Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(b)(5) is designed to provide a debt collector with a
straightforward yet flexible way to determine the last date of the
validation period referenced in Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i) through (iii).
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(b)(5) on the basis that consumers
will typically receive a validation notice no more than five days
(excluding legal public holidays, Saturdays, and Sundays) after the
debt collector provides it. Further, proposed Sec. 1006.34 would not
prohibit a debt collector from honoring a consumer's request to
exercise verification rights after the date certain that appears in the
validation notice pursuant to Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i) through (iii).
Proposed comment 34(b)(5)-1 would clarify that, if a debt collector
sends a subsequent validation notice to a consumer because the consumer
did not receive the original validation notice, and the consumer has
not otherwise received the validation information, the debt collector
must calculate the end of the validation period based on the date the
consumer receives or is assumed to receive the subsequent validation
notice. In other words, proposed comment 34(b)(5)-1 would clarify that,
if a debt collector sends an initial validation notice that was not
received and then sends a subsequent validation notice, the validation
period ends 30 days after the consumer receives or is assumed to
receive the subsequent validation notice.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(5) and on
comment 34(b)(5)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on debt
collectors' current practices for determining the end of the validation
period. The Bureau also requests comment on whether the length of the
five-day timing presumption should be modified and on whether different
timing presumptions should apply depending on whether a validation
notice is delivered by mail or electronically, for example by email or
text message. Finally, the Bureau requests comment on whether a
different timing presumption should apply if validation information is
provided orally.
34(c) Validation Information
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) sets forth the validation information
that debt collectors would be required to disclose under Sec.
1006.34(a)(1). As described below, the validation information that
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) would require consists of four general
categories: Information to help consumers identify debts (including the
information specifically referenced in FDCPA section 809(a));
information about consumers' protections in debt collection;
information to facilitate consumers' ability to exercise their rights
with respect to debt collection; and certain other statutorily required
information.
34(c)(1) Debt Collector Communication Disclosure
FDCPA section 807(11) requires a debt collector to disclose in its
initial written communication with a consumer--and if the initial
communication is oral, in that oral communication as well--that the
debt collector is attempting to collect a debt and that any information
obtained will be used for that purpose. FDCPA section 807(11) also
requires a debt collector to disclose in each subsequent communication
that the communication is from a debt collector.\445\ As discussed
above, the Bureau proposes the Sec. 1006.18(e) disclosure to implement
FDCPA section 807(11). If a debt collector provides validation
information, the debt collector engages in a debt collection
communication and must make an appropriate FDCPA section 807(11)
disclosure.\446\ The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(1) to provide
that the Sec. 1006.18(e) disclosure is validation information that
must be provided to the consumer pursuant to Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). The
Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\445\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.18(e).
\446\ See, e.g., Dorsey v. Morgan, 760 F. Supp. 509 (D. Md.
1991).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(2) Information About the Debt
While validation notices in use today typically contain the
specific information required under FDCPA section 809(a), the Bureau
understands that debt collectors often do not include any other
information to help consumers identify debts.\447\ As a result,
validation notices in use today may lack sufficient information to
enable some consumers to exercise their FDCPA section 809 rights. For
example, the Bureau's qualitative consumer research indicates that
certain information that appears to help consumers to recognize a
debt--including a debt's original account number or an itemization of
interest and fees--may not consistently appear on validation
notices.\448\ Complaints about insufficient information to verify debts
consistently rank among the most frequent types of consumer debt
collection complaints received by the Bureau.\449\ Further, validation
notices in use today may not be written in plain language that promotes
consumer understanding. Thus, in some cases, consumers may not
understand information about the debt that appears on the validation
notice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\447\ See Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at
15.
\448\ See FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 8-11.
\449\ In its 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, the Bureau noted that 72
percent of consumers who complain about written notifications about
debt stated that they did not receive enough information to verify
the debt. 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 11, at 17. Consumers
have consistently complained to the Bureau about receiving
insufficient information to verify debts. See 2018 FDCPA Annual
Report, supra note 16, at 15-16; 2017 FDCPA Annual Report, supra
note 21, at 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's understanding is consistent with FTC findings, as well
as with consumer advocate and industry feedback. According to the FTC,
debt collectors do not provide sufficient information to allow
consumers to determine whether they owe a debt in question or to
exercise their FDCPA rights.\450\ Observing that validation notices
lack sufficient detail for consumers to recognize whether a debt
belongs to them, the FTC has suggested that more information about the
debt
[[Page 23339]]
should appear in validation notices.\451\ In response to the Bureau's
ANPRM, consumer advocates stated that many validation notices contain
insufficient information for consumers to evaluate whether they owe a
debt. Industry commenters also identified additional information for
validation notices that would help consumers recognize debts, such as
the date of the consumer's last payment and itemization information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\450\ FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at 21.
\451\ Id. at 29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The lack of information about the debt currently provided in
validation notices--combined with limited disclosure of consumers'
rights with respect to debt collection, which is discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)--may
disadvantage both consumers and debt collectors. If a consumer receives
a validation notice for an unfamiliar debt, the consumer may experience
uncertainty, which may lead to the consumer disputing a debt that is
owed. If a consumer disputes a debt the consumer owes but does not
recognize, the debt collector must spend time and resources responding
to a dispute that could have been avoided had the consumer initially
received more complete information. Participants in the Bureau's
consumer testing also reported that the inability to recognize a debt
is a major concern because of the risk of potential fraud or identity
theft.\452\ In addition, a consumer may, in some instances, pay an
unfamiliar debt that the consumer did not owe.\453\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\452\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 13.
\453\ Academic research and agency experience offer insight into
why some consumers may pay debts that they do not owe in response to
debt collection efforts. In one study of how consumers would react
to a validation notice concerning a debt that they did not owe, 3
percent of respondents stated that they would pay the debt rather
than dispute it. The study's authors hypothesized that fear of
negative credit reporting may explain this behavior. See Jeff Sovern
et al., Validation and Verification Vignettes: More Results from an
Empirical Study of Consumer Understanding of Debt Collection
Validation Notices, Rutgers L. Rev. (forthcoming) (manuscript at 46-
47), https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3219171. In
a settlement agreement with a debt collector, the FTC alleged that
many consumers paid purported debts that they did not owe because
they believed that the debts were real, or because they wanted to
stop harassing debt collection efforts. See Complaint at ] 22, Fed.
Trade Comm'n v. Lombardo Daniels & Moss, LLC. No. 3:17-CV-503-RJC
(W.D.N.C. Aug. 21, 2017), https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/lombardo_complaint_8-29-17.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In light of these concerns, proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2) would
describe the information about the debt and the parties related to the
debt that debt collectors must provide to the consumer under Sec.
1006.34(a)(1).\454\ The section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(i) through (x) discusses the specific items of
information, which would include existing statutory disclosures,
designed to help consumers recognize debts. Except where noted--for
example, in the case of merchant brand information for credit card debt
under proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iii)--the information described in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) is not conditioned on availability. Thus, if
a debt collector does not have a piece of information for a debt, the
debt collector would be unable able to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1) for that debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\454\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) would establish a special
rule for information about the debt for certain residential mortgage
debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2),
including on whether any of the proposed items should be excluded or
any additional items should be added. The Bureau also requests comments
on whether proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)'s content requirements risk
overwhelming consumers and decreasing their understanding, thereby
making the proposed disclosures less effective.
Except with respect to Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iv), the Bureau proposes
Sec. 1006.34(c)(2) pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section
814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of debts by
debt collectors and, as described more fully below, its authority to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 809. Except with respect to Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vi) and (x), the Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)
pursuant to its authority under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act,
on the basis that the validation information describes the debt, which
is a feature of debt collection. Requiring disclosure of validation
information may help to ensure that the features of debt collection are
fully, accurately, and effectively disclosed to consumers, such that
consumers may better understand whether they owe particular debts and,
consequently, the costs, benefits, and risks associated with paying or
not paying those debts.
34(c)(2)(i)
FDCPA section 809(b) provides that a consumer may notify a debt
collector in writing, within 30 days after receipt of the information
required by FDCPA section 809(a), that the consumer is exercising
certain verification rights, including the right to dispute the debt.
FDCPA section 809(a)(3) through (5), in turn, requires debt collectors
to disclose how consumers may exercise their verification rights. To
notify a debt collector in writing that the consumer is exercising the
consumer's verification rights, the consumer must have the debt
collector's name and address.\455\ For this reason, and pursuant to its
authority to interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(3) through (5) and (b), as
well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau
proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(i) to provide that the debt collector's
name and mailing address is validation information that must be
provided to the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(i) and on whether additional
clarification would be useful.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\455\ Participants in the Bureau's consumer testing reported
that contact information for debt collectors, including the debt
collector's mailing address, is important. FMG Focus Group Report,
supra note 38, at 15-16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(2)(ii)
FDCPA section 809(a) requires debt collectors to disclose
information about the debt itself that helps consumers identify the
debt and facilitate resolution of the debt. Like the information
specifically referenced in FDCPA section 809(a), the consumer's name
and address is essential information about the debt that may help a
consumer determine whether the consumer owes a debt and is the intended
recipient of a validation notice. For this reason, and pursuant to its
authority to interpret FDCPA section 809(a), as well as its authority
under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(ii) to provide that the consumer's name and mailing
address is validation information that must be provided to the consumer
under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).\456\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\456\ As discussed in part VI, debt collectors may already
include the consumer's complete name information available on
validation notices, so proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ii) may not pose
significant operational challenges.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To avoid confusing or misleading consumers, the consumer's name and
mailing address used by the debt collector in a validation notice would
be the most complete information that the debt collector obtained from
the creditor or another source. For example, a consumer advocate has
noted that including the consumer's complete name in the validation
notice would help senior consumers who may be contacted about a debt
owed by a spouse or an adult child. Because a consumer may share the
same last name as a spouse or an adult child, the consumer may need
complete name information--for example, a name suffix such as
``Junior'' or ``Senior''--to determine whether the consumer is the
[[Page 23340]]
validation notice's intended recipient, or whether the consumer
received the validation notice in error. Proposed comment 34(c)(2)(ii)-
1 therefore would clarify that the consumer's name should reflect what
the debt collector reasonably determines is the most complete version
of the name information about which the debt collector has knowledge,
whether obtained from the creditor or another source. Proposed comment
34(c)(2)(ii)-1 further explains that a debt collector would not be able
to omit name information in a manner that would create a false,
misleading, or confusing impression about the consumer's identity.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ii) and
on comment 34(c)(2)(ii)-1, including on whether additional
clarification would be useful. The Bureau specifically requests comment
on how debt collectors currently determine the complete version of a
consumer's name if creditors or third parties, such as a skip tracing
vendors, provide conflicting name information. The Bureau also requests
comment on what a debt collector should be required to do to reasonably
determine the consumer's complete name information.
34(c)(2)(iii)
The purpose of FDCPA section 809 is to ``eliminate the recurring
problem of debt collectors dunning the wrong person or attempting to
collect debts which the consumer has already paid.'' \457\ Consistent
with this purpose, FDCPA section 809(a) requires debt collectors to
disclose to consumers certain information, including the name of the
creditor, to help consumers identify debts and determine whether they
owe them. For credit card debts, the merchant brand appears to be an
integral part of the name of the creditor that helps consumers identify
debts and determine whether they owe them. Merchant brands appear to be
salient information for debts arising from use of co-branded or
private-label credit cards because consumers may associate such debts
more closely with merchant brands than with credit card issuers.\458\
For example, the Bureau's consumer focus group findings indicate
consumers use merchant brands to recognize credit card debts.\459\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\457\ S. Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 4.
\458\ The Bureau believes that merchant brand information is
unique to credit card debt. Other types of debt do not typically
involve an entity like a merchant, whom the consumer may associate
with the debt but who did not provide the credit, product, or
service that gave rise to the debt.
\459\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 13-14; FMG
Usability Report, supra note 41, at 43-44.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For this reason, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section
1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iii) to provide that
the merchant brand, if any, associated with a credit card debt, to the
extent available to the debt collector, is validation information that
must be provided to the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). Proposed
comment 34(c)(2)(iii)-1 provides an example of merchant brand
information that the Bureau believes would be available to a debt
collector and must be included on a validation notice. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iii) and on comment
34(c)(2)(iii)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on whether
merchant brand or similar information should be required for debts
other than credit card debts.
34(c)(2)(iv)
FDCPA section 809(a)(2), which requires debt collectors to disclose
to consumers the name of the creditor to whom the debt is owed,
typically is understood to refer to the current creditor.\460\ When the
original creditor (or the creditor as of the itemization date) and the
current creditor are the same, a consumer is more likely to recognize
the creditor's name. If they are different, however, a consumer may be
less likely to recognize the current creditor. For example, after the
itemization date, a creditor may have sold a debt to a debt buyer, or
may have changed its corporate identity following a merger or
acquisition, and the consumer may not have had any contact with the new
entity before collections began. In these cases, the consumer may be
more likely to recognize the name of the creditor as of the itemization
date than the name of the current creditor. This is because (as
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(b)(3)) the itemization date is intended to reflect a notable
event in a debt's history that the consumer may recall, or for which
the consumer may have records. A consumer may be more likely to
recognize the creditor as of that date than the current creditor, with
whom the consumer may have no prior relationship.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\460\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vi) regarding FDCPA section 809(a)(2)'s requirement to
disclose the name of the creditor to whom the debt is owed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority under Dodd-Frank
Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iv) to
provide that, if a debt collector is collecting a consumer financial
product or service debt, as that term is defined in Sec. 1006.2(f),
the name of the creditor to whom the debt was owed on the itemization
date is validation information that the debt collector must provide to
the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iv).
34(c)(2)(v)
The purpose of FDCPA section 809 is to ``eliminate the recurring
problem of debt collectors dunning the wrong person or attempting to
collect debts which the consumer has already paid.'' \461\ The Bureau
believes that the problem of debt collectors attempting to collect
debts from consumers who do not owe the debts continues today. For
example, ``attempts to collect debt not owed'' is consistently the most
common type of debt collection complaint consumers provide to the
Bureau.\462\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\461\ S. Rept. No. 382, supra note 70, at 4.
\462\ See 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 11, at 16 (40
percent of consumer complaints about debt collection involve
attempts to collect debt not owed); 2018 FDCPA Annual Report, supra
note 16, at 15 (39 percent of consumer complaints about debt
collection involve attempts to collect debt not owed).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with the FDCPA's purpose, FDCPA section 809(a) requires
debt collectors to disclose to consumers certain information, such as
the amount of the debt itself, to help consumers identify debts. An
account number associated with a debt on the itemization date may be
integral information that a consumer uses to identify the debt itself.
For example, the Bureau's consumer testing suggests that a validation
notice that includes an account number appears to ease concerns that a
debt is fraudulent because the consumer may recognize the number or be
able to verify the debt with their records.\463\ In addition, in
response to the Bureau's ANPRM, State attorneys general, consumer
advocates, and industry stakeholders all provided feedback that the
account number associated with a debt may help a consumer recognize the
debt. For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority to interpret
FDCPA section 809(a), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act
section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(v) to provide
that the account number, if any, associated with the debt on the
itemization date, or a
[[Page 23341]]
truncated version of that number, is validation information that the
debt collector must provide to the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\463\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors may wish to truncate account numbers to prevent
disclosure of consumer account information, or to comply with
applicable privacy rules, such as the FTC Safeguards Rule.\464\
Proposed comment 34(c)(2)(v)-1 explains that debt collectors may do so
provided that the account number remains recognizable. For example, in
lieu of disclosing a complete account number, debt collectors may
disclose only the last four digits of the number. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(v) and on comment 34(c)(2)(v)-
1, including on whether the Bureau should mandate truncation of account
numbers rather than making truncation optional. Further, the Bureau
requests comment on whether additional clarification about truncation
would be helpful. For example, such clarification might explain when a
truncated account number is recognizable, or how debt collectors may
indicate that digits have been omitted from a truncated account number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\464\ See 16 CFR part 314.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(2)(vi)
FDCPA section 809(a)(2) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers the name of the creditor to whom the debt is owed. By using
the present tense ``is owed,'' the statute appears to refer to the
creditor to whom the debt is owed when the debt collector makes the
disclosure. For this reason, and pursuant to its authority to implement
and interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(2), the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vi) to provide that the name of the current creditor is
validation information that the debt collector must provide to the
consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).
34(c)(2)(vii)
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers the amount of the debt. In Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(viii), the
Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(1), and to use its
authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), to provide that the
amount of the debt on the itemization date is validation information
that the debt collector must disclose under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).\465\
Consistent with proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(viii)--and for the same
reasons and pursuant to the same authority discussed in the section-by-
section analysis thereof--the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii)
to provide that the itemization date, as defined in Sec.
1006.34(b)(3), also is validation information that must be provided to
the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).\466\ The itemization date would
indicate the beginning of the time period that the itemization of the
debt in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ix) is intended to capture. The
Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\465\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(viii).
\466\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3) and (c)(2)(viii) and (ix), the
itemization date is the reference date for, among other things, the
itemization of the debt, which the Bureau believes may help a
consumer identify an alleged debt. For additional discussion of
these provisions, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iv) and (v).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(2)(viii)
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers the amount of the debt. The phrase ``the amount of the debt''
is ambiguous; it does not specify which debt amount is being referred
to, even though the debt amount may change over time. For example,
because of accrued interest or fees, the current amount of the debt
(i.e., the amount on the date that the validation information is
provided) may be more than the amount of the debt at origination.
Because of applied payments or credits, the current amount of the debt
also may be less than the amount of the debt the consumer originally
incurred. If the amount of the debt has changed over time, consumers
may not recognize the debt or the current amount of the debt. By
contrast, consumers may recognize the amount of the debt as of the
itemization date. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3), the itemization date reflects a notable
event in a debt's history that a consumer may recall or be able to
verify with records, particularly if that amount is itemized as
described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(ix).
Because the amount of the debt on the itemization date may help a
consumer recognize a debt and determine whether the amount of a debt is
accurate, the Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(1), and
to use its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), to provide
in Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(viii) that the amount of the debt on the
itemization date is validation information that the debt collector must
provide to the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).\467\ Proposed
comment 34(c)(2)(viii)-1 explains that this amount includes any fees,
interest, or other charges owed as of the itemization date. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(viii) and on comment
34(c)(2)(viii)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\467\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x) separately provides that
the current amount of the debt also is validation information that
must be disclosed under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). See the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(2)(ix)
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires a debt collector to disclose to
consumers the amount of the debt. This disclosure is intended to help
consumers recognize debts that they owe and raise concerns about debts
that are unfamiliar or inaccurate. For the reasons discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(viii) and
(x), the Bureau proposes to implement and interpret FDCPA section
809(a)(1) to provide that debt collectors must disclose to consumers
both the amount of the debt on the itemization date and the current
amount of the debt (i.e., the amount of the debt on the date that the
validation information is provided).
In conjunction with the amount of the debt on the itemization date
and the current amount of the debt, an itemization of how the amount of
the debt changed between those dates may be an integral part of the
amount of the debt. Specifically, consumers may be better positioned to
recognize whether they owe a debt and to evaluate whether the current
amount alleged due is accurate if they understand how the amount
changed over time due, for example, to interest, fees, payments, and
credits that have been assessed or applied to the debt.
The Bureau's qualitative consumer testing indicates that an
itemization appears to improve consumer understanding about and
recognition of the debt.\468\ In particular, some testing participants
emphasized that an itemization in a tabular format helped them
understand specific fees and charges.\469\ The FTC has also suggested
that the validation notice should contain an itemization that includes
principal, interest, and fees.\470\ Some State debt collection laws
also require that the validation notice include an itemization.\471\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\468\ FMG Usability Report, supra note 41, at 16-19.
\469\ FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 10.
\470\ FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at v.
\471\ See Cal. Civ. Code sec. 1788.52(a)(2); NYCRR Sec.
1.2(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Courts have also observed that an itemization may enhance consumer
understanding. Some courts have opined that an itemized accounting
helps a consumer assess the validity of
[[Page 23342]]
an alleged debt.\472\ Further, some courts have held that a debt
collector's failure to properly disclose interest and fees--or to
disclose that a debt may increase in the future due to interest and
fees--may violate the FDCPA.\473\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\472\ See, e.g., Haddad v. Alexander, Zelmanski, Danner &
Fioritto, PLLC, 758 F. 3d 777, 785 (6th Cir. 2015).
\473\ See Avila v. Riexinger & Associates, LLC, 817 F.3d 72, 76
(2d Cir. 2016) (holding that 15 U.S.C. 1692e requires debt
collectors to disclose when the amount of a debt may increase due to
interest and fees); Miller v. McCalla, Raymer, Padrick, Cobb,
Nichols, and Clark, LLC, 214 F.3d 872, 875-76 (7th Cir. 2000)
(finding that a validation notice's omission of accrued interest and
fees violated 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a)(1)'s requirement to disclose the
amount of the debt); Wood v. Allied Interstate, LLC (17 C 4921),
2018 WL 2967061, at *2-3 (N.D. Ill. June 13, 2018) (holding that an
itemization that listed ``$0.00'' due in interest and fees, when
interest and fees were not allowed, could violate 15 U.S.C. 1692e
and 1692f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An itemization also may discourage debt collectors from engaging in
unfair, deceptive, or abusive practices by ensuring that consumers
have, as a matter of course, sufficient information to evaluate claims
of indebtedness presented in validation notices. For example, requiring
a debt collector to disclose an itemization of the debt may help a
consumer identify erroneous or fabricated fees that a creditor or debt
collector may have added that inflated the amount of an alleged debt.
An itemization requirement also may help debt collectors disclose
interest and fees in a manner that provides essential information to
consumers and reduces debt collectors' legal risk when providing
validation notices.
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(1), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act
section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ix) to provide
that an itemization of the current amount of the debt, in a tabular
format reflecting interest, fees, payments, and credits since the
itemization date, is validation information that must be provided to
the consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). Proposed comment 34(c)(2)(ix)-1
would clarify how debt collectors can disclose that no interest, fees,
payments, or credits were assessed or applied to a debt.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ix) and
on comment 34(c)(2)(ix)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on whether the itemization should be more detailed--for example, by
reflecting each fee charged and each payment received--or whether
certain itemization categories, such as credits and payments, should be
combined. The Bureau also requests comment on whether the itemization
proposal is practicable across all categories of debt or conflicts with
disclosure requirements established by other applicable law, such as
State case law, statutory law, and regulatory law, as well as
disclosures required by judicial opinions or orders.
34(c)(2)(x)
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers the amount of the debt. As noted, however, the phrase ``the
amount of the debt'' is ambiguous; it does not specify which debt
amount is being referred to, even though the debt amount may change
over time. One reasonable interpretation of FDCPA section 809(a)(1) is
that ``amount of the debt'' refers to the current amount of the debt,
which is the amount of the debt on the date that the validation
information is provided. For this reason, and pursuant to its authority
to implement and interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(1), proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(x) provides that the current amount of the debt is
validation information that the debt collector must provide to the
consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1).
Proposed comment 34(c)(2)(x)-1 explains that, for residential
mortgage debt subject to Sec. 1006.34(c)(5), a debt collector may
comply with Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x) by including in the validation
notice the total balance of the outstanding mortgage, including
principal, interest, fees, and other charges. The Bureau proposes this
to accommodate debt collectors collecting mortgage debt, who sometimes
disclose to consumers the total balance of the outstanding mortgage,
rather than the current amount due on a given date when providing the
amount of the debt pursuant to FDCPA section 809(a)(1).\474\ The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x) and on comment
34(c)(2)(x)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\474\ Under Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41(d)(3), certain mortgage
servicers are required to provide a past-payment breakdown that may
be functionally equivalent to, and as useful for the consumer, as
the disclosures that would be required by proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix). As discussed in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5), the Bureau
proposes a special rule that would allow servicers of certain
residential mortgage debt to satisfy the requirements of proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix) by providing disclosures
required by Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41(d)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(3) Information About Consumer Protections
The disclosures in FDCPA section 809(a) help consumers determine if
a particular debt is theirs and facilitate action in response to a
collection attempt. The Bureau understands, however, that debt
collectors typically may disclose only the information that FDCPA
section 809(a) specifically references and may provide the FDCPA
section 809 information using statutory language, rather than plain
language that consumers can more easily comprehend.
Consumer advocates, State agencies, and State attorneys general
provided ANPRM feedback that validation notices do not contain enough
information about a consumer's rights with respect to debt
collection.\475\ The FTC similarly has asserted that debt collectors
generally do not provide enough information about the actions consumers
may take under the FDCPA, which makes it difficult for some consumers
to exercise those rights.\476\ The Bureau's consumer focus group
findings also indicate that consumers often are unfamiliar with or have
erroneous beliefs about their FDCPA rights.\477\ Many testing
participants responded favorably to sample validation notices that
disclosed additional rights and protections.\478\ Consumer testing also
suggests that consumers generally prefer disclosures written in plain
language, as opposed to statutory language.\479\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\475\ Consumer complaints received by the Bureau tend to
corroborate this feedback. In its 2019 FDCPA Annual Report, the
Bureau noted that 25 percent of consumers who complained about
written notifications about debt stated that they did not receive a
notice of their right to dispute. See 2019 FDCPA Annual Report,
supra note 11, at 17.
\476\ FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at v. The notion
that some consumers may have difficulty exercising FDCPA
verification rights is supported by one academic study that found a
substantial proportion of survey respondents did not understand they
would need to dispute a debt in writing to trigger certain FDCPA
protections. According to the study, 75 percent of consumers who
were shown a court-approved validation notice believed that they
could orally exercise their verification rights, even though the
notice expressly stated that disputes must be in writing. See Jeff
Sovern & Kate E. Walton, ``Are Validation Notices Valid? An
Empirical Evaluation of Consumer Understanding of Debt Collection
Validation Notices,'' 70 SMU L. Rev. 63, at 94-98 (2017).
\477\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 6-8.
\478\ FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 27-33.
\479\ Id. at 26-27; FMG Summary Report, supra note 42, at 25-26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To address these concerns, proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3) would deem
certain information about a consumer's rights with respect to debt
collection to be validation information that must be provided to the
consumer under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). This information, which is
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(i) through (vi), would include disclosures specifically
referenced in FDCPA
[[Page 23343]]
section 809(a)(4) and (5), as well as additional disclosures intended
to help consumers understand their debt collection rights.\480\ The
Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3) generally,
including on whether any of the proposed items should be excluded or
any additional items should be added.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\480\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692g(a)(4) and (5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i) through (iii) and (v)
pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors and, as
described more fully below, its authority to implement and interpret
FDCPA section 809. The Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)
pursuant to its authority under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act,
on the basis that a consumer's rights are a feature of debt collection.
Requiring disclosure of information about these rights may help to
ensure that the features of debt collection are fully, accurately, and
effectively disclosed to consumers, such that consumers may better
understand the costs, benefits, and risks associated with debt
collection.
34(c)(3)(i)
FDCPA section 809(a)(4) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers their right under FDCPA section 809(b) to dispute the
validity of the debt within 30 days after receipt of the validation
information (i.e., during the validation period). As discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.38, if a consumer
disputes a debt in accordance with FDCPA section 809(b), a debt
collector must cease collecting the debt until the debt collector
provides verification to the consumer; this is sometimes referred to as
the collections pause. FDCPA section 809(a)(4) does not expressly
indicate that a debt collector must disclose to consumers that a
dispute triggers FDCPA section 809(b)'s collections pause, or whether a
debt collector must disclose the end date of the validation period.
FDCPA section 809(b)'s collections pause is an integral feature of
the dispute right disclosure required by FDCPA section 809(a)(4).
Unless debt collectors disclose the collections pause, consumers may
not fully appreciate their FDCPA dispute right. Participants in the
Bureau's consumer testing reported that knowing about the collections
pause was important and would encourage them to exercise their dispute
right if they question a debt's validity.\481\ This is consistent with
the FTC's observation that consumers are generally unaware of the
collections pause, even though it may benefit them.\482\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\481\ FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 30; see also FMG
Summary Report, supra note 42, at 25.
\482\ FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at 26-27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The validation period end date similarly is an integral feature of
a consumer's dispute right. Unless debt collectors disclose the end
date of the validation period, consumers may be uncertain about the
time period during which they are entitled to dispute the debt under
FDCPA section 809(b).
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(4) and (b), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank
Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i) to
provide that validation information includes a statement that specifies
the end date of the validation period and states that, if the consumer
notifies the debt collector in writing before the end of the validation
period that the debt, or any portion of the debt, is disputed, the debt
collector must cease collection of the debt until the debt collector
sends the consumer either the verification of the debt or a copy of a
judgment. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(i).
34(c)(3)(ii)
FDCPA section 809(a)(5) requires debt collectors to disclose to
consumers their right under FDCPA section 809(b) to request, within 30
days after receipt of the validation information, the name and address
of the original creditor, if different than the current creditor. FDCPA
section 809(a)(5) does not expressly indicate that a debt collector
must disclose to consumers that an original-creditor information
request invokes FDCPA section 809(b)'s collections pause, or whether a
debt collector must disclose the end date of the validation period.
FDCPA section 809(b)'s collections pause is an integral feature of
the consumer's right to request original-creditor information under
FDCPA section 809(a)(5). Unless debt collectors disclose the
collections pause, consumers may not fully appreciate their right to
request original-creditor information under FDCPA section 809(b).
The validation period end date similarly is an integral feature of
a consumer's right to request original-creditor information. Unless
debt collectors disclose the validation period end date, consumers may
be uncertain about the time period during which they are entitled to
request original-creditor information under FDCPA section 809(b).
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(5) and (b), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank
Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(ii) to
provide that validation information includes a statement that specifies
the end date of the validation period and states that, if the consumer
requests in writing before the end of the validation period the name
and address of the original creditor, the debt collector must cease
collection of the debt until the debt collector sends the consumer the
name and address of the original creditor, if different from the
current creditor. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(ii). In particular, the Bureau notes that the proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(ii) disclosure language that appears on proposed
Model Form B-3 omits the statutory phrase, ``if different from the
current creditor.'' The Bureau intentionally omitted this phrase to
achieve a plain language disclosure that enhances consumer
understanding. The Bureau requests comment on whether omitting this
phrase on proposed Model Form B-3 would enhance consumer understanding
by simplifying the statutory language, or whether it might lead
consumers incorrectly to conclude that a debt collector always would
need to cease collection upon request for original-creditor
information, even if the original creditor and the current creditor
were the same.
34(c)(3)(iii)
FDCPA section 809(a)(3) requires a debt collector to disclose to a
consumer that, unless the consumer disputes the validity of the debt
within 30 days of receipt of the validation information, the debt
collector will assume the debt to be valid. The Bureau is aware that
courts in various jurisdictions have reached different conclusions
about whether FDCPA section 809(a)(3) requires debt collectors to
recognize oral disputes, received within 30 days of a consumer's
receipt of the validation information, about the validity of the
debt.\483\ These differing decisions
[[Page 23344]]
principally arise from the fact that, whereas FDCPA section 809(a)(4)
and (5) explicitly require a consumer to submit a written dispute to
invoke the FDCPA's verification rights, FDCPA section 809(a)(3)
specifies no writing requirement. In the absence of an express writing
requirement in FDCPA section 809(a)(3), the majority of circuit courts
that have considered this issue have determined that a consumer's oral
dispute triggers certain FDCPA protections, including, for example,
FDCPA section 810's payment application requirement.\484\ These
decisions have created uncertainty for debt collectors in some
jurisdictions when seeking to comply with FDCPA section 809(a)'s
disclosure requirements.\485\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\483\ Compare Clark v. Absolute Collection Serv., Inc., 741 F.3d
487, 490 (4th Cir. 2014) (holding that oral disputes trigger certain
FDCPA protections, including under FDCPA section 809(a)(3)), Hooks
v. Forman, Holt, Eliades & Ravin, LLC, 717 F.3d 282, 286 (2d Cir.
2013) (same), and Camacho v. Bridgeport Fin. Inc., 430 F.3d 1078,
1082 (9th Cir. 2005) (same), with Graziano v. Harrison, 950 F.2d
107, 112 (3d Cir. 1991) (``[A] dispute, to be effective, must be in
writing''), and Durnell v. Stoneleigh Recovery Assocs., LLC, (No.
18-2335), 2019 WL 121197, at *3-4 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 7, 2019) (holding
that a validation notice that ``mirror[ed] the language'' of the
FDCPA section 809 still violated the FDCPA because disputes must be
in writing).
\484\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692i; Camacho, 430 F.3d at 1081-82 (holding
that oral disputes trigger certain FDCPA protections, including
under FDCPA sections 807(8) and 810).
\485\ See, e.g., Caprio v. Healthcare Revenue Recovery Grp., 709
F.3d 142, 151-52 (3d Cir. 2013) (holding that a collection letter
encouraging a consumer to ``please call'' the debt collector
violated FDCPA section 809(a)); Riggs v. Prober & Raphael, 681 F.3d
1097, 1103-04 (9th Cir. 2012) (holding that a validation notice that
implied a written dispute requirement--but that did not expressly
require a written dispute--did not violate FDCPA section 809(a)(3));
Homer v. Law Offices of Frederic I. Weinberg & Assocs., P.C., 292 F.
Supp. 3d 629, 633-34 (E.D. Pa. 2017) (holding that a validation
notice that used ``hears from you'' language was deceptive because
it suggested that disputes could be made orally).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with the position articulated by the majority of circuit
courts, and pursuant to its authority to implement and interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(3) as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section
1032(a), the Bureau proposes to interpret FDCPA 809(a)(3) to allow oral
disputes. The Bureau believes that this may be the most persuasive
interpretation of Congressional intent, given the lack of the words
``in writing'' in FDCPA 809(a)(3), as compared to the presence of those
words throughout FDCPA 809(a)'s other provisions. Accordingly, the
Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(iii) to provide that validation
information includes a statement that specifies the end date of the
validation period and states that, unless the consumer contacts the
debt collector to dispute the validity of the debt, or any portion of
the debt, before the end of the validation period, the debt collector
will assume that the debt is valid. Model Form B-3 would inform
consumers that they have the option to ``call'' or ``write'' a debt
collector to dispute the validity of a debt during the validation
period. While Model Form B-3 would alert consumers to an oral dispute
option, the form would clarify that only a written dispute would invoke
verification rights pursuant to FDCPA sections 809(a)(4) and (5).\486\
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(2), the use of Model Form B-3 would provide debt collectors
with a safe harbor for compliance with FDCPA section 809(a)'s
disclosure requirements.\487\ The Bureau requests comment on whether
debt collectors require additional clarification about how to comply
with FDCPA section 809(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\486\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(i) and (ii).
\487\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(3)(iv)
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3), consumers may not receive sufficient information about
their rights and protections in debt collection. While validation
information helps consumers determine if a particular debt is theirs
and facilitates action in response to a collection attempt, consumers
could benefit if validation information included additional information
about consumer protections in debt collection. The Bureau makes such
information available on its website and intends to develop additional
resources to enhance consumer understanding of these protections and
the debt collection process in general. The Bureau is developing a
reference document that would describe certain legal protections
relevant to debt collection. This reference document was initially
conceived as a mandatory disclosure that debt collectors would be
required to provide to consumers along with the validation notice.
Although the Bureau does not propose to require debt collectors to
provide the reference document to consumers, if the Bureau finalizes
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(iv), the Bureau would publish a version of
the document as a consumer resource on the Bureau's website before the
final rule's effective date.\488\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\488\ For additional detail about information that may appear on
the reference document, refer to appendix G of the Small Business
Review Panel Outline, supra note 56.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To enhance consumer understanding of protections available during
the debt collection process, and pursuant to its authority under Dodd-
Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(iv)
to provide that, if a debt collector is collecting a consumer financial
product or service debt, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), then validation
information includes a statement that informs the consumer that
additional information regarding consumer rights in debt collection is
available on the Bureau's website at https://www.consumerfinance.gov.\489\ The Bureau proposes this requirement on
the basis that this information informs consumers how to exercise their
FDCPA rights and protections and therefore is a feature of debt
collection. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(iv).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\489\ To the extent that the Bureau develops a more specific
landing page for information about consumer protections during the
debt collection process, the Bureau would include the website
address for that landing page in a final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(3)(v)
As discussed below, proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) would provide that
validation information includes information that a consumer can use to
take certain actions, which generally include disputing a debt or
requesting original-creditor information.\490\ As discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i) and
(ii), FDCPA section 809(b) provides that consumers must notify a debt
collector ``in writing'' to dispute a debt or request original-creditor
information. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.38, the Bureau would interpret FDCPA section
809(b)'s writing requirement as being satisfied when a consumer submits
a dispute or request for original-creditor information to the debt
collector via a medium of electronic communication through which a debt
collector accepts electronic communications from consumers, such as
email or a website portal. Thus, debt collectors only would be required
to give legal effect to consumer disputes or requests for original-
creditor information submitted electronically where a debt collector
chooses to accept electronic communications from consumers. This would
apply regardless of whether the validation notice itself is delivered
electronically.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\490\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) would set forth required
consumer response information. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii)(B)
and (vi)(B) would permit certain other consumer response information
related to payment requests and requests for Spanish-language
validation notices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, FDCPA section 809(b) prohibits debt collector
communications during the validation period that are inconsistent with
the disclosure of a consumer's verification rights. If debt collectors
refuse to accept consumers' disputes or requests for original-creditor
information through a medium of electronic communication after
[[Page 23345]]
providing an electronic validation notice through that same medium,
consumers may become confused about how to exercise their verification
rights. While the FDCPA does not directly address electronic debt
collection communications, a reasonable consumer could expect to be
able to respond to a debt collector through the same medium of
electronic communication that the debt collector used to contact the
consumer. Because of the potential for confusion, a debt collector's
refusal to accept a dispute or request for original-creditor
information electronically after providing a validation notice
electronically may be inconsistent with the effective disclosure of the
consumer's verification rights.
For these reasons, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a) and (b), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act
section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) to provide
that validation information includes a statement explaining how a
consumer can take the actions described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)
electronically, if the debt collector sends the validation notice
electronically. Proposed comment 34(c)(3)(v)-1 explains that a debt
collector may provide the information described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(v) by including the statements, ``We accept disputes
electronically,'' using that phrase or a substantially similar phrase,
followed by an email address or website portal that a consumer can use
to take the action described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i), and ``We accept
original creditor information requests electronically,'' using that
phrase or a substantially similar phrase, followed by an email address
or website portal that a consumer can use to take the action described
in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(ii). Proposed comment 34(c)(3)(v)-1 also would
clarify that, if a debt collector accepts electronic communications
from consumers through more than one medium, such as by email and
through a website portal, the debt collector is only required to
provide information regarding one of these media but may provide
information about additional media.
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives supported
the Bureau's proposal to clarify how debt collectors could use newer
communication technologies, such as email and text messages, which some
consumers may prefer.\491\ Consistent with this feedback, the Small
Business Review Panel Report recommended that the Bureau consider
whether the debt collection rule should promote newer communication
technologies, and, if so, establish guidelines for the appropriate use
of such technologies.\492\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) is
responsive to this feedback. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) and on comment 34(c)(3)(v)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\491\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
16-17; see also CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 37 (finding that email was the most preferred contact method for
11 percent of consumers contacted about a debt in collection).
\492\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(3)(vi)
As discussed elsewhere in this proposed rule--for example, in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42--the use of
electronic media such as email and text messages for debt collection
communications may further the interests of both consumers and debt
collectors, but communications sent by such media may require tailored
protections for consumers. One such protection, as proposed in Sec.
1006.6(e), would require a debt collector who communicates or attempts
to communicate with a consumer electronically in connection with the
collection of a debt using a specific email address, telephone number
for a text message, or other electronic-medium address to include in
such communication or attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous
statement describing one or more ways the consumer can opt out of
further electronic communications or attempts to communicate by the
debt collector to that address or telephone number.
Consistent with proposed Sec. 1006.6(e), and pursuant to the legal
authorities discussed in the section-by-section analysis thereof, the
Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(vi) to provide that, for a
validation notice delivered in the body of an email pursuant to Sec.
1006.42(b)(1) or (c)(2)(i), validation information includes the opt-out
statement required by Sec. 1006.6(e). Proposed comment 34(c)(3)(vi)-1
explains that, if a validation notice is delivered on a website
pursuant to Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii), the validation notice need not
contain the opt-out statement because the statement will be required in
any email or text message that provides a hyperlink to the website
where the notice is placed. Proposed comment 34(c)(3)(vi)-1 further
explains that delivery of a validation notice that a debt collector
previously provided pursuant to Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) or (c)(2)(i) or
(ii) is not rendered ineffective because a consumer opts out of future
electronic communications. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(vi) and on comment 34(c)(3)(vi)-1.
34(c)(4) Consumer Response Information
The FTC has noted that some consumers do not receive sufficient
information explaining how they may exercise their FDCPA rights.\493\
This observation is consistent with at least one academic study, which
found that many consumers did not understand how to properly exercise
their FDCPA verification rights even after reviewing a typical
validation notice.\494\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\493\ See FTC Modernization Report, supra note 176, at v.
\494\ See Jeff Sovern & Kate E. Walton, Are Validation Notices
Valid? An Empirical Evaluation of Consumer Understanding of Debt
Collection Validation Notices, 70 SMU L. Rev. 63, 94-98 (2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the development of this proposal, the Bureau tested
validation notices that included information about how consumers could
exercise their FDCPA verification rights using a separate section of
the notice, which consumers could detach and return to the debt
collector. For purposes of this section-by-section analysis, the Bureau
refers to this information as consumer response information. The
Bureau's usability testing indicated that consumers understood that
they could use the consumer response information to dispute a debt, or
to communicate that information about the debt in the validation notice
was incorrect.\495\ The usability testing findings thus indicated that
the consumer response information enhanced consumers' comprehension of
their dispute rights.\496\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\495\ See FMG Usability Report, supra note 41, at 59-60.
\496\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's testing suggests that requiring debt collectors to
disclose consumer response information, segregated from other
validation information, appears to help consumers exercise their FDCPA
section 809(b) rights to dispute the validity of a debt and to request
original-creditor information. Further, the consumer response
information may facilitate a debt collector's ability to process and
understand a consumer's response to a validation notice. For example,
by requiring the consumer response information section to include
statements describing specific reasons for disputes, proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4) could reduce the burden of responding to generic or
ambiguous disputes. While the proposal would not require consumers to
indicate a specific dispute
[[Page 23346]]
description listed in the consumer response information, consumers may
be likely to do so, thereby lessening the number of generic disputes
(e.g., a communication that only contains the statement ``I dispute''
with no further detail) sent to debt collectors.\497\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\497\ Usability testing findings suggested that consumers
generally understood how to use the consumer response information
section to indicate a specific reason for a dispute. See id. at 59-
61.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes requiring a consumer
response information section on the validation notice. Specifically,
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) provides that the validation information
that must be disclosed under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) includes certain
consumer response information situated next to prompts that the
consumer could use to indicate that action or request. The information,
which is discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4)(i) through (iii), would include statements describing
certain actions that a consumer could take, including submitting a
dispute, identifying the reason for the dispute, providing additional
detail about the dispute, and requesting original-creditor
information.\498\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\498\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii)(B) and (vi)(B), a debt collector
also could choose to include a payment disclosure and Spanish-
language validation notice request disclosure as consumer response
information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) provides that the consumer response
information section must be segregated from the validation information
described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(1) through (3) and from any optional
information included pursuant to Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(i), (ii), (iv), or
(v) and, if the validation information is provided in writing or
electronically, located at the bottom of the notice and under the
headings, ``How do you want to respond?'' and ``Check all that
apply:''. Requiring the consumer response information section to be
presented in this manner may help consumers respond to the disclosures
required under Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). Specifically, requiring the
information to be located at the bottom of a validation notice may
enable consumers to use the bottom section of the notice to reply to
the debt collector while retaining the required disclosures located in
the validation notice's upper section. Proposed comment 34(c)(4)-1
would clarify that, if the validation information is provided in
writing or electronically, a prompt described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)
may be formatted as a checkbox, as in Model Form B-3.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4). The
Bureau specifically requests comment on whether validation information
should include consumer response information, and, if so, on whether
any of the proposed items should be excluded or any additional items
should be added.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors and, as described more fully
below, its authority to implement and interpret FDCPA section 809. The
Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) pursuant to its authority
under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act, on the basis that the
information in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i) through (iii) informs
consumers how to exercise their rights under FDCPA section 809(b) and
therefore is a feature of debt collection. Requiring disclosure of the
information may help to ensure that the features of debt collection are
fully, accurately, and effectively disclosed to consumers, such that
consumers may better understand the costs, benefits and risks
associated with debt collection.
34(c)(4)(i) Dispute Prompts
FDCPA section 809(a)(4) requires a debt collector to disclose to
consumers their right under FDCPA section 809(b) to dispute the
validity of the debt within 30 days after receipt of the validation
notice. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i), which would implement and interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(4), some consumers may not adequately understand this
FDCPA dispute right or may face challenges when attempting to exercise
it. Providing consumers with prepared dispute statements may assist
consumers by helping them articulate the nature of their disputes.
Enabling consumers to communicate specific information about their
disputes also may reduce the number of burdensome, generic disputes
received by debt collectors and may allow debt collectors to provide
more relevant information in response.
For this reason, and pursuant to its authority to implement and
interpret FDCPA section 809(a)(4), as well as its authority under Dodd-
Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i)
to provide that consumer response information includes statements,
situated next to prompts, that the consumer can use to dispute the
validity of a debt and to specify a reason for that dispute. Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i), which is designed to work in tandem with
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(i), would provide that consumer response
information includes the following four statements, listed in the
following order, using the following phrasing or substantially similar
phrasing,\499\ each next to a prompt: ``I want to dispute the debt
because I think:''; ``This is not my debt''; ``The amount is wrong'';
and ``Other: (please describe on reverse or attach additional
information).'' The first three proposed dispute categories appear to
capture the vast majority of consumer disputes about the validity of a
debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\499\ To provide debt collectors with greater flexibility, the
Bureau does not propose to require a debt collector to use the exact
phrasing set forth in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives suggested
that including dispute prompts in the validation notice could increase
dispute volume and frequency, which could cause debt collectors to
incur more costs investigating and responding to disputes. Some small
entity representatives particularly were concerned that the consumer
response information might increase the number of generic disputes that
lack enough detail for debt collectors to provide responsive
information to consumers. Several small entity representatives also
objected to a potential dispute prompt that would state, ``You are not
the right person to pay,'' noting that this statement would not provide
debt collectors enough information to respond effectively to the
dispute and would require the debt collector to re-contact the
consumer, imposing costs on both debt collectors and consumers. The
Small Business Review Panel Report recommended that the Bureau consider
further its proposed consumer response information, including
soliciting more specific disputes.
In response to this feedback, the proposed rule omits the dispute
prompt, ``You are not the right person to pay.'' However, the proposed
rule retains the consumer response information concept. Proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4)(i) may facilitate consumers' ability to exercise their
dispute right, which is an important FDCPA protection. In addition,
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2), by requiring more information about the
debt, may help consumers recognize debts that they owe, reducing the
number of disputes arising from lack of consumer recognition and,
thereby, limiting overall dispute volume. Further, any information that
consumers provide in response to the free-form dispute prompt in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i)(D) could help debt collectors better
understand the nature of a consumer's dispute and respond
[[Page 23347]]
more efficiently than if consumers had provided generic disputes.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i),
including on whether any dispute prompts should be added, revised, or
removed. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on the potential
risks, costs, and benefits of the dispute prompts for both consumers
and industry, including on whether proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i) will
impact dispute volumes or affect the proportion of specific disputes
that debt collectors receive as compared to generic disputes.
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.38, the Bureau would interpret FDCPA section 809(b) to require a
debt collector to honor disputes that a consumer provides via a medium
of written electronic communication \500\ accepted by the debt
collector, such as a dispute portal accessed on or through a hyperlink
in an electronic communication. The Bureau declines to propose
requirements related to debt collector website communications,
including the content or formatting of dispute information accessible
via website or hyperlink.\501\ The Bureau requests comment on whether
the Bureau should propose rules concerning website communications. In
particular, the Bureau requests comment about the risks, costs, and
benefits to consumers and industry related to prescribing requirements
for the content and formatting of debt collector website
communications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\500\ For ease of reference, the Bureau uses the phrase
``written electronic communications'' to refer to emails, text
messages, and other electronic communications that are readable. The
Bureau's use of this phrase has no bearing on the Bureau's
interpretation of the terms ``written'' or ``in writing'' under any
law or regulation, including the FDCPA or the E-SIGN Act.
\501\ While the Bureau does not propose rules specifically
addressing debt collector website communications, such
communications are subject to existing legal requirements, including
those under the FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank Act. For example, debt
collectors may be liable for website communications that violate the
Dodd-Frank Act's prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive
practices, or the overshadowing prohibition under FDCPA section
809(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(c)(4)(ii) Original-Creditor Information Prompt
FDCPA section 809(a)(5) requires a debt collector to disclose to
consumers their right under FDCPA section 809(b) to request the name
and address of the original creditor, if different from the current
creditor.\502\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(ii), which would implement and interpret
FDCPA section 809(a)(5), some consumers may not adequately understand
their right to request original-creditor information or how to exercise
it. Providing consumers with a prepared statement that they could use
to request original-creditor information could help to address this
concern.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\502\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(iv) also would require that
the validation notice include the name of the creditor to whom the
debt was owed on the itemization date, if the debt collector is
collecting a consumer financial product or service debt, as defined
in proposed Sec. 1006.2(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For this reason, and pursuant to its authority to interpret FDCPA
section 809(a)(5), as well as its authority under Dodd-Frank Act
section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(ii) to provide
that consumer response information includes the statement, ``I want you
to send me the name and address of the original creditor,'' using that
phrase or a substantially similar phrase, next to a prompt the consumer
could use to request original-creditor information. Proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4)(ii) is intended to work in tandem with proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(3)(ii). The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4)(ii).
34(c)(4)(iii) Mailing Addresses
FDCPA section 809(b) assumes that a consumer has the ability to
write to a debt collector to exercise the consumer's verification
rights. Requiring a debt collector to include mailing addresses for the
consumer and the debt collector, which would include the consumer's and
the debt collector's names, along with the consumer response
information described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i) and (ii), may
facilitate consumers' use of that address information to exercise their
debt collection rights. For example, for mailed validation notices, a
debt collector may choose to format the addresses to appear in a return
envelope's glassine window, which the Bureau understands is industry
practice. Alternatively, the mailing address may be useful in the event
the consumer loses the upper portion of the validation notice
containing the debt collector's contact information. In this scenario,
the consumer also could review the mailing address in the consumer
response information section to confirm that the consumer was the
intended recipient of the validation notice. For these reasons, and
pursuant to its authority to implement FDCPA section 809(a), as well as
its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a), the Bureau proposes
Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(iii) to provide that consumer response information
includes mailing addresses for the consumer and the debt collector.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(iii).
The Bureau understands that some debt collectors use letter vendors to
mail validation notices and that, in some cases, the letter vendor's
mailing address may appear on validation notices in lieu of the debt
collector's mailing address. The Bureau requests comment on whether
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(iii) would be consistent with current
practices related to debt collectors' use of letter vendors to mail
validation notices.
34(c)(5) Special Rule for Certain Residential Mortgage Debt
FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requires a debt collector to disclose to
consumers the amount of the debt. As discussed in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix), the
Bureau interprets FDCPA section 809(a)(1) to require debt collectors to
disclose three pieces of itemization-related information: The
itemization date; the amount of the debt on the itemization date; and
an itemization of the debt reflecting interest, fees, payments, and
credits since the itemization date.\503\ The Bureau proposes to
establish a special rule that would replace these disclosure
requirements for debt collectors collecting certain residential
mortgage debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\503\ Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x) would require debt
collectors also to disclose the current amount of the debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For certain residential mortgage debt subject to 12 CFR 1026.41, 12
CFR 1026.41(b) generally requires that a periodic statement be
delivered or placed in the mail within a reasonably prompt time after
the payment due date or the end of any courtesy period provided for the
previous billing cycle. The Bureau believes that most residential
mortgage debt is subject to this requirement, although exceptions
exist.\504\ The Bureau understands that a consumer is provided with
such a periodic statement every billing cycle, even when a loan is
transferred between
[[Page 23348]]
servicers. Pursuant to Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41(d)(3), such a
periodic statement must include a past payment breakdown, which shows
the total of all payments received since the last statement, including
a breakdown showing the amount, if any, that was applied to principal,
interest, escrow, fees, and charges, and the amount, if any, sent to
any suspense or unapplied funds account.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\504\ The periodic statement requirement pursuant to 12 CFR
1026.41(b) does not apply to open-end consumer credit transactions,
such as a home equity line of credit. See 12 CFR 1026.41(a)(1).
Pursuant to 12 CFR 1026.41(e), certain types of transactions are
exempt from Sec. 1026.41(b)'s periodic statement requirement,
including reverse mortgages, timeshare plans, certain charged-off
mortgage loans, mortgage loans with certain consumers in bankruptcy,
and fixed-rate mortgage loans where a servicer provides the consumer
with a coupon book for payment. Further, small servicers as defined
by 12 CFR 1026.41(e)(4)(ii) are entirely exempt from the periodic
statement requirement. Where the Sec. 1026.41(b) periodic statement
was not provided, a debt collector collecting debts related thereto
would not be able to satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii)
through (ix) by providing a consumer, at the same time as the
validation notice, a copy of the most recent periodic statement
provided to the consumer under Sec. 1026.41(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau believes that these periodic statement disclosures may
be functionally equivalent to, and as useful for the consumer as, the
information described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through
(ix). For example, 12 CFR 1026.41(d)(3) requires that the past payment
breakdown reflect payments, interest, and other charges since the last
periodic statement. This requirement is consistent with the proposed
rule: Pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)'s itemization date
definition, a debt collector may use the date of the last periodic
statement as the reference date for the itemization-related information
required by proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix). Further,
the periodic statement required by 12 CFR 1026.41(b) is tailored to
disclose mortgage information effectively. For example, the periodic
statement under 12 CFR 1026.41(d) specifically addresses disclosure of
escrow and suspense account information. Proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix), which applies to debts more generally,
is silent with respect to these mortgage-specific concepts.
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) would establish
that, for debts subject to Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41, a debt
collector need not provide the validation information described in
Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix) if the debt collector provides
the consumer, at the same time as the validation notice, a copy of the
most recent periodic statement provided to the consumer under 12 CFR
1026.41(b), and refers to that periodic statement in the validation
notice. Proposed comment 34(c)(5)-1 provides examples clarifying how
debt collectors may comply with Sec. 1006.34(c)(5).
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) to implement and interpret
the FDCPA section 809(a)(1) requirement that the validation notice
include the amount of the debt, and pursuant to its FDCPA section
814(d) authority to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors. The Bureau also proposes this requirement
under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to
ensure that the features of consumer financial products and services
are disclosed fully, accurately, and effectively. The Bureau proposes
this requirement on the basis that the information otherwise required
to be disclosed under Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix) is a
feature of debt collection and the alternative information that
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) would permit is equally effective and
accurate for the collection of debts subject to 12 CFR 1026.41. For the
reasons described above, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) to
ensure that the debt, which is a feature of debt collection, is fully,
accurately, and effectively disclosed in a manner that permits the
consumer to understand the costs, benefits, and risks associated with
debt collection.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) and on
comment 34(c)(5)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on the
application of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) to mortgage debt for which
consumers were provided coupon books. For instance, the Bureau believes
that for mortgage debt for which consumers were provided coupon books,
debt collectors could comply with proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) because
servicers generally have a practice of providing periodic statements to
delinquent consumers, even if coupon books were previously provided.
The Bureau also requests comment on the extent to which creditors,
assignees, and servicers for transaction types that are exempt from 12
CFR 1026.41(b)'s periodic statement requirement pursuant to Sec.
1026.41(e) nevertheless provide periodic statements voluntarily and, if
so, whether the Bureau should clarify how proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5)
would apply in those circumstances. The Bureau also requests comment on
the application of proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(5) to servicers exempt
from 12 CFR 1026.41(b)'s periodic statement requirement pursuant to
Sec. 1026.41(e), such as small servicers or servicers servicing
mortgage loans that have been charged off, and servicers who provide
modified periodic statements pursuant to 12 CFR 1026.41(f) where a
consumer on the mortgage loan is a debtor in bankruptcy. Finally, the
Bureau also requests comment on whether there are other debt types,
such as student loan debt, for which the information described in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(vii) through (ix) may duplicate existing
disclosure requirements.
34(d) Form of Validation Information
34(d)(1) In General
34(d)(1)(i)
FDCPA section 809(a)'s required disclosures will be ineffective
unless a debt collector discloses them in a manner that is readily
understandable to consumers. For this reason, the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.34(d)(1) to require that the validation information described in
Sec. 1006.34(c) be conveyed in a clear and conspicuous manner. As
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of Sec. 1006.34(b)(1),
the Bureau proposed to define the term clear and conspicuous consistent
with the standards used in other consumer financial services laws and
their implementing regulations. The clear and conspicuous standard
would apply to written, electronic, and oral disclosures.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(d)(1)(i) to implement and
interpret FDCPA section 809(a), and pursuant to its authority under
FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection
of debts by debt collectors. The Bureau also proposes Sec.
1006.34(d)(1)(i) pursuant to its authority under section 1032(a) of the
Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to ensure that the features of
consumer financial products and services are disclosed fully,
accurately, and effectively. The Bureau proposes this requirement on
the basis that validation information is a feature of debt collection
and this information must be readily understandable to be effectively
and accurately disclosed. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(1)(i).
