[Federal Register Volume 82, Number 205 (Wednesday, October 25, 2017)]
[Notices]
[Pages 49462-49468]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2017-23143]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION
[Docket No. SSA-2015-0055]
Social Security Ruling 16-3p Titles II And XVI: Evaluation Of
Symptoms In Disability Claims
AGENCY: Social Security Administration.
ACTION: Notice of Social Security Ruling (SSR).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We are republishing SSR 16-3p, a ruling that rescinded and
superseded SSR 96-7p, with a revision detailing how we apply the SSR as
it relates to the applicable date. We changed our terminology from
``effective date'' to ``applicable date'' based on guidance from the
Office of the Federal Register. We also updated citations to reflect
the revised regulations that became effective on March 27, 2017. This
Ruling is otherwise unchanged, and provides guidance about how we
evaluate statements regarding the intensity, persistence, and limiting
effects of symptoms in disability claims under Titles II and XVI of the
Social Security Act (Act) and blindness claims under Title XVI of the
Act.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Elaine Tocco, Office of Disability
Policy, Social Security Administration, 6401 Security Boulevard,
Baltimore, MD 21235-6401, (410) 966-6356. For information on
eligibility or filing for benefits, call our national toll-free number,
1-800-772-1213 or TTY 1-800-325-0778, or visit our internet site,
Social Security Online, at http://www.socialsecurity.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Although 5 U.S.C. 552(a)(1) and (a)(2) do
not require us to publish this SSR, we are doing so in accordance with
20 CFR 402.35(b)(1).
Through SSRs, we convey to the public SSA precedential decisions
relating to the Federal old age, survivors, disability, supplemental
security income, and special veterans benefits programs. We may base
SSRs on determinations or decisions made at all levels of
administrative adjudication, Federal court decisions, Commissioner's
decisions, opinions of the Office of the General Counsel, or other
interpretations of the law and regulations.
Although SSRs do not have the same force and effect as statutes or
regulations, they are binding on all components of the Social Security
Administration. 20 CFR 402.35(b)(1).
This SSR will remain in effect until we publish a notice in the
Federal Register that rescinds it, or we publish a new SSR that
replaces or modifies it.
This SSR, republished in its entirety, includes a revision to
clarify that our adjudicators will apply SSR 16-3p when we make
determinations and decisions on or after March 28, 2016. When a Federal
court reviews our final decision in a claim, we also explain that we
expect the court to review the final
[[Page 49463]]
decision using the rules that were in effect at the time we issued the
decision under review. If a court remands a claim for further
proceedings after the applicable date of the ruling (March 28, 2016),
we will apply SSR 16-3p to the entire period in the decision we make
after the court's remand.
(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance, Programs Nos. 96.001,
Social Security--Disability Insurance; 96.002, Social Security--
Retirement Insurance; 96.004, Social Security--Survivors Insurance;
96.006--Supplemental Security Income.)
Nancy A. Berryhill,
Acting Commissioner of Social Security.
POLICY INTERPRETATION RULING
TITLES II AND XVI: EVALUATION OF SYMPTOMS IN DISABILITY CLAIMS
This SSR supersedes SSR 96-7p: Policy Interpretation Ruling Titles
II and XVI: Evaluation of Symptoms in Disability Claims: Assessing the
Credibility of an Individual's Statements.
