[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 142 (Friday, July 24, 2015)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 43911-43921]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-18239]
========================================================================
Rules and Regulations
Federal Register
________________________________________________________________________
This section of the FEDERAL REGISTER contains regulatory documents
having general applicability and legal effect, most of which are keyed
to and codified in the Code of Federal Regulations, which is published
under 50 titles pursuant to 44 U.S.C. 1510.
The Code of Federal Regulations is sold by the Superintendent of Documents.
Prices of new books are listed in the first FEDERAL REGISTER issue of each
week.
========================================================================
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 142 / Friday, July 24, 2015 / Rules
and Regulations
[[Page 43911]]
BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION
12 CFR Parts 1024 and 1026
[Docket No. CFPB-2015-0029]
RIN 3170-AA48
2013 Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Rule Under the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth in Lending Act
(Regulation Z) and Amendments; Delay of Effective Date
AGENCY: Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.
ACTION: Final rule; official interpretations; delay of effective date.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is delaying until
October 3, 2015, the effective date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
the related TILA-RESPA Amendments. In light of certain procedural
requirements under the Congressional Review Act (CRA), the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule and the TILA-RESPA Amendments cannot take effect on August
1, 2015, as originally provided by those rules. To comply with the CRA
and to help ensure the smooth implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, the Bureau is extending the effective date of both the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule and the TILA-RESPA Amendments beyond the additional minimum
period required by the CRA to October 3, 2015, as proposed. The Bureau
is also making certain technical amendments to the Official
Interpretations of Regulation Z to reflect the new effective date and
technical corrections to two provisions of Regulation Z adopted by the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule.
DATES: The amendments in this final rule are effective on October 3,
2015. Effective July 24, 2015, this final rule delays the effective
date from August 1, 2015, until October 3, 2015, for the final rules
amending 12 CFR parts 1024 and 1026 published December 31, 2013, at 78
FR 79730, and February 19, 2015, at 80 FR 8767; and for amendatory
instruction 5 amending Supplement I to 12 CFR part 1026, appearing on
page 65325 in the Federal Register on November 3, 2014.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Pedro De Oliveira, David Friend, or
Joel Singerman, Counsels; or Laura Johnson or Amanda Quester, Senior
Counsels, Office of Regulations, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
1700 G Street NW., Washington, DC 20552, at (202) 435-7700.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Summary of the Final Rule
In November 2013, pursuant to sections 1098 and 1100A of the Dodd-
Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank
Act),\1\ the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (Bureau or CFPB)
issued the Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Under the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth in Lending Act
(Regulation Z) (TILA-RESPA Final Rule), combining certain disclosures
that consumers receive in connection with applying for and closing on a
mortgage loan.\2\ On January 20, 2015, the Bureau issued the Amendments
to the 2013 Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Rule Under the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth in Lending Act
(Regulation Z) and the 2013 Loan Originator Rule Under the Truth in
Lending Act (Regulation Z) (TILA-RESPA Amendments or Amendments).\3\ As
published in the Federal Register, the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and the
TILA-RESPA Amendments (together, the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
Amendments) are effective on August 1, 2015. Because of an
administrative error on the Bureau's part in complying with the
Congressional Review Act (CRA) with respect to the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments cannot take effect
until, at the earliest, August 15, 2015 (CRA Effective Date).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Public Law 111-203, 124 Stat. 1376, 2007, 2103-04, 2107-09
(2010).
\2\ 78 FR 79730 (Dec. 31, 2013). The TILA-RESPA Final Rule
finalized a proposal the Bureau had issued on July 9, 2012, 77 FR
51116 (Aug. 23, 2012) (2012 TILA-RESPA Proposal).
\3\ 80 FR 8767 (Feb. 19, 2015). The TILA-RESPA Amendments
finalized a proposal the Bureau had issued on October 10, 2014, 79
FR 64336 (Oct. 29, 2014).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 24, 2015, the Bureau issued a proposed rule to delay the
effective date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments to October
3, 2015 (Proposed Rule). The Proposed Rule also included certain
technical amendments to the Official Interpretations to Regulation Z to
reflect the proposed new effective date.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ For purposes of this final rule, these technical amendments
include a change to amendatory instruction 5, appearing at 79 FR
65325 (Nov. 3, 2014), which will change the effective date of
comment 43(e)(3)(iv)-2. The Amendments to the 2013 Mortgage Rules
Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z) revised that comment
to coordinate the points and fees cure with the tolerance cure
available under the TILA-RESPA Final Rule. The Bureau proposed to
change amendatory instruction 5 to conform with the new effective
date for the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments and is finalizing
that proposal in this final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau is now issuing this final rule to delay the effective
date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments to October 3, 2015,
and to finalize the related technical amendments in the Proposed Rule.
As discussed in more detail in parts VI and VII below, this final rule
also makes certain technical corrections to the TILA-RESPA Final Rule.
Specifically, the Bureau is: (1) Amending Sec. 1026.38(i)(8)(ii) and
(iii)(A) to include, in the amount disclosed as ``Final'' for
Adjustments and Other Credits, the amount disclosed under Sec.
1026.38(j)(1)(iii) for certain personal property sales, thus conforming
the calculation of Adjustments and Other Credits on the Closing
Disclosure and Loan Estimate; and (2) amending Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv)
to include, in the amount disclosed as Closing Costs Paid at Closing,
lender credits disclosed under Sec. 1026.38(h)(3), thus conforming the
disclosure of the borrower's cash to close in the Calculating Cash to
Close and the Summaries of Transactions tables on the Closing
Disclosure. These technical corrections are in line with existing
industry expectations and informal Bureau guidance.
II. Background
A. The TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosures Rulemaking
Dodd-Frank Act sections 1032(f), 1098, and 1100A mandated that the
Bureau establish a single disclosure scheme for use by lenders and
creditors
[[Page 43912]]
in complying with the disclosure requirements of both the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) and the Truth in Lending Act
(TILA).\5\ Section 1098(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act amended RESPA section
4(a) to require that the Bureau publish a single, integrated disclosure
for mortgage loan transactions, including ``the disclosure requirements
of this section and section 5, in conjunction with the disclosure
requirements of [TILA].'' \6\ Similarly, section 1100A(5) of the Dodd-
Frank Act amended TILA section 105(b) to require that the Bureau
publish a single, integrated disclosure for mortgage loan transactions,
including ``the disclosure requirements of this title in conjunction
with the disclosure requirements of [RESPA].'' \7\ The Bureau issued
proposed integrated disclosure forms and rules for public comment on
July 9, 2012, and issued the TILA-RESPA Final Rule on November 20,
2013.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ 12 U.S.C. 5532(f), 2603; 15 U.S.C. 1604(b).
\6\ 12 U.S.C. 2603(a).
\7\ 15 U.S.C. 1604(b). The amendments to RESPA and TILA
mandating a single, integrated disclosure are among numerous
conforming amendments to existing Federal laws found in subtitle H
of the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010 (the Consumer
Financial Protection Act of 2010 is title X of the Dodd-Frank Act).
Subtitle C of the Consumer Financial Protection Act, ``Specific
Bureau Authorities,'' codified at 12 U.S.C. chapter 53, subchapter
V, part C, contains a similar provision. Specifically, section
1032(f) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that, by July 21, 2012, the
Bureau ``shall propose for public comment rules and model
disclosures that combine the disclosures required under [TILA] and
sections 4 and 5 of [RESPA] into a single, integrated disclosure for
mortgage loan transactions covered by those laws.'' 12 U.S.C.
5532(f). The Bureau issued the 2012 TILA-RESPA Proposal pursuant to
that mandate and the parallel mandates established by the conforming
amendments to RESPA and TILA, discussed above.
