[Federal Register Volume 79, Number 30 (Thursday, February 13, 2014)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 8656-8667]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2014-01526]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Fish and Wildlife Service
50 CFR Part 17
[Docket No. FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133; 4500030113]
RIN 1018-AY78
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Remove the Modoc
Sucker From the Federal List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.
ACTION: Proposed rule and 12-month petition finding; notice of
availability of draft post-delisting monitoring plan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service), propose to
remove the Modoc sucker (Catostomus microps) from the Federal List of
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife. This determination is based on a
thorough review of the best available scientific and commercial
information, which indicates that the threats to this species have been
eliminated or reduced to the point that the species no longer meets the
definition of an endangered species or a threatened species under the
Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act). If finalized, the
effects of this rule would be to remove the Modoc sucker from the List
of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife. This proposed rule, if made
final, would also remove the currently designated critical habitat for
the Modoc sucker throughout its range. This document also constitutes
our 12-month finding on a petition to reclassify the Modoc sucker from
endangered to threatened. We are seeking information and comments from
the public regarding this 12-month finding and proposed rule. In
addition to the proposed rule, we are also seeking information and
comments on the draft post-delisting monitoring plan.
DATES: We will accept comments received or postmarked on or before
April 14, 2014. We must receive requests for public hearings, in
writing, at the address shown in the FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT
section by March 31, 2014.
ADDRESSES: Comment submission: You may submit comments by one of the
following methods:
(1) Electronically: Go to the Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov. In the Search box, enter FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133,
which is the docket number for this rulemaking. Then, in the Search
panel on the left side of the screen, under the Document Type heading,
click on the Proposed Rules link to locate this document. You may
submit a comment by clicking on ``Comment Now!''
(2) By hard copy: Submit by U.S. mail or hand-delivery to: Public
Comments Processing, Attn: FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133; Division of Policy and
Directives Management; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; 4401 N. Fairfax
Drive, MS 2042-PDM; Arlington, VA 22203.
We request that you send comments only by the methods described
above. We will post all comments on http://www.regulations.gov. This
generally means that we will post any personal information you provide
us (see the Information Requested section below for more information).
Document availability: A copy of the Species Report referenced
throughout this document can be viewed at http://ecos.fws.gov/speciesProfile/profile/speciesProfile.action?spcode=E053, at http://www.regulations.gov under Docket No. FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133, or at the
Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office's Web site at http://www.fws.gov/klamathfallsfwo. The draft post-delisting monitoring plan
will be posted on our Endangered Species Program's national Web page
(http://endangered.fws.gov), and the Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife
Office Web page (http://fws.gov/klamathfallsfwo), and on the Federal
eRulemaking Portal at http://www.regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Laurie Sada, Field Supervisor, U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service, Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office, 1936
California Avenue, Klamath Falls, OR 97601; by telephone 541-885-8481,
or by facsimile 541-885-7837. If you use a telecommunications device
for the deaf (TDD), call the Federal Information Relay Service (FIRS)
at 800-877-8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Information Requested
We intend any final action resulting from this proposal to be based
on the best scientific and commercial data available, and be as
accurate and as effective as possible. Therefore, we request comments
or information from other governmental agencies, tribes, the
[[Page 8657]]
scientific community, industry, or other interested parties concerning
this proposed rule. We particularly seek comments concerning:
(1) Biological information on Modoc sucker, including additional
information on its distribution, population size, and population trend;
(2) Relevant information concerning any current or likely future
threats (or lack thereof) to Modoc sucker, including the extent and
adequacy of Federal and State protection and management that would be
provided to Modoc sucker as a delisted species;
(3) Current or planned activities within the range of Modoc sucker
and their possible impacts to the species;
(4) Regional climate change models and whether they are reliable
and credible to use in assessing the effects of climate change on Modoc
sucker and its habitat;
(5) Our draft post-delisting monitoring plan. We request
information regarding how best to conduct post-delisting monitoring,
should the proposed delisting lead to a final delisting rule (see Post-
Delisting Monitoring Plan Overview section below, which briefly
outlines the goals of the draft plan that is available for public
comment concurrent with publication of this proposed rule). Such
information might include suggestions regarding the monitoring focus,
procedures for determining site occupancy and abundance, or for
monitoring threats and recruitment over the course of at least 5 years.
Please include sufficient information with your submission (such as
scientific journal articles or other publications) to allow us to
verify any scientific or commercial information you include. Please
note that submissions merely stating support for or opposition to the
action under consideration without providing supporting information,
although noted, will not be considered in making a determination, as
section 4(b)(1)(A) of the Act directs that determinations as to whether
any species is an endangered or threatened species must be made
``solely on the basis of the best scientific and commercial data
available.''
You may submit your comments and materials concerning this proposed
rule by one of the methods listed in ADDRESSES. We request that you
send comments only by the methods described in ADDRESSES. If you submit
information via http://www.regulations.gov, your entire submission--
including any personal identifying information--will be posted on the
Web site. If your submission is made via a hardcopy that includes
personal identifying information, you may request at the top of your
document that we withhold this information from public review. However,
we cannot guarantee that we will be able to do so. We will post all
hardcopy submissions on http://www.regulations.gov.
Comments and materials we receive, as well as supporting
documentation we used in preparing this proposed rule, will be
available for public inspection on http://www.regulations.gov, or by
appointment, during normal business hours, at the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office (see FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT).