PURPOSE:
We are rescinding SSR 96-7p: Policy Interpretation Ruling Titles II
and XVI Evaluation of Symptoms in Disability Claims: Assessing the
Credibility of an Individual's Statements and replacing it with this
Ruling. We solicited a study and recommendations from the
Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) on the topic of
symptom evaluation. Based on ACUS's recommendations \1\ and our
adjudicative experience, we are eliminating the use of the term
``credibility'' from our sub-regulatory policy, as our regulations do
not use this term. In doing so, we clarify that subjective symptom
evaluation is not an examination of an individual's character. Instead,
we will more closely follow our regulatory language regarding symptom
evaluation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ ACUS made several recommendations in its March 12, 2015
final report, ``Evaluating Subjective Symptoms in Disability
Claims.'' Among other things, ACUS recommended we consider amending
SSR 96-7p to clarify that subjective symptom evaluation is not an
examination of an individual's character, but rather is an evidence-
based analysis of the administrative record to determine whether the
nature, intensity, frequency, or severity of an individual's
symptoms impact his or her ability to work. In any revised SSR, ACUS
also recommended we more closely follow our regulatory language
about symptom evaluation, which does not use the term
``credibility'' and instead directs adjudicators to consider medical
and other evidence to evaluate the intensity and persistence of
symptoms to determine how the individual's symptoms limit capacity
for work if he or she is an adult, or for a child with a title XVI
disability claim, how symptoms limit ability to function. ACUS
further recommended when revising SSR 96-7p, we offer additional
guidance to adjudicators on regulatory implementation problems that
have been identified since we published SSR 96-7p.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consistent with our regulations, we instruct our adjudicators to
consider all of the evidence in an individual's record when they
evaluate the intensity and persistence of symptoms after they find that
the individual has a medically determinable impairment(s) that could
reasonably be expected to produce those symptoms. We evaluate the
intensity and persistence of an individual's symptoms so we can
determine how symptoms limit ability to perform work-related activities
for an adult and how symptoms limit ability to function independently,
appropriately, and effectively in an age-appropriate manner for a child
with a title XVI disability claim.
CITATIONS (AUTHORITY):
Sections 216(i), 223(d), and 1614(a)(3) of the Social Security Act
as amended; Regulations no. 4, sections 404.1502, 404.1512(d),
404.1513, 404.1520, 404.1520c, 404.1521, 404.1526, 404.1527, 404.1529,
404.1545 and 404.1594; and Regulations No. 16 sections 416.902,
416.912(d), 416.913, 416.920, 416.920c, 416.921, 416.924(c),
416.924a(b)(9)(ii-iii), 416.926a, 416.927, 416.929, 416.930(c),
416.945, 416.994, and 416.994a.
BACKGROUND:
In determining whether an individual is disabled, we consider all
of the individual's symptoms, including pain, and the extent to which
the symptoms can reasonably be accepted as consistent with the
objective medical and other evidence in the individual's record. We
define a symptom as the individual's own description or statement of
his or her physical or mental impairment(s).\2\ Under our regulations,
an individual's statements of symptoms alone are not enough to
establish the existence of a physical or mental impairment or
disability. However, if an individual alleges impairment-related
symptoms, we must evaluate those symptoms using a two-step process set
forth in our regulations.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ See 20 CFR 404.1502(i) and 416.902(n) for how our
regulations define symptoms.
\3\ See 20 CFR 404.1529 and 416.929 for how we evaluate
statements of symptoms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
First, we must consider whether there is an underlying medically
determinable physical or mental impairment(s) that could reasonably be
expected to produce an individual's symptoms, such as pain. Second,
once an underlying physical or mental impairment(s) that could
reasonably be expected to produce an individual's symptoms is
established, we evaluate the intensity and persistence of those
symptoms to determine the extent to which the symptoms limit an
individual's ability to perform work-related activities for an adult or
to function independently, appropriately, and effectively in an age-
appropriate manner for a child with a title XVI disability claim.
This ruling clarifies how we consider:
The intensity, persistence, and functionally limiting
effects of symptoms,
Objective medical evidence when evaluating symptoms,
Other evidence when evaluating symptoms,
The factors set forth in 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(3) and
416.929(c)(3),
The extent to which an individual's symptoms affect his or
her ability to perform work-related activities or function
independently, appropriately, and effectively in an age-appropriate
manner for a child with a title XVI disability claim, and
Adjudication standards for evaluating symptoms in the
sequential evaluation process.
POLICY INTERPRETATION:
We use a two-step process for evaluating an individual's symptoms.
The two-step process:
Step 1: We determine whether the individual has a medically
determinable impairment (MDI) that could reasonably be expected to
produce the individual's alleged symptoms
An individual's symptoms, such as pain, fatigue, shortness of
breath, weakness, nervousness, or periods of poor concentration will
not be found to affect the ability to perform work-related activities
for an adult or to function independently, appropriately, and
effectively in an age-appropriate manner for a child with a title XVI
disability claim unless medical signs or laboratory findings show a
medically determinable impairment is present. Signs are anatomical,
physiological, or psychological abnormalities established by medically
acceptable clinical diagnostic techniques that can be observed apart
from an individual's symptoms.\4\ Laboratory findings are anatomical,
physiological, or psychological phenomena, which can be shown by the
use of medically acceptable laboratory diagnostic techniques.\5\ We
call the medical
[[Page 49464]]
evidence that provides signs or laboratory findings objective medical
evidence. We must have objective medical evidence from an acceptable
medical source \6\ to establish the existence of a medically
determinable impairment that could reasonably be expected to produce an
individual's alleged symptoms.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ See 20 CFR 404.1502(g) and 416.902(l) for how our
regulations define signs.
