[Federal Register Volume 83, Number 245 (Friday, December 21, 2018)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 65601-65609]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2018-27663]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
17 CFR Parts 210, 230, 239, 240, 243, and 249
[Release No. 33-10588; 34-84842; File No. S7-26-18]
Request for Comment on Earnings Releases and Quarterly Reports
AGENCY: Securities and Exchange Commission.
ACTION: Request for comment.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Commission is requesting public comment on how we can
enhance, or at a minimum maintain, the investor protection attributes
of periodic disclosures while reducing administrative and other burdens
on reporting companies associated with quarterly reporting. We are
specifically requesting public comment on the nature and timing of the
disclosures that reporting companies are required to provide in their
quarterly reports filed on Form 10-Q, including when the disclosure
requirements overlap with disclosures these companies voluntarily
provide to the public in the form of an earnings release furnished on
Form 8-K. We are interested in exploring ways to promote efficiency in
periodic reporting by reducing unnecessary duplication in the
information that reporting companies disclose and how such changes
could affect capital formation, while enhancing, or at a minimum
maintaining, appropriate investor protection. We also are requesting
public comment on whether our rules should provide reporting companies,
or certain classes of reporting companies, with flexibility as to the
frequency of their periodic reporting. In addition, we are seeking
comment on how the existing periodic reporting system, earnings
releases, and earnings guidance, standing alone or in combination with
other factors, may affect corporate decision making and strategic
thinking--positively or negatively--including whether these factors
foster an inefficient outlook among registrants and market participants
by focusing on short-term results, sometimes referred to as ``short-
termism.''
DATES: Comments should be received by March 21, 2019.
ADDRESSES: Comments may be submitted by any of the following methods:
Electronic Comments
Use the Commission's internet comment form (http://www.sec.gov/rules/other.shtml); or
Send an email to [email protected]. Please include
File Number S7-26-18 in the subject line.
Paper Comments
Send paper comments to Brent J. Fields, Secretary,
Securities and Exchange Commission, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC
20549-1090.
All submissions should refer to File Number S7-26-18. This file number
should be included in the subject line if email is used. To help the
Commission process and review your comments more efficiently, please
use only one method. The Commission will post all comments on the
Commission's website (http://www.sec.gov/rules/other.shtml). Comments
also are available for website viewing and printing in the Commission's
Public Reference Room, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC 20549, on
official business days between the hours of 10:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m.
All comments received will be posted without change. Persons submitting
comments are cautioned that we do not redact or edit personal
identifying information from comment submissions. You should submit
only information that you wish to make publicly available.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Courtney L. Lindsay, Attorney-Adviser,
or Lilyanna L. Peyser, Special Counsel at (202) 551-3430, Division of
Corporation Finance, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC 20549.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
Overview of Quarterly Reporting
In addition to annual and current reports, companies subject to the
periodic reporting requirements under the Securities Exchange Act of
1934 (``Exchange Act''), other than foreign private issuers, must file
quarterly reports \1\ on Form 10-Q,\2\ which include interim financial
statements \3\ and other disclosure items.\4\ Form 10-Q is often
forward incorporated by reference into certain registration statements
under the Securities Act of 1933 (``Securities Act''), thereby avoiding
unnecessary duplication of information about an issuer's recent
financial results and material business developments that was
previously filed and remains available electronically on EDGAR.\5\ This
forward incorporation helps reduce the time and costs associated with
frequent updating of a registration statement to reflect such
developments. A company's Form 10-Q must comply with the requirements
of Sections 13(a) or 15(d) of the Exchange Act, as applicable, and is
subject to liability under Sections 10(b) and 18 of the Exchange Act
and Rule 10b-5 thereunder.\6\ In addition, in certain circumstances,
including in the offer and sale of securities, reporting companies,
affiliates, and underwriters may be subject to liability for their
[[Page 65602]]
disclosure in Form 10-Q under Sections 11, 12, and 17 of the Securities
Act.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ See 17 CFR 240.13a-13 and 17 CFR 240.15d-13.
\2\ 17 CFR 249.308a.
\3\ See 17 CFR 210.8-03 (``Rule 8-03'') and 17 CFR 210.10-01
(``Rule 10-01'').
\4\ Form 10-Q also requires a management's discussion and
analysis of financial condition and results of operations
(``Management's Discussion and Analysis''), along with disclosures
on quantitative and qualitative market risk, company disclosure
controls and procedures, legal proceedings, material changes to
previously disclosed risk factors, unregistered sales of equity
securities and the use of proceeds from such sales, defaults upon
senior securities, mine safety disclosures, and any information
required to be disclosed in a report on Form 8-K during the period
covered by the relevant 10-Q that was not reported.
\5\ See 17 CFR 230.415 (``Rule 415''), Item 12(a) of Part I of
Form S-1 [17 CFR 239.11], and Item 12(a) of Part I of Form S-3 [17
CFR 239.13]. All documents, not just a Form 10-Q, subsequently filed
pursuant to Sections 13(a), 13(c), 14 or 15(d) of the Exchange Act
may be forward incorporated by reference on Form S-3. Smaller
reporting companies may forward incorporate by reference on Form S-1
all documents subsequently filed pursuant to Sections 13(a), 13(c),
14, or 15(d) of the Exchange Act.
\6\ 15 U.S.C. 78m; 15 U.S.C. 78o; 15 U.S.C. 78r; 15 U.S.C.
78j(b); and 17 CFR 240.10b-5. General Instruction F.1. of Form 10-Q
states that pursuant to Rule 13a-13(d) [17 CFR 240.13a-13(d)] and
Rule 15d-13(d) [17 CFR 240.15d-13(d)], the information presented to
satisfy the requirements of Part I Items 1, 2 and 3 shall not be
deemed filed for purposes of Section 18 of the Exchange Act or
otherwise subject to the liability of that section, but shall be
subject to other provisions of the Exchange Act. Further, companies
must submit their Form 10-Q financial statement disclosures in the
eXtensible Business Reporting Language (``XBRL'') format, and these
XBRL structured financial statement disclosures are subject to the
same disclosure liability. See 17 CFR 229.601(b)(101) (``Item
601(b)(101) of Regulation S-K''). The Commission recently adopted
amendments requiring Inline XBRL, a newer XBRL technology, with
phased compliance dates depending on filer status: Large accelerated
filers and accelerated filers that prepare their financial
statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP must comply with the
requirements for fiscal periods ending on or after June 15, 2019 and
June 15, 2020, respectively; all other filers must comply with the
requirements for fiscal periods ending on or after June 15, 2021.
See SEC Release No. 33-10514 (Sept. 17, 2018).
