[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 151 (Thursday, August 6, 2015)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 47302-47313]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-18258]
[[Page 47301]]
Vol. 80
Thursday,
No. 151
August 6, 2015
Part X
Department of Housing and Urban Development
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
24 CFR Parts 5, 92, 570, et al.
Equal Participation of Faith-Based Organizations in HUD Programs:
Implementation of E.O. 13559; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 80 , No. 151 / Thursday, August 6, 2015 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 47302]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Parts 5, 92, 570, 574, 576, 578, 582, 583 and 1003
[Docket No. FR-5781-P-01]
RIN 2501-AD65
Equal Participation of Faith-Based Organizations in HUD Programs:
Implementation of E.O. 13559
AGENCY: Office of the Secretary, HUD.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This rule proposes to revise HUD's regulation that covers the
equal participation of faith-based (religious) organizations in HUD
Programs, including all of HUD's Native American Programs, as well as
several program-specific regulations regarding the equal participation
of faith-based organizations. These revisions are being undertaken to
implement Executive Order 13559, Fundamental Principles and
Policymaking Criteria for Partnerships with Faith-Based and Other
Neighborhood Organizations. Executive Order 13559 revised Executive
Order 13279, Equal Protection of the Laws for Faith-Based and Community
Organizations, which provides the legal basis for HUD's current equal
participation regulations. This rule implements changes to Executive
Order 13279 made by Executive Order 13559, including changes to
specific terminology, additional beneficiary protections, and
clarifications on the responsibilities of intermediaries. In addition
to proposing regulatory amendments to implement Executive Order 13559,
HUD is also publishing for public comment a sample notice of
beneficiary protections for use by faith-based organizations.
DATES: Comment Due Date. October 5, 2015.
ADDRESSES: Interested persons are invited to submit comments regarding
this rule to the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, 451
7th Street SW., Room 10276, Department of Housing and Urban
Development, Washington, DC 20410-0500. There are two methods for
submitting public comments. All submissions must refer to the above
docket number and title.
1. Submission of Comments by Mail. Comments may be submitted by
mail to the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, Department
of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410-0500. All comments received by mail are a part of
the public record and will be posted to www.regulations.gov without
change.
2. Electronic Submission of Comments. Interested persons may submit
comments electronically through the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly encourages commenters to submit
comments electronically. Electronic submission of comments allows the
commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a comment, ensures timely
receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to make them immediately available to
the public. Comments submitted electronically through the
www.regulations.gov Web site can be viewed by other commenters and
interested members of the public. Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to submit comments electronically.
Note: To receive consideration as public comments, comments must
be submitted through one of the two methods specified above. Again,
all submissions must refer to the docket number and title of the
rule.
No Facsimile Comments. Facsimile (fax) comments are not acceptable.
Public Inspection of Public Comments. All properly submitted
comments and communications submitted to HUD will be available for
public inspection and copying between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m., eastern time,
weekdays at the above address. Due to security measures at the HUD
Headquarters building, an advance appointment to review the public
comments must be scheduled by calling the Regulations Division at 202-
708-3055 (this is not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech or
hearing impairments may access this number through TTY by calling the
Federal Relay Service at 800-877-8339 (this is a toll-free number).
Copies of all comments submitted are available for inspection and
downloading at www.regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Paula Lincoln, Director, Center for
Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships, Department of Housing and
Urban Development, 451 7th Street SW., Room 10184, Washington, DC
20410-7000; telephone number 202-708-2404 (this is not a toll-free
number). Hearing- and speech-impaired persons may access this number
through TTY by calling the Federal Relay Service at 800-877-8339 (this
is a toll-free number).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
On December 12, 2002, President Bush signed Executive Order 13279,
Equal Protection of the Laws for Faith-Based and Community
Organizations, which was published on December 16, 2002, at 67 FR
77141. Executive Order 13279 set forth fundamental principles and
policymaking criteria to guide Federal agencies in formulating and
developing policies with implications for faith-based and other
community organizations, to ensure equal protection of the laws for
faith-based and other community organizations, and to expand
opportunities for, and strengthen the capacity of, faith-based and
other community organizations to meet social needs in America's
communities. In addition, Executive Order 13279 directed specified
agency heads to review and evaluate existing policies relating to
Federal financial assistance for social service programs and, where
appropriate, to implement new policies that were consistent with and
necessary to further the fundamental principles and policymaking
criteria that have implications for faith-based and community
organizations.
HUD implemented Executive Order 13279 through three final rules:
Participation in HUD Programs by Faith-Based Organizations;
Providing for Equal Treatment of all HUD Program Participants,
published on September 30, 2003, at 68 FR 56396, and amended HUD's
regulations in 24 CFR part 92 (HOME Investment Partnerships Program),
part 570 (Community Development Block Grants), part 572 (HOPE for
Homeownership of Single Family Homes (HOPE 3)), \1\ part 574 (Housing
Opportunities for Persons with AIDS), part 576 (Emergency Shelter
Grants Program, now Emergency Solutions Grants Program), part 582
(Shelter Plus Care), part 583 (Supportive Housing Program), and part
585 (Youthbuild Program); \2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Part 572 was removed by a HUD final rule published on
September 2, 2014, at 79 FR 51893.
\2\ Part 585 was removed by a HUD final rule published on
September 2, 2014, at 79 FR 51893.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Equal Participation of Faith-Based Organizations, published on July
9, 2004, at 69 FR 41712, and amended HUD's regulations in 24 CFR part 5
(General HUD Program Requirements and Waivers) and 24 CFR part 570
(Community Development Block Grant Program); and
Participation in HUD's Native American Programs by Religious
Organizations; Providing for Equal Treatment of All Program
Participants, published on October 22, 2004, at 69 FR 62164, and
amended HUD's regulations at 24 CFR part 954 (Indian HOME
[[Page 47303]]
Program),\3\ and 24 CFR part 1003 (Community Development Block Grants
for Indian Tribes and Alaska Native Villages).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ HUD stopped awarding grants on the Indian Home Program on
September 30, 1997, and part 954 was removed by a HUD final rule
published on February 9, 2012, at 77 FR 6673.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The regulations established by each of these three rules provide
that faith-based (religious) organizations are eligible on the same
basis as any other eligible organization to participate in HUD programs
and activities; \4\ organizations may not engage in inherently
religious activities as part of programs or services directly funded
under a HUD program or activity; faith-based organizations that
participate in HUD programs or activities may retain their
independence; and a faith-based organization that participates in a HUD
program does not forfeit its exemption from the Federal prohibition
against employment discrimination on the basis of religion, as provided
in title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (though some individual
HUD programs may have independent statutory nondiscrimination
requirements). These regulations also provide that organizations may
not discriminate against beneficiaries or prospective beneficiaries on
the basis of religion or religious beliefs; address the use of HUD
funds for acquisition, construction, and rehabilitation of structures
that are used for inherently religious activities; and clarify the
attachment of requirements to State, tribal, and local funds that are
commingled with HUD funds.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ Faith-based organizations must also meet any applicable
program requirements to participate in a HUD program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 5, 2009, President Obama signed Executive Order 13498,
entitled ``Amendments to Executive Order 13199 and Establishment of the
President's Advisory Council for Faith-Based and Neighborhood
Partnerships,'' which was published on February 9, 2009, at 74 FR 6533.
Executive Order 13498 established the President's Advisory Council for
Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships (Advisory Council) for the
purpose of bringing together experts to, among other things, make
recommendations to the President for changes in policies, programs, and
practices that affect the delivery of services by faith-based and other
neighborhood organizations.