\5\ See 20 CFR 404.1502(c) and 416.902(g) for how our
regulations define laboratory findings.
\6\ See 20 CFR 404.1502(a) and 416.902(a) for a list of
acceptable medical sources.
\7\ See 20 CFR 404.1521 and 416.921 for what is needed to show a
medically determinable impairment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In determining whether there is an underlying medically
determinable impairment that could reasonably be expected to produce an
individual's symptoms, we do not consider whether the severity of an
individual's alleged symptoms is supported by the objective medical
evidence. For example, if an individual has a medically determinable
impairment established by a knee x-ray showing mild degenerative
changes and he or she alleges extreme pain that limits his or her
ability to stand and walk, we will find that individual has a medically
determinable impairment that could reasonably be expected to produce
the symptom of pain. We will proceed to step two of the two-step
process, even though the level of pain an individual alleges may seem
out of proportion with the objective medical evidence.
In some instances, the objective medical evidence clearly
establishes that an individual's symptoms are due to a medically
determinable impairment. At other times, we may have insufficient
evidence to determine whether an individual has a medically
determinable impairment that could potentially account for his or her
alleged symptoms. In those instances, we develop evidence regarding a
potential medically determinable impairment using a variety of means
set forth in our regulations. For example, we may obtain additional
information from the individual about the nature of his or her symptoms
and their effect on functioning. We may request additional information
from the individual about other testing or treatment he or she may have
undergone for the symptoms. We may request clarifying information from
an individual's medical sources, or we may send an individual to a
consultative examination that may include diagnostic testing. We may
use our agency experts to help us determine whether an individual's
medically determinable impairment could reasonably be expected to
produce his or her symptoms. At the administrative law judge hearing
level or the Appeals Council level of the administrative review
process, we may ask for and consider evidence from a medical or
psychological expert to help us determine whether an individual's
medically determinable impairment could reasonably be expected to
produce his or her symptoms. If an individual alleges symptoms, but the
medical signs and laboratory findings do not substantiate any medically
determinable impairment capable of producing the individual's alleged
symptoms, we will not evaluate the individual's symptoms at step two of
our two-step evaluation process.
We will not find an individual disabled based on alleged symptoms
alone. If there is no medically determinable impairment, or if there is
a medically determinable impairment, but the impairment(s) could not
reasonably be expected to produce the individual's symptoms, we will
not find those symptoms affect the ability to perform work-related
activities for an adult or ability to function independently,
appropriately, and effectively in an age-appropriate manner for a child
with a title XVI disability claim.
Step 2: We evaluate the intensity and persistence of an
individual's symptoms such as pain and determine the extent to which an
individual's symptoms limit his or her ability to perform work-related
activities for an adult or to function independently, appropriately,
and effectively in an age-appropriate manner for a child with a title
XVI disability claim.
Once the existence of a medically determinable impairment that
could reasonably be expected to produce pain or other symptoms is
established, we recognize that some individuals may experience symptoms
differently and may be limited by symptoms to a greater or lesser
extent than other individuals with the same medical impairments, the
same objective medical evidence, and the same non-medical evidence. In
considering the intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of an
individual's symptoms, we examine the entire case record, including the
objective medical evidence; an individual's statements about the
intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of symptoms; statements
and other information provided by medical sources and other persons;
and any other relevant evidence in the individual's case record.