34(d)(1)(ii)
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(2), the Bureau proposes Model Form B-3 in appendix B as a
model validation notice form that debt collectors could use to comply
with the disclosure requirements of proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) and
(d)(1). Model Form B-3 was developed over multiple rounds of consumer
testing and through additional feedback and consideration, as described
in part III.B above. The Bureau believes that this form effectively
discloses the information described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c). For
the same reasons and pursuant to the same authority discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(1)(i),
proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(1)(ii) would require that, if provided in a
validation notice, the content, format, and placement of the
information described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) and the optional
[[Page 23349]]
disclosures permitted by proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3) must be
substantially similar to proposed Model Form B-3 in appendix B.
Proposed comment 34(d)(1)(ii)-1 explains that a debt collector may
make certain changes to the content, format, and placement of the
validation information described in Sec. 1006.34(c) as long as the
resulting disclosures are substantially similar to Model Form B-3 in
appendix B of the regulation. Proposed comment 34(d)(1)(ii)-1 also
provides an example of a change that debt collectors may make to the
validation notice if the consumer is deceased. As described in the
section-by-section analyses of Sec. Sec. 1006.2(e) and 1006.6(a)(4),
the proposal includes interpretations of the term consumer designed to
clarify communications between debt collectors and individuals
attempting to resolve the debts of a deceased consumer, including
provision of the validation notice to such individuals. Although the
validation notice will contain the name of the deceased consumer, some
persons who are authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's
estate may be misled by the use of second person pronouns such as
``you'' in the validation notice. For example, the model validation
notice states that ``you owe'' the debt collector.
While nothing in the proposed rule would prohibit a debt collector
from including a cover letter to explain the nature of the validation
notice, proposed comment 34(d)(1)(ii)-1 also would clarify that a debt
collector may modify inapplicable language in the validation notice
that could suggest that the recipient of the notice is liable for the
debt. For example, if a debt collector sends a validation notice to a
person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's
estate, and if that person is not liable for the debt, the debt
collector may use the deceased consumer's name instead of ``you.'' In
other contexts, such as mortgage servicing, the Bureau has allowed
servicers to include an explanatory notice and acknowledgement form,
add an affirmative disclosure, or adjust language in required notices
to reduce the risk of confusion to successors in interest.\505\ The
Bureau proposes a similar approach in Sec. 1006.34 and comment
34(d)(1)(ii)-1. The Bureau requests comment on proposed comment
34(d)(1)(ii)-1, on the risk of confusion or deception caused by the
second-person framing of the model validation notice in the deceased-
consumer context, and on options for reducing any possible confusion or
deception.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\505\ 81 FR 72160, 72182 (Oct. 19, 2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(d)(2) Safe Harbor
A model validation notice form that provides a safe harbor may
benefit both consumers and debt collectors. A model validation notice
form may effectively disclose validation information required by Sec.
1006.34(a)(1) in a manner that permits consumers to understand the
costs, benefits, and risks associated with debt collection. Further, a
model form may afford debt collectors protection from liability that
could arise if they developed and used their own forms. During the
SBREFA process, small entity representatives asserted that a model form
that provided protection from liability would promote efficiency and
predictability for debt collectors by reducing legal risk.\506\ Because
of these potential benefits, the Bureau has developed a model
validation notice--Model Form B-3 in appendix B.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\506\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 22;
see also Johnson v. Revenue Mgmt. Corp., 169 F.3d 1057, 1059-60 (7th
Cir. 1999) (holding that where a validation notice included demands
for ``prompt payment'' and that the consumer call the debt collector
``immediately,'' such statements may confuse a consumer or
overshadow their verification rights); Adams v. Law Offices of
Stuckert & Yates, 926 F.Supp. 521, 527 (E.D. Pa. 1996) (holding that
a validation notice threatening a lawsuit violated the FDCPA);
Vaughn v. CSC Credit Servs., Inc. (No. 93-4151), 1995 WL 51402, at
*3 (N.D. Ill. Feb. 3, 1995) (holding that a statement on a
validation notice about a debt's potential negative impact on
consumer's credit score violated FDCPA section 809(b) because it
overshadowed the verification rights disclosures).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Model Form B-3 was evaluated over multiple rounds of consumer
testing, as described in part III.B above, as well as through
additional feedback and consideration.\507\ Based on this testing, the
Bureau believes that Model Form B-3 effectively discloses the
validation information required by Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). Because of
Model Form B-3's effectiveness, and pursuant to its authority under
section 1032(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act, the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.34(d)(2) to permit a debt collector to comply with Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i) and (d)(1) by using Model Form B-3 in appendix B.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\507\ See generally FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40; FMG
Usability Report, supra note 41; FMG Summary Report, supra note 42.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 34(d)(2)-1 explains that, although the use of
Model Form B-3 in appendix B is not required, a debt collector who uses
the model form, including a debt collector who delivers the model form
electronically, will be in compliance with the disclosure requirements
of Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i) and (d)(1) and the requirements of FDCPA
section 809(a). Proposed comment 34(d)(2)-1 also explains that a debt
collector who includes on Model Form B-3 the optional disclosures
described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3) continues to be in compliance
as long as those disclosures are made consistent with the instructions
in Sec. 1006.34(d)(3). Further, proposed comment 34(d)(2)-1 explains
that a debt collector may embed hyperlinks in Model Form B-3 if
delivering the form electronically and continue to be in compliance as
long as the hyperlinks are included consistent with Sec.
1006.34(d)(4)(ii).
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(2) and on
proposed comment 34(d)(2)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on whether the Bureau should provide additional clarification about how
to deliver Model Form B-3 electronically in a manner that affords
protection from liability pursuant to proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(2). For
example, the Bureau requests comment on whether to prescribe or define
additional formatting requirements (e.g., type size) or delivery
standards for validation notices delivered electronically. The Bureau
also requests comment on the risks, costs, and benefits to consumers
and industry of extending the protection from liability pursuant to
proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(2) to validation notices delivered
electronically.
34(d)(3) Optional Disclosures
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3) provides that a debt collector may
include the optional information described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(i) through (vi) if providing the validation information
required by Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). These optional disclosures may assist
debt collectors and consumers by providing additional information about
the debt and consumers' rights with respect to debt collection in a
manner that does not violate FDCPA section 809(b)'s overshadowing
prohibition, a prohibition implemented by Sec. 1006.38(b). Under the
proposal, providing the disclosures in proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)
would not be regarded as overshadowing or inconsistent with the
disclosure about the consumer's right to dispute the debt or request
the name and address of the original creditor. The Bureau proposes
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3) to implement and interpret FDCPA section 809(a) and
(b) and pursuant to its FDCPA section 814(d) authority to prescribe
rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors and
pursuant to its authority under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act
to prescribe rules to ensure that the features of consumer financial
products
[[Page 23350]]
and services are disclosed fully, accurately, and effectively.
34(d)(3)(i) Telephone Contact Information
Telephone communications may benefit both debt collectors and
consumers by providing a low-cost and convenient communication method.
Debt collectors routinely contact consumers by telephone and currently
include their telephone numbers in validation notices. Also, some
consumers may prefer to engage with debt collectors by telephone rather
than by other communication methods.\508\ For these reasons, proposed
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(i) would permit a debt collector to include the
debt collector's telephone contact information, including telephone
number and the times that the debt collector accepts consumer telephone
calls, along with the validation information. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\508\ A Bureau survey found that 30 percent of consumers who had
been contacted about a debt in the prior year would most prefer to
be contacted about a debt in collection at a non-work telephone
number, as compared to a work telephone number, postal mail, email,
or in-person visits. See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra
note 18, at 36-37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(d)(3)(ii) Reference Code
Many debt collectors currently include reference codes on
validation notices for administrative purposes. Proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(ii) would accommodate this practice by permitting a debt
collector to include, along with the validation information, a number
or code that the debt collector uses to identify the debt or the
consumer. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(ii).
34(d)(3)(iii) Payment Disclosures
Payment disclosures that provide a method to easily send payment to
a debt collector may benefit both consumers and debt collectors. For
consumers who recognize and choose to repay all or part of a debt,
payment disclosures may make the transaction more efficient and
convenient. For consumers who determine that they owe a debt but may
not be ready to repay all of it at that time, payment disclosures may
facilitate a discussion that can lead to repayment, settlement, or a
payment plan.\509\ Consumer testing suggests that consumers believe
that a payment option is an important disclosure that should appear in
the validation notice.\510\ The Bureau also received feedback from debt
collectors requesting the ability to request payment from consumers
when providing validation information. For example, during the SBREFA
process, small entity representatives requested the ability to include
payment options in the consumer response information that Sec.
1006.34(c)(4) would require.\511\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\509\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 9.
\510\ FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40, at 17-19.
\511\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 22-
23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer advocates recommended that the Bureau prohibit debt
collectors from including payment disclosures along with validation
information. Consumer advocates expressed concerns that a consumer who
desires to dispute a debt might misconstrue the disclosure to require
the consumer to submit a payment in order to exercise the FDCPA dispute
right. The Bureau's proposal does not treat these concerns as
persuasive. While some formulations of a payment disclosure could
create a false sense of urgency or exaggerate the consequences of non-
payment,\512\ the Bureau believes that payment disclosures can be
designed to articulate payment requests in a neutral, non-threatening
manner. Moreover, the Bureau's consumer testing indicates that
consumers who encounter a payment disclosure on a validation notice
understand that a payment is not required to dispute a debt.\513\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\512\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 11-12.
\513\ FMG Usability Report, supra note 41, at 59-61.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes to allow debt collectors to
include certain payment disclosures along with the validation
information. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii) would permit a debt
collector to include certain payment disclosures in the validation
notice. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii) would require that these
optional payment disclosures be no more prominent than any of the
validation information described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c). Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii)(A) would allow the debt collector to include
in the validation notice the statement ``Contact us about your payment
options,'' using that phrase or a substantially similar phrase.
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii)(B) would allow the debt collector to
include in the consumer response information section that would be
required by proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) the statement, ``I enclosed
this amount,'' using that phrase or a substantially similar phrase,
payment instructions after that statement, and a prompt. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iii), including on
whether the payment disclosures should be permitted and, if so, whether
the payment disclosures should be modified.
34(d)(3)(iv) Disclosures Required by Applicable Law
Some States require specific disclosures to appear on the
validation notice. The Small Business Review Panel Report recommended
that the Bureau consider how to reconcile the Bureau's model validation
notice and such required State law disclosures.\514\ The Bureau also
understands that some courts have prescribed additional validation
notice disclosure requirements, or have fashioned optional disclosures
that offer a safe harbor to debt collectors providing information
required by the FDCPA. For example, several courts have crafted
language that debt collectors may use to comply with FDCPA section
809(a)(1) by disclosing that the amount of a debt may vary because of
accruing interest and fees.\515\ In response to these judicial
opinions, industry commenters have requested that the Bureau address
how debt collectors may disclose that the amount of a debt may vary
because of accruing interest and fees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\514\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 34.
\515\ See, e.g., Avila v. Riexinger & Associates, LLC, 817 F.3d
72, 77 (2d Cir. 2016); Miller v. McCalla, Raymer, Padrick, Cobb,
Nichols, and Clark, LLC, 214 F.3d 872, 876 (7th Cir. 2000).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To enable debt collectors to comply both with Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)
and with other applicable disclosure requirements, the Bureau proposes
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) to permit a debt collector to include, on the
front of the validation notice, a statement that other disclosures
required by applicable law appear on the reverse of the form and, on
the reverse of the validation notice, any such legally required
disclosures. Proposed comment 34(d)(3)(iv)-1 provides examples of
disclosure requirements that proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) would
cover, including disclosures required by State statutes or regulations
and disclosures required by judicial opinions or orders.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) and
on comment 34(d)(3)(iv)-1. The Bureau requests comment on conflicts
that might arise between the Bureau's model validation notice and other
disclosures required by applicable law. In particular, the Bureau
requests comment on whether proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) would
allow debt collectors to comply with applicable law, including on
[[Page 23351]]
whether any disclosures required by applicable law must be included on
the front of the validation notice. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) should cover a debt collector
who includes on the reverse of the model form disclosures that are
permitted, but not required, by applicable law.
34(d)(3)(v) Information About Electronic Communications
Despite the advent of new technologies, the bulk of debt collection
communication continues to occur by telephone and mail. Promoting newer
technologies may be beneficial both to consumers and debt collectors.
During the SBREFA process, small entity representatives supported the
Bureau's proposal to clarify how debt collectors could use newer
communication technologies, such as email and text messages, and some
consumers may prefer electronic communications to traditional
communication methods.\516\ Consistent with this feedback, the Small
Business Review Panel Report recommended that the Bureau consider
whether the debt collection rule should promote newer communication
technologies, and, if so, establish guidelines for their appropriate
use.\517\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\516\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 16-
17; CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at 37
(finding that email was the most preferred contact method for 11
percent of consumers contacted about a debt in collection).
\517\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(v) would permit
certain information about electronic communications to appear along
with the validation information. First, proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(v)(A) would permit debt collectors to provide the debt
collector's website and email address. Second, as discussed above,
proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) provides that, if a debt collector
sends a validation notice electronically, the debt collector must
include a statement explaining how a consumer can take the actions
described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) electronically. Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(v)(B) would permit a debt collector to include the
statement described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) for validation
notices not provided electronically. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(v).
34(d)(3)(vi) Spanish-Language Translation Disclosures
Validation information includes important information about the
debt and the consumer's rights with respect to debt collection.
Consumers with limited English proficiency may benefit from
translations of the validation notice in some circumstances, and
Spanish speakers represent the second-largest language group in the
United States after English speakers.\518\ Spanish-speaking consumers
with limited English proficiency may benefit from a Spanish-language
disclosure informing them of their ability to request a Spanish-
language translation, if a debt collector chooses to make such a
translation available. Further, debt collectors may wish to provide
validation information in Spanish, as doing so may facilitate their
communications with consumers. For these reasons, proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(vi) would allow debt collectors to include along with the
validation information optional Spanish-language disclosures that
consumers may use to request a Spanish-language validation notice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\518\ As of 2016, 40 million residents in the United States aged
five and older spoke Spanish at home. See U.S. Census Bureau,
Profile America for Facts for Features CB17-FF.17: Hispanic Heritage
Month 2017, at 4 (Oct. 17, 2017), https://www.census.gov/newsroom/facts-for-features/2017/hispanic-heritage.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
34(d)(3)(vi)(A)
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A) would permit a debt collector
to provide a statement in Spanish informing a consumer that the
consumer can request a Spanish-language validation notice.
Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A) would allow the
statement, ``P[oacute]ngase en contacto con nosotros para solicitar una
copia de este formulario en espa[ntilde]ol,'' using that phrase or a
substantially similar phrase in Spanish. In English, this phrase means,
``You may contact us to request a copy of this form in Spanish.'' If
providing this optional disclosure, a debt collector may include
supplemental information in Spanish that specifies how a consumer may
request a Spanish-language validation notice. Proposed comment
34(d)(3)(vi)(A)-1 explains that, for example, a debt collector may
provide a statement in Spanish that a consumer can request a Spanish-
language validation notice by telephone or email.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A)
and on comment 34(d)(3)(vi)(A)-1. The Bureau specifically requests
comment on: (1) Debt collectors' current collections activities
conducted in Spanish, as well as other non-English languages, including
whether debt collectors provide validation notices in non-English
languages; (2) any benefits, costs, or risks posed for consumers and
industry by the disclosure described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A); (3) examples of supplemental Spanish-language
instructions for requesting a translated validation notice that debt
collectors may wish to provide pursuant to proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A); and (4) the benefits or risks this supplemental
language disclosure may present, including whether such supplementary
information would make the proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A)
disclosure less effective.
34(d)(3)(vi)(B)
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(B) would permit debt collectors to
provide a statement in Spanish in the consumer response information
section that a consumer can use to request a Spanish-language
validation notice. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(B) would permit the
consumer response information section required by Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)
to include the statement, ``Quiero esta forma en espa[ntilde]ol,''
using that phrase or a substantially similar phrase in Spanish. In
English, this phrase means ``I want this form in Spanish.'' Proposed
Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(B) would require this statement to be next to a
prompt, which the consumer could use to request a Spanish-language
validation notice. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(B).
34(d)(4) Validation Notices Delivered Electronically
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42, promoting electronic communications may benefit consumers and
debt collectors. Allowing debt collectors to make certain formatting
modifications to validation notices delivered electronically may help
consumers exercise their verification rights under FDCPA section 809.
Certain formatting modifications also may facilitate a debt collector's
ability to process and understand a consumer's response to a validation
notice delivered electronically. Accordingly, the Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.34(d)(4) to permit a debt collector to, at its option, format a
validation notice delivered electronically in the manner described in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(4)(i) and (ii).\519\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\519\ As described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4), the Bureau
proposes additional formatting requirements applicable to validation
notices delivered electronically.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(d)(4) to implement and interpret
FDCPA section 809(a) by establishing formatting requirements that
facilitate the consumer's right to dispute a debt and
[[Page 23352]]
request original-creditor information, and pursuant to its FDCPA
section 814(d) authority to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors. The Bureau also proposes these
requirements under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe
rules to ensure that the features of consumer financial products and
services are disclosed fully, accurately, and effectively. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(4).
34(d)(4)(i) Prompts
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(4)(i) would permit a debt collector
delivering a validation notice electronically pursuant to Sec. 1006.42
to display any prompt required by Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i) or (ii) or
(d)(3)(iii)(B) or (vi)(B) as a fillable field. Allowing a debt
collector to design a validation notice delivered electronically so
that a consumer can take the actions described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(c)(4) by clicking a prompt would benefit consumers and
industry. The Bureau believes that this design modification would help
consumers exercise their FDCPA verification rights. Further, the Bureau
believes this design modification would improve consumer engagement and
facilitate a debt collector's ability to process and understand a
consumer's response to the validation notice. The Bureau requests
comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(4)(i).
34(d)(4)(ii) Hyperlinks
Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(4)(ii) would permit a debt collector
delivering a validation notice electronically to embed hyperlinks into
the validation notice that, when clicked, connect consumers to the debt
collector's website or permit consumers to take the actions described
in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c)(4). This formatting modification may help
consumers exercise their FDCPA verification rights when they are
already engaging with the validation notice in an online setting. This
modification also may improve consumer engagement and facilitate a debt
collector's ability to process and understand a consumer's response to
the validation notice. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.34(d)(4)(ii).
34(e) Translations Into Other Languages
Consumers with limited English proficiency may benefit from
translated disclosures, and some debt collectors may want to respond to
the needs of consumers with limited English proficiency using
translated disclosures, if doing so is consistent with the debt
collector's individual debt collection practices and preferences. At
the same time, some consumers who receive translated disclosures may
also desire to receive English-language disclosures, either because
they are fluent in English, or because they wish to share the
disclosures with an English-speaking spouse or assistance provider.
English-language disclosures may also allow consumers to confirm the
accuracy of the translation.
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(e) to provide
that a debt collector may send a consumer the validation notice
completely and accurately translated into any language, if the debt
collector also sends an English-language validation notice in the same
communication that satisfies proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). If a debt
collector already has provided a consumer an English-language
validation notice that satisfies proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) and
subsequently provides the consumer a validation notice translated into
any other language, the debt collector need not provide an additional
copy of the English-language notice. Proposed comment 34(e)-1 would
clarify that the language of a validation notice obtained from the
Bureau's website is considered a complete and accurate translation,
although debt collectors are permitted to use other validation notice
translations so long as they are accurate and complete.
Consumer advocacy groups have commented that debt collectors should
be required to provide validation notices translated into other
languages, in particular Spanish, at a consumer's request. For example,
some consumer advocacy groups suggested that debt collectors should be
required to provide a Spanish-language translation on the reverse of
every English-language validation notice.\520\ The Bureau declines to
propose a mandatory requirement that debt collectors provide translated
validation notices to consumers. Requiring debt collectors to provide a
translation on a separate page with each validation notice could result
in significant cost on a cumulative, industry-wide basis, especially
for smaller debt collectors and for languages whose use is not
prevalent in the United States. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(e) may strike an
appropriate balance by allowing a debt collector to provide translated
validation notices if they are complete and accurate and doing so is
consistent with the debt collector's individual debt collection
practices and preferences in a manner that does not impose undue
burden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\520\ The Bureau raised such an alternative approach as a
proposal under consideration in the Small Business Review Panel
Outline. See Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at
appendix F.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.34(e) and on
comment 34(e)-1. The Bureau also requests comment on whether debt
collectors should be required to provide a validation notice translated
into a non-English language at a consumer's request.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.34(e) pursuant to its authority
under section 1032(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act to prescribe rules to
ensure that the features of consumer financial products and services
are disclosed fully, accurately, and effectively. The Bureau proposes
Sec. 1006.34(e) to ensure that the features of debt collection are
fully, accurately, and effectively disclosed.
Section 1006.38 Disputes and Requests for Original-Creditor Information
FDCPA section 809(b) requires debt collectors both to refrain from
taking certain actions during the 30 days after the consumer receives
the validation information or notice described in FDCPA section 809(a)
(i.e., during the validation period) and to take certain actions if a
consumer either disputes the debt in writing, or requests the name and
address of the original creditor in writing, during the validation
period.\521\ FDCPA section 809(c) states that a consumer's failure to
dispute a debt under FDCPA section 809(b) may not be construed by any
court as an admission of liability.\522\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38 would
implement and interpret FDCPA section 809(b) and (c) as discussed
below. Except as otherwise noted, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.38
pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules
with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\521\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(b).
\522\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 38-1 would clarify the applicability of Sec.
1006.38 in the decedent debt context. As described in the section-by-
section analysis of Sec. 1006.2(e), the Bureau proposes to interpret
the term consumer in FDCPA section 803(3) to include deceased
consumers.\523\ This interpretation would apply to FDCPA section
809(b), as implemented by Sec. 1006.38, so that a deceased consumer
(i.e., that consumer's estate) would have the same rights under FDCPA
section 809(b) as
[[Page 23353]]
any living consumer. Accordingly, proposed comment 38-1 would clarify
that, if the debt collector knows or should know that the consumer is
deceased, and if the debt collector has not previously sent the
deceased consumer a written validation notice, then a person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate \524\
operates as the consumer for purposes of Sec. 1006.38. Proposed
comment 38-1 provides that, if such a person submits either a written
request for original-creditor information or a written dispute to the
debt collector during the validation period, then Sec. 1006.38(c) or
(d)(2)(i), respectively, would require the debt collector to respond to
that request or dispute. In addition, just as with living consumers,
the proposal would require a debt collector attempting to collect a
debt from a deceased consumer's estate to cease collection of the debt
until, where appropriate, the debt collector has mailed the name and
address of the original creditor or provided verification of the debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\523\ The Bureau proposes to define the term consumer to include
``any natural person, whether living or deceased, obligated or
allegedly obligated to pay any debt.'' See the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.2(e).
\524\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(a)(4) and comment 6(a)(4)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 38-2 also applies generally to proposed Sec.
1006.38. Proposed comment 38-2 notes that proposed Sec. 1006.38
contains requirements related to a dispute or request for original-
creditor information timely submitted in writing by the consumer.
Proposed comment 38-2 lists three examples of forms of communication
that the consumer can use for these purposes. The second example is a
medium of electronic communication; the Bureau proposes this example in
light of section 101 of the E-SIGN Act.\525\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\525\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The E-SIGN Act could affect whether a consumer satisfies the ``in
writing'' requirement of FDCPA section 809(b) by submitting a dispute
or request for original-creditor information electronically. Section
101(a)(1) of the E-SIGN Act generally provides that a record relating
to a transaction in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce may not
be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely because it
is in electronic form.\526\ However, section 101(b)(2) of the E-SIGN
Act does not require any person to agree to use or accept electronic
records or electronic signatures, other than a governmental agency with
respect to a record other than a contract to which it is a party.\527\
Section 104(b)(1)(A) of the E-SIGN Act permits a Federal agency with
rulemaking authority under a statute to interpret by regulation the
application of E-SIGN Act section 101 to that statute.\528\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\526\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(a)(1).
\527\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(b)(2).
\528\ 15 U.S.C. 7004(b)(1)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes to interpret the applicability of the E-SIGN
Act as it relates to FDCPA section 809(b)'s writing requirement for
consumer disputes or requests for original-creditor information.
Specifically, the Bureau would interpret FDCPA section 809(b)'s writing
requirement as being satisfied when a consumer submits a dispute or
request for original-creditor information using a medium of electronic
communication through which a debt collector accepts electronic
communications from consumers, such as email or a website portal.\529\
Thus, debt collectors would be required to give legal effect to
consumer disputes or requests for original-creditor information
submitted electronically only if a debt collector chooses to accept
electronic communications from consumers. The Bureau proposes to codify
this interpretation of the E-SIGN Act in comment 38-3. The Bureau
requests comment on proposed comments 38-1 through 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\529\ This interpretation is responsive to consumer advocates'
feedback recommending that, if a debt collector makes an electronic
means of communication available to consumers, electronic
communications received from consumers through that channel should
satisfy FDCPA section 809(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
38(a) Definitions
38(a)(1) Duplicative Dispute
The Bureau proposes to define the term duplicative dispute in Sec.
1006.38(a)(1). The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.38(a)(1) as an
interpretation of FDCPA section 809(b) and to facilitate compliance
with proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii), which would establish an
alternative to proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) \530\ applicable if a
debt collector reasonably has determined that a dispute is a
duplicative dispute. Proposed Sec. 1006.38(a)(1) would define the term
duplicative dispute to mean a dispute submitted by the consumer in
writing within the validation period that satisfies two criteria. The
first criterion is that the dispute is substantially the same as a
dispute previously submitted by the consumer in writing within the
validation period for which the debt collector already has satisfied
the requirements of Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i). The second criterion is
that the dispute does not include new and material supporting
information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\530\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) would implement the
requirements in FDCPA section 809(b) regarding disputes and
verification. See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 38(a)(1)-1 would clarify that, for purposes of
Sec. 1006.38(a)(1), a later dispute can be substantially the same as
an earlier dispute even if the later dispute does not repeat verbatim
the language of the earlier dispute. Proposed comment 38(a)(1)-2 would
clarify that, for purposes of Sec. 1006.38(a)(1), information is new
if the consumer did not provide the information when submitting an
earlier dispute, and information is material if it is reasonably likely
to change the verification the debt collector provided or would have
provided in response to the earlier dispute. Proposed comment 38(a)(1)-
2 also provides an example of new and material information.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.38(a)(1) and its
related commentary. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on
whether to specify criteria for determining whether one dispute is
substantially similar to another dispute, and, if so, what those
criteria should be. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on the
estimated percentage of current repeat disputes that would qualify as
duplicative disputes under the definition in proposed Sec.
1006.38(a)(1), including whether and how that figure is likely to vary
by debt type.
38(a)(2) Validation Period
To facilitate compliance in responding to disputes or requests for
original-creditor information, proposed Sec. 1006.38(a)(2) provides
that the term validation period as used in Sec. 1006.38 has the same
meaning given to it in Sec. 1006.34(b)(5).
38(b) Overshadowing of Rights To Dispute or Request Original-Creditor
Information
FDCPA section 809(b) provides that, for 30 days after the consumer
receives the validation information or notice described in FDCPA
section 809(a), a debt collector must not engage in collection
activities or communications that overshadow or are inconsistent with
the disclosure of the consumer's right to dispute the debt or request
information about the original creditor.\531\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38(b)
[[Page 23354]]
would implement this prohibition and generally restates the statute,
with only minor changes for style and clarity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\531\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(b). This language was added to the FDCPA
by the Financial Services Regulatory Relief Act of 2006, Public Law
109-351, section 802(c), 120 Stat. 2006 (2006), after an FTC
advisory opinion on the same subject. See Fed. Trade Comm'n,
Advisory Opinion to American Collector's Ass'n (Mar. 31, 2000)
(opining that the 30-day period set forth in FDCPA section 809(a)
``is a dispute period within which the consumer may insist that the
collector verify the debt, and not a grace period within which
collection efforts are prohibited'' but that ``[t]he collection
agency must ensure, however, that its collection activity does not
overshadow and is not inconsistent with the disclosure of the
consumer's right to dispute the debt specified by [s]ection
809(a).'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
38(c) Requests for Original-Creditor Information
FDCPA section 809(b) provides that, if a consumer requests the name
and address of the original creditor in writing within 30 days of
receiving the validation information or notice described in FDCPA
section 809(a), the debt collector must cease collection of the debt
until the debt collector obtains and mails that information to the
consumer.\532\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38(c) would implement and interpret
this requirement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\532\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In general, proposed Sec. 1006.38(c) mirrors the statute, with
minor changes for style and clarity. However, to accommodate various
electronic media through which a debt collector could send original-
creditor information under proposed Sec. 1006.42, proposed Sec.
1006.38(c) would interpret FDCPA section 809(b) to require debt
collectors to ``provide,'' rather than to ``mail,'' original-creditor
information to consumers in a manner consistent with the delivery
provisions in proposed Sec. 1006.42. As described above, the Bureau
proposes this interpretation to harmonize FDCPA section 809(b)'s
writing requirement with the E-SIGN Act. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.38(c) and on whether to clarify further how to
interpret proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.38(c) and 1006.42 together.
38(d) Disputes
38(d)(1) Failure To Dispute
FDCPA section 809(c) provides that a consumer's failure to dispute
a debt may not be construed by any court as an admission of liability
by the consumer.\533\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(1) would implement
FDCPA section 809(c) and generally restates the statute, with only
minor changes for style.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\533\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
38(d)(2) Response to Disputes
FDCPA section 809(b) provides that, if a consumer disputes a debt
in writing within 30 days of receiving the validation information or
notice described in section 809(a), the debt collector must cease
collection of the debt, or any disputed portion of the debt, until the
debt collector obtains verification of the debt or a copy of a judgment
and mails it to the consumer.\534\ Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d) would
implement and interpret this requirement as follows.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\534\ 15 U.S.C. 1692g(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
38(d)(2)(i)
Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) would implement FDCPA section
809(b)'s general requirements regarding disputes and verification.
Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) generally mirrors the statute, with
minor changes for style and clarity. However, to accommodate various
electronic media through which a debt collector could send a copy of
verification or a judgment under proposed Sec. 1006.42, proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(i) would interpret FDCPA section 809(b) to require debt
collectors to ``provide,'' rather than to ``mail,'' such information to
consumers in a manner consistent with the delivery provisions in
proposed Sec. 1006.42. As described above, the Bureau proposes this
interpretation to harmonize FDCPA section 809(b)'s writing requirement
with the E-SIGN Act. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(i) and on whether to clarify further how to interpret
proposed Sec. Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) and 1006.42 together. The Bureau
also requests comment on whether to clarify that a debt collector who
ceases collection of a debt in response to a consumer's written dispute
may communicate with the consumer one additional time to inform the
consumer that the debt collector is ceasing collection of the
debt.\535\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\535\ Such a clarification would be consistent with the FTC's
position in its October 5, 2007 advisory opinion regarding the same
topic. See Fed. Trade Comm'n, Advisory Opinion to ACA International
(Oct. 5, 2007), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_statements/debt-collector-informing-consumer-who-has-disputed-debt-its-collection-efforts-have-ceased-would-not./p064803fairdebt.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
38(d)(2)(ii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii) would establish an alternative way
for debt collectors to respond to disputes that they reasonably
conclude are duplicative disputes, as that term is defined in proposed
Sec. 1006.38(a)(1).
Some members of the debt collection industry have described being
overwhelmed by the number of repeat disputes they receive. In response
to the Bureau's ANPRM, some industry commenters estimated that between
10 and 20 percent of consumer disputes reiterate, without providing any
new supporting information, earlier disputes to which debt collectors
have already responded.\536\ An industry commenter also estimated that,
for medical debts, the percentage of repeat disputes may be as high as
50 or 60 percent of all disputes. Members of the debt collection
industry have also expressed uncertainty about how FDCPA section
809(b)--which, as discussed above, requires a debt collector who
receives a written dispute within the validation period to cease
collecting the debt, or any disputed portion of the debt, until it
provides the consumer with a copy either of verification of the debt or
of a judgment--applies to repeat disputes. This uncertainty may drive
up costs for debt collectors and harm consumers. Some debt collectors,
for example, may spend time and resources re-investigating identical
disputes and resending identical verification before continuing with
collections. This may leave debt collectors with fewer resources to
investigate and respond to non-repeat disputes. It may also impede the
collection of legitimate debts.\537\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\536\ These figures appear to include both repeat disputes filed
within the 30-day validation period and repeat disputes filed
outside of the 30-day validation period. As noted in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.38(a)(1), the definition of
duplicative disputes would include only disputes filed within the
validation period. As also noted in that section-by-section
analysis, the Bureau requests comment on the percentage of repeat
disputes that would qualify as duplicative disputes under the
proposed definition of duplicative dispute.
\537\ See, e.g., Hawkins-El v. First Am. Funding, LLC, 891 F.
Supp. 2d 402, 410 (E.D.N.Y. 2012) (``Plaintiff cannot forestall
collection efforts by repeating the same unsubstantiated assertions
and thereby contend that the debt is `disputed.' If Plaintiff were
permitted to do so, debtors would be able to prevent collection
permanently by sending letters, regardless of their merit, stating
that the debt is in dispute. Such a result is untenable, as it would
make debts effectively uncollectable.''); Derisme v. Hunt Leibert
Jacobson P.C., 880 F. Supp. 2d 339, 370-71 (D. Conn. 2012) (``To
allow a consumer to [repeatedly dispute a debt and repeatedly
receive verification] would lead to the illogical result that a
consumer could avoid paying its debt by repeatedly disputing the
debt.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The challenges that repeat disputes can pose to industry and
consumers are not unique to the debt collection market, and the Bureau
has clarified the treatment of repeat disputes in other contexts. Under
Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.35(g)(1)(i), for example, a mortgage servicer
is not required to comply with certain error resolution requirements
when the asserted error is substantially the same as an error
previously asserted by the borrower for which the servicer has
previously complied with its obligations under the rule, unless the
borrower provides new and material information to support the notice of
error. Similarly, under Regulation V, 12 CFR 1022.43(f)(1)(ii), a
furnisher of information to a consumer reporting
[[Page 23355]]
agency is not required to investigate a direct dispute if the dispute
is substantially the same as a previous dispute with respect to which
the furnisher has already satisfied the applicable reinvestigation
requirements, unless the dispute includes certain information not
previously provided to the furnisher. Just as the Bureau's regulations
outline a process for responding to repeat disputes in the mortgage
servicing and credit reporting context, the Bureau proposes to outline
a process pursuant to which debt collectors may respond to duplicative
disputes in a less burdensome way.
Consumers may submit repeat disputes for various reasons. Some may
do so to avoid paying debts they owe or because they disagree with the
outcome of the earlier dispute. Others may do so because they are
unfamiliar with the dispute process. For example, some consumers who
submit repeat disputes may not know that they can include supporting
documentation with their disputes. Knowing if and why debt collectors
might regard a dispute as duplicative may help consumers prepare
clearer, more specific disputes. Those disputes, in turn, could improve
the accuracy of the information in the debt collection system and help
to ensure that debt collectors collect the right amounts from the right
consumers. This could be achieved, for example, through a consumer
notice requirement.
Other Bureau rules that address repeat disputes contain consumer
notice provisions. Under Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.35(g)(2), for
example, a mortgage servicer who determines that a notice of error is
substantially the same as an error previously asserted by the borrower
for which the servicer has previously complied with its error
resolution obligations under the rule must notify the borrower of its
determination and provide the basis for that determination. Similarly,
under Regulation V, 12 CFR 1022.43(f)(2), a furnisher who determines
that a direct dispute is substantially the same as a previous dispute
for which the furnisher has already satisfied the applicable
reinvestigation requirements must notify the consumer of its
determination, provide the reasons for that determination, and identify
any information required to investigate the disputed information.
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii) would provide
that, upon receipt of a duplicative dispute, as defined in Sec.
1006.38(a)(1), a debt collector must cease collection of the debt, or
any disputed portion of the debt, until the debt collector either:
Notifies the consumer in writing or electronically in a manner
permitted by Sec. 1006.42 that the dispute is duplicative, provides a
brief statement of the reasons for the determination, and refers the
consumer to the debt collector's response to the earlier dispute; or
satisfies Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i). The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii) to clarify that debt collectors are not required to
expend resources conducting repetitive dispute investigations unless
there is a reasonable basis for re-opening a prior investigation
because of new and material information.
Proposed comment 38(d)(2)(ii)-1 explains that a debt collector
complies with the requirement to provide a brief statement of the
reasons for its determination that the dispute is duplicative if the
notice states that the dispute is substantially the same as an earlier
dispute submitted by the consumer and the consumer has not included any
new and material information in support of the earlier dispute.
Proposed comment 38(d)(2)(ii)-1 also explains that a debt collector
complies with the requirement to refer the consumer to the debt
collector's response to the earlier dispute if the notice states that
the debt collector responded to the earlier dispute and provides the
date of that response.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii) and
proposed comment 38(d)(2)(ii)-1, including on whether any additional
clarification is needed. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on
how debt collectors currently handle repeat disputes and the costs to
debt collectors of doing so, distinguishing, to the extent possible,
between repeat disputes filed during the validation period and repeat
disputes filed after the validation period. The Bureau also requests
comment on whether, in responding to disputes that would qualify as
duplicative disputes under the proposed rule, debt collectors expect to
use the method in proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) or the method in
proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii), as well as the expected costs and
benefits of using each method. In addition, the Bureau requests comment
on the risks to consumers, if any, posed by proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii).
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii) to implement and
interpret FDCPA section 809(b). In particular, proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii) interprets what it means for a debt collector to
``obtain[ ] verification of the debt or any copy of a judgment'' and to
provide a ``copy of such verification or judgment'' to the consumer
when the debt collector reasonably determines that a dispute is a
duplicative dispute. In circumstances where a consumer submits a timely
written dispute that is duplicative of an earlier dispute for which the
debt collector already obtained and mailed to the consumer a copy of
verification of the debt or a judgment, the Bureau interprets FDCPA
section 809(b)'s requirement to provide a ``copy of such verification
or judgment'' to the consumer to mean that a debt collector must
provide the consumer either with another copy of the materials the debt
collector provided in response to the earlier dispute, or with a notice
explaining the reasons for the debt collector's determination that the
dispute is duplicative and referring the consumer to the materials the
debt collector provided in response to the earlier dispute.
The Bureau also proposes the notice requirement of proposed Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii) pursuant to its authority under Dodd-Frank section
1032(a). As discussed above, Dodd-Frank Act section 1032(a) provides
that the Bureau ``may prescribe rules to ensure that the features of
any consumer financial product or service, both initially and over the
term of the product or service, are fully, accurately, and effectively
disclosed to consumers in a manner that permits consumers to understand
the costs, benefits, and risks associated with the product or service,
in light of the facts and circumstances.'' The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii)'s notice requirement on the basis that a debt
collector's decision to treat a dispute as a duplicative dispute under
proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii) is a feature of debt collection.
Knowing that a debt collector has determined that a dispute is a
duplicative dispute, and the reasons for that determination, may help a
consumer understand the costs, benefits, and risks associated with
filing additional disputes and deciding whether to pay a debt.
Section 1006.42 Providing Required Disclosures
42(a) Providing Required Disclosures
42(a)(1) In General
The proposed rule would require debt collectors to provide certain
disclosures to consumers. Proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would require a
debt collector who provides such required disclosures in writing or
electronically to do so: (1) In a manner that is reasonably expected to
provide actual notice to the consumer, and (2) in a form that the
consumer may keep and access later. The first prong of proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) would not require a debt collector to ensure a consumer's
actual receipt of required
[[Page 23356]]
disclosures; it would require instead a reasonable expectation of
actual notice. The second prong would require a debt collector, when
providing a required disclosure in writing or electronically, to
provide it, for example, in a form that the consumer could print or, in
the case of disclosures provided by hyperlink to a website, in a form
that consumers could access for a reasonable period of time.\538\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\538\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(2)(ii). For ease of reference, throughout the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42, the Bureau uses the
shorthand term ``retainability'' to refer to the consumer's ability
to keep and access a disclosure later.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42-1 explains how a debt collector could comply
with the general delivery standard in the decedent debt context. The
proposed comment provides that, if a debt collector knows or should
know that a consumer is deceased, a person who is authorized to act on
behalf of the deceased consumer's estate operates as the consumer for
purposes of Sec. 1006.42.\539\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\539\ Proposed comment 42-1 is consistent with proposed comments
34(a)(1)-1 and 38-1, which also would clarify delivery standards in
the decedent debt context.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42(a)(1)-1 would clarify that a debt collector who
provides a required disclosure in writing or electronically and who
receives a notice that the disclosure was not delivered has not
provided the disclosure in a manner that is reasonably expected to
provide actual notice under Sec. 1006.42(a)(1).
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would apply only if a debt collector
provides required disclosures in writing or electronically; it would
not apply if a debt collector provides required disclosures orally.
Apart from disclosures that a communication is from a debt collector or
is for a debt collection purpose--which proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(2)
would exclude from the general delivery standard \540\--the Bureau has
not identified widespread instances of debt collectors providing
required disclosures, such as the validation information, orally. In
addition, the Bureau's proposal would require debt collectors to
include more information in validation notices than they may currently
provide, which may further decrease the likelihood that debt collectors
would deliver such disclosures orally. For these reasons, the Bureau's
proposal focuses on clarifying general delivery requirements only for
required disclosures delivered electronically or in writing. The Bureau
requests comment on this approach, including on whether the Bureau
should address oral delivery of required disclosures and, if so, what
standards should apply, including how an oral disclosure could be
provided in a form that the consumer may keep and access later. The
Bureau also requests comment on the frequency with which debt
collectors provide required disclosures orally today and the frequency
with which debt collectors would expect to provide disclosures orally
under the proposed rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\540\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) also would not apply to any non-
required debt collection communications, such as emails that contain
only a request for payment. The Bureau requests comment on proposed
Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) and on proposed comments 42-1 and 42(a)(1)-1,
including on whether any additional clarification is needed as to this
general standard and on its costs to debt collectors and benefits to
consumers. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on the current
practices of debt collectors upon learning that a consumer has not
received a required disclosure--for example, because the disclosure has
been returned as undeliverable--as well as the risks, costs, and
benefits that these practices pose to consumers and industry. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether a delivery method that does not
satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1)'s notice requirement should be
permitted as long as the debt collector confirms that the consumer
received actual notice.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) to implement and interpret
FDCPA section 809(a) and (b) and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors. Under FDCPA section 809(a), a debt collector
must ``send the consumer'' a written validation notice unless the
information is ``contained in the initial communication'' with the
consumer, and under FDCPA section 809(b), a debt collector must ``mail[
] to the consumer'' any original-creditor or verification information
the debt collector provides. The Bureau proposes to require a form of
delivery that is reasonably expected to provide actual notice on the
basis that such a requirement is implicit in the concepts of
``send[ing] the consumer a written notice,'' information being
``contained in'' the initial communication, and ``mail[ing]''
information to the consumer.\541\ Similarly, the Bureau proposes to
require a form of delivery that the consumer may keep and access later
on the basis that such a requirement is also implicit in the concepts
of ``send[ing] the consumer a written notice,'' information being
``contained in'' the initial communication, and ``mail[ing]''
information to the consumer--requirements traditionally satisfied
through sending a paper document but that the Bureau is now adapting to
electronic communications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\541\ There is support for this interpretation in court
decisions. See, e.g., Lavallee v. Med-1 Solutions, LLC, No. 1:15-cv-
01922-DML-WTL, 2017 WL 4340342, at *4 (S.D. Ind. Sept. 29, 2017)
(``[I]f notice is not sent in a manner in which receipt should be
presumed as a matter of logic and common experience, then it cannot
be considered to have been `sent'.''); Johnson v. Midland Credit
Mgmt. Inc., No. 1:05 CV 1094, 2006 WL 2473004, at *12 (N.D. Ohio
Aug. 24, 2006) (``[W]hen a written notice is returned as
undeliverable, it has not actually been sent to the consumer.
Rather, it has been sent to an improper address for the consumer. .
. . If the debt collector knows the validation notice was sent to
the wrong address, the debt collector has not complied with the
plain language of the statute.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau also proposes Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) as an interpretation
of FDCPA section 808's prohibition on using unfair or unconscionable
means to collect a debt. It may be unfair or unconscionable under FDCPA
section 808 for a debt collector to deliver a disclosure using a method
that is not reasonably expected to provide actual notice to the
consumer or that does not allow the consumer to retain the disclosure
and access it later. If debt collectors deliver disclosures in a manner
that does not meet these standards, consumers may not receive required
information or have it available for future reference, potentially
leading them to take different actions with respect to debts than they
otherwise would have. A debt collector's decision to provide a required
disclosure in a manner not reasonably expected to provide actual notice
or in a form that the consumer cannot keep and access later is outside
of a consumer's control; therefore, a consumer cannot reasonably avoid
the injury caused by a debt collector who provides a required
disclosure in such a manner or form. In addition, as noted, providing
required disclosures in a manner not reasonably expected to provide
actual notice or in a form that the consumer cannot keep and access
later could effectively thwart FDCPA section 809's validation notice,
original-creditor, and dispute-verification provisions. Thus, whatever
benefits debt collectors may receive from such conduct do not appear to
be outweighed by the costs to consumers.
42(a)(2) Exceptions
Although proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) generally requires that debt
collectors
[[Page 23357]]
provide required disclosures in a manner reasonably expected to provide
actual notice and in a form consumers can keep and access later,
proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(2) identifies two circumstances in which a
debt collector would not need not to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) in providing required disclosures. The first circumstance
involves the disclosure required by proposed Sec. 1006.6(e); the
second circumstance involves the disclosure required by proposed Sec.
1006.18(e).
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would require a debt collector who
communicates or attempts to communicate with a consumer electronically
using a particular email address, telephone number for text messages,
or other electronic-medium address to include in each such
communication or attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous
statement describing how the consumer can opt out of further electronic
communications or attempts to communicate to that address or telephone
number. Proposed Sec. 1006.18(e) would require a debt collector to
disclose in its initial communication with a consumer that the debt
collector is attempting to collect a debt and that any information
obtained with be used for that purpose, and to disclose in each
subsequent communication that the communication is from a debt
collector.
The disclosures that would be required by proposed Sec. Sec.
1006.6(e) and 1006.18(e) would accompany all electronic debt collection
communications. Thus, absent an exception for these provisions,
proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would apply to all electronic debt
collection communications. This, in turn, would mean that all
electronic debt collection communications effectively would have to
meet the notice and retainability requirements of Sec. 1006.42(a)(1)--
including even relatively routine communications, such as ones that
convey settlement offers, payment requests, scheduling messages, and
other information not required by the FDCPA or Regulation F. The Bureau
believes that requiring all such communications to be provided in a
manner reasonably expected to provide actual notice and in a form
consumers can keep and access later is likely to impose an unnecessary
burden on debt collectors with little corresponding benefit to
consumers.
As discussed above, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) as an
interpretation of certain terms in FDCPA section 809 and pursuant to
FDCPA section 808. Because the disclosures in proposed Sec. Sec.
1006.6(e) and 1006.18(e) do not arise under FDCPA section 809, and
because they may not implicate FDCPA section 808's prohibition on using
unfair or unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any
debt, the Bureau proposes generally to except them from the
requirements of Sec. 1006.42(a)(1). For this reason, proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(2) provides that a debt collector need not comply with Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) when providing the disclosure required by Sec. 1006.6(e)
or Sec. 1006.18(e) in writing or electronically, unless the disclosure
is included on a notice required by Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i) or Sec.
1006.38(c) or (d)(2), or in an electronic communication containing a
hyperlink to such a notice. Any disclosure provided pursuant to
proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) or Sec. 1006.18(e), however, would need to be
provided clearly and conspicuously. This clear-and-conspicuous
requirement would apply even where proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would
not. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(2),
including whether the exceptions identified in proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(2) are underinclusive or overinclusive.
42(b) Requirements for Certain Disclosures Provided Electronically
The FDCPA requires three disclosures to be provided in writing. As
the Bureau proposes to implement them in Regulation F, these
disclosures are: (1) The validation notice described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B); (2) the original-creditor disclosure described in
proposed Sec. 1006.38(c); and (3) the validation-information
disclosure described in proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2).\542\ The Bureau
interprets the FDCPA's writing requirement to permit these disclosures
to be provided electronically.\543\ If provided electronically,
however, they are subject to the E-SIGN Act, the Federal statute that
provides standards for when delivery of a disclosure by electronic
record satisfies a requirement in a statute, regulation, or other rule
of law that the disclosure be provided or made available to a consumer
in writing.\544\ Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b) lists the requirements that
debt collectors would need to follow to satisfy proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) and, relatedly, the E-SIGN Act, when providing these
disclosures electronically. As discussed below, each requirement
described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(b) addresses either the actual
notice or retainability aspect of proposed Sec. 1006.42(a), or both.
Unless otherwise noted, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(b) for the
same reasons and pursuant to the same authority discussed in the
section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\542\ For ease of reference, throughout the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42, the Bureau refers to these three
disclosures as the ``required disclosures.'' The disclosure required
by FDCPA section 807(11) must be in writing only if the debt
collector otherwise is communicating with the consumer in writing.
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(2), the Bureau proposes to exclude FDCPA section 807(11)
written disclosures from meeting the delivery requirements in
proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) unless the disclosures are included on
a notice required by Sec. Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i) or 1006.38(c) or
(d)(2), or in an electronic communication containing a hyperlink to
such a notice.
\543\ See the section-by-section analyses of proposed Sec. Sec.
1006.34 and 1006.38.
\544\ See 15 U.S.C. 7001-7006.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(b), including
on the frequency with which debt collectors currently provide required
disclosures electronically, and the proportion of such disclosures
provided by email, text message, and other electronic means. To the
extent debt collectors do not currently provide required disclosures
electronically, the Bureau requests comment on why that is so. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether to require that debt collectors
who provide required disclosures electronically maintain reasonable
written policies and procedures designed to ensure that debt collectors
comply with the requirements of proposed Sec. 1006.42(b).\545\ Several
Bureau rules include similar policies-and-procedures requirements.\546\
Requiring such policies and procedures may facilitate compliance with
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b) by debt collectors who provide required
disclosures electronically, and may promote effective and efficient
enforcement and supervision by the Bureau and other Federal agencies.
However, requiring such policies and
[[Page 23358]]
procedures could impose costs on debt collectors, which, if passed on
to creditors, could ultimately reduce consumers' access to credit. The
Bureau therefore requests comment on the expected costs and benefits of
requiring debt collectors who provide required disclosures
electronically to maintain reasonable written policies and procedures
designed to comply with the requirements of proposed Sec. 1006.42(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\545\ Such a requirement could be based on the Bureau's
authority under Dodd-Frank Act sections 1022(b)(1) or 1024(b)(7) or
both.
\546\ See, e.g., Regulation E, 12 CFR 1005.33(g) (requiring
remittance transfer providers to ``develop and maintain written
policies and procedures that are designed to ensure compliance with
the error resolution requirements applicable to remittance transfers
under this section''); Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.38(a) (requiring
mortgage servicers to ``maintain policies and procedures that are
reasonably designed to achieve'' certain objectives); Regulation Z,
12 CFR 1026.36(j) (requiring depository institutions to ``establish
and maintain written policies and procedures reasonably designed to
ensure and monitor the compliance of the depository institution, its
employees, its subsidiaries, and its subsidiaries' employees'' with
certain requirements of the rule); id. 1026.51 (requiring card
issuers to ``establish and maintain reasonable written policies and
procedures to consider the consumer's ability to make the required
minimum payments under the terms of the account based on a
consumer's income or assets and a consumer's current obligations'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
42(b)(1)
The proposed rule would provide debt collectors with a choice
between two general options for providing the required disclosures
electronically. The first option would be to comply with the E-SIGN Act
after the consumer provides affirmative consent directly to the debt
collector. The second option would be to comply with the alternative
procedures described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(c). As explained in this
section-by-section analysis (discussing the proposed E-SIGN Act option)
and the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)
(discussing the proposed alternative procedures), a debt collector who
satisfies the requirements of either option has taken necessary but not
sufficient actions to support a finding that the debt collector has
provided the electronic disclosure in a manner that is reasonably
expected to provide actual notice and in a form that the consumer may
keep and access later.\547\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\547\ The debt collector still would need to satisfy the
requirements in proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) through (4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Regarding the E-SIGN Act option, E-SIGN Act section 101(c) sets
forth a detailed process for ensuring the consumer's informed,
affirmative consent before delivering disclosures electronically.\548\
Before a consumer may consent to electronic delivery, the consumer must
receive a clear and conspicuous statement of: (1) The consumer's right
not to consent and to withdraw consent; (2) the scope of the consumer's
consent, including whether it applies only to the particular
transaction which gave rise to the obligation to provide the disclosure
or to identified disclosures that may be provided or made available
during the course of the parties' relationship; (3) the procedures for
withdrawing consent; (4) how the consumer may obtain paper copies of
electronic records; and (5) any hardware and software requirements for
access to and retention of electronic records.\549\ The consumer must
consent electronically, or confirm the consumer's consent
electronically, in a manner that reasonably demonstrates that the
consumer can access information in the electronic form that will be
used to provide the information that is the subject of the
consent.\550\ In light of these requirements, a debt collector who
delivers required disclosures electronically in accordance with E-SIGN
Act section 101(c) (and who satisfies Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) through (4))
may reasonably expect to have provided the consumer with actual notice
in a form that the consumer may keep and access later.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\548\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(c).
\549\ Id.
\550\ Id. Further, after providing consent, if a change in the
hardware or software requirements needed to access or retain
electronic records creates a material risk that the consumer will
not be able to access or retain a subsequent electronic record that
was the subject of the consent, the person providing the electronic
record must provide the consumer with new disclosures and the
consumer must provide new consent. Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed rule would clarify that, to deliver disclosures
electronically in accordance with E-SIGN Act section 101(c), a debt
collector must obtain affirmative consent directly from the consumer.
The Bureau proposes this requirement as an interpretation of E-SIGN Act
section 101(c), pursuant to its authority under E-SIGN Act section
104(b)(1)(A) to interpret the E-SIGN Act through regulations.\551\ E-
SIGN Act section 101(c) permits electronic delivery of required
disclosures if, among other things, the consumer ``has affirmatively
consented to such use and has not withdrawn such consent.'' The E-SIGN
Act does not state that, in the debt collection context, a debt
collector may rely on E-SIGN Act consent provided by the consumer to
the original creditor or person to whom the debt is owed. Rather, the
E-SIGN Act generally limits the consumer's consent to ``records
provided or made available during the course of the parties'
relationship'' or ``only to the particular transaction which gave rise
to the obligation to provide the record.'' \552\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\551\ See 15 U.S.C. 7004(b)(1). The Bureau's proposed
interpretation of E-SIGN Act section 101(c) is ``with respect to''
the FDCPA within the meaning of E-SIGN Act section 104(b). The
proposed interpretation is therefore limited to disclosures required
under Regulation F, which must be provided in the name of and on
behalf of the FDCPA-covered debt collector. The Bureau does not
propose to issue an interpretation applicable to disclosures
required by other statutes or regulations, including where third
parties may provide disclosures in the name of or on behalf of the
creditor.
\552\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(c)(1)(B)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the debt collection context, the Bureau interprets ``the
parties' relationship'' to exclude a debt collector with whom the
creditor may eventually place the account, because the consumer and the
debt collector typically have no relationship at the time the consumer
provides E-SIGN Act consent to the creditor. Indeed, the consumer
likely does not know the identity of the debt collector the creditor
may hire, and the creditor may not know either. In the debt collection
context, the Bureau also interprets ``only the particular transaction
which gave rise to the obligation to provide the record'' to exclude
interactions between the consumer and the debt collector with whom the
creditor may eventually place the account. The statute uses the word
``only'' before referring to ``the particular transaction,'' suggesting
that the relevant transaction is limited and occurs within the confines
of the ``parties' relationship.'' Accordingly, the Bureau does not
propose to interpret a consumer's affirmative consent to receive
electronic disclosures from a creditor under the E-SIGN Act as
affirmative consent to receive electronic disclosures from a debt
collector under the E-SIGN Act. Instead, the Bureau proposes to
interpret E-SIGN Act section 101(c) to require that a consumer's
consent be given directly to the debt collector. The Bureau's proposed
interpretation is consistent with several FDCPA provisions pertaining
to consumer consent for certain debt collection communications,\553\ as
well as the ANPRM comments of several industry participants and
consumer advocates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\553\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692c(a) (permitting certain communications
with ``the prior consent of the consumer given directly to the debt
collector''); 15 U.S.C. 1692c(b) (same).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) would, except as
provided in Sec. 1006.42(c), require a debt collector to provide the
required disclosures in accordance with section 101(c) of the E-SIGN
Act after the consumer provides affirmative consent directly to the
debt collector. The Bureau proposes to codify this interpretation of
the E-SIGN Act in comment 42(b)(1)-1. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) and on proposed comment 42(b)(1)-1,
including on the extent to which debt collectors currently obtain E-
SIGN Act consent directly from the consumer. If debt collectors
currently do not obtain such consent, the Bureau requests comment on
the reasons why not and on any specific circumstances in which debt
collectors rely instead upon consent the consumer originally provided
to the creditor under the E-SIGN Act. The Bureau also requests comment
on whether to permit such reliance, or transfer of consent, in
[[Page 23359]]
certain specific circumstances and, if so, what those circumstances
should be.
42(b)(2)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) provides that, to comply with Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) when providing the required disclosures electronically, a
debt collector also must identify the purpose of the communication.