Public Hearings
Section 4(b)(5) of the Act provides for one or more public hearings
on this proposal, if requested. We must receive your request within 45
days after the date of this Federal Register publication. Send your
request to the address shown in FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT. We
will schedule public hearings on this proposal, if any are requested,
and announce the dates, times, and places of those hearings, as well as
how to obtain reasonable accommodations, in the Federal Register and
local newspapers at least 15 days before the hearing.
Previous Federal Action
On January 31, 1984, we proposed to list the Modoc sucker as an
endangered species and designate critical habitat under the Act based
on threats from habitat degradation and loss due to activities (such as
overgrazing by cattle) that cause erosion and siltation (49 FR 3892).
These activities and resulting erosion were thought to have eliminated
natural barriers separating Modoc suckers and the Sacramento suckers
(Catostomus occidentalis), allowing hybridization and a loss of genetic
integrity of Modoc sucker. We published a final rule listing Modoc
sucker as an endangered species and designating critical habitat in the
Federal Register on June 11, 1985 (50 FR 24526). The final rule also
included predation by the nonnative brown trout (Salmo trutta) as a
threat to Modoc sucker.
Under the Act, we maintain the Lists of Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife and Plants in title 50 of the Code of Federal Regulations
(CFR) at 50 CFR 17.11 (for animals) and 17.12 (for plants) (Lists). We
amend the Lists by publishing final rules in the Federal Register.
Section 4(c)(2)(A) of the Act requires that we conduct a review of
listed species at least once every 5 years. Section 4(c)(2)(B) requires
that we determine: (1) Whether a species no longer meets the definition
of endangered or threatened and should be removed from the Lists
(delisted), (2) whether a species listed as endangered more properly
meets the definition of threatened and should be reclassified to
threatened (downlisted), or (3) whether a species listed as threatened
more properly meets the definition of endangered and should be
reclassified to endangered (uplisted). In accordance with 50 CFR
424.11(d), using the best scientific and commercial data available, we
will consider a species for delisting only if the data substantiate
that the species is neither endangered nor threatened for one or more
of the following reasons: (1) The species is considered extinct; (2)
the species is considered recovered; or (3) the original data available
when the species was listed, or the interpretation of such data, were
in error.
We published a notice announcing the initiation of a review of the
status of Modoc sucker under section 4(c)(2) of the Act on March 22,
2006 (71 FR 14538). We notified the public of completion of the 5-year
review on May 21, 2010 (75 FR 28636). The 5-year review, completed on
August 17, 2009 (Service 2009), resulted in a recommendation to change
the status of the species from endangered to threatened. A copy of the
2009 5-year review for Modoc sucker is available on the Service's
Environmental Conservation Online System (http://http://ecos.fws.gov/docs/five_year_review/doc2546.pdf).
On December 21, 2011, we received a petition dated December 19,
2011, from the Pacific Legal Foundation, requesting the Service to
reclassify the Modoc sucker from endangered to threatened. The petition
was based on the analysis and recommendations contained in the most
recent 5-year review. On June 4, 2012 (77 FR 32922), we published in
the Federal Register a 90-day finding for the 2011 petition to
reclassify the species. In our 90-day finding, we determined the 2011
petition provided substantial information indicating the petitioned
actions may be warranted, and we initiated a status review for Modoc
sucker. This proposed rule to remove the Modoc sucker from the Federal
List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife also constitutes the 12-
month finding for the species.
Background
A completed scientific analysis is presented in detail in the Modoc
Sucker Species Report (Service 2013, entire), which is available at
http://www.regulations.gov at Docket Number
[[Page 8658]]
FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133. The Species Report was prepared by Service
biologists to provide thorough discussion of the species ecology,
biological needs, and analysis of the threats that may be impacting the
species. The Species Report includes discussion of the following:
Taxonomy and species description, habitat, biology, distribution and
abundance, summary of factors affecting the species, and recovery. This
detailed information is summarized in the following paragraphs of this
Background section, the Recovery and Recovery Plan Implementation
section, and the Summary of Factors Affecting the Species section.
The Modoc sucker is a small species of fish in the family
Catostomidae. Individuals measure 2.8 to 3.3 inches (70 to 85
millimeters) in length at full maturity, with few adults exceeding 6.3
to 7.1 in (160 to 180 mm). Modoc suckers are opportunistic feeders with
diets consisting of algae, small benthic invertebrates, and detritus.
Modoc sucker are primarily found in relatively small (second to
fourth order), perennial and intermittent streams. They occupy an
intermediate zone between the high-gradient and higher-elevation,
coldwater trout zone and the low-gradient and low-elevation, warm-water
fish zone. The pool habitat occupied by Modoc suckers generally
includes fine sediments to small cobble bottoms, substantial detritus,
and abundant cover. Spawning habitat appears to include gravel
substrates in the relatively low-energy, flowing portions of pools or
the protected area downstream of rocks (Reid 2008a). During low summer
flows, pools inhabited by Modoc suckers can become isolated, which
eliminates interaction of suckers within and among streams. Cover can
be provided by overhanging banks, larger rocks, woody debris, and
aquatic rooted vegetation or filamentous algae. Larvae occupy shallow
vegetated margins; juveniles tend to remain free-swimming in the
shallows of large pools, particularly near vegetated areas; and larger
juveniles and adults remain mostly on, or close to, the bottom (Martin
1972; Moyle and Marciochi 1975; Moyle 2002).