The Advisory Council issued its recommendations in a report
entitled ``A New Era of Partnerships: Report of Recommendations to the
President'' in March 2010.\5\ The Advisory Council Report included
recommendations to amend Executive Order 13279 to clarify the legal
foundation of partnerships, and offered a new set of fundamental
principles to guide agency decision-making in administering Federal
financial assistance and support to faith-based and neighborhood
organizations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ofbnp-council-final-report.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On November 17, 2010, President Obama signed Executive Order 13559,
entitled ``Fundamental Principles and Policymaking Criteria for
Partnerships with Faith-Based and Other Neighborhood Organizations,''
which was published on November 22, 2010, at 75 FR 71319.\6\ Executive
Order 13559 incorporated many of the Advisory Council's recommendations
and amended Executive Order 13279, to revise and add additional
fundamental principles and policymaking criteria for inclusion in
guidance and regulations.\7\ The principles include:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2010-11-22/pdf/2010-29579.pdf.
\7\ Executive Order 13279, Section 2, paragraphs (e)-(j).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Federal Government has an obligation to monitor and
enforce all standards regarding the relationship between religion and
the Federal Government in ways that avoid excessive entanglement
between religious bodies and governmental entities;
Organizations engaging in explicitly religious activities
must separate these activities, in time or location, from programs
supported with direct Federal financial assistance (including prime
awards and sub-awards). Participation in any explicitly religious
activity cannot be subsidized with direct Federal financial assistance
(including prime awards and sub-awards), and participation in such
activities must be voluntary for the beneficiaries of the social
service program supported with such Federal financial assistance;
Religious providers are welcome to compete for Federal
Government funding and maintain a religious identity as described in
the order;
Agencies that administer or award Federal financial
assistance must implement protections for the beneficiaries or
prospective beneficiaries of those programs (these protections include
providing referral to an alternative provider if the beneficiary
objects to the religious character of the organization providing
services, and ensuring that written notice of these and other
protections is provided to beneficiaries before they enroll in or
receive services from the program);
Agencies that provide Federal financial assistance must
post online regulations, guidance documents, and policies that have
implications for faith-based and neighborhood organizations, and post
online a list of entities receiving such assistance; and
Agency decisions about awards of Federal financial
assistance must be free from political interference or even the
appearance of such interference, and must be made on the basis of
merit, not on the basis of the religious affiliation, or lack of
affiliation, of the recipient organization.
In addition, Executive Order 13559 created the Interagency Working
Group on Faith-Based and Other Neighborhood Partnerships (Working
Group) for the purpose of reviewing and evaluating existing
regulations, guidance documents, and policies.
The Executive Order also stated that, following receipt of the
Working Group's report, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), in
coordination with the Department of Justice, must issue guidance to
agencies on the implementation of Executive Order 13559. The Working
Group issued its report in April 2012.\8\ In August 2013, OMB issued
guidance instructing specified agency heads to adopt regulations and
guidance that will fulfill the requirements of Executive Order 13559,
and to amend regulations and guidance to ensure that they are
consistent with this Executive order.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ Recommendations of the Interagency Working Group on Faith-
Based and Other Neighborhood Partnerships, April 2012, at http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/uploads/finalfaithbasedworkinggroupreport.pdf.
\9\ M-13-19, ``Implementation of Executive Order 13559,
`Fundamental Principles and Policymaking Criteria for Partnerships
with Faith-based and Other Neighborhood Organizations','' August 2,
2013, at http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/memoranda/2013/m-13-19.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prior to the issuance of the August 2013 guidance and after the
issuance of Executive Order 13559, HUD issued one interim rule, one
final rule, and one proposed rule that incorporated language to reflect
Executive Order 13559:
Interim Rule: Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to
Housing: Continuum of Care Program, published on July 31, 2012, at 77
FR 45422, which provided a new regulation on the equal participation of
faith-based organizations in 24 CFR part 578 (Continuum of Care
Program);
Final Rule: HOME Investment Partnerships Program: Improving
Performance and Accountability; Updating Property Standards, published
on July 24, 2013, at 78 FR 44627, which modified HUD's equal
participation of faith-based organizations regulation in
[[Page 47304]]
24 CFR part 92 (HOME Investment Partnerships Program); and
Proposed Rule: Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition
to Housing: Rural Housing Stability Assistance Program and Revisions to
the Definition of ``Chronically Homeless,'' published on March 27,
2013, at 78 FR 18725, which proposed regulations at 24 CFR part 579 for
the new Rural Housing Stability Assistance Program, including a
regulation on the equal participation of faith-based organizations.
II. This Proposed Rule
A. Overview of Proposed Regulations
This proposed rule updates all HUD regulations governing the equal
participation of faith-based organizations in HUD programs to reflect
the new fundamental principles and policymaking criteria in Executive
Order 13559. Some of the principles do not require regulations and will
be included in guidance that will accompany the final rule to follow
this proposed rule. HUD may issue guidance on the applicability of the
Executive order and this proposed rule to particular programs or
activities.
HUD is implementing Executive Order 13559 by amending its Sec.
5.109 regulation to: (1) Add definitions for direct Federal financial
assistance, Federal financial assistance, indirect Federal financial
assistance, and an intermediary; (2) state that decisions must be free
from political interference or even the appearance of such
interference; (3) clarify the separation of explicitly religious
activities from activities funded with direct Federal financial
assistance and defining explicitly religious activities; (4) clarify
the responsibilities of intermediary organizations; (5) add new
beneficiary protections, and (6) amend existing language in Sec. 5.109
to include Executive Order 13559 changes.
This proposed rule also proposes to remove duplicate faith-based
regulations in 24 CFR parts 92, 570, 574, 576, 578, 582, 583, and 1003,
and replaces them with cross-references to a uniform regulation at
Sec. 5.109.
B. Specific Proposed Amendments
1. New Definitions
This proposed rule adds a new paragraph (b) to Sec. 5.109
providing definitions for direct Federal financial assistance, Federal
financial assistance, indirect Federal financial assistance, and an
intermediary, meaning one that accepts and distributes Federal
financial assistance.
Executive Order 13559 noted that new regulations should distinguish
between ``direct'' and ``indirect'' Federal financial assistance
because the limitation on explicitly religious activities applies to
programs that are supported with ``direct'' Federal financial
assistance but does not apply to programs supported with ``indirect''
Federal financial assistance. To clarify this distinction, the proposed
rule provides definitions of these terms.
Programs are supported with ``direct'' Federal financial assistance
when either the Federal Government or an intermediary, as identified in
this proposed rule, selects a service provider and either purchases
services from that provider (i.e., through a contract) or awards funds
to that provider to carry out an activity (e.g., through a grant, sub-
grant, sub-award, or cooperative agreement). Under these circumstances,
there are no intervening steps in which the beneficiary's choice
determines the provider's identity, the beneficiary being the end user
of the service, product, or assistance.
``Indirect'' Federal financial assistance is distinguishable
because it places the choice of service provider in the hands of a
beneficiary before the Federal Government pays for the cost of that
service through a voucher, certificate, or other similar means. For
example, the Federal Government could choose to allow the beneficiary
to secure the needed service on their own. Alternatively, a
governmental agency, operating under a program of aid that has at least
one secular provider, could present each beneficiary or prospective
beneficiary with a list of all qualified providers from which the
beneficiary could obtain services using a Government-provided
certificate. Either way, the Government empowers the beneficiaries to
choose for themselves whether to receive the needed services, including
those that contain explicitly religious activities, through a faith-
based or other neighborhood organization. The Federal Government could
then pay for the beneficiary's choice of provider by giving the
beneficiary a voucher or similar document. Alternatively, the Federal
Government could choose to pay the provider directly after asking the
beneficiary to indicate the beneficiary's choice.\10\ An example would
be the Housing Choice Voucher Program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ See Freedom From Religion Found. v. McCallum, 324 F.3d 880,
882 (7th Cir. 2003).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Supreme Court has held that if a program meets certain
criteria, the Government may fund the program if, among other things,
the program places the benefit in the hands of individuals, who, in
turn, have the freedom to choose the provider from which they receive
their benefit and ``spend'' the Government funds, whether that provider
is public or private, non-religious or religious. See Zelman v.