We will not evaluate an individual's symptoms without making every
reasonable effort to obtain a complete medical history \8\ unless the
evidence supports a finding that the individual is disabled. We will
not evaluate an individual's symptoms based solely on objective medical
evidence unless that objective medical evidence supports a finding that
the individual is disabled. We will evaluate an individual's symptoms
based on the evidence in an individual's record as described below;
however, not all of the types of evidence described below will be
available or relevant in every case.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ By ``complete medical history,'' we mean the individual's
complete medical history for at least the 12 months preceding the
month in which he or she filed an application, unless there is a
reason to believe that development of an earlier period is necessary
or the individual says that his or her alleged disability began less
than 12 months before he or she filed an application. 20 CFR
404.1512(b)(ii) and 416.912(b)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Consideration of Objective Medical Evidence
Symptoms cannot always be measured objectively through clinical or
laboratory diagnostic techniques. However, objective medical evidence
is a useful indicator to help make reasonable conclusions about the
intensity and persistence of symptoms, including the effects those
symptoms may have on the ability to perform work-related activities for
an adult or to function independently, appropriately, and effectively
in an age-appropriate manner for a child with a title XVI claim.\9\ We
must consider whether an individual's statements about the intensity,
persistence, and limiting effects of his or her symptoms are consistent
with the medical signs and laboratory findings of record.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(2) and 416.929(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of many symptoms
can be clinically observed and recorded in the medical evidence.
Examples such as reduced joint motion, muscle spasm, sensory deficit,
and motor disruption illustrate findings that may result from, or be
associated with, the symptom of pain.\10\ These findings may be
consistent with an individual's statements about symptoms and their
functional effects. However, when the results of tests are not
consistent with other evidence in the record, they may be less
supportive of an individual's statements about pain or other symptoms
than test results and statements that are consistent with other
evidence in the record.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(2) and 416.929(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For example, an individual with reduced muscle strength testing who
indicates that for the last year pain has limited his or her standing
and walking to no more than a few minutes a day
[[Page 49465]]
would be expected to have some signs of muscle wasting as a result. If
no muscle wasting were present, we might not, depending on the other
evidence in the record, find the individual's reduced muscle strength
on clinical testing to be consistent with the individual's alleged
impairment-related symptoms.
However, we will not disregard an individual's statements about the
intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of symptoms solely because
the objective medical evidence does not substantiate the degree of
impairment-related symptoms alleged by the individual.\11\ A report of
minimal or negative findings or inconsistencies in the objective
medical evidence is one of the many factors we must consider in
evaluating the intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of an
individual's symptoms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ See 20 CFR 404.1529 and 416.929.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Consideration of Other Evidence
If we cannot make a disability determination or decision that is
fully favorable based solely on objective medical evidence, then we
carefully consider other evidence in the record in reaching a
conclusion about the intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of an
individual's symptoms. Other evidence that we will consider includes
statements from the individual, medical sources, and any other sources
that might have information about the individual's symptoms, including
agency personnel, as well as the factors set forth in our
regulations.\12\ For example, for a child with a title XVI disability
claim, we will consider evidence submitted from educational agencies
and personnel, statements from parents and other relatives, and
evidence submitted by social welfare agencies, therapists, and other
practitioners.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ See 20 CFR 404.1513 and 416.913.
\13\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(3) and 416.929(c)(3)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. The Individual
An individual may make statements about the intensity, persistence,
and limiting effects of his or her symptoms. If a child with a title
XVI disability claim is unable to describe his or her symptoms
adequately, we will accept a description of his or her symptoms from
the person most familiar with the child, such as a parent, another
relative, or a guardian.\14\ For an adult whose impairment prevents him
or her from describing symptoms adequately, we may also consider a
description of his or her symptoms from a person who is familiar with
the individual.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ See 20 CFR 416.924a(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An individual may make statements about symptoms directly to
medical sources, other sources, or he or she may make them directly to
us. An individual may have made statements about symptoms in connection
with claims for other types of disability benefits such as workers'
compensation, benefits under programs of the Department of Veterans
Affairs, or private insurance benefits.
An individual's statements may address the frequency and duration
of the symptoms, the location of the symptoms, and the impact of the
symptoms on the ability to perform daily living activities. An
individual's statements may also include activities that precipitate or
aggravate the symptoms, medications and treatments used, and other
methods used to alleviate the symptoms. We will consider an
individual's statements about the intensity, persistence, and limiting
effects of symptoms, and we will evaluate whether the statements are
consistent with objective medical evidence and the other evidence.
b. Medical Sources
Medical sources may offer diagnoses, prognoses, and opinions as
well as statements and medical reports about an individual's history,
treatment, responses to treatment, prior work record, efforts to work,
daily activities, and other information concerning the intensity,
persistence, and limiting effects of an individual's symptoms.
