[Federal Register Volume 82, Number 131 (Tuesday, July 11, 2017)]
[Notices]
[Pages 32056-32121]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2017-14251]
[[Page 32055]]
Vol. 82
Tuesday,
No. 131
July 11, 2017
Part II
Department of Defense
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Demonstration (AcqDemo)
Project; Department of Defense (DoD) Notices
Federal Register / Vol. 82 , No. 131 / Tuesday, July 11, 2017 /
Notices
[[Page 32056]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
Office of the Secretary
[Docket ID: DOD-2017-OS-0031]
Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Demonstration (AcqDemo)
Project; Department of Defense (DoD)
AGENCY: Office of the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense (Civilian
Personnel Policy) (DASD (CPP)), DoD.
ACTION: Proposed notice of consolidation, modification, and
republication as amended of a Personnel Demonstration Project Plan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The DoD, with the approval of the Office of Personnel
Management (OPM), received authority to conduct a personnel
demonstration project within DoD's civilian acquisition workforce and
among those supporting personnel assigned to work directly with it. The
purpose of this notice is to consolidate the original AcqDemo project
plan and, as appropriate, the still relevant interventions described in
the six subsequent amendments and one notice of intent as listed in
Appendix A into a single document for better understanding and ease of
use; record the modifications made to existing demonstration project
initiatives as a result of experience gained from their use; describe
additional personnel management initiatives undertaken to generate
further improvement of and increased efficiencies in support for the
DoD acquisition workforce; and republish the AcqDemo Project Plan as
amended and as updated for corrections, deletions, additions, and
clarifications.
DATES: DoD will consider written comments if received no later than
August 10, 2017.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by docket number and
title, by any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
Mail: Department of Defense, Office of the Deputy Chief
Management Officer, Directorate for Oversight and Compliance, 4800 Mark
Center Drive, Mailbox #24, Suite 08D09B, Alexandria, VA 22350-1700.
Instructions: All submissions received must include the agency
name, docket number and title for this Federal Register document. The
general policy for comments and other submissions from members of the
public is to make these submissions available for public viewing on the
Internet at http://www.regulations.gov as they are received without
change, including any personal identifiers or contact information.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: DoD: Scott Wortman, Program Manager,
Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Demonstration Project, 9820
Belvoir Road, Ft. Belvoir, VA 22060, 703-805-5050; DoD: Ms. Megan
Maciejewski, Defense Civilian Personnel Advisory Service, Human
Resources Operational Programs and Advisory Services, Staffing Policy
Division, 4800 Mark Center Drive, Suite 05F16, Alexandria, VA 22350-
1100, 571-372-1538.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
A. Background
The AcqDemo Project was established under the authority of the
Secretary of Defense, with the approval of OPM. Subject to the
authority, direction, and control of the Secretary, the Under Secretary
of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics (USD(AT&L))
carries out the powers, functions, and duties of the Secretary
concerning the DoD acquisition workforce (AWF). Title 10 United States
Code (U.S.C.) Chapter 87 describes general authorities and
responsibilities, defense acquisition positions, Acquisition Corps,
education and training, and general management provisions applicable to
the Defense AWF. The purpose of the AcqDemo, as stated in 10 U.S.C.
Chapter 87, Section 1762, is ``to determine the feasibility or
desirability of one or more proposals for improving the personnel
management policies or procedures that apply with respect to the
acquisition workforce of the [DoD] and supporting personnel assigned to
work directly with the acquisition workforce.''
This demonstration project was originally authorized under Section
4308 of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year
(FY) 1996 (Pub. L. 104-106, 110 Stat. 669; 10 United States Code
Annotated (U.S.C.A.) 1701 note), as amended by section 845 of NDAA for
FY 1998 (Pub. L. 105-85, 111 Stat.1845); Section 813 of NDAA for FY
2003 (Pub. L. 107-314, 116 Stat. 2609); and Section 1112 of NDAA for FY
2004 (Pub. L. 108-136, 117 Stat. 1634). The NDAA for FY 2004 authorized
the National Security Personnel System (NSPS) and most AcqDemo
employees converted to the NSPS in 2006. Section 1113 of NDAA for FY
2010 (Pub. L. 111-84, 123 Stat. 2190) repealed the NSPS and directed
conversion of all NSPS employees to their previous pay system by
January 1, 2012. All NSPS employees formerly in AcqDemo were
transitioned back to AcqDemo during the month of May 2011. On January
7, 2011, the original demonstration project authority was repealed and
codified at 10 U.S.C. 1762 pursuant to Section 872 of the Ike Skelton
NDAA for FY 2011 (Pub. L. 111-383, 124 Stat. 4300, 4302). With the
enactment of Section 872 of the Ike Skelton NDAA for Fiscal Year (FY)
2011, Public Law 111-383, Congress extended the authority for AcqDemo
until September 30, 2017, and increased the total number of persons who
may participate in the project from 95,000 to 120,000. Congress further
extended the authority for AcqDemo to December 31, 2020, in Section 846
of NDAA for FY 2016 (Pub. L. 114-92). Through Section 867 of NDAA for
FY 2017 (Pub. L. 114-328), Congress provided that the Secretary of
Defense shall exercise the authorities granted to the OPM under 5
U.S.C. 4703 for purposes of the demonstration project.
OPM approved and published the final project plan for the AcqDemo
on January 8, 1999, in 64 Federal Register (FR) 1426-1492. Since that
time, six amendments have been approved and published, and one notice
of intent to amend published by OPM. These are listed in Appendix A.
B. Overview
The project was initially designed in the 1997-1999 timeframe by a
Process Action Team under the authority of then-Under Secretary of
Defense for Acquisition and Technology with the participation of and
review by DoD and the OPM. The purpose of the project is to enhance the
quality, professionalism, and management of the DoD acquisition
workforce through improvements in the efficiency and effectiveness of
the human resources management system. The project interventions strive
to support DoD's efforts to ``create a professional, agile, and
motivated workforce that consistently makes smart business decisions,
acts in an ethical manner, and delivers timely and affordable
capabilities to the warfighter.'' \1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ DoD Directive 5000.52, January 12, 2005, Subject: Defense
Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics Workforce Education,
Training, and Career Development Program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The original AcqDemo Project Plan included streamlined hiring and
appointment authorities; a Voluntary Emeritus Program; broadbanding;
simplified classification; combined classification and appraisal
criteria into six factors; revised reduction-in-force procedures; a
contribution-based compensation and appraisal system; academic degree
and certification
[[Page 32057]]
training; and sabbaticals. A number of new initiatives have been added
and clarifications made to this updated project plan based on
experience gained with the original processes and procedures since
implementation in January 1999; feedback from participants at all
AcqDemo organizational levels; changes in title 5 U.S.C. and title 5
Code of Federal Regulations (CFR); changes in legislative language
impacting AcqDemo employee/organization coverage and project
evaluation; environmental conditions such as a weak economy, government
downsizing, and sequestration; and concerns with the relationship
between position management, Contribution-based Compensation and
Appraisal System (CCAS) scoring; compensation management; and
appropriate pay. The new or modified initiatives and/or topics include
target broadband level; reduction of the six classification and
appraisal factors to three factors; direct hire authority; modified
expedited hiring authority; rule of many; expanded supervisory
probationary period; expanded detail and temporary promotion authority;
revised reduction-in-force procedures basing order of retention
primarily on individual employee performance; compensation management;
clarification of various pay setting procedures for conversions, new
hires, employee movement within AcqDemo, and employees voluntarily
joining AcqDemo; supervisory and team leader cash differentials;
accelerated compensation for developmental positions; student intern
relocation incentive; overall assessment of the quality of performance;
CCAS very high score methodology; and modified contribution improvement
plan procedures. The text of the original FRN and its amendments have
been realigned and rewritten, as necessary, to improve clarity,
organize by topic, remove duplication, eliminate outdated and cancelled
items, and include revisions to existing flexibilities and descriptions
of new interventions. Consequently, the document needs to be read in
its entirety to obtain the full scope of the modernized demonstration
project.
C. Evaluation Results
Since its implementation in early 1999, the AcqDemo interventions
have confirmed that a human resources system tailored to the mission
and needs of the AWF increases workforce satisfaction with the
personnel management system, while providing quality acquisition
products to DoD customers as evidenced by the 2006 AcqDemo Summative
Evaluation \2\ and periodic AcqDemo employee attitude surveys.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ Department of Defense (DoD) Civilian Acquisition Workforce
Personnel Demonstration Project (AcqDemo), Summative Evaluation
Report, June 2006, prepared by the AcqDemo Project Office, 2001 N.
Beauregard Street, Suite 210, Alexandria, Virginia 22311.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The June 2006 Summative Evaluation Report stated: ``AcqDemo had a
positive impact on overall workforce quality by enabling managers to
compete with the private sector for the best talent available and make
timely job offers to potential employees. When AcqDemo procedures were
fully implemented, hiring timeliness was significantly improved.
AcqDemo succeeded in retaining `high contributors' and increasing the
separation rates of `low contributors' without damaging employees'
overall sense of fairness. AcqDemo resulted in high levels of customer
satisfaction, and both employees and supervisors realized the benefits
of AcqDemo flexibilities in responding to customer requirements
quickly. Finally, a variety of data indicated that there was a positive
shift in workforce satisfaction with the AcqDemo personnel management
system.''
Since the return of employees from NSPS in May 2011, there
continues to be strong evidence that the initiatives implemented under
the AcqDemo are effective:
(1) Component acquisition leaders' feedback on effectiveness of
AcqDemo programs on recruitment and retention has been positive.
(2) Senior Leader interviews were positive on the outcomes of
programs but suggested processes may need to be tweaked, e.g., two
recommended changes were (a) to decrease the number of classification
and appraisal factors from six factors to three factors to further
simplify position classification and streamline the CCAS appraisal
process, and (b) add a very high score scheme to each of the three
factors for contributions above the maximum score for each career path
to provide more gradation and increase flexibility for assessment of
different levels of contribution. Following receipt of the Senior
Leader feedback, the workforce was polled on a draft proposal for three
factors in 2014. Over 56% of the workforce was in favor of converting
to the more concise language recommended by the Senior Leaders.
Additionally, overwhelming support on the three-factor format was
received during follow-on Senior Leader Interviews that were conducted
as well as numerous requests for a very high score contribution
appraisal structure for each of the factors as initially suggested.
Therefore, the three new factors, each with their very high score
scheme, are included in the updated AcqDemo Project Plan described in
this FRN.
(3) Additional organizations are seeking to join AcqDemo.
(4) Analysis \3\ provided evidence that people who entered the
acquisition workforce and were covered by an AcqDemo pay plan (or any
demonstration pay plan) were retained longer compared to those in the
General Schedule (GS) plan. Retention was 24 percent higher for the
AcqDemo pay plan than for the GS plan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ RAND Corporation, Retention and Promotion of High-Quality
Civil Service Workers in the Department of Defense Acquisition
Workforce, by Christopher Guo, Philip Hall-Partyka, Susan M. Gates;
Copyright 2014; Chapter 4, Effects of Acquisition Demonstration Pay
Plan on Retention, page 34, 1st partial paragraph; and Conclusion,
page 36, 1st paragraph.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(5) Results from the 2015 OPM Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey
(FEVS) indicated that 87% of the 2015 AcqDemo FEVS responses were
better than the 2014 AcqDemo FEVS responses.
(6) Interview and survey data suggest that many aspects of AcqDemo
are positively perceived, i.e., supervisory perceptions regarding the
ability to hire people as needed and to reassign or reclassify
employees in response to changing mission needs.
(7) Survey respondents reported being more optimistic about
opportunities for promotion and were more likely to believe that their
organization is retaining the highest-performing employees among their
peers in the organizations selected for comparison.
(8) A 2016 independent research report \4\ indicated that unionized
employees have fared well in AcqDemo as compared to unionized employees
in the GS system. AcqDemo provided higher starting salaries, paid
higher salaries overall, and offered a more rapid increase in salaries.
The annualized basic pay was $700 to $1,400 higher for bargaining union
members compared to their GS counterparts. Unionized employees were
more likely to receive promotions than nonunionized employees, while
within the GS comparison group the reverse occurred. The four-year
retention rate for AcqDemo unionized employees was 80.3 percent
compared
[[Page 32058]]
to a corresponding rate of 78.5 percent for the weighted GS control
group.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ RAND Corporation, 2016 Assessment of the Civilian
Acquisition Workforce Personnel Demonstration Project, by Jennifer
Lamping Lewis, Laura Werber, Cameron Wright, Irina Danescu, Jessica
Hwang, Lindsay Daugherty; Copyright 2017; Report Number RR1783.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(9) The 2016 OPM FEVS Employee Engagement Index questions, which
best exemplify ``an employee's sense of purpose,'' and the New
Inclusive Intelligence (IQ) Index questions, which ``center on
behaviors that help create an inclusive environment,'' show continued
year after year improvement from 2014 through 2016 and consistently
higher positive responses than the DoD and overall Federal workforce
across all subcomponents. The top three AcqDemo 2016 positive items
reflect sense of pride in work and are shown below with their
respective percentage of positive responses:
(a) When needed I am willing to put in the extra effort to get a
job done. (95.2%)
(b) Pay raises depend on how well employees perform their jobs.
(39.8%)
(c) How satisfied are you with your opportunity to get a better job
in your organization? (37.9%)
This information is a testament to the success of AcqDemo as a
valuable human resources management tool in the efforts of the
USD(AT&L) to emphasize and achieve broader and stronger workforce
professional and technical qualifications, abilities, and capabilities
for all sixteen DoD acquisition career fields. With the extension of
the AcqDemo authority until December 31, 2020, the Department now has
an additional opportunity to better adjust AcqDemo to the emergent
qualifications associated with the myriad, complex defense acquisition
situations with timely workforce development and more efficient, agile,
and effective processes and procedures. New as well as modified
flexibilities in human resources management activities can be tested
and adjusted for maximum effectiveness in support of the USD(AT&L)
``principle that continuous improvement is the best approach to
improving the performance of the defense acquisition enterprise.'' \5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ Better Buying Power 3.0, White Paper, Office of the Under
Secretary of Defense Acquisition, Technology and Logistics,
Honorable Frank Kendall, 19 September 2014.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Notification Responsibilities
The DoD AcqDemo Program Office will post this amendment on the
Program Office's Web site at http://AcqDemo.hci.mil. In addition,
Participating Organizations will be requested to notify employees,
appropriate union officials, and other stakeholders of this FRN as well
as their communication vehicles, e.g., Web site; letters to employees
and union officials; consultation and negotiation with union officials;
town halls; etc.; and the DoD Program Office Web site and information
contained therein.
Dated: June 30, 2017.
Aaron Siegel,
Alternate OSD Federal Register Liaison Officer, Department of Defense.
Table of Contents
I. Introduction
A. Executive Summary
B. Governance
1. Management Oversight
2. Personnel Policy Boards
3. AcqDemo Project Plan Revisions
4. AcqDemo Internal Guidance
5. Legal Authority
C. Organization and Team Participation
1. Scope of Acquisition Organizations
2. Request To Participate in AcqDemo
3. Calls for Additional Participation
4. Eligibility Requirements
5. Application Process
D. Eligible Organizations
E. Workforce Coverage
1. Covered Workforce
2. Current Participating Employees
F. Bargaining Requirements
II. Personnel System Interventions
A. Classification
1. Broadbanding
2. Occupational Series, Titles, and Classification Standards
3. Classification Level and Appraisal Factors
4. Classification Authority
5. Position Requirements Document
6. Fair Labor Standards Act
7. Maximum Broadband Level
8. Classification Appeals
B. Recruitment and Staffing
1. Appointment Authorities
a. Competitive and Excepted Appointing Authorities
b. Modified Term Appointment Option
2. Targeted Recruitment and Outreach
3. Qualifications and Assessments
4. External Hiring Authorities
a. General Principles
b. Direct Hire Appointments for the Business and Technical
Management Professional Career Path
c. Veteran Direct Hire Appointments for the Business and
Technical Management Professional and Technical Management Career
Paths
d. Acquisition Student Intern Appointments
e. Scholastic Achievement Appointment
f. Simplified Hiring Processes
5. Expanded Initial Probationary Period
6. Staffing Within AcqDemo
a. Expanded Supervisory and/or Managerial Probationary Periods
b. Internal AcqDemo Assignment Process
c. Expanded Detail and Temporary Promotion Authority
d. Exceptions to Competition
e. Reduction in Force
C. Pay Administration
1. Introduction
2. Compensation Strategy
3. Aggregate Limitation on Basic Pay
4. Special Rates
5. Promotions
6. Retained Pay
7. General Schedule (GS) Annual Base Pay Increase
8. Locality Pay
9. Hires From Outside the AcqDemo
10. Internal AcqDemo Employee Movements
11. Accelerated Compensation for Developmental Positions
12. Supervisory and Team Leader Cash Differentials
13. Highest Previous Rate
14. Recruitment, Relocation, and Retention Incentives
15. Awards
D. Contribution-Based Compensation and Appraisal System
1. Overview
2. CCAS Appraisal Process
3. Integrated Pay Schedule
4. Compensation Adjustments
5. Contribution Improvement Plan (CIP)
6. CCAS Grievance Procedures
E. Employee Development
1. Academic Degree and Certificate Training
2. Sabbaticals
3. Student Intern Relocation Incentive
F. Movement Into and From AcqDemo
1. Management-Directed Conversion into the Demonstration Project
2. Non-AcqDemo Federal Employee Voluntarily Joins AcqDemo
3. Movement From the Demonstration Project
G. Training for AcqDemo
1. Introduction
2. Roles and Responsibilities
3. Conversion Training
III. Evaluation Plan
A. Internal
B. External
C. Purpose
IV. Project Duration
V. Demonstration Project Costs
VI. Automation Support
VII. Required Waivers to Law and Regulations
A. General
B. Waivers to Title 5, U.S.C.
C. Waivers to Title 5, CFR
Appendix A. History of Legislative Provisions and Federal Register
Notices DoD Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Management
Demonstration Project
Appendix B. Tables of Eligible Organizations
Appendix C. Series Included in the DoD Acquisition Workforce
Personnel Demonstration Project
Appendix D. Definitions of Career Paths and Corresponding Broadband
Levels
Appendix E. Classification Level and Appraisal Factors
Appendix F. Intervention Impact Evaluation Model
Appendix G. AcqDemo Sample Master Retention List (RIF Effective Date
July 2017), Competitve Area: Local Commuting Area; Fort Husky,
Virgina; Supply Directorate; Business Management and Technical
Management Career Path (NH)
[[Page 32059]]
I. Introduction
A. Executive Summary
AcqDemo is an acquisition-based alternative human resource
management pay and personnel system that provides managers and
organizations with increased flexibilities in recruitment, staffing,
classification, performance management, compensation, and employee
development. The purpose of the project is to enhance the quality,
professionalism, and management of the DoD AWF through improvements in
the efficiency, effectiveness, and agility of the human resources
management system. This project not only provides a system that
retains, recognizes, and rewards employees for their contributions, but
also supports their personal and professional growth as acquisition
specialists and professionals. In addition, this demonstration project
provides managers, at the lowest practical level, the authority,
control, and flexibility they need to achieve effective workforce
management, quality acquisition processes, and superior products.
B. Governance
1. Management Oversight
The AcqDemo Project was established under the authority of the
Secretary of Defense (SECDEF), with the approval of OPM. Subject to the
authority, direction, and control of the SECDEF, the USD(AT&L) carries
out the powers, functions, and duties of the SECDEF concerning the DoD
AWF. The USD(AT&L) is authorized to establish policies and procedures,
in coordination with the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and
Readiness (USD(P&R)), for the effective management of the acquisition,
technology, and logistics workforce in the DoD, which includes
management and oversight of the DoD AcqDemo. To assist in this
endeavor, the USD(AT&L) chartered the DoD Civilian Acquisition
Workforce Personnel Demonstration Project Program Office in September
1999. The Office of Human Capital Initiatives was chartered by the
USD(AT&L) in November 2015, and the Director designated as the senior
official responsible for the AcqDemo program. The Director, Human
Capital Initiatives, is responsible for oversight, policy, direction,
design and centralized management of the AcqDemo. Subject to the
authority, direction, and control of the Director, Human Capital
Initiatives, the AcqDemo Program Manager is responsible for the
centralized management of the DoD AcqDemo Project. The Program Manager
also has authority to establish and chair an Executive Council
comprised of a representative from each DoD Component, Agency, and
Field Activity with organizations and/or teams participating in the
AcqDemo Project (hereafter referred to as Participating Organizations)
plus USD(P&R) and/or USD(AT&L) representatives serving in an advisory
role as appropriate. Each Participating Organization has authority to
manage and oversee AcqDemo implementation and operation within
overarching USD(AT&L), HCI, and/or AcqDemo Program Office policy and
guidance.
2. Personnel Policy Boards
It is envisioned that each Participating Organization, to include
subordinate AcqDemo participating organizations and/or teams, shall
establish a Personnel Policy Board (PPB). The PPB is the body to
manage, evaluate, and make policy and procedural changes for its
respective organization within the parameters of the AcqDemo Project
Plan published in the Federal Register notice 64 FR 1426-1492, DoD
AcqDemo Program Office guidance, and Department of Defense Instructions
(DoDIs). The Executive Director, members, and staff of the Board are
designated by the Head of the Participating Organization. Should any
Participating Organization elect not to establish a PPB, the charter of
an existing group within the respective organization must be modified
to include the duties detailed in Section I.B.2(a) through (i). In
either case, the Board is tasked, at a minimum, with the following:
(a) Overseeing the civilian pay budget;
(b) Addressing issues associated with two or more pay systems
(e.g., AcqDemo, GS, and other pay banded systems);
(c) Determining the composition of the CCAS pay pool in accordance
with the established guidelines and statutory constraints;
(d) Reviewing operation of the organization's CCAS pay pools;
(e) Providing guidance to pay pool managers;
(f) Administering funds to CCAS pay pool managers;
(g) Reviewing hiring and promotion salaries;
(h) Monitoring award pool distribution by organization and
acquisition workforce (AWF) employees vs. non-AWF employees; and
(i) Assessing the need for and making changes to local
demonstration project procedures and policies when needed to further
define specific interventions to ensure standard application across the
participating AcqDemo organization(s) and/or team(s).
3. AcqDemo Project Plan Revisions
Modifications to the AcqDemo Project Plan must be made from time to
time as experience is gained, results are analyzed, and conclusions are
reached on how the various flexibilities are working individually and
within the overall project. Minor policy and procedural modifications
of this published AcqDemo project plan within already existing waivers
may be made by the Director, Human Capital Initiatives, with delegation
to the Program Manager, and published in internal issuances and AcqDemo
Memorandums and/or at http://www.acqdemo.hci.mil to inform stakeholders
such as USD(P&R); AcqDemo Executive Council; Defense Civilian Personnel
Advisory Service; Participating Organizations; employees; Unions; and/
or other interested parties as appropriate. New waivers from law or
regulation must be approved by the USD(AT&L) in coordination with the
USD(P&R) and published in a Federal Register notice.
4. AcqDemo Internal Guidance
The DoD AcqDemo Program Office is responsible for preparing and/or
issuing implementation, operational, sustainment, and other internal
guidance such as AcqDemo Memoranda, Operating Procedures, and/or DoDIs
regarding the AcqDemo provisions to Participating Organizations. This
internal guidance, which can be found at http://www.acqdemo.hci.mil,
supplements with additional details the general guidelines and
parameters established through legislation and Federal Register
notices. Participating Organizations may issue additional internal
guidance to ensure standard application across AcqDemo participating
subordinate organizations and teams. All personnel laws, regulations,
and guidelines not waived by the AcqDemo Project Plan will remain in
effect. Basic employee protections and entitlements such as grievance,
merit system principles, equal opportunity, leave, insurance,
annuities, etc., are unchanged by AcqDemo and remain applicable.
5. Legal Authority
For actions taken under the auspices of the demonstration project,
the legal authority code Z2W, Public Law 111-383, will be used. For all
other actions, the nature of action codes (NOAC) and legal authority
codes prescribed by OPM and/or DoD will continue to be used unless
revised or new codes are
[[Page 32060]]
developed for specific AcqDemo interventions. Information and guidance
on codes specific to AcqDemo will be published in internal implementing
issuances.
C. Organization and Team Participation
1. Scope of Acquisition Organizations. The DoD has numerous
civilian acquisition organizations and teams in the Departments of the
Army, the Navy (including the Marine Corps), and the Air Force as well
as several Defense agencies and field activities. These organizations
and teams are located not only across the United States but also in
various foreign countries. Various elements of these organizations may
be included in AcqDemo if they request to participate in AcqDemo, meet
the eligibility requirements, are coordinated with the USD(P&R), and
approved by the USD(AT&L).
2. Request to Participate in AcqDemo. As a demonstration project,
AcqDemo is subject to audit, evaluation, and reporting requirements as
Department leaders consider expanding participation in AcqDemo and the
merits of undertaking modified and installing new initiatives.
Therefore, to assist in the effective management of the project, it is
necessary to establish and utilize a formal application and approval
process for organizations and teams desiring to participate in AcqDemo.
The broad parameters of this process are described below with finite
content requirements to be issued by the DoD AcqDemo Program Office
using various internal DoD issuances such as AcqDemo Memorandum,
AcqDemo Operating Procedures, and/or DoDIs. As experience is gained
using this process, analysis is conducted, and conclusions reached,
minor modifications may be made by the DoD AcqDemo Program Office.
3. Calls for Additional Participation. The AcqDemo Program Office
may establish a regular schedule or periodically announce opportunities
for interested acquisition organizations to apply for approval to
participate in AcqDemo. Out-of-cycle participation requests will be
reviewed on a case-by-case basis. During the demonstration project
authority period, limited expansion of the project may be determined
valuable by the USD(AT&L). In these cases, plans for such expansion
will be coordinated with the USD(P&R) prior to execution.
4. Eligibility Requirements. Organizational and team participation
in AcqDemo is voluntary. For an interested organization or team to be
approved to participate, the following conditions must be met:
(a) At least one-third of the workforce selected to participate in
the demonstration project consists of members of the acquisition
workforce (civilian employees occupying positions coded as meeting the
requirements of the Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act
(DAWIA) of 1990 as amended);
(b) At least two-thirds of the workforce participating in the
demonstration project consists of members of the acquisition workforce
and supporting personnel assigned to work directly with the acquisition
workforce;
(c) Positions are classified to an approved occupational series;
and
(d) The organization or team request is coordinated through the
chain of command, to include the USD(P&R), for approval by USD(AT&L)
for participation in the AcqDemo Project. Following receipt of
appropriate coordination and approvals for the requesting organization
to participate in AcqDemo, the AcqDemo Program Office staff will
initiate appropriate notification to the requesting Military Department
or DoD Component and USD(P&R). In addition, any organization approved
to participate will notify affected employees, labor organizations, and
other appropriate stakeholders.
5. Application Process. The organization or team seeking approval
to participate in AcqDemo would follow the process steps listed below:
(a) Complete the following preliminary activities:
(1) Review the AcqDemo design with the Participating Organization's
DoD AcqDemo Executive Council Representative, if applicable, and DoD
AcqDemo Program Office officials;
(2) Informally coordinate concurrence of their participation within
its component leadership for any enterprise planning impacts; and
(3) Assess the acceptance level of the workforce with
participation, views of stakeholders such as local bargaining union
leadership (if applicable), and consider any other local climate and/or
operational issues that would impact effective implementation of the
project.
(b) Gather and include the required information described below in
an application packet:
(1) Complete DoD Component, DoD Agency, or DoD Field Activity
address.
(2) Identification of the acquisition-related mission of the
population requesting participation, including a brief discussion of
the major functions performed.
(3) Requesting organizations are encouraged to provide any
applicable local workforce challenges being encountered that are not
covered in 64 FR 1426-1492 and indicate how it is anticipated that
AcqDemo could help address such challenges.
(4) Workforce Demographic Data.
(5) Identification of occupational series that need to be added.
(6) A statement of confirmation that applicable Within-Grade
Increase (WGI) buy-in conversion costs, if applicable, have been
estimated and do not present an adverse financial impact on payroll
budgeting and execution.
(7) Communication plan, as available.
(8) Desired conversion date for candidate population.
(c) Route the application package through its command channels to
the Service Acquisition Executive and the Assistant Secretary for
Manpower and Reserve Affairs (M&RA) for the Military Departments or the
appropriate equivalent authority for other DoD components for
appropriate review and endorsement to the DoD AcqDemo Program Manager.
The AcqDemo Program Office staff will review the application package
for compliance with required information and eligibility requirements
and facilitate coordination of eligibility with USD(P&R), Defense
Civilian Personnel Advisory Services (DCPAS) and participation approval
with USD(AT&L). The AcqDemo Program Manager will then ensure the
approval decisions are implemented, with quarterly updates provided to
USD(P&R) and USD(AT&L).
D. Eligible Organizations
Appendix B provides two tables containing lists of organizations
that have been determined to be eligible to participate. Table 1 of
Appendix B provides a list of those organizations that were determined
to be eligible to participate as of July 1, 2002. Table 1A of Appendix
B contains a list of new or realigned organizations whose eligibility
to participate in AcqDemo was approved by the DoD in calendar year 2014
and by OPM in calendar year 2015.
E. Workforce Coverage
1. Covered Workforce. Section 872 of the Ike Skelton NDAA for FY
2011 increased the number of employees who may participate in AcqDemo
from 95,000 to 120,000 at any one time. The scope of AcqDemo workforce
coverage for the DoD-wide critical acquisition function gives primary
consideration to the number and diversity of occupations within (1) the
acquisition workforce; and (2) the supporting personnel assigned to
work directly with the acquisition workforce. This coverage encompasses
acquisition-related duties
[[Page 32061]]
and positions in sixteen acquisition career fields: Auditing; business-
cost estimating; business-financial management; contracting; facilities
engineering; information technology; life cycle logistics; production,
quality, and manufacturing; program management; property; purchasing;
science and technology management; engineering; test and evaluation;
small business; and international acquisition, with all but two
considered critical acquisition career fields. This position management
structure reflects the structure described in Appendix 1 of the April
2010 DoD Strategic Human Capital Plan (SHCP) Update for the Defense
Acquisition Workforce as well as in the Defense Acquisition Workforce
update for the 2016 DoD SHCP. The occupational series for this
collection of duties and associated positions included in the AcqDemo
are listed in Appendix C.
Additionally, in determining the scope of the demonstration
project, DoD human resources management design goals and priorities for
the entire civilian workforce were considered. While the intent of this
project is to provide DoD activities with increased control and
accountability for their covered workforce, the decision was made to
restrict development efforts initially to positions in the GS and GM
pay plans. Employees covered under the Performance Management and
Recognition System Termination Act (pay plan code GM) are GS employees
and are covered under the demonstration project. The AcqDemo currently
includes employees who previously held positions under the GS or GM pay
plan codes or under one of the National Security Personnel System pay
plan codes or under other pay systems. Employees and positions in other
personnel systems and pay plans may be converted into AcqDemo as a
result of reorganizations, restructuring, realignment, consolidation,
Base Realignment and Closure decisions, legislative dictates, or other
organizational changes as determined appropriate by the AcqDemo Program
Manager. Students and recent graduates hired through the Pathways
Programs may be included as determined by Participating Organizations.
Excluded from coverage of this project at this time are Senior
Executive Service, Senior Level, Scientific and Technical, Federal Wage
System, and Administratively Determined positions. Also excluded from
the project are (1) positions allocated to a Physicians and Dentist Pay
Plan, either GP or GR; (2) positions covered by the Defense Civilian
Intelligence Personnel System (10 U.S.C. chapter 83); (3) positions
covered by or to be included in one of the Science and Technology
Reinvention Laboratory (STRL) personnel demonstration projects (Section
342(b) of the NDAA for FY 1995, Pub. L. 103-337 (10 U.S.C. 2358), as
amended); (4) primary or secondary law enforcement officer (LEO)
positions (5 U.S.C. 5541(3)); and (5) administrative law judge
positions. To determine if an organization and series are included,
locate the organization in Appendix B, either in Table 1 or Table 1A,
and then find the job series in Appendix C.