At the time of listing, the species was known to occupy seven
streams in the Turner Creek (Turner Creek, Washington Creek, and
Hulbert Creek) and Ash Creek (Johnson Creek, Rush Creek, Dutch Flat
Creek, and Ash Creek) sub-basins of the Pit River drainage in
northeastern California. However, three of those streams (Rush Creek,
Dutch Flat Creek, and Ash Creek) and a fourth (Willow Creek) in the Ash
Creek sub-basin were presumed lost due to hybridization with Sacramento
suckers (Catostomus occidentalis). It is now recognized that the
historical distribution also included one additional stream (Garden
Gulch Creek) in the Turner Creek sub-basin and three additional streams
in the Goose Lake sub-basin (Thomas Creek, an unnamed tributary to
Thomas Creek, and Cox Creek) in southern Oregon, a disjoined, upstream
sub-basin of the Pit River. Also, a population has been established in
Coffee Mill Creek in the Turner Creek sub-basin--a stream not known to
have been occupied at the time of listing--as a result of California
Department of Fish and Wildlife transplanting efforts.
The current known distribution of Modoc sucker includes an
estimated 42.5 miles (68.4 kilometers) of occupied habitat in 12
streams within 3 sub-basins, compared to an estimated distribution of
12.9 miles (20.8 kilometers) of occupied habitat in 7 seven streams
within 2 sub-basins at the time of listing. Although population trend
data is not available because survey methods have varied among years,
surveys indicate that Modoc sucker populations still occur in all
streams where Modoc sucker populations were known to occur
historically. Surveys also indicate that Modoc suckers appear to occupy
nearly all available suitable habitat within the streams where they
occur in the Turner Creek, Ash Creek, and Goose Lake sub-basins. Land
ownership throughout the species' range is 51 percent public lands
(primarily the Modoc National Forest in northeastern California and the
Fremont-Winema National Forests in southern Oregon), 48 percent private
lands, and 1 percent State land.
For a detailed discussion of Modoc sucker taxonomy and species
description, habitat, biology, and distribution and abundance, please
see the ``Background'' section of the Species Report, which includes
subsections on ``taxonomy and species description'', ``habitat'',
``biology'', and ``distribution and abundance'' (Service 2013, pp. 5-
23).
Recovery and Recovery Plan Implementation
Section 4(f) of the Act directs us to develop and implement
recovery plans for the conservation and survival of endangered and
threatened species unless we determine that such a plan will not
promote the conservation of the species. Under section 4(f)(1)(B)(ii),
recovery plans must, to the maximum extent practicable, include:
``Objective, measurable criteria which, when met, would result in a
determination, in accordance with the provisions of [section 4 of the
Act], that the species be removed from the list.'' However, revisions
to the list (adding, removing, or reclassifying a species) must reflect
determinations made in accordance with sections 4(a)(1) and 4(b) of the
Act. Section 4(a)(1) requires that the Secretary determine whether a
species is endangered or threatened (or not) because of one or more of
five threat factors: (A) The present or threatened destruction,
modification, or curtailment of its habitat or range; (B)
overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or
educational purposes; (C) disease or predation; (D) the inadequacy of
existing regulatory mechanisms; or (E) other natural or human-made
factors affecting its continued existence. Section 4(b) of the Act
requires that the determination be made ``solely on the basis of the
best scientific and commercial data available.'' Therefore, recovery
criteria should indicate when a species is no longer an endangered
species or threatened species under the five statutory factors.
Thus, while recovery plans provide important guidance to the
Service, States, and other partners on methods of minimizing threats to
listed species and measurable objectives against which to measure
progress towards recovery, they are not regulatory documents and cannot
substitute for the determinations and promulgation of regulations
required under section 4(a)(1) of the Act. A decision to revise the
status of or remove a species from the Federal List of Endangered and
Threatened Plants (50 CFR 17.12) is ultimately based on an analysis of
the best scientific and commercial data then available to determine
whether a species is no longer an endangered species or a threatened
species, regardless of whether that information differs from the
recovery plan.
At the time of listing, the Service, the California Department of
Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), and the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) were
developing an ``Action Plan for the Recovery of the Modoc sucker''
(Action Plan). The April 27, 1983, revision of this Action Plan was
formally signed by all participants in 1984 (Service 1984). We
determined that the Action Plan and its 1989 revisions (Service 1984,
1989) adequately fulfilled the requirements of a recovery plan, and in
a 1992 memorandum from the Regional Director (Region 1) to the
Service's Director, we adopted it as the Recovery Plan for the Modoc
sucker (Service 1992) and determined we would not
[[Page 8659]]
prepare a separate recovery plan pursuant to section 4(f) of the Act.
The Recovery Plan included downlisting and delisting objectives
(considered to be equivalent to criteria). Below, we outline the
objectives to reclassify the Modoc sucker from endangered to threatened
and the objectives to remove Modoc sucker from the List of Endangered
and Threatened Wildlife, and we discuss progress towards meeting the
objectives.
Downlisting objective 1: Maintain the integrity of extant habitats
and prevent the invasion of Sacramento suckers into isolated stream
reaches of the Turner-Hulbert-Washington Creek system and upper Johnson
Creek. The intent of meeting this objective was to halt the threat of
further loss and degradation of habitat (Factor A) and to address the
threat of genetic introgression from hybridization with Sacramento
sucker (Factor E).