Important information about symptoms recorded by medical sources
and reported in the medical evidence may include, but is not limited
to, the following:
Onset, description of the character and location of the
symptoms, precipitating and aggravating factors, frequency and
duration, change over a period of time (e.g., whether worsening,
improving, or static), and daily activities. Very often, the individual
has provided this information to the medical source, and the
information may be compared with the individual's other statements in
the case record. In addition, the evidence provided by a medical source
may contain medical opinions about the individual's symptoms and their
effects. Our adjudicators will consider such opinions by applying the
factors in 20 CFR 404.1520c and 416.920c.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ For claims filed before March 27, 2017, our adjudicators
will apply the rules in 20 CFR 404.1527 and 416.927.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A longitudinal record of any treatment and its success or
failure, including any side effects of medication.
Indications of other impairments, such as potential mental
impairments, that could account for an individual's allegations.
Medical evidence from medical sources that have not treated or
examined the individual is also important in the adjudicator's
evaluation of an individual's statements about pain or other symptoms.
For example, State agency medical and psychological consultants and
other program physicians and psychologists may offer findings about the
existence and severity of an individual's symptoms. We will consider
these findings in evaluating the intensity, persistence, and limiting
effects of the individual's symptoms. Adjudicators at the hearing level
or at the Appeals Council level must consider the findings from these
medical sources even though they are not bound by them.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\ See 20 C.F.R. 404.1520c and 416.902c for claims filed on or
after March 27, 2017. See 20 CFR 404.1527 and 416.927 for claims
filed before March 27, 2017.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Non-Medical Sources
Other sources may provide information from which we may draw
inferences and conclusions about an individual's statements that would
be helpful to us in assessing the intensity, persistence, and limiting
effects of symptoms. Examples of such sources include public and
private agencies, other practitioners, educational personnel, non-
medical sources such as family and friends, and agency personnel. We
will consider any statements in the record noted by agency personnel
who previously interviewed the individual, whether in person or by
telephone. The adjudicator will consider any personal observations of
the individual in terms of how consistent those observations are with
the individual's statements about his or her symptoms as well as with
all of the evidence in the file.
d. Factors To Consider in Evaluating the Intensity, Persistence, and
Limiting Effects of an Individual's Symptoms
In addition to using all of the evidence to evaluate the intensity,
persistence, and limiting effects of an individual's symptoms, we will
also use the factors set forth in 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(3) and
416.929(c)(3). These factors include:
1. Daily activities;
2. The location, duration, frequency, and intensity of pain or
other symptoms;
[[Page 49466]]
3. Factors that precipitate and aggravate the symptoms;
4. The type, dosage, effectiveness, and side effects of any
medication an individual takes or has taken to alleviate pain or other
symptoms;
5. Treatment, other than medication, an individual receives or has
received for relief of pain or other symptoms;
6. Any measures other than treatment an individual uses or has used
to relieve pain or other symptoms (e.g., lying flat on his or her back,
standing for 15 to 20 minutes every hour, or sleeping on a board); and
7. Any other factors concerning an individual's functional
limitations and restrictions due to pain or other symptoms.
We will consider other evidence to evaluate only the factors that
are relevant to assessing the intensity, persistence, and limiting
effects of the individual's symptoms. If there is no information in the
evidence of record regarding one of the factors, we will not discuss
that specific factor in the determination or decision because it is not
relevant to the case. We will discuss the factors pertinent to the
evidence of record.