Simmons-Harris, 536 U.S. 639, 652-53 (2002). In these instances, the
Government does not encourage or promote any explicitly religious
programs that may be among the options available to beneficiaries.
Notably, the voucher scheme at issue in the Zelman decision, which was
described by the Court as one of ``true private choice'' \11\ was also
neutral toward religion and offered beneficiaries adequate secular
options. This type of Federal financial assistance is considered
``indirect.'' Accordingly, these criteria also are included in the text
of the proposed definition of ``indirect Federal financial
assistance.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ Zelman. at 653.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HUD also adds the definition of ``Federal financial assistance''
from Executive Order 13279 to clarify the new definitions ``direct
Federal financial assistance'' and ``indirect Federal financial
assistance.''
HUD also proposes a definition for intermediary. An intermediary is
an entity, including a nongovernmental organization, acting under a
contract, grant, or other agreement with the Federal Government or with
a State, tribal or local government that accepts Federal financial
assistance and distributes that assistance to other organizations that,
in turn, provide Government-funded services. This definition clarifies
the application of these requirements to recipients of Federal
financial assistance from HUD that are classified as intermediaries.
2. Decisions Must Be Free From Political Interference
This proposed rule adds to the existing paragraph (b) of Sec.
5.109, redesignated as paragraph (c) under the proposed rule, that
decisions about awards of Federal financial assistance must be free
from political interference or even the appearance of such interference
and must be made on the basis of merit, not on the basis of religion or
religious belief. To comply with this requirement, entities that award
Federal financial assistance (HUD or an intermediary) should instruct
participants in the awarding process to refrain from taking religious
affiliations or non-religious affiliations into account in the process
of awarding or allocating funds; i.e., an organization should not
receive favorable or unfavorable marks merely because it is affiliated
or unaffiliated with a religious body, or
[[Page 47305]]
related or unrelated to a specific religion. In addition, when
selecting peer reviewers, entities that award Federal financial
assistance should never ask about religious affiliation or take such
matters into account, but should encourage religious, political, and
professional diversity among peer reviewers by advertising for these
positions in a wide variety of venues.
3. Separation of Explicitly Religious Activities From Activities Funded
With Direct Federal Financial Assistance and Definition of Explicitly
Religious Activities
This proposed rule would amend paragraphs (c) and (d) in Sec.
5.109, redesignated as paragraphs (d) and (e) under this proposed rule,
to clarify the requirement that activities supported by direct Federal
financial assistance must be separate from explicitly religious
activities; define ``explicitly religious activities;'' and replace the
term ``inherently religious activities'' with the term ``explicitly
religious activities.''
Executive Order 13559 makes clear that all organizations that
receive Federal financial assistance are prohibited from discriminating
against beneficiaries or potential beneficiaries of Federal programs on
the basis of religion, a religious belief, refusal to hold a religious
belief, or a refusal to attend or participate in a religious practice.
Executive Order 13559 also states that organizations offering
explicitly religious activities (including activities that involve
overt religious content such as worship, religious instruction, or
proselytization) must not use direct Federal financial assistance to
subsidize or support those activities, and that any explicitly
religious activities must be offered outside of programs that are
supported with direct Federal financial assistance (including through
prime awards or sub-awards). In other words, to the extent that an
organization provides explicitly religious activities, those activities
must be offered separately, in time or location, from programs or
services supported with direct Federal financial assistance.
HUD's existing regulations and Executive Order 13279 prohibit
nongovernmental organizations from using direct Federal financial
assistance (e.g., government grants, contracts, sub-grants, sub-awards,
and subcontracts) for ``inherently religious activities, such as
worship, religious instruction, and proselytization.'' The term
``inherently religious,'' however, has proven confusing. In 2006, for
example, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that,
although all 26 of the religious social service providers it
interviewed said they understood the prohibition on using direct
Federal financial assistance for ``inherently religious activities,''
four of the providers described acting in ways that appeared to violate
that rule.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ GAO, Faith-Based and Community Initiative: Improvements in
Monitoring Grantees and Measuring Performance Could Enhance
Accountability, GAO-06-616, at 34-35 (June 2006) (available at
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d06616.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, though the Supreme Court has sometimes used the term
``inherently religious,'' the Court has not used this term to indicate
the boundary of what the Government may subsidize with direct Federal
financial assistance. If the term is interpreted narrowly, it could
permit actions that the Constitution prohibits. On the other hand, one
could also argue that the term ``inherently religious'' is too broad
rather than too narrow. For example, some might consider their
provision of a hot meal to a needy person to be an ``inherently
religious'' act when it is undertaken from a sense of religious
motivation or obligation, even though it has no overt religious
content.
The Court has determined that the Government cannot subsidize ``a
specifically religious activity in an otherwise substantially secular
setting.'' \13\ The Court has also said a direct aid program
impermissibly advances religion when the aid results in governmental
indoctrination of religion.\14\ This terminology is fairly interpreted
to prohibit the Government from directly subsidizing any ``explicitly
religious activity,'' including activities that involve overt religious
content. Thus, direct Federal financial assistance must not be used to
pay for activities such as religious instruction, devotional exercises,
worship, proselytizing or evangelism; production or dissemination of
devotional guides or other religious materials; or counseling in which
counselors introduce religious content. Similarly, direct Federal
financial assistance may not be used to pay for equipment or supplies
to the extent they are allocated to such activities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\ Hunt v. McNair, 413 U.S. 734, 743 (1973).
\14\ See Mitchell v. Helms, 530 U.S. 793, 808 (2000) (Thomas,
J., joined by Rehnquist, C.J., Scalia, and Kennedy, JJ., plurality);
Helms, at 845 (O'Connor, J., joined by Breyer, J., concurring in the
judgment); Agostini v. Felton, 521 U.S. 203, 223 (1997).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HUD provides the following activities as examples of permissible
use of funds, but anticipates that such activities would generally not
apply to HUD programs. Activities that are secular in content, such as
serving meals to the needy or using a nonreligious text to teach
someone to read, are not considered ``explicitly religious activities''
merely because the provider is religiously motivated to provide those
services. The study or acknowledgement of religion as a historical or
cultural reality also would not be considered an explicitly religious
activity. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the use of direct
Federal financial assistance to support explicitly religious
activities, there are rare instances when religious activities may be
Federally financed under the Establishment Clause and not subject to
the direct Federal financial assistance restrictions; for instance, in
situations where Federal financial assistance is provided to chaplains
to work with inmates in prisons, detention facilities, or community
correction centers through social service programs.\15\ Since such
activities have only been recognized in correctional settings, they
would likely not arise in HUD-funded programs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ Where there is extensive Government control over the
environment of the Federally financed social service program,
program officials may sometimes need to take affirmative steps to
provide an opportunity for beneficiaries of the social service
program to exercise their religion. See Cruz v. Beto, 405 U.S. 319,
322 n.2 (1972) (per curiam) (``reasonable opportunities must be
afforded to all prisoners to exercise the religious freedom
guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth Amendment without fear of
penalty''); Katcoff v. Marsh, 755 F.2d 223, 234 (2d Cir. 1985)
(finding it ``readily apparent'' that the Government is obligated by
the First Amendment ``to make religion available to soldiers who
have been moved by the Army to areas of the world where religion of
their own denominations is not available to them''). Without such
efforts, religious freedom might not exist for these beneficiaries.