2. Current Participating Employees. Table 1 provides a breakout of
the AcqDemo actual population as of July 29, 2016, by Participating
Organizations including number of employees by career path, broadband
level, and bargaining unit representation. Of the 33,639 employees,
6.45% or 2,171 are represented by labor unions. The American Federation
of Government Employees and the National Federation of Federal
Employees represent the largest number of employees. The International
Association of Fire Fighters, International Federation of Professional
and Technical Engineers, and Laborers' International Union of North
America represent the remainder of AcqDemo bargaining unit employees.
F. Bargaining Requirements
1. Written Agreements. Employees within a unit to which a labor
organization is accorded exclusive recognition under 5 U.S.C. chapter
71, shall not be included as part of the demonstration project unless
the exclusive representative and the agency have entered into a written
agreement covering participation in and implementation of this project.
In order to ensure that the integrity of the acquisition demonstration
project is maintained, parties may not change the design and intent of
any of the project initiatives during negotiations. DoD has authority
to operate only ONE project with the initiatives applying to all
Participating Organizations. Revisions to initiatives may only be made
in accordance with Section I.B.3 of this project plan.
The parties may use mediation or any other mutually acceptable
means to resolve disputes over the implementation of the project with
respect to unit employees. Neither party may request the assistance of
the Federal Service Impasses Panel to resolve such disputes. Either
labor or management may unilaterally withdraw from negotiations over
the application of this demonstration project to bargaining unit
members at any time up until final agreement approval, without such
action being considered an unfair labor practice under 5 U.S.C. 7116,
for refusing to negotiate in good faith.
Written agreements addressing the initial implementation of the
demonstration project to bargaining unit members of Participating
Organizations are subject to agency head review and approval within DoD
prior to implementation. Thus, agreements will be reviewed as provided
in 5 U.S.C. 7114(c).
2. Subsequent Negotiations. Once a written agreement is reached and
approved allowing for the local implementation of the project, all
subsequent negotiations during the life of the project shall be subject
to binding impasse procedures under 5 U.S.C. 7119.
BILLING CODE 5001-06-P
[[Page 32062]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.000
[[Page 32063]]
BILLING CODE 5001-06-C
II. Personnel System Interventions
A. Classification
1. Broadbanding
a. The broadbanding system replaces the current GS fifteen-grade
structure. The fifteen GS grades are arranged into three or four
broadband levels within a career path in accordance with recognized
advancement expected within the occupations assigned to the career
path. Broadband level pay ranges were derived from base pay rates under
5 U.S.C. 5303 of the banded GS grades. The lowest basic pay rate of any
given broadband level is that for step 1 of the lowest GS grade in that
broadband level. Likewise, the highest basic pay rate of any given
broadband level is that for step 10 of the highest GS grade in that
broadband level. There is a natural overlap in basic pay ranges in the
GS grades that also occurs in the broadband system. Once employees move
into the demonstration project, GS grades as well as WGIs and quality
step increases will no longer apply and promotions will be less
frequent. Movement through a broadband level will be based on employee
appraisals under the CCAS; movement to a higher broadband level will be
by competitive or non-competitive promotion; and voluntary or
involuntary movement to a lower broadband level by a change to a lower
broadband level personnel action.
b. There are three distinct career paths where AcqDemo occupations
with similar characteristics are grouped together to facilitate
advancement, pay progression, and more competitive recruitment of
quality candidates at differing rates. The career paths are designated
as Business Management and Technical Management Professional, Pay Plan
NH; Technical Management Support, Pay Plan NJ; and Administrative
Support, Pay Plan NK. The occupations placed within each of these
career paths are listed in Appendix C. The three career paths and their
associated broadband levels compared to GS grades are shown in Figure
1, Career Paths and Broadband Structure.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.001
c. The broadband levels represent basic pay only and will be
labeled I, II, III, or IV. Comparison to the GS base pay table is used
in setting the minimum and maximum basic pay limits of the broadband
levels. As the rates of the GS are increased for any annual across-the-
board GS pay increase, the minimum and maximum basic pay rates of the
broadband levels will also increase. Basic pay rates for employees are
established within the minimum and maximum basic pay range for their
position's broadband level. Section C, Pay Administration, offers more
detail on how to set pay within a broadband level.
Since employees' pay progression through a broadband level depends
on their contribution to the organization's mission and accomplishment
of higher level, broader scope, and/or more difficult work assignments,
there will be no scheduled WGIs or scheduled across-the-board GS
increases for employees covered by the broadbanding system. Advancement
to a higher broadband level is typically through merit promotion or
competitive recruitment procedures. Movement to a lower broadband level
may be voluntary or involuntary. Special salary rates will no longer be
applicable to demonstration project employees. Employees will be
eligible for the locality pay of their geographical area with the
exception of those employees stationed at an overseas location.
2. Occupational Series, Titles, and Classification Standards
The AcqDemo Project will continue to use the occupational series
designators and position titles consistent with those authorized by DoD
and/or OPM to identify positions. The current AcqDemo occupational
series will be placed into appropriate career paths as shown in
Appendix C. Appendix C has been updated to remove those series
cancelled by OPM, to provide current series titles, to include
additional series, and to move existing series to different or
additional career paths. Other occupational series may be added or
current series revised or deleted as a result of fluctuations in
mission requirements or future DoD or OPM modifications to occupational
series. Titling practices consistent with those
[[Page 32064]]
established by DoD or OPM classification standards will be used to
determine the official title of positions. References in the position
classification standards to grade criteria will not be used as part of
the demonstration project. Rather, the AcqDemo provides definitions for
each of the career paths and corresponding broadband levels within them
as described in Appendix D.
3. Classification Level and Appraisal Factors
a. General. Under the demonstration project, a standard set of
three classification levels and appraisal factors has been developed
for each career path--Factor 1. Job Achievement and/or Innovation;
Factor 2. Communication and/or Teamwork; and Factor 3. Mission Support.
These factors comprised of expected contribution criteria and broadband
level descriptors and discriminators, as aligned to the three career
paths and their broadband levels, will be used for broadband level
classification and employee contribution assessment. The employee
contribution assessment includes both a determination of an Overall
Contribution Score (OCS) and a performance appraisal level for each
factor. While the basic classification and appraisal factors,
descriptors, and discriminators cannot be changed, the factors with the
addition of an employee's contribution plan are fundamental to the
success of an acquisition organization and capture the critical content
and expectations for positions in the three career paths--Business
Management and Technical Management Professional, Technical Management
Support, and Administrative Support.
b. Expected Contribution Criteria. The AcqDemo utilizes baseline
expected contribution criteria prepared for each of the three factors.
These criteria are applicable to all contributions at all broadband
levels under the appropriate factor. The criteria form the basis from
which specific contribution expectations, standards, goals, or
objectives are developed for an employee's contribution plan for the
classification level of work in the employee's position. These criteria
may only be modified by the DoD AcqDemo Program Office.
c. Factors. The factors are derived from the Office of Personnel
Management, Introduction to the Position Classification Standards,
Appendix 3, Primary Standard, and represent the primary type of work
and contribution typically found in positions classified to a specific
career path and broadband level.
(1) Descriptors. Descriptors are narrative statements that are
written at increasing levels of complexity, scope, and value of
position and employee contribution. They are meant to correspond with
the broadband levels, and their associated ranges of basic pay, for
classification and appraisal purposes. While the descriptors indicate a
position classification and/or contribution level appropriate at the
upper end of each broadband level, a broadband may actually contain an
array of positions with varying levels of work, responsibilities, and
value. These attributes range from just above the upper end of the next
lower broadband level to an employee's position to the upper end of the
employee's broadband level as defined by an organization's position
management structure needed to accomplish its mission. Descriptors are
not to be used individually to determine position classification or
assess contributions, but rather are to be considered as a group to
derive a single evaluation of each factor.
(2) Discriminators. The discriminators refine the descriptors. For
example, the Communication and/or Teamwork factor has four
discriminators (oral, written, contribution to team, and
effectiveness), which are the same for all broadband levels. The
discriminators help to define the type and complexity of work; degree
of responsibility; and scope of contributions that need to be
ultimately accomplished to reach the highest basic pay potential within
a broadband level for an employee's position and contributions. The
discriminators are often times included in the duties portion of the
Position Requirements Document to clarify the generic descriptors as to
type and level of work, and in contribution expectations, standards,
goals, and/or objectives included in an employee's contribution plan to
foster contributions at the appropriate level and value for the
position within its broadband level and to support the organization's
strategic goals and objectives needed to meet its mission.
(3) Summary. The three factor evaluations when taken as a whole
result in either a classification determination of the broadband level
for the position or an OCS and performance appraisal for an employee's
contribution assessment depending on the action being addressed. This
structure in turn would be used to set the stage for determination of
position classification, contribution assessment, and ultimately
compensation decisions. The definitions for the career paths and
corresponding broadband levels within them are found in Appendix D. The
classification levels with descriptors, discriminators, and appraisal
factors can be found in Appendix E.
4. Classification Authority
Under the AcqDemo, Heads of Participating Organizations (or
equivalent) will have delegated classification authority and may re-
delegate this authority to subordinate management levels to a level not
lower than one management level above the first-line supervisor of the
position under review, except in the case of those employees reporting
directly to the Head of the Participating Organization or equivalent.
First-line supervisors will provide classification recommendations.
Individuals knowledgeable and experienced in classification
methodology, to include Human Resources Specialists, may provide
ongoing consultation and guidance to managers and supervisors
throughout the classification process.
5. Position Requirements Document
Under the demonstration project's classification system, a position
requirements document (PRD) combines the position information; staffing
requirements; factors, descriptors, and discriminators; expected
contribution criteria for the assigned broadband level; and position
evaluation statement into a single document. The AcqDemo Program Office
has developed fillable templates for each career path broadband level
to aid supervisors in producing a PRD. These templates may be found on
the AcqDemo Web site at: http://acqdemo.hci.mil/PRD.html. Participating
Organizations may use an alternative automated system to support
AcqDemo classification as needed. The objectives in developing the new
PRD are to: (a) Simplify the descriptions and the preparation process
through automation; (b) provide more flexibility in work assignments;
and (c) provide a more useful tool for other functions of personnel
management, e.g., recruitment, assessment of contribution, employee
development, and reduction in force.
6. Fair Labor Standards Act
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) exemption or non-exemption
determinations will be made consistent with criteria found in 5 CFR
part 551. All employees are covered by the FLSA unless they meet
criteria for exemption. Positions will be evaluated as needed by
comparing the duties and responsibilities assigned, the broadband level
descriptors for each broadband
[[Page 32065]]
level, and the 5 CFR part 551 FLSA criteria.
7. Maximum Broadband Level
Each position under the demonstration project will have a
designated maximum broadband level. This maximum broadband level will
be identified as the top broadband level within a career path for a
particular position and the broadband level to which an incumbent,
selected competitively or through merit promotion for a lower broadband
level, may be advanced without further competition. These broadband
levels will be based upon the full performance levels of positions
before conversion into AcqDemo. After conversion a newly created or re-
described AcqDemo position may be assigned a different maximum
broadband level based on the AcqDemo organization's position management
structure, change in mission, reorganization, and similar factors.
Maximum broadband levels may vary based upon occupation or career path.
An employee's basic pay will be capped at the maximum rate for the
designated broadband level until the employee has been promoted into
the next higher broadband level.
8. Classification Appeals
An employee may appeal the occupational series, title, or broadband
level of his or her own position at any time. An employee may not
appeal the accuracy of the position requirements document; the
demonstration project classification criteria; the pay-setting
criteria; the propriety of a salary schedule; or matters grievable
under an administrative or negotiated grievance procedure or an
alternative dispute resolution procedure.
An employee must formally raise the areas of concern to supervisors
in the immediate chain of command, either orally or in writing. If an
employee is not satisfied with the supervisory response, he/she may
appeal to the Head of his/her organization. If the employee is not
satisfied with the supervisory response, he/she may then appeal to his/
her organization's Component or Agency level in accordance with their
instructions. If the employee is not satisfied with the Component or
Agency decision, the employee may appeal to the DoD appellate level.
Appellate decisions rendered by DoD will be final and binding on all
administrative, certifying, payroll, disbursing, and accounting
officials of the Department. The evaluation of classification appeals
under this demonstration project is based upon the demonstration
project classification criteria. Case files will be forwarded for
adjudication through the civilian personnel/human resources office
providing personnel service and will include copies of appropriate
demonstration project criteria. Time periods for case processing under
5 CFR 511.605 apply.
B. Recruitment and Staffing
One of the goals of the DAWIA Program is to create well-trained,
multi-skilled professionals who can effectively manage multi-million-
dollar programs. Hiring restrictions and complex processes unduly
increase hiring timelines, exhaust valuable resources, and
unnecessarily detract attention from the acquisition mission. Managers
must be able to compete with academia and the private sector for the
best talent and be able to make timely job offers to potential
employees who display the experience, education, competencies,
knowledge, skills, abilities, and motivation to be successful in the
highly dynamic DoD acquisition environment. The program has statutory
and regulatory requirements necessitating substantial education,
training and experience, special certifications, and continuous
learning designed to create a cadre of highly skilled acquisition
professionals ready for assignment to the DoD's most senior acquisition
positions.
The position management structure for the DAWIA Program contains
three categories of AWF members and positions that may be found in each
of the acquisition career fields. The largest category is comprised of
persons assigned to developmental and mid-level acquisition positions.
The next category encompasses Critical Acquisition Positions which are
senior acquisition positions with significant responsibility, primarily
involving supervisory or management duties in acquisition systems. The
top level of positions, Key Leadership Positions, require special
USD(AT&L) attention, have significant leadership responsibilities, are
held by personnel in the most demanding acquisition positions, and are
critical to the success of the DoD acquisition program.
To maintain an adequate complement of trained AWF members in each
of the position categories and career fields, the DoD establishes
hiring strategies and goals that are published in its biennial Human
Capital Strategic Workforce Plan. A recent Government Accountability
Office (GAO) \6\ review of the results from the goals expressed in the
DoD 2010 acquisition workforce plan and to be achieved by 2015,
indicated that DoD did not reach the growth targets for six acquisition
career fields by about 4,400 personnel. This includes four critical
career fields, i.e., contracting; business; production, quality, and
manufacturing; and engineering along with two non-critical career
fields, i.e., property and purchasing. This shortfall in reaching
essential growth targets illustrates the need for more efficient,
agile, and effective hiring flexibilities to provide consideration of a
broader spectrum of candidates from which to quickly acquire and
steadfastly maintain a high quality acquisition workforce and its
direct support personnel for each of the sixteen acquisition career
fields.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ United States Government Accountability Office, Report to
Congressional Committees, Defense Acquisition Workforce, Actions
Needed to Guide Planning Efforts and Improve Workforce Capability,
December 2015, GAO-16-80.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Appointment Authorities
a. Competitive and Excepted Appointing Authorities. Under this
demonstration project, there are two primary tenure existing
competitive service appointment options used in the competitive service
and excepted service: Permanent and temporary time-limited (which
includes temporary and term (or term-like in the excepted service)).
The permanent option consists of the existing career-conditional and
career appointments (and equivalent appointments in the excepted
service). The temporary limited option may be used to fill a short-term
position, i.e., one that is not expected to last longer than one year
and is filled on a temporary basis. However, if warranted, the
temporary limited appointment may be extended up to a maximum of one
additional year for a total of 24 months of service. As appropriate
under the provisions of this demonstration project, Participating
Organizations may use other competitive service or excepted service
appointing authorities and assignment mechanisms including the
Veterans' Recruitment Appointment, Pathways Programs, and Appointment
for Individuals with Disabilities for appointments into AcqDemo. While
authorities such as Expert and Consultant and Intergovernmental
Personnel Act appointments are not covered by the FRN, Participating
Organizations may use them.
b. Modified Term Appointment Option.
(1) The modified term option is based on the existing term
appointment. A modified term appointment is expected to last longer
than one year but not to exceed five years unless a one-year
[[Page 32066]]
extension is locally approved for a total not to exceed six years when
the need for an employee's service is not permanent. Reasons for making
a modified term appointment include, but are not limited to, carrying
out special project work; staffing new or existing programs of limited
duration; filling a position in activities undergoing review for
reduction or closure; replacing permanent employees who have been
temporarily assigned to another position, are on extended leave, or
have entered military service; and hiring college students for the
Acquisition Student Intern Program. Most selections for modified term
appointments will be made under the competitive examining processes or
by using direct-hire procedures. However, an AcqDemo Participating
Organization may give a noncompetitive modified term appointment to a
selectee who is qualified for the position and is eligible for one of
the categories listed in 5 CFR 316.302(b), items (1) through (8).
(2) Reassignment. A Participating Organization may place a modified
term employee in any other modified term position provided the employee
meets the qualifying requirements of that position. However, such
reassignment will not serve to extend the appointment beyond the
original term appointment time period. The minimum eligibility
requirements for the position will be determined according to OPM's
Operating Manual ``Qualifications Standards for General Schedule
Positions'' and applicable DAWIA requirements. DAWIA requirements may
be used as quality ranking factors. Both sets of eligibility
requirements do provide waivers by an appropriate authority.
(3) Conversion to Career-Conditional Appointment. Employees hired
under the modified term appointment authority are in a temporary status
but may be eligible for conversion to career-conditional appointments
or career appointments if applicable. To be converted, the employee
must: (a) Have been selected for the term position under competitive
procedures, with the announcement specifically stating that the
individual(s) selected for the term positions(s) may be eligible for
conversion to career-conditional appointment at a later date; (b) have
served two years of continuous service in the term position; and (c)
have been considered to have adequate contributions for two appraisal
cycles (including the current appraisal cycle) immediately preceding
conversion. Service under a modified term appointment immediately prior
to a permanent appointment shall count toward the probationary period
requirements described in 10 U.S.C. 1599e.
(4) Benefits and Appeal Rights. Benefits and appeal rights are the
same as those currently afforded term employees.
2. Targeted Recruitment and Outreach
Hiring managers of Participating Organizations are encouraged to
use a variety of sources for their targeted recruitment and outreach
efforts for both permanent and time-limited positions in the
competitive and excepted services, including: Colleges/universities
with degree programs that meet acquisition position requirements, job
fairs, virtual career fairs, professional organizations, alumni
associations, USAJOBS and non-Federal employment Web sites, employee
referrals, contractors, and separating or retiring military members.
Short-term or long-term job announcements may be posted for current
and/or projected vacancies, multiple vacancies, broadband levels, and/
or geographic locations as appropriate based upon the availability of
qualified candidates and the type of position being filled. Hiring
managers have, in consultation with their Human Resources Offices, the
option of making on-the-spot tentative job offers at job fairs and
other recruiting events when using a noncompetitive or direct hiring
authority. These offers are contingent upon meeting appropriate public
notice requirements, clearing local priorities to include Priority
Placement Program, Reemployment Priority List, and Interagency Career
Transition Assistance Plan, and meeting any other requirements (e.g.,
security clearances, certifications).
3. Qualifications and Assessments
For external government hiring, an applicant's basic eligibility
for a position will be determined using OPM's Operating Manual,
``Qualifications Standards for General Schedule Positions,'' and DAWIA
requirements as appropriate. Experience gained in both permanent and
time-limited competitive and excepted service positons as well as
external government positions may be considered as appropriate.
a. Qualifications. Minimum eligibility requirements will be those
corresponding to the lowest GS grade referenced in the broadband level
of the position being filled. For internal government hiring,
qualifying experience is defined as one year at the next lower
broadband level in AcqDemo or an equivalent career path and broadband
level in a different pay banding system; or one GS grade or equivalent
level lower than the lowest GS grade referenced in the AcqDemo
broadband level of the position being filled; or a combination of both
this AcqDemo and GS experience.
b. Assessments. For assessment purposes, selective placement
factors may be established in accordance with OPM's Operating Manual
``Qualifications Standards for General Schedule Positions'' when judged
to be critical to successful job performance. Selective factors
identify any qualifications that are required when a selectee starts
the job. Based on his/her characteristics, if an applicant does not
meet a selective factor, he/she is ineligible for further
consideration. Quality ranking factors are experience, competencies,
knowledge, skills, abilities, and DAWIA certifications required that
are expected to enhance performance in a position and focus on the
level of proficiency the selectee brings to the job. Unlike selective
factors, quality ranking factors are not used to ``screen out''
applicants but to focus on the level of proficiency applicants would
bring to the position. Both the selective factors and/or quality
ranking factors, when used for applicant assessment, will be
communicated to applicants via a vacancy announcement or public notice
when such is required.
4. External Hiring Authorities
a. General Principles. When exercising the AcqDemo external hiring
authorities, Participating Organizations will adhere to all applicable
authorities and the following principles:
(1) A highly qualified workforce is critical to the Department's
acquisition mission.
(2) Recruitment efforts should be designed to attract diverse
candidates who are representative of all segments of society.
(3) Merit factors shall be the basis for selecting individuals for
positions. All personnel programs and practices shall be administered
in accordance with DoD Directive 1020.02E, ``Diversity Management and
Equal Opportunity in the DoD''.
(4) The criteria in 5 U.S.C. 2108 and 5 U.S.C. 2108a for
determining the preference eligibility of each applicant shall apply to
AcqDemo without change. DoD AcqDemo Program Office and Participating
Organizations' procedures shall ensure that, at a minimum:
(a) Selecting officials treat veterans' preference eligibility as a
positive factor when making a selection from external recruitment
sources or where veterans'
[[Page 32067]]
preference is otherwise applicable. The detailed definition of
``positive factor'' rests with participating organizations and is
expected to be described in internal issuances and on vacancy
announcements. The AcqDemo Program Office guidance is stated generally
to keep veterans' preference as a highlighted item to define how it
will be addressed in external recruiting and to provide maximum
flexibility to Participating Organizations in developing their policy.
(b) When making final selections, any candidates with veterans'
preference should be considered for appointments if they are found to
best meet mission requirements.
(c) If a non-preference eligible candidate is selected over a
veteran considered to best meet mission requirements, the reasons for
non-selection of any veteran considered to best meet mission
requirements must be documented in writing. Non-selection documentation
must be made part of the permanent selection record. Reasons for non-
selection will be provided to the veteran candidate by the servicing
human resources office if requested by the veteran. Participating
Organizations may establish a higher level review and/or approval
process above the selecting official if appropriate.
(5) Displaced employee procedures shall be adhered to when using
this authority.
(6) Participating Organizations must ensure transparency,
accountability, and auditability in hiring processes.
b. Direct Hire Appointments for the Business and Technical
Management Professional Career Path. The Head of a Participating
Organization may appoint qualified candidates possessing at least a
baccalaureate degree required by OPM or DoD qualification standards
covering acquisition positions and/or qualified candidates for those
positions involving 51% or more of time in direct support of
acquisition positions in a critical acquisition career field classified
to the Business and Technical Management Professional, NH, career path,
without regard to the provisions of 5 U.S.C. chapter 33, subchapter I
(other than sections 3303, 3308, and 3328 of such title).
c. Veteran Direct Hire Appointments for the Business and Technical
Management Professional and Technical Management Career Paths. The Head
of a Participating Organization may appoint qualified veteran
candidates to acquisition positions in a critical acquisition career
field and to those positions involving 51% or more of time in direct
support of an acquisition position classified to either the Business
and Technical Management Professional, NH, career path or to the
Technical Management Support, NJ, career path, without regard to the
provisions of 5 U.S.C. chapter 33, subchapter I (other than sections
3303 and 3328 of such title). The term ``veteran'' has the meaning
given that term in 38 U.S.C. 101.
d. Acquisition Student Intern Appointments. The Head of a
Participating Organization, without regard to the provisions of 5
U.S.C. chapter 33, subchapter (other than sections 3303 and 3328 of
such title), may appoint candidates enrolled in a program of
undergraduate or graduate instruction at an institution of higher
education leading to either:
(1) A baccalaureate degree in a course of study required by OPM or
DoD qualification standards for an acquisition position in a critical
acquisition career field; or (2) A degree the completion of which
(including any additional essential credit hours or related experience
in an acquisition-related field as defined by DoD internal issuances)
provides competencies, knowledge, skills, etc., directly linked to an
acquisition position's requirements (selective placement or quality
ranking factors) for one of the critical acquisition career fields.
An ``institution of higher education'' for this purpose has the
same meaning as that term is defined in Section 101 and 102 of the
Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001). Appointments under this
authority may be made using a term appointment authority or the
Pathways appointment authority.
e. Scholastic Achievement Appointment. This demonstration project
establishes a Scholastic Achievement Appointment that provides the
authority to appoint candidates with degrees to acquisition positions
with positive education requirements without regard to the provisions
of subchapter I of chapter 33 of title 5, U.S.C. (other than sections
3303 and 3328 of such title). This authority allows for competitive
appointment to acquisition positions classified to either the NH-II or
NH-III broadband level of the Business and Technical Management
Professional career path. Candidates may be appointed under this
procedure if:
(1) They have at least a baccalaureate degree required by OPM or
DoD qualification standards, or a degree the completion of which
(including any additional essential credit hours or specialized
experience in an acquisition-related field as identified by DoD
internal issuances) provides competencies, knowledge, skills, etc.,
directly linked to an acquisition position's requirements for one of
the critical acquisition career fields plus any selective factors,
quality ranking factors, and/or DAWIA certification requirements stated
in a vacancy announcement;
(2) the candidate has a cumulative grade point average (GPA) of
3.25 or better (on a 4.0 scale) in those courses in those fields of
study that are specified in the OPM Qualification Standards for the
occupational series and an overall undergraduate GPA of at least 3.0 on
a 4.0 scale; and
(3) the appointment is into a permanent or term position at a pay
level within the NH-II broadband level basic pay range. Appointments
may also be made to the NH-III broadband level on the basis of graduate
education and/or experience, but with the requirement of a GPA of at
least 3.5 on a scale of 4.0 for graduate courses in the field of study
required for the occupation.
f. Simplified Hiring Processes. The goal of the simplified hiring
processes is to enable AcqDemo Participating Organizations to expedite
the hiring and appointment of qualified persons to acquisition
positions as well as to direct support positions in any of the sixteen
acquisition career fields using the approaches described below:
(1) A name request may be submitted to expedite the appointment of
a qualified candidate identified through a Participating Organization's
targeted recruitment actions.
(2) A certificate of eligibles may be developed from qualified
applicants to a vacancy announcement who have been evaluated or rated
under an appropriate assessment methodology such as the Administrative
Careers with America examination, USA Hire, or OPM category rating
procedures.
(3) This demonstration project established a streamlined AcqDemo
Delegated Examining-Category Rating process. This process may be used
to fill both acquisition positions and those in direct support of
acquisition positions covered by this demonstration project.
An applicant's basic eligibility will be determined using OPM's
Operating Manual ``Qualifications Standards for General Schedule
Positions'' and any DAWIA requirements as needed. Minimum eligibility
qualification requirements will be those corresponding to the lowest GS
grade referenced in the broadband level of the position being filled.
For internal government hiring (i.e., promotion and internal placement
in the competitive service), qualifying experience is defined as one
year at the next lower broadband level in AcqDemo or an
[[Page 32068]]
equivalent career path and broadband level in a different pay banding
system; or one GS grade or equivalent level lower than the lowest GS
grade referenced in the AcqDemo broadband level of the position being
filled; or a combination of both this AcqDemo and GS experience.
Selective placement factors may be established in accordance with OPM's
Operating Manual ``Qualifications Standards for General Schedule
Positions'' when judged to be critical to successful job performance
and become part of the minimum qualification requirements for the
position being filled. Selective placement factors identify any
qualifications that are required when a selectee starts the job. Based
on the applicant's characteristics, if an applicant does not meet a
selective factor, he/she is ineligible for further consideration.
Quality ranking factors are experience, competencies, knowledge,
skills, abilities, and DAWIA certifications required that are expected
to enhance performance in a position and focus on the level of
proficiency the selectee brings to the job. Unlike selective factors,
quality ranking factors are not used to ``screen out'' applicants but
to focus on assessing the level of proficiency applicants would bring
to the position. Both the selective factors and/or quality ranking
factors, when used for applicant assessment, will be communicated to
applicants via a vacancy announcement, public notice, or job
announcement when such notice is required.
Candidates who meet the basic minimum eligibility qualifications
will be further evaluated based on knowledge, skills, and abilities
which are directly linked to the positions(s) to be filled. Based on
this assessment, candidates will be placed in one of the quality
groups, i.e., Superior, Highly Qualified, or Basically Qualified. The
process for listing names within each specific category is to be
determined by the Participating Organization.
Selecting officials should be provided with a reasonable number of
qualified candidates from which to choose. All candidates in the
highest group will be certified. If there is an insufficient number of
candidates in the highest group, candidates in the next lower group may
then be certified; should this process not yield a sufficient number,
groups will be certified sequentially until a selection is made or the
qualified pool is exhausted. When two or more groups are certified,
candidates will be identified by quality group (i.e., Superior, Highly
Qualified, or Basically Qualified). Veterans' preference eligibility
will be determined when making final selections. When making final
selections, any candidates with veterans' preference should be
considered for appointments if they are found to best meet mission
requirements.
(4) Rule of Many. When there are no more than 25 applicants for an
acquisition position or a direct support position in any career field,
all eligible applicants regardless of veterans' preference may be
referred. Veterans' preference eligibility will be determined when
making final selections. When making final selections, any candidates
with veterans' preference should be considered for appointments if they
are found to best meet mission requirements.
(5) Voluntary Emeritus Program
(a) Eligibility and Program Criteria. Under the demonstration
project, Heads of Participating Organizations have the authority to
offer voluntary assignments in Participating Organizations and to
accept the gratuitous services of the following individuals:
1--AcqDemo retired or separated civilian employees who served in
either DAWIA-covered positions or positions in direct support to DAWIA-
coded positions (for the Voluntary Emeritus Program, hereinafter
referred to as AcqDemo employees) and
2--Non-AcqDemo DoD retired or separated civilian employees and
former military members who worked in DAWIA-covered positions.
Voluntary Emeritus Program assignments are not considered
employment by the Federal Government (except as indicated below). Thus,
such assignments do not affect a former civilian employee's entitlement
to buy-outs or severance payments based on earlier separation from
Federal Service. This program may not be used to replace or substitute
for work performed by civilian employees occupying regular acquisition
positions required to perform the mission of the Participating
Organization.
The Voluntary Emeritus Program will ensure continued quality
acquisition by allowing experienced, former civilian and military DoD
acquisition professionals who served in DAWIA-covered positions and
former AcqDemo employees to accept retirement incentives with the
opportunity to retain a presence in the acquisition community. The
program will be beneficial during manpower reductions as program
managers, engineers, other skilled acquisition professionals and former
AcqDemo employees who provided direct support to acquisition
professionals to accept retirement and return to provide a continuing
source of corporate knowledge and valuable on-the-job training or
mentoring to less experienced employees.
To be accepted into the Voluntary Emeritus Program, a volunteer
must be recommended to the decision-making authority by one or more
acquisition managers familiar with the skills that the volunteer offers
to the organization. Acquisition managers at any level may initiate the
decision process, however the decision-making documentation must be
routed through the senior acquisition manager of the organization where
the volunteer will be assigned, in route to the Head of the
Participating Organization making the decision. No one who applies is
entitled to an emeritus position. The decision-making authority must
document the decision process for each applicant (whether accepted or
rejected) and retain the documentation throughout the assignment.
Documentation of rejections will be maintained for two years.