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) seeks to increase the likelihood that a
consumer who receives an electronic debt collection disclosure can
distinguish the communication from junk mail or ``spam.'' \554\ Reports
estimate that over 200 billion emails are sent and received worldwide
each day \555\ and that spam accounts for over half of all email
traffic.\556\ Given the volume of information, including spam,
transmitted by email, the likelihood that consumers will receive actual
notice of emailed debt collection disclosures may depend, in part, on
their ability to distinguish between the debt collector's communication
transmitting the disclosure and spam.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\554\ The term ``spam'' generally refers to unsolicited
commercial email. See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 7701(a)(2) (finding, in
connection with CAN-SPAM Act of 2003, that ``[t]he convenience and
efficiency of electronic mail are threatened by the extremely rapid
growth in the volume of unsolicited commercial electronic mail.'').
\555\ Radicati Grp., Inc., Email Statistics Report, 2015-19,
Executive Summary, at 3-4 (Mar. 2015), https://www.radicati.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Email-Statistics-Report-2015-2019-Executive-Summary.pdf.
\556\ Symantec, internet Security Threat Report, at 24 (Apr.
2017), https://www.symantec.com/content/dam/symantec/docs/reports/istr-22-2017-en.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to one recent study, the two most important factors in a
consumer's decision to open an email are whether the consumer
recognizes the sender and whether the email includes a relevant subject
line.\557\ At the outset of collections, a consumer may not recognize
the name of a debt collector who sends an email or text message. The
subject line of an email, or the first line of a text message, may
therefore be an especially important means of alerting consumers to
important debt collection communications. To address the spam problem,
many email providers and third parties have developed sophisticated
filters to help consumers identify and segregate potential spam
messages.\558\ There may be a risk that such filters will erroneously
identify a legitimate debt collection communication as spam. Using a
specific, informative subject line may decrease that risk.\559\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\557\ Direct Mktg. Ass'n, Consumer Email Tracker 2017, at 18
(2017),https://dma.org.uk/uploads/misc/5a1583ff3301a-consumer-email-tracking-report-2017-(2)_5a1583ff32f65.pdf.
\558\ See, e.g., Todd Jackson, How Our Spam Filter Works,
Official Gmail Blog (Oct. 31, 2007), https://gmail.googleblog.com/2007/10/how-our-spam-filter-works.html.
\559\ See, e.g., IBM, Which keywords or characters can trigger
spam filters?, IBM Knowledge Ctr., https://www.ibm.com/support/knowledgecenter/en/SSWU4L/Email/imc_Email/List_of_Keywords-Characters_Which_Can_Tr190.html (last visited May 6, 2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) would require a
debt collector to identify the purpose of the communication by
including, in the subject line of an email or in the first line of a
text message transmitting the required disclosure, the name of the
creditor to whom the debt currently is owed or allegedly is owed and
one additional piece of information identifying the debt, other than
the amount. Including limited but relevant information about the
creditor and the debt in the subject line of an email, or in the first
line of a text message, may improve a consumer's ability to distinguish
the communication from spam or junk, and therefore may increase the
likelihood that the consumer will receive actual notice within the
meaning of proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1).\560\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\560\ As explained in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1), (c)(1), and (e)(2), the email or text
message can only be sent to an email address or telephone number
that satisfies certain criteria. Those criteria are designed to
ensure that the email address or telephone number is one the
consumer actually used, thereby limiting privacy concerns.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the amount of the debt may change over time as interest and
fees accrue, including the current amount of the debt in the subject
line of an email or the first line of a text message, without further
itemization, may not help the consumer recognize a debt that belongs to
the consumer or that the communication pertains to debt collection.
Proposed comment 42(b)(2)-1 provides examples of information
identifying the debt, other than the amount, that a debt collector
could use to comply with proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2). These include a
truncated account number, the name of the original creditor, the name
of any store brand associated with the debt, the date of sale of a
product or service giving rise to the debt, the physical address of
service, and the billing address on the account.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) and on
proposed comment 42(b)(2)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on the risk that an email provider's spam filter may prevent a debt
collector's email from reaching a consumer's inbox, including on
whether any particular words or phrases in the subject line of an email
are likely to cause a spam filter to identify a legitimate debt
collection communication as spam and on whether debt collectors should
be required to take any other steps to decrease the likelihood that an
email will be filtered as spam. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether any particular words or phrases in the subject line of an email
or in the first line of a text message are likely to help consumers
distinguish between spam and debt collection communications. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on the risks to consumers, if
any, of including the name of the creditor to whom the debt is owed, a
truncated account number, the date of sale of a product or service
giving rise to the debt, the physical address of service, the billing
address, or any other particular item of information in the subject
line of an email or in the first line of a text message. The Bureau
also requests comment on how consumers handle emails marked as spam,
including on the frequency with which consumers review their spam
folders to identify emails they should read, and the extent to which
major email providers delete unread emails in spam folders.
42(b)(3)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(3) describes a third requirement that a
debt collector would need to satisfy to comply with proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) when providing the required disclosures electronically.
Just as a debt collector who sends a paper letter by postal mail may
receive notice that the letter was undeliverable, a debt collector who
sends an email or a text message may receive notice from a
communications carrier that the email or text message was
undeliverable. This notice often takes the form of an automated
message. Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(3) would require a debt collector to
permit receipt of notifications of undeliverability from communications
providers, monitor for any such notifications, and treat any such
notifications as precluding a reasonable expectation of actual notice
for that delivery attempt.
The Bureau proposes this requirement because it appears
unreasonable for a debt collector to expect that a consumer has actual
notice of an electronic disclosure if that disclosure has been returned
as undelivered. There is support for this interpretation in court
decisions. For example, in a similar context, courts have held that a
paper validation notice sent to the consumer by postal mail but
returned to the debt collector as undeliverable was not actually sent
to the consumer within the
[[Page 23360]]
meaning of FDCPA section 809(a).\561\ The Bureau requests comment on
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(3), including on how a debt collector who
attempts to deliver a required disclosure electronically may become
aware that the disclosure has not been delivered. The Bureau also
requests comment on whether debt collectors should be required to take
any steps in addition to those described in proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\561\ See, e.g., Johnson v. Midland Credit Mgmt. Inc., No. 1:05
CV 1094, 2006 WL 2473004, at *12-13 (N.D. Ohio Aug. 24, 2006)
(``[W]hen a written notice is returned as undeliverable, it has not
actually been sent to the consumer. Rather, it has been sent to an
improper address for the consumer. . . . If the debt collector knows
the validation notice was sent to the wrong address, the debt
collector has not complied with the plain language of the
statute.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
42(b)(4)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4) describes an additional step that a
debt collector must take to comply with proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1).
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4) would apply only when a debt collector
provides electronically the validation notice described in proposed
Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B). Proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4) seeks to ensure
that debt collectors provide the validation notice in a format that is
compatible with the range of commercially available electronic devices
a consumer may use to view the disclosure.
According to recent research, smartphone ownership has doubled
since 2011, and today a larger share of consumers own a smartphone (77
percent) than a desktop or laptop computer (73 percent).\562\ In
addition, roughly half of all consumers own a tablet computer.\563\ As
a result, consumers may view disclosures on a variety of screen sizes.
A disclosure that automatically adjusts to the size of the consumer's
screen is sometimes called a ``responsive'' disclosure. If a consumer
views a disclosure using a device to which the disclosure is not
responsive, the disclosure may appear in small text with truncated
margins; in some cases, the disclosure may be difficult for the
consumer to read and navigate. In addition, some research suggests that
mobile-friendly design may improve consumer attention to digital
information.\564\ Consistent with these considerations, the Bureau's
2016 final rule concerning prepaid accounts under Regulations E and Z
(2016 Prepaid Final Rule) requires financial institutions to provide
electronic disclosures required by that rule in a form that is
responsive to different screen sizes.\565\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\562\ internet & Tech, Mobile Fact Sheet, Pew Res. Ctr. (Feb. 5,
2018), http://www.pewinternet.org/fact-sheet/mobile.
\563\ Id.
\564\ For example, a 2014 marketing study found that optimizing
email messages to be read on a variety of devices boosted the rate
at which consumers clicked on hyperlinks. See Lauren Smith, The
Science of Email Clicks: The Impact of Responsive Design & Inbox
Testing, Litmus (Dec. 8, 2014), https://litmus.com/blog/the-science-of-email-clicks-the-impact-of-responsive-design-inbox-testing.
\565\ 12 CFR 1005.18(b)(6)(i)(B); comment 18(b)(6)(i)(B)-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given the prevalence of mobile technology, it may be unreasonable
for a debt collector to expect that a consumer has actual notice of an
electronic disclosure that does not adjust to the screen size of the
consumer's mobile device. On smaller screens, such a disclosure may be
illegible if viewed in its entirety. As a result, some information may
be lost to consumers. This may be especially true as to disclosures,
such as the validation notice described in proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), with formatting elements meant to draw a
consumer's attention to particularly important information when the
entirety of the disclosure is in view. For example, the validation
notice's presentation of information in a tabular format could be lost
to consumers using mobile devices if the validation notice is not in a
responsive format viewable on smaller screens.
In addition, graphical representations of textual content generally
cannot be accessed by assistive technology used by the blind and
visually impaired, such as screen readers. Providing electronically-
delivered disclosures in machine-readable text may help ensure that
consumers who use screen readers can access the information. Thus,
unless a debt collector knows that a consumer does not use a screen
reader, it also may be unreasonable for a debt collector to expect that
a consumer has actual notice of an electronic disclosure that is not
machine readable. The Bureau's 2016 Prepaid Final Rule requires
financial institutions to provide electronic disclosures required by
that rule using machine-readable text that is accessible on screen
readers.\566\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\566\ 12 CFR 1005.18(b)(6)(i)(B); comment 18(b)(6)(i)(B)-3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To address concerns about readability on mobile devices and
accessibility for persons with disabilities, proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(4) would require a debt collector who provides
electronically the validation notice described in Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B) to do so in a responsive format that is reasonably
expected to be accessible on a screen of any commercially available
size and via commercially available screen readers.\567\ Proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(4) would apply only to the validation notice described in
proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B). It would not apply to the original-
creditor disclosure described in proposed Sec. 1006.38(c) because that
disclosure typically is brief and does not feature standardized
information or formatting. It also would not apply to the verification
disclosures described in proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2). Those
disclosures may include images of original paper documents, and it does
not appear that commercially available file formats for delivering
images electronically could comply with proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4).
It may therefore be impractical to require debt collectors to provide
the verification disclosures in accordance with proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\567\ In connection with this proposal, the Bureau intends to
make available on its website the source code for a version of the
validation notice that would comply with proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(4). Based on its own feasibility testing of a mail merge
process, the Bureau believes that the burden on debt collectors of
populating an email based on this source code with transaction data
may be low.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42(b)(4)-1 provides examples of how to satisfy
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4). The comment explains that a debt
collector provides the validation notice in a responsive format
accessible on a screen of any commercially available size if, for
example, the notice adjusts to different screen sizes by stacking
elements in a manner that accommodates consumer viewing on smaller
screens while still meeting the other applicable formatting
requirements in proposed Sec. 1006.34. It also explains that a debt
collector provides the validation notice in a manner accessible via
commercially available screen readers if, for example, the validation
notice is machine readable.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4) and on
proposed comment 42(b)(4)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on the cost to debt collectors of developing and using a validation
notice that is responsive to screen size and accessible via screen
readers, including the one-time costs of designing such a disclosure
and the ongoing costs of populating such a disclosure with information
about individual debts. The Bureau also requests comment on how those
costs might change if the Bureau provides debt collectors with source
code for a version of the validation notice that would comply with
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(4). In addition, the Bureau requests comment
on whether the original-creditor disclosure described in
[[Page 23361]]
proposed Sec. 1006.38(c) and the validation-information disclosure
described in proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2) should be subject to proposed
Sec. 1006.42(b)(4).
42(c) Alternative Procedures for Providing Certain Disclosures
Electronically
Under proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1), a debt collector who provides
the required disclosures electronically must, except as provided in
Sec. 1006.42(c), comply with section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act as
interpreted by the Bureau in the proposed rule. Proposed Sec.
1006.42(c) would allow for electronic delivery of the required
disclosures outside of the E-SIGN Act's consent process. The Bureau
proposes this alternative because debt collectors and consumers may
benefit from greater flexibility as to electronic disclosures.
According to industry commenters to the Bureau's ANPRM and to the
small entity representatives who participated in the SBREFA process, it
is often infeasible for debt collectors to send electronic disclosures
for two reasons. First, debt collectors are concerned about violating
FDCPA section 805(b)'s limitations on third-party communications when
they engage in electronic communications with consumers, an issue the
Bureau proposes to address in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3).\568\ Second, the
process for obtaining E-SIGN Act consent is particularly cumbersome in
the debt collection context, where consumers and debt collectors
typically lack a pre-existing relationship.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\568\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The process for obtaining consumer consent under the E-SIGN Act may
impose a substantial burden on electronic commerce in the unique
context of debt collection. Most communication between debt collectors
and consumers continues to take place by telephone and postal mail,
neither of which is well-suited to obtaining E-SIGN Act consent.
Section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act requires that the consumer receive
certain disclosures before consenting to electronic delivery. These
disclosures may be more than 1,000 words long and, although a debt
collector could provide them over the telephone, they could take a
considerable amount of time to recite to the consumer. Moreover, on a
telephone call, it may be challenging for a consumer to ``reasonably
demonstrate[ ]'' the ability to ``access information in the electronic
form that will be used to provide the information that is the subject
of the consent,'' as required by E-SIGN Act section
101(c)(1)(C)(ii).\569\ Similarly, although a debt collector could
provide E-SIGN disclosures by postal mail, it is not clear how a
consumer could, by postal mail, ``reasonably demonstrate'' the ability
to access electronic information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\569\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thus, even if a debt collector incorporates some elements of the E-
SIGN Act consent process into an initial telephone or postal mail
communication, the debt collector likely still must rely on the
consumer to take the further step of demonstrating the ability to
access electronic information. A debt collector may be uncertain
whether and when the consumer will take this further step. Such
uncertainty may be particularly challenging in connection with
delivering the validation notice. Under FDCPA section 809(a) and
proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), the debt collector must send the
validation notice within five days of the debt collector's initial
communication with the consumer, leaving little time for the debt
collector to arrange an alternative delivery method if the consumer
does not complete the E-SIGN Act consent process soon after receiving
the initial communication. While a debt collector could, by
introductory letter, ask the consumer to complete the entire E-SIGN Act
consent process online, a consumer may be unlikely to respond quickly
to such a request from a debt collector with whom the consumer lacks a
prior relationship.
Further, it may not be effective for debt collectors to adopt the
practice that creditors often use of sending emails or text messages
with hyperlinks directing consumers to websites requesting E-SIGN Act
consent. Even if the creditor previously identified the debt collector
for the consumer,\570\ the debt collector would need to send the
validation notice within five days of the initial communication, again
leaving little time for the debt collector to arrange an alternate
delivery method if the consumer does not consent to electronic delivery
quickly.\571\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\570\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3).
\571\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(1), the Bureau proposes to interpret the
E-SIGN Act to require consent to be provided directly from the
consumer to the debt collector.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau is not aware of instances in which a debt collector has
delivered a validation notice electronically pursuant to E-SIGN Act
consent provided directly to the debt collector. Industry commenters to
the Bureau's ANPRM generally stated that debt collectors do not send
validation notices electronically. Similarly, a consumer advocate
commenter stated that a survey of its members did not find any evidence
that debt collectors currently deliver validation notices
electronically. However, the consumer advocate commenter also stated
that, given the consent requirements of the E-SIGN Act and the timing
requirements of the FDCPA, it is conceivable that electronic delivery
of validation notices could occur under current law. More recently, the
consumer advocate commenter noted that several debt collectors may be
delivering validation notices electronically.\572\ However, it is
unclear how widespread this practice is and whether it involves
consumer consent provided directly to the debt collector.\573\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\572\ Similarly, an association of State regulators stated that
many technologically sophisticated debt collectors provided
disclosures electronically, but it did not provide further details.
\573\ Direct consent may be easier to obtain for required
disclosures other than the validation notice. For example, in
response to the ANPRM, one industry trade association reported that
20 percent of members that responded to a survey delivered
verification materials by email and fax. However, this commenter did
not identify the proportion sent by email, and it did not indicate
whether these debt collectors obtained E-SIGN Act consent directly
from the consumer before doing so. Another industry trade
association commenting on the ANPRM stated that electronic delivery
of verification materials occurs rarely.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(c), which
describes procedures a debt collector may use to provide the required
disclosures electronically without the need to comply with section
101(c) of the E-SIGN Act. As discussed below, proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(1) would require a debt collector to send an electronic
communication to a particular email address or, in the case of a text
message, a particular telephone number. Proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)
would provide two methods from which debt collectors could choose for
placing a required disclosure in such an electronic communication. A
debt collector who follows the procedures described in proposed Sec.
1006.42(c) would satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1)'s requirement to
provide the required disclosures in a manner that is reasonably
expected to provide actual notice and in a form that the consumer may
keep and access later, provided that the debt collector also satisfies
proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2) through (4).
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(c) pursuant to its authority,
under section 104(d)(1) of the E-SIGN Act, to exempt a specified
category or type of record from the requirements relating to
[[Page 23362]]
consent in section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act if such exemption is
necessary to eliminate a substantial burden on electronic commerce and
will not increase the material risk of harm to consumers.\574\ The
Bureau proposes the exemption on the basis that requiring debt
collectors to comply with the consent requirements in section 101(c) E-
SIGN Act may impose a substantial burden on electronic commerce by
potentially reducing opportunities for consumers and debt collectors to
communicate and resolve debts more quickly; for consumers to submit
disputes more easily; and for consumers to make online payments in
response to notices delivered electronically. Further, as discussed in
part VI, the Bureau estimates that as many as 140 million validation
notices are sent annually, almost all by postal mail. As also discussed
in part VI, electronic delivery costs may be substantially lower than
the costs of printing disclosures and delivering them by postal
mail.\575\ Given the number of validation notices sent annually, and
the unique challenges in the debt collection context of obtaining E-
SIGN Act consent to receive them electronically, these printing and
mailing costs also may impose a substantial burden on the debt
collection industry, which may, in turn, result in increased cost and
decreased availability of credit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\574\ 15 U.S.C. 7004(d)(1).
\575\ As discussed in part VI, the Bureau estimates that it
costs between $0.50 and $0.80 to send a validation notice by postal
mail, whereas the marginal cost of sending a validation notice
electronically is approximately zero.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The procedures described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(c) are designed
so as not to increase the material risk of harm to consumers. Consumers
are exposed to a materially increased risk of harm when electronic
delivery of the required disclosures by the alternative method would
make consumers less likely to receive, identify, open, read, or
understand the disclosures, or would increase the likelihood of an
unintended third-party disclosure. Pursuant to its E-SIGN Act exemption
authority, the Bureau designed each component of proposed Sec.
1006.42(c) to prevent an increase in these risks. For example, as
discussed below, the procedures in proposed Sec. 1006.42(c) are
designed to help ensure that, among other things, the email address or
telephone number to which a debt collector sends a required disclosure
or a hyperlink to such a disclosure belongs to the consumer; the
consumer is prepared to receive electronic disclosures at that email
address or telephone number; the consumer is prepared to view required
disclosures electronically, including when provided on a website; and
the consumer can retain electronic disclosures.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(c), including
on whether the requirements relating to consent in section 101(c) of
the E-SIGN Act--including as the Bureau proposes to interpret them--
impose a substantial burden on electronic commerce in the debt
collection context, and on whether proposed Sec. 1006.42(c) is
necessary and sufficient to eliminate those burdens. With respect to
possible burdens on electronic commerce, the Bureau requests
information on the costs of delivering required disclosures
electronically, how those costs compare to delivering required
disclosures on paper, and the broader impacts of increased electronic
delivery in the debt collection context. The Bureau also requests
comment on whether the procedures described in proposed Sec.
1006.42(c) increase the material risk of harm to consumers and, if so,
any adjustments that can be made to mitigate that risk.
42(c)(1)
To help ensure that a consumer receives a required disclosure
provided electronically when a debt collector uses the alternative
procedures, proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(1) would require a debt collector
to provide the disclosure by sending an electronic communication to an
email address or, in the case of a text message, a telephone number
that the creditor or a prior debt collector could have used to provide
electronic disclosures related to that debt in accordance with section
101(c) of the E-SIGN Act. This may include, for example, an email
address or telephone number covered by the consumer's unwithdrawn E-
SIGN Act consent provided directly to the creditor or a prior debt
collector. The Bureau proposes to exercise its E-SIGN Act exemption
authority to limit the email addresses and telephone numbers to which a
debt collector may send required disclosures under proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(1) on the basis that, if a consumer has not provided
unwithdrawn E-SIGN Act consent for a particular email address or
telephone number to the creditor or a prior debt collector, a new debt
collector should not presume that the consumer is able or prepared to
receive electronic disclosures at that email address or telephone
number.
Proposed comment 42(c)(1)-1 would clarify that, if a consumer has
opted out of debt collection communications to a particular email
address or telephone number by, for example, following instructions
provided pursuant to Sec. 1006.6(e), then a debt collector cannot use
that email address or telephone number to deliver disclosures under
Sec. 1006.42(c). This would be the case even if the consumer provided
unwithdrawn E-SIGN Act consent allowing the creditor or an earlier debt
collector to use that email address or telephone number.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(1) and on
proposed comment 42(c)(1)-1, including on the risks and benefits of
allowing debt collectors to use an email address or telephone number
with respect to which the consumer provided to the creditor or a prior
debt collector unwithdrawn E-SIGN Act consent related to the debt. The
Bureau also requests comment on how often creditors obtain E-SIGN Act
consent from consumers and how often consumers withdraw any such
consent.
42(c)(2)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2) would provide two methods from which
debt collectors could choose for placing a required disclosure in an
electronic communication. The first method, described in proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(2)(i), would be to place the disclosure in the body of an
email. The second method, described in proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(2)(ii), would be to place the disclosure on a secure website
that is accessible by clicking on a hyperlink included within an
electronic communication, provided certain other conditions are met.
42(c)(2)(i)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(i) would allow a debt collector to
place the disclosure in the body of an email sent to an email address
described in Sec. 1006.42(c)(1). Proposed comment 42(c)(2)(i)-1 would
clarify that a debt collector places a disclosure in the body of an
email if the disclosure's content is viewable within the email itself.
Some pre-proposal feedback suggested that creditors rarely provide
required disclosures within the body of an email if those disclosures
include transaction-specific information. This may be because email has
not traditionally been viewed as a secure form of communication. It may
also be because creditors prefer to provide required disclosures in a
PDF or similar format. On the other hand, many creditors now send email
alerts to consumers, and these alerts often include transaction-
specific information. In addition, the use of technology that protects
[[Page 23363]]
consumer privacy by encrypting emails while in transit appears to be
increasing.\576\ For these reasons, providing a disclosure in the body
of an email may pose no more risk of third-party interception than
delivery by mail.\577\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\576\ For example, at least one major email provider reports
that a growing number of email providers encrypt messages sent to
and from their services using Transport Layer Security encryption,
and that use of ``in transit'' encryption continues to increase. See
Google, Email Encryption in Transit, Google Transparency Rep.,
https://transparencyreport.google.com/safer-email/overview (last
visited May 6, 2019).
\577\ In pre-proposal feedback, several industry stakeholders
and a small entity representative who participated in the SBREFA
process requested that the Bureau clarify how to deliver required
disclosures by text message. As described in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii), the Bureau's proposal
would, subject to certain conditions, permit a debt collector to use
a text message to deliver a hyperlink to a disclosure placed on a
secure website.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(i) and
on proposed comment 42(c)(2)(i)-1, including on the risks and benefits
of allowing a debt collector to place a required disclosure in the body
of an email without first providing the consumer with notice and an
opportunity to opt out. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on
whether creditors or debt collectors currently provide required
disclosures bearing transaction-specific information in the body of
emails and, if not, the reasons why not. The Bureau also requests
comment on the prevalence of ``in-transit'' encryption technology and
whether that technology has reduced any concerns about the security of
emails. The Bureau also requests comment on the prevalence of
technology that would allow a consumer to save or print a text message.
42(c)(2)(ii)
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii) provides that, in lieu of placing
a disclosure in the body of an email, a debt collector who is
delivering a required disclosure electronically pursuant to the
alternative procedures may place the disclosure on a secure website
that is accessible by clicking on a clear and conspicuous hyperlink
included within an electronic communication sent to an email address or
a telephone number described in Sec. 1006.42(c)(1). However, this
method would be available only if three additional conditions,
described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii)(A) through (C), are
satisfied.
First, proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii)(A) would require that the
disclosure be accessible on the website for a reasonable period of time
and be capable of being saved or printed. The Bureau proposes these
requirements because a disclosure that is only briefly accessible, like
a disclosure that cannot be saved or printed, may be unlikely to
provide notice in a form the consumer can keep and access later.
Second, proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii)(B) would require that the
consumer receive notice and an opportunity to opt out of hyperlinked
delivery as described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d). Placing a required
disclosure on a secure website and sending the consumer an electronic
communication containing a hyperlink may be more convenient for some
debt collectors than including the required disclosure in the body of
an email. However, because debt collectors and consumers typically lack
a pre-existing relationship, delivering a required disclosure by
hyperlink without first alerting the consumer by separate means may not
be reasonably expected to provide actual notice. Federal agencies have
advised consumers against clicking on hyperlinks provided by unfamiliar
senders.\578\ According to recent reports, some scams have used fake
debt collection emails to lure consumers into clicking on
hyperlinks.\579\ To address these risks, some consumer email services
can be configured to block hyperlinks from unrecognized senders.\580\
Consumers may be likely to follow safe browsing habits and not click on
a hyperlink in an initial communication from an unfamiliar debt
collector.\581\ Therefore, it may be unreasonable for a debt collector
to expect that a consumer has actual notice of an electronic disclosure
delivered by hyperlink if the consumer does not expect to receive a
hyperlinked disclosure from that particular debt collector. Proposed
Sec. 1006.42(d), discussed below, describes consumer notice-and-opt-
out processes meant to ensure that, before a debt collector sends a
required disclosure by hyperlink, the consumer expects to receive it
and does not object to such receipt. By helping the consumer identify
the sender in advance, a notice-and-opt-out process may also reduce the
risk that the consumer will treat an email containing a hyperlink as
spam.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\578\ For example, the FTC advises consumers not to open links
or attachments to emails they do not recognize, in order to prevent
phishing and malware. See Fed. Trade Comm'n, Phishing (July 2017),
https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0003-phishing; Fed. Trade
Comm'n, Malware (Nov. 2015), https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0011-malware. The FDIC offers consumers similar guidance. See Fed.
Deposit Ins. Comm'n, Beware of Malware: Think Before You Click,
https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/consumer/news/cnwin16/malware.html
(last updated Mar. 8, 2016).
\579\ See, e.g., Claer Barrett, Beware Fake Debt Collection
Emails, Says Action Fraud, Fin. Times, Apr. 8, 2016, https://www.ft.com/content/43fdbb30-fce4-11e5-b3f6-11d5706b613b.
\580\ See Microsoft Off. Support, Help Keep Spam and Junk Email
Out of Your Inbox in Outlook.com, Microsoft, https://support.office.com/en-us/article/help-keep-spam-and-junk-email-out-of-your-inbox-in-outlook-com-a3ece97b-82f8-4a5e-9ac3-e92fa6427ae4
(last visited May 6, 2019).
\581\ In comments to the Bureau's ANPRM, a large debt collector
agreed that consumers may view disclosures from unknown collectors
with suspicion, such as when the consumer has not received advance
information about the debt collector from a creditor.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Third, proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii)(C) would require that the
consumer not have opted out during the opt-out period. The Bureau
proposes this requirement because a debt collector may not reasonably
expect that a consumer has actual notice of a hyperlinked disclosure if
the consumer has opted out of receiving disclosures in that manner.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii),
including on the risks and benefits of allowing a debt collector to
place a required disclosure on a secure website accessible by
hyperlink, particularly compared to placing a required disclosure in
the body of an email. The Bureau also requests comment on whether to
clarify further what it means for a hyperlink to be clear and
conspicuous and, if so, what factors may be relevant to determining
whether a hyperlink is clear and conspicuous. In addition, the Bureau
requests comment on whether to clarify further what it means for a
disclosure to remain available on a website for a reasonable time and,
if so, the length of time that should qualify as reasonable. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on the prevalence of anti-virus
software and other technologies that identify whether a hyperlink
included in an email or text message is safe, and whether consumers
using such technologies are likely click on hyperlinks from
unrecognized debt collectors. The Bureau also requests comment on
whether debt collectors who wish to provide required disclosures
electronically would be more likely to do so in the body of an email
under proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(i) or on a secure website that is
accessible by clicking on a hyperlinked included within an electronic
communication under proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii), and the reasons
why.
42(d) Notice and Opportunity To Opt Out of Hyperlinked Delivery
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(d) describes two processes for providing
consumers with notice and an opportunity to opt out of
[[Page 23364]]
hyperlinked delivery of required disclosures, as required by proposed
Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii)(B). A debt collector who wishes to place a
required disclosure on a website that is accessible by clicking on a
hyperlink included within an electronic communication would be required
to choose between these notice-and-opt-out processes. One process,
described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1), would involve a
communication between the debt collector and the consumer before the
required disclosure is provided; the other process, described in
proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2), would involve a communication between the
creditor and the consumer before the required disclosure is provided.
Proposed comment 42(d)-1 would clarify that a debt collector's or a
creditor's communication with a consumer pursuant to Sec.
1006.42(d)(1) or (2), respectively, applies to all disclosures covered
by Sec. 1006.42(a) that the debt collector thereafter sends regarding
that debt, unless the consumer later designates that email address or,
in the case of text messages, that telephone number as unavailable for
the debt collector's use, such as by opting out pursuant to the
instructions required by Sec. 1006.6(e). The Bureau proposes Sec.
1006.42(d) for the same reasons and pursuant to the same authority
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42(c).
42(d)(1) Communication by the Debt Collector
Under proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1), a debt collector must inform
the consumer, in a communication with the consumer before providing the
required disclosure, of the information in proposed Sec.
1006.42(d)(1)(i) through (vi). Proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1)(i) and (ii)
would require the debt collector to inform the consumer of the name of
the consumer who owes or allegedly owes the debt, and the name of the
creditor to whom the debt currently is owed or allegedly owed. The
Bureau proposes to require this information to help the consumer
identify whether the debt belongs to the consumer. Proposed Sec.
1006.42(d)(1)(iii) and (iv) would require the debt collector to inform
the consumer of the email address or telephone number from which and to
which the debt collector intends to send the electronic communication
containing the hyperlink. The Bureau proposes to require this
information to help the consumer ensure that an electronic
communication containing the hyperlink is directed to an appropriate
email address or telephone number, and to help the consumer identify
any such electronic communication once the communication reaches the
consumer's inbox. Finally, proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1)(v) and (vi)
would require the debt collector to inform the consumer of the
consumer's ability to opt out of hyperlinked delivery of disclosures
and to provide instructions for doing so within a reasonable period of
time. The Bureau proposes to require this information to enable the
consumer to choose whether to opt out of hyperlinked electronic
disclosures from the debt collector--a choice the consumer would not
have had the opportunity to make when providing E-SIGN Act consent
originally to the creditor because the consumer likely would not have
known the identity of any future debt collector.\582\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\582\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii), the rule would not permit a debt
collector to deliver required disclosures by hyperlink to a consumer
who opted out of such delivery.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42(d)(1)-1 would clarify that, for purposes of a
debt collector's communication with the consumer under Sec.
1006.42(d)(1), the term ``name of the consumer'' has the same meaning
as the term ``consumer's name'' under Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ii). The
comment also includes a cross-reference to proposed comment
34(c)(2)(ii)-1, which explains that the consumer's name is what the
debt collector reasonably determines is the most complete version of
the name about which the debt collector has knowledge, whether obtained
from the creditor or another source. Proposed comment 42(d)(1)-2 would
clarify that, if a debt collector's communication with the consumer
under Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) applies to multiple debts, Sec.
1006.42(d)(1)(i) and (ii) require the debt collector to identify the
consumer and the creditor for each debt to which the communication
applies.\583\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\583\ As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of
proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(1), proposed comment 42(c)(1)-1 would
clarify that, if a consumer has opted out of communications by the
debt collector to an email address or, in the case of text messages,
a telephone number, then that email address or telephone number
cannot be used to deliver disclosures under Sec. 1006.42(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42(d)(1)-3 would clarify how the requirement to
communicate with the consumer before providing a hyperlinked disclosure
works together with the requirement to provide the consumer a
reasonable period within which to opt out. The comment explains that,
in an oral communication with the consumer, such as a telephone or in-
person conversation, the debt collector may require the consumer to
make an opt-out decision during that same communication; however, a
written or electronic communication that requires the consumer to make
an opt-out decision within a period of five or fewer days does not
satisfy proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1). The Bureau proposes to require a
debt collector to allow a consumer more than five days to make an opt-
out decision in order to grant sufficient time for the consumer to see
and respond to an opt-out notice provided in a written or electronic
communication. Because no more than five days may elapse between an
initial debt collection communication and the time the debt collector
sends the validation notice under FDCPA section 809(a) as implemented
by proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), a debt collector who wishes to
obtain consumer consent to hyperlinked delivery in an initial
communication must do so orally.\584\ Proposed comment 42(d)(1)-4 would
clarify that an opt-out notice provided by a debt collector under Sec.
1006.42(d)(1) may be combined with an opt-out notice provided by the
debt collector under Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\584\ Under proposed Sec. 1006.6(e), the communication
containing the hyperlink would need to include a clear and
conspicuous statement describing one or more ways the consumer can
opt out of further electronic communications or attempts to
communicate by the debt collector to that address or telephone
number. A consumer who no longer wished to receive hyperlinked
delivery of required disclosures could revoke consent by following
the opt-out instructions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) and its
related commentary. In particular, the Bureau requests comment on
whether, to limit the risk of third-party disclosure of the opt-out
notice and to increase the likelihood that a consumer will receive
actual notice of a required disclosure delivered by hyperlink, the rule
should restrict the email addresses or telephone numbers to which a
debt collector may send the opt-out notice that would be required by
proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1), such as by requiring that the opt-out
notice be sent to an email address or telephone number other than the
one to which the debt collector intends to send the hyperlink. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether the information required to be
provided under proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1)(i) through (vi) is
sufficient to allow a consumer to make an informed decision whether to
opt out of receiving hyperlinked delivery of required disclosures. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether to clarify further what it
means to provide a reasonable opt-out period and, if so, how long an
opt-out period should be to qualify as reasonable. In particular, the
[[Page 23365]]
Bureau requests comment on whether the requirement to allow a consumer
more than five days to make an opt-out decision in response to an opt-
out notice delivered electronically, as described in proposed comment
42(d)(1)-3, should be imposed or should be shortened or lengthened. In
addition, the Bureau requests comment on how a debt collector could
obtain a consumer's oral consent to hyperlinked delivery of required
disclosures.
42(d)(2) Communication by the Creditor
Instead of complying with the notice-and-opt-out process described
in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1), which would rely on a communication
between the debt collector and the consumer, a debt collector could
choose to comply with the notice-and-opt-out process described in
proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2). The notice-and-opt-out process described
in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) would rely on a communication between
the creditor and the consumer.
Under proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2), a debt collector must, no more
than 30 days before the debt collector's electronic communication
containing the hyperlink to the disclosure, confirm that the creditor:
(1) Communicated with the consumer using the email address or, in the
case of a text message, the telephone number to which the debt
collector intends to send the electronic communication, and (2)
informed the consumer of the information in proposed Sec.
1006.42(d)(2)(i) through (iv). The Bureau proposes to require the
creditor to have communicated using the same email address or telephone
number to which the debt collector intends to send the electronic
communication containing the hyperlink to help ensure that the email
address or telephone number is a valid one. The Bureau proposes the 30-
day timing requirement to ensure that the creditor's communication with
the consumer occurs shortly before the debt collector's delivery of the
electronic communication containing the hyperlink to the consumer.
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2)(i) and (ii) provide that the creditor
must have informed the consumer of the placement or sale of the debt to
the debt collector, and of the name the debt collector uses when
collecting debts. The Bureau proposes to require this information to
help the consumer identify the debt collector and the debt collector's
relationship to the creditor and the account. Proposed Sec.
1006.42(d)(2)(iii) provides that the creditor must have informed the
consumer of the debt collector's option to use the consumer's email
address or, in the case of a text message, the consumer's telephone
number to provide any legally required debt collection disclosures in a
manner that is consistent with Federal law. The Bureau proposes to
require this information to help the consumer expect and recognize an
electronic communication from the debt collector containing a hyperlink
to a disclosure.
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2)(iv) provides that the creditor must
have informed the consumer of the information described in Sec.
1006.42(d)(1)(iii), (v), and (vi). The Bureau proposes to require this
information for the reasons discussed in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1).\585\ Proposed comment
42(d)(2)-1 would clarify that a creditor's communication with the
consumer under Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) may apply to multiple debts being
placed with or sold to the same debt collector at the same time.
Proposed comment 42(d)(2)-2 would clarify how the requirement to
communicate with the consumer before providing a hyperlinked disclosure
works together with the requirement to provide the consumer a
reasonable period within which to opt out. The comment explains that,
in an oral communication with the consumer, such as a telephone or in-
person conversation, the creditor may require the consumer to make an
opt-out decision during that same communication; however, a written or
electronic communication that requires the consumer to make an opt-out
decision within a period of five or fewer days does not satisfy
proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2). The Bureau proposes to require a creditor
to allow a consumer more than five days to make an opt-out decision in
order to grant sufficient time for the consumer to see and respond to
an opt-out notice provided in a written or electronic communication.
Proposed comment 42(d)(2)-3 would clarify that an opt-out notice
provided by a creditor under Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) may be combined with
an opt-out notice provided by the creditor under Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\585\ The process described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) for
ensuring that consumers reasonably expect delivery of hyperlinked
disclosures may generally align with some existing industry
practices. For example, some creditors may already notify consumers
when a debt is placed for collection or sold to a third party. The
communications described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) could be
included in such notices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) and on
proposed comment 42(d)(2)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on whether the 30-day timing requirement should be lengthened or
shortened. In addition, the Bureau requests comment on whether the
information that proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2)(i) through (iv) would
require is sufficient to allow a consumer to make an informed decision
whether to opt out of receiving hyperlinked delivery of required
disclosures. The Bureau also requests comment on how often creditors
communicate with consumers regarding the placement or sale of a debt.
The Bureau also requests comment on whether debt collectors who wish to
provide required disclosures electronically pursuant to proposed Sec.
1006.42(c)(2)(ii) would be more likely to choose the notice-and-opt-out
process described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) (communication by the
debt collector) or the notice-and-opt-out process described in proposed
Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) (communication by the creditor), and the reasons
why.
42(e) Safe Harbors
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(e) would establish two safe harbors, the
first covering provision of disclosures by mail and the second covering
provision of the validation notice within the body of an email that is
a debt collector's initial communication with the consumer. Conduct
that falls within these safe harbors would satisfy proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1)'s notice and retainability requirements.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.42(e) to implement and interpret
FDCPA sections 809(a) and (b) and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA
section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors. Under FDCPA section 809(a), a debt collector
must include certain information in the debt collector's initial
communication with the consumer or ``send the consumer'' a ``written''
notice (i.e., the validation notice) containing that information. Under
FDCPA section 809(b), a debt collector must ``mail[ ] to the consumer''
any original-creditor or verification information it provides. As
discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.42(a)(1), a form of delivery that is not reasonably expected to
provide actual notice may not satisfy FDCPA section 809(a)'s
requirement to ``send the consumer'' a notice or FDCPA section 809(b)'s
requirement to ``mail[ ]'' original-creditor and verification
information to the consumer. In addition, a written or electronic
notice that is not retainable may not satisfy FDCPA section 809's
writing requirement. Conversely, a debt collector may reasonably expect
that conduct falling within the safe harbors described in proposed
Sec. 1006.42(e) will provide actual notice to the consumer in a
retainable form.
[[Page 23366]]
42(e)(1) Disclosures Provided by Mail
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(1) would establish a safe harbor for
delivery of disclosures by mail. Specifically, proposed Sec.
1006.42(e)(1) provides that a debt collector satisfies Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) if the debt collector mails a printed copy of a required
disclosure to the consumer's residential address, unless the debt
collector receives notification from the entity or person responsible
for delivery that the disclosure was not delivered.
Although proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(1) mentions the consumer's
residential address, mailing a printed disclosure to another address,
such as a consumer's post office box, may be reasonably expected to
provide actual notice in certain circumstances. The Bureau understands,
however, that most debt collectors send paper validation notices to
residential addresses and that, in general, it is reasonable to expect
that sending a validation notice to a consumer's residential address
will provide actual notice. Accordingly, the safe harbor in proposed
Sec. 1006.42(e)(1) only covers validation notices sent to residential
addresses. The safe harbor in proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(1) also would
not apply if a debt collector receives notification that the disclosure
was not delivered. This aspect of proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(1) is
consistent with case law holding that a written notice returned as
undeliverable has not actually been sent to the consumer within the
meaning of the FDCPA.\586\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\586\ See, e.g., Johnson v. CFS II, Inc., No. 12-CV-01091, 2013
WL 1809081, at *10 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 28, 2013) (``[I]f a debtor rebuts
the presumption of proper delivery by showing that notice was sent
to an incorrect address or returned as undeliverable, the language
and purpose of the FDCPA require further action by a debt
collector.''); Johnson v. Midland Credit Mgmt. Inc., No. 1:05 CV
1094, 2006 WL 2473004, at *12 (N.D. Ohio Aug. 24, 2006) (``[W]hile
the plain language of the statute does not require the debt
collector to ensure actual receipt of the validation notice, the
plain language does require the debt collector to send the
validation notice to a valid and proper address where the consumer
may actually receive it. If the debt collector knows the validation
notice was sent to the wrong address, the debt collector has not
complied with the plain language of the statute.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed comment 42(e)(1)-1 would clarify that, for purposes of
Sec. 1006.42(e)(1), a disclosure is not mailed to a consumer's
residential address if the debt collector knows or should know at the
time of mailing that the consumer does not currently reside at that
location. The Bureau proposes this comment because, in such a
circumstance, the debt collector likely lacks a reasonable expectation
of actual notice. The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec.
1006.42(e)(1) and on proposed comment 42(e)(1)-1.
42(e)(2) Validation Notice Contained in the Initial Communication
In pre-proposal feedback, industry stakeholders asked the Bureau to
clarify how to deliver the validation notice electronically in a debt
collector's initial communication with the consumer. Proposed Sec.
1006.42(e)(2) would provide a safe harbor to debt collectors who
deliver a validation notice in the body of an email that is the debt
collector's initial communication with the consumer, provided certain
other conditions are satisfied.
The E-SIGN Act's consumer consent provisions apply if a statute,
regulation, or other rule of law requires that information relating to
a transaction or transactions in or affecting interstate or foreign
commerce be provided or made available to a consumer in writing.\587\
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34(a)(1), neither FDCPA section 809(a) nor proposed Regulation F
prohibit a debt collector from providing the validation information
described in proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) orally or electronically in the
debt collector's initial communication with the consumer. Accordingly,
the E-SIGN Act's consumer consent provisions do not apply to the extent
a debt collector provides the validation information in the body of an
email that is the debt collector's initial communication with the
consumer.\588\ However, proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would apply.\589\
Thus, a debt collector who provides the validation notice in the body
of an email that is the debt collector's initial communication with the
consumer would need to do so in a manner reasonably expected to provide
actual notice and in a form that the consumer may keep and access
later.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\587\ 15 U.S.C. 7001(c).
\588\ Conversely, the E-SIGN Act's consumer consent provisions
do apply to the extent a debt collector provides the validation
information outside of the initial communication because, under
FDCPA section 809(a), that information must be in writing if not
contained in the initial communication.
\589\ This is because proposed Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) would apply
if a debt collector provides in writing or electronically a
disclosure that is required by Regulation F.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The processes described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(b) may be
reasonably expected to provide actual notice in a form that the
consumer may keep and access later. Accordingly, a debt collector who
provides the validation notice in the body of an email that is the debt
collector's initial communication with the consumer would satisfy Sec.
1006.42(a)(1) by complying with Sec. 1006.42(b). Proposed Sec.
1006.42(b)(1) would, except as provided in Sec. 1006.42(c), require a
debt collector to provide the disclosure in accordance with the E-SIGN
Act after the consumer provides affirmative consent directly to the
debt collector. Proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(1), which describes one
element of the alternative procedures, would require a debt collector
to provide the disclosure by sending an electronic communication to an
email address or, in the case of a text message, a telephone number
that the creditor or a prior debt collector could have used to provide
electronic disclosures in accordance with section 101(c) of the E-SIGN
Act.
When it comes to providing the validation notice in the body of an
email that is the initial communication with the consumer, however, it
may be appropriate to expand the email addresses to which a debt
collector may send the disclosure. In particular, because the E-SIGN
Act does not apply to this form of delivery in the first place, it may
not be necessary to limit the safe harbor to those email addresses for
which a consumer has already provided E-SIGN Act consent to the
creditor or a prior debt collector. Proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)
identifies procedures for identifying email addresses to which debt
collection communications can be sent. As described in the section-by-
section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3), these proposed
procedures are designed to ensure that a debt collector who uses a
particular email address or telephone number selected through the
procedures does not have a reason to anticipate that an unauthorized
third-party disclosure may occur. One point of the procedures is to
identify an email address or telephone number that the consumer who
owes or allegedly owes the debt uses. Thus, if a debt collector
includes the validation notice in the body of an email that is its
initial communication with the consumer, sending the email to an email
address selected through the procedures described in proposed Sec.
1006.6(d)(3) may be reasonably likely to provide actual notice to the
consumer.
For these reasons, proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(2) provides that a
debt collector who provides the validation notice described in Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(A) within the body of an email that is the initial
communication with the consumer satisfies Sec. 1006.42(a)(1) if the
debt collector satisfies the requirements of Sec. 1006.42(b) for
validation notices described in Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B).\590\ If
[[Page 23367]]
such a debt collector follows the procedures described in proposed
Sec. 1006.42(c), the debt collector may, in lieu of sending the
validation notice to an email address that the creditor or a prior debt
collector could use for delivery of electronic disclosures in
accordance with section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act (as described in Sec.
1006.42(c)(1)), send the validation notice to an email address selected
through the procedures described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\590\ This means that, among other things, for a debt
collector's conduct to fall within the safe harbor that proposed
Sec. 1006.42(e)(2) would create, a debt collector would need to
comply with the requirement proposed in Sec. 1006.42(b)(4) to
provide the validation notice in a responsive form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(2) would create a safe harbor. It would
not establish the only way a debt collector may deliver the validation
notice in the body of an email that is the debt collector's initial
communication with the consumer. Nor would it provide a safe harbor for
a debt collector delivering the validation notice as a hyperlink in an
email or text message that is the debt collector's initial
communication with the consumer. Indeed, for the reasons discussed in
the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(2)(ii), it
may be unreasonable for a debt collector to expect that a consumer has
actual notice of a validation notice delivered by hyperlink--no matter
the email address or telephone number to which the electronic
communication containing the hyperlink is sent--if the consumer does
not expect to receive a hyperlinked disclosure from that particular
debt collector. Proposed comment 42(e)(2)-1 would clarify that, if a
consumer has opted out of debt collection communications to a
particular email address or telephone number by, for example, following
the instructions provided pursuant to Sec. 1006.6(e), then a debt
collector cannot use that email address or telephone number to deliver
disclosures under Sec. 1006.42(e)(2).
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.42(e)(2) and on
proposed comment 42(e)(2)-1. In particular, the Bureau requests comment
on whether using an email address selected through the procedures
described in proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) is reasonably likely to
provide actual notice to the consumer. The Bureau also requests comment
on whether a debt collector who wishes to provide the validation notice
in the body of an email that is the debt collector's initial
communication with the consumer is more likely to send the validation
notice to an email address described in proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(1) or
to an email address selected through the procedures described in
proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3). In addition, the Bureau requests comment
on whether a debt collector who wishes to provide a validation notice
in the debt collector's initial communication with the consumer is
likely to use the safe harbor in proposed Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) and, if
not, the reasons why not.
Subpart C--Reserved
Subpart D--Miscellaneous
Section 1006.100 Record Retention
Proposed Sec. 1006.100 would require a debt collector to retain
evidence of compliance with Regulation F. The purpose of a record
retention requirement would be to promote effective and efficient
enforcement and supervision of Regulation F. Any retention period
therefore must be long enough to ensure access to evidence that the
debt collector performed the actions and made the disclosures required
by the regulation. For ease of compliance, any retention period also
should have easily determinable beginning and end dates.
For these reasons, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.100 to require a
debt collector to retain evidence of compliance with Regulation F
starting on the date that the debt collector begins collection activity
on a debt and ending three years after: (1) The debt collector's last
communication or attempted communication in connection with the
collection of the debt; or (2) the debt is settled, discharged, or
transferred to the debt owner or to another debt collector. Requiring
debt collectors to begin retaining evidence of compliance when
collection activity begins should provide an easily determinable start
date.
In the Small Business Review Panel Outline, the Bureau described a
proposal to determine the end of the retention obligation from a debt
collector's last communication or attempted communication with the
consumer about a debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.100 is not limited to
communications or attempted communications with a consumer; a
communication with any person may serve as the end date from which the
retention period may be calculated. Proposed Sec. 1006.100 also adds
that the end of the retention period may be calculated from the time a
debt is settled, discharged, or transferred to the debt owner or to
another debt collector. This addition is intended to provide debt
collectors with a more easily ascertainable date from which to measure
their retention obligations, if such a date exists. The proposed three-
year retention period should promote effective and efficient
enforcement and supervision of Regulation F while not unduly burdening
debt collectors; during the SBREFA process, nearly all small entity
representatives stated that they already retain many records for at
least three years.
Proposed comment 100-1 would clarify that, under proposed Sec.
1006.100, a debt collector must retain evidence that the debt collector
performed the actions and made the disclosures required by Regulation
F. Proposed comment 100-1 also provides examples of the evidence that a
debt collector could retain to show that the debt collector complied
with certain sections of the regulation. Proposed comment 100-2 would
clarify that proposed Sec. 1006.100 would not require debt collectors
to retain paper copies of documents, provided the records are retained
by a method that reproduces the records accurately. Proposed comment
100-3 would clarify that proposed Sec. 1006.100 would not require debt
collectors to record telephone calls, but that a debt collector who
records such calls must retain the recordings if they are evidence of
compliance with Regulation F.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.100 and on
whether any additional clarification is needed. In particular, the
Bureau requests comment on the length of the retention period, the date
from which the retention obligation should be measured, and the types
of records that should be maintained. The Bureau also requests comment
on the burden proposed Sec. 1006.100 would impose on debt collectors
who may engage in initial attempts to collect a debt and then
transition to monitoring the account without engaging in any collection
communications but with the intent or option of restarting collection
at a later date. The Bureau also requests comment on whether there are
scenarios in which it is not possible to determine the last
communication or attempted communication, such as when a person
contacts the debt collector without outreach from the debt collector.
The Bureau further requests comment on the merits of narrowing this
prong to the debt collector's last communication or attempted
communication with the consumer in connection with the collection of
the debt, instead of the debt collector's last communication or
attempted communication with any person. The Bureau requests comment on
whether the two alternative proposed end dates of the retention period
provide sufficient clarity on calculating the retention period.
During the SBREFA process, some small entity representatives stated
that
[[Page 23368]]
they retain some information, such as telephone calls or notes, for
less than three years, and they expressed concern about the potential
cost of storing additional data. The Small Business Review Panel
recommended that the Bureau seek more information to estimate the costs
of record retention and request comment about whether the retention of
some records, such as telephone calls, poses particularly high costs
for any debt collectors. The Bureau requests comment on these topics,
on debt collectors' current record retention practices, and on the
benefits to consumers of a record retention requirement that applies to
all FDCPA-covered debt collectors.
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.100 pursuant to its authority under
Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1), which, among other things, provides
that the Bureau's director may prescribe rules and issue orders and
guidance as may be necessary or appropriate to enable the Bureau to
administer and carry out the purposes and objectives of the Federal
consumer financial laws and to prevent evasions thereof. The Bureau
also proposes Sec. 1006.100 pursuant to Dodd-Frank Act section
1024(b)(7)(A), which authorizes the Bureau to prescribe rules to
facilitate supervision of persons identified as larger participants of
a market for a consumer financial product or service as defined by rule
in accordance with section 1024(a)(1)(B) of the Dodd-Frank Act; \591\
and Dodd-Frank Act section 1024(b)(7)(B), which authorizes the Bureau
to require a person described in Dodd-Frank Act section 1024(a)(1) to
retain records for the purpose of facilitating supervision of such
persons and assessing and detecting risks to consumers. For the reasons
described above, the Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.100 to facilitate
supervision of, and to assess and detect risks to consumers posed by,
debt collectors that are larger participants of the consumer debt
collection market, as defined by rule, and to enable the Bureau to
conduct enforcement investigations to identify and help prevent and
deter the abusive, unfair, and deceptive debt collection practices
identified in the regulation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\591\ 12 CFR 1090.105 defines larger participants of the
consumer debt collection market.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1006.104 Relation to State Laws
FDCPA section 816 provides that the Act does not annul, alter, or
affect, or exempt any person subject to the provisions of the Act from
complying with the laws of any State \592\ with respect to debt
collection practices, except to the extent that those laws are
inconsistent with any provision of the Act, and then only to the extent
of the inconsistency. FDCPA section 816 also provides that, for
purposes of that section, a State law is not inconsistent with the Act
if the protection such law affords any consumer is greater than the
protection provided by the Act.\593\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\592\ Proposed Sec. 1006.2(l) would define State to mean ``any
State, territory, or possession of the United States, the District
of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, or any political
subdivision of any of the foregoing.''
\593\ 15 U.S.C. 1692n.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes Sec. 1006.104 to implement FDCPA section 816
and pursuant to its authority under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe
rules with respect to the collection of debts by debt collectors.
Proposed Sec. 1006.104 mirrors the statute, except that proposed Sec.
1006.104 refers to both the provisions of the Act and the corresponding
provisions of Regulation F.
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.34, some States and localities impose their own disclosure
requirements on debt collectors. During the SBREFA process, several
small entity representatives expressed concern about possible overlap
or inconsistencies between State and local disclosure requirements and
the Bureau's proposed disclosure requirements. In its report, the Small
Business Review Panel recommended that the Bureau continue to consider
State law disclosures, particularly to determine whether there are any
specific burdens or costs caused by overlap or conflict between the
Bureau's disclosures and State disclosures. The Panel also recommended
that the Bureau continue to consider whether clarifications may be
necessary in the event that Federal disclosures overlap with State law
requirements.\594\ Consistent with the Small Business Review Panel's
recommendations, proposed comment 104-1 would clarify that a disclosure
required by applicable State law that describes additional protections
under State law does not contradict the requirements of the Act or the
corresponding provisions of the regulation.\595\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\594\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 34.
\595\ In response to the Small Business Review Panel's
recommendations on this issue, proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)(3)(iv)
permits a debt collector to include State law disclosures on the
reverse of the validation notice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.104 and proposed
comment 104-1, including on whether any additional clarification is
needed. In particular, consistent with the Small Business Review
Panel's recommendation, the Bureau requests comment on whether
disclosures required by specific State or local laws are inconsistent
with the Bureau's proposed disclosures, and any specific burdens or
costs caused by such overlap or conflict.
Section 1006.108 Exemption for State Regulation and Appendix A
Procedures for State Application for Exemption From the Provisions of
the Act
FDCPA section 817 provides that the Bureau shall by regulation
exempt from the requirements of the Act any class of debt collection
practices within any State if the Bureau determines that, under the law
of that State, that class of debt collection practices is subject to
requirements substantially similar to those imposed by the Act, and
that there is adequate provision for enforcement.\596\ Sections 1006.1
through 1006.8 of current Regulation F implement FDCPA section 817 and
set forth procedures and criteria whereby States may apply to the
Bureau for exemption of debt collection practices within the applying
State from the provisions of the Act.\597\ The Bureau proposes to
retain these procedures and criteria, reorganized as Sec. 1006.108 and
appendix A and with the minor changes for clarity described below, to
implement and interpret FDCPA section 817 and pursuant to its authority
under FDCPA section 814(d) to prescribe rules with respect to the
collection of debts by debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\596\ 15 U.S.C. 1692o.
\597\ 12 CFR part 1006.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with existing Sec. 1006.2, proposed Sec. 1006.108(a)
provides that any State may apply to the Bureau for a determination
that, under the laws of that State, any class of debt collection
practices within that State is subject to requirements that are
substantially similar to, or provide greater protection for consumers
than, those imposed under FDCPA sections 803 through 812, and that
there is adequate provision for State enforcement of such requirements.
Proposed Sec. 1006.108(a) would clarify that, to be eligible for an
exemption, the class of debt collection practices within that State
also would need to be subject to requirements that are substantially
similar to, or provide greater protection for consumers than, the
provisions of Regulation F corresponding to FDCPA sections 803 through
812.
Proposed Sec. 1006.108(b) provides that the procedures and
criteria whereby States may apply to the Bureau for exemption of a
class of debt collection
[[Page 23369]]
practices within the applying State from the provisions of the Act and
the corresponding provisions of Regulation F are set forth in appendix
A to the regulation. Proposed appendix A, in turn, sets forth the
procedures and criteria whereby States may apply to the Bureau for the
exemption described in proposed Sec. 1006.108. Proposed appendix A
largely mirrors existing Sec. Sec. 1006.1 through 1006.8, with certain
organizational changes and other, minor changes for clarity and to more
closely track the statute. The Bureau also proposes to amend the
current notice system for acting on State requests for exemption to a
proposed and final rule system.
