[Federal Register Volume 81, Number 174 (Thursday, September 8, 2016)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 62260-62320]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2016-21276]
[[Page 62259]]
Vol. 81
Thursday,
No. 174
September 8, 2016
Part II
Department of Commerce
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
50 CFR Parts 223 and 224
Endangered and Threatened Species; Identification of 14 Distinct
Population Segments of the Humpback Whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) and
Revision of Species-Wide Listing; Final Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 81 , No. 174 / Thursday, September 8, 2016 /
Rules and Regulations
[[Page 62260]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
50 CFR Parts 223 and 224
[Docket No. 130708594-6598-03]
RIN 0648-XC751
Endangered and Threatened Species; Identification of 14 Distinct
Population Segments of the Humpback Whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) and
Revision of Species-Wide Listing
AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Commerce.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We, NMFS, issue a final determination to revise the listing
status of the humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) under the
Endangered Species Act (ESA). We divide the globally listed endangered
species into 14 distinct population segments (DPS), remove the current
species-level listing, and in its place list four DPSs as endangered
and one DPS as threatened. Based on their current statuses, the
remaining nine DPSs do not warrant listing. At this time, we find that
critical habitat is not determinable for the three listed DPSs that
occur in U.S. waters (Western North Pacific, Mexico, Central America);
we will consider designating critical habitat for these three DPSs in a
separate rulemaking.
DATES: This final rule is effective October 11, 2016.
ADDRESSES: Public comments, a list of references cited in this final
rule, and other supporting materials are available at
www.regulations.gov identified by docket number NOAA-NMFS-2015-0035, or
by submitting a request to the National ESA Listing Coordinator, Office
of Protected Resources, NMFS, 1315 East-West Highway, Room 13536,
Silver Spring, MD 20910.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Marta Nammack, NMFS, (301) 427-8469,
[email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
On August 12, 2009, we announced the initiation of a status review
of the humpback whale to determine whether an endangered listing for
the entire species was still appropriate (74 FR 40568). We sought
information from the public to inform our review, contracted with two
post-doctoral students to compile the best available scientific and
commercial information on the species (Fleming and Jackson 2011),
including the past, present, and foreseeable future threats to this
species, and appointed a Biological Review Team (BRT) to analyze that
information, make conclusions on extinction risk, and prepare a status
review report (Bettridge et al. 2015).
On April 16, 2013, we received a petition from the Hawaii
Fishermen's Alliance for Conservation and Tradition, Inc., to classify
the North Pacific humpback whale population as a DPS and then
``delist'' that DPS under the ESA. On February 26, 2014, the State of
Alaska submitted a petition to delineate the Central North Pacific
(Hawaii) ``stock'' of the humpback whale as a DPS and subsequently
remove that DPS from the ESA List of Endangered and Threatened Species.
After reviewing the petitions, the literature cited in the petitions,
and other literature and information available in our files, we found
that both petitioned actions may be warranted and issued positive 90-
day findings (78 FR 53391, August 29, 2013; 79 FR 36281, June 26,
2014). Public comment periods were opened upon publication of these
findings to solicit information to be considered in the context of the
ongoing status review. We subsequently extended the public comment
period pertaining to information regarding the Central North Pacific
(Hawaii) population (79 FR 40054; July 11, 2014). We then incorporated
all information into a single status review report of the humpback
whale (available at http://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/pr/species/mammals/whales/humpback-whale.html).
Based on information presented in the status review report (which
included a demographic analysis, threats analysis, and extinction risk
analysis), our assessment of the BRT's conclusions, and efforts being
made to protect the species, we initially determined: (1) 14
populations of the humpback whale met the criteria of the NMFS and U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) joint 1996 DPS Policy and were,
therefore, considered to be DPSs; (2) the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest
Africa and Arabian Sea DPSs were in danger of extinction throughout
their ranges; (3) the Western North Pacific and Central America DPSs
were likely to become endangered throughout all of their ranges within
the foreseeable future; and (4) the West Indies, Hawaii, Mexico,
Brazil, Gabon/Southwest Africa, Southeast Africa/Madagascar, West
Australia, East Australia, Oceania, and Southeastern Pacific DPSs were
not in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of
their ranges or likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Accordingly, we issued a proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015) to
revise the species-wide listing of the humpback whale by replacing it
with two endangered species listings (Cape Verde Islands/Northwest
Africa and Arabian Sea DPSs) and two threatened species listings
(Western North Pacific and Central America DPSs). We also proposed to
extend all ESA section 9 prohibitions to both the Western North Pacific
and the Central America DPSs. As described below, after considering
public comments and the best available scientific and commercial
information, we have now reached our final determinations, which in
three instances differ from our proposed determinations. We now issue a
final rule to revise the species-wide listing of the humpback whale by
replacing it with four endangered species listings (Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa, Western North Pacific, Central America, and Arabian
Sea DPSs) and one threatened species listing (Mexico DPS). We also
finalize our proposed rule to extend all ESA section 9 prohibitions to
threatened humpback whales (which now consists of the Mexico DPS).
Listing Determinations Under the ESA
We are responsible for determining whether species are threatened
or endangered under the ESA (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). To reach a
listing determination for a particular group of organisms, we must
first consider whether that group of organisms constitutes a
``species'' under the ESA, and then we consider whether the status of
the species qualifies it for listing as either threatened or
endangered. Section 3 of the ESA defines a ``species'' to include ``any
subspecies of fish or wildlife or plants, and any distinct population
segment of any species of vertebrate fish or wildlife which interbreeds
when mature.'' On February 7, 1996, NMFS and the USFWS (together, the
Services) adopted a policy describing what constitutes a DPS of a
species or subspecies (61 FR 4722). The joint DPS policy identified two
elements that must be considered when identifying a DPS: (1) The
discreteness of the population segment in relation to the remainder of
the species (or subspecies) to which it belongs; and (2) the
significance of the population segment to the remainder of the species
(or subspecies) to which it belongs. As stated in the joint DPS policy,
Congress expressed an expectation that the Services would exercise
authority with regard to identifying DPSs sparingly and
[[Page 62261]]
only when the biological evidence indicates such action is warranted.
Section 3 of the ESA defines an endangered species as ``any species
which is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant
portion of its range'' and a threatened species as one ``which is
likely to become an endangered species within the foreseeable future
throughout all or a significant portion of its range'' (16 U.S.C.
1533(6); (20)). Thus, we interpret an ``endangered species'' to be one
that is presently in danger of extinction. A ``threatened species,'' on
the other hand, is not presently in danger of extinction, but is likely
to become so within the foreseeable future (that is, at a later time).
In other words, the primary statutory difference between a threatened
and endangered species is the timing of when a species may be in danger
of extinction, either presently (endangered) or in the foreseeable
future (threatened).
As we explained in the proposed rule and summarize here, when we
consider whether a species might qualify as threatened under the ESA,
we must consider the meaning of the term ``foreseeable future.'' It is
appropriate to interpret ``foreseeable future'' as the horizon over
which predictions about the conservation status of the species can be
reasonably relied upon. The foreseeable future considers the life
history of the species, habitat characteristics, availability of data,
particular threats, ability to predict threats, and the reliability to
forecast the effects of these threats and future events on the status
of the species under consideration. Because a species may be
susceptible to a variety of threats for which different data are
available, or which operate across different time scales, the
foreseeable future is not necessarily reducible to a particular number
of years. Our approach is consistent with the legal analysis adopted by
the Department of the Interior. See United States Department of the
Interior, Office of the Solicitor, Memorandum, ``The Meaning of
`Foreseeable Future' in section 3(20) of the Endangered Species Act,''
M-37021 (Jan. 16, 2009).
In determining the listing status of a species, subspecies, or DPS,
the ESA and implementing regulations require that we consider whether
the species is endangered or threatened because of any one or a
combination of the following factors: The present or threatened
destruction, modification, or curtailment of its habitat or range;
overutilization of the species for commercial, recreational,
scientific, or educational purposes; disease or predation; the
inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms; and other natural or
manmade factors affecting a species' continued existence (16 U.S.C.
1533(a)(1); 50 CFR 424.11(c)). We evaluate demographic risk factors
(i.e., abundance and trend information) in conjunction with the section
4(a)(1) factors. The demographic risk analysis is an assessment of the
manifestation of past threats that have contributed to the species'
current status and also informs the consideration of the biological
response of the species to present and future threats.
Section 4(b)(1)(A) of the ESA requires us to make listing
determinations based solely on the best scientific and commercial data
available after conducting a review of the status of the species and
after taking into account efforts being made by any State or foreign
nation or political subdivision thereof to protect the species (16
U.S.C. 1533(b)(1)(A)).
Applying the definitions of ``endangered species'' and ``threatened
species,'' we first consider the status of a ``species'' (which
includes subspecies and DPSs) ``throughout all . . . of its range.'' If
(and only if) this rangewide evaluation does not lead to a conclusion
that the species should be listed as endangered or threatened, then we
must consider whether the species may be endangered or threatened in
``a significant portion of its range.'' If it is, then the entire
species (or subspecies, or DPS) will be listed. As we explained in the
proposed rule and summarize here, we are guided in these listing
determinations by the final joint policy adopted by the Services in
2014 (79 FR 37577; July 1, 2014) (Final SPOIR Policy). The Final SPOIR
Policy explains that it is necessary to fully evaluate a portion under
the ``significant portion of its range'' authority only if substantial
information indicates that the members of the species in a particular
area are likely to both meet the test for biological ``significance''
established in the policy and to be currently endangered or threatened
in that area. Making this preliminary determination triggers a need for
further review, but does not prejudge whether the portion actually
meets these standards such that the species should be listed.
The BRT initially applied the higher threshold for ``significance''
from the 2011 draft SPOIR policy but before finalizing the report
confirmed that application of the threshold of the final SPOIR Policy
would not have changed the findings for any DPS (See 80 FR 22304, at
22349). (The draft SPOIR policy differed from the final SPOIR policy in
that a portion of the range of a species was considered ``significant''
if the portion's contribution to the viability of the species was so
important that, without that portion, the species would be in danger of
extinction (i.e., endangered) throughout all of its range. Under the
Final SPOIR Policy, the hypothetical loss of the portion being
considered would only need to result in the species being at least
threatened throughout its range instead of endangered throughout its
range.)
Status Review
A summary of basic biological and life history information of the
humpback whale can be found in the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April
21, 2015 at 22307-22309) and more details can be found in Fleming and
Jackson (2011) and the BRT's status review report (Bettridge et al.
2015; available at http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/species/statusreviewes.htm). As we described more fully in the proposed rule,
to identify potential DPSs, the BRT reviewed the best scientific and
commercial data available on the humpback whale's taxonomy and
concluded that there are likely three unrecognized subspecies of
humpback whale: North Pacific, North Atlantic, and Southern Hemisphere.
In reaching this conclusion, the BRT considered available life history,
morphological, and genetic information (mtDNA and DNA relationships and
distribution, as described in Jackson et al. (2014)). Next, the BRT
considered various humpback whale populations to determine whether they
satisfied the DPS criteria of discreteness and significance relative to
the three subspecies.
The BRT considered both the abundance and trend information (i.e.,
the demographic analysis) and the threats to each DPS before reaching
its conclusions on overall extinction risk for each DPS. With regard to
the demographic analysis, the BRT concluded that abundance and, where
available, trend information should be considered carefully but were
not the sole criteria for evaluating extinction risk. When considering
numbers of individuals within a DPS, the BRT considered the following
general thresholds for population risk: A DPS with a total population
size >2,000 individuals was not likely to be at risk due to low
abundance alone; a DPS with a population size <2,000 individuals would
be at increasing risk from factors associated with low abundance (and
the lower the population size, the greater the risk); a DPS with a
population size <500 individuals would be at high risk due to low
abundance; and a DPS with
[[Page 62262]]
a population size <100 individuals would be at extremely high risk due
to low abundance. BRT members also considered how each of the factors
(or threats) listed in ESA section 4(a)(1) contribute to the extinction
risk of each DPS now and in the foreseeable future.
The BRT decided to evaluate risk of extinction over a time frame of
approximately 60 years, which corresponds to about three humpback whale
generations. The BRT concluded it could be reasonably confident in
evaluating extinction risk over this time period (the foreseeable
future) because current trends in both the biological status of the
species and the threats it faces are reasonably foreseeable over this
period of time. In making our listing determinations, we have applied a
period of 60 years as the general foreseeable future when considering
impacts to the species.
In reaching our proposed listing determinations, we reviewed the
status review report (Bettridge et al. 2015) and concluded that it
provided the best available scientific and commercial data on the
identification of DPSs, abundance and trends, and section 4(a)(1)
factors as of the time it was compiled. To make the proposed listing
determinations, we used the best available scientific and commercial
data on the humpback whale, which are summarized in the status review
report and incorporated herein. After considering conservation efforts
by States and foreign nations to protect the DPS, as required under
section 4(b)(1)(A), we proposed listing determinations based on the
statutory definitions of ``endangered species'' and ``threatened
species'' (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015).
To make our final listing determinations, we reviewed all
information provided during the 90-day public comment period on the
proposed rule (which included some studies and reports not initially
considered for the proposed rule), information received through the
four public hearings, and additional scientific and commercial data
that became available since the publication of the proposed rule and
the status review report. In most cases, this additional information
merely supplemented, and did not differ significantly from, the
information presented in the proposed rule. Where new information was
received, we have reviewed it and present our evaluation of the
information in this final rule. In most cases, the new information
received was not so significant that we are relying on it for our final
determinations. We received comments and received or obtained new
information on the West Indies DPS, the Western North Pacific DPS, the
Hawaii DPS, the Mexico DPS, the Central America DPS, the Gabon/
Southwest Africa DPS, and the Oceania DPS. After reviewing public
comments and new information, we determined that: (1) Some of the data
we relied upon for the West Indies DPS abundance estimate is not yet
available in final, validated form or fully analyzed by the authors of
the relevant study, so for the final rule we are relying solely on data
from an earlier survey because it represents the best available
scientific and commercial data, but this does not change our initial
determination that listing this DPS is not warranted; (2) upon
reconsideration of the information we had at the time of our proposal,
the extinction risk to the Western North Pacific DPS should be
classified as high, not moderate, and therefore, we are listing this
DPS as endangered instead of threatened; (3) upon reconsideration of
the information we had at the time of our proposal, and in light of
updated, lower abundance estimates, the extinction risk to the Mexico
DPS should be classified as moderate, not low, and therefore, we are
listing this DPS as threatened; (4) upon reconsideration of the
information we had at the time of our proposal, and in light of the
updated, lower abundance estimate for the Central America DPS and
associated uncertainties, the extinction risk to the Central America
DPS should be classified as high, not moderate, and therefore, we are
listing this DPS as endangered instead of threatened; (5) we have
updated the population abundance estimate for the Gabon/Southwest
Africa DPS to 7,134, based on more reliable data, but this does not
change our initial determination that listing this DPS is not
warranted; and (6) the population abundance estimate and the population
growth rate of the Oceania DPS are 4,329 and 3 percent per year
(previously ``unknown''), respectively, which further strengthens our
initial determination that listing this DPS is not warranted. With this
rule, we finalize our listing determinations, resulting in four DPSs
listed as endangered (E), one DPS listed as threatened (T), and nine
DPSs not warranted for listing (NW), as described in the following
table:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Humpback Whale DPS Proposed Final
------------------------------------------------------------------------
West Indies...................... NW NW.
Cape Verde Islands/Northwest E E.
Africa.
Western North Pacific............ T E.
Hawaii........................... NW NW.
Mexico........................... NW T.
Central America.................. T E.
Brazil........................... NW NW.
Gabon/Southwest Africa........... NW NW.
Southeast Africa/Madagascar...... NW NW.
West Australia................... NW NW.
East Australia................... NW NW.
Oceania.......................... NW NW.
Southeastern Pacific............. NW NW.
Arabian Sea...................... E E.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rationale for Revising the Listing Status of a Listed Species Under the
ESA
We have determined that, based on the best available scientific and
commercial information, the humpback whale should be recognized under
the ESA as 14 individual DPSs. We described the delineations of these
14 DPSs in detail in the 12-month determination and proposed rule (80
FR 22304; April 21, 2015). Comments regarding the delineation are
addressed under Summary of Comments below. Based on a comprehensive
status review and our analysis of demographic factors and the section
4(a)(1) factors, we have concluded that four of the DPSs qualify as
endangered species, one qualifies as a threatened species, and nine do
not warrant listing. Our action here is prompted both by our own
review, begun in 2009, and the two delisting petitions we received.
Our final determinations are based on the best available scientific
and commercial information pertaining to the species throughout its
range and within each DPS. In this final rule, we are identifying 14
DPSs, making listing determinations for each DPS, and revising the
current listing. We find that the purposes of the ESA would be
furthered by managing this wide-ranging species as separate units under
the DPS authority, in order to tailor protections of the ESA to those
populations that warrant protection. Based on a review of the
demographics of these DPSs and the five factors contained in ESA
section 4(a)(1), we find that the best available science no longer
supports a finding that the species is an ``endangered species''
throughout its range. We revise the listing for the humpback whale by
removing the current species-wide listing and in its place listing four
DPSs as endangered and one DPS as threatened. Nine DPSs are not being
listed because their current status does not warrant listing. Because
these DPSs are not currently listed as separate entities, we are
revising and replacing the existing listing of the species with
separate listings for those DPSs that warrant classification as
threatened or
[[Page 62263]]
endangered under authority of sections 4(a)(1) and 4(c)(1) of the ESA,
rather than ``delisting'' those DPSs that do not warrant such
classification under our regulations (50 CFR 424.11(d)). However, the
effect of our final action is that the protections of the ESA no longer
apply to these nine DPSs. We note that we have previously reclassified
a species into constituent populations (e.g., identified western and
eastern populations of the gray whale (Eschrichtius robustus) and
revised the listing to remove one population (the eastern one) from the
endangered species list (59 FR 31094; June 16, 1994)).
The ESA gives us authority to make these listing determinations and
to revise the lists of endangered and threatened species to reflect
these determinations. Section 4(a)(1) of the ESA authorizes us to
determine by regulation whether ``any species,'' which is expressly
defined to include species, subspecies, and DPSs, is endangered or
threatened based on certain factors. Review of the status of a species
may be commenced at any time, either on our own initiative through a
status review at any time, or in connection with a ``5-year'' review
under section 4(c)(2), or in response to a petition. A DPS is not a
scientifically recognized entity, but rather one that is created under
the language of the ESA and effectuated through our 1996 DPS Policy.
Because recognition of DPSs is not mandatory, we have some inherent
discretion to determine whether a species-level listing should be
reclassified into DPSs and what boundaries should be recognized for
each DPS. At the conclusion of the listing review process, ESA section
4(c)(1) gives us authority to update the lists of endangered species
and threatened species to conform to our most recent determinations.
This can include revising the lists to remove a species from the lists
or reclassifying the listed entity.
Neither the ESA nor our regulations explicitly prescribe the
process we should follow where the best available scientific and
commercial information indicates that the listing of a taxonomic
species should be updated and revised into listings of constituent
DPSs. To the extent it may be said that the statute is ambiguous as to
precisely how the updated listings should replace the original listing
in such circumstances, we provide our interpretation of the statutory
scheme. The purposes of the statute are furthered in certain situations
where the agency has determined that it is appropriate to revise a
rangewide listing in order to ensure that the current lists of
endangered and threatened species comport with the best available
scientific and commercial information. For example, updating a listing
may further the statute's purpose of recognizing when the status of a
listed species has improved to the point that fewer protections are
needed under the ESA, allowing for appropriately tailored management
for the populations that do not warrant listing and for those remaining
populations that do. Where a species, subspecies, or DPS no longer
needs protection of the ESA, removing those protections may free
resources that can be devoted to the protection of other species.
Conversely, disaggregating a species listing into DPSs can also
sometimes lead to greater protections if one or more constituent DPSs
qualify for reclassification to endangered.
There is no practicable alternative to simultaneously recognizing
the newly identified DPSs and assigning them the various statuses of
threatened, endangered, or not warranted to replace the original
taxonomic species listing. It would be nonsensical and contrary to the
statute's purposes and the best available science requirement to
attempt to first separately list all the constituent DPSs; the best
available scientific and commercial information would not support
listing all of the DPSs now in order to delist some of them
subsequently. Nor would it make sense to attempt to first ``delist''
the species-level listing in order to then list some of the constituent
DPSs. Where multiple DPSs qualify for listing as endangered or
threatened, it would inherently thwart the statute's purposes to remove
protections of the ESA from all members of the species even
temporarily. The approach we have taken in this final rule ensures a
smooth transition from the former taxonomic species listing of
endangered to today's listing of certain specified DPSs: Four as
endangered and one as threatened (and nine as not-warranted).
We will continue to monitor the status of the entire range of the
humpback whale. For any listed DPSs, monitoring is as a matter of
course, pursuant to the obligation to periodically review the status of
these species (ESA section 4(c)(2)). In addition, we will undertake
monitoring of the DPSs that are not listed as a result of their
improved status (consistent with ESA section 4(g)).
Summary of Comments
On April 21, 2015, we solicited comments during a 90-day public
comment period from all interested parties including the public, other
concerned governments and agencies, Indian tribal governments, Alaska
Native tribal governments or organizations, the scientific community,
industry, and any other interested parties on the proposed rule (80 FR
22304). Specifically, we requested information regarding:
(1) The identification of 3 subspecies of humpback whale composed
of 14 DPSs;
(2) The current population status of identified humpback whale
DPSs;
(3) Biological or other information regarding the threats to the
identified humpback whale DPSs;
(4) Information on the effectiveness of ongoing and planned
humpback whale conservation efforts by countries, states, or local
entities;
(5) Activities that could result in a violation of section 9(a)(1)
of the ESA if such prohibitions are applied to the Western North
Pacific and Central America DPSs;
(6) Whether any DPS of the humpback whale that is not listed under
the ESA in a final rule would automatically lose depleted status under
the Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA), or, if not, what analysis and
process is required by the MMPA before a change in depleted status may
occur. We sought comments regarding different options for construing
the relevant provisions of these statutes in harmony;
(7) Whether approach regulations should be promulgated under the
MMPA for the protection of the Hawaii DPS of the humpback whale because
if the rule became final as proposed, that DPS would no longer be
listed under the ESA, or whether current protections in effect in the
Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary (at 15 CFR
922.184) are sufficient for the protection of the species from vessel
interactions. We indicated that commenters should consider the impact
of the proposal by NOAA's Office of National Marine Sanctuaries to
expand the sanctuary boundaries and strengthen the approach regulations
(80 FR 16224; March 26, 2015), which has since been withdrawn (81 FR
13303; March 14, 2016);
(8) Whether approach regulations in effect for the protection of
humpback whales in Alaska, currently set forth at 50 CFR 224.103(b),
should be relocated to Part 223 (which applies to threatened species)
for the continuing protection of the Western North Pacific DPS, and
whether these regulations should also be set out in 50 CFR part 216 as
MMPA regulations for the protection of all humpback whales occurring in
that area, in light of the fact that the MMPA
[[Page 62264]]
was one of the original authorities cited in promulgating the
regulation;
(9) Information related to the designation of critical habitat,
including identification of those physical or biological features which
are essential to the conservation of the Western North Pacific and
Central America DPSs of humpback whale and which may require special
management consideration or protection;
(10) Economic, national security, and other relevant impacts from
the designation of critical habitat for the Western North Pacific and
Central America DPSs of humpback whale; and
(11) Research and other activities that would be important to
include in post-delisting monitoring plans for the West Indies, Hawaii,
Mexico, Brazil, Gabon/Southwest Africa, Southeast Africa/Madagascar,
West Australia, East Australia, Oceania, and Southeastern Pacific DPSs.
We received 225 comment letters on the proposed rule. One of the
commenters attached a form letter that was signed by 13,279 members, as
well as 539 letters that were modified versions of the same form
letter. Another commenter sent a letter, including signatures from
3,464 U.S. individuals and 4,046 individuals from foreign countries. We
also held four public hearings in Honolulu, HI; Juneau, AK; Plymouth,
MA; and Virginia Beach, VA, at which 13 members of the public provided
testimony.
Summaries of the substantive public comments received, and our
responses, are provided below, organized by topic.
Comments on Topics That Apply to Multiple DPSs
Comment 1: One commenter stated that NMFS initiated an ESA status
review of the humpback whale in 2009 and asserted that it has yet to be
completed. The commenter added that the findings are likely to shed new
light onto the population status of humpback whale DPSs in the North
Pacific.
Response: We initiated an ESA status review in 2009 and completed
it in 2015 (Bettridge et al. 2015). We relied upon the status review
report to make our conclusions about the humpback whale DPSs and their
status under the ESA. More recent information available since the
report's publication and since publication of the proposed rule was
considered during development of this final rule. If we become aware of
new information at a later date that may affect our understanding of
the DPSs' status, we can initiate a new status review. New information
can also be evaluated during the 5-year reviews that are required under
ESA section 4(c)(2) or presented via a petition at any time.
Comment 2: One commenter stated that the ESA is only valid within
the borders of the United States and that consideration of listing or
delisting populations that are not within our borders is meaningless as
far as protective status is concerned.
Response: Section 4 of the ESA requires that we list any species
that we determine to be endangered or threatened, whether it occurs
within the United States or elsewhere. Demonstrating a need to secure
particular protections under the other sections of the ESA, or that
such protections will be afforded where the species is found, is not a
precondition to listing. While it is true that fewer protections apply
under the ESA for foreign species, important protections do apply. All
persons subject to the jurisdiction of the United States (including its
citizens) must comply with section 9 of the ESA, which, among other
things, makes it unlawful to import endangered species into the United
States or to export them from the United States, or to ``take''
endangered species within the territorial sea of the United States or
upon the high seas (16 U.S.C. 1538(a)(1)(A)-(C)). These protections may
be extended to threatened species through a rule issued under section
4(d). In addition, listing provides important educational benefits.
Comment 3: One commenter questioned the ``significance'' criterion
of the DPS Policy, asserting that if a population is discrete from
other populations, it should qualify as a DPS.
Response: As noted earlier, the Services published the Policy
Regarding the Recognition of Distinct Vertebrate Population Segments
Under the Endangered Species Act in 1996 (61 FR 4722; February 7,
1996). To be considered a DPS, a population must be both discrete from
the remainder of the species to which it belongs and significant to the
species to which it belongs. The DPS policy states:
If a population segment is considered discrete under one or more
of the above conditions, its biological and ecological significance
will then be considered in light of Congressional guidance (see
Senate Report 151, 96th Congress, 1st Session) that the authority to
list DPS's be used `` * * * sparingly'' while encouraging the
conservation of genetic diversity. In carrying out this examination,
the Services will consider available scientific evidence of the
discrete population segment's importance to the taxon to which it
belongs. This consideration may include, but is not limited to, the
following:
1. Persistence of the discrete population segment in an
ecological setting unusual or unique for the taxon;
2. Evidence that loss of the discrete population segment would
result in a significant gap in the range of a taxon;
3. Evidence that the discrete population segment represents the
only surviving natural occurrence of a taxon that may be more
abundant elsewhere as an introduced population outside its historic
range; or
4. Evidence that the discrete population segment differs
markedly from other populations of the species in its genetic
characteristics. Because precise circumstances are likely to vary
considerably from case to case, it is not possible to describe
prospectively all the classes of information that might bear on the
biological and ecological importance of a discrete population
segment.
The DPS Policy was adopted following a period of public comment and
is the Services' definitive interpretation of ``distinct population
segments.'' See Northwest Ecosystem Alliance v. U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, 475 F.3d 1136, 1143 (9th Cir. 2007) (holding that
the DPS Policy is entitled to deference as a duly promulgated,
binding policy). Therefore, discreteness alone is not sufficient for
identifying a population as a DPS.
Comment 4: Several commenters supported identifying DPSs, but
recommended that populations in different feeding areas be identified
as DPSs separately from breeding population DPSs in order to support
species diversity, as is done under the MMPA in some cases. One of
these commenters supported our decision to identify DPSs because they
agree that humpback whales should not be listed under the ESA as a
global species, nor solely as three sub-species. This commenter also
understood the rationale for initially focusing on distinct breeding
stocks, as well as the mandate to apply DPSs sparingly.
The commenters were nevertheless concerned that the proposed set of
DPSs may not be adequate to maintain species diversity in light of
humpback whale ecology, suggesting that humpback whales exhibit strong
fidelity to feeding grounds as well as breeding grounds. This commenter
noted that individuals that interbreed return reliably to their own
discrete feeding areas, and these can be widely separated across ocean
basins. The commenter asserted that we have previously indicated that
if humpback whales were to be extirpated on one North Atlantic feeding
ground then that area would not be re-colonized within a management-
relevant time frame (Waring et al. 2000), stating that this rationale
was used to redefine the MMPA management unit for stock assessment from
the Western North Atlantic to the Gulf of Maine (Waring et
[[Page 62265]]
al. 2000). The commenter strongly agreed with this view and management
action and believed that the same rationale applies to the preservation
of species range and diversity under the ESA.
Furthermore, the commenter stated, there are significant genetic
differences among feeding grounds in both the North Atlantic and the
North Pacific (Palsb[oslash]ll et al. 2001; Baker et al. 2013),
including among feeding grounds that share a proposed DPS. One example
is the ``low but significant divergence between all summer foraging
grounds . . . as well as between all summer foraging grounds and the
samples collected on the breeding grounds in the West Indies''
(Palsb[oslash]ll et al. 2001). The commenter asserted that such
differences are not adequately explained by our knowledge of breeding
stocks, and therefore likely not captured by breeding-based DPS units
alone. Finally, this commenter noted, there is evidence of cultural
transmission of feeding behavior among individuals on at least one
feeding ground (Allen et al. 2013; Weinrich et al. 1992), and such
knowledge cannot be shared across breeding populations due to the
segregation of breeding and feeding habitats. For these reasons, this
commenter suggested that feeding aggregations warrant individual
consideration under the ESA.
Response: MMPA stocks do not necessarily coincide with DPSs under
the ESA. To be identified as a DPS under the ESA, a population must be
both discrete from other conspecific populations and significant to the
species or subspecies to which it belongs. A population need only be
demographically independent from another population to be considered a
stock under the MMPA (NMFS 2016). It may be true that humpback whales
demonstrate fidelity to their feeding areas, and if a stock in a
particular feeding area is extirpated, it may not be repopulated within
a management-relevant time period; however, this is not the test under
the DPS policy. NMFS held a workshop on Conservation Units of Managed
Fish, Threatened or Endangered Species, and Marine Mammals in February
2006 to discuss the differences among stocks under the MMPA, fisheries
stocks under the Magnuson-Stevens Act, and DPSs under the ESA (NMFS
2008). We concluded that DPSs can encompass multiple MMPA stocks
because of the significance criterion of the DPS policy. DPSs can be
identified at different hierarchical levels, and we determine the DPS
configuration that makes the most sense after evaluating the best
available scientific and commercial information and considering what
management approach best furthers the purposes of the ESA as concerns
that species.
Comment 5: One commenter recommended that we identify
demographically independent populations as DPSs in the Southern
Hemisphere because this has implications for candidacy for
``delisting.'' The commenter asserted that the proposed rule omitted a
number of DPSs that meet the DPS policy criterion of ``discreteness.''
Such omissions, they asserted, have further implications for
estimations of abundance, status, threats, and possibly extinction
risk, if a DPS includes a number of demographically independent units.
The commenter cited relatively recent studies (Barendse et al. 2011;
Carvalho et al. 2014; Elwen et al. 2014; Ersts et al. 2011; Fossette et
al. 2014; Kershaw 2015; Rosenbaum et al. 2014; Van Waerebeek et al.
2013) indicating statistically significant differences between
substocks within International Whaling Commission (IWC) stocks B and C
(equivalent to the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS and the Southeast Africa/
Madagascar DPS). The commenter also recommended that the significance
of Fst values (measure of genetic differentiation among
groups) rather than the magnitude of these values be considered in
delineating DPSs.
Another commenter asserted that NMFS' proposed designation of the
East Australia DPS and Oceania DPS uses a different boundary between
two breeding stocks (designated E and F by the IWC) than the boundary
used by the IWC. This commenter stated that NMFS' proposal is therefore
arbitrary and capricious. The commenter suggests that this boundary may
or may not be adequately protective of animals using the Southern
Hemisphere breeding areas east of the coast of Australia, which appear
to have a mixing of a fairly robust stock with smaller and more fragile
stocks. The commenter pointed to one publication (Garrigue et al.,
undated), not cited by NMFS, that discusses the ``known connections
between eastern Australia and the westerly component of Oceania (New
Caledonia, Tonga and New Zealand).'' Clearly, this commenter asserted,
some of these East Australia animals are mixing with breeding stocks
included in the Oceania DPS. This commenter added that there has also
been a documented interchange between humpbacks in New Caledonia and
Eastern Australia at the same rate of exchange seen between New
Caledonia and ``the rest of'' Oceania (i.e., Vanuatu and Tonga)
(Garrigue et al. 2011).
Response: We appreciate the citations for studies not included in
the status review report or in the proposed rule. Some of these papers
were published after the BRT had substantially completed drafting its
status review report. We have carefully reviewed each publication, and
all available information has now been considered for this final rule.
While the substocks identified by the commenters represent
demographically independent populations (as identified by the IWC),
they do not meet the criteria of our DPS Policy (please see response to
Comment 3). Criteria in the DPS policy indicate a population must be
discrete from other conspecific populations and significant to the
taxon to which it belongs. Our DPS determinations are case specific; we
do not rely on a particular Fst value to indicate that
populations are discrete from each other. Genetic differences among
populations may be an indication of discreteness, but not necessarily
an indication of significance. The BRT identified 15 humpback whale
DPSs, and, as we explained in the proposed rule, we agreed with its
conclusions in all cases but one (we combined two of the populations
the BRT identified as separate into one DPS; please see response to
Comment 43).
In the case of the East Australia and Oceania DPSs, the BRT
reviewed the data and made a modification based on the best available
data, as the ESA requires. We are aware that there are migrants between
these DPSs. The DPS Policy criteria do not require complete separation
between populations. In discussing the DPS configuration of Southern
Hemisphere humpback whale populations, the BRT stated, ``. . .
significant differentiation was present among major breeding areas, and
the estimated number of migrants/generation among areas was small
compared to the estimated sizes of the populations'' (Bettridge et al.
2015 at 24). The BRT interpreted the interchange between humpback
whales in eastern Australia and New Caledonia as evidence that the
whales share a migration corridor: ``Breeding population in New
Caledonia and east Australia are separate but some overlap between the
populations occurs: some whales bound for New Caledonia use the same
migratory pathways as some whales headed past east Australia''
(Bettridge et al. 2015 at 25). The Garrigue et al. (2011) study cited
by the commenter discusses only 7 matches between Eastern Australia and
Oceania, which is a small number. Similar
[[Page 62266]]
movements occur between the Hawaii and Mexico DPSs.
Further, the possibility that a population could be a candidate for
``delisting'' if it were identified as a DPS is not one of the DPS
policy criteria and is not otherwise an appropriate consideration. The
ESA requires that we base our listing determinations solely on the best
available scientific and commercial data. In conclusion, we do not
agree with the commenters that the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS, the
Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS, East Australia DPS, or Oceania DPS
should be further divided into smaller DPSs at this time.
Comment 6: One commenter stated that the ESA should be faithful to
its name, and afford protection to taxonomic ``species.'' Specifically,
the commenter indicated that dividing the species into populations does
not recognize the biological validity of a species concept.
Response: The ESA provides for identifying and listing different
populations separately. As originally enacted, the statute defined
``species'' to include--in addition to taxonomic species--subspecies
and ``any other group of fish or wildlife of the same species or
smaller taxa in common spatial arrangement that interbreed when
mature.'' In 1978, the ESA was amended to replace that language with
the current language regarding ``distinct population segments'' (DPSs)
in the definition of ``species'' (Pub. L. 95-632 (1978)). Congress
instructed us to exercise this authority with regard to DPSs ``. . .
sparingly and only when the biological evidence indicates that such
action is warranted'' (S. Rep. No. 96-151 (1979)). In 1996 the Services
published the DPS Policy to define this term. Under the DPS Policy, if
a population is both discrete from other conspecific populations and
significant to the taxon to which it belongs, it is considered a DPS,
and therefore, is a ``species'' under the ESA.
For humpback whales, we found that the purposes of the ESA would be
furthered by managing this wide-ranging species as separate units under
the DPS authority, in order to tailor protections of the ESA to those
populations that warrant protection. Please see our response to Comment
3 for more details on the DPS Policy.
Comment 7: Several commenters stated that increasing abundance does
not equate to full recovery, and that it is premature to delist any
DPSs. One of these commenters suggested that the ESA does not allow us
to identify DPSs for the purpose of delisting, citing the District of
Columbia District Court in Humane Society v. Jewell, ``the creation or
initial designation of a DPS operates as a one-way ratchet to provide
ESA protections to the covered vertebrates'' (Humane Society of the
United States v. Jewell, Case 1:13-cv-00186-BAH (D.D.C. Dec. 19, 2014).
This commenter also cited Friends of the Wild Swan v. U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, 12 F. Supp. 2d 1121, 1133 (D. Or. 1997), and
Defenders of Wildlife v. Norton, 239 F Supp. 2d 9, 2 (D.D.C. 2002).
They suggested that Federal courts have come to the same conclusion
(quoting the Friends of the Wild Swan decision): ``As USFWS's own
population segment policy acknowledges, listing of population segments
is a proactive measure to prevent the need for listing a species over a
larger range--not a tactic for subdividing a larger population that
USFWS has already determined, on the same information, warrants listing
throughout a larger range.'' The commenter also stated that a DPS
cannot be delisted until after it is first designated and after the
mandatory recovery planning process is completed for that particular
DPS and that to do otherwise would shortcut the process designed to
ensure public comment and peer review. Finally, this commenter asserted
that NMFS cannot conclude in a ``5-year review'' that a DPS can be
simultaneously designated and delisted because this practice conflicts
with the plain meaning and statutory requirements of section 4(c) of
the ESA. This commenter asserted that we apparently recognized the lack
of legal authority for our decision, so we claimed that we were not
designating DPSs to delist them, but rather dividing the currently
listed global population into 14 separate DPSs, downlisting two of
those DPSs, and not proposing to list ten of those DPSs. This commenter
further asserted that semantics cannot hide our actions, which
simultaneously designate previously unlisted DPSs and strips the
majority of those DPSs of all their ESA protections.
Response: We must base our listing determinations solely on the
best available scientific and commercial data, after considering
ongoing conservation efforts. Increasing abundance is one key
indication that a species no longer warrants listing (i.e., is not an
``endangered species'' or a ``threatened species''), but it is not the
only factor we considered, as we explained in our proposed rule (80 FR
22304; April 21, 2015 at 22316-22317). Rather, we have considered the
factors under section 4(a)(1) in conjunction with the species' current
demographic information. Further, it is important to understand the
function of the status review report prepared by the BRT as it relates
to our listing determinations. Convening a BRT to compile the best
available information about the species' status is an optional process
that helps inform, and does not supersede, the agency's listing
determinations. The BRT does not make decisions in its report. We,
NMFS, take into consideration the information provided by the BRT in
the status review report, but must also independently evaluate that
information in light of all factors that govern listing. We thus
evaluated the information in the status review report and other
information that became available to us and, after considering ongoing
conservation efforts, we developed our listing determinations.
With regard to our approach to identifying DPSs, see Rationale for
Revising the Listing Status of a Species Under the ESA above. As we
explained in the proposed rule and reaffirm here, we have developed a
rational approach that is consistent with both the statutory framework
and our obligation to ensure that only those species that actually
qualify for the protections of the ESA receive its protections. The
commenter's suggested approach of first listing individual DPSs is
untenable for the reasons we explained in the proposed rule and above:
Where it is clear by direct application of the 4(a)(1) factors that a
DPS does not presently qualify for listing, we have no authority to
list it separately. Thus it is simply illogical to suggest we must list
such a DPS in order to delist it. By evaluating the species
comprehensively throughout its range and assigning listing status to
each and every DPS, we have taken an approach that best fits the
statutory framework and fulfills our obligation to adjust the original
listing to reflect the species' actual circumstances. This approach
differs significantly from that reviewed in Humane Society of the
United States (HSUS) v. Jewell, 76 F. Supp. 3d 69 (D.D.C. 2014)
(Western Great Lakes gray wolf), appeal docketed, No. 15-5041 (D.C.
Cir. Feb. 19, 2015).
Further, we note that the DPS Policy does not set forth an
interpretation of what procedures should be followed in reclassifying a
species-wide listing into DPSs. However, the policy states that the
policy is adopted ``for the purposes of listing, delisting, and
reclassifying vertebrates . . . .'' 61 FR 4722 (emphasis added). Thus,
it does not provide support for the view that the DPS authority may
only be used to recognize and list populations. We thus respectfully
disagree with characterizing the Friends of the Wild Swan case to
[[Page 62267]]
suggest that the Services have no authority to consider replacing
existing species-wide listings with DPS listings. We note that the
facts here are not analogous to the agency action reviewed in that
case, which involved a petition to list where FWS had initially
concluded that listing of the entire species of bull trout was
``warranted but precluded'' but then, in a revised decision just a few
years later, shifted to considering listing of individual DPSs without
adequately explaining the basis for the shift in approach. Here, we
have extensively explained that after more than 40 years of listing
under the ESA, the scientific understanding of the population structure
of humpback whales, as well as the variations in the degree of threats
and rates of rebound, have reached the point that there is now a
scientific basis to identify DPSs, and that listing each DPS at the
appropriate level furthers the purposes of conservation management
under the ESA. It is eminently reasonable that, in light of this more
developed understanding, the agency has discretion to manage a
population of 10,000 individuals differently than it does a population
of less than 100 individuals.
To the extent this action may be said to constitute a delisting for
the nine DPSs that will not be listed, it is consistent with our
regulations at 50 CFR 424.11(d) because we would be delisting these
DPSs on ``the basis of recovery'' (Sec. 424.11(d)(2)). As that phrase
is used in the regulations, it means that ``the best scientific and
commercial data available indicate that [the species] is no longer
endangered or threatened'' (Sec. 424.11(d)(2)). We have determined,
after application of the section 4(a)(1) factors, that some of the DPSs
do not warrant listing--therefore, we find that they are no longer
endangered or threatened. Delisting determinations are to be based on
consideration of the same factors as listing determinations (50 CFR
424.11(b), (c)). The Services may directly apply the section 4(a)(1)
factors at any time (not just in the context of a ``5-year review'') to
determine whether a species continues to warrant protection under the
ESA and are not bound to apply recovery criteria developed in a
recovery plan. This is discussed further in response to the next
comment.
Comment 8: Some commenters raised the issue of the intersection of
this process with recovery planning. One commenter stated that on pages
59-60 (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22317), our proposed rule
explains that the original benchmarks for recovery established in the
U.S. Final Recovery Plan for humpback whales (NMFS 1991) (i.e., for
populations to achieve 60 percent of pre-whaling abundance) were not
prioritized in our status review. This commenter stated that data on
progress toward meeting the Recovery Plan abundance goal are now
available for the proposed DPSs in the Southern Hemisphere, as the
result of a Comprehensive Assessment undertaken by the Scientific
Committee of the IWC (IWC 2015). Although a similar effort for the
North Atlantic produced ambiguous results (IWC 2001; IWC 2002), the
commenter argues that this was likely due to the same uncertainties
about stock structure and population parameters that are a potential
concern in our status review. For the North Pacific, the commenter
notes that there are now more data available on whaling catches (e.g.,
Ivashchenko et al. 2013) as well as population size, structure, and
trend (Baker et al. 2013; Barlow et al. 2011). The commenter
recommended that we propose that the IWC undertake an assessment of the
recovery status of stocks in that ocean.