To ensure success and encourage participation, the volunteer's
Federal retirement pay (whether the retirement pay is based upon
military or civilian service) will not be affected while the volunteer
is serving in emeritus status. Retired or separated AcqDemo employees,
non-AcqDemo DoD civilian employees and military members who served in
DAWIA-coded positions may accept an emeritus position without a ``break
in service'' or mandatory waiting period.
Voluntary Emeritus Program volunteers will not be permitted to
monitor contracts on behalf of the Government but may participate on
any contract if no conflict of interest exists. The volunteer may be
required to submit a financial disclosure form annually and will not be
permitted to participate on any contracts where a conflict of interest
exists. The same rules that currently apply to source selection members
will apply to volunteers.
(b) Agreement Requirements. An agreement will be established among
the volunteer, the decision-making authority, and the Human Resources
Office. The agreement must be finalized before the assumption of duties
and shall include:
1--A statement that the service provided is gratuitous, does not
constitute an appointment in the Civil Service, is without compensation
or other benefits except as provided for in the agreement itself, and
that, except as provided in the agreement regarding work-related injury
compensation, any and all claims against the Government
[[Page 32069]]
because of the service are waived by the volunteer;
2--A statement that the volunteer will be considered a Federal
employee for the purposes of:
a--Subchapter I of 5 U.S.C. chapter 81 (using the formula
established in 10 U.S.C. 1588 for determination of compensation) (work-
related injury compensation);
b--28 U.S.C. chapter 171 (tort claims procedure);
c--5 U.S.C. 552a (records maintained on individuals); and
d--18 U.S.C. chapter 11 (conflicts of interest).
3--The volunteer's work schedule;
4--Length of agreement (defined by length of project or time
defined by weeks, months, or years);
5--Support provided by the activity (travel, administrative, office
space, supplies, etc.);
6--A one-page statement of duties and experience;
7--A statement specifying that no additional time will be added to
a volunteer's service credit for such purposes as retirement, severance
pay, and leave as a result of being a member of the Voluntary Emeritus
Program;
8--A provision allowing either party to void the agreement with ten
days' written notice; and
9--The level of security access required by the volunteer (any
security clearance required by the position will be managed by the
Participating Organization and may or may not result in a delay in
setting the volunteer's reporting date).
5. Expanded Initial Probationary Period. The original AcqDemo
expanded initial probationary period covering periods of training
beyond 1 year has been eliminated and replaced by the provisions of 10
U.S.C. 1599e (NDAA 2016 (Pub. L. 114-92), section 1105, Required
Probationary Period for New Employees of the Department of Defense). 10
U.S.C. 1599e requires a two-year probationary period for ``. . . any
individual appointed to a permanent position within the competitive
service at the Department of Defense . . .'' Use of this provision will
be required for Participating Organizations.
6. Staffing Within AcqDemo
a. Expanded Supervisory and/or Managerial Probationary Periods. New
supervisors, that is, those who have not previously completed a civil
service supervisory probationary period, will be required to complete a
one-year probationary period for the initial appointment to a
supervisory position. An additional supervisory probationary period of
one year may be required when an employee is officially assigned to a
different supervisory position that constitutes a major change in
supervisory responsibilities from any previously held supervisory
position, e.g., moving from a journeyman level supervisory acquisition
position to a Critical Acquisition Position or moving from a Critical
Acquisition Position to a Key Leadership Position. If, during a
supervisory probationary period, the decision is made to return the
employee to a non-supervisory position for reasons related to conduct
or supervisory contribution and/or performance, the probationary
employee's supervisor will provide written notification subject to
higher level management approval and the employee will be returned to a
comparable position of no lower basic pay than the position from which
promoted or reassigned.
b. Internal AcqDemo Assignment Process. Today's environment of
downsizing and workforce transition mandates that the organization have
maximum flexibility to assign individuals. The AcqDemo waivers to title
5 U.S.C. and title 5 CFR enable organizations to have the maximum
flexibility under the broadbanding structure to assign an employee
within broad descriptions, consistent with the needs of the
organization and the individual's qualifications. Employees may receive
subsequent organizational assignments to projects, tasks, or functions
within their broadband level requiring the same occupational series,
level and area of expertise, knowledge, skills, abilities,
competencies, qualifications, and DAWIA certification, as appropriate,
as their current position and typically without change in their rate of
basic pay. For instance, a technical expert can be assigned to any
project, task, or function requiring similar technical expertise.
Likewise, a manager could be assigned to manage any similar function or
organization consistent with that individual's qualifications.
Assignments generally may be accomplished as Realignments using Nature
of Action Code 790 and do not constitute a position change. However, if
the assignment results in an occupational series change; broadband
level change; change to competencies, knowledge, skills, or abilities;
change in acquisition certification levels; change in official duty
station; change to a different agency; or a change in CCAS pay pools, a
different Nature of Action Code, an official SF-50, and/or Defense
Civilian Personnel Data System (DCPDS) data field updates may be
required by the OPM Guide to Processing Personnel Actions or internal
guidance. For example, when an employee moves to a different AcqDemo
organization and becomes a member of its CCAS pay pool, the DCPDS Pay
Pool Identifier data field needs to be updated to reflect the
employee's new pay pool for use in internal assessments and
evaluations. Further guidance on documenting the assignment will be
published in implementing issuances.
c. Expanded Detail and Temporary Promotion Authority. Current
regulations require that temporary promotions and details for more than
120 days to higher broadband level positions than an employee currently
holds or previously held must be made competitively. Under the
demonstration project, AcqDemo Participating Organizations would be
able to effect temporary promotions and details to higher broadband
level positions than AcqDemo employees currently hold or previously
held without competition as long as the temporary promotion, detail, or
a combination of a detail and temporary promotion does not exceed one
year within a 24-month period to positions within the demonstration
project. If any detail and/or temporary promotion is needed beyond one
year, competition is required. In addition, renewing the detail or
temporary promotion in 120-day or other short-term renewals is waived
under this demonstration project.
d. Exceptions to Competition. The following actions are exceptions
from competitive procedures:
(1) Non-competitive Movements Involving Promotion:
(a) Promotion, re-promotion, reassignment, change to a lower
broadband level, transfer, or reinstatement to an AcqDemo position in a
broadband level having a referenced GS grade or level of work and no
greater promotion potential than the GS grade or level of work and
promotion potential of the position a reinstatement candidate held or
an employee currently holds or previously held on a permanent basis in
the competitive service.
(b) Promotion without current competition when the employee was
appointed through competitive procedures to a position with a
documented GS career ladder position or target pay band/broadband level
or promotion potential equivalent to a referenced GS grade or level of
work in a higher broadband level than what would be the AcqDemo
broadband level appropriate for the employee's current position.
[[Page 32070]]
(c) A temporary promotion or detail of an AcqDemo employee to a
position in a higher broadband level not to exceed one year in a 24-
month period.
(d) A promotion resulting from the correction of an initial
classification error or the issuance of a new classification standard.
(2) Examples of Other Non-Competitive Movements
(a) Movement is to a position in a broadband level having a
referenced GS grade or level of work equal to that of the employee's
current position and no promotion potential. For example: Employee's
current position is a GS-318-7 without promotion potential and the
employee is moving to an NK-318-II position which contains the GS-7 as
the highest grade and offers no promotion potential; or
(b) Movement is to a position in a broadband level having a
referenced range of GS grades or levels of work containing that of the
employee's current position with no potential to a higher broadband
level. For example: Employee's current position is a GS-1102-12 with
potential to a full performance level of GS-1102-13 and the employee is
moving to an NH-1102-III position which contains both the referenced
GS-12 and the referenced full performance level of GS-13 without
further promotion potential to a higher referenced GS grade found in
the NH-IV broadband level; or
(c) Referenced GS grade or level of work or potential of the new
position is no greater than the GS grade or level of work of a position
previously held by the employee on a permanent basis in the competitive
service. For example: Employee held a competitive service GS-855-7
position with potential to GS-855-11 from May 1, 2012 to April 30, 2014
and is returned to an NH-855-II position on July 6, 2015 which contains
the range of referenced GS grades (GS-7 through 11) and levels of work
without potential to a higher referenced GS grade found in the NH-III
broadband level; or
(d) Movement is to an AcqDemo position from a different
demonstration project with referenced GS grades of selectee's current
pay banded position split between two AcqDemo broadband levels without
further promotion potential. For example: Employee's current position
is an Engineering Technician, Pay Band DT-IV (includes referenced GS
grades 11 and 12). Candidate being considered for either an AcqDemo NJ-
802-III position containing referenced GS grades 9 and 11 or an NJ-802-
IV position containing referenced GS grades 12 and 13. Candidate could
be placed non-competitively in either NJ position as both broadband
levels contain one of the referenced GS grades.
(3) A position change permitted by demonstration project reduction-
in-force procedures.
(4) Consideration of a candidate not given proper consideration in
a prior competitive promotion action under the demonstration project.
(5) Conversion of an AcqDemo employee from a modified term
appointment to a permanent appointment in the same broadband level and
occupational family as the modified term position.
(6) Addition of supervisory duties within the assigned broadband
level.
(7) Reclassification to include impact of person in the job or an
accretion of duty promotion.
(8) Any other non-competitive action as determined by the
Participating Organizations.
e. Reduction in Force
(1) Employee Separations Primarily on the Basis of Performance. For
any RIF of civilians covered by the AcqDemo within DoD, the
determination as to which employees will be separated from employment
will be made primarily on the basis of performance.
(2) Title 10 U.S.C. 1597. AcqDemo Participating Organizations, in
accordance with 10 U.S.C. 1597, may not implement any involuntary
reduction or furlough of civilians and may not implement any
substantial reduction of contract operations or contract employment
(involving 100 or more people) during a fiscal year, until the
expiration of the 45-day period beginning on the date that the
Component for the Participating Organization submits to Congress a
report setting forth the reasons such reductions or furloughs are
required and a description of any change in workload or position
requirements that will result from same.
(3) Coordination with the Office of the USD(P&R). DoD Components of
Participating Organizations will coordinate with the Office of the
USD(P&R) (ATTN: Office of the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for
Civilian Personnel Policy) regarding any proposed involuntary reduction
or furlough of civilians or any substantial reduction of contract
operations or contract employment (involving 100 or more people) during
a fiscal year. The coordination process must occur before any
notification to an employee or member of the public regarding such
action, release of information to an employee or the public, or
notification to a Member or Committee of Congress, or their staffs, or
other executive branch agencies.
(4) Minimizing the need for RIF as a result of Workforce Reshaping.
The Heads of Participating Organizations will consider and employ every
reasonably available option, consistent with applicable policies and
procedures, to mitigate the size of a proposed RIF, including job
changes or retraining, the use of voluntary early retirement authority
or voluntary separation incentive payments, hiring freezes, termination
of temporary employees, reductions in work hours, curtailment of
discretionary spending, and other pre-RIF placement activities for
employees eligible for placement assistance and referral programs.
(5) RIF Procedures. If a RIF becomes nessesary, RIF procedures will
be used when an employee faces separation or downgrading due to lack of
work, shortage of funds, reorganization, insufficient personnel
ceiling, the exercise of re-employment or restoration rights, or
furlough for more than 30 calendar or more than 22 discontinuous days.
Generally, AcqDemo RIF shall be conducted according to the provisions
of 5 CFR part 351, except as otherwise specified below:
(a) Competitive Areas. A competitive area establishes the
boundaries within which employees compete for retention under AcqDemo
RIF regulations. AcqDemo competitive areas may be refined beyond a
given component or part of a component at a given geographic location.
Generally, the geographic area of coverage will be the local commuting
area. Once the geographic area is determined, additional factors will
be introduced to ensure that there is sufficient flexibility within the
competitive area to effect such reassignments and reallocations of work
as necessary to carry out the mission of the organization with minimal
disruptions. Typically, these additional factors could include such
items as career path (pay plan), specific broadband level(s) within a
career path, and occupational series. Additional factors may include
lines of business, product lines, organizational units, funding lines,
and/or functional area, or a combination of these elements and must
include all AcqDemo project employees within the defined competitive
area. For each defined RIF competitive area, AcqDemo and non-AcqDemo
employees must be placed in separate RIF competitive areas. The RIF
competitive areas will be established no fewer than 90 days in advance
of any planned effective date of an AcqDemo RIF. All AcqDemo project
employees
[[Page 32071]]
within the AcqDemo defined competitive area must be included in that
competitive area. Therefore, AcqDemo employees would not displace non-
AcqDemo employees and vice versa.
(b) Master Retention List. Competitive service employees and
excepted service employees are placed on separate Master Retention
Lists which are established in accordance with this FRN. A Master
Retention List contains the names and position information for all
competing employees in the RIF competitive area ranked by tenure group
category and within each category by three retention factors, i.e.,
average annual rating of record, veterans' preference, and RIF service
computation date (SCD). The employees are listed within the tenure
groups in the order of their relative retention standing with
performance being the primary retention factor. For example, the
employee with the highest average annual rating of record, i.e., a
Level 5--Outstanding Rating, is at the top of a tenure group category
list; an employee with no months of assessed performance would be at
the bottom of the Tenure Group I--Less than 12 months of Assessed
Performance category; and the employee who received an unacceptable
performance appraisal as his/her most recent rating of record, i.e., a
Level 1--Unacceptable Rating, is placed in Tenure Group I--Current
Unacceptable Rating of Record category ranked by average annual rating
of record. Further ranking occurs in each category using additional
retention factors to accommodate veterans' preference and RIF service
computation date. A sample Master Retention List is contained in
Appendix G.
(c) Tenure Groups
1--Tenure Group Change. Tenure Groups I and II, as defined in 5 CFR
351.501(b) for competitive service and 5 CFR 351.502(b) for excepted
service, have been combined into a new Tenure Group I for the
competitive service and a new Tenure Group I for the excepted service.
Tenure group III remains the same and will be listed below any Tenure
Group I categories. Under AcqDemo, the conversion to permanent
appointment of term employees (Tenure Group III) previously selected
through competitive procedures, and who otherwise meet conditions
required for such conversion, may be converted to permanent
appointments (Tenure Group I), provided such conversions are effective
not less than 90 days prior to the effective date of the RIF.
2--Tenure Group Categories
a--Competing employees within a competitive area are listed on a
master retention list in one of two tenure groups: Tenure Group I
includes all permanent career and career-conditional employees and
Tenure Group III includes employees on Term Appointments. Tenure Group
I is divided into three categories: Tenure Group I employees who have
12 months or more of assessed performance; Tenure Group I employees who
have less than 12 months of assessed performance; and Tenure Group I
employees who received an unacceptable performance appraisal as their
most recent rating of record. Tenure Group III employees are also
divided into three categories: Tenure Group III employees who have 12
months or more of assessed performance; Tenure Group III employees who
have less than 12 months or more of assessed performance; and Tenure
Group III employees who received an unacceptable performance appraisal
as their most recent rating of record.
b--Periods of Assessed Performance. For purposes of AcqDemo RIF,
employees are placed in one of two assessed performance categories:
employees with a period of assessed performance of less than 12 months
and employees with a period of assessed performance of 12 months or
more. An employee's period of assessed performance for RIF purposes
will be the sum of the months of assessed performance associated with
the employee's performance appraisals within the most recent four-year
period preceding the ``cutoff date'' established for the RIF. Periods
of time in a rating cycle for which an employee's performance was not
assessed are not included in the employee's period of assessed
performance. For example, if an employee receives a rating of record
after serving 10 months of a 12-month appraisal cycle, the employee's
period of assessed performance is ``10 months'' for that rating cycle.
(d) Retention Factors.
1--Average Annual Rating of Record. The average annual rating of
record is the primary retention factor in determining which employees
shall be separated from employment.
a--Rating of Record Criteria. A rating of record may be issued only
in accordance with the AcqDemo appraisal cycle, other approved
appraisal periods under AcqDemo, another DoD performance management
program, or a performance management system used by another federal
agency with which an employee was formerly employed. Ratings of record
may not be issued solely for purposes of documenting performance in
advance of a RIF. An employee's average annual rating of record for RIF
purposes is the average of the ratings of record averages drawn from
the two most recent annual CCAS ratings or other official ratings of
record received by the employee within the four-year period preceding
the ``cutoff date ``established for the RIF, except when the employee's
most recent rating of record is ``unacceptable.'' When the most recent
rating of record is ``unacceptable,'' only that rating of record will
be considered for purposes of RIF. Other rating of record exceptions
include the following situations:
i. Employees serving as fulltime union representatives or on a
prolonged absence due to a work-related injury discussed in Section
II.D.2(h)(5); and
ii. Employees who were absent for military service referred to in
Section II.D.2(h)(6).
b--``Cutoff Date.'' The ``cutoff date'' is the date after which no
new rating of record will be considered for purposes of the RIF. The
``cutoff date'' established will be at least 60 days prior to the date
of the issuance of RIF notices.
c--CCAS Ratings of Record. The CCAS average annual rating of record
is the average of the averages obtained for each of the two most recent
CCAS ratings of record (if less than two, the actual rating of record
average) that determined the final performance appraisal level for each
of the two most recent annual ratings of record in the four-year period
preceding the ``cutoff date'' established for the RIF. The averages for
the two CCAS ratings of record would be totaled and the sum divided by
two to determine the average annual rating of record for RIF retention.
The resulting quotient will be rounded to the nearest tenth of a
decimal point. If the hundredths decimal is less than 0.05, the tenths
decimal does not change. If the hundredths decimal is equal to or
greater than 0.05, the tenths decimal is increased by ``.1''.
d--Non-CCAS Ratings of Record. An employee may have a non-CCAS
rating from another Federal organization as one or both of the two most
recent ratings of record within the most recent four-year period
preceding the RIF ``cutoff date.'' In this instance, the average annual
rating of record will be determined by converting the employee's two
non-CCAS ratings (if less than two, the actual rating) to the
corresponding numeric rating, regardless of performance summary level
pattern (for example: Highly Successful--Level 4; Pass--Level 3;
[[Page 32072]]
Marginally Successful--Level 2; or Unacceptable--Level 1) provided by
the summary level pattern used by the employee's former Federal
organization, totaling the numeric ratings, and dividing by the actual
number of ratings. If one of the two most recent ratings is a CCAS
rating, add the average obtained for determination of the annual CCAS
rating of record and the numeric rating of record level for the non-
CCAS rating of record to obtain a total, divide the sum by two. The
resulting quotient, for either scenario, is rounded in the same manner
as for two CCAS ratings as described in Section II.B.6.e(5)(d)1-a-.
e--Employees without a Rating. Presumptive status ratings 1, 2, and
3 assigned pursuant to Section II.D.6.h will not be used for RIF
purposes. In the event of a RIF, employees with less than 12 months of
assessed performance within the most recent four-year period prior to a
RIF ``cutoff date'' will be placed at the bottom of Tenure Group I--
Less than 12 months of Assessed Performance.
f--CIP. Employees under a CIP are listed on the master retention
list in their appropriate tenure group category until a decision is
reached. If the decision is that the employees have improved to a fully
successful level, the employees will continue to compete in their
appropriate tenure group category with other employees whose average
ratings of record are above unacceptable. If the decision results in an
unacceptable rating of record, the employees are listed in Tenure Group
1--Current Unacceptable Rating of Record according to their retention
standing and compete only within this tenure group
g--Unacceptable Ratings of Record. If an employee's most recent
annual or other official rating of record, e.g., rating of record based
on completion of a CIP, is ``unacceptable,'' the employee would compete
only in Tenure Group I--Current Unacceptable Rating of Record with
other employees who received a current unacceptable rating of record.
If a position encumbered by an unacceptable employee is the best offer
for an employee with a rating of record above unacceptable, the
employee with the higher retention standing may be offered the position
regardless of the retention standing of the unacceptable employee. If
there is no other position listed in Tenure Group I--Current
Unacceptable Rating of Record for which the unacceptable employee is
qualified, the employee will be separated. The unacceptable employee
has no further displacement rights.
2--Veterans' Preference. Competing employees are placed in a
veterans' preference subgroup in accordance with the definitions in 5
CFR 351.501(c). The three veterans' preference subgroups are: AD (30%
disabled veteran); A (a veteran who is eligible for veterans'
preference for purposes of RIF, but is not eligible for placement in
the AD category); and B (an employee not eligible for veterans'
preference for purposes of RIF.)
3--Length of Service (DoD SCD-RIF). The DoD service computation
date includes all creditable service under 5 CFR 351.503(a) and (b).
Each AcqDemo Participating Organization is responsible for establishing
the DoD SCD-RIF applicable to each employee competing for retention
under this process. Additional service credit for outstanding and fully
successful performance appraisals will not be calculated in the DoD
SCD-RIF.
(e) Displacement. The AcqDemo RIF process has a single round of
competition which replaces the traditional two-round (bump and retreat)
process. Displacement is limited to an employee's current career path,
broadband level, and one broadband level below that is within the
employee's career path. Broadband level I employees would displace
within their current broadband level I. Preference eligible employees
with a compensable service connected disability of 30 percent or more
may displace within the two broadband levels below their present
broadband level within their career path not to exceed the equivalent
of 5 GS grades below the employee's present GS grade-level equivalent.
Broadband level I preference eligible employees with a compensable
service connected disability of 30 percent or more can displace within
their current broadband level. Offer of assignment shall be to the
position that requires no reduction or the least possible reduction in
broadband. Where more than one such position exists, the employee must
be offered the position encumbered by the employee with the lowest
retention standing.
(f) Qualifications for Assignment. An employee is qualified to
displace another employee on the retention list if he or she meets the
designated standards and requirements in 5 CFR 351.702, including DAWIA
certification, if applicable, for the position. (However, statutory
waivers shall continue to apply.) Recency of experience may be used,
when appropriate, to determine an employee's proper placement. The
``undue disruption'' standard currently outlined in 5 CFR 351.203 will
serve as the criteria to determine if an employee is fully qualified.
(g) Pay Retention. Employees covered by the demonstration are not
eligible for grade retention. Pay retention will be granted to
employees downgraded by reduction in force whose rate of basic pay
exceeds the maximum basic pay range of the broadband level to which
assigned. Such employees will be entitled to retain the rate of basic
pay received immediately before the reduction, not to exceed 150% of
the maximum salary of the lower broadband level.
(h) Appeals. Under the demonstration project, all employees
affected by a reduction-in-force action, other than a reassignment,
maintain the right to appeal to the Merit Systems Protection Board
(MSPB) if they believe the process/procedures were not properly
applied.
(i) Vacant Positions. Prior to RIF, employees may be offered a
vacant position in the same broadband as the highest broadband
available by displacement. Employees may also be offered placement into
vacant positions for which management has waived the qualifications
requirements. When an AcqDemo Participating Organization chooses to
fill a vacancy with an employee who will be released from his/her
position, the organization must consider the relative retention
standing of all released employees. The vacant position must be offered
to the released employee with the highest retention standing before
offering a position to a released employee with a lower retention
standing. If the employee is not placed into a vacant position and
cannot be made an offer of assignment via displacement, the employee
shall be separated.
(j) Interim RIF Process. In the event a RIF is necessary after the
final FRN is published but before a rating of record with an average
score can be established for employees in the competitive area pursuant
to this FRN, the USD(P&R) may approve an interim RIF process.
C. Pay Administration
1. Introduction
AcqDemo inspires the use of a compensation strategy that utilizes
all available and appropriate compensation tools to attract and retain
an agile, highly-skilled, professional acquisition workforce and the
supporting personnel assigned to work with that workforce.
Organizations executing the DoD acquisition mission need talent with
very specific skills, knowledge, and certifications. To be successful
in this mission also demands a commitment to providing the warfighter
with state-of-the-art effective and reliable weapon
[[Page 32073]]
systems that yield equally effective and predictable results. AcqDemo's
compensation philosophy insures equitable pay for the duties of the
position, recognizes individual competency achievements, and rewards
contribution to mission. To assist in this endeavor, AcqDemo provides a
number of interventions and policies for special situations such as pay
setting for new hires, reinstatement eligibles, and non-AcqDemo Federal
civilian employees voluntarily accepting an AcqDemo position;
promotions; buy-ins on voluntary permanent lateral transfers,
reassignments, and realignments into AcqDemo; changes to lower career
path, broadband level, and/or basic pay; supervisory and team leader
cash differentials; accelerated compensation for developmental
positions; and a contribution-based compensation system that aligns
employees' pay to their contributions to the organization's mission and
to the scope, difficulty, and value of their positions.
The DoD AcqDemo Program Office will issue policy and guidance on
pay setting. Participating Organizations are encouraged, through their
Personnel Policy Boards to issue internal guidance and/or criteria to
further define their compensation policy and processes based upon
funding levels; qualifications and experience of selectees; market
conditions; difficulty of position; organizational level of position;
etc., to ensure standard application. Copies of an organization's
internal pay setting guidance are to be provided to the AcqDemo Program
Office.
Modifications to the AcqDemo pay administration guidance,
processes, and/or procedures may be made by the DoD AcqDemo Program
Manager as experience is gained, economic conditions change, results
are analyzed, and conclusions are reached. Any supplemental policies,
guidance, and procedures on pay setting (and modifications to those
policies, guidance, and procedures) issued by the DoD AcqDemo Program
Office and Participating Organizations will adhere to the pay
administration provisions and waivers in this Federal Register notice.
2. Compensation Strategy
A primary goal of AcqDemo is to compensate employees appropriately
for their individual and organizational contribution to the mission of
their organization and the value of their position. This goal promotes
greater compensation for those who are the highest contributors;
encouragement for the lowest contributors to improve; and appropriate
compensation for all levels of contribution in between. Equal with the
need to appropriately recognize and compensate employee contribution is
the need to effectively manage the compensation levels of the AcqDemo
organizational positions. Although each position contained within a
broadband level could have access to the complete range of pay options,
it does not mean that all jobs within that broadband level should be
compensated at the top rate of basic pay of the broadband level.
Instead, management decisions should be made about the appropriate
compensation value of the organization's position management structure,
based on factors such as level of effort, required skills and/or
certifications, and labor market conditions. Once made, management
should seek to maintain that level of compensation, unless changes
occur in the stated compensation factors. Total pay set above or below
the target basic pay is contingent upon the employee's overall
contribution to the mission. This approach challenges the organization
to consider the value identified for each position when determining an
appropriate level and means of compensation (basic pay adjustment and/
or award) for individual compensation.
Although broadbanding makes available a broader range of
compensation choices, basic pay adjustments known within AcqDemo as
Contribution Rating Increase (CRI) adjustments, are not the sole means
to compensate employees, and in some cases are not the recommended
means. As the compensation value of organizational positions are
identified, managers should consider utilizing appropriate means to
preserve those values. Compensation methodologies include the
assignment of a maximum OCS, to coincide with the identified
compensation value. A CRI resulting from the assignment of an OCS
assumes the level of contribution, and associated basic pay, is
expected to continue at least at that level and will be reflected in
the employee's Contribution Plan for future assessment cycles. These
scores or values should be identified against PRDs, and then considered
during hiring actions and in determining compensation means to
recognize contribution assessments. Means to preserve the identified
compensation values may include the establishment of control points or
pay ranges within a broadband level. When compared to their
counterparts in other compensation systems, e.g., GS and STRL, these
employees as a group should generally maintain equity with the normal
pay progression scenarios in these systems. For example, for positions
equivalent to GS-14 in value and level of difficulty, control points
should be established based on the basic pay ranges of the lowest
referenced GS grade in the appropriate broadband level, i.e., GS-14,
step 10, for the NH-IV broadband level. These tools should be
considered to, at a minimum, require a management decision to establish
an appropriate compensation value or to increase an employee's basic
pay above the identified compensation value. The use of such
methodologies establishes compensation equity, consistency, and
transparency for employees and supervisors alike throughout the
organization. No matter what the compensation system, over time
positions reach a plateau where salary growth levels off; some at the
top of the pay scale and others at other points.
3. Aggregate Limitation on Basic Pay
The calendar year aggregate limitation on pay under 5 U.S.C. 5307
and 5 CFR part 530, subpart B, of the rate payable for level I of the
Executive Schedule applies to employees. In addition, the maximum rate
of basic pay for each broadband level will be limited to the maximum
rate of basic pay for the highest referenced grade covered by the
broadband. Other than where a retained rate applies, basic pay rates
will be limited to the maximum rate of basic pay payable for each
broadband level.
4. Special Rates
AcqDemo will not utilize OPM derived special rates. Employees on
special rates at the time of conversion of their organization into
AcqDemo will have their pay protected under the provisions of Section
II.F of this notice. New hires, reinstatement eligibles, and non-
AcqDemo Federal civilian employees entering an AcqDemo position not as
the result of a conversion will have pay set in accordance with Section
II.C.9 of this notice.
5. Promotions
a. Permanent or Temporary Promotion. A permanent or temporary
promotion action occurs when a non-AcqDemo Federal employee or an
AcqDemo employee is selected under competitive or merit promotion
procedures for an AcqDemo position in a broadband level with a
referenced GS grade or level of work in a higher broadband level than
what would be appropriate for the Federal employee's current GS grade,
or the AcqDemo employee's current broadband level, or a previously held
position on a
[[Page 32074]]
permanent basis in the competitive service. When setting pay for a
promotion action, either permanent or temporary, consideration must be
given to both the value of the position and the selectee's expected
level of contribution in the new position. The basic pay for a
permanent or temporary promotion action will be set within the
broadband level for the position to be filled, not to exceed 20 percent
of the selectee's current basic pay. However, if the minimum rate of
the selectee's new broadband level is more than 20 percent greater than
the selectee's current basic pay, then the minimum rate of the new
broadband level is the new basic pay. The selectee's basic pay shall
not exceed the basic pay range of the new broadband level.
b. Temporary Promotion Basic Pay Adjustment Guidelines.
(1) Upon Termination. When a temporary promotion is terminated, an
employee's pay entitlements will be re-determined based on the
employee's permanent position of record with appropriate adjustments to
reflect any CCAS ratings, e.g., a presumptive rating, and/or General
Pay increases applicable to the permanent position during the period of
the employee's temporary promotion. While on a temporary promotion, any
basic pay adjustments to reflect a CCAS rating for contributions and
General Pay increases occurring while on that temporary promotion will
be applied to the temporary promotion basic pay and not the basic pay
of the permanent position of record. If a temporary promotion of less
than 1 year is extended so that the total time of the temporary
promotion equals or exceeds 1 year, pay may be set in the permanent
position based on a rate received under the temporary promotion,
subject to the specific policies and rules established by the Head of
the Participating Organization or Personnel Policy Board.
(2) When Made Permanent. If a temporary promotion is made permanent
immediately after the temporary promotion ends, the temporary promotion
is converted to a permanent promotion without a change in basic pay. If
there is any period of time between the end of an employee's temporary
promotion and the beginning of a permanent promotion, the employee must
be returned to his/her permanent position and his/her permanent
position's rate of basic pay recomputed as if the employee had never
been temporarily promoted. Also, at the organization's discretion and
if eligible, pay may be set in the permanent position based on a rate
received under the temporary promotion if that would yield a higher
basic pay rate. However, the higher basic pay rate may not exceed the
basic pay range of the new broadband level. Whatever method is used,
the resulting rate is the basis for any subsequent promotion.