Downlisting objective 2: Restore and maintain the quality of
aquatic habitat conditions within these watersheds and thereby increase
their carrying capacity for Modoc suckers. The intent of this objective
was to further address habitat loss and degradation (Factor A) through
active restoration, with the ultimate goal to allow the habitat to
support an increase in population numbers. These efforts would improve
the resiliency of the species (ability to withstand and recover from
stochastic events, such as drought).
Downlisting objective 3: Secure populations of Modoc sucker have
been maintained in these creeks for 3 consecutive years. The intent of
this objective was to monitor Modoc sucker populations to ensure
recruitment had occurred and is based on the life history of Modoc
suckers, in which individuals mature at age 2+ years.
Since the time of listing, actions have been taken to maintain or
improve Modoc sucker habitat within Turner Creek, Hulbert Creek,
Washington Creek, and Johnson Creek as it relates to downlisting
objectives 1 and 2. The Service and partners have implemented projects
and management that maintain the integrity of extant habitat
(downlisting objective 1) and restore and maintain the quality of
habitat (downlisting objective 2) to provide effective stabilization of
stream banks, fencing to exclude livestock grazing in riparian areas,
restoration of riparian vegetation, and increased instream habitat. On
public lands, 1.5 miles of Washington Creek, 0.2 mi of Hulbert Creek,
0.5 mi of Coffee Mill Creek, and approximately 1.5 mi of Turner Creek
have been fenced to protect riparian habitat (Reid 2008a, p. 85; M.
Yamagiwa, USFS, personal communication). Additionally, since Modoc
sucker was listed in 1985, fencing has been constructed to exclude
cattle on Rush Creek and Johnson Creek below Higgins Flat (Modoc
National Forest). Fencing led to immediately protecting extant habitat
(immediate, near term), and allowed habitat to recover. This improved
the quality and carrying capacity in the long term, thus addressing
downlisting objectives 1 and 2. Extensive landowner outreach by the
Service, USFS, and State agencies, and improved livestock grazing
management practices in Modoc and Lassen Counties have also resulted in
improved protection of riparian corridors on private lands in the
Turner and Ash Creek sub-basins. Protection of riparian habitat by
excluding cattle and by improving livestock grazing management
practices on both public and private lands has resulted in improved
habitat conditions along these streams as a result of reduced erosion
and improved vegetative and hydrologic characteristics (Reid 2008a, pp.
41, 85-86).
Active habitat restoration (downlisting objective 2) has been
implemented in many locations throughout the species range since the
species was listed. Restoration on the Modoc National Forest has led to
improved habitat conditions in riparian areas along many of the streams
occupied by Modoc suckers. Willows have been planted along portions of
streams occupied by Modoc suckers in the Turner Creek and Ash Creek
sub-basins to stabilize streambanks and provide shading and cover (Reid
2008a, pp. 85-86; USFS 2008, p. 16). As a result of riparian habitat
improvements and improved livestock grazing management practices,
channel widths have narrowed and created deeper habitat preferred by
Modoc suckers (USFS 2008, p. 16). Other habitat restoration activities
include juniper revetment (the use of cut juniper trees to stabilize
streambanks), creation and expansion of pool habitat, placement of
boulders within streams to provide cover and shade, and restoration of
channel headcuts (areas of deep erosion) to prevent further downcutting
of channels (Reid 2008a, pp. 85-86; USFS 2008, p. 16).
Habitat conditions in designated critical habitat and other
occupied streams have steadily improved since listing and have
sustained populations of Modoc suckers for at least 25 years, although
recent habitat surveys indicate erosion and sedimentation continue to
be a problem along lower Turner Creek. However, this degraded reach
amounts to 2.4 percent (1.01 mi/42.5 mi) of the total length of streams
occupied by Modoc sucker. Land management practices employed on public
and private lands since the early 1980s are expected to continue, or
improve, thereby maintaining stable to upward habitat trends. Thus, we
believe the integrity of extant habitat has been maintained (part of
downlisting objective 1) and the quality of habitat has been restored
and maintained through restoration efforts (downlisting objective 2),
and we conclude that these portions of the downlisting objectives have
been met.
While part of downlisting objective 1 was to prevent invasion of
Sacramento sucker, further research into the magnitude and consequences
of genetic introgression with Sacramento suckers has led us to conclude
that this part of the objective is no longer relevant. Observed levels
of genetic introgression by Sacramento suckers in streams dominated by
Modoc suckers are low, even when there are no physical barriers between
the two species (Topinka 2006, pp. 64-65). This suggests that either
ecological differences, selective pressures, or other natural
reproductive-isolating mechanisms are sufficient to maintain the
integrity of the species, even after more than a century of habitat
alteration by human activities. Currently, only Ash Creek exhibits a
considerable degree of introgression. Scientists who have studied
suckers in western North America consider that, throughout their
evolutionary history, hybridization among sympatric native fishes is
not unusual and may actually provide an adaptive advantage (Dowling and
Secor 1997, pp. 612-613; Dowling 2005, p. 10; Topinka 2006, p. 73;
Tranah and May 2006, p. 313). Reexamination of information on natural
barriers, morphological characters, and new genetic information that
were unavailable at the time of listing indicate that hybridization is
not a threat to the Modoc sucker and may be part of its natural
evolutionary history. Thus, because of the new information that has
become available since the time of listing, we believe this portion of
the downlisting criterion, to prevent the invasion of Sacramento
suckers, is obsolete and no longer needs to be met.