As with proposed Sec. 1006.108(a), proposed appendix A would
clarify that, to be eligible for an exemption, the class of debt
collection practices within the applying State also would need to be
subject to requirements that are substantially similar to, or provide
greater protection for consumers than, the provisions of Regulation F
corresponding to FDCPA sections 803 through 812. The Bureau also
proposes to revise certain phrases in existing Sec. Sec. 1006.1
through 1006.8 to ensure uniform terminology throughout appendix A. For
example, proposed appendix A would use the phrase ``more protective of
consumers than'' State law throughout, rather than variations such as
``more extensive than'' and ``more favorable than'' State law, which
appear in certain places in existing Sec. Sec. 1006.3 and 1006.4.
Proposed appendix A would include several additional changes to
existing Regulation F.
First, to streamline appendix A, the Bureau proposes to include two
new definitions in proposed paragraph I(b). The first, in proposed
paragraph I(b)(1), would define ``applicant State law'' to mean the
State law that, for a class of debt collection practices within that
State, is claimed to contain requirements that are substantially
similar to the requirements that relevant Federal law imposes on that
class of debt collection practices, and that contains adequate
provision for State enforcement. The second, in proposed paragraph
I(b)(3), would define ``relevant Federal law'' to mean sections 803
through 812 of the Act (15 U.S.C. 1692a through 1692j) and the
corresponding provisions of Regulation F. Accordingly, the proposed
text of appendix A substitutes these terms throughout where
appropriate.
Second, proposed appendix A would strike existing Sec. 1006.3(c)
as redundant of proposed paragraph III(a) as revised.
Third, proposed paragraph III(d) of appendix A would repeat
existing Sec. 1006.3(e) with certain clarifications. Existing Sec.
1006.3(e) requires the applicant State to submit, among other
supporting materials, information regarding the State's fiscal
arrangements for administrative enforcement and the number and
qualifications of enforcement personnel, along with a description of
State enforcement procedures. In assessing the adequacy of State
enforcement, however, existing Sec. 1006.4(b)--which is repeated in
proposed paragraph IV(b) of appendix A--requires the Bureau to consider
three general categories of information: necessary facilities,
personnel, and funding. Because the criteria for evaluating the
adequacy of State enforcement refers to these general categories of
information, the Bureau proposes that paragraph III(d) of appendix A
also refer to these general categories of information. Proposed
paragraph III(d) of appendix A therefore would require the applicant
State to submit information concerning the adequacy of enforcement,
including information about necessary facilities, personnel, and
funding. Proposed paragraph III(d) of appendix A also would clarify
that examples of information relating to adequacy of enforcement that
an applicant State must submit include the State's fiscal arrangements
for administrative State enforcement, the number and qualifications of
enforcement personnel, and a description of the State's enforcement
procedures.
Fourth, the Bureau proposes to clarify in proposed paragraph
IV(a)(1)(i) of appendix A that the ``substantially similar'' standard
in FDCPA section 817 applies to the Bureau's consideration of all
aspects of the State law for which the exemption is sought, including
defined terms and rules of construction. Existing Sec. 1006.4(a)(1)(i)
states that defined terms and rules of construction must be ``the
same'' as the FDCPA. The Bureau interprets FDCPA section 817's
substantial similarity standard also to apply to defined terms and
rules of construction. That standard permits variation from FDCPA
defined terms and rules of construction, as long as the State law
definitions and rules of construction are substantially similar to or
more protective of consumers than the FDCPA. Accordingly, proposed
paragraph IV(a)(1)(iv) of appendix A uses the phrase ``substantially
similar'' rather than ``the same.''
Fifth, proposed paragraph VI(b) of appendix A would repeat existing
Sec. 1006.6(b) with certain clarifications. Existing Sec. 1006.6(b)
requires a State that has obtained an exemption to submit such reports
to the Bureau as the Bureau may from time to time require. The Bureau
proposes to clarify that this provision requires the State to submit to
the Bureau, not later than two years after the date the exemption is
granted, and every two years thereafter, a written report concerning
the manner in which the State has enforced its law in the preceding two
years and an update of the information required under proposed
paragraph III(d) of appendix A. By requiring such information to be
updated every two years, proposed appendix A would ensure that the
Bureau is aware of changes that may affect the State's capacity to
enforce the laws that qualified the State for the exemption.
The Bureau requests comment on proposed Sec. 1006.108 and proposed
appendix A, and on whether any additional clarification is needed. The
Bureau also requests comment on whether proposed Sec. 1006.108 should
be clarified or broadened to allow for an exemption from provisions of
Regulation F that are not based exclusively on FDCPA sections 803
through 812. Similarly, the Bureau requests comment on whether proposed
Sec. 1006.108 should be clarified or broadened to allow for an
exemption from provisions of Regulation F that are based solely on the
Bureau's authority under the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau potentially
could adopt such a process pursuant to its exemption authority under
section 1022(b)(3)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
Further, current Regulation F includes the phrase ``provide greater
protection for consumers than,'' which is a concept incorporated from
FDCPA section 816. It also provides that ``[a]fter an exemption is
granted, the requirements of the applicable State law constitute the
requirements of relevant Federal law, except to the extent such State
law imposes requirements not imposed by the Act or this part.'' The
Bureau does not propose to change this language in proposed Sec.
1006.108 or proposed appendix A, as the Bureau does not seek to make
additional substantive changes to the requirements for State requests
for exemption. The Bureau requests comment on the use of this language
in proposed Sec. 1006.108 and proposed appendix A.
[[Page 23370]]
Appendix C to Part 1006--Issuance of Advisory Opinions 598
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\598\ Proposed appendix A is discussed in the section-by-section
analysis of proposed Sec. 1006.108. Proposed appendix B is
discussed in the section-by-section analyses of proposed Sec. Sec.
1006.26 and 1006.34.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau proposes to add appendix C to Regulation F to publish a
list of any advisory opinions that the Bureau issues pursuant to FDCPA
section 813(e). Proposed appendix C would clarify that any act done or
omitted in good faith in conformity with any advisory opinion issued by
the Bureau, including those referenced in appendix C, provides the
protection from liability for FDCPA-based violations afforded under
FDCPA section 813(e). Proposed appendix C also includes instructions
for requesting an advisory opinion. The Bureau requests comment on
whether additional clarification regarding the effect of conformity
with Bureau advisory opinions would be helpful.
Supplement I to Part 1006--Official Interpretations
The Bureau proposes to add Supplement I to Regulation F to publish
official interpretations of the regulation (i.e., commentary). Proposed
comment I-1 explains that the commentary is the Bureau's vehicle for
supplementing Regulation F and has been issued pursuant to the Bureau's
authority to prescribe rules under 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d) and in accordance
with the notice-and-comment procedures for informal rulemaking under
the Administrative Procedure Act. Proposed comment I-2 sets forth the
procedure for requesting that an official interpretation be added to
Supplement I, and proposed comment I-3 describes how the commentary is
organized and numbered. Proposed commentary relating to specific
sections of the regulation are addressed in the section-by-section
analyses of those sections, above. The Bureau requests comment on
proposed comments I-1, -2, and -3, including on whether additional
clarification regarding either the purpose or organization of
Supplement I, or the procedure for requesting official interpretations,
would be helpful.
VI. Dodd-Frank Act Section 1022(b) Analysis
A. Overview
In developing the proposed rule, the Bureau has considered the
proposal's potential benefits, costs, and impacts.\599\ The Bureau
requests comment on the preliminary analysis presented below as well as
submissions of additional data that could inform the Bureau's analysis
of the benefits, costs, and impacts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\599\ Specifically, section 1022(b)(2)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act
(12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(2)(A)) requires the Bureau to consider the
potential benefits and costs of the regulation to consumers and
covered persons, including the potential reduction of access by
consumers to consumer financial products or services; the impact of
the proposed rule on insured depository institutions and insured
credit unions with $10 billion or less in total assets as described
in section 1026 of the Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5516); and the
impact on consumers in rural areas.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors play a critical role in markets for consumer
financial products and services. Credit markets function because
lenders expect that borrowers will pay them back. In consumer credit
markets, if borrowers fail to repay what they owe per the terms of
their loan agreement, creditors often engage debt collectors to attempt
to recover amounts owed, whether through the court system or through
less formal demands for repayment.
In general, third-party debt collection creates the potential for
market failures. Consumers do not choose their debt collectors, and as
a result debt collectors do not have the same incentives that creditors
have to treat consumers fairly.\600\ Certain provisions of the FDCPA
may help mitigate such market failures in debt collection, for example
by prohibiting unfair, deceptive, or abusive debt collection practices
by third-party debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\600\ Consumers do choose their lenders, and in principle
consumer loan contracts could specify which debt collector would be
used or what debt collection practices would be in the event a loan
is not repaid. Some economists have identified potential market
failures that prevent loan contracts from including such terms even
when they could make both borrowers and lenders better off. For
example, terms related to debt collection may not be salient to
consumers at the time a loan is made. Alternatively, if such terms
are salient, a contract that provides for more lenient collection
practices may lead to adverse selection, attracting a
disproportionate share of borrowers who know they are more likely to
default. See Thomas A. Durkin et al., Consumer Credit and the
American Economy 521-525 (Oxford U. Press 2014) (discussing
potential sources of market failure and potential problems with some
of those arguments).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Any restriction on debt collection may reduce repayment of debts,
providing a benefit to some consumers who owe debts and an offsetting
cost to creditors and debt collectors. A decrease in repayment will in
turn lower the expected return to lending. This can lead lenders to
increase interest rates and other borrowing costs and to restrict
availability of credit, particularly to higher-risk borrowers.\601\
Because of this, policies that increase protections for consumers with
debts in collection involve a tradeoff between the benefits of
protections for such consumers and the possibility of increased costs
of credit and reduced availability of credit for all consumers. Whether
there is a net benefit from such protections depends on whether
consumers value the protections enough to outweigh any associated
increase in the cost of credit or reduction in availability of credit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\601\ See id. (discussing theory and evidence on how
restrictions on creditor remedies affect the supply of credit).
Empirical evidence on the impact of State laws restricting debt
collection is discussed in section G below. The provisions in this
proposal could also affect consumer demand for credit, to the extent
that consumers contemplate collection practices when making
borrowing decisions. However, there is evidence suggesting that
consumer demand for credit is generally not responsive to
differences in creditor remedies. See James Barth et al., Benefits
and Costs of Legal Restrictions on Personal Loan Markets, Journal of
Law & Economics, 29(2) (1986).
\601\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposal would further the FDCPA's goals of eliminating abusive
debt collection practices and ensuring that debt collectors who refrain
from such practices are not competitively disadvantaged.\602\ However,
as discussed below, it is not clear based on the information available
to the Bureau at this time whether the net effect of the proposal's
different provisions would be to make it more costly or less costly for
debt collectors to recover unpaid amounts, and therefore not clear
whether the proposal would tend to increase or decrease the supply of
credit. The proposed rule would benefit both consumers and debt
collectors by increasing clarity and certainty about what the FDCPA
prohibits and requires. When a law is unclear, it is more likely that
parties will disagree about what the law requires, that legal disputes
will arise, and that litigation will be required to resolve disputes.
Since 2010, consumers have filed approximately 10,000 to 12,000
lawsuits under the FDCPA each year.\603\ The number of disputes settled
without litigation has likely been much greater.\604\ Perhaps more
important than the costs of resolving legal disputes are the steps that
debt collectors take to prevent legal disputes from arising in the
first place. This includes direct costs of legal compliance, such as
auditing and legal advice, as well as indirect costs from avoiding
collection practices that might be both effective and legal but that
raise potential legal risks. In some cases, debt
[[Page 23371]]
collectors seeking to follow the law and avoid litigation have adopted
practices that appear to be economically inefficient, with costs that
exceed the benefits to consumers or even impose net costs on
consumers.\605\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\602\ See id.
\603\ See WebRecon LLC, WebRecon Stats for Dec 2017 & Year in
Review, https://webrecon.com/webrecon-stats-for-dec-2017-year-in-review (last visited May 6, 2019). Greater clarity about legal
requirements could reduce unintentional violations and could also
reduce lawsuits because, when parties can better predict the outcome
of a lawsuit, they may be more likely to settle claims out of court.
\604\ Some debt collectors have reported that they receive
approximately 10 demand letters for each lawsuit filed. See Small
Business Review Panel Outline, supra note 56, at 69 n.105.
\605\ For example, as discussed further below, many debt
collectors currently avoid leaving voice messages for consumers or
communicating with consumers by email because sending voice messages
or emails may create legal risks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several provisions of the proposed rule would likely change the way
debt collectors communicate with consumers, and the potential impacts
of these provisions are likely to interact with each other in ways that
are difficult for the Bureau to predict. Most significant of these are
the provisions related to frequency limits for telephone calls,
limited-content messages, and electronic disclosures, although other
provisions such as the proposed model validation notice might fall into
this category as well. The communication provisions collectively are
likely to reduce the number of telephone calls from debt collectors.
Currently many, though by no means all, debt collectors communicate
with consumers strictly through actual and attempted live telephone
calls and postal mail, with no communication by voice message, email,
text message, or other electronic media.
It is possible that the net effect of the proposed provisions would
be to make debt collection more effective: Debt collectors who
currently communicate by live telephone calls in excess of the proposed
limits could substitute for some of the excessive call volume by
leaving voice messages and sending email, and consumers could respond
to this change in communication channels by engaging with such debt
collectors as much as or more than they currently do by telephone. If
this occurs, consumers could benefit from a reduction in calls that may
annoy, abuse, or harass them, as well as from resolving their
outstanding debts in a more timely fashion. At the same time, debt
collectors could benefit from reduced time spent making calls and from
increased revenue. There is some reason to believe this may occur--as
noted below, a substantial fraction of consumers prefers to communicate
by email, and consumers may well be more likely to return a voice
message than to answer their telephones in response to a call from an
unknown number.
Alternatively, the proposed provisions might make debt collection
less effective: Debt collectors could comply with the frequency limits,
reducing outbound calling, but end up not increasing contact with
consumers by using voicemail and email as communication channels. This
might occur if debt collectors still fear some legal risk from other
channels, or if they find the new communication methods are not
effective in reaching consumers. In this case, although the number of
telephone calls would be reduced, it would come at the cost of making
it more difficult for debt collectors to reach some consumers, reducing
revenue and potentially imposing costs on both consumers and debt
collectors from increased litigation to recover debts.
The effect of the proposal on debt collectors would likely lie
somewhere in between these two extremes, and the Bureau believes these
effects will likely vary by debt collector and type of debt. If the
proposed communication provisions were adopted in a final rule, some
firms would likely adopt newer communication methods due to the reduced
legal risk and find less need for telephone calls, while other firms
would not do so or would not experience the same effect. Still other
firms might be largely unaffected by the communication-related
provisions in the proposal. As discussed below, some debt collectors
currently place only one or two calls per week to any consumer, and
such debt collectors are unlikely to change their calling practices and
may not find it cost-effective to develop the information-technology
infrastructure necessary to communicate by email or text message.
Relatedly, the Bureau is aware of at least one mid-sized collection
firm that primarily uses email for communication currently, and such
firms also will be unlikely to alter their practices, although they may
benefit from reduced litigation costs.
In short, the proposed provisions related to communications would
likely reduce the overall number of calls per consumer, while at the
same time potentially reducing the number of calls required to reach
each consumer. Although the Bureau believes it is likely that consumers
would benefit directly from a reduction in calls that annoy, abuse, or
harass them, the Bureau cannot predict the net effect of these
provisions on debt collectors' costs and revenues or the net change in
indirect costs to consumers from potential credit reporting and
litigation in the event debt collectors cannot reach them.
Apart from the proposed communication provisions, other provisions
of the proposal could make debt collection either more or less costly
in ways that are difficult to predict. For example, the proposed
validation notice requirements would provide consumers with more
information than they currently receive about debts, which could reduce
costs to consumers and debt collectors from disputes that arise when
consumers do not recognize the debt or understand the basis for the
alleged amount due. At the same time, the proposal's clearer
explanation of dispute rights could make consumers more likely to
dispute, which could provide benefits to consumers while increasing
costs for debt collectors. Disputes are costly for debt collectors to
process, so these proposed requirements could either increase or
decrease debt collector and consumer costs depending on the net effect
on dispute rates.
In developing the proposed rule, the Bureau has consulted, or
offered to consult with, the appropriate prudential regulators and
other Federal agencies, including regarding consistency with any
prudential, market, or systemic objectives administered by such
agencies.
B. Provisions To Be Analyzed
The analysis below considers the potential benefits, costs, and
impacts to consumers and covered persons of key provisions of the
proposed rule (proposed provisions), which include:
1. Prohibited communications with consumers.
2. Frequency limits for telephone calls and telephone
conversations.
3. Limited-content messages.
4. Time-barred debt: prohibiting suits and threats of suit.
5. Communication prior to furnishing information.
6. Prohibition on the sale or transfer of certain debts.
7. Notice for validation of debts.
8. Electronic disclosures and communications.
In addition to the proposed provisions listed above, the Bureau
proposes to codify several FDCPA provisions into the rule and to add
certain clarifying commentary.
C. Data Limitations and Quantification of Benefits, Costs, and Impacts
The discussion in this part VI.C relies on publicly available
information as well as information the Bureau has obtained. To better
understand consumer experiences with debt collection, the Bureau
developed its 2015 Debt Collection Consumer Survey, which provides the
first comprehensive and nationally representative data on consumers'
experiences and preferences related to debt collection.\606\ The Bureau
[[Page 23372]]
also relies on its consumer complaint data, its Consumer Credit Panel,
the Credit Card Database,\607\ and other sources to understand
potential benefits and costs to consumers of the proposed rule.\608\ To
better understand potential effects of the proposed rule on industry,
the Bureau has engaged in significant outreach to industry, including
the Operations Survey.\609\ In July 2016, the Bureau consulted with
small entities as part of the SBREFA process and obtained important
information on the potential impacts of proposals that the Bureau was
considering at the time, many of which are included in the proposed
rule.\610\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\606\ The Bureau's survey was conducted between December 2014
and March 2015. Consumers with and without debts in collection were
asked to complete this survey in order to provide the Bureau with
data necessary to understand experience and demographics of
consumers who have been contacted by debt collectors. Consumers were
selected using the Bureau's Consumer Credit Panel, a de-identified
1-in-48 sample of Americans with consumer reports at one of the
nationwide CRAs. See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra
note 18, at 7-10.
\607\ The Credit Card Database is a compilation of de-identified
loan-level information from the credit card portfolios of large
banks. See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., Credit Card Agreement
Database, https://www.consumerfinance.gov/credit-cards/agreements/
(last visited May 6, 2019).
\608\ For more information about Bureau data sources, see
Sources and Uses of Data at the Bureau of Consumer Financial
Protection (Sept. 2018), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/sources-and-uses-data-bureau-consumer-financial-protection/.
\609\ See CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45.
\610\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The sources described above, together with other sources of
information and the Bureau's market knowledge, form the basis for the
Bureau's consideration of the likely impacts of the proposed rule. The
Bureau makes every attempt to provide reasonable estimates of the
potential benefits and costs to consumers and covered persons of this
proposal. While the Debt Collection Consumer Survey provides
representative data on consumer experiences with debt collection, the
survey responses generally do not permit the Bureau to quantify, in
dollar terms, how particular proposed provisions will affect consumers.
With respect to industry impacts, much of the Bureau's existing data
come from qualitative input from debt collectors and other entities
that operate in this market rather than representative sampling that
would allow the Bureau to estimate total benefits and costs.
General economic principles and the Bureau's expertise in consumer
financial markets, together with the data and findings that are
available, provide insight into the potential benefits, costs, and
impacts of the proposed rule. Where possible, the Bureau has made
quantitative estimates based on these principles and the data
available. Some benefits and costs, however, are not amenable to
quantification, or are not quantifiable given the data available to the
Bureau. The Bureau provides a qualitative discussion of those benefits,
costs, and impacts. The Bureau requests additional data or studies that
could help quantify the benefits and costs to consumers and covered
persons of the proposed rule.
D. Baseline for Analysis
In evaluating the potential benefits, costs, and impacts of the
proposal, the Bureau takes as a baseline the current legal framework
governing debt collection. This includes the requirements of the FDCPA
as currently interpreted by courts and law enforcement agencies, other
Federal laws, and the rules and statutory requirements promulgated by
the States. In the consideration of benefits and costs below, the
Bureau discusses its understanding of practices in the debt collection
market under this baseline and how those practices would change under
the proposal.
Until the creation of the Bureau, no Federal agency was given the
authority to write substantive regulations implementing the FDCPA,
meaning that many of the FDCPA's requirements are subject to
interpretations in court decisions that are not always consistent or
fully authoritative, such as a single district court opinion on an
issue. Debt collectors' practices reflect their interpretations of the
FDCPA and their decisions about how to balance effective collection
practices against litigation risk. Many of the impacts of the proposed
rule relative to the baseline would arise from changes that debt
collectors would make in response to additional clarity about the most
appropriate interpretation of what conduct is permissible and not
permissible under the FDCPA's provisions.
E. Coverage of Proposal
The proposed rule would apply to debt collectors as defined in the
FDCPA. This definition encompasses a number of types of businesses,
which can be generally categorized as: Collection agencies, which
collect payments owed to their clients, often for a contingency fee;
debt buyers, which purchase delinquent debt and attempt to collect it,
either themselves or through agents, or who may have as their principal
purpose the collection of consumer debt; collection law firms that
either have as their principal purpose the collection of consumer debt
or regularly collect consumer debt owed to others; and loan servicers
when they acquire servicing of loans already in default.
Although creditors that collect on debts they own generally would
not be affected directly by the proposal, they may experience indirect
effects. Creditors that hire or sell debts to FDCPA-covered debt
collectors may experience higher costs if debt collectors' costs
increase and if those costs are passed on to creditors. As described
below, the Bureau believes that many compliance costs on FDCPA-covered
debt collectors will be one-time costs to come into compliance rather
than ongoing costs to stay in compliance. To the extent compliance
costs are incurred only once to adjust existing debt collectors'
systems and do not increase costs for new entrants, they are unlikely
to be passed on to creditors.
F. Potential Benefits and Costs to Consumers and Covered Persons
The Bureau discusses the benefits and costs of the proposal to
consumers and covered persons (generally FDCPA-covered debt collectors)
in detail below.\611\ The Bureau believes that an important benefit of
many of the proposed provisions to both consumers and covered persons--
compared to the baseline of the FDCPA as currently interpreted by
courts and law enforcement agencies--is an increase in clarity and
precision of the law governing debt collection. Greater certainty about
legal requirements can benefit both consumers and debt collectors,
making it easier for consumers to understand and assert their rights
and easier for firms to ensure they are in compliance. The Bureau
discusses these benefits in more detail with respect to certain
provisions below but believes that they generally apply, in varying
degrees, to all of the proposed provisions discussed below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\611\ For purposes of the section 1022(b)(2) analysis, the
Bureau considers any consequences that consumers perceive as harmful
to be a cost to consumers. In considering whether consumers might
perceive certain activities as harmful, the Bureau is not analyzing
whether those activities would be unlawful under the FDCPA or the
Dodd-Frank Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Prohibited Communications With Consumers
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b) generally would implement FDCPA section
805(a)'s prohibition on a debt collector communicating with a consumer
at unusual or inconvenient times and places, with a consumer
represented by an attorney, and at a consumer's place of employment.
This section would also expressly prohibit attempts to make
[[Page 23373]]
such communications, which debt collectors already must avoid given
that a successful attempt would be an FDCPA violation. Proposed Sec.
1006.14(h)(1) would interpret FDCPA section 806's prohibition on a debt
collector engaging in any conduct the natural consequence of which is
to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the
collection of a debt to prohibit debt collectors from communicating or
attempting to communicate with consumers through a medium of
communication if the consumer has requested that the debt collector not
use that medium to communicate with the consumer.
Debt collectors are already prohibited from communicating with
consumers at a time or place that is known or should be known to be
inconvenient to the consumer. The Bureau therefore expects that debt
collectors already keep track of what consumers tell them about the
times and places that they find inconvenient and avoid communicating or
attempting to communicate with consumers at those times or places.
Similarly, the proposed provisions regarding communication with
attorneys and at the consumer's place of employment track consumer debt
collector practices that are already required to comply with the FDCPA.
The Bureau understands that many debt collectors currently employ
systems and business processes designed to limit communication attempts
to consumers at inconvenient times and places and that many debt
collectors also use these systems and processes to prevent
communications with consumers through media that consumers have told
them are inconvenient. The proposed provisions might benefit consumers
and debt collectors by providing further clarity in the application of
the requirements of FDCPA section 805(a) and 806, but the Bureau does
not expect that the proposed provision would cause significant changes
to debt collectors' existing practices.
2. Frequency Limits for Telephone Calls and Telephone Conversations
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) would prohibit a debt collector from,
in connection with the collection of a debt, placing telephone calls or
engaging in telephone conversations repeatedly or continuously with
intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person at the called number.
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) provides that, subject to certain
exceptions set forth in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector
violates proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) if the debt collector places a
telephone call to a person in connection with the collection of a
particular debt either: (i) More than seven times within seven
consecutive days, or (ii) within a period of seven consecutive days
after having had a telephone conversation with the person in connection
with the collection of such debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would
clarify the effect of complying with the frequency limits in Sec.
1006.14(b)(2), stating that a debt collector who does not exceed the
limits complies with Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) and FDCPA section 806(5), and
does not, based on the frequency of its telephone calls, violate Sec.
1006.14(a), FDCPA section 806, or Dodd-Frank Act sections 1031 or
1036(a)(1)(B).
Potential benefits to consumers. Calls debt collectors make with
intent to annoy, abuse, or harass consumers are likely to cause them
harm, and the Bureau has evidence, discussed below and in part V, that
many consumers perceive harm from debt collectors' repeated telephone
calls.\612\ The proposed provision would limit this harm by capping the
frequency of telephone calls and telephone conversations.\613\ FDCPA
section 806 already prohibits conduct the natural consequence of which
is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person. FDCPA section 806(5) also
specifically prohibits repeated or continuous calling and telephone
conversations with ``intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person at
the called number.'' These prohibitions have been interpreted
differently by different courts, and while some debt collectors call
consumers less frequently than the proposed frequency limits would
permit, there are many debt collectors who place telephone calls to
consumers or engage consumers in telephone conversations more
frequently than the proposed frequency limits would permit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\612\ The FDCPA's standard of liability for excessive calling is
not perceived harm by consumers, but rather depends on the debt
collector's intent or the ``natural consequence'' of the conduct.
See FDCPA section 806(5) and 806, 15 U.S.C. 1692d(5) and 1692d.
Nonetheless, section 1022(b)(2)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act requires
the Bureau to consider the potential benefits and costs of its
regulation to consumers and covered persons, which may include
potential benefits or costs that were not contemplated or intended
by the FDCPA.
\613\ The proposed rule could have the ancillary effect of
preventing some calls that are not intended to annoy, abuse, or
harass consumers and could in fact prevent some calls that consumers
would find beneficial, as discussed below under ``Potential costs to
consumers.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To quantify consumer benefits from the proposed provision, the
Bureau would need information regarding both how much the provision
would reduce the number of calls debt collectors place to consumers and
the benefit (or harm) each consumer would receive as a result of this
reduction. Although the Bureau's data do not permit it to reliably
quantify either the reduction in call frequency or how much borrowers
would value this reduction in dollar terms, the discussion below
summarizes the data available to the Bureau on these two points.
Data from the CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey indicate that
debt collectors often may attempt to contact consumers more frequently
than seven times per week. In the survey, 35 percent of consumers who
had been contacted by a debt collector said the debt collector had
contacted or attempted to contact them four or more times per week,
including 14 percent who said the debt collector had contacted or
attempted to contact them eight or more times per week.\614\ Another 29
percent said that the debt collector had attempted to contact them one
to three times per week.\615\ The survey question did not ask
respondents to distinguish between actual contacts and contact
attempts, and consumers are likely not aware of all unsuccessful
contact attempts. Still, the survey responses suggest that it is not
uncommon for debt collectors to attempt to telephone consumers more
than seven times per week, and the responses would be consistent with
many debt collectors having live telephone conversations with consumers
more frequently than the one time per week that generally would be
permitted under the proposal.\616\ Based on this, it is reasonable to
estimate that at least 6.9 million consumers \617\ are called by debt
collectors more than seven times in one week during a year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\614\ CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at 44
n.5.
\615\ Id.
\616\ Information from industry also confirms that debt
collectors sometimes attempt to communicate more than seven times
per week. See discussion under ``Costs to covered persons'' below.
\617\ This is calculated as 14 percent of an estimated 49
million consumers contacted by debt collectors each year. The Bureau
estimates that about 32 percent of consumers with a credit file, or
about 67 million, are contacted each year by a creditor or debt
collector attempting to collect a debt. Of those, 23 percent were
most recently contacted by a creditor, 63 percent by a debt
collector, and 15 percent did not know whether the contact was from
a creditor or debt collector. Based on this, the Bureau estimates
that 73 percent of consumers were contacted by a debt collector,
assuming that the share of consumers contacted by a debt collector
is the same in this group as it is among consumers who did know
whether the most recent contact was from a debt collector. See CFPB
Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at 13, 40-41.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey provides evidence that
many consumers would benefit if they received fewer calls from debt
collectors, although it does not provide
[[Page 23374]]
evidence with which to estimate the dollar value of those benefits.
Most respondents who had been contacted by a debt collector at least
once per week said they had been contacted too often. As shown in Table
1, 95 percent of respondents who said debt collectors had contacted or
attempted to contact them four or more times per week and 76 percent of
those reporting contact or attempted contact one to three times per
week said that they had been contacted too often by the debt collector,
whereas 22 percent of those contacted less than once per week said they
had been contacted too often.
Table 1--Consumers Indicating They Had Been Contacted Too Often, by
Contact Frequency
[Percent]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers who
said they were
Contact frequency contacted too
often
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Less than once per week................................. 22
One to three times per week............................. 76
Four or more times per week............................. 95
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The survey questions did not distinguish between contact attempts
and contacts that result in a live communication. They also did not
distinguish among different types of contact, and survey responses may
have included contacts such as letters or emails that would not be
included in the proposed limits.\618\ Nonetheless, the results indicate
that a large majority of consumers who are contacted at least once per
week believe they are being contacted too frequently.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\618\ The survey suggests that contact attempts from debt
collectors other than by telephone or letter are relatively
uncommon. Id. at 42, table 22. The Bureau understands that debt
collectors seldom send letters more than once per week, so the
survey responses suggest that a large majority of contact attempts
are by telephone.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's consumer complaint data also indicate that consumers
find frequent or repeated calls harmful. Communication tactics ranked
third in debt collection complaints submitted to the Bureau during
2018, and the majority of complaints in this category--55 percent, or
about 6,000 complaints during 2018--were about frequent or repeated
telephone calls.\619\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\619\ See 2018 FDCPA Annual Report, supra note 16, at 16-17,
table 1. Also note that consumers can identify only one issue to
categorize their complaints, so that the count does not include
cases in which a consumer chooses a different issue (such as ``I
don't owe the debt'') but still express concern about call
frequency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the Bureau does not have evidence that could be used to
estimate the monetary value consumers attach to a reduction in call
frequency, there is indirect evidence of costs consumers are willing to
bear to avoid unwanted calls. One leading service that offers to block
inbound ``robocalls'' to a consumer's cellular telephone charges $1.99
per month for the service and claims over 1,000,000 users. Such
services are an imperfect analogy to the proposed frequency limits for
at least two different reasons: First, they are intended to completely
block calls rather than limit their frequency; and second, such
services block telemarketing calls in addition to debt collection
calls, while not blocking all debt collection calls. Given these
differences, the price of this service does not provide a precise
analog for the value to consumers of the proposed call frequency
limits. Nonetheless, the example does provide evidence that many
consumers are willing to pay prices in the range of $24 per year to
avoid unwanted telephone calls.\620\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\620\ Another source of indirect evidence on the value to
consumers of reduced call frequency is the Bureau's consumer
complaints. The Bureau received approximately 6,000 complaints about
call frequency during 2018. See id. Based on the Bureau's records,
the average time for a consumer to file a complaint with the Bureau
by telephone or through the web portal is approximately 15 minutes,
although this varies over time and across complaint categories.
Valuing consumers' time using the average U.S. private sector wage
of approximately $27 per hour suggests that some consumers are
willing to give up approximately $6.75 worth of their time in hopes
of reducing call frequency from one debt collector. See U.S. Dept.
of Labor, Bureau of Lab. Stat., Economic News Release: Employment
Situation, table B-3 (Feb. 1, 2019), https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t19.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some of the benefits from the proposed call frequency limits could
be obtained if consumers used protections they already have under the
FDCPA to help them avoid too-frequent debt collection calls. Debt
collectors must cease most communications in response to a written
request from the consumer to do so. Furthermore, because section
805(a)(1) of the FDCPA prohibits debt collectors from communicating
about a debt at any time or place that the debt collector knows or
should know is inconvenient to the consumer, debt collectors risk
violating section 805(a)(1) if they do not take heed when consumers say
they do not want to communicate at certain times or places. However,
many consumers may not want to completely cease communication about a
debt because, for example, debt collectors who cannot recover through
such communications may initiate litigation to recover on the debt.
Many consumers may also be unaware of their rights to limit whether and
how debt collectors communicate with them. For example, consumers who
tell debt collectors to cease communication orally may not benefit
because some debt collectors may not respond to consumers' requests to
limit communications unless they are made in writing. In the Debt
Collection Consumer Survey, 42 percent of respondents who had been
contacted about a debt in collection reported having requested that a
creditor or debt collector stop contacting them.\621\ These respondents
generally did not make the request in writing.\622\ Of these consumers,
approximately 75 percent reported that the creditor or debt collector
did not stop attempting to contact them.\623\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\621\ CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at
35, table 17.
\622\ Of consumers who asked not to be contacted, 87 percent
said they made the request by telephone or in person only. Id. at
34-35.
\623\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, technological solutions are also increasingly
available to consumers who want to avoid certain calls and may be used
to screen out calls from some debt collectors. However, such solutions
may be under-inclusive (in that they do not screen out calls from all
debt collectors) or over-inclusive (in that a consumer may want to
maintain some telephone contact with a debt collector rather than
eliminating all calls from that debt collector).
Potential costs to consumers. Consumers may benefit from
communicating with debt collectors about their debts. For consumers
being contacted about a debt they in fact owe, communicating with the
debt collector may help consumers resolve the debt, which could help
avoid further fees and interest, credit reporting harms, or lawsuits.
For consumers being contacted about a debt they do not owe,
communications from debt collectors may alert consumers to errors in
their credit reports or that they are victims of identity theft. During
the meeting of the Small Business Review Panel, some debt collectors
said that frequency limits could extend the period needed to establish
contact with a consumer, as further discussed below under ``Potential
costs to covered persons.'' If the proposed frequency limits mean that
debt collectors are less able to reach some consumers, or that
communication with some consumers is delayed, those consumers may be
harmed.
To quantify any such harm, the Bureau would need data to estimate
how the proposed frequency limits would affect whether and when debt
collectors communicate with consumers as well as the harm consumers
[[Page 23375]]
experience when they do not communicate with debt collectors. The
Bureau discusses the available evidence on how the proposed frequency
limits would affect whether debt collectors communicate with consumers
below in its discussion of costs to covered persons. As discussed
there, the data are limited, but evidence the Bureau does have suggests
that the proposed limits might somewhat reduce the number of consumers
reached by telephone within a few months after a debt collector starts
attempting contact, but that the reduction is likely to be limited to a
relatively small fraction of debts.
The Bureau does not have representative data that can be used to
quantify the harm consumers experience when they do not communicate
with debt collectors, or when those communications are delayed. If
consumers do not communicate with debt collectors about debts, they
could suffer additional harm from debt collection in some cases,
particularly if the debt collector or creditor initiates a lawsuit. A
suit could lead to increased fees, legal costs, and the possibility of
a judgment that could lead to garnishment of wages or other legal steps
to recover the debt.
To the extent that some debt collectors currently call less than
the proposed frequency limits to avoid legal risks, such debt
collectors could increase their calling frequency as a result of the
proposal. This would result in costs to some consumers if they find the
increase in call frequency harmful.
Potential benefits to covered persons. As with several other
provisions of the proposed rule, the proposed limits would reduce legal
uncertainty about the interpretation of existing FDCPA language.
Frequent telephone calls are a consistent source of consumer-initiated
litigation and consumer complaints to Federal and State law enforcement
agencies. By establishing a clear standard for call frequency, the
proposed provision would make it easier for debt collectors to know
what calling patterns are permitted and avoid the costs of litigation
and threats of litigation. To the extent that some debt collectors
currently call less than the proposed frequency limits to avoid legal
risks, such debt collectors could increase their calling frequency,
potentially increasing collection revenue.
Some debt collectors might also benefit from a reduction in calls
made by other debt collectors. The Bureau understands that many
consumers have multiple debts being collected by different debt
collectors.\624\ In seeking payments from consumers, multiple debt
collectors compete with each other for consumers' attention, which can
lead to a large aggregate number of debt collection calls, potentially
overwhelming some consumers and making them less likely to answer calls
or otherwise engage with debt collectors.\625\ This in turn could make
it harder for each debt collector to recover outstanding debt.\626\
Thus, one potential benefit to debt collectors of the proposed call
frequency limits is a lower frequency of telephone calls by other debt
collectors, which could make consumers more likely to engage and repay.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\624\ The Bureau's survey indicates that 72 percent of consumers
with a debt in collection were contacted about two or more debts in
collection, and 16 percent were contacted about five or more debts.
Id. at 13, table 1.
\625\ For example, borrowers could simply ignore telephone calls
or could adopt call screening or blocking technology.
\626\ In other words, debt collectors may face a ``prisoner's
dilemma,'' in which each debt collector has incentives to call more
frequently even though debt collectors might collectively benefit
from a mutual reduction in call frequency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, some debt collectors specialize in approaches to
collection that do not rely on frequent call attempts, and these debt
collectors may benefit from the proposed call frequency limits. In
particular, debt collectors who focus on litigation and those who
communicate with consumers primarily by means not covered by the
proposed limits, such as letters and emails, may be more effective in
communicating with consumers relative to debt collectors who are
affected by the proposed limits. This, in turn, may increase their
market share at the expense of debt collectors who are more dependent
on frequent calls.
Potential costs to covered persons. The proposed provision would
impose at least two categories of costs on debt collectors. First, it
would mean that debt collectors must track the frequency of outbound
telephone calls, which would require many debt collectors to bear one-
time costs to update their systems and train staff, and which would
create ongoing costs for some debt collectors. Second, for some debt
collectors, the proposed provision would require a reduction in the
frequency with which they place telephone calls to consumers, which
could make it harder to reach consumers and delay or reduce collections
revenue.
With respect to one-time implementation costs, many debt collectors
would incur costs to revise their systems to incorporate the proposed
call frequency limits. Such revisions could range from small updates to
existing systems to the introduction of completely new systems and
processes. The Bureau understands that larger debt collectors generally
already implement system limits on call frequency to comply with client
contractual requirements, debt collector internal policies, and State
and local laws.\627\ Such debt collectors might need only to revise
existing calling restrictions to ensure that existing systems comply
with the caps. Larger collection agencies might also need to respond to
client requests for additional reports and audit items to verify that
they comply with the caps, which could require these agencies to make
systems changes to alter the reports and data they produce for their
clients to review.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\627\ See CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45,
at 28-29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smaller debt collectors and collection law firms are less likely to
have existing systems that track or limit calling frequency, and may
therefore face larger costs to establish systems to do so. However,
many smaller debt collectors report that they generally attempt to
reach each consumer by telephone only one or two times per week and
generally do not speak to a consumer more than one time per week, which
suggests that their practices are already within the proposed frequency
limits.\628\ For such debt collectors, existing policies may be
sufficient to ensure compliance with the proposed provision.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\628\ See id. at 29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to ongoing costs of compliance, the Bureau expects
that the proposed limit on call attempts in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i)
could have an impact on some debt collectors' ability to reach
consumers, particularly when the debt collector has not yet established
contact with a consumer. These impacts are discussed below. The
Bureau's understanding, based on feedback from small entity
representatives and other industry outreach, is that the proposed limit
of one telephone conversation per week in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) is
unlikely to affect debt collectors' ability to communicate with
consumers in most cases.629 630
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\629\ The impact might be greater if consumers could not consent
to more frequent contact. For example, if a debt collector reached a
consumer on the telephone and the consumer said it was not a good
time to speak, then the proposal would permit the debt collector and
consumer to agree to speak again at a specified time within less
than one week. See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(3)(ii).
\630\ Similarly, the Bureau expects that debt collectors would
be largely unaffected by the proposal to apply the frequency limits
to location contacts with third parties because the Bureau
understands that while location calls may be made to several
numbers, they do not generally involve frequently calling each
number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23376]]
The proposed limit of placing no more than seven telephone calls
per week would cause many debt collectors to place telephone calls less
frequently than they currently do. This decrease in telephone calls may
impose ongoing costs on debt collectors by increasing the time it takes
to establish contact with consumers. Most debt collectors rely heavily
on telephone calls as a means of establishing contact with consumers.
While debt collectors generally send letters in addition to
calling,\631\ the Bureau understands that response rates to letters can
be quite low. If contact with consumers is delayed, it will delay
collection revenue and may reduce revenue if consumers who are reached
later are less willing or able to repay the debt. In addition, if the
debt collector is unable to reach the consumer using the permitted
number of telephone calls during the period the owner of the debt
permits the debt collector to attempt to collect the debt, then the
call frequency limits might prevent a debt collector from reaching the
consumer entirely.\632\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\631\ In the Bureau's survey, 85 percent of respondents who had
been contacted by a debt collector said that they had been contacted
by telephone and 71 percent said that they had been contacted by
letter. Respondents were asked to select all ways in which they had
been contacted. CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 29-30, table 14.
\632\ If the provision were to cause some debt collectors to
lose revenue for this reason, the amounts not collected would
generally be transferred to another party: Either to consumers (if
the amounts were never collected) or to another debt collector (if
the amounts were collected through further collection efforts,
including through a lawsuit).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some debt collectors do not place telephone calls frequently enough
to be affected by the proposed caps. While the Bureau understands that
some debt collectors regularly call consumers two to three times per
day or more, others have told the Bureau that they seldom attempt to
call more than once or twice per week. These differences may reflect
different debt types and collection strategies. For example, smaller
debt collectors frequently retain debts indefinitely, and they may face
less pressure to reach consumers quickly than debt collectors who
collect debts for a limited period. Debt collectors who focus on
litigation may also place less emphasis on establishing telephone
communication with consumers.
Some debt collectors have indicated that frequent calling is
especially important if the debt collector has multiple potential
telephone numbers and does not know the best way to reach the
consumer.\633\ Additionally, some debt collectors specialize in
attempting to collect debts for which the creditor has lost contact
with the consumer, and frequent call attempts to establish contact with
the consumer may be especially important for such debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\633\ See, e.g., Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note
57, at appendix A (letter from Venable).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For debt collectors who currently call consumers more frequently,
the proposed frequency limits could affect when and if they establish
communication with consumers. The Bureau does not have representative
data that would permit it to quantify how the proposed limits on call
frequency would impact how long it takes to establish contact or
whether contact is established at all. However, the Bureau has analyzed
microdata on outbound calling from one large collection agency (Calling
Data) that helps illustrate the potential impact of the proposed
limits. While the data from this agency may not be representative of
the market as a whole, the results of the Bureau's analysis of the data
are generally consistent with summary information shared by other large
collection agencies.\634\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\634\ The summary information was shared with Bureau staff
during industry outreach meetings that are part of the Bureau's
routine market-monitoring efforts. Although most debt collectors are
small firms, evidence suggests that a majority of debt collected is
collected by collection agencies with 100 or more employees. See
CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Calling Data show that, in the first eight weeks of
collections, the overall frequency of call attempts to consumers who
have not yet spoken with the debt collector declines slowly. Roughly 40
percent of consumers receive more than seven calls per week in the
first four weeks, but this drops to 27 percent by week eight. Although
the overall distribution of contact attempts changes slowly from week
to week, the data show that over time some consumers get called more,
while others get called less. Consumers with whom a ``right-party
contact'' (RPC) has been established and who made no payment and
consumers for whom RPC has not been achieved tend to receive the most
collection calls. Consumers who have engaged but made a partial payment
receive fewer calls. Moreover, the debt collector who provided the
Calling Data engages in ``call sloping,'' meaning that it places fewer
total calls each week that it works a portfolio of debts.
The Calling Data show that, for the debts included in that data
set, consumers who take longer to reach are not less likely to pay.
Although the probability that each call results in an RPC declines with
successive calls, the rate at which RPCs are translated into payments
increases steadily through at least the first 50 calls. As a result, an
RPC that is achieved in any of the first 50 calls is approximately
equal in value to the debt collector as an RPC that is achieved with
fewer calls, suggesting that call attempts remain important to debt
collection even after many calls have been attempted.
Summary data provided by some other large debt collectors indicate
that the number of calls needed to reach consumers can vary
considerably, but that the majority of debts would not be affected or
would be affected very little by the proposed frequency limits. These
data indicate that 50 percent or more of consumers who are ultimately
reached by these debt collectors are reached within the first seven
calls overall (not per week), though other debt collectors have
indicated that it takes 15 to 21 calls to reach 50 percent of such
consumers. These data also indicate that reaching 95 percent of
consumers may take between 50 and 60 calls, meaning that 5 percent of
consumers reached are contacted only after more than 50 or 60
communication attempts.
There are limitations to using the data discussed above to make
inferences about how limits on telephone calls may affect debt
collectors' ability to reach consumers. This is in part because
establishing contact depends on factors other than the number of calls
made (e.g., the time of day called) and in part because debt collectors
subject to frequency limits might change their contact behavior in ways
that permit them to reach a given number of consumers with fewer calls,
as discussed further below. In addition, other aspects of the proposed
rule, including the provision that would clarify the legal status of
limited-content voice messages, could make it easier for debt
collectors to reach consumers with a smaller number of calls.
The data discussed above may not be representative, meaning that
some debt collectors might need more or fewer calls to reach similar
numbers of consumers. Overall, however, the available data suggest that
the proposed limits would somewhat reduce the ability of debt
collectors to reach consumers by telephone within a few months, but
that the reduction is likely to be limited to a relatively small
fraction of debts. This could affect primarily debt collectors who
receive placements of debts for four to six months and do not engage in
litigation. Such debt collectors could lose revenue if the limits
prevent them from
[[Page 23377]]
establishing contact with consumers or if collections based on
telephone calls become less effective and, as a result, creditors place
more debts with debt collectors specializing in litigation.
To illustrate potential effects of the provision on debt collector
revenue, the Bureau used the Calling Data to simulate the effect of the
proposed frequency limits under specific assumptions about how the call
frequency limits affect collections. That is, the Bureau created a
``but-for'' version of the Calling Data in which calls that would not
have been permitted under the proposed frequency limits were assumed to
have been either delayed or eliminated, and compared RPCs and payments
in this ``but-for'' data with the actual outcomes achieved by the debt
collector. This is at best a rough approximation of the effects of the
proposed provision, both because it relies heavily on the assumptions
made and because it is based on the data of one particular debt
collector, and may not be representative of other firms in the
industry.
The Bureau created two versions of its simulation analysis, one of
which uses more conservative assumptions as to the impact of the
proposed provision on successful contacts and collections. However, the
Bureau believes that even the more conservative version of this
analysis likely overstates the potential effects of the proposed
frequency limits because it cannot reflect any changes the debt
collector would make to its calling strategy in response to the
frequency limits. That is, one would expect a rational collection firm
to strategically choose which calls to eliminate or delay in response
to the proposed frequency limits, while the Bureau's analysis must to
some extent select calls arbitrarily. In particular, at least for the
debt collector who provided data to the Bureau, debts with multiple
telephone numbers would be most likely to be affected by the frequency
limits. The Bureau is not able to identify telephone type (such as
mobile vs. landline, or work vs. home) in the data, but the debt
collector would generally be able to do so. The Bureau would expect
debt collectors in similar situations to omit calls to less promising
telephone numbers, rather than call the same telephones and cease
calling earlier in the process.
In the first, more conservative version of the simulation (Version
1), the Bureau assumed that all calls in excess of the proposed
frequency limit each week were simply shifted to the next week.\635\
The Bureau assumed that any successful RPCs that occur after the 25th
simulated week would never occur under a frequency limit because in
reality the debt collector was only contracted to collect on the debts
in the data for up to 25 weeks. Version 1 implicitly assumes that the
probability that a call results in an RPC does not depend on how much
time has passed since collection began, only on the number of calls
that have been made.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\635\ For example, if the debt collector called a particular
consumer 10 times in the first week, eight times in the second week,
and five times in the third week, in the Bureau's simulation, the
last three calls in the first week would become the first three
calls in the second week. The second week would then have a total of
11 calls, and the last four calls would become the first four calls
in the third week. The third week would then have eight calls, so
the last call would become the first call of the fourth week, and so
on.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a second, more aggressive version of the simulation (Version 2),
the Bureau assumed that any calls that would be above the proposed
frequency limit are eliminated, rather than shifted forward. When a
consumer's first RPC would have occurred on a call that would not be
permitted under the proposed frequency limit in a given week, the
Bureau treats the data for that debt as censored as of that week.\636\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\636\ That is, the Bureau assumes that it does not know when or
whether that consumer would ever have a successful RPC, only that
there was no RPC up until that week. The Bureau then calculates the
percent of debts with an RPC by the 25th week of collections using
the Kaplan-Meier product limit estimator for the survival function,
a standard tool for measuring rates of an outcome when some
observations are censored. It is necessary to assume that such
consumers are censored because in reality after an initial RPC, the
debt collector generally changes its calling behavior, particularly
if it obtains a promise to pay.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau made additional assumptions that were common to both
versions of the simulation. For inbound calls, that is, calls from
consumers to the debt collector, the Bureau assumed that the calls were
not delayed or eliminated. Thus, the Bureau is implicitly assuming that
inbound calls are prompted by letters from the debt collector or other
external factors, rather than by a number of calls.\637\ The Bureau
also made additional assumptions to simulate the effect on payments.
The Calling Data indicate if the consumer ever paid and how much, but
they do not always indicate when payment was received--the Bureau
observes the timing of payments only if the consumer made a payment
over the telephone. About one-half of all consumers in the data who
make at least a partial payment do so without ever having an RPC. For
the simulation, the Bureau assumed that, if the debt collector achieved
at least one RPC in the simulation, then the amount of any payments
made by the consumer is unchanged. If the consumer received an RPC in
the original data but did not receive any RPC in the simulation, the
Bureau assumed that any payments recorded in the original data did not
occur for purposes of the simulation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\637\ The debt collector who provided the data does not leave
voicemails, but it is possible that consumers eventually return a
call in response to repeated missed calls on their telephones.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2 shows the results of the simulation analysis described
above. Under Version 1, the proposed frequency limit would reduce first
RPCs by 2.76 percent of the first RPCs and dollars collected by 1
percent.\638\ The average first RPC would be delayed by less than one
week. These effects are not evenly distributed across consumers,
however. In the simulation, the debt collector is much more likely to
miss an RPC or payment when it calls multiple telephone numbers for a
consumer.\639\ For consumers where the debt collector calls only one
telephone number, hardly any miss an RPC in the simulation, and the
average delay is almost zero. This is because the debt collector rarely
calls a particular telephone more than seven times per week. In
contrast, for consumers where the debt collector calls five or more
telephone numbers, the simulation predicts that the frequency limit
would eliminate more
[[Page 23378]]
than 7 percent of RPCs and delay the remaining RPCs by almost two
weeks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\638\ The change in payments is less than the change in RPCs
both because some consumers pay without an RPC (and the Bureau
assumed this did not change in the simulation) and because consumers
in the data who had an earlier first RPC, and thus were less likely
to be affected by the frequency limits, were also more likely to pay
in full.
\639\ The Bureau does not observe in the data how many telephone
numbers the consumer has, only how many the debt collector chooses
to call.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The assumptions of Version 2 suggest a more substantial effect on
RPCs and collections, although the Bureau notes again that even Version
1 likely overstates the potential effect of the proposed provision. The
simulation predicts that RPCs would decline by 15.7 percent, and
dollars collected would decline by 7.7 percent.
Table 2--Results of Simulation Analysis
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Percent change
Assumed effect of Percent change Average delay in dollars
Version proposed call frequency in RPCs within in remaining collected
limit 25 weeks RPCs (weeks) within 25
weeks
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Version 1............................. Calls above limit roll -2.76 0.85 -1.04
to next week.
Version 2............................. Calls above limit -15.7 0 -7.7
eliminated.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall, the Bureau believes that the simulation analysis
overstates the potential effect of the provision because it ignores any
changes debt collectors would make to mitigate the effects of the call
frequency limit. Nevertheless, certain assumptions that the Bureau
makes for simplicity likely reduce the predicted impact of the
provision. In particular, in Version 1 the Bureau assumes that a call
with an RPC that is shifted later due to the proposed frequency limit
will remain an RPC. This may not be true in practice. Empirically, the
probability that a call results in an RPC declines over time--this is
evident in the data examined by the Bureau and is consistent with input
from industry stakeholders. If consumers are less likely to answer the
telephone as time passes, irrespective of the number of calls debt
collectors have made, the proposed frequency limit could reduce
payments and revenue by a larger fraction than the simulation suggests
(assuming no re-optimization by debt collectors).\640\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\640\ Another assumption that might reduce the predicted effect
of the proposed frequency limits in both versions is the assumption
that payment is tied to whether or not the first RPC occurs. For
instance, in Version 1, the Bureau assumed that a consumer would not
pay under the frequency limits only if the first RPC would have
occurred after the 25th week in the simulation. Yet about a quarter
of consumers in the data who eventually pay some portion of their
debt had at least two RPCs. It may be that the subsequent RPCs were
necessary for the payment to occur, but the Bureau's analysis did
not track whether subsequent RPCs occurred after the 25th week under
the simulated frequency limits. The Bureau also notes there is an
implicit assumption in both versions of the simulation that could
lead to overstating the effect of the proposed frequency limits. The
simulation assumes that, if all RPCs for a consumer were eliminated
by the proposed frequency limits, then the consumer would never pay.
Given that, as noted above, a substantial number of consumers in the
original data pay despite having no RPCs, it is possible that some
consumers whose RPCs were eliminated by the proposed frequency
limits would nonetheless pay something eventually.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors could take steps to reduce the number of calls
necessary to establish contact and mitigate any lost revenue from the
proposed frequency limit. As indicated, if multiple telephone numbers
are available, debt collectors might reduce their calls to numbers that
they can identify as being less likely to yield a successful contact.
In addition, the Bureau understands that debt collectors can reduce the
number of calls needed to establish an RPC by purchasing higher-quality
contact information from data vendors.
In addition and as discussed below, the Bureau's proposed rule also
includes provisions that could reduce the legal risks associated with
other means of communication, such as voice messages or emails, which
could enable debt collectors to reach consumers more effectively with
fewer calls. This could mitigate the impact of call frequency limits
and might mean that the net effect of the proposal would be to increase
the likelihood that debt collectors are able to reach consumers. In
addition, debt collectors who are unable to reach consumers as a result
of frequency limits might still pursue such debts through litigation.
To the extent that frequent call attempts play a more important role in
collecting certain types of debt relative to others, some debt
collectors might shift their business toward collecting those types for
which frequent calls are less important.
The Bureau requests data and other information about the benefits
and costs of the proposed frequency limits for both consumers and debt
collectors. In particular, the Bureau requests data and other
information on current calling practices, how those practices are
likely to be affected by the proposed frequency limits, and how those
changes are likely to affect debt collectors' ability to contact
consumers.
Alternative approaches to limiting the frequency of communications
or communication attempts. The Bureau considered alternatives to the
proposed frequency limits on debt collector telephone calls and
telephone conversations. The potential benefits and costs of those
alternatives to consumers and covered persons relative to the proposal
are discussed briefly below.
The Bureau considered proposing a broader version of proposed Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(i) that would have prohibited repeated or continuous
attempts to contact a person by other media, such as by sending
letters, emails, or text messages to a person in connection with the
collection of a debt. Such an approach could provide additional
benefits to consumers if they are harassed or abused by frequent
communication from debt collectors who use such media. However, as
discussed in part V, the Bureau is not aware of evidence demonstrating
that debt collectors commonly harass consumers or others through
repeated or continuous debt collection contacts by media other than
telephone calls. The cost of sending letters is much higher than that
of placing telephone calls, which likely discourages frequent
communication by mail, and the Bureau has received few complaints about
debt collectors sending excessive letters. The Bureau understands that
few debt collectors currently communicate by email or text message, and
stakeholders have suggested that such media may be inherently less
harassing than telephone calls because, for example, recipients may
have more ability to decide whether or when to engage with an email or
a text message than with a debt collection telephone call.
In addition, during the SBREFA process, some small entity
representatives suggested that compliance with a rule that limited the
frequency of communications by media other than telephone calls would
be more costly than compliance with a rule that applied only to calls.
These small entity representatives indicated that, while many existing
debt collection systems already track the frequency of telephone calls,
modifying systems to
[[Page 23379]]
track communication by other media would be significantly more
expensive.