Response: As we have explained in the proposed rule, it is clear
that a recovery plan represents one potential pathway to improving the
status of the populations addressed in the plan, but does not establish
a binding or the only pathway for determining when a species no longer
qualifies for protection under the ESA. The criteria set forth in a
recovery plan are non-binding proxies for the section 4(a)(1) factors,
which are the governing considerations that must be applied in any
determination regarding the listing status of a species. The Services
(as the designees of the Secretaries of Commerce and of the Interior)
retain authority to directly apply the section 4(a)(1) factors at any
time to determine whether a species continues to warrant protection
under the ESA. The Services are, thus, not bound to apply recovery
criteria developed in a recovery plan (Friends of Blackwater v.
Salazar, 691 F.3d 428 (D.C. Cir. 2012)). This is particularly true
where adequate data do not exist to determine if the criteria are met,
as is the case here. As we discuss below, we find that it is not
possible on the basis of available information to determine if the
overall targets or interim goals of the plan for those populations the
recovery plan focused on are met. Further, we find that even if the
data were available they would not necessarily demonstrate that the
relevant DPSs should or should not continue to be listed.
At the outset, one must note that the 1991 Recovery Plan did not
address all populations of humpback whale; at the time the humpback was
listed globally with no recognized DPSs. The plan focused only on those
populations that occur in the North Atlantic and North Pacific. The
relevant DPSs implicated by the plan are: West Indies, Cape Verde
Islands/Northwest Africa, Western North Pacific, Hawaii, Mexico, and
Central America DPSs. Thus the plan simply would not apply to the
majority of the DPSs we now identify.
With regard to using the original benchmark for recovery
(populations achieving 60 percent of pre-whaling abundance), where
available, estimates of historical abundance can provide useful context
for setting recovery goals and are likely to be indicative of abundance
levels associated with low extinction risk. However, populations may
also be at low risk of extinction at abundance levels below historical
levels, and accurate estimates of historical abundance are not
essential for evaluating extinction risk. In the case of humpback
whales, the 1991 recovery plan noted that estimates of historical
abundance were highly uncertain and therefore specific numerical
targets based on those goals were not provided in the plan. That
situation remains true today, despite additional efforts to summarize
historical abundance. Because of this uncertainty and because a
comparison of current to historical abundance is not necessary for an
evaluation of extinction risk, the BRT elected to focus its extinction
risk analysis primarily on current abundance and trends relative to
benchmarks associated with low risk (See section III/C of Bettridge et
al., 2015).
One commenter suggested that we should be required to develop a
recovery plan particular to each DPS in order to preserve opportunities
for public comment and peer review. The development of recovery plans
under section 4(f) of the ESA is a non-regulatory process that
nevertheless includes receiving and considering public comment. The
Services solicit expert input and peer review of information used in
developing recovery plans (See ``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and
Plants: Notice of Interagency Cooperative Policy for Peer Review in
Endangered Species Act Activities.'' 59 FR 34270 (July 1, 1994)). The
comment does not cast doubt on our approach here. The ESA does not
require that a recovery plan must be developed before a determination
can be made that a species no longer qualifies for protection under
section 4(a)(1). Moreover, an opportunity for public comment and peer
review of the information underlying our
[[Page 62268]]
determinations has been made available in connection with our proposed
listing rule.
With regard to the recommendation that we propose that the IWC
undertake an assessment of the recovery status of stocks in the North
Pacific Ocean, we support any efforts to estimate population abundance
of humpback whales. However, recommending that the IWC undertake an
assessment of the recovery status of stocks in the North Pacific is
beyond the scope of this action. The ESA requires that we base our
determinations on the best available scientific and commercial
information. This standard does not require conduct of new studies, and
because we have sufficient data to support our proposed determinations,
there is no reason for us to defer implementing those decisions until
additional information becomes available. If additional information
becomes available at a later time that the commenter believes should
affect our determinations, a petition for consideration of the
information could be filed. In addition, we will continue to monitor
all DPSs (those that will not be listed will be monitored under the
Monitoring Plan that we are issuing today (see Monitoring Plan section
below), and the listed DPSs are reviewed periodically through the 5-
year review mechanism).
Comment 9: Several commenters stated that population numbers of
humpback whales were much higher historically, and humpback whales will
not be recovered until they reach pre-whaling numbers (i.e., historical
abundance, or carrying capacity), and they should remain listed as
endangered. One commenter argued that without an agreed upon and
established historical population baseline, it is impossible to
determine if humpback whales in the North Pacific qualify for
delisting. In addition, the commenter noted that some geographic areas
where humpback whales used to be observed do not appear to have been
recolonized (Gregr et al., 2000). The commenter stated that Fleming and
Jackson (2011) concluded that, despite observed positive population
trends over the past decade, the California-Oregon population likely
remains well below pre-exploitation size.
Response: The suggestion that humpback whales must remain listed
until they reach pre-whaling numbers is inconsistent with the relevant
legal standards under the ESA. A listing determination may be made at
any time by directly applying the section 4(a)(1) factors (please see
our response to Comment 8). Whether a species qualifies for listing
under the ESA depends on whether the species is in danger of extinction
or likely to become so within the foreseeable future as a result of one
or more of the factors described in section 4(a)(1) (See 16 U.S.C.
1533(a)(1)). If a species is viable at its current population levels
into the foreseeable future, it is irrelevant whether that population
level is or is not close to its historical levels.
Recovery under the ESA does not mean a species has attained its
historical abundance. It simply means that a species is no longer in
danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its
range or likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
As we stated under Rationale for Revising the Listing Status under
the ESA and in our response to Comment 8, to the extent that our action
may be found to constitute a delisting for the nine DPSs not proposed
for listing under the ESA, it is consistent with 50 CFR 424.11(d)
because we would be delisting these DPSs on ``the basis of recovery''
(Sec. 424.11(d)(2)). As discussed in the proposed rule (80 FR 22304;
April 21, 2015), we initially determined, after evaluating abundance
and trend information, the ESA section 4(a)(1) factors, and ongoing
conservation efforts, that ten humpback whale DPSs did not warrant
listing; therefore, we found that they were not endangered or
threatened. The Services have authority to apply ESA section 4(a)(1)
factors at any time, and we now finalize our determination that nine of
the DPSs do not warrant listing.
Comment 10: Several commenters noted that NMFS acknowledges that
surveys of humpback whales have not spanned 20 years since issuance of
the 1991 recovery plan and data are not available to evaluate the
status of humpback whale populations against these goals. Therefore,
one commenter added, the BRT focused its biological risk analysis
primarily on recent abundance trends and whether absolute abundance was
sufficient for biological viability. This commenter asserted that there
are a number of populations for which there are 20 years of data
against which to measure growth and, as such, it is inappropriate to
disregard the recovery plan.
The commenter also stated that NMFS references the 3.5 percent
population growth rate from the recovery plan for some southern ocean
DPSs, though the plan focused only on the North Pacific and North
Atlantic populations. This commenter also suggested that there are 20
years of data indicating that the West Indies DPS has not met recovery
plan targets and the agency has instead proposed to entirely remove the
protections of the ESA. One of the other commenters noted that it is
obvious that in the past 20 years, the North Pacific humpback whale
population, on an ocean-basin scale, has achieved the interim goal of
doubling population size. Another commenter stated that, given that we
initiated the ESA status review process just 2 years prior to the two-
decade threshold, the commenter believes that it would still be worth
evaluating progress toward that management goal of doubling the
population within 20 years.
Response: A recovery plan is not binding on the Services and does
not represent the only path toward a determination that a species no
longer warrants protection under the ESA (please see our response to
Comment 8). While estimated population growth rate has been calculated
for six of the 14 DPSs (but only two of the DPSs in the North Pacific
and North Atlantic, which was the focus of the 1991 Recovery Plan)
based on data since the Recovery Plan was issued, we do not think the
available data allow directly evaluating whether the Recovery Plan
criteria have been met. The plan was a forward-looking document that
specified that the doubling of the population size was to be over a 20-
year period from that point in time (``within 20 years''); it would not
make sense to evaluate progress toward a doubled population using data
collected before the plan was even developed. As we stated in our
proposed rule, surveys from which abundance estimates could be
estimated in order to estimate population growth rate were not
separated by 20 years or conducted continuously over that period. To
achieve a doubling of the population would require a 3.5 percent
average annual growth rate to occur over the course of 20 years; if the
trend is only documented for less than 20 years, this does not
establish that the population is on track to doubling.
Further, the BRT concluded (personal communication, Paul Wade,
NMFS, Northwest Fisheries Science Center, BRT member), and we agree,
that the Recovery Plan goal of doubling the population within 20 years
is not an appropriate proxy for applying the section 4(a)(1) factors in
the context of current abundance for evaluating extinction risk. One
reason this metric is not an adequate proxy for applying the section
4(a)(1) factors is that if a population approaches carrying capacity
(K), the growth rate will be expected to decrease. A population could
have recovered to K, but this would only be known if the entire 20-year
period was documented, including the early time period with the faster
[[Page 62269]]
growth rate. This is why the BRT decided to rely on absolute population
size as indicating the relative extinction risk of each DPS due to
small population size alone, with trend information as supplemental.
We referenced the 3.5 percent population growth rate for some of
the DPSs in the Southern Hemisphere, even though the 1991 recovery plan
that recommended an interim goal of doubling the population size (which
translates to a 3.5 percent average annual population growth rate)
focused on humpback whales in the North Pacific and North Atlantic.
However, we did not measure population growth rate against that 3.5
percent target; we included it only as a point of reference as part of
our summary of the best available scientific and commercial
information. The BRT and we evaluated whether growth rates were
increasing, stable, or decreasing as part of the extinction risk
analysis, not whether they were greater than or equal to 3.5 percent.
To be clear, then, whether a specific DPS' growth trend was at or above
the interim recovery goals set out for certain populations in the 1991
Recovery Plan did not play a role in our determinations.
Comment 11: The State of Washington indicated that individuals of
the Mexico DPS comprise the majority of humpback whales feeding off
Washington. A threatened status for the Central America DPS will
encourage NMFS and others to continue efforts to mitigate threats off
the west coast. Another commenter expressed concern that creation of
the DPS construct complicates management and dilutes the effectiveness
of any plan as a species saving effort. Another commenter stated that
the status review report did not include information that allows
understanding of the proportion of each stock/DPS along the eastern
Pacific that uses the North American feeding areas (i.e., from
California through the Aleutians) such that takes might be assigned
proportionately to a stock on the basis of their proportionate use of
the area as NMFS has done in its management of lethal takes of mixed
species of pilot whales in the Atlantic.
This same commenter stated that, even if NMFS determines that the
Mexico and Hawaii DPSs are recovered, NMFS must retain ESA protections
for these DPSs because of similarity of appearance. This commenter
noted that mixing of breeding stocks in a single feeding area
complicates any threat analysis and will confound determination of
stock identity when anthropogenic mortalities that occur in a mixed
feeding area need to be attributed to the appropriate stock. This
commenter pointed to NMFS' treatment of progeny of naturally spawned
adults of west coast salmon (all progeny are protected as ``naturally
spawned'' because offspring of hatchery-born salmon adults cannot
easily be distinguished from their wild counterparts (70 FR 37,160;
June 28, 2005, at 37,166)) to show how NMFS ensures appropriate levels
of protection for listed species where there is overlap between listed
and non-listed populations.
The commenter also attempted to draw support for protecting all
DPSs from the provisions of the statute and regulations governing
recognition of experimental populations, citing: (1) 16 U.S.C.
1539(j)(1) and 50 CFR 17.80(a) (``where part of an experimental
population overlaps with a natural population of the same species . . .
specimens of the experimental populations will not be recognized as
such while in the area of overlap''; (2) United States v. McKittrick,
142 F.3d 1170, 1174-75 (9th Cir. 1998) (``When experimental and
nonexperimental populations overlap--even if the overlap occurs
seasonally--section 10(j) populations lose their experimental
status.''); and (3) H.R. Rep. No. 97-567 at 33 (1982), reprinted in
1982 U.S.C.C.A.N. 2807, 2833 (legislative history of section 10(j)
stressing that ``in the case of the introduction of individuals of a
listed fish species into a portion of a stream where the same species
already occurs, the introduced specimens would not be treated as an
`experimental population' separate from the non-introduced
specimens'').
While this commenter believes that delisting or downlisting of any
DPS is inappropriate at this time, if a downlisting occurs and NMFS
does not retain ESA protections for all DPSs, this commenter recommends
that mortality or injury in a feeding area with mixed breeding stocks
be attributed to the listed DPS with the most protected status unless
it can definitively be determined that it does not belong to that DPS.
Response: Once a DPS is identified, it is considered a species
under the ESA. Listing DPSs separately can complicate management when
DPSs of different status mix. In particular, when listed species mix
with non-listed species, it is important to ensure that the listed
species is protected. We have concluded in this final rule that the
Mexico DPS is threatened instead of ``not warranted,'' and the Central
America DPS is endangered instead of threatened (please see the Mexico
DPS and Central America DPS sections for our rationale). We are
extending the section 9 prohibitions to threatened humpback whales,
which at this time includes the Mexico DPS, and these same prohibitions
are automatically applied to the endangered Central America DPS. Where
humpback whales from different DPSs mix on feeding grounds, such as is
the case off the coast of Alaska where the non-listed Hawaii DPS mixes
with the listed Western North Pacific and Mexico DPSs, we will continue
to work with partners to mitigate threats to all humpback whales,
regardless of their ESA listing status, because all whales remain
protected under the MMPA. We recognize the need for an approach that
will allow us to determine which DPSs have been affected by directed or
incidental take or may be affected by Federal actions subject to
consultation under section 7. As we have for other species (e.g.,
Pacific salmon), we will likely use a proportional approach to indicate
which DPSs are affected by any takes based upon the best available
science of what DPSs are present, depending on location and timing
where take occurred. We have not finalized this approach, but it will
be fluid and based upon the best available science as it changes with
increased understanding.
With regard to the commenter's suggestion that we protect the
Hawaii and Mexico DPSs based on similarity of appearance, we disagree
that the authority to list based on ``similarity of appearance'' should
be invoked here. The statute affords discretion to extend protections
to a non-imperiled species based on similarity of appearance only where
all three criteria of ESA section 4(e) are met. Specifically, section
4(e) of the ESA provides that the Secretary ``may, by regulation of
commerce or taking, and to the extent he deems advisable'' treat any
species as an endangered species or threatened species even though it
is not listed under section 4 of the ESA if he finds that:
(A) Such species so closely resembles in appearance, at the
point in question, a species which has been listed pursuant to such
section that enforcement personnel would have substantial difficulty
in attempting to differentiate between the listed and unlisted
species;
(B) the effect of this substantial difficulty is an additional
threat to an endangered or threatened species; and
(C) such treatment of an unlisted species will substantially
facilitate the enforcement and further the policy of this chapter.
16 U.S.C. 1533(e).
This authority allows the Services to treat a species that is not
itself imperiled as a listed species for certain purposes
[[Page 62270]]
in very limited situations. Criterion A under section 4(e) of the ESA
is met for humpback whales because humpback whales from different DPSs
are not readily distinguishable in areas where two or more DPSs
overlap. Criteria B and C are not met. There is no incentive for people
to ``take'' humpback whales and claim they thought they were taking a
different species, because there is no (legal) trade in those products.
Therefore, the effect of this substantial difficulty in assigning a
humpback whale to a particular DPS does not pose an additional threat
to the listed DPS. And finally, treating the unlisted DPS as a listed
DPS will not facilitate enforcement of laws against take of humpback
whales from a listed DPS. Therefore, we did not propose to protect non-
listed DPSs of the humpback whale based on grounds of similarity of
appearance to listed DPSs and we do not find a basis to do so in this
final rule. However, we note that we changed our listing determination
for the Mexico DPS, and, as noted above, we are listing it as a
threatened species under the ESA and extending the section 9
prohibitions to the DPS so that it will be protected under the ESA.
Finally, in response to the comments citing to the statutory and
regulatory provisions of section 10(j) and related case law, we note
that the authority to designate experimental populations is completely
separate from making listing determinations under section 4. That
authority is designed to allow the Services to introduce or reintroduce
species to areas where they do not currently occur. We are not
proposing to take such an action here, and there is no basis to
conclude that Congress intended the specific provisions relating to the
10(j) authority to apply more broadly. Had Congress intended that
result, it could have chosen to do so explicitly, but it did not. Thus
the portions of the comments relating to 10(j) are simply not relevant
or informative here.
Comment 12: One commenter noted that humpback whales migrate
between the equator and the poles and that, therefore, no population of
whales around the globe is entirely protected within the borders of any
one country. Regardless of their protected status in the United States,
this movement leaves protected animals vulnerable to hunting as they
migrate across the borders of whaling countries. Several commenters
argued that delisting of any humpback whale populations by the United
States will weaken the perception of their protected status, and signal
to other countries that the United States approves and encourages
hunting humpback whales, particularly in waters beyond the exclusive
economic zone (EEZ). Another commenter added that the overlap in ranges
of many populations of humpback whales would provide a perfect excuse
for whaling nations to hunt protected populations. The commenter
indicated there would be no way to prove whalers had violated the
protection, as there would be much confusion as to which population
they were actually hunting in the overlapping territories. Another
commenter asserted that Japan, Norway, Iceland, former Soviet
Republics, and others have gained votes and allies on the IWC to open
up hunting to the larger baleen whales. The commenter believes that
tropical nations, where humpbacks congregate to calf and mate, can be
incentivized for votes at the IWC to support hunting of humpbacks in
their waters. Many other commenters stated that whaling would start
again if humpback whales were no longer protected under the ESA.
Response: We are confident that whaling will not resume as a result
of not including nine humpback whale DPSs on the ESA List of Endangered
and Threatened Wildlife. The IWC's commercial whaling moratorium
implemented by the IWC in 1986 remains in effect as a needed
conservation measure for whale stocks worldwide. We have no indications
that the status quo will be changed, and thus conclude on the basis of
the best available scientific and commercial information that the
commercial whaling moratorium will continue to be in effect for the
foreseeable future. In addition, the humpback whale is currently an
Appendix I species under the Convention for International Trade in
Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), which restricts
international trade and provides an additional layer of protection
against resumed whaling. Regarding scientific whaling, there are
currently no countries hunting humpback whales for scientific research
and we have no information to indicate there are plans to do so in the
foreseeable future. Regarding subsistence whaling, we have no reason to
believe that the small number of West Indies DPS humpback whales killed
for subsistence (see our response to Comment 42) will increase because
the DPS is not listed.
Comment 13: Many commenters asserted that it is premature to remove
ESA protections from some humpback whale populations, as the research
needs to be updated (e.g., address questions about population
abundance, trends and risks), and a precautionary approach should be
taken to protecting these iconic animals. One commenter asserted that
NMFS seeks to completely delist from the ESA some of the 14 populations
it has identified, relying largely on a ``speculative'' approach using
qualitative information that is contrary to the clear mandates of the
ESA (``The obvious purpose of the requirement that agencies ``use the
best scientific and commercial data available'' is to ensure that the
ESA not be implemented haphazardly, on the basis of speculation or
surmise'' (Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154 (1997)). This commenter
asserted that we should not rely on qualitative data to strip ESA
protections, as ``[T]his is highly risk prone and an affront to the
``institutionalized caution'' Congress embodied in the ESA'' (Tennessee
Valley Authority (TVA) v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153 (1978)). Several other
commenters said that we should use the precautionary principle when
there are so many uncertainties in the scientific data (e.g., unknown
trends for several DPSs; unknown effects of climate change,
contaminants, and harmful algal blooms (HABs); transfer rates of
contaminants to calves; chronic, sublethal impacts of contaminants).
Another commenter asserted that NMFS' proposed rule was not based on
the best available science as NMFS failed to consider a number of
scientific reports published after 2011.
Response: We are required to base our decisions solely on the best
available scientific and commercial data, a standard that does not
require certainty. The use of qualitative data is appropriate if they
are the best available. We have quantitative abundance estimates for
each humpback whale DPS, although some of these estimates are
associated with large confidence intervals (meaning that there is
relatively less certainty as to their accuracy when compared to
estimates with small confidence intervals). While we have quantitative
trend information for some DPSs, we do not have it for others, though
for most we have at least a qualitative estimate. Regardless of whether
the data are quantitative or qualitative, we must use our best
professional judgment to determine whether a species meets the
definition of an ``endangered species'' or a ``threatened species.''
When new data become available, we can reinitiate a status review on
our own or in response to a petition. New information can also be
evaluated during the 5-year reviews that are required under ESA section
4(c)(2).
With regard to whether the ``precautionary'' approach should be
applied and whether that should lead to
[[Page 62271]]
retaining the species' current listing status for each DPS, section 4
of the ESA requires that we base listing determinations solely on the
best available scientific and commercial data. It is well established
that this standard does not require certainty in the data supporting
the agency's decision but instead charges NMFS to apply professional
judgment to identify significant uncertainties and determine how to
proceed in light of them. Moreover, where the fundamental question of
whether a species meets the foundational tests for requiring the ESA's
protections under section 4(a)(1) is at issue, the context is
significantly different from cases arising under other provisions of
the ESA, such as section 7 consultations, where legislative history and
case law indicate that significant uncertainties should be resolved
against action agencies. Thus, the commenter's citation to TVA v. Hill
(437 U.S. 153 (1978)) is not pertinent. Congress vested NMFS ``with
discretion to make listing decisions based on consideration of the
relevant statutory factors using the best scientific information
available'' (Trout Unlimited v. Lohn, 645 F. Supp. 2d 929, 947 (D. Or.
2007)).
Each of our determinations is supported by the best available
scientific and commercial information, and we have evaluated the data
for each particular DPS carefully and deliberately. While there are
some uncertainties in the data--as there almost always are in every
case of scientific information--we have identified the relevant,
significant uncertainties, discussed them, and explained our decisions
in light of them. Where those uncertainties are particularly
significant, we have erred on the side of retaining protections for the
DPS (and, in the case of the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central
America DPSs, have increased the level of protection from that in our
proposed rule). Indeed, one commenter expressed the opposite concern
from that raised by this commenter, accusing NMFS of ``abusing'' the
precautionary approach by listing the Western North Pacific DPS (see
response to Comment 44).
In response to the comment that the proposed rule did not rely on
the best available information because we had not yet considered
certain scientific papers published after 2011, this comment fails to
take into account the important information-gathering and consideration
that takes place during the public comment period as well as the
iterative nature of agency decisionmaking. In all scientific
decisionmaking, there must come a point in time where the search for
new information pauses while the information already possessed is
analyzed and reviewed. It would be unreasonable to expect that the BRT
was searching the literature during the entire time between initiation
of the status review and issuance of the final status review report.
The BRT was presented with a draft compilation of available literature
when it first convened, and the team members were tasked to update that
compilation at a point prior to completion of the draft report. Once
the BRT had substantially completed its draft report, NMFS reviewed the
BRT findings and developed the proposed rule. Our proposed rule invited
comment and submission of any additional, relevant information for
consideration in development of the final rule. This iterative process
ensures that all available information is considered for the final
rule.
Further, the Monitoring Plan that we are implementing for those
DPSs that do not warrant listing helps ensure these DPSs are managed
appropriately in light of all threats, including those that may worsen.
For any DPSs that are listed, monitoring is as a matter of course,
pursuant to the obligation to periodically review the status of these
species (ESA section 4(c)(2)). Finally, though not directly relevant to
our listing determinations, we note that the non-listed DPSs will
continue to be protected under the MMPA.
Comment 14: Many commenters requested that we keep all humpback
whale populations listed under the ESA, as MMPA protection may not be
effective if ``delisting'' is perceived as ``no longer protected.''
These commenters said that population numbers may have increased, but
they may not stay at a safe population size because of noise, water
pollution, climate change, vessel collisions, and habitat destruction.
Response: Regardless of whether they are also listed under the ESA,
marine mammals are protected under the MMPA. The MMPA's provisions
include prohibitions on take in U.S. waters and by U.S. citizens on the
high seas. We based our listing determinations on the best available
data, including an evaluation of available information on threat
levels. Where we are not listing a DPS as threatened or endangered, it
is because we have determined that, based on the best available data,
the DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant
portion of its range or likely to become so within the foreseeable
future. We discuss the related issue of whether the previously listed
populations retain ``depleted'' status under the MMPA, below.
Comment 15: Canada's Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO)
commented that, in 2003, the Committee on the Status of Endangered
Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC) assessed the western North Atlantic
humpback whale population as ``not at risk,'' which is consistent with
NMFS' proposed designation for the West Indies DPS from which the
Canadian western North Atlantic population derives. In 2003, COSEWIC
assessed the North Pacific humpback whale population as ``threatened,''
and in 2005 the population was listed as such under Canada's Species at
Risk Act (SARA). COSEWIC reassessed this population as ``special
concern'' in 2011 and confirmed the ``special concern'' status of this
population in 2013. In response to this ``special concern'' assessment,
the North Pacific humpback whale population is being considered for
reclassification as ``special concern'' under SARA. Humpback whales
from the proposed Hawaii, Mexico, and Central America DPSs contribute
to the population that frequents Canadian waters. The proposed ``not at
risk'' status for the Hawaii and Mexico DPSs is lower than the current
(threatened) or potential (special concern) SARA status of the Canadian
North Pacific humpback whale population. Therefore, the proposed ``not
at risk'' designation for the Hawaii and Mexico DPSs would not offer
the species the current or potential level of protection in Canada. The
proposed status of ``threatened'' for the Central America DPS aligns
with the North Pacific Humpback Whale current designation as
``threatened'' under SARA.
Response: We appreciate the detailed information provided by
Canada's DFO. While it may appear that the status categories under the
ESA (``endangered,'' ``threatened,'' ``candidate,'' and ``not
warranted'') correlate to those under the SARA (``endangered,''
``threatened,'' ``special concern,'' and ``not at risk''), the ESA and
SARA use different criteria to assess the status of species. Therefore,
a species listed as ``threatened'' under the ESA might not be at the
same level of extinction risk as one listed as ``threatened'' under
SARA. However, we recognize that the Hawaii DPS will not be protected
under the ESA in U.S. waters or on the high seas (with respect to U.S.
citizens) and it will be protected in Canadian waters (until the
Canadian North Pacific population is reclassified as ``special
concern,'' if this happens). All humpback whales will continue to
receive significant protection from taking under the MMPA in U.S.
waters
[[Page 62272]]
and by U.S. citizens on the high seas. And while we did not propose to
list the Mexico DPS as threatened or endangered and we proposed to list
the Central America DPS as threatened, we are now listing the Mexico
DPS as threatened and the Central America DPS as endangered (please see
the Mexico DPS and Central America DPS sections). Canada's DFO is
correct that the Central America DPS will receive essentially the same
protections under both the ESA and SARA. The Mexico DPS will, too,
because we are extending the section 9 prohibitions to threatened
humpback whales.
Comment 16: Several commenters expressed support for our decision
to list the Western North Pacific DPS and Central America DPS (as
threatened) and to list the Arabian Sea and Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS (as endangered).
Response: We acknowledge the commenters' support. Please see the
Western North Pacific DPS, the Mexico DPS, and the Central America DPS
sections for our rationale for listing the Mexico DPS as threatened and
for reaching the determination of ``endangered'' for the Western North
Pacific and Central America DPSs.
Comment 17: One commenter stated that NMFS' proposal is not based
on the best available science because it fails to properly define and
analyze the risk of extinction in the foreseeable future. The commenter
asserted that there are two problems with our approach to weighing
extinction risk: (1) Improper use of a 60-year timeframe for risk
assessment; and (2) failure to properly apply the chosen 60-year time
frame. The commenter stated that, in prior listing decisions and
recovery plans for whale species, NMFS consistently uses longer time
frames to evaluate extinction risk, generally 100 years. In the case of
both North Atlantic and North Pacific right whales, the commenter
argued, 100 years was used, and this was based on conclusions from a
large whale recovery criteria workshop (Angliss et al. 2002). The
commenter suggested that NMFS provided no explanation or justification
for the foreseeable future used in this rulemaking. The commenter
suggests that, despite claiming to analyze future impacts, the threats
analysis references ``current'' risks, but contains no analysis of the
risk of extinction posed by reasonably foreseeable future impacts. The
commenter also suggests that the extinction risk approach improperly
``raised the bar'' for the threatened category and cites to the
unreported decision in Western Watersheds Project v. Foss, No. CV-04-
168, 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 45753, *49 (D. Idaho Aug. 19, 2005) for the
proposition that it is inappropriate to evaluate ``high risk of
extinction'' over the ``foreseeable future.'' The commenter states that
this focus on current threats also fails to recognize that, while the
definition of a ``threatened'' species is necessarily forward-looking,
so, too, is the definition of an ``endangered species.'' Simply put, a
species ``in danger'' of extinction is not currently extinct. Rather,
it is a species facing a risk of extinction in the future.
Response: The commenter's suggestion that it is improper to use
different time periods for different listing determinations or recovery
plans (the latter of which are not binding regulatory documents)
misunderstands the nature of the determination of ``foreseeable
future.'' As we explained in the proposed rule and summarized in the
introductory paragraphs of this final rule, the concept of the
``foreseeable future'' must be determined and applied specifically for
each species undergoing a status review or listing determination under
the ESA in order to consider whether a species is a threatened species.
See, e.g., In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and 4(d)
Rule Litigation, 794 F. Supp. 2d 65, 95 (D.D.C. 2011) (``As with the
term `likely,' Congress has not defined the term ``foreseeable future''
under the ESA . . . .''). Instead of using an inflexible quantitative
standard, ``a `foreseeable future' determination is made on the basis
of the agency's reasoned judgment in light of the best available
science for the species under consideration.'' id.
In its status review report, the BRT determined that 60 years was
the appropriate time period over which it could reasonably predict the
humpback whale's responses to threats. We agreed with the BRT's
rationale and thus adopted the 60-year period as the ``foreseeable
future'' for this listing determination. Nothing the commenter cites
undercuts the basis for the foreseeable future identified for this
rulemaking. The 1991 Recovery Plan for the Northern Right Whale
(Eubalaena glacialis) (NMFS 1991) included several criteria for
reclassification from ``endangered'' to ``threatened,'' one of which
was that the species has less than a 1 percent probability of going
extinct in 100 years. Similarly, it included several criteria for
delisting, one of which was that the species has less than a 10 percent
probability of becoming endangered in 25 years. The timeframes of 100
years and 25 years as used in the large whale recovery criteria
workshop referred to by the commenter are part of a population
viability analysis (x percent chance of extinction in y years); they do
not refer to the foreseeable future as used under the ESA. As explained
above, the ``foreseeable future'' is generally defined for each species
based on how far into the future we may reliably project individual
threats as well as the species' response to those threats. Here, for
the reasons already explained, 60 years was articulated by both the BRT
and NMFS as the appropriate timeframe.
Even if equivalency in ``foreseeable future'' determinations among
species with similar life history traits was required, there is no
basis to compare the foreseeable future for humpback whales with any
``foreseeable future'' for the Cook Inlet beluga whale, North Pacific
right whale, and North Atlantic right whale because we did not define
foreseeable future periods for any of the latter three species. Our
extinction risk analyses for these species concluded that these species
were all endangered; thus, we did not need to define foreseeable future
for these species; the ``foreseeable future'' concept is relevant only
to consideration of ``threatened'' status, which is unnecessary where
we have determined the species meets the higher standard for
``endangered.'' The 100-year period the commenter refers to is simply
one of two timeframes over which we estimated the risk of extinction
for the Cook Inlet beluga whale (the other timeframe was 300 years) in
the context of a population viability analysis. Neither we nor the BRT
mentioned a 100-year time period in any context in the North Atlantic
and North Pacific right whale status reviews, proposed listing rule, or
final listing determination. There is no requirement that the same time
period used to forecast effects as a matter of scientific modeling must
be chosen as the ``foreseeable future'' for the listing determination
for that species. Determining the appropriate ``foreseeable future''
for a listing decision involves the professional judgment of the
resource managers, who must determine at what point it is no longer
reasonable to make official predictions about threats and the species'
response. Thus, while a particular period may have been chosen to
underlie a PVA in order to generate useful information, that same
period will not necessarily be equivalent to the foreseeable future
adopted for the ultimate listing decision. Indeed, it is not required
that the foreseeable future be quantified as a specific number of years
at any point for any listing decision.
Recovery criteria remain case-specific. Further, there is no
requirement under
[[Page 62273]]
the ESA to define extinction risk in quantitative terms; there is
``nothing in the text or structure of the statute to compel the
conclusion that Congress intended to bind the agency to a particular
formula for determining when a species is `in danger of extinction.' ''
In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and 4(d) Rule
Litigation, 748 F. Supp. 2d 19, 27 (D.D.C. 2010). Rather, ``[t]he
overall structure of the ESA suggests that the definition of an
endangered species was `intentionally left ambiguous,' '' and
``Congress broadly delegated responsibility to the Secretary to
determine whether a species is `in danger of extinction' in light of
the five statutory listing factors and the best available science for
that species.'' Id.
Under the ESA, in order to list a species as threatened, we must
conclude that the species is likely to become in danger of extinction
throughout all or a significant portion of its range within the
foreseeable future. For the humpback whale, the BRT and NMFS defined
the foreseeable future as 60 years. The classifications used by the BRT
for its extinction risk assessment appropriately maintained the
temporal distinction between risk that currently exists and risk that
will become manifest within the foreseeable future. Here, the BRT
specifically defined the ``high risk of extinction'' category to
measure near-term risk, while the ``moderate risk of extinction''
category incorporates the foreseeable future (Bettridge et al. 2015 at
67-68). The commenter is thus flatly incorrect in the suggestion that
the BRT or NMFS conflated the threatened category with the endangered
category, and the citation to Western Watersheds Project v. Foss is
inapposite.
When we reviewed the BRT's extinction risk conclusions, and then
evaluated ongoing conservation efforts as we are required to do, we
agreed with the BRT's conclusions. For those DPSs that the BRT
determined were at ``moderate risk of extinction,'' we generally
concluded that the DPSs were likely to become endangered over the next
60 years (threatened). For those DPSs that the BRT concluded were at
``high risk of extinction,'' we generally concluded that the DPSs were
in danger of extinction currently (endangered). (However, for this
final rule we have applied greater levels of protection than the BRT
votes would predict for three DPSs. Please see our rationale for
reconsidering our listing determinations for the Western North Pacific
(Western North Pacific DPS section), Mexico (Mexico DPS section), and
Central America (Central America DPS section) DPSs.) We agree with the
commenter that the definitions of ``threatened'' species and
``endangered species'' are forward looking (i.e., a species ``in
danger'' of extinction is not currently extinct; rather, it is a
species facing a risk of extinction at an undefined point in the
future). We did consider that the threats we can reliably predict will
act on the species within the foreseeable future.
Comment 18: One commenter stated that the ESA is enforced in U.S.
waters, and that other countries recognize and respect this and may
assign statuses under their acts. The commenter asserted that other
status classifications, such as the International Union for
Conservation of Nature (IUCN), are likely to be removed in response to
removing humpback whales from the ESA list.
Response: The ESA is enforced in U.S. waters and on the high seas
for persons subject to U.S. jurisdiction. The ESA requires us to make
our determinations in accordance with the best available scientific and
commercial information without regard to what other countries might do
with regard to conservation status of species under their jurisdiction.
With regard to IUCN, species classifications under the ESA and the IUCN
Red List are not equivalent. Data standards, criteria used to evaluate
species status, and treatment of uncertainty are not considered
similarly, and the legal effect is not the same.
Unlike the ESA, the IUCN Red List is not a statute and is not a
legally binding or regulatory instrument. It does not include legally
binding requirements, prohibitions, or guidance for the protection of
threatened (i.e., critically endangered, endangered, or vulnerable)
taxa (IUCN 2012). Rather, it provides taxonomic, conservation status,
and distribution information on species. The IUCN Red List is based on
a system of categories and criteria designed to determine the relative
risk of extinction (http://www.iucnredlist.org/about/introduction),
classifying species in one of nine categories, as determined via
quantitative criteria, including population size reductions, range
reductions, small population size, and quantitative extinction risk.
Whether the IUCN removes status classifications as a result of an ESA
listing determination is not relevant to the ESA's requirement that we
base listing determinations solely on the best available scientific and
commercial data.
Having said this, the IUCN classified the humpback whale as ``least
concern'' in 2008.
Comment 19: Several commenters asserted that we underestimated the
risks of oil spills to humpback whales.
Response: We do not agree that we underestimated the risks of oil
spills to humpback whales. We discussed this risk in our proposed rule
(80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22321), concluding that long-term
ingestion of pollutants, including oil residues, could affect
reproduction, but that data are lacking to determine how oil may fit
into this scheme for humpback whales. The effects of oil spills are
generally associated with low probabilities of occurrence, and are
generally localized in nature. Documented impacts from these activities
in the past have been minimal. Therefore, we do not believe that we
have underestimated the risks of oil spills, and we have accurately
portrayed the effect of oil and gas activities on the status of the
species within the foreseeable future.
Comment 20: One commenter noted that humpback whales off Southern
California and Asia are known to have high levels of
dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, polychlorinated biphenyls, and other
persistent organic pollutants (Elfes et al. 2010).
Response: We considered Elfes et al. (2010), but when this
information is combined with all of the other information presented on
contaminants in the status review report (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 41-
42), we agreed with the BRT that the severity of this threat was low in
all regions, except where lack of data indicated a finding of unknown.
Even where the extent of risk is unknown, it is not enough to place any
DPS in danger of extinction presently or within the foreseeable future.
Regardless, we are listing the Western North Pacific and Central
America DPSs as endangered and the Mexico DPS as threatened for other
reasons (see the Western North Pacific DPS, Mexico DPS, and Central
America DPS sections for our rationale). These are the DPSs that occur
off Southern California and Asia.
Comment 21: One commenter stated that the ESA section 4(a)(1)
factors must be addressed before a species can be delisted. For
example, the commenter noted, contaminants were given a risk score of
``low'' or ``none'' for both the Mexico and Central America DPSs, both
of which are acknowledged to feed off the coast of California. However,
the commenter continued, the text of the status review report cites
data indicating that ``contaminant levels have been proposed as a
causative factor in lower reproductive rates found among humpback
whales off Southern
[[Page 62274]]
California.'' Another commenter pointed to the increased number of
fishing gear entanglements off California, Oregon, and Washington in
2015 as cause for concern for the Mexico and Central America DPSs.
Response: While it is true that individuals from both the Mexico
and Central America DPSs feed off the coast of California, we are not
aware of any evidence to indicate that either of the DPSs is being
negatively impacted because of lower reproductive rates. We cited data
indicating that ``contaminant levels have been proposed as a causative
factor in lower reproductive rates found among humpback whales off
Southern California'' (Steiger and Calambokidis 2000), but we also
added that, ``at present the threshold level for negative effects, and
transfer rates to calves, are unknown for humpback whales'' and ``[t]he
health effects of different doses of contaminants are currently unknown
for humpback whales (Krahn et al. 2004c).'' While Steiger and
Calambokidis (2000) clearly state that contaminants could be one of
several possible causes of the observed lower rates of reproduction
amongst these whales (which are still increasing, just not as rapidly
as other groups), they do not point to contaminants as the primary or
sole cause; they actually indicate that mysticetes are thought to have
lower exposure to contaminants such as hydrocarbons than pinnipeds and
odontocetes. We do not have much information from recent humpback whale
strandings that could shed light on either contaminant loads or their
possible effects on reproduction. We will continue to monitor the
health of humpback whales, whether they are listed under the ESA or
not.
Regarding the higher number of whale entanglement reports made in
2015 off California, Oregon, and Washington, this may be attributable
to changes in the number and distribution of whales in recent years,
and/or changes in the distribution of fishing and other human
activities, which are, in part, influenced by environmental conditions.
We are working to better understand and predict how all these factors
may be impacting whales off the west coast. Broader public awareness
may also be contributing to the recent increase in entanglement
reports. Increasing awareness about whale entanglements and available
reporting mechanisms is a focus of our outreach. We have also been
working with trained and authorized responders along the west coast to
increase their capacity to respond to entanglement reports and train
new responders in reporting and response techniques--additional
outreach that may be contributing to the 2015 numbers. However, the
fact is that the number of reported fishing gear entanglements have
increased, and therefore, we continue to view this threat as posing a
moderate risk to the Mexico and Central America DPSs.
Comment 22: Several commenters stated that prey depletion in terms
of competition from fisheries is a significant threat to humpback
whales.
Response: We have no evidence of prey depletion contributing
significantly to the extinction risk of any DPS of the humpback whale.
It is conceivable that reduction of forage fish could cause shifts in
the feeding range of humpback whales to areas with more threats from
fishing gear, commercial shipping, or areas not under U.S.
jurisdiction. However, we have no information to indicate that the fish
species that humpback whales prey upon are reduced in number or will be
reduced in number in the foreseeable future to the point where the
feeding ranges of humpback whales are changing.
In Alaska, for example, herring are the only forage fish species
with a directed fishery, unless we consider juvenile pollock and salmon
(the only life stage of these fishes that humpback whales eat), which
have fisheries targeting the adults and not the juveniles. Krill are
probably the dominant prey item for humpback whales in Alaska, and have
no directed harvest. Herring fisheries in Alaska are managed with a
fairly conservative guideline harvest rate and a minimum biomass
threshold before fishing is permitted. In Prince William Sound, we
found that humpback whales were consuming 15-20 percent of the pre-
spawning biomass of herring; this rate is sustainable and roughly what
the fishery would take, if the fishery were open. Humpback whales in
Prince William Sound appear to be the most herring-focused whales in
Alaskan waters based on diet analysis, and likely represent the high
end of humpback whale dependency on herring.
The BRT discussed the high level of fishing pressure in the region
occupied by the Okinawa/Philippines portion of the Western North
Pacific DPS (a small humpback whale population). Although specific
information on prey abundance and competition between whales and
fisheries is not known in this area, overlap of whales and fisheries
has been indicated by the bycatch of humpback whales in set-nets in the
area. The BRT determined that competition with fisheries is a medium
threat to the Okinawa/Philippines portion of the Western North Pacific
DPS (which will be listed as an endangered species), given the high
level of fishing and small humpback whale population, and a low or
unknown threat for all other DPSs (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 56).
Comment 23: Many commenters expressed concern about whale watch
vessels approaching humpback whales too closely or at high speeds. One
commenter asserted that some of the worst harassment is currently seen
within marine sanctuary areas because of lack of enforcement, and that
this results in displacement of humpback whales through disturbance,
harassment, and the abandonment of areas by the whales. The commenter
provided examples of harassment from whale watchers a few miles out of
Auke Bay off Juneau, AK, off Maui, HI, and in Stellwagen Bank in MA.
This commenter urges us to maintain ESA protections for humpback
whales.
Response: Stellwagen Bank National Marine Sanctuary (SBNMS) is
working with NMFS and other sanctuary partners to educate the public,
deter harassment, and encourage responsible stewardship among whale
watchers in the sanctuary, including through development of whale
watching guidelines for Atlantic waters off the northeast United
States, implementation of a citizen science program in collaboration
with the U.S. Coast Guard auxiliary, and the joint enforcement
agreement between NOAA's Office of Law Enforcement (OLE) and the State
of Massachusetts.
In addition to establishing regulations that prohibit vessels from
approaching within 100 yards of a whale in sanctuary waters, the
Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary (HIHWNMS) has
a number of outreach programs designed to increase awareness of
humpback whales and to reduce harassment by interactions with ocean
users, including ocean awareness and ocean etiquette training that
educates both the general public and commercial whale watch operators
in the region. HIHWNMS has also convened a standing Sanctuary
Interagency Law Enforcement Task Force to coordinate enforcement of the
humpback whale approach regulation by state and Federal law enforcement
partners. We believe these efforts will help reduce the threat of whale
watching and increase enforcement and compliance with whale watching
guidelines and vessel approach regulations.
We continue to work with the whale watch industry to ensure that
vessels do not approach humpback whales too closely through vessel
approach regulations in Hawaii and Alaska, and vessel speed rules in
the North Atlantic. In fact, in two separate notices
[[Page 62275]]
published elsewhere in today's issue of the Federal Register, we are:
(1) Promulgating a direct final rule making minor technical corrections
to and recodifying the Alaska approach regulations that have been in
place in the part of the Code of Federal Regulations addressing
endangered marine or anadromous species (50 CFR 224.103(b)) so that
they also appear in the part of the Code of Federal Regulations
addressing threatened marine and anadromous species (50 CFR 223.214)
and the part setting forth MMPA regulations (50 CFR 216.18); and (2)
promulgating an interim final rule setting out similar regulations in
Hawaii under the MMPA (50 CFR 216.19). In addition, we have implemented
a number of responsible viewing programs across the United States to
promote precautionary practices on the water. One of these programs,
Whale SENSE, works closely with the whale watch industry along the U.S.
Atlantic and in Alaska, whereby operators agree to adopt a high
standard of stewardship on the water, including limiting speeds and
time spent with whales.
Comment 24: One commenter asserted that we failed to consider the
science demonstrating that ocean acidification could profoundly affect
the growth and toxicity of phytoplankton associated with harmful algal
blooms (known as ``red tides'') and the detrimental effects this will
have on all humpbacks, particularly the proposed Mexico, Central
America, and Hawaii DPSs, and that we failed to adequately consider
impacts to their food supply.
Response: We did consider HABs, and the BRT found, and we agreed,
that HABs represented a minor threat to most humpback whale
populations. HABs may be increasing in Alaska, but the BRT was unaware
of records of humpback whale mortality resulting from HABs in this
region.
We have recent evidence of high levels of domoic acid in two
humpback whales that stranded in California in 2015. We obtained very
few samples from the eight humpback whales that stranded in California
in 2015 as most were too decayed or inaccessible for necropsy, but in
these two cases we were able to test for domoic acid and detected its
presence. Domoic acid has not been identified as the cause of death for
the two humpback whales at this time, and at least one of them also had
marks of blunt force trauma.
A recent study (Lefebvre et al. 2016) documented spatial patterns
and prevalence of domoic acid and saxitoxin exposure in Alaskan marine
mammals in order to assess health risks to northern populations.
Humpback whales typically feed in cooler Alaskan waters during the
spring, summer, and fall months (Baker et al. 1986). There may be
resident populations of humpback whales in the southeastern Gulf of
Alaska. In Alaska, their diet consists of krill and many different
kinds of fish including herring (Clupea pallasii) and capelin (Mallotus
villosus), all of which are planktivorous and therefore likely vectors
of domoic acid and saxitoxin exposure (Bargu et al. 2002; Doucette et
al. 2005; Lefebvre et al. 2002a). A lower percentage of humpbacks
tested positive for domoic acid (38 percent, highest concentration = 51
ng/g feces) than saxitoxin (50 percent, highest concentration = 62 ng/
g). The highest domoic acid and saxitoxin concentrations were found in
an individual that died from a ship strike, which may not be a
coincidence because saxitoxin and domoic acid intoxication have been
suggested to be a factor in the loss of ability to avoid ships and to
be a cause of stranding (Geraci et al. 1989). Unless unknown factors
inhibit HABs in northern waters, warming water temperatures and
increased light availability due to loss of sea ice are likely to
support more blooms, increasing toxin concentrations and the health
risks they present for northern marine mammal species as they have for
southern species. Despite these results, we do not have any evidence to
indicate that HABs are causing humpback whale mortalities that rise to
a level that would indicate they are contributing significantly to the
extinction risk of humpback whale DPSs, now or in the foreseeable
future. (Please note that the Arabian Sea DPS, which we list as
endangered, presents special considerations as discussed in the Arabian
Sea DPS section.)
With regard to impacts on the humpback whale's food supply (in
terms of krill), humpback whales switch prey types and are also found
feeding on schools of small fish when those are more available. This
adaptability is beneficial within and between years and feeding areas
and may help humpback whales be more resilient to changing prey
distributions and availability. On the negative side, this adaptability
may also bring the whales into greater contact with fisheries for these
same fish, leading to increases in interactions. As we stated in the
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015), ``. . . the BRT did not
think the linkage between climate change and future krill production
was sufficiently well understood to rate it as moderate or high risk.
Nonetheless, any potential impacts resulting from these threats will
almost certainly increase, but not in the foreseeable future.''
While it is important to continue monitoring humpback whale health,
we cannot conclude that ocean acidification is contributing
significantly to the extinction risk of any humpback whale DPS through
growth and toxicity of phytoplankton associated with HABs or impacts to
the humpback whale's food supply, now or in the foreseeable future.
Comment 25: Several commenters asserted that NMFS makes nothing
more than a passing reference to climate change and ocean
acidification, despite repeatedly recognizing that threats from climate
change are likely to increase. In so doing, one commenter argued, NMFS
failed to adequately analyze the threat they pose and improperly and
summarily dismissed these threats in its analysis for the DPSs not
proposed to be listed. Another commenter stated that humpback whales
have not recovered to abundances that could sustain a rapid decline due
to expected climate changes in the foreseeable future.
Response: We evaluated the effects of climate change and ocean
acidification on each humpback whale DPS, as discussed in our proposed
rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22328-22329), but found no basis
to conclude they contribute significantly to extinction risk for most
DPSs, now or in the foreseeable future. (Please note that the Arabian
Sea DPS, which we list as endangered, presents special considerations
as discussed in the Arabian Sea DPS section). The ESA requires that
listing decisions be based solely on the best available scientific and
commercial information. We cannot merely speculate that climate change
and ocean acidification contribute significantly to the extinction risk
of any humpback whale DPS, but must base our listing determinations on
evidence sufficient to indicate that a particular effect is likely to
lead to particular biological responses at the species level. In fact,
the only evidence for climate change effects on prey abundance or type
is humpback whales moving north into Arctic waters, which is an
expansion of their range and could be seen as a positive effect. There
is a high degree of uncertainty associated with the fundamental issue
of whether loss of sea ice will negatively affect krill; while
overwintering larval krill use sea ice for predator protection and as a
food source (algae on the underside of the ice), it is possible that
krill would do better in open water because it has higher primary
productivity. Here the data do not allow us to draw more than
speculative conclusions as to the impacts of climate change on the
[[Page 62276]]
species, and thus our qualitative analysis of the impacts of climate
change satisfies our obligation to use the best scientific and
commercial data available. See Oceana, Inc. v. Pritzker, 75 F. Supp. 3d
469, 493 (D.D.C. 2014)
Comment 26: One commenter asserted that the scientific record does
not support the statement made by the IWC and cited in the status
review report and the proposed rule, ``It is generally accepted that
cetaceans are unlikely to suffer problems because of changes in water
temperature per se (IWC 1997).'' This commenter added that the proposed
rule changes fail to address environmental and health concerns
regarding climatic events that have already begun, and that they
believe will escalate in the foreseeable future. The commenter
described her research on the structure and innervation of humpback
whale skin, and concluded that critical concerns facing the species
from climate change include: (1) UV radiation exposure secondary to
ozone depletion compromises skin by burns and blisters, making the
whale more susceptible to pathogens and weakening its immune response;
(2) If water temperatures rise, the ability of these animals to cool
down, particularly in tropical birthing and calving grounds, will be
diminished. While the metabolic effects of this are unknown, her
experience with whale skin suggests to her that one complication will
be a breakdown of skin integrity; (3) Low pH levels are experienced as
chemical burns. This commenter asserted that her research has shown
these animals have neuroanatomical fibers in their skin that may
respond to similar stimuli; (4) Skin diseases, lesions, lice,
pathological microbial communities, and pollutants is another area of
particular concern, as the science exploring lesions and immune
response is minimal, though reported occurrences are increasing. While
whales were able to evolve during past climatic shifts, this commenter
argues, the present rapid rate of temperature change and ocean
acidification is unprecedented. The commenter concludes that it is not
wise to assume whales will be able to genetically evolve or adopt
behavioral modifications sufficient to overcome the foreseeably
predicted changes. The commenter provided 4 citations related to
ultraviolet (UV) radiation damage to whale skin.
Response: When we cited the IWC (1997) report in the proposed rule,
we added, ``Rather, global warming is more likely to effect changes in
habitats that in turn potentially affect the abundance and distribution
of prey in these areas.'' We carefully reviewed the four citations
(Martinez-Levasseur et al. 2010, 2013a, 2013b; Bowman et al. 2013)
related to UV radiation damage to whale skin provided by the commenter
and not reviewed at the time of the proposed rule. Results from
Martinez-Levasseur et al. (2010) may indicate quick responses to
increasing irradiation, based on increased number of melanocytes,
stimulation of the synthesis of melanin, and augmented apoptosis (the
death of cells that occurs as a normal and controlled part of an
organism's growth or development) when exposed to UV radiation in blue
whales, fin whales, and sperm whales. Martinez-Levasseur et al. (2013a)
discovered an apparent plastic pigmentation response as well as the use
of distinct strategies to counteract harmful exposure to UV radiation
amongst whale species, raising questions about the selective pressure
that sun exposure has exerted on these marine mammals. Martinez-
Levasseur et al. (2013b) provided preliminary results that demonstrate
an association between the levels of expression of target genes and
sunburn microscopic lesions previously recorded in cetacean epidermis.
Bowman et al. (2013) presented a reliable method which, for the first
time in the literature, allows for the simultaneous detection of skin
mtDNA damage in the same three species of sun blistered whales and
noted that it would be interesting to see if detected differences in
damage among these species reflect any behavioral differences, such as
migration patterns, skin pigmentation, or the time spent at the surface
of the ocean. While these studies are interesting, they do not provide
sufficient evidence to conclude that increased UV radiation due to
climate change is currently affecting the status of humpback whale DPSs
or is likely to do so within the foreseeable future. The commenter did
not provide any citations to her own published research, so we cannot
evaluate her other assertions, which were only generally described. We
have no evidence that humpback whales will be impacted in the ways
described by this commenter within the foreseeable future. The only DPS
for which we consider climate change to be a significant threat is the
Arabian Sea DPS, as we stated in the proposed rule, and we are listing
this DPS as endangered.
Comment 27: One commenter stated that delisting populations will
also expose whales to new threats, the impacts of which are not well
understood. The commenter suggested that acoustic prospecting, off-
shore drilling, and other impacts of the oil and gas industry have
never been fully realized for these animals as these types of projects
are recent additions to the ocean environment and their development has
been limited in the whales' habitat due to their protected status. The
commenter further suggested that deep-sea mining is another new
industry, the impacts of which are just beginning to be studied now,
that has the potential to release toxic contaminants previously locked
away in the seabed, and that old industries haven't yet reformed into
modern, sustainable practices. This commenter asserted that fishing
continues globally to take larger catches than science recommends;
farming, sewage, and industrial practices continue to put too many
nutrients and pollutants into the ocean, increasing dead zones and
bioaccumulation; and the shipping industry continues to increase,
increasing the likelihood of ship strikes and acoustic interference as
the oceans become noisier. Another commenter asserted that NMFS also
failed to consider new practices in the oil and gas industry that
present new threats. Offshore ``fracking''--an unconventional oil and
gas extraction practice that involves blasting voluminous amounts of
water and toxic chemicals into the earth at high pressures to crack
rock beneath the ocean floor--is expanding, exposing animals to
possible leaks and to the chemical discharges that are a byproduct of
this activity. This same commenter said that, in addition to analyzing
each threat on its own, NMFS must also analyze threats to humpbacks
cumulatively to determine if they are threatened or endangered, citing
Carlton v. Babbitt, 900 F. Supp. 526, 530 (D.D.C. 1995) (the agency
``must consider each of the listing factors singularly and in
combination with the other factors''). This commenter asserted that
NMFS paid lip service to this requirement by claiming that the five
listing factors do not pose a threat to recovery ``either alone or
cumulatively.''
Response: The threats mentioned in this comment are described very
generally, and we have no specific evidence to indicate that they will
negatively impact any humpback whale DPS. We considered the potential
for new threats in developing our proposed listing determinations, and
we conclude that these threats are not likely to increase the risk of
extinction to any of the DPSs not proposed for listing to the point
where they would warrant listing under the ESA. Finally, it is
important to note that the Monitoring Plan we are issuing today for
humpback whales
[[Page 62277]]
establishes a framework for continued monitoring and assessment of
potential threats for the next 10 years (twice the minimum 5-year
monitoring period required by the ESA).
With regard to the suggestion that we failed to adequately evaluate
the combined effects to the species from all section 4(a)(1) factors,
while we did not explicitly discuss the combined effects of different
threats on the different DPSs in the proposed rule, it is clear that we
did consider them. For the West Indies, Hawaii, and Mexico DPSs, we did
not mention the combined effects of threats in the proposed rule
because the abundance estimates of these DPSs were sufficiently high
that we could not foresee any combination of threats impacting the DPSs
to the point where we would consider them threatened or endangered.
(Note that we now have revised abundance estimates for the Mexico DPS
and have reconsidered its status in light of the continuing threat of
fishing gear entanglements). For the Southern Hemisphere DPSs that we
did not propose to list (Brazil, Gabon/Southwest Africa, Southeast
Africa/Madagascar, West Australia, East Australia, Oceania, and
Southeastern Pacific), we noted in our proposed rule, ``None of the
factors that may negatively impact the status of the humpback whale
appear to pose a threat to recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for
these DPSs.'' The high abundances of these DPSs similarly led us to
conclude there was no potential combination of threats that would
result in endangered or threatened status for any of these DPSs. For
those DPSs that we proposed listing as endangered (Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa, Arabian Sea) on the basis of the factors identified,
there was no need for further consideration of combinations of effects
because no amount of additional risk could lead to any greater
protected status than endangered. While the discussion in the status
review report and proposed rule was not explicit on this point,
consideration of the combined effect of threats can be reasonably
discerned from them and we reiterate this reasoning here.
Since the proposed rule published, we have reconsidered our listing
determinations for the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central
America DPSs. We have determined that the Western North Pacific and
Central America DPSs are endangered (please see Western North Pacific
DPS and Central America DPS sections for our rationale) and that the
Mexico DPS is threatened (please see Mexico DPS section for our
rationale). Further, we now confirm in this final rule that we have
considered whether any section 4(a)(1) threats in combination would
lead us to conclude that a different listing status is appropriate for
any DPS. We have reached our final listing determinations after fully
considering all factors together and individually.
Comments on the West Indies DPS
Comment 28: One commenter noted that on page 95 (80 FR 22304; April
21, 2015 at 22325), the proposed rule states that the SBNMS has the
potential to reduce the extinction risk of the West Indies DPS by
providing protection on the feeding ground. While this commenter agrees
that the SBNMS is a site of important research and management
initiatives, the commenter points out that it is a small marine
protected area that is visited by only approximately 200 individual
humpback whales per year on average (CCS, unpublished data). As such,
argues the commenter, it is unlikely that it could have significant
effect on the viability of the West Indies DPS. The commenter further
notes that, on a larger scale, the SBNMS is part of a Sister Sanctuary
Program with other marine protected areas within the range of North
Atlantic humpback whales and that this relationship has the potential
to facilitate conservation and research across international
boundaries. However, it is not clear how this program might be impacted
by a change in the ESA status of the proposed West Indies DPS.
Response: We agree that the SBNMS is a small marine protected area,
but as the commenter noted, it is part of a larger Sister Sanctuary
Program that can provide some protection to these whales at certain
stages in their migration. To date, SBNMS has sister sanctuary
agreements with the Dominican Republic, the French Antilles, and
Bermuda. The intent of the agreement(s) is to foster cooperation on
activities of mutual interest and exchange experience through
coordination of capacity building, research, and education concerning
the conservation, stewardship, and management of the endangered
humpback whale, and the respective marine bank ecosystems they
frequent. We do not expect these activities to change because the West
Indies DPS of humpback whale is not protected under the ESA.
Comment 29: The State of Massachusetts supports not listing the
West Indies DPS and asserts that the MMPA and the Atlantic Large Whale
Take Reduction Plan (ALWTRP) will provide protections.
Response: We acknowledge the State of Massachusetts' comments, and
are finalizing the identification of, and a ``not warranted'' finding
for, the West Indies DPS in this final rule. We agree these other
actions provide protection for humpback whales.
Comment 30: Two commenters suggested that there was insufficient
support for a single, wider Caribbean region DPS, taking the position
that the West Indies DPS we identified comprises two (or more) DPSs
that should be considered endangered. Another commenter stated that new
information is now available based on research in the eastern Caribbean
and the eastern North Atlantic and that this information does not
support previous assumptions that the West Indies is a homogeneous
breeding population. Rather, whales in the eastern Caribbean appear to
exhibit different breeding timing and preferential exchange with
eastern North Atlantic areas (Stevick et al. accepted; Stevick et al.
2015). This commenter stated that it is unclear whether these results
might require a change in the spatial boundaries of the two proposed
DPSs, or if there should be more than two DPSs in the North Atlantic.
The commenter stated that it is also not clear whether further
heterogeneity may exist within other under-sampled areas of the
Caribbean. The commenter believes that these results must be further
scrutinized before ascertaining the number, the geographic extent, and
status of DPSs in the North Atlantic.
Response: Research (Stevick et al. 2015) shows that some humpback
whales that are resighted in the western North Atlantic feeding grounds
move into the more northern part of the Caribbean in January and
February, and another group that is resighted in Iceland and northern
Norway enters the southeastern Caribbean at a later date. Further,
Stevick et al. (2016) discusses 4 individual humpback whales sighted in
Guadeloupe and the Cape Verde Islands; one was subsequently sighted in
Norway. However, this information is based on very few data, and does
not provide a sufficient or convincing basis to combine whales that
breed in the Southeastern Caribbean with those in the Cape Verde
Islands/Northwest Africa DPS or to identify three or more DPSs in the
North Atlantic. The difference in observed breeding timing could be a
result of survey period. In addition, at least three humpback whales
from the Lesser Antilles (southeastern Caribbean) have been resighted
in West Greenland, Newfoundland, and Norway, as well as the Dominican
Republic, which indicates mixing. At this time, we believe the best
available scientific and
[[Page 62278]]
commercial information supports the DPS structure we have identified.
While further research, including studies of genetic variation between
breeding areas in the northern Caribbean and southeast Caribbean, as
well as the Cape Verde Islands, may support the commenter's position in
the future. At this time we find no basis to draw different conclusions
about the DPS structure of humpback whales in the North Atlantic than
we described in our proposed rule.
Comment 31: Several commenters stated that the Years of the North
Atlantic Humpback (YONAH) and More North Atlantic Humpbacks (MONAH)
surveys are 20+ and 10 years old, respectively, and that we relied on
older, unpublished abundance data for the proposed West Indies DPS. The
commenters noted that we have suggested in the past that data older
than 8 years are not good enough for estimating potential biological
removal (PBR) (Stevick et al. 2015). One of the commenters asserted
that the MONAH data were used to calculate a population trend that is
said to vary from a ``zero percent'' increase to a 3 percent increase
in a 10-year period depending on the model used. This commenter added
that the MONAH data remain unavailable for review a decade later. The
commenters also stated that the population growth rate for this DPS
seems to be only 3.1 percent (Stevick et al. 2003), but the Humpback
Whale Recovery Plan said 3.5 percent would be required before we could
consider delisting the humpback whale. Further, they argued, the
abundance estimate of 12,312 individuals for the West Indies DPS'
putative breeding ground is only 10 percent of the long-term estimate
of 112,000 individuals.
Response: We are required to use the best available scientific or
commercial information when making a listing determination under the
ESA, and this is what we did when we relied on these abundance and
trend estimates. The commenter has taken certain prior statements out
of context: We have determined that, unless compelling evidence
indicates that a stock has not declined since the last census, the
minimum population size estimate of the stock should be considered
unknown if 8 years have transpired since the last abundance survey
(NMFS 2016). This guidance is in the context of our PBR calculations
under the MMPA and does not apply to ESA listing determinations, which
require that we base our decisions on the best available scientific and
commercial data.
However, we agree with the commenter that the MONAH data remain
unavailable and have not been fully analyzed yet, so in this final rule
we are not relying on the abundance estimate from the MONAH survey. The
abundance estimates from the YONAH survey are therefore the best
available scientific or commercial information, and they indicate a
population size for this DPS of 10,400 (95 percent confidence interval
(CI) 8,000-13,600) individuals using genetic identification data, and
10,752 (coefficient of variation (CV) = 6.8 percent) individuals using
photo identification data for the period 1992-1993. Stevick et al.
(2003) estimated the growth rate at 3.1 percent (standard error (SE) =
1.2 percent) for the period 1979-1993. While these abundance and growth
rate estimates are based on data that were collected prior to the MONAH
data, we consider them to be more reliable at this time. We reaffirm
our conclusion that the West Indies DPS is not threatened or endangered
under the ESA. If newer reliable data become available, that
information can be considered in the context of 5-year reviews, the
Monitoring Plan, or upon a petition, to determine whether any further
changes to listing status are warranted.
The commenters who stated that the population growth rate for this
DPS seems to be only 3.1 percent (Stevick et al. 2003) are correct, but
their assertion that the Humpback Whale Recovery Plan said 3.5 percent
would be required before we could consider delisting the humpback whale
is incorrect. The Recovery Plan did not state that a 3.5 percent growth
rate would satisfy the recovery goal of doubling the population size
(please see our response to Comment 10 for further details).
As we have explained, our action today is based on a comprehensive
evaluation of the DPSs comprising the humpback whale's entire range and
assigns a listing status to each DPS. To the extent that our action for
the West Indies DPS may constitute a ``delisting,'' it is consistent
with Sec. 424.11(d), which provides for delisting on ``the basis of
recovery'' (424.11(d)(2)). As that phrase is used in the regulations,
it means that ``the best scientific and commercial data available
indicate that [the species] is no longer endangered or threatened''
(424.11(d)(2)). We are not required to first find that the recovery
plan criteria have been met in order to directly apply the 4(a)(1)
factors. As discussed in the proposed rule, we determined, after
evaluating the ESA section 4(a)(1) factors, that the West Indies DPS is
not endangered or threatened. For further explanation, please see the
Rationale for Revising the Listing Status of a Listed Species Under the
ESA section above and our responses to Comments 8 and 9.
Comment 32: One commenter noted that there is very little available
scientific information about breeding areas for the humpback whales
near Iceland and Norway, where whales are still killed. Many of these
populations use the same feeding areas, so if a whale is killed, it
would be hard to determine the origin of a particular humpback whale
population. In these areas where multiple populations feed, it would be
difficult to determine which level of protection applies to individuals
when each population is treated differently. This commenter does not
support the removal of ESA protections from North Atlantic humpback
whales that breed in the West Indies, a population that they assert has
not yet recovered from whaling and continues to be seriously impacted
by human induced threats.
Response: We agree that there is little available scientific or
commercial information about breeding areas for humpback whales near
Iceland and Norway. Humpback whales feeding in the Northeast Atlantic
have been matched to breeding grounds in the Cape Verde Islands and the
Caribbean. Additional research would provide a greater understanding of
the proportions of humpback whales in the Northeast Atlantic that come
from the Cape Verde Islands and the Caribbean, but the ESA standard of
``best available scientific and commercial information'' does not
require that we conduct new studies. Rather, we must rely on the best
available information. Here, we conclude that the best available
scientific and commercial information is sufficient to support our
determinations.
Iceland and Norway do not hunt humpback whales, so we are confident
that individual humpback whales migrating to Iceland and Norway from
the Caribbean are not in danger of extinction due to whaling. Nor is
this threat likely to affect the status of whales in the foreseeable
future. Iceland hunts minke whales for its domestic market and its hunt
for fin whales was recently suspended. Norway hunts minke whales only
for domestic consumption. These countries have not recently expressed a
desire to hunt humpback whales, and there are no other indications to
suggest that they will conduct such hunts. Therefore, we are confident
they will not begin whaling for humpback whales in the foreseeable
future. (Please also see our response to Comment 12).
Comment 33: One commenter noted that few humpback whales were seen
in the New York Bight area before 2011, and now they are coming back.
This
[[Page 62279]]
commenter stated that the Hudson River is improving, but that threats
still remain, and shipping in this area will only increase. This
commenter recommended leaving the West Indies DPS listed as endangered,
adding that there is no definitive evidence to conclude that the West
Indies DPS is leveling off or reaching carrying capacity.
Response: The best available scientific and commercial information
indicates that the West Indies DPS is increasing in abundance. As we
explained in our response to Comment 9, whether a DPS reaches carrying
capacity (or historical abundance) is not a criterion for recovery
under the ESA. Please see responses to Comments 34-38 and 42 regarding
threats to the West Indies DPS.
Comment 34: One commenter asserted that humpback whales in the
Northwest Atlantic are subject to impacts of industrial electric
generators operating on the shoreline, such as Entergy Pilgrim Nuclear
Power Station on the shore of Cape Cod Bay (Plymouth, MA), Seabrook
Station Nuclear Power Plant (Seabrook, NH), and Mirant Canal Power
Plant (Sandwich, MA). Possible and realized negative impacts include
entrainment and impingement of food sources (fish and ichthyoplankton),
as well as chemical, thermal, and radioactive discharges.
Response: We have conducted informal consultations under section 7
of the ESA for the relicensing of the named power plants. The
consultations concluded that the relicensing and continued operation of
the power plants were not likely to adversely affect any ESA-listed
species under our jurisdiction (including, at the time, humpback
whales). On May 17, 2012, we concluded an informal consultation with
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) on the relicensing of the
Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant Station (PNPPS) located in Plymouth,
Massachusetts. The consultation concluded that the relicensing and
continued operation of the PNPPS was not likely to adversely affect any
NMFS-listed species. No new information has come to our attention that
would cause us to take a different view for this final listing
determination. While some zooplankton is likely lost to entrainment at
the PNPPS each year, approximately 85 percent of entrained zooplankton
are believed to survive (Bridges and Anderson 1984). Further, in
October 2015, Entergy Corporation announced that it will close its
PNPPS in Plymouth, MA, no later than June 1, 2019.
On October 10, 2012, we completed an informal consultation with the
NRC on the proposed relicensing of the Seabrook Nuclear Power Station
(SBNPS) located in Seabrook, New Hampshire. We concurred with the NRC's
determination that the continued operation of the SBNPS is not likely
to adversely affect any ESA-listed species.
We consulted on the Mirant Canal Power Plant in 2008, concluding,
``Based on the above analysis of water quality effects and the
determination that all effects, if adverse, will be insignificant or
discountable, NMFS is able to concur with EPA's determination that the
proposed NPDES permit for this facility is not likely to adversely
affect listed whales or sea turtles.''
Comment 35: One commenter expressed concern about the adequacy of
other protection measures for the West Indies DPS, which the commenter
understands to be the primary breeding ground for North Atlantic
humpback whales that consistently return to U.S. waters each year. The
latest information on population size and growth rate for the West
Indies DPS is more than a decade old and, according to the commenter,
the results are somewhat ambiguous. This commenter would be more
comfortable with listing changes if there were proven success in DPS-
level monitoring and controlling current human impacts. The commenter
stated that if populations were to lose ESA protections then it will be
necessary to track their status more intensively to reliably detect and
potentially reverse adverse effects of delisting in a timely manner.
Response: The commenter refers to the West Indies DPS as ``the
primary breeding ground for North Atlantic humpback whales.'' To
clarify, the West Indies DPS refers to the individual humpback whales
that constitute the DPS, not the breeding ground itself. The breeding
grounds for the West Indies DPS include waters of the Dominican
Republic (primarily Silver Bank, Navidad Bank) and Puerto Rico (Mona
Passage).
There are a number of ongoing conservation efforts that benefit the
West Indies DPS. These include a number of measures implemented under
the authority of the MMPA, including the ALWTRP and Harbor Porpoise
Take Reduction Plan (HPTRP) to reduce the risks associated with large
whale interactions with fishing gear, and the Ship Strike Reduction
Strategy to reduce risks associated with vessel collisions. Please see
the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 15, 2015 at 22324-22325) for more
information on these measures.
Finally, it is important to note that the Monitoring Plan we are
issuing today for humpback whales establishes a framework for continued
monitoring and assessment of threats for the next 10 years (twice the
minimum 5 year monitoring window required by the ESA).
Comment 36: One commenter stated that it has not been possible to
adequately limit the human impacts from entanglement and ship strikes
that are known to occur within U.S. waters, let alone those that may
occur in other parts of the range of the West Indies DPS. The commenter
stated that humpback whale takes along the U.S. East Coast have
exceeded management limits for more than two decades, and these are
thought to be underestimates of the total number of takes actually
occurring (van der Hoop et al. 2013; Pace et al. 2014; Cole and Henry
2013). As rationale for urging us to keep the West Indies DPS listed as
endangered, another commenter asserted that this year alone the marine
animal disentanglement team, based out of Provincetown, MA, has
received reports of 7 entangled humpback whales. Another commenter
asserted that entanglement-related mortality in Canada is largely
unaddressed, and there has been an increase in the use of trap/pot
gear. This commenter also asserted that there was an increased risk of
entanglement for humpback whales in the areas that were reopened to
groundfishing when the New England Fishery Management Council took
final action on their Omnibus Essential Fish Habitat Amendment 2.
Response: The largest potential threats to the West Indies DPS are
entanglement in fishing gear and ship strikes; these occur primarily in
the feeding grounds, with some documented in U.S. waters of the mid-
Atlantic. While some large whales display evidence of surviving vessel
collisions, these interactions, particularly with larger ships, are
routinely lethal due to blunt force trauma of the impact and the severe
lacerations associated with the vessel propeller. It is difficult to
determine whether mortalities and injuries from these threats are due
to increasing abundance of humpback whales or increased numbers of
fishing gears and vessels. However, we have determined that the West
Indies DPS continues to grow in abundance, despite the fishing gear
entanglements and vessel strikes, and we determine that its high
abundance provides sufficient resilience within the foreseeable future
against such threats.
[[Page 62280]]
We disagree that it has not been possible to adequately limit the
human impacts from entanglement and ship strikes that are known to
occur within U.S. waters, let alone those that may occur in other parts
of the range of the West Indies DPS. Existing management measures
implemented specifically for protected resource conservation should
mitigate any impacts of the amendment on large whales and other marine
mammals. The ALWTRP implements gear restrictions, spatially and
seasonally, to minimize interactions between whales and vertical lines
from fishing gear, as well as to reduce serious injury or mortality,
should an interaction occur. Two recent adjustments to the ALWTRP
include the ``Sinking Groundline Rule'' that became effective in April
2009 (73 FR 51228; September 2, 2008), and the ``Vertical Line'' rule
that became effective in August 2014 (79 FR 36586; June 27, 2014).
These rules have improved, or are expected to improve, management of
marine mammal interactions with fishing gear. In addition, when the
Atlantic Large Whale Take Reduction Team (ALWTRT) was working on the
vertical line rule to address entanglement risk of vertical lines to
large whales, it determined that gillnets represent less than 1 percent
of the total vertical lines on the east coast (see Appendix 3A in the
most recent ALWTRP Final Environmental Impact Statement) and that the
impacts from this gear on large whales is minimal. Therefore, the 2014
rule focused on trap/pot vertical line reduction, which is a gear that
has been, and would, for the most part, continue to be allowed in the
habitat management areas. Areas with the greatest co-occurrence of
large whales and gillnet gear will continue to be subject to existing
restrictions under the ALWTRP. Further, should data indicate that
gillnet entanglement risk has increased, the ALWTRT would be reconvened
to address the issue.
Because a number of the proposed alternatives considered for
Omnibus Essential Fish Habitat Amendment 2 would potentially open areas
to fishing that have been closed for a significant period of time,
there are no data to provide insight as to how gear may potentially
shift and, if there is a shift, what kind of impact this may have on
protected species. As a result, it is not possible to forecast
precisely what entanglement risk would exist if the closures are
removed. However, we can adequately examine risk based on overall
gillnet effort--i.e., the actual number of nets in the water. Because
there is unlikely to be an increase in gillnet effort overall, the
overall risk of marine mammal entanglement is unlikely to increase and
the risk of opening closed areas to gillnet fishing is unknown. There
could potentially be a decreased level of entanglement risk, as areas
in which gillnet gear is currently heavily concentrated become more
diffuse. Please see our response to Comment 39 for details on measures
that are in place for Atlantic right whales that likely reduce the risk
of vessel collisions with humpback whales.
Further, Barlow and Clapham (1997) have estimated a population
growth rate of 6.5 percent (SE = 1.2 percent) for the well-studied
humpback whale population in the Gulf of Maine, which is part of the
West Indies DPS. Clapham et al. (2003) suggest that there are
indications this growth rate has slowed in recent years.
The current PBR for Gulf of Maine humpback whale population stock
(under the MMPA) is 2.7 animals per year. When this final rule becomes
effective, PBR will be recalculated and will increase because the West
Indies DPS will no longer be listed, and there will be no ESA-listed
DPS that overlaps with the Gulf of Maine stock. The total estimated
human-caused mortality and serious injury to the Gulf of Maine humpback
whale stock is estimated as 10.3 animals per year. This average is
derived from two components: (1) Incidental fishery interaction
records, 8.9; and (2) records of vessel collisions, 1.4 (Waring et al.
2014).
While mortality and serious injury of humpback whales from the Gulf
of Maine stock have exceeded its PBR, this stock is only a small
component of the total West Indies DPS humpback whale population. The
best estimate for the total population of humpback whales in the Gulf
of Maine stock is 823 animals (Waring et al. 2014). The overall
population of the West Indies DPS of humpback whales is estimated to be
10,400-10,752 (please see response to Comment 31). Overall, the West
Indies DPS was estimated to be increasing slowly over the time period
1980 to 2005, but there is not sufficient evidence to statistically
conclude the DPS has leveled off, such as would occur for a population
reaching carrying capacity (Bettridge et al. 2015). In contrast,
estimates from feeding areas in the North Atlantic indicate strongly
increasing trends in Iceland (1979-1988 and 1987-2007), Greenland
(1984-2007), and the Gulf of Maine (1979-1991). There is some
indication that the population growth rate in the Gulf of Maine has
slowed in more recent years. It is not clear why the trends appear so
different between the feeding and breeding grounds. A possible
explanation would be that the Silver Bank breeding ground has reached
carrying capacity, and that an increasing number and percentage of
whales are using other parts of the West Indies as breeding areas
(Bettridge et al. 2015). In any case, the ESA does not require that the
population level of a listed species must ``level off'' or reach
carrying capacity for ESA protections to not apply; we have directly
evaluated the likelihood of the DPS to persist by considering abundance
and trend information and applying the section 4(a)(1) factors
directly.
It is not clear whether there is a significant increase in the use
of trap/pot gear in Canada as the commenter suggests. Canada's most
recent assessment of the Northwest Atlantic population of humpback
whales conducted by COSEWIC determined that the population is not at
risk of being listed as endangered under SARA. A Code of Ethics was
established by a non-profit organization working with whale-watching
operators to minimize the impact of whale watching on whales. Whale
watching and ecotourism operators throughout Atlantic Canada and Quebec
have adopted similar codes of ethics to reduce interactions with large
whales, including humpback whales. A protocol has been established for
releasing entangled whales from fishing gear. There are a number of
first responders in Canadian waters. In addition to the Grand Manan
Whale and Seabird Research Station and other groups in Nova Scotia, the
volunteer Campobello Whale Rescue Team responds to entanglements in
Canadian waters (primarily the lower Bay of Fundy) and collaborates
with U.S.-based rescue groups at the Provincetown Center for Coastal
Studies and the New England Aquarium where humpback whales and other
whale species are more prevalent. We do not agree that entanglement-
related mortality in Canada is largely unaddressed.
Regarding the commenter's assertion that there would be an
increased risk of entanglement for humpback whales in the areas that
were reopened to groundfishing when the New England Fishery Management
Council (Council) took final action on their Omnibus Essential Fish
Habitat Amendment, this is not a final action. NMFS has not taken a
final action on this amendment. Between October 10, 2013 and January 8,
2014, the Council accepted written comments on the amendment and its
associated draft Environmental Impact Statement, and these comments
were submitted to us. Between November 24,
[[Page 62281]]
2014 and January 7, 2015, the Council held 12 public hearings on
Omnibus Essential Fish Habitat Amendment 2. All of the proposed habitat
management alternatives, except for the no action alternative, would
remove year-round groundfish closures and result in gear capable of
catching groundfish being allowed into areas where they had previously
been restricted. Changes in the patterns of fixed gear use,
specifically concentrations of fixed gear, have the greatest potential
to influence the magnitude of protected resources impacts in the
region. Gillnets and traps/pots have been documented as having the most
interactions with whales and dolphins as compared to trawl or hook
gear. The management measures currently in place for the Northeast
multispecies, monkfish, and skate fisheries (i.e., the fisheries that
use gillnets and bottom trawls) and the scallop fishery all limit the
overall amount of fishing effort, mainly through annual catch limits on
target stocks. As a result, the changes proposed in this amendment
would not be expected to result in an increase in fishing effort
overall, just shifts in the location of that effort.
Comment 37: Commenters assert that while some humpback whale
populations have shown signs of recovery, North Atlantic humpback
whales struggle to recover from decades of whaling as they face
unsustainable threats from entanglements in fishing gear, vessel
strikes, energy development, ocean noise, and pollution. The commenters
argue that Gulf of Maine humpback whales are currently being seriously
injured or killed by human impacts at a rate higher than the population
can sustain to recover, and some BRT members considered that North
Atlantic humpback whales who breed in the West Indies may be at a
``moderate'' or ``high risk of extinction'' due to ``potentially high
rates of entanglement and/or ship strikes in some parts of its range''
as well as the multiple cases of mass die-offs of humpback whales in
the Gulf of Maine. The commenters do not support removing ESA
protections from North Atlantic humpback whales that breed in the West
Indies.
Response: The BRT concluded that North Atlantic humpback whales
that breed in the West Indies are at low risk of extinction, and we
agree. As discussed in the West Indies DPS section, the most reliable
estimate of abundance for the West Indies DPS is 10,400-10,752 animals
(please see response to Comment 31). Humpback whale numbers in the Gulf
of Maine are increasing at a rate of 3.1 percent per year, which we
conclude is evidence of the population's resilience to the injuries and
mortalities it may experience into the foreseeable future. The most
recent and best estimate of annual serious injury and mortality for the
Gulf of Maine stock of humpback whales is 10.2 animals annually (Waring
et al. 2014). As stated above in our response to Comment 36, the Gulf
of Maine stock (under the MMPA) is only a small portion of the overall
population of humpback whales that comprise the West Indies DPS.
Further, these whales will still be protected under the MMPA, which
prohibits take and requires that marine mammal stocks be maintained at
optimum sustainable population levels (please see response to Comment
36).
The majority of the BRT members concluded that the West Indies DPS
was ``not at risk of extinction'' (82 percent of the likelihood
points). The concern by some members of the BRT that there is potential
for this DPS to be at ``moderate'' or ``high risk of extinction''
reflects uncertainty on the part of some BRT members stemming from
potentially high rates of entanglement and/or ship strikes in some
portions of its range (17 and 1 percent, respectively), and the
occurrence in the Gulf of Maine of recent multiple unusual mortality
events (UMEs) (Bettridge et al. 2015). Despite these threats, the
abundance of the West Indies DPS is substantial, and the growth rate is
positive.
The threats mentioned in this comment are described very generally,
and we have no indication that they will negatively impact humpback
whale DPSs. We considered the potential for new threats in developing
our proposed determinations, and we conclude that these threats are not
likely to increase the risk of extinction to any of the DPSs that have
not been proposed for listing to the point where they would warrant
listing under the ESA.
Finally, it is important to note that the Monitoring Plan we are
issuing today per section 4(g)(1) of the ESA establishes a framework
for continued monitoring and assessment of threats for the next 10
years (twice the minimum 5-year monitoring window required by the ESA).
We have determined that the West Indies DPS continues to grow in
abundance, despite the fishing gear entanglements and vessel strikes.
Please see our responses to Comments 19, 20, 21, 34, 35, 36, 38, and
41.
Comment 38: Several commenters stated that NMFS' own data say most
humpback whales have been entangled at least once. One commenter stated
that, according to Center for Coastal Studies, 80 humpback whales have
been rescued since 1984, many from gear entanglement. According to
another commenter, a quarter to a third of the population show evidence
of vessel strikes, and well over half show signs of a previous
entanglement. In discussing their assertion that we did not consider
the inadequacy of regulatory mechanisms when making our listing
determinations for the 14 humpback whale DPSs, another commenter
asserted that regulations have proven inadequate to reduce humpback
whale mortality to legally mandated levels, citing Pace et al. (2014).
Response: The commenters misconstrue the source of the data in
Waring et al. (2014). Those data are from the Stock Assessment Report
for humpback whales. Stock Assessment Reports are, for the most part,
compilations of published information rather than NMFS' own data.
Waring et al. (2014) note that scarification rates have been used to
study entanglement-related scarring on humpback whales in the Gulf of
Maine, with the results suggesting that between 48 percent and 65
percent had experienced some sort of entanglement (see also Robbins and
Mattila 2001). However, those entanglement rates include all sources of
entanglement, including moorings and other non-fishing activities.
Large whale entanglements, including those involving humpback
whales, are difficult to study, as the moment of entanglement is rarely
observed and in most cases animals move away from the location of the
event. Since 1997, scarification rates have been used as a measure of
entanglement rates for large whales. These scar studies provide a
method for evaluating both lethal and non-lethal entanglement events.
The continued monitoring of scarification rates provides a means to
help monitor the effectiveness of management efforts implemented to
reduce the frequency of these types of interactions. Further, since
those scarification studies have been conducted, NMFS, in consultation
with the ALWTRT, has developed and implemented two major regulatory
actions that have significantly reduced the volume of groundlines from
trap/pot and gillnet gear (72 FR 57104; October 5, 2007) and vertical
lines in all trap/pot gear (79 FR 36586; June 27, 2014) to
significantly reduce the risk of entanglement.
We acknowledge that fishing gear entanglement continues to impact
humpback whales to varying degrees in the range of different DPSs.
However, we have assessed the potential effects of fishing gear
entanglements on several species of large whales including humpback
whales in the northwest
[[Page 62282]]
Atlantic (West Indies DPS) through the ESA section 7 consultation
process. We have completed a number of biological opinions on several
fishery management plans (FMPs), including the American lobster, the
Northeast Multispecies, monkfish, spiny dogfish, Atlantic bluefish,
Northeast skate complex, mackerel/squid/butterfish, and summer
flounder/scup/black sea bass fisheries and concluded that these
fisheries are not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of the
species (see http://www.greateratlantic.fisheries.noaa.gov/protected/section7/bo/actbo.html).
Pace et al. (2014) analyzed data from mortalities and serious
injuries prior to new regulations requiring sinking ground lines and
vertical lines, which are a known important whale entanglement problem.
That paper supports our conclusion that additional measures to reduce
entanglement were needed at that time and are still required now. The
ALWTRT was apprised of these findings, and our Greater Atlantic
Regional Fisheries Office cited this information as support for the
ground line and vertical line rules with the goal of reducing
entanglements that result in serious injuries and mortalities, in
accordance with requirements of MMPA and ESA. Further, we collaborated
with the ALWTRT to develop a monitoring plan for the ALWTRP that
provides for a 5-year monitoring period to evaluate the impact from and
compliance with the regulations associated with the ALWTRP. As such, we
will gather data over 5 years, and will then analyze whether there is a
noticeable change from the suite of conservation measures implemented
through the ALWTRP. We are currently in our second year of implementing
the combined sinking groundline and vertical line regulations. The
monitoring plan provides for taking immediate additional action if
needed (as a safety mechanism that allows us to respond if a new
emerging issue arises that is not addressed in the ALWTRP) prior to the
end of 5 years.
Comment 39: Many commenters urged us not to take the West Indies
DPS off the endangered and threatened species list, as many threats
still remain, including vessel collisions, fishing gear entanglements,
noise, and climate change. One of these commenters asserts that the
Gulf of Maine population will demonstrate moderate habitat variability
in coming years that will increase the risk to it from these threats.
The commenter states that, without the additional protections of the
ESA, NMFS may find it hard to meet its legal obligations under the
MMPA. If too many individuals are lost as a result of human activity,
this commenter argues, the population will continually end up going
over its PBR rate and will fail to meet or maintain its optimum
sustainable population (OSP) level. This commenter also asserts that
the ESA provides more protection than the MMPA. This commenter
concludes that it is likely that delisting this particular population
will cause these cases of human interactions to increase, which may
ultimately lead to a need for NMFS to relist the population, wasting
valuable resources that could have been saved if the population
remained listed the entire time. Another commenter cited Laist et al.
(2014) to assert that the authors concluded that there is no evidence
to show that the North Atlantic right whale vessel speed rule confers
benefits to the humpback whale (West Indies DPS).
Response: As discussed above, measures to reduce the take of
humpback whales (as well as other large whales) have been promulgated
under the authority of the MMPA (please see our response to Comment
35). These measures implemented to protect large whales, including
humpback whales, will remain in place, including those to reduce the
risks of fishing gear interactions and ship strikes. The measures we
have imposed to reduce the threat posed by ship strikes to North
Atlantic right whales have been promulgated under the authority of the
ESA and MMPA, and although these measures were keyed closely to North
Atlantic right whale distribution, they are expected to help reduce
risk to humpback whales to the extent that the distribution of the two
species overlap. Related to this, additional actions established
primarily to protect right whales almost certainly will reduce the risk
of vessel collisions with humpback whales. Among these are various
vessel routing measures endorsed by the International Maritime
Organization and implemented domestically (Silber et al. 2012); one of
which is expected to reduce the likelihood of fatal collisions with
humpback whales by 81 percent in the relevant geographical area (http://stellwagen.noaa.gov/science/tss.html).
Further, we have concluded that climate change and noise do not
currently place this DPS in danger of extinction or make it likely that
they will become so within the foreseeable future (please see our
responses to Comments 25 and 41).
Our obligations to make listing determinations under the ESA are
separate and apart from our obligations under the MMPA. We cannot agree
with the commenter that recognizing the improved status of this DPS
under the ESA and adjusting the listing to accurately reflect that
status (as we are required to do under sections 4(a)(1), 4(b)(1)(A),
and 4(c)) is incompatible with our obligations under the MMPA.
Comment 40: One commenter suggested that new breakaway nets that
protect whales from entanglement be required.
Response: The current action is a final listing determination
addressing the status of the DPSs under the ESA on the basis of the
best scientific and commercial data available. We are also
categorically extending all the protections of section 9 to the
threatened DPSs. It is outside the scope of this action to consider
modifying or promulgating additional special protections, though we may
do so in the future through a special rule under section 4(d).
Nevertheless, we respond to clarify the current regulatory status of
the type of protective measure to which we understand the commenter to
be referring. We assume the commenter's mention of ``breakaway nets''
was referring to weak links that allow the gear to part under various
weight tolerances, with the intention of reducing the risk of serious
injury and mortality should a whale encounter trap/pot or gillnet gear.
The use of weak links is already required through the regulations
implementing the ALWTRP. The ALWTRP is intended to reduce the risk of
serious injury and mortality of large whales caused by the incidental
entanglement of large whales in U.S. commercial trap/pot and gillnet
fishing gear. The ALWTRP focuses on reducing entanglements of right,
humpback, and fin whales.
Comment 41: Several commenters stated that noise was a threat to
humpback whales in the North Atlantic.
Response: We described the research on the effects of noise on
marine mammals in the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at
22326), and we concluded that population-level impacts on cetaceans
have not been confirmed. There is little specific, reliable information
regarding, for example, the interruption of breeding and other
behaviors or a resulting reduction in population growth or mortality of
individuals. Therefore, the BRT considered this to be a low threat for
all DPSs. We agree with that conclusion.
Comment 42: Several commenters asserted that we underestimated the
risks of subsistence whaling to the West Indies DPS.
Response: We disagree, and have not received any information to
change our conclusion from the proposed rule. The number of West Indies
DPS humpback whales killed for subsistence is very
[[Page 62283]]
small, and the abundance of the West Indies DPS is large (10,400-
10,752). Bequians in St. Vincent and the Grenadines in the Lesser
Antilles currently retain an IWC ``block'' quota of up to 24 whales
over a 6-year period (2013-2018) (IWC 2012), and 27 humpback whales
were killed in Greenland between 2010 and 2012 under a 2010 IWC quota.
We have determined, based on the best available information, the West
Indies DPS is not threatened or endangered under the ESA, and it can
sustain a small number of subsistence takes.
Comments on the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
We did not receive any comments on this DPS, other than the general
comment recommending endangered status for all DPSs. This DPS is being
listed as endangered (please see Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa
DPS section).
Comments on the Western North Pacific DPS
Comment 43: One commenter expressed concern that we had combined
two populations that the BRT identified as separate DPSs (Okinawa/
Philippines and 2nd West Pacific) into one DPS, the Western North
Pacific DPS. According to the commenter, if we had identified them as
separate DPSs, at least one of them might warrant endangered status.
Response: We concluded that combining the two putative DPSs into
one DPS was the most consistent with the best available scientific and
commercial information. It is not known where the ``2nd West Pacific''
population breeds, and therefore it cannot be classified as a separate
DPS from the others, which are generally identified by breeding area.
Further, whether or not identifying an entity as threatened or
endangered if it is a smaller entity would lead to a different listing
determination would not be an appropriate rationale for identifying
that entity as a DPS. Regardless, we are listing the Western North
Pacific DPS as endangered in this final rule. Please see the Western
North Pacific DPS section below for our rationale for listing this DPS
as endangered instead of threatened (as proposed).
Comment 44: The Fisheries Agency of Japan (Japan) commented that
the Western North Pacific DPS should not be listed under the ESA,
asserting that we did not provide support for suspicions about Japanese
illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing. Japan suggested
that our main rationale for proposing to list the Western North Pacific
DPS as threatened was, ``Some poaching is reported to occur in Korean
waters and is suspected off Japan (Baker et al. 2002; IWC 2005c).''
Japan asserted, however, that Baker et al. (2002) deals with only two
cases: (1) A case of gray whale market products whose origin was
unidentified; and (2) a case of one gray whale which was reported as
``stranded'' by the Japanese government but appeared to have been
killed by fishermen. Japan expressed concern about the leap of logic in
concluding that some poaching of humpback whales is suspected off Japan
because a few cases of illegal catch of gray whales were suspected in
the 1990s before the introduction, in 2001, of the system to ban the
market distribution of products of whale meat not obtained legally.
Japan recommended deletion of some sentences about Japanese catch/
research/entanglement, and provided some references to support its
view. Japan explained that after the Government of Japan introduced a
domestic regulation in 2001 requiring reporting of bycatch, the
reported number of bycaught humpback whales has actually been stable
with no increasing trend (http://www.jfa.maff.go.jp/j/whale/w_document/index.html (in Japanese); link provided by Japan). Japan argued that
this fact clearly shows that the alleged increase in the number of
reported entanglement/deaths lacks foundation. Also, Japan noted, no
whale products derived from whales other than legally obtained ones
have been found in the market sample monitoring survey (using DNA
sequencing technique) conducted by the Fisheries Agency of Japan in
recent years. Judging from this survey result, Japan stated, it is
highly unlikely that there is substantial underreporting of bycaught
whales in Japan, and Japan concluded that the assertion that ``the
actual number of entanglements may be underrepresented'' is not
persuasive. Likewise, Japan stated that IWC (2005c) reported five cases
of illegal catch of minke whales, not humpback whales, in Korea in
2003. Japan believes that the precautionary approach is being abused in
justifying the ``threatened'' status of the Western North Pacific DPS.
Response: We do not agree that our main rationale for proposing to
list the Western North Pacific DPS as threatened was the reported or
suspected poaching in Korean waters or off Japan. We proposed to list
this DPS as threatened because of the relatively low abundance estimate
(~1,100); the threats of energy development, whaling, competition with
fisheries, vessel collisions, and fishing gear entanglements;
significant uncertainties associated with the abundance estimates,
population growth rate, and the extent of its breeding ground; and the
BRT's distribution of likelihood points, which indicated a high level
of uncertainty regarding overall extinction risk to this DPS. Regarding
the commenter's assertion that our listing is based on an ``abuse'' of
the precautionary approach, we disagree. Our final listing
determination is based on the best available scientific and commercial
information. In this case, the best available scientific and commercial
information about the species' status and threats directly supports our
conclusion that the Western North Pacific DPS is an endangered species
under the ESA. See our response to Comment 13 for additional
explanation of ``best available information'' and the Western North
Pacific DPS section below for our rationale for listing this DPS as
endangered instead of threatened (as proposed).
With regard to the comments about illegal catches and bycatch, we
note that what was discussed were IUU takes; by definition these takes
are not necessarily illegal, but may be unreported or unregulated.
Market survey results from 2001-2009 in Japan have documented concerns
for IUU takes from stocks of at least six species of whales, including
humpback whales; the others are sei, Bryde's, gray, North Pacific
minke, and fin whales (Baker et al. 2015 SC/66a/SD2; Steel et al. 2009
SC/61/BC8, Baker et al. 2008 SC/60/BC2, Baker et al. 2007 SC/59/BC9).
This includes the possibility of the sale of whale meat from
undocumented sei and fin whales from the Southern Hemisphere, and of a
greater number of individual fin whales than expected from reports of
bycatch. Therefore, recent IUU of large whales in this region remains
possible. We do not agree that bycatch of humpback whales has not
increased; using Japan's Progress Reports to the IWC, and numbers
provided by the Japan Fisheries Agency for years for which no Progress
Report was provided to the IWC, there has been a significant increase
in bycatch of humpback whales in Japan from 2000 to 2015 (e.g., an
average of 2.4 whales per year in 2000-2004, versus an average of 6.2
whales per year in 2010-2015).
Comment 45: Japan and another commenter noted that the abundance
estimate of the Western North Pacific DPS is 1,000 and its growth rate
is 6.9 percent (p.64-65 of the proposed rule; 80 FR 22303; April 21,
2015 at 22318). Japan stated that the annual number of
[[Page 62284]]
bycaught humpback whales in Japan for the last 5 years is six
individuals on average, well below one percent of the total abundance
and the growth rate. Japan argued that this shows that the bycatch of
humpback whales in Japan has no adverse impact on the status of the
Western North Pacific DPS.
Response: Calambokidis et al. (2008) estimated the growth rate for
humpback whales in the Western North Pacific to be 6.9 percent between
1991-93 and 2004-2006, although this could be biased upwards by the
comparison of earlier estimates based on photo-identification records
from Ogasawara and Okinawa with current estimates based on the more
extensive records collected in Ogasawara, Okinawa, and the Philippines
during the Structure of Populations, Levels of Abundance and Status of
Humpback Whales in the North Pacific (SPLASH) program (Calambokidis et
al. 2008). However, the overall number of whales identified in the
Philippines was small relative to both Okinawa and Ogasawara, so any
bias would likely not be large. Given the possible bias in the rate of
increase and the fact that it represents a combination of two
populations that the BRT had proposed as separate DPSs (Okinawa/
Philippines and Second West Pacific), it is not possible to make a
definite statement about the rate of increase of the Western North
Pacific DPS. Therefore, we conclude that the population growth rate for
the Western North Pacific DPS is unknown, as we stated in the
Conclusions on the Status of Each DPS Under the ESA section of our
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22349).
The BRT concluded that, given the relatively low abundance of the
Philippines/Okinawa portion of this DPS (~1,000 individuals), fishing
gear entanglement could seriously reduce its population size or growth
rate. Given this conclusion, and the BRT's uncertainty about the
threats facing the Second West Pacific portion of this DPS, we cannot
conclude that bycatch of humpback whales in Japan or anywhere else is
not having an impact on the status of the Western North Pacific DPS.
Please see the Western North Pacific DPS section below for our
rationale for listing this DPS as endangered instead of threatened (as
proposed).
Comment 46: Japan notes that the points raised above are all
related to Japan. In order to evaluate the status of the Western North
Pacific DPS, a similar examination should be done of all relevant
countries that could impact the status of this DPS. Japan notes that
the proposed rule states, ``Some degree of IUU exploitation is also
possible in other regions within the range of humpback whales in the
Western North Pacific DPS, including Taiwan and the Philippines, given
past histories of whaling'' (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22332).''
But, Japan argues, no descriptions of past histories or references are
presented. Japan argues that without such descriptions to support the
possibility of IUU exploitation in those other regions, statements that
IUU exploitation is possible have no basis and cannot be raised as
evidence to support the ``threatened'' status of the Western North
Pacific DPS. Japan notes that any information on stranded, beached,
bycaught, and/or landed whales can be easily and promptly shared
through the internet. Such a circumstance, being combined with the
market-sample monitoring, makes it quite difficult, if not impossible,
to hide illegal harvesting/products from the public in Japan.
Response: The statements we made in the proposed rule about
possible exploitation in other regions within the range of the Western
North Pacific DPS, given past histories of whaling, were clearly
labeled as not being based on specific supporting documentation;
rather, our evaluation was based on our professional judgment. Further,
our final listing of this DPS as endangered is based on consideration
of objective factors using the best available scientific and commercial
information, as explained in the responses to Comments 44 and 47 and in
the Western North Pacific DPS section.
Comment 47: One commenter recommended delisting the Western North
Pacific DPS because information not cited in the proposed rule (Okamoto
2013) indicates the DPS is recovering at a rate similar to other North
Pacific DPSs, and threats identified by NMFS do not appear to be
negatively impacting them. The commenter asserted that NMFS' analysis
of threats was speculative and overestimated. Further, the commenter
stated that additional surveys independent of SPLASH have been
conducted in Okinawa and Ogasawara, indicating the population is
increasing in abundance (unpublished study in Okinawa, by Kato: 1989-
2008 (16.9 percent growth rate); 2009-2028 (3 percent growth rate),
reaching pre-exploitation abundance in 2029; and Okamoto (2013),
indicating a 4-fold sighting increase in abundance from 1997 to 2013
from 0.06 individuals to 0.24 individuals per nautical mile (nmi) in
Okinawa). The commenter adds that pre-exploitation abundance in the
Okinawa area of this DPS is likely to be smaller (~1,500 individuals)
than what was considered by NMFS.
Response: We reviewed Okamoto (2013) for the proposed rule, but we
did not consider it to provide enough information to be reliable. The
Okamoto (2013) study consisted of a visual survey of whales in the
Ogasawara area conducted on one day (January 30, 2013), which was
compared to a similar previous survey conducted in 1997 (cited as
Yoshida and Kato 1999, but with no other information given). While it
is encouraging that Okamoto (2013) reports a higher encounter rate
around Ogasawara in 2013, given the nature of this study, there are
other reasons that different encounter rates might have occurred on the
two surveys, so the results cannot be used to conclude there has been
an increase in abundance. Survey data such as this need to be analyzed
using line transect methods to take account of differing abilities to
detect whales, which could occur because of differences in variables
such as vessel type or weather conditions, for which no information was
provided. Additionally, no estimates of precision (such as confidence
limits) were calculated for either estimate of encounter rate. Finally,
the BRT concluded, and we agree, that the Ogasawara area is an area
through which humpback whales migrate on the way to their feeding
grounds. Therefore, the number of whales in a location such as
Ogasawara is highly dependent upon the timing of the survey and the
timing of migration of the whales. No date is given for the 1997
survey, so if it occurred earlier or later in the migration, this could
account for the lower encounter rate. Moreover, it is not clear that a
survey on a single day could reliably track abundance in a migratory
area if the timing of migration varies between years; a more reliable
survey design would be to have repeated surveys across a longer time
period than a single day.
We have reviewed the more recent information provided by the
commenter (Kato, unpublished), but this study is also not reliable.
This information consists of a 2014 abstract of Mr. Nobuyuki Suzuki's
undergraduate thesis, supervised by Professor Hidehiro Kato, which
reported an abundance estimate of 683 (CV = 0.10) humpback whales
migrating to the research area around the Okinawa main islands in 2009
and an estimated average annual rate of increase of 16.9 percent (no
confidence limits reported) from 1989-2008 and 3.0 percent from 2009-
2028. A growth rate of 16.9 percent is not biologically plausible
(Zerbini et al. 2010), so without further information it
[[Page 62285]]
is difficult to know how to interpret this estimate. We were not able
to review the undergraduate thesis itself, and not enough information
is given to understand exactly how the analysis and modeling was
conducted, and whether the thesis was submitted for any external peer
review. Further, this study focused on whales around Okinawa, but the
Western North Pacific DPS also includes whales from breeding areas in
the Philippines and other unidentified areas, so the estimated growth
rate does not necessarily reflect the growth rate of the entire DPS.
Finally, we do not consider the estimate of pre-exploitation abundance
(from the 2014 abstract of the undergraduate thesis) in the Okinawa
area of this DPS to be reliable; as we have described, the migration of
North Pacific humpback whales is complex and the thesis appears to have
ignored the fact that the Asia population would have also experienced
commercial whale catches on its summer feeding areas in Russia, the
Aleutian Islands, and the Bering Sea. In any case, given the relatively
low abundance of this DPS, several other remaining threats, and the
significant uncertainties associated with the abundance estimate, we
have changed our listing determination for this DPS, and we list it as
endangered under the ESA instead of threatened (as proposed). Please
see the Western North Pacific DPS section below for our rationale for
this change.
Comment 48: One commenter suggested that there is no information
provided in the proposed rule's discussion of the proposed Western
North Pacific DPS that allows an understanding of the BRT's level of
concern given the admittedly low population size, unknown trend, and
the fact that there is an acknowledgement that threats from energy
development, whaling, competition with fisheries, and vessel collisions
are considered moderately likely to reduce the population size or
growth rate of this small, ``remnant'' population. Further, this
commenter states, there is an acknowledgement that ``there is great
uncertainty'' regarding threats and status of this proposed DPS. This
commenter believes that we should have applied the precautionary
approach in the face of this uncertainty. The commenter included a
citation to the decision in Greater Yellowstone Coalition, Inc. v.
Servheen, 665 F.3d 1015 (9th Cir. 2011).
Response: We are required to use the best available scientific and
commercial information when making ESA listing determinations. We are
not required to consider only information that is free from
uncertainty. Although there are threats to this DPS and there is some
uncertainty as to the particular effects, we and the BRT viewed those
threats against the backdrop of the population level, which at around
1,000 is higher than the level (500) that would indicate the population
is at high risk from small size alone.
The situation here is distinguishable from that which was reviewed
in the Greater Yellowstone Coalition case. There, FWS had decided to
delist the Yellowstone population of grizzly bears, concluding without
adequate explanation that changes in whitebark pine production were not
likely to impact the bear to the point at which it would be threatened.
FWS reached this conclusion despite the fact that the record documented
a close association between reduced abundance of whitebark pine seeds
and increases in grizzly mortality, recent reductions in whitebark pine
due to pine beetles, and a potential for climate change to drastically
affect the presence and distribution of whitebark pine seeds. The court
found that the decision to delist the Yellowstone grizzly population
could not rationally be reconciled with those particular facts in the
record. The record before us does not present the kinds of documented
effects that were present in the grizzly bear case.
Nevertheless, we have found that, upon reconsideration of the best
available information, the Western North Pacific DPS should be
finalized as an endangered species instead of as a threatened species
as proposed. Please see the Western North Pacific DPS section for our
rationale for listing this DPS as endangered and our response to
Comment 13 for discussion of the precautionary approach.
Comments on the Hawaii DPS
Comment 49: The State of Alaska concurs with our proposal to not
list the Hawaii DPS (which is consistent with Alaska's petition) and to
list the Western North Pacific DPS as threatened. The State believes
that any potential threats to the Hawaii DPS from human disturbance can
be controlled through continued monitoring and management under the
MMPA, the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the Fisheries Act of Canada, and SARA,
as well as the IUCN, IWC, and the CITES. The State goes on to say that
information on the Western North Pacific DPS is limited, particularly
regarding the wintering/breeding area used by the whales that feed in
the Aleutians and western Bering Sea. It notes that individual whales
from the Western North Pacific DPS (proposed to be listed as
threatened) and Hawaii DPS will mix to some extent during the summer in
the Aleutians and the Bering Sea. As a result, ESA section 7
consultations are likely to continue in the area of overlap because of
the difficulty in distinguishing between individuals of the two DPSs.
Response: We agree with the State of Alaska that the areas where
individuals of a listed DPS mix with individuals of a DPS that is not
listed will result in difficulty in distinguishing between individuals
of the two DPSs. Any Federal agency that funds, authorizes, or carries
out an action that may affect a listed DPS is required to consult with
us under section 7 of the ESA, so this means that, in these areas where
DPSs of different status mix, section 7 consultation will still be
required to ensure that the threatened and endangered DPSs are
protected under the ESA. Please see response to Comment 11, and the
Western North Pacific DPS section for our rationale for listing the
Western North Pacific DPS as endangered instead of threatened (as
proposed).
Comment 50: One commenter fully supports delisting the Hawaii DPS,
emphasizing that the Hawaii-based commercial longline fisheries have no
significant or detectable impact on the Hawaii DPS (or humpback whales
from any other DPS), and any regulation of the fisheries that may be
necessary with respect to humpback whales is amply addressed by the
rigorous provisions contained in section 117 of the MMPA.
Response: We acknowledge the comment. Fisheries that interact with
marine mammals are regulated under section 118 of the MMPA, so this
will provide a mechanism for continued monitoring and evaluation of the
impacts of fisheries on humpback whales. We note that the Hawaii-based
longline fisheries have been determined to have negligible impacts on
humpback whales (79 FR 24567; October 16, 2014).
Comment 51: One commenter stated that a recent assessment found
that 78 percent of whales in northern Southeastern Alaska had been non-
lethally entangled in fishing gear (Neilson et al. 2009).
Response: Entanglement in fishing gear remains a risk to large
whales worldwide. Though these interactions occur in many regions,
including the cases referred to in Southeast Alaska, many are non-
lethal (Bradford and Lyman 2015) and collectively they do not rise to a
population level impact for the Hawaii DPS (which comprises most of the
humpbacks found in Southeast Alaska). The Hawaii DPS has continued
[[Page 62286]]
to grow rapidly in spite of occasional entanglements. As required under
the MMPA, we assess marine mammal serious injury and mortality levels
resulting from human interactions, and monitor these levels against the
thresholds for removal that have been calculated as sustainable for the
population. We collect, analyze, and respond to large whale
entanglement reports through the Marine Mammal Health and Stranding
Program.
Comment 52: One commenter noted that collisions of humpbacks and
ships appear to be increasing in important breeding areas such as
Hawaii (Lammers et al. 2003) and that available evidence also suggests
that ship strikes are increasing in Alaska (Gabriele et al. 2007).
Response: In general, it is difficult to conclude that ship strike
levels are definitively increasing based on an increase in reports. For
instance, in Alaska, following the implementation of a stranding
hotline in 2009, many types of stranding reports increased, likely due
to heightened public awareness. That said, large whale ship strikes
reported to NMFS in Alaska have been fairly steady over the past decade
(NMFS Alaska Region Stranding Program data). Most collisions in Alaska
involve small recreational vessels or whale watch boats with no
apparent long-term consequences for the whale. NMFS is actively working
with sectors of the maritime industry on ship strike avoidance and
awareness programs.
In Hawaii, Lammers et al. (2013) estimated that vessel collisions
(i.e., any physical contact between a humpback whale and a vessel)
increased 20-fold between 1976 and 2011, particularly between 2000 and
2011. As in Alaska, an extensive educational campaign and hotline
number were initiated in 2003 and likely contributed to the increased
number of reports of vessel collisions. However, the authors concluded
that increasing numbers of humpback whales in Hawaii was an important
contributor to the trend. They also suggest that an increase in the
number of vessels of a specific size and changes in behavior of vessels
around humpback whales could affect the rate of vessel collisions.
Although the total number of registered vessels in Hawaii has not
significantly increased in recent years, registered vessels sized
between 7.9 m and 19.8 m has significantly increased. Approximately two
thirds of reported collisions involved vessels that were within the 7.9
m to 19.8 m length range (Lammers et al. 2013).
See the Comments on the Need for Approach Regulations section for
details on our plans to implement approach regulations in Alaska and
Hawaii.
Comment 53: One commenter noted that NOAA can take pride in the
improved status of the species, but too many risks still abound and the
humpback whale is nowhere near its historical numbers. The commenter
indicates that whale strikes from tour ships and commercial vessels are
on the increase each year, noticeably in Southeast Alaska where the
number of docks to accommodate them continually increases. The number
of whale watching boats also increases every year. One study finds the
whales are adapting, but vigilance is warranted. The commenter also
stated that Alaska is also in the forefront of experiencing the effects
of climate change. In northern Alaska, delisting may ease the way for
underwater oil exploration. In Auke Bay, coastal development has been
excessive. Another commenter stated that there are no boat speed limits
in Hawaiian waters or limits on fish nets, adding that limits are
needed on krill fishing in Alaska. Further, removing endangered status
from the humpback whale will weaken legal protections that might limit
the Navy's behavior toward the ocean (high speed ships, active sonar).
Response: The threats mentioned in this comment are described very
generally, and we have no indication that they will negatively impact
humpback whale DPSs on a population level. These whales will still be
protected under the MMPA, which prohibits take and requires that marine
mammal stocks are maintained at optimum sustainable population levels.
We considered the potential for new threats in developing our proposed
determinations, and we conclude that these threats are not likely to
increase the risk of extinction to any of the DPSs not being listed to
the point where they would warrant listing under the ESA. Finally, it
is important to note that the Monitoring Plan we are issuing today
pursuant to section 4(g)(1) of the ESA establishes a framework for
continued monitoring and assessment of threats for the next 10 years
(twice the minimum 5-year monitoring window required by the ESA). The
risk of vessel collisions will be addressed through the approach
regulations (See the Comments on the Need for Approach Regulations
section for details on our plans to implement approach regulations in
Alaska and Hawaii).
Comment 54: One commenter feels that now, more than ever, the
Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary should assume
a leadership role in drafting a comprehensive management plan for
Sanctuary waters that will assist in ensuring the species' lasting
survival. A comprehensive ESA status review, coupled with an updated
and comprehensive Sanctuary management plan, should be completed prior
to any discussion of species delisting.
Response: NOAA's Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine
Sanctuary is developing a revised management plan based on the relevant
elements of the March 2015 draft management plan that focused on
humpback whales and their habitat. NOAA will work with the State of
Hawaii and the Sanctuary Advisory Council on this revised management
plan. However, while we must consider ongoing conservation efforts when
making ESA listing determinations, the ESA does not provide for
extending the timeframe to act on a proposed rule to implement ESA
listing determinations in order to incorporate other management plans.
Therefore, we are finalizing our proposed rule to revise the listing
status of the humpback whale.
Comment on the Mexico DPS
Comment 55: One commenter noted that NMFS stated that the Mexico
DPS has no trend information, yet NMFS is not listing it as endangered.
Response: While we do not have trend information for the Mexico DPS
by itself, there is population growth in most of its primary feeding
areas, and this led us to conclude that it is unlikely to be declining,
as we explained in the proposed rule (58 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The
abundance estimate we relied on in our proposed rule for this DPS was
6,000-7,000, and this abundance estimate, along with available
information on the species' response to ongoing threats, indicated to
us that the Mexico DPS was not in danger of extinction throughout all
or a significant portion of its range or likely to become so within the
foreseeable future. However, the abundance estimate has been updated to
3,264 (CV = 0.06), and we now conclude, in light of the ongoing threat
of fishing gear entanglements which are believed likely to have a
moderate impact on this DPS, that the Mexico DPS is threatened. Lack of
definitive information on a growth rate trend alone is not
determinative of a listing determination, which is based primarily on
an assessment of threats to the species and consideration of whether
the current abundance is sufficient to provide resilience against those
threats. Here, however, in combination with these other considerations,
we conclude that it does
[[Page 62287]]
support a determination of ``threatened'' for the Mexico DPS. (See the
Mexico DPS section below for the rationale for our final listing
determination.)
Comments on the Central America DPS
Comment 56: Several commenters stated that the Central America DPS
should remain endangered, not threatened, because there are only 500-
600 individuals, and the BRT concluded that 500 individuals indicates a
high risk of extinction due to low abundance. One of these commenters
noted that, according to the status review report, the population trend
is unknown, and vessel strikes and fishing gear entanglement are likely
to moderately reduce population size or growth rate. The other
commenter noted that there were many uncertainties associated with the
abundance estimate. Also, one of the commenters stated that this DPS
may serve as a conduit for gene flow between the North Pacific and the
Southern Hemisphere. The Government of Costa Rica agreed that the
SPLASH study results clearly show that the Central America DPS is
smaller than the Hawaii and Mexico DPSs and that the distinction would
facilitate the management and protection of this segment of the
population that uses the waters of Central America for the purpose of
breeding and reproduction.
Response: We have reconsidered our proposal, and we conclude that
the Central America DPS should be listed as endangered under the ESA.
The BRT reported that a preliminary estimate of abundance of the
Central America population was about 500 from the SPLASH project
(Calambokidis et al. 2008), or about 600 based on the reanalysis by
Barlow et al. (2011). There are no estimates of precision associated
with these estimates, so there is considerable uncertainty about the
actual population size (Bettridge et al. 2015). Therefore, the actual
population size could be somewhat larger or smaller than 500-600. Even
though the BRT used 500 as a guideline between moderate and high risk
of extinction (when considering abundance alone), the abundance
estimates include a high level of uncertainty, and we note that this
number straddles that threshold. The BRT concluded that this DPS was
between ``moderate'' and ``high risk of extinction.'' After
reconsidering all of the available information, we believe it is
appropriate to give greater weight to the threats facing the Central
America DPS, and we are now listing the DPS as endangered in this final
rule. An updated abundance estimate of 411 for the Central America DPS
(Wade et al. 2016) provides further support for this conclusion (Please
see the Central America DPS section for further rationale.)
Comment on the Brazil DPS
Comment 57: One commenter noted that the abundance estimate for the
proposed Brazil DPS is from the 1990s and the citation for its
entanglement risk is from a 1998 study reporting that calves are most
heavily involved (a possible challenge to future reproduction). The
commenter stated that although it is clear that mortality is ongoing
and NMFS stated in the status review report of this DPS that there is
``no current estimate of mortality,'' it proposed to remove ESA
protection from this DPS.
Response: The commenter's claim that the abundance estimate was
based on data from the 1990s is incorrect. In the proposed rule (58 FR
22304; April 21, 2015), we cited Andriolo et al. (2010), a study that
is based on aerial surveys conducted off the coast of Brazil in 2002-
2005. However, the population growth rate estimate is based on data
from the 1990s (Ward et al. 2011), which is the best available
information. Because the abundance estimate is 6,400 with a 7.4 percent
growth rate, the BRT concluded that the Brazil DPS was at low risk of
extinction. Based on this, we concluded that, despite the presence of
threats, the Brazil DPS does not meet the definition of a threatened or
endangered species.
Comment on the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
Comment 58: One commenter noted that NMFS stated that the Gabon/
Southwest Africa DPS has no trend information, yet NMFS is not listing
it as endangered. Another commenter stated that abundance estimates for
the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS are cited to a 2008 ``unpublished''
paper that is also inaccessible to the public.
Response: With regard to the comment that we are not listing the
Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS as endangered, despite having no trend
information, please see our responses to Comments 10 and 13. In all
cases, we have based our listing determinations on the best available
scientific and commercial information, as required by the ESA. There is
no requirement that we have specific trend information where the data
establish that the species is not currently endangered or threatened.
Regarding the comment on the abundance estimates being based on an
``unpublished'' paper, the paper we relied on (Collins et al. 2008) was
submitted to the IWC Scientific Committee (Collins et al. 2008), and
the commenter is correct, it was not (to our knowledge) and will not be
published. This paper is available to the public because we have it in
our files and can provide it upon request. Nonetheless, we note that
our final listing determination does not rely on that information. We
have reviewed two more recent papers (Collins et al. 2010, with
abundance estimates of 4,314 (CV = 0.19) for 2001-2004 and 7,134 (CV =
0.23) for 2004-2006) and the IWC (2012) assessment of the Gabon stock
for 2005, which reported an abundance estimate of 9,484 (90 percent
prediction interval (PI) = 7465, 12221) and a growth rate of 0.045 (90
percent PI = 0.006, 0.081)).
The estimates in Collins et al. (2008) had a fairly substantial
genotyping error rate that would produce false negatives (missed
matches), so Collins et al. (2010) corrected for this using an estimate
of genotyping error rates that they estimated by repeat genotyping of a
subset of the samples. The Collins et al. 2010 paper was reviewed in
depth by the Southern Hemisphere subcommittee of the IWC Scientific
Committee. In the IWC (2012) assessment, this committee decided that
the best data to use were the male-only genetic mark-recapture data
(the data that gave the estimate of 7,134 (CV = 0.23)), and we agree.
The IWC (2012) abundance estimate of 9,484 is an output from a very
complicated assessment model. Although in principle it is appropriate
to use model-based estimates like this, the BRT did not do so in any
other cases in its review, and this estimate is from a model that
involved multiple stocks and is thus not directly informative.
Therefore, we will not rely on this model output (and it does not make
any difference to our evaluation of extinction risk).
Further, the ``estimate'' of population growth rate in IWC (2012)
should not be used as an estimate of trend; the IWC (2012) report makes
this same conclusion. This was also a model output from its Bayesian
assessment model, and IWC (2012) explains that this is not an estimate;
rather, it is something that was pre-specified. We agree that it is
better not to rely on this model output as an estimate of population
trend.
Despite the threat of offshore hydrocarbon activity off the coast
of west Africa, the BRT concluded that this DPS was not at risk of
extinction, and we agreed with the BRT's assessment. The updated
abundance estimate for this DPS is still significantly larger than
2,000, which is the population size above which the BRT considered a
DPS not to be likely to be at risk due to low
[[Page 62288]]
abundance alone. We reaffirm our proposed determination that the Gabon/
Southwest Africa DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout all or a
significant portion of its range or likely to become so within the
foreseeable future.
Comments on the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
Comment 59: One commenter asserted that there is a considerable
discrepancy in population estimates cited in the status review report
and derived from surveys in 2004-2006, almost a decade ago. This
commenter added that various data sets and models resulted in best
estimates ranging widely from 4,936 to 8,169. With regard to trend
information, this commenter noted, NMFS cited land-based observations
passing east South Africa that included an estimate of the rate of
population increase of 12.3 percent (which NMFS acknowledges is
``outside biological plausibility for this species'') and a second
estimated increase of 9 percent that NMFS stated is within the range
calculated for other Southern Hemisphere breeding grounds; yet it still
stated that ``both rates are considered with caution.'' This wording
regarding abundance and trend incorporates a great deal of uncertainty
(i.e., wide range of population estimates, words including
``possibly,'' ``to a smaller degree,'' should be ``considered with
caution'') and NMFS itself states that ``given this uncertainty . . .
it is likely the DPS is increasing but it is not possible to provide a
quantitative estimate of the rate of increase.'' The commenter
concludes that NMFS' conclusion is subjective, risk prone, and
inappropriate under the ESA.
Response: Please see our response to Comment 13.
Comments on the West Australia DPS
Comment 60: One commenter asserted that the best abundance estimate
for the West Australia DPS provided in the status review report is
21,750, based on a 2009 paper reporting on results of line transect
surveys and with an estimated 10 percent annual rate of increase that
is at the approximate limit of biological plausibility. This commenter
stated that a more recent study by Kent et al. (2012) provided caveats
in this estimate but provided a ``best estimate'' of 26,100 (CI =
20,152-33,272) and a rate of increase of 10-12 percent annually with a
large coefficient of variance, precluding a reliable trend estimate.
Response: The work cited by the BRT had documented an ~10 percent
rate of increase between 1982 and 1994 (Bannister 1994), and semi-
quantitative information indicated the population had been increasing
steadily since the 1960s. Then Paxton et al. (2011) estimated an
increase of 9.8 percent between 1999 and 2005, and Hedley et al. (2011)
estimated a continued increase on the order of 12.5 percent between
2005 and 2008. The Kent et al. (2012) study cited by the commenter used
completely different data from a different location, but still
estimated an increase of 13 percent (CI = 5.6 percent-18.1 percent) for
the period 2000-2008. When Kent et al. (2012) combined the two data
sets, they estimated an 11.9 percent (SE = 2.6 percent) growth rate for
1999-2008. The West Australia DPS of the humpback whale is, by any
measure, very large, and has been steadily increasing for decades at
one of the highest measured growth rates of any whale.
Kent et al. (2012) noted that the coefficient of variation for the
13-percent growth rate estimate was too large for a reliable trend
estimate. Zerbini et al. (2010) had calculated that 11.8 percent should
be a maximum plausible growth rate for humpback whales. However, it is
important to keep in mind the nature of precision and statistics, where
the estimate can be larger than the true value. One would need an
extremely precise estimate to be able to tell if a growth rate estimate
is significantly greater than the theoretical maximum of 11.8 percent
calculated by Zerbini et al. (2010).
Comments on the East Australia DPS
We did not receive any substantive comments on this DPS, other than
the general comment recommending endangered status for all DPSs and
DPS-related comments (see responses to Comments 3 and 4).
Comments on the Oceania DPS
Comment 61: One commenter noted that NMFS stated that the Oceania
DPS has no trend information, yet NMFS is not listing it as endangered.
Response: We based our proposal on the best available scientific
and commercial information. As noted elsewhere, the ESA does not
require that we have trend information in order to make a determination
under section 4(a)(1). The humpback whale status review report cited a
preliminary report that estimated humpback whale abundance in the
Oceania DPS (New Caledonia, Tonga, French Polynesia, and Cook Islands)
as 3,827 (CV = 0.12) in 1999-2004 (South Pacific Whale Research
Consortium et al. 2006). This abundance estimate is large (>2,000) and,
despite the unknown population trend, we determined that the DPS was at
low risk of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its
range, currently and in the foreseeable future.
Since the BRT's review and publication of the proposed rule, we
became aware of a more recent publication (Constantine et al. 2012),
which included updated data from 2005 and a new analysis that included
genetic data to better account for differences in capture probability
between individuals.
We have considered this study for our final rule. This more recent
publication (Constantine et al. 2012) presents an improved estimate of
abundance in the region (4,329, 95 percent CI = 3,345-5,313) in 2005
and new estimates of population growth rate (3-7 percent/year for 1999-
2005). There is now published evidence that this population is growing.
The previous abundance estimate and available information on the
species' response to ongoing threats indicated that the DPS was not in
danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its
range or likely to become so within the foreseeable future. The new
estimate of population growth rate provides further support for this
conclusion.
Comment 62: One commenter noted that a single DPS (Oceania DPS) has
been proposed for the range of breeding sites across the South Pacific
Ocean basin from New Caledonia to French Polynesia and that NOAA also
proposes to remove all protections under the ESA. The commenter notes
that, last year, the Scientific Committee of the IWC completed an
assessment of the recovery status of whales that breed in this region,
concluding that these breeding populations had only recovered to within
37 percent of pre-whaling numbers as of 2012 (IWC 2015). This commenter
notes that this is well below the 60 percent recovery threshold that
was originally proposed as indicative of recovery under the final
recovery plan. Furthermore, it is far below apparent recovery of
adjacent breeding stocks off west and east Australia (90 percent and 63
percent, respectively). The reason for this relatively low recovery
rate is not known, but this commenter believes that it is adequate
cause for continuing concern and listing under the ESA.
Another commenter asserted that the proposal to identify and delist
the Oceania DPS is troubling, given the major uncertainties underlying
stock definition and status. This commenter noted that the BRT itself
showed substantial concern for this DPS (29 percent of the votes cast
by the NMFS' BRT were suggesting a ``moderate risk''
[[Page 62289]]
of extinction for this DPS). The commenter stated that almost half of
the BRT votes were in the same ``moderate risk'' of extinction category
for the Okinawa/Philippines population, which, together with the Second
West Pacific portion of the Western Pacific DPS, NMFS ultimately
proposed for listing as ``threatened.'' This commenter expressed the
opinion that these distributions of votes should have translated to
equivalent levels of protections for the Oceania and Western North
Pacific DPSs.
The commenter added that numerous studies indicate that humpback
whales in the Oceania DPS move among different island nations and mix
with individuals in the East Australia DPS (Garrigue et al. 2000;
Garrigue et al. 2010; Hauser et al. 2010) and asserted that Garrigue et
al. (2000) concluded, ``[t]he documented movement of some whales among
portions of Oceania indicate that stock assessments based on combining
regional estimates of abundance are likely to be positively biased. In
contrast with the apparent recovery exhibited in Area IV and in the
western portion of Area V, humpback whale abundance appears to remain
low in Oceania, presumably because of overexploitation in the feeding
grounds of Area VI.'' This commenter stated that Hauser et al. (2010),
not cited by NMFS in the status review report or the proposed rule,
stated, ``the feeding ground connections with breeding areas in Oceania
are among the poorest known, as is the degree of movement between
different areas in the southwestern South Pacific.'' Further, the
commenter noted, Garrigue et al. (2006) analyzed whales from New
Caledonia and Tonga using both photo- and genetic-ID and found
``significant differences in the FST and [Fcy]ST
for mitochondrial and nuclear markers, strongly suggesting
differentiation among the Breeding Stock E, supporting the proposed
sub-stock division for New Caledonia (E2) and Tonga (E3).'' The
commenter asserted that NMFS arbitrarily lumped these various areas
into a single DPS without explaining why they constitute a single
breeding stock that differs from the IWC management scheme and
contradicts observations of researchers whose work suggests a complex
situation within breeding grounds in which there may be either mixing
of stocks or, contrarily, isolation in and between different areas
within the region.
The commenter further noted that NMFS indicates there is no trend
information available, the DPS is ``quite sub-divided,'' and the
population estimate applies to an aggregate ``although it is known that
sub-populations differ in growth rates and other demographic
parameters'' (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 100). The commenter stated that
NMFS also acknowledged that some areas of the historical range extent
have not rebounded and there are others without historical whaling
information to indicate pre- and post-exploitation levels. Most
recently, the commenter adds, the Scientific Committee of the IWC
concluded in a stock assessment that ``. . . complexities in Oceania
require further investigation due to inadequate stock structure
definition across the broad area, a lack of population trend data for
most of the region, and a lack of resolution and understanding of
connectivity in eastern Oceania'' (IWC Scientific Committee 2015). The
commenter adds that both the Federal Register notice and the status
review report acknowledge that ``[t]here is uncertainty regarding which
geographic portion of the Antarctic this DPS uses for feeding. The
complex population structure of humpback whales within the Oceania
region creates higher uncertainty regarding demographic parameters and
threat levels than for any other DPS.''
To draw an analogy, the commenter asserted that the uncertainties
underlying the proposed Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS are a
major part of the rationale for NMFS' determination to leave an area
around Cape Verde Islands classified as endangered. However, the
commenter stated, in the face of similar uncertainty regarding the
proposed Oceania DPS, NMFS proposed to delist these humpback whales
despite admitting that it has no reliable population abundance or an
estimate of trend(s) in the various sub-divided areas in the region,
and despite acknowledging that the area used for feeding grounds is
unknown. This is particularly troubling to the commenter, considering
that the agency admits that there is a higher ``uncertainty regarding
demographic parameters and threat levels [for the proposed Oceania DPS]
than for any other DPS.''
Response: As we explained in the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April
21, 2015 at 22317), the 1991 Humpback Whale Recovery Plan did not
identify specific numerical targets based on the recovery criterion
that populations grow to at least 60 percent of their historical (pre-
hunting) abundance because of uncertainty surrounding historical
abundance levels. Further, the Recovery Plan focused on the North
Pacific and North Atlantic populations, so recovery criteria outlined
in the Recovery Plan would not necessarily apply to DPSs in the
Southern Hemisphere. Please see our response to Comment 8.
The 1991 recovery plan recommended an interim goal of doubling the
population size of the humpback whale within 20 years because of
uncertainty surrounding historical abundance levels. However, as we
explained in our proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22316-
22317) and in our response to Comment 8, the BRT focused its biological
risk analysis primarily on recent abundance trends (where available)
and whether absolute abundance was sufficient for biological viability
in light of consideration of the factors under section 4(a)(1). See
Rationale for Revising the Listing Status of a Listed Species Under the
ESA and our responses to Comments 8 and 10 for an explanation of why we
do not need to meet recovery criteria in a recovery plan and why
evaluating whether the population size has met the interim growth rates
for specific years is not the best methodology for evaluating
extinction risk. We considered the best available scientific and
commercial information, and we determined that the abundance of the
Oceania DPS (and now, the population trend estimate, as discussed in
our response to Comment 61) is at a level that demonstrates resilience
against threats and does not support a listing as threatened or
endangered under the ESA. Moreover, as we have explained in response to
other comments, the Services may at any time apply the section 4(a)(1)
factors directly in considering the appropriate listing status for a
species and is not bound to apply the recovery criteria, which are
merely proxies for those factors.
Next we respond to the commenter who asserted that the BRT's
allocation of 29 percent of likelihood points to the ``moderate'' risk
of extinction category for the Oceania DPS should have translated to
equivalent levels of protections for the Oceania and Western North
Pacific DPSs because the BRT allocated less than half of its likelihood
points to the ``moderate'' risk of extinction category for the Okinawa/
Philippines portion of the Western North Pacific DPS. The BRT allocated
44 percent of its likelihood points to the ``moderate'' risk of
extinction category and 36 percent to the ``high'' risk of extinction
category for the Okinawa/Philippines portion of the Western North
Pacific DPS, and 47 percent of its likelihood points to the
``moderate'' risk of extinction category and 14 percent to the ``high''
risk extinction category for the Second West Pacific portion of this
DPS. For the Oceania DPS, the
[[Page 62290]]
distribution of points was quite different in that 68 percent of the
points were allocated to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category,
reflecting much more certainty about the low level of extinction risk
of this DPS compared to that for the Western North Pacific DPS (which
will now, coincidentally, be listed as endangered under this final
rule). We see no parallel between these two examples.
The comparison the other commenter made between the Oceania and
Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPSs is not valid. We have a much
higher abundance estimate for the Oceania DPS (approximately 4,300
whales compared to less than 100 for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest
Africa DPS), good information on where whales are, some information
about movements between areas, and a fair degree of reliability around
the abundance estimate. In contrast, there is a great lack of knowledge
and study of the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS, and only one
genetics study that indicates there is more than one breeding
population for humpback whales feeding in central and eastern North
Atlantic. It is appropriate to use additional caution in the case of
the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS, given the considerable
uncertainty about where the central and eastern North Atlantic animals
breed and the likelihood that the abundance of this DPS is extremely
low (less than 100).
We know there are significant genetic differences between some of
the regional breeding grounds within the Oceania DPS, but,
unfortunately, there are no accepted estimates of abundance for some of
the regions currently aggregated into the Oceania stock (e.g., Tonga,
French Polynesia). Even if we had reliable regional estimates, we have
no way of allocating the historical catches in the Antarctic feeding
grounds to regional breeding grounds, with confidence. Therefore, the
IWC chose to undertake the comprehensive assessment for Oceania as an
aggregate, and the BRT took this same approach. The commenter who
expressed concern about the likelihood of a positively biased estimate
for the Oceania DPS because of the exchange among areas makes a good
point. On the other hand, abundance estimates are also likely to be
negatively biased because we are almost certainly not surveying some
significant habitats within the vast area of Oceania, and as a result,
there are probably many whales with a zero probability of capture in
the survey years that lead to abundance estimates. Please see our
response to Comment 5 for an explanation of why statistically
significant differences between populations are not sufficient
justification for identifying DPSs.
Comment 63: One commenter noted that the longest humpback whale
migration on record is not from Costa Rica to Antarctica (Rasmussen et
al. 2007) as stated on page 24 of the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April
21, 2015 at 22308); rather, they state, the longest minimum return
movement has been documented as 18,840 km from American Samoa to the
Antarctic Peninsula (Robbins et al. 2011). This extreme movement is an
example of the complexity of movement in the South Pacific, and the
challenges that we face in understanding its status.
Response: We appreciate the updated information on the longest
humpback whale migration distance. The updated information on maximum
migration distance has been considered but does not cause us to change
the determinations in this final rule. Our listing determinations are
supported by consideration of the best available scientific and
commercial information.
Comments on the Southeastern Pacific DPS
Comment 64: Two commenters noted that NMFS stated that the
Southeastern Pacific DPS has no trend information, yet NMFS is not
listing it as endangered. One of these commenters noted that the study
on which NMFS relies for the population estimate uses data collected
from non-systematic sightings by whale watch vessels, data that NMFS
virtually never uses for its U.S. stock assessments because of the
unreliability of data from non-systematic tracks used by commercial
whale watching vessels. Having provided that population estimate, the
commenter added, NMFS failed to include in the discussion an important
recommendation from this study, which was that there is a pressing need
for information on ``population parameters such as survival and birth
rates, population growth rates and movements, all of which are still
poorly known for this population'' (Felix et al. 2011). This commenter
stated that it would seem important to better understand all of this
information before proposing to remove all protections.
One commenter expressed concern about the threat of fishing gear
entanglement, noting that NMFS indicated that entanglement poses the
most serious risk to this DPS. The commenter stated that the problem of
entanglement is significant enough for the proposed Southeastern
Pacific DPS that researchers have recently warned that the ``intensive
use of gillnets and the increasing use of longlines in artisanal
fisheries represent serious threats to the conservation of large
cetaceans in Peru and the Southeast Pacific and need to be addressed by
national and regional conservation authorities'' (Garc[iacute]a-Godos
et al. 2013). The commenter quoted from a study during a single year in
Ecuador that extrapolated observed bycatch rates, resulting in a total
bycatch in Ecuador in 2005 ``estimated to be 25 whales (C.I. 95
percent, 20-32). This high bycatch rate is the result of the over-
dimensioned artisanal fishing fleet and the lack of fishing
management'' (Felix et al. 2005). The commenter stated that Alava et
al. (2011) confirmed that this bycatch is continuing in Ecuador,
estimating that ``bycatch mortality is equivalent to 15 or 33 whales a
year'' depending on assumptions of population size interacting with the
estimated 15,000 vessels fishing off Ecuador; these authors expressed
concern about the Southeastern Pacific DPS' breeding grounds becoming a
hot spot for bycatch and cautioned that ``mitigation strategies and
precautionary management and conservation measures are required to
protect this vulnerable stock of whales in the long term.'' The
commenter added that we did not consider this study, which also depicts
a declining birth rate off Ecuador--contrasting to higher birth rates
in Colombian calving areas. The commenter noted that the authors warn,
``[c]onsidering low birth rates [off Ecuador] of less than 8% and 62%
survival rates for this stock and possibly ~1% of the total population
bycaught per year, the bycatch problem seems to be far more severe and
can pose a serious threat for this humpback whale population
survival.''
This commenter noted that Capella Alzueta et al. (2001), cited in
the status review report, looked at stranded animals and found the
``annual frequency of occurrence over the 15-year period indicates an
increasing trend of entanglement and vessel strike since 1996.'' The
commenter asserted that the BRT mislead readers by implying that
humpback whales are not struck by ships, even though Capella Alzueta et
al. (2001) report increasing trends in carcasses evidencing both vessel
collisions and entanglement.
With regard to other threats to this stock, the same commenter
noted that the status review cited a study from ten years ago that
found that oil and gas production is increasing in Ecuador and
stipulated energy development is likely to expand if oil and gas
reserves are discovered in the area but indicated that ``it does not
currently pose a threat to this population.'' Indeed, the
[[Page 62291]]
commenter asserted, there is increasing onshore production that
requires additional shipping and, as the status review report
indicates, there is a spill risk from difficult navigation in the area.
The commenter stated that NMFS should be evaluating the threat over the
foreseeable future, not just at the present time.
This commenter also asserted that the status review report
insufficiently addressed krill harvest, and that this harvest may well
be increasing with the decline in abundance of other commercial fishery
targets and the indication from the Marine Stewardship Council that it
is willing to certify Antarctic krill harvests as sustainable. The
commenter stated that the likely impact of this increasing harvest is
compounded by increasing warming of the Antarctic waters and range
contraction of krill.
The commenter concluded that, given the acknowledgement that
``population parameters such as survival and birth rates, population
growth rates and movements . . . are still poorly known for this
population'' and, in light of threats to this population from
entanglement, future fishery conflicts in a warming ocean, it appears
premature to remove this stock from the protections offered by its ESA
listing.
Response: Abundance estimates for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
suggest that it is increasing. While we still do not have trend
information for this DPS, we based our proposal on the best available
scientific and commercial information. The abundance estimate of 6,504
individuals (95 percent CI: 4,270-9,907) is likely to be an
underestimate because, as we stated in the proposed rule, only a
portion of the DPS was enumerated for this estimate. This estimate is
much higher than 2,000, and the BRT did not consider populations larger
than 2,000 to be at risk due to low abundance alone. All threats other
than fishing gear entanglement are likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown for the
Southeastern Pacific DPS. Despite our conclusion that fishing gear
entanglements are likely to moderately reduce the population size or
the growth rate of this DPS, the large population size makes this
threat unlikely to contribute significantly to the extinction risk of
the Southeastern Pacific DPS, now or in the foreseeable future. (Also,
see our response to Comment 21 for possible explanations for an
increase in number of fishing gear entanglements.) Therefore, we
conclude that this DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout all or
a significant portion of its range or likely to become so within the
foreseeable future.
As we have acknowledged, the BRT concluded that fishing gear
entanglement is likely to moderately reduce the abundance or population
growth rate of the Southeastern Pacific DPS. The commenter cited
Garc[iacute]a-Godos et al. (2013) in asserting that this threat needed
to be addressed by national and regional conservation authorities.
Garc[iacute]a-Godos et al. (2013) expressed concern about the 10
humpback whales entangled off Peru between 1995 and 2012 and suggested
that this was likely a small fraction of fishing gear entanglements
because the data-collection methodology applied was largely
opportunistic. They recommended a nationally and regionally integrated
stranding network along the Peruvian coast, capable of monitoring the
impacts of fisheries and shipping on populations of large cetaceans off
Peru, as well as encouraging reporting of whale entanglements by
fishermen and raising awareness among fishermen and coastal communities
of the impacts of whale entanglements, potential preventive and
mitigation measures, and reporting duties. We agree that all of these
recommendations would benefit humpback whales in the Southeastern
Pacific DPS, but we do not agree with the commenter's assertion, based
on fishing gear entanglements off Peru and Ecuador, that this threat is
likely to negatively impact this DPS to such a degree that extinction
risk is increased. The abundance of this DPS is high, and we do not
consider the threat to be causing the DPS to be threatened or
endangered. Most of the threats the BRT evaluated are subject to
various national, international, and/or local regulations, and the BRT
determined that the adequacy of these regulations is, at least to a
large degree, reflected in the overall biological status of the
species. The BRT also considered the adequacy of the major regulations
governing these threats when making predictions about future status.
Please see Comment 65 for a list of ongoing conservation efforts in
Colombia, where humpback whales from the Southeastern Pacific DPS are
more concentrated.
With regard to the comment about ship strikes, again, we do not
consider this to be a significant threat to the Southeastern Pacific
DPS. The commenter neglected to provide a more full statement of the
conclusion from Capella Alzueta et al. (2001), which stated, ``[w]hile
the current rate of mortality from human related activities (fishing
gear or vessel strike) does not appear to seriously threaten this stock
of humpback whales, it may slow its population recovery.'' ``Population
recovery'' as used by the commenter does not have the same meaning as
``recovery'' under the ESA; instead, it refers to the goal of reaching
historical abundance or carrying capacity, which, as we explained in
our response to Comment 9, is not the goal of recovery under the ESA.
We are required to determine whether a species is actually threatened
or endangered because of any of the ESA section 4(a)(1) factors; we
consider the information known about threats over the course of the
foreseeable future, but we are not permitted to rely on speculation
about future impacts. We agree with the BRT that the Southeastern
Pacific DPS is not currently threatened by vessel strikes. We disagree
that there is a sufficient basis to predict serious impacts in the
foreseeable future. We reaffirm our conclusion that ship strikes pose a
low risk to this DPS now or within the foreseeable future.
With regard to climate change impacts on the availability of krill
to humpback whales, please see our response to Comment 25. With regard
to the commenter's concern about certification of krill fisheries, to
date, the Marine Stewardship Council has certified two krill fisheries
in the Antarctic, Aker Biomarine and Norwegian Olympic Seafood (see
https://www.msc.org/newsroom/news/msc-responds-to-questions-about-antarctic-krill-certification and https://www.msc.org/newsroom/news/antarctic-krill-fishery-achieves-msc-certification/?searchterm=krill).
The Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living
Resources (CCAMLR) came into being at least in part to address concerns
that an increase in krill catches in the Southern Ocean could have a
serious effect on populations of krill and other marine life,
particularly on birds, seals, whales, and fish, which mainly depend on
krill for food. The 25 governments of CCAMLR that regulate the krill
fishery have adopted a precautionary approach to minimize risk, and
they set the overall quotas to specifically take into account the needs
of dependent predators. CCAMLR is widely regarded as the most
precautionary of all organizations in terms of setting catch quotas.
The total krill catch allowed in the fishery area (CCAMLR Area 48)
represents just 1 percent (620,000 tonnes) of the population of krill
(estimated at 62 million tonnes). Olympic Seafood currently catches
around 3 percent (15,000 tonnes) of the 620,000 tonnes catch limit set
by CCAMLR. By contrast it is estimated
[[Page 62292]]
that predators eat at least 20 million tonnes annually (32 percent
total krill biomass). Trigger levels are set so that fishing cannot be
too concentrated in one area. At these low rates fishing has a very
minimal impact on predators and other species in the food chain.
Given what we know about the Southeastern Pacific DPS of the
humpback whale and the threats it faces, we still conclude that the DPS
is at low risk of extinction, now and within the foreseeable future. We
have based our determination on the best available scientific and
commercial information, including an evaluation of ongoing conservation
efforts (see our response to Comment 65).
Comment 65: The Directorate for Marine and Coastal Affairs and
Aquatic Resources (DAMCRA) of the Colombian Ministry of Environment and
Sustainable Development stated that it will maintain the humpback whale
as ``vulnerable'' (IUCN), and it provided references for population
size estimates in Malaga Bay (857--Florez-Gonzalez et al. 2007) and
Gorgona Island (1,366--Escobar 2009; Caballero et al. 2000, 2001,
2009). It also provided some biological and conservation effort
information (the Plan of Action for the Conservation of the Aquatic
Mammals in the Southeast Pacific of the Permanent Commission of the
Southeast Pacific; the Strategy for the Conservation of the Humpback
Whale of the Southeast Pacific; the recent adhesion of Colombia to the
International Whaling Commission for the Regulation of the Hunt of
Whales (Law 1348 of 2009); National Action Plan for the Conservation of
the Aquatic Mammals of Colombia; the Diagnosis of the State of
Knowledge and Conservation of the Aquatic Mammals in Colombia; and the
Plan of Migratory Species, Diagnosis and Identification of Actions for
the Conservation and the Sustainable Management of Migratory Species of
the Biodiversity in Colombia. Finally, Colombia also provided a paper
by Carmona et al. (2011) entitled ``Occurrence and encounter rates of
marine mammals in the waters around the Malpelo Island and to the
continent.''
Response: We acknowledge and appreciate the information Colombia
has provided and are encouraged to know about Colombia's humpback whale
conservation efforts.
Comments on the Arabian Sea DPS
Comment 66: One commenter asserted that we underestimated the risk
of climate change vs. geography-based protections for the Arabian Sea
DPS.
Response: The comment is unclear. Our proposal to list the Arabian
Sea DPS as endangered was partially based on the potential impact of
climate change within the foreseeable future on a species that is so
restricted geographically that it cannot adapt to climate change by
moving elsewhere. In any case, we are finalizing a listing for this DPS
at the highest possible level (endangered).
Comments on ``Depleted'' Status under the MMPA
Comment 67: Several commenters asserted that removal of any DPSs
from the list of endangered or threatened species would result in loss
of depleted status under the MMPA. The commenters noted that NMFS could
re-designate a species or stock as depleted if warranted.
Response: We agree with the commenters that a species or stock that
is considered to be depleted solely on the basis of an ESA listing
loses that status if it is removed from the list of threatened or
endangered species. Section 3(1) of the MMPA defines ``depleted'' as
``any case in which:'' (1) the Secretary ``determines that a species or
population stock is below its optimum sustainable population;'' (2) a
state to which authority has been delegated makes the same
determination; or (3) a species or stock ``is listed as an endangered
species or a threatened species under the [ESA]'' (16 U.S.C. 1362(1)).
In the case of a species or stock that achieved its depleted status
solely on the basis of its ESA status, the species or stock would cease
to qualify as depleted under the terms of the definition set forth in
section 3(1) if the species or stock is no longer listed as threatened
or endangered. Humpback whales were considered depleted species-wide
under the MMPA solely on the basis of the species' ESA listing. Upon
the effective date of this rule, humpback whales that are listed as
threatened or endangered will retain depleted status under the MMPA.
Humpback whales that are not listed as threatened or endangered will
not have depleted status under the MMPA. We note that the DPSs
established in this final rule that occur in waters under the
jurisdiction of the United States do not equate to the existing MMPA
stocks for which Stock Assessment Reports (SARs) have been published in
accordance with section 117 of the MMPA (16 U.S.C. 1386). For further
information on how this rulemaking affects existing MMPA stocks in U.S.
waters, please see ``Effects of this Rulemaking,'' below.
Comment 68: One commenter suggested that NMFS ask the BRT to re-
convene as soon as possible to determine if any of the DPSs proposed to
be delisted are below their OSP. The commenter also recommended that in
the future NMFS consider rulemaking approaches that would avoid any
lapse in depleted status for stocks that are below their OSP.
Response: The specific charge to the Humpback Whale BRT was to
assess and describe the status of humpback whales pursuant to the ESA,
and to identify potential DPSs and evaluate the extinction risk of
those potential DPSs. NMFS did not ask the BRT to determine MMPA stock
delineations or evaluate any MMPA stocks relative to OSP because NMFS
did not want to conflate the two laws and their different standards for
evaluating species and populations. As described below in the ``Effects
of this Rulemaking'' section, at the time of a delisting, NMFS may
choose to initiate a rulemaking under MMPA section 115(a) if
information in its files or information presented by a Scientific
Review Group indicates that the species or stock is below its OSP. In
such cases, NMFS agrees that it would be beneficial to avoid or
minimize any lapse in depleted status and associated MMPA protections
for marine mammals that may be below their OSP. NMFS is evaluating
different approaches to minimize any such lapse.
Comment 69: One group of commenters asserted that depleted status
under the MMPA should be maintained for all humpback whales. The
commenters stated that any change in an unlisted DPS' depleted status
can occur only through a separate rulemaking.
Response: We disagree with the commenters. Consistent with the D.C.
Circuit's opinion in In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing
and Section 4(d) Rule Litigation, 720 F.3d 354 (D.C. Cir. 2013), we
believe that the process described in MMPA section 115(a) applies only
to the first basis for designating a species as depleted (i.e., when
the agency determines that the species is below its OSP). Therefore, we
are required to issue a rule in accordance with the process described
in section 115(a) to determine that a species or stock is no longer
depleted in cases where we previously issued a rule pursuant to section
115(a) designating the species or stock as depleted on the basis that
it is below its OSP. However, in the case of a species or stock that
achieved depleted status solely on the basis of an ESA listing,
depleted status automatically terminates if the species or stock is
removed from the list of threatened or endangered species. For more
information, please see the
[[Page 62293]]
response to Comment 67 and ``Effects of this Rulemaking,'' below.
Comment 70: One commenter stated that PBR for the MMPA Gulf of
Maine stock would increase from 2.6 to between 13.4 and 26 if the West
Indies DPS is no longer ESA-listed. The commenter noted that current
fishery-related mortality is 7.2 individuals per year, which is above
the current PBR but would likely be below the new PBR and thus this
stock would no longer be a priority under the MMPA.
Response: The Gulf of Maine stock of humpback whales partially
coincides with the West Indies DPS, which is no longer listed under the
ESA. Therefore, the Gulf of Maine stock will no longer have depleted
status under the MMPA. The stock's PBR is expected to increase
following the change in depleted status, because the depleted status
affects the selection of the recovery factor used in the PBR
calculation. Despite the fact that fishery-related mortality was
exceeding the previously-defined PBR for the Gulf of Maine stock (2.6),
the abundance of the West Indies DPS is large and increasing. The Gulf
of Maine stock is only a small component of the total West Indies DPS
of the humpback whale. The best estimate for the total population of
humpback whales in the Gulf of Maine stock is 823 animals (Waring et
al. 2014), while the overall population of the West Indies DPS is
estimated to be between 10,400 and 10,752 individuals (Bettridge et al.
2015; please see response to Comment 31). We plan to review the MMPA
Gulf of Maine stock delineation with respect to the West Indies DPS in
the near future. Any resulting change in stock delineation, strategic
status, PBR, or other MMPA section 117 elements would be proposed in
future stock assessment reports following Scientific Review Group
review, with opportunity for public comment.
Comment 71: One commenter stated that the MMPA is adequate in
identifying depleted status, and no change is necessary to the MMPA at
this time. Under 16 U.S.C. 1362, section 2(1)(A), ``the Secretary,
after consultation with the Marine Mammal Commission and the Committee
of Scientific Advisors on Marine Mammals established under subchapter
III of this chapter, determines that a species or population stock is
below its optimum sustainable population.'' This mechanism authorizing
the Secretary to declare any DPS of the humpback whale as ``depleted''
is an open and transparent process and is adequate use of the best
available scientific information.
Response: We did not propose any changes to the MMPA, which is a
Federal law that may only be amended by Congress.
Comment 72: One commenter stated that if the West Indies DPS is not
listed under the ESA, NMFS should reevaluate the inclusion of humpback
whales as a strategic stock in the ALWTRP. For example, how does the
MMPA Gulf of Maine stock (800 minimum population size, PBR = 2.7) and
its management align with the West Indies DPS? If the Gulf of Maine is
one of the primary feeding grounds for the West Indies DPS, how can the
population estimate used in the ALWTRP 2014 final rule be so much
smaller than that which is described in the proposed rule? There needs
to be clear and sensible interplay between the ESA, MMPA, and ALWTRP.
Response: We plan to review the MMPA Gulf of Maine stock
delineation with respect to the West Indies DPS in the near future. Any
resulting change in stock delineation, strategic status, PBR, or other
MMPA section 117 elements would be proposed in future stock assessment
reports following Scientific Review Group review, with opportunity for
public comment. Once final, any changes would be reflected in other
related management programs, as appropriate. Humpback whales will
remain within the scope of the ALWTRP regulations unless changed by
separate rulemaking, and this is not affected by the action we take
today.
Comments on the Need for Approach Regulations
Comment 73: One commenter stated that approach regulations are not
necessary in Hawaii because vessels do not pose a threat to the
population. The commenter added that the Sanctuary regulations provide
enough protection, given the high density of humpback whales there that
overlap with whale watching. Further, the commenter suggested, NMFS
determined that vessel collisions pose a negligible impact to the
Hawaii DPS and, when they do occur, there is little warning, so
approach regulations would not be helpful. Instead, the commenter
believes we should enhance outreach efforts to educate the public on
safe approach distances.
Response: We appreciate the comments received in response to our
request on this issue. As a direct consequence of our final listing
determination, the current regulations protecting whales from approach
in Hawaii, which were promulgated only under authority of the ESA, are
no longer supported. Therefore, upon the effective date of this final
rule, the existing regulations at 50 CFR 224.103(a) will be deleted and
that paragraph of the regulations reserved. However, given the
importance of the issue, we have determined that approach regulations
in Hawaii should be developed through a separate rulemaking under the
MMPA, in the form of an interim final rule published elsewhere in
today's issue of the Federal Register. As detailed in the separate
interim final rule, we have determined that relying solely on
protections within the Sanctuary would be inadequate. Comments received
in response to the request for information on this topic through our
proposed rule were considered in connection with that process. There
will also be a further opportunity for comment in response to the
interim final approach regulations.
To clarify the issues raised by the commenter, we have not
determined that vessel collisions pose a negligible impact to the
Hawaii DPS; we did, however, find that the mortality and serious injury
incidental to Hawaii deep-set and shallow-set longline fisheries have a
negligible impact on this DPS (79 FR 62105; October 16, 2014). While
the analysis considered all sources of human-caused mortality and
serious injury, including vessel strikes, the determination was
specific to these fisheries.
Comment 74: One commenter stated that approach regulations under
the MMPA should be issued in Hawaiian waters and that we should work
with the Sanctuary on its regulations.
Response: As noted above, we developed a separate interim final
rule to promulgate approach regulations for Hawaii under the MMPA, and
this has been done in coordination with the Sanctuary managers. We
believe the approach regulations that we are issuing, published
elsewhere in this issue of the Federal Register, are largely consistent
with the Sanctuary's regulations.
Comment 75: The State of Hawaii Department of Land and Natural
Resources (DLNR) noted that references to Hawaii State law protections
were missing from the proposed rule. Under Hawaii Administrative Rules
(HAR) section 13-244-40, the Hawaii DLNR prohibits approach within 100
yards of a humpback whale in State waters (0-3 nmi). Under HAR sections
13-256-16 and 19, the Hawaii DLNR prohibits the use of thrill craft and
parasail vessels off South and West Maui to avoid possible adverse
impacts on humpback whales. The Hawaii DLNR recommends that the final
rule include references to the State of Hawaii's relevant rules.
[[Page 62294]]
Response: We acknowledge the Hawaii DLNR's comment and appreciate
the reference to their regulations.
Comment 76: The Hawaii DLNR also stated that the March 26, 2015,
NOAA rule revising regulations within the Sanctuary proposed to
strengthen the Sanctuary's humpback whale approach regulation to
address ``interceptions,'' otherwise known as leapfrogging (80 FR
16223). It noted that, though the State can regulate vessel approach
out to 3 nm, and the Sanctuary can regulate approach in Federal and
State waters of the Sanctuary, these efforts alone do not sufficiently
protect humpback whales from vessel interactions throughout the
Hawaiian Islands and out to the seaward boundary of the U.S. EEZ (200
mi). Therefore, the Hawaii DLNR encourages NOAA to promulgate the 100-
yard approach regulations and 1,000-ft overflight regulation under the
MMPA, as this would make regulations consistent throughout state and
Federal waters off Hawaii, thus improving compliance. NOAA should also
consider including those provisions from the Sanctuary proposed rule
that address leapfrogging. The Hawaii DLNR intends to adopt these
provisions.
Response: We are issuing an interim final rule to implement
approach regulations in Hawaii under the MMPA, published elsewhere in
this issue of the Federal Register. These regulations are similar to
the State of Hawaii regulations and the Sanctuary regulations, and they
include an additional provision prohibiting interception (or
``leapfrogging''). Please see the interim final rule published
elsewhere in today's issue of the Federal Register for additional
details.
Comment 77: The State of Alaska noted that NMFS promulgated the
approach regulations in Alaska under both the ESA and the MMPA, so if
the ESA status of the Hawaii DPS is revised, the authority under MMPA
should remain. For the Western North Pacific DPS, which is proposed to
be listed as threatened, authority for this regulation under both the
ESA and MMPA should be valid. The State supported retaining the
approach regulations in U.S. waters off Alaska because of the
conservation benefits that will accrue to both the proposed threatened
Western North Pacific DPS and to the increasing number of whales in the
Hawaii DPS that frequent Alaska waters in summer. Potential areas of
concern at present for this DPS include ship strikes and entanglements,
which are currently at low levels, but continued enforcement of
approach regulations will assist in keeping those levels low.
Response: We appreciate the State of Alaska's comments, and we
concur. In a separate, direct final rule (publishing elsewhere in
today's issue of the Federal Register), we are publishing a technical
correction making minor amendments to the regulations currently set out
in the part of the Code of Federal Regulations that applies to
endangered marine and anadromous species (at 50 CFR 224.103(b)) and
recodifying them so that they also appear in the part that applies to
threatened marine and anadromous species (at 50 CFR 223.214) and in the
part setting out MMPA regulations (at 50 CFR 216.18). Setting out these
approach regulations at 50 CFR 223.214 will ensure that threatened
humpback whales in Alaska (which includes the threatened Mexico DPS)
will also be protected under the ESA approach regulations. As noted
above, we have determined that the Western North Pacific DPS is
endangered instead of threatened (see Western North Pacific DPS section
for rationale), so the approach regulations will also remain at 50 CFR
224.103 for their continuing protection. Setting the regulations out at
216.18 reflects that the approach regulations in Alaska were also
originally promulgated under the authority of the MMPA and that they
protect all whales in Alaskan waters whether listed under the ESA or
not.
Comments on Critical Habitat
Comment 78: Colombia provided an atlas of distribution, migratory
routes, and critical and threatened habitat for large whales in the
East Pacific.
Response: We appreciate the information. However, pursuant to the
regulations implementing the ESA, we lack authority to designate
critical habitat in non-U.S. waters (50 CFR 424.12(g)).
Comment 79: Jamaica stated that the Silver-Navidad-Muchoir bank
complex is a major breeding area in the West Indies and could qualify
as critical habitat.
Response: We appreciate Jamaica's comment. However, pursuant to the
regulations implementing the ESA, we lack authority to designate
critical habitat in non-U.S. waters (50 CFR 424.12(g)).
Comment 80: One commenter noted that protecting habitat will be
difficult without the additional protections of the ESA, and most of
the threats require active management of habitat.
Response: A critical habitat designation has limited regulatory
effect and does not mean that NMFS will actively manage habitat.
Rather, when an area is designated as critical habitat, Federal
agencies must consult with us on any action they authorize, fund, or
carry out that may affect the area to ensure that the action is not
likely to destroy or adversely modify that habitat (16 U.S.C.
1536(a)(2)).
There are separate tools for protection of habitat that are beyond
the scope of this rulemaking. For example, section 112(e) of the MMPA
gives us authority to promulgate regulations to protect habitat for
strategic stocks. Stocks that maintain depleted status (see Comments on
``Depleted'' Status under the MMPA) due to endangered/threatened status
will remain strategic. Other laws will continue to protect habitat used
by humpback whales (e.g., Clean Water Act, National Environmental
Policy Act).
Comment 81: One commenter stated that critical habitat is not
necessary in Guam and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands
(CNMI) because it is unlikely to provide a measureable conservation
benefit to the DPS and there are no threats there to the Western North
Pacific DPS. Another commenter stated that, despite NMFS' clear
statutory mandate, NMFS has never designated critical habitat for
humpback whales. This commenter noted that amending the listing status
for humpback whales would trigger NMFS' duty anew. If NMFS goes forward
with its proposal, this commenter asserted, NMFS must designate
critical habitat for any and all ESA-listed humpback whale populations
in U.S. waters.
Response: The humpback whale was first listed under the precursor
to the ESA in 1970, and was transferred to the list of endangered
species under the original ESA before the statute was amended to
require designation of critical habitat for listed species. Therefore,
there was no statutory requirement to designate critical habitat for
the endangered humpback whale. We agree with the commenter that, upon
revising the listing status of the humpback whale to recognize 14 DPSs
and list five of them as threatened or endangered, the obligation
arises to designate critical habitat in areas under U.S. jurisdiction
for the listed DPSs to the maximum extent prudent and determinable (16
U.S.C. 1533(a)(3)(A)). Our regulations provide that critical habitat is
not determinable when data sufficient to perform required analyses are
lacking and/or the biological needs of the species are not sufficiently
well known (50 CFR 424.12(a)(2)). At this time, we find that critical
habitat is not determinable for both of these reasons, as discussed
further in the ``Effects of this Action'' section, below.
[[Page 62295]]
We are currently evaluating the habitat needs of humpback whale
DPSs that occur in U.S. waters to determine habitat areas that may be
essential in supporting the conservation of the species, including
areas occupied at the time of listing that contain essential physical
and biological features for humpback whales and unoccupied areas that
may be essential for their conservation (16 U.S.C. 1532(5)). At this
time, we cannot predict whether designating critical habitat in Guam
and CNMI or anywhere else will be ``prudent,'' e.g., whether it will
provide a conservation benefit to the species (50 CFR
424.12(a)(1)(ii)). If we identify areas that meet the definition of
critical habitat, we will publish a proposed rule and solicit public
comments on the proposal before finalizing any critical habitat
designation.
Comments on Monitoring Humpback Whale DPSs
Comment 82: One commenter provided actions that should be included
in the Monitoring Plan: Continuation of SPLASH, at least in part;
Entanglement Response Program; abundance estimates by aerial surveys;
humpback whale strike/contact database; serious injury determinations;
sanctuary research efforts; outreach programs; ocean etiquette;
guidelines for boater and ocean users; sanctuary ocean count; sanctuary
interagency law enforcement task force; ship strike workshop; humpback
whale protections working group. Another commenter (MMC) suggested that
we reexamine population structure and DPSs with more genetic sampling
and other studies, that we reconvene the BRT after the final
determination to seek advice on humpback whale research and monitoring,
that we share advice with states and countries, and that we announce
the reconvening of a BRT after 5 years.
Response: Today we are issuing a Monitoring Plan for the nine
humpback whale DPSs that are not being listed under the ESA. The
Monitoring Plan Coordinator will work with collaborators to identify
specific surveys and monitoring efforts that we can use to continue
monitoring these humpback whales. We believe most, if not all, of the
actions identified by the commenter would provide valuable information,
and we will pursue them within fiscal and other constraints. As far as
the recommendation that we reconvene the BRT to seek advice on research
and monitoring, we already consulted with many BRT members as we
developed the Monitoring Plan. We plan to collaborate with States and
countries in an effort to gather data from all humpback whale DPSs that
are not listed under the ESA. With regard to reconvening a BRT after 5
years, the ESA requires us to conduct a 5-year review after a species
has been removed from threatened or endangered status. As we get closer
to that date, we will know more about our plans for conducting that
review.
Comment 83: The State of Massachusetts recommended that NMFS fund
population surveys to update abundance and trend information.
Response: Population surveys are important, and we intend to work
with collaborators from the States and other Federal agencies to take
advantage of ongoing surveys and stranding databases to monitor
abundance, trends, and health of humpback whale DPSs that are not being
listed under the ESA. However, we cannot predict our budget or
competing priorities from year to year. Further, we cannot commit or
require any Federal agency to obligate or pay funds in contravention of
the Anti-Deficiency Act, 31 U.S.C. 1341, or any other law or
regulation.
Comment 84: The State of Alaska noted that various groups have
expressed concerns about the potential for increased ship strikes by
cruise ships and whale-watching vessels as the humpback whale
population increases in Southeast Alaska, but pointed out that such
``takes'' for DPSs that are not listed will still be prohibited under
the MMPA (but no longer the ESA). The State of Alaska stated that if
the proposed rule is finalized, the post-delisting monitoring effort
will present opportunities for the State to comment on such concerns
and the need to develop feasible mitigation measures, an effort to
which the State would like to contribute.
Response: We worked closely with the State of Alaska and other
entities to develop a Monitoring Plan, sent it out for public comment
and peer review, and are issuing it today with publication of this
final rule. We also appreciate the State of Alaska's willingness to
contribute to developing feasible mitigation measures.
Comment 85: One commenter noted that funding for population
monitoring would be reduced and eventually removed if ESA protections
are removed from humpback whales. This commenter asserted that it is
unlikely that a reduction in sustainability of any humpback whale DPS
will be acknowledged until it is too late. Adding the DPS back to the
Endangered and Threatened Species list and developing a recovery plan
will take too long.
Response: We disagree. Under the MMPA we are required to assess
strategic marine mammal stocks in the United States every year, and
non-strategic stocks every 3 years. We do not expect other countries to
discontinue their monitoring efforts of humpback whale DPSs that are
not listed under the ESA. For example, the IWC will continue to assess
the status of humpback whale stocks in order to conserve and manage
them. Finally, it is important to note that the Monitoring Plan we are
issuing today per section 4(g)(1) of the ESA (16 U.S.C. 1533(g)(1))
establishes a framework for continued monitoring and assessment of
threats for the next 10 years (twice the minimum 5-year monitoring
window required by the ESA). We do not expect any existing funding to
be reduced or removed with removal of ESA protections.
Comment 86: One commenter noted that some of the proposed DPSs are
simply too large to effectively or routinely study and manage,
including in the event of post-delisting monitoring.
Response: Size of a DPS and ability to manage it did not factor
into our identification of DPSs (please see response to Comment 3 for
more details on DPS Policy criteria). DPSs must meet the criteria of
the DPS Policy, and we do our best to study and manage DPSs once they
are identified and listed under the ESA. We will use the best
scientific and commercial data available to monitor DPSs that are not
listed under the ESA.
Comments on the Draft Monitoring Plan
Comment 87: The Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADFG) supported
our efforts and offered editorial suggestions for clarification and
consistency in the Monitoring Plan.
Response: We acknowledge ADFG's support, and we appreciate the
editorial suggestions, which we have incorporated into the final
Monitoring Plan that we are issuing today.
Comment 88: The Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries (DMF)
fully supports the development of the Monitoring Plan and is interested
in contributing to a successful Monitoring Plan to ensure that NMFS and
its collaborators can successfully detect changes in the status of the
stock and ensure the non-listed DPSs are appropriately managed.
Response: We acknowledge MA DMF's support and appreciate its
willingness to contribute.
Comment 89: The MA DMF strongly urges NMFS and collaborators to
coordinate efforts to collect photo ID
[[Page 62296]]
mark-recapture data during the monitoring period, which requires
prioritization of sustained and increased funding of vessel-based
surveys. The DMF notes that the Monitoring Plan cannot rely
predominately on threat monitoring or serious injuries and mortalities
without considering those threats and cases in the context of
population monitoring. Another commenter noted that NMFS provides
caveats with regard to achieving its aims and the sufficiency of
funding, and this is cause for concern regarding the ability of the
agency to monitor populations and trends and/or make timely
interventions. This commenter adds that lack of guaranteed funding
renders almost meaningless the agency's commitment to convene a ``team
of experts'' to advise it on whether monitoring should be extended or
additional studies initiated. The commenter states that the need to
convene this team is predicated on obtaining data indicating that calf
production is declining, juvenile and/or adult abundance and growth
rates are declining, distributional changes cause concerns or existing
or emerging threats ``seem to be negatively affecting production,
abundance, population growth rate or distribution,'' and that one
cannot find what one is not able to seek.
Response: While we cannot predict future funding levels, to the
extent feasible, we intend to budget for post-delisting monitoring
efforts through the annual appropriations process. However, we are
constrained by the provisions of the Anti-Deficiency Act (See 31 U.S.C.
1341 (a)(1)). Further, guaranteeing funding for the measures
recommended in a plan is not a precondition to making a listing
determination such as we make today. Nevertheless, we understand the
high value of vessel-based surveys for obtaining photo ID mark-
recapture data, and we will endeavor to fund vessel-based surveys to
the extent possible consistent with available budgetary resources.
Comment 90: The MA DMF urges NMFS to work with its international
partners to monitor humpback whales in areas where they may
redistribute because of ocean warming (e.g., Gulf of Maine).
Response: We will continue our efforts to work with our
international partners to monitor humpback whales in all areas where
they occur.
Comment 91: One commenter provided a list of monitoring efforts in
National Marine Sanctuaries off California. Another commenter noted
that while the proposed rule mentions humpback whale protection
measures taken by Stellwagen Bank and Greater Farallones National
Marine Sanctuaries, it does not mention efforts made by the Cordell
Bank and Channel Islands sanctuaries. This commenter provided a list of
humpback whale protection, management, and research measures
implemented by west coast National Marine Sanctuaries and links to two
working group reports: (1) Reducing the Threat of Ship Strikes on Large
Cetaceans in the Santa Barbara Channel Region and Channel Islands
National Marine Sanctuary: Recommendations and Case Studies and (2)
Vessel Strikes and Acoustic Impacts: Report of a Joint Working Group of
the Gulf of the Farallones and Cordell Bank National Marine Sanctuaries
Advisory Councils.
Response: We appreciate the information and will collaborate with
these sanctuaries to access the available data. We reviewed the
protective efforts on Cordell Bank and Channel Islands sanctuaries
provided by the other commenter, and we intend to continue
collaborating with National Marine Sanctuaries to reduce threats to
listed and non-listed humpback whale DPSs that breed or feed within or
migrate through the boundaries of these sanctuaries. We appreciate the
education and outreach efforts made by these sanctuaries.
Comment 92: One commenter recommended that we add to the list of
ongoing conservation efforts, under section I.B., of the draft
Monitoring Plan the regulations that apply to all U.S. west coast
National Marine Sanctuaries. Specifically, under 15 CFR 922, west coast
National Marine Sanctuaries prohibit ``Disturbing, taking or possessing
any marine mammal, sea turtle or bird within or above the sanctuary;
except as permitted by regulations under the Marine Mammal Protection
Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the Migratory Bird Act.''
Response: We have moved the list of ongoing conservation efforts
from section I.B. to Appendix C of the Monitoring Plan, and we have
added these regulations as background to the same list.
Comment 93: The West Coast Region of the National Marine Sanctuary
Program noted that many ongoing monitoring programs conducted by
sanctuaries are aligned with the prescribed monitoring methods in the
draft Monitoring Plan. They strongly support the 10-year monitoring
period and will continue to collaborate and enhance communication with
the Humpback Whale Monitoring Plan Coordinator and regional staff of
NMFS, the research community, and the general public on monitoring and
resource protection efforts within U.S. west coast National Marine
Sanctuaries.
Response: We acknowledge the West Coast Region of the National
Marine Sanctuary Program's comments and appreciate their willingness to
continue collaborating with us.
Comment 94: The MMC stated that the objectives and methods
identified in our Monitoring Plan for monitoring humpback whale growth
rates, distribution, and threats are appropriate.
Response: We acknowledge the MMC's support.
Comment 95: The MMC recommends that the Monitoring Plan be expanded
to include (1) an objective to determine whether additional DPSs merit
consideration as endangered or threatened under the ESA, and (2) a
description of the methods, including further collections of tissue
samples and genetic analyses, that will be used to assess population
structure further within the ten DPSs.
Response: We received comments on the proposed rule to revise the
listing status of the humpback whale from the MMC and others about
dividing some of the DPSs we identified into smaller units because they
may be genetically distinct. We believe the DPS structure we proposed
and are finalizing is based on the best available scientific and
commercial information. Please see our responses to Comments 3, 4, and
5 for more details. If reliable data become available that would lead
us to identify smaller DPSs within any of the identified DPSs, we will
evaluate the data at that time. Note that only nine DPS are included in
the Monitoring Plan (rather than the ten DPS that were included in the
draft Plan) because of changes to the listing status of some DPSs in
this final rule.
Comment 96: One commenter and one peer reviewer noted that existing
baseline data for many of the proposed DPSs are outdated, not
available, or have significantly wide confidence intervals. They
asserted that accomplishing the objectives of the draft Monitoring Plan
depends on: (1) Having confidence in the information on current
abundance and trends in population and on population dynamics (e.g.,
growth rates, calf production, age structure); (2) having accurately
identified the spatial and temporal distribution of the DPSs, including
differential use by various age classes; and (3) proper identification
of and ability to accurately monitor trends in threats.
Response: Under the ESA, we are required to base our decisions on
the best available scientific and commercial
[[Page 62297]]
information. Where quantitative data are not available, it is
appropriate to use qualitative data. Please see our response to Comment
13 for more discussion of the ESA's requirement to base our decisions
on the best available scientific and commercial information.
Comment 97: One commenter stated that it will be difficult to
determine whether changes in ocean climate, overharvest of primary prey
resources, or other factors are adversely affecting populations until a
significant decline has already resulted. As support for this
statement, the commenter cited Taylor et al. (2007), who estimated
that, given the frequency and precision of estimates, a precipitous
decline of 50 percent in 15 years would not be detected for over 70
percent of baleen whales, including many humpback populations.
Response: The commenter cited Taylor et al. (2007), which discusses
the difficulty of monitoring trends in marine mammal stocks when
declines are caused by factors that do not involve direct human-caused
mortalities. The most common methods to increase our ability to detect
precipitous declines are to increase survey frequency and/or change
decision criteria (Taylor et al. 2007). For example, Taylor et al.
(2007) suggests that if we wanted to detect a precipitous decline 80
percent of the time for bowhead whales, we could do annual surveys. To
save expense, surveys could be less frequent, but the decision
criterion for significance would have to be changed to [alpha] = 0.1
for 4-year intervals or [alpha] = 0.2 for 6-year intervals. In the
latter case, underprotection and overprotection errors are equal at
about 20 percent.
As we stated in our responses to Comments 83 and 89, we will
endeavor to fund vessel-based surveys to the extent possible consistent
with available budgetary resources, and we must rely on the best
available information in making decisions under the ESA. However, we
are not relying only on abundance information. As we stated in the
draft Monitoring Plan, threats monitoring will be important to indicate
that a new threat has emerged, the magnitude of an existing threat has
increased, and/or that the cumulative impact from threats is likely
greater than previously understood.
Comment 98: One commenter wondered how we think we can detect
changes in the spatial or temporal distribution of humpback whales in
the Southern Hemisphere when the whales' use of specific feeding areas
is largely conjectural.
Response: We will need to base our monitoring on the best available
scientific and commercial information. We have added a qualifier to the
distribution trigger to clarify that a large contraction in range would
indicate a potential problem.
Comment 99: One commenter noted that there is a great deal of
mixing of breeding stocks in feeding areas that will make threat
assessment for individual proposed DPSs difficult if not impossible,
adding that a monitoring plan that commits to tracking the impact of
threats is of no use if it cannot reliably determine which stock is
being adversely affected in an area of mixing.
Response: Again, we must rely on the best available scientific and
commercial information. As we noted in our response to Comment 11,
where humpback whales from different DPSs mix on feeding grounds, we
recognize the need for an approach that will allow us to determine
which DPSs have been affected by directed or incidental take or may be
affected by Federal actions subject to consultation under section 7. We
will likely use a proportional approach to indicate which DPSs are
affected by any takes based upon the best available science of what
DPSs are present, depending on location and timing where take occurred.
We have not finalized this approach, but it will be fluid, based upon
the best available science as it changes with increased understanding.
Of course, we will continue to work with partners to mitigate threats
to all humpback whales, regardless of their ESA listing status, because
they remain protected under the MMPA. We will also work with our
partners to determine the most effective ways to track the impacts of
these threats to humpback whales.
Comment 100: One commenter noted that we stated that we will
monitor abundance, distribution, and protection of key prey species
even as we admit that ``[d]ata are lacking for most locations for
humpback whale prey species that are not commercially harvested.''
Response: Again, we acknowledge the comment, and we must rely on
the best available scientific and commercial information. We have added
a list of funded Federal efforts to the Monitoring Plan, but we cannot
do the same for non-federal efforts because there is no guarantee that
these will be funded. In a particular year, we may have available
annual discretionary funds and some ESA section 6 funds that we hope to
be able to use to support some of these efforts.
Comment 101: One commenter stated that we appear to be poised to
attribute any health effects or slowed growth to the DPS reaching
carrying capacity, saying that as ``DPSs continue to increase in
abundance, they may reach and/or possibly exceed carrying capacity in
certain locations and nutritional stress could affect population
dynamics.'' The commenter asserts that we are apparently excusing
ourselves from the need to identify domestic or international
management actions that may be taken to allow an improved recovery
trajectory if slowed growth is a consequence of habitat degradation
rather than a species or DPS attaining full recovery.
Response: We will rely on the best available scientific and
commercial information to determine whether DPSs are reaching carrying
capacity. For the Southern Hemisphere DPSs, we can rely on IWC
assessments (IWC 2015) to determine whether different DPSs are
approaching carrying capacity. IWC Breeding Stocks correspond, for the
most part, to the DPSs we have identified, with the exception that the
boundary between the East Australia DPS and the Oceania DPS differs
from the boundary between IWC Breeding Stocks E and F. We expect to be
able to review estimates of population sizes relative to carrying
capacity for the North Pacific DPSs this year based on modeling work
that was submitted to the IWC Scientific Committee in June 2016. More
work on population structure in the North Atlantic is needed before we
can estimate population size relative to carrying capacity there.
Comment 102: One commenter stated that we incorrectly asserted that
the Stellwagen Bank National Marine Sanctuary (SBNMS) has its own
approach guidelines ``that provide some protection [sic] individuals
from the West Indies'' DPS. This commenter noted that currently there
are no SBNMS-specific approach guidelines beyond those NMFS suggests
for vessels operating in the Greater Atlantic Region. Therefore, the
commenter states, in these areas where harassment necessitates control
of vessel and aircraft approaches to whales based on their listing
under the ESA, these protections will be largely lost.
Response: It is true that SBNMS does not have its own approach
guidelines. The only species in this area with ESA regulatory
restrictions on aircraft, vessel speed, and approach is the North
Atlantic right whale. Because the MMPA also offers general harassment
prohibitions to all marine mammals, no protections will be lost for
humpback whales in this respect. Humpback whales will also continue to
receive ancillary benefits from those regulations in place to protect
right whales (please
[[Page 62298]]
see our response to Comment 39). In the Greater Atlantic Region,
voluntary guidelines are in place to encourage aircraft and vessel
behaviors that will not violate the harassment prohibitions of both the
MMPA and ESA. These voluntary guidelines will remain in place for
humpback whales under the MMPA, regardless of their status under the
ESA.
Comment 103: One commenter stated that because there is an existing
TRP that currently applies to humpback whales in the North Atlantic,
the TRP should continue to apply to the West Indies DPS and any other
humpback whale populations off the U.S. east coast even if ESA
protections are removed. The commenter added that, similar to the
ALWTRP, NMFS should make clear that the provisions of the Pacific
Offshore Cetacean Take Reduction Plan (POCTRP) will continue to apply
to humpback whales, even if some DPSs are delisted.
Response: Provisions of the ALWTRP and the POCTRP will continue
even though some DPSs are no longer listed under the ESA. These take
reduction plans are implemented under the authority of the MMPA.
Comment 104: One commenter stated that it is unclear how NMFS
considers the IWC's ship strike database, stranding networks, and
disentanglement training as sufficient monitoring measures for humpback
whales. The commenter added that there are no mandates for any
individual or country to report ship strikes to the database, and our
own data indicate that ship strikes are underreported. The commenter
stated that stranding response varies by region and adequate carcass
examinations are rare. This commenter asserted that, while
disentanglement training is laudable, it is not legally mandated and
only a small percentage of whales benefit from this activity.
Response: Regardless of the ESA status of humpback whales, we have
a continuing directive under Title IV of the MMPA to collect health
indices for marine mammal populations. The national stranding network
will continue to document reports of ship strike and consistently
necropsy humpback whale carcasses to determine if ship strike is a
cause of death. These results are incorporated into serious injury and
mortality estimates in the Stock Assessment Reports and considered in
management decisions on behalf of the species. New ship strike
avoidance tools are being used in various parts of the United States,
such as the reporting application Whale Alert, and we are actively
working with the cruise and shipping industries on both the U.S. east
and west coasts to both promote prevention and facilitate reporting of
incidents. The IWC is currently examining the mechanisms for reporting
ship strikes globally and is working with the International Maritime
Organization on outreach to industry for areas of overlap of large
whales and shipping lanes. In addition, the IWC is beginning the
process of tracking and standardizing data on large whale entanglements
world-wide and making the data available for prevention and mitigation.
Both NMFS and the IWC have supported the training and equipping of
tiered skilled entanglement response teams for large whales in a
domestic and international capacity. The IWC is actively training large
whale entanglement response personnel around the world in high-risk or
high reported entanglement areas. Again, this work to mitigate injury
and mortality of whales in distress falls under MMPA Title IV, at the
national level. When a whale with an entanglement is reported to NMFS
or the network, an assessment of whether the entanglement is life-
threatening is undertaken. If it is a life-threatening entanglement,
all efforts are made to respond if it is safe and conditions allow.
From experience, we know that many whales shed gear on their own in
successful self-releases, so not all entanglements require human
intervention.
Given the high abundance estimates for those DPSs not being listed
under the ESA, we do not believe that ship strikes, entanglements, or
other human caused factors are having a negative population level
impact on these DPSs at this time or within the foreseeable future.
Comment 105: One commenter and two peer reviewers took issue with
the notion of accurately assessing carrying capacity, let alone
determining that a species or DPS has reached it. The commenter
suggested we should reference the achievement of optimum sustainable
populations rather than carrying capacity, which fluctuates with
resource availability. One of the peer reviewers noted that carrying
capacity for monitoring the DPSs is a useless term because most DPS
managers have no realistic idea of the target population abundance.
Instead, we should focus on ways to document or monitor status via
reproductive rates and environmental threats. The other peer reviewer
expressed concern with the emphasis on using carrying capacity to
identify response triggers because determining carrying capacity for
species like humpback whales with such slow life histories is not easy,
straightforward, or static. This peer reviewer added that, even if it
is determined for a particular region, carrying capacity can shift
along with changing environmental conditions, especially with respect
to dynamic ecosystem changes due to climate change.
Response: Please see our response to Comment 101. We must continue
to base our decisions on the best available scientific and commercial
information. We believe the ongoing assessment work can help us
determine when DPSs are approaching carrying capacity.
Comment 106: Two peer reviewers stated that a 10-year monitoring
period was too short for detecting changes in population trends, given
the slow life history, and they would advise a longer monitoring period
if possible. Regardless, they noted, the ability to detect population
trends and other triggers will rely on regular, thorough, consistent,
and coordinated survey effort throughout the monitoring period.
Response: Section 4(g) of the ESA requires that we monitor species
that have recovered under the ESA for a period of at least 5 years. We
decided to adopt a period for this rule that is twice the minimum time
period. If we determine that we need more than 10 years to detect
changes in population trends, we can extend the monitoring period. We
agree that the ability to detect population trends and other triggers
will rely on regular, thorough, consistent, and coordinated survey
effort throughout the monitoring period, and we will do the best we can
to achieve a high quality monitoring effort.
Comment 107: One peer reviewer noted that the southern hemisphere
DPSs appear to have solid current IWC monitoring but that the Hawaii
DPS description of data being gathered for mark-recapture for Southeast
Alaska in the draft Monitoring Plan was incorrect. This reviewer stated
that the regional Southeast Alaska and Prince William Sound datasets
are collaborations with Glacier Bay National Park and the NOAA
Fisheries Auke Bay Laboratory, and the North Gulf Oceanic Society and
Eye of the Whale datasets will be useful. However, this peer reviewer
recommended that a monitoring plan (and agreements) be established to
access and maintain the usefulness of these long-term datasets
collected since 1979. The peer reviewer believes we are overstating the
monitoring efforts. Given the funding situation for humpback whales,
this peer reviewer noted that the only guaranteed systematic survey for
the Hawaii DPS is the Glacier Bay work.
Response: If the commenter is referring to surveys with guaranteed
[[Page 62299]]
funding, the commenter is correct. We do not intend to overstate the
monitoring efforts. With the exception of Glacier Bay National Park and
our work in Prince William Sound (if we receive funding for continued
work), there are no systematic surveys in place for the Hawaii DPS.
North Gulf Oceanic Society data are incorporated into our Exxon Valdez
Oil Spill-Prince William Sound database. The Eye of the Whale, Alaska
Whale Foundation, and similar efforts may be useful for identifying
some of the triggers but are not suitable for a robust mark-recapture
model. We have revised the Monitoring Plan to clarify that we do not
expect a full suite of SPLASH-like humpback whale surveys to be funded
in the near future. Instead, the Monitoring Plan provides us with
guidance to assess the data that exist on a regular basis (and fund
additional efforts where possible), and then try to extrapolate from
that. We plan to collaborate with other Federal agencies, states, the
IWC, and academia to obtain the information we need in order to monitor
the status of these humpback whale DPSs.
Comment 108: One commenter noted that the warmer waters throughout
the Pacific have been documented to affect marine animals from Alaska
to Baja and out to the Pacific Islands, resulting in widespread HABs,
some of which have been linked to the die-off of marine mammals,
including humpback whales. Because of the ocean warming trend, this
commenter cautioned that this trend may potentially have a significant
effect on humpback whale populations, as well as other marine mammals.
This commenter recommended that the Monitoring Plan add a bullet
related to rapid changes in environmental conditions under the
``Response triggers.'' The existing bullets are linked to the condition
of the whales (numbers, distribution, calves, and health) but do not
take into account changes in the environment. For example, a large HAB
detected in southeastern Alaska might trigger NMFS to initiate
additional surveys to detect any potentially dead whales. Early
detection of dead whales may enable researchers to respond more rapidly
to necropsy and thereby diagnose potential causes for mortality. The
commenter suggested the following for such an environmental trigger:
``Evidence of rapid environmental changes in oceanographic conditions
in calving or foraging grounds that potentially could pose an immediate
threat to the health of humpback whales or their prey. Examples of
rapid changes in environmental condition include, but are not limited
to, HABs or die-offs of other marine animals such as pinnipeds or
seabirds.''
Response: While there is no evidence that climate-change related
effects currently contribute, or within the foreseeable future are
likely to contribute, significantly to the extinction risk of most DPSs
(except the Arabian Sea DPS) (see responses to Comments 24 and 25), we
agree that monitoring HABs and unusual mortality events is important.
Early detection may provide us with a better opportunity to diagnose
potential causes of mortality. However, stranding networks are already
in place and, either through these networks or as a result of direct
contacts to NMFS via the hotlines and other lines of communication, we
are made aware of dead animals, floating animals, and animals in
distress. We track these strandings, and the MMPA has provisions for
declaring UMEs and assessing the potential causes. Stock assessment
reports will capture this information as well. We do not believe this
particular trigger is needed. While we will likely indirectly monitor
changes in environmental conditions through the stranding networks, it
is highly unlikely that we will be launching surveys, as suggested by
the commenter. There have been HABs on both U.S. coasts, and they will
continue. While individual humpback whales may be affected, it is
unlikely that an HAB event would present sufficient cause to reevaluate
the population's listing status. An HAB would have to be very large in
scale, or repetitive, to have meaningful impact at the population
level.
Summary of Changes From the Proposed Rule
We are relying on the YONAH survey data instead of the
MONAH survey data for the abundance estimate for the West Indies DPS.
We have updated the abundance estimates for the Western
North Pacific, Hawaii, Mexico, Central America, and Gabon/Southwest
Africa DPSs.
We are listing the Western North Pacific and Central
America DPSs as endangered instead of threatened based on a
reconsideration of the information we presented in the proposed rule.
We are listing the Mexico DPS as threatened instead of not
listing it, based on a reconsideration of the information we presented
in the proposed rule and the new abundance estimate.
We have updated the abundance estimate for the Oceania DPS
with an estimate that is based on an additional year of data, and we
have added a population growth-rate estimate.
We reviewed, and incorporated as appropriate, scientific
data from references that were not included in the status review report
and proposed rule. We include the following references, which together
with previously cited references, represent the best available
scientific and commercial data. Several of these references present new
data, but, with the exception of Wade et al. (2016), the new data do
not result in a change in any of our listing determinations. We are
making a change to the Western North Pacific DPS listing determination
because we have reconsidered our original determination in light of the
fact that the abundance estimate for this DPS is relatively low,
numerous threats of at least moderate impact still exist, and the DPS
includes a population with unknown breeding grounds and unknown growth
rate. We are also making changes to the Mexico and Central America DPS
listing determinations. The new, lower abundance estimates (Wade et al.
2016) for these DPSs increase our level of concern about their
extinction risk. For the Central America DPS we would have listed the
DPS as endangered even in the absence of the new abundance estimate,
for the reasons we explain further in the Central America DPS section.
In all other cases where new information was received (or obtained by
us), the information either was not sufficient to convince us to change
our determination or provided support for our proposed determinations,
and thus we do not rely on the information for our final
determinations: Alava et al. (2011); Alter et al. (2010); Alter et al.
(2015); Alzueta et al. (2001); Anderson et al. (2014); Baker et al.
(2013); Barendse et al. (2011); Barnosky et al. (2012); Barth et al.
(2007); Barth et al. (2007); Beaugrand (2014); Bowman et al. (2013);
Bednarsek et al. (2014) Boyce et al. (2010); Braithwaite et al. (2015);
Caballero et al. (2000, 2001, 2009); Carmona et al. (2011); Carstensen
et al. (2015); Carvalho et al. (2014); Chen et al. (2011); Coello-Camba
et al. (2014); Childerhouse and Smith (undated); Collins et al. (2010);
Comeau et al. (2012); Constantine et al. (2012); Corrie et al. (2015);
Dalla Rosa et al. (2012); Darling and Mori (1992); Dunlop et al.
(2010); Elwen et al. (2014); Ersts et al. (2011); Escobar (2009); Evans
et al. (2013); Felix et al. (2005); Fire et al. (2010); Feng et al.
(2009); Florez-Gonzalez et al. (2007); Flynn et al. (2015); Fossette et
al. (2014); Frisch et al. (2015); Fu et al. (2012); Garcia-Godes et al.
(2013); Garrigue et al. (undated); Garrigue et al. (2000); Garrigue et
al. (2006); Garrigue et al. (2010); Garrigue
[[Page 62300]]
et al. (2011); Gattuso and Hansson (2011); Gaylor et al. (2015);
Goldbogen et al. (2013); Grebmeier (2012); Hattenrath-Lehmann et al.
(2015); Haigh et al. (2015); Hare et al. (2007); Hauser et al. (2010);
Hedley et al. (2011); Hester et al. (2008); Hollowed et al. (2012);
Honisch et al. (2012); Ilyina et al. (2010); IWC (2015); Ivashchenko et
al. (2013); IWC (2012); Jensen et al. (2015); Kajawara et al. (2004);
Kato (unpublished abstract); Kawaguchi et al. (2013); Kent et al.
(2012); Kershaw (2015); Kirkley et al. (2014); Krieger and Wing (1984,
1986); Kroeker et al. (2010); Kroeker et al. (2013); Laist et al.
(2014); Lefebvre et al. (2016); Leandro et al. (2010); Le Quere et al.
(2015); Lischka et al. (2010); Lewitus et al. (2012); Maclean and
Wilson (2011); Martinez-Levasseur et al. (2011); Martinez-Levasseur et
al. (2013a); Martinez-Levasseur et al. (2013b); McHuron et al. (2013);
Moore et al. (2015); Moura et al. (2013); Moy et al. (2009); NOAA
National Climatic Data Center (2015); NMFS (2015); Nemoto (1957, 1959);
Noad et al. (2005); Okamoto et al. (2013); Olavarria et al. (2006);
Pace et al. (2014); Pachauri et al. (2014); Parmesan (2006); Parmesan
and Yohe (2003); Paxton et al. (2011); Payne et al. (1986); Ramp et al.
(2015); Risch et al. (2012); Robbins et al. (2011); Rolland et al.
(2012); Rosenbaum et al. (2014); Schonberg et al. (2014); Sible et al.
(2002); Simmonds and Eliott (2009); Simmonds and Isaac (2007); Stevick
et al. (2015); Stevick et al. (2016); Strinddberg et al. (2011); Tanabe
et al. (1994); Tatters et al. (2012); Thomas et al. (2004); Trainer et
al. (2012); Tyack et al. (2011); Van Bressem et al. (2009); van derHoop
et al. (2014); Van Waerebeek et al. (2013); Vikingsson et al. (2015);
Wade et al. (2016); Warren et al. (2013); Wiley et al. (2011);
Witteveen et al. (2006); Witteveen et al. (2008); Wright (2008); Wright
et al. (2015); Yasunaga and Fujise (2009a); and Yasunaga and Fujise
(2009b).
Identification of DPSs
As we discussed earlier in our responses to comments on particular
DPSs, the comments that we received on the proposed rule did not change
our conclusions regarding the identification of DPSs. We reviewed
relevant and recently available scientific data that were not included
in the status review report and proposed rule: Barendse et al. 2011;
Carvalho et al. 2014; Elwen et al. 2014; Ersts et al. 2011; Fossette et
al. 2014; Kershaw 2015; Rosenbaum et al. 2014; Stevick et al. 2015;
Stevick et al. 2016; and Van Waerebeek et al. 2013. Based on the best
available scientific and commercial data, we reaffirm that the DPSs
identified in the proposed rule are discrete and significant.
Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on the identification
of DPSs provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80 FR
22304; April 21, 2015).
In summary, we apply our joint DPS policy (61 FR 4722; February 7,
1996) to identify 14 discrete and significant DPSs: West Indies, Cape
Verde Islands/Northwest Africa, Western North Pacific, Hawaii, Mexico,
Central America, Brazil, Gabon/Southwest Africa, Southeast Africa/
Madagascar, West Australia, East Australia, Oceania, Southeastern
Pacific, and Arabian Sea.
We next present a summary of the extinction risk analysis and our
listing determinations for each DPS. Additional detail may be found in
the proposed rule.
West Indies DPS
The comments that we received on the West Indies DPS and additional
information that became available since the publication of the proposed
rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not warrant
listing. However, as previously explained in a response to Comment 31,
we determined that we should not rely on the MONAH abundance estimate
(12,312 individuals) because the underlying data are not final, and
they are not verifiable. We incorporate herein all other information on
the West Indies DPS provided in the status review report and proposed
rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief
summary of that information.
The West Indies DPS consists of the humpback whales whose breeding
range includes the Atlantic margin of the Antilles from Cuba to
northern Venezuela, and whose feeding range primarily includes the Gulf
of Maine, eastern Canada, and western Greenland. While many West Indies
whales also use feeding grounds in the central (Iceland) and eastern
(Norway) North Atlantic, many whales from these feeding areas appear to
winter in another unknown location.
Abundance and Trends for the West Indies DPS
The most reliable abundance estimates for this DPS are from the
1992-1993 YONAH survey on the breeding grounds in the Caribbean: 10,400
(95 percent CI, 8,000-13,600) individuals according to genetic ID data;
and 10,752 (CV = 6.8 percent) individuals according to photo ID data
(Stevick et al. 2003). Stevick et al. (2003) estimated the average
annual growth rate at 3.1 percent (SE = 1.2 percent) for the period
1979-1993, but because of concerns that the same data may have been
used twice and potentially lead to an over-estimate of the precision of
the trend estimate, they re-calculated the trend analysis using only
one set of abundance estimates for each time period. The revised trend
for this time period was still 3.1 percent (SE = 1.2 percent).
In contrast, estimates from feeding areas in the North Atlantic
indicate strongly increasing trends in Iceland (1979-1988 and 1987-
2007), Greenland (1984-2007), and the Gulf of Maine (1979-1991)
(Bettridge et al. 2015). There is some indication that the increase
rate in the Gulf of Maine has slowed in more recent years (6.5 percent
from 1979 to 1991 (Barlow and Clapham 1997), 0-4 percent from 1992-2000
(Clapham et al. 2003a)). It is not clear why the trends appear so
different between the feeding and breeding grounds. A possible
explanation would be that the Silver Bank breeding ground has reached
carrying capacity, and that an increasing number and percentage of
whales are using other parts of the West Indies as breeding areas.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the West Indies DPS
The best documented unusual mortality event (UME) for humpback
whales attributable to disease occurred in 1987-1988 in the North
Atlantic, when at least 14 mackerel-feeding humpback whales died of
saxitoxin poisoning (a neurotoxin produced by some dinoflagellate and
cyanobacteria species) in Cape Cod, Massachusetts (Geraci et al. 1989).
The whales subsequently stranded or were recovered in the vicinity of
Cape Cod Bay and Nantucket Sound, and it is highly likely that other
unrecorded mortalities occurred during this event. Such events have
been linked to increased coastal runoff. During the first 6 months of
1990, seven dead juvenile (7.6 to 9.1 m long) humpback whales stranded
between North Carolina and New Jersey. The significance of these
strandings is unknown.
Additional UMEs occurred in the Gulf of Maine in 2003 (12-15 dead
humpback whales on Georges Bank), 2005 (7 in New England), and 2006-
2007 (minimum of 21 whales), with no cause yet determined but HABs
potentially implicated (Gulland 2006; Waring et al. 2009). In the Gulf
of Maine in 2003, a few sampled individuals among 16 humpback whale
carcasses were found with saxitoxin and domoic acid (produced by
certain species of diatoms, a different type of algae (Gulland 2006)).
The BRT discussed the possible levels of unobserved mortality
[[Page 62301]]
that may be resulting from HABs and determined that, as the West Indies
population had been affected by HABs in the past, it is likely
experiencing a higher level of HAB-related mortality than is detected.
The largest potential threats to the West Indies DPS are
entanglement in fishing gear and ship strikes (vessel collisions);
these occur primarily in the feeding grounds, with some documented in
the mid-Atlantic U.S. migratory grounds. There are no reliable
estimates of entanglement or ship-strike mortalities for most of the
North Atlantic. During the period 2003-2007, the minimum annual rate of
human-caused mortality and serious injury (from both entanglements and
ship collisions) for the Gulf of Maine feeding population averaged 4.4
animals per year (Waring et al. 2009). Off Newfoundland, an average of
50 humpback whale entanglements (range 26-66) was reported annually
between 1979 and 1988 (Lien et al. 1988); another 84 were reported
entangled in either Newfoundland or Labrador from 2000-2006 (Waring et
al. 2009). Not all entanglements result in mortality (Waring et al.
2009). However, all of these figures are likely to be underestimates,
as not all entanglements are observed. A study of entanglement-related
scarring on the caudal peduncles of 134 individual humpback whales in
the Gulf of Maine suggested that between 48 percent and 65 percent had
experienced entanglements (Robbins and Mattila 2001).
Ship strike injuries were identified for 8 percent (10 of 123) of
dead stranded humpback whales between 1975-1996 along the U.S. East
Coast, 25 percent (9 of 36) of which were along mid-Atlantic and
southeast states (south of the Gulf of Maine) between Delaware Bay and
Okracoke Island North Carolina (Wiley and Asmutis 1995). Ship strikes
made up 4 percent of observed humpback whale mortalities between 2001-
2005 (Nelson et al. 2007) and 7 percent between 2005-2009 (Henry et al.
2011) along the U.S. East Coast, and the Canadian Maritimes. Among
strandings along the mid- and southeast U.S. coastline during 1975-
1996, 80 percent (8 of 10) of struck whales were considered to be less
than 3 years old based on their length (Laist et al. 2001). This
suggests that young whales may be disproportionately affected. However,
those waters may be used preferentially by young animals (Swingle et
al. 1993; Barco et al. 2002). It should be noted that ship strikes do
not always produce external injuries and may therefore be
underestimated among strandings that are not examined for internal
injuries.
HABs, vessel collisions, and fishing gear entanglements are likely
to moderately reduce the population size and/or the growth rate of the
West Indies DPS. All other threats, with the exception of climate
change (unknown severity), are considered likely to have no or minor
impact on population size or the growth rate of this DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the West Indies DPS
The BRT distributed 82 percent of its likelihood points for the
West Indies DPS to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category and 17
percent to the ``moderate risk of extinction'' category. Given the
large population size (10,400-10,752, more than five times the
population size that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that
a population was not at risk due to low abundance alone), moderately
increasing trend, and the high percentage of likelihood points
allocated to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category, we conclude
that, despite the moderate threats of HABs, vessel collisions, and
fishing gear entanglements and unknown severity of climate change as a
threat, the West Indies DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout
its range or likely to become so within the foreseeable future
throughout its range.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, because we have determined that
the DPS is neither endangered nor threatened based on a rangewide
evaluation, we need to determine whether the West Indies DPS is in
danger of extinction or likely to become so within the foreseeable
future in a significant portion of its range. The BRT noted that there
are some regional differences in threats for the West Indies DPS, but
it was unable to identify any portions of the DPS that both faced
particularly high threats and were so significant to the viability of
the DPS as a whole that their loss would result in the remainder of the
DPS being at high risk of extinction. We agree with the BRT's
conclusions and conclude that there are no portions of the DPS that
face particularly high threats and are so significant to the viability
of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of the DPS would be in danger
of extinction or likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Therefore, we conclude that the DPS is not in danger of extinction in a
significant portion of its range and is not likely to become so within
the foreseeable future.
Conservation Efforts for the West Indies DPS
While there are many ongoing conservation efforts that apply to the
West Indies DPS, we do not need to further evaluate them in the context
of this decision because they would serve only to further reduce the
likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the West Indies DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the West Indies DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing as
threatened or endangered under the ESA.
Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
The comments that we received on the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest
Africa DPS and additional information that became available since the
publication of the proposed rule did not change our conclusions
regarding listing this DPS as endangered. Therefore, we incorporate
herein all information on the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80 FR 22304;
April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of that
information.
This DPS consists of the humpback whales whose breeding range
includes waters surrounding the Cape Verde Islands as well as an
undetermined breeding area in the eastern tropical Atlantic which may
be more geographically diffuse than the West Indies breeding ground.
Its feeding range includes primarily Iceland and Norway. The population
of whales breeding in the Cape Verde Islands, plus this unknown area,
likely represent the remnants of a historically larger population
breeding around the Cape Verde Islands and northwestern Africa (Reeves
et al. 2002). In our proposed rule, we stated that there is no known
overlap in breeding range with North Atlantic humpback whales that
breed in the West Indies, although overlap occurs among feeding
aggregations in Iceland and Norway from different breeding populations.
However, recent information provides some evidence to indicate there
may be two different breeding areas in the Caribbean, with different
breeding times, and the whales breeding in the southeast Caribbean seem
to be more prevalent in the Northeast Atlantic feeding grounds (Stevick
et al. 2015). Some humpback whales from the Cape Verde Islands breeding
grounds have been re-sighted in the southeast Caribbean (Guadeloupe)
[[Page 62302]]
(Stevick et al. 2016), suggesting the southeast Caribbean may be part
of the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS' breeding ground, though
this has not been confirmed.
Abundance and Trends for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
The population abundance and population trend for the Cape Verde
Islands/Northwest Africa DPS are unknown. The Cape Verde Islands photo-
identification catalog contains only 88 individuals from a 20-year
period (1990-2009) (Wenzel et al. 2010). Of those 88 individuals, 20
(22.7 percent) were seen more than once, 15 were seen in 2 years, 4
were seen in 3 years, and 1 was seen in 4 years. The relative high re-
sighting rate suggests a small population size with high fidelity to
this breeding area, although the DPS may also contain other, as yet
unknown, breeding areas (Wenzel et al. 2010).
Little is known about the total size of the Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS, and its trend is unknown.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
For the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS, the threats of
HABs, disease, parasites, vessel collisions, fishing gear entanglements
and climate change are unknown. All other threats to this DPS are
considered likely to have no or minor impact on the population size
and/or growth rate.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa
DPS
The BRT distributed 32 percent of its likelihood points for this
DPS to the ``high risk of extinction'' category, 43 percent to the
``moderate risk of extinction'' category, and 25 percent to the ``not
at risk of extinction'' category. Unlike for the other DPSs we have
identified, we have no reason to believe that this DPS' status has
improved since humpback whales within the range of this DPS were listed
as endangered. There is a high likelihood that the abundance of this
DPS is low (much lower than the BRT's threshold of 500 individuals for
a population that would be considered at high risk from low abundance,
and potentially below the threshold of 100 individuals for a population
that would be considered at extremely high risk). There is also
considerable uncertainty regarding the risks of extinction of this DPS
due to a general lack of data as reflected in the wide spread of BRT
points. Therefore, we conclude that this DPS is in danger of extinction
throughout its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
Other than protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and
CITES, we are not aware of any ongoing conservation efforts for this
DPS. The IWC has programs that provide protection to humpback whales
from all DPSs. The IWC's Conservation Committee was established to
consider a number of emerging cetacean conservation issues, and its
role continues to evolve. The Conservation Committee collaborates
closely with the IWC's Scientific Committee to understand and address a
range of threats to whales and their habitats including whale watching,
ship strikes, and marine debris. In addition, the humpback whale is
currently an Appendix I species under CITES, which restricts
international trade and provides an additional layer of protection
against resumed whaling.
Listing Determination for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS
While the IWC and CITES conservation efforts are likely to benefit
all humpback whales, they are not sufficient to change the extinction
risk of this DPS. For the above reasons, we finalize our proposal to
list the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS of the humpback whale
as an endangered species under the ESA.
Western North Pacific DPS
After reviewing the comments we received on the Western North
Pacific DPS and reconsidering the information in the proposed rule, we
have reached a different conclusion regarding the appropriate listing
status for this DPS. Specifically, though we proposed to list the DPS
as a ``threatened species,'' we will finalize the listing as an
``endangered species.'' Additional information became available since
the publication of the proposed rule, and some information had not been
cited in the status review report (Darling and Mori 1992; Kato
unpublished; Okamoto 2013; Wade et al. 2016), but this information did
not influence our conclusion. We incorporate herein all information on
the Western North Pacific DPS provided in the status review report and
proposed rule (80 FR 22303; April 21, 2015). The following represents a
brief summary of that information.
The Western North Pacific DPS consists of the whales breeding/
wintering in the area of Okinawa and the Philippines, another
unidentified breeding area (inferred from sightings of whales in the
Aleutian Islands area feeding grounds), and those transiting the
Ogasawara area. These whales migrate to feeding grounds in the northern
Pacific, primarily off the Russian coast.
Abundance and Trends for the Western North Pacific DPS
The abundance of humpback whales in the Western North Pacific was
estimated to be around 1,000, based on the photo-identification,
capture-recapture analyses from the years 2004-2006 by the SPLASH
program (Calambokidis et al. 2008) from two primary sampling regions,
Okinawa and Ogasawara. The growth rate for humpback whales in the
Western North Pacific is estimated to be 6.9 percent (Calambokidis et
al. 2008) between 1991-93 and 2004-2006, although this could be biased
upwards by the comparison of earlier estimates based on photo-
identification records from Ogasawara and Okinawa with current
estimates based on the more extensive records collected in Ogasawara,
Okinawa, and the Philippines during the SPLASH program. However, the
overall number of whales identified in the Philippines was small
relative to both Okinawa and Ogasawara, so any bias may not be large.
Given the possible bias in the rate of increase and the fact that it
represents a combination of two populations that the BRT had proposed
as separate DPSs (Okinawa/Philippines and Second West Pacific), it is
not possible to make a definitive statement about the rate of increase
of the Western North Pacific DPS.
More recently, in advance of the June 2016 IWC Scientific Committee
meeting in Slovenia, Wade et al. (2016) submitted a paper in which they
used an integrated spatial multi-strata mark-recapture model to
simultaneously estimate abundance for all winter and summer areas
sampled during the SPLASH project in the North Pacific. We believe the
multi-strata estimates are likely less subject to bias from capture
heterogeneity, which has been shown to lead to substantial biases, and
they use all the data (from both summer and winter), rather than
estimating abundance from just part of the data. Given this, it seems
reasonable to conclude that the multi-strata estimates calculated here
are more accurate than the within-season Chapman-Peterson estimates.
From these analyses, the multi-strata estimate for the Western North
Pacific DPS is 1,059 (CV = 0.08). This is not significantly different
from the earlier Calambokidis et al. (2008) estimate of about 1,000.
Overall recovery seems to be slower than in the Central and Eastern
North Pacific.
[[Page 62303]]
Humpback whales in the Western North Pacific remain rare in some parts
of their former range, such as the coastal waters of Korea, and have
shown no signs of a recovery in those locations (Gregr 2000; Gregr et
al. 2000).
The abundance of the Western North Pacific DPS is 1,059
individuals, with unknown trend.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Western North Pacific DPS
The BRT noted that the Sea of Okhotsk currently has a high level of
energy exploration and development, and these activities are likely to
expand with little regulation or oversight. The BRT determined that the
threat posed by energy exploration to the Okinawa/Philippines portion
of the Western North Pacific DPS is medium, but noted that there was
low certainty regarding this because specifics of feeding location (on
or off the shelf) are unavailable. If feeding activity occurs on the
shelf in the Sea of Okhotsk, energy exploration in this area could
impact what is likely one of the most depleted subunits of humpback
whales. The threat posed by energy exploration to the 2nd West Pacific
portion of the Western North Pacific DPS was unknown.
The BRT discussed the high level of fishing pressure in the region
occupied by the Okinawa/Philippines portion of the Western North
Pacific DPS (a small humpback whale population). Although specific
information on prey abundance and competition between whales and
fisheries is not known in this area, overlap of whales and fisheries
has been indicated by the bycatch of humpback whales in set-nets in the
area. The BRT determined that competition with fisheries is a medium
threat for this DPS (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 56), given the high level
of fishing and small humpback whale population.
The likely range of the Western North Pacific DPS includes some of
the world's largest centers of human activities and shipping. Although
reporting of ship strikes is requested in the Annual Progress reports
to the IWC, reporting by Japan and Korea is likely to be poor
(Bettridge et al. 2015 at 94). A reasonable assumption, although not
established, is that shipping traffic will increase as global commerce
increases; thus, a reasonable assumption is that the level of the
threat will increase. The threat of ship strikes was therefore
considered to be medium for the Okinawa/Philippines portion of the
Western North Pacific DPS and unknown for the 2nd West Pacific DPS
portion.
Whales along the coast of Japan and Korea are at risk of
entanglement in fisheries gear and related mortality, although overall
rates of net and rope scarring are similar to other regions of the
North Pacific (Brownell et al. 2000). The reported number of humpback
whale entanglements/deaths has increased for Japan since 2001 as a
result of improved reporting, although the actual number of
entanglements may be underrepresented in both Japan and Korea (Baker et
al. 2006). The BRT concluded that the threat of fishing gear
entanglement to this DPS was high for the Okinawa/Philippines portion
of this DPS and unknown for the 2nd West Pacific portion of the DPS
(Bettridge et al. 2015, Table 9). The level of confidence in
understanding the minimum magnitude of this threat is medium for the
Okinawa/Philippines portion of this DPS and low for the 2nd West
Pacific portion of this DPS, given the unknown wintering grounds and
primary migratory corridors.
To summarize, all threats are considered likely to have no or minor
impact on population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with
the following exceptions: Energy development, competition with
fisheries (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 56), whaling, and vessel collisions
are considered likely to moderately reduce the population size or the
growth rate of the Okinawa/Philippines portion of this DPS; and fishing
gear entanglement is likely to seriously reduce the population size or
the growth rate of the Okinawa/Philippines portion of this DPS
(Bettridge et al. 2015, Table 9). The levels of these threats are
higher than in most other regions of the world and are expected to
increase, rather than decline (Bettridge et al. 2015 at 94). Also, the
threats of underwater noise and ship strikes to this portion of the DPS
are expected to increase as shipping traffic increases (Bettridge et
al. 2015 at 94). In general, there is great uncertainty about the
threats facing the 2nd West Pacific portion of this DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Western North Pacific DPS
The BRT distributed 36 percent of its likelihood points for the
Okinawa/Philippines portion of the DPS in the ``high risk of
extinction'' category and 44 percent in the ``moderate risk of
extinction'' category, with only 21 percent of the points in the ``not
at risk of extinction'' category. The distribution of likelihood points
among the risk categories indicates uncertainty. There was also
considerable uncertainty regarding the risk of extinction of the 2nd
West Pacific portion of this DPS, with 14 percent of the points in the
``high risk of extinction'' category, 47 percent in the ``moderate risk
of extinction'' category, and 39 percent in the ``not at risk of
extinction'' category. The majority of likelihood points were in the
``moderate risk of extinction'' category for both portions of the
Western North Pacific DPS. Given the relatively low population size of
the Western North Pacific DPS (1,059, about half the population size
that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that a population was
not at risk due to low abundance alone), the moderate reduction of its
population size or growth rate likely from energy development,
competition with fisheries, whaling, and vessel collisions, the serious
reduction of its population size or growth rate likely from fishing
gear entanglements, the fact that the majority of the BRT's likelihood
points were in the ``moderate risk of extinction'' category for both
portions of the DPS, and the considerable uncertainty associated with
abundance and trend estimates, we concluded in our proposed rule that
the Western North Pacific DPS was likely to become endangered
throughout its range within the foreseeable future.
However, the abundance estimate of 1,059 for this DPS is still
relatively low and below the level that would signify that the
population is not at risk due to low abundance alone. This DPS faces a
significant number of moderate threats and one serious threat (fishing
gear entanglement) that are expected to increase. The BRT members
expressed a considerable degree of uncertainty with regard to both
portions of this DPS in their allocation of likelihood points among
different extinction risk categories. Further, we note that this DPS
includes members of two different populations that the BRT considered
to be two different DPSs, one of which has an unknown breeding area;
thus, they are likely to have different demographic characteristics. As
discussed above under the Status Review section, the BRT considered
abundance and trend information carefully in evaluating extinction
risk, but abundance was not the sole criterion for evaluating
extinction risk. The thresholds described by the BRT were only general
guidelines, and we must consider them in light of the threats the DPS
faces.
We have reconsidered our original listing determination for this
DPS in light of the relatively low abundance estimate, the threats that
continue to operate on the population, and the considerable uncertainty
reflected in the distribution of BRT votes. Under these circumstances,
for this particular DPS,
[[Page 62304]]
the risk to the species is compounded by the lack of information on the
population abundance trend. We conclude that the Western North Pacific
DPS is in danger of extinction throughout its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Western North Pacific DPS
Currently, NMFS approach regulations exist in Alaska to protect
humpback whales from vessels by prohibiting vessels from approaching
within 100 yards of a humpback whale (50 CFR 224.103(b)). This
regulation also requires vessels to maintain a slow, safe speed near
humpback whales, and prohibits vessels from intercepting oncoming
whales (a practice also known as ``leap-frogging''). In a separate
direct final rule published elsewhere in today's issue of the Federal
Register, this approach regulation is also being set forth in MMPA
regulations (50 CFR part 216) because the Alaska regulation was adopted
under authority of both the MMPA and the ESA but was inadvertently not
codified under the MMPA regulations. It is also being added to 50 CFR
223.214 to extend these ESA protections to threatened humpback whales
in Alaskan waters (the Mexico DPS).
In addition, Whale SENSE, a voluntary program promoting responsible
viewing to minimize disturbance and protect whales from harassment,
currently exists in Alaska.
IWC and CITES conservation efforts apply to this DPS (please see
Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS).
Listing Determination for the Western North Pacific DPS
While these conservation efforts are likely to benefit this DPS,
they are not sufficient to reduce its extinction risk. For the above
reasons, we list the Western North Pacific DPS of the humpback whale as
an endangered species under the ESA.
Hawaii DPS
The comments that we received on the Hawaii DPS and additional
information that became available since the publication of the proposed
rule or that was not cited in the status review report (Darling and
Morowitz 1986) did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not
warrant listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on
the Hawaii DPS provided in the status review report and proposed rule
(80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary
of that information.
The Hawaii DPS consists of humpback whales that breed in Hawaii and
feed in the east Bering Sea, Gulf of Alaska, and northern British
Columbia.
Abundance and Trends for the Hawaii DPS
Calambokidis et al. (2008) estimated the size of the humpback whale
populations frequenting the Hawaii breeding area at 10,000 individuals
and, assuming that proportions from the Barlow et al. (2011) estimate
of 21,808 individuals in breeding areas in the North Pacific are likely
to be similar to those estimated by Calambokidis et al. (2008), the
population size frequenting the Hawaii breeding area would have
increased to about 12,000 individuals. The most recent growth rate for
this DPS was estimated between 5.5 percent and 6.0 percent
(Calambokidis et al. 2008).
More recently, in advance of the June 2016 IWC Scientific Committee
meeting in Slovenia, Wade et al. (2016) submitted a paper in which they
used an integrated spatial multi-strata mark-recapture model to
simultaneously estimate abundance for all winter and summer areas
sampled during the SPLASH project in the North Pacific. We believe the
multi-strata estimates are likely less subject to bias from capture
heterogeneity, which has been shown to lead to substantial biases, and
they use all the data (from both summer and winter), rather than
estimating abundance from just part of the data. Given this, it seems
reasonable to conclude that the multi-strata estimates calculated here
are more accurate than the within-season Chapman-Peterson estimates.
The multi-strata estimate for the Hawaii DPS is 11,398 (CV = 0.04),
which is higher than the Calambokidis et al. (2008) estimate of 10,000
and just a little less than the estimate based on Barlow et al. (2011).
The abundance estimate for the Hawaii DPS is 11,398 individuals and
its population trend estimate is 5.5-6 percent.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Hawaii DPS
Studies of characteristic wounds and scarring indicate that this
DPS experiences a high rate of interaction with fishing gear (20-71
percent), with the highest rates recorded in Southeast Alaska and
Northern British Columbia (Neilson et al. 2009). However, these rates
represent only survivors. Fatal entanglements of humpback whales in
fishing gear have been reported in all areas, but, given the isolated
nature of much of their range, observed fatalities are almost certainly
under-reported and should be considered minimum estimates. Studies in
another humpback whale feeding ground, which has similar levels of
scarring, estimate that the actual annual mortality rate from
entanglement may be as high as 3.7 percent (Angliss and Outlaw 2008).
There is a high level of certainty with regard to this information. The
threat is considered to be medium.
Threats generally are considered likely to have no or minor impact
on population size and/or the growth rate of the Hawaii DPS or are
unknown, with the following exception: Fishing gear entanglements are
considered likely to moderately reduce the population size or the
growth rate of the Hawaii DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Hawaii DPS
The BRT distributed 98 percent of its likelihood points for the
Hawaii DPS to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category. Given the
large population size (11,398, more than five times the population size
that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that a population was
not at risk due to low abundance alone), population growth rate of 5.5-
6 percent, and high percentage of likelihood points allocated to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Hawaii DPS, we conclude
that, despite the moderate threat of fishing gear entanglements, the
Hawaii DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout its range and not
likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Hawaii DPS is presently in danger of extinction or likely to become so
within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range,
because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor
threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT noted that there
are some regional differences in threats for the Hawaii DPS, but it was
unable to identify any portion of the DPS that both faced particularly
high threats and was so significant to the viability of the DPS as a
whole that its loss would result in the remainder of the DPS being at
high risk of extinction. We agree, and we conclude that no portion of
the Hawaii DPS faces particularly high threats and is so significant to
the viability of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of the DPS would
be in danger of extinction, or likely to become so within the
foreseeable future. Therefore, we conclude that the Hawaii DPS is not
in danger of extinction in a significant portion of its range and is
not likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
[[Page 62305]]
Conservation Efforts for the Hawaii DPS
While there are many ongoing conservation efforts that apply to the
Hawaii DPS, including IWC and CITES conservation efforts (please see
Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS),
we do not need to further evaluate them in the context of this decision
because they would serve only to further reduce the likely impact of
threats.
Listing Determination for the Hawaii DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Hawaii DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing as a
threatened or an endangered species under the ESA.
Mexico DPS
After reviewing the comments we received on the Mexico DPS,
reconsidering the information in the proposed rule, and reviewing Wade
et al. (2016), we have reached a different conclusion regarding the
appropriate listing status for this DPS. Specifically, though we did
not propose to list the DPS as a ``threatened species'' or an
``endangered species,'' we will finalize the listing status as a
``threatened species.'' We incorporate herein all information on the
Mexico DPS provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80
FR 22303; April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of
that information.
The Mexico DPS consists of whales that breed along the Pacific
coast of mainland Mexico, and the Revillagigedos Islands and transit
through the Baja California Peninsula coast. The Mexico DPS feeds
across a broad geographic range from California to the Aleutian
Islands, with concentrations in California-Oregon, northern Washington-
southern British Columbia, northern and western Gulf of Alaska and
Bering Sea feeding grounds.
Abundance and Trends for the Mexico DPS
The preliminary estimate of abundance of the Mexico DPS that
informed our proposed rule was 6,000-7,000 from the SPLASH project
(Calambokidis et al. 2008), or higher (Barlow et al. 2011). There were
no estimates of precision associated with that estimate, so there was
considerable uncertainty about the actual population size. However, the
BRT was confident that the population was likely to be much greater
than 2,000 in total size (above the BRT threshold for a population to
be not at risk due to low abundance). Estimates of population growth
trends do not exist for the Mexico DPS by itself. Given evidence of
population growth throughout most of the primary feeding areas of the
Mexico DPS (California/Oregon (Calambokidis et al. 2008), Gulf of
Alaska from the Shumagins to Kodiak (Zerbini et al. 2006a)), it was
considered unlikely this DPS was declining, but the BRT noted that a
reliable, quantitative estimate of the population growth rate for this
DPS was not available.
More recently, in advance of the June 2016 IWC Scientific Committee
meeting in Slovenia, Wade et al. (2016) submitted a paper in which they
used an integrated spatial multi-strata mark-recapture model to
simultaneously estimate abundance for all winter and summer areas
sampled during the SPLASH project in the North Pacific. We believe the
multi-strata estimates are likely less subject to bias from capture
heterogeneity, which has been shown to lead to substantial biases, and
they use all the data (from both summer and winter), rather than
estimating abundance from just part of the data. Given this, it seems
reasonable to conclude that the multi-strata estimates calculated here
are more accurate than the within-season Chapman-Peterson estimates.
The multi-strata estimate for the Mexico DPS is 3,264 (CV = 0.06). This
is a significantly lower abundance estimate than the Calambokidis et
al. (2008) estimate, and with a coefficient of variation of 0.06, it is
more reliable.
The abundance estimate for the Mexico DPS is 3,264 individuals, and
the population trend is unknown.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Mexico DPS
Of the 17 records of stranded whales in Washington, Oregon, and
California in the NMFS stranding database, three involved fishery
interactions, two were attributed to vessel strikes, and in five cases
the cause of death could not be determined (Carretta et al. 2010).
Specifically, between 2004 and 2008, 14 humpback whales were reported
seriously injured in commercial fisheries offshore of California and
two were reported dead. The proportion of these that represent the
Mexican breeding population is unknown. Fishing gear involved included
gillnet, pot, and trap gear (Carretta et al. 2010). Between 2004 and
2008, there were two humpback whale mortalities resulting from ship
strikes reported and eight ship strike attributed injuries for
unidentified whales in the California-Oregon-Washington stock as
defined by NMFS, and some of these may have been humpback whales
(Carretta et al. 2010). The Mexico DPS is known to also use Alaska and
British Columbia waters for feeding (Calambokidis et al. 2008).
Numerous collisions have been reported from Alaska and British Columbia
(where shipping traffic has increased 200 percent in 20 years) (Neilson
et al. 2012). According to a summary of Alaska ship strike records, an
average of 5 strikes a year was reported from 1978-2011 (Neilson et al.
2012). However, effects in Alaska will likely be mitigated by the
vessel approach regulations discussed above (66 FR 29502; May 31, 2001)
and by NMFS outreach to the cruise ship industry to share information
about whale siting locations.
Since the publication of the proposed rule, we have updated
information on the number of entanglements off the coasts of
California, Oregon, and Washington in 2015: 31 confirmed humpback
whales of 48 confirmed whale entanglements (NMFS 2015). This represents
a higher rate of fishing gear entanglements than was considered by the
BRT and presented in the proposed rule, but the reasons for the
observed increase is not clear. These new reports did not influence our
conclusions on the status of the Mexico DPS. That is, our final listing
determination takes into account that fishing gear entanglement poses
at least a moderate risk to this DPS but does not attempt to speculate
as to whether or why entanglement may be increasing, as the data are
inconclusive (please see our response to Comment 21).
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate of this DPS or are unknown, with
the following exception: Fishing gear entanglements are still
considered likely to moderately reduce the population size or the
growth rate of the Mexico DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Mexico DPS
The BRT distributed 92 percent of its likelihood points for the
Mexico DPS to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category. At the time
we made our proposed determinations, given the large population size of
6,000-7,000, qualitatively described trend (which, based on data about
growth in the feeding areas off the west coast of the United States
could be interpreted to be moderately increasing), and high percentage
of likelihood points allocated to the ``not at risk of extinction''
category for the Mexico DPS, we concluded that, despite the moderate
threat of fishing gear entanglements, the Mexico DPS was not in danger
of extinction throughout its range or likely to become so within the
foreseeable future.
[[Page 62306]]
The updated abundance estimate of 3,264 (Wade et al. 2016), while
still higher than 2,000 (the BRT's threshold between ``not likely to be
at risk of extinction due to low abundance alone'' and ``increasing
risk from factors associated with low abundance''), is significantly
lower than the previous estimate of 6,000-7,000, though these estimates
were derived from the same data. The BRT considered that this DPS was
unlikely to be declining because of the population growth throughout
most of its feeding areas, in California/Oregon and the Gulf of Alaska,
but we do not have specific evidence that this DPS is actually
increasing in overall population size.
We have reconsidered our original listing determination for this
DPS in light of the revised abundance estimate that is significantly
lower than we previously thought (that is only about 50 percent greater
than the size that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that a
population was not at risk due to low abundance alone) and the presence
of a known threat of moderate intensity. In these circumstances, for
this particular DPS, the risk to the species is compounded by the
absence of firm data to establish the population abundance trend. As
discussed above under the Status Review section, the BRT considered
abundance and trend information carefully in evaluating extinction
risk, but abundance was not the sole criterion for evaluating
extinction risk. The thresholds described by the BRT were only general
guidelines, and we must consider them in light of the considerations we
just outlined. Fishing gear entanglement is likely to moderately reduce
the population size or growth rate of this DPS. In this case, we do not
agree with the BRT's conclusions on the extinction risk for the Mexico
DPS. We conclude that the Mexico DPS is likely to become endangered
throughout its range within the foreseeable future, i.e., that it is a
threatened species.
Conservation Efforts for the Mexico DPS
Mexican Standard 131 establishes guidelines and specifications for
whale watching, including avoidance distances and speeds, limits on the
number of boats, and protection from noise (echo sounders are
prohibited). Mexico has also established protected natural areas that
contribute to the conservation and sustainable management of humpback
whales. These include Natural Heritage whale sanctuaries (Biosphere
Reserve ``El Vizca[iacute]no'' and National Marine Park ``Cabo Pulmo''
in Baja California Sur) and other protected areas (National Park
``Bah[iacute]a de Loreto,'' Archipelago ``Islas Mar[iacute]as,''
National Park ``Isla Isabel,'' and National Park ``Islas Marietas'' in
Nayarit).
The Greater Farallones National Marine Sanctuary has whale approach
guidelines that provide some protection to individuals from the Mexico
DPS while they are in their feeding areas.
In addition, Whale SENSE, a voluntary program promoting responsible
viewing to minimize disturbance and protect whales from harassment is
expected to be adopted in California in the near future.
In Canada, the ``North Pacific'' population of humpback whales
(i.e., the whales that feed along the entire length of the west coast
of British Columbia from Washington to Alaska, including in inshore
coastal inlets and offshore waters) is listed as threatened under the
SARA (http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/approach/act/default_e.cfm), so it
is illegal to kill, harass, capture or harm members of this population
in any way. Because some individuals from the Mexico DPS feed in
southern British Columbia, the SARA listing should provide some
benefits to individuals while feeding there. Critical habitat has been
identified under Canadian law to the extent possible off Langara
Island, southeast Moresby Island, Gil Island and southwest Vancouver
Island. These areas support feeding and foraging, and resting and
socializing, and they are protected from destruction. A recovery
strategy under SARA was published in 2013 (Fisheries and Oceans Canada
2013). The two goals of this recovery strategy are: In the short term,
to maintain, at a minimum, the current abundance of humpback whales in
British Columbia (using best estimate of 2,145 animals (95 percent CI =
1,970-2,331 as presented in Ford et al. 2009)); and, in the longer-
term, to observe continued growth of the population and expansion into
suitable habitats throughout British Columbia. To meet these goals,
threat and population monitoring, research, management, protection and
enforcement, stewardship, outreach and education activities were
recommended. Based on the need to assess population-level effects of
threats and develop appropriate mitigation measures, activities to
monitor and assess threats were given higher priority. An action plan
to implement the Canadian recovery strategy is expected to be completed
within five years of final posting of the recovery strategy on the SAR
Public Registry.
IWC and CITES conservation efforts apply to this DPS (please see
Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS).
Listing Determination for the Mexico DPS
While these conservation efforts are likely to benefit this DPS,
they are not sufficient to change its extinction risk. For the above
reasons, we list the Mexico DPS of the humpback whale as a threatened
species under the ESA.
Central America DPS
After reviewing the comments we received on the Central America DPS
and reconsidering the information in the proposed rule, we have reached
a different conclusion regarding the appropriate listing status for
this DPS. Specifically, though we proposed to list the DPS as a
``threatened species,'' we will finalize the listing as an ``endangered
species.'' We incorporate herein all information on the Central America
DPS provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80 FR
22303; April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of
that information.
The Central America DPS is composed of whales that breed along the
Pacific coast of Costa Rica, Panama, Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras
and Nicaragua. Whales from this breeding ground feed almost exclusively
offshore of California and Oregon in the eastern Pacific, with only a
few individuals identified at the northern Washington-southern British
Columbia feeding grounds.
Abundance and Trends for the Central America DPS
A preliminary estimate of abundance of the Central America
population was ~500 from the SPLASH project (Calambokidis et al. 2008),
or ~600 based on the reanalysis by Barlow et al. (2011). There were no
estimates of precision associated with these estimates, so there was
considerable uncertainty about the actual population size. Therefore,
the actual population size could have been somewhat larger or smaller
than 500-600, but the BRT considered it very unlikely to be as large as
2,000 or more. The size of this DPS was relatively low compared to most
other North Pacific breeding populations (Calambokidis et al. 2008) and
within the range of population sizes considered by the BRT to be at
risk based on low abundance. The trend of the Central America DPS was
considered unknown.
More recently, in advance of the June 2016 IWC Scientific Committee
meeting in Slovenia, Wade et al. (2016) submitted a paper in which they
used
[[Page 62307]]
an integrated spatial multi-strata mark-recapture model to
simultaneously estimate abundance for all winter and summer areas
sampled during the SPLASH project in the North Pacific. We believe the
multi-strata estimates are likely less subject to bias from capture
heterogeneity, which has been shown to lead to substantial biases, and
they use all the data (from both summer and winter), rather than
estimating abundance from just part of the data. Given this, it seems
reasonable to conclude that the multi-strata estimates calculated here
are more accurate than the within-season Chapman-Peterson estimates.
The multi-strata estimate for the Central America DPS is 411 (CV =
0.30), which is lower than the Calambokidis et al. (2008) preliminary
estimate of 500 and the estimate of 600 based on Barlow et al. (2011).
The abundance estimate of the Central America DPS is 411
individuals, with unknown population trend.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Central America DPS
Vessel collisions and entanglement in fishing gear pose the
greatest threat to this DPS. Especially high levels of large vessel
traffic are found in this DPS' range off Panama, southern California,
and San Francisco. Several records exist of ships striking humpback
whales (Carretta et al. 2008; Douglas et al. 2008), and it is likely
that not all incidents are reported. Two deaths of humpback whales were
attributed to ship strikes along the U.S. west coast in 2004-2008
(Carretta et al. 2010). Ship strikes are probably underreported
(Bettridge et al. 2015 at 88), and the level of associated mortality is
also likely higher than the observed mortalities. Vessel collisions
were determined to pose a medium risk to this DPS, especially given the
small population size. Shipping traffic will probably increase as
global commerce increases; thus, a reasonable assumption is that the
level of ship strikes will also increase.
Between 2004 and 2008, 18 humpback whale entanglements in
commercial fishing gear off California, Oregon, and Washington were
reported (Carretta et al. 2010), although the actual number of
entanglements may be underreported. Effective fisheries monitoring and
stranding programs exist in California, but are lacking in Central
America and much of Mexico. Levels of mortality from entanglement are
unknown and do vary by region, but entanglement scarring rates indicate
a significant interaction with fishing gear. Since the proposed rule
published, we have received updated information on the number of
entanglements off California, Oregon, and Washington in 2015: 31
confirmed humpback whales of 48 confirmed whale entanglements (NMFS
2015). This represents a higher rate of fishing gear entanglements than
was considered by the BRT and presented in the proposed rule, but the
reasons for the observed increase is not clear. These new reports did
not influence our conclusions on the status of the Central America DPS.
That is, our final listing determination does not rely on entanglements
being at a higher rate than previously believed (please see our
response to Comment 21).
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with the
following exceptions: Vessel collisions and fishing gear entanglements
are considered likely to moderately reduce the population size or the
growth rate of the Central America DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Central America DPS
The BRT distributed 28 percent of its likelihood points for the
Central America DPS in the ``high risk of extinction'' category, 56
percent in the ``moderate risk of extinction'' category, and 16 percent
in the ``not at risk of extinction'' category, but the distribution of
votes among the risk categories indicates uncertainty. Even though the
BRT used 500 as a guideline between moderate and high risk of
extinction (when considering abundance alone), the abundance estimates
include a high level of uncertainty. As noted above, the population
trend is unknown.
While some may point out that this population feeds in Southern and
central California, and those populations are increasing, Mexico DPS
whales also feed in this area, and it is likely that Mexico DPS whales
represent a higher proportion of the whales in this feeding area
because they are more abundant (3,264 individuals in the Mexico DPS vs.
411 individuals in the Central America DPS). Vessel strikes and fishing
gear entanglement are still likely to moderately reduce population size
or growth rate.
The BRT concluded that this DPS was between ``moderate'' and ``high
risk of extinction,'' with over a quarter of its likelihood points in
the ``high risk of extinction'' category. Because the Central America
DPS shares mtDNA haplotypes with some Southern Hemisphere DPSs,
suggesting it may serve as a conduit for gene flow between the North
Pacific and Southern Hemisphere, it is unique.
We have reconsidered our original listing determination for this
DPS in light of the original low abundance estimate (which was at the
dividing line between BRT risk categories), the fact that the moderate
threats of vessel collisions and fishing gear entanglement continue to
act upon a population that is so small, and the considerable
uncertainty reflected in the distribution of BRT votes. Under these
circumstances, for this particular DPS, the risk is compounded by the
lack of information on the population abundance trend. This conclusion
was reached prior to receipt of the updated abundance estimate, but we
note that the revised estimate of 411 is below the threshold of 500,
under which the BRT considered a DPS to be at high risk of extinction
due to abundance alone and thus reinforces our final determination. We
conclude that the Central America DPS is in danger of extinction
throughout its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Central America DPS
The Greater Farallones National Marine Sanctuary has whale approach
guidelines that provide some protection to individuals from the Central
America DPS while they are in their feeding areas.
In addition, Whale SENSE, a voluntary program promoting responsible
viewing to minimize disturbance and protect whales from harassment is
expected to be adopted in California in the near future.
In Canada, the ``North Pacific'' population of humpback whales
(i.e., the whales that feed along the entire length of the west coast
of British Columbia from Washington to Alaska, including in inshore
coastal inlets and offshore waters) is listed as threatened under the
SARA (http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/approach/act/default_e.cfm), so it
is illegal to kill, harass, capture or harm members of this population
in any way. Since some individuals from the Central America DPS feed in
southern British Columbia, the SARA listing should provide some
benefits to individuals while feeding there. Critical habitat has been
identified under Canadian law to the extent possible off Langara
Island, southeast Moresby Island, Gil Island and southwest Vancouver
Island. These areas support feeding and foraging, and resting and
socializing, and they are protected from destruction. A recovery
strategy under SARA was published in 2013 (Fisheries and Oceans Canada
2013). The two goals of this recovery strategy are: In the short term,
to maintain at a minimum, the current
[[Page 62308]]
abundance of humpback whales in British Columbia (using best estimate
of 2,145 animals (95 percent CI = 1,970-2,331 as presented in Ford et
al. 2009)); and in the longer-term, to observe continued growth of the
population and expansion into suitable habitats throughout British
Columbia. To meet these goals, threat and population monitoring,
research, management, protection and enforcement, stewardship, outreach
and education activities were recommended. Based on the need to assess
population-level effects of threats and develop appropriate mitigation
measures, activities to monitor and assess threats were given higher
priority. An action plan to implement the Canadian recovery strategy is
expected to be completed within five years of final posting of the
recovery strategy on the SAR Public Registry.
IWC and CITES conservation efforts apply to this DPS (please see
Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa DPS).
Listing Determination for the Central America DPS
While these conservation efforts are likely to benefit this DPS,
they are not sufficient to change its extinction risk. For the above
reasons, we list the Central America DPS of the humpback whale as an
endangered species under the ESA.
Brazil DPS
The comments that we received on the Brazil DPS and additional
information that became available since the publication of the proposed
rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not warrant
listing as a threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on the Brazil DPS
provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80 FR 22304;
April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of that
information.
This DPS consists of whales that breed between 3[deg] S. and
23[deg] S. in the southwestern Atlantic along the coast of Brazil, with
a prominent concentration around the Abrolhos Bank (15[deg]-18[deg]
S.), and feed off South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands.
Abundance and Trends for the Brazil DPS
The most recent abundance estimate for the Brazil DPS comes from
aerial surveys conducted off the coast of Brazil in 2002-2005 (Andriolo
et al. 2010). These surveys covered the continental shelf between
6[deg] S. and 24[deg]30' S. and provided a best estimate of 6,400
whales (95 percent CI = 5,000-8,000) in 2005. This estimate corresponds
to nearly 24 percent of this DPS' pre-exploitation abundance (Zerbini
et al. 2006d). Nearly 80 percent of the whales are found in the
Abrolhos Bank, the eastern tip of the Brazilian continental shelf
located between 16[deg] S. and 18[deg] S. (Andriolo et al. 2010). The
best estimate of population growth rate is 7.4 percent per year (95
percent CI = 0.5-14.7 percent) for the period 1995-1998 (Ward et al.
2011).
The abundance estimate for the Brazil DPS is estimated to be 6,400
individuals, with a 7.4 percent per year population growth rate.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Brazil DPS
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate of the Brazil DPS or are
unknown.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Brazil DPS
The BRT distributed 96 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Brazil DPS, thus
indicating a high certainty in its voting. None of the factors that may
negatively impact the status of the humpback whale appear to have
impeded recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for this DPS. Given the
large population size (6,400, more than three times the population size
that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that a population was
not at risk due to low abundance alone) of this DPS, the fact that it
is known to be increasing in population size, the high percentage of
likelihood points allocated to the ``not at risk of extinction''
category, and the high certainty associated with these extinction risk
estimates, we conclude that the Brazil DPS is not in danger of
extinction throughout its range presently and not likely to become so
within the foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Brazil DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to become so in the
foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range, because we
have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor threatened based
on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT was unable to identify a portion of
the Brazil DPS that both faced particularly high threats and was so
significant to the viability of the DPS as a whole that its loss would
result in the remainder of the DPS being at high risk of extinction. We
agree, and we also conclude that no portion of this DPS faces
particularly high threats and is so significant to the viability of the
remainder of the DPS that, if lost, it would be in danger of
extinction, or likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Therefore, we conclude that the Brazil DPS is not threatened or
endangered in a significant portion of its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Brazil DPS
Other than protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and
CITES (please see Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS), we are not aware of any ongoing conservation
efforts for this DPS. Regardless, we do not need to further evaluate
conservation efforts in the context of this decision because they would
serve only to further reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the Brazil DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Brazil DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing as a
threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
The comments that we received on the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS and
additional information that became available since the publication of
the proposed rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not
warrant listing as a threatened species or an endangered species. We
incorporate herein all information on the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80 FR 22304;
April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of that
information and some new information.
The Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS consists of whales that breed and
calve off central western Africa between ~6[deg] S. and ~6[deg] N. in
the eastern Atlantic, including the coastal regions of northern Angola,
Congo, Togo, Gabon, Benin, other coastal countries within the Gulf of
Guinea and possibly further north. This DPS is thought to feed offshore
of west South Africa and Namibia south of 18[deg] S. and in the
Southern Ocean beneath west South Africa (20[deg] W. -10[deg] E.).
Abundance and Trends for the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
We have reviewed two more recent papers that were not included in
the status review report or considered in the proposed rule (Collins et
al. 2010, with abundance estimates of 4,314 (CV = 0.19) for 2001-2004
and 7,134 (CV = 0.23) for 2004-2006) and the IWC 2012
[[Page 62309]]
assessment of the Gabon stock for 2005 (9,484 (90 percent PI =
7465,12,221), growth rate = 0.045 (90 percent PI = 0.006, 0.081)). We
conclude that it is appropriate to use an abundance estimate of 7,134
(CV = 0.23, 95 percent CI 4,576-11,124) for the Gabon/Northwest Africa
DPS, as explained in our response to Comment 58. The trend is still
unknown because we have determined that it is not appropriate to rely
on the growth rate from the IWC (2012) assessment (see response to
Comment 58).
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
For humpback whales using the waters of central western Africa,
expanding offshore hydrocarbon extraction activity now poses an
increasing threat (Findlay et al. 2006). The degree to which humpback
whales are affected by offshore hydrocarbon extraction activity is not
known, but it is believed that long-term exposure to low levels of
pollutants and noise, as well as the drastic consequences of potential
oil spills, could have conservation implications.
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with the
exception of energy exploration posing a moderate threat to Gabon/
Southwest Africa DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
The BRT distributed 93 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Gabon/Southwest Africa
DPS, thus indicating a high certainty in its voting. Despite the threat
of offshore hydrocarbon activity off west Africa, the BRT distributed
93 percent of its likelihood points in the ``not at risk of
extinction'' category, and we agreed with the BRT's assessment. We are
now relying on the more recent Collins et al. (2010) abundance estimate
of 7,134 for this DPS. This estimate does not differ significantly from
the average of the previous estimates of 6,560 (CV = 0.15) for 2001-
2004 and 8,064 (CV = 012) for 2001-2005 (Collins et al. 2008), which is
7,312. This abundance estimate is more than three times the population
size that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that a
population was not at risk due to low abundance alone), and therefore,
we affirm our earlier conclusion that the DPS is not in danger of
extinction throughout its range presently and not likely to become so
within the foreseeable future.
Therefore, we conclude that the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS is not
in danger of extinction throughout its range presently or within the
foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to
become so within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its
range, because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered
nor threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT concluded that
there was some evidence for population substructure within the Gabon/
Southwest Africa DPS, based on an extensive breeding range with some
significant genetic differentiation among breeding locations (Rosenbam
et al. 2009). However, the BRT was unable to identify any portion of
the DPS that both faced particularly high threats and was so
significant to the viability of the DPS as a whole that its loss would
result in the remainder of the DPS being at high risk of extinction. We
agree, and we also conclude that no portions of this DPS face
particularly high threats and are so significant to the viability of
the DPS that, if lost, the DPS would be in danger of extinction, or
likely to become so within the foreseeable future. Therefore we
conclude that the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS is not threatened or
endangered in a significant portion of its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
Other than whale-watching regulations in South Africa that help
protect humpback whales from the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS and
protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and CITES (please
see Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa
DPS), we are not aware of any ongoing conservation efforts specific to
this DPS. Regardless, we do not need to further evaluate conservation
efforts in the context of this decision because they would serve only
to further reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Gabon/Southwest Africa DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant
listing as a threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
The comments that we received on the Southeast Africa/Madagascar
DPS and additional information that became available since the
publication of the proposed rule did not change our conclusion that
this DPS does not warrant listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all
information on the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS provided in the
status review report and proposed rule (80 FR 22303; April 21, 2015).
The following represents a brief summary of that information.
The Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS includes whales breeding in at
least three different areas in the western Indian Ocean: One associated
with mainland coastal waters of southeastern Africa, extending from
Mozambique to as far north as Tanzania and southern Kenya; a second
found in the coastal waters of the northern Mozambique Channel Islands
and the southern Seychelles; and the third found in the coastal waters
of eastern Madagascar. The feeding grounds of this DPS in the Southern
Ocean are not well defined but are believed to include multiple
localities to the west and east of the region bounded by 5[deg] W. -
60[deg] E.
Abundance and Trends for the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
The most recent abundance estimates for the Madagascar population
were from surveys of Antongil Bay, 2000-2006 (Cerchio et al. 2009).
Estimates using data from 2004-2006 and involving ``closed'' models of
photo-identification of individuals and genotype data were 7,406 (CV =
0.37, CI = 2,106-12,706) and 6,951 (CV = 0.33, CI = 2,509-11,394),
respectively. Additional estimates were made using various data sets
(e.g., photo-identification and genotype) and models, estimating 4,936
(CV = 0.44, CI = 2,137-11,692) and 8,169 individuals (CV = 0.44, CI =
3,476-19,497, Cerchio et al. 2009). The mark-recapture data were
derived from surveys over several years and thus may represent the
abundance of whales breeding off Madagascar, in addition to possibly
whales breeding in Mayotte and the Comoros (Ersts et al. 2006), and to
a smaller degree from the East African Mainland (Razafindrakoto et al.
2008).
Two trends in relative abundance have been calculated from land-
based observations of the migratory stream passing Cape Vidal, east
South Africa in July 1998-2002, and July 1990-2000. The first was an
estimate of 12.3 percent per year (Findlay and Best 2006) (however,
this estimate is likely outside biological plausibility for this
species (Bannister and Hedley 2001; Noad et al. 2008; Zerbini et al.
2010)); and the second is 9.0 percent (an estimate that is within the
range calculated for other Southern Hemisphere breeding grounds (e.g.,
Ward et al. 2006; Noad et al. 2008; Hedley et al. 2009)). Both rates
are
[[Page 62310]]
considered with caution because the surveys were short in duration. It
is not certain that these estimates represent the growth rate of the
entire DPS. Given this uncertainty, and the uncertainty from the short
duration of the surveys, we conclude it is likely the DPS is
increasing, but it is not possible to provide a quantitative estimate
of the rate of increase for the entire DPS.
The Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS is thought to be between 4,936
and 8,169 individuals in population size, and its trend is thought to
either be increasing or stable.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
Information regarding fisheries and other activities is limited.
Kiszka et al. (2009) and Razafindrakoto et al. (2008) provided
summaries of humpback whale entanglement and strandings based on
interviews with artisanal fishing communities. Substantial gillnet
fisheries have been reported in the near-shore waters off the coasts of
mainland Africa and Madagascar, and to a lesser extent in the Comoros
Archipelago, Mayotte, and Mascarene Islands, where such practices are
hindered by coral reefs and a steep continental slope bathymetry
(Kiszka et al. 2009). Stranding reports and observations from Tanzania
and Mozambique have mostly implicated gillnets, with most Madagascan
entanglements associated with long-line shark fishing (Razafindrakoto
et al. 2008). In Mayotte, humpback whales have been observed with
gillnet remains attached to them (Kiszka et al. 2009), although no
fatalities have yet been documented. Industrial fishing operations,
including longlines and drift longlines on fish aggregation devices,
purse seine and midwater trawling, occur in waters off Mauritius. The
extent of bycatch and entanglement in these waters is unknown (Kiszka
et al. 2009). Strandings and bycatch data from 2001-2005 from South
Africa indicated an estimated 15 humpback whales entangled in shark
nets (large-mesh gillnets) in KwaZulu Natal province (only one death),
while nine stranded whales were reported from the south and east coasts
(IWC 2002b, 2003, 2004b, 2005b, 2006b).
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with the
exception of fishing gear entanglements posing a moderate threat to the
Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
The BRT distributed 96 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Southeast Africa/
Madagascar DPS, thus indicating a high degree of certainty in its
voting. None of the factors that may negatively impact the status of
the humpback whale appear to have impeded recovery, either alone or
cumulatively, for this DPS. The population size (4,936-8,169) for this
DPS is estimated to be more than twice and maybe four times the
population size that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that
a population was not at risk due to low abundance alone and its
population trend is likely to be stable or increasing. The high
percentage of likelihood points allocated to the ``not at risk of
extinction'' category and the high certainty associated with this
extinction risk estimate further support a finding that this DPS is
healthy and resilient, despite the moderate threat posed to this DPS by
fishing gear entanglements. Therefore, we conclude that the Southeast
Africa/Madagascar DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout its
range presently and not likely to become so within the foreseeable
future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to
become so within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its
range, because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered
nor threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT was unable to
identify any portion of the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS that both
faced particularly high threats and was so significant to the viability
of the DPS as a whole that its loss would result in the remainder of
the DPS being at high risk of extinction. We agree, and we also
conclude that no portion of this DPS faces particularly high threats
and is so significant to the viability of the DPS that, if lost, the
remainder of the DPS would be in danger of extinction, or likely to
become so within the foreseeable future. Therefore, we conclude that
the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS is not threatened or endangered in
a significant portion of its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
Other than protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and
CITES (please see Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS), we are not aware of any ongoing conservation
efforts for this DPS. Regardless, we do not need to further evaluate
conservation efforts in the context of this decision because they would
serve only to further reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Southeast Africa/Madagascar DPS of the humpback whale does not
warrant listing as a threatened species or an endangered species under
the ESA.
West Australia DPS
The comments that we received on the West Australia DPS and
additional information that became available since the publication of
the proposed rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not
warrant listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on
the West Australia DPS provided in the status review report and
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a
brief summary of that information.
The West Australia DPS consists of the whales whose breeding/
wintering range includes the West Australia coast, primarily in the
Kimberly Region. Individuals in this population migrate to feeding
areas in the Antarctic, primarily between 80[deg]E and 110[deg]E based
on tagging data.
Abundance and Trends for the West Australia DPS
Abundance of northbound humpback whales in the southeastern Indian
Ocean in 2008 was estimated at 21,750 (95 percent CI = 17,550-43,000)
based upon line transect survey data (Hedley et al. 2009). The current
abundance appears likely close to the historical abundance for the DPS,
although there is some uncertainty of the historical abundance because
of difficulties in allocating catch to specific breeding populations
(IWC 2007a). The current abundance is large relative to any of the
general guidelines for viable abundance levels. The rate of population
growth is estimated to be ~10 percent annually since 1982, which is at
or near the estimated physiological limit of the species (Bannister
1994; Bannister and Hedley 2001).
The West Australia DPS abundance estimate is 21,750 individuals,
with a 10 percent per year population growth rate.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the West Australia DPS
The threat posed by energy development to the West Australia DPS
was considered medium because of the substantial number of oil rigs and
the
[[Page 62311]]
amount of energy exploration activity in the region inhabited by the
whales (indicator CO-26 in (Beeton et al. 2006)). Additionally, there
are proposals for many more oil platforms to be built in the near
future, which are highly likely to be executed (Department of Industry
and Resources 2008).
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with the
exception of energy exploration posing a moderate threat to the West
Australia DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the West Australia DPS
The BRT distributed 97 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the West Australia DPS, thus
indicating a high degree of certainty in its voting. None of the
factors that may negatively impact the status of the humpback whale
appear to have impeded recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for this
DPS. Given the large population size (21,750) for this DPS (more than
ten times the population size that the BRT considered sufficient to
demonstrate that a population was not at risk due to low abundance
alone), the fact that its trend is increasing at a rate of 10 percent
per year, the high percentage of likelihood points allocated to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category, and the high certainty
associated with this extinction risk estimate, we conclude that the
West Australia DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout its range
presently and not likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
West Australia DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to become so
within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range,
because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor
threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT was unable to
identify a portion of the West Australia DPS that both faced
particularly high threats and was so significant to the viability of
the DPS as a whole that its loss would result in the remainder of the
DPS being at high risk of extinction. We agree, and we also conclude
that no portion of this DPS faces particularly high threats and is so
significant to the viability of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of
the DPS would be in danger of extinction, or likely to become so within
the foreseeable future. Therefore, we conclude that the West Australia
DPS is not threatened or endangered in a significant portion of its
range.
Conservation Efforts for the West Australia DPS
While there are many ongoing conservation efforts that apply to the
West Australia DPS, we do not need to further evaluate them in the
context of this decision because they would serve only to further
reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the West Australia DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the West Australia DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing
as a threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
East Australia DPS
The comments that we received on the East Australia DPS and
additional information that became available since the publication of
the proposed rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not
warrant listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on
the East Australia DPS provided in the status review report and
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a
brief summary of that information.
The East Australia DPS consists of the whales breeding/wintering
along the eastern and northeastern Australian coast. Based upon
tagging, telemetry, and re-sighting data, individuals in this
population migrate to Antarctic feeding areas ranging from 100[deg] E.
to 180[deg] E., but are concentrated mostly between 120[deg] E. and
180[deg] E.
Abundance and Trends for the East Australia DPS
Abundance of the East Australia DPS was estimated to be 6,300-7,800
(95 percent CI = 4,040-10,739) in 2005 based on photo-ID data (Paton
and Clapham 2006; Paton et al. 2008; Paton et al. 2009). The current
abundance is large relative to any of the general guidelines for viable
abundance levels. The annual rate of increase is estimated to be 10.9
percent for humpback whales in the southwestern Pacific Ocean (Noad et
al. 2008). This estimate of population increase is very close to the
biologically plausible upper limit of reproduction for humpbacks
(Zerbini et al. 2010). The surveys presented by Noad et al. (2005,
2008) have remained consistent over time, with a strong correlation (r
> 0.99) between counts and years.
The East Australia DPS abundance estimate is between 6,300 and
7,800, with a 10.9 percent per year population growth rate.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the East Australia DPS
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the East Australia DPS
The BRT distributed 96 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the East Australia DPS, thus
indicating a high degree of certainty in its voting. None of the
factors that may negatively impact the status of the humpback whale
appear to have impeded recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for this
DPS. Given the large population size (6,300-7,800, more than three
times the population size that the BRT considered sufficient to
demonstrate that a population was not at risk due to low abundance
alone) for this DPS, the fact that its trend is increasing at a rate of
10.9 percent per year, the high percentage of likelihood points
allocated to the ``not at risk of extinction'' category, and the high
certainty associated with this extinction risk estimate, we conclude
that the East Australia DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout
its range presently and not likely to become so within the foreseeable
future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
East Australia DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to become so
within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range,
because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor
threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT was unable to
identify a portion of the East Australia DPS that both faced
particularly high threats and was so significant to the viability of
the DPS as a whole that its loss would result in the remainder of the
DPS being at high risk of extinction. We agree, and we also conclude
that no portion of this DPS faces particularly high threats and is so
significant to the viability of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of
the DPS would be in danger of extinction, or likely to become so within
the foreseeable future. Therefore, we conclude that the East Australia
DPS is not threatened or endangered in a significant portion of its
range.
Conservation Efforts for the East Australia DPS
While there are many ongoing conservation efforts that apply to the
East Australia DPS, we do not need to further evaluate them in the
context of
[[Page 62312]]
this decision because they would serve only to further reduce the
likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the East Australia DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the East Australia DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing
as a threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Oceania DPS
The comments that we received on the Oceania DPS and additional
information that became available since the publication of the proposed
rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not warrant
listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on the
Oceania DPS provided in the status review report and proposed rule (80
FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a brief summary of
that information.
The Oceania DPS consists of whales that breed/winter in the South
Pacific Islands between ~160[deg] E., (west of New Caledonia) to
~120[deg] W. (east of French Polynesia), including American Samoa, the
Cook Islands, Fiji, French Polynesia, Republic of Kiribati, Nauru, New
Caledonia, Norfolk Island, New Zealand, Niue, the Independent State of
Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tokelau, Kingdom of Tonga, Tuvalu, Vanuatu, and
Wallis and Futuna. Individuals in this population are believed to
migrate to a largely undescribed Antarctic feeding area.
Abundance and Trends for the Oceania DPS
The Oceania humpback whale DPS is of moderate size (4,329 whales;
95 percent CI = 3,345-5,313) (Constantine et al. 2012). The trend of
the Oceania DPS was unknown at the time of publication of the proposed
rule, though more recent information (Constantine et al. 2012) that was
not included in the status review report (please see our response to
Comment 61) or considered in the proposed rule indicates that the
growth rate of this DPS is 3 percent per year or higher. The DPS is
quite subdivided, and the population estimate applies to an aggregate
(although it is known that sub-populations differ in growth rates and
other demographic parameters). There are some areas of historical range
extent that have not rebounded and other areas without historical
whaling information (Fleming and Jackson 2011). There is uncertainty
regarding which geographic portion of the Antarctic this DPS uses for
feeding. The complex population structure of humpback whales within the
Oceania region creates higher uncertainty regarding demographic
parameters and threat levels than for any other DPS.
The abundance estimate for the Oceania DPS is 4,329 individuals,
with a population growth rate of 3 percent per year.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Oceania DPS
There is little information available from the South Pacific
regarding entanglement with fishing gear; two humpback whales have been
observed in Tonga entangled in rope in one instance and fishing net in
another (Donoghue, pers. comm.). One humpback mother (and her calf) was
reported entangled in a longline in the Cook Islands in 2007 (South
Pacific Whale Research Consortium 2008). Entanglement scars have been
seen on humpback whales in American Samoa, but there are not enough
data to determine an entanglement rate. Available evidence suggests
that entanglement is a potential concern in regions where whales and
stationary or drifting gear in the water overlap (Mattila et al. 2010).
The threat of entanglements was ranked low for the Oceania DPS.
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown. In the section
4(a)(1) analysis section of the proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21,
2015 at 22344), we stated that the BRT ranked the threat of
entanglements as low for the Oceania DPS. However, in the Conclusions
on the Status of Each DPS Under the ESA section of the proposed rule
(80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015 at 22350), we incorrectly stated that
fishing gear entanglements posed a moderate threat to the Oceania DPS.
This latter apparently contradictory statement was in error and
reflected a corresponding error in the Executive Summary of the BRT
report.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Oceania DPS
The BRT distributed 68 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Oceania DPS, indicating
a moderate degree of certainty, and 29 percent of its points to the
``moderate risk of extinction'' category, indicating some support for a
conclusion that the species is imperiled. None of the factors that may
negatively impact the status of the humpback whale appear to have
impeded recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for this DPS. Given the
moderate population size (4,329) for this DPS (more than twice the
population size that the BRT considered sufficient to demonstrate that
a population was not at risk due to low abundance alone), the 3 percent
annual growth rate, the majority of likelihood points allocated to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category, and the moderate certainty
associated with the extinction risk estimate for the Oceania DPS, we
conclude that the Oceania DPS is not in danger of extinction throughout
all of its range presently and not likely to become so within the
foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Oceania DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to become so within
the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range, because
we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor threatened
based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT noted that the Oceania DPS has
potentially somewhat greater substructure than most other humpback
whale DPSs due to its extended breeding range, though a lack of strong
genetic structure indicates there are likely to be considerable
demographic connections among these areas. Some threats, such as whale
watching in the Southern Lagoon of New Caledonia, appear to be
localized. Nonetheless, the BRT was unable to identify any specific
areas where threats were sufficiently severe to be likely to cause
local extirpation. We agree, and we also conclude that no portion of
this DPS faces particularly high threats and is so significant to the
viability of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of the DPS would be
in danger of extinction, or likely to become so within the foreseeable
future. Therefore, we conclude that the Oceania DPS is not threatened
or endangered in a significant portion of its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Oceania DPS
Other than protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and
CITES (please see Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS), we are not aware of any ongoing conservation
efforts for this DPS. Regardless, we do not need to further evaluate
conservation efforts in the context of this decision because they would
serve only to further reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the Oceania DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Oceania DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant listing as a
threatened
[[Page 62313]]
species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Southeastern Pacific DPS
The comments that we received on the Southeastern Pacific DPS and
additional information that became available since the publication of
the proposed rule did not change our conclusion that this DPS does not
warrant listing. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information on
the Southeastern Pacific DPS provided in the status review report and
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a
brief summary of that information.
The Southeastern Pacific DPS consists of whales that breed/winter
along the Pacific coasts of Panama to northern Peru (9[deg] N.-6[deg]
S.), with the main wintering areas concentrated in Colombia. Feeding
grounds for this DPS are thought to be concentrated in the Chilean
Magellan Straits and the western Antarctic Peninsula. These cross-
equatorial breeders feed in the Southern Ocean during much of the
austral summer.
Abundance and Trends for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
Individuals of the Southeastern Pacific population migrate from
breeding grounds between Costa Rica and northern Peru to feeding
grounds in the Magellan Straits and along the Western Antarctic
Peninsula. Though no quantitative growth rate information is available
for this DPS, abundance estimates over a 13-year period suggest that
the DPS size is increasing, and abundance was estimated to be 6,504 (95
percent CI = 4,270-9,907) individuals in 2005-2006 (F[eacute]lix et al.
2006a; F[eacute]lix et al. 2011). Total abundance is likely to be
larger because only a portion of the DPS was enumerated.
The abundance estimate for the Southeastern Pacific DPS is 6,504
individuals, with a population trend that is likely increasing.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
Aquaculture activities are high in waters of Argentina and Chile,
but the impact of these activities on this DPS of humpback whales has
not been documented and is likely low if few whales use these inland
areas. Entanglement was determined to pose a medium threat to this DPS
based on stranding and entanglement observations and spatial and
temporal overlap with aquaculture activities.
All threats are considered likely to have no or minor impact on
population size and/or the growth rate or are unknown, with the
exception of fishing gear entanglements posing a moderate threat to the
Southeastern Pacific DPS.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
The BRT distributed 93 percent of their likelihood points to the
``not at risk of extinction'' category for the Southeastern Pacific
DPS, thus indicating a high certainty in its voting. None of the
factors that may negatively impact the status of the humpback whale
appear to have impeded recovery, either alone or cumulatively, for this
DPS. Given the large population sizes (6,504) for this DPS (more than
three times the population size that the BRT considered sufficient to
demonstrate that a population was not at risk due to low abundance
alone), the fact that it is thought to be increasing, the high
percentage of likelihood points allocated to the ``not at risk of
extinction'' category, and the high certainty associated with this
extinction risk estimate, we conclude that the Southeastern Pacific DPS
is not in danger of extinction throughout all of its range presently
and not likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Next, per the Final SPOIR Policy, we need to determine whether the
Southeastern Pacific DPS is in danger of extinction or likely to become
so within the foreseeable future in a significant portion of its range,
because we have determined that the DPS is neither endangered nor
threatened based on a rangewide evaluation. The BRT was unable to
identify a portion of the Southeastern Pacific DPS that both faced
particularly high threats and was so significant to the viability of
the DPS as a whole, that its loss would result in the remainder of the
DPS being at high risk of extinction. We agree, and we also conclude
that no portion of this DPS faces particularly high threats and is so
significant to the viability of the DPS that, if lost, the remainder of
the DPS would be in danger of extinction, or likely to become so within
the foreseeable future. Therefore, we conclude that the Southeastern
Pacific DPS is not threatened or endangered in a significant portion of
its range.
Conservation Efforts for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
While there are many ongoing conservation efforts that apply to the
Southeastern Pacific DPS, we do not need to further evaluate them in
the context of this decision because they would serve only to further
reduce the likely impact of threats.
Listing Determination for the Southeastern Pacific DPS
For the above reasons, we finalize our proposed determination that
the Southeastern Pacific DPS of the humpback whale does not warrant
listing as a threatened species or an endangered species under the ESA.
Arabian Sea DPS
The comments that we received on the Arabian Sea DPS and additional
information that became available since the publication of the proposed
rule did not change our conclusions that this DPS warrants listing as
an endangered species. Therefore, we incorporate herein all information
on the Arabian Sea DPS provided in the status review report and
proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015). The following represents a
brief summary of that information.
The Arabian Sea DPS includes those whales that are currently known
to breed and feed along the coast of Oman. However, historical records
from the eastern Arabian Sea along the coasts of Pakistan and India
indicate its range may also include these areas.
Abundance and Trends for the Arabian Sea DPS
Mark-recapture studies using tail fluke photographs collected in
Oman from 2000-2004 yielded a population estimate of only 82
individuals (95 percent CI = 60-111). However, sample sizes were small,
and there are various sources of possible negative bias, including
insufficient spatial and temporal coverage of the population's
suspected range (Minton et al. 2010b).
Reproductive rates in this DPS are not well understood. Cow-calf
pairs were very rarely observed in surveys off the coast of Oman,
composing only 7 percent of encounters in Dhofar, and not encountered
at all since 2001. Soviet whaling catches off Oman, Pakistan and
northwestern India also included low numbers of lactating females (3.5
percent of mature females) relative to pregnant females (46 percent of
mature females) (Mikhalev 1997).
No trend data are available for this DPS. A low proportion of
immature whales (12.4 percent of all females) was also found, even
though catches were indiscriminate with respect to sex and condition
(Mikhalev 1997), suggesting that calf mortality in this DPS is high,
immature animals occupy areas that have not been surveyed, or that the
whales have reproductive ``boom and bust'' cycles which respond to high
annual variation in productivity. The BRT noted that the entire region
has not
[[Page 62314]]
been surveyed; however, in areas where the whales are likely to be, not
many whales have been observed. The BRT noted that this is a very small
population by any standard but felt that there was some uncertainty in
abundance estimates.
The estimated abundance of the Arabian Sea DPS is 82 individuals,
but its entire range was not surveyed, so it could be somewhat larger.
Its population trend is unknown.
Section 4(a)(1) Factors for the Arabian Sea DPS
The BRT determined that the threat posed by energy exploration to
the Arabian Sea DPS should be classified as high, given the small
population size and the present levels of energy activity. A
catastrophic event similar to the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill that
occurred in the Gulf of Mexico, the potential for which is reasonably
foreseeable in light of the scope of ongoing activity, could be
devastating to this DPS, especially in light of the year-round presence
of humpback whales in this area.
Liver damage was detected in 68.5 percent of necropsied humpback
whales in this area during Soviet whaling in 1966, with degeneration of
peripheral liver sections, cone-shaped growths up to 20 cm in diameter
and blocked bile ducts (Mikhalev 1997). While this pathology was
consistent with infection by trematode parasites, none were identified
during necropsy, and the causes of this liver damage remain unknown.
Poisonous algal blooms and biotoxins have been implicated in some
mass fish, turtle, and possibly cetacean, mortality events on the Oman
coast, although no events have yet been known to include humpback
whales. Coastal run-off from industrial activities is likely to be
increasing rapidly, while regular oil spills in shipping lanes from
tankers also contribute to pollution along the coast (e.g., Shriadah
1999). Tattoo skin lesions were observed in 26 percent of photo-
identified whales from Oman (Baldwin et al. 2010). While not thought to
be a common cause of adult mortality, it has been suggested that tattoo
skin disease may differentially kill neonates and calves that have not
yet gained immunity (Van Bressem et al. 2009). The authors also
suggested that this disease may be more prevalent in marine mammal
populations that experience chronic stress and/or are exposed to
pollutants that suppress the immune system.
Humpback whales in the Arabian Sea are exposed to a high level of
vessel traffic (Baldwin 2000; Minton 2004; Kaluza et al. 2010), so the
threat of ship strikes was considered medium for this small DPS.
There is high fishing pressure in areas off Oman where humpback
whales are sighted. Eight live humpback whale entanglement incidents
were documented between 1990 and 2000, involving bottom set gillnets
often with weights still attached and anchoring the whales to the ocean
floor (Minton 2004). Minton et al. (2010b) examined peduncle
photographs of humpback whales in the Arabian Sea and concluded that at
least 33 percent had been entangled in fishing gear at some stage. The
threat of fishing gear entanglements in the Arabian Sea is considered
high and increasing.
The threat posed by climate change to the Arabian Sea DPS of the
humpback whale within the foreseeable future was determined to be
slightly higher than to the other DPSs and was assigned a medium threat
level. This higher threat level is based on the more limited movement
of this DPS that both breeds and feeds in the Arabian Sea. In the
foreseeable future, changing climatic conditions may change the
monsoon-driven upwelling that creates seasonal productivity in the
region. While Northern Hemisphere individuals may be able to adapt to
climatic changes by moving farther north, Arabian Sea individuals have
less flexibility for expanding their range to cooler regions.
Evidence that this DPS has undergone a recent genetic bottleneck
and is currently at low abundance (Minton et al. 2010b) suggests that
there may be an additional risk of impacts from increased inbreeding
(which may reduce genetic fitness and increase susceptibility to
disease). At low densities, populations are more likely to suffer from
the ``Allee'' effect, where inbreeding and the heightened difficulty of
finding mates reduces the population growth rate in proportion to
reducing density.
The Arabian Sea DPS faces unique threats, given that the whales do
not migrate, but instead feed and breed in the same, relatively
constrained geographic location. Energy exploration and fishing gear
entanglements are considered likely to seriously reduce the
population's size and/or growth rate, and disease, vessel collisions,
and climate change are likely to moderately reduce the population's
size or growth rate.
Extinction Risk Analysis for the Arabian Sea DPS
The BRT distributed 87 percent of its likelihood points for the
Arabian Sea DPS in the ``at high risk of extinction'' category. We
agree with the BRT and conclude that the Arabian Sea DPS is presently
in danger of extinction.
Conservation Efforts for the Arabian Sea DPS
Other than protections provided to humpback whales by the IWC and
CITES (please see Conservation Efforts for the Cape Verde Islands/
Northwest Africa DPS), we are not aware of any ongoing conservation
efforts for this DPS.
Listing Determination for the Arabian Sea DPS
While the IWC and CITES conservation efforts are likely to benefit
all humpback whales, they are not sufficient to change the extinction
risk of this DPS. For the above reasons, we finalize our proposal to
list the Arabian Sea DPS of the humpback whale as an endangered species
under the ESA.
Final Determinations
We reviewed the best available scientific and commercial
information, including the information in the peer reviewed status
review report, public comments, and information that has become
available since the publication of the proposed rule. We identified 14
humpback whale DPSs: West Indies, Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa,
Western North Pacific, Hawaii, Mexico, Central America, Brazil, Gabon/
Southwest Africa, Southeast Africa/Madagascar, West Australia, East
Australia, Oceania, Southeastern Pacific, and Arabian Sea. For each
DPS, we reviewed the abundance and trends and section 4(a)(1) factors,
performed an extinction risk analysis, and considered conservation
efforts. We determined that the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa,
Western North Pacific, Central America, and Arabian Sea DPSs are
endangered species, and the Mexico DPS is a threatened species.
Pursuant to the second sentence of section 4(d) of the ESA, we extend
the prohibitions of section 9(a)(1)(A) through 9(a)(1)(G) of the ESA
(16 U.S.C. 1538) relating to endangered species to threatened humpback
whales (which under this rule consists of the Mexico DPS).
The following nine DPSs do not warrant listing under the ESA: West
Indies, Hawaii, Brazil, Gabon/Southwest Africa, Southeast Africa/
Madagascar, West Australia, East Australia, Oceania, and Southeastern
Pacific. We hereby replace the original endangered listing for the
entire species with listings of the four endangered DPSs and one
threatened DPS.
[[Page 62315]]
Peer Review
In December 2004, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) issued
a Final Information Quality Bulletin for Peer Review, establishing
minimum peer review standards, a transparent process for public
disclosure of peer review planning, and opportunities for public
participation. The OMB Bulletin, implemented under the Information
Quality Act (Pub. L. 106-554), is intended to enhance the quality and
credibility of the Federal government's scientific information and
applies to influential or highly influential scientific information
disseminated on or after June 16, 2005. To satisfy our requirements
under the OMB Bulletin, we obtained independent peer review of the
status review report by 5 independent scientists with expertise in
humpback whale biology and genetics, and related fields. All peer
reviewer comments were addressed prior to the publication of the status
review report and proposed rule.
Peer reviewer comments and responses to comments can be reviewed in
the appendix of the status review report and also at http://www.cio.noaa.gov/services_programs/prplans/ID284.html.
Monitoring Plan
We worked with the States of Alaska, Hawaii, and Massachusetts,
NOAA's National Marine Sanctuary Program, and the National Park Service
to develop a plan pursuant to section 4(g)(1) of the ESA to continue to
monitor the status of the DPSs that we consider to not warrant listing
under the ESA. We find that it is appropriate to monitor the status of
the populations that will no longer be listed under this final rule;
although this action is not technically a delisting, we believe
monitoring is consistent with the intent of section 4(g)(1) of the ESA
(See 16 U.S.C. 1533(g)(1)). We are finalizing this plan today with
publication of this final rule. The objective of the monitoring plan
will be to ensure that necessary recovery actions remain in place and
to ensure the absence of substantial new threats to the DPSs' continued
existence. In part, such monitoring efforts are already an integral
component of ongoing research, existing stranding networks, and other
management and enforcement programs implemented under the MMPA. These
activities are conducted by NMFS in collaboration with other Federal
and state agencies, the Western Pacific Fishery Management Council,
North Pacific Fishery Management Council, the New England Fishery
Management Council, university affiliates, and private research groups.
As noted in Bettridge et al. (2015), many regulatory avenues already in
existence provide for review of proposed projects to reduce or prevent
adverse effects to humpback whales and for post-project monitoring to
ensure protection to humpback whales, as well as penalties for
violation of the prohibition on unauthorized take under the MMPA for
all DPSs that occur in U.S. waters or by U.S. persons or vessels on the
high seas. However, the addition and implementation of a specific
Monitoring Plan will provide an additional degree of attention and an
early warning system to ensure that identifying 14 DPSs and concluding
that nine of these DPSs do not warrant listing as threatened or
endangered will not result in the re-emergence of threats to the DPSs.
We sought peer review and public comment on the draft Monitoring
Plan during a 30-day public comment period, and we have addressed these
comments in the Comment and Response section above.
Prohibitions and Protective Measures
Section 9 of the ESA prohibits certain activities that directly or
indirectly affect endangered species. These prohibitions apply to all
individuals, organizations and agencies subject to U.S. jurisdiction.
Section 4(d) of the ESA directs the Secretary of Commerce (Secretary)
to implement regulations ``to provide for the conservation of
[threatened] species'' that may include extending any or all of the
prohibitions of section 9 to threatened species. Section 9(a)(1)(g)
also prohibits violations of protective regulations for threatened
species implemented under section 4(d). We extend all of the
prohibitions of section 9(a)(1) in protective regulations issued under
the second sentence of section 4(d) for threatened humpback whales,
which under this final rule includes the Mexico DPS. No special
findings are required to support extending section 9 prohibitions for
the protection of threatened species. See In re Polar Bear Endangered
Species Act Listing and 4(d) Rule Litigation, 818 F. Supp. 2d 214, 228
(D.D.C. 2011); Sweet Home Chapter of Cmties. for a Great Oregon v.
Babbitt, 1 F.3d 1, 8 (D.C. Cir. 1993), modified on other grounds on
reh'g, 17 F.3d 1463 (D.C. Cir. 1994), rev'd on other grounds, 515 U.S.
687 (1995).
Sections 7(a)(2) and (4) of the ESA require Federal agencies to
consult or confer with us to ensure that activities they authorize,
fund, or conduct are not likely to jeopardize the continued existence
of a listed species or a species proposed for listing, or to adversely
modify critical habitat or proposed critical habitat. If a Federal
action may affect a listed species or its critical habitat, the
responsible Federal agency must enter into consultation with us.
Examples of Federal actions that may require section 7 consultation
because they affect the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa, Western
North Pacific, Mexico, Central America, and Arabian Sea DPSs of the
humpback whale include permits and authorizations for shipping,
fisheries, oil and gas exploration, and toxic waste and other pollutant
discharges, if they occur in U.S. waters or on the high seas.
Sections 10(a)(1)(A) and (B) of the ESA provide us with authority
to grant exceptions to the ESA's section 9 ``take'' prohibitions.
Section 10(a)(1)(A) scientific research and enhancement permits may be
issued to entities (Federal and non-Federal) for scientific purposes or
to enhance the propagation or survival of a listed species. The type of
activities potentially requiring a section 10(a)(1)(A) research/
enhancement permit include scientific research that targets humpback
whales, including the importation of non-U.S. samples for research
conducted in the United States. Section 10(a)(1)(B) incidental take
permits are required for non-Federal activities that may incidentally
take a listed species in the course of an otherwise lawful activity.
Identification of Those Activities That Would Constitute a Violation of
Section 9 of the ESA
On July 1, 1994, the Services issued an Interagency Cooperative
Policy for Endangered Species Act Section 9 Prohibitions (59 FR 34272).
The intent of this policy is to increase public awareness of the effect
of our ESA listing on proposed and ongoing activities within the
species' range. We identify, to the extent known, specific activities
that will be considered likely to result in violation of section 9 for
endangered species (as well as for threatened species where the section
9 prohibitions have been extended), as well as activities that will not
be considered likely to result in violation. Although the Cape Verde
Islands/Northwest Africa and Arabian Sea DPSs occur outside of the
jurisdiction of the United States, the possibility for violations of
section 9 of the ESA exists with respect to these DPSs (for example,
import into the United States or take by a person subject to the
jurisdiction of the United States on the high seas). Activities that we
believe could result in violation of section 9 prohibitions against
``take'' of the members of the
[[Page 62316]]
Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs of the humpback
whale include: (1) Unauthorized harvest or lethal takes of humpback
whales that are members of the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and
Central America DPSs by U.S. citizens; (2) unauthorized in-water
activities conducted by any person subject to the jurisdiction of the
United States that produce high levels of underwater noise, which may
harass or injure humpback whales that are members of the Western North
Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs; (3) unauthorized U.S.
fisheries that may result in entanglement of humpback whales that are
members of the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs;
(4) vessel strikes on whales from the Western North Pacific, Mexico,
and Central America DPSs by U.S. ships operating in U.S. waters or on
the high seas; and (5) discharging or dumping toxic chemicals or other
pollutants by U.S. citizens into areas used by humpback whales that are
members of the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs.
We expect, based on the best available information, the following
actions will not result in a violation of section 9: (1) Federally
funded or approved projects for which ESA section 7 consultation has
been completed and necessary mitigation developed, and that are
conducted in accordance with any terms and conditions we provide in an
incidental take statement accompanying a biological opinion; and (2)
takes of humpback whales in the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and
Central America DPSs that have been authorized by NMFS pursuant to
section 10 of the ESA.
These lists are not exhaustive. They are merely intended to provide
some examples of the types of activities that we might or might not
consider as constituting a take of humpback whales in the Western North
Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs based on the information
currently available. Whether a violation results from a particular
activity is entirely dependent upon the facts and circumstances of each
incident. Further, an activity not listed may in fact constitute or
result in a violation.
Effects of This Rulemaking
Conservation measures provided for species listed as endangered or
threatened under the ESA include development of recovery plans (16
U.S.C. 1533(f)); concurrent designation of critical habitat, to the
maximum extent prudent and determinable (16 U.S.C. 1533(a)(3)(A));
Federal agency requirements to consult with NMFS under section 7 of the
ESA to ensure their proposed actions are not likely to jeopardize the
continued existence of the species or result in destruction or adverse
modification of any designated critical habitat (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2));
and prohibitions against ``take'' (16 U.S.C. 1538(a)(1)). Recognition
of the species' plight through listing promotes conservation actions by
Federal and state agencies, foreign entities, private groups, and
individuals. The main effects of the listings are prohibitions on take,
as well as export and import. The provisions discussed above will no
longer apply to the nine DPSs that are in effect removed from the
endangered species list. For section 7 requirements that will continue
to apply to listed DPSs, we recognize the need for an approach that
will allow us to determine which DPSs may be affected by Federal
actions subject to consultation under section 7 where humpback whales
from different DPSs mix. As we have for other species, we will likely
use a proportional approach to indicate which DPSs are affected by any
takes based upon the best available science indicating which DPSs are
present, depending on the location and timing where take occurred.
The MMPA provides substantial protections to all marine mammals,
such as humpback whales, whether they are listed under the ESA or not.
In addition, the MMPA provides heightened protections to marine mammals
designated as ``depleted'' (e.g., no take waiver, additional
restrictions on the issuance of permits for research, importation, and
captive maintenance). Section 3(1) of the MMPA defines ``depleted'' as
``any case in which'': (1) The Secretary ``determines that a species or
population stock is below its optimum sustainable population''; (2) a
state to which authority has been delegated makes the same
determination; or (3) a species or stock ``is listed as an endangered
species or a threatened species under the [ESA]'' (16 U.S.C. 1362(1)).
Section 115(a)(1) of the MMPA establishes that ``[i]n any action by the
Secretary to determine if a species or stock should be designated as
depleted, or should no longer be designated as depleted,'' such
determination must be made by rule, after public notice and an
opportunity for comment (16 U.S.C. 1383b(a)(1)). It is our position
that a marine mammal species or stock automatically gains ``depleted''
status under the MMPA when it is listed under the ESA. In the absence
of an ESA listing, we follow the procedures described in section
115(a)(1) to designate a marine mammal species or stock as depleted
when the basis for its depleted status is that it is below its OSP.
This interpretation was confirmed by the United States Court of Appeals
for the D.C. Circuit. See In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act
Listing and Section 4(d) Rule Litigation, 720 F.3d 354 (D.C. Cir.
2013).
The language and structure of the MMPA's definition of depleted
lead NMFS to the conclusion that a species or stock that is designated
as depleted solely on the basis of its ESA listing status would cease
to qualify as depleted under the terms of that definition if it is no
longer listed. Therefore, a species or stock that is removed from the
list of threatened and endangered species loses its depleted status
when removed from the list. Consistent with the D.C. Circuit's opinion
in In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and Section 4(d)
Rule Litigation, 720 F.3d 354 (D.C. Cir. 2013), we believe that the
process described in section 115(a) applies only to the first basis for
designating a species as depleted (i.e., when the agency determines
that the species is below its OSP). Therefore, we are required to issue
a rule in accordance with the process described in section 115(a) to
determine that a species or stock is no longer depleted in cases where
the agency previously issued a rule pursuant to section 115(a)
designating the species or stock as depleted on the basis that it is
below its OSP. However, in the case of a species or stock that achieved
depleted status solely on the basis of an ESA listing, depleted status
automatically terminates if the species or stock is removed from the
list of threatened or endangered species. In such a situation, we may
choose to evaluate whether the species or stock is below its OSP and
re-designate the species or stock as depleted through an MMPA
rulemaking on that basis if warranted.
We have previously delisted two populations of marine mammals, both
of which were considered to be depleted solely on the basis of an ESA
listing. The first delisting occurred in 1994, when the agency delisted
the Eastern North Pacific (ENP) population of gray whales. See 59 FR
31094 (June 16, 1994). As indicated by our rejection of a petition to
designate the ENP gray whales as depleted under the MMPA in 2010, we
considered the population to be no longer depleted following its
delisting (See 75 FR 81225; December 27, 2010). The second delisting
occurred in 2013, when we delisted the Eastern DPS of the Steller sea
lion (See 78 FR 66139; November 4, 2013). In our final rule to delist
the DPS, we notified the
[[Page 62317]]
public that the delisting ``w[ould] likely lead to two modifications to
classifications of the eastern DPS of Steller sea lion under the MMPA:
from its current classification as a `strategic stock' and as a
`depleted' species to a new classification as a `non-strategic stock'
and/or as not depleted.'' Id. at 66168. We stated that we ``w[ould]
consider redesignating the eastern stock of Steller sea lions as non-
strategic and not depleted under the MMPA following review by the
Alaska Scientific Review Group in 2014.'' Id. We take this opportunity
to clarify our interpretation that loss of depleted status is automatic
at the time at the time of a delisting if the sole basis for the
species or stocks' depleted status was an ESA listing. In the future,
we will notify the public in any proposed rule to delist a marine
mammal species or stock that a final rule, if promulgated, will have
the effect of designating the species or stock as no longer depleted.
At the time of a delisting, we may choose to initiate a rulemaking
under section 115(a) if information in our files or information
presented by a Scientific Review Group indicates that the species or
stock is below its OSP. We will also initiate a review of the species
or stock pursuant to section 115(a) if we are petitioned to do so.
However, loss of depleted status at the time of a delisting is
automatic if the sole basis for the population's depleted status was an
ESA listing; no further review as to OSP is necessary before loss of
depleted status occurs.
Humpback whales were considered to be depleted species-wide under
the MMPA solely on the basis of the species' ESA listing. Therefore,
upon the effective date of this rule, humpback whales that are listed
as threatened or endangered will retain depleted status under the MMPA
and humpback whales that are not listed as threatened or endangered
will lose depleted status under the MMPA. However, we note that the
DPSs established in this final rule that occur in waters under the
jurisdiction of the United States do not necessarily equate to the
existing MMPA stocks for which Stock Assessment Reports (SARs) have
been published in accordance with section 117 of the MMPA (16 U.S.C.
1386). Following publication of this rule, we will conduct a review of
humpback whale stock delineations in waters under the jurisdiction of
the United States to determine whether any stocks should be realigned
in light of the ESA DPSs established herein. Until such time as the
MMPA stock delineations are reviewed, because we cannot manage one
portion of a stock as depleted and another portion as not depleted
under the MMPA, we will treat existing MMPA stocks that fully or
partially coincide with a listed DPS as depleted and stocks that do not
fully or partially coincide with a listed DPS as not depleted for
management purposes. Therefore, in the interim, we will treat the
Western North Pacific, Central North Pacific, and California/Oregon/
Washington stocks as depleted because they partially or fully coincide
with ESA-listed DPSs, and we will treat the Gulf of Maine and American
Samoa stocks as no longer depleted because they do not coincide with
any ESA-listed DPS. Any changes in stock delineation or MMPA section
117 elements (such as PBR or strategic status) will be reflected in
future stock assessment reports, and the Scientific Review Groups and
the public will be provided opportunity to review and comment.
This final rule also has implications for the approach regulations
currently at 50 CFR 224.103(a) and (b). With regard to the regulations
in effect in Hawaii (224.103(a)), the delisting of the Hawaii DPS
removes the ESA basis for promulgation of that rule. Therefore, upon
the effective date of this final rule, the regulations currently at
Sec. 224.103(a) will be deleted and that paragraph reserved. However,
elsewhere in today's issue of the Federal Register, we are issuing an
interim final rule to promulgate approach regulations in Hawaii under
the MMPA that are substantially similar to the ESA regulations being
removed, but also prohibit interception (i.e., leap-frogging).
With regard to the regulations in effect in Alaska (224.103(b)),
the impacts of this final rule are different. When the Alaska
provisions were adopted, we cited section 112(a) of the MMPA in
addition to section 11(f) of the ESA as authority (16 U.S.C. 1382(a);
16 U.S.C. 1540(f)). However, because the humpback whale was listed
throughout its range as endangered, the rule was codified only in Part
224 of the ESA regulations (which applies to ``Endangered Marine and
Anadromous Species''). At the time of the proposed listing rule, we did
not expect that there would be any endangered DPSs present in Alaska
and so sought comment as to whether we should relocate the approach
regulations from Part 224 to Part 223 (setting out ESA regulations
applicable to ``Threatened Marine and Anadromous Species'') and also as
to whether we should set them out in Part 216 as MMPA regulations.
Because we are now listing the Western North Pacific DPS as endangered,
we will retain the approach regulations under the ESA at 50 CFR
224.103, and because we are listing the Mexico DPS as threatened, we
will also add the provisions to Part 223 at 50 CFR 223.214. By separate
rulemaking elsewhere in today's issue of the Federal Register, we
therefore promulgate a final rule effecting a technical correction and
recodification that recodifies these provisions so that they appear in
both Parts 223 and 224 and also sets the provisions out in Part 216
(MMPA Regulations) at 50 CFR 216.18, to reflect that these provisions
were originally adopted under the MMPA as well as the ESA and are an
important source of protection for these marine mammals.
Critical Habitat
Section 3 of the ESA (16 U.S.C. 1532(5)(A)) defines critical
habitat as ``(i) the specific areas within the geographical area
occupied by the species, at the time it is listed . . . on which are
found those physical or biological features (I) essential to the
conservation of the species and (II) which may require special
management considerations or protection; and (ii) specific areas
outside the geographical area occupied by the species at the time it is
listed . . . upon a determination by the Secretary that such areas are
essential for the conservation of the species.'' Section 3 of the ESA
also defines the terms ``conserve,'' ``conserving,'' and
``conservation'' to mean ``to use and the use of all methods and
procedures which are necessary to bring any endangered species or
threatened species to the point at which the measures provided pursuant
to this chapter are no longer necessary'' (16 U.S.C. 1532(3)).
Section 4(a)(3)(A)(i) of the ESA requires that, to the maximum
extent practicable and determinable, critical habitat be designated
concurrently with the listing of a species. Designation of critical
habitat must be based on the best scientific data available, and must
take into consideration the economic, national security, and other
relevant impacts of specifying any particular area as critical habitat
(16 U.S.C. 1533(b)(2)). Once critical habitat is designated, section 7
of the ESA requires Federal agencies to ensure that they do not fund,
authorize, or carry out any actions that are likely to destroy or
adversely modify that habitat (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2)). This requirement
is in addition to the section 7 requirement that Federal agencies
ensure their actions do not jeopardize the continued existence of the
species.
[[Page 62318]]
In determining what areas qualify as critical habitat, 50 CFR
424.12(b) requires that NMFS ``Identify physical and biological
features essential to the conservation of the species at an appropriate
level of specificity using the best available scientific data. This
analysis will vary between species and may include consideration of the
appropriate quality, quantity, and spatial and temporal arrangements of
such features in the context of the life history, status, and
conservation needs of the species.'' ``Physical or biological
features'' are defined as the ``features that support the life-history
needs of the species, including but not limited to, water
characteristics, soil type, geological features, sites, prey,
vegetation, symbiotic species, or other features. A feature may be a
single habitat characteristic, or a more complex combination of habitat
characteristics. Features may include habitat characteristics that
support ephemeral or dynamic habitat conditions. Features may also be
expressed in terms relating to principles of conservation biology, such
as patch size, distribution distances, and connectivity'' (50 CFR
424.02).
The ESA directs the Secretary of Commerce to consider the economic
impact, the national security impacts, and any other relevant impacts
from designating critical habitat, and under section 4(b)(2), the
Secretary may exclude any area from such designation if the benefits of
exclusion outweigh those of inclusion, provided that the exclusion will
not result in the extinction of the species.
50 CFR 424.12(g) specifies that critical habitat shall not be
designated within foreign countries or in other areas outside U.S.
jurisdiction. Because the known distributions of the humpback whales in
the Cape Verde Islands/Northwest Africa and Arabian Sea DPSs occur in
areas outside the jurisdiction of the United States, no critical
habitat will be designated for these DPSs.
In our proposed rule (80 FR 22304; April 21, 2015), we requested
information on the identification of specific areas that meet the
definition of critical habitat defined above for the Western North
Pacific and Central America DPSs of the humpback whale. These DPSs,
together with the Mexico DPS that we are now listing as threatened, are
the only listed DPSs that occur in U.S. waters or its territories. We
also solicited biological and economic information relevant to making a
critical habitat designation for each DPS. We have reviewed the
comments provided and the best available scientific information. We
conclude that critical habitat is not determinable at this time for the
following reasons: (i) Data sufficient to perform required analyses are
lacking; and (ii) the biological needs of the species are not
sufficiently well known to identify any area that meets the definition
of ``critical habitat'' (50 CFR 424.12(a)(2)). We will propose critical
habitat for the Western North Pacific, Mexico, and Central America DPSs
of the humpback whale in a separate rulemaking if we determine that it
is prudent to do so. (See 50 CFR 424.12(a)(1).)
Classification
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
The 1982 amendments to the ESA, in section 4(b)(1)(A), restrict the
information that may be considered when assessing species for listing.
Based on this limitation of criteria for a listing decision and the
opinion in Pacific Legal Foundation v. Andrus, 657 F. 2d 829 (6th Cir.
1981), we have concluded that NEPA does not apply to ESA listing
actions. (See NOAA Administrative Order 216-6 (1999), Sec. 6.03.e.1;
NAO 216-6A (2016), Sec. 6.01.) Further, we conclude that extension of
the section 9(a)(1) protections in a blanket or categorical fashion is
a form of ministerial action taken under the authority of the second
sentence of ESA section 4(d). Courts have found that it is reasonable
to interpret the second sentence of section 4(d) as setting out
distinct authority from that of the first sentence, which is invoked
when the agency proposes tailored or special protections that go beyond
the standard section 9 protections. See In re Polar Bear Endangered
Species Act Listing and 4(d) Rule Litigation, 818 F. Supp. 2d 214, 228
(D.D.C. 2011); Sweet Home Chapter of Cmties. for a Great Oregon v.
Babbitt, 1 F.3d 1, 8 (D.C. Cir.1993), modified on other grounds on
reh'g, 17 F.3d 1463 (D.C. Cir. 1994), rev'd on other grounds, 515 U.S.
687 (1995). This type of action is covered under the NOAA categorical
exclusion for ``policy directives, regulations and guidelines of an
administrative, financial, legal, technical or procedural nature . . .
.'' See NAO 216-6, Sec. 6.03c.3(i). None of the exceptional
circumstances of Sec. 5.05c of NAO 216-6 applies. That is, the action
does not involve a geographic area with unique characteristics, is not
the subject of public controversy based on potential environmental
consequences, does not have uncertain environmental impacts or unique
or unknown risks, does not establish a precedent or decision in
principle about future proposals, will not result in cumulatively
significant impacts, and will not have any adverse effects upon
endangered or threatened species or their habitats. In particular, the
rule may not reasonably be said to potentially have ``any adverse
effects upon endangered or threatened species or their habitats''
because here the rule will ensure the same level of protections
continue to apply to any threatened DPS, which benefits the species. In
addition, we note that there will be no change in the legal or
regulatory status quo as it relates to the threatened DPS of humpback
whales, because these whales have for decades been covered by all
protections of section 9 as endangered species. Issuance of this rule
thus does not alter the legal and regulatory status quo in such a way
as to create any environmental effects. See Humane Soc. of U.S. v.
Johanns, 520 F. Supp. 2d. 8, 29 (D.D.C. 2007). NEPA analysis is not
required in cases where the rule will not result in any physical
effects to the environment, much less any adverse effects. See Oceana,
Inc. v. Bryson, 940 F. Supp. 2d 1029 (N.D. Cal. 2013).
Executive Order (E.O.) 12866, Paperwork Reduction Act, and Regulatory
Flexibility Act
This rule is exempt from review under E.O. 12866. This final rule
does not contain a collection of information requirement for the
purposes of the Paperwork Reduction Act.
As noted in the Conference Report on the 1982 amendments to the
ESA, economic impacts cannot be considered when assessing the status of
a species. Therefore, the economic analyses required by the Regulatory
Flexibility Act are not applicable to the listing process.
E.O. 13132, Federalism
E.O. 13132 requires agencies to take into account any federalism
impacts of regulations under development. It includes specific
directives for consultation in situations where a regulation will
preempt state law or impose substantial direct compliance costs on
state and local governments (unless required by statute). Neither of
those circumstances is applicable to this final rule; therefore this
action does not have federalism implications as that term is defined in
E.O. 13132.
E.O. 13175, Consultation and Coordination with Indian Tribal
Governments
The longstanding and distinctive relationship between the Federal
and tribal governments is defined by
[[Page 62319]]
treaties, statutes, executive orders, judicial decisions, and co-
management agreements, which differentiate tribal governments from the
other entities that deal with, or are affected by, the Federal
government. This relationship has given rise to a special Federal trust
responsibility involving the legal responsibilities and obligations of
the United States toward Indian Tribes and the application of fiduciary
standards of due care with respect to Indian lands, tribal trust
resources, and the exercise of tribal rights. E.O. 13175--Consultation
and Coordination with Indian Tribal Governments--outlines the
responsibilities of the Federal Government in matters affecting tribal
interests. Section 161 of Public Law 108-199 (188 Stat. 452), as
amended by section 518 of Public Law 108-447 (118 Stat. 3267), directs
all Federal agencies to consult with Alaska Native tribes or
organizations on the same basis as Indian tribes under E.O. 13175.
We have coordinated with tribal governments and native corporations
that may be affected by the action. We provided them with a copy of the
proposed rule, and offered the opportunity to comment on the Monitoring
Plan. We did not receive any comments.
References Cited
A list of all references cited in this final rule is available at
www.regulations.gov (identified by docket number NOAA-NMFS-2015-0035)
or upon request from NMFS (see ADDRESSES).
List of Subjects
50 CFR Part 223
Endangered and threatened species, Exports, Imports,
Transportation.
50 CFR Part 224
Endangered and threatened species.
Samuel D. Rauch III,
Deputy Assistant Administrator for Regulatory Programs, National Marine
Fisheries Service.
For the reasons set out in the preamble, 50 CFR parts 223 and 224
are amended as follows:
PART 223--THREATENED MARINE AND ANADROMOUS SPECIES
0
1. The authority citation for part 223 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1531-1543; subpart B, Sec. 223.201-202
also issued under 16 U.S.C. 1361 et seq.; 16 U.S.C. 5503(d) for
Sec. 223.206(d)(9).
0
2. In Sec. 223.102, in the table in paragraph (e), add an entry for
``Whale, humpback (Mexico DPS)'' under MARINE MAMMALS in alphabetical
order by common name to read as follows:
Sec. 223.102 Enumeration of threatened marine and anadromous species.
* * * * *
(e) * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Species \1\
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Citation(s) for
Description of listed listing Critical habitat ESA rules
Common name Scientific name entity determination(s)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marine Mammals
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* * * * * * *
Whale, humpback (Mexico DPS)...... Megaptera Humpback whales that breed 81 FR [Insert Federal NA.................. 223.213
novaeangliae. or winter in the area of Register page where
mainland Mexico and the the document
Revillagigedos Islands, begins], September
transit Baja California, 8, 2016.
or feed in the North
Pacific Ocean, primarily
off California-Oregon,
northern Washington-
southern British
Columbia, northern and
western Gulf of Alaska
and East Bering Sea.
* * * * * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Species includes taxonomic species, subspecies, distinct population segments (DPSs) (for a policy statement, see 61 FR 4722, February 7, 1996), and
evolutionarily significant units (ESUs) (for a policy statement, see 56 FR 58612, November 20, 1991).
* * * * *
0
3. Add Sec. 223.213 to subpart B to read as follows:
Sec. 223.213 Humpback whales.
The prohibitions of section 9(a)(1)(A) through 9(a)(1)(G) of the
ESA (16 U.S.C. 1538) relating to endangered species apply to threatened
species of the humpback whale listed in Sec. 223.102(e).
PART 224--ENDANGERED MARINE AND ANADROMOUS SPECIES
0
4. The authority citation for part 224 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1531-1543 and 16 U.S.C. 1361 et seq.
0
5. In Sec. 224.101, in the table in paragraph (h), remove the entry
for ``Whale, humpback'' and add four entries in its place to read as
follows:
Sec. 224.101 Enumeration of endangered marine and anadromous species.
* * * * *
(h) * * *
[[Page 62320]]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Species \1\
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Citation(s) for
Description of listed listing Critical habitat ESA rules
Common name Scientific name entity determination(s)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marine Mammals
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* * * * * * *
Whale, humpback (Arabian Sea DPS). Megaptera Humpback whales that breed 81 FR [Insert Federal NA.................. NA
novaeangliae. and feed in the Arabian Register page where
Sea. the document
begins], September
8, 2016.
Whale, humpback (Cape Verde Megaptera Humpback whales that breed 81 FR [Insert Federal NA.................. NA
Islands/Northwest Africa DPS). novaeangliae. in waters surrounding the Register page where
Cape Verde Islands in the the document
Eastern North Atlantic begins], September
Ocean, as well as those 8, 2016.
that breed in an
undetermined breeding
area in the eastern
tropical Atlantic
(possibly Canary Current)
and feed along the
Iceland Shelf and Sea and
the Norwegian Sea.
Whale, humpback (Central America Megaptera Humpback whales that breed 81 FR [Insert Federal
DPS). novaeangliae. in waters off Central Register page where
America in the North the document
Pacific Ocean and feed begins], September
along the west coast of 8, 2016.
the United States and
southern British Columbia.
Whale, humpback (Western North Megaptera Humpback whales that breed 81 FR [Insert Federal
Pacific DPS). novaeangliae. or winter in the area of Register page where
Okinawa and the the document
Philippines in the begins], September
Kuroshio Current (as well 8, 2016.
as unknown breeding
grounds in the Western
North Pacific Ocean),
transit the Ogasawara
area, or feed in the
North Pacific Ocean,
primarily in the West
Bering Sea and off the
Russian coast and the
Aleutian Islands.
* * * * * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Species includes taxonomic species, subspecies, distinct population segments (DPSs) (for a policy statement, see 61 FR 4722, February 7, 1996), and
evolutionarily significant units (ESUs) (for a policy statement, see 56 FR 58612, November 20, 1991).
* * * * *
0
6. Remove and reserve Sec. 224.103(a) to read as follows:
Sec. 224.103 Special prohibitions for endangered marine mammals.
(a) [Reserved]
* * * * *
[FR Doc. 2016-21276 Filed 9-6-16; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 3510-22-P