How We Will Determine if an Individual's Symptoms Affect the Ability To
Perform Work-Related Activities for an Adult, or Age-Appropriate
Activities for a Child With a Title XVI Disability Claim
If an individual's statements about the intensity, persistence, and
limiting effects of symptoms are consistent with the objective medical
evidence and the other evidence of record, we will determine that the
individual's symptoms are more likely to reduce his or her capacities
to perform work-related activities for an adult or reduce a child's
ability to function independently, appropriately, and effectively in an
age-appropriate manner for a child with a title XVI disability
claim.\17\ In contrast, if an individual's statements about the
intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of symptoms are
inconsistent with the objective medical evidence and the other
evidence, we will determine that the individual's symptoms are less
likely to reduce his or her capacities to perform work-related
activities or abilities to function independently, appropriately, and
effectively in an age-appropriate manner.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(c)(4) and 416.929(c)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We may or may not find an individual's symptoms and related
limitations consistent with the evidence in his or her record. We will
explain which of an individual's symptoms we found consistent or
inconsistent with the evidence in his or her record and how our
evaluation of the individual's symptoms led to our conclusions. We will
evaluate an individual's symptoms considering all the evidence in his
or her record.
In determining whether an individual's symptoms will reduce his or
her corresponding capacities to perform work-related activities or
abilities to function independently, appropriately, and effectively in
an age-appropriate manner, we will consider the consistency of the
individual's own statements. To do so, we will compare statements an
individual makes in connection with the individual's claim for
disability benefits with any existing statements the individual made
under other circumstances.
We will consider statements an individual made to us at each prior
step of the administrative review process, as well as statements the
individual made in any subsequent or prior disability claims under
titles II and XVI. If an individual's various statements about the
intensity, persistence, and limiting effects of symptoms are consistent
with one another and consistent with the objective medical evidence and
other evidence in the record, we will determine that an individual's
symptoms are more likely to reduce his or her capacities for work-
related activities or reduce the abilities to function independently,
appropriately, and effectively in an age-appropriate manner. However,
inconsistencies in an individual's statements made at varying times
does not necessarily mean they are inaccurate. Symptoms may vary in
their intensity, persistence, and functional effects, or may worsen or
improve with time. This may explain why an individual's statements vary
when describing the intensity, persistence, or functional effects of
symptoms.
We will consider an individual's attempts to seek medical treatment
for symptoms and to follow treatment once it is prescribed when
evaluating whether symptom intensity and persistence affect the ability
to perform work-related activities for an adult or the ability to
function independently, appropriately, and effectively in an age-
appropriate manner for a child with a title XVI disability claim.
Persistent attempts to obtain relief of symptoms, such as increasing
dosages and changing medications, trying a variety of treatments,
referrals to specialists, or changing treatment sources may be an
indication that an individual's symptoms are a source of distress and
may show that they are intense and persistent.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(c) and 416.929(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In contrast, if the frequency or extent of the treatment sought by
an individual is not comparable with the degree of the individual's
subjective complaints, or if the individual fails to follow prescribed
treatment that might improve symptoms, we may find the alleged
intensity and persistence of an individual's symptoms are inconsistent
with the overall evidence of record. We will not find an individual's
symptoms inconsistent with the evidence in the record on this basis
without considering possible reasons he or she may not comply with
treatment or seek treatment consistent with the degree of his or her
complaints. We may need to contact the individual regarding the lack of
treatment or, at an administrative proceeding, ask why he or she has
not complied with or sought treatment in a manner consistent with his
or her complaints. When we consider the individual's treatment history,
we may consider (but are not limited to) one or more of the following:
An individual may have structured his or her activities to
minimize symptoms to a tolerable level by avoiding physical activities
or mental stressors that aggravate his or her symptoms.
An individual may receive periodic treatment or evaluation
for refills of medications because his or her symptoms have reached a
plateau.
An individual may not agree to take prescription
medications because the side effects are less tolerable than the
symptoms.
An individual may not be able to afford treatment and may
not have access to free or low-cost medical services.
A medical source may have advised the individual that
there is no further effective treatment to prescribe or recommend that
would benefit the individual.
An individual's symptoms may not be severe enough to
prompt him or her to seek treatment, or the symptoms may be relieved
with over the counter medications.
An individual's religious beliefs may prohibit prescribed
treatment.
Due to various limitations (such as language or mental
limitations), an individual may not understand the appropriate
treatment for or the need for consistent treatment of his or her
impairment.
Due to a mental impairment (for example, individuals with
mental impairments that affect judgment,
[[Page 49467]]
reality testing, or orientation), an individual may not be aware that
he or she has a disorder that requires treatment.
A child may disregard the level and frequency of treatment
needed to maintain or improve functioning because it interferes with
his or her participation in activities typical of other children his or
her age without impairments.
The above examples illustrate possible reasons an individual may
not have pursued treatment. However, we will consider and address
reasons for not pursuing treatment that are pertinent to an
individual's case. We will review the case record to determine whether
there are explanations for inconsistencies in the individual's
statements about symptoms and their effects, and whether the evidence
of record supports any of the individual's statements at the time he or
she made them. We will explain how we considered the individual's
reasons in our evaluation of the individual's symptoms.
Adjudication--How we will use our evaluation of symptoms in our five-
step sequential evaluation process to determine whether an individual
is disabled
In evaluating an individual's symptoms, it is not sufficient for
our adjudicators to make a single, conclusory statement that ``the
individual's statements about his or her symptoms have been
considered'' or that ``the statements about the individual's symptoms
are (or are not) supported or consistent.'' It is also not enough for
our adjudicators simply to recite the factors described in the
regulations for evaluating symptoms. The determination or decision must
contain specific reasons for the weight given to the individual's
symptoms, be consistent with and supported by the evidence, and be
clearly articulated so the individual and any subsequent reviewer can
assess how the adjudicator evaluated the individual's symptoms.
Our adjudicators must base their findings solely on the evidence in
the case record, including any testimony from the individual or other
witnesses at a hearing before an administrative law judge or hearing
officer. The subjective statements of the individual and witnesses
obtained at a hearing should directly relate to symptoms the individual
alleged. Our adjudicators are prohibited from soliciting additional
non-medical evidence outside of the record on their own, except as set
forth in our regulations and policies.
Adjudicators must limit their evaluation to the individual's
statements about his or her symptoms and the evidence in the record
that is relevant to the individual's impairments. In evaluating an
individual's symptoms, our adjudicators will not assess an individual's
overall character or truthfulness in the manner typically used during
an adversarial court litigation. The focus of the evaluation of an
individual's symptoms should not be to determine whether he or she is a
truthful person. Rather, our adjudicators will focus on whether the
evidence establishes a medically determinable impairment that could
reasonably be expected to produce the individual's symptoms and given
the adjudicator's evaluation of the individual's symptoms, whether the
intensity and persistence of the symptoms limit the individual's
ability to perform work-related activities or, for a child with a title
XVI disability claim, limit the child's ability to function
independently, appropriately, and effectively in an age-appropriate
manner.
In determining whether an individual is disabled or continues to be
disabled, our adjudicators follow a sequential evaluation process.\19\
The first step of our five-step sequential evaluation process considers
whether an individual is performing substantial gainful activity. If
the individual is performing substantial gainful activity, we find him
or her not disabled. If the individual is not performing substantial
gainful activity, we proceed to step 2. We do not consider symptoms at
the first step of the sequential evaluation process.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ See 20 CFR 404.1520 and 416.920. For continuing disability,
see 404.1594, 416.994 and 416.994a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At step 2 of the sequential evaluation process, we determine
whether an individual has a severe medically determinable physical or
mental impairment or combination of impairments that has lasted or can
be expected to last for a continuous period of at least 12 months or
end in death.\20\ A severe impairment is one that affects an
individual's ability to perform basic work-related activities for an
adult or that causes more than minimal functional limitations for a
child with a title XVI disability claim.\21\ At this step, we will
consider an individual's symptoms and functional limitations to
determine whether his or her impairment(s) is severe unless the
objective medical evidence alone establishes a severe medically
determinable impairment or combination of impairments that meets our
duration requirement.\22\ If an individual does not have a severe
medically determinable impairment that meets our duration requirement,
we will find the individual not disabled at step 2. If the individual
has a severe medically determinable impairment that has met or is
expected to meet our duration requirement, we proceed to the next step.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\ See 20 CFR 404.1520(a)(4)(ii) and 416.920(a)(4)(ii).
\21\ See 20 CFR 416.924(c).