Several estimates of population size of Modoc suckers in Turner
Creek, Hulbert Creek, Washington Creek, and Johnson Creek have been
completed since the 1970s, which found that Modoc sucker populations
have been maintained in the Turner-Hulbert-Washington Creek system and
upper Johnson Creek for 3 consecutive years (downlisting objective 3).
Modoc suckers appear broadly
[[Page 8660]]
distributed throughout suitable habitat in these streams. Although the
observations during each survey may not be directly comparable due to
differences in sampling methods, there does not appear to be any major
changes in observations of these stream populations over time.
Observations of Modoc suckers in Hulbert Creek and Johnson Creek prior
to 2008 appear to be greater than observations made in 2008 and 2012.
However, this may be explained by differences in survey methods,
inclusion of young-of-the-year suckers in earlier counts, and the fact
that some numbers reported are population estimates rather than counts
on individuals. Although population monitoring has not been conducted
on an annual basis, sucker surveys conducted in 2008 and 2012 show that
Modoc sucker populations have been maintained, and are still well
established, in Turner Creek, Washington Creek, Hulbert Creek, and
Johnson Creek--as well as each of the other streams known to be
occupied at the time of listing--more than 25 years after listing.
Thus, we believe that populations of Modoc sucker have been maintained
(remained stable), demonstrating successful recruitment given that
individuals mature at 2+ years, and that downlisting objective 3 has
been met.
Delisting objective 1: The remaining suitable, but presently
unoccupied, stream reaches within Turner-Hulbert Creek-Washington Creek
and Rush-Johnson Creek drainages must be renovated and restored to
Modoc sucker. The intent of this objective was to further address
habitat loss and degradation (Factor A) through active restoration.
Once occupied, these stream reaches would demonstrate that the habitat
is restored and has expanded. This restoration will allow the habitat
to support an increase in population numbers, improving redundancy
(having multiple populations that provide security from the risk of
extinction of the spices given the low probability that all populations
will be negatively affected by a single catastrophic event) and
resiliency (ability to withstand and recover from stochastic events,
such as drought) of the species.
Delisting objective 2: Secure populations of Modoc suckers must be
reestablished in at least two other streams outside of the above
drainages, but within the historical range. The intent of this
objective was to increase both habitat available and the number of
populations, thereby increasing redundancy of the Modoc sucker
populations.
Delisting objective 3: All populations must have sustained
themselves through a climactic cycle that includes drought and flood
events. This objective was intended to indicate that Modoc suckers have
responded positively to habitat protection and restoration and have a
sufficient number of populations and individuals to withstand and
recover from environmental variability and stochastic events.
At the time of listing, it was estimated that Modoc suckers
occupied 2.0 mi (3.2 km) of habitat in Turner Creek, 0.8 mi (1.3 km) of
habitat in Hulbert Creek, 0.5 mi (0.8 km) of habitat in Washington
Creek, 4.6 mi (7.4 km) in Rush Creek, and 1.2 mi (1.9 km) of habitat in
Johnson Creek (Reid 2008a, p. 25). Since the time of listing, Reid
(2008a, p. 25) estimated that there was 5.5 mi (8.9 km) of available
habitat in Turner Creek, 3.0 mi (4.8 km) in Hulbert Creek, 4.1 mi (6.6
km) in Washington Creek, 4.6 mi (7.4 km) in Rush Creek, and 2.7 mi (4.3
km) in Johnson Creek. Habitat conditions along Turner Creek, Hulbert
Creek, Washington Creek, and Johnson Creek have improved since the time
of listing. Modoc suckers currently occupy all available habitats
within Turner Creek, Hulbert Creek, Rush Creek, and Johnson Creek;
Modoc suckers occupy 3.4 mi (5.5 km) of the available habitat in
Washington Creek (Reid 2008a, p. 25). Therefore, we believe delisting
objective 1 has been met.
The Recovery Plan stated that additional populations were needed to
provide population redundancy (delisting objective 2). New information
indicates the presence of Modoc sucker populations in four streams that
were not known to be occupied at the time of listing (Garden Gulch
Creek in the Turner Creek sub-basin and Thomas Creek, an unnamed
tributary to Thomas Creek, and Cox Creek in the Goose Lake sub-basin).
In addition, a population of Modoc sucker has been established as a
result of transplanting in Coffee Mill Creek in the Turner Creek sub-
basin. In 1987, CDFW transplanted Modoc suckers from Washington Creek
to Coffee Mill Creek to establish an additional population in the
Turner Creek sub-basin (CDFW 1986, p. 11). Modoc suckers appear to be
well established and relatively abundant; spawning adult and juvenile
suckers have been consistently observed there during visual surveys
(Reid 2009, p. 25). Therefore, we believe that the intent of delisting
objective 2 has been met by the discovery of Modoc sucker populations
in additional locations and the establishment of one population.
The northwestern corner of the Great Basin where the Modoc sucker
occurs is naturally subject to extended droughts, during which even the
larger water bodies such as Goose Lake have dried up (Laird 1971, pp.
57-58). Regional droughts have occurred every 10 to 20 years in the
last century (Reid 2008, pp. 43-44). Collections of Modoc suckers from
Rush Creek and Thomas Creek near the end of the ``dustbowl'' drought of
the 1920s to 1930s (Hubbs 1934, p. 1; Reid 2008a, p. 79) indicate that
the species was able to persist in those streams even through a
prolonged and severe drought. Modoc suckers have persisted throughout
the species' historical range since the time it was listed in 1985,
even though the region has experienced several pronounced droughts as
well as heavy-precipitation, high-water years (for example, 2011),
indicating that the species is at least somewhat resilient to weather
and hydrologic fluctuations. Therefore, we believe delisting objective
3 has been met.