6. Retained Pay
a. Calculation. Retained pay under AcqDemo is the combined basic
pay and locality pay compared to the maximum rate of the highest
applicable rate range that applies to the highest referenced GS grade
included in the broadband level of an employee's new position. If the
retained rate is greater than the maximum rate of the highest
applicable rate range for the new position, an employee continues to be
entitled to the existing retained rate. If the retained rate is equal
to or less than the maximum rate of the highest applicable rate range
for the new position, the payable rate of basic pay is converted to the
employee's new AcqDemo basic pay rate and appropriate locality pay, and
retained pay terminates.
b. Pay Adjustments. Employees on retained pay in the demonstration
project are to be treated as GS employees and will receive pay
adjustments in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 5363 and 5 CFR part 536 except
under the following provisions: (1) Pay retention provisions do not
apply to conversions from General Schedule special rates to
demonstration project pay, as long as total pay is not reduced; (2) pay
retention provisions do not apply to movements to a lower broadband
level as a result of not receiving the general increase due to a
contribution assessment, either annual or interim, of ``Unacceptable''
for the most recent contribution appraisal cycle; and (3) provide that
an employee on pay retention whose most recent annual or interim
contribution assessment is ``Unacceptable'' may have the 50 percent of
the amount of the increase in the maximum rate of basic pay payable for
the broadband level of the employee's position reduced or denied. An
employee receiving retained pay is not eligible for a CCAS contribution
rating increase, since such increases are limited by the maximum basic
pay rate for the employee's broadband level. Depending upon the
employee's CCAS assessment, employees on retained pay may be eligible
to receive a CCAS contribution award.
c. Promotion from Retained Pay. When an employee on retained pay is
promoted to a higher broadband level, the employee's basic pay upon
promotion will be set in the higher broadband level: (1) Not to exceed
20 percent of the maximum basic pay of the employee's existing
broadband level as determined by AcqDemo internal policies, or (2) at
the employee's existing retained rate, whichever is greater. The final
basic pay should align with the position's value (its target basic pay)
and the employee's expected contribution in the position.
d. Adverse Action or Contribution-based Reduction in Pay to Include
Change to Lower Broadband Level and/or Change in Career Path. An
employee may receive an involuntary reduction in broadband level with
or without a reduction in basic pay; an involuntary reduction in basic
pay within his/her existing broadband level and career path; and/or an
involuntary move to a new position in a different career path due to an
adverse or contribution-based action. Involuntary reductions in pay
will result in a basic pay level consistent with an employee's
demonstrated contribution level. For involuntary change to lower
broadband level, the employee's basic pay will be reduced by a
percentage determined by Participating Organizations, but will be set
no lower than the minimum basic pay of the broadband level to which
assigned. Employees placed into a lower broadband due to an adverse or
contribution-based action are not entitled to pay retention.
e. Change to Lower Broadband Level/Change in Career Path, Other
than by Adverse or Contribution-based Action. If an employee is subject
to an involuntary change to a lower broadband level/change in career
path by other than an adverse or contribution-based action, such as a
reclassification of his/her position, the employee is entitled to pay
retention if all conditions in title 5 U.S.C. 5363 and 5 CFR part 536,
subparts A and C are met.
f. Reduction-in-Force (RIF) Action (including Employees Who are
Offered and Accept a Vacancy at a Lower Broadband Level or in a
Different Career Path). The employee is entitled to pay retention in
accordance with 5 U.S.C. 5363 and 5 CFR part 536, subpart A.
7. General Schedule (GS) Annual Base Pay Increase
The GS base rates may be adjusted each January under the provisions
in 5 U.S.C. 5303. Under AcqDemo, the minimum and maximum basic pay rate
of each broadband level will be adjusted at the same time as this GPI.
The amount of the increase calculated for an organization's AcqDemo
employees will be based on the amount of any GPI and is allocated for
use in that organization's pay pool fund and disbursed to
[[Page 32075]]
employees based upon their contribution assessments under the CCAS as
described in Section II.D.2.d(2).
8. Locality Pay
All employees will be entitled to the locality pay authorized for
their official worksite in accordance with 5 CFR part 531, subpart F,
if eligible. In addition, the locality-adjusted pay of any employee may
not exceed the rate for Executive Level IV. Geographic movement within
the demonstration project will result in the employee's locality pay
being recomputed using the newly applicable locality pay percentage,
which may result in a higher or lower locality pay and thus, a higher
or lower adjusted basic pay. This adjustment is not an adverse action.
9. Hires From Outside the AcqDemo
a. New Hires. For new hires who are receiving their first Federal
government appointment as a civilian employee, initial basic pay will
be set within the basic pay range for the broadband level of the
position for which hired at a level consistent with the individual's
qualifications and the level of work and contribution expected for the
position at the time of hire. Other considerations in determining
starting basic pay are available labor market conditions relative to
special qualifications requirements, scarcity of qualified applicants,
programmatic urgency, and education/experience of new selectees.
b. Reinstatement Eligible Hires. For reinstatement eligibles,
initial basic pay will be set within the basic pay range for the
broadband level of the position for which hired giving consideration to
the various criteria mentioned for new hires from outside the AcqDemo.
AcqDemo Highest Previous Rate (HPR) as defined in Section II.C.13 and
AcqDemo internal guidance may provide an appropriate tool for
establishing basic pay in this instance. Reinstatement eligibility
refers to the ability for those individuals who previously held a
career or career-conditional appointment to apply for jobs in the
competitive Federal service open to status applicants.
c. Non-AcqDemo Federal Civilian Employees Voluntarily Joining
AcqDemo. Federal employees entering into the AcqDemo from the GS or
other pay systems not as the result of a conversion will be moved into
a career path and broadband level with basic pay set in accordance with
AcqDemo guidance and reflective of the duties and responsibilities of
the AcqDemo position and an individual's qualifications. AcqDemo HPR
may provide an appropriate tool for establishing basic pay in this
instance. The move will be described using the appropriate nature of
action, e.g., promotion, reassignment, transfer, etc., as provided by
the OPM's Guide to Processing Personnel Actions or AcqDemo Program
Office guidance.
(1) Lateral Transfers, Reassignments, and Realignments
(a) GS Employees. Individual GS employees who enter the project
voluntarily by permanent lateral transfer, reassignment, or realignment
to an AcqDemo position in a broadband level containing a referenced GS
grade the same as the employee's current GS grade and no greater
promotion potential than the GS grade or level of work and promotion
potential of the position the employee currently holds may be subject
to the same pay setting rules as those GS employees entering the
demonstration project upon initial conversion of their organization.
These rules provide an adjustment to an employee's basic pay for a WGI
and/or non-competitive career ladder promotion buy-in, if eligible.
Eligibility criteria will be defined in implementing issuances. In any
case, the employee's basic pay shall not exceed the basic pay range of
the new broadband level.
(b) Non-GS Employees. Federal employees in other pay systems, e.g.,
a Science and Technology Reinvention Laboratory Personnel Demonstration
Project, who do not have WGI eligibility under their current pay
system, are not eligible for a WGI Buy-in when they move into the
AcqDemo by lateral transfer, reassignment, or realignment. A Career
Ladder Promotion Buy-in is not authorized for movement from a pay
system other than the GS pay system to the AcqDemo pay system by a
permanent lateral transfer, reassignment, or realignment.
(2) Temporary Reassignments Not to Exceed (NTE)
Current AcqDemo authorities do not contain provisions for Temporary
Reassignments NTE to, from, or within AcqDemo. However, if a component
or agency has established a Temporary Reassignment NTE Nature of Action
Code, it may be used to move non-AcqDemo employees into AcqDemo, move
AcqDemo employees out of AcqDemo to a non-AcqDemo organization, and
move AcqDemo employees within AcqDemo, but no WGI Buy-in or Career
Ladder Promotion Buy-in is authorized for any of these personnel
actions.
10. Internal AcqDemo Employee Movements
a. Movement within a Broadband Level. The movement of an employee's
basic pay in relation to the minimum and maximum basic pay range for
his/her position's broadband level is determined by the assessment of
the employee's contributions through the CCAS, Section II.D, or
Accelerated Compensation for Developmental Positions (ACDP), Section
II.C.11.
b. Change to Lower Broadband Level or Different Career Path. When
an employee accepts a voluntary change to a lower broadband level or a
different career path, basic pay may be set at any point within the
broadband level to which assigned, except that the new basic pay will
not exceed the employee's current basic pay or the maximum basic pay of
the broadband level to which assigned, whichever is lower. Upon request
for or acceptance of a change to a lower broadband level or different
career path, the employee will be required to provide a written
statement acknowledging voluntary acceptance and understanding of the
influence of such a move on pay and benefits. This paragraph does not
apply to promotion actions.
11. ACDP
a. AcqDemo will implement ACDP to provide recognition for employees
in DAWIA-coded positions classified to Broadband Levels I, II, and III
of the Business and Technical Management Professional Career Path who:
(1) Are participating in formal training programs, internships, or
other developmental capacities; and
(2) Have demonstrated successful or better growth and development
in the attainment of job-related competencies; and
(3) Have demonstrated effective accomplishment of a level of work
higher than that represented by an AcqDemo employee's Expected Overall
Contribution Score (set by current basic pay) under CCAS.
b. Standards by which ACDP increases will be provided and
development criteria by which additional basic pay increases may be
given will be established in combination with the CCAS and documented
in internal business rules, policies, and procedures.
c. ACDPs may be awarded twice per CCAS appraisal cycle but not
sooner than six months after the effective date of an ACDP for a basic
pay increase ranging from 0% not to exceed a 10% increase and a growth
in the employee's Overall Contribution Score. The amount
[[Page 32076]]
of the ACDP increase may not cause the employee's basic pay to exceed
the top of the employee's broadband level, the target pay for the
employee's maximum broadband level, or compensation strategy set by
internal business rules, policies, or procedures for both the
position's value and employee contributions.
d. ACDPs will not be funded from pay pool allocations. A general
O&M budget allocation or equivalent for civilian salaries, as
appropriate, would be used to cover ACDP basic pay increases. Defense
Acquisition Workforce Development Funds (DAWDF) may be an additional
source of funds for ACDPs.
12. Supervisory and Team Leader Cash Differentials
a. Supervisory and team leader cash differentials may be used by
Heads of Participating Organizations as an additional tool to
incentivize and compensate supervisors and team leaders as defined by
the OPM General Schedule Supervisory Guide or Leader Grade Evaluation
Guide in situations where:
(1) Organizational level and scope, difficulty, and value of
position warrants additional compensation;
(2) Supervisory and/or team leader positions are extremely
difficult to fill; or
(3) Salary inequities may exist between the supervisor's or team
leader's and non-supervisory/non-team leader subordinates' basic pay.
b. A supervisory cash differential may not exceed 10 percent of
basic pay and a team leader cash differential may not exceed 5 percent
of basic pay. A cash differential is not paid from pay pool funds; is
not included as part of basic pay for entitlement calculations (e.g.,
retirement and Thrift Savings Plan); and is subject to the total
aggregate limitation on pay. Because it is not part of basic pay,
supervisors or team leaders who are at the maximum basic pay for their
respective broadband level may still receive a supervisory cash
differential. It is paid on a pay period basis with a specified not to
exceed date of one year or less; reviewed every year at the same time
as the CCAS annual assessment and may be terminated or reduced as
dictated by fiscal limitations, changes in assignment or scope of work,
and/or an employee's removal from the supervisory or team leader
position regardless of cause. Termination or reduction of a cash
differential is not an adverse action and is not subject to appeal or
grievance. A signed statement by an employee receiving a cash
differential acknowledging all of the stipulations will be required.
c. Payment criteria to be considered in determining the amount of
the cash differential will be outlined in internal implementing
issuances and will contain considerations such as the needs of the
organization to attract, retain, and motivate high-quality supervisors
and team leaders; budgetary constraints; years and quality of related
experience and current level of compensation; length of the assignment
and difficulty of the supervisory or team leader duties; organizational
level of the position; and impact on the organization.
d. The cash differentials are not automatic by virtue of holding a
supervisory or team leader position. They will be used selectively, not
routinely, to compensate only those supervisors and/or team leaders who
fully meet the criteria. The contribution of supervisors and team
leaders to the mission of their organization will be assessed
separately under the CCAS.
13. Highest Previous Rate
AcqDemo HPR may be considered in setting pay in placement actions
authorized under rules that are consistent with those found in 5 CFR
531.221 through 531.223 as described in AcqDemo internal policy and
guidance. Use of AcqDemo HPR will be at the discretion of the Head of
the Participating Organization and subject to policies established by
the organization's senior leaders and/or Personnel Policy Board.
AcqDemo HPR allows a Participating Organization to set pay for an
AcqDemo employee at a rate above the rate that would be established
using normal AcqDemo rules, based on a higher rate of basic pay the
employee received previously in another Federal job. The AcqDemo HPR
may be used for reemployment, transfer, reassignment, promotion,
demotion, change in type of appointment, termination of a critical
position pay authority under 5 CFR part 535, movement from a non-GS pay
system, or termination of grade or pay retention under 5 CFR part 536.
14. Recruitment, Relocation, and Retention Incentives
The participating AcqDemo organizations may make full use of the
recruitment, retention, and relocation incentive payments under 5
U.S.C. 5753 and 5754; OPM's regulations at 5 CFR part 575, subparts A-
C; and any supplemental policy guidance.
15. Awards
To provide additional flexibility in motivating and rewarding
individuals and groups, some portion of the performance award budget
will be reserved for special acts and other categories as they occur.
Awards may include, but are not limited to, special acts, patents,
invention awards, suggestions, and on-the-spot. The funds available to
be used for traditional title 5 U.S.C. awards are separately allocated
within the constraints of the organization's budget. The Service
Acquisition Executives of AcqDemo Participating Organizations will have
the authority to grant special act awards to covered employees not to
exceed $25,000 in accordance with the criteria established by DoD,
Component, or Agency instructions.
D. Contribution-Based Compensation and Appraisal System
1. Overview
The purpose of the CCAS is to provide an equitable and flexible
method for appraising and compensating the DoD civilian acquisition
workforce and its supporting personnel. It is central to the objectives
of the DAWIA and Better Buying Power 3.0 which emphasize continuing
efforts to increase the productivity, efficiency, and effectiveness of
the Department's many acquisition, technology, and logistics efforts
and the professionalism of the acquisition workforce. CCAS integrates
classification, contribution, and compensation into a cohesive
management system that recognizes level of difficulty, scope, and value
of an employee's position; impact of contribution results on strategic
goals, objectives, and organizational mission accomplishment; and
appropriate compensation in recognition of the value of an employee's
contribution and position. CCAS allows for more employee involvement in
the contribution/performance appraisal process, increases communication
between supervisors and employees, promotes a clear accountability of
contribution by each employee, facilitates employee progression tied to
organizational contribution, and provides an understandable basis for
basic pay changes. Most of the funds previously allocated for
performance-based awards will be reserved for distribution under the
CCAS system based on employee contribution.
CCAS is a contribution-based appraisal system that goes beyond a
performance-based rating system. That is, it emphasizes and measures
the value and effectiveness of the employee's
[[Page 32077]]
contribution to the mission and goals of the organization, rather than
merely how well the employee performed a job as defined by a set of
standards for the work to be accomplished. Past experience with the
existing civilian performance appraisal system indicates that standards
in performance plans are often tailored to the individual's level of
previous performance. Hence, an employee may have been rewarded by
basic pay step increases meeting standards of performance beneath those
actually needed to achieve the expected organizational mission
outcomes. Under CCAS, an employee's performance is a component of
contribution that influences the employee's ultimate overall
expectations and contribution assessment. CCAS promotes basic pay
adjustment decisions made on the basis of an individual's overall
annual contribution to the mission of the organization when compared to
the classification and appraisal factors and an employee's contribution
plan, expected results, and the scope, level of difficulty, and value
of the employee's position. The three key components of CCAS are the
appraisal process, the Integrated Pay Schedule as a mechanism to relate
contribution to pay, and the compensation adjustment results.
2. CCAS Appraisal Process
a. Annual Cycle. The annual appraisal cycle begins on October 1 and
ends on September 30 of the following year. In the event a management
decision is made to terminate the demonstration project or the
management of an AcqDemo Participating Organization directs conversion
of its employees out of AcqDemo to a different pay and/or personnel
system, the annual appraisal cycle may be condensed so that a closeout
appraisal or a closeout appraisal and a payout may be completed as
determined appropriate. Section II.F.3.b provides additional operating
details for situations of this type.
b. Assessment Criteria. An employee's contribution is assessed by
using the same set of three factors, descriptors, and discriminators
used for classification of positions to appropriate broadband levels as
discussed in Section II.A.3. Classification Level and Appraisal
Factors. Taken together, these factors, descriptors, and discriminators
capture the critical content of jobs in each career path that is
relevant to the success of a DoD acquisition organization. Each factor
has multiple levels of increasing contribution corresponding to the
broadband levels. Each factor also contains descriptors and
discriminators for each respective level within the relevant career
path. The descriptors are written so that all factors are considered
critical and are weighted equally. However, if pay pool panel members/
managers agree that some factors are more important than others to
effectively accomplish the organization's mission, they may adjust the
factor weights. The factors, descriptors, and discriminators may not be
modified. The three factors with their descriptors and discriminators
are located in Appendix E. In conjunction with the contribution factor
assessment is an overall assessment of the quality of performance in
achieving contribution results. A set of generic performance appraisal
quality levels is provided in Table 2. A written Contribution Plan
containing an employee's goals, objectives, and expected contribution
in relation to each factor should be developed collaboratively by the
supervisor and the employee working together to have a clear
understanding of what is needed for the employee to satisfactorily and
effectively contribute to the organization's mission. The supervisor is
responsible for ensuring completion of the plan.
c. Appraisal Eligibility. To be eligible for an appraisal,
employees must be under CCAS on September 30 and have served under CCAS
for 90 calendar days or more immediately preceding September 30 before
they may receive an annual contribution assessment. If on October 1,
the employee has served under CCAS for less than 90 calendar days prior
to the end of the cycle, the rating official shall wait for the
subsequent annual cycle to assess the employee. The first CCAS
appraisal must be rendered within 15 months of when an employee enters
the demonstration project. Employees who have served under CCAS for
less than 90 calendar days immediately preceding the end of the rating
cycle shall not receive contribution rating increases or contribution
awards for that cycle. However, their basic pay shall be increased by
the amount and at the time of the next General Schedule pay increase as
adjusted by 5 U.S.C. 5303.
d. Beginning of Appraisal Cycle Activities
(1) Contribution Planning Meeting. At the beginning of the annual
appraisal period, a supervisor and an employee plan how the employee
will contribute to the mission of the organization during the appraisal
cycle. This contribution planning meeting typically includes discussion
of career path and broadband level, contribution factors,
organizational mission, expected contribution criteria, Expected OCS
(EOCS), contribution results, assessment of the quality of performance,
and career development. Normally, new employees who join AcqDemo during
an appraisal cycle should have their contribution plan established
within 30 days, but will not have a CCAS OCS until after their first
annual CCAS assessment process. However, until their contribution plan
is formalized, they may determine their EOCS range by using the
Expected Contribution Range (ECR) calculator found on the AcqDemo Web
site at http://acqdemo.hci.mil/tools.html under the Tools tab. Future
CCAS assessments may alter an employee's ECR. At this time, employees
will be advised that all factors are critical and of any factor weights
that have been established. Key terms such as ``team'' and ``customer''
will be defined or clarified.
(2) Pay Pool.
(a) Composition. A pay pool is a group of employees among whom the
funding allocated to CCAS is distributed. This might be all the
employees in a division or directorate, or employees involved in the
same type of work, e.g., supervisors. The pay pool structure and
allocated funds are under the authority of the Head of a Participating
Organization. The following minimal guidelines will apply. A pay pool:
1--Is based on the organizational structure and should include a
range of salaries and contribution levels;
2--Should be large enough to constitute a reasonable size, i.e.,
not less than 35 individuals (when possible) or more than 300
individuals when sensible;
3--Should be large enough to include a second level of supervision,
since the CCAS process uses a group of supervisors in the pay pool to
determine OCS and recommended basic pay adjustments; and
4--May have the pay pool manager as a member of the pay pool.
However, the pay pool manager shall not directly influence or
participate in the determination of his/her own contribution
assessments, recommend his/her own individual basic pay levels, or
establish the amount of his/her own individual basic pay levels. Also,
the supervisors within the pay pool shall not directly influence or
participate in the determination of their own contribution assessments,
recommend their own individual basic pay levels, or establish the
amount of their own individual basic pay levels.
(b) Pay Pool Panel Process. The CCAS pay pool panel process is
designed to validate the evaluation of contribution
[[Page 32078]]
and performance against the three factors among a group of peer
managers from across an organization. This process works to achieve
fairness and standard application of the factor descriptors, expected
contribution criteria, and performance appraisal levels. At the onset
of each appraisal period, a Personnel Policy Board or equivalent board
verifies the accuracy of the pay pool structure for the organization,
develops and/or validates pay pool business rules, and administers
funds to pay pool managers. The pay pool panel is typically composed of
the pay pool manager and those who report directly to him/her. Their
purpose is to share a common view of the organization mission, goals,
and objectives in reviewing the contribution and performance of
employees by subordinate supervisors and bring a common perspective to
how employees are evaluated and, therefore, compensated and appraised.
(c) Funding. The funding allocation to be included in the pay pool
will be computed based on the salaries of the employees in the pay pool
as of the last calendar day of the CCAS appraisal period. The amount of
funding available within a pay pool will be based on a balancing of
appropriate factors, including the following: (1) General Pay Increase;
(2) historical spending for WGI, quality step increases, and promotions
between grades encompassed in the same broadband level; (3) awards
(performance-based awards as defined in 5 U.S.C. 4505(a)); (4) labor
market conditions and the need to recruit and retain a skilled
workforce to meet the business needs of the organization; (5) the
fiscal condition of the organization; and (6) guidance from the AcqDemo
Program Office. The USD(P&R) may, at his/her discretion, adjust the
minimum funding levels set forth in this paragraph to take into account
factors such as the Department's fiscal condition, guidance from the
Office of Management and Budget, and equity in circumstances when
funding is reduced or eliminated for GS pay raises or awards. The pay
pool funding allocation includes three forms of compensation:
1--General Pay Increase (GPI). The GPI is the across-the-board
basic pay increase authorized by law or the President for the GS under
5 U.S.C. 5303. The funds allocated for the GPI that are not awarded may
be transferred to either the CRI Fund or the Contribution Award (CA)
Fund or divided among them barring any higher authority restrictions.
2--CRI Fund. The CRI fund includes what are WGIs, quality step
increases, and promotions between grades encompassed in the same
broadband level. The maximum CRI funding allocation will be set each
year by the DoD AcqDemo Program Manager with a minimum funding of not
less than 2.0 percent of the activity's total basic pay budget. This
figure will be adjusted by the DoD AcqDemo Program Manager as necessary
to maintain cost discipline over the life of the demonstration project.
The amount of funding available to each pay pool is determined annually
by the Personnel Policy Board, or equivalent. CRI funds not awarded may
be transferred to the CA fund based on DoD AcqDemo Program Office
Guidance. In the event of an out-of-cycle payout, this funding floor
may be suspended.
3--CA Fund. The CA Fund includes what were formerly performance
awards and will be used for awards given under the CCAS process. The CA
funding allocation will be set at not less than 1.0 percent of an
activity's total adjusted basic pay budget. A minimum of 10% of the CA
fund is withheld to be used for other awards not related to the CCAS
process, e.g., on-the-spot awards and group awards, which will continue
to be encouraged by management to promote excellence in acquisition and
attainment of organizational goals. CA funding not granted may not be
transferred to other funding categories. In the event of an out-of-
cycle payout, this funding floor may be suspended.
e. Feedback during the Appraisal Cycle. Ongoing supervisor (or
designated rating official) and employee discussion during the
appraisal cycle of specific work assignments, objectives, contribution
expectations, strengths, weaknesses, and the employee's contribution
results, and assessment of the quality of performance within the CCAS
framework is essential. This must include discussion of any inadequate
contribution and quality of performance in one or more of the factors.
Approximately midway through each appraisal cycle, the supervisor will
meet with the employee to discuss progress and make a notation of that
discussion.
f. Evaluation at the Conclusion of the Appraisal Cycle. The CCAS,
using a holistic approach, provides a process that evaluates the scope
of work, level of difficulty, value of position and contributions,
performance rating levels, and quality of an employee's efforts in
achieving contribution results. This methodology fosters consistency
and equity in contribution assessments.
(1) Compensation Equity
(a) Contribution Scores. Rating officials use the Integrated Pay
Schedule design to assess the contribution level of work against the
employee's current compensation level indicated by the employee's EOCS.
Each factor will receive two types of scores, the categorical score
assigned by the rating official, and a numerical score assigned during
the pay pool panel process. At the end of the annual appraisal period,
the rating official determines preliminary categorical scores. The
categorical score is determined by comparing an employee's contribution
results to the set of descriptors and discriminators for a particular
factor and broadband level as a group and selecting the most
appropriate categorical score level shown in Table 2 below. The
numerical score is selected by a pay pool panel following further
refinement and rank ordering of the categorical scores. The panel
selects the numerical score from the range of scores associated with
the specific categorical score selected as representative of an
employee's overall contribution. The numerical scores that may be
available for use in the assessment process depend upon the value of an
employee's position as developed through the organization's position
management structure and compensation strategy. Table 2 shows the
structure for the broadband and very high score levels and their
associated categorical scores and numerical score ranges for each
career path. Very high scores are available to recognize an employee
for exemplary contributions and overall quality of performance the
results of which are substantially beyond what was expected and warrant
a score exceeding the top score for the highest broadband level in the
employee's career path. Very high scores for factors may only be
assigned to employees holding a position in Level IV of the Business
and Technical Management Professional Career Path, Level IV of the
Technical Management Support Career Path, or Level III of the
Administrative Support Career Path.
[[Page 32079]]
Table 2--Contribution Categorical Scores and Numerical Score Ranges by Career Path
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Business and Technical Administrative
technical support (NJ) support (NK)
professional -------------------------------
Broadband and very high score levels Categorical scores (NH)
---------------- Numerical Numerical
Numerical score range score range
score range
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Very High Score....................... High.................... 115 95 70
Medium.................. 110 91 67
Low..................... 105 87 64
IV.................................... High.................... 96-100 79-83
Med..................... 84-95 67-78
Low..................... 79-83 61-66
III................................... High.................... 79-83 62-66 57-61
Med..................... 67-78 52-61 47-56
Low..................... 61-66 43-51 38-46
II.................................... High.................... 62-66 47-51 42-46
Med High................ 51-61 41-46 ..............
Med..................... 41-50 36-40 30-41
Med Low................. 30-40 30-35 ..............
Low..................... 22-29 22-29 22-29
I..................................... High.................... 24-29 24-29 24-29
Med High................ 6-23 6-23 6-23
Low..................... 0-5 0-5 0-5
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(b) Contribution Scoring Process. The process for scoring a factor
begins by assessing an employee's contributions and his/her results
during the appraisal cycle in relation to his/her contribution plan,
the factor descriptors, discriminators, and expected contribution
criteria for the broadband level of the employee's position; and the
assessment of quality of performance. At the end of the appraisal
cycle, the rating official meets with his/her employees, requesting
them to summarize the impact and quality of their contributions against
the factor descriptions, expected contribution criteria, and the
objectives and expectations described in their contribution plans. From
employees' input, clients' feedback, his/her own knowledge, and other
sources, the rating official assigns, from the appropriate career path
broadband or very high score level for the employee's position, a
preliminary categorical score. This step is repeated for each of the
three factors.
During the pay pool panel process, panel members will assign a
numerical score from the numerical score range appropriate for the
chosen categorical score for each factor by considering contributions
(documented and addressed by panel members) against the factor level
descriptors and discriminators, expected contribution criteria, the
contribution plan, the quality of performance criteria, and the impact
of the contributions on the organization. If the employee's
contributions are awarded a very high score, the score must be one of
the three numerical scores assigned to the very high score level for
the employee's career path. At the discretion of the Pay Pool Manager,
different weights may be applied to the factors to produce a weighted
average, provided that the weights are applied uniformly across the pay
pool and employees are advised in advance, i.e., at the beginning of
the rating period. Weighting may not result in any factor becoming
zero. The preliminary numeric scores assigned for each of the three
factors are totaled and the sum averaged to obtain an OCS. The OCS will
be rounded to the nearest whole number. An OCS average with a decimal
of less than 0.5 will be rounded down to the nearest whole number.
Averages with 0.5 and higher will be rounded up to the nearest whole
number.
(2) Quality of Performance
(a) Appraisal Criteria. 10 U.S.C. 1597(f) requires the
determination of which DoD employees shall be separated from employment
in a reduction in force to be made primarily on the basis of
performance. In order to comply with 10 U.S.C. 1597(f), the CCAS has
been modified to embrace the quality of performance an employee
demonstrates in achieving his/her expected contribution results through
an assessment of performance under each of the three contribution
factors. Three performance appraisal levels are provided as shown in
Table 3 below together with generic quality criteria. The performance
level to be assigned to each contribution factor should reflect an
employee's characteristic level of performance during the appraisal
cycle as compared to the CCAS factor descriptors and discriminators,
expected contribution criteria, an employee's contribution plan, and
the impact of the quality of the contributions on the organization. A
Participating Organization may supplement the generic criteria with
additional standards that identify milestones, production, due dates,
or other measureable aspects of success contributing to the
accomplishment of the goals and objectives necessary to meet an
organization's mission and are achievable during the appraisal cycle.
Table 3--Performance Appraisal Quality Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performance appraisal level Performance appraisal level quality criteria
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Level 5--Outstanding................................. An employee's quality of performance exhibited in
achieving his/her contribution results substantially and
consistently surpasses the factor-specific expected
contribution criteria and the employee's contribution
plan goals and objectives.
[[Page 32080]]
Level 3--Fully Successful............................ An employee's performance consistently achieves, and
sometimes exceeds, the factor-specific expected
contribution criteria and his/her contribution plan
goals and objectives.
Level 1--Unacceptable................................ An employee's performance fails to meet the expectations
for quality of work and the required results for the
goals and objectives set forth in his/her contribution
plan for the appraisal cycle.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(b) Performance Appraisal Process. The quality of performance
appraisal is conducted in conjunction with the contribution scoring
process. As the rating official considers such items as the employee's
self-assessment, clients' feedback, and personal observations in
preparation for assigning preliminary CCAS categorical scores, he/she
will also assess the quality of the employee's performance in achieving
his/her contribution results under each of the three contribution
factors. A preliminary performance appraisal level of either Level 5--
Outstanding, Level 3--Fully Successful, or Level 1--Unacceptable from
Table 3 will be assigned by the rating official to each of the three
contribution factors. The three performance appraisal levels are
averaged to calculate the annual rating of record. The resulting
quotient will be rounded to the nearest tenth of a decimal point. If
the hundredths and thousandths places of the decimal reflect forty-nine
or less, they are dropped and the tenths place does not change. If the
hundredths and thousandths places of the decimal is fifty or more, they
are dropped and the tenths place is increased by ``.1''. The final
average will then reflect the employee's overall job performance during
the appraisal cycle based on the rating criteria outlined in Table 4.
Table 4--Rating Criteria
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rating of record Rating criteria
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Level 5--Outstanding................................. The average score of the three appraisal levels is 4.3 or
greater, with no contribution factor being rated a ``1''
(Unacceptable), resulting in a rating of record that is
a ``5''.
Level 3--Fully Successful............................ The average score of the three appraisal levels is less
than 4.3, with no contribution factor being rated a
``1'' (Unacceptable), resulting in a rating of record
that is a ``3''.
Level 1--Unacceptable................................ Any contribution factor rated as ``1''.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the pay pool panel process, panel members will review the
preliminary performance appraisal level justifications for the
contribution factors and rating of record for all pay pool members for
consistency and equity of application within the pay pool population
before final approval. The average raw score of the three appraisal
levels and the approved annual rating of record will be recorded in the
Defense Civilian Personnel Data System. The annual rating of record
will be recorded as a Level 5--Outstanding, Level 3--Fully Successful,
or Level 1--Unacceptable.
g. Pay Pool Panel Responsibilities. The pay pool panel meets at key
points in the assessment process, e.g., following assignment of
preliminary categorical scores, numeric score ranges, and quality of
performance levels; after assignment of preliminary OCSs and ranking
employees and their contributions; and/or following assignment of
preliminary categorical scores and numeric score ranges; and/or
following a final review of the OCS and the recommended compensation
adjustments for employees of the pay pool. During the pay pool panel
meetings, panel officials review contribution assessments to include
employee feedback, rank order, contribution scores, compensation
adjustments, performance appraisal levels, average raw score for the
three levels, and performance rating of record for all employees,
correcting any inconsistencies identified and making the appropriate
adjustments.