\22\ See 20 CFR 416.920(c) for adults and 416.924(c) for
children.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At step 3 of the sequential evaluation process, we determine
whether an individual's impairment(s) meets or medically equals the
severity requirements of a listed impairment. To decide whether the
impairment meets the level of severity described in a listed
impairment, we will consider an individual's symptoms when a symptom(s)
is one of the criteria in a listing to ensure the symptom is present in
combination with the other criteria. If the symptom is not one of the
criteria in a listing, we will not evaluate an individual's symptoms at
this step as long as all other findings required by the specific
listing are present. Unless the listing states otherwise, it is not
necessary to provide information about the intensity, persistence, or
limiting effects of a symptom as long as all other findings required by
the specific listing are present.\23\ In considering whether an
individual's symptoms, signs, and laboratory findings are medically
equal to the symptoms, signs, and laboratory findings of a listed
impairment, we will look to see whether the symptoms, signs, and
laboratory findings are at least equal in severity to the listed
criteria. However, we will not substitute the individual's allegations
of pain or other symptoms for a missing or deficient sign or laboratory
finding to raise the severity of the impairment(s) to that of a listed
impairment.\24\ If an individual's impairment meets or medically equals
the severity requirements of a listing, we find him or her disabled. If
an individual's impairment does not meet or medically equal a listing,
we proceed to assess the individual's residual functional capacity at
step 4 of the sequential evaluation process unless the individual is a
child with a title XVI disability claim.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(d)(2) and 416.929(d)(2).
\24\ See 20 CFR 404.1529(d)(3) and 416.929(d)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For a child with a title XVI disability claim whose impairment does
not meet or medically equal the severity requirements of a listing, we
consider whether his or her impairment functionally equals the
listings. This
[[Page 49468]]
means that the impairment results in ``marked'' limitations in two out
of six domains of functioning or an ``extreme'' limitation in one of
the six domains.\25\ We will evaluate an individual's symptoms at this
step when we rate how a child's impairment-related symptoms affect his
or her ability to function independently, appropriately, and
effectively in an age-appropriate manner in each functional domain. If
a child's impairment functionally equals a listing, we find him or her
disabled. If a child's impairment does not functionally equal the
listings, we find him or her not disabled. For a child with a title XVI
disability claim, the sequential evaluation process ends at this step.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\ See 20 CFR 416.926a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If the individual's impairment does not meet or equal a listing, we
will assess and make a finding about an individual's residual
functional capacity based on all the relevant medical and other
evidence in the individual's case record. An individual's residual
functional capacity is the most the individual can still do despite his
or her impairment-related limitations. We consider the individual's
symptoms when determining his or her residual functional capacity and
the extent to which the individual's impairment-related symptoms are
consistent with the evidence in the record.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\ See 20 CFR 404.1545 and 416.945.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After establishing the residual functional capacity, we determine
whether an individual is able to do any past relevant work. At step 4,
we compare the individual's residual functional capacity with the
requirements of his or her past relevant work. If the individual's
residual functional capacity is consistent with the demands of any of
his or her past relevant work, either as the individual performed it or
as the occupation is generally performed in the national economy, then
we will find the individual not disabled. If none of the individual's
past relevant work is within his or her residual functional capacity,
we proceed to step 5 of the sequential evaluation process.
At step 5 of the sequential evaluation process, we determine
whether the individual is able to adjust to other work that exists in
significant numbers in the national economy. We consider the same
residual functional capacity, together with the individual's age,
education, and past work experience. If the individual is able to
adjust to other work that exists in significant numbers in the national
economy, we will find him or her not disabled. If the individual cannot
adjust to other work that exists in significant numbers in the national
economy, we find him or her disabled. At step 5 of the sequential
evaluation process, we will not consider an individual's symptoms any
further because we considered the individual's symptoms when we
determined the individual's residual functional capacity.
This SSR is applicable on MARCH 28, 2016.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ Our adjudicators will apply this ruling when we make
determinations and decisions on or after March 28, 2016. When a
Federal court reviews our final decision in a claim, we expect the
court will review the final decision using the rules that were in
effect at the time we issued the decision under review. If a court
finds reversible error and remands a case for further administrative
proceedings after March 28, 2016, the applicable date of this
ruling, we will apply this ruling to the entire period at issue in
the decision we make after the court's remand. Our regulations on
evaluating symptoms are unchanged.
CROSS-REFERENCES: SSR 96-8p, ``Titles II and XVI: Assessing
Residual Functional Capacity in Initial Claims,'' and Program
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operations Manual System, section DI 24515.064.
[FR Doc. 2017-23143 Filed 10-24-17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4191-02-P