The Recovery Plan was based on the best scientific and commercial
information available at the time. In evaluating the extent to which
recovery objectives have been met, we must also assess new information
that has become available since the species was listed and the recovery
action plan prepared. As noted above, research and new information
since the time of listing and the recovery action plan indicate that
hybridization and introgression with Sacramento sucker is not a
substantial threat to Modoc suckers. Additionally, Modoc suckers were
found occupying areas they were not known to occupy at the time of
listing. This new information alters the extent to which the recovery
objectives related to hybridization and establishing new populations
need to be met. In the case of hybridization and genetic introgression,
we found that objective no longer relevant given the lack of threat to
the species. With regard to the objective to establish new populations,
we found that the discovery of additional populations substantially met
the intent of the objective to provide for population redundancy so
that reestablishing two additional populations was no longer needed.
Additionally, we must assess whether a recovery plan adequately
addresses all the factors affecting the species. The recovery
objectives did not directly address predation by brown trout and other
nonnative fish or the point at which that threat would be ameliorated,
although actions were included. Since the time of listing, additional
predatory nonnative fish have been recorded in streams containing Modoc
suckers. Actions to address nonnative predatory
[[Page 8661]]
species and an assessment of their impact are discussed below. While
not specific to predatory nonnative fish, attainment of delisting
objective 3, indicating that Modoc sucker populations have sustained
themselves since listing in 1985, provides some indication that
nonnative predatory fish are no longer a serious threat to the species'
persistence. Climate change is an additional threat identified since
listing and preparation of the Recovery Plan. All threats, including
those identified since listing and preparation of the Recovery Plan are
further discussed below. Based on our analysis of the best available
information, we conclude that the downlisting and delisting objectives
have been substantially met. Additional threats not directly addressed
in the recovery objectives are discussed below. Additional information
on recovery and recovery plan implementation are described in the
``Recovery'' section of the Species Report (Service 2013, pp. 58-65).
Summary of Factors Affecting the Species
Section 4 of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR part
424) set forth the procedures for listing species, reclassifying
species, or removing species from listed status. ``Species'' is defined
by the Act as including any species or subspecies of fish or wildlife
or plants, and any distinct population segment of any species of
vertebrate fish or wildlife which interbreeds when mature (16 U.S.C.
1532(16)). A species may be determined to be an endangered or
threatened species because of any one or a combination of the five
factors described in section 4(a)(1) of the Act: (A) The present or
threatened destruction, modification, or curtailment of its habitat or
range; (B) overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or
educational purposes; (C) disease or predation; (D) the inadequacy of
existing regulatory mechanisms; or (E) other natural or human-made
factors affecting its continued existence. A species may be
reclassified on the same basis.
A recovered species is one that no longer meets the Act's
definition of threatened or endangered. Determining whether a species
is recovered requires consideration of whether the species is
endangered or threatened because of the same five categories of threats
specified in section 4(a)(1) of the Act. For species that are already
listed as endangered or threatened, this analysis of threats is an
evaluation of both the threats currently facing the species and the
threats that are reasonably likely to affect the species in the
foreseeable future following the delisting or downlisting and the
removal or reduction of the Act's protections.
A species is an ``endangered species'' for purposes of the Act if
it is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion
of its range and is a ``threatened species'' if it is likely to become
an endangered species within the foreseeable future throughout all or a
significant portion of its range. The Act does not define the term
``foreseeable future.'' For the purposes of this rule, we define the
``foreseeable future'' to be the extent to which, given the amount and
substance of available data, we can anticipate events or effects, or
reliably extrapolate threat trends, such that we reasonably believe
that reliable predictions can be made concerning the future as it
relates to the status of Modoc sucker. Specifically, for Modoc sucker,
we consider two factors: the management of threats and the response of
the species to management. First, as described below, the threats to
the species have been successfully ameliorated, largely due to
management plans that are currently in place and expected to stay in
place, and that are expected to successfully continue to control
potential threats (USFS 1989, entire; USFS 1991, entire). Management
plans that consider natural resources are required by law for all
Federal lands on which Modoc sucker occurs, which encompasses greater
than 50 percent of the species' range. Management plans are required to
be in effect at all times and to be in compliance with various Federal
regulations. Efforts to promote conservation of Modoc sucker habitat on
private lands have been successful and are expected to continue into
the future. Second, the Modoc sucker has demonstrated a quick positive
response to management over the past 28 years since the species was
listed; based on this, we anticipate being able to detect a species
response to any changes in the management that may occur because of a
plan amendment. Therefore, in consideration of Modoc sucker's positive
response to management and our partners' commitment to continued
management, as we describe below, we do not foresee that management
practices will change and we anticipate that threats to the Modoc
sucker will remain ameliorated into the foreseeable future. The word
``range'' in the significant portion of its range phrase refers to the
range in which the species currently exists. For the purposes of this
analysis, we first evaluate the status of the species throughout all
its range, then consider whether the species is in danger of extinction
or likely to become so in any significant portion of its range.
At the time of listing, the primary threats to Modoc sucker were
threats from habitat degradation and loss due to activities (such as
overgrazing by cattle) that cause erosion and siltation, and eliminated
natural barriers that resulted in loss of genetic integrity of the
species due to hybridization with Sacramento suckers (Catostomus
occidentalis). Predation by the nonnative brown trout (Salmo trutta)
was also identified as a threat to Modoc sucker.