\7\ 15 U.S.C. 77k; 15 U.S.C. 77l; and 15 U.S.C. 77q. Each of
these provisions, which we reference throughout this Request for
Comment, imposes liability on companies in certain instances for
making any untrue statements of a material fact or omitting to state
a material fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in
the light of the circumstances under which they were made, not
misleading. Liability under certain of these provisions, such as
Sections 11 and 12 of the Securities Act and Section 18 of the
Exchange Act, attaches only to documents that are filed with the
Commission or incorporated by reference into a Securities Act
registration statement. For example, Section 11 liability can result
from disclosure in a Form 10-Q that is incorporated by reference
into a Securities Act registration statement. There are instances,
however, when liability may attach to documents that are not deemed
to be filed. For example, liability under Section 10(b) and Rule
10b-5 of the Exchange Act may attach to documents that are furnished
to, in addition to documents that are filed with, the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
By contrast, foreign private issuers \8\ subject to the periodic
reporting requirements of the Exchange Act are required to file annual
reports, but are not required to file quarterly reports.\9\ Foreign
private issuers are required to furnish reports on Form 6-K to the
extent that the ``issuer (i) makes or is required to make public
pursuant to the law of the jurisdiction of its domicile or in which it
is incorporated or organized, or (ii) files or is required to file with
a stock exchange on which its securities are traded and which was made
public by that exchange, or (iii) distributes or is required to
distribute to its security holders.'' \10\ Among other information
required to be furnished in this context, foreign private issuers must
disclose material information about changes in business, changes in
management or control, changes in the registrant's auditors,\11\ the
financial condition and results of operations, material legal
proceedings, and related party transactions.\12\ Foreign private
issuers are subject to liability for the disclosures they make in Form
6-K under Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5
thereunder.\13\ In addition, foreign private issuers, affiliates and
underwriters are subject to liability for the disclosures they make in
Form 6-K under Sections 11, 12, and 17 of the Securities Act \14\ to
the extent the Form 6-K is incorporated by reference into a Securities
Act registration statement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ A foreign private issuer is any foreign issuer other than a
foreign government, except for an issuer that has more than 50% of
its outstanding voting securities held of record by U.S. residents
and any of the following: A majority of its officers or directors
are citizens or residents of the United States; more than 50% of its
assets are located in the United States; or its business is
principally administered in the United States. See 17 CFR 230.405
and 17 CFR 240.3b-4(c). Foreign private issuers with a class of
securities listed on the NYSE or NASDAQ must submit semi-annual
unaudited financial information under cover of Form 6-K within six
months following the end of the second fiscal quarter. See NYSE Rule
203.03 and NASDAQ Rule 5250(c)(2). Similarly, Item 8.A.5 of Form 20-
F requires a foreign private issuer to include interim financial
statements when its registration statement is dated more than nine
months after the end of the last audited financial year. In
addition, foreign private issuers may have more frequent reporting
requirements based on the laws of their home country.
\9\ Issuers conducting Tier 2 offerings under Regulation A also
are required to file annual and semi-annual reports, as well as
current reports, with the Commission, but are not required to file
quarterly reports. See 17 CFR 230.257(b).
\10\ 17 CFR 249.306.
\11\ Commission rules and forms use various terms to refer to
the accountant that is independent and performs the audit and review
of the registrant's financial statements as required by Regulation
S-X. For example, Rule 2-01 of Regulation S-X uses the term
``auditor'' interchangeably with ``certified public accountant,''
``public accounting firm,'' or ``public accountant.'' Form 6-K uses
the term ``certifying accountants.'' In this Request for Comment, we
refer to these accountants as ``auditors.''
\12\ 17 CFR 249.306.
\13\ 15 U.S.C. 78j; 17 CFR 240.10b-5.
\14\ 15 U.S.C. 77k; 15 U.S.C. 77l; 15 U.S.C. 77q.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are many jurisdictions and foreign exchanges that have
quarterly reporting requirements similar to the United States,
including Canada, Hong Kong and Japan.\15\ The European Union and other
jurisdictions, by contrast, recently developed requirements that differ
from those in the United States to address concerns about the frequency
of reporting. The evolution of reporting requirements in these
jurisdictions may inform the policy considerations presented by
potential changes to the United States reporting system. In 2004, the
European Union adopted the Transparency Directive (2004/109/EC), which
governs the ongoing disclosure requirements for companies whose
securities are listed on a European Economic Area (``EEA'')-regulated
market.\16\ The Transparency Directive required listed companies to
publish a quarterly report, known as the interim management statement
(``IMS'').\17\ Unlike a quarterly report on Form 10-Q, an IMS did not
require financial statements, but rather, needed to include only a
``general description of the [company's] financial position and
performance since the last half-yearly or annual report and [explain]
any material events and transactions that have since taken place.''
\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ See Hong Kong Stock Exchange Listing Rule 18.66, National
Instrument 51-102 Continuous Disclosure Obligations (Canada), and
Financial Instruments and Exchange Act (Act No. 25 of 1948) (Japan).
\16\ Directive 2004/109/EC on the Harmonisation of Transparency
Requirements in Relation to Information about Issuers Whose
Securities Are Admitted to Trading on a Regulated Market and
Amending Directive 2001/34/EC (Dec. 15, 2004) (OJ L 390, 31.12.2004,
p.38-57) (``Transparency Directive'').
\17\ A key argument in favor of quarterly reports was to
increase investor protection and investor confidence, as well as to
``close the transparency gap between the USA and the EU.'' See
Thomas Schleicher & Martin Walker, Are Interim Management Statements
Redundant? 233 (Mar. 2015), available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00014788.2014.1002444 (``Are Interim Management Statements
Redundant?''). Prior to the Transparency Directive, most European
Union member states required only semi-annual and annual reports,
although several countries required quarterly reports, specifically:
Finland, Greece, Portugal, Sweden, Italy, and Spain.
\18\ See Transparency Directive, supra note 16. Commentators
observed that ``IMSs are lightly regulated trading statements with
management retaining considerable control over form and content''
and that ``the issuer can choose which financial statement line
item, if any, to comment on . . . .'' See Are Interim Management
Statements Redundant?, supra note 17.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2013, the EU adopted the Revised Directive on transparency
requirements (2013/50/EU), or the Revised Transparency Directive, which
abolished the requirement to publish IMSs.\19\ Although a report that
preceded the Revised Transparency Directive noted that IMSs were
generally well-perceived by market participants,\20\ the Revised
Transparency Directive noted that the IMSs were a burden for small and
medium-sized issuers \21\ without being necessary for investor
[[Page 65603]]
protection.\22\ Furthermore, the IMSs were thought to encourage a focus
on short-term performance and discourage long-term investment.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ Directive 2013/50/EU Amending Directive 2004/109/EC on the
Harmonisation of Transparency Requirements in Relation to
Information About Issuers Whose Securities are Admitted to Trading
on a Regulated Market, Directive 2003/71/EC on the Prospectus to be
Published When Securities are Offered to the Public or Admitted to
Trading and Commission Directive 2007/14/EC Laying Down Detailed
Rules for the Implementation of Certain Provisions of Directive
2004/109/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22
October 2013 Amending Directive 2004/109/EC, (Oct. 22, 2013) (OJ L
294, 6.11.2013, p. 13-27). This followed the 2010 European
Commission report reviewing the operation of the Transparency
Directive, which considered whether quarterly disclosures
contributed to undue focus on near-term results. The report noted
that abolishing the quarterly information requirement would
alleviate pressure on issuers and establish incentives for a longer-
term vision. See Report from the Commission to the Council, the
European Parliament, the European Economic and Social Committee and
the Committee of the Regions--Operation of Directive 2004/109/EC on
the Harmonisation of Transparency Requirements in Relation to
Information About Issuers Whose Securities are Admitted to Trading
on a Regulated Market (May 27, 2010) (SEC 611) (``EU Commission
Report'').
\20\ See EU Commission Report, supra note 19.
\21\ See Commission Recommendation of 6 May 2003 Concerning the
Definition of Micro, Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises, (May 5,
2003) (OJ L 124 20.5.2003, p. 36-41) (defining ``micro,'' ``small''
and ``medium-sized'' enterprises as ``enterprises which employ fewer
than 250 persons and which have an annual turnover not exceeding EUR
50 million, and/or an annual balance sheet total not exceeding EUR
43 million'' and further clarifying that ``small'' enterprises as
those that ``[employ] fewer than 50 persons and whose annual
turnover and/or annual balance sheet total does not exceed EUR 10
million.'').