The Bureau also considered a proposal that would have limited the
number of calls permitted to any particular telephone number (e.g., at
most two calls to each of a consumer's landline, mobile, and work
telephone numbers). The Bureau considered such a limit either instead
of or in addition to an overall limit on the frequency of telephone
calls to one consumer. Such an alternative could potentially reduce the
effect of frequency limits on debt collector calls if it permitted more
total calls when a consumer has multiple telephone numbers. Such an
approach could impose smaller costs on debt collectors in some cases by
making it easier to contact consumers for whom debt collectors have
multiple telephone numbers. At the same time, such an approach might
provide smaller consumer benefits compared to the proposal by
potentially permitting a high frequency of calls in some cases. Some
consumers could receive (and some debt collectors could place) more
telephone calls simply based on the number of telephone numbers that
certain consumers happened to have (and that debt collectors happened
to know about). Such an approach also could create incentives for debt
collectors to, for example, place telephone calls to less convenient
telephone numbers after exhausting their telephone calls to consumers'
preferred numbers.
3. Limited-Content Messages
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j) would define a limited-content message as
a message for a consumer that includes all of the content described in
Sec. 1006.2(j)(1), that may include any of the content described in
Sec. 1006.2(j)(2), and that includes no other content. In particular,
proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) provides that a limited-content message
must include all of the following: The consumer's name, a request that
the consumer reply to the message, the name or names of one or more
natural persons whom the consumer can contact to reply to the debt
collector, a telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to the
debt collector, and, if applicable, a disclosure explaining how the
consumer can stop receiving messages through a particular medium.\641\
Proposed Sec. 1006.2(j)(2) provides that a limited-content message
also may include one or more of the following: A salutation, the date
and time of the message, a generic statement that the message relates
to an account, and suggested dates and times for the consumer to reply
to the message. Proposed Sec. 1006.2(b) and (d), which define the
terms attempt to communicate and communication, respectively, provide
that a limited-content message is an attempt to communicate but is not
a communication.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\641\ As discussed below, proposed Sec. 1006.6(e) would require
a debt collector who communicates or attempts to communicate with a
consumer electronically in connection with the collection of a debt
using a particular email address, telephone number for text
messages, or other electronic-medium address to include in such
communication or attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous
statement describing one or more ways the consumer can opt out of
further electronic communications or attempts to communicate by the
debt collector to that address or telephone number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Potential benefits and costs to consumers. As discussed below under
``potential benefits and costs to covered persons,'' many debt
collectors currently do not leave voice or text messages for consumers
because of the risk of litigation. The Bureau expects that, by
clarifying that ``communication'' for purposes of the FDCPA does not
include the proposed limited-content message, the proposed rule would
make debt collectors more likely to leave voice or text messages if
they are unable to reach consumers by telephone.
In general, an increased use of voice and text messages should make
it more convenient for consumers to communicate with debt collectors
because consumers will be better able to arrange a discussion at a time
that is convenient for them rather than at a time when the debt
collector happens to reach them. Related to this, some consumers
express annoyance at receiving repeated calls from callers who do not
leave messages. To the extent that debt collectors respond to the
proposed rule by leaving messages when a consumer does not answer the
telephone, the proposal might help address that problem.
If more debt collectors are willing to leave messages, it may lead
to an indirect benefit to consumers by reducing the number of unwanted
call attempts without reducing the likelihood that consumers
communicate with debt collectors. Although some debt collectors may
leave frequent messages or continue to call frequently despite having
left messages, an industry trade publication recommends a best practice
of waiting three to seven days after leaving a message to give the
consumer an opportunity to return the call.\642\ During the meeting of
the Small Business Review Panel, small entity representatives indicated
that limited-content messages would reduce the need for frequent
calling.\643\ Thus, some consumers may experience reduced numbers of
calls if more debt collectors leave messages and wait for a return
call.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\642\ insideARM, Operations Guide: Call Volume 10 (Nov. 14,
2014).
\643\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors cannot be certain that a voice message will be
heard only by the consumer for whom it was left. Some consumers could
be harmed by an increase in limited-content messages, either because
they are harassed by frequent messages or because the messages increase
the risk of third-party disclosure. Although the message itself would
not convey any information about the debt, some third parties who hear
the message may discover that the caller is a debt collector, either
because they have familiarity with the type of generic messages that
debt collectors leave or because they do further research, such as by
researching the telephone number. On the other hand, the proposal might
lead debt collectors who currently leave more detailed messages that
risk revealing the purpose of the call to third parties to switch to
messages that reveal no information about the debt. In such instances,
the impact of the proposal may be to reduce the likelihood of third-
party disclosures.
Survey results indicate that consumers are concerned about third
parties overhearing voice messages left by debt collectors, with nearly
two-thirds of consumers saying it is very important that others do not
hear or see a message from a creditor or debt collector, as shown in
Table 3 below. However, most respondents also said that they would
prefer that a voice message from a debt collector indicate that the
caller is attempting to collect a debt. Even among consumers who said
it was ``very important'' that others not see or hear messages about
debt collection, 63 percent said they preferred that the purpose of the
call be included in a message from a creditor or debt collector
attempting to collect the debt. This suggests that many consumers
either do not expect third parties to overhear voice messages left for
them or attach greater importance to knowing what the call is about
than to the risk a third party will overhear the message.
[[Page 23380]]
Table 3--Preferences Regarding Others Seeing or Hearing Debt Collector
Message
[Percent]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers
Importance of others not seeing or contacted
hearing a message All consumers about a debt
in collection
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Very important.......................... 64 65
Somewhat important...................... 23 24
Not at all important.................... 14 10
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Potential benefits and costs to covered persons. The Bureau
understands that many debt collectors avoid leaving messages, or leave
them only under limited circumstances, because of the legal risk
associated with leaving a message. Currently, debt collectors leaving a
voice message for a consumer either omit the disclosure stating that
the call is from a debt collector (the so-called ``mini-Miranda''
warning) and risk being deemed in violation of FDCPA section 807(11) or
include that disclosure and risk that the existence of a debt will be
disclosed to a third party hearing the message and that they will be
deemed in violation of FDCPA section 805(b). The proposed provision
would reduce both direct and indirect costs to some debt collectors by
interpreting the FDCPA not to require the mini-Miranda warning in a
limited-content message, which would reduce legal risks associated with
messages.
Debt collectors may indirectly benefit from clarification of the
type of messages that may be left because messages may make it easier
to establish contact with consumers. Currently, many debt collectors
limit or avoid leaving messages for fear of FDCPA liability.\644\
Leaving messages may be a more efficient way of reaching consumers than
repeated call attempts without leaving messages. For example, consumers
who do not answer calls from callers they do not recognize might return
a message. If so, the proposed provision could permit debt collectors
to reach such consumers with fewer contact attempts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\644\ In the Bureau's Debt Collection Operations Study, 42 of 58
respondents reported sometimes leaving voice messages. Of those that
do leave voice messages, many reported leaving them only under
certain specific circumstances. CFPB Debt Collection Operations
Study, supra note 45, at 29-30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposal may also reduce the direct costs of voicemail-related
litigation, which can be large.\645\ While the Bureau does not have
data on the costs to debt collectors of defending such litigation, some
debt collectors have suggested that resolving an individual lawsuit
typically costs $5,000 to $10,000, and resolving a class action could
cost much more. Moreover, debt collectors report that the large
majority of threatened lawsuits are settled before a suit is filed, so
the frequency of filed lawsuits substantially understates how often
debt collectors bear costs from claimed FDCPA violations.\646\ The
Bureau anticipates that the proposed clarification of the definition of
communication would significantly reduce any legal risk to debt
collectors of leaving voice messages that fit within the definition of
limited-content message.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\645\ There were at least 162 voicemail-related lawsuits filed
in 2015 under section 805(b) of the FDCPA, which prohibits third-
party disclosures; of these, 11 cases were class actions. In
addition, at least 125 voicemail-related lawsuits were pursued under
section 807(11), which prohibits communicating with a consumer
without providing the mini-Miranda disclosure; of these 49 cases
were class actions. See Small Business Review Panel Outline, supra
note 56, at 69 n.104 (citing data provided by WebRecon, LLC).
\646\ Some debt collectors have reported that they receive
approximately 10 demand letters for every lawsuit filed and that
FDCPA claims are typically settled for $1,000 to $3,000. See id. at
69 n.105.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed provision would generally not require debt collectors
to incur new costs because it would not require any debt collectors to
change their policies regarding messages. However, in order to obtain
benefits from the provision, debt collectors who plan to adopt the
practice of leaving limited-content messages would incur one-time costs
to develop policies and procedures to implement limited-content
messages under the rule and to train employees on these policies and
procedures.
The Bureau requests data and other information about the benefits
and costs to consumers and covered persons of the proposed limited-
content messages. In particular, the Bureau requests information that
is informative of how consumers would respond to limited-content
messages, how the proposed limited-content messages would affect debt
collectors' ability to contact consumers, and the one-time and ongoing
costs to debt collectors who plan to adopt the practice of leaving
limited-content messages.
4. Time-Barred Debt: Prohibiting Suits and Threats of Suit
Proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) would prohibit a debt collector from
suing or threatening to sue on a debt that the debt collector knows or
should know is time-barred.
As discussed in part V, multiple courts have held that the FDCPA
prohibits suits and threats of suit on time-barred debt. In light of
this, the Bureau understands that most debt collectors do not knowingly
sue or threaten to sue consumers to collect time-barred debts, and
therefore the Bureau does not expect this provision of the proposed
rule to have a significant effect on most consumers or debt
collectors.\647\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\647\ For example, small entity representatives at the meeting
of the Small Business Review Panel indicated that it was standard
practice in the industry not to knowingly initiate lawsuits to
collect time-barred debt. See Small Business Review Panel Report,
supra note 57, at 35. Some industry groups have adopted policies
requiring members to refrain from suing or threatening to sue on
time-barred debts. See, e.g., Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n, Receivables
Management Certification Program at 32 (Jan. 19, 2018), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Certification-Policy-version-6.0-FINAL-20180119.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To the extent that there are costs to covered persons or benefits
to consumers from this provision, they will most likely come from
reduced payments on time-barred debts, to the extent that some debt
collectors currently use lawsuits or threats to sue on time-barred
debts as a strategy to elicit payment.\648\ If it is currently true
that (1) suing or threatening to sue on debts is an important means of
collection for debts for which the statute of limitations is close to
expiring, and (2) most debt collectors stop suing or threatening to sue
once the statute of limitations for a debt expires, then one
[[Page 23381]]
would expect repayment rates to drop after the statute of limitations
expires, and that drop might be made more significant by the proposed
provision. Such a reduction in payments would benefit consumers who owe
the debts while imposing costs on debt collectors and creditors and
potentially increasing the cost of credit generally.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\648\ As noted above in section V, although multiple courts have
held and the FTC has stated that suing or threating to sue on time-
barred debts violates the FDCPA, the Bureau's enforcement experience
has shown that some debt collectors may continue to sue or threaten
to sue on time-barred debts. The proposal could reduce such activity
by eliminating any legal uncertainty about whether such suits or
threats of suit are permitted and potentially by strengthening
enforcement of the prohibition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau therefore attempted to indirectly measure the potential
effect of the provision by examining the behavior of consumers who owe
debts that either recently expired or are close to expiring under their
state's statutes of limitations. To do so, the Bureau used data from
its Consumer Credit Panel (CCP), which contains information from one of
the three nationwide CRAs. The Bureau used data from the CCP to attempt
to estimate the current effect of State statutes of limitation on the
propensity of consumers to pay old debts in collection.
The CCP contains information on collections tradelines--records
that were furnished to this nationwide CRA by third-party debt
collectors or debt buyers. The Bureau analyzed these data to determine
whether the probability of payment declines around the expiration of
the statute of limitations in the consumer's State. Specifically, the
Bureau followed debts reported in the CCP from the time they were first
reported on consumers' credit records until they either showed some
record of payment or disappeared from the credit records.\649\ In this
analysis, the Bureau assumed that the applicable statute of limitations
is the one applicable to written contracts in the consumer's State of
residence and that the statute of limitations begins for a debt on the
date that the debt first appears on the consumer's credit report.\650\
The Bureau assumed this starting date because there was no other
reasonable basis in the available data to assign the beginning of the
statute of limitations. There is likely to be some inaccuracy in this
assumption due to a variety of factors, including delays between the
beginning of the period defined by the statute of limitations and the
first report and cases in which the applicable statute of limitations
is not the one in the consumer's State. However, if the estimated
expiration of the statute of limitations is at least approximately
correct in most cases, then one would expect to observe whether the
expiration of the statute of limitations has an effect on the
likelihood that a debt is reported to have been paid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\649\ Debts in the CCP that are reported by multiple debt
collectors, for instance if the debt is transferred or sold, are not
explicitly linked. As in the Bureau's prior quarterly Consumer
Credit Trends report on collection of telecommunication debt,
tradelines were linked based on the dollar amount and opening dates
associated with the tradelines. Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Quarterly Consumer Credit Trends: Telecommunication Debt Collection
(Aug. 22, 2018), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/quarterly-consumer-credit-trends-telecommunications-debt-collection/. For this analysis, a tradeline
was considered to be a continuation of a previous debt if it had the
same original balance and it was opened on or after the latest
balance date for the previous tradeline. Debt collectors do not
appear to consistently report payment information when furnishing
information to the nationwide CRA. As such, for this analysis, the
Bureau considered a debt to have had a payment made if in any month:
(1) There is a positive payment amount; (2) there is a populated
last payment date, or (3) the account is marked paid in full or
settled. With regard to the timing of the first payment, the
Bureau's analysis used the earliest value of the last payment date
for a debt, if populated, or the earliest balance data associated
with a payment amount or paid-in-full flag, as appropriate. The
method for determining whether a debt was ever paid is the same as
is used in Charles Romeo and Ryan Sandler, The Effect of Debt
Collection Laws on Access to Credit (Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Office of Research Working Paper No. 2018-01, Feb. 12, 2018),
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3124954.
\650\ The collections tradelines in the CCP are primarily
medical debts, utility debts, and telecommunications debts, and it
is the Bureau's understanding that the statute of limitations for
written contracts is the one that would generally apply for these
types of debts. Relatively few collection tradelines relate to
credit card debt; the Bureau understands that this is because credit
card issuers prefer to furnish information to the nationwide CRAs
regarding their customers' accounts even when accounts have been
charged off and placed with a debt collector.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau calculated the probability of payment occurring after a
given number of days, conditional on no payment occurring before--in
technical terms, the ``hazard rate'' for payments--for all collections
tradelines in the CCP. The Bureau then calculated the average hazard
rate based on the number of months before or after the estimated
expiration of the applicable statute of limitations. This calculation
is plotted in Figure 1, below.\651\ The figure shows that the
probability of a collections tradeline showing evidence of payment
declines steadily for at least one year leading up to the estimated
expiration of the statute of limitations, and continues to decline at
roughly the same rate afterwards.\652\ Thus, while the probability of
payment declines over time, the reduced ability to pursue litigation
does not seem to materially affect payments on collections tradelines.
Combined with the Bureau's understanding that debt collectors generally
do not sue on time-barred debt, this suggests that the proposed
provision would be unlikely to cause any further reduction in the rate
of repayment on time-barred debt.\653\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\651\ The overall level of the hazard rate in the figure is
quite low--on the order of two-tenths of 1 percent. This is to be
expected given the monthly nature of the series--although around 10
percent of all collections tradelines eventually show some evidence
of payment, the proportion that do so in any given month is quite
low.
\652\ While Figure 1 is based on all collections tradelines,
regardless of the type of original creditor, the pattern over time
looks very similar if the calculation is done separately by type of
original creditor.
\653\ Alternatively, this result would also be consistent with
all debt collectors currently ignoring the statute of limitations
and continuing to sue or threaten to sue on time-barred debt.
However, as discussed above, the Bureau understands that most debt
collectors avoid suits or threats of suits on time-barred debt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 23382]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP21MY19.000
Because the available data do not permit the Bureau to identify the
expiration of the statute of limitations precisely, the analysis above
may fail to identify some effects. The Bureau requests data and other
evidence on how the expiration of the statute of limitations affects
debt collection in the current market.
5. Communication Prior To Furnishing Information
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(a) would prohibit a debt collector from
furnishing information to a CRA regarding a debt before communicating
with the consumer about that debt, a requirement that a debt collector
could satisfy by sending a validation notice prior to furnishing
information.
Potential benefits and costs to consumers. The proposal would help
ensure that consumers learn about an alleged debt before a debt
collector furnishes adverse information to a CRA. When consumers
believe that the information is in error, they will have an opportunity
to dispute the debt.
When debt collectors furnish information about unpaid debts to
CRAs, that information can appear on consumer credit reports,
potentially limiting consumers' ability to obtain credit, employment,
or housing. If consumers are unaware that information about a possible
unpaid debt is being furnished to a CRA, then they may not realize that
their ability to obtain credit, employment or housing may be affected
by the debt's presence on their credit reports. They may pay more for
credit or lose out on employment or housing because they are unaware
that their credit scores have been negatively affected or they may
discover the adverse information only when they apply for credit,
employment, or housing.
To quantify the potential consumer benefits from the proposal, the
Bureau would need to know: (1) How frequently consumers are unaware
debt collectors had furnished information about their debts to credit
bureaus but would become aware of it if the debt collectors
communicated with consumers prior to furnishing data; and (2) the
benefit to these consumers of becoming aware they had a debt in
collections.
In many cases, consumers would not be affected by the proposed
provision because many debt collectors already send validation notices
before furnishing information to CRAs. Many other consumers would not
be affected because debt collectors do not furnish information to CRAs
for some or all debts on which they are seeking to recover.
The Bureau understands that most debt collectors mail validation
notices to consumers shortly after they receive accounts for
collections.\654\ A minority of debt collectors sometimes or always
mail validation notices only after speaking with consumers (whether
contact was initiated by the debt collector or the consumer).\655\ In
addition, a number of debt collectors do not furnish information to
CRAs, so again in these cases the proposed provision would not affect
consumers. The Bureau does not have representative data to estimate how
often consumers would be affected by the proposed provision, but the
evidence suggests that a relatively small share of debt collectors
furnish information to CRAs before providing a validation notice. If
this occurs in 5 percent of cases, for example, it could result in
approximately 7 million additional validation notices sent each year
(assuming that no debt collectors would cease credit reporting in
response to the proposed provision).\656\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\654\ See CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45,
at 28.
\655\ In the Bureau's Operations Study, 53 of 58 respondents
said that they send a validation notice shortly after debt
placement, and of those that do not, three respondents that said
that they furnish data to CRAs. CFPB Debt Collection Operations
Study, supra note 45, at 28. During the meeting of the Small
Business Review Panel, only one small entity representative
described additional burdens it would face as a result of a
requirement to communicate with consumers before furnishing
information to credit bureaus.
\656\ This estimate assumes 140 million validation notices are
sent each year, based on an estimated 49 million consumers contacted
by debt collectors each year and an assumption that each receives
notices about an average of approximately 2.8 notices during the
year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Learning that a debt is in collections shortly after the
collections process begins can help consumers prevent or mitigate harm
from adverse information on their credit reports. It can be
particularly important if the information
[[Page 23383]]
about the debt is inaccurate because in those cases consumers who learn
of the alleged debt can dispute the item under the FCRA. By informing
consumers about the collection item before it is furnished to a CRA,
the proposal would make it less likely that consumers learn about a
collection item when they are in the process of applying for credit or
other benefits, at which point they may feel pressure to resolve the
item and may not have the opportunity to fully dispute the item.
An FTC report addressed the prevalence of collections-related
errors in credit reports.\657\ The FTC report analyzed data from a
sample of 1,001 consumers and identified errors in the credit records
of three nationwide CRAs. The report found collections-related errors
in 4.9 percent of credit reports, and credit reports with documented
errors contained, on average, 1.8 errors per report. The Bureau's Debt
Collection Consumer Survey also suggests that debt collectors made
collection errors, finding that 53 percent of consumers who said they
had been contacted about one or more debts in collection said that
these contacts included at least one debt the consumer thought was in
error.\658\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\657\ Fed. Trade Comm'n, Report to Congress under Section 319 of
the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003, (2012).
\658\ CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at
24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credit scores are based on a wide variety of information in
consumer credit files. While many errors have only small effects on
consumers' credit scores,\659\ in some cases information in credit
files about unpaid debts can have a reasonably large impact on credit
scores. For example, analysis of telecommunications collection items in
credit reports has shown that, while additional collection items have
relatively small effects in some cases, it can have substantial effects
for some consumers, with an average reduction in credit score of more
than 41 points for super-prime consumers.\660\ In some circumstances,
these changes could lead to higher interest rates for consumers or
denial of credit, in particular for borrowers with otherwise high
credit scores.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\659\ See Fed. Trade Comm'n, Report to Congress under Section
319 of the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003, at 43
(2012).
\660\ See Brian Bucks et al., Collection of Telecommunication
Debt, Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot. (Aug. 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Potential benefits and costs to covered persons. The proposal would
affect the practices of debt collectors who sometimes furnish
information about consumers' debts to CRAs before the debt collectors
have communicated with consumers. The Bureau understands that most debt
collectors mail validation notices to consumers shortly after they
receive the accounts for collections and before they furnish data on
those accounts, and so they already would be in compliance with the
proposed requirement.\661\ Forty-five out of 58 debt collectors
responding to the Bureau's Operations Survey said that they furnish
information to credit bureaus.\662\ Of these respondents, all but three
said that they send a validation notice upon account placement, such
that the proposed requirement would be satisfied. These debt collectors
likely would need to review their policies to ensure that validation
notices always are sent (or validation information is provided in an
initial communication) prior to reporting on accounts, which the Bureau
expects would involve a small one-time cost. Other debt collectors do
not furnish information at all to CRAs and so would not be affected by
the proposed requirement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\661\ In the Operations Survey, 53 of 58 respondents said that
they send a validation notice shortly after debt placement. CFPB
Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at 28.
\662\ Id. at 19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors who furnish information to CRAs but provide
validation notices to consumers only after they have been in contact
with consumers would need to change their practices and would face
increased costs as a result of the proposal. Because these debt
collectors are already required to provide validation notices to
consumers (unless validation information is provided in an initial
communication), the Bureau expects that they already have systems in
place for sending notices and would not face one-time compliance costs
greater than those of other debt collectors. However, debt collectors
would face ongoing costs from sending validation notices to more
consumers than they would otherwise, at an estimated cost of $0.50 to
$0.80 per debt if sent by postal mail.\663\ To the extent debt
collectors take advantage of opportunities to send validation notices
electronically, an option the proposal elsewhere seeks to make more
viable, the marginal cost of sending each notice is likely to be
approximately zero. Alternatively, these debt collectors could cease
furnishing information to CRAs, which could impact the effectiveness of
their collection efforts.\664\ Because debt collectors could choose the
less burdensome of these options, the additional costs of delivering
notices represent an upper bound on the burden of the provision for
debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\663\ See CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45,
at 32-33. One small entity representative on the Bureau's Small
Business Review Panel indicated that, for about one-half of its
accounts, it currently sends validation notices only after speaking
with a consumer, and that, if it were required to send validation
notices to all consumers, it would incur additional mailing costs of
$0.63 per mailing for an estimated 400,000 accounts per year.
\664\ If debt collectors furnish information to CRAs less
frequently this could make consumer reports less informative in
general, which could have negative effects on the credit system by
making it harder for creditors to assess credit risk.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests data and other information about the benefits
and costs to consumers and covered persons of the proposed requirement.
In particular, the Bureau requests information that would help the
Bureau to estimate the number of consumers affected by the proposed
provision, the benefits for these consumers, and the potential costs to
covered persons of complying with the proposed provision.
6. Prohibition on the Sale or Transfer of Certain Debts
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1) would prohibit a debt collector from
selling, transferring, or placing for collection a debt if the debt
collector knows or should know that the debt was paid or settled, the
debt was discharged in bankruptcy, or an identity theft report was
filed with respect to the debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2) would
create several exceptions to this prohibition.
The Bureau understands, based on its market knowledge and outreach
to debt collectors, that debt collectors generally do not sell,
transfer, or place for collections debts (other than in circumstances
covered in the exceptions) if they have reason to believe the debts
cannot be validly collected because they have been paid, they were
settled in bankruptcy, or an identity theft report was filed with
respect to them.\665\ Therefore, the Bureau expects the benefits and
costs of this provision to be minimal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\665\ With respect to debts subject to an identity theft report,
FCRA section 615(f) already prohibits a debt collector from selling,
transferring for consideration, or placing for collection debts if
the debt collector has been notified by a consumer reporting agency
that the debt resulted from identity theft.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Notice for Validation of Debts
Proposed Sec. 1006.34 would implement and interpret FDCPA section
809(a), (b), (d), and (e). Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)
provides that, subject to certain exceptions, a debt collector must
provide a consumer the validation information described in Sec.
1006.34(c). Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) would implement FDCPA section
809(a)'s content
[[Page 23384]]
requirements and require that the validation notice include certain
information about the debt and the consumer's protections with respect
to debt collection that debt collectors do not currently provide on
validation notices. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d) would set forth general
formatting requirements and permit debt collectors to comply with these
requirements by using the proposed model validation notice in appendix
B. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(e) would permit, but not require, debt
collectors to provide a consumer the validation notice translated into
any language, if the debt collector also sends an English-language
validation notice.
Potential benefits and costs to consumers. The proposed validation
information may benefit consumers in four ways. First, the disclosures
would provide more information about the debt, which may help consumers
determine whether the debt is theirs and whether the reported amount
owed is accurate. Second, the notice would provide a plain-language
disclosure of the consumer's rights in debt collection, in particular
the right to dispute, which should help consumers to know their rights
and be able to exercise them. Third, the validation information would
include consumer response information that should make it easier for
consumers to take certain actions, including disputing a debt. Finally,
the proposed model validation notice form is intended to provide
information to consumers in a more appealing and easy-to-read format,
making it more likely that consumers read and comprehend the
information than with the validation notices currently in use.
To quantify the benefit of providing more and clearer validation
information, the Bureau would need to estimate the impact of this
additional information on consumers' ability to recognize their debts
compared to what is currently provided on validation notices, as well
as how consumers would respond to that additional information. Although
the Bureau is not aware of data that would permit a full accounting of
these benefits, below is a summary of information the Bureau is aware
of that is relevant to some factors affecting these benefits.
The Bureau understands that, in general, validation notices
currently include little or no information about the debt beyond the
information specifically listed in section 809(a) of the FDCPA (i.e.,
the current amount of the debt and the name of the current creditor).
This information may not be sufficient for the consumer to recognize
the debt, particularly if: (1) The amount owed has changed over time
due to interest, fees, payments, or credits; (2) the debt collector has
changed since an original collection attempt; or (3) the creditor's
name is not one the consumer associates with the debt (as with some
store-branded credit cards issued by third-party financial
institutions). Consumers who do not recognize a debt because the
information on a validation notice is insufficient may incur costs if
they mistakenly dispute a debt they owe, pay a debt they do not owe, or
ignore a debt on the assumption that the collection attempt is in
error.
Relative to current validation notices, the proposed validation
information would include more specific details about the debt, such as
the debt's account number and an itemization of the debt. The Bureau
believes this information would benefit consumers by making it easier
for them to determine whether they owe a debt and, therefore, reducing
the likelihood of incurring costs due to mistakes like those noted
above. The consumer can also use the consumer response information to
request the name and address of the original creditor, which may
further help the consumer to recognize the debt.
To fully evaluate the benefits to consumers of disclosing
additional information, the Bureau would need representative data to
estimate how often consumers would read and understand the additional
information on the notice and the extent to which that information
increases consumer recognition and understanding compared to a notice
without it. For example, the Bureau could further quantify some of the
consumer benefits of the notice if the Bureau were able to estimate:
(1) How many consumers ignore notices out of a mistaken conclusion that
the debt is not theirs; (2) how many consumers dispute correct debts,
and subsequently, how much time the proposed validation notice would
save by obviating later interactions that result from improper
disputes; and (3) how many consumers fail to dispute or make payments
on incorrect debts. The Bureau is not aware of a source of information
on the number of consumers in these categories or the possible time
savings that could result from the proposed validation information. As
discussed in the section-by-section analysis in part V, the Bureau
currently is conducting additional consumer testing of possible time-
barred debt and revival disclosures. This testing may also provide
additional evidence about the benefits of the proposed validation
information to consumers.
The Bureau's Debt Collection Consumer Survey suggests that the
proposed validation information would likely be helpful in recognizing
a debt. Specifically, when asked how helpful various pieces of
information would be in figuring out whether they owed a debt,
consumers were most likely to indicate that the creditor name, type of
debt, and an itemization of the amount owed (such as principal,
interest, and fees) were especially valuable. These opinions were
echoed in focus groups in which consumers noted that after a debt is
sold it is more difficult to recognize, and that they wanted as much
information as possible to help them recognize the debt as theirs
(especially the account number, creditor, and amount due) with the
exception of sensitive information like social security numbers.\666\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\666\ FMG Focus Group Report, supra note 38, at 15-16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To quantify the benefits of the proposed provision requiring a
clear and conspicuous disclosure of a consumer's right to dispute a
debt, the Bureau would need to estimate the number of consumers who
fail to dispute debts that they do not owe because they are unaware of,
or do not comprehend, their right to dispute. The Bureau cannot
precisely quantify this benefit; however, the discussion below
identifies several applicable considerations and estimates.
The Bureau estimates that at least 49 million consumers are
contacted by debt collectors each year.\667\ Twenty-eight percent of
consumers who said they had been contacted about one or more debts in
collection reported that the contacts included attempts to collect at
least one debt that the consumers believed they did not owe.\668\ One-
third of consumers who had been contacted said the amount the creditor
or debt collector was trying to collect was wrong for at least one of
these debts, and 16 percent said the contacts included at least one
contact about a debt that was instead owed by a family member. Taken
together, more than one-half of the consumers (53 percent) who said
they had been contacted about one or more debts in collection reported
that they thought at least one of the debts they
[[Page 23385]]
were contacted about was in error. This suggests that there are many
consumers who receive the validation notices in use today who might be
likely to dispute based on their perception that either the debt is not
theirs or is wrong.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\667\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 13, 40-41.
\668\ The survey questions concerning consumer beliefs about
errors in collections did not ask respondents to distinguish between
debts owed to a debt collector and debts owed to a creditor. If
consumers are more or less likely to believe there is an error for
collection attempts by debt collectors, then this percentage and
those below may over- or under-estimate the likelihood that a
consumer believes a debt is in error when contacted by a debt
collector.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Among the 53 percent of consumers who cited one of the issues noted
above, 42 percent reported that they disputed a collection in the prior
year, and 11 percent of consumers who had not cited one of those issues
indicated that they had disputed a debt. The fact that less than one-
half of the consumers who questioned a debt about which the creditor or
collector contacted them reported disputing a debt is consistent with
the possibility that some consumers do not dispute in response to a
collection effort because they are not aware of the option to dispute
or do not understand the steps required to do so. The proposed clear
and conspicuous statement of the dispute right could benefit consumers
by making salient the possibility of dispute.
The survey's finding that only 42 percent of consumers who thought
they experienced an error with a debt in collection disputed the error
suggests consumers are uncertain about how to dispute a debt in
collection or that they believe that disputes require too much time and
effort relative to the expected benefit. The consumer response
information could reduce these impediments to disputing debts that
consumers believe are in error. Specifically, the consumer response
information would provide a clear means of disputing a debt in a way
that triggers the protections provided by the FDCPA and this proposed
rule, if finalized. Furthermore, the convenience of the consumer
response information could reduce barriers to responding by eliminating
or reducing the burden of, for example, deciding what information is
relevant and how to phrase the response.\669\ This could allow some
consumers to save time and avoid other negative consequences, such as
lower credit scores due to a debt they may not owe being listed as
unpaid in their credit files.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\669\ A 2016 research report by the United Kingdom's Financial
Conduct Authority showed that, in a large randomized control trial,
a tear off form (with a text or email reminder) led to more
consumers switching from a current savings account to one with a
better interest rate relative to getting only an informational text
and/or email reminder and relative to an informational box with
instructions on how to switch. Paul Adams et al., Attention, Search
and Switching: Evidence on Mandated Disclosure from the Savings
Market, (UK Fin. Conduct Authority, Occasional Paper No. 19 2016).
https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/occasional-papers/occasional-paper-19.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, the consumer response information includes an option
to request information about the original creditor. This additional
information may help consumers in determining whether the debt is
theirs.
The Bureau has proposed a model validation notice. Several
considerations went into the content and design of the model validation
notice. First, consumers must have relevant and accurate information to
make informed decisions on how to act with regard to the debt;
therefore the Bureau conducted consumer testing to identify what pieces
of information consumers considered to be important to help them
identify whether a debt was theirs, whether the amount stated was
correct, and how the amount the debt collector was attempting to
collect has changed over time (e.g., due to fees, interest, and
payments).\670\ However, there is some indication that consumers tend
to not read certain types of standard-form disclosures.\671\ To try to
avoid this result, the Bureau conducted consumer testing exploring how
consumers interacted and engaged with the notice and the pieces of
information contained therein.\672\ This helped the Bureau understand
whether consumers were inclined to engage with the document in general,
and which pieces of the validation notice received more or less
consumer attention.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\670\ FMG Summary Report, supra note 42.
\671\ See, e.g., Ian Ayres & Alan Schwartz, The No-Reading
Problem in Consumer Contract Law, 66 Stan. L. Rev. 545 (2014);
Yannis Bakos et al., Does Anyone Read the Fine Print? Consumer
Attention to Standard-Form Contracts, 43 J.Legal Studies 1, 1-35
(2014); George R. Milne & Mary J. Culnan, Strategies for Reducing
Online Privacy Risks: Why Consumers Read (or Don't Read) Online
Privacy Notices, 18 J. Interactive Mktg. 3, 15-29 (2004); Jonathan
A. Obar & Anne Oeldorf-Hirsch, The Biggest Lie on the internet:
Ignoring the Privacy Policies and Terms of Service Policies of
Social Networking Services, (York U., draft version, 2018), http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2757465.
\672\ FMG Cognitive Report, supra note 40.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau incorporated the findings from this consumer testing in
its design of the proposed model validation notice form. To increase
both engagement and comprehension of the validation information, the
Bureau designed the proposed form to be visually engaging. The proposed
form uses plain language wherever possible and conforms to
recommendations the SEC set forth in their plain English handbook.\673\
To reduce the perceived complexity of the information, the proposed
form uses a clear hierarchy of information through positioning in a
columnar format, varying type-size, and bold-faced type for subsection
headings. It uses shading to highlight the amount due and uses plain
language rather than technical terms. Usability testing research using
eye-tracking suggests that participants were able to locate relevant
information on the proposed form, with most participants able to
quickly locate their account number and the contact information of the
creditor.\674\ The information presented in the proposed form is also
concise, presenting consumers with a manageable amount of information
about the debt and what they can do in response to the notice. This is
important, as the perceived cost to a consumer of reading a disclosure
increases with the amount of information provided.\675\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\673\ See Sec. Exchange Comm'n, A Plain English Handbook (Aug.
1998), https://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdf.
\674\ FMG Summary Report, supra note 42.
\675\ The idea that consumers may decrease their engagement with
information when more information is provided is somewhat supported
by research on ``choice overload.'' This work indicates that if
choice sets are large, some people opt to make no choice at all.
See, e.g., Sheena Iyengar et al., How Much Choice is Too Much?
Contributions to 401(k) Retirement Plans, in Pension Design and
Structure: New Lessons from Behavioral Finance, at 83 (Oxford U.
Press 2004).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau expects consumers to experience few costs as a result of
the proposed provision.
Potential benefits to covered persons. The proposed provision would
significantly reduce the litigation risk that debt collectors face when
mailing validation notices. This would benefit debt collectors
directly, by reducing litigation costs related to validation notices.
It could also indirectly benefit debt collectors by adding information
to validation notices that would be helpful to debt collectors and
consumers but which debt collectors currently do not include for fear
that it would increase litigation risk. The proposed validation
information may also make consumers more likely to dispute, which could
increase costs for debt collectors, as discussed under ``Potential
costs to covered persons'' below.
The Bureau understands that debt collectors currently face
litigation risk associated with the validation notices they send,
reflecting, in part, conflicting court decisions about what language is
required and what language is permitted in the notices.\676\ The
proposal would reduce this risk for debt collectors who use the
proposed model form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\676\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
22.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed validation information would include specific
information about the debt intended to help consumers identify the debt
and understand the amount the debt collector claims is owed. The
Bureau's qualitative consumer research and the
[[Page 23386]]
Bureau's complaint data suggest that the information currently included
in validation notices is often not sufficient for consumers to identify
a debt or whether the amount owed is correct.\677\ If consumers are
better able to identify debts, they may be less likely to dispute or
ignore a debt that they in fact owe, and at the same time may be better
able to articulate the basis for a dispute of a debt that they do not
owe. These effects could benefit debt collectors by reducing the costs
associated with consumer disputes. Although it is possible that debt
collectors could currently provide such information on validation
notices, the Bureau understands that some debt collectors who would
like to provide additional information do not do so largely due to the
legal risks associated with including information in the validation
notice beyond what is expressly listed in the FDCPA.\678\ The proposal
would significantly reduce this legal risk.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\677\ See supra notes 451-52 and accompanying text.
\678\ See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at
22 (finding that small entities would benefit from a model notice
that reduced litigation risk arising from conflicting court
decisions about what information is permitted on a validation
notice).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To quantify the benefits of this provision to covered persons, the
Bureau would need data on how frequently consumers do not recognize the
debt or amount owed identified in a validation notice, how many
consumers would better recognize the debt given the proposed
information, and how consumers would act on that information. While the
Bureau is not aware of available data that would permit it to estimate
these numbers, the Debt Collection Consumer Survey does provide some
basis for thinking that the proposed validation information would be
helpful to consumers.
The proposed validation information could reduce debt collector
costs associated with disputes by preventing some disputes from
consumers who are more likely to recognize that they owe a debt and by
making disputes that debt collectors receive clearer and easier to
resolve. Debt collectors report that processing disputes is a costly
activity, and that it can be especially difficult to process disputes
if the consumer provides little or no detail about the basis for a
dispute. Debt collectors surveyed by the Bureau indicated that most
disputes took between five minutes and one hour of staff time to
resolve, with 15 to 30 minutes being the most common amount of
time.\679\ Respondents said that disputes took the longest amount of
time to resolve if the basis of the dispute was unclear or if the
consumer said the debt was not theirs.\680\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\679\ CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at
31.
\680\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau does not have a basis to estimate how much the proposed
validation information might affect dispute rates. As an illustration
of potential cost savings if dispute rates fall, if the proposed
information were to reduce the number of consumers who dispute by 1
percent of all validation notices sent, and assuming that there are 140
million validation notices sent per year,\681\ the overall number of
annual disputes would fall by 1.4 million. Assuming an average time to
process each dispute of 0.375 hours, the overall savings to industry
would be estimated at 525,000 person-hours, or approximately 250 full-
time equivalents. Assuming labor costs for debt collectors of $22 per
hour,\682\ this would represent industry cost savings of about $11.5
million.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\681\ The assumption of 140 million validation notices per year
is based on an estimated 49 million consumers contacted by debt
collectors each year and an assumption that each consumer receives
an average of approximately 2.8 notices during the year.
\682\ This assumes an hourly wage of $15 and taxes, benefits,
and incentives of $7 per hour. See CFPB Debt Collection Operations
Study, supra note 45, at 17 (reporting estimated debt collector
wages between $10 and $20 per hour plus incentives).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed validation information could also reduce the cost of
processing disputes by making it easier for consumers who dispute to
provide at least some information about the basis of their disputes.
This could reduce the costs to covered persons of processing disputes
by making it easier for debt collectors to investigate disputed debts
in order to verify the debt.
Potential costs to covered persons. Debt collectors already send
validation notices to consumers to comply with the FDCPA, so the
proposed validation information would generally affect the content of
existing disclosures debt collectors are sending rather than require
debt collectors to send entirely new disclosures. Nonetheless, debt
collectors would incur certain costs to comply with the proposal. These
include one-time compliance costs, the ongoing costs of obtaining the
required validation information, and potentially ongoing costs of
responding to a potential increase in the number of disputes.
The proposed provision would require debt collectors to reformat
their validation notices to accommodate the proposed validation
information requirements. The Bureau expects that any one-time costs to
debt collectors of reformatting the validation notice would be
relatively small, particularly for debt collectors who rely on vendors,
because the Bureau expects that most vendors would provide an updated
notice at no additional cost.\683\ The Bureau understands from its
outreach that many covered persons currently use vendors to provide
validation notices.\684\ Surveyed firms, and their vendors, told the
Bureau that vendors do not typically charge an additional cost to
modify an existing template (although this practice might not apply if
the proposal required more extensive changes to validation notices than
vendors typically make today).\685\ Debt collectors and vendors would
bear costs to understand the requirements of the provision and to
ensure that their systems generate notices that comply with the
requirements, although these costs would be mitigated somewhat by the
availability of a model form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\683\ See id. at 33.
\684\ In the Operations Study, over 85 percent of debt
collectors surveyed by the Bureau reported using letter vendors. Id.
at 32.
\685\ Id. at 33
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed validation information would require debt collectors
to provide certain additional information about the debt, which would
require that debt collectors receive and maintain certain data fields
and incorporate them into the notices. The Bureau believes that the
large majority of debt collectors already receive and maintain most
data fields included in the proposed validation information. However,
some respondents to the Debt Collection Operations Survey reported that
they do not receive information from creditors about post-default
interest, fees, payments, and credits.\686\ These debt collectors would
have to update their systems to track these fields. The Bureau
understands that such system updates would be likely to cost less than
$1,000 for each debt collector.\687\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\686\ In the Operations Study, 52 of 58 respondents reported
receiving itemization of post-charge-off fees on at least some of
their accounts. Id. at 23.
\687\ Id. at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If debt collectors adjust their systems to produce notices
including the new validation information, the Bureau would not expect
there would be an increase in the ongoing costs of printing and sending
validation notices. However, there could be ongoing costs related to
the validation information requirements if the required data are not
always available to debt collectors. The Bureau understands that some
creditors do not currently track post-default charges and credits in a
way that can be readily transferred to debt collectors.
[[Page 23387]]
Under the proposal, debt collectors would be unable to send validation
notices--and therefore unable to collect--if creditors do not provide
this information.\688\ Some debt collectors might lose revenue as a
result of not being able to collect debts if they do not obtain this
information from creditors. The Bureau does not have representative
data that would permit it to estimate how frequently this would occur.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\688\ For example, the Bureau understands that after New York
State began requiring itemization of post-charge-off fees and
credits, some creditors were at least initially unable to provide
this information and therefore did not place New York accounts for
collection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other potential costs to debt collectors could arise if changes to
the validation information affect how consumers respond, particularly
whether they dispute the debt. As discussed above, because the proposed
validation information would include more detail, consumers might be
more likely to recognize the debt and less likely to mistakenly dispute
debts that they owe. On the other hand, the new consumer response
information would make it easier to dispute debts or request the name
and address of the original creditor. Together with the additional
information about consumers' ability to dispute that would be provided,
this could increase the number of consumers who dispute or request
original-creditor information. The overall impact on dispute rates is
unclear.
The Bureau does not believe that any increases in dispute rates
would be likely to substantially reduce collection revenue, but
increased dispute rates would increase debt collector costs. With
respect to collections revenue, the Bureau expects that, with some
fairly limited exceptions, consumers who choose to pay a debt are
generally those who recognize that they owe the debt and want to pay
it, and that in most cases the proposed validation information would be
unlikely to cause such consumers to dispute rather than pay.\689\ With
respect to costs, the disclosures could lead consumers who do not
recognize the debt or who believe there is a problem with the amount
demanded to dispute the debt rather than ignoring it. Responding to
disputes is a costly activity for debt collectors, so an increase in
dispute rates would increase these costs. As discussed above, covered
persons surveyed by the Bureau indicated that most disputes took
between five minutes and one hour of staff time to resolve, with 15 to
30 minutes being the most common amount of time.\690\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\689\ While there is some evidence that consumers sometimes pay
alleged debts even though they do not believe they owe them, such
consumers may be motivated by factors, such as concerns about credit
reporting, that are not addressed by the validation notice itself.
See Jeff Sovern et al., Validation and Verification Vignettes: More
Results from an Empirical Study of Consumer Understanding of Debt
Collection Validation Notices, at 46-47 (St. John's U., Working
Paper No. 18-0016, 2018), https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3219171.
\690\ CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at
31. The discussion in ``Benefits to covered persons'' above provides
an illustration of the potential impact on debt collectors of a
change in dispute rates. Using the assumptions in that illustration,
if the net impact of the proposal were to increase industrywide
disputes by 1 million disputes per year, it could imply increased
industry costs totaling around $8.25 million per year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests additional information about the benefits and
costs to consumers and covered persons of the proposed validation
information requirements, including information on whether and to what
extent consumers would benefit from the requirements in the proposal,
the costs to covered persons of providing the information that the
proposal would require, and the likely effects of the proposal on
consumer dispute rates.
Alternative proposals to require Spanish-language disclosures. The
Bureau considered proposals that would require debt collectors to
provide a Spanish-language translation of the validation information
under certain circumstances, such as on the reverse side of any
English-language validation notice or if requested by a consumer.
Consumers with limited English proficiency may benefit from
translations of the validation information, and Spanish speakers
represent the second-largest language group in the United States after
English speakers.\691\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\691\ In 2013, 38.4 million residents in the United States aged
five and older spoke Spanish at home. See U.S. Census Bureau, Facts
for Features: Hispanic Heritage Month 2015 (Sept. 14, 2015), https://www.census.gov/newsroom/facts-for-features/2015/cb15-ff18.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Requiring Spanish-language disclosures would impose costs on some
debt collectors. A requirement to send a Spanish-language disclosure on
the back of each validation notice could increase mailing costs for all
validation notices that are sent by mail, because it would require
information that would otherwise be printed on the back of validation
notices, such as State-mandated disclosures, to be provided on a
separate page. A requirement to provide Spanish-language validation
notices upon request could lead to a smaller increase in mailing costs
but could require debt collectors to develop and maintain systems for
tracking a consumer's language preference and responding to that
preference.
The Bureau understands that some debt collectors currently send
validation notices in Spanish to some consumers. To the extent sending
such notices is already prevalent it would limit the consumer benefits
of a proposal that required Spanish-language translations as well as
the costs to debt collectors of such a proposal, although there would
still be costs associated with ensuring that such disclosures were made
as required by regulation.
8. Electronic Disclosures and Communications
The proposed rule includes provisions that the Bureau expects would
encourage debt collectors to communicate with consumers by email and
text message more frequently than they currently do. With respect to
the validation notice, which most debt collectors currently provide by
postal mail, proposed Sec. 1006.42 specifies methods that debt
collectors would be able to use to send notices by email or by
hyperlink to a secure website in a way that complies with the FDCPA's
validation notice requirements. With respect to any communications
about a debt, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) specifies procedures that
debt collectors would be able to use to send an email or text message
to a consumer about a debt without risking liability under the FDCPA
for disclosure of the debt to a third party.
Potential benefits and costs to consumers. Today, debt collectors
generally communicate with consumers by letter and telephone. If the
proposal were to lead debt collectors to increase their use of emails
and text messages, the proposal would benefit consumers who prefer
electronic communications to letters or telephone calls.
Many consumers appear to prefer to receive certain disclosures
about financial products by electronic means rather than postal mail.
In 2016, of a sample of 203 million active general purpose credit card
accounts, approximately 141 million accounts (69 percent of all
accounts) were enrolled in online servicing, of which approximately 80
million (39 percent of all accounts) opted into delivery of periodic
statements by electronic means only.\692\ Because consumers who
[[Page 23388]]
experience debt collection differ from consumers who do not,\693\ these
estimates would be more accurate if the Bureau knew how many consumers
who experience debt collection have opted into receiving electronic-
only (paperless) disclosures from their creditors. It is not clear
whether consumers who experience debt collection would be more or less
digitally engaged with disclosures than their counterparts without debt
collection experience.\694\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\692\ These estimates are based on data reported in Bureau of
Consumer Fin. Prot., The Consumer Credit Card Market, at 164-66
(Dec. 2017), https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_consumer-credit-card-market-report_2017.pdf. This rate has
increased every year since at least 2013. These rates were lower for
private label and retail co-brand cards, suggesting that the
product's use case, acquisition channel, and consumer base
composition may all affect both provider practices and consumer
behavior.
\693\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 15-17. Consumers who have experienced debt collection tend to
have lower incomes, be under age 62, and be non-white.
\694\ An FDIC survey that addressed access to banking services
found that the share of respondents accessing bank accounts through
online or mobile methods generally increased with income and was
lower for respondents aged 65 or more. See 2017 FDIC National Survey
of Unbanked and Underbanked Households at 27 & table 4.4 (Oct.
2018), https://www.fdic.gov/household survey/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other data from the Debt Collection Consumer Survey show that about
15 percent of consumers indicate that email is their most preferred
method of being contacted about a debt in collection, with almost half
of consumers indicating that a letter is their most preferred method,
and about a quarter identifying a telephone as their most preferred
method.\695\ The lower percentage for email may suggest that consumers
are more likely to prefer electronic communications for periodic
statements and similar disclosures than for debt collection
communications. Taken together, the available data suggest that a
minority of consumers--between 15 and 39 percent--would prefer
electronic validation notices, while a majority--as many as 69
percent--might prefer to receive electronic communications (other than
the validation notice) instead of or in addition to paper
communications or telephone calls.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\695\ CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18, at
23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above with respect to the proposal's provisions
regarding call frequency, most consumers experiencing debt collection
report that debt collectors call too often. The proposed provisions
regarding electronic communications may have the indirect effect of
reducing call frequency. These provisions may cause debt collectors to
substitute email or text for telephone calls, and email or text may
provide an easier channel for consumers to ask debt collectors to call
less often. The benefits to consumers of reduced call frequency
generally are discussed above. While some consumers prefer not to
receive electronic communications from debt collectors, the Bureau
believes that the proposal's opt-out provisions will reduce any harm to
such consumers by making it relatively easy for consumers to stop
attempts at electronic communication.
The risk of third-party disclosure may be different for electronic
debt collection communications than for letters or telephone calls,
although the Bureau is not aware of evidence that would indicate
whether such risk is higher or lower. Bureau data suggests that almost
two-thirds of consumers consider it very important that third parties
do not hear or see a message from a creditor or debt collector.\696\ To
the extent that information in an electronic disclosure is less likely
or more likely to be seen or heard by third parties than communications
by mail or telephone, consumers receiving the validation notice
electronically are likely to experience a benefit or a cost,
respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\696\ See CFPB Debt Collection Consumer Survey, supra note 18,
at 38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Receiving disclosures electronically rather than in the mail may
affect the likelihood that borrowers notice and read the disclosures,
which could lead to benefits or costs for consumers if they become more
or less likely to inadvertently ignore or miss important information.
The Bureau does not have information about how frequently consumers
currently read validation notices sent by mail or how often they would
read disclosures if sent by email or by hyperlink to a secure
website.\697\ The requirement that debt collectors provide certain
details about the debt in the subject line of an email or the first
line of a text message may lower the likelihood that a consumer would
miss or ignore the email or text message from the debt collector
transmitting the disclosure. The option of providing the disclosure on
a secure website, while reducing further the risk of third-party
disclosure, may also reduce the likelihood the consumer would read it
because more effort is required to obtain the disclosure.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\697\ One debt collector who currently communicates with
consumers by email reports that 60 percent of consumers open at
least one email and 25 percent click a link to review their options.
See Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 7. As of
2015, about one tenth of all mass market credit card consumers
accessed their online PDF periodic account statements in the final
quarter of the year, which implies that fewer than one-half of
consumers who receive only electronic statements viewed those
statements. See Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot., The Consumer Credit
Card Market, at 134 figure 8 (Dec. 2015). However, the Bureau does
not have data about the frequency with which consumers open or
otherwise access paper periodic statements. In addition, notices of
debts in collection may seem more serious or important than periodic
statements, and may be more likely to be opened.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on available information, the Bureau does not believe that
consumer comprehension of an electronic notice will be different from a
paper notice. The proposal includes requirements designed to make
electronic disclosures no harder to read than paper notices, including
requiring that the proposed electronic disclosure resize to fit the
consumer's screen. Some research suggests that shorter disclosures
(e.g., one to two pages), such as the proposed notice, would result in
similar levels of comprehension regardless of whether they are
delivered on paper or electronically.\698\ In cases in which
differences in performance exist between reading information on paper
and electronically, the difference may be due to use of different
reading strategies--people tend to scan and jump around more when
reading electronic information than they do with paper.\699\ Studies of
other reading-based tasks (surveys, ratings, and tests or quizzes) find
no differences in performance between tasks completed on paper and
electronically.\700\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\698\ Some recent studies find no differences in comprehension
between information displayed on paper and information displayed on
computers; many of these use relatively short texts. See, e.g.,
Robert Ball & Juan Pablo Hourcade, Rethinking Reading for Age from
Paper and Computers, 27 Int'l J. Human-Computer Interaction 11
(2011). In contrast, many studies using longer texts find
comprehension is higher for paper. See, e.g., Lauren Singer &
Patricia Alexander, Reading Across Mediums: Effects of Reading
Digital and Print Texts on Comprehension and Calibration, 85 J.
Experimental Educ. 1 (2017) (finding better engagement when
undergraduates read from paper); Anne Mangen et al., Reading Linear
Texts on Paper Versus Computer Screen, 58 Int'l J. Educ. Res. 61-68
(2013) (finding that a small sample of high school students had
lower comprehension of electronic information relative to paper);
Scott Althaus & David Tewksbury, Agenda Setting and the ``New''
News: Patterns of Issue Importance Among Readers of the Paper and
Online Versions of the New York Times, 29 Comm. Res. 2 (2002)
(randomly assigned participants to read the paper or digital version
of the New York Times and found better memory for readers of the
paper version).
\699\ Ziming Liu, Reading Behavior in the Digital Environment,
61 J. Documentation 6 (2005).
\700\ See Jan Noyes & Kate Garland, Computer- vs. Paper-based
Tasks: Are They Equivalent?, 51 Ergonomics 9 (2008).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Potential benefits and costs to covered persons. Debt collectors
who send disclosures by email or hyperlink to a secure website rather
than sending letters could benefit because they would no longer have to
print and mail disclosures. The Bureau estimates that the marginal cost
of mailing a validation notice is approximately $0.50 to $0.80, whereas
the marginal cost of sending the same communication by email
[[Page 23389]]
would be approximately zero. The Bureau estimates that approximately
140 million validation notices are mailed each year.\701\ Assuming, for
example, that 40 percent of validation notices that are currently
mailed were sent by email under the proposed rule (the approximate
percentage of credit card customers electing paperless disclosures),
and assuming average mailing costs of $0.65, this would suggest reduced
costs to industry in the range of $36 million per year. To the extent
that debt collectors were to provide validation notices by email more
or less frequently than this under the proposal, the cost savings would
be proportionately higher or lower.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\701\ The assumption of 140 million validation notices per year
is based on an estimated 49 million consumers contacted by debt
collectors each year and an assumption that each receives an average
of approximately 2.8 notices during the year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors who use electronic communication may also benefit
to the extent that some consumers are more likely to engage with debt
collectors electronically than by telephone call or letter. During the
SBREFA process, several small entity representatives said that
communication by email or text message was preferred by some consumers
and would be a more effective way to engage with them about their
debts.\702\ One debt collector who currently uses email to contact
consumers reports that its collection rates are greater than those of
traditional debt collectors. While collection rates are likely to vary
according to debt collector, type of debt, and related factors,
clarifying the legality of electronic communications and disclosures
would make it easier for debt collectors to test the efficacy of
electronic communication and use it if they find it effective,
potentially lowering costs and increasing the overall effectiveness of
collections.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\702\ See, e.g., Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note
57, at appendix A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests additional information about the benefits and
costs to consumers and covered persons of the proposed requirements
related to electronic disclosure and communication, including
information on whether and to what extent consumers would benefit from
the requirements in the proposal and the benefits and costs to covered
persons of providing electronic communications as discussed in the
proposal.
G. Potential Reduction of Access by Consumers to Consumer Financial
Products and Services
This proposal contains a mix of provisions that would either
restrict or encourage certain debt collection activities the net impact
of which is uncertain. Economic theory indicates that it is possible
for changes in debt collection rules, such as those contained in this
proposal, to affect consumers' access to credit. Theory says that
creditors should decide to extend credit based on the discounted
expected value of the revenue stream from that extension of credit.
This entails considering the possibility that the consumer will
ultimately default. Specifically, the discounted expected value of an
extension of credit will be the discounted present value of the stream
of interest payments under the terms of the credit agreement,
multiplied by the probability that the consumer pays, plus the
discounted expected value of the creditor's recovery should the
consumer default, times the probability of default. A profit-maximizing
creditor will only extend credit to a given consumer if this expected
value is positive.\703\ Anything that reduces the expected value of a
creditor's recovery in the event of default, in general, will lower the
discounted expected value of the extension of credit as a whole. This,
in turn, may make potential extensions of credit with a discounted
expected only slightly above zero to become negative, such that a
creditor will be less willing to extend credit. Likewise, anything that
increases the expected value of a creditor's recovery increases the
discounted expected value of the credit extension, and may change the
sign of the expected value of potential credit extensions that had
negative expected values, such that a profit-maximizing creditor will
be more willing to extend credit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\703\ For purposes of this discussion, the Bureau ignores risk
preferences and assumes that creditors are risk neutral. That is,
while a risk-averse decision maker would prefer a certain payment of
$100 to an uncertain investment with expected value of $100, the
discussion in this section assumes creditors are indifferent between
these options. Creditors may be risk averse to some degree, such
that they would prefer the certain investment to the gamble, or even
risk seeking, such that they prefer a gamble with the prospect of a
higher return. The theoretical argument described here does not
hinge on creditors' risk preferences--the Bureau makes this
assumption solely for ease of exposition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are a few ways that the proposal might increase or decrease
the expected value of creditors' recovery in the event of default,
although theory alone gives no indication whether any of these actual
effects on recovery would be large enough to have practical
significance. The safe harbor for limited-content messages and
affirming the legality of email use would tend to increase the expected
value of recovery, while call frequency limits may reduce the expected
value of recovery. First, to the extent that the proposal would raise
costs for debt collectors, debt collectors in theory could pass these
costs on to creditors, whether by charging higher contingency fees to
creditors or by paying lower prices to creditors when buying debt.\704\
Second, the proposed rule may reduce the amount of expected recovery,
either by making it less likely that consumers ultimately pay, or by
reducing the amount that consumers pay in the event of a settlement.