\8\ 77 FR 51116 (Aug. 23, 2012) (2012 TILA-RESPA Proposal); 78
FR 79730 (Dec. 31, 2013) (TILA-RESPA Final Rule); see also CFPB,
CFPB Proposes ``Know Before You Owe'' Mortgage Forms (July 9, 2012),
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/pressreleases/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-proposes-know-before-you-owe-mortgage-forms/; Know
Before You Owe: Introducing Our Proposed Mortgage Disclosure Forms,
CFPB Blog (July 9, 2012), http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/know-before-you-owe-introducing-our-proposed-mortgage-disclosure-forms/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upon issuing the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, the Bureau initiated
extensive efforts to support industry implementation.\9\ Information
regarding the Bureau's TILA-RESPA implementation initiative and
available resources can be found on the Bureau's regulatory
implementation Web site at www.consumerfinance.gov/regulatory-implementation/tila-respa.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ These ongoing efforts include: (1) The publication of a
small entity compliance guide and a guide to forms to help industry
understand the new rules, including updates to the guides, as
needed; (2) the publication of a readiness guide for institutions to
evaluate their readiness and facilitate compliance with the new
rules; (3) the publication of a disclosure timeline that illustrates
the process and timing requirements of the new disclosure rules; (4)
an ongoing series of webinars to address common interpretive
questions, including an index of questions answered during those
webinars; (5) roundtable meetings with industry, including
creditors, settlement service providers, and technology vendors, to
discuss and support their implementation efforts; (6) participation
in dozens of conferences and forums; and (7) close collaboration
with State and Federal regulators on implementation of the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule and Amendments, including coordination on
consistent examination procedures. There were over 30,000 downloads
of the Bureau's small entity compliance guide and other regulatory
implementation support materials during June 2015 alone.
Additionally, the Bureau has provided extensive informal guidance to
support implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Proposed Effective Date
As adopted, the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments are effective
on August 1, 2015. Section 801 of the CRA precludes a rule from taking
effect until the Federal agency promulgating the rule submits a rule
report, including a copy of the rule, to each House of Congress and to
the Comptroller General of the Government Accountability Office
(GAO).\10\ The TILA-RESPA Final Rule is a major rule under the CRA.
Major rules, as defined under the CRA, have several additional
procedural requirements, including that they cannot take effect until
60 days after (1) publication in the Federal Register or (2) receipt by
Congress, whichever is later.\11\ Although the TILA-RESPA Final Rule
was published in the Federal Register on December 31, 2013, and
received widespread public and Congressional attention, the Bureau
discovered on June 16, 2015, that it inadvertently had not submitted
the rule report to Congress. Later that day, the Bureau submitted the
report to both Houses of Congress and the GAO. Under the CRA, the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule cannot take effect until, at the earliest, August 15,
2015, two weeks after the originally scheduled effective date. The
TILA-RESPA Amendments cannot take effect before the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, as they amend the TILA-RESPA Final Rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ 5 U.S.C. 801(a)(1)(A).
\11\ 5 U.S.C. 801(a)(3), 804(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given that the TILA-RESPA Final Rule would not take effect until
the CRA Effective Date, the Bureau proposed a brief additional delay to
October 3, 2015. In doing so, the Bureau discussed whether this
additional delay could potentially benefit both consumers and industry
more than having the new rules take effect on the CRA Effective Date.
The Bureau recognized that adjusting operational systems from a target
readiness date of August 1 to a target readiness date of August 15
would likely pose implementation challenges for many organizations. The
Bureau also recognized that a mid-month effective date could create
additional challenges. Moreover, the Bureau noted that delays in the
delivery of system updates had left some creditors with limited time to
fully test all of their systems and system components to ensure that
each system works with the others in an effective manner. These delays
pose risks to smooth implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule when
combined with the challenges for institutions of adjusting operational
systems to a new effective date.
The Bureau also explained in the Proposed Rule that a Saturday
effective date could allow for smoother implementation by affording
industry time over a weekend to launch new systems configurations and
to test systems. The Bureau noted that a Saturday launch would be
consistent with existing industry plans tied to the original Saturday
August 1 effective date. The Bureau explained its concern that a longer
delay in implementation would impose unnecessary costs both on
consumers and on those segments of industry that have worked diligently
for a timely implementation. A longer delay would also be inconsistent
with the Bureau's goal of implementing the new disclosures on the
earliest practically feasible date to support consumer understanding of
mortgage loan transactions.
III. Summary of the Rulemaking Process
On June 24, 2015, the Bureau issued the Proposed Rule with a
request for public comment. The Proposed Rule was published in the
Federal Register on June 26, 2015.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ 80 FR 36727 (June 26, 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau solicited comment on all aspects of the Proposed Rule.
In particular, the Bureau asked commenters to provide specific detail
and any available data regarding current and planned practices, as well
as relevant knowledge and specific facts about any benefits, costs, or
other impacts on both industry and consumers of the Proposed Rule. The
Bureau solicited comment regarding the proposed extension of the
effective date to October 3, 2015, as well as alternative dates for
extension, including the prospect of allowing the new rules to take
effect on the CRA Effective Date.
The comment period closed on July 7, 2015. In response to the
Proposed Rule, the Bureau received more than 1,300
[[Page 43913]]
comments from industry trade associations, creditors, technology
vendors, and other industry representatives, as well as consumer
advocacy groups and others. In adopting this final rule, the Bureau has
considered and discussed relevant comments in parts V and VI below.
Many of the comments urged the Bureau to take actions beyond the scope
of the Proposed Rule.
IV. Legal Authority
The Bureau is issuing this final rule pursuant to its authority
under TILA, RESPA, and the Dodd-Frank Act. Specifically, the Bureau is
exercising its rulemaking authority pursuant to TILA section 105(a),
RESPA section 19(a), and Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1) to delay the
effective date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments, including
related technical amendments in the Proposed Rule.
The legal authority for the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and the TILA-
RESPA Amendments is described in detail in the Legal Authority parts of
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and the TILA-RESPA Amendments,
respectively.\13\ As amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, TILA section 105(a)
directs the Bureau to prescribe regulations to carry out the purposes
of TILA and provides that such regulations may contain additional
requirements, classifications, differentiations, or other provisions,
and may provide for such adjustments and exceptions for all or any
class of transactions, that the Bureau judges are necessary or proper
to effectuate the purposes of TILA, to prevent circumvention or evasion
thereof, or to facilitate compliance therewith.\14\ Section 19(a) of
RESPA authorizes the Bureau to prescribe such rules and regulations and
to make such interpretations and grant such reasonable exemptions for
classes of transactions as may be necessary to achieve the purposes of
RESPA.\15\ Additionally, under Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1), the
Bureau has general authority to prescribe rules ``as may be necessary
or appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry out the
purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws, and to
prevent evasions thereof.'' \16\ TILA and RESPA are Federal consumer
financial laws.\17\ Accordingly, in issuing this final rule, the Bureau
is exercising its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1) to
prescribe rules under TILA, RESPA, and title X of the Dodd-Frank Act
that carry out the purposes and objectives and prevent evasion of those
laws. The Bureau believes that delaying the effective date to October
3, 2015, will facilitate compliance with--and help ensure the smooth
implementation of--the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments. Section
1022(b)(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act prescribes certain standards for
rulemaking that the Bureau must follow in exercising its authority
under section 1022(b)(1).\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\ 78 FR 79730, 79753-56 (Dec. 31, 2013); 80 FR 8767, 8768-70
(Feb. 19, 2015).
\14\ 15 U.S.C. 1604(a).
\15\ 12 U.S.C. 2617(a).
\16\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1).
\17\ 12 U.S.C. 5481(12), (14).
\18\ 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau is also making technical corrections to Sec.
1026.38(i)(8)(ii) and (iii)(A) and Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv), relying on
the same authority used to implement Sec. 1026.38(i) and (j) in the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule: TILA section 105(a); RESPA section 19(a); and
Dodd-Frank Act sections 1032(a) and 1405(b).\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ See 78 FR 79730, 80016, 80020 (Dec. 31, 2013). Sections
1032(a) and 1405(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act are codified,
respectively, at 15 U.S.C. 5532 and 15 U.S.C. 1601 note.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
V. Effective Date
In the Proposed Rule, the Bureau requested comment specifically
regarding the proposed extension of the effective date to October 3,
2015, as well as alternative dates for extension, including allowing
the new rules to take effect on the CRA Effective Date.
