[Federal Register Volume 81, Number 242 (Friday, December 16, 2016)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 90997-91012]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2016-30421]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Part 91
[Docket No. FR 5891-F-02]
RIN 2506-AC41
Modernizing HUD's Consolidated Planning Process To Narrow the
Digital Divide and Increase Resilience to Natural Hazards
AGENCY: Office of the Assistant Secretary for Community Planning and
Development, HUD.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: HUD's Consolidated Plan is a planning mechanism designed to
help States and local governments to assess their affordable housing
and community development needs and to make data-driven, place-based
investment decisions. The Consolidated Planning process serves as the
framework for a community-wide dialogue to identify housing and
community development priorities that align and focus funding from
HUD's formula block grant programs. This rule amends HUD's Consolidated
Plan regulations to require that jurisdictions consider two additional
concepts in their planning efforts.
The first concept is how to address the need for broadband access
for low- and moderate-income residents in the communities they serve.
Broadband is the common term used to refer to a high-speed, always-on
connection to the Internet. Such connection is also referred to as
high-speed broadband or high-speed Internet. Specifically, the rule
requires that States and localities that submit a Consolidated Plan
describe the broadband access in housing occupied by low- and moderate-
income households. If low-income residents in the communities do not
have such access, States and jurisdictions must consider providing
broadband access to these residents in their decisions on how to invest
HUD funds. The second concept added to the Consolidated Plan process
requires jurisdictions to consider incorporating resilience to natural
hazard risks, taking care to anticipate how risks will increase due to
climate change, into development of the plan in order to begin
addressing impacts of climate change on low- and moderate-income
residents.
DATES: Effective Date: January 17, 2017.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Lora Routt, Senior Advisor, Office of
Community Planning and Development, Department of Housing and Urban
Development, Office of Community Planning and Development, 451 7th
Street SW., Suite 7204, Washington, DC 20410 at 202-402-4492 (this is
not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech or hearing impairments
may access this number via TTY by calling the Federal Relay Service at
800-877-8339 (this is a toll-free number).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Executive Summary
A. Purpose of This Rule
The purpose of this rule is to require States and local governments
to evaluate the availability of broadband access and the vulnerability
of housing occupied by low- and moderate income households to natural
hazard risks, many of which may be increasing due to climate change, in
their Consolidated Planning efforts. These evaluations are to be
conducted using readily available data sources developed by Federal
government agencies, other available data and analyses (including
State, Tribal, and local hazard mitigation plans that have been
approved by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)), and data
that State and local government grantees may have available to them.
Where access to broadband Internet service is not currently available
or is minimally available (such as in certain rural areas), States and
local governments must consider ways to bring broadband Internet access
to low- and moderate-income residents, including how HUD funds could be
used to narrow the digital divide for these residents. Further, where
low- and moderate-income communities are at risk of natural hazards,
including those that are expected to increase due to climate change,
States and local governments must consider ways to incorporate
appropriate hazard mitigation and resilience into their community
planning and development goals, codes, and standards, including the use
of HUD funds to accomplish these objectives. These two planning
considerations reflect emerging needs of communities in this changing
world. Broadband provides access to a wide range of resources,
services, and products, which assist not only individuals and, but also
communities, in their efforts to improve their economic outlooks.
Analysis of natural hazards, including the anticipated effects of
climate change on those hazards, is important to help ensure that
jurisdictions are aware of existing and developing vulnerabilities in
the geographic areas that they serve that can threaten the health and
safety of the populations they serve.
[[Page 90998]]
B. Summary of Major Provisions of This Rule
HUD's currently codified Consolidated Plan regulations require that
local governments and States consult public and private agencies that
provide assisted housing, health services, and social and fair housing
services during preparation of the Consolidated Plan. Under these
regulations, local governments and States are also required in their
citizen participation plan to encourage the participation of local and
regional institutions and businesses in the process of developing and
implementing their Consolidated Plans. This rule requires States and
local governments, in preparing their Consolidated Plan, to add to the
list of public and private agencies and entities that they now must
consult with for preparation of their plans, to consult with public and
private organizations, including broadband internet service providers,
organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide (e.g., schools,
digital literacy organizations), and agencies whose primary
responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas, public
land or water resources, and emergency management agencies (see
Sec. Sec. 91.100 and 91.110). Jurisdictions must also encourage the
participation of these entities in implementing relevant components of
the plan (see Sec. Sec. 91.105 and 91.115).
The rule also requires each jurisdiction to describe broadband
needs in housing occupied by low- and moderate-income households based
on an analysis of data for its low- and moderate-income neighborhoods
for which the source is cited in the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan.
These needs include the need for broadband wiring and for connection to
the broadband service in the household units, and the need for
increased competition by having more than one broadband Internet
service provider serve the jurisdiction (see Sec. Sec. 91.210 and
91.310). Possible sources of such data include the National Broadband
Mapcreated by the National Telecommunications and Information
Administration (NTIA) of the Department of Commerce. Grantees may also
find broadband availability data in Federal Communications Commission
(FCC) Form 477. As discussed later in this preamble, the regulatory
text does not include recommended sources of data to avoid any
confusion that these are not required sources, only recommended
sources.
The rule also requires that jurisdictions provide, as part of their
required housing market analysis, an assessment of natural hazard risks
to low- and moderate-income residents, including risks expected to
increase due to climate change, based on an analysis of data, findings,
and methods identified by the jurisdiction, for which a reputable
source is cited in the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan. Possible
sources of such data include: (1) The most recent National Climate
Assessment, (2) the Climate Resilience Toolkit, (3) the Community
Resilience Planning Guide for Buildings and Infrastructure Systems
prepared by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),
and, (4) other climate risk-related data published by the Federal
government or other State or local government climate risk related
data, including FEMA-approved hazard mitigation plans which incorporate
climate change data or analysis. For the same reasons discussed above,
the regulatory text related to natural hazard risk analysis does not
include the recommended sources of data. Prior to implementation of the
new requirements established by this rule, HUD will provide additional
resources to support grantees in the form of guides and trainings.
Grantees may also request Technical Assistance through their HUD Field
Office or directly at www.HUDExchange.info/get-assistance.
C. Costs and Benefits of This Rule
HUD's Consolidated Plan process, established by regulation in 1995,
provides a comprehensive planning process for HUD programs administered
by HUD's Office of Community Planning and Development, specifically the
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program, the HOME Investment
Partnerships (HOME) program, the Emergency Solutions Grants (ESG)
program and the Housing with Opportunities for Persons With AIDS
(HOPWA) program. Comprehensive community planning provides officials
with an informative profile of their communities in terms of
population, housing, economic base, community facilities, and
transportation systems, and such information aids officials in their
investment decisions. HUD's Consolidated Planning process assists State
and local officials that are recipients of HUD funds under the above-
listed programs in determining the housing and community development
needs of their respective communities. Requiring Consolidated Plan
jurisdictions to consider the broadband and natural hazard resilience
needs of their communities helps to ensure a more complete profile of
the needs of their communities. As discussed in this preamble, the
importance of providing broadband access to all cannot be overstated.
Broadband access is not only important for increasing opportunities for
individuals' success, but also for the success of a community.
Consideration of the impact of natural hazard risks, many of which are
anticipated to increase due to climate change, in one's community, and
how communities can help mitigate any such adverse impacts, is equally
important as it will help to guide the best use of land and orderly and
sustainable growth. In brief, the benefits of this rule are to promote
a balanced planning process that more fully considers the housing,
environmental, and economic needs of communities.
The costs of the revised consultation and reporting requirements
are not significant since the regulatory changes proposed by this rule
merely build upon similar existing requirements for other elements
covered by the Consolidated Planning process rather than mandating
completely new procedures. Further, the required assessments are based
on data readily available on the Internet, or which the Consolidated
Plan jurisdiction may already have available to it, such as its own
local data. Therefore, jurisdictions will not have to incur the expense
and administrative burdens associated with collecting data. HUD
anticipates providing grantees with data early in Federal Fiscal Year
2018. HUD will not require grantees to incorporate these new
requirements into their Consolidated Plan process until HUD is able to
make the data available to all grantees. To provide such time, the
regulatory text provides that the new requirements apply to
Consolidated Plans submitted on or after January 1, 2018.
Moreover, this rule does not mandate that actions be taken to
address broadband needs or climate change adaptation needs. HUD's
Consolidated Plan process has long provided that jurisdictions are in
the best position to decide how to expend their HUD funds. The
additional analyses required by this rule may highlight areas where
expenditure of funds would assist in opening up economic opportunities
through increased broadband access or mitigate the impact of possible
natural hazards, including those that may be exacerbated due to climate
change. But HUD leaves it to jurisdictions to consider any appropriate
methods to promote broadband access or protect against the adverse
impacts of climate change, taking into account the other
[[Page 90999]]
needs of their communities, and available funding, as identified
through the Consolidated Planning process.
II. Background
A. Broadband Access
On March 23, 2015, President Obama issued a Presidential Memorandum
on ``Expanding Broadband Deployment and Adoption by Addressing
Regulatory Barriers and Encouraging Investment and Training.'' In this
memorandum, the President noted that access to high-speed broadband is
no longer a luxury, but a necessity for American families, businesses,
and consumers. The President further noted that the Federal government
has an important role to play in developing coordinated policies to
promote broadband deployment and adoption, including promoting best
practices, breaking down regulatory barriers, and encouraging further
investment.
On July 15, 2015, HUD launched its Digital Opportunity
Demonstration, known as ``ConnectHome,'' in which HUD provided a
platform for collaboration among local governments, public housing
agencies, Internet service providers, philanthropic foundations,
nonprofit organizations and other relevant stakeholders to work
together to produce local solutions for narrowing the digital divide in
communities across the nation served by HUD. The demonstration, or
pilot as it is also called, commenced with the participation of 28
communities. Through contributions made by the Internet service
providers and other organizations participating in the pilot, these 28
communities will benefit from the ConnectHome collaboration by
receiving, for the residents living in HUD public and assisted housing
in these communities, broadband infrastructure, technical assistance,
literacy training, and electronic devices that provide for accessing
high-speed Internet.