Accordingly, services such as chaplaincy services would not be
considered explicitly religious activities that are subject to
direct financial aid restrictions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is important to emphasize that the restrictions on explicitly
religious content apply to content generated by the administrators of
the program receiving direct Federal financial assistance, not to
spontaneous comments made by individual beneficiaries about their
personal lives in the context of these programs. For example, if a
person administering a federally funded job skills program asks
beneficiaries to describe how they gain the motivation necessary for
their job searches and some beneficiaries refer to their faith or
membership in a faith community, these kinds of comments do not violate
the restrictions and should not be censored. In this context, it is
clear that the administrator of the Government-funded program did not
orchestrate or encourage such comments.
HUD, therefore, proposes to replace the term ``inherently religious
activities'' with the term ``explicitly
[[Page 47306]]
religious activities'' and define the latter term as ``including
activities that involve overt religious content such as worship,
religious instruction, or proselytization.'' These changes in language
will provide greater clarity and more closely match constitutional
standards as they have been developed in case law.
These restrictions would not diminish existing regulatory
protections for the religious identity of faith-based providers. The
proposed rule would not affect, for example, organizations' ability to
use religious terms in their organizational names, select board members
on a religious basis, include religious references in mission
statements and other organizational documents, and post religious art,
messages, scriptures and symbols in buildings where Federal financial
assistance is delivered.
4. Responsibilities of Intermediary Organizations
HUD also proposes to add a new paragraph (f) to Sec. 5.109 to
clarify the responsibilities of intermediaries, which may include
States, tribes, or units of local governments. Each intermediary must
abide by all statutory and regulatory requirements by, for example,
providing any services supported with direct Federal financial
assistance in a religiously neutral manner that does not include
explicitly religious activities. The intermediary also has the same
duties as the Federal Government to comply with these rules by, for
example, selecting any providers to receive Federal financial
assistance in a manner that does not favor or disfavor organizations on
the basis of religion or religious belief. While intermediaries may be
used to distribute Federal financial assistance to other organizations
in some programs, intermediaries remain accountable for the Federal
financial assistance they disburse. Accordingly, intermediaries must
ensure that any providers to which they disburse Federal financial
assistance also comply with these rules; for example, through funding
contracts or agreements. If the intermediary is a nongovernmental
organization, it retains all other rights of a nongovernmental
organization under the statutory and regulatory provisions governing
the program.
A State's use of intermediaries does not relieve the State of its
traditional responsibility to effectively monitor the actions of such
organizations. States are obligated to manage the day-to-day operations
of grant- and sub-grant-supported activities to ensure compliance with
applicable Federal requirements and performance goals. Moreover, a
State's use of intermediaries does not relieve the State of its
responsibility to ensure that providers are selected, and deliver
services, in a manner consistent with the First Amendment's
Establishment Clause.
5. New Beneficiary Protections
This rule proposes to add a new paragraph (g) to Sec. 5.109
implementing a variety of valuable protections for the religious
liberty rights of beneficiaries. These protections are aimed at
ensuring that Federal financial assistance is not used to coerce or
pressure beneficiaries along religious lines, and to make beneficiaries
aware of their rights, through appropriate notice, when potentially
obtaining services from providers with a religious affiliation.
Executive Order 13559 requires that faith-based organizations
providing services under a program that is supported by direct Federal
financial assistance give written notice in a manner prescribed by the
agency to beneficiaries and prospective beneficiaries of their right to
be referred to an alternative provider if they object to the
organization's religious character, when available. Written notice
should be provided prior to enrollment or receipt of services. However,
when the nature of the service provided or exigent circumstances make
it impracticable to provide such written notice in advance of the
actual service, service providers must advise beneficiaries in writing
of their protections at the earliest available opportunity. A sample
notification of beneficiary rights is attached in appendix A for public
comment.
If a beneficiary or prospective beneficiary of a social service
program supported by Federal financial assistance objects to the
religious character of an organization that provides services under the
program, the organization must attempt to refer the beneficiary to an
alternative provider. More specifically, the proposed rule provides
that, if a beneficiary or prospective beneficiary of a program
supported by direct Federal financial assistance objects to the
religious character of an organization that provides services under the
program, that organization shall promptly undertake reasonable efforts
to identify and refer the beneficiary to an alternative provider to
which the prospective beneficiary has no objection. HUD will provide
further guidance regarding the referral requirement.
A referral may be made to another religiously affiliated provider,
if the beneficiary has no objection to that provider. But if the
beneficiary requests a secular provider, and a secular provider that
offers the needed services is available, then a referral must be made
to that provider. The proposed rule specifies that, except for services
provided by telephone, Internet, or similar means, the referral would
be to an alternative provider that is in reasonable geographic
proximity to the organization making the referral and that offers
services that are similar in substance and quality to those offered by
the referring organization. The alternative provider also would need to
have the capacity to accept additional clients. If a Federally
supported alternative provider meets these requirements and is
acceptable to the beneficiary, a referral should be made to that
provider. If, however, there is no Federally supported alternative
provider that meets these requirements and is acceptable to the
beneficiary, a referral should be made to an alternative provider that
does not receive Federal financial assistance but does meet these
requirements and is acceptable to the beneficiary. In the case of a
referral, the organization should follow up with the beneficiary, if
the beneficiary provides contact information, or the organization to
which the beneficiary has been referred unless the beneficiary opts out
of follow up. Under no circumstances, however, may an organization
violate privacy laws in following up on a beneficiary referral.
If an organization is unable to identify an alternative provider,
the organization is required under the proposed rule to notify HUD or
the intermediary, if applicable, and that entity would determine
whether there is any other suitable alternative provider to which the
beneficiary may be referred. Further, the Executive order and the
proposed rule require that HUD or the intermediary ensure that
appropriate and timely referrals are made to an appropriate provider,
and that referrals are made in a manner consistent with applicable
privacy laws and regulations. It must be noted that in some instances
that HUD or the intermediary may also be unable to identify a suitable
alternative provider. In all instances, the organization must maintain
records of all requests for referrals, referrals made, and attempts to
make a referral. HUD will issue guidance to clarify what constitutes
reasonable efforts to identify an alternative provider.
6. Amending Existing Sec. 5.109 To Include Executive Order 13559
Changes
HUD also proposes to amend the other paragraphs in Sec. 5.109 to
include the new Executive Order 13559
[[Page 47307]]
principles and to make clarifying changes, including the replacement of
the terms religious organizations with faith-based organization and
``inherently religious'' with ``explicitly religious;'' adding the term
``direct Federal financial assistance'' where appropriate; and
clarifying that the regulations apply to all HUD programs, including
all of HUD's Native American programs.
In addition, HUD proposes to replace the current reference to 24
CFR parts 84 and 85 with a reference to 2 CFR part 200 in new paragraph
(j) of this proposed rule. The Federal Government-wide regulations
governing real property disposition at 24 CFR 84 and 85 have been
replaced by the new provision at 2 CFR part 200 for awards made on or
after December 26, 2014. When program-specific regulations governing
real property disposition conflict with the real property disposition
regulations in 2 CFR part 200, the HUD program office will provide
guidance on recipients' (or subrecipients') compliance
responsibilities.
