[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 115 (Tuesday, June 16, 2015)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 34500-34525]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-14232]
[[Page 34499]]
Vol. 80
Tuesday,
No. 115
June 16, 2015
Part II
Department of the Interior
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fish and Wildlife Service
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
50 CFR Part 17
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Listing All Chimpanzees
as Endangered Species; Final Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 80 , No. 115 / Tuesday, June 16, 2015 / Rules
and Regulations
[[Page 34500]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Fish and Wildlife Service
50 CFR Part 17
[Docket No. FWS-R9-ES-2010-0086; 4500030115]
RIN 1018-AZ52
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Listing All
Chimpanzees as Endangered Species
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service), determine
endangered species status for all chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) under
the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act). This rule
eliminates the separate classification of captive and wild chimpanzees
under the Act. We are also amending the rule issued under section 4(d)
of the Act for primates, which is set forth at 50 CFR 17.40(c), by
removing chimpanzees from that rule. This final rule implements the
Federal protections provided by the Act for all chimpanzees, whether
found in captivity or in the wild.
DATES: This rule is effective September 14, 2015.
ADDRESSES: This final rule is available on the Internet at http://www.regulations.gov and comments and materials received, as well as
supporting documentation used in the preparation of this rule, will be
available for public inspection, by appointment, during normal business
hours at: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; 5275 Leesburg Pike; Falls
Church, VA 22041.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Janine Van Norman, Chief, Branch of
Foreign Species, Ecological Services Program, U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service; telephone 703-358-2171; facsimile 703-358-1735. If you use a
telecommunications device for the deaf (TDD), call the Federal
Information Relay Service (FIRS) at 800-877-8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Executive Summary
I. Purpose of the Regulatory Action
We are listing all chimpanzees, whether in the wild or in
captivity, as endangered under the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as
amended (Act). We have determined that the Act does not allow for
captive chimpanzees to be assigned separate legal status from their
wild counterparts on the basis of their captive state, including
through designation as a separate distinct population segment (DPS). It
is also not possible to separate out captive chimpanzees for different
legal status under the Act by other approaches. Therefore, we are
eliminating the separate classification of chimpanzees held in
captivity and listing the entire species, wherever found, as an
endangered species under the Act.
II. Major Provision of the Regulatory Action
This action eliminates separate classifications for wild and
captive chimpanzees under the Act. All chimpanzees, whether in the wild
or in captivity, will be listed as one entity that is an endangered
species in the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife at 50 CFR
17.11(h). This action will also remove the chimpanzee and paragraph
(c)(3) from the rule issued under section 4(d) of the Act for primates,
which is set forth at 50 CFR 17.40(c), and extend the Act's protections
for endangered species to all chimpanzees.
Background
The Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act) (16 U.S.C.
1531 et seq.), is a law that was passed to prevent extinction of
species by providing measures to help alleviate the loss of species and
their habitats. Before an animal or plant species can receive the
protection provided by the Act, it must first be added to the Federal
List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife or the Federal List of
Endangered and Threatened Plants; section 4 of the Act and its
implementing regulations at 50 CFR part 424 set forth the procedures
for adding species to these lists.
Previous Federal Actions
On October 19, 1976, we published in the Federal Register a rule
listing the chimpanzee and 25 other species of primates under the Act
(41 FR 45990); the chimpanzee and 13 of the other primate species were
listed as threatened species. The chimpanzee was found to be a
threatened species based on: (1) Commercial logging and clearing of
forests for agriculture and the use of arboricides; (2) capture and
exportation for use in research labs and zoos; (3) diseases, such as
malaria, hepatitis, and tuberculosis contracted from humans; and (4)
inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms. We simultaneously issued
a rule under section 4(d) of the Act (``4(d) rule'') that the general
prohibitions provided to the threatened species would apply except for
live animals of these species held in captivity in the United States on
the effective date of the rulemaking (November 18, 1976; 41 FR 45990),
progeny of such animals, or the progeny of animals legally imported
into the United States after the effective date of the rulemaking
(November 18, 1976).
On November 4, 1987, we received a petition from the Humane Society
of the United States, World Wildlife Fund, and Jane Goodall Institute,
requesting that the chimpanzee be reclassified from a threatened
species to an endangered species. On March 23, 1988 (53 FR 9460), we
published in the Federal Register a finding, in accordance with section
4(b)(3)(A) of the Act, that the petition had presented substantial
information indicating that the requested reclassification may be
warranted and initiated a status review. We opened a comment period,
which closed July 21, 1988, to allow all interested parties to submit
comments and information.
On December 28, 1988 (53 FR 52452), we published in the Federal
Register a finding that the requested reclassification was warranted
with respect to chimpanzees in the wild. This decision was based on the
petition and subsequent supporting comments that dealt primarily with
the status of the species in the wild and not with the circumstances of
captive populations. We did not propose reclassification of captive
chimpanzees. We found that the 4(d) rule exempting captive chimpanzees
in the United States from the general prohibitions may encourage
propagation, providing surplus animals and reducing the incentive to
remove animals from the wild. On February 24, 1989 (54 FR 8152), we
published in the Federal Register a proposed rule to implement such
reclassification. With publication of the proposed rule, we opened a
60-day comment period to allow all interested parties to submit
comments and information.
On March 12, 1990, we published in the Federal Register (55 FR
9129) a final rule reclassifying the wild populations of the chimpanzee
as endangered species. The captive chimpanzees remained classified as
threatened species, and those within the United States continued to be
covered by the 4(d) rule allowing activities otherwise prohibited.
On March 16, 2010, we received a petition dated the same day, from
Meyer Glitzenstein & Crystal on behalf of The Humane Society of the
United States, the American Association of Zoological Parks and
Aquariums, the Jane Goodall Institute, the Wildlife Conservation
Society, the Pan African Sanctuary Alliance, the Fund for Animals,
Humane Society International, and the New England Anti-Vivisection
Society
[[Page 34501]]
(hereafter referred to as ``petitioners'') requesting that captive
chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) be reclassified as endangered species
under the Act. The petition clearly identified itself as such and
included the requisite identification information for the petitioners,
as required by 50 CFR 424.14(a). The petition contained information on
what the petitioners reported as potential threats to the species from
habitat loss, poaching and trafficking, disease, and inadequate
regulatory mechanisms. On October 12, 2010, we received a letter from
Anna Frostic, Staff Attorney with the Humane Society of the United
States, on behalf of the petitioners clarifying that the March 16,
2010, petition was a petition to list the entire species (Pan
troglodytes) as an endangered species, whether in the wild or in
captivity, pursuant to the Act.
On September 1, 2011, we published in the Federal Register a
finding that the March 16, 2010, petition presented substantial
scientific or commercial information indicating that the requested
action may be warranted, and we initiated a status review (76 FR
54423).
On November 1, 2011, we published in the Federal Register a notice
correcting an incorrect Docket Number given under the ADDRESSES section
of the September 1, 2011, petition finding. We also gave notice that we
were making the large volume of supporting documents submitted with the
petition available to the public. To allow the public adequate time to
review the supporting documents, we extended the period of time for
submitting information to January 30, 2012 (74 FR 67401). On June 12,
2013, the Service published in the Federal Register a proposed rule to
list all chimpanzees as an endangered species under the Act and remove
chimpanzees from the 4(d) rule for primates set forth at 50 CFR
17.40(c) (78 FR 35201).
Summary of Changes From the Proposed Rule
We fully considered comments from the public and the peer reviewer
on the proposed rule to determine our final listing status of
chimpanzees. This final rule incorporates changes to our proposed rule
based on the comments that we received that are discussed below and
newly available scientific and commercial information. We made some
technical corrections and incorporated additional information into our
discussion of diseases. On the basis of an evaluation of the
information we received or incorporated into this final rule we affirm
our determination that listing the chimpanzee as an endangered species
is warranted.
Evaluation of Captive Chimpanzees as a Separate Listable Entity
Under section 3(16) of the Act, we may consider for listing any
species, which includes subspecies of fish, wildlife, and plants, or
any distinct population segment (DPS) of vertebrate fish or wildlife
that interbreeds when mature (16 U.S.C. 1532(16)). Such entities are
considered eligible for separate listing status under the Act (and,
therefore, referred to as listable entities) should we determine that
they meet the definition of an endangered species or threatened
species.
The Service was petitioned to list all chimpanzees, whether in the
wild or in captivity, as endangered species. Essentially, this request
is to eliminate the separate classification of captive chimpanzees from
chimpanzees located in the wild. This petition raised questions
regarding whether the Service has any discretion to differentiate the
listing status of chimpanzees in captivity from those in the wild.
The Service has not had an absolute policy or practice with respect
to this issue, but generally has included wild and captive animals
together when it has listed species. The example set by the separate
chimpanzee listings was used as support for two petitions the Service
received in 2010 to delist U.S. captive and U.S. captive-bred members
of three antelope species in the United States. In the 2005 listing
determination for the scimitar-horned oryx (Oryx dammah), dama gazelle
(Gazella dama), and addax (Addax nasomaculatus) (70 FR 52310, September
2, 2005), the Service found that a differentiation in the listing
status of captive specimens of these antelopes in the United States was
not appropriate. The petitioners, Exotic Wildlife Association, Safari
Club International, and Safari Club International Foundation, asserted
that the treatment by the Service of chimpanzees in 1990 warranted
similar treatment for these antelope species. Because the Service had
not specifically examined whether the current statute, regulations, and
applicable policies provide any discretion to differentiate the listing
status of specimens in captivity from those in the wild, we reviewed
the issues raised by these petitions to ensure the Act is implemented
appropriately. On June 5, 2013, we found that delisting U.S. captive
and U.S. captive-bred members of the three antelope species was not
warranted (78 FR 33790). In addition, on August 9, 2013, the U.S.
District Court for the District of Columbia upheld the Service's
decision to include U.S. captive-bred antelope in its 2005 listing of
the three antelope species as endangered (see Safari Club Int'l v.
Jewell, 960 F. Supp. 2d 17 (D.D.C. 2013)).
For similar reasons and as discussed below, we find that the Act
does not allow for captive chimpanzees to be assigned separate legal
status from their wild counterparts on the basis of their captive
state, including through designation as a separate distinct population
segment (DPS).\1\ It is also not possible to separate out captive
chimpanzees for different legal status under the Act by other
approaches (see Other Potential Approaches for Separate Legal Status).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ As compared to populations that exist in the wild,
``captivity'' is defined as ``living wildlife . . . held in a
controlled environment that is intensively manipulated by man for
the purpose of producing wildlife of the selected species, and that
has boundaries designed to prevent animal [sic], eggs or gametes of
the selected species from entering or leaving the controlled
environment. General characteristics of captivity may include but
are not limited to artificial housing, waste removal, health care,
protection from predators, and artificially supplied food'' (50 CFR
17.3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Provisions of the Act
The legal mandate of section 4(a)(1) is to determine ``whether any
species is an endangered species or a threatened species . . .''
(emphasis added). In the Act, a ``species'' is defined to include any
subspecies and any DPS of a vertebrate animal, as well as taxonomic
species. Other than a taxonomic species or subspecies, captive
specimens (of a vertebrate animal species) would have to qualify as a
``distinct population segment . . . which interbreeds when mature'' to
qualify as a separate DPS.\2\ Nothing in the plain language of the
definitions of ``endangered species,'' ``threatened species,'' or
``species'' expressly indicates that captive chimpanzees can or cannot
have separate status under the Act on the basis of their state of
captivity. However, certain language in the Act is inconsistent with a
determination of separate legal status for captive chimpanzees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ The analysis in this document addresses only where it is not
disputed that the specimens are members of a wildlife species, such
as chimpanzees. This analysis does not address situations where
members of a species have been held in captivity for a sufficiently
long period that they have developed into a separate domesticated
form of the species, including where the domesticated form is
sufficiently distinct to be considered a separate taxonomic species
or subspecies (e.g., domesticated donkey vs. the African wild ass).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under section 4(c)(1), the agency is to specify for each species
listed ``over what portion of its range'' it is an
[[Page 34502]]
endangered or threatened species.\3\ ``Range,'' while not defined in
the Act, consistently has been interpreted under the Act as the general
geographical area of the species in the wild. Thus, chimpanzees held in
captivity and analyzed as a separate listable entity have no ``range''
separate from that of the species to which they belong, at least as
that term has been applied under the Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ Even though the Service has taken the position in its
significant portion of the range (SPR) policy (79 FR 37578) that the
range information called for under section 4(c)(1) is for
information purposes, this statutory language still informs the
question of Congress' intent under the statute.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As demonstrated in various species' listings at 50 CFR 17.11 and
17.12, information in the ``Historic Range'' column is the range of the
species in the wild. For none of these species does the ``range''
information include countries or geographic areas on the basis of where
specimens are held in captivity, even though the Service knows that
specimens of many of these species have long been held in facilities
outside their native range, including in the United States.
Also, in analyzing the ``present or threatened destruction,
modification, or curtailment of [a species'] habitat or range''
(emphasis added) (see section 4(a)(1)(A) of the Act), the Service has
traditionally analyzed habitat threats in the native range of wild
specimens and not included other geographic areas where specimens have
been moved to and are being held in captivity. We are not aware of any
Service listing decision where analysis of threats to the ``range'' has
included geographic areas outside the native range where specimens are
held in captivity.
In analyzing other threats to a species (see sections 4(a)(1)(B),
4(a)(1)(C), 4(a)(1)(D), and 4(a)(1)(E) of the Act), the Service has
also limited its analysis to threats acting upon wild specimens within
the native range of the species, and has not included analysis of
``threats'' to animals held in captivity except as those threats impact
the potential for the captive population to contribute to recovery of
the species in the geographic area where wild specimens are native.
In addition to the use of ``range'' in sections 4(a)(1) and
4(c)(1), the definitions of ``endangered species'' and ``threatened
species'' found in section 3 of the Act also discuss the role of the
species' range in listing determinations. The Act defines an endangered
species as ``any species which is in danger of extinction throughout
all or a significant portion of its range,'' and a threatened species
as ``any species which is likely to become an endangered species within
the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its
range.'' The Service's 2014 Final Policy on Interpretation of the
Phrase ``Significant Portion of Its Range'' in the Endangered Species
Act's Definitions of ``Endangered Species'' and ``Threatened Species''
(79 FR 37578; July 1, 2014) interprets ``range'' as the ``general
geographical area within which that species can be found at the time
[the Service] or [the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)] makes
any particular status determination. This range includes those areas
used throughout all or part of the species' life cycle, even if they
are not used regularly (e.g., seasonal habitats). Lost historical range
is relevant to the analysis of the status of the species, but it cannot
constitute a significant portion of a species' range.'' The ``general
geographical area within which that species can be found'' is broad
enough to include geographic areas where animals have been moved by
humans and are being held in captivity. However, the Service has not
applied the term in this manner in the past and does not intend to do
so in the future. ``Significant portion of its range'' (SPR) analyses
have been and will be limited to geographic areas where specimens are
found in the wild.
Thus, throughout the Act ``range'' has consistently been
interpreted by the Service as being the natural range of the species in
the wild.\4\ For all the reasons discussed above, chimpanzees held in
captivity should not have separate legal status under the Act because
they have no ``range'' that is separate from the range of the species
in the wild to which they belong, as that term is used in the Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ See also Endangered Species Act: Hearings on H.R. 37, H.R.
470, H.R. 471, H.R. 1461, H.R. 1511, H.R. 2669, H.R. 2735, H.R.
3310, H.R. 3696, H.R. 3795, H.R. 4755, H.R. 2169 and H.R. 4758
Before the House Subcomm. on Fisheries and Wildlife Conservation and
the Environment, House Comm. on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, 93d
Cong. 198 (1973) (hereinafter 1973 Hearing on H.R. 37 and others)
(Letter from S. Dillon Ripley, Secretary of Smithsonian Institute,
to Chairman, House Comm. on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, April 23,
1973 (lauding H.R. 4758, the Administration's legislative proposal
that contained a definition of ``endangered species'' substantially
similar to the statutory definition eventually adopted by Congress
in the 1973 Act: ``In effect the bill offers a great deal of
flexibility by providing that a species may be placed on the list if
the Secretary determines that it is presently threatened with
extinction, not only in all of its natural range, but in a
significant part thereof, as well.'') (emphasis added)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Certain provisions in sections 9 and 10 of the Act show that
Congress anticipated that captive animals would have the same legal
status as their wild counterparts by providing certain exceptions for
animals held in captivity. Section 9(b)(1) of the Act provides an
exemption from certain section 9(a)(1) prohibitions for listed animals
held in captivity or in a controlled environment as of the date of the
species' listing (or enactment of the Act), provided the holding in
captivity and any subsequent use is not in the course of a commercial
activity. Section 9(b)(2) of the Act provides an exemption from all
section 9(a)(1) prohibitions for raptors held in captivity or in a
controlled environment as of 1978 and their progeny. Section
10(a)(1)(A) of the Act allows permits to ``enhance the propagation or
survival'' of the species (emphasis added). This demonstrates that
Congress recognized the value of captive-holding and propagation of
listed specimens held in captivity, but intended that such specimens
would be protected under the Act, with these activities generally
regulated by permit.\5\ If captive specimens could simply be excluded
through the listing process, none of these exceptions and permits would
be needed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ See Endangered Species Conservation Act of 1972: Hearing on
S. 249, S. 3199 and S. 3818 Before the Senate Subcomm. on the
Environment, Senate Comm. on Commerce, 92nd Cong. 211-12 (1972)
(statement of Deborah Appel, Assistant to the Director for Public
Information, National Audubon Society) (endorsing S. 3199, a bill
considered by the Senate that contained similar language eventually
adopted by Congress in the purpose section of the 1973 Act, but
advising against a specific mandate requiring captive propagation
because ``the capture of specimens for experiment in captive
propagation may in itself endanger the chances of some rare species
for survival in the wild.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Purpose of the Act
Meaning of Section 2(b) of the Act
The full purposes of the Act, stated in section 2(b), are ``to
provide a means whereby the ecosystems upon which endangered species
and threatened species depend may be conserved [hereafter referred to
as the first purpose], to provide a program for the conservation of
such endangered species and threatened species [hereafter referred to
as the second purpose], and to take such steps as may be appropriate to
achieve the purposes of the treaties and conventions set forth in
subsection (a) of this section [hereafter referred to as the third
purpose].'' It has been stated, without explanation, that the language
of section 2(b) of the Act supports protecting only specimens that
occur in the wild. However, the purposes listed in section 2(b)
indicate that the three provisions are intended to have independent
meaning, with little to indicate that Congress' intent was to protect
only specimens of endangered or threatened
[[Page 34503]]
species found in the wild. The treaties and conventions under the third
purpose are expressly those listed in section 2(a)(4) of the Act, all
of which are for the protection of wildlife and plants, and none of
which is limited to protection of endangered or threatened specimens in
the wild.\6\ The first purpose calls for conservation of ecosystems,
independent of conservation of species themselves (which is separately
listed as the second purpose). This does focus on protection of native
habitats (those inhabited by the species in the wild in its native
range), as it is generally the ecosystems or habitats within which a
species has evolved that are those upon which it ``depends.'' However,
the phrase ``upon which endangered species and threatened species
depend'' indicates only that ecosystem (i.e., habitat) protection
should be focused on that used by endangered and threatened species,
and does not indicate that the sole focus of the Act is conservation of
species within their native ecosystems. Several provisions in the Act
provide authority to protect habitat, independent of authorities
applicable to protection and regulation of specimens of listed species
themselves. See, for example, section 5 (Land Acquisition), section 6
(Cooperation With the States), section 7 (Interagency Cooperation), and
section 8 (International Cooperation).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ Nor are these treaties and conventions limited to protection
of species listed as endangered or threatened under the Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is the second purpose under section 2(b) of the Act that speaks
to the conservation of species themselves that are endangered or
threatened species. However, nothing in the language of the second
purpose indicates that conservation programs should be limited to
specimens located in the wild. The plain language of section 2(b)
refers to ``species,'' with no distinction between wild specimens of
the species as compared to captive specimens of the species. Thus,
nothing in the plain language indicates that captive specimens should
be excluded from the Act's processes and protections that would
contribute to recovery (i.e., ``conservation'') of the entire taxonomic
species. It is true that the phrasing of the second purpose (``to
provide a program for the conservation of such endangered species and
threatened species'' (emphasis added)) links the second purpose of
species recovery to the first purpose of ecosystem (i.e., native
habitat) protection, thus making the goal of the statute recovery of
endangered and threatened species in their natural ecosystems. But
there is nothing in the phrasing to indicate that the specific
provisions of the statute for meeting this goal should be limited to
specimens of the species located within the ecosystems upon which they
depend.