\22\ See Revised Transparency Directive, supra note 19 at 13
(``The obligations to publish interim management statements or
quarterly financial reports represent an important burden for many
small and medium-sized issuers whose securities are admitted to
trading on regulated markets, without being necessary for investor
protection.'').
\23\ See the Revised Transparency Directive at 13 (``Those
obligations also encourage short-term performance and discourage
long-term investment. In order to encourage sustainable value
creation and long-term oriented investment strategy, it is essential
to reduce short-term pressure on issuers and give investors an
incentive to adopt a longer term vision. The requirement to publish
interim management statements should therefore be abolished.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the Revised Transparency Directive, a European Union member
state may require issuers to publish additional periodic financial
information on a more frequent basis than the annual or half-yearly
reports only under specific conditions.\24\ Companies may nonetheless
publish quarterly information on a voluntary basis.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\ Specifically, more frequent reporting may be instituted if,
after an assessment of the impacts, it is shown that such additional
requirement does not lead to (a) an excessive focus on short-term
results and performance of the issuers and (b) to a negative impact
on the access of small and medium sized issuers to regulated
markets.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, effective November 7, 2014, the Financial Conduct
Authority (``FCA'') of the United Kingdom \25\ eliminated IMS
requirements. Issuers are permitted to continue to publish IMSs on a
voluntary basis, but the FCA does not treat them as regulated
information.\26\ A 2017 market survey found that, in a sample of 516
U.K. companies, 471 (91.3%) continued issuing quarterly reports in
2015.\27\ A more recent analysis found that ``between October 2016 and
[August 2017], the number of [Financial Times Stock Exchange
(``FTSE'')] 100 companies issuing quarterly reports fell by nearly a
fifth, from 70 to 57. Among the FTSE 250, the figure fell by a quarter,
from 111 to 83.'' \28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\ The FCA is the conduct regulator for financial services
firms and financial markets in the United Kingdom and the prudential
regulator for many of those firms.
\26\ See Removing the Transparency Directive's Requirement to
Publish Interim Management Statements, Financial Conduct Authority
(Nov. 2014), available at https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/policy/ps14-15.pdf.
\27\ See Suresh Nallareddy, Robert Pozen & Shivaram Rajgopal,
Consequences of Mandatory Quarterly Reporting: The U.K. Experience,
Columbia Business School Research Paper No. 17-33 (Mar. 1, 2017),
available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2817120 (the survey also
found evidence that the companies that ceased issuing quarterly
reports were smaller than average, were less likely to provide
marginal guidance in mandatory reporting, and were more likely to be
in the energy industry). See also PricewaterhouseCoopers' survey on
quarterly reporting for listed companies and transition to IFRS 16
(Nov. 9, 2017), available at https://www.pwc.no/no/publikasjoner/kapitalmarkedstjenester/PwC-survey-quarterly-reporting-listed-companies-and-transition-ifrs-16.pdf (finding that 5% of surveyed
companies stated that they would not continue to report quarterly or
had not yet made a decision).
\28\ Owen Walker, The Long and Short of the Quarterly Reports
Controversy, Financial Times (July 1, 2018), available at https://www.ft.com/content/e61046bc-7a2e-11e8-8e67-1e1a0846c475.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also note that a 2017 study found that when quarterly reporting
was no longer required of U.K. companies in 2014, there was no
significant difference between the levels of corporate investment of
the U.K. companies that stopped quarterly reporting and those that
continued quarterly reporting.\29\ There was, however, a general
decline in the analyst coverage of those companies that reduced the
frequency of reporting.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ See Robert Pozen, Suresh Nallareddy & Shivaram Rajgopal,
Impact of Reporting Frequency on UK Companies, CFA Institute
Research Foundation (Mar. 2017).
\30\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations on Quarterly Reporting and Earnings Release Practices
Many companies required to file Form 10-Q also voluntarily
communicate certain quarterly financial results through earnings
releases.\31\ Federal securities laws do not require reporting
companies to publish earnings releases, conduct earnings calls with
investors and analysts, or issue forward-looking earnings guidance.\32\
To the extent that a company makes such communications, neither the
disclosure of specific information, nor the structure of that
information, is regulated by the Commission. The Commission does,
however, regulate the presentation of certain financial measures by
reporting companies, including in their earnings releases.\33\ To the
extent that a company elects to make a public announcement or release
of earnings information,\34\ it must furnish the earnings release on
Form 8-K.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\ Among all Form 10-Qs filed with the Commission in calendar
year 2017, we estimate that 63% were accompanied by prior or
concurrent earnings releases furnished on Form 8-K. For Form 10-Qs
filed by S&P 500 and S&P 1500 Super Composite companies in calendar
year 2017, we estimate that 97% and 98%, respectively were
accompanied by prior or concurrent earnings releases furnished on
Form 8-K.
\32\ The term ``earnings release'' as used in this Request for
Comment means a public announcement or release by a company, or
person acting on its behalf, of material non-public information
regarding a company's results of operations or financial condition
for a completed quarterly or annual financial period. The
requirements of Item 2.02 of Form 8-K are triggered by the
disclosure of this information. Forward-looking information provided
by a company to its investors on a quarterly basis in a method other
than Form 8-K or Form 10-Q is referred to as ``forward-looking
earnings guidance'' or ``earnings guidance.''
\33\ See 17 CFR 244.100 and 17 CFR 229.10. In addition, earnings
releases and related communications are subject to the antifraud
provisions of the federal securities laws.
\34\ Generally, a company publishes an earnings release prior to
the occurrence of any associated conference call with investors and
analysts.
\35\ See Item 2.02 of Form 8-K [17 CFR 249.308]. Forms 8-K that
are furnished to, as opposed to filed with, the Commission are not
automatically incorporated into Securities Act registration
statements or subject to liability under Section 18 of the Exchange
Act; however, they are subject to liability under Section 10(b) and
Rule 10b-5 of the Exchange Act. An issuer also may choose to file,
rather than furnish, earnings release information on Form 8-K, for
example, in order to ensure that a registration statement currently
in use does not contain a material omission of the information
contained in an earnings release.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While some companies provide earnings releases in advance of the
corresponding Form 10-Q filings, many companies now issue earnings
releases concurrently with their Form 10-Q filings.\36\ Given the
potential overlap between the financial information provided in the
earnings release and the Form 10-Q, some market participants view the
Form 10-Q primarily as a compliance document that subsequently (or
concurrently) confirms the material information about the quarterly
period included in an earnings release issued before (or at the same
time as) the Form 10-Q.\37\ Other market participants, however, view
the Form 10-Q as distinct from earnings releases and as an
[[Page 65604]]
essential component of market transparency.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\ See Arif, Salman et. al. A Growing Disparity in Earnings
Disclosure Mechanisms: The Rise of Concurrently Released Earnings
Announcements and 10-Ks (June 6, 2018), Kelley School of Business
Research Paper No. 16-50, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2801701 (stating that ``the fraction of concurrent
[earnings releases and Form 10-Q filings] has increased from 20% in
2002 to more than 60% by 2015'') (``A Growing Disparity in Earnings
Disclosure Mechanisms'').