A thorough analysis and discussion of the current status review
initiated with our 2012 90-day finding (77 FR 32922) is detailed in the
Species Report (Service 2013, entire). The following sections provide a
summary of the past, current, and potential future threats impacting
the Modoc sucker. These threats include activities (such as
overgrazing) that cause erosion and siltation (Factor A); elimination
of natural barriers (Factor A); climate change and drought (Factor A);
predation by nonnative species (Factors C); and hybridization and
genetic introgression (infiltration of genes of another species)
(Factor E).
Erosion and Cattle Grazing
The listing rule stated that activities (such as overgrazing) that
cause a reduction in riparian vegetation, which then leads to stream
erosion, siltation, and incision were a threat to the species. An
increase in silt from eroding banks may fill in the preferred pool
habitat of Modoc suckers and can cover gravel substrate used for
spawning (50 FR 24526, June 11, 1985; Moyle 2002, p. 190). Sediment
introduced into streams can adversely affect fish populations by
inducing embryo mortality, affecting primary productivity, and reducing
available habitat for macroinvertebrates that Modoc suckers feed upon
(Moyle 2002, p. 191). However, land and resource management, as guided
through regulations and policies, can effectively reduce or control
threats to Modoc sucker.
The National Forest Management Act (NFMA) and regulations and
policies implementing the NFMA are the main regulatory mechanisms that
guide land management on the Fremont-Winema and Modoc National Forests,
which constitute about 51 percent of Modoc suckers' range. Since
listing, the Fremont-Winema National Forests (USFS 1989, entire) and
Modoc National Forest (USFS 1991, entire) have each included Modoc
sucker and their habitat in their resource management plans. These
plans are required by
[[Page 8662]]
NFMA and the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (FLPMA).
The NFMA requires revision of the Plans every 15 years; however, plans
may be amended or revised as needed. Management plans are required to
be in effect at all times (in other words, if the revision does not
occur, the previous plan remains in effect) and to be in compliance
with various Federal regulations. The plans direct these national
forests to maintain or increase the status of populations of federally
endangered or threatened species and their habitats. In addition, these
plans guide riparian management with a goal of restoring and
maintaining aquatic and riparian ecosystems to their desired management
potential (USFS 1989, Appendix p. 86; USFS 1991, pp. 4-26, Appendix pp.
M-1-M-2).
Management direction for grazing on Forest-managed lands is
provided through allotment management plans and permits, which
stipulate various grazing strategies that will minimize adverse effects
to the watershed and listed species. The allotment management plans
outline grazing management goals that dictate rangeland management
should maintain productive riparian habitat for threatened, endangered,
and sensitive species (USFS 1995, p. 1). These grazing permits are
valid for 10 years though operating instructions for these permits are
issued on an annual basis. Also, as Federal agencies, the Fremont-
Winema and Modoc National Forests comply with the National
Environmental Policy Act process when evaluating potential land-
disturbing projects or changes in National Forest management.
Although State lands comprise only 1 percent of Modoc suckers'
range, both California and Oregon provide habitat protection. In
California on State lands, the California Fish and Game Code affords
protection to stream habitats for all perennial, intermittent, and
ephemeral rivers and streams. In Oregon, the Oregon Department of Land
Conservation and Development requires local land use planning
ordinances to protect natural resources, including riparian and wetland
habitats.
The improved livestock grazing management practices in these
management plans have greatly reduced impacts to Modoc sucker habitat
from poor livestock grazing practices since the time of listing. Since
listing, some of the Modoc sucker streams on public land have been
fenced to exclude or actively manage livestock grazing for the benefit
of Modoc sucker conservation (Reid 2008a, pp. 34-36, 85). Riparian
fencing along occupied streams to exclude cattle during the past 25
years has resulted in continued improvements in riparian vegetative
corridors, in-stream cover, and channel morphology.
In 2012, the Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office completed
habitat surveys in Washington Creek, Garden Gulch Creek, Coffee Mill
Creek, Dutch Flat Creek, Turner Creek, Hulbert Creek, and Johnson Creek
within the Ash Creek and Turner Creek sub-basins. Data collected
indicated that the average percent bank erosion was low (less than 40
percent) at Garden Gulch Creek, Coffee Mill Creek, Hulbert Creek,
Washington Creek, and Johnson Creek. Bank erosion appeared moderate at
the Dutch Flat Creek site (49 percent) and was highest at the Turner
Creek site (75 percent). However, these two degraded reaches (Dutch
Flat Creek and Turner Creek) combined amount to only 4.1 percent (1.76
mi/42.5 mi) of Modoc sucker's total occupied habitat. Bank erosion
along these creeks has resulted in an introduction of silt, which can
cover gravel substrate used for spawning by Modoc suckers (Moyle 2002,
p. 191).