The importance of all Americans having access to the Internet
cannot be overstated. As HUD stated in its announcement of the Digital
Opportunity Demonstration, published in the Federal Register on April
3, 2015, at 80 FR 18248, ``[k]nowledge is a pillar to achieving the
American Dream--a catalyst for upward mobility as well as an investment
that ensures each generation is as successful as the last.'' \1\ Many
low-income Americans do not have broadband Internet at home,
contributing to the estimated 66 million Americans who are without the
most basic digital literacy skills. Without broadband access and
connectivity and the skills to use Internet technology at home,
children will miss out on the high-value educational, economic, and
social impact that high-speed Internet provides. It is for these
reasons that HUD is exploring ways, beyond ConnectHome, to narrow the
digital divide for the low-income individuals and families served by
HUD multifamily rental housing programs. This rule presents one such
additional effort.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ See 80 FR 18248, at 18249.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Natural Hazards Resilience
On November 1, 2013, President Obama signed Executive Order 13653,
on ``Preparing the United States for the Impacts of Climate
Change.''[thinsp]Executive Order 13653 was subsequently published in
the Federal Register on November 6, 2013 (78 FR 66819). The Executive
Order recognizes that the potential impacts of climate change--
including an increase in prolonged periods of excessively high
temperatures, more heavy precipitation, an increase in wildfires, more
severe droughts, permafrost thawing, ocean acidification, and sea-level
rise--are often most significant for communities that already face
economic or health-related challenges. Research has bolstered the
understanding of the concept of social vulnerability, which describes
characteristics (age, gender, socioeconomic status, special needs,
race, and ethnicity) of populations that influence their capacity to
prepare for, respond to, and recover from hazards and disasters,
including the sensitivity of a population to climate change impacts and
how different people or groups are more or less vulnerable to those
impacts. Social vulnerability and equity in the context of climate
change are important because some populations may have less capacity to
prepare for, respond to, and recover from climate-related hazards and
effects. Executive Order 13653 asserts that managing these risks
requires deliberate preparation, close cooperation, and coordinated
planning by the Federal government, State, Tribal, and local
governments, and stakeholders. Further, the Executive Order calls upon
Federal agencies to identify opportunities to support and encourage
smarter, more climate-resilient investments by States, local
communities, and tribes, through grants and other programs, in the
context of infrastructure development.
Section 7 of Executive Order 13653 established the President's
State, Local, and Tribal Leaders Task Force on Climate Change
Resilience and Preparedness (Task Force). Co-chaired by the Chair of
the White House Council on Environmental Quality and the Director of
the White House Office of Intergovernmental Affairs, the Task Force
consisted of 26 governors, mayors, county officials, and Tribal leaders
from across the United States. Members brought first-hand experiences
in building climate preparedness and resilience in their communities
and conducted broad outreach to thousands of government agencies, trade
associations, planning agencies, academic institutions, and other
stakeholders, to inform their recommendations to the Administration.
The President charged the Task Force with providing recommendations
on how the Federal government can respond to the needs of communities
nationwide that are dealing with the impacts of climate change by
removing barriers to resilient investments, modernizing Federal grant
and loan programs to better support local efforts, and developing the
information and tools they need to prepare, among other measures. In
November 2014, Task Force members presented their recommendations for
the President at a White House meeting with Vice President Biden and
other senior Administration officials. Among other actions, the Task
Force called on HUD to consider strategies within existing grant
programs to facilitate and encourage integrated hazard mitigation
approaches that address climate-change related risks, land use,
development codes and standards, and capital improvement planning. This
final rule represents one step that HUD is taking to implement these
recommendations.
HUD's May 2016 Proposed Rule
On May 18, 2016, at 81 FR 31192, HUD published a proposed rule that
would require Consolidated Plan jurisdictions to consider broadband
Internet access and the natural hazard resilience needs of their
communities and to consider whether they should and can take actions to
address these needs.
HUD's Consolidated Planning process serves as the framework for a
community-wide dialogue to identify housing and community development
priorities that align and focus funding from the HUD formula block
grant programs: The CDBG program, the HOME program, the ESG program,
and the HOPWA program. HUD's regulations for the Consolidated Plan are
codified at 24 CFR part 91 (entitled ``Consolidated Submissions for
Community Planning and Development Programs''). A Consolidated Plan,
which may have a planning duration of
[[Page 91000]]
between 3 and 5 years, is designed to help States and local governments
to assess their affordable housing and community development needs, in
the context of market conditions at the time of their planning, and to
make data-driven, place-based decisions on how to expend HUD funds in
their jurisdictions.
In developing their Consolidated Plans, States and local
governments are required to engage their communities, both in the
process of developing and reviewing the proposed plan, and as partners
and stakeholders in the implementation of the plan. By consulting and
collaborating with other public and private entities, States and local
governments can better align and coordinate community development
programs with a range of other plans, programs, and resources to
achieve greater impact. A jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan is carried
out through annual Action Plans, which provide a concise summary of the
actions, activities, and the specific Federal and non-federal resources
that will be used each year to address the priority needs and specific
goals identified by the Consolidated Plan. States and local governments
report on accomplishments and progress toward Consolidated Plan goals
in the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER).
The regulatory amendments proposed by HUD's May 2016 rule would
require States and local governments to consider broadband access and
natural hazard resilience as part of their Consolidated Planning
efforts. Where the required analysis demonstrates that broadband
Internet support is not currently available or is minimally available,
or the jurisdiction's community is at risk of natural hazards, the
jurisdiction should consider ways of addressing those needs.
The public comment period for HUD's May 18, 2016, proposed rule
closed on July 18, 2016. HUD received 37 public comments on the
proposed rule. The commenters included State and local governments,
climate adaptation and environment organizations, public housing
agencies (PHAs) and nonprofit organizations. The following Section III
discusses the significant comments raised by the commenters and HUD's
responses to the comments.
III. Discussion of Public Comments Received on the May 16, 2016,
Proposed Rule
This section of the preamble presents a summary of the significant
issues and questions raised by the commenters and HUD's responses to
these comments. The majority of the commenters supported the inclusion
of both assessments in the Consolidated Planning process, but as shown
below in the discussion of public comments were concerned about
administrative burden. In responding to the comments, HUD has strived
to highlight that the burden is minimal. The only change that HUD makes
in responses to public comments, as is more fully discussed below, is
to remove from the regulatory text specific recommended broadband and
risk hazard sources to consult in making the required assessments.
There was confusion about whether or when consultation with these
sources was required. They are recommended, not required sources.
Removing these references from the regulatory text eliminates this
confusion.
A. General Comments
Comment: Support for the rule. The majority of commenters supported
the proposed rule. These commenters commended HUD on recognizing the
importance of requiring jurisdictions to assess broadband access for
low-and moderate-income households and to consider how to incorporate
resilience to natural hazard risks in their planning efforts.
HUD Response. HUD appreciates the support of the commenters and
agrees that these changes to the Consolidated Planning process should
aid jurisdictions in addressing two emerging needs of communities in
this changing world.
Comment: The rule is an unfunded mandate. Several commenters stated
that the proposed rule represented an overreach of HUD's authority and
that the changes were an unfunded mandate.
HUD Response. The commenters are not correct that the two new
assessments impose an unfunded mandate. As an initial matter, HUD notes
that the rule's scope is limited to requiring consideration of the
broadband and natural hazards resilience needs of low-income
communities. The rule does not mandate that any actions be taken in
response to the required assessments. Jurisdictions retain the
discretion to consider the most appropriate methods to address their
assessments, taking into account other needs identified as part of the
Consolidated Planning process as well as financial and other resource
constraints. Further, HUD notes that the Consolidated Planning process
is required only to the extent jurisdictions voluntarily seek to
participate in HUD's community planning and development programs.
Accordingly, there is no mandate for jurisdictions choosing not to
receive such funding. The concept of unfunded mandates excludes
voluntarily-assumed requirements imposed as a condition for receipt of
Federal assistance.
Comment: The proposed regulatory changes are administratively and
economically burdensome. Several commenters wrote that the proposed
rule imposes an administrative burden, especially on smaller
communities. The commenters wrote that the financial burden would
unduly stretch already limited CDBG and HOME program funding. The
commenters also objected that HUD underestimated the administrative
burden of complying with the new requirements. Some of these commenters
focused on the administrative burden associated with the expanded
consultation requirements, which now include broadband internet service
providers, organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide, and
agencies engaged in resilience planning. These commenters stated that
HUD's estimates of the administrative burden failed to account for the
person-hours required to locate, engage, evaluate, and compile
recommendations from qualified public and private entities within
either content area. The commenters wrote that HUD should refrain from
pursuing the changes or make the two new assessments optional.
HUD Response. As noted in the proposed rule, HUD has sought to
minimize the costs and burdens imposed on communities by allowing the
assessments to be completed using readily available online data
sources. HUD further minimizes the burden imposed on jurisdictions by
providing an electronic template for completing the Consolidated Plan.
This template, first used in 2012, provides a uniform and flexible
template that helps ensure the Consolidated Plan is complete per the
regulations found in 24 CFR part 91. Many of the data tables within the
Consolidated Plan template are pre-populated with the most up-to-date
housing and economic data available, and HUD plans to input data for
both broadband and resilience assessment requirements. While grantees
will need to provide explanations relating their funding priorities to
the pre-populated data, they do not need to incur the costs or time of
searching for, entering, and compiling the data. HUD also notes that
the rule does not require jurisdictions to use the pre-populated data;
jurisdictions may opt to use other data of their choice.
HUD anticipates providing grantees with data early in Federal
Fiscal Year 2018. HUD will not require grantees to
[[Page 91001]]
incorporate these new requirements into their Consolidated Plan process
until HUD is able to make the data available to all grantees. To
provide such time, the regulatory text provides that the new
requirements apply to Consolidated Plans submitted on or after January
1, 2018.
With respect to the consultation requirements, HUD notes the
Consolidated Plan has always served as a planning document for the
jurisdiction as a whole. Jurisdictions are already required to consult
with public and private agencies, business and civic leaders, and units
of local government. The inclusion of the newly specified entities does
not substantively alter the cost or administration of the already
required participatory process.
Comment: The new proposed rule lacks necessary specificity of how
the two new assessments are to be conducted. Several commenters wrote
that the proposed rule lacked sufficient specificity regarding the
required contents of the new assessments and the criteria HUD will use
to evaluate the adequacy of the assessment. The commenters wrote that
this lack of details would make it difficult for jurisdictions to
comply with the new requirements. One of the commenters asked whether
the data sources cited by the community would be subject to review by
HUD. The commenters urged HUD to provide additional guidance to
communities on how it plans to measure compliance with the rule.