III. Tribal Consultation
HUD's policy is to consult with Indian tribes early in the process
on matters that have tribal implications. Accordingly, on November 19,
2014, HUD sent letters to all tribal leaders participating in HUD
programs, informing them of the nature of this forthcoming rulemaking.
HUD received no comments in response to those letters. Tribal leaders
are welcome to provide public comments on this proposed rule.
IV. Findings and Certifications
Regulatory Review--Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
Executive Orders 12866 and 13563 direct agencies to assess all
costs and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, if
regulation is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize
net benefits (including potential economic, environmental, public
health, and safety effects; distributive impacts; and equity).
Executive Order 13563 emphasizes the importance of quantifying both
costs and benefits, of reducing costs, of harmonizing rules, and of
promoting flexibility. Under Executive Order 12866 (Regulatory Planning
and Review), a determination must be made whether a regulatory action
is significant and, therefore, subject to review by OMB in accordance
with the requirements of the order. This proposed rule meets the
principles of Executive Order 13563 in that its implementation of
Executive Order 13559 harmonizes HUD's proposed regulations with those
of the other Federal agencies, but does not rise to the level of
significant regulatory action as defined in Executive Order 12866. This
proposed rule clarifies existing principles and policies applicable to
faith-based and neighborhood organizations participating in Federally
funded programs. In addition, this proposed rule underwent extensive
review by the Office of Faith-Based Neighborhood Partnerships and the
Working Group.
With respect to the principles of Executive Order 13563, this
proposed rule, as discussed above, would further provide for the equal
participation of faith-based organizations in HUD's programs, and
clarify the rights of entities participating in HUD programs and the
beneficiaries they serve. This proposed rule would also add the
following provisions that HUD believes will likely impose costs on the
regulated community: (1) That faith-based organizations that carry out
an activity with direct Federal financial assistance from HUD must give
beneficiaries and prospective beneficiaries written notice of the
protections listed at Sec. 5.109(g)(1) of this proposed rule, and (2)
that if a beneficiary or prospective beneficiary objects to the
religious character of the organization, the organization must make
reasonable efforts to identify and refer the beneficiary or prospective
beneficiary to an alternative provider to which the beneficiary or
prospective beneficiary has no objection. To minimize compliance costs
on these recipients, this proposed rule includes a sample written
notice that a faith-based organization can provide to a beneficiary or
prospective beneficiary. An estimate of the cost of providing this
notice is discussed in the Paperwork Reduction Act section of this
proposed rule.
Environmental Impact
This proposed rule sets forth nondiscrimination standards.
Accordingly, under 24 CFR 50.19(c)(3), this proposed rule is
categorically excluded from environmental review under the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321).
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1531-1538)
(UMRA) establishes requirements for Federal agencies to assess the
effects of their regulatory actions on State, local, and tribal
governments and on the private sector. This proposed rule does not
impose a Federal mandate on any State, local, or tribal government, or
on the private sector, within the meaning of UMRA.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) generally
requires an agency to conduct a regulatory flexibility analysis of any
rule subject to notice and comment rulemaking requirements, unless the
agency certifies that the rule will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities.
This proposed rule would provide more access for entities to
participate in HUD programs by clarifying requirements for
participation in HUD programs. In addition, the proposed rule requires
that faith-based organizations that carry out activities under a HUD
program with direct Federal financial assistance must give
beneficiaries and prospective beneficiaries written notice of the
protections listed at Sec. 5.109(g)(1) of this proposed rule. This
includes notification that the organization must undertake reasonable
efforts to identify and refer the beneficiary to an alternative
provider to which the beneficiary has no objection, if the beneficiary
objects to the religious character of the organization. The
organization must inform the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary in
writing and, if a referral is made, the organization would be required
to notify HUD or the intermediary.
As described above, HUD has made every effort to ensure that the
written notice and referral requirements of the proposed rule impose
minimum burden and allow maximum flexibility in implementation by
providing a sample notice that organizations may provide to
beneficiaries informing them of the protections listed at Sec.
5.109(g)(1) of this proposed rule and by not prescribing a specific
format for making referrals through this proposed rule. HUD estimates
it will take no more than 2 hours for service providers to familiarize
themselves with the notice requirements of this proposed rule and print
and duplicate an adequate number of written notices for prospective
beneficiaries. Using the May 2013 Bureau of Labor Statistics hourly
mean wage of $22.81 for a Training and Development Specialist, the
labor cost is approximately $45.62 per service provider for preparing
the notice. In addition, HUD estimates an upper limit of $100 for the
annual cost of materials (paper, ink, toner) to print multiple copies
of the notices. Because these costs will be borne by every faith-based
organization that carries out an activity under a HUD program with
direct
[[Page 47308]]
Federal financial assistance, HUD believes that a substantial number of
small entities will be affected by this provision. However, HUD does
not believe that a compliance cost of less than $200 per service
provider per year is a significant percentage of any service provider's
total revenue. In addition, HUD notes that, after the first year, the
labor costs associated with compliance will likely decrease
significantly because small service providers will be familiar with the
requirements.
In addition, HUD does not foresee that the cost to comply with
effective communication requirements pursuant to Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and its implementing regulations at 24 CFR
8.6 will exceed the estimated cost of $200 per service provider.
However, HUD specifically invites comments on whether there would be
additional costs to make this accommodation.
The rule will also require faith-based organizations, upon a
beneficiary's objection, to make reasonable efforts to identify and
refer the beneficiary to an alternative provider to which the
beneficiary has no objection. HUD estimates that each referral will
require 2 hours of a Training and Development Specialist's time to
process at a labor cost of $22.81 per hour. Although HUD does not have
any way to determine the number of referrals that will occur in any 1
year, HUD does not believe that referral costs will be significant for
small service providers. HUD invites interested parties to provide data
on which HUD can formulate better estimates of the compliance costs
associated with the written notice and referral requirements of this
proposed rule.
Notwithstanding HUD's determination that this proposed rule would
not have a significant effect on a substantial number of small
entities, HUD specifically invites comments regarding any less
burdensome alternatives to this rule that will meet HUD's objectives
and the principles in Executive Order 13559, as described in this
preamble.
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled ``Federalism'') prohibits an agency
from publishing any rule that has federalism implications if the rule
either: (1) Imposes substantial direct compliance costs on State and
local governments and is not required by statute, or (2) preempts State
law, unless the agency meets the consultation and funding requirements
of section 6 of the Executive order. This proposed rule does not have
federalism implications and does not impose substantial direct
compliance costs on State and local governments nor preempt State law
within the meaning of the Executive order.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The proposed rule includes a new information collection section.
Section 5.109(g) would impose requirements on faith-based organizations
that carry out activities under a HUD program with direct Federal
financial assistance to give beneficiaries (or prospective
beneficiaries) written notice of certain protections described in this
proposed rule; beneficiaries can provide a written response that may
impose a burden under the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA); and faith-
based organizations must provide a referral if a beneficiary or
prospective beneficiary objects to the religious character of the
organization. This rule also requires the retention of records to show
that the referral requirements in this rulemaking have been met.
HUD estimates that a faith-based organization would need 2 minutes
to distribute to each beneficiary the notice required in these proposed
regulations. This estimate takes into consideration the likelihood
that, in one-on-one interactions between a staff member and a
beneficiary, providing the notice might take longer than a minute.
Conversely, providing notice to a group of beneficiaries at the same
time would take significantly less than a minute for each beneficiary
because a few beneficiaries would pass the notice to the remaining
beneficiaries in a group.