Separate Legal Status Is Inconsistent With Section 2(b)
The potential consequences of captive chimpanzees having separate
legal status under the Act on the basis of their captive state,
particularly where captive specimens could have no legal protection
while wild specimens are listed as an endangered species,\7\ indicate
that such separate legal status is not consistent with the section 2(b)
purpose of conserving endangered and threatened species. Congress
specifically recognized ``overutilization for commercial, recreational,
scientific, or educational purposes'' as a potential threat that
contributes to the risk of extinction for many species. If captive
chimpanzees have separate legal status under the Act, particularly with
no protections under the Act, the threat of overutilization would
potentially increase. The United States is one of the world's largest
markets for wildlife and wildlife products.\8\ Poachers and smugglers
would have increased incentive to remove animals from the wild and
smuggle them into captive-holding facilities in the United States for
captive propagation or subsequent commercial use, because once in
captivity there would be no Act restrictions on use of the captive
specimens or their offspring. This would be a particular issue for
foreign species such as chimpanzees where States regulate native
wildlife (and therefore captive domestic endangered or threatened
specimens would continue to be regulated under State law), but often do
not regulate use of nonnative wildlife. This could be a particularly
lucrative trade for poachers and smugglers because many endangered and
threatened species (particularly foreign species such as chimpanzees)
can be at risk of extinction because of their high commercial value in
trade (as trophies or pets, or for their furs, horns, ivory, shells, or
medicinal or decorative use).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ If it were determined that captive chimpanzees can have
separate legal status on the basis of their captive state,
proponents of separate legal status could argue that these captive
specimens do not qualify as endangered or threatened species at all
because they do not face ``threats'' that create a substantial risk
of extinction to the captive specimens such as those faced by the
wild population, in which case captive chimpanzees would have no
protections under the Act (see Section 4: Listing Effects on Captive
Animals).
\8\ See USFWS Office of Law Enforcement Annual Report for FY
2009 p. 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Once removed from the wild, species such as chimpanzees would
potentially be subject to increased trade in ``laundered'' wild-caught
specimens to feed U.S. or foreign market demand because protected wild
specimens would be generally indistinguishable from unprotected captive
specimens. Because there would be no restriction or regulation on the
taking, sale, import, export, or transport in the course of commercial
activities in interstate or foreign commerce of captive specimens by
persons subject to U.S. jurisdiction, there would be a potential legal
U.S. market in captive specimens and their progeny operating parallel
to any illegal U.S. market (or U.S. citizen participation in illegal
foreign markets) in wild specimens. With the difficulty of
distinguishing captive from wild specimens, especially if they are
broken down into their parts and products, illegal wild specimens of
commercial value could likely easily be passed off as legal captive
specimens and thus be traded as legal specimens. As the court found in
Safari Club Int'l v. Jewell, listing captive members of the species
along with the wild members ``avoids any confusion about the source of
the [animals]'' and therefore is consistent with the purposes of the
Act (960 F. Supp. 2d at 67).
Congress included the similarity-of-appearance provision in section
4(e) to allow the Service to regulate species under the Act where one
species so closely resembles an endangered or threatened species that
enforcement personnel cannot distinguish between the protected and
unprotected species and this difficulty is a threat to the species. The
Service's only option in the situations described above would be to
complete separate similarity-of-appearance listings for captive animals
not regulated under the Act. A similarity-of-appearance listing under
the Act for such captive specimens would become the only means to make
captive specimens subject to the same restrictions as listed wild
specimens and thereby protect the wild populations from overutilization
for commercial, recreational, scientific, or educational purposes.
Operation of Key Provisions of the Act
As described in the following subsections, operation of key
provisions in sections 4 and 7 of the Act also indicate that it would
not be consistent with Congressional intent or the purpose of the Act
to treat captive chimpanzees as a separate listable entity on the basis
of their captive state.
[[Page 34504]]
Section 4: Listing Effects on Captive Animals
The section 4 listing process is not well suited to analyzing
threats to an entirely captive group of specimens that are maintained
under controlled, artificial conditions, and the process could be lead
to consequences that are not consistent with the purposes of the Act.
The majority of the section 4(a)(1) factors would be difficult to
apply to captive specimens with a range independent of wild specimens
because the five factors are not readily suited to evaluating specimens
held in captivity. There may be situations where only disease threats
(factor C) and other natural or manmade factors (factor E) would be
applicable to consideration of purely captive groups of specimens. The
present or threatened destruction, modification, or curtailment of
habitat or range (factor A) may not be a threat for a listable entity
consisting solely of captive specimens, because the physical
environment under which captive specimens are held is generally readily
controllable and, in many cases, optimized to ensure the physical
health of the animal. Overutilization (factor B) is unlikely to be a
factor threatening the continued existence of groups of captive
specimens where both breeding and culling are managed to ensure the
continuation of stock at a desired level based on ownership interest
and market demand. Predation (factor C) may rarely be a factor for
captive specimens because predators may be more readily controlled in
captive situtions. In addition, human management may provide for all
essential life functions, thereby eliminating selection or competition
for mates, food, water resources, and shelter.
It is unclear how the ``inadequacy of existing regulatory
mechanisms'' (factor D) would apply to captive specimens with a range
independent of wild specimens because this factor generally applies in
relationship to threats identified under the other factors. Regulatory
mechanisms applicable to wild specimens usually include measures to
protect natural habitat and laws that regulate activities such as take,
sale, and import and export. However, there might be no regulatory
mechanisms applicable when the group of specimens under consideration
is in captivity (except perhaps general humane treatment or animal
health laws).
That the section 4 process is not well suited to listings of
entirely captive specimens is demonstrated by the previous listing
action for the chimpanzee. The chimpanzee was originally listed in its
entirety as a threatened species (41 FR 45990, October 19, 1976). On
March 12, 1990 (55 FR 9129), the Service reclassified wild populations
of chimpanzees as a separate endangered species, noting that wild
populations had declined due to massive habitat destruction, excessive
hunting and capture by people, and lack of effective national and
international controls. But the reclassification rule never analyzed
whether the newly designated DPS consisting of chimpanzees ``wherever
found in captivity'' separately met the definition of a threatened
species based on the five factors found in section 4(a)(1) of the Act.
Instead, the rule discussed estimated numbers of animals in captivity
and known captive-breeding programs, stating in response to a comment
that some chimpanzee breeding groups were being managed in the United
States with the objective of achieving self-sustainability. The five-
factor analysis in both the proposed and final listing rules considered
only information applicable to wild populations and within the
taxonomic species' native range.
That the section 4 listing process is not well suited to separate
consideration of captive specimens could result in consequences that
would be contrary to the purposes of the Act. Because captive members
of the species and wild members of the species would be under separate
consideration for listing under the Act and therefore under separate
five-factor analyses, some would argue that captive chimpanzees do not
meet the definition of a threatened species or an endangered species
under the statutory factors when the scope of the section 4 analysis
would be the conditions under which the captive specimens are kept, not
the conditions of the members of the species as a whole. They might
argue that captive chimpanzees as well as captive members of other
species do not meet the definition of an endangered species (in danger
of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range) or
a threatened species (likely to become endangered within the
foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its
range) when the conditions for individual animals' survival are
carefully controlled under human management and therefore not subject
to ``threats,'' especially for species that readily breed in captivity,
where breeding has resulted in large numbers of genetically diverse
animals, or where there are no known uncontrollable conditions such as
disease.
If wild specimens and captive specimens could qualify as separate
listable entities and it was determined that captive chimpanzees do not
qualify as a threatened species or an endangered species under the
section 4 analysis because they do not face ``threats,'' captive
chimpanzees would receive no assistance or protection under the Act
even where wild populations continue to decline, even to the point of
the taxonomic species being extirpated from the wild with the animals
in captivity being the only remaining members of the species and
survival of the entire taxonomic species being dependent on the
survival of the captive animals. Indeed, we have been petitioned at
least once in the past to delist captive members of three species--the
three African antelope, one of which is extirpated from the wild--where
the petitioner argued that captive members should be removed from the
list because the captive animals had ``recovered.'' This would not be
consistent with the purposes of the Act.
Section 4: Listing Effects on Wild Populations
If wild populations and captive chimpanzees could qualify as
separate listable entities, and because the analysis for determining
legal status of wild populations would be separate from the analysis
for determining legal status of captive specimens, the wild population
would likely qualify for delisting in the event that all specimens are
extirpated from the wild (in other words, if they became extinct in the
wild), thereby removing both incentives and protections for
conservation of the species in the wild and the conservation of its
ecosystem.
Under the Service's standard section 4 process, both captive and
wild specimens of the species are members of the listed entity and have
legal status as endangered or threatened species. In situations where
all specimens in the wild are gone, either because they are extirpated
due to threats or because, as a last conservation resort, the remaining
wild specimens are captured and moved into captivity, the species
remains listed until specimens from captivity can be reintroduced to
the wild and wild populations are recovered. However, if captive
specimens and wild populations could have separate legal status, once
all members of the wild population were gone from the wild, the wild
population could be petitioned for and would likely qualify for
delisting under 50 CFR 424.11(d)(1) as a ``species'' that is now
extinct. As shown above, the separate
[[Page 34505]]
captive members of the taxonomic species might not qualify for legal
status as endangered or threatened species, due to the lack of
``threats.'' With no protected members of the species and therefore no
authority to use funding or other provisions of the Act for the
species, the Service would lose valuable tools for recovery of the
species to the wild. This would clearly not be consistent with the
purposes of the Act.
Section 7: Consultation
All Federal agencies have a legal obligation to ensure that their
actions are not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of
endangered and threatened species. This means that for separately
listed captive endangered or threatened specimens, any Federal agency
that is taking an action within the United States or on the high seas
that may affect the captive listed species arguably would have a legal
duty to consult with the Service. However, the section 7 consultation
process is not well suited to analysis of adverse impacts posed to a
purely captive group of specimens given that such specimens are
maintained under controlled, artificial conditions.
Section 4: Designation of Critical Habitat
For any listed entity located within the United States or within
U.S. jurisdictional territories or waters, we have a section 4 duty to
designate critical habitat unless such designation is not prudent.\9\
Although it is appropriate not to designate critical habitat for
foreign species or to limit a critical habitat designation to natural
habitats for U.S. species when a listing is focused on the species in
the wild (even when some members of the species may be held in
captivity within the United States), it is not clear how the Service
would support not designating critical habitat when the listed entity
would consist entirely of captive specimens (when the focus of
captivity is within the United States). As with the consultation
process, the critical habitat designation duty is not well suited for
listings that consist entirely of captive specimens, especially given
the anomaly of identifying the physical and biological features that
would be essential to the conservation of a species consisting entirely
of captive animals in a controlled environment. These complexities
related to section 7 consultations and designation of critical habitat
indicate that Congress did not intend the Service to treat captive
specimens as separate listable entities on the basis of their captive
state.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ Making a not determinable finding is also an option under
section 4(b)(6) of the statute, but only delays the requirement to
designate such critical habitat.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Legislative History
Legislative history surrounding the 1978 amendment of the
definition of ``species'' in the Act indicates that Congress intended
designation of a DPS to be used for wild vertebrate populations, not
separation of captive specimens from wild members of the same taxonomic
species. The original (1973) definition of species was ``any subspecies
. . . and any other group of fish or wildlife of the same species or
smaller taxa in common spatial arrangement that interbreed when
mature'' (Pub. L. 93-205). In 1978, Congress amended the Act to the
Act's current definition of species, substituting ``any distinct
population segment'' for ``any other group'' and ``common spatial
arrangement'' following testimony on the inadequacy of the original
definition, such as the exclusion of one category of populations
commonly recognized by biologists: Disjunct allopatric populations that
are separated by geographic barriers from other populations of the same
species and are consequently reproductively isolated from them
physically (See Endangered Species Act Oversight: Hearing Before Senate
Subcommittee on Resource Protection, Senate Committee on Environment
and Public Works, 95th Cong. 50 (July 7, 1977) (hereafter 1977
Oversight Hearing) (letter from Tom Cade, Program Director, The
Peregrine Fund, to Director of the Service). Although there was
discussion regarding population stocks and reproductive isolation
generally, particularly in association with development of the 1973
definition,\10\ discussions that provide additional context on the
scope of the definition of ``species'' show that Congress thought of
the population-based listing authority as appropriate for populations
that are distinct for natural and evolutionary reasons. For example,
one witness discussed ``species'' as associated with the concept of
geographic reproductive isolation and including characteristics of a
population's ability or inability to freely exchange genes in nature
(See 1977 Oversight Hearing at 50 (Cade letter)). There is no evidence
that Congress intended for the agency to use the authority to
separately list groups of animals that have been artificially separated
from other members of the species through human removal from the wild
and maintenance in a controlled environment. Examples in testimony for
which population-based listing authority would be appropriately used
were all for wild populations (See 1973 Hearing on H.R. 37 and others
at 307 (statement of Stephen Seater, Defenders of Wildlife); Endangered
Species Act of 1973: Hearings on S. 1592 and S. 1983 Before the Senate
Subcomm. on Environment, Senate Comm. on Commerce, 93d Cong. 98 (1973)
(statement of John Grandy, National Parks and Conservation Assoc.);
Endangered Species Authorization: Hearings on H.R. 10883 Before the
House Subcomm. on Fisheries and Wildlife Conservation and the
Environment, House Comm. on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, 95th Cong.
560 (1978) (statement of Michael Bean, Environmental Defense Fund)). No
examples were given suggesting designation of captive vertebrates as a
DPS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ See 1973 Hearing on H.R. 37 and others p. 286 (statement of
John Grandy, National Parks and Conservation Assoc.) p. 307
(statement of Stephen Seater, Defenders of Wildlife), and pp. 299-
300 (statement of Tom Garrett, Friends of the Earth).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Potential Approaches for Separate Legal Status
In addition to separate designation as ``species,'' there are two
other approaches under which it could be argued that captive
chimpanzees could be given separate legal status from their wild
counterparts: (1) Directly excluding captive chimpanzees from the Act's
protections, or (2) designating only wild chimpanzees as a DPS, with
captive chimpanzees not included in the DPS. However, neither approach
would be consistent with Congress' intent for the Act.
One court already determined that captive specimens of a listable
entity cannot simply be excluded when they are members of the listable
entity and the Service agrees with the court's reasoning in this case.
The Service cannot exclude captive animals from a listing once these
animals are determined to be part of the species. This case--Alsea
Valley Alliance v. Evans-- involved the listing of coho salmon by NMFS.
NMFS's 1993 Hatchery Policy (58 FR 17573, April 5, 1993) stated that
hatchery populations could be included in the listing of wild members
of the same evolutionary significant unit (equivalent to a DPS), but
only if the hatchery fish were ``essential to recovery.'' In 1998, NMFS
listed only ``naturally spawned'' specimens when it listed an
evolutionary significant unit (ESU) of coho salmon (63 FR 42587, August
10, 1998). This decision was challenged in court, and the Court found
NMFS's
[[Page 34506]]
listing decision invalid because it excluded hatchery populations
(which are fish held in captivity) even though they were part of the
same DPS (or ESU) (Alsea Valley Alliance v. Evans, 161 F. Supp. 2d 1154
(D. Or. 2001)). The Court held that ``Congress expressly limited the
Secretary's ability to make listing distinctions below that of
subspecies or a DPS of a species,'' which was the practical result of
excluding all hatchery specimens. NMFS subsequently changed its
Hatchery Policy in 2005, stating that all hatchery fish that qualify as
members of the ESU would be considered part of the ESU, would be
considered in determining whether the ESU should be listed as an
endangered or threatened species, and would be included in any listing
under the Act (70 FR 37204, June 28, 2005). NMFS's 2005 Hatchery Policy
was upheld by the Ninth Circuit Court in Trout Unlimited v. Lohn, 559
F. 3d 946 (2009).
For the same reasons as discussed earlier in this document, the
Service also cannot simply designate wild chimpanzees as a DPS, leaving
all captive animals unlisted. Although this would avoid designating
captive animals as a separate DPS and would not technically be
excluding animals that otherwise have been found to be members of a DPS
(and thereby avoid the error the court found in the Alsea Valley
Alliance v. Evans decision), the result would be separate legal status
and no legal protections for captive chimpanzees, and many of the same
legal and conservation consequences discussed above would occur. For
these reasons, we also find this outcome to be inconsistent with
Congress' intent for the Act, primarily as inconsistent with the
purposes of the Act.
Listing Evaluation
Now that we have determined that all chimpanzees, including captive
and wild animals, should be considered as a single listable entity
under the Act, we will next assess the status of the species and
determine if the species meets the definition of endangered or
threatened under the Act. In 1990, we determined that chimpanzees in
the wild are endangered. This analysis considers new information in
light of that previous determination and includes the extent to which
captive chimpanzees create or contribute to threats to the species or
remove or reduce threats to the species by contributing to the
conservation of the species.
Species Information
Taxonomy and Species Description
In 1990, when the wild populations of chimpanzees were reclassified
as endangered species, only three subspecies were recognized. Since
that time, the correct taxonomic labeling for chimpanzees has been
debated and includes the use of a two-subspecies system, a four-
subspecies system, and the use of the species level without subspecific
designations (Carlsen et al. 2012, p. 5; Morgan et al. 2011, p. 7;
Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Ghobrial et al. 2010, p. 2; Oates et al.
2008, unpaginated). Today, four subspecies are commonly recognized and
include the Central African chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes troglodytes),
East African chimpanzee (P. t. schweinfurthii), West African chimpanzee
(P. t. verus), and Nigeria-Cameroon chimpanzee (P. t. ellioti) (Morgan
et al. 2011, p. 7; Oates et al. 2009, pp. 78-80; Gonder et al. 2006, p.
1120; Gonder et al. 1997, p. 337).
Characteristics of the chimpanzee include an opposable thumb and
prominent mouth. The skin on a chimpanzee's face, ears, palms, and
soles of the feet are bare, whereas the rest of the body is covered
with brown to black hair. Arms extend beyond the knees. This species
walks ``on all four'' but is able to walk on just its legs for more
than a kilometer (0.6 miles (mi)) (WWF n.d., unpaginated). The male
stands over 1.2 meters (m) (4 feet (ft)) tall and weighs 59 kilograms
(kg) (130 pounds (lb)); the female is closer to 0.9 m (3 ft) tall and
weighs less than 45 kg (100 lb) (AZA 2000, p. 1).
Chimpanzees live in social communities that range from 5 to 150
individuals (Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated). A male dominance
hierarchy forms the core of the community. Males work together to
defend a home range and will occasionally attack and kill individuals
from another community (Lonsdorf 2007, pp. 72, 74). These communities
do not move around in a group like gorillas or monkeys, but rather
spend most of their time in subgroups called parties (Pusey et al.
2007, p. 626; Plumptre et al. 2003, p. 9). Members of a community may
join, or leave, at any time and parties may change frequently in size
and composition depending on presence of receptive females, food
availability, and activity of the party (Lonsdorf 2007, p. 72; Lehmann
and Boesch 2004, p. 207; Humle 2003, p. 17; Plumptre et al. 2003, p.
9).
Males remain in the community in which they were born; however,
once females become sexually mature, between the ages of 9 and 13, they
leave the community to join a new one (Humle 2003, p. 16). Chimpanzees
are slow breeders; females do not give birth until they are 12 years of
age or older and only have one infant every 5 or 6 years. Infants are
weaned around 4 years old, and stay with their mothers until they are
about 8 to 10 years old (Lonsdorf 2007, p. 72; Kormos 2003, p. 1;
Plumptre et al. 2003, pp. 8, 10, 13). The relationship between the
mother and her offspring is critical; young may not survive being
orphaned, even after they are weaned (Lonsdorf 2007, p. 72).
Essential Needs of the Species
The chimpanzee lives in a variety of moist and dry forest habitats
including savanna woodlands, mosaic grassland forests, and tropical
moist forests (Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Pusey et al. 2007, p.
626; GRASP 2005a, p. 6; Butynski 2003, p. 6). In general, chimpanzees
need large areas to provide sufficient resources for feeding, nesting,
and shelter (Carter 2003b, p. 158). However, home ranges may vary
depending on the quality of habitat and community size; competition for
food and predation risk may also play a role. Home ranges average 12.5
square kilometers (km\2\) (8 square miles (mi\2\)), but can range from
5-400 km\2\ (3-249 mi\2\) (Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Humle 2003,
pp. 17-18).
Chimpanzees are omnivores; half their diet is ripe fruit, but they
also feed on leaves, bark, stems, insects, and mammals, mostly red
colobus (Procolobus spp.), but also black-and-white colobus (Colobus
guereza), and occasionally blue duikers (Philantomba monticola) and
red-tailed guenons (Cercopithecus ascanius). Diets vary seasonally and
between populations, depending on food availability and habitat type
(Oates 2013, pers. comm.; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Pusey et al.
2007, p. 626; Humle 2003, pp. 13-14; Watts and Mitani 2002, p. 7).
Chimpanzees build arboreal nests in which they sleep at night and
may rest during the day (Plumptre et al. 2003, p. 10; Humle 2003, p.
15). Nests are constructed by preparing a foundation of solid side
branches; bending, breaking, and interweaving side branches crosswise;
then bending smaller twigs in a circle around the rim. Chimpanzees
exhibit strong preferences for certain tree species for nesting,
independent of their availability in the habitat. Choice of nesting
sites is variable across populations and communities of chimpanzees and
is dependent on habitat structure, resource distribution, predation
levels, and human disturbance. Chimps can be
[[Page 34507]]
deterred from nesting in certain areas where human habitation is
concentrated. As a result, human presence influences nesting behavior
and can put chimpanzees at risk of predators, as habitats where they
relocate nests to avoid humans may not provide sufficient protection
(Humle 2003, pp. 15-16).
Range and Population
Historically, this species may have spanned most of Equatorial
Africa, from Senegal to southwest Tanzania, ranging over 25 countries
(Butynski 2003, p. 6). Today, the chimpanzee is reported as extirpated
in Benin, Togo, and Burkina Faso; however, there are a few recent
reports of chimpanzees in eastern Togo and reports of chimpanzees
migrating into Burkina Faso from C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire during the rainy
season. The species now occurs in a wide but discontinuous distribution
over 22 countries in an area approximately 2,342,000 km\2\ (904,000
mi\2\) (Mitchell and Gonder 2013, p. 1; Oates 2013, pers. comm.;
Carlsen et al. 2012, p. 5; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Kormos and
Boesch 2003, p. 1; Butynski 2003, pp. 6, 7; Brownell 2003a, p. 117;
Brownell 2003b, p. 121).
Chimpanzees are thought to have numbered in the millions at the
beginning of the 20th century, although there are no hard data to
support this. Chimpanzee populations are believed to have declined by
66 percent, from 600,000 to 200,000 individuals before the 1980s
(Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 1). Since the 1980s, estimates for the
chimpanzee have varied, but in general have increased over the past
three decades (see Table 1) (Oates 2006, pp. 102-104; Butynski 2003, p.
10). Using the latest population estimates for each subspecies, the
chimpanzee, today, totals between 294,800 and 431,100 individuals;
although we note that this estimate does not factor in a recent
calamitous decline in the chimpanzee population of C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire
(see below). The range countries and most recent population estimates
for each subspecies are outlined in Table 2.
Table 1--Historical Population Estimates for Chimpanzee
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Year Estimated population Source
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1900........................................ 1,000,000 Teleki in Butynski 2003, p. 10; Oates 2006, p. 104.
1900........................................ 2,000,000 Goodall 2000 in Butynski 2003, p. 10.
1960........................................ >1,000,000 Goodall 2000 in Butynski 2003, p. 10.
1979........................................ 20,000-200,000 Lee et al. 1988 in Oates 2006, p. 103.
1987........................................ 151,000-235,000 Teleki in Butynski 2003, p. 10; Oates 2006, p. 104.
1989........................................ <=150,000 Goodall 2000 in Butynski 2003, p. 10.
1989........................................ 145,000-228,000 Teleki 1991 in Butynski 2003, p. 10.
2000........................................ 152,200-254,600 Butynski 2001 in Oates 2006, p. 104.
2003........................................ 173,000-300,000 Butynski 2003, p. 10.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2--Range Countries and Population Estimates for Each Chimpanzee Subspecies
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subspecies Range countries Population estimate Reference
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eastern (P.t. schweinfurthii)... Burundi, Central 200,000-250,000 Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 22.
African Republic,
Democratic Republic of
Congo, Rwanda, Sudan,
Tanzania, Uganda.
Nigeria-Cameroon (P.t. ellioti). Cameroon, Nigeria...... 3,500-9,000 Morgan et al. 2011, p. 4.
Central (P.t. troglodytes)...... Angola, Cameroon, 70,000-116,500 Butynski 2003, p. 8.
Central African
Republic, Congo, The
Democratic Republic of
Congo, Equatorial
Guinea, Gabon.
Western (P.t. verus)............ Burikina Faso, 21,300-55,600 Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 3; Butynski 2003, p. 8.
C[ocirc]te d'lvoire,
Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-
Bissau, Liberia, Mali,
Nigeria, Senegal,
Sierra Leone.
-------------------------
Total....................... ....................... 294,800-431,100
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As stated above, the chimpanzee population has appeared to increase
since the 1980s. However, this estimated increase is believed to be a
result of previous difficulties in producing accurate estimates
combined with the more recent availability of new information, rather
than an actual increase in chimpanzee numbers (Oates 2006, p. 104).
Some of the difficulties associated with earlier estimates include: Few
areas being adequately surveyed; some chimpanzee populations survived
at densities too low for accurate detection; survey methods lacked
precision to enable extrapolation to large areas of potential habitat;
some surveys were outdated; and in many cases estimates were simply
best guesses (Morgan et al. 2011, p. 9; Plumptre et al. 2010, pp. 5, 7,
9, 31, 41; Campbell et al. 2008, p. 904; Oates 2006, p. 102; Tutin et
al. 2005, p. 6; GRASP 2005a, p. 7; Butynski 2003, p. 5; Kormos and
Bakarr 2003, p. 29). When more careful surveys of chimpanzees are made,
higher estimates are produced, indicating that previous estimates
underestimated the size of surviving populations (Oates 2006, p. 104).
Therefore, the estimated increase in chimpanzees is not evidence of
steady increase in the population, but a result of inaccurate early
estimates to which newer estimates are compared.
Despite the appearance of an increase in chimpanzee numbers,
experts agree that chimpanzee populations are declining (Plumptre et
al. 2010, p. 1; Greengrass 2009, pp. 77, 80-82; Kabasawa 2009, p. 37;
Campbell et al. 2008, pp. 903-904; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated;
Oates 2006, p. 110; Tutin 2005, p. 2; GRASP 2005a, p. 3; Kormos and
Boesch 2003, p. 2; Butynski 2003, p. 11; Nishida et al. 2001, pp. 45-
46). Data to support a declining trend come from nationwide surveys of
Gabon, C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire, and Tanzania; data from long-term
chimpanzee research sites; a
[[Page 34508]]
questionnaire survey of great ape field researchers; and the expansion
and increasing intensity of threats (Junker et al. 2012, p. 3; Plumptre
et al. 2010, p. 8; Oates 2006, pp. 105-106; Nishida et al. 2001, p. 45;
Campbell et al. 2008, pp. 903-904; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 32). One of
the greatest documented losses of chimpanzees comes from a 2007 survey
of C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire, which found a 90 percent decline in the total
nest encounter rate since the last survey conducted in 1989-1990,
indicating a significant loss of chimpanzees from a country once
thought to be one of the final strongholds of the western chimpanzee
(Campbell et al. 2008, p. 903). Many remaining populations are now
small and isolated, and face serious threats (Oates 2006, pp. 104,
110). Furthermore, the chimpanzee is reported to already have been
extirpated from three countries. Due to national populations fewer than
1,000 individuals, there is concern that the chimpanzee could soon be
extirpated from Senegal, Ghana, and Guinea-Bissau (Carlsen et al. 2012,
p. 5; Butynski 2003, p. 11).
In addition to wild populations, chimpanzees are held in captivity
in several countries around the world, including African countries and
the United States. We do not have detailed information on the number,
subspecies, or location of captive chimpanzees. However, we did find
information indicating that 70 chimpanzees are living in sanctuaries in
Cameroon and Nigeria (Morgan et al. 2011, p. 9). Approximately 171
chimpanzees are living in sanctuaries throughout West Africa; another
478 chimpanzees in the region are known to be held outside of
sanctuaries (e.g., in homes or hotels) (Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 4).
Within the United States, approximately 2,000 chimpanzees are in
captivity (ChimpCare 2013, unpaginated; Ross et al. 2008, p. 1,487).
Summary of Threats
Threats to the chimpanzee have intensified and expanded since 1990,
when wild populations of the chimpanzee were listed as an endangered
species. Across its range, high deforestation rates are destroying,
degrading, and fragmenting forests the chimpanzee needs to support
viable populations and provide food and shelter. Widespread poaching,
capture for the pet trade, and outbreaks of disease are removing
individuals needed to sustain viable populations; recovery from the
loss of individuals is more difficult given the slow reproductive rates
of chimpanzees. These actions are exacerbated by an increasing human
population, the expansion of settlements, and increasing pressure on
natural resources to meet the needs of the growing population (Morgan
et al. 2011, p. 10; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Kabasawa 2009, p. 37;
Campbell et al. 2008, p. 903; Lonsdorf 2007, p. 72; Unti 2007a, p. 4;
Unti 2007b, p. 5; Bennett 2006, p. 885; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 1; GRASP
2005a, p. 3; Kormos 2003, pp. ix, 1; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 4;
Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 97; Walsh et al. 2003, pp. 611-612; Carter et
al. 2003, p. 38).
Deforestation, with consequent access and disturbance by humans,
remains a major factor in the decline of chimpanzee populations across
their range. Although some large forest blocks remain, commercial
logging and the conversion of forests to agricultural land, especially
for oil palm production, continue to severely reduce and fragment
chimpanzee habitat (Morgan et al. 2011, pp. 12, 18, 19, 26, 31;
Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Unti 2007a,
p. 4; Unti 2007b, p. 5; CBFP 2006, p. 16; Fa et al. 2006, p. 498; Tutin
et al. 2005, pp. 1, 2, 10, 12, 14-17, 21-23; Humle 2003, p. 150; Carter
et al. 2003, p. 38; Duvall et al. 2003, p. 47; Gippoliti et al. 2003,
p. 57; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, p. 83; Herbinger et al. 2003, pp. 106,
109; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 71; Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 151; Magnuson
et al. 2003, p. 113; Nisbett et al. 2003, pp. 95, 97; Oates et al.
2003, p. 129; Walsh et al. 2003, p. 613; Parren and Byler 2003, p.
135). As the human population and economic development have increased,
pressure on forest resources has also increased. This increasing
pressure has led to uncontrolled legal and illegal forest conversion
within and outside of protected areas (e.g., national parks and forest
reserves), leaving them destroyed and fragmented (Greengrass 2009, pp.
77, 80; Campbell et al. 2008, p. 903; CBFP 2006, pp. 16, 33; Nasi et
al. 2006, p. 14; Carter et al. 2003, p. 38; Duvall et al. 2003, p. 47;
Herbinger et al. 2003, p. 109; Magnuson et al. 2003, p. 113; Oates et
al. 2003, p. 129; Parren and Byler 2003, pp. 135, 137).
The natural protection once afforded to chimpanzees by large blocks
of suitable habitat, isolated from human activities, is disappearing
due to logging activity. Much of the chimpanzee's range is already
allocated to logging concessions, and logging operations, both legal
and illegal, are expanding (Morgan et al. 2011, pp. 12, 26; Laporte et
al. 2007, p. 1451; Morgan and Sanz 2007, pp. 3, 5; CBFP 2006, p. 29;
Hewitt 2006, p. 43; Nasi et al. 2006, p. 14; Tutin 2005, pp. 2, 4, 12,
30, 32; Kormos et al. 2003a, p. 29). Heavy pressures on timber
resources have led to cutting cycles that occur too frequently in an
area to allow for proper regrowth, resulting in rapid degradation of
forests (Parren and Byler 2003, p. 135). In addition to clearing
forests, logging operations often create a network of roads for
transporting timber. These roads provide greater access to forests that
were once inaccessible, facilitate the establishment of human
settlements, and are accompanied by further deforestation from the
conversion of forests to agriculture (Junker et al. 2012, p. 7; Morgan
et al, 2011, p. 12; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Greengrass 2009, p. 80;
Laporte et al. 2007, p. 1451; Hewitt 2006, p. 44; Duvall 2003, p. 143;
Oates et al. 2003, p. 129; Parren and Byler 2003, pp. 133, 137-138).
Human population growth and agricultural expansion have destroyed
and fragmented forests across the range of the chimpanzee and are two
of the greatest threats to chimpanzee survival. The spread of large-
scale commercial plantations, including oil palm plantations, results
in additional land being cleared of most vegetation and planting crops
in monocultures; plantations and farms have been established in
suitable chimpanzee habitat, including within protected areas (Oates
2013, pers. comm.; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 9; Greengrass 2009, p. 80;
Unti 2007a, p. 4; Unti 2007b, p. 5; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 20; Duvall
2003, p. 143; Gippoliti et al. 2003, pp. 55, 57; Hanson-Alp et al.
2003, p. 83; Humle 2003, p. 147; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 63; Magnuson
et al. 2003, p. 113; Parren and Byler 2003, p. 138). In West Africa,
most unreserved forests have been converted to cultivation (Parren and
Byler 2003, p. 138). Agricultural practices are largely unsustainable
and are encroaching into additional forested areas (Parren and Byler
2003, p. 133).
Chimpanzees are highly adaptive and occur in a variety of habitats,
including primary, secondary, and regenerating forests, logged forests,
and plantations; they have even been found living in close proximity to
humans. However, the loss, or even the degradation, of the chimpanzee's
traditional habitat can affect their survival by impacting the species'
food resources, behavior, susceptibility to disease, and abundance and
distribution (Morgan and Sanz 2007, p. 1; Carter et al. 2003, p. 36;
Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, p. 83; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 18; Nisbett
et al. 2003, p. 97; Parren and Byler 2003, p. 137).
Although chimpanzees feed on a wide variety of foods, their energy
requirements, as large primates with
[[Page 34509]]
large home ranges, predispose them to a reliance on high-energy fruits
(Greengrass 2009, p. 81). Removal, or lowering the quality, of habitat
through logging activity or establishment of agricultural lands
destroys the structure and composition of the forest, eliminating
essential food sources, which can affect sociability, condition of
individuals, and female reproductive success, and increase
vulnerability to diseases or parasites and infant and juvenile
mortality (Greengrass 2009, pp. 81-82). Even in areas with lower levels
of logging where essential food sources were unaffected, chimpanzee
densities have declined significantly and remained low for years.
Clear-cutting results in total habitat loss, and because of severe soil
erosion, the potential for future forest regeneration is also lost
(Parren and Byler 2003, pp. 137-138).
The loss or reduction of food sources and the noise and disturbance
from logging activity can cause chimpanzee communities to abandon their
home range to find a new home range with sufficient resources and less
human activity. These chimpanzees may enter another community's
territory, which can lead to further competition for resources and
conflict that can lead to death. As habitat is lost or fragmented and
chimpanzee populations are forced into smaller forest fragments, lethal
interactions with other chimpanzees may increase. Furthermore,
chimpanzees may be cautious about reinhabiting previous home ranges
where they were displaced by humans (Morgan et al. 2011, p. 12;
Lonsdorf 2007, p. 74; Carter et al. 2003, p. 36; Parren and Byler 2003,
pp. 137-138). If the displacement of chimpanzees forces them into
suboptimal habitat, they may not have sufficient protection from
predators, especially at night (Humle 2003, pp. 15-16).
The loss or reduction of food sources due to expanding logging,
agriculture, and human settlements into chimpanzee habitat has also
resulted in increased conflicts between humans and chimpanzees
(Tacugama Sanctuary 2013, unpaginated; Unti 2007b, p. 5; Tweheyo et al.
2005, pp. 237-238, 244; Herbinger et al. 2003, p. 106; Humle 2003, p.
147; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 71; Naughton-Treves et al. 1998, pp. 597,
600). Lack of sufficient wild food and an increase in farming and human
presence have increased the occurrence of crop raiding to supplement
the chimpanzee's diet. Crop raiding can cause substantial losses to
farmers, reduce the tolerance of humans to chimpanzee presence, and
increase killing chimpanzees to protect valuable crops or in
retaliation for the destruction of crops (Tacugama Chimpanzee Sanctuary
2013, unpaginated; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Bennett et al. 2006,
p. 885; Tweheyo et al. 2005, p. 245; Duvall 2003, p. 144; Carter et al.
2003, p. 36; Gippoliti et al. 2003, p. 57; Humle 2003, pp. 147, 150;
Parren and Byler 2003, p. 138; Naughton-Treves 1998, p. 597).
Unsustainable hunting for the bushmeat trade is one of the major
causes of the decline in chimpanzees, and continues to be a major
threat to the survival of chimpanzees in protected and unprotected
areas (Ghobrial et al. 2011, pp. 1, 2, 11; Morgan et al. 2011, p. 10;
Hicks et al. 2010, pp. 1, 3, 6, 11; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2;
Kabasawa 2009, p. 37; Campbell et al. 2008, p. 903; Oates et al. 2008,
unpaginated; Lonsdorf 2007, p. 74; Unti 2007b, p. 5; Tutin et al. 2005,
pp. 1, 10-23, 27-28; Herbinger et al. 2003, p. 109; Humle 2003, p. 17;
Kormos and Boesch 2003, pp. 2, 14, 16, 19; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 63;
Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 151; Magnuson et al. 2003, pp. 111, 113;
Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 95; Oates et al. 2003, pp. 123, 129; Nishida et
al. 2001, p. 47; Bowen-Jones 1998, p. 12). Growth in the human
population in Africa has increased the demand for wild animal meat, or
bushmeat. Expansion of logging activities, including the construction
of logging roads, has facilitated a significant market, much of it
illegal, for commercial bushmeat to meet this demand (Amati et al.
2009, p. 6; Kabasawa 2009, pp. 50-51; AV Oates et al. 2008,
unpaginated; Fa et al. 2006, pp. 503, 506; Magazine 2003, p. 7; Kormos
et al. 2003c, p. 151; Walsh et al. 2003, p. 613; Nishida et al. 2001,
p. 47; Bowen-Jones 1998, pp. 1, 11). Logging roads and vehicles provide
access to the forests and a means to export meat to markets and cities.
Logging operations are accompanied by an onslaught of workers who are
encouraged to hunt to provide for their own needs and commercial
hunters who operate in forests to supply the needs of forestry workers
and to trade outside of the forested areas (Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2;
Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 151; Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 95; Walsh et al.
2003, p. 613; Nishida et al. 2001, p. 47; Bowen-Jones 1998, p. 1).
Furthermore, bushmeat trade is also an important livelihood and the
primary source of protein for humans in much of the chimpanzee's range
(Abwe and Morgan 2008, p. 26; Fa et al. 2006, p. 507; Bennett et al.
2006, p. 885; Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 155; Wilkie and Carpenter 1999,
p. 927).
The intensity of hunting chimpanzees varies by country and region
(Kormos et al. 2003c, pp. 151-152). Religious, traditional, and
familial taboos against the killing of chimpanzees and the consumption
of their meat exist in many areas (Hicks et al. 2010, p. 9; Plumptre et
al. 2010, p. 2; Greengrass 2009, p. 81; Kabasawa 2009, p. 51; Unti
2007a, p. 4; Carter et al. 2003, pp. 31, 38; Duvall et al. 2003, p. 47;
Gippoliti et al. 2003, pp. 55, 57; Humle 2003, p. 18; Kormos and Boesch
2003, pp. 10, 13; Kormos et al. 2003b, pp. 63, 71; Kormos et al. 2003c,
pp. 152, 154; Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 95; Oates et al. 2003, p.
129;Waller and Reynolds 2001, p. 135; Bowen-Jones 1998, pp. 19, 27).
However, these areas may be hunted by people from surrounding areas
where there is demand for chimpanzee meat (Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 72).
Furthermore, these traditions and beliefs are not necessarily being
passed down to younger generations and cannot be relied on to protect
chimpanzees in the future (Hicks et al. 2010, p. 9; Unti 2007a, p. 4;
Oates et al. 2003, p. 129).
Despite the high demand for bushmeat, primates do not represent the
majority of animals killed for the bushmeat trade (AV Magazine 2003, p.
7; Magnuson et al. 2003, p. 113; Walsh et al. 2003, p. 613; Nishida et
al. 2001, p. 47; Bowen-Jones 1998, p. 1). In fact, studies have found
that chimpanzee meat makes up only a small fraction of the meat found
in markets; estimates from different regions have ranged from 0.01 to 3
percent (Kabasawa 2009, p. 38; Fa et al. 2006, p. 502; Herbinger et al.
2003, p. 106; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 2; Kormos et al 2003c, pp.
151-152). However, because the sale of ape meat is often hidden and the
meat may be eaten in villages and never make it to markets, the
proportion of chimpanzee meat in bushmeat markets could be greater than
reported (Kabasawa 2009, p. 38; Kormos et al. 2003c, pp. 151-152;
Bowen-Jones 1998, p. 21). Hunting pressure even at a low level is
enough to result in the local extirpation of large chimpanzee
populations. Low population densities and slow reproductive rates
prevent chimpanzees from recovering easily from the loss of several
individuals (Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Fa et al. 2006, p. 503; AV
Magazine 2003, p. 7; Duvall et al. 2003, p. 47; Herbinger et al. 2003,
p. 106; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 2; Kormos et al. 2003c, pp. 151,
153; Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 95; Magnuson et al. 2003, p. 113; Bowen-
Jones 1998, p. 13).
Threats to the chimpanzee from habitat loss and commercial hunting
have been exacerbated by civil unrest that has occurred in several
chimpanzee range countries (Plumptre et al. 2010, pp. 4-5; Campbell et
al. 2008, p. 903; CBFP 2006, p. 16; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, p. 85;
Nisbett et al. 2003, pp. 89,
[[Page 34510]]
95; Draulans and Van Krunkelsven 2002, pp. 35-36). During civil
conflict, many people, including refugees, military groups, and rebels,
take shelter in interior forests and protected areas (Plumptre et al.
2010, p. 4; CBFP 2006, p. 16). The presence of soldiers and displaced
refugees increases the number of people that rely on bushmeat for
protein. Not only do soldiers hunt, but they also supply locals with
weapons and ammunition to hunt them (Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 5;
Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, p. 85; Draulans and Van Krunkelsven 2002, pp.
35-36). Civil unrest has contributed to a significant loss of wildlife,
including chimpanzees (Campbell et al. 2008, p. 903; Hanson-Alp et al.
2003, p. 85).
Capture of live chimpanzees for the pet trade has been one of the
major causes of the decline in chimpanzees. Today, illegal capture and
smuggling of chimpanzees continue for the pet trade across Africa and,
to some extent, the international market (Ghobrial et al. 2010, pp. 1,
2, 11; Kabasawa 2009, pp. 37, 48-49; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated;
Carter 2003b, p. 157; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 4; Nisbett et al.
2003, p. 95). A recent increase in orphaned chimpanzees has been
attributed to the growing bushmeat crisis. Killing a mother with an
infant earns twice the income for the hunter; the mother's body is sold
in the bushmeat trade while the infant enters the pet trade (Kabasawa
2009, p. 50; Carter 2003b, p. 157). Furthermore, hunters have found a
lucrative market for pet chimpanzees with military personnel, police,
government officials, and traditional chiefs (Hicks et al. 2010, p. 8;
Draulans and Van Krunkelsven 2002, pp. 35-36). The intensity of trade
differs among countries, but is reportedly a substantial problem in The
Democratic Republic of the Congo, C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire, Sierra Leone,
Ghana, and Guinea (Hicks et al. 2010, pp. 3, 6, 11; Plumptre et al.
2010, p. 2; Unit 2007, p. 5; Unti 2007a, p. 4; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003,
p. 84; Herbinger et al. 2003, p. 106; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 72;
Magnuson et al. 2003, p. 113). It is not possible to determine how many
wild chimpanzees are captured for the pet trade, but the number of
chimpanzees in sanctuaries that were either confiscated from owners by
authorities, surrendered by owners after being informed about wildlife
laws, or voluntarily donated or abandoned by owners indicates it is a
significant problem. Since 2000, the number of chimpanzees in African
sanctuaries has increased 59 percent (Kabasawa 2009, pp. 37, 44-45,
50).
The petitioners assert that the exploitation of chimpanzees in the
U.S. entertainment and pet industries is seen around the world and
misleads the public into believing chimpanzees are well protected in
the wild and make good pets, further fueling the demand for
chimpanzees. Studies suggest a link between seeing chimpanzees
portrayed in the media and misperceptions about the species' status in
the wild. This misperception may also affect conservation efforts (Ross
et al. 2011, pp. 1, 4-5; Schroepfer et al. 2011, pp. 6-7; Ross 2008a,
pp. 25-26; Ross et al. 2008b, p. 1487). However, we did not find
evidence that this situation was a significant driver in the status of
the species under the Act.
The effects of the pet trade are particularly devastating to wild
populations because the mother and other family members may be killed
to capture an infant. Researchers estimate that as many as 10
chimpanzees may be killed for every infant that enters the pet trade.
Furthermore, the infant is likely to die of malnutrition, disease, or
injury (Hicks et al. 2010, p. 8; Kabasawa 2009, p. 49; Lonsdorf 2007,
p. 74; Carter 2003b, p. 157; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, p. 84; Kormos and
Boesch 2003, p. 4). The loss of even just a few individuals from a
population can have devastating effects due to the slow reproductive
rate of chimpanzees. Because so many chimpanzees may be killed to
secure an infant, the pet trade has a significant draining effect on
remaining populations, and threatens the survival of wild chimpanzees
(Kabasawa 2009, p. 49; Carter 2003b, p. 157; Magnuson et al. 2003, p.
113).
Historically, wild chimpanzees were captured and exported to meet a
significant demand for chimpanzees in biomedical research in countries
around the world, significantly impacting chimpanzee distribution and
abundance (Unti 2007a, p. 4; Unti 2007b, p. 5; Kormos et al. 2003b, p.
72). A substantial number of countries do not permit or conduct
research on chimpanzees, and the international research community is no
longer seeking access to wild chimpanzees (Hicks 2011, pers. comm.;
Unti 2007a, p. 4; Unti 2007b, p. 5). Although some biomedical research
on captive chimpanzees continues in the United States and Gabon, in the
United States, there is a decreasing scientific need for chimpanzee
studies due to the emergence of non-chimpanzee models and technologies
(Institute of Medicine 2011, pp. 5, 66-67).
As previously stated, chimpanzees are held in captivity in several
countries around the world, including African countries and the United
States. Chimpanzees in captivity are bred and sold as pets, used in the
entertainment industry (e.g., movies, television, and advertisements),
exhibited in hotels and roadside shows, used as party entertainment or
animal encounters, displayed in zoos, and used for biomedical research.
It is thought that self-sustaining breeding groups of captive
chimpanzees provide surplus animals for research and other purposes,
thereby reducing the demand for wild individuals. Although captive
chimpanzees may have removed the demand for wild chimpanzees in
biomedical research, given that threats to the chimpanzee have expanded
and intensified, and capture for the illegal pet trade continues to be
a major threat to remaining chimpanzee populations, it does not appear
that the availability of captive chimpanzees has reduced any threats to
the species.
National laws exist within all range countries to protect
chimpanzees. In general, hunting, capture, possession, and commercial
trade of chimpanzees are prohibited. Laws also protect chimpanzee
habitat, including the establishment of protected areas, in many of the
range countries. However, as evidenced by the continuing and increasing
habitat destruction and hunting and trading of this species (Ghobrial
et al. 2010, pp. 1, 2, 11; Hicks et al. 2010, pp. 8-9; Kabasawa 2009,
p. 39; Laporte et al. 2009, p. 1451; Unti 2007a, pp. 4, 6, 10-11; Unti
2007b, p. 6, 8, 10; Bennett et al. 2006, p. 885; AV Magazine 2003, p.
7; Carter 2003a, p. 52; Carter 2003b, p. 157; Carter et al. 2003, pp.
31, 32, 38; Duvall et al. 2003, p. 47; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, pp. 79,
87; Herbinger et al. 2003, pp. 100, 106; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 6;
Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 64; Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 155; Magnuson et
al. 2003, p. 112; Nisbett et al. 2003, pp. 90, 95; Oates et al. 2003,
p. 123), even within protected areas, these laws are not often
enforced. A lack of resources, limited training, limited personnel,
lack of basic logistical support, corrupt officials, and weak
legislation prevent government agencies charged with the protection of
wildlife and forest management from providing effective protection
(Hicks et al. 2010, p. 9; Unti 2007a, pp. 4, 6, 8; Unti 2007b, p. 7-10;
Bennett et al. 2006, p. 887; AV Magazine 2003, p. 7; Duvall et al.
2003, p. 47; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, pp. 79, 87; Magnuson et al. 2003,
p. 112; Nisbett et al. 2003, p. 95; Oates et al. 2003, p. 125).
Furthermore, penalties for violations are not adequate to serve as a
deterrent (Unti 2007b, p. 8; Hanson-Alp et al. 2003, pp. 79; Kormos and
Boesch 2003, p. 6; Kormos et al. 2003c, p. 155).
[[Page 34511]]
The chimpanzee is also protected under the Convention on
International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora
(CITES), an international agreement between governments to ensure that
the international trade of CITES-listed plant and animal species does
not threaten species' survival in the wild. Under this treaty, CITES
Parties (member countries or signatories) regulate the import, export,
and reexport of specimens, parts, and products of CITES-listed plant
and animal species. Trade must be authorized through a system of
permits and certificates that are provided by the designated CITES
Management Authority of each CITES Party. All chimpanzee range
countries are Parties to CITES.
The chimpanzee is listed in Appendix I of CITES. An Appendix-I
listing includes species threatened with extinction whose trade is
permitted only under exceptional circumstances, which generally
precludes commercial trade. The import of an Appendix-I species
generally requires the issuance of both an import and export permit.
Import permits for Appendix-I species are issued only if findings are
made that the import would be for purposes that are not detrimental to
the survival of the species and that the specimen will not be used for
primarily commercial purposes (CITES Article III(3)). Export permits
for Appendix-I species are issued only if findings are made that the
specimen was legally acquired and trade is not detrimental to the
survival of the species, and if the issuing authority is satisfied that
an import permit has been granted for the specimen (CITES Article
III(2)).
Based on CITES trade data from 1990-2011, obtained from United
Nations Environment Programme-World Conservation Monitoring Center
(UNEP-WCMC) CITES Trade Database, there has been significant legal
trade of chimpanzees and their parts, and products worldwide. However,
legal trade in wild specimens, including live animals, bones,
scientific specimens, and hair has been limited. Trade of these wild
specimens for commercial purposes was reported for 14 live specimens,
121 scientific specimens, and 10 skulls. From 2002-2012, exports and
re-exports of wild specimens from the United States have numbered 8
scientific specimens for scientific purposes. Imports of wild specimens
into the United States have been limited and have included hairs,
scientific specimens, a skull, and one unspecified specimen for
personal, scientific, educational, and medical purposes.
As human settlements expand and populations of chimpanzees and
their habitat are reduced, the frequency of interactions between
chimpanzees and humans or human waste increases, leading to greater
risks of disease transmission with a similar magnitude of impact on
wild chimpanzee populations as habitat loss and poaching. A close
genetic relationship allows for easy transmission of infectious
diseases between chimpanzees and humans (Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 1;
Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Lonsdorf
2007, p. 73; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 29; Formenty et al. 2003, p. 169;
Huijbregts et al. 2003, p. 437). Rural communities that share the same
habitat as chimpanzees have no access to health care and are not
vaccinated against diseases that can spread through ape populations and
result in high mortality rates. Additionally, exposure to humans
through conservation and research activities, such as habituation,
ecotourism, and reintroductions, can also increase the risk of disease
transmission (Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 2; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2;
K[ouml]ndgen et al. 2008, p. 260; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Pusey
et al. 2008, p. 738; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 29; Huijbregts et al. 2003,
p. 437; Nishida et al. 2001, p. 48).
As discussed below, disease transmission is a major threat to
remaining populations of the central and eastern chimpanzees (Fausther-
Bovendo et al. 2012, p. 3; Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 2; Morgan et al.
2011, p. 10; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; Pusey et al. 2008, p. 743;
GRASP 2005a, p. 7; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 2; Leendertz et al. 2004, p.
451; Walsh et al. 2003, p. 612). Five subtypes of the Ebola virus have
been identified: Zaire, Sudan, C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire, Bundibugyo, and
Reston. All five are lethal to great apes. Repeated epidemics have
resulted in dramatic declines in ape populations in C[ocirc]te
d'Ivoire, Gabon, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and the Republic of
Congo. The Zaire strain alone has killed nearly one-third of the
world's chimpanzees (Fausther-Bovendo et al. 2012, p. 1; Ryan and Walsh
2011, p. 2; Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 2; K[ouml]ndgen et al. 2008, p.
261; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 29;
Leendertz et al. 2004, p. 451; Huijbregts et al. 2003, pp. 437, 441;
Walsh et al. 2003, pp. 612-613; Formenty et al. 2003, pp. 169-172).
Chimpanzees are naturally infected with simian immunodeficiency
viruses (SIVs), the precursor to acquired immunodeficiency syndrome
(AIDS), but it was long thought that SIVs were non-pathogenic (not
capable of inducing disease) and did not generally cause AIDS. However,
testing from 2000 to 2008 found that SIV is, in fact, pathogenic in
wild chimpanzees. Chimpanzees infected with SIV showed AIDS-like
symptoms and had a 10- to 16-fold increased chance of death than
uninfected chimpanzees. Additionally, females were less likely to give
birth and had higher infant mortality (Keele et al. 2009, pp. 517-518).
Other infectious diseases, including Marburg virus, polio, anthrax,
pneumonia, human respiratory syncytical virus, and human
metapneumovirus have resulted in widespread death of chimpanzees, even
within national parks (Ryan and Walsh 2011, pp. 2, 3; Rudicell et al.
2010, pp. 1, 10; Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; K[ouml]ndgen et al.
2008, pp. 260-262; Pusey et al. 2008, pp. 740, 741; Williams et al.
2008, pp. 766, 768-770; Leendertz et al. 2004, pp. 451-452; Nishida et
al. 2001, p. 48). Disease can have a particularly devastating impact to
ape populations since they have little resilience to diseases. For
example, recovery of a gorilla population from a single disease
outbreak can range from 5 years for a low mortality (4 percent)
respiratory disease outbreak to 131 years for an Ebola outbreak with
high mortality (96 percent); this does not take into account other
impacts to the populations such as additional disease outbreaks or
Allee effects. Recovery for a chimpanzee population would be longer as
they have a lower maximum population growth rate than gorillas (Ryan
and Walsh 2011, pp. 2, 3).
There are several strategies that can be taken to protect wild
chimpanzees from diseases. Some ``hands off'' approaches include
educating governments about the cost of too much tourism, stricter
enforcement of health guidelines for approaching habituated animals,
excluding humans from protected areas, and health programs for staff
and local populations. However, tourism is a substantial source of
revenue, and enforcement of guidelines is often weak, making these
strategies difficult to implement (Ryan and Walsh 2011, pp. 5-6; Pusey
et al. 2008, p. 742).
A more interventionist approach is treatment and vaccination of
wild apes via darting or oral baiting (Fausther-Bovendo et al. 2012, p.
4; Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 5). At this time, treatment is not
practical, as there are no licensed anti-viral drugs effective against
Ebola and anti-viral drugs have limited effectiveness against
respiratory viruses. Furthermore, a reactive type strategy, such as
treatment, requires a sufficient monitoring system to detect symptoms
and a veterinary infrastructure to effectively implement
[[Page 34512]]
treatment (Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 6). However, one of the reasons the
Kasekela community in Gombe National Park has maintained its size
through periodic epidemic diseases is that efforts were made to treat
sick chimpanzee when possible. Chimpanzees were given Ivermectin during
a mange epidemic and antibiotics during a respiratory epidemic (Pusey
et al. 2008, p. 741).
There have only been a few occasions in which wild apes have been
vaccinated against diseases. Chimpanzees in the Kasekela community were
given a polio vaccine in 1966, during a polio epidemic; gorillas were
vaccinated during a measles outbreak in 2011; and a few gorillas were
vaccinated against tetanus when immobilized for treatment of snare
wounds (Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 6; Walsh 2011, p. 3; Academy of
Achievement 2009, p. 9; Pusey et al. 2008, p. 741). There are
approximately 16 human vaccines that could potentially be used to
protect wild apes, including chimpanzees (Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 6).
However, vaccines for great apes require the same standard of testing
and ethical review as a vaccine for humans (Fausther-Bovendo et al.
2012, p. 5). Because management authorities place a strong emphasis on
animal welfare, it is preferable that vaccines be tested on captive
apes. Captive chimpanzees in the United States could be used to test
vaccines before they are given to wild populations. In 2011, for the
first time, captive chimpanzees were used in an experiment aimed to
help wild chimpanzees. The experiment assessed the safety of an Ebola
vaccine and its ability to trigger an immune response. Ultimately, the
vaccine could be given to gorillas and chimpanzees in the wild to
protect them against Ebola (Cohen 2011, unpaginated; Walsh 2011, p. 3).
Similar experiments on vaccines and treatments against other diseases
known to pose a high risk to wild apes, including respiratory
pathogens, gastrointestinal parasites, SIV, and malaria, are planned
for the future (Walsh 2011, p. 3). At this time, these types of
experiments have been extremely limited and have not yet contributed to
a reduction in any threats to chimpanzees from diseases.
Once a chimpanzee population has been reduced, whether by hunting,
capture for the pet trade, or disease, its ability to recover is
limited due to very slow reproductive rates and complex social behavior
(Plumptre et al. 2010, p. 1; Kabasawa 2009, p. 49; Bennett et al. 2006,
p. 885; Tutin et al. 2005, p. 32; Leroy et al. 2004, p. 389; Kormos et
al. 2003c, pp. 151, 155; Wilkie and Carpenter 1999, p. 927). Even low
levels of hunting can have a devastating effect on the population. The
loss of reproductive-age female chimpanzees can be particularly
devastating, further reducing the population's ability to recover from
the loss (Carter 2003b, p. 157; Kormos et al. 2003b, p. 72). The
occurrence of chimpanzees at low densities coupled with slow
reproductive rates can lead to the rapid extinction of even large
populations (Oates et al. 2008, unpaginated; Kormos and Boesch 2003, p.
2).
The current threats to the chimpanzee, as described above, are not
likely to improve in the foreseeable future, resulting in a continuing
decline of chimpanzee populations. Threats to this species are driven
by the needs of an expanding human population. Within the range
countries of the chimpanzee, the human population is expected to
continue to increase and will inevitably increase the pressures on
natural resources. Therefore, impacts to remaining populations of
chimpanzees, as described above, from deforestation, hunting,
commercial trade, and disease are likely to continue or even intensify
(Morgan et al. 2011, p. 10; Ryan and Walsh 2011, p. 5; Plumptre et al.
2010, pp. 50, 71; Fitzherbert et al. 2008, pp. 538-539, 544; Oates et
al. 2008, unpaginated; CBFP 2006, p. 33; Fa et al. 2006, p. 506; Hewitt
2006, pp. 44, 48-49; Nasi et al. 2006, p. 14; Carter et al. 2003, p.
38; Duvall 2003, p. 145; Parren and Byler 2003, p. 137; Nishida et al.
2001, p. 45; Wilkie and Carpenter 1999, pp. 927-928).
Continuing threats acting on chimpanzee populations, coupled with
the species' inability to recover from population reductions, will
likely lead to the loss of additional populations. Chimpanzees could be
lost from an additional three countries due to threats acting on
populations that are already below what is considered the minimum for a
viable population (Carlsen et al. 2012, p. 5; Butynski 2003, p. 11;
Kormos and Boesch 2003, p. 3). Many remaining populations are small and
isolated, putting them at an increased risk of extinction (Morgan et
al. 2011, p. 12).
Many management plans have been developed to conserve the
chimpanzee (e.g., Morgan et al. 2011; Plumptre et al. 2010; GRASP
2005a; GRASP 2005b; Tutin et al. 2005; Kormos and Boesch 2003; Kormos
et al. 2003). These plans lay out goals and research needs to address
the threats faced by chimpanzees. Development of forest management
plans with the goal of sustainable forestry practices has increased
(Hewitt 2006, p. 43; Nasi et al. 2006, pp. 17-19). However,
implementation of these management plans faces challenges, and the
effect of these plans has yet to be determined. There is no evidence
that management plans have reduced threats to the species. Chimpanzees
are found in numerous protected areas. In some cases, these areas
provide adequate protection and support substantial populations of
chimpanzees. Unfortunately, many protected areas have weak or
nonexistent management with poor law enforcement and are illegally
logged, converted to agricultural lands, and hunted (Campbell et al.
2011, p. 1). Furthermore, we have no evidence that enforcement of
legislation to protect chimpanzees and their habitat, including
protected areas, will improve.
Finding
Section 4 of the Act (16 U.S.C. 1533) and implementing regulations
(50 CFR part 424) set forth procedures for adding species to, removing
species from, or reclassifying species on the Federal Lists of
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants. Under section 4(a)(1) of
the Act, a species may be determined to be an endangered species or a
threatened species based on any of the following five factors:
(A) The present or threatened destruction, modification, or
curtailment of its habitat or range;
(B) Overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or
educational purposes;
(C) Disease or predation;
(D) The inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms; or
(E) Other natural or manmade factors affecting its continued
existence.
As required by the Act, we conducted a review of the status of the
species and considered the five factors in assessing whether the
chimpanzee is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant
portion of its range or likely to become endangered within the
foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its
range. We examined the best scientific and commercial information
available regarding the past, present, and future threats faced by the
chimpanzee. We reviewed the petition, information available in our
files, and other available published and unpublished information.
One approach we can use to determine whether a species is an
endangered species or a threatened species, as defined under the Act,
is to evaluate the viability of the species. In this context, viability
refers to the ability of a species to persist over the long term, and
conversely, avoid
[[Page 34513]]
extinction over the long term. A species can be considered viable if it
has a sufficient degree of resiliency, representation, and redundancy.
However, a species that is deficient in one or more of these
characteristics will have a lower probability of being viable and,
therefore, a greater risk of extinction.
Species have certain needs at the individual, population, and
species level that are to be met in order to be viable. Using the
concepts of resiliency, representation, and redundancy, we can evaluate
threats to these needs, determine the effect on the species, and gauge
the probability of viability. In evaluating threats to the needs of the
species and considering whether a species may warrant listing under any
of the five factors, we look beyond the species' exposure to a
potential threat or aggregation of threats under any of the factors,
and evaluate whether the species responds to those potential threats in
a way that causes actual impact to the species. The identification of
threats that might impact a species negatively may not be sufficient to
compel a finding that the species warrants listing. The information
must include evidence indicating that the threats are operative and,
either singly or in aggregation, affect the status of the species.
Threats are significant if they drive, or contribute to, the risk of
extinction of the species, such that the species warrants listing as an
endangered species or a threatened species, as those terms are defined
in the Act.
Resiliency describes the characteristics of a species and its
habitat that allow it to recover from periodic disturbance. Species-
level resiliency is measured through the resiliency of its collective
populations. Healthy populations allow for recovery after stochastic
events or periodic disturbances. Populations lacking healthy
characteristics will be less likely to bounce back and are thus less
resilient.
Chimpanzee habitat is continually subjected to disturbance.
Chimpanzees need large areas to provide sufficient resources for food,
nesting, and shelter. However, across its range, habitat that is needed
to support viable chimpanzee populations is being fragmented and lost
to logging operations and conversion to agriculture. Logging operations
often create a network of roads for transporting timber. These roads
provide greater access to forests that were once inaccessible,
facilitate the establishment of human settlements, and are accompanied
by further deforestation from the conversion of forests to agriculture.
Additionally, agricultural practices are largely unsustainable and are
encroaching into additional forested areas. As the human population and
economic development have increased, pressure on forest resources has
also increased. This increasing pressure has led to uncontrolled legal
and illegal forest conversion within and outside of protected areas
(e.g., national parks and forest reserves), leaving them destroyed and
fragmented. Cutting cycles that occur too frequently in an area to
allow for proper regrowth, clear-cutting that results in total habitat
loss, and severe soil erosion results in the loss of future forest
regeneration and recovery of vital habitat.
The loss, or even the degradation, of the chimpanzee's traditional
habitat can affect their survival by impacting the species' food
resources, behavior, susceptibility to disease, and abundance and
distribution. Removal, or lowering the quality, of habitat through
logging activity or establishment of agricultural lands destroys the
structure and composition of the forest, eliminating essential food
sources, which can affect sociability, condition of individuals, and
female reproductive success, and increases vulnerability to diseases or
parasites and infant and juvenile mortality. Even in areas with lower
levels of logging where essential food sources were unaffected,
chimpanzee densities declined significantly and were unable to recover,
remaining low for years.
Chimpanzee populations are also continually subjected to
disturbance. Individuals needed to maintain viable populations are lost
to hunting for the bushmeat trade, trade in pet chimpanzees, disease,
and conflicts with humans. Hunting pressure even at a low level is
enough to result in the local extirpation of large chimpanzee
populations. The loss of reproductive-age female chimpanzees can be
particularly devastating, further reducing the population's ability to
recover from the loss. The pet trade has a significant draining effect
on remaining populations, and threatens the survival of wild
chimpanzees, because so many chimpanzees may be killed to secure one
infant. Repeated epidemics have resulted in dramatic declines in ape
populations in C[ocirc]te d'Ivoire, Gabon, Democratic Republic of the
Congo, and the Republic of Congo. The Zaire strain of the Ebola virus
alone has killed nearly one-third of the world's chimpanzees. Disease,
such as SIV increase the chance of death by 10- to 16-fold, decreases
the likelihood of females giving birth, and increases infant mortality.
Disease can have a particularly devastating impact to ape populations
since they have little resilience to diseases. For example, recovery of
a gorilla population from a single disease outbreak can range from 5
years for a low mortality (4 percent) respiratory disease outbreak to
131 years for an Ebola outbreak with high mortality (96 percent); this
does not take into account other impacts to the populations such as
additional disease outbreaks or Allee effects. Recovery for a
chimpanzee population would be longer as they have a lower maximum
population growth rate than gorillas.
Once a chimpanzee population has been reduced, whether by hunting,
capture for the pet trade, or disease, its ability to recover is
limited due to very slow reproductive rates and complex social
behavior. Females do not give birth until 12 years of age and have only
one infant every 5 to 6 years. Infants are weaned around 4 years old,
and stay with their mothers until they are about 8 to 10 years old.
Even after being weaned, young may not survive if orphaned. The
occurrence of chimpanzees at low densities coupled with slow
reproductive rates can lead to the rapid extinction of even large
populations.
Continuing threats acting on chimpanzee habitat and populations,
coupled with the loss of future forest regeneration and recovery of
vital habitat and the species' inability to recover from population
reductions, will lead to the loss of additional populations and is
evidence that neither chimpanzees, nor its habitat, are resilient.
Representation is the species' ability to adapt to changing
environmental conditions, whether natural or human caused. The species'
adaptive capabilities are supported by the range in variation found
within and between populations. Representation can be measured through
the breadth of genetic diversity within and among populations and/or
ecological diversity occupied by populations across the species range.
In short, sufficient representation is having the genetic flexibility
and/or inhabiting varying environmental conditions to allow the
populations to respond to changing environmental conditions through
adaptation. Species without diversity within and among populations are
thought to be more likely to go extinct as conditions change.
Genetic diversity in chimpanzees is evident by the four-subspecies
taxonomic classification. Determining intraspecific variation among
natural populations is more difficult. Given that some chimpanzee
populations are
[[Page 34514]]
small, isolated and continue to face threats, it is reasonable to
conclude that these particular populations may have, or will
experience, decreased genetic diversity. However, we found no
information to suggest that genetic exchange is particularly low for
the species as a whole or chimpanzee populations in general.
Chimpanzee habitats, diet, and choice of nesting sites vary across
populations and communities. In regards to habitat, chimpanzees are
highly adaptive, occurring in primary, secondary, and regenerating
forests, logged forests, and plantations; they have even been found
living in close proximity to humans. However, the loss, or even the
degradation, of the chimpanzee's traditional habitat can affect their
survival by impacting the species' food resources, behavior,
susceptibility to disease, and abundance and distribution. Although
chimpanzees feed on a wide variety of foods, their energy requirements,
as large primates with large home ranges, predispose them to a reliance
on high-energy fruits. Removal, or lowering the quality, of habitat
through logging activity or establishment of agricultural lands
destroys the structure and composition of the forest, eliminating
essential food sources, which can affect sociability, condition of
individuals, female reproductive success, and increase vulnerability to
diseases or parasites and infant and juvenile mortality. Choice of
nesting sites is variable across populations and communities of
chimpanzees, but chimpanzees exhibit strong preferences for certain
tree species for nesting, independent of their availability in the
habitat. Chimps can also be deterred from nesting in certain areas
where human habitation is concentrated. As a result, chimpanzees are at
a greater risk of predation, as habitats where they relocate nests may
not provide sufficient protection. Furthermore, the loss or reduction
of food sources and the noise and disturbance from logging activity can
cause chimpanzee communities to abandon their home range to find a new
home range with sufficient resources and less human activity. These
chimpanzees may enter another community's territory, which can lead to
further competition for resources and conflict that can lead to death.
As habitat is lost or fragmented and chimpanzee populations are forced
into smaller forest fragments, lethal interactions with other
chimpanzees may increase. Chimpanzees may also be cautious about
reinhabiting previous home ranges where they were displaced by humans.
Chimpanzees are ecologically diverse across subspecies,
populations, and communities. However, this species faces ongoing
threats that impact the various habitat types and result in declining
populations across its range. As stated above, these impacts are
particularly devastating to populations as their ability to recover
from these ongoing disturbances is limited due to very slow
reproductive rates and complex social behavior. Therefore, we find that
chimpanzees do not have sufficient representation to adapt to changing
environmental conditions.
Redundancy is the ability of a species to withstand catastrophic
events either by having populations that are unaffected or by having
populations that can recover following such an event. Sufficient
redundancy is having enough populations distributed across the
landscape to provide a margin of safety for the species to withstand
catastrophic events. This can be measured by the number of populations
comprising the species and how they are distributed across the
landscape. Additionally, because the species depends on its habitat,
the ability of its habitat to withstand, or recover from, a
catastrophic event should be considered.
Chimpanzee populations occur across 22 African countries. Affected
populations, owing to the lack of resiliency, would be unlikely to
recover after a catastrophic event, leaving the species more depleted
and fragmented than its current state. Additionally, unaffected
populations would continue to face ongoing threats, and owing to a lack
of resiliency, will be unlikely to sufficiently recover from these
continuous disturbances. Similarly, the habitat types occupied by
chimpanzees across the 22 range countries are not likely to be all be
directly impacted by a catastrophic event, but the ability of the
habitat to recover, given the current threats acting on chimpanzee
habitat and the lack of forest regeneration, is unlikely. Furthermore,
unaffected habitat will continue to face threats and will be unable to
recover due to heavy pressures to meet the demands and needs of the
growing human population. Therefore, we find that chimpanzee
populations do not represent sufficient redundancy to withstand a
catastrophic event.
In summary, wild chimpanzees were listed as an endangered species
in 1990 due to habitat loss, excessive hunting, capture for the pet
trade, disease, and lack of effective national and international laws.
Since then, threats to the chimpanzee have only expanded and
intensified. The chimpanzee is a species whose declining and fragmented
populations are not resilient to current ongoing disturbances. Despite
the ecological diversity of the species, threats to the chimpanzee and
its habitat are such that the representation is not sufficient to allow
chimpanzees to adapt to the ongoing changes in its environment. In the
event of a catastrophic event, the remaining populations would likely
not recover due to ongoing threats. Due to the current, ongoing threats
and impacts to the chimpanzee and its habitat, resiliency,
representation, and redundancy are not sufficient to characterize the
chimpanzee as a viable species. Laws exist throughout the range
countries and internationally to protect the chimpanzee, but
enforcement of national laws is lacking. Impacts to the chimpanzee and
its habitat are expected to continue into the future as the human
population continues to expand and pressures on natural resources to
meet the demands of the human population increase.
Threats and the impact of these threats to the chimpanzee and its
habitat are at a level that compromises the viability of the species.
We do not find that the chimpanzee is likely to become endangered
within the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion
of its range. Rather, we find that the chimpanzee (including
consideration of all members, both captive and wild) is not a viable
species and is currently in danger of extinction throughout all of its
range. Therefore, we are retaining the status of the chimpanzee as an
endangered species, but with this listing we are now including all
members of the species in the endangered classification.
We also examined the chimpanzee to analyze if any other listable
entity under the definition of ``species,'' such as subspecies or
distinct population segments, may qualify for a different status.
Because of the magnitude and uniformity of the threats throughout its
range, we find that there are no other listable entities that may
warrant a different determination of status. In addition, because we
find that the chimpanzee is in danger of extinction throughout all of
its range, consistent with our Final Policy on Interpretation of the
Phrase ``Significant Portion of Its Range'' in the Endangered Species
Act's Definitions of ``Endangered Species'' and ``Threatened Species''
(79 FR 37578; July 1, 2014) it is not necessary to consider whether the
species might qualify for a different status based on some
``significant portion of its range''
[[Page 34515]]
because if a species is endangered or threatened throughout its range,
no portions of its range can qualify as ``significant.'' Therefore, on
the basis of the best available scientific and commercial information,
we have determined that the chimpanzee meets the definition of an
endangered species under the Act. Consequently, we are revising the
listing of chimpanzees under the Act so that all chimpanzees, wherever
found, are listed as endangered species.
A rule normally becomes effective 30 days after publication of a
final rule in the Federal Register; however, our final determination to
list all chimpanzees as endangered species under the Act will become
effective in 90 days (see DATES, above). We are delaying the effective
date to allow time to process applications for ongoing activities
involving chimpanzees that would require a permit under the Act. This
will allow persons who qualify for a permit to avoid unnecessary
suspension of their activities, which include important ongoing medical
and scientific research. Delaying the effective date will not adversely
affect wild populations of chimpanzees or significantly affect captive
chimpanzees.
4(d) Rule
For threatened species, section 4(d) of the Act gives the Service
discretion to specify the prohibitions and any exceptions to those
prohibitions that are appropriate for the species, as well as include
provisions that are necessary and advisable to provide for the
conservation of the species. A 4(d) rule allows us to develop
regulatory provisions that are tailored to the specific conservation
needs of the threatened species and which may be more or less
restrictive than the general provisions for threatened wildlife at 50
CFR 17.31 and 17.32. Because captive chimpanzees in the United States
were previously classified as threatened species, they were exempt from
the general prohibitions for threatened wildlife at 50 CFR 17.31 under
a 4(d) rule for primates set forth at 50 CFR 17.40(c). However, because
4(d) rules can be applied only to threatened species, and we find that
all chimpanzees, both wild and captive, are an endangered species, the
4(d) rule for captive chimpanzees can no longer be applied. Therefore,
we are removing the chimpanzee, including a provision specific to the
chimpanzee, from the 4(d) rule found at 50 CFR 17.40(c).
Available Conservation Measures
Conservation measures provided to species listed as endangered or
threatened species under the Act include recognition, requirements for
Federal protection, and prohibitions against certain practices.
Recognition through listing results in public awareness, and encourages
and results in conservation actions by Federal and state governments,
private agencies and groups, and individuals.
Section 7(a) of the Act, as amended, and as implemented by
regulations at 50 CFR part 402, requires Federal agencies to evaluate
their actions within the United States or on the high seas with respect
to any species that is proposed or listed as endangered or threatened
species and with respect to its critical habitat, if any is being
designated. However, given that the chimpanzee is not native to the
United States, we are not designating critical habitat for this species
under section 4 of the Act.
Section 8(a) of the Act authorizes the provision of limited
financial assistance for the development and management of programs
that the Secretary of the Interior determines to be necessary or useful
for the conservation of endangered and threatened species in foreign
countries. Sections 8(b) and 8(c) of the Act authorize the Secretary to
encourage conservation programs for foreign endangered species and to
provide assistance for such programs in the form of personnel and the
training of personnel.
In 2000, the U.S. Congress passed the Great Ape Conservation Act to
protect and conserve the great ape species, including the chimpanzee,
listed under both the Endangered Species Act and CITES. The Great Ape
Conservation Act granted the Service the authority to establish the
Great Ape Conservation Fund to provide funding for projects that aim to
conserve great apes through law enforcement training, community
initiatives, and other conservation efforts. The Service's Wildlife
Without Borders program, through the Great Ape Conservation Fund, is
supporting efforts to fight poaching and trafficking in great apes; to
increase habitat protection by creating national parks and protected
areas; and to engage the community through local initiatives to
conserve the most threatened great ape species.
The Endangered Species Act and its implementing regulations set
forth a series of general prohibitions and exceptions that apply to all
endangered wildlife and to threatened wildlife that are not regulated
through a 4(d) rule. These prohibitions, at 50 CFR 17.21 and 17.31, in
part, make it illegal for any person subject to the jurisdiction of the
United States to ``take'' (take includes harass, harm, pursue, hunt,
shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, collect, or to attempt any of these)
within the United States or upon the high seas; import or export;
deliver, receive, carry, transport, or ship in interstate or foreign
commerce in the course of commercial activity; or sell or offer for
sale in interstate or foreign commerce any endangered or threatened
wildlife species. To possess, sell, deliver, carry, transport, or ship
any such wildlife that has been taken in violation of the Act is also
illegal. Certain exceptions apply to agents of the Service and State
conservation agencies.
Permits may be issued to carry out otherwise prohibited activities
involving endangered and threatened wildlife species under certain
circumstances. Regulations governing permits are codified at 50 CFR
17.22 for endangered wildlife and 17.32 for threatened wildlife. For
endangered wildlife, a permit may be issued for scientific purposes, to
enhance the propagation or survival of the species, and for incidental
take in connection with otherwise lawful activities. For threatened
species, a permit may be issued for the same activities, as well as
zoological exhibition, education, and special purposes consistent with
the Act.
Summary of Comments and Recommendations
We based this action on a review of the best scientific and
commercial information available, including all information received
during the public comment period. In the June 12, 2013, proposed rule,
we requested that all interested parties submit information that might
contribute to development of a final rule. We also contacted
appropriate scientific experts and organizations and invited them to
comment on the proposed listing. We received tens of thousands of
comments.
We reviewed all comments we received from the public for
substantive issues and new information regarding the proposed listing
of this species, and we address those comments below. Overall, most
commenters supported the proposed listing, but did not provide
additional scientific or commercial data for consideration. We have not
included responses to comments that supported the listing decision but
did not provide specific information for consideration. Most of the
commenters that did not support the proposed listing were affiliated
with the biomedical industry and opposed the rule due to potential
impacts on biomedical research. Additionally, we received comments
opposing our finding that the Act does not allow for captive
chimpanzees to be assigned separate legal status from their
[[Page 34516]]
wild counterparts on the basis of their captive state, including
through designation as a separate distinct population segment.
Peer Review
In accordance with our policy published on July 1, 1994 (59 FR
34270), we solicited expert opinions from five individuals with
scientific expertise that included familiarity with the species, the
geographic region in which wild members of the species occur, and
conservation biology principles. We received responses from one of the
peer reviewers from whom we requested comments. The peer reviewer found
the proposed rule generally accurate and comprehensive in its
description of the biology, habitat, population trends, and
distribution of chimpanzees, including the factors affecting the
species. The peer reviewer provided comments for our consideration to
improve the accuracy of the rule. Those comments are addressed below.
Technical corrections suggested by the peer reviewer have been
incorporated into this final rule. In some cases, a technical
correction is indicated in the citations by ``personal communication''
(pers. comm.), which could indicate either an email or telephone
conversation; in other cases, the research citation is provided.
Peer Reviewer Comments
(1) Comment: The peer reviewer provided technical corrections,
including more appropriate citations, on the species' taxonomy,
description, diet, and population estimates.
Our Response: We reviewed the recommended citations and made minor
changes to the Taxonomy and Species Description, Essential Needs of the
Species, and Range and Population sections.
(2) Comment: The Service's statement that chimpanzees have been
lost from Benin, Togo, and Burkina Faso is too definitive, as there are
a few recent, second-hand reports of chimpanzees in Togo, one of which
has led a primatologist to plan a new survey to investigate.
Our Response: The loss of chimpanzees from Togo is widely reported
in scientific literature; therefore, in the absence of a survey
confirming the presence of chimpanzees in this country we will continue
to rely on the best scientific data available, which indicates that
chimpanzees have been extirpated from Togo. However, we acknowledge
these recent reports in our Range and Population section.
(3) Comment: The peer reviewer disagrees that the chimpanzee could
be extirpated from Nigeria. The current population of chimpanzees in
just one national park in Nigeria, Gashaka-Gumti, appears to be over
1,000 individuals and is relatively well protected.
Our Response: In light of this information we have reevaluated our
analysis of potential extirpation from specific countries. According to
Carlsen et al. (2012, p. 5) and Butynski (2003, p. 11), the western
chimpanzee is highly threatened; combined with national populations
fewer than 1,000 chimpanzees, survival in Senegal, Guineau Bissau, and
Ghana is a concern. Because the population in a well-protected national
park in Nigeria is over 1,000 chimpanzees, we have revised our analysis
under our Range and Population section. However, this did not change
our finding that the chimpanzee meets the definition of an endangered
species under the Act.
Public Comments
(4) Comment: The inclusion of non-native species under the
Endangered Species Act is a misdirection of agency resources that does
little to protect wild habitat and merely imposes regulatory burdens on
those who maintain these in human care domestically.
Our Response: The Act requires the Service to determine if species
qualify as endangered or threatened species regardless of whether a
species is native to the United States. Benefits to the species include
prohibitions on certain activities including import, export, take, and
certain commercial activity in interstate or foreign commerce. By
regulating these activities, the Act helps to ensure that people under
the jurisdiction of the United States do not contribute to the further
decline of listed species. Although the Act's prohibitions regarding
listed species apply only to people subject to the jurisdiction of the
United States, the Act can generate additional conservation benefits
such as increased awareness of listed species, research efforts to
address conservation needs, or funding for in-situ conservation of the
species in its range countries.
(5) Comment: Several commenters oppose the elimination of the
separate classification of chimpanzees held in captivity and the
listing of the entire species, wherever found, as an endangered species
under the Act, stating that it is unlikely to benefit chimpanzees in
the wild and will have little effect on the major threats to
chimpanzees.
Our Response: Our determination that the Act does not allow for
captive chimpanzees to be assigned separate legal status from their
wild counterparts is based on a detailed analysis on whether the
current statute, regulations, and applicable policies provide any
discretion to differentiate the listing status of specimens in
captivity from those in the wild. Therefore, benefits to the species or
the effect of the listing decision is not relevant to what constitutes
a listable entity and is eligible for separate listing status under the
Act. We did, however, consider to what extent captive chimpanzees
contribute to or create threats to the species or reduce or remove any
threats to the species as a whole.
(6) Comment: Commenters requested chimpanzees located in the United
States to continue to be regulated under the existing rule issued under
section 4(d) of the Act, or that the special rule for chimpanzees be
revised in order to allow certain activities with chimpanzees to be
undertaken without the administrative burden and delays associated with
obtaining permits under the Act.
Our Response: Because special rules under section 4(d) authority
can only apply to threatened species, the special rule that includes
captive chimpanzees at 50 CFR 17.40(c) will no longer be available once
this listing action and the accompanying removal of the special rule as
applied to chimpanzees become effective.
(7) Comment: Several commenters oppose the listing of all
chimpanzees as endangered species, and removal of chimpanzees from the
4(d) rule for primates, because essential biomedical research for both
human and chimpanzee health, including critical research needed to
develop preventions and treatments of infectious diseases in wild
chimpanzee populations, that uses chimpanzees could be prohibited.
Furthermore, the utilization of research chimpanzees is currently well-
regulated under other Federal statutes, including the Animal Welfare
Act (AWA), the Public Health Service Act, and the Chimp Act of 2000, as
well as other Federal policies and guidelines.
Our Response: It is not our intent to prevent any biomedical
research. However, research involving chimpanzees that could cause harm
to the animal (i.e., ``take'') will require a take permit under the
Act. While take includes harassment of individual animals, our
regulations specify that when captive animals are involved, harassment
does not include animal husbandry practices that meet or exceed AWA
standards, breeding procedures, or veterinary care that is not likely
to result in injury (see the definition of harass at 50 CFR 17.3). In
addition,
[[Page 34517]]
research that does not adversely affect chimpanzees, such as
observations in behavioral research, are not considered take and will
not require a permit. For activities that may result in a prohibited
act such as a taking, permits may be issued for scientific purposes or
to enhance the propagation or survival of the species. Enhancement may
be direct, such as developing a vaccination to be administered to
chimpanzees in the wild (in situ), or indirect such as contributions
that are made to in situ conservation.
Additionally, the comment appears to imply that additional
regulation under the Act is not needed for captive chimpanzees in the
United States. Whether or not additional regulation is needed is not a
factor considered when evaluating whether a species meets the
definition of a threatened or endangered species. Having concluded that
we had no discretion to treat captive chimpanzees as a separate
listable entity from wild chimpanzees, the Service properly assessed
the status of the ``species'' to determine if it met the definition of
a ``threatened species'' or an ``endangered species'' due to any one or
a combination of the five factors found in section 4(a)(1) of the Act.
We properly applied the five factors under section 4(a)(1) to the
species, including the extent to which captive chimpanzees create or
contribute to the threats to the species or remove or reduce threats to
the species. Having determined that all chimpanzees qualify as an
``endangered species,'' the Act's protections for endangered species
are extended to all chimpanzees.
(8) Comment: There is no causal nexus between research with
chimpanzees in the United States and the removal of specimens from the
wild by ``poachers and smugglers,'' and the Service has provided no
example of illegal trafficking attributable to research.
Our Response: In assessing whether captive chimpanzees actually
create or contribute to the threat of overutilization to the species as
part of its status review, the Service did not find evidence that
captive animals used for research in the United States were
contributing to or creating any threats to the species. In fact, the
availability of captive chimpanzees may have removed the demand for
wild chimpanzees in biomedical research.
(9) Comment: Several commenters are concerned that the permitting
process may delay time-sensitive research.
Our Response: The Service intends to work with research
institutions to minimize the time needed to authorize activities under
the Act. However, it should be noted that the permitting process
includes a 30-day comment period required by statute for permit
applications involving endangered species. Given that it takes time to
plan and implement any research studies, we do not believe the
permitting process will be problematic or result in any critical delays
in research.
(10) Comment: The Service should amend the permitting requirements
so that details of requests for biomedical research permits are not
required to be published in the Federal Register.
Our Response: We do not publish the details of permit applications
in the Federal Register; we publish only a notice to the public that we
have received a permit application. Information received as part of any
application is available to the public, however, as a matter of public
record.
(11) Comment: How many and for which type of biomedical research
will the Service issue permits?
Our Response: All determinations of whether particular entities and
particular activities qualify for permits under the Act are made on a
case-by-case basis depending on the facts of the situation. We do not
set a limit on the number of permits we issue; however, in the course
of reviewing permit applications we may refer back to all applications
we have received and issued for a particular species and activity. We
cannot foresee what biomedical research would be authorized because up
until the effective date of this rule (see DATES), permits for
activities involving chimpanzees have not been required. Further, to
list those activities prior to reviewing them during the course of the
permitting procedure would be predecisional. We will issue permits for
activities that meet the requirements of 50 CFR 17.22.
(12) Comment: The Service's proposed listing rule does not consider
the inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms for permitting
biomedical research with captive chimpanzees under the Act.
Our Response: The commenter appears to be referencing factor D and
appears to maintain that inadequate permitting of research negatively
impacts wild chimpanzees because such regulations impede research that
has the potential to treat diseases that impact chimpanzees. As stated
above, biomedical research involving chimpanzees that benefits
chimpanzees in the wild would likely meet enhancement requirements and,
therefore, would likely be authorized. Thus, the issue mentioned by the
commenter is not applicable.
(13) Comment: The impact of this rule on the biomedical community
will endanger human populations. The Service should include biomedical
research aimed at improving human health within the definition of
``scientific purposes'' under the Act.
Our Response: The purposes of the Act are to conserve species and
the ecosystems on which they depend, and any permit issued must meet
the standards under section 10(a) and 10(d) of the Act. While not
intended to impact research involving human health, there are
requirements that must be met when endangered species, such as the
chimpanzee, are involved. We will evaluate each application for a
permit on a case-by-case basis to determine if it qualifies under the
Act, including for scientific purposes. We will work with institutions
applying for a permit to minimize adverse effects to research
activities.
(14) Comment: An enhancement-of-survival permit for biomedical
research on chimpanzees would require research programs to provide a
conservation benefit to species in the wild, a huge imposition on
research institutions' resources.
Our Response: The Service does not believe that requiring
biomedical institutions to obtain authorization to carry out otherwise
prohibited activities would impose a significant imposition on their
resources. In discussions with a number of the institutions currently
holding chimpanzees, it appears that there are ways these institutions
could benefit chimpanzees in the wild through currently on-going
activities or activities that could be reasonably developed. Behavioral
studies, the development of veterinary treatments, and support for in-
situ conservation efforts like orphan care, currently carried out by
some institutions, all would support the issuance of an endangered
species permit by the Service. The Service will continue to work with
research institutions on ways to continue their current activities,
while ensuring that the standards of the Act are met.
(15) Comment: Additional information on diseases and the threat
they pose to the viability of wild chimpanzees was provided.
Our Response: We have incorporated additional information into our
discussion of diseases, including the potential impact of disease
outbreaks on chimpanzee populations and the potential for captive
chimpanzees in the United States to be used to test vaccines for wild
populations. This information did not change our finding that the
chimpanzee meets the definition of an endangered species under the Act.
[[Page 34518]]
Rather, it provided additional support to our finding that disease is a
threat to chimpanzees.
(16) Comment: The Service only used literature related to wild
chimpanzees and included very limited scientific data related to
captive chimpanzees, especially information on the use of captive
chimpanzees in research to advance both human and chimpanzee health.
Our Response: Consistent with the Act, we assessed the status of
the species to determine whether chimpanzees meet the definition of an
endangered or threatened species and should be listed under the Act.
This included assessing the extent to which captive chimpanzees create
or contribute to threats to the species or remove or reduce threats to
the species by contributing to the conservation of the species. We have
included in our Summary of Threats section information on the potential
for captive chimpanzees to contribute to a reduction in threats to
chimpanzees from diseases. Because the use of captive chimpanzees in
the advancement of human health does not impact chimpanzees, either
positively or negatively, this information is not relevant in assessing
the status of the species.
(17) Comment: Some commenters claimed listing all chimpanzees as
endangered species would hurt conservation efforts to the extent that
the Service would set limitations on the exhibition of endangered
chimpanzees in zoological settings.
Our Response: The Act does not prohibit the exhibition of listed
species. Listing all chimpanzees will not set any limitations on
exhibition. The Service disagrees, however, that listing all
chimpanzees as endangered would have any negative impact on
conservation efforts. Instead, the listing will most likely promote
greater participation in conservation efforts by zoological
institutions and the public. Before the listing, individuals wishing to
sell and engage in certain other commercial activities with captive
chimpanzees could do so without providing any conservation benefits to
the species. With this listing, otherwise prohibited activities, such
as these commercial activities, will require authorization from the
Service and this authorization can be issued only if the activity meets
the requirements of the Act.
(18) Comment: The listing petition's general arguments regarding
exhibitors' commercial gain from their exhibition of captive
chimpanzees should have no bearing on Service's decision regarding the
conservation status of captive chimpanzees under the Act. Furthermore,
the Service should clarify that commercial gains from educational and
entertainment activities are not illegal under the Act.
Our Response: The Service's listing determination is based upon an
analysis of the best available scientific and commercial information
relative to the statutory standards under the Act indicating that
chimpanzees as a species meet the definition of an endangered species
under the Act. Thus, the appropriate conservation status of the species
was not based upon the issue mentioned by the commenter. Additionally,
the Act and our implementing regulations set forth the prohibitions
that apply to all endangered wildlife. These prohibitions make it
illegal for any person who is subject to the jurisdiction of the United
States to, among other things, sell or offer for sale an endangered
species in interstate or foreign commerce or to deliver, receive,
transport, carry, or ship an endangered species in interstate or
foreign commerce in the course of a commercial activity. Services
provided by persons who own captive chimpanzees such as those provided
by circuses and appearances in movies, television, advertisements, or
parties are not unlawful unless the person engages in one of the
prohibited activities.
(19) Comment: The Service's differentiation between threatened and
endangered species permits issued for the purpose of exhibition is
misplaced because the Service's regulatory definition of ``enhancement
of propagation or survival'' includes ``exhibition of living wildlife
in a manner designed to educate the public about the ecological role
and conservation needs of the affected species.'' Thus, in the event
that the Service designates captive chimpanzees as endangered under the
Act, the Service should expressly reaffirm that public exhibition
continues to be permitted.
Our Response: The Act does not prohibit the exhibition of listed
species. Therefore, the Service does not issue permits for public
exhibition or education. However, the Act does regulate, among other
things, import; export; sale and offer for sale in interstate and
foreign commerce; and delivery, receipt, transport, carrying, and
shipment in interstate or foreign commerce in the course of a
commercial activity. As pointed out in the proposed rule, Section
10(a)(1)(A) of the Act for endangered species states that the Secretary
may permit ``any act otherwise prohibited by section 9 for scientific
purposes or to enhance the propagation or survival of the affected
species . . .'' In addition, any permit issued under section
10(a)(1)(A) must, among other things, be consistent with the policies
and purposes of the Act. Therefore, when considering whether a permit
can be issued to authorize activities that would otherwise be
prohibited with an endangered species, the purposes of the activity
must be for either scientific purposes or for enhancement, not solely
for educational or exhibition purposes.
The commenter is correct, however, in referencing that the
definition of ``enhance the propagation or survival'' in the
regulations (50 CFR 17.3) does identify exhibition of living wildlife
as part of an overall approach to enhancement for captive wildlife.
Specifically, the regulations state: Enhance the propagation or
survival, when used in reference to wildlife in captivity, the
following activities when it can be shown that such activities would
not be detrimental to the survival of wild or captive populations of
the affected species:
(a) Provision of health care, management of populations by culling,
contraception, euthanasia, grouping or handling of wildlife to control
survivorship and reproduction, and similar normal practices of animal
husbandry needed to maintain captive populations that are self-
sustaining and that possess as much genetic vitality as possible;
(b) Accumulation and holding of living wildlife that is not
immediately needed or suitable for propagative or scientific purposes,
and the transfer of such wildlife between persons in order to relieve
crowding or other problems hindering the propagation or survival of the
captive population at the location from which the wildlife would be
removed;
(c) Exhibition of living wildlife in a manner designed to educate
the public about the ecological role and conservation needs of the
affected species.
This definition was established primarily in relation to the
Captive-bred Wildlife Registration program (50 CFR 17.21(g)) to
facilitate captive breeding of listed species as part of an overall
captive management program. Therefore, public display in a manner
designed to education the public about the ecological role of the
species, along with being part of a captive breeding program that
strives for a self-sustaining captive population that ensures maximum
genetic diversity and vitality could be permitted under the Act.
(20) Comment: Several commenters opposed the proposed rule, and the
[[Page 34519]]
associated regulation of captive chimpanzees, stating that captive
populations are essential for the perpetuation of global chimpanzee
populations and repopulating African countries.
Our Response: The status of all chimpanzees as endangered does not
affect the ability to maintain captive populations. The Act does not
prohibit captive breeding of listed species.
(21) Comment: One commenter requested amending the Service's
regulatory definition of the phrase ``industry and trade'' found in the
Act's definition of the term ``commercial activity,'' as well as
revising the Service's Captive-Bred Wildlife Regulations under 50 CFR
17.21(g) to require the agency to respond in the Federal Register to
public comments received on applications for captive-bred wildlife
registrations.
Our Response: The comment is outside the scope of this agency
action to consider whether all chimpanzees should be listed as
endangered species under the Act.
(22) Comment: Some commenters believed that this rulemaking was not
the appropriate vehicle for issuing new agency policy regarding whether
captive animals, in general, may be assigned separate legal status from
their wild counterparts on the basis of their captive state. One
commenter explained that the Service could not use a petition-specific
determination to promulgate a new interpretive rule, and the law
requires such action to be done via a more direct and thorough public
process, not as an adjunct to a species listing petition. One commenter
maintained that the Service's actions violated section 4(h) of the Act.
Thus, these commenters indicated promulgation of such a policy or
interpretive rule should be subject to separate public notice and
comment procedures pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act and the
Endangered Species Act.
Our Response: The Service was petitioned to list all chimpanzees,
whether in the wild or in captivity, as an endangered species, thereby
eliminating the separate classification of captive chimpanzees from
chimpanzees located in the wild. As explained in the preamble of our
proposed listing rule, we therefore examined the question raised by the
petition as to whether the Service has discretion under the Act to
differentiate the listing status of chimpanzees in captivity from those
in the wild. Because the Service had not specifically examined whether
the Act, its implementing regulations, and applicable policies provide
such discretion prior to receiving the petitions for chimpanzees and
the African antelope, we reviewed the issue in order to ensure that we
addressed each petition in accordance with the Act. Nonetheless, each
assessment is specific to the petitioned species. The rule has been
revised to clarify that the Service's analysis is specific to the issue
of whether captive chimpanzees should have separate legal status on the
basis of their captivity.
Furthermore, this listing decision does not establish new agency
policy. In fact, this listing determination is consistent with the
Service's general practice for captive members of a species to be
afforded the same legal status under the Act as those members of the
species in the wild.
In compliance with the Endangered Species Act and the
Administrative Procedure Act, the Service's listing determination,
which included its evaluation of whether captive chimpanzees may have
separate legal status under the Act, was subject to public notice and
comment. The Service was under no legal requirement, as suggested by
the commenter, to subject the analysis used in evaluating this petition
to an additional and separate rulemaking process or to develop agency
guidelines such as those identified under section 4(h) of the Act.
(23) Comment: Commenters expressed concern that the Service's broad
statements of policy regarding its legal authority to recognize
exemptions from the Act for captive animals is beyond the scope of the
petition. According to one commenter, the petition is specific to the
listing of chimpanzees only, and the Service's proposal should be as
well.
Our Response: Assuming that the commenters are characterizing the
authority to designate separate legal status under the Act for captive
animals as an ``exemption,'' the Service disagrees that the issue of
designating separate legal status for captive chimpanzees is beyond the
scope of the petition. Because the petition requested, in essence, the
elimination of the separate classification for captive chimpanzees from
chimpanzees located in the wild, the Service appropriately considered,
as an initial matter, whether it had any discretion to designate legal
status under the Act to captive members separate from their wild
counterparts. Assessing whether the petitioned action involves an
entity eligible for legal status under the Act is part of the Service's
standard practice in making petition-findings. See, e.g., 12-Month
Findings on Petitions to Delist U.S. Captive Populations of the
Scimitar-horned Oryx, Dama Gazelle, and Addax 78 FR 33790, 33791 (June
5, 2013) (including a discussion on the ``Evaluation of Listable
Entities''); 12-Month Finding on a Petition to List 14 Aquatic Mollusks
as Endangered or Threatened, 77 FR 57922, 57923 (September 18, 2012)
(including a discussion on the ``Evaluation of Listable Entities'');
12-Month Finding on Petition to List the Wanton's Cave Meshweaver as
Endangered or Threatened, 79 FR 47413, 47415 (August 13, 2014)
(including a discussion on ``Evaluation of Listable Entities''); 90-Day
Finding on a Petition to List Thermophilic Ostracod as Endangered or
Threatened, 77 FR 9618, 9618 (February 17, 2012) (including a
discussion on the ``Evaluation of Listable Entities''); 90-Day Finding
on Petition to List Sphinx Date Palm, 77 FR 71757 (including a
discussion on the ``Evaluation of Listable Entities''). Thus, the issue
was properly part of the Service's petition-finding and determination
to list all chimpanzees as an endangered species. In addition, as noted
above the rule has been revised to clarify that the Service's analysis
is specific to the issue of whether captive chimpanzees should have
separate legal status on the basis of their captivity.
(24) Comment: One commenter stated that for a notice of a new
policy to be effective, particularly one that modifies, or at least
substantially impacts, the Captive-Bred Wildlife rule, it must alert
the public that a change in policy is being considered.
Our Response: The commenter fails to identify any new policy or a
change in policy being issued through this listing determination. As
explained in the preamble of our proposed listing rule, the Service has
not had an absolute policy or practice with respect to the designation
of separate legal status under the Act for captive animals, but
generally has included wild and captive animals together when it has
listed species. Thus, this action does not involve a change in policy,
nor does it involve any modification or impact to the Captive-Bred
Wildlife rule. In fact, this listing action is consistent with the
Service's general practice of listing captive and wild members of a
species together. As part of the Service's evaluation of the petition
to list all chimpanzees as endangered, this action included an
examination of whether the agency has any discretion to differentiate
the listing status of specimens in captivity from those in the wild.
The Service's listing determination, including its analysis of whether
captive chimpanzees may have separate legal status under the Act from
[[Page 34520]]
their wild counterparts, was subject to public notice and comment.
(25) Comment: The Service received comments that it should base
this listing determination on the conservation status of the captive
specimens, focusing on an assessment of whether the five factors
require listing of captive chimpanzees, rather than a position or
policy that the agency lacks authority to assign a separate legal
status to all captive species by virtue of their captive status. Other
commenters claimed that the Service's failure to analyze whether
captive chimpanzees are an endangered species due to the five factors
under section 4(a)(1) constituted a violation of the Act. Some
commenters further contended that captive chimpanzees are not in danger
of extinction due to any of the five factors set forth under section
4(a)(1) of the Act.
Our Response: Having concluded that we do not have discretion to
treat captive chimpanzees as a separate listable entity from wild
chimpanzees, the Service properly assessed the status of the
``species'' to determine if it met the definition of a ``threatened
species'' or an ``endangered species'' due to any one or a combination
of the five factors found in section 4(a)(1) of the Act. See Trout
Unlimited v. Lohn, 559 F. 3d 946, 955-956 (9th Cir 2009)
(distinguishing between two analytical phases of the listing process--
the ``composition phase'' involving the ``neutral'' task of defining a
``species'' and the subsequent decision to list due to the factors
under section 4(a)(1) of the Act). As part of the assessment of the
status of the ``species,'' the Service examined the extent to which
captive chimpanzees created or contributed to threats to the species or
remove or reduce threats to the species by contributing to the
conservation of the species. This approach of considering the
contribution of captive members on their wild counterparts in a status
assessment of the species has been upheld by the Ninth Circuit in Trout
Unlimited v. Lohn, 559 F. 3d at 961 (upholding NMFS's 2005 Hatchery
Policy which established that the effects of hatchery fish will be
included in assessing the status of the entire Evolutionary Significant
Unit in the context of their contributions to conserving natural self-
sustaining populations). But having found for a number of reasons that
the Service does not have the discretion to give captive chimpanzees
separate legal status, it was both unnecessary and would be
inappropriate to conduct a listing analysis on just captive
chimpanzees.
(26) Comment: The proposed rule states that captive populations of
wildlife do not have their own recognizable range and that a species'
range consists only of those portions of the species' historic range
where the species is found in the wild. This approach ignores the
importance that adaptation plays in species conservation. If the
Service refuses to recognize a species' range as the habitat in which
the population currently lives, whether in the wild or in captivity,
then the Service will be powerless to accommodate circumstances that
change wildlife behavior patterns.
Our Response: It appears that the commenter may have misunderstood
our interpretation of ``range.'' Nonetheless, we stand by our position
noted in the proposed rule and this final rule that ``range'' has
consistently been interpreted by the Service as being the natural range
of the species in the wild. Furthermore, the Service's 2014 policy on
the meaning of the phrase ``significant portion of its range'' (SPR)
(79 FR 37577; July 1, 2014) defines ``range'' as the ``general
geographic area within which that species can be found at the time [the
Service] or [the National Marine Fisheries Service] makes any
particular status determination,'' which we interpret also to apply to
the range of the species in the wild. Therefore, the Service's
definition of range does not ignore the importance of adaptation in
species conservation. If circumstances change wildlife behavior
patterns, changes in areas where the species is found in the wild would
be considered part of its range.
(27) Comment: One commenter asserted that the Service's
interpretation of the term ``range'' under section 4(c)(1) of the Act
as including the general geographical area where the species is found
in the wild would prevent the Service from complying with its statutory
obligation to specify for each species listed over what portion of its
range it is an endangered species or a threatened species in the event
a species no longer exists in the wild and can only be found in
captivity.
Our Response: Under this hypothetical, the Service disagrees that
its interpretation of the term ``range'' would prevent it from
specifying ``over what portion of its range'' it is an endangered
species or a threatened species in accordance with section 4(c)(1) of
the Act. For a species that only exists in captivity, the Service
indicates the range of the species in the wild that would occur but for
the conditions that have led to extirpation from the wild in the
``Historic Range'' column of the listing at 50 CFR 17.11 or 17.12,
consistent with our interpretation. For example, the listing of the
Scimitar-horned oryx at 50 CFR 17.11 indicates the historic range as
North Africa, even though the Service acknowledged the oryx may no
longer exist in the wild. See Final Rule to List the Scimitar-horned
oryx, Addax, and Dama Gazelle as Endangered, 70 FR 52319 (September 2,
2005).
(28) Comment: The Service's position that the Act deprives it of
the authority to separately classify a population made exclusively of
captive members contradicts the Service's litigation position in Safari
Club International v. Salazar, et al. in which the Service maintained
that it possessed the authority to make decisions about the listing
status of captive populations on a case-by-case basis.
Our Response: Prior to fully analyzing the issue of designating
separate legal status for captive animals for consistency with the
statutory standards, an issue raised in the petitions to delist U.S.
captive populations of Scimitar-horned oryx, addax, and dama gazelle
and the petition to list all chimpanzees as an endangered species, we
acknowledge that the Service provided the same listing status to all
members of a species as the default, unless the facts indicated that
there should be a different result. See Safari Club International v.
Jewell, 960 F.Supp 2d 17, 64 (D.D.C. 2013) (upholding the Service's
2005 final determination to list Scimitar-horned oryx, addax, and dama
gazelle as being consistent with the agency's general policy and
practice). Having now examined the language, purpose, operation of key
provisions, and the legislative history of the Act in response to the
issue raised in the above-mentioned petitions, we have concluded that
the Service does not have the discretion to designate separate legal
status under the Act for captive chimpanzees from wild members of the
same species, which is consistent with our findings on the antelope
petitions. As noted above, the rule has been revised to clarify that
the Service's analysis is specific to the petitioned species.
(29) Comment: The Service expresses a general concern that captive
chimpanzees might not meet the Act's definition of ``threatened
species'' or ``endangered species,'' leaving captive chimpanzees
unprotected by the Act. In order to avoid this result, the Service
proposes that captive chimpanzees must receive the same listing as wild
chimpanzees to ensure that they receive protections, even though they
do not qualify for listing. Such an approach is inconsistent with the
Act's purpose to promote conservation of the species and
[[Page 34521]]
DPS which are actually endangered or threatened species.
Our Response: It is unclear whether the commenter believes that the
Service found that captive chimpanzees would not qualify for listing
under the Act if the required analysis were conducted or whether the
commenter believes that captive chimpanzees do not qualify for listing.
To process the petition, we had to consider whether captive chimpanzees
had appropriately been considered separate listable entities
previously. Part of this analysis included potential conservation
outcomes if a section 4(a) analysis were conducted solely on captive
chimpanzees (which was not done when we designated captive chimpanzees
as a separate threatened DPS in 1990) and whether the potential
consequences of this approach would be consistent with Congress' intent
for the Act. Having found for a number of reasons that the Service does
not have the discretion to give captive animals separate legal status,
it was both unnecessary and would be inappropriate to conduct a listing
analysis on just captive chimpanzees. For all the reasons explained in
this rule, we find that this decision is consistent with the purposes
of the Act and Congress' intent.
In fact, if the separate designation of wild chimpanzees and
captive chimpanzees were maintained, proponents of separate legal
status could argue that captive specimens do not qualify as endangered
or threatened species under an analysis of the best available
scientific information related to the five factors found under section
4(a)(1) of the Act. Indeed, we note that this commenter appears to
contend that captive chimpanzees do not qualify for listing. Because
under this line of thinking captive chimpanzees might not meet the
definitions of endangered or threatened species under the statutory
factors, captive chimpanzees could be petitioned for, and arguably
would qualify for, delisting. These animals would therefore lose any
legal protections of the Act, even as wild chimpanzees face threats
that have intensified and expanded since 1990, continue to decline, and
have already been extirpated from some range countries. Unfortunately
it is conceivable that all wild chimpanzees could be extirpated at some
point in the future and therefore, under the commenter's line of
reasoning, wild chimpanzees would qualify for delisting as extinct
under 50 CFR 424.11(d)(1) while captive chimpanzees would still have no
protections under the Act. Such potential consequences due to separate
listings of chimpanzees would be inconsistent with the Act's purpose of
protecting threatened and endangered species.
(30) Comment: The Service should reconsider its definition of
``captivity.'' If a species' existence outside of its historic range
involves a lifestyle closely resembling life in the wild, then the
Service should treat that population more like wild populations than
captive ones. In captivity, chimpanzees do not have a lifestyle that
even remotely mimics their existence in the wild.
Our Response: The request to reconsider the Service's regulatory
definition of ``captivity'' is beyond the scope of this action to
consider whether all chimpanzees should be listed as an endangered
species under the Act.
(31) Comment: In its new interpretation, the Service did not
address the fact that the Act recognizes the ``scientific'' value of
wildlife and acknowledges ``scientific'' purposes as a separate animal
use in addition to other possible uses, i.e., commercial, recreational,
or educational purposes, when the potential for overutilization is
considered.
Our Response: In determining whether we had any discretion to
designate separate legal status under the Act to captive chimpanzees,
the Service specifically acknowledged that Congress recognized
``overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or
education purposes'' as a potential threat that contributes to the risk
of extinction for many species. We found that if captive specimens
could have separate legal status under the Act, the threat of
overutilization could increase. Such a consequence would be
inconsistent with section 2(b)'s purpose of conserving endangered and
threatened species. The role of scientific use of endangered wildlife
is also acknowledged under section 10(a)(1)(A) as one of the purposes
for which a permit may be issued to conduct otherwise prohibited
activities.