\37\ See The Promise of Market Reform, Nasdaq, (May 2017),
available at https://business.nasdaq.com/media/Nasdaq_Blueprint_to_Revitalize_Capital_Markets_April_2018_tcm5044-43175.pdf (stating that ``companies provide key data via an earnings
press release each quarter'' and that ``[f]or virtually all
investors, the press release is the quarterly report. Yet companies
are then required to file a formal Form 10-Q . . . which is complex,
time-consuming, and provides little additional actionable
information that cannot be found in the press release'') (``The
Promise of Market Reform''). See, also, Diamond, Colin J. and Irina
Yevmenenko, Earnings Releases and Earnings Calls, White & Case LLP
(2015), available at https://www.whitecase.com/sites/whitecase/files/files/download/publications/article-earnings-releases-and-earnings-calls.pdf (stating that ``earnings releases and calls are
among the most material announcements that reporting companies
make'' and ``often result in significant movements in a reporting
company's stock price,'' and that ``a company's stock price usually
is not affected by the filing of its Form 10-K or Form 10-Q
following a corresponding earnings release, because all material
information has already been disclosed in the earnings release'').
\38\ See, e.g., Jamie Dimon & Warren E. Buffett, Short-Termism
Is Harming the Economy: Public companies should reduce or eliminate
the practice of estimating quarterly earnings, Wall St. J. (Jun. 6,
2018) (``Dimon and Buffet WSJ Article''), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/short-termism-is-harming-the-economy-1528336801
(stating that the authors' misgivings about quarterly earnings
forecasts should not be misconstrued as opposition to quarterly and
annual reporting that offers a retrospective look at actual
reporting); Michael Posner, Why Quarterly Reporting Makes Business
Sense, Forbes (Aug. 17, 2018), available at https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelposner/2018/08/17/why-quarterly-reporting-from-business-makes-sense/#1416b5c67ed8 (discussing information that is
contained in the Form 10-Q that is distinct from what is providing
in an earnings release); Robert C. Pozen & Mark Roe, Keep Quarterly
Reporting, Brookings Institution (Sept. 5, 2018), available at
https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/keep-quarterly-reporting/
(opposing quarterly earnings guidance and expressing a belief that a
semi-annual reporting would not be beneficial).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Form 10-Q typically contains most, if not all, of the historical
information presented in an earnings release along with additional
information, such as the financial disclosures required by U.S. GAAP.
The information in Form 10-Q is typically provided in greater detail
than in an earnings release and is easier to machine process and
analyze, through the aggregation of results and comparison across
filers, because it is required to be structured in interactive data
format. While financial statements in Form 10-Q are unaudited,
Regulation S-X \39\ specifies that the interim financial statements
included in Form 10-Q must be reviewed by an auditor \40\ and U.S. GAAP
prescribes the form and content of interim financial statements.\41\ In
addition, the Form 10-Q requires certification by the principal
executive and financial officers of the reporting company.\42\ A Form
8-K, however, is not subject to such requirements. Some of the
potential changes and flexibility described in this Request for
Comment, therefore, may require coordination with standard-setters,
such as the FASB, PCAOB, as well as the stock exchanges and appropriate
quoting venues.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ Rules 8-03 and 10-01(d).
\40\ The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (``PCAOB'')
is generally the standard-setter for audit and review procedures in
the United States. The PCAOB's AS 4105, Reviews of Interim Financial
Information, addresses the auditor requirements for reviews of
interim financial information.
\41\ Financial Accounting Standards Board (``FASB'') Accounting
Standards Codification (``ASC'') 270: Interim Reporting also
provides recognition and measurement guidance for interim periods.
The Commission has designated the FASB as the private-sector
accounting standard setter for United States financial reporting
purposes. Section 108 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act amended Section 19
of the Securities Act to provide that the Commission ``may
recognize, as `generally accepted' for purposes of the securities
laws, any accounting principles established by a standard setting
body that met certain criteria.'' The Commission has determined that
the FASB satisfies the criteria in Section 19 and, accordingly, the
FASB's financial accounting and reporting standards are recognized
as ``generally accepted'' for purposes of the federal securities
laws. See Policy Statement: Reaffirming the Status of the FASB as a
Designated Private-Sector Standard Setter, Release No. 33-8221 (Apr.
25, 2003) [68 FR 23333 May 1, 2003].
\42\ 17 CFR 240.13a-14 (``Rule 13a-14'') and 17 CFR 240.15d-14
(``Rule 15d-14''). These rules require the certifying officers to
certify, among other things, that they have reviewed the Form 10-Q
and that based on their knowledge: (i) The 10-Q does not contain any
untrue statement of material fact or omit to state a material fact
necessary to make any statements made, in light of the circumstances
under which such statements were made, not misleading with respect
to the period covered by the 10-Q; and (ii) the financial
statements, and other financial information included in the 10-Q,
fairly present in all material respects the financial condition,
results of operations and cash flows of the company as of, and for,
the periods presented in the 10-Q.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Purpose of Request for Comment
The purpose of this Request for Comment is to solicit public input
on the nature, timing, format and frequency of periodic reporting, as
well as the relationship between the periodic reports that Exchange Act
reporting companies must provide and the earnings releases that they
must furnish on Form 8-K, to the extent they choose to issue such
releases. We seek to understand how we might simplify the process by
which investors access, process, and evaluate information, for example,
by relieving any burdens associated with investors' efforts to compare
an earnings release and Form 10-Q to identify information that is new
or different. We also are interested in exploring how we might enhance,
or at a minimum maintain, the investor protection benefits of
disclosure, while reducing the costs (including time) \43\ that
companies spend complying with quarterly reporting requirements. For
example, we seek comment on the potential benefits and drawbacks of
providing an option for companies that issue earnings releases to use
the releases to satisfy the core disclosure requirements of Form 10-Q.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\43\ See The Promise of Market Reform, supra note 37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we are seeking comment on how the periodic reporting
system, earnings releases, and earnings guidance may affect corporate
decision making and strategic thinking--positively and negatively--
including whether it fosters an inefficient outlook among registrants
and market participants by focusing on short-term results. For example,
some market participants have urged companies to ``move away from
providing'' earnings per share guidance that companies give and instead
put more focus in Form 10-Qs on demonstrating progress made against the
company's long-term strategic plan.\44\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\ Matt Turner, Here is the Letter the World's Largest
Investor, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink, Just Sent to CEOs Everywhere,
Business Insider (Feb. 2, 2016) (``2016 Fink Letter to CEOs''),
available at https://www.businessinsider.com/blackrock-ceo-larry-fink-letter-to-sp-500-ceos-2016-2 (affirming support of quarterly
reports and stating that companies should stop publishing earnings
per share guidance to encourage a focus on a company's long-term
plans for value creation). See also Dimon and Buffet WSJ Article,
supra note 38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the past, the Commission has received input related to some of
the issues discussed in this Request for Comment.\45\ Most recently, we
requested comment on issues related to the frequency of reporting in
our Concept Release on business and financial disclosure requirements
in Regulation S-K (``Concept Release'').\46\ As we continue to evaluate
this topic, we are soliciting additional input from the public on
issues related to the nature, timing, format, and frequency of
reporting in the context of the more narrow scope of this Request for
Comment. The Commission encourages commenters to provide any data and
information that could help us quantify the effects of the approaches
discussed herein on capital formation and investor protection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\45\ See, e.g., Final Report of the Advisory Committee on
Improvements to Financial Reporting to the United States Securities
and Exchange Commission, Advisory Committee on Improvements to
Financial Reporting, (Aug. 1, 2008), available at https://www.sec.gov/about/offices/oca/acifr/acifr-finalreport.pdf. See also,
e.g., Final Rule: Conditions for Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures,
Release No. 33-8176; 34-47226 (Jan. 22, 2003), available at https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/33-8176.htm.