HUD Response: As it does on other components of the Consolidated
Plan, HUD will provide technical assistance and training materials to
assist jurisdictions in meeting the new requirements. However, HUD
notes that the requirements of the new rule are not entirely
unfamiliar, as the Consolidated Planning process already requires
jurisdictions to identify non-housing community development needs that
would aid communities in developing viable urban communities, providing
a suitable living environment and expanding economic opportunities
principally for low-income and moderate-income persons. (See 24 CFR
91.215(f).) With respect to data, as noted in response to an earlier
comment, HUD plans to pre-populate data in the electronic Consolidated
Plan template. Through the standardized template with prepopulated data
tables at the jurisdictional level and providing the ability to map
community needs, jurisdictions will be able to ascertain and satisfy
HUD's needs assessment expectations. To ensure that jurisdictions have
engaged in analysis regarding community broadband and natural hazard
resilience needs, plans will be reviewed for compliance with the new
requirements. Guidance will be developed for the field staff to support
consistent implementation of this policy. In order to aid grantees, HUD
will provide in its guidance best practices and examples for
incorporating broadband and natural hazards into the Consolidated Plan.
Comment: HUD should first establish eligible activities for the two
new assessments, before requiring that such assessments be undertaken.
A commenter wrote that the two new assessments do not directly address
CDBG's objectives. The commenter stated that before any changes are
made to the consultation and citizen participation regulations, HUD
should update the eligible activities and guidance regarding these
kinds of activities. The commenter stated that, for instance, income
payments, including payments for utilities such as Internet, are not
considered an eligible CDBG activity. The commenter stated that CDBG
funding could be used to make utility payments, including Internet
payments, to ensure low- and moderate-income families have access to
the Internet. Another commenter asked whether CDBG funds can be used to
assist in broadband infrastructure or otherwise connect housing
assisted by HUD to broadband.
HUD Response: One of the statutory objectives of the CDBG program
is to ``provid[e] . . . [a] suitable living environment,'' which
encompasses a range of related goals and activities such as improving
the safety and livability of neighborhoods; increasing access to
quality public and private facilities and services; and reducing the
isolation of income groups within a community or geographical area
through the spatial deconcentration of housing opportunities for
persons of lower income, the revitalization of deteriorating or
deteriorated neighborhoods, and the conservation of energy resources.
The two new assessments required under this rule align with this
objective. With respect to eligible activities, while HUD does not have
regulatory authority to add new eligible activities to the CDBG program
beyond those authorized in statute, the CDBG program already includes
numerous eligible activities, such as rehabilitation, through which
grantees can assist broadband connectivity and natural hazard
resilience efforts directly. When determining their public facility,
housing rehabilitation, economic development, and infrastructure needs,
grantees may wish to consider high performing infrastructure to
ameliorate/withstand natural hazards, as well as ways to use eligible
activities to meet community broadband needs. HUD has provided guidance
on using existing eligible activities for these purposes,\2\ and will
also be providing additional technical assistance and guidance on how
CDBG funds may be used to address both broadband and resilience needs
in the community.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ Please see the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for the
CDBG, HOME, and Housing Trust Fund programs available at the
following links: https://www.hudexchange.info/resource/4891/cdbg-broadband-infrastructure-faqs/ https://www.hudexchange.info/onecpd/assets/File/HOME-FAQs-Broadband.pdf https://www.hudexchange.info/resource/4420/htf-faqs/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Comment: HUD's regulations should be generally stated and guidance
should provide the necessary specificity. A commenter wrote that as
proposed, HUD requires very specific data sources to be included in the
Consolidated Plan. The commenter stated that this is problematic
because data sources often change or are renamed. The commenter stated
that HUD's regulations should list general information that is required
in the Consolidated Plan while HUD guidance and other materials that
are regularly updated, such as the ``Consolidated Plan in IDIS Desk
Guide,'' should provide recommended data sources. The commenter stated
that this will allow HUD to update data sources easily in circumstances
where sources change or new sources become available.
HUD Response: HUD appreciates the suggestion made by the commenter,
and has revised the rule accordingly. As recommended, the regulation no
longer identifies specific recommended sources. These suggested sources
of data will now be listed in guidance to facilitate updating as new
data becomes available or data sources are re-named. Jurisdictions will
still be able to use either the data identified by HUD and pre-
populated in the electronic Consolidated Plan template or other data
sources of the jurisdiction's choice, for which the source is cited in
the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan.
Comment: The rule includes no mandate thereby providing no
assurance goals will be met. A commenter wrote that despite HUD's
recognition of the importance of access to broadband and the increasing
risk of natural hazards, the proposed rule does not mandate
jurisdictions take any action, or even formulate actions steps, to
address these needs. The commenter wrote that while is it is often true
that ``jurisdictions are in the best position to decide how to expend
their HUD funds,'' requiring concrete plans of
[[Page 91002]]
action instead of just data collection is the only real way to ensure
HUD's stated goals are met.
HUD Response: A fundamental principle of the Consolidated Planning
process, as well as of HUD's community development formula programs
(for which the Consolidated Plan is the submission vehicle) is that
grantees have the flexibility and responsibility for developing their
own programs and funding priorities, based on their own assessment of
their needs. HUD does not mandate what objectives grantees should
achieve or what activities grantees are to undertake with their formula
funding. It will be up to the jurisdiction through its needs assessment
process to determine whether to select activities related to these
issues as a priority need. The grantee would identify the financial and
organizational resources available to address its priority needs. In
the Consolidated Planning process, the level of resources available
will play a key role in determining strategies and goals. Once
broadband or increasing resilience have been selected as a priority
need, grantees would then develop a set of goals based on the
availability of resources, and local organizational capacity.
Comment: The new assessments are already made by agencies within
each State tasked with such assessments. A commenter stated that new
assessments should not be required of State housing agencies. The
commenter stated that these assessments are already made by those State
agencies charged with technology authority or charged with emergency
management. The commenter stated that generally, for each State, these
assessments are made through programs that are not part of the
Consolidated Planning process.
HUD Response: HUD agrees that jurisdictions often already have
assessments undertaken by other agencies regarding both broadband
access and natural hazard resiliency. HUD is encouraging through its
Consolidated Planning process a collaborative consultation process. HUD
also encourages jurisdictions to use these plans developed by other
agencies in identifying community needs and priorities. The
Consolidated Planning process provides the opportunity for
jurisdictions to reference existing plans and HUD is not requiring a
separate, distinct study to be undertaken. It is up to each
jurisdiction to determine which agencies or departments will be
responsible for developing its Consolidated Plan and for administering
the HUD community development formula funding received through each
block grant program. All other jurisdictions (including States) are
encouraged to ensure collaboration among internal and external agencies
and staff to take full advantage of relevant expertise. Ideally, State
agencies would develop these plans in alignment with each other, not
only to reduce duplication of work but also to ensure that Federal
investments are more aligned throughout the State and in their
communities.
Comment: Consider requiring assessments for broadband adoption and
increasing resilience to natural hazards beyond the context of housing
needs. Several commenters wrote that HUD should consider requiring
assessments in Consolidated Plans beyond just housing needs. The
commenter stated that even though Consolidated Plans are focused on
housing needs, communities would benefit if jurisdictions are required
to at least analyze how funds could be used for broadband adoption and
enhancing resilience to natural hazard risks for communities as a
whole.
HUD Response: The Consolidated Plan is not exclusively concerned
with housing needs. HUD's Consolidated Plan regulations include both a
housing needs assessment and a non-housing community development plan.
Specifically, under 24 CFR 91.215 (for local governments) and 24 CFR
92.315 (for States), jurisdictions must provide a description of
priority non-housing community development needs eligible for
assistance under HUD's community development programs. In line with the
goals of this rulemaking, HUD strongly encourages jurisdictions to
consider implementing actions to support broadband access and adoption
and increase resilience in their non-housing community development
efforts, but such decisions on priorities are determined by grantees.
Comment: These two new Consolidated Plan assessments require input
by the residents of the community. A commenter stated that assessing
broadband and natural hazards concerns of the community beyond the data
points and institutional input required in the proposed rule is
essential for local governments and States in assessing the true needs
of the community. The commenter stated that without direct
communication with the households that are affected by these issues,
States and localities cannot properly assess the full needs of the
communities they serve. The commenter urged HUD to require
jurisdictions to create a public process where members of the community
have opportunity to comment on Consolidated Plans, and that HUD should
consider a community participation structure similar to the requirement
under HUD's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) regulation.
HUD Response: HUD's Consolidated Plan regulations already require
jurisdictions to undertake a citizen participation and consultation
process (see, subpart B of the Consolidated Plan regulations at 24 CFR
part 91, entitled ``Citizen Participation and Consultation''). The AFFH
citizen participation process was modeled on the citizen participation
and consultation process required by HUD's Consolidated Plan
regulations. HUD does not believe that a separate citizen participation
and consultation process is required for the two new assessments
established by this rule, as was established under the AFFH rule. HUD's
AFFH rule implemented a requirement, affirmatively furthering fair
housing, under a separate statute, the Fair Housing Act. That is not
the case here.
Comment: Broadband access and natural hazard risk resilience should
be included in the jurisdictions' Assessment of Fair Housing required
by HUD's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing regulation. A commenter
wrote that in addition to addressing concerns about broadband access
and resilience to natural hazard risks in their Consolidated Plans, HUD
should require jurisdictions to incorporate these assessments into
their Assessment of Fair Housing required under HUD's AFFH rule. The
commenter stated that HUD's AFFH rule aims to aide States and local
governments ``in taking a meaningful actions, in addition to combating
discrimination, that overcome patterns of segregation and foster
inclusive communities free from barriers that restrict access to
opportunity based on protected characteristics.'' The commenter stated
that under the AFFH rule, jurisdictions are charged with taking
meaningful actions that ``transform racially and ethnically
concentrated areas of poverty into areas of opportunity.''
HUD Response: While HUD, in this rule, is not mandating inclusion
of the broadband access and resilience assessments in the Assessment of
Fair Housing required under HUD's AFFH rule, jurisdictions may
voluntarily elect to include them in their assessment required under
the AFFH rule. As noted, HUD encourages jurisdictions to ensure
collaboration among State and local agencies and staff to take full
advantage of relevant expertise among all agencies and employees, be
they internal or external to the jurisdiction.
[[Page 91003]]
The suggestion made by the commenter may be one possible way of
achieving that goal.
