[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 111 (Wednesday, June 10, 2015)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 33030-33098]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-13764]
[[Page 33029]]
Vol. 80
Wednesday,
No. 111
June 10, 2015
Part II
Department of Energy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
10 CFR Part 430
Energy Conservation Program: Energy Conservation Standards for
Residential Conventional Ovens; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 80 , No. 111 / Wednesday, June 10, 2015 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 33030]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
10 CFR Part 430
[Docket Number EERE-2014-BT-STD-0005]
RIN 1904-AD15
Energy Conservation Program: Energy Conservation Standards for
Residential Conventional Ovens
AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of
Energy.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR) and public meeting.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1975 (EPCA), as
amended, prescribes energy conservation standards for various consumer
products and certain commercial and industrial equipment, including
residential conventional ovens. EPCA also requires the U.S. Department
of Energy (DOE) to determine whether more-stringent, amended standards
would be technologically feasible and economically justified, and would
save a significant amount of energy. DOE is proposing new and amended
energy conservation standards for residential conventional ovens. DOE
is also announcing a public meeting to receive comment on these
proposed standards and associated analyses and results.
DATES: DOE will hold a public meeting on Tuesday, July 14, 2015, from 9
a.m. to 4 p.m., in Washington, DC. The meeting will also be broadcast
as a webinar. See section VII Public Participation for webinar
registration information, participant instructions, and information
about the capabilities available to webinar participants.
DOE will accept comments, data, and information regarding this
notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR) before and after the public
meeting, but no later than August 10, 2015. See section VII Public
Participation for details.
ADDRESSES: The public meeting will be held at the U.S. Department of
Energy, Forrestal Building, Room 8E-089, 1000 Independence Avenue SW.,
Washington, DC 20585. To attend, please notify Ms. Brenda Edwards at
(202) 586-2945. Persons can attend the public meeting via webinar. For
more information, refer to the Public Participation section near the
end of this notice.
Any comments submitted must identify the NOPR for Energy
Conservation Standards for residential conventional cooking products,
and provide docket number EE-2014-BT-STD-0005 and/or regulatory
information number (RIN) number 1904-AD15. Comments may be submitted
using any of the following methods:
1. Federal eRulemaking Portal: www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
2. Email: [email protected].
Include the docket number and/or RIN in the subject line of the
message.
3. Mail: Ms. Brenda Edwards, U.S. Department of Energy, Building
Technologies Program, Mailstop EE-2J, 1000 Independence Avenue SW.,
Washington, DC 20585-0121. If possible, please submit all items on a
CD. It is not necessary to include printed copies.
4. Hand Delivery/Courier: Ms. Brenda Edwards, U.S. Department of
Energy, Building Technologies Program, 950 L'Enfant Plaza SW., Suite
600, Washington, DC 20024. Telephone: (202) 586-2945. If possible,
please submit all items on a CD, in which case it is not necessary to
include printed copies.
Written comments regarding the burden-hour estimates or other
aspects of the collection-of-information requirements contained in this
proposed rule may be submitted to Office of Energy Efficiency and
Renewable Energy through the methods listed above and by email to
[email protected].
For detailed instructions on submitting comments and additional
information on the rulemaking process, see section VII of this document
(Public Participation).
Docket: The docket, which includes Federal Register notices, public
meeting attendee lists and transcripts, comments, and other supporting
documents/materials, is available for review at regulations.gov. All
documents in the docket are listed in the regulations.gov index.
However, some documents listed in the index, such as those containing
information that is exempt from public disclosure, may not be publicly
available.
A link to the docket Web page can be found at: http://www.regulations.gov/#!docketDetail;D=EERE-2014-BT-STD-0005. This Web
page will contain a link to the docket for this notice on the
regulations.gov site. The regulations.gov Web page will contain simple
instructions on how to access all documents, including public comments,
in the docket. See section VII for further information on how to submit
comments through www.regulations.gov.
For further information on how to submit a comment, review other
public comments and the docket, or participate in the public meeting,
contact Ms. Brenda Edwards at (202) 586-2945 or by email:
[email protected].
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Mr. John Cymbalsky, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy
Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Building Technologies Program, EE-2J,
1000 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20585-0121. Telephone:
(202) 287-1692. Email: [email protected].
Ms. Celia Sher, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of the General
Counsel, GC-33, 1000 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20585-
0121. Telephone: (202) 287-6122. Email: [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Table of Contents
I. Synopsis of the Proposed Rule
A. Benefits and Costs to Consumers
B. Impact on Manufacturers
C. National Benefits and Costs
D. Conclusion
II. Introduction
A. Authority
B. Background
1. Current Standards
2. History of Standards Rulemaking for Residential Conventional
Cooking Products
III. General Discussion
A. Scope of Coverage
B. Further Rulemaking To Consider Energy Conservation Standards
for Conventional Cooking Tops
C. Test Procedure
D. Technological Feasibility
1. General
2. Maximum Technologically Feasible Levels
E. Energy Savings
1. Determination of Savings
2. Significance of Savings
F. Economic Justification
1. Specific Criteria
2. Rebuttable Presumption
IV. Methodology and Discussion of Comments
A. Market and Technology Assessment
1. General
2. Product Classes
3. Technology Options
B. Screening Analysis
1. Screened-Out Technologies
2. Remaining Technologies
C. Engineering Analysis
1. Methodology
2. Product Testing and Reverse Engineering
3. Efficiency Levels
4. Incremental Manufacturing Production Cost Estimates
5. Consumer Utility
D. Markups Analysis
E. Energy Use Analysis
F. Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Period Analysis
[[Page 33031]]
1. Product Costs
2. Installation Costs
3. Unit Energy Consumption
4. Energy Prices
5. Repair and Maintenance Costs
6. Product Lifetime
7. Discount Rates
8. Compliance Date
9. Base Case Efficiency Distribution
10. Inputs to Payback Period Analysis
11. Rebuttable-Presumption Payback Period
G. Shipments Analysis
H. National Impact Analysis
1. Efficiency Trends
2. National Energy Savings
3. Net Present Value of Customer Benefit
I. Consumer Subgroup Analysis
J. Manufacturer Impact Analysis
1. Overview
2. GRIM Analysis and Key Inputs
3. Discussion of Comments
4. Manufacturer Interviews
K. Emissions Analysis
L. Monetizing Carbon Dioxide and Other Emissions Impacts
1. Social Cost of Carbon
2. Social Cost of Other Air Pollutants
M. Utility Impact Analysis
N. Employment Impact Analysis
V. Analytical Results
A. Trial Standard Levels
B. Economic Justification and Energy Savings
1. Economic Impacts on Individual Consumers
2. Economic Impacts on Manufacturers
3. National Impact Analysis
4. Impact on Utility or Performance of Products
5. Impact of Any Lessening of Competition
6. Need of the Nation to Conserve Energy
7. Summary of National Economic Impacts
8. Other Factors
C. Conclusion
1. Benefits and Burdens of TSLs Considered for Conventional
Ovens
2. Annualized Benefits and Costs of the Proposed Standards
VI. Procedural Issues and Regulatory Review
A. Review Under Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
B. Review Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act
1. Description and Estimated Number of Small Entities Regulated
2. Description and Estimate of Compliance Requirements
3. Duplication, Overlap, and Conflict With Other Rules and
Regulations
4. Significant Alternatives to the Rule
C. Review Under the Paperwork Reduction Act
D. Review Under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
E. Review Under Executive Order 13132
F. Review Under Executive Order 12988
G. Review Under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
H. Review Under the Treasury and General Government
Appropriations Act, 1999
I. Review Under Executive Order 12630
J. Review Under the Treasury and General Government
Appropriations Act, 2001
K. Review Under Executive Order 13211
L. Review Under the Information Quality Bulletin for Peer Review
VII. Public Participation
A. Attendance at the Public Meeting
B. Procedure for Submitting Prepared General Statements For
Distribution
C. Conduct of the Public Meeting
D. Submission of Comments
E. Issues on Which DOE Seeks Comment
VIII. Approval of the Office of the Secretary
I. Synopsis of the Proposed Rule
Title III, Part B \1\ of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of
1975 (EPCA or the Act), Public Law 94-163 (42 U.S.C. 6291-6309, as
codified), established the Energy Conservation Program for Consumer
Products Other Than Automobiles.\2\ These products include residential
conventional ovens, the subject of this rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ For editorial reasons, upon codification in the U.S. Code,
Part B was redesignated Part A.
\2\ All references to EPCA in this document refer to the statute
as amended through the American Energy Manufacturing Technical
Corrections Act (AEMTCA), Public Law 112-210 (Dec. 18, 2012).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to EPCA, any new or amended energy conservation standard
must be designed to achieve the maximum improvement in energy
efficiency that is technologically feasible and economically justified.
(42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(A)) Furthermore, the new or amended standard must
result in a significant conservation of energy. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(3)(B)) In accordance with these and other statutory provisions
discussed in this notice, DOE proposes new and amended energy
conservation standards for residential conventional ovens. The proposed
standards, which are the maximum allowable integrated annual energy
consumption (IAEC), are shown in Table I-1. The integrated annual
energy consumption includes active mode (including fan-only mode for
conventional ovens), standby mode, and off mode energy use. These
proposed standards, if adopted, would apply to all products listed in
Table I-1 and manufactured in, or imported into, the United States on
or after the date three years after the publication of any final rule
for this rulemaking. The proposed standards correspond to trial
standard level (TSL) 2, which is described in section V.A. DOE also
notes that any newly adopted performance standards for conventional
ovens resulting from this current rulemaking would not affect the
current prescriptive standards prohibiting constant burning pilots for
all gas cooking products (10 CFR 430.32(j)).
Table I-1--Proposed Energy Conservation Standards for Conventional Ovens
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maximum integrated annual
Product class energy consumption (IAEC)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Standard Oven, Free-standing.. 122.5 + (31.8 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Standard Oven, Built-In/Slide- 128.6 + (31.8 x Rated Cavity
In. Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing 163.2 + (42.3 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/ 169.1 + (42.3 x Rated Cavity
Slide-In. Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Standard Oven, Free-Standing....... 492.9 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Standard Oven, Built-In/Slide-In... 499.5 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing..... 746.7 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/Slide-In. 755.5 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The Rated Cavity Volume is the volume of the oven cavity in cubic
feet as measured using the final DOE test procedure at 10 CFR part
430, subpart B, appendix I.
As discussed in section III.B, DOE has decided to defer its
decision regarding whether to adopt amended energy conservation
standards for conventional cooking tops, pending further rulemaking. In
both the test procedure NOPR published on January 30, 2013 (78 FR 6232,
the January 2013 TP NOPR) and the test procedure supplemental NOPR
(SNOPR) published on December 3, 2014 (79 FR 71894, the December 2014
TP SNOPR), DOE proposed amendments to the cooking products test
procedure in Appendix I to subpart B of Title 10 of the CFR part 430
that would allow for the testing of active mode energy consumption of
induction cooking tops. After reviewing public comments on the December
2014 TP SNOPR, conducting interviews with manufacturers, and performing
[[Page 33032]]
additional analyses, DOE believes further study is required before a
cooking top test procedure can be established that produces test
results which measure energy use during a representative average use
cycle, is repeatable and reproducible, and is not unduly burdensome to
conduct. For these reasons, this NOPR is limited to addressing energy
conservation standards for conventional ovens. As discussed in section
III.A, the proposed standards would cover conventional ovens, including
conventional ovens that are a part of conventional ranges. DOE intends
to complete the rulemaking process for conventional cooking tops once
additional key data and information become available.
A. Benefits and Costs to Consumers
Table I-2 presents DOE's evaluation of the economic impacts of the
proposed standards on consumers of residential conventional ovens, as
measured by the average life-cycle cost (LCC) savings and the simple
payback period (PBP).\3\ The average LCC savings are positive for all
product classes, and the PBP is less than the average lifetime of the
equipment, which is estimated to be 15 years for electric and 17 years
for gas ovens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ The average LCC savings are measured relative to the base-
case efficiency distribution, which depicts the market in the
compliance year (see section IV.F.9). The simple PBP, which is
designed to compare specific efficiency levels, is measured relative
to the baseline model.
Table I-2--Impacts of Proposed Energy Conservation Standards (TSL 2) on
Consumers of Residential Conventional Ovens
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average LCC Simple payback
Product class savings * period
(2014$) (years)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Standard Oven, Free-standing... $15.18 4.0
Electric Standard Oven, Built-in/Slide- 15.25 4.0
in.....................................
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing. 14.10 0.9
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Built-in/Slide- 14.20 0.9
in.....................................
Gas Standard Oven, Free-Standing........ 289.73 1.7
Gas Standard Oven, Built-in/Slide-in.... 289.77 1.7
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing...... 282.80 1.2
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/Slide-in.. 282.85 1.2
------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no
impact).
DOE's analysis of the impacts of the proposed standards on
consumers is described in section IV.F of this notice.
B. Impact on Manufacturers
The industry net present value (INPV) is the sum of the discounted
cash flows to the industry from the base year through the end of the
analysis period (2015 to 2048). Using a real discount rate of 9.1
percent, DOE estimates that the industry net present value (INPV) for
manufacturers of residential conventional ovens is $783.5 million in
2014$. Under the proposed standards, DOE expects that manufacturers may
lose up to 11.0 percent of their INPV, which is approximately $86.4
million in 2014$. Additionally, based on DOE's interviews with the
manufacturers of residential conventional ovens, DOE does not expect
any plant closings or significant loss of employment.
DOE's analysis of the impacts of the proposed standards on
manufacturers is described in section IV.J of this NOPR notice.
C. National Benefits and Costs \4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ All monetary values in this section are expressed in 2013
dollars and, where appropriate, are discounted to 2014.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE's analyses indicate that the proposed standards would save a
significant amount of energy. The lifetime energy savings from
residential conventional oven products purchased in the 30-year period
that begins in the assumed year of compliance with the proposed
standards (2019-2048), relative to the base case without the proposed
standards, amount to 0.71 quadrillion Btu (quads).\5\ This represents a
savings of 11.2 percent relative to the energy use of these products in
the base case.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ A quad is equal to 10\15\ British thermal units (Btu). The
quantity refers to full-fuel-cycle (FFC) energy savings. FFC energy
savings includes the energy consumed in extracting, processing, and
transporting primary fuels (i.e., coal, natural gas, petroleum
fuels), and thus presents a more complete picture of the impacts of
energy efficiency standards. For more information on the FFC metric,
see section IV.H.2.
A quad is equal to 10\15\ British thermal units (Btu).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The cumulative net present value (NPV) of total consumer costs and
savings of the proposed standards for ovens in residential conventional
cooking products ranges from $4.7 billion (at a 7-percent discount
rate) to $11.0 billion (at a 3-percent discount rate). This NPV
expresses the estimated total value of future operating-cost savings
minus the estimated increased product costs for products purchased in
2019-2048.
In addition, the proposed standards would have significant
environmental benefits. The energy savings described above are
estimated to result in cumulative emission reductions of 41.1 million
metric tons (Mt) \6\ of carbon dioxide (CO2), 221.2 thousand
tons of methane, 29.5 thousand tons of sulfur dioxide (SO2),
69 thousand tons of nitrogen oxides (NOX), 0.52 thousand
tons of nitrous oxide (N2O), and 0.09 tons of mercury
(Hg).\7\ The cumulative reduction in CO2 emissions through
2030 amounts to 7.5 Mt, which is equivalent to the emissions resulting
from the annual electricity use of 0.7 million homes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ A metric ton is equivalent to 1.1 short tons. Results for
emissions other than CO2 are presented in short tons.
\7\ DOE calculated emissions reductions relative to the Annual
Energy Outlook 2014 (AEO 2014) Reference case, which generally
represents current legislation and environmental regulations for
which implementing regulations were available as of October 31,
2013.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 33033]]
The value of the CO2 reductions is calculated using a
range of values per metric ton of CO2 (otherwise known as
the Social Cost of Carbon, or SCC) developed by a recent Federal
interagency process.\8\ The derivation of the SCC values is discussed
in section IV.L. Using discount rates appropriate for each set of SCC
values (see Table I-4), DOE estimates the present monetary value of the
CO2 emissions reduction is between $0.3 billion and $4.1
billion, with a value of $1.3 billion using the central SCC case
represented by $41.2/t in 2015.\9\ DOE also estimates the present
monetary value of the NOX emissions reduction, is $0.1
billion at a 7-percent discount rate and $0.2 billion at a 3-percent
discount rate.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ Technical Update of the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory
Impact Analysis Under Executive Order 12866. Interagency Working
Group on Social Cost of Carbon, United States Government. May 2013;
revised November 2013. http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/assets/inforeg/technical-update-social-cost-of-carbon-for-regulator-impact-analysis.pdf.
\9\ The values only include CO2 emissions, not
CO2 equivalent emissions; other gases with global warming
potential are not included.
\10\ DOE is currently investigating valuation of avoided Hg and
SO2 emissions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table I-3 summarizes the national economic costs and benefits
expected to result from the proposed standards for residential
conventional ovens.
Table I-3--Summary of National Economic Benefits and Costs of Proposed
Energy Conservation Standards for Residential Conventional Ovens *
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Present value
Category (Billion 2014$) Discount rate (%)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Benefits
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating Cost Savings........... 5.0 7
11.6 3
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 0.3 5
($12.2.0/t case) **.............
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 1.3 3
($41.2/t case) **...............
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 2.1 2.5
($63.4/t case) **...............
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 4.1 3
($121/t case) **................
NOX Reduction Monetized Value 0.1 7
[dagger]........................ 0.2 3
Total Benefits [dagger][dagger].. 6.4 7
13.2 3
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Costs
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Incremental Installed Costs...... 0.3 7
0.6 3
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Net Benefits
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Including Emissions Reduction 6.1 7
Monetized Value [dagger][dagger] 12.6 3
------------------------------------------------------------------------
* This table presents the costs and benefits associated with residential
conventional ovens shipped in 2019-2048. These results include impacts
to consumers which accrue after 2048 from the products purchased in
2019-2048. The results account for the incremental variable and fixed
costs incurred by manufacturers due to any final standard, some of
which may be incurred in preparation for the rule.
** The CO2 values represent global monetized values of the SCC, in
2014$, in 2015 under several scenarios of the updated SCC values. The
first three cases use the averages of SCC distributions calculated
using 5%, 3%, and 2.5% discount rates, respectively. The fourth case
represents the 95th percentile of the SCC distribution calculated
using a 3% discount rate. The SCC time series incorporate an
escalation factor.
[dagger] The $/ton values used for NOX are described in section IV.L.2.
[dagger][dagger] Total Benefits for both the 3% and 7% cases are derived
using the series corresponding to average SCC with 3-percent discount
rate ($40.5/t case).
The benefits and costs of these proposed standards, for products
sold in 2019-2048, can also be expressed in terms of annualized values.
The annualized monetary values are the sum of (1) the annualized
national economic value of the benefits from consumer operation of
products that meet the new or amended standards (consisting primarily
of operating cost savings from using less energy, minus increases in
equipment purchase and installation costs, which is another way of
representing consumer NPV), and (2) the annualized monetary value of
the benefits of emission reductions, including CO2 emission
reductions.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ To convert the time-series of costs and benefits into
annualized values, DOE calculated a present value in 2014, the year
used for discounting the NPV of total consumer costs and savings.
For the benefits, DOE calculated a present value associated with
each year's shipments in the year in which the shipments occur
(e.g., 2020 or 2030), and then discounted the present value from
each year to 2014. The calculation uses discount rates of 3 and 7
percent for all costs and benefits except for the value of
CO2 reductions, for which DOE used case-specific discount
rates, as shown in Table I.3. Using the present value, DOE then
calculated the fixed annual payment over a 30-year period, starting
in the compliance year that yields the same present value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although DOE believes that the values of operating savings and
CO2 emission reductions are both important, two issues are
relevant. First, the national operating savings are domestic U.S.
consumer monetary savings that occur as a result of market
transactions, whereas the value of CO2 reductions is based
on a global value. Second, the assessments of operating cost savings
and CO2 savings are performed with different methods that
use different time frames for analysis. The national operating cost
savings is measured for the lifetime of residential conventional ovens
shipped in 2019-2048. Because CO2 emissions have a very long
residence time in the atmosphere,\12\ the SCC values in future years
reflect future climate-related impacts resulting from the emission of
CO2 that continue well beyond 2100.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ The atmospheric lifetime of CO2 is estimated of
the order of 30-95 years. Jacobson, MZ (2005). ``Correction to
``Control of fossil-fuel particulate black carbon and organic
matter, possibly the most effective method of slowing global
warming.'' '' J. Geophys. Res. 110. pp. D14105.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimates of annualized benefits and costs of the proposed
standards are shown in Table I-4. The results under
[[Page 33034]]
the primary estimate are as follows. Using a 7-percent discount rate
for benefits and costs other than CO2 reduction, for which
DOE used a 3-percent discount rate along with the average SCC series
that has a value of $41.2/t in 2015, the cost of the proposed standards
is $33.5 million per year in increased equipment costs, while the
benefits are $494 million per year in reduced equipment operating
costs, $74 million in CO2 reductions, and $9 million in
reduced NOX emissions. In this case, the net benefit amounts
to $543 million per year. Using a 3-percent discount rate for all
benefits and costs and the average SCC series that has a value of
$41.2/t in 2015, the cost of the proposed standards is $33.1 million
per year in increased equipment costs, while the benefits are $648
million per year in reduced operating costs, $74 million in
CO2 reductions, and $13 million in reduced NOX
emissions. In this case, the net benefit amounts to $701 million per
year.
Table I-4--Annualized Benefits and Costs of Proposed Energy Conservation Standards for Residential Conventional Ovens
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(million 2014$/year)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discount rate Low net benefits High net benefits
Primary estimate * estimate * estimate *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Benefits
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating Cost Savings............. 7%...................................... 494.................... 457.................... 542.
3%...................................... 648.................... 593.................... 719.
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 5%...................................... 21..................... 20..................... 24.
($12.2/t case) *.
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 3%...................................... 74..................... 68..................... 81.
($41.2/t case) *.
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value 2.5%.................................... 108.................... 100.................... 119.
($63.4/t case) *.
CO2 Reduction Monetized Value ($121/ 3%...................................... 228.................... 211.................... 252.
t case) *.
NOX Reduction Monetized 7%...................................... 9.24................... 8.66................... 10.11.
Value[dagger]. 3%...................................... 13.43.................. 12.46.................. 14.80.
Total Benefits [dagger][dagger].... 7% plus CO2 range....................... 524 to 731............. 485 to 677............. 576 to 804.
7%...................................... 577.................... 534.................... 634.
3% plus CO2 range....................... 682 to 889............. 625 to 817............. 758 to 986.
3%...................................... 734.................... 674.................... 815.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Costs
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Incremental Product Costs. 7%...................................... 34..................... 34..................... 33.
3%...................................... 33..................... 34..................... 33.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net Benefits
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total [dagger][dagger]............. 7% plus CO2 range....................... 491 to 697............. 451 to 642............. 543 to 771.
7%...................................... 543.................... 499.................... 601.
3% plus CO2 range....................... 649 to 856............. 592 to 783............. 725 to 953.
3%...................................... 701.................... 640.................... 783.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* This table presents the annualized costs and benefits associated with residential conventional ovens shipped in 2019-2048. These results include
benefits to consumers which accrue after 2048 from the products purchased in 2014-2043. The results account for the incremental variable and fixed
costs incurred by manufacturers due to any final standard, some of which may be incurred in preparation for the rule. The Primary, Low Benefits, and
High Benefits Estimates utilize projections of energy prices from the AEO 2015 \13\ Reference case, Low Estimate, and High Estimate, respectively. In
addition, incremental product costs reflect a medium decline rate in the Primary Estimate, a low decline rate in the Low Benefits Estimate, and a high
decline rate f in the High Benefits Estimate. The methods used to derive projected price trends are explained in section IV.F.1.
** The CO2 values represent global monetized values of the SCC, in 2014$, in 2015 under several scenarios of the updated SCC values. The first three
cases use the averages of SCC distributions calculated using 5%, 3%, and 2.5% discount rates, respectively. The fourth case represents the 95th
percentile of the SCC distribution calculated using a 3% discount rate. The SCC time series incorporate an escalation factor.
[dagger] The $/ton values used for NOX are described in section IV.L.2.
[dagger][dagger] Total Benefits for both the 3% and 7% cases are derived using the series corresponding to the average SCC with 3-percent discount rate
($41.2/t case). In the rows labeled ``7% plus CO2 range'' and ``3% plus CO2 range,'' the operating cost and NOX benefits are calculated using the
labeled discount rate, and those values are added to the full range of CO2 values.
DOE's analysis of the national impacts of the proposed standards is
described in sections IV.H, IV.K and IV.L of this notice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\ http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/AEO/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Conclusion
DOE has tentatively concluded that the proposed standards represent
the maximum improvement in energy efficiency that is technologically
feasible and economically justified, and would result in the
significant conservation of energy. DOE further notes that products
achieving these standard levels are already commercially available for
at least some, if not most, product classes covered by this proposal.
Based on the analyses described above, DOE has tentatively concluded
that the benefits of the proposed standards to the Nation (energy
savings, positive NPV of consumer benefits, consumer LCC savings, and
emission reductions) would outweigh the burdens (loss of INPV for
manufacturers and LCC increases for some consumers).
DOE also considered more-stringent energy efficiency levels as
trial standard levels, and is considering them in this rulemaking.
However, DOE has tentatively concluded that the potential burdens of
the more-stringent energy efficiency levels would outweigh the
projected benefits. Based on consideration of the public comments DOE
receives in response to this notice and related information collected
and
[[Page 33035]]
analyzed during the course of this rulemaking effort, DOE may adopt
energy efficiency levels presented in this notice that are either
higher or lower than the proposed standards, or some combination of
level(s) that incorporate the proposed standards in part.
II. Introduction
The following section briefly discusses the statutory authority
underlying this proposal, as well as some of the relevant historical
background related to the establishment of standards for residential
cooking products.
A. Authority
Title III, Part B of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1975
(EPCA or the Act), Public Law 94-163 (42 U.S.C. 6291-6309, as codified)
established the Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products Other
Than Automobiles, a program covering most major household appliances
(collectively referred to as ``covered products''), which includes
residential cooking products \14\, and specifically residential
conventional ovens, that are the subject of this rulemaking. (42 U.S.C.
6292(a)(10)) EPCA prescribed energy conservation standards for these
products (42 U.S.C. 6295(h)(1)), and directed DOE to conduct
rulemakings to determine whether to amend these standards. (42 U.S.C.
6295(h)(2)) (DOE notes that under 42 U.S.C. 6295(m), the agency must
periodically review its already established energy conservation
standards for a covered product. Under this requirement, the next
review that DOE would need to conduct must occur no later than six
years from the issuance of a final rule establishing or amending a
standard for a covered product.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ DOE's regulations define kitchen ranges and ovens, or
``cooking products'', as one of the following classes: Conventional
ranges, conventional cooking tops, conventional ovens, microwave
ovens, microwave/conventional ranges and other cooking products. (10
CFR 430.2) Based on this definition, in this notice, DOE interprets
kitchen ranges and ovens to refer more generally to all types of
cooking products including, for example, microwave ovens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to EPCA, DOE's energy conservation program for covered
products consists essentially of four parts: (1) Testing; (2) labeling;
(3) the establishment of Federal energy conservation standards; and (4)
certification and enforcement procedures. The Federal Trade Commission
(FTC) is primarily responsible for labeling, and DOE implements the
remainder of the program. Subject to certain criteria and conditions,
DOE is required to develop test procedures to measure the energy
efficiency, energy use, or estimated annual operating cost of each
covered product. (42 U.S.C. 6293) Manufacturers of covered products
must use the prescribed DOE test procedure as the basis for certifying
to DOE that their products comply with the applicable energy
conservation standards adopted under EPCA and when making
representations to the public regarding the energy use or efficiency of
those products. (42 U.S.C. 6293(c) and 6295(s)) Similarly, DOE must use
these test procedures to determine whether the products comply with
standards adopted pursuant to EPCA. Id. The DOE test procedures for
residential conventional cooking products currently appear at title 10
of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) part 430, subpart B, appendix
I (Appendix I).
DOE must follow specific statutory criteria for prescribing new or
amended standards for covered products. As indicated above, any new or
amended standard for a covered product must be designed to achieve the
maximum improvement in energy efficiency that is technologically
feasible and economically justified. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(A))
Furthermore, DOE may not adopt any standard that would not result in
the significant conservation of energy. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(3))
Moreover, DOE may not prescribe a standard: (1) For certain products,
including residential conventional ovens, if no test procedure has been
established for the product, or (2) if DOE determines by rule that the
standard is not technologically feasible or economically justified. (42
U.S.C. 6295(o)(3)(A)-(B)) In deciding whether a standard is
economically justified, DOE must determine whether the benefits of the
standard exceed its burdens. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)) DOE must make
this determination after receiving comments on the proposed standard,
and by considering, to the greatest extent practicable, the following
seven statutory factors:
1. The economic impact of the standard on manufacturers and
consumers of the products subject to the standard;
2. The savings in operating costs throughout the estimated average
life of the covered products in the type (or class) compared to any
increase in the price, initial charges, or maintenance expenses for the
covered products that are likely to result from the imposition of the
standard;
3. The total projected amount of energy, or as applicable, water,
savings likely to result directly from the imposition of the standard;
4. Any lessening of the utility or the performance of the covered
products likely to result from the imposition of the standard;
5. The impact of any lessening of competition, as determined in
writing by the Attorney General, that is likely to result from the
imposition of the standard;
6. The need for national energy and water conservation; and
7. Other factors the Secretary of Energy (Secretary) considers
relevant. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(I)-(VII))
EPCA, as codified, also contains what is known as an ``anti-
backsliding'' provision, which prevents the Secretary from prescribing
any amended standard that either increases the maximum allowable energy
use or decreases the minimum required energy efficiency of a covered
product. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(1)) Also, the Secretary may not prescribe
an amended or new standard if interested persons have established by a
preponderance of the evidence that the standard is likely to result in
the unavailability in the United States of any covered product type (or
class) of performance characteristics (including reliability),
features, sizes, capacities, and volumes that are substantially the
same as those generally available in the United States. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(4))
Further, EPCA, as codified, establishes a rebuttable presumption
that a standard is economically justified if the Secretary finds that
the additional cost to the consumer of purchasing a product complying
with an energy conservation standard level will be less than three
times the value of the energy savings during the first year that the
consumer will receive as a result of the standard, as calculated under
the applicable test procedure. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(iii))
Additionally, 42 U.S.C. 6295(q)(1) specifies requirements when
promulgating a standard for a type or class of covered product that has
two or more subcategories. DOE must specify a different standard level
than that which applies generally to such type or class of products for
any group of covered products that have the same function or intended
use if DOE determines that products within such group (A) consume a
different kind of energy from that consumed by other covered products
within such type (or class); or (B) have a capacity or other
performance-related feature which other products within such type (or
class) do not have and such feature justifies a higher or lower
standard. (42 U.S.C. 6294(q)(1)) In determining whether a performance-
related feature justifies a different standard for a group of
[[Page 33036]]
products, DOE must consider such factors as the utility to the consumer
of the feature and other factors DOE deems appropriate. Id. Any rule
prescribing such a standard must include an explanation of the basis on
which such higher or lower level was established. (42 U.S.C.
6295(q)(2))
Federal energy conservation requirements generally supersede State
laws or regulations concerning energy conservation testing, labeling,
and standards. (42 U.S.C. 6297(a)-(c)) DOE may, however, grant waivers
of Federal preemption for particular State laws or regulations, in
accordance with the procedures and other provisions set forth under 42
U.S.C. 6297(d)).
Finally, pursuant to the amendments contained in section 310(3) of
EISA 2007, any final rule for new or amended energy conservation
standards promulgated after July 1, 2010, are required to address
standby mode and off mode energy use. (42 U.S.C. 6295(gg) (3))
Specifically, when DOE adopts a standard for a covered product after
that date, it must, if justified by the criteria for adoption of
standards under EPCA (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)), incorporate standby mode and
off mode energy use into the standard, or, if that is not feasible,
adopt a separate standard for such energy use for that product. (42
U.S.C. 6295(gg)(3)(A)-(B)) DOE's current test procedures for
residential conventional cooking products address standby mode and off
mode energy use. In this rulemaking, DOE intends to incorporate such
energy use into any amended energy conservation standards it adopts in
the final rule.
DOE has also reviewed this proposed regulation pursuant to
Executive Order 13563. 76 FR 3281 (Jan. 21, 2011). EO 13563 is
supplemental to and explicitly reaffirms the principles, structures,
and definitions governing regulatory review established in Executive
Order 12866. To the extent permitted by law, agencies are required by
Executive Order 13563 to: (1) Propose or adopt a regulation only upon a
reasoned determination that its benefits justify its costs (recognizing
that some benefits and costs are difficult to quantify); (2) tailor
regulations to impose the least burden on society, consistent with
obtaining regulatory objectives, taking into account, among other
things, and to the extent practicable, the costs of cumulative
regulations; (3) select, in choosing among alternative regulatory
approaches, those approaches that maximize net benefits (including
potential economic, environmental, public health and safety, and other
advantages; distributive impacts; and equity); (4) to the extent
feasible, specify performance objectives, rather than specifying the
behavior or manner of compliance that regulated entities must adopt;
and (5) identify and assess available alternatives to direct
regulation, including providing economic incentives to encourage the
desired behavior, such as user fees or marketable permits, or providing
information upon which choices can be made by the public.
DOE emphasizes as well that Executive Order 13563 requires agencies
to use the best available techniques to quantify anticipated present
and future benefits and costs as accurately as possible. In its
guidance, the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has
emphasized that such techniques may include identifying changing future
compliance costs that might result from technological innovation or
anticipated behavioral changes. For the reasons stated in the preamble,
DOE believes that the NOPR is consistent with these principles,
including the requirement that, to the extent permitted by law,
benefits justify costs and that net benefits are maximized. Consistent
with EO 13563, and the range of impacts analyzed in this rulemaking,
the energy efficiency standards proposed herein by DOE achieve maximum
net benefits. For further discussion of how this NOPR achieves maximum
net benefits, see section V.
B. Background
1. Current Standards
In a final rule published on April 8, 2009 (April 2009 Final Rule),
DOE prescribed the current energy conservation standards for
residential cooking products to prohibit constant burning pilots for
all gas cooking products (i.e., gas cooking products both with or
without an electrical supply cord) manufactured on or after April 9,
2012. 74 FR 16040, 16041-16044. DOE's regulations, codified at 10 CFR
430.2, define conventional cooking tops, conventional ovens, and
conventional ranges as classes of cooking products. As noted in the
April 2009 Final Rule, DOE considered standards for conventional
cooking tops and conventional ovens separately, and noted that any
cooking top or oven standard would apply to the individual components
of the conventional range. 74 FR 16040, 16053.
Based on DOE's review of gas cooking products available on the
market in the United States, DOE notes that there may be confusion
regarding how the current standards apply to different pilot ignition
systems. Specifically, DOE is aware of a gas range that is designed to
heat and cook food based on the principle of heat storage. A low input
rate burner continuously heats the cooking top surface and cast iron
oven cavities, and maintains these components at a constant
temperature. A secondary ``pilot burner'' is used to ignite the main
burner and this pilot remains lit between cooking cycles as well as
when the main burner is shut off for short periods of non-use. Although
the secondary pilot may provide additional heating to the body of the
range, its primary function is to ignite the main burner, and would
thus be considered a constant burning pilot because it is a continuous
gas flame used to ignite the gas at the main burner. It is the main
burner that provides the primary source of heat for the cooking
function of the range.
In this NOPR, DOE is clarifying that a constant burning pilot in
conventional cooking products is considered to be a continuous gas
flame having the primary purpose to ignite the gas at the burner(s)
that is (are) used to heat or cook food and which remains lit between
cooking cycles. The design and configuration, including whether it
incorporates any air premixing or whether it has a secondary heating
function, does not exclude the device from consideration as constant
burning pilot.
DOE also notes that any newly adopted performance standards for
conventional cooking products resulting from this current rulemaking
would not affect the current prescriptive standards prohibiting
constant burning pilots for all gas cooking products.
2. History of Standards Rulemaking for Residential Conventional Cooking
Products
The National Appliance Energy Conservation Act of 1987 (NAECA),
Public Law 100-12, amended EPCA to establish prescriptive standards for
gas cooking products, requiring gas ranges and ovens with an electrical
supply cord that are manufactured on or after January 1, 1990, not to
be equipped with a constant burning pilot light. NAECA also directed
DOE to conduct two cycles of rulemakings to determine if more stringent
or additional standards were justified for kitchen ranges and ovens.
(42 U.S.C. 6295 (h)(1)-(2))
DOE undertook the first cycle of these rulemakings and published a
final rule on September 8, 1998, which found that no standards were
justified for conventional electric cooking products at that time. In
addition, partially due to the difficulty of conclusively demonstrating
that elimination of standing pilots for conventional gas
[[Page 33037]]
cooking products without an electrical supply cord was economically
justified, DOE did not include amended standards for conventional gas
cooking products in the final rule. 63 FR 48038. For the second cycle
of rulemakings, DOE published the April 2009 Final Rule amending the
energy conservation standards for conventional cooking products to
prohibit constant burning pilots for all gas cooking products (i.e.,
gas cooking products both with or without an electrical supply cord)
manufactured on or after April 9, 2012. DOE decided to not adopt energy
conservation standards pertaining to the cooking efficiency of
conventional electric cooking products because it determined that such
standards would not be technologically feasible and economically
justified at that time. 74 FR 16040, 16041-16044.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ As part of the April 2009 Final Rule, DOE decided not to
adopt energy conservation standards pertaining to the cooking
efficiency of microwave ovens. DOE also published a final rule on
June 17, 2013 adopting energy conservation standards for microwave
oven standby mode and off mode. 78 FR 36316. DOE is not considering
energy conservation standards for microwave ovens as part of this
rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EPCA also requires that, not later than 6 years after the issuance
of a final rule establishing or amending a standard, DOE publish a NOPR
proposing new standards or a notice of determination that the existing
standards do not need to be amended. (42 U.S.C. 6295(m)(1)) Based on
this provision, DOE must publish by March 31, 2015, either a NOPR
proposing new standards for conventional electric cooking products and/
or amended standards for conventional gas cooking products \16\ or a
notice of determination that the existing standards do not need to be
amended.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\ As discussed in section III.A, DOE is also tentatively
planning to consider new energy conservation standards for gas
cooking products with higher burner input rates, which were
previously excluded from standards.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 12, 2014, DOE published a request for information (RFI)
notice (the February 2014 RFI) to initiate the mandatory review process
imposed by EPCA. As part of the RFI, DOE sought input from the public
to assist with its determination on whether new or amended standards
pertaining to conventional cooking products are warranted. 79 FR 8337.