HUD estimates that in cases where a beneficiary objects to the
religious character of a faith-based organization, the time required
for the faith-based organization to make a reasonable effort to
identify an alternative provider and refer a beneficiary to that
provider would be about 2 hours. This estimate includes the time
required to identify service providers that provide similar services,
preferably under the same or similar programs to the one under which
the beneficiary is being served by the faith-based organization. The
estimate also includes the time required to determine whether one of
the alternative providers is acceptable to the beneficiary. Also,
depending on whether the beneficiary asked the faith-based organization
to follow up either with the beneficiary or the alternative service
provider to determine whether the referral is successful, this estimate
includes the time required to do the follow-up.
The Department of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and
Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), implemented a similar
referral requirement in its 2003 final rule, Charitable Choice
Regulations Applicable to States Receiving Substance Abuse Prevention
and Treatment Block Grants, Projects for Assistance in Transition From
Homelessness Formula Grants, and to Public and Private Providers
Receiving Discretionary Grant Funding From SAMHSA for the Provision of
Substance Abuse Services Providing for Equal Treatment of SAMHSA
Program Participants (SAMHSA Program Rule), 68 FR 56430. Since SAMHSA
implemented the referral requirement, the SAMHSA program office has
received no reports of requests for an alternative provider. Because
faith-based organizations are required to provide a written
notification of the beneficiary's rights under this proposed rule,
requests for referrals may be more likely. However, given SAMHSA's
experience, HUD estimates that 0.10 percent of beneficiaries and
potential beneficiaries would request referrals to alternative
providers. HUD will monitor its programs to assess whether this
estimate is accurate.
HUD is not estimating the burden of maintaining the records needed
to demonstrate compliance with the requirements imposed on faith-based
organizations. HUD has recordkeeping requirements included in
information collection instruments for HUD programs. Those collection
instruments cover burdens imposed by program and administrative
requirements that exist under current, OMB-approved, information
collection instruments and each of those collections has an OMB-
assigned information collection control number.
The recordkeeping burden that this proposed rule would add to those
program-specific information collection instruments is so small that,
under most programs, it would not measurably increase the burden that
already exists under current program and administrative requirements.
If, due to the unique nature of a particular program, the recordkeeping
burden associated with these proposed regulations is large enough to be
measurable, that burden will be calculated under the recordkeeping and
reporting requirements of the affected program and identified in
information collection requests that are submitted to OMB for PRA
approval. Therefore, we have not included any estimate of recordkeeping
burden in this PRA analysis.
The new information collection requirements contained in this
proposed
[[Page 47309]]
rule have been submitted to OMB under the Paperwork Reduction Act of
1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501-3520). In accordance with the Paperwork Reduction
Act, an agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required
to respond to, a collection of information unless the collection
displays a currently valid OMB control number.
The burden of the information collections in this proposed rule is
estimated as follows:
Reporting and Recordkeeping Burden
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Number of respondents in covered programs Estimated Estimated
24 CFR Section ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Number of average annual burden
CPD FHEO Housing OLHCHH PD&R PIH responses response time (in hours)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.109(g) (Written Notice of 196,487 400 30,400 250 3,141 495,375 1 per 2 minutes per 24,202
Rights). beneficiary. beneficiary.
5.109(g) (Referral).......... 198 1 30 1 3 495 1 per 2 hours per 1,456
beneficiary. beneficiary.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Burden (for all HUD ......... ......... ......... .............. ......... ......... ................ ............... 25,658
programs covered by this
rulemaking).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In accordance with 5 CFR 1320.8(d)(1), HUD is soliciting comments
from members of the public and affected agencies concerning this
collection of information to:
(1) Evaluate whether the proposed collection of information is
necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the agency,
including whether the information will have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of the agency's estimate of the burden of
the proposed collection of information;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to
be collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the collection of information on those
who are to respond, including through the use of appropriate automated
collection techniques or other forms of information technology; for
example, permitting electronic submission of responses.
Interested persons are invited to submit comments regarding the
information collection requirements in this rule. Comments must refer
to the proposed rule by name and docket number (FR-5781-P-01) and must
be sent to: HUD Desk Officer, Office of Information and Regulatory
Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, New Executive Office
Building, Washington, DC 20503, Email: [email protected],
Fax: 202-395-6947 and
Colette Pollard, Reports Liaison Officer, Department of Housing and
Urban Development, 451 Seventh Street SW., Room 2204, Washington, DC
20410-7000.
Interested persons may submit comments regarding the information
collection requirements electronically through the Federal eRulemaking
Portal at http://www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly encourages
commenters to submit comments electronically. Electronic submission of
comments allows the commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a
comment, ensures timely receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to make them
immediately available to the public. Comments submitted electronically
through the http://www.regulations.gov Web site can be viewed by other
commenters and interested members of the public. Commenters should
follow the instructions provided on that site to submit comments
electronically.
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance
The regulatory amendments contained in this proposed rule apply to
all HUD assistance programs for which faith-based organizations are
eligible to participate. The Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance
(CFDA) number for a particular HUD program may be found on the CFDA Web
site at: http://www.cfda.gov.
List of Subjects
24 CFR Part 5
Administrative practice and procedure, Aged, Claims, Crime,
Government contracts, Grant programs-housing and community development,
Individuals with disabilities, Intergovernmental relations, Loan
programs-housing and community development, Low and moderate income
housing, Mortgage insurance, Penalties, Pets, Public housing, Rent
subsidies, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Social security,
Unemployment compensation, Wages.
24 CFR Part 92
Administrative practice and procedure, Grant programs-housing and
community development, Low and moderate income housing, Manufactured
housing, Rent subsidies, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 570
Administrative practice and procedure, American Samoa, Community
development block grants, Grant programs-education, Grant programs-
housing and community development, Guam, Indians, Loan programs-housing
and community development, Low and moderate income housing, Northern
Mariana Islands, Pacific Island Trust Territory, Puerto Rico, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements, Student aid, Virgin Islands.
24 CFR Part 574
Community facilities, Grant programs-housing and community
development, Grant programs-social programs, HIV/AIDS, Low and moderate
income housing, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 576
Community facilities, Grant programs-housing and community
development, Grant programs-social programs, Homeless, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 578
Community facilities, Continuum of Care, Emergency solutions
grants, Grant programs-housing and community development, Grant
programs-social programs, Homeless, Rural housing, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements, Supportive housing programs- housing and
community development, Supportive services.
24 CFR Part 582
Civil rights, Community facilities, Grant programs-housing and
community development, Grant programs-social
[[Page 47310]]
programs, Homeless, Individuals with disabilities, Mental health
programs, Nonprofit organizations, Rental subsidies, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 583
Civil rights, Community facilities, Employment, Grant programs-
housing and community development, Grant programs-social programs,
Homeless, Indians, Individuals with disabilities, Mental health
programs, Nonprofit organizations, Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Technical assistance.
24 CFR Part 1003
Alaska, Community development block grants, Grant programs-housing
and community development, Grant programs- Indians, Indians, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
Accordingly, for the reasons described in the preamble, HUD
proposes to amend 24 CFR parts 5, 92, 570, 574, 576, 578, 582, 583 and
1003 as follows:
PART 5--GENERAL HUD PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS; WAIVERS
0
1. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 5 is revised to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 1437a, 1437c, 1437f, 1437n, 3535(d), Sec.
327, Pub. L. 109-115, 119 Stat. 2936, Sec. 607, Pub. L. 109-162, 119
Stat. 3051, E.O. 13279, 67 FR 77141, 3 CFR, 2002 Comp., p. 258, and
E.O. 13559, 75 FR 71319, 3 CFR, 2010 Comp., p. 273.