B. Specific Comments on Narrowing the Digital Divide
Comment: The National Broadband Map and Form 477 do not provide
current data and HUD should therefore allow use of State and local
data. Several commenters objected to use of National Broadband Map and
Form 477 data to determine broadband availability. A commenter
questioned the accuracy of data quality and accuracy within the
broadband services sector. Another commenter wrote that Federally
collected data on broadband access and adoption is often of
inconsistent quality, unverified, not released in a timely manner, and
insufficient for the planning needs of many communities. Commenters
stated that the National Broadband Map has not been updated or
maintained and currently shows data from the fall of 2014, and this
outdated resource could lead to confusion and inaccurate information. A
commenter requested that HUD, in partnership with the Department of
Commerce's National Telecommunications and Information Administration
(NITA), pre-certify broadband coverage data and maps that communities
could use.
With respect to the Form 477, commenters wrote that the data has
not been mapped and is difficult to access. To address these concerns,
the commenters suggested that HUD allow Consolidated Plans to include
data on broadband access collected directly through State and local
broadband efforts. A commenter wrote that currently 37 States still
have active broadband planning teams with data and resources that are
likely more up-to-date than current federal data. Another commenter
wrote that few communities have the ability and knowledge base to
``consult with . . . broadband internet service providers'' as would be
required in proposed revisions to the consultation and citizen
participation requirements. The commenter stated that HUD would need to
provide substantial levels of policy and practical guidance to enable
local staff to determine broadband ``needs'' for a specific subset of
the overall population within each community.
HUD Response: While HUD does not agree with the commenters'
objections to use of the National Broadband Map and Form 477, it is
sympathetic to the general concerns expressed regarding the need to
ensure that data sources are accurate and up-to-date. As noted in
response to an earlier comment, this final rule does not codify
specific recommended data sources. These will now be listed in guidance
to facilitate updating as new data becomes available or data sources
are re-named. It was not HUD's intent to mandate use of the National
Broadband Map or Form 477. While HUD plans to provide pre-populated
data in the electronic Consolidated Plan template, jurisdictions are
not required to use such data and may use alternative data. The
template's default data can be replaced or complemented by other data
identified by the jurisdiction, for which the source is cited in the
jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan. Further, HUD is committed to aiding
jurisdictions with meeting the new requirements contained in this rule,
and will supplement the rule with guidance as may be needed. As it does
on other components of the Consolidated Plan, HUD will provide
technical assistance and training materials to assist jurisdictions in
meeting these new requirements.
Comment: The rule offers no suggested sources for States and
communities to assess the extent to which the need for connection to
the broadband service in the household units is being met. A commenter
wrote that the data sources identified in the rule are not adequate to
permit jurisdictions to assess the extent to which broadband services
have actually penetrated the market of low-to-moderate income
households in a given community. This commenter suggested two readily
available federal sources for actual household connection data which
should be suggested, but not required, by the rule. In contrast to
commenters that submitted concerns about the data in the immediately
preceding comment, the first source recommended by the commenter is
FCC's Form 477 Census Tract Data on Internet Access Services, which the
commenter stated provides a summary of reported connections for each
tract and compares the total to the tract's total Census households.
The commenter stated that this form, along with the FCC's national
interactive color-coded map, make it reasonably easy to rank or map a
state or community's Census tracts by household broadband penetration
and have an easy first look at their tracts' penetration levels. The
second source recommended by the commenter is the American Community
Survey (ACS) data on household computer ownership and Internet access.
HUD Response: HUD appreciates the suggestions of additional data
sources that may be useful to jurisdictions in preparing the required
broadband assessment. HUD notes that the Form 477 is already included
as a suggested data source. As previously addressed in this preamble,
jurisdictions may either use the data sources suggested by HUD or other
data identified by the jurisdiction, for which the source is cited in
the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan.
Comment: Do not ignore other causes of digital exclusion other than
availability in the housing market analysis. A commenter stated that in
creating a framework through its Consolidated Plan process for
community dialogue leading to possible action toward greater digital
access and inclusion, HUD should recognize that low rates of household
Internet access among low- and moderate-income residents can be the
result of many causes other than physical availability of service,
including the following: Unaffordability of available Internet services
to low-income residents; a lack of convenient opportunities for
residents to gain digital literacy skills; a failure to communicate the
value of available Internet services and tools; and other factors
specific to communities, such as language, cultural barriers, etc.
HUD Response: HUD appreciates the concerns raised by the commenter.
The Consolidated Plan contains both a housing need assessment and a
non-housing community plan development component. HUD encourages
jurisdictions to look at their broadband and resiliency needs across
all components of the Consolidated Planning process. The jurisdiction
has the ability to include an infrastructure assessment as well as
public services assessment as part of its non-housing community
development plan. HUD is cognizant that the adoption of broadband
internet is an equally critical component of closing the digital divide
and is contingent on many factors other than the availability of
internet service. This rule, however, is but one part of HUD's broader
efforts to expand the access and use of broadband internet. HUD also
notes that the jurisdictions are free to expand their broadband
assessment to include the types of issues listed by the commenter,
based on their identification of local needs and circumstances.
Comment: Consultation requirements should include other identified
stakeholders. Several commenters expressed support for the proposed
rule requiring the consultation of broadband stakeholders in
preparation for creating Consolidated Plans. The commenters suggested
additional stakeholders that should be included in the consultation
[[Page 91004]]
process. One commenter specifically recommended that State planning
programs be identified as possible partners in the locations they are
available. Another commenter suggested that HUD clarify that public-
private initiatives or partnerships (like a local community technology
planning team or task force, which might not have a formal legal
identity or corporate status) will qualify as an ``organization engaged
in narrowing the digital divide.'' The commenter stated that the needs
of often-voiceless, low-income communities with low adoption rates will
not always register with broadband providers, but allowing these
public-private organizations to voice the needs of low-income
communities can help establish a business case for improved service
offerings and options. Yet another commenter suggested adding language
to include ``local social service and public agencies providing digital
literacy, public internet access, or other broadband adoption
programs.'' The commenter stated that these may include, but are not
limited to: Adult literacy and education providers; K-20 schools; youth
program providers; libraries; and small business and workforce training
program providers.
HUD Response: The purpose of the Consolidated Planning process is
to aid jurisdictions, as a whole, in identifying their housing and
community development needs and funding priorities. The Consolidated
Plan builds on a participatory process that includes citizens,
organizations, businesses, and other stakeholders. In carrying out
these already required consultations, HUD encourages jurisdictions to
conduct the broadest possible outreach, including State and local
agencies and other entities identified by the commenters.
Comment: Require grantees to submit progress reports in closing the
digital divide. A commenter recommended that HUD revise the language at
the final rule stage to state that after submission and acceptance of
the Consolidated Plan, communities are expected to develop a reasonable
and achievable strategy for closing the digital divide. The commenter
stated that this language should leave no doubt as to the expectation
that progress will begin immediately. The commenter stated that HUD
should mandate that communities provide regular progress reports as
they take their first steps into closing the digital divide.
HUD Response: Grantees are currently required to submit progress
reports on the priority needs and goals they select during the
Consolidated Planning process. Under HUD's Consolidated Plan
regulations, within 90 days after the end of its program year, a
grantee must submit a Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation
Report (CAPER) to HUD. The primary purpose of the CAPER is to report on
accomplishments of funded activities within the program year and to
evaluate the grantee's progress in meeting one-year goals it has
described in the Annual Action Plan and long-term goals it has
described in the Consolidated Plan.
Comment: Encourage jurisdictions to partner with successful
ConnectHome communities. A commenter stated that to ease and facilitate
the assessment of broadband needs as part of the Consolidated Planning
process, HUD should recommend and/or establish connections between
applicants and successful ConnectHome communities that have developed
and implemented their own connection plans. The commenter stated that
this additional resource would dramatically increase the information
available to each community while further reducing administrative and
financial costs as communities share best practices. Another commenter
suggested that HUD document and widely share data and promising
practices from the 28 ConnectHome pilot communities, and assess what
strategies have been most (and least) successful in supporting
broadband access and adoption. The commenter encouraged HUD to
regularly undertake and make public an analysis of findings from
broadband access and adoption strategies jurisdictions reported in
their Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report or other
relevant reporting processes. The commenter also requested that HUD
establish a single-stop data center that contains links to all relevant
resources.
HUD Response: HUD agrees that ConnectHome communities could be a
valuable resource for other jurisdictions. HUD encourages
collaboration, where possible, between jurisdictions in developing and
implementing their plans to expand access to broadband internet. As the
commenter notes, such collaboration can be a cost-effective way to
share successful strategies and best practices. HUD will seek ways to
facilitate sharing of best practices of the ConnectHome communities.
For example, HUD is developing playbook that provides suggestions and
best practices for communities seeking to expand digital inclusion. The
suggestions identified in the playbook are based on HUD's experience
and expertise developed during implementation of the ConnectHome
initiative.
Comment: Examine how HUD programs may limit the ability of grantees
to invest funds in broadband access and adoption. A commenter suggested
that HUD assess how existing rules and legislation governing HUD
programs may limit the ability of grantee governments to invest funds
in broadband access and adoption. The commenter offered as an example
of such limitation the ``public services cap'' on grantees' permissible
use of CDGB grant funds. The commenter stated that any local investment
of CDBG funds in digital literacy training, technical assistance or
even consumer premises equipment to support household internet adoption
is currently classified as a public service expenditure and limited by
the cap, which means it competes for a fixed pool of dollars with all
kinds of ongoing community needs such as emergency homeless shelters.
HUD Response: As with all its programs and initiatives, HUD will,
on an ongoing basis, review and assess the impact of legislative and
regulatory requirements on program participants. Where appropriate or
necessary to policy goals, HUD will seek changes through the
appropriate vehicle, rulemaking, legislation or other policy action
that may facilitate a change. However, HUD does not agree with the
commenter that the CDBG program unduly limits activities to expand
access and adoption of broadband internet. The CDBG regulations allow
the use of grant funds for a wide range of eligible activities
including public services, which is not the only activity a community
can use to address its broadband needs. Grantees have the flexibility
and responsibility for developing their own programs and funding
priorities, based on their own assessment of their needs. Additionally,
other funding associated with the Consolidated Plan, such as HOME and
Housing Trust Fund funds, may be used for the actual costs of
constructing or rehabilitating single family or multifamily housing,
including the costs to wire the property for broadband internet, which
could help address a community's broadband needs.