In making this determination, DOE must evaluate whether new or amended
standards would (1) yield a significant savings in energy use and (2)
be both technologically feasible and economically justified. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(3)(B))
III. General Discussion
A. Scope of Coverage
As discussed in section II.A, 6292(a)(10) of EPCA covers kitchen
ranges and ovens, or ``cooking products.'' DOE's regulations define
``cooking products'' as consumer products that are used as the major
household cooking appliances. They are designed to cook or heat
different types of food by one or more of the following sources of
heat: Gas, electricity, or microwave energy. Each product may consist
of a horizontal cooking top containing one or more surface units \17\
and/or one or more heating compartments. They must be one of the
following classes: Conventional ranges, conventional cooking tops,
conventional ovens, microwave ovens, microwave/conventional ranges and
other cooking products. (10 CFR 430.2) In this NOPR, DOE is considering
energy conservation standards for certain residential conventional
cooking products, namely, conventional ovens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ The term surface unit refers to burners for gas cooking
tops, electric resistance heating elements for electric cooking
tops, and inductive heating elements for induction cooking tops.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE notes that conventional ranges are defined in 10 CFR 430.2 as a
class of kitchen ranges and ovens which is a household cooking
appliance, consisting of a conventional cooking top and one or more
conventional ovens. In this rulemaking, DOE is not considering gas and
electric conventional ranges as a distinct product category and is not
basing its product classes on that category. Instead, DOE plans to
consider energy conservation standards for conventional cooking tops
and conventional ovens separately. Because ranges consist of both a
cooking top and oven, any potential cooking top or oven standards would
apply to the individual components of the range. DOE invites comment on
its proposal to develop two distinct component standards under separate
timetables, and whether issues of product design and development,
consumer utility, and more broadly, cumulative regulatory burden
concerns that could arise as a result of its proposal (see sections
IV.J and VII.E). DOE anticipates issuing a NOPR for energy conservation
standards for cooktops in the next year. In this NOPR, DOE is proposing
to clarify in the definitions of conventional cooking tops and
conventional ovens, in 10 CFR 430.2, that these include the individual
cooking top or oven portion of a conventional range.
As part of the most recent standards rulemaking for conventional
cooking products, DOE decided to exclude residential conventional gas
cooking products with higher burner input rates, including products
marketed as ``commercial-style'' or ``professional-style,'' from
consideration of energy conservation standards due to a lack of
available data for determining efficiency characteristics of those
products. DOE considers these products to be gas cooking tops with
burner input rates greater than 14,000 British thermal units (Btu)/hour
(h) and gas ovens with burner input rates greater than 22,500 Btu/h. 74
FR 16040, 16054 (Apr. 8, 2009); 72 FR 64432, 64444-64445 (Nov. 15,
2007). DOE also stated that the current DOE cooking products test
procedures may not adequately measure performance of gas cooking tops
and ovens with higher burner input rates. 72 FR 64432, 64444-64445
(Nov. 15, 2007).
As part of the February 2014 RFI, DOE stated that it tentatively
planned to consider energy conservation standards for all residential
conventional cooking products, including gas cooking products with
higher burner input rates. In addition, DOE stated that it may consider
developing test procedures for these products and determine whether
separate product classes are warranted. 79 FR 8337, 8340 (Feb. 12,
2014).
The Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM) and
Whirlpool Corporation (Whirlpool) commented that because there is no
test procedure to test commercial-style products, they cannot
effectively comment on how these products should be treated in a
standards rulemaking, nor can DOE effectively evaluate their energy
use. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 2; \18\ Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p. 2) AHAM
added that nothing has changed since DOE determined in the April 2009
Final Rule that it lacks efficiency data to determine whether
commercial-style cooking products should be excluded from the
rulemaking, and thus, DOE cannot make a tentative conclusion to
consider energy conservation standards for commercial-style products.
(AHAM, STD No. 9 at pp. 2-3) In response to the December 2014 TP SNOPR,
Sub Zero Group, Inc. (Sub Zero) stated that DOE's conclusion that the
existing test procedure in Appendix I should be used to test ovens with
high input rates is incorrect. Sub Zero commented that, due to the lack
of data, complexity, and
[[Page 33038]]
small potential for energy savings, DOE should exempt commercial-style
or ``high performance'' products from coverage. (Sub Zero, TP No. 20 at
p. 3 \19\)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\ A notation in the form ``AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 2''
identifies a written comment (1) made by AHAM; (2) recorded in
document number 9 that is filed in the docket of this energy
conservation standards rulemaking (Docket No. EERE-2014-BT-STD-0005)
and maintained in the Resource Room of the Building Technologies
Program; and (3) which appears on page 2 of document number 9.
\19\ A notation in the form ``Sub Zero, TP No. 20 at p. 3''
identifies a written comment (1) made by Sub Zero; (2) recorded in
document number 20 that is filed in the docket of the concurrent
cooking products test procedures rulemaking (Docket No. EERE-2012-
BT-TP-0013) and maintained in the Resource Room of the Building
Technologies Program; and (3) which appears on page 3 of document
number 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), Southern California Gas
Company (SCGC), San Diego Gas and Electric (SDG&E), and Southern
California Edison (SCE) (collectively, the California investor-owned
utilities (IOUs)) supported DOE's decision to consider standards for
professional-style gas cooking products and commented that DOE should
refer to American National Standards Institute (ANSI) Standard Z83.11-
2006/CSA Standard 1.8-2006 (R2011), ``Gas Food Service Equipment,''
when developing a definition for these products. (California IOUs, STD
No. 11 at p. 1)
As discussed in section III.B, DOE proposed to amend the
conventional cooking top test procedure in Appendix I to, among other
things, measure the energy use of gas cooking tops with high burner
input rates and to clarify that the existing conventional oven test
procedure is appropriate for ovens with high burner input rates,
including products marketed as commercial-style. See 79 FR 71894 (Dec.
3, 2014). DOE notes that the current definitions for ``conventional
cooking top,'' ``conventional oven,'' and ``conventional range'' in 10
CFR 430.2 already cover conventional gas cooking products with higher
burner input rates, as these products are household cooking appliances
with surface units or compartments intended for the cooking or heating
of food by means of a gas flame. As a result, DOE is proposing energy
conservation standards for all residential conventional cooking
products, including gas cooking products with higher burner input
rates. As discussed in section IV.A.2, DOE is not considering
establishing a separate product class for gas cooking products with
higher burner input rates that are marketed as ``commercial-style''
and, as a result, DOE is not proposing separate definitions for these
products.
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) commented that DOE should
separately define commercial and residential gas cooking products. NRDC
noted that because of the availability of residential gas cooking tops
with higher burner input rates previously associated with commercial
use, these burner types are not what define commercial units. NRDC
stated that the definitions should be based on more fundamental
distinctions between commercial and residential products, such as
configuration of the burners on the cooking top, number of burners, or
number of high-input rate burners. (NRDC, STD No. 12 at p. 2) As part
of this rulemaking, DOE is considering energy conservation standards
for residential conventional cooking products. As discussed above, this
includes residential conventional gas cooking products with high burner
input rates, including those marketed as commercial-style. For these
products, DOE tentatively concludes that the existing definitions for
conventional cooking top, conventional oven, and conventional range
accurately describe the products that are the subject of this
rulemaking. In addition, DOE clarifies that the proposed scope of
coverage for this rulemaking relates only to consumer products. Thus,
this rule applies to those residential conventional cooking products
that are of a type which, to any significant extent, are distributed
into commerce for personal use or consumption. (See 42 U.S.C. 6291(1)).
These consumer products can be distinguished from commercial/industrial
equipment, which are of a type not sold for consumer use. (42 U.S.C.
6311(2)(A)) Thus, DOE is not proposing to define commercial cooking
products as part of this rulemaking.
DOE notes that the test procedures for conventional ranges, cooking
tops, and ovens found at Appendix I do not address all possible types
of combined cooking products (i.e., residential products that combine a
conventional cooking product with other appliance functionality, which
may or may not include another cooking product), such as microwave/
conventional ovens or any other products that may combine a
conventional cooking product with other appliance functionality that is
not a conventional cooking product. DOE stated in the February 2014 RFI
that because test procedures are not available addressing products that
combine a conventional cooking product with other appliance
functionality that is not a conventional cooking product (e.g.,
microwave/conventional ovens), DOE is not considering energy
conservation standards for such products at this time. 79 FR 8337, 8340
(Feb. 12, 2014).
AHAM and Whirlpool agreed with DOE's tentative determination to not
consider standards for combined cooking products. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at
p. 3; Whirlpool STD No. 13 at p. 2) AHAM stated that combined products
are too diverse and probably do not occupy enough of the market to
justify coverage by DOE. AHAM stated that DOE has not provided
sufficient analysis on each of these products to justify their
coverage, nor has DOE provided adequate definitions. Thus, AHAM
continues to oppose the inclusion of combined products in the scope of
covered products in the conventional cooking products rulemakings.
(AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 3) In the absence of comments opposing this
determination and for the reasons discussed above, DOE is not
considering energy conservation standards in this NOPR for products
that may combine a conventional cooking product with other appliance
functionality that is not a conventional cooking product.
B. Further Rulemaking To Consider Energy Conservation Standards for
Conventional Cooking Tops
As part of this rulemaking, DOE intends only to address energy
conservation standards for conventional ovens, including conventional
ovens that are a part of conventional ranges. In response to the
concurrent cooking products test procedure proposed rulemaking, DOE
received a number of comments from interested parties that presented
information and arguments for deferring the rulemaking process to
consider standards for conventional cooking tops until a
representative, repeatable, and reproducible test procedure could be
developed. DOE also conducted a series of manufacturer interviews and
performed additional testing in order to confirm stakeholder comments
that additional study was warranted before establishing both a test
procedure and amended standards for conventional cooking tops. These
comments and DOE's response are discussed below.
In the January 2013 TP NOPR, DOE proposed amendments to the cooking
products test procedure in Appendix I to subpart B of Title 10 of the
CFR part 430 that would allow for testing the active mode energy
consumption of induction cooking products; i.e., conventional cooking
tops and ranges equipped with induction heating technology for one or
more surface units on the cooking top. DOE proposed to incorporate
induction cooking tops by amending the definition of ``conventional
cooking top'' to include induction heating technology. Furthermore, DOE
proposed to require for all cooking tops the use of test equipment
compatible with induction technology. Specifically, DOE proposed to
replace the solid aluminum test
[[Page 33039]]
blocks currently specified in the test procedure for cooking tops with
hybrid test blocks comprising two separate pieces: An aluminum body and
a stainless steel base. 78 FR 6232, 6234 (Jan. 30, 2013).
AHAM commented that DOE should rely on the finalized version of the
test procedure (i.e., the October 2012 TP Final Rule) and not a
proposed test procedure when evaluating energy conservation standards,
particularly given the significant opposing comments that question the
validity of the proposed test procedure for cooking tops (as discussed
in AHAM's comments on the January 2013 TP NOPR). Accordingly, AHAM
stated that DOE should address AHAM's and other stakeholder comments
regarding induction cooking and finalize amendments to the test
procedure before using those amendments to conduct any analysis for the
standards rulemaking, or else proceed without addressing induction
cooking products in this round of standards rulemaking. (AHAM, STD No.
9 at pp. 3-4, 6, 7)
AHAM and Whirlpool commented that a test procedure should be
developed to address commercial-style cooking products if DOE plans to
evaluate them in a standards analysis. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 2;
Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p. 1) AHAM also commented that DOE should
either proceed without addressing commercial-style products as it did
for the April 2009 Final Rule or delay the rulemaking analysis until
there is a finalized test procedure that can measure commercial-style
products. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 4, 6, 7) AHAM added that it cannot
provide data regarding the differences between residential-style and
commercial-style gas cooking products without a test procedure to
measure higher input rated burners. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 7) The
California IOUs supported amending the test procedure to measure the
energy use of residential conventional gas cooking products with higher
burner input rates. (California IOUs, STD No. 11 at p. 2)
In the December 2014 TP SNOPR, DOE modified its proposal from the
January 2013 TP NOPR to specify different test equipment that would
allow for measuring the energy efficiency of induction cooking tops,
and would include an additional test block size for electric surface
units with large diameters (both induction and electric resistance). 79
FR 71894 (Dec. 3, 2014). In addition, DOE proposed methods to test non-
circular electric surface units, electric surface units with flexible
concentric cooking zones, and full-surface induction cooking tops. Id.
In the December 2014 TP SNOPR, DOE also proposed amendments to add a
larger test block size to test gas cooking top burners with higher
input rates. Id.
AHAM formally requested an extension of the comment period for the
December 2014 TP SNOPR, citing the difficulty the members had procuring
the specified hybrid test block materials, and noting that many
manufacturers were not able to properly assess the new specifications,
testing variation, repeatability, and reproducibility of the proposed
test procedure before the comment period closed. (AHAM, TP No. 14 at p.
1) AHAM also expressed concern with DOE's choice to pursue an
accelerated rulemaking schedule for cooking products, stating that
DOE's deadlines did not allow for a thorough technical examination.
AHAM believes DOE has not conducted adequate outreach to manufacturers,
has not been sufficiently transparent in its data collection and
analysis, and has failed to adhere to its own Process Improvement Rule,
which calls for all of the above. AHAM asked DOE to conduct more
substantive dialogue with stakeholders that would result in more in-
depth comments on the test procedure SNOPR and advised DOE that the
cooking top test procedure as proposed in the December 2014 TP SNOPR
may result in technical problems. (AHAM, TP No. 18 at pp. 1-2)
Both the BSH Home Appliances Corporation (BSH) and General Electric
Appliances (GE) confirmed that delays associated with acquiring the
hybrid test block materials meant they needed additional time to
evaluate DOE's proposed cooking top test procedure. (BSH, TP No. 16 at
p. 2; GE, TP No. 17 at p. 1) BSH commented that the proposed hybrid
test block method fails to cover several aspects which are necessary to
enhance the reproducibility of measuring cooking top energy
consumption, such as test load sizing and positioning, and recommended
DOE take into account important specifications which are already fixed
in International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) Standard 60350-2
Edition 2, ``Household electric appliances--Part 2: Hobs--Method for
measuring performance'' (IEC Standard 60350-2). (BSH, TP No. 16 at p.
1) Further, both manufacturers and AHAM suggested that DOE specify
additional test block diameters because the test block sizes proposed
by DOE do not adequately reflect the surface unit sizes currently
available on the market. (BSH, TP No. 16 at p. 5; GE, TP No. 17 at p 2;
AHAM, TP No. 18 at p. 2)
Stakeholders also expressed a significant number of concerns with
the use of thermal grease. GE noted that since receiving DOE's
proposal, it has not been able to replicate the DOE test results using
the methods described. (GE, TP No. 17 at p. 2) Specifically, GE
observed that the aluminum body slid off the stainless steel base
during the test, that the thermal grease dried out, and that the amount
of grease between the blocks changed from one test to another. (GE, TP
No. 17 at p. 2) Both manufacturers and AHAM requested that DOE specify
an operating temperature range for the thermal grease as well as an
application thickness to address these issues, but also noted that the
thermal conductivity and viscosity of the grease may still change over
time or after repeated use at high temperatures. (BSH, TP No. 16 at p.
11; GE, TP No. 17 at p. 2; AHAM, TP No. 18 at p. 3) GE further
commented that the variation introduced by the hybrid test block due to
block construction, flatness, thermal grease, and inadequate sizing,
may be small sources of variation individually, but collectively, these
issues result in a test method that is incapable of being able to
reliably discern efficiency differences between similar products,
alternate technology options, and product classes. Thus, GE believes
the test method proposed for conventional cooking tops in the December
2014 TP SNOPR results in too much variability to serve as the basis for
establishing a standard. (GE, TP No. 17 at p. 3)
The California IOUs also stated that they prefer an alternative to
the hybrid test block and recommended that DOE require water-heating
test methods to measure the cooking efficiency of conventional cooking
tops. Specifically, the California IOUs requested that DOE align the
residential cooking product test methods with existing industry test
procedures, such as ASTM F1521-12 and IEC Standard 60350-2. (California
IOUs, TP No. 19 at p. 1) The California IOUs commented that they plan
to conduct additional testing to better characterize the differences
between the water-heating and hybrid test block test procedures, and
will provide these results to DOE. According to the California IOUs,
the differences in test procedure standard deviation between the hybrid
test block and water-heating test method as presented in the December
2014 TP SNOPR did not sufficiently show that the hybrid test block
method is more repeatable than a water-heating method. (California
IOUs, TP No. 19 at p. 2) Additionally, the California IOUs believe
cooking
[[Page 33040]]
efficiencies derived using a water-heating test method are more
representative of the actual cooking performance of cooking tops as
opposed to a test procedure using hybrid test blocks since many
different foods prepared on cooktops will have relatively high liquid
content. (California IOUs, TP No. 19 at p. 1)
In February and March of 2015, DOE conducted a series of interviews
with manufacturers of conventional cooking products, representing the
majority of the U.S. market, regarding the proposed cooking top test
procedure. Manufacturers agreed that the hybrid test block method, as
proposed, presented many issues which had not yet been addressed, and
which left the repeatability and reproducibility of the test procedure
in question. These concerns were similar to those expressed in written
comments but came from a larger group of contributing manufacturers and
included:
Difficulty obtaining the hybrid test block materials;
Difficulty obtaining and applying the thermal grease
without more detailed specifications (i.e., thermal conductivity alone
was not sufficient to identify a grease that performed according to
DOE's descriptions in the SNOPR);
Difficulty testing induction cooking tops that use
different programming techniques to prevent overheating (some
manufacturers still observed that power to the heating elements cut off
prematurely during testing with the hybrid test block, despite adding
thermal grease); and
The need for larger test block sizes to test electric
surface units having 12-inch and 13-inch diameters and gas surface
units with high input rates.
Interviewed manufacturers that produce and sell products in Europe
overwhelmingly supported the use of water-heating test method and
harmonization with IEC Standard 60350-2 for measuring the energy
consumption of electric cooking tops. These manufacturers noted that
the benefits of pursuing a test method similar to the IEC water-heating
method include compatibility with all electric cooking top types,
additional cookware diameters to account for the variety of surface
unit sizes on the market, and the test load's ability to represent a
real-world cooking top load.
For these reasons, DOE has decided to continue the energy
conservation standards rulemaking for conventional ovens but to defer
its decision regarding adoption of energy conservation standards for
conventional cooking tops until a representative, repeatable and
reproducible test method for cooking tops is finalized. At such time,
DOE will consider further modifications to DOE's cooking top active
mode test procedure and, on the basis of such an amended test
procedure, DOE will analyze potential energy conservation standards for
cooking top energy consumption. DOE invites data and information that
will allow it to further conduct the analysis of cooking tops,
particularly when using a water-heating method to evaluate energy
consumption. DOE anticipates issuing additional notices for cooking top
test procedures and standards in order to obtain public input on DOE's
updated proposals. As part of these notices, DOE will carefully
consider and address any cooking top-related comments on the December
2014 TP SNOPR and the February 2014 RFI that remain relevant.
C. Test Procedure
DOE's test procedures for conventional ranges, conventional cooking
tops, conventional ovens, and microwave ovens are codified at appendix
I to subpart B of Title 10 of the CFR part 430.
DOE established the test procedures in a final rule published in
the Federal Register on May 10, 1978. 43 FR 20108, 20120-20128. DOE
revised its test procedures for cooking products to more accurately
measure their efficiency and energy use, and published the revisions as
a final rule in 1997. 62 FR 51976 (Oct. 3, 1997). These test procedure
amendments included: (1) A reduction in the annual useful cooking
energy; (2) a reduction in the number of Self-Clean oven cycles per
year; and (3) incorporation of portions of IEC Standard 705-1988,
``Methods for measuring the performance of microwave ovens for
household and similar purposes,'' and Amendment 2-1993 for the testing
of microwave ovens. Id. The test procedures for conventional cooking
products establish provisions for determining estimated annual
operating cost, cooking efficiency (defined as the ratio of cooking
energy output to cooking energy input), and energy factor (defined as
the ratio of annual useful cooking energy output to total annual energy
input). 10 CFR 430.23(i); Appendix I.
DOE subsequently conducted a rulemaking to address standby and off
mode energy consumption, as well as certain active mode (i.e., fan-only
mode) testing provisions, for residential conventional cooking
products. DOE published a final rule on October 31, 2012 (77 FR 65942,
the October 2012 TP Final Rule), adopting standby and off mode
provisions that satisfy the EPCA requirement that DOE include measures
of standby mode and off mode energy consumption in its test procedures
for residential products, if technically feasible. (42 U.S.C.
6295(gg)(2)(A))
In the December 2014 TP SNOPR, DOE proposed modifications to the
test block used to evaluate conventional cooking top energy
consumption. As discussed in section III.B, DOE plans to consider
further modifications to DOE's cooking top active mode test procedure
in a future rulemaking. In the December 2014 TP SNOPR, DOE also
proposed to incorporate methods for measuring conventional oven volume,
clarified that the existing oven test block must be used to test all
ovens regardless of input rate, and provided a method to measure the
energy consumption and efficiency of conventional ovens equipped with
an oven separator. 79 FR 71894 (Dec. 3, 2014). DOE is proposing energy
conservation standards for conventional ovens in this NOPR based on
these proposals in the December 2014 TP SNOPR. DOE intends to update
the standards rulemaking analyses based on any final amendments related
to ovens developed as part of the concurrent test procedure rulemaking.
DOE recognizes that interested parties need sufficient time to evaluate
the proposed energy conservation standards using the final test
procedure for conventional ovens. DOE considers the stated energy
conservation standards rulemaking process to provide sufficient time to
submit meaningful comments based on a finalized DOE conventional oven
test procedure.
D. Technological Feasibility
1. General
In each energy conservation standards rulemaking, DOE conducts a
screening analysis based on information gathered on all current
technology options and prototype designs that could improve the
efficiency of the products or equipment that are the subject of the
rulemaking. As the first step in such an analysis, DOE develops a list
of technology options for consideration in consultation with
manufacturers, design engineers, and other interested parties. DOE then
determines which of those means for improving efficiency are
technologically feasible. DOE considers technologies incorporated in
commercially available products or in working prototypes to be
technologically feasible. 10 CFR part 430, subpart C, appendix A,
section 4(a)(4)(i).
After DOE has determined that particular technology options are
technologically feasible, it further
[[Page 33041]]
evaluates each technology option in light of the following additional
screening criteria: (1) Practicability to manufacture, install, and
service; (2) adverse impacts on product utility or availability; and
(3) adverse impacts on health or safety. 10 CFR part 430, subpart C,
appendix A, section 4(a)(4)(ii)-(iv). Section IV.B of this notice
discusses the results of the screening analysis for residential
conventional ovens, particularly the designs DOE considered, those it
screened out, and those that are the basis for the trial standard
levels (TSLs) in this rulemaking. For further details on the screening
analysis for this rulemaking, see chapter 4 of the NOPR Technical
Support Document (TSD).
2. Maximum Technologically Feasible Levels
When DOE proposes to adopt an amended standard for a type or class
of covered product, it must determine the maximum improvement in energy
efficiency or maximum reduction in energy use that is technologically
feasible for such product. (42 U.S.C. 6295(p)(1)) Accordingly, in the
engineering analysis, DOE determined the maximum technologically
feasible (``max-tech'') improvements in energy efficiency for
residential conventional ovens, using the design parameters for the
most efficient products available on the market or in working
prototypes, and information from the previous rulemaking. The max-tech
levels that DOE determined for this rulemaking are described in section
IV.C.3 of this proposed rule and in chapter 5 of the NOPR TSD.
E. Energy Savings
1. Determination of Savings
For each TSL, DOE projected energy savings from the products that
are the subject of this rulemaking purchased in the 30-year period that
begins in the year of compliance with new and amended standards (2019
to 2048).\20\ The savings are measured over the entire lifetime of
products purchased in the 30-year analysis period. DOE quantified the
energy savings attributable to each TSL as the difference in energy
consumption between each standards case and the base case. The base
case represents a projection of energy consumption in the absence of
new and amended efficiency standards, and it considers market forces
and policies that affect demand for more efficient products.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\ DOE also presents a sensitivity analysis that considers
impacts for products shipped in a 9-year period.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE uses its national impact analysis (NIA) spreadsheet models to
estimate energy savings from potential new and amended standards. The
NIA spreadsheet model (described in section IV.H of this notice)
calculates energy savings in site energy, which is the energy directly
consumed by products at the locations where they are used. For
electricity, DOE calculates national energy savings in terms of primary
energy savings, which is the savings in the energy that is used to
generate and transmit the site electricity. For electricity, natural
gas, and oil, DOE also calculates full-fuel-cycle (FFC) energy savings.
As discussed in DOE's statement of policy and notice of policy
amendment, the FFC metric includes the energy consumed in extracting,
processing, and transporting primary fuels (i.e., coal, natural gas,
petroleum fuels), and thus presents a more complete picture of the
impacts of energy efficiency standards. 76 FR 51281 (Aug. 18, 2011), as
amended at 77 FR 49701 (Aug. 17, 2012).
To calculate primary energy savings, DOE derives annual conversion
factors from the model used to prepare the Energy Information
Administration's (EIA) most recent Annual Energy Outlook (AEO).\21\ For
FFC energy savings, DOE's approach is based on the calculation of an
FFC multiplier for each of the energy types used by covered products or
equipment. For more information, see section IV.H.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\ For this NOPR, DOE used AEO 2014. Available at http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/AEO/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Significance of Savings
To adopt standards for a covered product, DOE must determine that
such action would result in ``significant'' energy savings. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(3)(B)) Although the term ``significant'' is not defined in the
Act, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, in
Natural Resources Defense Council v. Herrington, 768 F.2d 1355, 1373
(D.C. Cir. 1985), opined that Congress intended ``significant'' energy
savings in the context of EPCA to be savings that were not ``genuinely
trivial.'' The energy savings for the proposed standards (presented in
section IV.H.2) are nontrivial, and, therefore, DOE considers them
``significant'' within the meaning of section 325 of EPCA.
F. Economic Justification
1. Specific Criteria
EPCA provides seven factors to be evaluated in determining whether
a potential energy conservation standard is economically justified. (42
U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)) The following sections discuss how DOE has
addressed each of those seven factors in this rulemaking.
a. Economic Impact on Manufacturers and Consumers
In determining the impacts of a potential amended standard on
manufacturers, DOE conducts a manufacturer impact analysis (MIA), as
discussed in section IV.J. DOE first uses an annual cash-flow approach
to determine the quantitative impacts. This step includes both a short-
term assessment--based on the cost and capital requirements during the
period between when a regulation is issued and when entities must
comply with the regulation--and a long-term assessment over a 30-year
period. The industry-wide impacts analyzed include industry net present
value (INPV), which values the industry on the basis of expected future
cash flows; cash flows by year; changes in revenue and income; and
other measures of impact, as appropriate. Second, DOE analyzes and
reports the impacts on different types of manufacturers, including
impacts on small manufacturers. Third, DOE considers the impact of
standards on domestic manufacturer employment and manufacturing
capacity, as well as the potential for standards to result in plant
closures and loss of capital investment. Finally, DOE takes into
account cumulative impacts of various DOE regulations and other
regulatory requirements on manufacturers.
For individual consumers, measures of economic impact include the
changes in LCC and PBP associated with new or amended standards. These
measures are discussed further in the following section. For consumers
in the aggregate, DOE also calculates the national net present value of
the economic impacts applicable to a particular rulemaking. DOE also
evaluates the LCC impacts of potential standards on identifiable
subgroups of consumers that may be affected disproportionately by a
national standard.
b. Savings in Operating Costs Compared to Increase in Price
EPCA requires DOE to consider the savings in operating costs
throughout the estimated average life of the covered product in the
type (or class) compared to any increase in the price of, or in the
initial charges for, or maintenance expenses of, the covered product
that are likely to result from a standard. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(II)) DOE conducts this comparison in its LCC and PBP
analysis.
[[Page 33042]]
The LCC is the sum of the purchase price of a product (including
its installation) and the operating expense (including energy,
maintenance, and repair expenditures) discounted over the lifetime of
the product. The LCC analysis requires a variety of inputs, such as
product prices, product energy consumption, energy prices, maintenance
and repair costs, product lifetime, and consumer discount rates. To
account for uncertainty and variability in specific inputs, such as
product lifetime and discount rate, DOE uses a distribution of values,
with probabilities attached to each value. For its analysis, DOE
assumes that consumers will purchase the covered products in the first
year of compliance with amended standards.
The LCC savings for the considered efficiency levels are calculated
relative to a base case that reflects projected market trends in the
absence of amended standards. DOE identifies the percentage of
consumers estimated to receive LCC savings or experience an LCC
increase, in addition to the average LCC savings associated with a
particular standard level. DOE's LCC and PBP analysis is discussed in
further detail in section IV.F.
c. Energy Savings
Although significant conservation of energy is a separate statutory
requirement for adopting an energy conservation standard, EPCA requires
DOE, in determining the economic justification of a standard, to
consider the total projected energy savings that are expected to result
directly from the standard. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(III)) As
discussed in section IV.H.2, DOE uses spreadsheet models to project
national energy savings.
d. Lessening of Utility or Performance of Products
In establishing classes of products, and in evaluating design
options and the impact of potential standard levels, DOE evaluates
potential standards that would not lessen the utility or performance of
the considered products. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(IV)) Based on data
available to DOE, the standards proposed in this notice would not
reduce the utility or performance of the products under consideration
in this rulemaking.
e. Impact of Any Lessening of Competition
EPCA directs DOE to consider the impact of any lessening of
competition, as determined in writing by the Attorney General, that is
likely to result from a proposed standard. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(V)) It also directs the Attorney General to determine
the impact, if any, of any lessening of competition likely to result
from a proposed standard and to transmit such determination to the
Secretary within 60days of the publication of a proposed rule, together
with an analysis of the nature and extent of the impact. (42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(2)(B)(ii)) DOE will transmit a copy of this proposed rule to
the Attorney General with a request that the Department of Justice
(DOJ) provide its determination on this issue. DOE will publish and
respond to the Attorney General's determination in the final rule.
f. Need for National Energy Conservation
DOE also considers the need for national energy conservation in
determining whether a new or amended standard is economically
justified. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(VI)) The energy savings from new
or amended standards are likely to provide improvements to the security
and reliability of the nation's energy system. Reductions in the demand
for electricity also may result in reduced costs for maintaining the
reliability of the nation's electricity system. DOE conducts a utility
impact analysis to estimate how standards may affect the nation's
needed power generation capacity, as discussed in section IV.M.
New or amended standards also are likely to result in environmental
benefits in the form of reduced emissions of air pollutants and
greenhouse gases (GHGs) associated with energy production and use. DOE
conducts an emissions analysis to estimate how standards may affect
these emissions, as discussed in section IV.K. DOE reports the
emissions impacts from each TSL it considered in section IV.K of this
notice. DOE also estimates the economic value of emissions reductions
resulting from the considered TSLs, as discussed in section IV.L.
g. Other Factors
EPCA allows the Secretary of Energy, in determining whether a
standard is economically justified, to consider any other factors that
the Secretary deems to be relevant. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(VII))
To the extent interested parties submit any relevant information
regarding economic justification that does not fit into the other
categories described above, DOE could consider such information under
``other factors.''
2. Rebuttable Presumption
As set forth in 42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(iii), EPCA creates a
rebuttable presumption that an energy conservation standard is
economically justified if the additional cost to the consumer of a
product that meets the standard is less than three times the value of
the first year's energy savings resulting from the standard, as
calculated under the applicable DOE test procedure. DOE's LCC and PBP
analyses generate values used to calculate the effects that proposed
energy conservation standards would have on the payback period for
consumers. These analyses include, but are not limited to, the 3-year
payback period contemplated under the rebuttable-presumption test. In
addition, DOE routinely conducts an economic analysis that considers
the full range of impacts to consumers, manufacturers, the Nation, and
the environment, as required under 42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i). The
results of this analysis serve as the basis for DOE's evaluation of the
economic justification for a potential standard level (thereby
supporting or rebutting the results of any preliminary determination of
economic justification). The rebuttable presumption payback calculation
is discussed in section IV.F.11 of this proposed rule.
IV. Methodology and Discussion of Comments
DOE used several analytical tools to estimate the impact of the
proposed standards. The first tool is a spreadsheet that calculates the
LCC and PBP of potential energy conservation standards. The national
impacts analysis uses a spreadsheet set that provides shipments
forecasts and calculates national energy savings and net present value
resulting from potential energy conservation standards. DOE uses the
third spreadsheet tool, the Government Regulatory Impact Model (GRIM),
to assess manufacturer impacts of potential standards. These three
spreadsheet tools are available at the Web site for this rulemaking:
http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/rulemaking.aspx?ruleid=85. Additionally, DOE used output from the EIA's
Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) 2014, a widely known energy forecast for
the United States, for the emissions and utility impact analyses.
A. Market and Technology Assessment
1. General
For the market and technology assessment, DOE develops information
[[Page 33043]]
that provides an overall picture of the market for the products
concerned, including the purpose of the products, the industry
structure, and market characteristics. This activity includes both
quantitative and qualitative assessments, based primarily on publicly
available information. Chapter 3 of the NOPR TSD contains additional
discussion of the market and technology assessment.
2. Product Classes
When evaluating and establishing energy conservation standards, DOE
divides covered products into product classes by the type of energy
used or by capacity or other performance-related features that
justifies a different standard. In making a determination whether a
performance-related feature justifies a different standard, DOE must
consider such factors as the utility to the consumer of the feature and
other factors DOE determines are appropriate. (42 U.S.C. 6295(q))
During the previous energy conservation standards rulemaking for
cooking products, DOE evaluated product classes for conventional ovens
based on energy source (i.e., gas or electric). These distinctions
initially yielded two conventional oven product classes: (1) Gas ovens;
and (2) electric ovens. DOE later determined that the type of oven-
cleaning system is a utility feature that affects performance. DOE
found that standard ovens and ovens using a catalytic continuous-
cleaning process use roughly the same amount of energy. On the other
hand, Self-Clean ovens use a pyrolytic process that provides enhanced
consumer utility with lower overall energy consumption as compared to
either standard or catalytically lined ovens. DOE defined the following
product classes in the TSD for the April 2009 Final Rule (2009 TSD)
\22\ for conventional ovens:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\ The technical support document from the previous
residential cooking products standards rulemaking is available at:
http://www.regulations.gov/#!documentDetail;D=EERE-2006-STD-0127-
0097.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric ovens--standard oven with or without a catalytic
line;
Electric ovens--self-clean oven;
Gas ovens--standard oven with or without a catalytic line;
and
Gas ovens--self-clean oven.
As part of the February 2014 RFI, DOE stated that it tentatively
plans to maintain the product classes for conventional ovens from the
previous standards rulemaking, as presented above. DOE stated that it
may consider whether separate product classes are warranted for
conventional gas ovens with higher burner input rates. 79 FR 8337,
8341-8342 (Feb. 12, 2014).
Based on DOE's review of gas conventional ovens and ranges
available on the U.S. market, and based on manufacturer interviews and
testing conducted as part of the engineering analysis described in
section IV.C and Chapter 5 of the TSD, DOE notes that the self-cleaning
function of the self-clean oven may employ methods other than a high
temperature pyrolytic cycle to perform the cleaning action.
Specifically, DOE is aware of a type of self-cleaning oven that uses a
proprietary oven coating and water to perform a self-clean cycle with a
shorter duration and at a significantly lower temperature setting. The
self-cleaning cycle for these ovens, unlike catalytically-lined
standard ovens that provide continuous cleaning during normal baking,
still have a separate self-cleaning mode that is user-selectable and
must be tested separately. In this NOPR, DOE is clarifying that a self-
clean electric or gas conventional oven is an oven that has a user-
selectable mode separate from the normal baking mode, not intended to
heat or cook food, which is dedicated to cleaning and removing cooking
deposits from the oven cavity walls.
With regard to commercial-style products, AHAM commented that
without a definition or test procedure for such products, neither AHAM
nor DOE can determine at this stage whether these products would
warrant a separate product class. AHAM noted that DOE should first
develop a test procedure for these products to allow for analysis of
them. (AHAM, No. 9 at p. 12)
Based on DOE's review of the residential conventional gas ovens
available on the market, residential-style gas ovens typically have an
input rate of 16,000 to 18,000 Btu/h whereas residential gas ovens
marketed as commercial-style typically have burner input rates ranging
from 22,500 to 30,000 Btu/h.\23\ Additional review of both the
residential-style and commercial-style gas oven cavities indicated that
there is significant overlap in oven cavity volume between the two oven
types. Standard residential-style gas oven cavities range from 2.5 to
5.6 cubic feet (ft\3\) in volume and gas ovens marketed as commercial-
style have cavity volumes ranging from 3.0 to 6.0 ft\3\. Sixty percent
of the commercial-style models surveyed had cavity volumes between 4.0
and 5.0 ft\3\ while fifty percent of the standard models had cavity
volumes between 4.0 and 5.0 ft\3\. The primary differentiating factor
between the two oven types was burner input rate, which is greater than
22,500 Btu/h for commercial-style gas ovens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\ However, DOE noted that many gas ranges, while marketed as
commercial- or professional-style and having multiple surface units
with high input rates, did not have a gas oven with a burner input
rate above 22,500 Btu/h.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As discussed in the December 2014 TP SNOPR, DOE determined that the
test load for ovens as specified in the existing DOE test procedure in
Appendix I is appropriate for gas ovens with burner input rates greater
than 22,500 Btu/h. 79 FR at 71915-71916. As a result, DOE conducted
testing for this NOPR to determine whether conventional gas ovens with
higher burner input rates warrant establishing a separate product
class. DOE evaluated the cooking efficiency of the eight conventional
gas ovens listed in Table IV-1. Five of these ovens had burners rated
at 18,000 Btu/h or less and the remaining three had burner input rates
ranging from 27,000 Btu/h to 30,000 Btu/h.
Table IV-1--Performance Characteristics of Gas Oven Test Sample
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Normalized
Installation Burner input rate Cavity volume Measured cooking cooking
Test unit No. Type configuration (Btu/h) (cubic feet efficiency efficiency **
(ft\3\)) (percent) (percent)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................ Standard............ Freestanding....... 18,000 4.8 6.6 7.0
2................................ Standard............ Freestanding....... 18,000 4.8 6.0 6.3
3................................ Self-Clean.......... Freestanding....... 18,000 5.0 7.6 8.1
4................................ Standard............ Freestanding....... 16,500 4.4 6.2 6.2
5................................ Self-Clean.......... Built-in........... 13,000 2.8 9.4 8.3
6................................ Standard *.......... Freestanding....... 28,000 5.3 4.3 5.1
[[Page 33044]]
7................................ Standard *.......... Slide-in........... 27,000 4.4 5.2 5.2
8................................ Standard *.......... Freestanding....... 30,000 5.4 3.9 4.7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* These products are marketed as commercial-style gas ovens.