0
2. In Sec. 5.109:
0
a. The section heading is revised;
0
b. Paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d), (f), (g), and (h) are revised;
0
c. Paragraph (e) is redesignated as paragraph (i);
0
d. New paragraph (e) is added; and
0
e. Paragraphs (j) and (k) are added, to read as follows:
Sec. 5.109 Equal participation of Faith-based Organizations in HUD
programs.
(a) Purpose. Consistent with Executive Order 13279 (issued on
December 12, 2002, 67 FR 77141), entitled ``Equal Protection of the
Laws for Faith-Based and Community Organizations,'' as amended by
Executive Order 13559 (issued on November 17, 2010, 75 FR 71319),
entitled ``Fundamental Principles and Policymaking Criteria for
Partnerships With Faith-Based and Other Neighborhood Organizations,''
this section describes requirements for ensuring the equal
participation of faith-based organizations in HUD programs. These
requirements apply to all HUD programs, including all of HUD's Native
American Programs, except as may be otherwise noted in the respective
program regulations in title 24 of the Code of Federal Regulations
(CFR), or unless inconsistent with certain HUD programs authorizing
statutes.
(b) Definitions. The following definitions apply to this section:
Direct Federal financial assistance means Federal financial
assistance provided when a Federal Government agency or an
intermediary, as defined in this section, selects the provider and
either purchases services from that provider (i.e., via a contract) or
awards funds to that provider to carry out an activity (e.g., via
grant, sub-grant, sub-award, or cooperative agreement). The recipients
of sub-grants or sub-awards that receive Federal financial assistance
through State-administered programs (e.g., flow-through programs) are
considered recipients of direct Federal financial assistance. In
general, Federal financial assistance shall be treated as direct,
unless it meets the definition of indirect Federal financial
assistance.
Federal financial assistance means assistance that non-Federal
entities receive or administer in the forms of grants, contracts,
loans, loan guarantees, property, cooperative agreements, food
commodities, direct appropriations, or other assistance, but does not
include a tax credit, deduction, or exemption.
Indirect Federal financial assistance means Federal financial
assistance provided when the choice of the service provider is placed
in the hands of the beneficiary, and the cost of that service is paid
through a voucher, certificate, or other similar means of Government-
funded payment. Federal financial assistance provided to an
organization is considered indirect when the Government program through
which the beneficiary receives the voucher, certificate, or other
similar means of Government-funded payment is neutral toward religion;
the organization receives the assistance as a result of a decision of
the beneficiary, not a decision of the Government; and the beneficiary
has at least one adequate secular option for the use of the voucher,
certificate, or other similar means of Government-funded payment.
Intermediary means an entity, including a nongovernmental
organization, acting under a contract, grant, or other agreement with
the Federal Government or with a State, tribal or local government,
that accepts Federal financial assistance and distributes that
assistance to other entities that, in turn, carry out activities under
HUD programs.
(c) Equal participation of faith-based organizations in HUD
programs. Faith-based organizations are eligible, on the same basis as
any other organization, to participate in HUD programs. Neither the
Federal Government, nor a State, tribal or local government, nor any
other entity that administers any HUD program, shall discriminate
against an organization on the basis of the organization's religious
character or affiliation. In addition, decisions about awards of
Federal financial assistance must be free from political interference
or even the appearance of such interference and must be made on the
basis of merit, not on the basis of religion or religious belief.
(d) Separation of explicitly religious activities from direct
Federal financial assistance.
(1) A faith-based organization that applies for, or participates
in, a HUD program supported with Federal financial assistance retains
its independence and may continue to carry out its mission, including
the definition, development, practice, and expression of its religious
beliefs, provided that it does not use direct Federal financial
assistance that it receives (e.g., via contract, grant, sub-grant or
sub-award or cooperative agreement) to support or engage in any
explicitly religious activities (including activities that involve
overt religious content such as worship, religious instruction, or
proselytization), or in any other manner prohibited by law.
(2) A faith-based organization that receives direct Federal
financial assistance may use space (including a sanctuary, chapel,
prayer hall, or other space) in its facilities (including a temple,
synagogue, church, mosque, or other place of worship) to carry out
activities under a HUD program without removing religious art, icons,
scriptures, or other religious symbols. In addition, a faith-based
organization participating in a HUD program retains its authority over
its internal governance, and may retain religious terms in its
organization's name, select its board members on a religious basis, and
include religious references in its organization's mission statements
and other governing documents.
(e) Explicitly religious activities. If an organization engages in
explicitly religious activities (including activities that involve
overt religious content such as worship, religious instruction, or
proselytization), the explicitly religious activities must be offered
separately, in time or location, from the activities supported by
direct Federal financial assistance and participation must be voluntary
for the beneficiaries of the activities that receive direct Federal
financial assistance.
[[Page 47311]]
(f) Intermediary responsibilities to ensure equal participation of
faith-based organizations in HUD programs. If an intermediary--acting
under a contract, grant, or other agreement with the Federal Government
or with a State, tribal or local government that is administering a
program supported by Federal financial assistance--is given the
authority to select a nongovernmental organization to receive Federal
financial assistance under a contract, grant, sub-grant, sub-award, or
cooperative agreement, the intermediary must ensure that such
organization complies with the requirements of this section. If the
intermediary is a nongovernmental organization, it retains all other
rights of a nongovernmental organization under the program's statutory
and regulatory provisions.
(g) Beneficiary protections. Faith-based organizations that receive
direct Federal financial assistance to carry out activities under a HUD
program must give written notice to beneficiaries and prospective
beneficiaries of the program describing certain protections available
to them, as provided in this subsection. In addition, if a beneficiary
or prospective beneficiary objects to the religious character of the
organization carrying out activities under the HUD program, that
organization must promptly undertake reasonable efforts to identify and
refer the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary to an alternative
provider to which the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary has no
such objection.
(1) Written notice. The written notice must be given in a manner
prescribed by HUD, and state that:
(i) The organization may not discriminate against beneficiaries on
the basis of religion or religious belief;
(ii) The organization may not require beneficiaries to attend or
participate in any explicitly religious activities that are offered by
the organization, and any participation by beneficiaries in such
activities must be purely voluntary;
(iii) The organization must separate, in time or location, any
privately funded explicitly religious activities from activities
supported by direct Federal financial assistance;
(iv) If a beneficiary objects to the religious character of the
organization, the organization must undertake reasonable efforts to
identify and refer the beneficiary to an alternative provider to which
the beneficiary has no such objection; and
(v) Beneficiaries may report violations of these protections to HUD
(or the intermediary, if applicable).
(2) Timing of notice. The written notice must be given to
prospective beneficiaries prior to the time they enroll in the program
or receive services from such programs. When the nature of the service
provided or exigent circumstances make it impracticable to provide such
written notice in advance of the actual service, the organization
providing the services with direct Federal financial assistance must
provide written notice to beneficiaries of their protections at the
earliest available opportunity.
(3) Referral requirements. (i) If a beneficiary or prospective
beneficiary of a program that receives direct Federal financial
assistance from HUD objects to the religious character of an
organization that provides services under the program, that
organization must promptly undertake reasonable efforts to identify and
refer the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary to an alternative
provider to which the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary has no
such objection.
(ii) A referral may be made to another faith-based organization, if
the beneficiary or prospective beneficiary has no objection to that
provider based on the provider's religious character. But if the
beneficiary or prospective beneficiary requests a secular provider, and
a secular provider is available, then a referral must be made to that
provider.