The pay pool panel members are encouraged to include initial rating
officials in the process to ensure equity and consistency in the
scoring, ranking, and appraisal of all employees and establish local
policies and procedures to guide the inclusion of these officials in a
uniform manner. Together, with the Pay Pool Manager, the pay pool panel
members determine a consistent approach to involving initial rating
officials in the process.
Final approval of OCS, compensation adjustments, and ratings of
record rests with the Pay Pool Manager, the individual within the
organization responsible for managing the CCAS process. Rating
officials will communicate the factor scores, OCS, quality of
performance appraisal levels, average raw score, rating of record, and
compensation adjustments to each employee and discuss the results after
final approval by the Pay Pool Manager.
h. Special Circumstances affecting a CCAS Assessment. When an
employee cannot be evaluated readily by the normal CCAS appraisal
process due to special circumstances that take the individual away from
normal duties or duty station (e.g., long-term full-time training;
active military duty; extended sick leave; qualified family and medical
leave; full time union representation; leave without pay, etc.), the
rating official will document the special circumstances on the
appraisal form. The rating official will then determine which of the
following five options to use, guided by local business rules and with
consideration of any special legal entitlements such as the Uniformed
Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA) which may
affect that determination:
(1) Use available observations and documentation to prepare an
assessment and determine a recommended OCS and an appropriate CCAS
overall assessment of the quality of performance appraisal level; or
(2) Assign a Presumptive--Status 1: New AcqDemo hires with less
than the necessary time to receive an actual CCAS contribution
assessment.
(3) Assign a Presumptive--Status 2: Presume the employee is
contributing consistently with his/her EOCS representative of his/her
basic pay level by recommending the EOCS for the OCS and Level 3--Fully
Successful rating of record; or
(4) Assign a Presumptive--Status 3: Recommend the pay pool panel
re-
[[Page 32081]]
certify the employee's last contribution assessment OCS if greater than
the current EOCS and the last CCAS rating of record if higher than the
expected rating of record performance appraisal level. [Option (3) is
not available (a) for first year AcqDemo assessments and/or (b) for
employees who have changed broadband levels during the assessment
period.]
(5) Assign a Presumptive--Status 4: Prolonged Absence Due to Work-
related Injury or Full Time Union Representation Duties. A
Presumptive--Status 4 may be used as a rating of record for purposes of
RIF for those periods in which an employee did not receive a
performance appraisal due to a prolonged absence resulting from a work-
related injury approved for compensation pursuant to an Office of
Workers' Compensation Program or while performing the duties of a full
time union representative. Presumptive--Status 4 is limited to only
periods of time for which the employee has no rating of record under
any performance management system within the four-year period preceding
the ``cutoff date'' established for the RIF. A Presumptive--Status 4
presumes the employee is contributing consistently with his/her EOCS
representative of his/her basic pay level by recommending the EOCS for
the OCS and an overall Level 3--Fully Successful rating of record.
(6) Assign a Presumptive--Status 5: Employees Absent for Military
Service. Employees who are absent for military service will receive a
CCAS assessment and be assigned a rating of record provided they have
performed work under an approved contribution plan for a minimum of 90
calendar days. If an employee absent for military service has not
performed work under an approved contribution plan for a minimum of 90
days and has no rating of record under any performance management
system within the previous four-year period, the employee will be
presumed to be contributing consistently with his/her EOCS
representative of his/her basic pay level and will receive the rating
of record most frequently given among the actual ratings of record in
the same competitive area. Employees performing military service who do
not meet the 90-calendar day requirement but have a rating of record
under any performance management system within the four-year period
preceding the RIF ``cutoff date'' will receive a CCAS rating of record
consistent with this previous rating of record and will be assigned
their most recent rating of record as the new CCAS rating of record for
the appraisal cycle.
3. Integrated Pay Schedule. The CCAS Integrated Pay Schedule (IPS),
Figure 2, is the foundation for the basic pay structure under the
demonstration project. It provides a direct link between increasing
levels of contribution and increasing basic pay. The IPS covers basic
pay only and is the same for all AcqDemo employees, career paths, and
positions regardless of geographical location. The appropriate locality
pay is added following the determination of basic pay.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.002
a. IPS Horizontal Axis. The horizontal axis of the IPS represents
the OCS available through contribution appraisals. The OCS span from a
score of zero to the maximum OCS of 100, with a notional ``very high
score'' level
[[Page 32082]]
containing three scores to accommodate ``very high scores'' as
appropriate for those employees in the top broadband level of their
respective career paths. The ``very high scores'' of 105, 110, and 115
are provided for employees in Broadband Level IV of the Business and
Technical Management Professional career path; ``very high scores'' of
87, 91, and 95 are provided for employees in Broadband Level IV of the
Technical Management Support career path; and ``very high scores'' of
64, 67, and 70 are provided for employees in Broadband Level III of the
Administrative Support career path.
b. IPS Vertical Axis. The vertical axis of the IPS spans from the
dollar equivalent of the lowest basic pay under the AcqDemo, GS-1, Step
1, to the dollar equivalent of the highest basic pay of GS-15, step 10.
This encompasses the full basic pay range (excluding locality pay)
available under AcqDemo.
c. Normal Pay Region (NPR). The goal of CCAS is to make basic pay
consistent with the scope, level, and difficulty of an employee's
position and the value of his/her contributions to the mission of the
organization. Within the full basic pay range embodied in the IPS
vertical axis, an NPR was developed around a Standard Pay Line (SPL) to
provide a mechanism to determine appropriate compensation. The NPR
represents the area of the IPS where basic pay and value and level of
contributions and position are assumed to be properly related and
appropriately compensated. This relationship is represented by the
marker where an employee's basic pay and OCS intersect in relation to
the NPR and the SPL, the reference line for OCS.
(1) SPL. The SPL begins at an OCS of zero and the basic pay of a
GS-1, Step 1, and terminates at an OCS of 100 and the basic pay of a
GS-15, Step 10. Changes in OCS correspond to a constant percentage
change in basic pay along the SPL. The constant percentage change (or
SPL factor) used to arrange OCS evenly along the SPL in 100 increments,
where 100 is the range of OCS points, can be thought of as
approximately a +2 percentage change in basic pay associated with a one
score change in the OCS. The SPL factor for calendar year 2017 can be
computed from the GS-15, Step 10 pay and the GS-1, Step 1 pay. The SPL
factor for calendar year 2017 is 1.0200426. The SPL factor normally
changes on an annual basis with any General Schedule base pay increase
granted to the Federal civilian workforce.
(2) NPR. Employees whose annual OCS plotted against their basic pay
falls on or within the upper and lower rails of the NPR are considered
to be in the ``Normal Pay'' Region for basic pay adjustments and
eligible for either a performance rating of record of Level 5--
Outstanding or Level 3--Fully Successful. The upper and lower rails
encompass an area of 8.0 scores, or 8.0 percent
from the SPL in terms of basic pay or approximately 4.0 in
terms of scores, relative to the SPL. Given these constraints, the
formulae for the NPR SPL and upper and lower rails found in Figure 2
are:
Basic Pay Upper Rail = (GS-1, Step 1) * (1.0800) * (SPL factor) \OCS\
Basic Pay SPL = (GS-1, Step 1) * (SPL factor) \OCS\
Basic Pay Lower Rail = (GS-1, Step 1) * (0.9200) * (SPL factor) \OCS\
An example calculation is provided below for an OCS of 50 and 51 using
calendar year 2017 basic pay for GS-1, Step 1. It indicates an
approximate 2% in basic pay between OCS along the SPL.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.003
d. Overcompensated Region. Employees whose annual OCS when plotted
against their basic pay falls above the upper rail of the NPR into the
``overcompensated'' region are considered overpaid for their level of
contribution and compensation adjustments, and ``unacceptable'' for
their contribution assessment. Typically, employees who are scored
above the upper rail into the overcompensated region are not meeting
contribution and performance expectations and will be placed on a CIP.
e. Undercompensated Region. Employees whose annual OCS when plotted
against their basic pay falls below the lower rail of the NPR into the
``undercompensated'' region are considered underpaid for their level of
contribution and position, in the ``Undercompensated'' Category for
[[Page 32083]]
compensation adjustments, and have either a Level 5--Outstanding or
Level 3--Fully Successful rating of record as part of their
contribution assessment. These employees may expect to receive greater
basic pay increases than those eligible employees who fall within the
normal pay region.
f. Relation to Career Paths. The IPS and the NPR are the same for
all the career paths. What varies among the career paths are the
beginnings and endings of the broadband levels. The minimum and maximum
numerical OCS values and associated basic pay for each broadband level
by career path are provided in Table 5. These minimum and maximum
breakpoints represent the lowest and highest GS base pay for the grades
banded together and, therefore, the minimum and maximum basic pay
possible under AcqDemo for each broadband level.
Table 5--OCS and Basic Pay Ranges by Career Path and Broadband Level
[Calendar year 2017]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Broadband and very high score levels GS grades Numerical score range Basic pay range
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Business Management and Technical Management Professional (NH)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.......................................... 1-4 0-29......................... $18,526-$33,164
II......................................... 5-11 22-66........................ 28,545-68,025
III........................................ 12-13 61-83........................ 62,722-96,958
IV......................................... 14-15 79-100....................... 88,136-134,776
Very High Score............................ N/A 105, 110, or 115............. N/A
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Technical Management Support (NJ)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.......................................... 1-4 0-29......................... 18,526-33,164
II......................................... 5-8 22-51........................ 28,545-50,904
III........................................ 9-11 43-66........................ 43,251-68,025
IV......................................... 12-13 61-83........................ 62,722-96,958
Very High Score............................ N/A 87, 91, or 95................ N/A
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Administrative Support (NK)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.......................................... 1-4 0-29......................... 18,526-33,164
II......................................... 5-7 22-46........................ 28,545-45,970
III........................................ 8-10 38-61........................ 39,159-61,922
Very High Score............................ N/A 64, 67, and 70............... N/A
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Compensation Adjustments. After the initial assignment into the
CCAS, employees' yearly contributions and performance will be
determined by the CCAS contribution assessment process described above,
and their OCS versus their current rate of basic pay will be plotted on
the IPS graph (Figure 3) to determine their compensation category. The
marker at the intersection of the OCS vertical straight line with the
current basic pay horizontal straight line respective to the
Participating Organization's choice of target line, i.e., SPL, upper
rail, or lower rail of the NPR, gives a relative measure of the
compensation (basic pay) versus contribution (OCS) for pay adjustment
and/or award determinations. The target line of the SPL, upper rail, or
lower rail, or other target line is chosen by a Participating
Organization to serve as a compensation strategy for CRI payouts and to
determine the number of employees eligible to receive a CRI based on
their position in the Normal Pay Region in relation to the target line.
For instance, since the AcqDemo goal is to have employees' basic pay
centered on the SPL, if the Lower Rail were used as the target line,
fewer people would receive payouts, but those that did would receive
larger payouts. Whereas, if the Upper Rail were used as the target
line, more people would receive payouts, but each payout would be
smaller. The SPL allows for something in between the upper and lower
rail options.
a. Compensation Categories. Employees fall into one of the three
compensation categories: Overcompensated, appropriately compensated, or
undercompensated.
[[Page 32084]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.004
Depending on the category into which an employee's marker falls,
he/she may be eligible for one to three forms of additional
compensation. The pay pool panel has the option of awarding the
employee up to and including the full General Pay Increase (as
authorized by law or the President), a CRI (an increase in basic pay
and/or a CRI carryover lump sum payment for the CRI basic pay amount
that exceeds a control point in or the maximum basic pay of an
employee's broadband level) and/or a contribution award (a lump-sum
payment that does not affect basic pay). In general, those employees
whose marker plots in the undercompensated region of the IPS may
receive greater percentage basic pay increases than those whose marker
plots in the overcompensated region of the IPS. Employees on retained
rate in the demonstration project will generally receive pay
adjustments in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 5363 and 5 CFR part 536;
however, the normal retained rate increase granted in connection with a
general pay increase may be reduced or denied for an employee with an
OCS above the upper rail and a performance appraisal of Level 1--
Unacceptable. An employee receiving a retained rate is not eligible for
a contribution rating increase, since such increases are limited by the
maximum salary rate for the employee's broadband level. Over time,
people will migrate closer to the standard pay line and receive basic
pay appropriate for their level of contribution and position. An
outline of compensation eligibility by contribution category is given
in Table 6.
Table 6--Compensation Eligibility Chart
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General pay Contribution
Category increase rating increase Contribution award Locality pay \7\
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overcompensated................. Could be reduced No................ No................ Yes.
or denied \8\.
Appropriately Compensated....... Yes............... Yes \9\--Up to 6%. Yes \10\.......... Yes.
Undercompensated................ Yes............... Yes--Up to 20% 11 Yes............... Yes.
12.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 32085]]
b. Local Policy. Each Pay Pool Manager will set the necessary
guidelines for pay adjustments in the pay pool based on guidance
received from the organization's Personnel Policy Board, Head of the
Participating Organization, and/or Component. Decisions will be
consistent within the pay pool, reflect cost discipline over the life
of the demonstration project, and be subject to review by Components
and the DoD AcqDemo Project Office.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ Basic pay plus locality pay may not exceed the rate payable
for level IV of the Executive Schedule.
\8\ Also applies to employees on pay retention whose
contribution and performance assessment is ``Unacceptable''.
\9\ May not exceed upper rail of NPR for employee's OCS or
maximum basic pay for current broadband level.
\10\ Pay pool manager approves up to $10,000 for a contribution
award. Amounts exceeding $10,000 not to exceed $25,000 for a
contribution award require the Head of the Participating
Organization approval.
\11\ Over 20% requires approval of the Head of the Participating
Organization.
\12\ May not exceed 6% above the lower rail or the maximum basic
pay for current broadband level.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Documentation. Basic pay adjustments and cash awards will be
documented by a SF-50, Notification of Personnel Action. The
performance appraisal level is uploaded into DCPDS at the same time as
the pay adjustments and cash awards. For historical and analytical
purposes, the CCAS Appraisal Form, to include the contribution plan,
employee self-assessment, supervisor annual assessment, effective date
of CCAS assessments, annual performance appraisal level, contribution
rating level, actual basic pay increases, amounts contributed to the
pay pool, and applicable ``bonus'' amounts, will be maintained for each
demonstration project employee. Each Participating Organization shall
provide for maintenance of contribution-related records for their
employees for a minimum of four years, as required in 5 CFR 293.402 and
404.
5. CIP Process.
a. Regulatory Coverage. This section applies to reassignment,
reduction in broadband level with or without a reduction in pay;
reduction in pay with or without a reduction in broadband level; or
removal of demonstration project employees based solely on inadequate
contribution. Inadequate contribution is identified by the employee's
annual CCAS contribution assessment resulting in an OCS falling above
the upper rail of the NPR (which normally occurs at either a -3 or -4
OCS or greater negative number) and an unacceptable rating of record,
or the deterioration of an employee's contribution during the appraisal
year such that, if rated, the employee would receive an OCS score above
the upper rail of the NPR and an unacceptable performance appraisal
level on at least one of the three contribution appraisal factors; or
by a combination of these results. An inadequate contribution
assessment in any one contribution factor at any time during the
appraisal period is considered grounds for the initiation of a CIP that
may result in reassignment, reduction in pay, or removal action,
hereafter referred to as contribution-based actions. The following
procedures replace those established in 5 U.S.C. 4303 pertaining to
reductions in grade or removal for unacceptable contribution except
with respect to appeals of such actions. As is currently the situation
for contribution-based actions taken under 5 U.S.C. 4303, inadequate
contribution-based actions shall be sustained if the decision is
supported by substantial evidence and the Merit Systems Protection
Board shall not have mitigation authority with respect to such actions.
The separate statutory authority to take inadequate contribution-based
actions under 5 U.S.C. chapter 75, as modified in the waiver section of
this notice (Section VII), remains unchanged by these procedures.
b. CIP. When a supervisor determines during or at the end of the
appraisal period that an employee is not completing work assignments
adequately, the supervisor must make a determination as to whether the
employee is contributing inadequately in one or more of the
contribution factors and/or quality of performance levels. All
contribution factors are considered critical elements. A determination
of inadequate contribution must be made by comparing the employee's
contribution to the expected contribution criteria in the appraisal
factors as well as the contribution expectations established in the
employee's CCAS Contribution Plan covering the factors and fully
successful performance.
If an employee's annual CCAS assessment or a contribution
assessment during the appraisal year results in the need for a CIP, the
supervisor must inform the employee, in writing, that he/she will be
placed on a CIP and that, unless the employee's contribution increases
such that the OCS would be scored in the NPR, contribution would be
considered fully successful, and this level of effort is sustained, he/
she may be subject to one of the previously listed contribution-based
actions. If an employee is placed on a CIP near the end of the
appraisal cycle, the CIP may not extend past October 31, with a
decision rendered no later than November 15.
When the rating official informs the employee of possible
contribution-based actions that may occur, the rating official will
afford the employee a reasonable opportunity to demonstrate acceptable
contribution and/or performance with regard to identifiable factors. A
CIP must provide the employee this opportunity to demonstrate adequate
contribution. The CIP will state the preliminary factor scores above
the upper rail, how the employee's contribution and/or performance are
inadequate, what improvements are required, recommendations on how to
achieve adequate contribution and/or performance, assistance that the
agency shall offer to the employee in improving inadequate
contribution, and consequences of failure to improve. Additionally, the
CIP will normally include a clarification (or further clarification) of
the meaning of terms used in the employee's specific responsibilities
and assignments described under the appraisal factors.
Once an employee has been afforded a reasonable CIP opportunity to
demonstrate adequate contribution and/or performance but fails to do so
and receives an unacceptable rating of record based on the CIP, a
reassignment, reduction in broadband level with or without a reduction
in pay, reduction in pay with or without a reduction in broadband
level, or removal action may be proposed in accordance with 5 U.S.C.
4303 and related OPM regulations under 5 CFR part 432. This
unacceptable rating of record will be considered an official rating of
record for RIF purposes whether it is issued during an appraisal cycle
or as an annual rating of record. If it is an employee's most recent/
current rating of record in the four-year period preceding a RIF, the
employee would be listed on the Master Retention List in the category
Tenure Group I--Current Unacceptable Performance Appraisal.
If the employee's contribution increases to an adequate level and
is again determined to deteriorate in any factor within two years from
the beginning of the opportunity period, actions may be initiated to
effect a contribution-based action with no additional opportunity to
improve. If an employee has contributed adequately for two years from
the beginning of a CIP opportunity period, and the employee's overall
contribution once again declines to an inadequate level, the employee
will be afforded an additional opportunity to demonstrate
[[Page 32086]]
adequate contribution before it is determined whether or not to propose
a contribution-based action.
An employee who is subject to a proposed contribution-based action
is entitled to a 30-day advance notice of the proposed action that
identifies specific instances of inadequate contribution by the
employee on which the action is based. The employee will be afforded a
reasonable time to answer the notice of proposed action orally and/or
in writing.
A decision to pursue a contribution-based action on an employee for
inadequate contribution may be based only on those instances of
inadequate contribution that occurred during the two-year period ending
on the date of issuance of the proposed action. The employee will be
issued written notice at or before the time the action will be
effective. Such notice will specify the instances of inadequate
contribution by the employee on which the action is based and will
inform the employee of any applicable appeal or grievance rights.
c. Inadequate Contribution under 5 U.S.C. 7512. Employees may also
be removed or reduced in broadband level based on inadequate
contribution (which inherently addresses performance) under the
provisions of 5 U.S.C. 7512.
d. Procedural and Appeal Rights. All procedural and appeal rights
set forth in the applicable statute and related OPM regulations will be
afforded to demonstration project employees reassigned, removed, or
reduced in level for inadequate contribution.
e. Documentation. All relevant documentation concerning a
contribution-based action that is based on a determination of
inadequate contribution will be preserved and made available for review
by the affected employee or a designated representative in accordance
with the employee's DoD Component policy for records management. At a
minimum, the records, in accordance with 5 CFR 432.107, will consist of
a copy of the notice of proposed action; the written answer of the
employee or a summary when the employee makes an oral reply; and the
written notice of decision and the reasons thereof, along with any
supporting material including documentation regarding the opportunity
afforded the employee to demonstrate adequate contribution.
6. CCAS Grievance Procedures.
a. Bargaining Unit Employees. Bargaining unit employees who are
covered under a collective bargaining agreement may grieve CCAS pay
determinations and performance appraisal levels under the grievance-
arbitration provisions of the agreement. The negotiated grievance
procedure shall be the sole and exclusive procedure for resolving such
grivances. If an employee is in a bargaining unit in which grievances
over appraisal scores have been excluded from the negotiated grievance
procedure, the employee may use the administrative grievance procedure
(5 CFR part 771) with supplemental instructions described in paragraph
b below.
b. Administrative Grievance Procedures. Employees not included in a
bargaining unit may grieve the contribution assessment which includes
the OCS and performance appraisal levels received under the CCAS using
procedures established under the appropriate Administrative Grievance
Procedures (5 CFR part 771). Under these procedures, the employee's
grievance will first be considered by the rating official who reviews
and submits a recommendation to the pay pool panel. The pay pool panel
may accept the rating official's recommendation or reach an independent
decision. In the event that the pay pool panel's decision is different
from the rating official's recommendation, appropriate justification
will be provided. The pay pool panel's decision is final unless the
employee requests reconsideration by the next higher official to the
Pay Pool Manager. That official would then render the final decision on
the grievance.
E. Employee Development
1. Academic Degree and Certificate Training
Trained and educated personnel are a critical resource in an
acquisition organization. This demonstration supports the concept that
well-developed training and development programs are essential to
improving the performance of AWF individuals and those employees in
direct support positions to the AWF, thus raising the overall level of
performance of the AWF as well as serving as a valuable tool for
recruiting and retaining motivated employees. AWF members have a
continuous learning (CL) requirement to ensure maintenance of currency
in their career field. They must earn a minimum of 80 CL points every
two years. Some have specific education and/or statutory requirements
depending on their career field. In addition, all acquisition positions
have certification requirements whereby AWF members must become
certified in their primary career field at the level required within 24
months of assignment. Currently, DAWIA authorizes degree and
certificate training for acquisition-coded positions. This
demonstration extends that authority and expands its coverage to the
acquisition direct support positions included in the project. It also
provides authorization at the local level to administer and pay for
these degree and certificate training programs. This authorization will
facilitate continuous attainment of advanced, specialized knowledge
essential to the AWF and its direct support employees. It also provides
a capability to assist in the recruiting and retaining of personnel
critical to the present and future requirements of the AWF.
A Participating Organization may require an employee who
participates in training to continue to work in that organization for
at least three times the length of the training period. The service
obligation begins when the training is completed. Funding for this
training, while potentially available from numerous sources (including
DAWDF for employees in acquisition-coded positions), is the
responsibility of the Participating Organization.
2. Sabbaticals
Organizations participating in the acquisition demonstration
project will have the authority to grant sabbaticals without
application to higher levels of authority. These sabbaticals will
permit employees to engage in study or work experience that contributes
to their development and effectiveness. The sabbatical provides
opportunities for employees to acquire knowledge and expertise that
cannot be acquired in the standard working environment. These
opportunities should result in enhanced employee contribution. The
spectrum of available activities under this program is limited only by
the constraint that the activity contribute to the organization's
mission and to the employee's development. The program can be used for
training with industry or on-the-job work experience with public,
private, or nonprofit organizations. It enables an employee to spend
time in an academic or industrial environment or to take advantage of
the opportunity to devote full-time effort to technical or managerial
research.
The acquisition demonstration project sabbatical program will be
available to all demonstration project employees who have seven or more
years of Federal service. Each sabbatical will be of three to twelve
months' duration and must result in a product, service, report, or
study that will benefit the acquisition community as well as increase
the employee's individual effectiveness. Requests for a sabbatical must
be made
[[Page 32087]]
by the employee through the chain of command to the Participating
Organization's management official, who has final approval authority
and who must ensure that the program benefits both the acquisition
workforce and the individual employee. Funding for the employee's
salary and other expenses of the sabbatical is the responsibility of
the Participating Organization.
Employees approved for a paid sabbatical must sign a service
obligation agreement to continue in service in the covered
organizations for a period of three times the length of the sabbatical.
The service obligation begins when the training is completed.
Sabbaticals approved prior to the effective date of this FRN are not
subject to the service obligation requirement. If an employee
voluntarily leaves the covered organizations before the service
obligation is completed he/she is liable for repayment of expenses
incurred by the covered organizations that are associated with training
during the sabbatical. Expenses do not include salary costs. The
delegated sabbatical approving management official of the Participating
Organization has the authority to waive this requirement.
3. Student Intern Relocation Incentive. Recruitment of students is
often limited to the local commuting area of the employing organization
as college students frequently cannot afford to relocate to accept
student intern job offers in a commuting area different from that of
the college/university they are attending or their permanent home
residence. To alleviate this barrier and to further Better Buying Power
3.0 initiatives to recruit the next generation of high performers to
sustain and promote professionalism in the acquisition workforce, the
Head of the Participating Organization may approve relocation
incentives for new student interns and relocation incentives to student
interns whose worksite is in a different geographic location than that
of the college/university enrolled or their permanent home residence
each time the student interns return to duty at their official
worksites.
F. Movement Into and From AcqDemo
1. Management-Directed Conversion into the Demonstration Project
a. Conversion from the GS Pay System. An employee who is converted
into AcqDemo with his/her organization will have an automatic
conversion from his/her permanent GS grade rate of pay of record at
time of conversion into the new broadband system. Initial entry into
the AcqDemo for covered employees will occur through a full employee
protection approach that ensures each employee's initial placement into
a broadband level without loss of pay.
(1) WGI Buy-Ins. Rules governing WGIs within each Participating
Organization will remain in effect until an employee's conversion date.
Implementation of the AcqDemo broadbanding pay structure eliminates the
WGI increments of the current GS pay structure. To facilitate
conversion and employee acceptance of the new system, eligible
employees will receive a basic pay increase for that portion of their
next WGI corresponding to the weeks of service in-step they have
completed up to the effective date of their conversion so that they
will not feel they are losing pay or a pay entitlement accrued under
the GS system.
Employees on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) will remain in
their current system until the conclusion of the PIP and a decision is
rendered. If the PIP results in a current rating of record of
satisfactory performance or better, the employees will be eligible for
a WGI buy-in upon conversion. Employees will not be eligible for the
WGI buy-in if their current rating of record is unacceptable at the
time of conversion. Employees at step 10, or receiving retained pay at
the time of conversion will not be eligible for a WGI buy-in.
(2) Career-Ladder Promotion Buy-Ins. For those GS employees in
career-ladder promotion programs who are scheduled to be promoted to a
higher grade and whose performance is at least fully successful, basic
pay will be increased by a prorated share of the current value of the
next scheduled promotion increase based upon the actual number of weeks
the employee has completed towards the next scheduled promotion as of
the employee's conversion date. No WGI buy-in will be made if the
employee's pay is adjusted for a promotion that would be effective
before the next scheduled WGI.
(3) Special salary rates. Special salary rates will no longer be
applicable to demonstration project employees. Employees on special
salary rates at the time of conversion will receive a new basic rate of
pay computed by dividing their highest adjusted rate of basic pay
(i.e., special pay rate, or if higher, the locality rate) by the
special pay rate factor or the locality pay factor for their area. All
employees will be eligible for the future locality pay increases of
their geographic area. When conversion into the demonstration project
is accompanied by a simultaneous geographic move, the employee's GS
basic pay entitlements (including any locality or special rate) in the
new area will be determined before converting the employee's pay to the
demonstration project basic pay system. A full locality adjustment will
then be added to the new basic pay rate.
(4) Employees on Term and Temporary Appointments. (a) Employees
serving under term appointments at the time of conversion to the
demonstration project will be converted to a modified term appointment
provided they were hired for their current positions under competitive
procedures. These employees will be eligible for conversion to career
or career-conditional appointments in the competitive service provided
they:
1--Have served two years of continuous service in the term
position;
2--Were selected for the term position under competitive
procedures; and
3--Are contributing at an adequate contribution level, or meeting
fully successful performance objectives, or their equivalent, in non-
AcqDemo performance management systems.
Converted term employees who do not meet these criteria may
continue on their term appointment up to the not-to-exceed date
established under their current appointment. Extensions of term
appointments for employees who do not meet the above criteria may be
granted after conversion in accordance with the provision of this
regulation.
(b) Employees serving under temporary appointments when their
organization converts to the demonstration project will be converted
and may continue on their temporary appointment up to their
established, current not-to-exceed date.
Extensions of temporary appointments after conversion may be
granted in accordance with 5 CFR 213.104 for excepted service employees
and 5 CFR part 316, subpart D, for competitive service employees.
(5) Probationary Periods.
(a) Initial Probationary Period. Employees who have completed an
initial probationary period prior to conversion to AcqDemo will not be
required to serve a new initial probationary period. Employees who are
serving an initial probationary period upon conversion to AcqDemo will
serve the time remaining on their initial probationary period and may
have their initial probationary period extended in accordance with DoD
and demonstration project regulations and implementing issuances.
(b) Supervisory Probationary Periods. Employees transitioning to
AcqDemo who are serving a supervisory
[[Page 32088]]
probationary period upon conversion to AcqDemo will serve the time
remaining on their supervisory probationary period. Converting
employees who have completed a supervisory probationary period in their
current position prior to conversion to AcqDemo will not be required to
serve a new supervisory probationary period in that position. However,
an additional supervisory probationary period of one year may be
required if the employee is officially assigned to a different
supervisory position that constitutes a major change in supervisory
responsibilities from any previously held supervisory position.
(6) Retained Pay. If the employee's rate of basic pay exceeds the
maximum rate of basic pay for the broadband level corresponding to the
employee's GS grade, the employee will remain at that broadband level
and will receive a retained rate. The retained rate will be the total
of the employee's basic pay and locality or special pay.
b. Conversion from Other Personnel Pay Systems. Employees who enter
this demonstration project from other personnel pay systems (e.g.,
Defense Civilian Intelligence Personnel System or an STRL Demonstration
Project) due to a reorganization, mandatory conversion, Defense Base
Realignment and Closure process, or other directed action will be
converted into the AcqDemo via movement of their positions using an
appropriate Nature of Action Code. Employees' positions will be
classified based upon the position classification criteria and
broadband level definitions under the AcqDemo rules and their pay, upon
conversion, maintained under AcqDemo pay setting rules. In addition,
the provisions of Section II.F.1(a)(4), (5), and (6) are applicable to
conversions from other personnel and pay systems.
2. Non-AcqDemo Federal Employees Voluntarily Joining AcqDemo.
Federal employees entering into the AcqDemo from the GS or other pay
systems not as the result of a conversion will be moved into a career
path and broadband level with basic pay set in accordance with AcqDemo
guidance and reflective of the duties and responsibilities of the
AcqDemo position and an individual's qualifications. Highest previous
rate as defined in Section II.C.13 and AcqDemo internal guidance may
provide an appropriate tool for establishing basic pay in this
instance. The move will be described using the appropriate nature of
action, e.g., promotion, reassignment, transfer, etc., as provided by
the OPM's Guide to Processing Personnel Actions; the AcqDemo specified
NOAC; and the AcqDemo Legal Authority Code Z2W, Public Law 111-383.