** Measured cooking efficiency normalized to a fixed cavity volume of 4.3 cubic feet.
The measured cooking efficiencies for ovens with burner input rates
above 22,500 Btu/h were lower than for ovens with ratings below 22,500
Btu/h, even after normalizing cooking efficiency to a fixed cavity
volume. However, DOE also noted that the conventional gas ovens with
higher burner input rates in DOE's test sample were marketed as
commercial-style and had greater total thermal mass, including heavier
racks and thicker cavity walls, even after normalizing for cavity
volume. To determine whether the lower measured efficiency of these
ovens was due to the higher input rate burners, DOE isolated the
heating element from the thermal mass of the oven by placing 1-inch
thick insulation on all surfaces inside the oven cavity, except for the
bottom of the cavity where the burner was located, and ran tests
according to the DOE test procedure. By adding insulation, heat
transfer to the cavity walls was minimized and retained in the cavity
to heat the test block. DOE selected test unit 3 and test unit 8 in
Table IV-1 for test because of the similarity in cavity volume, their
difference in efficiency, and their differing input rate (18,000 Btu/h
and 30,000 Btu/h, respectively). Figure IV.1 displays the resulting
test block temperature increase as a function of test time, measured
with and without insulation lining the interior oven cavity walls.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP10JN15.000
Without the added insulation inside the oven cavity, the
temperature rise in the test block was similar for each oven, despite
the large difference in burner input rate. In contrast, by adding
insulation inside the cavity, the test block temperature in the 30,000
Btu/h oven increased at a faster rate than in the 18,000 Btu/h oven.
This suggests that much of the energy input to the 30,000 Btu/h oven
goes to heating the added mass of the cavity, rather than the test
load, resulting in relatively lower measured efficiency.
[[Page 33045]]
DOE also investigated the time it took each oven in the test sample
to heat the test load to a final test temperature of 234 degrees
Fahrenheit ([deg]F) above its initial temperature, specified in the DOE
test procedure in Appendix I. As shown in Table IV-2, gas ovens with
burner input rates greater than 22,500 Btu/h do not heat the test load
significantly faster than the ovens with lower burner input rates, and
two out of the three units with the higher burner input rates took
longer than the average time to heat the test load. Therefore, DOE
preliminarily concludes that there is no unique utility associated with
faster cook times that is provided by gas ovens with burner input rates
greater than 22,500 Btu/h.
Table IV-2--Gas Oven Test Times
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bake time to
Burner input rate reach 234 [deg]F Difference in
Unit Type (Btu/h) above initial time from avg
temp (min) (min)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................ Standard............ 18,000 43.6 -3.8
2................................ Standard............ 18,000 43.6 -3.8
3................................ Self-Clean.......... 18,000 47.2 -0.2
4................................ Standard............ 16,500 44.9 -2.5
5................................ Self-Clean.......... 13,000 48.9 1.5
6................................ Standard *.......... 28,000 48.9 1.5
7................................ Standard *.......... 27,000 45.4 -2.0
8................................ Standard *.......... 30,000 57.2 9.8
--------------------------------------------------------
Average...................... .................... ................. 47.4 .................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Test units 6, 7, and 8 are marketed as commercial-style ovens.
In response to the December 2014 TP SNOPR, Sub Zero commented that
categorizing all ovens under the term conventional cooking suggests
that DOE is unaware of the significant positive differences provided to
a subset of consumers by commercial-style products. (Sub Zero, TP No.
20 at p. 2) If standards are to be proposed, Sub Zero requested that
the product classes be significantly expanded in number to recognize
the unique and important utility and performance attributes associated
with ``high performance'' cooking products. (Sub Zero, TP No. 20 at p.
3) Sub Zero suggested that these products offer residential consumers
performance similar to that found in restaurants, at a safety and
convenience level that is acceptable for residential use. Commercial-
style ovens would thus include gas ranges in widths up to 60 inches,
gas ovens up to 36 inches wide with high output infrared broilers and
convection fans, dual fuel ranges combining gas cooktops with sealed
burners and large, electric self-cleaning convection ovens that use
hidden bake elements and multiple heating circuits for added control,
as well as separate convection elements or multiple convection fans.
Sub Zero believes that analysis based largely on the traditional 30-
inch wide gas or electric range cannot adequately evaluate the very
different performance attributes offered by high performance products
which are essential to consumer utility. (Sub Zero, TP No. 20 at p. 2)
In selecting a test sample to support DOE's engineering analysis,
discussed in section IV.C.2 and Chapter 5 of the TSD, DOE attempts to
capture a wide range of products having features that may result in the
determination of additional product classes. DOE included two
commercial-style gas ovens greater than 30-inches in width as part of
its test sample. DOE is not aware of data showing the improved cooking
performance of these products due to the features described in the
comments as compared to conventional gas ovens not marketed as
commercial-style or commercial-style gas ovens less than or equal to 30
inches in width. All of the commercial-style ovens evaluated by DOE
contained features such as infrared broilers, convection fans, and
hidden bake elements, but DOE observed that many of the same features
were also available in conventional gas ovens with lower input rates.
DOE welcomes data demonstrating the improved cooking performance
associated with the features for commercial-style gas ovens with widths
greater than 30-inches that result in increased energy consumption, but
are not available in conventional gas ovens with lower input rates or
commercial-style gas ovens with widths of 30 inches or less.
Based on DOE's testing, reverse engineering, and additional
discussions with manufacturers, DOE determined that the major
differentiation between conventional gas ovens with lower burner input
rates and those with higher input rates, including those marketed as
commercial-style, was design and construction related to aesthetics
rather than improved cooking performance. Further, DOE did not identify
any unique utility conferred by commercial-style gas ovens. For the
reasons discussed above, DOE is not proposing to establish a separate
product class for conventional gas ovens with higher burner input
rates.
As discussed in section III.B, in the October 2012 TP Final Rule,
DOE amended appendix I to include methods for measuring fan-only
mode.\24\ Based on DOE's testing of freestanding, built-in, and slide-
in conventional gas and electric ovens, DOE noted that all of the
built-in and slide-in ovens tested consumed energy in fan-only mode,
whereas freestanding ovens did not. The energy consumption in fan-only
mode for built-in and slide-in ovens ranged from approximately 1.3 to
37.6 watt-hours (Wh) per cycle (0.25 to 7.6 kWh/yr). Based on DOE's
reverse engineering analyses discussed in section IV.C.2, DOE noted
that built-in and slide-in products had an additional exhaust fan and
vent assembly that was not present in freestanding products. The
additional energy required to exhaust air from the oven cavity is
necessary for slide-in and built-in installation configurations to meet
safety-related temperature requirements because the oven is enclosed in
cabinetry. For these reasons, DOE proposes to include separate product
classes for freestanding and built-in/slide-in ovens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\ Fan-only mode is an active mode that is not user-selectable
in which a fan circulates air internally or externally to the
cooking product for a finite period of time after the end of the
heating function.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 33046]]
In summary, DOE proposes the product classes listed in Table IV-3
for the NOPR.
Table IV-3--Proposed Product Classes for Conventional Ovens
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Product class Product type Sub-category Installation type
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................. Electric oven.................. Standard with or Freestanding.
without a
catalytic line.
2.............................. ............................... ................... Built-in/Slide-in.
3.............................. ............................... Self-clean......... Freestanding.
4.............................. ............................... ................... Built-in/Slide-in.
5.............................. Gas oven....................... Standard with or Freestanding.
without a
catalytic line.
6.............................. ............................... ................... Built-in/Slide-in.
7.............................. ............................... Self-clean......... Freestanding.
8.............................. ............................... ................... Built-in/Slide-in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Technology Options
As part of the market and technology assessment, DOE uses
information about existing and past technology options and prototype
designs to help identify technologies that manufacturers could use to
improve energy efficiency. Initially, these technologies encompass all
those that DOE believes are technologically feasible. Chapter 3 of the
NOPR TSD includes the detailed list and descriptions of all technology
options identified for this equipment.
In the February 2014 RFI, DOE stated that based on a preliminary
review of the cooking products market and information published in
recent trade publications, technical reports, and manufacturer
literature, the results of the technology screening analysis performed
during the previous standards rulemaking remain largely relevant for
this rulemaking. 79 FR 8337, 8341 (Feb. 12, 2014). DOE stated in the
February 2014 RFI that it planned to consider the technology options
presented in Table IV-4 for conventional ovens. 79 FR 8337, 8342-8343
(Feb. 12, 2014).
Table IV-4--February 2014 RFI Technology Options for Conventional Ovens
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Bi-radiant oven (electric only).
2. Electronic spark ignition (gas only).
3. Forced convection.
4. Halogen lamp oven (electric only).
5. Improved and added insulation.
6. Improved door seals.
7. No oven-door window.
8. Oven separator.
9. Radiant burner (gas only).
10. Reduced conduction losses.
11. Reduced thermal mass.
12. Reduced vent rate.
13. Reflective surfaces.
14. Steam cooking.
15. Low-standby-loss electronic controls.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to the February 2014 RFI, DOE received a number of
comments regarding the technology options for conventional ovens.
AHAM commented that forced convection should not be considered a
technology option for gas or electric ovens. AHAM stated that only some
foods can be cooked with convection and that accelerating the cooking
time or baking rate for other foods will not produce acceptable
results. Accordingly, AHAM believes this technology option would impact
consumer utility. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 5) DOE recognizes that using
forced convection for cooking certain foods may be undesirable. DOE is
not considering forced convection as a complete replacement to the
conventional bake cooking function. Instead DOE considered forced
convection as a separate heating mode in addition to the bake function
for the engineering analysis. DOE also notes that the test procedure in
Appendix I averages the energy consumption measured during bake-only
mode with the energy consumption measured during forced convection mode
to calculate the total cooking efficiency and IAEC for the oven,
representing equal use of forced convection and bake-only cooking
cycles. As a result, DOE is retaining forced convection as a technology
option for this NOPR.
AHAM and Whirlpool commented that reducing the vent rate should not
be considered because it could result in incomplete combustion. In
addition, AHAM stated that it would impact the ability of the product
to manage moisture release. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 6; Whirlpool, STD
No. 13 at p. 4) As noted in the 2009 TSD, DOE believes that vent size
of both standard electric and standard gas ovens could be reduced while
maintaining a satisfactory combustion environment. Since all Self-Clean
ovens are already designed with this technology, no new improvements
are required by the industry to incorporate this technology option. DOE
noted in the 2009 TSD that an increase of approximately 0.62 absolute
percentage points for standard electric ovens and 0.5 absolute
percentage points for standard gas ovens was possible with this
technology option. As a result, DOE retained reduced vent rate as a
technology option for standard ovens for this NOPR.
AHAM commented that improved door seals may not provide a
significant improvement in efficiency. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 6) DOE
notes that door seals for standard ovens generally consist of a strip
of silicone rubber, while Self-Clean ovens usually incorporate
fiberglass seals. Because some venting is required for proper cooking
performance, a complete seal on the oven is undesirable. As DOE noted
in the 2009 TSD, the oven door seals can be improved further without
sealing the oven completely. Based on discussions with manufacturers,
DOE believes that fiberglass seals can be installed in standard ovens
to improve efficiency. As a result, DOE retained improved door seals as
a technology option for standard ovens.
Whirlpool commented that it has already optimized insulation in its
ovens for safety reasons. (Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p. 4) DOE noted in
the 2009 TSD that standard ovens used low-density insulation (1.09
pounds (lb)/ft\3\) whereas self-clean ovens used higher-density
insulation (1.90 lb/ft\3\). Based on interviews with manufacturers for
this rulemaking, DOE notes that manufacturers generally use the same
amount of insulation for standard ovens versus self-clean ovens, but
with different densities. Insulation is added primarily to pass
Underwriters Laboratory (UL) surface temperature safety testing
requirements, which explains why Self-Clean ovens, which require high
temperatures for pyrolysis, tend to have a more effective insulation
package. DOE notes that higher-density insulation can be used in
standard
[[Page 33047]]
ovens to improve efficiency. As a result, DOE retained improved
insulation as a technology option for standard ovens.
Whirlpool commented that there may be savings associated with steam
cooking realized by the user, but these savings would likely not be
measured in the DOE test procedure. (Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p. 4)
While there are several residential steam ovens currently on the
market, DOE is unaware of any test procedures that accurately measure
the energy use of the steam cooking mode while producing repeatable and
reproducible results. As a result, DOE is unaware of any data regarding
the efficiency of steam cooking. For these reasons, DOE did not
consider steam cooking in the analysis.
Whirlpool commented that there could be savings for gas ovens from
electronic spark ignition over a glo-bar igniter, which could use 250-
500W throughout the cooking cycle. (Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p. 4) As
discussed in section IV.C.2, based on DOE's testing, DOE agrees that
switching from a glo-bar to an electronic spark ignition system would
result in energy savings. As a result, DOE is maintaining electronic
spark ignition as a technology option for this NOPR.
Based on DOE's review of products on the market, DOE notes that
radiant burners for gas ovens are only incorporated into broiling,
which is a secondary cooking function not measured under the test
procedure; energy use is instead measured during the primary bake
function. As a result, the benefits of radiant burners are not measured
by the current test procedure. Accordingly, DOE eliminated radiant
burners in gas ovens from further analysis.
In the previous standards rulemaking, DOE noted that oven
separators had only been researched, but never put into production. 72
FR 64432, 64456 (Nov. 15, 2007). Based on DOE's review of products on
the market, DOE notes that one manufacturer offers a conventional
electric oven with an oven separator. As a result, DOE plans to
consider oven separators as a technology option for electric ovens.
In addition to the technology options presented in Table IV-4, DOE
considered an additional technology option for optimizing the burner
and cavity design for gas ovens based on product testing and reverse
engineering analyses conducted for this NOPR. As described in section
IV.A.2 and further in section IV.C.2, DOE's testing indicated that
reducing the thermal mass of the oven cavity can increase cooking
efficiency. Because oven cavity and burner design are interdependent,
DOE is proposing to consider optimized burner and cavity design as a
technology option for increasing efficiency for gas ovens consistent
with products available on the market rather than the reduced thermal
mass technology option considered for the previous rulemaking.
Table IV-5 lists the proposed technology options that DOE is
considering for the NOPR.
Table IV-5--Proposed Technology Options for Conventional Ovens
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Bi-radiant oven (electric only).
2. Electronic spark ignition (gas only).
3. Forced convection.
4. Halogen lamp oven (electric only).
5. Improved and added insulation (standard ovens only).
6. Improved door seals.
7. No oven-door window.
8. Oven separator (electric only).
9. Reduced conduction losses.
10. Reduced vent rate.
11. Reflective surfaces.
12. Low-standby-loss electronic controls.
13. Optimized burner and cavity design.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE seeks comment on the use of optimized burner and cavity design
(and other options listed in Table IV-5) to meet the proposed
efficiency levels discussed in section I.A.1.b. (See section VII.E)
B. Screening Analysis
DOE uses the following four screening criteria to determine which
technology options are suitable for further consideration in an energy
conservation standards rulemaking:
1. Technological feasibility. Technologies that are not
incorporated in commercial products or in working prototypes will not
be considered further.
2. Practicability to manufacture, install, and service. If it is
determined that mass production and reliable installation and servicing
of a technology in commercial products could not be achieved on the
scale necessary to serve the relevant market at the time of the
compliance date of the standard, then that technology will not be
considered further.
3. Impacts on product utility or product availability. If it is
determined that a technology would have significant adverse impact on
the utility of the product to significant subgroups of consumers or
would result in the unavailability of any covered product type with
performance characteristics (including reliability), features, sizes,
capacities, and volumes that are substantially the same as products
generally available in the United States at the time, it will not be
considered further.
4. Adverse impacts on health or safety. If it is determined that a
technology would have significant adverse impacts on health or safety,
it will not be considered further. (10 CFR part 430, subpart C,
appendix A, 4(a)(4) and 5(b))
In sum, if DOE determines that a technology, or a combination of
technologies, fails to meet one or more of the above four criteria, it
will be excluded from further consideration in the engineering
analysis. The reasons for eliminating any technology are discussed
below.
The subsequent sections include comments from interested parties
pertinent to the screening criteria, DOE's evaluation of each
technology option against the screening analysis criteria, and whether
DOE determined that a technology option should be excluded (``screened
out'') based on the screening criteria.
1. Screened-Out Technologies
For conventional ovens, DOE screened out added insulation, bi-
radiant oven, halogen lamp oven, no oven door window, and reflective
surfaces, for the reasons that follow.
Although some analyses have shown reduced energy consumption by
increasing the thickness of the insulation in the oven cabinet walls
and doors from two inches to four inches, consumer utility would be
negatively impacted by the necessary reduction in cavity volume to
maintain the same oven footprint and overall cabinet volume. Therefore,
DOE screened out added insulation. The improved insulation design
option, however, will be retained, because insulation with a higher
density (i.e., greater insulating value) does not require additional
space and thus would not impact oven cavity size.
The last working prototype of a bi-radiant oven known to DOE was
tested in the 1970s. The technology requires a low-emissivity cavity,
electronic controls, and highly absorptive cooking utensils. The need
for specialized cookware and cavity maintenance issues negatively
impact consumer utility. Therefore, DOE screened out bi-radiant ovens
from further analysis.
DOE is not aware of any ovens that utilize halogen lamps alone as
the heating element, and no data were found or submitted to demonstrate
how efficiently halogen elements alone perform relative to conventional
ovens. DOE believes that it would not be practicable to manufacture,
install, and service halogen lamps for use in
[[Page 33048]]
consumer cooking products on the scale necessary to serve the relevant
market at the time of the standard's effective date. Therefore, DOE
screened out halogen lamp ovens.
Whirlpool commented that oven door windows are a key consumer
utility and purchase driver, and there may even be more energy used
from increased door openings to check on food (associated with no oven
door window) versus looking through the window. (Whirlpool, STD No. 13
at p. 4) DOE notes that the 2009 TSD reported a small annual energy
savings associated with no oven door window, but that consumer
practices of opening the door to inspect the food while cooking could
negate any benefit. Comments during manufacturer interviews and
comments from stakeholders in previous rulemakings agreed that removing
the window was not a feasible option for most ovens. 63 FR 48038,
48040-48041 (Sep. 8, 1998); 72 FR 64432, 64456 (Nov. 15, 2007). Reduced
consumer utility and the potential for increased energy use along with
decreased safety due to the additional door openings, justify
elimination of this design option from further analysis. In addition,
DOE addresses the efficiency impact of double-pane or other highly
insulated oven door windows by means of the reduced conduction losses
design option, which has been retained for further analysis.
Whirlpool commented that reflective surfaces would be very
difficult to implement correctly. Whirlpool stated that there would be
reduced consumer savings if the surface gets dirty and reduced consumer
functionality from the appearance of stains. (Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at
p. 4) In the 2009 TSD, DOE noted that manufacturers have stated that it
has been very difficult to obtain satisfactory cooking performance with
reflective surfaces and that reflective surfaces degrade after the
first baking function and continue to degrade through the life of the
product. DOE also noted in the 2009 TSD that is uncertain whether, or
how much, energy savings is realizable with this technology option.
Because of the uncertainty of the potential energy savings and the
general lack of sophistication in the technology in terms of
maintaining clean, reflective surfaces over the lifetime of the
product, DOE screened out this technology option from further analysis.
2. Remaining Technologies
Based on the screening analysis, DOE considered the design options
listed in Table IV-6 for conventional ovens.
Table IV-6--Remaining Conventional Oven Technology Options
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Electronic spark ignition (gas only).
2. Forced convection.
3. Improved insulation.
4. Improved door seals (standard ovens only).
5. Oven separator (electric only).
6. Reduced conduction losses.
7. Reduced vent rate.
8. Low-standby-loss electronic controls.
9. Optimized burner and cavity design (gas only).
------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Engineering Analysis
The engineering analysis estimates the cost-efficiency relationship
of products at different levels of increased energy efficiency. This
relationship serves as the basis for the cost-benefit calculations for
consumers, manufacturers, and the Nation. In determining the cost-
efficiency relationship, DOE estimates the increase in manufacturer
cost associated with increasing the efficiency of products from the
baseline up to the maximum technologically feasible (``max-tech'')
efficiency level for each product class.
1. Methodology
DOE typically structures the engineering analysis using one of
three approaches: (1) The design-option approach, which provides the
incremental costs of adding design options to a baseline model that
will improve its efficiency (i.e., lower its energy use); (2) the
efficiency-level approach, which provides the incremental costs of
moving to higher energy efficiency levels, without regard to the
particular design option(s) used to achieve such increases; and (3) the
reverse-engineering (or cost-assessment) approach, which provides
``bottom-up'' manufacturing cost assessments for achieving various
levels of increased efficiency, based on teardown analyses (or physical
teardowns) that provide detailed data on costs for parts and material,
labor, overhead, and equipment, tooling, conveyor, and space
investments for models that operate at particular efficiency levels.
In the February 2014 RFI, DOE stated that in order to create the
cost-efficiency relationship, it anticipated having to structure its
engineering analysis using a design-option approach, supplemented by
reverse engineering (physical teardowns and testing of existing
products in the market) to identify the incremental cost and efficiency
improvement associated with each design option or design option
combination. In addition, DOE stated that it intends to consider cost-
efficiency data from the 2009 TSD. 79 FR 8337, 8347 (Feb. 12, 2014).
DOE maintained this approach for this NOPR. DOE also conducted
interviews with manufacturers of conventional ovens to develop a deeper
understanding of the various combinations of design options used to
increase product efficiency, and their associated manufacturing costs.
2. Product Testing and Reverse Engineering
To develop the cost-efficiency relationships for the engineering
analysis, DOE conducted testing and reverse engineering teardowns on
products available on the market. Because there are no performance-
based energy conservation standards or energy reporting requirements
for conventional cooking products, DOE selected test units based on
performance-related features and technologies advertised in product
literature. DOE's test sample included 1 gas wall oven, 7 gas ranges, 5
electric wall ovens, and 2 electric ranges for a total of 15
conventional ovens covering all of the product classes considered in
this NOPR. The test units are described in detail in chapter 5 of the
NOPR TSD.
Each test unit was tested according to the oven test procedure
clarifications proposed in the December 2014 TP SNOPR. DOE then
conducted physical teardowns on each test unit to develop a
manufacturing cost model and to evaluate key design features. DOE
supplemented its reverse engineering analyses by conducting
manufacturer interviews to obtain feedback on efficiency levels, design
options, inputs for the manufacturing cost model, and resulting
manufacturing costs. DOE used the results from testing, reverse
engineering, and manufacturer interviews to develop the efficiency
levels and manufacturing costs discussed in sections IV.C.3 and IV.C.4.
Table IV-7 and Table IV-8 present the testing results for the
conventional gas and electric ovens, respectively.
[[Page 33049]]
Table IV-7--DOE Conventional Gas Oven Test Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Burner input Cavity volume Convection (Y/ IAEC (kBtu/
Test Unit No. Oven product class rate (Btu/h) (ft\3\) Ignition type N) yr)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................. Gas Standard--Freestanding 18,000 4.8 Spark..................... N 1341.4
2.............................. Gas Standard--Freestanding 18,000 4.8 Glo-bar................... N 1503.7
3.............................. Gas Self-Clean-- 18,000 5.0 Glo-bar................... Y 1419.0
Freestanding.
4.............................. Gas Standard--Freestanding 16,500 4.4 Glo-bar................... N 1516.6
5.............................. Gas Self-Clean--Built-in/ 13,000 2.8 Glo-bar................... N 1171.3
Slide-in.
6.............................. Gas Standard--Freestanding 28,000 5.3 Glo-bar................... Y 2078.9
7.............................. Gas Standard--Built-in/ 27,000 4.4 Glo-bar................... Y 1938.0
Slide-in.
8.............................. Gas Standard--Freestanding 30,000 5.4 Glo-bar................... Y 2315.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-8--DOE Conventional Electric Oven Test Results
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Heating
Test Unit No. Oven product class element Cavity volume Convection (Y/ IAEC (kWh/yr)
wattage (W) (ft\3\) N)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1........................ Electric Self-Clean-- 3,000 5.9 * Y 266.2
Freestanding.
2........................ Electric Standard-- 2,000 2.4 N 213.7
Freestanding.
3........................ Electric Self-Clean-- 3,400 2.7 N 158.7
Built-in/Slide-in.
4........................ Electric Standard-- 2,600 4.3 N 287.8
Built-in/Slide-in.
5........................ Electric Self-Clean-- 2,600 4.3 N 308.8
Built-in/Slide-in.
6........................ Electric Self-Clean-- 2,600 4.3 Y 341.8
Built-in/Slide-in.
7........................ Electric Self-Clean-- 2,800 4.3 N 370.0
Built-in/Slide-in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Test Unit 1 was equipped with an oven separator that allowed for splitting the single cavity into two separate
smaller cavities with volumes of 2.7 ft\3\ and 3.0 ft\3\.
3. Efficiency Levels
a. Baseline Efficiency Levels
A baseline unit is a product that just meets current Federal energy
conservation standards. DOE uses the baseline unit for comparison in
several phases of the NOPR analyses, including the engineering
analysis, LCC analysis, PBP analysis, and NIA. To determine energy
savings that will result from an amended energy conservation standard,
DOE compares energy use at each of the higher energy ELs to the energy
consumption of the baseline unit. Similarly, to determine the changes
in price to the consumer that will result from an amended energy
conservation standard, DOE compares the price of a unit at each higher
EL to the price of a unit at the baseline.
As part of the February 2014 RFI, DOE initially developed baseline
efficiency levels by considering the current standards for conventional
gas ovens and the baseline efficiency levels for conventional electric
ovens from the previous standards rulemaking analysis. DOE developed
tentative baseline efficiency levels for the February 2014 RFI
considering the current test procedure in appendix I. The baseline
efficiency levels proposed in the February 2014 RFI are presented in
Table IV-9. DOE developed baseline efficiency levels for standby mode
and off mode based on test data presented in the microwave oven test
procedure SNOPR.\25\ For fan-only mode, DOE developed baseline
efficiency levels considering the additional annual energy consumption
in fan-only mode based on test data presented in an SNOPR for the
conventional cooking products test procedure. 77 FR 31443, 31449 (May
25, 2012). The efficiency levels presented in the February 2014 RFI are
based on an oven with a cavity volume of 3.9 ft\3\.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\ In the May 2012 microwave oven test procedure SNOPR, DOE
considered test procedure amendments for measuring the standby mode
and off mode energy consumption of combined cooking products and, as
a result, presented standby power data for microwave ovens,
conventional cooking tops, and conventional ovens. 77 FR 28805,
28811 (May 16, 2012).
Table IV-9--February 2014 RFI Conventional Oven Baseline Efficiency Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2009 Standards rulemaking
--------------------------------------------
Product class Energy factor Annual energy consumption Proposed IAEC
(EF) \26\
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Oven--Standard Oven with or 0.1066 274.9 kWh................. 370.0 kWh.
without a Catalytic Line.
Electric Oven--Self-Clean Oven.......... 0.1099 266.6 kWh................. 360.0 kWh.
Gas Oven--Standard Oven with or without 0.0536 1656.7 kBtu............... 2076.5 kBtu.
a Catalytic Line.
Gas Oven--Self-Clean Oven............... 0.0540 1644.4 kBtu............... 1965.0 kBtu.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\ DOE notes that the previous conventional cooking products
test procedure in appendix I included the clock energy consumption.
As a result, DOE subtracted the clock energy consumption before
adding the standby and off mode energy consumption when considering
integrated efficiency levels for this standards rulemaking.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AHAM commented that, while they agreed fan-only mode should be
considered, DOE should gather more data before determining appropriate
[[Page 33050]]
baseline levels. AHAM stated that DOE should update the data collected
during the test procedure rulemaking and request information from
manufacturers on the energy use in fan-only mode. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at
p. 6) Whirlpool commented that fan-only mode power varies greatly for
ovens and depends on the size of the oven, insulation, dual or single
speed fan, single or double oven, etc. Whirlpool stated that it does
not currently have fan-only mode data and cannot comment on the
appropriateness of DOE's assumptions for fan-only power. (Whirlpool,
STD No. 13 at p. 6)
DOE developed baseline efficiency levels for this NOPR considering
both data from the previous standards rulemaking and the measured
energy use for the test units. As discussed in section IV.C.2, DOE
conducted testing for all units in its test sample to measure IAEC,
which includes energy use in active mode (including fan-only mode) and
standby mode. DOE also requested energy use data as part of the
manufacturer interviews. However, because manufacturers are not
currently required to conduct testing according to the DOE test
procedure, very little energy use information was available.
The baseline efficiency levels for this NOPR differ from those
presented in the February 2014 RFI. DOE compared the minimum cooking
efficiency measured in its test sample to the minimum cooking
efficiency levels assumed for the previous standards rulemaking
analysis. Often, the lowest measured efficiency in DOE's test sample
for this NOPR was lower than the values for the previous rulemaking.
To update the baseline efficiency levels for conventional ovens,
first DOE derived a new relationship between IAEC and cavity volume as
discussed in section I.A.1.c. Using the slope from the previous
rulemaking, DOE selected new intercepts corresponding to the ovens in
its test sample with the lowest efficiency, so that no ovens in the
test sample were cut off by the baseline curve. DOE then set baseline
standby energy consumption for conventional ovens equal to that of the
oven/range with the highest standby energy consumption in DOE's test
sample to maintain the full functionality of controls for consumer
utility. While only DOE test data was available to validate the
baseline equation for gas ovens, DOE compared the new baseline equation
for electric ovens with data available in the Natural Resources Canada
(NRCan) databases, which showed that DOE's assumptions for slopes and
intercepts reasonably represented the market. A detailed discussion of
DOE's derivation of the cavity volume relationship is provided Chapter
5 of the NOPR TSD.
In addition to the product classes proposed in the February 2014
RFI, DOE is also proposing separate product classes for freestanding
and built-in/slide-in ovens as discussed in section IV.A.2. As a
result, DOE developed separate baseline efficiency levels for each
proposed product class based on testing conducted for this NOPR. The
proposed baseline efficiency levels for this NOPR are presented in
Table IV-10. After receiving manufacturer feedback and reviewing
products currently on the market, DOE determined that a cavity volume
of 3.9 ft\3\ no longer represents the market average. Thus, efficiency
levels are based on an oven with a cavity volume of 4.3 ft\3\.
Additional details on the development of the proposed baseline
efficiency levels are included in chapter 5 of the NOPR TSD.
Table IV-10--Conventional Oven Baseline Efficiency Levels
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Product class Sub type Proposed IAEC *
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Oven--Standard Oven Freestanding...... 294.5 kWh.
with or without a Catalytic Built-in/Slide-in. 301.5 kWh.
Line.
Electric Oven--Self-Clean Oven.. Freestanding...... 355.0 kWh.
Built-in/Slide-in. 361.1 kWh.
Gas Oven--Standard Oven with or Freestanding...... 2118.2 kBtu.
without a Catalytic Line. Built-in/Slide-in. 2128.1 kBtu.
Gas Oven--Self-Clean Oven....... Freestanding...... 1883.8 kBtu.
Built-in/Slide-in. 1893.7 kBtu.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Proposed IAEC baseline efficiency levels are normalized based on a 4.3
ft\3\ volume oven.
b. Incremental Efficiency Levels
For each product class, DOE analyzes several efficiency levels and
determines the incremental cost at each of these levels. For the
February 2014 RFI, DOE tentatively proposed the incremental efficiency
levels presented in Table IV-11 through Table IV-14. DOE developed
these levels based primarily on the efficiency levels presented in the
2009 TSD, adjusted to account for the proposed and amended test
procedures. DOE also considered efficiency levels for standby mode and
off mode associated with changing conventional linear power supplies to
switch-mode power supplies and the Commission of the European
Communities Regulation 1275/2008 (hereinafter ``Ecodesign
regulation''), which requires products to have a maximum standby power
of 1 W. 79 FR 8337, 8345-8346 (Feb. 12, 2014).The efficiency levels
presented in the February 2014 RFI are based on an oven with a cavity
volume of 3.9 ft\3\.
Table IV-11--February 2014 RFI Gas Standard Oven Efficiency Levels
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC
Level Efficiency level source (kBtu)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 2009 TSD (Electric Glo- 2076.5
bar Ignition).
1........................... 2009 TSD (Electric Glo- 1932.0
bar Ignition) + SMPS.
2........................... 2009 TSD (Improved 1844.2
Insulation) + SMPS.
3........................... 2009 TSD (2 + 1717.7
Electronic Spark
Ignition) + SMPS.
4........................... 2009 TSD (3 + Improved 1702.6
Door Seals) + SMPS.
5........................... 2009 TSD (4 + Reduced 1695.4
Vent Rate) + SMPS.
6........................... 2009 TSD (5 + Reduced 1685.9
Conduction Losses) +
SMPS.
7........................... 2009 TSD (6 + Forced 1636.0
Convection) + SMPS.
[[Page 33051]]
8........................... 2009 TSD (7) + 1W 1499.1
Standby.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-12--February 2014 RFI Gas Self-Clean Oven Efficiency Levels
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC
Level Efficiency level source (kBtu)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 2009 TSD (Baseline).... 1965.0
1........................... 2009 TSD (Baseline) + 1820.5
SMPS.
2........................... 2009 TSD (Forced 1596.9
Convection) + SMPS.
3........................... 2009 TSD (2) + 1482.3
Electronic Spark
Ignition + SMPS.
4........................... 2009 TSD (3 + Improved 1472.0
Door Seals) + SMPS.
5........................... 2009 TSD (4 + Reduced 1467.8
Conduction Losses) +
SMPS.
6........................... 2009 TSD (5) + 1 W 1330.9
Standby.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-13--February 2014 RFI Electric Standard Oven Efficiency Levels
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC
Level Efficiency level source (kWh)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 2009 TSD (Baseline).... 370.0
1........................... 2009 TSD (Baseline) + 327.7
SMPS.
2........................... 2009 TSD (Reduced Vent 316.1
Rate) + SMPS.
3........................... 2009 TSD (2 + Improved 304.8
Insulation) + SMPS.
4........................... 2009 TSD (3 + Improved 300.9
Door Seals) + SMPS.
5........................... 2009 TSD (4 + Reduced 300.3
Conduction Losses) +
SMPS.
6........................... 2009 TSD (5 + Forced 295.2
Convection) + SMPS.
7........................... 2009 TSD (6) + 1 W 255.0
Standby.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-14--February 2014 RFI Electric Self-Clean Oven Efficiency
Levels
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC
Level Efficiency level source (kWh)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 2009 TSD (Baseline).... 360.0
1........................... 2009 TSD (Baseline) + 317.7
SMPS.
2........................... 2009 TSD (Reduced 317.0
Conduction Losses) +
SMPS.
3........................... 2009 TSD (2 + Forced 312.0
Convection) + SMPS.
4........................... 2009 TSD (3) + 1 W 271.9
Standby.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to the February 2014 RFI, AHAM disagreed with DOE's
consideration of the 1-W Ecodesign regulation standby requirements
because products sold in the European Union are different from the
products sold in the United States. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 6) DOE
reevaluated the efficiency levels associated with standby power
improvements based on design options identified during product testing
and reverse engineering rather than considering an efficiency level
specifically associated with the 1-W Ecodesign regulation standby
requirement.
Laclede commented that DOE's assumption of 3.5 amp x 110 volt
continuous consumption of a typical glo-bar ignition module would mean
its consuming 385 W (0.385 kW) per hour. Laclede stated that they
believe this may be the worst-case scenario and may make it appear that
further efficiency improvements are possible. However, Lacelede stated
that further efficiency improvements in glo-bar may lead to higher
costs for gas cooking products without sufficient economic benefits.
Laclede's testing data indicates glo-bar ignition system consumption of
only 0.16 kWh. (Laclede, STD No. 8 at p. 2) Laclede also commented that
it appears that DOE considers the electric load from glo-bar ignition
systems as of no value to the thermal process of cooking in the oven.
Laclede contends this electric resistance load in gas ovens most likely
does contribute to the cooking process and DOE will need to provide
transparent and robust analyses to explain this relationship. (Laclede,
STD No. 8 at pp. 2-3)
Based on DOE's testing of units in its test sample, electric glo-
bar ignition systems consumed between 330 W and 450 W and ranged
between 0.141 kWh and 0.261 kWh per cycle, with an average of 0.202 kWh
per cycle. DOE notes that the glo-bar energy consumption may vary
depending on burner and cavity design (e.g., burner input rating,
cavity volume). DOE also notes that the glo-bar ignition system was not
power on throughout the entire cooking cycle and only consumed power
when gas flow to the burner was on, turning off when the burner cycled
off. As discussed above, DOE updated its efficiency level analysis
based on testing conducted for this NOPR. Any contribution of the glo-
bar ignition system to heating the load would be accounted for in
testing according to the DOE test procedure in Appendix I.
For the NOPR, DOE developed incremental efficiency levels for each
product class by first considering information from the 2009 TSD. In
cases where DOE identified design options during testing and reverse
engineering teardowns, DOE updated the efficiency
[[Page 33052]]
levels based on the tested data. In addition to the efficiency levels
associated with design options identified in the February 2014 RFI, DOE
also included an efficiency level for electric ovens based on a test
unit equipped with an oven separator that allowed for reducing the
cavity volume that is used for cooking. For conventional gas ovens,
DOE's testing showed that energy use was correlated to oven burner and
cavity design (e.g., thermal mass of the cavity and racks) and can be
significantly reduced when optimized. DOE determined the efficiency
level associated with optimized burner and cavity design based on the
tested units normalized for cavity volume.
Table IV-15 through Table IV-18 show the incremental efficiency
levels for each product class, including whether the efficiency level
is from the 2009 TSD or based on testing for the NOPR. The efficiency
levels are normalized based on an oven with a cavity volume of 4.3
ft\3\. Details of the derivations of each efficiency level are provided
in chapter 5 of the NOPR TSD.
Table IV-15--Electric Standard Oven Efficiency Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC (kWh)
-------------------------------- Relative %
Level Efficiency level source Design option Built-in/Slide- decrease in
Freestanding in IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline............. NOPR Testing............ Baseline....... 294.5 301.5 ..............
1.................... NOPR Testing............ Baseline + SMPS 284.6 291.4 -3.37%
2.................... 2009 TSD................ 1 + Reduced 271.7 278.2 -4.51%
Vent Rate.
3.................... 2009 TSD................ 2 + Improved 259.2 265.4 -4.61%
Insulation.
4.................... 2009 TSD................ 3 + Improved 254.9 261.0 -1.64%
Door Seals.
5.................... NOPR Testing............ 4 + Forced 244.6 250.5 -4.04%
Convection.
6.................... NOPR Testing............ 5 + Oven 207.8 212.8 -15.04%
Separator.
7.................... 2009 TSD................ 6 + Reduced 207.3 212.2 -0.27%
Conduction
Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-16--Electric Self-Clean Oven Efficiency Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC (kWh)
-------------------------------- Relative %
Level Efficiency level source Design option Built-in/Slide- decrease in
Freestanding in IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline............. NOPR Testing............ Baseline....... 355.0 361.1 ..............
1.................... NOPR Testing............ Baseline + SMPS 345.1 351.0 -2.78%
2.................... NOPR Testing............ 1 + Forced 327.2 332.7 -5.21%
Convection.
3.................... NOPR Testing............ 2 + Oven 278.9 283.7 -14.74%
Separator.
4.................... 2009 TSD................ 3 + Reduced 278.1 282.9 -0.29%
Conduction
Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-17--Gas Standard Oven Efficiency Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC (kWh)
-------------------------------- Relative %
Level Efficiency level source Design option Built-in/Slide- decrease in
Freestanding in IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline............. 2009 TSD................ Baseline....... 2118.2 2128.1 ..............
1.................... NOPR Testing............ Baseline + 1649.3 1657.0 -22.14%
Optimized
Burner/Cavity.
2.................... NOPR Testing............ 1 + SMPS....... 1614.7 1622.2 -2.10%
3.................... NOPR Testing............ 2 + Electronic 1490.7 1497.7 -7.68%
Spark Ignition.
4.................... 2009 TSD................ 3 + Improved 1414.8 1421.5 -5.09%
Insulation.
5.................... 2009 TSD................ 4 + Improved 1400.6 1407.2 -1.01%
Door Seals.
6.................... NOPR Testing............ 5 + Forced 1355.6 1362.0 -3.21%
Convection.
7.................... 2009 TSD................ 6 + Reduced 1347.0 1353.3 -0.64%
Conduction
Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-18--Gas Self-Clean Oven Efficiency Levels
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Proposed IAEC (kWh)
-------------------------------- Relative %
Level Efficiency level source Design option Built-in/Slide- decrease in
Freestanding in IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline............. 2009 TSD................ Baseline....... 1883.8 1893.7 ..............
1.................... NOPR Testing............ Baseline + SMPS 1848.2 1858.0 -1.89%
2.................... NOPR Testing............ 1 + Electronic 1668.7 1677.5 -9.71%
Spark Ignition.
3.................... NOPR Testing............ 2 + Forced 1596.3 1604.7 -4.34%
Convection.
4.................... 2009 TSD................ 3 + Reduced 1591.0 1599.4 -0.33%
Conduction
Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 33053]]
c. Relationship Between IAEC and Oven Cavity Volume
The conventional oven efficiency levels detailed above are
predicated upon baseline ovens with a cavity volume of 4.3 ft\3\. Based
on DOE's testing of conventional gas and electric ovens and discussions
with manufacturers, IAEC scales with oven cavity volume due to the fact
that larger ovens have higher thermal masses and larger volumes of air
(including larger vent rates) than smaller ovens. Because the DOE test
procedure for measuring IAEC uses a fixed test load size, larger ovens
with higher thermal mass will have a higher measured IAEC. As a result,
DOE considered available data to characterize the relationship between
IAEC and oven cavity volume.
DOE established the slopes by first evaluating the data from the
2009 TSD, which presented the relationship between measured energy
factor (EF) and cavity volume, then translated from EF to IAEC
considering the range of cavity volume for the majority of products
available on the market. DOE believes these slopes continue to be
relevant based on DOE's testing. For electric ovens, DOE considered the
data for standard and self-clean ovens available in the Natural
Resources Canada product databases.\27\ DOE notes that this data is
based on the same test procedure considered for the previous DOE
standards rulemaking, and as a result, DOE believes the slopes based on
these larger datasets are relevant for this analysis. The intercepts
for each efficiency level were then chosen so that the equations pass
through the desired IAEC corresponding to a particular volume. Values
for the slopes and intercepts for each conventional oven product class
are presented in Table IV-19 and Table IV-20. Additional details
regarding the derivation of the slopes and intercepts for the oven IAEC
versus cavity volume relationship are presented in chapter 5 of the
NOPR TSD.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ Available at: http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/pml-lmp/index.cfm?action=app.search-recherche&appliance=OVENS_E.
Table IV-19--Slopes and Intercepts of Electric Oven IAEC Versus Cavity Volume Relationship
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Standard electric ovens Self-clean electric ovens
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Slope = 31.8 Slope = 42.3
Level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in/Slide-in Freestanding Built-in/slide-in
intercepts intercepts intercepts intercepts
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 157.74 164.78 173.12 179.18
1........................... 147.82 154.62 163.24 169.13
2........................... 134.98 141.47 145.28 150.86
3........................... 122.45 128.64 97.05 101.81
4........................... 118.20 124.29 96.24 100.98
5........................... 107.91 113.75 ................... ...................
6........................... 71.10 76.07 ................... ...................
7........................... 70.54 75.49 ................... ...................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-20--Slopes and Intercepts of Gas Oven IAEC versus Cavity Volume Relationship
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Standard gas ovens Self-clean gas ovens
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Slope = 214.4 Slope = 214.4
Level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in/slide-in Freestanding Built-in/slide-in
intercepts intercepts intercepts intercepts
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 1196.3 1206.2 961.8 971.8
1........................... 727.4 735.1 926.3 936.0
2........................... 692.7 700.3 746.7 755.5
3........................... 568.8 575.8 674.4 682.8
4........................... 492.9 499.5 669.1 677.5
5........................... 478.7 485.2 ................... ...................
6........................... 433.7 440.1 ................... ...................
7........................... 425.1 431.4 ................... ...................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Incremental Manufacturing Production Cost Estimates
Based on the analyses discussed above, DOE developed the cost-
efficiency results for each product class shown in Table IV-21. Where
available, DOE developed incremental manufacturing production costs
(MPCs) based on manufacturing cost modeling of test units in its sample
featuring the proposed design options. For design options that were not
observed in DOE's sample of test units for this NOPR, DOE used the
incremental manufacturing costs developed as part of the 2009 TSD, then
adjusted the values to reflect changes in the Bureau of Labor
Statistics' Producer Price Index (PPI) for household cooking appliance
manufacturing.\28\ DOE notes that the estimated incremental MPCs would
be equivalent for the freestanding and built-in/slide-in oven product
classes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\ Available at: http://www.bls.gov/ppi/.
[[Page 33054]]
Table IV-21--Conventional Oven Incremental Manufacturing Product Cost
[2014$]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric ovens Gas ovens
Level ---------------------------------------------------------------
Standard Self-clean Standard Self-clean
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline........................................ .............. .............. .............. ..............
1............................................... $0.82 $0.82 $0.00 $0.82
2............................................... 2.76 25.00 0.82 7.31
3............................................... 7.89 56.74 7.31 27.96
4............................................... 10.22 61.93 12.44 33.15
5............................................... 34.40 .............. 14.77 ..............
6............................................... 66.14 .............. 35.43 ..............
7............................................... 70.36 .............. 39.74 ..............
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Consumer Utility
In determining whether a standard is economically justified, EPCA
requires DOE to consider ``any lessening of the utility or the
performance of the covered products likely to result from the
imposition of the standard.'' (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(IV))
In a response to the December 2014 TP SNOPR, Sub Zero commented
that heavier gauge materials provide customers with extended product
life, quality, functionality, and durability. Sub Zero also commented
that that full extension oven racks provided in these products provide
consumer utility. (Sub Zero, TP No. 20 at p. 3)
In response to the February 2014 RFI, AHAM and Whirlpool commented
that new energy conservation standards could likely impact the utility
of conventional ovens in the following ways:
A standard could lower burner input rates, which will
impact cooking times. Higher burner input rates allow for quicker
cooking time, which is an important consumer utility;
A standard could result in smaller oven windows. Consumers
desire larger windows in order to view the food during cooking without
opening the oven door. Smaller windows could result in more door
openings, and thus increase energy use;
A standard could also result in the removal of accent
lighting and large displays which are preferred consumer features.
There is reduced consumer utility from further reducing standby power
from what products use today. According to Whirlpool, the market is
still pushing manufacturers to add more advanced electronics that use
more standby power. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 7; Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at
pp. 5, 8).
Accordingly, AHAM and Whirlpool opposed amendment of the existing
standards for cooking products. AHAM and Whirlpool stated that not only
would amended standards fail to be technologically feasible or
economically justified, but they would also impact the utility of
cooking products. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 7; Whirlpool, STD No. 13 at p.
8).
DOE conducted the engineering analysis by considering design
options that are consistent with products currently on the market, and
as a result, DOE did not consider changes that would result in smaller
oven windows or removal of accent lighting and display features. In
addition, as discussed in section IV.A.2, DOE noted that gas ovens with
higher burner input rates did not have significantly faster cooking
times when tested according to the DOE test procedure in Appendix I.
This is likely due in large part to the fact that gas-cooking products
with higher burner input rates marketed as commercial-style often have
significantly larger thermal masses, which absorb a significant amount
of additional heat. DOE is also not aware of data justifying how added
thermal mass improves durability, extends product life, or provides
additional consumer utility as compared to standard residential-style
ovens. As a result, DOE does not believe that any of the design options
and efficiency levels considered in this NOPR would impact the consumer
utility of conventional ovens, as suggested by AHAM and Whirlpool.
However DOE welcomes continued feedback on this topic, including how
the efficiency levels and technology options presented in Table IV-15
through Table IV-18 may affect consumer utility (see section VII.E).
D. Markups Analysis
The markups analysis develops appropriate markups in the
distribution chain to convert the MPC estimates derived in the
engineering analysis to consumer prices. At each step in the
distribution channel, companies mark up the price of the product to
cover business costs and profit margin. For conventional cooking
products, the main parties in the distribution chain are manufacturers
and retailers.
Thus, DOE analyzed a manufacturer-to-consumer distribution channel
consisting of three parties: (1) The manufacturers of the products; (2)
the retailers purchasing the products from manufacturers and selling
them to consumers; and (3) the consumers who purchase the products.
The manufacturer markup converts MPC to manufacturer selling price
(MSP). DOE developed an average manufacturer markup by examining the
annual Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) 10-K reports filed by
publicly traded manufacturers primarily engaged in appliance
manufacturing and whose combined product range includes conventional
cooking products.
For retailers, DOE developed separate markups for baseline products
(baseline markups) and for the incremental cost of more efficient
products (incremental markups). Incremental markups are coefficients
that relate the change in the MSP of higher-efficiency models to the
change in the retailer sales price. DOE relied on economic data from
the U.S. Census Bureau to estimate average baseline and incremental
markups.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ U.S. Census, 2007 Annual Retail Trade Survey (ARTS),
Electronics and Appliance Stores sectors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to developing manufacturer and retailer markups, DOE
included sales taxes in the final appliance retail prices. DOE used an
Internet source, the Sales Tax Clearinghouse, to calculate applicable
sales taxes.
Chapter 6 of the NOPR TSD provides details on DOE's development of
markups for conventional ovens.
E. Energy Use Analysis
The energy use analysis provides estimates of the annual energy
consumption of ovens at the considered efficiency levels. DOE uses
these values in the LCC and PBP analyses and in the NIA to establish
the savings in
[[Page 33055]]
consumer operating costs at various product efficiency levels. DOE
developed energy consumption estimates for all product classes analyzed
in the engineering analysis.
For the April 2009 Final Rule, DOE utilized a 2004 California
Residential Appliance Saturation Study (RASS) \30\ and a Florida Solar
Energy Center (FSEC) study \31\ to establish representative annual
energy use values for cooking products. For this NOPR, DOE used an
update to the California RASS \32\ and a recent FSEC study \33\ to
establish representative annual energy use values for conventional
ovens. These studies confirmed that annual cooking energy use has been
consistently declining since the late 1970s.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\ California Energy Commission, California Statewide
Residential Appliance Saturation Study (June 2004).
\31\ D.S. Parker. ``Research Highlights from a Large Scale
Residential Monitoring Study in a Hot Climate,'' Proceeding of
International Symposium on Highly Efficient Use of Energy and
Reduction of its Environmental Impact (January 2002).
\32\ California Energy Commission, Residential Appliance
Saturation Survey (RASS) (2009).
\33\ Parker, D., Fairey, P., Hendron, R., ``Updated
Miscellaneous Electricity Loads and Appliance Energy Usage Profiles
for Use in Home Energy Ratings, the Building America Benchmark
Procedures and Related Calculations,'' Florida Solar Energy Center
(FSEC) (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE's energy use analysis estimated the range of energy use of
cooking products in the field, i.e., as they are actually used by
consumers. Because energy use by residential cooking products varies
greatly based on consumer usage patterns, DOE established a range of
energy use. The Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s 2009
Residential Energy Consumption Survey (RECS 2009) is one source for
estimating the range of energy use for cooking products.\34\ DOE used
data from RECS 2009 for this NOPR to establish this range.\35\ Although
RECS 2009 does not provide the annual energy consumption of the cooking
product, it does provide the frequency of cooking use. DOE was unable
to use the frequency of use to calculate the annual energy consumption
using a bottom-up approach, as data in RECS did not include information
about the duration of a cooking event to allow for an annual energy use
calculation. DOE therefore relied on California RASS and FSEC studies
to establish the annual energy consumption of a cooking product.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\ U.S. Department of Energy: Energy Information
Administration, Residential Energy Consumption Survey: 2009 RECS
Survey Data (2013) (Available at: http://www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/data/2009/).
\35\ RECS 2009 is based on a sample of 12,083 households
statistically selected to represent 113.6 million housing units in
the United States. RECS 2009 data are available for 27 geographical
areas (including 16 large States) (Available at: www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
From RECS 2009, DOE developed household samples for each product
class. For each household using a conventional cooking product, RECS
provides data on the frequency of use and number of meals cooked in the
following bins: (1) Less than once per week, (2) once per week, (3) a
few times per week, (4) once per day, (5) two times per day, and (6)
three or more times per day. Thus, DOE utilized the frequency of use to
define the variability of the annual energy consumption. Conducting the
analysis in this manner captures the observed variability in annual
energy consumption while maintaining the average annual energy
consumption. To determine the variability of cooking product energy
consumption, DOE first equated the weighted-average cooking frequency
from RECS with the average energy use values based on CA RASS and FSEC
studies. DOE then varied the annual energy consumption for each RECS
household based on its reported cooking frequency. Thus, DOE utilized
the range in frequency of use to define the variability of the annual
energy consumption.
Chapter 7 of the NOPR TSD describes the energy use analysis in
detail.
AHAM expressed objections to DOE's reliance on RECS 2009 for
analyses, stating that it is difficult, if not impossible, to compare
the results to the energy use measured in a controlled test procedure
situation. (AHAM, STD No. 9 at p. 7) DOE utilized RECS 2009 only to
characterize variability of usage across various consumers. For
representative energy use DOE relied on other studies and surveys to
establish baseline energy consumption.
Whirlpool noted that cooking product energy use is unique from
other major appliances in that there is a wide variation amongst
consumers, with consumer behavior as a key determinant. (Whirlpool, STD
No. 13 at p. 8) DOE acknowledges that consumer behavior is a key
determinant of the eventual energy use by the product. To characterize
the variability in usage across consumers, DOE utilized data from RECS
2009, as described above.
F. Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Period Analysis
The purpose of the LCC and PBP analysis is to evaluate the economic
impacts of potential energy conservation standards for cooking products
on individual consumers. The LCC is the total consumer expense over the
life of the product, including purchase and installation expense and
operating costs (energy expenditures, repair costs, and maintenance
costs). The PBP is the number of years it would take for the consumer
to recover the increased costs of purchasing a higher efficiency
product through energy savings. To calculate LCC, DOE discounted future
operating costs to the time of purchase and summed them over the
lifetime of the product.
For any given efficiency level, DOE measures the change in LCC
relative to an estimate of the base-case product efficiency
distribution. The base-case estimate reflects the market in the absence
of new or amended energy conservation standards, including the market
for products that exceed the current energy conservation standards. In
contrast, the PBP is measured relative to the baseline product.
DOE calculated the LCC and payback periods for conventional ovens
for a nationally representative set of housing units selected from RECS
2009. By using a representative sample of households, the analysis
captured the variability in energy consumption and energy prices
associated with cooking product use.
For each sample household, DOE determined the energy consumption
for the cooking product and the appropriate energy price. DOE first
calculated the LCC associated with a baseline cooking product for each
household. To calculate the LCC savings and PBP associated with
products meeting higher efficiency standards, DOE substituted the
baseline unit with more efficient designs.
As part of the LCC and PBP analyses, DOE developed data that it
used to establish product prices, installation costs, annual household
energy consumption, energy prices, maintenance and repair costs,
product lifetime, and discount rates. Inputs to the LCC and PBP
analysis are categorized as: (1) Inputs for establishing the total
installed cost and (2) inputs for calculating the operating costs. DOE
models the uncertainty and the variability in the inputs to the LCC and
PBP analysis using Monte Carlo simulations and probability
distributions.\36\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\ The Monte Carlo process statistically captures input
variability and distribution without testing all possible input
combinations. Therefore, while some atypical situations may not be
captured in the analysis, DOE believes the analysis captures an
adequate range of situations in which the conventional cooking
products operate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following sections contain comments on the inputs and key
assumptions of DOE's LCC and PBP analysis and explain how DOE took
[[Page 33056]]
these comments into consideration. Chapter 8 of the TSD accompanying
this notice contains detailed discussion of the methodology and data
utilized for the LCC and PBP analysis.
1. Product Costs
To calculate the prices faced by cooking products purchasers, DOE
multiplied the manufacturing costs developed from the engineering
analysis by the supply chain markups it developed (along with sales
taxes).
To project future product prices, DOE examined the electric and gas
cooking products Producer Price Index (PPI) for the period 1982-2013.
This index, adjusted for inflation, shows a declining trend. The
decline for gas cooking products is a little more significant than that
for electric cooking products (see appendix 10-D of the NOPR TSD).
Based on an exponential fit of the adjusted PPIs, DOE utilized a
declining price trend for both electric and gas cooking products as the
default case to project future product price.
2. Installation Costs
Installation costs include labor, overhead, and any miscellaneous
materials and parts. For this NOPR, DOE used data from the 2013 RS
Means Mechanical Cost Data on labor requirements to estimate
installation costs for conventional ovens.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\ RS Means Company Inc., RS Means Mechanical Cost Data (2013)
(Available at http://rsmeans.reedconstructiondata.com/default.aspx).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In general, DOE estimated that installation costs would be the same
for different efficiency levels.
3. Unit Energy Consumption
Section IV.E describes the derivation of annual energy use for
conventional ovens.
DOE did not find any evidence of a rebound effect, in which
consumers use a more efficient appliance more intensively, for
conventional ovens. Cooking practices are affected by people's eating
habits, which are unlikely to change due to higher product efficiency.
DOE requests comment on its decision to not use a rebound effect for
cooking products (see issue 11 in section VII.E).
4. Energy Prices
DOE derived marginal residential electricity and natural gas prices
for 27 geographic areas.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\ DOE characterized the geographic distribution into 27
geographic areas to be consistent with the 27 states and group of
states reported in RECS 2009.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE estimated residential electricity prices for each of the 27
areas based on 2013 data from EIA Form 861, Annual Electric Power
Industry Report.\39\ DOE first estimated a marginal residential price
for each utility, and then calculated an marginal price for each area
by weighting each utility with customers in an area by the number of
residential customers served in that area.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ Utility EIA form 861 submissions for 20132012 are available
at http://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE estimated marginal residential natural gas prices in each of
the 27 geographic areas based on 2013 data from the EIA publication
Natural Gas Monthly publication.\40\ DOE calculated a marginal natural
gas price for each area by first calculating the average prices for
each State, and then calculating a regional price by weighting each
State in a region by its population.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\40\ The EIA Natural Gas Monthly publication is available at
http://www.eia.gov/naturalgas/monthly/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To estimate future trends in electricity and natural gas prices,
DOE used price forecasts in AEO 2015. To arrive at prices in future
years, DOE multiplied the marginal prices described above by the
forecast of annual average changes in national-average residential
electricity and natural gas prices. Because AEO 2015 forecasts prices
only to 2040, DOE used the average rate of change during 2025-2040 to
estimate the price trends beyond 2040.
Laclede and the American Gas Association (AGA) suggest that DOE use
consumer marginal energy rates when evaluating the LCC for each
standard efficiency level. They noted that this approach was
recommended by DOE's Advisory Committee on Appliance Energy Efficiency
Standards in April 1998. AGA notes that a marginal price analysis
reflects incremental changes in natural gas costs most closely
associated with changes in the amount of gas consumed. (Laclede, STD
No. 8 at p. 4 and AGA, STD No. 7 at p. 2) DOE developed estimates of
marginal electricity and natural gas prices for the NOPR analysis.
The spreadsheet tool used to conduct the LCC and PBP analysis
allows users to select the AEO 2015 high-growth case or low-growth case
price forecasts to estimate the sensitivity of the LCC and PBP to
different energy price forecasts.
5. Repair and Maintenance Costs
Repair costs are associated with repairing or replacing components
that have failed in the appliance. Maintenance costs are associated
with maintaining the operation of the equipment.
Typically, small incremental changes in product efficiency incur
no, or only very small, changes in repair and maintenance costs over
baseline products. For all electric cooking products, DOE did not
include any changes in repair and maintenance costs for products more
efficient than baseline products.
For gas ovens, DOE determined the repair and maintenance costs
associated with different types of ignition systems. Following the
approach adopted in the April 2009 Final Rule for electric glo-bar/hot
surface ignition systems, DOE estimated an average repair cost of $170
occurring every fifth year during the product's lifetime. For
electronic spark ignition systems, DOE estimated an average repair cost
of $206 occurring in the tenth year of the product's life. DOE seeks
comments from the industry on repair cost estimation (see section
VII.E).
See chapter 8 of the TSD accompanying this notice for further
information regarding repair and maintenance costs.
6. Product Lifetime
Equipment lifetime is the age at which the equipment is retired
from service. DOE used a variety of sources to establish low, average,
and high estimates for product lifetime. Utilizing data from Appliance
Magazine Market Insight, DOE established average product lifetimes of
15 years for conventional electric ovens and 17 years for conventional
gas ovens.\41\ DOE characterized the product lifetimes with Weibull
probability distributions. See chapter 8 of the TSD accompanying this
notice for further details on the sources used to develop product
lifetimes, as well as the use of Weibull distributions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\ Appliance Magazine, Market Insight. The U.S. Appliance
Industry: Market Value, Life Expectancy & Replacement Picture 2012.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Discount Rates
In the calculation of LCC, DOE applies discount rates appropriate
to households to estimate the present value of future operating costs.
DOE estimated a distribution of residential discount rates for
conventional cooking products based on consumer financing costs and
opportunity cost of funds related to appliance energy cost savings and
maintenance costs.
To establish residential discount rates for the LCC analysis, DOE's
approach involved identifying all relevant household debt or asset
classes in order to approximate a consumer's opportunity cost of funds
related to appliance energy cost savings and maintenance costs. DOE
estimated the average percentage shares of the various
[[Page 33057]]
types of debt and equity by household income group using data from the
Federal Reserve Board's Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) for 1995,
1998, 2001, 2004, 2007, and 2010.\42\ Using the SCF and other sources,
DOE then developed a distribution of rates for each type of debt and
asset by income group to represent the rates that may apply in the year
in which amended standards would take effect. DOE assigned each sample
household a specific discount rate drawn from one of the distributions.
The average rate across all types of household debt and equity and
income groups, weighted by the shares of each class, is 5.0 percent.
See chapter 8 in the NOPR TSD for further details on the development of
consumer discount rates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\42\ Note that two older versions of the SCF are also available
(1989 and 1992). These surveys were not used in this analysis
because they do not provide all of the necessary types of data
(e.g., credit card interest rates). DOE determines that the 15-year
span covered by the six surveys included is sufficiently
representative of recent debt and equity shares and interest rates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Compliance Date
The compliance date is the date when a covered product is required
to meet a new or amended standard. DOE calculated the LCC and PBP for
all customers as if each were to purchase new equipment in the year
that compliance with amended standards is required. EPCA, as amended,
requires that not later than 6 years after issuance of any final rule
establishing or amending a standard, DOE must publish either a notice
of determination that standards for the product do not need to be
amended, or a NOPR that includes new proposed energy conservation
standards. (42 U.S.C. 6295(m)(1)) DOE's last final rule for
conventional cooking products was issued on March 31, 2009. Thus, DOE
must act by March 31, 2015. (42 U.S.C. 6295(m)(1)(b). Any amended
standards would apply to conventional cooking products manufactured
three years after the date on which the final amended standard is
published. (42 U.S.C. 6295(m)(4)(A)(i)) Therefore, for purposes of its
analysis, DOE assumed that a final rule would be published in 2016,
which results in 2019 being the first year of compliance with amended
standards.
9. Base Case Efficiency Distribution
To accurately estimate the percentage of consumers that would be
affected by a particular standard level, DOE estimates the distribution
of equipment efficiencies that consumers are expected to purchase under
the base case (i.e., the case without amended energy efficiency
standards). DOE refers to this distribution of equipment energy
efficiencies as a base-case efficiency distribution. This approach
reflects the fact that some consumers may already purchase equipment
with efficiencies greater than the baseline equipment levels.
DOE did not have market data reflecting the efficiency distribution
of cooking products being sold. DOE's Compliance Certification Database
provides information on models of gas cooking products that comply with
the requirement of not having a standing pilot. In the absence of data
on the efficiency distribution of the products being sold in the
market, DOE calculated the market share of available efficiency options
based on consumer's sensitivity to first cost. DOE treated renters and
owners as two separate entities to establish price sensitivities, and
used a logit model to characterize historical shipments as a function
of price. DOE used shipments data collected by the Market Research
Magazine and the PPI for household cooking appliance manufacturers
between the years 2002-2012, along with the manufacturer cost data from
the engineering analysis to analyze factors that influence consumer
purchasing decisions of cooking products. Because the data are not
sufficient to capture any definite trend in efficiency, DOE used the
2013 distribution (described in Chapter 8 of the NOPR TSD) to represent
the market in the compliance year (2019).
Table IV-22 and present market shares of the efficiency levels in
the base case for conventional ovens.\43\ See chapter 8 of the NOPR TSD
for further details on the development of base-case market shares.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\43\ For the conventional oven product classes, the efficiency
levels are based on an oven with a cavity volume of 3.9 ft\3\. As
discussed in section IV.C.3, DOE developed slopes and intercepts to
characterize the relationship between IEAC and cavity volume for
each efficiency level.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BILLING CODE 6450-01-C
[[Page 33058]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP10JN15.001
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P
10. Inputs to Payback Period Analysis
The PBP is the amount of time it takes the consumer to recover the
additional installed cost of more efficient equipment, compared to
baseline equipment, through energy cost savings. PBPs are expressed in
years. PBPs that exceed the life of the product mean that the increased
total installed cost is not recovered in reduced operating expenses.
The inputs to the PBP calculation are the total installed cost of
the product to the customer for each efficiency level and the annual
first year operating expenditures for each efficiency level. The PBP
calculation uses the same inputs as the LCC analysis, except that
energy price trends and discount rates are not needed.
11. Rebuttable-Presumption Payback Period
EPCA establishes a rebuttable presumption that a standard is
economically justified if the Secretary finds that the additional cost
to the consumer of purchasing a product complying with an energy
conservation standard level will be less than three times the value of
the energy savings during the first year that the consumer will receive
as a result of the standard, as calculated under the test procedure
[[Page 33059]]
in place for that standard. (42 U.S.C. (o)(2)(B)(iii) For each
considered efficiency level, DOE determines the value of the first
year's energy savings by calculating the quantity of those savings in
accordance with the applicable DOE test procedure, and multiplying that
amount by the average energy price forecast for the year in which
compliance with the amended standards would be required.
G. Shipments Analysis
DOE uses projections of product shipments to calculate the national
impacts of standards on energy use, NPV, and future manufacturer cash
flows. DOE develops shipment projections based on historical data and
an analysis of key market drivers for each product. Historical
shipments data are used to build up an equipment stock and also to
calibrate the shipments model. DOE accounted for three market segments:
(1) New construction, (2) existing homes (i.e., replacing failed
products), and (3) retired but not replaced. DOE used the retired but
not replaced market segment to calibrate the shipments model to
historical shipments data.
DOE considered the impacts of prospective standards on product
shipments. The combined market of conventional electric and gas cooking
products is completely saturated. Thus, DOE concluded that any price
increase due to a standard would not impact the overall decision to
purchase. However, DOE did implement an impact due to a standard on the
efficiency of the product that will likely be purchased. This impact is
captured through a change in the efficiency distribution of the market.
Table IV-24 summarizes the approach and data DOE used to derive the
inputs to the shipments analysis for the NOPR.
Table IV-24--Approach and Data Used To Derive the Inputs to the
Shipments Analysis
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Inputs Approach
------------------------------------------------------------------------
New Construction Shipments........ Determined by multiplying housing
forecasts by forecasted saturation
of cooking products for new
housing. Housing forecasts based on
AEO2014 projections. New housing
product saturations based on RECS
2009. Forecasted saturations
maintained at 2009 levels.
Replacements...................... Determined by tracking total product
stock by vintage and establishing
the failure of the stock using
retirement functions from the LCC
and PBP analysis. Retirement
functions were based on Weibull
lifetime distributions.
Retired but not replaced.......... Used to calibrate shipments model to
historical shipments data to
account for a decline in the
replacement shipments.
Historical Shipments.............. Data sources include U.S.
Statistical Review of Appliance
Industry and Appliance Magazine.
Impacts Due to Efficiency Not considered due to a fully
Standards. saturated market.
Fuel Switching.................... Not considered, as no significant
movement was observed from
historical data.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To determine new construction shipments, DOE used a forecast of new
housing coupled with product market saturation data for new housing.
For new housing completions and mobile home placements, DOE adopted the
projections from EIA's AEO 2015 through 2040.
DOE estimated replacements using product retirement functions
developed from product lifetimes. For this NOPR, DOE used retirement
functions based on Weibull distributions.
To reconcile the historical shipments with the model, DOE assumed
that every retired unit is not replaced. DOE attributed the reason for
this non-replacement to building demolition occurring at the rate of
approximately three percent of the retiring units per annum over the
period 2013-2048. The assumed not-replaced rate is distributed into 2.8
percent for electric cooking products and 4.1 percent for gas cooking
products.
DOE allocated shipments to each of the eight product classes based
on the current market share of each class. DOE developed the market
shares based on historical data collected from Appliance Magazine
Market Research report \44\ and U.S. Appliance Industry Statistical
Review.\45\ The shares are kept constant over time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\ Appliance Magazine Market Research. The U.S. Appliance
Industry: Market Value, Life Expectancy & Replacement Picture 2012.
\45\ Appliance 2011. U.S. Appliance Industry Statistical Review:
2000 to YTD 2011.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AGA voiced concern that the establishment of energy conservation
standards for natural gas cooking appliances may result in increased
first-cost of these appliances, making them less attractive and leading
to potential fuel switching. (AGA, STD No. 7 at p. 2) Because this NOPR
considers standards for both electric and natural gas appliances, any
increase in the price of the appliance would impact cooking products of
both fuel types. As switching typically includes additional
installation costs for accessing the new fuel source (e.g. installation
of a gas line for gas appliances and installation of electrical lines
for electrical appliances), which would outweigh the incremental change
in equipment price, DOE determined that fuel-switching would not occur.
For further details on the shipments analysis, please refer to
chapter 9 of the NOPR TSD.
H. National Impact Analysis
The NIA assesses the national energy savings and the national NPV
of total consumer costs and savings that would be expected to result
from amended standards at specific efficiency levels.
DOE used an MS Excel spreadsheet model to calculate the national
energy savings and the consumer costs and savings from each TSL.\46\
The NIA calculations are based on the annual energy consumption and
total installed cost data from the energy use analysis and the LCC
analysis. DOE projected the lifetime energy savings, energy cost
savings, equipment costs, and NPV of customer benefits for each product
class over the lifetime of equipment sold from 2019 through 2048.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\ DOE's use of MS Excel as the basis for the spreadsheet
models provides interested parties with access to the models within
a familiar context. In addition, the TSD and other documentation
that DOE provides during the rulemaking help explain the models and
how to use them. Interested parties can review DOE's analyses by
changing various input quantities within the spreadsheet.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE evaluated the impacts of proposed standards for conventional
ovens by comparing base-case projections with standards-case
projections. The base-case projections characterize energy use and
customer costs for each product class in the
[[Page 33060]]
absence of proposed energy conservation standards.
Table IV-25 summarizes the key inputs for the NIA. The sections
following provide further details, as does chapter 10 of the NOPR TSD.
Table IV-25--Inputs for the National Impact Analysis
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Description
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shipments......................... Annual shipments from shipments
model.
Compliance date................... January 1, 2019.
Base case efficiency.............. Based on the consumer choice model.
Standards case efficiency......... Based on a ``roll up'' scenario to
establish a 2019 shipment weighted
efficiency.
Annual energy consumption per unit Calculated for each efficiency level
and product class based on inputs
from the energy use analysis.
Total installed cost per unit..... Calculated by efficiency level using
manufacturer selling prices and
weighted-average overall markup
values.
Energy expense per unit........... Annual energy use is multiplied by
the corresponding average
electricity and gas price.
Escalation of electricity and gas AEO 2015 forecasts (to 2040) and
prices. extrapolation beyond 2040 for
electricity and gas prices.
Electricity site-to-primary energy A time series conversion factor;
conversion. includes electric generation,
transmission, and distribution
losses.
Discount rates.................... 3% and 7%.
Present year...................... 2014.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Efficiency Trends
A key component of DOE's estimates of national energy savings and
NPV is the energy efficiencies forecasted over time. For the base case,
in the absence of any historical efficiency data, and absence of an
ENERGY STAR program for conventional cooking products, DOE assumed that
efficiency would follow the distribution based on consumer choice
model. The model responds to changes in product prices, and therefore,
is affected by the learning effect on the prices.
To estimate the impact that standards would have in the year
compliance becomes required, DOE used a ``roll-up'' scenario, which
assumes that equipment efficiencies in the base case that do not meet
the standard level under consideration would ``roll up'' to meet the
new standard level and equipment shipments at efficiencies above the
standard level under consideration are not affected. In each standards
case, the efficiency distributions remain constant at the 2019 levels
for the remainder of the shipments forecast period.
2. National Energy Savings
For each year in the forecast period, DOE calculates the national
energy savings for each standard level by multiplying the shipments of
ovens by the per-unit annual energy savings. Cumulative energy savings
are the sum of the annual energy savings over the lifetime of all
equipment shipped during 2019-2048.
The annual energy consumption per unit depends directly on
equipment efficiency. DOE used the shipment-weighted energy
efficiencies associated with the base case and each standards case, in
combination with the annual energy use data, to estimate the shipment-
weighted average annual per-unit energy consumption under the base case
and standards cases. The national energy consumption is the product of
the annual energy consumption per unit and the number of units of each
vintage, which depends on shipments. DOE calculates the total annual
site energy savings for a given standards case by subtracting total
energy use in the standards case from total energy use in the base
case. Note that total shipments are the same in the standards cases as
in the base case.
DOE converted the site electricity consumption and savings to
primary energy (power sector energy consumption) using annual
conversion factors derived from the AEO 2014 version of the National
Energy Modeling System (NEMS).
The American Public Gas Association (APGA), National Propane Gas
Association (NGPA), AGA, and Laclede recommend that DOE incorporate
full fuel cycle analysis in the conservation standard. (APGA, STD No. 6
at p. 2, NPGA, STD No. 5 at pp. 1-3, AGA, STD No. 7 at p. 2, and
Laclede, STD No. 8 at p. 3) In response to the recommendations of a
committee on ``Point-of-Use and Full-Fuel-Cycle Measurement Approaches
to Energy Efficiency Standards'' appointed by the National Academy of
Science, DOE announced its intention to use FFC measures of energy use,
GHG emissions and other emissions in the national impact analyses and
emissions analyses included in future energy conservation standards
rulemakings. 76 FR 51281 (August 18, 2011). After evaluating the
approaches discussed in the August 18, 2011 notice, DOE published a
statement of amended policy in the Federal Register in which DOE
explained its determination that NEMS is the most appropriate tool for
its FFC analysis and its intention to use NEMS for that purpose. 77 FR
49701 (August 17, 2012). The FFC factors incorporate losses in
production and delivery in the case of natural gas (including fugitive
emissions), and energy used to produce and deliver the fuels used by
power plants. The approach used for this NOPR, and the FFC multipliers
that were applied, are described in appendix 10A of the NOPR TSD. DOE
continues to work with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to make
available to the consumer information regarding FFC energy use through
the Energy Guide label. Table IV-26 through Table IV-29 below present
the FFC equivalent of IAEC for the considered efficiency levels.
Table IV-26--Conventional Electric Standard Ovens: FFC Equivalent of IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IAEC--site (kWh) IAEC--FFC (kWh)
Standard level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in Freestanding Built-in
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 294 302 962 985
[[Page 33061]]
1........................... 285 291 930 952
2........................... 272 278 888 909
3........................... 259 265 847 867
4........................... 255 261 833 853
5........................... 245 250 799 819
6........................... 208 213 679 695
7........................... 207 212 677 694
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-27--Conventional Electric Self-Clean Ovens: FFC Equivalent of IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IAEC--site (kWh) IAEC--FFC (kWh)
Standard level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in Freestanding Built-in
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 355 361 1,160 1,180
1........................... 345 351 1,128 1,147
2........................... 327 333 1,069 1,087
3........................... 279 284 912 927
4........................... 278 283 909 924
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-28--Conventional Gas Standard Ovens: FFC Equivalent of IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IAEC--site (kWh) IAEC--FFC (kWh)
Standard level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in Freestanding Built-in
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 2,118 2,128 2,347 2,358
1........................... 1,649 1,657 1,828 1,836
2........................... 1,615 1,622 1,789 1,798
3........................... 1,491 1,498 1,652 1,660
4........................... 1,415 1,421 1,568 1,575
5........................... 1,401 1,407 1,552 1,559
6........................... 1,356 1,362 1,502 1,509
7........................... 1,347 1,353 1,493 1,500
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table IV-29--Conventional Gas Self-Clean Ovens: FFC Equivalent of IAEC
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IAEC--site (kWh) IAEC--FFC (kWh)
Standard level -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freestanding Built-in Freestanding Built-in
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Baseline.................... 1,884 1,894 2,087 2,098
1........................... 1,848 1,858 2,048 2,059
2........................... 1,669 1,677 1,849 1,859
3........................... 1,596 1,605 1,769 1,778
4........................... 1,591 1,599 1,763 1,772
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Net Present Value of Customer Benefit
The inputs for determining the NPV of the total costs and benefits
experienced by consumers are: (1) Total annual installed cost; (2)
total annual savings in operating costs; and (3) a discount factor to
calculate the present value of costs and savings. DOE calculates the
lifetime net savings for equipment shipped each year as the difference
between the base case and each standards case in total savings in
lifetime operating costs and total increases in installed costs. DOE
calculates lifetime operating cost savings over the life of each
considered oven unit in conventional cooking products shipped during
the forecast period.
a. Total Annual Installed Cost
The total installed cost includes both the equipment price and the
installation cost. For each product class, DOE calculated equipment
prices by efficiency level using manufacturer selling prices and
weighted-average overall markup values. Because DOE calculated the
total installed cost as a function of equipment efficiency, it was able
to determine annual total installed costs based on the annual shipment-
weighted efficiency levels determined in the shipments model. DOE
accounted for the repair and maintenance costs associated with the
ignition systems in gas cooking products.
As noted in section IV.F.1, DOE assumed a declining trend in the
conventional cooking products prices
[[Page 33062]]
over the analysis period. In addition, DOE conducted sensitivity
analyses using alternative price trends: One in which the rate of
decline in prices is greater after 2014, and one in which the rate of
decline is lower. These price trends, and the NPV results from the
associated sensitivity cases, are described in appendix 10B of the NOPR
TSD.
b. Total Annual Operating Cost Savings
The per-unit energy savings were derived as described in section
IV.H.2. To calculate future electricity and natural gas prices, DOE
applied the projected trend in national-average commercial electricity
and natural gas price from the AEO 2015 Reference case, which extends
to 2040, to the prices derived in the LCC and PBP analysis. DOE used
the trend from 2025 to 2040 to extrapolate beyond 2040. DOE requests
comment on its approach (see issue 9 in section VII.E).
In addition, DOE analyzed scenarios that used the energy price
projections in the AEO 2015 Low Economic Growth and High Economic
Growth cases. These cases have higher and lower energy price trends
compared to the Reference case. These price trends, and the NPV results
from the associated cases, are described in appendix 10C of the NOPR
TSD.
In calculating the NPV, DOE multiplies the net dollar savings in
future years by a discount factor to determine their present value. DOE
estimates the NPV using both a 3-percent and a 7-percent real discount
rate in accordance with guidance provided by the OMB to Federal
agencies on the development of regulatory analysis.\47\ The discount
rates for the determination of NPV are in contrast to the discount
rates used in the LCC analysis, which are designed to reflect a
consumer's perspective. The 7-percent real value is an estimate of the
average before-tax rate of return to private capital in the U.S.
economy. The 3-percent real value represents the ``social rate of time
preference,'' which is the rate at which society discounts future
consumption flows to their present value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\47\ U.S. Office of Management and Budget, ``Circular A-4:
Regulatory Analysis,'' Section E, (Sept. 17, 2003) (Available at:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a004_a-4/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
I. Consumer Subgroup Analysis
In analyzing the potential impact of new or amended standards on
individual consumers, DOE evaluates the impact on identifiable
subgroups of consumers that may be disproportionately affected by a
national standard level. For this NOPR, DOE used RECS 2009 data to
analyze the potential effect of standards for residential cooking
products on two consumer subgroups: (1) Households with low income
levels, and (2) households comprised of seniors.
More details on the consumer subgroup analysis can be found in
chapter 11 of the TSD accompanying this notice.
J. Manufacturer Impact Analysis
1. Overview
DOE conducted an MIA for residential conventional ovens to estimate
the financial impact of new and amended energy conservation standards
on manufacturers of these products. The MIA has both quantitative and
qualitative aspects. The quantitative part of the MIA relies on the
GRIM, an industry cash-flow model customized for residential
conventional ovens covered in this rulemaking. The key GRIM inputs are
data on the industry cost structure, equipment costs, shipments, and
assumptions about manufacturer markups and conversion costs. The key
MIA output is INPV. DOE used the GRIM to calculate cash flows using
standard accounting principles and to compare changes in INPV between a
base case and various TSLs in the standards case. The difference in
INPV between the base and standards cases represents the financial
impact of new and amended energy conservation standards on residential
conventional oven manufacturers. Different sets of assumptions
(scenarios) produce different INPV results. The qualitative part of the
MIA addresses factors such as manufacturing capacity; characteristics
of, and impacts on, any particular subgroup of manufacturers; and
impacts on competition.
DOE conducted the MIA for this rulemaking in three phases. In the
first phase DOE prepared an industry characterization based on the
market and technology assessment and publicly available information. In
the second phase, DOE developed an interview guide based on the
industry financial parameters derived in the first phase. In the third
phase, DOE conducted interviews with a variety of residential
conventional cooking product manufacturers that account for more than
85 percent of domestic residential conventional oven sales covered by
this rulemaking. During these interviews, DOE discussed engineering,
manufacturing, procurement, and financial topics specific to each
company and obtained each manufacturer's view of the residential
conventional oven industry as a whole. The interviews provided
information that DOE used to evaluate the impacts of new and amended
standards on manufacturers' cash flows, manufacturing capacities, and
direct domestic manufacturing employment levels. Section V.B.2 of this
NOPR contains a discussion on the estimated changes in the number of
domestic employees involved in manufacturing residential conventional
ovens covered by the proposed standards. Section IV.J.4 of this NOPR
contains a description of the key issues manufacturers raised during
the interviews.
During the third phase, DOE also used the results of the industry
characterization analysis in the first phase and feedback from
manufacturer interviews to group together manufacturers that exhibit
similar production and cost structure characteristics. DOE identified
one manufacturer subgroup for a separate impact analysis--small
business manufacturers--using the small business employee threshold of
750 total employees published by the Small Business Administration
(SBA). This threshold includes all employees in a business' parent
company and any other subsidiaries. Based on this classification, DOE
identified seven residential conventional oven manufacturers that
qualify as small businesses. The manufacturer subgroup analysis is
discussed in greater detail in chapter 12 of the NOPR TSD and in
section VI.B of this notice.
2. GRIM Analysis and Key Inputs
DOE uses the GRIM to quantify the changes in cash flows over time
due to new and amended energy conservation standards. These changes in
cash flows result in either a higher or lower INPV for the standards
case compared to the base case (the case where a standard is not set).
The GRIM analysis uses a standard annual cash flow analysis that
incorporates manufacturer costs, markups, shipments, and industry
financial information as inputs. It then models changes in costs,
investments, and manufacturer margins that result from new and amended
standards. The GRIM uses these inputs to calculate a series of annual
cash flows beginning with the base year of the analysis, 2015, and
continuing to 2048. DOE computes INPV by summing the stream of annual
discounted cash flows during the analysis period. DOE used a real
discount rate of 9.1 percent for residential conventional cooking
product manufacturers. The discount rate estimates were derived from
[[Page 33063]]
industry corporate annual reports to the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC 10-Ks). During manufacturer interviews residential
conventional oven manufacturers were asked to provide feedback on this
discount rate. Most manufacturers agreed that a discount rate of 9.1
was appropriate to use for residential conventional oven manufacturers.
Many inputs into the GRIM came from the engineering analysis, the NIA,
manufacturer interviews, and other research conducted during the MIA.
The major GRIM inputs are described in detail in the following
sections.
a. Capital and Product Conversion Costs
DOE expects new and amended energy conservation standards for
residential conventional ovens to cause manufacturers to incur
conversion costs to bring their production facilities and product
designs into compliance with the new and amended standards. For the
MIA, DOE classified these conversion costs into two major groups: (1)
Capital conversion costs, and (2) product conversion costs. Capital
conversion costs are investments in property, plant, and equipment
necessary to adapt or change existing production facilities such that
new product designs can be fabricated and assembled. Product conversion
costs are investments in research, development, testing, marketing,
certification, and other non-capitalized costs necessary to make
product designs comply with new and amended standards.
Using feedback from manufacturer interviews, DOE conducted a top-
down analysis to calculate the capital and product conversion costs for
residential conventional oven manufacturers. DOE asked manufacturers
during interviews to estimate the total capital and product conversion
costs they would need to incur to be able to produce each residential
conventional oven at specific ELs. DOE then summed these values
provided by manufacturers to arrive at total top-down industry
conversion cost for residential conventional ovens.
See chapter 12 of this NOPR TSD for a complete description of DOE's
assumptions for the capital and product conversion costs.
b. Manufacturer Production Costs
Manufacturing more efficient residential conventional ovens is
typically more expensive than manufacturing baseline products due to
the need for more costly materials and components. The higher MPCs for
these more efficient products can affect the revenue, gross margin, and
the cash flows of residential conventional oven manufacturers. DOE
developed MPCs for each representative unit at each EL analyzed. DOE
purchased a number of units for each product class, then tested and
tore down those units to create a unique bill of materials for the
purchased unit. Using the bill of materials for each residential
conventional oven, DOE was able to create an aggregated MPC based on
the material costs from the bill of materials, the labor costs based on
an average labor rate and the labor hours necessary to manufacture the
residential conventional oven, and the overhead costs, including
depreciation, based on a markup applied to the material and labor costs
based on the materials used. For more information about MPCs, see
section IV.C of this NOPR.
c. Shipment Scenarios
INPV, the key GRIM output, depends on industry revenue, which
depends on the quantity and prices of residential conventional ovens
shipped in each year of the analysis period. Industry revenue
calculations require forecasts of: (1) The total annual shipment volume
of residential conventional ovens; (2) the distribution of shipments
across product classes (because prices vary by product class); and (3)
the distribution of shipments across efficiency levels (because prices
vary with efficiency level).
In the base case shipment analysis, DOE develops shipment
projections based on historical data and an analysis of key market
drivers for each product. In the standards case, DOE modeled a roll-up
scenario. The roll-up scenario represents the case in which all
shipments in the base case do not meet the new and amended standards
shift to now meet the new and amended standard level but do not exceed
the new and amended standard. Also, no shipments that meet or exceed
the new and amended standards have an increase in efficiency due to the
new and amended standards.
For a complete description of the shipments used in the base and
standards case see the shipments analysis discussion in section IV.G of
this NOPR.
d. Markup Scenarios
As discussed in the previous manufacturer production costs section,
the MPCs for each of the product classes of residential conventional
ovens are the manufacturers' factory costs for those units. These costs
include materials, direct labor, depreciation, and overhead, which are
collectively referred to as the cost of goods sold (COGS). The MSP is
the price received by residential conventional oven manufacturers from
their customers, typically retail outlets, regardless of the downstream
distribution channel through which the residential conventional ovens
are ultimately sold. The MSP is not the cost the end-user pays for
residential conventional ovens because there are typically multiple
sales along the distribution chain and various markups applied to each
sale. The MSP equals the MPC multiplied by the manufacturer markup. The
manufacturer markup covers all the residential conventional oven
manufacturer's non-production costs (i.e., selling, general and
administrative expenses (SG&A), research and development (R&D), and
interest, etc.) as well as profit. Total industry revenue for
residential conventional oven manufacturers equals the MSPs at each EL
for each product class multiplied by the number of shipments at each EL
for each product class.
Modifying these manufacturer markups in the standards case yields a
different set of impacts on residential conventional oven manufacturers
than in the base case. For the MIA, DOE modeled two standards case
markup scenarios for residential conventional ovens to represent the
uncertainty regarding the potential impacts on prices and profitability
for residential conventional oven manufacturers following the
implementation of new energy conservation standards. The two scenarios
are: (1) A preservation of gross margin markup scenario, and (2) a
preservation of operating profit markup scenario. Each scenario leads
to different manufacturer markup values, which, when applied to the
inputted MPCs, result in varying revenue and cash flow impacts on
residential conventional oven manufacturers.
The preservation of gross margin markup scenario assumes that the
COGS for each residential conventional oven is marked up by a flat
percentage to cover SG&A expenses, R&D expenses, interest expenses, and
profit. This allows manufacturers to preserve the same gross margin
percentage in the standards case as in the base case throughout the
entire analysis period. This markup scenario represents the upper bound
of the residential conventional oven industry profitability in the
standards case because residential conventional oven manufacturers are
able to fully pass through additional costs due to standards to their
consumers.
To derive the preservation of gross margin markup percentages for
residential conventional ovens, DOE examined the SEC 10-Ks of all
publicly
[[Page 33064]]
traded residential conventional oven manufacturers to estimate the
industry average gross margin percentage. DOE estimated that the
manufacturer markup for residential conventional ovens is 1.20 for all
residential conventional ovens. Manufacturers were then asked about
this industry gross margin percentage derived from SEC 10-Ks during
interviews. Residential conventional oven manufacturers agreed that the
1.20 average industry gross margin calculated from SEC 10-Ks was an
appropriate estimate to use in the MIA. DOE seeks comment on the use of
1.20 for all residential conventional ovens.
DOE included an alternative markup scenario, the preservation of
operating profit markup scenario, because manufacturers stated they do
not expect to be able to markup the full cost of production in the
standards case, given the highly competitive residential conventional
oven market. The preservation of operating profit markup scenario
assumes that manufacturers are able to maintain only the base case
total operating profit in absolute dollars in the standards case,
despite higher production costs and investment. The base case total
operating profit is derived from marking up the COGS for each product
by the preservation of gross margin markup previously described. In the
standards case for the preservation of operating profit markup
scenario, DOE adjusted the residential conventional oven manufacturer
markups in the GRIM at each TSL to yield approximately the same
earnings before interest and taxes in the standards case in the year
after the compliance date of the new and amended standards as in the
base case. Under this scenario, while manufacturers are not able to
earn additional operating profit on higher per unit production costs
and the increase in capital and product investments that are required
to comply with new and amended energy conservation standards, they are
able to maintain the same operating profit in absolute dollars in the
standards case that was earned in the base case.
The preservation of operating profit markup scenario represents the
lower bound of industry profitability in the standards case. This is
because manufacturers are not able to fully pass through the additional
costs necessitated by new and amended energy conservation standards, as
they are able to do in the preservation of gross margin markup
scenario. Therefore, manufacturers earn less revenue in the
preservation of operating profit markup scenario than they do in the
preservation of gross margin markup scenario.
3. Discussion of Comments
The February 2014 RFI did not focus on the MIA or specifically
address any issues relating to the MIA. Therefore, DOE did not receive
any MIA specific comments from the February 2014 RFI.
4. Manufacturer Interviews
DOE conducted manufacturer interviews following publication of the
February 2014 RFI in preparation for the NOPR analysis. In these
interviews, DOE asked manufacturers to describe their major concerns
with this residential conventional ovens rulemaking. The following
section describes the key issues identified by residential conventional
oven manufacturers during these interviews.
a. Premium Products Tend To Be Less Efficient
Manufacturers stated that their premium products are usually less
efficient than their baseline products. For example, premium ovens
typically have bigger cavities with hidden heat sources under the floor
of the cavity. This makes the heat source less direct, therefore
decreasing the efficiency. On the other hand, baseline ovens tend to
use direct heating sources which are more efficient. Manufacturers
warned DOE that focusing only on the efficiency of residential
conventional ovens could cause some manufacturers to redesign their
products in a way that reduces consumer satisfaction as consumers tend
to value premium features.
b. Product Utility
Manufacturers stated that energy efficiency is not one of the most
important aspects that consumers value when purchasing residential
conventional ovens. Manufacturers state that there are several other
factors, such as performance and durability, which consumers value more
when purchasing residential conventional ovens. Forcing manufacturers
to improve the efficiency of their products could lead to some
manufacturers removing premium features that consumers desire from
their products, reducing overall consumer utility.
c. Testing and Certification Burdens
Several manufacturers expressed concern about the testing and
recertification costs associated with new and amended energy
conservation standards for residential conventional ovens. Because
testing and certification costs are incurred on a per model basis, if a
large number of models are required to be redesigned to meet new and
amended standards, manufacturers would be forced to spend a significant
amount of money testing and certifying products that were redesigned
due to new and amended standards. Manufacturers stated that these
testing and certification costs associated with residential
conventional ovens could significantly strain their limited resources
if these costs were all incurred in the three year time frame from the
publication of a final rule to the implementation of the standards.
K. Emissions Analysis
In the emissions analysis, DOE estimated the reduction in power
sector emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides
(NOX), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and mercury (Hg)
from potential energy conservation standards for conventional ovens. In
addition, DOE estimated emissions impacts in production activities
(extracting, processing, and transporting fuels) that provide the
energy inputs to power plants. These are referred to as ``upstream''
emissions. Together, these emissions account for the FFC. In accordance
with DOE's FFC Statement of Policy,\48\ the FFC analysis includes
impacts on emissions of methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide
(N2O), both of which are recognized as GHGs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\48\ 76 FR 51281 (Aug. 18, 2011). DOE's FFC was amended in 2012
for reasons unrelated to the inclusion of CH4 and
N2O. 77 FR 49701 (Aug. 17, 2012).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The analysis of power sector emissions uses marginal emissions
factors calculated using a methodology based on results published for
the AEO 2014 reference case and a set of side cases that implement a
variety of efficiency-related policies.\49\ The methodology is
described in chapter 15 of the NOPR TSD.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\ DOE did not use AEO 2015 for the emissions analysis because
it does not provide the side cases that DOE uses to derive marginal
emissions factors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Combustion emissions of CH4 and N2O were
estimated using emissions intensity factors published by the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), GHG Emissions Factors Hub.\50\
Site emissions of CO2 and NOX (from gas
combustion) were estimated using emissions intensity factors from an
EPA publication.\51\ DOE developed separate emissions factors for power
sector emissions and upstream emissions. The method that DOE used to
derive
[[Page 33065]]
emissions factors is described in chapter 13 of the NOPR TSD.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\50\ See http://www.epa.gov/climateleadership/inventory/ghg-emissions.html.
\51\ U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Compilation of Air
Pollutant Emission Factors, AP-42, Fifth Edition, Volume I:
Stationary Point and Area Sources (1998) (Available at: http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/ap42/index.html).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For CH4 and N2O, DOE calculated emissions
reduction in tons and also in terms of units of carbon dioxide
equivalent (CO2eq). Gases are converted to CO2eq
by multiplying the physical units by the gas' global warming potential
(GWP) over a 100-year time horizon. Based on the Fifth Assessment
Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,\52\ DOE used
GWP values of 28 for CH4 and 265 for N2O.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\52\ IPCC, 2013: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science
Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment
Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Stocker,
T.F., D. Qin, G.-K. Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A.
Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and P.M. Midgley (eds.)]. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
Chapter 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the on-site operation of gas cooking products requires use
of fossil fuels and results in emissions of CO2 and
NOX at the sites where these appliances are used, DOE also
accounted for the reduction in these site emissions and the associated
upstream emissions due to potential standards. Site emissions were
estimated using emissions intensity factors from an EPA
publication.\53\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\53\ U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Compilation of Air
Pollutant Emission Factors, AP-42, Fifth Edition, Volume I:
Stationary Point and Area Sources (1998) (Available at: http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/ap42/index.html).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EIA prepares the Annual Energy Outlook using NEMS. Each annual
version of NEMS incorporates the projected impacts of existing air
quality regulations on emissions. AEO 2014 generally represents current
legislation and environmental regulations, including recent government
actions, for which implementing regulations were available as of
October 31, 2013.
SO2 emissions from affected electric generating units
(EGUs) are subject to nationwide and regional emissions cap-and-trade
programs. Title IV of the Clean Air Act sets an annual emissions cap on
SO2 for affected EGUs in the 48 contiguous states and the
District of Columbia (DC). SO2 emissions from 28 eastern
states and DC were also limited under the Clean Air Interstate Rule
(CAIR), which created an allowance-based trading program that operates
along with the Title IV program. 70 FR 25162 (May 12, 2005). CAIR was
remanded to the EPA by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit but it remained in effect.\54\ In 2011, EPA issued a
replacement for CAIR, the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR). 76 FR
48208 (Aug. 8, 2011). On August 21, 2012, the D.C. Circuit issued a
decision to vacate CSAPR.\55\ The court ordered EPA to continue
administering CAIR. On April 29, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed
the judgment of the D.C. Circuit and remanded the case for further
proceedings consistent with the Supreme Court's opinion.\56\ On October
23, 2014, the D.C. Circuit lifted the stay of CSAPR.\57\ Pursuant to
this action, CSAPR went into effect (and CAIR ceased to be in effect)
as of January 1, 2015.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\54\ See North Carolina v. EPA, 550 F.3d 1176 (D.C. Cir. 2008);
North Carolina v. EPA, 531 F.3d 896 (D.C. Cir. 2008).
\55\ See EME Homer City Generation, LP v. EPA, 696 F.3d 7, 38
(D.C. Cir. 2012), cert. granted, 81 U.S.L.W. 3567, 81 U.S.L.W. 3696,
81 U.S.L.W. 3702 (U.S. June 24, 2013) (No. 12-1182).
\56\ See EPA v. EME Homer City Generation, 134 S.Ct. 1584, 1610
(U.S. 2014). The Supreme Court held in part that EPA's methodology
for quantifying emissions that must be eliminated in certain States
due to their impacts in other downwind States was based on a
permissible, workable, and equitable interpretation of the Clean Air
Act provision that provides statutory authority for CSAPR.
\57\ See Georgia v. EPA, Order (D.C. Cir. filed October 23,
2014) (No. 11-1302).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because AEO 2014 was prepared prior to the Supreme Court's opinion,
it assumed that CAIR remains a binding regulation through 2040. Thus,
DOE's analysis used emissions factors that assume that CAIR, not CSAPR,
is the regulation in force. However, the difference between CAIR and
CSAPR is not relevant for the purpose of DOE's analysis of emissions
impacts from energy conservation standards.
The attainment of emissions caps is typically flexible among EGUs
and is enforced through the use of emissions allowances and tradable
permits. Beginning in 2016, however, SO2 emissions will
decline significantly as a result of the Mercury and Air Toxics
Standards (MATS) for power plants. 77 FR 9304 (Feb. 16, 2012). In the
final MATS rule, EPA established a standard for hydrogen chloride as a
surrogate for acid gas hazardous air pollutants (HAP), and also
established a standard for SO2 (a non-HAP acid gas) as an
alternative equivalent surrogate standard for acid gas HAP. The same
controls are used to reduce HAP and non-HAP acid gas; thus,
SO2 emissions will be reduced as a result of the control
technologies installed on coal-fired power plants to comply with the
MATS requirements for acid gas. AEO 2014 assumes that, in order to
continue operating, coal plants must have either flue gas
desulfurization or dry sorbent injection systems installed by 2016.
Both technologies, which are used to reduce acid gas emissions, also
reduce SO2 emissions. Under the MATS, emissions will be far
below the cap established by CAIR, so it is unlikely that excess
SO2 emissions allowances resulting from the lower
electricity demand would be needed or used to permit offsetting
increases in SO2 emissions by any regulated EGU. Therefore,
DOE believes that energy efficiency standards will reduce
SO2 emissions in 2016 and beyond.
CAIR established a cap on NOX emissions in 28 eastern
states and the District of Columbia.\58\ Energy conservation standards
are expected to have little effect on NOX emissions in those
states covered by CAIR because excess NOX emissions
allowances resulting from the lower electricity demand could be used to
permit offsetting increases in NOX emissions. However,
standards would be expected to reduce NOX emissions in the
states not affected by the caps, so DOE estimated NOX
emissions reductions from the standards considered in this proposed
rule for these states.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\58\ CSAPR also applies to NOX, and it would
supersede the regulation of NOX under CAIR. As stated
previously, the current analysis assumes that CAIR, not CSAPR, is
the regulation in force. The difference between CAIR and CSAPR with
regard to DOE's analysis of NOX is slight.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The MATS limit mercury emissions from power plants, but they do not
include emissions caps. DOE estimated mercury emissions reduction using
emissions factors based on AEO 2014, which incorporates the MATS.
L. Monetizing Carbon Dioxide and Other Emissions Impacts
As part of the development of this rule, DOE considered the
estimated monetary benefits from the reduced emissions of
CO2 and NOX that are expected to result from each
of the TSLs considered. In order to make this calculation similar to
the calculation of the NPV of consumer benefit, DOE considered the
reduced emissions expected to result over the lifetime of equipment
shipped in the forecast period for each TSL. This section summarizes
the basis for the monetary values used for each of these emissions and
presents the values considered in this rulemaking.
DOE is relying on a set of values for the SCC that was developed by
an interagency process. A summary of the basis for these values is
provided below, and a more detailed description of the methodologies
used is provided as an appendix to chapter 14 of the NOPR TSD.
1. Social Cost of Carbon
The SCC is an estimate of the monetized damages associated with an
incremental increase in carbon emissions in a given year. It is
intended
[[Page 33066]]
to include (but is not limited to) changes in net agricultural
productivity, human health, property damages from increased flood risk,
and the value of ecosystem services. Estimates of the SCC are provided
in dollars per metric ton of carbon dioxide. A domestic SCC value is
meant to reflect the value of damages in the United States resulting
from a unit change in carbon dioxide emissions, while a global SCC
value is meant to reflect the value of damages worldwide.
Under section 1(b)(6) of Executive Order 12866, ``Regulatory
Planning and Review,'' 58 FR 51735 (Oct. 4, 1993), agencies must, to
the extent permitted by law, assess both the costs and the benefits of
the intended regulation and, recognizing that some costs and benefits
are difficult to quantify, propose or adopt a regulation only upon a
reasoned determination that the benefits of the intended regulation
justify its costs. The purpose of the SCC estimates presented here is
to allow agencies to incorporate the monetized social benefits of
reducing CO2 emissions into cost-benefit analyses of
regulatory actions. The estimates are presented with an acknowledgement
of the many uncertainties involved and with a clear understanding that
they should be updated over time to reflect increasing knowledge of the
science and economics of climate impacts.
As part of the interagency process that developed the SCC
estimates, technical experts from numerous agencies met on a regular
basis to consider public comments, explore the technical literature in
relevant fields, and discuss key model inputs and assumptions. The main
objective of this process was to develop a range of SCC values using a
defensible set of input assumptions grounded in the existing scientific
and economic literatures. In this way, key uncertainties and model
differences transparently and consistently inform the range of SCC
estimates used in the rulemaking process.
a. Monetizing Carbon Dioxide Emissions
When attempting to assess the incremental economic impacts of
carbon dioxide emissions, the analyst faces a number of challenges. A
report from the National Research Council points out that any
assessment will suffer from uncertainty, speculation, and lack of
information about: (1) Future emissions of greenhouse gases; (2) the
effects of past and future emissions on the climate system; (3) the
impact of changes in climate on the physical and biological
environment; and (4) the translation of these environmental impacts
into economic damages.\59\ As a result, any effort to quantify and
monetize the harms associated with climate change will raise serious
questions of science, economics, and ethics and should be viewed as
provisional.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\59\ National Research Council. Hidden Costs of Energy: Unpriced
Consequences of Energy Production and Use. National Academies Press:
Washington, DC (2009).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the limits of both quantification and monetization, SCC
estimates can be useful in estimating the social benefits of reducing
carbon dioxide emissions. The agency can estimate the benefits from
reduced (or costs from increased) emissions in any future year by
multiplying the change in emissions in that year by the SCC values
appropriate for that year. The NPV of the benefits can then be
calculated by multiplying each of these future benefits by an
appropriate discount factor and summing across all affected years.
It is important to emphasize that the interagency process is
committed to updating these estimates as the science and economic
understanding of climate change and its impacts on society improves
over time. In the meantime, the interagency group will continue to
explore the issues raised by this analysis and consider public comments
as part of the ongoing interagency process.
b. Development of Social Cost of Carbon Values
In 2009, an interagency process was initiated to offer a
preliminary assessment of how best to quantify the benefits from
reducing carbon dioxide emissions. To ensure consistency in how
benefits are evaluated across Federal agencies, the Administration
sought to develop a transparent and defensible method, specifically
designed for the rulemaking process, to quantify avoided climate change
damages from reduced CO2 emissions. The interagency group
did not undertake any original analysis. Instead, it combined SCC
estimates from the existing literature to use as interim values until a
more comprehensive analysis could be conducted. The outcome of the
preliminary assessment by the interagency group was a set of five
interim values: global SCC estimates for 2007 (in 2006$) of $55, $33,
$19, $10, and $5 per metric ton of CO2. These interim values
represented the first sustained interagency effort within the U.S.
government to develop an SCC for use in regulatory analysis. The
results of this preliminary effort were presented in several proposed
and final rules.
c. Current Approach and Key Assumptions
After the release of the interim values, the interagency group
reconvened on a regular basis to generate improved SCC estimates.
Specifically, the group considered public comments and further explored
the technical literature in relevant fields. The interagency group
relied on three integrated assessment models commonly used to estimate
the SCC: the FUND, DICE, and PAGE models. These models are frequently
cited in the peer-reviewed literature and were used in the last
assessment of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
Each model was given equal weight in the SCC values that were
developed.
Each model takes a slightly different approach to model how changes
in emissions result in changes in economic damages. A key objective of
the interagency process was to enable a consistent exploration of the
three models while respecting the different approaches to quantifying
damages taken by the key modelers in the field. An extensive review of
the literature was conducted to select three sets of input parameters
for these models: climate sensitivity, socio-economic and emissions
trajectories, and discount rates. A probability distribution for
climate sensitivity was specified as an input into all three models. In
addition, the interagency group used a range of scenarios for the
socio-economic parameters and a range of values for the discount rate.
All other model features were left unchanged, relying on the model
developers' best estimates and judgments.
In 2010, the interagency group selected four sets of SCC values for
use in regulatory analyses.\60\ Three sets of values are based on the
average SCC from three integrated assessment models, at discount rates
of 2.5 percent, 3 percent, and 5 percent. The fourth set, which
represents the 95th-percentile SCC estimate across all three models at
a 3-percent discount rate, is included to represent higher-than-
expected impacts from climate change further out in the tails of the
SCC distribution. The values grow in real terms over time.
Additionally, the interagency group determined that a range of values
from 7 percent to 23 percent should be used to adjust the global SCC to
calculate
[[Page 33067]]
domestic effects,\61\ although preference is given to consideration of
the global benefits of reducing CO2 emissions. Table IV-30
presents the values in the 2010 interagency group report, which is
reproduced in appendix 14-A of the NOPR TSD.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\60\ Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact Analysis Under
Executive Order 12866. Interagency Working Group on Social Cost of
Carbon, United States Government (February 2010) (Available at:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/inforeg/for-agencies/Social-Cost-of-Carbon-for-RIA.pdf).
\61\ It is recognized that this calculation for domestic values
is approximate, provisional, and highly speculative. There is no a
priori reason why domestic benefits should be a constant fraction of
net global damages over time.
Table IV-30--Annual SCC Values From 2010 Interagency Report, 2010-2050
[In 2007 dollars per metric ton CO2]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discount rate %
---------------------------------------------------------------
5 3 2.5 3
Year ---------------------------------------------------------------
95th
Average Average Average Percentile
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2010............................................ 4.7 21.4 35.1 64.9
2015............................................ 5.7 23.8 38.4 72.8
2020............................................ 6.8 26.3 41.7 80.7
2025............................................ 8.2 29.6 45.9 90.4
2030............................................ 9.7 32.8 50.0 100.0
2035............................................ 11.2 36.0 54.2 109.7
2040............................................ 12.7 39.2 58.4 119.3
2045............................................ 14.2 42.1 61.7 127.8
2050............................................ 15.7 44.9 65.0 136.2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The SCC values used were generated using the most recent versions
of the three integrated assessment models that have been published in
the peer-reviewed literature.\62\ Table IV-31 shows the updated sets of
SCC estimates from the 2013 interagency update in five-year increments
from 2010 to 2050. Appendix 14-B of the NOPR TSD provides the full set
of values. The central value that emerges is the average SCC across
models at 3-percent discount rate. However, for purposes of capturing
the uncertainties involved in regulatory impact analysis, the
interagency group emphasizes the importance of including all four sets
of SCC values.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\62\ Technical Update of the Social Cost of Carbon for
Regulatory Impact Analysis Under Executive Order 12866. Interagency
Working Group on Social Cost of Carbon, United States Government
(May 2013; revised November 2013) (Available at: http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/assets/inforeg/technical-update-social-cost-of-carbon-for-regulator-impact-analysis.pdf).
Table IV-31--Annual SCC Values From 2013 Interagency Update, 2010-2050
[In 2007 dollars per metric ton CO2]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discount rate %
---------------------------------------------------------------
5 3 2.5 3
Year ---------------------------------------------------------------
95th
Average Average Average Percentile
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2010............................................ 11 32 51 89
2015............................................ 11 37 57 109
2020............................................ 12 43 64 128
2025............................................ 14 47 69 143
2030............................................ 16 52 75 159
2035............................................ 19 56 80 175
2040............................................ 21 61 86 191
2045............................................ 24 66 92 206
2050............................................ 26 71 97 220
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AHAM suggested that DOE rely on the 2010 estimates for SCC until it
has resolved all comments on the derivation of the SCC estimates from
the 2013 report. (AHAM, STD No. 9, at p. 8) The 2013 report provides an
update of the SCC estimates based solely on the latest peer-reviewed
version of the models, replacing model versions that were developed up
to ten years ago in a rapidly evolving field. It does not revisit other
assumptions with regard to the discount rate, reference case socio-
economic and emission scenarios, or equilibrium climate sensitivity.
Improvements in the way damages are modeled are confined to those that
have been incorporated into the latest versions of the models by the
developers themselves in the peer-reviewed literature. Given the above,
using the 2010 estimates would be inconsistent with DOE's objective of
using the best available information in its analyses.
It is important to recognize that a number of key uncertainties
remain, and that current SCC estimates should be treated as provisional
and revisable since they will evolve with improved scientific and
economic understanding. The interagency group also recognizes that the
existing models are imperfect and incomplete. The National Research
Council report mentioned above points out that there is tension between
the goal of producing quantified estimates of the economic damages from
an incremental ton of carbon and the limits of existing efforts to
model these effects. There are a number of analytical challenges that
are being addressed by the research community, including research
programs housed in many of the Federal agencies participating in the
[[Page 33068]]
interagency process to estimate the SCC. The interagency group intends
to periodically review and revise those estimates to reflect increasing
knowledge of the science and economics of climate impacts, as well as
improvements in modeling.
In summary, in considering the potential global benefits resulting
from reduced CO2 emissions, DOE used the values from the
2013 interagency report, adjusted to 2014$ using the Gross Domestic
Product price deflator. For each of the four SCC cases specified, the
values used for emissions in 2015 were $12.2, $41.2, $63.4, and $121
per metric ton avoided (values expressed in 2014$). DOE derived values
after 2050 using the relevant growth rates for the 2040-2050 period in
the interagency update.
DOE multiplied the CO2 emissions reduction estimated for
each year by the SCC value for that year in each of the four cases. To
calculate a present value of the stream of monetary values, DOE
discounted the values in each of the four cases using the specific
discount rate that had been used to obtain the SCC values in each case.
DOE acknowledges the limitations of the SCC estimates, which are
discussed in detail in the 2010 interagency group report. Specifically,
uncertainties in the assumptions regarding climate sensitivity, as well
as other model inputs such as economic growth and emissions
trajectories, are discussed and the reasons for the specific input
assumptions chosen are explained. However, the three integrated
assessment models used to estimate the SCC are frequently cited in the
peer-reviewed literature and were used in the last assessment of the
IPCC. In addition, new versions of the models that were used in 2013 to
estimate revised SCC values were published in the peer-reviewed
literature (see appendix 14B of the NOPR TSD for discussion). Although
uncertainties remain, the revised estimates that were issued in
November, 2013 are based on the best available scientific information
on the impacts of climate change. The current estimates of the SCC have
been developed over many years, using the best science available, and
with input from the public. In November 2013, OMB announced a new
opportunity for public comment on the interagency technical support
document underlying the revised SCC estimates. 78 FR 70586 (Nov. 26,
2013). OMB is reviewing comments and considering whether further
revisions to the SCC estimates are warranted. DOE stands ready to work
with OMB and the other members of the interagency working group on
further review and revision of the SCC estimates as appropriate.
In addition, it is important to note that the monetized benefits of
carbon emission reductions are one factor that DOE considers in its
evaluation of the economic justification of proposed standards. As
shown in Table I.4, the benefits of these standards in terms of
consumer operating cost savings exceed the incremental costs of the
standards-compliant products. The benefits of CO2 emission
reductions were considered by DOE, but were not determinative in DOE's
decision to adopt these standards.
2. Social Cost of Other Air Pollutants
As noted above, DOE has taken into account how amended energy
conservation standards would reduce site NOX emissions
nationwide and increase power sector NOX emissions in those
22 States not affected by the CAIR. DOE estimated the monetized value
of net NOX emissions reductions resulting from each of the
TSLs considered for this NOPR based on estimates developed by EPA for
2016, 2020, 2025, and 2030.\63\ The values reflect estimated mortality
and morbidity per ton of directly emitted NOX reduced by
electricity generating units. EPA developed estimates using a 3-percent
and a 7-percent discount rate to discount future emissions-related
costs. The values in 2016 are $5,562/ton using a 3-percent discount
rate and $4,920/ton using a 7-percent discount rate (2014$). DOE
extrapolated values after 2030 using the average annual rate of growth
in 2016-2030. DOE multiplied the emissions reduction (tons) in each
year by the associated $/ton values, and then discounted each series
using discount rates of 3 percent and 7 percent as appropriate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\63\ http://www2.epa.gov/benmap/sector-based-pm25-benefit-ton-estimates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE is evaluating appropriate monetization of avoided
SO2 and Hg emissions in energy conservation standards
rulemakings. It has not included monetization of these emissions in the
current analysis. DOE requests comment on its approach to monetizing
emissions reductions for cooking products (see issue 12 in section
VII.E).
M. Utility Impact Analysis
The utility impact analysis estimates several effects on the power
generation industry that would result from the adoption of new or
amended energy conservation standards. In the utility impact analysis,
DOE analyzes the changes in installed electricity capacity and
generation that would result for each TSL. The utility impact analysis
is based on published output from the NEMS associated with AEO 2014.
NEMS produces the AEO reference case as well as a number of side cases
that estimate the economy-wide impacts of changes to energy supply and
demand. DOE uses those published side cases that incorporate
efficiency-related policies to estimate the marginal impacts of reduced
energy demand on the utility sector.\64\ The output of this analysis is
a set of time-dependent coefficients that capture the change in
electricity generation, primary fuel consumption, installed capacity
and power sector emissions due to a unit reduction in demand for a
given end use. These coefficients are multiplied by the stream of
energy savings calculated in the NIA to provide estimates of selected
utility impacts of new or amended energy conservation standards.
Chapter 15 of the NOPR TSD describes the utility impact analysis in
further detail.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\64\ DOE did not use AEO 2015 for the analysis because it does
not provide the side cases that DOE uses to derive marginal impact
factors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
N. Employment Impact Analysis
Employment impacts from new or amended energy conservation
standards include direct and indirect impacts. Direct employment
impacts are any changes in the number of employees of manufacturers of
the equipment subject to standards; the MIA addresses those impacts.
Indirect employment impacts are changes in national employment that
occur due to the shift in expenditures and capital investment caused by
the purchase and operation of more efficient equipment. Indirect
employment impacts from standards consist of the jobs created or
eliminated in the national economy, other than in the manufacturing
sector being regulated, due to: (1) Reduced spending by end users on
energy; (2) reduced spending on new energy supply by the utility
industry; (3) increased consumer spending on the purchase of new
equipment; and (4) the effects of those three factors throughout the
economy.
One method for assessing the possible effects on the demand for
labor of such shifts in economic activity is to compare sector
employment statistics developed by the Labor Department's Bureau of
Labor Statistics (BLS). BLS regularly publishes its estimates of the
number of jobs per million dollars of economic activity in different
sectors of the economy, as well as the jobs created elsewhere in the
economy by this same economic activity. Data from BLS
[[Page 33069]]
indicate that expenditures in the utility sector generally create fewer
jobs (both directly and indirectly) than expenditures in other sectors
of the economy. There are many reasons for these differences, including
wage differences and the fact that the utility sector is more capital-
intensive and less labor-intensive than other sectors. Energy
conservation standards have the effect of reducing consumer utility
bills. Because reduced consumer expenditures for energy likely lead to
increased expenditures in other sectors of the economy, the general
effect of efficiency standards is to shift economic activity from a
less labor-intensive sector (i.e., the utility sector) to more labor-
intensive sectors (e.g., the retail and service sectors). Thus, based
on the BLS data alone, DOE believes net national employment may
increase because of shifts in economic activity resulting from amended
standards.
DOE estimated indirect national employment impacts for the standard
levels considered in this NOPR using an input/output model of the U.S.
economy called Impact of Sector Energy Technologies, Version 3.1.1
(ImSET).\65\ ImSET is a special-purpose version of the ``U.S. Benchmark
National Input-Output'' (I-O) model, which was designed to estimate the
national employment and income effects of energy-saving technologies.
The ImSET software includes a computer-based I-O model having
structural coefficients that characterize economic flows among the 187
sectors most relevant to industrial, commercial, and residential
building energy use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\65\ M.J. Scott, O.V. Livingston, P.J. Balducci, J.M. Roop, and
R.W. Schultz, ImSET 3.1: Impact of Sector Energy Technologies, PNNL-
18412, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (2009) (Available at:
www.pnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-18412.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE notes that ImSET is not a general equilibrium forecasting
model, and understands the uncertainties involved in projecting
employment impacts, especially changes in the later years of the
analysis. Because ImSET does not incorporate price changes, the
employment effects predicted by ImSET may over-estimate actual job
impacts over the long run. Therefore, DOE generated results for near-
term timeframes, where these uncertainties are reduced. For more
details on the employment impact analysis, see chapter 16 of the NOPR
TSD.
V. Analytical Results
The following section addresses the results from DOE's analyses
with respect to potential energy conservation standards for
conventional ovens. It addresses the TSLs examined by DOE and the
projected impacts of each of these levels if adopted as energy
conservation standards for conventional ovens. Additional details
regarding DOE's analyses are contained in the NOPR TSD supporting this
notice.
A. Trial Standard Levels
DOE analyzed the benefits and burdens of three TSLs for
conventional ovens. These TSLs were developed using combinations of
efficiency levels for the product classes analyzed by DOE. DOE presents
the results for those TSLs in this proposed rule. The results for all
efficiency levels that DOE analyzed are in the NOPR TSD.
Table V-1. and Table V-2. presents the TSLs and the corresponding
efficiency levels for conventional ovens.\66\ TSL 3 represents the
maximum technologically feasible (``max-tech'') improvements in energy
efficiency for all product classes. TSL 2 comprises efficiency levels
for all product classes providing the maximum NES with maximum NPV. TSL
1 was configured with standby levels with maximum NES.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\66\ For the conventional oven product classes, the efficiency
levels are based on an oven with a cavity volume of 3.9 ft. As
discussed in section I.A.1.c, DOE developed slopes and intercepts to
characterize the relationship between IEAC and cavity volume for
each efficiency level.
Table V-1--Summary of Trial Standard Levels for Ovens, Electric
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric standard ovens, Electric standard ovens, Electric self-clean Electric self-clean
free-standing built-in/slide-in ovens, free-standing ovens, built-in/slide-in
TSL --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Efficiency IAEC (kWh/ Efficiency IAEC (kWh/ Efficiency IAEC (kWh/ Efficiency IAEC (kWh/
level yr) level yr) level yr) level yr)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................. 1 284.6 1 291.4 1 345.1 1 351.0
2.............................................. 3 259.2 3 265.4 1 345.1 1 351.0
3.............................................. 7 207.3 7 212.2 4 278.1 4 282.9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-2--Summary of Trial Standard Levels for Ovens, Gas
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gas standard ovens, Gas standard ovens, Gas self-clean ovens, Gas self-clean ovens,
free-standing built-in/slide-in free-standing built-in/slide-in
TSL --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Efficiency IAEC (kBtu/ Efficiency IAEC (kBtu/ Efficiency IAEC (kBtu/ Efficiency IAEC (kBtu/
level yr) level yr) level yr) level yr)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................. Baseline 2,118.2 Baseline 2,128.1 1 1,848.2 1 1,858.0
2.............................................. 4 1,414.8 4 1,421.5 2 1,668.7 2 1,677.5
3.............................................. 7 1,347.0 7 1,353.3 4 1,591.0 4 1,599.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, Table V-3 to Table V-6 illustrate the design and
performance related changes that are assumed for each TSL for each
product class.
[[Page 33070]]
Table V-3--Summary of Trial Standard Levels and Design Options for Ovens, Electric Standard
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric standard ovens, free- Electric standard ovens, built-in/
standing slide-in
TSL ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Efficiency Efficiency
level Design option level Design option
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................... 1 1. SMPS. 1 1. SMPS.
2................................... 3 1. SMPS. 3 1. SMPS.
2. Reduced Vent Rate. 2. Reduced Vent Rate.
3. Improved Insulation. 3. Improved
Insulation.
3................................... 7 1. SMPS. 7 1. SMPS.
2. Reduced Vent Rate. 2. Reduced Vent Rate.
3. Improved Insulation. 3. Improved
Insulation.
4. Improved Door Seals. 4. Improved Door
Seals.
5. Forced Convection. 5. Forced Convection.
6. Oven Separator. 6. Oven Separator.
7. Reduced Conduction 7. Reduced Conduction
Losses. Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-4--Summary of Trial Standard Levels and Design Options for Ovens, Electric Self-Clean
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric self-clean ovens, free- Electric self-clean ovens, built-in/
standing slide-in
TSL ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Efficiency Efficiency
level Design option level Design option
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................... 1 1. SMPS. 1 1. SMPS.
2................................... 1 1. SMPS. 1 1. SMPS.
3................................... 4 1. SMPS. 4 1. SMPS.
2. Forced Convection. 2. Forced Convection.
3. Oven Separator. 3. Oven Separator.
4. Reduced Conduction 4. Reduced Conduction
Losses. Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-5--Summary of Trial Standard Levels and Design Options for Ovens, Gas Standard
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gas standard ovens, free-standing Gas standard ovens, built-in/slide-
--------------------------------------- in
TSL ------------------------------------
Efficiency Design option Efficiency
level level Design option
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................... Baseline ........................ Baseline ......................
2................................... 4 1. Optimized Burner/ 4 1. Optimized Burner/
Cavity. Cavity.
2. SMPS. 2. SMPS.
3. Electric Spark 3. Electric Spark
Ignition. Ignition.
4. Improved Insulation. 4. Improved
Insulation.
3................................... 7 1. SMPS. 7 1. SMPS.
2. Optimized Burner/ 2. Optimized Burner/
Cavity. Cavity.
3. Electric Spark 3. Electric Spark
Ignition. Ignition.
4. Improved Insulation. 4. Improved
5. Improved Door Seals. Insulation.
6. Forced Convection. 5. Improved Door
7. Reduced Conduction Seals.
Losses. 6. Forced Convection.
7. Reduced Conduction
Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-6--Summary of Trial Standard Levels and Design Options for Ovens, Gas Self-Clean
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gas self-clean ovens, free-standing Gas self-clean ovens, built-in/
--------------------------------------- slide-in
TSL ------------------------------------
Efficiency Design option Efficiency
level level Design option
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................... 1 1. SMPS. 1 1. SMPS.
2................................... 2 1. SMPS. 2 1. SMPS.
2. Electronic Spark 2. Electronic Spark
Ignition. Ignition.
3................................... 4 1. SMPS. 4 1. SMPS.
2. Electronic Spark 2. Electronic Spark
Ignition. Ignition.
3. Forced Convection. 3. Forced Convection.
4. Reduced Conduction 4. Reduced Conduction
Losses. Losses.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 33071]]
B. Economic Justification and Energy Savings
1. Economic Impacts on Individual Consumers
DOE analyzed the economic impacts on conventional oven consumers by
looking at the effects potential amended standards would have on the
LCC and PBP. DOE also examined the impacts of potential standards on
consumer subgroups. These analyses are discussed below.
a. Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Period
In general, higher-efficiency products affect consumers in two
ways: (1) Purchase price increases, and (2) operating costs decrease.
Inputs used for calculating the LCC and PBP include total installed
costs (i.e., product price plus installation costs), and operating
costs (i.e., annual energy savings, energy prices, energy price trends,
repair costs, and maintenance costs). The LCC calculation also uses
product lifetime and a discount rate. Chapter 8 of the NOPR TSD
provides detailed information on the LCC and PBP analyses.
Table V-7 through Table V-22 show the LCC and PBP results for all
efficiency levels considered for each conventional oven product class.
In the first of each pair of tables, the simple payback is measured
relative to the baseline product. In the second table, the LCC savings
are measured relative to the base-case efficiency distribution in the
compliance year (see section IV.F.8 of this notice).
Table V-7--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC1 Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... 1 $558 $16 $191 $748 0.9
2....................................................... 3 568 15 174 742 4.0
3....................................................... 7 653 12 142 795 7.5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
Table V-8--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC1 Electric Standard
Ovens, Free-Standing
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................................. 1 0 $13.96
2.............................................................. 3 12 15.18
3.............................................................. 7 82 (37.60)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-9--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC2 Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average Costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... 1 $584 $16 $190 $775 0.9
2....................................................... 3 594 15 174 768 4.0
3....................................................... 7 680 12 142 821 17.5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
[[Page 33072]]
Table V-10--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC2 Electric Standard
Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................................. 1 0 $14.11
2.............................................................. 3 12 15.25
3.............................................................. 7 82 (37.64)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-11--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC3 Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,2..................................................... 1 $602 $22 $251 $853 0.9
3....................................................... 4 686 18 211 897 18.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
Table V-12--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC3 Electric Self-Clean
Ovens, Free-Standing
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,2............................................................ 1 0 $14.10
3.............................................................. 4 76 (27.79)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-13--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC4 Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,2..................................................... 1 $628 $22 $252 $880 0.9
3....................................................... 4 712 18 212 924 18.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
[[Page 33073]]
Table V-14 Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC4 Electric Self-Clean
Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1,2............................................................ 1 0 $14.20
3.............................................................. 4 76 (27.80)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-15--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC5 Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... Baseline $602 $20 $600 $1,202 ..............
2....................................................... 4 619 9 277 896 1.7
3....................................................... 7 656 9 277 933 5.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
Table V-16--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC5 Gas Standard Ovens,
Free-Standing
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................................. Baseline 0% ...............
2.............................................................. 4 0 $289.73
3.............................................................. 7 24 178.91
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-17--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC6 Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... Baseline $628 $20 $600 $1,228 ..............
2....................................................... 4 645 9 277 922 1.7
3....................................................... 7 682 9 277 959 5.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
[[Page 33074]]
Table V-18--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC6 Gas Standard Ovens,
Built-In/Slide-In
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................................. Baseline 0 ...............
2.............................................................. 4 0 $289.77
3.............................................................. 7 24 178.92
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-19--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC7 Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... 1 $718 $20 $612 $1,329 0.8
2....................................................... 2 726 13 334 1,060 1.2
3....................................................... 4 762 13 333 1,094 5.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
Table V-20--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC7 Gas Self-Clean Ovens,
Free-Standing
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
--------------------------------
Percentage of Average
Efficiency consumers savings *
TSL level that ----------------
experience
---------------- 2014$
Net cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.............................................................. 1 0 $18.02
2.............................................................. 2 0 282.80
3.............................................................. 4 27 165.73
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
Table V-21--Average LCC and PBP Results by Efficiency Level for PC8 Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average costs 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Efficiency First year's Lifetime Simple
level Installed cost operating operating LCC payback years
cost cost
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... 1 $744 $20 $612 $1,355 0.8
2....................................................... 2 752 13 334 1,086 1.2
3....................................................... 4 788 13 333 1,120 5.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The results for each TSL are calculated assuming that all consumers use products at that efficiency level. The PBP is measured relative to the
baseline product.
[[Page 33075]]
Table V-22--Average LCC Savings Relative to the Base-Case Efficiency Distribution for PC8 Gas Self-Clean Ovens,
Built-In/Slide-In
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Life-cycle cost savings
-------------------------------
Percent of Average
TSL Efficiency consumers that savings *
level experience ---------------
----------------
Net cost 2014$
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1............................................................... 1 0 $18.03
2............................................................... 2 0 282.85
3............................................................... 4 27 165.75
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The calculation does not include households with zero LCC savings (no impact).
b. Consumer Subgroup Analysis
As described in section IV.I of this notice, DOE determined the
impact of the considered TSLs on low-income households and senior-only
households. Table V-23 through Table V-30 compare the average LCC
savings and PBP at each efficiency level for the two consumer
subgroups, along with the average LCC savings for the entire sample. In
most cases, the average LCC savings and PBP for low-income households
and senior-only households at the considered efficiency levels are not
substantially different from the average for all households. Chapter 11
of the NOPR TSD presents the complete LCC and PBP results for the
subgroups.
Table V-23--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households for PC1 Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.................................................... $13.88 $14.00 $13.96 0.9 0.9 0.9
2.................................................... 18.70 12.28 15.18 3.6 4.4 4.0
3.................................................... (28.75) (45.09) (37.60) 14.9 20.6 17.5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-24--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households for PC2 Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.................................................... $14.06 $14.11 $14.11 0.9 0.9 0.9
2.................................................... 18.79 12.34 15.25 3.6 4.4 4.0
3.................................................... (28.80) (45.13) (37.64) 14.9 20.6 17.5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-25--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households PC3 Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1, 2................................................. $13.98 $14.19 $14.10 0.9 0.9 0.9
3.................................................... (18.98) (32.84) (27.79) 15.2 20.3 18.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 33076]]
Table V-26--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households PC4 Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1, 2................................................. $14.11 $14.27 $14.20 0.9 0.9 0.9
3.................................................... (18.99) (32.84) (27.80) 15.2 20.3 18.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-27--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households PC5 Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 .............. .............. ..............
2....................................................... 314.79 282.03 289.73 1.4 1.8 1.7
3....................................................... 197.33 173.10 178.91 4.4 5.7 5.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-28--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households for PC6 Gas Standard Oven, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 .............. .............. ..............
2....................................................... 314.84 282.07 289.77 1.4 1.8 1.7
3....................................................... 197.34 173.11 178.92 4.4 5.7 5.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-29--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households for PC7 Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... $17.28 $18.39 $18.02 0.8 0.7 0.8
2....................................................... 298.61 278.34 282.80 1.0 1.3 1.2
3....................................................... 176.87 162.47 165.73 4.7 5.7 5.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-30--Comparison of Average LCC Savings for Consumer Subgroups and All Households for PC8 Gas Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/Slide-In
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average life-cycle cost savings (2014$) Simple payback period (years)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL Low-income Senior-only Low-income Senior-only
households households All households households households All households
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1....................................................... $17.30 $18.40 $18.03 0.8 0.7 0.8
2....................................................... 298.68 278.39 282.85 1.0 1.3 1.2
3....................................................... 176.89 162.48 165.75 4.7 5.7 5.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
c. Rebuttable Presumption Payback
As discussed above, EPCA provides a rebuttable presumption that an
energy conservation standard is economically justified if the increased
purchase cost for a product that meets the standard is less than three
times the value of the first-year energy savings resulting from the
standard. In calculating a rebuttable presumption payback period for
the considered standard levels, DOE used discrete values rather than
distributions for input values, and, as required by EPCA, based the
energy use calculation on the DOE test procedures for conventional
cooking products. As a result, DOE calculated a single rebuttable
presumption payback value,
[[Page 33077]]
and not a distribution of payback periods, for each efficiency level.
Table V-31 presents the rebuttable-presumption payback periods for
the considered TSLs. While DOE examined the rebuttable-presumption
criterion, it considered whether the standard levels considered for
this rulemaking are economically justified through a more detailed
analysis of the economic impacts of those levels pursuant to 42 U.S.C.
6295(o)(2)(B)(i). The results of that analysis serve as the basis for
DOE to evaluate the economic justification for a potential standard
level (thereby supporting or rebutting the results of any preliminary
determination of economic justification).
Table V-31--Conventional Ovens: Rebuttable PBPs
(Years)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Product class --------------------------------------
1 2 3
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, 0.9 2.3 8.5
Free-Standing...................
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, 0.8 2.3 8.3
Built-In/Slide-In...............
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, 0.9 0.9 8.4
Free-Standing...................
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, 0.9 0.9 8.3
Built-In/Slide-In...............
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free- ........... 2.4 7.0
Standing........................
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/ ........... 2.4 6.9
Slide-In........................
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 3.1 4.6 15.3
Standing........................
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built- 3.1 4.6 15.2
In/Slide-In.....................
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Economic Impacts on Manufacturers
DOE performed an MIA to estimate the impact of new and amended
energy conservation standards on manufacturers of residential
conventional ovens. The following sections describe the expected
impacts on residential conventional oven manufacturers at each TSL.
Chapter 12 of this NOPR TSD explains the MIA in further detail.
a. Industry Cash-Flow Analysis Results
Table V-32 through Table V-33 depict the financial impacts
(represented by changes in INPV) of new and amended energy conservation
standards on residential conventional oven manufacturers as well as the
conversion costs that DOE estimates manufacturers would incur at each
TSL. To evaluate the range of cash flow impacts on the residential
conventional oven industry, DOE modeled two markup scenarios that
correspond to the range of anticipated market responses to new and
amended standards. Each markup scenario results in a unique set of cash
flows and corresponding industry values at each TSL.
In the following discussion, the INPV results refer to the
difference in industry value between the base case and the standards
case that result from the sum of discounted cash flows from the base
year (2015) through the end of the analysis period. The results also
discuss the difference in cash flows between the base case and the
standards case in the year before the compliance date for new and
amended energy conservation standards. This figure represents the size
of the required conversion costs relative to the cash flow generated by
the residential conventional oven industry in the absence of new and
amended energy conservation standards. In the engineering analysis, DOE
enumerates common technology options that achieve the efficiencies for
each of the product classes. For descriptions of these technology
options and the required efficiencies at each TSL, see section IV.C and
section V.A respectively of this NOPR.
To assess the upper (less severe) end of the range of potential
impacts on residential conventional oven manufacturers, DOE modeled a
preservation of gross margin markup scenario. This scenario assumes
that in the standards case, manufacturers would be able to pass along
all the higher production costs required for more efficient products to
their consumers. Specifically, the industry would be able to maintain
its average base case gross margin (as a percentage of revenue) despite
the higher product costs in the standards case. In general, the larger
the product price increases, the less likely manufacturers are to
achieve the cash flow from operations calculated in this scenario
because it is less likely that manufacturers would be able to fully
mark up these larger cost increases.
To assess the lower (more severe) end of the range of potential
impacts on the residential conventional oven manufacturers, DOE modeled
the preservation of operating profit markup scenario. This scenario
represents the lower end of the range of potential impacts on
manufacturers because no additional operating profit is earned on the
higher product costs, eroding profit margins as a percentage of total
revenue.
Table V-32 and Table V-33 present the projected results for
residential conventional ovens under the preservation of gross margin
and preservation of operating profit markup scenarios. DOE examined
results for all product classes together since most manufacturers
produce both gas and electric ovens.
Table V-32--Manufacturer Impact Analysis for Residential Conventional Ovens--Preservation of Gross Margin Markup
Scenario
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Units Base case --------------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INPV........................ (2014$ 783.5 762.8 702.6 140.6
millions).
Change in INPV.............. (2014$ .............. (20.7) (80.9) (642.9)
millions).
(%)............ .............. (2.6) (10.3) (82.0)
Product Conversion Costs.... (2014$ .............. 4.3 67.9 401.5
millions).
Capital Conversion Costs.... (2014$ .............. 9.0 42.0 528.0
millions).
[[Page 33078]]
Total Conversion Costs...... (2014$ .............. 13.3 109.9 929.5
millions).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* DOE presents a range of potential employment impacts. Numbers in parentheses indicate negative numbers.
Table V-33--Manufacturer Impact Analysis for Residential Conventional Ovens--Preservation of Operating Profit
Markup Scenario
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Units Base case --------------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INPV........................ (2014$ 783.5 762.1 697.1 56.0
millions).
Change in INPV.............. (2014$ .............. (21.4) (86.4) (727.5)
millions).
(%)............ .............. (2.7) (11.0) (92.9)
Product Conversion Costs.... (2014$ .............. 4.3 67.9 401.5
millions).
Capital Conversion Costs.... (2014$ .............. 9.0 42.0 528.0
millions).
Total Conversion Costs...... (2014$ .............. 13.3 109.9 929.5
millions).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL 1 sets the efficiency level at baseline for two product classes
(gas standard ovens, free-standing; and gas standard ovens, built-in/
slide-in), and EL 1 for six product classes (electric standard ovens,
free-standing; electric standard ovens, built-in/slide-in; electric
self-clean ovens, free-standing; electric self-clean ovens, built-in/
slide-in; gas self-clean ovens, free-standing; and gas self-clean
ovens, built-in/slide-in). At TSL 1, DOE estimates impacts on INPV
range from -$21.4 million to -$20.7 million, or a change in INPV of -
2.7 percent to -2.6 percent. At TSL 1, industry free cash flow
(operating cash flow minus capital expenditures) is estimated to
decrease to $52.1 million, or a drop of 14.3 percent, compared to the
base-case value of $60.8 million in 2018, the year leading up to new
and amended energy conservation standards.
Percentage impacts on INPV are slightly negative at TSL 1. DOE does
not anticipate that manufacturers would lose a significant portion of
their INPV at this TSL. DOE projects that in the expected year of
compliance (2019), 100 percent of gas standard oven, free-standing
shipments; and gas standard oven, built-in/slide-in shipments would
meet or exceed the efficiency levels required at TSL 1. Meanwhile in
2019, 60 percent of electric standard oven, free-standing shipments; 60
percent of electric standard oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 53
percent of electric self-clean oven, free-standing shipments; 53
electric self-clean oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 52 percent of
gas self-clean oven, free-standing shipments; and 52 percent of gas
self-clean oven, built-in/slide-in shipments would meet the efficiency
levels at TSL 1.
DOE expects conversion costs to be small at TSL 1 because the
design changes prescribed at this TSL only affect standby mode power
consumption and do not apply to active mode power consumption. DOE
expects residential conventional oven manufacturers to incur $4.3
million in product conversion costs for product redesigns that will
convert residential conventional ovens from using linear power supply
to switch mode power supply to reduce standby power consumption. DOE
expects $9.0 million in capital conversion costs for manufacturers to
upgrade production lines and retool equipment associated with achieving
this reduction in standby power.
At TSL 1, under the preservation of gross margin markup scenario,
the shipment-weighted average MPC increases very slightly by
approximately 0.1 percent relative to the base-case MPC. This extremely
slight price increase is outweighed by the $13.3 million in conversion
costs estimated at TSL 1, resulting in slightly negative INPV impacts
at TSL 1 under the preservation of gross margin markup scenario.
Under the preservation of operating profit markup scenario,
manufacturers earn the same nominal operating profit as would be earned
in the base case, but manufacturers do not earn additional profit from
their investments. The very slight increase in the shipment weighted-
average MPC is again outweighed by a slightly lower average
manufacturer markup (slightly smaller than the 1.20 manufacturer markup
used in the base case) and $13.3 million in conversion costs, resulting
in slightly negative impacts at TSL 1.
TSL 2 sets the efficiency level at EL 1 for two product classes
(electric self-clean ovens, free-standing; and electric self-clean
ovens, built-in/slide-in), EL 2 for two product classes (gas self-clean
ovens, free-standing; and gas self-clean ovens, built-in/slide-in), EL
3 for two product classes (electric standard ovens, free-standing and
electric standard ovens, built-in/slide-in); and EL 4 for two product
classes (gas standard ovens, free-standing and gas standard ovens,
built-in/slide-in). At TSL 2, DOE estimates impacts on INPV to range
from -$86.4 million to -$80.9 million, or a change in INPV of -11.0
percent to -10.3 percent. At this standard level, industry free cash
flow is estimated to decrease to $17.6, or a drop of 71.0 percent,
compared to the base-case value of $60.8 million in 2018.
Percentage impacts on INPV are moderately negative at TSL 2. While
the $109.9 million in industry conversion costs represent a significant
investment for manufacturers, DOE does not anticipate that
manufacturers would lose a significant portion of their INPV at this
TSL since the base case INPV for manufacturers is slightly less than
$800 million. DOE projects that in 2019, 40 percent of electric
standard oven, free-standing shipments; 40 percent of electric standard
oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 53 percent of electric self-clean
oven, free-standing shipments; 53 percent of electric self-clean oven,
built-in/slide-in shipments; 32 percent of gas standard oven, free-
standing shipments; 32 percent of gas standard oven, built-in/slide-in
shipments; 39 percent of gas
[[Page 33079]]
self-clean oven, free-standing shipments; and 39 percent of gas self-
clean oven, built-in/slide-in shipments would meet or exceed the
efficiency levels at TSL 2.
While DOE expects conversion costs to be a large investment at TSL
2, the much larger base case INPV reduces the overall INPV impact on a
percentage basis at TSL 2. DOE expects that product conversion costs
will significantly rise from $4.3 million at TSL 1 to $67.9 million at
TSL 2 for extensive product redesigns and testing. Capital conversion
costs will also significantly increase from $9.0 million at TSL 1 to
$42.0 million at TSL 2 to upgrade production equipment to accommodate
for added or redesigned features in each product class. The large
conversion costs at TSL 2 are driven by reduce vent rate and improve
insulation in the electric oven product classes, and conversion from
glo-bar to electronic spark ignition systems in the gas oven product
classes.
At TSL 2, under the preservation of gross margin markup scenario,
the shipment weighted-average MPC only slightly increases by 0.9
percent, relative to the base-case MPC. In this scenario, INPV impacts
are moderately negative because manufacturers incur sizable conversion
costs ($109.9 million) and are not able to recover much of those
conversion costs through the slight increase in the shipment weighted-
average MPC at TSL 2.
Under the preservation of operating profit markup scenario, the 0.9
percent shipment weighted-average MPC increase is outweighed by a
slightly lower average manufacturer markup (slightly smaller than the
1.20 manufacturer markup used in the base case) and $109.9 million in
conversion costs, resulting in moderately negative INPV impacts at TSL
2.
TSL 3 sets the efficiency level at max tech for all product
classes. At TSL 3, DOE estimates impacts on INPV to range from -$727.5
million to -$642.9 million, or a change in INPV of -92.9 percent to -
82.0 percent. At this standard level, industry free cash flow is
estimated to decrease by approximately 635.3 percent to -$325.5
million, compared to the base-case value of $60.8 million in 2018.
At TSL 3 conversion costs significantly increase causing free cash
flow to become significantly negative in the year leading up to energy
conservation standards and cause manufacturers to loss a substantial
amount of INPV. Also, the percent change in INPV at TSL 3 is
significantly negative due to the extremely large conversion costs.
Manufacturers at this TSL would have a very difficult time in the short
term to make the necessary investments to comply with new and amended
energy conservation standards prior to when standards went into effect.
Also, the long-term profitability of residential conventional oven
manufacturers could be seriously jeopardized as some manufacturers
would struggle to comply with standards at this TSL.
A high percentage of total shipments will need to be redesigned to
meet efficiency levels prescribed at TSL 3. DOE projects that in 2019,
only 7 percent of electric standard oven, free-standing shipments; 7
percent of electric standard oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 12
percent of electric self-clean oven, free-standing shipments; 12
percent of electric self-clean oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 8
percent of gas standard oven, free-standing shipments; 8 percent of gas
standard oven, built-in/slide-in shipments; 13 percent of gas self-
clean oven, free-standing shipments; and 13 percent of gas self-clean
oven, built-in/slide-in shipments would meet the efficiency levels
prescribed at TSL 3.
DOE expects significant conversion costs at TSL 3, which represents
max tech. DOE expects product conversion costs to significantly
increase from $67.9 million at TSL 2 to $401.5 million at TSL 3. Large
increases in product conversion are due to the vast majority of
shipments needing extensive redesign as well as a significant increase
in testing and recertification for redesigned products. DOE estimates
that capital conversion costs will also significantly increase from
$42.0 million at TSL 2 to $528.0 million at TSL 3. Capital conversion
costs are driven by investments in production equipment to accommodate
for forced convection and reduced conduction losses in the electric and
gas oven product classes.
At TSL 3, under the preservation of gross margin markup scenario,
the shipment weighted-average MPC increases by 12.7 percent relative to
the base-case MPC. In this scenario, INPV impacts are significantly
negative because the $929.5 million in conversion costs significantly
outweighs the modest increase in shipment weighted-average MPC.
Under the preservation of operating profit markup scenario, the
12.7 percent MPC increase is again significantly outweighed by a lower
average manufacturer markup of 1.19 (compared to 1.20 used in the base
case) and $929.5 million in conversion costs, resulting in
significantly negative impacts at TSL 3.
b. Impacts on Employment
DOE quantitatively assessed the impacts of new and amended energy
conservation standards on direct employment. DOE used the GRIM to
estimate the domestic labor expenditures and number of domestic
production workers in the base case and at each TSL from 2019 to 2048.
DOE used statistical data from the U.S. Census Bureau's 2011 Annual
Survey of Manufacturers (ASM), the results of the engineering analysis,
and interviews with manufacturers to determine the inputs necessary to
calculate industry-wide labor expenditures and domestic employment
levels. Labor expenditures involved with the manufacturing of the
products are a function of the labor intensity of the products, the
sales volume, and an assumption that wages remain fixed in real terms
over time.
In the GRIM, DOE used the labor content of the MPCs to estimate the
annual labor expenditures in the industry. DOE used census data and
interviews with manufacturers to estimate the portion of the total
labor expenditures that is attributable to domestic labor.
The production worker estimates in this section cover only workers
up to the line-supervisor level directly involved in fabricating and
assembling a product within a manufacturing facility. Workers
performing services that are closely associated with production
operations, such as material handing with a forklift, are also included
as production labor. DOE's estimates account for production workers who
manufacture only the specific products covered in this rulemaking.
The employment impacts shown in Table V-34 represent the potential
production employment that could result following new and amended
energy conservation standards. The upper bound of the results estimates
the maximum change in the number of production workers that could occur
after compliance with new and amended energy conservation standards
when assuming that manufacturers continue to produce the same scope of
covered products in the same production facilities. It also assumes
that domestic production does not shift to lower labor-cost countries.
Because there is a real risk of manufacturers evaluating sourcing
decisions in response to new and amended energy conservation standards,
the lower bound of the employment results includes the estimated total
number of U.S. production workers in the industry who could lose their
jobs if some or all
[[Page 33080]]
existing production were moved outside of the United States. While the
results present a range of employment impacts following 2019, the
following sections also include qualitative discussions of the
likelihood of negative employment impacts at the various TSLs. Finally,
the employment impacts shown are independent of the employment impacts
from the broader U.S. economy, documented in chapter 17 of the NOPR
TSD.
Using 2011 ASM data and interviews with manufacturers, DOE
estimates that approximately 60 percent of the residential conventional
ovens sold in the United States are manufactured domestically. With
this assumption, DOE estimates that in the absence of new and amended
energy conservation standards, there would be approximately 6,564
domestic production workers involved in manufacturing residential
conventional ovens in 2019. Table V-34 shows the range of the impacts
of new and amended energy conservation standards on U.S. production
workers in the residential conventional oven industry.
Table V-34--Potential Changes in the Total Number of Domestic Residential Conventional Ovens Production Workers
in 2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Base case -----------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Number of Domestic Production Workers in 6,564 6,571 6,622 7,397
2019 (without changes in production locations).
Potential Changes in Domestic Production Workers .............. 0-7 (1,641)-58 (3,282)-833
in 2019 *......................................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* DOE presents a range of potential employment impacts. Numbers in parentheses indicate negative numbers.
At the upper end of the range, all examined TSLs show a slight
increase in the number of domestic employment for residential
conventional ovens. DOE believes that manufacturers would increase
production hiring due to the increase in the labor associated with
adding the required components to make residential conventional ovens
more efficient. However, as previously stated, this assumes that in
addition to hiring more production employees, all existing domestic
production would remain in the United States and not shift to lower
labor-cost countries.
DOE does not expect any significant changes in domestic employment
at TSL 1 because standards would only affect standby mode power
consumption at this TSL. Most manufacturers stated that this TSL would
not require significant design changes and therefore would not have a
significant impact on domestic employment decisions.
At TSLs 2 and 3, all product classes would require higher
efficiency standards and therefore most manufacturers would be required
to make modifications to their existing production lines. However,
manufacturers stated that due to the larger size of most residential
conventional ovens very few units are shipped from far distances such
as Asia or Europe. The vast majority of residential conventional ovens
are currently made in North America. Some manufacturers stated that
even significant changes to production line would not cause them to
shift their production to lower labor-cost countries, as several
manufacturers either only produce residential conventional ovens
domestically or have recently made significant investments to continue
to produce a portion of their residential conventional ovens
domestically. DOE estimates that at most 25 percent of the domestic
labor for residential conventional ovens could move to other countries
in response to the standards proposed at TSL 2. However, DOE believes
this to be a high upper bound estimate as most manufacturers would not
significantly alter their production locations at the efficiency levels
prescribed at TSL 2.
At TSL 3, manufacturers could alter production locations in
response to standards since all product classes would be required to
meet max tech. DOE estimated that at most 50 percent of the domestic
labor for residential conventional ovens could move to other countries
in response to the standards prescribed at TSL 3.
DOE seeks comment on the potential domestic employment impacts to
residential conventional oven manufacturers at the proposed efficiency
levels.
c. Impacts on Manufacturer Capacity
Residential conventional oven manufacturers stated that they did
not anticipate any capacity constraints for the efficiency levels
analyzed for either electric or gas residential conventional ovens.
DOE requests comment on any potential manufacturer capacity
constraints caused by the proposed standards in this NOPR, TSL 2.
d. Impacts on Sub-Groups of Manufacturers
Using average cost assumptions to develop an industry cash-flow
estimate may not be adequate for assessing differential impacts among
manufacturer subgroups. Small manufacturers, niche product
manufacturers, and manufacturers exhibiting cost structures
substantially different from the industry average could be affected
disproportionately. DOE analyzed the impacts to small businesses in
section VI.B and did not identify any other adversely impacted
subgroups for residential conventional ovens for this rulemaking based
on the results of the industry characterization.
DOE requests comment on manufacturer subgroups that DOE should
analyze and/or types of residential conventional oven manufacturers for
the subgroup analysis.
e. Cumulative Regulatory Burden
While any one regulation may not impose a significant burden on
manufacturers, the combined effects of recent or impending regulations
may have serious consequences for some manufacturers, groups of
manufacturers, or an entire industry. Assessing the impact of a single
regulation may overlook this cumulative regulatory burden. In addition
to energy conservation standards, other regulations can significantly
affect manufacturers' financial operations. Multiple regulations
affecting the same manufacturer can strain profits and lead companies
to abandon product lines or markets with lower expected future returns
than competing products. For these reasons, DOE conducts a cumulative
regulatory burden analysis as part of its rulemakings pertaining to
appliance efficiency.
DOE acknowledges that most residential conventional oven
manufacturers also make appliances that are or could be subject to
future
[[Page 33081]]
energy conservation standards implemented by DOE. DOE is aware of
several other energy conservations that could also affect residential
conventional oven manufacturers. These energy conservation standards
include residential refrigerators and freezers that have a compliance
date in 2014,\67\ residential clothes dryers that have a compliance
date in 2015,\68\ residential clothes washers that have a compliance
date in 2015 and in 2018,\69\ and microwave ovens that have a
compliance date in 2016.\70\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\67\ Energy conservation standards for residential
refrigerators, refrigerators-freezers, and freezers became effective
on September 14, 2014. 76 FR 57516 [Docket Number EE-2008-BT-STD-
0012]
\68\ Energy conservation standards for residential clothes
dryers became effective on January 1, 2015. 76 FR 52854 [Docket
Number EERE-2007-BT-STD-0010]
\69\ The first round of prescribed energy conservation standards
for residential clothes washers became effective on March 7, 2015.
The second round of standards will go into effect on January 1,
2018. 77 FR 59719 [Docket Number EERE-2008-BT-STD-0019]
\70\ Energy conservation standards for microwave oven operating
in standby mode and off mode will go into effect on June 17, 2016.
78 FR 36316 [Docket Number EERE-2011-BT-STD-0048]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The compliance years and expected industry conversion costs of
relevant amended energy conservation standards are indicated in Table
V-35.
Table V-35--Compliance Dates and Expected Conversion Expenses of Federal
Energy Conservation Standards Affecting Residential Conventional Oven
Manufacturers
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated total
Federal energy conservation industry
standards Compliance date conversion
expense
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Residential Refrigerators and 2014............... $1,243M (2009$)
Freezers--76 FR 57516
(September 15, 2011).
Residential Clothes Dryers--76 2015............... 95M (2009$)
FR 52854 (April 21, 2011).
Residential Clothes Washers--77 2015--First Round.. 418.5M (2010$)
FR 59719 (May 31, 2012). 2018--Second Round.
Microwave Ovens--78 FR 36316 2016............... 43.1M (2011$)
(June 17, 2013).
Residential Cooking Tops........ 2020 *............. N/A **
------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The date listed is an approximation. The exact date is pending final
DOE action.
** For energy conservation standards awaiting DOE final action. DOE does
not have finalized estimated total industry conversion expenses.
DOE discusses these and other requirements and includes the full
details of the cumulative regulatory burden analysis in chapter 12 of
the NOPR TSD. DOE seeks comment on the compliance costs of any other
regulations residential conventional oven manufacturers must make,
especially if compliance with those regulations is required three years
before or after the estimated compliance date of this proposed standard
(2019).
3. National Impact Analysis
a. Significance of Energy Savings
To estimate the energy savings attributable to potential standards
for conventional ovens, DOE compared the energy consumption of those
products under the base case to their anticipated energy consumption
under each TSL. Table V-36 and Table V-37 present DOE's projections of
the national energy savings for each TSL considered for conventional
ovens. The savings were calculated using the approach described in
section IV.H.1 of this notice.
Table V-36--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative Primary National Energy Savings for Products Shipped in 2019-2048
(quads)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Product class -----------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing..................... 0.023 0.057 0.161
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In................. 0.000 0.001 0.003
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing................... 0.071 0.071 0.372
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In............... 0.021 0.021 0.108
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing.......................... 0.000 0.204 0.209
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In...................... 0.000 0.038 0.039
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing........................ 0.038 0.268 0.282
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In.................... 0.002 0.014 0.014
-----------------------------------------------
Total (All Products)........................................ 0.156 0.673 1.188
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-37--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative FFC National Energy Savings for Products Shipped in 2019-2048
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Product class -----------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing..................... 0.024 0.060 0.168
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In................. 0.000 0.001 0.003
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing................... 0.074 0.074 0.389
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In............... 0.022 0.022 0.113
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing.......................... 0.000 0.216 0.223
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In...................... 0.000 0.041 0.042
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing........................ 0.040 0.281 0.297
[[Page 33082]]
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In.................... 0.002 0.014 0.015
-----------------------------------------------
Total (All Products)........................................ 0.163 0.709 1.251
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OMB Circular A-4 \71\ requires agencies to present analytical
results, including separate schedules of the monetized benefits and
costs that show the type and timing of benefits and costs. Circular A-4
also directs agencies to consider the variability of key elements
underlying the estimates of benefits and costs. For this rulemaking,
DOE undertook a sensitivity analysis using nine, rather than 30, years
of product shipments. The choice of a nine-year period is a proxy for
the timeline in EPCA for the review of certain energy conservation
standards and potential revision of and compliance with such revised
standards.\72\ The review timeframe established in EPCA is generally
not synchronized with the product lifetime, product manufacturing
cycles, or other factors specific to conventional ovens. Thus, such
results are presented for informational purposes only and are not
indicative of any change in DOE's analytical methodology. The NES
sensitivity analysis results based on a nine-year analytical period are
presented in Table V-38. The impacts are counted over the lifetime of
conventional ovens purchased in 2019-2027.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\71\ U.S. Office of Management and Budget, ``Circular A-4:
Regulatory Analysis'' (Sept. 17, 2003) (Available at: http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a004_a-4/).
\72\ Section 325(m) of EPCA requires DOE to review its standards
at least once every 6 years, and requires, for certain products, a
3-year period after any new standard is promulgated before
compliance is required, except that in no case may any new standards
be required within 6 years of the compliance date of the previous
standards. While adding a 6-year review to the 3-year compliance
period adds up to 9 years, DOE notes that it may undertake reviews
at any time within the 6 year period and that the 3-year compliance
date may yield to the 6-year backstop. A 9-year analysis period may
not be appropriate given the variability that occurs in the timing
of standards reviews and the fact that for some consumer products,
the compliance period is 5 years rather than 3 years.
Table V-38--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative FFC National Energy Savings for Products Shipped in 2019-2027
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Product class -----------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing..................... 0.007 0.016 0.046
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In................. 0.000 0.001 0.002
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing................... 0.018 0.018 0.102
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In............... 0.006 0.006 0.033
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing.......................... 0.000 0.070 0.072
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In...................... 0.000 0.013 0.013
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing........................ 0.012 0.081 0.085
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In.................... 0.001 0.004 0.004
-----------------------------------------------
Total (All Products)........................................ 0.044 0.210 0.358
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Net Present Value of Consumer Costs and Benefits
DOE estimated the cumulative NPV to the nation of the total costs
and savings for consumers that would result from particular standard
levels for conventional ovens. In accordance with the OMB's guidelines
on regulatory analysis (OMB Circular A-4, section E, September 17,
2003),\73\ DOE calculated NPV using both a 7-percent and a 3-percent
real discount rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\73\ Available at: www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a004_a-4.
Available at: www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a004_a-4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-39. shows the consumer NPV results for each TSL DOE
considered for conventional ovens. The impacts are counted over the
lifetime of products purchased in 2019-2048.
Table V-39--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative Net Present Value of Consumer Benefits for Products Shipped in 2019-
2048
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
Equipment type Discount rate -----------------------------------------------
% 1 2 3 *
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing.... 3% 0.17 0.31 (0.57)
7% 0.07 0.11 (0.49)
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In 3% 0.00 0.01 (0.02)
7% 0.00 0.00 (0.01)
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing.. 3% 0.52 0.52 (1.02)
7% 0.21 0.21 (0.96)
[[Page 33083]]
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide- 3% 0.16 0.16 (0.32)
In............................................ 7% 0.07 0.07 (0.30)
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing......... 3% 0.00 3.59 3.06
7% 0.00 1.55 1.24
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In..... 3% 0.00 0.67 0.57
7% 0.00 0.29 0.23
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing....... 3% 0.28 5.48 4.72
7% 0.12 2.31 1.87
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In... 3% 0.01 0.28 0.24
7% 0.01 0.12 0.10
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total (All Products)....................... 3% 1.15 11.02 6.67
7% 0.48 4.66 1.67
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Parentheses indicate negative (-) values.
The NPV results based on the aforementioned 9-year analytical
period are presented in Table V-40. The impacts are counted over the
lifetime of products purchased in 2019-2027. As mentioned previously,
such results are presented for informational purposes only and is not
indicative of any change in DOE's analytical methodology or decision
criteria.
Table V-40--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative Net Present Value of Consumer Benefits for Products Shipped in 2019-
2027
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Billion 2014$)
-----------------------------------------------
Equipment type Discount rate Trial standard level
-----------------------------------------------
1 2 3 *
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free-Standing.... 3% 0.06 0.10 (0.28)
7% 0.03 0.05 (0.28)
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In 3% 0.00 0.00 (0.01)
7% 0.00 0.00 (0.01)
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing.. 3% 0.16 0.16 (0.53)
7% 0.09 0.09 (0.55)
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide- 3% 0.05 0.05 (0.17)
In............................................ 7% 0.03 0.03 (0.18)
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing......... 3% 0.00 1.47 1.22
7% 0.00 0.83 0.65
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In..... 3% 0.00 0.27 0.22
7% 0.00 0.15 0.12
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing....... 3% 0.10 2.02 1.71
7% 0.06 1.16 0.92
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In... 3% 0.01 0.11 0.09
7% 0.00 0.06 0.05
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total (All Products)....................... 3% 0.38 4.18 2.26
7% 0.22 2.38 0.72
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Parentheses indicate negative (-) values.
The above results reflect the use of a default trend to estimate
the change in price for conventional ovens over the analysis period
(see section IV.F.1 of this notice). DOE also conducted a sensitivity
analysis that considered one scenario with a lower rate of price
decline than the reference case and one scenario with a higher rate of
price decline than the reference case. The results of these alternative
cases are presented in appendix 10C of the NOPR TSD. In the high price
decline case, the NPV is higher than in the default case. In the low
price decline case, the NPV is lower than in the default case.
c. Impacts on Employment
DOE expects energy conservation standards for conventional ovens to
reduce energy bills for consumers of those products, and the resulting
net savings to be redirected to other forms of economic activity. These
expected shifts in spending and economic activity could affect the
demand for labor. As described in section IV.N of this notice, DOE used
an input/output model of the U.S. economy to estimate indirect
employment impacts of the TSLs that DOE considered in this rulemaking.
DOE understands that there are uncertainties involved in projecting
employment impacts, especially changes in the later years of the
analysis. Therefore, DOE generated results for near-term timeframes,
where these uncertainties are reduced.
The results suggest that the proposed standards are likely to have
negligible
[[Page 33084]]
impact on the net demand for labor in the economy. The net change in
jobs is so small that it would be imperceptible in national labor
statistics and might be offset by other, unanticipated effects on
employment. Chapter 16 of the NOPR TSD presents detailed results.
4. Impact on Utility or Performance of Products
Based on testing conducted in support of this proposed rule,
discussed in section IV.C.2 of this notice, DOE concluded that the
standards proposed in this NOPR would not reduce the utility or
performance of the conventional ovens under consideration in this
rulemaking. Manufacturers of these products currently offer units that
meet or exceed the proposed standards.
5. Impact of Any Lessening of Competition
DOE has also considered any lessening of competition that is likely
to result from the proposed standards. The Attorney General determines
the impact, if any, of any lessening of competition likely to result
from a proposed standard, and transmits such determination to DOE,
together with an analysis of the nature and extent of such impact. (42
U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(V) and (B)(ii))
DOE will transmit a copy of this NOPR and the accompanying TSD to
the Attorney General, requesting that the DOJ provide its determination
on this issue. DOE will consider DOJ's comments on the proposed rule in
determining whether to proceed with the proposed energy conservation
standards. DOE will also publish and respond to DOJ's comments in the
Federal Register.
6. Need of the Nation To Conserve Energy
Enhanced energy efficiency, where economically justified, improves
the nation's energy security, strengthens the economy, and reduces the
environmental impacts of energy production. Reduced electricity demand
due to energy conservation standards is also likely to reduce the cost
of maintaining the reliability of the electricity system, particularly
during peak-load periods. As a measure of this reduced demand, chapter
15 in the NOPR TSD presents the estimated reduction in generating
capacity for the TSLs that DOE considered in this rulemaking.
Energy savings from proposed standards for conventional ovens are
expected to yield environmental benefits in the form of reduced
emissions of air pollutants and greenhouse gases. Table V-41. provides
DOE's estimate of cumulative emissions reductions to result from the
TSLs considered in this rulemaking. DOE reports annual emissions
reductions for each TSL in chapter 13 of the NOPR TSD.
Table V-41--Conventional Ovens: Cumulative Emissions Reduction for Products Shipped in 2019-2048
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trial standard level
-----------------------------------------------
1 2 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Power Sector Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO2 (million metric tons)....................................... 9.0 38.6 68.2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SO2 (thousand tons)............................................. 7.4 29.1 51.8
NOX (thousand tons)............................................. 6.9 32.2 56.7
Hg (tons)....................................................... 0.02 0.09 0.16
CH4 (thousand tons)............................................. 0.88 3.51 6.22
N2O (thousand tons)............................................. 0.13 0.50 0.89
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upstream Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO2 (million metric tons)....................................... 0.52 2.52 4.42
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SO2 (thousand tons)............................................. 0.09 0.36 0.63
NOX (thousand tons)............................................. 7.5 36.6 64.2
Hg (tons)....................................................... 0.00 0.00 0.00
CH4 (thousand tons)............................................. 43.6 218 381
N2O (thousand tons)............................................. 0.00 0.02 0.03
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total FFC Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO2 (million metric tons)....................................... 9.5 41.1 72.6
SO2 (thousand tons)............................................. 7.5 29.5 52.4
NOX (thousand tons)............................................. 14.4 68.8 120.9
Hg (tons)....................................................... 0.02 0.09 0.16
CH4 (thousand tons)............................................. 44.4 221.2 387.5
CH4 (thousand tons CO2eq) *..................................... 1,244 6,195 10,849
N2O (thousand tons)............................................. 0.13 0.52 0.92
N2O (thousand tons CO2eq) *..................................... 34.6 137.0 243.2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* CO2eq is the quantity of CO2 that would have the same GWP.
As part of the analysis for this proposed rule, DOE estimated
monetary benefits likely to result from the reduced emissions of
CO2 and NOX that DOE estimated for each of the
considered TSLs. As discussed in section IV.L of this notice, for
CO2, DOE used the most recent values for the SCC developed
by an interagency process. The four sets of SCC values for
CO2 emissions reductions in 2015 resulting from that process
(expressed in 2014$) are represented by $12.2/metric ton (the average
value from a distribution that uses a 5-percent discount rate), $41.2/
metric ton (the average value from a distribution that uses a 3-percent
discount rate), $63.4/metric ton (the
[[Page 33085]]
average value from a distribution that uses a 2.5-percent discount
rate), and $121/metric ton (the 95th-percentile value from a
distribution that uses a 3-percent discount rate). The values for later
years are higher due to increasing damages (emissions-related costs) as
the projected magnitude of climate change increases.
Table V-42. presents the global value of CO2 emissions
reductions at each TSL. For each of the four cases, DOE calculated a
present value of the stream of annual values using the same discount
rate as was used in the studies upon which the dollar-per-ton values
are based. DOE calculated domestic values as a range from 7 percent to
23 percent of the global values; these results are presented in chapter
14 of the NOPR TSD.
Table V-42--Conventional Ovens: Estimates of Global Present Value of CO2 Emissions Reduction for Products
Shipped in 2019-2048
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Million 2014$)
-------------------------------------------------------------------
SCC case *
TSL -------------------------------------------------------------------
3% discount
5% discount 3% discount 2.5% discount rate, 95th
rate, average rate, average rate, average percentile
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Power Sector Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1........................................... 62.0 288.2 458.0 892.8
2........................................... 266.7 1,238.9 1,968.8 3,836.7
3........................................... 473.1 2,194.1 3,485.5 6,794.3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upstream Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1........................................... 3.5 16.6 26.5 51.5
2........................................... 17.1 80.0 127.4 248.0
3........................................... 30.0 140.6 223.8 435.8
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total FFC Emissions
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1........................................... 65.5 304.8 484.5 944.3
2........................................... 283.8 1,319.0 2,096.1 4,084.7
3........................................... 503.1 2,334.7 3,709.3 7,230.1
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE is well aware that scientific and economic knowledge about the
contribution of CO2 and other GHG emissions to changes in
the future global climate and the potential resulting damages to the
world economy continues to evolve rapidly. Thus, any value placed on
reducing CO2 emissions in this rulemaking is subject to
change. DOE, together with other Federal agencies, will continue to
review various methodologies for estimating the monetary value of
reductions in CO2 and other GHG emissions. This ongoing
review will consider the comments on this subject that are part of the
public record for this and other rulemakings, as well as other
methodological assumptions and issues. However, consistent with DOE's
legal obligations, and taking into account the uncertainty involved
with this particular issue, DOE has included in this proposed rule the
most recent values and analyses resulting from the interagency process.
DOE also estimated the cumulative monetary value of the economic
benefits associated with NOX emissions reductions
anticipated to result from the considered TSLs for conventional ovens.
The dollar-per-ton value that DOE used is discussed in section IV.L of
this notice. Table V-43. presents the cumulative present values for
each TSL calculated using 7-percent and 3-percent discount rates.
Table V-43--Conventional Ovens: Estimates of Present Value of NOX
Emissions Reduction for Products Shipped in 2019-2048
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Million 2014$)
---------------------
TSL 3% 7%
discount discount
rate rate
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Power Sector Emissions
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................................. 24.6 9.7
2................................................. 113.8 45.2
3................................................. 200.9 80.1
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Upstream Emissions
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................................. 25.9 9.7
2................................................. 127.1 48.4
3................................................. 223.2 85.1
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total FFC Emissions
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................................. 50.4 19.4
2................................................. 240.9 93.5
3................................................. 424.1 165.2
------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. Summary of National Economic Impacts
The NPV of the monetized benefits associated with emissions
reductions can be viewed as a complement to the NPV of the consumer
savings calculated for each TSL considered in this rulemaking.
Table V-44. presents the NPV values that result from adding the
estimates of the potential economic benefits resulting from reduced
CO2 and NOX emissions in each of four valuation
scenarios to the NPV of consumer savings calculated for each TSL
considered in this rulemaking, at both a 7-percent and 3-percent
discount rate. The CO2 values used in the columns of each
table correspond to the four sets of SCC values discussed above.
[[Page 33086]]
Table V-44--Conventional Ovens: Net Present Value of Consumer Savings Combined With Present Value of Monetized Benefits From CO2 and NOX Emissions
Reductions
(Billion 2014$)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer NPV at 3% discount rate added with:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL SCC case $12.2/t and SCC case $41.2/t and SCC case $63.4/t and SCC case $121/t and
medium NOX value medium NOX value medium NOX value medium NOX value
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................................... 1.3 1.5 1.7 2.1
2................................................... 11.5 12.6 13.4 15.3
3................................................... 7.6 9.4 10.8 14.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer NPV at 7% discount rate added with:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TSL SCC case $12.2/t and SCC case $41.2/t and SCC case $63.4/t and SCC case $121/t and
medium NOX value medium NOX value medium NOX value medium NOX value
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................................................... 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.4
2................................................... 5.0 6.1 6.9 8.8
3................................................... 2.3 4.2 5.5 9.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although adding the value of consumer savings to the values of
emission reductions provides a valuable perspective, two issues should
be considered. First, the national operating cost savings are domestic
U.S. monetary savings that occur as a result of market transactions,
while the value of CO2 reductions is based on a global
value. Second, the assessments of operating cost savings and the SCC
are performed with different methods that use different time frames for
analysis. The national operating cost savings is measured for the
lifetime of equipment shipped in 2019 to 2048. Because CO2
emissions have a very long residence time in the atmosphere,\74\ the
SCC values in future years reflect future climate-related impacts
resulting from the emission of CO2 that continue well beyond
2100.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\74\ The atmospheric lifetime of CO2 is estimated of
the order of 30-95 years. Jacobson, MZ (2005). ``Correction to
``Control of fossil-fuel particulate black carbon and organic
matter, possibly the most effective method of slowing global
warming.'' '' J. Geophys. Res. 110. pp. D14105.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Other Factors
The Secretary of Energy, in determining whether a standard is
economically justified, may consider any other factors that the
Secretary deems to be relevant. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)(VII)) DOE
did not consider any other factors for this NOPR.
C. Conclusion
When considering proposed standards, the new or amended energy
conservation standard that DOE adopts for any type (or class) of
covered product must be designed to achieve the maximum improvement in
energy efficiency that the Secretary determines is technologically
feasible and economically justified. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(A)) In
determining whether a standard is economically justified, the Secretary
must determine whether the benefits of the standard exceed its burdens,
considering to the greatest extent practicable the seven statutory
factors discussed previously. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(i)) The new or
amended standard must also result in a significant conservation of
energy. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(3)(B))
The Department considered the impacts of standards at each TSL,
beginning with a maximum technologically feasible level, to determine
whether that level was economically justified. Where the max-tech level
was not justified, DOE then considered the next most efficient level
and undertook the same evaluation until it reached the highest
efficiency level that is both technologically feasible and economically
justified and saves a significant amount of energy.
To aid the reader as DOE discusses the benefits and/or burdens of
each trial standard level, tables present a summary of the results of
DOE's quantitative analysis for each TSL. In addition to the
quantitative results presented in the tables, DOE also considers other
burdens and benefits that affect economic justification. Those include
the impacts on identifiable subgroups of consumers who may be
disproportionately affected by a national standard. Section V.B.1 of
this notice presents the estimated impacts of each TSL for these
subgroups.
DOE also notes that the economics literature provides a wide-
ranging discussion of how consumers trade off upfront costs and energy
savings in the absence of government intervention. Much of this
literature attempts to explain why consumers appear to undervalue
energy efficiency improvements. This undervaluation suggests that
regulation that promotes energy efficiency can produce significant net
private gains (as well as producing social gains by, for example,
reducing pollution). There is evidence that consumers undervalue future
energy savings as a result of (1) a lack of information; (2) a lack of
sufficient salience of the long-term or aggregate benefits; (3) a lack
of sufficient savings to warrant delaying or altering purchases; (4)
excessive focus on the short term, in the form of inconsistent
weighting of future energy cost savings relative to available returns
on other investments; (5) computational or other difficulties
associated with the evaluation of relevant tradeoffs; and (6) a
divergence in incentives (between renters and owners, or builders and
purchasers). Having less than perfect foresight and a high degree of
uncertainty about the future, consumers may trade off these types of
investments at a higher than expected rate between current consumption
and uncertain future energy cost savings.
In DOE's current regulatory analysis, potential changes in the
benefits and costs of a regulation due to changes in consumer purchase
decisions are included in two ways: First, if consumers forego a
purchase of a product in the standards case, this
[[Page 33087]]
decreases sales for product manufacturers, and the impact on
manufacturers attributed to lost revenue is included in the MIA.
Second, DOE accounts for energy savings attributable only to products
actually used by consumers in the standards case; if a regulatory
option decreases the number of products used by consumers, this
decreases the potential energy savings from an energy conservation
standard. DOE provides estimates of shipments and changes in the volume
of product purchases in chapter 9 of the NOPR TSD. However, DOE's
current analysis does not explicitly control for heterogeneity in
consumer preferences, preferences across subcategories of products or
specific features, or consumer price sensitivity variation according to
household income.\75\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\75\ P.C. Reiss and M.W. White. Household Electricity Demand,
Revisited. Review of Economic Studies (2005) 72, 853-883.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While DOE is not prepared at present to provide a fuller
quantifiable framework for estimating the benefits and costs of changes
in consumer purchase decisions due to an energy conservation standard,
DOE is committed to developing a framework that can support empirical
quantitative tools for improved assessment of the consumer welfare
impacts of appliance standards. DOE has posted a paper that discusses
the issue of consumer welfare impacts of appliance energy efficiency
standards, and potential enhancements to the methodology by which these
impacts are defined and estimated in the regulatory process.\76\ DOE
welcomes comments on how to more fully assess the potential impact of
energy conservation standards on consumer choice and how to quantify
this impact in its regulatory analysis in future rulemakings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\76\ Alan Sanstad, Notes on the Economics of Household Energy
Consumption and Technology Choice. Lawrence Berkeley National
Laboratory. 2010. Available online at: www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/pdfs/consumer_ee_theory.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Benefits and Burdens of TSLs Considered for Conventional Ovens
Table V-45. and Table V-46. summarize the quantitative impacts
estimated for each TSL for conventional ovens. The efficiency levels
contained in each TSL are described in section V.A of this notice.
Table V-45--Conventional Ovens: Summary of National Impacts
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Category TSL 1 TSL 2 TSL 3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative FFC Energy Savings (quads)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0.163.................... 0.709................... 1.251.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NPV of Consumer Costs and Benefits 2014$ billion
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3% discount rate................. 1.2...................... 11.0.................... 6.7.
7% discount rate................. 0.5...................... 4.7..................... 1.7.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative FFC Emissions Reduction
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO2 million metric tons.......... 9.5...................... 41.1.................... 72.6.
SO2 thousand tons................ 7.5...................... 29.5.................... 52.4.
NOX thousand tons................ 14.4..................... 68.8.................... 120.9.
Hg tons.......................... 0.02..................... 0.09.................... 0.16.
CH4 thousand tons................ 44.4..................... 221.2................... 387.5.
CH4 thousand tons CO 2 eq *...... 1,244.................... 6,195................... 10,849.
N2O thousand tons................ 0.13..................... 0.52.................... 0.92.
N2O thousand tons CO 2 eq *...... 34.6..................... 137.0................... 243.2.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Value of Emissions Reduction
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CO2 2014$ million **............. 66 to 944................ 284 to 4,085............ 503 to 7,230.
NOX--3% discount rate 2014$ 50.4..................... 240.9................... 424.1.
million.
NOX--7% discount rate 2014$ 19.4..................... 93.5.................... 165.2.
million.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Parentheses indicate negative (-) values.
* CO2eq is the quantity of CO2 that would have the same GWP.
** Range of the economic value of CO2 reductions is based on estimates of the global benefit of reduced CO2
emissions.
Table V-46--Conventional Ovens: Summary of Manufacturer and Consumer Impacts
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Category TSL 1 TSL 2 TSL 3*
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Manufacturer Impacts
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Industry NPV (2014$ million) (Base 762.1-762.8 697.1-702.6 56.0-140.6
Case INPV = $783.5)..................
Industry NPV (% change)............... (2.7)-(2.6) (11.0)-(10.3) (92.9)-(82.0)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Average LCC Savings (2014$)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free- $13.96 $15.18 ($37.60)
Standing.............................
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-in/ 14.11 15.25 (37.64)
Slide-in.............................
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 14.10 14.10 (27.79)
Standing.............................
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built- 14.20 14.20 (27.80)
in/Slide-in..........................
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing 0.00 289.73 178.91
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/ 0.00 289.77 178.92
Slide-In.............................
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 18.02 282.80 165.73
Standing.............................
[[Page 33088]]
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/ 18.03 282.85 165.75
Slide-In.............................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Simple PBP (years)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free- 0.9 4.0 17.5
Standing.............................
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-in/ 0.9 4.0 17.5
Slide-in.............................
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 0.9 0.9 18.1
Standing.............................
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built- 0.9 0.9 18.1
in/Slide-in..........................
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing ................. 1.7 5.3
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/ ................. 1.7 5.3
Slide-In.............................
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 0.8 1.2 5.4
Standing.............................
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/ 0.8 1.2 5.4
Slide-In.............................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% of Consumers That Experience Net Cost
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PC1: Electric Standard Ovens, Free- 0 12 82
Standing.............................
PC2: Electric Standard Ovens, Built-in/ 0 12 82
Slide-in.............................
PC3: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 0 0 76
Standing.............................
PC4: Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built- 0 0 76
in/Slide-in..........................
PC5: Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing 0 0 24
PC6: Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/ 0 0 24
Slide-In.............................
PC7: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 0 0 27
Standing.............................
PC8: Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/ 0 0 27
Slide-In.............................
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Parentheses indicate negative (-) values.
DOE first considered TSL 3, which represents the max-tech
efficiency levels. TSL 3 would save 1.25 quads of energy, an amount DOE
considers significant. TSL 3 has an estimated NPV of consumer benefit
of 1.7 billion using a discount rate of 7 percent, and 6.7 billion
using a discount rate of 3 percent.
The cumulative emissions reductions at TSL 3 are 72.6 Mt of
CO2, 120.9 thousand tons of NOX, 52.4 thousand
tons of SO2, 0.2 ton of Hg, 387.5 thousand tons of
CH4, and 0.92 thousand tons of N2O. The estimated
monetary value of the CO2 emissions reduction at TSL 3
ranges from $503 million to $7,230 million.
At TSL 3, the average LCC impact is a savings ranging from -$37.64
for PC2 (Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In) to $178.92 for
product class 6 (Gas Standard Ovens, Built-in/Slide-in). The simple
payback period ranges from 5 years for PC5, PC6, PC7, and PC8 (Gas
Standard Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In, and Gas Self-Clean
Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In) to 18 years for PC1, PC2,
PC3, and PC4 (Electric Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In and Free-
Standing and Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/Slide-In and Free-
Standing). The fraction of consumers experiencing an LCC net cost
ranges from 24 percent for PC5 and PC6 (Gas Standard Ovens, Free-
Standing and Built-In/Slide-In) to 82 percent for PC1 and PC2 (Electric
Standard Oven, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In).
At TSL 3, the projected change in INPV ranges from a decrease of
$727.5 million to a decrease of $642.9 million, equivalent to a loss of
92.9 percent and a loss of 82.0 percent, respectively.
Products that meet the efficiency standards specified by this TSL
are forecast to represent 11 percent of shipments in the year leading
up to new and amended standards. As such, manufacturers would have to
redesign the vast majority of their products by the 2019 compliance
date to meet demand. Redesigning all these units to meet the current
max-tech efficiency levels would require considerable capital and
equipment conversion expenditures. At TSL 3, the capital conversion
costs total $528.0 million, 4.3 times the industry annual capital
expenditure in the year leading up to new and amended standards. DOE
estimates that complete platform redesigns would cost the industry
$401.5 million in product conversion costs. These conversion costs
largely relate to the research programs required to develop new
products that meet the efficiency standards set forth by TSL 3. These
costs are equivalent to 4.5 times the industry annual budget for
research and development. Total capital and product conversion costs
associated with the changes in products and manufacturing facilities
required at TSL 3 would require significant use of manufacturers'
financial reserves, impacting other areas of business that compete for
these resources, and significantly reducing INPV. In addition,
manufacturers could face a substantial impact on profitability at TSL
3. Because manufacturers are more likely to reduce their margins to
maintain a price-competitive product at higher TSLs, DOE expects that
TSL 3 would yield impacts closer to the high end of the range of INPV
impacts. If the high end of the range of impacts is reached, as DOE
expects, TSL 3 could result in a net loss of 92.9 percent in INPV to
residential conventional oven manufacturers. As a result, at TSL 3, DOE
expects that some companies could be forced to exit the residential
conventional oven market or shift production abroad, both of which
would negatively impact domestic manufacturing capacity and employment.
In view of the foregoing, DOE concludes that, at TSL 3 for
conventional ovens, the benefits of energy savings, positive NPV of
total customer benefits, customer LCC savings for four of the eight
product classes, emission reductions and the estimated monetary value
of the emissions reductions would be outweighed by the negative
customer impacts for product classes 1, 2, 3, and 4 (Electric Standard
Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In and Electric Self-Clean
Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In), the significant reduction
in industry value at TSL 3, as well as the potential for loss of
domestic manufacturing. Consequently, DOE has concluded that TSL 3 is
not economically justified.
DOE then considered TSL 2. TSL 2 would save 0.71 quads of energy,
an
[[Page 33089]]
amount DOE considers significant. Under TSL 2, the estimated NPV of
consumer benefit is $4.7 billion using a discount rate of 7 percent,
and $11.0 billion using a discount rate of 3 percent.
The cumulative emissions reductions at TSL 2 are 41.1 Mt of
CO2, 68.8 thousand tons of NOX, 29.5 thousand
tons of SO2, 0.09 tons of Hg, 221.2 thousand tons of
CH4, and 0.52 thousand tons of N2O. The estimated
monetary value of the CO2 emissions reduction at TSL 2
ranges from $284 million to $4,085 million.
At TSL 2, the average LCC impact is a savings ranging from $14.10
for PC3 (Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing) to $289.77 for PC6
(Gas Standard Ovens, Built-In/Slide-in). The simple payback period
ranges from 1 year for PC3, PC4, PC7, and PC8 (Electric Self-Clean
Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In and Gas Self-Clean Ovens,
Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In) to 4 years for PC1 and PC2
(Electric Standard Ovens Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-In). The
fraction of consumers experiencing an LCC net cost ranges from zero
percent for PC3 through PC8 (Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing
and Built-In/Slide-In, Gas Standard Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/
Slide-In, and Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free-Standing and Built-In/Slide-
In) to 12 percent for PC1 and PC2 (Electric Standard Ovens, Free-
Standing and Built-In/Slide-In).
At TSL 2, the projected change in INPV ranges from a decrease of
$86.4 million to a decrease of $80.9 million, equivalent to a loss of
11.0 percent and a loss of 10.3 percent, respectively. Products that
meet the efficiency standards specified by this TSL are forecast to
represent 46 percent of shipments in the year leading up to new and
amended standards. DOE estimates that compliance with TSL 2 would
require manufacturers to make an estimated $42.0 million in capital
conversion costs. This represents a 0.3 times increase in the annual
capital expenditure budget in the year leading up to new and amended
standards. TSL 2 will also require manufacturers to make an estimated
$67.9 million in product conversion costs primarily relating to the
research and development programs needed to improve upon existing
platforms to meet the specified efficiency levels. This represents 0.8
times the industry budget for research and development in the year
leading up to new and amended standards. The substantial reduction in
conversion costs corresponding to compliance with TSL 2 greatly
mitigates the operational risk and impact on INPV.
The Secretary tentatively concludes that at TSL 2 for residential
conventional ovens, the benefits of energy savings, positive NPV of
consumer benefits, emission reductions, and the estimated monetary
value of the CO2 emissions reductions, and positive average
LCC savings would outweigh the negative impacts on some consumers and
on manufacturers, including the conversion costs that would result in a
reduction in INPV for manufacturers.
After considering the analysis and the benefits and burdens of TSL
2, DOE has tentatively concluded that this TSL will offer the maximum
improvement in efficiency that is technologically feasible and
economically justified, and will result in significant conservation of
energy. Therefore, DOE proposes TSL 2 for conventional ovens. The
proposed energy conservation standards for conventional ovens are shown
in Table V-47.
Table V-47--Proposed Amended Energy Conservation Standards for
Conventional Ovens
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Compliance Date: January 1, 2019
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Integrated annual energy consumption
(IAEC)
---------------------------------------
Product class Electricity
consumption (kWh/ Gas consumption
year) (kBtu/year)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Standard Ovens, Free- 122.5 + (31.8 x ..................
Standing. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Electric Standard Ovens, Built- 128.6 + (31.8 x ..................
in/Slide-in. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Free- 163.2 + (42.3 x ..................
Standing. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Electric Self-Clean Ovens, Built- 169.1 + (42.3 x ..................
in/Slide-in. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Gas Standard Ovens, Free- .................. 492.9 + (214.4 x
Standing. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Gas Standard Ovens, Built-in/ .................. 499.5 + (214.4 x
Slide-in. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Free- .................. 746.7 + (214.4 x
Standing. Rated Cavity
Volume).
Gas Self-Clean Ovens, Built-In/ .................. 755.5 + (214.4 x
Slide-in. Rated Cavity
Volume).
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The Rated Cavity Volume is the volume of the oven cavity in cubic
feet as measured using the final DOE test procedure at 10 CFR part
430, subpart B, appendix I.
2. Annualized Benefits and Costs of the Proposed Standards
The benefits and costs of the proposed standards can also be
expressed in terms of annualized values. The annualized monetary values
are the sum of (1) the annualized national economic value of the
benefits from operating products that meet the proposed standards
(consisting of operating cost savings from using less energy, minus
increases in product purchase costs, which is another way of
representing consumer NPV), and (2) the monetary value of the benefits
of CO2 and NOX emission reductions.\77\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\77\ To convert the time-series of costs and benefits into
annualized values, DOE calculated a present value in 2014, the year
used for discounting the NPV of total consumer costs and savings.
For the benefits, DOE calculated a present value associated with
each year's shipments in the year in which the shipments occur
(2020, 2030, etc.), and then discounted the present value from each
year to 2014. The calculation uses discount rates of 3 and 7 percent
for all costs and benefits except for the value of CO2
reductions, for which DOE used case-specific discount rates. Using
the present value, DOE then calculated the fixed annual payment over
a 30-year period, starting in the compliance year that yields the
same present value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table V-48 shows the annualized values for conventional ovens under
TSL 2, expressed in 2014$. The results under the primary estimate are
as follows. Using a 7-percent discount rate for benefits and costs
other than CO2 reductions, for which DOE used a 3-percent
discount rate along with the SCC series corresponding to a value of
$41.2/ton in 2015 (in 2014$), the cost of the standards for
conventional ovens in today's rule is $33.5 million per year in
increased equipment costs, while the annualized benefits are $494
million per year in reduced equipment operating costs, $74 million in
CO2 reductions,
[[Page 33090]]
and $9 million in reduced NOX emissions. In this case, the
net benefit amounts to $543 million per year. Using a 3-percent
discount rate for all benefits and costs and the SCC series
corresponding to a value of $41.2/ton in 2015 (in 2014$), the cost of
the standards for conventional ovens in today's rule is $33.1 million
per year in increased equipment costs, while the benefits are $648
million per year in reduced operating costs, $74 million in
CO2 reductions, and $13 million in reduced NOX
emissions. In this case, the net benefit amounts to $701 million per
year.
Table V-48--Annualized Benefits and Costs of Proposed Amended Standards (TSL 2) for Conventional Ovens Sold in 2019-2048
(Million 2014$/year)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Low net benefits estimate High net benefits
Discount rate Primary estimate * * estimate *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Benefits
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Operating Cost Savings.... 7%................................. 494...................... 457...................... 542.
3%................................. 648...................... 593...................... 719.
CO2 Reduction at $12.2/t **........ 5%................................. 21....................... 20....................... 24.
CO2 Reduction at $41.2/t **........ 3%................................. 74....................... 68....................... 81.
CO2 Reduction at $63.4/t **........ 2.5%............................... 108...................... 100...................... 119.
CO2 Reduction at $121/t **......... 3%................................. 228...................... 211...................... 252.
NOX Reduction [dagger]............. 7%................................. 9.24..................... 8.66..................... 10.11.
3%................................. 13.43.................... 12.46.................... 14.80.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total [dagger][dagger]......... 7% plus CO2 range.................. 524 to 731............... 485 to 677............... 576 to 804.
7%................................. 577...................... 534...................... 634.
3% plus CO2 range.................. 682 to 889............... 625 to 817............... 758 to 986.
3%................................. 734...................... 674...................... 815.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Costs
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumer Incremental Product Costs. 7%................................. 34....................... 34....................... 33.
3%................................. 33....................... 34....................... 33.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total [dagger][dagger]......... 7% plus CO2 range.................. 491 to 697............... 451 to 642............... 543 to 771.
7%................................. 543...................... 499...................... 601.
3% plus CO2 range.................. 649 to 856............... 592 to 783............... 725 to 953.
3%................................. 701...................... 640...................... 783.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* The results include benefits to consumers which accrue after 2048 from products purchased from 2019 through 2048. Costs incurred by manufacturers,
some of which may be incurred prior to 2019 in preparation for the rule, are not directly included, but are indirectly included as part of incremental
equipment costs. The Primary, Low Benefits, and High Benefits Estimates utilize forecasts of energy prices and housing starts from the AEO 2015
Reference case, Low Estimate, and High Estimate, respectively. In addition, incremental product costs reflect a medium decline rate for projected
product price trends in the Primary Estimate, a low decline rate in the Low Benefits Estimate, and a high decline rate in the High Benefits Estimate.
The methods used to derive projected price trends are explained in section IV.F.1 of this notice.
** The CO2 values represent global values (in 2014$) of the social cost of CO2 emissions in 2015 under several scenarios. The values of $12.2, $41.2,
and $63.4 per ton are the averages of SCC distributions calculated using 5%, 3%, and 2.5% discount rates, respectively. The value of $121 per ton
represents the 95th percentile of the SCC distribution calculated using a 3% discount rate.
[dagger] The $/ton values used for NOX are described in section IV.L.2.
[dagger][dagger] Total Benefits for both the 3% and 7% cases are derived using the SCC value calculated at a 3% discount rate, which is $41.2/ton in
2015 (2014$). In the rows labeled as ``7% plus CO2 range'' and ``3% plus CO2 range,'' the operating cost and NOX benefits are calculated using the
labeled discount rate, and those values are added to the full range of CO2 values.
VI. Procedural Issues and Regulatory Review
A. Review Under Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
Section 1(b)(1) of Executive Order 12866, ``Regulatory Planning and
Review,'' 58 FR 51735 (Oct. 4, 1993), requires each agency to identify
the problem that it intends to address, including, where applicable,
the failures of private markets or public institutions that warrant new
agency action, as well as to assess the significance of that problem.
The problems that the proposed standards address are as follows:
(1) Insufficient information and the high costs of gathering and
analyzing relevant information leads some consumers to miss
opportunities to make cost-effective investments in energy efficiency.
(2) In some cases the benefits of more efficient products are not
realized due to misaligned incentives between purchasers and users. An
example of such a case is when the products purchase decision is made
by a building contractor or building owner who does not pay the energy
costs.
(3) There are external benefits resulting from improved energy
efficiency of appliances that are not captured by the users of such
equipment. These benefits include externalities related to public
health, environmental protection, and national security that are not
reflected in energy prices, such as reduced emissions of air pollutants
and greenhouse gases that impact human health and global warming.
In addition, DOE has determined that this regulatory action is an
``economically significant regulatory action'' under Executive Order
12866. DOE presented to the Office of Information and Regulatory
Affairs (OIRA) in the OMB for review the draft rule and other documents
prepared for this rulemaking, including a regulatory impact analysis
(RIA), and has included these documents in the rulemaking record. The
assessments prepared pursuant to Executive Order 12866 can
[[Page 33091]]
be found in the technical support document for this rulemaking.
DOE has also reviewed this regulation pursuant to Executive Order
13563. 76 FR 3281 (Jan. 21, 2011). Executive Order 13563 is
supplemental to and explicitly reaffirms the principles, structures,
and definitions governing regulatory review established in Executive
Order 12866. To the extent permitted by law, agencies are required by
Executive Order 13563 to: (1) Propose or adopt a regulation only upon a
reasoned determination that its benefits justify its costs (recognizing
that some benefits and costs are difficult to quantify); (2) tailor
regulations to impose the least burden on society, consistent with
obtaining regulatory objectives, taking into account, among other
things, and to the extent practicable, the costs of cumulative
regulations; (3) select, in choosing among alternative regulatory
approaches, those approaches that maximize net benefits (including
potential economic, environmental, public health and safety, and other
advantages; distributive impacts; and equity); (4) to the extent
feasible, specify performance objectives, rather than specifying the
behavior or manner of compliance that regulated entities must adopt;
and (5) identify and assess available alternatives to direct
regulation, including providing economic incentives to encourage the
desired behavior, such as user fees or marketable permits, or providing
information upon which choices can be made by the public.
DOE emphasizes as well that Executive Order 13563 requires agencies
to use the best available techniques to quantify anticipated present
and future benefits and costs as accurately as possible. In its
guidance, the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has
emphasized that such techniques may include identifying changing future
compliance costs that might result from technological innovation or
anticipated behavioral changes. For the reasons stated in the preamble,
DOE believes that the NOPR is consistent with these principles,
including the requirement that, to the extent permitted by law,
benefits justify costs and that net benefits are maximized.
B. Review Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) requires
preparation of an initial regulatory flexibility analysis (IRFA) for
any rule that by law must be proposed for public comment, unless the
agency certifies that the rule, if promulgated, will not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
As required by Executive Order 13272, ``Proper Consideration of Small
Entities in Agency Rulemaking,'' 67 FR 53461 (August 16, 2002), DOE
published procedures and policies on February 19, 2003, to ensure that
the potential impacts of its rules on small entities are properly
considered during the rulemaking process. 68 FR 7990. DOE has made its
procedures and policies available on the Office of the General
Counsel's Web site (http://energy.gov/gc/office-general-counsel). DOE
has prepared the following IRFA for the products that are the subject
of this rulemaking.
1. Description and Estimated Number of Small Entities Regulated
a. Methodology for Estimating the Number of Small Entities
For manufacturers of residential conventional ovens, the Small
Business Administration (SBA) has set a size threshold, which defines
those entities classified as ``small businesses'' for the purposes of
the statute. DOE used the SBA's small business size standards to
determine whether any small entities would be subject to the
requirements of the rule. 65 FR 30836, 30848 (May 15, 2000), as amended
at 65 FR 53533, 53544 (September 5, 2000) and codified at 13 CFR part
121. The size standards are listed by North American Industry
Classification System (NAICS) code and industry description and are
available at http://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/Size_Standards_Table.pdf. Residential conventional oven manufacturing
is classified under NAICS 335221, ``Household Cooking Appliance
Manufacturing.'' The SBA sets a threshold of 750 employees or fewer for
an entity to be considered a small business for this category.
DOE reviewed the potential standard levels considered in this NOPR
under the provisions of the Regulatory Flexibility Act and the
procedures and policies published on February 19, 2003. To better
assess the potential impacts of this rulemaking on small entities, DOE
conducted a more focused inquiry of the companies that could be small
business manufacturers of products covered by this rulemaking. During
its market survey, DOE used available public information to identify
potential small manufacturers. DOE's research involved industry trade
association membership directories (e.g., AHAM), information from
previous rulemakings, individual company Web sites, and market research
tools (e.g., Hoover's reports) to create a list of companies that
manufacture or sell residential conventional ovens covered by this
rulemaking.
Table VI-1--Sources Used To Identify Residential Conventional Oven Manufacturers
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Number of large Number of small
Source manufacturers identified manufacturers identified
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AHAM Trade Association Directory...................... 10 1
Previous Rulemaking................................... 2 3
Market Research....................................... 0 3
---------------------------------------------------------
Total............................................. 12 7
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE also asked stakeholders and industry representatives if they
were aware of any additional small manufacturers during manufacturer
interviews and at DOE public meetings. DOE reviewed publicly available
data and contacted various companies on its complete list of
manufacturers, as necessary, to determine whether they met the SBA's
definition of a small business manufacturer. DOE screened out companies
that do not offer products impacted by this rulemaking, do not meet the
definition of a ``small business,'' or are foreign owned and operated.
DOE identified 19 companies that either manufacture or sell
residential conventional ovens that would be affected by this proposal.
Of these 19 companies, DOE identified seven that met the SBA's
definition of a small business.
b. Manufacturer Participation
DOE contacted identified businesses to invite them to take part in
a
[[Page 33092]]
manufacturer impact analysis interview. Of the businesses contacted,
DOE was able to reach and discuss potential standards with one small
business. DOE also obtained information about small businesses and
potential impacts on small businesses while interviewing large
manufacturers.
c. Residential Conventional Oven Industry Structure and Nature of
Competition
Three major manufacturers supply approximately 85 percent of the
market for residential conventional ovens. DOE estimates that the
remaining 15 percent of the market is served by a combination of small
businesses and large businesses. None of the three major manufacturers
of residential conventional ovens affected by this rulemaking is a
small business.
d. Comparison Between Large and Small Manufacturers
In general, small manufacturers differ from large manufacturers in
several ways that affect the extent to which a manufacturer may be
impacted by proposed standards. Characteristics of small manufacturers
typically include: Lower production volumes, fewer engineering
resources, and less access to capital. Lower production volumes in
particular may place small manufacturers at a competitive disadvantage
relative to large manufacturers as they convert products and facilities
to comply with new and amended standards. When producing at lower
volumes, a small manufacturer's conversion costs must be spread over
fewer units than a larger competitor's. Therefore, unless a small
manufacturer can differentiate its products in order to earn a price
premium, the small manufacturer may experience a disproportionate cost
penalty as it spreads one-time conversion costs over fewer unit sales.
Additionally, when producing at lower volumes, small manufacturers may
lack the purchasing power of their larger competitors and may therefore
face higher costs when sourcing components for more efficient products.
Disadvantages tied to lower production volumes may be further
exacerbated by the fact that small manufacturers often have more
limited engineering resources than their larger competitors, thereby
complicating the redesign effort required to comply with new and
amended standards. Finally, small manufacturers often have less access
to capital, which may be needed to cover the conversion costs
associated with new and amended standards. Combined, these factors may
entail a disproportionate burden on small manufacturers.
2. Description and Estimate of Compliance Requirements
At TSL 1 DOE estimates capital conversion costs of $0.3 million and
product conversion costs of $0.1 million for an average small
manufacturer. For an average large manufacturer, DOE estimates capital
conversion costs of $0.6 million and product conversion costs of $0.3
million.
At TSL 2, the level proposed here, DOE estimates capital conversion
costs of $1.3 million and product conversion costs of $4.1 million for
an average small manufacturer. For an average large manufacturer, DOE
estimates capital conversion costs of $2.7 million and product
conversion costs of $3.3 million. Table VI-2 presents the estimated
conversion costs as a percentage of annual revenue for an average small
manufacturer relative to an average large manufacturer.
Table VI-2--Conversion Costs Facing an Average Small Manufacturer Versus an Average Large Manufacturer of Residential Conventional Ovens
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Capital conversion costs Product conversion costs Total conversion costs as
as a percentage of annual as a percentage of annual a percentage of annual
revenue revenue revenue
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Average Small Manufacturer....................................... 2 6 8
Average Large Manufacturer....................................... 1 1 1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
At TSL 3, DOE estimates capital conversion costs of $16.5 million
and product conversion costs of $19.2 million for an average small
manufacturer. For an average large manufacturer, DOE estimates capital
conversion costs of $34.4 million and product conversion costs of $22.2
million.
As the results for TSL 2 indicate, new and amended energy
conservation standards could potentially impact small businesses
disproportionately. Although estimated conversion costs at TSL 2 are
higher for an average large manufacturer than an average small
manufacturer, the relative impacts of conversion costs on large
manufacturers will likely be offset by higher annual revenues. This is
consistent with the dynamic previously described, whereby large
manufacturers tend to have larger production and sales volumes over
which to spread costs and may also enjoy a competitive advantage due to
their size and ability to access capital that may not be available to
small manufacturers. Since the proposed standards could cause
competitive concerns for small manufacturers, DOE cannot certify that
the proposed standards would not have a significant impact on a
substantial number of small businesses.
DOE requests comments on the number of small businesses identified
and on the impacts of new and amended energy conservation standards on
small businesses.
3. Duplication, Overlap, and Conflict With Other Rules and Regulations
DOE is not aware of any rules or regulations that duplicate,
overlap, or conflict with the rule being proposed.
4. Significant Alternatives to the Rule
The discussion in the previous section analyzes impacts on small
businesses that would result from DOE's new and amended standards. In
reviewing alternatives to the proposed rule, DOE examined energy
conservation standards set at higher and lower efficiency levels, TSL 3
and TSL1, respectively. As discussed in section VI.B.2, compared to TSL
3, DOE estimates that the capital conversion costs and product
conversion costs for an average small manufacturer at TSL 2 would be 92
and 79 percent lower, respectively. The substantial reduction in small
manufacturer capital and product conversion costs corresponding to TSL
2 compared to TSL 3 greatly mitigates the operational risk and the
impact of the standard on INPV.
While TSL 1 would reduce the impacts on small business
manufacturers, it would come at the expense of a significant reduction
in energy savings and NPV benefits to consumers, achieving 75 percent
lower energy savings and 84 percent less NPV benefits to consumers
compared to the
[[Page 33093]]
energy savings and NPV benefits at TSL 2.
DOE believes that establishing standards at TSL 2 balances the
benefits of the energy savings and the NPV benefits to consumers
created at TSL 2 with the potential burdens placed on residential
conventional oven manufacturers, including small business
manufacturers. Accordingly, DOE is declining to adopt one of the other
TSLs considered above, or the other policy alternatives detailed as
part of the regulatory impacts analysis included in Chapter 17 of this
NOPR TSD.
Additional compliance flexibilities may be available through other
means. For example, individual manufacturers may petition for a waiver
of the applicable test procedure. (See 10 CFR 431.401.) Further, EPCA
provides that a manufacturer whose annual gross revenue from all of its
operations does not exceed $8,000,000 may apply for an exemption from
all or part of an energy conservation standard for a period not longer
than 24 months after the effective date of a final rule establishing
the standard. (42 U.S.C. 6295 (t)). DOE estimates that two of the seven
small manufacturers could potentially petition for a waiver based on
their annual gross revenue not exceeding $8 million. Additionally,
Section 504 of the Department of Energy Organization Act, 42 U.S.C.
7194, provides authority for the Secretary to adjust a rule issued
under EPCA in order to prevent ``special hardship, inequity, or unfair
distribution of burdens'' that may be imposed on that manufacturer as a
result of such rule. Manufacturers should refer to 10 CFR part 430,
subpart E, and part 1003 for additional details.
DOE continues to seek input from businesses that would be affected
by this rulemaking and will consider comments received in the
development of any final rule (See section VII.E. that solicits
specific data as well as input on the results of the analyses contained
in this section VI.B.4).
C. Review Under the Paperwork Reduction Act
Manufacturers of covered products must certify to DOE that their
products comply with any applicable energy conservation standards. In
certifying compliance, manufacturers must test their products according
to the applicable DOE test procedure, including any amendments adopted
for that test procedure. DOE has established regulations for the
certification and recordkeeping requirements for all covered consumer
products and commercial equipment, including conventional cooking
products. 76 FR 12422 (March 7, 2011). The collection-of-information
requirement for the certification and recordkeeping is subject to
review and approval by OMB under the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA).
This requirement has been approved by OMB under OMB control number
1910-1400. Public reporting burden for the certification is estimated
to average 30 hours per response, including the time for reviewing
instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and
maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the
collection of information.
Notwithstanding any other provision of the law, no person is
required to respond to, nor shall any person be subject to a penalty
for failure to comply with, a collection of information subject to the
requirements of the PRA, unless that collection of information displays
a currently valid OMB Control Number.
D. Review Under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
Pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969,
DOE has determined that the proposed rule fits within the category of
actions included in Categorical Exclusion (CX) B5.1 and otherwise meets
the requirements for application of a CX. See 10 CFR part 1021, App. B,
B5.1(b); 1021.410(b) and Appendix B, B(1)-(5). The proposed rule fits
within the category of actions because it is a rulemaking that
establishes energy conservation standards for consumer products or
industrial equipment, and for which none of the exceptions identified
in CX B5.1(b) apply. Therefore, DOE has made a CX determination for
this rulemaking, and DOE does not need to prepare an Environmental
Assessment or Environmental Impact Statement for this proposed rule.
DOE's CX determination for this proposed rule is available at http://cxnepa.energy.gov/.
E. Review Under Executive Order 13132
Executive Order 13132, ``Federalism.'' 64 FR 43255 (Aug. 10, 1999)
imposes certain requirements on Federal agencies formulating and
implementing policies or regulations that preempt State law or that
have Federalism implications. The Executive Order requires agencies to
examine the constitutional and statutory authority supporting any
action that would limit the policymaking discretion of the States and
to carefully assess the necessity for such actions. The Executive Order
also requires agencies to have an accountable process to ensure
meaningful and timely input by State and local officials in the
development of regulatory policies that have Federalism implications.
On March 14, 2000, DOE published a statement of policy describing the
intergovernmental consultation process it will follow in the
development of such regulations. 65 FR 13735. EPCA governs and
prescribes Federal preemption of State regulations as to energy
conservation for the products that are the subject of this proposed
rule. States can petition DOE for exemption from such preemption to the
extent, and based on criteria, set forth in EPCA. (42 U.S.C. 6297) No
further action is required by Executive Order 13132.
F. Review Under Executive Order 12988
With respect to the review of existing regulations and the
promulgation of new regulations, section 3(a) of Executive Order 12988,
``Civil Justice Reform,'' imposes on Federal agencies the general duty
to adhere to the following requirements: (1) Eliminate drafting errors
and ambiguity; (2) write regulations to minimize litigation; and (3)
provide a clear legal standard for affected conduct rather than a
general standard and promote simplification and burden reduction. 61 FR
4729 (Feb. 7, 1996). Section 3(b) of Executive Order 12988 specifically
requires that Executive agencies make every reasonable effort to ensure
that the regulation: (1) Clearly specifies the preemptive effect, if
any; (2) clearly specifies any effect on existing Federal law or
regulation; (3) provides a clear legal standard for affected conduct
while promoting simplification and burden reduction; (4) specifies the
retroactive effect, if any; (5) adequately defines key terms; and (6)
addresses other important issues affecting clarity and general
draftsmanship under any guidelines issued by the Attorney General.
Section 3(c) of Executive Order 12988 requires Executive agencies to
review regulations in light of applicable standards in section 3(a) and
section 3(b) to determine whether they are met or it is unreasonable to
meet one or more of them. DOE has completed the required review and
determined that, to the extent permitted by law, this proposed rule
meets the relevant standards of Executive Order 12988.
G. Review Under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA)
requires each Federal agency to assess the effects of Federal
regulatory actions on State, local, and Tribal governments and the
private sector. Public Law 104-4, sec. 201 (codified at 2 U.S.C. 1531).
For a
[[Page 33094]]
proposed regulatory action likely to result in a rule that may cause
the expenditure by State, local, and Tribal governments, in the
aggregate, or by the private sector of $100 million or more in any one
year (adjusted annually for inflation), section 202 of UMRA requires a
Federal agency to publish a written statement that estimates the
resulting costs, benefits, and other effects on the national economy.
(2 U.S.C. 1532(a), (b)) The UMRA also requires a Federal agency to
develop an effective process to permit timely input by elected officers
of State, local, and Tribal governments on a proposed ``significant
intergovernmental mandate,'' and requires an agency plan for giving
notice and opportunity for timely input to potentially affected small
governments before establishing any requirements that might
significantly or uniquely affect small governments. On March 18, 1997,
DOE published a statement of policy on its process for
intergovernmental consultation under UMRA. 62 FR 12820. DOE's policy
statement is also available at http://energy.gov/gc/office-general-counsel.
Although the proposed rule does not contain a Federal
intergovernmental mandate, it may require expenditures of $100 million
or more on the private sector. Specifically, the proposed rule will
likely result in a final rule that could require expenditures of $100
million or more. Such expenditures may include: (1) Investment in
research and development and in capital expenditures by conventional
cooking product manufacturers in the years between the final rule and
the compliance date for the new standards, and (2) incremental
additional expenditures by consumers to purchase higher-efficiency
conventional cooking products, starting at the compliance date for the
applicable standard.
Section 202 of UMRA authorizes a Federal agency to respond to the
content requirements of UMRA in any other statement or analysis that
accompanies the proposed rule. 2 U.S.C. 1532(c). The content
requirements of section 202(b) of UMRA relevant to a private sector
mandate substantially overlap the economic analysis requirements that
apply under section 325(o) of EPCA and Executive Order 12866. The
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of the NOPR and the ``Regulatory
Impact Analysis'' section of the TSD for this proposed rule respond to
those requirements.
Under section 205 of UMRA, the Department is obligated to identify
and consider a reasonable number of regulatory alternatives before
promulgating a rule for which a written statement under section 202 is
required. 2 U.S.C. 1535(a). DOE is required to select from those
alternatives the most cost-effective and least burdensome alternative
that achieves the objectives of the proposed rule unless DOE publishes
an explanation for doing otherwise, or the selection of such an
alternative is inconsistent with law. This proposed rule would
establish energy conservation standards for conventional cooking
products that are designed to achieve the maximum improvement in energy
efficiency that DOE has determined to be both technologically feasible
and economically justified. A full discussion of the alternatives
considered by DOE is presented in the ``Regulatory Impact Analysis''
section of the TSD for the proposed rule.
H. Review Under the Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act,
1999
Section 654 of the Treasury and General Government Appropriations
Act, 1999 (Pub. L. 105-277) requires Federal agencies to issue a Family
Policymaking Assessment for any rule that may affect family well-being.
This rule would not have any impact on the autonomy or integrity of the
family as an institution. Accordingly, DOE has concluded that it is not
necessary to prepare a Family Policymaking Assessment.
I. Review Under Executive Order 12630
DOE has determined, under Executive Order 12630, ``Governmental
Actions and Interference with Constitutionally Protected Property
Rights'' 53 FR 8859 (Mar. 18, 1988), that this regulation would not
result in any takings that might require compensation under the Fifth
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
J. Review Under the Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act,
2001
Section 515 of the Treasury and General Government Appropriations
Act, 2001 (44 U.S.C. 3516, note) provides for Federal agencies to
review most disseminations of information to the public under
guidelines established by each agency pursuant to general guidelines
issued by OMB. OMB's guidelines were published at 67 FR 8452 (Feb. 22,
2002), and DOE's guidelines were published at 67 FR 62446 (Oct. 7,
2002). DOE has reviewed the NOPR under the OMB and DOE guidelines and
has concluded that it is consistent with applicable policies in those
guidelines.
K. Review Under Executive Order 13211
Executive Order 13211, ``Actions Concerning Regulations That
Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use'' 66 FR 28355
(May 22, 2001), requires Federal agencies to prepare and submit to OIRA
at OMB, a Statement of Energy Effects for any proposed significant
energy action. A ``significant energy action'' is defined as any action
by an agency that promulgates or is expected to lead to promulgation of
a final rule, and that: (1) Is a significant regulatory action under
Executive Order 12866, or any successor order; and (2) is likely to
have a significant adverse effect on the supply, distribution, or use
of energy, or (3) is designated by the Administrator of OIRA as a
significant energy action. For any proposed significant energy action,
the agency must give a detailed statement of any adverse effects on
energy supply, distribution, or use should the proposal be implemented,
and of reasonable alternatives to the action and their expected
benefits on energy supply, distribution, and use.
DOE has tentatively concluded that this regulatory action, which
sets forth energy conservation standards for conventional cooking
products, is not a significant energy action because the proposed
standards are not likely to have a significant adverse effect on the
supply, distribution, or use of energy, nor has it been designated as
such by the Administrator at OIRA. Accordingly, DOE has not prepared a
Statement of Energy Effects on the proposed rule.
L. Review Under the Information Quality Bulletin for Peer Review
On December 16, 2004, OMB, in consultation with the Office of
Science and Technology Policy (OSTP), issued its Final Information
Quality Bulletin for Peer Review (the Bulletin). 70 FR 2664 (Jan. 14,
2005). The Bulletin establishes that certain scientific information
shall be peer reviewed by qualified specialists before it is
disseminated by the Federal Government, including influential
scientific information related to agency regulatory actions. The
purpose of the bulletin is to enhance the quality and credibility of
the Government's scientific information. Under the Bulletin, the energy
conservation standards rulemaking analyses are ``influential scientific
information,'' which the Bulletin defines as scientific information the
agency reasonably can determine will have, or does have, a clear and
substantial impact on important public policies or private sector
decisions. 70 FR 2667.
[[Page 33095]]
In response to OMB's Bulletin, DOE conducted formal in-progress
peer reviews of the energy conservation standards development process
and analyses and has prepared a Peer Review Report pertaining to the
energy conservation standards rulemaking analyses. Generation of this
report involved a rigorous, formal, and documented evaluation using
objective criteria and qualified and independent reviewers to make a
judgment as to the technical/scientific/business merit, the actual or
anticipated results, and the productivity and management effectiveness
of programs and/or projects. The ``Energy Conservation Standards
Rulemaking Peer Review Report'' dated February 2007 has been
disseminated and is available at the following Web site:
www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/peer_review.html.
VII. Public Participation
A. Attendance at the Public Meeting
The time, date, and location of the public meeting are listed in
the DATES and ADDRESSES sections at the beginning of this notice. If
you plan to attend the public meeting, please notify Ms. Brenda Edwards
at (202) 586-2945 or [email protected]. Please note that
foreign nationals participating in the public meeting are subject to
advance security screening procedures which require advance notice
prior to attendance at the public meeting. If a foreign national wishes
to participate in the public meeting, please inform DOE of this fact as
soon as possible by contacting Ms. Regina Washington at (202) 586-1214
or by email: [email protected] so that the necessary
procedures can be completed.
Please also note that those wishing to bring laptops into the
Forrestal Building will be required to obtain a property pass. Visitors
should avoid bringing laptops, or allow an extra 45 minutes.
Due to the REAL ID Act implemented by the Department of Homeland
Security (DHS), there have been recent changes regarding ID
requirements for individuals wishing to enter Federal buildings from
specific states and U.S. territories. Driver's licenses from the
following states or territory will not be accepted for building entry
and one of the alternate forms of ID listed below will be required. DHS
has determined that regular driver's licenses (and ID cards) from the
following jurisdictions are not acceptable for entry into DOE
facilities: Alaska, American Samoa, Arizona, Louisiana, Maine,
Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Oklahoma, and Washington.
Acceptable alternate forms of Photo-ID include: U.S. Passport or
Passport Card; an Enhanced Driver's License or Enhanced ID-Card issued
by the states of Minnesota, New York or Washington (Enhanced licenses
issued by these states are clearly marked Enhanced or Enhanced Driver's
License); a military ID or other Federal government issued Photo-ID
card.
In addition, you can attend the public meeting via webinar. Webinar
registration information, participant instructions, and information
about the capabilities available to webinar participants will be
published on DOE's Web site at: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/rulemaking.aspx?ruleid=85. Participants are
responsible for ensuring their systems are compatible with the webinar
software.
B. Procedure for Submitting Prepared General Statements for
Distribution
Any person who has plans to present a prepared general statement
may request that copies of his or her statement be made available at
the public meeting. Such persons may submit requests, along with an
advance electronic copy of their statement in PDF (preferred),
Microsoft Word or Excel, WordPerfect, or text (ASCII) file format, to
the appropriate address shown in the ADDRESSES section at the beginning
of this notice. The request and advance copy of statements must be
received at least one week before the public meeting and may be
emailed, hand-delivered, or sent by mail. DOE prefers to receive
requests and advance copies via email. Please include a telephone
number to enable DOE staff to make follow-up contact, if needed.
C. Conduct of the Public Meeting
DOE will designate a DOE official to preside at the public meeting
and may also use a professional facilitator to aid discussion. The
meeting will not be a judicial or evidentiary-type public hearing, but
DOE will conduct it in accordance with section 336 of EPCA (42 U.S.C.
6306). A court reporter will be present to record the proceedings and
prepare a transcript. DOE reserves the right to schedule the order of
presentations and to establish the procedures governing the conduct of
the public meeting. After the public meeting, interested parties may
submit further comments on the proceedings as well as on any aspect of
the rulemaking until the end of the comment period.
The public meeting will be conducted in an informal, conference
style. DOE will present summaries of comments received before the
public meeting, allow time for prepared general statements by
participants, and encourage all interested parties to share their views
on issues affecting this rulemaking. Each participant will be allowed
to make a general statement (within time limits determined by DOE),
before the discussion of specific topics. DOE will allow, as time
permits, other participants to comment briefly on any general
statements.
At the end of all prepared statements on a topic, DOE will permit
participants to clarify their statements briefly and comment on
statements made by others. Participants should be prepared to answer
questions by DOE and by other participants concerning these issues. DOE
representatives may also ask questions of participants concerning other
matters relevant to this rulemaking. The official conducting the public
meeting will accept additional comments or questions from those
attending, as time permits. The presiding official will announce any
further procedural rules or modification of the above procedures that
may be needed for the proper conduct of the public meeting.
A transcript of the public meeting will be included in the docket,
which can be viewed as described in the Docket section at the beginning
of this notice. In addition, any person may buy a copy of the
transcript from the transcribing reporter.
D. Submission of Comments
DOE will accept comments, data, and information regarding this
proposed rule before or after the public meeting, but no later than the
date provided in the DATES section at the beginning of this proposed
rule. Interested parties may submit comments, data, and other
information using any of the methods described in the ADDRESSES section
at the beginning of this notice.
Submitting comments via regulations.gov. The regulations.gov Web
page will require you to provide your name and contact information.
Your contact information will be viewable to DOE Building Technologies
staff only. Your contact information will not be publicly viewable
except for your first and last names, organization name (if any), and
submitter representative name (if any). If your comment is not
processed properly because of technical difficulties, DOE will use this
information to contact you. If DOE cannot read your comment due to
technical difficulties and cannot contact you for clarification, DOE
may not be able to consider your comment.
[[Page 33096]]
However, your contact information will be publicly viewable if you
include it in the comment itself or in any documents attached to your
comment. Any information that you do not want to be publicly viewable
should not be included in your comment, nor in any document attached to
your comment. Otherwise, persons viewing comments will see only first
and last names, organization names, correspondence containing comments,
and any documents submitted with the comments.
Do not submit to regulations.gov information for which disclosure
is restricted by statute, such as trade secrets and commercial or
financial information (hereinafter referred to as Confidential Business
Information (CBI)). Comments submitted through regulations.gov cannot
be claimed as CBI. Comments received through the Web site will waive
any CBI claims for the information submitted. For information on
submitting CBI, see the Confidential Business Information section
below.
DOE processes submissions made through regulations.gov before
posting. Normally, comments will be posted within a few days of being
submitted. However, if large volumes of comments are being processed
simultaneously, your comment may not be viewable for up to several
weeks. Please keep the comment tracking number that regulations.gov
provides after you have successfully uploaded your comment.
Submitting comments via email, hand delivery/courier, or mail.
Comments and documents submitted via email, hand delivery, or mail also
will be posted to regulations.gov. If you do not want your personal
contact information to be publicly viewable, do not include it in your
comment or any accompanying documents. Instead, provide your contact
information in a cover letter. Include your first and last names, email
address, telephone number, and optional mailing address. The cover
letter will not be publicly viewable as long as it does not include any
comments
Include contact information each time you submit comments, data,
documents, and other information to DOE. If you submit via mail or hand
delivery/courier, please provide all items on a CD, if feasible. It is
not necessary to submit printed copies. No facsimiles (faxes) will be
accepted.
Comments, data, and other information submitted to DOE
electronically should be provided in PDF (preferred), Microsoft Word or
Excel, WordPerfect, or text (ASCII) file format. Provide documents that
are not secured, that are written in English, and that are free of any
defects or viruses. Documents should not contain special characters or
any form of encryption and, if possible, they should carry the
electronic signature of the author.
Campaign form letters. Please submit campaign form letters by the
originating organization in batches of between 50 to 500 form letters
per PDF or as one form letter with a list of supporters' names compiled
into one or more PDFs. This reduces comment processing and posting
time.
Confidential Business Information. According to 10 CFR 1004.11, any
person submitting information that he or she believes to be
confidential and exempt by law from public disclosure should submit via
email, postal mail, or hand delivery/courier two well-marked copies:
one copy of the document marked confidential including all the
information believed to be confidential, and one copy of the document
marked non-confidential with the information believed to be
confidential deleted. Submit these documents via email or on a CD, if
feasible. DOE will make its own determination about the confidential
status of the information and treat it according to its determination.
Factors of interest to DOE when evaluating requests to treat
submitted information as confidential include: (1) A description of the
items; (2) whether and why such items are customarily treated as
confidential within the industry; (3) whether the information is
generally known by or available from other sources; (4) whether the
information has previously been made available to others without
obligation concerning its confidentiality; (5) an explanation of the
competitive injury to the submitting person which would result from
public disclosure; (6) when such information might lose its
confidential character due to the passage of time; and (7) why
disclosure of the information would be contrary to the public interest.
It is DOE's policy that all comments may be included in the public
docket, without change and as received, including any personal
information provided in the comments (except information deemed to be
exempt from public disclosure).
E. Issues on Which DOE Seeks Comment
Although DOE welcomes comments on any aspect of this proposal, DOE
is particularly interested in receiving comments and views of
interested parties concerning the following issues:
1. DOE seeks comment on its proposal to develop two distinct
component standards under separate timetables, and whether issues of
product design and development, consumer utility and more broadly,
cumulative regulatory burden concerns would arise as a result of its
proposal (see section III.A of this notice).
2. DOE requests comment on its decision to defer the consideration
of adopting energy conservation standards for conventional cooking tops
until a representative, repeatable and reproducible test method for
cooking tops is finalized. DOE invites data and information that will
allow it to further conduct the analysis of cooking tops, particularly
when using a water-heating method to evaluate energy consumption. (see
section III.B of this notice).
3. DOE requests comment on the proposed product classes for
residential conventional cooking products. DOE requests comment on
establishing separate product classes for freestanding and built-in/
slide-in ovens. DOE also welcomes comment and data on the determination
that conventional gas cooking products with higher input rates do not
warrant establishing a separate product class. (see section IV.A.2 of
this notice).
4. DOE seeks data that characterize the energy consumption of
residential steam ovens currently available on the market and requests
comment regarding whether a test procedure that accurately measures the
energy of a steam cooking mode exists. DOE also seeks comment on the
use of optimized burner and cavity design (and other options listed in
Table IV-5) to meet the proposed efficiency levels discussed in section
I.A.1.b (see section IV.A.3 of this notice).
5. DOE requests comment and data regarding additional design
options or variants of the considered design options that can increase
the range of considered efficiency improvements for conventional
cooking products, including design options that may not yet be found in
the market (see section IV.B.2 of this notice).
6. DOE requests comment on the proposed baseline and incremental
efficiency levels. DOE specifically requests inputs and test data on
the efficiency improvements associated with the design options
identified at each incremental efficiency level that were determined
based on either the analysis from the 2009 TSD or updated based on
testing and reverse engineering analyses for this NOPR. DOE also seeks
comment and data on the proposed slopes and intercepts used to
characterize the relationship between IAEC and oven cavity volume for
each
[[Page 33097]]
conventional oven product class (see section IV.C.3 of this notice).
7. DOE requests input and data on the proposed incremental
manufacturing production costs for each efficiency level analyzed that
were determined based on either the analysis from the 2009 TSD adjusted
to reflect changes in the PPI or costs determined based on testing and
reverse engineering analyses conducted for this NOPR (see section
IV.C.4 of this notice).
8. DOE seeks comment on the tentative determination that the
proposed efficiency levels and design options would not impact the
consumer utility of conventional ovens (see section IV.C.5 of this
notice).
9. DOE requests comments on repair costs and frequency of repair
incurred by gas standard and self-clean ovens with Glo-bar ignition and
electronic spark ignition technologies. In this NOPR, DOE used data
from 2008 provided by the industry (see section IV.E.5 of this notice
for details).
10. DOE requests data that would allow for use of different price
trend projections for electric and gas cooking products. (see section
IV.H.3.b of this notice)
11. To estimate the impact on shipments of the price increase for
the considered efficiency levels, DOE determined that the overall
market will be inelastic to price changes and will not impact
shipments. DOE welcomes stakeholder input on the effect of amended
standards on impacts across products within the same fuel class and
equipment. (see section IV.G of this notice).
12. DOE requests comment on the reasonableness of the approach DOE
has used to consider the rebound effect with higher-efficiency cooking
products. (see section IV.F.3 of this notice)
13. DOE requests comment on DOE's approach for estimating monetary
benefits associated with emissions reductions. (see section IV.L of
this notice).
14. DOE seeks comment on the proposed manufacturer markup of 1.20
for all residential conventional ovens (see section IV.J.2).
15. DOE seeks comment on the potential domestic employment impacts
to residential conventional oven manufacturers at the proposed
efficiency levels (see section V.B.2).
16. DOE requests comment on any potential manufacturer capacity
constraints caused by the proposed standards in the NOPR, TSL 2 (see
section V.B.2).
17. DOE requests comment on manufacturer subgroups that DOE should
analyze and/or types of residential conventional oven manufacturers for
the subgroup analysis (see section V.B.2).
18. DOE seeks comment on the compliance costs of any other
regulations residential conventional oven manufacturers must make,
especially if compliance with those regulations is required three years
before or after the estimated compliance date of this proposed standard
(2019) (see section V.B.2).
19. DOE requests comments on the number of small businesses
identified and on the impacts of new and amended energy conservation
standards on small businesses (see section VI.B).
VIII. Approval of the Office of the Secretary
The Secretary of Energy has approved publication of this proposed
rule.
List of Subjects in 10 CFR Part 430
Administrative practice and procedure, Confidential business
information, Energy conservation, Household appliances, Imports,
Intergovernmental relations, and Small businesses.
Issued in Washington, DC, on May 29, 2015.
David T. Danielson,
Assistant Secretary, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.
For the reasons set forth in the preamble, DOE proposes to amend
part 430 of chapter II, subchapter D, of title 10 of the Code of
Federal Regulations, as set forth below:
PART 430--ENERGY CONSERVATION PROGRAM FOR CONSUMER PRODUCTS
0
1. The authority citation for part 430 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 6291-6309; 28 U.S.C. 2461 note.
0
2. In Sec. 430.2 revise the definitions of ``conventional cooking
top'' and ``conventional oven'' to read as follows:
Sec. 430.2 Definitions.
* * * * *
Conventional cooking top means a class of kitchen ranges and ovens
which is a household cooking appliance consisting of a horizontal
surface containing one or more surface units which include either a gas
flame or electric resistance heating. This includes the conventional
cooking top portion of a conventional range.
Conventional oven means a class of kitchen ranges and ovens which
is a household cooking appliance consisting of one or more compartments
intended for the cooking or heating of food by means of either a gas
flame or electric resistance heating. It does not include portable or
countertop ovens which use electric resistance heating for the cooking
or heating of food and are designed for an electrical supply of
approximately 120 volts. This includes the conventional oven(s) portion
of a conventional range.
* * * * *
0
3. In Sec. 430.32 revise paragraph (j) to read as follows:
Sec. 430.32 Energy and water conservation standards and their
compliance dates.
* * * * *
(j) Cooking Products.
(1) Gas cooking products with an electrical supply cord
manufactured on or after January 1, 1990, shall not be equipped with a
constant burning pilot light.
(2) Gas cooking products without an electrical supply cord
manufactured on or after April 9, 2012, shall not be equipped with a
constant burning pilot light.
(3) Conventional ovens manufactured on or after [INSERT DATE 3
YEARS AFTER FINAL RULE Federal Register PUBLICATION] shall have an
integrated annual energy consumption no greater than:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Integrated annual energy
Product class consumption
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electric Standard Oven, Free-standing.. 122.5 + (31.8 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Standard Oven, Built-In/Slide- 128.6 + (31.8 x Rated Cavity
In. Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing 163.2 + (42.3 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Electric Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/ 169.1 + (42.3 x Rated Cavity
Slide-In. Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Standard Oven, Free-Standing....... 492.9 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Standard Oven, Built-In/Slide-In... 499.5 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Free-Standing..... 746.7 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
[[Page 33098]]
Gas Self-Clean Oven, Built-In/Slide-In. 755.5 + (214.4 x Rated Cavity
Volume in cubic feet) kWh/yr.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The Rated Cavity Volume is the volume of the oven cavity in cubic
feet as measured using the final DOE test procedure at 10 CFR part
430, subpart B, appendix I.
(4) Microwave-only ovens and countertop convection microwave ovens
manufactured on or after June 17, 2016 shall have an average standby
power not more than 1.0 watt. Built-in and over-the-range convection
microwave ovens manufactured on or after June 17, 2016 shall have an
average standby power not more than 2.2 watts.
* * * * *
[FR Doc. 2015-13764 Filed 6-9-15; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P