(iii) Except for services provided by telephone, Internet, or
similar means, the referral must be to an alternative provider that is
in reasonable geographic proximity to the organization making the
referral and that offers services that are similar in substance and
quality to those offered by the organization. The alternative provider
also must have the capacity to accept additional clients.
(iv) When the organization makes a referral to an alternative
provider, or when the organization determines that it is unable to
identify an alternative provider, the organization shall notify HUD (or
the intermediary, if applicable). If the organization is unable to
identify an alternative provider, HUD (or the intermediary, if
applicable) shall determine whether there is any other suitable
alternative provider to which the beneficiary or prospective
beneficiary may be referred. An intermediary that receives a request
for assistance in identifying an alternative provider may request
assistance from HUD.
(h) Nondiscrimination requirements. No recipient of Federal
financial assistance may discriminate against a beneficiary or
prospective beneficiary of a HUD program on the basis of religion or
religious belief in carrying out activities with Federal financial
assistance.
* * * * *
(j) Acquisition, construction, and rehabilitation of structures.
Direct Federal financial assistance may be used for the acquisition,
construction, or rehabilitation of structures only to the extent that
those structures are used for conducting eligible activities under a
HUD program. Where a structure is used for both eligible and explicitly
religious activities (including activities that involve overt religious
content such as worship, religious instruction, or proselytization),
direct Federal financial assistance may not exceed the cost of the
share of acquisition, construction, or rehabilitation attributable to
eligible activities in accordance with the cost accounting requirements
applicable to the HUD program. However, acquisition, construction, or
rehabilitation of sanctuaries, chapels, or other rooms that a HUD-
funded faith-based organization uses as its principal place of worship,
may not be paid with direct Federal financial assistance. Disposition
of real property after use for the authorized purpose, or any change in
use of the property from the authorized purpose, is subject to
Governmentwide regulations governing real property disposition (see,
e.g., 2 CFR part 200).
(k) Commingling of Federal and State, tribal, and local funds. If a
State, tribal, or local government voluntarily contributes its own
funds to supplement direct Federal financial assistance for an
activity, the State, tribal or local government has the option to
segregate those funds or commingle them with the direct Federal
financial assistance. However, if the funds are commingled, the
requirements of this section apply to all of the commingled funds.
Further, if a State, tribal, or local government is required to
contribute matching funds to supplement direct Federal financial
assistance for an activity, the matching funds are considered
commingled with the direct Federal financial assistance and, therefore,
subject to the requirements of this section. Some HUD programs'
requirements govern any activity assisted under those programs.
Accordingly, recipients should consult with the appropriate HUD program
office to determine the scope of applicable requirements.
PART 92--HOME INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIPS PROGRAM
0
3. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 92 continues to read as
follows:
[[Page 47312]]
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d) and 12701-12839.
0
4. Revise Sec. 92.257 to read as follows:
Sec. 92.257 Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations.
The HUD program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this subtitle apply
to the HOME program.
PART 570--COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANTS
0
5. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 570 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d) and 5301-5320.
0
6. In Sec. 570.200 revise paragraph (j) to read as follows:
Sec. 570.200 General policies.
* * * * *
(j) Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations. The HUD
program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to the CDBG
program.
PART 574--HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FOR PERSONS WITH AIDS
0
7. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 574 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d) and 12901-12912.
0
8. In Sec. 574.300, revise paragraph (c) to read as follows:
Sec. 574.300 Eligible activities.
* * * * *
(c) Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations. The HUD
program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to the HOPWA
program.
PART 576--EMERGENCY SOLUTIONS GRANTS PROGRAM
0
9. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 576 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq., 42 U.S.C. 3535(d).
0
10. Revise Sec. 576.406 to read as follows:
Sec. 576.406 Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations.
The HUD program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to
the ESG program.
PART 578--CONTINUUM OF CARE PROGRAM
0
11. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 578 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq., 42 U.S.C. 3535(d).
0
12. In Sec. 578.87, revise paragraph (b) to read as follows:
Sec. 578.87 Limitation on use of funds.
* * * * *
(b) Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations. The HUD
program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to the
Continuum of Care program.
* * * * *
PART 582--SHELTER PLUS CARE
0
13. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 582 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d) and 11403-11407b.
0
14. In Sec. 582.115, revise paragraph (c) to read as follows:
Sec. 582.115 Limitations on assistance.
* * * * *
(c) Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations. The HUD
program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to the S+C
program.
* * * * *
PART 583--SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROGRAM
0
15. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 583 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 11389 and 3535(d).
0
16. In Sec. 583.150, revise paragraph (b) to read as follows:
Sec. 583.150 Limitations on use of assistance.
* * * * *
(b) Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations. The HUD
program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to the
Supportive Housing Program.
* * * * *
PART 1003--COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANTS FOR INDIAN TRIBES AND
ALASKA NATIVE VILLAGES
0
17. The authority citation for 24 CFR part 1003 continues to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 3535(d) and 5301 et seq.
0
18. Revise Sec. 1003.600 to read as follows:
Sec. 1003.600 Equal participation of Faith-Based Organizations.
The HUD program requirements in Sec. 5.109 of this title apply to
the ICDBG program.
Dated: May 27, 2015.
Juli[aacute]n Castro,
Secretary.
Note: The following appendix will not appear in the Code of
Federal Regulations.
Appendix A
WRITTEN NOTICE OF BENEFICIARY RIGHTS
Name of Organization:
Name of Program:
Contact Information for Program Staff (name, phone number, and email
address, if appropriate):
Because this program is supported in whole or in part by financial
assistance from the Federal Government, we are required to let you
know that:
We may not discriminate against you on the basis of
religion or religious belief;
We may not require you to attend or participate in any
explicitly religious activities that are offered by us, and any
participation by you in these activities must be purely voluntary;
We must separate, in time or location, any privately funded
explicitly religious activities from activities supported with
direct Federal financial assistance;
If you object to the religious character of our
organization, we must make reasonable efforts to identify and refer
you to an alternative provider to which you have no objection; and
You may report violations of these protections to HUD [or
the intermediary, if applicable].
We must give you this written notice before you enroll in our
program or receive services from the program, as required by [Insert
Federal Agency's regulations].
BENEFICARY REFERRAL REQUEST
If you object to receiving services from us based on the
religious character of our organization, please complete this form
and return it to the program contact identified above. Your use of
this form is voluntary.
If you object to the religious character of our organization, we
must make reasonable efforts to identify and refer you to an
alternative provider to which you have no objection. We cannot
guarantee, however, that in every instance, an alternative provider
will be available. With your consent, we will follow up with you or
the organization to which you are referred to determine whether you
have contacted that organization.
( ) Please check if you want to be referred to another service
provider.
Please provide the following information if you want us to follow up
with you:
Your Name:
Best way to reach me (phone/address/email):
Please provide the following information if you want us to follow up
with the service provider only.
Your Name:
You are permitted to withhold your name, though if you choose to do
so, we will be unable to follow up with you or the service provider
about your referral.
( ) Please check if you do not want follow-up.
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
1. Date of Objection: __/ __/ __
2. Referral (check one):
[[Page 47313]]
( ) Individual was referred to (name of alternative provider and
contact information):
( ) Individual left without a referral
( ) No alternative service provider is available--summarize below
what efforts you made to identify an alternative (including reaching
out to HUD or the intermediary, if applicable):
3. Follow-up date: __/ __/ __
( ) Individual contacted alternative provider
( ) Individual did not contact alternative provider
4. Staff name and initials:
[FR Doc. 2015-18258 Filed 8-5-15; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE P