[Federal Register Volume 83, Number 152 (Tuesday, August 7, 2018)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 38768-38936]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2018-15896]
[[Page 38767]]
Vol. 83
Tuesday,
No. 152
August 7, 2018
Part II
Securities and Exchange Commission
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
17 CFR Parts 232, 240, 242, et al.
Regulation of NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems; Final Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 83 , No. 152 / Tuesday, August 7, 2018 /
Rules and Regulations
[[Page 38768]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
17 CFR Parts 232, 240, 242, and 249
[Release No. 34-83663; File No. S7-23-15]
RIN 3235-AL66
Regulation of NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems
AGENCY: Securities and Exchange Commission.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Securities and Exchange Commission is adopting amendments
to regulatory requirements in Regulation ATS under the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934 (``Exchange Act'') applicable to alternative
trading systems (``ATSs'') that trade National Market System (``NMS'')
stocks (hereinafter referred to as ``NMS Stock ATSs''), including so
called ``dark pools.'' First, we are adopting new Form ATS-N, which
will require NMS Stock ATSs to disclose information about their manner
of operations, the broker-dealer that operates the ATS (``broker-dealer
operator''), and the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates. Second, as amended, the regulations will
require public posting of certain Form ATS-N filings on the
Commission's website, which will be accomplished through the
Commission's Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval system
(``EDGAR'') and require each NMS Stock ATS that has a website to post
on its website a direct URL hyperlink to the Commission's website.
Third, the amendments that we are adopting today provide a process for
the Commission to review Form ATS-N filings and, after notice and
opportunity for hearing, declare an NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N
ineffective. Fourth, the regulations, as amended, will require all ATSs
subject to the regulations to place in writing its safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information. We
are also adopting conforming amendments.
DATES:
Effective Date: October 9, 2018.
Compliance Dates: The applicable compliance dates are discussed in
the section of the release titled ``VIII. Effective Date and Compliance
Date.''
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Tyler Raimo, Senior Special Counsel,
at (202) 551-6227; Matthew Cursio, Special Counsel, at (202) 551-5748;
Marsha Dixon, Special Counsel, at (202) 551-5782; Jennifer Dodd,
Special Counsel, at (202) 551-5653; David Garcia, Special Counsel, at
(202) 551-5681; or Megan Mitchell, Special Counsel, at (202) 551-4887;
Office of Market Supervision, Division of Trading and Markets,
Securities and Exchange Commission, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC
20549-7010.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: We are adopting: (1) Amendments to 17 CFR
242.300 through 242.303 (``Regulation ATS'') to add new 17 CFR 242.304
(``Rule 304'') under the Exchange Act to provide new conditions for NMS
Stock ATSs seeking to rely on the exemption from the definition of
``exchange'' provided by 17 CFR 240.3a1-1(a) (``Rule 3a1-1(a)'') of the
Exchange Act; (2) new Form ATS-N \1\ under the Exchange Act, which NMS
Stock ATSs will file to comply with the new conditions provided under
Rule 304; and (3) related amendments to 17 CFR 242.300; 17 CFR 242.301,
17 CFR 242.303, and 17 CFR 240.3a1-1 under the Exchange Act
(respectively, ``Rule 300,'' ``Rule 301,'' and ``Rule 303'' of
Regulation ATS, and ``Rule 3a1-1''). We are also adopting amendments to
17 CFR 242.301(b)(10) and 17 CFR 242.303 (``Rules 301(b)(10) and 303 of
Regulation ATS'') under the Exchange Act to require all ATSs to make
and keep written safeguards and written procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ 17 CFR 249.640.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table of Contents
I. Introduction
II. Background
A. Role of ATSs in the Current Equity Market Structure
1. Significant Source of Liquidity for NMS Stocks
2. Operational Complexity; Conflict of Interests
B. Exemption for Alternative Trading Systems
C. Conditions to the ATS Exemption; Confidential Notice Regime
D. Concerns Regarding the Lack of Operational Transparency
III. Heightened Regulatory Requirements for NMS Stock ATSs
A. Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a) Exemption: New Conditions for NMS
Stock ATSs
1. Comments on the Rule 304 Requirements; Effectiveness
a. Comments on Form ATS-N Requirement
b. Comments on Effects on ATSs Relative to National Securities
Exchanges
c. Comments on Effectiveness Requirement
2. Comments on Extending Rule 304 to Non-NMS Stock ATSs
B. Amendments to Existing Regulation ATS Rules for NMS Stock
ATSs
1. Rule 300(k): Definition of NMS Stock ATS
2. Rule 301(a): Exemption From Compliance With Regulation ATS
3. Rule 301(a)(5): Exemptions From Certain Requirements of
Regulation ATS Pursuant to Application to the Commission
4. Rule 301(b)(2): Form ATS Reporting Requirements No Longer
Apply to NMS Stock ATSs
5. Rule 301(b)(9): Form ATS-R Quarterly Reports
6. Rule 303: Recordkeeping Requirements for Form ATS-N
7. Comments Recommending Changes To Other Existing Regulation
ATS Rules
IV. Form ATS-N Filing Process; Effectiveness Review
A. Initial Form ATS-N
1. Rule 304(a)(1)(i): Filing and Effectiveness Requirement
2. Rule 304(a)(1)(ii): Commission Review Period
3. Rule 304(a)(1)(iii): Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness
Determination
a. Comments on the Standard of Review To Accept Filings on Form
ATS-N
b. Comments on the Review for Declarations of Ineffectiveness
c. Effectiveness, Ineffectiveness Process
d. Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness Determinations Under Rule
301(a)(1)(iii)
4. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv): Transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
a. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A): Initial Filing Requirements
b. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B): Commission Review Period;
Ineffectiveness Determination
c. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C): Amendments to Initial Form ATS-N
B. Rule 304(a)(2): Form ATS-N Amendments
1. Rule 304(a)(2)(i): Filing Requirements
a. Material Changes
(i) Comments on Advance Notice
(ii) Comments on Materiality
(iii) Order Display and Fair Access Amendments
b. Updating Amendments
c. Correcting Amendments
2. Rule 304(a)(2)(ii): Commission Review Period; Ineffectiveness
Determination
C. Rule 304(a)(3): Notice of Cessation
D. Rule 304(a)(4): Suspension, Limitation, or Revocation of the
Exemption From the Definition of Exchange
E. Rule 304(b): Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N and Related
Commission Orders
1. Rule 304(b)(1): Form ATS-N ``Report''
2. Rule 304(b)(2): Making Public Form ATS-N Filings and
Commission Orders
a. Public Disclosure of Effective Initial Form ATS-N, As Amended
b. Public Disclosure of Orders of an Ineffective Initial Form
ATS-N
c. Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N Amendments
d. Public Disclosure of Ineffective Form ATS-N Amendment
e. Public Disclosure of Notices of Cessation
f. Public Disclosure of Each Order Suspending, Limiting, or
Revoking the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) Exemption
3. Rule 304(b)(3): Disclosure of Form ATS-N on the NMS Stock
ATS's Website
V. Form ATS-N Disclosures
A. Form ATS-N Disclosure Requirements and Definitions
[[Page 38769]]
1. Rule 304(c): Disclosure Requirements
2. Terminology
a. Definitions for Form ATS-N
(i) Proposed Defined Terms
(ii) New Defined Terms
b. Comments on the Definition of ``Subscriber''
B. Cover Page and Part I of Form ATS-N: Identifying Information
1. Cover Page
2. Part I of Form ATS-N: Identifying Information
a. Part I: Identifying Information
b. Comments on Proposed Exhibit 1
c. ATS Governance Structure and Compliance Programs and Controls
C. Part II of Form ATS-N: ATS-Related Activities of the Broker-
Dealer Operator and Affiliates
1. Broker-Dealer Operator and its Affiliate Trading Activities
on the NMS Stock ATS
a. Proposed Requests and Response to Comments
b. Adopted Part II, Item 1 and 2 of Form ATS-N; ATS-Related
Trading Activities of the Broker-Dealer Operator and its Affiliates
2. Order Interaction with Broker-Dealer Operator; Affiliates
3. Arrangements with Trading Centers
4. Other Products and Services
5. Activities of Service Providers
a. Shared Employees
b. Third-Party Service Providers
6. Protection of Confidential Trading Information
7. Differences in Availability of Services, Functionalities, or
Procedures
8. Other Recommendations From Commenters
D. Part III Form ATS-N: Manner of ATS Operations
1. Types of ATS Subscribers
2. Eligibility for ATS Services
3. Exclusion From ATS Services
4. Hours of Operations
5. Means of Entry
6. Connectivity and Co-Location
7. Order Types and Attributes
8. Order Sizes
9. Conditional Order and Indications of Interest
10. Opening and Reopening
11. Trading Services, Facilities and Rules
12. Liquidity Providers
13. Segmentation; Notice
14. Counter-Party Selection
15. Display
16. Routing
17. Closing
18. Trading Outside of Regular Trading Hours
19. Fees
20. Suspension of Trading
21. Trade Reporting
22. Clearance and Settlement
23. Market Data
24. Order Display and Execution Access
25. Fair Access
26. Aggregate Platform-Wide Data; Trading Statistics
a. Disseminated Aggregated Platform-Wide Data
b. Other Standardized Statistical Disclosures
VI. Amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) and Rule 303(a)(1) for Written
Safeguards and Written Procedures To Protect Confidential Trading
Information
VII. EDGAR Filing Requirements; Structured Data
VIII. Effective Date and Compliance Date
IX. Paperwork Reduction Act
A. Summary of Collection of Information
1. Requirements Relating to Rule 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1) of
Regulation ATS
2. Requirements Relating to Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of
Regulation ATS, Including Form ATS-N
B. Proposed Use of Information
1. Amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1) of Regulation ATS
2. Rules 301(b)(2)(viii), 304 of Regulation ATS, Including Form
ATS-N, and 301(b)(9)
C. Respondents
D. Total Initial and Annual Reporting and Recordkeeping Burdens
1. Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS
a. Baseline Measurements
b. Burdens
2. Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS, Including
Form ATS-N
a. Baseline Measurements
b. Burdens
(i) Analysis of Estimated Additional Burden for Form ATS-N
(a) Part I
(b) Part II
(c) Part III
(ii) Estimated Burden Above the Current Baseline for an Initial
Form ATS-N, Form ATS-N Amendment, and Notice of Cessation on Form
ATS-N
(a) Initial Form ATS-N
(b) Form ATS-N Amendments
(c) Notice of Cessation on Form ATS-N
(iii) ATSs That Trade Both NMS and Non-NMS Stocks
(iv) Access to EDGAR
(v) Recordkeeping Requirements
E. Collection of Information Is Mandatory
F. Confidentiality of Responses to Collection of Information
G. Retention Period for Recordkeeping Requirements
X. Economic Analysis
A. Background
B. Baseline
1. Current NMS Stock ATSs
2. Current Reporting Requirements for NMS Stock ATSs
3. Lack of Standardized Public Disclosure
4. NMS Stock ATS Treatment of Subscriber Confidential Trading
Information
5. Competition
a. Competition Between NMS Stock ATSs and Registered National
Securities Exchanges
b. Competition Among NMS Stock ATSs
c. Competition Between Broker-Dealers That Operate NMS Stock
ATSs and Broker-Dealers That Do Not Operate NMS Stock ATSs
6. Effect of NMS Stock ATSs on the Current Market for NMS Stock
Execution Services
a. Trading Costs
b. Price Discovery
c. Market Efficiency
C. Economic Effects and Effects on Efficiency, Competition, and
Capital Formation
1. Economic Effects of Enhanced Filing Requirements of Form ATS-
N
a. Benefits
b. Costs
2. Economic Effects of Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N
a. Benefits
(i) Benefits of Public Disclosure of Standardized Information of
Operations of NMS Stock ATSs
(ii) Benefits of Public Disclosure of the ATS-Related Activities
of the Broker-Dealer Operator and Its Affiliates
(iii) Benefits of Public Disclosure of Aggregate Platform-Wide
Order Flow and Execution Statistics
(iv) Benefits of Filing Form ATS-N in a Structured Format
b. Costs
(i) Costs to NMS Stock ATSs
(ii) Price Impact Costs
(iii) Filing in Structured Format
3. Economic Effects of Written Safeguards and Written Procedures
To Protect Subscribers' Confidential Trading Information
a. Benefits
b. Costs
4. Impact on Efficiency, Competition, and Capital Formation
a. Competition
(i) Entry of New and Continuation of Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
(a) Enhance Filing Requirements of Form ATS-N
(b) Implementation and Ongoing Compliance Costs
(c) Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N
(ii) Effects on Changes in Number of NMS Stock ATSs on Market
Participant Trading Costs
(iii) Innovation
b. Efficiency
c. Capital Formation
D. Reasonable Alternatives
1. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Publicly Disclose Current Form ATS
2. Require Form ATS-N but Deem Information Confidential
3. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Publicly Disclose Form ATS-N but
not Declare Form ATS-N Ineffective
4. Initiate Differing Levels of Public Disclosure Depending on
NMS Stock ATS Characteristics
5. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Register as National Securities
Exchanges and Become SROs
6. Discontinue Quarterly Volume Reports on Form ATS-R
7. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Operate as Limited Purpose Entities
8. Prohibit Broker-Dealer Operators and Affiliates From Trading
on the NMS Stock ATS
9. Lower the Fair Access Threshold for NMS Stock ATSs
10. Requirements To Disclose Aggregate Platform-Wide Order Flow
and Execution Statistics to All Subscribers
11. Specify Alternative Structured Formats for Form ATS-N
12. Specify Other Filings Methods for Form ATS-N
[[Page 38770]]
XI. Regulatory Flexibility Act Certification
I. Introduction
NMS Stock ATSs, including trading centers commonly referred to as
dark pools,\2\ have become an integral part of the national market
system. Since the adoption of Regulation ATS in 1998,\3\ the number of
these ATSs, and the volume of NMS stocks traded on them, has
significantly increased. NMS Stock ATSs, which meet the definition of
an exchange but are not required to register as national securities
exchanges, compete with, and operate with complexity akin to, national
securities exchanges. Many NMS Stock ATSs are operated by multi-service
broker-dealers, whose business activities have become increasingly
intertwined with those of the ATS, adding further complexity to their
operations of NMS Stock ATSs and creating the potential for conflicts
between the interests of the broker-dealer operator and the ATS's
subscribers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ The term ``dark pool'' is not used or defined in the
Exchange Act or Commission rules. For purposes of this release, the
term refers to NMS Stock ATSs that do not publicly display
quotations in the consolidated quotation data. See Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 76474 (Nov. 18, 2015), 80 FR 80998, 81008
n.123 (Dec. 28, 2015) (``Proposal''). Currently, NMS Stock ATSs
operate predominantly as dark pools. See infra Section II.A.1.
A ``trading center'' means a national securities exchange or
national securities association that operates an SRO trading
facility, an ATS, an exchange market maker, an OTC market maker, or
any other broker or dealer that executes orders internally by
trading as principal or crossing orders as agent. 17 CFR
242.600(b)(78). Some trading centers, such as OTC market makers,
also offer dark liquidity, primarily in a principal capacity, and do
not operate as ATSs. For purposes of this adopting release, these
trading centers are not defined as dark pools because they are not
ATSs.
\3\ Securities Exchange Act Release No. 40760 (December 8,
1998), 63 FR 70844, 70863 (December 22, 1998) (Regulation of
Exchanges and Alternative Trading Systems) (``Regulation ATS
Adopting Release'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite their role in the equity markets, little information is
widely available to market participants about NMS Stock ATSs, which
restricts their ability to adequately assess these ATSs as potential
routing destinations. On November 18, 2015, we proposed to amend
Regulation ATS with the stated goals of enhancing operational
transparency for NMS Stock ATSs to enable market participants to make
more informed order routing decisions, and to facilitate better
Commission oversight of these trading venues.\4\ To achieve these
goals, we proposed to require NMS Stock ATSs to publicly report on new
Form ATS-N information about how the ATS operates and activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that relate to the ATS; and
provide a process for the Commission to determine whether an NMS Stock
ATS qualifies for the exemption from the definition of ``exchange,'' in
which the Commission would, by order, declare a Form ATS-N effective
or, after notice and opportunity for hearing, ineffective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ See Proposal, supra note 2. Section 11A(a)(2) of the
Exchange Act (15 U.S.C. 78k-1(a)(2)) enacted as part of the
Securities Acts Amendments of 1975 (``1975 Amendments'') (Pub. L.
94-29, 89 Stat. 97 (1975)) directs the Commission, having due regard
for the public interest, the protection of investors, and the
maintenance of fair and orderly markets, to use its authority under
the Exchange Act to facilitate the establishment of a national
market system for securities in accordance with the Congressional
findings and objectives set forth in Section 11A(a)(1) of the
Exchange Act. See 15 U.S.C. 78k-1(a)(1). See also Regulation ATS
Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70858; Proposal, supra note 2, at
80999-81000.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received 32 comment letters on the Proposal from a variety of
interested persons, including ATSs, a national securities exchange,
broker-dealers, institutional investors, industry trade groups, the
Commission's Investor Advocate, and the Attorney General of the State
of New York.\5\ Commenters generally support the goals of the Proposal,
although some commenters express concern about various specific
elements, and recommend certain modifications or clarifications. We are
adopting Form ATS-N and amendments to Regulation ATS and Exchange Act
Rule 3a1-1(a) with modifications from the Proposal, as discussed
below.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ Comments received on the Proposal are available on the
Commission's website, available at: https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-23-15/s72315.shtml. See Appendix A for a citation key to comment
letters cited in this release.
\6\ If any of the provisions of these rules, or the application
thereof to any person or circumstance, is held to be invalid, such
invalidity shall not affect other provisions or application of such
provisions to other persons or circumstances that can be given
effect without the invalid provision or application.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Background
A. Role of ATSs in the Current Equity Market Structure
1. Significant Source of Liquidity for NMS Stocks
At the time Regulation ATS was proposed, there were 8 registered
national securities exchanges,\7\ and the Commission estimated that
there were approximately 43 systems that would be eligible to operate
as ATSs.\8\ As of March 31, 2018, there were 21 registered national
securities exchanges and 87 ATSs with a Form ATS on file with the
Commission. Of these, there were 12 national securities exchanges that
trade NMS stocks and 41 ATSs that had noticed on Form ATS that they
expect to trade NMS stocks.\9\ Approximately 502.8 billion shares
($25.4 trillion) were traded in NMS stocks during the first quarter of
2018.\10\ During this period, the 33 ATSs that reported transactions in
NMS stocks \11\ accounted for 57.3 billion shares (approximately $2.9
trillion in dollar volume), representing 11.4% of the combined total
share trading volume (11.5% of the total dollar volume) in NMS stocks
on all national securities exchanges, ATSs, and non-ATS OTC trading
centers.\12\ By comparison, the number of active dark pools trading NMS
stocks in 2002 was approximately 10,\13\ and in 2009, dark
[[Page 38771]]
pools accounted for 7.9% of NMS share volume.\14\ Additionally, no
individual ATS executed more than 20.1% of the total share volume on
NMS Stock ATSs or more than 2.3% of total NMS stock share volume during
the first quarter of 2018.\15\ Given this dispersal of trading volume
in NMS stocks among an increasing number of trading centers, NMS Stock
ATSs, with their approximately 11.4% market share, represent a
significant source of liquidity in NMS stocks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 39884 (April 21,
1998), 63 FR 23504, 23523 (April 29, 1998) (``Regulation ATS
Proposing Release'') at 23543 n.341.
\8\ See id. at 23540 n.313 and accompanying text.
\9\ Data compiled from Forms ATS submitted to the Commission as
of March 31, 2018.
NYSE National, Inc. (f.k.a. National Stock Exchange, Inc.) was
not trading as of March 31, 2018 but filed a proposed rule change
with the Commission for its proposed relaunch. See Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 82819 (March 7, 2018) 83 FR 11098 (March
13, 2018) (NYSENAT-2018-02) (notice of proposed ruled change). The
Commission has approved the proposed rule change. See Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 83289 (May 17, 2018) 83 FR 23968 (May 23,
2018) (NYSENAT-2018-02) (order approving proposed ruled change).
In contrast to dark pools, an ATS could be an Electronic
Communication Network (``ECN''), which are ATSs that provide their
best-priced orders for inclusion in the consolidated quotation data,
whether voluntarily or as required by Rule 301(b)(3) of Regulation
ATS. See Rule 600(b)(23) of Regulation NMS, 17 CFR 242.600(b)(23)
(definition of ``electronic communications network''); see also 2010
Equity Market Structure Release, supra note 13, at 3599. In general,
ECNs offer trading services (such as displayed or non-displayed
order types, maker-taker pricing, and data feeds) that are analogous
to national securities exchanges. See id. Currently, however, based
on Form ATS filings, there are no NMS Stock ATSs operating as ECNs.
\10\ See infra Table 1--``NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Dollar
Trading Volume--January 1, 2018 to March 30, 2018'' (citing Trade
and Quote (TAQ) Data).
\11\ Data compiled from Forms ATS and Forms ATS-R filed with the
Commission as of the end of, and for the first quarter of 2018.
\12\ See infra Table 1--``NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Dollar
Trading Volume--January 1, 2018 to March 30, 2018.'' See id. (citing
Trade and Quote (TAQ) Data).
During the second quarter of 2015, there were 38 ATSs that
reported transactions in NMS stocks, accounting for 59 billion
shares traded in NMS stocks ($2.5 trillion), which represented
approximately 15.0% of total share trading volume (15.4% of total
dollar trading volume) on all national securities exchanges, ATSs,
and non-ATS OTC trading venues combined. See Proposal, supra note 2,
at 81008 n.121 and accompanying text.
Competitors for listed-equity (NMS) trading services also
include several hundred OTC market makers and broker-dealers.
\13\ See Regulation of Non-Public Trading Interest, Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 60997 (November 13, 2009) 74 FR 61208,
61209 n.9 (November 23, 2009) (``Regulation of Non-Public Trading
Interest'').
In 2009, there were 32 active dark pools trading in NMS stocks.
See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 61358 (January 14, 2010), 75
FR 3594 (January 21, 2010) (``2010 Equity Market Structure
Release'')), at 3598 n.22 and accompanying text.
\14\ See id. at 3598.
\15\ The NMS Stock ATS with the greatest volume executed
approximately 20.1% of NMS Stock ATS share volume and 2.3% of the
total consolidated NMS stock share trading volume.
The market share percentages were calculated by Commission staff
using aggregate trade data reported by ATSs to the FINRA equity
trade reporting facilities and made available on FINRA's website and
TAQ Data. See infra Table 1--``NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Dollar
Trading Volume--January 1, 2018 to March 30, 2018.''
Pursuant to FINRA rules, each ATS is required to use a unique
MPID in its reporting to FINRA, such that its volume reporting is
distinguishable from other transaction volume reported by the
broker-dealer operator of the ATS, including volume reported for
other ATSs operated by the same broker-dealer. See FINRA Rules 6160,
6170, 6480, and 6720. FINRA aggregates on a weekly basis ATS data
reported by ATSs to the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities. The
data can be viewed on a security-by-security basis or by ATS. See
FINRA Rules 6110 and 6610. See also Securities Exchange Act Release
No. 76931 (January 19, 2016), 81 FR 4076 (January 25, 2016) (SR-
FINRA-2016-002) (notice of filing and immediate effectiveness of a
proposed rule change relating to ATS volume and trading information)
(``FINRA ATS Reporting Notice'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Operational Complexity; Conflict of Interests
NMS Stock ATSs have grown increasingly complex in terms of the
services and functionalities that they offer subscribers, and they have
used advances in technology to improve the speed, capacity, and
efficiency of the trading functionalities that they offer to execute
orders in NMS stocks.\16\ Additionally, NMS Stock ATSs today offer a
wide range of order types, matching systems to bring together orders
and counterparties in NMS stocks, order interaction protocols, or
opportunities to customize trading parameters, such as parameters that
allow subscribers to preference interaction of their order flow with
that of certain other specific subscribers or types of subscribers.\17\
A variety of market participants use these ATSs to display or execute
orders and trading interest in NMS stocks, including broker-dealers
that route customer orders to ATSs for execution and potential price
improvement, and asset managers that seek to execute large size orders
without suffering adverse price impact.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\ ATSs that traded NMS stocks prior to the adoption of
Regulation ATS did not offer the same services and functionalities
that they do today. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81009.
\17\ See id. at 81009-81010.
\18\ Market participants may include many different types of
persons seeking to transact in NMS stocks, including broker-dealers
and institutional or retail investors. See id. at 81001 n.28 and
accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The relationships between broker-dealer operators \19\ and the ATSs
they operate have also become more complex and intertwined since the
adoption of Regulation ATS.\20\ The broker-dealer operator of an NMS
Stock ATS controls all aspects of the operation of the ATS, including,
among other things: the means of access to the ATS; who may trade on
the ATS; how orders are matched and executed; and any differences in
access to services among subscribers.\21\ The broker-dealer operator,
or its affiliate, may also own, and control access to, the technology
and systems that support the trading facilities of the NMS Stock ATS,
or provide and control the personnel servicing the ATS's trading
facilities.\22\ Additionally, the broker-dealer operator, or in some
cases, its affiliates, determines the means by which orders are entered
on the ATS, in many cases, through the use of a smart order router that
is owned and operated by the broker-dealer operator or one of its
affiliates.\23\ The broker-dealer operator, or in some cases, its
affiliates, also controls the market data that the ATS uses to match,
and execute orders and the transmission of, and access to, confidential
order and execution information sent to and from the ATS.\24\ The
operations of the NMS Stock ATS and the other operations of the broker-
dealer operator are usually closely intertwined, and the broker-dealer
operator may leverage its information technology, systems, personnel,
and market data, and those of its affiliates, to operate the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81010, 81041-81043.
\20\ See id.
\21\ See id. at 81010.
\22\ See id. Some technology or functions of an ATS may be
licensed from a third party. The broker-dealer operator of the ATS
is nonetheless legally responsible for ensuring that all aspects of
the ATS comply with applicable laws. See id. at 81041 n.362.
\23\ See id. at 81041.
\24\ See id. For example, the broker-dealer operator determines
the source of market data that the NMS Stock ATS uses to calculate
the NBBO and how the NBBO will be calculated.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, ATSs that trade NMS stocks are increasingly operated
by multi-service broker-dealers that engage in significant brokerage
and dealing activities in addition to operation of their ATS.\25\ These
other business activities may include, among others, providing
algorithmic trading software, agency sales desk support, and automated
smart order routing services, often with, or through, their affiliates.
As indicated by commenters, the fees charged to subscribers for their
use of an NMS Stock ATS operated by a multi-service broker-dealer are
generally bundled with other services offered by the broker-dealer
operator to subscribers.\26\ Multi-service broker-dealers that also
operate NMS Stock ATSs may use the ATS as a complement to the broker-
dealer's other service lines. For instance, the broker-dealer operator
of an NMS Stock ATS, or its affiliate, may also operate an OTC market
making desk or principal trading desk,\27\ or may have other business
units that actively trade NMS stocks on a principal or agency basis in
the ATS or at other trading centers.\28\ Some of these broker-dealer
operators that operate multiple NMS Stock ATSs may use their ATSs as an
opportunity to execute orders ``in house'' before seeking contra-side
interest at other execution venues. A multi-service broker-dealer may
also execute orders in NMS stocks internally (and not within its ATS)
by trading as principal against such orders or crossing orders as agent
in a riskless principal capacity, before routing the orders to its NMS
Stock ATS or another external trading center. Consequently, the non-ATS
trading centers operated by the broker-dealer operator of an NMS Stock
ATS, or its affiliates, may compete with the ATS for the execution of
transactions in NMS stocks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\ Throughout the Proposal and this release, broker-dealer
operators of NMS Stock ATSs that provide brokerage or dealing
services in addition to operating an ATS are referred to as ``multi-
service broker-dealers.'' See id. at 81001 n.30.
\26\ See infra Section V.D.19.
\27\ These non-ATS, OTC activities in NMS stocks may include
operating as an OTC market maker or block positioner or operating an
internal broker-dealer system. See 2010 Equity Market Structure
Release, supra note 13, at 3599-3600. Additionally, an affiliate of
the broker-dealer operator of an NMS Stock ATS may also operate non-
ATS trading centers.
\28\ See id. See also infra Section V.C (discussing comments on
the proposed disclosure requirements of Form ATS-N).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Exemption for Alternative Trading Systems
Exchange Act Rule 3b-16(a) \29\ provides a functional test to
assess
[[Page 38772]]
whether a trading platform meets the definition of exchange, and if so,
triggers the requirement to register as a national securities exchange
pursuant to Section 5 of the Exchange Act \30\ and comply with the
requirements applicable to exchanges. Under Rule 3b-16(a), ``an
organization, association, or group of persons shall be considered to
constitute, maintain, or provide `a market place or facilities for
bringing together purchasers and sellers of securities or for otherwise
performing with respect to securities the functions commonly performed
by a stock exchange,' if such organization, association, or group of
persons: (1) Brings together the orders for securities of multiple
buyers and sellers; and (2) uses established, non-discretionary methods
(whether by providing a trading facility or by setting rules) under
which such orders interact with each other, and the buyers and sellers
entering such orders agree to the terms of a trade.'' \31\ Exchange Act
Rule 3b-16(b) explicitly excluded certain systems that the Commission
believed were not exchanges.\32\ Accordingly, a system is not included
in the Commission's interpretation of ``exchange'' if: (1) The system
fails to meet the two-part test in paragraph (a) of Rule 3b-16; (2) the
system falls within one of the exclusions in paragraph (b) of Rule 3b-
16; or (3) the Commission otherwise conditionally or unconditionally
exempts \33\ the system from the definition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ See 17 CFR 240.3b-16. See generally Regulation ATS Adopting
Release, supra note 3. See also Proposal, supra note 2, at 81004
(discussing the current exemption from the definition of exchange
available to ATSs).
\30\ See 15 U.S.C. 78f.
\31\ See 17 CFR 240.3b-16(a).
\32\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70852. Specifically, Rule 3b-16(b) excludes from the definition of
exchange systems that perform only traditional broker-dealer
activities, including: (1) systems that route orders to a national
securities exchange, a market operated by a national securities
association, or a broker-dealer for execution, or (2) systems that
allow persons to enter orders for execution against the bids and
offers of a single dealer if certain additional conditions are met.
\33\ See 17 CFR 240.3b-16(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 5 of the Exchange Act \34\ requires an organization,
association, or group of persons that meets the definition of
``exchange'' under Section 3(a)(1) of the Exchange Act,\35\ unless
otherwise exempt, to register with the Commission as a national
securities exchange pursuant to Section 6 of the Exchange Act.\36\
Registered national securities exchanges are also SROs,\37\ and must
comply with regulatory requirements applicable to both national
securities exchanges and SROs.\38\ Before a national securities
exchange may commence operations, the Commission must approve the
national securities exchange's application for registration filed on
Form 1. Section 6(b) of the Exchange Act requires, among other things,
that the national securities exchange be so organized and have the
capacity to carry out the purposes of the Exchange Act and to comply,
and enforce compliance by its members and persons associated with its
members, with the federal securities laws and the rules of the
exchange.\39\ Both a national securities exchange's registration
application and the Commission's order approving the application are
public. After registering, a national securities exchange must file
with the Commission any proposed changes to its rules.\40\ The initial
application on Form 1, amendments thereto, and filings for proposed
rule changes, in combination, publicly disclose important information
about national securities exchanges, such as the trading services they
offer and fees they charge for those services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\ 15 U.S.C. 78e.
\35\ Pursuant to Section 3(a)(1) of the Exchange Act, the
statutory definition of ``exchange'' means ``any organization,
association, or group of persons, whether incorporated or
unincorporated, which constitutes, maintains, or provides a market
place or facilities for bringing together purchasers and sellers of
securities or for otherwise performing with respect to securities
the functions commonly performed by a stock exchange. . . .'' 15
U.S.C. 78c(a)(1).
\36\ 15 U.S.C. 78f. A ``national securities exchange'' is an
exchange registered as such under Section 6 of the Exchange Act.
A trading platform that meets the definition of ``exchange''
under Section 3(a)(1) of the Exchange and fails to register with the
Commission as a national securities exchange pursuant to Section 6
of the Exchange Act, unless exempt, risks operating as an
unregistered exchange in violation of Section 5 of the Exchange Act.
See, e.g., Report of Investigation Pursuant to Section 21(a) of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934: The DAO, Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 81207 (July 25, 2017) https://www.sec.gov/litigation/investreport/34-81207.pdf (``DAO Report'') (finding that certain
tokens offered and sold by a ``virtual'' organization were
securities, and confirming that issuers of distributed ledger or
blockchain technology-based securities must register offers and
sales of such securities unless a valid exemption applies, and that
securities exchanges providing for trading in these securities must
register unless they are exempt). Specifically, we confirmed that a
system that meets the criteria of Rule 3b-16(a), and is not excluded
under Rule 3b-16(b), must register as a national securities exchange
pursuant to Sections 5 and 6 of the Exchange Act or operate pursuant
to an appropriate exemption. See id. at Section III.D. See also In
the Matter of BTC Trading, Corp. and Ethan Burnside, Respondents,
Securities Exchange Act Release No. 73783 (December 8, 2014),
https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2014/33-9685.pdf (order
instituting administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings, making
findings, and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist
order and alleging, among other things, that an operator of two
online venues through which account holders could trade securities
using virtual currencies violated Section 5 of the Exchange Act by
failing to register the trading venues as exchanges).
\37\ Section 3(a)(26) of the Exchange Act defines a self-
regulatory organization as any national securities exchange,
registered securities association, registered clearing agency, or
(with limitations) the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board. See 15
U.S.C. 78c(a)(26). See also Proposal, supra note 2, at 81000-81001
nn. 20-26 and accompanying text (discussing certain differences
between certain obligations and benefits applicable to national
securities exchanges and those applicable to ATSs).
\38\ See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 78f and 78s.
\39\ See Section 6(b)(1) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C.
78f(b)(1). The Commission must also find that the national
securities exchange has rules that meet certain criteria. See
generally Exchange Act Section 6(b)(2) through (10), 15 U.S.C.
78f(b)(2) through (10).
\40\ See generally Section 19(b) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C.
78s(b), and Exchange Act Rule 19b-4, 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) \41\ exempts from the Exchange Act
Section 3(a)(1) definition of ``exchange'' an organization,
association, or group of persons that complies with Regulation ATS,\42\
which requires, among other things, meeting the definition of an ATS
and registering as a broker-dealer.\43\ As a result of the exemption,
an organization, association, or group of persons that meets the
definition of an exchange and complies with Regulation ATS is not
required by Section 5 of the Exchange Act to register as a national
securities exchange pursuant to Section 6 of the Exchange Act, is not
an SRO, and, therefore, is not required to comply with regulatory
requirements applicable to national securities exchanges and SROs.\44\
An ATS that fails to comply with the requirements of Regulation ATS
would no longer qualify for the exemption provided under Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2), and thus, risks operating as an unregistered exchange in
violation of Section 5 of the Exchange Act.\45\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\ See 17 CFR 240.3a1-1(a)(2).
\42\ See id. Rule 3a1-1 also provides two other exemptions from
the definition of ``exchange'' for any ATS operated by a national
securities association and any ATS not required to comply with
Regulation ATS pursuant to Rule 301(a) of Regulation ATS. See 17 CFR
240.3a1-1(a)(1) and (3).
Rule 3a1-1(b) provides an exception to the Rule 3a1-1(a)
exemptions pursuant to which the Commission may require a trading
system that is a substantial market to register as a national
securities exchange, if the Commission finds doing so is necessary
or appropriate in the public interest or consistent with the
protection of investors. See 17 CFR 240.3a1-1(b). See also
Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70857-70858.
\43\ See 17 CFR 242.300(a); 17 CFR 242.301(a); and
242.301(b)(1). In addition to the other requirements of Regulation
ATS, to qualify for the Rule 3a1-1(a) exemption, an organization,
association, or group of persons must otherwise meet the definition
of ``exchange.''
\44\ See generally Sections 5, 6, and 19 of the Exchange Act, 15
U.S.C. 78e, 78f, and 78s.
\45\ See 15 U.S.C. 78e.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Conditions to the ATS Exemption; Confidential Notice Regime
Rule 300(a) of Regulation ATS defines an ATS as: ``any
organization, association, person, group of persons, or
[[Page 38773]]
system: (1) [t]hat constitutes, maintains, or provides a market place
or facilities for bringing together purchasers and sellers of
securities or for otherwise performing with respect to securities the
functions commonly performed by a stock exchange within the meaning of
[Rule 3b-16]; and (2) [t]hat does not: (i) [s]et rules governing the
conduct of subscribers other than the conduct of such subscribers'
trading on such organization, association, person, group of persons, or
system; or (ii) [d]iscipline subscribers other than by exclusion from
trading.'' \46\ Governing the conduct of or disciplining subscribers
are functions performed by an SRO that we believe should be regulated
as such.\47\ Accordingly, pursuant to the definition in Rule 300(a), a
trading system that performs SRO functions, or performs functions
common to national securities exchanges, such as establishing listing
standards, is precluded from the definition of ATS and would be
required to register as a national securities exchange or be operated
by a national securities association (or seek another exemption).\48\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\ See 17 CFR 242.300(a).
\47\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70859. As we noted when we adopted Regulation ATS, any system that
uses its market power to regulate its participants should be
regulated as an SRO. We stated that it would consider a trading
system to be ``governing the conduct of subscribers'' outside the
trading system if it imposed on subscribers, as conditions of
participation in trading, any requirements for which the trading
system had to examine subscribers for compliance. In addition, we
stated our belief that if a trading system imposed as conditions of
participation, directly or indirectly, restrictions on subscribers'
activities outside of the trading system, such a trading system
should be a registered exchange or operated by a national securities
association, but that the limitation would not preclude an ATS from
imposing credit conditions on subscribers or requiring subscribers
to submit financial information to the ATS. See id.
\48\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 301(b)(1) of Regulation ATS requires that every ATS that is
subject to Regulation ATS, pursuant to paragraph (a) of Rule 301,\49\
be registered as a broker-dealer under Section 15 of the Exchange
Act.\50\ As a registered broker-dealer, an ATS must also, in addition
to complying with Regulation ATS, comply with broker-dealer filing and
conduct obligations, including becoming a member of an SRO, such as the
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (``FINRA''), and comply with
SRO rules.\51\ An ATS must also comply with Rule 301(b)(2) of
Regulation ATS, which currently requires all ATSs to file an initial
operation report with the Commission on Form ATS \52\ at least 20 days
before commencing operations.\53\ Form ATS requirements include that an
ATS provide information about: Classes of subscribers and differences
in access to the services offered by the ATS to different groups or
classes of subscribers; securities the ATS expects to trade; any entity
other than the ATS involved in its operations; the manner in which the
system operates; how subscribers access the trading system; procedures
governing order entry; and procedures governing execution, reporting,
clearance, and settlement of transactions effected through the ATS.\54\
Regulation ATS states that information filed by an ATS on Form ATS is
``deemed confidential when filed'' \55\ and ATSs are not otherwise
required to publicly disclose such information.\56\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\ Pursuant to Rule 301(a), certain ATSs that are subject to
other appropriate regulations are not required to comply with
Regulation ATS. These ATSs include those that are: Registered as a
national securities exchange under Section 6 of the Exchange Act;
exempt from national securities exchange registration based on the
limited volume of transactions effected; operated by a national
securities association; Registered as a broker-dealer under Sections
15(b) or 15C of the Exchange Act, or are banks, that limits their
activities to certain instruments; or exempted, conditionally or
unconditionally, by Commission order, after application by such ATS.
See 17 CFR 242.301(a).
\50\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(1).
\51\ Section 15(b)(8) of the Exchange Act requires a broker or
dealer to become a member of a registered national securities
association, unless it effects transactions in securities solely on
an exchange of which it is a member. 15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(8). See also
Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70903 (discussing
some of the regulatory obligations of registered broker-dealers,
such as membership in an SRO and compliance with that SRO's rules).
For example, a broker-dealer that is a FINRA member must file an
application for approval of a material change to its business
operations (as defined in FINRA Rule 1011(k)). See FINRA Rule
1017(a). Among other obligations, a broker-dealer operator of an NMS
Stock ATS that is a FINRA member is subject to trade reporting
requirements pursuant to FINRA rules. See, e.g., supra note 15
(discussing FINRA trade reporting requirements applicable to NMS
Stock ATSs).
\52\ Form ATS and the Form ATS Instructions are available at
http://www.sec.gov/about/forms/formats.pdf.
\53\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(i). The Commission stated in the
Regulation ATS Adopting Release that Form ATS would provide the
Commission the opportunity to identify problems that might impact
investors before the system begins to operate. See Regulation ATS
Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70864; Proposal, supra note 2, at
81005 n.70 and accompanying text. Unlike a Form 1 filed by a
national securities exchange, Form ATS is not approved by the
Commission. Instead, Form ATS provides the Commission with notice
about an ATS's operations prior to commencing operations. See
Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70864.
\54\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81005.
\55\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(vii). See Form ATS.
\56\ As we noted in the Proposal, some ATSs may currently make
voluntary public disclosures. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81011,
n.156. See also infra note 559 and accompanying text (discussing
comments regarding voluntary postings of Form ATS by NMS Stock
ATSs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ATSs must notify the Commission of any changes in their operations
by filing an amendment to its Form ATS initial operation report. There
are three types of amendments to an initial operation report.\57\
First, if any material change is made to its operations, the ATS must
file an amendment on Form ATS at least 20 calendar days before
implementing such change.\58\ Second, if any information contained in
the initial operation report becomes inaccurate for any reason and has
not been previously reported to the Commission as an amendment on Form
ATS, the ATS must file an amendment on Form ATS correcting the
information within 30 calendar days after the end of the calendar
quarter in which the system has operated.\59\ Third, an ATS must
promptly file an amendment on Form ATS correcting information that it
previously reported on Form ATS after discovery that any information
was inaccurate when filed.\60\ Also, upon ceasing to operate as an ATS,
an ATS is required to promptly file a cessation of operations report on
Form ATS.\61\ As is the case with respect to initial operation reports,
Form ATS amendments and cessation of operations reports serve as notice
to the Commission of changes to the ATS's operations,\62\ and Rule
301(b)(2)(vii) and the Instructions to the form state that Form ATS is
``deemed confidential.'' \63\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\57\ Form ATS is used for three types of submissions: Initial
operation reports; amendments to initial operation reports; and
cessation of operations reports. An ATS designates the type of
submission on the form. See Form ATS.
\58\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(ii). A ``material change,''
includes, but is not limited to, any change to the operating
platform, the types of securities traded, or the types of
subscribers. In addition, the Commission has stated that ATSs
implicitly make materiality decisions in determining when to notify
their subscribers of changes. See Regulation ATS Adopting Release,
supra note 3, at 70864. See also infra Section IV.B.1.a.ii
(discussing the materiality standard that would apply to the filing
of amendments on Form ATS-N).
\59\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(iii).
\60\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(iv).
\61\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(v).
\62\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70864.
\63\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(vii); Form ATS at 3, General
Instructions A.7. Under the final rules, NMS Stock ATSs that trade
only NMS stocks will not be required to file Form ATS in accordance
with Rules 301(b)(2)(i) through (vii), but instead will be required
to comply with the requirements of new Rule 304 and file Form ATS-N.
See infra Section III.B.4. See also infra Sections IV.A, B, and C.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 301(b)(9) of Regulation ATS also requires an ATS to
periodically report certain information about transactions on the ATS
and information about certain activities on Form ATS-R within 30
calendar days after the end of each calendar quarter in which the
market
[[Page 38774]]
has operated.\64\ Form ATS-R requires quarterly volume information for
specified categories of securities, as well as a list of all securities
traded on the ATS during the quarter and a list of all subscribers that
were participants during the quarter.\65\ As with respect to Form ATS,
Rule 301(b)(2)(vii) and the instructions to Form ATS-R state that Form
ATS-R is ``deemed confidential.'' \66\ Under the amendments we are
adopting, the requirements of Rule 301(b)(9) will continue to apply to
all ATSs, including NMS Stock ATSs, as will the other requirements of
Regulation ATS other than the Form ATS reporting requirements of Rule
301(b)(2).\67\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\64\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(9)(i). Form ATS-R and the Form ATS-R
Instructions are available at https://www.sec.gov/about/forms/formats-r.pdf. In the Regulation ATS Adopting Release, the
Commission stated that the information provided on Form ATS-R would
permit the Commission to monitor the trading on ATSs. See Regulation
ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70878.
\65\ See Form ATS-R at 4, Items 1 and 2 (describing the
requirements for Exhibit A and Exhibit B of Form ATS-R). Form ATS-R
also requires an ATS that is subject to the fair access obligations
under Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS to provide as Exhibit C, a
list of all persons granted, denied, or limited access to the ATS
during the period covered by the Form ATS-R and designate for each
person (a) whether it was granted, denied, or limited access; (b)
the date the ATS took such action; (c) the effective date of such
action; and (d) the nature of any denial or limitation of access.
ATSs must also complete and file Form ATS-R within 10 calendar days
after ceasing to operate. See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(9)(ii); Form ATS-R
at 2, General Instructions A.2 to Form ATS-R.
\66\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(vii); Form ATS-R at 2, General
Instruction A.7.
\67\ See generally infra Section III. See also Section III.B.5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Rule 301(b)(3), an ATS that (1) displays subscriber orders in
an NMS stock to any person (other than an employee of the ATS) and (2)
during at least four of the preceding six calendar months, had an
average daily trading volume of 5% or more of the aggregate average
daily share volume for that NMS stock, as reported by an effective
transaction reporting plan, must comply with certain order display and
execution access obligations.\68\ An ATS that meets these criteria must
comply with Rule 301(b)(3)(ii), which requires the ATS to provide to a
national securities exchange or national securities association (each
an SRO), for inclusion in the quotation data made available by the SRO
to vendors, the prices and sizes of its orders at the highest buy price
and lowest sell price for that NMS stock that are displayed to more
than one subscriber.\69\ An ATS that meets the volume threshold also is
required to comply with Rule 301(b)(3)(iii), which sets forth certain
access standards regarding the orders that the ATS is required to
provide to an SRO pursuant to Rule 301(b)(3)(ii).\70\ Under Rule
301(b)(4), an ATS must not charge any fee to broker-dealers that access
the ATS through a national securities exchange or national securities
association that is inconsistent with the equivalent access to the ATS
that is required under Rule 301(b)(3)(iii).\71\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\68\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(3)(i).
\69\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(3)(ii).
\70\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(3)(iii).
\71\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(4). In addition, if the national
securities exchange or national securities association to which an
ATS provides the prices and sizes of orders under Rules
301(b)(3)(ii) and 301(b)(3)(iii) establishes rules designed to
assure consistency with standards for access to quotations displayed
on such national securities exchange, or the market operated by such
national securities association, the ATS shall not charge any fee to
members that is contrary to, that is not disclosed in the manner
required by, or that is inconsistent with any standard of equivalent
access established by such rules. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Rule 301(b)(5)--and even if the ATS does not display
subscribers' orders to any person (other than an ATS employee)--an ATS
with 5% or more of the average daily volume in an NMS stock during at
least four of the preceding six calendar months, as reported by an
effective transaction reporting plan, must: \72\ Establish written
standards for granting access to trading on its system; not
unreasonably prohibit or limit any person in respect to access to
services offered by such ATS by applying the above standards in an
unfair or discriminatory manner; make and keep records of all grants of
access including, for all subscribers, the reasons for granting such
access, and all denials or limitations of access and reasons, for each
applicant, for denying or limiting access; and report the information
required in Exhibit C of Form ATS-R regarding grants, denials, and
limitations of access.\73\ These requirements are referred to as the
``fair access'' requirements and apply on a security-by-security
basis.\74\ A denial of access to a market participant after an ATS
reaches the 5% fair access threshold in an NMS stock would be
reasonable if it is based on objective standards.\75\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\72\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(5)(i).
\73\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(5)(ii). Regulation ATS does not
mandate compliance with these requirements when an ATS reaches the
5% trading threshold in an NMS stock if the following conditions are
met: The ATS matches customer orders for a security with other
customer orders; such customers' orders are not displayed to any
person, other than employees of the ATS; and such orders are
executed at a price for such security disseminated by an effective
transaction reporting plan, or derived from such prices. See 17 CFR
242.301(b)(5)(iii).
\74\ The fair access requirements also apply for non-NMS stocks
when an ATS reaches a 5% trading threshold in certain securities
other than NMS stocks, including certain equity securities,
municipal securities, and corporate debt securities. See 17 CFR
242.301(b)(5)(i).
\75\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70874.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prior to the Commission's adoption of Regulation SCI,\76\ NMS Stock
ATSs were required to comply with Rule 301(b)(6), which requires
certain ATSs trading 20% or more of the volume in any equity security
or debt securities to comply with standards regarding the capacity,
integrity, and security of their automated systems.\77\ Regulation SCI
superseded and replaced Rule 301(b)(6)'s requirements with regard to
ATSs that trade NMS stocks and equity securities that are not NMS
stocks \78\ and requires SCI entities,\79\ including NMS Stock ATSs
that meet the definition of an ``SCI ATS,'' \80\ to establish written
policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that their
systems have levels of capacity, integrity, resiliency, availability,
and security adequate to maintain their operational capability and
promote the maintenance of fair and orderly markets, and that they
operate in a manner that complies with the Exchange Act.\81\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\76\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 73639 (November 19,
2014), 79 FR 72251 (December 5, 2014) (adopting final rules for
systems compliance and integrity) (``SCI Adopting Release'').
\77\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(6).
\78\ Regulation SCI does not apply to ATSs that trade municipal
securities or corporate debt securities. See SCI Adopting Release,
supra note 76, at 72262.
\79\ Regulation SCI defines ``SCI entity'' to mean ``an SCI
self-regulatory organization, SCI alternative trading system, plan
processor, or exempt clearing agency subject to [the Commission's
Automation Review Policies].'' See 17 CFR 242.1000.
\80\ Regulation SCI defines ``SCI alternative trading system''
or ``SCI ATS'' to mean an ATS, which during at least four of the
preceding six calendar months: (1) Had with respect to NMS stocks
(a) five percent (5%) or more in any single NMS stock, and one-
quarter percent (0.25%) or more in all NMS stocks, of the average
daily dollar volume reported by applicable transaction reporting
plans, or (b) one percent (1%) or more in all NMS stocks of the
average daily dollar volume reported by applicable transaction
reporting plans; or (2) had with respect to equity securities that
are not NMS stocks and for which transactions are reported to a
self-regulatory organization, five percent (5%) or more of the
average daily dollar volume as calculated by the self-regulatory
organization to which such transactions are reported. However, an
SCI ATS is not required to comply with the requirements of
Regulation SCI until six months after satisfying the aforementioned
criteria. See 17 CFR 242.1000.
\81\ See SCI Adopting Release, supra note 76, 79 FR at 72252.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 301(b)(7) \82\ requires all ATSs, regardless of the volume
traded on their systems, to permit the examination and inspection of
their premises, systems, and records, and cooperate with the
examination, inspection, or investigation of subscribers, whether such
examination is being conducted by
[[Page 38775]]
the Commission or by an SRO of which such subscriber is a member. Rule
301(b)(8) \83\ requires all ATSs to make and keep current the records
specified in Rule 302 of Regulation ATS \84\ and preserve the records
specified in Rule 303 of Regulation ATS.\85\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\82\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(7).
\83\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(8).
\84\ See 17 CFR 242.302.
\85\ See 17 CFR 242.303. In the Regulation ATS Adopting Release,
the Commission stated that these requirements to make, keep, and
preserve records are necessary to create a meaningful audit trail
and to permit surveillance and examination to help ensure fair and
orderly markets. See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3,
at 70877-78.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Rule 301(b)(10), all ATSs must establish adequate safeguards
and procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information, which includes limiting access to the confidential trading
information of subscribers to those employees of the ATS who are
operating the system or responsible for its compliance with Regulation
ATS or any other applicable rules; and implementing standards
controlling employees of the ATS trading for their own accounts.\86\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\86\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, all ATSs must adopt and implement adequate oversight
procedures to ensure that the above safeguards and procedures are
followed.\87\ Finally, Rule 301(b)(11) \88\ expressly prohibits any ATS
from using the word ``exchange'' or derivations of the word
``exchange,'' such as the term ``stock market,'' in its name.\89\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\87\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10)(ii).
\88\ See 17 CFR 240.301(b)(11).
\89\ When we proposed Regulation ATS, we said that ``it is
important that the investing public not be confused about the market
role [ATSs] have chosen to assume.'' See Regulation ATS Proposing
Release, supra note 7 at 23523. We expressed concern that ``use of
the term `exchange' by a system not regulated as an exchange would
be deceptive and could mislead investors that such alternative
trading system is registered as a national securities exchange.''
See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Concerns Regarding the Lack of Operational Transparency
Despite their role in the equity markets and complexity of their
operations, NMS Stock ATSs are not required under Regulation ATS to
publicly disclose information about their operations. We are concerned
that little information is widely available to market participants
about NMS Stock ATSs, and that the lack of, or differential access to,
information about operations of NMS Stock ATSs inhibits the ability of
market participants to assess NMS Stock ATSs as potential trading
venues. These concerns are shared by several commenters.\90\ Commenters
also concur with our belief that NMS Stock ATSs today play a
significant role in equity market structure, and that their role has
changed since Regulation ATS was adopted in 1998.\91\ In addition,
commenters reinforce our belief that NMS Stock ATSs have become more
operationally complex, that the potential for conflicts of interest has
risen as a result of that complexity, and that the conditions to the
exemption for NMS Stock ATSs should be modified.\92\ Commenters also
express concern about the lack of operational transparency for NMS
Stock ATSs.\93\ Given the complexities of NMS Stock ATS operations, the
lack of information about the ATS's order types, priority rules,
segmentation procedures, use of market data, and fees, for example, may
impede the ability of market participants to adequately understand how
their orders in NMS stocks would interact, match, and execute.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\90\ See, e.g., CFA Institute Letter at 2; ICI Letter at 3;
Better Markets Letter at 2; Investor Advocate Letter at 14; Luminex
Letter at 1.
\91\ See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 2; Investor Advocate Letter at
4; LeveL ATS Letter at 2. Other commenters also recognized that the
role of NMS Stock ATSs has changed since the adoption of Regulation
ATS. See, e.g., Schneiderman Letter at 1; Virtu Letter at 2; UBS
Letter at 1; Fidelity Letter at 1; ICI Letter at 2-3; STANY Letter
at 2-3.
\92\ See, e.g., Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4; ICI
Letter at 2; HMA Letter at 18; Schneiderman Letter at 1-2; Better
Markets Letter at 2; CFA Institute Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 8.
See also infra Section V.D (describing comments on proposed
disclosures required by Form ATS-N).
\93\ See, e.g., CBOE Letter at 1; CFA Institute Letter at 3;
Consumer Federation of America Letter at 2; ICI Letter at 3. See
also Investor Advocate Letter at 14; Luminex Letter at 1; Consumer
Federation of America Letter at 4; UBS Letter at 5-7; AI Letter at
2. One commenter critiques both the current regulatory regime for
ATSs, as well as the Proposal, but describes issues with the lack of
transparency and states that the Proposal represents an important
enhancement in the oversight of ATSs. See Better Markets Letter at
1-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also concerned that the lack of available information about
the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates may hinder the ability of market participants to evaluate
potential conflicts of interest, and thus limit their ability to
protect their interests. Because of overlap between a broker-dealer's
ATS operations and its other operations, there is a risk of information
leakage of subscribers' confidential trading information to other
business units of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates.\94\
Several commenters describe NMS Stock ATS operational structures that
exemplify the kinds of relationships about which the Commission
expressed concern, or otherwise reinforce our belief that the complex
relationship between an NMS Stock ATS and its broker-dealer operator,
or its affiliates, creates potential conflicts of interest.\95\
Further, in recognizing the current potential for conflicts of interest
that exist as a result of the complexity of the operations of NMS Stock
ATSs, the relationship many have with their broker-dealer operator or
its affiliates, and the lack of transparency about those operations and
potential conflicts, many commenters also highlight recent enforcement
actions brought by the Commission.\96\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\94\ In the Regulation ATS Adopting Release, the Commission
recognized the potential for abuse involving a broker-dealer that
operates an ATS and offers other traditional brokerage services, and
expressed concern about the potential for the misuse of confidential
trading information. See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note
3, at 70879. See also Proposal, supra note 2, at 81041-81042 n.367
and accompanying text.
\95\ See, e.g., Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4;
LeveL ATS Letter at 3; Fidelity Letter at 2 n.4. See also KCG Letter
at 2; Luminex Letter at 3-4; Liquidnet Letter at 11.
Not all NMS Stock ATSs, however, are operated by multi-service
broker-dealers. See, e.g., BIDS Letter at 1. This commenter
describes itself as the owner and broker-dealer operator of an NMS
Stock ATS that does not engage in any proprietary trading and does
not have any trading affiliates.
The rules being adopted today would not require a broker-dealer
that operates an NMS Stock ATSs to limit it business only to
operating the ATS. We believe that the Form ATS-N disclosures will
inform market participants about the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that give rise to
potential conflicts between the interests of the broker-dealer
operator and subscribers that use the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
See infra Sections X.D.7 (discussing the alternative of requiring
NMS Stock ATSs to operate as limited purpose entities) and V.C.8
(discussing comments stating that the Commission should prohibit
conflicts of interest arising from the other business activities of
the broker-dealer operator of an NMS Stock ATS, and those of its
affiliates, and the Commission's response to those comments).
See also HMA Letter at 3 and attachment The Dark Side of the
Pools: What Investors Should Learn from Regulator's Action,
September 15, 2015, at 10; Investor Advocate Letter at 8; Better
Markets Letter at 2; infra Section V.C (discussing comments related
to disclosures about the activities of an NMS Stock ATS's broker-
dealer affiliate and those of its affiliates).
\96\ See, e.g., Schneiderman Letter at 2; Better Markets Letter
at 2-3; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 5; and HMA Letter
at 12, 16-17. See also CFA Institute Letter at 2; Fidelity Letter at
4; Investor Advocate Letter at 5; Citadel Letter at 1-7.
One commenter, however, observes that in the recent settlements
cited in the Proposal, there were conflicts of interest related to
commercial relationships that had nothing to do with affiliates, and
believes that all differential treatment of subscribers should be
disclosed and recommends limiting disclosures regarding affiliate
relationships. See Markit Letter at 8. Under the requirements we are
adopting today, NMS Stock ATSs must disclose on Form ATS-N
differences in treatment of subscribers and the broker-dealer
operator and affiliate, and we have, in response to commenters,
revised questions of Form ATS-N to narrow the scope of information
related to affiliates to be disclosed. See infra Sections V.C and D.
See also Proposal, supra note 2, at 81042-81043 n.374 (citing
prior settled enforcement actions against ATSs that trade NMS
stocks). Since the Proposal, we have entered additional settlements
regarding NMS Stock ATSs. See In the Matter of Barclays Capital
Inc., Securities Exchange Act Release No. 77001 (Jan. 31, 2016),
https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2016/33-10010.pdf (order
instituting administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings, making
findings, and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist
order); In the Matter of Credit Suisse Securities (USA) LLC,
Securities Act Release No. 77002 (Jan. 31, 2016), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2016/33-10013.pdf (order instituting
administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings, making findings,
and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist order)
(``Crossfinder Settlement''); In the Matter of Credit Suisse
Securities (USA) LLC, Securities Act Release No. 77003 (Jan. 31,
2016), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2016/33-10014.pdf (order
instituting administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings, making
findings, and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist
order); In the Matter of Deutsche Bank Securities Inc., Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 79576 (Dec. 16, 2016), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2016/33-10272.pdf (order instituting administrative
and cease-and-desist proceedings, making findings, and imposing
remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist order).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38776]]
NMS Stock ATSs, which meet the definition of ``exchange'' but are
not required to register with the Commission as national securities
exchanges, compete with national securities exchanges and operate with
similar complexity. Unlike national securities exchanges, NMS Stock
ATSs are not required to, among other things, publicly disclose their
operations and fees.\97\ In addition, because we review the rules of
national securities exchanges, a process which requires, among other
things, that to approve certain rule changes, the Commission find \98\
that the national securities exchange's proposed rule changes are
consistent with the Exchange Act,\99\ each existing national securities
exchange has implemented rules that restrict affiliation between the
national securities exchange and its members to mitigate the potential
for conflicts of interest. We believe that the regulatory differences
between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges with regard to
disclosure obligations may create a competitive imbalance between two
functionally similar trading centers that trade the same security.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\97\ See infra notes 34-40 and accompanying text (discussing the
regulatory framework applicable to national securities exchanges,
including that national securities exchanges are self-regulatory
organizations (``SROs'')). See also Regulation ATS Adopting Release,
supra note 3; infra Section II.B (discussing the current
requirements of Regulation ATS applicable to all ATSs).
\98\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81042 n.372 and accompanying
text.
\99\ See 15 U.S.C. 78s(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Transparency has long been a hallmark of the U.S. securities
markets, and is one of the primary tools used by investors to protect
their interests.\100\ We believe that one of the most important
functions the Commission can perform for investors is to ensure that
they have access to the information they need to protect and further
their own interests.\101\ The amendments that we are adopting to
Regulation ATS and Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1 are designed to address the
concerns identified above and provide benefits to a wide range of
market participants. Public disclosures on Form ATS-N will provide
market participants with information about the operations of an NMS
Stock ATS, which they can use to understand how orders interact, match,
and execute in an NMS Stock ATS and compare to other NMS Stock ATSs and
national securities exchanges. Form ATS-N will also provide the public
with information about the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates, which can be used by market participants
to assess potential conflicts of interest and information leakage.\102\
Collectively, the Form ATS-N public disclosures will allow market
participants to better evaluate an NMS Stock ATS as a potential trading
destination for their orders and help them better protect their
interests. The Form ATS-N public disclosures are also designed, in
part, to bring the operational transparency requirements for NMS Stock
ATSs more in line with the requirements for national securities
exchanges. Finally, we believe that our process for reviewing Form ATS-
N filings, which provides for Commission review of disclosures for
compliance with the requirements of Rule 304 and Form ATS-N, and a
potential declaration of ineffectiveness of a Form ATS-N, after notice
and opportunity for hearing, will facilitate better Commission
oversight of NMS Stock ATSs and thus, better protection of investors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\100\ See id.
\101\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81010.
\102\ See id. at 81042. We believe that to understand the
operations of an NMS Stock ATS, it is necessary to understand the
relationship and interactions between the NMS Stock ATS and its
registered broker-dealer operator as well as the relationship and
interactions between the NMS Stock ATS and the affiliates of its
broker-dealer operator.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Heightened Regulatory Requirements for NMS Stock ATSs
A. Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a) Exemption: New Conditions for NMS Stock
ATSs
ATSs that trade NMS stocks operate pursuant to the exemption
provided by Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2), which exempts from the
definition of an ``exchange'' any ATS that complies with Rules 300
through 303 of Regulation ATS.\103\ Given our concerns regarding the
lack of public transparency around the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and
the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates, we proposed to expand the conditions of the Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) exemption to enhance operational transparency and oversight for
these ATSs. We are adopting this requirement as proposed.\104\ We
proposed to require NMS Stock ATSs to comply with proposed Rule 304, in
addition to existing Rules 300 through 303 of Regulation ATS (except
Rule 301(b)(2)), to be eligible for the exemption.\105\ Proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(i) set forth two new fundamental conditions to the Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) exemption: (1) An NMS Stock ATS must file Form ATS-N with the
Commission (instead of the current Form ATS), and (2) the Commission
must declare the Form ATS-N effective before the NMS Stock ATS can
operate pursuant to the exemption. Adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(i) deletes
the proposed condition that the Commission declare the Form ATS-N
effective, and provides that the Form ATS-N must be effective
[[Page 38777]]
pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) or Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). Adopted Rule
304(a)(1)(iii) has been modified to provide that Form ATS-N will become
effective if the Commission does not otherwise declare Form ATS-N
ineffective--the Commission will not be declaring Form ATS-N filings
effective.\106\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\103\ 17 CFR 240.3a1-1(a)(2).
\104\ In Exchange Act Rules 3a1-1(a)(2) and (3), Regulation ATS
is currently defined as ``17 CFR 242.300 through 242.303.'' We are
amending the references to Regulation ATS to define Regulation ATS
as ``17 CFR 242.300 through 242.304.'' We also proposed conforming
Rule 3a1-1(a)(3) by changing the reference to Rule 303 to Rule 304
to make clear that an NMS Stock ATS that meets the requirements of
Rule 301(a) is not required to comply with Regulation ATS, which
would be amended to include proposed Rule 304. No changes were
proposed to Rule 3a1-1(a)(1), which exempts any ATS that is operated
by a national securities association.
\105\ Proposed Rule 304(a) provided that, unless not required to
comply with Regulation ATS pursuant to Rule 301(a) of Regulation
ATS, an NMS Stock ATS must comply with Rules 300 through 304 of
Regulation ATS (except Rule 301(b)(2)) to be exempt from the
definition of an ``exchange'' pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2). We are adopting proposed Rule 304(a) with certain
modifications. As adopted, Rule 304(a) will state, ``[u]nless not
required to comply with Regulation ATS pursuant to Sec. 242.301(a),
an NMS Stock ATS must comply with Sec. Sec. 242.300 through 242.304
(except Sec. Sec. 242.301(b)(2)(i) through (vii)) to be exempt
pursuant to Sec. 240.3a-1(a)(2)'' (emphasis added). The adopted
rule text specifies the subparagraphs of Rule 301(b)(2) with which
an NMS Stock ATS would not be required to comply. We believe that
specifying the applicable subsections of Rule 301(b)(2) provides
greater clarity, because Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) will apply to NMS
Stock ATSs that also trade non-NMS stocks. The reference to Rule
301(b)(2) in the proposed rule text could be confusing to market
participants because it does not make clear that Rule
301(b)(2)(viii) applies to certain NMS Stock ATSs. We believe that
the added specificity in the adopted rule clarifies that only Rules
301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) will not be applicable to NMS Stock ATSs.
See infra Section III.B.4. In addition, to reduce any potential
ambiguity and improve readability, the adopted rule text deletes the
language that states that the NMS Stock ATS would need to comply
with the requirements to be exempt ``from the definition of an
`exchange''' pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2).
\106\ See infra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We proposed to amend Rules 3a1-1(a)(2) and (3) to require
compliance with proposed Rule 304 as a condition to operating pursuant
to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption.\107\ We received several comments on
the proposal to expand the conditions of the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption
for NMS Stock ATSs and require these ATSs to comply with Rule 304. We
also received comments on the application of the Proposal to ATSs that
trade securities other than NMS stocks, and, specifically, requiring
these types of ATSs to file a Form ATS-N and operate pursuant to the
effectiveness process. Both sets of comments are discussed below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\107\ In Exchange Act Rules 3a1-1(a)(2) and (3), Regulation ATS
is currently defined as ``17 CFR 242.300 through 242.303.'' We
proposed amending these references to Regulation ATS to define
Regulation ATS as ``17 CFR 242.300 through 242.304.'' We also
proposed conforming Rule 3a1-1(a)(3) by changing the reference to
Rule 303 to final Rule 304 to make clear that an NMS Stock ATS that
meets the requirements of Rule 301(a) is not required to comply with
Regulation ATS, which would be amended to include proposed Rule 304.
No changes were proposed to Rule 3a1-1(a)(1), which exempts any ATS
that is operated by a national securities association.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Comments on the Rule 304 Requirements; Effectiveness
Nearly all commenters agree with our stated goal of enhancing
operational transparency for NMS Stock ATSs.\108\ Several commenters
agree that the Commission should adopt the heightened disclosure
requirements of proposed Rule 304.\109\ In particular, several
commenters support enhancing the disclosure and oversight regime for
NMS Stock ATSs as progress toward increasing operational transparency
in NMS Stock ATSs.\110\ Specifically, some commenters express support
for NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-N as a tool to improve
transparency.\111\ Several commenters assert that more transparency
regarding ATS operations could help market participants evaluate and
compare trading venues so they can determine where to route
orders.\112\ One commenter states that ``it is good for investors to
have access to information on how their orders are handled and with
whom they are dealing.'' \113\ Several commenters believe that making
Form ATS-N filings public would encourage competition among trading
venues,\114\ and one commenter asserts that the proposed transparency
requirements could reduce competitive imbalances between NMS Stock ATSs
and national securities exchanges.\115\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\108\ See SIFMA Letter at 2; Barnard Letter at Public comment on
IOSCO's Consultation Report on Issues Raised by Dark Liquidity;
Anonymous Letter at 1; Luminex Letter at 1; MFA/AIMA Letter at 1-2;
Fidelity Letter at 1; UBS Letter at 1; Markit Letter at 3-4;
Schneiderman Letter at 1; ICI Letter at 3; CFA Institute Letter at
3, 6; CBOE Letter at 1; KCG Letter at 1; PDQ Letter at 1; STA Letter
at 2; Liquidnet Letter at 1; STANY Letter at 1; FINRA Letter at 1;
HMA Letter at 1, 5; Citadel Letter at 1; Better Markets Letter at 3-
4; BIDS Letter at 1-2; SSGA Letter at 2; T. Rowe Price Letter at 1;
AI Letter at 2-3; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4; Morgan
Stanley Letter at 1; Investor Advocate Letter at 2, 6; LeveL ATS
Letter at 1; Virtu Letter at 2; MFA Letter 2 at 30. But see Morgan
Stanley Letter at 1, 3 (stating that it is important to balance
public disclosure with disclosure more suitable for the Commission
(see discussion below and infra note 150 and accompanying text);
that certain disclosure requirements, such as any disclosure around
broker trading infrastructure and order handling practices beyond
ATS operations, should apply to all brokers (see discussion infra
note 217-218and accompanying text and infra Section III.A.2); and
that the Proposal treats all ATSs like exchanges and fails to
account for distinct ATS models (see discussion below and infra note
176 and accompanying text)). One commenter commented only on whether
the Proposal should apply to ATSs that trade only fixed-income
securities. See MarketAxcess Letter; infra Section III.A.2.
\109\ See generally Virtu Letter; T. Rowe Price Letter;
Schneiderman Letter; ICI Letter; MFA/AIMA Letter; Consumer
Federation of America Letter; CBOE Letter; Citadel Letter; Anonymous
Letter; Better Markets Letter; Investor Advocate Letter. See also
CFA Institute Letter at 6; SIFMA Letter at 3.
\110\ See SIFMA Letter at 3; Virtu Letter at 2; T. Rowe Price at
1; Schneiderman Letter at 1; MFA/AIMA Letter at 2; MFA Letter 2 at
30; CBOE Letter at 1; Citadel Letter at 1; Consumer Federation of
America Letter at 6; CFA Institute Letter at 3; Anonymous Letter at
1; KCG Letter at 3; Morgan Stanley Letter at 1; Investor Advocate
Letter at 6; Better Markets Letter at 1.
\111\ See ICI Letter at 4-6; Consumer Federation of America
Letter at 6; CFA Institute Letter at 3; Citadel Letter at 3; KCG
Letter at 3; STA Letter at 2; MFA/AIMA Letter at 4; CBOE Letter at
1; Investor Advocate Letter at 2, 8.
\112\ See Luminex Letter at 1; Fidelity Letter at 1; SSGA Letter
at 2; KCG Letter at 1; Citadel Letter at 1; ICI Letter at 3; STA
Letter at 2; Schneiderman Letter at 2; Consumer Federation of
America Letter at 6; Investor Advocate Letter at 11.
\113\ See Luminex Letter at 1.
\114\ See STA Letter at 2; Consumer Federation of America Letter
at 6; Investor Advocate Letter at 3, 11-12.
\115\ See Citadel Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to the Commission's effectiveness determination for
Form ATS-N, another commenter states that ``given the level of
competition between exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs, this effectiveness
determination would better align the Commission's oversight among
different types of trading venues.'' \116\ One commenter, however,
believes that ATSs do not add sufficient value to offset the regulatory
inequity and market fragmentation they have created.\117\ This
commenter also states that the Proposal represents ``meaningful
progress in the effort to increase the operational transparency of NMS
Stock ATSs.'' \118\ The Proposal was not designed to eliminate the
exemption from the definition of exchange that is currently available
to all ATSs, including NMS Stock ATSs. We believe that NMS Stock ATSs
play a significant role in equity market structure and provide market
participants with a variety of trading models to facilitate the
interaction and execution of orders in NMS stocks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\116\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 12.
\117\ See CBOE Letter at 1.
\118\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that the current market for NMS stock execution
services, consisting of national securities exchanges, NMS Stock ATSs,
and other off-exchange venues, has resulted in an improvement to market
efficiency.\119\ The changes to the requirements for NMS Stock ATSs
that we are adopting today will increase operational transparency for
these ATSs, bringing it more in line with the operational transparency
for national securities exchanges, while continuing to recognize the
difference in the business structure of ATSs as registered broker-
dealers. We also believe that while the rules adopted today will
increase the regulatory burden for NMS Stock ATSs and could result in
some NMS Stock ATSs electing to no longer operate as an ATS, those NMS
Stock ATSs that remain may compete more heavily with each other and
with national securities exchanges, which could ultimately result in
improvements to efficiency and capital formation.\120\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\119\ See infra Section X.B.6 (discussing the effects of NMS
Stock ATSs on the market for NMS stock execution services, including
fragmentation).
\120\ See infra Section X.C (discussing the expected economic
effects of today's rulemaking, as well as its expected effects on
efficiency, competition, and capital formation).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter believes that increased disclosure will aid in
developing industry-based standards.\121\ Three commenters state that
increased disclosure will boost investor confidence,\122\ and according
to one of these commenters, increased transparency and investor
confidence could lead to more investors using NMS Stock ATSs, and
result in greater price discovery and lower costs of capital
formation.\123\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\121\ See STA Letter at 2.
\122\ See CFA Institute Letter at 3; Schneiderman Letter at 2;
Investor Advocate Letter at 11-12.
\123\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 11, 12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that a wide range of market participants will benefit
from the enhanced operational transparency,
[[Page 38778]]
including, for example, fund managers and the many brokers that
subscribe to NMS Stock ATSs and route their orders, and those of their
customers, to NMS Stock ATSs for execution. Five commenters observe,
for example, that more transparency regarding ATS operations could
assist market participants in achieving best execution.\124\ One
commenter states that disclosure of material aspects of ATS operations
that allow market participants to weigh the costs and benefits of
venues is ``particularly important for asset managers who are acting in
a fiduciary capacity.'' \125\ Another commenter believes that making
Form ATS-N filings publicly available would provide a ``valuable tool
for funds to use to assess NMS Stock ATSs, make informed routing
decisions, and evaluate the performance of their brokers.'' \126\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\124\ See Citadel Letter at 1; Consumer Federation of America
Letter at 6; HMA Letter at 10; Luminex at 1; SIFMA Letter at 35.
\125\ See SSGA Letter at 2.
\126\ See ICI Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that the information disclosed on Form ATS-N will help
brokers meet their best execution obligations to their customers, as
they should be better able to assess the trading venues to which they
route orders.\127\ We also believe that asset managers and
institutional investors, who subscribe to an NMS Stock ATS or whose
orders may be routed to an NMS Stock ATS by their brokers, should have
more information about how NMS Stock ATSs operate, including how orders
and trading interest of the institutional investor may be displayed or
made known outside the ATS. This information also will enable asset
managers to better evaluate the routing decisions of their brokers,
including whether their brokers routed their orders to a venue that
best fits their trading interests.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\127\ See, e.g., Proposal, supra note 2, at 81002 n.36 and
accompanying text, 81013 n.187 and accompanying text (discussing
that the Consumer Federation of America previously commented that
Form ATS should require ATSs to provide ``critical details about an
ATS's participants, segmentation, and fee structure'' because the
``information will allow market participants, regulators, and third
party analysts to assess whether an ATS's terms of access and
service are such that it makes sense to trade on that venue'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Comments on Form ATS-N Requirement
Some commenters, however, believe NMS Stock ATSs should not be
required to comply with new Rule 304 and the Commission should instead
simply amend Regulation ATS to require making Form ATS public for NMS
Stock ATSs.\128\ Two of these commenters assert that the Commission
should mandate disclosure of current Form ATS as a first step to
increase disclosure before considering implementing more burdensome
disclosure requirements.\129\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\128\ See Luminex Letter at 2-3; PDQ Letter at 2; Fidelity
Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 3; Morgan Stanley Letter at 2.
\129\ See Fidelity Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not adopting commenters' suggestion to make Form ATS public
rather than requiring NMS Stock ATSs to comply with Rule 304 and file
Form ATS-N. First, we believe that new Form ATS-N requires important
additional disclosures that are not made under existing Form ATS.\130\
While Form ATS-N will require NMS Stock ATSs to disclose more
information than Form ATS, in response to certain comments, we have
reduced the burden of completing Form ATS-N by narrowing the scope of
several requests for information and, in some cases, eliminating
certain requests from the form.\131\ We have also simplified Form ATS-N
to make completing and maintaining the form less burdensome and have
modified questions so as not to solicit competitively sensitive
information.\132\ We believe that Form ATS-N disclosures will help
market participants compare and evaluate NMS Stock ATSs and make better
informed decisions about where to route their orders to achieve their
trading or investment objectives, enhance execution quality, and
improve efficiency and capital allocation.\133\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\130\ See infra Sections X.C.1 and X.C.2. We have considered any
additional burden that may result from completion of Form ATS-N and
the benefits of the additional information that will be made
available to market participants by requiring NMS Stock ATSs to file
Form ATS-N, and making Form ATS-N public. See id.
\131\ For example, we have narrowed a request for information
regarding trading by affiliates of the broker-dealer operator on the
NMS Stock ATS by requiring only the disclosures of affiliates that
can enter or direct the entry of orders and trading interest into
the ATS. See infra Section V.C.1. We are not requiring NMS Stock
ATSs to provide proposed Exhibit 1 to Form ATS-N. See infra Section
V.B.2. Exhibit 1 would have required that NMS Stock ATSs provide a
copy of any materials currently provided to subscribers or other
persons related to the operations of the ATS or the disclosures on
Form ATS-N, such as frequently asked questions, manuals, and
marketing materials.
\132\ See infra Section V.C.
\133\ See infra Section X.C.4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on Commission staff's experience reviewing disclosures made
by ATSs on Form ATS over the past 19 years and as discussed in the
Proposal, we have observed that ATSs have often provided minimal,
rudimentary, and summary disclosures about their operations on Form
ATS. One commenter agrees with our assessment, stating that based on
its review of publicly available Forms ATS, the forms ``often provide
minimal and often generalized information'' with respect to
classification and segmentation of subscribers, means of access to the
ATS, matching priority, order interaction, order types, and how the
NBBO is calculated, and they are often missing ``critical details''
about their operations.\134\ Further, this commenter states that
``[r]arely do Form ATSs provide information relating to their fee
structures and potential or actual conflicts of interest.'' \135\
According to another commenter, current Form ATS is ``not adequate'' to
allow the Commission and market participants to ``understand how NMS
Stock ATSs operate in today's environment, given the complexity and the
potential for significant conflicts of interest with the broker-dealer
operator.'' \136\ In addition, one commenter observes that market
participants currently receive ``varying levels'' of information about
the operations of the NMS Stock ATS.\137\ As described in the
Proposal,\138\ we believe that the complexity of NMS Stock ATS
operations has increased substantially and in a manner that causes the
current disclosure requirements of Form ATS to result in an
insufficient, and inconsistent, level of detail about the operations of
NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\134\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 3.
\135\ See id.
\136\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 8.
\137\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 1.
\138\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81011.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters argue that a new Form ATS-N is unnecessary because
most of the fundamental information required in Form ATS-N is currently
covered by Form ATS.\139\ In addition, three commenters suggest that,
as an alternative to requiring NMS Stock ATSs to file and make public
Form ATS-N, we should clarify the requests for information on Form ATS
and mandate that the revised Form ATS be made public.\140\ One of these
commenters believes such an approach would help achieve the
Commission's goal of operational transparency, while ``maintaining a
regulatory structure under which NMS Stock ATSs can continue to
innovate.'' \141\ Even if we were to ``clarify'' the requests for
information on Form ATS to standardize disclosures and make current and
past Forms ATS public, Form ATS does not require the
[[Page 38779]]
disclosure of certain information that will be required by Form ATS-N.
For example, Form ATS-N requires NMS Stock ATSs to disclose information
about the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates that will allow market participants to assess potential
conflicts of interest and information about the NMS Stock ATS's
safeguards and procedures to protect confidential trading information.
The disclosure requirements of Form ATS are not sufficient to provide
market participants with adequate information about the operational
complexity of NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that exist today. Form ATS-N
is designed to provide market participants with more robust, detailed,
and standardized disclosures, and to enable market participants to
better understand the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and potential
conflicts of interest between ATS operations and the other ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\139\ See Luminex Letter at 2-3; STANY Letter at 3.
\140\ See STANY Letter at 3; PDQ Letter at 2; Fidelity Letter at
5.
\141\ See STANY Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter who suggests making Form ATS public as an alternative
to requiring Form ATS-N expresses concern that the ``crippling amount
of detail'' required to be disclosed under Form ATS-N would not be
useful to market participants.\142\ We do not believe that Form ATS-N,
as modified from the Proposal, will require a ``crippling'' level of
detail that will only be useful to the Commission, and several
commenters agree that the Form ATS-N disclosures would be useful for
market participants in comparing trading venues and assessing conflicts
of interest.\143\ While Form ATS-N will require NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose more information than Form ATS, we have recognized commenters'
concerns regarding the burden of completing Form ATS-N by narrowing the
scope of several requests, eliminating certain requests altogether, and
simplifying its format.\144\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\142\ See id. at 4.
\143\ See supra notes 109-123 and accompanying text.
\144\ See infra Section V.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other commenters discuss how market participants currently glean
information about ATSs, and suggest that such methods could serve as
alternatives to the requirements of Rule 304, or inform the Rule 304
requirements.\145\ One commenter states that it performs periodic due
diligence on ATSs because it believes that as a fiduciary, it should
only trade on venues or exchanges that further its goals of satisfying
``best execution,'' that protect client information, and generally
support principles of fair access.\146\ This commenter also states that
currently, market participants perform such due diligence by sending
ATSs questionnaires.\147\ Similarly, another commenter observes that
ATSs are incentivized to respond to these questionnaires to attract
participants, and therefore, the Commission should not place additional
disclosure burdens on ATSs.\148\ We do not believe that the practice of
some market participants individually soliciting information about the
operations of NMS Stock ATSs and conflicts of interest through
questionnaires is an adequate alternative to Form ATS-N. We believe
that disclosures on Form ATS-N should be easily accessible to all
market participants. This is particularly important for NMS Stock ATSs
given how orders in NMS stocks may be routed among various trading
centers before receiving an execution. Based on the Commission's
experience, responses to questionnaires are generally unavailable to
non-subscribers, including potential subscribers and customers of
current subscribers. Without this information, potential subscribers
would be unable to fully assess an NMS Stock ATS as a trading center
and customers of subscribers would be inhibited from assessing their
broker's routing decisions. In addition, we believe, as indicated by
comments,\149\ that the publicly available, standardized disclosure
regime that will result from Rule 304 and Form ATS-N is critical for
all market participants to receive equal information about NMS Stock
ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\145\ See SSGA Letter at 2; PDQ Letter at 2; Morgan Stanley
Letter at 2.
\146\ See SSGA Letter at 2. See also Fidelity Letter at 8
(discussing that, from a due diligence perspective, subscribers may
require NMS Stock ATS information).
\147\ See SSGA Letter at 2. See also PDQ Letter at 2.
\148\ See PDQ Letter at 2.
\149\ See Virtu Letter at 2; Schneiderman Letter at 1; ICI
Letter at 3; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 6; and Citadel
Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that, as an alternative to the proposed Form
ATS-N, the Commission should mandate that ATS operators publicly
disclose current and historical Form ATS filings and related
amendments, and responses to standardized, frequently asked questions
(``FAQs'') regarding ATS operations.\150\ The commenter believes that
this approach would be ``more balanced and appropriate'' and ``less
burdensome and faster to implement.'' \151\ For the reasons discussed
above in this section, we believe that the requests on Form ATS are not
designed to produce adequate information for market participants about
the operational complexity of NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related
activities of their broker-dealer operators and their affiliates. We
also believe that making public an ATS's responses to standardized,
FAQs regarding its operations would not achieve the same level of
disclosure that Form ATS-N will require, and would not facilitate our
oversight of NMS Stock ATSs. Based on Commission experience, the
information required to be disclosed on Form ATS-N exceeds the
information provided by NMS Stock ATSs in their responses to FAQs and
will provide a greater benefit to market participants. In addition, NMS
Stock ATSs must file Form ATS-N disclosures with the Commission, which
will be subject to Commission review before they become public. As
discussed in the Proposal, the public disclosures on Form ATS-N are
designed to standardize the information available to all market
participants about NMS Stock ATSs and facilitate their ability to
compare and evaluate these trading venues.\152\ Finally, we believe
that the burden resulting from filing a Form ATS-N would not be
significant compared to requiring an NMS Stock ATS to prepare
disclosures on Form ATS and responses to FAQs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\150\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 2 (asserting that
``standardization is the key to concise, comparable and meaningful
information regarding ATS operations''). This commenter states that
while it supports the Proposal's effort to mandate transparency, it
is concerned that proposed Form ATS-N ``will result in more
subjective, narrative responses that will not lend themselves to
side-by-side comparison.'' See id. at 1.
\151\ See id. at 2.
\152\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81123. See also infra
Section V.A.1. We believe that requiring NMS Stock ATSs to provide
only ``yes'' or ``no'' responses would limit ATSs, which provide
diverse services and often operate uniquely, from accurately
describing their operations and inhibit market participants from
fully understanding the operations of the ATS or the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates. See id.
(discussing the Commission's belief that narrative responses are
important for market participants to understand the operations of
NMS Stock ATSs given differences across ATSs, and provide NMS Stock
ATSs with the flexibility in their responses).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received four comments about the application of Rule 304 to some
or all NMS Stock ATSs. We received three comments expressing the
importance of the Commission's need to heighten the regulatory
requirements for all NMS Stock ATSs.\153\ In particular, one commenter
states that the Commission's additional disclosure requirements are
important for creating a consistent and
[[Page 38780]]
fair set of obligations for all NMS Stock ATSs while providing market
participants and subscribers with complete information.\154\ This
commenter observes that although an ATS may have a small share of
volume relative to the overall equities trading marketplace, it does
not necessarily follow that such ATS has a similarly small share of
each subscriber's flow.\155\ Another commenter cautions the Commission
about allowing exemptions based on metrics such as dollar volume,
trading volume, or number of subscribers because allowing such
exemptions could increase ``incentives and opportunities'' for
regulatory arbitrage, and may result in unintended consequences.\156\
On the other hand, one commenter argues that the Commission should take
a tiered regulatory approach to NMS Stock ATSs by applying certain of
the enhanced requirements only to larger NMS Stock ATSs.\157\ This
commenter suggests that to foster competitive innovations among NMS
Stock ATSs, the Commission should only apply the requirement of prior
Commission ``approval'' of changes before they are implemented to
``larger ATSs with a substantial market footprint.'' \158\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\153\ See CFA Institute Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 2. See also
KCG Letter at 1.
\154\ See UBS Letter at 2.
\155\ See id.
\156\ See CFA Institute Letter at 3.
\157\ See STANY Letter at 2. See also Luminex Letter at 1.
\158\ See STANY Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that requiring all NMS Stock ATSs to
publicly file a Form ATS-N, irrespective of the volume of NMS stocks
transacted on the ATS is appropriate, and does not agree that its
objectives would be achieved by applying Rule 304 on a tiered basis to
NMS Stock ATSs. Given that broker-dealers can route their customers'
orders to any NMS Stock ATS for execution, we do not believe that
transaction volume in NMS stocks serves as a proxy for whether
customers of broker-dealers or subscribers to an ATS should have
information about how their orders would be prioritized, matched, or
executed on an NMS Stock ATS or understand the ATS-related activities
of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that may give rise to
conflicts of interest.\159\ As a result, customers of broker-dealers
that route their orders to NMS Stock ATSs with low volume will have the
same level of information to assess their broker-dealers' routing
decisions as customers of broker-dealers that may route orders to any
other NMS Stock ATSs. Amending Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a) to apply the
requirements of Rule 304 to all NMS Stock ATSs would promote efficient
and effective market operations by providing information all market
participants can use to evaluate all NMS Stock ATSs that could be
potential destinations for their orders. We believe that these
requirements, including the requirement that NMS Stock ATSs file
amendments to Form ATS-N in advance of adopting material changes,\160\
would not place an undue burden on smaller NMS Stock ATSs or their
ability to innovate.\161\ Smaller NMS Stock ATSs that are not operated
by multi-service broker-dealer operators and do not engage in other
brokerage or dealing activities in addition to their ATS operations
would have a lower burden than other ATSs because certain sections of
Form ATS-N (such as several items of Part II) may not be applicable to
these NMS Stock ATSs.\162\ We believe that the reduction in costs from
exempting small NMS Stock ATSs would be minimal as compared to the
benefits that would result from requiring the same level of
transparency from small NMS Stock ATSs as from other NMS Stock
ATSs.\163\ Further, under Regulation ATS, every ATS must currently wait
20 calendar days from the date of filing an amendment to Form ATS-N
before implementing a material change to its operations.\164\ In
addition, we believe that the new process for NMS Stock ATSs applicable
to filing material amendments is appropriate,\165\ and, like the other
requirements of Rule 304, should be applied consistently across NMS
Stock ATSs, regardless of their size or trading volume. The Commission
review process for Form ATS-N amendments is designed to improve
operational transparency for all market participants and not only for
market participants that use NMS Stock ATSs with significant trading
volume as compared to other NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\159\ National securities exchanges are subject to the same
public rule filing and registration requirements irrespective of the
volume transacted on the exchange. While an NMS Stock ATS may not
transact significant overall volume in NMS stocks, that ATS may
transact a significant volume of orders in certain NMS stocks or
orders for certain subscribers. Additionally, we also believe that
applying the enhanced regulatory requirements only to larger NMS
Stock ATSs could create an opportunity for arbitrage without
appropriate benefit, in that an NMS Stock ATS may be incentivized to
structure their operations to avoid being subject to enhanced
requirements. We believe that the burden of complying with the
enhanced regulatory requirements imposed on lower volume NMS Stock
ATSs is justified by the benefits. See infra Section X.D.4.
\160\ One commenter expresses its concern that ``small and
innovative ATSs will be frustrated by the requirement that changes
to their technology must be approved by the Commission prior to
implementation.'' See STANY Letter at 2. The Commission will not
``approve'' material amendments, but instead, may declare amendments
ineffective if the disclosures filed by an NMS Stock ATS on Form
ATS-N are materially deficient with respect to their completeness or
comprehensibility. See infra Section IV.B.2. In addition, we are
requiring that NMS Stock ATSs publicly disclose a brief summary of a
material amendment upon filing, and after the Commission has had an
opportunity to review the amendment, the material amendment would be
made public. This change from the Proposal is in response to
commenters who believe that an ATS may be placed at a competitive
disadvantage if it is required to publicly file a material change 30
calendar days before implementing the change. See infra Section
IV.E.2.c.
\161\ See infra Section X.D.4.
\162\ See infra Section V.C and Section X.C.4.a.
\163\ See infra Section X.D.4.
\164\ See supra note 58 and accompanying text.
\165\ See infra Section IV.B.1.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Comments on Effects on ATSs Relative to National Securities
Exchanges
We received comments regarding the competitive effect of Rule 304
on ATSs relative to national securities exchanges.\166\ Some commenters
support public disclosure of Form ATS-N on the grounds that the current
differences in transparency requirements for ATSs and national
securities exchanges are competitively unfair.\167\ On the other hand,
other commenters express concern about the competitive burden that the
requirements of Rule 304 could place on ATSs.\168\ Specifically, one
commenter states that not extending the enhanced transparency
requirements to national securities exchanges may ``result in a
competitive advantage to exchanges.'' \169\ We believe that the new
disclosure requirements for NMS Stock ATSs are not more rigorous than
the disclosure standards for national securities exchanges and will not
provide national securities exchanges with a competitive advantage over
NMS Stock ATSs. National securities exchanges are required to publicly
file proposed rule changes with the Commission to disclose, among other
things, their manner of operations and fees.\170\ These proposed rules
changes are subject to notice and comment from the public, as well as
Commission consideration, pursuant to Section 19(b) and 17 CFR 240.19b-
4 (Rule 19b-4).\171\ This is not the case for NMS Stock ATSs.
Furthermore, Form ATS-N is designed to solicit information about ATS-
related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates to
help
[[Page 38781]]
market participants better understand potential conflicts of interest
and information leakage. In the context of national securities
exchanges, we have expressed concern that the affiliation of a national
securities exchange with one of its members raises potential conflicts
of interest, and the potential for unfair competitive advantage; and
because the Commission reviews the rules of national securities
exchanges, a process which requires, among other things, that to
approve certain rule changes the Commission find that the proposed rule
change is consistent with the Exchange Act, each existing national
securities exchange has implemented rules that restrict affiliation
between the exchange and its members to mitigate the potential for
these types of conflicts of interest.\172\ NMS Stock ATSs are not
subject to such restrictions with respect to the activities of their
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that may raise conflicts of
interests.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\166\ See, e.g., Anonymous Letter at 1, Citadel Letter at 1;
Markit Letter at 4; STANY Letter at 3.
\167\ See Anonymous Letter at 1; Citadel Letter at 1.
\168\ See Markit Letter at 4; STANY Letter at 3.
\169\ See Markit Letter at 4.
\170\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81011.
\171\ See id.
\172\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81042 n. 370-372 and
accompanying text. In cases where we have approved exceptions to
this prohibition, there have been limitations and conditions on the
activities of the national securities exchange and its affiliated
member designed to address concerns about potential conflicts of
interest and unfair competitive advantage. See id. at 81042 n.372.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states its view that requiring public disclosure
of Form ATS-N will ``alter the competitive landscape . . . between NMS
Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges.'' \173\ We continue to
believe that since the adoption of Regulation ATS, the market in
execution services for NMS stocks has evolved such that trading
functions of NMS Stock ATSs have become more functionally similar to
those of national securities exchanges.\174\ The enhanced transparency
requirements for NMS Stock ATSs are designed to allow market
participants to compare execution services of NMS Stock ATSs against
national securities exchanges, to appropriately calibrate the level of
transparency between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges,
and to foster even greater competition for order flow of NMS stocks
between those trading centers.\175\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\173\ See STANY Letter at 3.
\174\ See supra Section II.D.
\175\ See infra Section X.C.2.a (discussing the economic
benefits of the new disclosure requirements). See also Section
X.C.4.a.i.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter asserts that the Proposal treats all ATSs as stand-
alone, exchange-like price/time priority models and fails to account
for distinct ATS models (e.g. price/capacity/size priority and interval
VWAP crossing) and does not consider that an ATS may be part of a
broader, integrated electronic offering available to clients choosing
to access the markets through a full-service broker-dealer.\176\ This
commenter also states that while Regulation ATS recognizes the
distinction between exchanges and ATS offerings, the regulatory
structure specifically tailored for exchanges can be seen throughout
much of the Proposal and proposed Form ATS-N, such as in the Proposal's
focus on: Subscribers, in the way an exchange has members; a subscriber
manual, in the way an exchange has a rule book; and fees, similar to an
exchange fee schedule.\177\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\176\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 3.
\177\ See id. at 2-3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter questions why the Commission has determined that NMS
Stock ATSs should be subject to ``essentially similar disclosure
requirements'' as national securities exchanges without affording NMS
Stock ATSs benefits such as limited immunity and market data revenue
that national securities exchanges receive.\178\ NMS Stock ATSs, unlike
registered national securities exchanges, are registered as broker-
dealers and exempt from the requirements of, among other provisions,
Sections 6 and 19(b) of the Exchange Act. However, an NMS Stock ATS
that desires the benefits afforded to national securities exchanges can
choose to register as a national securities exchange under Section 6 of
the Exchange Act \179\ and be subject to the requirements of, among
other provisions, Sections 6 and 19(b) of the Exchange Act. In
addition, we do not agree with the commenter's view that the disclosure
requirements with which NMS Stock ATSs must comply are ``essentially
similar'' to the disclosure requirements imposed on national securities
exchanges. For example, a national securities exchange is required to
file with the Commission all rule changes establishing or changing a
due, fee, or other charge assessed to members, which the Commission
reviews for consistency with the Exchange Act.\180\ In contrast, an NMS
Stock ATS will be required to provide disclosure on the types of fees
and charges of the NMS Stock ATS.\181\ Further, disclosure is only one
of the requirements to which national securities exchanges are subject.
Notably, the rules and changes to the rules of national securities
exchanges are required to be filed with the Commission and are subject
to public notice and comment.\182\ NMS Stock ATSs are not subject to
these requirements, as well as many others, applicable to national
securities exchanges.\183\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\178\ See Fidelity Letter at 4.
\179\ See 15 U.S.C. 78f. An ATS is not required to comply with
the requirements of Rule 301(b) if it is registered as an exchange
under Section 6 of the Exchange Act. See 17 CFR 242.301(a)(1).
\180\ See 17 CFR 240.19b-4(f)(2). Another commenter states that
while Regulation ATS recognizes the distinction between national
securities exchanges and ATS offerings, the regulatory structure
tailored for national securities exchanges can be seen throughout
much of the Proposal and proposed Form ATS-N, and included as
examples the Proposal's focus on disclosures regarding subscribers,
subscriber manuals, and fees, as well as the public posting upon
filing of amendments to Form ATS-N. See Morgan Stanley Letter at 3-
4. This commenter believes this approach is contrary to the
objectives of Regulation ATS and urges the Commission to reconsider
aspects of the Proposal that have the effect of not recognizing the
materially different roles that ATSs and exchanges are intended to
play in the U.S. marketplace. See id at 4. We agree that registered
broker-dealers that operate ATSs should continue to be able to avail
themselves of the exemption from the definition of ``exchange''
provided by Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1 and Regulation ATS, but believe
that due to changes in the role and operation of NMS Stock ATSs
since the adoption of Regulation ATS, it is in the public interest
to update the requirements for that exemption applicable to that
subset of ATSs. Also many of the disclosure items identified by this
commenter are the kinds of disclosures other commenters have
described as significant to their understanding of the operation of
NMS Stock ATSs.
\181\ See infra Section V.D.19.
\182\ See generally 15 U.S.C. 78s(b); 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
\183\ See 15 U.S.C. 78f(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges are subject
to different regulatory regimes, NMS Stock ATSs are trading centers
that perform similar trading functions as national securities exchanges
and have evolved to become more like national securities exchanges in
their operations. We believe that Form ATS-N, as adopted, accommodates
the differences between the regulatory requirements for national
securities exchanges and those of NMS Stock ATSs while increasing
public operational transparency for NMS Stock ATSs. The Commission does
not agree that NMS Stock ATSs are being treated like national
securities exchanges and believes that Form ATS-N is designed in a
manner that allows ATSs to explain their unique business models. For
example, NMS Stock ATSs will be able to explain their trading models,
and associated facilities and procedures, in Part III, Item 11 of
adopted Form ATS-N (``Trading, Rules and Facilities''). In addition,
Part III, Item 19 (``Fees'') requires an NMS Stock ATS to identify and
describe the types of fees or charges of the ATS and any differences
among subscribers, whereas national securities exchanges are required
to publicly post their complete fee schedules and any changes are
subject to the SRO rule filing process under Section 19 of the
[[Page 38782]]
Exchange Act. The Commission also understands that some broker-dealer
operators offer their NMS Stock ATSs along with other execution and
routing services. We believe that requests on Form ATS-N are
appropriately designed, and provide narrative flexibility, to elicit
information about the varying NMS Stock ATS models, including those of
multi-service broker-dealers.\184\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\184\ See, e.g., infra Section V.D.11 (describing Part III, Item
11 of Form ATS-N, which asks NMS Stock ATSs to provide a summary of
their marketplaces and the means and facilities for bringing
together the orders of multiple buyers and sellers on the NMS Stock
ATS).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Comments on Effectiveness Requirement
We proposed that to qualify for the exemption from the definition
of ``exchange,'' an NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N must be declared
effective by the Commission; as adopted, a Form ATS-N must be effective
for the ATS to qualify for the exemption.\185\ Several commenters
express their support for requiring that Form ATS-N be subject to
Commission review,\186\ and some commenters support the proposed
requirement that Form ATS-N be declared effective by the
Commission,\187\ while other commenters raise concerns about requiring
that Form ATS-N be declared effective by the Commission.\188\ One
commenter states that the proposed effective/ineffective process is
``unnecessary'' and ``will have a chilling effect'' on, or stifle
innovation of, ATS operations.\189\ Another commenter similarly
questions the need for the Commission to make a determination of
effectiveness for Form ATS-N, and expresses concern that such a process
would increase the regulatory risk for new NMS Stock ATSs and stifle
innovation in the ATS marketplace by delaying the effectiveness of NMS
Stock ATSs whose features, while meeting regulatory requirements, do
not meet industry norms.\190\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\185\ See infra Section IV.A.1. As adopted, the Commission will
not declare initial Form ATS-N filings effective under Rule 304.
\186\ See Citadel Letter at 3; HMA Letter at 7-8; and Investor
Advocate Letter at 11-12.
\187\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4; CFA Institute Letter at 4; and
PDQ Letter at 2. Two commenters do not object to the effectiveness
process. See Liquidnet Letter at 3 and STANY Letter at 2.
\188\ See Luminex Letter at 1; Fidelity Letter at 8-9.
\189\ See Luminex Letter at 1.
\190\ See Fidelity Letter at 8-9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe that requiring Form ATS-N to become effective
after Commission review is ``unnecessary;'' \191\ rather, the review
process will facilitate the Commission's oversight of NMS Stock ATSs
and help ensure that information required by the form is disclosed in a
complete and comprehensible manner. We have modified the proposed
effectiveness process for initial Form ATS-N so that the Commission
will not declare initial Form ATS-N effective; instead, initial Form
ATS-N, as amended, will become effective, unless declared ineffective,
upon the earlier of: (1) The completion of review by the Commission and
publication pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2), or (2) the expiration of the
Commission review period, or, if applicable, the extended review
period.\192\ Form ATS-N will nevertheless be subject to Commission
review, and, as proposed, the Commission may declare a Form ATS-N
ineffective if it finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that
such action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is
consistent with the protection of investors.\193\ We believe that
requiring Form ATS-N to be effective, which would occur only after
being subject to Commission review, could incentivize NMS Stock ATSs to
make more detailed and informative disclosures than under current Form
ATS. While requiring Form ATS-N to be effective may have some impact on
innovation,\194\ our review of Form ATS-N is designed to mitigate any
effect on innovation, and accordingly would focus on, for example, the
completeness and comprehensibility of the Form ATS-N disclosures and
not include a review of the merits of the disclosures or whether such
trading functionalities meet industry norms.\195\ We do not believe
that requiring Form ATS-N to be effective will unduly increase the
``regulatory risk'' of launching a new NMS Stock ATS as one commenter
suggests.\196\ We understand that the Commission review process will
generate some uncertainty for NMS Stock ATSs as a Form ATS-N could be
declared ineffective, which is not currently the case with respect to
Form ATS.\197\ The Commission review process, however, will not be
merit based, and determinations of ineffectiveness will require the
Commission to make certain findings after notice to the NMS Stock ATS
and opportunity for hearing.\198\ In addition, the rule provides that
if the Commission does not declare the Form ineffective before the end
of a fixed time period, the Form ATS-N will become effective. We
believe that these factors will provide NMS Stock ATSs with greater
regulatory certainty regarding the effectiveness process.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\191\ See supra note 189 and accompanying text.
\192\ See infra Sections IV.A.3.c and IV.A.4.a.
\193\ See id.
\194\ See infra Section X.C.
\195\ See supra note 190 and accompanying text. See also infra
Section IV.A.3.d.
\196\ See supra note 190 and accompanying text.
\197\ See infra Section X.C.4.
\198\ See infra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Comments on Extending Rule 304 to Non-NMS Stock ATSs
Rule 304 of Regulation ATS, as proposed and adopted, would apply
only to NMS Stock ATSs, as defined in Rule 300(k) of Regulation ATS. We
are concerned that, given the significance of NMS Stock ATSs in equity
market structure and their operational complexities, the lack of
transparency around NMS Stock ATSs operations could inhibit market
participants' ability to evaluate NMS Stock ATSs as potential routing
destinations for their orders in NMS stocks. As discussed in the
Proposal, we did not propose to apply Rule 304 to non-NMS Stock ATSs,
which would include ATSs that trade corporate or municipal fixed income
securities (``Fixed Income ATSs''), U.S. Government securities
(``Government Securities ATSs''),\199\ or OTC Equity securities (``OTC
Equity Securities ATSs'').\200\ We sought comment on whether Rule 304,
in whole or in part, should apply to Fixed Income ATSs, Government
Securities ATSs, and OTC Equity Securities ATSs.\201\ We also did not
propose to apply Rule 304 to any other type of trading center besides
NMS Stock ATSs,\202\ such as non-ATS OTC trading centers \203\ or
national securities exchanges.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\199\ The term ``U.S. Government securities'' is defined under
Section 3(a)(42) of the Exchange Act. See 15 U.S.C. 78c(a)(42)
(defining ``government securities'' as, among other things,
``securities which are direct obligations of, or obligations
guaranteed as to principal or interest by, the United States'').
\200\ For purposes of this discussion, we are using the term
``OTC Equity Security'' as it is defined in FINRA's 6400 rule series
for quoting and trading in OTC Equity Securities. FINRA defines OTC
Equity Security as ``any equity security that is not an `NMS stock'
as that term is defined in Rule 600(b)(47) of SEC Regulation NMS;
provided, however, that the term `OTC Equity Security' shall not
include any Restricted Equity Security,'' which FINRA defines as
``any equity security that meets the definition of `restricted
security' as contained in Securities Act Rule 144(a)(3).'' See FINRA
Rules 6420(f), (k).
\201\ See Proposal, supra note 1, at 81018.
\202\ See Proposal, supra note 2. See also infra note 668 and
accompanying text (discussing the term ``trading center'').
\203\ For purposes of this discussion, references to non-ATS OTC
trading centers, as used herein, encompass all executions that occur
off a national securities exchange and outside an ATS, including
when a broker-dealer is acting as an OTC market maker, block
positioner (i.e., any broker-dealer in the business of executing, as
principal or agent, block size trades for its customers), or
operation of an internal broker-dealer system. See 17 CFR
242.600(b)(52) (defining ``OTC market maker'' as any dealer that
holds itself out as being willing to buy and sell to its customers,
or others, in the United States, an NMS stock for its own account on
a regular or continuous basis otherwise than on a national
securities exchange in amounts of less than block size); 17 CFR
242.600(b)(9) (defining ``block size'' as an order of at least
10,000 shares or for a quantity of stock having a market value of at
least $200,000); and 17 CFR 240.17a-3(a)(16)(ii)(A) (defining
``internal broker-dealer system'' as any facility, other than a
national securities exchange, an exchange exempt from registration
based on limited volume, or an alternative trading system as defined
in Regulation ATS that provides a mechanism, automated in full or in
part, for collecting, receiving, disseminating, or displaying system
orders and facilitating agreement to the basic terms of a purchase
or sale of a security between a customer and the sponsor, or between
two customers of the sponsor, through use of the internal broker-
dealer system or through the broker or dealer sponsor of such
system). See also 2010 Equity Market Structure Release, supra note
13, at 3599-3600.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38783]]
We received several comments generally supporting operational
transparency and about whether or not to apply Rule 304 to non-NMS
Stock ATSs.\204\ Of the commenters generally supporting enhanced
operational transparency, several encourage the Commission to make the
current Form ATS public for all ATSs.\205\ Some commenters urge the
Commission to amend Regulation ATS to apply Rule 304 to all ATSs.\206\
Two commenters explicitly support applying the Proposal solely to NMS
Stock ATSs.\207\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\204\ See Better Markets Letter at 3, 8; CFA Institute Letter;
Citadel Letter; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 6-7;
Fidelity Letter at 6-7; HMA Letter at 5-6, 10, 12; ICI Letter at 11;
Investor Advocate Letter at 2, 12-15; KCG Letter at 12-13; Liquidnet
Letter at 3; Luminex Letter at 2, 4; MarketAxess Letter; Markit
Letter at 2, 4, 9; MFA/AIMA Letter 2-4; MFA Letter 2 at 30; Morgan
Stanley Letter at 5-6; PDQ Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 3, 5; STANY
Letter at 5; T. Rowe Price Letter at 2; Virtu Letter at 2.
\205\ See Fidelity Letter at 7; ICI Letter at 11; Luminex Letter
at 2; Morgan Stanley Letter 2, 5; Investor Advocate Letter at 2-3;
PDQ Letter at 2; STANY Letter at 3; SIFMA Letter at 3-4.
\206\ See Better Markets Letter at 3, 8; CFA Institute Letter at
3-4; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 6-7; HMA Letter 5-6,
10, 12.
\207\ See ICI Letter at 11; Liquidnet Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters specifically argue for extending Rule 304,
including Form ATS-N, to Fixed Income ATSs.\208\ Several commenters,
however, recommend against extending the Proposal requirements for NMS
Stock ATSs to Fixed Income ATSs.\209\ Several commenters suggest that
the Commission require Fixed Income ATSs to make their Forms ATS
public.\210\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\208\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 6; Better
Markets Letter at 8; CFA Institute Letter at 3-4; HMA Letter at 10;
MFA/AIMA Letter at 2-3.
\209\ See Fidelity Letter at 6-7; KCG Letter at 12-13; Liquidnet
Letter at 3; MarketAxess Letter at 3-4 ; Markit Letter at 9; SIFMA
Letter at 3.
\210\ See Fidelity Letter at 6; SIFMA Letter at 34-35; Markit
Letter at 9; Investor Advocate Letter at 12-16; ICI Letter at 11.
See also Luminex Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received several comments that specifically address
enhancing operational transparency for, or extending Rule 304 to,
Government Securities ATSs.\211\ Several commenters support applying
Rule 304 requirements to Government Securities ATSs,\212\ while several
state that Regulation ATS should be amended to include electronic
platforms for U.S. Government securities.\213\ Other commenters believe
that the Commission should gather additional information on fixed
income markets, which include U.S. Government securities markets, and
as an interim step, make the Form ATS filings for these ATSs
public.\214\ We also received comments that specifically oppose
applying the Proposal requirements to Government Securities ATSs,\215\
or more generally oppose expanding Rule 304 to non-NMS Stock ATSs.\216\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\211\ See Better Markets Letter at 8; CFA Institute Letter at 3-
4; Citadel Letter at 4-5; Investor Advocate Letter at 16-17; KCG
Letter; Liquidnet Letter at 3; MFA/AIMA Letter at 2-7; SIFMA Letter
at 3, 5, 35-36; Virtu Letter at 2.
\212\ Some commenters specifically support operational
transparency and enhanced monitoring of trading activity for
Government Securities ATSs. See Virtu Letter at 2; Better Markets
Letter at 8; CFA Institute Letter at 3-4; Citadel Letter at 4-5;
MFA/AIMA Letter at 2-7. See also Liquidnet Letter at 3 (stating that
it does ``not object'' to the requirements of Regulation ATS
applying to systems that cross trades in U.S. Government
securities).
\213\ See Citadel Letter at 4-5; Liquidnet Letter at 3; Investor
Advocate Letter at 16-19; Virtu Letter at 2. One commenter combined
its support for transparency of ATSs that trade U.S. Government
securities and Fixed Income ATSs. See MFA/AIMA Letter at 3-4
\214\ See SIFMA Letter at 34-35; Markit Letter at 9; Investor
Advocate Letter, at 14. See also Fidelity Letter at 6.
\215\ See KCG Letter at 13; SIFMA Letter at 3, 5, 36.
\216\ See supra note 209 accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received comments regarding enhancing operational
transparency for other non-ATS OTC trading centers--namely broker-
dealers that internalize order flow.\217\ In general, these commenters
point out the discrepancy in disclosure obligations that would result
from the Proposal, or the possibility that broker-dealers would route
order flow to non-ATS trading centers as a result.\218\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\217\ See ICI Letter at 12; Morgan Stanley Letter at 2-3.
\218\ See id. See also Fidelity Letter at 11-12. Another
commenter recommends that the Commission be required to conduct a
review within a designated time-period to assess the effectiveness
of the new rules and determine if any refinements should be
proposed. See T. Rowe Price Letter at 3. In addition, one commenter
suggests that regulators periodically monitor the development of the
market and technological developments, and take appropriate action
as needed. See Barnard Letter at 3. In addition to the Commission's
ongoing oversight responsibilities under the Exchange Act, Rule 304
provides a process for the Commission to review disclosures filed on
Form ATS-N, either through an initial Form ATS-N, Form ATS-N
amendment, or cessation of operations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given the range of commenter views on these questions and our
belief that it is appropriate to take an incremental approach by first
applying the amended regime to NMS Stock ATSs before considering a
further step, we are not amending Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS for
non-NMS Stock ATSs. We intend to monitor the implementation and
effectiveness of Rule 304 to NMS Stock ATSs, and should we decide to
take further action with respect to non-NMS Stock ATSs, we would do so
in a separate rulemaking and take into account our experience with Rule
304 and NMS Stock ATSs.
The Commission notes that the Fixed Income Market Structure
Advisory Committee (``FIMSAC'') was formed in 2017 pursuant to the
Commission's authority under the Federal Advisory Committee Act to
provide the Commission with diverse perspectives on the structure and
operations of the U.S. fixed income markets, as well as advice and
recommendations on matters related to fixed income market
structure.\219\ The FIMSAC recently issued recommendations for the
Commission to review the framework for the oversight of electronic
trading platforms for municipal securities and corporate bonds.
Specifically, the FIMSAC recommended that the Commission form, together
with FINRA and the MSRB, a joint working group to review the regulatory
framework for oversight of electronic trading platforms used in the
municipal securities and corporate bond markets.\220\ In light of
recent recommendations of the FIMSAC, and comments received, we will
review the regulatory framework for fixed income electronic trading
platforms, including to consider whether we should propose amendments
to Regulation ATS (and any other applicable rules) to account for
operational and regulatory differences among electronic trading
[[Page 38784]]
platforms for municipal securities and corporate bonds.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\219\ See 5 U.S.C.--App; Securities Exchange Act Release No.
81958 (October 26, 2017), 82 FR 50460 (October 31, 2017) (Notice of
Federal Advisory Committee Establishment).
\220\ See Recommendation for the SEC to Review the Framework for
the Oversight of Electronic Trading Platforms for Corporate and
Municipal Bonds (July 16, 2018) available on the Commission's
website at https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/fixed-income-advisory-committee/fimsac-electronic-trading-platforms-recommendation.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Amendments to Existing Regulation ATS Rules for NMS Stock ATSs
To operate pursuant to the Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1a(2) exemption,
NMS Stock ATSs will be required to comply with new Rule 304, in
addition to the applicable existing Rules 300 through 303 of Regulation
ATS. In light of the new requirements of Rule 304, we are adopting,
with modifications discussed below, amendments to several existing
rules of Regulation ATS.
1. Rule 300(k): Definition of NMS Stock ATS
Proposed Rule 300(k) of Regulation ATS defined ``NMS Stock ATS'' in
new paragraph (k) as ``an alternative trading system, as defined in
Sec. 242.300(a), that facilitates transactions in NMS stocks, as
defined in Sec. 242.300(g).'' We received no comments on the proposed
definition of NMS Stock ATS and are adopting Rule 300(k) with
modifications. We are replacing ``facilitates transactions in'' with
``trades.'' The term ``trades'' is well understood in the context
Regulation ATS \221\ and the term ``facilitates'' is not used in the
definition of an ATS. This change is non-substantive and will clarify
the rule text.\222\ Accordingly, Rule 300(k), as adopted, defines an
``NMS Stock ATS'' as ``an alternative trading system, as defined in
paragraph (a) of [Rule 300], that trades NMS stocks, as defined in
paragraph (g) of [Rule 300].''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\221\ We believe that the concept of NMS Stock ATSs ``trading''
or ``transacting'' in NMS stocks, should be familiar to existing NMS
Stock ATSs as Form ATS requires disclosure regarding, among other
things ``the types of securities the [ATS] trades'' and ``the name
of any entity, other than the [ATS] that will be involved in the
operation of the [ATS], including the execution, trading, clearing,
and settling of transactions on behalf of the [ATS].'' See Form ATS.
Additionally, Form ATS requires disclosure regarding ``[t]he
procedures governing execution, reporting, clearance and settlement
of transactions effected through the [ATS]''; and Form ATS-R
requires NMS Stock ATSs to ``[p]rovide the total unit and dollar
volume of transactions'' in specified securities categories. See
Form ATS and Form ATS-R.
\222\ As proposed, an NMS Stock ATS would include any ATS that
effects transactions in securities that are listed on a national
securities exchange (other than options, debt or convertible debt).
See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81015-81016.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Rule 301(a): Exemption From Compliance With Regulation ATS
We made explicit in proposed Rule 304(a) that NMS Stock ATSs must
comply with Rules 300 through 304, unless not required to comply with
Regulation ATS pursuant to Rule 301(a). Pursuant to Rule 301(a),
certain ATSs that are subject to other appropriate regulations are not
required to comply with Regulation ATS.\223\ To the extent that an NMS
Stock ATS meets the criteria of the Rule 301(a) exemption, such ATS
would not be required to comply with Rules 300 through 304 of
Regulation ATS. We received no comments on the application of Rule
301(a) to NMS Stock ATSs and are adopting as proposed this language in
Rule 304(a) to make clear that Rules 300 through 303 of Regulation ATS,
including Rule 301(a) continue to apply to NMS Stock ATSs, unless
otherwise provided by Rule 301(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\223\ ATSs that are not subject to Rule 301(a) include those
that are: Registered as an exchange under Section 6 of the Exchange
Act; exempt from national securities exchange registration based on
limited volume; operated by a national securities association;
registered as a broker-dealer, under Sections 15(b) or 15C of the
Exchange Act, or that are banks, and that limit their securities
activities to certain instruments; or exempted, conditionally or
unconditionally, by Commission order, after application by such ATS
from one or more of the requirements of Rule 301(b). See 17 CFR
242.301(a). See also Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3,
at 70859-63.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Rule 301(a)(5): Exemptions From Certain Requirements of Regulation
ATS Pursuant to Application to the Commission
Rule 301(a)(5) of Regulation provides that an ATS shall comply with
the requirements of Rule 301(b) unless such ATS is exempted,
conditionally or unconditionally, by Commission order after application
by such ATS, from one or more of the requirements of Rule 301(b), and
that the Commission will grant such exemption only after determining
that such an order is consistent with the public interest, the
protection of investors, and the removal of impediments to, and
perfection of, a national market system.\224\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\224\ See 17 CFR 242.301(a)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When adopting Rule 301(a)(5), we stated that while the requirements
of Regulation ATS are appropriate for all ATSs, a system may develop in
the future for which these requirements may not be appropriate. The
Commission expected to issue such an order only under unusual
circumstances, and only after making the applicable determination.\225\
The requirements of Rule 304 were not part of Regulation ATS at the
time the Commission adopted Rule 301(a)(5). We believe that, given the
amendments to Regulation ATS that will require NMS Stock ATSs to comply
with the filing requirements of Rule 304, including filing Form ATS-N,
instead of the Form ATS filing requirements of Rules 301(b)(2)(i)-
(vii), it may be appropriate under certain limited, unusual facts and
circumstances for the Commission to exempt an NMS Stock ATS,
conditionally or unconditionally, by Commission order, from one or more
requirements of Rule 304. As such, we are amending Rule 301(a)(5) to
include exemptions from the requirements of Rule 304.\226\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\225\ Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70863.
\226\ The Commission continues to also have general exemptive
authority pursuant to Section 36(a) of the Exchange Act to grant
both conditional and unconditional exemptions from any provisions or
provisions of the Exchange Act, or any rule or regulation thereunder
(including Rule 304 and any other provision of Rule 3a1-1 and
Regulation ATS), to the extent necessary or appropriate in the
public interest and consistent with the protection of investors. See
15 U.S.C. 78mm(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to the Proposal, we received one comment regarding
possible use of the Commission Section 36 exemptive authority in
connection with the requirements of Rule 304.\227\ This commenter
states that instead of modifying the requirements under the Proposal in
such a way that could result in less relevant information being
provided to the Commission and to the public, certain concerns of other
commenters could be addressed through use of the Commission's Section
36 exemptive authority. Specifically, this commenter observes that an
NMS Stock ATS could seek relief tailored to its unique facts and
circumstances pursuant to Section 36(a)(1) of the Exchange Act, and
that Section 36(a)(1) permits the Commission to grant both conditional
and unconditional exemptions from any provisions of a rule, to the
extent necessary or appropriate in the public interest and consistent
with the protection of investors.\228\ This commenter also states that
using Section 36 exemptive authority would be consistent with the
manner in which the Commission generally treats requests it receives
from regulated entities, and encourages the Commission to consider
providing guidance as to what factors it might consider when evaluating
a request for specific exemptive relief.\229\ We believe that
amendments made to Rule 301(a)(5) make clear that the Commission could
[[Page 38785]]
exempt an NMS Stock ATS, conditionally or unconditionally, by order,
after application by the ATS from one or more of the requirements of
Rule 304 of Regulation ATS provided that the Commission determines that
such an exemption is consistent with the public interest, the
protection of investors, and removal of impediments to, and perfection
of the mechanisms of, a national market system.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\227\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 8.
\228\ See id. See also infra notes 723-725 and accompanying text
(discussing this comment in the specific context of disclosures
regarding affiliates of the broker-dealer operator).
\229\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 9. For example, in the
context of any exemptions from the requirements applicable to
disclosures regarding affiliates of the broker-dealer operator of an
NMS Stock ATS, the commenter encouraged the Commission to consider
providing guidance as to what facts and circumstances it might
consider when evaluating a broker-dealer operator's request for
exemptive relief. See id. See also infra notes 723-725 and
accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received other comments regarding specific exceptions from
the proposed requirements of Rule 304. Specifically, three commenters
suggest providing an exception to the 30-calendar day advance notice
requirement for material changes in case of exigent circumstances.\230\
One commenter states that unless the Commission narrows the materiality
standard for material amendments, the 30-calendar day advance notice
requirement could affect an ATS operator's ability to take ``decisive
action.'' \231\ This commenter further believes that NMS Stock ATS
operators often must take decisive action without time for a lengthy
review and approval process, given that the speed of response to
technical or operational issues (including cybersecurity) often is
measured in seconds. This commenter believes there should be a carve-
out for exigent circumstances when an NMS Stock ATS must act
swiftly.\232\ Another commenter states that there could be situations
in which it would be difficult for an NMS Stock ATS to meet the 30-
calendar day advance notice requirement based on ongoing business
changes, and that the Commission should clarify that certain Form ATS-N
disclosures may be subject to immediate change without notice.\233\
Another commenter states that the Commission should allow for more
rapid action (than the 30-day advance notice requirement) in the event
of an ``external emergency,'' such as an extreme market event, but that
such circumstances should be rare and only granted upon express
approval of the Commission, upon a finding that such action is
necessary to protect investors and promote fair and efficient
markets.\234\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\230\ See HMA Letter at 10; SIFMA Letter at 31; KCG Letter at
10.
\231\ See SIFMA Letter at 31.
\232\ See id.
\233\ See KCG Letter at 10. The commenter states that, for
example, if a broker-dealer operator provides a disclosure that it
routes orders to the ATS from its algorithmic business, and the data
center from which the algorithmic business operates subsequently
experiences systems issues that force it to stop routing orders to
the ATS, the disclosure would no longer be accurate and the broker-
dealer operator would not be in position to provide 30-calendar day
advance notice of the change.
\234\ See HMA Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that there may be unusual circumstances under which an
NMS Stock ATS may need to seek an exemption from the requirements of
Rule 304 or the disclosure requirements of Form ATS-N. For example,
under exceptionally rare occasions, an NMS Stock ATS may need to make a
material change to its operations on an expedited basis to prevent
substantial harm to market participants, such as in response to a
significant operational or market-wide event. The amendments to Rule
301(a)(5) are designed to address these concerns.\235\ Applications for
relief from a requirement of Rule 304 generally should explain why the
applicant believes the relief sought is consistent with the public
interest, the protection of investors, and the removal and impediments
to, and perfection of the mechanism of, a national market system.\236\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\235\ As amended, Rule 301(a)(5) will apply to ATSs that have
received exemptive relief from one or more requirements of Rule 304.
See Rule 301(a)(5).
\236\ Applications for exemptive relief from the 30-calendar day
advance notice requirement of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) generally should,
for example, contain a description of the circumstances that
necessitate the implementation of the material change on an
expedited basis, and why, in the view of the NMS Stock ATS,
expedited implementation is necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and consistent with the protection of investors, such as
why the expedited implementation is necessary to prevent substantial
harm to investors. The Commission will not consider hypothetical or
anonymous requests for exemptive relief.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As noted by commenters, circumstances may necessitate the
implementation of a material change to the operations of an NMS Stock
ATS on an expedited basis. We believe that, based on particular facts
and circumstances, it may be appropriate to grant such an exemption
from the 30-day advance notice requirement of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A), for
example, in the event of extraordinary, unforeseen circumstances, and
if delaying implementation pursuant to the 30-calendar day advance
notice requirement would cause substantial harm to subscribers or other
markets trading NMS stocks. By comparison, to the extent that an NMS
Stock ATS may need to change its operations in response to an
operational problem, as suggested by one commenter, an NMS Stock ATS
could proactively develop and disclose in the relevant Form ATS-N Item
alternative procedures that the ATS would apply if the ATS experiences
a systems problem that causes it to be unable to perform a particular
function. For example, an NMS Stock ATS that routes orders and trading
interest resting in the ATS to destinations outside the ATS could
state, for example, that the NMS Stock ATS will either execute or
cancel orders and trading interest submitted to the ATS if the ATS is
unable to route orders and trading interest away from the ATS due to a
systems problem.
4. Rule 301(b)(2): Form ATS Reporting Requirements No Longer Apply to
NMS Stock ATSs
We proposed in Rule 304 to except NMS Stock ATSs from complying
with Rule 301(b)(2) of Regulation ATS. Existing Rule 301(b)(2) requires
an ATS to file with the Commission a Form ATS initial operation report,
amendments to the Form ATS initial operation report, and cessation of
operations reports on Form ATS, all of which are ``deemed confidential
when filed.'' \237\ We proposed this exception to make clear that NMS
Stock ATSs would not be required to comply with the Form ATS reporting
requirements provided in Rule 301(b)(2) because the NMS Stock ATS would
file a Form ATS-N pursuant to Rule 304. We also proposed Rule
301(b)(2)(viii) to make clear that NMS Stock ATSs must file with the
Commission the reports and amendments required by Rule 304 and that NMS
Stock ATSs were not subject to Rule 301(b)(2) of Regulation ATS. We
also proposed that ATSs that effect transactions in both NMS stocks and
non-NMS stocks would be subject to the requirements of proposed Rule
304, with respect to NMS stocks, and Rule 301(b)(2), with respect to
non-NMS stocks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\237\ See Rule 301(b)(2)(vii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received one comment regarding proposed Rule
301(b)(2)(viii).\238\ The commenter states that requiring an ATS that
transacts in both NMS stocks and non-NMS Stocks to file reports on Form
ATS-N with respect to NMS stocks but also file reports on Form ATS with
respect to non-NMS stocks could be unduly burdensome.\239\ The
commenter states that an ATS should have the option to file reports on
Form ATS-N
[[Page 38786]]
for all U.S. equities that it trades, whether listed or unlisted
because an ATS operator would otherwise have the burden of maintaining
two separate ATS filings for what the commenter believes is essentially
the same functionality.\240\
We do not believe that requiring an ATS that trades both NMS stocks
and non-NMS stocks to file reports on Form ATS-N with respect to NMS
stocks, but also file reports on Form ATS with respect to non-NMS
stocks, will be unduly burdensome. We recognize the additional burdens
for NMS Stock ATSs resulting from the requirement to file disclosures
on new Form ATS-N; however, we estimate that the burden for these ATSs
to maintain their Forms ATS will decrease, because they will no longer
be required to disclose information about their NMS stock operations on
Form ATS.\241\ We also believe that allowing a broker-dealer operator
to choose to disclose information on Form ATS-N about trading in non-
NMS stocks, as suggested by the commenter,\242\ would likely result in
incomplete disclosures about the ATS's non-NMS stock operations that
may be confusing or not useful to market participants. Form ATS-N was
specifically designed to solicit information about trading in NMS
stocks on an ATS to allow market participants to understand the ATS's
NMS stock operations and readily compare the ATS against other ATSs and
national securities exchanges that trade NMS stocks.\243\ While many of
the requests on Form ATS-N could apply to Fixed Income ATSs or
Government Securities ATSs, the requests are not fully tailored to
solicit information about trading in those types of securities and the
systems that trade them. For example, transactions in NMS stocks are,
in some cases, subject to different federal securities laws and
Commission rules than transactions in other securities, such as fixed
income securities.\244\ Because Form ATS-N is specifically designed for
NMS Stock ATSs, subscribers relying on Form ATS-N disclosures to assess
a non-NMS Stock ATS, such as one that trades fixed income securities,
as a potential trading venue may not receive a complete or
comprehensible understanding of the ATS's fixed income operations, or
fixed income activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates as such activities relate to the ATS, because Form ATS-N
does not solicit such information. We believe that allowing NMS Stock
ATSs to choose whether to integrate information about trading in non-
NMS stocks on a Form ATS-N could make the disclosures confusing for
users and make it difficult for them to compare the operations of an
NMS Stock ATS against other NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\238\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3. We received two comments
regarding the application of Rule 301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) to
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs that have filed a Form ATS-N that has not yet
become effective. See Liquidnet Letter at 3; BIDS Letter at 2-3. We
are adopting a transitional rule that will not require a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS to amend its Form ATS under Rule 301(b)(2) if it has filed
a Form ATS-N with the Commission that has not yet become effective.
We are instead requiring such Legacy NMS Stock ATS to file
amendments on Form ATS-N pursuant to the requirements of Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (C). Rule 304(a)(1)(v)(C) is discussed below
in greater detail. See infra Section IV.A.4.c.
\239\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3.
\240\ See id.
\241\ An ATS that trades both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks will
be required to amend its Form ATS, after the ATS files Form ATS-N,
by removing information that pertains solely to the ATS's NMS stock
operations. Amending Form ATS in this manner should help ensure that
the Form ATS accurately describes the ATS's non-NMS stock
operations.
\242\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3.
\243\ See supra Section III.A.
\244\ For example, Rule 611 of Regulation NMS, which requires a
trading center to establish, maintain, and enforce written policies
and procedures that are reasonably designed to prevent trade-
throughs on that trading center, subject to certain exceptions,
applies only to protected quotations in NMS stocks, and not to non-
NMS stocks. See 17 CFR 242.611.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because we are adopting rules that require NMS Stock ATSs to file
Form ATS-N pursuant to Rule 304, we are adopting Rule 304(a) with
modifications to provide that an NMS Stock ATS would specifically be
excepted from compliance with Rules 301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) of
Regulation ATS, which govern the filing of Form ATS.\245\ An NMS Stock
ATS that is operating pursuant to an initial operation report on Form
ATS as of January 7, 2019 (``Legacy NMS Stock ATS'') will be required
to file a Form ATS-N no earlier than January 7, 2019 and no later than
February 8, 2019.\246\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\245\ See supra Section III.A.
\246\ See infra Section IV.A.4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also adopting Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) to provide for how Legacy
NMS Stock ATSs transition from filing a Form ATS to filing a Form ATS-
N. We are defining the term ``Legacy NMS Stock ATS'' to mean an NMS
Stock ATS that is operating pursuant to an initial operation report on
Form ATS as of January 7, 2019. We are also replacing proposed language
that stated that an NMS Stock ATS would not be subject to the
requirements of Rule 301(b)(2) with language stating that a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS shall be subject to the Form ATS filing requirements of Rule
301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) until the Legacy NMS Stock ATS files an
initial Form ATS-N with the Commission pursuant to Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(A), and that thereafter, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall
file reports \247\ pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). We intended in
the Proposal to except a Legacy NMS Stock ATS from compliance with Rule
301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) after it filed Form ATS-N, but also intended
that a Legacy NMS Stock ATSs be subject to Rule 301(b)(2)(viii), which
requires NMS Stock ATSs to file reports required by Rule 304.\248\ We
believe that this modification will make clear that, until a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS files its Form ATS-N with the Commission, the Legacy NMS
Stock ATS must amend Form ATS in compliance with Rule 301(b)(2) of
Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\247\ To reduce redundancy, we are revising the proposed rule
text to state that the Legacy NMS Stock ATS must file ``reports''
(rather than ``the reports and amendments'') required by Rule 304.
Rule 304(b)(1) provides that every Form ATS-N, which will include
every amendment filed on Form ATS-N, shall constitute a ``report''
within the meaning of sections 11A, 17(a), 18(a), and 32(a) (15
U.S.C. 78k-1, 78q(a), 78r(a), and 78ff(a)), and any other applicable
provisions of the Exchange Act.
\248\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81022-24, 81027-31. Without
this modification, Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) could be interpreted,
contrary to the Commission's intention, to except an NMS Stock ATS
from compliance with all of Rule 301(b)(2), including Rule
301(b)(2)(viii) itself.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also including language in Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) stating that
as of January 7, 2019, an entity seeking to operate as an NMS Stock ATS
shall not be subject to the ATS filing requirements of Rule
301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) and shall file reports pursuant to Rule
304.\249\ Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) describes the reporting obligations of
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, and we believe that this additional language
will make clear that NMS Stock ATSs must file an initial Form ATS-N,
and that they do not need to comply with Rule 301(b)(2)(i) through
(vii) and therefore should not file Form ATS.\250\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\249\ EDGAR will be ready to accept Form ATS-N filings on
January 7, 2019, and we have conformed Rule 301(b)(2)(iii) to be
consistent with the EDGAR ability to accept Form ATS-N filings.
\250\ See infra Section IV.A.1 (discussing the filing
requirements for new NMS Stock ATSs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We recognize that an entity may wish to start operating as an NMS
Stock ATS between the time the final rule is adopted and January 7,
2019. During that time, an entity must file an initial operation report
on Form ATS and comply with Rule 301(b)(2); after January 7, 2019, the
ATS, which would operate as a Legacy NMS Stock ATS, must file an
initial Form ATS-N between January 7, 2019 and February 8, 2019
pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A).\251\ As of January 7, 2019, an
entity that seeks to operate as an NMS Stock ATS must comply with Rule
304 (and not with Rules 301(b)(2)(i) through (vii)) and file an initial
Form ATS-N with the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\251\ See infra Section IV.A.4.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting, with a non-substantive modification, the proposed
Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) requirement that an ATS that effects transactions
in both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks be subject to the requirements of
new Rule 304 with respect to NMS stocks and
[[Page 38787]]
Rule 301(b)(2) with respect to non-NMS stocks. We are modifying the
requirement to replace ``effects transactions in'' with ``trades.'' As
adopted, Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) requires that an ATS that trades both NMS
stocks and non-NMS stocks be subject to the requirements of new Rule
304 with respect to NMS stocks and Rule 301(b)(2) with respect to non-
NMS stocks.\252\ By adopting Rule 304 and Form ATS-N, we believe it has
addressed concerns raised by NMS Stock ATSs, as discussed above and in
the Proposal, but that applying Rule 304 to the non-NMS Stock ATS
operations of ATSs that trade both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks would
impose unequal regulatory burdens across ATSs that transact in non-NMS
stocks. Finally, we are adopting as proposed non-substantive amendments
to Rule 301(b)(2)(i) and Rule 301(b)(2)(vii) to delete outdated
references to dates for phased-in compliance with Regulation ATS for
ATSs that were operational as of April 21, 1999, and to update the name
of the Division of Trading and Markets, respectively.\253\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\252\ This modification is being made for clarity and
consistency with the Rule 300(k) definition of NMS Stock ATS. See
supra Section III.B.1.
\253\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(i) and (vii), respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Rule 301(b)(9): Form ATS-R Quarterly Reports
We also proposed to amend Rule 301(b)(9) of Regulation ATS,\254\
which provides that an ATS shall report transaction volume on Form ATS-
R on a quarterly basis and within 10 calendar days after it ceases
operation,\255\ to require an ATS that trades both NMS stocks and non-
NMS stocks to separately report its transactions in NMS stocks on one
Form ATS-R, and its transactions in non-NMS stocks on another Form ATS-
R.\256\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\254\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(9).
\255\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70878. The information filed on Form ATS-R permits the Commission to
monitor trading on an ATS.
\256\ We did not propose any other changes to Rule 301(b)(9).
Form ATS-R would continue to be deemed confidential.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received two comments regarding Form ATS-R. One commenter states
that in light of information on FINRA's website regarding ATSs,\257\
and the detailed disclosures in periodic disclosures required by Form
ATS-N, the Commission should no longer require an NMS Stock ATS to file
Form ATS-R.\258\ We are not amending Regulation ATS at this time to
remove the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-R.
Notwithstanding the disclosure on FINRA's website of certain volume
information for ATSs that trade NMS stocks, we continue to believe that
the form helps the Commission oversee and monitor the trading activity
of NMS Stock ATSs, because Form ATS-R provides the Commission with
information that is unavailable on the FINRA website.\259\ Another
commenter states that to alleviate burdens on ATSs and promote more
meaningful comparisons across firms and venues, the Commission should
significantly revise reporting obligations on Form ATS-R.\260\ The
commenter does not specify how Form ATS-R should be revised; however,
we believe that the role Form ATS-R plays in helping the Commission to
oversee and monitor the trading activities of NMS Stock ATSs justifies
the burden on NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-R.\261\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\257\ See supra note 15.
\258\ See SIFMA Letter at 8 n.16.
\259\ Form ATS-R requires ATSs to provide, among other things,
trading volumes, a list of all subscribers that were participants of
the ATS, and a list of all securities traded. The information on
Form ATS-R permits the Commission to monitor ATSs for compliance
with the fair access requirements of Rule 301(b)(5), as ATSs subject
to those requirements must report quarterly on Form ATS-R the
persons to whom they grant, deny, or limit access to the ATS, as
well as the date of the action, the effective date of the action,
and the nature of the denials of limitations of access. See Form
ATS-R; see also Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70878.
\260\ See HMA Letter at 11 n.64.
\261\ See supra Section X.D.6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. Rule 303: Recordkeeping Requirements for Form ATS-N
We proposed amending Rules 303(a)(1) and 303(a)(2) of Regulation
ATS to reflect the proposed amendments to Rule 301(b)(2) \262\ and the
addition of Rule 304.\263\ In addition, the proposed rules would make
minor technical amendments to Rule 303. We received no comments on the
proposed amendments to Rule 303 and are adopting these requirements as
proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\262\ See supra Section III.B.4.
\263\ See infra Section IV.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unless not required to comply with Regulation ATS pursuant to Rule
301(a) \264\ of Regulation ATS, an ATS must comply with the
recordkeeping requirements of Regulation ATS.\265\ Specifically, Rule
301(b)(8) \266\ requires an ATS to make and keep current the records
specified in Rule 302 \267\ and to preserve the records specified in
Rule 303.\268\ Before the adoption of the amendments to Rule 303, Rule
303(a)(1) required an ATS to preserve certain records for at least
three years, the first two years in an easily accessible place.\269\
Specifically, Rule 303(a)(1) \270\ required an ATS to preserve: (1) All
records required to be made pursuant to Rule 302; (2) all notices
provided to subscribers, including notices addressing hours of
operations, system malfunctions, changes to system procedures,
maintenance of hardware and software, and instructions pertaining to
access to and denials of, or limitations on, access to the ATS; (3)
documents made or received in the course of complying with the system
capacity, integrity, and security standards in Rule 301(b)(6), if
applicable; \271\ and (4) if the ATS is subject to the fair access
requirements under Rule 301(b)(5),\272\ a record of its access
standards. Rule 303(a)(2) \273\ requires that certain other records
must be kept for the life of the ATS and any successor enterprise,
including partnership articles or articles of incorporation (as
applicable), and copies of reports filed pursuant to Rule
301(b)(2),\274\ which includes current Form ATS, and records made
pursuant to Rule 301(b)(5).\275\ In particular, reports required to be
maintained for the life of the ATS, or any successor enterprise,
include initial operation reports, amendments, and cessation of
operations reports, filed on Form ATS.\276\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\264\ 17 CFR 242.301(a).
\265\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81087.
\266\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(8).
\267\ See 17 CFR 242.302.
\268\ See 17 CFR 242.303.
\269\ See 17 CFR 242.303(a)(1).
\270\ See id.
\271\ See supra notes 77-81 and accompanying text.
\272\ See supra notes 72-75 and accompanying text.
\273\ See 17 CFR 242.303(a)(2).
\274\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2).
\275\ See supra notes 72-75 and accompanying text.
\276\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are amending the record preservation requirements of Rule 303 to
incorporate the preservation of records that would be created pursuant
to the requirements that NMS Stock ATSs file initial Form ATS-N, Form
ATS-N amendments, and notices of cessation on Form ATS-N, instead of
Form ATS. Specifically, we are amending Rule 303(a)(2)(ii) to require
that an ATS shall preserve, for the life of the enterprise and of any
successor enterprise, copies of reports filed pursuant to Rule
301(b)(2) or--in the case of an NMS Stock ATS--Rule 304, and records
made pursuant to Rule 301(b)(5).\277\ As a result, because an NMS Stock
ATS will be required to file initial Form ATS-N, Form ATS-N amendments,
and notices of cessation on Form ATS-N pursuant to Rule 304,
[[Page 38788]]
instead of on Form ATS pursuant to Rule 301(b)(2), the NMS Stock ATS
must preserve those reports for the life of the enterprise and of any
successor enterprise pursuant to Rule 303(a)(2) as amended.\278\ We are
not amending the recordkeeping requirements of Rule 302, or any other
amendments to the record preservation requirements of Rule 303(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\277\ See 17 CFR 242.303(a)(2)(ii).
\278\ NMS Stock ATSs that had previously made filings on Form
ATS must preserve those filings for the life of the enterprise, as
well as filings made going forward on Form ATS-N. See id. We believe
that the amendments to Rule 303 are necessary to create a meaningful
audit trail of an ATS's current and previous written safeguards and
procedures pursuant to Rule 301(b)(2) and permit surveillance and
examination staff to help ensure fair and orderly markets without
imposing any undue burden on ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also adopting a minor technical amendment to Rule 303(a).
Currently, Rule 303(a) references ``paragraph (b)(9) of Sec. 242.301''
when setting forth the record preservation requirements for ATSs; this
reference is incorrect, as Rule 301(b)(9) describes the filing
requirements, rather than the recordkeeping requirements, for ATSs. We
are therefore adopting a change to correct the above reference to
``paragraph (b)(8) of Sec. 242.301.'' In addition, we are adopting an
amendment to Rule 303(a)(1) to incorporate amendments to Rule
301(b)(10).\279\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\279\ See infra Section VI.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Comments Recommending Changes to Other Existing Regulation ATS Rules
In the Proposal, we requested comment on other potential changes to
Regulation ATS rules, including the order display and execution access
requirement in Rule 301(b)(3) and the fair access requirement in Rule
301(b)(5).\280\ We received two comments recommending changes to Rule
301(b)(3) of Regulation ATS.\281\ One commenter urges the Commission to
consider lowering or eliminating the threshold for the order display
requirement.\282\ Another commenter states that lowering the threshold
for the order display requirement would result in reduced choice and
higher trading costs for long-term investors, and urges the Commission
to provide a block exemption from the order display requirement.\283\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\280\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81058, 81083.
\281\ See Citadel Letter at 3; Liquidnet Letter at 14-15; see
also supra Section II.C (discussing the order display and execution
access requirements under Rule 301(b)(3) of Regulation ATS).
\282\ See Citadel Letter at 3.
\283\ The commenter believes that the threshold for the order
display requirement may prevent it from offering functionalities
that may provide market participants flexibility in how they display
block orders. See Liquidnet Letter at 14-15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, the Commission received two comments recommending
changes to the fair access requirements in Rule 301(b)(5).\284\ One
commenter urges the Commission to eliminate the 5% trading volume fair
access threshold, in light of the importance of NMS Stock ATSs to
equity markets today.\285\ Another commenter states that rather than
lowering the trading volume threshold that triggers the fair access
requirement of Rule 301(b)(5), the Commission should exclude block
executions from counting towards the fair access threshold.\286\ In
addition, one commenter believes that, in connection with Rule
301(b)(3) of Regulation ATS (order display and execution access), it is
not appropriate to include actionable indications of interest in the
definitions of ``bid'' and ``offer'' under Regulation NMS.\287\ Another
commenter states that actionable indications of interest should be
treated as quotes and should be transparent to the public.\288\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\284\ See Citadel Letter at 2-3; Liquidnet Letter at 9-12; see
also supra Section II.C (discussing the fair access requirements
under Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS).
\285\ See Citadel Letter at 2.
\286\ See Liquidnet Letter at 10.
\287\ See UBS Letter at 8. In 2009, the Commission published a
proposal to address certain practices with respect to undisplayed
liquidity, which is trading interest that is available for execution
at a trading center, but is not included in the consolidated
quotation data that is widely disseminated to the public. See
Regulation of Non-Public Trading Interest at 61209 (proposal to
amend, among other things, Rule 301(b)(3) of Regulation ATS).
\288\ See Barnard Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not adopting changes to the order display and execution
requirement or the fair access requirement at this time. We believe
that it is appropriate to take an incremental approach by first
applying the amended regime to NMS Stock ATSs before considering a
further step and we intend to monitor the effectiveness of Rule
301(b)(3) and Rule 301(b)(5) requirements. Should the Commission decide
to take further action with regard to these requirements, such as
proposing to amend Regulation ATS, the Commission would do so in a
separate rulemaking and take into account its experience with Rule 304
and NMS Stock ATSs.
IV. Form ATS-N Filing Process; Effectiveness Review
A. Initial Form ATS-N
1. Rule 304(a)(1)(i): Filing and Effectiveness Requirement
Rule 304(a)(1)(i) requires that an NMS Stock ATS operate pursuant
to an effective initial Form ATS-N to be exempt from the definition of
``exchange.'' Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) (``Filing'') provided that no
exemption from the definition of ``exchange'' is available to an NMS
Stock ATS pursuant to Sec. 240.3a1-1(a)(2) unless the NMS Stock ATS
files with the Commission a Form ATS-N, in accordance with the
Instructions therein, and the Commission declares the Form ATS-N
effective. Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) also included transitional
provisions for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-N and operate
under Rule 304. These provided that if an NMS Stock ATS is operating
pursuant to a previously-filed initial operation report on Form ATS as
of the effective date of the final rule, such NMS Stock ATS shall file
with the Commission a Form ATS-N, in accordance with the Instructions
therein, no later than 120 calendar days after the effective date of
the final rule. Further, proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) would have provided
that an NMS Stock ATS operating as of the effective date of the final
rule may continue to operate pursuant to a previously-filed initial
operation report on Form ATS pending the Commission's review of the
filed Form ATS-N. We are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(i) (``Filing and
Effectiveness Requirement'') with modifications and relocating the
provisions applicable to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to another provision
within Rule 304(a)(1). Rule 304(a)(1)(i) sets forth two principal
conditions of the Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption for NMS Stock
ATSs: (1) The NMS Stock ATS must file an initial Form ATS-N, and (2)
the initial Form ATS-N must be effective.\289\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\289\ See supra Section III.A.1. See also Rule 301(a)(1)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are relocating the provisions of proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i)
regarding the filing of Form ATS-N by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs during the
Commission review period to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) to better organize the
rule text, particularly in light of other changes we are making to the
proposed rule in response to comments. In addition, we are making
other, non-substantive modifications that we believe will not impact
NMS Stock ATSs and will result in a more readable rule text for the
public.\290\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\290\ We are making the following non-substantive modifications
to Rule 304(a)(1)(i): (1) Deleting the phrase ``from the definition
of `exchange';'' (2) changing the phrase ``in accordance with the
instructions therein'' to ``in accordance with the conditions of
this section;'' and (3) adding the term ``initial'' before ``Form
ATS-N.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also changing Rule 304(a)(1)(i) to state that the exemption
for NMS Stock ATSs will not be available unless ``the initial Form ATS-
N is effective
[[Page 38789]]
pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)(iii) or (a)(1)(iv)(A) of [Rule 304]''
rather than the proposed rule text, which stated that the exemption is
available only if ``the Commission declares the Form ATS-N effective.''
This change is made in connection with adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) and
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A), which, in response to comments, provide that an
initial Form ATS-N for both a non-Legacy NMS Stock ATS and Legacy NMS
Stock ATS, as amended, becomes effective, unless declared ineffective,
upon the earlier of: (1) The completion of review by the Commission and
publication pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2) or (2) the expiration of the
Commission review period, or, if applicable, the end of the extended
review period. Accordingly, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(i), which
provides that no exemption is available to an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to
Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) unless the NMS Stock ATS files with the Commission an
initial Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions of Rule 304 and
the initial Form ATS-N is effective pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) or
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). Consequently, an NMS Stock ATS that is not a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS operating pursuant to an initial operation report
on Form ATS as of January 7, 2019, will be required to comply with the
requirements of Rule 304 as of that date. \291\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\291\ See Rule 301(b)(1). An entity seeking to operate as an NMS
Stock ATS that has filed an initial operation report on Form ATS
prior to January 7, 2019, but has not yet become operational
pursuant to Rule 301(b)(2)(i), must file an initial operation report
on Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions of Rule 304, and
the initial Form ATS-N must become effective before the new NMS
Stock ATS may commence operations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Rule 304(a)(1)(ii): Commission Review Period
Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) describes the timing for the Commission's review
of initial Form ATS-N for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs. Proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(ii) provided the timing for the Commission's review of
initial Form ATS-N as adopted for both Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and non-
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs. The timing for the Commission's review of
initial Form ATS-N for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs is provided by Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(B).\292\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\292\ See infra Section IV.A.4.b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(A) (``Review period and extension of
the 120-day review period'') provided that the Commission would declare
a Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS effective or ineffective
no later than 120 calendar days from filing with the Commission.
Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(A) also provided that the Commission could
extend the review period for Forms ATS-N filed by Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs: (1) An additional 120 calendar days if the Form ATS-N is
unusually lengthy or raises novel or complex issues that require
additional time for review, in which case the Commission will notify
the NMS Stock ATS in writing within the initial 120-calendar day review
period and will briefly describe the reason for the determination for
which additional time for review is required; or (2) any extended
review period to which a duly-authorized representative of the NMS
Stock ATS agrees in writing.
Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(B) would have provided that the
Commission would declare a Form ATS-N filed by an non-Legacy NMS Stock
ATS effective or ineffective no later than 120 calendar days from
filing with the Commission. The proposed rule also would have provided
that the Commission may extend the Form ATS-N review period for: (1) An
additional 90 days, if the Form ATS-N is unusually lengthy or raises
novel or complex issues that require additional time for review, in
which case the Commission will notify the NMS Stock ATS in writing
within the initial 120-calendar day review period and will briefly
describe the reason for the determination for which additional time for
review is required; or (2) any extended review period to which a duly-
authorized representative of the NMS Stock ATS agrees in writing. We
received three comments regarding the length of the Commission review
period and extended review period for Form ATS-N filings.\293\ One
commenter states that the 120-calendar day period for the Commission to
review Form ATS-N filings is a reasonable amount of time for the
Commission to process each filing, and the 120-day extension of the
review period for Form ATS-N filings by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs that are
particularly novel or complex is agreeable.\294\ Another commenter does
not object to the proposed period for reviewing Form ATS-N.\295\ We
continue to believe that an initial review period of 120 calendar days
for Form ATS-N filings would provide the Commission adequate time to
carry out its oversight functions with respect to its review of Forms
ATS-N filed by both Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and non-Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs, including its responsibilities to protect investors and maintain
fair, orderly, and efficient markets.\296\ We also continue to believe
that extended review periods of 120 calendar days for Form ATS-N
filings by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, and 90 calendar days for filings by
non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, that are unusually lengthy or raise novel or
complex issues, are appropriate. As discussed in the Proposal, these
time periods will allow the Commission and its staff to conduct a
thorough review of certain lengthy, novel, or complex Form ATS-N
filings and provide sufficient opportunity to discuss a filing with an
NMS Stock ATS if necessary.\297\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\293\ See CFA Institute Letter at 4; Liquidnet Letter at 3; PDQ
Letter at 2. See also infra note 435.
\294\ See CFA Institute Letter at 4.
\295\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3. See also PDQ Letter at 2.
\296\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81023-81024. See infra
Section IV.A.4.b for a description of Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B), which
provides the Commission review period for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs.
\297\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter worries the review process may devolve into other
market centers seeking to have the Commission preserve their market
positions, and urges the Commission to promptly evaluate and act on
initial Form ATS-N filings.\298\ We believe that the proposed time
periods for review of Form ATS-N filings are appropriate. The
Commission could, depending on the length and complexity of a Form ATS-
N filing, complete the review prior to the expiration of the review
period; thus, the Form ATS-N would become effective upon publication,
pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2).\299\ The review periods and extended review
periods combined cannot exceed 240 calendar days for a Legacy NMS Stock
ATS or 210 calendar days for a non-Legacy NMS Stock ATS unless the NMS
Stock ATS agrees, in writing, to a longer review period.\300\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\298\ See HMA Letter at 7-8.
\299\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(iii); Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). See also
Section IV.A.4.b.
\300\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(A); 304(a)(1)(iv)(B). See also
infra Section IV.A.4.b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter states that the proposed process for
determining whether an NMS Stock ATS qualifies for the exemption from
the definition of ``exchange'' could, in light of the Commission's SRO
rule filing review responsibilities, overwhelm staff by adding
potentially hundreds of new NMS Stock ATS filings.\301\ This commenter
expresses concern that Commission staff may spend too much time
reviewing whether an NMS Stock ATS meets its procedural obligations
rather than trying to better understand the ``substance, merits, and
potential misconduct of ATSs' trading operations and activities, and
how they fit into the broader market structure,'' and worries that
Commission staff ``might get caught in a procedural morass and miss the
[[Page 38790]]
forest for the trees.'' \302\ This commenter compares the proposed
review process for Form ATS-N filings to the review and approval
process for SRO rule changes, and states that unless the Commission is
more willing than it has previously been to challenge applications, the
proposed process for reviewing Form ATS-N filings will devolve into an
``unreasonably burdensome exercise for Commission staff while providing
little benefit to market integrity or investor protection.'' \303\ We
do not believe that the review process would be unreasonably burdensome
to the Commission or its staff. The Commission's review will not be
merit-based; instead, it will focus on the completeness and
comprehensibility of disclosures. In addition, under the adopted rules,
a Form ATS-N, as amended, will become effective, unless declared
ineffective, upon the earlier of the completion of Commission review or
the end of the Commission review period. This streamlined process will
facilitate efficient Commission review, which is designed to protect
investors by allowing the Commission to review disclosures on Form ATS-
N for potential deficiencies that might otherwise confuse or mislead
market participants about the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or the
ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\301\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 10.
\302\ See id.
\303\ See id. at 2, 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(B) with modifications,
renumbering the proposed rule as Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) (``Commission
review period''), and relocating Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(A), which relates
to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B). We are modifying
proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) to state that the Commission ``may,'' ``by
order,'' \304\ as provided in Rule 304(a)(1)(iii), declare an initial
Form ATS-N filed by an NMS Stock ATS ineffective no later than 120
calendar days from the date of filing with the Commission or, if
applicable, the end of the extended review period.\305\ Proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(iv) (``Order regarding effectiveness'') would have required
the Commission to issue an order to declare a Form ATS-N effective or
ineffective. We are not adopting the proposed requirement \306\ that
the Commission issue an order to declare a Form ATS-N effective
because, as described below, the Commission will only issue orders of
ineffectiveness. In addition, to improve readability, the adopted rule
references the ineffectiveness process in Rule 304(a)(1)(iii). The
Commission will make public, on its website, any effective initial Form
ATS-N, as amended.\307\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\304\ We are: (1) Deleting proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv), which
stated that the Commission would issue an order declaring a Form
ATS-N effective or ineffective and (2) adding the words ``by order''
to adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(ii). These changes simplify the rule text
without changing the Commission's proposal to inform the public
about the ineffectiveness of Form ATS-N by issuing an order.
\305\ We are deleting text that states that this provision
applies to ``an NMS Stock ATS that was not operating as of
[effective date of the final rule]'' as it will be clear that the
provisions of Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) apply to the filing of initial Form
ATS-N by non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and that the provisions of Rule
304(a)(1)(iv) will apply to filings by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs.
\306\ See proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv).
\307\ See Rule 304(b)(2)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are modifying Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) to add a provision that will
allow NMS Stock ATSs to amend their initial Forms ATS-N during the
Commission review period. We discussed in the Proposal that during the
Commission's review, the Commission staff may provide comments to the
entity, and may request that the entity supplement information in the
Form ATS-N or revise its disclosures on Form ATS-N.\308\ In addition,
an NMS Stock ATS may need to update disclosures on its initial Form
ATS-N to otherwise reflect changes during the Commission review period.
To allow an NMS Stock ATS to correct or update its disclosures on an
initial Form ATS-N during the review period, we are modifying Rule
304(a)(1)(ii) to provide that during the review period of the initial
Form ATS-N, the NMS Stock ATS shall amend its initial Form ATS-N
pursuant to the requirements of Rules 304(a)(2)(i)(B) and (C), which
are discussed further below.\309\ We believe that updates or
corrections to an NMS Stock ATS's disclosures about its intended
operations would be properly filed as updating or correcting amendments
pursuant to Rules 304(a)(2)(i)(B) and (C).\310\ We believe allowing an
entity seeking to operate as an NMS Stock ATS to amend its initial Form
ATS-N during the Commission review period will promote transparency and
facilitate complete and comprehensible disclosures. Once an initial
Form ATS-N becomes effective, the Commission will make public the
initial Form ATS-N, as amended, which will incorporate any amendments
that were filed during the Commission review period. An NMS Stock ATS
(other than a Legacy NMS Stock ATS),\311\ however, seeking to amend its
initial Form ATS-N to make a material change to its Form ATS-N
disclosures during the Commission review period must withdraw its
initial Form ATS-N and may refile a new, initial Form ATS-N pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(1). We believe a material change to the disclosures on an
initial Form ATS-N would necessitate a full review period.\312\ In
addition, we have made several technical, non-substantive modifications
to Rule 304(a)(1)(ii) that are designed to improve the readability of
the rule, reduce potential ambiguity, or both.\313\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\308\ See Proposal supra note 2, at 81026.
\309\ See infra Sections IV.B.1.b and IV.B.1.c. Amendments will
be subject to Commission review under Rule 304(a)(2)(ii), which
states that the Commission will, by order, declare ineffective any
Form ATS-N amendment no later than 30 calendar days from filing of
such amendment with the Commission if the Commission finds that such
action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is
consistent with the protection of investors.
\310\ See id.
\311\ Unlike non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
will operate during the Commission review period pursuant to a
filed, but not yet effective, initial Form ATS-N. Accordingly,
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs may file amendments to their Form ATS-N during
the Commission review period to make material changes to their
operations and introduce new functionalities. See infra Section
IV.A.4.c.
\312\ The Commission could, however, complete its review of a
refiled initial Form ATS-N in less than 120 calendar days from the
date of filing, and the Form ATS-N would become effective upon
publication. See Rules 304(a)(1)(ii)-(iii) and 304(b).
\313\ We are making additional changes from proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(ii) to: (1) Rename the paragraph from ``Review period and
extension of the 120-day review period'' to ``Commission review
period;'' (2) add to the end of the first sentence that the
Commission may declare an initial Form ATS-N ineffective no later
than 120 calendar days from the date of filing with the Commission
``or, if applicable, the end of the extended review period;'' (3)
specify that the Commission will declare an initial Form ATS-N
ineffective no later than 120 calendar days from ``the date of''
filing with the Commission; (4) add the word ``initial'' before Form
ATS-N; and (5) add the word ``calendar'' before ``day'' in the
description of the 90-day extension period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Rule 304(a)(1)(iii): Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness Determination
Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) describes the process by which an initial Form
ATS-N would become effective, or be declared ineffective by the
Commission. Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) (``Effectiveness'') provided
that the Commission will declare effective a Form ATS-N if the NMS
Stock ATS qualifies for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption and that the
Commission will declare ineffective a Form ATS-N if it finds, after
notice and opportunity for hearing, that such action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with the
protection of investors.\314\ Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) (``Order
regarding effectiveness'')
[[Page 38791]]
provided that the Commission will issue an order to declare a Form ATS-
N effective or ineffective. Proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) also provided
that upon the effectiveness of the Form ATS-N, the NMS Stock ATS may
operate pursuant to the conditions of Rule 304, and if the Commission
declares a Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS shall be
prohibited from operating as an NMS Stock ATS. Proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(iv) further provided that a Form ATS-N declared ineffective
would not prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form
ATS-N. We also discussed in the Proposal our preliminary beliefs
regarding when it would be necessary or appropriate in the public
interest to declare ineffective a Form ATS-N.\315\ We received several
comments related to proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iii), proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(iv), and the standard of review for declaring Form ATS-N
filings effective or ineffective, which are summarized below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\314\ See proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iii).
\315\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024-81026.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to Rule 304 and Form ATS-N, as adopted and as discussed
below, an NMS Stock ATS must provide all the information required by
the form and respond to each item, as applicable, and disclose
information that is accurate, current, and complete. A Form ATS-N
filing that is defective may be rejected. If the filing is accepted for
review, it will become effective unless the Commission finds, after
notice and opportunity for hearing, that it is necessary or appropriate
in the public interest, and consistent with the protection of
investors, to declare the filing ineffective. Responsibility for
current, complete, and accurate disclosures rests with the NMS Stock
ATS.\316\ The Commission will consider whether it is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with the protection
of investors, to declare an initial Form ATS-N filing ineffective
because, for example, the Form ATS-N was filed by an entity that does
not meet the proposed definition of NMS Stock ATS; one or more
disclosures reveal non-compliance with federal securities laws, or the
rules or regulations thereunder, including Regulation ATS; or the
disclosures are materially deficient with respect to completeness or
comprehensibility.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\316\ See Rule 304(c); Instructions to Form ATS-N. The
Commission's staff may become aware of information, as a result of
discussions with the NMS Stock ATS or otherwise, that calls into
question, for example, the currency or accuracy of the disclosures
on a Form ATS-N, which may result in a determination to begin the
process to declare the Form ATS-N ineffective. See infra Section
IV.A.3.d.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Comments on the Standard of Review To Accept Filings of Form ATS-N
The determination of whether to reject a Form ATS-N filing is
separate from the Commission's determination to declare a filed Form
ATS-N ineffective after Commission review. We received one comment
regarding the process pursuant to which a Form ATS-N would be accepted
for Commission review.\317\ The commenter states that the Commission
should not review a Form ATS-N filing for accuracy and completeness in
connection with accepting a Form ATS-N filing, but rather that such
review should be conducted when the Commission is considering whether
to declare the Form ATS-N effective or ineffective.\318\ The commenter
states that the Commission's standards for accepting a Form ATS-N
should be clear and objective, and Form ATS-N should be rejected only
for purely ``technical deficiencies.'' \319\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\317\ See SIFMA Letter at 28.
\318\ See id.
\319\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As proposed, the Instructions to Form ATS-N required that ``[a]n
NMS Stock ATS must respond to each item, as applicable, in detail and
disclose information that is accurate, current, and complete. An NMS
Stock ATS must provide all the information required by the form,
including the exhibits, and must present the information in a clear and
comprehensible manner. A filing that is incomplete or similarly
deficient may be returned to the NMS Stock ATS.'' \320\ In the
Proposal, we stated that ``a Form ATS-N that contains technical
deficiencies, such as missing pages or one in which the entity does not
respond to all questions, including sub-questions, would not be
complete and would be returned to the NMS Stock ATS.'' \321\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\320\ See proposed Instructions to Form ATS-N. As adopted, the
Instructions to Form ATS-N state that: ``An NMS Stock ATS must
provide all the information required by Form ATS-N, including
responses to each Item, as applicable, and the Exhibits, and
disclose information that is accurate, current and complete. . . . A
filing that is defective may be rejected and not accepted by the
EDGAR system. Any filing so rejected shall be deemed not to have
been filed.'' The Instructions to Form ATS-N replace the proposed
cite to 17 CFR 240.0-3 under the Exchange Act, which applies to
paper filings, with a cite to Regulation S-T, which applies to
electronic filings, because the form will be electronically filed
via EDGAR. See Instructions to Form ATS-N. Because Form ATS-N will
be electronically filed, we do not believe it is necessary to return
a copy of Form ATS-N filings and are therefore replacing the word
``returned'' with ``rejected'' to specify this.
We are also modifying the Instructions to Form ATS-N to delete
the phrase: ``and must present the information in a clear and
comprehensible manner.'' See Instructions to Form ATS-N. This
modification to the Instructions to Form ATS-N will streamline the
instructions by removing confusing language relating to the
Commission's standard of review, but will not modify an NMS Stock
ATS's obligations with respect to Form ATS-N. Additionally, the
Commission has reorganized the Instructions to differentiate between
an NMS Stock ATS's filing obligations, and the consequences of
incompleteness or similar deficiency.
We are modifying our guidance and the rule text for
determinations of ineffectiveness, and believe these modifications
to the Instructions to Form ATS-N better align them with that
guidance and adopted rule text and reduce any potential confusion
about the difference between an NMS Stock ATS's obligations with
respect to completing Form ATS-N and the standard of review that the
Commission will apply when determining whether to declare a Form
ATS-N ineffective. See infra Section IV.A.3.d. See also infra
Section V.A.1 (discussing the Form ATS-N disclosure requirements).
\321\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024 n.284.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that it would be appropriate to reject a Form ATS-N if
the filing is defective.\322\ For example, a Form ATS-N is defective if
it is missing sections or missing responses to any questions, including
sub-questions, or does not comply with the electronic-filing
requirements. A decision to reject a Form ATS-N filing, and not accept
it for review, would be for reasons distinct from Commission review
pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii), as discussed below. The rejection of a
Form ATS-N would not prejudice any decision by the Commission regarding
ineffectiveness should the NMS Stock ATS resubmit a Form ATS-N.\323\ An
NMS Stock ATS also may choose to withdraw a filed Form ATS-N.\324\ The
Commission will apply the same standard when determining whether to
accept an amendment to Form ATS-N for review or reject the filing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\322\ See 17 CFR part 232.
\323\ Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024 n.284.
\324\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Comments on the Review for Declarations of Ineffectiveness
We proposed that the Commission will declare effective a Form ATS-N
if the NMS Stock ATS qualifies for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption, and
will declare it ineffective if it finds, after notice and opportunity
for hearing, that such action is necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and is consistent with the protection of investors.\325\ We
discussed in the Proposal that the Commission would use Form ATS-N to
evaluate whether an entity qualifies for the exemption, and would
evaluate, among other things, whether the entity satisfies the
definition of NMS Stock ATS.\326\ We also discussed our preliminary
beliefs regarding when it would be necessary or appropriate in the
public interest to declare ineffective
[[Page 38792]]
a Form ATS-N, and provided examples.\327\ We stated that it would be
necessary and appropriate in the public interest to declare a Form ATS-
N ineffective if the Commission finds, after notice and opportunity for
hearing, that: An entity does not meet the definition of NMS Stock ATS;
one or more disclosures on Form ATS-N are materially deficient with
respect to their accuracy, currency or completeness; or one or more
disclosures reveal non-compliance with federal securities laws, or the
rules and regulations thereunder, including Regulation ATS.\328\ We
also stated that a declaration of effectiveness would not constitute a
finding that the NMS Stock ATS's operations are consistent with the
Exchange Act, but rather only address the issue of whether the NMS
Stock ATS had complied with the requirements of Form ATS-N.\329\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\325\ See proposed Rule 303(a)(1)(iii).
\326\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024.
\327\ See id. at 81024-81026.
\328\ See id.
\329\ See id. at 81026. With respect to compliance with federal
securities laws, we stated that the Commission's evaluation would
involve a ``red-flag'' review of the Form ATS-N disclosures. See id.
at 81025. With respect to whether an entity meets the definition of
NMS Stock ATS, we stated our preliminary belief that proper
classification of an entity would clearly indicate to market
participants, as well as the Commission, the functions that entity
performs and the regulatory framework and attendant obligations that
attach to that entity. See id. at 81024 n.288 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received several comments regarding the standard that the
Commission would apply to declare a Form ATS-N effective or
ineffective. One commenter asserts that it would be helpful to have the
Commission review initial Forms ATS-N for completeness and accuracy,
and legal and regulatory compliance, and to help standardize the level
of disclosure across NMS Stock ATSs.\330\ Another commenter urges the
Commission to move forward with the effectiveness determination as
proposed.\331\ This commenter states that market participants will use
the information disclosed on Form ATS-N to evaluate whether a
particular NMS Stock ATS would be a desirable venue to which to route
their orders, and that it is important that the detailed information be
accurate, current, and complete.\332\ This commenter also states that
the Commission should be able to conduct a ``red flag'' review of the
disclosures for apparent non-compliance with the federal securities
laws, and avoid having a noncompliant NMS Stock ATS begin operation
with inadequate system operations; this commenter states that while not
affording complete certainty, this review process would be an
improvement over the review process for Form ATS.\333\ Further, the
commenter states that the notice and hearing process will furnish the
industry with useful information regarding specific regulatory concerns
and questions.\334\ One commenter expresses concern that the Commission
would lack objective standards to evaluate initial Forms ATS-N and
amendments.\335\ Another commenter believes that in the Proposal, the
Commission did not articulate a ``consistent standard of review'' for
declaring a Form ATS-N or Form ATS-N amendment effective or
ineffective.\336\ The commenter expresses its view that the standard
for declaring a Form ATS-N ineffective should be only if the Form ATS-N
is ``materially deficient with respect to completeness,'' \337\
asserting that criteria such as currency, accuracy, and fair
presentation are subjective standards that could make it difficult for
NMS Stock ATSs to understand the level of disclosure necessary to
satisfy the Commission's review requirements, and therefore require
extended discussion with the Commission.\338\ Further, the commenter
believes that such subjective standards would be difficult to
standardize in application from firm to firm, would complicate the
Commission's review of Form ATS-N, and are unnecessary to increase the
operational transparency of NMS Stock ATSs and to ensure a consistent
level of information regarding NMS Stock ATSs is available to market
participants.\339\ The commenter believes that the rule's directives to
consider whether to declare a Form ATS-N ineffective would provide the
Commission with flexibility to determine whether declaring a Form ATS-N
ineffective is ``necessary or appropriate in the public interest'' and
``consistent with the protection of investors,'' and therefore that
including additional subjectivity in the Commission's standard is
unnecessary.\340\ The commenter believes that NMS Stock ATSs would have
other incentives to ensure the accuracy of their Forms ATS-N.\341\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\330\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4.
\331\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 11.
\332\ See id.
\333\ See id.
\334\ See id. We agree with the commenter and intend to help
market participants understand the reason the Form ATS-N was
declared ineffective by explaining the Commission's reasoning for
the ineffective declaration in the Commission order. See supra
Section IV.A.3.d.
\335\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 8-9.
\336\ See SIFMA Letter at 32.
\337\ See id.
\338\ See id. at 33.
\339\ See id.
\340\ See id.
\341\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This commenter also states that the Commission should only find a
disclosure to be ``materially deficient'' with respect to the accuracy,
currency, and completeness in an ``extreme situation, not a
circumstance where additional color or language might be viewed as
preferable to a disclosure as filed,'' and asserts that a response that
is facially responsive to a question on Form ATS-N should be deemed
sufficient.\342\ This commenter agrees with the examples of
``materially deficient'' disclosures that the Commission provided in
the Proposal, but also requests that the Commission provide examples of
``disclosures that would not be viewed as materially deficient.'' \343\
Additionally, this commenter states that if the Commission declares an
initial Form ATS-N or amendment ineffective, it should provide the NMS
Stock ATS with a clear written statement of the reasons for the
declaration.\344\ The commenter urges the Commission to provide clarity
and practical guidance around its expectations on declaring Form ATS-N
filings effective.\345\ Another commenter raises concerns that the
process for declaring Form ATS-N effective or ineffective may result in
the Commission staff undertaking merit-based reviews of the disclosures
on Form ATS-N that could be used to delay the effectiveness of NMS
Stock ATSs whose features, ``while meeting regulatory requirements, do
not meet current industry norms.'' \346\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\342\ See id. at 30.
\343\ See id. at 30 (emphasis in original). See also Proposal,
supra note 2, at 81025. Another commenter states that it recognizes
the difficulty associated with identifying every potential scenario
that might cause a Form ATS-N to be declared ineffective, but
requests that the Commission provide additional guidance to ensure
that NMS Stock ATS operators understand the standard to be applied.
See LeveL ATS Letter at 9.
\344\ See SIFMA Letter at 30.
\345\ See id.
\346\ See Fidelity Letter at 2, 9. This commenter requests that
the Commission implement a ``completeness review'' under which the
Commission would review responses to Form ATS-N for completeness and
consistency without considering the merits of each answer. The
commenter also requests that the Commission provide additional
guidance with respect to the process by which it could declare a
Form ATS-N ineffective, and questions how review by Commission staff
of initial filings will be undertaken to ensure consistency across
Form ATS-N filings. See id. at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that it would be necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and consistent with the protection of investors, to declare
ineffective a Form ATS-N if, for example, the Commission finds, after
notice and opportunity for hearing, the Form ATS-N was filed by an
entity that does not meet the definition of NMS Stock ATS; one or more
disclosures reveal non-compliance
[[Page 38793]]
with federal securities laws, or the rules or regulations thereunder,
including Regulation ATS; or one or more disclosures on Form ATS-N are
materially deficient with respect to their completeness or
comprehensibility.\347\ We are providing additional examples of when,
depending on the facts and circumstances, the Commission may make such
a finding.\348\ In response to comments regarding the scope of the
Commission's review of initial Form ATS-N filings and the standard to
be applied for declarations of ineffectiveness, we are making clear
that the Commission will not be conducting a merit-based review.\349\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\347\ See infra Section IV.A.3.d.
\348\ See id.
\349\ See infra notes 404-407 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Effectiveness, Ineffectiveness Process
The Commission received comments about the proposed process by
which a Form ATS-N would become effective or ineffective, including the
potential implications of the proposed process. One commenter expresses
concern that a declaration of effectiveness may give market
participants a false sense of security that the Commission's deeming an
NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N ``effective'' will be tantamount to the
Commission's approval of an ATS's operations on the merits, as market
participants may not fully understand that a declaration of
effectiveness only implies that the NMS Stock ATS has met the Form ATS-
N filing requirements, and that the Commission is not approving the
merits of the NMS Stock ATS's operations or conflicts of interest.
\350\ The commenter believes that such mistaken belief could cause
market participants to route orders to venues that are not in their
best interests.\351\ Another commenter states that there is the danger
that the Commission review process would encourage market complacency,
and that the Commission, through guidance in this adopting release and
continuing investor education, should help to ensure that: (1)
Investors understand that such a determination would not constitute a
finding that the NMS Stock ATS's operations are necessarily consistent
with the Exchange Act; and (2) operators of NMS Stock ATSs understand
that the determination would not preclude the Commission from later
determining that an NMS Stock ATS has violated federal securities
laws.\352\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\350\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 2, 10-11.
\351\ See id. at 11.
\352\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 12. See also supra note
340 and accompanying text. Pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) the
Commission will issue an order declaring an initial Form ATS-N
filing ineffective if it finds, after notice and opportunity for
hearing, that such action is necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and is consistent with the protection of investors if, for
example, the Form ATS-N was filed by an entity that does not meet
the definition of NMS Stock ATS; one or more disclosures reveal non-
compliance with federal securities laws, or the rules or regulations
thereunder, including Regulation ATS; or the disclosures are
materially deficient with respect to completeness or
comprehensibility.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received two comments about an NMS Stock ATS potentially
using a declaration of effectiveness to shield itself from potential
liability.\353\ Both express concern that, although the Proposal
explains that a declaration of effectiveness is not an ``approval'' of
Form ATS-N, the process could be used to inappropriately inoculate NMS
Stock ATS operators from liability.\354\ One of these commenters states
that its concern is heightened by a recent court decision in which the
court found that the Commission's review and approval of exchanges'
activities made the activities legal.\355\ One commenter believes that
a declaration of ineffectiveness will ``sound the death knell'' for an
NMS Stock ATS and that the opportunity to file a new Form ATS-N would
be of no practical value because the marketplace would not use the
ATS.\356\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\353\ See HMA Letter at 8; Consumer Federation of America Letter
at 11.
\354\ See id.
\355\ See HMA Letter at 8.
\356\ See Fidelity Letter at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While we do not believe that providing a process by which Form ATS-
N filings will become effective or ineffective \357\ would risk
misleading market participants about the kind of review that will be
undertaken by the Commission,\358\ we are modifying the process for
initial Form ATS-N filings to become effective, to mitigate any such
risk. Accordingly, the Commission will not declare initial Form ATS-N
filings effective pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii). Further, the
Commission will only declare ineffective an initial Form ATS-N if it
finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that such action is
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with
the protection of investors. An initial Form ATS-N, as amended, will
become effective, unless declared ineffective, upon the earlier of
completion of review by the Commission and publication pursuant to Rule
304(b)(2), or the expiration of the review period, or, if applicable,
the extended review period. Unlike proposed rule changes filed by
national securities exchanges, the Commission will not make affirmative
findings about Form ATS-N filings with regard to consistency with the
Exchange Act in the general course of the review of Form ATS-N
filings.\359\ As discussed below, the Commission's review will not
focus on the merits of the Form ATS-N disclosures, such as determining
the strengths and weaknesses of the trading platform or a protocol
offered by the NMS Stock ATS, nor is the Commission making findings
regarding whether the means by which orders will interact on the
trading platform are consistent with certain provisions of the Exchange
Act.\360\ If disclosures on Form ATS-N reveal non-compliance with
federal securities laws or the rules and regulations thereunder,
however, the Commission may find that it is appropriate to declare the
filing ineffective. We believe that the scope of the Commission's
review is clear and that the benefits of the Commission review process
for Form ATS-N filings justify any risk that market participants
misunderstand that the Commission is not performing a merit review of
Form ATS-N. We further believe that adopting a process for initial Form
ATS-N filings to become effective without the Commission affirmatively
declaring them effective by order will help signal to market
participants that the Commission is not passing on the merits of the
NMS Stock ATSs' disclosures regarding their operations. Even if we
assume that a declaration of ineffectiveness will ``sound the death
knell,'' as suggested by a commenter,\361\ or result in reputational
harm to an NMS Stock ATS, the process for declaring a Form ATS-N filing
ineffective will be consistent with the Commission's objective to
protect investors and the public interest and will provide NMS Stock
ATSs with opportunities to avoid or mitigate such a declaration. An NMS
Stock ATS would be given notice and an opportunity for hearing to
respond to the Commission's concerns. A non-Legacy NMS Stock ATS would
also have the option of withdrawing and subsequently refiling its Form
ATS-N. In addition, during the Commission review period, both non-
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and Legacy NMS Stock ATSs can amend their initial
Form ATS-N to cure potential deficiencies. Additionally, if the
Commission does
[[Page 38794]]
declare an initial Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS will have
an opportunity to revise its disclosures, or change its operations, and
subsequently file a new initial Form ATS-N, and such filing could
become effective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\357\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(iii).
\358\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 2, 10.
\359\ See supra note 405.
\360\ See infra notes 404-407 and accompanying text.
\361\ See supra note 356.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter argues that a Form ATS-N should be
considered ineffective upon filing until the Commission affirmatively
declares it effective or ineffective.\362\ However, this commenter also
recommends that if the Commission fails to declare a Form ATS-N
effective or ineffective within the 120-calendar day review period, or
does not extend the review period, the ``default decision'' should be
that the Form ATS-N is declared effective.\363\ We believe that it
would be appropriate for an initial Form ATS-N to become effective if
the Commission does not declare, by order, the filing ineffective
during the initial review period, or in the case of an extended review
period, during the extended period, to provide certainty about timing
of the Commission's review to the NMS Stock ATS and to market
participants. Providing for an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS to become effective in this manner will allow the Legacy NMS
Stock ATS to continue to operate without disruption to its subscribers
(provided the Commission does not declare the Form ATS-N
ineffective).\364\ Considering an initial Form ATS-N ineffective upon
filing, before the Commission has completed the review, as suggested by
a commenter, would cause a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to stop operating,
which may harm the market participants that currently use the services
on the Legacy NMS Stock ATS. Once an initial Form ATS-N is effective,
Rule 304(a)(4) provides a process for the Commission to suspend, limit,
or revoke the exemption for the NMS Stock ATS. Given this change in the
effectiveness determination process, we do not believe that requiring
that an initial Form ATS-N filing be considered ineffective upon filing
would provide any additional benefit, because an NMS Stock ATS (except
for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS) may not operate pursuant to the conditions
of the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption unless its Form ATS-N has become
effective, pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\362\ See CFA Institute Letter at 5.
\363\ See id. at 4.
\364\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). See also infra Section IV.A.4.a
(discussing the initial Form ATS-N requirements for Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
d. Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness Determinations Under Rule
301(a)(1)(iii)
We are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) with modifications, and
relocating most of proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv), with
modifications,\365\ to adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) (``Effectiveness;
Ineffectiveness determination''). For the reasons described above, we
are modifying Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) to provide that an initial Form ATS-N
filed by an NMS Stock ATS, as amended,\366\ will become effective,
unless declared ineffective, upon the earlier of: (1) The completion of
review by the Commission and publication pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2)(i),
or (2) the expiration of the review period, or, if applicable, the end
of the extended review period, pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(ii). Rule
304(a)(1)(iii) will further provide that the Commission will, by order,
declare ineffective an initial Form ATS-N if it finds, after notice and
opportunity for hearing, that such action is necessary or appropriate
in the public interest, and is consistent with the protection of
investors.\367\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\365\ See infra note 368 and accompanying text.
\366\ We are adopting a process that allows NMS Stock ATSs to
file an updating and correcting amendment to an initial Form ATS-N
during the Commission review period. See supra Section IV.A.2. We
are adding to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) that an initial Form ATS-N ``as
amended'' will become effective, which includes any amendments filed
to the initial Form ATS-N during the Commission review period.
Amendments filed by an NMS Stock ATS to an initial Form ATS-N during
the Commission review period are subject to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii),
which provides that the Commission will, by order, declare
ineffective any Form ATS-N amendment no later than 30 calendar days
from filing with the Commission. The Commission will have 30
calendar days to declare any amendments ineffective, including
amendments to Form ATS-N that are filed during the Commission review
period. For example, if an NMS Stock ATS files an updating or
correcting amendment to an initial Form ATS-N on calendar day 110 of
the Commission review period, and the initial Form ATS-N becomes
effective on calendar day 120, the updating or correcting amendment
could be declared ineffective by the Commission up to an additional
20 calendar days after the initial Form ATS-N becomes effective--
until the Commission's 30-calendar day review period has expired.
\367\ We are also making technical changes to the proposed text
of Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) by adding to Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) the word
``initial'' before Form ATS-N and renaming the paragraph as
``Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness determination.''
In the Proposal, we stated that it would be necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with the
protection of investors, to declare ineffective a Form ATS-N if it
finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that one or more
disclosures on Form ATS-N are materially deficient with respect to
their accuracy, currency, or completeness. See Proposal, supra note
2, at 81025. As discussed further below, we are modifying the
proposed guidance regarding when it may be necessary or appropriate
to declare a Form ATS-N ineffective.
We are also modifying the Instructions to Form ATS-N to better
align them with that guidance, and to reduce any potential confusion
about the difference between an NMS Stock ATS's obligations with
respect to completing Form ATS-N and the standard of review that the
Commission will apply when determining whether to declare a Form
ATS-N ineffective. See supra note 320.
The same standard for declarations of ineffectiveness will
apply to filings of both initial Form ATS-N and Form ATS-N
amendments. See infra Section IV.B.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also relocating two provisions of proposed Rule
304(a)(1)(iv), with non-substantive modifications,\368\ to adopted Rule
304(a)(1)(iii). As a result, Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) states that if the
Commission declares an initial Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock
ATS shall be prohibited from operating as an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to
Sec. 240.3a1-1(a)(2); and that an initial Form ATS-N declared
ineffective does not prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing
a new Form ATS-N. We believe Rule 304(a)(1)(iii), as modified, clearly
explains when an initial Form ATS-N will become effective or declared
ineffective, and the consequences of an order of ineffectiveness.
Accordingly, an NMS Stock ATS whose initial Form ATS-N has become
effective may commence operations and will be required to comply with
Rule 304 as well as applicable provisions of Rules 300 through 303 of
Regulation ATS. An NMS Stock ATS whose initial Form ATS-N was declared
ineffective would be prohibited from operating pursuant
[[Page 38795]]
to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption. Similarly, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
whose initial Form ATS-N was declared ineffective would no longer be
eligible for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption and would be required to
cease operations.\369\ If the Commission declares an initial Form ATS-N
ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS that filed the form could subsequently
file a new Form ATS-N for Commission consideration.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\368\ We are deleting the following language, which was part of
proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iv): ``The Commission will issue an order to
declare a Form ATS-N effective or ineffective.'' This is addressed
in the adopted rule text stating that ``[a]n initial Form ATS-N, as
amended, filed by an NMS Stock ATS will become effective, unless
declared ineffective, upon the earlier of: (1) [T]he completion of
review by the Commission and publication pursuant to paragraph
(b)(2)(i) of [Rule 304] or (2) [t]he expiration of the review
period, or, if applicable, the end of the extended review period,
pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)(ii) of [Rule 304]'' and that ``[t]he
Commission will, by order, declare an initial Form ATS-N ineffective
if it finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that such
action is necessary and appropriate in the public interest, and is
consistent with the protection of investors.'' See Rule
304(a)(1)(iii)(B). In addition, we are not adopting the language
that states ``[u]pon the effectiveness of the Form ATS-N, the NMS
Stock ATS may operate pursuant to the conditions of this section''
or language that states ``[i]f the Commission declares an initial
Form ATS-N effective, the NMS Stock ATS may operate pursuant to the
conditions of this section'' for purposes of clarity and
readability. Rule 304(a)(1)(i) provides that an initial Form ATS-N
must be effective for the NMS Stock ATS to avail itself of the Rule
3a1-1(a)(2) exemption (see supra Section IV.A.1), and Rule
304(a)(1)(iii) specifies when an initial Form ATS-N filing will
become effective. Rule 304(a)(1)(iii) also states that: (1) if the
Commission declares an initial Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock
ATS shall be prohibited from operating as an NMS Stock ATS
``pursuant to Sec. 240.3a1-1(a)(2);'' and (2) an initial Form ATS-N
declared ineffective ``does'' not (rather than ``would'' not)
prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form ATS-N.
\369\ The initial filing of Form ATS-N by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
is discussed further below. See infra Section IV.A.4.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the Proposal, we provided certain examples of scenarios in which
we believed that it would be necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and consistent with the protection of investors, to declare
ineffective a Form ATS-N, after notice and opportunity for
hearing.\370\ We continue to believe that the examples provided in the
Proposal are appropriate for the Commission to declare a Form ATS-N
ineffective and will provide NMS Stock ATSs and market participants
with clarity with respect to when the Commission could find, after
notice and opportunity for hearing, it necessary or appropriate in the
public interest, and consistent with the protection of investors, to
declare ineffective a Form ATS-N. We are also providing additional
clarity with respect to this guidance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\370\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024-26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters request additional guidance and clarity
regarding the Commission's review of initial Form ATS-N filings and
Form ATS-N amendments and the circumstances under which the Commission
may declare a Form ATS-N ineffective.\371\ We believe that it would be
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with
the protection of investors, to declare ineffective a Form ATS-N if the
Commission finds, for example, after notice and opportunity for
hearing, the Form ATS-N was filed by an entity that does not meet the
definition of NMS Stock ATS; one or more disclosures reveal non-
compliance with federal securities laws, or the rules or regulations
thereunder, including Regulation ATS; or one or more disclosures on
Form ATS-N are materially deficient with respect to their completeness
or comprehensibility. Given that the objective of Rule 304 is to
provide market participants with information about NMS Stock ATSs
through Form ATS-N disclosures, our review is designed to focus on the
Form ATS-N disclosures and is not a merit-based review of the
operations of the NMS Stock ATS or the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator.\372\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\371\ See supra notes 343, 345, and 346 and accompanying text.
See also supra notes 335-340 and accompanying text discussing
commenter concerns regarding whether the Commission articulated an
objective or consistent standard of review.
\372\ See infra notes 404-407 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe \373\ that it would be necessary to declare ineffective
a Form ATS-N if the Form ATS-N was filed by an entity that does not
satisfy the definition of ATS, and more specifically, the definition of
NMS Stock ATS.\374\ The proper classification of an entity would
clearly indicate to market participants, as well as the Commission, the
functions that entity performs and the regulatory framework and
attendant obligations that attach to that entity.\375\ We believe that
the review of Form ATS-N disclosures will help mitigate concerns that
market participants may be confused or misled about whether an entity
in fact meets the definition of an NMS Stock ATS. If an entity does not
meet the definition, market participants may hold false expectations
about how their orders may interact or be matched with other orders or
they may not fully understand whether the entity with which they are
doing business is required to comply with Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\373\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024-81025.
\374\ See Rule 300(k).
\375\ For example, an ATS that is not an NMS Stock ATS would be
subject to different conditions under Regulation ATS to be eligible
for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption. Similarly, depending on the
facts and circumstances, an entity that is not an ATS may be subject
to requirements as a broker-dealer, but not the conditions of
Regulation ATS, or may be required to register as a national
securities exchange. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81024 n.288 and
accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that it would be necessary to declare Form ATS-N
ineffective if one or more disclosures reveal non-compliance with
federal securities laws, including Regulation ATS. As discussed in the
Proposal,\376\ the Commission will conduct a ``red-flag'' review for
instances of non-compliance with federal securities laws that seem
apparent from the disclosures on Form ATS-N. For example, as a
condition to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption, Rule 301(b)(1) of
Regulation ATS requires that an ATS register as a broker-dealer under
Section 15 of the Exchange Act.\377\ Section 15(b)(8) of the Exchange
Act \378\ prohibits a registered broker or dealer from effecting a
transaction unless the broker or dealer is a member of a securities
association registered pursuant to Section 15A of the Exchange Act
\379\ or effects transactions solely on a national securities exchange
of which it is a member. Therefore, to comply with Regulation ATS, and
thus qualify for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption, an ATS must become a
member of an SRO and comply with the rules of the SRO, including
obtaining approval by the SRO to operate an ATS in accordance with
applicable SRO rules. If an entity were to file a Form ATS-N before
registering as a broker-dealer under Section 15 of the Exchange Act,
the entity would not be in compliance with Rule 301(b)(1) of Regulation
ATS.\380\ Moreover, if the entity were to file a Form ATS-N before
becoming a member of an SRO, the entity would not be in compliance with
Rule 301(b)(1) of Regulation ATS because Section 15(b)(1) of the
Exchange Act provides that a Commission order granting registration is
not effective until the broker-dealer has become a member of a national
securities association registered pursuant to Section 15A of the
Exchange Act,\381\ and the Commission's order granting broker-dealer
registration would not be effective.\382\ As another example, if the
Form ATS-N reveals non-compliance with Regulation NMS, including, among
other provisions, Rule 612, known as the ``Sub-Penny Rule,'' which
prohibits market participants, including ATSs, from displaying,
ranking, or accepting orders, quotations, or indications of interest in
NMS stock priced in an increment smaller than $0.01,\383\ the Form ATS-
N would not be consistent with Rule 304 because the NMS Stock ATS would
operate in a manner that may violate the federal securities laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\376\ See Proposal at 81025-26.
\377\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(1).
\378\ 15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(8).
\379\ 15 U.S.C. 78o-3.
\380\ See 17 CFR 301(b)(1). Rule 301(b)(1) of Regulation ATS
requires an ATS to register as a broker-dealer under Section 15 of
the Exchange Act.
\381\ See 15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(1).
\382\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(1).
\383\ Specifically, Rule 612(a) of Regulation NMS provides that
``no national securities exchange, national securities association,
alternative trading system, vendor, or broker or dealer shall
display, rank, or accept from any person a bid or offer, an order,
or an indication of interest in any NMS stock priced in an increment
smaller than $0.01 if that bid or offer, order, or indication of
interest is priced equal to or greater than $1.00 per share.'' See
17 CFR 242.612(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that it would be necessary to declare Form ATS-N
ineffective if one or more disclosures are materially deficient with
respect to their completeness and comprehensibility. The following are
non-exhaustive examples of Form ATS-N disclosures that may be deficient
with respect to
[[Page 38796]]
their completeness: \384\ an NMS Stock ATS discloses an order type on
Form ATS-N but does not describe the key attributes of the order type,
such as time-in-force limitations that can be placed on the ability to
execute the order, the treatment of unfilled portions of orders, or
conditions for cancelling orders in whole or in part; \385\ an NMS
Stock ATS describes some of its priority rules, but fails to describe
conditions or exceptions to its priority rules, or fails to describe
any priority overlays; \386\ an NMS Stock ATS, in response to Part II,
Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N, discloses that a principal trading desk
of the broker-dealer operator trades on the NMS Stock ATS, but does not
explain advantages the broker-dealer operator receives compared to
other subscribers; an NMS Stock ATS, in response to Part III, Item 19
of adopted Form ATS-N, fails to provide complete information about fees
and rebates charged for use of the NMS Stock ATS; an NMS Stock ATS
discloses that it has only one class of subscribers but the Commission
or its staff learns through discussions (during the review period) with
the NMS Stock ATS or otherwise that the ATS in fact has several classes
of subscribers; or an NMS Stock ATS discloses that it has two classes
of subscribers that are charged the same trading fees, but the
Commission or its staff learns through discussions with the ATS or
otherwise that in fact one class receives more favorable fees than the
other.\387\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\384\ These are some, but not all, of the types of circumstances
that could result in the Commission declaring a Form ATS-N
ineffective due to being materially deficient with respect to
completeness. We also provided some of these examples in the
Proposal as examples of disclosures that could cause the Commission
to declare a Form ATS-N ineffective because it contains one or more
disclosures that appear to be materially deficient. See Proposal,
supra note 2, at 81025. Because we are modifying the standard of
review to focus on completeness and comprehensibility, some of the
examples discussed in the Proposal are also discussed below to show
application of the standard the Commission is adopting to the same
scenarios.
\385\ This example was discussed in the Proposal as an example
of a disclosure that may be materially deficient because it may not
be sufficiently detailed. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81025.
\386\ See id. Another example would be if the NMS Stock ATS
fails to describe which order would receive priority where two or
more orders are otherwise on par, such as a situation in which a
customer and non-customer order are at the same price in a price
priority system.
\387\ These examples were discussed in the Proposal as examples
of disclosures that may be materially deficient because they would
not be accurate. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81025.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following are non-exhaustive examples of Form ATS-N disclosures
that may be deficient with respect to their comprehensibility: \388\
Form ATS-N includes inconsistent information among the disclosures,
such as a statement by the NMS Stock ATS in one part of the form that
the ATS uses private feeds to calculate the NBBO but in another part of
the form indicates that it uses the SIP; \389\ the NMS Stock ATS states
in one part of Form ATS-N that it does not segment its orders but
provides a description in another part of the Form ATS-N that indicates
that the ATS offers a functionality that allows institutional investors
to limit their trading activity to interactions with other
institutional investors; the Form ATS-N disclosures indicate that the
NMS Stock ATS uses time/price priority to execute orders but provides
an example that demonstrates an order received before an identically
priced order does not receive priority over the later order; or the NMS
Stock ATS states in one part of the Form ATS-N that it provides certain
order types, transacts in certain types of securities, or provides
access to certain classes of subscribers, and there is contrary
disclosure in other parts of the Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\388\ These are some, but not necessarily all, of the types of
circumstances that could result in the Commission declaring a Form
ATS-N ineffective due to being materially deficient with respect to
comprehensibility.
\389\ In the Proposal, this was provided as an example of a
disclosure that may be materially deficient because it may not be
accurate; however, inconsistent disclosures in a Form ATS-N also may
render disclosures unclear as to which rule or procedure, for
example, controls and how the NMS Stock ATS intends to operate. See
Proposal, supra note 2, at 81025. Depending on the facts and
circumstances, inconsistent or contradictory disclosures in a Form
ATS-N may be materially deficient with respect to comprehensibility.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not agree with the commenter that believes that the term
materially deficient should be understood to represent only ``extreme
situation[s].'' \390\ The Commission review will focus on whether the
lack of completeness or comprehensibility in a Form ATS-N disclosure
would prevent market participants from understanding an ATS's
operations or the ATS-related activities of its broker-dealer operator
or its affiliates. We believe that subscribers and market participants
will rely on Form ATS-N disclosures to understand and evaluate the
operations of the NMS Stock ATS and conflicts of interest that may
arise from the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and
its affiliates and use this information to help determine where to
route their orders, or the orders of their customers. We believe that a
disclosure on Form ATS-N that is materially deficient with respect to
its completeness or comprehensibility could mislead market participants
or impede their ability to understand an NMS Stock ATS's operations, or
the ATS-related activities of its broker-dealer operator, which would
frustrate the purpose of the transparency goals of this rulemaking. We
do not believe that it would be practical, as one commenter
suggests,\391\ to provide examples of disclosures that the Commission
would not view as materially deficient because the context of each
disclosure is crucial to determining whether a disclosure is complete
and comprehensible. Whether a disclosure deficiency is material depends
on the facts and circumstances, as does whether the deficiency would
support a finding that the deficiency is such that a declaration of
ineffectiveness would be in the public interest and consistent with the
protection of investors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\390\ See supra note 342 and accompanying text.
\391\ See supra note 343 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, one commenter questions how the Commission's
review will be undertaken to help ensure consistency across filings
when initial Form ATS-N filings are made ``without any prior knowledge
of the detail the Commission expects,'' \392\ and another states that
it ``would be helpful'' to have the Commission review initial filings
to, among other things, help ``standardize the level of disclosure
across NMS Stock ATSs.'' \393\ We have revised Form ATS-N in a number
of ways in response to comments. For instance, we added more ``yes'' or
``no'' questions, separated questions into distinct subject matter
categories, provided additional examples as guidance, and made requests
more explicit for more targeted responses.\394\ These changes to Form
ATS-N are designed to better inform NMS Stock ATSs of the requirements
of Form ATS-N and to solicit more consistent responses from NMS Stock
ATSs. However, NMS Stock ATSs operate differently, and with different
complexities, and use different terms to describe their systems. While
this could lead to different levels of disclosures among ATSs, we
believe that the combination of refinements to the form, and the
Commission's review of all Forms ATS-N filed by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
during the same period of time, will assist the Commission in providing
a consistent level of comment on the forms that will help facilitate a
more consistent and standard level of information disclosed across NMS
Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\392\ See Fidelity Letter at 9. See also supra note 346.
\393\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4. See also supra note 330 and
accompanying text.
\394\ See infra Section V (discussing modifications to Proposed
Form ATS-N).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38797]]
Any order declaring a Form ATS-N ineffective will require the
Commission to find that such action is necessary or appropriate in the
public interest, and consistent with the protection of investors. Rule
304(a)(1)(iii) provides that the Commission must provide notice to the
NMS Stock ATS and provide an opportunity for a hearing. As such, an NMS
Stock ATS will have the opportunity to be heard before the Commission
declares its Form ATS-N ineffective.
As discussed above, we do not agree with a commenter's suggestion
that a Form ATS-N be considered ineffective upon filing.\395\ We also
do not agree with the comment that a declaration of ineffectiveness of
a Form ATS-N will prejudice an entity such that a revised filed Form
ATS-N will have no practical value.\396\ We anticipate a dialogue
between Commission staff and the NMS Stock ATS regarding the Form ATS-N
disclosures and an NMS Stock ATS will have the opportunity to amend its
initial Form ATS-N during the Commission review period. If a Form ATS-N
is declared ineffective by the Commission, the Commission's order will
provide the basis for the declaration of ineffectiveness, and the NMS
Stock ATS will have the opportunity to file another Form ATS-N that
addresses the basis for the ineffectiveness determination. To the
extent that the NMS Stock ATS files a revised initial Form ATS-N or
Form ATS-N amendment that no longer contains, for example, material
deficiencies with respect to its completeness or comprehensibility, the
Form ATS-N would become effective, assuming no other basis for an
ineffectiveness determination. Regarding the comment that the
Commission should provide an NMS Stock ATS with a clear written
statement of the reasons for a declaration of ineffectiveness,\397\ the
Commission intends to provide the basis for declaring a Form ATS-N
ineffective in an order declaring a Form ATS-N ineffective, which will
help the NMS Stock ATS address disclosure deficiencies if the ATS
decides to refile an initial Form ATS-N and help market participants
understand the reason the Form ATS-N was declared ineffective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\395\ See supra notes 362-363 and accompanying text.
\396\ See supra note 356 and accompanying text.
\397\ See supra note 344 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received three comments regarding whether the Commission
should add a requirement to make available Form ATS-N filings for
public notice and comment before the Commission declares a Form ATS-N
effective or ineffective. One commenter notes that the rule filings of
national securities exchanges are made publicly available and subject
to notice and comment before approval, and that Form ATS-N should be
the same.\398\ Another commenter expresses the view that it would be
helpful for the Commission to receive feedback from market participants
regarding Form ATS-N filings, and supports harmonizing the process with
the application and filing process for national securities
exchanges.\399\ One commenter, however, expresses the view that Form
ATS-N should not be subject to a public notice and comment
process.\400\ This commenter states that the Commission has long
recognized several fundamental differences between national securities
exchanges and ATSs, and that imposing a public notice and comment
period on ATSs would not be equitable and would impede dynamic market
structure advances because the Commission has fostered competition
among different types of trading venues.\401\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\398\ See CBOE Letter at 2.
\399\ See Citadel Letter at 3.
\400\ See UBS Letter at 4.
\401\ See id. Another commenter, in expressing the view that
Form ATS-N amendments should not be made public upon filing, states
that doing so would risk turning the effectiveness process into an
extended review, notice, and comment period, which the commenter
believes would be inappropriate and unwarranted. See SIFMA Letter at
31-32.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that it would not be appropriate to subject Form ATS-N
filings to public notice and comment, as some commenters suggest. The
Commission did not propose to subject Form ATS-N filings to a public
notice and comment process. As discussed above,\402\ the Commission is
not performing a review of the merits of initial Form ATS-N
disclosures, such as determining the strengths and weaknesses of the
trading platform or a protocol offered by the NMS Stock ATS. The
Commission also is not making findings regarding whether the means by
which orders will interact on the trading platform are, or are not,
consistent with the Exchange Act, as is the case with respect to
certain SRO rule filings.\403\ Rather the Commission's review of Form
ATS-N disclosures will focus on the completeness and comprehensibility
of the disclosures, which does not lend itself to public notice and
comment. We do not believe that public comment would facilitate the
review of Form ATS-N, and are not subjecting Form ATS-N filings to a
process similar to SROs' proposed rule change filings, which are
subject to notice and comment, and consideration by the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\402\ See supra Section IV.A.3.c.
\403\ See supra note 359 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The standard of review for ineffectiveness of Form ATS-N filings
that we are adopting does not include an evaluation of the merits of
the services that an NMS Stock ATS offers to subscribers. As discussed
above, some commenters raise concerns about whether the Commission
review process will result in imposing substantive standards on NMS
Stock ATSs.\404\ Rule 304 and Form ATS-N are designed to enhance
operational transparency for NMS Stock ATSs, and therefore, the
standard of review undergirding the Commission review will focus on the
disclosures on Form ATS-N, as described above, and not the manner in
which the NMS Stock ATS operates. Unlike proposed rule changes filed by
national securities exchanges, the Commission will not make affirmative
findings about Form ATS-N filings with regard to consistency with the
Exchange Act.\405\ Regulation ATS was designed to encourage innovation
\406\ and provide enough flexibility to accommodate the business
objectives of, and benefits provided by, alternative trading
systems.\407\ As follows, the standard of review for ineffectiveness of
Form ATS-N is designed to enhance the transparency objectives of the
new disclosure requirements in a manner consistent with allowing NMS
Stock ATSs to continue to innovate and provide benefits to the market.
The Commission review is not intended to evaluate an NMS Stock ATS's
services against industry norms, nor approve or disapprove aspects of
the NMS Stock ATS's operations, for example, a new trading
functionality, order type, or execution protocol.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\404\ See, e.g., supra note 346 and accompanying text.
\405\ Proposed rule changes filed by national securities
exchanges pursuant to Section 19 of the Exchange Act must be
consistent with the Exchange Act. In addition, filings made pursuant
to Section 19(b)(2) require the Commission to approve a proposed
rule change if it finds the proposed rule change is consistent with
the Exchange Act and the rules and regulations thereunder, or it
must disapprove the proposed rule change. While a disclosure that
reveals non-compliance with the federal securities laws or the rules
and regulations thereunder may be a basis for the Commission finding
that a declaration of ineffectiveness would be in the public
interest and consistent with the protection of investors, Regulation
ATS is a disclosure regime, and the Commission will not be making
findings on consistency with the Exchange Act with respect to
disclosures on Form ATS-N.
\406\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70910.
\407\ See id. at 70847.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38798]]
4. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv): Transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
a. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A): Initial Filing Requirements
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) describes the process through which Legacy NMS
Stock ATSs would file their initial Form ATS-N. We are adopting Rule
304(a)(1)(iv) (``Transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs'') to provide a
process for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to file its initial Form ATS-N, and
to continue to operate while its initial Form ATS-N is under Commission
review.\408\ Adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) (``Initial Form ATS-N filing
requirements'') requires that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall file with
the Commission an initial Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions
of Rule 304(a)(1)(iv), no earlier than January 7, 2019, and no later
than February 8, 2019. Further, adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) provides
that an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall
supersede and replace for purposes of the exemption the previously-
filed Form ATS (including any amendments to Form ATS) of the Legacy NMS
Stock ATS.\409\ The Legacy NMS Stock ATS may operate, on a temporary
basis, pursuant to the filed initial Form ATS-N, and any amendment
thereto, during the review of the initial Form ATS-N by the
Commission.\410\ In addition, adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) provides
that an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS, as amended,
will become effective, unless declared ineffective, upon the earlier
of: (1) The completion of review by the Commission and publication
pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2) or (2) the expiration of the review period,
or, if applicable, the end of the extended review period, pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\408\ We are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) to delineate the
initial filing process applicable to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs from the
initial filing process applicable to non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs. This
differs from the proposed rule text, which integrated the
requirements applicable to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs within the
requirements applicable to all NMS Stock ATSs set forth in proposed
Rule 304(a)(1)(i) through (iii). Providing these requirements in a
separate section of the rule better organizes the rule text so
filers can more easily understand the initial Form ATS-N filing
process that is applicable to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and is
responsive to comments, which are discussed below.
\409\ Although the Form ATS for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS will no
longer have any legal effect for purposes of the exemption after the
ATS files a Form ATS-N, a Form ATS will nevertheless continue to be
subject to the federal securities laws and the regulations
thereunder, including Regulation ATS, as a Form ATS previously filed
with the Commission will constitute a ``report'' within the meaning
of sections 11A, 17(a), 18(a), and 32(a), and any other applicable
provisions of the Exchange Act. See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(vi).
\410\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv) modifies proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) to
address certain commenter concerns, as described below. Under the
proposed rule, an NMS Stock ATS operating as of the effective date of
the final rule would continue to operate pursuant to its previously
filed initial operation report on Form ATS, pending the Commission's
review of the filed Form ATS. We modified this proposed process in
response to comments. In the Proposal, we asked whether the Commission
should allow a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to continue operations pursuant to
Form ATS pending the Commission's review of Form ATS-N.\411\ Two
commenters express support for certain aspects of the proposed
transition process for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs (including that the
Commission allow Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to operate during the Commission
review period).\412\ One commenter states that it supports requiring
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to file an initial Form ATS-N.\413\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\411\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81026.
\412\ See CFA Institute Letter at 5; BIDS Letter at 3.
\413\ See CFA Institute Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Legacy NMS Stock ATS will be required to file an initial Form
ATS-N to continue to operate pursuant to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption
with respect to its Rule 3b-16 activity in NMS stocks beyond January 7,
2019. This provision will allow a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to continue its
current operations without disruptions to the ATS or its current
subscribers and provide the Legacy NMS Stock ATS with sufficient time
to make an orderly transition from compliance under the current
Regulation ATS requirements to compliance with Rule 304.
Under the adopted rule, both Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and non-Legacy
NMS Stock ATSs will be required to file an initial Form ATS-N. We
believe that market participants should have access to the same level
of information disclosed by both Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and non-Legacy
NMS Stock ATSs as market participants will consider routing orders to
both types of NMS Stock ATS. Allowing Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to file
Form ATS instead of Form ATS-N would limit the amount of information
available to market participants about these ATSs' operations and the
ATS-related activities of their broker-dealer operators, and would
thereby make it difficult for market participants to assess Legacy NMS
Stock ATSs as potential routing destinations for their orders.
We believe that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS should be permitted to
continue to operate during the Commission review period for initial
Form ATS-N.\414\ Therefore, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) to
transition Legacy NMS Stock ATSs from operating pursuant to Form ATS to
operating pursuant to Form ATS-N without interruption. As noted above,
the transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs will benefit Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs and their subscribers, as subscribers will be able to continue to
send their orders to Legacy NMS Stock ATSs without disruption.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\414\ See also supra note 412 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters request clarification about the process for a Legacy
NMS Stock ATS to file an initial Form ATS-N and its obligations to
update its Form ATS on file with the Commission while the Commission
reviews its initial Form ATS-N.\415\ One commenter expresses concerns
about the regulatory and legal uncertainties that could result from a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS operating while having filed with the Commission
both a Form ATS and a Form ATS-N.\416\ Similarly, another commenter
requests clarification about how a Legacy NMS Stock ATS should handle
material changes to the NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS.\417\ This commenter
also asks the Commission to clarify whether a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
should amend its Form ATS to avoid potential liability caused by the
NMS Stock ATS submitting the additional information required in Form
ATS-N.\418\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\415\ See BIDS Letter at 2-3; SIFMA Letter at 29.
\416\ See BIDS Letter at 2.
\417\ See SIFMA Letter at 29.
\418\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These commenters suggest processes that they believe will address
these concerns.\419\ One commenter suggests that the Commission deem
effective a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N upon filing but
nevertheless subject it to a review and comment period by the
Commission.\420\ We are not adopting this suggestion because labeling
an initial Form ATS-N ``effective'' before the Commission has completed
the review could mislead market participants. Another commenter
suggests that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS that makes changes to its
operations during the 120-calendar day review period or extended review
period should only be required to amend its Form ATS, and that the
Legacy NMS Stock ATS should not be required to
[[Page 38799]]
also amend its initial Form ATS-N until the Commission declares it
effective, and that the NMS Stock ATS could then file a ``clean-up''
amendment to its initial Form ATS-N.\421\ We are not adopting this
approach because, as discussed below, our adopted approach to require a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS to amend Form ATS-N would be less burdensome for
the ATS than requiring the Legacy NMS Stock ATS to amend its Form ATS
during the Commission review period and Form ATS-N after the Form ATS-N
becomes effective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\419\ See BIDS Letter at 2-3; SIFMA Letter at 29.
\420\ See BIDS Letter at 2.
\421\ See SIFMA Letter at 29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to these commenters, and after considering their
alternative suggestions, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A), which
is modified from proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i), to provide that a filed
Form ATS-N shall supersede and replace for purposes of the exemption a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS's previously-filed Form ATS. After considering the
comments, we acknowledge that if the Commission were to require a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS to file and amend both Form ATS and Form ATS-N
during the Commission review period for an initial Form ATS-N, the
Legacy NMS Stock ATS could incur additional legal and regulatory risks,
as it would be required to make changes to two forms and ensure that
the information on the two forms is consistent. The disclosures on an
initial Form ATS-N would include the vast majority of information
provided to the Commission on Form ATS that pertains to the ATS's NMS
stock operations. Therefore, we believe that the modifications to the
proposed rule would alleviate the burden on Legacy NMS Stock ATSs of
filing two separate documents with the Commission that would likely
contain significantly overlapping information. In addition, to address
the commenters' concerns, and facilitate the ability of a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS to maintain only one filing for a limited time during the
transition, we are also modifying proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i), and
adopting as Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A), to provide that the Legacy NMS Stock
ATS may operate, on a provisional basis, pursuant to the filed Form
ATS-N, and any amendments thereto,\422\ during the Commission review
period of the filed initial Form ATS-N. This provision is designed to
facilitate an orderly transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs from the
Form ATS regime to the Form ATS-N regime while at the same time
requiring an appropriate level of disclosure by NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\422\ A Legacy NMS Stock ATS may file amendments pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) during the Commission review period. A change
subject to a material amendment filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
within 30 calendar days of the end of the 240-calendar day extended
review period, as provided by Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B)(1), or other
period to which the Legacy NMS Stock ATS agrees in writing described
in Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B)(2), may only be implemented by the Legacy
NMS Stock ATS after the expiration of the 30-calendar day period
provided by Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A), and the Commission may declare
such an amendment ineffective, as appropriate, until the 30-calendar
day review period expires.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we are adopting a provision in Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A)
that provides that an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock
ATS, as amended, will become effective, unless declared ineffective,
upon the earlier of: (1) The completion of review by the Commission and
publication pursuant to Rule 304(b)(2) or (2) the expiration of the
review period, or, if applicable, the end of the extended review
period, pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B). We are adding this provision
to reflect changes to the effectiveness process; this provision is
designed to replace parts of proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(iii). In addition,
because we are adopting a process that allows a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to
amend its initial Form ATS-N during the Commission review period, we
are adding to Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form
ATS-N ``as amended'' will become effective, which will include any
amendments made to an initial Form ATS-N during the Commission review
period.
Finally, proposed Rule 304(a)(1) would have required Legacy NMS
Stock ATSs to submit their initial Form ATS-N filings within 120 days
of the effective date of this rulemaking. We received one comment
supporting the requirement that Legacy NMS Stock ATSs file Form ATS-N
within 120 calendar days of the effective date of the final rule,
``given the reasonable assumption that the operators of the ATS should
be very familiar with the operational structure of said ATS.'' \423\ We
are modifying proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) (as part of adopted Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(A)) to require Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to file an initial
Form ATS-N no earlier than January 7, 2019, and no later than February
8, 2019 and making additional technical modifications.\424\ We believe
that this will provide adequate time following the date that the
enhanced disclosure requirements under Rule 304 become effective and
for NMS Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to prepare and file an initial Form ATS-N
with the Commission. NMS Stock ATSs will file Form ATS-N via EDGAR,
which will be ready to accept Form ATS-N filings on January 7, 2019. We
agree with the commenter that a Legacy NMS Stock ATSs should be
knowledgeable of the operations of its system and the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates and
believes that requiring Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to file their initial
Form ATS-N between January 7, 2019 and February 8, 2019 provides these
with reasonable time to prepare and file their disclosures on Form ATS-
N.\425\ We note that, until a Legacy NMS Stock ATS files its initial
Form ATS-N with the Commission, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS must provide
notice of changes to its operations by amending its Form ATS on file
with the Commission pursuant to Rule 301(b)(2) of Regulation ATS.\426\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\423\ See CFA Institute Letter at 5.
\424\ This provision, which was proposed as the second sentence
of proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) is now the first sentence of adopted
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). In the adopted rule, we are making technical,
non-substantive modifications to the proposed rule text, including:
(1) Referring to ``an'' NMS Stock ATS rather than ``the'' NMS Stock
ATS; (2) defining an NMS Stock ATS operating pursuant to an initial
operation report on Form ATS as of the effective date as a ``Legacy
NMS Stock ATS;'' (3) revising the definition of Legacy NMS Stock ATS
to state that it operates pursuant to ``an initial operation
report'' rather than a ``previously filed'' initial operation
report; and (4) adding to Rule 304(a)(1)(i) the term ``initial''
before Form ATS-N. We are also changing the term ``in accordance
with the instructions therein'' to ``in accordance with the
conditions of this section'' because we intended for NMS Stock ATSs
to comply with all of the applicable provisions of Rule 304,
including any procedural provisions, in addition to the Instructions
on Form ATS-N.
\425\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81023.
\426\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2). See supra notes 57-63 and
accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B): Commission Review Period; Ineffectiveness
Determination
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B) provides the process and timing for the
Commission to review a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N, and,
if applicable, declare such initial Form ATS-N effective. We are
adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B) (``Commission review period;
Ineffectiveness determination''), which provides that the Commission
may, by order, as provided in Rule 304(a)(1)(iii), declare an initial
Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS ineffective no later than
120 calendar days from the date of filing with the Commission, or, if
applicable, the end of the extended review period. The Commission may
extend the initial Form ATS-N review period for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
for: (1) An additional 120 calendar days if the initial Form ATS-N is
unusually lengthy or raises novel or complex issues that require
additional time for review, in which case the Commission will notify
the
[[Page 38800]]
Legacy NMS Stock ATS in writing within the initial 120-calendar day
review period and will briefly describe the reason for the
determination for which additional time for review is required; or (2)
any extended review period to which a duly-authorized representative of
the Legacy NMS Stock ATS agrees in writing.
As discussed above, we received comments on the 120-calendar day
review period and extended review periods that either support or do not
object to the time frames proposed for both non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
and Legacy NMS Stock ATSs.\427\ We continue to believe that 120
calendar days typically would provide the Commission adequate time to
carry out its oversight functions with respect to the review of Forms
ATS-N filed by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, including its responsibilities to
protect investors and maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets,
and that the extended review period for filings that are unusually
lengthy or raise novel or complex issues will allow the Commission and
its staff to conduct a thorough review and provide sufficient
opportunity to discuss the filing with the NMS Stock ATS if
necessary.\428\ We are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B), which was
proposed as part of Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(A), with modifications,
consistent with and for the reasons discussed above with respect to the
Commission review period for Form ATS-N filings by non-Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs.\429\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\427\ See supra notes 294-295 and accompanying text.
\428\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81023-24. See also supra
notes 296-297 and accompanying text.
\429\ See supra Section IV.A.3. We added language to the
proposed rule text, and created a separate paragraph (B) of Rule
304(a)(1)(iv) to address the Commission review period for Legacy NMS
Stock ATS amendments including: (1) Specifying, consistent with the
proposed rule text, that the Commission will declare ``by order'' an
initial Form ATS-N ineffective and referencing the paragraphs under
the rule that delineate the process pursuant to which the Commission
will do so; (2) specifying that the Commission will declare an
initial Form ATS-N ineffective no later than 120 calendar days from
``the date of'' filing with the Commission; (3) adding to the first
sentence that the Commission may declare an initial Form ATS-N
ineffective no later than 120 calendar days from the date of filing
with the Commission, ``or, if applicable, the end of the extended
review period'' to reduce ambiguity regarding the length of the
Commission review period; (4) specifying that the Commission will
notify the Legacy NMS Stock ATS of any extension of the review
period within the 120 ``calendar day'' review period; (5) specifying
that the Commission review period described in this section applies
to ``initial'' Form ATS-N; and (6) using the defined term ``Legacy
NMS Stock ATS'' throughout the paragraph.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that if the Commission declares a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS should
have the opportunity to amend its Form ATS-N so that the form would be
effective before the NMS Stock ATS is required to cease operating.\430\
During the review process, we expect to engage in dialogue with the
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs about their Form ATS-N disclosures. To the extent
any deficiencies exist with the Form ATS-N disclosures, we expect that
the Legacy NMS Stock ATSs typically will have an opportunity to
understand and cure deficiencies in the filing before the Commission
declares the Form ATS-N ineffective. If, after discussion with
Commission staff, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS determines that it needs more
time to address deficiencies in its initial Form ATS-N to avoid a
Commission declaration of ineffectiveness, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS could
consent to an extended Commission review period under Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(B)(2). Prior to declaring a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form
ATS-N ineffective, the Commission will provide the ATS with notice and
opportunity for hearing about the Commission's intention to declare the
form ineffective. After the Commission declares a Form ATS-N
ineffective, however, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS will not have an
opportunity to amend its Form ATS-N.\431\ Upon its Form ATS-N being
declared ineffective, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS must cease operating
pursuant to the Rule 3a1-1(a) exemption,\432\ and to the extent that
the ATS does continue to operate, the Commission could find it to be an
unregistered national securities exchange, and thus operating in
violation of Section 5 of the Exchange Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\430\ See SIFMA Letter at 29.
\431\ Because its initial Form ATS-N supersedes and replaces a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS for purposes of the exemption and
the initial Form ATS-N can be amended, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS may
not withdraw its initial Form ATS-N. See infra Section V.B.1.
\432\ See infra note 434.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This commenter also states that a declaration of ineffectiveness
should remain confidential until the Legacy NMS Stock ATS has amended
the Form ATS-N and the amended form is ``approved.'' \433\ We do not
agree with the commenter's suggestion. As discussed immediately above,
there will be an opportunity during the review process for the ATS to
supplement its filing. Once its initial Form ATS-N is declared
ineffective, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS would not be able to operate
pursuant to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption and would not be able to
amend its Form ATS-N after it is declared ineffective. It could file a
new Form ATS-N, which the Commission will review without prejudice. We
believe that it is in the public interest for the Commission to make an
order of ineffectiveness for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS publicly available
so that market participants have notice of the operating status of the
NMS Stock ATS and can make appropriate adjustments to their routing
strategies.\434\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\433\ See SIFMA Letter at 29.
\434\ The Commission could also, in the case of a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS, provide in its order of ineffectiveness a period of time
for the NMS Stock ATS to wind down its operations. Because
Commission orders of ineffectiveness would be made public, market
participants would also have notice of any wind down period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters request clarification about whether amending an
initial Form ATS-N as a result of a material change during the
Commission review period would toll the review period, and suggest that
the review period should not restart with every amendment.\435\ The
filing of a Form ATS-N material amendment by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS,
even if filed within 30 days of the expiration of the Commission's
extended review period, would not toll the review period for the Form
ATS-N; initial Form ATS-N will become effective in accordance with the
timeframes set forth in Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A). However, a change
reflected in a material amendment that is filed within 30 days of the
expiration of the Commission review period could not be implemented
until the end of the Commission's 30-calendar day review period
pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\435\ See BIDS Letter at 3; SIFMA Letter at 29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C): Amendments to Initial Form ATS-N
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) describes the process through which Legacy
NMS Stock ATSs would amend their initial Form ATS-N during the
Commission review period. We are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C)
(``Amendments to initial Form ATS-N''), which requires that during the
review period of the initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock
ATS, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall amend its initial Form ATS-N
pursuant to the requirements of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (D). The
adopted rule differs from the Proposal. As proposed, during the
Commission review period for an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy
NMS Stock ATS, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS would have been required to
continue operating pursuant to its existing Form ATS initial operation
report and file amendments on Form ATS to provide notice of changes to
the operations of its
[[Page 38801]]
system.\436\ Because adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A) states that a filed
Form ATS-N will supersede and replace for purposes of the exemption a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS's previously-filed Form ATS, a Legacy NMS Stock
ATS will no longer file Form ATS amendments once it files an initial
Form ATS-N. Instead, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS will be required to update
Form ATS-N during the Commission review period.\437\ If the ATS trades
both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks, such ATS would update its Form ATS
with respect to its non-NMS stock operations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\436\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81023; see also 17 CFR
242.301(b)(2)(ii) through (iv). The Commission is modifying the
proposed rule by creating a new paragraph (C) of Rule 304(a)(1)(iv),
which provides a process for reporting changes during the Commission
review period for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs.
\437\ See supra note 409.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, two commenters request that the Commission
clarify the process for filing amendments during the Commission review
period for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs \438\ and suggest alternative
approaches.\439\ The modifications in adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) are
designed to address the comments requesting clarification about the
process for reporting material changes during the time the Commission
reviews the initial Form ATS-N of a Legacy NMS Stock ATS.\440\ Adopted
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) also addresses the alternative approaches that
the commenters suggest by requiring a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to update
its Form ATS-N (rather than Form ATS), and operate pursuant to its Form
ATS-N (rather than Form ATS).\441\ We believe that Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(C) will relieve any unnecessary burden from maintaining
two forms and ease the transition to the Form ATS-N regime.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\438\ See supra note 415 and accompanying text.
\439\ See supra notes 420 and 421 and accompanying text.
\440\ See supra note 415 and accompanying text.
\441\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter asked the Commission to adopt a process
that would allow Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to introduce a new functionality
or make changes during the 120-calendar day review period for the
initial Form ATS-N.\442\ We agree with the commenter that Legacy NMS
Stock ATSs should have a method to make changes to their operations and
introduce new functionalities during the Commission review period. In
accordance with Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C), during the Commission review
period, the Legacy NMS Stock ATSs may make changes to the operations of
the ATS and shall file amendments to reflect those changes pursuant to
the requirements of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (D). For example,
during the period of Commission review of its initial Form ATS-N, a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS may make a material change to its operations,
provided that it files with the Commission an amendment to its Form
ATS-N describing such change at least 30 calendar days prior to the
date of implementation of such change, pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A). A change subject to a material amendment filed by a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS may be implemented by the Legacy NMS Stock ATS
after the expiration of the 30-calendar day period provided by Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\442\ See Liquidnet Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) provides that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall
amend its initial Form ATS-N pursuant to the requirements of Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (D), which govern the process for filing
amendments to Form ATS-N. Amendments will be subject to Commission
review and could be declared ineffective under Rule 304(a)(2)(ii).
Filed Form ATS-N amendments will not be made public until the Legacy
NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N becomes effective and publicly
available. Once a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N becomes
effective, the Commission will make public the Form ATS-N, as amended,
which will incorporate any amendments that the Legacy NMS Stock ATS
filed to the initial Form ATS-N during the Commission review period,
except for any material amendments still subject to the 30-calendar day
Commission review period.\443\ In connection with the changes described
above, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C), which provides that a
Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall amend its filed Form ATS-N during the
Commission review pursuant to the requirements of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A)
through (D).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\443\ See infra note 587 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Rule 304(a)(2): Form ATS-N Amendments
1. Rule 304(a)(2)(i): Filing Requirements
Rule 304(a)(2)(i) describes the types of amendments that NMS Stock
ATSs would be required to file to their Form ATS-N. We proposed Rule
304(a)(2)(i) (``Form ATS-N amendment filing requirements'') to require
an NMS Stock ATS to update information disclosed on Form ATS-N
concerning its manner of operations and the ATS-related activities of
its broker-dealer operator and its affiliates. Proposed Rule
304(a)(2)(i) would have required an NMS Stock ATS to amend an effective
Form ATS-N in accordance with the Instructions therein: (A) at least 30
calendar days prior to the date of implementation of a material change
to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or to the activities of the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates that are subject to disclosure
on Form ATS-N; (B) within 30 calendar days after the end of each
calendar quarter to correct any other information that has become
inaccurate for any reason and has not been previously reported to the
Commission as a Form ATS-N amendment; or (C) promptly, to correct
information in any previous disclosure on Form ATS-N, after discovery
that any information filed under proposed Rule 304(a)(1)(i) or
(a)(2)(i)(A) or (B) was inaccurate or incomplete when filed.
We are adopting Rule 304(a)(2)(i) with modifications. As adopted,
Rule 304(a)(2)(i) requires an NMS Stock ATS to amend a Form ATS-N in
accordance with the conditions of Rule 304: \444\ (1) At least 30
calendar days, except as provided by Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D), prior to the
date of implementation of a material change to the operations of the
NMS Stock ATS or to the activities of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates that are subject to disclosure on Form ATS-N; (2) no later
than 30 calendar days after the end of each calendar quarter to correct
information that has become inaccurate or incomplete for any reason and
was not required to be reported to the Commission as a Form ATS-N
amendment pursuant to Rules 304(a)(2)(i)(A), (C), or (D); (3) promptly,
to correct information in any previous disclosure on Form ATS-N, after
[[Page 38802]]
discovery that any material information previously filed on Form ATS-N
was inaccurate or incomplete when filed; and (4) no later than seven
calendar days after information required to be disclosed in Part III,
Items 24 and 25 on Form ATS-N has become inaccurate or incomplete. Form
ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS filing an amendment to ``select one''
of the four types of amendments; each amendment type is mutually
exclusive.\445\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\444\ The proposed rule text required that an NMS Stock ATS
amend ``an effective'' Form ATS-N in accordance with the
``instructions therein.'' We have modified this requirement in the
Rule 304(a)(2)(i) as adopted by deleting the word ``effective''
because, as discussed in Section IV.A.4.c, we are adopting Rule
304(a)(1)(ii) and Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C), which allow an NMS Stock
ATS to amend a Form ATS-N that has not yet become effective.
In addition, we are replacing the rule text that stated that an
NMS Stock ATS shall amend Form ATS-N in accordance with ``the
instructions therein'' with text requiring an NMS Stock ATS to amend
Form ATS-N in accordance with ``the conditions of this section''
because we intended for NMS Stock ATSs to comply with all of the
applicable provisions of Rule 304, including any procedural
provisions, in addition to the Instructions on Form ATS-N.
We are also adding a separate amendment filing process for
changes to information disclosed in Part III, Item 24 and 25 of Form
ATS-N. See infra Sections IV.B.1.a.iii. Because in Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(D) we are specifying treatment for order display and
fair access amendments, which generally would be material changes,
we are also adding that Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) applies ``except as
provided by'' Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D). See infra Sections IV.B.1.a.iii.
\445\ See cover page to Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Material Changes
(i) Comments on Advance Notice
We proposed that an NMS Stock ATS would be required to amend an
effective Form ATS-N at least 30 calendar days prior to the date of
implementation of a material change to the operations of the NMS Stock
ATS or to the activities of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates that are subject to disclosure on Form ATS-N.\446\ In the
Proposal, we stated that a 30-calendar day advance notice period would
give the Commission the opportunity to clarify any questions that might
arise or to take action, if appropriate, regarding problems that may
impact market participants, before the NMS Stock ATS implemented the
change.\447\ We also stated that such advance notice would allow market
participants to evaluate the changes before implementation and assess
the NMS Stock ATS as a continued, or potential, trading venue.\448\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\446\ See proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A).
\447\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81027-28.
\448\ See id. at 81028.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received several comments relating to the proposed 30-calendar
day advance notice requirement for material changes in proposed Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A). One commenter states that it supports the requirement
that an NMS Stock ATS file a material amendment to Form ATS-N 30 days
in advance of implementing a material change to the operations of the
NMS Stock ATS, or the activities of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates.\449\ Another commenter states that although advance notice
of 20 calendar days before implementing a material change may be
adequate, it believes that the 30-calendar day advance notice
requirement strikes an appropriate balance between an NMS Stock ATS's
ability to innovate, while also providing market participants and
regulators adequate time to evaluate and respond to the intended
change.\450\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\449\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4.
\450\ See HMA Letter at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters suggest that instead of requiring 30 calendar days
of advance notice, the Commission should require NMS Stock ATSs to file
an amendment on Form ATS-N at least 20 calendar days in advance of
implementing a material change, which is the same as the current
requirement for filing amendments to Form ATS.\451\ One commenter
believes the 30-calendar day advance notice period would provide
minimal benefit for the Commission because the Commission may at any
time object to an NMS Stock ATS's functionality or require
clarification.\452\ This commenter also states that lengthening the
advance notice period would create an unnecessary delay for NMS Stock
ATSs in introducing new functionality and improving existing
functionality and processes.\453\ The other commenter supports
retaining the 20-calendar day advance notice period, stating that due
to the breadth of disclosures on Form ATS-N and the fact that Form ATS-
N disclosures will be made public, market participants will have access
to a much greater level of information about ATS operations and changes
than in the past.\454\ Another commenter states that a process for
reviewing Form ATS-N amendments that extends beyond 30 days could have
a significant impact on NMS Stock ATS operations, particularly with
regard to the launch of new technologies.\455\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\451\ See Liquidnet Letter at 4; KCG Letter at 5.
\452\ See Liquidnet Letter at 4.
\453\ See id.
\454\ See KCG Letter at 5.
\455\ See Fidelity Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) with modifications. We do not
agree with commenters who believe that the current 20-calendar day
advance notice period for material amendments to be filed on Form ATS
would be more appropriate for NMS Stock ATSs than a 30-calendar day
period. We believe that a 30 calendar day advance notice period for a
material change would allow the Commission sufficient time to review
the amendment and determine, if necessary, whether the filing should be
declared ineffective. Although we agree with the commenter that states
that market participants will have access to more information regarding
NMS Stock ATS operations than in the past,\456\ given the complexity of
NMS Stock ATSs today and the breadth of disclosures required on Form
ATS-N, the 10 additional calendar days provides the Commission with the
necessary time to review, and communicate with the NMS Stock ATS about,
the Form ATS-N disclosures. We believe that the benefits of a longer
advance notice period justify any potential burden on an NMS Stock ATS
and any potential delay to the introduction of a new technology. We
believe that a 30-calendar day review period will benefit subscribers
and market participants as the time will allow the Commission to help
ensure that disclosures made available to the public are complete and
comprehensible.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\456\ See KCG Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that the advance notice requirement for
material changes would be close to an ``advance notice and approval''
approach that may effectively result in a merit review process of NMS
Stock ATS operations.\457\ As discussed above with respect to the
Commission's review of an initial Form ATS-N pursuant to Rule
304(a)(1)(iii),\458\ the Commission's review of a Form ATS-N amendment
does not weigh the merits of a change that is the subject of a Form
ATS-N amendment. Rather, the Commission's review is focused on the
completeness and comprehensibility of the disclosures themselves.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\457\ See KCG Letter at 4.
\458\ See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter expresses concern regarding situations in which
it files a material amendment to Form ATS-N but needs to modify a
functionality based on customer feedback or unanticipated workflows or
scenarios.\459\ The commenter states that it would be beneficial for an
NMS Stock ATS to have the flexibility to make modifications without
delay, as long as any modifications were disclosed in advance to
customers, would not adversely impact customers, and do not change the
key elements of the new functionality that had been previously
described in a Form ATS-N amendment.\460\ In addition to providing
advance notice to the public about a potential material change to the
NMS Stock ATS, the advance notice period allows the Commission to
review the disclosures on Form ATS-N, and we believe that the review
will help ensure that market participants receive complete and
comprehensible disclosures. We are providing guidance for determining
whether a change is material.\461\ In deciding whether to implement a
modification to a functionality without delay in response to customer
feedback or unanticipated workflows or scenarios, an NMS Stock ATS is
required to determine if, in light of all relevant facts and
circumstances,
[[Page 38803]]
the modification constitutes a material change. If the modification
does not constitute a material change, the NMS Stock ATS could
implement the change and file an updating amendment. However, if the
modification is material, the NMS Stock ATS must file a material
amendment and wait 30 calendar days before implementing the
change.\462\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\459\ See Liquidnet Letter at 5.
\460\ See id.
\461\ See infra Section IV.B.1.a.ii.
\462\ In the event that it is appropriate for the Commission to
exempt an NMS Stock ATS, conditionally or unconditionally, by
Commission order, after application by the ATS, from the advance
filing requirement, the Commission will be able to issue exemptions.
See supra note 226 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) Comments on Materiality
In the Proposal, we stated our belief that a change to the
operations of an NMS Stock ATS, or the disclosures regarding the
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates, would be
material if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable market
participant would consider the change important when evaluating the NMS
Stock ATS as a potential trading venue.\463\ We continue to believe
that this standard of materiality is appropriate. This standard of
materiality is similar to materiality standards applied in the context
of securities disclosures made pursuant to other rules.\464\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\463\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81028.
\464\ See id. at 81028 n.309.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters agree that materiality is an appropriate standard
for requiring advance notice.\465\ One commenter states that it agrees
with the guidance regarding materiality set forth in the Proposal \466\
but notes that facts and circumstances could determine whether the
scenarios the Commission provided in the Proposal would likely
constitute material changes, and states that although the scenarios set
forth in the Proposal are helpful examples, they are broadly
written.\467\ We continue to believe that scenarios that are
particularly likely to implicate a material change would include: (1) A
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates beginning to trade on the NMS
Stock ATS; (2) a change to the broker-dealer operator's policies and
procedures governing the written safeguards and written procedures to
protect the confidential trading information of subscribers pursuant to
Rule 301(b)(10)(i) of Regulation ATS; (3) a change to the types of
participants on the NMS Stock ATS; (4) the introduction or removal of a
new order type on the NMS Stock ATS; (5) a change to the order
interaction and priority procedures; (6) a change to the segmentation
of orders and participants; (7) a change to the manner in which the NMS
Stock ATS displays orders or quotes; and (8) a change of a service
provider to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS that has access to
subscribers' confidential trading information.\468\ This list is not
intended to be exhaustive, and we do not mean to imply that other
changes to the operations of an NMS Stock ATS or the activities of the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates could not constitute material
changes. Further, the NMS Stock ATS should generally consider whether
the cumulative effect of a series of changes to the operations of the
NMS Stock ATS or the activities of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates with regard to the NMS Stock ATS is material. In addition,
in determining whether a change is material, an ATS generally should
consider whether such change would affect: (1) The competitive dynamics
among ATS subscribers; (2) the execution quality or performance of the
orders of any subscriber or category of subscribers; (3) the fees that
any subscriber or category of subscribers would pay to access and/or
use the ATS; (4) the nature or composition of counter-parties with
which any subscriber or category of subscribers interact; and (5) the
relative speed of access or execution of any subscriber or group of
subscribers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\465\ See BIDS Letter at 3; SIFMA Letter at 30-31.
\466\ See infra note 468 and accompanying text.
\467\ See Liquidnet Letter at 4.
\468\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81028.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters ask that we provide greater clarity with respect to
the types of changes that would be material changes.\469\ One commenter
states that we should provide examples of types of changes that would
not be considered material or would be excluded from being considered
``material'' given the impracticality of the 30-calendar day amendment
period, and states that changes that are not subscriber-facing (e.g.,
changes to software, hardware, or other trading infrastructure) should
not be deemed to be material changes.\470\ This commenter also states
that NMS Stock ATSs should not be required to make a good-faith
decision that a change is not material ``only to be informed that the
Commission has decided the change is material based on an unpublished
standard.'' \471\ Another commenter states that the ``standard'' for
determining material changes is one of the most difficult and
potentially unworkable obligations under the Proposal.\472\ Another
commenter states that the Commission should provide ``clear and
objective standards'' on what triggers the requirement for an NMS Stock
ATS to file a Form ATS-N amendment; this commenter states that if the
Commission staff regards every change as material, then it means
nothing to provide that amendments are required only for material
changes.\473\ In addition, one commenter states that a clearer
``definition'' of what is considered a ``material amendment'' is
critical to NMS Stock ATS broker-dealer operators due to the fact that
NMS Stock ATSs must provide advance notice before implementing a
material change.\474\ Another commenter observes that NMS Stock ATSs
have operations, offerings, and interactions that regularly evolve and
states that it is ``essential'' for NMS Stock ATSs to have ``clear and
specific expectations'' on what types of changes would be deemed
material and what level of detail should be included in the
disclosures.\475\ Another commenter states that without descriptive and
informative commentary from the Commission, there will be uncertainty
and disparity as to which changes are actually filed by NMS Stock ATS
operators as material changes, and suggests that the Commission provide
a clear set of standards that would trigger a Form ATS-N
amendment.\476\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\469\ See BIDS Letter at 3-4; Fidelity Letter at 10; UBS Letter
at 3; SIFMA Letter at 31.
\470\ See SIFMA Letter at 31.
\471\ See id.
\472\ See KCG Letter at 5.
\473\ See SIFMA Letter at 30-31.
\474\ See Fidelity Letter at 10.
\475\ See SIFMA Letter at 5.
\476\ See UBS Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that the Proposal's guidance regarding
whether a change is material is appropriate. In addition, we agree with
the comment that a change that falls in one of the categories set forth
in the Proposal, including a change to the manner in which the NMS
Stock ATS displays orders or trading interest, such as the font size in
which orders are displayed,\477\ would not be a material change if
there would not be a substantial likelihood that a reasonable market
participant would consider the change important when evaluating the NMS
Stock ATS as a potential trading venue. We also do not believe that
market participants should be concerned, as suggested by one
commenter,\478\ that the Commission staff may regard ``every change''
as material and thereby render
[[Page 38804]]
meaningless the Commission's materiality guidance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\477\ See Liquidnet Letter at 4.
\478\ See SIFMA Letter at 30-31.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter notes that NMS Stock ATSs may over-file material
amendments to avoid risk, and that over-filing would cost substantial
time and resources for NMS Stock ATSs, as well as burden the Commission
staff that will be processing and reviewing the submissions.\479\
Another commenter expresses concern that the requirements for amending
Form ATS-N would create a reporting regime that is ``overly
voluminous'' and may be less effective for market participants seeking
transparency.\480\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\479\ See BIDS Letter at 3-4.
\480\ See STA Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission does not believe that its materiality standard will
result in overreporting or underreporting of information by an NMS
Stock ATS or create an overly time-consuming and voluminous Form ATS-N
amendment filing process for NMS Stock ATSs or the Commission. The
Commission recognizes that Form ATS-N will require an NMS Stock ATS to
provide more information about its operations and ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates than Form
ATS. The Commission also recognizes that the structure and complexities
of NMS Stock ATS operations have significantly changed since Regulation
ATS was adopted, and believes that these changes require enhanced
disclosures for subscribers to better understand how NMS Stock ATSs
operate. Given the technology advancements and the proclivity for NMS
Stock ATSs to enhance the operations of their ATSs, and the fact that
market participants search for the best trading venue for their orders,
we believe that it is important for an NMS Stock ATS to amend its Form
ATS-N as required to ensure disclosures on Form ATS-N are complete and
comprehensible. Based on the Commission experience with Form ATS
filings, we believe that we have provided reasonable estimates of the
time and resources that NMS Stock ATSs will need to expend to ensure
that disclosures on amended Form ATS-N are accurate, current, and
complete.
With regard to the commenter that asks for more specificity about
the level of detail that amendments to Form ATS-N require,\481\ we have
revised Parts II and III of adopted Form ATS-N to make requests more
explicit and clear about information that would be responsive to form
requirements, and in some questions, we are requiring NMS Stock ATSs to
provide a ``summary'' or a ``list'' of information.\482\ These changes
are designed to provide an NMS Stock ATS with more specificity about
the level of detail that is required by the form and to alleviate the
burden on NMS Stock ATSs. Further, we revised Form ATS-N to remove
certain terms that commenters believe are vague and, in some cases,
reduced the scope of information requested, and revised requests in
adopted Form ATS-N to make more explicit what we meant by these terms.
We believe that the requests in adopted Form ATS-N, as revised from the
Proposal, provide NMS Stock ATSs the appropriate level of specificity
for them to understand the information that is required by the form. In
addition, the Commission will apply the same standard of review for
declaring ineffective a Form ATS-N amendment as it will apply for
declaring ineffective an initial Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\481\ See supra note 475 and accompanying text.
\482\ See Part II, Items 4, 5, 6, and 7 of adopted Form ATS-N;
Part III, Items 2, 3, 5, 6, 11, 13, and 19 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that it may be worth considering an approach
that leverages the Regulation SCI framework of major changes determined
to be material because such an approach would help ensure consistency
between different Commission regulations that impact and govern
ATSs.\483\ We are declining to adopt the commenter's suggestion to
apply the Regulation SCI framework for materiality. Regulation SCI does
not define material systems changes but requires an SCI entity to
establish written criteria for identifying a change to its SCI systems
and the security of indirect SCI systems as material and to report to
the Commission those changes the SCI entity identified as material in
accordance with such criteria.\484\ Additionally, Form ATS-N is a
public reporting form, and we believe the materiality guidance for
material amendments to Form ATS-N is more appropriate than the
Regulation SCI framework because it provides NMS Stock ATSs, market
participants, and the Commission a clearer standard for determining
whether a change would be material in the context of public reporting.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\483\ See UBS Letter at 3.
\484\ See Regulation SCI Adopting Release, supra note 76, 79 FR
at 72341-42.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter states that because consumers of ATS
disclosures vary widely in business models and sophistication, the
Commission should not create ``tiers'' of materiality, and states that
although the Commission has always understood that some ``material''
factors may be more or less important to different market participants,
it should not substitute its priorities and relative rankings of
importance for those of diverse market participants.\485\ We are not
adopting ``tiers'' of materiality or using our own priorities or other
relative ``rankings'' to determine whether a change to an NMS Stock
ATS's operations is material. The materiality of any change is
dependent on the specific facts and circumstances, and we believe that
creating tiers of materiality would add unnecessary complexity and
would be inconsistent with the Commission's approach to materiality in
other contexts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\485\ See HMA Letter at 9-10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) Order Display and Fair Access Amendments
In the Proposal, we stated that if an NMS Stock ATS triggers the
Rule 301(b)(3)(i) order display and execution access volume thresholds
after commencing operations pursuant to an effective Form ATS-N, the
Commission generally would consider this to be a material change to the
operations of the NMS Stock ATS.\486\ We also stated in the Proposal
that if an NMS Stock ATS triggers the Rule 301(b)(5)(i) fair access
volume thresholds after commencing operations pursuant to an effective
Form ATS-N, the Commission would generally consider this to be a
material change to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS.\487\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\486\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at n.500.
\487\ See id. at n.506.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Rule 304(a)(i)(2)(A), an NMS Stock ATS is required to file a
material amendment at least 30 calendar days prior to the date of
implementation of a material change. We continue to believe that it
generally would be a material change to the operations of an NMS Stock
ATS if the ATS were to exceed the order display and execution access
threshold or become subject to the order display and execution access
requirements under Rule 301(b)(3). Likewise, we continue to believe
that it generally would be a material change to the operations of an
NMS Stock ATS if the ATS were to exceed the fair access threshold or
become subject to the order display and execution access requirements
under Rule 301(b)(5). We recognize, however, that an NMS Stock ATS may
not be able to comply with the 30-calendar day advance notice period
for material amendments because the ATS may not be able to foresee when
it will exceed the order display and execution access or fair access
volume thresholds. To provide market participants with information
about when an NMS Stock ATS becomes subject to, or no longer is subject
to, the
[[Page 38805]]
order display and execution access and fair access requirements, while
not placing an undue burden on the NMS Stock ATS, we are adding to Rule
304(a)(2)(i) new subparagraph (D) to require an NMS Stock ATS to amend
its Form ATS-N no later than seven calendar days after a change to the
information required to be disclosed in Part III, Items 24 and 25 on
Form ATS-N by an NMS Stock ATS (``order display and fair access
amendments'').\488\ We believe that requiring NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose changes to the information required to be disclosed in Part
III, Items 24 and 25 of adopted Form ATS-N no later than seven calendar
days from such changes will provide sufficient time for NMS Stock ATSs
to comply with the requirement, while providing market participants
with timely notice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\488\ Because order display and fair access amendments generally
would be material changes, we are also adding to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) that such amendments must be filed under Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) ``except as provided by'' Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Updating Amendments
We proposed in Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) that an NMS Stock ATS is
required to update its Form ATS-N within 30 calendar days after the end
of each calendar quarter to correct any other information that has
become inaccurate for any reason and has not been previously reported
to the Commission as a Form ATS-N amendment.
We are amending Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) to expand the circumstances
under which ``updating amendments'' \489\ would be filed. As proposed,
NMS Stock ATSs would have been required to file updating amendments to
correct information that has become ``inaccurate.'' \490\ We are
amending Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) also to require that NMS Stock ATSs file
updating amendments to correct information that has become
``incomplete.'' Although we received no comments directly on proposed
Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B), one comment on the amendment process in general
expresses the view that an ATS must have the ability to update its
filing to address ambiguities in how its rules would apply to different
scenarios or uses.\491\ The commenter also states that if an ATS
determines that it can ``make its disclosure clearer, add detail, or
improve the organization of the disclosure, the ATS should be
encouraged to do so.'' \492\ We are modifying proposed Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(B) to specify that an NMS Stock ATS will be required to
file an updating amendment to revise disclosures that become
``inaccurate or incomplete.'' Although, as proposed, Rule 304(a)(2)(i)
did not explicitly require an NMS Stock ATS to disclose changes (other
than material changes under Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A)) that would render its
Form ATS-N incomplete, the Commission stated its intent for Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(B) to provide a ``a mechanism for NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose changes to their operations or to update information that does
not constitute a material change.'' \493\ We continue to believe that
it is important that market participants have access to accurate,
current, and complete disclosures on Form ATS-N. Accordingly, the
Commission is requiring that an NMS Stock ATS disclose, no later than
30 calendar days after the end of the calendar quarter, changes that
would render its Form ATS-N inaccurate or incomplete, but would not be
required to be filed as correcting, material, or order display and fair
access amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\489\ In the Proposal, we referred to these amendments as
``periodic amendments.'' See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81029. We
believe that calling these amendments ``updating amendments''
reduces any potential ambiguity regarding the timing and purpose of
these amendments, which is discussed below.
\490\ Proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B).
\491\ See Liquidnet Letter at 7.
\492\ See id.
\493\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81029.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also are revising Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) to provide that an
updating amendment shall be filed ``no later than'' 30 calendar days
after the end of the calendar quarter. This change allows, but does not
require, an NMS Stock ATS to file amendments required by Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(B) earlier than the 30 calendar day window at the end of
each calendar quarter.
In addition, proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) would have required an
NMS Stock ATS to file an amendment to correct ``any other'' information
that has not been previously reported as a Form ATS-N amendment. We
believe that, as proposed, the phrase ``any other'' information could
be vague and therefore, it could have been unclear when it would be
permitted for an NMS Stock ATS to file an updating amendment, as
opposed to a material or correcting amendment. To distinguish between
what information may be filed pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B), rather
than as a material amendment under Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A), correcting
amendment under Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C), or order display and fair access
amendment under Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D), we are making a change to provide
that updating amendments shall be filed to correct information that
``was not required to be reported to the Commission as a Form ATS-N
amendment pursuant to paragraphs 304(a)(2)(i)(A), (C), or (D) of this
section.''
We believe that requiring NMS Stock ATSs to correct information
that has become inaccurate or incomplete for any reason (and was not
required to be reported to the Commission as a material amendment,
correcting, or order display and fair access amendment) no later than
30 calendar days after the end of each calendar quarter would tailor
the reporting burden for filing amendments on NMS Stock ATSs to the
degree of significance of the change in a manner that does not
compromise the Commission's oversight of NMS Stock ATSs or its ability
to protect investors and the public interest. For example, if an NMS
Stock ATS that publishes or otherwise provides to one or more
subscribers or persons aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution
statistics of the NMS Stock ATS that are not otherwise required
disclosures under Rule 605 of Regulation NMS, the NMS Stock ATS could,
depending on the facts and circumstances, disclose changes to such
statistics in a updating amendment no later than 30 calendar days after
the end of the calendar quarter in which the changes occurred.\494\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\494\ See Proposal, supra note 2 at 81084 (stating that to
comply with the requirements of Part IV, Item 16 (adopted Part III,
Item 26), an NMS Stock ATS would file a Form ATS-N amendment within
30 calendar days after the end of each calendar quarter). See also
infra Section V.D.26.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that allowing NMS Stock ATSs to implement
non-material changes immediately would allow NMS Stock ATSs to make
updating changes to their operations and disclosures without delay,
while at the same time provide disclosure about those changes to market
participants and the Commission within an appropriate time frame.
Updating amendments, like all amendments to Form ATS-N, will be subject
to Commission review pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) and could be
declared ineffective if the Commission makes the required findings.
c. Correcting Amendments
We proposed in Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C) to require an NMS Stock ATS to
amend its Form ATS-N promptly to correct information in any previous
disclosure on Form ATS-N after discovery that any information
previously filed on Form ATS-N was inaccurate or incomplete when filed.
We proposed that such amendments will be subject to
[[Page 38806]]
Commission review pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii).\495\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\495\ See Proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received one comment regarding proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C)
that supports allowing an NMS Stock ATS to file a Form ATS-N amendment
to correct information in a previous Form ATS-N disclosure that was
inaccurate or incomplete when filed.\496\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\496\ See Liquidnet Letter at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter is generally concerned about the amount and types
of amendment filings required under the Proposal, and the burden that
filing such amendments could impose on NMS Stock ATSs.\497\ To address
this concern, we are modifying proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C) to require
that NMS Stock ATSs file correcting amendments after discovery that any
information previously filed on Form ATS-N was materially inaccurate or
incomplete when filed.\498\ We believe that it is appropriate to
require NMS Stock ATSs to promptly file an amendment only when the
information previously filed was materially inaccurate or incomplete
because such information is likely to be important to current
subscribers and market participants and could impact their decision to
use the NMS Stock ATS's services. Corrections of immaterial
inaccuracies and completeness can be made by updating amendments. In
determining whether previously filed information is materially
inaccurate or incomplete, an NMS Stock ATS should consider the factors
it would consider in determining whether a change would require a
material amendment.\499\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\497\ See Fidelity Letter at 10.
\498\ In addition, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C) with
technical modifications. The rule text of proposed Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(C) stated that an NMS Stock ATS must amend Form ATS-N
upon discovery that any information ``filed under paragraphs
(a)(1)(i) or (a)(2)(i)(A) or (B)'' was inaccurate or incomplete when
filed. This inadvertently excluded applying the requirement to
inaccurate or incomplete information filed under paragraph
(a)(2)(i)(C). We believe that deleting the cross-references and
simply stating that an NMS Stock ATS must file an amendment when
``any previous disclosure on Form ATS-N'' was materially inaccurate
or incomplete when filed would require that an NMS Stock ATS correct
materially incomplete or inaccurate information on initial Form ATS-
N and any amendment thereto (including any amendment previously
required by Rule 304(a)(2)(C)). We are making this change to correct
this error, and to specify that an NMS Stock ATS would have an
obligation to promptly correct a materially inaccurate or incomplete
disclosure on any initial Form ATS-N or amendment thereto.
Generally, we will consider a correcting amendment to be filed
``promptly,'' if it is filed within five business days after
discovery that any material information previously filed on Form
ATS-N was materially inaccurate or incomplete when filed.
In addition, we are making a technical change by defining the
type of amendment described in Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C) as a
``correcting amendment.''
\499\ See supra Section IV.B.1.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Rule 304(a)(2)(ii): Commission Review Period; Ineffectiveness
Determination
Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) provides the process through which the
Commission would review and declare Form ATS-N amendments to Form ATS-
N. Proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) (``Commission review period;
Ineffectiveness determination'') provided that the Commission will, by
order, if it finds that such action is necessary or appropriate in the
public interest, and is consistent with the protection of investors,
declare ineffective any Form ATS-N amendment filed pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (C) no later than 30 calendar days from filing
with the Commission. The proposed rule also provided that if the
Commission declares a Form ATS-N amendment ineffective, the NMS Stock
ATS shall be prohibited from operating pursuant to the ineffective Form
ATS-N amendment. Under proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(ii), the NMS Stock ATS
could have, however, continued to operate pursuant to a Form ATS-N that
was previously declared effective. In addition, the proposed rule
provided that a Form ATS-N amendment declared ineffective would not
prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form ATS-N
amendment that resolves the disclosure deficiency that resulted in the
declaration of ineffectiveness. We are adopting Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) with
modifications to provide that the Commission will, by order, declare
ineffective any Form ATS-N amendment filed pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) through (D), no later than 30 calendar days from filing
with the Commission, if the Commission finds that such action is
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with
the protection of investors.\500\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\500\ We are also making several other changes to Rule
304(a)(2)(ii): (1) Reordering some of the language of Rule
304(a)(2)(ii) from the proposed rule text; (2) changing the heading
of the paragraph from ``Commission review period'' to ``Commission
review period; Ineffectiveness determination''; (3) revising the
proposed rule text that stated ``If the Commission declares a Form
ATS-N Amendment ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS shall be prohibited
from operating pursuant to the ineffective Form ATS-N'' to simply
state ``A Form ATS-N amendment declared ineffective shall prohibit
the NMS Stock ATS from operating pursuant to the ineffective Form
ATS-N amendment''; (4) deleting references to the defined term
``Form ATS-N Amendment''; (5) stating that a Form ATS-N amendment
declared ineffective ``does'' not (rather than ``would'' not)
prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form ATS-N
amendment; and (6) referring to amendments filed pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A) ``through (D)''.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We stated in the Proposal that the Commission could declare
ineffective a Form ATS-N amendment if one or more disclosures on an
amended Form ATS-N are materially deficient with respect to its
accuracy, currency, completeness, or fair presentation.\501\ We also
stated that it could declare ineffective a Form ATS-N amendment if it
finds that such action is necessary or appropriate in the public
interest, and is consistent with the protection of investors, because
the amendment disclosures reveal that, under a ``red flag'' review, the
activity described would not comply with the federal securities laws or
the rules or regulations thereunder, including Regulation ATS.\502\ We
further stated that like the review of an initial Form ATS-N, the
Commission's review of a Form ATS-N amendment would focus on the
disclosures made on Form ATS-N, and that the Commission would not be
precluded from later determining that an NMS Stock ATS had violated the
federal securities laws or the rules and regulations thereunder.\503\
As discussed above in the context of initial Form ATS-N filings, we are
not performing a review of the merits of the disclosures on Form ATS-N
amendments, such as determining the strengths and weaknesses of the
trading platform or a protocol offered by the NMS Stock ATS. The
Commission also is not making findings regarding whether the means by
which orders will interact on the trading platform are, or are not,
consistent with the Exchange Act, as is the case with respect to
certain SRO rule filings.\504\ As with respect to initial filings of
Form ATS-N, the Commission could declare a Form ATS-N amendment
ineffective if the Commission finds that such action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with the
protection of investors. The Commission notes that this process will be
similar to the review process for initial Form ATS-N. Accordingly, the
examples provided above to illustrate scenarios that would cause the
Commission to declare an initial Form ATS-N ineffective (e.g.,
materially deficient disclosures with respect to completeness or
comprehensibility) would equally apply in the context of a Form ATS-N
amendment filed with the Commission.\505\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\501\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81029.
\502\ See id. at 81030.
\503\ See id.
\504\ See supra note 359 and accompanying text.
\505\ See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38807]]
We received comments regarding the proposed process for reviewing
Form ATS-N amendments. One commenter expresses support for the proposal
not to require the Commission to affirmatively declare material
amendments effective, and states that such a requirement might serve as
an impediment to NMS Stock ATSs seeking to introduce a new
functionality, would unnecessarily burden Commission staff, and would
discourage NMS Stock ATSs from filing changes more than 30 days in
advance of implementation.\506\ This commenter expresses concern that
requiring pre-approval of changes to Form ATS-N would inhibit informal
communication between an NMS Stock ATS and the Commission staff in
cases where an ATS may otherwise be willing to share information with
the Commission staff in advance of filing.\507\ We are not adopting a
rule to declare a Form ATS-N amendment effective. The Commission's
oversight function of NMS Stock ATSs will be preserved because the
Commission will be able to declare ineffective a Form ATS-N if it finds
that such action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest and
consistent with the protection of investors. This process will be
similar to the review process for initial Form ATS-N.\508\ Accordingly,
the examples provided above to illustrate scenarios that would cause
the Commission to declare an initial Form ATS-N ineffective (e.g.,
materially deficient disclosures with respect to completeness or
comprehensibility) would equally apply in the context of a Form ATS-N
amendment filed with the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\506\ See Liquidnet Letter at 5-6.
\507\ See id. at 6.
\508\ See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter does not object to the Commission having the ability
to declare a material amendment ineffective, but hopes the Commission
would identify concerns as soon as practical during the review period
so an NMS Stock ATS could address any issues.\509\ The Commission
intends to engage in dialogue with an NMS Stock ATS regarding its Form
ATS-N amendment disclosures and communicate to the NMS Stock ATS any
concerns so the ATS may amend its disclosures, as appropriate or
necessary to avoid an ineffective declaration. Such dialogue will
benefit market participants by creating more effective disclosures in
Form ATS-N amendments that will help enable them to make more informed
routing decisions. To facilitate this, we are adopting a process for an
NMS Stock ATS to file, during the Commission's review of a material
amendment, a correcting or updating amendment pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(B) through (C) to the material amendment.\510\ This
process is designed to promote transparency and facilitate complete and
comprehensible disclosure. Any updating or correcting amendments to a
material amendment filed during the Commission review period will be
subject to Commission review under Rule 304(a)(2)(ii).\511\ Although a
correcting or updating amendment is not subject to an implementation
delay, Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A) requires that the NMS Stock ATS delay the
implementation of the change subject to the material amendment until 30
calendar days following filing of the material amendment; therefore,
any correcting or updating amendment that amends a material amendment
during the Commission review could not be implemented before the
material amendment that it is amending is effective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\509\ See Liquidnet Letter at 5.
\510\ Although we acknowledged in the Proposal that the
Commission staff would likely engage in discussions with NMS Stock
ATSs during the review period, we did not propose a process for NMS
Stock ATSs to amend a material amendment during the Commission
review period. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81035. The adopted
process is similar to the process we are adopting to allow non-
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to amend initial Form ATS-N during the
Commission review period. See supra Section IV.A.2.
\511\ Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) states that the Commission will, by
order, declare ineffective any Form ATS-N amendment no later than 30
calendar days from filing of such amendment with the Commission. We
will have 30 calendar days to declare any amendment ineffective,
including updating or correcting amendments to material amendments
that are filed during the Commission review period. For example, if
an NMS Stock ATS files an updating or correcting amendment to a
material amendment on calendar day 25 of the Commission review
period of the material amendment, the updating or correcting
amendment could be declared ineffective by the Commission up to 25
calendar days after the Commission review period for the material
amendment expires--until the Commission's 30-calendar day review
period for the updating or correcting amendment has expired.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In contrast, we believe a material change to a Form ATS-N material
amendment could reflect a significant change to the intended operations
of the ATS or the ATS-related activities of its broker-dealer operator,
which would necessitate a full review period. Therefore, we are
modifying Rule 304(a)(a)(2)(ii) to specify that an NMS Stock ATS making
material changes to a filed material amendment during the Commission
review period shall withdraw its filed material amendment and, if the
NMS Stock ATS chooses to pursue the change, must file a new material
amendment pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A).
Another commenter suggests that similar to the current process for
reviewing Form ATS amendments, the Commission should require advanced
notice of material changes, but not impose a review process for
ineffectiveness.\512\ The commenter states that requiring NMS Stock
ATSs to provide advance notice and receive Commission ``approval''
before an NMS Stock ATS can implement a material change could incent an
NMS Stock ATS to err on the side of submitting ``vague'' disclosures,
which are less helpful to market participants, so that it has
``sufficient operational flexibility'' to make future changes, or could
stifle ATS innovation as NMS Stock ATSs may be reluctant to make
changes that would be subject to the ``approval/disapproval'' review
process.\513\ The commenter further states that NMS Stock ATS operators
should be allowed to furnish universal operations and systems material
via a web link, and updates to such materials should not be subject to
advance notice and Commission review because requiring an NMS Stock ATS
to provide advance notice of changes to operations and systems ``would
cause lengthy delays and stifle NMS Stock ATS technical innovation.''
\514\ Another commenter observes that ``approval'' of Form ATS-N
amendments ``would require positive response from the Commission
instead of the current passive approval after a certain period of
time.'' \515\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\512\ See KCG Letter at 5.
\513\ See id.
\514\ See id. at 7-8.
\515\ See PDQ Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are declining to adopt the commenter's suggestion to not review
Form ATS-N amendments for ineffectiveness because the review process
allows the Commission to better fulfill its oversight responsibilities
of NMS Stock ATSs and to help ensure that Form ATS-N amendments contain
disclosures that are complete and comprehensible. We also disagree with
the commenter's view that the Commission review process will
incentivize NMS Stock ATSs to make vague disclosures to allow for
operational flexibility. Rather, we believe that without a process to
declare ineffective a Form ATS-N amendment, an NMS Stock ATS may have
less incentive to provide complete and comprehensible disclosures.
While the review process for Form ATS-N amendments may have some
[[Page 38808]]
impact on innovation by ATSs,\516\ under the rules adopted today and
consistent with proposed Rule 304(a)(2)(ii), the Commission will not be
declaring Form ATS-N amendments ``effective;'' if the 30-calendar day
review period elapses and the Commission has not declared an amendment
ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS may commence operating pursuant to the
Form ATS-N amendment. Further, Form ATS-N amendments will not be
approved by the Commission and the amendment review process, like the
review process for initial Form ATS-N, will not be a merit-based
review, but rather will focus on the completeness and comprehensibility
of the disclosures. We are declining to adopt the commenter's
suggestion to allow an NMS Stock ATS to change its operations and
systems without a review process and by furnishing a web link.\517\ We
believe that it is important that subscribers have advance notice of
material changes and that the Commission has the opportunity to review
material amendments to the Form ATS-N disclosures. If the NMS Stock ATS
makes changes that are not material, the NMS Stock ATS can implement
such changes and report them by way of an updating amendment.\518\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\516\ See infra Section X.C.
\517\ See supra note 514 and accompanying text.
\518\ See Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other commenters express the same concerns with regard to the
review process for Form ATS-N amendments as they did for the review
process for initial Form ATS-N. These comments are addressed
above.\519\ With respect to determining whether to declare an amendment
to Form ATS-N ineffective, the Commission will apply the same standard
of review that will be applied to initial filings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\519\ Several commenters address our proposed review process for
all Form ATS-N filings, rather than specifically addressing the
review of Form ATS-N amendments. See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Rule 304(a)(3): Notice of Cessation
Rule 304(a)(3) provides the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to
provide notice if they plan to cease to operate. Proposed Rule
304(a)(3) (``Notice of cessation'') provided that an NMS Stock ATS
shall notice its cessation of operations on Form ATS-N at least 10
business days before the date the NMS Stock ATS ceases to operate as an
NMS Stock ATS. Proposed Rule 304(a)(3) also provided that a notice of
cessation shall cause the Form ATS-N to become ineffective on the date
designated by the NMS Stock ATS.
We received no comments regarding proposed Rule 304(a)(3). We
believe that 10 business days is a reasonable period within which an
NMS Stock ATS will provide notice that it intends to cease operations
and will give market participants sufficient time to seek alternative
routing destinations for their orders.\520\ We are adopting Rule
304(a)(3) with non-substantive modifications.\521\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\520\ After ceasing operations, the broker-dealer operator of an
NMS Stock ATS will be required to file Form ATS-R within 10 calendar
days as required by Rule 301(b)(9) of Regulation ATS.
\521\ As proposed, Rule 304(a)(3) states that an NMS Stock ATS
shall notice its cessation at least 10 business days ``before'' the
date it ``ceases'' to operate. As adopted, Rule 304(a)(3) states
that an NMS Stock ATS shall notice its cessation at least 10
business days ``prior to the date'' it ``will cease'' to operate. We
believe these changes enhance the readability of the rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Rule 304(a)(4): Suspension, Limitation, or Revocation of the
Exemption From the Definition of Exchange
Paragraph (i) of proposed Rule 304(a)(4) (``Suspension, limitation,
and revocation of the exemption from the definition of exchange'')
provided that the Commission will, by order, if it finds, after notice
and opportunity for hearing, that such action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with the
protection of investors, suspend for a period not exceeding twelve
months, limit, or revoke an NMS Stock ATS's exemption from the
definition of ``exchange'' pursuant to Rule 3a1-1(a)(2). Further,
proposed Rule 304(a)(4)(ii) provided that if an NMS Stock ATS's
exemption is suspended or revoked pursuant to proposed Rule
304(a)(4)(i), the NMS Stock ATS would be prohibited from operating
pursuant to the exemption from the definition of an ``exchange''
pursuant to Rule 3a1-1(a)(2). In addition, proposed Rule 304(a)(4)(i)
provided that if an NMS Stock ATS's exemption is limited pursuant to
proposed Rule 304(a)(4)(i), the NMS Stock ATS shall be prohibited from
operating in a manner otherwise inconsistent with the terms and
conditions of the Commission order. We are adopting Rule 304(a)(4) with
minor modifications.\522\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\522\ We made technical, non-substantive changes from the
proposed rule by: (1) Replacing references to an ``NMS Stock ATS's
exemption'' to ``the exemption for an NMS Stock ATS'' throughout
Rule 304(a)(4); and (2) deleting the reference to ``the definition
of an `exchange' '' in Rule 304(a)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received four comments regarding proposed Rule 304(a)(4).\523\
One commenter supports the Commission's proposal to introduce a
mechanism for the suspension for a period not exceeding 12 months,
limitation, or revocation of the exemption provided under Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) because it believes that there must be a clear mechanism for
removing non-compliant trading venues from ``the exchange-waiver regime
rather than relying on more general enforcement powers.'' \524\ This
commenter asserts that considering whether an NMS Stock ATS has
accurately and timely filed Form ATS-N in determining whether the ATS
qualifies for an exemption ``is necessary to ensure the credibility of
these public disclosure documents and the accountability of the
entities seeking the exemption.'' \525\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\523\ See CFA Institute Letter at 4; Liquidnet Letter at 7-8;
HMA Letter at 5-6; Better Markets Letter at 7.
\524\ See CFA Institute Letter at 4.
\525\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter states that the Commission ``should be
empowered to suspend, limit, or revoke an ATS's exemption from the
definition of an `exchange', irrespective of the assets traded on the
ATS.'' \526\ We have determined to apply the additional conditions to
the Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a) exemption, including Rule 304(a)(4),
only to NMS Stock ATSs \527\ and are not adopting Rule 304(a)(4) to
apply to non-NMS Stock ATSs at this time. We will consider the comment
if we propose in the future to apply Rule 304, including Rule
304(a)(4), to non-NMS Stock ATSs. We intend to monitor the
implementation of Rule 304 to NMS Stock ATSs, and should we decide to
take further action with applying Rule 304, including Rule 304(a)(4),
to non-NMS Stock ATSs, we would do so in a separate rulemaking and take
into account our experience with Rule 304 and NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\526\ See HMA Letter at 5.
\527\ See supra Section III.A.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter is concerned that the process to suspend, limit, or
revoke an NMS Stock ATS's exemption provided under Rule 3a1-1(a)(2)
could result in a sanction (such as suspension or revocation of its
exemption) that is ``disproportionate to the alleged violation,'' and
asks the Commission to reconsider such requirement.\528\ The Rule
304(a)(4) process for the suspension, limitation, or revocation of the
Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption is designed in part to help prevent failure
by an NMS Stock ATS to adhere to the conditions for the exemption. The
conditions of the Rule 3a1-1(a) exemption are designed to, among other
things, protect investors.\529\ We believe
[[Page 38809]]
that it is important to provide a process tailored to the regulatory
structure for NMS Stock ATSs for the Commission to use in the event an
NMS Stock ATS does not meet the conditions of the exemption as investor
protections may be at risk. As proposed, prior to issuing an order
suspending, limiting, or revoking an NMS Stock ATS's exemption pursuant
to Rule 304(a)(4)(i), the Commission would provide notice and
opportunity for hearing to the NMS Stock ATS, and make the findings
specified in Rule 304(a)(4)(i), that, in the Commission's opinion, the
suspension, limitation, or revocation is necessary or appropriate in
the public interest, and is consistent with the protection of
investors. We believe that this process will provide an NMS Stock ATS
with adequate opportunity to respond before Commission action, and will
provide the Commission with an appropriate tool, subject to notice and
hearing safeguards, to protect the public from an NMS Stock ATS that
fails to comply with Regulation ATS or otherwise violates any provision
of the federal securities laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\528\ See Liquidnet Letter at 7-8.
\529\ In the Regulation ATS Adopting Release, we stated our
belief that the enhanced regulation of alternative trading systems
that choose to remain registered broker-dealers under Regulation ATS
provides more protection for the investors who use these systems.
See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70857.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The exemption from the definition of ``exchange'' provided under
Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) is conditional upon initial and ongoing compliance
with Regulation ATS. As a result of this rulemaking, the conditions of
the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption are being expanded for NMS Stock ATSs.
An ATS that fails to comply with those conditions would fall outside
the scope of the exemption. We believe that it is appropriate to
provide a process by which the Commission may, by order, suspend,
limit, or revoke an NMS Stock ATS's exemption provided under Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) if the NMS Stock ATS is operating or has operated in a manner
such that the exemption for the NMS Stock ATS is not necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, or is inconsistent with the
protection of investors,\530\ and are adopting Rule 304(a)(4)
substantially as proposed.\531\ We believe that a determination as to
whether to suspend, limit, or revoke an NMS Stock ATS's exemption would
depend on the particular facts and circumstances; however, we believe
that revocation of the exemption would be appropriate upon the
existence of a problem involving the ATS that significantly impacts the
public interest and the protection of investors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\530\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81032.
\531\ See supra note 522 and accompanying text. In the Proposal,
we provided examples of when it would be appropriate to provide for
the suspension, limitation, or revocation of an NMS Stock ATS's
exemption pursuant to Rule 3a1-1(a)(2). See Proposal, supra note 2
at 81032.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to Rule 304(a)(4)(ii), an NMS Stock ATS whose exemption
has been suspended or revoked would be prohibited from operating
pursuant to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption; if an NMS Stock ATS were to
continue to engage in Rule 3b-16 activity in NMS stocks without the
exemption, it would be operating as an unregistered national securities
exchange because it would no longer qualify for the exemption.\532\ If
an NMS Stock ATS's exemption were limited pursuant to Rule
304(a)(4)(i), the NMS Stock ATS would be prohibited from operating in a
manner otherwise inconsistent with the terms and conditions of the
Commission order, and if it operated in a manner inconsistent with the
terms and conditions of the order, it would risk operating as an
unregistered national securities exchange. The exemption provided under
Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) is conditional upon initial and ongoing compliance
with Regulation ATS. We believe that the process for suspending,
limiting, or revoking an NMS Stock ATS's exemption, if necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with the protection
of investors, will protect investors in the event of non-compliance by
an NMS Stock ATS with the conditions with which the NMS Stock ATS must
adhere to continue to qualify for the exemption.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\532\ If the Commission revoked or suspended the exemption of an
NMS Stock ATS, the Commission could provide in its order a period of
time for the NMS Stock ATS to wind down its operations. Because
Commission orders revoking or suspending the exemption would be made
public, market participants would also have notice of any wind down
period. Additionally, if the Commission revoked the exemption of an
NMS Stock ATS and the entity wished to continue operations, the
entity could do so only if it were registered as a national
securities exchange pursuant to Section 6 of the Exchange Act or
were exempted by the Commission from such registration based on the
limited volume of transactions effected on such exchange, or seeks
another exemption. See 17 CFR 242.301(a)(1)-(2). The entity would
not be prohibited from filing a new Form ATS-N, pursuant to Rule
304(a)(1)(i). An NMS Stock ATS that has had its exemption suspended
or limited may, depending on the facts and circumstances, be able to
file a Form ATS-N amendment or revise its operations to come into
compliance with the conditions of the exemption or the provision of
any other federal securities law that may have been the basis of the
Commission's findings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also continue to believe that providing a process by which the
Commission can determine to suspend, limit, or revoke an NMS Stock
ATS's exemption will provide appropriate flexibility to address the
specific facts and circumstances of an NMS Stock ATS's failure to
comply with Regulation ATS.\533\ This process will also allow the
Commission to consider the nature of the violation of federal
securities laws and the potential harm to investors as a result of the
non-compliance or violation. The process for the Commission to limit
the exemption in Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) will allow flexibility to address
specific disclosures or activities that are the cause of the non-
compliance with Regulation ATS or that violate federal securities
laws.\534\ We believe that, depending on the facts and circumstances,
it may be more appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with
the protection of investors, to limit the scope of an NMS Stock ATS's
exemption, instead of revoking or suspending the exemption and causing
the NMS Stock ATS to cease operating as an ATS.\535\ By comparison, we
believe it would be more appropriate to revoke the exemption of an NMS
Stock ATS that no longer meets the definition of NMS Stock ATS or is no
longer a registered broker-dealer, as these conditions are fundamental
to the exemption.\536\ Additionally, we believe that it could be
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with
the protection of investors, to revoke the exemption of an NMS Stock
ATS if, for example, the NMS Stock ATS appears to be violating, or to
have violated, the antifraud provisions of the federal securities
laws.\537\ Nonetheless, the entry of an order revoking an NMS Stock
ATS's exemption would not prohibit the broker-dealer operator of the
NMS Stock ATS from continuing its other broker-dealer operations.\538\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\533\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81033.
\534\ See id. If the Commission finds that an NMS Stock ATS
implemented a material change to its operations, but failed to
disclose the material change on its Form ATS-N, the Commission could
determine to allow the ATS to continue to operate as disclosed on
its Form ATS-N, but prohibit the ATS from engaging in the
undisclosed activity until the ATS properly amends its Form ATS-N in
accordance with Rule 304(a)(2). Or, if the Commission finds that an
NMS Stock ATS offers an order type that resulted in violations of
the Commission's rules restricting the acceptance and ranking of
orders in impermissible sub-penny increments, the Commission could
allow the ATS to continue to operate but prohibit the ATS from
offering the order type, if it finds that doing so is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with the
protection of investors.
\535\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81033.
\536\ See id.
\537\ See id.
\538\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter requests clarification regarding the process for
revoking, suspending, or limiting an NMS Stock ATS's exemption. The
commenter asks the Commission to clarify how an ATS could reestablish
its exemption provided under Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) after it has been
revoked. This commenter also questions whether there
[[Page 38810]]
will be penalties for non-compliance or whether the Commission's
deliberations on the re-submitted Form ATS-N would in any way differ
from those on initial Form ATS-N.\539\ An NMS Stock ATS whose exemption
has been revoked cannot operate pursuant to the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2)
exemption, and if such entity were to continue to engage in Rule 3b-16
activity, it could be determined to be an unregistered national
securities exchange in violation of Section 5 of the Exchange Act.\540\
To operate as an NMS Stock ATS after revocation, the entity would need
to file a new initial Form ATS-N with the Commission. The Commission
would review the Form ATS-N without prejudice and would not apply a
different standard than it would to any other entity filing Form ATS-N
pursuant to Rule 304(a)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\539\ See CFA Institute Letter at 5.
\540\ See infra note 532 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter also requests clarification regarding the procedure
that the Commission will follow for an NMS Stock ATS that has had its
exemption suspended for the maximum 12 months.\541\ Upon the expiration
of the suspension period, an NMS Stock ATS could operate pursuant to
its initial Form ATS-N, as long as its exemption is not otherwise
limited or revoked and the NMS Stock ATS is otherwise in compliance
with Rule 304. The suspension period is not to exceed 12 months, and
the Commission could order a suspension period of less than 12 months.
During the suspension period, the Commission could reevaluate the
status of the NMS Stock ATS's exemption and determine, pursuant to Rule
304(a)(4), to revoke or limit the Rule 3a1-1(a) exemption if the
Commission finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that such
action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is
consistent with the protection of investors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\541\ See CFA Institute Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An additional commenter questions what action the Commission would
take in the event that there are ``ambiguous, seemingly incomplete, or
otherwise questionable disclosures that do not rise to the level of
material deficiency,'' and suggests that the Commission apply
``intermediate'' sanctions, such as monetary fines and the temporary
suspension of the right to operate as an NMS Stock ATS without notice
or hearing.\542\ The purpose of Rule 304(a)(4) is to prohibit the NMS
Stock ATSs from operating in a manner inconsistent with the Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) exemption, which we believe is necessary or appropriate in the
public interest and consistent with the protection of investors. We do
not believe it is appropriate to impose monetary fines or temporarily
suspend an NMS Stock ATS's exemption without such due process, as
suggested by the commenter. Any suspension, limitation, or revocation
of an NMS Stock ATS's exemption provided by Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) would not
preclude the Commission from using its enforcement authority if the NMS
Stock ATS fails to comply with the federal securities laws.\543\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\542\ See Better Markets Letter at 7.
\543\ See generally Exchange Act Section 21C. The use of the
process whereby the Commission could suspend, limit, or revoke an
NMS Stock ATS's Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption would not preclude the
Commission from using its enforcement authority, such as, for
example, pursuant to Sections 10(b), 15(b)(4), and 15(c) (15 U.S.C.
78(j)(b), 15 U.S.C. 78o(b)(4); 15 U.S.C. 78o(c)). Rather, it would
provide an additional means of helping to ensure that NMS Stock ATSs
that no longer qualify for the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) exemption are unable
to take advantage of the exemption. For example, if an NMS Stock ATS
failed to file a Form ATS-N amendment to disclose material changes
to the operation of the ATS, the Commission could invoke the process
to suspend, limit, or revoke the ATS's exemption, but would not be
precluded from bringing an action against the broker-dealer operator
of the ATS for failing to comply with Rule 304(a)(2), or violating
the antifraud provisions of the federal securities laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
E. Rule 304(b): Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N and Related Commission
Orders
1. Rule 304(b)(1): Form ATS-N ``Report''
Rule 304(b)(1) provides that every Form ATS-N would constitute a
report under the Exchange Act. Paragraph (1) of proposed Rule 304(b)
(``Public disclosures'') provided that every Form ATS-N filed pursuant
to Rule 304 shall constitute a ``report'' within the meaning of
Sections 11A, 17(a), 18(a), and 32(a) and any other applicable
provisions of the Exchange Act. Because proposed Form ATS-N is a report
that is required to be filed under the Exchange Act, it would be
unlawful for any person to willfully or knowingly make, or cause to be
made, a false or misleading statement with respect to any material fact
in Form ATS-N. Proposed Rule 304(b)(1) is nearly identical to current
Rule 301(b)(2)(vi),\544\ which provides that every notice or amendment
filed pursuant to Rule 301(b)(2), including Form ATS, shall constitute
a ``report'' within the meaning of Sections 11A, 17(a), 18(a), and
32(a), and any other applicable provisions of the Exchange Act.\545\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\544\ See 17 CFR 301(b)(2)(vi).
\545\ 15 U.S.C. 78k-1, 78q(a), 78r(a), and 78ff(a). See 17 CFR
242.301(b)(2)(vi). Section 17(a) of the Exchange Act imposes
recordkeeping requirements on national securities exchanges and
registered securities associations; Section 18(a) of the Exchange
Act imposes liability for false or misleading statements with
respect to a material fact in applications, reports, or documents
filed pursuant to the Exchange Act or any rule or regulation
thereunder; and Section 32(a) of the Exchange Act provides for
penalties against any person that willfully violates any provision
of, or that willfully and knowingly makes, or causes to be made, any
false or misleading statements with respect to a material fact in
any application, report, or document required to be filed under the
Exchange Act or any rule or regulation thereunder.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received two comments on proposed Rule 304(b)(1).\546\ One
commenter supports that Form ATS-N shall constitute a ``report'' within
the meaning of applicable provisions of the Exchange Act.\547\ The
other commenter expresses concern regarding the potential liability and
consequences of the provision that Form ATS-N would constitute a
``report'' within the meaning of Sections 11A, 17(a), 18(a), and 32(a)
of the Exchange Act in light of the increased disclosure requirements
under Form ATS-N.\548\ This commenter states that although this same
standard applies to current Form ATS, the potential for an NMS Stock
ATS to unknowingly but willfully file a statement that turns out to be
false is heightened by the increased amount and scope of disclosure
contemplated under Form ATS-N.\549\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\546\ See Better Markets Letter at 7; SIFMA Letter at 33.
\547\ See Better Markets Letter at 7.
\548\ See SIFMA Letter at 33.
\549\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe that the fact that Form ATS-N requires more
detailed disclosures than Form ATS would justify reducing the potential
liability for false or misleading statements made in Form ATS-N
disclosures. The information required on Form ATS-N is designed to
provide the public with transparency into an NMS Stock ATS's operations
and the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates. Although the commenter does not directly object to Rule
304(b)(1), the commenter argues that the Commission should narrow the
scope of disclosures and standardize the Form ATS-N format in light of
the potential liability this presents.\550\ In response to the
comments, we have modified certain requests on Form ATS-N to remove
language that some commenters believe is vague, and in many cases,
changed questions to solicit more general information.\551\ Further,
given that Form ATS-N will be made public, we expect that market
participants will rely on these disclosures when making routing
[[Page 38811]]
decisions or assessing their brokers' routing practices, so it is
critical that the disclosures constitute a ``report'' and are subject
to the applicable consequences. We also believe that making Form ATS-N
disclosures subject to liability as a ``report'' under the Exchange Act
further will incentivize NMS Stock ATS operators to make truthful
statements on Form ATS-N. We are adopting Rule 304(b)(1) as proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\550\ See id.
\551\ See infra Section V.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Rule 304(b)(2): Making Public Form ATS-N Filings and Commission
Orders.
Rule 304(b)(2) provides which Form ATS-N filings and related orders
the Commission would make public. Proposed Rule 304(b)(2) provided that
we would make public, via posting on the Commission's website, each (1)
order of effectiveness of a Form ATS-N; (2) order of ineffectiveness of
a Form ATS-N; (3) effective Form ATS-N; (4) filed Form ATS-N amendment;
(5) order of ineffectiveness of a Form ATS-N amendment; (6) notice of
cessation; and (7) order suspending, limiting, or revoking the
exemption from the definition of an ``exchange'' pursuant to Exchange
Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2). We are adopting Rule 304(b)(2) with modifications
discussed below.\552\ In addition, as proposed, we specify that we will
make NMS Stock ATS filings public via posting on the Commission's
website.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\552\ To conform to changes that provide that we will not issue
orders of effective initial Form ATS-N, we have eliminated proposed
Rule 304(b)(2)(i) from adopted Rule 304(b)(2). See supra Section
IV.A.1. In addition, the Commission made the following technical,
non-substantive modifications to the proposed text of Rule
304(b)(2): (1) Renumbered proposed Rule 304(b)(2)(ii) through (vii);
(2) reordered proposed Rule 304(b)(2)(iii) so that ``Effective Form
ATS-N'' is adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(i); (3) changed the proposed
language stating that the Commission ``would'' make public the
documents specified in Rule 304(b)(2)(i)-(vii) to the Commission
``will'' make public the documents specified in Rule 304(b)(2)(i)
through (vi); (4) specified that the Commission will publish
``initial'' Form ATS-N, as amended, under adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(i);
(5) changed the proposed language that the Commission will make
public each ``Order of ineffectiveness of a Form ATS-N'' to ``Order
of ineffective initial Form ATS-N''; (6) changed references to
uppercase ``Amendment'' in adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(iii) and (iv) to
lowercase; (7) changed the language in adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(iv)
from describing an ``Order of ineffectiveness of a'' Form ATS-N
amendment to a ``Order of ineffective'' Form ATS-N amendment; and
(8) modified language in the rule to state that the order
suspending, limiting, or revoking the exemption in adopted Rule
304(b)(2)(vi) will apply to the exemption for an ``NMS Stock ATS.''
We are adopting these changes to simplify and improve the clarity of
the rule text and we do not believe that these changes impact the
operation of the proposed rules. Because we are providing a process
for NMS Stock ATSs to amend their initial Forms ATS-N during the
Commission review period, we are also revising proposed Rule
304(b)(2)(iii) (renumbered as Rule 304(b)(2)(i)) to state that the
Commission will publish initial Form ATS-N, ``as amended,'' to
specify that the initial Form ATS-N will reflect amendments made
during the Commission review period. See supra Section IV.A.2 and
Section IV.A.4.b. In addition, in response to comments, we are
adopting a modified requirement that for material amendments, the
cover page of the material amendment will be made public upon filing
and the entirety of the material amendment, as amended, will be made
public upon the expiration of the Commission review period. See
infra Section IV.E.2.c. We are also adding to Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(B)
that the Commission will make public each updating or correcting
amendment filed to a material amendment following the expiration of
the review period for the material amendment pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(ii). See id. We are also adopting Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(B)
to provide that the Commission will make the entirety of order
display and fair access amendments, as well as updating amendments
and correcting amendments, public upon filing. See id. We are also
adopting Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A) to specify that the Commission will
not make public the entirety of a material amendment that it
declares ineffective. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, many commenters support making Form ATS-N
public, observing that market participants do not currently have access
to sufficient, standardized information about the operations and
ownership of NMS Stock ATSs.\553\ Nearly all commenters agree with the
Commission's stated goal of enhancing transparency.\554\ Although many
commenters express general support for public disclosure of Form ATS-N,
many commenters recommend certain modifications or clarifications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\553\ See supra note 93 and accompanying text.
\554\ See supra note 108.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that making Form ATS-N filings publicly
available is important because most market participants have limited
access to information that permits them to adequately compare and
contrast how an NMS Stock ATS would handle its orders with how a
national securities exchange or other NMS Stock ATS would handle its
orders.\555\ Currently, a Form ATS filed with the Commission by an ATS
that trades NMS stocks is ``deemed confidential when filed'' under Rule
301(b)(2)(vii) of Regulation ATS,\556\ whereas a national securities
exchange is required to both (1) make available to the public its
entire rulebook and (2) publicly file all proposed rule changes
pursuant to Section 19(b) of the Exchange Act.\557\ The only
information the Commission currently makes publicly available regarding
ATSs is a list of the names and locations of ATSs with a Form ATS on
file with the Commission, which is updated monthly.\558\ Unless an NMS
Stock ATS voluntarily publicizes how its functionalities operate,
market participants have limited information to adequately compare and
contrast the operation of the ATS with that of a national securities
exchange or another NMS Stock ATS. And when NMS Stock ATSs voluntarily
make their Forms ATS-N public, the lack of uniformity or
standardization makes it difficult to compare disclosures across ATSs.
Currently, approximately 20 NMS Stock ATSs voluntarily post a Form ATS
on their website. Some commenters, however, observe that in the absence
of mandatory and uniform disclosure requirements, Forms ATS vary in
content and the level of detail disclosed, and are therefore difficult
to compare.\559\ Accordingly, through Form ATS-N, we are adopting
disclosures that will provide information that market participants can
use to perform these comparisons as they evaluate the ATS as a
potential destination for their orders.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\555\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81035.
\556\ See 17 CFR 240.301(b)(2)(vii).
\557\ See 15 U.S.C. 78s(b).
\558\ See Alternative Trading System (``ATS'') List, http://www.sec.gov/foia/docs/atslist.htm.
\559\ See, e.g., Consumer Federation of America Letter at 3; HMA
Letter at 2; Morgan Stanley Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Rule 304(b)(2), with the modifications to address
commenters' concerns, to mandate greater public disclosure of NMS Stock
ATS operations through the publication of Form ATS-N. Adopted Rule
304(b)(2) provides that the Commission will make Form ATS-N and related
filings available via posting on the Commission's website. NMS Stock
ATS broker-dealer operators will submit Form ATS-N filings via EDGAR,
and the Commission will make such filings available on its website.
a. Public Disclosure of Effective Initial Form ATS-N, As Amended
Several commenters express support for proposed Rule
304(b)(2)(iii), which would make public an effective Form ATS-N.\560\
Four commenters agree with the Commission's approach of making initial
Forms ATS-N publicly available once the Commission declared such forms
effective.\561\ One commenter asserts that publishing a filing that is
not yet effective, and may ultimately not be ``approved,'' will cause
confusion among market participants regarding the manner of operation
of the NMS Stock ATS.\562\ Another commenter states that requiring
disclosure of Forms ATS-N that the Commission has declared ineffective
``may place undue suspicion from market participants on ATSs that fail
to gain exemption status on the first
[[Page 38812]]
attempt.'' \563\ The Commission will make only effective Forms ATS-N
public because this would be less confusing for market participants. We
expect that in the course of reviewing an initial Form ATS-N,
Commission staff would likely engage in discussions with the entity
regarding its disclosures and could request the entity to revise or
augment its disclosures to cure deficiencies and provide market
participants with greater clarity regarding the entity's operations.
Accordingly, we continue to believe that it would be premature to make
publicly available an initial Form ATS-N filing before it becomes
effective because of the potential confusion that may result from
making public disclosures on an initial Form ATS-N that is not
effective. Therefore, under adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(i), the Commission
will make public an effective initial Form ATS-N, as amended.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\560\ See supra notes 110-123 and accompanying text.
\561\ See CFA Institute Letter at 6; BIDS Letter at 3; UBS
Letter at 3; LeveL ATS Letter at 7.
\562\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 7.
\563\ See CFA Institute Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(ii)(B) and Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) provide
processes for NMS Stock ATSs to amend their initial Forms ATS-N during
the Commission review period. If, for example, the Commission staff
provides comments to a broker-dealer operator suggesting modifications
designed to enhance the completeness and comprehensibility of its
initial Form ATS-N disclosures, the NMS Stock ATS would have the
opportunity to file an amendment to respond to such comments during the
Commission review period. We believe that it is appropriate to make
public initial Form ATS-N, as revised by any such amendments (except
for material amendments during the Commission review period),\564\ when
the initial Form ATS-N becomes effective. Accordingly, we are revising
proposed Rule 304(b)(2)(iii) (renumbered as Rule 304(b)(2)(i)) to state
that the Commission will publish initial Form ATS-N, ``as amended.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\564\ Material amendments filed by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs during
the Commission review period are subject to Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A),
which provides that the entirety of a material amendment will not be
made public until the expiration of the Commission's 30-calendar day
review period. Therefore, under Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A), material
amendments filed during the final 30 calendar days of the Commission
review period would not be made public until the 30-calendar day
Commission review period for such amendments has expired. For
example, if an NMS Stock ATS files a material amendment on calendar
day 230 of the Commission review period, and the Form ATS-N becomes
effective on calendar day 240, the material amendment would remain
subject to the Commission's review, and not publicly disclosed, for
an additional 20 calendar days--until the Commission's 30-calendar
day review period has expired. Under Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A), the
cover page for any material amendments during the Commission review
would be made public when the initial Form ATS-N becomes effective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters express concerns regarding the timing of publicly
disclosing a filed Form ATS-N.\565\ One commenter states its view that
for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs that are filing Form ATS-N for the first
time, the Commission should not make any Forms ATS-N public until the
date on which the Commission has completed the review of the initial
Form ATS-N filings for all Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, so that a Legacy NMS
Stock ATS is not disadvantaged by making its Form ATS-N public prior to
other Legacy NMS Stock ATSs.\566\ As we stated in the Proposal, and as
many commenters have agreed,\567\ the public has a strong interest in
public disclosure about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs. For some
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, the review period may be extended pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B). We believe that disclosure of all Legacy NMS
Stock ATSs' Forms ATS-N should not be delayed during any extended
review period that may be necessary for the Commission to review any
Legacy NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N that raises novel or complex
issues and therefore requires additional time for review.\568\
Additionally, some NMS Stock ATSs may not wish to delay public
disclosure once their Forms ATS-N become effective, and it is neither
in the public interest nor in the interest of those NMS Stock ATSs to
withhold effective Forms ATS-N from the public.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\565\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3; SSGA Letter at 2; Fidelity
Letter at 7-8; STANY Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 6-8; Luminex Letter
at 2,4; PDQ Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 4.
\566\ See Liquidnet Letter at 3.
\567\ See, e.g., MFA/AIMA Letter at 2; Schneiderman Letter at 2;
ICI Letter at 1; CFA Institute Letter at 3; Consumer Federation of
America Letter at 6.
\568\ See Rule 304(a)(1)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters suggest that the Commission should make certain
information required by Form ATS-N available only to the
Commission.\569\ Some commenters state that the scope of items required
for public disclosure, particularly those related to the administration
of the ATS, is too detailed and may not be helpful to market
participants in making routing decisions.\570\ We believe that Form
ATS-N, as adopted, solicits the appropriate level of information about
NMS Stock ATSs that would be useful to subscribers and market
participants.\571\ In response to commenters, we have revised proposed
Form ATS-N to remove certain requests that commenters believe are not
relevant to subscribers, limited the scope of certain requests that
commenters believe to be too broad, and narrowed certain requests to
only require summary information or specific information to avoid the
disclosure of commercially sensitive information.\572\ We nevertheless
believe that responses to Form ATS-N requests must be sufficiently
detailed for subscribers and market participants to adequately
understand the operations of an NMS Stock ATS and the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\569\ See SSGA Letter at 2; Fidelity Letter at 7-8; STANY Letter
at 3; UBS Letter at 6-8; Luminex Letter at 2,4; PDQ Letter at 2;
SIFMA Letter at 4.
\570\ See Luminex Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 4; KCG Letter at
6.
\571\ See infra Section V.
\572\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other commenters express concern that publicly disclosing Form ATS-
N could result in the disclosure of an NMS Stock ATS's proprietary or
commercially sensitive information.\573\ In particular, and as
discussed further below, commenters express concern about disclosing
information regarding classification of subscribers,\574\ details about
administrative operations of broker-dealer operators,\575\ and
contractual agreements between broker-dealer operators and their
clients,\576\ and NMS Stock ATSs and their vendors.\577\ One commenter
raises concern about customer confidentiality.\578\ We have determined
not to adopt the proposed Exhibit 1 requirements \579\ and have revised
the Form ATS-N requests to not seek disclosure of certain information
that could be proprietary or commercially sensitive, such as routing
tables or numerical order flow segmentation metrics.\580\ We do not
believe that the vast majority of information responsive to adopted
Form ATS-N would be proprietary or commercially sensitive. Furthermore,
we do not believe that the requests of adopted Form ATS-N, as modified,
would require NMS Stock
[[Page 38813]]
ATSs to compromise customer confidentiality when making thorough and
accurate disclosures.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\573\ See Fidelity Letter at 8; UBS Letter at 7; Luminex Letter
at 2-4; SIFMA Letter at 16.
\574\ See Fidelity Letter at 8; UBS Letter at 7.
\575\ See Fidelity Letter at 4; Luminex Letter at 2-4.
\576\ See UBS Letter at 7.
\577\ See SIFMA Letter at 16.
\578\ See PDQ Letter at 2.
\579\ See infra Section V.B.2. Exhibit 1 would have required NMS
Stock ATSs to attach a copy of any materials currently provided to
subscribers or other persons related to the operations of the NMS
Stock ATS or the disclosures on Form ATS-N. The determination not to
adopt this proposed requirement renders irrelevant the comment
regarding allowing NMS Stock ATSs to post updated marketing
materials on their websites. See infra note 705 and accompanying
text.
\580\ See infra Sections V.D.5, V.D.13, V.D.16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters that believe that Form ATS-N disclosures may be too
detailed to be helpful to market participants \581\ or that they may
disclose proprietary or commercially sensitive information suggest that
the Commission make only parts of Form ATS-N public, or delay public
disclosure of certain parts of Form ATS-N.\582\ Specifically, one
commenter suggests that the Commission require NMS Stock ATSs to submit
a full Form ATS-N to the Commission, but only provide that a selected
sub-set of fields be publicly disclosed.\583\ We are not adopting the
commenters' suggestions to limit public disclosures because the vast
majority of adopted Form ATS-N will not require the disclosure of
proprietary or commercially sensitive information.\584\ In addition,
not making certain items public would undercut the transparency that is
the primary purpose of this rulemaking.\585\ Another commenter suggests
that the Commission should consider ``tiering'' proprietary information
by first making it only available to the Commission and subscribers,
and after a ``reasonable'' time lag, further disseminating such
information to the general public.\586\ In response to commenter
concerns, the cover page of the filed material amendment will be made
public by the Commission upon filing and, unless the Commission
declares the material amendment ineffective, the entirety of the
material amendment, as amended, will be made public by the Commission
following the Commission's 30-calendar day review period.\587\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\581\ See SSGA Letter at 2.
\582\ See T. Rowe Price Letter at 2.
\583\ See SSGA Letter at 2.
\584\ See infra Sections V.C.6, V.D.6, V.D.13, V.D.23.
\585\ One commenter believes that an ATS should have the ability
to file supplemental materials with the Commission that are not part
of the public filing as long as the ATS's public filing accurately
responds to all questions on the Form ATS-N. See Liquidnet Letter at
9. We have determined not to adopt a formal process through which
broker-dealer operators can disclose supplemental information for
Commission review alone. We believe that the primary purpose of Form
ATS-N is to provide the public with critical information regarding
NMS Stock ATS operations and affiliate relationships.
\586\ See T. Rowe Price Letter at 2.
\587\ See Section IV.E.2.c.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that, although the Commission should not
address commenters' concerns regarding disclosure of sensitive or
proprietary information,\588\ by automatically making any portion of
Form ATS-N confidential, if a ``genuine need for confidentiality
exists,'' the broker-dealer can obtain confidential treatment under
Commission Rule 24b-2, and suggests that the Commission provide
guidance around the use of this limited exception.\589\ We believe that
questions on adopted Form ATS-N, as modified, do not solicit the type
of information that typically would constitute confidential
information.\590\ The existing processes for obtaining confidential
treatment will remain available to broker-dealer operators.\591\
Furthermore, the purpose of Form ATS-N is to create a public
transparency regime for NMS Stock ATSs, with commensurate benefits, and
allowing disclosures to be made only to the Commission would be
contrary to the purposes of this rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\588\ See supra notes 574-578 and accompanying text.
\589\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 10-11.
\590\ See supra note 584 and accompanying text.
\591\ See 17 CFR. 240.24b-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, FINRA requests that the Commission require NMS Stock
ATSs to file duplicate copies of Form ATS-N submissions with FINRA so
that FINRA has access to these filings before they become effective, or
in the event that they are deemed ineffective and thus never made
public.\592\ Requiring an NMS Stock ATS to provide Form ATS-N filings
to the SRO of which the ATS is a member before the filings become
effective or are declared ineffective would place additional
administrative burdens on the NMS Stock ATS, particularly in the event
the NMS Stock ATS amends its Form ATS-N during discussion with the
Commission staff. We continue to believe that making Form ATS-N public
will enhance the information available to market participants and
benefit the marketplace, and therefore are adopting Rule 304(b)(2)(i),
to provide that the Commission will make public each effective initial
Form ATS-N, as amended.\593\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\592\ See FINRA Letter at 2-3.
\593\ See supra note 552.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Public Disclosure of Orders of an Ineffective Initial Form ATS-N
Because the Commission will not issue orders of effective initial
Forms ATS-N, adopted Rule 304(b)(2) does not include each ``Order of
effectiveness of a Form ATS-N.'' We continue to believe that it is
appropriate to make public each order of ineffective Form ATS-N,
substantially as proposed,\594\ to provide the public with notice
regarding the regulatory status of potential trading venues; if a Form
ATS-N is declared ineffective, the ATS may not operate pursuant to the
exemption from the definition of ``exchange,'' and the public should be
aware of such regulatory status.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\594\ We proposed this requirement as Rule 304(b)(2)(i) and are
adopting this requirement as Rule 304(b)(2)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other than the comment about orders of ineffectiveness relating to
a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N, which is discussed
above,\595\ we received no comments on making public orders of
effective or ineffective Form ATS-N. We continue to believe that it is
necessary to make public an order of ineffective Form ATS-N for market
participants to be informed of the operating status of an NMS Stock
ATS. Therefore, we are adopting Rule 304(a)(2)(ii) to provide that
orders of ineffective initial Form ATS-N will be made public, with
modifications to reduce any potential ambiguity and improve readability
of the rule text.\596\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\595\ See supra note 433 and accompanying text.
\596\ Adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(ii) states that this provision
applies to each ``[o]rder of ineffective initial Form ATS-N''
instead of the proposed language, which stated that the provision
would apply to each ``[o]rder of ineffectiveness of a Form ATS-N.''
As discussed above, the Commission will, by order, declare
ineffective an initial Form ATS-N if it finds, after notice and
opportunity for hearing, that such action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with the
protection of investors. See supra Section IV.A.3. We believe that
the revised rule text reduces any potential ambiguity by specifying
that the public disclosure requirement applies to orders related to
``initial'' Form ATS-N and simplifying the rule language.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N Amendments
We proposed, in Rule 304(a)(2)(iv), making all filed amendments to
Form ATS-N public; as proposed, Form ATS-N amendments would have been
public during the Commission review period and prior to the
Commission's determination of whether a Form ATS-N amendment should be
declared ineffective.
In the Proposal, we asked whether commenters believe that the
Commission should make public on its website upon filing a Form ATS-N
amendment for a material change, and whether there should be a delay in
when the Form ATS-N for a material change is made public.\597\ We
received several comments on this aspect of the Proposal.\598\ Although
one commenter agrees with our proposal to make Form ATS-N amendments
public upon filing because it would keep market participants informed
about changes to
[[Page 38814]]
potential trading venues,\599\ several other commenters express
concerns about making Form ATS-N amendments public upon filing or argue
that the Commission should make amendments public only once the related
changes are operative.\600\ Some of these commenters state that public
disclosure of changes to ATS operations at least 30 calendar days
before such changes are implemented may burden the ability of NMS Stock
ATSs to act competitively, or may reduce the competitive advantage
associated with being the first to innovate.\601\ In addition,
commenters assert that making public Form ATS-N amendments that may
never be implemented could be confusing or misleading to market
participants; \602\ one commenter states that publicly disclosing
material changes in advance of implementation could cause market
participants to not understand current operations of an NMS Stock ATS
versus its proposed, future operations.\603\ One commenter asserts that
immediate publication of amendments would stifle dialogue between the
NMS Stock ATS and Commission staff.\604\ Another commenter states that
it does not believe that making Form ATS-N amendments public upon
filing would provide a benefit to market participants as ``existing
documents'' should be adequate for market participants considering
whether to use a particular NMS Stock ATS.\605\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\597\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81028.
\598\ See ICI Letter at 3; Liquidnet Letter at 6; SIFMA Letter
at 31; UBS Letter at 3; BIDS Letter at 4; STA Letter at 5; STANY
Letter at 2; CFA Institute Letter at 6; LeveL ATS Letter at 7.
\599\ See ICI Letter at 3, n.3.
\600\ See Liquidnet Letter at 6; SIFMA Letter at 31; UBS Letter
at 3; BIDS Letter at 4; STA Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 2; CFA
Institute Letter at 6; LeveL ATS Letter at 7. Some commenters state
that an amendment to Form ATS-N should not be made public until it
is declared effective. See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 31; UBS Letter at
3. We, however, did not propose, and are not adopting, a process for
declaring amendments to Form ATS-N effective. The Commission will
have a 30-calendar day review period to declare amendments to Form
ATS-N ineffective. See supra Section IV.B.2.
\601\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 7-8. See also SIFMA Letter at 31;
STANY Letter at 2.
\602\ See BIDS Letter at 4; UBS Letter at 3; LeveL ATS Letter at
7.
\603\ See UBS Letter at 3.
\604\ See Liquidnet Letter at 6-7.
\605\ See BIDS Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are modifying the proposed rules for making Form ATS-N
amendments to an effective Form ATS-N public. In response to
commenters' concerns, we are adding new subparagraph (b)(2)(iii)(A) to
Rule 304 to provide that, for material amendments (as defined by Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(A)) to an effective Form ATS-N, the cover page of the
filed material amendment will be made public by the Commission upon
filing and, unless the Commission declares the material amendment
ineffective, the entirety of the material amendment, as amended, will
be made public by the Commission following the Commission's 30-calendar
day review period. In addition, we are adding new subparagraph
(b)(2)(iii)(B) to Rule 304 to provide that, for updating, correcting,
and order display and fair access amendments (as defined by Rule
304(a)(2)(i)(B), (C), and (D), respectively) to an effective Form ATS-
N, the entirety of the updating, correcting, or order display and fair
access amendment will be made public by the Commission upon filing. We
are also adding to subparagraph (b)(2)(iii)(B) that an updating or
correcting amendment filed to a material amendment will be made public
by the Commission following the expiration of the review period for
such material amendment pursuant to paragraph (a)(2)(ii) of Rule 304.
We share the commenters' concerns that making public Form ATS-N
material amendments before expiration of the Commission's 30-day
calendar review period could be confusing or misleading to the public,
particularly in the event the material amendment is declared
ineffective and the related change is never implemented. One commenter
asserts that advance disclosure of Form ATS-N amendments may burden
market participants who feel obligated to review premature disclosures
for possible effects on them and their underlying customers.\606\ We
believe that publicly disclosing the cover page to a Form ATS-N
material amendment during the review period, and disclosing the entire
material amendment following the expiration of 30-calendar day
Commission review period, when the related changes can be implemented,
will reduce any potential for confusion and will not pose an undue
burden on market participants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\606\ See SIFMA Letter at 32.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we share the commenters' concerns that providing
advance public notice of material changes to NMS Stock ATSs could
burden ATSs, which would be required to provide at least 30-calendar
day advance notice of material changes to all market participants,
including their competitors. Requiring such advance public notice of
material changes before they are implemented could reduce incentives
for NMS Stock ATSs to innovate.
However, we continue to believe that market participants that are
planning routing strategies would benefit from advance notice that the
NMS Stock ATS is planning changes to its operations or conflicts of
interest. To minimize the potential competitive harm of advance public
notice, while also providing the benefits of immediate public
transparency, the Commission will make public the cover page of a
material amendment to an effective Form ATS-N upon filing of such
amendment. The cover page will indicate that the NMS Stock ATS has
filed a material amendment and provide a brief narrative about the
content of the amendment. An NMS Stock ATS is required to indicate the
part and item number of Form ATS-N that is subject to the change, state
whether or not such change will apply to all subscribers and the
broker-dealer operator, and provide a brief summary of the changes. For
example, if an NMS Stock ATS is introducing a new order type, the brief
narrative might state: ``The ATS is amending Part III, Item 7(a) of
Form ATS-N to include a new order type, which will be available to all
subscribers.''
In addition, we are adding, in new subparagraph (b)(2)(iii)(A) to
Rule 304, that the Commission will, following the expiration of the 30-
calendar day Commission review period pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii),
make public the entirety of the material amendment ``as amended.'' We
are providing a process, under Rule 304(a)(2)(ii), for NMS Stock ATSs
to file updating and correcting amendments under Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B)
and (C), respectively, to material amendments during the Commission
review period. In addition, Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(B) provides that an
updating or correcting amendment filed to a material amendment will be
made public by the Commission following the expiration of the review
period for such material amendment pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii). We
believe that disclosing updating and correcting amendments to material
amendments before expiration of the Commission's 30-day calendar review
period for the material amendment (and before the material amendment is
made public) could be confusing or misleading to the public as the
underlying material amendment would not yet be public or operative. We
will make public material amendments ``as amended;'' material
amendments will reflect any updating and correcting amendments filed
during the Commission review period. Such amended disclosures could
provide market participants with more complete and comprehensible
information about NMS Stock ATS operations and the activities of their
broker-dealer operators and affiliates. Accordingly, Rule
304(b)(2)(iii)(B) provides that an updating or correcting amendment
filed to a material amendment will be made public by the Commission
following the
[[Page 38815]]
expiration of the review period for such material amendment pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(2)(ii), and Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A) provides that a material
amendment will be made public, as amended, which would incorporate any
amendments that were filed to the material amendment during the
Commission review period.
The change to delay making the entirety of Form ATS-N material
amendments, as amended, public until after the Commission has completed
the review will not impact the manner in which we proposed to make
public updating, correcting, and order display and fair access
amendments. Form ATS-N updating amendments require NMS Stock ATSs to,
no later than 30 calendar days after the end of a calendar quarter,
correct information that has become inaccurate or incomplete for any
reason and was not required to be reported to the Commission as a Form
ATS-N amendment pursuant to Rules 304(a)(2)(i)(A), (C), or (D).\607\
NMS Stock ATSs are required to correct information in any previous
disclosure on Form ATS-N through a correcting amendment after discovery
that any material information previously filed on Form ATS-N was
inaccurate or incomplete when filed.\608\ Order display and fair access
amendments are required to be filed no later than seven calendar days
after information required to be disclosed in Part III, Items 24 and 25
on Form ATS-N has become inaccurate or incomplete.\609\ We proposed
that all amendments, which include Form ATS-N updating and correcting
amendments (as well as material amendments), be made public upon
filing. Two commenters assert that publicly disclosing changes that the
Commission could later declare ineffective could create confusion among
market participants.\610\ Although, as adopted, the Commission would
not make the entirety of material amendments public until after its 30-
calendar day review period expires, because correcting, updating, and
order display and fair access amendments would be made public upon
filing, the Commission could declare such an amendment ineffective
after it has been made public. We continue to believe that, even with
the risk of some confusion if updating, correcting, and order display
and fair access amendments later were declared ineffective, it is
appropriate to make updating, correcting, and order display and fair
access amendments to an effective Form ATS-N public upon filing because
the related changes, any inaccurate or incomplete disclosures about the
operation of the NMS Stock ATS, or triggering of the order display and
execution access and fair access thresholds, may have been implemented
at or before the time of filing, and we believe that it is crucial that
market participants have updated information about current NMS Stock
ATS operations.\611\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\607\ See Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B) and supra Section IV.B.1.b.
\608\ See Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C).
\609\ See Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D).
\610\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 7; UBS Letter at 3.
\611\ An updating or correcting amendment to a material
amendment during Commission review will not be made public until the
material amendment that is amended becomes public. We believe this
is appropriate because updating and correcting amendments to a
material amendment during Commission review would amend a material
amendment that is not yet public or operative.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to amendments declared ineffective, one commenter
states that such amendments should be returned to the NMS Stock ATS and
not be made publicly accessible.\612\ Under Rule 304(b)(2)(iii)(A), as
adopted, the Commission is specifying that it will not make public the
entirety of a material amendment that it declares ineffective. The
Commission would, however, upon filing, make public on its website the
cover page of the material amendment, and subsequently, any order of
ineffectiveness related to such material amendment. In addition,
because the Commission will make public updating, correcting, and order
display and fair access amendments to an effective Form ATS-N upon
filing, such amendments will be publicly available even if the
Commission declares such amendments ineffective during its 30-calendar
day review period. We believe that it is appropriate to make public
updating, correcting, and order display and fair access amendments upon
filing, even if the Commission could later declare them ineffective,
because, unlike material amendments, the disclosures included in
updating, correcting, and order display and fair access amendments have
been implemented and reflect an NMS Stock ATS's current operations and
affiliate relationships. If the Commission later declares an updating,
correcting, or order display and fair access amendment ineffective, it
will issue an order of ineffectiveness, which the Commission will make
public to notify market participants that such change is no longer in
effect.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\612\ See SIFMA Letter at 31.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Three commenters state that by making pending amendments public,
the Commission may incidentally turn the process into a review, notice,
and comment period.\613\ Under the adopted rule, the Commission will
not make material amendments to Form ATS-N public until the Commission
review period has expired. Further, the Commission does not believe
that publicly disclosing the brief description of a material amendment
on the cover page of Form ATS-N or publicly disclosing correcting,
updating, and order display and fair access amendments upon filing will
create a public notice, comment, and review period, as the Commission
is not soliciting public comments on amendments.\614\ This process will
be distinct from the proposed rule filing process for national
securities exchanges, in which the Commission solicits comment for
proposed rule changes and considers whether rule changes are consistent
with the Exchange Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\613\ See SIFMA Letter at 32; Morgan Stanley Letter at 4; KCG
Letter at 4.
\614\ See supra Section IV.B.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters suggest that material amendments should be made
public after the Commission has completed its review, but prior to
implementation.\615\ We are not adopting this suggestion because doing
so would require that, to provide additional time for public disclosure
after the end of the Commission review period, either the Commission
truncate the period for Commission review from the entire 30-calendar
day advance notice period, which we believe is necessary for the
review,\616\ to a shorter segment of the total 30-calendar day advance
notice period, or require that NMS Stock ATSs disclose changes further
in advance, which could potentially be burdensome for NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\615\ See UBS Letter at 3; STA Letter at 5.
\616\ See supra Section IV.A.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we received comments asking for clarification
regarding the process for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to file amendments to
its Form ATS while the Commission is reviewing the ATS's initial Form
ATS-N.\617\ In response, we are requiring that a Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
amend only its initial Form ATS-N, and not its Form ATS, during the
Commission review period.\618\ Further, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form
ATS-N will not be made public until the end of the Commission review
period under Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(B). Rule 304(b)(2)(iii) provides that
amendments to an effective Form ATS-N will be made public. Accordingly,
amendments to a Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS during the
Commission review period will not be made public until after the
Commission review period has ended and the Form ATS-N
[[Page 38816]]
becomes effective. We believe that making Form ATS-N amendments public
before the initial Form ATS-N is public would provide little utility,
and would likely only confuse market participants. At the end of the
Commission review period, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N
will be made public, along with all filed correcting, updating, and
order display and fair access amendments, material amendments for which
the Commission's 30-calendar day review period has expired, and the
cover pages to any material amendments during the Commission review
period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\617\ See supra note 438 and accompanying text.
\618\ See supra Section IV.A.4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
d. Public Disclosure of Orders of Ineffective Form ATS-N Amendment
Under Rule 304(b)(2)(iv), the Commission will make public each
order of ineffective Form ATS-N amendment. This would provide notice to
market participants that the Commission had declared a Form ATS-N
amendment ineffective. We received no comments on making public orders
of ineffective Form ATS-N amendments. We are adopting proposed Rule
304(b)(2)(v) as adopted Rule 304(b)(2)(iv).\619\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\619\ See supra note 552.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
e. Public Disclosure of Notices of Cessation
Under Rule 304(b)(2)(v) (which was proposed as Rule
304(b)(2)(vi)),\620\ the Commission will make public each notice of
cessation of a Form ATS-N filed pursuant to Rule 304(a)(3). One
commenter states that it supports our proposal to make notices of
cessation publicly available.\621\ No commenters express opposition to
such requirement. We continue to believe that making public each
properly filed Form ATS-N notice of cessation will provide the public
with notice that the NMS Stock ATS will cease operations and that the
organization, association, or group of persons no longer operates
pursuant to the exemption provided under Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2).
The notice of cessation will provide market participants with the date
that the NMS Stock ATS will cease operations, as designated by the NMS
Stock ATS, and allow them to make arrangements to select alternative
routing destinations for their orders. Therefore, we are adopting as
proposed the requirement for public disclosure of notices of cessation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\620\ See id.
\621\ See ICI Letter at 11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
f. Public Disclosure of Each Order Suspending, Limiting, or Revoking
the Rule 3a1-1(a)(2) Exemption
Under proposed Rule 304(b)(2)(vii), the Commission would make
public each order suspending, limiting, or revoking the exemption
provided pursuant to Rule 3a1-1(a)(2). We did not receive any comments
on this requirement. We believe that it is important for market
participants to be aware of whether an NMS Stock ATS is subject to an
order suspending, limiting, or revoking the exemption from the
definition of ``exchange'' when they are making their routing decisions
because such an order could prevent an NMS Stock ATS from operating, or
it could limit its functionality. Therefore, we are adopting
substantially as proposed the requirement that the Commission make
public each order suspending limiting, or revoking the exemption from
the definition of ``exchange,'' as renumbered Rule 304(b)(2)(vi).\622\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\622\ See supra note 552. We are making one modification to
specify that this applies to the exemption ``for an NMS Stock ATS.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Rule 304(b)(3): Disclosure of Form ATS-N on the NMS Stock ATS's
Website
Proposed Rule 304(b)(3) required each NMS Stock ATS to make public
via posting on its website a direct URL hyperlink to the Commission's
website that contains the documents enumerated in proposed Rule
304(b)(2).
We received two comments on proposed Rule 304(b)(3).\623\ One
commenter supports adding a requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to post the
effective Forms ATS-N on their own websites and not simply provide
links to the Commission's website.\624\ Another commenter requests that
rather than requiring materials to be posted centrally through the
Commission, the Commission should allow an NMS Stock ATS to post its
disclosure materials on its public website.\625\ We are not adopting a
requirement that an NMS Stock ATS post its filings on its own website
because it believes that requiring each NMS Stock ATS to provide a link
to the Commission's website, which will link to Form ATS-N filings in
EDGAR, will provide market participants easy and uniform access to Form
ATS-N filings. The link to the Commission website would provide users
with access to all new filings available in EDGAR.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\623\ See CFA Institute Letter at 6; UBS Letter at 3.
\624\ See CFA Institute Letter at 6.
\625\ See UBS Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting, with modifications, the requirement that each NMS
Stock ATS make public via posting on its website a direct URL hyperlink
to the Commission's website that contains the documents enumerated in
proposed Rule 304(b)(2). We continue to believe that the requirement of
posting on the NMS Stock ATS's website a direct URL hyperlink to the
Commission's website would make it easier for market participants to
review an NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N filings by providing an additional
means for market participants to locate Form ATS-N filings that are
made available through the Commission's website.\626\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\626\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81035.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
V. Form ATS-N Disclosures
A. Form ATS-N Disclosure Requirements and Definitions
1. Rule 304(c): Disclosure Requirements
Proposed Rule 304(c)(1) required NMS Stock ATSs to respond to each
item on Form ATS-N, as applicable, in detail, and disclose information
that is accurate, current, and complete. Unlike proposed Rule
304(c)(2), reports required under Rule 304 must be filed electronically
on Form ATS-N, include all information as prescribed in Form ATS-N and
the Instructions thereto, and contain an electronic signature that is
authenticated by manual signature. Further, proposed Rule 304(c)(2)
required that such document be executed before or at the time Form ATS-
N is electronically filed and be retained by the NMS Stock ATS in
accordance with Rule 303.\627\ The proposed Form ATS-N required the
signator to represent that the information and statements in the
applicable Form ATS-N, including exhibits, schedules, or other
documents attached to the Form ATS-N, and other information filed with
the Form ATS-N, are current, true, and complete.\628\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\627\ See id.
\628\ See Proposed Form ATS-N, Part V.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Rule 304(c)(2), with technical and non-substantive
modifications to reduce redundancy and reduce potential ambiguity about
the filing requirements for Form ATS-N.\629\
[[Page 38817]]
In the Proposal, the Commission stated that Regulation ATS requires NMS
Stock ATSs to register as broker-dealers with the Commission, which
entails becoming a member of an SRO, such as FINRA, and fully complying
with the broker-dealer regulatory regime.\630\ The Commission requested
comment on whether the certification under FINRA Rule 3130 would help
ensure an NMS Stock ATS's compliance with proposed Rule 304, including
the requirement that disclosures on Form ATS-N be accurate, current,
and complete.\631\ The Commission received two comment letters
regarding the requirement that an authorized person certify that the
form is ``current, true, and complete.'' \632\ One commenter supports
the certification requirement.\633\ Another commenter expresses concern
about immaterial errors being a basis for liability.\634\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\629\ The Commission is deleting the word ``electronically'' and
the language ``and contain an electronic signature'' in the first
sentence of proposed Rule 304(c)(2). All NMS Stock ATSs are required
to file Form ATS-N through EDGAR. Therefore, we believe that
referencing the term ``electronic'' and ``electronic signature'' is
redundant because all filings are electronically submitted through
EDGAR. We are deleting the second sentence (regarding manually
signing a signature page or document) and instead adding a reference
to 232.302 of Regulation S-T, which includes the general rules for
electronic filings, including rules governing electronic signatures.
We are also modifying the third sentence of Rule 304(c)(2) to state
that any report filed under Rule 304 shall be executed ``at, or
prior to,'' the time the Form ATS-N is filed (instead of ``before or
at''). We are also adding a reference to the Instructions in Form
ATS-N, which includes the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to maintain
a paper copy with original manual signatures, instead of including a
reference to retaining Form ATS-N in accordance with Sec. 242.303,
as proposed.
\630\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81005.
\631\ See id. at 81037.
\632\ See SIFMA Letter at 33; Better Markets Letter at 7.
\633\ See Better Markets Letter at 7.
\634\ See SIFMA Letter at 33.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission continues to believe that it is appropriate to
require authorized persons to certify that the Form ATS-N is ``current,
true, and complete.'' We believe that market participants will rely on
Form ATS-N disclosures to understand the operations of an NMS Stock ATS
and ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator, and decide
whether that trading center would be a desirable venue for their
orders. The information contained on Form ATS-N will also be available
for Commission use, including as part of its oversight functions.
Further, existing Form ATS also requires authorized persons to certify
that the information and statements in the form, exhibits, schedules
and other documents attached are ``current, true, and complete.'' \635\
In addition, Form 1, the application for registration or exemption from
registration as a national securities exchange, requires a similar
certification.\636\ Neither of these certifications includes a
materiality qualifier, and the Commission does not believe that it
would be appropriate to include a materiality qualifier in Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\635\ See Form ATS at 1.
\636\ See Form 1 at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Rule 304(c)(1) with certain modifications.\637\
Specifically, adopted Rule 304(c)(1) requires that ``[a]n NMS Stock ATS
must file a Form ATS-N in accordance with the Instructions therein.''
\638\ The adopted Instructions to Form ATS-N require, among other
things, that ``[a]n NMS Stock ATS must provide all the information
required by Form ATS-N, including responses to each Item, as
applicable, and the Exhibits, and disclose information that is
accurate, current, and complete.'' \639\ Similar to the Instructions of
proposed Form ATS-N, the Instructions to adopted Form ATS-N asks an NMS
Stock ATS to respond to each item ``in detail.'' In response to
comments, we revised some of the requests on Form ATS-N to solicit ``a
summary of information'' to tailor further, as appropriate, the
required disclosure or avoid requiring the disclosure of personal or
commercially sensitive information.\640\ Accordingly, we are revising
the Instructions to require that ``unless otherwise provided'' (i.e.,
where the request indicates that the ATS is required to disclose
``summary'' information), the NMS Stock ATS respond to each request in
detail.\641\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\637\ We changed the heading of proposed Rule 304(c) from ``Form
ATS-N filing requirements'' to ``Form ATS-N disclosure
requirements,'' which we believe more accurately describes the
purpose and content of the paragraph.
\638\ See Rule 304(c)(1).
\639\ See Instructions to Form ATS-N.
\640\ See, e.g., Form ATS-N Part III, Item 13(a) (instructing
NMS Stock ATS to provide a summary of the parameters for each
segmented order category).
\641\ In addition, to avoid potential confusion, we are removing
``in detail'' from Rule 304(c)(1) and instead, specifying that the
Form ATS-N must be filed ``in accordance with the instructions
therein.'' See Rule 304(c)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that an NMS Stock ATS should be permitted to
disclose additional information to its subscribers and potential
customers, outside of the Form ATS-N process, or respond to requests
for information from market participants.\642\ Similarly, one commenter
states that NMS Stock ATSs should be allowed to separately disclose
information, upon request, regarding order segmentation to subscribers
who require such information from a ``due diligence perspective'' and
who, due to the nature of their trading, would not present gaming
concerns.\643\ We believe that it would be inconsistent with the goals
of this rulemaking were its adoption to chill communication between
broker-dealer operators and subscribers about the NMS Stock ATS. The
adopted enhanced disclosure requirements do not prohibit broker-dealer
operators from communicating with subscribers and other market
participants about information not otherwise required by Form ATS-N in
a manner that is consistent with federal securities laws and the rules
or regulations thereunder. A broker-dealer operator responding to a
request for information from a subscriber or market participant
generally should evaluate whether the information provided in response
to these requests must be disclosed on Form ATS-N if the information
does not already appear in its Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\642\ See T. Rowe Price Letter at 2.
\643\ See Fidelity Letter at 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission received several comments on the general format of
the Form ATS-N. Several commenters suggest that the Commission modify
Form ATS-N so that the requests for information result in disclosures
that are more standardized and allow market participants to more easily
compare Form ATS-N filings.\644\ Some commenters express concern that
requesting what they characterize as ``extraneous'' information could
obscure the information that market participants would find the most
relevant.\645\ Some of these commenters also express concern that the
volume of data that NMS Stock ATSs would provide in response to
questions that require narrative responses would make it difficult for
participants to understand ATS operations \646\ or conduct due
diligence.\647\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\644\ See SSGA Letter at 2-3; BIDS Letter at 4-5; Fidelity
Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 5; UBS Letter at 2-3; KCG Letter at 8-
9, 11; Morgan Stanley Letter at 1; STA Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at
9; LeveL ATS Letter at 6-7.
\645\ See STANY Letter at 3; Luminex Letter at 4; KCG Letter at
4; SSGA Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 7.
\646\ See STA Letter at 2; KCG Letter at 3-4; SIFMA Letter at 9.
\647\ See SSGA Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although one commenter expressly agrees with the Commission's
approach of requiring summaries of amendments,\648\ several commenters
state that narrative responses on Form ATS-N are likely to vary widely,
and could make comparing multiple platforms difficult.\649\ Multiple
commenters advocate for replacing some of the proposed narrative
responses to Form ATS-N with ``yes'' or ``no'' responses.\650\ One
commenter states that requiring ATSs to respond in a ``yes'' or ``no''
format would support
[[Page 38818]]
more fulsome disclosure and create a universal standard of review, as
allowing narrative responses may allow ATSs to disclose only the
information that they deem appropriate.\651\ Some commenters recognize
that ``yes'' or ``no'' information may need to be supplemented by short
narrative responses.\652\ One commenter suggests introducing a tabular
format, where reasonable, to capture the disclosures required by Forms
ATS-N would facilitate comparison of Forms ATS-N.\653\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\648\ See Liquidnet Letter at 18.
\649\ See SSGA Letter at 2; Fidelity Letter at 5; STA Letter at
2; BIDS Letter at 4-5; KCG Letter at 8-9; Morgan Stanley Letter at
1.
\650\ See SSGA Letter at 2; BIDS Letter at 4; STANY Letter at 5;
STA Letter at 2; UBS Letter at 2-3; KCG Letter at 8-11; SIFMA Letter
at 9; LeveL ATS Letter at 6.
\651\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 7.
\652\ See BIDS Letter at 4; SIFMA Letter at 12; LeveL ATS Letter
at 7.
\653\ See BIDS Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission has revised the format of proposed Form ATS-N to
further standardize the form's requests, better organize questions by
subject matter, reduce redundancy, reduce ambiguity, make more explicit
requests on Form ATS-N to facilitate complete responses, and achieve
the appropriate balance between yes/no and narrative responses. For
instance, the adopted format of Form ATS-N changes several questions
from proposed Form ATS-N for certain subject matters (e.g., order
display, co-location services, and segmentation) to require ``yes'' or
``no'' responses with further narrative disclosure required in
connection with ``yes'' responses. We believe that adding more ``yes''
or ``no'' questioning in Form ATS-N will help standardize responses and
address commenters' concerns about facilitating market participants'
review and comparisons of Form ATS-N disclosures. We continue to
believe, however, that narrative responses enable market participants
to understand the operations of the NMS Stock ATS and the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator, particularly in light of the
different trading functionalities, options, and procedures that are
offered across NMS Stock ATSs, and provide NMS Stock ATSs with the
flexibility to communicate required information to the public that is
required by the form.
Also, certain requests have been amended to only require summary
information. We believe that requiring summaries for certain
disclosures could help reduce potential extraneous information.
2. Terminology
a. Definitions for Form ATS-N
(i) Proposed Defined Terms
As proposed, Form ATS-N would have set forth definitions of the
following terms: (1) Affiliate; (2) alternative trading system; (3)
broker-dealer operator; (4) control; (5) NMS security; (6) NMS Stock;
(7) NMS Stock ATS; (8) order; (9) person; and (10) subscriber.
The Commission received several comments regarding the proposed
definitions of ``affiliate.'' The Commission is adopting the definition
of the term ``affiliate,'' with a technical change,\654\ to mean ``with
respect to a specified Person, any Person that directly, or indirectly,
controls, is under common control with, or is controlled by, the
specified Person.'' One commenter states that the proposed definition
of ``affiliate'' would include, among others, owners of the ATS
operator, without regard for whether the affiliate is separately
registered as a broker-dealer and therefore subject to the Commission's
jurisdiction.\655\ The commenter notes that the definition of
``affiliate'' would include persons ``under common control with'' the
NMS Stock ATS operator, with control meaning at least 25% ownership,
such that the threshold would capture entities that operate
independently from one another.\656\ Similarly, another commenter
points out that although the Proposal contains a customary definition
of the term ``affiliate,'' the definition is not limited in any way
that focuses on direct interactions or relationships with the NMS Stock
ATS.\657\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\654\ The Commission is making one technical change to the
proposed term ``affiliate'' by capitalizing the defined term
``Person.'' This change is meant to identify the term Person as a
defined term for purposes of the Form ATS-N.
\655\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 3, n.5.
\656\ See id. at 4, n.7.
\657\ See UBS Letter at 4. This commenter states that the
broker-dealer operator of its ATS has well over 300 global
affiliates under the definition set forth in the Proposal, and that
not all such affiliates are users of the ATS; only orders routed by
a small number of affiliates end up in its ATS. See id. The
commenter also points out that as proposed, it would need to
disclose every affiliate regardless of whether it has any
interactions with the ATS. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe that the status of an affiliate's registration
with the Commission should limit the scope of the disclosures about
that affiliate in Form ATS-N. However, the adopted Form ATS-N
conflicts-of-interest disclosures are tailored to inform market
participants about how affiliates of the broker-dealer operator trade
on the NMS Stock ATS and how the use of the ATS by affiliates may
affect the handling and execution of orders from unaffiliated parties.
While the definition of ``affiliate'' in Form ATS-N may encompass a
large number of entities for some ATSs, Form ATS-N is designed to
solicit information that is relevant to a market participant's
evaluation of an NMS Stock ATS as a potential trading venue. Therefore,
while we have not amended the proposed definition of ``affiliate,'' the
disclosures about affiliate activity on an NMS Stock ATS are not
designed to require information about affiliates that the Commission
and commenters believe would be extraneous to a market participant's
evaluation of conflicts of interest and information leakage on the ATS.
We received two comments regarding the proposed definition of
``control.'' After carefully considering these comments, we are
adopting the definition of ``control,'' as proposed, to mean:
the power, directly or indirectly, to direct the management or
policies of the broker-dealer of an alternative trading system,
whether through the ownership of securities, by contract, or
otherwise. A Person is presumed to control the broker-dealer of an
alternative trading system, if that Person (1) is a director,
general partner, or officer exercising executive responsibility (or
having similar status or performing similar functions); (2) directly
or indirectly has the right to vote 25% or more of a class of voting
securities or has the power to sell or direct the sale of 25% or
more of a class of voting securities of the broker-dealer of the
alternative trading system; or (3) in the case of a partnership, has
contributed, or has the right to receive, upon dissolution, 25% or
more of the capital of the broker-dealer of the alternative trading
system.
One commenter expresses support for the Commission's proposal that
the definition of control contain a 25% ownership threshold that the
commenter states currently serves as a presumption of control and is
consistent with that used in other areas of the securities laws.\658\
Another commenter states, however, that the proposed definition of
``control'' provides that certain persons are presumed to control the
broker-dealer operator of an NMS Stock ATS, but that there is no
corresponding safe harbor whereby persons are presumed not to control
an NMS Stock ATS.\659\ Accordingly, the commenter opines that an NMS
Stock ATS operator may feel obligated to provide overly broad
disclosures, which could confuse subscribers regarding potential
conflicts.\660\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\658\ See HMA Letter at 15.
\659\ See LeveL ATS Letter at 3, n.6.
\660\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclosures related to affiliates extend to persons that control,
are controlled by, or are under common control with the broker-dealer
operator, and, as a result, parallel the disclosures related to
``control affiliates'' that broker-dealer
[[Page 38819]]
operators must make on Form BD.\661\ The Commission disagrees that an
NMS Stock ATS operator may feel obligated to provide unnecessarily
broad disclosures regarding potential conflicts of interest due to the
proposed definition of ``control.'' The presumed control tests set
forth in the adopted definition of ``control'' are meant to provide
clarity to NMS Stock ATSs as to when an entity and the broker-dealer
operator are defined as ``affiliated,'' which would trigger the NMS
Stock ATSs' disclosure duties under Part II of adopted Form ATS-N. We
believe that the enumerated circumstances under which there is presumed
control involve factors (such as a shared executive or 25% ownership)
that would likely result in one entity or person having the power,
directly or indirectly, to direct the management or policies of the
broker-dealer operator of an ATS. Therefore, in such situations, a
presumption of control is appropriate. On the other hand, because
control can manifest itself in several ways under the adopted
definition, the Commission does not feel that there are certain facts
that would warrant a presumption of no control. For example, the unique
facts and circumstances of several different ownership structures could
result in different conclusions regarding control, even though the
various structures contain some similarities. Accordingly, the
Commission has not added provisions setting forth circumstances under
which there would be a presumption of no control.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\661\ See Form BD at 2 (defining ``control affiliate'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission is adopting as proposed the changes to the
definition of ``control'' under Rule 300(f) in Regulation ATS. The
definition of the term control being adopted herein contains the
additional phrase ``the broker-dealer of'' before the two instances of
the phrase ``an alternative trading system'' and before the phrase
``the alternative trading system'' in subsections (2) and (3) of the
definition.\662\ As discussed in the Proposal, the purpose of this
difference is to make clear that, because an ATS must register as a
broker-dealer, control of the broker-dealer of the ATS is control of
the ATS, and that the broker-dealer operator is legally responsible for
all operational aspects of the ATS and for ensuring that the ATS
complies with applicable federal securities laws and the rules and
regulations thereunder, including Regulation ATS.\663\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\662\ 17 CFR 242.300(f).
\663\ See Proposal, supra note 1, at 81044.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The disclosures of ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator's affiliates in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N are designed to
provide subscribers and market participants with a comprehensive
understanding of the conflicts of interest that may arise from the
broker-dealer operator's other business activities and its operation of
the NMS Stock ATS. Under the adopted definitions of ``affiliate'' and
``control,'' any affiliate of the broker-dealer operator of the NMS
Stock ATS would be an affiliate of the NMS Stock ATS. These definitions
are designed to cover entities that have a close relationship with the
broker-dealer operator and whose activities could raise conflicts of
interest concerns, or could otherwise be relevant to market
participants when evaluating an NMS Stock ATS.
Furthermore, in Part III, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N, the
Commission used the term ``non-ATS trading center.'' A commenter
requests that the Commission define the term ``non-ATS trading center''
so that broker-dealer operators can better focus on making proper
disclosures.\664\ As further explained below, in response to comments,
the Commission is reorganizing and changing Part III, Item 1 of
proposed Form ATS-N to request information about the trading activities
of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates, irrespective of
whether the broker-dealer operator's business units and/or affiliates
are non-ATS trading centers.\665\ Given the revisions the Commission is
making to Part III, Item 1, we believe that the defined term is no
longer necessary, and the Commission is, therefore, eliminating the
term from adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\664\ See SIFMA Letter at 10.
\665\ See infra Section V.C.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter agrees with the goal of highlighting potential
conflicts of interest faced by broker-dealer operators of NMS Stock
ATSs and their affiliates in connection with the ATS.\666\ The
commenter endorses the proposed requirement to identify non-ATS trading
centers managed by the ATS operator or its affiliates that interact
with the ATS. The commenter also states that disclosures related to
non-ATS trading centers should be limited to non-ATS trading centers
that interact with or exchange information with the ATS.\667\ The
Commission also believes that public disclosure of non-ATS trading
centers managed by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates that
interact with the ATS furthers the stated goal of helping market
participants evaluate potential conflicts of interest on an NMS Stock
ATS. The requests in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N are tailored to
elicit such information without burdening NMS Stock ATSs with a
requirement to list the non-ATS trading centers of the broker-dealer
operator or its affiliates that do not interact with the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\666\ See KCG Letter at 8.
\667\ See id. at 8-9. This commenter also asserts that it is
imperative for the Commission to clarify that the interaction
between the NMS Stock ATS and any non[hyphen]ATS trading center may
be subject to change and the ATS operator does not need file and
receive Commission approval before implementation. See id. We note
that the materiality of any changes to the interaction and
coordination between non-ATS trading centers and the NMS Stock ATS
that would require disclosure on Form ATS-N should be evaluated
based on the facts and circumstances related to each change.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) New Defined Terms
The Commission is adding the term ``trading center'' to the
definitions set forth in the Instructions to adopted Form ATS-N to
define that term for purposes of its use in Part II and Part III of
adopted Form ATS-N. The term ``trading center'' was used in proposed
Form ATS-N with regard to arrangements with other trading centers--Part
III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N--and is used in adopted Form ATS-N's
requests regarding the routing of orders from the NMS Stock ATS to
business units or affiliates of the broker-dealer operator (adopted
Part II, Items 1 and 2) and the NMS Stock ATS's arrangements with other
trading centers (adopted Part II, Item 4).
The definition of the term ``trading center'' used for purposes of
adopted Form ATS-N is the same as that currently set forth in
Regulation NMS Rule 600(b)(78).\668\ The adopted definition is ``a
national securities exchange or national securities association that
operates an SRO trading facility, an alternative trading system, an
exchange market maker, an OTC market maker, or any other broker or
dealer that executes orders internally by trading as principal or
crossing orders as agent.'' While we believe that the scope of the term
``trading center'' in Form ATS-N would likely be understood by NMS
Stock ATSs, we believe that adding a definition to the Form ATS-N will
reduce any potential ambiguity with regard to those requests in Part
II, Items 1, 2, and 4 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\668\ See 17 CFR 242.600(b)(78).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that the Commission should add additional
definitions for certain terms to promote consistency throughout Forms
ATS-N, which the commenter believes could ultimately facilitate
comparison among
[[Page 38820]]
Forms ATS-N.\669\ Another commenter emphasizes that the Commission
should establish fundamental uniformity in the way information is
defined and disclosed.\670\ We have structured adopted Form ATS-N to
allow market participants to better compare disclosures among NMS Stock
ATSs. We do not, however, believe that it should establish standardized
terms to be used by NMS Stock ATSs when completing their disclosures on
Form ATS-N. We do not desire to impose substantive standards for how
disclosures should be written by adopting and defining terms to be used
by all NMS Stock ATSs to describe the functionalities, operations, or
procedures of their systems. The operations of NMS Stock ATSs vary,
and, apart from some common terms, many NMS Stock ATSs use different
terminology to describe their operations and functionalities. Based on
our review of Form ATS filings, we believe that NMS Stock ATSs may use
differing terms and definitions to describe functionalities,
operations, or procedures, even if a particular function, operation, or
procedure on one ATS may resemble that on another. We do not believe
that it would be very helpful to define terms for functionalities,
operations, or procedures across NMS Stock ATSs because doing so may
not result in complete or comprehensible disclosures due to these
substantive and semantical differences in the operations of NMS Stock
ATSs. We believe that adopting standardized, substantive terms for Form
ATS-N disclosures may limit the ability of an NMS Stock ATS to
completely and clearly describe its system, which we believe could
reduce the utility of Form ATS-N disclosures for market participants.
We also believe that such defined terminology would limit the
flexibility of NMS Stock ATSs to name or market new services of the
ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\669\ See BIDS Letter at 5.
\670\ See UBS Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Comments on the Definition of ``Subscriber''
When seeking disclosures regarding how an NMS Stock ATS operates
and the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates, proposed Form ATS-N used the terms ``subscriber'' and
``person(s).'' One commenter believes that Form ATS-N should instead
focus on the term ``user'' rather than ``subscriber.'' \671\ This
commenter states that the term ``subscriber'' can be disparately
interpreted and applied by broker-dealer operators of ATSs and would
inhibit uniform application across ATSs in terms of disclosure, access,
priority, and other purposes. This commenter further states that the
current definition in Regulation ATS fails to adequately define
``subscriber'' in the case of an ATS that is part of a larger broker-
dealer operation, leading to inconsistencies in the application of the
requirements applicable to subscribers across ATSs. The commenter
believes that disclosures in Form ATS-N should not depend on whether a
broker-dealer operator has a contractual agreement with a user for
accessing the ATS, but should be consistent for all users that access
an ATS whether such users are internal or external and whether such
users access the ATS directly or indirectly.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\671\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, another commenter believes the phrase ``subscriber
orders or other trading interest'' as used in proposed Part III, Item
1--which would have required the NMS Stock ATS to disclose information
about the interaction and coordination between non-ATS trading centers
operated by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates and the NMS
Stock ATS--should be read as ``subscriber orders or subscriber trading
interest.'' \672\ This commenter believes that the alternative reading
would potentially capture all trading interest sent to the broker-
dealer operator of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\672\ See UBS Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We agree that responses to questions in Form ATS-N should be
uniformly applied by NMS Stock ATSs regardless of the source of orders
(e.g., principal trading desks of the broker-dealer operator, third
parties using direct connectivity, affiliates of the broker-dealer
operator, customers of the broker-dealer operator whose orders are
submitted to the ATS through a functionality of the broker-dealer
operator, such as a smart order router (``SOR'')). We have revised
several requests on proposed Form ATS-N to help facilitate a uniform
application of responses by NMS Stock ATSs and, in response to
commenters' concerns, are providing guidance regarding the definition
of ``subscriber'' under Regulation ATS and in the context of Form ATS-N
disclosures.
First, we believe that the term ``subscriber'' sufficiently
captures the vast majority of market participants whose orders or
trading interest are submitted to and executed in an NMS Stock ATS.
Regulation ATS defines subscriber ``[a]s any person that has entered
into a contractual agreement with an ATS to access such ATS for the
purpose of effecting transactions in securities or submitting,
disseminating, or displaying orders on such ATS, including a customer,
member, user, or participant in an ATS.'' \673\ In the Proposal, as the
Commission discussed, the broker-dealer operator of an NMS Stock ATS is
legally responsible for, and controls all aspects of, the ATS
operation, including, among other things, providing access to the
ATS.\674\ Based on our experience, persons seeking to use an ATS's
services enter into agreements with the broker-dealer operator, and
these agreements could cover services in addition to the ATS services.
These agreements may take a variety of forms, and may or may not be
written.\675\ If a market participant has an agreement--written or
unwritten--with a broker-dealer that allows the market participant to
enter orders directly into an ATS operated by the broker-dealer, that
market participant is a subscriber of the ATS for purposes of
Regulation ATS and Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\673\ 17 CFR 242.300(b) (emphasis added). Additionally, the
definition of the term ``subscriber'' under Regulation ATS states
that a subscriber shall not include a national securities exchange
or national securities association. See id.
\674\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81041 (discussing the
relationship between the broker-dealer operator's operation of the
NMS Stock ATS and its other operations).
\675\ For example, third-party market participants--including,
potentially, affiliates and non-affiliates of the broker-dealer
operator--may enter into subscriber agreements or some other form of
contract with the broker-dealer operator to connect directly to the
ATS to submit or display orders. We note that a determination as to
who may be a ``subscriber'' to the ATS would depend upon the facts
and circumstances of the relationship between the ATS and the
broker-dealer operator, so the preceding examples are not
exhaustive.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another example of a subscriber would include a customer of the
broker-dealer operator whose orders are submitted to the ATS by the
broker-dealer operator. Many NMS Stock ATSs are operated by broker-
dealers that offer their customers a wide range of order handling and
execution services in addition to the execution services of their NMS
Stock ATSs.\676\ These services typically involve functionality such as
an SOR or other types of trading algorithms. In cases where a customer
uses this wider range of services of the broker-dealer, the customer
would not
[[Page 38821]]
send its orders directly to the ATS, but rather, send its orders to
some functionality external to the ATS, which could be the SOR or
algorithm itself or a client service desk that submits the customer
orders into the broker-dealer's SOR or trading algorithms. A SOR or
trading algorithm typically has the capability to route customer orders
to a number of execution venues, including the broker-dealer operator's
own ATS. We note that such commercial relationships may be governed by
formal or informal agreements. To the extent a person enters into a
contract, written or unwritten, to use the broker-dealer operator's
order routing and execution services, and those services could include
routing to and executing in the broker-dealer operator's own ATS, that
agreement would fall within the contractual agreements under the
definition of ``subscriber'' under Regulation ATS and the person would
be a subscriber to the ATS. On the other hand, a customer's order
routed by the broker-dealer operator's SOR or trading algorithm to an
external market for execution would not be a subscriber order because
the order was not destined or entered into the ATS.\677\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\676\ See UBS Letter at 5 (noting that market participants may
maintain a commercial relationship with the broker-dealer operator
for purposes other than accessing the broker-dealer operator's ATS,
such as to use the broker-dealer's high touch block trading desk or
to use the broker-dealer's trading algorithms); Morgan Stanley
Letter at 1-2 (explaining that full service broker-dealers may
provide clients with a broad, integrated electronic offering of
trading services, which might include ATS services).
\677\ We do not intend for Form ATS-N to require disclosures
about aspects of a market participant's other commercial
relationships with a broker-dealer operator that do not pertain to
the NMS Stock ATS. We believe that the adopted Form ATS-N disclosure
requests are tailored so that operations of the broker-dealer
operator not housed within the NMS Stock ATS--and that do not
otherwise pertain to the functions of the ATS--would not be subject
to disclosure on Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second, as noted above, a commenter believes that Regulation ATS
does not adequately define the term ``subscriber'' in the case of an
ATS that is part of a larger broker-dealer operation, which the
commenter believes could lead to inconsistencies in the application of
the requirements applicable to subscribers across ATSs.\678\ While we
believe that the term ``subscriber'' sufficiently captures the vast
majority of market participants whose orders or trading interest are
submitted to and executed in an NMS Stock ATS, we also acknowledge that
business units of multi-service broker-dealer operators, in many cases,
participate in the ATS of that broker-dealer operator and submit
principal orders to the ATS. Despite participating in the ATS, these
business units might not always meet the definition of ``subscriber''
because an ATS may not have a contractual agreement with a business
unit that is part of the same entity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\678\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adopted Form ATS-N uses the term ``subscriber'' throughout, and, in
certain Items, specifically states the type of ATS-related activities
of, or information about, the broker-dealer operator that must be
disclosed. For example, Part III, Item 5(b) of adopted Form ATS-N
requires the NMS Stock ATS to state whether the terms and conditions to
directly enter orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS are
the same for all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator. We believe
that drafting the Form ATS-N requests in this manner will help ensure
that the scope of information solicited encompasses all relevant users
of the ATS services (i.e., subscribers, and to the extent such users do
not meet the definition of ``subscriber,'' the business units of the
broker-dealer operator). We believe that adopted Form ATS-N is not
designed to solicit disparate disclosures among NMS Stock ATS due to
varying interpretations of the term ``subscriber'' by individual ATSs.
B. Cover Page and Part I of Form ATS-N: Identifying Information
1. Cover Page
In response to concerns from commenters that the public may be led
to believe that the Commission is conducting a merit-based review of
Form ATS-N disclosures filed with the Commission, we are including on
the cover page of Form ATS-N a legend stating that the Commission has
not passed upon the merits or accuracy of the disclosures in the
filing.
On the cover page of adopted Form ATS-N, the responding entity is
required to identify the type of filing \679\ by marking the
appropriate checkbox.\680\ We are also adopting, as proposed, a
requirement that NMS Stock ATSs file a notice of cessation of
operations on Form ATS-N and provide the date that the NMS Stock ATS
will cease to operate. We are also adopting a check box that allows a
Form ATS-N filer to withdraw a previously filed Form ATS-N filing.\681\
The Instructions to Form ATS-N state that an NMS Stock ATS may withdraw
an initial Form ATS-N or an amendment before the end of the applicable
Commission review period. Because its initial Form ATS-N supersedes and
replaces a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS for purposes of the
exemption and the initial Form ATS-N can be amended, a Legacy NMS Stock
ATS may not withdraw its initial Form ATS-N at any time. Once the
Commission review period has expired or a Legacy NMS Stock ATS has
filed its initial Form ATS-N, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS cannot withdraw
the filing and must file a notice of cessation pursuant to Rule
304(a)(3) if it intends to cease to operate or file an amendment to its
Form ATS-N, as appropriate. In addition, an NMS Stock ATS may withdraw
a notice of cessation of operations at any time before the date that
the NMS Stock ATS had indicated it intended to cease operating.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\679\ Proposed Form ATS-N would have required NMS Stock ATSs to
check the ``Submission Type.'' Adopted Form ATS-N requires NMS Stock
ATSs to check the ``Type of Filing.'' This is a non-substantive
change.
\680\ Adopted Form ATS-N's cover page provides that a filing may
be an initial Form ATS-N, or a Form ATS-N material amendment,
updating amendment, correcting amendment, or order display and fair
access amendment. Proposed Form ATS-N included a check box above the
``Submission Type'' menu, where an NMS Stock ATS could indicate if
the filing was an ``Initial Form Filing.'' In addition, in the
proposed Form ATS-N ``Submission Type'' menu, an NMS Stock ATS could
check whether its submission was a ``Form ATS-N.'' Adopted Form ATS-
N does not include a check box to indicate whether the filing is an
``Initial Form Filing,'' and revises the proposed check box under
the ``Type of Filing'' menu to state ``Initial Form ATS-N''
(emphasis added).
\681\ Proposed Form ATS-N included a check box, above the
``Submission Type'' menu, where an NMS Stock ATS could indicate that
a filing was a ``Withdrawal of Initial Form Filing.'' Adopted Form
ATS-N relocates this check box to the ``Type of Filing'' menu and
revises it to say ``Withdrawal of Form ATS-N filing'' so that such
check box can accommodate withdrawals of different types of filings,
and not just a withdrawal of an initial Form ATS-N. Adopted Form
ATS-N provides a space for the EDGAR accession number for the Form
ATS-N filing to be withdrawn, which will enable market participants
to identify the prior filing that is being withdrawn.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the cover page of proposed Form ATS-N, the Commission sought a
brief narrative description for Form ATS-N amendments so market
participants could quickly understand the nature of the amendment.\682\
We are modifying this requirement to be more specific as to what
information is required in this narrative. Adopted Form ATS-N requires
the NMS Stock ATS to indicate
[[Page 38822]]
the part and item number of the Form ATS-N that is the subject of the
change, provide a brief summary of the changes, and state whether or
not the changes apply to all subscribers and the broker-dealer
operator.\683\ In addition, the NMS Stock ATS is required to provide
the EDGAR accession number for the Form ATS-N filing to be amended,
which will allow market participants to identify the filing that is
being amended.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\682\ An NMS Stock ATS is required to attach a document marked
to indicate changes for a Form ATS-N amendment to Form ATS-N Part,
I, Part II, and Part III, as applicable, and to highlight changes to
``yes'' or ``no'' answers or additions or deletions from its prior
Form ATS-N filing. We believe that marked documents will help market
participants and the Commission review Form ATS-N amendments in an
efficient manner. We have changed the marked document requirement
that was proposed. In the proposal the marked document was referred
to a redline. We proposed for an NMS Stock ATS to submit two
redlines--Exhibit 3A to show changes to Part III of proposed Form
ATS-N and Exhibit 4A to show changes to Part IV of proposed Form
ATS-N. We are adopting a requirement that ATSs provide a single
exhibit, Exhibit 3, that contains a marked document to indicate
changes to Parts I, II, and III. We believe that only requiring a
single document may reduce the filing burden on ATSs. We believe
that the marked documents will be helpful for market participants to
review changes to Part I. In addition, to reflect the use of ``yes''
or ``no'' questions in adopted Form ATS-N, we are specifying that
the marked document would be required to indicate changes in ``yes''
or ``no'' answers.
\683\ Accordingly, the adopted Instructions have been enhanced
from the proposed Instructions so that they provide more guidance to
an NMS Stock ATS drafting the narrative. The proposed Instructions
would have asked an NMS Stock ATS to ``[p]rovide a brief narrative
description of the Amendment.'' See Proposal, supra note 2, at
81138.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, in response to comments, we are adopting Rule
304(b)(2)(iii), which provides that it will make public the cover page
of a filed Form ATS-N material amendment upon filing and then make
public the entirety of the material amendment following the expiration
of the review period pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(ii).\684\ In connection
with this change, we are adopting Instructions that we believe will
better solicit information that will notify market participants of the
general subject matter of a Form ATS-N amendment, as well as the
subscribers that would be affected by the amendment. For updating and
correcting amendments, which will be made public upon filing, we
believe that the information in the narrative can assist market
participants in understanding the general nature of the change that the
NMS Stock ATS is implementing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\684\ See supra Section IV.E.2.c.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we are making a technical change to relocate the check
box indicating whether an initial Form ATS-N is being filed by a Legacy
NMS Stock ATS operating pursuant to a Form ATS.\685\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\685\ Proposed Form ATS-N set forth this check box in Part I,
Item 4, whereas adopted Form ATS-N sets forth this check box on the
cover page.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Part I of Form ATS-N: Identifying Information
a. Part I: Identifying Information
Part I of adopted Form ATS-N combines the requests set forth in
Parts I and II of proposed Form ATS-N, which covered, among other
things, the name of the NMS Stock ATS and the NMS Stock ATS's broker-
dealer operator's registration and contact information.\686\ We are
adding to Part I, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N, a new requirement,
which was not proposed, that the filer check a box indicating whether
the filer is a registered broker-dealer with the Commission to readily
notify the Commission whether the filer is eligible to operate as an
NMS Stock ATS pursuant to Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\686\ The subsequent sections of adopted Form ATS-N have been
renumbered accordingly. The disclosures regarding the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates on the
NMS Stock ATS are contained in Part II, the manner of operations
disclosures are contained in Part III, and the contact information,
signature block, and consent to service are contained in Part IV of
adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To assist the Commission in more easily assessing whether the NMS
Stock ATS has registered as a broker-dealer pursuant to Rule 301(b)(1)
of Regulation ATS, we are adopting the proposed requirement that the
NMS Stock ATS provide the name of the registered broker-dealer for the
NMS Stock ATS (i.e., the broker-dealer operator), as it is stated on
Form BD, in Part I, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N. To the extent that a
commercial or ``DBA'' (doing business as) name or names \687\ are used
to identify the NMS Stock ATS to the public, the Commission, or its
SRO, or if a registered broker-dealer operates multiple NMS Stock ATSs,
adopted Form ATS-N would require the full name(s) of the NMS Stock ATS
under which business is conducted, if different,\688\ in Part I, Item 3
of adopted Form ATS-N. We are also adopting Part II, Items 2 and 3 of
proposed Form ATS-N as Part I, Item 4 \689\ of adopted Form ATS-N to
require the NMS Stock ATS to provide the broker-dealer operator's SEC
File Number and Central Registration Depository (``CRD'') Number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\687\ In some instances, an NMS Stock ATS may have several
commercial or doing-business-as names, such as a name the ATS uses
in its filings to the Commission, or to FINRA pursuant to FINRA Rule
6110. Adopted Form ATS-N requires the ATS to list all names under
which it conducts business in Part I, Item 2.
\688\ Part I, Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
an NMS Stock ATS to disclose the full name of the NMS Stock ATS
under which its business is conducted, ``if any.'' Part I, Item 3 of
adopted Form ATS-N only requires this disclosure ``if different.''
\689\ The requirements of Part II, Items 2 and 3 of proposed
Form ATS-N are consolidated into Part I, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-
N, and divided into two subparts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not, however, including in adopted Part I the proposed
requests that the NMS Stock ATS provide the effective date of its
broker-dealer operator's registration with the Commission, the broker-
dealer operator's legal status (e.g., sole proprietorship,
corporation), information about its date and place of formation if the
broker-dealer operator is other than a sole proprietor, and the mailing
address of the NMS Stock ATS (if not the same as the physical address).
This identifying information is disclosed on Form BD or otherwise made
available to the public and the Commission.\690\ We do not believe that
it is necessary to require the NMS Stock ATS to provide this
information on Form ATS-N because other information requests about the
registration status of the broker-dealer operator will inform the
Commission about whether the NMS Stock ATS has met the condition of
Rule 301(b)(1) of Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\690\ The mailing address for registered broker-dealers is
available to the Commission via EDGAR. The mailing address, type of
entity, and date when established for each broker-dealer is
available to the public through FINRA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Part II, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N as Part I,
Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N to require the NMS Stock ATS to provide
the full name of the national securities association of the broker-
dealer operator and the effective date of the broker-dealer operator's
membership with the national securities association. We are adding to
Part I, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N the proposed requirement for an
NMS Stock ATS to provide its Market Participant Identifier
(``MPID'').\691\ Providing the name of the NMS Stock ATS or DBAs and
its MPID would identify the ATS to the public and Commission. One
commenter states that the name, identity of the broker-dealer operator,
any ``doing business as'' name, and the ATS's MPID are basic
information critical to market participants and should be
disclosed.\692\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\691\ This requirement was previously a stand-alone request and
has been moved to Part I, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N, which asks
the NMS Stock ATS to disclose its national securities association,
which would issue the MPID to the ATS. An MPID, or other mechanism
or mnemonic, is used to identify a market participant for the
purposes of electronically accessing a national securities exchange
or an ATS. See, e.g., Securities Exchange Act Release No. 63241
(November 3, 2010), 75 FR 69792 (November 15, 2010). ATSs are
required to use a unique MPID when reporting trade information to
FINRA. See FINRA ATS Reporting Approval, supra note 15.
\692\ See HMA Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, as was proposed, adopted Form ATS-N requires the NMS Stock
ATS to provide a URL address for the website of the ATS, and in the
signature block in Part IV of adopted Form ATS-N, the representative of
the broker-dealer operator will also be required to provide his or her
business contact information, including the person's name and title,
telephone number, email address, and primary street address and mailing
address (if different) of the NMS Stock ATS.\693\ This information will
facilitate
[[Page 38823]]
communication with the broker-dealer operator during the Commission
review period of a Form ATS-N and later as necessary as part of the
Commission's ongoing monitoring of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\693\ Contact information of the broker-dealer operator's
representative in Part IV of Form ATS-N will not be made public. In
addition, consistent with the requirements of proposed Form ATS-N,
the signature block in Part IV of adopted Form ATS-N requires the
NMS Stock ATS to consent that service of any civil action brought
by, or notice of any proceeding before, the Commission or a SRO in
connection with the ATS's activities may be given by registered or
certified mail to the contact employee at the primary street address
or mailing address, if different, of the NMS Stock ATS, or via
email, at the addresses provided on this Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are modifying the proposed request for the physical street
address of the NMS Stock ATS to also require the ATS to provide the
physical street address, if any, of a secondary location for the ATS
that may be used in the event that the primary physical location is not
available. The location of an NMS Stock ATS, including its matching
system, may differ from the main physical or mailing address of the
broker-dealer operator. We believe that it is important for both the
Commission and market participants to know where the NMS Stock ATS is
located in the event of, for instance, a natural disaster that could
impact market participants' ability to trade on the ATS and potential
latency that could be experienced due to the location of the secondary
site of the NMS Stock ATS. Also, we are concerned that market
participants could be harmed from systems problems that necessitate a
suspension or halt to trading at an NMS Stock ATS. Thus, we believe it
is important to fully understand what, if any, trading procedures an
NMS Stock ATS would follow if trading is suspended or stopped, which
would be disclosed under Part III, Item 20 of adopted Form ATS-N. We
believe that knowing any secondary location(s) for the NMS Stock ATS
would be relevant to both the Commission's and market participants'
understanding of how the ATS handles certain contingencies.
The main physical address and mailing address of the broker-dealer
operator are provided on Form BD, so we do not believe it is necessary
to publicly disclose this information on Form ATS-N.\694\ Part II, Item
6 of proposed Form ATS-N provided that the NMS Stock ATS could indicate
by check box that the broker-dealer operator is a sole proprietor and
that the physical street address is a private residence, and that in
such case, the private residential address would not be included in the
publicly available version of the form.\695\ One commenter asserts that
Form ATS-N should require disclosure of all relevant addresses, and
states its view that we should eliminate the proposed exception for NMS
Stock ATSs out of a personal residence.\696\ In light of this comment,
we are not including in adopted Form ATS-N the proposed check box
noting that the physical address of the matching system is at a sole
proprietor's private residence. We agree that market participants
should be aware of the physical addresses of the matching systems for
all NMS Stock ATSs, regardless of whether they are at a sole
proprietor's private residence. In addition, based on Commission
experience, NMS Stock ATSs generally do not operate out of a sole
proprietor's residence, and the Commission does not believe that the
exception is necessary. We will therefore make the physical address of
the matching system available for every Form ATS-N.\697\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\694\ Part IV of adopted Form ATS-N, which will not be made
public, requires the primary street address and mailing address of
the NMS Stock ATS in order to facilitate the Commission contacting
the NMS Stock ATS. See supra note 693.
\695\ See Part II, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N.
\696\ See HMA Letter at 11.
\697\ Part I, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, as was proposed, the Part I, Items 8 and 9 require an NMS
Stock ATS to attach its most recently filed or amended Schedule A of
the broker-dealer operator's Form BD disclosing information related to
direct owners and executive officers, and its most recently filed or
amended Schedule B of the broker-dealer operator's Form BD disclosing
information related to indirect owners as Exhibits 1 and 2,
respectively. In lieu of attaching those schedules, the NMS Stock ATS
can indicate, via a checkbox, that the information under those
schedules is available on its website and is accurate as of the date of
the filing of the Form ATS-N. We continue to believe that these
exhibits will help market participants identify the persons and
entities that directly and indirectly own the broker-dealer operator
and any potential associated conflicts of interest. We are requiring
the NMS Stock ATS to provide this information on Form ATS-N, even
though the same information is provided on Form BD, because information
about ownership of the broker-dealer operator will enable market
participants to better understand conflicts of interest that may arise
therefrom, which is one of the central purposes of the form. As such,
an NMS Stock ATS must file this information on Form ATS-N. We also
continue to believe that it is appropriate for an NMS Stock ATS to
provide this information using a URL address for these documents in
lieu of attaching the actual documents to their Form ATS-N filings
because the ATS's disclosures on Form ATS-N will provide the public
with the required information. Part I, Item 10 of adopted Form ATS-N
requires the NMS Stock ATS, for filings made pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2)(i) (i.e., Form ATS-N amendments), to attach as Exhibit 3 a
marked document to indicate changes to ``yes'' or ``no'' answers or
additions or deletions from any item in Part I, Part II, Part III, as
applicable.
b. Comments on Proposed Exhibit 1
We proposed to require that NMS Stock ATSs provide, in Exhibit 1 to
Form ATS-N, a copy of any materials currently provided to subscribers
or other person related to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or the
disclosures on Form ATS-N (e.g., FIX protocol procedures, rules of
engagement/manuals, frequently asked questions, marketing materials).
We received several comments regarding Exhibit 1.\698\ We are not
adopting the proposed Exhibit 1 requirements to Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\698\ See SIFMA Letter at 7; Liquidnet Letter at 8; KCG Letter
at 6; HMA Letter at 11; STANY Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 3; Level
ATS Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters express concerns that the requirements of Exhibit 1 are
broad,\699\ not relevant for purposes of facilitating ATS comparisons
by market participants,\700\ and would require unnecessarily cumbersome
amount of disclosure.\701\ Three commenters express concern about the
requirement to make subscriber materials attached to Form ATS-N as
exhibits public on the grounds that such documents may include
confidential information.\702\ Commenters propose that as an
alternatives to the Exhibit 1 requirements, the Commission could make
exhibits public only when they are responsive to certain categories of
documents made available to users (such as FIX protocol procedures,
rules of engagement, user manuals, frequently asked questions, and
marketing materials) or are required to accurately respond to the
questions on Form ATS-N,\703\ or not make public certain
[[Page 38824]]
information (such as electronic trading protocols or other customer
agreements) and provide other ``proprietary'' information only to
regulators upon request.\704\ Another commenter suggests that rather
than requiring formal amendments to Form ATS-N every time an ATS wishes
to change or enhance marketing materials and similar disclosures, the
Commission should allow an NMS Stock ATS to post the most recent
versions of its marketing materials on its website.\705\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\699\ See SIFMA Letter at 7; Liquidnet Letter at 8; KCG Letter
at 6.
\700\ See KCG Letter at 6.
\701\ See SIFMA Letter at 7.
\702\ See Liquidnet Letter at 8; KCG Letter at 6; Level ATS
Letter at 5. One of these commenters also expresses concern that the
proposed requirement would require disclosure of subscriber
agreements, which are individually negotiated and confidential. See
Level ATS Letter at 5-6. Another one of these commenters is
concerned that NMS Stock ATS operators would limit the amount of
information shared with subscribers in order to avoid sharing that
information with the public and its competitors. See Liquidnet
Letter at 8.
\703\ See Liquidnet Letter at 8.
\704\ See SIFMA Letter at 7-8.
\705\ See UBS Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not adopting the proposed requirement that NMS Stock ATSs
provide a copy of any materials currently provided to subscribers or
other persons related to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or the
disclosures on Form ATS-N. We recognize that some of such materials
could contain proprietary or other information that NMS Stock ATSs
would not wish to make public due to confidentiality or competitive
concerns. With respect to the comments in support of requiring
subscriber materials to be made public,\706\ or in support of a limited
version of the Exhibit 1 requirements,\707\ we believe that Form ATS-N
is designed to elicit meaningful disclosures about how the NMS Stock
ATS operates and the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliate. We believe that the vast amount of
information that would have been contained in the Exhibit 1 materials
will be disclosed in response to the request in Form ATS-N and that no
longer requiring NMS Stock ATSs to produce these materials will reduce
their burden and the potential disclosure of redundant information to
the public.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\706\ See HMA Letter at 12 (supporting the adoption of a revised
Exhibit 1 because it would enhance consistency of information to
subscribers and the public and would be valuable to those seeking to
evaluate NMS Stock ATSs). See infra note 709.
\707\ See KCG Letter at 5-6 (supporting a requirement that
information be made available to all market participants, and not
selectively disclosed, but asserting that as drafted, Exhibit 1 is
overly broad).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that while it does not support a requirement
for public filing of exhibits, it supports requiring these exhibits to
be filed with the Commission.\708\ We are not adopting this suggestion.
As discussed above, the purpose of this rulemaking is to expand the
public transparency of NMS Stock ATSs; providing the proposed Exhibit 1
information to only the Commission would not serve this purpose.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\708\ See Liquidnet Letter at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that to the extent that ATSs would
disclose statistics or data that had been requested by firms to help
with their cost and best execution analysis, such an approach would be
less helpful than a greatly enhanced, comprehensive disclosure for this
information.\709\ The commenter states that this information is
essential. However, this commenter expresses concern that as a
consequence of the Exhibit 1 requirements, NMS Stock ATSs may cease to
provide subscribers with information and statistics to avoid having to
make such information public. This commenter suggests that Exhibit 1 be
revised to include all marketing materials, manuals, and fee
information, but not customized statistics and information, provided
that such statistics and information are otherwise publicly disclosed.
We are not expanding market statistics that NMS Stock ATSs are
currently required to disclose as part of this rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\709\ See HMA Letter at 12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. ATS Governance Structure and Compliance Programs and Controls
In the Proposal, we asked if NMS Stock ATSs should be required to
provide disclosure about their governance structure and compliance
programs and controls to comply with Regulation ATS.\710\ In response,
we received one comment, which states that governance structures are
likely to vary materially among ATSs, and that the Commission's goals
in this area would best be served through the Commission's Office of
Compliance Inspections and Examination's regular examination
efforts.\711\ We did not receive comments supporting a request for such
information. We believe that it is appropriate to take an incremental
approach to this topic and intends to monitor the effectiveness of the
disclosures on adopted Form ATS-N. Should the Commission decide to take
further action with regard to Form ATS-N's disclosure requirements,
including adding requests about NMS Stock ATS governance structure and
compliance programs and controls, the Commission would do so in a
separate rulemaking in the future.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\710\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81041.
\711\ See UBS Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Part II of Form ATS-N: ATS-Related Activities of the Broker-Dealer
Operator and Affiliates
We believe that the interests of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates sometimes compete against the interest of those that use the
ATS's services. These competing interests, at times, may give rise to
conflicts of interests for the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates or the potential for information leakage of subscribers'
confidential trading information. As such, Part II of Form ATS-N is
designed to provide subscribers and market participants with
information about these competing interests, and in doing so, inform
them about: (1) The operation of the NMS Stock ATS--regardless of the
corporate structure of the NMS Stock ATS--and of its broker-dealer
operator, or any arrangements the broker-dealer operator may have made,
whether contractual or otherwise, pertaining to the operation of its
NMS Stock ATS; and (2) ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates that may give rise to conflicts of interest
for the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates or the potential for
information leakage of subscribers' confidential trading information.
Commenters generally support disclosing information about potential
conflicts of interest and information leakage, and we did not receive
any comments opposing the principle that information related to
conflicts of interest or information leakage on an NMS Stock ATS should
be publicly disclosed.\712\ Several commenters, however, state general
concerns that the scope of the requests in Part III of proposed Form
ATS-N is too broad.\713\ A number of commenters believe that the
requests regarding affiliates should be limited to descriptions of how
the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates or business units
directly interact with or affect the operations of the NMS Stock
ATS.\714\ For example, one commenter argues that proposed Form ATS-N
would have required disclosures that are not meaningful to market
participants and could possibly inhibit useful comparison of NMS Stock
ATSs.\715\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\712\ As discussed further below, several commenters suggest how
to refine the specific requests proposed for Part III of Form ATS-N.
\713\ See, e.g., STA Letter at 4; KCG Letter at 8-9; SIFMA
Letter at 4-8; Luminex Letter at 2-3; Fidelity Letter at 5; STANY
Letter at 5; UBS Letter at 6; Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
\714\ See Fidelity Letter at 2 and 4; UBS Letter at 2-4; SIFMA
Letter at 4, 8; Luminex Letter at 3; Markit Letter at 7-8.
\715\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, a commenter argues that the proposed conflicts of
interest requests regarding affiliates of the broker-dealer operator
would have placed a significant burden on multi-service broker-dealers
with a large number of affiliates, sometimes numbering in the
hundreds.\716\ Similarly, another commenter states that an NMS Stock
ATS's broker-dealer operator may not be privy to certain
[[Page 38825]]
information about its affiliates for valid compliance reasons.\717\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\716\ See UBS Letter at 2-5.
\717\ See Fidelity Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As outlined below in more detail--and in response to both these
general commenter concerns and commenter concerns that are more
specific to particular disclosure requests, which are explained below--
we are modifying the conflicts of interest requests to focus on: (1)
The ability of business units or affiliates of the broker-dealer
operator to enter, or direct the entry of, orders into the NMS Stock
ATS and whether such business units or affiliates actually trade on the
NMS Stock ATS; and (2) whether those business units and affiliates that
do trade on the NMS Stock ATS receive any preferential treatment with
respect to the services offered by the NMS Stock ATS.
We continue to believe that disclosures regarding the ATS-related
activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates will help
enable market participants to assess potential conflicts of interest
that may impact their trading on the ATS and assess the potential for
information leakage. At the same time, we also believe that Form ATS-N
should not require public disclosure of activities or affiliate
relationships of the broker-dealer operator that do not relate to the
NMS Stock ATS and thus, do not present a potential conflict of
interest. We believe that the revisions to the proposed disclosure
requests are responsive to commenters' concerns about the scope of the
form's affiliate disclosures.
Furthermore, the burden of responding to the affiliate requests has
been reduced from that which was proposed. First, the adopted affiliate
disclosure requests focus on substantive information about how
affiliated entities interact with the ATS and differences in how the
ATS treats affiliates' orders. As such, frequent updates to Part II for
ministerial or minor administrative changes by the ATS would not
normally be necessary.\718\ To the extent a ministerial or
administrative change affects a disclosure on Form ATS-N in a non-
material way, the NMS Stock ATS would, in most instances, only be
required to file a quarterly updating amendment. Additionally, an NMS
Stock ATS likely already has the necessary information about the
services that it offers affiliates that trade on the ATS because of its
current recordkeeping requirements,\719\ and we believe that
maintaining up-to-date Part II disclosures is justified by the benefit
to market participants from public disclosure of conflicts of interest
information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\718\ Updating amendments for non-material changes may be
required, as appropriate.
\719\ See 17 CFR 242.302.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter expresses concern that the proposed conflicts of
interest requests would seek public disclosure of proprietary or
confidential information that would pose unintended consequences or
security risks to ATS operators.\720\ We are sensitive to concerns
about the burden of providing disclosures of potentially commercially
sensitive information. In response to these commenter concerns, we have
revised the wording of relevant requests to mitigate such concerns or
provided guidance regarding the scope of certain disclosure requests,
as further explained below.\721\ We believe that in the vast majority
of cases, the level of detail required by Form ATS-N should not require
the public disclosure of commercially sensitive information. In the
Proposal, we did not intend to require NMS Stock ATSs to publicly
disclose such information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\720\ See SIFMA Letter at 6, 9.
\721\ For example, in the request under Part II, Item 5 of
adopted Form ATS-N, an NMS Stock ATS is only required to provide a
summary of the terms and conditions for the use of products or
services offered by the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also note that the disclosure requests on Form ATS-N seek
information that the Commission and some commenters believe to be
important to market participants when evaluating an NMS Stock ATS as a
potential trading venue. We believe that the disclosures on adopted
Form ATS-N will provide market participants with information necessary
to evaluate potential conflicts of interest and information leakage
while not requiring NMS Stock ATSs to provide granular details about
aspects of the ATS that it might consider to be commercially sensitive.
Accordingly, to the extent an NMS Stock ATS believes that Form ATS-N
requires the disclosure of what it believes to be commercially
sensitive information, we believe that such disclosure is justified by
the public benefit of the information required on Form ATS-N becoming
publicly available.
On the other hand, one commenter expresses a specific concern that
narrowing the universe of affiliates subject to disclosure could result
in less relevant information being provided to the Commission and the
public, as NMS Stock ATSs could structure their legal affiliations and
operations to take advantage of unanticipated gaps in the rule.\722\
This commenter states that the Commission should draw exemptions for
certain affiliate relationships very narrowly and provide ``bright
lines'' to help ensure that the requirements are clear and unambiguous,
so that ATSs would not be permitted to determine whether to disclose an
affiliate. This commenter also states that it recognizes that
information on certain affiliates required by Form ATS-N may have
little relevance to the Commission's review of the broker-dealer
operator's Form ATS-N.\723\ This commenter believes that rather than
modifying the Proposal, this issue could be addressed by an NMS Stock
ATS seeking relief tailored to its unique facts and circumstances
pursuant to Section 36(a)(1) of the Exchange Act,\724\ which permits
the Commission to grant exemptions from any provision of a rule, to the
extent such exemption is necessary or appropriate in the public
interest and consistent with the protection of investors.\725\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\722\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 8.
\723\ See id. at 9.
\724\ See 15 U.S.C. 78mm(a)(1).
\725\ See Investor Advocate Letter at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We agree with this commenter that Form ATS-N requests regarding the
ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates
should provide clear and unambiguous requirements for NMS Stock ATSs.
We also agree that Form ATS-N should be comprehensive enough to
preclude an NMS Stock ATS from finding ``unanticipated gaps'' in the
language to avoid disclosing critical aspects of its operations. We
believe that the refinements to adopted Form ATS-N, as outlined above
and further explained below, strike the appropriate balance between
providing market participants with relevant information about potential
conflicts of interest information and information leakage and the
burden that Form ATS-N will place on NMS Stock ATSs. We do not believe
that it is necessary to adopt all of the conflicts of interest requests
as proposed and require NMS Stock ATSs to seek exemptive relief from
certain disclosure requirements. Furthermore, the adopted definitions
of ``affiliate'' and ``control'' are intended to encompass all relevant
affiliate relationships between the broker-dealer operator and other
entities that we believe would help market participants' evaluation of
potential conflicts of interest.
1. Broker-Dealer Operator and its Affiliate Trading Activities on the
NMS Stock ATS
a. Proposed Requests and Response to Comments
Part III, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures
[[Page 38826]]
regarding non-ATS trading centers operated or controlled by the NMS
Stock ATS's broker-dealer operator or any of its affiliates. Part III,
Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required disclosures about the
operation of any other NMS Stock ATSs operated by the broker-dealer
operator or any of its affiliates. Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form
ATS-N would have required disclosures regarding the broker-dealer
operator's and its affiliates' trading activity on the NMS Stock ATS.
As discussed above, we received general comments on Part III of
proposed Form ATS-N.\726\ Additionally, we received comments
specifically addressing the requests in Part III, Items 1, 2, and 5, of
proposed Form ATS-N. In this section, we outline and address these more
specific comments not previously outlined above. In Section V.C.1.b.,
we outline how we have consolidated much of the subject matter set
forth in in Part III, Items 1, 2, and 5 of proposed Form ATS-N into
Part II, Items 1 and 2 of adopted Form ATS-N.\727\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\726\ See supra notes 712-715 and accompanying text.
\727\ We also note that because Parts I and II of proposed Form
ATS-N have been consolidated into a single section of adopted Form
ATS-N, the disclosure requests about the ATS-related activities of
the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates on the NMS Stock ATS
are set forth in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
First, in addition to the general comments regarding the scope of
the affiliate disclosure requests that are explained above, some
commenters provide comments specific to proposed Part III, Item 1 and
Part III, Item 5.\728\ One of these commenters states that the scope of
the proposed requests in Part III, Item 1 with regard to non-ATS
trading centers of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates could
have prejudiced commercial strategy.\729\ We believe that a list
containing business units or affiliates of the broker-dealer operator
that do not use the trading services of the NMS Stock ATS would not be
as helpful to market participants as would a list of only those that
trade on, or otherwise use the trading services of, the ATS.\730\
Accordingly, we have revised these disclosures so that Part II, Items
1(a) and 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N ask whether business units of the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates, respectively, are permitted
to enter or direct the entry of orders into the ATS. This disclosure is
designed to inform market participants about whether the ATS permits
the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates to trade on the NMS Stock
ATS. If the ATS permits the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates to
trade on the ATS, the NMS Stock ATS will be required to only list the
business units or affiliates that actually enter or direct the entry of
orders into the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\728\ See STA Letter at 4-5; UBS Letter at 5; SIFMA Letter at
10; LeveL ATS Letter at 4.
\729\ See UBS Letter at 5.
\730\ In the Proposal, the term ``non-ATS trading center'' was a
defined term, but as explained above, adopted Form ATS-N will not
use the term ``non-ATS trading center.'' See supra Section V.A.2.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, with regard to Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-
N, one commenter states that affiliates or business units that
indirectly send orders to an NMS Stock ATS through another entity or
through services provided by another entity are not `enter[ing]' orders
``on the NMS Stock ATS.'' \731\ We believe that if a business unit or
affiliate of the broker-dealer operator enters or directs the entry of
orders into the ATS, market participants would find it useful to know
that they may be trading against those business units, affiliates, or
client orders entered by those entities. For example, if a principal
trading desk of the broker-dealer operator or an affiliate uses a
direct connection to the NMS Stock ATS or the broker-dealer operator's
SOR to submit orders or trading interest into the ATS, the NMS Stock
ATS must list that desk or affiliate on adopted Form ATS-N under Part
II, Item 1(a) or 2(a), respectively. Likewise, if an affiliated asset
manager of the broker-dealer operator uses the services of a third-
party broker-dealer to route directed orders to the NMS Stock ATS
(i.e., the asset manager instructs the third-party broker-dealer to
send its orders to the NMS Stock ATS), the NMS Stock ATS would be
required to list that affiliated asset manager under Item 2(a).
However, if that affiliated asset manager submits orders to a third-
party broker-dealer, and that third-party broker-dealer using its own
discretion, routes the orders of the asset manager into the affiliated
NMS Stock ATS (e.g., the third-party broker-dealer's SOR decides where
to route the affiliated asset manager's orders using its routing
table), the NMS Stock ATS would not be required to list the affiliated
asset manager under Item 2(a); under such circumstances, the affiliate
would not be ``directing'' orders to the ATS because the third-party
broker-dealer is using its discretion to route the affiliate's orders
and thus, not required to be listed under Item 2(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\731\ See UBS Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adopted requests also specify the type of information that must
be provided with regard to business units or affiliates of the broker-
dealer operator. Specifically, Item 1(a) requires the NMS Stock ATS to
name and describe each type of business unit of the broker-dealer
operator that enters or directs the entry of orders and trading
interest into the ATS (e.g., NMS Stock ATS, type of trading desks,
market maker, sales or client desk) and, for each business unit, to
provide the applicable MPID and list the capacity of its orders and
trading interest (e.g., principal, agency, riskless principal). Item
2(a) requires the NMS Stock ATS to name and describe each type of
affiliate that enters or directs the entry of orders and trading
interest into the ATS (e.g., broker-dealers, NMS Stock ATS, investment
company, hedge fund, market maker, principal trading firm) and, for
each of those affiliates, provide the applicable MPID and list the
capacity of its orders and trading interest (e.g., principal, agency,
riskless principal). We believe that market participants will find it
more relevant to know both the types of broker-dealer operator business
units and affiliates that can trade in the NMS Stock ATS, and their
trading activities, rather than, as proposed, having a potentially
voluminous list of entities that might include some that cannot send or
direct orders or trading interest to the ATS.
We also believe that the revised requests will reduce the burden on
NMS Stock ATSs when completing the form because they will only require
the NMS Stock ATS to list entities that trade on the ATS. The narrative
responses to Items 1(a) and 2(a) could typically be kept up-to-date via
Updating Amendments to Form ATS-N, which the ATS could file on a
quarterly basis. However, we also note that in most cases, if the
``yes'' or ``no'' response to Items 1(a) or 2(a) changes (e.g., the NMS
Stock ATS changes its operations to allow affiliates to trade whereas
they could not do so prior, or vice versa), the NMS Stock ATS would be
required to file a material amendment. Accordingly, we believe that the
scope of the requests in Part II, Items 1(a) and 2(a) of adopted Form
ATS-N present a reasonable disclosure requirement for NMS Stock ATSs,
particularly multi-service broker-dealers with many affiliates, without
eliminating the requirements for the NMS Stock ATS to provide
information about the NMS Stock ATS-related trading activities of
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates, which we believe will be
helpful for market participants.
Another commenter recommends that the Commission take a progressive
approach of ``yes'' or ``no'' questioning for disclosures concerning
affiliates of the broker-dealer operators that initially targets
whether the affiliate directly
[[Page 38827]]
routes orders to the NMS Stock ATS.\732\ The commenter recommends that
the Commission require NMS Stock ATSs to state whether the ATS directly
receives any order flow from an affiliated party, and if so, if the
affiliated party is treated exactly the same as every other party with
access to the ATS.\733\ If the ATS answers in the affirmative, the
commenter suggests that the ATS be required to identify the affiliated
parties with access and the procedure for treatment of their orders,
and if the ATS answers in the negative, the ATS would be required to
identify parties with access and specifically articulate differences in
treatment. The disclosure requests in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N are
all structured in a ``yes'' or ``no'' format with follow-on narrative
(as necessary), and we believe that the information this commenter
recommends to be included in Form ATS-N is presented in a format that
resembles that recommendation.\734\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\732\ See Fidelity Letter at 5.
\733\ See id. at 5-6.
\734\ Specifically, Item 2(a) requires the NMS Stock ATS to
answer ``yes'' or ``no'' as to whether affiliates of the broker-
dealer operator are permitted to enter or direct the entry of orders
and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS, and if the answer is
``yes'', the ATS must provide specific information about those
affiliates and the capacity of the orders and trading interest that
the affiliates enter onto the ATS. Item 2(b) then requires the NMS
Stock ATS to answer ``yes'' or ``no'' as to whether the services
that the NMS Stock ATS offers and provides to the affiliates
identified in Item 2(a) are the same for all subscribers, and if the
NMS Stock ATS answers no, it must explain any differences. We also
note that the requests in Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N with
regard to trading activity of the broker-dealer operator on the NMS
Stock ATS follow the same format as that in Item 2 of adopted Form
ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters also opine that terms such as ``describe,''
``any interaction or coordination,'' ``circumstances,'' and ``otherwise
made known'' in the conflicts of interest requests might result in
overbroad or lengthy responses that contain information which would not
be helpful for market participants.\735\ Another commenter cites Part
III, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N as an example of a request that
should be tailored to elicit information based on which ATS users can
make informed decisions.\736\ This commenter states that full-service
broker-dealers often have hundreds of affiliates and business units
that meet the definition of entities that may trade on the subject ATS,
and that keeping such information current and accurate on an ongoing
basis would bring additional burden with very little, if any, benefit
to ATS users; the commenter believes that the request regarding trading
on the ATS by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates should be
focused on whether they receive any preferential or differentiated
treatment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\735\ See KCG Letter at 8-9; STA Letter at 4; SIFMA Letter at
10-11; 14. See also SIFMA Letter at 4, 8.
\736\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to these comments, we are eliminating the terms
``interaction and coordination,'' ``circumstances,'' and ``otherwise
made known'' from these requests to reduce any potential
ambiguity.\737\ The adopted requests are closely tailored to solicit
information that market participants find relevant to evaluating
potential conflicts of interest on an NMS Stock ATS.\738\ Further, both
Part II, Items 1(a) and 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N enumerate the type
of information that an NMS Stock ATS must provide if it answers in the
affirmative that the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates,
respectively, is permitted to trade on the NMS Stock ATS.\739\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\737\ While the terms ``interaction and coordination'' are no
longer used in this disclosure request, many, if not all, Form ATS-N
requests are designed to provide insight into how the broker-dealer
operator, its affiliates, or third-parties interact or coordinate
their activities with the NMS Stock ATS. Two examples of this
include Part II, Items 3 and 5 of adopted Form ATS-N. Part II, Item
3 of adopted Form ATS-N requests specific information about how
subscribers can opt out from interacting with orders of the broker-
dealer operator or its affiliates. Likewise, Item 5 of adopted Form
ATS-N requests specific information about how the ATS interacts with
affiliates by requiring certain disclosures about products and
services offered by the broker-dealer operator.
\738\ Because we are replacing the term ``interaction and
coordination'' with these enumerated points of information, aspects
of the requests set forth in Part III, Items 1(b)(ii)-(iii) and
2(b)(i), (iii) of proposed Form ATS-N--which addressed the
transmission of subscriber orders to other trading centers operated
by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates--are being either
narrowed or eliminated from adopted Part II, Items 1 and 2. As
explained further below, to the extent information that would have
been required by Part III, Items 1(b)(ii)-(iii) and 2(b)(i), (iii)
of proposed Form ATS-N is responsive to Part II, Item 4 of adopted
Form ATS-N--which requests information about the NMS Stock ATS's
arrangements with unaffiliated or affiliated trading centers--the
NMS Stock ATS is required to provide that information in response to
Item 4. See infra Section V.C.3.
\739\ Another commenter suggests that the Commission's goals
would be served more simply by requiring ATSs to categorize and
disclose to their subscribers the nature of a counterparty (i.e.,
agent, principal (including affiliates of the broker-dealer
operator)) rather than using the term ``proprietary'' in the
disclosures regarding trading activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates. See UBS Letter at 6. The commenter
believes that this type of disclosure would succinctly inform a
subscriber about what type of counterparty was on the other side of
a trade. See id. This commenter also notes that in the Proposal, the
Commission discussed disclosures and potential additional
regulations related to ``proprietary trading.'' See id. The
commenter states that federal regulators have encountered challenges
in defining this term as part of the ``Volcker Rule'' under the Dodd
Frank Act. See id. In response to this comment, the Commission has,
in the language of Part II, Items 1 and 2, listed several examples
of the capacity in which the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates enter or direct the entry of orders (principal, agency,
or riskless principal) to provide more guidance about the type of
information sought by Form ATS-N. The Commission has also removed
references to ``proprietary trading'' from Form ATS-N, and the
adopted form's disclosure requirements refer to, when applicable,
``principal trading'' of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, while the term ``describe'' is still used in Items
1(a) and 2(a), we are adding specific examples to each respective
request to better explain the type of description that would necessary,
such as ``NMS Stock ATS,'' ``trading desks,'' ``market maker,''
``sales'' or ``client desk.'' Also, Items 1(b)-(d) and 2(b)-(d)
specifically state that the NMS Stock ATS must explain (1) any
differences between the treatment of those business units or affiliates
of the broker-dealer operator and other subscribers regarding services
offered and provided by the NMS Stock ATS; (2) whether any of those
business units or affiliates of the broker-dealer operator have formal
or informal arrangements with the NMS Stock ATS to provide liquidity to
the NMS Stock ATS; and (3) how orders and trading interest in the NMS
Stock ATS can be routed to a trading center of the broker-dealer
operator or affiliate.\740\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\740\ With regard to the latter two of these items, adopted Form
ATS-N requests that the description be provided in the applicable
Part III item to reduce redundancy on the Form ATS-N, as further
explained below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, a commenter expresses concern that it may not be
privy to some the information that proposed Form ATS-N would have
required.\741\ We note that ATSs are currently obligated to make and
keep records of, among other things, subscribers to the ATS and daily
summaries of trading, including the identity of the parties to the
transactions.\742\ We believe that the specific information sought in
these requests with regard to affiliate trading activity on the ATS in
adopted Form ATS-N should be maintained as part of the ATS's
recordkeeping obligation without the ATS having to breach any
information barriers or other compliance protections. To the extent
that a business unit or affiliate of the broker-dealer operator
triggers a disclosure obligation on Form ATS-N by directing the entry
of orders into the NMS Stock ATS through a third-party broker-dealer,
we believe that the broker-dealer operator should have--or be able to
obtain--such information through appropriate internal compliance
procedures to be responsive to Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\741\ See supra note 717 and accompanying text.
\742\ See 17 CFR 242.302.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38828]]
We have also revised the requests in proposed Form ATS-N to reduce
redundant disclosure requirements. First, Part II, Items 1 and 2 of
adopted Form ATS-N now require the NMS Stock ATS to provide any
narratives about differences in treatment between the broker-dealer
operator, its affiliates, and other subscribers in Part III of the
adopted form, and only cross reference those narratives in Part II (as
opposed to providing a separate, likely redundant narrative in Part
II). Second, Part II, Items 1 and 2 of adopted Form ATS do not require
the NMS Stock ATS to disclose whether subscriber orders or other
trading interest sent to the NMS Stock ATS are displayed or otherwise
made known to a non-ATS trading center or another NMS Stock ATS
operated by the broker-dealer operator or an affiliate.\743\ Rather,
any narrative with regard to order display (including a description
about differences in services) is only required to be set forth in Part
III, Item 15 of adopted Form ATS-N, which contains the order display
requests of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\743\ This information would have been required under Part III,
Item 1(b)(i) and 2(b)(ii) of proposed Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, Part II, Items 1 and 2 of adopted Form ATS-N do not
require the NMS Stock ATS to disclose how the business units and
affiliates of the broker-dealer operator connect to the ATS, such as
through a Financial Information Exchange (``FIX'') protocol.\744\
Rather, any narrative about order entry in the NMS Stock ATS (including
a description about differences in services) is only required by Part
III, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N (Means of Entry). Accordingly, Part
II of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide market participants
with information about how the NMS Stock ATS interacts with the
business units and affiliates of the broker-dealer operator so they can
assess potential conflicts of interest, while minimizing disclosure
requests that would be redundant with those contained in Part III.\745\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\744\ This information would have been required under Part III,
Item 5(c) of proposed Form ATS-N.
\745\ One commenter also recommends limiting the requests
related to order routing from proposed Part III, Item 2 (Multiple
NMS Stock ATS Operations) to the functions of ATS operation, as
distinguished from other algorithmic or routing functions housed
within the broker-dealer operator or an affiliate, which the
commenter states appear to be addressed in Part III, Item 3 of
proposed Form ATS-N, as well as asking what it means to ``remove''
an order. See SIFMA Letter at 11. See infra Section V.D.7. for a
discussion of the required disclosures related to the removal of
trading interest. Furthermore, this commenter recommends that
Commission state whether the ATS operator should distinguish between
parent and child orders for the disclosures related to Part III,
Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N. See id. Adopted Part III, Item 16(b)
requires the NMS Stock ATS to either describe the affirmative
instructions from a subscriber that must be obtained to route
outside of the NMS Stock ATS or, if no instructions are required,
the ATS must explain when orders in the ATS can be routed from the
NMS Stock ATS. If the NMS Stock ATS breaks up a parent order into
child orders or otherwise uses the fact that an order is a parent
order or child order to make routing decisions, such information
must be disclosed under Item 16(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter believes that the information requested under
proposed Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N was too granular,
duplicative of information required by Form BD, and that some of the
prompts (e.g., ``business unit,'' ``describe the circumstances'') were
too open-ended, which could lead to non-standardized responses that
would not be helpful to market participants.\746\ This commenter
recommends: (i) Eliminating proposed Item 5 and replacing the proposed
disclosure requirements with yes/no prompts or short-answer responses
that are more focused or narrowly tailored and (ii) eliminating or
further clarifying and limiting the request for information of
affiliates and business units.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\746\ See SIFMA Letter at 14.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Items 1(a) and 2(a) of adopted Form
ATS-N provide more specificity about the information requested about
the ATS-related activities of business units and affiliates of the
broker-dealer operator by providing examples of what we intend to
solicit from these requests. To the degree that some information
solicited by adopted Form ATS-N is duplicative of information sought on
Form BD, the duplicative information is straightforward for the broker-
dealer to reproduce on Form ATS-N, and we believe that market
participants will derive greater benefit from this information being
disclosed on a single form (Form ATS-N) as opposed to being spread
across multiple forms filed with the Commission.
Similarly, another commenter cites the proposed requirement to
provide the names of specific business units and algorithms that trade
in NMS Stock ATS as an example of requested information that it
believes is unnecessary to risk assessment.\747\ We believe that some
market participants may find it very helpful to know the identities and
number of the broker-dealer operator's business units or affiliates
that trade on the NMS Stock ATS. As indicated by commenters, some
market participants may, for example, view trading on an ATS by a
principal trading desk of the broker-dealer operator as presenting a
potential conflict of interest for the broker-dealer operator, even if
the ATS does not give any preference to the orders from that desk.\748\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\747\ See STANY Letter at 5.
\748\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 7-8; HMA
Letter at 13.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received comments supporting the original requests under
Part III, Items 1, 2, and 5 of proposed Form ATS-N. One commenter
believes that these proposed disclosure requests are essential to
alerting market participants about potentially significant advantages
of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates and to allow market
participants to obtain a reasonable understanding of the conflicts of
interest posed by the broker-dealer operator's or its affiliates'
trading activities on the ATS.\749\ In addition, a commenter states
that the requests under Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N would
help investors better understand the relationship between the NMS Stock
ATS, its broker-dealer operator, and any affiliates.\750\ One commenter
asserts that market participants would want to know the specific
advantages afforded to the ATS operator or its affiliate, and urges the
Commission to adopt proposed Part III, Item 5.\751\ While we have
refined the scope of certain subject matter in response to comment, we
still believe that the disclosure requests in adopted Form ATS-N about
the trading activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates
will allow for a high degree of transparency by capturing information
that these commenters believe is important to market participants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\749\ See HMA Letter at 15-18. Another commenter states its
support for the goal of a fulsome disclosure of circumstances where
subscriber orders or other trading interest could leave an NMS Stock
ATS and be made available to other areas of the broker-dealer
operator. See UBS Letter at 5. The commenter states that market
participants are entitled to know such information, but also states
that the Commission's goal could be achieved through simplified
disclosures. The commenter states that the proposed requirement to
list the non-ATS trading centers controlled by the broker-dealer
operator or its affiliates should only be required if orders are
routed to the NMS Stock ATS from such trading centers or from the
NMS Stock ATS to those trading centers.
\750\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5.
\751\ See HMA Letter at 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter states that it supports the disclosure
of potential trading activity on the NMS Stock ATS by the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates, but asserts that the disclosure
requirement should be revised to allow for a series of progressive
``yes'' or ``no'' responses.\752\ The commenter also notes that as
proposed, it would be difficult for NMS Stock ATSs to maintain this
disclosure on an on-going basis. As is
[[Page 38829]]
explained above, we do not believe that maintaining up-to-date
disclosures regarding the ATS-related trading activities of the broker-
dealer operator and its affiliates will impose an unreasonable
administrative burden on the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\752\ See KCG Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Adopted Part II, Item 1 and 2 of Form ATS-N; ATS-Related Trading
Activities of the Broker-Dealer Operator and its Affiliates
As noted above, we reorganized and relocated the subject matter
requested in Part III, Items 1, 2, and 5 of proposed Form ATS-N to Part
II, Items 1 (``Broker-Dealer Operator ATS Trading Activities'') and 2
(``Affiliates ATS Trading Activities'') of adopted Form ATS-N. We have
also revised the content of the proposed disclosure requests in
response to public comment.\753\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\753\ The subject matter covered in Part III, Item 5.d of
proposed Form ATS is now addressed in Part II Item 3 of adopted Form
ATS-N. See infra Section V.C.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requires the NMS Stock ATS
to disclose whether business units of the Broker-Dealer Operator are
permitted to enter or direct the entry of orders and trading interest
(e.g., quotes, conditional orders, or indications of interest) into the
NMS Stock ATS. This request will be in the form of a ``yes'' or ``no''
question, and if the NMS Stock ATS answers ``yes,'' it will be required
to name and describe each type of business unit of the Broker-Dealer
Operator that enters or directs the entry of orders and trading
interest into the ATS (e.g., NMS Stock ATS, type of trading desks,
market maker, sales or client desk) and, for each type of business
unit, it must provide the applicable MPID and list the capacity of its
orders or trading interest (e.g., principal, agency, riskless
principal). This request is designed to encompass the information
request in Part III, Items 5(a) and (b) of proposed Form ATS-N and
capture elements of Part III Items 1(a) and (b) and Items 2(a) and (b)
of proposed Form ATS-N.
The subject matter covered by Part III, Item 1(b)(i) and (ii) is no
longer included in the disclosure request contained in Part II, Item 1
of adopted Form ATS-N.\754\ Likewise, the subject matter covered by
Part III, Item 2(b)(i) and (ii) is no longer included in the disclosure
request contained in Part II, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N.\755\ Part
II, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N focuses on the trading activity of the
broker-dealer operator in the NMS Stock ATS, so those proposed
disclosure requests are outside the scope of adopted Part II, Item 1.
However, to the extent that information about the subjects in those
proposed disclosure requests are responsive to other disclosure
requests in adopted Form ATS-N--such as Part II, Item 3 (``Arrangements
With Trading Centers) and Part III, Item 15 (``Display'')--the NMS
Stock ATS must respond to those items accordingly.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\754\ These proposed requests would have required disclosures
regarding the display of subscriber orders to a non-ATS trading
center operated by the broker-dealer operator (proposed Part III,
Item 1(b)(i)) and the execution of subscriber orders in a non-ATS
trading center operated by the broker-dealer operator (proposed Part
III, Item 1(b)(ii)), respectively.
\755\ These proposed requests would have required disclosures
about sending subscriber orders to another NMS Stock ATS operated by
the broker-dealer operator in lieu of the NMS Stock ATS filing the
form (proposed Part III, Item 2(b)(i)) and the display of subscriber
orders to another NMS Stock ATS operated by the broker-dealer
operator (proposed Part III, Item 2(b)(ii)), respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Next, Part II, Item 1(b) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose whether the services that the NMS Stock ATS
offers and provides to the business units required to be identified in
Item 1(a) are the same for all subscribers. This request will be in the
form of a ``yes'' or ``no'' question, and if the NMS Stock ATS answers
``no,'' it will be required to explain any differences in response to
the applicable Item number(s) in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N and
list the applicable Item number(s). If there are differences that are
not applicable to Part III of adopted Form ATS-N, the NMS Stock ATS
must explain those differences in detail under Part II, Item 1.
Next, Part II, Item 1(c) of adopted Form ATS-N requires NMS Stock
ATSs to disclose the broker-dealer operator's role as a liquidity
provider on the NMS Stock ATS, if applicable.\756\ This item requires
the NMS Stock ATS to disclose--in the form of a ``yes'' or ``no''
question--whether there are any formal or informal arrangements with
any of the sources of orders or trading interest of the broker-dealer
operator identified in Item 1(a) to provide orders or other trading
interest to the NMS Stock ATS (e.g., undertaking to buy or sell
continuously, or to meet specified thresholds of trading or quoting
activity). If the NMS Stock ATS answers ``yes,'' it must identify the
business unit(s) and respond to the request in Part III, Item 12, which
sets forth the requests for liquidity providers on the NMS Stock
ATS.\757\ We believe that highlighting, in Part II of adopted Form ATS-
N, whether the broker-dealer operator acts as a liquidity provider on
the NMS Stock ATS will be helpful to market participants when
evaluating the potential for conflicts of interest or information
leakage on the trading platform. However, to reduce duplicative
requests on adopted Form ATS-N, we are not requiring the NMS Stock ATS
to provide a narrative in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N regarding the
broker-dealer operator's liquidity provider activities because that
information will be disclosed under Part III, Item 12 of adopted Form
ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\756\ The requirement to disclose liquidity providers and the
terms and condition of any arrangements with liquidity providers was
set forth under Part IV, Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N.
\757\ See infra Section V.D.12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, Part II, Item 1(d) of adopted Form ATS-N requires the NMS
Stock ATSs to disclose information about the routing of orders and
trading interest to trading centers operated or controlled by the
broker-dealer operator. This Item will require the NMS Stock ATS to
disclose--in the form of a ``yes'' or ``no'' question--whether orders
and trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS can be routed to a trading
center of the broker-dealer operator. If the NMS Stock ATS answers
``yes,'' it must respond to the requests in Part III, Item 16 of
adopted Form ATS-N, which sets forth the requests for disclosures about
routing orders and trading interest out of the NMS Stock ATS. We
continue to believe that disclosures regarding the routing of orders
will provide subscribers with information about how their orders would
be handled if they are not executed on the ATS and allow them to assess
whether such routing could result in the leakage of confidential
information, particularly if those orders are being routed to a trading
center of the broker-dealer operator. Similar to Part II, Item 1(c) of
adopted Form ATS-N, the request in Part II, Item 1(d) will not require
a narrative because Part IV, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N requires
disclosures about routing.\758\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\758\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS
to disclose whether affiliates of the broker-dealer operator are
permitted to enter or direct the entry of orders and trading interest
into the NMS Stock ATS. This request will be in the form of a ``yes''
or ``no'' question, and if the NMS Stock ATS answers ``yes,'' it must
name and describe each type of affiliate that enters or directs the
entry of orders and trading interest in the ATS (e.g., broker-dealers,
NMS Stock ATS, mutual fund, hedge fund, market maker) and, for each
affiliate that trades on the NMS Stock ATS, the NMS Stock ATS must
provide the applicable MPID and list the capacity(ies) of its orders
and trading interest (e.g., principal, agency, riskless
[[Page 38830]]
principal). As with Item 1, these requests are designed to encompass
the information that would have been required under Part III, Items
5(a) and (b) of proposed Form ATS-N and is designed to capture elements
of Part III Item 1(a) and Item 2(a) of proposed Form ATS-N.\759\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\759\ Also like Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N, Item
2(a) does not contain the subject matter covered by Part III, Item
1(b)(i) and (ii) and Part III, Item 2(b)(i) and (ii) of proposed
Form ATS-N, but to the extent that information about the subjects in
those proposed requests are responsive to other requests in adopted
Form ATS-N, the NMS Stock ATS must respond to those items
accordingly.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Next, Part II, Item 2(b) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose whether the services that the NMS Stock ATS
offers and provides to the affiliates required to be identified in Item
2(a) are the same for all subscribers. This request is in the form of a
``yes'' or ``no'' question, and if the NMS Stock ATS answers ``no,'' it
will be required to explain any differences in response to the
applicable Item number(s) in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N, as
required, and list the applicable Item number(s). If there are
differences that are not applicable to Part III of adopted Form ATS-N,
the NMS Stock ATS must explain those differences in detail under Part
II, Item 2.\760\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\760\ We have incorporated the requests of proposed Part III,
Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N into individual Part II requests in
adopted Form ATS-N, and thus, there is no longer a stand-alone
question addressing differences among the services provided to the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates and other subscribers. See
supra Section V.C.7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part II, Item 2(c) of adopted Form ATS-N requests information about
the role of the broker-dealer operator's affiliates as liquidity
providers on the NMS Stock ATS, if applicable. This item requires the
NMS Stock ATS to disclose--in the form of a ``yes'' or ``no''
question--whether there are there any formal or informal arrangements
with affiliates of the broker-dealer operator identified in Item 2(a)
to provide orders or other trading interest to the NMS Stock ATS (e.g.,
undertaking to buy or sell continuously, or to meet specified
thresholds of trading or quoting activity). If the NMS Stock ATS
answers ``yes,'' it must identify the affiliates and respond to the
request in Part III, Item 12, which sets forth the required disclosures
for liquidity providers on the NMS Stock ATS.
Finally, Part II, Item 2(d) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose information about routing orders and trading
interest out of the NMS Stock ATS to a trading center operated and
controlled by affiliates of the broker-dealer operator. This item will
require the NMS Stock ATS to disclose--in the form of a ``yes'' or
``no'' question--whether orders and trading interest in the NMS Stock
ATS can be routed to a trading center operated or controlled by an
affiliate of the broker-dealer operator. If the NMS Stock ATS answers
``yes,'' it must respond to request in Part III, Item 16, which sets
forth the required disclosures for routing orders and trading interest
out of the NMS Stock ATS.
2. Order Interaction With Broker-Dealer Operator; Affiliates
Part II, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N requests information about
the interaction of orders of between unaffiliated subscribers to the
ATS and orders of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates in the
NMS Stock ATS. Part II, Item 3(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose whether a subscriber can opt out of interacting
with orders and trading interest of the broker-dealer operator in the
NMS Stock ATS, and Part II, Item 3(b) requires an NMS Stock ATS to
disclose whether a subscriber can opt out of interacting with the
orders and trading interest of an affiliate of the broker-dealer
operator in the NMS Stock ATS.\761\ Part II, Item 3(c) of adopted Form
ATS-N requires the NMS Stock ATS to disclose whether the terms and
conditions of the opt-out processes for the broker-dealer operator and
affiliates required to be identified in Items 3(a) and (b) are the same
for all subscribers. The content of these requests are intended to
cover the subject matter contained in Part III, Item 5(d) of proposed
Form ATS-N.\762\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\761\ For example, if a broker-dealer operator uses its SOR or
algorithms to submit subscriber orders into the ATS, any steps that
either the broker-dealer operator or the subscriber would have to
take so that those orders are opted-out of trading with the broker-
dealer operator or its affiliates would be required disclosures
under Items 3(a) and 3(b), respectively.
\762\ Part III, Item 5(d) of proposed Form ATS-N would have
required the NMS Stock ATS to describe any means by which a
subscriber can be excluded from interacting or trading with orders
or other trading interest of the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates on the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that is helpful to market participants for the subject
matter covered by proposed Part III, Item 5(d) to be a stand-alone
question in adopted Form ATS-N. Such information is important to
unaffiliated market participants trading on an ATS because some
unaffiliated subscribers may not wish to interact with the order flow
of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates. This disclosure will
help market participants understand whether and how they may avoid
trading with the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates should they
elect to use the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
As explained above, we received several comments about the proposed
requests addressing ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates, including the request set forth in Part
III, Item 5. In addition to these comments, one commenter opines that
if a subscriber desires to opt out of trading with the broker-dealer
operator's principal orders, the broker-dealer operator should be
obliged to follow and implement the stated instruction.\763\ This
rulemaking addresses enhanced disclosure requirements for NMS Stock
ATSs, and not regulations to require certain actions by NMS Stock ATSs
outside of the disclosures and other requirements specifically
enumerated herein.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\763\ See UBS Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Arrangements With Trading Centers
Part III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N requested disclosures about
arrangements the broker-dealer operator, or any of its affiliates, has
with unaffiliated trading centers. The subject matter covered in Part
III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N is under Part II, Item 4 of adopted
Form ATS-N.
The Commission received several comments regarding disclosure
requests about arrangements with unaffiliated trading centers. Three
commenters support the public disclosure of preferential arrangements
with third parties.\764\ One of these commenters, while supporting the
disclosure of preferential arrangements in principle, believes the
requests in Part III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N could be too
exhaustive and should be narrowed to focus on preferential
arrangements.\765\ Similarly, another commenter believes the central
concern around affiliate relationships should focus on whether a third-
party entity has differentiated or unique access to an ATS.\766\
Another commenter believes that the broker-dealer operators of NMS
Stock ATSs should not be required to provide proprietary information to
the public under this disclosure, stating that in instances where SORs
operate outside of the NMS Stock ATS and make routing decisions
independent of the NMS Stock ATS, the appropriate source of information
sought by the Commission
[[Page 38831]]
is the operator of the SOR, not the operator of the NMS Stock ATS.\767\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\764\ See HMA Letter at 16; UBS Letter at 5; SIFMA Letter at 13.
\765\ See SIFMA Letter at 13.
\766\ See UBS Letter at 5.
\767\ See STANY Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have not limited the disclosures required under adopted Part II,
Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N to preferential arrangements or other
unique access given to unaffiliated third parties, as suggested by
these commenters. We believe that some market participants may consider
other arrangements with third parties relevant to their evaluations of
an NMS Stock ATS as a potential trading venue. For example, if an NMS
Stock ATS has a mutual access agreement with another ATS, a market
participant may take into account the fact that its order may
eventually route to another ATS, even if orders from the other ATS do
not receive preferential treatment on the ATS.
The disclosure requests in Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N
will provide market participants with information necessary to evaluate
potential conflicts of interest or sources of information leakage. For
example, Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N requires the disclosure
of an arrangement between the NMS Stock ATS and an unaffiliated NMS
Stock ATS under which the NMS Stock ATS would route orders or other
trading interest to the unaffiliated NMS Stock ATS for possible
execution before routing to any other destination. By way of further
example, Item 4 also requires disclosure of an arrangement pursuant to
which any subscriber orders routed out of the unaffiliated NMS Stock
ATS would be routed first to the NMS Stock ATS before any other trading
center; it also requires a summary of the terms and conditions of the
arrangement such as, for example, whether the NMS Stock ATS is
providing monetary compensation or some other brokerage service to the
unaffiliated NMS Stock ATS.
In response to the above commenter concerns, however, Part II, Item
4 of adopted Form ATS-N includes some modifications. First, the adopted
disclosure request in Part II, Item 4 replaces the proposed phrase
``describe the terms of the arrangement'' with the phrase ``provide a
summary of the terms and conditions of the arrangement.'' We believe
that replacing the term ``describe'' with a requirement to ``provide a
summary'' will make it clear that the scope of the adopted request
should not typically require the NMS Stock ATS to provide granular
details about its arrangements that the ATS might consider to be
commercially sensitive.
Second, Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N does not use the
phrase ``person(s), or affiliate(s) of such person(s) that operates a
trading center'' when establishing the scope of the request, as was
proposed. Rather, the adopted request focuses on arrangements with
trading centers themselves. One commenter argues that to the extent a
third-party entity solely has access to functionality disclosed
elsewhere in proposed Form ATS-N, proposed Part III, Item 4 would not
be necessary.\768\ We did not intend for the proposed request to
encompass, for example, a subscriber agreement between a third-party
broker-dealer, who happens to also operate a trading center, and the
NMS Stock ATS under which the third-party broker-dealer submits orders
to the ATS in the same manner as all other subscribers. Rather, the
purpose of the request in Part II, Item 4 is to publicly disclose any
arrangement with another trading center that may be relevant to a
conflicts of interest analysis, such as one under which the NMS Stock
ATS and a third-party NMS Stock ATS send their respective subscriber
orders to one another.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\768\ See UBS Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, we are including in Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form
ATS-N examples of the types of arrangements that would be responsive to
the disclosure request, such as mutual or reciprocal access
arrangements \769\ and preferential access arrangements \770\ to
clarify that the disclosures required by Part II, Item 4 of adopted
Form ATS are not so broad as to require the NMS Stock ATS to list each
unaffiliated subscriber that accesses its system. We are also revising
the request in Part III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N to only require
disclosures about arrangements with trading centers to access the NMS
Stock ATS's services in adopted Form ATS-N. For example, an NMS Stock
ATS must provide details about how it disseminates orders or trading
interest submitted by a trading center under a unique arrangement with
that trading center such a reciprocal access agreement; these types of
arrangements would typically be different than the ATS's standard
contract with subscribers to access the services of the ATS. We believe
that this change will better define the scope of information responsive
to the Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N while not removing any
proposed disclosure requirements.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\769\ Mutual or reciprocal access arrangements may be, for
example, an NMS Stock ATS that allows another broker-dealer operator
to access its ATS for liquidity in return for the ability to access
the liquidity of the other broker-dealer's ATS.
\770\ Preferential routing arrangements may be, for example, an
NMS Stock ATS being the first routing destination on the routing
table of a third party's algorithm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Likewise, the Commission is modifying the wording of the proposed
disclosure requests to require the NMS Stock ATS to disclose formal or
informal arrangements for a trading center ``to access the NMS Stock
ATS services.'' Adding the word ``services'' clarifies that the
disclosure must explain the services provided to the unaffiliated
trading center after it connects to the ATS. An NMS Stock ATS can
provide various types of services to subscribers and the request, as
revised, is tailored for those ATSs services that a subscriber may use.
Next, the scope of Part III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N only
encompassed arrangements with unaffiliated trading centers, but Part
II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N encompasses arrangements with both
unaffiliated and affiliated trading centers. As explained above, the
requests set forth in Part III, Items 1(b)(ii)-(iii) and 2(b)(i), (iii)
of proposed Form ATS-N--which addressed the transmission of subscriber
orders to other trading centers operator by the broker-dealer operator
or its affiliates--have either been narrowed or eliminated from Part
II, Items 1 and 2 of adopted Form ATS-N. However, to the extent that an
NMS Stock ATS has an arrangement with a trading center operated by the
broker-dealer operator or an affiliate, we believe that market
participants are still likely to consider information about such
arrangements relevant to their evaluation of an NMS Stock ATS as a
potential trading venue and such an arrangement may raise concerns
about conflicts of interest or information leakage.\771\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\771\ For example, a potential conflict of interest could arise
where an NMS Stock ATS has a preferred routing arrangement with an
affiliated, non-ATS trading center wherein all orders sent to the
NMS Stock ATS would first be routed to the affiliated, non-ATS
trading center before entering the NMS Stock ATS in exchange for
monetary compensation. Such an arrangement could also pose a risk of
information leakage because the non-ATS trading center would know
that any unexecuted orders would then be routed to the NMS Stock
ATS. Alternatively, if an arrangement between the NMS Stock ATS and
affiliated trading center provides that any subscriber orders routed
out of the NMS Stock ATS would be first routed to the affiliated,
non-ATS trading center, the NMS Stock ATS may have an incentive to
remove subscribers' orders from the NMS Stock ATS and allow the
affiliated non-ATS trading center the opportunity to execute those
orders.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, Part III, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N would also
have required the disclosure of mutual access arrangements between an
NMS Stock
[[Page 38832]]
ATS and other trading centers whereby, for example, a broker-dealer
operator, or its affiliate, may offer access to the broker-dealer
operator's NMS Stock ATS in exchange for access to another NMS Stock
ATS of operated by another broker-dealer. Accordingly, Part II, Item 4
of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to inform subscribers about these
arrangements as such information may impact a subscriber's experience
on the NMS Stock ATS and allow them to evaluate potential conflicts of
interest of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.\772\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\772\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81049. Furthermore, as
discussed in the Proposal, an NMS Stock ATS would not be prohibited
from establishing arrangements with other trading centers, provided
that such arrangements comply with other applicable laws and rules,
including applicable federal securities laws and Regulation ATS. A
broker-dealer operator may have valid business reasons for it or its
affiliates to have formal or informal arrangements with an
unaffiliated person(s), or affiliate(s) of such person that operates
a trading center regarding access to the NMS Stock ATS. See id. at
81049, n.401.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, in Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N, the Commission
has divided the request into two subparts--one subpart addressing the
broker-dealer operator's arrangements, and another subpart addressing
its affiliates' arrangements. This is a technical edit so that the
format of Part II, Item 4 of Form ATS-N is consistent with the format
of Part II, Items 1-3 above.
4. Other Products and Services
Part III, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about products and services offered to subscribers used in
connection with trading on the NMS Stock ATS. We are adopting Part III,
Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N as Part II, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N;
however, we are modifying the proposed disclosure request in response
to commenter concerns.
One commenter states that the proposed requests would have helped
investment funds assess an NMS Stock ATS as a potential execution venue
by improving their ability to understand all functionality offered by
the broker-dealer operator and whether the broker-dealer operator makes
all services available in a fair and impartial manner.\773\ Some
commenters, while not opposing the general category of disclosure
requested in proposed Part III, Item 3, believe the scope of the
requests regarding products and services should be narrowed.\774\ One
commenter agrees with the Commission's approach, but states that the
disclosure requirement should be refined to cover products or services
used in connection with trading NMS stocks, not just trading on the NMS
Stock ATS.\775\ Another commenter believes that distinct products and
services provided by an affiliate of the broker-dealer operator to a
client--who happens to be an ATS subscriber--but which are not directly
linked to the ATS subscription should not be captured by this
requirement, particularly, when the client/subscriber ultimately may or
may not use those services to trade on the ATS.\776\ Another commenter
suggests only requiring an ATS to list or outline broad categories of
products or services rather than requiring the NMS Stock ATS to
``describe'' its products or services.\777\ Another commenter states
that each relationship and customer experience is different and free-
standing in certain respects, and believes that the proposed request
would potentially require the disclosure of a whole array of products
or services, the enumeration of which would add little value and be
burdensome to maintain/update.\778\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\773\ See ICI Letter at 7.
\774\ See HMA Letter at 16; KCG Letter at 9; SIFMA Letter at 11-
13; UBS Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 4.
\775\ See HMA Letter at 16.
\776\ See KCG Letter at 9. The commenter states that, in many
cases, an ATS operator may be unaware of products and services
separately provided by an affiliate to a customer that are entirely
independent from and may pre-exist the client's ATS subscription.
See id.
\777\ See SIFMA Letter at 12.
\778\ See UBS Letter at 5. The commenter also states that a
forced public listing of a broker-dealer's products and services may
be inconsistent with the broker-dealer's traditional approach and
preferences for marketing. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Broker-dealer operators of NMS Stock ATSs may, directly or
indirectly through an affiliate, offer products or services to
subscribers for the purpose of, for example, submitting orders, or
receiving information about displayed interest, in the ATS.\779\ We
continue to believe that subscribers would want to know the products or
services that the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates may offer
for the purpose of effecting transactions, or submitting,
disseminating, or displaying orders and trading interest on the NMS
Stock ATS because such products or services may impact the subscribers'
access to, or trading on, the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\779\ See Proposal, supra note 2 at 81048. For example, if a
subscriber purchases a service offered by the broker-dealer operator
of an NMS Stock ATS, the broker-dealer operator might also provide
that subscriber more favorable terms for its use of the NMS Stock
ATS than other subscribers who do not purchase the service. Such
favorable terms could include fee discounts or access to a faster
connection to the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We note that many broker-dealer operators are multi-service broker-
dealers and provide routing and execution services in NMS stocks
separate from their ATS services. We further note that customers of a
broker-dealer operator could be both subscribers to its ATS and
customers of the broker-dealer operator that use trading products and
services outside of the ATS. To the extent that a customer is a
subscriber to the NMS Stock ATS and is offered use of products and
services by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliate for the purpose
of effecting transactions or submitting, disseminating, or displaying
orders and trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS, Part II, Item 5 of
adopted Form ATS-N would require disclosures about those products or
services. However, the adopted requests in Part II, Item 5 would not
encompass trading products or services offered by the broker-dealer
operator to customers that are not for the purpose of effecting
transactions or submitting, disseminating, or displaying orders and
trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS.
Two commenters express opinions about how the scope of the proposed
requests relate to the scope of an NMS Stock ATS's operations. One
commenter states that the Proposal does not draw sufficient distinction
between the operations of the NMS Stock ATS and other products and
services of the broker-dealer operator, including agency execution
services, market making and algorithms.\780\ Another commenter states
that the Commission should clarify the terminology used in this item
because it appears to conflate the NMS Stock ATS itself with routing
and algorithmic functions.\781\ Whether a product or service is part of
the ATS requires a facts and circumstances analysis. Based on
Commission experience, broker-dealers generally offer various products
and services to customers, which include execution and routing
services, such as a SOR. These products and services are generally
independent of each other, and how such products and services may be
used by a subscriber to an NMS Stock ATS varies. However, to the extent
that a SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm performs a function
of the ATS by bringing together the orders for securities of multiple
buyers and sellers using established nondiscretionary methods, the SOR
(or similar functionality) or algorithm may be part of the NMS Stock
ATS.\782\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\780\ See STANY Letter at 4.
\781\ See SIFMA Letter at 12-13.
\782\ For a further discussion about when a broker-dealer
operator's SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm may operate
as part of its NMS Stock ATS, see Section V.D.5 below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that Form ATS-N should only require
disclosure
[[Page 38833]]
of products or services at a high level and that commercially sensitive
or proprietary information should not be required to be publicly
disclosed.\783\ As noted above, we are sensitive to concerns about the
potential disclosure of commercially sensitive information. The
proposed request stated that NMS Stock ATSs must ``[d]escribe the
products or services.'' To address commenter concerns regarding the
potential disclosure of commercially sensitive information in this
disclosure request, the adopted disclosure request requires the NMS
Stock ATS to provide only a summary of the terms and conditions for the
products and services disclosed and to explain how the product or
service is used with the ATS in the applicable Item number in Part III
of adopted Form ATS-N. As explained above, we believe that requiring
only a summary narrative would normally not require the broker-dealer
operator to disclose commercially sensitive information.\784\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\783\ See STANY Letter at 4.
\784\ We note that, as part of our review of Form ATS-N
responses, we intend to monitor the level of summary information
provided on the form for completeness to help ensure that such
information is responsive to the form and is not designed to avoid
meaningful disclosure.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To reduce redundancy and streamline disclosures, we are requiring
NMS Stock ATSs to provide a narrative explaining the use of the product
or service required to be disclosed in Part II, Item 5 in the relevant
item in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N. We are also adding to Part II,
Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N the language ``for the purpose of'' before
effecting transactions, or submitting, disseminating, or displaying
orders and trading interest on the NMS Stock ATS to make clear that
this Item requests information about those products or services offered
by the broker-dealer operator or its affiliate that have a nexus to the
ATS services. We believe that the disclosure requests in Part III of
adopted Form ATS-N are limited to information that we believe is
necessary for market participants to understand the operation of the
ATS, without requiring a level of detail that would normally require
the disclosure of commercially sensitive information.
In summary, we are modifying the proposed requests being adopted as
Part II, Item 5 of Form ATS-N to clarify that the NMS Stock ATS is only
required to provide information about products and services offered to
subscribers for the purpose of effecting transactions, or submitting,
disseminating, or displaying orders and trading interest on the NMS
Stock ATS. Specifically, we have modified the proposed language to
state that the broker-dealer operator must disclose any products or
services offered to subscribers for the purpose of effecting
transactions or for submitting, disseminating, or displaying orders and
trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS (e.g., algorithmic trading
products that send orders to the ATS, order management or order
execution systems and market data feeds). We believe that this language
makes a sufficient distinction between products and services that
relate to the functions of the ATS and those that do not; disclosures
about the latter would not be required.\785\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\785\ The revised wording for this request also provides
examples of the types of services that would be encompassed by this
question, such as algorithmic trading products that send orders to
the ATS, order management or order execution systems, and market
data feeds.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we have divided the disclosure requests into four
subparts: (i) One subpart addresses the products or services that the
broker-dealer operator offers to subscribers for the purpose of
effecting transactions or for submitting, disseminating, or displaying
orders and trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS; (ii) another subpart
addresses products or services that the broker-dealer operator's
affiliates offer to subscribers for the purpose of effecting
transactions or for submitting, disseminating, or displaying orders and
trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS; and (iii) the other two subparts
address any differences between the terms and conditions of the
services or products required to be identified in Item 5 among the
broker-dealer operator, affiliates, and unaffiliated subscribers.\786\
This is a technical edit to the proposed disclosures so that the format
of Part II, Item 5 is consistent with the format of Part II, Items 1-4
above.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\786\ For example, if a broker-dealer operator offers
subscribers alternative algorithms to handle orders, including
sending such order to the NMS Stock ATS, and there is a difference
in the speed or latency in which each of the alternatives transmits
information, such differences in speed or latency would need to be
disclosed in Part II, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Activities of Service Providers
a. Shared Employees
Part III, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about employees of the broker-dealer operator that service
the operations of the NMS Stock ATS and also service other business
units of the broker-dealer operator or any of its affiliates (``shared
employees''). We received several comments on Part III, Item 7 of
proposed Form ATS-N. We are adopting Part III, Item 7 of proposed Form
ATS-N with modifications in response to commenters' concerns, as
further explained below, and we are also renumbering Part III, Items 7
of proposed Form ATS-N as Part II, Item 6(a) of adopted Form ATS-N.
One commenter recommends eliminating the requests related to shared
employees because the commenter believes that keeping the item up-to-
date would be too burdensome and unnecessary as employee roles and
responsibility shift periodically.\787\ Similarly, another commenter
believes that while accountability for the safeguarding of customer
information is essential, the commenter is uncertain as to why the
disclosures regarding shared employees under Part III, Item 7 of
proposed Form ATS-N need to be public, particularly in light of the
proposal's other reforms regarding the safeguarding of customers'
confidential information.\788\ We continue to believe that disclosures
about shared employees with access to confidential trading information
from the NMS Stock ATS would help market participants evaluate
circumstances under which a conflict of interest may arise for the NMS
Stock ATS or when there is the potential for information leakage
involving shared employees. For example, we believe that market
participants would likely want to know if an employee of the broker-
dealer operator that is responsible for the operations of a system
containing confidential subscriber trading information from the NMS
Stock ATS is also responsible for supporting the principal trading
activity of the broker-dealer operator. As discussed further below,
however, we are modifying the proposed request about shared employees
on Form ATS-N to more narrowly tailor the request in response to
comments, which should reduce the proposed reporting burden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\787\ See SIFMA Letter at 16.
\788\ See HMA Letter at 17.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters believe that the Commission should narrow the scope
of the shared employee request to shared employees who may have access
to or knowledge of confidential subscriber information or orders.\789\
One commenter states that market participants would need to dedicate
resources to determine which employees actually could pose risks of
information leakage without limiting the disclosure in this
manner.\790\ Another commenter also opines that it would be more useful
to limit the information
[[Page 38834]]
about shared employees to those with access to confidential
information.\791\ We acknowledge that for some broker-dealer
operators--particularly multi-service broker-dealers for which the NMS
Stock ATS is one of many business units--some employees provide purely
administrative services or other support services to multiple business
units that would not make them privy to confidential subscriber trading
information of the NMS Stock ATS. In response to these comments, the
adopted request requires disclosures only about shared employees with
access to confidential trading information on the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\789\ See ICI Letter at 5-6; STANY Letter at 4.
\790\ See ICI Letter at 5-6.
\791\ See STANY Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, some commenters state that information about shared
employees should not contain certain personal information about the
employee, such as the employees name, title, or position.\792\ Several
of these commenters believe that such public disclosures would provide
little benefit to market participants because, for example, titles
change frequently, lack standard meaning across firms and businesses,
and do not provide meaningful information about potential information
leakage on the ATS.\793\ In response to these comments, we have
eliminated the requirement that the NMS Stock ATS identify the name and
position or title of shared employees because we agree that any benefit
to providing personally identifiable information about shared employees
would not be justified by the potential negative effects to the
individual whose personally identifiable information has been posted.
We also agree that such information could become stale or change
frequently, resulting in an increased burden on NMS Stock ATSs to keep
that information up-to-date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\792\ See ICI Letter at 5-6; STANY Letter at 4-5; Liquidnet
Letter at 9; STANY Letter at 4-5; UBS Letter at 6.
\793\ See ICI Letter at 5-6; STANY Letter at 4-5; UBS Letter at
6-7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One of the above commenters also states that, while it supports
disclosure to the Commission of relevant information concerning
individuals responsible for ATS functions, it believes that the request
concerning shared employees should be limited to ``categories of
service'' as opposed to individual positions and titles.\794\ As
explained above, we have removed the proposed requirement that the
disclosures regarding shared employees contain the name and position or
title of all shared employees, and Form ATS-N only requires a summary
of the role and responsibilities of a shared employee that has access
to confidential trading information.\795\ While these changes reduce
the proposed burden on filers, disclosures responsive to Part II, Item
6(a) of adopted Form ATS-N should also provide market participants with
sufficient information to evaluate whether a shared employee's role
with the NMS Stock ATS may create a potential for information leakage.
We do not believe that market participants would benefit from even
broader, or more general, disclosures, such as ``categories of
service'' for shared employees because such information would likely
not provide market participants with relevant information to assess the
potential for information leakage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\794\ See UBS Letter at 6.
\795\ As guidance for this request, the summary of the shared
employees' role and responsibilities generally should include
sufficient detail to provide market participants with a
comprehensive understanding of the full range of the shared
employee's responsibilities with the NMS Stock ATS and each relevant
entity, including responsibilities that could enable the employee to
view confidential trading information of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters express support for Part III, Item 7 of proposed
Form ATS-N by noting that current Form ATS Exhibit E calls for the
disclosure of other entities relevant to the operation of the ATS,
which the commenters believe would be helpful in determining whether
there are apparent conflicts of interest that could come into play in
terms of how orders are executed in the ATS.\796\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\796\ See Luminex Letter at 2; see also PDQ Letter at 1
(agreeing with Luminex's letter).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter recommends that the Commission ensure that the
requests provide meaningful narrative information about the role and
duties of each shared employee, both at the NMS Stock ATS and the other
business unit or affiliate of the broker-dealer operator.\797\ This
commenter states that, to better equip funds and other market
participants to assess the roles and expertise of shared employees, an
NMS Stock ATS should also disclose whether any shared employees are
registered with the Commission or the Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority and whether they hold one or more securities licenses.\798\
Because we have amended the proposed requests to reduce the potential
for the public disclosure of personally identifiable information, we
will not incorporate this commenter's recommendation to require an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose whether any shared employees are registered with
the Commission or FINRA and whether they hold one or more securities
licenses. The details solicited in Part II, Item 6(a) of adopted Form
ATS-N are designed to provide market participants with information to
assess whether an NMS Stock ATS's use of shared employees poses a risk
of information leakage or other conflicts of interest that could affect
a market participant's decision of whether or not to trade on the ATS.
Requiring an NMS Stock ATS to disclose information about a shared
employee's credentials would be contrary to the Commission's intent to
limit the amount of personally identifiable information that is
required by Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\797\ See ICI Letter at 5-6.
\798\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Third-Party Service Providers
Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about third-party service providers to the NMS Stock ATS.
The Commission received several comments on Part III, Item 8 of
proposed Form ATS-N. The Commission is adopting Part III, Item 8 of
proposed Form ATS-N with modifications in response to commenters'
concerns, as further explained below, and is renumbering Part III, Item
8 of proposed Form ATS-N as Part II, Items 6(b), 6(c), and 6(d) of
adopted Form ATS-N.
Two commenters support the Commission's proposal to require the
disclosure of information related to third-party service providers
because such disclosures would provide information related to potential
information leakage on the NMS Stock ATS.\799\ One of those commenters
further opines that while shared employees are likely subject to
increased oversight and it supports the proposed requests related to
shared employees, the oversight of third-parties is significantly less
formidable and may result in greater risk for information leakage.\800\
As they did for Part III, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N, two other
commenters express support for Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N
by noting that current Form ATS Exhibit E calls for the disclosure of
other entities relevant to the operation of the ATS, which the
commenters believe would be helpful in determining whether there are
apparent conflicts of interest that could come into play in terms of
how orders are executed in the ATS.\801\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\799\ See HMA Letter at 17; ICI Letter at 5.
\800\ See HMA Letter at 17.
\801\ See Luminex Letter at 2; see also PDQ Letter at 1
(agreeing with Luminex's letter).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters believe that aspects of the request under Part
III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N related to third-party service
providers are unnecessary to evaluating an NMS
[[Page 38835]]
Stock ATS as a potential trading venue. Two commenters state that
information about certain shared personnel for vendors or certain
support functions, such as back-office or technology resources, are not
necessary for risk assessment of an ATS.\802\ Similarly, another
commenter believes that the disclosures could, in fact, inhibit useful
comparison of ATSs and create unnecessary and burdensome disclosure
obligations.\803\ Specifically, this commenter cites the proposed
requirements to provide detailed information regarding persons,
including natural persons, providing services for the ATS, but who are
unaffiliated with the broker-dealer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\802\ See Luminex Letter at 4; STANY Letter at 5.
\803\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We disagree that the proposed request regarding third party service
providers to the NMS Stock ATS is unnecessary, would not be meaningful
to market participants, or, when compared to the current requirements
on Form ATS, would be overly burdensome. As noted in the Proposal,\804\
the request related to service providers is intended to expand on the
current disclosure requirement of Exhibit E of Form ATS, which requires
ATSs to disclose the name of any entity other than the ATS that will be
involved in the operation of the ATS, including the execution, trading,
clearing, and settling of transactions on behalf of the ATS; and to
provide a description of the role and responsibilities of each
entity.\805\ We continue to believe that subscribers and market
participants would be interested in whether services performed by a
third-party may or may not be under the control of the broker-dealer
operator for the purposes of evaluating the potential information
leakage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\804\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81055.
\805\ See Item 7 of Form ATS (describing the requirements for
Exhibit E of Form ATS).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters recommend clarifying or more narrowly tailoring the
scope of the requests in Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N
related to service providers so as not to capture information about
vendors that only provide administrative services to the ATS or other
overhead, such as utility companies.\806\ We believe that the scope of
the third-party service provider requests should not encompass purely
administrative items--such as human resources support--or basic
overhead items--such as phone services and other utilities. The
information solicited in this disclosure is meant to provide
information about the extent to which a third-party may be able to
influence or control the operations of the ATS through involvement with
its operations (such as operating the ATS's proprietary data feeds sent
to subscribers). As indicated by commenters, information about the
roles and responsibilities of service providers to the ATS is important
because it could inform market participants about the potential
information leakage on the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\806\ See ICI Letter at 6; UBS Letter at 6; SIFMA Letter at 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A commenter also states that it is very difficult for a broker-
dealer to know the structure of all of its vendors, much less whether
the vendor has an affiliate that may enter orders in the subject
ATS.\807\ This commenter believes that requiring an ATS to disclose
information regarding whether any such persons, or any of their
affiliates, may enter orders or other trading interest on the NMS Stock
ATS would be unduly burdensome. We believe that the benefit to market
participants from the public disclosure of information concerning the
use of ATS services by third-party service providers and their
affiliates justifies the potential burden on the NMS Stock ATS to
provide those disclosures in Form ATS-N. Service providers have
business relationships outside of simple subscriber-ATS arrangements,
which may give those service providers or their affiliates access to
confidential trading information of other subscribers. As such, market
participants should be aware of how those service providers utilize the
ATS as a trading venue or for any other services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\807\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, the adopted requests under Part II, Items 6(c)-(d)
require the NMS Stock ATS to disclose whether any service providers or
their affiliates use the services of the NMS Stock ATS and if they do,
the ATS is required to identify the service providers, the service(s)
used, and whether there is any disparate treatment between those
service providers and other subscribers. Thus, an NMS Stock ATS would
only be required to obtain and disclose information about third-party
vendors and their affiliates that actively use the services of the ATS;
the ATS should be aware of all parties the use its services under its
current recordkeeping obligations.\808\ Additionally, because the ATS
has already established a relationship with its service providers, we
do not believe that it would impose a significant burden on ATSs to
require its service providers to inform them about any affiliates that
use the services of the ATS. Accordingly, to the extent that an
affiliate of a service provider uses the services of the ATS, we
believe that the burden to obtain the information required by Form ATS-
N is justified by the above-explained benefits to market participants
from these disclosures.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\808\ See supra note 742 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This commenter also states that if the Commission's concern is
whether a service provider is receiving preferential treatment from an
ATS, the Proposal should have mandated disclosure of whether there is
any preferential and/or differentiated treatment.\809\ We believe
market participants would find it very useful to understand whether
potential counterparties with whom they are trading, and who also
service the operation of the NMS Stock ATS, have access to different or
unique ATS-related services when analyzing potential conflicts of
interest or information leakage on the venue. We have added a request
to Part II, Item 6 of adopted Form ATS-N to expressly require the ATS
to identify and explain any differences in ATS services to a service
provider and all other subscribers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\809\ See Morgan Stanley Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter questions the feasibility of providing ``a detailed
description of information technology services, including both hardware
and software'' in Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N, which the
commenter opines can be taken to the extreme of requiring an ATS
operator to disassemble a server to enumerate the manufacturer of
various components. The commenter believes that a general--but
thorough--description of the information technology services would be
more practical.\810\ We did not intend for the adopted disclosures to
require the level of granular detail to which this commenter cites in
its comment letter. To clarify the scope of the required disclosure
about services provided by third parties, adopted Form ATS-N no longer
requires the NMS Stock ATS to ``describe'' the operation, service, or
function provided by the third party service provider. Instead, it
requires an NMS Stock ATS to provide a ``summary'' of the service
provider's role and responsibilities.\811\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\810\ See UBS Letter at 7.
\811\ As guidance for this request, the Commission would view,
for example, an NMS Stock ATS simply stating that a third-party
provides technology or hardware to the ATS as insufficient. See
Proposal, supra note 2, at 81055. In this example, the summary
generally should provide market participants with an understanding
of the types of technology or hardware provided, and how that
hardware or technology is used by the NMS Stock ATS. This
information is meant to provide market participants with a better
understanding about whether the service provider could access
confidential trading information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38836]]
As guidance for this request, we would view, for example, an NMS
Stock ATS simply stating that a third-party provides technology or
hardware to the ATS as not responsive to the required summary of the
service provider's role. But we would not expect the ATS to provide
information about the manufacturer of certain components of its
hardware. This request for summary information is designed to provide
market participants with a general understanding of the types of
technology or hardware provided by the service provider as part of its
responsibilities, and how that hardware or technology is used by the
NMS Stock ATS. The purpose of this disclosure is to provide market
participants with information to better understand whether the service
provider might be able to access confidential trading information, so
NMS Stock ATSs should draft its disclosure with the goal of conveying
such information.
Furthermore, to reduce redundant disclosures on Form ATS-N, adopted
Form ATS-N will only require this in Part III, unless there are no
disclosure requests in Part III that would encompass these types of
services. The disclosure requests in Part III will likely require the
NMS Stock ATS to describe the services provided by third-parties, and
we believe that a summary narrative about the roles and
responsibilities of third-party service providers will likely be
included in that description of the services. We do not believe that it
is not necessary to also provide a redundant summary narrative of the
roles and responsibilities of service providers in Part II.
A commenter also recommends eliminating the disclosures of third-
party service providers from the publicly available Form ATS-N and
requiring that the information requested be made available only to the
Commission on a confidential basis.\812\ We are not changing the nature
of the third-party service provider request to require the disclosures
to be filed on a confidential basis with the Commission. We have
narrowed the scope of the request so that the information provided is
tailored to address the concerns of market participants and NMS Stock
ATSs clarify the level of detail required by these disclosures. We
believe that requiring only a summary description of the roles and
responsibilities of third-party service providers would not require the
type of details that could be subject to confidentiality concerns or
otherwise put either the NMS Stock ATS or the service provider at a
competitive disadvantage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\812\ See SIFMA Letter at 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, we are replacing the proposed word ``person'' with the
word ``entity'' in Part II, Item 6(b) of adopted Form ATS-N. The
Commission does not believe that an NMS Stock ATS is likely to contract
with a natural person who is not associated with a legal entity (e.g.,
a corporation or an LLC) to provide services to the ATS. Furthermore,
the Commission does not intend for the service provider request to
disclose details about natural persons providing services to the ATS
when those natural persons are employees of, or independent contractors
hired by, a third party.
6. Protection of Confidential Trading Information
Part III, Item 10 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required an NMS
Stock ATS to provide disclosures about its confidential treatment of
trading information. One commenter states its belief that the proposed
requests under Part III, Item 10 of proposed Form ATS-N seemed
appropriate given the risk of misuse of confidential information.\813\
This commenter believes the requests fit well within the framework of
the new requirement that all ATSs maintain written safeguards and
procedures to protect confidential trading information. We are adopting
Part III, Item 10 of proposed Form ATS-N with modifications in response
to commenter concerns, as further explained below, and renumbering the
proposed request as Part II, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\813\ See HMA Letter at 18.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part II, Item 7(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS
to describe its written safeguards and written procedures to protect
the confidential trading information of subscribers to the NMS Stock
ATS, including: (i) Written standards controlling employees of the ATS
that trade for employees' accounts; and (ii) written oversight
procedures to ensure that the safeguards and procedures described above
are implemented and followed. The protection of confidential trading
information is a bedrock component of the regulation of ATSs and is
essential to ensuring the integrity of ATSs as an execution venue. If
such information is not protected, many of the advantages or purposes
for which a subscriber may choose to send its orders to an ATS (e.g.,
trade anonymously and/or to mitigate the impact of trading in large
positions) are eliminated. In cases where the confidential trading
information of a subscriber is impermissibly shared with the personnel
of the broker-dealer operator or any of its affiliates (e.g., persons
who are not responsible for the operation of the ATS or compliance with
applicable rules), such an abuse is also compounded by the conflicting
interests of the broker-dealer operator. That is, in such a case, the
broker-dealer operator has invited subscribers to trade on its ATS and
may have abused that relationship to provide itself or its affiliates
with a direct competitive advantage over that subscriber. Accordingly,
we believe that disclosures informing market participants about broker-
dealer operators' written safeguards and procedures to protect
confidential trading information are necessary so market participants
can independently evaluate the robustness of the safeguards and
procedures that are employed by the NMS Stock ATS to protect subscriber
confidential trading information and decide for themselves whether they
wish to do business with a particular NMS Stock ATS.\814\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\814\ If an NMS Stock ATS has disclosed information on its Form
ATS-N about the written safeguards and procedures that it has
established to protect the confidential trading information of
subscribers, including oversight procedures to ensure that such
safeguards and procedures are followed, but those disclosures
materially differ from the actual means by which the NMS Stock ATS
protected the confidential trading information of subscribers, the
ATS would be required to file an amendment pursuant to Rule
304(a)(2) to revise its Form ATS-N to accurately describe such
safeguards and procedures.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Part II, Items 7(b) and (c) to require an NMS Stock
ATS to disclose whether a subscriber can consent and withdraw consent,
respectively, to the disclosure of its confidential trading information
to any person (not including those employees of the NMS Stock ATS who
are operating the system or responsible for its compliance with
applicable rules). Subscribers should be able to give consent if they
so choose to share their confidential trading information.\815\ ATSs
that transact in NMS stocks vary in terms of what types of orders,
indications of interests, or other forms of trading interest are
confidential on their systems and what information about such trading
interest may be shared. For example, an ATS might provide that no IOIs
submitted by subscribers will be considered confidential, but may
provide subscribers with the option to restrict the information in the
IOI message to just the symbol and side (i.e., buy or sell).\816\ For
this example, Part II, Items 7(b) and 7(c) of adopted Form ATS-N
[[Page 38837]]
would require the NMS Stock ATS to describe the means by which a
subscriber could control some of the information contained in the IOI
message by providing consent or withdrawing such consent for the
sharing of its confidential trading information.\817\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\815\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70879.
\816\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81058.
\817\ See id. We believe that there may be some NMS Stock ATSs
that might not offer any means by which a subscriber could consent
to the dissemination of its confidential trading information. An NMS
Stock ATS would be required to disclose this fact pursuant to Item
7(a). See id., n.437.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part II, Items 7(b) and 7(c) contain requests similar to those in
Part III, Item 10(a) of proposed Form ATS-N, but we are modifying the
format of these requests so that they are in the form of a ``yes'' or
``no'' question, and if the NMS Stock ATS answers ``yes,'' the NMS
Stock ATS must explain how and under what conditions consent can be
given and withdrawn. We are also adding the phrase ``not including
those employees of the NMS Stock ATS who are operating the system or
responsible for its compliance with applicable rule'' to Part II, Item
7(b) of adopted Form ATS-N. This change is to clarify that the request
does not cover such employees that may need access to such information
in the course of their responsibilities to service the system. As noted
above, Regulation ATS requires that access to confidential subscriber
information be available only to those employees of the ATS that
operate the ATS's system or are responsible for the ATS's compliance
with applicable rules.\818\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\818\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70879; 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10)(i)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, we are adopting Part II, Item 7(d) to require an NMS Stock
ATS to provide a summary of the roles and responsibilities of any
persons that have access to confidential trading information, the
confidential trading information that is accessible by them, and the
basis for the access. Part III, Item 10(b) of proposed Form ATS-N would
have required the NMS Stock ATS to identify the position or title of
any person who has access to confidential trading information, describe
the confidential information to which the person has access, and
describe the circumstances under which the person can access
confidential trading information. Some commenters express concerns
regarding the potential disclosure of personally identifiable
information under proposed Part III, Item 10(b).\819\ We have
eliminated the proposed requirement to publicly disclose the positions
or titles of persons with access to confidential trading information
and part II, Item 7(d) of adopted Form ATS-N requires only a summary of
the roles and responsibilities of any persons that have access to
confidential trading information, the confidential trading information
that is accessible by them, and the basis for the access. We believe
that any benefit of providing personally identifiable information is
not justified by the potential negative effects of publicly posting
personally identifiable information; a summary of the information
required under Item 7(d) will buttress the existing obligations on ATSs
to restrict access only to permitted personnel (e.g., those responsible
for its operation or compliance).\820\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\819\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 6 (expressing concern that
requiring disclosure of the positions or titles of persons who have
access to confidential trading information would paint a target on
such persons and could increase their security risks and risks of
receiving phishing attacks); SIFMA Letter at 17-18 (stating that the
public disclosure of information under Part IV, Item 10 of proposed
Form ATS-N would have raised privacy, security, and proprietary
information concerns).
\820\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70879; 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10)(i)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Differences in Availability of Services, Functionalities, or
Procedures
Part III, Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose information regarding the differences in the
availability of services, functionalities, or procedures of the NMS
Stock ATS that are available or apply to the broker-dealer operator or
its affiliates that are not available or do not apply to other
subscribers.
In general, several commenters support requests for information
about differences between subscribers and the broker-dealer with
respect to their use of the NMS Stock ATS.\821\ A commenter also states
that the proposed requests in Part III, Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N
are reasonable.\822\ One commenter, however, expresses concern that the
proposed disclosures that would have been required under Part III, Item
9 of proposed Form ATS-N were too broad and could result in the
disclosure of either proprietary information or other information that
could pose a cybersecurity risk.\823\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\821\ See SIFMA Letter at 6; Consumer Federation of America
Letter at 9-10. See also Fidelity Letter at 5 (stating it should be
disclosed when subscribers are not treated the same way); UBS Letter
at 7 (suggesting the Commission request should highlight differences
among subscribers).
\822\ See HMA Letter at 17-18.
\823\ See SIFMA Letter at 17.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that the disclosure about differences in
treatment are important to market participants and will better allow
them to decide whether submitting order flow to that NMS Stock ATS
aligns with their trading or investment objectives. To more closely
tailor the Form ATS-N disclosures about differences in treatment to the
subject matter covered in relevant conflicts-of-interest requests, we
are removing Part III, Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N as a stand-alone
question and incorporating the request into Part II, Items 1, 2, 3, and
6 of adopted Form ATS-N. We believe that under this format, disclosures
regarding the differences in the availability of services,
functionalities, or procedures of the NMS Stock ATS will relate to the
specific subject matter covered by each of the aforementioned
disclosure requests that relate to services, functionalities, or
procedures that may differ among subscribers or the broker-dealer
operator and subscribers.
The requests in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N focus on the ATS-
related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates and
are designed to inform market participants about the competing
interests between the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates and
other subscribers and the potential for information leakage of
subscribers' confidential trading information. In response to a
commenter's concern,\824\ we note that we did not intend for these
requests to require descriptions of technologies or other aspects of
the NMS Stock ATS that could pose a cybersecurity risk or are otherwise
disclose commercially sensitive information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\824\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Other Recommendations From Commenters
The Commission received comments recommending additional regulation
or disclosures for NMS Stock ATSs related to conflicts of interests. In
the Proposal, the Commission considered alternatives to address
conflicts of interests between the broker-dealer operator and the NMS
Stock ATS. One alternative the Commission considered was to eliminate
any potential conflicts of interest by requiring the NMS Stock ATS to
operate with a single business function--operating the NMS Stock ATS--
and by eliminating any other function of the broker-dealer, such as
principal trading.\825\ The Commission also considered continuing to
allow broker-dealer operators to act as a broker-dealer operator of an
NMS Stock ATS and engage in non-ATS functions while imposing new
requirements designed to limit potential conflicts of
[[Page 38838]]
interest.\826\ In the Proposal, the Commission requested comment about
whether certain conflicts of interest arising out of the broker-
dealer's operation of the NMS Stock ATS should be prohibited.\827\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\825\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81043.
\826\ See id.
\827\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters recommend that the Commission prohibit conflicts
of interest altogether on NMS Stock ATSs, which would include a
prohibition on trading on the NMS Stock ATS by the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates, rather than simply increasing the
disclosure requirements for conflicts of interest.\828\ However, we
continue to believe that prohibiting conflicts of interest for the
broker-dealer operator related to its operation of an NMS Stock ATS
would be significantly more intrusive relative to requiring additional
disclosures about the operations of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates, and therefor did not propose these alternatives.\829\ We
also believe that such a prohibition would substantially affect or
limit the current operations of ATSs that trade NMS stocks. Part II of
adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide disclosures to market
participants about ATS-related activities of a broker-dealer operator
and its affiliates that might give rise of potential conflicts of
interest or information leakage, and thus, should better enable market
participants to evaluate whether they want to use the services of that
NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\828\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 7-8
(asserting that certain conflicts of interest are so acute and
pernicious that they cannot be mitigated or absolved merely by
disclosing them; the commenter provides principle trading by the
broker-dealer operator as an example); HMA Letter at 13-18
(advocating for: (1) The Commission to prohibit what the commenter
considers to be the deeply troubling conflicts of interest attendant
with allowing an ATS operator or affiliate to trade in the ATS; or
(2) alternatively if the Commission would not adopt such a
prohibition, for the Commission to affirmatively restrict how the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates interact with the ATS);
Better Markets Letter at 5-6 (advocating that the Commission ban
material conflicts of interest rather than relying on disclosure
alone).
\829\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81043.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, one commenter recommends that, for any conflicts of interest
that are permitted, at a minimum Form ATS-N should include clear
disclosures of conflicts of interest under a section titled ``conflicts
of interest.'' \830\ We decline the commenter's request to title Part
II ``conflicts of interest.'' We believe that it is more helpful to
market participants for Form ATS-N to provide the information market
participants need to individually evaluate whether there is a conflict
of interest on a given NMS Stock ATS rather than relying on the ATS to
determine when a conflict exits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\830\ See Better Markets Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received a comment requesting the Commission to require NMS
Stock ATSs to disclose in Part II of Form ATS-N any proceeding within
the last 10 years against the NMS Stock ATS, the broker-dealer operator
or officers or employees of the broker-dealer operator that relates to
the handling of equity orders or the operation of the NMS Stock
ATS.\831\ Form ATS-N is designed to provide market participants with
public disclosures about the current operations of an NMS Stock ATS and
the current ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and
its affiliates. We believe that this information will help market
participants assess the NMS Stock ATS as potential venue for their
orders. We believe that disclosures about past proceedings, or other
disciplinary matters, of the NMS Stock ATS, its broker-dealer operator,
or officers and employees of the broker-dealer operator--even those
that relate to the handling of equity orders or the operation of the
NMS Stock ATS--would not provide additional transparency into the
current operations of the NMS Stock ATS. To the extent that such
information is publicly available, a market participant may review
details about past and pending proceedings involving the NMS Stock ATS,
its broker-dealer operator, or the officers and employees of the
broker-dealer operator via, for example, public databases maintained by
the Commission or FINRA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\831\ See ICI Letter at 6, n.14.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Part III Form ATS-N: Manner of ATS Operations
Part III of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide public
disclosures to help market participants understand, among other things,
how subscribers' orders and trading interest are handled, matched, and
executed on the NMS Stock ATS. In response to comments, we are revising
the format of several requests in Part IV of proposed Form ATS-N
(renumbered as Part III in the adopted Form) to help NMS Stock ATSs
provide disclosures that would be useful to market participants. For
example, in response to commenters that believe the Commission's use of
the term ``describe'' is vague and would lead to discursive disclosures
and obscure key information, we are revising requests to be more
explicit, adding specificity to clarify the meaning of the requests,
and providing non-exhaustive examples for NMS Stock ATSs to better
understand what would be responsive to the Form ATS-N.\832\ In
addition, we have added ``yes'' or ``no'' questions, and converted
proposed Items into ``yes'' or ``no'' questions, throughout Part III of
Form ATS-N, which we believe will allow market participants to find
information more efficiently and facilitate their comparisons across
NMS Stock ATSs.\833\ Moreover, we have separated the requests for
information in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N into more items (and
renumbered the items) and discrete topics to help readers more easily
find information and compare that information among NMS Stock ATSs. In
addition, we are combining or removing certain requests to reduce
redundancy within Part III, and between Parts II and III, and
separating certain requests for information into new items or subparts
that focus the information required in response to commenter
suggestions and concerns. Finally, we are adding a requirement to
identify and explain any differences in the treatment of subscribers
and the broker-dealer operator to several items that did not require
this information as proposed.\834\ We intended that these differences
be explained for all of the subject matter covered by Form ATS-N, and
several commenters support requests for information about differences
between subscribers and the broker-dealer operator with respect to
their use of the NMS Stock ATS.\835\ Differences in the treatment among
subscribers and the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates
[[Page 38839]]
will help market participants discern any benefit or disadvantage they
may receive in comparison to other market participants or the broker-
dealer operator.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\832\ The topics and examples provided on Form ATS-N are
designed to help NMS Stock ATS consider the scope of the request and
information potentially responsive to the form requirements. While
we use the term ``including'' to denote topics responsive to an Item
and have provided examples in many of the requests, these topics or
examples are not an exhaustive list of what may be responsive to a
Form ATS-N request. See, e.g., Items 4, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 13, 19, 21,
and 23 of Part III of adopted Form ATS-N.
\833\ See e.g., SSGA Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 9; STANY
Letter at 5; LeveL ATS Letter at 6-7; KCG Letter at 10. See also
Section V.A.1. (discussing the format of items in Part II and III of
Form ATS-N).
\834\ Specifically, this requirement is being added to Items 10,
14, 17, 18, and 23 of adopted Form ATS-N. In the Proposal, the
Commission required a description of any differences between
subscribers and persons in Part IV, Items 1(b), 1(e), 2(b), 3(b)-
(d), 4, 5(a), 5(b), 6(a), 7, 8, 10(b), 12(b), and 13 of proposed
Form ATS-N. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81146-81152.
\835\ See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 5-6 (stating whether all
subscribers have access to the same suite of products and services
is particularly appropriate and useful); Fidelity Letter at 5
(calling for disclosure when subscribers are not treated the same
way); UBS Letter at 7 (suggesting the Commission request should
highlight differences in subscriber access that may impact other
users of the ATS). See also Consumer Federation of America Letter at
9-10 (discussing how to address potential advantages of the broker-
dealer operator and its affiliates).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Types of ATS Subscribers
Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about types of subscribers to the NMS Stock ATS. We are
adopting Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N with modifications
as Part III Item 1 (``Types of Subscribers'') of adopted Form ATS-
N.\836\ Part III, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide
market participants with information about the type of order flow in
the NMS Stock ATS. NMS Stock ATSs may design their system for trading
by retail, institutional, or any other type of market participant.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\836\ As also discussed under Section V.D.2., commenters state
with regard to the entirety of Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-
N that the Commission should adopt a ``yes'' or ``no'' format for
the item instead of requests for descriptions. See SIFMA Letter at
19; KCG Letter at 11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter recommends that the Commission consider eliminating
or consolidating this request because it is redundant to the request in
Part IV, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N regarding segmentation.\837\ In
response to this comment, we are removing the requirement from Part IV,
Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N to ``describe any criteria for
distinguishing among types of subscribers, classes of subscriber, or
other persons.'' To the extent that an NMS Stock ATS distinguishes
among ATS subscribers, the ATS will be required to discuss such
information in Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N, which relates
to segmentation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\837\ See SIFMA Letter at 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter believes that the phrase ``types of subscribers''
should be specifically defined.\838\ In response to this comment, we
are providing a list of market participants in Part III, Item 1 of
adopted Form ATS-N that, in the Commission's experience, are commonly
used. The revised list includes: Retail investors, issuers, asset
managers, brokers, dealers, NMS Stock ATSs, investment companies, hedge
funds, market makers, principal trading firms, and banks. The list is
non-exhaustive and an NMS Stock ATS is required to list any type of
subscriber that can use the NMS Stock ATS services. Also, in response
to this comment, we are revising Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form
ATS-N, by removing the request to describe the type of subscribers and
other persons and instead, are only requesting that the NMS Stock ATS
select the checkbox for the types of subscribers that can use the NMS
Stock ATS services (and identify any other types of subscribers not
listed in a checkbox). We are also revising the Item to require the
selection of the types of subscribers that ``can'' use the NMS Stock
ATS services, rather than solely those types of subscribers that in
fact use the NMS Stock ATS as was proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\838\ See KCG Letter at 12. The proposed Item required the NMS
Stock ATS to describe the types of subscribers and other persons
that use the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, in response to general comments that the Form ATS-N
should be formatted to facilitate comparisons across NMS Stock
ATSs,\839\ we are relocating Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N
into a separate Item in Part III, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N and
naming it ``Types of ATS Subscribers.'' \840\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\839\ See e.g., SSGA Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 9; STANY
Letter at 5; LeveL ATS Letter at 6-7; KCG Letter at 10.
\840\ See Section V.D.2 for a discussion of changes to the
requirement under Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N that NMS
Stock ATSs state whether they accept non-broker-dealers as
subscribers to the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Eligibility for ATS Services
Part IV, Item 1(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about eligibility requirements of the NMS Stock ATS.\841\
We are adopting Part IV, Item 1(a) of proposed Form ATS-N with certain
modifications described below, naming the Item ``Eligibility for ATS
Services,'' and relocating the request as Part III, Item 2 of adopted
Form ATS-N.\842\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\841\ As discussed in the Proposal, the eligibility process and
requirements to access an NMS Stock ATS may vary, and the
requirements may differ depending on whether a potential subscriber
is a customer of the broker-dealer operator of the ATS. For
instance, some ATSs may require that a potential subscriber be a
broker-dealer to submit orders in the ATS, while other ATSs may not.
Some NMS Stock ATSs may require potential subscribers to submit
financial information as a pre-requisite to subscribing to, or
maintaining their subscriber status on, the NMS Stock ATS. See
Proposal, supra note 2, at 81060.
\842\ One commenter supports the proposed disclosures stating
that funds and other market participants would find this information
valuable because it would facilitate the efficient comparison of
eligibility processes and requirements across all NMS Stock ATSs and
describe the types of participants that may dominate order flow on a
particular NMS Stock ATS. See ICI Letter at 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received comment seeking modifications to the proposed
Item. One commenter suggests that the term ``eligibility requirements''
under Part IV, Item 1(a) of proposed Form ATS-N is unclear and suggests
using eligibility ``standards'' as a more accurate way to capture the
various subscriber criteria an ATS might evaluate.\843\ In response to
this comment, we are replacing the reference to ``eligibility
requirements'' in Part IV, Item 1(a) of proposed Form ATS-N with a
reference to ``conditions'' the NMS Stock ATS requires a person to
satisfy before accessing the ATS services. We believe that the term
``conditions'' provides the NMS Stock ATS with more flexibility to
describe the relevant criteria.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\843\ See SIFMA Letter at 19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, commenters express confusion over the difference between Part
IV, Item 1(a) and 1(e) (adopted as Part III, Items 2 and 3,
respectively) of proposed Form ATS-N and whether they overlapped.\844\
In response to these commenters, we are clarifying the request by
adding the phrase ``before accessing the ATS services'' in Part III,
Item 2(b) of adopted Form ATS-N. On the other hand, Part III, Item 3 of
adopted Form ATS-N, as discussed infra, requires disclosures about any
conditions that would exclude a subscriber, in whole or in part, from
using the services of the NMS Stock ATS after the person, as a
subscriber, is permitted to use or submit orders to the NMS Stock ATS,
such as for certain subscriber behavior while actively participating in
the ATS.\845\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\844\ Id. at 20 (stating it cannot distinguish between the
requested information in proposed Items 1(a) and 1(e)); KCG Letter
at 11-12 (noting an apparent overlap between the information
requested under proposed Item 1(a) and proposed Item 1(e) and
recommending that the Commission revisit and clarify the request).
\845\ For example, if an NMS Stock ATS has a practice of
excluding subscribers that do meet certain percentage thresholds for
submitting firm-up orders in response to receiving a conditional
order sent to them by the NMS Stock ATS, then this practice would be
subject to disclosure under Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N
(``Exclusion from Services'') and not Part III, Item 2
(``Eligibility Requirements'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not imposing new requirements for NMS Stock ATSs to have
certain eligibility requirements, either by implicating the fair access
rule under Rule 301(b)(5) (as suggested by a commenter), or
otherwise.\846\ The ``yes'' or ``no'' questions of Part III, Item 2(b)
of adopted Form ATS-N ask whether there are any conditions that the NMS
Stock ATS requires a person to satisfy before accessing the ATS
services. If an NMS Stock ATS marks ``yes,'' the ATS is indicating that
it has such conditions and must list and provide a summary of the
conditions. We believe that these revisions make clear that we are not
requiring any eligibility requirements.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\846\ See infra notes 855-857 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In Part III, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N, we are requiring the
NMS Stock ATS to state whether it requires subscribers to be registered
broker-dealers. This request is similar to the
[[Page 38840]]
proposed request in Part IV, Item 1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N but asked
in a ``yes'' or ``no'' format. Part III, Items 2(c) and 2(d) of adopted
Form ATS-N are requirements proposed in Part IV, Item 1(a) \847\ and
1(b), respectively, of proposed Form ATS-N, that the Commission is
formatting as ``yes'' or ``no'' questions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\847\ We are removing the reference to `subscriber' from the
Item, as proposed, because Part III, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N
relates to eligibility requirements of persons before they become
subscribers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If the NMS Stock ATS indicates that it does have conditions that a
person must satisfy before accessing the ATS services, the request, as
modified, requires an NMS Stock ATS to list and provide a ``summary''
of those conditions. We believe a summary of those conditions would
provide sufficient disclosure (in conjunction with Part III, Item 1 of
adopted Form ATS-N) for market participants to discern the type of
order flow that they are likely to interact with on the NMS Stock ATS,
while at the same time, not impairing the ATS's ability to reasonably
control the activities and quality of flow on its platform.\848\ One
commenter acknowledges that it already discloses the general
requirements for becoming a user of its ATS,\849\ which is analogous to
the summary of conditions we are adopting in this Item. Moreover, we
believe that requiring additional disclosures about differences in
treatment among persons is important to market participants.\850\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\848\ See UBS Letter at 7. See infra note 853 and accompanying
text.
\849\ See id.
\850\ See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 5-6 (stating whether all
subscribers have access to the same suite of products and services
is particularly appropriate and useful); Fidelity Letter at 5
(stating it should be disclosed when subscribers are not treated the
same way); UBS Letter at 7 (suggesting the Commission request should
highlight differences in subscriber access that may impact other
users of the ATS). See also Consumer Federation of America Letter at
9-10 (discussing how to address potential advantages of the broker-
dealer operator and its affiliates).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received comment unfavorable to Part IV, Item 1(b) of
proposed Form ATS-N.\851\ The proposed Item would have required an NMS
Stock ATS to describe the terms and conditions of any contractual
agreements for granting access to the NMS Stock ATS for the purpose of
effecting transactions in securities or for submitting, disseminating,
or displaying orders on the NMS Stock ATS, and to state whether these
contractual agreements are written and if the terms and conditions of
any contractual agreements were not the same for all subscribers and
persons, the NMS Stock ATS would be required to describe any
differences.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\851\ See Liquidnet Letter at 12; UBS Letter at 7; SIFMA Letter
at 19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not adopting the provision requiring the disclosure of the
terms and conditions of any contractual agreements in Part IV, Item
1(b) of proposed Form ATS-N.\852\ We believe that the Form ATS-N, as
adopted, requires comprehensive disclosure on the principal aspects of
the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and any differences in the treatment
of subscribers and the broker-dealer operator. We believe that a
description of the terms of any contractual agreements is unlikely to
provide much, if any, further information about the ATS's operations
that is not already required to be disclosed in the other items of Form
ATS-N and would likely impose a significant burden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\852\ We are moving the provision in Part IV, Item 1(b) of
proposed Form ATS-N, which would have required that the NMS Stock
ATS state whether the contractual agreements for granting access to
the NMS Stock ATS were written, to Part III, Item 2(d) of adopted
Form ATS-N. Part III, Item 2(d) asks a ``yes'' or ``no'' question on
whether subscribers are required to enter a written agreement to use
the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Exclusion From ATS Services
Part IV, Item 1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about limitation and denial of ATS services. We are
adopting Part IV, Item 1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N, with certain
modifications discussed below, including adopting a ``yes'' or ``no''
format to questions, as Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N, and naming the
request ``Exclusion from ATS Services.''
One commenter states that requiring an NMS Stock ATS to disclose
additional details about why the ATS would limit or deny ATS services
could affect the ATS's ability to reasonably control the activities and
quality of flow on its platform; the commenter suggests, therefore,
that such disclosure remain confidential with the Commission.\853\ In
response to this comment, we are adopting Part III, Item 3(a) of
adopted Form ATS-N, as modified, to require the NMS Stock ATS to
provide a list and ``summary'' of the conditions for excluding (or
limiting) a participant from using the ATS, and are removing the
requirement to describe the procedures or standards of the NMS Stock
ATS that are used to determine whether to exclude a subscriber. We
believe that these changes would protect sensitive information and
prevent participants from using the disclosures to potentially misuse
or game its system while ensuring that participants have the
information necessary to understand when they may be excluded.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\853\ See UBS Letter at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter suggests that it is unclear whether Part IV, Item
1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N requests disclosure of instances where a
subscriber requests not to interact with certain counterparties.\854\
We are not requiring in Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N that the
NMS Stock ATS disclose instances where a subscriber requests not to
interact with certain counterparties. Information regarding counter-
party selection procedures on the NMS Stock ATS, including where a
subscriber requests not to interact with certain counterparties, is
required to be disclosed, as applicable, in Part III, Item 14 of
adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\854\ See SIFMA Letter at 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This commenter also expresses concern about the implications for
fair access raised by Part IV, Item 1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N.\855\
The commenter assumes that the Commission intends that Part IV, Item
1(e) should apply only to entities subject to the fair access
threshold, and believes that entities not subject to the fair access
rule can deny access for any reason. The commenter further believes
that it is important to note that unless an ATS exceeds the fair access
threshold, the ATS should be able to deny access for any reason (e.g.,
credit risk). This commenter requests clarification from the Commission
if this interpretation is wrong to avoid later misunderstanding or
interpretive conflicts. The commenter also suggests that Part IV, Item
1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N goes beyond the fair access requirements
(to keep records of all grants, denials, and limitations of access, and
to report that information), and states that if the Commission intends
to replace the fair access rule with a different regulatory and
disclosure regime, the Commission should address this issue directly.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\855\ Id. at 19-20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are not implicating or changing Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation
ATS, the so-called fair access rule, by requiring NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose information about when the ATS can exclude, in whole or in
part, a subscriber from the services of the ATSs. Pursuant to Rule
300(a)(2) of Regulation ATS, an ATS cannot set rules governing the
conduct of subscribers other than the conduct of subscribers' trading
on the system and cannot discipline subscribers other than by exclusion
from trading.\856\ NMS Stock ATSs are not required to establish rules
for excluding subscribers from
[[Page 38841]]
using the ATS. Nevertheless, based on the Commission's experience, ATSs
that trade NMS stocks often have rules governing subscribers'
participation on the ATS, and if a subscriber fails to comply with
these rules, the ATS may limit or deny access to the ATS.\857\ Part
III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide subscribers
with information about when the NMS Stock ATS can exclude, in whole or
in part, a subscriber from the services of the ATSs and help them
reasonably expect the types of activities that may cause them to be
excluded (or limited) from using the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\856\ See 17 CFR 242.300(a)(2).
\857\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81063. These limitations
can result in some subscribers having different levels of
functionality or more favorable terms of access than others. For
example, in the Commission's experience, some ATSs exclude
subscribers that have a high percentage of not responding with firm-
up orders after receiving an IOI or conditional order.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter requests guidance about the ability of an ATS to deny
access pursuant to Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS when such ATS has
not exceeded the fair access threshold requirements under Rule
301(b)(5)(i).\858\ This commenter expresses concern that Part IV, Item
1(a) (``Eligibility'') and Item 1(e) (``Limitations and Denial of
Services'') of proposed Form ATS-N raises the specter of fair access
and that if the Commission is seeking to change regulatory expectations
relating to fair access, the Commission should do so in a straight
forward manner and not by way of requiring disclosures around
``eligibility requirements.'' We did not propose and are not adopting
any change to the fair access rule under Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation
ATS. The commenter appears to misconstrue the requirements and
application of the fair access rule in the context of the proposed
disclosure requirements of Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N, and
we believe it is important, in response to the commenter's request for
clarification if its interpretation is wrong, to further explain the
operation of the fair access rule ``to avoid later misunderstanding or
interpretive conflicts. ''\859\ In the Proposal, we discussed that a
significant difference between national securities exchanges and NMS
Stock ATSs is the extent to which each trading center allows access to
its services by its users.\860\ Section 6(b)(2) of the Exchange Act
generally requires national securities exchanges to allow any qualified
and registered broker-dealer to become a member of the national
securities exchange--a key element in assuring fair access to national
securities exchange services.\861\ In contrast, the access requirements
that apply to ATSs are much more limited. Because NMS Stock ATSs are
exempt from the definition of an ``exchange'' so long as they comply
with Regulation ATS, and thus, are not required to register as a
national securities exchange pursuant to Section 6 of the Exchange Act,
NMS Stock ATSs are not required to provide fair access unless they
reach a 5% trading volume threshold in a stock, which almost all NMS
Stock ATSs currently do not.\862\ As a result, ATSs may treat
subscribers differently with respect to the services offered by the ATS
unless prohibited by applicable federal securities laws or the rules
and regulations thereunder. Furthermore, even if an ATS is not subject
to the fair access requirements, inaccurate or misleading disclosures
about an ATS's operations could result in violations of the antifraud
provisions of the federal securities laws.\863\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\858\ See SIFMA Letter at 19-20.
\859\ Id.
\860\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81057.
\861\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(2).
\862\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(5). See also supra notes 72-75 and
accompanying text (discussing the fair access requirements of
Regulation ATS). For example, an ATS with at least 5% of the average
daily volume for any covered security during four of the preceding
six months is required to comply with fair access requirements under
Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS, which, among other things, require
an ATS to establish written standards for granting access to trading
on its system and not unreasonably prohibit or limit any person with
respect to access to services offered by the ATS by applying the
written standards in an unfair or discriminatory manner. Thus, for
example, an ATS that discloses a service to one class of subscribers
(or makes the associated functionality available to only one class
of subscribers) could not, if it were subject to the fair access
requirements, discriminate in this manner unless it adopted written
standards and applied them in a fair and non-discriminatory manner.
\863\ See, e.g., In the Matter of ITG Inc. and Alternet
Securities Inc., Securities Exchange Act Release No. 75672 (Aug. 12,
2015), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2015/33-9887.pdf (order
instituting administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings, making
findings, and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist
order); In the Matter of UBS Securities LLC, Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 74060 (Jan. 15, 2015), http://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2015/33-9697.pdf (order instituting administrative and cease-
and-desist proceedings, making findings, and imposing remedial
sanctions and a cease-and-desist order) (``UBS Settlement''); In the
Matter of Liquidnet, Inc., Securities Exchange Act Release No. 72339
(Jun. 6, 2014), http://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2014/33-9596.pdf
(order instituting administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings,
making findings, and imposing remedial sanctions and a cease-and-
desist order); In the Matter of Pipeline Trading Systems LLC, Fred
J. Federspiel, and Alfred R. Berkeley III, Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 9271 (Oct. 24, 2011) (order instituting administrative
and cease-and-desist proceedings, making findings, and imposing
remedial sanctions and a cease-and-desist order), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2011/33-9271.pdf; 48718 (Oct. 30,
2003), http://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/34-48718.htm (all
settling violations of Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act, which
prohibits, directly or indirectly, in the offer or sale of
securities, obtaining money or property by means of any untrue
statement of a material fact or any omission to state a material
fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in light of the
circumstances under which they were made, not misleading.) 15 U.S.C.
77q(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In this rulemaking, we are requiring NMS Stock ATSs to identify and
explain on Form ATS-N any instances where the ATS differs in how it
treats subscribers and the broker-dealer operator so market
participants can have additional information to consider when
evaluating an ATS. More favorable service or pricing for certain ATS
subscribers necessarily implies less favorable service or pricing for
others.\864\ We believe that it is consistent with the goals of
operational transparency for subscribers that receive less favorable
service or pricing than other subscribers to know that fact. These
subscribers will thus have better information to assess whether they
should continue to trade on the ATS despite their different treatment
or, if they do continue to trade on the ATS, whether they should alter
their behavior in any way to better protect their interests. Part III,
Items 2 and 3 of adopted Form ATS-N do not limit an NMS Stock ATS's
ability to discriminate among different subscribers. To the extent that
an NMS Stock ATS is subject to the fair access rule under Rule
301(b)(5) and treats subscribers differently, the NMS Stock ATS must
comply with the requirements of Rule 301(b)(5) with respect to its
treatment of subscribers. If an NMS Stock ATS elects to treat
subscribers differently by creating types or levels of eligibility and
exclusion requirements, Part III, Items 2 and 3 of adopted Form ATS-N
require an NMS Stock ATS to ``identify and explain any differences,''
which is similar to the vast majority of items on Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\864\ See, e.g., UBS Settlement, supra note 864 (noting that UBS
did not disclose the existence of a sub-penny order type to all ATS
subscribers and that ``nearly all of the subscribers'' who received
notice of the order type ``were market makers and/or HFT firms'')
and at 10 (noting that certain orders--those entered on behalf of
UBS clients that paid to use UBS-developed order-routing
algorithms--had the ability to avoid executing in the ATS against
orders entered by subscribers that UBS had deemed ``non-natural''
and no other subscribers had the ability to use this natural-only
crossing restriction) and Crossfinder Settlement supra note 96
(noting the ATS did not permit all subscribers to receive IOIs from
the IOI server).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Part III, Item 3 of Form ATS-N with certain
language to reduce potential confusion with the application of Rule
301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS. As indicated above, to meet the definition
of an ATS, a system
[[Page 38842]]
must not discipline subscribers other than by exclusion from trading.
\865\ The language in Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N now uses
``exclude, in whole or in part,'' which is similar to language used in
the definition of ATS in Rule 300(a)(2), rather than using the term
``limitations and denials of services,'' as used in Part IV, Item 1(e)
of proposed Form ATS-N. We recognize that exclusions from services, in
whole or in part, are functionally equivalent to limitations and
denials of services; however, we believe that the elimination of these
terms from Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N should mitigate any
potential confusion that we are implicating Rule 301(b)(5) in the
request.\866\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\865\ See 17 CFR 242.300(a).
\866\ See supra note 855 and accompanying text. Part III, Item
25 of adopted Form ATS-N (``Fair Access'') is specifically designed
to require an NMS Stock ATS, as applicable, to provide information
in connection with Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS. See also
Section V.D.25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Hours of Operations
Part IV, Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about the hours of operations. We did not receive comment
on Part IV, Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N. We are adopting the Item
with modifications as Part III, Item 4 (``Hours of Operations'') of
adopted Form ATS-N, as discussed below. We continue to believe that it
is important for market participants and the Commission to understand
when an NMS Stock ATS operates and when orders can be entered,
including when an NMS Stock ATS will accept orders outside of regular
trading hours. Making such information publicly available would enable
market participants to more easily compare when trading interest can be
entered on NMS stock trading centers. We are modifying the example
provided in this Item by replacing references in the Proposal to hours
when ``pre-opening or after-hours trading occurs'' (emphasis added)
with ``hours of operation outside of regular trading hours.'' Our
intent is to provide market participants with information about when
the NMS Stock ATS is operating, whether trading or performing another
function, such as accepting orders, and not simply when trading is
occurring.\867\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\867\ We are also modifying this request to require the times
when trading interest can be entered on the ATS, as opposed to
identifying the times trading interest is entered, so as to more
precisely indicate when the ATS is available for the entry of
trading interest. We are replacing references to pre-opening and
after-hours with the more general reference to hours of operation
``outside of regular trading hours.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Means of Entry
In Part III, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N we proposed a similar
request to Part IV, Item 4(a) of proposed Form ATS-N that focused on
the activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates. Part
III, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required disclosures
about the broker-dealer operator's, or any of its affiliates', use of a
SOR(s) (or similar functionality) or an algorithm. Part IV, Item 4(a)
of proposed Form ATS-N would have required disclosures about
connectivity and order entry to the NMS Stock ATS. We are adopting both
requests with modifications and combining them into Part III, Item 5
(``Means of Entry'') of adopted Form ATS-N.
One commenter asserts that the information sought in Part III, Item
6 of proposed Form ATS-N is generally duplicative of the requests in
Part III, Item 3 (``Products or Services Offered to Subscribers'') and
Part III, Item 5 (``Trading Activities on the NMS Stock ATS'') of
proposed Form ATS-N and that the requests in Part III, Item 6 of
proposed Form ATS-N (``Smart Order Router (`SOR') (or Similar
Functionality of Algorithm)'') should be either consolidated into those
requests or eliminated altogether.\868\ To reduce redundancy, we are
combining the proposed requests for information as explained above.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\868\ See SIFMA Letter at 15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With regard to Part IV, Item 4(a) of proposed Form ATS-N, one
commenter states that the requirement to ``describe'' the means of
connectivity by ``other persons'' is potentially overbroad--
particularly for ATSs with affiliated broker-dealers or other business
units that may connect directly or indirectly to the ATS.\869\ This
commenter suggests that Part IV, Item 4(a) conflates the identities of
market participants (subscribers and other persons) with the means of
connectivity. The commenter submits that end users would be better
served by a table identifying the various means of connectivity without
respect to the identities of who connects and in which fashion.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\869\ See id. at 22.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to this comment, Part III, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N
first requires an NMS Stock ATS to identify and explain the protocol
that can be used to directly enter orders and trading interest into the
ATS. In a separate subpart to Part III, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N,
the NMS Stock ATS must identify and explain any other means for
entering orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS (e.g.,
smart order router, algorithm, order management system, sales desk) and
indicate whether these means are provided by the broker-dealer
operator, either by itself or through a third-party contracting with
the broker-dealer operator, or any affiliate of the broker-dealer
operator. Both of these subparts are followed, respectively, by a
request to identify and explain any differences in the terms and
conditions for these means of entry among subscribers and the broker-
dealer operator. We believe that these changes will better distinguish
subject matter regarding means of entry from subject matter regarding
the identity of any party offering access to such means of entry.
We note that subscribers may submit orders or trading interest to
the NMS Stock ATS both directly and indirectly.\870\ A direct method of
sending orders or trading interest to an ATS that trades NMS stocks,
for example, may include the use of the FIX Protocol. The FIX Protocol
allows subscribers to enter orders or trading interest into the ATS
without an intermediary. An example of an indirect method of submitting
orders or trading interest to an NMS Stock ATS would include the use of
the broker-dealer operator's SOR (or similar functionality) or
algorithm. SORs (or similar functionalities) and algorithms are
discussed further below. The means of order entry into an ATS (e.g.,
direct or indirect) could impact the speed in which a subscriber's
order is handled and potentially executed and potentially increases the
risk of information leakage.\871\ We believe that the disclosures
regarding the direct or indirect means of order entry would inform
subscribers and market participants about the functionalities that its
orders and trading interest pass through on their way to the ATS and
help them assess any potential advantages that orders sent through the
broker-dealer operator may have with respect to other subscribers on
the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\870\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81068.
\871\ To the extent that a subscriber connects to the NMS Stock
ATS by way of a FIX connection and an order sent by that subscriber
passes through an intermediate application or functionality on its
way to the ATS, the ATS must identify the application or
functionality and provide a description of its purpose. In this
example, given that the intermediate application or functionality
has access to a subscriber's order information, the NMS Stock ATS
must take appropriate measures to protect the confidentiality of
such information pursuant to Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received several other comments on the request for
information in Part III, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N, which as
[[Page 38843]]
explained above, have been incorporated into Part III, Item 5 of
adopted Form ATS-N. Many commenters express general support for public
disclosures about an NMS Stock ATS's use of the broker-dealer
operator's or its affiliates' SORs or algorithms.\872\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\872\ See Schneiderman Letter at 1; HMA Letter at 17; STA Letter
at 5; Liquidnet Letter at 9; KCG Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some commenters, however, express concern that Part III, Item 6 of
proposed Form ATS-N would require the NMS Stock ATS to publicly
disclose proprietary information about its SOR and/or algorithms.\873\
Two commenters believe that disclosing the information required under
proposed Part III, Item 6 would harm broker-dealers that operate an NMS
Stock ATS to the benefit of broker-dealers that do not, who would not
be required to disclose what the commenter considers to be proprietary
information.\874\ Similarly, another commenter believes that it is not
necessary to require disclosure of how the SOR or algorithm interacts
with any ATS operated by third-party operators; the commenter states
that requiring that type of disclosure would impose a disclosure
obligation on ATS operators that is not imposed on competing broker-
dealers that do not operate an ATS.\875\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\873\ See STA Letter at 5; Liquidnet Letter at 9; STANY Letter
at 4; SIFMA Letter at 15.
\874\ See STA Letter at 5; STANY Letter at 4.
\875\ See Liquidnet Letter at 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We did not intend for the proposed requests regarding SORs (or
other functionalities) and algorithms used by the broker-dealer
operator or its affiliates to enter orders or trading interest into an
NMS Stock ATS to mandate the public disclosure of information that
could place the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates at a
competitive disadvantage with other broker-dealers. To clarify the
scope of the adopted disclosure requirements, Part III, Item 5(c) of
adopted Form ATS-N no longer contains the proposed language
``[d]escribe the interaction and coordination.'' Rather, Part III, Item
5(c) only requires the NMS Stock ATS to ``list and explain'' sources of
order flow other than those used for direct entry into the ATS, which
could include SORs or algorithms offered by the broker-dealer operator.
Furthermore, the adopted disclosure requirements only require the NMS
Stock ATS to ``list and provide a summary description of the terms and
conditions for entering orders or trading interest into the ATS''
through these sources. This revised language is intended to clarify
that the NMS Stock ATS need not provide a detailed description of the
programming for its SOR (or other similar functionality), algorithms,
or other non-direct means for entering order and trading interests that
could put the ATS at a competitive disadvantage with competitors. For
example, NMS Stock ATSs need not disclose their SORs' routing tables or
other information about how the SOR may route orders.\876\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\876\ For example, a broker-dealer operator that uses its SOR to
both enter customer orders into its ATS and send customer orders to
external trading venues would not be required to disclose how its
SOR is programmed to decide how to route those orders. The NMS Stock
ATS would be required to disclose whether the broker-dealer
operator's SOR is a means for entering client orders and, if so,
indicate whether these means are provided by the broker-dealer
operator, either by itself or through a third-party contracting with
the broker-dealer operator, or through an affiliate of the broker-
dealer operator, and list and provide a summary of the terms and
conditions for entering orders or trading interest into the ATS
through these means.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that there are numerous questions in the
proposed Form ATS-N that would require ATS operators ``to act as de
facto agents of the SEC'' by asking the ATS operators to seek
information relating to the operations of certain trading algorithms or
SORs that the ATS operators have nothing to do with and may be blocked
via firm information barriers from knowing anything about.\877\ This
commenter opines that ATS operators should properly be asked about how
their ATSs work, and that information should be made available to all
market participants, but if the Commission wants ATS operators to
disclose whether they give preferential treatment to orders from
affiliates at the expense of other ATS customers, or if they give
preferential treatment to anyone else that isn't an affiliate over
other ATS customers, then the Commission should pose that specific
question and require a specific answer.\878\ This commenter continues
to state that anything beyond that which is of regulatory interest to
the Commission with respect to how trading algorithms or smart order
routers interact with ATSs generally or with other market centers
should be asked of the firms that own or operate those algorithms or
smart order routers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\877\ See Luminex Letter at 3.
\878\ See id. at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We agree that it is outside of the scope of this rulemaking for us
to require NMS Stock ATSs to obtain detailed information about how the
SORs and algorithms of third parties operate when such information does
not pertain to the operation of the ATS. However, if an affiliate of
the broker-dealer operator provides a means of entry into the ATS for
its customers or its principal orders, we believe that market
participants should understand certain details about the interaction
between that affiliate and the ATS, which are solicited in Part III,
Item 6, to properly evaluate potential conflicts of interest and
information leakage on the ATS.
For example, among the advantages and disadvantages that market
participants should be able to discern from the disclosure of Part III,
Item 5(b) is any differences in the latency of the alternative means
for entering orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS. We
understand that alternative means of entering orders and trading
interest may have different latencies associated with each alternative.
For instance, in some cases, a direct connection to the NMS Stock ATS
may have reduced latencies as compared to indirect means where orders
and trading interest pass through an intermediate functionality.
Alternatively, a broker-dealer operator could, for example, configure
the NMS Stock ATS to provide reduced latencies for certain means of
order entry used by itself or its affiliates, such as through a SOR or
algorithm.\879\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\879\ The Commission is not requiring a reporting regime with
precise latencies calculated for each means of entry. But see
Healthy Markets Letter at 19-20 (requesting that the Commission
adopt annual reporting requirements regarding the latency of certain
data on ATSs). Rather, the response to Item 5(b) would provide
market participants with an appreciation of relative differences in
the speed of order entry through the alternative means offered.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also believe that it is important for subscribers and market
participants to understand a means of entry provided by an affiliate,
such as the use of an affiliate's SOR, even if it does not provide an
advantage to a particular entity. Specifically, we continue to believe
that disclosures about a broker-dealer operator's use of its or an
affiliate's SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithms to enter
orders into the NMS Stock ATS are important to market participants when
evaluating NMS Stock ATSs.\880\ Today, most broker-dealers that operate
an NMS Stock ATS use some form of SOR (or similar functionality) in
connection with the NMS Stock ATS.\881\ A SOR (or similar
functionality) can generally be understood as an automated system used
to route orders or trading interest among trading centers, including
trading centers other than the NMS Stock ATS operated by the broker-
dealer operator, to carry out certain trading instructions or
strategies of a broker-dealer.\882\ SORs (or similar
[[Page 38844]]
functionalities) have become an integral part of the business of many
multi-service broker-dealers, given the increase in the speed of
trading in today's equity markets and the large number of trading
centers, including national securities exchanges, ATSs, and non-ATS
trading centers, that have emerged since the adoption of Regulation ATS
\883\ In addition to the SOR (or similar functionality), orders or
trading interest may be entered on an NMS Stock ATS through the use of
a trading algorithm, which is a computer assisted trading tool that,
for instance, may be used by or on behalf of institutional investors to
execute orders that are typically too large to be executed all at once
without excessive price impact, and divide the orders into many small
orders that are fed into the marketplace over time.\884\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\880\ See Proposal, supra note 2 at 81052.
\881\ See id.
\882\ See id.
\883\ See id.
\884\ See id. See also Staff of the Division of Trading and
Markets, Commission, ``Equity Market Structure Literature Review,
Part II: High Frequency Trading,'' at 5 (March 18, 2014), http://www.sec.gov/marketstructure/research/hft_lit_review_march_2014.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in the Proposal, we believe that market participants
would benefit from increased disclosures about the use of a SOR(s) (or
similar functionality) or algorithm(s) by the broker-dealer operator or
its affiliates in connection with the NMS Stock ATS because of the
potential for information leakage.\885\ As also discussed in the
Proposal, broker-dealer operators of NMS Stock ATSs or their affiliates
may use SORs (or similar functionality) or algorithms in a variety of
ways.\886\ For example, the broker-dealer operator may use the SOR (or
similar functionality) to route their agency and principal orders to
different trading venues, or the broker-dealer operator may use the SOR
as the primary means of routing subscriber orders or trading interest
to or from the NMS Stock ATS. We understand that for some ATSs that
currently transact in NMS stocks, the SOR (or similar functionality) or
algorithm of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates is the only
means of access (i.e., all orders or trading interest entered on, or
removed from, the ATS, must pass through the SOR (or similar
functionality) or algorithm). A broker-dealer operator may also use a
SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm to handle all order flow
received by the broker-dealer operator (or its affiliates), including
both orders that a subscriber has specifically directed to the NMS
Stock ATS and orders that may not be sent to the NMS Stock ATS, as well
as the broker-dealer's own principal orders and those of its
affiliates. For many orders, the SOR (or similar functionality) or
algorithm determines whether to route the order to the NMS Stock ATS,
another ATS or a non-ATS trading center operated by the broker-dealer
operator, another broker-dealer, an unaffiliated NMS Stock ATS, or a
national securities exchange. The SOR (or similar functionality) may
obtain knowledge of subscriber orders or trading interest that have
been routed to the NMS Stock ATS (and may now be resting on the NMS
Stock ATS) and subscriber orders that have been routed out of the NMS
Stock ATS. Similarly, the system operating an algorithm used by the
broker-dealer operator to enter subscriber orders based on the
algorithm's trading strategy may obtain information about subscriber
orders sent to the NMS Stock ATS. The broker-dealer operator (or its
affiliates) programs and operates the SOR (or similar functionality)
and/or algorithm(s), unless the broker-dealer operator contracts such
functions to a third-party vendor, in which case the broker-dealer
operator or third-party vendor may have access to information that
passes through the SOR(s) (or similar functionality), algorithm(s) or
both. We continue to believe that the high likelihood that a SOR (or
similar functionality) or algorithm could access subscribers'
confidential trading information necessitates disclosure of certain
information to subscribers about the use of a SOR (or similar
functionality) or algorithm by the broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates to route subscriber orders to or out of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\885\ See Proposal, supra note 1, at 81052.
\886\ See id. Broker-dealer operators are likely to vary in
their organizational structures. Accordingly, Part III, Item 5 of
adopted Form ATS-N will include third parties that contract with the
broker-dealer operator and affiliates of the broker-dealer operator
that may operate a SOR(s) (or similar functionality) or algorithm to
help ensure that SORs (or similar functionalities) or algorithms
used with the NMS Stock ATSs are disclosed regardless of whether the
SOR(s) (or similar functionality) or algorithm(s) is operated by a
third-party contracting with the broker-dealer operator or an
affiliate of the broker-dealer operator.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A system may consist of various functionalities, mechanisms, or
protocols that operate collectively to bring together the orders for
securities of multiple buyers and sellers using non-discretionary
methods under the criteria of Rule 3b-16(a). In some circumstances, the
various functionalities, mechanisms, or protocols may be offered or
performed by another business unit of the broker-dealer operator or by
a separate entity.\887\ As discussed in the Proposal, broker-dealer
operators that use a SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm may
operate the SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm separate and
apart from their ATS.\888\ However, to the extent that a SOR (or
similar functionality) or algorithm performs a function of the NMS
Stock ATS to bring together the orders for securities of multiple
buyers and sellers using established nondiscretionary methods, the SOR
(or similar functionality) or algorithm may be considered part of the
NMS Stock ATS.\889\ We believe that information provided on Form ATS-N
about the use of a SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm in Part
III, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N will allow the Commission to better
understand the operations and scope of the NMS Stock ATS. That is, the
disclosures would assist the Commission in determining if a SOR (or
similar functionality) or algorithm is performing a function of the NMS
Stock ATS to bring together the orders for securities of multiple
buyers and sellers using established nondiscretionary methods, and
would consequently be part of the NMS Stock ATS for the purposes of
Regulation ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\887\ We stated in adopting Regulation ATS that we ``will
attribute the activities of a trading facility to a system if that
facility is offered by the system directly or indirectly'' and ``if
an organization arranges for separate entities to provide different
pieces of a trading system, which together meet the definition
contained in paragraph (a) of Rule 3b-16, the organization
responsible for arranging the collective efforts will be deemed to
have established a trading facility.'' See Regulation ATS Adopting
Release, supra note 3, at 70852.
\888\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81053.
\889\ In this example, if the SOR(s) (or similar functionality)
or algorithm(s) were operated by an affiliate of the NMS Stock ATS
or an entity unaffiliated with the NMS Stock ATS, the SOR(s) (or
similar functionality) or algorithm(s) could still be considered a
part of the NMS Stock ATS depending on the facts and circumstances.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, some commenters suggest reducing the level of detail
solicited in the proposed disclosures about the use of SORs (or other
functionalities) or algorithms. One commenter suggests reframing the
proposed requests regarding the use of SORs (or other functionality) or
algorithms to ``yes'' or ``no'' questions or attestations of ``no
advantage,'' and in situations where the broker-dealer operators or its
affiliates does have an advantage, the NMS Stock ATS should disclose
that advantage publicly and in similar detail to what was proposed in
Part III, Item 6.\890\ Another commenter states that if the Commission
does not eliminate or consolidate Part III, Item 6 of proposed Form
ATS-N, the commenter
[[Page 38845]]
recommends focusing the requests on the controls within the ATS (as
opposed to the attributes of the algorithm or SOR) and asking whether
the algorithm or SOR possesses information about the ATS by virtue of
its affiliation with the ATS that other algorithms or SORs do not
possess.\891\ Likewise, a commenter states that a more granular
requirement than progressive ``yes'' or ``no'' answers for Part III,
Item 6 of proposed Form ATS would pose challenges to maintain up-to-
date disclosures.\892\ This commenter recommends that Form ATS-N
disclosures about potential trading activity on the ATS should be
formatted as progressive ``yes'' or ``no'' questions and that certain
Form ATS-N disclosures may be subject to immediate change without
notice.\893\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\890\ See STA Letter at 5.
\891\ See SIFMA Letter at 15. The commenter also states that it
would like the Commission to define ``Person'' as used in proposed
Part III, Item 6(b). See id. The term ``Person'' is defined in Form
ATS-N. See supra Section V.A.2.
\892\ See KCG Letter at 10.
\893\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe that the requests about the means for entering
orders and trading interests on the NMS Stock ATS will be overly
burdensome to keep up-to-date on Form ATS-N because the requests do not
require a level of detail that would mandate an amendment for every
programming change to these services, such as an update to the routing
table. Furthermore, to the extent that an NMS Stock ATS is unable to
use a means for entering order and trading interests due to unexpected
circumstances, such as a power failure or act of nature, the NMS Stock
ATS could state in its Form ATS-N information about the alternative
procedures that the ATS would use for the entry of orders and trading
interests into the NMS Stock ATS under such exigent circumstances; this
would obviate the need for an amendment when such alternative
procedures are used. Finally, as explained in detail above, we believe
that the information solicited in adopted Form ATS-N about the use of
SORs (or similar functionalities) or algorithms by the ATS is very
important for market participants when evaluating potential conflicts
of interest on the ATS, so we do not think it would be helpful to
reduce the level of detail required by the adopted form as suggested by
these commenters.
6. Connectivity and Co-Location
Part IV, Item 4(b) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about co-location. We are adopting Part IV, Item 4(b) of
proposed Form ATS-N, with modifications, and renumbering the request as
Part III, Item 6 (``Connectivity and Co-location'') of adopted Form
ATS-N.
A commenter recommends that the Part IV, Item 4(b) co-location
request could be reworded as two ``yes'' or ``no'' questions, provides
recommended questions, and states that any further information
requested should be as simple and direct as possible without requiring
detailed, idiosyncratic information in the form.\894\ In response to
this comment, we have circumscribed the description of terms and
conditions of co-location services and are requiring ``a summary'' of
the terms and conditions for co-location and related services,
including the speed and connection (e.g., fiber, copper) options
offered. We believe a summary would provide market participants with
the necessary information to consider and evaluate the co-location and
related services the NMS Stock ATS is offering without requiring overly
burdensome disclosure. We do not believe that solely asking ``yes'' or
``no'' questions (with no obligation to provide additional detail)
would provide market participants with sufficient information to
evaluate the co-location services the NMS Stock ATS is offering. For
example, a price-sensitive market participant may not want to
participate on an ATS that offers co-located subscribers certain, more
expensive, high-speed connectivity options that the market participant
may perceive as providing an advantage to other subscribers that are
willing to pay for the service. Such information would not be disclosed
by ``yes'' or ``no'' questions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\894\ The commenter suggests the following two questions in
place of proposed Item 4(b): (i) Do you offer co-location to the ATS
matching engine, and (ii) do all clients have the same access to co-
location services? See SIFMA Letter at 22.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are reformatting the question regarding connectivity and co-
location in Part III, Item 6 of adopted Form ATS-N to provide two sub-
items that relate to speed of communication with the ATS, which were
requested in Part IV, Item 4(b) of proposed Form ATS-N. As adopted,
Part III, Item 6(c) of Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS to indicate
whether it provides any other means besides co-location and related
services described in the Item to increase the speed of communication
with the ATS, and if so, to explain the means and offer a summary of
the terms and conditions for its use.\895\ We separated the proposed
request for information related to means to increase the speed of
communication with the ATS into its own separate sub-item (i.e., Part
III, Item 6(c)) to improve readability, make the information easier to
locate, and facilitate comparisons across NMS Stock ATSs.\896\ We
believe the request is necessary to account for advances in technology.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\895\ Question 347 of the Proposal asks if Part IV, Item 4(b) of
Form ATS-N captures the information that is most relevant to
understanding the operations of the NMS Stock ATS related to co-
location services or any other means by which any subscriber or
other persons may enhance the speed by which to send or receive
orders, trading interest, or messages to or from the NMS Stock ATS.
See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81069.
\896\ See supra note 839. Part IV, Item 4(b) of proposed Form
ATS-N would have required an NMS Stock ATS to describe ``any other
means by which any subscriber or other persons may enhance the speed
by which to send or receive orders, trading interest, or messages to
or from the NMS Stock ATS.'' Part III, 6(c) of adopted Form ATS-N
would require similar information as Part IV, Item 4(b) of proposed
Form ATS-N. The language revisions are intended to simplify and
improve readability of the request.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also are adopting a request in Part III, Item 6(e) for the NMS
Stock ATS to indicate whether it offers any means to reduce the speed
of communication with the ATS and provide a summary of the terms and
conditions for its use. As indicated by commenters,\897\ latency is an
important feature of equity market trading, and market participants are
interested in understanding the functionalities employed by NMS Stock
ATSs to influence it. There have been recent developments in equity
market structure for trading centers to employ mechanisms to increase
the latency or the length of time for orders, trading interest, or
other information to travel from a user to the system.\898\ Part IV,
Item 7(a) of proposed Form ATS-N required an NMS Stock ATS to disclose
information about the means or facilities used by the ATS to bring
together the orders of multiple buyers and sellers, as well as the
established, non-discretionary methods that dictate the terms of
trading on the ATS. To the extent that an NMS Stock ATS applied a
functionality or means for the ATS or a subscriber to decrease speed of
communications with the NMS Stock ATS, the ATS would have been required
to disclose that functionality in response to Part IV, Item 7(a) of
proposed Form ATS-N. In adopted
[[Page 38846]]
Form ATS-N, because of commenters' concerns regarding communication
latencies with NMS Stock ATSs and the impact they may have on how the
subscriber's orders and trading interest are executed on the NMS Stock
ATS, we are making this request a separate sub-part for market
participants to more readily find information related to how a
subscriber communicates with the NMS Stock ATS. For Part III, Items
6(c) and 6(e), the Item requires a summary of the terms and conditions
of the services offered if applicable. We believe a summary would
provide subscribers and market participants with relevant information
about the NMS Stock ATS to consider and evaluate its services without
requiring overly burdensome disclosure.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\897\ See infra note 1037 and accompanying text.
\898\ See In the Matter of the Application of Investors'
Exchange, LLC for Registration as a National Securities Exchange, 81
FR 41142, 41154 (June 23, 2016) (explaining the use of the IEX coil
and an additional distance to the IEX trading system that results in
an equivalent 350 microseconds of latency) (``IEX Exchange
Registration''); Securities Exchange Act Release No. Release No.
80700 (May 16, 2017), 82 FR 23381 (May 22, 2017) (Order Approving
Proposed Rule Change Amending Rules 7.29E and 1.1E to Provide for a
Delay Mechanism) (approving rule change on NYSE MKT LLC to provide
for an intentional delay of 350 microseconds of latency to inbound
and outbound order messages).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also providing examples in Part III, Item 6 of adopted Form
ATS-N to clarify the types of services and connection options related
to co-location that an NMS Stock ATS may offer. We believe that
providing these examples will help NMS Stock ATSs better understand the
type of information that would be responsive to the Form ATS-N
requests.
We are providing further guidance as to what is required of NMS
Stock ATSs when disclosing any differences in the terms and conditions
among subscribers and the broker-dealer operator related to co-location
and related services. Subscribers of co-location services can
experience faster or slower connection speeds to an NMS Stock ATS
depending on factors such as the distance of the customer servers from
the matching engine, or the use or non-use of ``coiling'' to its
matching engine to equal connection speeds among subscribers, among
others. Such differences in connection speed or latency would be
required to be disclosed under Part III, Item 6(a).
7. Order Types and Attributes
Part IV, Item 3(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about order types and modifiers.\899\ We received comments
on Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N expressing general support
for the Commission's aim to provide disclosure for order types that
could benefit market participants' understanding how their orders may
be handled by the NMS Stock ATS and that could help optimize order
routing practices by market participants.\900\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\899\ Part IV, Item 3(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have
required an NMS Stock ATS to describe any requirements and handling
procedures for minimum order sizes, odd-lot orders, or mixed-lot
orders. The NMS Stock ATS would also have been required to describe
any differences if the requirements and handling procedures for
minimum order sizes, odd-lot orders, or mixed-lot orders were not
the same for all subscribers and persons. As discussed further
below, minimum order sizes, odd-lot orders, and mixed-lot orders are
addressed in Part III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N.
\900\ See ICI Letter at 7 (stating that disclosure would end the
practice of some ATSs of disclosing the existence of certain order
types to only favored subscribers and provide long term benefits by
allowing funds to optimize their order routing practices); SIFMA
Letter at 6 (suggesting the proposed Item requires useful
information for market participants, whose investments may be traded
indirectly on ATSs via their third-party broker-dealers). See also
Citadel Letter at 1; Better Markets Letter at 5; Morgan Stanley
Letter at 1; Markit Letter at 4; KCG Letter at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that all market participants should have
full information about the operations of order types available on an
NMS Stock ATS for market participants to comprehensively understand how
their orders and trading interest will be handled and executed on the
ATS. Accordingly, we are adopting Part IV, Item 3(a) of proposed Form
ATS-N with certain modifications described below, naming the Item
``Order Types and Attributes,'' and relocating the request as Part III,
Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N. Order types are a primary means by which
users of an NMS Stock ATS communicate their instructions for handling
their trading interest to the NMS Stock ATS. Moreover, order types can
be complex and operate in various ways. Given the importance of order
types and their complex nature, we are requiring NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose the information called for by Part III, Item 7 on adopted Form
ATS-N.
One commenter suggests that Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N
would require excessive information that would be unnecessarily
burdensome and duplicative, and offers several suggestions on how to
streamline the Item, including defining a set of order type terminology
for completing the form, allowing a table template for responses, and
suggested ``yes'' or ``no'' questions.\901\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\901\ See SIFMA Letter at 20-21.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe that it would be practical to define or
standardize order types because the operation and naming of order types
is not consistent across NMS Stock ATSs or trading centers, and broadly
similar order types can have many permutations.\902\ We believe that
Part III, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N provides NMS Stock ATSs with
necessary flexibility to describe the order types that the ATS offers
subscribers while still providing the necessary information for market
participants to understand how an order type will function.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\902\ See also Consolidated Audit Trail, Final Rule, Securities
Exchange Act Release No. 67457 (July 18, 2012), 77 FR 45722, 45742
(August 1, 2012) (declining under Rule 613 to enumerate specific
order types or prescribing the format or nature of how this
information would be represented to allow flexibility for the future
when new order types may be introduced and added).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For similar reasons, we are declining to adopt the commenter's
suggestions that Part IV, Item 3(a)(vi) of proposed Form ATS-N could be
simplified to a ``yes'' or ``no'' question asking whether each order
type is available to all subscribers. This Item specifically relates to
whether every order type is available across all forms of connectivity,
not to all subscribers.\903\ A ``yes'' or ``no'' format would not allow
an NMS Stock ATS to explain any differences in order types available
across all forms of connectivity, if any.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\903\ See supra note 901.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An NMS Stock ATS can choose a format that it finds best to provide
market participants with complete and comprehensible information, such
as, for instance, a table with the relevant characteristics of each
order type.
We have made several edits to remove duplicative requirements,
improve readability and specificity, and remove unnecessary
language.\904\ We are removing references to the ranking of order types
and time in force instructions to avoid duplication. We are revising
the language of the Item to require information on order types that
``can be'' entered on the NMS Stock ATS, because we intended for NMS
Stock ATSs to disclose to market participants the services that the ATS
offers. We are also removing superfluous language that is already
captured by the instruction to ``identify and explain.'' \905\ We are
also removing the language from proposed Part IV, Item 3(b) requiring
the NMS Stock ATS to describe any differences among subscribers in the
``availability of order types'' because the request to describe any
differences in the terms and conditions of order types among
subscribers and the broker-dealer operator in Part III, Item 7(b)
encompasses any differences in availability.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\904\ See SIFMA Letter at 20-21.
\905\ Specifically, we are removing language that NMS Stock ATS
describe the ``characteristics, operations, and how [order types]
are handled on the NMS Stock ATS.'' As indicated in the text, we do
not view this as a substantive change, and the information requested
using the deleted language is captured by the instruction to
identify and explain each order type.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adding in Part III, Item 7(a)(i) of adopted Form ATS-N that
the NMS Stock ATS provide not only whether an order type can receive a
new time stamp, but also, when, so that market
[[Page 38847]]
participants can better understand how their orders or trading interest
will be handled by the NMS Stock ATS. We are also removing the prompt
in the proposed Item that would have required information on whether an
order type can be used with any routing services offered because these
services are usually provided by the broker-dealer operator.
Finally, the Commission is providing further guidance with regard
to the prompt in Item 7(a)(vii) that the NMS Stock ATS describe the
circumstances under which orders types may be removed from the NMS
Stock ATS as the information required relates to the disclosures
required under Part III, Item 16 (Routing). While we are not requiring
broker-dealers to disclose information about their handling of customer
orders when such orders are not routed to the NMS Stock ATS, we believe
that market participants should be aware of how a subscriber order or
trading interest that has been received by and rests in the NMS Stock
ATS can be subsequently removed from the ATS. Such circumstances may be
as simple as the broker-dealer cancelling a customer order that it is
handling from the ATS, or such circumstances could include the broker-
dealer operator removing a third-party subscriber's order at its own
discretion. To the extent that this information about removal of orders
overlaps with the disclosures regarding routing of orders under Part
III, Item 16, the NMS Stock ATS need only provide the information in
Part III, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N. Additionally, the Part III,
Item 7 requests regarding removal of orders and trading interest from
the ATS will not require the broker-dealer operator to publicly
disclose its routing table or other information about where the order
is sent once it is removed from the NMS Stock ATS.
8. Order Sizes
Part IV, Item 3(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about order size requirements and odd-lot orders. We did
not receive any comments directed at Part IV, Item 3(c) of proposed
Form ATS-N; however, in response to commenters' general request for the
Commission to use more ``yes'' or ``no'' questions to navigate
information and facilitate comparisons, we are relocating Part IV, Item
3(c) of proposed Form ATS-N to Part III, Item 8 (``Order Sizes'') of
adopted Form ATS-N and adopting a ``yes'' or ``no'' format.\906\ In
addition, we are requiring that the NMS Stock ATS identify and explain
any differences in the treatment of subscribers and the broker-dealer
operator, as applicable, in separate sub-items 8(b), 8(d), and 8(f),
respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\906\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we are adding to Part III, Item 8(a) of adopted Form
ATS-N a request for the NMS Stock ATS to provide information about any
maximum order or trading interest size requirements.\907\ Adding a
request regarding a cap or maximum limit on an order size in the Part
III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N would help streamline an NMS Stock
ATS's response to Form ATS-N and help market participants understand,
the size requirements for trading on the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\907\ As proposed, Part IV, Item 3(b) requested information
about minimum order size requirements. Also, Part IV, Item 7(b) of
proposed Form ATS-N would have required NMS Stock ATS to disclose
information about the ``established, non-discretionary methods that
dictate the terms of trading . . . on the NMS Stock ATS.'' To the
extent that an NMS Stock ATS established a cap or a limit on the
size of orders or trading interest that the ATS would accept from
subscribers, this cap or limit would be a procedure governing the
trading on the ATS and would have been responsive to proposed Form
ATS-N (specifically, proposed Part IV, Item 7(b)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, we are providing examples in a parenthetical
indicating that ATSs state whether or not odd-lot and mix-lot orders
and trading interest are treated the same as round lot orders and
trading interest. Information regarding the treatment of odd-lot and
mixed-lot orders and trading interest compared to round lot orders and
trading interest could influence whether market participants submit
odd-lot or mixed-lot orders to the NMS Stock ATS.
9. Conditional Order and Indications of Interest
Part IV, Item 3(d) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about conditional orders and indications of interest. We
received one comment regarding Part IV, Item 3(d) of proposed Form ATS-
N contending that providing additional disclosure regarding order types
and handling (including the use of IOIs) is useful information for
subscribers and the investing public, whose investments may be traded
indirectly on ATS platforms via their third-party broker-dealers.\908\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\908\ See SIFMA Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting Part IV, Item 3(d) of proposed Form ATS-N with
modification and relocating the request to Part III, Item 9
(``Conditional Orders and Indications of Interest'') of adopted Form
ATS-N. Part III, Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N is designed to provide
specific information about the use of messages on the NMS Stock ATS, in
particular, IOIs, actionable IOIs, conditional orders, and similar
functionalities.\909\ As stated in the Proposal,\910\ NMS Stock ATSs
use IOIs to convey trading interest available on those trading centers.
Some NMS Stock ATSs also transmit ``actionable'' IOIs to selected
market participants for the purpose of attracting contra-side order
flow to the ATS. In general, an actionable IOI is an IOI containing
enough information to effectively alert the recipient about the details
of the NMS Stock ATS's trading interest in a security.\911\ While an
actionable IOI may not specify the price and/or size of the trading
interest, the practical context in which it is submitted implicitly or
explicitly conveys information about the symbol, side (buy or sell),
size (minimum of a round lot of trading interest), and price (at or
better than the NBBO, depending on the side of the order).\912\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\909\ See Proposal, supra note 1, at 81067 for additional
discussion of IOIs, actionable IOIs, conditional orders, and similar
functionalities.
\910\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81067.
\911\ See id.
\912\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conditional orders are also messages indicating trading interest on
a trading venue, and conditional orders generally function in a similar
manner to IOIs. A conditional order may contain the same attributes as
other order types when a subscriber enters it onto the trading venue
(e.g., side, price, and size), but NMS Stock ATSs will generally not
transmit those details to other subscribers or market
participants.\913\ Rather, the NMS Stock ATS will tentatively match the
conditional order with contra side interest and then alert the
subscriber that entered the conditional order of the potential match.
That subscriber may then either accept or decline the execution (i.e.,
``firm up'' the conditional order).\914\ As discussed in the Proposal,
NMS Stock ATSs may only permit conditional orders to execute against
other conditional orders, but some ATSs allow conditional orders to
interact with other order types.\915\ Understanding the manner in which
NMS Stock ATSs use messages that convey trading interest, such as IOIs,
actionable IOIs, conditional orders, and similar functionalities could
be useful to market participants in analyzing the potential execution
of a subscriber's trading interest.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\913\ See id.
\914\ See id.
\915\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to comment,\916\ we are removing the word
``circumstances''
[[Page 38848]]
from the request and adding more detail to the request to aid NMS Stock
ATSs in responding.\917\ The Commission is adding ``price or size
minimums'' as examples of information that could be contained in the
messages and ``order management system, smart order router and FIX'' to
illustrate the types of mechanisms that could transmit messages, such
as IOIs and conditional orders. In the Commission's experience, the
information that NMS Stock ATS include in IOIs and conditional orders
can vary, including different combinations of symbol, size and/or
price, and we believe that this information would be relevant to market
participants when understanding what information about their orders are
communicated to others and assessing potential information leakage.
Second, we are adding a requirement that the NMS Stock ATS identify the
type of persons that receive the message \918\ (e.g., subscriber,
trading center), and the possible responses to conditional orders or
IOIs (e.g., submission to firm-up conditional orders). These two
factors could help market participants understand when a message, such
as a conditional order or IOI, would result in an execution and provide
market participants important information to understand how the market
participant can use the ATS, who will see its trading interest, how its
trading interest will be executed, and the potential for information
leakage.\919\ Finally, we are including ``response time parameters,
interaction and matching'' as examples of topics to discuss when
disclosing the conditions under which the conditional order or IOI
might result in an execution in the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\916\ See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 9; BIDS Letter at 4; STA Letter
at 4.
\917\ We also believe the more explicit requests address
commenters' concerns that prompts like ``describe the
circumstances'' would not allow NMS Stock ATSs to know whether the
disclosure ``meets the Commission's expectation until after the Form
ATS-N itself or an amendment is filed.'' See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at
19.
\918\ We are requiring the ``type of Persons'' that receives the
message in this Item and are not requesting the names of individual
recipients in the case of natural persons.
\919\ The information required by the prompts to disclose the
type of recipient and possible responses to conditional orders or
IOIs would have been required in Part III, Item 3(d) of proposed
Form ATS-N in response to the request for ``circumstances in which
[the messages] may result in an execution on the NMS Stock ATS.''
Because commenters requested more specificity, we are making more
explicit the information required in Part III, Item 9(a) of adopted
Form ATS-N. See supra note 917.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
10. Opening and Reopening
Part IV, Item 9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about opening and reopening processes. We received one
comment on Part IV, Item 9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N stating that Part
IV of proposed Form ATS-N, including requests relating to the opening
and reopening procedures, is essential for investors or routing brokers
who are seeking to understand how the ATS works.\920\ We are adopting
Part IV, Item 9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications,
as described below in this section, and relocating the request as Part
III, Item 10 (``Opening and Reopening'') of adopted Form ATS-N. The
Commission is separating proposed Part IV, Items 9(b) (``Closing
Process'') and 9(c) (``After-Hours Trading'') of proposed Form ATS-N,
which were previously part of the same Item as Opening and Reopening
Processes (Part IV, Item 9(a)), into separate items on the adopted Form
ATS-N to facilitate locating information and making comparisons across
NMS Stock ATSs.\921\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\920\ See HMA Letter at 18.
\921\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As stated in the Proposal,\922\ Part III, Item 10 of adopted Form
ATS-N is designed to inform market participants about whether an NMS
Stock ATS uses any special procedures to match orders at the opening,
or to set a single opening or reopening price to, for example, maximize
liquidity and accurately reflect market conditions at the opening or
reopening of trading. The disclosures under this Item would allow for
comparisons between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges,
which conduct opening and closing auctions and permit members to enter
orders specially designated to execute on the opening. We continue to
believe that market participants would likely want to know about any
special opening or reopening processes employed by an NMS Stock ATS,
including if any order types participate in an NMS Stock ATS's opening
or reopening processes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\922\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81077.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, to provide additional guidance about what needs to be
included in the description of the opening and reopening process, we
are adding to Part III, Item 10 of adopted Form ATS-N that the ATS
describe: When and how such orders and trading interest are ``priced
[and] prioritized'' and ``any order types allowed'' during the opening
and reopening processes. Specifically requesting information about when
orders and trading interest will be priced and prioritized during the
opening or reopening of the ATS will provide market participants with
the information they need to plan and execute their trading strategies
during these periods. The Item would also, for example, require
disclosure of any procedures to match orders to set a single opening or
reopening price to maximize liquidity and accurately reflect market
conditions at the opening or reopening of trading.\923\ We believe most
participants consider important the rules and procedures surrounding
the pricing and priority of orders and trading interest, and the order
types allowed because these rules and procedures can directly impact
their execution price.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\923\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81077 n. 485, 486 and
accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the Proposal, we would have required the information related to
the pricing and priority of orders during the opening and reopening
processes and any order types allowed during that time period under
Part IV, Items 9(a) (``Opening and Reopening Process''), 7(b) (``Order
Interaction Rules'') and Item 3 (``Types of Orders''). Part IV, Item
9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N required, in part, a description of ``how
orders or other trading interest are matched and executed'' during an
opening or reopening. In order to fully describe the matching and
execution of orders during an opening or reopening in response to the
Item, the NMS Stock ATS would necessarily have needed to disclose the
pricing, priority, and order types allowed. Moreover, Part IV, Item
7(b) of proposed Form ATS requested information about the established
non-discretionary methods that dictate terms of trading among multiple
buyers and sellers, which included rules and procedures for priority
and pricing. In addition, Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N would
have required disclosure of ``any types of orders that are entered on
the NMS Stock,'' which would have included any order types during an
opening or reopening.
We are adding a specific question about the rules and procedures
for the opening and reopening process in Part III, Item 10 of adopted
Form ATS-N to help streamline responses to Form ATS-N requests and help
market participants locate and understand information about the opening
and reopening process on the ATS.\924\ In Part III, Item 10, we are
formatting the information requested, which parallels the Item in the
Proposal, into three subparts (adopted Items 10(a), 10(c) and 10(e))
and adding a ``yes'' or ``no'' question to Item 10(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\924\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. Trading Services, Facilities and Rules
Part IV, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding the trading services of the
[[Page 38849]]
NMS Stock ATS, including matching methodology, order interaction rules,
and other trading procedures. We are adopting Part IV, Item 7, with
modifications, as Part III, Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N and renaming
it ``Trading Services, Facilities, and Rules.'' Part III, Item 11 is
designed to inform market participants and the Commission about the
type of marketplace the NMS Stock ATS operates (e.g., crossing system,
auction market, limit order matching book). In addition, Part III, Item
11 is designed to solicit disclosures about the facilities,
functionalities, and mechanisms that the NMS Stock ATS uses to match
the orders and trading interest of counterparties and facilitate
transactions on the ATS. As discussed in the Regulation ATS Adopting
Release and restated in the Proposal,\925\ we explained that an ATS
brings together orders when orders entered into the system for a given
security have the opportunity to interact with other orders entered
into the system for the same security.\926\ An ATS can bring together
orders through various methods. For instance, a system brings together
orders if it displays, or otherwise represents, trading interests
entered on the system, such as a consolidated quote screen, to system
users.\927\ A system also brings together orders if it receives
subscribers' orders centrally for future processing and execution, such
as part of a limit order matching book that allows subscribers to
display buy and sell orders in particular securities and to obtain
execution against matching orders contemporaneously entered or stored
in the system.\928\ As explained above, to qualify for the Rule 3a1-
1(a)(2) exemption from the statutory definition of ``exchange,'' an ATS
must, among other things, bring together the orders of multiple buyers
and sellers.\929\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\925\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81073.
\926\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70849.
\927\ See id.
\928\ See id.
\929\ See id. In the Regulation ATS Adopting Release, systems in
which there is only a single seller, such as systems that permit
issuers to sell their own securities to investors, would not be
included within Rule 3b-16. See Regulation ATS Adopting Release,
supra note 3, at 70849. The Commission emphasized in the Regulation
ATS Adopting Release that the mere interpositioning of a designated
counterparty as riskless principal for settlement purposes after the
purchasing and selling counterparties to a trade have been matched
would not, by itself, mean that the system does not have multiple
buyers and sellers. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in the Proposal, ATSs that trade NMS stocks may offer
subscribers various types of trading mechanisms.\930\ For example, many
ATSs bring together multiple buyers and sellers using limit order
matching systems. Other ATSs use crossing mechanisms that allow
participants to enter unpriced orders to buy and sell securities, with
the ATS's system crossing orders at specified times at a price derived
from another market.\931\ Some ATSs use an auction mechanism that
matches multiple buyers and sellers by first pausing execution in a
certain security for a set amount of time, during which the ATS's
system seeks out and/or concentrates liquidity for the auction; after
the trading pause, orders will execute at either a single auction price
or according to the priority rules for the auction's execution.
Furthermore, some ATSs use a blotter scraping functionality, which may
inform the ATS's system about the orders placed on a participant's
order management system, but not yet entered into the ATS; the ATS or
broker-dealer operator oftentimes can automatically generate those
orders and enter them into the ATS on behalf of the subscriber, in
accordance with the relevant terms and conditions, when certain contra-
side trading interest exists in the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\930\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81073.
\931\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70849 n.37.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that it would be useful to market
participants to be availed information about the trading facilities,
functionalities, and mechanisms offered by an NMS Stock ATS to evaluate
whether the operations of the NMS Stock ATS comports with their trading
and investment strategies. Part III, Item 11(a) of adopted Form ATS-N
is consistent with Part IV, Item 7(a) of proposed Form ATS-N; however,
we are limiting the request to require NMS Stock ATSs to provide only a
summary of the structure of the NMS Stock ATS marketplace.\932\ The
summary is designed to provide market participants with a brief
overview of the type of market the ATS operates, such as a limit order
book, auction market, or crossing system, in a more concise manner.
This Item requires more detailed responses when explaining the means
and facilities for bringing together the orders of multiple buyers and
sellers on the NMS Stock ATS. We also separated the requested
information on whether the means and facilities are the same for all
subscribers and the broker-dealer operator into subpart Part III, 11(b)
and formatted the subpart request as a ``yes'' or ``no'' question in
response to comment.\933\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\932\ In the Proposal under Part IV, Item 7(a), we proposed that
the NMS Stock ATS describe the means or facilities used by the NMS
Stock ATS to bring together the orders of multiple buyers and
sellers, including ``the structure of the market.''
\933\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 11(c) is designed to inform market participants
about the rules and procedures used to determine how orders and trading
interest may interact on an NMS Stock ATS upon being entered into the
system.\934\ We previously explained in the Regulation ATS Adopting
Release that use of established, non-discretionary methods could
include operation of a trading facility or the setting of rules
governing subscribers' trading.\935\ For example, we consider the use
of an algorithm by an electronic trading system, which sets trading
procedures and priorities, to be a trading facility that uses
established, non-discretionary methods.\936\ Similarly, the Commission
has previously stated that rules imposing execution priorities, such as
time and price priority rules, would be ``established, non-
discretionary methods.'' \937\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\934\ One commenter states that, when discussing electronic
trading platforms for corporate bonds, ``as the Commission knows, a
bond trading platform that utilizes an RFQ [request for quote]
trading protocol is not an ATS.'' See MarketAxess Letter at 2.
Whether a platform that trades securities is an ATS depends on
whether that platform meets the definition of an ``exchange''
pursuant to the criteria of Exchange Act Rule 3b-16(a) which
requires a facts and circumstances analysis. A platform that uses an
RFQ protocol to trade securities would be subject to the Rule 3b-
16(a) analysis, and depending on its design, activities, and rules,
an RFQ platform may or may not meet the criteria of Rule 3b-16(a).
\935\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70851-52.
\936\ See id. at 70851.
\937\ See id. at 70852.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in the Proposal, NMS Stocks ATSs may employ various
terms and conditions under which orders interact and match.\938\ Some
NMS Stock ATSs may offer price-time priority to determine how to match
orders (potentially with various exceptions), while other NMS Stock
ATSs may offer midpoint-only matching with time priority. Some NMS
Stock ATSs might also take into account other factors to determine
priority. For example, an NMS Stock ATS may assign either a lower or
higher priority to an order entered by a subscriber in a certain class
(e.g., orders of proprietary traders or retail investors) or routed
from a particular source (e.g., orders routed by the broker-dealer
operator's SOR (or similar functionality) or algorithm) when compared
to an equally priced order entered by a different subscriber or via a
different source. Furthermore, in the Commission's experience, an NMS
Stock ATS might elect to apply
[[Page 38850]]
different priority rules for matching conditional orders than it does
for matching other order types. Part III, Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N
will allow the Commission to better evaluate whether the entity that
filed a proposed Form ATS-N meets the criteria of Exchange Act Rule 3b-
16 and the definition of an NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\938\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81074.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In Part III, Item 11(c) of adopted Form ATS-N, we are combining the
requests in Part IV, Items 7(b) (``Order Interaction Rules'') and 7(c)
(``Other Trading Procedures'') of proposed Form ATS-N. Part IV, Items
7(b) and 7(c) of proposed Form ATS-N were intended to solicit
information about the ATS's established non-discretionary methods that
dictate the terms of trading among the multiple buyers and sellers
entering orders and trading interest. In addition to a trading
facility, non-discretionary methods include rules and procedures.\939\
Adopted Part III, Item 11(c) combines the requests in Part IV, Items
7(b) and 7(c) of proposed Form ATS-N and is designed to communicate the
rules and procedures that govern how their orders will be executed on
the NMS Stock ATS. We are revising the language in adopted Item 11(c)
to recognize this overlap by requiring the NMS Stock ATS to ``explain
the established, non-discretionary rules and procedures of the NMS
Stock ATS, including order interaction rules,'' which requires the same
information as the proposed subparts. As another component of an NMS
Stock ATS's non-discretionary methods, we are moving the trading
procedures in proposed Item 7(c) into adopted Item 11(c) and including
the examples of the trading procedures of an NMS Stock ATS (e.g., price
protection mechanisms, shorts sales, locked-cross markets) into adopted
Item 11(c) as well.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\939\ The Commission recognized the intersection of
``established, non-discretionary methods that dictate the terms of
trading'' and ``trading procedures'' in the Regulation ATS Adopting
Release when it stated that the second essential element of what
constitutes an exchange is that trading on the exchange takes place
according to ``established, non-discretionary rules or procedures.''
See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at 70900. The
Commission is adopting this formulation in Part III, Item 11(c),
which we believe encompasses the information proposed to be required
in Part IV, Items 7(b) and 7(c) of proposed Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A description of the ``established non-discretionary rules and
procedures'' of the NMS Stock ATS is a principal requirement of Item
11(c) and we are requiring that any differences among subscribers and
the broker-dealer operator related to these methods be identified and
explained. This request was moved to Part III, 11(d) and formatted as a
``yes'' or ``no'' question in response to comment.\940\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\940\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We seek to provide additional guidance regarding the procedures
that need to be discussed in this Item.\941\ Specifically, in response
to various initiatives (e.g., pilot programs, national market system
plans, rules and regulations), NMS Stock ATSs have designed and/or
modified the design of their systems and trading procedures to comply
with these initiatives, including, for example, Regulation NMS,\942\
and more recently, the Tick Size Pilot.\943\ To be fully informed about
the trading procedures of the NMS Stock ATS, we believe that market
participants would need to understand the operations and procedures
that NMS Stock ATSs adopt in response to these initiatives as the
responses could affect the decision of a market participant to use the
NMS Stock ATS.\944\ To the extent an NMS Stock ATS has designed trading
procedures to operate consistently with Commission initiatives, the NMS
Stock ATS would need to disclose these procedures in response to this
Item (Part III, Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N). Furthermore, this
information required on trading procedures resulting from Commission
initiatives was encompassed under Part IV, Items 7(b) and 7(c) of
proposed Form ATS-N, which proposed requiring comprehensive information
on order interaction rules and trading procedures, including all of the
established non-discretionary methods that dictate the terms of trading
on the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\941\ See SIFMA Letter at 24 (stating item as proposed could
result in discursive disclosures of limited use to market
participants).
\942\ For example, Rule 611 of Regulation NMS, which requires a
trading center to establish, maintain, and enforce written policies
and procedures that are reasonably designed to prevent trade-
throughs on that trading center, subject to certain exceptions. See
17 CFR 242.611.
\943\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. Release No. 74892
(May 6, 2015), 80 FR 27513 (May 13, 2015) (File No. 4-657) (Order
Approving the National Market System Plan to Implement a Tick Size
Pilot Program [(``Tick Size Pilot'')] by BATS Exchange, Inc., BATS
Y-Exchange, Inc., Chicago Stock Exchange, Inc., EDGA Exchange, Inc.,
EDGX Exchange, Inc., Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.,
NASDAQ OMX BX, Inc., NASDAQ OMX PHLX LLC, The Nasdaq Stock Market
LLC, New York Stock Exchange LLC, NYSE MKT LLC, and NYSE Arca, Inc.,
as Modified by the Commission, For a Two-Year Period) (modifying the
definition of ``block-size'' for purposes of the Tick Size Pilot to
an order (1) of at least 5,000 shares or (2) with a market value of
at least $100,000).
\944\ As discussed in the Proposal, NMS Stock ATSs apply various
trading procedures to determine an execution price based on the
circumstances of the match. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81074.
For example, an ATS may price an execution of a midpoint pegged
order with a limit or market order at the midpoint of the NBBO. An
ATS executing a match of two limit orders, or a limit and market
order, might price the execution at or within the NBBO, with the
possibility of offering the limit order(s) price improvement. On the
other hand, an ATS that operates a block crossing network, with
specialized size discovery mechanisms, might calculate a volume-
weighted average price after the final size of the execution has
been determined.
In the Commission's experience, NMS Stock ATSs have trading
procedures for executing orders that include price protections to
re-price orders or prevent their execution under certain
circumstances, such as Limit Up Limit Down price bands pursuant to
the National Market System Plan to Address Extraordinary Market
Volatility (``LULD Plan''), or short sales to be executed on its
system. Thus, an NMS Stock ATS would be required to configure its
system to comply with federal securities laws related to short
sales, including Regulation SHO, rules and procedures governing and/
or precluding the execution of orders in a locked or crossed market,
or procedures governing the handling of execution errors, such as
the use of an error account by the NMS Stock ATS.
Other trading procedures include protocols for time-stamping
orders and executions to ensure compliance with the Exchange Act and
the rules and regulations thereunder and any execution procedures
related to price improvement. For example, an NMS Stock ATS may have
procedures to reprice orders under its price protection mechanisms,
to reprice short sale orders to ensure compliance with Regulation
SHO, or to reprice orders due to price-sliding order types (such as
certain pegged order types); it would be required to explain when it
creates new timestamps for such re-priced orders. Trading procedures
include any functionality or mechanism available on the NMS Stock
ATS that allows for price improvement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter suggests that disclosure of certain additional
trading services should be required, specifically whether the NMS Stock
ATS employs technology designed to detect and deter price manipulation
and other disruptive trading practices, i.e., anti-gaming technology,
and if so, to include a description of this technology in the
form.\945\ Another commenter states that anti-gaming technology and
other subscriber-related safeguards are among the core attributes of
ATSs that are of particular importance to buy-side institutions.\946\
We, however, are not adopting a request related to anti-gaming
technology and subscriber-related safeguards because such descriptions
made in a publicly available document could serve to undermine those
safeguards by disclosing information that makes evading those
safeguards easier.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\945\ See ICI Letter at 9-10. See also Memorandum from the
Office of Commissioner Kara Stein regarding a July 26, 2016 meeting
with representatives of Morgan Stanley (including in a presentation
that whether an ATS has anti-gaming controls is among the frequently
asked questions by clients).
\946\ See State Street Letter at 2-3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that Part IV, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N
had ``the potential to become quite technical and granular'' and thus
perhaps of limited use to end-readers, and suggests the Commission
consider ``requesting
[[Page 38851]]
high-level generalized descriptions or converting these prompts to a
more narrow set of focused, ``yes'' or ``no'' or short-answer questions
with more detail available to regulators as needed for surveillance or
other purposes.'' \947\ The commenter also indicates that prompts to
``describe'' require extensive disclosures that would be difficult to
maintain current. Part III of adopted Form ATS-N requests information
about common operational attributes of NMS Stock ATSs, which are
organized by subject matter to facilitate market participants'
understanding and evaluation of an NMS Stock ATS. The Commission
recognizes that requests in Part III, Item 11 could be more expansive
than other requests in Part III; however, Part III, Item 11 of adopted
Form ATS-N is designed to solicit information about the unique rules
and procedures that are tailored for the trading activities and
interaction of orders of subscribers on the NMS Stock ATS. National
securities exchanges make public similar information in their rule
books, in detail, which are designed to provide their members with
information about how they should expect their orders to be handled by
the exchange. It would be impractical to posit ``yes'' or ``no'' to NMS
Stock ATSs without allowing NMS Stock ATSs to explain how their trading
mechanisms or trading procedures operate. We also believe that ``yes''
or ``no'' questions, in this case, have the potential to quickly become
outdated as practices in the securities industry evolve and new
developments emerge. As the industry and NMS Stock ATS operations
change, NMS Stock ATS can better provide market participants with
complete and comprehensive disclosures if they are able to describe how
their system operates in their own words. We also are not discounting
that certain items may only require a short answer depending on the
complexity of the trading rules and procedures of the NMS Stock ATS. In
addition, the commenter's suggestion that more detail could be given to
regulators as needed does not address the need for market participants
to have full information about the ATS's trading rules, procedures, and
facilities to determine whether to route orders to the system for
execution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\947\ See SIFMA Letter at 24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not believe, as suggested by a commenter, that Part III, Item
11 of adopted Form ATS-N will require ``discursive disclosures'' \948\
that would make maintaining a current Form ATS-N challenging. Although
the item requires substantial information depending on the complexity
of the NMS Stock ATS, Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A)-(C) of Regulation ATS
provides a mechanism for an NMS Stock ATS to file amendments to Form
ATS-N that allows for both material changes to the operations of an ATS
and updating amendments. We believe that an NMS Stock ATS may keep
current its Form ATS-N without the obligation to file continuous
updates for non-material changes by filing an updating amendment under
Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\948\ See supra note 941 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter suggests that both Part IV, Item 7 and Item 8
(relating to suspensions of trading, system disruptions or
malfunctions) of proposed Form ATS-N would be better suited as a
required disclosure to subscribers that could be included in
contractual agreements or systematically available to subscribers on
ATS operators' websites, rather than formally filed with the
Commission.'' \949\ We, however, believe that this information could be
useful to potential subscribers to evaluate an NMS Stock ATS as a
potential destination for its orders.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\949\ See SIFMA Letter at 24-25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that the Commission require NMS Stock ATSs
to disclose precise, mathematically analyzable specifications of their
algorithms to enable the Commission and financial firms to leverage
formal verification techniques to automatically analyze the
specifications for potential violations of regulations, and allow
market participants to automatically test their connectivity and verify
their routing algorithms (for best execution principles).\950\ We
believe that requiring disclosure of mathematically analyzable
specifications, which would be used to conduct compliance checks by the
Commission, is outside of the scope of this rulemaking.\951\ While we
will review Form ATS-N filings, the Commission's review is not designed
to verify the accuracy of the disclosures nor designed as an
independent investigation of whether all aspects of the NMS Stock ATS
operations or the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator
are disclosed on Form ATS-N.\952\ At this time, we believe that the
Commission's compliance oversight of NMS Stock ATSs would best be
served through the Commission's and the SRO's examination and
inspection efforts.\953\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\950\ See AI Letter at 1-3.
\951\ We did not propose compliance checks for NMS Stock ATSs
and the commenter's recommendation is not currently required of
other trading centers, such as national securities exchanges.
\952\ See Section IV.A.3.
\953\ The commenter also suggests that we adopt a test that
would only require NMS Stock ATSs to disclose information necessary
to write an observationally-equivalent simulator of the venue. See
AI Letter at 2. As we are not adopting the commenter's suggestion to
require NMS Stock ATSs to disclose operational details in a
mathematically-analyzable format, we do not believe that such a test
would be appropriate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. Liquidity Providers
Part IV, Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding liquidity providers to the NMS Stock ATS. The
Commission is adopting Part IV, Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N as
Part III, Item 12 (``Liquidity Providers'') of adopted Form ATS-N with
certain modifications, which are discussed below. As discussed in the
Proposal,\954\ we believe that an NMS Stock ATS may want to ensure that
there is sufficient liquidity in a particular NMS stock to incentivize
market participants to send order flow in that NMS stock to the ATS.
Some ATSs that trade NMS stocks may engage certain subscribers to
provide liquidity to the NMS Stock ATS and perform similar functions to
that of a market maker on a national securities exchange.\955\ The
obligations required of liquidity providers and the benefits that they
provide vary across NMS Stock ATSs. We believe that information about
liquidity providers would be useful to subscribers and market
participants who, for example, may want their orders to only interact
with agency orders (and not with those of a liquidity provider), or,
conversely, may themselves want to become liquidity providers on the
NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\954\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81062-63.
\955\ These liquidity providers may quote in a particular NMS
stock on the ATS during trading hours and may receive a benefit for
performing this function, such as discounts on fees, rebates, or the
opportunity to execute with a particular type of segmented order
flow.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that the term ``liquidity provider'' should
be specifically defined; however, the commenter did not suggest a
definition.\956\ While we are not adopting a specific definition of
liquidity provider, the Commission is providing examples of the
functions a liquidity provider could perform on the NMS Stock ATS in
Part III, Item 12 of adopted Form ATS-N. We believe that such
arrangement could take many forms and the function of the liquidity
provider on an ATS could depend on the structure and trading protocols
of the ATS. Furthermore, as explained above,\957\ we
[[Page 38852]]
intend for this Item to cover, for example, arrangements or agreements
between the broker-dealer operator and another party to trade on the
NMS Stock ATS. We do not intend this to cover agreements with a
subscriber that has no obligation to buy or sell NMS stocks on the
system.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\956\ See KCG Letter at 12.
\957\ See supra Sections V.C.1 and V.C.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that the Commission should consider
eliminating or consolidating Part IV, Items 1(c) and 1(d) of proposed
Form ATS-N and suggests these subparts are redundant with information
about segmentation sought in Part III of proposed Form ATS-N.\958\ Part
III, Item 12, however, requests information about subscribers or the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates that are obligated in some way
to buy, sell, or both, NMS stocks on the ATS; while Part III, Item 13
pertains to disclosure about categorization of orders and trading
interest submitted to the NMS Stock ATS.\959\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\958\ See SIFMA Letter at 20. See supra Section V.D.1 for
discussion of proposed Item 1(c) and comments thereto, and comments
applicable to Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N as a whole.
\959\ See Section V.D.13 (Segmentation; Notice).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After considering whether Part IV, Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N
may overlap with any other items on the form, we require ATSs in Part
II, Items 1(c) and 2(c) of adopted Form ATS-N to indicate whether there
are any formal or informal arrangements with the broker-dealer operator
and affiliate of the broker-dealer operator, respectively. As discussed
above, if the answer is ``yes'' to any of these items, the NMS Stock
ATS must identify the broker-dealer operator (e.g., business unit) or
the affiliate in Part II, Items 1(c) and 2(c).\960\ In addition, the
NMS Stock ATS would be required to complete Part III, Item 12 of
adopted Form ATS-N regarding the arrangements with the broker-dealer
operator or affiliate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\960\ See supra Section V.C.1 (discussing the requirements of
Part II, Items 1(c) and 2(c)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
13. Segmentation; Notice
Part IV, Items 5(a) and 5(b) of proposed Form ATS-N would have
required disclosures regarding segmentation of order flow and notice of
segmentation. We are adopting Part IV, Item 5 with certain
modifications. We are also renumbering the request as Part III, Item 13
of adopted Form ATS-N and renaming it ``Segmentation; Notice.'' As
discussed in the Proposal, some NMS Stock ATSs elect to segment order
flow entered in the NMS Stock ATS according to various categories.\961\
An NMS Stock ATS could elect to segment trading interest by type of
participant (e.g., buy-side or sell-side firms, principal trading
firms, agency-only firms, firms above or below certain assets under
management thresholds). In addition, buy-side or institutional
subscribers might seek to trade only against other buy-side or
institutional order flow, or might seek to avoid trading against
principal trading firms or so-called high frequency trading firms. When
segmenting order flow in the system, an NMS Stock ATS might elect to
look to the underlying source of the trading interest such as the
trading interest of retail customers. Some NMS Stock ATSs segment by
the nature of the trading activity, which could include segmenting by
patterns of behavior, time horizons of traders, or the passivity or
aggressiveness of trading strategies. NMS Stock ATSs might elect to use
some combination of these criteria or other criteria altogether.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\961\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81070.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters express support for the Commission requiring
information about order segmentation.\962\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\962\ See ICI Letter at 9 (stating it would inform funds of the
possibility of order segmentation and allow funds to determine
whether to avoid trading with certain types of market participants).
See also UBS Letter at 7; Fidelity Letter at 8; SIFMA Letter at 23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission also received comments recommending changes to
aspects of Part IV, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N. One commenter
suggests that the Item should be converted to a series of ``yes'' or
``no'' questions and that the Item overlaps with Part IV, Item 1 of
proposed Form ATS-N.\963\ The Commission is adding a ``yes'' or ``no''
question to Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N for ATSs to convey,
and so market participants can readily understand, whether the NMS
Stock ATS segments orders and trading interest and whether the ATS
discloses to any Person the designated segmented category,
classification, tier, or level of orders and trading interest of a
subscriber or person. We believe that a response to a request that
includes solely ``yes'' or ``no'' questions would not provide the
necessary detail for market participants to understand and evaluate how
the NMS Stock ATS segments trading interest and against whose order
flow their trading interest could match. Moreover, the Commission has
revised Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N (Part III, Item 1 of
adopted Form ATS-N) to eliminate overlap.\964\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\963\ See SIFMA Letter at 22-23.
\964\ See supra Section V.D.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters express concern that Part IV, Item 5 of proposed
Form ATS-N would have required the publication of precise metrics used
to segment trading interest that could result in the gaming of those
metrics to the detriment of order flow on the ATS.\965\ The Commission
recognizes the concerns of commenters that believe describing the
precise criteria used to segment trading interest could result in
potential gaming of those criteria and thus, the reduction of the
effectiveness of segmentation as a control. On the other hand, we
believe that market participants are interested in understanding how
their orders and trading interest are categorized on the ATS and the
types of market participants that would interact with those orders and
trading interest. We believe that Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form
ATS-N appropriately balances these competing interests by soliciting a
summary of the parameters for each segmented category and length of
time each segmented category is in effect.\966\ Requiring NMS Stock
ATSs to provide a summary of these parameters on Form ATS-N, rather
than a detailed analysis of those parameters and how they are
calculated, is designed to avoid responses that could allow the gaming
of segmentation criteria, as suggested by commenters.\967\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\965\ See UBS Letter at 7; Fidelity Letter at 8. See also SIFMA
Letter at 23 (stating that disclosing proprietary or sensitive
information as required by this item is not necessary or
appropriate).
\966\ In the Commission's experience, NMS Stock ATSs can vary
the lengths of time that a segmented category is in force, such as
one day, week, or monthly. The NMS Stock ATS must disclose in
responding to this Item if any such time period applies to its
segmentation parameters. We proposed requiring this information in
Part IV, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N by proposing to require that
the NMS Stock ATS disclose any procedures for evaluating and
changing segmented categories, which may be affected by the length
of time a subscriber is placed in a category. We are specifying here
that the length of time that a segmented category is in force is
responsive to facilitate responding to the Item.
\967\ We note that, as part of our review of Form ATS-N
responses, we intend to monitor the level of summary information
provided on the form for completeness to help ensure that such
information is responsive to the form and is not designed to avoid
meaningful disclosure.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters suggest that the information requested by Part IV, Item
5 of proposed Form ATS-N could be provided to the Commission
confidentially,\968\ or the ATS be allowed to redact classification
criteria that is based upon trading characteristics from Form ATS-N
prior to its release.\969\ We believe that allowing NMS Stock ATSs to
provide summary information in response to Part III, Item 13 on adopted
Form ATS-N addresses the concerns
[[Page 38853]]
underlying the commenters' suggestions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\968\ See UBS Letter at 7 (stating that if the Commission
continues to believe the information is necessary, then access
should be restricted solely to the Commission); SIFMA Letter at 23.
\969\ See Fidelity Letter at 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter suggests that information barriers between the
ATS and other affiliates would ``make it challenging or inappropriate
for the ATS itself to seek some of this information.'' \970\ The ATS
has no need to seek information from affiliates to respond to this Item
as it relates solely to the segmentation of orders and trading interest
in the NMS Stock ATS and how such orders and trading are segmented for
purposes of order interaction and execution in the NMS Stock ATS.\971\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\970\ See SIFMA Letter at 23.
\971\ To the extent that orders or trading interest are
segmented outside the NMS Stock ATS and then sent to the NMS Stock
ATS for handling and execution, the functionality or entity
segmenting order or trading interest could be considered part of the
NMS Stock ATS, and information about its activity may be responsive
to the Form ATS-N requests. See supra note 888 and accompanying
text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter recommends that an NMS Stock ATS should be
required to disclose whether it identifies customer orders of broker-
dealers as customer orders (which it views as a form of
segmentation).\972\ The commenter states disclosing the origin of a
particular order can contribute to information leakage and adverse
selection of fund orders. We agree with the commenter's concerns and
are adding a ``yes'' or ``no'' question to solicit information
regarding whether the NMS Stock ATS identifies orders or trading
interest entered by a customer of a broker-dealer on the NMS Stock ATS
as a customer order. We agree with the commenter that disclosing the
origin of a customer order of a broker-dealer is a form of segmentation
because it can facilitate users restricting their trading to only
certain types of market participants, and that it can contribute to
information leakage and adverse selection of fund orders.\973\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\972\ See ICI Letter at 9.
\973\ Part IV, Item 5(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have
required an NMS Stock ATS to describe any segmentation of orders and
other trading interest on the ATS. In the Proposal, we provided
``classification by type of participant'' or ``source'' as examples
of forms of segmentation. We consider identifying the orders of
customers of broker-dealers (i.e., the source or type of
participant) a form of segmentation and providing a separate request
on the form would facilitate market participants' understanding of
the ATS's segmentation categories.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter states that Part IV, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-
N would be more meaningful if there was a quantitative component, such
as the percentage of orders and trades per segmented class.\974\ We are
not requiring that NMS Stock ATSs provide quantitative information on
each segmented class at this time. We believe that providing market
participants with narrative disclosures about the operations of the NMS
Stock ATS, which oftentimes is not publicly available, will allow
market participants to understand the nature of order flow in the ATS.
Nevertheless, we intend to monitor the quality of responses and
information received through Form ATS-N and will continually assess in
the future whether quantitative information would facilitate
operational transparency for NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\974\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5. The commenter states that a
quantitative component would provide investors with information on
the extent to which a broker-dealer operator or its affiliate
transacts on the NMS Stock ATS. However, Part II, Items 1, 2, and 3
of adopted Form ATS are designed to provide disclosures about the
nature of trading by the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates
in the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also are modifying certain components of Part IV, Item 5
proposed Form ATS-N (as adopted in Part III, Item 13). First, we are
adding the terms ``classifications, tiers, or levels'' in addition to
``categories'' to describe the groupings into which an NMS Stock ATS
elects to segment subscriber orders to better reflect the language used
by commenters and in existing Form ATS disclosures. Second, we are
providing two additional examples, order size and duration,\975\ of
criteria whereby an NMS Stock ATS might elect to segment subscribers'
orders and trading interest. We are providing these examples to provide
additional guidance on some of the types of segmentation that would be
responsive to the Item and allow NMS Stock ATSs to focus their
responses accordingly. Third, we are providing additional specificity
around what ``changing segmented categories'' means by requiring NMS
Stock ATSs to provide a discussion of procedures for overriding a
determination of segmented category. Subscribers would likely want to
know of any such procedures, which could affect the trading interest
against which their orders trade.\976\ Fourth, we are requiring a
description of how segmentation affects order interaction in Part III,
Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N. We proposed that an NMS Stock ATS
provide information about its order interaction rule in Part IV, Item 7
of proposed Form ATS-N, but believe that it would be more relevant and
efficient to request that information here.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\975\ Duration can refer to segmenting trading interest
according to how long it has rested on the book of a trading system.
\976\ Thus, if an NMS Stock ATS has established automated and
empirical tests for segmenting subscribers into different
categories--which would require the ATS to respond ``yes'' to Item
III, 13(a) of adopted Form ATS-N and to explain how the segmentation
procedures are applied--but allows any kind of override of those
automated and empirical tests (such as an ad hoc determination by a
member of the ATS's staff), the NMS Stock ATS would have to respond
``no'' to Item III, 13(b) (``Are the segmentation procedures the
same for all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator?'') and
explain any differences in how its segmentation procedures are
applied.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, we are requiring under Part III, Item 13(d) of adopted
Form ATS-N that the NMS Stock ATS describe ``whether and how [a
designated segmented category] can be contested'' (if applicable). This
request is generally consistent with Part IV, Item 5 of proposed Form
ATS-N which would have required information on the changing or
overriding of segmented categories, as well as notice provided to
subscribers of their segmented category.
14. Counter-Party Selection
Part IV, Item 5(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding order preferencing. The Commission did not
receive specific comment on Part IV, Item 5(c) of proposed Form ATS-
N.\977\ We are adopting Part IV, Item 5(c) as Part III, Item 14
(``Counter-Party Selection'') of adopted Form ATS-N and adding examples
of counter-party selection in a parenthetical in the Item. Market
participants have an interest in knowing whether--and how--they may
designate their orders or trading interest to interact or avoid
interacting with specific orders, trading interest, or persons on an
NMS Stock ATS. For instance, the disclosures required under this Item
would allow a market participant to know whether it could designate an
order submitted to the NMS Stock ATS to interact with specific orders
resting in the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\977\ One commenter states that it is unclear whether Part IV,
Item 1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N requests disclosure of instances
where a subscriber requests not to interact with certain
counterparties. See SIFMA Letter at 20. As discussed in Part III,
Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N above, any procedures related to
counter-party selection would be responsive to this item (Part III,
Item 14 of adopted Form ATS-N).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
15. Display
Part IV, Item 6(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about the display of order and trading interest, including
recipients. We received several comments on Part IV, Item 6(a) of
proposed Form ATS-N. We are adopting Part IV, Item 6(a) of proposed
Form ATS-N with modifications, as discussed more fully below, and
renumbering the request as Part III, Item 15 (``Display'') of adopted
Form ATS-N. The display of subscriber orders and trading interest can
occur in a number of ways. For instance, as
[[Page 38854]]
discussed in the Proposal,\978\ when an NMS Stock ATS sends electronic
messages outside of the ATS that expose the presence of orders or other
trading interest on the ATS, it is displaying or making known orders or
other trading interest on the NMS Stock ATS. An NMS Stock ATS also
might elect to display subscriber order and trading interest through a
direct data feed from the NMS Stock ATS that contains real-time
information about current quotes, orders, or other trading interest in
the NMS Stock ATS. Also, it would be responsive to this adopted Item
for the NMS Stock ATS to disclose the circumstances under which the ATS
would send these messages, the types of market participants that
received them, and the information contained in the messages, including
the exact content of the information, such as symbol, price, size,
attribution, or any other information made known.\979\ In addition, an
NMS Stock ATS would need to disclose arrangements, whether formal or
informal (oral or written) to the extent they exist, with third parties
to display the NMS Stock ATS's trading interest outside of the NMS
Stock ATS, such as IOIs from the subscribers being displayed on vendor
systems, or arrangements with third parties to transmit IOIs between
subscribers.\980\ We continue to believe that subscribers that use the
services of the NMS Stock ATSs, including customers of the broker-
dealer operator, have limited information about the extent to which
their orders and trading interest sent to the NMS Stock ATS could be
displayed outside the ATS.\981\ For example, subscriber orders or
trading interests directed to the NMS Stock ATS could pass through the
broker-dealer operator's systems or functionality before entering the
ATS. Such systems and functionalities, which could include a common
gateway function, algorithm, or smart order router, could be used to
support the broker-dealer operator's other business units, including
any trading centers.\982\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\978\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81072.
\979\ See id.
\980\ See id.
\981\ See id.
\982\ The broker-dealer operator typically controls the logic
contained in these systems or functionality that determines where an
order that the broker-dealer receives will be handled or sent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter supports this item.\983\ Other comments raise certain
concerns about Part IV, Item 6(a) of proposed Form ATS-N. One commenter
states that the proposed Item would cover ``order information or other
trading interest'' rather than ``subscriber order information or other
trading interest'' and could entangle the ordinary situation where a
multi-service broker-dealer that operates an ATS uses a tool to manage
child orders across multiple trading venues.\984\ Another commenter
suggests that the Commission draw a clearer distinction between the
actions and operations of an ATS operator and those of affiliated
broker-dealers, technical support teams, or others external to the ATS,
and instead emphasize disclosures relating to the ATS operator
itself.\985\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\983\ See HMA Letter at 18.
\984\ See UBS Letter at 8.
\985\ See SIFMA Letter at 23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to these commenters' suggestions, we are changing the
request to ``subscriber orders and trading interest.'' We did not
intend for the Proposal to, in the commenter's words, entangle the
ordinary situation where a multi-service broker-dealer uses a tool to
manage child orders across multiple trading venues.\986\ Consistent
with the discussion above regarding the definition of subscriber, a
subscriber order directed to the ATS would be a subscriber order for
purposes of display. For a subscriber order routed out of the NMS Stock
ATS to a third-party trading venue, for example, that order in the
third-party venue would not be considered a subscriber order for
purposes of display.\987\ As explained above,\988\ we do not intend for
Form ATS-N to require disclosures about aspects of a market
participant's commercial relationships with a broker-dealer operator
that do not pertain to the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\986\ See UBS Letter at 8.
\987\ See supra Section V.A.2.b.
\988\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A commenter suggests a better way of phrasing Part IV, Item 6(a) of
proposed Form ATS-N would be to ask whether orders or IOIs are ever
displayed in external venues, with which venues, and what information
is shared.\989\ However, the form of this request is broader, as just
discussed, and limiting the request for information to orders and
trading interest displayed in external venues would not capture all of
the relevant locations where subscriber orders and trading interest can
be displayed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\989\ See SIFMA Letter at 23. The commenter also states the need
for frequent filing of amendments and the demand for specificity
will diminish the readability, comparability and ultimately the
usefulness of the form for subscribers and other end readers. See
id. at 24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that the Commission revise this Item to
distinguish between orders or other trading interest displayed in
external venues with real-time access to systems designed to take
advantage of this information, such as liquidity providers and SORs,
and orders or other trading interest displayed in external venues
without real-time access to systems designed to take advantage of this
information, such as vendors (where no further information is needed or
possibly not required).\990\ The final disclosure requirement does not
draw a distinction between these orders and trading interests. Market
participants can be very sensitive to precisely how and when their
orders and trading interest are displayed or otherwise made known, and
the Commission remains concerned that subscribers to NMS Stock ATSs
might not know the full extent to which their orders and trading
interest are displayed.\991\ While the display of orders or trading
interest at venues in real time that have systems designed to take
advantage of such information may raise the most acute concerns, we
believe that market participants should have a full understanding about
how and when an ATS displays their orders or trading interest.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\990\ See Fidelity Letter at 8.
\991\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81072.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Differences in the latencies associated with the NMS Stock ATS
displaying subscriber orders and trading interest due to a
functionality of the ATS would be responsive to the request in Part
III, Item 15(c).\992\ For example, if an NMS Stock ATS transmits and
displays its proprietary data feed to certain subscribers faster than
other subscribers as a result of the alternative means offered by the
ATS to connect, such information would be responsive.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\992\ See supra note 850. We proposed to require an NMS Stock
ATS to disclose differences among subscribers regarding the display
of orders and trading interest in Part IV, Item 6(a) of proposed
Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part IV, Item 6(b) of proposed Form ATS-N, requested the identity
of any individuals in responding to whom the order and trading interest
would be displayed or made known. One commenter raises confidentiality
concerns with the requirement to publicly identify the position and
title of the natural person to whom orders or other trading interest
are displayed, because it believes that it would be relatively easy
through social media to reverse engineer certain identities, and such
information would require frequent updates with little market
utility.\993\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\993\ See Fidelity Letter at 8. See also SIFMA Letter at 23
(suggesting that identifying individuals by title or more specific
identifying characteristics would present security and privacy
issues, as well as client confidentiality issues).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38855]]
We have revised the request so that Part III, Item 15 of adopted
Form ATS-N does not require the NMS Stock ATS to identify natural
persons. We understand commenters' potential confidentiality concerns
and had modified the request to make clear that the request does not
seek the names of natural persons or their identity. Instead, it
requires the NMS Stock ATS to only identify the recipient of displayed
information, by functionality of the broker-dealer operator or the type
of market participant, or both.\994\ For example, if orders bound for
the NMS Stock ATS pass through the broker-dealer operator's common
gateway, SOR, or algorithm, the NMS Stock ATS would need to disclose
these functionalities as the order was displayed to a functionality of
the broker-dealer operator that would likely be outside the NMS Stock
ATS. If orders resting in the NMS Stock ATS are displayed to certain
subscribers or one or more of the broker-dealer operator business
units, the NMS Stock ATS would need to identify these subscribers and
business units of the broker-dealer operator by type of market
participant (e.g., institutional investors, principal trading firms,
market makers, affiliates, trading desks at the broker-dealer operator,
market data vendors, clearing entities, and potential subscribers,
among others). We believe this modification addresses commenters'
concerns, obviates the need for any redaction of information, and
reduces the frequency of updates necessary as compared to responses
identifying individual persons as proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\994\ See Part III, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N (providing
examples of types of market participants).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are revising Part III, Item 15 of adopted Form ATS-N to address
another commenter's concern that certain persons at the ATS in
technical or quality assurance roles would need to be disclosed even
though they may not be involved with trading activity.\995\ Part III,
Item 15 now specifies that the request does not include ``employees of
the NMS Stock ATS who are operating the system.'' so that employees of
the NMS Stock ATS in non-trading related roles, such as technical,
quality assurance, compliance or accounting roles, among others, that
support the ATS's operations would not be captured under the adopted
Item.\996\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\995\ See SIFMA Letter at 23.
\996\ The NMS Stock ATS would still be subject to the
requirements of Rule 301(b)(10) and required to establish adequate
safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers' confidential
trading information, which must include: Limiting access to the
confidential trading information of subscribers to those employees
of the ATS who are operating the system or responsible for its
compliance with these or any other applicable rules; and
implementing standards controlling employees of the ATS trading for
their own accounts. See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, we are adding a ``yes'' or ``no'' questions in Part III,
Item 15(a) that asks if the NMS Stock ATS operates as an ECN as defined
in Rule 600(a)(23) of Regulation NMS. In the Proposal, the Commission
noted that NMS Stock ATSs that are also ECNs may differ in how and
where orders or other trading interest are displayed, and that Part IV,
Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N was designed inform market participants
about how ECN display orders.\997\ We believe that adding this ``yes''
or ``no'' question would allow the NMS Stock ATS to identify itself to
market participants as an ECN. An ATS that indicates ``yes'' to Part
III, Item 15(a) would also be required to provide information in
response to Part III, Item 15(b) and 15(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\997\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81072.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
16. Routing
Part IV, Item 10(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about outbound routing. We are adopting Part IV, Item 10(a)
of proposed Form ATS-N with modifications, renaming the request as
``Routing,'' and renumbering the request as Part III, Item 16 of
adopted Form ATS-N.
One commenter sought to understand whether the description of
outbound routing required by the Item was limited to outbound routing
performed as a functionality of the ATS itself rather than routing of
client orders by the broker-dealer operator to third-party execution
venues.\998\ The commenter believes that if this Item also applies to
routing performed by the broker-dealer operator, all broker-dealers,
whether or not they operate an ATS, should be required to publicly
disclose routing information. Furthermore, the commenter also argues
for ``required disclosure of routing by a broker-dealer to any
affiliate ATS'' and of ``the method by which a broker-dealer interacts
with the ATSs that it operates. '' \999\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\998\ See Liquidnet Letter at 12.
\999\ Id. We note that adopted Form ATS-N requires disclosure on
both subjects. Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N solicits
information about the entry of orders and trading interest by the
broker-dealer operator, including its business unit(s), into the NMS
Stock ATS. Part II, Item 1(d) of adopted Form ATS-N solicits
information about orders and trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS
that can be routed to a trading center of the broker-dealer
operator, which would include affiliates of the NMS Stock ATS, and
if so, the NMS Stock ATS must provide information that is required
in response to Part III, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As the commenter points out above, order handling and the routing
of orders by the broker-dealer operator in its capacity as a broker-
dealer may be separate from routing of orders in the ATS to other
execution venues. As noted above,\1000\ we did not intend to require
broker-dealer operators to disclose information about their handling of
customer orders when such orders are not routed to or residing in the
NMS Stock ATS. In response to the commenter's concerns, the adopted
Item does not request information about routing of orders and trading
interest by the broker-dealer operator that are not routed to or
residing in the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1000\ See supra Section V.D.15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We made several changes to Part IV, Item 10(a) of proposed Form
ATS-N in response to comments (and adopted as Part III, Item 16).
First, we are requiring an NMS Stock ATS to indicate whether orders and
trading interest in the ATS can be routed to a destination outside the
ATS, and if the answer to that question is ``yes,'' whether affirmative
instructions from a subscriber must be obtained before their orders or
trading interest is routed from the ATS. If the NMS Stock ATS indicates
that ``yes'' instructions from a subscriber must first be obtained, the
NMS Stock ATS will be required to describe the affirmative instruction
and how the affirmative instruction is obtained. If instructions from a
subscriber need not be first obtained, the NMS Stock ATS will be
required to explain when orders in the NMS Stock ATS can be routed from
the NMS Stock ATS (e.g., at the discretion of the broker-dealer
operator).\1001\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1001\ We have consolidated the discussion of how orders can be
removed from the NMS Stock ATS in Part III, Item 7(a)(vii) of
adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In Part III, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N, we are removing the
proposed requirement to ``describe the circumstances'' of outbound
routing more broadly, and instead, are now requiring, as applicable,
that the NMS Stock ATS ``describe the affirmative instruction'' of the
subscriber and ``explain how the affirmative instruction is obtained.''
This change is consistent with the instruction in the Proposal to
``describe the circumstances,'' but provides more specific instruction.
Moreover, if trading interest can be routed away from the NMS Stock ATS
without the affirmative instruction of the subscriber, we are no longer
limiting the alternative to be when it happens at the discretion of the
broker-dealer, as proposed, but instead, are requiring an explanation
of when orders can be routed from the NMS Stock ATS. We
[[Page 38856]]
believe that phrasing the request this way reflects that trading
interest can be routed from the NMS Stock ATS in different ways and
better accommodates potential future developments in the industry. We
believe that the information in this Item will provide a subscriber
with the necessary information to authorize routing and understand how
its orders in the ATS can be routed from the ATS, and help prevent the
subscriber from unknowingly agreeing to the routing of their trading
interest.
We are not adopting in Part III, Item 16 of Form ATS-N the proposed
requirements that the NMS Stock ATS explain the means by which routing
is performed, or that the NMS Stock ATS explain any differences among
subscribers in the means by which trading interest is routed, as this
could expand the scope of Form ATS-N beyond ATS activity and into the
other broker-dealer functions of the broker-dealer operator.
17. Closing
Part IV, Item 9(b) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about the NMS Stock ATS's closing process. We did not
receive specific comment on Part IV, Item 9(b) of proposed Form ATS-N.
We are adopting Part IV, Item 9(b) with certain modifications discussed
below, and renumbering the request as Part III, Item 17 (``Closing'')
of adopted Form ATS-N. Part III, Item 17 is designed to inform market
participants about whether an NMS Stock ATS uses any special procedures
to match orders at the close of regular trading. The Item is designed
to provide market participants with information about any special
closing processes used by the NMS Stock ATS, particularly whether there
are any order types used during the close.
The vast majority of requests in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N
relate to trading during regular hours. Therefore, when discussing
differences between trading during the close and during regular hours,
the NMS Stock ATS must discuss differences as compared to relevant
information disclosed in Part III Items, including, among others, order
types (Item 7), order interaction, priority, matching, and execution
procedures (Item 11), segmentation (Item 13), and display (Item 15). We
believe this information will be important for market participants to
understand in evaluating whether participating in the closing process
is consistent with their trading objectives.\1002\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1002\ As discussed in the Proposal, the Item would, for
example, require disclosure of any procedures to match orders to set
a single closing price to maximize liquidity and accurately reflect
market conditions at the close of trading. See Proposal, supra note
2, at 81077 (discussing closing auctions and orders designed to
execute at the close of trading).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
18. Trading Outside of Regular Trading Hours
Part IV, Item 9(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding after-hours trading. The Commission did not
receive any comments regarding the substance of Part IV, Item 9(c) of
proposed Form ATS-N. The Commission is adopting Part IV, Item 9(c) of
proposed Form ATS with certain modifications, as discussed below, and
relocating the request as Part III, Item 18 (``Trading Outside of
Regular Trading Hours'') of adopted Form ATS-N.
The Commission is merging requests from Part IV, Item 9(a), which
requested information about pre-opening executions,\1003\ and Part IV,
Item 9(c), which requested information about after-hours trading. We
believe that the potential for redundant disclosures, as observed by
commenters,\1004\ would be reduced by merging these two requests.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1003\ Part IV, Item 9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N requested the
NMS Stock ATS describe any differences between pre-opening
executions, executions following a stoppage of trading in a security
during regular trading hours, and executions during regular trading
hours.
\1004\ See, e.g., SIFMA Letter at 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This Item will require NMS Stock ATSs to indicate in Part III,
Items 18(a) and 18(b) whether the ATS conducts trading outside regular
trading hours, and indicate whether there are any differences between
trading outside of regular trading hours and trading during regular
hours. To the extent that there are differences, the NMS Stock ATS must
describe those differences. Similar to Item 17 (requesting differences
between the closing and regular trading hours), an NMS Stock ATS must
discuss differences in trading outside of regular trading hours as
compared to the relevant information disclosed in Part III Items,
including, among others, order types (Item 7), order interaction,
priority, matching, and execution procedures (Item 11), segmentation
(Item 13), and display (Item 15). Many of the disclosures discussed
elsewhere in Form ATS-N will relate to regular trading hours so the ATS
can simply discuss any differences between trading during regular hours
and trading outside regular trading hours in Part III, Item 18(b).
19. Fees
Part IV, Item 12 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures about fees. We are adopting Part IV, Item 12 of proposed
Form ATS-N with modifications, which are discussed below, and
renumbering the request as Part III, Item 19 (``Fees'') of adopted Form
ATS-N. Some commenters suggest that the Commission exercise restraint
in the area of fees given that they are the product of negotiations
between sophisticated financial institutions and leave to market
competition the setting of appropriate fees.\1005\ Another commenter
suggests that NMS Stock ATSs be allowed to voluntarily report their fee
structure.\1006\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1005\ See UBS Letter at 8; LeveL ATS at 6 (stating that ATS
subscribers are sophisticated counterparties that have a keen sense
of the market for the services provided and are not in need of the
fee disclosures proposed).
\1006\ See STA Letter at 3-4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission continues to believe that disclosures regarding fees
on Form ATS-N are necessary and important, and should not be voluntary
for NMS Stock ATSs. Fee disclosures on Form ATS-N are designed to allow
all market participants to analyze the fee structures across NMS Stock
ATSs in an expedited manner and decide which ATS offers them the best
pricing according to the characteristics of their order flow, the type
of participant they are (if relevant), or any other aspects of an ATS's
fee structure that serves to provide incentives or disincentives for
specific market participants or trading behaviors. As NMS Stock ATSs
have become a significant source of liquidity in NMS Stocks,\1007\ we
believe that disclosures about their fees are warranted as, in the
Commission's experience, fees can be a primary factor for market
participants in deciding where to route their orders and trading
interest. Several commenters express support, on behalf of different
types of market participants, for fee disclosures on Form ATS-N.\1008\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1007\ See supra Section II.A.1.
\1008\ See ICI Letter at 10; HMA Letter at 18 (suggesting that
disclosure of the details regarding fees (among other topics in part
III) is essential for investors or routing brokers seeking to
understand how the ATS works). See also SIFMA Letter at 25 (stating
that a broad description of compensation mechanisms is appropriate
and a description of the mechanisms and categories of fee structure
would offer an appropriate level of clarity and transparency); KCG
Letter at 7 (stating the Commission should require standard
documents, including pricing schedules).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, given commenters' concerns that the use of the term
``describe'' in Form ATS-N is vague and would lead to discursive
disclosures and obscure key information,\1009\ the
[[Page 38857]]
Commission is providing additional specificity on the Item's
requirements and more examples in the text of the Item. The Commission
is adding to Part III, Item 19 requests that NMS Stock ATSs include in
their descriptions: The structure of the fee, variables that impact the
fee, and differentiation among types of subscribers, along with
examples of responsive information included in a parenthetical in the
text of each subpart.\1010\ The Item also would still require a range
of fees as proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1009\ See supra note 941 and accompanying text.
\1010\ We are including examples of responsive information in
parentheticals in the text of the item. For instance, for
descriptions of the structure of the fee, the Commission is
providing as examples a fixed fee, volume-based and transaction-
based fee structures. For the description of variables that may
impact the fee, the Commission is providing as examples: The types
of securities traded, block orders, and the form of connectivity to
the ATS. For the description of the differentiation among types of
subscribers for the fee, the Commission is providing as examples of
the types of subscribers: Broker-dealers, institutional investors,
and retail.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter recommends that the Commission require that any
description of a differential fee structure contain enough information
for a market participant to understand exactly which, or which level,
of fees/rebates/charges apply to each type of subscriber or other
person and the criteria that the NMS Stock ATS uses to sort subscribers
into different fee categories so that market participants can assess
eligibility requirements for different fee tiers.\1011\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1011\ See ICI Letter at 10.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission recognizes that the fee structures of NMS Stock ATSs
can vary and that not all NMS Stock ATSs apply set tiers or categories
of fees for subscribers; \1012\ however, the Commission agrees with the
commenter that a market participant should have sufficient information
to understand the fees for using the services of the NMS Stock ATS.
Recognizing the various fees that can be charged by NMS Stock ATSs, the
Commission is specifying in the fee request the types of information
that an NMS Stock ATS must provide in response to the Commission's
proposed request to describe its fees (e.g., the structure of the fees,
variables that impact each fee, differentiation among types of
subscribers, and the range of fees). These disclosures are designed to
provide market participants with more insight regarding the fees
charged so that they can better understand how fees may apply to them
and assess how such fees may impact their trading strategies. This
approach does not require NMS Stock ATSs to provide comprehensive fee
schedules but still gives subscribers meaningful information about the
fees the NMS Stock ATS charges.\1013\ Although the fees charged for NMS
Stock ATS services may be individually negotiated between the broker-
dealer operator and the subscriber, the disclosures about the type of
fees charged by the NMS Stock ATS are designed to help market
participants discern how an NMS Stock ATS's fees are organized and
compare that information across NMS Stock ATSs, which could reduce the
search costs of market participants in deciding where to send their
orders and trading interest. Relatedly, the Commission recognizes that
a requirement to disclose the complete fee schedule for each subscriber
may provide more information, but this would not be desirable or
preferable given the fees for NMS Stock ATSs can be highly bespoke and
specific to each subscriber.\1014\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1012\ See Liquidnet Letter at 12 (stating it has in place over
1,500 subscriber agreements).
\1013\ See SIFMA Letter at 25-26 (stating a description of the
mechanisms and categories of fee structures would offer an
appropriate level of clarity and transparency).
\1014\ One commenter notes that it agrees with the Commission on
this point, and states that the concept of a fixed fee schedule
would not be practical or appropriate in this context. See Liquidnet
Letter at 13.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that a description of the mechanisms and
categories of fee structures would offer an appropriate level of
clarity and transparency, and that the disclosure of the existence of
rebates or commission relating to volume is workable, but a high/low
range of fees or more client-specific descriptions affect registrants'
ability to negotiate custom agreements with subscribers.\1015\ Part
III, Item 19 of adopted Form ATS-N does not require or reveal customer-
specific information regarding the fees or terms and conditions of fee
agreements that result in the high or low in the range of fees
disclosed. Part III, Item 19 of adopted Form ATS-N requests the range
of fees and does not require the NMS Stock ATS to disclose the name of
the customer, or even the types of subscriber, who is the highest or
lowest in the range.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1015\ See SIFMA Letter at 25-26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A commenter states that the Commission also should require an NMS
Stock ATS to explain whether it discriminates among different types of
subscribers in establishing fees, rebates, or other charges.\1016\ In
Part IV, Item 12(b) of proposed Form ATS-N, we proposed that NMS Stock
ATSs describe any differences if the fees, rebates, or other charges of
the NMS Stock ATS were not the same ``for all subscribers and
persons.'' We continue to believe that NMS Stock ATSs should be
required to disclose differences in the treatment of subscribers;
however, the Commission is changing Part III, Item 19 to require a
description of any differentiation among ``types of subscribers''
because the Commission did not intend to require fee differences among
individual subscribers. Rather, we believe that differences in fees,
rebates and other charges among ``types of subscribers'' would be more
informative to market participants about the fee structure of the ATS
than disclosures of individual differences between subscribers, which
could result from particular negotiations with individual subscribers.
This information would allow subscribers to observe whether an NMS
Stock ATS is offering preferential treatment among types of subscribers
with regards to fees, and therefore, the information could aid them in
deciding where to route their trading interest.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1016\ See ICI Letter at 10 (recommending NMS Stock ATSs explain
whether they discriminate among different types of subscribers in
establishing fees, rebates, or other charges).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter suggests that the Commission should require NMS
Stock ATSs to provide complete information about their sources of
revenue, including revenue arrangements the ATS may have with other
trading centers.\1017\ The commenter suggests funds and other market
participants would use these disclosures to evaluate the potential for
information leakage attendant to routing orders to a particular NMS
Stock ATS or whether these arrangements may disadvantage subscribers of
the ATS, including funds. We do not believe that disclosure of all of
an ATS's sources of revenue would likely contribute more to
subscribers' understanding of conflicts of interest than the
combination of the disclosures in this Item and the disclosures in Part
II of adopted the Form ATS-N, which include disclosures regarding ATS-
related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates,
such as Part II, Item 4.\1018\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1017\ See id.
\1018\ See supra Section V.C.4 (discussing any formal or
informal arrangements between the Broker-Dealer Operator and a
Trading Center to access the NMS Stock ATS services).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other commenters express various reasons for why they believe the
Commission should not require some or all of the disclosures on fees of
Part IV, Item 12 of proposed Form ATS-N. Commenters state that NMS
Stock ATSs, and especially NMS Stock ATSs of multi-service broker-
dealers, may establish fees based on a number of factors, including the
depth and breadth of a client relationship, or the full suite of
brokerage services made available to
[[Page 38858]]
the client.\1019\ The commenters believe that because fees are set
taking into account these other factors, any disclosures on the range
of fees on the NMS Stock ATS would be misleading.\1020\ As discussed in
the Proposal, the types of fees charged to use an NMS Stock ATS's
services could influence whether a market participant subscribes to, or
the extent to which it participates on, the NMS Stock ATS.\1021\ The
Commission recognizes, as indicated by commenters, that fees charged
for the use of the NMS Stock ATS services can be bundled with non-ATS
services that the broker-dealer operator offers to subscribers of the
ATS. While Part IV, Item 12 of proposed Form ATS-N request did not
explicitly identify bundled service fees, the proposed request did
require a description of any fees, rebates, or other charges of the NMS
Stock ATS. As a type of fee for use of the services of the NMS Stock
ATS, bundled service fees would have been responsive to Part IV, Item
12 of proposed Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1019\ See UBS Letter at 8; Morgan Stanley Letter at 4; STA
Letter at 3-4; LeveL ATS Letter at 6.
\1020\ See UBS Letter at 8; STA Letter at 3-4; Morgan Stanley
Letter at 4.
\1021\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81080.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To avoid potential confusion about fees charged by an NMS Stock
ATS, and to account for bundled service fees charged to a subscribers
by multi-service broker-dealer operators of NMS Stock ATSs, the
Commission is adding a separate and specific request to Part III, Item
19(b) of adopted Form ATS-N. Specifically, the Commission is requiring
that the NMS Stock ATS describe any bundled fees, including a summary
of the bundled services and products offered by the broker-dealer
operator or its affiliates, the structure of the fee, variables that
impact the fee (including, for example, whether the particular broker-
dealer services selected would impact the fee), differentiation among
types of subscribers, and range of fees. Part III, Item 19(b) is
designed to allow market participants to better evaluate fees for
bundled services that include access to the NMS Stock ATS. NMS Stock
ATSs will be required to provide information, including the relevant
services and products offered by the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates for each bundled fee offered, that will provide context to
market participants with which to assess how fees could apply to them
as subscribers.
Another commenter states its understanding that the disclosures
required would relate only to the fees that the ATS charges for its
services, and not include brokerage services, because otherwise, it
believes there would be unfair discrimination relative to broker-
dealers that do not operate an ATS.\1022\ To the extent that a broker-
dealer operator bundles its services with its NMS Stock ATS services,
and the ATS services do not have an explicit fee, then the broker-
dealer operator would not be required to provide a range of fees
charged for the bundled services. On the other hand, if a broker-dealer
operator bundles its services with its NMS Stock ATS services and
charges an explicit fee for the ATS services, then the fee for the ATS
services should be taken into account for determining the range of fees
under this Item. Further, if a broker-dealer operator sometimes bundles
its services with its NMS Stock ATS services for certain subscribers,
but charges a separate fee for ATS services, it would be required to
provide the information responsive to this Item, including the range,
for the separate fee for ATS services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1022\ See Liquidnet Letter at 12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A commenter also suggests the Item be expressly limited to fees set
by the ATS operator and not include fees from other affiliates or third
parties (e.g., related to co-location).\1023\ Part III, Item 19(a) of
adopted Form ATS-N covers charges to subscribers for their ``use of the
NMS Stock ATS services.'' \1024\ The fee information disclosed in Part
III, Item 19 of adopted Form ATS-N must include fees resulting from a
subscriber's use of the NMS Stock ATS services that are charged by the
broker-dealer operator, or a third party, such as a service provider to
the NMS Stock ATS. The Item's required disclosures are not limited by
the entity charging the fee; rather, if the fee is for use of the NMS
Stock ATS services, then the Item's requests apply regardless of the
entity charging the fee. Many broker-dealer operators today outsource
some or all of the operations of the NMS Stock ATS to third parties
(e.g., such as the matching engine). To the extent that subscribers are
charged a fee by the third-party service provider of the NMS Stock ATS,
the NMS Stock ATS would be required to disclose such fees in Part III,
Item 19(a) of Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1023\ See SIFMA Letter at 26.
\1024\ The NMS Stock ATS services generally include those
services used for the purpose of effecting transactions in NMS
Stock, or for submitting, disseminating or displaying orders on the
ATS. See 17 CFR 242.300(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On the other hand, Part III, Item 19(a) of adopted Form ATS-N does
not request information on fees charged for non-ATS services by a third
party not in contract with the broker-dealer operator. If, for example,
the NMS Stock ATS is located in a facility owned by a third party, and
in order to co-locate to the NMS Stock ATS a subscriber would be
required to lease physical space from the third-party facility owner, a
fee for the space rental would not be required to be disclosed on Form
ATS-N by the NMS Stock ATS. On the other hand, if an NMS Stock ATS
provides co-location services for subscribers and charges a fee to
those subscribers for the co-location services, such fee would be
responsive to Part III, Item 19 of Form ATS-N. In addition, to the
extent that a broker-dealer operator enters into an agreement or
arrangement with a third party for that third party to provide a
service of the NMS Stock ATS to subscribers and charge a fee that is
passed back to the broker-dealer operator in any form, the broker-
dealer operator would be required to disclose that fee in response to
Part III, Item 19 of Form ATS-N. In such a case, to prevent an NMS
Stock ATS from circumventing disclosure otherwise responsive to Part
III, Item 19(b) of adopted Form ATS-N, the pass-backed fee by the third
party is a fee ``for the use of NMS Stock ATS services.''
Another commenter suggests that clients are highly interested in
understanding whether an ATS offers rebates to subscribers and would
support the inclusion of this question.\1025\ In response to the
commenter, the disclosure requests under Item 19 will contain a stand-
alone Item--Item 19(c)--which requests information about rebates and
discounts of fees that are identified in subparts (a) and (b) of Item
19. Item 19(c) requires information about rebates and discounts that is
similar to that which is required for fees (e.g., the structure of the
rebate or discount, variables that impact the rebate or discount,
differentiation among types of subscribers, and range of rebate or
discount).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1025\ See UBS Letter at 8. We proposed in Part IV, Item 12(a)
of proposed Form ATS-N that the NMS Stock ATS describe ``any fees,
rebates, or other charges'' of the NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
20. Suspension of Trading
Part IV, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding any procedures governing trading during a
suspension of trading, disruption or malfunction. The Commission is
adopting Part IV, Item 8 with certain modifications, renaming it
``Suspension of Trading,'' and renumbering the request to Part III,
Item 20 in adopted Form ATS-N. Part III, Item 20 is designed to, for
example, inform market participants of whether, among other things, an
NMS Stock ATS
[[Page 38859]]
will continue to accept orders after a suspension, whether the NMS
Stock ATS routes, holds, or continues to execute orders resting in the
system prior to the suspension, and the type of notice provided to
market participants during a suspension. Furthermore, as discussed in
the Proposal,\1026\ one of the primary concerns of the Commission is
that given the speed and interconnected nature of the U.S. securities
markets, a seemingly minor systems problem at a single entity can
quickly create losses and liability for market participants, and spread
rapidly across the national market system, potentially creating
widespread damage and harm to market participants and investors.
Accordingly, it is important to fully understand what, if any, trading
procedures an NMS Stock ATS would follow when trading is suspended or
stopped. Consistent with the Proposal, we are adding the phrase
``including the suspension of trading in individual NMS stocks'' to
Item 20(a) to make clear that the procedures to suspend trading in an
NMS stock by an NMS Stock ATS are required by this request.\1027\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1026\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81076.
\1027\ Based on Commission experience, an NMS Stock ATS's
procedures may include the suspension of trading in an NMS stock
security to not trigger the requirements of Rule 301(b)(3) or Rule
301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81104.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received two comments regarding Part IV, Item 8 of proposed Form
ATS-N. One commenter suggests that this information would be better
suited as a disclosure to subscribers rather than formally filed with
the Commission and publicly disclosed.\1028\ We do not agree and
believe that this information would allow non-subscribers to better
evaluate their brokers' order routing practices and whether the routing
of their orders to an NMS Stock ATS would achieve their trading or
investment strategies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1028\ See SIFMA Letter at 24-25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter requests that the Commission consider harmonizing
any definitions used in the Item with those found in Regulation
SCI.\1029\ As discussed in the Proposal, the Commission does not intend
to alter or amend the requirements of Regulation SCI with this Item,
nor does it intend to require NMS Stock ATSs to adopt specific
procedures during a system disruption as it did in Regulation
SCI.\1030\ Instead, we are requiring an NMS Stock ATS to disclose what
procedures, if any, it follows when suspending or stopping trading so
that market participants can better understand how their orders will be
handled under those circumstances.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1029\ See UBS Letter at 8.
\1030\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81076. We are removing
references to ``system disruptions'' to mitigate any confusion with
Regulation SCI. We believe this technical change does not change the
substantive information required.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
21. Trade Reporting
Part IV, Item 13(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding trade reporting. We are adopting Part IV, Item
13(a) of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications discussed
below, and renumbering the request as Part III, Item 21 of adopted Form
ATS-N. One commenter suggests that the prompt to disclose ``any
arrangements'' is broad and poses challenges to keep current and
recommends it would be more useful to limit the requested arrangements
to those that are material to or a core feature of the operations of
the ATS.\1031\ In response to this comment, we are revising the request
to focus on ``material'' arrangements for reporting transactions on the
NMS Stock ATS. We recognize that there could be arrangements relevant
to trade reporting, such as the specific software used to report, that
play a minor role in the ATS's trade reporting and need not be
disclosed. We believe that this change clarifies the Form ATS-N
requirement and reduces potential burdens on NMS Stock ATSs while
providing market participants with sufficient information to understand
how their trade information will be reported.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1031\ See SIFMA Letter at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we are adding a phrase to the Item to make clear that
the explanation of procedures or material arrangements required
includes ``where an ATS reports transactions and under what
circumstances.'' We believe this language will help NMS Stock ATSs
better understand what would be responsive to Part III, Item 21 of
adopted Form ATS-N and focus their responses accordingly, and is
consistent with the request in Part IV, Item 13(a) of proposed Form
ATS-N. For example, the NMS Stock ATS will be required to disclose the
SRO to which it reports transactions, and any alternative trade
reporting destinations, if applicable. Information about where an NMS
Stock ATS reports transactions and under what circumstances would have
been responsive to Part IV, Item 13(a) of proposed Form ATS-N, which
required the NMS Stock ATS to ``describe any arrangements or procedures
for reporting transactions on the NMS Stock ATS.'' The addition of the
phrase to Item 21(a) clarifies those procedures that would be
responsive to the request. Finally, we are revising the proposed Item
to clarify that the NMS Stock ATS explain any ``procedures and material
arrangements'' (emphasis added), instead of ``procedures or material
arrangements'' (emphasis added). We intended that a description of both
procedures and material arrangements would provide a complete and
comprehensive disclosure of the most important aspects of the NMS Stock
ATS's trade reporting.
22. Clearance and Settlement
Part IV, Item 13(b) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding clearance and settlement. The Commission is
adopting Part IV, Item 13(b) of proposed Form ATS-N with certain
modifications discussed below, and renumbering it as Part III, Item 22
of adopted Form ATS-N. The integrity of the trading markets depends on
the prompt and accurate clearance and settlement of securities
transactions.\1032\ Part III, Item 22 is designed to help market
participants understand the measures the NMS Stock ATS takes to
facilitate clearance and settlement of transactions, including the
process through which an NMS Stock ATS clears a trade (e.g., whether
the NMS Stock ATS becomes a counterparty to a transaction, interposing
itself between two counterparties to a transaction, or whether the NMS
Stock ATS submits trades to a registered clearing agency for clearing)
and any requirements an NMS Stock ATS places on its subscribers, or
other persons whose orders are routed to an NMS Stock ATS, to have
clearance and settlement systems and/or arrangements with a clearing
firm.\1033\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1032\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81081.
\1033\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggests that the prompt to disclose ``any
arrangements'' is broad and poses challenges to keep current and
recommends it would be more useful to limit the requested arrangements
to those that are material to or a core feature of the operations of
the ATS.\1034\ In response to this comment, and for similar reasons to
those stated above for Part III, Item 21 (``Trade Reporting''), we are
revising this request to focus the Item on ``material'' arrangements to
facilitate the clearance and settlement of transaction on the NMS Stock
ATS. For example, an arrangement under which a third party would have a
role in clearance and settlement on the NMS Stock ATS may constitute a
material arrangement that could trigger the disclosure requirement
under Part III, Item 22. Limiting the explanation required to material
arrangements will reduce the burden on
[[Page 38860]]
NMS Stock ATSs while at the same time still allowing market
participants to understand and more easily compare clearing
arrangements required across NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1034\ See SIFMA Letter at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For similar reasons as stated above for Part III, Item 21 (``Trade
Reporting''), we are revising this request to state that the NMS Stock
ATS describe any ``procedures and material arrangements'' (emphasis
added), instead of ``procedures or material arrangements'' (emphasis
added). In addition, we are removing the phrase ``undertaken by the NMS
Stock ATS'' from the proposed requirement. NMS Stock ATSs may engage a
third party to facilitate the clearance and settlement of transactions
on the NMS Stock ATS, and we do not intend to limit the procedures and
material arrangements explained to only those specifically performed by
the NMS Stock ATS.
23. Market Data
Part IV, Item 11 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding market data. The Commission is adopting Part IV,
Item 11 of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications and
renumbering the request as Part III, Item 23 of adopted Form ATS-N.
Market data is a critical component to understanding the operations of
an NMS Stock ATS. For instance, the market data received by an NMS
Stock ATS might affect the price at which orders and trading interest
is prioritized and executed in the ATS, including orders that are
pegged to an outside reference price. The source of an NMS Stock ATS's
market data could impact the execution price received by a subscriber.
Disclosures about the NMS Stock ATS's sources of market data, and how
the ATS uses such data, can help to inform market participants about
how their orders would be handled and executed by the NMS Stock ATS.
One commenter recommends the elimination of prompts that it
suggests request proprietary, sensitive, or duplicative information.
The commenter instead recommends a general, high-level description
regarding the determination of NBBO and pricing.\1035\ As routing is a
function performed by a broker-dealer and outside the ATS, the
Commission is revising the request to make clear that an NMS Stock ATS
would not be required to provide information about the market data that
the broker-dealer operator uses to route orders and trading interest
from the NMS Stock ATS to away destinations. Part III, Item 23 would
require information, however, about the ATS's use of market data to
determine when resting orders and trading interest will be removed from
inside the NMS Stock ATS because these orders and trading interest
reside inside the ATS and the data used to act on them could impact
their execution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1035\ See SIFMA Letter at 25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An NMS Stock ATS would also be required to provide information
about how the ATS uses market data to provide the services it offers.
Among other things, for example, the NMS Stock ATS would need to
disclose in response to Part III, Item 23, of adopted Form ATS-N, its
use of market data to display, price, prioritize, execute, and remove
trading interest. As part of its explanation for how the NMS Stock ATS
uses market data, the ATS would be required to specify, if applicable,
when the ATS may change between its use of different sources of market
data to provide its services.
Given commenters' concerns that the use of the term ``describe'' in
Form ATS-N is vague and would lead to discursive disclosures and
obscure key information,\1036\ the Commission is providing additional
examples in the text of the Item to give NMS Stock ATSs more guidance
on the types of information that would be responsive to the request,
including how the ATS determines the NBBO and protected quotes in the
Item.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1036\ See supra note 941.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter believes that the form should require annual
disclosures of an NMS Stock ATS's approximate latency (in microseconds)
to receive market data feeds, assemble the NBBO, and deliver the
updated NBBO to the matching engine.\1037\ As discussed elsewhere in
relation to comments requesting quantitative data,\1038\ the Commission
is not adopting ongoing reporting requirements for NMS Stock ATSs to
report performance metrics of their system and therefore not requiring
NMS Stock ATS to disclose this information. The information above could
be important to market participants because they could be concerned,
for example, about price impacts on their trading interest if the NMS
Stock ATS compiles the NBBO slower than other trading venues, or that
they would trade on stale prices, as well as the potential for
information leakage. To address the commenter's concern, the Commission
is providing guidance to NMS Stock ATSs that, in response to Part III,
Item 23, the NMS Stock ATS should explain how market data is received
by the ATS, compiled, and delivered to the matching engine. For
example, among other possible arrangements, the NMS Stock ATS could
explain in response to the Item that market data is received by the
broker-dealer operator and assembled there, and subsequently delivered
to the matching engine, or that market data is sent directly to the
matching engine, which normalizes the data for its use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1037\ See HMA Letter at 19.
\1038\ See Section V.D.13 (discussing why the Commission is
requiring narrative responses instead of a quantitative component,
such as the percentage of orders and trades per segmented class),
and V.D.26 (discussing why the Commission is requiring narrative
responses instead of quantitative data from NMS Stock ATSs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
24. Order Display and Execution Access
Part IV, Item 14 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding order display and execution access pursuant to
Rule 301(b)(3). The Commission is adopting Part IV, Item 14 in proposed
Form ATS-N, with certain modifications, and renumbering this Item as
Part III, Item 24 in adopted Form ATS-N.
One commenter recommends eliminating this request altogether on the
grounds that it is unclear how subscribers would benefit from the
detailed information under this Item or how it would be used.\1039\ The
Commission does not agree. As noted in the Proposal, under the current
regulatory regime for ATSs, there is no mechanism under which an ATS
must notify the Commission, its SRO, or market participants after it
has triggered the order display requirements.\1040\ Thus, the
commenter's suggestion that the Item is more appropriate in the context
of a Commission examination would not remedy the current lack of notice
to the public once the NMS Stock ATS triggers the order display
requirement. This notice would inform the Commission and the public
whether an NMS Stock ATS is subject to Rule 301(b)(3). Removing Part
IV, Item 14 (adopted as Part III, Item 24) would forego the benefit to
market participants of knowing when an NMS Stock ATS has become a
significant source of liquidity in an NMS stock and how they can access
applicable quotations of that ATS. The commenter maintains, but does
not describe how, the required disclosure would undermine the NMS Stock
ATS's subscriber access criteria, and we do not agree that the required
disclosure would do so.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1039\ See SIFMA Letter at 27.
\1040\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81082.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We recognize that an NMS Stock ATS may not be subject to Rule
301(b)(3)(ii) of Regulation ATS even if the ATS displays subscriber
orders in an NMS stock to any person (other than employees of the ATS)
(Rule 301(b)(3)(i)(A)), and executes 5% or
[[Page 38861]]
more of the average daily trading volume in that NMS stock as reported
by an effective transaction reporting plan during at least four of the
preceding six calendar months (Rule 301(b)(3)(i)(B)).\1041\ If an NMS
Stock ATS satisfies the Rule 301(b)(3)(i) threshold, the ATS must also
meet the criteria of Rule 301(b)(3)(ii) to be subject to the
requirements of Rules 301(b)(3)(ii) and (iii). As proposed, Part IV,
Item 14 of Form ATS-N would have required that an NMS Stock ATS that
meets the threshold requirements of Rule 301(b)(3)(i), but is not
subject to Rules 301(b)(3)(ii) and (iii), to provide information about
how they display and provide execution access. This was not the
Commission's intended result. Rather, the Commission intended for an
NMS Stock ATS that is subject to Rule 301(b)(3)(ii) and (iii) to
provide the information that the Commission proposed in Part IV, Item
14(a)-(c) of proposed Form ATS-N. Therefore, the Commission is
modifying the disclosure requirement of this Item and relocating it to
Part III, Item 24 of Form ATS-N. As adopted, Part III, Item 24(a) of
Form ATS-N asks if the NMS Stock ATS meets the threshold requirements
of Rule 301(b)(3)(i) of Regulation ATS, and, if so, whether the NMS
Stock ATS is required to comply with Rule 301(b)(3)(ii) of Regulation
ATS (i.e., does the ATS display to more than one person in the system).
If the NMS Stock ATS is required to comply with Rule 301(b)(3)(ii),
Part III, Item 24(b) requires the NMS Stock ATS to provide the
information that the Commission proposed in Part IV, Item 14(a)-(c) of
proposed Form ATS-N (i.e., the ticker symbol of the NMS stocks
displayed, information about how the ATS displays such orders, and
information about how the ATS provides access to such orders).\1042\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1041\ See Liquidnet Letter at 13-14 (stating that the ``order
display requirement of [Rule 301(b)(ii)] only applies where orders
are `displayed to more than one person in the [ATS]'' such that the
disclosure obligation of proposed Part IV, Item 14 would only apply
where an ATS displays orders to more than one subscriber in
securities where it has exceeded the applicable 5% threshold).
\1042\ If the NMS Stock ATS responds ``no'' to Part III, Item
24(a) it will not be required to respond to Item 24(b), and if it
responds ``yes'' to Item 24(a) but ``no'' to Item 24(b), it will not
be required to provide any additional information in response to
Item 24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To ensure consistency with Rule 301(b)(3) of Regulation ATS, the
Commission is making minor modifications to the request to better
comport with requirements of Rule 301(b)(3), and in response to the
commenter's concerns regarding proposed Form ATS-N's disclosure
requirements for NMS Stock ATSs that meet the threshold requirements of
Rule 301(b)(3)(i), but may not be subject to Rules 301(b)(ii) and
(iii).\1043\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1043\ See Liquidnet Letter at 13-14.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
25. Fair Access
Part IV, Item 15 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding the fair access requirement of Rule 301(b)(5).
The Commission is adopting Part IV, Item 15 of proposed Form ATS-N,
with certain modifications, and renumbering this Item as Part III, Item
25 in adopted Form ATS-N. The Commission received comment recommending
the elimination of the request altogether on the grounds that it is
unclear how subscribers would benefit from the detailed information
under the Item or how it would be used.\1044\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1044\ See SIFMA Letter at 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission does not agree for the same reason discussed above
in connection with Part III, Item 24. As noted in the Proposal,
although triggering the fair access provision requires the NMS Stock
ATSs to provide certain information confidentially to the Commission
under Exhibit C of Form ATS-R,\1045\ there is no mechanism under which
an ATS must notify market participants after it has triggered the fair
access threshold under the current regulatory regime for ATSs.\1046\
Removing Part IV, Item 15 of proposed Form ATS-N (adopted Part III,
Item 25) as suggested by the commenter, would forego the benefit to
market participants of knowing when an NMS Stock ATS has become a
significant source of liquidity in an NMS stock and must comply with
fair access requirements of Rule 301(b)(5). We believe that the
information that an NMS Stock ATS will be required to disclose pursuant
to Part III, Item 25 will allow market participants to assess whether
fair access is in fact being granted by NMS Stock ATSs that meet the
fair access threshold of Rule 301(b)(5), in part by making publicly
available a description of the NMS Stock ATS's written standards for
granting access. In addition, the commenter mentions that, but does not
describe how, the required disclosure would undermine the NMS Stock
ATS's subscriber access criteria.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1045\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81082, n.502. An ATS that
meets any of the trading volume thresholds set forth in Rule
301(b)(5)(i), must comply with the requirements of Rule
301(b)(5)(ii) (including the requirement to disclose to the
Commission on Form ATS-R the information required by Rule
301(b)(5)(ii)(D)), unless it meets the exception set forth in Rule
301(b)(5)(iii).
\1046\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81082.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similar to Part IV, Item 14 of proposed Form ATS-N as discussed
above,\1047\ Part IV, Item 15 of proposed Form ATS-N would have applied
to an NMS Stock ATS that meets the threshold requirements of Rule
301(b)(5)(i), but is not required to comply with Rule 301(b)(5)(ii).
The Commission intended for an NMS Stock ATS to provide this
information only if it is required to comply with Rule 301(b)(5)(ii).
Therefore, the Commission is modifying the disclosure requirement of
this Item and relocating it to Part III, Item 25 of adopted Form ATS-N.
As adopted, Part III, Item 25(a) of Form ATS-N asks if the NMS Stock
ATS meets the threshold requirements of Rule 301(b)(5)(i)(A) of
Regulation ATS and if so, whether the NMS Stock ATS is required to
comply with Rule 301(b)(5)(ii) of Regulation ATS (i.e., the ATS does
not meet the exception set forth in Rule 301(b)(5)(iii)). If the NMS
Stock ATS is required to comply with Rule 301(b)(5), Part III, Item
25(b) requires the NMS Stock ATS to provide the information that the
Commission proposed in Part IV, Item 15(a) and 15(b) of proposed Form
ATS-N (i.e., the ticker symbol of each NMS stock and a description of
the ATS's written standards for granting access to trading on the
ATS).\1048\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1047\ See supra Section V.D.24.
\1048\ If the NMS Stock ATS responds ``no'' to Part III, Item
25(a), it will not be required to respond to Item 25(b), and if it
responds ``yes'' to Item 25(a) but ``no'' to Item 25(b), it will not
be required to provide any additional information in response to
Item 25.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To ensure consistency with Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS, the
Commission is making minor modifications to the request to better
comport with requirements of Rule 301(b)(5), and for consistency with
the modifications the Commission is making to Part III, Item 24
described above.
26. Aggregate Platform-Wide Data; Trading Statistics
a. Disseminated Aggregated Platform-Wide Data
Part IV, Item 16 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required
disclosures regarding market quality statistics published or provided
to subscribers. The disclosure requests in Part IV, Item 16 of proposed
Form ATS-N are now contained in Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-
N.
We received several comments on Part IV, Item 16 of proposed Form
ATS-N. Some commenters express concerns about the potential effects
that the public disclosure of the information under Part IV, Item 16
would have on the flow of information to
[[Page 38862]]
subscribers.\1049\ One commenter expresses concern that the proposed
requirements of Part IV, Item 16 would have made the process of
providing information requested by customers more difficult, noting
that it receives information requests on an ongoing basis from traders
at more than 800 firms.\1050\ Another commenter questions the value
that the snapshot disclosed under Part IV, Item 16 would have for the
general public, and states that adopting Part IV, Item 16 as proposed
would cause NMS Stock ATSs to stop sharing some categories of
information with clients.\1051\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1049\ See SIFMA Letter at 27; Liquidnet Letter at 15.
\1050\ See Liquidnet Letter at 15.
\1051\ See SIFMA Letter at 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continue to believe that it is appropriate to require an NMS
Stock ATS to make public aggregate, platform-wide order flow and
execution statistics it already otherwise collects and publishes or
provides to one or more subscribers to the NMS Stock ATS. We believe
that an NMS Stock ATS may choose to create and publish or provide to
one or more subscribers or persons information concerning order flow
and execution quality for different reasons. Certain performance
metrics and statistics may be important factors for market participants
in comparing and selecting an ATS that is most appropriate for their
investment objectives.
We acknowledge a commenter's point that that these disclosures
might limit communication between NMS Stock ATSs and their participants
to the extent that an NMS Stock ATS chooses to cease providing such
statistics to subscribers due to the Form ATS-N requirements.\1052\
However, we believe that only a few NMS Stock ATSs would take this type
of action because such ATSs would have already chosen to distribute
such statistics to outside persons, thus triggering the requirements of
Item 26. Furthermore, we believe that the benefits of this disclosure--
requiring that all market participants have an equal opportunity to
analyze aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution data that is
distributed by an NMS Stock ATS--justify the potential cost of some
ATSs choosing to no longer distribute such statistics to select
subscribers on their platforms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1052\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter believes this request should not require the
disclosure of ``bespoke'' statistics for a subscriber.\1053\ The
commenter is concerned that if an NMS Stock ATS has to amend its Form
ATS-N each time it receives a subscriber's request for additional
information, it will not provide investors with additional information;
accordingly, the commenter suggests revising Part IV, Item 16 in a way
that would not discourage an NMS Stock ATS from providing additional
market quality information to investors. We share the concern that if
an NMS Stock ATS is compelled to amend its Form ATS-N each time it
receives a request for additional information from a market
participant, it will not provide investors with this information. Item
26, however, would not require an NMS Stock ATS to amend its Form ATS
every time it receives a data request. As explained in the Proposal, to
comply with this request, an NMS Stock ATS would only be required to
file a Form ATS-N updating amendment on a quarterly basis.\1054\ We are
not modifying the language or substantive requirements in adopted Form
ATS-N. Rather, to provide greater clarity regarding when and how NMS
Stock ATSs are required to respond to Item 26(a), we are adding an
instruction to Form ATS-N to state that an NMS Stock ATS shall file a
Form ATS-N amendment pursuant to Rule 304(a)(i)(2)(B) of Regulation ATS
to provide information in response to Item 26(a). Furthermore, as
explained above, the benefits of this disclosure justify the potential
cost of some ATSs choosing to no longer distribute such statistics to
select subscribers on their platforms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1053\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5.
\1054\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81084. As also explained
in the Proposal, if, for example, an NMS Stock ATS publishes or
provides a particular statistic on a daily basis, the NMS Stock ATS
would include in Exhibit 4 of adopted Form ATS-N the statistic that
was published or provided to one or more subscribers on the last
trading day of the calendar quarter (e.g., the statistic published
or provided on June 30th or last trading day prior to June 30th).
See id. at n.512. If an NMS Stock ATS publishes or provides a
particular statistic weekly, the NMS Stock ATS would be required to
include in Exhibit 4 of adopted Form ATS-N the statistic that was
published or provided to one or more subscribers at the end of the
week prior to the end of the calendar quarter (e.g., the statistic
published for the last full week of June). See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, one commenter believes that broker-dealer operators
and their affiliated broker-dealers should be permitted to respond to
individualized questions from subscribers and to continue to provide
customized reports in the course of responding to those individualized
questions without attendant Form ATS-N revisions or amendment
requirements.\1055\ This commenter states that without clarification
regarding how individualized or custom reports are to be treated, this
disclosure requirement could potentially introduce misleading or skewed
information into the public arena, which could undermine the
transparency goals of the proposed rules.\1056\ Similarly, one
commenter states that the Commission should clarify that Part IV, Item
16 would not apply when an NMS Stock ATS provides data to a customer
relating to that customer's specific usage of the ATS.\1057\ The
commenter states that institutions must have access to this type of
information to fulfill their best execution obligations, but making
this type of information public could compromise an institution's
anonymity.\1058\ We note that Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N
requires only aggregate platform-wide data and, thus, would not apply
when an NMS Stock ATS provides a participant with individualized or
custom reports containing data relating to that participant's specific
usage of the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1055\ See SIFMA Letter at 27.
\1056\ See id.
\1057\ See Liquidnet Letter at 16.
\1058\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters also recommend changes and/or other clarifications to
the requests under Part IV, Item 16 of proposed Form ATS-N. One of
these commenters recommends that the Commission eliminate the public
disclosure requirements under Item 16 and instead propose a revised
report on aggregate order flow and execution that is to be filed on an
annual and confidential basis with the Commission as an exhibit to Form
ATS-N.\1059\ As noted above, we are adopting the proposed disclosure
requests, as the public disclosure of the material encompassed by Part
IV, Item 16 of proposed Form ATS-N will benefit market participants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1059\ See SIFMA Letter at 28.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another commenter recommends revising Part IV, Item 16 of proposed
Form ATS-N to only mandate the disclosure of the required market
quality statistics when the NMS Stock ATS publishes or otherwise
provides such statistics to a substantial portion of its subscribers
(e.g., 10% or more).\1060\ As explained above, we believe that there is
a strong policy objective behind ensuring that the information
encompassed by Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N is available to
a wide array or market participants. We believe that setting a
threshold for when these disclosure requirements are
[[Page 38863]]
triggered would not advance this policy objective because an NMS Stock
ATS would be able to limit distribution of the statistics encompassed
by Part II, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N to a select number of
participants on the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1060\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5; see also 17 CFR 242.605
(requiring market centers, which include ATSs, to make available for
each calendar month an electronic report on certain categories of
order execution information).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As an alternative to the proposed requirements for the disclosure
of aggregate platform-wide statistics on Form ATS-N, a commenter
recommends that the Commission designate specific execution statistics
for all ATSs to provide.\1061\ However, if the Commission were to adopt
the requests of Part IV, Item 16 as proposed, the commenter believes
that the Commission should clarify that trade-specific data would not
be subject to this filing requirement, including pre-trade and post-
trade transaction cost analyses. The commenter also requests
clarification that this disclosure request only covers execution
quality statistics and that other types of statistics are not included.
By way of example, the commenter believes that disclosing the
percentage of customers that have used a specific product or product
feature would not trigger the requirements of Part III, Item 26 because
that information would not be considered a market quality statistic.
Finally, the commenter believes that NMS Stock ATSs should be permitted
to file the relevant statistics under Part III, Item 26 without filing
any associated communication to a specific customer (such as the other
contents of an email containing these statistics or a questionnaire
submitted by the customer), as this could compromise customer
anonymity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1061\ See Liquidnet Letter at 15. We are not expanding the
regulatory regime of Regulation ATS to require the public disclosure
of specific, standardized statistics for ATSs. See also infra
Section V.D.26.b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We confirm that Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N only
requires the disclosure of order flow and execution statistics, and
that trade-specific data that does not include aggregate, platform-wide
information would not be covered by this request. We note, however,
that whether or not a specific type of statistic should be categorized
as an order and execution statistic or considered aggregate, platform-
wide data will depend on the nature of the specific statistics being
compiled by the NMS Stock ATS. An NMS Stock ATS should independently
evaluate any statistics that it compiles and distributes to determine
whether they are responsive to this disclosure request. We also agree
that protecting customer anonymity should be a priority with any public
disclosure under this Item, and thus, an ATS would not be required to
publicly file customer communications associated with the responsive
statistics.
While we are not changing the substance of the proposed data
request being adopted in Part III, Item 26, we are making technical
modifications to improve the means by which the disclosures are filed
on Form ATS-N. We believe that these modifications will make it easier
for market participants to review and compare the filed information. In
addition to changing the proposed request into a ``yes'' or ``no''
question in adopted Form ATS-N, Part III, Item 26 requires the NMS
Stock ATS to attach both the responsive statistics and its explanation
of the categories or metrics of those statistics as Exhibits 4 and 5,
respectively, rather than including such information as part of the
form, as was proposed. We believe it will be easier for market
participants to review the disclosures as stand-alone documents than it
would be if they were filed and publicly posted as narratives in the
form. Also, in lieu of filing Exhibits 4 and 5, the NMS Stock ATS may
certify that the information requested under Exhibits 4 and 5 is
available at the website provided in Part I, Item 5 of the form and is
accurate as of the date of the filing.
b. Other Standardized Statistical Disclosures
In the Proposal, we solicited comment on whether other standardized
statistical disclosures should be required from NMS Stock ATSs and the
nature and extent of any such metrics or statistics that commenters
believe should be disclosed.\1062\ Several commenters believe that the
Commission should add additional public statistical disclosure
requirements to the ATS regulatory regime.\1063\ We believe that it is
appropriate to take an incremental approach to the disclosure of
additional market statistics. At this time, we believe it is
appropriate to only require NMS Stock ATSs to provide to all market
participants--via public disclosure on Form ATS-N--aggregate, platform
wide order flow and execution statistics that they already collect and
distribute and that would be encompassed by adopted Item 26.
Accordingly, we are not adopting rules to require NMS Stock ATSs or
national securities exchanges to report quantitative data above what
these trading centers are already required to report under current
federal securities laws.\1064\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1062\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81084-85.
\1063\ See, e.g., T. Rowe Price Letter at 1 (recommending that
ATSs be required to collect and disclose statistics about the
percentage of volume executed in block and demi-block sizes,
percentage of volume executed relative to national best bid/offer
(i.e., near, far, midpoint, and intra-spread), trade size and market
cap distribution, and aggregate statistics regarding
counterparties); Citadel Letter at 4 (advocating for the Commission
to require the reporting of end-of-day trade information that the
commenter believes would bring greater transparency to market
participants); HMA Letter at 22 (recommending that ATSs be required
to collect and disclose statistics about Order Trading and
Descriptive Statistics, Subscriber Characteristics, and ATS
Relationship and Trading Statistics); Anonymous at 1 (stating that
the same data produced by national securities exchanges should also
be provided by ATSs, including transactional short sale data); and
Liquidnet Letter at 16 (recommending that ATSs be required to
publicly report all individual ATS executions on an attributed
basis, which could be subject to a suitable delay period, such as 30
days).
\1064\ See 17 CFR 242.605 and 17 CFR 242.606.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also received comments advocating that this rulemaking include
amendments to Rule 605 of Regulation NMS.\1065\ Other commenters
recommend enhancing the disclosure requirement of Rule 606 of
Regulation NMS.\1066\ Should we decide to take action with respect to
the reporting of additional market quality data under Rule 605, we
would do so in a separate rulemaking. Additionally, a separate
rulemaking has been proposed to amend Rule 606 by requiring additional
disclosures by broker-dealers to customers about the routing of their
institutional orders.\1067\ We are currently considering the proposal
and comments received.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1065\ See 17 CFR 242.605. Rule 605 generally requires a market
center that trades NMS stocks to make available to the public
monthly electronic execution reports that include uniform
statistical measures of execution quality. See HMA Letter at 20;
Consumer Federation of America Letter at 7; Markit Letter at 5-6.
\1066\ 17 CFR 242.606. Rule 606 of Regulation NMS requires every
broker or dealer to make publicly available for each calendar
quarter a report on its routing of non-directed orders in NMS
securities during that quarter. See Markit Letter at 6-7; ICI Letter
at 8.
\1067\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 78309 (July 13,
2016), 81 FR 49432 (July 27, 2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VI. Amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) and Rule 303(a)(1) for Written
Safeguards and Written Procedures To Protect Confidential Trading
Information
Current Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS \1068\ requires every ATS
to have in place safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers'
confidential trading information and to separate ATS functions from
other broker-dealer functions, including proprietary and customer
trading.\1069\ Rule 301(b)(10), however, does not currently require
that the safeguards and procedures
[[Page 38864]]
mandated under Rule 301(b)(10) be memorialized in writing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1068\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1069\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70879.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We proposed to amend Rule 301(b)(10)(i) to require that all ATSs
(including both NMS Stock ATSs and non-NMS Stock ATSs) adopt written
safeguards and written procedures that limit access to the confidential
trading information of subscribers to those employees of the ATS who
are operating the system or are responsible for its compliance with
Regulation ATS or any other applicable rules,\1070\ and implement
written standards controlling employees of the ATS trading for their
own accounts.\1071\ In addition, proposed Rule 301(b)(10)(ii) would
require that the oversight procedures, which an ATS adopts and
implements to ensure that the above safeguards and procedures are
followed, be in writing.\1072\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1070\ See Rule 301(b)(10)(i)(A).
\1071\ See Rule 301(b)(10)(i)(B).
\1072\ See Rule 301(b)(10)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received five comments on the proposed amendment to Rule
301(b)(10).\1073\ Four commenters indicate that they support the
requirement that ATSs memorialize safeguards and procedures in writing
as proposed.\1074\ An additional commenter does not object to the
Commission's proposal to require that an ATS's procedures to protect
confidential information be memorialized in writing.\1075\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1073\ See ICI Letter at 10; MFA/AIMA Letter at 6; HMA Letter at
23; STANY Letter at 2; Liquidnet Letter at 17. See also Investor
Advocate Letter at 2.
\1074\ See ICI Letter at 10; MFA/AIMA Letter at 6; HMA Letter at
23; STANY Letter at 2.
\1075\ See Liquidnet Letter at 17. In addition, this commenter
expresses concern that the requirements of Regulation ATS relating
to protection of confidential information could be interpreted in a
manner that would be harmful to long-term investors by prohibiting
broker-dealers that operate ATSs from providing information to
customers that the customers can use to evaluate and enhance their
trading performance, such reports of participants' positive action
rates and the positive action rates of the contras with which they
match. See id. The commenter is concerned that if Rule 301(b)(10) is
interpreted to restrict the distribution of this type of
information, this would harm long-term investors. See id. Proposed
and adopted amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) to require an ATS to
maintain written procedures to protect confidential trading
information neither (i) change the standard for what constitutes
adequate safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers'
confidential trading information nor (ii) narrow or expand the scope
of what is considered to be confidential trading information under
that rule. In general, the determination of what constitutes
subscribers' confidential trading information is a facts and
circumstances analysis, but it is also outside of the scope of this
rulemaking to provide interpretive guidance about the scope of Rule
301(b)(10).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting the amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) as proposed. We
continue to believe that safeguards and procedures to ensure the
confidential treatment of ATS subscribers' trading information are
important, and that the potential for misuse of such information
continues to exist. We also continue to believe that requiring an ATS
to reduce to writing those safeguards and procedures, as well as its
oversight procedures to ensure that such safeguards and procedures are
followed, will strengthen the effectiveness of the ATS's safeguards and
procedures and will better enable the ATS to protect confidential
subscriber trading information and implement and monitor the adequacy
of, and the ATS's compliance with, its safeguards and procedures.\1076\
The proposed revisions would aid investors, market participants, and
regulators by consolidating written safeguards and procedures into one
place for easy review and evaluation.\1077\ Further, we agree with the
comment that asserts that the process of consolidating these safeguards
and procedures may facilitate ATS operators' identification of gaps or
opportunities for improvement of these measures.\1078\ In addition, we
believe that reducing ATSs' safeguards and procedures under Rule
301(b)(10) to writing will help the Commission and its staff, and the
staff of the SRO of which an ATS's broker-dealer operator is a member,
evaluate whether an ATS has established such procedures and safeguards,
whether the ATS has implemented and is abiding by them, and whether
they comply with the requirements of Rule 301(b)(10). This should
assist the Commission, and the applicable SRO(s), to exercise more
effective oversight of ATSs regarding the ATSs' compliance with Rule
301(b)(10) and other federal securities laws, rules, and regulations.
Furthermore, we believe that the amendments we are adopting to Rule
301(b)(1) will benefit market participants because they will be able to
better evaluate the implementation of such safeguards and procedures,
once they are reduced to writing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1076\ In addition, we are requiring public disclosure related
to such safeguards and procedures. See supra Section V.C.6.
\1077\ See HMA Letter at 23.
\1078\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also proposed to amend the record preservation requirements of
Rule 303(a)(1) to incorporate the amendments to Rule 301(b)(10).\1079\
We received no comments on the proposed change to Rule 303(a)(1).\1080\
We are adopting, as proposed, Rule 303(a)(1)(v), which requires that an
ATS, for a period of not less than three years, the first two years in
an easily accessible place, preserve at least one copy of the written
safeguards and written procedures to protect subscribers' confidential
trading information and the written oversight procedures created in the
course of complying with Rule 301(b)(10).\1081\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1079\ See supra Section V.C.8.
\1080\ See supra Section III.B.6.
\1081\ See proposed Rule 303(a)(1)(v).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VII. EDGAR Filing Requirements; Structured Data
Form ATS-N would be filed electronically in a structured format
through EDGAR. By filing in EDGAR, NMS Stock ATSs will be given the
option of filing using a web-fillable Form ATS-N which will render into
XML in EDGAR, or to file directly in XML using the XML schema for NMS
Stock ATSs as published on the Commission's website. With both options,
the Commission will receive the Form ATS-N information in XML format.
For those NMS Stock ATSs that would prefer to manually key in all of
their Form ATS-N responses, as had been originally proposed by us,
those NMS Stock ATSs can do so using the Commission's web-fillable Form
ATS-N, which will render into XML in EDGAR. For those NMS Stock ATSs
that would prefer to map the information in their existing systems so
that filing of Form ATS-N can be more automated and more efficient for
them, those NMS Stock ATS can file in XML using the XML schema as
published on the Commission's website. The Commission's XML schema and
the Commission's web-fillable Form ATS-N both reflect the same set of
custom XML tags and XML restrictions designed by the Commission to
submit the disclosures in Form ATS-N.
As we proposed, all effective Forms ATS-N and all properly filed
Form ATS-N amendments will be made publicly available. Because Form
ATS-N will be filed in an XML format (either using the Commission's
web-fillable form or as an XML file submitted according to the
Commission's XML schema) in EDGAR, once effective, all Forms ATS-N will
be centrally located on EDGAR for the public to access in the same XML
format in which the Form ATS-N was received by the Commission.
The XML format is a text-searchable format that does not require
the use of optical character recognition and will enhance the
Commission's and the public's abilities to better gather, analyze,
aggregate, compare, and use the Form ATS-N data. Requiring XML should
result in the Form ATS-N data being provided in a consistent,
structured format. XML is an open
[[Page 38865]]
standard that defines, or ``tags,'' data using standard definitions.
The tags establish a consistent structure of identity and context. This
consistent structure can be automatically recognized and processed by a
variety of software applications such as databases, financial reporting
systems, and spreadsheets, and then made immediately available to the
end user to search, aggregate, compare, and analyze.
In addition, XML is an open standard that is maintained by a
consensus based market standards organization, rather than the
Commission, and undergoes constant review. As updates to XML or
industry practice develop, the Commission's XML schema and web-fillable
XML architecture may also have to be updated to reflect the updates in
technology. If that occurs, the supported version of the XML schema
would be made available on the Commission's website and the outdated
version of the schema would be removed in order to maintain data
quality and consistency with the standard, while the web-fillable Form
ATS-N would be updated in EDGAR to reflect the same changes in
technology as the Commission's XML schema.
The Commission's XML schema and architecture for the web-fillable
Form ATS-N would also incorporate certain validations to help ensure
consistent formatting and completeness among all Forms ATS-N, in other
words, to help ensure data quality. Validations are restrictions placed
on the formatting for each data element so that comparable data is
presented comparably. However, these validations would not be designed
to ensure the underlying accuracy of the data. Any Form ATS-N filed in
EDGAR would have to comply with validations that are incorporated
within the XML schema, otherwise the Form ATS-N will not be accepted by
EDGAR.
We believe that requiring Form ATS-N be provided in an XML format
would provide the Commission and the public with data about NMS Stock
ATSs in a format that facilitates search capabilities, and comparative
analyses across NMS Stock ATSs and across filings, including more
advanced text analytics for the more narrative responses of Form ATS-N.
Absent this requirement, users of the Form ATS-N data that wanted to
aggregate the data or search across filings or filers would need to
spend additional time transferring the data into a consistent format
before it could be analyzed, or incur the cost of a service provider
that specializes in this data aggregation and comparison process.
Further, unrestricted manual entry of data may lead to errors, thereby
potentially reducing data quality and usability.
We understand that there are costs associated with structuring and
that these costs may vary depending on the filer and the type of
structuring. By offering two options for filers to submit Form ATS-N in
EDGAR, filers will be able to select the method best suited to their
situation. Overall, the we believe that the XML format of Form ATS-N
will have enhanced benefits for the Commission's and the public's use
of Form ATS-N while minimizing costs relative to filers having to file
Form ATS-N using other structured formats.\1082\ Requiring the
Commission's XML schema with its incorporated validations (whether
submitted as XML or in the web-fillable form) will help ensure that the
data that filers submit is complete and appropriately formatted so that
additional time will not have to be spent on subsequent Form ATS-N
filings to correct for those errors. By comparison, the EFFS system
originally proposed does not support the open-source XML format, but
rather a proprietary XML implementation called XFDL. As a result, the
EFFS system has fewer validation capabilities and cannot test for
consistency and completeness as broadly as the XML format, and in
particular, at the element level. In addition, as proposed, filers
would have been required to individually upload each narrative response
as a separate exhibit, whereas the XML format permits filers to provide
all their narrative responses in one structured XML file, which will
slightly diminish their time spent in filing in the Form ATS-N
narrative information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1082\ See infra Section X.D.11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
End users will be able to download the consistently structured
information directly into databases and analyze it using various
software. This would enhance their ability to conduct large-scale
analysis and immediate cross-filing comparisons of NMS Stock ATSs, as
well as comparisons across reporting periods within the same and among
different NMS Stock ATSs. Moreover, as an open standard, XML is widely
available to the public at no cost. By comparison, viewing information
in the current EFFS system requires a license of a commercial
proprietary viewer, which currently is not separately available to
every member of the public without licensing.
Commenters who supported the standardization of Form ATS-N
information also underscored the importance of making the information
comparable.\1083\ While the commenters did not make specific reference
to the structured format, having the Form ATS-N information submitted
using the Commission's XML schema or the web-fillable form will enhance
the comparability of the Form ATS-N data by ensuring that the
information has been submitted completely and consistently. Two
commenters addressed the importance of completeness to Form ATS-N
filings.\1084\ With the Commission's XML schema, the restrictions
incorporated into the schema (and consequently, also reflected in the
web-fillable form) will help test for completeness of the data before
submission and reduce filer uncertainty on the completeness and
consistency of their filing. One commenter recommends that we consider
ways to present information that would improve the readability and
navigability of disclosure through the use of technology such as
hyperlinks and/or XBRL technology.\1085\ The XML format is a technology
format that presents the data consistently, which improves the
readability and navigability of the data. In fact, XBRL is an XML-based
technology, but, as discussed later, we do not think that XBRL is the
appropriate format for this form.\1086\ While hyperlinks may be useful
in some situations to cross-reference information, hyperlinks do not by
themselves enhance the comparability of the underlying data, but can be
incorporated within the XML format, as permitted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1083\ See Fidelity Letter at 1; Morgan Stanley Letter at 2;
SIFMA Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 2-3.
\1084\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4; SIFMA Letter at 32-33.
\1085\ See Fidelity Letter at 5.
\1086\ See infra Section X.D.11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because Form ATS-N filings will be submitted electronically,\1087\
we are revising Rule 101 of Regulation S-T \1088\ to add paragraph
(a)(1)(xxi) to the list of mandated electronic submissions.
Specifically, paragraph (a)(1)(xvii) adds to this list Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1087\ See supra Section V.A.1.
\1088\ 17 CFR 232.101.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VIII. Effective Date and Compliance Date
We did not receive any comments about the effective date for the
amendments. The rules being adopted today will become effective 60 days
after the date of publication in the Federal Register.
With regard to the adopted amendments to Rules 301(b)(10) and
303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS,\1089\ we
[[Page 38866]]
believe the 60 day effective date provides sufficient time for ATSs to
memorialize in writing their safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information (to the extent that those
safeguards and procedures are not currently maintained in written
form). Current Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS \1090\ requires every
ATS to have safeguards and procedures that limit access to the
confidential trading information of subscribers to those employees of
the ATS who are operating the system or are responsible for its
compliance with Regulation ATS or any other applicable rules,\1091\ and
implement standards controlling employees of the ATS trading for their
own accounts.\1092\ We note that the adopted amendments to Rules
301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) do not modify that requirement other than
to require that those safeguards and procedures be written, pursuant to
Rule 301(b)(1) and preserved pursuant to Rule 303(a)(1)(v).
Accordingly, we believe that the 60 days after the final rule is
published in the Federal Register is reasonable for the amendments to
Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) to become effective, and for ATSs to
comply with those rules.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1089\ See supra Section VI.
\1090\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1091\ See Rule 301(b)(10)(i)(A).
\1092\ See Rule 301(b)(10)(i)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that the compliance dates provided in Rules 304 and
301(b)(2)(viii) provide sufficient time for NMS Stock ATSs to prepare
and file Form ATS-N disclosures with the Commission. Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(A) requires a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to file with the
Commission an initial Form ATS-N, in accordance with Rule 304, no
earlier than January 7, 2019, and no later than February 8, 2019.\1093\
Rule 301(b)(2)(viii) provides that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS that is
operating pursuant to an initial operation report on Form ATS on file
with the Commission as of January 7, 2019 shall be subject to the
requirements of Rule 301(b)(2)(i) through (vii) until the Legacy NMS
Stock ATS files an initial Form ATS-N with the Commission pursuant to
Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(A).\1094\ In addition, pursuant to Rule
301(b)(2)(viii), as of January 7, 2019, an entity seeking to operate as
a new NMS Stock ATS shall also be subject to Rule 304 and the rules
amended in relation.\1095\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1093\ See supra Section IV.A.4.a. See also Rule
304(a)(1)(iv)(A).
\1094\ See supra Section III.B.4.
\1095\ See supra Section III.B.4; IV.A.1. See also supra note
291 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
IX. Paperwork Reduction Act
Certain provisions of the proposal contain ``collection of
information'' requirements within the meaning of the Paperwork
Reduction Act of 1995 (``PRA'').\1096\ The titles of these requirements
are:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1096\ 44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Requirements for Alternative Trading Systems That Are Not
National Securities Exchanges--Rule 301, Form ATS and Form ATS-R, 17
CFR 242.301 (OMB Control No. 3235-0509);
Rule 303 (17 CFR 242.303) Record Preservation Requirements
for Alternative Trading Systems (OMB Control No. 3235-0505); and
Rule 304 and Form ATS-N (a new collection of information).
In accordance with 44 U.S.C. 3507(d) and 5 CFR 1320.11, we
submitted these requirements to the Office of Management and Budget
(``OMB'') for review and approval in accordance with the PRA and its
implementing regulations.\1097\ The title for the new collection of
information in Rule 304 and Form ATS-N is ``Rule 304 and Form ATS-N.''
We have applied for a new OMB Control Number for this collection in
accordance with 44 U.S.C. 3507(j) and 5 CFR 1320.13. An agency may not
conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a
collection of information requirement unless it displays a currently
valid OMB control number.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1097\ 44 U.S.C. 3507; 5 CFR 1320.11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the Proposal, we solicited comments on the proposed collection
of information burdens and asked whether commenters agree with our
estimate of the number of respondents and burdens of the Proposal. We
received one comment on our estimates of the collection of information
burden included in the Proposal, which is addressed below.\1098\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1098\ See infra note 1235 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. Summary of Collection of Information
The amendments to Regulation ATS include two new categories of
obligations that require a collection of information within the meaning
of the PRA. The first category relates to Rule 301(b)(10) and Rule 303
of Regulation ATS \1099\ and applies to all ATSs, while the second
category relates to Form ATS-N and applies only to NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1099\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10); 17 CFR 242.303.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Requirements Relating to Rule 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1) of Regulation
ATS
The amendments to Regulation ATS will require an ATS to place in
writing the safeguards and procedures required by Rule 301(b)(10) to
protect subscribers' confidential trading information and oversight
procedures to ensure that the safeguards and procedures are followed.
In addition, we are amending Rule 303(a)(1) \1100\ of Regulation ATS to
require an ATS to preserve at least one copy of written safeguards and
written procedures, and written oversight procedures created in the
course of complying with Rule 301(b)(10) for a period of not less than
three years, the first two years in an easily accessible place.\1101\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1100\ 17 CFR 242.303(a)(1).
\1101\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Requirements Relating to Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation
ATS, Including Form ATS-N
Any ATS that meets the definition of an NMS Stock ATS is required
to complete an initial Form ATS-N, file it with the Commission via
EDGAR, and make public via posting on its website a direct URL
hyperlink to the Commission's website that contains the documents
enumerated in Rule 304(b)(2).\1102\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1102\ See generally Section IV.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Form ATS-N requires that the entity submitting the filing would
indicate whether the NMS Stock ATS currently operates pursuant to a
Form ATS, and the type of Form ATS-N filing--whether the Form ATS-N is
an initial Form ATS-N, a Form ATS-N amendment (whether a material
amendment, updating amendment, correcting amendment, or order display
and fair access amendment), a notice of cessation, and if it is a
notice of cessation, the date the NMS Stock ATS will cease to operate,
or if it is a withdrawal. If the filing is a Form ATS-N amendment, the
NMS Stock ATS is also required to provide a brief summary of the
amendment and the EDGAR accession number for the Form ATS-N filing to
be amended. If the filing is a withdrawal, the NMS Stock ATS is
required to provide the EDGAR accession number for the Form ATS-N
filing to be withdrawn.
Part I requires information about the broker-dealer operator.\1103\
Part II of Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS to disclose information
about the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates.\1104\ Part
[[Page 38867]]
III of Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS to provide certain
information about the manner of operations of the NMS Stock ATS.\1105\
Part IV of Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS to provide contact
information. In addition, Form ATS-N will require NMS Stock ATSs to
file the form electronically via EDGAR with a typed signature.\1106\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1103\ See Section V.B.2.
\1104\ See Section V.C.
\1105\ See Section V.D.
\1106\ See Section V.A.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also amending Rule 303(a)(2)(ii) to require that an NMS
Stock ATS preserve, for the life of the enterprise and of any successor
enterprise, copies of reports filed pursuant to Rule 304.\1107\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1107\ See Rule 303(a)(2)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, an ATS that trades both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks
will be required to file both a Form ATS-N with respect to its trading
of NMS stocks and a revised Form ATS that removes discussion of those
aspects of the ATS related to the trading of NMS stocks. The ATS will
also be required to file two Forms ATS-R filings--one to report its
trading volume in NMS stocks and another to report its trading volume
in non-NMS stocks.
B. Proposed Use of Information
1. Amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1) of Regulation ATS
We continue to believe that both the Commission and the SRO of
which the ATS's broker-dealer operator is a member will use the written
safeguards and written procedures required by the amendments to Rule
301(b)(10) to better understand how each ATS protects subscribers'
confidential trading information from unauthorized disclosure and
access. We continue to believe that the information contained in the
records required to be preserved by Rule 303(a)(1)(v) will be used by
examiners and other representatives of the Commission, state securities
regulatory authorities, and SROs to evaluate whether ATSs are in
compliance with Regulation ATS as well as other applicable rules and
regulations. We also believe that the requirement to memorialize in
writing the safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers'
confidential trading information will help assist ATSs in more
effectively complying with their existing legal requirements under
Regulation ATS; in particular, the requirements to protect the
confidentiality of subscribers' trading information under Rule
301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS.
2. Rules 301(b)(2)(viii), 304 of Regulation ATS, Including Form ATS-N,
and 301(b)(9)
We believe that market participants will use the information
publicly disclosed on Form ATS-N to compare and evaluate NMS Stock ATSs
when making their routing decisions.\1108\ In addition, we believe we
will use the information disclosed on Form ATS-N, Form ATS, and Form
ATS-R to oversee the growth and development of NMS Stock ATSs.\1109\ We
believe that the information contained in the records required to be
preserved by the amendment to Rule 303(a)(2)(ii) will be used by
examiners and other representatives of the Commission, state securities
regulatory authorities, and SROs to evaluate whether ATSs are in
compliance with Regulation ATS as well as other applicable rules and
regulations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1108\ See supra Section III.A.1.a.
\1109\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Respondents
The ``collection of information'' requirements under the amendments
to Regulation ATS relating to Rule 301(b)(10) and Rule 303(a)(1)(v)
would apply to all ATSs, including NMS Stock ATSs. The ``collection of
information'' requirements under the amendments to Regulation ATS
relating to Rule 304, Form ATS-N, and the amendments to Rule
303(a)(2)(ii) would apply only to NMS Stock ATSs, and the ``collection
of information'' requirements under the amendments to Rule 301(b)(9)
would apply to NMS Stock ATSs that also transact in both NMS stocks and
non-NMS stocks. Currently, there are 87 ATSs that have filed Form ATS
with us. Of these 87 ATSs, 41 would meet the definition of an NMS Stock
ATS.\1110\ Accordingly, the we estimate that 87 entities would be
required to comply with the amendments related to Rule 301(b)(10) of
Regulation ATS and 41 entities would be required to complete Form ATS-
N.\1111\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1110\ As of March 31, 2018, 41 ATS have disclosed on their Form
ATS that they trade or expect to trade NMS stock.
\1111\ We recognize that there may be new entities that will
seek to become ATSs, or NMS Stock ATSs, that would be required to
comply with the proposed amendments to Rule 301(b)(10). From January
2014 through the first half of 2017, an average of 12 Form ATS
initial operation reports were filed each year with us. Similarly,
some ATSs may cease operations in the normal course of business or
possibly in response to the proposed amendments to Regulation ATS.
From January 2014 through the March 31, 2018, an average of 9 ATSs,
including those that trade NMS stocks have ceased operations. For
the purposes of this paperwork burden analysis, we assume that 87
respondents would be required to comply with the proposed amendments
to Rule 301(b)(10), if adopted. We are estimating that the number of
entities that may file a Form ATS initial operation report would
generally offset any ATSs that may file a Form ATS cessation of
operations report.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, there are currently 10 ATSs that trade, or have
indicated in Exhibit B to their Form ATS that they expect to trade,
both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks on the ATS.\1112\ Under the
amendments to Regulation ATS, these 10 entities would be required to
file a Form ATS-N to disclose information about their NMS stock
activities and file a Form ATS to disclose information about their non-
NMS stock activities. Consequently, these 10 ATSs would have to amend
their Forms ATS to remove information regarding operations related to
the trading of NMS stocks and on an ongoing basis, file separate Forms
ATS-R to report trading volume in NMS stocks and trading volume in non-
NMS stocks.\1113\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1112\ Data compiled from Forms ATS and ATS-R submitted to us as
of March 31, 2018. These 10 ATSs are included within the 41 NMS
Stock ATSs.
\1113\ Pursuant to Rule 301(b)(9), all ATSs are required to file
Form ATS-R within 30 calendar days after the end of each calendar
quarter in which the market has operated, and within 10 calendar
days after the ATS ceases to operate. An ATS that trades both NMS
stocks and non-NMS stocks would report its transactions in NMS
stocks on one Form ATS-R, and its transaction volume in other
securities on a separate Form ATS-R.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to Form ATS-N, we recognize there may be entities that
might file a Form ATS-N to operate an NMS Stock ATS in the future. From
January 2014 through March 2018, an average of 2 new ATSs per year
disclose that they trade or expect to trade NMS stocks on their Form
ATS initial operation reports, and would therefore fall within the
definition of an NMS Stock ATS. Similarly, some ATSs that currently
trade NMS stocks may choose to cease operations rather than comply with
the amendments requiring them to file Form ATS-N. Other ATSs may choose
to cease operations in the normal course of business. From January 2014
through March 2018, an average of 9 ATSs that trade NMS stocks have
ceased operations each year.\1114\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1114\ In the Proposal, we cited the average number of new ATSs
and ATSs that ceased operations from 2012 through the first half of
2015, which were 2 and 6, respectively. See Proposal, supra note 2,
at 81092.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that most ATSs that currently trade NMS stocks would
continue to operate notwithstanding the amendments to Regulation ATS.
For the purposes of this analysis of the paperwork burden associated
with the amendments to Regulation ATS, we assume that there will be 41
respondents. This number assumes that most ATSs that currently trade
NMS
[[Page 38868]]
stocks would file a Form ATS-N with the Commission. We acknowledge that
some ATSs may cease operations altogether and other entities that may
commence operations as an NMS Stock ATS. Based on the current number of
initial operation reports and cessation of operations reports on
current Form ATS for ATSs that trade NMS stocks described above, we
estimate that 2 to 3 new entities will file initial Form ATS-N to
become an NMS Stock ATS and 7 to 9 NMS Stock ATSs will cease operations
in each of the next three years.
D. Total Initial and Annual Reporting and Recordkeeping Burdens
1. Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS
a. Baseline Measurements
We believe that ATSs--in particular, ATSs whose broker-dealer
operators are large, multi-service broker-dealers--generally have and
maintain in writing their safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information, as well as the oversight
procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures are followed.\1115\
However, neither Rule 301(b)(10) nor Rule 303(a)(1) of Regulation ATS
currently requires that an ATS have and preserve those safeguards and
procedures in writing. For ATSs that currently have and preserve in
written format the safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers'
confidential trading information under Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation
ATS, we estimate that the average annual burden they voluntarily
undertake to update and preserve those written safeguards and written
procedures is 4 hours.\1116\ Because neither current Rule 301(b)(10)
nor current Rule 303(a)(1) requires an ATS to have and preserve its
safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information in writing, this burden is not reflected in the current PRA
baseline burdens for Rules 301 and 303.\1117\ In accordance with the
below analysis, we are modifying the current PRA burdens for Rules 301
and 303 to account for the new requirement that ATSs have and preserve
in written format the safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers'
confidential trading information.\1118\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1115\ See infra Section VI.
\1116\ Attorney at 2 hours + Compliance Clerk at 2 hours = 4
burden hours. For ATSs that do not have their safeguards and
procedures or oversight procedures in a written format, these firms
would incur a one-time initial burden to record their safeguards and
procedures as well as their oversight procedures in a written format
as described below.
\1117\ See FR Doc. 2014-02143, 79 FR 6236 (February 3, 2014)
(Request to OMB for Extension of Rule 301 and Forms ATS and ATS-R;
SEC File No. 270-451; OMB Control No. 3235-0509) (hereinafter ``Rule
301 PRA Update''); FR Doc. 2013-17474, 78 FR 43943 (July 22, 2013)
(Request to OMB for Extension of Rule 303; SEC File No. 270-450; OMB
Control No. 3235-0505) (hereinafter ``Rule 303 PRA Update'').
\1118\ See infra note 1125 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Burdens
We recognize that Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation
ATS would impose certain burdens on respondents. For ATSs that
currently have and preserve in written format the safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information and
written oversight procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures
are followed, we believe that there will be no increased burden under
the amendments to Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS.
We believe that the current practices of those ATSs would already be in
compliance with the rules and the amendments should not require these
ATSs to take any actions in addition to those currently undertaken.
For ATSs that have not recorded in writing their safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information and
oversight procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures are
followed, there will be an initial, one-time burden to memorialize them
in a written document(s). In the Proposal, we estimated that an ATS's
initial, one-time burden to put in writing its safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information and
the oversight procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures are
followed would be 8 hours.\1119\ We did not receive any comment on the
preliminary estimates. Because ATSs are already required to have
safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information and to have oversight procedures to ensure such safeguards
and procedures are followed, we believe that recording these items in a
written format would not impose a substantial burden on ATSs and would
rely on internal staff to record the ATS's Rule 301(b)(10) procedures
in writing. Therefore, we estimate that an ATS's initial, one-time
burden to put in writing its safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information and the oversight
procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures are followed would
be approximately 8 hours,\1120\ but we estimate that the burden could
range between 5 and 10 hours.\1121\ We estimate that, of the 87 current
ATSs, 15 ATSs might not have their safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information or oversight procedures
to ensure such safeguards and procedures are followed in writing, and
would therefore be subject to this one-time initial burden.\1122\
Accordingly, we estimate that the aggregate initial, one-time burden on
all ATSs would be 120 hours based on our highest approximation of the
additional burden per ATS.\1123\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1119\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81094.
\1120\ Attorney at 7 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1 hour = 8
burden hours.
\1121\ Attorney at 4-9 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1 hour = 5-10
burden hours.
\1122\ It is likely that most, if not all, ATSs already fulfill
their Rule 301(b)(10) obligations in writing, given the practical
difficulty in ensuring such safeguards and procedures, as well as
oversight procedures, are ``adequate,'' as required under Rule
301(b)(10), and contain all necessary components.
\1123\ (Attorney at 7 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1 hour) x (15
ATSs) = 120 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We estimate that the average annual, ongoing burden per ATS to
update and preserve written safeguards and written procedures to
protect subscribers' confidential trading information, as well as to
update and preserve the written standards controlling employees of the
ATS trading for their own account and the written oversight procedures,
would be 4 hours.\1124\ As a result, we estimate that the total
aggregate, ongoing burden per year for all ATSs would be 348
hours,\1125\ and thus, we are modifying the current PRA burden
estimates for Rules 301 and 303 to account for this increased burden on
ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1124\ See supra note 1116 and accompanying text.
\1125\ (Attorney at 2 hours + Compliance Clerk at 2 hours) x 87
ATSs = 348 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS, Including Form ATS-
N
a. Baseline Measurements
Currently, Rule 301(b)(2)(i) of Regulation ATS \1126\ requires an
ATS to file an initial operation report on current Form ATS at least 20
days prior to commencing operation as an alternative trading system.
Current Form ATS requires information regarding the operation of the
ATS, including, among other things, classes of subscribers, the types
of securities traded, the outsourcing of operations of the ATS to other
entities, the procedures governing the entry of orders, the means of
access to the ATS, and procedures governing execution and reporting.
Regarding amendments to an existing Form ATS, Rule 301(b)(2)(ii) of
Regulation ATS \1127\ requires an ATS to file amendments to its current
Form ATS at least 20
[[Page 38869]]
calendar days prior to implementing a material change to its
operations. Rule 301(b)(2)(iii) of Regulation ATS \1128\ requires an
ATS to file amendments to its current Form ATS within 30 calendar days
after the end of each calendar quarter if any information contained in
its initial operation report becomes inaccurate and has not been
previously reported to the Commission.\1129\ Regarding shutting down an
ATS, Rule 301(b)(2)(v) of Regulation ATS \1130\ requires an ATS to
promptly file a cessation of operation report on current Form ATS upon
ceasing operations as an ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1126\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(i).
\1127\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(ii).
\1128\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(iii).
\1129\ In addition, Rule 301(b)(2)(iv) requires an ATS to
promptly file an amendment on current Form ATS after the discovery
that any information previously filed on current Form ATS was
inaccurate when filed. 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(iv).
\1130\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(v).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our currently approved estimate for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS is 20 hours to gather the necessary information,
provide the required disclosures in Exhibits A through I, and submit
the Form ATS to the Commission.\1131\ With respect to Form ATS
amendments, we understand, based on the review of Form ATS amendments
by the Commission and its staff, that ATSs that trade NMS stocks
typically amend their Form ATS on average twice per year.\1132\ The
frequency and scope of Form ATS amendments vary depending on whether
the ATS is implementing a material change or an updating change. Some
ATSs may not change how they operate or anything else that might
require an amendment to Form ATS in a given year while others may
implement a number of changes during a given year that require Form ATS
amendments. Our currently approved estimated average compliance burden
for each amendment to Form ATS is approximately 6 hours.\1133\
Accordingly, the estimated average annual ongoing burden of updating
and amending Form ATS is approximately 12 hours per NMS Stock
ATS.\1134\ With respect to ceasing operations, the currently approved
average estimated compliance burden for an ATS to complete a notice of
cessation is 2 hours to check the appropriate box on Form ATS and send
the notice of cessation to the Commission.\1135\ Our currently approved
estimate for the average compliance burden for each Form ATS-R filing
is 4 hours.\1136\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1131\ Attorney at 13 hours + Compliance Clerk at 7 hours = 20
burden hours. See Rule 301 PRA Update, supra note 1117, 79 FR 6237.
\1132\ See id.
\1133\ Attorney at 4.5 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1.5 hours = 6
burden hours. See id.
\1134\ 2 Form ATS amendments filed annually x 6 burden hours per
Form ATS amendment = 12 burden hours per ATS.
\1135\ Attorney at 1.5 hours + Compliance Clerk at 0.5 hours = 2
burden hours. See PRA Update, supra note 1117, 79 FR 6237.
\1136\ Attorney at 3 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1 hour = 4
burden hours. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Burdens
We recognize that Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS,
including Form ATS-N, would impose certain burdens on
respondents.\1137\ Although many of the disclosures required by Form
ATS-N are currently required by Form ATS, Form ATS-N requires an NMS
Stock ATS to provide significantly more detail in those disclosures
than currently required by Form ATS. Form ATS-N also requires
additional disclosures not currently mandated by current Form ATS such
as those contained in Part II of adopted Form ATS-N. Under the
amendments to Regulation ATS, NMS Stock ATSs will be required to
complete and file the enhanced and additional disclosures on Form ATS-
N.\1138\ Section IX.D.2.b.i below provides the estimated burden above
the current Form ATS baseline of each item of Form ATS-N. Many of the
disclosure items on Form ATS-N are already required disclosures by
respondents in whole or in part on current Form ATS, while other
disclosure items on Form ATS-N are novel (i.e., current Form ATS does
not require some form of the disclosure). Section IX.D.2.b.ii
aggregates these new burdens and the additional burdens above the
current Form ATS baseline that will be imposed by Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1137\ In establishing the estimates below with respect to Form
ATS-N, we have considered its estimate of the burden for an SRO to
amend a Form 19b-4. Specifically, we estimated that 34 hours is the
amount of time required to complete an average rule filing and 129
hours is the amount of time required to complete a complex rule
filing, and three hours is the amount of time required to complete
an average amendment to a rule filing. See Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 50486 (October 4, 2004), 69 FR 60287, 60294 (October 8,
2004).
\1138\ These disclosures will be provided on Form ATS-N and may
have to be amended periodically as provided in proposed Rule 304.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(i) Analysis of Estimated Additional Burden for Form ATS-N
(a) Part I
In the Proposal, we estimated that preparing Parts I and II for a
Form ATS-N would add 0.5 hours to the current baseline for an NMS Stock
ATS to prepare an initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1139\
Part I of adopted Form ATS-N contains substantially the same
information as Parts I and II of proposed Form ATS-N. However, adopted
Form ATS-N does not include several proposed disclosure requirements
and contains several new requests. Overall, we estimate that the burden
for Part I of adopted Form ATS-N will be the same as that which was
estimated for proposed Form ATS-N. Accordingly, we estimate that Part I
of adopted Form ATS-N will add an additional 0.5 hours above the
baseline of current Form ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1139\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81095.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(b) Part II
As explained above, Part II, Items 1 and 2 contain disclosure
requests about the broker-dealer operator's and affiliates',
respectively, trading activity on the NMS Stock ATS. For Part II, Item
1(a), to the extent that the broker-dealer operator is not permitted to
enter or direct orders and trading interest to the NMS Stock ATS, the
NMS Stock ATS would only be required to check ``no.'' In addition, to
the extent the broker-dealer operator enters or directs the entry of
orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS, but such orders and
trading interest is treated the same as trading interest from other
subscribers and persons, Part II, Item 1(b) would require that the NMS
Stock ATS check ``no.''
Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N incorporates aspects of
several proposed disclosures that addressed the activity of the broker-
dealer operator's trading activity on the NMS Stock ATS. First, Part
II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N incorporates requirements of Part
III, Items 1 and 2 of proposed Form ATS-N, which would have requested
disclosures about the non-ATS trading centers and other NMS Stock ATSs
operated by the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates. In the
Proposal, we estimated that preparing Part III, Item 1 for proposed
Form ATS-N would add 10 hours to the current baseline of Form ATS and
Part III, Item 2 would add 4 hours to the current baseline of Form ATS,
for a total estimated burden of 14 hours for Part III, Items 1 and 2.
Adopted Part II, Item 1(a) more narrowly tailors those proposed
requests by focusing on the actual trading activities of the broker-
dealer operator on the NMS Stock ATS and its use of the ATS's services.
Primarily, the request under adopted Item 1(a): (i) Does not require an
NMS Stock ATS to list all non-ATS trading centers and NMS Stock ATSs
operated by the broker-dealer operator, regardless of whether those
entities trade on the NMS Stock ATS; and (ii) replaces what some
commenters perceived as potentially broad narrative requests to
describe the ``interaction and coordination'' between
[[Page 38870]]
the NMS Stock ATS and those non-ATS trading centers and other NMS Stock
ATSs. Instead, the NMS Stock ATS is now required to name and describe
each type of business unit of the broker-dealer operator that enters or
directs the entry of orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock
ATS, and we have replaced the term ``interaction and coordination''
with specific, enumerated data points and narratives that the NMS Stock
ATS must provide. Furthermore, the corresponding affiliate disclosures
for Part III, Items 1 and 2 of proposed Form ATS-N are now encompassed
by Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N, so Part II, Item 1(a) of
adopted Form ATS-N will not impose the entire burden that was estimated
for proposed Part III, Items 1 and 2. It will impose the burden from
those proposed items that would have been imposed by the disclosure
requirements related to the broker-dealer operator itself, which we
believe is a small fraction of the proposed estimate relevant to the
requirements related to affiliates of the broker-dealer operator.
Accordingly, out of the 14-hour estimate for proposed Part III, Items 1
and 2, we estimate that Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N would
add approximately 2.75 hours to the baseline estimate to complete an
initial operation report on Form ATS.
Second, the request under Part II, Items 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N
also incorporates aspects of the disclosures proposed under Part III,
Item 5(a) of proposed Form ATS-N. We estimated that preparing proposed
Part III, Item 5(a) would add 5 hours to the current baseline.\1140\
While we did not provide estimates for each individual subpart of Part
III, Item 5 of proposed Form ATS-N, the aspects of Part III, Item 5
that are incorporated into Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N
(i.e., information about the broker-dealer operator's trading activity
on the ATS, other than the information covered by proposed Item 5(d))
accounted for approximately 1.5 hours of the 5 hour estimate. We
believe that the aspects of proposed Part III, Item 5 that are
incorporated into Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N would still
add approximately 1.5 hours to the baseline for an initial operation
report on current Form ATS.\1141\ Adopted Form ATS-N requires the NMS
Stock ATS to identify business units of the broker-dealer operator that
enter or direct the entry of orders, whereas proposed Form ATS-N would
have required the NMS Stock ATS to identity all business units that may
enter orders or other trading interest. However, we believe that it
would impose approximately the same burden for the broker-dealer
operator to compile both lists because both would involve the
collection of information about internal units of the broker-dealer
operator.\1142\ Accordingly, we estimate that the adopted requests
under Part II, Item 1(a) would add a total of approximately 4.25 hours
to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 174.25 hours
above the baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Items
1(a) and (b) of Form ATS-N.\1143\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1140\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81097.
\1141\ The estimated burden hours for proposed Part III, Item
5(a) related to affiliate trading on the ATS are now allocated to
Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N.
\1142\ As noted below with regard to Part II, Item 2(a) of
adopted Form ATS-N, however, the analogous change in scope for
affiliate trading activity on the NMS Stock ATS will reduce the
burden on NMS Stock ATSs relative to that which was proposed.
\1143\ (Attorney at 3.75 + Compliance Manager at 0.5) x 41 NMS
Stock ATSs = 174.25 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The information sought under Part II, Item 1(b) of adopted Form
ATS-N would have been requested under Part III, Item 9 of proposed Form
ATS-N. We estimated that completing Part III, Item 9 of proposed Form
ATS-N would add 2 hours to the current baseline of Form ATS.\1144\ In
most cases, Part II, Item 1(b) of adopted Form ATS-N will require the
NMS Stock ATS to answer ``yes'' or ``no'' and list applicable item
numbers in Part III of adopted Form ATS-N. An NMS Stock ATS will need
to provide a narrative under Item 1(b) only if there are differences
that are not applicable to Part III. But we believe that the subject
matter covered by Part III is very comprehensive, and therefore, we do
not believe that an NMS Stock ATS typically will need to provide
additional narratives about differences in treatment that are not
otherwise covered by Part III. Accordingly, we estimate that Part II,
Item 1(b) of adopted Form ATS-N would add 0.25 hours out of the
proposed 2-hour estimate for Part III, Item 9 to the current baseline
for an initial operation report on Form ATS because in most instances,
the NMS Stock ATS will be required to check the ``yes'' or ``no'' box
and provide a list of relevant requests in Part III. This would result
in an aggregate initial burden of 10.25 hours above the baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 1(b) of Form ATS-N.\1145\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1144\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81098.
\1145\ Attorney at 0.25 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 10.25 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, Part II, Items 1(c) and 1(d) of adopted Form ATS-N
include requests for information that are intended to highlight
disclosures about conflicts of interests and potential information
leakage in Part III, Items 12 and 16, respectively, of adopted Form
ATS-N. Part IV, Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N set forth the proposed
disclosure requirements regarding liquidity providers on the NMS Stock
ATS. This request for information is now set forth in Part III, Item 12
of adopted Form ATS-N. In Part II, Item 1(c) of adopted Form ATS-N, we
have now added the additional disclosure requirements for the NMS Stock
ATS to answer a ``yes'' or ``no'' question and provide a list of any
internal business units that trade on the NMS Stock ATS as liquidity
providers in order to highlight information about potential conflicts
of interest that might be disclosed in Part III, Item 12 of adopted
Form ATS-N. We therefore estimate that, on average, preparing Part II,
Item 1(c) for a Form ATS-N would add 1 hour to the current baseline for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This would result in
an aggregate initial burden of 41 hours above the baseline for all NMS
Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 1(c) of Form ATS-N.\1146\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1146\ Compliance Manager at 1.0 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41
burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Items 1(b)(iii) and 2(b)(iii) of proposed Form ATS-N
would have required the NMS Stock ATS to explain the circumstances
under which subscriber orders or trading interest received by the NMS
Stock ATS may be removed from the NMS Stock ATS and sent to non-ATS
trading centers or other NMS Stock ATSs operated or controlled by the
broker-dealer operator, respectively. These disclosures are now
incorporated into Part III, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N. However, we
believe that information about the routing or removal of orders from
the NMS Stock ATS to a trading center operated or controlled by the
broker-dealer operator may include information that market participants
find necessary to evaluate potential conflicts of interest or
information leakage on the NMS Stock ATS, so we have added Part II,
Item 1(d) to Part II of adopted Form ATS-N. Part II, Item 1(d) of
adopted Form ATS-N requires the NMS Stock ATS to answer a ``yes'' or
``no'' question. The narrative associated with this disclosure will be
set forth in Part III, Item 16. We therefore estimate that, on average,
preparing Part II, Item 1(d) for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5 hour to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.
This would result in an aggregate initial
[[Page 38871]]
burden of 20.5 hours above the baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to
complete Part II, Item 1(d) of Form ATS-N.\1147\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1147\ Compliance Manager at 0.5 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
20.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The requests under Part II, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N mirror
those of Part II, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N, except that the former
requires disclosures about the trading activity of the broker-dealer
operator and the latter require disclosures about the trading
activities of affiliates.\1148\ As with Item 1, to the extent no
affiliate of the broker-dealer operator can enter or direct the entry
of orders and trading interest into the NMS Stock ATS, the NMS Stock
ATS would be required to check ``no'' under Part II, Item 2(a). In
addition, to the extent that there are no differences between treatment
of affiliates that can enter or direct the entry of orders and trading
interest into the ATS and other subscribers and persons regarding
services offered and provided by the NMS Stock ATS, the NMS Stock ATS
would \ be required to check ``no'' under Part II, Item 2(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1148\ See supra Section V.C.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Likewise, as with Part II, Item 1(a) of adopted Form ATS-N, the
disclosure requests in Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N are
more narrowly tailored than those which were proposed, and the
disclosure requests about trading activities of the broker-dealer
operator are no longer contained in the same questions as those
regarding affiliate trading in adopted Form ATS-N. Most significantly,
we believe that the burden for an NMS Stocks ATS to provide information
about each of its broker-dealer operator's affiliates that trades on
the NMS Stock ATS will be less than it would have been to provide: (i)
A comprehensive list of all non-ATS trading centers and NMS Stock ATSs
operated by affiliates, as was proposed under Part III, Items 1 and 2,
respectively; and (ii) a list of each affiliate that may enter orders
or other trading interest on the NMS Stock ATS, as was proposed under
Part III, Item 5(a). Under their current disclosure requirements
pursuant to Regulation ATS, ATSs must compile a list of subscribers
that were participants on the ATS for its quarterly reports on current
Form ATS-R.\1149\ On the other hand, there is no current requirement
for an ATS to maintain a list of its broker-dealer operator's
affiliates' non-ATS trading centers or NMS Stock ATSs, as was proposed.
To the extent that an NMS Stock ATS must dedicate resources to
determine whether any of its affiliates direct the entry of orders or
trading interest into the ATS through a third-party broker-dealer in
order to be responsive to Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N, we
believe that burden will also be less than it would have been to
compile--and keep up-to-date--a list of all non-ATS trading centers and
NMS Stock ATSs operated by its affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1149\ See Exhibit A of Form ATS-R.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, the burden to complete Item 2(a) will likely vary
significantly among NMS Stock ATSs because the number of affiliates of
each broker-dealer operator--and the number of those affiliates that
trade on the NMS Stock ATS--may vary significantly among ATSs. However,
even though the wording of the disclosure requests are almost
identical, Part II, Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N will likely impose
a greater burden than that of Part II, Item 1(a) because we believe it
will take an NMS Stock ATS longer to compile the necessary information
about affiliated third-party entities than it will to compile that
information for internal business units of the broker-dealer operator.
Accordingly, we estimate that, on average, preparing adopted Part II,
Item 2(a) would add approximately 6.25 hours to the current baseline
for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This will result
in an aggregate initial burden of 256.25 hours above the baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 2(a) of Form ATS-N.\1150\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1150\ (Attorney at 5.75 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.5
hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 256.25 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Like Part II, Item 1(b) of adopted Form ATS-N, the disclosure
request in Part II, Item 2(b) will usually require the NMS Stock ATS to
answer ``yes'' or ``no'' and list applicable item numbers in Part III
of adopted Form ATS-N. An NMS Stock ATS must provide a narrative under
Item 2(b) only if there are differences that are not applicable to Part
III. Accordingly, we estimate that Part II, Item 2(b) of adopted Form
ATS-N would add .25 hours out of the proposed 2 hours for Part III,
Item 9 to the current baseline for an initial operation report on Form
ATS because in most instances, the NMS Stock ATS will be required to
check the ``yes'' or ``no'' box and provide a list of relevant requests
in Part III. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 10.25
hours above the baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II,
Item 1(b) of Form ATS-N.\1151\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1151\ Attorney at 0.25 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 10.25 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, as is the case with Part II, Item 1 of adopted Form
ATS-N, Part II, Items 2(c) and 2(d) of adopted Form ATS-N includes
requests for information that are intended to highlight potential
conflicts of interests and information leakage that will be disclosed
in Part III, Items 12 and 16, respectively, of adopted Form ATS-N.
Accordingly, similar to Part II, Item 1(c), we estimate that, on
average, preparing Part II, Item 2(c) for a Form ATS-N would add 1 hour
to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 41 hours above
the baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 1(c) of
Form ATS-N.\1152\ Similar to Part II, Item 1(d), we estimate that, on
average, preparing Part II, Item 2(d) for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5
hour to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current
Form ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 20.5
hours above the baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II,
Item 2(d) of Form ATS-N.\1153\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1152\ (Compliance Manager at 1.0 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
41 burden hours.
\1153\ (Compliance Manager at 0.5 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
20.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N contains
disclosure requests about order interaction with the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates. To the extent that the NMS Stock ATS does
not allow subscribers to opt out of interacting with the broker-dealer
operator, the NMS Stock ATS must check ``no'' to Part II, Item 3(a).
Similarly, to the extent that the NMS Stock ATS does not allow
subscribers to opt out of interacting with the broker-dealer operator,
the NMS Stock ATS must check ``no'' to Part II, Item 3(b). In addition,
to the extent that the terms and conditions of the opt out processes
are the same for all subscribers, the NMS Stock ATS must check ``no''
to Part II, Item 3(c).
The requirements under Part II, Items 3(a) and (b) of adopted Form
ATS-N are intended to cover the subject matter originally proposed
under Part III, Item 5(d) of proposed Form ATS-N.\1154\ In the
Proposal, we estimated that all of the items of Part III, Item 5 of
proposed Form ATS-N would add 5 hours to the current baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1155\ While we did not
provide estimates for each individual subpart of Part III, Item 5 of
proposed Form ATS-N, subpart (d) of Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form
ATS-N accounted for approximately 1 hour of the 5 hour estimate. We
believe that the requests under Part II, Items 3(a)
[[Page 38872]]
and (b) would still add approximately 1 hour to the baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS. As described in the
Proposal, the broker-dealer operator should already know whether
subscribers can opt out of interacting with the orders and trading
interests of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.\1156\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1154\ Other requirements of Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form
ATS-N are incorporated in adopted Part II, Item 1.
\1155\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81097.
\1156\ See id. at 81096.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, we have incorporated the disclosure request from Part
III, Item 9 regarding differentiated and preferential treatment into
the disclosure request under Part II, Item 3(c) of adopted Form ATS-N.
We estimate that Item 3(c) would add approximately .5 hours out of the
proposed 2 hours for Part III, Item 9 to the baseline for an initial
operation report on Form ATS. To the extent there are such differences,
the NMS Stock ATS would be required to provide a narrative under Part
II, Item 3(c) regarding services or functionalities of the NMS Stock
ATS in addition to the narratives about manner of operations required
under Part III. Accordingly, we estimate that, on average, preparing
Part II, Item 3 for adopted Form ATS-N would add 1.5 hours to the
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This will
result in an aggregate initial burden of 61.5 hours above the baseline
for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-
N.\1157\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1157\ (Attorney at 1 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.5 hours) x
41 NMS Stock ATSs = 61.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N contains
disclosure requests about arrangements with other trading centers. In
the Proposal, we estimated that the requirements of Part III, Item 4 of
proposed Form ATS-N--which set forth the proposed requests regarding
arrangements with unaffiliated trading centers--would add 4 hours to
the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS.\1158\ We have revised the proposed disclosure to clarify the scope
of requested information and to add a requirement to disclose any
arrangements with affiliated trading centers.\1159\ As we stated in the
Proposal, depending on the extent to which the broker-dealer operator
or any affiliate of the broker-dealer operator has any formal or
informal arrangement with a trading center to access the services of
the NMS Stock, the hourly burden related to completing Part II, Item 4
would likely vary.\1160\ While the scope of Part III, Item 4 of
proposed Form ATS-N only encompassed arrangements with unaffiliated
trading centers, Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N encompasses
arrangements with both unaffiliated and affiliated trading centers.
However, we still believe that the hourly burden for the adopted
disclosure request will vary depending on the extent to which a broker-
dealer operator enters into arrangements with its affiliates and on the
number of the broker-dealer operator's affiliates. We therefore,
estimate that, on average and consistent with the proposed disclosure
requirement, preparing Part II, Item 4 for a Form ATS-N would still add
approximately 4 hours, on average, to the current baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS. This results in an
aggregate initial burden of 164 hours above the current baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-
N.\1161\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1158\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81096.
\1159\ See supra Section V.C.3.
\1160\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81096.
\1161\ (Compliance Manager at 3 hours + Senior Marketing Manager
at 1 hour) x 164 NMS Stock ATSs = 164 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N contains
disclosure requests about other products or services. To the extent
that that the broker-dealer operator or any of its affiliates does not
offer subscribers any products or services for the purpose of effecting
transactions or for submitting, disseminating, or displaying orders and
trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS, the NMS Stock ATS would need to
check ``no'' on Part II, Items 5(a) and 5(b) and Items 5(c) and 5(d),
respectively.
Part II, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N adopts, with modifications,
the disclosure requests in Part III, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N,
which would have required an NMS Stock ATS to disclose whether the
broker-dealer operator, or any of its affiliates, offers subscribers
any products or services used in connection with trading on the NMS
Stock ATS (e.g., algorithmic trading products, market data feeds). In
the Proposal, we estimated that it would take an average of 3 hours for
an NMS Stock ATS to disclose this information.\1162\ As noted in the
Proposal, we believe that depending on the extent to which the broker-
dealer operator or any of its affiliates offers subscribers or persons
any products or services for the purpose of effecting transactions or
for submitting, disseminating, or displaying orders and trading
interest in the NMS Stock ATS, the hourly burden related to completing
Part II, Item 5 would likely vary.\1163\ We have modified the proposed
disclosures to require a summary of the terms and conditions for use
and a cross-reference to the applicable Item number(s) in Part III of
adopted Form ATS-N where the use of the product or service is
explained. Only if there is no applicable Item in Part III would the
NMS Stock ATS be required to include a narrative of the use of the
product or service with the ATS under Part II, Item 5. While we have
revised the wording of the adopted disclosure request to reduce the
potential of NMS Stock ATSs unnecessarily disclosing commercially
sensitive information,\1164\ we do not believe that the estimated
burden of the proposed disclosure request should change. It was not our
intent to require NMS Stock ATSs to provide granular details that might
constitute commercially sensitive information in response to the
proposed disclosure requests. We therefore, estimate that, on average
and consistent with the estimate in the Proposal, preparing Part II,
Item 5 for a Form ATS-N would add 3 hour to the current baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS. This results in an
aggregate initial burden of 123 hours above the current baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 5 of Form ATS-N.\1165\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1162\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81096.
\1163\ See id.
\1164\ See supra Section V.C.4.
\1165\ (Compliance Manager at 2 hours + Senior Marketing Manager
at 1 hour) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 123 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Item 6 of adopted Form ATS-N contains
disclosure requests about the activities of service providers. Part II,
Item 6(a) is similar to the request contained in Part III, Item 7 of
proposed Form ATS-N, and Part II, Items 6(b) and (c) of adopted Form
ATS-N are similar to the requests in Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form
ATS-N. In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part
III, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N would add 4 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1166\
Part II, Item 6(a) of adopted Form ATS-N asks for information about
shared employees like proposed Part III, Item 7, but does not require
the NMS Stock ATS to disclose the identity and titles of such
employees, as was proposed. In addition, Part II, Item 6(a) requires a
summary of such information, which results in a reduced filing burden
relative to that which was proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1166\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81097.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N would have required an NMS
Stock ATS to disclose information about whether any operation, service,
or function of the NMS Stock ATS is
[[Page 38873]]
performed by any person(s) other than the broker-dealer operator of the
NMS Stock ATS. We had estimated that, on average, preparing Part III,
Item 8 for proposed Form ATS-N would add 3 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1167\
Like Part II, Item 6(a), Part II, Item 6(b) of adopted Form ATS-N only
requires a summary of the role and responsibilities of service
providers to the ATS. As with Part II, Item 6(a) of adopted Form ATS-N,
we estimate that only requiring a summary narrative for the service
provider request in adopted Form ATS-N would result in a reduced filing
burden relative to that which was proposed. Additionally, Item 6(c)
requires the NMS Stock ATS to identify service providers and their
affiliates that use the services of the ATS and list the services used;
Part III, Item 8(c) of proposed Form ATS-N would have required the NMS
Stock ATS to describe the circumstances and means by which service
providers enter orders or trading interest on the ATS. Due to the
reduced filing burden of adopted Part II, Items 6(a)-(c) relative that
which was proposed, we estimate that, on average, Part II, Items 6(a)-
(c) of adopted Form ATS-N would add 4.5 hours to the current baseline
for an initial operating report on Form ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1167\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, as with Part II, Items 1, 2, and 3 of adopted Form
ATS-N, we have incorporated aspects of Part III, Item 9 of proposed
Form ATS-N regarding differentiated and preferential treatment into
Part II, Item 6(d) of adopted Form ATS-N.\1168\ We estimate that Item
3(c) would add approximately .5 hours out of the proposed 2-hour burden
estimate for Part III, Item 9 to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS because the NMS Stock ATS would be
required to provide a narrative in Item 6(d) in additional to
narratives about the manner of operations under Part III of adopted
Form ATS-N. Accordingly, we estimate that on average, Part II, Item 6
of adopted Form ATS-N will add approximately 5 hours to the burden for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This results in an
aggregate initial burden of 205 hours above the current baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part II, Item 6 of Form ATS-N.\1169\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1168\ Other requirements of Part III, Item 5 of proposed Form
ATS-N are incorporated in adopted Part II, Item 1.
\1169\ (Attorney at 3 hours + Compliance Manager at 2 hours) x
41 NMS Stock ATSs = 205.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As explained above, Part II, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N contains
disclosure requests about the NMS Stock ATS's protection of
confidential subscriber trading information. Part II, Item 7 of adopted
Form ATS-N is similar to Part III, Item 10 of proposed Form ATS-N,
which would have required certain disclosures related to the NMS Stock
ATS's written safeguards and written procedures to protect the
confidential trading information of subscribers pursuant to Rule
301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS.\1170\ As previously discussed, NMS Stock
ATSs will now be required to have and maintain written policies and
procedures under Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS.\1171\ Part II, Item
7(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requires a description of these policies and
procedures, and the request in Item 7(a) will contain the information
requested in Part III, Items 10(c) and (d) of proposed Form ATS-N. Part
II, Item 7(b)-(c) of adopted Form ATS-N requests the same information
as Part III, Item 10(a) of proposed Form ATS-N. Lastly, Part II, Item
7(d) is similar to Part III, Item 10(b) of proposed Form ATS-N, but the
adopted request only requires a summary of roles and responsibilities,
rather than identification of the positions or titles of all persons
that have access to confidential trading information and a description
of the circumstances of such access as was proposed. We continue to
believe that NMS Stock ATSs should, pursuant to their existing
obligations under Rule 301(b)(10), be aware of all persons that can
access the confidential trading information of subscribers, the
circumstances under which such persons can access that information, and
what information they can access. As such, we believe that this change
to proposed Part II, Item 10(b) of adopted Form ATS-N does not increase
the proposed burden estimate. Rather, because the adopted request in
Part II, Item 7(d) reduces the level of detail from that which was
proposed and the other requests from proposed Part III, Item 10 are
unchanged in adopted Form ATS-N, we estimate that the burden for Part
II, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N is less than that which was proposed
by 0.5 hours. In the Proposal, we estimated that Part III, Item 10
would add 2 hours to the baseline for an NMS Stock ATS to complete this
item.\1172\ Accordingly, we estimate that, on average, preparing Part
II, Item 7 for a Form ATS-N would add 1.5 hours above the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This
would result in an aggregate initial burden of 61.5 hours above the
current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Item 7 of Part II
of Form ATS-N.\1173\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1170\ Specifically, an NMS Stock ATS would be required to: (1)
Describe the means by which a subscriber may consent or withdraw
consent to the disclosure of confidential trading information to any
persons (including the broker-dealer operator and any of its
affiliates); (2) identify the positions or titles of any persons
that have access to confidential trading information, describe the
confidential trading information to which the persons have access,
and describe the circumstances under which the persons can access
confidential trading information; (3) describe the written standards
controlling employees of the NMS Stock ATS that trade for employees'
accounts; and (4) describe the written oversight procedures to
ensure that the safeguards and procedures are implemented and
followed.
\1171\ See supra Section VI.
\1172\ See Proposal, supra note 1 at 81098.
\1173\ (Attorney at 1.0 hour + Compliance Manager at 0.5 hour) x
41 NMS Stock ATSs = 61.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(c) Part III
Part III, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N is based on Part IV, Item
1(c) of proposed Form ATS-N, although certain information from the
proposed item is not required to be disclosed in this item.
Specifically, the requirement to describe any criteria for
distinguishing among types of subscribers, classes of subscribers, or
other persons is being removed from the item because such information
is covered under Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N on
``Segmentation; Notice.'' \1174\ Moreover, the required information on
whether the NMS Stock ATS accepts non-broker-dealers as subscribers to
the ATS is being converted to a ``yes'' or ``no'' question and placed
in Part III, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1174\ See supra Section V.D.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N is, in large part, already
required under current Form ATS.\1175\ We estimated all of Part IV,
Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N, which includes subparts (a)-(e), would
add 6 hours to the to the current baseline for an initial operation
report on current Form ATS.\1176\ We now estimate that Part III, Item 1
as adopted would add 0.5 hours of burden to the current baseline. The
current requirement of Exhibit A on Form ATS to describe the classes of
subscribers on the ATS should oftentimes have substantial overlap with
the requirement in Part III, Item 1 to select the types of subscribers
from a list of checkboxes and identify any other types of subscribers.
The additional 0.5 hours of burden is meant to account for identifying
and listing any types of
[[Page 38874]]
subscribers that are not already captured by the classes of subscribers
identified in Exhibit A of Form ATS. We therefore estimate that, on
average, preparing Part III, Item 1 for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5
hours to the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of
20.5 hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to
complete Part III, Item 1 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1177\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1175\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81098-81099.
\1176\ The requirements related to subparts (a)-(e) of Item 1 of
proposed Form ATS-N have been broken out into separate questions
with the exception of subpart (b) which is being eliminated. We did
not provide estimates for each individual subpart of Part IV, Item 1
of proposed Form ATS-N.
\1177\ Attorney at 0.5 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 20.5 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-N requires similar information
to that required under Part IV, Items 1(a) and 1(b) of proposed Form
ATS-N.\1178\ In the Proposal, we estimated all of Part IV, Item 1 of
proposed Form ATS-N, which includes subparts (a)-(e), would add 6 hours
to the to the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS.\1179\ However, a number of provisions of Part IV,
Item 1 of proposed Form ATS-N either have been eliminated or moved to
other Items in the adopted Form. Depending on the complexity of the NMS
Stock ATS, the disclosure burden related to Part III, Item 2 of Form
ATS-N would likely vary. For example, an NMS Stock ATS with two sets of
conditions for different persons to satisfy before accessing the ATS
services would likely have less of a burden than an NMS Stock ATS with
five groups of persons that have to satisfy varying conditions.
Accordingly, we estimate that, on average, preparing Part III, Item 2
for a Form ATS-N would add 1.0 hour to the current baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS. This would result in an
aggregate initial burden of 41 hours above the current baseline for all
NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-
N.\1180\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1178\ Adopted Part III, Item 2 removed some of the provisions
in Part IV, Items 1(a) and 1(b) of proposed Form ATS-N and formatted
the item to ''yes'' or ``no'' questions.
\1179\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81098-81099.
\1180\ (Attorney at 0.7 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.3 hours)
x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-N requires similar information
to that required under Part IV, Item 1(e) of proposed Form ATS-N, with
certain clarifications to reduce potential confusion with the
application of Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS. First, Item 3(a) as
adopted asks for a summary description of the conditions for excluding,
in whole or in part, a subscriber from the ATS's services rather than
the more detailed proposed requirement that the NMS Stock ATS describe
the circumstances by which access for a subscriber or other person may
be limited or denied. Second, we are no longer requiring that the NMS
Stock ATS describe its procedures or standards to determine whether to
exclude. Third, we are changing the language in the request to
correspond closely with the definition of ATS in Regulation ATS.\1181\
In the Proposal, we estimated all of Part IV, Item 1 of proposed Form
ATS-N, which includes subparts (a)-(e), would add 6 hours to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS.\1182\ Although ATSs are not required to establish conditions for
excluding subscribers from using the ATS, as stated in the
Proposal,\1183\ in our experience, ATSs often have rules governing
subscribers' participation on the ATS, and if a subscriber fails to
comply with these rules, the ATS may limit or deny access to the NMS
Stock ATS. The burden associated with the request would likely vary
depending on the complexity of the ATS, whether it has conditions for
excluding subscribers, and whether those conditions differ among
subscribers. For some NMS Stock ATSs, the information required by Part
III, Item 3 would require gathering information on its practices for
excluding subscribers that previously may have been ad hoc decisions in
order to prove the summary of conditions for excluding subscribers
required by the Item. Accordingly, we estimate that, on average,
preparing Part III, Item 3 for a Form ATS-N would add 1 hour to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.
This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 41 hours above the
current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 3 of
adopted Form ATS-N.\1184\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1181\ See 17 CFR 242.300(a).
\1182\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81098-81099.
\1183\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81063.
\1184\ (Attorney at 0.7 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.3 hours)
x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N is substantially similar to
Part IV, Item 2 of proposed Form ATS-N, except that we are modifying
the example provided in this item by replacing references in the
Proposal to hours when ``pre-opening or after-hours trading occurs''
(emphasis added) with ``hours of operation outside of regular trading
hours'' and the format of the item is being changed to a ``yes'' or
``no'' question. In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average,
preparing Part IV, Item 2 for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5 hours to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS,
and we believe this estimate is still accurate for the adopted
Item.\1185\ The NMS Stock ATS is aware of the hours during which it
operates, including any hours of operation outside of regular trading
hours. Based on the experience of the Commission and its staff
reviewing Form ATS and ATS-R filings, we believe that most ATSs that
currently trade NMS stocks do not provide for after-hours or pre-
opening trading of NMS stock. For NMS Stock ATSs for which the times
when orders or trading interest may be sent to the NMS Stock ATS are
not the same for all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator, the
disclosure burden related to Part IV, Item 2 would likely be greater.
Considering the foregoing, we continue to believe that, on average,
preparing Part III, Item 4 for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5 hours to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.
This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 20.5 hours above
the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item
4 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1186\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1185\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81099.
\1186\ Compliance Manager at 0.5 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
20.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 5 of adopted Form ATS-N is based on Part IV, Item
4(a) of proposed Form ATS-N, although we have made modifications to the
proposed item, and also are incorporating Part III, Item 6 proposed
Form ATS-N. First, we are separating the requests regarding direct and
indirect means of entry for orders and trading interest into the NMS
Stock ATS so that information regarding direct means of entry will be
disclosed in Part III, Item 5(a) of adopted Form ATS-N and information
about other means of entry for orders and trading interest will be
disclosed in adopted Part III, Item 5(c) of adopted Form ATS-N. Also,
the information required by Part III, Item 5(a) on the direct means of
order entry is being revised from the Proposal to be in a ``yes'' or
``no'' format. We are also moving and revising Part III, Item 6 of
proposed Form ATS-N to adopted Part III, Item 5(c) regarding the means
available for entering orders other than entering orders
directly.\1187\ Part III, Item 5(c) of adopted Form ATS-N would not
require a broker-dealer operator to disclose its SOR's routing table or
other information about how the SOR may route orders. Part III, Item
5(b) of adopted Form ATS-N no longer contains the proposed language
``[d]escribe the interaction and coordination,'' which was contained in
[[Page 38875]]
Part III, Item 6(b) of proposed Form ATS-N. Rather, Part III, Item 5(b)
requires the NMS Stock ATS to ``identify and explain'' sources of order
flow other than those used for direct entry into the ATS. Furthermore,
the adopted disclosure requirements of Part III, Item 5(c) require the
NMS Stock ATS to ``list and provide a summary description of the terms
and conditions for entering orders or trading interest into the ATS''
through these sources.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1187\ See supra Section V.D.5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV,
Item 4, which includes both subparts (a) (related to order entry) and
(b) (related to co-location) would add 5 hours to the current baseline
for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1188\ While we did
not provide estimates for each individual subpart, each subpart of Part
IV, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N accounted for half of the 5 hour
estimate (i.e., 2.5 hours each for subparts (a) and (b)). Furthermore,
we estimated that, on average, preparing Part III, Item 6 of proposed
Form ATS-N would add 10 hours to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS. We estimate that the burden hours
for adopted Part III, Item 5 that correspond to the information
required in Part IV, Item 4(a) of proposed Form ATS-N would be
substantially similar (i.e., 2.5 hours). Therefore, we estimate Part
III, Item 4 would add 2.5 hours to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS.\1189\ The disclosure requirements
that were proposed in Part III, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N have been
revised and moved to this Item 5(c) as adopted. We expect that the
associated burden would be reduced as we are allowing the NMS Stock ATS
to ``list and provide a summary description of the terms and conditions
for entering orders or trading interest into the ATS,'' as opposed to
the ``interaction and coordination'' language used in the Proposal.
Therefore, we estimate this requirement would add 8.0 hours to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS
\1190\ Thus, in total, we estimate that, on average, preparing Part
III, Item 5 for a Form ATS-N would add 10.5 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This
would result in an aggregate initial burden of 430.5 hours above the
current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 5 of
adopted Form ATS-N.\1191\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1188\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81101-02.
\1189\ (Attorney at 0.5 hours + Compliance Manager at 1 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 1 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 102.5
burden hours.
\1190\ (Attorney at 3 hours + Compliance Manager at 2 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 3 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 328 burden
hours.
\1191\ (Attorney at 3.5 hours + Compliance Manager at 3 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 4 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 430.5
burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have made various revisions to the proposed item in adopted Part
III, Item 6 of adopted Form ATS-N. Part III, Item 6(a) is limiting the
proposed request by allowing for a ``summary'' of the terms and
conditions for co-location and related services. We are also converting
the information required by Part IV, Item 4(b) of proposed Form ATS-N
into a series of ``yes'' or ``no'' questions, with accompanying
explanations as applicable, in Part III, Item 6 of adopted Form ATS-N.
\1192\ We are also separating the requests for disclosure into separate
sub-parts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1192\ See supra note 839.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the Proposal, the we estimated that, on average, preparing Part
IV, Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N, which included subparts (a)
(connectivity and order entry) and (b) (co-location), would add 5 hours
to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS.\1193\ We intended that each subpart of Part IV, Item 4 accounted
for half of the 5 hour estimate (i.e., 2.5 hours each for subparts (a)
and (b)). We have reduced the burden compared to the proposed item by
allowing for a summary of the terms and conditions related to co-
location and related services in Part III, Item 6(a). On the other
hand, the information required in Part III, Item 6(e) of Form ATS-N was
previously proposed under a different item (Part IV, Item 7 of proposed
Form ATS-N), and therefore, the burden related to responding to this
item is now being added to Item 6(e) as adopted. Therefore, as we have
revised Part III, Item 6 to both reduce the associated burden (by
allowing for a summary) and increase the associated burden (by moving
information required in proposed Part IV, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-
N), we believe that the burden hours for Part III, Item 6 will remain
the same as the proposed estimate for Part IV, Item 4(b), 2.5 hours
above the current baseline for an initial operation report. This would
result in the aggregate initial burden of 95 hours above the current
baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 6 of adopted
Form ATS-N.\1194\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1193\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81101-02. The requirements
related to subparts (a) and (b) of Item 4 of proposed Form ATS-N
have been broken out into separate items in the adopted form. Item
4(a) is being adopted as Part III, Item 5, as modified. See supra
notes 1188- 1191 and accompanying text.
\1194\ (Attorney at 1 hour + Compliance Manager at 1 hour +
Senior Systems Analyst at .5) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 102.5 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The disclosure requirements in Part III, Item 7 of adopted Form
ATS-N are substantially the same as those set forth in Part IV, Item
3(a) and(b) of proposed Form ATS-N. ATSs that currently trade NMS
stocks vary in the depth of their disclosures related to order types.
We estimated in the Proposal that, on average, preparing Part IV, Item
3 of proposed Form ATS-N, which also included Items 3(c) and 3(d) that
have been moved to other items in the adopted form,\1195\ would add 6
hours to the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS.\1196\ Because the requirements in Part III, Item 7 of
adopted Form ATS-N are substantially the same as the corresponding
requirements set forth in subparts (a) and (b) of Part IV, Item 3 of
proposed Form ATS-N, we estimate that the burden hours will also be
substantially similar. While we did not provide estimates for each
individual subpart of Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N, subparts
(a) and (b) of Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N, accounted for 4
hours (of the 6 burden hours estimated for Part IV, Item 3).
Consequently, we estimate that adopted Part III, Item 7 will also add 4
hours above the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS, resulting in the aggregate initial burden of 164
hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete
Part III, Item 7 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1197\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1195\ Item 3(c) of proposed Form ATS-N is being adopted with
modifications as Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N. Item 3(d) is being
adopted with modifications as Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N.
\1196\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81099.
\1197\ (Attorney at 1.0 hours + Compliance Manager at 2 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 1) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 164 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N is based on Part IV, Item
3(c) of proposed Form ATS-N. In adopted Form ATS-N, Part III, Item 8,
we separated the requests proposed under Item 3(c) into six sub-parts.
However, the requirements have not changed significantly.\1198\
Additionally, we are adding to Part III, Item 8(a) of adopted Form ATS-
N a request for the NMS Stock ATS to provide information about any
maximum order or trading interest size requirements. Because the
requirements in Part III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N are
substantially the same as the corresponding
[[Page 38876]]
requirements set forth in Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N, we
estimate that the burden hours in adopted Part III, Item 8 that
correspond to the information required in proposed Part IV, Item 3
would be substantially similar. While we did not provide estimates for
each individual subpart of Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N,
subpart (c) of Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N, would have
accounted for 1 hour (of the 6 burden hours estimated for Part IV, Item
3). Consequently, we estimate that the burden hours in adopted Part
III, Item 8 would add 1 hour to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS, resulting in the aggregate
initial burden of 41 hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock
ATSs to complete Part III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1199\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1198\ We are relocating Part IV, Item 3(c) of proposed Form
ATS-N to Part III, Item 8 of adopted Form ATS-N and adopting a
``yes'' or ``no'' format. We are requiring that the NMS Stock ATS
identify and explain any differences in the treatment of subscribers
and the broker-dealer operator, as applicable, in separate sub-items
8(b), 8(d), and 8(f), respectively, which is the same as required in
Part IV, Item 3(c) of the Proposal.
\1199\ (Attorney at .25 hours + Compliance Manager at .25 hours
+ Senior Systems Analyst at .5) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N is based on Part IV, Item
3(d) of proposed Form ATS-N. We separated Part IV, Item 3(d) of
proposed Form ATS-N into two sub-parts in adopted Part III, Item 9.
However, the requirements have not changed substantially. We are adding
``price or size minimums'' as examples of information that could be
contained in the messages and ``order management system, smart order
router and FIX'' to illustrate the types of mechanisms that could
transmit messages, such as IOIs and conditional orders. Because the
requirements in Part III, Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N are
substantially the same as the corresponding requirements set forth in
Part IV, Item 3(d) of proposed Form ATS-N, we estimate that the burden
hours in adopted Part III, Item 9 that correspond to the information
required in Part IV, Item 3(d) of proposed Form ATS-N are substantially
similar. While we did not provide estimates for each individual subpart
of Part IV, Item 3 of proposed Form ATS-N, subpart (d) would have
accounted for 1 hour (of the 6 burden hours estimated for Part IV, Item
3). Accordingly, we estimate that the burden hours in adopted Part III,
Item 9 would add 1 hour to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS, resulting in the aggregate
initial burden of 41 hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock
ATSs to complete Part III, Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1200\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1200\ (Attorney at .25 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.25 hours
+ Senior Systems Analyst at 0.5) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41 burden
hours. As noted above, we estimate the burden for Part III, Item 7
of adopted Form ATS-N to be 4 hours above the baseline and the
burden for Part III, Item 8 to be 1 hour above the baseline.
Accordingly, we estimate that the total burden hours above the
baseline for Part III, Items 7, 8, and 9 of adopted Form ATS-N is 6
hours, which is the same as that which was proposed for Part IV,
Item 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 10 of adopted Form ATS-N corresponds with Part IV,
Item 9(a) of proposed Form ATS-N. We separated what was proposed in
Part IV, Item 9(a) into five sub-parts in adopted Part III, Item 10. We
are adding to Part III, Item 10(a) of adopted Form ATS-N requirements
regarding ``when'' and how such orders and trading interest are
``priced [and] prioritized'' and ``any order types allowed'' during the
opening and reopening processes.\1201\ Additionally, we are formatting
the requests that parallel the information requested in the Proposal
into three sub-parts (adopted Items 10(a), 10(c) and 10(e)) and adding
a ``yes'' or ``no'' question to Item 10(e) to improve readability and
facilitate comparisons of the information for market participants.
Also, we are adding a new requirement to identify and explain any
differences in the treatment of subscribers and the broker-dealer
operator in the opening and reopening processes, if applicable, in the
form of ``yes'' or ``no'' questions in adopted Part III, Items 10(b)
and 10(d). We estimate that the overall burden hours for adopted Part
III, Item 10 will be slightly more than Part IV, Item 9(a) because
while the adopted subparts that parallel the information requested in
the proposed item (adopted Items 10(a), 10(c) and 10(e)) result in a
similar burden, we expect that the new subparts (adopted Items 10(b)
and 10(d)) will impose an additional burden on some NMS Stock ATSs that
treat subscribers and the broker-dealer operator differently. While we
did not provide an estimate for each individual subpart of Part IV,
Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N, subpart (a) would have accounted for 1
hour (of the 3 burden hours estimated for Part IV, Item 9).\1202\
Consequently, we estimate that the burden hours in adopted Part III,
Item 10 would add 1.25 hours to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS, resulting in the aggregate
initial burden of 51.25 hours above the current baseline for all NMS
Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 9 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1203\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1201\ The words in quotes in this sentence represent new text
from that proposed in Item 9(a), adopted as Item 10(a). The
requirement to explain when orders and trading interest are priced,
prioritized, matched and executed when the NMS Stock ATS opens or
re-opens for trading is not expected to change significantly the
burden on the ATS given that Form ATS-N requires disclosure of the
hours of operations under Part III, Item 4 of adopted Form ATS-N.
\1202\ Part IV, Item 9(b) of proposed Form ATS-N is being
adopted with modifications as Item 17 of adopted Form ATS-N. Part
IV, Item 9(c) of proposed Form ATS-N is being adopted with
modifications as Item 18 of adopted Form ATS-N. We are estimating
1.25 burden hours for Item 17 and 1.25 burden hours for Item 18 of
adopted Form ATS-N.
\1203\ (Attorney at .5 hours + Senior Systems Analyst at .75) x
41 NMS Stock ATSs = 51.25 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N is substantively similar to
Part IV, Item 7 of proposed Form ATS-N, but we are making various
revisions to the Item. We are limiting the request to require NMS Stock
ATSs to provide a summary of the structure of the NMS Stock ATS
marketplace instead of describing the means or facilities used by the
NMS Stock ATS to bring together the orders of multiple buyers and
sellers. In Part III, Item 11(c) of adopted Form ATS-N, we are
combining the requests in the Proposal in Part IV, Items 7(b) (``Order
Interaction Rules'') and 7(c) (``Other Trading Procedures''). Part IV,
Items 7(b) and 7(c) of proposed Form ATS-N were intended to solicit
information about the ATS's established non-discretionary methods that
dictate the terms of trading among the multiple buyers and sellers
entering orders and trading interest. In addition to a trading
facility, non-discretionary methods include rules and procedures. We
are revising the language in adopted Item 11(c) to recognize this
overlap by requiring the NMS Stock ATS to ``explain the established,
non-discretionary rules and procedures of the NMS Stock ATS, including
order interaction rules,'' which requires the same information as the
proposed subparts. As another component of an NMS Stock ATS's non-
discretionary methods, we are moving the trading procedures description
required in proposed Item 7(c) into adopted Item 11(c) and including
the examples of the trading procedures of an NMS Stock ATS (e.g., price
protection mechanisms, shorts sales, locked-cross markets) in adopted
Item 11(c) as well. Finally, we are converting the prompts in Part IV,
Item 7(a), 7(b) and 7(c) of proposed Form ATS-N to identify and explain
any differences among subscribers and persons into ``yes'' or ``no''
questions in Items 11(b) and 11(d) of adopted Form ATS-N.
Consistent with the estimate in the Proposal, we estimate that, on
average, preparing Part III, Item 11 for a Form ATS-N will add 6 hours
to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS to provide a description of the NMS Stock ATS's trading services.
This will result in an aggregate initial burden of 246 hours
[[Page 38877]]
above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III,
Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1204\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1204\ Attorney at 1.0 + Compliance Manager at 2.0 + Senior
Systems Analyst at 3.0) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 246 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The requirements of Part III, Item 12 were proposed as Part IV,
Item 1(d) of proposed Form ATS-N. In the Proposal, we estimated that
the entire Part IV, Item 1 (which also would have addressed
eligibility, terms and conditions of use, types of subscribers, and
liquidity providers) \1205\ would add 6 hours to the current baseline
for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. The requirements
related to eligibility, terms and conditions of use, types of
subscribers, and liquidity providers have been broken out into separate
questions, and Part III, Item 12 of adopted Form ATS-N solely relates
to formal and informal arrangements with subscribers or the broker-
dealer operator to provide orders or trading interest to the NMS Stock
ATS. We believe that Part III, Item 12 of adopted Form ATS-N will add 1
hour to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current
Form ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 41 hours
above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III,
Item 12 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1206\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1205\ Proposed Part IV, Item 1(a) (``eligibility'') is being
adopted with modifications as Part III, Item 2 of adopted Form ATS-
N. Proposed Part IV, Item 1(b) (``terms and conditions'') is not
being adopted, except for the request to state whether contractual
agreements are written, which is being adopted with modifications as
Part III, Item 2(d) of adopted Form ATS-N. Proposed Part IV, Item
1(c) (``Types of Subscribers'') is being adopted with modifications
as Part III, Item 1 and Item 2(a) of adopted Form ATS-N. Proposed
Part IV, Item 1(e) (``Limitation and Denial of Services'') is being
adopted with modifications as Part III, Item 3 of adopted Form ATS-
N.
\1206\ (Attorney at 0.7 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.3 hours)
x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 41 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N corresponds with Part IV,
Item 5(a) and (b) of proposed Form ATS-N. The requirements of Part III,
Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N cover the requirements proposed under
Part IV, Items 5(a) and 5(b), although we have modified the proposed
requirements.\1207\ We are adding ``yes'' or ``no'' questions to Part
III, Item 13(a), 13(b), 13(d) and 13(e) of adopted Form ATS-N to
facilitate responses to the items and to facilitate market participants
finding the information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1207\ See supra Section V.D.13.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also modifying certain components of Part IV, Item 5 of
proposed Form ATS-N. First, we are adding the terms ``classifications,
tiers, or levels'' to adopted Part III, Item 13(a) through (e) in
addition to ``categories'' to describe the groupings that an NMS Stock
ATS may segment subscriber orders. Second, we are providing two
additional examples, order size and duration, of criteria for
segmentation of subscribers' orders and trading interest. Third, we are
providing additional specificity around what ``changing segmented
categories'' means by requiring NMS Stock ATSs to provide a discussion
around overriding a determination of segmented category. Fourth, we are
requiring a description of how segmentation affects order interaction
on Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N. Finally, we are requiring
under Part III, Item 13(d) of adopted Form ATS-N that the NMS Stock ATS
describe ``whether and how such designation can be contested.''
In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV,
Item 5 for a Form ATS-N would add 7 hours to the current baseline for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS to provide a detailed
description of how, if at all, the NMS Stock ATS segments order flow,
provides any notice to those trading on the NMS Stock ATS regarding
segmentation, and allows order preferencing. The proposed requirement
regarding order preferencing is broken out into a separate item, Part
III, Item 14 of adopted Form ATS-N, which is described below. We also
are adding a ``yes'' or ``no'' question in adopted Part III, Item 13(b)
regarding identifying orders by a customer of a broker-dealer as a
customer order. We believe the aforementioned minor modifications to
the proposed question will slightly increase the burden for the adopted
item. Therefore, we believe that Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-
N will add 6 hours to the current baseline for an initial operation
report on current Form ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial
burden of 205 hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs
to complete Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1208\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1208\ (Attorney at 2.0 hours + Compliance Manager at 2.25 hours
+ Senior Systems Analyst at 1.75 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 205
burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 14(a) is substantially similar to Part IV, Item 5(c)
of proposed Form ATS-N. However, we have added a requirement in Item
14(b), that if counter-party selection functionality is not the same
for all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator, that the NMS Stock
ATS identify and explain any differences. The burden associated with
this change is likely to vary among NMS Stock ATS depending on their
complexity and the extent to which they treat all subscribers and the
broker-dealer operator the same or differently. We estimated that, on
average, preparing all of Part IV, Item 5 (including subparts (a), (b),
and (c)) for a Form ATS-N would add 7 hours to the current baseline for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS to provide a detailed
description of how, if at all, the NMS Stock ATS segments order flow,
provides any notice to those trading on the NMS Stock ATS regarding
segmentation, and allows counter-party selection.\1209\ We understand
that most, but not all, ATSs that currently trade NMS stocks allow
subscribers to enter some type of counter-party selection criteria.
These ATSs vary in the depth of their description as to how they allow
counter-party selection. We believe that Part III, Item 14 of adopted
Form ATS-N, which solely relates to counter-party selection, will add 2
hours to the current baseline for an initial Form ATS. This will result
in an aggregate initial burden of 82 hours above the current baseline
for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 14 of adopted Form
ATS-N.\1210\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1209\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81100. Proposed Part IV,
Items 5(a) and 5(b) are being adopted with modifications as Part
III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N. We are estimating 5 burden hours
for Part III, Item 13 of adopted Form ATS-N.
\1210\ (Attorney at 0.5 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.75 hours
+ Senior Systems Analyst at 0.75 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 82
burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 15 is modified from a similar requirement of Part
IV, Item 6 of proposed Form ATS-N, which asked about order display and
the subscribers and persons to which orders and trading interest are
displayed or otherwise made known. We are changing the language in this
item from ``order information or other trading interest'' to
``subscriber orders and trading interest.'' We are also revising the
proposed requests to make clear that it only applies to the display of
the NMS Stock ATS's subscriber orders and trading interest as opposed
to non-ATS orders and trading interest handled or otherwise displayed
to the broker-dealer operator. Accordingly, the disclosure of non-ATS
orders by affiliates of the NMS Stock ATS and others external to the
ATS of non-ATS orders would not have to be disclosed. However, if for
example, an affiliate of the NMS Stock ATS is displaying an order that
is simultaneously bound for or resting in the NMS Stock ATS, then Item
15 would apply. In addition, we have revised the request so that Part
III, Item 15(b) of adopted Form ATS-N makes clear that the request does
not
[[Page 38878]]
require the NMS Stock ATS to identify employees of the ATS who are
operating the system. Finally, we are adding a ``yes'' or ``no''
questions in Part III, Item 15(a) that asks if the NMS Stock ATS is an
ECN as defined in Rule 600(a)(23) of Regulation NMS.
Depending on the variety of trading interest that shares some
trading information outside of the NMS Stock ATS and the complexity of
such information sharing, the disclosure burden in responding to Part
III, Item 15 would likely vary among NMS Stock ATSs. In the Proposal,
we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV, Item 6 of proposed
Form ATS-N would add 5 hours to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS, depending on such factors as
described above. Although we are revising the item text to provide more
specificity so NMS Stock ATSs better understand the requirements and
scope of the request and provide sufficient information to market
participants in Part III, Item 15 of adopted Form ATS-N, we are also
simplifying responses to the item by no longer requiring NMS Stock ATSs
to identify the subscriber or person to whom order and trading interest
is displayed and instead requiring disclosure of the types of market
participants that receive the information. Thus, we believe these
changes would, in total, provide no additional burden from proposed
Form ATS-N. We therefore believe that preparing Part III, Item 15 of
adopted Form ATS-N will add 5 hours to the current baseline for an
initial Form ATS. This will result in an aggregate initial burden of
205 hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete
Part III, Item 15 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1211\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1211\ (Attorney at 1 hour + Compliance Manager at 2 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 2 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 205 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 16(a) relates to disclosures surrounding orders and
trading interest in the NMS Stock ATS being routed to a destination
outside the ATS. We understand, based on disclosures in Form ATS
submissions, that some ATSs that currently trade NMS stocks do not
route orders out of the ATS. Consequently, the disclosure burden
related to Part III, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N will likely vary
among NMS Stock ATSs depending on whether they route orders at all. In
the Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV, Item 10
for proposed Form ATS-N would add 6 hours to the current baseline for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS, depending on such
factors as described above. We, however, are substantially simplifying
the item as adopted by converting subpart (a) into a ``yes'' or ``no''
question that no longer requires a description of the circumstances
under which orders are routed, and also removes the requirement to
describe the means by which routing is performed and the requirement to
describe any differences among subscribers and persons. We therefore
estimate that Part III, Item 16 of adopted Form ATS-N will add 2 hours
to the current baseline for an initial operation report, depending on
the extent to which the ATS routes orders and trading interest. This
will result in an aggregate initial burden of 82 hours above the
current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 16
of adopted Form ATS-N.\1212\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1212\ (Attorney at 0.5 hours + Compliance Manager at 0.5 hours
+ Senior Systems Analyst at 1 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 82 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The requirements of Part III, Item 17(a) are similar to those
proposed in Part IV, Item 9(b) of the proposed Form ATS-N.\1213\ We
estimated that, on average, preparing all of Part IV, Item 9, including
subparts (a)-(c), for proposed Form ATS-N would have added 3 hours to
the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS to describe its opening, reopening, or closing processes, and
after-hours trading procedures.\1214\ While we did not provide an
estimate for each individual subpart of Part IV, Item 9 of proposed
Form ATS-N, subpart (b) would have accounted for 1 hour (of the 3
burden hours estimated for Part IV, Item 9). As we stated in the
Proposal, current Form ATS, Exhibit F requires an ATS to describe its
closing processes. Therefore, we continue to believe that Part III,
Item 17 of adopted Form ATS-N will not impose a significant additional
requirement. We are newly requiring, as Part III, Item 17(b) of adopted
Form ATS-N, that if the treatment of orders and trading interest during
the close is not the same for all subscribers and the broker-dealer
operator, the NMS Stock ATS identify and explain such differences. The
burden associated with this change is likely to vary among NMS Stock
ATS depending on their complexity and the extent to which they treat
all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator the same or differently.
Therefore, we believe that it would add 1.25 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on Form ATS-N. This would
result in an aggregate initial burden of 51.25 hours above the current
baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 17 of
adopted Form ATS-N.\1215\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1213\ Although we are revising the item text to provide more
specificity so NMS Stock ATSs better understand the requirements and
scope of the request and provide sufficient information to market
participants, we believe these revisions should not change the
burden of the required disclosure.
\1214\ Part IV, Items 9(a) and 9(c) of proposed Form ATS-N are
being adopted with modifications as Part III, Items 10 and 18 of
adopted Form ATS-N, respectively. We are estimating 1.25 burden
hours for Item 10 and 1.25 burden hours for Item 18 of adopted Form
ATS-N.
\1215\ (Compliance Manager at .75 hours + Senior Systems Analyst
at 0.50 hour) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 51.25 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subparts (a) and (b) of Part III, Item 18 of adopted Form ATS-N are
substantially similar to Part IV, Item 9(c) of proposed Form ATS-N. We
estimated that, on average, preparing all of Part IV, Item 9 for a
proposed Form ATS-N would add 3 hours to the current baseline for an
initial operation report on current Form ATS to describe its opening,
reopening, or closing processes, and after-hours trading
procedures.\1216\ While we did not provide an estimate for each
individual subpart of Part IV, Item 9 of proposed Form ATS-N, subpart
(c) would have accounted for 1 hour (of the 3 burden hours estimated
for Part IV, Item 9). In the Proposal, we stated that Exhibit F of
current Form ATS requires an ATS to describe after-hours trading
procedures. These procedures may vary widely across different ATSs.
Therefore, we continue to estimate that the additional requirements
will not impose a significant additional burden above the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. Unlike
Part IV, Item 9(c) of proposed Form ATS-N, an ATS that has trading
outside of regular hours that follows the same procedures as trading
within regular trading hours would need to check the boxes to indicate
it conducts trading outside of its regular trading hours and to
indicate that its trading procedures do not differ between regular and
outside of regular trading hours; it would not need to describe any
after-hours trading procedures. We, however, also added the requirement
that the NMS Stock ATS describe, as applicable, the treatment of orders
and trading interest outside of regular trading hours if it is not the
same for all subscribers and broker-dealer operator as Item 18(c) of
adopted Form ATS-N. In light of these changes, we believe that Part
III, Item 18 of adopted Form ATS-N would add 1.25 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on Form ATS-N. This would
result in an
[[Page 38879]]
aggregate initial burden of 51.25 hours above the current baseline for
all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 18 of adopted Form ATS-
N.\1217\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1216\ Part IV, Items 9(a) and 9(b) of proposed Form ATS-N are
being adopted with modifications as Part III, Items 10 and 17 of
adopted Form ATS-N, respectively. We are estimating 1.25 burden
hours for Item 10 and 1.25 burden hours for Item 17 of adopted Form
ATS-N.
\1217\ (Compliance Manager at .75 hours + Senior Systems Analyst
at 0.50 hour) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 51.25 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 19 of adopted Form ATS-N is similar to Part IV, Item
12 of proposed Form ATS-N. In the Proposal, we estimated that, on
average, preparing Part IV, Item 12 for a Form ATS-N would add 5 hours
to the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS to describe the NMS Stock ATS's fee structure and any differences
among subscribers relating to fees, rebates, or other charges. As
discussed in the Proposal,\1218\ current Form ATS does not require an
ATS to disclose and explain its fee structure, and few, if any, do so
in their current Form ATS filings. We recognize that, like national
securities exchanges, NMS Stock ATSs may adopt a variety of fee
structures that may include rebates, incentives for subscribers to
bring liquidity to the NMS Stock ATS, more traditional transaction-
based fee structures, and other fees such as a monthly subscriber
access fee. Depending on the complexity and variety of an NMS Stock
ATS's fee structure and the extent to which these fees are not the same
for all subscribers, the disclosure burden related to Part III, Item 19
of adopted Form ATS-N will likely vary.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1218\ See id. at 81103.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, we are requiring additional specificity related to the
description of fees of the NMS Stock ATS that are based on or bundled
with the use of non-ATS services or products offered by the broker-
dealer operator or its affiliates. These were not previously explicitly
specified by Part IV, Item 12 of proposed Form ATS-N, and the adopted
item will likely require additional burden hours for NMS Stock ATSs
that are operated by multi-service broker-dealers that bundle their ATS
fees with other non-ATS services or products. In contrast, we are
narrowing the request for NMS Stock ATSs to describe any differences in
fees or rebates charged to different ``subscribers,'' and instead
asking for NMS Stock ATSs to disclose any differentiation between fees
and/or rebates charged among ``types'' of subscribers, which should
reduce the burden of responding as differences among individual
subscribers need not be explained. Accordingly, we estimate that, on
average, preparing Part III, Item 19 of Form ATS-N would add 6 hours to
the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS. This will result in an aggregate initial burden of 246 hours above
the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item
19 of Form ATS-N.\1219\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1219\ (Attorney at 2 hour + Compliance Manager at 3 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 1 hour) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 246 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 20 of adopted Form ATS-N is substantially similar to
Part IV, Item 8 of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications. We
are renaming the item ``Suspension of Trading,'' converting the prompt
in Part IV, Item 8(a) of proposed Form ATS-N to identify and explain
any differences among subscribers and persons into a ``yes'' or ``no''
question in Part III, Item 20(b) of adopted Form ATS-N, revising the
language to refer to procedures for stopping trading, and clarifying
that suspensions of trading in an NMS stock are responsive. In the
Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV, Item 8 for
a Form ATS-N would add 2.5 hours to the current baseline for an initial
operation report on current Form ATS to provide a detailed description
of the NMS Stock ATS's procedures for system disruptions, malfunctions,
or other suspensions.
We believe that NMS Stock ATSs should be able to provide the
disclosures in Part III, Item 20 of adopted Form ATS-N as they should
already be aware of how the ATS operates, handles system disruptions,
malfunctions or other suspensions based on the information required in
Exhibits G and F of current Form ATS. We recognize, however, that Part
III, Item 20 is significantly more specific and detailed in its
disclosure requirements than current Form ATS.
Accordingly, we estimate that respondents would incur an additional
burden above the current baseline when preparing the disclosures
required under Part III, Item 20 of Form ATS-N, consistent with the
estimated burden for proposed Item IV, Part 8. We estimate that, on
average, preparing Part III, Item 20 for a Form ATS-N would add 2.5
hours to the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS to provide a detailed description of the NMS Stock
ATS's procedures for suspending or stopping trading on the NMS Stock
ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 102.5 hours
above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III,
Item 20 of proposed Form ATS-N.\1220\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1220\ (Attorney at 1 hour + Compliance Manager at .5 hours +
Senior Systems Analyst at 1 hour) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 102.5 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 21 is substantially the same as Part IV, Item 13(a)
of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications. We are limiting the
description of any arrangements for reporting transactions on the NMS
Stock ATS to only ``material arrangements'' in the adopted item, and
converting the prompt in the proposed Part IV, Item 13(a) to describe
any differences among subscribers and persons into a ``yes'' or ``no''
question in Part III, Item 21(b) of adopted Form ATS-N.
Part III, Item 22 is substantially the same as Part IV, Item 13(b)
of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications. We are limiting the
description of any arrangements to facilitate the clearance and
settlement of transactions on the NMS Stock ATS to only ``material
arrangements'' in the adopted item, and converting the prompt in Part
IV, Item 13(b) of proposed Form ATS-N to describe any differences among
subscribers and persons into a ``yes'' or ``no'' question in Part III,
Item 22(b) of adopted Form ATS-N. In addition, we are removing the
phrase ``undertaken by the NMS Stock ATS'' from the proposed
requirement to describe any procedures or arrangements by the NMS Stock
ATS to facilitate clearance and settlement on the ATS.
In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average, preparing Part IV,
Item 13 for a Form ATS-N would add 0.5 hours to the current baseline
for an initial operation report on current Form ATS.\1221\ We believe
that preparing Part III, Items 21 and 22 for a Form ATS-N will impose a
lesser burden as compared to the proposed items because the adopted
items only require that ``material'' arrangements related to reporting
and clearance and settlement of transactions be disclosed (as opposed
to ``any arrangements'' in the Proposal). Therefore, we estimate that,
on average, preparing Part III, Item 21 and 22 for a Form ATS-N would
add 0.5 hours to the current baseline for an initial operation report
on current Form ATS to provide a more detailed description of the NMS
Stock ATS's trade reporting, clearance, and settlement arrangements or
procedures. This will result in an aggregate initial burden of 20.5
hours above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete
Part III, Items 21 and 22 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1222\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1221\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81103.
\1222\ Compliance Manager at 0.50 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
20.5 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 23 of adopted Form ATS-N is substantially the same
as Part IV, Item 11 of proposed Form ATS-N with certain modifications.
We are revising the request to make clear that an NMS Stock ATS would
not be
[[Page 38880]]
expected to provide information about the market data that the broker-
dealer operator uses to route orders and trading interest from the NMS
Stock ATS to away destinations by removing from the item the prompt to
describe how the ATS uses market data to determine routing
destinations. As discussed above in Section V.D.23, we believe,
however, that it would be responsive to Part III, Item 23 for the NMS
Stock ATS to provide information about the ATS's use of market data to
determine when resting orders and trading interest will be removed from
inside the NMS Stock ATS as such orders and trading interest reside
inside the ATS. Accordingly, the NMS Stock ATS should disclose, in
response to this request, the market data that is used to remove
resting orders and trading from the NMS Stock ATS. Because the adopted
Item is removing the requirement from the proposed Item for information
related to using market data to determine routing destinations, and the
adopted Item is adding a requirement to explain how market data is used
to determine when resting orders will be removed from the NMS Stock
ATS, we believe that the resulting overall burden for the adopted Item
will remain the same. In addition, we are adding a requirement that if
the use of market data is not the same for all subscribers and the
broker-dealer operator, that the NMS Stock ATS must identify and
explain any differences.
We believe that the disclosures under Part III, Item 23 will not
impose any significant additional burden on NMS Stock ATSs, which
should already be aware of the market data that they use and the manner
in which they use it. The information requested in Part III, Item 23 of
adopted Form ATS-N is similar to that required by Part IV, Item 11 of
proposed Form ATS-N. In the Proposal, we estimated that, on average,
preparing Part IV, Item 11 for a Form ATS-N would add 4 hours to the
current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS to
describe the sources of market data and the manner in which the NMS
Stock ATS uses market data.\1223\ However, unlike Part IV, Item 11 of
proposed Form ATS-N, Part III, Item 23 also requests information
regarding differences in treatment between subscribers and the broker-
dealer operator. We believe that this requirement would add to the
total additional burden; however, we believe that such information
should be readily available to the NMS Stock ATS. Therefore, we believe
that preparing Part IV, Item 11 for a Form ATS-N will add 5 hours to
the current baseline for an initial operation report on current Form
ATS. This would result in an aggregate initial burden of 205 hours
above the current baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part IV,
Item 11 of adopted Form ATS-N.\1224\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1223\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81103.
\1224\ (Compliance Manager at 2.5 hours + Senior Systems Analyst
at 2.5 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 205 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Items 24 and 25 of adopted Form ATS-N correspond with of
Part IV, Item 14 and 15 of proposed Form ATS-N. Current Form ATS does
not require an ATS to disclose the information that would be required
under Part III, Items 24 and 25 of Form ATS-N. However, based on the
experience of the Commission and its staff, we continue to believe that
no ATSs currently executed 5% or more of the average daily volume in an
NMS Stock as reported by an effective transaction reporting plan for
four of the preceding six calendar months, and we believe that most--if
not all--ATSs that currently trade NMS stocks already have procedures
in place to prevent that threshold from being crossed on the ATS's
system. Historically, ATSs have crossed these thresholds very rarely,
with at most three ATSs that trade NMS stocks crossing either of the
thresholds in any given year.
If, however, an NMS Stock ATS were to cross these 5% thresholds, a
disclosure burden related to amending a Form ATS-N to complete Part
III, Items 24 and 25 of Form ATS-N may result. Because Items 24 and 25
of Part III are tied to existing obligations that arise pursuant to
Rule 301(b)(3) and Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS, respectively, we
believe that NMS Stock ATSs should already be generally aware of the
procedures they would follow pursuant to those rules, which should
reduce the burden associated with the disclosures that would be
required under Items 24 and 25. An NMS Stock ATS would only have to
respond to Part III, Items 24 or 25 of a Form ATS-N if the NMS Stock
ATS previously operated as an ATS, triggered the applicable 5%
thresholds, and was subject to Rules 301(b)(3) and 301(b)(5). Further,
NMS Stock ATSs would be less likely to have to complete Item 24 as
compared to Item 25 because Item 24 requires as an additional
precondition that the NMS Stock ATS displays orders in an NMS stock to
more than one person in the system (other than employees of the NMS
Stock ATS). For new NMS Stock ATSs (i.e., NMS Stock ATSs that did not
previously operate as an ATS), the NMS Stock ATS would not have been in
operation for at least four months to trigger the applicable
thresholds, meaning that such NMS Stock ATSs would only be required to
complete Item 24 or 25 (or both) in a Form ATS-N Amendment. In the
Proposal, we estimated that completion of Part IV, Item 14 or 15 in a
Form ATS-N amendment (or in a Form ATS-N in the case of an NMS Stock
ATS that previously operated as an ATS), would be 5 hours per item. We
believe that the requirements in Part III, Items 24 and 25 remain
substantially unchanged, and that the burden should remain the same.
Therefore, we continue to believe that completion of Part III, Item 24
or 25 would be 5 hours per item.
Triggering the 5% threshold, a precondition necessary to require
completion of Part III, Items 24 and 25 of Form ATS-N, currently
occurs, and we estimate would continue to occur, very infrequently.
Based on the review of Form ATS and Form ATS-R disclosures by the
Commission and its staff, we estimate that 1 NMS Stock ATS would have
to complete Item 24, and 2 NMS Stock ATSs would have to complete Item
25 in any given year. Accordingly, we estimate that the disclosures
that would be required under Part III, Items 24 and 25 of adopted Form
ATS-N would result in an aggregate initial burden of 15 hours above the
current baseline.\1225\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1225\ (Attorney at 2 hours + Compliance Manager at 1 hour +
Senior Systems Analyst at 2 hours) x 3 NMS Stock ATSs = 15 burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N corresponds with of Part
IV, Item 16 of proposed Form ATS-N. An NMS Stock ATS will not be
required to develop or publish any new statistics for purposes of
making the required disclosures under Item 26. It is only be required
to make the disclosures for statistics it already otherwise publishes
or provides in the course of its operations. Thus, NMS Stock ATSs that
do not publish or otherwise provide aggregate platform-wide market
quality statistics, other than those currently required under Rule 605
of Regulation NMS, would not incur any additional burden due to the
adopted disclosure request under Item 26. For NMS Stock ATSs that do
publish or provide such statistics, Item 26 imposes an additional
burden above the baseline because current Form ATS does not require the
disclosure of market quality statistics. In the Proposal, we estimated
that preparing Part IV, Item 16 of proposed Form ATS-N would add 7
hours to the current baseline for an initial operation report on
current Form ATS.\1226\ Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N is
substantially the same as Part IV, Item
[[Page 38881]]
16 of proposed Form ATS-N. Therefore, as adopted, we still estimate
that preparing Part III, Item 26 will add 7 hours to the current
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This will
result in an aggregate initial burden of 287 hours above the current
baseline for all NMS Stock ATSs to complete Part III, Item 26 of
adopted Form ATS-N.\1227\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1226\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81104.
\1227\ (Attorney at 1 hour + Compliance Manager at 1 hour +
Senior Systems Analyst at 5 hours) x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 287 burden
hours. Unlike the proposed requirement under Part IV, Item 16, the
adopted requirement will allow the NMS Stock ATS to make
certifications in lieu of filing Exhibits 4 and 5, which we believe
will significantly reduce the burden imposed by this request for
information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) Estimated Burden Above the Current Baseline for an Initial Form
ATS-N, Form ATS-N Amendment, and Notice of Cessation on Form ATS-N
(a) Initial Form ATS-N
Based on the above analysis, we estimate that an initial Form ATS-N
will, on average, require approximately 107.4 burden hours above the
baseline for an initial operation report on current Form ATS. This
results in an estimated 127.4 hours in total, including the current
baseline.\1228\ ATSs that trade NMS stocks vary in terms of their
structure, the manner in which they operate, and the depth and extent
of their disclosures on Form ATS. Consequently, we believe that the
estimated hour burden regarding Form ATS-N will likely vary among NMS
Stock ATSs, depending on such factors as the extent of their current
disclosures on Form ATS, the complexity and structure of their system,
and the extent of their other broker-dealer or affiliate activities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1228\ (Current Baseline at 20 hours) + (Part I at 0.5 hour) +
(Part II at an average of 29 hours) + (Part III at an average of
77.5 hours) + (Access to EDGAR at 0.15 hours, see infra Section
IX.D.2.b.iv) = 127.4 burden hours. The aggregate totals by
professional, including the baseline, are estimated to be
approximately 54.1 hours for an Attorney, .5 hours for a Chief
Compliance Manager, 33.9 hours for a Compliance Manager, 30.25 hours
for a Senior Systems Analyst, 1 hour for a Senior Marketing Manager,
and 7.65 hours for a Compliance Clerk. This estimated burden for a
Form ATS-N includes the hour burden associated with completing Part
III, Items 24 and 25 of proposed Form ATS-N. We believe that the
majority of NMS Stock ATSs would not be required to complete those
items of the proposed form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(b) Form ATS-N Amendments
As previously noted, we estimate that ATSs that trade NMS stocks
submit 2 amendments on Form ATS, on average, each year.\1229\ In the
Proposal we estimated that the 46 respondents would file 3 Form ATS-N
amendments each year, for an estimated total of 138 Form ATS-N
amendments.\1230\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1229\ See supra note 1132 and accompanying text. During the
fiscal year of 2017, we received 85 amendments from ATSs that trade
NMS stocks, of which there were approximately 38 at any given time
during 2017. Some ATSs that trade NMS stocks filed as many as 7
amendments while others did not file any amendments in 2017.
\1230\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81105.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We currently estimate that the hourly burden related to an
amendment to Form ATS is 6 hours.\1231\ In the Proposal, we estimated
that the average hourly burden above this current baseline of 6 hours
for each Form ATS-N amendment would be 3 hours--for a total of 9
hours--to accommodate the more voluminous and detailed disclosures
required by Form ATS-N as compared to Form ATS.\1232\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1231\ See supra note 1133 and accompanying text.
\1232\ Attorney at 1 hour + Compliance Manager at 2 hours = 3
burden hours above the baseline.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 304(a)(2) of Regulation ATS will contain the same three
general categories of required amendments for Form ATS-N as Rule
301(b)(2) of Regulation ATS currently requires for current Form ATS;
\1233\ in addition, Form ATS-N requires two additional types of
amendments--order display and fair access amendments. However, due to
the greater detail and number of disclosures required by Form ATS-N, we
believe that respondents will likely file more amendments to Form ATS-N
than NMS Stock ATSs currently do for Form ATS. For example, adopted
Form ATS-N requests information about the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates in Part III of Form ATS-N,
and these requests are not contained in current Form ATS. To the extent
information provided in response to these requests changes, an NMS
Stock ATS must file a Form ATS-N amendment. We are mitigating some of
the additional burden by requiring that NMS Stock ATSs file correcting
amendments only to correct ``material'' information that was inaccurate
or incomplete when filed.\1234\ Current Form ATS requires ATSs to
promptly file amendments upon discovery that any information was
inaccurate when filed. As adopted, filers instead would correct any
immaterial information when they file updating amendments, which could
potentially reduce the frequency with which NMS Stock ATSs would need
to file amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1233\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2). See also supra Section IV.B.1.
\1234\ See supra note 498 and accompanying text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
With respect to Form ATS-N amendments, one commenter expresses
concern that due to the breadth of Form ATS-N disclosures, the
estimated amount of time and resources required to keep Form ATS-N
``evergreen'' is ``daunting,'' and asserts that the Commission did not
fully consider in the Proposal the amount of time and resources that
would be required to keep Form ATS-N current.\1235\ We fully considered
the burden for each question on the Form ATS-N by indicating the
estimated burden hour for each item. After consideration of comments,
we made changes to adopted Form ATS-N, which we believe will alleviate
some of the potential burdens of Form ATS-N, including, among other
things, requiring correcting amendments only for ``material''
information,\1236\ narrowing the scope of the required disclosures
related to affiliates that can enter or direct the entry of orders and
trading interest into the ATS,\1237\ and eliminating the proposed
requirement to attach a copy of any materials currently provided to
subscribers or other persons related to the operations of the NMS Stock
ATS or the disclosures on Form ATS-N.\1238\ However, as with amendments
to Form ATS, the burden on NMS Stock ATSs associated with updating Form
ATS-N to reflect current ATS functionality will vary depending on the
frequency and scope of changes made by the NMS Stock ATSs. Making
complete and comprehensible disclosures of material changes to the NMS
Stock ATS's operations, such as the introduction of a new order type
and its attributes or changes to segmentation procedures and
parameters, would likely require more time and resources from an NMS
Stock ATS than providing complete and comprehensible disclosures of a
simple change to the NMS Stock ATS's physical or website address. We
believe that the frequency with which an NMS Stock ATS files Form ATS-N
amendments in a given year may vary greatly, as some NMS Stock ATSs may
make infrequent changes to their operations and functionality, but
other NMS Stock ATSs, such as those that publish or otherwise provide
to one or more subscribers or person aggregate platform-wide market
quality statistics, may file several Form ATS-N amendments annually.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1235\ See Fidelity Letter at 10.
\1236\ See supra note 498 and accompanying text.
\1237\ See supra Section V.C.
\1238\ See supra Section V.B.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Therefore, we continue to believe that the requirements for Form
ATS-N amendments will add 3 hours above the current baseline of 6 hours
for amendments to Form ATS, as set forth in the Proposal. We estimate
that the 41 respondents will file 3 Form ATS-N amendments each year,
for a total of 123
[[Page 38882]]
Form ATS-N amendments.\1239\ In addition, an NMS Stock ATS must provide
a brief summary of the amendment at the top of Form ATS-N.\1240\ As
proposed, an NMS Stock ATS would have been required to submit two
redlines--Exhibit 3A to show changes to Part III of proposed Form ATS-N
and Exhibit 4A to show changes to Part IV of proposed Form ATS-N. We
estimated that the requirement would create an additional burden of 0.5
hours to draft the summary and create the redline(s).\1241\ Adopted
Form ATS-N requires NMS Stock ATSs to submit as Exhibit 3 one marked
document that indicates changes to ``yes'' or ``no'' answers or
additions to or deletions to both Part I, Parts II, and III. We believe
that requiring a single marked document rather than two separate
documents will reduce the filing burden on ATSs, and that requiring a
marked document for changes to Part I would impose minimal burden, and
therefore we estimate that this requirement would add an additional
burden of 0.4 hours to draft the summary and prepare the marked
documents showing the amendments the NMS Stock ATS is making.\1242\
This would result in a total estimated hourly burden, including the
baseline, of 9.4 hours for a Form ATS-N amendment,\1243\ and an
aggregate annual burden on all NMS Stock ATSs of 1,156.2 hours.\1244\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1239\ 41 respondents x 3 Form ATS-N amendments per year = 123
Form ATS-N amendments per year.
\1240\ See Exhibit 3 to Form ATS-N.
\1241\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81105.
\1242\ Compliance Clerk at 0.4 hours. Most word processing
software provides for this functionality.
\1243\ Attorney at 5.5 hours + Compliance Manager at 2 hours +
Compliance Clerk at 1.9 hours = 9.4 burden hours.
\1244\ 123 amendments per year x 9.4 hours = 1,156.2 aggregate
burden hours. Therefore, the aggregate burden hours equals 1,156.2
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the Proposal, a Legacy NMS Stock ATS would have continued to
operate pursuant to its existing Form ATS initial operation report
pending our review of the Legacy NMS Stock ATS's filed Form ATS-N and
would have been required to continue filing amendments on Form ATS to
provide notice of changes to the operations of its system.\1245\
Adopted Rule 304(a)(1)(iv)(C) requires a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to amend
its Form ATS-N to notify the Commission of operational changes during
the review period.\1246\ We believe that if a Legacy NMS Stock ATS had
been required to file amendments to Form ATS during the Commission
review period, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS would have also complied with
the requirements of Rule 304 by amending its Form ATS-N to reflect such
changes disclosed in such Form ATS amendments. During the Commission
review period, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS would have, therefore,
submitted amendments to both Form ATS and Form ATS-N. Although we are
now requiring that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS amend its Form ATS-N during
the review period rather than its Form ATS, this requirement does not
change our estimates of the aggregate burden hours for filing
amendments. Although a Legacy NMS Stock ATS will be required to amend
Form ATS-N, which requires greater detail and a larger number of
disclosures than Form ATS, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS will no longer need
to file a Form ATS amendment during the review period and a Form ATS-N
amendment to reflect changes disclosed in such Form ATS-N amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1245\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81023; see also proposed
Rule 304(a)(1)(i).
\1246\ See 17 CFR 242.304(a)(1)(iv)(C).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(c) Notice of Cessation on Form ATS-N
From January 2014 through March 2018, an average of 9 ATSs that
trade NMS stocks ceased operations each year.\1247\ Although it is
unclear how many NMS Stock ATSs might cease operations each year going
forward, for purposes of providing a PRA burden estimate, we are
estimating that this average would generally remain the same for NMS
Stock ATSs using Form ATS-N because economic conditions, business
reasons, and other factors may cause some NMS Stock ATSs to cease
operations. Accordingly, we estimate that 9 respondents may file a
cessation of operation report on Form ATS-N each year. In the Proposal,
we estimated that the average compliance burden for each cessation of
operations filing would be 2 hours.\1248\ We received no comments on
this estimate, and continue to believe that the burden for filing a
notice of cessation on Form ATS-N will not be significantly greater
than that for filing a cessation of operations report on current Form
ATS. Both Form ATS and Form ATS-N require the ATS to check the
appropriate box indicating that the ATS is ceasing operations; however,
Form ATS-N also requires that the NMS Stock ATS provide the date that
the NMS Stock ATS expects to cease operating. Accordingly, we estimate
that the average compliance burden for each respondent will be 2
hours.\1249\ This will result in an aggregate annual burden of 18 hours
for all NMS Stock ATSs that choose to cease operations and submit a
cessation of operation report on Form ATS-N.\1250\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1247\ See supra note 1114.
\1248\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81105.
\1249\ Attorney at 1.5 hours + Compliance Clerk at 0.5 hours = 2
burden hours. See supra note 1135, and accompanying text.
\1250\ 2 burden hours x 9 NMS Stock ATSs = 18 aggregate annual
burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) ATSs That Trade Both NMS and Non-NMS Stocks
ATSs that trade both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks would incur: (1)
The above baseline burdens related to filing a Form ATS-N and Form ATS-
N amendments; \1251\ (2) the additional burden of filing a new Form ATS
to only disclose information related to non-NMS stock trading activity
on the ATS; \1252\ and (3) the burden of completing and filing two
Forms ATS-R. We received no comment on the estimated burden set forth
in the Proposal for ATSs to separately file a Form ATS for its non-NMS
stock trading activity and Form ATS-N for its NMS stock trading
activity.\1253\ We continue to believe that the average estimated
burden set forth in the Proposal is a reasonable estimate of the
additional burden. Accordingly, we estimate that the total hourly
burden for an ATS to separately file a Form ATS for its non-NMS stock
trading activity and Form ATS-N for its NMS stock trading activity will
be 20 burden hours to amend its initial operation report on Form ATS
for its non-NMS stock trading activity and 127.4 burden hours to file
its initial Form ATS-N. The estimated hour burden related to the
initial operation report submission on Form ATS for non-NMS stock
trading activity may be less than the estimated 20 burden hours, as, to
the extent the NMS Stock ATS in question is currently operating, the
description of its non-NMS stock trading activity should already be
contained in its existing Form ATS.\1254\ As previously noted, there
are currently 10 ATSs that trade, or have indicated that they expect to
trade, in Exhibit B to their Form ATS, both NMS stocks and non-NMS
stocks on the ATS. Consequently, we estimate that the aggregate initial
burden on ATSs to file these separate forms would be 1,774 hours, and
the aggregate annual
[[Page 38883]]
burden for filing amendments to both forms would be 402 hours.\1255\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1251\ See supra Sections IX.D.2.b.ii.A and B.
\1252\ See supra Section IX.D.2.a and accompanying text for the
baseline estimates for submitting an IOR for Form ATS and amendments
to Form ATS.
\1253\ See supra note 1136 and accompanying text for the
baseline estimate for submitting a Form ATS-R.
\1254\ The hourly burden related to amendments to its Form ATS
and Form ATS-N would remain unchanged: 6 estimated burden hours for
amendments to Form ATS, and 9.4 estimated burden hours for Form ATS-
N amendments. See supra notes 1231-1232, 1240-1243 and accompanying
text.
\1255\ (Form ATS initial operation report at 20 hours + Form
ATS-N at 127.4 hours) x 10 respondents = 1,774 aggregate burden
hours. Using the estimates of 2 amendments each year to Form ATS,
see supra Section IX.D.2.a, and 3 amendments each year to Form ATS-
N, see supra Section IX.D.2.b.ii.B, the ongoing aggregate burden for
these bifurcated ATSs would be ((2 Form ATS amendments per year x 6
hours) + (3 Form ATS-N amendments per year x 9.4 hours)) x 10
respondents = 402 aggregate ongoing burden hours per year relating
to amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We estimate that the total burden for completing and filing two
Forms ATS-R would be 4.5 hours, which is 0.5 hours \1256\ above the
current baseline burden of 4 hours for filing a Form ATS-R.\1257\ We
believe that ATSs required to file two Forms ATS-R will incur an
additional burden above the baseline because they would be required to
divide their trading statistics between two forms and file each form
separately. We do not believe that those ATSs will incur any additional
burden to collect the required information because they currently
assemble that information when preparing their current Form ATS-R
filings. As previously noted, there are currently 10 ATSs that trade,
or have indicated that they expect to trade in Exhibit B to their Form
ATS, both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks on the ATS; those ATSs would be
required to file a pair of Forms ATS-R four times annually.
Consequently, we estimate that the aggregate annual burden of filing
two Forms ATS-R for those ATS that effect transactions in both NMS
stocks and non-NMS stocks would be 180 hours.\1258\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1256\ Attorney at 0.5 hours = 0.5 burden hours.
\1257\ See supra note 1136 and accompanying text for the
baseline estimate for submitting a Form ATS-R.
\1258\ ((Attorney at 3.5 hours + Compliance Clerk at 1 hour) x
(4 filings annually)) x 10 ATSs = 180 aggregate burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iv) Access to EDGAR
The Proposal contemplated the use of an online filing system, the
EFFS, but the adopted amendments to Regulation ATS will require NMS
Stock ATSs to submit certain Form ATS-N filings through the
Commission's EDGAR system. Based on the widespread use and availability
of the internet, we believe that filing Form ATS-N in an electronic
format will be a less burdensome and more efficient filing process for
NMS Stock ATSs and the Commission, as it is likely to be less expensive
and cumbersome than mailing and filing paper forms to the
Commission.\1259\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1259\ All estimated burden hours with regard to completing
Parts I-V of proposed Form ATS-N, which are explained above and
herein, include the estimated burden associated with the requirement
that NMS Stock ATSs file Form ATS-N in a structured XML format on
EDGAR, including narrative responses that are block-text tagged, or
use the web-fillable form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For a Form ATS-N filer to gain access to make filings on the EDGAR
system, the filer must submit a Form ID as required by Regulation S-T
Rule 11 (B) and submit the Form ID following the processes detailed in
Volume I of the EDGAR Filer Manual. Once a Form ID has been
successfully completed and processed, EDGAR will establish a Central
Index Key (``CIK'') number which enables each authorized user to create
EDGAR access codes, which will enable the NMS Stock ATS to use EDGAR.
We estimate that the burden associated with receiving access to EDGAR
by submitting a Form ID is 0.15 burden hours per response. All
registered broker-dealers have been assigned a CIK number and do not
need to submit a Form ID to access EDGAR.\1260\ Because all ATSs,
regardless of whether they trade NMS stocks, are operated by registered
broker-dealers, we estimate that there will be no burden associated
with gaining access to EDGAR for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs or non-NMS Stock
ATSs that later decide to trade NMS stocks. Based on the number of
initial filings and cessation of operations reports on current Form ATS
for ATSs that trade NMS stocks, we estimate that, 2 to 3 new entities
will file Form ATS-N to become an NMS Stock ATS in each of the next
three years. We estimate that among these new entities, 1 new entity
per year will be operated by an entity that has not previously
registered as a broker-dealer or that does not otherwise already have
access to EDGAR. The total estimated hourly burden and aggregate
initial burden for gaining access to EDGAR is therefore 0.15
hours.\1261\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1260\ A broker-dealer that has never used EDGAR to make
electronic submissions may use its assigned CIK number to receive
access codes that will allow the broker-dealer operator to submit
Form ATS-N filings on EDGAR without needing to apply for a Form ID.
\1261\ Compliance Manager at 0.15 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
6.15 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
v. Public Posting on NMS Stock ATS's Website
Rule 304(b)(3) will require each NMS Stock ATS to make public via
posting on the NMS Stock ATS's website, a direct URL hyperlink to the
Commission's website that contains the documents enumerated in Rule
304(b)(2). We estimate that each NMS Stock ATS will incur an initial,
one-time burden to program and configure its website to post the
required direct URL hyperlink pursuant to Rule 304(b)(3). We estimate
that this initial, one-time burden would be approximately 2 hours, in
part because many broker-dealer operators currently maintain a website
for their NMS Stock ATSs.\1262\ This is unchanged from the estimate set
forth in the Proposal.\1263\ We estimate that the aggregate initial,
one-time burden will be approximately 82 hours.\1264\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1262\ Senior Systems Analyst at 2 burden hours.
\1263\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81106-07.
\1264\ Senior Systems Analyst at 2 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs =
82 burden hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(v) Recordkeeping Requirements
Because NMS Stock ATSs that solely trade NMS stocks will file Form
ATS-N in lieu of Form ATS, we believe that the amendment to Rule
303(a)(2)(ii) will not result in any burden for those ATSs that are not
already accounted for under the current baseline burden estimate for
Rule 303.\1265\ The estimated burden under amended Rule 303(a)(2)(ii)
for each ATS is the same as in the Proposal.\1266\ For the 10 ATSs that
transact in, or have indicated in Exhibit B to their Forms ATS that
they expect to trade both NMS stock and non-NMS stock on their
respective ATSs, we estimate that the burden above the current baseline
estimate for preserving records relating to compliance with the
amendment to Rule 303(a)(ii) will be, consistent with the estimate in
the proposing release, approximately 3 hours annually per ATS for a
total annual burden above the current baseline burden estimate of 30
hours for all respondents.\1267\ Accordingly, we are modifying the PRA
burden estimate for Rule 303 to account for the increased burden on
ATSs that trade both NMS stock and non-NMS stock.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1265\ To comply with all of the record preservation
requirements of Rule 303, we currently estimate that ATSs spend
approximately 1,305 hours per year (87 respondents at 15 burden
hours per respondent). See Rule 303 PRA Update, supra note 1613, 78
FR 43943. At an average cost per burden hour of $111.32, the
resultant total related cost of compliance is $145,272.60 per year
(1,305 burden hours x $111.32/hour). See id. The cost per burden
hour is adjusted for an inflation rate of 6.8% based on the Bureau
of Labor Statistics data on CPI-U between July 2013 and March 2018.
\1266\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81107.
\1267\ 3 additional burden hours x 10 ATSs = 30 aggregate burden
hours.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
E. Collection of Information Is Mandatory
All collections of information pursuant to the amended rules and
Form ATS-N are mandatory for entities that meet the definition of NMS
Stock ATS.
[[Page 38884]]
F. Confidentiality of Responses to Collection of Information
With respect to the amendments to Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of
Regulation ATS, including Form ATS-N, the Commission will make publicly
available on its website all effective Forms ATS-N, all properly filed
Form ATS-N amendments to effective Forms ATS-N, and notices of
cessation on Form ATS-N. The Commission will not make publicly
available on its website initial Forms ATS-N that the Commission has
declared ineffective, but these forms will be available for examination
and inspection by the Commission and its staff, state securities
authorities, and self-regulatory organizations. Form ATS-N amendments
also require each NMS Stock ATS that has a website to post on the NMS
Stock ATS's website a direct URL hyperlink to the Commission's website
that contains the documents enumerated in Rule 304(b)(2). The
collection of information required by the amendments to Rules
301(b)(10), 303(a)(1)(v), 301(b)(9), and 303(a)(2)(ii) will not be made
public, but would be used for regulatory purposes by the Commission and
the SRO(s) of which the ATS's broker-dealer operator is a member. In
Part II, Item 7 of Form ATS-N, however, NMS Stock ATSs must describe
the written safeguards and written procedures to ensure confidential
treatment of trading information that will be required under Rule
301(b)(10) as amended. To the extent that the Commission receives
confidential information pursuant to this collection of information,
such information will be kept confidential, subject to the provisions
of applicable law.
G. Retention Period for Recordkeeping Requirements
All reports required to be made under Rules 301(b)(2)(viii),
301(b)(9), and 304 of Regulation ATS, including Form ATS-N, will be
required to be preserved during the life of the enterprise and any
successor enterprise, pursuant to the amendment to Rule 303(a)(2) of
Regulation ATS. In addition, ATSs will be required to preserve a copy
of their written safeguards and written procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information under Rule 301(b)(10) of
Regulation ATS for not less than 3 years, the first 2 years in an
easily accessible place, pursuant to Rule 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation
ATS.
X. Economic Analysis
A. Background
We are concerned that the current regulatory requirements relating
to operational transparency for NMS Stock ATSs may no longer fully meet
the goals of furthering the public interest and protecting
investors.\1268\ We are concerned that the limited and differential
level of operational transparency around NMS Stock ATSs impedes market
participants' ability to adequately discern how their orders interact,
match, and execute on NMS Stock ATSs, which impedes their ability to
evaluate whether submitting order flow to a particular NMS Stock ATS
aligns with their business interests and would help them achieve their
investing or trading objectives. In addition, we are concerned that the
current lack of transparency around the potential conflicts of interest
that arise from the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates hinders market participants' abilities to
protect their interests when doing business on NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1268\ See supra Section I. See also supra Sections II.A and D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are adopting amendments to Regulation ATS to require NMS Stock
ATSs to publicly file Form ATS-N, which would require NMS Stock ATSs to
provide detailed disclosures about their trading operations and the
ATS-related activities of their broker-dealer operators and their
affiliates. In addition, we are adopting new Rule 304 as part of
Regulation ATS, which provides a process for the Commission to review
Form ATS-N filings and declare an NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N,
after notice and opportunity for hearing, ineffective.\1269\ Finally,
we are adopting amendments to Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS to
require that all ATSs memorialize in writing their procedures and
safeguards to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information.\1270\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1269\ Rule 304 also provides a process for the Commission to
declare amendments to Form ATS-N ineffective.
\1270\ Current Rule 301(b)(10) requires all ATSs establish
procedures and safeguards to protect subscribers' confidential
trading information, but it does not expressly require that such
procedures and safeguards must be maintained in writing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adopted amendments and Form ATS-N seek to make information
regarding the operations of NMS Stock ATSs available to market
participants, which will increase the operational transparency for NMS
Stock ATSs, bringing it more in line with the operational transparency
for national securities exchanges. The amendments also seek to improve
the quality of information regarding different NMS Stock ATSs'
operations and the ATS-related activities of their broker-dealer
operators and their affiliates. As discussed in more detail below, we
believe that this would help market participants make better-informed
decisions about where to route their orders in order to achieve their
trading or investment objectives, thereby improving the efficiency of
capital allocation and enhancing execution quality. Additionally, we
believe that requiring NMS Stock ATSs to memorialize their safeguards
and written procedures in writing will improve Commission oversight by
helping it better understand, monitor, and evaluate how each ATS
protects subscribers' confidential trading information from
unauthorized disclosure and access, which in turn could increase
investor protection. On the other hand, creation of responses to aid
disclosure of Form ATS-N and the possibility that we may declare the
Form ATS-N ineffective would entail costs to NMS Stock ATSs, which
could result in some of them ceasing to operate as ATSs. If some NMS
Stock ATSs cease operating as ATSs, it could impact the competitive
dynamics between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges, as
well as the competitive dynamics among NMS Stock ATSs and between NMS
Stock ATSs and broker-dealers who trade NMS stocks but do not operate
an ATS.
We are sensitive to the economic consequences and effects,
including the costs and benefits, of our rules. The following economic
analysis identifies and considers the costs and benefits--including the
effects on efficiency, competition, and capital formation--that would
result from new Rule 304, Form ATS-N and the amendments to Rule 3a1-
1(a) and Regulation ATS. These costs and benefits are discussed below
and have informed the policy choices described throughout this
release.\1271\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1271\ Exchange Act Section 3(f) requires the Commission, when
it is engaged in rulemaking pursuant to the Exchange Act and is
required to consider or determine whether an action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, to consider, in addition to the
protection of investors, whether the action will promote efficiency,
competition and capital formation. See 15 U.S.C. 78c(f). In
addition, Exchange Act Section 23(a)(2) requires the Commission,
when making rules pursuant to the Exchange Act, to consider among
other matters the impact that any such rule would have on
competition and not to adopt any rule that would impose a burden on
competition that is not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of
the purposes of the Exchange Act. See 15 U.S.C. 78w(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38885]]
B. Baseline
The numerous parties that would be affected by new Rule 304, Form
ATS-N, and the amendments include: Existing NMS Stock ATSs; potential
new NMS Stock ATSs; current and potential subscribers of NMS Stock
ATSs; broker-dealers that are affiliated with NMS Stock ATSs and their
customers; non-ATS affiliated broker-dealers and their customers;
broker-dealers that do not operate NMS Stock ATSs but send order flow
to NMS Stock ATSs; institutional investors that periodically transact
large trades on NMS Stock ATSs; other persons that seek to transact in
NMS stocks on ATSs; and national securities exchanges that compete for
order flow with NMS Stock ATSs and other OTC trading systems.
We recognize that the economic effects of Rule 304, Form ATS-N, and
the amendments, including costs and benefits and effects on efficiency,
competition and capital formation, should be compared to a baseline
that accounts for the current market and regulatory framework for
trading NMS stocks. The baseline includes: Statistics on the number of
NMS Stock ATSs; current reporting requirements for NMS Stock ATSs; the
lack of public disclosure of NMS Stock ATSs' operations, as well as
disparate levels of information available to market participants about
NMS Stock ATSs' operations and the ATS-related activities of their
broker-dealer operators and their affiliates; and the competitive
environment between national securities exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs,
among NMS Stock ATSs, and between broker-dealers that operate NMS Stock
ATSs and broker-dealers that do not operate NMS Stock ATSs.
1. Current NMS Stock ATSs
As of March 31, 2018 there are 41 ATSs that have noticed on their
Form ATS that they expect to trade NMS stocks.\1272\ During the first
quarter in 2018, 33 ATSs, all of which operated as dark pools, traded
NMS stocks and accounted for approximately 57 billion shares traded in
NMS stocks (approximately $2.9 trillion in dollar volume), representing
approximately 11.4% of total share trading volume (11.5% of total
dollar trading volume) on all registered national securities exchanges,
ATSs, and non-ATS OTC trading venues in the first quarter of
2018.\1273\ Based on their market share, NMS Stock ATSs represent a
significant source of liquidity in NMS stocks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1272\ See supra note 9 and accompanying text.
\1273\ See infra Table 1, ``NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Dollar
Trading Volume (January 1, 2018-March 30, 2018)'' Total dollar
trading volume on all exchanges and off-exchange trading in the
first quarter of 2018 was approximately $25.4 trillion and
approximately 503 billion shares.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Current Reporting Requirements for NMS Stock ATSs
Even though ATSs directly compete for order flow in NMS stocks with
national securities exchanges, ATSs are exempt from the definition of
``exchange'' and therefore are not required to register as national
securities exchanges with the Commission.\1274\ A system that meets the
criteria of Rule 3b-16(a) may operate as an ATS on the condition that
the ATS complies with Regulation ATS, which requires, among other
things, that the ATS make filings with the Commission on Form ATS and
Form ATS-R,\1275\ which are ``deemed confidential when filed,'' as well
as adhere to other reporting requirements under Regulation ATS.\1276\
Furthermore, ATSs must register as broker-dealers and become members of
an SRO. Accordingly, the ATS must comply with rules applicable to a
broker-dealer and the SRO's rules applicable to broker-dealers. In
addition, FINRA Rules 6160 and 6170 require each NMS Stock ATS to use a
single, unique MPID for trade reporting purposes.\1277\ FINRA uses the
trade data reported by ATSs to publish aggregated weekly trading volume
and trade count information on its website for each ATS on a security-
by-security basis.\1278\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1274\ See supra Section II.B (discussing the conditions to the
exemption from the definition of ``exchange'' for an ATS).
\1275\ See supra Section II.C (discussing the Form ATS filing
requirements). See also supra note 65 and accompanying text
(discussing the Form ATS-R filing requirements).
\1276\ See supra Section II.C (discussing the requirements of
Regulation ATS); see also 17 CFR 242.301(b).
\1277\ See FINRA Rules 6160 and 6170. See also supra note 15.
\1278\ FINRA computes the aggregated statistics from trade data
reported by ATSs to the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities
(i.e., the Alternative Display Facility, the Trade Reporting
Facilities, and the OTC Reporting Facility). For trade data prior to
February 1, 2016, FINRA publishes aggregated trade data reported by
ATSs pursuant to former FINRA Rule 4552. FINRA publishes the
information regarding NMS stocks in the S&P500 Index or the Russell
1000 Index and certain exchange-traded products on a two-week
delayed basis, and the information on all other NMS stocks and OTC
equity securities on a four-week delayed basis. See FINRA OTC
Transparency Data at https://otctransparency.finra.org/. See also
supra note 15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Lack of Standardized Public Disclosure
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1279\ the level of
information about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related
activities of the NMS Stock ATSs' broker-dealer operators and their
affiliates vary across NMS Stock ATSs and across subscribers. Although
Regulation ATS states that information on Form ATS is ``deemed
confidential when filed,'' \1280\ some NMS Stock ATSs voluntarily make
their filings publicly available.\1281\ NMS Stock ATSs that either
voluntarily make their Form ATS publicly available, or publish summary
information of their operations, provide market participants more
information about their operations than do NMS Stock ATSs that do not
make their Forms ATS or information about their operations publicly
available.\1282\ However, market participants cannot always use these
voluntary disclosures to systematically compare NMS Stock ATSs, because
the disclosures are not standardized.\1283\ Additionally, subscribers
might have access to more information about the NMS Stock ATSs to which
they subscribe than they might about others, and also might have more
information about their NMS Stock ATSs than might non-subscribers. For
example, subscribers might have access to the NMS Stock ATS's
subscriber manual, other subscriber quotes, and, potentially, certain
market quality statistics an NMS Stock ATS may publish or otherwise
disclose to subscribers in addition to what is currently publicly
disclosed under Exchange Act Rule 605.\1284\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1279\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81110-11.
\1280\ See 17 CFR 242.301(b)(2)(vii).
\1281\ See supra note 56.
\1282\ On the other hand, some ATSs not only provide current
Form ATS on their public websites, they also provide more
information regarding their ATS operations. For instance, one
commenter asks all their subscribers to consent to having their
names publicly disclosed on their website so that all their
subscribers know the universe of entities that they could be
executing against. See Luminex Letter at 1.
\1283\ The level of detail and the format in which information
is presented on Form ATS varies among the NMS Stock ATSs. Several
commenters agree with us that either there is a lack of disclosure
about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs or that there is a need to
standardize disclosures made by NMS Stock ATSs. See Fidelity Letter
at 1; ICI Letter at 1; SIFMA Letter at 3. One commenter specifically
states that opacity of venue matching logic ``increases costs for
brokers connecting to venues, and they in turn pass these costs to
clients.'' See AI Letter at 2.
\1284\ Exchange Act Rule 605(a) requires every market center,
including ATSs, to make publicly available for each calendar month a
report containing standardized data on the covered orders in NMS
stocks that it receives for execution from any market participant.
Data on execution quality required under Exchange Act Rule 605(a)
includes order sizes, execution sizes, effective spreads, price
improvement, and quarterly volume of shares traded. See Rule
605(a)(8) for the definition of a covered order.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribers to an NMS Stock ATS might have varying access to the
different services of the NMS Stock
[[Page 38886]]
ATS.\1285\ Those subscribers with greater access might obtain more
knowledge and information about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs than
the subscribers with less access. With this additional information,
subscribers with greater access can make more nuanced decisions about
which trading venue suits their trading purposes, and thus possess an
informational advantage over other subscribers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1285\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81111 (discussing the
differential access of subscribers to NMS Stock ATSs).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even if having greater access to the services of an NMS Stock ATS
yields additional information about the operations of the NMS Stock ATS
to certain subscribers, subscribers that do not have full access to
services of the NMS Stock ATS, and the resulting additional
information, might still want to trade on NMS Stock ATSs in spite of
their relative informational disadvantage. Had these subscribers
possessed more detailed information about the operations of the NMS
Stock ATS, they might have been able to make more informed--and
therefore potentially different--decisions about where to route their
orders for execution.
4. NMS Stock ATS Treatment of Subscriber Confidential Trading
Information
Under current Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation ATS,\1286\ all ATSs
must establish adequate safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information, and, to ensure that
those safeguards and procedures are followed, must also establish
adequate oversight procedures.\1287\ Furthermore, all ATSs are required
to preserve certain records pursuant to Rule 303(a)(1).\1288\ However,
neither Rule 301(b)(10) nor Rule 303(a)(1) of Regulation ATS currently
requires that an ATS maintain and preserve their safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information, or
their related oversight procedures in writing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1286\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1287\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1288\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81087; see also supra
Section III.B.6 (discussing amendments to Exchange Act Rule 303).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in the Proposal,\1289\ we believe that ATSs--in
particular, ATSs whose broker-dealer operators are large, multi-service
broker-dealers--currently have and maintain in writing their safeguards
and procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information, as well as the oversight procedures to ensure such
safeguards and procedures are followed. One commenter agrees that
significant ATSs have largely reduced to writing their safeguards and
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information.\1290\ Additionally, this commenter also states these
written safeguards and procedures are likely to occur in multiple
formats and in different forms within the same broker-dealer. We
acknowledge that, to the extent an ATS broker-dealer operator currently
maintains written safeguards and written procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information, the written safeguards
and written procedures might exist in multiple formats or differing
forms within the same broker-dealer operator. Nevertheless, under the
current regulatory environment for ATSs, absent specific questions in
an examination by the Commission or its staff, we are not able to
determine whether all ATSs currently have written safeguards and
written procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading
information or, if an ATS does possess written safeguards and written
procedures, to what extent they exist in multiple formats or differing
forms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1289\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81111.
\1290\ See HMA Letter at 23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Competition
The current market for trading NMS stocks is served by national
securities exchanges, ATSs, and liquidity providers (including broker-
dealers who internalize), who compete to supply investors with
execution services at efficient prices. These trading venues, which
compete to match orders, provide a framework for price negotiation and
disseminate trading information. The sections below discuss the current
state of competition between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities
exchanges; competition among NMS Stock ATSs; and competition between
broker-dealers that operate NMS Stock ATSs and broker-dealers that do
not operate NMS Stock ATSs.
a. Competition Between NMS Stock ATSs and Registered National
Securities Exchanges
In the market for NMS stock execution services, NMS Stock ATSs not
only compete with other NMS Stock ATSs, they also compete with national
securities exchanges. As discussed in the Proposal,\1291\ NMS Stock
ATSs have grown in complexity and sophistication. Some NMS Stock ATSs
now offer features similar to those offered by national securities
exchanges, including, among other things, anonymous order submission,
limit order book matching systems, a wide range of order types, and
high-speed connectivity options. However, unlike national securities
exchanges, most NMS Stock ATSs have adopted a dark trading model, and
do not display any quotations in the consolidated quotation data.\1292\
Two commenters state that NMS Stock ATSs also compete with national
securities exchanges for order flow by offering features that are not
readily available on national securities exchanges.\1293\ For example,
while most national securities exchanges match trades via a price/time
priority limit order book, some NMS Stock ATSs may match trades via
auctions or block crossing mechanisms.\1294\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1291\ See Proposal, supra note 2, 80 FR at 81009.
\1292\ See id.
\1293\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4; ICI
Letter at 3.
\1294\ See Proposal, supra note 2, 80 FR at 81009; see also ICI
Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above and explained in more detail in the
Proposal,\1295\ NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges are
subject to different regulatory regimes, including different
obligations to disclose information about their trading operations and
activities. This has resulted in differences in operational
transparency between national securities exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs,
which limits the ability of market participants to compare the
operations and execution quality of NMS Stock ATSs and national
securities exchanges.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1295\ See supra Sections II.B-C (discussing the different mix
of obligations and benefits applicable to ATSs and registered
national securities exchanges). See also Proposal, supra note 2, at
81111-12.
\1296\ See supra Section II.B.
\1297\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81111-12
\1298\ See, e.g., Section 19(g) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C.
78s(g), and Section 6(b) of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. 78f(b). For
further discussion of the costs and benefits of registering as a
national securities exchange, see Proposal, supra note 2, at 81111-
12.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to the burdens discussed above,\1296\ and as discussed
in more detail in the Proposal,\1297\ national securities exchanges and
other SROs also have regulatory obligations, such as enforcing their
rules and the federal securities laws with respect to their members,
which do not apply to ATSs.\1298\ However, national securities
exchanges also enjoy certain benefits that are not afforded to NMS
Stock ATSs, such as establishing norms regarding conduct, trading, and
fee structures. ATSs, on the other hand, are regulated as broker-
dealers, and must comply with the rules of FINRA. Trading venues that
elect to register as national securities exchanges can gain
[[Page 38887]]
added prestige by establishing listing standards for their securities.
Additionally, national securities exchanges can be direct participants
in NMS plans, which provide additional sources of revenue and input
into the operation of the national market system that is not available
to NMS Stock ATSs.\1299\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1299\ See Regulation ATS Adopting Release, supra note 3, at
70880, 70902-70903 (Section discussing generally some of the
obligations and benefits of registering as a national securities
exchange).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in more detail in the Proposal, since the adoption of
Regulation NMS in 2005, the market for NMS stock execution services has
become more fragmented and the number of national securities exchanges
and NMS Stock ATSs has increased.\1300\ Over the past decade, with the
increase in fragmentation in the market for execution services, there
has been a shift in the market share of trading volume in NMS stocks
across trading venues.\1301\ The number of active dark pools trading
NMS stocks has increased from approximately 10 in 2002,\1302\ to 33
today.\1303\ The market share of total NMS stock share volume that is
attributable to dark pools has increased from 7.9% in 2009 \1304\ to
11.4% during the first quarter of 2018.\1305\ Thus, greater
fragmentation in the market for NMS stock execution services over the
past decade has resulted in trading volume being executed on different
venues, some of which include NMS Stock ATSs, particularly NMS Stock
ATSs that operate as dark pools.\1306\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1300\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81112. For a list of
current national securities exchanges, see https://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml.
Although there are 12 national securities exchanges that trade
NMS stocks, they are currently controlled by 5 exchange groups,
namely, CBOE Global Markets, Inc. (which controls BZX, BYX, EDGA,
and EDGX), CHX Holdings, Inc. (which controls CHX), Intercontinental
Exchange, Inc. (which controls NYSE American, NYSE, and NYSE Arca),
IEX Group Inc. (which controls IEX), and NASDAQ, Inc. (which
controls Nasdaq, BX, and PHLX).
\1301\ For further discussion see Proposal, supra note 2, at
81112.
\1302\ See Regulation of Non-Public Trading Interest at 61209
n.9, and accompanying text (proposing rules and amendment to joint
industry plans describing the term dark pool).
\1303\ See supra notes 11-12 and accompanying text.
\1304\ See supra notes 13-14 and accompanying text.
\1305\ See supra Section X.B.1.
\1306\ Several commenters also stated that ever since the
inception of Regulation ATS, the market for trading NMS stocks has
become more fragmented, and the number of NMS Stock ATSs and the
trading volume executed on these venues has increased, but they did
not provide quantitative estimates of the number of ATSs or the
fraction of trading volume executed on different venues. See CFA
Institute Letter at 2; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4;
Fidelity Letter at 3; LeveL ATS Letter at 2; Schneiderman Letter at
1, SIFMA Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters state that since the inception of Regulation
ATS, ATSs have operated at a competitive advantage relative to national
securities exchanges, because they operate with lower transparency and
greater opacity relative to national securities exchanges.\1307\
Another commenter states that ``ATSs are competitors to exchanges, but
do not have the same oversight, transparency requirements or
responsibilities.'' \1308\ This commenter also states that ``It is
clearly unfair competition for ATSs to be subject to far less
requirements than exchanges while executing a large percentage of the
market volume.'' \1309\ We agree that NMS Stock ATSs face lower
regulatory burdens than national securities exchanges, including
differences in the obligations to publicly disclose information about
their trading operations and activities. This has resulted in
differences between the operational transparency of NMS Stock ATSs and
national securities exchanges and made it more difficult for market
participants to evaluate how their orders interact, match, and execute
on the NMS Stocks ATSs than on national security exchanges. As
discussed in the Proposal,\1310\ the growth in the number of NMS Stock
ATSs may be driven by these less stringent regulatory obligations.
However, national securities exchanges also enjoy certain advantages
which are not available to NMS Stock ATSs, such as the ability to list
securities and share in market data revenue generated by the CTA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1307\ See CBOE Letter at 1; CFA Institute Letter at 2; Consumer
Federation of America Letter at 1-2, 4; ICI Letter at 3.
\1308\ See Anonymous at 1.
\1309\ See id.
\1310\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81112.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Competition Among NMS Stock ATSs
NMS Stock ATSs also compete with each other in a niche in the
market for NMS stock execution services. The rise in the number of NMS
Stock ATSs has not only affected competition between national
securities exchanges and ATSs for order flow of NMS stocks, it has also
impacted competition among NMS Stock ATSs.
Table 1, which is based on aggregated trade data reported by ATSs
to the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities for 13 weeks of trading
from January 1, 2018, to March 30, 2018, depicts the market share of
total dollar volume for NMS stocks, and the total share volume for NMS
stocks for individual ATSs.\1311\ Even though there are many NMS Stock
ATSs, much of the NMS stock dollar volume on ATSs is transacted by only
a handful of venues. Table 1 shows that the top 7 NMS Stock ATSs ranked
by dollar volume accounted for 63.4% of total dollar volume transacted
on ATSs and 59.2% of total share volume transacted on ATSs from January
1, 2018, to March 30, 2018.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1311\ See supra note 15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38888]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.000
Table 1: NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Dollar Trading Volume
(January 1, 2018--March 30, 2018) \1314\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1312\ Total Consolidated Volume includes all trading in NMS
stocks on all national securities exchanges, ATSs, and non-ATS OTC
trading.
\1313\ See supra note 2 for definition of ``dark pool''.
\1314\ Table 1 Data Sources: (1) FINRA Alternative Trading
System (ATS) Transparency Data is aggregated trade data reported by
ATSs to the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities and made
available on FINRA's website as part of the OTC Transparency Data.
The OTC Transparency Data is provided via http://www.finra.org/industry/OTC-Transparency and is copyrighted by FINRA 2018. (2) NYSE
Trade and Quote Database (TAQ).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This table shows the 33 ATSs that effected transactions in NMS
stocks from January 1, 2018--March 30, 2018, ranked in descending order
by dollar volume transacted. ATS data is reported weekly, and these
dates approximately correspond to the first quarter of 2018. Dollar
volume transacted on an ATS is calculated by multiplying the share
volume for a given NMS stock on the ATS in a given week by the average
trade price for that week. Dollar volume for each NMS stock is then
aggregated across all NMS stocks that traded on the given ATS in that
week. Also reported in this table is the number of trades, share
volume, each NMS Stock ATS's market share of all NMS Stock ATS dollar
volume and NMS Stock ATS share volume in that quarter.
Table 2, which is based on aggregated trade data reported by ATSs
to the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities
[[Page 38889]]
for 13 weeks of trading from January 1, 2018, to March 30, 2018, shows
the average trade size, which is share volume divided by the number of
trades on each of the NMS Stock ATSs. The table reveals marked
differences in the average trade size of transactions executed on the
various NMS Stock ATSs. Eight NMS Stock ATSs had average trade sizes in
excess of 10,000 shares. This suggests that some NMS Stock ATSs receive
large block orders and execute large trades.\1315\ One of the
advantages for market participants of trading on block crossing
networks is the ability to execute large block orders while minimizing
the movement of prices against their trading interest.\1316\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1315\ For purposes of this analysis we considered block orders
as orders of more than 10,000 shares, which is the traditional
definition for block orders. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81008.
See also Rule 600(b)(9) of Regulation NMS (defining block size with
respect to an order), 17 CFR 242.600(b)(9).
\1316\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81008 n.126, 127.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While these NMS Stock ATSs on average execute large size trades,
the combined market share of these NMS Stock ATSs is only 12.6% when
measured in dollar volume, and 6.0% when measured in share volume. The
vast majority of NMS Stock ATSs have average trade sizes between 100
and 460 shares. The average trade size across all 33 NMS Stock ATSs is
204 shares, while the two NMS Stock ATSs with the highest market shares
(measured either in dollar volume or share volume) have average trade
sizes of 155 and 163 shares, respectively. These trade sizes are not
significantly different from the average trade size of 146 shares on
national securities exchanges,\1317\ which suggests that the niche
market NMS Stock ATSs serve is not very different from the market as a
whole.\1318\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1317\ Tuttle (2013) also found that trade sizes on ``lit''
national securities exchanges are similar to those taking place on
``dark ATSs.'' However, Tuttle (2013) did not include odd lot trades
when calculating trade sizes for ``lit'' national securities
exchanges or ``dark ATSs.'' See Laura Tuttle, Alternative Trading
Systems: Description of ATS Trading in National Market System Stocks
(October 2013), http://www.sec.gov/marketstructure/research/alternative-trading-systems-march-2014.pdf (``Tuttle: ATS Trading in
NMS Stocks''). Unlike ``lit'' national securities exchanges, dark
ATSs do not publicly disseminate top of the limit-order book
information. See id.
Table 2 in the Proposal reports that between March 30, 2015, and
June 26, 2015, the average trade size on NMS Stock ATSs was 214
shares and the average trade size on national securities exchanges
was 181 shares. Calculations for both of the average trade size
metrics reported in the Proposal include odd lots trades. However,
calculations for the average trade size on national securities
exchanges reported in the Proposal also include TAQ trade volume
reported from bulk trades, opening and closing trades, and intraday
crosses. See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81114.
\1318\ One commenter conducted similar analysis, computing
average trade sizes in ``top volume ATSs'' for three time periods:
May 12, 2014-May 16, 2014; March 30-June 26, 2015; and January 11,
2016-January 15, 2016 and reached similar conclusions. See Anonymous
Letter at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38890]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.001
Table 2: NMS Stock ATSs Ranked by Average Trade Size
(January 1, 2018-March 30, 2018) \1320\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1319\ National securities exchanges that transacted in NMS
stocks during the period January 1, 2018 to March 30, 2018 included
NYSE MKT LLC, Cboe BZX Exchange, Inc.; Cboe BYX Exchange, Inc.; Cboe
EDGA Exchange, Inc.; Cboe EDGX Exchange, Inc.; Chicago Stock
Exchange, Inc.; The Investors Exchange LLC; NASDAQ OMX BX, Inc.;
NASDAQ OMX PHLX, Inc.; The Nasdaq Stock Market LLC; New York Stock
Exchange LLC; and NYSE Arca, Inc. NYSE National, Inc. (f.k.a.
National Stock Exchange, Inc.) was not trading, but on May 17, 2018
the Commission approved a proposed rule change in connection with
its relaunch. See supra note 9.
\1320\ Table 2 Sources: (1) FINRA Alternative Trading System
(ATS) Transparency Data is aggregated trade data reported by ATSs to
the FINRA equity trade reporting facilities and made available on
FINRA's website as part of the OTC Transparency Data. The OTC
Transparency data is provided via http://www.finra.org/industry/OTC-Transparency and is copyrighted by FINRA 2018. (2) NYSE Trade and
Quote Database (TAQ).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This table shows 33 ATSs that effected transactions in NMS stocks
from January 1, 2018-March 30, 2018, ranked in descending order by
average trade size. ATS data is reported weekly, and these dates
correspond approximately to the fourth quarter of 2017. Also reported
in this table is the raw number of trades, share volume, dollar volume,
and each NMS Stock ATS's market share of all NMS Stock ATS dollar
volume and NMS Stock ATS share volume. Dollar volume transacted on an
ATS is calculated by multiplying the share volume for a given NMS stock
on the ATS in a given week by the average trade price for that week.
Dollar volume for each NMS stock is then
[[Page 38891]]
aggregated across all NMS stocks that traded on the given ATS in that
week. Average trade size on national securities exchanges is calculated
from TAQ data using intraday trades that took place between 9:30 a.m.
and 4:00 p.m. Bulk trades and trades during the opening and close and
intraday crosses are excluded from the calculation.
One commenter mentions that because the difference in average trade
size between national securities exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs is small,
this is evidence that ``these venues are no longer beneficial for
executing block size trades between large traders.'' \1321\ We do not
agree with the comment that NMS Stock ATSs are no longer beneficial for
executing block size trades. As can be seen in Table 2, eight ATSs have
average trade sizes in excess of 10,000 shares, indicating that these
ATSs are attractive venues for crossing block orders. Based on this, we
believe that some ATSs--particularly ones which have average trade
sizes in excess of 10,000 shares--are beneficial for certain market
participants wanting to trade large block sizes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1321\ See Anonymous Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in more detail in the Proposal,\1322\ while many NMS
Stock ATSs operating today are similar with respect to the limited
transparency they provide with respect to their trading model, we
understand that the services offered vary significantly across NMS
Stock ATSs.\1323\ Even though NMS Stock ATSs may not be privy to
detailed information about the operations of other NMS Stock ATSs, they
are able to garner information about the differential services offered
by their competitors through various means,\1324\ enabling ATSs to
modify their products and services to better compete within the market
for NMS stock execution services. Thus, as explained in more detail in
the Proposal,\1325\ an NMS Stock ATS may not be incented to fully
reveal how orders interact, match and execute on its platform, because
revealing such information adversely impacts the ATS's position within
the market by also informing its competitors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1322\ Proposal, supra note 2, at 81115.
\1323\ Two commenters agree with us. These commenters mention
that some ATSs offer subscribers the ability to customize trading
parameters, including price instructions and counterparty selection,
while others offer subscribers different methods of accessing the
ATS, such as FIX connections or trading through the broker-dealer's
smart order router. See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 4;
ICI Letter at 2-3.
\1324\ These are discussed in more detail in the Proposal. See
Proposal, supra note 2, at 81115.
\1325\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Competition Between Broker-Dealers That Operate NMS Stock ATSs And
Broker-Dealers That Do Not Operate NMS Stock ATSs
As explained in more detail in the Proposal, competition for NMS
stock order flow also exists between the broker-dealers that operate
NMS Stock ATSs and broker-dealers that do not operate NMS Stock ATSs
but otherwise effect transactions in NMS stocks.\1326\ Some broker-
dealers who operate their own NMS Stock ATS(s) may provide their
affiliates with access to certain services that are not afforded to
broker-dealers that do not have their own ATS platform,\1327\ which may
result in trading advantages.\1328\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1326\ See id.
\1327\ A number of commenters state that broker-dealer operators
and their affiliates may have access to certain features of an ATS
that are not available to other subscribers. See Better Markets
Letter at 4-6; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 7-10; HMA
Letter at 13-15; Liquidnet Letter at 11. One of these commenters
states that broker-dealer operators and their affiliates may receive
preferential treatment or access to the ATS, such as faster or more
direct access to the ATS, priority status to execute their orders
over those of other subscribers, or the ability to further customize
with whom their order flow interacts. See Consumer Federation of
America Letter at 8.
\1328\ For further explanation, see Proposal, supra note 2, at
81115.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. Effect of NMS Stock ATSs on the Current Market for NMS Stock
Execution Services
As discussed above, the current market for NMS stock execution
services consists of competition for order flow among national
securities exchanges, NMS Stock ATSs, and broker-dealers who operate or
control non-ATS trading centers.\1329\ This section specifically
discusses the impact that this current market structure for NMS stock
execution services has on trading costs to market participants; the
process by which the price of NMS stocks are determined in the market
(``price discovery''); and market efficiency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1329\ See supra Section X.B.5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Trading Costs
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1330\ some academic
research has suggested that the decline in trading costs since the
adoption of Regulation ATS in 1998 and Regulation NMS in 2005 could, in
part, be driven by the rising fragmentation of trading volume and
competition for order flow, through the proliferation of new trading
venues such as NMS Stock ATSs.\1331\ Trading on NMS Stock ATSs may also
benefit institutional investors \1332\ by providing a useful tool
whereby they may be able to reduce the ``price impact'' of their trades
and obtain enhanced execution quality for their orders.\1333\ Five
commenters also express the belief that the increase in trading on ATSs
has contributed to a competitive marketplace that has led to improved
costs and liquidity, and that this has benefitted both retail and
institutional investors.\1334\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1330\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81115-16.
\1331\ Other academic literature has suggested that the increase
in fragmentation has had a counteracting effect and has increased
bid-ask spreads. This literature, however, has focused on small
stocks, and fragmentation across exchanges, rather than
fragmentation across exchanges and between exchanges and NMS Stock
ATSs. See Haslag, Peter and Matthew Ringgenberg, 2016, ``The Causal
Impact of Market Fragmentation on Market Liquidity,'' working paper,
available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2591715; Baldauf, Markus and Joshua Mollner,
2017, ``Trading in Fragmented Markets,'' working paper, available at
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2782692.
\1332\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81115 (discussing the
impact of NMS Stock ATSs on institutional investor trading costs).
\1333\ One commenter agreed that NMS Stock ATSs, specifically
dark pools, serve a ``useful purpose to those wishing to trade large
blocks of shares at lower cost without moving the public price as a
result of other market participants identifying and trading ahead of
their interest.'' Barnard Letter at 1.
\1334\ See Fidelity Letter at 3; LeveL ATS Letter at 2; Morgan
Stanley Letter at 4; STANY Letter at 2; UBS Letter at 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another element that may affect trading costs is order
internalization by broker-dealers. As described detail in the
Proposal,\1335\ some academic literature has found that internalization
of order flow increases trading costs and reduces market depth and
price informativeness. In the current operational environment of NMS
Stock ATSs, subscribers' orders or other trading interests could be
removed from the broker-dealer's NMS Stock ATS and routed to, among
other destinations, another trading center operated by the broker-
dealer operator for internalization. Thus, the fact that some broker-
dealers operate their own NMS Stock ATSs, and yet internalize some
order flow rather than executing it on their own NMS Stock ATS, may
have a deleterious effect on market quality.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1335\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81117.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The current market for NMS stock execution services--which includes
NMS Stock ATSs--provides value to market participants. If all NMS Stock
ATSs were to cease operating as ATSs, market participants might incur
costs associated with not being able to find an adequate trading venue
that offers benefits similar to those that NMS Stock ATSs provide. To
the extent that market participants value these ATS-specific features,
the decision of certain NMS
[[Page 38892]]
Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs could increase the trading costs
of these market participants and impact whether and how they affect
certain trading strategies.
While the existence of NMS Stock ATSs has reduced the trading costs
on average for market participants, the lack of transparency regarding
ATS operations and the ATS-related activities of the ATS broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates has contributed to higher search costs for
market participants to find a trading venue that serves their investing
or trading objectives. A by-product of these higher search costs is
uncertainty pertaining to how their orders will be handled,
particularly for subscribers to NMS Stock ATSs that have not made their
Form ATS public.\1336\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1336\ Several commenters agree with our analysis that the
differences have resulted in higher search costs for market
participants. See Better Markets Letter at 2; CFA Institute Letter
at 2; Consumer Federation of America Letter at 2-4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Price Discovery
While the increased fragmentation of trading volume associated with
the current market for NMS stock execution services has been a factor
in lowering trading costs for market participants, the academic
literature has found that it has had a mixed impact on price discovery.
As described in more detail in the Proposal,\1337\ some academic
studies have suggested that the market segmentation caused by the
coexistence of national securities exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs can
improve price discovery.\1338\ They suggest that price discovery can
improve either as a result of more aggressive competition among market
participants in providing liquidity or as a result of the segmentation
of informed and uninformed market participants.\1339\ These academic
studies predict that because the orders of informed market participants
are more likely to execute on national securities exchanges, they will
be more likely to trade on national securities exchanges and uninformed
market participants will be more likely to trade on NMS Stock
ATSs.\1340\ Because informed market participants have better knowledge
about the value of a security than uninformed market participants, this
segmentation can improve price discovery on national securities
exchanges.\1341\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1337\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81116-17.
\1338\ See Boulatov, Alex, and Thomas George, 2013, ``Hidden and
Displayed Liquidity in Securities Markets with Informed Liquidity
Providers,'' Review of Financial Studies 26, 2095-2137; Comerton-
Forde, Carole and Talis Putnins, 2015, ``Dark Trading and Price
Discovery,'' Journal of Financial Economics 118, 70-92.; and Zhu,
Haoxiang, 2014, ``Do Dark Pools Harm Price Discovery?'' Review of
Financial Studies 27, 747-789. Comerton-Forde and Putnins (2015) and
Zhu (2014) specifically examine dark pools.
\1339\ Uninformed market participants trade for non-
informational reasons. In some cases, they are termed ``noise
traders,'' since their trades are based on their beliefs and
sentiments, and are not grounded on fundamental information. See
Vishwanath, Ramanna and Chandrasekhar Krishnamurti, 2009,
``Investment Management: A Modern Guide to Security Analysis and
Stock Selection,'' Springer Publishing.
\1340\ See Proposal, supra note2, at 81116 (discussing the
segmentation of trading by informed and uninformed market
participants between national securities exchanges and ATSs).
\1341\ See Comerton-Forde and Putnins (2015) and Zhu (2014),
supra note 1338.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other academic studies suggest that the presence of NMS Stock ATSs
in the current trading environment can harm price discovery.\1342\
These studies have suggested that because some NMS Stock ATSs are
crossing networks and often derive their prices from national
securities exchanges, price impact costs that result from trading on a
national securities exchange harm prices on NMS Stock ATSs, resulting
in less trading and harming price discovery.\1343\ When trading,
informed market participants often balance two types of costs, namely
price impact costs and execution costs. In comparison to NMS Stock
ATSs, on national securities exchanges an informed market participant's
order experiences lower execution risk but higher price impact costs.
However, since NMS Stock ATSs often match orders at prices derived from
national securities exchanges, and if trading on national securities
exchanges generates worse prices due to price impact, this could spill
over and affect a market participant's profit on trades executed on the
NMS Stock ATS. This spillover could result in informed market
participants trading less aggressively, which could in turn reduce
price discovery.\1344\ One academic study finds, while low levels of
trading on NMS Stock ATSs are not harmful, price discovery is harmed
when levels of trading on NMS Stock ATSs are high (i.e., they estimate
that this occurs when trading on NMS Stock ATSs in a given NMS stock
exceeds approximately 10% of dollar volume).\1345\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1342\ See Ye, Mao, 2011, ``A Glimpse into the Dark: Price
Formation, Transaction Cost and Market Share of the Crossing
Network,'' working paper, available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1521494; Degryse, Hans, Frank de Jong and
Vincent van Kervel, 2015, ``The Impact of Dark Trading and Visible
Fragmentation on Market Quality,'' Review of Finance 19, 1587-1622;
Comerton-Forde and Putnins (2015), supra note1338. These studies
specifically examine dark pools.
\1343\ One commenter agrees with the conclusions from these
studies and remarked that trading on NMS Stock ATSs ``reduces the
information that could assist the transparent market in determining
an accurate fair price'' and that prices quoted on transparent
markets may no longer be efficient or informative. See Barnard
Letter at 1-3.
\1344\ See Ye (2011), supra note1342.
\1345\ See Comerton-Forde and Putnins (2015), supra note 1338.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Market Efficiency
Currently, the coexistence of national securities exchanges and NMS
Stock ATSs seems to have beneficial effects on market efficiency. One
academic study suggests that while not all trades that execute on NMS
Stock ATSs are large block trades, those that are have been beneficial
to market efficiency.\1346\ If NMS Stock ATSs were not a viable trading
venue for market participants, some market participants might not
execute large orders at all because of the price impact costs of
executing on a national securities exchange. Therefore, the ability for
market participants to execute large trades on NMS Stock ATSs generates
liquidity, which can improve market efficiency.\1347\ The same study
also suggests that small trades that execute on NMS Stock ATSs are
beneficial in that they also generate market efficiency.\1348\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1346\ See id.
\1347\ A number of academic studies have found that increased
liquidity can improve market efficiency by reducing the limits to
arbitrage or increasing the incentives to produce costly
information. See Chordia, Tarun, Richard Roll and Avanidhar
Subrahmanyam, 2008, ``Liquidity and market efficiency,'' Journal of
Financial Economics 97, 249-268; Kyle, Albert, 1984, ``Market
structure, information, futures markets, and price formation,'' Gary
G. Storey, Andrew Schmitz, and Alexander H. Sarris (Editors.),
International Agricultural Trade: Advanced Readings in Price
Formation, Market Structure, and Price Instability, Westview Press,
Boulder and London (1984), pp. 45-64.
\1348\ See Comerton-Forde and Putnins (2015), supra note 1338.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Several commenters assert that the lack of transparency of NMS
Stock ATSs has resulted in a decrease in market efficiency because more
order flow executed on NMS Stock ATSs increases the difficulty
investors face when identifying which venues offer them the best
execution quality.\1349\ As discussed above, increased market
fragmentation could increase search costs by making it more difficult
for market participants to find liquidity to execute their
orders.\1350\ Increased search costs could reduce competition between
liquidity suppliers, which could increase trading costs.\1351\ These
increased trading costs could reduce the incentives for market
participants to acquire costly information, which could in turn result
[[Page 38893]]
in a reduction in market efficiency.\1352\ However, as discussed above,
the increased market fragmentation caused by NMS Stock ATSs could also
improve market efficiency by allowing institutional investors a viable
way to trade and reduce price impact costs.\1353\ The commenters did
not provide any analysis to support their claims that the increase in
order flow executed on NMS Stock ATSs has decreased market efficiency.
As such, we continue to believe that the current market for NMS stock
execution services, consisting of national securities exchanges, ATSs
and other off-exchange venues, has together resulted in an improvement
to market efficiency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1349\ See Barnard Letter at 1-3; Better Markets Letter at 2.
\1350\ See supra Section X.B.6.a.
\1351\ See Yin, Xiangkang, 2005, ``A Comparison of Centralized
and Fragmented Markets with Costly Search,'' Journal of Finance, 60,
1567-1590.
\1352\ See Kyle, Albert, 1989, ``Information speculation with
imperfect competition,'' Review of Economic Studies 56, 317-356.
\1353\ See supra Section X.B.6.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Economic Effects and Effects on Efficiency, Competition, and Capital
Formation
We have considered the economic effects of new Rule 304, Form ATS-N
and the amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS. This section
provides an overview of the economic effects of new Rule 304, Form ATS-
N, and the amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS, including
the costs, benefits, and the effects on efficiency, competition, and
capital formation. This section also discusses additional economic
effects, including benefits and costs related to specific requirements
of new Rule 304, Form ATS-N and the amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and
Regulation ATS.
We believe that the amendments will improve Commission oversight
and thereby improve investor protection and generate greater
transparency about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related
activities of their broker-dealer operators and their affiliates.\1354\
As explained below, through these effects, the adopted amendments may
promote greater competition for order flow, which could result in
enhanced execution quality, and we believe that this could result in
improvements to efficiency and capital formation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1354\ See supra Sections V.C-D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We have attempted, where possible, to quantify the benefits and
costs and impacts on efficiency, competition, and capital information
that may result from new Rule 304, Form ATS-N, and the amendments to
Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS. However, as we discussed in the
Proposal and as explained more fully below,\1355\ it is difficult to
quantify many of the economic effects of the new rule and amendments
due to the complexity of the market for NMS execution services and our
lack of certain relevant information. For instance, it is difficult to
determine what fraction of order flow will be internalized or routed to
national securities exchanges or to non-ATS trading centers if NMS
Stock ATSs are required to publicly disclose information about their
operations on Form ATS-N. Additionally, we do not have certain
information, such as information on market participant routing
agreements or fee arrangements that may influence future order routing
decisions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1355\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81118.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As we further noted in the Proposal, it is similarly difficult to
determine whether NMS Stock ATSs will continue or cease operating as
ATSs in light of the new rule and amendments,\1356\ as that decision
depends on numerous factors and we lack information about many of those
factors. For example, we do not have information on the extent to which
existing NMS Stock ATSs or potentially new ATSs rely on a competitive
advantage, such as a unique matching methodology or other operational
characteristics, to attract order flow, or the extent to which the new
disclosure requirements will impact those competitive advantages and
thus drive decisions on operating status. Moreover, we lack information
on how many NMS Stock ATSs may decide to register as national
securities exchanges, as some ECNs have in previous years, as a result
of new Rule 304, Form ATS-N and the amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and
Regulation ATS.\1357\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1356\ For the purposes of the PRA, we estimate the annual
average number of NMS Stock ATSs that file Cessation of Operation
notices on Form ATS-N. See supra Section IX.D.2.b.ii.C. This
estimate is based on the historical number of cessations per year
and, while recognizing that the amendments may result in cessations,
does not attempt to predict the effect of the amendments on the
number of cessations.
\1357\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81109 (discussing ATSs
that previously operated as ECNs and subsequently registered as
national securities exchanges).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters did not provide any additional information or analysis
that would allow us to estimate the impacts on order flow or the
continued operation of NMS Stock ATSs under the new rule and
amendments. In light of the complexities of the market and the lack of
currently available information, we are unable to quantify many of the
economic effects of new Rule 304, Form ATS-N, and the amendments to
Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS. Therefore, much of the discussion
below is qualitative in nature, although we try to describe, where
possible, the direction of these effects.
1. Economic Effects of Enhanced Filing Requirements of Form ATS-N
As discussed above, we are amending Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation
ATS to require ATSs that transact in NMS stocks to comply with the
requirements of Rule 304 to operate pursuant to the exemption from the
definition of ``exchange.'' \1358\ The amendments would require an NMS
Stock ATS to file reports pursuant to Rule 304, which includes the
requirement to file Form ATS-N, in lieu of current Form ATS, to
disclose information about its operations and the ATS-related
activities of its broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.\1359\ We
believe that these disclosures will help market participants assess
whether the ATS's mode of operation is consistent with their ability to
obtain the best executions and also help them assess potential
conflicts of interest that might adversely impact their trading on the
NMS Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1358\ See supra Section III.A. See also Rules 3a1-1(a)(2) and
(3), 300, 301, and 304.
\1359\ See supra Section V for information disclosed on Form
ATS-N.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 304 will also provide a process by which the Commission will
review initial Forms ATS-N and Form ATS-N amendments and declare them
ineffective if it finds that such action is necessary or appropriate in
the public interest, and is consistent with the protection of
investors. We are also adopting a process by which the Commission could
suspend, limit, or revoke an NMS Stock ATS's exemption from the
definition of an ``exchange'' under Rule 3a1-1(a)(2).\1360\ An NMS
Stock ATS could not operate pursuant to the exemption from the
definition of ``exchange'' unless the NMS Stock ATS files Form ATS-N
with the Commission and the Form ATS-N has become effective.\1361\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1360\ See supra Section IV.E (discussing the public posting
requirements of Form ATS-N).
\1361\ See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Benefits
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1362\ we believe that new
Rule 304, Form ATS-N and the amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation
ATS would result in better regulatory oversight of NMS Stock ATSs and
increased investor protection by providing the Commission and relevant
SROs with information about NMS Stock ATSs that currently may only be
available during an examination process. In comparison to Form
[[Page 38894]]
ATS,\1363\ Form ATS-N will contain more detailed information about the
operations of NMS Stock ATSs, including information about the ATS-
related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates.\1364\ The Commission and SROs could utilize this
information to help prioritize examinations and possibly help identify
potential issues. Additionally, the enhanced disclosure requirements
under Form ATS-N will provide market participants with significantly
more detailed information with which to analyze and evaluate how orders
are handled and executed on NMS Stock ATSs, which could allow them to
better assess an NMS Stock ATS as a potential trading venue.\1365\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1362\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81119-20.
\1363\ See supra Section II.C (discussing the Form ATS filing
requirements).
\1364\ See supra Section V for information disclosed on ATS-N.
\1365\ Three commenters agreed with our assessment that the
enhanced disclosure requirements under Form ATS-N would result in
improved regulatory oversight by the Commission. See Fidelity Letter
at 1; SIFMA Letter at 3; Virtu Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also adopting a requirement that Form ATS-N and Form ATS-N
amendments be filed electronically in a XML text-searchable format. We
believe that requiring Form ATS-N and Form ATS-N amendments to be filed
in a XML text-searchable format, coupled with the enhanced disclosure
requirements, will facilitate a more effective and thorough review and
analysis of NMS Stock ATSs by regulators, which should yield greater
insights into the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related
activities of their broker-dealer operators and their affiliates. Such
benefits could increase investor protection by improving the
effectiveness and efficiency of the examination process.
We believe that the process of reviewing an initial Form ATS-N or
Form ATS-N amendments will allow the Commission to evaluate, among
other things, the completeness and comprehensibility of the NMS Stock
ATSs' disclosures and, if necessary, declare the Form ATS-N
ineffective.\1366\ We believe that the review and public disclosure
process will improve the quality of information the Commission receives
from NMS Stock ATSs, which will allow the Commission to better protect
investors from potentially incomprehensible or incomplete disclosures
that would misinform market participants about the operations of an NMS
Stock ATS or the ATS-related activities of its broker-dealer
operator.\1367\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1366\ See supra Section IV.A.4 (describing the effectiveness
process for initial Form ATS-N filings).
\1367\ One commenter agrees that our enhanced regulatory
oversight can help ensure consistency of disclosures provided by
ATSs and their broker-dealer operators. See Fidelity Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We received several comment letters regarding whether the proposed
amendments would adequately protect investors. One commenter was
optimistic, stating the amendments are aimed at ``bolstering
transparency in capital markets, which should enable and enhance
investor protections.'' \1368\ Three commenters were not as optimistic.
One commenter states that the Commission review process for Form ATS-N
``will very quickly devolve into an unreasonably burdensome exercise
for Commission staff while providing little benefit to market integrity
or investor protection.'' \1369\ Another commenter mentions that ``no
amount of required public disclosure can cure the problem presented by
an ATS that makes inaccurate disclosures to subscribers.'' \1370\ A
third states that no amount of disclosure can provide the necessary
protection against broker-dealer conflicts of interest, and that more
needs to be done to protect investors.\1371\ We continue to believe
that increased regulatory oversight and disclosure of NMS Stock ATS
operations and activities would help protect investors. We expect that
the quality of the information the Commission receives from NMS Stock
ATSs will improve as a result of the incentives created by the
procedure to review their filings and declare them ineffective, if
necessary, and that the incidences of incomplete and incomprehensible
disclosures would be mitigated. As market participants will not be able
to trade on NMS Stocks ATSs that do not comply with Form ATS-N
requirements, the review process will protect investors from events
that may have transpired if ATSs, whose Forms ATS-N have been declared
ineffective, were allowed to trade NMS stocks. Additionally, we
continue to believe that the disclosure of broker-dealer conflicts of
interest will allow market participants to better assess an NMS Stock
ATS as a potential trading venue and thus better protect their
interests.\1372\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1368\ See CFA Institute Letter at 6.
\1369\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 10.
\1370\ See Fidelity Letter at 4.
\1371\ See Better Markets Letter at 1, 5-6.
\1372\ See infra Section X.C.2.a (``Economic Effects of Public
Disclosure of Form ATS-N--Benefits'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Costs
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1373\ we believe that the
filing requirements of Form ATS-N could impose costs on NMS Stock ATSs.
We recognize that an ineffectiveness declaration could impose costs on
an NMS Stock ATS--such as costs from having to cease operations, roll
back a change in operations, or delay the start of operations--and
could impose costs on individual market participants and the overall
market for NMS stock execution services resulting from a potential
reduction in competition or the removal of a sole provider of a niche
service within the market.\1374\ However, NMS Stock ATSs and market
participants would not incur these costs unless the Commission declares
a Form ATS-N or a Form ATS-N amendment ineffective. We believe that NMS
Stock ATSs would be incentivized to comply with the requirements of
Form ATS-N, as well as federal securities laws, including the other
requirements of Regulation ATS, to avoid an ineffectiveness
declaration, which produces benefits to the market. Therefore, we
believe that NMS Stock ATSs would be incentivized to submit Form ATS-N
disclosures that are complete and comprehensive to avoid bearing the
costs of resubmitting a Form ATS-N filing or of having their Form ATS-N
declared ineffective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1373\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81120-21.
\1374\ See infra Section X.C.4.a (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Competition'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We also understand that both new and existing NMS Stock ATSs will
incur implementation costs in order to comply with the amendments to
Regulation ATS. NMS Stock ATSs will need to develop internal processes
to ensure correct and complete reporting on Form ATS-N, which can be
viewed as a fixed setup cost, which NMS Stock ATSs may have to incur,
regardless of the amount of trading activity that takes place on them.
As a result, these implementation costs will fall more heavily on
lower-dollar volume NMS Stock ATSs (as opposed to ATSs transacting
greater dollar volume), because these ATSs have a smaller revenue base
to accommodate the largely fixed implementation costs. However, smaller
NMS Stock ATSs that are not operated by multi-service broker-dealer
operators and do not engage in other brokerage or dealing activities in
addition to their NMS Stock ATSs will likely incur lower implementation
costs because certain sections of Form ATS-N (such as
[[Page 38895]]
several items of Part II) will not be applicable to these NMS Stock
ATSs.
In addition to affecting NMS Stock ATSs, the implementation costs
could also indirectly affect market participants by potentially causing
some NMS Stock ATSs to alter or reduce the services they offer to
certain subscribers. For example, the adopted amendments might cause
some NMS Stock ATSs to reduce or stop offering customized reports to
certain subscribers in order to redirect resources to support the
standardized reports.
Relative to the baseline, the amendments to Regulation ATS will
also impose implementation costs for all NMS Stock ATSs, including
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, in that they will require NMS Stock ATSs to
adhere to heightened disclosure and reporting requirements regarding
their operations. Legacy NMS Stock ATSs should already comply with the
current requirements of Regulation ATS. Therefore, the compliance costs
of the amendments should be incremental relative to the costs
associated with the existing requirements. Specifically, we believe
that the incremental costs will consist largely of providing new
disclosures and updating records and retention policies necessary to
comply with the amendments. Based on the analysis for purposes of the
PRA,\1375\ we estimate that the amendments to Regulation ATS relating
to Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS, including Form ATS-
N, will result in a one-time burden of 127.4 hours for each NMS Stock
ATS,\1376\ which will result in an estimated one-time paperwork
compliance cost to an NMS Stock ATS of approximately $41,689.10.\1377\
This will result in an aggregate estimated initial hour burden for all
NMS Stock ATSs to complete Form ATS-N and comply with Rules
301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS of 5,223.4 hours at an
estimated cost of $1,709,253.10.\1378\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1375\ See supra Section IX (estimating burden hours). We
estimate the wage rate associated with these burden hours based on
salary information for the securities industry compiled by SIFMA.
The estimated wage figure for attorneys, for example, is based on
published rates for attorneys, modified to account for a 1,800-hour
work-year and multiplied by 5.35 to account for bonuses, firm size,
employee benefits, and overhead, yielding an effective hourly rate
for 2013 of $380 for attorneys. See Securities Industry and
Financial Markets Association, Management & Professional Earnings in
the Securities Industry--2013, available at: https://www.sifma.org/resources/research/management-and-professional-earnings-in-the-securities-industry-2013/. These estimates are adjusted for an
inflation rate of 6.85% based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics data
on CPI-U between October 2013 and March 2018. Therefore, the current
inflation-adjusted effective hourly wage rates for attorneys are
estimated at $406 ($380 x 1.0685). We discuss other costs of
compliance with the proposed rule below.
\1376\ See supra note 1228 and accompanying text.
\1377\ (Attorney at $406 x 54.1 hours) + (Chief Compliance
Manager at $518 x 0.5 hours) + (Compliance Manager at $302 x 33.9
hours) + (Senior Systems Analyst at $278 x 30.25 hours) + (Senior
Marketing Manager at $298 x 1 hour) + (Compliance Clerk at $68 x
7.65 hours) = $41,689.10. This compliance cost estimate for a Form
ATS-N includes the estimated costs associated with completing Part
III Items 24 and 25 of Form ATS-N, but as explained above, we
believe that the majority of NMS Stock ATSs would not be required to
complete those items of the form. See supra Section IX.D.2.b.i.C.
\1378\ 127.4 burden hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 5,223.4 burden
hours. $41,689.10 x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = $1,709,253.10. This
preliminary aggregate compliance cost estimate assumes that all NMS
Stock ATSs would be required to complete Part III Items 24 and 25 of
Form ATS-N. However, as noted above, we estimate that 1 NMS Stock
ATS would be required to complete Part III, Item 24, see supra
Section IX.D.2.b.i.C, and 2 NMS Stock ATSs would be required to
complete Part III, Item 25, see id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to the implementation costs mentioned above, there are
also expected ongoing costs for NMS Stock ATSs to comply with the
amendments to Rule 3a1-1(a) and Regulation ATS. For instance, NMS Stock
ATSs will incur ongoing costs associated with amending their Form ATS-N
prior to material changes in their operations, or to correct any
material information that has become inaccurate. Regardless of the
reason for filing a Form ATS-N amendment, we estimate for the purposes
of the PRA that it will take an NMS Stock ATS approximately 28.2 hours
annually \1379\ to prepare and file its Form ATS-N amendments at an
estimated annual cost of $8,898.60 per ATS.\1380\ This will result in
an estimated aggregate ongoing hour burden for all NMS Stock ATSs to
amend their Forms ATS-N and comply with Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304
of Regulation ATS of 1,156.2 hours at an estimated cost of $364,842.60
annually.\1381\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1379\ See supra Section IX.D.2.b.ii.B. As explained above, we
estimate that each NMS Stock ATS would file 3 Form ATS-N amendments
per year, and the hourly burden per amendment would be 9.4 hours.
\1380\ (Attorney at $406 x 16.5 hours) + (Compliance Manager at
$302 x 6 hours) + (Compliance Clerk at $68 x 5.7 hours) = $8,898.60.
\1381\ 28.2 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 1,156.2 hours. $8.898.60
x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = $364,842.60.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some existing NMS Stock ATSs that also trade non-NMS stocks might
incur additional costs due to the amendments. As discussed above,\1382\
pursuant to the amendments to Regulation ATS, an ATS that trades both
NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks will be subject to the requirements of
Rule 304 with respect to its NMS stock trading operations and Rule
301(b)(2) with respect to its non-NMS stock trading operations.
Accordingly, NMS Stock ATSs that also transact in non-NMS stocks will
incur additional implementation costs when compared to ATSs that only
trade NMS stocks, because the former group will be required to file
both Form ATS-N and a revised Form ATS that removes discussion of those
aspects of the ATS related to the trading of NMS stocks. Those NMS
Stock ATSs will also be required to file a pair of Forms ATS-R four
times annually. For the purposes of the PRA, we estimate that the
aggregate initial burden for those ATSs to separately file an initial
Form ATS-N in regard to their NMS stock trading activity and a current
Form ATS in regard to their non-NMS stock trading activity will be
1,774 hours \1383\ at an aggregate estimated cost of $474,431.\1384\ We
also estimate that the aggregate annual burden to file separate Forms
ATS-R for those ATSs that effect transactions in both NMS stocks and
non-NMS stocks will be 180 hours \1385\ at an aggregate estimated cost
of $59,560.\1386\ Furthermore, we estimate that these ATSs that
facilitate transactions in both NMS stocks and non-NMS stocks will
incur an additional estimated recordkeeping burden of 3 hours annually
per ATS, resulting in an estimated cost of $333.96 per ATS \1387\ and
an aggregate estimated hour burden of 30 hours at an estimated cost of
$3,339.60, due to the amendments to Rule 303(a)(2)(ii).\1388\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1382\ See supra Section IX.D.2.b.iii.
\1383\ See supra note 1255 and accompanying text.
\1384\ ((Attorney for Form ATS at $406 x 13 hours) + (Attorney
for Form ATS-N at $406 x 54.1 hours) + (Chief Compliance Manager for
Form ATS-N at $518 x 0.5 hours) + (Compliance Manager for Form ATS-N
at $302 x 33.9 hours) + (Senior Systems Analyst for Form ATS-N at
$278 x 30.25 hours) + (Senior Marketing Manager for Form ATS-N at
$298 x 1 hour) + (Compliance Clerk for Form ATS at $68 x 7 hours) +
(Compliance Clerk for Form ATS-N at $68 x 7.65 hours)) x 10 ATSs =
$474,431. This aggregate compliance cost estimate includes the
estimated costs associated with completing Part III, Items 24 and 25
of Form ATS-N, but as explained above, we believe that the majority
of NMS Stock ATSs would not be required to complete those items of
the form. See supra Section IX.D.2.b.i.C.
\1385\ See supra note 1258 and accompanying text.
\1386\ ((Attorney at $406 x 3.5 hours) + (Compliance Clerk at
$68 x 1 hours) x (4 filings annually)) x 10 ATSs = $59,560.
\1387\ At an average cost per burden hour of $111.32, see supra
note 1265, the resultant total related cost of compliance for each
ATS would be $333.96 ((3 burden hours) x $111.32/hour).
\1388\ 3 hours x 10 ATSs = 30 burden hours. $333.96 x 10 ATSs =
$3,339.60. See supra Section IX.D.2.b.vi.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The amendments to Regulation ATS will require Form ATS-N be filed
electronically in a structured format
[[Page 38896]]
through EDGAR.\1389\ Based on the widespread use and availability of
the internet, we believe that filing Form ATS-N in an electronic format
will be less burdensome and a more efficient filing process than the
current paper process for NMS Stock ATSs and the Commission, as it is
likely to be less expensive and cumbersome than mailing and filing
paper forms to the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1389\ See supra Section VII (Section in the front-end which
specifically discusses structured disclosure aspects of Form ATS-N).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In order to electronically file a Form ATS-N, a broker-dealer
operator of an NMS Stock ATS will need to access the EDGAR system. As
discussed above,\1390\ a broker-dealer that has not previously received
access to EDGAR would need to submit a Form ID.\1391\ For the purposes
of the PRA, we estimate that each ATS that needs to submit a Form ID to
gain access to EDGAR will incur a one-time burden of 0.15 hours, which
would result in each ATS incurring a one-time estimated cost of
$45.30.\1392\ Based on analysis in the PRA, we estimate that each year
1 new NMS Stock ATS will be operated by an entity that needs to submit
a Form ID to gain access to EDGAR.\1393\ This would result in an
aggregate estimated initial burden of 0.15 hours at an estimated cost
of $45.30.\1394\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1390\ See supra Section IX.D.2.b.iv.
\1391\ See id (discussing Central Index Key (``CIK'') numbers).
\1392\ Compliance Manager at $302 x 0.15 hours = $45.30.
\1393\ Because all ATSs, regardless of whether they trade NMS
stocks, are operated by registered broker-dealers who have been
assigned a CIK number, for the purposes of the PRA, we estimate that
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs or non-NMS Stock ATSs that later decide to
trade NMS stocks will not incur any costs associated with gaining
access to EDGAR. See supra Section IX.D.2.b.iv.
\1394\ 0.15 burden hours x 1 NMS Stock ATS = 0.15 burden hours.
$45.30 x 1 NMS Stock ATS = $45.30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 304(b)(3) will require each NMS Stock ATS to make public via
posting on the NMS Stock ATS's website, a direct URL hyperlink to the
Commission's website that contains the documents enumerated in Rule
304(b)(2). For the purposes of the PRA, we estimate that each NMS Stock
ATS will incur an initial, one-time burden of approximately 2 hours to
program and configure its website in order to post the required direct
URL hyperlink pursuant to Rule 304(b)(3),\1395\ which will result in
each NMS Stock ATS incurring an estimated one-time cost of
approximately $556.\1396\ This will result in an aggregate estimated
initial, one-time hour burden for all NMS Stock ATSs to comply with
Rule 304(b)(3) of approximately 82 hours at an estimated cost of
approximately $22,796.\1397\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1395\ See supra Section IX.D.2.b.v.
\1396\ Senior Systems Analyst at $278 x 2 hours = $556.
\1397\ 2 hours x 41 NMS Stock ATSs = 82 hours. $556 x 41 NMS
Stock ATSs = $22,796.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Economic Effects of Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N
We believe that the amendments requiring public disclosure of Form
ATS-N will improve the information available to market participants and
make that information consistent, which would assist market
participants in evaluating and choosing the NMS Stock ATSs to which
they may route orders or become a subscriber due to the enhanced
disclosure requirements. Requiring such public disclosure will increase
the operational transparency requirements of NMS Stock ATSs to bring
those requirements more in line with the operational transparency
requirements of national securities exchanges.\1398\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1398\ See supra Section III.A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Benefits
We believe that the public disclosure of Form ATS-N will generate
greater transparency about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs and the
ATS-related activities of their broker-dealer operators and their
affiliates. This will aid market participants by reducing search costs
when evaluating potential NMS stock trading venues to decide which
venue best suits their trading purposes. This section discusses
specific economic benefits of the public disclosure of Form ATS-N
including: The economic benefits of public disclosure of standardized
information about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs; the economic
benefits of public disclosure of the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates; the economic benefits of
public disclosure of aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution
statistics regarding the NMS Stock ATS; and the economic benefits of
filing Form ATS-N in a structured format.
(i) Benefits of Public Disclosure of Standardized Information of
Operations of NMS Stock ATSs
We believe that requiring detailed, public disclosures about the
operations of NMS Stock ATSs will, among other things, better
standardize the type of information market participants receive about
those operations. As a result, search costs for market participants
will be lower relative to the baseline, as homogenous disclosure
requirements for all NMS Stock ATSs as part of the amendments to
Regulation ATS should facilitate market participants' comparison of NMS
Stock ATSs when deciding which venue most suits their trading purposes.
Accordingly, as described in detail in the Proposal,\1399\ we believe
the enhanced operational transparency resulting from the public
disclosures on Form ATS-N should aid market participants when
evaluating potential trading venues, and that the requirement for NMS
Stock ATSs to disclose whether and how they segment their order flow,
any criteria used to assign order flow, and their fee structures should
provide market participants with a better understanding of the
operating environment for NMS Stock ATSs.\1400\ Beyond providing
benefits to market participants, the enhanced disclosure requirements
for NMS Stock ATSs could provide benefits to certain NMS Stock ATSs or
national securities exchanges.\1401\ Since the establishment of
Regulation ATS, the market for order execution services for trading NMS
stocks--particularly on ATSs--has flourished. The number of ATSs that
trade NMS stocks has increased substantially since the inception of
Regulation ATS, and as of the end of the first quarter of 2018, trading
volume of NMS stocks on ATSs accounted for 11.4% of total share
volume.\1402\ As they are expected to calibrate the level of
transparency between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges,
the amendments could foster greater competition for order flow of NMS
stocks between these trading platforms. This greater competition for
order flow could in turn incentivize NMS Stock ATSs to innovate--
particularly in terms of their technology--so that they can attract
more trading volume to their venue.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1399\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81123-24.
\1400\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81123 (discussing the
effects of the increased public disclosures about the operations of
NMS Stock ATSs on market participant search costs).
\1401\ See id (discussing the effects of the increased public
disclosures about the operations of NMS Stock ATSs on certain NMS
Stock ATSs).
\1402\ See supra Section X.B.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter states that ``[f]ailing to extend enhanced
transparency requirements to Exchanges for activities commensurate with
those of ATSs would result in an incomplete picture of market quality,
making it difficult for investors to conduct meaningful comparisons to
inform their decisions and protect their own interests.'' \1403\ As
discussed above,\1404\ national securities exchanges are already
subject to more stringent public disclosure requirements than NMS Stock
ATSs. For example,
[[Page 38897]]
national securities exchanges are required to publicly file proposed
rule changes with the Commission to disclose, among other things, their
manner of operations and fees.\1405\ These proposed rules changes are
subject to notice and comment from the public, as well as Commission
consideration, pursuant to Section 19(b) and Rule 19b-4.\1406\
Therefore, we continue to believe that the adopted amendments would
reduce the discrepancy in the level of transparency between NMS Stock
ATSs and national securities exchanges, thereby assisting market
participants in making more informed trading decisions and providing
them with a clearer understanding about where to route their orders in
order to receive best execution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1403\ See Markit Letter at 4.
\1404\ See supra Section X.B.5.a.
\1405\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81011.
\1406\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adopted amendments modify the process for publicly disclosing a
material amendment to a Form ATS-N from the process originally detailed
in the Proposal.\1407\ We proposed in Rule 304(b)(2)(iv) making all
amendments to Form ATS-N, including material amendments, public upon
filing.\1408\ In response to commenters' concerns that making public
Form ATS-N material amendments before expiration of the Commission's
30-day calendar review period could stifle innovation or be confusing
or misleading to the public,\1409\ we are modifying the proposed rules
for making Form ATS-N material amendments public. Under the adopted
amendments, the cover page of the filed material amendment will be made
public by the Commission upon filing and, unless the Commission
declares the material amendment ineffective, the entirety of the
material amendment, as amended, will be made public by the Commission
following the expiration of the Commission's 30-calendar day review
period.\1410\ The cover page would provide a brief narrative about the
content of the amendment including: The Part and Item number of Form
ATS-N that is subject to the change, whether or not such change will
apply to all subscribers and the broker-dealer operator, and a brief
summary of the change. Although the adopted process for material
amendments would not provide market participants with as much
transparency about a forthcoming material change to the operations of
the NMS Stock ATS as the proposed process, we believe that the adopted
process will provide increased transparency, relative to the baseline,
to market participants about a material change during the Commission
review period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1407\ See supra Section IV.B.1.a (discussing Form ATS-N
material amendments).
\1408\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81034.
\1409\ See supra Section IV.E.2.c.
\1410\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) Benefits of Public Disclosure of the ATS-Related Activities of the
Broker-Dealer Operator and Its Affiliates
Most NMS Stock ATSs are operated by broker-dealers that also engage
in other brokerage and dealing activities.\1411\ A broker-dealer
operator of an NMS Stock ATS, or its affiliates, could have business
interests that conflict with the interests of its ATS's
subscribers,\1412\ or customers of its subscribers.\1413\ As described
in more detail in the Proposal,\1414\ we believe that public disclosure
of detailed information about the ATS-related activities of the broker-
dealer operator and its affiliates on Form ATS-N will allow market
participants to better evaluate any conflicts of interest that may
arise from such activities, allowing market participants to better
determine whether submitting order flow to a particular NMS Stock ATS
aligns with their business interests.\1415\ Further, the enhanced
disclosure requirements could discourage broker-dealer operators from
trading internally as principal in their NMS Stock ATS under
circumstances where the trading might raise conflict of interest
concerns, because those operations will be subject to public scrutiny
by market participants.\1416\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1411\ See supra Section II.A.2.
\1412\ Based on information provided on Form ATS, a small number
of ATSs solely limit their broker-dealer business to the operation
of an ATS.
\1413\ One commenter states that unavoidable conflicts of
interest arise if an operator (or its affiliates) engages in
principal trading activities within the ATS or if it is informed by
others' trading activities within the ATS. See HMA Letter at 13.
Another commenter states ``conflicts of interest arising from the
operational complexities of ATSs, including the dual roles of the
broker-dealer as ATS operators and as brokers, proliferated, all
while remaining invisible to investors.'' Better Markets Letter at
2.
\1414\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81124-25.
\1415\ A number of commenters generally agree with us that
increased standardized information about the manner of operations of
the broker-dealer that operates the NMS Stock ATS and potential
conflicts of interest that may arise with its affiliates may better
enable market participants to evaluate the extent to which
individual trading venues align with their investment and trading
decisions. See Fidelity Letter at 1; ICI Letter at 3; KCG Letter at
1; MFA/AIMA Letter at 2; PDQ Letter at 2; SIFMA Letter at 4-8.
\1416\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81124 (discussing the
effects of the public disclosure of the ATS-related activities of
the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adopted amendments modify the requests for information on Form
ATS-N regarding the activities of the NMS Stock ATS broker-dealer
operator and its affiliates from those in Proposed Form ATS-N.\1417\ In
response to commenters' concerns that the scope of the requests in Part
III of proposed Form ATS-N are too broad (especially for large,
multiservice broker-dealers) and might require information about the
broker-dealer operator's and its affiliates' activities that do not
directly relate to the NMS Stock ATS, we are modifying certain requests
on proposed Form ATS-N to solicit information from NMS Stock ATSs that
focus on (1) the ability of the business units or affiliates of the
broker-dealer operator to enter, or direct the entry of, orders into
the NMS Stock ATS; and (2) whether those business units and affiliates
receive any preferential treatment with respect to the services offered
by the NMS Stock ATS, including any special access to information about
trading interest.\1418\ This differs from the Proposal primarily with
regard to the proposed requests for information about the trading
centers of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates that did not
transact on the NMS Stock ATS. For example, Part III, Item 1 of
proposed Form ATS-N would have required an NMS Stock ATS to disclose
whether the broker-dealer operator or any of its affiliates operate or
control any non-ATS trading center(s) that is an OTC market maker or
executes orders in NMS stocks internally by trading as principal or
crossing orders as agent (``non-ATS trading centers''), and if so, to
(1) identify the non-ATS trading center(s); and (2) describe any
interaction or coordination between the identified non-ATS trading
center(s) and the NMS Stock ATS.\1419\ We have modified this disclosure
to omit from Form ATS-N a list of non-ATS trading centers of the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates that cannot trade on the NMS
Stock ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1417\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81043.
\1418\ See supra Section V.C.
\1419\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81045.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This modification means that, relative to the disclosures on
proposed Form ATS-N, market participants will receive less information
concerning the non-ATS related operations of the NMS Stock ATS broker-
dealer operator and its affiliates. However, we believe that the
disclosures in adopted Form ATS-N concerning the ATS-related activities
of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates will still allow market
participants to better evaluate any potential conflicts of interest
that may arise on the NMS Stock ATS. Therefore, we do not believe that
the benefits from the public disclosure of the ATS-related
[[Page 38898]]
activities of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates on adopted
Form ATS-N will vary significantly from the benefits described in the
Proposal.\1420\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1420\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81122.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) Benefits of Public Disclosure of Aggregate Platform-Wide Order
Flow and Execution Statistics
Part III, Item 26 of adopted Form ATS-N requests that an NMS Stock
ATS explain and provide the most recent disclosure of aggregate
platform-wide order flow and execution statistics regarding the NMS
Stock ATS that are not otherwise required disclosures under Exchange
Act Rule 605 of Regulation NMS and that the NMS Stock ATS provided to
one or more subscribers by the NMS Stock ATS at the end of calendar
quarter. As described in detail in the Proposal, this disclosure
request could benefit market participants.\1421\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1421\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81124.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
NMS Stock ATSs that currently provide these aggregate platform-wide
order flow and execution statistics to one or more subscribers could
continue to provide their subscribers with these market quality
statistics, in which case, the NMS Stock ATS will publicly disclose
these statistics and how they are calculated in Form ATS-N, and all
market participants, not just subscribers, would have access to the
information. We believe this would reduce the discrepancy in
information that subscribers receive and provide the opportunity for
more market participants to benefit from this information which may be
useful to market participants when evaluating an NMS Stock ATS as a
possible venue to which to route orders in order to accomplish their
investing or trading objectives.\1422\ Further, to the extent that
subscribers that receive those market quality statistics currently do
not know how the NMS Stock ATS calculates the market quality
statistics, adopted Form ATS-N would help these subscribers better
understand the statistics.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1422\ See id (discussing how the disclosure of aggregate
platform-wide order flow and execution statistics might help NMS
Stock ATSs attract order flow).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters agree with us that the requirement to disclose
aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution statistics on Form
ATS-N, if they are otherwise disclosed to subscribers, could cause NMS
Stock ATSs to stop providing these statistics to their
subscribers.\1423\ If some NMS Stock ATSs cease disclosing these market
quality statistics to subscribers, it could reduce transparency to the
detriment of the subscribers who currently benefit from the receipt of
certain market quality statistics regarding an NMS Stock ATS, which
could in turn result in spill-over effects on the market. One commenter
agrees and states the elimination of this flow of information from the
NMS Stock ATSs would have a deleterious effect on subscriber knowledge
and understanding of a given ATS's operations, and negatively affect
the availability of information that some subscribers consider
important for their best execution determinations.\1424\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1423\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5; SIFMA Letter at 27. One of
these commenters suggests that these NMS Stock ATSs could begin to
direct parties requesting statistics and analysis to order
information available on FINRA's website or through third-party
vendors. See SIFMA Letter at 27.
\1424\ See SIFMA Letter at 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iv) Benefits of Filing Form ATS-N in a Structured Format
We believe that benefits will accrue to both the Commission and
market participants as a result of having a structured format for Form
ATS-N. Specifically, having Form ATS-N filed in the XML text-searchable
format will allow the Commission and its staff and market participants
to efficiently review and analyze information provided on Form ATS-N.
In particular, the XML format will allow the Commission and the public
to better gather, analyze, aggregate, compare, and use the Form ATS-N
data. Requiring XML should result in the Form ATS-N data being provided
in a consistent, structured format. XML is an open standard that
defines, or ``tags,'' data using standard definitions. The tags
establish a consistent structure of identity and context. This
consistent structure can be automatically recognized and processed by a
variety of software applications such as databases, financial reporting
systems, and spreadsheets, and then made immediately available to the
end user to search, aggregate, compare, and analyze.
We believe that requiring Form ATS-N be provided in an XML format
will provide the Commission and the public with data about NMS Stock
ATSs in a format that facilitates search capabilities, and comparative
analyses across NMS Stock ATSs and across filings, including more
advanced text analytics for the more narrative responses of Form ATS-N.
Absent this requirement of a specified format, users of the Form ATS-N
data that wanted to aggregate the data or search across filings or
filers would need to spend additional time transferring the data into a
consistent format before it could be analyzed, or incur the cost of a
service provider that specializes in this data aggregation and
comparison process. Further, unrestricted manual entry of data could
lead to errors, thereby potentially reducing data quality and
usability.
Commenters who supported the standardization of Form ATS-N
information also underscored the importance of making the information
comparable.\1425\ While the commenters did not make specific reference
to the structured format, having the Form ATS-N information submitted
using the Commission's XML schema will enhance the comparability of the
Form ATS-N data by ensuring that the information has been submitted
completely and consistently. Two commenters addressed the importance of
completeness to Form ATS-N filings.\1426\ With the Commission's XML
schema, the restrictions incorporated into the schema (and
consequently, also reflected in the web-fillable form) will help test
for completeness of the data before submission and reduce filer
uncertainty on the completeness and consistency of their filing. One
commenter recommended that we consider ways to present information that
would improve the readability and navigability of disclosure through
the use of technology such as hyperlinks and/or XBRL technology.\1427\
The XML format selected by us is a technology format that presents the
data consistently, which improves the readability and navigability of
the data. In fact, XBRL is an XML-based technology, but, as discussed
later, we do not think that XBRL is the appropriate format for this
form.\1428\ While hyperlinks may be useful in some situations to cross-
reference information, it does not by itself enhance the comparability
of the underlying data, but can be incorporated within the XML format,
as permitted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1425\ See Fidelity Letter at 1; Morgan Stanley Letter at 2;
SIFMA Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 2-3.
\1426\ See MFA/AIMA Letter at 4; SIFMA Letter at 32-33.
\1427\ See Fidelity Letter at 5.
\1428\ See infra Section X.D.11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Costs
We recognize that the filing and public disclosure of Form ATS-N
and Form ATS-N amendments could impose costs on NMS Stock ATSs as well
as costs on market participants. This section discusses specific costs
associated with the filing and public disclosure of Form ATS-N
including: the costs to NMS Stock ATSs; the effects of public
disclosure of Form ATS-N on
[[Page 38899]]
the price impact costs of market participants; and the costs associated
with filing Form ATS-N and Form ATS-N amendments in a structured
format.
(i) Costs to NMS Stock ATSs
We recognize that there would be costs that accrue to NMS Stock
ATSs as a result of the adopted amendments. For NMS Stock ATSs,
disclosure of previously non-public information could have some impact
on the direction of order flow in the market. If this previously non-
public information is valuable to certain NMS Stock ATSs--to the extent
that it drives its revenues--disclosure of this information on Form
ATS-N could be costly for these NMS Stock ATSs. For instance,
disclosure of an NMS Stock ATS's innovations could potentially result
in other ATSs implementing similar methodologies, which could cause the
NMS Stock ATS to lose its technological advantage. Such an ATS may need
to engage in costly research in order to develop new innovations to
stay profitable in the market. If an ATS cannot innovate fast enough to
regain its competitive advantage in the market, order flow may then
potentially migrate to other NMS Stock ATSs, broker-dealers that
operate non-ATS trading centers, or to national securities
exchanges.\1429\ Additionally, some order flow could be directed away
from an NMS Stock ATS and towards one of these other trading centers if
the disclosure of previously non-public information, such as aggregate
platform-wide order flow and execution statistics or information about
the ATS related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates, causes some market participants to discover that their
orders would have a greater likelihood of receiving lower execution
quality on the NMS Stock ATS relative to these other trading centers.
As such, this may result in lower revenues for some NMS Stock ATSs.
These ATSs may then find it unprofitable to continue operating as ATSs
and could exit the market for stock execution services or switch their
business strategies to increase market share or profitability, possibly
by continuing to operate as non-ATS OTC execution venues, such as OTC
trading venues in which the broker-dealer operator internalizes order
flow.\1430\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1429\ See infra Section X.C.4.a for a discussion of the
competitive effects of these costs (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Competition'').
\1430\ See infra Section X.C.4.a.i.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, as discussed above,\1431\ we lack certain information
necessary to quantify the extent to which entities that operate as ATSs
for NMS Stocks would be dissuaded from doing so. Specifically, as
discussed in the Proposal,\1432\ the decision for an NMS Stock ATS to
continue operating or to cease operating as an ATS depends on numerous
factors and we lack information about many of those factors. Commenters
did not provide any additional information or analysis that would allow
us to quantify the impact on Legacy NMS Stocks ATSs or other entities
that may otherwise seek to operate a new NMS Stock ATS. Therefore,
while we continue to believe that the costs of the adopted amendments
could cause some Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs and
could dissuade some entities who would seek to operate as ATSs for NMS
Stocks from doing so, we remain unable to quantify that impact.
Furthermore, we do not have information to make reasonable assumptions
about the fraction of displaced volume--from NMS Stock ATSs that would
cease operations--that would be internalized by broker-dealer operator
or its affiliates or directed towards national securities exchanges,
NMS Stock ATSs, or non-ATS OTC trading centers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1431\ See supra Section X.C and supra note 1356.
\1432\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81118.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) Price Impact Costs
We recognize that heightened disclosure requirements pertaining to
the public disclosure of Form ATS-N could increase market participants'
trading costs relative to the baseline if some ATSs cease operating as
ATSs or if there is reduced entry of new NMS Stock ATSs. Institutional
investors can elect to use NMS Stock ATSs in an attempt to minimize the
price impact of their trades. Even though the size of the average order
on NMS Stock ATSs has been shown to be roughly equivalent to that on
national securities exchanges, smaller orders on NMS Stock ATSs can be
the result of shredding larger orders.\1433\ Preventing information
regarding those orders from becoming public can minimize adverse price
moves that may occur when proprietary traders learn that there may be
large buyers or sellers in the market. Thus, NMS Stock ATSs represent a
tool for institutional investors to help control information leakage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1433\ See Tuttle: ATS Trading in NMS Stocks, supra note 1317.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If there is reduced entry of new NMS Stock ATSs or some NMS Stock
ATSs cease operating as ATSs and shut down their ATSs as a result of
the amendments, there could be a reduction in the number of trading
platforms that allow institutional investors to control their price
impact costs. Institutional investors who would have traded on these
NMS Stock ATSs, might now have to trade on other trading venues, such
as other NMS Stock ATSs, non-ATS OTC execution venues, or national
securities exchanges. If institutional investors execute their orders
on a national securities exchange, they might have to absorb price
impact costs, because national securities exchanges may not offer a
means for reducing these costs.
Additionally, if some NMS Stock ATSs cease operating as ATSs and
begin operating as non-ATS OTC execution venues, such as an OTC trading
venue in which the broker-dealer operator internalizes order flow,
there could be an increase in the internalization of order flow.
Increased internalization could reduce market depth and price
informativeness and increase spreads and price impact costs.\1434\
However, as discussed above,\1435\ we do not know the extent to which
the adopted amendments would affect an NMS Stock ATS's decision to
continue operations or cease operating as an ATS, and, therefore,
cannot estimate the number of ATSs that would cease operating as ATSs.
Nor do we have information in order for us to make reasonable
assumptions about the fraction of displaced volume--from NMS Stock ATSs
that would cease operations--that would be internalized by a broker-
dealer operator or its affiliates or directed towards national
securities exchanges, NMS Stock ATSs, or non-ATS OTC trading centers.
Commenters did not provide any additional information or analysis that
would allow us to quantify the number of Legacy NMS Stocks ATSs that
would cease operating as ATSs or estimate the impacts on
internalization or order flow. Therefore, we cannot estimate the impact
that the adopted amendments would have on an NMS Stock ATS's price
impact costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1434\ See supra Section X.B.6.a.
\1435\ See supra Section X.C and supra note 1356.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1436\ the price impact cost
institutional investors face on a national securities exchange is
related to the depth of the market, and the depth of the market is
often related to the market capitalization of a stock and its
liquidity.\1437\ Because NMS Stock ATSs
[[Page 38900]]
trade larger dollar volume in small capitalization, low-priced stocks,
the price impact costs for institutional investors that trade in such
stocks could in fact increase significantly if many NMS Stock ATSs
decide to exit the market. However, as discussed above,\1438\ we cannot
estimate what price market participants would receive in these stocks
and, thus, we cannot estimate the price impact costs associated with
the adopted amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1436\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81127-28.
\1437\ A deep market is one in which larger orders do not have a
much greater impact on prices than smaller orders. See Foucault,
Pagano and Roell, 2013, ``Market Liquidity,'' Oxford University
Press.
\1438\ See supra Section X.C and supra note 1356.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) Filing in Structured Format
We understand that there are also costs associated with varying
degrees of structuring Form ATS-N. By offering two options for filers
to submit Form ATS-N in EDGAR, filers will be able to select the method
best suited to their situation.\1439\ We believe that the XML format of
Form ATS-N has enhanced benefits for the Commission's and market
participants' use of Form ATS-N while minimizing costs relative to
filers having to file Form ATS-N using other structured formats.\1440\
By requiring the XML format, the Form ATS-N data must be structured to
conform to incorporated validations. As stated previously, the
validations will not test for the underlying accuracy of the data, but
it will test for consistency and completeness.\1441\ For the NMS Stock
ATSs that file Form ATS-N, the validations will help ensure that the
form they submit is complete and appropriately formatted so that
additional time will not have to be spent on subsequent Form ATS-N
filings to correct for those errors. By comparison, the EFFS system
originally proposed does not support the open-source XML format, but
rather a proprietary XML implementation called XFDL. As a result, the
EFFS system has fewer validation capabilities and cannot test for
consistency and completeness as broadly as the XML format, in
particular, at the element level. In addition, as proposed, filers
would have been required to individually upload each narrative response
as a separate exhibit, whereas EDGAR permits filers to provide all of
their narrative responses within one structured XML file, which will
slightly diminish their time spent in filing in the Form ATS-N
information.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1439\ See supra Section VII.
\1440\ See infra Section X.D.11.
\1441\ See supra Section VII (discussing structured disclosure
aspects of Form ATS-N).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Economic Effects of Written Safeguards and Written Procedures To
Protect Subscribers' Confidential Trading Information, and
Recordkeeping Requirements
a. Benefits
As explained above, we believe that the amendments to Rules
301(b)(10) \1442\ and 303(a)(1) \1443\ of Regulation ATS could increase
investor protection by strengthening the effectiveness of NMS Stock
ATSs' safeguards and procedures to better protect confidential
subscriber trading information and improving those ATSs' ability to
implement and monitor the adequacy of, and the ATSs' compliance with,
their safeguards and procedures.\1444\ Furthermore, as discussed
above,\1445\ we believe that requiring ATSs to memorialize their
safeguards and procedures in writing will improve Commission oversight
by helping the Commission better understand, monitor, and evaluate how
each NMS Stock ATS protects subscribers' confidential trading
information from unauthorized disclosure and access, which in turn
could increase investor protection.\1446\ We also expect that this
requirement will help oversight by the SRO of which the NMS Stock ATS's
broker-dealer operator is a member.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1442\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1443\ 17 CFR 242.303(a).
\1444\ See supra Section VI.
\1445\ See id.
\1446\ Three commenters agree with us that requiring ATSs to
adopt written safeguards and written procedures would be beneficial
to Commission oversight by helping the Commission better understand,
monitor, and evaluate how each ATS protects subscribers'
confidential trading information from unauthorized disclosure and
access. See HMA Letter at 17-18; ICI Letter at 10-11; MFA/AIMA
Letter at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Costs
We believe that there would be implementation costs for NMS Stock
ATSs that have not preserved in writing their safeguards and procedures
to protect subscribers' confidential trading information and their
oversight procedures to ensure that those safeguards and procedures are
followed, which are required under Rule 301(b)(10) of Regulation
ATS.\1447\ Based on the analysis for purposes of the PRA, we estimate
that, in order to comply with the amendments to Rules 301(b)(10) and
303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS,\1448\ it could take up to 87 ATSs an
estimated one-time burden of up to 8 hours each, resulting in an
estimated one-time paperwork cost of $2,910 for each ATS.\1449\ This
would result in an aggregate estimated initial hour burden of 696 hours
at an estimated cost of $253,170.\1450\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1447\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(10).
\1448\ See supra Section VI.
\1449\ (Attorney at $406 x 7 hours) + (Compliance Clerk at $68 x
1 hour) = $2,910. As explained in the PRA, we believe that the
majority of ATSs already maintain their written safeguards and
procedures in writing, so most ATSs would not incur this initial
cost. See supra Section IX.D.1.b. For purposes of this economic
analysis, however, we assume that the initial cost of this new
requirement would be imposed on all ATSs.
\1450\ 8 hours x 87 ATSs = 696 hours. $2,910 x 87 ATSs =
$253,170.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, the amendments to Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v)
relating to written safeguards and written procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information would impose ongoing
costs for all NMS Stock ATSs. For the purposes of the PRA, we estimate
it could take approximately 4 hours annually for each ATS to update and
maintain these safeguards and procedures,\1451\ resulting in an
estimated annual paperwork cost for each ATS of $948.\1452\ This would
result in an estimated aggregate ongoing hour burden for all ATSs to
maintain and update their safeguards and procedures pursuant to Rules
301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of 348 hours at an estimated cost of
$82,476 annually.\1453\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1451\ See supra note 1116 and accompanying text.
\1452\ (Attorney at $406 x 2 hours) + (Compliance Clerk at $68 x
2 hours) = $948 annual paperwork cost per ATS.
\1453\ 4 annual burden hours x 87 ATSs = 348 annual burden
hours. $948 annual paperwork cost per ATS x 87 NMS Stock ATSs =
$82,476 aggregate annual paperwork cost.'
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also amending the recordkeeping rules relevant to the
amendments to Rule 301 and new Rule 304. NMS Stock ATSs shall preserve
Form ATS-N, Form ATS-N amendments, and a Form ATS-N notice of cessation
for the life of the enterprise and any successor enterprise pursuant to
Rule 303(a)(2) \1454\ of Regulation ATS.\1455\ We are also amending
Rule 303(a)(1) \1456\ so that ATSs must preserve for a period of not
less than three years, the first two in an easily accessible place, the
written safeguards and procedures that would be required under the
amendments to Rule 301(b)(10). We understand that these amendments
regarding recordkeeping requirements will require NMS Stock ATSs to set
up systems and procedures, and these are expected to account for a
portion of the implementation costs
[[Page 38901]]
related to Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS \1457\ and
the amendments to Rules 301(b)(10) and 303(a)(1)(v) of Regulation ATS
discussed above.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1454\ 17 CFR 242.303(a)(2).
\1455\ An NMS Stock ATS that had previously made filings on Form
ATS would be required to preserve those filings for the life of the
enterprise, as well as filings made going forward on Form ATS-N.
\1456\ 17 CFR 242.303(a)(1).
\1457\ See supra Section X.C.1.b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Impact on Efficiency, Competition, and Capital Formation
We have considered the effects of the amendments on efficiency,
competition, and capital formation. We believe that the amendments will
help market participants make better informed decisions about where to
route their orders in order to achieve their trading or investment
objectives, enhance execution quality, and improve efficiency and
capital allocation.
We understand that the amendments to Regulation ATS could affect
the competitive dynamics in the market for NMS stock execution
services.\1458\ These disclosure requirements for NMS Stock ATSs could
create a disincentive for entities to become ATSs in the market for NMS
stock execution services and also result in some stand-alone ATSs
exiting the market and some multi-service broker-dealers electing to
cease operating their NMS Stock ATSs and instead initiate or increase
operations as non-ATS OTC execution venues. However, in spite of these
costs, and as discussed in more detail below, we believe that the NMS
Stock ATSs that remain may propagate greater interaction between buyers
and sellers who trade on these venues, fostering not only trading
between one and another, but also facilitating the price discovery
process and capital formation. The consistent set of information that
will be disclosed in Form ATS-N will impact how market participants
react in terms of their trading, which could improve market
efficiency.\1459\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1458\ See infra Section X.C.4.a (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Competition'').
\1459\ See infra Section X.C.4.b (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Efficiency'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moreover, increased transparency regarding the operations of NMS
Stock ATSs could impact competition between broker-dealers that operate
NMS Stock ATSs and broker-dealers who trade NMS stocks but do not
operate an NMS Stock ATS, such as internalizers. Because broker-dealers
who transact in NMS stocks but do not operate ATSs are not subject to
the operational transparency requirements, these broker-dealers could
obtain a competitive advantage and attract and internalize order flow
that would otherwise be entered and executed on NMS Stock ATSs.
Furthermore, greater operational transparency of NMS Stock ATSs could
also impact competition between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities
exchanges, resulting in a larger amount of order flow being executed on
national securities exchanges.
a. Competition
The adopted amendments could impact the competitive dynamics in the
market for NMS stock execution services, which includes competition
between national securities exchanges and NMS Stock ATSs, among NMS
Stock ATSs themselves, and between broker-dealers that operate NMS
Stock ATSs and those that do not.
As discussed above,\1460\ we believe that the public disclosure of
Form ATS-N could appropriately calibrate the level of transparency
between NMS Stock ATSs and national securities exchanges, which could
foster even greater competition for order flow of NMS stocks between
those trading platforms. However, the increased public disclosure
requirements associated with adopted Form ATS-N along with the
uncertainty as to whether a Form ATS-N will be declared ineffective may
raise the barriers to entry for new entities seeking to act as ATSs in
the market for NMS stock execution services and may cause some existing
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs. This could affect
competition in the market for NMS stock execution services, which could
in turn affect market participants. Additionally, the public disclosure
of some previously non-public information about the manner of
operations of the ATS, such as information on certain matching
methodologies or order types, along with the greater competition for
order flow, could affect the incentives of NMS Stock ATSs to innovate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1460\ See supra Section X.C.2.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The sections below discuss specific impacts of the adopted
amendments on the competitive dynamics in the market for NMS stock
execution services, including: Their impact on the entry of new NMS
Stock ATSs and the continuation of existing Legacy NMS Stock ATSs, the
impact of changes in the number of NMS Stock ATSs on market participant
trading costs, and their impact on the incentives of ATSs to innovate.
(i) Entry of New and Continuation of Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
We believe that the adopted amendments could potentially raise the
barriers to entry for new entities seeking to act as ATSs in the market
for NMS stock execution services and could also affect the decision of
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to continue operating as ATSs. As discussed in
more detail below, the uncertainty surrounding whether Form ATS-N and
Form ATS-N amendment filings will be declared ineffective, the
increased implementation and ongoing compliance costs associated with
the adopted amendments, and the effects of public disclosure of
previously non-public information required on Form ATS-N might dissuade
some potential new ATSs from entering the market and could cause some
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs.\1461\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1461\ Several commenters agreed that the disclosure
requirements associated with Form ATS-N could act as a barrier to
entry for new NMS Stock ATSs in the market; dissuade some existing
ATSs from continuing to operate as ATSs; and force some smaller NMS
Stock ATSs out of business. See Fidelity Letter at 10; Luminex
Letter at 1-2; STANY Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If the costs of the adopted amendments make it unprofitable for the
broker-dealer operator of a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to continue operating
the ATS,\1462\ the broker-dealer operator could sell the ATS to another
broker-dealer or shut down the ATS. Alternatively, a multi-service
broker-dealer operator could cease operating the Legacy NMS Stock ATS
as an ATS and instead initiate operations as a non-ATS OTC execution
venue, such as an OTC trading venue in which the broker-dealer operator
internalizes order flow.\1463\ If a Legacy NMS Stock ATS that ceases
operations is operated by a multi-service broker-dealer operator that
also operates, or has affiliates that operate, other non-ATS OTC
execution venues, the multi-service broker-dealer operator or its
affiliates could increase operations at one of these venues instead of
choosing to operate the Legacy NMS Stock ATS as a non-ATS OTC execution
venue. If a Legacy NMS Stock ATS ceases to operate as an ATS, the
broker-dealer operator or its affiliates might internalize the order
flow that would have typically been sent to the ATS or they might send
that order flow to a third-party broker-dealer to internalize.\1464\
Alternatively, the displaced order flow could be sent to one of the
remaining NMS Stock ATSs
[[Page 38902]]
or to a national securities exchange for execution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1462\ See supra Section X.C.1.b, Section X.C.2.b, and Section
X.C.3.b.
\1463\ One commenter said that the disclosure obligations that
only apply to broker-dealer ATS operators may incentivize broker-
dealer ATS operators to seek alternatives other than operating an
ATS. See Morgan Stanley Letter at 3.
\1464\ One commenter said the disclosure requirements could
result in ATSs closing down their NMS Stock ATS operations and
increase the use of broker-dealer internalized executions. See
Fidelity Letter at 4, 5, 9, 10-11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If increased barriers to entry cause fewer ATSs to enter the market
or the increased costs of the adopted amendments cause some
unprofitable Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to shut down operations, there could
be fewer trading venues in the market for NMS Stock execution services.
We believe that if the adopted amendments result in fewer trading
venues in the market or cause some Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to operate as
non-ATS OTC execution venues, it could affect market participants by
reducing the number of NMS stock trading venues and, thus, reducing a
market participant's opportunities to minimize its trading costs by
sending orders to different trading platforms.\1465\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1465\ See infra Section X.C.4.a.ii.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While we believe that the adopted amendments could act as a barrier
to entry or dissuade some existing ATSs from continuing to operate as
ATSs, we reiterate that we lack certain information necessary to
quantify the extent to which entities that otherwise would seek to
operate as ATSs for NMS Stocks would be dissuaded from doing so.\1466\
Specifically, as discussed in the Proposal,\1467\ the decision for an
NMS Stock ATS to continue operating or to cease operating as an ATS
depends on numerous factors and we lack information about many of those
factors. For example, we do not have information on the extent to which
existing NMS Stock ATSs or potentially new ATSs rely on a competitive
advantage, such as a unique matching methodology, to attract order flow
or the extent to which the new rule and amendments would impact that
competitive advantage. Furthermore, the decision to cease operating as
an ATS is idiosyncratic to the particular NMS Stock ATS and we cannot
ascertain the extent to which small (or in fact large) ATSs may be more
prone to cease operating as ATSs.\1468\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1466\ See supra Section X.C and supra note 1356.
\1467\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81118.
\1468\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Commenters did not provide any additional information or analysis
that would allow us to quantify the impact on Legacy NMS Stocks ATSs or
other entities that might otherwise seek to operate a new NMS Stock
ATS. Therefore, while we continue to believe that the costs of the
adopted amendments could cause some Legacy NMS Stock ATSs to cease
operating as ATSs and could dissuade some entities who would seek to
operate as ATSs for NMS Stocks from doing so, we remain unable to
quantify that impact.
The subsections below discuss how various elements of the adopted
amendments could potentially affect the barriers to entry for new
entities seeking to act as ATSs and the decision of Legacy NMS Stock
ATSs to continue or cease operating as ATSs in the market for NMS stock
execution services, including: The enhanced filing requirements of Form
ATS-N, the implementation and ongoing compliance costs associated with
the adopted amendments, and the public disclosure of previously non-
public information required on Form ATS-N.
(a) Enhanced Filing Requirements of Form ATS-N
The filing requirements of Form ATS-N will impose costs on NMS
Stock ATSs. An ineffectiveness declaration would impose costs on an NMS
Stock ATS--such as costs from having to cease operations, roll back a
change in operations, or delay the start of operations--and could
impose costs on the overall market for NMS stock execution services
resulting from a potential reduction in competition or the removal of a
sole provider of a niche service within the market. The adopted
amendments to Regulation ATS might beget uncertainty as to whether an
NMS Stock ATS's Form ATS-N will be declared ineffective.\1469\ Greater
uncertainty surrounding this process might act as a deterrent for
potential ATSs wishing to effect transactions in NMS stocks, which
could raise barriers for potential new entrants to the market for NMS
stock execution services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1469\ See supra Section X.C.1.b.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The amendments we are adopting permit a Legacy NMS Stock ATS to
continue its operations, on a provisional basis, pursuant to the filed
initial Form ATS-N, and any amendments thereto, during the Commission's
review of its initial Form ATS-N. However, if after notice and
opportunity for hearing, the Commission declares the Form ATS-N filed
by a legacy NMS Stock ATS ineffective, the ATS would be required to
cease its activities relating to NMS stocks. The NMS Stock ATS would
then have the opportunity to address deficiencies in the previously
filed form by filing a new Form ATS-N.\1470\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1470\ See supra Section IV.A.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission could also declare amendments to an effective Form
ATS-N ineffective. In particular, the adopted amendments require an NMS
Stock ATS to file amendments on Form ATS-N to notice a material change
to its operations at least 30 days prior to implementing that material
change.\1471\ If the Commission declares a material amendment
ineffective before this advance notice period has expired, the NMS
Stock ATS would be required to unwind the material change if it has
already been implemented on the ATS or be precluded from proceeding to
implement the change if it was not already implemented. The NMS Stock
ATS could, however, continue to operate pursuant to a Form ATS-N that
had become effective.\1472\ Given the additional uncertainty introduced
by the possibility that the Commission could declare a Form ATS-N or a
Form ATS-N amendment ineffective, coupled with the number and
complexity of the new disclosures that would be required under Form
ATS-N, some broker-dealer operators of Legacy NMS Stock ATSs might find
that the costs of compliance outweigh the benefits of continuing to
operate their NMS Stock ATS, particularly if the operation of the ATS
does not constitute a significant source of profit for a broker-dealer
operator. As such, some NMS Stock ATSs might elect to cease operating
as an ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1471\ The amendments to Rule 301(a)(5) could, under exceptional
circumstances such as to prevent substantial harm to market
participants, allow an NMS Stock ATS to implement a material change
more quickly by seeking an exemption from the Commission from the
30-calendar day advance notice requirements of Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A).
See supra Section III.B.3.
\1472\ Nothing would preclude the NMS Stock ATS from later
submitting a new or revised Form ATS-N amendment for consideration
by the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The adopted amendments might also potentially raise the barriers to
entry for new entities seeking to act as ATSs in the market for NMS
stock execution service by delaying the start of operations for new NMS
Stock ATSs. Currently, to comply with Regulation ATS, an entity seeking
to operate as an ATS must, among other things, file an initial
operation report with the Commission on Form ATS at least 20 days
before commencing operations.\1473\ Under the adopted amendments, an
entity seeking to operate as an ATS in the market for NMS stock
execution services could not commence operations until its initial Form
ATS-N became effective, which could occur 120 calendar days after
initially filing Form ATS-N with the Commission or at the end of the
extended Commission review period.\1474\ Additionally, the disclosures
required by Form ATS-N would be more comprehensive and require
[[Page 38903]]
significantly more detail than those required on current Form ATS,
which in turn could also delay the start of operations for new NMS
Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1473\ See supra Section II.C.
\1474\ Our review period could last less than 120 days.
Alternatively, we could extend the review period an additional 90
calendar days, if the Form ATS-N is unusually lengthy or raises
novel or complex issues that require additional time for review. See
supra Section IV.A.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(b) Implementation and Ongoing Compliance Costs
As explained above, NMS Stock ATSs will incur both implementation
and ongoing costs to meet the regulatory requirements under Rule
304.\1475\ On the margin, if these costs outweigh the benefits of
operating an NMS Stock ATS, they could act as a deterrent for potential
ATSs wishing to effect transactions in NMS stocks or cause some Legacy
NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as an ATS. However, we do not believe
that the implementation and ongoing costs are significant enough to
make this a likely possibility.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1475\ See supra Section X.C.1.b (``Economic Effects of Enhanced
Filing Requirements of Form ATS-N--Costs'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The implementation and ongoing costs associated with filing Form
ATS-N could also differentially affect small and large NMS Stock ATSs.
As Table 1 shows, there is a significant degree of difference in the
size of NMS Stock ATSs, when measured by dollar or share volume. We
believe that the estimated implementation cost is a fixed cost that
would be roughly similar across NMS Stock ATSs, regardless of their
dollar volume size; this implies that implementation costs will
represent a larger fraction of revenue generated on a small NMS Stock
ATS relative to that percentage on a large NMS Stock ATS. If the costs
associated with filing Form ATS-N become disproportionately greater for
smaller volume NMS Stock ATSs, some of these Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
might be more likely to cease operating as ATSs. However, if the NMS
Stock ATSs that decide to cease operating as ATSs due to this fixed
implementation cost only transact small dollar (or share) volume, there
may not be a large impact on the overall competitive structure for
remaining NMS Stock ATSs. Moreover, the order flow that was being
traded on these small NMS Stock ATSs might be absorbed and
redistributed amongst these larger remaining NMS Stock ATSs. On the
other hand, if the implementation costs cause a small NMS Stock ATS
that is the sole provider of a niche service to cease operating as an
ATS, it could affect market participants by requiring them to seek
execution on other NMS stock trading venues that do not minimize their
trading costs to the same extent.\1476\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1476\ See infra Section X.C.4.a.ii.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(c) Public Disclosure of Form ATS-N
Once an NMS Stock ATS's initial Form ATS-N has become effective,
the information disclosed on Form ATS-N will be made available to the
broader investing public.\1477\ Updating and correcting amendments to
Form ATS-N, as well as the cover page of material amendments, would be
made public upon filing and the entirety of material amendments to Form
ATS-N would be made public following the expiration of the review
period.\1478\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1477\ See supra Section V for information contained on Form
ATS-N.
\1478\ See supra Section IV.E. See also Rule 304(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the information elicited on Form ATS-N is similar to the
information that national securities exchanges are required to publicly
disclose, we believe that the disclosure of this previously non-public
information could have some impact on the competition for order flow in
the market. For instance, to the extent that an NMS Stock ATS's
competitive advantage in the market is driven by its matching
methodology, other operational characteristics that are currently
confidential, or the non-public disclosure of certain aggregate
platform-wide market quality statistics provided to subscribers, the
disclosure of this information could result in other NMS Stock ATSs
implementing similar methodologies, which might cause market
participants to direct more order flow to those other NMS Stock ATSs.
In addition, some order flow might be directed away from NMS Stock ATSs
and towards national securities exchanges or broker-dealers that
operate non-ATS trading centers if market participants discover that
their orders would have a greater likelihood of receiving lower
execution quality on an NMS Stock ATS relative to these other trading
centers. As such, this could result in lower revenues for some NMS
Stock ATSs. Those ATSs might then find it unprofitable to continue
operating as ATSs. This might cause the broker-dealer operator to sell
the ATS to another broker-dealer or shut down the ATS. It could also
cause the broker-dealer operator to switch its business strategies to
increase market share or profitability, possibly by continuing to
operate as a non-ATS OTC execution venue, such as OTC trading venue in
which the broker-dealer operator internalizes order flow. The
disclosure of previously non-public operational information required
under initial Form ATS-N could erode a new NMS Stock ATS's competitive
advantage and prevent it from attracting order flow. This could
potentially raise the barriers to entry for new entities seeking to act
as ATSs in the market for NMS stock execution services and dissuade
some entities that would potentially seek to operate as ATSs for NMS
stocks from doing so. We believe that a reduction in the entry of new
ATSs or some Legacy NMS Stock ATSs electing to cease operating as ATSs
could affect competition in the market for NMS Stock execution
services, which could in turn affect market participants.
Not only could an NMS Stock ATS's competitive advantage be driven
by its current matching methodology or other operational
characteristics, it could also be driven by the NMS Stock ATS's ability
to improve these methodologies through technological innovation or
enhancements.\1479\ We believe that the disclosure of an NMS Stock
ATS's innovations in Form ATS-N amendments could potentially result in
certain NMS Stock ATSs losing their technological advantage. If NMS
Stock ATSs cannot innovate fast enough to regain their competitive
advantage in the market, orders may also flow away from those NMS Stock
ATSs, and as a result, those trading venues may choose to cease
operating as ATSs if operating the ATS becomes unprofitable for the
broker-dealer operator.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1479\ See infra X.C.4.a.iii.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Both large and small NMS Stock ATSs could be affected by the
detailed disclosures required under Rule 304 and Form ATS-N, though,
the adopted amendments could affect the ability of each type of ATS to
stay in the market differently. As noted above, to the extent that an
ATS's dominance in the market--in terms of being able to attract
substantial NMS stock trading volume--is driven by its matching
methodology or other operational characteristics that are currently
confidential, the public disclosure of this information might result in
lower revenue for the NMS Stock ATS. If public disclosure reduces
revenue for a small NMS Stock ATS, or a large ATS without a substantial
profit margin, the broker-dealer operator might no longer view the ATS
as being profitable and cease operating it as an ATS. The broker-dealer
operator of a large ATS that ceases operating as an ATS might be more
likely to continue to operate the system as a non-ATS OTC execution
venue. However, the broker dealer of a small ATS that ceases to operate
as an ATS could potentially shutdown the ATS altogether. Alternatively,
if public disclosure reduces revenue for a large NMS Stock ATS or a
smaller NMS Stock ATS with large profit margins, such an ATS may
[[Page 38904]]
continue operating as an ATS but may need to engage in costly research
in order to develop new methodologies or enhancements that are less
likely to be affected by the public disclosure requirements in order to
stay profitable in the market. Further, if revenue and earnings margins
for operating an NMS Stock ATS are below the average for the entire
market, the NMS Stock ATS risks being squeezed out by its competitors
and could potentially cease operating as an ATS.\1480\ As discussed in
detail above,\1481\ the effect on market participants if an ATS ceases
operating as an ATS could vary based on the size (dollar volume) of the
ATS. If the NMS Stock ATSs that cease operating as ATSs transact only
small dollar (or share) volumes, we might not expect to see a large
impact on the overall competitive structure of the NMS Stock ATSs that
would remain in the market. Many smaller NMS Stock ATSs might not
engage in other brokerage or dealing activities in addition to the
operation of their NMS Stock ATS. Therefore, certain aspects of Form
ATS-N (such as several items of Part II) might not be applicable to
smaller NMS Stock ATSs, which would reduce the burdens and mitigate the
effects of the disclosure requirements on these smaller NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1480\ See Singhvi, Surrendra S. and Harsha B. Desai, 1971, ``An
Empirical Analysis of the Quality of Corporate Financial
Disclosure,'' Accounting Review 46, 129-138.
\1481\ See supra Section X.C.4.a.i.B.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The increased transparency regarding the operations of NMS Stock
ATSs might impact competition between broker-dealers that operate NMS
Stock ATSs and broker-dealers who trade NMS stocks but do not operate
an NMS Stock ATS, such as internalizers. Because broker-dealers who
transact in NMS stocks but do not operate ATSs are not subject to the
operational transparency requirements, these broker-dealers could be at
a competitive advantage and attract and internalize order flow that
would otherwise be entered and executed on NMS Stock ATSs.\1482\ These
disclosure requirements could also influence a broker-dealer operator's
decisions with respect to its operations of the NMS Stock ATS. Given
the disclosure requirements regarding the ATS-related activities of
broker-dealer operators and their affiliates, a multi-service broker-
dealer operator of an NMS Stock ATS might cease operating its NMS Stock
ATS as an ATS and instead internalize the order flow or send that order
flow to a third-party broker-dealer that executes it.\1483\
Alternatively, the broker-dealer operator might send the order flow to
a non-affiliated NMS Stock ATS that is operated by a non-multi-service
broker-dealer, which would likely not encounter the same potential
conflicts of interest as a multi-service broker-dealer that operates an
NMS Stock ATS. Finally, the broker-dealer operator could also send its
order flow to national securities exchanges for execution. While we
cannot quantify how much order flow from these displaced multi-services
broker-dealers that operate NMS Stock ATSs would be routed back to
national securities exchanges,\1484\ we believe that routing order flow
to lit venues could potentially have some positive effects on price
discovery and transparency.\1485\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1482\ Four commenters assert that the enhanced filing
requirements under the amendments to Regulation ATS would
disproportionately impact multi-service broker-dealers who operate
NMS Stock ATSs relative to other broker-dealers. These commenters
state that these broker-dealers are held to a higher disclosure
standard than broker-dealers that do not operate ATSs. See Fidelity
Letter at 4, 9, 11; Liquidnet Letter at 9; Morgan Stanley Letter 2;
STA Letter at 2.
\1483\ One commenter agrees that the enhanced disclosure
requirements may incentivize multi-service broker-dealer ATS
operators to seek alternatives other than operating an ATS. See
Morgan Stanley Letter at 3. Another commenter states that the
enhanced disclosure requirements could result in ATSs closing down
their NMS Stock ATS operations and increase the use of broker-dealer
internalized executions. See Fidelity Letter at 4, 9, 10-11.
\1484\ See supra Section X.C.
\1485\ See infra Section X.4.b (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Efficiency'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to commenters' concerns that proposed Form ATS-N would
have required the public disclosure of proprietary or commercially
sensitive information, we have revised the adopted Form ATS-N requests
to not seek disclosure of certain information that could be proprietary
or commercially sensitive, such as routing tables or numerical order
flow segmentation metrics.\1486\ Additionally, we have revised the
disclosures concerning the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates to
focus on (1) the ability of the business units or affiliates of the
broker-dealer operator to enter, or direct the entry of, orders into
the NMS Stock ATS; and (2) whether those business units and affiliates
receive any preferential treatment with respect to the services offered
by the NMS Stock ATS, including any special access to information about
trading interest.\1487\ We believe these changes should reduce the
costs of the public disclosure of Form ATS-N for a NMS Stock ATS
relative to what they were in the Proposal.\1488\ Additionally, these
changes, because of the decreased costs of public disclosure relative
to the Proposal, should reduce the barriers to entry and also reduce
the likelihood that a Legacy NMS Stock ATS ceases operating as an ATS
compared to the Proposal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1486\ See supra Section IV.E.2.a.
\1487\ See supra Section V.C.
\1488\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81125.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(ii) Effects of Changes in Number of NMS Stock ATSs on Market
Participant Trading Costs
Overall, we believe that the possible decision of entities that
currently are NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs, or the reduced
entry of new NMS Stock ATSs, due to the requirements under Rule 304 and
Form ATS-N could affect competition in the market for NMS stock
execution services and could impact market participants by reducing the
number of entities that are willing to act as NMS Stock ATSs and
publicly disclose how they operate. If there is a reduction in the
number of trading venues, either from some Legacy NMS Stock ATSs
shutting down their operations or reduced entry into the market by
prospective NMS Stock ATSs, it could impact market participants by
reducing the number of NMS stock trading venues and, thus, reducing
market participants' opportunities to minimize its trading costs by
sending orders to different trading platforms. Additionally, if some
Legacy NMS Stock ATSs cease operating as ATSs and begin to operate as
non-ATS OTC execution venues, there might be an increase in the
internalization of order flow. Increased internalization could reduce
market depth and price informativeness and increase spreads,\1489\
which could increase market participant trading costs. Therefore, the
possible decision of NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs and
lower rate of entry for new NMS Stock ATSs could result in greater
costs relative to the baseline cost savings that NMS Stock ATSs
currently afford market participants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1489\ See supra Section X.A.6.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, as discussed above and in the Proposal,\1490\ we lack
information to determine the extent to which the increased public
disclosure requirements associated with adopted Form ATS-N or the
uncertainty as to whether a Form ATS-N will be declared ineffective
would affect a Legacy NMS Stock ATS's decision to continue operations
or cease operating as an ATS or the decision of potential ATSs to enter
the market. Therefore, we cannot
[[Page 38905]]
estimate the number of ATSs that would cease operating as ATSs or the
number of potential new ATSs that would be dissuaded from entering the
market. Furthermore, we do not have information in order for us to make
reasonable assumptions about the fraction of displaced volume--from NMS
Stock ATSs that would cease operating as ATSs--that would be
internalized by a broker-dealer operator or its affiliates or directed
towards national securities exchanges, NMS Stock ATSs, or non-ATS OTC
trading centers. Commenters did not provide any additional information
or analysis that would allow us to estimate the impacts on order flow
or the continued operation of NMS Stock ATSs under the new rule and
amendments. Therefore, we cannot quantify the ultimate effect that this
will have on competition and market participant trading costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1490\ See supra Section X.C and supra note 1356; see also
Proposal, supra note 2, at 81118.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) Innovation
As discussed above, the public availability of effective Form ATS-N
and Form ATS-N amendments could result in the disclosure of an NMS
Stock ATS's previously non-public operational information.\1491\ These
disclosures could potentially affect the incentives of NMS Stocks ATSs
to innovate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1491\ See supra Section X.C.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The disclosure of an NMS Stock ATS's innovations in its Form ATS-N
or Form ATS-N amendments could potentially result in certain NMS Stock
ATSs losing their technological advantage. For example, to the extent
that an NMS Stock ATS's competitive advantage in the market is driven
by its matching methodology, the disclosure of this information could
result in other NMS Stock ATSs implementing similar methodologies. On
the one hand, this could potentially reduce the incentives for ATSs to
innovate. For instance, if publicly disclosing an NMS Stock ATS's new
technological innovations results in the ATS earning less revenue from
new innovations it develops, relative to the baseline, the ATS might
lose its incentives to innovate.
On the other hand, the increase in transparency resulting from the
public disclosure of Form ATS-N could foster greater competition for
order flow in the market for NMS Stock ATS execution services. This
greater competition for order flow could in turn incentivize NMS Stock
ATSs to innovate--particularly in terms of their technology--so that
they can attract more trading volume to their venue. For example, if
the public disclosure of technology giving an NMS Stock ATS a
competitive advantage results in the ATS losing that competitive
advantage, the ATS could be forced to innovate and develop new
technology or enhancements in order to attract more trading volume to
its venue. However, if some NMS Stock ATSs cannot innovate fast enough
to regain their competitive advantage in the market, orders might also
flow away from these NMS Stock ATSs, and as a result, these ATSs may
choose to cease operating as ATSs.\1492\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1492\ See supra Section X.C.4.a.i.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We do not have information on the extent to which existing NMS
Stock ATSs or potentially new ATSs rely on a technological advantage,
such as a unique matching methodology, to attract order flow. Nor do we
have information regarding the ability of NMS Stock ATSs to innovate
and replace a competitive advantage it might lose. Additionally,
commenters did not provide any further information or analysis that
would allow us to estimate at what rate NMS Stock ATSs innovate.
Therefore, we cannot quantify the ultimate effect the adopted
amendments will have on innovation.
As discussed above, we have revised the adopted Form ATS-N requests
to not seek disclosure of certain information that could be proprietary
or commercially sensitive, such as routing tables or numerical order
flow segmentation metrics.\1493\ Additionally, in response to
commenters' concerns that making Form ATS-N material amendments public
before the expiration of the Commission's 30-day calendar review
period, at which point material changes could be implemented, could
reduce the incentives for ATSs to innovate or be confusing or
misleading to the public,\1494\ we are modifying the proposed rules for
making Form ATS-N material amendments public. Under the adopted
amendments, the entirety of the material amendment, as amended, will be
made public by the Commission following the Commission's 30-calendar
day review period.\1495\ We believe that these changes, relative to the
Proposal, will reduce the likelihood that details concerning an NMS
Stock ATS's technological innovations are disclosed to competitors
before the ATS has a chance to implement them. Relative to the
Proposal, the ATS might be able to derive greater benefits from new
innovations, which could increase the incentives for NMS Stock ATSs to
innovate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1493\ See supra Section IV.E.2.a.
\1494\ See supra Section IV.E.2.c.
\1495\ The cover page of the filed material amendment will be
made public by the Commission upon filing. See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Four commenters state that the proposed process for declaring a
Form ATS-N ineffective would reduce the incentives to develop new
technological innovations.\1496\ One of these commenters expresses
concern that the process will be used to delay the effectiveness of NMS
Stock ATSs whose features, while meeting regulatory requirements, do
not meet current industry norms.\1497\ The Commission's review process
for declaring a Form ATS-N ineffective could affect the incentives of
an existing or potentially new NMS Stock ATS to innovate. As discussed
above,\1498\ an ineffectiveness declaration could impose costs on an
NMS Stock ATS--such as costs from having to cease operations, roll back
a change in operations, or delay the start of operations. The
uncertainty regarding whether a Form ATS-N featuring a new innovation
will be declared ineffective could discourage or delay existing and
potentially new NMS Stock ATSs from developing or introducing new
technological innovations. Additionally, the extended review for an
initial Form ATS-N could raise the barriers to entry for new NMS Stock
ATSs and reduce the incentives for potentially new ATSs to bring new
innovations to the market.\1499\ However, as discussed in detail
above,\1500\ the Commission's review of Form ATS-N disclosures will not
focus on the merits of the Form ATS-N disclosures. Therefore, to the
extent the disclosures are complete and comprehensible, the
Commission's review process for a Form ATS-N filing that contains
innovative features that do not meet current industry norms should not
take longer or result in an increased chance of the Form ATS-N being
declared ineffective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1496\ See Fidelity Letter at 2-3, 8; KCG Letter at 5, 8;
Luminex Letter at 1; STANY Letter at 2.
\1497\ See Fidelity Letter at 9.
\1498\ See supra Section X.C.1.b.
\1499\ See supra Section X.C.4.a.i.A.
\1500\ See supra Section IV.A.3.b.
\1501\ See supra Section X.C.4.a (``Impact on Efficiency,
Competition, and Capital Formation--Competition'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Efficiency
As discussed above, the heightened disclosure requirements for NMS
Stock ATSs might cause some NMS Stock ATSs to cease operating as ATSs
and either shut down their operation or instead operate as non-ATS OTC
execution venues, such as an OTC trading venue in which the broker-
dealer operator internalizes order flow. This could affect competition
in the market for NMS Stock execution services.\1501\ If it is the case
that the NMS Stock ATSs that cease operating as
[[Page 38906]]
ATSs are the ones that have worse execution quality, the surviving NMS
Stock ATSs might enhance execution quality and allow market
participants to transact at lower prices. If more order flow is
directed towards these remaining NMS Stock ATSs, there could be a
higher likelihood that the orders of buyers and sellers on an NMS Stock
ATS would interact and execute, which could improve liquidity. It is
also possible that the enhanced disclosure from NMS Stock ATSs might
result in more order flow migrating towards national securities
exchanges, which might foster greater order interaction between buyers
and sellers on a national securities exchange, thereby improving price
discovery. Moreover, because some NMS Stock ATSs operate as crossing
networks and derive their prices from national securities exchanges,
greater price discovery on a national securities exchange could spill
over to affect the execution prices on the surviving NMS Stock ATSs and
thereby potentially reduce market participants' trading costs.
Additionally, given the fairly standardized set of information that
will be publicly disclosed on Form ATS-N and that trading in the market
by NMS Stock ATSs might in fact be concentrated on fewer NMS Stock ATSs
as a result of the amendments, market participants might process, and
react more quickly to, information pertaining to changes in an NMS
Stock ATS's operations when evaluating potential trading venues. As
such, the amendments to Regulation ATS might improve market efficiency.
c. Capital Formation
Under the adopted amendments, market participants would be aware of
which NMS Stock ATSs offer better execution services or better
protection against the dissemination of their non-public trading
information, and as a result, these NMS Stock ATSs could attract even
more order flow. Furthermore, to the extent the adopted amendments
appropriately calibrate the level of transparency between NMS Stock
ATSs and national securities exchanges, this would foster greater
competition for order flow of NMS stocks between those trading
platforms. Even if some NMS Stock ATSs cease operating as ATSs, we
believe the enhanced disclosure requirements of the adopted amendments
will assist market participants in obtaining best execution of their
orders. This could lead to lower spreads and thereby foster greater
capital formation and increased market liquidity relative to the
baseline.
D. Reasonable Alternatives
1. Require NMS Stock ATSs to Publicly Disclose Current Form ATS
We could allow NMS Stock ATSs to continue to describe their
operations on current Form ATS, but make Form ATS public either by
posting it on the Commission's website or requiring NMS Stock ATSs to
publicly disclose their initial operation reports, amendments, and
cessation of operations on Form ATS. Non-NMS Stock ATSs' Form ATS
filings would continue to remain confidential.
As described in detail in the Proposal, this alternative would
lower the cost of compliance for current and future NMS Stock ATSs
compared to the adopted amendments, but market participants would
continue to receive limited information regarding how orders interact,
match, and execute on NMS Stock ATSs and the ATS-related activities of
NMS Stock ATSs' broker-dealer operators and their affiliates.\1502\
Public disclosure of Form ATS could have some harmful effects on the
competitive dynamics of NMS Stock ATSs; however, such effects would
likely be smaller than those expected under the adopted amendments.
Regulators' oversight of NMS Stock ATSs under this alternative would
not be improved compared to the baseline, as it would under the adopted
amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1502\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81128-29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Six commenters disagree with our analysis of this
alternative.\1503\ These commenters suggest that we could achieve our
transparency goals by requiring all ATS operators to publicly disclose
Form ATS. For the reasons discussed above and in the Proposal, we
continue to believe that this alternative would reduce the benefits
that would accrue to market participants as compared to the adopted
amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1503\ See Luminex Letter at 2-5; MFA/AIMA Comment Letter at 2;
Morgan Stanley Letter at 2; PDQ Letter at 2; SIFMA Comment Letter at
3; STANY Letter at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Require Form ATS-N But Deem Information Confidential
We could require NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-N with the
Commission, but not make it publicly available. Form ATS-N would
include detailed disclosures about the NMS Stock ATS's operations and
the ATS-related activities of its broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates, and the Commission could declare filings on Form ATS-N
ineffective. As described in detail in the Proposal,\1504\ we believe
that this alternative would improve the quality of NMS Stock ATSs'
disclosures and strengthen the Commission's oversight of NMS Stock
ATSs. However, this alternative would not make NMS Stock ATSs'
operations more transparent for market participants.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1504\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81129.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
No commenters directly remarked on this alternative, and we
continue to believe that this alternative would entail fewer benefits
to market participants as compared to the adopted amendments, because
it would not make NMS Stock ATSs' operations more transparent for
market participants. However, a number of commenters suggest we take a
tiered public disclosure approach and not publicly disclose certain
information on Form ATS-N that is potentially sensitive and of a
proprietary nature.\1505\ We believe that a tiered public disclosure
system for Form ATS-N would still produce the benefits from the
improved quality of NMS Stock ATSs' disclosures and the information
about the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its
affiliates described above. Additionally, the public disclosure of a
portion of Form ATS-N could improve transparency and provide market
participants with more information about an NMS Stock ATS's operations,
which would lower search costs relative to the baseline. Because all of
the information on Form ATS-N would not be made public, the benefits of
increased transparency could be lower under a tiered public disclosure
approach than they would be under the adopted amendments. Therefore,
search costs may be higher and market participants may make less
informed decisions regarding where to route their orders and therefore
result in lower execution quality under a tiered public disclosure
approach than they would obtain under the adopted amendments. However,
the public disclosure costs to ATSs may be lower under a tiered public
disclosure approach, which could result in lower barriers to entry for
new NMS Stock ATSs and fewer Legacy NMS Stock ATSs ceasing to operate
at ATSs than under the adopted amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1505\ See Liquidnet Letter at 8; Luminex Letter at 2; Morgan
Stanley at 2; SSGA Letter at 2; STANY Letter at 3; UBS Letter at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Require NMS Stock ATSs to Publicly Disclose Form ATS-N But Not
Declare Form ATS-N Ineffective
We could require NMS Stock ATSs to file Form ATS-N and make it
public, but continue to use the current notice regime instead of the
process for declaring Form ATS-N ineffective. As described in detail in
the Proposal,\1506\
[[Page 38907]]
relative to the adopted rule, the alternative of maintaining the
current notice regime would lower demand for Commission and staff
resources, could reduce costs for NMS Stock ATSs, and could lower the
barriers to entry for new NMS Stock ATSs. However, it would be more
difficult for the Commission to exercise its oversight responsibilities
and the alternative would not provide the same level of protection to
market participants as the adopted amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1506\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81129.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Two commenters disagree with our analysis of this alternative, and
expressed concerns that the effectiveness determination of Form ATS-N
would be a burdensome process for the Commission.\1507\ They suggest
that these potential costs outweigh the benefits of the review process
under the adopted amendments. We believe that the review process will
contribute towards costs in terms of Commission resources. However, for
the reasons discussed above, we continue to believe that the review
process will provide benefits in terms of mitigating inaccurate and
incomplete disclosures, which could improve investor protection.\1508\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1507\ See Consumer Federation of America Letter at 2, 10-11;
Fidelity Letter at 9.
\1508\ See supra Section IV.A.2 (``Rule 304(a)(1)(ii):
Commission Review Period'')
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Initiate Differing Levels of Public Disclosure Depending on NMS
Stock ATS Characteristics
We could require different levels of disclosure among NMS Stock
ATSs based on dollar trading volume. As described in detail in the
Proposal,\1509\ this could reduce compliance costs relative to the
adopted amendments. However, because a portion of the implementation
costs are fixed and because certain sections of Form ATS-N would not be
applicable to smaller NMS Stock ATSs that are not operated by multi-
service broker-dealer operators and do not engage in other brokerage or
dealing activities, any reduction in compliance costs smaller NMS Stock
ATSs might experience under this alternative could be small.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1509\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81129.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the same time, this alternative could result in a competitive
advantage for small NMS Stock ATSs, because it could give them more
time to innovate without having to disclose such innovation to
competitors.\1510\ This could give small NMS Stock ATSs an advantage in
attracting order flow relative to large NMS Stock ATSs, which could
spill over to market participants that execute on these ATSs, by
increasing the execution quality of their trades. Nonetheless, because
broker-dealer operators could have the incentive to allocate order flow
to multiple NMS Stock ATSs to avoid reaching threshold volumes, this
alternative could create some information opacity in the market, which
could lead to lower execution quality for market participants relative
to the adopted amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1510\ See id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter expressed concerns about applying different levels of
disclosure based on metrics such as trading volume, mentioning that
Form ATS-N is not sufficiently onerous relative to Form ATS to justify
small-scale exemptions.\1511\ Contrary to this concern, another
commenter stated that the disclosure requirements should apply to
larger ATSs with a ``substantial market footprint'' to avoid
discouraging competitive innovations among NMS Stock ATSs.\1512\
Although compliance costs may be lessened if small stock ATSs are
required to provide less disclosure on Form ATS-N, (i.e., ATSs with
lower trading volume), this reduction in compliance costs could be
small.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1511\ See CFA Institute Letter at 3.
\1512\ See STANY Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Requiring less disclosure from small NMS Stock ATSs might also
result in greater innovation relative to the adopted amendments.
However, we continue to believe that requiring less disclosure from
low-volume NMS Stock ATSs could reduce the benefits market participants
receive from the greater transparency about the operations of NMS Stock
ATSs and the ATS-related activities of their broker-dealer operators
and their affiliates. This could increase market participant search
costs when evaluating potential NMS stock trading venues, which could
result in market participants making less informed decisions about
which trading venue aligns with their investing or trading objectives.
5. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Register as National Securities Exchanges
and Become SROs
We could eliminate the exemption from the definition of
``exchange'' for NMS Stock ATSs under Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a) so
that an NMS Stock ATS would be required to register as a national
securities exchange and become an SRO. While commenters did not remark
on this alternative, we continue to believe that, as described in
detail in the Proposal,\1513\ this alternative would provide market
participants with more information about priority, order interaction,
display, and execution procedures, which would help them make better
informed decisions about where to route their orders for best
execution. Competition among and between trading venues could increase,
leading to greater market liquidity and market efficiency. Further,
this alternative could strengthen Commission oversight, thus
benefitting market participants.
However, this alternative would create high startup costs and high
ongoing operational costs for NMS Stock ATSs compared to the adopted
amendments.\1514\ We continue to believe that these costs to NMS Stock
ATSs would be significant.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1513\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81129-30.
\1514\ Newly registered national securities exchanges must
establish appropriate surveillance and disciplinary mechanisms, and
as a result incur start-up costs associated with such obligations,
such as writing a rule book. See Regulation ATS Adopting Release,
supra note 3, at 70907. Furthermore, the cost of acquiring the
necessary assets and the operating funds to carry out the day-to-day
functions of a national securities exchange are significant.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. Discontinue Quarterly Volume Reports on Form ATS-R
We could amend Regulation ATS so that NMS Stock ATSs would no
longer be required to file quarterly volume reports on Form ATS-R. As
described in detail in the Proposal,\1515\ we believe this alternative
could result in reduced costs for NMS Stock ATSs, because they would no
longer be required to prepare a quarterly Form ATS-R in addition to
their Form ATS-N. However, some competitively sensitive information
contained on Form ATS-R, such as the ATS's subscriber list and the list
of persons granted, denied, or limited access during the reporting
period--which is not solicited under adopted Form ATS-N, would be made
public on Form ATS-N. Making such information public could harm the NMS
Stock ATS as well as persons denied access.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1515\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81130.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One commenter suggested that in light of information on FINRA's
website regarding ATSs,\1516\ and the detailed disclosures in periodic
disclosures that would be required by proposed Form ATS-N, we should no
longer require an NMS Stock ATS to file Form ATS-R.\1517\ However, this
commenter did not suggest that the information that is contained on
Form ATS-R and not included on FINRA's website or Form ATS-N,\1518\
such as the ATS's subscriber list and the list of persons granted,
denied, or limited access during the reporting period, should be
[[Page 38908]]
included in Form ATS-N. If ATSs were no longer required to file Form
ATS-R and this information was not made available in Form ATS-N, then
the Commission could lose efficient access to information available in
the form that helps it oversee and monitor the trading activity of NMS
Stock ATSs.\1519\ This loss of efficiency could reduce the benefits of
Commission oversight, which could reduce investor protection relative
to today.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1516\ See supra note 15.
\1517\ See SIFMA Letter at 8 n.16.
\1518\ See supra note 259.
\1519\ See supra Section III.B.5 (``Rule 301(b)(9): Form ATS-R
Quarterly Reports'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Require NMS Stock ATSs To Operate as Limited Purpose Entities
We could amend Regulation ATS to require an NMS Stock ATS to
operate as a ``stand-alone'' entity, which would exist only to operate
the ATS and have no affiliation with any broker-dealer that seeks to
execute proprietary or agency orders on the NMS Stock ATS. Under this
alternative, NMS Stock ATSs would be required to publicly disclose Form
ATS-N, Form ATS-N amendments, and notices of cessation on Form ATS-N,
and would be limited purpose entities that could not engage in any
activities other than operation of the ATS. This alternative would
prohibit the broker-dealer operator of the NMS Stock ATS from engaging
in any other broker-dealer activity, and would consequently prohibit
the operation of an NMS Stock ATS by a multi-service broker-dealer.
While commenters did not remark on this alternative, we continue to
believe that, as described in detail in the Proposal,\1520\ the benefit
of this alternative would be to eliminate potential conflicts of
interest, but that this alternative might discourage broker-dealers
from creating and operating innovative NMS Stock ATS platforms, and
instead drive them to execute their own proprietary trades internally
on their other broker-dealer systems. In addition, many broker-dealers
might choose to file a cessation of operations report and shut down the
operations of their NMS Stock ATS,\1521\ resulting in similar (though
potentially more severe) effects on the competitive dynamics of the ATS
market as under the adopted amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1520\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81130.
\1521\ Alternatively, current broker-dealer operators of ATSs
that trade NMS stocks may choose to spin-off or sell their ATS
rather than cease operations. The expected number of broker-dealer
operators selling their ATSs at once could affect the value the
broker-dealer operator could receive from the sale and, as such,
could factor into the decision of whether to spin-off, sell, or fold
their ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Prohibit Broker-Dealer Operators and Affiliates From Trading on the
NMS Stock ATS
Several commenters believe that the increased disclosure
requirements on Form ATS-N concerning the ATS-related activities of the
broker-dealer operator and its affiliates do not do enough to reduce
conflicts of interest and suggested that we prohibit conflicts of
interest altogether on NMS Stock ATSs.\1522\ Under this alternative,
the broker-dealer operator could continue to act as a broker-dealer
operator of an NMS Stock ATS and engage in non-ATS functions, but would
be subject to new requirements designed to limit potential conflicts of
interest. These requirements would include a prohibition on trading on
the NMS Stock ATS by the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1522\ See Better Markets Letter at 5-6; Consumer Federation of
America Letter at 7-8; HMA Letter at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We believe that banning conflicts of interest, as opposed to
increasing disclosure of relationships between the ATS and the broker-
dealer operator and the broker-dealer operator's affiliates, could be
potentially harmful. Multi-service broker-dealers, that is, broker-
dealers who have operations and activities in addition to the ATS may
be more prone to having conflicts of interest, and therefore, banning
conflicts of interest could result in these broker-dealers ceasing to
operate their ATSs.\1523\ Therefore, we believe that this approach
suggested by these commenters could have substantially deleterious
effects on liquidity provision, and for this reason, we are maintaining
our approach in the adopted amendment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1523\ See supra Section X.C.4.a.i.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. Lower the Fair Access Threshold for NMS Stock ATSs
NMS Stock ATSs are not required to provide fair access to the
services of the NMS Stock ATS unless the ATS reaches the 5% trading
volume threshold in a stock under Rule 301(b)(5) of Regulation
ATS.\1524\ We could lower the fair access threshold under Rule
301(b)(5) of Regulation ATS \1525\ for NMS Stock ATSs to a level
sufficiently low that most NMS Stock ATSs would be prohibited from
engaging in many discriminatory practices.\1526\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1524\ See supra Section II.C.
\1525\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(5).
\1526\ As discussed above in Section II.C, the requirements of
Rule 301(b)(5) that prohibit or limit discriminatory practices of
ATSs only apply to NMS Stock ATSs that cross the fair access
threshold, and then, apply only with respect to the NMS stocks in
which an ATS crosses the threshold.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As described in detail in the Proposal,\1527\ we believe that there
would be fewer benefits under this alternative because the fair access
requirements would apply only to the NMS stocks for which the NMS Stock
ATS had crossed the fair access threshold. We could address that
situation by proposing further amendments to the fair access
requirements. However, we believe that the disclosures that would be
required by Form ATS-N requirements would be a cost effective and
simpler approach than proposing fundamental revisions to the fair
access requirements that would achieve the aim of providing market
participants with information to better assess NMS Stock ATSs as
potential trading venues.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1527\ See Proposal, supra note 2, at 81131.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
No commenters directly commented on this alternative, and we
continue to believe it would result in fewer benefits than the adopted
amendments. However, one commenter recommended as an alternative that,
in addition to the adopted amendments, we should also eliminate the 5%
fair access threshold for NMS Stock ATSs, i.e., reduce the fair access
threshold to zero, because the current volume threshold creates a
competitive imbalance between exchanges--which are subject to fair
access requirements--and NMS Stock ATSs.\1528\ Under the commenter's
alternative, if the fair access threshold were eliminated, then all NMS
Stock ATSs would need to meet the requirements of Rule 301(b)(5) that
prohibit or limit discriminatory practices of ATSs.\1529\ Because the
commenter's alternative would include the adopted amendments and the
public disclosure of Form ATS-N, the operational transparency for NMS
Stock ATSs would still increase, bringing it more in line with the
operational transparency for national securities exchanges. In
addition, imposing fair access requirements on all NMS Stock ATSs could
further reduce conflicts of interest on ATSs, relative to the adopted
amendments, because an ATS might not be able to offer preferential
treatment to certain subscribers. However, the increased costs of fair
access compliance could cause more ATSs to cease operating as ATSs.
More ATSs ceasing to operate as ATSs may cause an increase in the
internalization of order flow, which could reduce price informativeness
and increase trading costs.\1530\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1528\ See Citadel Letter at 2-3.
\1529\ See supra Section II.C.
\1530\ See supra Section X.B.6.a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38909]]
10. Requirements To Disclose Aggregate Platform-Wide Order Flow and
Execution Statistics to all Subscribers
We could eliminate the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to disclose
aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution statistics that the
ATS publishes or otherwise provides to one or more subscribers that are
not disclosed pursuant to Rule 605 of Regulation NMS from Form ATS-N.
An advantage of this approach is that NMS Stock ATSs may be motivated
to continue to provide order flow and execution statistics to
subscribers under this alternative.\1531\ However, relative to the
adopted amendments, this approach may fail to mitigate the problem of
differential access to information about ATS operations and activities
across market participants, resulting in some market participants
making less-informed decisions about how to obtain best execution for
themselves and their clients.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1531\ Two commenters agree with our assessment under this
alternative that eliminating the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to
disclose aggregate platform-wide order flow and execution statistics
that the ATS publishes or otherwise provides to one or more
subscribers that are not disclosed pursuant to Rule 605 of
Regulation NMS could be beneficial to subscribers because it may
motivate NMS Stock ATSs to continue to provide order flow and
execution statistics to subscribers. See MFA/AIMA Letter at 5; SIFMA
Letter at 27.
The same commenters also suggest that eliminating these
requirements could result in ATSs continuing to send customized
reports and bespoke statistics to their clients. See MFA/AIMA Letter
at 5; SIFMA Letter at 27. Under the adopted amendments disclosure
requirements under Part III, Item 26 would not apply when an NMS
Stock ATS provides a participant with individualized or custom
reports containing data relating to that participant's specific
usage of the ATS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. Specify Alternative Structured Formats for Form ATS-N
We could specify alternative structured formats such as Inline
XBRL, or FIXML.\1532\ The benefit of Inline XBRL is that it provides
more sophisticated validation, presentation and reference features for
filers and users. However, we do not believe that Inline XBRL is yet in
common use by all entities that would be filing Form ATS-N. To use
Inline XBRL with Form ATS-N, the Commission would have to design a new
Commission-specific taxonomy for the Form ATS-N disclosures. While the
Inline XBRL, FIXML, and XML formats would all require the use of an
XML-based schema, Inline XBRL would require the additional familiarity
with the Commission-specific taxonomy that is not necessary for the
relatively simple disclosure requirements of Form ATS-N. FIXML is a
format designed and used for expressing trading information, and while
familiar to NMS Stock ATSs, it is not widely used by the public. The
end users of Form ATS-N data will likely incur upfront costs to learn
and use FIXML, unlike the widely used and freely available XML format.
For these reasons, we believe that the XML format would minimize costs
relative to filers having to file Form ATS-N using these other
structured formats.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1532\ One commenter recommends that we structure Form ATS-N so
that it breaks out the required information on NMS Stock ATS
operations in a format that is comparable across ATSs. It also
suggests we might also consider ways to present information that
would improve the readability and navigability of disclosure through
the use of technology such as hyperlinks and/or XBRL technology. See
Fidelity Letter at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. Specify Other Filings Methods for Form ATS-N
We could require NMS Stock ATSs to use the EFFS/SRTS system
currently used for other NMS filings instead of EDGAR. While commenters
did not remark on this alternative, the primary benefit of this
alternative approach would be that ATSs would likely be familiar with
the web fillable forms and related filing process on EFFS/SRTS.
Relative to the adopted amendments, learning the EDGAR filing process
may pose an initial transition burden, although the larger NMS Stock
ATSs may already be familiar with the EDGAR filing process, and the
completion of web fillable forms in EDGAR would be very similar to the
EFFS/SRTS experience without the additional burden of an annual digital
signature certification. Finally, the time and effort of filing as
proposed would be incrementally more costly to NMS Stock ATSs because
each narrative response would have to be individually uploaded as a
separate exhibit, as opposed to providing all of their narrative
responses within one structured XML file or completing all narrative
responses in one web-fillable form. Moreover, because the EFFS system
does not support the open-source XML format, but rather a proprietary
XML implementation called XFDL, the EFFS system has fewer validation
capabilities than EDGAR, particularly at the element level. As a
result, some NMS Stock ATSs might inadvertently submit incomplete or
inconsistently formatted information that is not discovered until after
Commission staff review, which would then require the NMS Stock ATS to
spend additional time to refile the information. We believe this would
result in extra costs in filing Form ATS-N through EFFS/SRTS relative
to requiring NMS Stock ATSs to filing Form ATS-N through EDGAR.
XI. Regulatory Flexibility Act Certification
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (``RFA'') \1533\ requires Federal
agencies, in promulgating rules, to consider the impact of those rules
on small entities. We certified in the Proposal, pursuant to Section
605(b) of the RFA,\1534\ that the amendments to Regulation ATS would
not, if adopted, have a significant economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. We included this certification in Section XV
of the Proposing Release. Although we encouraged written comments
regarding this certification, no commenters responded to this request.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1533\ 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.
\1534\ 5 U.S.C. 605(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For purposes of Commission rulemaking in connection with the
RFA,\1535\ a small entity includes a broker or dealer that: (1) Had
total capital (net worth plus subordinated liabilities) of less than
$500,000 on the date in the prior fiscal year as of which its audited
financial statements were prepared pursuant to Rule 17a-5(d) under the
Exchange Act,\1536\ or, if not required to file such statements, a
broker-dealer with total capital (net worth plus subordinated
liabilities) of less than $500,000 on the last day of the preceding
fiscal year (or in the time that it has been in business, if shorter);
and (2) is not affiliated with any person (other than a natural person)
that is not a small business or small organization.\1537\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1535\ Although Section 601(b) of the RFA defines the term
``small entity,'' the statute permits agencies to formulate their
own definitions. We have adopted definitions for the term ``small
entity'' for the purposes of Commission rulemaking in accordance
with the RFA. Those definitions, as relevant to this rulemaking, are
set forth in Rule 0-10 under the Exchange Act, 17 CFR 240.0-10. See
Exchange Act Release No. 18451 (January 28, 1982), 47 FR 5215
(February 4, 1982) (File No. AS-305).
\1536\ 17 CFR 240.17a-5(d).
\1537\ See 17 CFR 240.0-10(c). See also 17 CFR 240.0-10(i)
(providing that a broker or dealer is affiliated with another person
if: such broker or dealer controls, is controlled by, or is under
common control with such other person; a person shall be deemed to
control another person if that person has the right to vote 25
percent or more of the voting securities of such other person or is
entitled to receive 25 percent or more of the net profits of such
other person or is otherwise able to direct or cause the direction
of the management or policies of such other person; or such broker
or dealer introduces transactions in securities, other than
registered investment company securities or interests or
participations in insurance company separate accounts, to such other
person, or introduces accounts of customers or other brokers or
dealers, other than accounts that hold only registered investment
company securities or interests or participations in insurance
company separate accounts, to such other person that carries such
accounts on a fully disclosed basis).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All ATSs, including NMS Stock ATSs, would continue to have to
[[Page 38910]]
register as broker-dealers.\1538\ We examined recent FOCUS data for the
41 broker-dealers that currently operate ATSs that trade NMS stocks and
concluded that no more than 5 of the broker-dealer operators of ATSs
that currently trade NMS stocks had total capital of less than $500,000
on the last day of the preceding fiscal year (or in the time that it
has been in business, if shorter) and were not affiliated with any
person that is not a small business or small organization. Three of
these five entities, however, never reported transactions in any
security, including NMS stocks, to the Commission since filing an
initial operations report on Form ATS. Therefore, we believe that it is
unlikely that these three entities would complete a Form ATS-N to
operate as an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to Rule 304.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1538\ 17 CFR 242.301(b)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The remaining two entities include one broker-dealer that operates
an ATS pursuant to an active Form ATS on file with the Commission and
has reported transactions in NMS stocks to the Commission. The other
broker-dealer has filed an initial operation report on Form ATS with
the Commission and noticed its intention to trade NMS stocks; however,
this ATS has not yet commenced operations. We do not believe that Rule
304, including the requirement for NMS Stock ATSs to file a Form ATS-N,
will represent a significant economic impact on these two entities.
Stand-alone broker-dealers that operate an ATS, such as these two
entities, will have less complex ATS operations than multi-service
broker-dealers that operate an ATS. For example, we believe that these
two entities would not need to respond to all requests in Part II of
Form ATS-N because they are not likely to engage in the same ATS-
related activities as multi-service broker-dealers that operate an ATS.
As a result, we expect that the burden associated with completing the
form would be substantially lower for these two ATS.\1539\ In addition,
because we believe that the two ATSs are operationally less complex
than ATSs operated by multi-service broker-dealer operators, the burden
to respond to the items under Part III of Form ATS-N (Manner of ATS
Operations) \1540\ would be lower than for the average NMS Stock ATS
operated by a multi-service broker-dealer operator.\1541\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1539\ As estimated in the PRA, we estimate an average total
cost of $41,689.10 for the initial hour burden of complying with
Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and 304 of Regulation ATS (including
completing Form ATS-N). The burden hours associated with Part II of
Form ATS-N is 29 hours. See supra note 1228. We estimate that ATSs
that are small entities would likely need to complete approximately
half of Part II. Thus, the reduction of 14.5 burden hours (29 hours
x 0.5 = 14.5 hours) would result in a cost savings of $5,155 for
each small entity compared to the average total cost estimate.
(Attorney 7.5 hours x $406) + (Compliance Manager 6.0 hours x $302)
+ (Senior Marketing Manager 1 hour x $298) = $5,155.
\1540\ For example, based on Commission experience, less
operationally complex ATS may not need to respond to all or part of
the requests in Part III of Form ATS-N, such as Item 5 (Means of
Entry), Item 6 (Connectivity and Co-location), Item 7 (Order Types
and Attributes), Item 9 (Conditional Orders and Indications of
Interest), Item 13 (Segmentation; Notice), Item 14 (Counter-Party
Selection), among others. In addition, a smaller NMS Stock ATS is
unlikely to exceed the volume thresholds that would subject the ATS
to the requirements of Rule 301(b)(3) and 301(b)(5) of Regulation
ATS, and therefore, Part III, Items 24 and 25 would be inapplicable.
These items represent 36 burden hours above the current baseline for
an initial operation report on current Form ATS. These 36 burden
hours represent a cost of approximately $11,846 for each ATS that
would likely be substantially reduced for these two small entities.
(Attorney 12.25 hours x $406) + (Compliance Manager 11.25 hours x
$302) + (Senior Systems Analyst 12.5 hours x $278) = $11,846. As
noted above, the we estimate an average total cost of $41,689.10 for
the initial hour burden of complying with Rules 301(b)(2)(viii) and
304 of Regulation ATS (including completing Form ATS-N).
\1541\ If the three inactive ATSs discussed above in this
section (which we expect would not complete a Form ATS-N) were to
complete a Form ATS-N, they would experience a substantially reduced
burden in completing Form ATS-N given that they also are not multi-
service broker-dealers, and their systems are less complex than
other NMS Stock ATSs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are also amending Rule 301(b)(10) to require that all ATSs
reduce to writing their safeguards and procedures to protect
subscribers' confidential trading information and their oversight
procedures to ensure that such safeguards and procedures are followed.
The amendment to Rule 301(b)(10) would thus apply to the 15 small
entities that are ATSs (including NMS Stock and non-NMS Stock ATSs),
but we believe that there would not be significant economic impact on
these entities because, based on our experience, most of these ATSs
already maintain their Rule 301(b)(10) safeguards and procedures in
writing, and to the extent they do not, any resulting burden is
small.\1542\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1542\ In the Proposal, we estimated that 15 of the 84 ATS at
that time might not have these procedures in writing. See Proposal,
supra note 2, at 81093. We did not receive any comments on this
estimate. The PRA burden for an ATS to put in writing its procedures
protect subscribers' confidential trading information, and the
oversight procedures to ensure such safeguards and procedures are
followed, would be approximately 8 hours, which represents $2,910 in
costs for each ATS. (Attorney 7 hours x $406) + (Compliance Clerk 1
hour x $68) = $2,910.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consequently, for these reasons, for purposes of the RFA, we
certify that the amendments to Regulation ATS would not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
XII. Statutory Authority and Text of Amendments
Pursuant to Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. 78a et seq., and particularly
Sections [3(b), 5, 6, 11A, 15, 17(a), 17(b), 19, 23(a), and 36 thereof
(15 U.S.C. 78c, 78k-1, 78o, 78q(a), 78q(b), 78w(a), and 78mm)], the
Commission adopts Form ATS-N under the Exchange Act, to amend Rule 3a1-
1(a) and Regulation ATS under the Exchange Act, and to amend 17 CFR
200.30-33.
List of Subjects in 17 CFR Parts 232, 240, 242 and 249
Brokers, Confidential business information, Fraud, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements, Securities.
For the reasons stated in the preamble, title 17, chapter II of the
Code of Federal Regulations is amended as follows:
PART 232--REGULATION S-T--GENERAL RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR
ELECTRONIC FILINGS
0
1. The general authority citation for part 232 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 15 U.S.C. 77c, 77f, 77g, 77h, 77j, 77s(a), 77z-3,
77sss(a), 78c(b), 78l, 78m, 78n, 78o(d), 78w(a), 78ll, 80a-6(c),
80a-8, 80a-29, 80a-30, 80a-37, 7201 et seq.; and 18 U.S.C. 1350,
unless otherwise noted.
* * * * *
0
2. Amend Sec. 232.101 by adding paragraph (a)(1)(xxi) to read as
follows:
Sec. 232.101 Mandated electronic submissions and exceptions.
(a) * * *
(1) * * *
(xxi) Form ATS-N (Sec. 249.640 of this chapter).
* * * * *
PART 240--GENERAL RULES AND REGULATIONS, SECURITIES ACT OF 1934
0
3. The general authority citation for part 240 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 15 U.S.C. 77c, 77d, 77g, 77j, 77s, 77z-2, 77z-3,
77eee, 77ggg, 77nnn, 77sss, 77ttt, 78c, 78c-3, 78c-5, 78d, 78e, 78f,
78g, 78i, 78j, 78j-1, 78k, 78k-1, 78l, 78m, 78n, 78n-1, 78o, 78o-4,
78o-10, 78p, 78q, 78q-1, 78s, 78u-5, 78w, 78x, 78ll, 78mm, 80a-20,
80a-23, 80a-29, 80a-37, 80b-3, 80b-4, 80b-11, 7201 et seq.; and
8302; 7 U.S.C. 2(c)(2)(E); 12 U.S.C. 5221(e)(3); 18 U.S.C. 1350; and
Pub. L. 111-203, 939A, 124 Stat. 1887 (2010); and secs. 503 and 602,
Pub. L. 112-106, 126 Stat. 326 (2012), unless otherwise noted.
* * * * *
[[Page 38911]]
Sec. 240.3a1-1 [Amended]
0
4. Amend Sec. 240.3a1-1 by removing ``242.303'' from paragraphs (a)(2)
and (3) and adding in its place ``242.304''.
PART 242--REGULATIONS M, SHO, ATS, AC, NMS, AND SBSR AND CUSTOMER
MARGIN REQUIREMENTS FOR SECURITY FUTURES
0
5. The authority citation for part 242 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 15 U.S.C. 77g, 77q(a), 77s(a), 78b, 78c, 78g(c)(2),
78i(a), 78j, 78k-1(c), 78l, 78m, 78n, 78o(b), 78o(c), 78o(g),
78q(a), 78q(b), 78q(h), 78w(a), 78dd-1, 78mm, 80a-23, 80a-29, and
80a-37.
0
6. Amend Sec. 242.300 by:
0
a. In paragraph (f) introductory text, adding the phrase ``the broker-
dealer of'' before the phrase ``an alternative trading system''
wherever it occurs;
0
b. In paragraphs (f)(2) and (3), adding the phrase ``the broker-dealer
of'' before the phrase ``the alternative trading system''; and
0
c. Adding paragraph (k) to read as follows:
Sec. 242.300 Definitions.
* * * * *
(k) NMS Stock ATS means an alternative trading system, as defined
in paragraph (a) of this section, that trades NMS stocks, as defined in
paragraph (g) of this section.
0
7. Amend Sec. 242.301 by:
0
a. In paragraph (a)(5), adding the phrase ``or Sec. 242.304'' after
the phrase ``paragraph (b) of this section'';
0
b. In paragraph (b)(2)(i), removing the phrase ``, or if the
alternative trading system is operating as of April 21, 1999, no later
than May 11, 1999'';
0
c. In paragraph (b)(2)(vii), removing the phrase ``Market Regulation,
Stop 10-2'' and in its place adding ``Trading and Markets'';
0
d. Adding paragraph (b)(2)(viii);
0
e. In paragraph (b)(9)(i), adding the word ``Separately'' before the
word ``File'' and changing the first letter of the word ``File'' to
lower case and adding the phrase ``for transactions in NMS stocks, as
defined in paragraph (g) of this section, and transactions in
securities other than NMS stocks'' after the phrase ``(Sec. 249.638 of
this chapter)'';
0
f. In paragraph (b)(9)(ii), adding the word ``Separately'' before the
word ``File'' and changing the first letter of the word ``File'' to
lower case and adding the phrase ``for transactions in NMS stocks and
transactions in securities other than NMS stocks'' after the phrase
``required by Form ATS-R'';
0
g. In the heading of paragraph (b)(10), adding the word ``Written''
before the phrase ``Procedures to ensure the confidential treatment of
trading information'' and changing the first letter of the word
``Procedures'' to lower case;
0
h. In paragraph (b)(10)(i) introductory text, adding the word
``written'' before the word ``safeguards'' in both instances and adding
the word ``written'' before the word ``procedures'' in both instances;
and
0
i. In paragraph (b)(10)(ii), adding the word ``written'' before the
word ``oversight'' and adding the word ``written'' before the word
``safeguards''.
The addition reads as follows:
Sec. 242.301 Requirements for alternative trading systems.
* * * * *
(b) * * *
(2) * * *
(viii) An NMS Stock ATS that is operating pursuant to an initial
operation report on Form ATS on file with the Commission as of January
7, 2019 (``Legacy NMS Stock ATS'') shall be subject to the requirements
of paragraphs (b)(2)(i) through (vii) of this section until that ATS
files an initial Form ATS-N with the Commission pursuant to Sec.
242.304(a)(1)(iv)(A). Thereafter, the Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall file
reports pursuant to Sec. 242.304. An alternative trading system that
trades NMS stocks and securities other than NMS stocks shall be subject
to the requirements of Sec. 242.304 of this chapter with respect to
NMS stocks and paragraph (b)(2) of this section with respect to non-NMS
stocks. As of January 7, 2019, an entity seeking to operate as an NMS
Stock ATS shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs
(b)(2)(i) through (vii) of this section and shall file reports pursuant
to Sec. 242.304.
* * * * *
0
8. Amend Sec. 242.303 by:
0
a. In paragraph (a) introductory text, removing ``(b)(9)'' and adding
in its place ``(b)(8)'';
0
b. Adding paragraph (a)(1)(v); and
0
c. In paragraph (a)(2)(ii), adding the phrase ``or Sec. 242.304''
after the phrase ``paragraph (b)(2) of Sec. 242.301''.
The addition reads as follows:
Sec. 242.303 Record preservation requirements for alternative trading
systems.
(a) * * *
(1) * * *
(v) At least one copy of the written safeguards and written
procedures to protect subscribers' confidential trading information and
the written oversight procedures created in the course of complying
with paragraph (b)(10) of Sec. 242.301.
* * * * *
0
9. Add Sec. 242.304 under the undesignated center heading Regulation
ATS--Alternative Trading Systems to read as follows:
Sec. 242.304 NMS Stock ATSs.
(a) Conditions to the exemption. Unless not required to comply with
Regulation ATS pursuant to Sec. 242.301(a), an NMS Stock ATS must
comply with Sec. Sec. 242.300 through 242.304 (except Sec.
242.301(b)(2)(i) through (vii)) to be exempt pursuant to Sec. 240.3a1-
1(a)(2).
(1) Initial Form ATS-N. (i) Filing and effectiveness requirement.
No exemption is available to an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to Sec.
240.3a1-1(a)(2) unless the NMS Stock ATS files with the Commission an
initial Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions of this section,
and the initial Form ATS-N is effective pursuant to paragraph
(a)(1)(iii) or (a)(1)(iv)(A) of this section.
(ii) Commission review period. (A) The Commission may, by order, as
provided in paragraph (a)(1)(iii) of this section, declare an initial
Form ATS-N filed by an NMS Stock ATS ineffective no later than 120
calendar days from the date of filing with the Commission, or, if
applicable, the end of the extended review period. The Commission may
extend the initial Form ATS-N review period for:
(1) An additional 90 calendar days, if the Form ATS-N is unusually
lengthy or raises novel or complex issues that require additional time
for review, in which case the Commission will notify the NMS Stock ATS
in writing within the initial 120-calendar day review period and will
briefly describe the reason for the determination for which additional
time for review is required; or
(2) Any extended review period to which a duly authorized
representative of the NMS Stock ATS agrees in writing.
(B) During review by the Commission of the initial Form ATS-N, the
NMS Stock ATS shall amend its initial Form ATS-N pursuant to the
requirements of paragraphs (a)(2)(i)(B) and (C) of this section. To
make material changes to its initial Form ATS-N during the Commission
review period, the NMS Stock ATS shall withdraw its filed initial Form
ATS-N and may refile an initial Form ATS-N pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)
of this section.
(iii) Effectiveness; Ineffectiveness determination. (A) An initial
Form ATS-N, as amended, filed by an NMS Stock ATS will become
effective, unless declared ineffective, upon the earlier of:
(1) The completion of review by the Commission and publication
pursuant to paragraph (b)(2)(i) of this section; or
[[Page 38912]]
(2) The expiration of the review period, or, if applicable, the end
of the extended review period, pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)(ii) of this
section.
(B) The Commission will, by order, declare an initial Form ATS-N
ineffective if it finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that
such action is necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is
consistent with the protection of investors. If the Commission declares
an initial Form ATS-N ineffective, the NMS Stock ATS shall be
prohibited from operating as an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to Sec.
240.3a1-1(a)(2). An initial Form ATS-N declared ineffective does not
prevent the NMS Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form ATS-N.
(iv) Transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs. (A) Initial Form ATS-N
filing requirements. A Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall file with the
Commission an initial Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions of
this section, no earlier than January 7, 2019, and no later than
February 8, 2019. An initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
shall supersede and replace for purposes of the exemption the
previously filed Form ATS of the Legacy NMS Stock ATS. The Legacy NMS
Stock ATS may operate, on a provisional basis, pursuant to the filed
initial Form ATS-N, and any amendments thereto, during the review of
the initial Form ATS-N by the Commission. An initial Form ATS-N filed
by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS, as amended, will become effective, unless
declared ineffective, upon the earlier of:
(1) The completion of review by the Commission and publication
pursuant to paragraph (b)(2)(i) of this section; or
(2) The expiration of the review period, or, if applicable, the end
of the extended review period, pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)(iv)(B) of
this section.
(B) Commission review period; Ineffectiveness determination. The
Commission may, by order, as provided in paragraph (a)(1)(iii) of this
section, declare an initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS
ineffective no later than 120 calendar days from the date of filing
with the Commission, or, if applicable, the end of the extended review
period. The Commission may extend the initial Form ATS-N review period
for a Legacy NMS Stock ATS for:
(1) An additional 120 calendar days if the initial Form ATS-N is
unusually lengthy or raises novel or complex issues that require
additional time for review, in which case the Commission will notify
the Legacy NMS Stock ATS in writing within the initial 120-calendar day
review period and will briefly describe the reason for the
determination for which additional time for review is required; or
(2) Any extended review period to which a duly-authorized
representative of the Legacy NMS Stock ATS agrees in writing.
(C) Amendments to initial Form ATS-N. During review by the
Commission of the initial Form ATS-N filed by a Legacy NMS Stock ATS,
the Legacy NMS Stock ATS shall amend its initial Form ATS-N pursuant to
the requirements of paragraphs (a)(2)(i)(A) through (D) of this
section.
(2) Form ATS-N amendment. (i) Filing requirements. An NMS Stock ATS
shall amend a Form ATS-N, in accordance with the conditions of this
section:
(A) At least 30 calendar days, except as provided by paragraph
(a)(2)(i)(D) of this section, prior to the date of implementation of a
material change to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or to the
activities of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates that are
subject to disclosure on Form ATS-N (``Material Amendment'');
(B) No later than 30 calendar days after the end of each calendar
quarter to correct information that has become inaccurate or incomplete
for any reason and was not required to be reported to the Commission as
a Form ATS-N amendment pursuant to paragraphs (a)(2)(i)(A), (C), or (D)
of this section (``Updating Amendment'');
(C) Promptly, to correct information in any previous disclosure on
Form ATS-N, after discovery that any information previously filed on
Form ATS-N was materially inaccurate or incomplete when filed
(``Correcting Amendment''); or
(D) No later than seven calendar days after information required to
be disclosed in Part III, Items 24 and 25 on Form ATS-N has become
inaccurate or incomplete (``Order Display and Fair Access Amendment'').
(ii) Commission review period; Ineffectiveness determination. The
Commission will, by order, declare ineffective any Form ATS-N amendment
filed pursuant to paragraphs (a)(2)(i)(A) through (D) of this section,
no later than 30 calendar days from filing with the Commission, if the
Commission finds that such action is necessary or appropriate in the
public interest, and is consistent with the protection of investors. A
Form ATS-N amendment declared ineffective shall prohibit the NMS Stock
ATS from operating pursuant to the ineffective Form ATS-N amendment. A
Form ATS-N amendment declared ineffective does not prevent the NMS
Stock ATS from subsequently filing a new Form ATS-N amendment. During
review by the Commission of a Material Amendment, the NMS Stock ATS
shall amend the Material Amendment pursuant to the requirements of
paragraphs (a)(2)(i)(B) through (C) of this section. To make material
changes to a filed Material Amendment during the Commission review
period, an NMS Stock ATS shall withdraw its filed Material Amendment
and must file the new Material Amendment pursuant to (a)(2)(i)(A) of
this section.
(3) Notice of cessation. An NMS Stock ATS shall notice its
cessation of operations on Form ATS-N at least 10 business days prior
to the date the NMS Stock ATS will cease to operate as an NMS Stock
ATS. The notice of cessation shall cause the Form ATS-N to become
ineffective on the date designated by the NMS Stock ATS.
(4) Suspension, limitation, and revocation of the exemption from
the definition of exchange. (i) The Commission will, by order, if it
finds, after notice and opportunity for hearing, that such action is
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, and is consistent with
the protection of investors, suspend for a period not exceeding twelve
months, limit, or revoke the exemption for an NMS Stock ATS pursuant to
Sec. 240.3a1-1(a)(2) of this chapter.
(ii) If the exemption for an NMS Stock ATS is suspended or revoked
pursuant to paragraph (a)(4)(i) of this section, the NMS Stock ATS
shall be prohibited from operating pursuant to the exemption pursuant
to Sec. 240.3a1-1(a)(2) of this chapter. If the exemption for an NMS
Stock ATS is limited pursuant to paragraph (a)(4)(i) of this section,
the NMS Stock ATS shall be prohibited from operating in a manner
otherwise inconsistent with the terms and conditions of the Commission
order.
(b) Public disclosures. (1) Every Form ATS-N filed pursuant to this
section shall constitute a ``report'' within the meaning of sections
11A, 17(a), 18(a), and 32(a) (15 U.S.C. 78k-1, 78q(a), 78r(a), and
78ff(a)), and any other applicable provisions of the Act.
(2) The Commission will make public via posting on the Commission's
website, each:
(i) Effective initial Form ATS-N, as amended;
(ii) Order of ineffective initial Form ATS-N;
(iii) Form ATS-N amendment to an effective Form ATS-N:
(A) Material Amendments: The cover page of the Material Amendment
will be made public by the Commission upon filing and, unless the
Commission declares the Material Amendment
[[Page 38913]]
ineffective, the entirety of the Material Amendment, as amended, will
be made public by the Commission following the expiration of the review
period pursuant to paragraph (a)(2)(ii) of this section.
(B) Updating, Correcting, and Order Display and Fair Access
Amendments: The entirety of Updating, Correcting, and Order Display and
Fair Access Amendments will be made public by the Commission upon
filing. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an Updating or Correcting
Amendment filed to a Material Amendment will be made public by the
Commission following the expiration of the review period for such
Material Amendment pursuant to paragraph (a)(2)(ii) of this section.
(iv) Order of ineffective Form ATS-N amendment;
(v) Notice of cessation; and
(vi) Order suspending, limiting, or revoking the exemption for an
NMS Stock ATS from the definition of an ``exchange'' pursuant to Sec.
240.3a1-1(a)(2) of this chapter.
(3) Each NMS Stock ATS shall make public via posting on its website
a direct URL hyperlink to the Commission's website that contains the
documents enumerated in paragraph (b)(2) of this section.
(c) Form ATS-N disclosure requirements. (1) An NMS Stock ATS must
file a Form ATS-N in accordance with the instructions therein.
(2) Any report required to be filed with the Commission under this
section shall be filed on Form ATS-N, and include all information as
prescribed in Form ATS-N and the instructions thereto. Such document
shall be executed at, or prior to, the time Form ATS-N is filed and
shall be retained by the NMS Stock ATS in accordance with Sec. Sec.
242.303 and Sec. 232.302 of this chapter, and the instructions in Form
ATS-N.
PART 249--FORMS, SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
0
10. The general authority citation for part 249 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 15 U.S.C. 78a et seq. and 7201 et seq.; 12 U.S.C.
5461 et seq.; 18 U.S.C. 1350; Sec. 953(b), Pub. L. 111-203, 124
Stat. 1904; Sec. 102(a)(3), Pub. L. 112-106, 126 Stat. 309 (2012);
Sec. 107, Pub. L. 112-106, 126 Stat. 313 (2012), and Sec. 72001,
Pub. L. 114-94, 129 Stat. 1312 (2015), unless otherwise noted.
* * * * *
0
11. Add Sec. 249.640 to subpart G to read as follows:
Sec. 249.640 Form ATS-N, information required of NMS Stock ATSs
pursuant to Sec. 242.304(a) of this chapter.
This form shall be used by every NMS Stock ATS to file required
reports under Sec. 242.304(a) of this chapter.
Note: The text of Form ATS-N will not appear in the Code of
Federal Regulations.
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P
[[Page 38914]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.004
[[Page 38915]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.005
[[Page 38916]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.006
[[Page 38917]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.007
[[Page 38918]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.008
[[Page 38919]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.009
[[Page 38920]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.010
[[Page 38921]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.011
[[Page 38922]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.012
[[Page 38923]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.013
[[Page 38924]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.014
[[Page 38925]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.015
[[Page 38926]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.016
[[Page 38927]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.017
[[Page 38928]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.018
[[Page 38929]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.019
[[Page 38930]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.020
[[Page 38931]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.021
[[Page 38932]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.022
[[Page 38933]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR07AU18.023
FORM ATS-N INSTRUCTIONS
A. FILING FORM ATS-N:
1. Form ATS-N is a public reporting form that is designed to
provide market participants and the Commission with information about
the operations of the NMS Stock ATS and the ATS-related activities of
its Broker-Dealer Operator and its Affiliates. Among other things, an
NMS Stock ATS must file Form ATS-N to be exempt from the definition of
``exchange'' pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 3a1-1(a)(2).
2. A separate Form ATS-N is required for each NMS Stock ATS
operated by the same Broker-Dealer Operator.
3. An NMS Stock ATS must provide all the information required by
Form ATS-N, including responses to each Item, as applicable, and the
Exhibits, and disclose information that is accurate, current, and
complete.
4. An NMS Stock ATS must respond to each request in detail unless
otherwise provided (i.e., where the request indicates that the ATS is
required to disclose ``summary'' information).
5. Any report required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 304 of
Regulation ATS shall be prepared, formatted, and submitted in
accordance with Regulation S-T and the EDGAR Filer Manual. Filers have
the option of submitting the information to EDGAR using the most recent
version of the XML schema for Rule 304 as specified by the EDGAR Filer
Manual, or submitting the information using the web-fillable form for
Rule 304 in EDGAR.
6. Initial Form ATS-N: Prior to commencing operations, an NMS Stock
ATS shall file an initial Form ATS-N and the initial Form ATS-N must
become effective. If an NMS Stock ATS is currently operating pursuant
to a Form ATS it must indicate such on the Form ATS-N. If the NMS Stock
ATS is operating pursuant to a previously filed initial operation
report on Form ATS as of January 7, 2019, such NMS Stock ATS shall file
with the Commission a Form ATS-N no earlier than January 7, 2019, and
no later than February 8, 2019.
7. Form ATS-N Amendment
a. An NMS Stock ATS shall amend a Form ATS-N in accordance with the
conditions of Rule 304.
b. A Material Amendment, except as provided by Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D)
for an
[[Page 38934]]
Order Display and Fair Access Amendment, must be filed at least 30
calendar days prior to the date of implementation of a material change
to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or to the activities of the
Broker-Dealer Operator or its Affiliates that are subject to disclosure
on Form ATS-N.
c. An Updating Amendment must be filed no later than 30 calendar
days after the end of each calendar quarter to correct any other
information that has become inaccurate or incomplete for any reason and
was not previously required to be reported to the Commission as a Form
ATS-N Amendment pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A), Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C),
or Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D).
d. A Correcting Amendment must be filed promptly to correct
information in any previous disclosure on Form ATS-N, after discovery
that any information previously filed on Form ATS-N was materially
inaccurate or incomplete when filed.
e. An Order Display and Fair Access Amendment must be filed no
later than seven calendar days after information required to be
disclosed in Part III, Items 24 and 25 on Form ATS-N has become
inaccurate or incomplete.
f. An NMS Stock ATS must select only one ``Type of Amendment'' for
each Form ATS-N Amendment filed with the Commission.
g. For each Amendment, indicate the Part and Item number of the
Form ATS-N that is the subject of the change, provide a brief summary
of the changes, and state whether or not the changes apply to all
Subscribers and the Broker-Dealer Operator.
h. For each Amendment, provide the EDGAR accession number for the
filing that is being amended.
8. Notice of Cessation: An NMS Stock ATS shall notice its cessation
of operations on Form ATS-N at least 10 business days prior to the date
the NMS Stock ATS will cease to operate as an NMS Stock ATS.
9. Withdrawal: If an NMS Stock ATS determines to withdraw a filing,
it must check the ``Withdrawal of Form ATS-N filing'' check box for the
type of filing and provide the EDGAR accession number of the Form ATS-N
filing that is being withdrawn. An NMS Stock ATS may withdraw an
initial Form ATS-N or an Amendment before the end of the applicable
Commission review period. An NMS Stock ATS may withdraw a notice of
cessation of operations at any time before the date that the NMS Stock
ATS had indicated it intended to cease operating. A Legacy NMS Stock
ATS may not withdraw its initial Form ATS-N at any time.
10. A filing that is defective may be rejected and not be accepted
by the EDGAR system. Any filing so rejected shall be deemed not to have
been filed. See generally Regulation S-T (17 CFR part 232).
B. CONTACT INFORMATION
The individual listed on the NMS Stock ATS's response to
Part IV of Form ATS-N as the contact representative must be authorized
to receive all incoming communications and be responsible for
disseminating that information, as necessary, within the NMS Stock ATS.
The contact information provided in Part IV of Form ATS-N will not be
made public.
C. RECORDKEEPING
A copy of this Form ATS-N must be retained by the NMS
Stock ATS in accordance with the EDGAR Filer Manual and Rule 303 of
Regulation ATS and must be made available for inspection upon a
regulatory request.
D. PAPERWORK REDUCTION ACT DISCLOSURE
Form ATS-N requires an NMS Stock ATS to provide the
Commission with certain information regarding: (1) the operation of the
NMS Stock ATS and the ATS-related activities of the Broker-Dealer
Operator and its Affiliates; (2) material and other changes to the
operations and disclosures of the NMS Stock ATS; and (3) notice upon
ceasing operation of the NMS Stock ATS. Form ATS-N is designed to
provide the public with information to, among other things, help them
make informed decisions about whether to participate on the NMS Stock
ATS. In addition, the Form ATS-N is designed to provide the Commission
with information to permit it to carry out its market oversight and
investor protection functions.
The information provided on Form ATS-N will help the
Commission to determine whether an NMS Stock ATS is in compliance with
the federal securities laws and the rules or regulations thereunder,
including Regulation ATS. An NMS Stock ATS must:
[cir] File an initial Form ATS-N prior to commencing operations.
[cir] File a Form ATS Amendment: (1) At least 30 calendar days
prior to the date of implementation of a material change to the
operations of the NMS Stock ATS or to the activities of the Broker-
Dealer Operator or its Affiliates that are subject to disclosure on
Form ATS-N (Material Amendment); (2) no later than 30 calendar days
after the end of each calendar quarter to correct any other information
that has become inaccurate or incomplete for any reason and was not
previously required to be reported to the Commission as a Form ATS-N
amendment pursuant to Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(A), Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C), or
Rule 304(a)(2)(i)(D) (Updating Amendment); (3) promptly, to correct
information in any previous disclosure on Form ATS-N, after discovery
that any information previously filed on Form ATS-N was materially
inaccurate or incomplete when filed (Correcting Amendment); or (4) no
later than seven calendar days after information required to be
disclosed in Part III, Items 24 and 25 on Form ATS-N has become
inaccurate or incomplete (Order Display and Fair Access Amendment).
During the Commission review period of an initial Form ATS-N filing, an
NMS Stock ATS that is operating as of January 7, 2019 shall amend its
filed Form ATS-N pursuant to these requirements, and an NMS Stock ATS
that was not operating as of January 7, 2019 shall amend its filed Form
ATS-N pursuant to the requirements for Updating and Correcting
Amendments. During the Commission review period of an initial Form ATS-
N filing, an NMS Stock ATS shall amend a filed Material Amendment
pursuant to the requirements for Updating and Correcting Amendments.
[cir] Notice its cessation of operations at least 10 business days
before the date the NMS Stock ATS ceases to operate as an NMS Stock
ATS.
This collection of information will be reviewed by the
Office of Management and Budget in accordance with the clearance
requirements of 44 U.S.C. 3507. An agency may not conduct or sponsor,
and a Person is not required to respond to, a collection of information
unless it displays a currently valid control number. We estimate that
an NMS Stock ATS will spend approximately 127.4 hours completing the
Form ATS-N, approximately 9 hours preparing each amendment to Form ATS-
N, and approximately 2 hours preparing a notice of cessation on Form
ATS-N. Any member of the public may direct to the Commission any
comments concerning the accuracy of this burden estimate and any
suggestions for reducing this burden.
E. EXPLANATION OF TERMS
The following terms are defined for purposes of Form ATS-N.
AFFILIATE: Shall mean, with respect to a specified Person,
any Person that, directly or indirectly, controls, is under common
control with, or is controlled by, the specified Person.
[[Page 38935]]
ALTERNATIVE TRADING SYSTEM: Shall mean any organization,
association, Person, group of Persons, or system: (1) that constitutes,
maintains, or provides a market place or facilities for bringing
together purchasers and sellers of securities or for otherwise
performing with respect to securities the functions commonly performed
by a stock exchange within the meaning of Rule 3b-16 under the Exchange
Act; and (2) that does not (i) set rules governing the conduct of
subscribers other than the conduct of such subscribers' trading on such
organization, association, Person, group of Persons, or system, or (ii)
discipline subscribers other than by exclusion from trading. 17 CFR
242.300(a).
BROKER-DEALER OPERATOR: Shall mean the registered broker-
dealer of the NMS Stock ATS pursuant to 17 CFR 242.301(b)(1).
CONTROL: Shall mean the power, directly or indirectly, to
direct the management or policies of the broker-dealer of an
alternative trading system, whether through ownership of securities, by
contract, or otherwise. A Person is presumed to control the broker-
dealer of an alternative trading system if that Person: (1) is a
director, general partner, or officer exercising executive
responsibility (or having similar status or performing similar
functions); (2) directly or indirectly has the right to vote 25 percent
or more of a class of voting securities or has the power to sell or
direct the sale of 25 percent or more of a class of voting securities
of the broker-dealer of the alternative trading system; or (3) in the
case of a partnership, has contributed, or has the right to receive
upon dissolution, 25 percent or more of the capital of the broker-
dealer of the alternative trading system. 17 CFR 242.300(f).
NMS SECURITY: Shall mean any security or class of
securities for which transaction reports are collected, processed, and
made available pursuant to an effective transaction reporting plan, or
an effective national market system plan for reporting transactions in
listed options. 17 CFR 242.600(b)(46).
NMS STOCK: Shall mean any NMS security other than an
option. 17 CFR 242.600(b)(47).
NMS STOCK ATS: Shall mean an alternative trading system,
as defined in Rule 300(a) under the Exchange Act, that trades NMS
stocks, as defined in Rule 300(g) under the Exchange Act. 17 CFR
242.300(k).
ORDER: Shall mean any firm indication of a willingness to
buy or sell a security as either principal or agent, including any bid
or offer quotation, market order, limit order, or other priced order.
17 CFR 242.300(e).
PERSON: Shall mean a natural person or a company. 15
U.S.C. 80a-2(a)(28).
SUBSCRIBER: Shall mean any Person that has entered into a
contractual agreement with an alternative trading system to access an
alternative trading system for the purpose of effecting transactions in
securities, or for submitting, disseminating or displaying orders on
such alternative trading system, including a customer, member, user, or
participant in an alternative trading system. A subscriber, however,
shall not include a national securities exchange or association. 17 CFR
242.300(b).
TRADING CENTER: Shall mean a national securities exchange
or national securities association that operates an SRO trading
facility, an alternative trading system, an exchange market maker, an
OTC market maker, or any other broker or dealer that executes orders
internally by trading as principal or crossing orders as agent. 17 CFR
242.600(b)(78).
By the Commission.
Dated: July 18, 2018
Brent J. Fields,
Secretary.
Note: The following appendix will not appear in the Code of
Federal Regulations.
Appendix A
Key to Comment Letters Cited in Regulation of NMS Stock Alternative
Trading Systems (File No. S7-23-15
Letter from Venu Palaparthi, Senior Vice President, Virtu Financial
to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated December 2, 2015
(``Virtu Letter'')
Letter from Clive Williams, Head of Global Equity Trading, Thea N.
Williams, Head of Global Fixed Income Trading, and Jonathan D.
Siegel, Senior Legal Counsel, T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 23, 2016
(``T. Rowe Price Letter'')
Letter from Jonathan A. Clark, Chief Executive Officer, and James C.
Dolan, Chief Compliance Office, Luminex Trading & Analytics LLC to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 23, 2016
(``Luminex Letter'')
Letter from Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, State of New
York, to the Honorable Mary Jo White, Chair, and Brent J. Fields,
Secretary, Commission, dated February 23, 2016 (``Schneiderman
Letter'')
Letter from Scott Pintoff, General Counsel, MarketAxess Corporation,
to Secretary, Commission, dated February 24, 2016 (``MarketAxess
Letter'')
Letter from David W. Blass, General Counsel, Investment Company
Institute, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February
25, 2016 (``ICI Letter'')
Letter from Chris Barnard, to the Commission, dated February 25,
2016 (``Barnard Letter'').
Letter from Stuart J. Kaswell, Executive Vice President & Managing
Director, General Counsel, Managed Funds Association and
Ji[rcaron][iacute] Kr[oacute]l, Deputy Chief Executive Officer,
Global Head of Government Affairs, Alternative Investment Management
Association, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated
February 26, 2016 (``MFA/AIMA Letter'')
Letter from Marcia E. Asquith, Senior Vice President and Corporate
Secretary, Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc., to Brent
J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016 (``FINRA
Letter'')
Letter from Phillip S. Gillespie, General Counsel and Executive Vice
President, State Street Global Advisors, to Brent J. Fields,
Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016 (``SSGA Letter'')
Letter from John Russell, Chairman of the Board and James Toes,
President and Chief Executive Office, Securities Traders
Association, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated
February 26, 2016 (``STA Letter'')
Letter from D. Keith Ross, Chief Executive Officer, PDQ Enterprises,
LLC and Christopher Meade, Chief Compliance Officer, PDQ ATS, Inc.,
to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016
(``PDQ Letter'')
Letter from Howard Meyerson, General Counsel, Liquidnet, Inc., to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016
(``Liquidnet Letter'')
Letter from Denis Ignatovich, Co-Founder, and Grant Passmore, Ph.D.,
Co-Founder, Aesthetic Integration Ltd. (``AI Letter'')
Letter from Dave Lauer, Chairman, Healthy Markets Association, to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016
(``HMA Letter'')
Letter from Kurt N. Schacht, CFA, Managing Director, Standards &
Advocacy, CFA Institute, and James C. Allen, CFA, Head, Capital
Markets Policy, CFA Institute, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary,
Commission, dated February 26, 2016 (``CFA Institute Letter'')
Letter from Micah Hauptman, Financial Services Counsel, Consumer
Federation of America, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission,
dated February 26, 2016 (``Consumer Federation of American Letter'')
Letter from Timothy J. Mahoney, Chief Executive Office, BIDS Trading
L.P., to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26,
2016 (``BIDS Letter'')
Letter from Marc B. Bryant, Senior Vice President, Deputy General
Counsel, Fidelity Investments, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary,
Commission, dated February 26, 2016 (``Fidelity Letter'')
Letter from Angelo Evangelou, Deputy General Counsel, Legal
Division, Chicago Board Options Exchange, Incorporated, to Brent J.
Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated March 1, 2016 (``CBOE Letter'')
Letter from Adam C. Cooper, Senior Managing Director and Chief Legal
Officer, Citadel LLC, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary,
[[Page 38936]]
Commission, dated March 1, 2016 (``Citadel Letter'')
Letter from Theodore R. Lazo, Managing Director and Associate
General Counsel, Securities Industry and Financial Markets
Association, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated March
7, 2016 (``SIFMA Letter'')
Letter from Kimberly Unger, Chief Executive Officer & Executive
Director, The Security Traders Association of New York, Inc., to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated March 4, 2016 (``STANY
Letter'')
Letter from Mark Holder, Managing Director, UBS Securities LLC, to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated March 21, 2016 (``UBS
Letter'')
Letter from Anonymous to Commission, dated February 26, 2016
(``Anonymous Letter'')
Letter from Dennis M. Kelleher, President and Chief Executive
Officer, Stephen W. Hall, Legal Director & Securities Specialist,
and Allen Dreschel, Attorney, Better Markets, Inc., to Brent J.
Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated February 26, 2016 (``Better
Markets Letter'')
Letter from John A. McCarthy, General Counsel, KCG Holdings, Inc.,
to Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated March 15, 2016
(``KCG Letter'')
Letter from David Weisberger, Managing Director, Markit, to Brent J.
Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated April 15, 2016 (``Markit
Letter'')
Letter from William Neuberger and Andrew F. Silverman, Managing
Directors and Global Co-Heads, Morgan Stanley Electronic Trading, to
Brent J. Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated May 19, 2016 (``Morgan
Stanley Letter'')
Letter from John F. Linares, General Counsel, LeveL ATS, to Brent J.
Fields, Secretary, Commission, dated September 7, 2016 (``LeveL ATS
Letter'').
Letter from Rick A. Fleming, Investor Advocate, Office of the
Investor Advocate, Commission, to Brent J. Fields, Secretary,
Commission, dated September 9, 2016 (``Investor Advocate Letter'')
Letter from Stuart J. Kaswell, Executive Vice President & Managing
Director, General Counsel, Managed Funds Association, to the
Honorable Walter J. Clayton, Chairman, Commission, dated May 18,
2017 (``MFA Letter 2'')
[FR Doc. 2018-15896 Filed 8-6-18; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P