Finally, the proposed rule could increase the time it takes for debt
collectors to recover. A rational creditor would discount future income
more the further in the future it occurs, and so later payment of the
same amount of money would reduce the discounted expected value of the
payment. Alternatively, the proposed rule might lower costs for debt
collectors, increase expected recovery, and decrease the time it takes
for debt collectors to recover amounts owed.\705\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\704\ The degree of this pass-through depends on the relative
degree of market power held by debt collectors and creditors. If
creditors have more market power, debt collectors will have limited
ability to demand higher fees or lower wholesale prices. Given that
many comments on the Small Business Review Panel Outline indicated
that debt collectors have little market power in their interactions
with creditors, it is likely that there is little pass-through of
additional costs. See, e.g., Small Business Review Panel Report,
supra note 57, at 16-17.
\705\ Because creditors are generally not subject to the FDCPA,
creditors could also respond to changes to debt collection rules by
changing their decisions about whether to use third-party debt
collectors or to collect debts themselves. The option to move debt
collection activities ``in house'' could reduce any impact of the
proposal on the costs of recovering unpaid debts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If the proposal were to reduce the expected value of extending
credit, creditors might respond in three ways: (1) Increase their
standards for lending, with an aim of reducing the probability of
default; (2) reduce the amount of credit offered, thus reducing their
losses in the event of a default; or (3) increase interest rates or
other costs of credit such as fees, thus increasing their revenue from
consumers who do not default. Which of these mechanisms any given
creditor would pursue with respect to any given credit transaction
would depend on the specifics of the particular credit market.
The Bureau is aware of three empirical academic studies using
modern data and methods that estimate the magnitude of the effect of
debt collection restrictions on access to credit,\706\ one by a
researcher affiliated
[[Page 23390]]
with the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia (Fedaseyeu Study),\707\
another by researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (Fonseca
Study),\708\ and a third by researchers at the Bureau (Romeo-Sandler
Study).\709\ All three studies use changes in State or local debt
collection laws and regulations to examine the effect of those laws on
measures of credit access.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\706\ In addition, earlier empirical research examined the
relationship between restrictions on creditor remedies and the
supply of credit. See Thomas A. Durkin et al, Consumer Credit and
the American Economy 521-525 (Oxford U. Press 2014) (summarizing
this empirical literature).
\707\ Viktar Fedaseyeu, Debt Collection Agencies and the Supply
of Consumer Credit (Fed. Reserve Bank of Phila. Working Paper No.
15-23, 2015).
\708\ Julia Fonseca, Katherine Strair & Basit Zafar, Access to
Credit and Financial Health: Evaluating the Impact of Debt
Collection (Fed. Reserve Bank of N.Y. Staff Report No. 814, 2017).
\709\ Charles Romeo & Ryan Sandler, The Effect of Debt
Collection Laws on Access to Credit (Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Off. of Research, Working Paper No. 2018-01, 2018.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Fedaseyeu Study used aggregate data on new credit card accounts
combined with credit union call report data to examine the effect of
various State law changes between 1999 and 2012 on the number of new
revolving lines of credit opened each year in each State. This study
finds that an additional restriction on debt collectors decreases the
number of new accounts by about two accounts per quarter per 1,000
consumers residing in a State. For comparison, the data used for the
Fedaseyeu Study showed an average of 120 new accounts per quarter per
1,000 consumers. The Fedaseyeu Study finds no effect of debt collection
laws on the average credit card interest rate.\710\ However, the
Fedaseyeu Study has some important limitations, particularly regarding
extrapolating its results to the effects of the proposed rule. Most
importantly, it considers a wide variety of types of debt collection
laws, including provisions with limited consumer protection aspects.
Specifically, a majority of the debt collection law changes included in
the Fedaseyeu Study largely involve changes to licensing fees, bonds,
or levels of statutory penalties for violations, rather than
prohibiting or requiring specific conduct, and each such change is
given the same weight as a law governing conduct.\711\ Leaving aside
the question of whether monetary adjustments under State law are of a
comparable magnitude to the proposed regulations under Federal law, the
proposed rule focuses on conduct, rather than State licensing fees,
bonds, or penalty amounts. As such, the results of the Fedaseyeu Study
are less informative as to the effects of the proposed rule than they
would be if the legal changes at issue were more comparable. The data
analysis in the Fedaseyeu Study is also somewhat limited by the data
that were available. The aggregate data used make it difficult to
control for confounding factors, such as differences in credit scores
between consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\710\ In addition to the results described here, the Fedaseyeu
Study also examines the effect of debt collection laws on the number
of debt collection firms per capita and a measure of the recovery
rate from debt collection. The Bureau omits discussion of these
results here because they are not directly relevant to the question
of consumer access--the Bureau discusses potential effects on debt
collection firms above.
\711\ Specifically, Fedaseyeu created an index of debt
collection regulation, with one point added for a tightening in any
one of six categories of regulation, including licensing
requirements, bonding requirements, and the creation of a board to
regulate third-party debt collectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Fonseca Study follows a similar design as the Fedaseyeu Study
and examines the same set of State law changes, but it employs
microdata from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's Consumer Credit
Panel, a nationally representative sample of credit records from
Equifax. The main results of the Fonseca Study focus on the initial
loan amounts or limits for automobile loans, credit cards, and non-
traditional finance loans.\712\ The study finds a moderate effect on
automobile loan amounts, and a small effect on initial credit card
limits. Like the Fedaseyeu Study, a major limitation of the Fonseca
Study is its focus on licensing requirements, which are not directly
comparable to the provisions in the proposal. That the Fonseca Study
finds larger effects on automobile loans than credit cards also raises
questions. Although third-party debt collectors are sometimes involved
in collecting on automobile loans when the loan balance exceeds the
value of the car, most delinquent automobile debt is resolved through
repossession. The fact that the Fonseca Study nonetheless found a
moderately large effect on automobile balances suggests that possibly
the study's methodology was not successful in isolating the causal
effect of the debt collection laws, but instead was picking up other,
unrelated, factors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\712\ The Fonseca Study defines non-traditional finance loans as
``retail cards, personal loans and a residual loan category.'' Like
the Fedaseyeu Study, the Fonseca Study also examines the effect of
the debt collection laws studied on the number of debt collectors
present in each State; again, the Bureau omits discussion of those
results in this section.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Romeo-Sandler Study uses microdata from two large
administrative datasets: The Bureau's Consumer Credit Panel (CCP) \713\
and Credit Card Database (CCDB).\714\ This study focuses on four recent
major changes in State or local laws and regulations that imposed
additional conduct requirements on either debt buyers or on all debt
collectors.\715\ By focusing on the effect of changes to laws that
regulate debt collector conduct, the results of the Romeo-Sandler Study
are arguably more applicable to understanding the effects of the
proposal, although the specific changes to State or local laws studied
differ considerably from the provisions of the proposed rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\713\ Although similar in nature, the Bureau's CCP is not the
same as the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's Consumer Credit
Panel, discussed above. The Bureau's CCP is an anonymized sample of
credit records from one of the three nationwide CRAs, containing a
1-in-48 representative sample of all adults with a credit record.
The data contain all credit accounts (trade lines) and hard
inquiries on a consumer's credit report, with a unique, anonymous
identifier linking records belonging to the same consumer. This CCP
does not contain any personally identifying information on
individual consumers.
\714\ The CCDB is a monthly panel describing balances, payments,
and interest rates on all credit card accounts issued by a set of
major banks, representing roughly 90 percent of the credit card
market. As with the CCP, accounts are identified by an anonymous
identifier, and the CCDB does not contain any personally identifying
information.
\715\ New laws were put into effect in North Carolina in October
2009 and California in January 2014; both of these laws focused
exclusively on debt buyers. In addition, New York City, in April
2010, and New York State, in December 2014, introduced new debt
collection restrictions through administrative regulations. These
updated restrictions generally require debt collectors to take
additional steps before collecting, including requiring additional
documents to substantiate debts before collections can begin,
requiring disclosures or additional documentation before lawsuits
can be filed to enforce a debt, and requiring disclosures once the
State's statute of limitations has run out.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Romeo-Sandler Study assesses three main outcomes: The
probability that a credit inquiry results in an open credit card
account, the credit limit on newly opened credit card accounts, and
initial interest rates on credit card accounts. As discussed above,
creditors might limit any of these factors to adjust for the effects of
a regulation such as the proposal. The Romeo-Sandler Study controls for
individual consumers' credit scores and census tract demographic
information and flexibly adjusts for State-level trends over time that
might otherwise bias the estimates of an analysis. As with the
Fedaseyeu Study and Fonseca Study, the Romeo-Sandler Study found
effects of debt collection laws that are in the direction predicted by
theory (i.e., increased regulation increases the cost or decreases the
availability of credit), but the effects are quite small in magnitude.
Using the CCP, this study found that additional regulations on debt
collectors' conduct caused the success rate of a credit inquiry to
decline by less than 0.02 percentage points off a base
[[Page 23391]]
rate of about 43 percent. The study concludes that one can
statistically reject that the effect was as large as 0.7 percentage
points. The study provides some context for these effects by comparing
them to the effect of changing consumers' credit scores. The study
found that each credit score point increases the probability of a
successful credit inquiry for subprime borrowers by about 0.2
percentage points. Thus, the estimated effect of a debt collection law
is equivalent to lowering consumers' credit scores by less than one
point.\716\ The Romeo-Sandler Study finds similarly small effects on
credit limits, which are again equivalent to a very small change in
credit score. The magnitude of the credit limit effect in the Romeo-
Sandler Study is smaller than that found in the Fonseca Study.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\716\ The study notes, as a point of comparison, that this
effect is considerably smaller than that of routine errors in credit
reports. See Fed. Trade Comm'n, Report to Congress Under Section 319
of the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act of 2003, at 43
(Dec. 2012), https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/reports/section-319-fair-and-accurate-credit-transactions-act-2003-fifth-interim-federal-trade-commission/130211factareport.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Romeo-Sandler Study also analyzes the effect of debt collection
laws on credit card interest rates using the CCDB. The study finds that
initial interest rates increase slightly following a State or local
debt collection law or regulation, but that this entirely takes the
form of a reduced frequency of accounts with an introductory APR of 0
percent--the level of positive initial interest rates are essentially
unchanged.
The Romeo-Sandler Study is also able to shed light on potential
areas of heterogeneity in the effects of State debt collection laws
because of its access to rich microdata. The Romeo-Sandler Study
explores the effects separately for consumers with high and low credit
scores, and finds somewhat larger (although still small) effects on
consumers with sub-prime credit scores. This is consistent with theory.
Even within the sub-sample of consumers with sub-prime credit scores,
the effect of the laws is equivalent to a three-point decrease in sub-
prime borrowers' credit scores.
The studies discussed above provide evidence that regulation of
debt collection can affect consumer access to credit in ways consistent
with economic theory. However, these studies do not speak directly to
the likely effects of the proposed rule on consumer credit markets. The
State or local laws analyzed in these studies implement a different set
of consumer protections than those in the proposed rule. The proposed
rule includes some provisions likely to increase debt collector costs,
but it also includes other provisions, such as those related to
limited-content messages and email and text messages, which could lower
costs for some debt collectors. In addition, creditors and debt
collectors might react differently to changes in State or local
collection standards than the standards in the Bureau's proposed rule,
which could affect all U.S. consumers. For instance, a nationwide
creditor might choose not to adjust its credit standards in response to
a change in only one State's debt collection laws, but might find it
optimal to change its standards if similar laws applied nationwide or
to a large share of its potential borrowers.
H. Potential Specific Impacts of the Proposed Rule
1. Depository Institutions and Credit Unions With $10 Billion or Less
in Total Assets, as Described in Section 1026
Depository institutions and credit unions are generally not debt
collectors under the FDCPA and therefore would not be covered by the
proposal. However, as noted above, creditors could experience indirect
effects from the proposal to the extent they hire FDCPA-covered debt
collectors or sell debt in default to such debt collectors. Such
creditors could experience higher costs if debt collectors' costs
increase and if debt collectors are able to pass those costs on to
creditors.
The Bureau understands that many depository institutions and credit
unions with $10 billion or less in total assets rely on FDCPA-covered
debt collectors to collect unpaid amounts, but the Bureau does not have
data indicating whether such institutions are more or less likely than
other creditors to do so. The Bureau requests additional data and other
information about potential benefits and costs of the proposal for
these institutions.
2. Impact of the Proposed Provisions on Consumers in Rural Areas
Consumers in rural areas may experience benefits from the proposed
rule that are different in certain respects from the benefits
experienced by consumers in general. For example, consumers in rural
areas may be more likely to borrow from small local banks and credit
unions that may be less likely to outsource debt collection to FDCPA-
covered debt collectors. Debts owed by consumers in rural areas may
also be more likely to be collected by smaller debt collectors, which
the Bureau understands are less likely to attempt debt collection calls
more frequently than the proposed frequency caps would permit. The
proposed frequency caps may therefore have less of an impact on
consumers in rural areas.
The Bureau will further consider the impact of the proposed rule on
consumers in rural areas. The Bureau therefore asks interested parties
to provide data, research results, and other factual information on the
impact of the proposed rule on consumers in rural areas.
I. Request for Information
The Bureau will further consider the benefits, costs, and impacts
of the proposed provisions and additional proposed modifications before
finalizing the proposal. As noted above, there are a number of areas in
which additional information would allow the Bureau to better estimate
the benefits, costs, and impacts of this proposal and more fully inform
the rulemaking. The Bureau asks interested parties to provide comment
or data on various aspects of the proposed rule, as detailed in the
section-by-section analysis. Information provided by interested parties
regarding these and other aspects of the proposed rule may be
considered in the analysis of the benefits, costs, and impacts of the
final rule. The Bureau specifically requests precise cost or
operational data that would permit it to better evaluate the potential
impacts on consumers and covered persons, including impacts on
collection rates, implementation costs and ongoing operational costs
imposed by the proposed provisions. The Bureau also requests comment on
the research referenced above, including its use of the Fedaseyeu
Study, the Fonseca Study, and the Romeo-Sandler Study.
[[Page 23392]]
VII. Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
Under section 603(a) of the Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA), an
initial regulatory flexibility analysis (IRFA) ``shall describe the
impact of the proposed rule on small entities.'' \717\ Section 603(b)
of the RFA sets forth the required elements of the IRFA. Section
603(b)(1) requires a description of the reasons agency action is being
considered.\718\ Section 603(b)(2) requires a succinct statement of the
objectives of, and the legal basis for, the proposed rule.\719\ Section
603(b)(3) requires a description of and, where feasible, an estimate of
the number of small entities to which the proposed rule will
apply.\720\ Section 603(b)(4) requires a description of the projected
reporting, recordkeeping, and other compliance requirements of the
proposed rule, including an estimate of the classes of small entities
that will be subject to the requirement and the types of professional
skills necessary for the preparation of the report or record.\721\
Section 603(b)(5) requires identifying, to the extent practicable, all
relevant Federal rules which may duplicate, overlap, or conflict with
the proposed rule.\722\ Section 603(c) requires a description of any
significant alternatives to the proposed rule that accomplish the
stated objectives of applicable statutes and that minimize any
significant economic impact of the proposed rule on small
entities.\723\ Finally, section 603(d)(1) requires a description of any
projected increase in the cost of credit for small entities, a
description of any significant alternatives to the proposed rule that
accomplish the stated objectives of applicable statutes and that
minimize any increase in the cost of credit for small entities (if such
an increase in the cost of credit is projected), and a description of
the advice and recommendations of representatives of small entities
relating to the cost of credit issues.\724\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\717\ 5 U.S.C. 603(a).
\718\ 5 U.S.C. 603(b)(1).
\719\ 5 U.S.C. 603(b)(2).
\720\ 5 U.S.C. 603(b)(3).
\721\ 5 U.S.C. 603(b)(4).
\722\ 5 U.S.C. 603(b)(5).
\723\ 5 U.S.C. 603(c).
\724\ 5 U.S.C. 603(d)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. Description of the Reasons Why Agency Action Is Being Considered
As noted in part I, the Bureau is issuing this proposed rule to
implement and interpret the FDCPA, particularly with respect to debt
collection communication, disclosure, and other related practices by
FDCPA-covered debt collectors, and to further the FDCPA's goals of
eliminating abusive debt collection practices and ensuring that debt
collectors who refrain from abusive debt collection practices are not
competitively disadvantaged.\725\ The FDCPA established certain
consumer protections, but interpretive questions have arisen since its
passage. Some questions, including those related to communication
technologies that did not exist at the time the FDCPA was enacted (such
as mobile telephones, emails, and text messages), have been the subject
of inconsistent court decisions, resulting in legal uncertainty and
additional cost for industry and consumers. The Bureau proposes to
clarify how debt collectors may employ such technologies in compliance
with the FDCPA and to address other communications- and disclosure-
related practices that currently pose a risk of harm to consumers,
legal uncertainty to industry, or both. The Bureau also proposes that
FDCPA-covered debt collectors comply with certain additional
disclosure-related and record retention requirements pursuant to the
Bureau's Dodd-Frank Act rulemaking authority; these proposed
requirements are designed to enhance consumer understanding of the debt
collection process and to promote effective and efficient enforcement
and supervision of Regulation F.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\725\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Statement of the Objectives of, and Legal Basis for, the Proposed
Rule
As discussed in part IV, the Bureau issues this proposal pursuant
to its authority under the FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank Act. The objectives
of the proposed rule are to answer certain interpretive questions that
have arisen since the FDCPA's passage and to further the FDCPA's goals
of eliminating abusive debt collection practices and to ensuring that
debt collectors who refrain from abusive debt collection practices are
not competitively disadvantaged.\726\ As the first Federal agency with
authority under the FDCPA to prescribe substantive rules with respect
to the collection of debts by debt collectors, the Bureau proposes to
clarify by rule how debt collectors may appropriately employ newer
communication technologies in compliance with the FDCPA and to address
other communications-related practices that currently pose a risk of
harm to consumers, legal uncertainty to industry, or both. The Bureau
also proposes to clarify consumer disclosure requirements to provide
clarity for both consumers and industry participants. The Bureau
intends that these clarifications will help to eliminate abusive debt
collection practices and ensure that debt collectors who refrain from
abusive debt collection practices are not competitively
disadvantaged.\727\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\726\ See 15 U.S.C. 1692(e).
\727\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, FDCPA section 814(d) provides
that the Bureau may ``prescribe rules with respect to the collection of
debts by debt collectors,'' as that term is defined in the FDCPA.\728\
Section 1022(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that ``[t]he Bureau is
authorized to exercise its authorities under Federal consumer financial
law to administer, enforce, and otherwise implement the provisions of
Federal consumer financial law.'' \729\ ``Federal consumer financial
law'' includes title X of the Dodd-Frank Act and the FDCPA. The legal
basis for the proposed rule is discussed in detail in the legal
authority analysis in part IV and in the section-by-section analysis in
part V.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\728\ 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d).
\729\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Description and, Where Feasible, Provision of an Estimate of the
Number of Small Entities To Which the Proposed Rule Will Apply
As discussed in the Small Business Review Panel Report, for the
purposes of assessing the impacts of the proposed rule on small
entities, ``small entities'' is defined in the RFA to include small
businesses, small nonprofit organizations, and small government
jurisdictions.\730\ A ``small business'' is determined by application
of SBA regulations in reference to the North American Industry
Classification System (NAICS) classifications and size standards.\731\
Under such standards, the Small Business Review Panel (Panel)
identified four categories of small entities that may be subject to the
proposed provisions: Collection agencies (NAICS 561440) with $15
million or less in annual receipts, debt buyers (NAICS 522298) with
$38.5 million or less in annual revenues, collection law firms (NAICS
54110) with $11 million or less in annual receipts, and servicers who
acquire accounts in default. These servicers include depository
institutions (NAICS 522110, 522120, and 522130) with $550 million or
less in annual receipts or non-depository institutions (NAICS 522390)
with $20.5 million or less in annual receipts. The Panel did not meet
[[Page 23393]]
with small nonprofit organizations or small government
jurisdictions.\732\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\730\ 5 U.S.C. 601(6).
\731\ The current SBA size standards are found on SBA's website,
http://www.sba.gov/content/table-small-business-size-standards.
\732\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following table provides the Bureau's estimate of the number
and types of entities that may be affected by the proposed provisions:
Table 4--Estimated Number of Affected Entities and Small Entities by Category
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated
total number Estimated
Small entity of debt number of
Category NAICS threshold collectors small entity
within debt
category collectors
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Collection agencies............... 561440............... $15.0 million in 9,000 8,800
annual receipts.
Debt buyers....................... 522298............... $38.5 million in 330 300
annual receipts.
Collection law firms.............. 541110............... $11.0 million in 1,000 950
annual receipts.
Loan servicers.................... 522110, 522120, and $550 million in 700 200
522130 annual receipts for
(depositories); depository
522390 (non- institutions; $20.5
depositories. million or less for
non-depositories.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Descriptions of the Four Categories
Collection agencies. The Census Bureau defines ``collection
agencies'' (NAICS code 561440) as ``establishments primarily engaged in
collecting payments for claims and remitting payments collected to
their clients.'' \733\ In 2012, according to the Census Bureau, there
were approximately 4,000 collection agencies with paid employees in the
United States. Of these, the Bureau estimates that 3,800 collection
agencies have $15.0 million or less in annual receipts and are
therefore small entities.\734\ Census Bureau estimates indicate that in
2012 there were also more than 5,000 collection agencies without
employees, all of which are presumably small entities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\733\ As defined by the Census Bureau, collection agencies
include entities that collect only commercial debt, and the
proposals under consideration apply only to debt collectors of
consumer debt. However, the Bureau understands that relatively few
collection agencies collect only commercial debt.
\734\ The Census Bureau estimates average annual receipts of
$95,000 per employee for collection agencies. Given this, the Bureau
assumes that all firms with fewer than 100 employees and
approximately one-half of the firms with 100 to 499 employees are
small entities, which implies approximately 3,800 firms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt buyers. Debt buyers purchase delinquent accounts and attempt
to collect amounts owed, either themselves or through agents. The
Bureau estimates that there are approximately 330 debt buyers in the
United States, and that a substantial majority of these are small
entities.\735\ Many debt buyers--particularly those that are small
entities--also collect debt on behalf of other debt owners.\736\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\735\ The Receivables Management Association, the largest trade
group for this industry segment, states that it has approximately
300 debt buyer members and believes that 90 percent of debt buyers
are current members.
\736\ The Bureau understands that debt buyers are generally
nondepositories that specialize in debt buying and, in some cases,
debt collection. The Bureau expects that debt buyers that are not
collection agencies would be classified by the Census Bureau under
``all other nondepository credit intermediation'' (NAICS Code
522298).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Collection law firms. The Bureau estimates that there are 1,000 law
firms in the United States that either have as their principal purpose
the collection of consumer debt or regularly collect consumer debt owed
to others, so that the proposed rule would apply to them. The Bureau
estimates that 95 percent of such law firms are small entities.\737\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\737\ The primary trade association for collection attorneys,
the National Creditors Bar Association (NARCA), states that it has
approximately 600 law firm members, 95 percent of which are small
entities. The Bureau estimates that approximately 60 percent of law
firms that collect debt are NARCA members and that a similar
fraction of non-member law firms are small entities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loan servicers. Loan servicers would be covered by the proposed
rule if they acquire servicing of loans already in default.\738\ The
Bureau believes that this is most likely to occur with regard to
companies that service mortgage loans or student loans. The Bureau
estimates that approximately 200 such mortgage servicers may be small
entities and that few, if any, student loan servicers that would be
covered by the proposed rule are small.\739\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\738\ The Bureau expects that loan servicers are generally
classified under NAICS code 522390, ``Other Activities Related to
Credit Intermediation.'' Some depository institutions (NAICS codes
522110, 522120, and 522130) also service loans for others and may be
covered by the proposed rule.
\739\ Based on the December 2015 Call Report data as compiled by
SNL Financial (with respect to insured depositories) and December
2015 data from the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry
(with respect to non-depositories), the Bureau estimates that there
are approximately 9,000 small entities engaged in mortgage
servicing, of which approximately 100 service more than 5,000 loans.
See 81 FR 72160, 72363 (Oct. 19, 2016). The Bureau's estimate is
based on the assumption that all those servicing more than 5,000
loans may acquire servicing of loans when loans are in default and
that at most 100 of those servicing 5,000 loans or fewer acquire
servicing of loans when loans are in default.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Projected Reporting, Recordkeeping, and Other Compliance
Requirements of the Proposed Rule, Including an Estimate of Classes of
Small Entities That Will Be Subject to the Requirements and the Type of
Professional Skills Necessary for the Preparation of the Report or
Record
The proposed rule would not impose new reporting requirements, but
would impose new recordkeeping and compliance requirements on small
entities subject to the proposal. The proposed requirements and the
costs associated with them are discussed below.
1. Recordkeeping Requirements
Proposed Sec. 1006.100 would require FDCPA-covered debt collectors
to retain evidence of compliance with Regulation F starting on the date
that the debt collector begins collection activity on a debt and ending
three years after: (1) The debt collector's last communication or
attempted communication in connection with the collection of the debt;
or (2) the debt is settled, discharged, or transferred to the debt
owner or to another debt collector.
The Bureau believes that most debt collectors are already
maintaining records for three or more years for legal purposes and
therefore would not incur significant costs as a result of the
proposal's record retention requirement. During the SBREFA process,
nearly all small entity representatives stated that their current
practices are already consistent with a three-year record retention
requirement, and some said that they retain records for longer periods
ranging from five to 10 years.\740\ Some participants said, however,
that
[[Page 23394]]
they retain some information for a shorter period of time such as one
year. Such small entities would incur additional costs for data storage
and to update systems to reflect the longer storage period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\740\ Small Business Review Panel Report, supra note 57, at 28.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Compliance Requirements
The proposal contains a number of compliance requirements that
would apply to FDCPA-covered debt collectors who are small entities.
The anticipated costs of compliance for small entities of these
requirements are discussed below.
In evaluating the potential impacts of the proposal on small
entities, the Bureau takes as a baseline conduct in the debt collection
markets under the current legal framework governing debt collection.
This includes debt collector practices as they currently exist,
responding to the requirements of the FDCPA as currently interpreted
and other Federal laws as well as State statutes and rules. This
baseline represents the status quo from which the impacts of this
proposal will be evaluated.
The Bureau requests comment on the estimated impacts on small
entities discussed below and solicits data and analysis that would
supplement the quantitative estimates discussed below or provide
quantitative estimates of benefits, costs, or impacts for which there
are currently only qualitative discussions.
The discussion here is confined to the direct costs to small
entities of complying with the requirements of the proposed rule, if
finalized. Other impacts, such as the impacts of call frequency limits
on debt collectors' ability to contact consumers, are discussed at
length in part VI. The Bureau believes that, except where otherwise
noted, the impacts discussed in part VI would apply to small entities.
(a) Prohibited Communications With Consumers
Proposed Sec. 1006.6(b) generally would implement FDCPA section
805(a)'s prohibition on a debt collector communicating with a consumer
at unusual or inconvenient times and places, with a consumer
represented by an attorney, and at a consumer's place of employment.
This section would also expressly prohibit attempts to make such
communications, which debt collectors already must avoid given that a
successful attempt would be an FDCPA violation. Proposed Sec.
1006.14(h)(1) would interpret FDCPA section 806's prohibition on a debt
collector engaging in any conduct the natural consequence of which is
to harass, oppress, or abuse any person in connection with the
collection of a debt to prohibit debt collectors from communicating or
attempting to communicate with consumers through a medium of
communication if the consumer has requested that the debt collector not
use that medium to communicate with the consumer.
Debt collectors are already prohibited from communicating with
consumers at a time or place that is known or should be known to be
inconvenient to the consumer. The Bureau therefore believes that many
debt collectors already keep track of what consumers tell them about
the times and places that they find inconvenient and avoid
communicating or attempting to communicate with consumers at these
times or places. Similarly, the proposed provisions regarding
communication with attorneys and at the consumer's place of employment
track debt collector practices that already comply with the FDCPA. The
Bureau understands that many debt collectors currently employ systems
and business processes designed to limit communication attempts to
consumers at inconvenient times and places and that many debt
collectors also use these systems and processes to prevent
communications with consumers through media that consumers have told
them are inconvenient. For these reasons, the Bureau does not expect
that the proposed provisions would significantly impact small entities
subject to the proposal.
(b) Frequency Limits for Telephone Calls and Telephone Conversations
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) would prohibit a debt collector from,
in connection with the collection of a debt, placing telephone calls or
engaging in telephone conversation repeatedly or continuously with
intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any person at the called number.
Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) would provide that, subject to certain
exceptions set forth in proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector
violates proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) if the debt collector places a
telephone call to a person in connection with the collection of a
particular debt either: (i) More than seven times within seven
consecutive days; or (ii) within a period of seven consecutive days
after having had a telephone conversation with the person in connection
with the collection of such debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.14(b)(4) would
clarify the effect of complying with the frequency limits in Sec.
1006.14(b)(2), stating that a debt collector who does not exceed the
limits complies with Sec. 1006.14(b)(1) and FDCPA section 806(5), and
does not, based on the frequency of its telephone calls, violate Sec.
1006.14(a), FDCPA section 806, or Dodd-Frank Act sections 1031 or
1036(a)(1)(B).
The proposed provision would impose at least two categories of
costs on small entities subject to the FDCPA. First, it would mean that
debt collectors must track the frequency of outbound telephone calls,
which would require many debt collectors to bear one-time costs to
update their systems and train staff and create ongoing costs for some
debt collectors. Second, for some debt collectors, the proposed
provision would require a reduction in the frequency with which they
place telephone calls to consumers, which could make it harder to reach
consumers and delay or reduce collections revenue.
With respect to one-time implementation costs, many debt collectors
would incur costs to revise their systems to incorporate the proposed
call frequency limits. Such revisions could range from small updates to
existing systems to the introduction of completely new systems and
processes. The Bureau understands that larger debt collectors
(including those that are small entities) generally already implement
system limits on call frequency to comply with client contractual
requirements, debt collector internal policies, and State and local
laws.\741\ Such debt collectors might need only to revise existing
calling restrictions to ensure that existing systems comply with the
limits. Larger debt collectors might also need to respond to client
requests for additional reports and audit items to verify that they
comply with the limits, which could require these agencies to make
systems changes to alter the reports and data they produce for their
clients to review.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\741\ Id. at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smaller debt collectors and debt collection law firms are less
likely to have existing systems that track or limit communication
frequency, and may therefore face larger costs to establish systems to
do so. However, many smaller debt collectors report that they generally
attempt to reach each consumer by telephone only one or two times per
week and generally do not speak to a consumer more than one time per
week, which suggests that their practices are already within the
proposed frequency limits.\742\ For such debt collectors, existing
policies may be
[[Page 23395]]
sufficient to ensure compliance with the proposed provision.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\742\ CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at
29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(c) Time-Barred Debt: Prohibiting Suits and Threats of Suit
Proposed Sec. 1006.26(b) would prohibit a debt collector from
suing or threatening to sue on a debt that the debt collector knows or
should know is time-barred.
As discussed in part V, courts have held that the FDCPA prohibits
suits and threats of suit on time-barred debt. In light of this, the
Bureau understands that most debt collectors do not knowingly sue or
threaten to sue consumers to collect time-barred debts, and therefore
the Bureau does not expect this provision of the proposed rule to have
a significant effect on small entities.\743\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\743\ For example, small entity representatives at the meeting
of the Small Business Review Panel indicated that it was standard
practice in the industry not to knowingly initiate lawsuits to
collect time-barred debt. See Small Business Review Panel Report,
supra note 57, at 35. Some industry groups have adopted policies
requiring members to refrain from suing or threatening to sue on
time-barred debts. See, e.g., Receivables Mgmt. Ass'n, Receivables
Management Certification Program, at 32 (Jan. 19, 2018), https://rmassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Certification-Policy-version-6.0-FINAL-20180119.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(d) Communication Prior To Furnishing Information
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(a) would prohibit a debt collector from
furnishing information to a CRA regarding a debt before communicating
with the consumer about that debt, a requirement that debt collectors
could satisfy by sending a validation notice prior to furnishing
information.
The proposal would affect the practices of debt collectors who
sometimes furnish information about consumers' debts to CRAs before the
debt collectors have communicated with consumers. The Bureau
understands that most debt collectors mail validation notices to
consumers shortly after they receive the accounts for collections and
before they furnish data on those accounts, and so they already would
be in compliance with the proposed requirement.\744\ Forty-five out of
58 debt collectors responding to the Debt Collection Operations Survey
said that they furnish information to credit bureaus.\745\ In all but
three of these cases, the respondents said that they send a validation
notice upon account placement, such that the proposed requirement would
be satisfied. These debt collectors would likely need to review their
policies to ensure that validation notices are always sent (or
validation information is provided in an initial communication) prior
to reporting on the account, which the Bureau expects would involve a
small one-time cost. Other debt collectors do not furnish information
at all to CRAs and so would not be affected by the proposed
requirement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\744\ In the Operations Study, 53 of 58 respondents said that
they send a validation notice shortly after account placement. CFPB
Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45, at 28.
\745\ Id. at 19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debt collectors who furnish information to CRAs but provide
validation notices to consumers only after they have been in contact
with consumers would need to change their practices and would face
increased costs as a result of the proposal. Because these debt
collectors are already required to provide validation notices to
consumers once they communicate with those consumers (unless validation
information is provided in an initial communication or the consumer
pays the debt), the Bureau expects that they already have systems in
place for sending notices and would not face one-time compliance costs
greater than those of other debt collectors. However, debt collectors
would face ongoing costs from sending validation notices to more
consumers than they would otherwise, at an estimated cost of $0.50 to
$0.80 per debt if sent by postal mail.\746\ To the extent debt
collectors take advantage of opportunities to send validation notices
electronically, an option the proposal elsewhere seeks to make more
viable, the marginal cost of sending each notice is likely to be
approximately zero. Alternatively, these debt collectors could cease
furnishing information to CRAs, which could impact the effectiveness of
their collection efforts.\747\ Because debt collectors could choose the
less burdensome of these options, the additional costs of delivering
notices represent an upper bound on the burden of the provision on
small entities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\746\ One small entity representative on the Bureau's Small
Business Review Panel indicated that, for about one-half of its
debts, it sends validation notices only after speaking with a
consumer and that, if it were required to send validation notices to
all consumers, it would incur mailing costs of $0.63 per mailing for
an estimated 400,000 accounts per year.
\747\ If debt collectors furnish to credit reporting agencies
less frequently this could make consumer reports less informative in
general, which could have negative effects on the credit system by
making it harder for creditors to assess credit risk.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(e) Prohibition on the Sale or Transfer of Certain Debts
Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(1) would prohibit a debt collector from
selling, transferring, or placing for collection a debt if the debt
collector knows or should know that the debt was paid or settled, the
debt was discharged in bankruptcy, or an identity theft report was
filed with respect to the debt. Proposed Sec. 1006.30(b)(2) would
create several exceptions to this prohibition.
The Bureau understands, based on its market knowledge and outreach
to debt collectors, that debt collectors generally do not sell,
transfer, or place for collections debts (other than in circumstances
covered in the exceptions) if they have reason to believe the debts
cannot be validly collected because they have been paid, they were
settled in bankruptcy, or an identity theft report was filed with
respect to them. Therefore, the Bureau does not expect this provision
to create significant compliance costs for small entities.
(f) Notice for Validation of Debts
Proposed Sec. 1006.34 would implement and interpret FDCPA section
809(a), (b), (d), and (e). Specifically, proposed Sec. 1006.34(a)
provides that, subject to certain exceptions, a debt collector must
provide a consumer the validation information described in Sec.
1006.34(c). Proposed Sec. 1006.34(c) would implement FDCPA section
809(a)'s content requirements and require that the validation notice
include certain information about the debt and the consumer's
protections with respect to debt collection that debt collectors do not
currently provide on the validation notice. Proposed Sec. 1006.34(d)
would set forth general formatting requirements and permit debt
collectors to comply with these requirements by using the proposed
model validation notice in appendix B.
Debt collectors already send validation notices to consumers to
comply with the FDCPA, so the proposed validation information would
generally affect the content of existing disclosures debt collectors
are already sending rather than require debt collectors to send
entirely new disclosures. Nonetheless, debt collectors would incur
certain costs to comply with the proposal. These include one-time
compliance costs, the ongoing costs of obtaining the required
validation information, and potentially ongoing costs of responding to
a potential increase in the number of disputes.
The proposed provision would require debt collectors to reformat
their validation notices to accommodate the proposed validation
information requirements. The Bureau expects that any one-time costs to
debt collectors of reformatting the validation notice would
[[Page 23396]]
be relatively small, particularly for debt collectors who rely on
vendors, because the Bureau expects that most vendors would provide an
updated notice at no additional cost.\748\ The Bureau understands from
its outreach that many debt collectors currently use vendors to provide
validation notices.\749\ Surveyed firms, and their vendors, told the
Bureau that vendors do not typically charge an additional cost to
modify an existing template (although this practice might not apply if
the proposal required more extensive changes to validation notices than
vendors typically make today).\750\ Debt collectors and vendors would
bear costs to understand the requirements of the proposed provision and
to ensure that their systems generate notices that comply with the
requirement, although these costs would be mitigated somewhat by the
availability of a model form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\748\ See CFPB Debt Collection Operations Study, supra note 45,
at 33.
\749\ In the Operations Survey, over 85 percent of debt
collectors surveyed by the Bureau reported using letter vendors. Id.
at 32.
\750\ Id. at 33.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The proposed validation information requires debt collectors to
provide certain additional information about the debt, which would
require that debt collectors receive and maintain certain data fields
and incorporate them into the notices. The Bureau believes that the
large majority of debt collectors already receive and maintain most
data fields included in the proposed validation information. However,
some respondents to the Operations Survey reported that they do not
receive from creditors information on post-default interest, fees,
payments, and credits.\751\ These debt collectors would have to update
their systems to track these fields. The Bureau understands that such
system updates would be likely to cost less than $1,000 for each debt
collector.\752\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\751\ In the Operations Survey, 52 of 58 respondents reported
receiving itemization of post-charge-off fees on at least some of
their accounts. Id. at table 8.
\752\ See id. at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If debt collectors adjust their systems to produce notices
including the new validation information, the Bureau would not expect
there would be an increase in the ongoing costs of printing and sending
validation notices. However, there could be ongoing costs related to
the validation information requirements if the required data are not
always available to debt collectors. The Bureau understands that some
creditors do not currently track post-default charges and credits in a
way that can be readily transferred to debt collectors. Under the
proposal, debt collectors would be unable to send validation notices--
and therefore unable to collect--if creditors do not provide this
information.\753\ Some debt collectors might lose revenue as a result
of not being able to collect debts if they do not obtain this
information from creditors. The Bureau does not have representative
data that would permit it to estimate how frequently this would occur.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\753\ For example, the Bureau understands that after New York
began requiring itemization of post-charge-off fees and credits,
some creditors were at least initially unable to provide this
information and therefore did not place New York accounts for
collection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(g) Electronic Disclosures and Communications
The proposed rule includes provisions that the Bureau expects would
encourage debt collectors to communicate with consumers by email and
text message more frequently than they currently do. With respect to
the validation notice, which most debt collectors currently provide by
postal mail, proposed Sec. 1006.42 specifies methods that debt
collectors would be able to use to send notices by email or by
hyperlink to a secure website in a way that complies with the FDCPA's
validation notice requirements. With respect to any communications
about a debt, proposed Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) specifies procedures that
debt collectors would be able to use to send an email or text message
to a consumer about a debt without risking liability under the FDCPA
for disclosure of the debt to a third party.
The Bureau understands that few debt collectors currently
communicate with consumers using electronic means. For debt collectors
who do communicate with consumers electronically, the proposal would
require them to provide a method for opting out of such communications
and, if providing required disclosures electronically, to provide
certain information about the account in the subject line. The Bureau
understands that these requirements are common features of services
that provide the ability to send email to consumers. The Bureau
therefore does not anticipate that these requirements would impose
significant costs on small entities that choose to communicate with
consumers using electronic means.
E. Identification, to the Extent Practicable, of All Relevant Federal
Rules That May Duplicate, Overlap, or Conflict With the Proposed Rule
Certain other Federal laws and regulations include requirements
that apply to FDCPA-covered debt collectors, as described below.
However, consistent with the findings of the Small Business Review
Panel, the Bureau is not aware of any other Federal regulations that
currently duplicate, overlap, or conflict with the proposed rule.
For example, the Bureau's Mortgage Rules under the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) and Truth in Lending Act (TILA)
include communication requirements and policies and procedures
applicable to mortgage servicers, some of whom may also be subject to
the FDCPA. As a result, when the Bureau issued the 2016 Servicing Final
Rule, the Bureau concurrently issued an FDCPA interpretive rule to
clarify the interaction of the FDCPA and specified mortgage servicing
rules in Regulations X and Z.\754\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\754\ See the section-by-section analysis of proposed Sec.
1006.6(a)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) also includes certain
provisions that apply to debt collectors, including a provision that
prohibits any person from selling, transferring for consideration, or
placing for collection a debt that the person has been notified
resulted from identity theft.\755\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\755\ 15 U.S.C. 1681m(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some Federal laws implemented by other government agencies also
include protections and requirements that may apply to debt collection
activities. For example, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act
(TCPA),\756\ which is implemented by the Federal Communications
Commission (FCC), affects some debt collection activities by
restricting the use of automatic telephone dialing systems and
artificial or prerecorded voice messages.\757\ In addition, the
Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA) \758\ provides certain
protections from civil actions against servicemembers in active duty.
The SCRA restricts or limits actions against these personnel in a
variety of areas related to financial management, including rental
agreements, security deposits, evictions, credit card interest rates,
judicial proceedings, and income tax payments.\759\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\756\ 47 U.S.C. 227.
\757\ See ACA Int'l v. Fed. Commc'ns Comm'n, 885 F.3d 687 (DC
Cir. 2018).
\758\ 50 U.S.C. 3901-4043.
\759\ The Bureau also recognizes that other Federal regulations,
including those issued by the Department of Education, may relate to
debt collection. The Bureau will consult again with other Federal
agencies whose regulations may be related to this rulemaking prior
to issuing a final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requests comment on the intersection between the
proposed rule and other Federal laws and regulations. The Bureau
specifically requests
[[Page 23397]]
comment on conflicts that may arise between the proposed rule and other
Federal laws and regulations and methods to minimize such conflicts to
the extent they exist.
F. Description of Any Significant Alternatives to the Proposed Rule
That Accomplish the Stated Objectives of the Applicable Statutes and
Minimize Any Significant Economic Impact of the Proposed Rule on Small
Entities
Section 603(c) of the RFA requires the Bureau to describe in the
IRFA any significant alternatives to the proposed rule that accomplish
the stated objectives of applicable statutes and that minimize any
significant economic impact of the proposed rule on small
entities.\760\ In developing the proposed rule, the Bureau has
considered alternative provisions and believes that none of the
alternatives considered would be as effective at accomplishing the
stated objectives of the FDCPA and the applicable provisions of title X
of the Dodd-Frank Act while minimizing the impact of the proposed rule
on small entities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\760\ 5 U.S.C. 603(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In developing the proposal, the Bureau considered a number of
alternatives, including those considered as part of the SBREFA process.
Many of the alternatives considered would have resulted in greater
costs to small entities than would the proposal. For example, the
Bureau considered limiting the frequency of contacts or contact
attempts by any media, rather than by telephone calls only, and the
Bureau considered requiring debt collectors to provide validation
notices in Spanish under certain circumstances. Because such
alternatives would result in a greater economic impact on small
entities than the proposal, they are not discussed here. The Bureau
also considered alternatives that might have resulted in a smaller
economic impact on small entities than the proposal. Certain of these
alternatives are briefly described and their impacts relative to the
proposed provisions are discussed below.
Limitations on call frequency. The Bureau also considered a
proposal that would have limited the number of calls permitted to any
particular telephone number (e.g., at most two calls to each of a
consumer's landline, mobile, and work telephone numbers). The Bureau
considered such a limit either instead of or in addition to an overall
limit on the frequency of telephone calls to one consumer. Such an
alternative could potentially reduce the effect on debt collector calls
if it permitted more calls when consumers have multiple telephone
numbers. The Bureau decided to propose an aggregate approach because of
concerns that a more prescriptive, per-telephone number approach could
less effectively carry out the consumer protection purposes of the
FDCPA--some consumers could receive (and some debt collectors could
place) more telephone calls simply based on the number of telephone
numbers that certain consumers happened to have (and that debt
collectors happened to know about). Such an approach also could create
incentives for debt collectors to, for example, place telephone calls
to less convenient telephone numbers after exhausting their telephone
calls to consumers' preferred numbers.
The Bureau also considered alternatives to the proposal's bright-
line limit on call frequency. One alternative would be a rebuttable
presumption of a violation when debt collectors call more frequently
than the proposed limits, paired with a rebuttable presumption of
compliance when debt collectors call less frequently. The presumptions
could be rebutted based on the facts and circumstances of a particular
situation. Another alternative would be to provide only a safe harbor
for telephone calls below the frequency limits, with no provision for
telephone calls above the frequency limits. Such an approach would
provide certainty to both debt collectors and consumers about a per se
permissible level of calling, but it would leave open the question of
how many telephone calls is too many under the FDCPA and the Dodd-Frank
Act. The Bureau decided not to propose such an approach because it
appears that it would not provide the clarity that debt collectors and
consumers have sought, nor would it appear to provide the same degree
of consumer protection as a per se prohibition against telephone calls
in excess of a specified frequency. However, the proposal solicits
comment on these and other alternatives.
G. Discussion of Impact on Cost of Credit for Small Entities
Section 603(d) of the RFA requires the Bureau to consult with small
entities regarding the potential impact of the proposed rule on the
cost of credit for small entities and related matters.\761\ To satisfy
these statutory requirements, the Bureau provided notification to the
Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Business Administration (Chief
Counsel) that the Bureau would collect the advice and recommendations
of the same small entity representatives identified in consultation
with the Chief Counsel through the SBREFA process concerning any
projected impact and the proposed rule on the cost of credit for small
entities. The Bureau sought to collect the advice and recommendations
of the small entity representatives during the Small Business Review
Panel meeting regarding the potential impact on the cost of business
credit because, as small debt collectors with credit needs, the small
entity representatives could provide valuable input on any such impact
related to the proposed rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\761\ 5 U.S.C. 603(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau's Small Business Review Panel Outline asked small entity
representatives to comment on how proposed provisions will affect cost
of credit to small entities. The Bureau believes that the proposed rule
will have little impact on the cost of credit. However, it does
recognize that consumer credit may become more expensive and less
available as a result of some of these provisions, although the Romeo-
Sandler Study indicates that the magnitude of the cost and availability
of consumer credit from recent changes to State debt collection laws is
small. Many small entities affected by the proposed rule use consumer
credit as a source of credit and may, therefore, see costs rise if
consumer credit availability decreases. The Bureau does not expect this
to be a large effect and does not anticipate measurable impact.\762\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\762\ Charles Romeo & Ryan Sandler, The Effect of Debt
Collection Laws on Access to Credit, (Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Off. of Research, Working Paper No. 2018-01, 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the SBREFA process, several small entity representatives
said that the proposals under consideration at that time could have an
impact on the cost of credit for them and for their small business
clients. Some small entity representatives said that they use lines of
credit in their business and that regulations that raise their costs or
reduce their revenue could mean they are unable to meet covenants in
their loan agreements, causing lenders to reduce access to capital or
increase their borrowing costs.
VIII. Paperwork Reduction Act
Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (PRA),\763\ Federal
agencies are generally required to seek approval from the Office of
Management and Budget (OMB) for information collection requirements
prior to implementation. Under the PRA, the Bureau may not conduct or
sponsor, and, notwithstanding any other provision of law, a person is
not required to respond
[[Page 23398]]
to, an information collection unless the information collection
displays a valid control number assigned by OMB.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\763\ 44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As part of its continuing effort to reduce paperwork and respondent
burden, the Bureau conducts a preclearance consultation program to
provide the general public and Federal agencies with an opportunity to
comment on the information collection requirements in accordance with
the PRA. This helps ensure that the public understands the Bureau's
requirements or instructions, respondents can provide the requested
data in the desired format, reporting burden (time and financial
resources) is minimized, collection instruments are clearly understood,
and the Bureau can properly assess the impact of collection
requirements on respondents.
The proposed rule would amend 12 CFR part 1006 (Regulation F),
which implements the FDCPA. The Bureau's OMB control number for
Regulation F is 3170-0056. This proposed rule would revise the
information collection requirements contained in Regulation F that OMB
has approved under that OMB control number.
Under the proposal, the Bureau would require nine information
collection requirements in Regulation F:
1. State application for exemption (current Sec. 1006.2, proposed
Sec. 1006.108).
2. Opt-out notice for electronic communications or attempts to
communicate (proposed Sec. 1006.6(e)).
3. Communication with consumers prior to furnishing information
(proposed Sec. 1006.30(a)).
4. Validation notices (proposed Sec. 1006.34).
5. Responses to requests for original-creditor information
(proposed Sec. 1006.38(c)).
6. Responses to disputes (proposed Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(ii)).
7. Subject-line information requirements when required disclosures
are delivered electronically (proposed Sec. 1006.42(b)(2)).
8. Notice and opt-out requirements for certain types of electronic
delivery (proposed Sec. 1006.42(c)(3)).
9. Record retention (proposed Sec. 1006.100).
The first collection, the State application for an exemption, is
required to obtain a benefit and its respondents are exclusively State
governments. The information collected under this collection regards
State law, and so no issue of confidentiality arises. The remaining
collections would be to provide protection for consumers and would be
mandatory. Because the Bureau does not collect any information in these
remaining collections, no issue of confidentiality arises. The likely
respondents would be for-profit businesses that are FDCPA-covered debt
collectors, including contingency debt collection agencies, debt
buyers, law firms, and loan servicers, or State governments in the case
of applications under Sec. 1006.2 (proposed Sec. 1006.108).
The collections of information contained in this proposed rule, and
identified as such, have been submitted to OMB for review under section
3507(d) of the PRA. A complete description of the information
collection requirements, including the burden estimate methods, is
provided in the information collection request (ICR) that the Bureau
has submitted to OMB under the requirements of the PRA. Please send
your comments to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB,
Attention: Desk Officer for the Bureau of Consumer Financial
Protection. Send these comments by email to [email protected]
or by fax to 202-395-6974. If you wish to share your comments with the
Bureau, please send a copy of these comments as described in the
Addresses section above. The ICR submitted to OMB requesting approval
under the PRA for the information collection requirements contained
herein is available at www.regulations.gov as well as on OMB's public-
facing docket at www.reginfo.gov.
Title of Collection: Regulation F: Fair Debt Collection Practices
Act.
OMB Control Number: 3170-0056.
Type of Review: Revision of a currently approved collection.
Affected Public: Private Sector; State Governments.
Estimated Number of Respondents: 12,027.
Estimated Total Annual Burden Hours: 1,029,500.
Comments are invited on: (a) Whether the collection of information
is necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the Bureau,
including whether the information will have practical utility; (b) the
accuracy of the Bureau's estimate of the burden of the collection of
information, including the validity of the methods and the assumptions
used; (c) ways to enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the
information to be collected; and (d) ways to minimize the burden of the
collection of information on respondents, including through the use of
automated collection techniques or other forms of information
technology. Comments submitted in response to this proposal will be
summarized and/or included in the request for OMB approval. All
comments will become a matter of public record.
If applicable, the notice of final rule will display the control
number assigned by OMB to any information collection requirements
proposed herein and adopted in the final rule.
List of Subjects in 12 CFR Part 1006
Administrative practice and procedure, Consumer protection, Credit,
Debt collection, Intergovernmental relations.
Authority and Issuance
0
For the reasons set forth above, the Bureau proposes to revise
Regulation F, 12 CFR part 1006, to read as follows:
PART 1006--DEBT COLLECTION PRACTICES (REGULATION F)
Sec.
Subpart A--General
1006.1 Authority, purpose, and coverage.
1006.2 Definitions.
Subpart B--Rules for FDCPA Debt Collectors
1006.6 Communications in connection with debt collection.
1006.10 Acquisition of location information.
1006.14 Harassing, oppressive, or abusive conduct.
1006.18 False, deceptive, or misleading representations or means.
1006.22 Unfair or unconscionable means.
1006.26 Collection of time-barred debts.
1006.30 Other prohibited practices.
1006.34 Notice for validation of debts.
1006.38 Disputes and requests for original-creditor information.
1006.42 Providing required disclosures.
Subpart C--[Reserved]
Subpart D--Miscellaneous
1006. 100 Record retention.
1006.104 Relation to State laws.
1006.108 Exemption for State regulation.
Appendix A to Part 1006--Procedures for State application for
exemption From the provisions of the Act
Appendix B to Part 1006--Model forms and clauses
Appendix C to Part 1006--Issuance of advisory opinions
Supplement I to Part 1006--Official interpretations
Authority: 12 U.S.C. 5512, 5514(b), 5531, 5532; 15 U.S.C.
1692l(d), 1692o, 7004.
Subpart A--General
Sec. 1006.1 Authority, purpose, and coverage.
(a) Authority. This part, known as Regulation F, is issued by the
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection pursuant to sections 814(d) and
817 of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA or Act), 15 U.S.C.
1692l(d), 1692o; title X of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-
[[Page 23399]]
Frank Act), 12 U.S.C. 5481 et seq.; and paragraphs (b)(1) and (d)(1) of
section 104 of the Electronic Signatures in Global and National
Commerce Act (E-SIGN Act), 15 U.S.C. 7004.
(b) Purpose. This part carries out the purposes of the FDCPA, which
include eliminating abusive debt collection practices by debt
collectors, ensuring that debt collectors who refrain from using
abusive debt collection practices are not competitively disadvantaged,
and promoting consistent State action to protect consumers against debt
collection abuses. This part also prescribes requirements to ensure
that certain features of debt collection are disclosed fully,
accurately, and effectively to consumers in a manner that permits
consumers to understand the costs, benefits, and risks associated with
debt collection, in light of the facts and circumstances. Finally, this
part sets record retention requirements to enable the Bureau to
administer and carry out the purposes of the FDCPA, the Dodd-Frank Act,
and this part, as well as to prevent evasions thereof. The record
retention requirements also will facilitate supervision of debt
collectors and the assessment and detection of risks to consumers.
(c) Coverage. (1) Except as provided in Sec. 1006.108 and appendix
A of this part regarding applications for State exemptions from the
FDCPA, this part applies to debt collectors, as defined in Sec.
1006.2(i), other than a person excluded from coverage by section
1029(a) of the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010, title X of
the Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5519(a)).
(2) Certain provisions of this part apply to debt collectors only
when they are collecting consumer financial product or service debt as
defined in Sec. 1006.2(f). These provisions are Sec. Sec.
1006.14(b)(1)(ii), 1006.34(c)(2)(iv) and (3)(iv), and
1006.30(b)(1)(ii).
Sec. 1006.2 Definitions.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions apply:
(a) Act or FDCPA means the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (15
U.S.C. 1692 et seq.).
(b) Attempt to communicate means any act to initiate a
communication or other contact with any person through any medium,
including by soliciting a response from such person. An attempt to
communicate includes providing a limited-content message, as defined in
paragraph (j) of this section.
(c) Bureau means the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.
(d) Communicate or communication means the conveying of information
regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person through any
medium. A debt collector does not convey information regarding a debt
directly or indirectly to any person if the debt collector provides
only a limited-content message, as defined in paragraph (j) of this
section.
(e) Consumer means any natural person, whether living or deceased,
obligated or allegedly obligated to pay any debt. For purposes of
Sec. Sec. 1006.6 and 1006.14(h), the term consumer includes the
persons described in Sec. 1006.6(a).
(f) Consumer financial product or service debt means any debt
related to any consumer financial product or service, as that term is
defined in section 1002(5) of the Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5481(5)).
(g) Creditor means any person who offers or extends credit creating
a debt or to whom a debt is owed. The term creditor does not, however,
include any person to the extent that such person receives an
assignment or transfer of a debt in default solely to facilitate
collection of the debt for another.
(h) Debt, except for the purpose of paragraph (f) of this section,
means any obligation or alleged obligation of a consumer to pay money
arising out of a transaction in which the money, property, insurance,
or services that are the subject of the transaction are primarily for
personal, family, or household purposes, whether or not the obligation
has been reduced to judgment. For the purpose of paragraph (f) of this
section, debt means debt as that term is used in the Dodd-Frank Act.
(i)(1) Debt collector means any person who uses any instrumentality
of interstate commerce or mail in any business the principal purpose of
which is the collection of debts, or who regularly collects or attempts
to collect, directly or indirectly, debts owed or due, or asserted to
be owed or due, to another. Notwithstanding paragraph (h)(2)(vi) of
this section, the term debt collector includes any creditor that, in
the process of collecting its own debts, uses any name other than its
own that would indicate that a third person is collecting or attempting
to collect such debts. For the purpose of Sec. 1006.22(e), the term
also includes any person who uses any instrumentality of interstate
commerce or mail in any business the principal purpose of which is the
enforcement of security interests.