A. Comments Received
Extending the Effective Date Beyond the CRA Effective Date
The vast majority of commenters who opined on the effective date--
including banks, credit unions, mortgage companies, industry service
providers, trade associations, and individual commenters--supported
extending the effective date beyond the CRA Effective Date. Consumer
advocacy groups did not oppose the extension beyond the CRA Effective
Date. Many commenters supported the proposed October 3, 2015, effective
date without requesting any additional delay in the effective date.
Other commenters recommended extending the effective date to various
other dates, including September 3, 2015; November 1, 2015; December
31, 2015; January 1, 2016; January 2, 2016; January 4, 2016; January
14, 2016; or February 1, 2016.
However, some commenters expressed concern about any delay of the
effective date. For example, a few industry commenters suggested that
their institutions or creditors more generally would be prepared for an
August 1 effective date and that they consequently would not need or
want any further delays. Several commenters were concerned about costs
associated with any delay, including costs related to staffing,
communications, scheduling, programming, and training, but they did not
provide sufficient information about those costs from which to develop
a reliable estimate of the costs on industry.
Several commenters opposed any further delay beyond an early
October effective date. For example, consumer advocacy groups urged
that the effective date should not be delayed any further, in order to
maximize the benefits of the new disclosures. Consumer advocacy groups
commented that the new integrated disclosures will improve the format,
content, and timing of information provided to many consumers in
connection with the biggest purchase of their lives. Several industry
commenters, including various trade associations, a technology vendor,
and two banks, stated that adjusting operational systems from an
effective date of August 1, 2015, to a later date poses extensive
implementation challenges. As a result, industry has begun the process
of making operational systems adjustments, even before finalization of
the Proposed Rule, based on the proposed October 3, 2015, effective
date.
Support for extending the effective date was most often justified
by commenters on the basis that industry needs more time to prepare. In
particular, many commenters from industry, both individuals and
institutions, cited delays in updating software and systems that
industry relies on for compliance and also cited related delays in
testing and training on such systems. Several industry commenters noted
that extending the effective date would provide more time for creditors
and service providers to clarify their understanding of the rule's
extensive provisions, including through additional guidance issued by
the Bureau. Some commenters, including trade organizations and a
technology vendor, supported extending the effective date because
implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments has been
occurring while industry is implementing or adjusting to various other
legal and regulatory changes, and at least one commenter noted that
their resources are stretched thin as a result. Some industry
commenters expressed the opinion that a delay in implementation would
benefit consumers because industry would be better prepared to
implement
[[Page 43914]]
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments with more time.
Industry commenters who sought a further delay in the effective
date beyond October 3, 2015, generally relied on the same arguments
raised by other commenters for any extension of the effective date.
Among commenters who requested an additional delay in the effective
date beyond October 3, 2015, the most common alternative date fell
sometime near the beginning of 2016 (e.g., January 1, 2016; January 2,
2016; or January 4, 2016). Industry commenters argued that they expect
mortgage origination activity to slow during the end of the calendar
year and the beginning of the new year, based on historical patterns,
and a delay until early 2016 would thus permit a smoother transition.
Some commenters, including a community bank and a credit union,
requested a February 1, 2016, effective date instead of a date in
January because implementation could be difficult around the end-of-
the-year holidays.
Specific Day of the Week or Time During the Month for the Effective
Date
Some industry commenters, including a national trade association,
specifically supported a Saturday effective date (for example, October
3, 2015) because it would allow companies to migrate their systems over
a weekend. At least one commenter, a state trade association, supported
a Friday effective date for similar reasons. Other commenters favored
different days of the week for the effective date, such as a Monday or
Thursday. For example, a credit union commenter favored a Thursday
effective date because the TILA-RESPA Final Rule allows a three-
business-day window for delivering or placing the Loan Estimate in the
mail, and thus a Thursday effective date would provide additional time
to work through potential systems issues before the start of the
following workweek. A credit union association commenter stated that a
weekend effective date would require additional staff overtime costs
and would therefore be undesirable.
Several commenters, including a credit union and an individual
commenter, stated that an effective date on the first day of the month
would simplify implementation. However, a bank commenter stated that
there would be additional staff challenges if the effective date is
within the first few days after the end of a quarterly reporting
period.
Technical Comments on the Effective Date
The Bureau also received a number of technical comments about the
effective date. One commenter suggested that the Bureau should amend an
additional amendatory instruction, as discussed further below. Some
commenters, including consumer advocacy groups, requested clarification
as to whether all or only parts of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
Amendments will have a new effective date. Additionally, other
commenters requested clarification that the proposal for the final rule
to take effect immediately upon publication referred to the delay of
the effective date, not to the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.
Other Comments
The Bureau also received a number of comments that did not relate
directly to the date when the TILA-RESPA Final Rule should become
effective. Many banks, credit unions, mortgage companies, industry
service providers, trade associations, and individual commenters from
industry--including many who did not request an additional delay in the
effective date beyond October 3, 2015--requested a safe harbor period,
hold-harmless period, or other formal grace period after the effective
date to insulate creditors from private liability or public
enforcement. Many suggested that a grace period could apply to
creditors that demonstrate good faith efforts to comply with the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule and Amendments. Some commenters arguing for an
effective date later than October 3, 2015, asked for a grace period if
the Bureau maintained the October 3, 2015, effective date. Some
commenters supporting a grace period stated that it should last for a
specific duration.
Consumer advocacy groups opposed a formal grace period, expressing
concerns about consumer protection, precedential value, and the
Bureau's legal authority to implement a formal grace period. The
consumer advocacy groups noted that regulators already have the
discretion not to sanction creditors and that various existing
provisions of TILA protect creditors acting in good faith.
Some industry commenters, including various credit unions and their
trade associations, requested an optional ``dual compliance'' period
before the effective date. During such a dual compliance period, the
commenters stated that creditors should have the option to test their
systems by using the new integrated disclosures in real-life
transactions or continue using the current disclosures. A law firm
commenter that supported an optional dual compliance period stated that
creditors that are already prepared for an August 2015 effective date
should not be penalized by being forced to wait until October or later.
Other industry commenters, including a technology vendor and a
title underwriter, opposed a dual compliance period and stated that it
would increase the risk of errors, create a competitive disadvantage
for some (likely smaller) industry members not using the new
disclosures, complicate the flow of information for secondary market
investors, and increase the risk of consumer confusion.
The Bureau also received a number of other comments that did not
relate, even indirectly, to the effective date and therefore are not
discussed in this preamble.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\ For example, the Bureau received a large number of comments
asking it to revisit the requirement to identify owner's title
insurance as ``optional'' and the method of disclosure of owner's
and lender's title insurance when there is a discount for
simultaneous issuance of both policies. A large number of commenters
also suggested that the Bureau should require creditors' disclosures
to separately itemize an appraiser's charge versus related charges
for an appraisal management company. The Bureau considered the same
arguments presented by these commenters in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule
and did not open its decisions to notice-and-comment rulemaking in
the Proposed Rule. Therefore, these comments are outside the scope
of this rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Final Rule
Effective Date of October 3, 2015
The Bureau is adopting an October 3, 2015, effective date for the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments, as proposed.
The Bureau concludes that implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule and Amendments will provide significant benefits to consumers and
that the earliest practically feasible implementation date remains
essential to aid consumer understanding of mortgage loan transactions.
The TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments significantly strengthen and
streamline the mortgage loan disclosures provided to consumers. The
Bureau believes the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments will deliver
significant value to consumers, among other ways, by helping: (1) To
ensure that consumers understand the costs, risks, and benefits of
their loans at a time when they can still negotiate the terms of, or
walk away from, the transaction; and (2) to minimize changes at the
closing table and make it easier for consumers to understand how and
why any costs may have changed.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\ 78 FR 79730, 80071 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 43915]]
However, given the CRA requirements discussed above, the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule and Amendments cannot take effect on August 1, 2015, and
therefore the effective date must be moved to the CRA Effective Date or
later. Having reviewed and considered the comments, the Bureau
continues to believe that a brief delay beyond the CRA Effective Date
may minimize costs to consumers and those segments of industry that
have worked diligently to implement on time, while allowing all
industry participants time to adjust their operations to a new
effective date. The Bureau recognizes that the unusual circumstances of
this rulemaking place extensive implementation challenges on industry
in stopping and restarting progress toward implementation.
The Bureau has considered comments supporting both earlier and
later effective dates than October 3, 2015. The Bureau continues to
believe that a date before the beginning of October would pose large
implementation challenges for much of industry, given the time required
to adjust to a new effective date. Further delaying implementation to
the beginning of 2016, as many commenters suggested, would impose large
costs on consumers denied the benefits of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule.
Moreover, multiple commenters indicated that industry would incur
additional costs should the Bureau finalize a different effective date
than October 3, 2015, because many industry participants of necessity
have relied on the Bureau's proposed October 3, 2015, date in taking
steps towards adjusting their implementation schedules and operations.
Absent compelling evidence demonstrating the objective superiority of a
different effective date, the Bureau is reluctant to impose further
costs on industry.
The Bureau has also considered the comments regarding the day of
the week and time during the month. While industry commenters did not
express a uniform preference for Saturday, many expressed a preference
for a weekend day. Additionally, the Bureau notes that, since November
2013, industry has been preparing for implementation of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule with the understanding that implementation would occur on a
Saturday, at the beginning of the month. Again, absent compelling
arguments to the contrary, the Bureau believes it is preferable to
minimize disruptions to settled industry expectations.
The Bureau acknowledges that at least one commenter expressed
concern about an implementation date near the start of a quarter.
However, this view was not widely expressed. Many commenters who
expressed a preference for another effective date, e.g., January 1,
2016, also recommended one near the start of a quarter. Taking into
account the various opinions expressed in the comments, the Bureau
believes that an effective date near the start of a quarter will not
pose unreasonable implementation challenges to industry. Moreover, the
Bureau must balance the costs of additional delay to consumers and
those segments of industry that have worked diligently to prepare, the
general concern about mid-month implementation, and the need for some
additional time for industry to adjust to the new effective date.
Balancing those concerns, the Bureau believes that an effective date of
October 3, 2015, is the earliest practically feasible date.
The Bureau recognizes, as it always has, that the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule and Amendments require major operational changes for industry and
close coordination among many different parties. At the same time, the
Bureau concludes that the original nearly 21-month implementation
period together with two additional months, coupled with the Bureau's
extensive regulatory implementation support efforts, should afford all
participants a reasonable opportunity to come into compliance with the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments by October 3, 2015.
Technical Issues Regarding Effective Date
In response to some commenters' requests for clarification, this
final rule changes the effective date to October 3, 2015, for all
provisions of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.\22\ The
technical amendments also take effect on October 3, 2015, the same
effective date as the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.\23\ Some
commenters specifically asked whether the change in effective date to
October 3, 2015, applies to the post-consummation notice requirements
including Sec. Sec. 1026.20(e) and 1026.39(d)(5). As discussed in the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule, implementation of the Dodd-Frank Act disclosures
in Sec. Sec. 1026.20(e) and 1026.39(d)(5) becomes mandatory on the
effective date, now October 3, 2015.\24\ As discussed further in part
VII below, the portions of this final rule related to the delay in the
effective date to October 3, 2015, are effective immediately upon
publication in order to move the effective date for the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule and Amendments and the amendatory instruction discussed in
note 4 from August 1, 2015 to October 3, 2015. As a result of this
final rule, the provisions of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments,
as well as the technical amendments and corrections made in this final
rule, are not effective immediately upon publication, but on October 3,
2015.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\ As explained in the section-by-section analysis of Sec.
1026.43 below, this final rule also delays from August 1, 2015,
until October 3, 2015, an amendatory instruction issued in
conjunction with the Amendments to the 2013 Mortgage Rules Under the
Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z).
\23\ This final rule also makes technical corrections to two
provisions in Sec. 1026.38, which are effective on October 3, 2015,
the same effective date as the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.
\24\ 78 FR 79730, 79753 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to one law firm commenter's assertion that the Proposed
Rule fails to amend the amendatory instruction to Sec.
1026.36(g)(2)(ii) in the TILA-RESPA Amendments by revising the
effective date from August 1, 2015, to October 3, 2015, the Bureau
disagrees. The Bureau proposed to change the effective date of both the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule and the TILA-RESPA Amendments to October 3, 2015.
The proposed change to the effective date would apply to all amendatory
instructions for both rules, including the TILA-RESPA Amendments'
amendatory instruction to Sec. 1026.36(g)(2)(ii).
Requests for a Formal Grace Period or a Dual Compliance Period
With regard to some commenters' requests for a formal grace period
or a dual compliance period, the Bureau considered and rejected similar
arguments when it finalized the TILA-RESPA Final Rule.\25\ The Bureau
did not seek comments on these issues in this rulemaking and, for the
reasons expressed in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and herein, is not
instituting either a formal grace period or a dual compliance period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\ See, e.g., 78 FR 79730, 80066-68, 80072-73 (2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although many commenters requested a formal grace period, the
Bureau continues to believe that the original implementation period
from November 2013 to August 2015, coupled with the Bureau's extensive
regulatory implementation support initiative, afforded creditors
adequate time to implement the TILA-RESPA Final Rule under the original
effective date. The Bureau also believes that the additional time
afforded by the October 3 effective date adequately accounts for the
challenges of adjusting to a new date.
At the same time, the Bureau recognizes, as it always has, that the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule poses
[[Page 43916]]
significant implementation challenges for industry. The Bureau
continues to believe that the approach expressed in Director Cordray's
letter to members of Congress on June 3, 2015, remains appropriate:
[O]ur oversight of the implementation of the Rule will be
sensitive to the progress made by those entities that have squarely
focused on making good-faith efforts to come into compliance with
the Rule on time. My statement . . . is consistent with the approach
we took to implementation of the Title XIV mortgage rules in the
early months after the effective dates in January 2014, which has
worked out well.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\ Letter from Director Richard Cordray, CFPB, to
Representatives Andy Barr and Carolyn B. Maloney, U.S. House of
Representatives (June 3, 2015). See also Know Before You Owe: You'll
Get 3 Days to Review Your Mortgage Closing Documents, CFPB Blog
(June 3, 2015), http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/know-before-you-owe-youll-get-3-days-to-review-your-mortgage-closing-documents/.
The Bureau considered arguments regarding dual compliance when it
issued the TILA-RESPA Final Rule in November 2013 in the context of
evaluating whether different creditors should be subject to different
effective dates.\27\ While the Bureau recognizes that the delay in the
effective date imposes costs on the many creditors who have worked
diligently to be ready for the original August 1 effective date, the
Bureau continues to share the concerns of commenters both to the 2012
TILA-RESPA Proposal and to the Proposed Rule finalized here that dual
compliance could be confusing to consumers and complicated for
industry, including vendors, the secondary market, and institutions who
act both as correspondent lenders and originators. The Bureau is not
persuaded that a dual compliance period would be beneficial. For these
reasons, the Bureau declines to institute a dual compliance period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ See, e.g., 78 FR 79730, 80066, 80068, 80073 (2013)
(discussing comments requesting a bifurcated implementation period
depending on the size of the institution).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VI. Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1026.1 Authority, Purpose, Coverage, Organization, Enforcement,
and Liability
1(d) Organization
1(d)(5)
Comment 1(d)(5)-1 provides clarity regarding the application of the
effective date to transactions covered by the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
Amendments. The Bureau proposed conforming amendments to comment
1(d)(5)-1 to reflect the proposed change in effective date to October
3, 2015. The Bureau received no comments specifically relating to
comment 1(d)(5)-1, other than the general comments relating to the
effective date that are discussed in part V above. The Bureau is
finalizing comment 1(d)(5)-1 as proposed.
Section 1026.19 Certain Mortgage and Variable-Rate Transactions
19(g) Special Information Booklet at Time of Application
19(g)(2) Permissible Changes
Comment 19(g)(2)-3 refers to the general restriction on changing
the settlement cost booklet's title under Sec. 1026.19(g)(2)(iv). The
Bureau proposed conforming amendments to comment 19(g)(2)-3 to reflect
the proposed change in effective date to October 3, 2015. The Bureau
received no comments specific to the amendments to comment 19(g)(2)-3,
other than the general comments relating to the effective date that are
discussed in part V above. The Bureau is finalizing the amendments to
comment 19(g)(2)-3 as proposed.
Section 1026.38 Content of Disclosures for Certain Mortgage
Transactions (Closing Disclosure)
38(i) Calculating Cash to Close
38(i)(8) Adjustments and Other Credits
The Calculating Cash to Close table in the Closing Disclosure under
Sec. 1026.38(i) generally mirrors the format of, and updates the
amounts shown on, the Calculating Cash to Close table in the Loan
Estimate under Sec. 1026.37(h). To determine the amount of cash or
other funds the consumer is to provide at consummation, the tables must
account for the sales price of any tangible personal property being
sold in a purchase real estate transaction that is excluded from the
contract sales price, as disclosed under Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iii). The
TILA-RESPA Final Rule does not specify a place within the Calculating
Cash to Close table on the Closing Disclosure for this amount. However,
comment 37(h)(1)(vii)-6, relating to the Calculating Cash to Close
table on the Loan Estimate, indicates that the sales price of
additional personal property can be included in the Adjustments and
Other Credits amount. To conform this aspect of the Closing Disclosure
to the Loan Estimate, the Bureau is amending Sec. 1026.38(i)(8)(ii) to
include the amount disclosed under Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iii) in the
amount disclosed as ``Final'' for Adjustments and Other Credits. This
change will ensure that the Calculating Cash to Close table on the
Closing Disclosure accurately reflects the total amount of cash or
other funds that the consumer must provide at consummation and will
complete the alignment of the disclosure of Adjustments and Other
Credits between the Closing Disclosure and the Loan Estimate. The
Bureau believes this is consistent with industry expectations of the
proper disclosure of the Adjustments and Other Credits on both the Loan
Estimate and Closing Disclosure and will reduce uncertainty in
implementation by confirming that the calculation of Adjustments and
Other Credits is the same on both the Closing Disclosure and the Loan
Estimate.
The Bureau is also making a conforming change to Sec.
1026.38(i)(8)(iii)(A). That paragraph requires creditors to disclose
the basis for any difference between the Adjustments and Other Credits
disclosed on the Loan Estimate and the Adjustments and Other Credits
disclosed as ``Final'' on the Closing Disclosure (unless the difference
is due to rounding). As explained in comment 38(i)-3, creditors may
disclose the basis for the difference by providing a general or
specific line cross-reference to the Summaries of Transactions table.
This conforming change will permit creditors to cross-reference to the
personal property sales price disclosed under Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iii)
as a basis for the calculation of the amount disclosed under Sec.
1026.38(i)(8)(ii). This modification is unlikely to change creditors'
practice because creditors may provide consumers with a more general
cross-reference to the Summaries of Transactions table and need not
provide a specific line cross-reference.
These changes to Sec. 1026.38(i)(8) will also ensure that the
amount disclosed as due to or from the consumer in the Calculating Cash
to Close table on the Closing Disclosure matches the amount disclosed
as due to or from the consumer in the Summaries of Transactions table
on the Closing Disclosure. As alignment between these two disclosures
is required by existing comment 38(i)(9)(ii)-1, this change should
facilitate implementation and is consistent with existing industry
preparations and informal guidance provided by the Bureau.
38(j) Summary of Borrower's Transaction
38(j)(1) Itemization of Amounts Due From Borrower
38(j)(1)(iv)
In the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, Sec. 1026.38(j) provides for a
summary of
[[Page 43917]]
the borrower's transaction on the Closing Disclosure. The total amount
due from or to the consumer at the real estate closing in this
Summaries of Transactions table should match the disclosure of the
``Final'' cash to close on the Calculating Cash to Close table pursuant
to Sec. 1026.38(i)(9)(ii) (as explained in comment 38(i)(9)(ii)-1).
For the Summaries of Transactions table, the disclosure of the
total amount of closing costs that are designated borrower-paid at
closing is specified in Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv). In the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule, Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv) provides that the total amount of
closing costs disclosed that are designated borrower-paid at closing is
calculated pursuant to Sec. 1026.38(h)(2). As originally proposed in
the 2012 TILA-RESPA Proposal, Sec. 1026.38(h)(2) included the lender
credits described in Sec. 1026.38(h)(3).\28\ In the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, however, the Bureau removed the lender credits set forth in Sec.
1026.38(h)(3) from the calculation in Sec. 1026.38(h)(2) in order to
reconcile the Calculating Cash to Close table in Sec. 1026.38(i). In
doing so, the Bureau inadvertently failed to adjust Sec.
1026.38(j)(1)(iv) to include the lender credits disclosed pursuant to
Sec. 1026.38(h)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\ 77 FR 51116, 51324 (Aug. 23, 2012).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As a result, under the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, the total amount due
from or to the consumer at the real estate closing in the Summaries of
Transactions table may not match the ``Final'' amount of cash to close
disclosed in the Calculating Cash to Close table under Sec.
1026.38(i)(9)(ii). To correct this, the Bureau is modifying Sec.
1026.38(j)(1)(iv) to require disclosure of the sum of the amount
disclosed under Sec. 1026.38(h)(2) and the amount of any lender
credits disclosed as a negative number under Sec. 1026.38(h)(3). The
lender credits described in Sec. 1026.38(h)(3) are appropriately and
necessarily included in the summary of the borrower's transaction as an
offsetting credit to the amount due from the borrower at closing. This
change makes the Summaries of Transactions table accurately reflect the
total amount due from or to the consumer at the real estate closing;
comports the disclosure of the ``Final'' amount of cash to close in the
Calculating Cash to Close table with the amount disclosed in the
Summaries of Transactions table as required by existing comment
38(i)(9)(ii)-1; and is consistent with informal guidance provided by
the Bureau.
Section 1026.43 Minimum Standards for Transactions Secured by a
Dwelling
43(e) Qualified Mortgages
43(e)(3) Limits on Points and Fees for Qualified Mortgages
43(e)(3)(iv)
In addition to proposing the amendments discussed above, the Bureau
proposed one amendment to an amendatory instruction that relates to the
Amendments to the 2013 Mortgage Rules Under the Truth in Lending Act
(Regulation Z).\29\ Specifically, the Bureau proposed to amend
instruction 5, which is drafted so the comment referenced would take
effect on August 1, 2015, to coordinate with the original effective
date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule. The amendatory instruction relating
to comment 43(e)(3)(iv)-2, Relationship to RESPA tolerance cure, will
replace an existing comment clarifying the relationship between
tolerance cures under RESPA and Regulation Z points and fees cures with
a comment that incorporates the tolerance cure provisions of Sec.
1026.19(f)(2)(v) under the TILA-RESPA Final Rule. The Bureau proposed
to have the instruction take effect on October 3, 2015, instead of
August 1, 2015, to preserve this coordination. The Bureau received no
comments specifically relating to this proposed amendment. The Bureau
is finalizing this change to the amendatory instruction as proposed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ 79 FR 65300, 65325 (Nov. 3, 2014).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VII. Administrative Procedure Act
5 U.S.C. 553(b)
In the Proposed Rule, the Bureau provided notice and an opportunity
for public comment with respect to its proposal to delay the effective
date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments and to make certain
technical amendments to the Official Interpretations of Regulation Z
related to the proposed new effective date. In this final rule, the
Bureau is also finalizing technical corrections to Sec.
1026.38(i)(8)(ii) and (iii)(A) and Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv). The Bureau
did not seek public comment on these technical corrections but finds
that there is good cause to publish them without notice and comment.
Under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), notice and opportunity
for public comment are not required if the Bureau finds that notice and
public procedure thereon are impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to
the public interest.\30\ The Bureau has determined that notice and
comment are unnecessary because the technical corrections to Sec.
1026.38(i)(8)(ii) and (iii)(A) and Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv) in this
final rule correct inadvertent, technical errors and merely align and
harmonize those provisions with other provisions of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule. Furthermore, the technical corrections clarify the
operation of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule in a way that is consistent with
informal guidance provided by the Bureau and with industry
preparations. The Bureau believes that there is minimal, if any, basis
for substantive disagreement with these technical corrections.
Therefore, the technical corrections to Sec. 1026.38(i)(8)(ii) and
(iii)(A) and Sec. 1026.38(j)(1)(iv) are adopted in final form.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\ 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5 U.S.C. 553(d)
Section 553(d) of the APA generally requires that the effective
date of a final rule be at least 30 days after publication of that
final rule, except for (1) a substantive rule which grants or
recognizes an exemption or relieves a restriction; (2) interpretive
rules or statements of policy; or (3) as otherwise provided by the
agency for good cause found and published with the rule.\31\ The Bureau
finds that there is good cause for making the portions of this final
rule related to delaying the effective date effective immediately upon
publication in the Federal Register. These portions do not establish
any requirements; instead, they delay the effective date of the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule and Amendments and the amendatory instruction
referenced in note 4 until October 3, 2015. Therefore, under section
553(d)(1) of the APA, the Bureau is publishing these portions less than
30 days before the effective date of this final rule because they are
substantive rules which grant or recognize an exemption or relieve a
restriction. Further, delaying the effective date of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule and Amendments will ensure an orderly change to the new
integrated disclosures and will synchronize the effective date of the
Amendments with that of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule. Thus, this final
rule will facilitate compliance and help reduce industry and consumer
confusion and market disruption. Therefore, the Bureau also finds it
has good cause pursuant to section 553(d)(3) of the APA to dispense
with the 30-day delayed effective date requirement for this final rule
because, on balance, the need to implement immediately the delay of the
August 1, 2015, effective
[[Page 43918]]
date to October 3, 2015, outweighs the need for affected parties to
prepare for this delay.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\ 5 U.S.C. 553(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
VIII. Section 1022(b)(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act
A. Overview
In developing this final rule, the Bureau has considered potential
benefits, costs, and impacts.\32\ The Bureau has consulted, or offered
to consult, with the prudential regulators; the Federal Housing Finance
Agency; the Federal Trade Commission; the U.S. Department of
Agriculture; the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development; the
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of the
Inspector General; the U.S. Department of the Treasury; the U.S.
Department of Veterans Affairs; and the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission. The Bureau's consultation and offer of consultation
included assessing consistency with any prudential, market, or systemic
objectives administered by such agencies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\ Specifically, section 1022(b)(2)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act
calls for the Bureau to consider the potential benefits and costs of
a regulation to consumers and covered persons, including the
potential reduction of access by consumers to consumer financial
products or services; the impact on depository institutions and
credit unions with $10 billion or less in total assets as described
in section 1026 of the Dodd-Frank Act; and the impact on consumers
in rural areas.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau requested comment on the preliminary analysis presented
in the Proposed Rule, as well as submissions of additional data that
could inform the Bureau's analysis of the benefits, costs, and impacts
of the Proposed Rule. Because the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments
cannot take effect before the CRA Effective Date, the Bureau has
evaluated the benefits, costs, and impacts of this final rule, assuming
that the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments would become effective on
August 15 absent this final rule. The Bureau has relied on a variety of
data sources to consider the potential benefits, costs, and impacts of
this final rule. In some instances, the requisite data are not
available or are quite limited. Data with which to quantify the
benefits of this final rule are particularly limited. As a result,
portions of this analysis rely in part on general economic principles
to provide a qualitative discussion of the benefits, costs, and impacts
of this final rule.
As a result of this final rule, affected covered persons will incur
costs associated with delaying implementation from the CRA Effective
Date until October 3, 2015. These costs include communication with and
training of staff, software programming, vendor and outside supplier
coordination, advertising and product development costs, and broker and
settlement agent coordination. The Bureau believes that these costs are
likely higher for larger creditors and creditors that rely primarily on
proprietary systems rather than on third-party software vendors.\33\
While many of these costs are largely incurred with the initial delay
to the CRA Effective Date, affected entities may incur additional costs
for subsequent delay beyond the CRA Effective Date, including ongoing
training, testing, and opportunity costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\ As in the section 1022(b)(2) analysis of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule, the Bureau believes that approximately 5 percent of
creditors do not rely on third-party vendors. See 78 FR 79730,
80081, 80101 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, consumers will incur costs associated with delaying the
effective date. These costs will consist mostly of delayed benefits
described in the section 1022(b)(2) analysis of the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, primarily improved consumer understanding of mortgage loan
transactions and an increased ability to shop for a mortgage loan. The
longer the delay in the implementation of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
Amendments, the greater will be the cost to consumers from not
receiving the benefits of the new integrated disclosures.
This final rule amends the effective date of the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule and Amendments. In the section 1022(b)(2) analyses of the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule and Amendments, the Bureau previously considered the
costs, benefits, and impact of the rules. This final rule also contains
technical corrections to two provisions of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule.
These technical corrections are necessary to resolve minor
inconsistencies in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and are consistent with
informal guidance provided by the Bureau. Thus, the Bureau believes
that creditors will not be adversely affected by these technical
corrections and will enjoy additional certainty when originating loans.
Given that the Bureau believes that the vast majority of creditors
would have implemented their systems in a manner consistent with these
technical corrections regardless of this final rule, the Bureau does
not believe that these technical corrections will have a discernible
impact on consumers.
B. Potential Benefits and Costs to Consumers and Covered Persons
The primary consumers who will be affected by this final rule are
consumers that engage in mortgage shopping between the CRA Effective
Date and October 3, 2015. Those consumers will be harmed by not
receiving the benefits of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments.
Consumers shopping for a mortgage during the period of delay in the
effective date will not receive those benefits, even if they close on
their loans after the delayed effective date. The benefits of the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule and Amendments include easier-to-understand
disclosures and the requirement that the creditor deliver the Closing
Disclosure containing the settlement information as well as the TILA
disclosures at least three days before closing.\34\ Some consumers may
benefit if the delay results in the industry using the time before
October 3 for more system testing or other preparation, leading to a
smoother transition to the new integrated disclosures. As in the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule, the Bureau cannot quantify either the benefit or the
cost of this final rule to consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\ These and other benefits are described in detail in the
section 1022(b)(2) analysis of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule. 78 FR
79730, 80073-89 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, for purposes of this section
1022(b)(2) analysis, the Bureau has considered three categories of
affected covered persons that will benefit or incur adjustment costs:
Creditors that engage in mortgage lending, mortgage brokers, and
settlement agents.\35\ The Bureau estimates that, in 2014, there were
about 11,150 creditors engaged in mortgage lending, about 7,000
mortgage brokers, and about 7,700 settlement agent firms.\36\ As noted
in part V above, due
[[Page 43919]]
to industry's implementation challenges, the Bureau believes that the
delay of the effective date beyond the CRA Effective Date could benefit
many of these creditors, mortgage brokers, and settlement agents, by
allowing them more time to transition to the new integrated disclosures
required by the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments and by diminishing
the magnitude of any potential disruptions associated with the
transition. The delay in the effective date could also benefit them to
the extent that it allows them to delay incurring any of the costs
described in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule section 1022(b)(2) analysis.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\ Some service providers, such as software vendors, will
incur costs, as well, as they update their products to comply with
this final rule, but these are not covered persons for the purposes
of this analysis.
\36\ The primary source of data used in this analysis is 2013
data collected under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA). The
empirical analysis also uses data from the 4th quarter 2013 bank and
thrift Call Reports, and the 4th quarter 2013 credit union Call
Reports from the National Credit Union Administration, to identify
financial institutions and their characteristics. Unless otherwise
specified, the numbers provided include appropriate projections made
to account for any missing information, for example, any
institutions that do not report under HMDA. The Bureau also utilizes
data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of
Labor.