C. Specific Comments on Increasing Resilience to Natural Hazards
Comment: Include a definition of resilience. A commenter stated
that resilience is a term that means many things to many people. The
commenter recommended that a definition of resiliency be included in
HUD's regulations in 24 CFR part 91.
HUD Response: HUD will provide technical assistance and training
[[Page 91005]]
materials to assist jurisdictions in meeting the new requirements. This
will include guidance to communities on how to assess their resilience
to natural hazard risk. As a guide, HUD points to the definition of the
term ``resilience'' used by HUD for the National Disaster Resilience
Competition, which is already familiar to HUD grantees and communities
participating in HUD programs. Specifically, in that notice of funding
availability, HUD defined resilience to mean ``the ability to
anticipate, prepare for, and adapt to changing conditions and
withstand, respond to, and recover rapidly from disruptions.''
Comment: For consistent evaluation of resilience, HUD should work
with other Federal agencies to develop guidance and tools that support
communities and practitioners. A commenter encouraged HUD to work with
other Federal agencies to develop guidance and tools that support
communities and practitioners, and noted that several tools already
exist and were identified in the proposed rule. The commenter
specifically noted as helpful tools the Integrated Rapid Visual
Screening (IRVS) Tool, the Community Resilience Planning Guide, and
Hazus MH FEMA. The commenter stated that to the extent practical, the
resilience evaluations required within the Consolidated Plan should
mirror requirements contained in other hazard identification and
mitigation plans conducted at the State and local level. The commenter
stated that this should include at a minimum the State Hazard
Mitigation Plan required to receive certain funding from the Federal
Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the Threat and Hazard
Identification and Risk Assessment (THIRA) process, and planning and
assessment requirements associated with Department of Transportation,
Economic Development Administration and other Federal programs. The
commenter also stated that the rule should require consultation with
additional community resources such as geological and meteorological
agencies, energy and sustainability offices, and building code
departments. Another commenter urged HUD to include academic
institutions as resources that should be consulted. Yet another
commenter stated that in addition to supporting communities' access to
critical governmental resources for assessing resilience to natural
hazards, HUD should convene a group of expert stakeholders from the
non-governmental organization community to strategize how to implement
effective resilience tactics, as well as hosting a broader
clearinghouse of readily available online data sources--including those
available in the private sector and nongovernmental organizations--to
achieve resilience solutions.
HUD Response: HUD notes that the final rule already provides
jurisdictions with the flexibility to consult with community resources
such as those identified by the commenter. HUD also strongly encourages
jurisdictions to leverage and integrate existing assessments of climate
and hazard related risks into their Consolidated Plan analysis where
the jurisdiction deems appropriate. With regard to the suggestion that
HUD work with other Federal agencies, HUD notes that it currently works
with other agencies to develop guidance and tools that support
communities and practitioners. For example, HUD conferred with various
Federal agencies in the development of this rule. More recently, HUD
has worked collaboratively with a group of expert stakeholders from
non-governmental organizations to strategize about the implementation
of effective resilience tactics to achieve resilience solutions through
its National Disaster Resilience Competition (NDRC).
Comment: Establish minimum investment requirements. A commenter
stated that while the identification of hazards and opportunities to
mitigate them is an important step to making communities more
resilient, once such efforts are institutionalized, the commenter
expressed hope that HUD will establish requirements that communities
invest in a minimum level of mitigation before Federal investments are
made within the community. The commenter stated that such requirements
will enhance the community and assure limited federal funds are used
responsibly.
HUD Response: HUD agrees with the commenter that identification of
hazards and opportunities to mitigate them is an important first step,
and appreciates the suggestion for establishing minimum investment
requirements. However, such a mandate runs contrary to the approach HUD
has taken with its Consolidated Planning regulations.
Comment: Expand the organizations with which jurisdictions should
consult. A commenter stated that the proposed rule is a step in the
right direction, but that to further this important work, jurisdictions
should be required to consult not only with the list of proposed
agencies, but also with a wide range of organizations working on
adaption to the decline of cheap fossil fuel energy, the depletion of
fresh water, access to fresh food, complex environmental crises like
climate change and biodiversity loss, and the issues of social,
economic and health equity. The commenter stated that such information
is consistent with HUD's new AFFH Data and Mapping Tool and could be
included as part of the assessment of fair housing. The commenter
stated that limiting mandatory consultation to ``agencies whose primary
responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas, public
land or water resources, and emergency management agencies'' is too
narrow for a full evaluation of vulnerability to natural hazards and
ensuring resilience of low- and moderate-income households.
The commenter stated that a number of public and private
organizations not listed in the proposed rule are immersed in
activities that enhance community resilience. For example,
organizations promoting home weatherization engage in energy
conservation, help prepare communities for a decline in cheap energy,
and contribute to efforts to improve neighborhood conditions;
organizations that focus on public health are able to provide local
data and findings on health inequity, such as asthma rates and food
deserts; and community organizations, colleges/universities, and other
non-profits are currently looking at and responding to the climate
crisis. The commenter stated that without casting a broad net, planning
efforts will be incomplete and continue the ill-suited forms of
planning for the new realities our communities face. Another commenter
stated that it was important for HUD grantees to consult with agencies
responsible for economic development and housing in the private sector.
The commenter stated that it is important to add this additional
category because the current HUD proposal seems to only cover agencies
responsible for ``public land and water resources,'' which would
exclude the many low- and moderate-income facilities regulated and
affected by local agencies responsible for economic development and
housing in the private sector.
HUD Response: The commenters offer very good suggestions on
agencies with whom to consult with respect to resilience. However, HUD
does not mandate consultation with these entities. As already noted in
this preamble, the approach taken in the Consolidated Plan is for
jurisdictions to determine their needs, decide which needs to fund,
conduct outreach to residents in their communities, and consult with
individuals and agencies that will aid them in good community
[[Page 91006]]
planning. The citizen participation and consultation process provides
the opportunity for a wide variety of stakeholders to participate the
in the Consolidated Planning process. As mentioned previously, the
Consolidated Plan includes a non-housing community development plan
that provides opportunity for a jurisdiction to assess its neighborhood
conditions, including economic needs, in its efforts to develop viable
communities.
Comment: Natural hazard risks should be assessed by the appropriate
government agency, not the government's housing and/or economic
development agency, and be done on a project-level basis. A commenter
that is a government economic development agency stated that it is not
the appropriate agency to assess natural hazard risks for low- and
moderate-income households, and that there are other governmental
organizations charged with assessing mitigating these risks. The
commenter stated that it can consult with the governmental agency
charged with assessing and mitigating risks and seek their input on
Consolidated Planning, but that it would not be appropriate for the
economic development agency to have a directive or management role in
this effort. The commenter also stated it is more impactful for this
type of review to take place at the project level. Once funded, each
project goes through an environmental review process. Many hazards are
assessed, ranging from hazardous waste and radiation to floodplain
analysis. The commenter stated that if a project site is in the
floodplain, it must go through a potentially lengthy and burdensome
process to determine if they can move the project or mitigate the
impact.
HUD Response: HUD addressed a similar comment early on in this
Section of the preamble that requested that HUD not mandate broadband
or natural hazards risk resilience assessments by a housing and/or
economic development agency when a State or local government has other
agencies charged to address these matters. As noted by HUD in response
to that earlier comment, HUD agrees that jurisdictions often already
have assessments undertaken by other agencies regarding both broadband
and resiliency. This final rule directs agencies to existing resources
to guide them in these two areas. Through its Consolidated Planning
process, HUD encourages a collaborative consultation process instead of
duplication of efforts. Given that HUD also encourages jurisdictions to
use other plans that identify community needs and priorities, the
Consolidated Planning process provides the opportunity for
jurisdictions to reference existing plans and is not requiring a
separate, distinct study to be undertaken. It is up to each State or
local government to determine which agencies or departments will be
responsible for developing its Consolidated Plan and for administering
the different HUD funding covered by HUD's Consolidated Plan
regulations. All jurisdictions (including States) are certainly
encouraged to ensure collaboration among internal and external agencies
and staff to take full advantage of all relevant expertise.
Comment: The National Climate Assessment and the Climate Resilience
Toolkit are confusing. A commenter stated that the National Climate
Assessment and the Climate Resilience Toolkit are very confusing. The
commenter stated that it was hard to understand how a State could use
this toolkit in a meaningful way in developing its Consolidated Plan.
The commenter stated that it shares data from its State's Homeland
Security and Emergency Management Department in its plans and then
relies on site-specific environmental reviews once projects are funded.
The commenter stated that these would seem to be better approaches to
assessing natural hazard risks to low-and moderate households for
States. In contrast to this comment, another commenter stated that the
Climate Resilience Toolkit is useful for screening and planning
purposes. This commenter also stated that while GIS tools that
integrate topography, hydrology, and social science are readily
available on the Internet, these tools are not likely to be commonly
used by housing programs. The commenter suggested that HUD provide
technical assistance in the form of webinars and workshops to train
housing staff on the use of these tools, and stated that training
programs are readily available through NOAA and EPA.
Another commenter stated that many of the natural hazard resources
named in HUD's proposed rule are not data sources, but instead are
plans and toolkits with already-made strategies [Sec. 91.210(a)(5)(i),
Sec. 91.210(a)(5)(ii), and Sec. 91.210(a)(5)(iii)]. The commenter
stated that the housing market analysis section of the Consolidated
Plan is intended to contain data with analysis that will inform the
later sections which include strategies and goals. The commenter stated
that because HUD is regulating the use of plans and strategies in this
data section of the Consolidated Plan, HUD is taking away the grantee's
efforts to create place-based strategies based on current data.
HUD Response: By referring to resources, plans, and toolkits, HUD
is encouraging jurisdictions to review what's been proposed and
discussed, and see whether it fits into the Consolidated Planning
efforts. HUD is developing guidance, resources, and tools to help
grantees work with these sources. Further, as already noted in this
section, HUD plans to provide pre-populated data in both CPD Maps and
the eCon Planning Suite template. Jurisdictions may use alternative
data in the Consolidated Planning process and are not required to use
the default data provided by the system. Default data can be replaced
or complemented by specifying a survey or administrative data source.
If an alternative source is specified, the jurisdiction will be
required to identify the source and provide basic information on how
the data was collected. The jurisdiction also has the option of
providing notes under each table in which alternate data is used to
indicate what was changed or why the change was necessary. Because the
public can view much of the default data in CPD Maps, these notes may
be useful to avoid confusion during the citizen participation process.
Comment: Expand approved sources of data to be made available to
jurisdictions for use, and require use of local data. A commenter
stated that jurisdictions should be required to both identify and
include local data when describing vulnerabilities of housing occupied
by low- and moderate-income households due to increased natural
hazards. The commenter stated that, for example, local data regarding
the quality of a jurisdiction's housing stock should be considered in
the planning process, and similarly, geographic location of the low-
and moderate-income households (which is available through HUD's AFFH
Assessment Tool Map) should be addressed in planning with regard to
vulnerabilities of housing.
HUD Response: As noted earlier, jurisdictions are already able to
use alternative data. While HUD plans to prepopulate data in both CPD
Maps and the eCon Planning Suite template, jurisdictions may use
alternative data in the Consolidated Planning process and are not
required to use the default data provided by the system. If an
alternative source is specified, the jurisdiction will be asked to
identify the source and provide basic information on how the data was
collected.
Comment: Issue guidance on how to undertake the required analysis.
A commenter strongly encouraged HUD to establish more specific guidance
for jurisdictions on how to complete the
[[Page 91007]]
required analysis. The commenter stated that such guidance should not
only include a step-by-step process for assessing community
vulnerability to climate change and natural hazard risks but also
should facilitate the identification and incorporation of actions that
build resilience to these risks in the Consolidated Planning process.
The commenter stated that developing more detailed guidance also would
reduce the burden placed on jurisdictions by providing greater clarity
on how to conduct a robust resiliency analysis, and would enhance
consistency among and improve confidence in resiliency analyses as well
as facilitate the review and approval of Consolidated Plans by HUD.
HUD Response: HUD plans to provide further guidance once the rule
is implemented, but since the Consolidated Plan is completed through
the e-Con Planning Suite template, the template provides a uniform and
flexible template that helps ensure the Consolidated Plan is complete
per the regulations found in 24 CFR part 91. Each screen in the
template cites the specific section(s) of the regulations that the
screen is designed to capture. Each screen includes a combination of
prepopulated data tables and narrative sections that set a baseline for
HUD's expectations for the amount of information required. HUD
anticipates providing this same format for both broadband and
resilience assessment requirements.
Comment: Ensure that grantees take steps to reduce the risks of
natural hazards. A commenter stated that HUD's proposed rule does not
ensure that grantees will take steps to reduce these risks or
disparities. The commenter stated that, as written, the proposed rule
explicitly, ``does not mandate that actions be taken to address . . .
climate change adaptation needs'' and requires nothing of grantees
beyond gaining knowledge of climate change risks. The commenter stated
that HUD's rule should ensure that grantees take reasonable and
adequate steps to both assess climate change risks and develop and
incorporate reasonable and effective climate change risk mitigation
strategies into their Consolidated Plans and project designs. The
commenter stated that without such strategies, the rule would continue
to allow HUD to invest in community development projects that may not
be resilient to the effects of climate change and could put communities
at risk. This commenter also stated that to ensure some level of
accountability HUD's final rule should state that if grantees invest
HUD funds in community development projects that do not include designs
and/or strategies to reduce identified climate risks, HUD could reduce
funding to that grantee in the future.
HUD Response: Through the Consolidated Planning process,
jurisdictions will continue to have the flexibility to determine their
own needs and priorities for distributing HUD funds. The rule provides
for the incorporation of broadband and resilience to natural hazard
risks into the existing needs assessment and market analysis required
under the Consolidated Planning process. However, it is up to the
jurisdiction through its needs assessment process to determine whether
to select either of these issues as a priority need. The grantee would
identify the financial and organizational resources available to
address its priority needs. In the Consolidated Planning process, the
level of resources available will play a key role in determining
strategies and goals. Once broadband access or increasing resilience
have been selected as a priority need, grantees would then develop a
set of goals based on the availability of resources, and local
organizational capacity. However, the statutory authority for the
Consolidated Plan process and the formula funding programs remain the
same. HUD has no authority to require that grantees carry out certain
types of activities or to achieve specific objectives.
Comment: Look at climate risk between disasters, not just risk
post-disaster. A commenter stated that it is essential that
jurisdictions look at climate risk between disasters, not just in a
post-disaster context. The commenter stated that identifying
vulnerabilities during calmer times gives the jurisdiction the
opportunity to address those challenges before the next disaster. The
commenter stated that HUD should be mindful that pre-disaster planning
is a preferable process, as post-disaster--when communities are in
crisis--is an incredibly difficult time to be strategic. In response to
HUD's specific inquiry regarding post-disaster reviews, another
commenter stated that it strongly believes that jurisdictions should be
required to conduct reviews and revisions of their resilience analysis
following any major disaster. The commenter stated that this post-
disaster review would not only enable jurisdictions to determine if the
disaster introduced new hazard risks, but would also serve an important
function in forcing jurisdictions to face and reconcile weaknesses and
oversights within their previous plans.
HUD Response: HUD agrees that it is important to review needs not
only in a post-disaster context but also between disasters. The
inclusion of an assessment of resilience in the Consolidated Plan is
not intended to apply to the post-disaster context, but rather is
designed to help all grantees be better prepared if a disaster were to
occur in the future. The Consolidated Plan is based on a community's
strategic plan over the next 3-5 years. The use of climate resilience
data will help a community identify its vulnerabilities and determine
whether there are priorities that the jurisdiction can address, as well
as develop preventive measures to address known issues in advance of a
disaster occurring. HUD appreciates the commenter responding to its
specific inquiry about post-disaster reviews. HUD is not mandating such
review in this final rule but encourages jurisdictions to undertake
these types of assessments.
Comment: Ensure communities are aware of local hazard mitigation
plans. A commenter stated that guiding communities to consider and
integrate this information into their Consolidated Plans is an
excellent move by HUD, assuring that risk reduction dovetails with a
community's economic and social development goals. The commenter stated
that its concern is that communities may not be aware of the existence
of local hazard mitigation plans, and may unfortunately duplicate
efforts that have already been expended on their behalf. The commenter
stated that its hope is that in the guidance for the rule, HUD would
direct communities to explore with local emergency managers and
planners the existence of current local hard mitigation plans, consider
the content of those plans (which often includes information about low-
income areas and vulnerability), and then use the information to inform
decisions made in the Consolidated Plans, referring to the mitigation
plan documents for justification or further data. The commenter stated
that in this way, there will be no duplication of effort, no confusion
as to valid risk assessment data, and the integration of mitigation
measures, policies and programs will be a seamless practice across a
community's planning portfolio.
HUD Response: HUD's rule addresses the commenter's concern by
requiring jurisdictions to consult with State and local emergency
managers (who are responsible for developing the State and local hazard
mitigation plans).
Comment: Coordinate and align with existing Federal, State and
local natural hazard risk management plans. A commenter stated that
while it understands HUD's intent to ensure that
[[Page 91008]]
communities consider resilience to natural hazard risks as a part of
the Consolidated Plan, the proposal goes about it in the wrong way. The
commenter stated that instead of asking communities to undertake
potentially new, unnecessary, and duplicative analysis, HUD should
focus on encouraging coordination and alignment with the pre-existing
Federal, State, and local plans that they already follow to comply with
the various programs that focus on resilience and natural hazard
planning. The commenter stated that it is concerned by the list of
resources in the rule and cites to the ``Impact of Climate Change and
Population Growth on the National Flood Insurance Program Through
2100'' as an example of such concern. The commenter expressed concerns
that the implication that this study could be included as the basis of
specific management decisions at a community level, since it would seem
to run counter to the scope and objectives of the study. The commenter
stated that the uncertainty that remains in accounting for mapping
future conditions, such as risks due to changes caused by climate
change, is the very reason that multiple segments of the National Flood
Insurance Program (NFIP) continue to examine the issue and how it might
best be addressed. The commenter stated that given that it is an
ongoing topic currently being studied by issue area experts such as the
Technical Mapping Advisory Council (TMAC), this is not something that
individual communities should be expected to get out in front of. The
commenter further stated that as the NFIP falls completely outside the
jurisdiction and expertise of HUD, the potential unintended
consequences may not be fully understood. The commenter stated that if
HUD chooses to move forward with promulgation of this rulemaking and
provide communities with a list of suggested resources for them to
consider, HUD should concentrate on more practical planning resources
which will still provide communities flexibility such as the Community
Resilience Planning Guide for Buildings and Infrastructure Systems
prepared by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
HUD Response: HUD agrees that it will continue to encourage
coordination and alignment with the pre-existing Federal, State, and
local plans that focus on resilience and natural hazard planning is a
benefit to the jurisdiction.
Comment: Require States and local jurisdictions to take action to
improve natural hazard resilience to protect Federal taxpayer
investments. A commenter expressed strong support for the rule but
expressed disappointment that the rule does not require actions to be
taken. The commenter stated that it believes that there should be a
much stronger attempt to compel States and communities to take action
to improve natural hazard resilience to protect federal taxpayer
investments--not merely just require an assessment of it.
HUD Response: HUD reiterates that the Consolidated Planning process
provides States and local government the flexibility and responsibility
to determine where HUD funding should be expended. Through the
Consolidated Planning process, jurisdictions will continue to have the
flexibility to determine their own needs and priorities for
distributing funds covered by the Consolidated Plan process. It will be
up to a jurisdiction through its needs assessment process to determine
whether to select either of these issues as a priority need. HUD has no
authority to require that grantees carry out certain types of
activities or to achieve specific objectives.
Comment: Ensure that jurisdictions comply with the Federal Flood
Risk Management Standard (FFRMS). A commenter stated that HUD must
ensure that jurisdictions funded by HUD comply with the FFRMS,
established by Executive Order 13690 (E.O. 13690) and Executive Order
11988 (E.O. 11988). The commenter stated that the FFRMS not only
reinforces the original intent of E.O. 11988--``to avoid to the extent
possible the long and short-term adverse impacts associated with the
occupancy and modification of floodplains and to avoid direct or
indirect support of floodplain development wherever there is a
practicable alternative,'' but expands upon it by requiring the federal
government to ``take action, informed by the best-available and
actionable [climate] science,'' to improve the nation's resilience to
flooding.
The commenter stated that the importance of transitioning from an
emphasis on flood protection to a broader focus on flood risk
management cannot be overstated because floodwaters can never be
completely controlled, nor the risks associated with flooding
completely eliminated. This is especially true when the impacts of
climate change are considered.
HUD Response: HUD is addressing this issue through separate
rulemaking.
IV. This Final Rule
As noted in Section III of this preamble, this final rule makes one
change from the proposed rule. In response to public comment, HUD no
longer identifies in the regulatory text specific recommended sources
for Consolidated Plan jurisdictions to consult for both assessments.
When included in the regulatory text, commenters thought these were
required sources to consult, rather than recommended sources. HUD
agrees with the commenters that such sources may change over time or
their names may change, or new sources will be introduced. HUD agreed
with the commenters that the better approach is to list these sources
outside of the regulation, in guidance.
Consultation and citizen participation requirements (Sec. Sec.
[thinsp]91.100, 91.105, 91.110, 91.115). HUD's currently codified
Consolidated Plan regulations require that local governments and States
consult public and private agencies that provide assisted housing,
health services, and social and fair housing services during
preparation of the Consolidated Plan. Under the currently codified
regulations, local governments and States are also required, in their
citizen participation plan, to encourage the participation of local and
regional institutions and businesses in the process of developing and
implementing their Consolidated Plans. This rule amends these
requirements to specify that local governments and States must consult
with public and private organizations, including broadband internet
service providers, and other organizations engaged in narrowing the
digital divide. Further, the citizen participation plan must encourage
their participation in implementing any components of the plan designed
to narrow the digital divide for low-income residents. The rule also
requires local governments and States to consult with agencies whose
primary responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas,
public land, or water resources, and emergency management agencies in
the process of developing the Consolidated Plan.
Contents of Consolidated Plan (Sec. Sec. [thinsp]91.5, 91.200,
9.200, 91.210, 91.300, 91.310). The rule makes several changes to these
sections in subparts C and D of HUD's regulations 24 CFR part 91, which
establish the required contents of the Consolidated Plan.
First, the rule requires that, in describing their consultation
efforts, local governments and States describe their consultations with
public and private organizations, including broadband internet service
providers, other organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide,
agencies whose primary responsibilities include the management of flood
prone areas, public land or water resources, and emergency management
agencies.
[[Page 91009]]
Second, the jurisdiction must also describe broadband needs in
housing occupied by low- and moderate-income households based on an
analysis of data, identified by the jurisdiction, for its low- and
moderate-income neighborhoods.
Third, the rule requires the jurisdiction to provide an assessment
of natural hazard risk to low- and moderate-income residents based on
an analysis of data identified by the jurisdiction. Possible sources of
such data include (1) the most recent National Climate Assessment, (2)
the Climate Resilience Toolkit, (3) the Community Resilience Planning
Guide for Buildings and Infrastructure Systems prepared by the National
Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), or (4) other climate
risk-related data published by the Federal government or other State or
local government climate risk related data, including FEMA-approved
hazard mitigation plans which incorporate climate change. HUD
encourages the use of other plans, including a jurisdiction's hazard
mitigation plan, in identifying community needs and priorities.
By undertaking these two analyses as part of their Consolidated
Planning, HUD believes that jurisdictions become better informed of two
emerging community needs in the world today: (1) The importance of
broadband access, which opens up opportunity to a wide range of
services, markets, jobs, educational, cultural and recreational
opportunities; and (2) the importance of being cognizant and prepared
for environmental and geographical conditions that may threaten the
health and safety of communities. As noted earlier in this preamble,
HUD is not mandating that jurisdictions take actions in either of these
areas, but HUD believes that these are two areas that must be taken
into consideration in a jurisdiction's planning for its expenditure of
HUD funds.
V. Findings and Certifications
Regulatory Review--Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
Under Executive Order 12866 (Regulatory Planning and Review), a
determination must be made whether a regulatory action is significant
and therefore, subject to review by the Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) in accordance with the requirements of the order. Executive Order
13563 (Improving Regulations and Regulatory Review) directs executive
agencies to analyze regulations that are ``outmoded, ineffective,
insufficient, or excessively burdensome, and to modify, streamline,
expand, or repeal them in accordance with what has been learned.
Executive Order 13563 also directs that, where relevant, feasible, and
consistent with regulatory objectives, and to the extent permitted by
law, agencies are to identify and consider regulatory approaches that
reduce burdens and maintain flexibility and freedom of choice for the
public. This rule was determined to be a ``significant regulatory
action'' as defined in section 3(f) of the Executive Order (although
not an economically significant regulatory action, as provided under
section 3(f)(1) of the Executive Order).
As noted, the regulatory amendments are designed to assist
Consolidated Plan jurisdictions in assessing two emerging needs of
communities in this changing world. Specifically, the final rule
directs States and local governments to consider broadband access and
natural hazard resilience in their consolidated planning efforts by
using readily available data sources. Where access to broadband
Internet service is either not currently available or only minimally
available, jurisdictions will be required to consider ways to bring
broadband Internet access to low- and moderate-income residents,
including how HUD funds could be used to narrow the digital divide for
these residents. Further, where low- and moderate-income communities
are at risk of natural hazards, including those that may be exacerbated
due to climate change, States and local governments must consider ways
to incorporate hazard mitigation and resilience into their community
planning and development goals, including the use of HUD funds.
Benefits and Costs of the Final Rule
A. Benefits
The Consolidated Planning process benefits jurisdictions by
establishing the framework for a community-wide dialogue to identify
housing and community development needs for 1,255 jurisdictions,
including 1,205 localities and all 50 States. Rather than a piecemeal
approach to planning based on differing program requirements, the
Consolidated Plan enables a holistic approach to the assessment of
affordable housing and community development needs and market
conditions. HUD established the Consolidated Plan, through a 1994 final
rule, for the explicit purpose of linking disparate program planning
requirements, thereby ensuring ``that the needs and resources of . . .
[jurisdictions] are included in a comprehensive planning effort to
revitalize distressed neighborhoods and help low-income residents
locally.'' \3\ The Consolidated Plan replaced a dozen separate planning
mechanisms with a unified approach enabling communities to make data-
driven, place-based investment decisions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ 60 FR 1878 (January 5, 1994).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
New housing and community development needs have arisen in the 21
years since the Consolidated Plan was created. Two of the most pressing
emerging needs facing communities in the twenty-first century are the
digital divide and climate change. Despite the benefits described above
of a comprehensive approach to planning and the allocation of scarce
Federal dollars, jurisdictions are not currently required to consider
either the digital divide or climate change resilience in development
of their Consolidated Plans. Jurisdictions may therefore place a low
priority on assessing, and using Federal dollars to address, these
critical issues relative to other needs included in the Consolidated
Plan. As a worst-case scenario, omitting these needs from the
consolidated planning process could mean that communities elect to
defer considering these needs.
The direct benefits provided by the final rule are, therefore, to
help ensure that Consolidated Plan jurisdictions consider broadband
access and natural hazard resilience as part of their comprehensive
assessment and planning efforts, including their determination of the
most effective use of HUD grant funds.
B. Costs
The costs of the revised consultation and reporting requirements
will not be substantial since the regulatory changes made by this final
rule build upon similar existing requirements for other elements
covered by the consolidated planning process rather than mandating
completely new procedures.
A complete Consolidated Plan that contains both a Strategic Plan
and Annual Action Plan is submitted once every 3 to 5 years. An Annual
Action Plan is submitted once a year. HUD data indicate that the cost
of preparing the Strategic Plan for a locality is $5,236, and for a
State is $14,382. The cost of preparing the Annual Action Plan is
$1,904 for a locality and $6,392 for each State. HUD estimates that the
increase in costs resulting from addressing the new elements under the
new rule will be minimal. Specifically, HUD estimates that cost to a
locality of preparing the Strategic Plan will increase to $5,406, while
the cost to a State will increase to $14,552. This represents an
increase of $170 per locality as well as per State.
[[Page 91010]]
The cost of preparing the Annual Action Plan will also increase by the
same amount, to $2,074 for a locality and $6,562 for a State. While
these are not trivial amounts, they are not substantial when considered
in proportion to HUD grant funding (for example, the average CDBG grant
to entitlement communities in FY 2012 was approximately $1.7
million).\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ Eugene Boyd, Community Development Block Grants: Recent
Funding History (Congressional Research Service, February 6, 2014),
available online at: https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=750383.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The amounts of the increased costs are based on HUD's estimate of
the increased number of hours it will take jurisdiction to complete the
new assessments. The table below summarizes the cost of the increased
burden hours across all jurisdiction that submit a Consolidated Plan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Completed
Consolidated plan tasks Number of Increased Cost per hour consolidated
respondents burden hours \5\ plan
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Localities
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Strategic Plan Development...................... 1205 5 34 $204,850
Action Plan Development......................... 1205 5 34 204,850
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
States
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Strategic Plan Development...................... 50 5 34 8,500
Action Plan Development......................... 50 5 34 8,500
---------------------------------------------------------------
Total....................................... .............. .............. .............. $426,700
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ Assumes a blended hourly rate that is equivalent to a GS-12,
Step 5 Federal Government Employee
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, and as noted elsewhere in this preamble, HUD has taken
several actions to further mitigate the cost of the regulatory changes.
Jurisdictions will be able to base the required assessments on data
that are already readily available on the Internet, and provided to
grantees via the eCon Planning Suite. Therefore, jurisdictions will not
have to incur the expense and administrative burdens associated with
collecting data. Moreover, the proposed rule does not mandate that
actions be taken to address broadband needs or climate change needs.
Consolidated plan jurisdictions are in the best position to decide how
to expend their HUD funds. However, HUD believes that the additional
analyses required by this proposed rule may highlight areas where
expenditure of funds would assist in opening up economic opportunities
through increased broadband access or mitigate the impact of possible
natural hazard risks and climate change impacts. HUD leaves it to
jurisdictions to consider any appropriate methods to promote broadband
access or protect against the adverse impacts of climate change, taking
into account the other needs of their communities, and available
funding, as identified through the consolidated planning process.
The docket file is available for public inspection in the
Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, Department of Housing
and Urban Development, 451 7th Street SW., Room 10276, Washington, DC
20410-0500. Due to security measures at the HUD Headquarters building,
please schedule an appointment to review the docket file by calling the
Regulation Division at 202-402-3055 (this is not a toll-free number).
Individuals with speech or hearing impairments may access this number
via TTY by calling the Federal Relay Service at 800-877-8339.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The information collection requirements contained in this rule have
been submitted to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) under the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501-3520), and assigned an
OMB control number 2506-0117.
Impact on Small Entities
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA)
generally requires an agency to conduct a regulatory flexibility
analysis of any rule subject to notice and comment rulemaking
requirements, unless the agency certifies that the rule will not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
The rule will amend the Consolidated Plan regulations to require
that States and local governments consider (1) broadband Internet
service access for low- and moderate-income households to; and (2) the
risk of potential natural hazards, including those that may be
exacerbated due to climate change, to low- and moderate-income
residents in their jurisdictions. As noted above under the heading
``Regulatory Review'' in the ``Findings and Certifications'' section of
this preamble, HUD's analysis of the economic costs associated with the
new regulatory requirements indicate that the final rule will not
impose significant economic burdens on HUD grantees, irrespective of
their size.
The RFA defines small governmental jurisdictions as those with a
population of less than 50,000 persons.\6\ As discussed above, the
Consolidated Planning process establishes the framework for identifying
housing and community development needs for 1,255 jurisdictions,
including 1,205 localities and all 50 States. Although HUD does not
have precise data indicating the number of small Consolidated Plan
localities as defined by the RFA, data from the Decennial census
indicates that there are 758 large incorporated places.\7\ This leaves
an estimated 447 small Consolidated Planning jurisdictions. This number
represents a minority of 37 percent of all jurisdictions. As noted
above, HUD estimates that cost to a locality of preparing the Strategic
Plan (which is submitted once every 3 to 5 years) will increase by $170
per locality. The cost of preparing the Annual Action Plan will also
increase by the same amount. Assuming submission of the Strategic Plan
on 3-year cycle, the total annual costs directly attributable to this
rule is $270 per locality.\8\ The increased costs are minimal when
considered in proportion to HUD grant funding. For example, and as
noted above, the average CDBG grant to entitlement
[[Page 91011]]
communities in FY 2012 was approximately $1.7 million).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ 5 U.S.C. 601(5).
\7\ https://www.census.gov/popest/data/cities/totals/2015/.
\8\ Diving the increased cost of preparing the Strategic Plan by
three to arrive at an annual figure ($170/3 = $57), and adding to
the $170 increased cost of preparing the Annual Action Plan. $57 +
$170 = $270.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moreover, HUD has taken several measures to even further minimize
the costs associated with complying with the rule. As discussed above,
jurisdictions will have the option to complete the required assessments
using data that has already been compiled and readily available on the
Internet. Jurisdictions will, therefore, not have to incur the expense
and administrative burdens associated with collecting and analyzing
data. Further, the rule does not mandate that any actions be taken in
response to the required assessments. Jurisdictions retain the
discretion to consider the most appropriate methods to address their
assessments, taking into account other needs identified as part of the
Consolidated Planning process as well as financial and other resource
constraints.
This rule therefore, which only requires consideration of the
broadband and natural hazards resilience needs of low-income
communities, has a minimal cost impact on all grantees subject to the
Consolidated Planning process, whether large or small, and will not
have a significant economic impact on substantial number of small
entities.
Environmental Review
This final rule does not direct, provide for assistance or loan and
mortgage insurance for, or otherwise govern, or regulate, real property
acquisition, disposition, leasing, rehabilitation, alteration,
demolition, or new construction, or establish, revise or provide for
standards for construction or construction materials, manufactured
housing, or occupancy. Accordingly, under 24 CFR 50.19(c)(1), this
final rule is categorically excluded from environmental review under
the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321).
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled ``Federalism'') prohibits an agency
from publishing any rule that has federalism implications if the rule
imposes either substantial direct compliance costs on state and local
governments and is not required by statute, or the rule preempts State
law, unless the agency meets the consultation and funding requirements
of section 6 of the Executive Order. This rule would not have
federalism implications and would not impose substantial direct
compliance costs on State and local governments or preempt State law
within the meaning of the Executive Order.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C.
1531-1538) (UMRA) establishes requirements for federal agencies to
assess the effects of their regulatory actions on State, local, and
tribal governments, and on the private sector. This rule would not
impose any federal mandates on any State, local, or tribal governments,
or on the private sector, within the meaning of the UMRA.
List of Subjects in 24 CFR Part 91
Aged, Grant programs--housing and community development, Homeless,
Individuals with disabilities, Low- and moderate-income housing,
Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
For the reasons discussed in the preamble, HUD amends 24 CFR part
91 as follows:
PART 91--CONSOLIDATED SUBMISSIONS FOR COMMUNNITY PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS
0
1. The authority citation for part 91 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d), 3601-3619, 5301-5315, 11331-
11388, 12701-12711, 12741-12756, and 12901-12912.
Subpart A--General
0
2. In Sec. [thinsp]91.100, add two sentences to the end of paragraph
(a)(1) to read as follows:
Sec. [thinsp]91.100 Consultation; local governments.
(a) * * *
(1) * * * When preparing the consolidated plan, the jurisdiction
shall also consult with public and private organizations. Commencing
with consolidated plans submitted on or after January 1, 2018, such
consultations shall include broadband internet service providers,
organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide, agencies whose
primary responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas,
public land or water resources, and emergency management agencies.
* * * * *
0
3. In Sec. [thinsp]91.105, add two sentences at the end of paragraph
(a)(2)(ii) to read as follows:
Sec. [thinsp]91.105 Citizen participation plan; local governments.
(a) * * *
(2) * * *
(ii) * * * The jurisdiction shall encourage the participation of
public and private organizations. Commencing with consolidated plans
submitted on or after January 1, 2018, such consultations shall include
broadband internet service providers, organizations engaged in
narrowing the digital divide, agencies whose primary responsibilities
include the management of flood prone areas, public land or water
resources, and emergency management agencies in the process of
developing the consolidated plan.
* * * * *
0
4. In Sec. 91.110, add two sentences at the end of paragraph (a)
introductory text to read as follows:
Sec. 91.110 Consultation; States.
(a) * * * When preparing the consolidated plan, the State shall
also consult with public and private organizations. Commencing with
consolidated plans submitted on or after January 1, 2018, such
consultations shall include broadband internet service providers,
organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide, agencies whose
primary responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas,
public land or water resources, and emergency management agencies.
* * * * *
0
5. In Sec. 91.115, add a sentence at the end of paragraph (a)(2)(ii)
to read as follows:
Sec. 91.115 Citizen participation plan; States.
(a) * * *
(2) * * *
(ii) * * * Commencing with consolidated plans submitted in or after
January 1, 2018, the State shall also encourage the participation of
public and private organizations, including broadband internet service
providers, organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide,
agencies whose primary responsibilities include the management of flood
prone areas, public land or water resources, and emergency management
agencies in the process of developing the consolidated plan.
* * * * *
Subpart C--Local Governments; Contents of Consolidated Plan
0
6. In Sec. 91.200, redesignate paragraph (b)(3)(iv) as paragraph
(b)(3)(vi), and add new paragraphs (b)(3)(iv) and (v) to read as
follows:
Sec. 91.200 General.
* * * * *
(b) * * *
(3) * * *
(iv) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, public and private organizations, including broadband
internet service providers and organizations engaged in narrowing the
digital divide;
[[Page 91012]]
(v) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, agencies whose primary responsibilities include the
management of flood prone areas, public land or water resources, and
emergency management agencies; and
* * * * *
0
7. Revise Sec. 91.210(a) to read as follows:
Sec. 91.210 Housing market analysis.
(a) General characteristics. (1) Based on information available to
the jurisdiction, the plan must describe the significant
characteristics of the jurisdiction's housing market, including the
supply, demand, and condition and cost of housing and the housing stock
available to serve persons with disabilities, and to serve other low-
income persons with special needs, including persons with HIV/AIDS and
their families.
(2) Data on the housing market should include, to the extent
information is available, an estimate of the number of vacant or
abandoned buildings and whether units in these buildings are suitable
for rehabilitation.
(3) The jurisdiction must also identify and describe any areas
within the jurisdiction with concentrations of racial/ethnic minorities
and/or low-income families, stating how it defines the terms ``area of
low-income concentration'' and ``area of minority concentration'' for
this purpose. The locations and degree of these concentrations must be
identified, either in a narrative or on one or more maps.
(4) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, the jurisdiction must also describe the broadband
needs of housing occupied by low- and moderate-income households based
on an analysis of data, identified by the jurisdiction, for its low-
and moderate-income neighborhoods. These needs include the need for
broadband wiring and for connection to the broadband service in the
household units and the need for increased competition by having more
than one broadband Internet service provider serve the jurisdiction.
(5) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, the jurisdiction must also describe the vulnerability
of housing occupied by low- and moderate-income households to increased
natural hazard risks associated with climate change based on an
analysis of data, findings, and methods identified by the jurisdiction
in its consolidated plan.
* * * * *
Subpart D--State Governments; Contents of Consolidated Plan
0
8. In Sec. 91.300, remove the word ``and'' following the semicolon at
the end of paragraph (b)(3)(iii), redesignate paragraph (b)(3)(iv) as
paragraph (b)(3)(vi), and add new paragraphs (b)(3)(iv) and (v) to read
as follows:
Sec. 91.300 General.
* * * * *
(b) * * *
(3) * * *
(iv) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, public and private organizations, including broadband
internet service providers and organizations engaged in narrowing the
digital divide;
(v) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, agencies whose primary responsibilities include the
management of flood prone areas, public land or water resources, and
emergency management agencies; and
* * * * *
0
9. Revise Sec. [thinsp]91.310(a) to read as follows:
Sec. [thinsp]91.310 Housing market analysis.
(a) General characteristics. (1) Based on data available to the
State, the plan must describe the significant characteristics of the
State's housing markets (including such aspects as the supply, demand,
and condition and cost of housing).
(2) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, the State must describe the broadband needs of housing
in the State based on an analysis of data identified by the State.
These needs include the need for broadband wiring and for connection to
the broadband service in the household units, the need for increased
competition by having more than one broadband Internet service provider
serve the jurisdiction.
(3) Commencing with consolidated plans submitted on or after
January 1, 2018, the State must also describe the vulnerability of
housing occupied by low- and moderate-income households to increased
natural hazard risks due to climate change based on an analysis of
data, findings, and methods identified by the State in its consolidated
plan.
* * * * *
Dated: December 14, 2016.
Harriet Tregoning,
Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Community Planning and
Development.
Nani A. Coloretti,
Deputy Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2016-30421 Filed 12-15-16; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4210-67-P