3. Movement From the Demonstration Project
a. Effect of Reorganizations. 10 U.S.C. 1762(d) provides that an
AcqDemo organization that loses, due to reorganization, the one-third,
two-thirds personnel demographic eligibility required for continued
inclusion in AcqDemo may continue to participate in the AcqDemo
project. Continued participation may be contingent upon such items as
the amount of reduction in the number and/or kinds of positions to be
counted for the one-third, two-thirds demographic eligibility
requirement; degree of personnel involvement in an organization with an
acquisition mission to acquire necessary supplies, equipment, and
services to support the warfighter and DoD support staff; scope of
direct support to an acquisition workforce organization or closely
related functional area; and/or the primary personnel system utilized
by the gaining organization.
AcqDemo organizations affected by reorganization, realignment,
consolidation, or other organizational changes that may impact the one-
third, two-thirds personnel demographic eligibility requirement are to
contact the AcqDemo Program Manager expeditiously to discuss the
workforce changes in relation to continued AcqDemo participation. The
AcqDemo Program Manager will decide the additional information that
needs to be included in the organization's request for continued
participation. The organization will submit a request for continued
participation in accordance with the DoD AcqDemo Program Office's
internal implementing guidance. The AcqDemo Program Office will review
the rationale for and the data supplied in support of continued
participation; conduct periodic audits of the participating
organizations' populations as appropriate; and request additional
details or formal documentation as needed. Based on an assessment of
the information provided, the AcqDemo Program Manager will approve or
disapprove the participation including any pertinent comments.
b. Conversion to a Different Pay and/or Personnel System. Prior to
a management directed conversion of any AcqDemo organization and its
employees to a different pay and/or personnel system, a CCAS closeout
appraisal may be accomplished and an out-of-cycle payout may be made.
CCAS closeout and payout procedures would be followed except that
funding levels for out-of-cycle payouts may be reduced on a pro rata
basis if the period between the previous CCAS payout and the out-of-
cycle payout was less than one year. Funding that corresponds to the
general pay increase shall not form part of the pay pools for any out-
of-cycle payouts. After making the out-of-cycle payout, conversion of
employees covered by this demonstration project to another pay and/or
personnel system shall be accomplished in accordance with the gaining
system's implementing issuances.
c. Employee returns to the GS System. If a demonstration project
employee is moving to a GS position, or if the project ends and each
project employee must be converted back to the GS system, the following
procedure will be used to translate the employee's project broadband
level to an equivalent GS grade and the employee's demonstration rate
of pay to an equivalent GS rate of pay. The equivalent GS grade and GS
rate of pay must be determined before movement or conversion out of the
demonstration project and any accompanying geographic movement,
promotion, or other simultaneous action. For conversions upon
termination of the project and for lateral assignments, the equivalent
GS grade and rate will become the employee's actual GS grade and rate
after leaving the demonstration project (before any other action). For
transfers, promotions, and other actions to the GS system, the
equivalent GS grade and pay rate will be used by the gaining personnel
office in applying the GS pay administration rules applicable in
connection with the employee's movement out of the project (e.g.,
promotion rules, highest previous rate rules, pay retention rules) as
if the GS-equivalent grade and pay rate were actually in effect
immediately before the employee left the demonstration project. The
losing organization will document an employee's equivalent GS grade and
pay rate in the remarks section of the official SF-50, Notification of
Personnel Action, used to move the employee from the AcqDemo
organization.
d. Employee moves to a Non-GS System. An equivalent GS grade and
pay rate is determined for an employee who leaves AcqDemo for a
position in a non-GS system using the same calculation as when an
employee moves to a GS position. The losing organization will ensure
documentation of an employee's equivalent GS grade and pay rate in the
remarks section of the official SF-50 used to move the employee from
the AcqDemo organization. It is the responsibility of the gaining
organization to establish the level of the employee's new position and
the appropriate pay under the pay system for that organization. The
equivalent GS grade and pay
[[Page 32089]]
information provided may assist in this process.
e. Determining an Equivalent GS Grade. Each broadband level in this
demonstration project encompasses two or more grades. An employee is
determined to have a GS-equivalent grade corresponding to one of those
grades according to the following rules:
(1) The employee's adjusted rate of basic pay under the
demonstration project, which includes any locality payment, is compared
with the step four rate in the highest applicable GS rate range. For
this purpose, a GS rate range includes a rate range in:
(a) The GS base schedule;
(b) The locality rate schedule for the locality pay area in which
the position is located; or
(c) The appropriate special rate schedule for the employee's
occupational series, as applicable. If the series is a two-grade-
interval series, only odd-numbered grades are considered below GS-11.
(2) If the employee's adjusted demonstration project rate of pay
equals or exceeds the applicable step four rate of the highest GS grade
in the broadband, the employee is converted to that grade.
(3) If the employee's adjusted demonstration project rate of pay is
lower than the applicable step four rate of the highest grade, the
adjusted rate is compared with the step four rate of the second-highest
grade in the employee's broadband. If the employee's adjusted rate
equals or exceeds the step four rate of the second-highest grade, the
employee is converted to that grade.
(4) This process is repeated for each successively lower grade in
the broadband until a grade is found in which the employee's adjusted
demonstration project rate of pay equals or exceeds the applicable step
four rate of the grade. The employee is then converted at that grade.
If the employee's adjusted rate of pay is below the step four rate of
the lowest grade in the broadband, the employee is converted to the
lowest grade.
(5) Exception: An employee will not be converted to a lower grade
than the grade held by the employee immediately preceding a conversion,
lateral assignment, or lateral transfer into the demonstration project,
unless, since that time the employee has undergone a reduction in
broadband level or reduction in pay based upon an adverse action, a
contribution-based action, a reduction-in-force action, or a voluntary
change to lower broadband level.
(6) Exception: If the employee's adjusted demonstration project
rate exceeds the maximum rate of the grade assigned under the above-
described step 4 rule but fits in the rate range for the next higher
applicable grade (i.e., between step 1 and step 4), then the employee
shall be converted to that next higher applicable grade.)
f. Determining an Equivalent GS Rate of Pay. An employee's pay
within the equivalent GS grade is set by converting the employee's
demonstration project rate of pay to a GS rate of pay in accordance
with the following rules:
(1) The pay conversion is done before any geographic movement or
other pay-related action that coincides with the employee's movement or
conversion out of the demonstration project.
(2) An employee's adjusted rate of basic pay under the
demonstration project (including any locality payment) is converted to
a GS rate on the highest applicable rate range for the converted GS
grade. For this purpose, a GS rate range includes a rate range in:
(a) The GS base schedule,
(b) An applicable locality rate schedule, or
(c) An applicable special rate schedule.
(3) If the highest applicable GS rate range is a locality pay rate
range, the employee's adjusted demonstration project rate is converted
to a GS locality rate of pay. If this rate falls between two steps in
the locality-adjusted schedule, the rate of pay must be set at the
higher step. The converted GS unadjusted rate of basic pay would be the
GS base rate corresponding to the converted GS locality rate (i.e.,
same step position).
(4) If the highest applicable GS rate range is a special rate
range, the employee's adjusted demonstration project rate is converted
to a special rate. If this rate falls between two steps in the special
rate schedule, the rate must be set at the higher step. The converted
GS unadjusted rate of basic pay will be the GS rate corresponding to
the converted special rate (i.e., same step position).
g. Retained Pay. If an employee is receiving a retained rate under
the demonstration project, the employee's GS-equivalent grade is the
highest referenced grade encompassed in his/her broadband level. The
employee's GS-equivalent rate of pay will equal the employee's retained
rate.
h. WGI-Equivalent Increase Determination.
Service under the demonstration project is potentially creditable
for WGI waiting period purposes under 5 CFR 531.405(b) upon conversion
back to the GS pay system. An equivalent increase under 5 CFR
531.407(b) is considered to occur at the time of an AcqDemo:
(1) Promotion to a higher broadband level, including a zero basic
pay increase (unless the promotion is cancelled and the employee's rate
of basic pay is redetermined as if the promotion had not occurred),
e.g., the termination of a temporary promotion.
(2) CCAS basic pay increase (including a zero increase). The date
of the last equivalent increase, based on the opportunity to receive a
CCAS basic pay increase, is the first day of the first pay period
beginning on or after January 1.
(3) WGI buy-in and/or Career Ladder promotion buy-in granted
immediately upon movement to the AcqDemo from another pay system.
(4) ACDP basic pay adjustment.
(5) Use of HPR when basic pay is set at a rate above the rate that
would be established using normal AcqDemo pay setting rules.
i. Quality of Performance. The most recent CCAS annual or interim
rating of record will be provided for use by the gaining activity.
G. Training for AcqDemo
1. Introduction. The key to the success or failure of the proposed
demonstration project will be the training provided. This training
provides not only the necessary knowledge and skills to carry out the
proposed changes, but will also lead to participant commitment to the
program.
2. Roles and Responsibilities.
a. AcqDemo Program Office. Training for new organizations wishing
to convert to the demonstration project will be provided by the DoD
AcqDemo Program Office to supervisors, employees, and the
administrative staff responsible for assisting managers in effecting
the changeover and operation of the new system. The Program Office will
be responsible for providing policy notifications as they occur.
b. Participating Organizations. Sustainment training will be the
responsibility of the participating organization.
3. Conversion Training.
a. Subject Matter. The elements to be covered in the orientation
portion of this training will include:
(1) A description of the personnel system;
(2) How employees are converted into and out of the system;
(3) The pay adjustment and/or bonus process;
(4) The new position requirements document;
(5) The new classification system; and
(6) The Contribution-based Compensation and Appraisal System.
b. Target Audiences.
[[Page 32090]]
(1) Supervisors. The focus of this project on management-centered
personnel administration, with increased supervisory and managerial
personnel management authority and accountability, demands thorough
training of supervisors and managers in the knowledge and skills that
will prepare them for their new responsibilities. Training will include
detailed information on the policies and procedures of the
demonstration project, as well as skills training in using the
classification system, position requirements document, and contribution
evaluation software.
(2) Human Resources/Pay Pool Administrative Staff. Human Resources
Specialists and Pay Pool Administrative Officers will play a key role
in advising, training, and coaching supervisors and employees in
implementing the demonstration project. This staff will receive
training in the procedural and technical aspects of the project.
(3) Employees. In the months prior to implementation, the
demonstration project team and Participating Organization training and
career development offices will provide workforce training through
various media. This training is intended to inform the workforce of
project features and to prompt the development of local procedures and
processes to implement the changes.
III. Evaluation Plan
A. Internal Evaluation
Demonstration-authorizing legislation (5 U.S.C. 4703) mandates
evaluation of the demonstration project to assess the effects of
project features and outcomes. In addition, the project will be
evaluated to determine the feasibility of application to other Federal
Agencies. The overall Program Management evaluation will consist of two
components--internal and external evaluation. The internal evaluation
will be ongoing and accomplished by the staff of the AcqDemo Program
Office, to include contracted resources, and the results reviewed by
the Executive Council. The main purpose of the internal evaluation is
to determine the effectiveness of the personnel system in meeting the
needs of the Defense Acquisition Workforce.
B. External
External evaluations will be conducted on a regular basis as
prescribed by the Secretary. The Secretary may designate an independent
evaluator to conduct the external assessments with the results overseen
by the Undersecretary of Defense (Acquisition, Technology & Logistics)/
Human Capital Initiatives; and the Deputy Assistant Secretary of
Defense (Civilian Personnel Policy).
C. Purpose
The evaluations are conducted to determine the effectiveness of the
personnel system changes implemented. To the extent possible, strong
direct or indirect relationships will be established between the
demonstration project features, outcomes, mission-related changes, and
personnel system effectiveness criteria. The evaluation approach uses
an intervention impact model that specifies each personnel system
change as an intervention, the expected effects of each intervention,
the corresponding measures, and the data sources for obtaining the
measures. Appendix F presents the Intervention Impact Evaluation Model
to be used for this demonstration project for initiatives affecting
title 5 U.S.C. and title 5 CFR.
IV. Project Duration
The Demonstration Project has been extended by statute three times
as indicated below:
1. Section 813 of the Bob Stump NDAA for FY 2003 (Pub. L. 107-314,
116 Stat. 2609) extended the authority to conduct the AcqDemo until
September 30, 2012;
2. Section 872 of the Ike Skelton NDAA for FY 2011 (Pub. L. 111-
383, 124 Stat. 4300, 4302) extended the authority to conduct the
AcqDemo Program until September 30, 2017; and
3. Section 846 of the NDAA for FY 2016 (Pub. L. 114-92) extended
the termination date for the AcqDemo Project to December 31, 2020.
V. Demonstration Project Costs
The AcqDemo Project requires a cost-disciplined approach to
maintain cost control. While this approach does not require cost
neutrality, it does require a continued comparison with the Government-
wide system to ensure an effective balance between cost, and personnel
management benefits such as improved organizational communication, and
greater recognition of higher contributors, leading to increased
retention rates and savings in turnover costs and loss of skills. This
cost-disciplined approach also requires Participating Organizations to
consider and implement a logical and effective compensation management
strategy, aimed at providing the appropriate level of compensation for
the contribution expended in accomplishing work at an assigned level.
To promote cost accountability, project and pay pool managers are
required to consider both the short- and long-term implications of pay-
related decisions on payroll and benefit costs, including decisions
regarding the size of pay pools and policies on developmental and
promotion pay increases. To support decision making and evaluations,
annual data will be collected on key cost-related matters, including
spending on CRIs, developmental increases, and promotion pay increases
(expressed as a percentage of total basic payroll, on both a project-
wide and individual pay pool basis).
The funding parameters for contribution increases in the out-years
will be determined as part of the annual project evaluation process, as
well as giving consideration to any funding limitations impacting the
Department. Annual funding guidance will then be reported by the
Program Manager to the AcqDemo Executive Council. As part of the
evaluation of the project by Participating Organizations, the AcqDemo
Program Management Office, and DoD, the basic pay costs (including
average basic pay, average starting salaries, overall and by employee
subcategories) under the demonstration project will be tracked and
compared to the basic pay costs under similar demonstration projects
and under a simulation model that replicates GS spending. These
evaluations will balance costs incurred against benefits gained, so
that both fiscal responsibility and project success are given
appropriate weight.
VI. Automation Support
One of the major goals of the demonstration project is to
streamline the personnel processes to increase efficiency,
effectiveness, agility, and cost discipline. Automation must play an
integral role in achieving that goal. Without the necessary automation
to support the interventions proposed for the demonstration project,
optimal benefits cannot be realized. In addition, adequate information
to support decision making must be available to managers if line
management is to assume greater authority and responsibility for human
resources management. Automation to support the demonstration project
is required at the DoD level to facilitate processing and reporting of
demonstration project personnel actions, and may be ultimately required
by the Participating Organizations to assist in processing a variety of
personnel-related actions in order to facilitate management processes,
evaluation of interventions, and decision making. The DCPDS is the
DoD's authoritative personnel data
[[Page 32091]]
system of record and will be the primary system for personnel data used
in dedicated electronic applications needed to process and evaluate a
variety of actions associated with AcqDemo initiatives such as
streamlined hiring and movement of employees; contribution-based
appraisal compensation; accelerated compensation for developmental
positions; supervisory and team leader cash differentials; staffing
supplements; and sabbaticals.
VII. Required Waivers to Law and Regulations
A. General
In addition to the authorities granted by 10 U.S.C. 1762 and 5
U.S.C. 4703, the following are waivers of law and regulation that will
be necessary for implementation and sustainment of the demonstration
project. In due course, additional laws and regulations may be
identified for a waiver request. The following waivers and adaptations
of certain title 5 U.S.C. and title 5 CFR provisions are required only
to the extent that these statutory and regulatory provisions limit or
are inconsistent with the actions contemplated under this demonstration
project. Nothing in this plan is intended to preclude the demonstration
project from adopting or incorporating any law or regulation enacted,
adopted, or amended after the original effective date, January 8, 1999,
of this demonstration project.
B. Waivers to Title 5, U.S.C.
Chapter 5, Section 552a: Records maintained on individuals. This
section is waived only to the extent required to clarify that
volunteers under the Voluntary Emeritus Program are considered
employees of the Federal Government for purposes of this section.
Chapter 31, Section 3111: Acceptance of volunteer service. This
section is amended to allow for a Voluntary Emeritus Corps in addition
to student volunteers.
Chapter 33, Subchapter I--Examination, Certification, and
Appointment: Waived except for sections 3302, 3321, and 3328 to allow
direct hire authority for (1) qualified candidates with bachelor's or
advanced degrees required by OPM or DoD qualification standards to
qualify for AWF positions in a critical acquisition career field
classified to the Business and Technical Management Professional, NH,
career path; (2) qualified veteran candidates for AWF positions in a
critical acquisition career field classified to either the Business and
Technical Management Professional, NH, career path or to the Technical
Management Support, NJ, career path; (3) candidates enrolled in a
program of undergraduate or graduate instruction at an institution of
higher education leading to a baccalaureate degree or an advanced
degree in a course of study required by OPM or DoD qualification
standards or a degree the completion of which (including any additional
essential credit hours in an acquisition-related field as appropriate)
provides competencies, knowledge, skills, etc., directly linked to an
AWF position's requirements (quality ranking factors) for one of the
critical acquisition career fields; and (4) degreed candidates with
superior scholastic achievement with a degree in a field of study
directly linked to the qualifications, competencies, knowledge, skills,
abilities, and DAWIA certifications for and duties of AWF positions in
one of the critical acquisition career fields.
Chapter 33, Section 3308: Competitive service; examinations;
educational requirements prohibited; exceptions to the extent necessary
to accommodate the Scholastic Achievement Appointment's requirement for
possession of a college degree, the completion of which provides
qualifications, competencies, knowledge, skills, and abilities,
directly linked to the requirements for and duties of an AWF
professional position (quality ranking factors) in one of the
acquisition career fields.
Chapter 33, Section 3317(a): Competitive service; certification
from registers. Waived insofar as ``Rule of Three'' is eliminated under
the demonstration project.
Chapter 33, Section 3318(a): Competitive Service, Selection from
Certificate. Waived insofar as the ``Rule of Three'' is eliminated
under the demonstration project and to provide a substitute selection
process that when making final selections, qualified candidates with
veterans' preference should be considered for appointments if they are
found to best meet mission requirements.
Chapter 33, Section 3319: Alternative ranking and selection
procedures. Waived to allow the continuation of the original AcqDemo
Delegated Examining Authority published in 64 FR 1426-1492, Friday,
January 8, 1999, as modified by the President's 2010 Memorandum
requiring agencies to use category rating; to replace the use of
veterans' preference points with ``determining veterans' preference
eligibility when the selecting official has identified the candidates
under serious consideration for a job offer,'' and to establish a
process that when making final selections from the serious-
consideration-for-a-job-offer group, any candidate with veterans'
preference should be considered for appointments if they are found to
best meet mission requirements.
Chapter 33, Section 3341: Details. Waived as necessary to extend
the time limits for details.
Chapter 35, Section 3502: Order of retention. Waived as necessary
to accommodate the reduction-in-force process described in this
demonstration project with 3502(c) waived in its entirety.
Chapter 41, Section 4107(a): Academic degree training. Waived to
the extent necessary to provide academic degree training as described
for the demonstration project.
Chapter 41, Section 4108(a)-(c): Employee agreements; service after
training. Waived to the extent necessary to require the employee to
continue in the service of the covered organizations for the period of
the required service and to the extent necessary to permit the
organization to waive in whole or in part a right of recovery.
Chapter 43, Sections 4301-4305 except for 4303(e) and (f): Related
to performance appraisal are waived in entirety. In turn, 4303(e) and
(f) are waived only to the extent necessary to (1) substitute
``broadband'' for ``grade'' and (2) provide that moving to a lower
broadband as a result of not receiving the full amount of a general pay
increase because of inadequate contribution is not an action covered by
the provisions of section 4303(a)-(d).
Chapter 45, Sections 4502(f): General Provisions. Waived to allow
Service Acquisition Executives to approve cash awards for superior
accomplishments not to exceed $25,000.
Chapter 51, Sections 5101-5113: Related to classification standards
and grading. Waived in entirety except section 5104 to the extent
needed to permit classification of broadband levels and factor
descriptors and discriminators.
Chapter 53, Sections 5301; 5302 (8) and (9); and 5303-5305 and
5331-5336: Related to special pay and pay rates and systems. Sections
5301, 5302 (8) and (9), and 5304 are waived only to the extent
necessary to allow demonstration project employees to be treated as
General Schedule employees and to allow basic rates of pay under the
demonstration project to be treated as scheduled rates of basic pay.
Chapter 53, Section 5362: Grade retention. Waived in its entirety.
Not applicable in the demonstration project.
[[Page 32092]]
Chapter 53, Section 5363: Pay retention. This waiver applies only
to the extent necessary to: (1) Allow demonstration project employees
to be treated as General Schedule employees; (2) provide that pay
retention provisions do not apply to conversions from General Schedule
special rates to demonstration project pay, as long as total pay is not
reduced; (3) replace the term ``grade'' with ``broadband level;'' and
(4) provide that an employee on pay retention whose contribution
assessment is ``Unacceptable'' may have the 50 percent of the amount of
the increase in the maximum rate of base pay payable for the pay band
of the employee's position reduced or denied.
Chapter 53, Section 5371: Related to health care positions. This
waiver applies only to the extent necessary to allow demonstration
project employees to hold positions subject to Chapter 51 of title 5.
Chapter 55, Section 5545(d): Hazardous duty premium pay. Waived
only to the extent necessary to allow demonstration project employees
to be treated as General Schedule employees.
Chapter 57, Sections 5753, 5754, and 5755: Related to recruitment,
relocation, and retention payments, and supervisory differentials.
Waived to the extent necessary (1) to allow employees and positions
under the demonstration project to be treated as employees and
positions under the General Schedule; (2) allow management to offer a
bonus to incentivize geographic mobility to a new student intern and to
one whose worksite is in a different geographic location than that of
the college enrolled or permanent home residence; and (3) authorize
supervisory and team leader cash differentials as described for this
demonstration project.
Chapter 59, Section 5941: Allowances based on living costs and
conditions of environment; employees stationed outside the continental
United States or Alaska. This waiver applies only to the extent
necessary to provide that COLAs paid to employees under the
demonstration project are paid in accordance with regulations
prescribed by the President (as delegated to OPM).
Chapter 59, Section 5948: Related to physicians comparability
allowances (only to the extent necessary to treat employees under the
demonstration project as General Schedule employees).
Chapter 71, to the extent its provisions (e.g., 5 U.S.C.
7103(a)(12) and 7116) would prohibit management or the union from
unilaterally terminating negotiations over whether the project will
apply to employees represented by the union.
Chapter 71, Section 7119: To the extent it gives the Federal
Service Impasses Panel jurisdiction to resolve impasses referred to it
by either party or both parties during implementation of the
demonstration project.
Chapter 75, Section 7512(3): Adverse actions. Waived to the extent
necessary to exclude reductions in broadband level not accompanied by a
reduction in pay and replace ``grade'' with ``broadband level''.
Chapter 75, Section 7512(4): Adverse actions. Waived to the extent
necessary to exclude conversions from a General Schedule special rate
to demonstration project pay that do not result in a reduction in the
employee's total rate of pay.
C. Waivers to Title 5, Code of Federal Regulations
Part 300, Sections 300.601 through 300.605: Time-in-grade
restrictions. Waived to eliminate time-in-grade restrictions in the
demonstration project.
Parts 300-330 other than Subpart G of 5 CFR part 300: Employment.
Waived to the extent necessary to allow direct hire authority for (1)
qualified candidates with bachelor's or advanced degrees required by
OPM or DoD qualification standards to qualify for AWF positions in a
critical acquisition career field classified to the Business and
Technical Management Professional, NH, career path; (2) qualified
veteran candidates for AWF positions in a critical acquisition career
field classified to either the Business and Technical Management
Professional, NH, career path or to the Technical Management Support,
NJ, career path; (3) candidates enrolled in a program of undergraduate
or graduate instruction at an institution of higher education leading
to a baccalaureate degree or an advanced degree in a course of study
required by OPM or DoD qualification standards or a degree the
completion of which (including any additional essential credit hours in
an acquisition-related field as appropriate) provides competencies,
knowledge, skills, etc., directly linked to an AWF position's
requirements (quality ranking factors) for one of the critical
acquisition career fields; and (4) degreed candidates with superior
scholastic achievement in a field of study directly linked to the
qualifications, competencies, knowledge, skills, abilities, and DAWIA
certifications for and duties of AWF positions in one of the critical
acquisition career fields.
Part 308, Volunteer service: Waived to allow volunteer service
under the provisions of the Voluntary Emeritus Program described in
this FRN.
Part 315, section 315.901: Statutory requirement. Waived to the
extent necessary to replace ``grade'' with ``broadband.''
Part 315, section 315.905: Length of the probationary period.
Waived to the extent necessary to allow for an additional supervisory/
managerial probationary period of one year when an employee is
officially assigned to a different position that constitutes a major
change in supervisory/managerial responsibilities.
Part 316, Section 316.301: Purpose and duration. Waived to the
extent that modified term appointments may cover a maximum period of
six years.
Part 316, Section 316.303: Tenure of term employees. Waived to the
extent necessary to allow term employees to acquire competitive status.
Part 316, Section 316.305: Eligibility for within-grade increases.
Waived in its entirety.
Part 332, Sections 332.401, Section 332.402, and Section 332.404:
Order on Registers; Regular order of certification for appointment; and
Order of Selection from Certificates. These sections are waived to the
extent necessary to allow: (1) No rating and ranking when there are 25
or fewer qualified applicants; (2) the hiring and appointment
authorities as described in this Federal Register notice; and (3)
elimination of the ``Rule of Three.'' Veterans' preference final
candidates are considered for appointments if they are found to best
meet mission requirements.
Part 332, Section 332.404: Order of selection from certificates.
Waived to the extent necessary to eliminate the requirement for
selection using the ``Rule of Three.''
Part 335, Section 335.103: Agency promotion programs. Waived to the
extent necessary to extend the length of details and temporary
promotions without requiring competitive procedures or numerous short-
term renewals.
Part 337, Subpart A, Section 337.101(a): Rating applicants. Waived
to the extent necessary to allow referral without rating when there are
25 or fewer qualified candidates, applying veterans' preference when
final candidates considered for appointments are found to best meet
mission requirements.
Part 337, Subpart C, Sections 337.301 through 337.305: Alternative
Rating and Selection Procedures. Waived to allow continuation of the
original AcqDemo Delegated Examining Authority published in the Federal
Register on Friday, January 8, 1999 (64 FR 1426-1492), as modified by
the President's
[[Page 32093]]
2010 Memorandum requiring agencies to use category rating.
Part 340, Subpart A, Subpart B, and Subpart C: Other than full-time
career employment. These subparts are waived to the extent necessary to
allow a Voluntary Emeritus Program.
Part 351, Sections 351.402 through 351.404: Competitive area,
Competitive levels, and Retention register. Waived in their entirety.
Part 351, Section 351.501: Order of retention-competitive service.
Waived (1) to allow no additional years of service based on
contribution/performance; (2) to combine Tenure Groups I and II into
one group, a new Tenure Group I for all permanent career and career-
conditional employees; and (3) separate the new Tenure Group I into
three categories: Tenure Group I for employees who have 12 or more
months of assessed performance; Tenure Group I for employees with less
than 12 months of assessed performance; and Tenure Group I--Current
Unacceptable Rating of Record.
Part 351, Section 351.502: Order of retention-excepted service.
Waived (1) to allow no additional years of service based on
performance; (2) to combine Tenure Groups I and II into one group, a
new Tenure Group I for all permanent employees; (3) separate the new
Tenure Group I into three categories: Tenure Group I for employees with
less than 12 months of assessed performance; and Tenure Group I--
Current Unacceptable Rating of Record.
Part 351, Section 351.504: Credit for Performance. Waived in its
entirety.
Part 351, Section 351.601: Order of Release from Competitive Level.
Waived in its entirety.
Part 351, Section 351.701: Assignment rights involving
displacement. Waived to the extent that the distinction between bump
and retreat is eliminated and the placement of demonstration project
employees is limited to an employee's current career path, current
broadband level, and one broadband level below that is within an
employee's current career path, except that a preference-eligible
employee with a compensable service-connected disability of 30 percent
or more may displace up to the two broadband levels below the
employee's present position (or the equivalent of five General Schedule
grades) below the employee's present level, and to limit the assignment
rights of employees with an unacceptable performance appraisal to a
position held by another employee with an unacceptable performance
appraisal.
Part 362, Subparts A, B, and C: General Provisions, Internship
Program, and Recent Graduates Program. Waived to the extent necessary
to allow for an AWF Scholastic Achievement Appointment Authority and an
AWF Student Intern Hiring Authority.
Part 410, Section 410.308(a): Training to obtain an academic
degree. Waived to the extent necessary to allow the Head of a
Participating Organization to provide academic degree and certificate
training as needed for interns and employees holding positions
allocated to acquisition career fields in order to meet AWF
certification requirements.
Part 410, Section 410.309: Agreements to continue in service.
Waived to the extent necessary to allow the Head of a Participating
Organization to determine requirements related to continued service
agreements.
Part 430, Subpart A and Subpart B: Performance Management and
Performance appraisal for General Schedule, Prevailing Rate, and
Certain Other Employees. Waived in its entirety including 430.208(a)(2)
and (h) to accommodate CCAS and the AcqDemo RIF process.
Part 432, Sections 432.101 through 432.107: Related to performance
based reduction in grade and removal actions, and definitions. Waived
to the extent necessary to (1) substitute ``broadband'' for ``grade;''
(2) provide that moving to a lower broadband as a result of not
receiving the full amount of a general pay increase because of
inadequate contribution is not an action covered by the provisions of 5
U.S.C. 4303 and 5 CFR 432.105 and 5 CFR 432.106; (3) delete reference
to critical element as all factors are critical; (4) waive section
432.105(a)(2) phrase ``If an employee has performed acceptably for 1
year'' to allow for ``performed acceptably for 2 years from the
beginning of a CIP;'' (5) waive section 432.105(a)(3) to provide
``within a two-year period ending on the date of the notice of proposed
action''; and (6) modify to the extent that an employee may be removed,
reassigned, reduced in broadband level with a reduction in pay, reduced
in pay without a reduction in broadband level, and reduced in broadband
level without a reduction in pay if performance does not improve to an
adequate level during a reasonable improvement period.
Part 451, Subpart A, Sections 451.106(b): Agency and OPM
Responsibilities. Waived to allow Service Acquisition Executives
authority to grant special act awards for superior achievements to
covered employees not to exceed $25,000.
Part 470, Subpart C, Section 470.315: Project modification and
extension. Waived to the extent necessary to expand participation in
the Voluntary Emeritus Program to allow former non-AcqDemo DoD civilian
employees and former military members who served in DoD DAWIA covered
acquisition positions to participate in the Program as well as former
AcqDemo employees serving in DAWIA-covered acquisition positions.
Part 511, Subpart A; Subpart B; Subpart F; and Subpart G:
Classification within the General Schedule. Waived in its entirety.
Part 530, Subpart C: Special Rate Schedules for Recruitment and
Retention. Waived in its entirety. Demonstration project does not
utilize special salary rates.
Part 531, Subpart B: Determining Rate of Basic Pay. Waived in its
entirety.
Part 531, Subparts D and E: Within-grade Increases and Quality Step
Increases. Waived in its entirety.
Part 531, Subpart F: Locality-Based Comparability Payments. Waived
only to the extent necessary to allow demonstration project employees
to be treated as General Schedule employees and to allow basic rates of
pay under the demonstration project to be treated as scheduled rates of
basic pay.
Part 536, Grade and Pay Retention: Waived to the extent necessary
to provide that, for the purposes of applying pay retention provisions:
(1) Grade retention is eliminated and there is no provision for
broadband level retention allowed; (2) ``grade'' is replaced by
``broadband level''; and (3) demonstration project employees are to be
treated as General Schedule employees except under the following
provisions: (a) Pay retention provisions do not apply to conversions
from General Schedule special rates to demonstration project pay, as
long as total pay is not reduced; (b) pay retention provisions do not
apply to movements to a lower broadband level as a result of not
receiving the general increase due to an annual contribution assessment
of ``Unacceptable''; and (c) provide that an employee on pay retention
whose performance appraisal is ``Unacceptable'' may have the 50 percent
of the amount of the increase in the maximum rate of base pay payable
for the broadband level of the employee's position reduced or denied.
Part 550, Section 550.703: Severance Pay. Definition of
``reasonable offer'' is waived by replacing ``two grade or pay levels''
with ``one broadband level'' and ``grade or pay level'' with
``broadband level.''
Part 550, Section 550.902: Hazard Pay. Definition of ``employee''
waived only to the extent necessary to allow demonstration project
employees to be treated as General Schedule employees.
[[Page 32094]]
Part 575, Sections 575.103(a)(1), 575.203 (a)(1), and
575.303(a)(1), and Subpart D: Recruitment, relocation, and retention
incentives, and supervisory differentials. Waived only to the extent
necessary (1) to allow employees and positions under the demonstration
project to be treated as employees and positions under the General
Schedule; (2) allow management to offer a bonus to incentivize
geographic mobility to a new student intern and to one whose worksite
is in a different geographic location than that of the college enrolled
or permanent home residence each time they return to duty at their
official work site; and (3) to allow supervisory and team leader cash
differentials as described for this demonstration project.
Part 591, Subpart B: Cost-of-Living Allowances and Post
Differential-Non-foreign Areas. This waiver applies only to the extent
necessary to allow demonstration project employees to be treated as
employees under the General Schedule for the purposes of these
provisions.
Part 752, Sections 752.401(a)(3) and 752.401(a)(4): Coverage.
Waived to the extent necessary (1) to provide that adverse action
provisions do not apply to reductions in broadband level not
accompanied by a reduction in pay and (2) to replace ``grade'' with
``broadband level.''
Part 752.401(a)(4): Coverage. Waived to the extent necessary to
exclude conversions from a General Schedule special rate to
demonstration project pay that do not result in a reduction in an
employee's total rate of pay.
Appendix A
History of Legislative Provisions and Federal Register Notices; DoD
Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Management Demonstration
Project
A. Legislative Provisions
This demonstration project was originally authorized under
section 4308 of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for
Fiscal Year (FY) 1996 (Public Law (Pub. L.) 104-106, 110 Stat. 669;
10 United States Code Annotated (U.S.C.A.) 1701 note), as amended by
section 845 of NDAA for FY 1998 (Pub. L. 105-85, 111 Stat. 1845);
section 813 of NDAA for FY 2003 (Pub. L. 107-314, 116 Stat. 2609);
section 1112 of NDAA for FY 2004 (Pub. L. 108-136, 117 Stat. 1634);
and section 1113 of NDAA for FY 2010 (Pub. L. 111-84, 123 Stat.
2190) repealed the National Security Personnel System and directed
conversion of all NSPS employees to their previous pay system by
January 1, 2012. All NSPS employees formerly in AcqDemo were
transitioned back to AcqDemo during the month of May 2011. On
January 7, 2011, the original demonstration project authority was
repealed and codified at 10 U.S.C. 1762 pursuant to section 872 of
the Ike Skelton NDAA for FY 2011 (Pub. L. 111-383, 124 Stat. 4300,
4302). Through Section 867 of NDAA for FY 2017 (Pub. L. 114-328),
Congress provided that the Secretary of Defense shall exercise the
authorities granted to the OPM under 5 U.S.C. 4703 for purposes of
the demonstration project.
B. Federal Register Notice and Subsequent Amendments
OPM approved and published the final project plan for the
AcqDemo on January 8, 1999, in 64 FR 1426-1492. Since that time, six
amendments have been approved and published, and one notice of
intent to amend published by OPM:
1. 66 FR 28006-28007 (May 21, 2001): This amendment was
published to (1) correct discrepancies in the list of occupational
series included in the project and (2) authorize managers to offer a
buy-in to Federal employees entering the project after initial
implementation.
2. 67 FR 20192-20193 (April 24, 2002): This amendment was
published to (1) make employees in the top broadband level of their
career path eligible to receive a ``very high'' overall contribution
score and (2) reduce the minimum rating period under the
Contribution-based Compensation and Appraisal System (CCAS) to 90
calendar days.
3. 67 FR 44250-44256 (July 1, 2002): This amendment (1)
contained a list of all organizations that are eligible to
participate in the project and (2) made the resulting adjustments to
the table that describes the project's workforce demographics and
union representation.
4. 67 FR 63948-63949 (October 16, 2002): This notice of the
intent to amend was published to propose a change in the method for
determining and translating retention service credit. The proposal
was overcome by the advent of the National Security Personnel System
(NSPS), which was projected to replace the AcqDemo.
5. 71 FR 58638-58639 (October 4, 2006): This amendment was
published to facilitate the transition of AcqDemo employees to NSPS
by authorizing an out-of-cycle Contribution-based Compensation and
Appraisal System payout and amending conversion-out procedures.
6. 80 FR 17109-17117 (March 31, 2015): This amendment announced
the repeal and replacement of AcqDemo's original legal authorization
and modified the project plan to include new provisions; updated the
project plan to address changes resulting from new General Schedule
regulations and operational experience; announced guidelines for a
formal process for interested DoD civilian acquisition organizations
to use to request approval to participate in AcqDemo; and provided
notice of expansion of coverage to new or realigned organizations.
7. 81 FR 6902 (February 9, 2016): This document publishes three
technical corrections to 80 FR 17109-17117 (March 31, 2015) to
ensure access for the entirety of an organization to participate in
AcqDemo.
Appendix B
Tables of Eligible Organizations
As a result of the success of the AcqDemo classification,
contribution appraisal, and compensation strategies and the desire
of the USD (AT&L) to increase participation to more evenly balance
the workforce among Participating Organizations for evaluation, the
organizations listed in Table 1A either applied in calendar year
2014 and have been approved to participate in the AcqDemo, or are
currently in Table 1 but require an update to their listed
organizational alignment.
Table 1--Eligible Organizations as of July 1, 2002
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOD component/DOD component major organizational
subdivision Organization/office symbol Locations
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Air Force Materiel Command (AFMC)................. Aeronautical System Center Wright-Patterson AFB, OH and
(ASC). all other locations.
AFMC.............................................. Air Armament Center (AAC) Eglin AFB, FL and all other
(except comparison group at locations.
Eglin AFB, FL).
AFMC.............................................. Air Force Flight Test Center Edwards AFB, CA and all other
(AFFTC). locations.
AFMC.............................................. Arnold Engineering Arnold AFB, TN and all other
Development Center (AEDC). locations.
AFMC.............................................. Electronic Systems Center Hanscom AFB, MA and all other
(ESC). locations.
AFMC.............................................. HQ AFMC...................... Wright-Patterson AFB, OH and
all other locations.
AFMC.............................................. Ogden Air Logistics Center Hill AFB, UT and all other
(OO-ALC). locations.
AFMC.............................................. Oklahoma City Air Logistics Tinker AFB, OK and all other
Center (OC-ALC). locations.
AFMC.............................................. Warner Robins Air Logistics Warner Robins AFB, GA and all
Center (WR-ALC). other locations.
[[Page 32095]]
Air Force Space Command (AFSPC)................... HQ AFSPC..................... Peterson AFB, CO and all
other locations.
AFSPC............................................. Space and Missile Center Los Angeles, CA and all other
(SMC). locations.
Miscellaneous Air Force........................... Contracting Organizations.... All locations in the National
Capital Region.
Secretary of the Air Force........................ Assistant Secretary of the Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Air Force (Acquisition) (SAF/ all other locations.
AQ) and Space Acquisition
Organization.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Army Acquisition Executive Support Agency (AAESA). Headquarters, Research, Orlando, FL; Alexandria, VA;
Development, and Acquisition Ft. Belvoir, VA; Falls
Information Systems Activity Church, VA; Pentagon,
(RDAISA); Army Digitization Arlington, VA; Radford, VA;
Office (ADO); Acquisition and all other locations.
Career Management Office;
Contract Support Agency
(CSA); Joint Simulations
(JSIMS); Leavenworth
Support; Management Support
Pentagon Support; Training
Group.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Huntsville, AL; Pentagon,
(PEO) Air and Missile Arlington, VA; and all other
Defense (See Note 1). locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Ammo All locations.
(See Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Huntsville, AL; Pentagon,
Aviation (AVN) (See Note 1). Arlington, VA; and all other
locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office All locations.
Chemical/Biological Defense
(See Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Huntsville, AL; El Segundo,
Command, Control, and CA; Tallahassee, FL; Ft.
Communication Systems (C3S). Wayne, IN; Ft. Leavenworth,
KS; Seoul, Korea; Yong San,
Korea; Ft. Monmouth, NJ;
White Sands Missile Range,
NM; Ft. Sill, OK; Ft. Hood,
TX; Ft. Bliss, TX: Ft.
Belvoir, VA; McLean, VA;
Pentagon, Arlington, VA; and
all other locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office CS/ All locations.
CSS (See Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Picatinny Arsenal, NJ;
Ground Combat Support Warren, MI; Pentagon,
Systems (GCSS) (See Note 1). Arlington, VA; Washington,
DC; and all other locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Officer Ft. Monmouth, NJ; Ft.
Intelligence, Electronic Belvoir, VA; and all other
Warfare, and Sensors (IEW&S) locations.
(See Notes 1 and 2).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office/ Orlando, FL; and all other
Program Management (PM) locations.
Joint Simulation System (See
Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office All locations.
National Missile Defense
Joint Program Office (See
Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office All locations.
Soldier (See Note 1).
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Office Ft. Knox, KY; Ft. Monmouth,
Standard Army Management NJ; Ft. Belvoir, VA; Ft.
Information Systems (STAMIS) Lee, VA; Ft. Monroe, VA; and
(See Note 1). all other locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Executive Officer Huntsville, AL; Pentagon,
Tactical Missiles (See Note Arlington, VA; Washington,
1). DC; and all other locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Management (PM) Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD;
Chemical Demilitarization. Pentagon, Arlington, VA;
Washington, DC; and all
locations.
AAESA............................................. Program Management (PM) Joint Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD;
Program for Biological Ft. Detrick, MD; Ft.
Defense. Ritchie, MD; Falls Church,
VA; and all locations.
Army Materiel Command (AMC)....................... Headquarters--Acquisition.... Alexandra, VA and all
locations.
AMC............................................... AMC Headquarters Staff Nahbohnch, Germany; Rock
Support Activities. Island, IL; Yong San, Korea;
Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD;
Alexandria, VA; and all
other locations.
AMC............................................... Installations and Services All locations.
Activity; Intelligence and
Technology Security
Activity; International
Cooperative Program
Activity; Logistics Support
Activity; Schools of
Engineering and Logistics;
Separate Reporting
Activities: Field Assistance
in Science and Technology;
Surety Field Activity;
Systems Analysis Activity
(See Note 2).
AMC............................................... Aviation and Missile Command All locations.
(AMCOM) (See Note 3).
AMC............................................... Communications-Electronics All locations.
Command (CECOM) (See Note 3).
AMC............................................... Operations Support Command All locations.
(See Note 3).
AMC............................................... Security Assistance Command All locations.
(See Note 2).
AMC............................................... Simulation, Training, and All locations.
Instrumentation Command
(STRICOM) (See Note 3).
AMC............................................... Soldier and Biological All locations.
Chemical Command (SBCCOM)
(See Note 3).
[[Page 32096]]
AMC............................................... Tank-Automotive and Armaments All locations.
Command (TACOM) (See Note 3).
Headquarters, Department of the Army (HQDA)....... Office of the Auditor Pentagon, Arlington, VA.
General; Office Surgeon
General; G1; G2; G3; G4; G6;
G8.
HQDA.............................................. Army Contracting Agency...... All locations.
Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Army Cost and Economic Analysis Falls Church, VA; Pentagon,
(Financial Management and Comptroller). Center; SAFM-BUI. Arlington, VA; and all other
locations.
Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Army Director of Assessment and Ft. Belvoir, VA; Falls
(Acquisition, Logistics, and Technology). Evaluation (SARD-ZD); Deputy Church, VA; Pentagon,
Assistant Secretary of the Arlington, VA; Radford, VA;
Army for Logistics (SARD- and all other locations.
ZL); Deputy Assistant
Secretary for Plans/Programs/
Policy (SARD-ZR); Deputy
Assistant Secretary of the
Army for Procurement (SARD-
ZP); Deputy Assistant
Secretary for Research and
Technology (SARD-ZT); Deputy
for Systems Management (SARD-
ZS); Management Support;
SACO and associated offices.
Medical Command (MEDCOM).......................... Healthcare Acquisition Augusta, GA; Honolulu, HI; El
Activity, MEDCOM Acquisition Paso, TX; San Antonio, TX;
Activity. Seattle, WA; Walter Reed
Army Medical Center,
Washington, DC; Landstuhl,
Germany.
MEDCOM............................................ Medical Research and Materiel Ft. Rucker, AL; Natick, MA;
Command (MRMC) (See Note 3). Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD;
Ft. Detrick, MD; Washington,
DC.
MEDCOM............................................ Medical Department Activity.. Ft. Greeley, AK; Ft.
Richardson, AK; Ft.
Wainwright, AK; Ft.
Huachuca, AZ; Ft. Carson,
CO; Heidelberg, Germany; Ft.
Campbell, KY; West Point,
NY; Ft. Jackson, SC; Ft.
Hood, TX.
MEDCOM............................................ Army Medical Centers......... Honolulu, HI; Ft. Bragg, NC;
San Antonio, TX; Tacoma, WA;
Washington, DC.
MEDCOM............................................ Center for Health Promotion Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD.
and Preventive Medicine..
US Army Eighth Army (EUSA)........................ Contracting Command Korea/ Seoul, Korea and all other
EAKC. locations.
EUSA.............................................. Troop Command................ Seoul, Korea and all other
locations.
US Army Test and Evaluation Command (ATEC)........ HQ, ATEC..................... Alexandria, VA.
ATEC.............................................. Operational Test Command Ft. Hood, TX and all other
(OTC). locations.
ATEC.............................................. Army Evaluation Center (AEC). Alexandria, VA and all other
locations.
ATEC.............................................. Developmental Test Command Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD
(DTC). and all other locations.
Headquarters, Department of the Army (HQDA)....... Defense Supply Services Alexandria, VA; Ft. Belvoir,
Washington (DSSW)/Joint-DSSW. VA; Falls Church, VA;
Washington, DC.
National Guard Bureau (NGB) (See Note 4).......... Program Executive Office/ Arlington, VA.
Program Management RCAS, NGB-
RCS-RA.
Joint Activities.................................. Information Management Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Support Center. all other locations.
Military Traffic Management Command (MTMC)........ HQ, MTMC..................... Alexandria, VA.
MTMC.............................................. MTAQ......................... Falls Church, VA and all
other locations.
MTMC.............................................. PM Global Freight Management Alexandria, VA.
System.
MTMC.............................................. 598th Transportation Terminal Yokohama, Japan; Rotterdam,
Group; 599th Transportation Netherlands; Oahu, HI; Fort
Terminal Group; 836th Eustis, VA; and all other
Transportation Terminal locations.
Group Deployment Support
Command.
Space and Missile Defense Command (SMDC).......... SMDC (See Note 1)............ Huntsville, AL; Kwajalein
Atoll, Marshall Islands;
Colorado Springs, CO; White
Sands Missile Range, NM;
Arlington, VA; Fairfax, VA;
all other locations.
Training and Doctrine Command (TRADOC)............ Headquarters, TRADOC Ft. Monroe, VA.
Acquisition Directorate and
Small and Disadvantaged
Business Utilization Office.
TRADOC............................................ Directorate of Contracting Ft. Eustis, VA.
and TRADOC Contracting
Activity.
TRADOC............................................ Directorate of Contracting Ft. Leavenworth, KS.
and Mission Contracting
Activity.
TRADOC............................................ Directorate of Contracting Ft. Lee, VA.
and Mission Contracting
Activity.
TRADOC............................................ Directorates of Contracting.. McClellan, AL; Rucker, AL;
Ft. Huachuca, AZ; Presidio
at Monterey, CA; Ft.
Benning, GA; Ft. Gordon, GA;
Ft. Knox, KY; Ft. Leonard
Wood, MO; Ft. Sill, OK;
Carlisle Barracks, PA; Ft.
Jackson, SC; Ft. Bliss, TX;
Ft. Lee, VA.
Corps of Engineers (COE).......................... Headquarters................. Washington, DC.
COE............................................... Regional Headquarters........ All locations.
[[Page 32097]]
COE............................................... Division, Directorates of All locations.
Contracting.
COE............................................... District Contracting Offices. All locations.
COE............................................... Transatlantic Programs All locations.
Center, Directorate of
Contracting.
COE............................................... Humphreys Engineering Center All locations.
Support Activity,
Contracting Office.
COE............................................... Marine Design Center......... All locations.
Intelligence and Security Command................. 704 Military Brigade, All locations.
Headquarters and
Headquarters Company; 718th
Military Group; HQ, U.S.
Army (USA) Intelligence
Security Command; USA
Element National Security
Agency (NSA); USA Foreign
Counter Intelligence (CI)
Activity; USA Land
Information Warfare; USA
National Ground Intelligence
Center (See Note 2).
Criminal Investigation Command.................... Headquarters................. Ft. Belvoir, VA and all other
locations.
U.S. Army Europe and 7th Army (USAREUR)........... Wiesbaden Contracting Center. Wiesbaden, Germany.
USAREUR........................................... USA Contracting Command Brussels, Belgium; Bad
Europe. Kreuznach, Germany;
Grafenwohr, Germany;
Seckenheim, Germany;
Wiesbaden, Germany;
Wuerzburg, Germany; Vicenza,
Italy; and all other
locations.
USAREUR........................................... USA Transportation Management Grafenwoehr, Germany.
Center.
Command........................................... Organization/Office Symbol... Locations.
USAREUR........................................... Southern European Task Force. Vicenza, Italy.
USAREUR........................................... 21st Theater Army Area Kaiserslautern, Germany.
Command.
USAREUR........................................... V Corps...................... Heidelberg, Germany.
USAREUR........................................... 7th Army Training Command.... Grafenwoehr, Germany.
USAREUR........................................... 26th Support Group........... Heidelberg, Germany.
Forces Command (FORSCOM).......................... U.S. Army Garrisons (USAGs).. Ft. Carson, CO; Ft.
McPherson, GA; Ft. Stewart,
GA; Ft. Riley, KS; Ft.
Campbell, KY; Ft.Polk, LA;
Ft. Bragg, NC; Ft. Hood, TX;
Ft. Dix, NJ; Ft. Drum, NY;
Ft. Lewis, WA; Ft. McCoy,
WI.
FORSCOM........................................... Reserve Command.............. All locations.
FORSCOM........................................... Signal Command............... Ft. Huachuca, Arizona and all
other locations.
FORSCOM........................................... First Army; Third Army; Fifth All locations.
Army.
US Military Academy............................... West Point (See Note 5)...... West Point, NY.
Military District of Washington................... 3rd U.S. Infantry; 12th All locations.
Aviation Battalion; Army
Signal Activity; Arlington
National Cemetery; Joint
Personal Property Shipping
Office; U.S. Army Band;
White House Transportation
Agency.
U.S. Army National Guard Bureau (ANGB)............ USPFO Activity (See Note 3).. All locations.
ANGB.............................................. State Area Command (See Note All locations.
3).
Southern Command.................................. U.S. Army Element, Miami, FL and all other
Headquarters Southern locations.
Command.
Recruiting Command................................ USA Recruiting Support Fort Knox, KY and all other
Battalions. locations.
Military Entrance Processing Command (MEPCOM)..... Headquarters, USA, MEPCOM.... North Chicago, IL.
Total Army Personnel Command...................... Information System Agency, St. Louis, MO.
Army Reserve Personnel
Center.
U.S. Army Pacific (USARPAC)....................... HQ, USARPAC; and subordinate All locations.
command/installations.
Office of the Secretary of the Army............... Immediate Office of the Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Secretary of the Army. all other locations.
Office of the Secretary of the Army............... Office of the Administrative Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Assistant to the Secretary all other locations.
of the Army.
Office of the Secretary of the Army............... Office of the Chief of Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Legislative Liaison. all other locations.
Office of the Secretary of the Army............... Office of Small and Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Disadvantaged Business all other locations.
Utilization.
Office of the Secretary of the Army............... Office of Director, Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Information Systems for all other locations.
Command Control,
Communications, and
Computers.
Field Operating Offices of the Office of the Army Broadcasting Service.... Alexandria, VA.
Secretary of the Army.
Field Operating Offices of the Office of the Cost and Economic Analysis Arlington, VA and all other
Secretary of the Army. Agency. locations.
[[Page 32098]]
Field Operating Offices of the Office of the Army Safety Center........... Ft. Rucker, AL and all other
Secretary of the Army. locations.
Field Operating Offices of the Office of the USA War College (See Note 5). Carlisle Barracks, PA and all
Secretary of the Army. other locations.
Field Operating Offices of the Office of the Communication Electronic Alexandria, VA and all other
Secretary of the Army. Service Office. locations.
Special Operations Command........................ Office of the Acquisition All locations.
Executive and all associated
PEOs and PMs.
Joint Activities.................................. Army Visual Information Pentagon, Arlington, VA and
Center. all other locations.
Joint Activities.................................. Defense Acquisition Ft. Belvoir, VA.
University (DUA) (See Note
5).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Navy
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Assistant Secretary of the Navy (Research, (ASN(RD&A)).................. Arlington, VA.
Development, and Acquisition).
Navy International Program Office (NIPO).......... NIPO......................... Arlington, VA.
Naval Supply Systems Command (NAVSUP)............. Fleet and Industrial Supply Bremerton, WA.
Center, Puget Sound.
NAVSUP............................................ Fleet and Industrial Supply San Diego, CA
Center.
Naval Sea Systems Command (NAVSEA)................ TEAM CX (Surface Ship Arlington, VA.
Directorate (SEA 91),
Program Executive Office
Aircraft Carriers, and
Program Executive Office
Expeditionary Warfare).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marine Corps
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marine Corps Systems Command (MARCORSYSCOM)....... Amphibious Vehicle Test Bed Camp Pendleton, CA.
(AVTB); Marine Corps
Tactical Systems Support
Activity (MCTSSA).
MARCORSYSCOM...................................... Headquarters, Marine Corps Albany, GA; Rock Island, IL;
Systems Command Picatinny Arsenal, NJ;
(MARCORSYSCOM); CSLE; Warren, MI; Quantico, VA.
Program Support Section.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office of the Secretary of Defense Office of the ATSD (NCB); DIR, Admin; DIR, Pentagon, Arlington, VA.
Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, API; DDR&E; DIR, DP; DSB;
Logistics, and Technology (USD(AT&L)). DUSD (ES); DUSD (AR); DUSD
(AT); DUSD (IA&I); DUSD
(I&CP); DUSD (L); DIR, S&TS;
DIR, TSE&E; Spec Prog; SADBU.
Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA). All (See Note 5)............. Arlington, VA.
Defense Logistics Agency.......................... All.......................... All locations.
Missile Defense Agency............................ All.......................... Arlington, VA.
Defense Contract Management Agency (DCMA)......... All.......................... All locations.
Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA)............ All.......................... Arlington, VA; Ft. Belvoir,
VA.
Defense Information Systems Agency................ PM DISN System Integration Falls Church, VA.
Project.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note 1: Includes all associated PMs and liaison representatives.
Note 2: Excludes Defense Civilian Intelligence Personnel System positions.
Note 3: Excludes positions covered by another demonstration project that is operating or under development
within DoD.
Note 4: Only title 5 National Guard Bureau positions are eligible to be included in this demonstration.
Note 5: Excludes Administratively Determined pay plan employees.
[[Page 32099]]
Table 1A--Eligible Organizations Updated and Approved in Calendar Year 2015
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOD component/DOD component major organizational
subdivision Organization/office symbol Locations
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AIR FORCE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Air Force Materiel Command (AFMC)................. Air Armament Complex (AAC)... Eglin AFB, FL and all other
locations.
AFMC.............................................. Air Force Life Cycle All locations.
Management Center.
AFMC.............................................. Air Force Test Center (AFTC). Edwards AFB, CA and all other
locations.
AFMC.............................................. Air Force Nuclear Weapons Kirtland AFB, NM.
Center.
AFMC.............................................. Air Force Sustainment Center. All locations.
Air Force Operational Test and Evaluation Center All.......................... Kirtland AFB, NM and all
(AFOTEC). other locations.
Miscellaneous Air Force........................... Contracting Organizations.... All locations.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NAVY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Naval Sea Systems Command (NAVSEA)................ Headquarters, Program All locations.
Executive Office (PEO)
Ships, PEO Subs, PEO LCS,
PEO IWS and PEO Carriers.
Naval Air Systems Command (NAVAIR)................ NAVAIR Headquarters and All locations.
associated PEO workforce.
Space and Naval Warfare Systems Command........... Headquarters and PEOs........ All locations.
Strategic Systems Programs (SSP).................. SSP.......................... Washington, DC (WNY) and all
locations.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Defense Acquisition University (DAU).............. Defense Acquisition All locations.
University (DAU) \13\.
Missile Defense Agency (MDA)...................... All.......................... All locations.
Defense Test Resource Management Center (DTRMC)... All.......................... Arlington, VA.
Washington Headquarters Services (WHS)............ Acquisition Directorate...... Arlington, VA.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOINT SERVICES
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. Special Operations Command................... Office of the Acquisition All locations.
Executive and all associated
PEOs and PMs.
U.S. Transportation Command....................... Office of the Acquisition All locations.
Executive and all associated
PEOs and PMs.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\ Excludes administratively determined pay plan employees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 32100]]
Appendix C
Information as of August 25, 2016
Series Included in the DoD Acquisition Workforce Personnel Demonstration
Project
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Occupational series
Occupational series No. title
------------------------------------------------------------------------
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT & TECHNICAL MANAGEMENT PROFESSIONAL (NH)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
0011.............................................. BOND SALES
PROMOTION.
0017.............................................. EXPLOSIVES SAFETY.
0018.............................................. SAFETY AND
OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH
MANAGEMENT.
0020.............................................. COMMUNITY PLANNING.
0023.............................................. OUTDOOR RECREATION
PLANNING.
0025.............................................. PARK RANGER.
0028.............................................. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION
SPECIALIST.
0030.............................................. SPORTS SPECIALIST.
0050.............................................. FUNERAL DIRECTING.
0062.............................................. CLOTHING DESIGN.
0072.............................................. FINGERPRINT
IDENTIFICATION.
0080.............................................. SECURITY
ADMINISTRATION.
0089.............................................. EMERGENCY
MANAGEMENT.
0095.............................................. FOREIGN LAW
SPECIALIST.
0099.............................................. GENERAL STUDENT
TRAINEE.
0101.............................................. SOCIAL SCIENCE.
0106.............................................. UNEMPLOYMENT
INSURANCE.
0110.............................................. ECONOMIST.
0130.............................................. FOREIGN AFFAIRS.
0131.............................................. INTERNATIONAL
RELATIONS.
0135.............................................. FOREIGN AGRICULTURAL
AFFAIRS.
0136.............................................. INTERNATIONAL
COOPERATION.
0140.............................................. WORKFORCE RESEARCH
AND ANALYSIS.
0142.............................................. WORKFORCE
DEVELOPMENT.
0150.............................................. GEOGRAPHY.
0160.............................................. CIVIL RIGHTS
ANALYSIS.
0170.............................................. HISTORY.
0180.............................................. PSYCHOLOGY.
0184.............................................. SOCIOLOGY.
0185.............................................. SOCIAL WORK.
0188.............................................. RECREATION
SPECIALIST.
0190.............................................. GENERAL
ANTHROPOLOGY.
0193.............................................. ARCHEOLOGY.
0199.............................................. SOCIAL SCIENCE
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0201.............................................. HUMAN RESOURCES
MANAGEMENT.
0241.............................................. MEDIATION.
0243.............................................. APPRENTICESHIP AND
TRAINING.
0244.............................................. LABOR MANAGEMENT
RELATIONS
EXAMINING.
0260.............................................. EQUAL EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITY.
0299.............................................. HUMAN RESOURCES
MANAGEMENT STUDENT
TRAINEE.
0301.............................................. MISCELLANEOUS
ADMINISTRATION AND
PROGRAM.
0306.............................................. GOVERNMENT
INFORMATION.
0308.............................................. RECORDS AND
INFORMATION
MANAGEMENT.
0340.............................................. PROGRAM MANAGEMENT.
0341.............................................. ADMINISTRATIVE
OFFICER.
0343.............................................. MANAGEMENT AND
PROGRAM ANALYSIS.
0346.............................................. LOGISTICS
MANAGEMENT.
0360.............................................. EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
COMPLIANCE.
0391.............................................. TELECOMMUNICATIONS.
0399.............................................. ADMINISTRATION AND
OFFICE SUPPORT
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0401.............................................. GENERAL NATURAL
RESOURCES MANAGMENT
AND BIOLOGICAL
SCIENCES.
0403.............................................. MICROBIOLOGY.
0405.............................................. PHARMACOLOGY.
0408.............................................. ECOLOGY.
0410.............................................. ZOOLOGY.
0413.............................................. PHYSIOLOGY.
0414.............................................. ENTOMOLOGY.
0415.............................................. TOXICOLOGY.
0430.............................................. BOTANY.
0434.............................................. PLANT PATHOLOGY.
0435.............................................. PLANT PHYSIOLOGY.
0437.............................................. HORTICULTURE.
0440.............................................. GENETICS.
0454.............................................. RANGELAND
MANAGEMENT.
0457.............................................. SOIL CONSERVATION.
0460.............................................. FORESTRY.
0470.............................................. SOIL SCIENCE.
[[Page 32101]]
0471.............................................. AGRONOMY.
0480.............................................. FISH AND WILDLIFE
ADMINISTRATION.
0482.............................................. FISH BIOLOGY.
0485.............................................. WILDLIFE REFUGE
MANAGEMENT.
0486.............................................. WILDLIFE BIOLOGY.
0487.............................................. ANIMAL SCIENCE.
0499.............................................. BIOLOGICAL SCIENCE
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0501.............................................. FINANCIAL
ADMINISTRATION AND
PROGRAM.
0505.............................................. FINANICIAL
MANAGEMENT.
0510.............................................. ACCOUNTING.
0511.............................................. AUDITING.
0512.............................................. INTERNAL REVENUE
AGENT.
0526.............................................. TAX SPECIALIST.
0560.............................................. BUDGET ANALYSIS.
0599.............................................. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0601.............................................. GENERAL HEALTH
SCIENCE.
0602.............................................. MEDICAL OFFICER.
0603.............................................. PHYSICIAN ASSISTANT.
0610.............................................. NURSE.
0630.............................................. DIETICIAN AND
NUTRITIONIST.
0631.............................................. OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPIST.
0633.............................................. PHYSICAL THERAPIST.
0635.............................................. KINESIOTHERAPY
THERAPIST.
0637.............................................. MANUAL ARTS
THERAPIST.
0639.............................................. EDUCATIONAL
THERAPIST.
0644.............................................. MEDICAL
TECHNOLOGIST.
0660.............................................. PHARMACIST.
0662.............................................. OPTOMETRIST.
0665.............................................. SPEECH PATHOLOGY AND
AUDIOLOGY.
0668.............................................. PODIATRIST.
0669.............................................. MEDICAL RECORDS
ADMINISTRATION.
0671.............................................. HEALTH SYSTEMS
SPECIALIST.
0680.............................................. DENTAL OFFICER.
0690.............................................. INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE.
0699.............................................. MEDICAL AND HEALTH
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0701.............................................. VETERINARY MEDICAL
SCIENCE.
0799.............................................. VETERINARY STUDENT
TRAINEE.
0801.............................................. GENERAL ENGINEERING.
0803.............................................. SAFETY ENGINEERING.
0804.............................................. FIRE PROTECTION
ENGINEERING.
0806.............................................. MATERIALS
ENGINEERING.
0807.............................................. LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE.
0808.............................................. ARCHITECTURE.
0810.............................................. CIVIL ENGINEERING.
0819.............................................. ENVIRONMENTAL
ENGINEERING.
0830.............................................. MECHANICAL
ENGINEERING.
0840.............................................. NUCLEAR ENGINEERING.
0850.............................................. ELECTRICAL
ENGINEERING.
0854.............................................. COMPUTER
ENGINEERING.
0855.............................................. ELECTRONICS
ENGINEERING.
0858.............................................. BIOMEDICAL
ENGINEERING.
0861.............................................. AEROSPACE
ENGINEERING.
0871.............................................. NAVAL ARCHITECTURE.
0880.............................................. MINING ENGINEERING.
0881.............................................. PETROLEUM
ENGINEERING.
0890.............................................. AGRICULTURAL
ENGINEERING.
0893.............................................. CHEMICAL
ENGINEERING.
0896.............................................. INDUSTRIAL ENGINEER.
0899.............................................. ENGINEERING AND
ARCHITECTURE
STUDENT TRAINEE.
0901.............................................. GENERAL LEGAL AND
KINDRED
ADMINISTRATION.
0904.............................................. LAW CLERK.
0905.............................................. GENERAL ATTORNEY.
0950.............................................. PARALEGAL
SPECIALIST.
0958.............................................. EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
LAW.
0965.............................................. LAND LAW EXAMINING.
0967.............................................. PASSPORT AND VISA
EXAMINING.
0987.............................................. TAX LAW SPECIALIST.
0991.............................................. WORKERS'
COMPENSATION CLAIMS
EXAMINING.
0993.............................................. RAILROAD RETIREMENT
CLAIMS EXAMINING.
0996.............................................. VETERANS CLAIMS
EXAMINING.
0999.............................................. LEGAL OCCUPATIONS
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1001.............................................. GENERAL ARTS AND
INFORMATION.
[[Page 32102]]
1008.............................................. INTERIOR DESIGN.
1010.............................................. EXHIBITS SPECIALIST.
1015.............................................. MUSEUM CURATOR.
1016.............................................. MUSEUM SPECIALIST.
1020.............................................. ILLUSTRATOR.
1035.............................................. PUBLIC AFFAIRS.
1040.............................................. LANGUAGE SPECIALIST.
1056.............................................. ART SPECIALIST.
1060.............................................. PHOTOGRAPHY.
1071.............................................. AUDIOVISUAL
PRODUCTION.
1082.............................................. WRITING AND EDITING.
1083.............................................. TECHNICAL WRITING
AND EDITING.
1084.............................................. VISUAL INFORMATION.
1099.............................................. INFORMATION AND ARTS
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1101.............................................. GENERAL BUSINESS AND
INDUSTRY.
1102.............................................. CONTRACTING.
1103.............................................. INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY
MANAGEMENT.
1104.............................................. PROPERTY DISPOSAL.
1109.............................................. GRANTS MANAGEMENT.
1130.............................................. PUBLIC UTILITIES
SPECIALIST.
1140.............................................. TRADE SPECIALIST.
1144.............................................. COMMISSARY
MANAGEMENT.
1145.............................................. AGRICULTURE PROGRAM
SPECIALIST.
1146.............................................. AGRICULTURAL
MARKETING.
1147.............................................. AGRICULTURAL MARKET
REPORTING.
1150.............................................. INDUSTRIAL
SPECIALIST.
1160.............................................. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS.
1163.............................................. INSURANCE EXAMINING.
1165.............................................. LOAN SPECIALIST.
1169.............................................. INTERNAL REVENUE
OFFICER.
1170.............................................. REALTY.
1171.............................................. APPRAISING.
1173.............................................. HOUSING MANAGEMENT.
1176.............................................. BUILDING MANAGEMENT.
1199.............................................. BUSINESS AND
INDUSTRY STUDENT
TRAINEE.
1210.............................................. COPYRIGHT.
1220.............................................. PATENT
ADMINISTRATION.
1221.............................................. PATENT ADVISER.
1222.............................................. PATENT ATTORNEY.
1223.............................................. PATENT CLASSIFYING.
1224.............................................. PATENT EXAMINING.
1226.............................................. DESIGN PATENT
EXAMINING.
1299.............................................. COPYRIGHT AND PATENT
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1301.............................................. GENERAL PHYSICAL
SCIENCE.
1306.............................................. HEALTH PHYSICS.
1310.............................................. PHYSICS.
1313.............................................. GEOPHYSICS.
1315.............................................. HYDROLOGY.
1320.............................................. CHEMISTRY.
1321.............................................. METALLURGY.
1330.............................................. ASTRONOMY AND SPACE
SCIENCE.
1340.............................................. METEOROLOGY.
1350.............................................. GEOLOGY.
1360.............................................. OCEANOGRAPHY.
1370.............................................. CARTOGRAPHY.
1372.............................................. GEODESY.
1373.............................................. LAND SURVEYING.
1380.............................................. FOREST PRODUCTS
TECHNOLOGY.
1382.............................................. FOOD TECHNOLOGY.
1384.............................................. TEXTILE TECHNOLOGY.
1386.............................................. PHOTOGRAPHIC
TECHNOLOGY.
1397.............................................. DOCUMENT ANALYSIS.
1399.............................................. PHYSICAL SCIENCE
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1410.............................................. LIBRARIAN.
1412.............................................. TECHNICAL
INFORMATION
SERVICES.
1420.............................................. ARCHIVIST.
1499.............................................. LIBRARY AND ARCHIVES
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1501.............................................. GENERAL MATHEMATICS.
1510.............................................. ACTUARIAL SCIENCE.
1515.............................................. OPERATIONS RESEARCH.
1520.............................................. MATHEMATICS.
1529.............................................. MATHEMATICAL
STATISTICS.
[[Page 32103]]
1530.............................................. STATISTICS.
1540.............................................. CRYPTOGRAPHY.
1541.............................................. CRYPTANALYSIS.
1550.............................................. COMPUTER SCIENCE.
1599.............................................. MATHEMATICS AND
STATISTICS STUDENT
TRAINEE.
1601.............................................. EQUIPMENT,
FACILITIES, AND
SERVICES.
1630.............................................. CEMETARY
ADMINISTRATION
SERVICES.
1640.............................................. FACILITY OPERATIONS
SERVICES.
1654.............................................. PRINTING SERVICES.
1667.............................................. FOOD SERVICES.
1670.............................................. EQUIPMENT SERVICES.
1699.............................................. EQUIPMENT,
FACILITIES, AND
SERVICES STUDENT
TRAINEE.
1701.............................................. GENERAL EDUCATION
AND TRAINING.
1702.............................................. EDUCATION AND
TRAINING.
1710.............................................. EDUCATION AND
VOCATIONAL
TRAINING.
1712.............................................. TRAINING
INSTRUCTION.
1715.............................................. VOCATIONAL
REHABILITATION.
1720.............................................. EDUCATION PROGRAM.
1725.............................................. PUBLIC HEALTH
EDUCATOR.
1730.............................................. EDUCATION RESEARCH.
1740.............................................. EDUCATION SERVICES.
1750.............................................. INSTRUCTIONAL
SYSTEMS.
1799.............................................. EDUCATION STUDENT
TRAINEE.
1801.............................................. GENERAL INSPECTION,
INVESTIGATION,
ENFORCEMENT, AND
COMPLIANCE.
1802.............................................. COMPLIANCE
INSPECTION AND
SUPPORT.
1810.............................................. GENERAL
INVESTIGATION.
1822.............................................. MINE SAFETY AND
HEALTH INSPECTION.
1825.............................................. AVIATION SAFETY.
1849.............................................. WAGE AND HOUR
INVESTIGATION.
1862.............................................. CONSUMER SAFETY
INSPECTION.
1863.............................................. FOOD INSPECTION.
1889.............................................. IMPORT COMPLIANCE.
1895.............................................. CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION.
1899.............................................. INVESTIGATION
STUDENT TRAINEE.
1910.............................................. QUALITY ASSURANCE.
1980.............................................. AGRICULTURAL
COMMODITY GRADING.
1999.............................................. QUALITY INSPECTION
STUDENT TRAINEE.
2001.............................................. GENERAL SUPPLY.
2003.............................................. SUPPLY PROGRAM
MANAGEMENT.
2010.............................................. INVENTORY
MANAGEMENT.
2030.............................................. DISTRIBUTION
FACILITIES AND
STORAGE MANAGEMENT.
2032.............................................. PACKAGING.
2099.............................................. SUPPLY STUDENT
TRAINEE.
2101.............................................. TRANSPORTATION
SPECIALIST.
2110.............................................. TRANSPORTATION
INDUSTRY ANALYSIS.
2121.............................................. RAILROAD SAFETY.
2123.............................................. MOTOR CARRIER
SAFETY.
2125.............................................. HIGHWAY SAFETY.
2130.............................................. TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT.
2150.............................................. TRANSPORTATION
OPERATIONS.
2152.............................................. AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL.
2161.............................................. MARINE CARGO.
2181.............................................. AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS.
2183.............................................. AIR NAVIGATION.
2199.............................................. TRANSPORTATION
STUDENT TRAINEE.
2210.............................................. INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY
MANAGEMENT.
2299.............................................. INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY STUDENT
TRAINEE.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
TECHNICAL MANAGEMENT SUPPORT (NJ)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
0019.............................................. SAFETY TECHNICIAN.
0021.............................................. COMMUNITY PLANNING
TECHNICIAN.
0102.............................................. SOCIAL SCIENCE AID
AND TECHNICIAN.
0181.............................................. PSYCHOLOGY AID AND
TECHNICIAN.
0187.............................................. SOCIAL SERVICES.
0332.............................................. COMPUTER OPERATION.
0342.............................................. SUPPORT SERVICES
ADMINISTRATION.
0390.............................................. TELECOMMUNICATIONS
PROCESSING.
0392.............................................. GENERAL
TELECOMMUNICATIONS.
0404.............................................. BIOLOGICAL SCIENCE
TECHNICIAN.
0421.............................................. PLANT PROTECTION
TECHNICIAN.
0455.............................................. RANGE TECHNICIAN.
[[Page 32104]]
0458.............................................. SOIL CONSERVATION
TECHNICIAN.
0459.............................................. IRRIGATION SYSTEM
OPERATION.
0462.............................................. FORESTRY TECHNICIAN.
0592.............................................. TAX EXAMINING.
0620.............................................. PRACTICAL NURSE.
0621.............................................. NURSING ASSISTANT.
0622.............................................. MEDICAL SUPPLY AIDE
AND TECHNICIAN.
0625.............................................. AUTOPSY ASSISTANT.
0646.............................................. PATHOLOGY
TECHNICIAN.
0647.............................................. DIAGNOSTIC
RADIOLOGIC
TECHNOLOGIST.
0648.............................................. THERAPEUTIC
RADIOLOGIC
TECHNOLOGIST.
0649.............................................. MEDICAL INSTRUMENT
TECHNICIAN.
0650.............................................. MEDICAL TECHNICAL
ASSISTANT.
0664.............................................. RESTORATION
TECHNICIAN.
0667.............................................. ORTHOTIST AND
PROSTHETIST.
0672.............................................. PROSTHETIC
REPRESENTATIVE.
0675.............................................. MEDICAL RECORDS
TECHNICIAN.
0679.............................................. MEDICAL SUPPORT
ASSISTANCE.
0681.............................................. DENTAL ASSISTANT.
0698.............................................. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
TECHNICIAN.
0802.............................................. ENGINEERING
TECHNICAL.
0809.............................................. CONSTRUCTION CONTROL
TECHNICAL.
0817.............................................. SURVEY TECHNICAL.
0818.............................................. ENGINEERING
DRAFTING.
0856.............................................. ELECTRONICS
TECHNICAL.
0873.............................................. MARINE SURVEY
TECHNICAL.
0895.............................................. INDUSTRIAL
ENGINEERING
TECHNICAL.
0962.............................................. CONTACT
REPRESENTATIVE.
0963.............................................. LEGAL INSTRUMENTS
EXAMINING.
0990.............................................. GENERAL CLAIMS
EXAMINING.
0992.............................................. LOSS AND DAMAGE
CLAIMS EXAMINING.
0995.............................................. DEPENDENT AND
ESTATES CLAIMS
EXAMINING.
1016.............................................. MUSEUM AID AND
TECHNICIAN.
1152.............................................. PRODUCTION CONTROL.
1202.............................................. PATENT TECHNICIAN.
1211.............................................. COPYRIGHT
TECHNICIAN.
1311.............................................. PHYSICAL SCIENCE
TECHNICIAN.
1316.............................................. HYDROLOGIC
TECHNICIAN.
1341.............................................. METEOROLOGICAL
TECHNICIAN.
1371.............................................. CARTOGRAPHIC
TECHNICIAN.
1374.............................................. GEODETIC TECHNICIAN.
1411.............................................. LIBRARY TECHNICIAN.
1421.............................................. ARCHIVES TECHNICIAN.
1521.............................................. MATHEMATICS
TECHNICIAN.
1531.............................................. STATISTICAL
ASSISTANT.
1658.............................................. LAUNDRY OPERATIONS.
1702.............................................. EDUCATION AND
TRAINING
TECHNICIAN.
2005.............................................. SUPPLY CLERICAL AND
TECHNICIAN.
2185.............................................. AIRCREW TECHNICIAN.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT (NK)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
0029.............................................. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION
ASSISTANT.
0085.............................................. SECURITY GUARD.
0086.............................................. SECURITY CLERICAL
AND ASSISTANCE.
0105.............................................. SOCIAL INSURANCE
ADMINISTRATION.
0107.............................................. HEALTH INSURANCE
ADMINISTRATION.
0119.............................................. ECONOMICS ASSISTANT.
0186.............................................. SOCIAL SERVICES AID
AND ASSISTANCE.
0189.............................................. RECREATION AID AND
ASSISTANCE.
0203.............................................. HUMAN RESOURCES
ASSISTANCE.
0204.............................................. MILITARY PERSONNEL
CLERICAL AND
TECHNICIAN.
0303.............................................. MISCELLANEOUS CLERK
AND ASSISTANT.
0304.............................................. INFORMATION
RECEPTIONIST.
0305.............................................. MAIL AND FILE.
0309.............................................. CORRESPONDENCE
CLERK.
0313.............................................. WORK UNIT
SUPERVISING.
0318.............................................. SECRETARY.
0319.............................................. CLOSED MICROPHONE
REPORTING.
0322.............................................. CLERK-TYPIST.
0326.............................................. OFFICE AUTOMATION
CLERICAL AND
ASSISTANCE.
0335.............................................. COMPUTER CLERK AND
ASSISTANCE.
[[Page 32105]]
0344.............................................. MANAGEMENT AND
PROGRAM CLERICAL
AND ASSISTANCE.
0350.............................................. EQUIPMENT OPERATOR.
0356.............................................. DATA TRANSCRIBER.
0357.............................................. CODING.
0361.............................................. EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
ASSISTANCE.
0382.............................................. TELEPHONE OPERATING.
0394.............................................. COMMUNICATIONS
CLERICAL.
0503.............................................. FINANICIAL CLERICAL
AND TECHNICIAN.
0525.............................................. ACCOUNTING
TECHNICIAN.
0530.............................................. CASH PROCESSING.
0540.............................................. VOUCHER EXAMINING.
0544.............................................. CIVILIAN PAY.
0545.............................................. MILITARY PAY.
0561.............................................. BUDGET CLERICAL AND
ASSISTANCE.
0986.............................................. LEGAL ASSISTANCE.
0998.............................................. CLAIMS ASSISTANCE
AND EXAMINING.
1016.............................................. MUSEUM AID.
1087.............................................. EDITORIAL
ASSISTANCE.
1105.............................................. PURCHASING.
1106.............................................. PROCUREMENT CLERICAL
AND TECHNICIAN.
1107.............................................. PROPERTY DISPOSAL
CLERICAL AND
TECHNICIAN.
1603.............................................. EQUIPMENT,
FACILITIES, AND
SERVICES
ASSISTANCE.
2091.............................................. SALES STORE
CLERICAL.
2102.............................................. TRANSPORTATION CLERK
AND ASSISTANT.
2131.............................................. FREIGHT RATE.
2135.............................................. TRANSPORTATION LOSS
AND DAMAGE CLAIMS
EXAMINING.
2144.............................................. CARGO SCHEDULING.
2151.............................................. DISPATCHING.
2154.............................................. AIR TRAFFIC
ASSISTANCE.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix D
Definitions of Career Paths and Corresponding Broadband Levels
Career Path: Business Management and Technical Management Professional
Includes professional and management positions in science,
engineering, medicine, and business management. These positions
often have positive degree requirements.
Level I. Includes student trainees. Education and employment
must be part of a formal student employment program. Specific, clear
and detailed instructions and supervision are given. The level of
education and experience completed is a major consideration in
establishing the level of on-the-job training and work assignments.
Level II. This is the entry or developmental stage, preparing
employees for the full and independent performance of their work.
Specific, clear, and detailed instructions and supervision are given
upon entry; recurring assignments are carried out independently.
Conducts successive activities with objectives and priorities
identified by supervisor or team leader; assistance given on new or
unusual projects or situations. Finished work is reviewed to ensure
accuracy and technical soundness.
Level III. This is the advanced developmental/target career
level of this career path. Employee plans and carries out
assignments independently; conceives and defines solutions to highly
complex problems; analyzes, interprets, and reports findings of
projects; and guides technical and programmatic work of team members
in comparable junior grades. Completed work and reports are reviewed
for feasibility, compatibility with other work or effectiveness in
meeting requirements or expected results.
Level IV. Professionals at this level are experts within their
functional areas; heads of branches or divisions; or key program
administrators. Conducts or directs activities or assists higher
levels on challenging and innovative program development with only
general guidance on policy, resources and planning; develops
solutions to highly complex problems requiring various disciplines;
responsible for fulfilling program objectives. Results are
authoritative and impact programs or the well-being of substantial
numbers of people.
Career Path: Technical Management Support
Includes nonprofessional positions that support science and
engineering activities through application of various skills in
areas such as the following: Engineering, physical, chemical,
biological, medical, and mathematical sciences.
Level I. This includes trainees who develop technical support
knowledge through actual work experience. Performs repetitive tasks
using knowledge of standardized procedures and operations. Receives
specific, clear and detailed instruction and supervision. Completed
work is reviewed for technical soundness.
Level II. Technicians at this level require a practical
knowledge of standard procedures in a technical field. Skill in
applying knowledge of basic principles, concepts, and methodology of
occupational and/or technical methods is required. Carries out
prescribed procedures and relies heavily on precedent methods. Work
is reviewed for technical adequacy and accuracy, and adherence to
instructions.
Level III. This is the advanced developmental level of this
career path, requiring extensive training or experience. Work
requires some adapting of existing precedents or techniques.
Receives outline of objectives desired and description of operating
characteristics and theory involved. Completed assignments are
reviewed for compliance with instructions, adequacy, judgment, and
satisfaction of requirements.
Level IV. Technicians at this level are considered to have
professional level knowledge of a specific field. Receives general
guidance on overall objectives and resources. Conceives, recommends,
and tests new techniques or methods. Completed work is reviewed for
overall soundness and compliance with overall project objectives.
Career Path: Administrative Support
Includes clerical, secretarial and assistant work in
nonscientific/engineering occupations.
Level I. This entry level, which includes student trainees as
well as others with some experience, requires a fundamental
knowledge of clerical/administrative field. Developmental
assignments may be given which lead to duties at a higher group
level. Performs repetitive tasks; specific, clear, and detailed
instruction and supervision; with more experience utilizes knowledge
of standardized procedures and operations. Assistance is given on
new or unusual projects. Completed work is reviewed for technical
soundness.
[[Page 32106]]
Level II. This is the journey level that requires knowledge of
standardized rules, procedures or operations requiring considerable
training. General guidance is received on overall objectives and
resources. Completed assignments may be reviewed for overall
soundness or meeting expected results.
Level III. This is the senior level that requires knowledge of
extensive procedures and operations requiring extensive training.
Receives general guidance on overall resources and objectives.
Skilled in applying knowledge of basic principles, concepts and
methodology of administrative occupation and/or technical methods.
Results are accepted as authoritative and normally without
significant change.
BILLING CODE 5001-06-P
[[Page 32107]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.005
[[Page 32108]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.006
[[Page 32109]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.007
[[Page 32110]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.008
[[Page 32111]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.009
[[Page 32112]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.010
[[Page 32113]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.011
[[Page 32114]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.012
[[Page 32115]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.013
[[Page 32116]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.014
BILLING CODE 5001-06-C
[[Page 32117]]
Appendix F
Intervention Impact Evaluation Model
DoD Civilian Acquisition Workforce Personnel Management
Demonstration Project
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Intervention Expected effects Measures Data sources
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. COMPENSATION
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Broadbanding...................... Increased Perceived flexibility.. Attitude
organizational survey.
flexibility, i.e., Focus groups.
simplified assignment,
pay setting.
Reduced administrative Actual/perceived time Personnel office data,
workload, paperwork savings. program management
reduction. evaluation (PME)
results, attitude
survey.
b. Maximum Broadband Level........... Higher starting basic Starting basic pay of Workforce data.
pay. banded v. non-banded
employees.
c. Accelerated Compensation for More gradual basic pay Progression of new Workforce data.
Developmental Positions. progression at entry hires over time by
levels. broadband, career
path, scores, deltas.
Increased basic pay Mean salaries Workforce
potential. by broadband, career data.
path and demographics.
Total payroll Personnel
costs. office data.
Increased satisfaction Employee perceptions of Attitude survey.
with advancement. advancement.
Increased basic pay Basic pay satisfaction, Attitude survey.
satisfaction. internal/external
equity.
Improved recruitment of Offer, acceptance, Personnel office data.
interns and recent declination, retention
graduates. ratios.
d. Student Intern Relocation Greater ability to hire Offer/ Personnel office data.
Incentive. students attending acceptance ratios.
colleges in different Percent
geographical locations. declinations..
Elevated quality of Perceived Attitude
hires. quality of candidates/ survey, focus groups,
hire, i.e., selecting official
experience, skills, interviews.
education.
First offer Personnel
accepted. office data.
Grade point Personnel
averages. office data.
Educational Personnel
levels. office data.
e. Conversion Buy-ins................ Employee acceptance.... Employee Attitude
perceptions of equity, survey.
fairness.
Cost as a Workforce
percent of payroll. data.
f. Supervisory and Team Leader Cash Increased Perceived Attitude
Differentials. incentive to accept motivational power. survey.
supervisory or team
leader positions.
Improved Offer, Personnel
recruitment and acceptance, retention office data.
retention of ratios.
supervisors and team
leaders.
Flatter Supervisory/ Workforce
organization. non-supervisory ratios. data.
Improved Employee Attitude
quality of supervisory perceptions of quality survey, focus groups.
staff. of supervisory and
team leader staff.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. CONTRIBUTION/PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. AcqDemo Contribution Rating Reward/motivate Perceived motivational Attitude survey.
Awards; Title 5 Special Act Awards, contribution. power. Workforce
Honorary Awards, and Other Title 5 To support fair and Amount and data.
Awards, e.g., Time-Off. appropriate number of awards by
distribution of awards. type, demographics.
Perceived Attitude
fairness of awards. survey.
Satisfaction Attitude
with monetary and non- survey.
monetary awards.
b. Contribution-based Basic Pay Increased basic pay/ Perceived Attitude
Progression. contribution- basic pay/contribution- survey.
performance link. performance link.
Perceived Attitude
fairness of scoring. survey.
Improved contribution/ Satisfaction Attitude
performance feedback. with scoring. survey.
Employee trust Attitude
in supervisors/pay survey.
pool panels.
Adequacy of Attitude
contribution/ survey.
performance feedback.
[[Page 32118]]
Decreased turnover of Turnover by integrated Workforce data.
employees scoring in pay schedule
normal or compensation
undercompensated categories.
categories/Increased
turnover of employees
scoring in
overcompensated
category.
Alignment of Linkage of contribution Contribution
organizational and expectations and plans.
individual objectives to Strategic
contribution strategic plans' goals. Plans.
expectations,
objectives, and
results.
Increased employee Perceived Attitude
involvement in involvement. survey/focus groups.
contribution planning Contribution Personnel/Demo
and assessment. management. regulations.
c. New Appraisal Process: Reduce administrative Employee and supervisor Attitude survey.
Contribution-based Compensation and burden. perceptions of revised
Appraisal System (CCAS). procedures.
Improved communication. Perceived fairness of Focus groups.
process.
d. Contribution Plan Development..... Better communication of Feedback and coaching Focus groups.
contribution procedures used. Personnel
expectations, office data.
performance
requirements, and
objectives.
Improved satisfaction Perceived workforce Attitude
and quality of quality. survey.
workforce. Focus groups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. POSITION CLASSIFICATION
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Improved Classification System Reduction in amount of Time spent on Personnel
with Generic Standards. time and paperwork classification office data.
spent on procedures. Personnel
classification. Reduction of office data.
paperwork/number of
personnel actions
(classification--promo
tion, change to lower
broadband level).
Simplified, automated Adaptable to Personnel
classification changes; number of office data.
applications and system change requests. Focus groups,
procedures. Ready access; surveys.
number and length of Personnel
down times. office data.
Easy to use; AcqDemo
number of user Program Office data.
inquiries.
Ease of Use............ Factors, Attitude
descriptors, and survey.
discriminators easy to Focus groups.
decipher and apply to
various positions at
different
organizational levels.
Perception of Attitude
managers, supervisors, survey.
administrative Focus groups.
personnel, and HR
specialists of time
savings, ease of use.
Number of Personnel
employee office data.
classification appeals.
b. Delegation of Classification Increased supervisory Perceived authority.... Attitude survey.
Authority. authority and
accountability.
Decreased conflict Number of Personnel
between management and classification records.
human resources staff. disputes/appeals pre-
and post-conversion.
Management Attitude.
satisfaction with
service provided by
the HR Office.
No negative impact on Internal pay equity.... Personnel
internal pay equity. records.
Attitude
survey.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. REDUCTION-IN-FORCE (RIF) PROCEDURES
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Modified RIF...................... Minimize loss of high Separated Workforce
contributing employees. employees by data.
demographics, overall Attitude
contribution score survey and focus
deltas, and integrated groups.
pay schedule
compensation regions.
Satisfaction Attitude
with RIF process. survey and focus
groups.
Contain cost and Cost Personnel/
disruption. comparisons of Budget Office data.
traditional vs.
modified RIF.
Number and Personnel
cost of separation office data.
incentives.
Time to Personnel
conduct RIF. office data.
Number of Personnel
employees affected. office data.
[[Page 32119]]
Number of Personnel
employees outplaced. office data.
Number of Personnel
appeals/reinstatements. office data.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. HIRING AUTHORITIES
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Direct Hire for the Business and Improved ease and Perceived Attitude
Technical Management Professional timeliness of hiring flexibility in survey.
Career Path positions. process. authority to hire. Personnel
Shortened office data.
timeline from
initiation of action
to firm offer letter/
EOD.
b. Veteran Direct Hire Appointments Improved recruitment of Offer/ Personnel
for the Business and Technical employees for shortage acceptance ratios. office data.
Management Professional Career Path category positions. Percent Personnel
and Technical Management Support declinations. office data.
Career. Timeliness of Personnel
job offers. office data.
Elevated quality of Perceived Attitude
hires. quality of candidates/ survey, focus groups,
hire, i.e., selecting official
experience, skills, interviews.
education.
First offer Personnel
accepted. office data.
Grade point Personnel
averages. office data.
Educational Personnel
levels. office data.
Reduced administrative Actual Personnel
workload/paperwork efficiencies and office data.
reduction. perceived skills. Attitude
survey, focus groups.
c. Acquisition Student Intern Hiring Improved recruitment of Offer/ Personnel
Authority. employees for AWF acceptance ratios. office data.
d. Scholastic Achievement Appointment positions. Percent Personnel
declinations. office data.
Timeliness of Personnel
job offers. office data.
Elevated quality of Perceived Attitude
hires. quality of candidates/ survey, focus groups,
hire, i.e., selecting official
experience, skills, interviews.
education.
First offer Personnel
accepted. office data.
Grade point Personnel
averages. office data.
Educational Personnel
levels. office data.
e. Simplified Accelerated Processes: Improved ease and Perceived Attitude
Name Request, Rule of Many, and List timeliness of hiring flexibility in survey.
or Certificate of Eligibles.. process. authority to hire. Personnel
Shortened office data.
timeline from
initiation of action
to firm offer letter/
EOD.
Improved recruitment of Offer/ Personnel
employees for AWF and acceptance ratios. office data.
direct support Percent Personnel
positions. declinations. office data.
Timeliness of Personnel
job offers. office data.
Elevated quality of Perceived Attitude
hires. quality of candidates/ survey, focus groups,
hire, i.e., selecting official
experience, skills, interviews.
education.
First offer Personnel
accepted. office data.
Grade point Personnel
averages. office data.
Educational Personnel
levels. office data.
Reduced administrative Actual Personnel
workload/paperwork efficiencies and office data.
reduction. perceived skills. Attitude
survey, focus groups.
f. Term Appointment Authority........ Increased capability to Number and Workforce
expand and contract length of appointments data.
workforce. by type of position. Personnel
office data.
Number/ Personnel
percentage of office data.
conversions from
modified term to
permanent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. STAFFING
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Expanded Detail and Temporary Increased capability to Number and Workforce
Promotion to Higher Broadband Level. expand and contract length of details and data.
workforce. temporary promotions
by type of position.
Number of Personnel
recipients receiving office data.
permanent promotions.
Demographics Personnel
of recipients. office data.
Increased ability to Number and Workforce
provide extended length of details and data.
developmental temporary promotions Personnel
assignments. by developmental office data.
assignment.
Demographics Personnel
of recipients. office data.
Realized Personnel
career growth. office data.
[[Page 32120]]
b. Voluntary Emeritus Program........ Encourages retirees to Frequency of Personnel
mentor junior use, length of office data.
professionals or serve assignment, type and
as consultants. level of position,
hours/days worked,
typical salary for
position.
Cost savings Personnel
by virtue of volunteer office data.
service.
Volunteer and Attitude
management survey, focus group,
satisfaction. interviews.
Participation
by non-AcqDemo
participants.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. EXPANDED DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. Sabbaticals....................... Expanded range of Number and Workforce
professional growth type of opportunities data.
and development. taken.
Demographics Personnel
of participants. office data.
Increased Workforce
employee career data.
progression. Personnel
Employee and office data.
management Attitude
satisfaction. survey.
Application of enhanced Employee and supervisor Focus groups,
knowledge and skills perceptions. interviews, attitude
to work product, survey.
contribution
expectations.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. COMBINATION OF ALL INTERVENTIONS
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a. All............................... Improved organizational Combination of All data sources.
effectiveness. personnel measures.
Improved management of Employee/Management job Attitude survey.
workforce. satisfaction
(intrinsic/extrinsic).
Improved planning...... Planning Strategic
procedures. planning documents.
Perceived Attitude
effectiveness of survey.
planning procedures.
Improved cross Actual/perceived Organizational charts.
functional coordination.
coordination.
Increased product Customer satisfaction.. Customer satisfaction
success. surveys.
Cost of demonstration Project training/ Demo Program
project innovation. developmental costs Office records.
(staff salaries, Contract
contract cost, documents.
training hours per
employee).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BILLING CODE 5001-06-P
[[Page 32121]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN11JY17.015
[FR Doc. 2017-14251 Filed 7-10-17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 5001-06-C