(32) Comment: Although the Service noted past examples of and
concerns about the possibility of not being able to distinguish between
captive and wild specimens in its proposed rule, chimpanzees currently
located at U.S. research facilities are not only few in number, but
also individually identified and recorded.
Our Response: The comment appears to be referring to the Service's
conclusion that, as a general matter, separate legal status for captive
animals would be inconsistent with the purpose of section 2(b) of the
Act due to the potential for increased take and trade in ``laundered''
wild-caught specimens that would generally be indistinguishable from
unprotected, captive specimens. In assessing whether captive
chimpanzees actually create or contribute to the threat of
overutilization to the species, the Service did not find evidence that
captive specimens specifically held in U.S. research facilities were
contributing to or creating any threats to the species. Nonetheless,
even if captive chimpanzees in U.S. research facilities are currently
few in number and all captive chimpanzees at these facilities are
individually identified and recorded, this may not be the case in the
future. In addition, it does not appear that captive chimpanzees
generally have reduced any threats to the species, including removal of
animals from the wild for the pet trade, as threats to the species have
only intensified since the 1990 reclassification of the wild population
from a threatened species to an endangered species.
(33) Comment: Some commenters indicated their support for the
Service's continued reliance on its policy regarding the Recognition of
Distinct Vertebrate Population Segments under the Endangered Species
Act to assign separate legal status under the Act for chimpanzees held
in captivity. Other commenters noted that captive chimpanzee population
in the U.S. qualifies as a ``distinct population segment'' under the
plain language of the Act and the interagency policy on distinct
population segments.
Our Response: Based upon an examination of the language, purpose,
operation of key provisions, and the legislative history of the Act,
the Service has concluded that it does not have the discretion to
assign legal status under the Act for captive specimens of chimpanzees
separate from their wild counterparts, which includes designating
captive chimpanzees and wild chimpanzees as separate distinct
population segments pursuant to our 1996 policy regarding the
Recognition of Distinct Vertebrate Population Segments under the
Endangered Species Act. Although the Service's 1990 final
reclassification rule for chimpanzees, issued prior to the promulgation
of the 1996 policy, designated captive and wild chimpanzees as separate
distinct population segments, that designation was not analyzed as to
how it was consistent with the statutory standards.
(34) Comment: The Service received comments indicating that the Act
does not limit the Service's authority to assign captive animals
separate legal status from specimens of the same species or subspecies
that occur in the wild. Some commenters noted that
[[Page 34522]]
nothing in the plain language, purpose, or legislative history of the
Act precludes according separate legal status to captive animals and
their wild counterparts. Other commenters maintained that the Act
provides broad authority to the Service to carry out animal
conservation and protection requirements, as well as flexibility for
the agency to take a variety of regulatory approaches.
Our Response: We agree that nothing in the Act expressly specifies
whether or not captive specimens can or cannot have separate legal
status based on their captive state. However, our analysis of the
language, purpose, operation, and legislative history of the Act, when
considered together, indicates that Congress did not intend for captive
specimens of wildlife to be subject to separate legal status on the
basis of their captive state. We believe that this is a reasonable
construction of the Act and is consistent with our general practice of
designating the same legal status to captive and wild members of the
same species.
As for the authority under the Act to carry out animal conservation
and protection programs, such programs, as well as other regulatory
options, are only available if the entity qualifies as an endangered or
threatened species. For the reasons explained in this final rule, as
well as past petitions received and comments received during this
rulemaking, it is possible that captive animals considered as separate
listable entities would not qualify as endangered or threatened
species.
(35) Comment: The Service received comments that this agency action
overturns 37 years of previous policy according separate conservation
status of captive chimpanzees without justification. Observing that an
agency's long-standing policies or statutory interpretations are
entitled to deference, one commenter indicated that the agency failed
to explain its reasoning for departing from its prior interpretation
through this action. Another commenter noted that the Service cannot
cite to any change in the language of the Act since it adopted the
split-listing of captive and wild chimpanzees to support its departure
from its 37-year-old policy.
Our Response: Because the Service has had no absolute policy or
practice concerning differentiating the listing status of specimens in
captivity from those in the wild, but has generally listed captive and
wild members together, we do not believe that this listing
determination represents a departure from any policy on that matter. To
the extent that the commenters maintain that this action is a departure
from how the Service has previously treated chimpanzees listed under
the Act, we agree that there has been no statutory change prompting the
Service to list all chimpanzees as an endangered species. However, the
Service's 1990 decision to reclassify wild chimpanzees from a
threatened species to an endangered species, while maintaining the
threatened species classification for captive chimpanzees, did not
include a thorough analysis of whether it was appropriate under the Act
to accord legal status for captive members separate from wild members
of the same species. In response to a comment that there was no
legislative history suggesting that captive populations could be
treated as distinct species and no precedent for doing so, the 1990
final chimpanzee rule stated only that captive animals are distinct
from wild populations and have the potential to interbreed when mature,
an apparent reference to the DPS provision within the Act's definition
of ``species,'' and that some captive chimpanzees were specifically
being managed as an interbreeding population. The 1990 final rule also
noted one situation--the Nile crocodile--where the Service had
previously listed captive specimens separately from wild specimens.
In response to the issues raised in this petition, we evaluated the
language, purposes, operation, and legislative history of the Act to
reasonably conclude that Congress did not intend for captive
chimpanzees to be subject to separate legal status on the basis of
their captive state. After determining that all chimpanzees, including
captive and wild animals, should be considered a single listable entity
under the Act, we evaluated the status of the ``species'' to find that
endangered is the correct conservation status for the chimpanzee. The
Service's justification for designating all chimpanzees as an
endangered species was thoroughly detailed in our 12-month finding and
proposed rule and is explained again here.
We acknowledge, however, that the Service has indicated in a
limited number of situations that captive wildlife can have separate
legal status from wild members of the species. In 1992, the Service
received a petition to reclassify cotton-top tamarins held in captivity
in North America and found that the petition presented substantial
information indicating that the petitioned action may be warranted (58
FR 64927, December 10, 1993). But the notice provided no analysis of
how the captive animals could be given separate legal status and no
further action was taken on the petition. The taxonomic species remains
listed as an endangered species in its entirety. In 2011, we found that
a petition to list plains bison did not present substantial information
indicating that listing may be warranted and in the notice stated that
we only considered wild bison in the evaluation because the Service did
not consider it to be within the intent of the Act to consider bison
``in commercial herds'' for listing (76 FR 10299, February 24, 2011).
This notice did not contain a thorough analysis like that conducted in
response to the antelope petitions or this petition, however, and we
likely would not reach the same conclusion today.
Other than the chimpanzee listing decision in 1990, there is only
one time where we have given separate legal status to captive specimens
on the basis of their captive state. On June 17, 1987, we published a
final rule reclassifying captive Nile crocodiles in Zimbabwe from an
endangered species to a threatened species (52 FR 23148). The rule
provided no explanation for how captive Nile crocodiles in Zimbabwe
could qualify as a separate listed entity, however, and appears to have
been based on a concurrent change in the specimens' status under CITES
from Appendix I to Appendix II, not on any analysis under the Act. The
differing listings statuses for captive and wild Zimbabwe Nile
crocodiles were resolved a little more than a year later when wild Nile
crocodiles in Zimbabwe were also reclassified from endangered to
threatened (53 FR 38451, September 30, 1988). Importantly, both the
chimpanzee and the Nile crocodile split listings were completed prior
to the development of our 1996 DPS Policy (61 FR 4722, February 7,
1996) and thus before we had fully considered the appropriateness of
separate legal status for captive specimens under the Act.
(36) Comment: The Service has not followed certain legal procedures
required in publishing the proposed listing rule. Specifically, the
Service failed to make certain documents available for review and
comment by the public. In addition, the Service failed to have this
regulatory action reviewed by the Office of Information and Regulatory
Affairs, as required by Executive Order 12866.
Our Response: The Service observed all procedural requirements in
promulgating this listing determination. Consistent with the
Administrative Procedure Act, all information upon which this
determination is based was identified in the Service's listing proposal
in order to allow for meaningful public comment on this rulemaking.
Additionally, as noted in
[[Page 34523]]
the Conference Report to the 1982 Amendments to the Act, economic
factors cannot be considered when assessing the legal status of a
species under the Act. Thus, this action is not subject to review by
the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs pursuant to Executive
Order 12866.
(37) Comment: The Service contends that captive chimpanzees cannot
qualify as a species because they have no ``habitat'' or ``range.''
However, the Act's definitions of ``species,'' ``habitat,'' or
``range'' does not require the Service to list all chimpanzees as an
endangered species. Just because the Service may interpret ``range'' as
the ``geographical area where the species is found in the wild,'' this
does not mean that the Act precludes a definition which would encompass
geographic areas where animals are held in captivity.
Our Response: We agree that nothing in the Act, including its
definition of ``species,'' ``endangered species,'' or ``threatened
species,'' expressly precludes designating legal status under the Act
for captive chimpanzees based on their captive state. However, as part
of our evaluation as to whether captive and wild chimpanzees can have
separate legal status, we reviewed, among other things, the language of
the Act. Although the Act does not contain a definition of the term
``range,'' the Service has consistently interpreted that term to mean
the geographical area where the species is found in the wild. Thus,
given the Service's consistent interpretation of ``range,'' among other
things, we have found that inconsistencies would exist under a
determination of separate legal status for captive animals. Overall, we
believe that the analysis shows that our interpretations of ``range''
and ``species'' are consistent with Congress' intent and the most
appropriate approach under the Act.
(38) Comment: Nothing in the Act's permitting provisions under
section 10(a)(1) of the Act or any other provision addressing
exceptions for animals in captivity precludes the Service from issuing
a split-listing. Thus, there is no inconsistency between the listing
procedures of the Act and those provisions that permit otherwise
unlawful activities that would result from designating legal status to
animals held in captivity from members of the same species or
subspecies that occur in the wild.
Our Response: We believe the exceptions in section 9(b)(1) and
section 9(b)(2), as well as the availability of permits for the
propagation of the species under section 10(a)(1)(A) of the Act, shows
that Congress intended that captive animals would generally have the
same legal status as their counterparts. Otherwise, if captive
specimens could simply be excluded through the listing process, none of
these provisions would be needed.
(39) Comment: The case law cited by the Service does not require
that captive chimpanzees be listed with the same conservation status as
wild chimpanzees.
Our Response: We agree that there is no case law specifically
addressing whether captive chimpanzees must be listed with the same
conservation status as wild chimpanzees. However, the decision in Alsea
Valley Alliance v. Evans, 161 F. Supp. 2d 1154 (D.Or. 2001), in which
the Court found that captive specimens, in that case hatchery fish,
cannot simply be excluded under the Act when they are members of the
listable entity, supports our conclusion that other potential
approaches besides separate designation as a DPS cannot be used to
provide separate legal status under the Act for captive specimens from
their wild counterparts.
(40) Comment: In its factual findings promulgated in the 1990 rule
to reclassify wild chimpanzees as endangered species, the Service
indicated that to the extent self-sustaining breeding groups of captive
chimpanzees provide surplus animals for research and other purposes,
there may be reduced probability that other individuals of that species
will be removed from the wild. The Service's failure to address or
distinguish its 1990 finding that research with captive chimpanzees may
conserve the wild chimpanzee population is irrational and inconsistent
with the Act's purpose to promote conservation of the species.
Our Response: In this listing action, we examined whether captive
chimpanzees create or contribute to threats to the species or remove or
reduce threats to the species. Although we stated in the 1990 rule that
captive chimpanzees may reduce the probability that individuals of the
species would be removed from the wild, we found that given that
threats to wild chimpanzees have expanded and intensified since 1990,
and capture for the illegal pet trade continues to be a major threat,
it doesn't appear that the availability of captive chimpanzees have
reduced any threats to the species. Therefore, we disagree that our
analysis is irrational and inconsistent with the purposes of the Act.
(41) Comment: Excluding captive species is consistent with the
Act's purposes, set forth in section 2(b), because it provides a pool
of genetic diversity and stock which can form the basis for
repopulation in the wild, or provide important research that assists in
wild species management and protection. As long as maintenance of a
captive population presents no threat to the species in the wild and
may assist in their conservation and protection, there is no barrier in
law to their exclusion.
Our Response: We disagree that the Act allows the Service to
exclude captive chimpanzees as long as they provide no threat to their
wild counterparts or may assist in their conservation and protection.
While captive animals may provide stock for reintroduction efforts or
provide important research for management and protection of the species
in the wild, we reasonably concluded that Congress did not intend for
captive chimpanzees to be subject to separate legal status under the
Act from specimens that occur in the wild based on the language,
purposes, operation of key provisions, and the legislative history of
the Act. In addition, sections 9 and 10 of the Act contain provisions
that allow the development and maintenance of genetically diverse
captive stock for use in reintroductions or research that assists the
species in the wild while at the same time providing these animals the
appropriate legal protections under the Act.
(42) Comment: The petition requests the Service for a new legal
opinion, as well as a repeal of the current 4(d) rule that applies to
captive chimpanzees; however, the Act does not provide the public a
right to petition for these types of relief.
Our Response: In making our 90-day finding, we determined that the
petition clearly identified itself as a petition under the Endangered
Species Act to request reclassification of captive chimpanzees from
threatened species to endangered species and contained the requisite
information required of petitions under our implementing regulations at
50 CFR 424.14(a). In a subsequent October 2010 letter, the petitioners
clarified that their petitioned action was to list the entire species
as an endangered species, whether in the wild or in captivity. Thus, we
found that the petition to reclassify chimpanzees was appropriate under
the Act. The petitioners did not petition for a new legal opinion. The
petitioners also did not specifically petition for revision of the 4(d)
rule as applied to chimpanzees, although petitioning for such a
rulemaking is available under the Administrative Procedure Act and our
regulations at 50 CFR 424.14(a).
(43) Comment: Listing captive chimpanzees as endangered species is
[[Page 34524]]
not warranted. No scientific information, substantial or otherwise, has
been presented suggesting that U.S. captive chimpanzees meet the
listing criteria set forth in the law and are in danger of extinction.
By the Service's own account, the availability of captive chimpanzees
has had, at worst, a neutral effect on wild populations.
Our Response: All chimpanzees, including captive and wild animals,
are considered by the Service to be a single listable entity under the
Act for the reasons explained in the proposed rule and this final rule.
As such, we did not evaluate whether captive chimpanzees, alone, met
the definition of an ``endangered species'' or a ``threatened species''
due to the five factors under section 4(a)(1) of the Act. Rather, in
our review of the status of the ``species'' pursuant to section 4(b)(1)
of the Act, we properly applied the five factors under section 4(a)(1)
to the species, including considering the extent to which captive
chimpanzees create or contribute to the threats to the species or
remove or reduce threats to the species in order to determine that all
chimpanzees are in danger of extinction.
(44) Comment: The Service hypothesizes that if captive and wild
specimens have different legal status under the Act, there will be
increased poaching, smuggling, and laundering of protected wild
specimens, and that wild populations would decline while survival of
the species would depend on unprotected members in captivity. However,
these hypotheticals cannot serve as valid authority for eliminating the
separate legal status of captive and wild chimpanzees under the Act
because the Service recognizes that, despite the current
classification, trade in wild chimpanzee specimens has in fact been
limited.
Our Response: Although we noted that legal trade in wild chimpanzee
specimens has been limited, that finding does not affect our conclusion
that chimpanzees, including captive and wild animals, should be treated
as a single listable entity, which is consistent with how we have
evaluated other species. In evaluating whether we have discretion to
provide separate legal status for captive chimpanzees, we found that
Congress did not intend for captive specimens to be subject to separate
legal status on the basis of their captive state, in part because of
the potential consequences of such designation. The Service
appropriately considered the conservation consequences of designating
legal status under the Act to captive members separate from wild
members of the same species in order to determine whether such
designation would be consistent with the purposes of the Act and
Congress' intent. Given the potential for increased take and trade in
``laundered'' wild-caught specimens that would generally be
indistinguishable from unprotected and unregulated captive specimens,
we concluded that separate legal status under the Act for captive
animals would be inconsistent with the purpose under section 2(b) of
the Act.
Required Determinations
National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.)
We have determined that we do not need to prepare an environmental
assessment, as defined under the authority of the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969, in connection with regulations
adopted under section 4(a) of the Act for the listing, delisting, or
reclassification of species. We published a notice outlining our
reasons for this determination in the Federal Register on October 25,
1983 (48 FR 49244).
References Cited
A list of all references cited in this document is available at
http://www.regulations.gov at Docket No. FWS-R9-ES-2010-0086, or upon
request from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Endangered Species
Program, Branch of Foreign Species (see FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT).
Authors
The primary authors of this rule are staff members of the Branch of
Foreign Species, Endangered Species Program, U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service.
List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 17
Endangered and threatened species, Exports, Imports, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements, Transportation.
Regulation Promulgation
Accordingly, we amend part 17, subchapter B of chapter I, title 50
of the Code of Federal Regulations, as set forth below:
PART 17--[AMENDED]
0
1. The authority citation for part 17 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1361-1407; 1531-1544; 4201-4245, unless
otherwise noted.
0
2. Amend Sec. 17.11(h) in the List of Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife by:
0
a. Revising the entry for ``Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)'' (``Wherever
found in the wild''); and
0
b. Removing the entry for ``Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes)'' (``Wherever
found in captivity'').
The revision reads as follows:
Sec. 17.11 Endangered and threatened wildlife.
* * * * *
(h) * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Species Vertebrate
------------------------------------------------------ population where Critical Special
Historic range endangered or Status When listed habitat rules
Common name Scientific name threatened
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAMMALS ................... .................. .................. ............ ................. ........... ...........
* * * * * * *
Chimpanzee...................... Pan troglodytes.... Africa............ Entire............ E 16, 376, 852 NA NA
* * * * * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0
3. Amend Sec. 17.40 by revising paragraph (c)(1) and removing
paragraph (c)(3).
The revision reads as follows:
Sec. 17.40 Special rules--mammals.
(c) * * *
(1) Except as noted in paragraph (c)(2) of this section, all
provisions of Sec. 17.31 apply to the lesser slow loris (Nycticebus
pygmaeus); Philippine tarsier (Tarsius syrichta); white-footed tamarin
(Saguinus leucopus); black howler monkey (Alouatta pigra); stump-tailed
macaque (Macaca arctoides); gelada baboon (Theropithecus gelada);
Formosan rock macaque (Macaca cyclopis); Japanese macaque (Macaca
fuscata); Toque macaque (Macaca sinica); long-tailed langur (Presbytis
potenziani); purple-faced langur
[[Page 34525]]
(Presbytis senex); and Tonkin snub-nosed langur (Pygathrix
[Rhinopithecus] avunculus).
* * * * *
Dated: June 1, 2015.
Stephen Guertin,
Acting Director, Fish and Wildlife Service.
[FR Doc. 2015-14232 Filed 6-12-15; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 4310-55-P