The Bureau analyzes data from all creditors, both the ones that
report under HMDA and the ones that do not, with the exception of
non-depository institutions that do not report under HMDA. For HMDA
reporters, the Bureau uses the data reported. For HMDA non-
reporters, the Bureau uses projections based on the match of the
Call Report data with HMDA.
\37\ See 78 FR 79730, 80073-89 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Creditors and other affected persons might also incur costs due to
the delay of the effective date of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and
Amendments. The Bureau estimated in its section 1022(b)(2) analysis of
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule that 95 percent of creditors (about 10,600)
rely on third-party vendors for their software, and the Bureau
estimates that these creditors will not incur significant software
programming costs.\38\ However, for the 5 percent of creditors
(approximately 560) that do not rely on third-party vendors, the change
of the effective date will require additional programming expense.
While a portion of this cost is already imposed by the delay in the
effective date to the CRA Effective Date and therefore is not imposed
by this final rule, the Bureau believes that some of this cost might be
greater with the delay of the effective date to October 3. The Bureau
specifically requested comment on the extent of programming expense but
received no specific comments thereon.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\ Id. at 80081, 80101.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moreover, the delay might also require rearranging already
established operational schedules and business processes. This
potential disruption might be costly and require additional effort from
employees and additional expenses due to, for example, overtime pay.
This potential disruption might especially affect creditors not relying
primarily on third-party vendors. The Bureau believes that mortgage
brokers and settlement agents will incur similar coordination and
implementation costs.
Finally, affected covered persons will incur costs in internal
communications, training, and software re-programming, among other
costs. The Bureau believes that the change in the effective date might
require communicating with any external suppliers of forms and booklets
and potentially ordering additional forms in the current format. Any
pre-ordered Loan Estimates or Closing Disclosures that comply with the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments will still be usable after October
3, and the Bureau does not believe that the current forms are
significantly more expensive than the ones that are required by the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments; thus, there should be no net
increase in expense of procuring forms and booklets. While many of
these costs are already imposed as a result of the delay in the
effective date to the CRA Effective Date (and therefore are not costs
imposed by this final rule), the Bureau believes that some of the costs
may be greater because this final rule further delays the effective
date until October 3.
The Bureau is uncertain as to the extent of the foregoing costs.
The Bureau requested comments on the magnitude of such costs, but there
were no comments submitted that provided a representative basis for
quantification. The Bureau is therefore unable to quantify the costs
for industry participants associated with delaying the effective date
from the CRA Effective Date to October 3, 2015.
C. Impact on Depository Institutions With No More Than $10 Billion in
Assets
The vast majority of the creditors described above have no more
than $10 billion in assets. The Bureau believes that depository
institutions with no more than $10 billion in assets will not be
differentially affected by the extension of the effective date.
D. Impact on Access to Credit
The Bureau does not believe that there will be an adverse impact on
credit availability resulting from this final rule.
E. Impact on Rural Areas
The Bureau does not believe that this final rule will have a unique
impact on consumers in rural areas.
IX. Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA),\39\ as amended by the Small
Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996,\40\ requires each
agency to consider the potential impact of its regulations on small
entities, including small businesses, small governmental units, and
small nonprofit organizations. The RFA defines a ``small business'' as
a business that meets the size standard developed by the Small Business
Administration (SBA) pursuant to the Small Business Act.\41\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ Public Law 96-354, 94 Stat. 1164 (1980).
\40\ Public Law 104-121, section 241, 110 Stat. 847, 864-65
(1996).
\41\ 5 U.S.C. 601(3). The Bureau may establish an alternative
definition after consultation with SBA and an opportunity for public
comment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The RFA generally requires an agency to conduct an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis and a final regulatory flexibility
analysis of any proposed rule subject to notice-and-comment rulemaking
requirements, unless the agency certifies that the proposed rule will
not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities. The Bureau also is subject to certain additional procedures
under the RFA involving the convening of a panel to consult with small
business representatives prior to proposing a rule for which an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis is required.
In the Proposed Rule, the Bureau concluded that the proposed
extension of the effective date, if adopted, would not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities
and that an initial regulatory flexibility analysis was therefore not
required. This final rule adopts the Proposed Rule substantially as
proposed.\42\ Therefore, a final regulatory flexibility analysis is not
required.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\42\ In addition to adopting the Proposed Rule substantially as
proposed, this final rule also includes technical corrections to two
provisions of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule to resolve potential
inconsistencies in the TILA-RESPA Final Rule requirements that could
have resulted in creditors being inadvertently out of compliance.
Under section 601(2) of the RFA, ``rule'' means ``any rule for which
the agency publishes a general notice of proposed rulemaking
pursuant to section 553(b) of this title, or any other law[.]'' As
discussed in Part VII above, the Bureau has found that notice and
comment are unnecessary for the issuance of these technical
corrections. Therefore, these technical corrections are not
considered in the Bureau's RFA certification analysis.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed above, this final rule extends the effective date of
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule and Amendments and technical amendments to
October 3, 2015.
A. Number and Classes of Affected Entities
The following table summarizes the estimated number and type of
entities that will be affected by this final rule.\43\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\43\ The Bureau assumes that all mortgage creditor non-
depository institutions are below the Small Business
Administration's threshold for small entities (annual receipts of
$38.5 million). See 13 CFR 121.201 (listing applicable size standard
for NAICS code 522292). Consistent with the TILA-RESPA Final Rule,
the Bureau has not reviewed the impact on software vendors for the
purposes of this analysis. 78 FR 79730, 80089-100 (Dec. 31, 2013).
[[Page 43920]]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Affected Small affected
Category NAICS codes entities entities
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mortgage Creditors............................ 522110, 522120, 522130, 522292.. 11,150 10,403
Mortgage Brokers.............................. 522310.......................... 7,007 6,895
Settlement Agents............................. 541191.......................... 7,719 7,580
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bureau believes that, as in the section 1022(b)(2) analysis of
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, 5 percent of all creditors, including small
creditors, do not utilize software vendors.\44\ Small creditors who do
not use software vendors could incur greater costs, but the fraction of
small creditors incurring these costs (at most 5 percent) is not
substantial.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\ 78 FR 79730, 80081 (Dec. 31, 2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Certification
Accordingly, the undersigned hereby certifies that this final rule
will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities.
X. Paperwork Reduction Act Analysis
Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (PRA) (44 U.S.C. 3501 et
seq.), Federal agencies are generally required to seek Office of
Management and Budget (OMB) approval for information collection
requirements prior to implementation. Under the PRA, the Bureau may not
conduct or sponsor and, notwithstanding any other provision of law, a
person is not required to respond to an information collection unless
the information collection displays a currently valid control number
assigned by OMB. The collections of information related to the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule, Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Under the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth In Lending Act
(Regulation Z) (78 FR 79730), have been previously reviewed and
approved by OMB in accordance with the PRA and assigned OMB Control
Numbers 3170-0015 (Regulation Z) and 3170-0016 (Regulation X). These
OMB approvals will become active on October 3, 2015, the effective date
of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule as established herein.
The Bureau has determined that this final rule would not have any
new or revised information collection requirements (recordkeeping,
reporting, or disclosure requirements) on covered entities or members
of the public that would constitute collections of information
requiring OMB approval under the PRA.
List of Subjects in 12 CFR Part 1026
Advertising, Consumer protection, Credit, Credit unions, Mortgages,
National banks, Recordkeeping and recordkeeping requirements,
Reporting, Savings associations, Truth in lending.
Authority and Issuance
For the reasons set forth in the preamble, the Bureau amends
Regulation Z, 12 CFR part 1026, as set forth below:
PART 1026--TRUTH IN LENDING (REGULATION Z)
0
1. The authority citation for part 1026 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 12 U.S.C. 2601, 2603-2605, 2607, 2609, 2617, 5511,
5512, 5532, 5581; 15 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.