\46\ See Business and Financial Disclosure Required by
Regulation S-K, Release No. 33-10064; 34-77599 (Apr. 13, 2016) [81
FR 23916 (Apr. 22, 2016)], available at https://www.sec.gov/rules/concept/2016/33-10064.pdf. Comment letters related to the Concept
Release are available at https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-06-16/s70616.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Issues for Consideration
A. Information Content Resulting From the Quarterly Reporting Process
Certain material information required by Form 10-Q is frequently
provided in earnings releases. However, in our observation, there is
variation in the items and methods of presentation in earnings
releases. Companies often report certain financial (and statistical)
information such as net income, earnings per share, and net sales, and
some may include condensed income statements, balance sheets, and cash
flow statements along with segment information. This financial
information
[[Page 65605]]
is often accompanied by a narrative discussion of the financial
information provided. However, more detailed information that is
generally reported on Form 10-Q, such as the notes to the financial
statements, a detailed and comprehensive Management's Discussion and
Analysis, disclosure relating to contractual obligations and market
risk, and a description of material changes to previously disclosed
risk factors,\47\ typically does not appear in an earnings release.\48\
Information included in earnings releases sometimes does not appear in
a Form 10-Q. For example, management may provide its expectations of
the company's future financial performance or ``forward-looking
earnings guidance'' in the earnings release or on the quarterly
earnings call.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\47\ Pursuant to Rule 13a-13(d) and Rule 15d-13(d), the
information presented to satisfy the requirements of Part I Items 1,
2 and 3 shall not be deemed filed for purposes of Section 18 of the
Exchange Act or otherwise subject to the liability of that section,
but shall be subject to other provisions of the Exchange Act.
\48\ In our observation, the financial information contained in
earnings releases is not ordinarily presented in a manner that
constitutes interim financial statements pursuant to Rules 8-03 and
10-01. We also note that Rule 10-01(a)(5) includes a presumption
that users of the interim financial information have read or have
access to the audited financial statements for the preceding fiscal
year. Further, it permits the omission of certain footnote
disclosures that substantially duplicates the disclosure contained
in the most recent annual report to shareholders or audited
financial statements.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Request for Comment
1. Why do reporting companies choose to issue earnings releases,
most typically quarterly? What are the costs to such companies in
preparing earnings releases? Would companies choose to stop issuing
these releases if disclosure of quarterly results was not required on
Form 10-Q, or would this provide a greater incentive to issue them? Why
do some companies choose to file only a Form 10-Q report and not to
issue a separate earnings release?
2. Do quarterly earnings releases provide benefits to investors,
companies, or the marketplace separate and apart from the Form 10-Q
report? If so, please describe the primary benefits. How do investors
use earnings guidance to inform their investment decisions? To the
extent there are benefits, do they stem largely from the content of the
releases, their timing, or other reasons? Do they have any negative
effects on investors, companies, or the marketplace? If so, please
describe such effects.
3. How do companies determine the information to present in the
earnings release? Is there a market standard, or are companies
otherwise generally consistent in the type and amount of information
they present in earnings releases? To what extent is the content of
earnings releases provided in response to investor and analyst needs or
demands? Are such releases satisfying those needs? How would the
content of earning releases change if they were required to be filed
with the Commission and become subject to applicable liability
provisions?
4. Is the Form 10-Q or the earnings release the primary document
upon which investors rely when a company provides both? What are the
factors or circumstances that an investor considers when determining
which document to rely on? Are there any benefits to investors and
other market participants from having two sources of historical
quarterly financial information, when only one is required? How do
investors use quarterly financial information, and how does it inform,
if at all, their investments decisions made throughout the year? Are
there specific pieces of quarterly information that are important to
long-term investors?
5. Are there meaningful differences between the financial
information typically provided in an earnings release and the financial
information required by Form 10-Q? What accounts for the differences?
6. When a company issues an earnings release that includes much of
the information required by Form 10-Q before the form is filed, is the
Form 10-Q still useful? Why or why not? How important to investors is
the confirmation or interpretation by the Form 10-Q of the information
in the earnings release? If investors rely on Form 10-Q as the primary
document, is the historical financial information about the quarterly
period included in the earnings release useful? Why or why not? Does
the fact that Form 10-Qs are filed as opposed to furnished, and include
certifications, impact the extent to which investors rely on them? \49\
Are there any instances when information disclosed in earnings releases
may be useful to investors for purposes of interpreting the content of
Form 10-Q? If so, when and how?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\ See General Instruction F of Form 10-Q.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Does confusion arise from overlapping disclosures in the
earnings release and Form 10-Q? If so, are there changes we could make
to our rules that would discourage the practice of providing earnings
releases that contain information that is different than what is
contained in Form 10-Q? Are there unnecessary burdens to investors or
other market participants associated with reviewing, comparing, and
digesting two presentations of similar financial information?
8. Some have suggested that the practice of providing quarterly
forward-looking earnings guidance creates an undue focus on short-term
financial results and thereby negatively affects the ability of
companies to focus on long-term results.\50\ Is this the case and, if
so, are there changes we could make to our rules that would discourage
this practice or address this concern? For example, should we require
that earnings guidance be filed with or furnished to the Commission?
Are there other factors that promote a focus on short-term results? If
so, what are they and what is their impact on investors and companies?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\50\ See, e.g., Dimon and Buffet WSJ Article, supra note 38
(stating that public companies should move ``away from providing
quarterly earnings-per-share guidance'' because it ``often leads to
an unhealthy focus on short-term profits at the expense of long-term
strategy, growth and sustainability''); 2016 Fink Letter to CEOs,
supra note 44 (noting that ``CEOs should be more focused in these
reports on demonstrating progress against their strategic plans than
a one-penny deviation from their EPS targets or analyst consensus
estimates''). See also, e.g., Darr, Rebecca and Tim Killer, How to
Build an Alliance Against Corporate Short-Termism, McKinsey &
Company (Jan. 2017), available at https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/how-to-build-an-alliance-against-corporate-short-termism (stating that longer-
term investors, who have ``an outsize influence on a company's share
price over time'' due to their ownership of seven in ten shares of
U.S. companies, ``generally oppose earnings guidance, especially
quarterly guidance'' and ``don't like quarterly calls and find them
a waste of time'' due to the quality of the calls).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. What are the specific benefits of the required Form 10-Q
disclosures to investors and the marketplace separate and apart from
the earnings releases? Do they stem largely from the incremental
financial statement disclosures, incremental management discussion and
analysis, auditor review, officer certificates or other items? Are
there sections of the Form 10-Q that are particularly informative for
investors? Are there any quarterly disclosure requirements that we
should eliminate because they elicit disclosures that are not material
to investors to make it easier for investors to focus on the
disclosures that are material? If so, which requirements should be
eliminated?
10. Do the XBRL requirements of Form 10-Q enhance accessibility
and/or usability of quarterly information relative to what is available
from earnings releases, which are not required to be structured for
machine readability or processing? \51\ If so, how is
[[Page 65606]]
that information used and by whom? Would similar benefits be achieved
if companies structured earnings releases using XBRL? Why or why not?
How would the costs of structuring earnings releases in XBRL compare to
the costs of complying with the XBRL requirements for Form 10-Q?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\51\ See Item 601(b)(101) of Regulation S-K. See also Ken
Tysiac, Driving Faster Decisions, Journal of Accountancy (Apr. 13,
2015), available at https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/issues/2015/apr/data-driven-auditing.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. What is the impact of the auditor review requirement of
quarterly financial information on investors, companies, and other
market participants? Do investors value the independent auditor review
of quarterly financial information? Why or why not? Does the auditor
review requirement have a relationship to the cost of capital for
companies? If so, how?
12. What are the cost burdens associated with the preparation of a
Form 10-Q? Are these cost burdens borne solely from the preparation of
the Form 10-Q? How do the costs of preparation vary among different
sections of the report? Would there be costs to a company to the extent
it does not file a Form 10-Q? Would additional cost burdens be
associated with the preparation of a registration statement in which a
company would otherwise incorporate by reference a previously filed
Form 10-Q?
13. Are there other sources of information investors use to
supplement information from earnings releases or quarterly reports? If
so, please describe these sources.
14. Are there approaches the Commission should consider to help
alleviate any burden associated with the preparation of a Form 10-Q
without adversely affecting the total mix of information provided to
investors? For example, should we permit companies to omit certain
disclosures currently furnished on Form 10-Q, such as unregistered
sales of securities, so long as the information is provided elsewhere,
such as on their websites? If so, should the information provided
elsewhere be expressly incorporated by reference into the Form 10-Q,
such that the same liability attaches to the disclosure of that
information? What would be the benefits and drawbacks to investors and
other market participants of such additional flexibility?
B. Timing of the Quarterly Reporting Process
Some companies issue an earnings release prior to filing the
associated Form 10-Q,\52\ though, as noted above, many companies now
issue earnings releases concurrently with the filing of these forms.
While we did not specifically solicit comment in the Concept Release on
issues related to earnings releases, some commenters nonetheless
provided input on this topic.\53\ One commenter suggested requiring
registrants to file Form 10-Q simultaneously with any earnings release
filed or furnished on Form 8-K, on the ground that this would help
investors to be more informed and better able to address issues with
management on earnings calls.\54\ Other commenters suggested requiring
the Form 10-Q to be filed prior to earnings releases and earnings calls
to allow analysts to digest U.S. GAAP disclosures before receiving
earnings release information, which may include non-U.S. GAAP
disclosures.\55\ Finally, one commenter suggested that structured
reporting in XBRL format is most effective when it is applied broadly
to all aspects of reporting, including earnings releases.\56\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\52\ See A Growing Disparity in Earnings Disclosure Mechanisms.
\53\ See Concept Release at 280.
\54\ See letter from R.G. Associates, Inc. (July 6, 2016).
\55\ See letters from Council of Institutional Investors (July
8, 2016), Railpen Investments (July 21, 2016), and California State
Teachers' Retirement System (July 21, 2016).
\56\ See letter from CFA Institute (Oct. 6, 2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Request for Comment
15. One study indicates that the ``average public company needed
31.7 days to announce its earnings . . . and another four days after
that to file its formal quarterly report.'' \57\ The study finds that
companies that release both documents on the same day tend to ``take
more time to deliver those pronouncements,'' while companies that
publish an earnings release ``soon after the end of the quarter take
more time to file their quarterly report.'' \58\ Why do some companies
publish an earnings release before filing Form 10-Q while other
companies publish an earnings report and file Form 10-Q on the same day
or near the same time? Should the Commission take any action to address
time lapses between an earnings release and Form 10-Q, and if so, what
action? If the Commission should take action to facilitate a decrease
in this delay, what is the best mechanism to facilitate such a
decrease? Is it more or less burdensome to issue the two documents
concurrently?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\57\ How Long Does It Take to Announce Earnings? Calcbench, Inc.
(Oct. 20, 2016), available at https://www.calcbench.com/home/pdf?name=CB-EarningsDays-Advisory-20161027.pdf.
\58\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
16. What is the impact on investors and other market participants
participating in earnings calls when a company publishes its earnings
release before filing its Form 10-Q? Are investors or other market
participants disadvantaged at the time of the earnings call by not
having access to the more detailed information contained in the Form
10-Q? If so, what are those disadvantages? Do the same disadvantages
exist for the fourth quarter earnings release in comparison to the
filing of Form 10-K?
17. To what extent are auditors involved with earnings releases?
Does such involvement or the auditor review of the quarterly financial
statements contribute to any delay between publication of an earnings
release and the filing of a Form 10-Q? If so, how? What steps could or
should be taken to help ameliorate this delay? Do auditors conduct
their review of quarterly financial information in phases due to
companies' preparation of two reporting documents? If so, does this
result in efficiencies or inefficiencies based upon the nature of the
two disclosure documents?
C. Earnings Release as Core Quarterly Disclosure
The Commission is requesting comment on different ways to alleviate
burdens related to Form 10-Q reporting while maintaining investor
protection. Among other approaches, we are requesting comment on
whether we should provide an option for companies that issue earnings
releases to use the releases to satisfy the core financial disclosure
requirements of Form 10-Q. Under this option, a company would use its
Form 10-Q to supplement a Form 8-K earnings release with additional
material information required by the Form 10-Q not already presented in
the Form 8-K or alternatively incorporate by reference disclosure from
the Form 8-K earnings release into its Form 10-Q (the ``Supplemental
Approach''). For example, registrants that do not provide interim
financial statements in accordance with Regulation S-X \59\ in the
earnings release would be required to include them in the Form 10-Q
under the Supplemental Approach.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\59\ Item 1 of Form 10-Q requires interim financial statements
in accordance with Rule 8-03 or 10-01. These rules require
disclosures either on the face of the financial statements or in
accompanying footnotes sufficient so as to make the interim
information presented not misleading. ASC 270-10-50-1 also requires
certain disclosures that must be provided at a minimum when
reporting companies report summarized financial information at
interim dates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Request for Comment
18. To what extent do companies take advantage of General
Instructions D.1 and D.2 of Form 10-Q to satisfy the
[[Page 65607]]
requirements of Form 10-Q? \60\ What changes to our rules, if any,
would increase the use of these Instructions? Is the required quarterly
reporting process complex and burdensome for investors or companies? If
so, how is it complex and burdensome? If so, what approaches should we
consider apart from the Supplemental Approach (hereafter ``other
suggested approach'') to simplify the process by which investors
collect and evaluate information and ease the burdens associated with
the publication of earnings releases and the preparation and filing of
Form 10-Q without adversely affecting the total mix of information
provided to investors?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\60\ General Instruction D.1 of Form 10-Q permits companies to
incorporate information by reference from a document that meets some
or all of the requirements of Part I of Form 10-Q and General
Instruction D.2. directs registrants to Exchange Act Rule 12b-23
with respect to other information that may be incorporated by
reference in response to all or some of Part II of Form 10-Q.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
19. Should Commission rules, accounting standards, and auditing
standards allow for the interim financial statements to be separated so
that certain parts could be presented only in the earnings release to
satisfy the Form 10-Q requirements under the Supplemental Approach or
other suggested approach? For example, should a registrant be able to
present condensed interim income statements only in the earnings
release and the remaining Regulation S-X required interim statements
and footnotes in the Form 10-Q? What changes would be needed to the
current accounting and/or auditing standards to accomplish such
separation? Would separation of the financial statements help, harm, or
have no effect on an investor's ability to evaluate a company's
performance?
20. Should information in an earnings release that is submitted on
Form 8-K be allowed to satisfy the Form 10-Q requirements? Why or why
not, and if so to what extent? What are the potential benefits and
drawbacks to investors, companies, and other market participants of the
Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach?
21. If companies were permitted to omit from Form 10-Q information
already contained in a Form 8-K earnings release, what specific
information should they be allowed to omit? Is there any earnings
release information that should not be allowed to satisfy the
requirements of Form 10-Q? Would companies be likely to rely on the
Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach, if available? If so,
would certain types of companies benefit more from the Supplemental
Approach other suggested approach than others?
22. If we adopt the Supplemental Approach or other suggested
approach, should we require the relevant Form 8-K to be filed rather
than furnished? \61\ Should we further require the relevant Form 8-K to
be incorporated by reference into the Form 10-Q, in whole or in part?
Should we require a hyperlink from the Form 10-Q to the relevant Form
8-K? Should we require the relevant Form 8-K to include certain
disclosures that are otherwise required in Form 10-Q? If so, which
disclosures should be required and why?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\61\ The information required by Items 1 (Financial Statements),
2 (Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and
Results of Operations) and 3 (Quantitative and Qualitative
Disclosures About Market Risk) of Part I of the Form 10-Q is not
deemed to be filed for purposes of Section 18 of the Exchange Act,
but an issuer may choose to file, rather than furnish, earnings
release information on Form 8-K, for example, to ensure that a
registration statement currently in use does not contain a material
omission of the information contained in an earnings release.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
23. Are there issues or concerns with the above approaches in
relation to a registration statement and the ability to incorporate by
reference? If so, please describe. For example, should a company
relying on the Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach have
to incorporate by reference the historical financial information in its
earnings release into a Securities Act registration statement so that
Securities Act liability would apply to that information, just as such
liability applies to Form 10-Q information that is incorporated by
reference into a registration statement?
24. Would the Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach
affect the quantity, quality, or nature of the disclosure being made to
the public? If so, how? Would the Supplemental Approach or other
suggested approach simplify or complicate the process by which
investors collect and evaluate information? How would the Supplemental
Approach or other suggested approach affect investors' evaluation of
company performance? Overall, what impact would the Supplemental
Approach or other suggested approach have on investors?
25. Would the Supplemental Approach affect the timing of earnings
releases? If so, how? If we implement the Supplemental Approach or
other suggested approach, should we modify the due date of Form 10-Q?
Why or why not, and if so, how?
26. How should the Supplemental Approach or other suggested
approach take into consideration the XBRL requirements of Form 10-Q? If
information currently required to be structured using the XBRL format
on Form 10-Q were instead only disclosed in an unstructured format on
Form 8-K, would this adversely affect investors or other market
participants?
27. If an earnings release were used to satisfy the requirements of
Form 10-Q, should any financial statements included in an earnings
release be subject to auditor review procedures at the time the Form 8-
K is filed? Why or why not?
28. Would the Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach
reduce or add to companies' disclosure or auditor review burdens? How
should the Supplemental Approach other suggested approach take into
consideration the requirements regarding disclosure controls and
procedures set forth in Rules 13a-15 and 15d-15,\62\ as well as the
related officer certification requirements, which apply to Forms 10-Q
but not to earnings releases furnished on Form 8-K? \63\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\62\ 17 CFR 240.13a-15; 17 CFR 240.15d-15.
\63\ Rules 13a-14 and 15d-14.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
29. Does the Supplemental Approach or other suggested approach
raise concerns regarding a company's liability under the federal
securities laws? If so, please explain.
D. Reporting Frequency
As noted above, we previously solicited public input on issues
related to the frequency of interim reporting in connection with the
Concept Release. Prior to adoption of Form 10-Q in 1970,\64\ reporting
companies were not required to provide specific information on a
quarterly basis, other than to satisfy the requirements of Form 8-
K.\65\ However, as noted in the Concept Release, prior to the adoption
of Form 10-Q, more than 70% of public companies produced quarterly
reports,
[[Page 65608]]
partly in response to exchange listing standards.\66\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\64\ See SEC Release No. 34-9004 (Oct. 28, 1970).
\65\ Prior to the adoption of Form 9-K in 1955, reporting
companies were only required to provide limited information related
to quarterly results in response to requirements on Form 8-K. See
SEC Release No. 34-5129 (Jan. 27, 1955). With the adoption of Form
9-K, companies were required to report certain financial information
on a semi-annual basis. See SEC Release No. 34-5189 (June 23, 1955).
In 1969, the Commission proposed to rescind Form 9-K and adopt Form
10-Q for the reporting of quarterly financial and other information
based on the observation that ``Current Reports on Form 8-K [were]
not widely used by investors and their advisors. This may be because
these reports [were] not filed at regular intervals and they [were]
not truly current reports since they need not be filed until 10 days
after the end of a month in which a reportable event occurred.'' The
Commission reasoned that mandated quarterly reports may ``provide
detailed information as a back-up to information released pursuant
to timely disclosure policies.'' See SEC Release 34-8683 (Sept. 15,
1969).
\66\ See Concept Release at 281.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters' responses to this issue as set forth in the Concept
Release were mixed. Many commenters recommended a less-than-quarterly
reporting requirement, such as a semi-annual reporting requirement,
either for all companies or a subset of companies.\67\ A number of
commenters expressly opposed increasing the frequency of reporting,\68\
with many of these commenters noting the costs and burdens associated
with the current quarterly reporting regime as one reason for
opposition.\69\ Many other commenters, citing a wide variety of
reasons, specifically supported retaining quarterly reporting.\70\ Some
of these commenters recommended evaluating the content of quarterly
reports, rather than changing the frequency.\71\ Other commenters
suggested that semi-annual reporting may increase the risk of insider
trading by lengthening the time insiders would be unable to trade in
order to comply with the insider trading prohibitions of Section 10(b)
and Rule 10b-5.\72\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\67\ See letters from Dylan Schweitzer (Apr. 20, 2016); Legal &
General Investment Management (July 20, 2016); National Association
of Real Estate Investment Trusts (July 21, 2016); Eric Bormel (July
27, 2016); Ball Corporation (July 19, 2016); Frederick D. Lipman
(May 2, 2016); Ernst & Young LLP (July 21, 2016); American Council
of Life Insurers (July 19, 2016); Insured Retirement Institute (July
21, 2016); and Committee of Annuity Insurers (July 21, 2016).
\68\ See letters from American Bankers Association (July 15,
2016) (``American Bankers Association''); U.S. Chamber of Commerce
(July 20, 2016) (``Chamber''); FedEx Corporation (July 21, 2016)
(``FedEx''); Business Roundtable (July 21, 2016) (``BRT'');
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (July 21,
2016) (``SIFMA''); Allstate Insurance Company (July 21, 2016)
(``Allstate''); General Motors Company (Sept. 30, 2016); and
Financial Executives International (Oct. 3, 2016).
\69\ See letters from American Bankers Association; Chamber;
FedEx; BRT; SIFMA; and Allstate.
\70\ See letters from Sat Parashar (Apr. 20, 2016); A. Whigman
(May 4, 2016); SEC Investor Advisory Committee (June 15, 2016); R.G.
Associates, Inc. (July 6, 2016); US SIF and US SIF Foundation (July
14, 2016); New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants
(July 19, 2016); Investment Program Association (July 21, 2016);
Committee on Securities Law, Maryland State Bar Association (July
21, 2016) (``Maryland Bar Securities Committee''); AFL-CIO (July 21,
2016); Bloomberg LP (July 21, 2016); Stephen P. Percoco (July 24,
2016); National Investor Relations Institute (Aug. 4, 2016)
(``NIRI''); Institute of Management Accountants (July 29, 2016)
(``IMA''); Nasdaq Inc. (Sept. 16, 2016) (``Nasdaq''); and Northrop
Grumman Corporation (Sept. 27, 2016).
\71\ See letters from Nasdaq and IMA.