(2) The term debt collector excludes:
(i) Any officer or employee of a creditor while the officer or
employee is collecting debts for the creditor in the creditor's name;
(ii) Any person while acting as a debt collector for another person
if:
(A) The person acting as a debt collector does so only for persons
with whom the person acting as a debt collector is related by common
ownership or affiliated by corporate control; and
(B) The principal business of the person acting as a debt collector
is not the collection of debts;
(iii) Any officer or employee of the United States or any State to
the extent that collecting or attempting to collect any debt is in the
performance of the officer's or employee's official duties;
(iv) Any person while serving or attempting to serve legal process
on any other person in connection with the judicial enforcement of any
debt;
(v) Any nonprofit organization that, at the request of consumers,
performs bona fide consumer credit counseling and assists consumers in
liquidating their debts by receiving payment from such consumers and
distributing such amounts to creditors;
(vi) Any person collecting or attempting to collect any debt owed
or due, or asserted to be owed or due to another, to the extent such
debt collection activity:
(A) Is incidental to a bona fide fiduciary obligation or a bona
fide escrow arrangement;
(B) Concerns a debt that such person originated;
(C) Concerns a debt that was not in default at the time such person
obtained it; or
(D) Concerns a debt that such person obtained as a secured party in
a commercial credit transaction involving the creditor; and
(vii) A private entity, to the extent such private entity is
operating a bad check enforcement program that complies with section
818 of the Act.
(j) Limited-content message means a message for a consumer that
includes all of the content described in paragraph (j)(1) of this
section, that may include any of the content described in paragraph
(j)(2) of this section, and that includes no other content.
(1) Required content. A limited-content message is a message for a
consumer that includes all of the following:
(i) The consumer's name;
(ii) A request that the consumer reply to the message;
(iii) The name or names of one or more natural persons whom the
consumer can contact to reply to the debt collector;
(iv) A telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to the
debt collector; and
(v) If applicable, the disclosure required by Sec. 1006.6(e).
(2) Optional content. In addition to the content described in
paragraph (j)(1)
[[Page 23400]]
of this section, a limited-content message may include one or more of
the following:
(i) A salutation;
(ii) The date and time of the message;
(iii) A generic statement that the message relates to an account;
and
(iv) Suggested dates and times for the consumer to reply to the
message.
(k) Person includes natural persons, corporations, companies,
associations, firms, partnerships, societies, and joint stock
companies.
(l) State means any State, territory, or possession of the United
States, the District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, or
any political subdivision of any of the foregoing.
Subpart B--Rules for FDCPA Debt Collectors
Sec. 1006.6 Communications in connection with debt collection.
(a) Definition. For purposes of this section, the term consumer
includes:
(1) The consumer's spouse;
(2) The consumer's parent, if the consumer is a minor;
(3) The consumer's legal guardian;
(4) The executor or administrator of the consumer's estate, if the
consumer is deceased; and
(5) A confirmed successor in interest, as defined in Regulation X,
12 CFR 1024.31, and Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.2(a)(27)(ii).
(b) Communications with a consumer--in general. Except as provided
in paragraph (b)(4) of this section, a debt collector must not
communicate or attempt to communicate with a consumer in connection
with the collection of any debt as prohibited by paragraphs (b)(1)
through (3) of this section.
(1) Prohibitions regarding unusual or inconvenient times or places.
A debt collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of any debt:
(i) At any unusual time, or at a time that the debt collector knows
or should know is inconvenient to the consumer. In the absence of the
debt collector's knowledge of circumstances to the contrary, a time
before 8:00 a.m. and after 9:00 p.m. local time at the consumer's
location is inconvenient; or
(ii) At any unusual place, or at a place that the debt collector
knows or should know is inconvenient to the consumer.
(2) Prohibitions regarding consumer represented by an attorney. A
debt collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of any debt if the debt
collector knows the consumer is represented by an attorney with respect
to the debt and knows, or can readily ascertain, the attorney's name
and address, unless the attorney:
(i) Fails to respond within a reasonable period of time to a
communication from the debt collector; or
(ii) Consents to the debt collector communicating directly with the
consumer.
(3) Prohibitions regarding consumer's place of employment. A debt
collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of any debt at the
consumer's place of employment, if the debt collector knows or has
reason to know that the consumer's employer prohibits the consumer from
receiving such communication.
(4) Exceptions. The prohibitions in paragraphs (b)(1) through (3)
of this section do not apply when a debt collector communicates or
attempts to communicate with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt with:
(i) The prior consent of the consumer, given directly to the debt
collector during a communication that does not violate paragraphs
(b)(1) through (3) of this section; or
(ii) The express permission of a court of competent jurisdiction.
(c) Communications with a consumer--after refusal to pay or cease
communication notice. (1) Prohibitions. Except as provided in paragraph
(c)(2) of this section, a debt collector must not communicate or
attempt to communicate further with a consumer with respect to a debt
if the consumer notifies the debt collector in writing that:
(i) The consumer refuses to pay the debt; or
(ii) The consumer wants the debt collector to cease further
communication with the consumer.
(2) Exceptions. The prohibitions in paragraph (c)(1) of this
section do not apply when a debt collector communicates or attempts to
communicate further with a consumer with respect to the debt:
(i) To advise the consumer that the debt collector's further
efforts are being terminated;
(ii) To notify the consumer that the debt collector or creditor may
invoke specified remedies that the debt collector or creditor
ordinarily invokes; or
(iii) Where applicable, to notify the consumer that the debt
collector or creditor intends to invoke a specified remedy.
(d) Communications with third parties. (1) Prohibitions. Except as
provided in paragraph (d)(2) of this section, a debt collector must not
communicate, in connection with the collection of any debt, with any
person other than:
(i) The consumer;
(ii) The consumer's attorney;
(iii) A consumer reporting agency, if otherwise permitted by law;
(iv) The creditor;
(v) The creditor's attorney; or
(vi) The debt collector's attorney.
(2) Exceptions. The prohibition in paragraph (d)(1) of this section
does not apply when a debt collector communicates, in connection with
the collection of any debt, with a person:
(i) For the purpose of acquiring location information, as provided
in Sec. 1006.10;
(ii) With the prior consent of the consumer given directly to the
debt collector;
(iii) With the express permission of a court of competent
jurisdiction; or
(iv) As reasonably necessary to effectuate a postjudgment judicial
remedy.
(3) Reasonable procedures for email and text message
communications. A debt collector maintains procedures that are
reasonably adapted, for purposes of FDCPA section 813(c), to avoid a
bona fide error in sending an email or text message communication that
would result in a violation of paragraph (d)(1) of this section if the
debt collector, when communicating with a consumer using an email
address or, in the case of a text message, a telephone number,
maintains procedures that include steps to reasonably confirm and
document that:
(i) The debt collector communicated with the consumer using:
(A) An email address or, in the case of a text message, a telephone
number that the consumer recently used to contact the debt collector
for purposes other than opting out of electronic communications;
(B) A non-work email address or, in the case of a text message, a
non-work telephone number, if:
(1) The creditor or the debt collector notified the consumer
clearly and conspicuously, other than through the specific non-work
email address or non-work telephone number, that the debt collector
might use that non-work email address or non-work telephone number for
debt collection communications by email or text message, where the
creditor or debt collector provided the notification no more than 30
days before
[[Page 23401]]
the debt collector's first such communication, and the notification
identified the legal name of the debt collector and the non-work email
address or non-work telephone number the debt collector proposed to
use, described one or more ways the consumer could opt out of such
communications, and provided the consumer with a specified reasonable
period in which to opt out before beginning such communications; and
(2) The opt-out period specified in the notice described in
paragraph (d)(3)(i)(B)(1) of this section has expired and the consumer
has not opted out of receiving debt collection communications at the
specific non-work email address or non-work telephone number, as
applicable; or
(C) A non-work email address or, in the case of a text message, a
non-work telephone number that the creditor or a prior debt collector
obtained from the consumer to communicate about the debt if, before the
debt was placed with the debt collector, the creditor or the prior debt
collector recently sent communications about the debt to that non-work
email address or non-work telephone number, and the consumer did not
request the creditor or the prior debt collector to stop using that
non-work email address or non-work telephone number to communicate
about the debt; and
(ii) The debt collector took additional steps to prevent
communications using an email address or telephone number that the debt
collector knows has led to a disclosure prohibited by paragraph (d)(1)
of this section.
(e) Opt-out notice for electronic communications or attempts to
communicate. A debt collector who communicates or attempts to
communicate with a consumer electronically in connection with the
collection of a debt using a specific email address, telephone number
for text messages, or other electronic-medium address must include in
such communication or attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous
statement describing one or more ways the consumer can opt out of
further electronic communications or attempts to communicate by the
debt collector to that address or telephone number. The debt collector
may not require, directly or indirectly, that the consumer, in order to
opt out, pay any fee to the debt collector or provide any information
other than the email address, telephone number for text messages, or
other electronic-medium address subject to the opt out.
Sec. 1006.10 Acquisition of location information.
(a) Definition. The term location information means a consumer's:
(1) Place of abode and telephone number at such place; or
(2) Place of employment.
(b) Form and content of location communications. A debt collector
communicating with a person other than the consumer for the purpose of
acquiring location information must:
(1) Identify himself or herself individually by name, state that he
or she is confirming or correcting the consumer's location information,
and, only if expressly requested, identify his or her employer;
(2) Not state that the consumer owes any debt;
(3) Not communicate by postcard;
(4) Not use any language or symbol on any envelope or in the
contents of any communication by mail indicating that the debt
collector is in the debt collection business or that the communication
relates to the collection of a debt; and
(5) After the debt collector knows the consumer is represented by
an attorney with regard to the subject debt and has knowledge of, or
can readily ascertain, such attorney's name and address, not
communicate with any person other than that attorney, unless the
attorney fails to respond to the debt collector's communication within
a reasonable period of time.
(c) Frequency of location communications. In addition to complying
with the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b), a debt collector
communicating with any person other than the consumer for the purpose
of acquiring location information about the consumer must not
communicate more than once with such person unless requested to do so
by such person, or unless the debt collector reasonably believes that
the earlier response of such person is erroneous or incomplete and that
such person now has correct or complete location information.
Sec. 1006.14 Harassing, oppressive, or abusive conduct.
(a) In general. A debt collector must not engage in any conduct the
natural consequence of which is to harass, oppress, or abuse any person
in connection with the collection of any debt, including, but not
limited to, the conduct described in paragraphs (b) through (h) of this
section.
(b) Repeated or continuous telephone calls or telephone
conversations. (1) In general. (i) FDCPA prohibition. In connection
with the collection of a debt, a debt collector must not place
telephone calls or engage any person in telephone conversation
repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass any
person at the called number.
(ii) Identification and prevention of Dodd-Frank Act unfair act or
practice. With respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer
financial product or service debt, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), it is
an unfair act or practice under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act to
place telephone calls or engage any person in telephone conversation
repeatedly or continuously in connection with the collection of such
debt, such that the natural consequence is to harass, oppress, or abuse
any person at the called number. To prevent this unfair act or
practice, such a debt collector must not exceed the frequency limits in
paragraph (b)(2) of this section.
(2) Frequency limits. Subject to paragraph (b)(3) of this section,
a debt collector violates paragraphs (b)(1)(i) and (ii) of this
section, as applicable, by placing a telephone call to a particular
person in connection with the collection of a particular debt either:
(i) More than seven times within seven consecutive days; or
(ii) Within a period of seven consecutive days after having had a
telephone conversation with the person in connection with the
collection of such debt. The date of the telephone conversation is the
first day of the seven-consecutive-day period.
(3) Certain telephone calls excluded from the frequency limits.
Telephone calls placed to a person do not count toward, and are
permitted in excess of, the frequency limits in paragraph (b)(2) of
this section if they are:
(i) Made to respond to a request for information from such person;
(ii) Made with such person's prior consent given directly to the
debt collector;
(iii) Not connected to the dialed number; or
(iv) With the persons described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(ii) through
(vi).
(4) Effect of complying with frequency limits. A debt collector who
does not exceed the frequency limits in paragraph (b)(2) of this
section complies with paragraph (b)(1) of this section and section
806(5) of the FDCPA (15 U.S.C. 1692d(5)), and does not, based on the
frequency of its telephone calls, violate paragraph (a) of this
section, section 806 of the FDCPA (15 U.S.C. 1692d), or sections 1031
or 1036(a)(1)(B) of the Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5531 or
5536(a)(1)(B)).
(5) Definition. For purposes of this paragraph (b), particular debt
means each of a consumer's debts in collection.
[[Page 23402]]
However, in the case of student loan debts, the term particular debt
means all student loan debts that a consumer owes or allegedly owes
that were serviced under a single account number at the time the debts
were obtained by the debt collector.
(c) Violence or other criminal means. In connection with the
collection of a debt, a debt collector must not use or threaten to use
violence or other criminal means to harm the physical person,
reputation, or property of any person.
(d) Obscene or profane language. In connection with the collection
of a debt, a debt collector must not use obscene or profane language,
or language the natural consequence of which is to abuse the hearer or
reader.
(e) Debtor's list. In connection with the collection of a debt, a
debt collector must not publish a list of consumers who allegedly
refuse to pay debts, except to a consumer reporting agency or to
persons meeting the requirements of sections 603(f) or 604(a)(3) of the
Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681a(f) or 1681b(a)(3)).
(f) Coercive advertisements. In connection with the collection of a
debt, a debt collector must not advertise for sale any debt to coerce
payment of the debt.
(g) Meaningful disclosure of identity. In connection with the
collection of a debt, a debt collector must not place telephone calls
without meaningfully disclosing the caller's identity, except as
provided in Sec. 1006.10.
(h) Prohibited communication media. (1) In general. In connection
with the collection of any debt, a debt collector must not communicate
or attempt to communicate with a consumer through a medium of
communication if the consumer has requested that the debt collector not
use that medium to communicate with the consumer. For purposes of this
paragraph, the term ``consumer'' has the meaning given to it in Sec.
1006.6(a).
(2) Exceptions. Notwithstanding the prohibition in paragraph (h)(1)
of this section:
(i) If a consumer opts out in writing of receiving electronic
communications from a debt collector, a debt collector may reply once
to confirm the consumer's request to opt out, provided that the reply
contains no information other than a statement confirming the
consumer's request; or
(ii) If a consumer initiates contact with a debt collector using an
address or a telephone number that the consumer previously requested
the debt collector not use, the debt collector may respond once to that
consumer-initiated communication.
Sec. 1006.18 False, deceptive, or misleading representations or
means.
(a) In general. A debt collector must not use any false, deceptive,
or misleading representation or means in connection with the collection
of any debt, including, but not limited to, the conduct described in
paragraphs (b) through (d) of this section.
(b) False, deceptive, or misleading representations. (1) A debt
collector must not falsely represent or imply that:
(i) The debt collector is vouched for, bonded by, or affiliated
with the United States or any State, including through the use of any
badge, uniform, or facsimile thereof.
(ii) The debt collector operates or is employed by a consumer
reporting agency, as defined by section 603(f) of the Fair Credit
Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681a(f)).
(iii) Any individual is an attorney or that any communication is
from an attorney.
(iv) The consumer committed any crime or other conduct in order to
disgrace the consumer.
(v) A sale, referral, or other transfer of any interest in a debt
causes or will cause the consumer to:
(A) Lose any claim or defense to payment of the debt; or
(B) Become subject to any practice prohibited by this part.
(vi) Accounts have been turned over to innocent purchasers for
value.
(vii) Documents are legal process.
(viii) Documents are not legal process forms or do not require
action by the consumer.
(2) A debt collector must not falsely represent:
(i) The character, amount, or legal status of any debt.
(ii) Any services rendered, or compensation that may be lawfully
received, by any debt collector for the collection of a debt.
(3) A debt collector must not represent or imply that nonpayment of
any debt will result in the arrest or imprisonment of any person or the
seizure, garnishment, attachment, or sale of any property or wages of
any person unless such action is lawful and the debt collector or
creditor intends to take such action.
(c) False, deceptive, or misleading collection means. A debt
collector must not:
(1) Threaten to take any action that cannot legally be taken or
that is not intended to be taken.
(2) Communicate or threaten to communicate to any person credit
information that the debt collector knows or should know is false,
including the failure to communicate that a disputed debt is disputed.
(3) Use or distribute any written communication that simulates or
that the debt collector falsely represents to be a document authorized,
issued, or approved by any court, official, or agency of the United
States or any State, or that creates a false impression about its
source, authorization, or approval.
(4) Use any business, company, or organization name other than the
true name of the debt collector's business, company, or organization.
(d) False representations or deceptive means. A debt collector must
not use any false representation or deceptive means to collect or
attempt to collect any debt or to obtain information concerning a
consumer.
(e) Disclosures required. (1) Initial communications. A debt
collector must disclose in its initial communication with a consumer
that the debt collector is attempting to collect a debt and that any
information obtained will be used for that purpose. If the debt
collector's initial communication with the consumer is oral, the debt
collector must make the disclosure required by this paragraph again in
its initial written communication with the consumer.
(2) Subsequent communications. In each communication with the
consumer subsequent to the communications described in paragraph (e)(1)
of this section, the debt collector must disclose that the
communication is from a debt collector.
(3) Exception. Disclosures under paragraphs (e)(1) and (2) of this
section are not required in a formal pleading made in connection with a
legal action.
(f) Assumed names. This section does not prohibit a debt
collector's employee from using an assumed name when communicating or
attempting to communicate with a person, provided that the employee
uses the assumed name consistently and that the employer can readily
identify any employee using an assumed name.
(g) Safe harbor for meaningful attorney involvement in debt
collection litigation submissions. A debt collector that is a law firm
or who is an attorney complies with Sec. 1006.18 when submitting a
pleading, written motion, or other paper submitted to the court during
debt collection litigation if an attorney personally:
(1) Drafts or reviews the pleading, written motion, or other paper;
and
(2) Reviews information supporting such pleading, written motion,
or other paper and determines, to the best of the
[[Page 23403]]
attorney's knowledge, information, and belief, that, as applicable:
(i) The claims, defenses, and other legal contentions are warranted
by existing law;
(ii) The factual contentions have evidentiary support; and
(iii) The denials of factual contentions are warranted on the
evidence or, if specifically so identified, are reasonably based on
belief or lack of information.
Sec. 1006.22 Unfair or unconscionable means.
(a) In general. A debt collector must not use unfair or
unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt,
including, but not limited to, the conduct described in paragraphs (b)
through (f) of this section.
(b) Collection of unauthorized amounts. A debt collector must not
collect any amount unless such amount is expressly authorized by the
agreement creating the debt or permitted by law. For purposes of this
paragraph, the term ``any amount'' includes any interest, fee, charge,
or expense incidental to the principal obligation.
(c) Postdated payment instruments. A debt collector must not:
(1) Accept from any person a check or other payment instrument
postdated by more than five days unless such person is notified in
writing of the debt collector's intent to deposit such check or
instrument not more than ten, nor less than three, days (excluding
legal public holidays, Saturdays, and Sundays) prior to such deposit.
(2) Solicit any postdated check or other postdated payment
instrument for the purpose of threatening or instituting criminal
prosecution.
(3) Deposit or threaten to deposit any postdated check or other
postdated payment instrument prior to the date on such check or
instrument.
(d) Charges resulting from concealment of purpose. A debt collector
must not cause charges to be made to any person for communications by
concealment of the true purpose of the communication. Such charges
include, but are not limited to, collect telephone calls and telegram
fees.
(e) Nonjudicial action regarding property. A debt collector must
not take or threaten to take any nonjudicial action to effect
dispossession or disablement of property if:
(1) There is no present right to possession of the property claimed
as collateral through an enforceable security interest;
(2) There is no present intention to take possession of the
property; or
(3) The property is exempt by law from such dispossession or
disablement.
(f) Restrictions on use of certain media. A debt collector must
not:
(1) Communicate with a consumer regarding a debt by postcard.
(2) Use any language or symbol, other than the debt collector's
address, on any envelope when communicating with a consumer by mail,
except that a debt collector may use the debt collector's business name
on an envelope if such name does not indicate that the debt collector
is in the debt collection business.
(3) Communicate or attempt to communicate with a consumer using an
email address that the debt collector knows or should know is provided
to the consumer by the consumer's employer, unless the debt collector
has received directly from the consumer either prior consent to use
that email address or an email from that email address.
(4) Communicate or attempt to communicate with a consumer in
connection with the collection of a debt by a social media platform
that is viewable by a person other than the persons described in Sec.
1006.6(d)(1)(i) through (vi).
(g) Safe harbor for certain emails and text messages relating to
the collection of a debt. A debt collector who communicates with a
consumer using an email address or telephone number and following the
procedures described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3) does not violate paragraph
(a) of this section by revealing in the email or text message the debt
collector's name or other information indicating that the communication
relates to the collection of a debt.
Sec. 1006.26 Collection of time-barred debts.
(a) Definitions. For purposes of this section:
(1) Statute of limitations means the period prescribed by
applicable law for bringing a legal action against the consumer to
collect a debt.
(2) Time-barred debt means a debt for which the applicable statute
of limitations has expired.
(b) Suits and threats of suit prohibited. A debt collector must not
bring or threaten to bring a legal action against a consumer to collect
a debt that the debt collector knows or should know is a time-barred
debt.
(c) [Reserved]
Sec. 1006.30 Other prohibited practices.
(a) Communication prior to furnishing information. A debt collector
must not furnish to a consumer reporting agency, as defined in section
603(f) of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681a(f)),
information regarding a debt before communicating with the consumer
about the debt.
(b) Prohibition on the sale, transfer, or placement of certain
debts. (1) In general. (i) FDCPA prohibition. Except as provided in
paragraph (b)(2) of this section, a debt collector must not sell,
transfer, or place for collection a debt if the debt collector knows or
should know that:
(A) The debt has been paid or settled;
(B) The debt has been discharged in bankruptcy; or
(C) An identity theft report, as defined in section 603(q)(4) of
the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681a(q)(4)), was filed with
respect to the debt.
(ii) Identification of Dodd-Frank Act unfair act or practice. With
respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer financial
product or service debt, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), it is an unfair
act or practice under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank Act to sell,
transfer, or place for collection a debt described in paragraph
(b)(1)(i) of this section.
(2) Exceptions. A debt collector may sell, transfer, or place for
collection a debt described in paragraph (b)(1)(i) of this section if
the debt collector:
(i) Transfers the debt to the debt's owner;
(ii) Transfers the debt to a previous owner of the debt if transfer
is authorized under the terms of the original contract between the debt
collector and the previous owner;
(iii) Securitizes the debt or pledges a portfolio of such debt as
collateral in connection with a borrowing; or
(iv) Transfers the debt as a result of a merger, acquisition,
purchase and assumption transaction, or transfer of substantially all
of the debt collector's assets.
(c) Multiple debts. If a consumer makes any single payment to a
debt collector with respect to multiple debts owed by the consumer, the
debt collector:
(1) Must apply the payment in accordance with the directions given
by the consumer, if any; and
(2) Must not apply the payment to any debt that is disputed by the
consumer.
(d) Legal actions by debt collectors. (1) Action to enforce
interest in real property. A debt collector who brings a legal action
against a consumer to enforce an interest in real property securing the
consumer's debt must bring the action only in a judicial district or
similar legal entity in which such real property is located.
(2) Other legal actions. A debt collector who brings a legal action
against a consumer other than to enforce an interest in real property
securing the consumer's debt must bring such action only in the
judicial district or similar legal entity in which the consumer:
[[Page 23404]]
(i) Signed the contract sued upon; or
(ii) Resides at the commencement of the action.
(3) Authorization of actions. Nothing in this part authorizes debt
collectors to bring legal actions.
(e) Furnishing certain deceptive forms. A debt collector must not
design, compile, and furnish any form that the debt collector knows
would be used to cause a consumer falsely to believe that a person
other than the consumer's creditor is participating in collecting or
attempting to collect a debt that the consumer allegedly owes to the
creditor.
Sec. 1006.34 Notice for validation of debts.
(a)(1) Validation information required. Except as provided in
paragraph (a)(2) of this section, a debt collector must provide a
consumer with the validation information described in paragraph (c) of
this section either:
(i) By sending the consumer a validation notice in a manner
permitted by Sec. 1006.42:
(A) In the initial communication, as defined in paragraph (b)(2) of
this section; or
(B) Within five days of that initial communication; or
(ii) By providing the validation information orally in the initial
communication.
(2) Exception. A debt collector who otherwise would be required to
send a validation notice pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)(i)(B) of this
section is not required to do so if the consumer has paid the debt
prior to the time that paragraph (a)(1)(i)(B) of this section would
require the validation notice to be sent.
(b) Definitions. For purposes of this section:
(1) Clear and conspicuous means disclosures that are readily
understandable. In the case of written and electronic disclosures, the
location and type size also must be readily noticeable to consumers. In
the case of oral disclosures, the disclosures also must be given at a
volume and speed sufficient for the consumer to hear and comprehend
them.
(2) Initial communication means the first time that, in connection
with the collection of a debt, a debt collector conveys information,
directly or indirectly, regarding the debt to the consumer, other than
a communication in the form of a formal pleading in a civil action, or
any form or notice that does not relate to the collection of the debt
and is expressly required by:
(i) The Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (26 U.S.C. 1 et seq.);
(ii) Title V of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (15 U.S.C. 6801 through
6827); or
(iii) Any provision of Federal or State law or regulation mandating
notice of a data security breach or privacy risk.
(3) Itemization date means any one of the following four reference
dates for which a debt collector can ascertain the amount of the debt:
(i) The last statement date, which is the date of the last periodic
statement or written account statement or invoice provided to the
consumer;
(ii) The charge-off date, which is the date the debt was charged
off;
(iii) The last payment date, which is the date the last payment was
applied to the debt; or
(iv) The transaction date, which is the date of the transaction
that gave rise to the debt.
(4) Validation notice means a written or electronic notice that
provides the validation information described in paragraph (c) of this
section.
(5) Validation period means the period starting on the date that a
debt collector provides the validation information described in
paragraph (c) of this section and ending 30 days after the consumer
receives or is assumed to receive the validation information. For
purposes of determining the end of the validation period, the debt
collector may assume that a consumer receives the validation
information on any date that is at least five days (excluding legal
public holidays, Saturdays, and Sundays) after the debt collector
provides it.
(c) Validation information. (1) Debt collector communication
disclosure. The statement required by Sec. 1006.18(e).
(2) Information about the debt. Except as provided in paragraph
(c)(5) of this section:
(i) The debt collector's name and mailing address.
(ii) The consumer's name and mailing address.
(iii) If the debt is a credit card debt, the merchant brand, if
any, associated with the debt, to the extent available to the debt
collector.
(iv) If the debt collector is collecting consumer financial product
or service debt as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), the name of the creditor
to whom the debt was owed on the itemization date.
(v) The account number, if any, associated with the debt on the
itemization date, or a truncated version of that number.
(vi) The name of the creditor to whom the debt currently is owed.
(vii) The itemization date.
(viii) The amount of the debt on the itemization date.
(ix) An itemization of the current amount of the debt in a tabular
format reflecting interest, fees, payments, and credits since the
itemization date.
(x) The current amount of the debt.
(3) Information about consumer protections. (i) A statement that
specifies what date the debt collector will consider the end date of
the validation period and states that, if the consumer notifies the
debt collector in writing before the end of the validation period that
the debt, or any portion of the debt, is disputed, the debt collector
must cease collection of the debt, or the disputed portion of the debt,
until the debt collector sends the consumer either the verification of
the debt or a copy of a judgment.
(ii) A statement that specifies what date the debt collector will
consider the end date of the validation period and states that, if the
consumer requests in writing before the end of the validation period
the name and address of the original creditor, the debt collector must
cease collection of the debt until the debt collector sends the
consumer the name and address of the original creditor, if different
from the current creditor.
(iii) A statement that specifies what date the debt collector will
consider the end date of the validation period and states that, unless
the consumer contacts the debt collector to dispute the validity of the
debt, or any portion of the debt, before the end of the validation
period, the debt collector will assume that the debt is valid.
(iv) If the debt collector is collecting consumer financial product
or service debt as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), a statement that informs
the consumer that additional information regarding consumer protections
in debt collection is available on the Bureau's website at https://www.consumerfinance.gov.
(v) A statement explaining how a consumer can take the actions
described in paragraphs (c)(4) and (d)(3), as applicable, of this
section electronically, if the debt collector sends a validation notice
electronically.
(vi) For a validation notice delivered in the body of an email
pursuant to Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) or (c)(2)(i), the opt-out statement
required by Sec. 1006.6(e).
(4) Consumer response information. The following information,
segregated from the validation information described in paragraphs
(c)(1) through (3) of this section and from any optional information
included pursuant to paragraphs (d)(3)(i), (ii), (iv), and (v) of this
section, and, if provided in a validation notice, located at the bottom
of the notice under the headings, ``How do you want to respond?'' and
``Check all that apply:'':
(i) Dispute prompts. The following statements, listed in the
following order, and using the following phrasing or
[[Page 23405]]
substantially similar phrasing, each next to a prompt:
(A) ``I want to dispute the debt because I think:;''
(B) ``This is not my debt;''
(C) ``The amount is wrong;'' and
(D) ``Other (please describe on reverse or attach additional
information).''
(ii) Original-creditor information prompt. The statement, ``I want
you to send me the name and address of the original creditor,'' using
that phrase or a substantially similar phrase, next to a prompt.
(iii) Mailing addresses. Mailing addresses for the consumer and the
debt collector, which include the debt collector's and the consumer's
names.
(5) Special rule for certain residential mortgage debt. For
residential mortgage debt subject to Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41, a
debt collector need not provide the validation information described in
paragraphs (c)(2)(vii) through (ix) of this section if the debt
collector:
(i) Provides the consumer at the same time as the validation
notice, a copy of the most recent periodic statement provided to the
consumer under Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41(b); and
(ii) Refers to that periodic statement in the validation notice.
(d) Form of validation information. (1) In general. (i) The
validation information described in paragraph (c) of this section must
be clear and conspicuous.
(ii) If provided in a validation notice, the content, format, and
placement of the validation information described in Sec. 1006.34(c)
and of the optional disclosures permitted by paragraph (d)(3) of this
section must be substantially similar to Model Form B-3 in appendix B
of this part.
(2) Safe harbor. A debt collector who uses Model Form B-3 in
appendix B of this part complies with the requirements of paragraphs
(a)(1)(i) and (d)(1) of this section.
(3) Optional disclosures. A debt collector may, at its option,
include any of the following information if providing the validation
information required by paragraph (a)(1) of this section.
(i) Telephone contact information. The debt collector's telephone
contact information, including telephone number and the times that the
debt collector accepts consumer telephone calls.
(ii) Reference code. A number or code that the debt collector uses
to identify the debt or the consumer.
(iii) Payment disclosures. (A) The statement, ``Contact us about
your payment options,'' using that phrase or a substantially similar
phrase. The optional payment disclosure permitted by this paragraph
must be no more prominent than any of the validation information
described in paragraph (c) of this section; and
(B) With the consumer response information described in paragraph
(c)(4) of this section, the statement ``I enclosed this amount,'' using
that phrase or a substantially similar phrase, payment instructions
after that statement, and a prompt. The optional payment disclosure
permitted by this paragraph must be no more prominent than the
validation information described in paragraph (c) of this section.
(iv) Disclosures required by applicable law. On the front of a
validation notice, a statement that other disclosures required by
applicable law appear on the reverse of the validation notice and, on
the reverse of the validation notice, any such required disclosures.
(v) Information about electronic communications. The following
information:
(A) The debt collector's website and email address.
(B) If validation information is not provided electronically, the
statement described in paragraph (c)(3)(v) of this section explaining
how a consumer can take the actions described in paragraphs (c)(4) and
(d)(3) of this section electronically.
(vi) Spanish-language translation disclosures. The following
disclosures regarding a consumer's ability to request a Spanish-
language translation of a validation notice:
(A) The statement, ``P[oacute]ngase en contacto con nosotros para
solicitar una copia de este formulario en espa[ntilde]ol'' (which means
``Contact us to request a copy of the form in Spanish''), using that
phrase or a substantially similar phrase in Spanish. If providing this
optional disclosure, a debt collector may include supplemental
information in Spanish that specifies how a consumer may request a
Spanish-language validation notice.
(B) With the consumer response information described in paragraph
(c)(4) of this section, the statement ``Quiero esta forma en
espa[ntilde]ol'' (which means ``I want this form in Spanish''), using
that phrase or a substantially similar phrase in Spanish, next to a
prompt.
(4) Validation notices delivered electronically. If a debt
collector delivers a validation notice electronically pursuant to Sec.
1006.42, a debt collector may, at its option, format the validation
notice as follows:
(i) Prompts. Any prompt described in paragraphs (c)(4)(i) or (ii)
or paragraphs (d)(3)(iii)(B) or (vi)(B) of this section may be
displayed electronically as a fillable field.
(ii) Hyperlinks. Hyperlinks may be embedded that, when clicked:
(A) Connect consumers to the debt collector's website; or
(B) Permit consumers to respond to the dispute and original-
creditor information prompts described in paragraphs (c)(4)(i) and (ii)
of this section.
(e) Translation into other languages. A debt collector may send the
consumer a validation notice completely and accurately translated into
any language if the debt collector also sends an English-language
validation notice in the same communication that satisfies paragraph
(a)(1) of this section. If a debt collector has already provided an
English-language validation notice that satisfies paragraph (a)(1) of
this section and subsequently provides the consumer a validation notice
translated into any another language, the debt collector need not
provide an additional copy of the English-language notice.
Sec. 1006.38 Disputes and requests for original-creditor information.
(a) Definitions. For purposes of this section, the following
definitions apply:
(1) Duplicative dispute means a dispute submitted by the consumer
in writing within the validation period that:
(i) Is substantially the same as a dispute previously submitted by
the consumer in writing within the validation period for which the debt
collector already has satisfied the requirements of paragraph (d)(2)(i)
of this section; and
(ii) Does not include new and material information to support the
dispute.
(2) Validation period has the same meaning given to it in Sec.
1006.34(b)(5).
(b) Overshadowing of rights to dispute or request original-creditor
information. During the validation period, a debt collector must not
engage in any collection activities or communications that overshadow
or are inconsistent with the disclosure of the consumer's rights to
dispute the debt and to request the name and address of the original
creditor.
(c) Requests for original-creditor information. Upon receipt of a
request for the name and address of the original creditor submitted by
the consumer in writing within the validation period, a debt collector
must cease collection of the debt until the debt collector provides the
name and address of the original creditor to the consumer in
[[Page 23406]]
writing or electronically in a manner permitted by Sec. 1006.42.
(d) Disputes. (1) Failure to dispute. The failure of a consumer to
dispute the validity of a debt does not constitute a legal admission of
liability by the consumer.
(2) Response to disputes. Upon receipt of a dispute submitted by
the consumer in writing within the validation period, a debt collector
must cease collection of the debt, or any disputed portion of the debt,
until the debt collector:
(i) Provides a copy either of verification of the debt or of a
judgment to the consumer in writing or electronically in a manner
permitted by Sec. 1006.42; or
(ii) In the case of a dispute that the debt collector reasonably
determines is a duplicative dispute, either:
(A) Notifies the consumer in writing or electronically in a manner
permitted by Sec. 1006.42 that the dispute is duplicative, provides a
brief statement of the reasons for the determination, and refers the
consumer to the debt collector's response to the earlier dispute; or
(B) Satisfies paragraph (d)(2)(i) of this section.
Sec. 1006.42 Providing required disclosures.
(a) Providing required disclosures. (1) In general. A debt
collector who provides disclosures required by this part in writing or
electronically must do so in a manner that is reasonably expected to
provide actual notice and in a form that the consumer may keep and
access later.
(2) Exceptions. A debt collector need not comply with paragraph
(a)(1) of this section when providing the disclosure required by Sec.
1006.6(e) or Sec. 1006.18(e) in writing or electronically, unless the
disclosure is included on a notice required by Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)
or Sec. 1006.38(c) or (d)(2), or in an electronic communication
containing a hyperlink to such notice.
(b) Requirements for certain disclosures provided electronically.
To comply with paragraph (a) of this section, a debt collector who
provides the validation notice described in Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B),
or the disclosures described in Sec. 1006.38(c) or (d)(2),
electronically must:
(1) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of this section, provide
the disclosure in accordance with section 101(c) of the Electronic
Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (E-SIGN Act) (15 U.S.C.
7001(c)) after the consumer provides affirmative consent directly to
the debt collector;
(2) Identify the purpose of the communication by including, in the
subject line of an email or in the first line of a text message
transmitting the disclosure, the name of the creditor to whom the debt
currently is owed or allegedly is owed and one additional piece of
information identifying the debt, other than the amount;
(3) Permit receipt of notifications of undeliverability from
communications providers, monitor for any such notifications, and treat
any such notifications as precluding a reasonable expectation of actual
notice for that delivery attempt; and
(4) When providing the validation notice described in Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), provide the disclosure in a responsive format that
is reasonably expected to be accessible on a screen of any commercially
available size and via commercially available screen readers.
(c) Alternative procedures for providing certain disclosures
electronically. A debt collector who provides the validation notice
described in Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), or the disclosures described in
Sec. 1006.38(c) or (d)(2), electronically need not comply with
paragraph (b)(1) of this section if the debt collector:
(1) Provides the disclosure by sending an electronic communication
to an email address or, in the case of a text message, a telephone
number that the creditor or a prior debt collector could have used to
provide electronic disclosures related to that debt in accordance with
section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act; and
(2) Places the disclosure either:
(i) In the body of an email sent to an email address described in
paragraph (c)(1) of this section; or
(ii) On a secure website that is accessible by clicking on a clear
and conspicuous hyperlink included within an electronic communication
sent to an email address or a telephone number described in paragraph
(c)(1) of this section, provided that:
(A) The disclosure is accessible on the website for a reasonable
period of time and can be saved or printed;
(B) The consumer receives notice and an opportunity to opt out of
hyperlinked delivery as described in paragraph (d) of this section; and
(C) The consumer, during the opt-out period, has not opted out.
(d) Notice and opportunity to opt out of hyperlinked delivery. For
a consumer to receive notice and an opportunity to opt out of
hyperlinked delivery as required by paragraph (c)(2)(ii)(B) of this
section, the debt collector must, before providing the disclosure,
either:
(1) Communication by the debt collector. Inform the consumer, in a
communication with the consumer, of:
(i) The name of the consumer who owes or allegedly owes the debt;
(ii) The name of the creditor to whom the debt currently is owed or
allegedly owed;
(iii) The email address or telephone number from which the debt
collector intends to send the electronic communication containing the
hyperlink to the disclosure;
(iv) The email address or telephone number to which the debt
collector intends to send the electronic communication containing the
hyperlink to the disclosure;
(v) The consumer's ability to opt out of hyperlinked delivery of
disclosures to such email address or telephone number; and
(vi) Instructions for opting out, including a reasonable period
within which to opt out; or
(2) Communication by the creditor. Confirm that, no more than 30
days before the debt collector's electronic communication containing
the hyperlink to the disclosure, the creditor communicated with the
consumer using the email address or, in the case of a text message, the
telephone number to which the debt collector intends to send the
electronic communication and informed the consumer of:
(i) The placement or sale of the debt to the debt collector;
(ii) The name the debt collector uses when collecting debts;
(iii) The debt collector's option to use the consumer's email
address or, in the case of a text message, the consumer's telephone
number to provide any legally required debt collection disclosures in a
manner that is consistent with Federal law; and
(iv) The information in paragraphs (d)(1)(iii), (v), and (vi) of
this section.
(e) Safe harbors. (1) Disclosures provided by mail. A debt
collector satisfies paragraph (a) of this section if the debt collector
mails a printed copy of a disclosure to the consumer's residential
address, unless the debt collector receives a notification from the
entity or person responsible for delivery that the disclosure was not
delivered.
(2) Validation notice contained in the initial communication. A
debt collector who provides the validation notice described in Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(A) within the body of an email that is the initial
communication with the consumer satisfies paragraph (a)(1) of this
section if the debt collector satisfies the requirements of paragraph
(b) of this section for validation notices described in Sec.
1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B). If such a debt
[[Page 23407]]
collector follows the procedures described in paragraph (c) of this
section, the debt collector may, in lieu of sending the validation
notice to an email address that the creditor or a prior debt collector
could use for delivery of electronic disclosures in accordance with
section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act (as described in paragraph (c)(1) of
this section), send the validation notice to an email address selected
through the procedures described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3).
Subpart C--[Reserved]
Subpart D--Miscellaneous
Sec. 1006.100 Record retention.
(a) A debt collector must retain evidence of compliance with this
part starting on the date that the debt collector begins collection
activity on a debt until three years after:
(1) The debt collector's last communication or attempted
communication in connection with the collection of the debt; or
(2) The debt is settled, discharged, or transferred to the debt
owner or to another debt collector.
Sec. 1006.104 Relation to State laws.
Neither the Act nor the corresponding provisions of this part
annul, alter, affect, or exempt any person subject to the provisions of
the Act or the corresponding provisions of this part from complying
with the laws of any State with respect to debt collection practices,
except to the extent that those laws are inconsistent with any
provision of the Act or the corresponding provisions of this part, and
then only to the extent of the inconsistency. For purposes of this
section, a State law is not inconsistent with the Act or the
corresponding provisions of this part if the protection such law
affords any consumer is greater than the protection provided by the Act
or the corresponding provisions of this part.
Sec. 1006.108 Exemption for State regulation.
(a) Exemption for State regulation. Any State may apply to the
Bureau for a determination that, under the laws of that State, any
class of debt collection practices within that State is subject to
requirements that are substantially similar to, or provide greater
protection for consumers than, those imposed under sections 803 through
812 of the Act (15 U.S.C. 1692a through 1692j) and the corresponding
provisions of this part, and that there is adequate provision for State
enforcement of such requirements.
(b) Procedures and criteria. The procedures and criteria whereby
States may apply to the Bureau for exemption of a class of debt
collection practices within the applying State from the provisions of
the Act and the corresponding provisions of this part as provided in
section 817 of the Act (15 U.S.C. 1692o) are set forth in appendix A of
this part.
Appendix A to Part 1006--Procedures for State Application for Exemption
from the Provisions of the Act
I. Purpose and Definitions
(a) This appendix establishes procedures and criteria whereby
States may apply to the Bureau for exemption of a class of debt
collection practices within the applying State from the provisions
of the Act and the corresponding provisions of this part as provided
in section 817 of the Act (15 U.S.C. 1692o).
(b) For purposes of this appendix:
(1) Applicant State law means the State law that, for a class of
debt collection practices within that State, is claimed to contain
requirements that are substantially similar to the requirements that
relevant Federal law imposes on that class of debt collection
practices, and that contains adequate provision for State
enforcement.
(2) Class of debt collection practices includes one or more such
classes of debt collection practices referred to in paragraph
I(b)(1) of this appendix.
(3) Relevant Federal law means sections 803 through 812 of the
Act (15 U.S.C. 1692a through 1692j) and the corresponding provisions
of this part.
(4) State law includes State statutes, any regulations that
implement State statutes, and formal interpretations of State
statutes or regulations by a court of competent jurisdiction or duly
authorized State agency.
II. Application
Any State may apply to the Bureau pursuant to the terms of this
appendix for a determination that the applicant State law contains
requirements that, for a class of debt collection practices within
that State, are substantially similar to, or provide greater
protection for consumers than, the requirements that relevant
Federal law imposes on that class of debt collection practices, and
that contains adequate provision for State enforcement. The
application must be in writing, addressed to the Assistant Director,
Office of Regulations, Division of Research, Markets, and
Regulations, Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, 1700 G Street
NW, Washington, DC 20552, signed by the Governor, Attorney General,
or State official having primary enforcement responsibility under
the State law that applies to the class of debt collection
practices, and must be supported by the documents specified in this
appendix.
III. Supporting Documents
The application must be accompanied by the following, which may
be submitted in paper or electronic form:
(a) A copy of the applicant State law.
(b) A comparison of each provision of relevant Federal law with
the corresponding provisions of the applicant State law, together
with reasons supporting the claim that the corresponding provisions
of the applicant State law are substantially similar to, or provide
greater protection to consumers than, the provisions of relevant
Federal law and an explanation as to why any differences between the
State statute or regulation and Federal law are not inconsistent
with the provisions of relevant Federal law and do not result in a
diminution in the protection otherwise afforded consumers; and a
statement that no other State laws (including administrative or
judicial interpretations) are related to, or would have an effect
upon, the State law that is being considered by the Bureau in making
its determination.
(c) A comparison of the provisions of the State law that provide
for enforcement with the provisions of section 814 of the Act (15
U.S.C. 1692l), together with reasons supporting the claim that the
applicant State law provides for adequate administrative
enforcement.
(d) A statement identifying the office designated or to be
designated to enforce the applicant State law. The statement must
show how the office provides for adequate enforcement of the
applicant State law, including by showing that the office has
necessary facilities, personnel, and funding. The statement must
include, for example, complete information regarding the fiscal
arrangements for administrative enforcement (including the amount of
funds available or to be provided), the number and qualifications of
personnel engaged or to be engaged in enforcement, and a description
of the procedures under which the applicant State law is to be
enforced by the State.
IV. Criteria for Determination
The Bureau will consider the criteria set forth below, and any
other relevant information, in determining whether applicant State
law is substantially similar to, or provides greater protection to
consumers than, relevant Federal law and whether there is adequate
provision for enforcement of the applicant State law. In making that
determination, the Bureau primarily will consider each provision of
the applicant State law in comparison with each corresponding
provision in relevant Federal law, and not the State law as a whole
in comparison with the Act as a whole.
(a)(1) In order for the applicant State law to be substantially
similar to relevant Federal law, the applicant State law at least
must provide that:
(i) Definitions and rules of construction, as applicable, import
a meaning and have an application that are substantially similar to,
or more protective of consumers than, those prescribed by relevant
Federal law.
(ii) Debt collectors provide all of the applicable notices
required by relevant Federal law, with the content and in the
terminology, form, and time periods prescribed pursuant to relevant
Federal law. The Bureau may determine whether additional notice
requirements under the applicant State law affect a determination
that the applicant State law is substantially similar to relevant
Federal law.
(iii) Debt collectors take all affirmative actions and abide by
obligations substantially
[[Page 23408]]
similar to, or more protective of consumers than, those prescribed
by relevant Federal law under substantially similar or more
protective conditions and within the substantially similar or more
protective time periods as are prescribed under relevant Federal
law;
(iv) Debt collectors abide by prohibitions that are
substantially similar to or more protective of consumers than those
prescribed by relevant Federal law;
(v) Consumers' obligations or responsibilities are no more
costly, lengthy, or burdensome than consumers' corresponding
obligations or responsibilities under relevant Federal law; and
(vi) Consumers' rights and protections are substantially similar
to, or more protective of consumers than, those provided by relevant
Federal law under conditions or within time periods that are
substantially similar to, or more protective of consumers than,
those prescribed by relevant Federal law.
(2) In applying the criteria set forth in paragraph IV(a)(1) of
this appendix, the Bureau will not consider adversely any additional
requirements of State law that are not inconsistent with the purpose
of the Act or the requirements imposed under relevant Federal law.
(b) In determining whether provisions for enforcement of the
applicant State law are adequate, consideration will be given to the
extent to which, under the applicant State law, provision is made
for administrative enforcement, including necessary facilities,
personnel, and funding.
V. Public Comment
In connection with any application that has been filed in
accordance with the requirements of parts II and III of this
appendix and following initial review of the application, a proposed
rule concerning the application for exemption will be published by
the Bureau in the Federal Register, and a copy of such application
will be made available for examination by interested persons during
business hours at the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, 1700
G Street, NW, Washington, DC 20552. A comment period will be allowed
from the date of such publication for interested parties to submit
written comments to the Bureau regarding that application.
VI. Exemption From Requirements
If the Bureau determines on the basis of the information before
it that, under the applicant State law, a class of debt collection
practices is subject to requirements substantially similar to, or
that provide greater protection to consumers than, those imposed
under relevant Federal law and that there is adequate provision for
State enforcement, the Bureau will exempt the class of debt
collection practices in that State from the requirements of relevant
Federal law and section 814 of the Act in the following manner and
subject to the following conditions:
(a) A final rule granting the exemption will be published in the
Federal Register, and the Bureau will furnish a copy of such rule to
the State official who made application for such exemption, to each
Federal authority responsible for administrative enforcement of the
requirements of relevant Federal law, and to the Attorney General of
the United States. Any exemption granted will be effective 90 days
after the date of publication of such rule in the Federal Register.
(b) Any State that receives an exemption must, through its
appropriate official, take the following steps:
(i) Inform the Assistant Director, Office of Regulations,
Division of Research, Markets, and Regulations, Bureau of Consumer
Financial Protection, 1700 G Street NW, Washington, DC 20552 in
writing within 30 days of any change in the applicant State law. The
report of any such change must contain copies of the full text of
that change, together with statements setting forth the information
and opinions regarding that change that are specified in paragraph
III.
(ii) Provide, not later than two years after the date the
exemption is granted, and every two years thereafter, a report to
the Bureau in writing concerning the manner in which the State has
enforced the applicant State law in the preceding two years and an
update of the information required under paragraph III(d) of this
appendix.
(c) The Bureau will inform any State that receives such an
exemption, through its appropriate official, of any subsequent
amendments of the Act or this part that might necessitate the
amendment of State law for the exemption to continue.
(d) After an exemption is granted, the requirements of the
applicable State law constitute the requirements of relevant Federal
law, except to the extent such State law imposes requirements not
imposed by the Act or this part.
VII. Adverse Determination
(a) If, after publication of a proposed rule in the Federal
Register as provided under part V of this appendix, the Bureau finds
on the basis of the information before it that it cannot make a
favorable determination in connection with the application, the
Bureau will notify the appropriate State official of the facts upon
which such findings are based and will afford that State authority a
reasonable opportunity to submit additional materials that
demonstrate the basis for granting an exemption.
(b) If, after having afforded the State authority such
opportunity to demonstrate the basis for granting an exemption, the
Bureau finds on the basis of the information before it that it still
cannot make a favorable determination in connection with the
application, the Bureau will publish in the Federal Register a final
rule containing its determination regarding the application and will
furnish a copy of such rule to the State official who made
application for such exemption.
VIII. Revocation of Exemption
(a) The Bureau reserves the right to revoke any exemption
granted under the provisions of the Act or this part, if at any time
it determines that the State law does not, in fact, impose
requirements that are substantially similar to, or that provide
greater protection to consumers than, relevant Federal law or that
there is not, in fact, adequate provision for State enforcement.
(b) Before revoking any such exemption, the Bureau will notify
the State of the facts or conduct that, in the Bureau's opinion,
warrant such revocation, and will afford that State such opportunity
as the Bureau deems appropriate in the circumstances to demonstrate
continued eligibility for an exemption.
(c) If, after having been afforded the opportunity to
demonstrate or achieve compliance, the Bureau determines that the
State has not done so, a proposed rule to revoke such exemption will
be published in the Federal Register. A comment period will be
allowed from the date of such publication for interested persons to
submit written comments to the Bureau regarding the intention to
revoke.
(d) If such exemption is revoked, a final rule revoking the
exemption will be published by the Bureau in the Federal Register,
and a copy of such rule will be furnished to the State, to the
Federal authorities responsible for enforcement of the requirements
of the Act, and to the Attorney General of the United States. The
revocation becomes effective, and the class of debt collection
practices affected within that State become subject to the
requirements of sections 803 through 812 of the Act and the
corresponding provisions of this part, 90 days after the date of
publication of the final rule in the Federal Register.
Appendix B to Part 1006--Model Forms and Clauses
B-1 [Reserved]
B-2 [Reserved]
B-3 Model Form for Validation Notice Sec. 1006.34
BILLING CODE 4810-AM-P
[[Page 23409]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP21MY19.001
BILLING CODE 4810-AM-C
Appendix C to Part 1006--Issuance of Advisory Opinions
1. Advisory opinions. Any act done or omitted in good faith in
conformity with any advisory opinion issued by the Bureau, including
advisory opinions referenced in this appendix, provides the
protection afforded under section 813(e) of the Act. The Bureau will
amend this appendix periodically to incorporate references to
advisory opinions that the Bureau issues.
2. Requests for issuance of advisory opinions. A request for an
advisory opinion should be in writing and addressed to the Associate
Director, Research, Markets, and Regulations, Bureau of Consumer
Financial Protection, 1700 G Street NW, Washington, DC 20552. The
request should contain a complete statement of all relevant facts
concerning the issue, including copies of all pertinent documents.
Designated officials will review and respond to requests for
advisory opinions.
3. Bureau-issued advisory opinions. The Bureau has issued the
following advisory opinions:
a. Safe Harbors from Liability under the Fair Debt Collection
Practices Act for Certain Actions Taken in Compliance with Mortgage
Servicing Rules under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act
(Regulation X) and the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 81 FR
71977 (Oct. 19, 2016).
[[Page 23410]]
Supplement I to Part 1006--Official Interpretations
Introduction
1. Official status. This commentary is the vehicle by which the
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection supplements Regulation F, 12
CFR part 1006, and has been issued under the Bureau's authority to
prescribe rules under 15 U.S.C. 1692l(d) in accordance with the
notice-and-comment procedures for informal rulemaking under the
Administrative Procedure Act. Unless specified otherwise, references
in this commentary are to sections of Regulation F or the Fair Debt
Collection Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. 1692 et seq. No commentary is
expected to be issued other than by means of this Supplement I.
2. Procedure for requesting interpretations. Anyone may request
that an official interpretation of the regulation be added to this
commentary. A request for such an official interpretation must be in
writing and addressed to the Associate Director, Research, Markets,
and Regulations, Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, 1700 G
Street NW, Washington, DC 20552. The request must contain a complete
statement of all relevant facts concerning the issue, including
copies of all pertinent documents. Interpretations that are adopted
will be incorporated in this commentary following publication in the
Federal Register.
3. Comment designations. Each comment in the commentary is
identified by a number and the regulatory section or paragraph that
it interprets. The comments are designated with as much specificity
as possible according to the particular regulatory provision
addressed. For example, comments to Sec. 1006.34(b)(3) are further
divided by subparagraph, such as comment 34(b)(3)(i)-1 and comment
34(b)(3)(iv)-1. Comments that have more general application are
designated, for example, as comments 38-1 and 38-2. This
introduction may be cited as comments I-1, I-2, and I-3.
Subpart A--General
Section 1006.2--Definitions
2(b) Attempt to communicate.
1. Examples. Section 1006.2(b) defines an attempt to communicate
as any act to initiate a communication or other contact with any
person through any medium, including by soliciting a response from
such person. An act to initiate a communication or other contact
with a person is an attempt to communicate regardless of whether the
attempt, if successful, would be a communication that conveys
information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person.
Attempts to communicate include, but are not limited to, the
following:
i. Placing a telephone call to a person, regardless of whether
the debt collector speaks to any person at the called number; or
ii. Transmitting a limited-content message, as defined in Sec.
1006.2(j), to a consumer by voicemail or text message sent directly
to the consumer or by an oral message left with a third party who
answers the consumer's home or mobile telephone number.
2(d) Communicate or communication.
1. Any medium. Section 1006.2(d) provides, in relevant part,
that a communication can occur through any medium. ``Any medium''
includes any oral, written, electronic, or other medium. For
example, a communication may occur in person or by telephone, audio
recording, paper document, mail, email, text message, social media,
or other electronic media.
2(j) Limited-content message.
1. In general. Section 1006.2(j) provides that a limited-content
message is a message for a consumer that includes all of the content
described in Sec. 1006.2(j)(1), that may include any of the content
described in Sec. 1006.2(j)(2), and that includes no other content.
Any other message is not a limited-content message. If a message
includes content other than the specific items described in Sec.
1006.2(j)(1) and (2), and such other content directly or indirectly
conveys any information about a debt, including but not limited to
any information that indicates that the message relates to the
collection of a debt, the message is a communication, as defined in
Sec. 1006.2(d). For example, a message that includes the consumer's
account number is not a limited-content message because it includes
more than a generic statement that the message relates to an
account.
2. Examples. i. The following example illustrates a limited-
content message that includes only the content described in Sec.
1006.6(j)(1): ``This is Robin Smith calling for Sam Jones. Sam,
please contact me at 1-800-555-1212.''
ii. The following example illustrates a limited-content message
that includes the content described in both Sec. 1006.6(j)(1) and
(2): ``Hi, this message is for Sam Jones. Sam, this is Robin Smith.
I'm calling to discuss an account. It is 4:15 p.m. on Wednesday,
September 1. You can reach me or, Jordan Johnson, at 1-800-555-1212
today until 6:00 p.m. eastern, or weekdays from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00
p.m. eastern.''
3. Message for a consumer. A debt collector may transmit a
limited-content message to a consumer by, for example, leaving a
voicemail at the consumer's telephone number, sending a text message
to the consumer's mobile telephone number, or leaving a message
orally with a third party who answers the consumer's home or mobile
telephone. Other provisions of this part may, in certain
circumstances, restrict a debt collector from transmitting a
limited-content message or otherwise attempting to communicate with
a consumer. See Sec. Sec. 1006.6(b) and (c) and 1006.22(f) and
their related commentary for further guidance regarding when a debt
collector is prohibited from attempting to communicate with a
consumer.
4. Meaningful disclosure of identity. A debt collector who
places a telephone call and leaves only a limited-content message
for a consumer does not violate Sec. 1006.14(g) with respect to
that telephone call.
Paragraph 2(j)(1)(iv).
1. Telephone number that the consumer can use to respond.
Section 1006.2(j)(1)(iv) provides that a limited-content message
includes a telephone number that the consumer can use to reply to
the debt collector. A voicemail or text message that spells out,
rather than enumerates numerically, a vanity telephone number is not
a limited-content message.
Subpart B--Rules for FDCPA Debt Collectors
Section 1006.6--Communications in Connection With Debt Collection
6(a) Consumer.
Paragraph 6(a)(1).
1. Spouse. Section 1006.6(a)(1) provides that, for purposes of
Sec. 1006.6, the term consumer includes a consumer's spouse. The
surviving spouse of a deceased consumer is a spouse as that term is
used in Sec. 1006.6(a)(1).
Paragraph 6(a)(2).
1. Parent. Section 1006.6(a)(2) provides that, for purposes of
Sec. 1006.6, the term consumer includes a consumer's parent, if the
consumer is a minor. A parent of a deceased minor consumer is a
parent as that term is used in Sec. 1006.6(a)(2).
Paragraph 6(a)(4).
1. Personal representative. Section 1006.6(a)(4) provides that,
for purposes of Sec. 1006.6, the term consumer includes the
executor or administrator of the consumer's estate, if the consumer
is deceased. The terms executor or administrator include the
personal representative of the consumer's estate. A personal
representative is any person who is authorized to act on behalf of
the deceased consumer's estate. Persons with such authority may
include personal representatives under the informal probate and
summary administration procedures of many States, persons appointed
as universal successors, persons who sign declarations or affidavits
to effectuate the transfer of estate assets, and persons who dispose
of the deceased consumer's assets extrajudicially.
6(b) Communications with a consumer--in general.
6(b)(1) Prohibitions regarding unusual or inconvenient times or
places.
1. Designation of inconvenience. Section 1006.6(b)(1) prohibits
a debt collector from, among other things, communicating or
attempting to communicate with a consumer in connection with the
collection of any debt at a time or place that the debt collector
knows or should know is inconvenient to the consumer. The debt
collector may know, or should know, that a time or place is
inconvenient if the consumer uses the word ``inconvenient'' to
notify the debt collector. In addition, depending on the facts and
circumstances, the debt collector may know, or should know, that a
time or place is inconvenient even if the consumer does not use the
word ``inconvenient'' to notify the debt collector. Further, if the
consumer initiates a communication with the debt collector at a time
or from a place that the consumer previously designated as
inconvenient, the debt collector may respond once to that consumer-
initiated communication at that time or place. After that response,
the debt collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate
further with the consumer at that time or place until the consumer
conveys that the time or place is no longer inconvenient. For
example (unless an exception in Sec. 1006.6(b)(4) applies):
[[Page 23411]]
i. Assume that a consumer tells a debt collector that the
consumer ``is busy'' or ``cannot talk'' on weekdays from 3:00 p.m.
to 5:00 p.m. Based on these facts, the debt collector knows or
should know that, on weekdays, the time period between 3:00 p.m. and
5:00 p.m. is inconvenient to the consumer and, thereafter, the debt
collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with the
consumer between those times.
ii. Assume the same facts as in comment 6(b)(1)-1.i, except
that, after the consumer tells the debt collector that the consumer
``is busy'' or ``cannot talk'' on weekdays from 3:00 p.m. to 5:00
p.m., the consumer initiates a communication with the debt collector
at 4:30 p.m. on a weekday. Based on these facts, Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(i) does not prohibit the debt collector from responding
once to the consumer. Unless the consumer otherwise informs the debt
collector, however, Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i) prohibits the debt
collector from future communications or attempts to communicate with
the consumer between 3:00 p.m. and 5:00 p.m. on weekdays.
iii. Assume that a consumer tells a debt collector not to
communicate with the consumer at school. Based on these facts, the
debt collector knows or should know that communications to the
consumer at school are inconvenient and, thereafter, the debt
collector must not communicate or attempt to communicate with the
consumer at that place.
iv. Assume the same facts as in comment 6(b)(1)-1.iii, except
that, after the consumer tells the debt collector not to communicate
with the consumer at school, the consumer initiates a communication
with the debt collector from school. Based on these facts, Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(ii) does not prohibit the debt collector from
responding once to the consumer. Unless the consumer otherwise
informs the debt collector, however, Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(ii)
prohibits the debt collector from future communications or attempts
to communicate with the consumer at school.
Paragraph 6(b)(1)(i).
1. Time of electronic communication. Under Sec.
1006.6(b)(1)(i), a debt collector is prohibited from communicating
or attempting to communicate electronically, such as through email
or text message, at a time the debt collector knows or should know
is inconvenient to the consumer. For purposes of determining the
time of an electronic communication under Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i), an
electronic communication occurs when the debt collector sends it,
not, for example, when the consumer receives or views it.
2. Consumer's location. Under Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i), in the
absence of the debt collector's knowledge of circumstances to the
contrary, an inconvenient time for communicating with a consumer is
before 8:00 a.m. and after 9:00 p.m. local time at the consumer's
location. If a debt collector is unable to determine a consumer's
location, then, in the absence of knowledge of circumstances to the
contrary, the debt collector complies with Sec. 1006.6(b)(1)(i) if
the debt collector communicates or attempts to communicate with the
consumer at a time that would be convenient in all of the locations
at which the debt collector's information indicates the consumer
might be located. The following examples, which assume that the debt
collector has no information about times the consumer considers
inconvenient or other information about the consumer's location,
illustrate the rule.
i. Assume that a debt collector's information indicates that a
consumer has a mobile telephone number with an area code associated
with the Eastern time zone and a street address in the Pacific time
zone. The convenient times to communicate with the consumer are
after 11:00 a.m. Eastern time (8:00 a.m. Pacific time) and before
9:00 p.m. Eastern time (6:00 p.m. Pacific time).
ii. Assume that a debt collector's information indicates that a
consumer has a mobile telephone number with an area code associated
with the Eastern time zone and a landline telephone number with an
area code associated with the Mountain time zone. The convenient
times to communicate with the consumer are after 10:00 a.m. Eastern
time (8:00 a.m. Mountain time) and before 9:00 p.m. Eastern time
(7:00 p.m. Mountain time).
6(b)(3) Prohibitions regarding consumer's place of employment.
1. Work email. Section 1006.6(b)(3) prohibits a debt collector
from communicating or attempting to communicate with a consumer in
connection with the collection of any debt at the consumer's place
of employment, if the debt collector knows or has reason to know
that the consumer's employer prohibits the consumer from receiving
such communication. For special rules regarding a consumer's work
email, see Sec. 1006.22(f)(3).
6(b)(4) Exceptions.
Paragraph 6(b)(4)(i).
1. Prior consent--in general. Section 1006.6(b)(4)(i) provides,
in part, that the prohibitions in Sec. 1006.6(b)(1) on a debt
collector communicating or attempting to communicate with a consumer
in connection with the collection of any debt at a time or place
that the debt collector knows or should know is inconvenient to the
consumer do not apply if the debt collector communicates or attempts
to communicate with the prior consent of the consumer. If the debt
collector learns during a communication that the debt collector is
communicating with a consumer at an inconvenient time or place, the
debt collector may ask the consumer what time or place would be
convenient. However, the debt collector cannot during that
communication ask the consumer to consent to the continuation of the
communication with the consumer at the inconvenient time or place.
2. Directly to the debt collector. Section 1006.6(b)(4)(i)
requires the prior consent of the consumer to be given directly to
the debt collector. For example, a debt collector cannot rely on the
prior consent of the consumer given to the original creditor or to a
previous debt collector.
6(c) Communications with a consumer--after refusal to pay or
cease communication notice.
6(c)(1) Prohibitions.
1. Notification complete upon receipt. If, pursuant to Sec.
1006.6(c)(1), a consumer notifies a debt collector in writing or in
electronic form using a medium of electronic communication through
which a debt collector accepts electronic communications from
consumers, that the consumer either refuses to pay a debt or wants
the debt collector to cease further communication with the consumer,
notification is complete upon the debt collector's receipt of that
information.
2. Interpretation of the E-SIGN Act. Comment 6(c)(1)-1
constitutes the Bureau's interpretation of section 101 of the E-SIGN
Act as applied to FDCPA section 805(c). Under this interpretation,
section 101(a) of the E-SIGN Act enables a consumer to satisfy the
requirement in FDCPA section 805(c) that the consumer's notification
of the debt collector be ``in writing'' through an electronic
request. Further, section 101(b) of the E-SIGN Act is not
contravened because the consumer may only satisfy the writing
requirement using a medium of electronic communication through which
a debt collect accepts electronic communications from consumers.
6(c)(2) Exceptions.
1. Written early intervention notice for mortgage servicers. The
Bureau has interpreted the written early intervention notice
required by 12 CFR 1024.39(d)(3) to fall within the exceptions to
the cease communication provision in FDCPA section 805(c)(2) and
(3). See 12 CFR 1024.39(d)(3), its commentary, and the Bureau's 2016
FDCPA Interpretive Rule (81 FR 71977 (Oct. 19, 2016)).
6(d) Communications with third parties.
6(d)(1) Prohibitions.
1. Limited-content message. Section 1006.2(j) provides, in part,
that a limited-content message is not a communication, as defined in
Sec. 1006.2(d). Because a limited-content message is not a
communication, a debt collector does not violate Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)
if the debt collector leaves a limited-content message for a
consumer with a third party who answers the consumer's home or
mobile telephone. Such a message is an attempt to communicate, as
defined in Sec. 1006.2(b), with the consumer. However, if, during
the course of the interaction with the third party, the debt
collector conveys content other than the specific items described in
Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) and (2), and such other content directly or
indirectly conveys any information regarding a debt, the message is
a communication, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(d), subject to the
prohibition on third-party communications in Sec. 1006.6(d)(1). See
Sec. 1006.2(j) and its related commentary for further guidance
concerning limited-content messages.
6(d)(2) Exceptions.
1. Prior consent. See the commentary to Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i)
for guidance concerning a consumer giving prior consent directly to
a debt collector.
6(d)(3) Reasonable procedures for email and text message
communications.
Paragraph 6(d)(3)(i).
1. Non-work email address and telephone number. For purposes of
Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B) and (C), an email address is a non-work
email address unless the debt collector knows or should know that
the email address is provided to the consumer by the consumer's
[[Page 23412]]
employer. For purposes of Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B) and (C), a
telephone number is a non-work telephone number unless the debt
collector knows or should know that the telephone number is provided
to the consumer by the consumer's employer. See Sec. 1006.22(f)(3)
and its related commentary for clarification regarding when a debt
collector knows or should know that an email address is provided by
a consumer's employer.
Paragraph 6(d)(3)(i)(B).
Paragraph 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1).
1. Format of notice. The opt-out notice described in Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) may be provided orally, in writing, or
electronically. The notice must be provided clearly and
conspicuously, as defined in Sec. 1006.34(b)(1). If the notice is
provided in writing or electronically, it must comply with the
requirements of Sec. 1006.42(a).
2. Reasonable period for consumer to opt out in an oral
communication. If a creditor or a debt collector provides the opt-
out notice described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1) to the consumer
in an oral communication, such as a telephone or in-person
conversation, the creditor or the debt collector may require the
consumer to make an opt-out decision during that same communication.
3. Combined notice concerning electronic communications and
hyperlinked delivery of notices. A debt collector or a creditor may
include the opt-out notice described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)
in the same communication as the opt-out notice described in Sec.
1006.42(d)(1) or (2), as applicable.
Paragraph 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2).
1. Expiration of opt-out period. Pursuant to Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(2), a debt collector may obtain a safe harbor
from liability for making a disclosure that violates Sec.
1006.6(d)(1) if, among other things, the debt collector communicates
with a consumer using a specific non-work email address or non-work
telephone number after the expiration of a specified opt-out period,
if the consumer has not opted out. However, if the consumer requests
after the expiration of the opt-out period that the debt collector
not use the specific non-work email address or non-work telephone
number, Sec. 1006.14(h) prohibits the debt collector from
communicating or attempting to communicate with the consumer using
that email address or telephone number. Likewise, if the consumer
requests after the expiration of the opt-out period that the debt
collector not communicate with the consumer by email or text
message, Sec. 1006.14(h) prohibits the debt collector from
communicating or attempting to communicate with the consumer by
email or text message, including by using the specific non-work
email address or non-work telephone number. See Sec. 1006.14(h).
6(e) Opt-out notice for electronic communications or attempts to
communicate.
1. In general. Section 1006.6(e) requires a debt collector who
communicates or attempts to communicate with a consumer
electronically in connection with the collection of a debt using a
specific email address, telephone number for text messages, or other
electronic-medium address to include in such communication or
attempt to communicate a clear and conspicuous statement describing
one or more ways the consumer can opt out of further electronic
communications or attempts to communicate by the debt collector to
that address or telephone number. Clear and conspicuous has the same
meaning as in Sec. 1006.34(b)(1). The following examples illustrate
the rule.
i. Assume that a debt collector sends a text message to a
consumer's mobile telephone number. Pursuant to Sec. 1006.6(e), the
text message must contain a clear and conspicuous statement
describing how the consumer can opt out of receiving further text
messages from the debt collector to that telephone number. For
example, a text message would comply with this requirement by
including the following instruction: ``Reply STOP to stop texts to
this telephone number.''
ii. Assume that a debt collector sends the consumer an email
message. Pursuant to Sec. 1006.6(e), the email message must contain
a clear and conspicuous statement describing how the consumer can
opt out of receiving further email messages from the debt collector
to that email address. For example, an email would comply with this
requirement by including instructions in a textual format in the
email, in a type size no smaller than the other text in the email,
explaining that the consumer may opt out of receiving further email
communications from the debt collector to that email address by
replying with the word ``stop'' in the subject line.
Section 1006.10--Acquisition of Location Information
10(a) Definition.
1. Location information about deceased consumers. If a consumer
obligated or allegedly obligated to pay any debt is deceased,
location information includes the information described in Sec.
1006.10(a) for a person who is authorized to act on behalf of the
deceased consumer's estate.
10(b) Form and content of location communications.
Paragraph 10(b)(2).
1. Executors, administrators, or personal representatives of a
deceased consumer's estate. Section 1006.10(b)(2) prohibits a debt
collector who is communicating with any person other than the
consumer for the purpose of acquiring location information about the
consumer from stating that the consumer owes any debt. If the
consumer obligated or allegedly obligated to pay the debt is
deceased and the debt collector is attempting to locate the person
who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's
estate, the debt collector does not violate Sec. 1006.10(b)(2) by
stating that the debt collector is seeking to identify and locate
the person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased
consumer's estate.
Section 1006.14--Harassing, Oppressive, or Abusive Conduct
14(b) Repeated or continuous telephone calls or telephone
conversations.
14(b)(1) In general.
1. In general. Section 1006.14(b)(1)(i) provides that, in
connection with the collection of a debt, a debt collector must not
place telephone calls or engage any person in telephone conversation
repeatedly or continuously with intent to annoy, abuse, or harass
any person at the called number. Section 1006.14(b)(1)(ii) provides
that, with respect to a debt collector who is collecting a consumer
financial product or service debt, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(f), it
is an unfair act or practice under section 1031 of the Dodd-Frank
Act to place telephone calls or engage any person in telephone
conversation repeatedly or continuously in connection with the
collection of such debt, such that the natural consequence is to
harass, oppress, or abuse any person at the called number. For
purposes of Sec. 1006.14(b)(1)(i) and (ii), placing a telephone
call includes conveying a ringless voicemail but does not include
sending an electronic message (e.g., a text message or an email) to
a mobile telephone.
14(b)(2) Frequency limits.
Paragraph 14(b)(2)(i).
1. Examples. Section 1006.14(b)(2)(i) provides that, subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector must not place a telephone
call to a particular person more than seven times within seven
consecutive days in connection with the collection of a particular
debt. The following examples illustrate the rule.
i. On Wednesday, March 1, a debt collector first attempts to
communicate with a consumer in connection with the collection of a
debt by placing a telephone call and leaving a limited-content
message on the consumer's voicemail. Between Thursday and Sunday,
the debt collector places six more telephone calls to the consumer,
all of which go unanswered. As of Sunday, the debt collector has
placed seven telephone calls to the consumer in connection with the
collection of the credit card debt within the period of seven
consecutive days that started on Wednesday, March 1. Subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may place another telephone
call to the consumer in connection with collection of the debt on
Wednesday, March 8 but not before that date.
ii. On Tuesday, October 5, a debt collector first attempts to
communicate with a particular third party for the purpose of
obtaining location information about a consumer by placing a
telephone call to that third party that goes unanswered. Subject to
Sec. Sec. 1006.10 and 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may place
up to six more telephone calls to that third party for the purpose
of obtaining location information about that consumer through
Monday, October 11, unless the debt collector engages in a telephone
conversation with the third party before that day. See Sec.
1006.10(c) for further guidance concerning when a debt collector is
prohibited from communicating with a person other than the consumer
for the purpose of acquiring location information.
2. Misdirected telephone calls. Section 1006.14(b)(2)(i) limits
the number of times a debt collector may place telephone calls to a
particular person within seven consecutive days in connection with
the collection of a particular debt. If, within a period of seven
consecutive days, a debt collector attempts to communicate with a
particular person by placing telephone calls to a particular
telephone number, and the debt collector then learns that the
telephone number is not that person's number, the calls that the
debt
[[Page 23413]]
collector made to that number are not considered to have been calls
to that person during that seven-day period for purposes of Sec.
1006.14(b)(2)(i). For example:
i. Assume that a debt collector attempts to communicate with a
consumer on Monday and Wednesday by placing one unanswered telephone
call to a particular telephone number on each of those days. On
Thursday, the debt collector learns that the telephone number
belongs to someone else and that the consumer does not answer calls
to that number. For purposes of Sec. 1006.14(b)(2)(i), the debt
collector has not yet placed any telephone calls to that consumer
during that seven-day period.
Paragraph 14(b)(2)(ii).
1. Examples. Section 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) provides that, subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), a debt collector must not place a telephone
call to a particular person in connection with the collection of a
particular debt within a period of seven consecutive days after
having had a telephone conversation with the person in connection
with the collection of such debt. Section 1006.14(b)(2)(ii) also
states that the date of the telephone conversation is the first day
of the seven-consecutive-day period. The following examples
illustrate the rule.
i. On Tuesday, April 11, a debt collector first attempts to
communicate with a consumer in connection with the collection of a
debt by placing a telephone call to the consumer that the consumer
does not answer. On Friday, April 14, the debt collector again
places a telephone call to the consumer and has a telephone
conversation with the consumer in connection with the collection of
the debt. Subject to Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may not
place a telephone call to the consumer in connection with the
collection of that debt again until Friday, April 21.
ii. On Thursday, August 13, a consumer initiates a telephone
conversation with a debt collector regarding a debt. Subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may not place a telephone
call to the consumer in connection with the collection of that debt
again until Thursday, August 20.
14(b)(3) Certain telephone calls excluded from the frequency
limits.
Paragraph 14(b)(3)(i).
1. Responsive calls. Section 1006.14(b)(3)(i) provides that
telephone calls placed to a person to respond to the person's
request for information do not count toward, and are permitted in
excess of, the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2). Once the
debt collector provides a response to a person's request for
information, the exception in Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) does not apply
to subsequent telephone calls placed by the debt collector to the
person, unless the person makes another request.
2. Example. On Wednesday, October 4, a debt collector places a
telephone call to a consumer. During the ensuing telephone
conversation in connection with the collection of a debt, the
consumer requests additional information about the debt that the
debt collector does not have at the time of the call. While Sec.
1006.14(b)(2) otherwise would prohibit the debt collector from
placing a telephone call to the consumer again until Wednesday,
October 11, Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(i) provides that the debt collector
may place telephone calls to respond to the consumer's request for
information before the following Wednesday. Assume further that the
debt collector provides a response to the consumer's request on
Friday, October 6. Thereafter, the exception in Sec.
1006.14(b)(3)(i) does not apply to subsequent telephone calls placed
by the debt collector to the consumer, unless the consumer makes
another request.
Paragraph 14(b)(3)(ii).
1. Prior consent. See the commentary to Sec. 1006.6(b)(4)(i)
for guidance concerning a person giving prior consent directly to a
debt collector.
2. Example. On Friday, April 5, a debt collector places a
telephone call to a consumer. During the ensuing telephone
conversation in connection with the collection of a debt, the
consumer requests that the debt collector call back at a later time.
While Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) otherwise would prohibit the debt
collector from placing a telephone call to the consumer again until
Friday, April 12, Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(ii) provides that the debt
collector may place telephone calls pursuant to the consumer's prior
consent before the following Friday. Assume further that the debt
collector calls the consumer back on Monday, April 8, and that they
have a telephone conversation on that date. Thereafter, the
exception in Sec. 1006.14(b)(3)(ii) does not apply to subsequent
telephone calls placed by the debt collector to the consumer, unless
the consumer again provides prior consent directly to the debt
collector.
Paragraph 14(b)(3)(iii).
1. Unconnected telephone calls. Section 1006.14(b)(3)(iii)
provides that telephone calls placed to a person do not count
toward, and are permitted in excess of, the frequency limits in
Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) if they do not connect to the dialed number. A
debt collector's telephone call does not connect to the dialed
number if, for example, the debt collector receives a busy signal or
an indication that the dialed number is not in service. Conversely,
a debt collector's telephone call connects to the dialed number if,
for example, the call causes a telephone to ring at the dialed
number but no one answers the call, or the call does not cause a
telephone to ring but is connected to a voicemail or other recorded
message.
2. Example. Section 1006.14(b)(3)(iii) provides that telephone
calls placed to a person do not count toward, and are permitted in
excess of, the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2) if they do
not connect to the dialed number. For example, on Thursday, February
2, a debt collector places a telephone call to a consumer about a
credit card debt in response to which the debt collector receives a
busy signal or an indication that the dialed number is not in
service. That telephone call does not count toward the frequency
limits in Sec. 1006.14(b)(2). Subject to Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the
debt collector may place seven more telephone calls to the consumer
about that credit card debt through Wednesday, February 8, unless
the debt collector engages in a telephone conversation with the
consumer in connection with the collection of the debt before that
day.
14(b)(5) Definition.
1. Particular debt. Section 1006.14(b)(2) limits the frequency
with which a debt collector may place telephone calls to, or engage
in telephone conversation with, a person in connection with the
collection of a particular debt. Section 1006.14(b)(5) provides
that, except in the case of student loan debt, the term particular
debt means each of a consumer's debts in collection. For student
loan debt, Sec. 1006.14(b)(5) provides that the term particular
debt means all student loan debts that a consumer owes or allegedly
owes that were serviced under a single account number at the time
the debts were obtained by the debt collector. The following
examples illustrate the rule.
i. A debt collector is attempting to collect a medical debt and
a credit card debt from the same consumer. Subject to Sec.
1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may, within a period of seven
consecutive days, place seven unanswered telephone calls to the
consumer in connection with the collection of the medical debt, and
seven unanswered telephone calls to the consumer in connection with
the collection of the credit card debt.
ii. A debt collector is attempting to collect a medical debt and
a credit card debt from the same consumer. On Monday, November 9,
the debt collector engages in a telephone conversation with the
consumer solely in connection with the collection of the medical
debt, but the debt collector does not place any telephone calls to
the consumer in connection with the collection of the credit card
debt. Subject to Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may not
place a telephone call to the consumer in connection with the
collection of the medical debt again until Monday, November 16.
Subject to Sec. 1006.14(b), however, the debt collector may place
telephone calls to, and engage in a telephone conversation with, the
consumer in connection with the collection of the credit card debt
before Monday, November 16.
iii. A debt collector is attempting to collect three student
loan debts that were serviced under a single account number at the
time that they were obtained by the debt collector and that are owed
or allegedly owed by the same consumer. All three debts are treated
as a single debt for purposes of Sec. 1006.14(b)(2). Subject to
Sec. 1006.14(b)(3), the debt collector may place seven telephone
calls within seven days to the consumer in connection with the
collection of the debts. If, however, the debt collector engages the
consumer in a telephone conversation in connection with the
collection of any of the debts, the debt collector may not place a
telephone call to the consumer again during the same seven-day
period in connection with the collection of any of the debts.
14(h) Prohibited communication media.
14(h)(1) In general.
1. Communication media. Section 1006.14(h) prohibits a debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of any debt through a
medium of communication if the consumer has requested that the debt
collector not use that medium to communicate with the
[[Page 23414]]
consumer. See comment 2(d)-1 for examples of communication media.
2. Specific address or telephone number. Within a medium of
communication, a consumer may request that a debt collector not use
a specific address or telephone number. For example, if a debt
collector has two mobile telephone numbers on file for a consumer,
the consumer may request that the debt collector not use either or
both mobile telephone numbers.
Section 1006.18--False, Deceptive, or Misleading Representations or
Means
18(e) Disclosures required.
1. Communication. A limited-content message, as defined in Sec.
1006.2(j), is not a communication, as that term is defined in Sec.
1006.2(d). Thus, a debt collector who leaves a limited-content
message for a consumer need not make the disclosures required by
Sec. 1006.18(e)(1) and (2). However, if a debt collector leaves a
voicemail message for a consumer that includes content in addition
to the content described in Sec. 1006.2(j)(1) and (2) and which
directly or indirectly conveys any information regarding a debt, the
voicemail message is a communication, and the debt collector is
required to make the Sec. 1006.18(e) disclosures. See the
commentary to Sec. 1006.2(d) and (j) for additional clarification
regarding the definitions of ``communication'' and ``limited-content
messages.''
18(e)(1) Initial communications.
1. Example. A debt collector must make the disclosure required
by Sec. 1006.18(e)(1) in the debt collector's initial communication
with a consumer, regardless of whether that communication is written
or oral, and regardless of whether the debt collector or the
consumer initiated the communication. For example, assume that a
debt collector who has not previously communicated with a consumer
attempts to communicate with the consumer by leaving a limited-
content message, as defined in Sec. 1006.2(j), in the consumer's
voicemail. After listening to the debt collector's limited-content
message, the consumer initiates a telephone call to, and
communicates with, the debt collector. Pursuant to Sec.
1006.18(e)(1), because the consumer-initiated call is the ``initial
communication'' between the debt collector and the consumer, the
debt collector must disclose to the consumer during that telephone
call that the debt collector is attempting to collect a debt and
that any information obtained will be used for that purpose.
Section 1006.22--Unfair or Unconscionable Means
22(f) Restrictions on use of certain media.
Paragraph 22(f)(3).
1. Consent to use employer-provided email address. Section
1006.22(f)(3) prohibits a debt collector from communicating or
attempting to communicate with a consumer using an email address
that the debt collector knows or should know is provided to the
consumer by the consumer's employer, unless the debt collector has
received directly from the consumer either prior consent to use that
email address or an email from that email address. The consumer
could at any time, however, opt out of receiving emails at that
address using instructions provided by a debt collector pursuant to
Sec. 1006.6(e), or otherwise request not to receive emails at that
address pursuant to Sec. 1006.14(h). See the commentary to Sec.
1006.6(b)(4)(i) for additional guidance concerning a consumer giving
prior consent directly to a debt collector.
2. Receipt of email from employer-provided email address.
Section 1006.22(f)(3) prohibits a debt collector from communicating
or attempting to communicate with a consumer using an email address
that the debt collector knows or should know is provided to the
consumer by the consumer's employer, unless the debt collector has
received directly from the consumer either prior consent to use that
email address or an email from that email address. A debt collector
who receives an email directly from a consumer from an email address
provided by the consumer's employer may communicate or attempt to
communicate with the consumer at that email address, even if the
consumer's email does not provide prior consent to the debt
collector. For example, assume a debt collector has provided to a
consumer a validation notice pursuant to Sec. 1006.34 but has not
otherwise communicated or attempted to communicate with the
consumer. Assume further that the consumer subsequently sends an
email directly to the debt collector from an email address that the
debt collector knows or should know is provided to the consumer by
the consumer's employer; that the consumer's email requests
additional information about the debt but does not give prior
consent to the debt collector's use of that email address; and that
the debt collector neither knows nor has reason to know that the
consumer's employer prohibits the consumer from receiving
communications in connection with the collection of a debt. Section
1006.22(f)(3) permits the debt collector to communicate or attempt
to communicate with the consumer using that email address. The
consumer could, however, subsequently opt out or request not to
receive messages at that email address pursuant to Sec. Sec.
1006.6(e) or 1006.14(h).
3. Knowledge of employer-provided email address. For purposes of
Sec. 1006.22(f)(3), a debt collector knows or should know an email
address is provided to the consumer by the consumer's employer if,
for example, the email address's top-level domain name is one
ordinarily associated with work email addresses (e.g., .gov or
.mil), the email address's domain name includes a corporate name
that is not commonly associated with non-work email addresses (e.g.,
springsidemortgage.com), or the debt collector knows the identity of
the consumer's employer and the email address's domain name includes
the employer's name or an abbreviation of the employer's name (e.g.,
the debt collector knows that the consumer works at Example Mortgage
Company and the email address is examplemortgagecompany.com or
exmoc.com). In the absence of contrary information, a debt collector
neither would know nor should know that an email address is provided
to the consumer by the consumer's employer if the email address's
domain name is one commonly associated with a provider of non-work
email addresses.
Paragraph 22(f)(4).
1. Social media. Section 1006.22(f)(4) prohibits a debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of a debt by a social
media platform that is viewable by a person other than the persons
described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(i) through (vi). For example, Sec.
1006.22(f)(4) prohibits a debt collector from posting, in connection
with the collection of a debt, any message, including a limited-
content message, for a consumer on a social media web page if that
web page is viewable by the general public or the consumer's social
media contacts. If a social media platform enables a debt collector
to send a private message to the consumer that is not viewable by a
person other than the persons described in Sec. 1006.6(d)(1)(i)
through (vi), however, Sec. 1006.22(f)(4) does not prohibit a debt
collector from communicating or attempting to communicate with a
consumer in connection with the collection of a debt by sending such
a private message to the consumer, including by sending a limited-
content message, although Sec. Sec. 1006.6(b) or 1006.14(h)
nonetheless may prohibit the debt collector from sending such a
private message if, for example, the consumer has requested that the
debt collector not use that medium to communicate with the consumer.
Section 1006.30--Other Prohibited Practices
30(a) Communication prior to furnishing information.
1. Communication. Section 1006.30(a) prohibits a debt collector
from furnishing information to a consumer reporting agency about a
debt before communicating with the consumer about that debt.
Pursuant to Sec. 1006.2(d), a debt collector has communicated with
the consumer about the debt if the debt collector conveys
information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to the consumer
through any medium. Pursuant to Sec. 1006.2(d), a debt collector
has not communicated with the consumer about the debt if the debt
collector attempts to communicate with the consumer but no
communication occurs. For example, a debt collector communicates
with the consumer if the debt collector provides a validation notice
to the consumer; a debt collector does not communicate with the
consumer by leaving a limited-content message for the consumer. For
additional clarification on providing disclosures in a manner that
is reasonably expected to provide actual notice to consumers, see
Sec. 1006.42.
30(b) Prohibition on the sale, transfer, or placement of certain
debts.
30(b)(1) In general.
30(b)(1)(i) FDCPA prohibition.
Paragraph 30(b)(1)(i)(C).
1. Identity theft report filed. Under Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i)(C),
a debt collector may not sell, transfer, or place for collection a
debt if the debt collector knows or should know that an identity
theft report was filed with respect to the debt. A debt collector
knows or should know that an identity theft report was filed if, for
example, the debt collector has received a copy of the identity
theft report.
30(b)(2) Exceptions.
[[Page 23415]]
Paragraph 30(b)(2)(i).
1. In general. Under Sec. 1006.30(b)(2)(i), a debt collector
who is collecting a debt described in Sec. 1006.30(b)(1)(i) may
transfer the debt to the debt's owner. However, unless another
exception under Sec. 1006.30(b)(2) applies, the debt collector may
not transfer the debt or the right to collect the debt to another
entity on behalf of the debt owner.
Section 1006.34--Notice for Validation of Debts
34(a)(1) Validation information required.
1. Deceased consumers. Section 1006.34(a)(1) generally requires
a debt collector to provide the validation information described in
Sec. 1006.34(c) either by sending the consumer a validation notice
in a manner that satisfies Sec. 1006.42(a), or by providing the
information orally in the debt collector's initial communication. If
the debt collector knows or should know that the consumer is
deceased, and if the debt collector has not previously provided the
validation information to the deceased consumer, a person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate
operates as the consumer for purposes of Sec. 1006.34(a)(1). In
such circumstances, to comply with Sec. 1006.34(a)(1), a debt
collector must provide the validation information to an individual
that the debt collector identifies by name who is authorized to act
on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate.
34(b) Definitions.
34(b)(3) Itemization date.
1. In general. Section 1006.34(b)(3) defines itemization date
for purposes of Sec. 1006.34. Section 1006.34(b)(3) states that the
itemization date is any one of four potential references dates for
which a debt collector can ascertain the amount of the debt. The
four potential reference dates are the last statement date, the
charge-off date, the last payment date, and the transaction date. A
debt collector may select any of these dates as the itemization date
to comply with Sec. 1006.34. Once a debt collector uses a reference
date for a specific debt in a communication with an individual
consumer, the debt collector must use that reference date for that
debt consistently when providing disclosures required by Sec.
1006.34 to that consumer. For example, if a debt collector uses the
last statement date to determine and disclose the account number
associated with the debt pursuant to Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(v), the
debt collector may not use the charge-off date to determine and
disclose the amount of the debt pursuant to Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(viii).
Paragraph 34(b)(3)(i).
1. Last statement date. Under Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i), the last
statement date is the date of the last periodic statement or written
account statement or invoice provided to the consumer. For purposes
of Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(i), a statement provided by a creditor or a
third party acting on the creditor's behalf, including a creditor's
service provider, may constitute the last statement provided to the
consumer.
Paragraph 34(b)(3)(iv).
1. Transaction date. Section 1006.34(b)(3)(iv) provides that the
itemization date may be the date of the transaction that gave rise
to the debt. The transaction date is the date that a creditor
provided, or made available, a good or service to a consumer. For
example, the transaction date for a debt arising from a medical
procedure may be the date the medical procedure was performed, and
the transaction date for a consumer's gym membership may be the date
the membership contract was executed. In some cases, a debt
collector may identify more than one potential transaction date. For
example, a debt may have two transaction dates if a contract for a
service is executed on one date and the service is performed on
another date. If a debt has more than one transaction date, a debt
collector may use any such date as the transaction date for purposes
of Sec. 1006.34(b)(3)(iv) but must use whichever transaction date
it selects consistently, as described in comment 34(b)(3)-1.
34(b)(5) Validation period.
1. Updated validation period. Section 1006.34(b)(5) defines the
validation period as the period starting on the date that a debt
collector provides the validation information required by Sec.
1006.34(a)(1) and ending 30 days after the consumer receives or is
assumed to receive those disclosures. Section 1006.34(c)(3)(i)
through (iii) requires statements that specify the end date of the
validation period. If a debt collector sends a subsequent validation
notice to a consumer because the consumer did not receive the
original validation notice and the consumer has not otherwise
received the validation information described in Sec. 1006.34(c),
the debt collector must calculate the end date of the validation
period specified in the Sec. 1006.34(c)(3) disclosures based on the
date the consumer receives or is assumed to receive the subsequent
validation notice. For example, assume a debt collector sends a
consumer a validation notice on January 1, and that notice is
returned as undeliverable. After obtaining accurate location
information, the debt collector sends the consumer a subsequent
validation notice on January 15. Pursuant to Sec. 1006.34(b)(5),
the end date of the validation period specified in the Sec.
1006.34(c)(3) disclosures should be based on the date the consumer
receives or is assumed to receive the validation notice sent on
January 15.
34(c) Validation information.
34(c)(2) Information about the debt.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(ii).
1. Consumer's name. Section 1006.34(c)(2)(ii) provides that
validation information includes the consumer's name and mailing
address. The consumer's name is what the debt collector reasonably
determines is the most complete version of the name about which the
debt collector has knowledge, whether obtained from the creditor or
another source. It would be unreasonable for a debt collector to
determine the consumer's name is the most complete version of the
consumer's name if the debt collector has omitted name information
in a manner that created a false, misleading, or confusing
impression about the consumer's identity. For example, if the
creditor provides the consumer's first name, middle name, last name,
and name suffix to the debt collector, it would be unreasonable for
the debt collector to not provide all of that information to the
consumer.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(iii).
1. Merchant brand. Section 1006.34(c)(2)(iii) provides that
validation information includes the merchant brand, if any,
associated with a credit card debt, to the extent that such
information is available to the debt collector. For example, assume
that a debt collector is attempting to collect a consumer's credit
card debt. The credit card was issued by ABC Bank and was co-branded
XYZ Store, and this information is available to the debt collector.
The debt collector must provide the ``XYZ Store'' merchant brand
information to the consumer.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(v).
1. Account number truncation. Section 1006.34(c)(2)(v) provides
that validation information includes the account number associated
with the debt on the itemization date, or a truncated version of
that number. If a debt collector uses a truncated account number,
the account number must remain recognizable. For example, a debt
collector may truncate a credit card account number so that only the
last four digits appear on a validation notice.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(viii).
1. Amount of the debt on the itemization date. Section
1006.34(c)(2)(viii) provides that validation information includes
the amount of the debt on the itemization date. The amount of the
debt on the itemization date includes any fees, interest, or other
charges owed as of that date.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(ix).
1. Itemization of the debt. Section 1006.34(c)(2)(ix) provides
that validation information includes an itemization of the current
amount of the debt in a tabular format reflecting interest, fees,
payments, and credits since the itemization date. When providing a
validation notice, a debt collector must include fields in the
notice for all of these items even if none of the items have been
assessed or applied to the debt since the itemization date. A debt
collector may indicate that the value of a required field is ``0''
or ``N/A,'' or may state that no interest, fees, payments, or
credits have been assessed or applied to the debt.
Paragraph 34(c)(2)(x).
1. Current amount of the debt. Section 1006.34(c)(2)(x) provides
that validation information includes the current amount of the debt
(i.e., the amount as of when the validation information is
provided). For residential mortgage debt subject to Regulation Z, 12
CFR 1026.41, a debt collector may comply with the requirement to
provide the current amount of the debt by providing the consumer the
total balance of the outstanding mortgage, including principal,
interest, fees, and other charges.
34(c)(3) Information about consumer protections.
Paragraph 34(c)(3)(v).
1. Electronic communication media. Section 1006.34(c)(3)(v)
provides that validation information includes a statement explaining
how a consumer can take the actions described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)
and (d)(3), as applicable, electronically, if the debt collector
provides the validation notice electronically. A debt collector may
provide the information described by Sec. 1006.34(c)(3)(v) by
including the
[[Page 23416]]
statements, ``We accept disputes electronically at,'' using that
phrase or a substantially similar phrase, followed by an email
address or website portal that a consumer can use to take the action
described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i), and ``We accept original
creditor information requests electronically,'' using that phrase or
a substantially similar phrase, followed by an email address or
website portal that a consumer can use to take the action described
in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(ii). If a debt collector accepts electronic
communications from consumers through more than one medium, such as
by email and through a website portal, the debt collector is only
required to provide information regarding one of these media but may
provide information on any additional media.
Paragraph 34(c)(3)(vi).
1. In general. Section 1006.34(c)(3)(vi) provides that, for a
validation notice delivered in the body of an email pursuant to
Sec. 1006.42(b)(1) or (c)(2)(i), validation information includes
the opt-out statement required by Sec. 1006.6(e). If a validation
notice is delivered on a website pursuant to Sec.
1006.42(c)(2)(ii), the validation notice need not contain the opt-
out instructions because the consumer would have already received
the opt-out instructions since those instructions are required for
any email or text message that provides a hyperlink to the website
where the notice is placed. Delivery of a validation notice that a
debt collector previously provided pursuant to Sec. 1006.42(b)(1)
or (c)(2)(i) or (ii) is not rendered ineffective because a consumer
opts out of future electronic communications.
34(c)(4) Consumer response information.
1. Prompts. If the validation information is provided in writing
or electronically, a prompt described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4) may be
formatted as a checkbox as in Model Form B-3 in appendix B.
34(c)(5) Special rule for certain residential mortgage debt.
1. In general. Section 1006.34(c)(5) provides that, for debts
subject to Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.41, a debt collector need not
provide the validation information described in Sec.
1006.34(c)(2)(vii) through (ix) if the debt collector provides the
consumer at the same time as the validation notice a copy of the
most recent periodic statement provided to the consumer under 12 CFR
1026.41(b), and the debt collector refers to that periodic statement
in the validation notice. A debt collector may comply with the
requirement to provide a copy of the most recent periodic statement
and the validation notice at the same time by, for example,
including both documents in the same mailing. A debt collector may
comply with the requirement to refer to the periodic statement in
the validation notice by, for example, including in the validation
notice the statement, ``See the enclosed periodic statement for an
itemization of the debt,'' situated next to the information about
the current amount of the debt required by Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(x).
For debt subject to Sec. 1006.34(c)(5), a debt collector need not
include the itemization table described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ix).
34(d) Form of validation information.
34(d)(1) In general.
Paragraph 34(d)(1)(ii).
1. Permissible changes. A debt collector may make certain
changes to the content, format, and placement of the validation
information described in Sec. 1006.34(c) as long as the resulting
disclosures are substantially similar to Model Form B-3 in appendix
B of this part. Acceptable changes include, for example:
i. Modifications to remove language that could suggest liability
for the debt if such language is not applicable. For example, if a
debt collector sends a validation notice to a person who is
authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate (see
comment 34(a)(1)-1), and that person is not liable for the debt, the
debt collector may use the name of the deceased consumer instead of
``you.''
34(d)(2) Safe harbor.
1. Safe harbor provided by use of model form. Although the use
of Model Form B-3 in appendix B of this part is not required, a debt
collector who uses the model form, including a debt collector who
delivers the model form electronically, complies with the disclosure
requirements of Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) and (d)(1). A debt collector who
uses Model Form B-3 and includes the optional disclosures described
in Sec. 1006.34(d)(3) continues to be in compliance as long as
those disclosures are made consistent with the instructions in Sec.
1006.34(d)(3). A debt collector who uses Model Form B-3 also may
embed hyperlinks if delivering the form electronically and continue
to be in compliance as long as the hyperlinks are included
consistent with Sec. 1006.34(d)(4)(ii).
34(d)(3) Optional disclosures.
34(d)(3)(iv) Disclosures required by applicable law.
1. Section 1006.34(d)(3)(iv) permits a debt collector to include
on the front of the validation notice a statement that other
disclosures required by applicable law appear on the reverse of the
validation notice and, on the reverse of the validation notice, any
such required disclosures. Disclosures required by other applicable
law may include, for example, disclosure requirements established by
State statutes or regulations, as well as disclosures required by
judicial decisions or orders. To comply with Sec.
1006.34(d)(3)(iv), a debt collector may include in the validation
notice a disclosure that is substantially similar to the language
about other required disclosures that appears on Model Form B-3 in
appendix B of this part and place any such required disclosures on
the reverse of the validation notice, located above the consumer
information section described in Sec. 1006.34(c)(4).
34(d)(3)(vi) Spanish-language translation disclosures.
Paragraph 34(d)(3)(vi)(A).
1. Customizing Spanish-language disclosure. Section
1006.34(d)(3)(vi)(A) permits a debt collector to include
supplemental information in Spanish that specifies how a consumer
may request a Spanish-language validation notice. For example, a
debt collector may include a statement in Spanish that a consumer
can request a Spanish-language validation notice by telephone or
email, if the debt collector chooses to accept consumer requests
through those communication media.
34(e) Translation into other languages.
1. In general. Section 1006.34(e) permits a debt collector to
satisfy Sec. 1006.34(a)(1) by sending a consumer a validation
notice accurately translated into any language, if the debt
collector also sends an English-language validation notice in the
same communication or has already provided an English-language
validation notice. The language of a validation notice a debt
collector obtains from the Bureau's website is considered a complete
and accurate translation, although debt collectors are permitted to
use other validation notice translations so long as they are
complete and accurate.
Section 1006.38--Disputes and Requests for Original-Creditor
Information
1. Deceased consumers. Section 1006.38 contains requirements
related to disputes and requests for the name and address of the
original creditor timely submitted in writing by the consumer. If
the debt collector knows or should know that the consumer is
deceased, and if the consumer has not previously disputed the debt
or requested the name and address of the original creditor, a person
who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's estate
operates as the consumer for purposes of Sec. 1006.38. In such
circumstances, to comply with Sec. 1006.38(c) or (d)(2),
respectively, a debt collector must respond to a request for the
name and address of the original creditor or to a dispute timely
submitted in writing by a person who is authorized to act on behalf
of the deceased consumer's estate.
2. In writing. Section 1006.38 contains requirements related to
a dispute or request for the name and address of the original
creditor timely submitted in writing by the consumer. A consumer has
disputed the debt or requested the name and address of the original
creditor in writing for purposes of Sec. 1006.38(c) or (d)(2) if
the consumer, for example:
i. Mails the written dispute or request to the debt collector;
ii. Returns to the debt collector the consumer response form
that Sec. 1006.34(c)(4)(i) requires to appear on the validation
notice and indicates on the form a dispute or request;
iii. Provides the dispute or request to the debt collector using
a medium of electronic communication through which a debt collector
accepts electronic communications from consumers, such as an email
address or a website portal; or
iv. Delivers the written dispute or request in person or by
courier to the debt collector.
3. Interpretation of the E-SIGN Act. Comment 38-2.ii constitutes
the Bureau's interpretation of section 101 of the E-SIGN Act as
applied to section 809(b) of the FDCPA. Under this interpretation,
section 101(a) of the E-SIGN Act enables a consumer to satisfy
through an electronic request the requirement in section 809(b) of
the FDCPA that the consumer's notification of the debt collector be
``in writing.'' Further, section 101(b) of the E-SIGN Act is not
contravened because the consumer may only use a medium of electronic
communication through which a debt collector accepts electronic
communications from consumers.
38(a) Definitions.
[[Page 23417]]
38(a)(1) Duplicative dispute.
1. Substantially the same. Section 1006.38(a)(1) provides that a
dispute is a duplicative dispute if, among other things, the dispute
is substantially the same as a dispute previously submitted by the
consumer in writing within the validation period for which the debt
collector has already satisfied the requirements of Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(i). A later dispute can be substantially the same as
an earlier dispute even if the later dispute does not repeat
verbatim the language of the earlier dispute.
2. New and material information. Section Sec. 1006.38(a)(1)
provides that a dispute that is substantially the same as a dispute
previously submitted by the consumer in writing within the
validation period for which the debt collector has already satisfied
the requirements of Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i) is not a duplicative
dispute if the consumer provides new and material information to
support the dispute. Information is new if the consumer did not
provide the information when submitting an earlier dispute.
Information is material if it is reasonably likely to change the
verification the debt collector provided or would have provided in
response to the earlier dispute. The following example illustrates
the rule:
i. ABC debt collector is collecting a debt from a consumer and
sends the consumer a validation notice. In response, the consumer
submits a written dispute to ABC debt collector within the
validation period asserting that the consumer does not owe the debt.
The consumer does not include any information in support of the
dispute. Pursuant to Sec. 1006.38(d)(2)(i), ABC debt collector
provides the consumer a copy of verification of the debt. The
consumer then sends a cancelled check showing the consumer paid the
debt. The cancelled check is new and material information.
38(d) Disputes.
38(d)(2) Response to disputes.
Paragraph 38(d)(2)(ii).
1. Duplicative dispute notice. Section 1006.38(d)(2)(ii)
provides that, in the case of a dispute that a debt collector
reasonably determines is a duplicative dispute, the debt collector
must cease collection of the debt, or any disputed portion of the
debt, until the debt collector notifies the consumer that the
dispute is duplicative or provides a copy either of verification of
the debt or of a judgment to the consumer. If the debt collector
notifies the consumer that the dispute is duplicative, Sec.
1006.38(d)(2)(ii) requires that the notice provide a brief statement
of the reasons for the debt collector's determination that the
dispute is duplicative and refer the consumer to the debt
collector's response to the earlier dispute. A debt collector
complies with the requirement to provide a brief statement of the
reasons for its determination if the notice states that the dispute
is substantially the same as an earlier dispute submitted by the
consumer and the consumer has not included any new and material
information in support of the earlier dispute. A debt collector
complies with the requirement to refer the consumer to the debt
collector's response to the earlier dispute if the notice states
that the debt collector responded to the earlier dispute and
provides the date of that response.
Section 1006.42--Providing Required Disclosures
1. Deceased consumers. Section 1006.42 contains requirements
related to providing certain disclosures required by this part. If a
debt collector knows or should know that a consumer is deceased, a
person who is authorized to act on behalf of the deceased consumer's
estate operates as the consumer for purposes of Sec. 1006.42.
42(a) Providing required disclosures.
42(a)(1) In general.
1. Notice of undeliverability. Under Sec. 1006.42(a)(1), a debt
collector who provides disclosures required by this part in writing
or electronically must, among other things, do so in a manner that
is reasonably expected to provide actual notice. A debt collector
who provides a required disclosure in writing or electronically and
who receives a notice that the disclosure was not delivered has not
provided the disclosure in a manner that is reasonably expected to
provide actual notice under Sec. 1006.42(a)(1). See comment
34(b)(5)-1 for how to calculate the updated validation period when
sending a subsequent validation notice.
42(b) Requirements for certain disclosures provided
electronically.
Paragraph 42(b)(1).
1. Interpretation of the E-SIGN Act. Section 1006.42(b)(1)
constitutes the Bureau's interpretation of section 101 of the E-SIGN
Act as applied to section 809 of the FDCPA. Under this
interpretation, section 101(c) of the E-SIGN Act enables a debt
collector to satisfy the requirement in section 809(a) of the FDCPA
that the debt collector's notice be ``written,'' and to satisfy the
requirement in section 809(b) of the FDCPA that the debt collector
mail the consumer a copy of verification or a judgment, or the name
and address of the original creditor, through an electronic notice
if the consumer provides consent in accordance with the E-SIGN Act
directly to the debt collector.
Paragraph 42(b)(2).
1. Information identifying the debt. Under Sec. 1006.42(b)(2),
a debt collector who provides the validation notice described in
Sec. 1006.34(a)(1)(i)(B), or the disclosures described in Sec.
1006.38(c) or (d)(2), electronically must, among other things,
identify the purpose of the communication by including, in the
subject line of an email or in the first line of a text message
transmitting the disclosure, the name of the creditor to whom the
debt currently is owed or allegedly is owed and one additional piece
of information identifying the debt, other than the amount. The
following are examples of an additional piece of information, other
than amount, identifying a debt: a truncated account number; the
name of the original creditor; the name of any store brand
associated with the debt; the date of sale of a product or service
giving rise to the debt; the physical address of service; and the
billing mailing address on the account.
Paragraph 42(b)(4).
1. Disclosures responsive to smaller screens. Under Sec.
1006.42(b)(4), a debt collector who provides a validation notice
electronically must provide the disclosure in a responsive format
that is reasonably expected to be accessible on a screen of any
commercially available size and via commercially available screen
readers. A debt collector provides the validation notice in a
responsive format accessible on a screen of any commercially
available size if, for example, the notice adjusts to different
screen sizes by stacking elements in a manner that accommodates
consumer viewing on smaller screens while still meeting the other
applicable formatting requirements in Sec. 1006.34. A debt
collector provides the validation notice in a manner accessible via
commercially available screen readers if, for example, the
validation notice is machine readable.
42(c) Alternative procedures for providing certain disclosures
electronically.
Paragraph 42(c)(1).
1. Effect of consumer opt out. If a consumer has opted out of
debt collection communications to a particular email address or
telephone number by, for example, following instructions provided
pursuant to Sec. 1006.6(e), then a debt collector cannot use that
email address or telephone number to deliver disclosures under Sec.
1006.42(c).
Paragraph 42(c)(2).
Paragraph 42(c)(2)(i).
1. Body of an email. The alternative procedures in Sec.
1006.42(c) permit a debt collector to place a disclosure in the body
of an email. A debt collector places a disclosure in the body of an
email if the disclosure's content is viewable within the email
itself.
42(d) Notice and opportunity to opt out of hyperlinked delivery.
1. Communication covering multiple disclosures. A debt
collector's or a creditor's communication with a consumer pursuant
to Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) or (2), respectively, applies to all
disclosures covered by Sec. 1006.42(a) that the debt collector
thereafter sends regarding that debt, unless the consumer later
designates that email address or, in the case of text messages, that
telephone number, as unavailable for the debt collector's use, such
as by opting out pursuant to the instructions required by Sec.
1006.6(e).
42(d)(1) Communication by the debt collector.
1. Name of the consumer. For purposes of a debt collector's
communication with the consumer under Sec. 1006.42(d)(1), the term
``name of the consumer'' has the same meaning as the term
``consumer's name'' under Sec. 1006.34(c)(2)(ii). See comment
34(c)(2)(ii)-1.
2. Debt collector communication covering multiple debts. If a
debt collector's communication with a consumer under Sec.
1006.42(d)(1) applies to multiple debts, Sec. 1006.42(d)(1)(i) and
(ii) require the debt collector to identify the consumer and the
creditor for each debt to which the communication applies.
3. Form of communication with consumer before hyperlinked
delivery. A debt collector's communication with the consumer under
Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) must inform the consumer of, among other things,
the consumer's ability to opt out of hyperlinked delivery of
disclosures to an email address or, in the case of text messages, to
a telephone number, and instructions for
[[Page 23418]]
opting out, including a reasonable period within which to opt out.
This communication must, among other things, take place before the
debt collector provides the hyperlinked disclosure, and the debt
collector must allow the consumer a reasonable period within which
to opt out. In an oral communication with the consumer, such as a
telephone or in-person conversation, the debt collector may require
the consumer to make an opt-out decision during that same
communication. However, a written or electronic communication that
requires the consumer to make an opt-out decision within a period of
five or fewer days does not meet these timing criteria. Therefore,
when using hyperlinked delivery for the validation notice required
by Sec. 1006.34, an oral communication, such as a telephone
conversation or in-person conversation, is necessary under Sec.
1006.42(d)(1).
4. Combined notice concerning electronic communications and
electronic delivery of disclosures. An opt-out notice provided by a
debt collector under Sec. 1006.42(d)(1) may be combined with an
opt-out notice provided by the debt collector under Sec.
1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1). See comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-3.
42(d)(2) Communication by the creditor.
1. Creditor communication covering multiple debts. A creditor's
communication with the consumer under Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) may apply
to multiple debts being placed with or sold to the same debt
collector at the same time.
2. Form of communication with consumer before hyperlinked
delivery. A creditor's communication with the consumer under Sec.
1006.42(d)(2) must inform the consumer of, among other things, the
consumer's ability to opt out of hyperlinked delivery of disclosures
to an email address or, in the case of a text message, to a
telephone number, and instructions for opting out, including a
reasonable period within which to opt out. This communication must,
among other things, take place no more than 30 days before the debt
collector's electronic communication containing the hyperlink to the
disclosure, and the creditor must allow the consumer a reasonable
period within which to opt out. In an oral communication with the
consumer, such as a telephone or in-person conversation, the
creditor may require the consumer to make an opt-out decision during
that same communication. However, a written or electronic
communication that requires the consumer to make an opt-out decision
within a period of five or fewer days does not meet these timing
criteria.
3. Combined notice concerning electronic communications and
electronic delivery of disclosures. An opt-out notice provided by a
creditor under Sec. 1006.42(d)(2) may be combined with an opt-out
notice provided by the creditor under Sec. 1006.6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1).
See comment 6(d)(3)(i)(B)(1)-3.
42(e) Safe harbors.
42(e)(1) Disclosures provided by mail.
1. Consumer's residential address. Section 1006.42(e)(1)
provides that a debt collector satisfies Sec. 1006.42(a) if the
debt collector mails a printed copy of a disclosure to the
consumer's residential address, unless the debt collector receives a
notification from the entity or person responsible for delivery that
the disclosure was not delivered. For purposes of Sec.
1006.42(e)(1), a disclosure is not mailed to the consumer's
residential address if the debt collector knows or should know at
the time of mailing that the consumer does not currently reside at
that location.
42(e)(2) Validation notice contained in the initial
communication.
1. Effect of consumer opt out. If a consumer has opted out of
debt collection communications to a particular email address by, for
example, following the instructions provided pursuant to Sec.
1006.6(e), then a debt collector cannot use that email address to
deliver disclosures under Sec. 1006.42(e)(2).
Subpart C--[Reserved]
Subpart D--Miscellaneous
Section 1006.100--Record Retention
1. Evidence of required actions. Section 1006.100 requires a
debt collector to retain evidence of compliance with this part.
Thus, under Sec. 1006.100, a debt collector must retain evidence
that the debt collector performed the actions and made the
disclosures required by this part. For example, a debt collector
could retain:
i. Telephone call logs as evidence that the debt collector
complied with the frequency limits in Sec. 1006.14; and
ii. Copies or records of documents provided to the consumer as
evidence that the debt collector provided the information required
by Sec. Sec. 1006.34 and 1006.38 and met the delivery requirements
of Sec. 1006.42.
2. Methods of retaining records. Retaining records that are
evidence of compliance with this part does not require retaining
actual paper copies of documents. The records may be retained by any
method that reproduces the records accurately (including computer
programs) and that ensures that the debt collector can easily access
the records (including a contractual right to access records
possessed by another entity).
3. Recorded telephone calls. Nothing in Sec. 1006.100 requires
a debt collector to record telephone calls. However, under Sec.
1006.100, a debt collector who records telephone calls must retain
the recordings if the recordings are evidence of compliance with
this part.
Section 1006.104--Relation to State Laws
1. State law disclosure requirements. A disclosure required by
applicable State law that describes additional protections under
State law does not contradict the requirements of the Act or the
corresponding provisions of this part.
Dated: May 6, 2019.
Kathleen L. Kraninger,
Director, Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.
[FR Doc. 2019-09665 Filed 5-20-19; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4810-AM-P