0
2. In amendatory instruction 5 appearing on page 65325 in the Federal
Register on November 3, 2014, change ``Effective August 1, 2015'' to
read ``Effective October 3, 2015.''
Subpart E--Special Rules for Certain Home Mortgage Transactions
0
3. Section 1026.38 is amended by revising paragraphs (i)(8)(ii),
(i)(8)(iii)(A), and (j)(1)(iv) to read as follows:
Sec. 1026.38 Content of disclosures for certain mortgage transactions
(Closing Disclosure).
* * * * *
(i) * * *
(8) * * *
(ii) Under the subheading ``Final,'' the amount equal to the total
of the amounts disclosed under paragraphs (j)(1)(iii) and (v) through
(x) of this section reduced by the total of the amounts disclosed under
paragraphs (j)(2)(vi) through (xi) of this section.
(iii) * * *
(A) If the amount disclosed under paragraph (i)(8)(ii) of this
section is different than the amount disclosed under paragraph
(i)(8)(i) of this section (unless the difference is due to rounding), a
statement of that fact, along with a statement that the consumer should
see the details disclosed under paragraphs (j)(1)(iii) and (v) through
(x) and (j)(2)(vi) through (xi) of this section; or
* * * * *
(j) * * *
(1) * * *
(iv) The total amount of closing costs disclosed that are
designated borrower-paid at closing, as the sum of the amounts
calculated pursuant to paragraphs (h)(2) and (3) of this section,
labeled ``Closing Costs Paid at Closing'';
* * * * *
0
4. In Supplement I to Part 1026--Official Interpretations, as amended
by 78 FR 79730 (Dec. 31, 2013):
0
A. Under Section 1026.1--Authority, Purpose, Coverage, Organization,
Enforcement and Liability, under Paragraph 1(d)(5), paragraph 1 is
revised.
0
B. Under Section 1026.19--Certain Mortgage and Variable-Rate
Transactions, under 19(g)(2) Permissible changes, paragraph 3 is
revised.
The revisions read as follows:
Supplement I to Part 1026--Official Interpretations
* * * * *
Subpart A--General
Section 1026.1--Authority, Purpose, Coverage, Organization, Enforcement
and Liability
* * * * *
1(d) Organization
Paragraph 1(d)(5)
1. Effective date. The Bureau's revisions to Regulation X and
Regulation Z published on December 31, 2013 (the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule), apply to covered loans (closed-end credit transactions secured
by real property) for which the creditor or mortgage broker receives an
application on or after October 3, 2015 (the ``effective date''),
except that new Sec. 1026.19(e)(2), the amendments to Sec.
1026.28(a)(1), and the amendments to the commentary to Sec. 1026.29,
become effective on October 3, 2015, without respect to whether an
application has been received. The provisions of Sec. 1026.19(e)(2)
apply prior to a consumer's receipt of the disclosures required by
Sec. 1026.19(e)(1)(i), and therefore, restrict activity that may occur
prior to receipt of an application by a creditor or mortgage broker
under Sec. 1026.19(e). These provisions include Sec.
1026.19(e)(2)(i), which restricts the fees that may be imposed on a
consumer, Sec. 1026.19(e)(2)(ii), which requires a statement to be
included on written estimates of terms or costs
[[Page 43921]]
specific to a consumer, and Sec. 1026.19(e)(2)(iii), which prohibits
creditors from requiring the submission of documents verifying
information related to the consumer's application. Accordingly, the
provisions under Sec. 1026.19(e)(2) are effective on October 3, 2015,
without respect to whether an application has been received on that
date. In addition, the amendments to Sec. 1026.28 and the commentary
to Sec. 1026.29 govern the preemption of State laws and thus, the
amendments to those provisions and associated commentary made by the
TILA-RESPA Final Rule are effective on October 3, 2015, without respect
to whether an application has been received on that date. The following
examples illustrate the application of the effective date for the TILA-
RESPA Final Rule.
i. General. Assume a creditor receives an application, as defined
under Sec. 1026.2(a)(3) of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, for a
transaction subject to Sec. 1026.19(e) and (f) on October 3, 2015, and
that consummation of the transaction occurs on October 31, 2015. The
amendments of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, including the requirements to
provide the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure under Sec. 1026.19(e)
and (f), apply to the transaction. The creditor would also be required
to provide the special information booklet under Sec. 1026.19(g) of
the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, as applicable. Assume a creditor receives an
application, as defined under Sec. 1026.2(a)(3) of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule, for a transaction subject to Sec. 1026.19(e) and (f) on
September 30, 2015, and that consummation of the transaction occurs on
October 30, 2015. The amendments of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule,
including the requirements to provide the Loan Estimate and Closing
Disclosure under Sec. 1026.19(e) and (f), do not apply to the
transaction, except that the provisions of Sec. 1026.19(e)(2),
specifically Sec. 1026.19(e)(2)(i), (e)(2)(ii), and (e)(2)(iii), do
apply to the transaction beginning on October 3, 2015, because they
become effective on October 3, 2015, without respect to whether an
application, as defined under Sec. 1026.2(a)(3) of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule, has been received by the creditor or mortgage broker on
that date. The creditor does not provide the Closing Disclosure so that
it is received by the consumer at least three business days before
consummation; instead, the creditor and the settlement agent provide
the disclosures under Sec. 1026.19(a)(2)(ii) and Sec. 1024.8, as
applicable, under the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate
Settlement Procedures Act, respectively. The requirement to provide the
special information booklet under Sec. 1026.19(g) of the TILA-RESPA
Final Rule would also not apply to the transaction. But the creditor
would provide the special information booklet under Sec. 1024.6, as
applicable.
ii. Predisclosure written estimates. Assume a creditor receives a
request from a consumer for a written estimate of terms or costs
specific to the consumer on October 3, 2015, before the consumer
submits an application to the creditor, and thus before the consumer
has received the disclosures required under Sec. 1026.19(e)(1)(i). The
creditor, if it provides such written estimate to the consumer, must
comply with the requirements of Sec. 1026.19(e)(2)(ii) and provide the
required statement on the written estimate, even though the creditor
has not received an application for a transaction subject to Sec.
1026.19(e) and (f) on that date.
iii. Request for preemption determination. Assume a creditor
submits a request to the Bureau under Sec. 1026.28(a)(1) for a
determination of whether a State law is inconsistent with the
disclosure requirements of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule on October 3,
2015. Because the amendments to Sec. 1026.28(a)(1) are effective on
that date and do not depend on whether the creditor has received an
application as defined under Sec. 1026.2(a)(3) of the TILA-RESPA Final
Rule, Sec. 1026.28(a)(1), as amended by the TILA-RESPA Final Rule, is
applicable to the request on that date and the Bureau would make a
determination based on the amendments of the TILA-RESPA Final Rule,
including, for example, the requirements of Sec. 1026.37.
Subpart C--Closed End Credit
* * * * *
Section 1026.19--Certain Mortgage and Variable-Rate Transactions
* * * * *
19(g)(2) Permissible changes.
* * * * *
3. Permissible changes to title of booklets in use before October
3, 2015. Section 1026.19(g)(2)(iv) provides that the title appearing on
the cover of the booklet shall not be changed. Comment 19(g)(1)-1
states that the Bureau may, from time to time, issue revised or
alternative versions of the special information booklet that address
transactions subject to Sec. 1026.19(g) by publishing a notice in the
Federal Register. Until the Bureau issues a version of the special
information booklet relating to the Loan Estimate and Closing
Disclosure under Sec. Sec. 1026.37 and 1026.38, for applications that
are received on or after October 3, 2015, a creditor may change the
title appearing on the cover of the version of the special information
booklet in use before October 3, 2015, provided the words ``settlement
costs'' are used in the title. See comment 1(d)(5)-1 for guidance
regarding compliance with Sec. 1026.19(g) for applications received on
or after October 3, 2015.
* * * * *
Dated: July 20, 2015.
Richard Cordray,
Director, Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.
[FR Doc. 2015-18239 Filed 7-22-15; 11:15 am]
BILLING CODE 4810-AM-P