\72\ See letters from NIRI and Maryland Bar Securities
Committee.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We recognize that there is ongoing debate regarding the adequacy
and appropriateness of mandated quarterly reporting.\73\ As we continue
to evaluate the existing reporting frequency, we are soliciting
additional input on reporting frequency and what alternate approaches,
if any, should be considered that would appropriately address the
informational needs of investors while reducing the costs and other
burdens on registrants who provide that information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\73\ See, e.g., Zweig, Jason, The End of Quarterly Reporting?
Not Much to Cheer About, The Wall Street Journal (Aug. 17, 2018),
available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-end-of-quarterly-reporting-not-much-to-cheer-about-1534540127. See also, e.g.,
Whelan, Tensie, Trump is Right: Quarterly Earnings Reports Should
Go, CNN Money (Aug. 23, 2018), available at https://money.cnn.com/2018/08/23/news/trump-quarterly-reporting/index.html, and La Croix,
Kevin, Is It Time to End Quarterly Reporting? The D&O Diary (Aug.
19, 2018), available at https://www.dandodiary.com/2018/08/articles/corporate-governance/time-end-quarterly-reporting/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Request for Comment
30. What are the benefits and costs to investors, companies, and
other market participants associated with the current reporting
frequency model, which requires from domestic issuers quarterly reports
on Form 10-Q, annual reports on Form 10-K, and current reports on Form
8-K? Does the frequency of reporting lead managers to focus on short-
term results to the detriment of long-term performance? Why or why not?
If so, does this negatively affect investors? If so, how? Would less
frequent reporting change management decision-making or otherwise
positively affect investors? Or does the practice of issuing earnings
guidance, including the frequency with which companies issue earnings
guidance, lead managers to focus on short-term results to the detriment
of long-term performance? Why or why not? Would more frequent reporting
change management decision-making?
31. Should we move to a semi-annual reporting model for all or
certain categories of reporting companies? Why or why not, and to which
categories of reporting companies (e.g., smaller reporting companies,
non-accelerated filers, emerging growth companies)? Are there other
categories of reporting companies, such as by industry, that we should
consider? For example, are there any unique considerations we should
give to certain commodity trusts, business development companies, and
other collective investment vehicles? Would any other frequency of
reporting model be more appropriate for these or other types of
companies?
32. What would the costs and benefits be to investors, companies,
and other market participants of a semi-annual reporting model for all
or certain categories of reporting companies? Are there market
practices in place, for example contractually mandated reports to
lenders and indenture trustees, that rely on the current regulatory
reporting regime? If so, how would these market practices be affected
by changes to that regime and what are the downstream effects?
33. Would a change in reporting frequency affect the cost of
capital to companies? Why or why not, and if so, how?
34. How would a semi-annual reporting model affect the general use
of Form 8-K to report material information? Should we consider any
particular additional Form 8-K requirements or triggers under a semi-
annual reporting model? If so, what type(s)?
35. How would a semi-annual reporting model affect the use of
earnings releases? If we were to allow semi-annual reporting, should we
require voluntarily published earnings releases, either on a quarterly
or semi-annual basis, to be filed rather than furnished? Or, if we were
to allow semi-annual reporting, should we require companies to file
earnings releases?
36. Should we allow for additional flexibility by permitting
companies to select an approach to periodic reporting that best suits
their needs and the needs of their investors? For example, should we
allow a company conducting an initial public offering to announce its
approach to periodic reporting, such as semi-annual periodic reporting,
during registration and implement the elected approach going forward?
Should a company be permitted to change its approach to frequency of
reporting once it selects a reporting frequency? Why or why not? If it
is permitted to change the frequency of reporting after it has
established an approach, how often should the company be permitted to
change its reporting frequency?
37. What are the downstream effects of changing the reporting
frequency to investment companies, investment advisers, broker-dealers,
data aggregators, and other users of the reports?
38. Should an emerging growth company or smaller reporting company
be permitted to elect a semi-annual reporting frequency?
39. What would the costs and benefits be to investors, companies,
and other market participants of moving to a flexible reporting
frequency model (rather than a mandatory quarterly or mandatory semi-
annual model)? How would a flexible reporting frequency model (rather
than a mandatory
[[Page 65609]]
quarterly or mandatory semi-annual model) affect the ability of
investors, analysts, and other market participants to compare results
among companies, especially if companies in the same industry report on
different schedules? Would companies that choose to report more
frequently suffer adverse competitive consequences if peer companies
choose to report less frequently (e.g., because relative performance
and/or estimates of expected future cash flows would be measured on a
less frequent basis)? Alternatively, would companies that choose to
report more frequently benefit from their provision to investors of
more and more timely information about historical results?
40. What are the accounting and auditing changes that would be
necessary for a flexible reporting frequency model (rather than a
mandatory quarterly or mandatory semi-annual model)? For example, would
there be concerns with how to apply ASC 270 Interim Reporting in U.S.
GAAP or certain Regulation S-X disclosure requirements in a flexible
reporting frequency model? Would there be concerns with how to apply
auditing standards \74\ in relation to interim financial information,
including procedures performed in relation to letters for underwriters
and certain other requesting parties, in a flexible reporting frequency
model?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\74\ For example, would there be questions about how to apply
PCAOB AS 4105 and AS 6101, Letters for Underwriters and Certain
Other Requesting Parties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
41. What other topics may raise concerns or questions with
application under a flexible reporting model, and what are those
concerns or questions? Do these concerns and questions exist in the
current quarterly reporting model and would they still exist with a
mandatory semi-annual model?
42. Are existing U.S. GAAP taxonomies used for XBRL reporting
appropriate for a flexible reporting frequency model?
43. Should we limit such flexibility in reporting frequency to a
particular group of companies as an initial step before considering
whether to provide such an option to all companies? If so, which group
of companies and why? Should any potential election by a company be
limited to a specific period of time?
44. How would a move to either a mandatory or optional semi-annual
reporting model affect the current rules of self-regulatory
organizations and national securities exchanges? For example, would
exchanges still require quarterly reporting as a requirement of
listing, as they did prior to 1970 when Form 10-Q was adopted?
45. How would a move to either a mandatory or optional semi-annual
reporting model affect a company's ability to comply with current rules
relating to Securities Act offerings? For example, given that Form 10-Q
is often incorporated by reference into certain registration statements
under the Securities Act,\75\ how would a company that reports semi-
annually ensure that a registration statement currently in use does not
contain a material omission of information? For example, how would an
issuer ensure that a shelf registration statement on Form S-3 remains
current? Under a flexible approach, would companies nonetheless elect
to maintain a quarterly reporting model to avoid concerns about keeping
their Securities Act registration statements current? How would
companies meet the requirements regarding the age of financial
statements \76\ under Regulation S-X with respect to new registration
statements under such an approach? How would a change in reporting
frequency impact the Commission's integrated disclosure regime,
including, for example, determining issuer eligibility and the speed by
which a company may offer securities? How would a change in reporting
frequency impact companies who use reports filed in the United States
to satisfy state or international reporting requirements?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\75\ See Rule 415, Item 12(a) of Part I of Form S-1 [17 CFR
239.11], and Item 12(a) of Part I of Form S-3 [17 CFR 239.13].
\76\ See 17 CFR 230.3-12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
46. Are there additional approaches that we should consider to
better facilitate the dissemination of timely periodic information to
investors and other market participants?
IV. Closing
This request for comment is not intended to limit the scope of
comments, views, issues or approaches to be considered. In addition to
investors and companies, the Commission welcomes comment from other
market participants, in particular statistical, empirical and other
data from commenters that may support their views and/or support or
refute the views or issues raised.
By the Commission.
Dated: December 18, 2018.
Eduardo A. Aleman,
Deputy Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2018-27663 Filed 12-20-18; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P