Land management practices employed on public and private lands
since the early 1980s are expected to continue, or improve, thereby
maintaining upward habitat trends as documented by survey data. On
public lands, the resource management plans are required by NFMA and
FLPMA and continue to be in effect until revised. Continued commitment
to protection of resources, including Modoc sucker and riparian areas,
in future revisions is expected. As an example, within the Fremont-
Winema National Forest, Thomas Creek is a Priority Watershed under
their Watershed Condition Framework, and the Forest is currently
working on a watershed restoration action plan. The action plan will
identify individual projects such as fish passage, instream
restoration, and road treatments/closures. On State lands, the
California Fish and Game Code affords protection to stream habitats for
all perennial, intermittent, and ephemeral rivers and streams. The
Oregon Department of Land Conservation and Development requires local
land use planning ordinances to protect natural resources, including
riparian and wetland habitats. However, there are no formalized
agreements in place with private landowners that establish protection
of Modoc sucker habitat, though continued outreach is expected to occur
in the near future (e.g., through the Service's Partners for Fish and
Wildlife Program).
Although the 2012 habitat surveys indicate that livestock grazing
still results in stream bank erosion along streams occupied by Modoc
suckers, these surveys and the 2008 and 2012 fish surveys indicate that
livestock grazing management has improved greatly, and as a result of
reduced impact to habitat, there has been no reduction in the
distribution of Modoc suckers, and grazing results in erosion in only a
small portion (4.1 percent) of the species' range. Management plans
that consider natural resources are required by law for all Federal
lands on which Modoc sucker occurs. Management plans are required to be
in effect at all times (in other words, if the revision does not occur,
the previous plan remains in effect) and to be in compliance with
various Federal regulations. Further, several organizations have
partnered with private landowners to complete habitat restoration on
the private land parcels to benefit fish passage and riparian habitat.
Therefore, based on the best available information and expectation that
current management practices will continue into the future, we conclude
that livestock grazing and erosion does not constitute a substantial
threat to the Modoc sucker now and is not expected to in the future.
Elimination of Natural Barriers
The listing rule assumed that natural passage barriers in streams
occupied by Modoc suckers had been eliminated by human activities,
allowing hybridization between the Modoc and Sacramento suckers (see
Hybridization and Genetic Introgression below). The lack of barriers
was also thought to provide exposure to nonnative predatory fishes (see
Predation by Nonnative Species below). However, surveys completed since
the time of listing reveal no evidence of historical natural barriers
that would have acted as a physical barrier. This is particularly true
during higher springtime flows when Sacramento suckers make their
upstream spawning migrations (Moyle 2002, p. 187). The source of this
misunderstanding appears to have been a purely conjectural discussion
by Moyle and Marciochi (1975, p. 559) that was subsequently accepted
without validation, and Moyle makes no mention of it in his most recent
account of Modoc sucker status (Moyle 2002, pp. 190-191). Since our
current understanding is that the elimination of passage barriers did
not occur, we conclude that elimination of passage barriers was
incorrectly identified as a threat and is not a threat to Modoc sucker.
Predation by Nonnative Species
The listing rule identified predation by nonnative brown trout as a
threat to Modoc suckers (50 FR 24526, June 11,
[[Page 8663]]
1985). Since the time of listing, additional predatory nonnative fish
species have been recorded in streams containing Modoc suckers (Service
2009): Largemouth bass, sunfish (green and bluegill), and brown
bullheads. Two of the three known sub-basins with Modoc suckers contain
introduced predatory fishes. The Ash Creek sub-basin contains brown
trout and possibly largemouth bass in downstream reaches of Ash Creek.
The Turner Creek sub-basin contains a number of warm-water predatory
fish. The Goose Lake sub-basin does not contain any nonnative predatory
fish.
The Ash Creek sub-basin contains brown trout, which have co-existed
with Modoc suckers for over 70 years, but may suppress local native
fish populations in small streams. There are no sources of largemouth
bass upstream of Modoc sucker populations in the Ash Creek basin,
although they may be present downstream in warmer, low-gradient reaches
of Ash Creek proper. A substantial eradication effort in Johnson Creek,
within the Ash Creek sub-basin, in 2009 and 2010 removed most brown
trout from occupied Modoc sucker habitat (Reid 2010, p. 2).
The Turner Creek sub-basin contains largemouth bass, sunfish (green
and bluegill), and brown bullheads, of which only the bass are
considered a significant predator on Modoc suckers. Bass do not appear
to reproduce or establish stable populations in Turner Creek because
the creek's cool-water habitat is generally unsuitable for supporting
largemouth bass populations. Since 2005, the Service has supported a
successful program of active management for nonnative fishes in the
Turner Creek basin, targeting bass and sunfishes with selective angling
and hand removal methods that do not adversely impact native fish
populations (Reid 2008b, p. 1).
Redband trout, the only native potential predator of Modoc sucker,
also occupies upper Thomas Creek, but there are no nonnative fishes
(Scheerer et al. 2010, pp. 278, 281). The upper reaches of Thomas Creek
occupied by Modoc suckers are unlikely to be invaded by nonnative
fishes given the lack of upstream source populations and presence of a
natural waterfall barrier in the lowest reach.
While Modoc suckers may be negatively impacted by introduced
predatory fishes, such as brown trout and largemouth bass, they have
persisted in the presence of nonnative predators, and populations have
remained relatively stable in the Ash Creek and Turner Creek sub-basins
prior to and since the time of listing. The separation of the three
known basins containing Modoc suckers further reduces the probability
that a new or existing nonnative predator would impact all three basins
simultaneously. In some instances, natural constraints limit the
distribution of nonnative predators, such as cool-water habitat. In
other cases, natural or manmade barriers limit potential introductions,
as do policies and regulations within Oregon and California. State
regulations and fish stocking policies, in both California and Oregon,
prohibit transfer of fish from one water body to another. Regulations
prohibiting transfer of fish between water bodies discourage the spread
of predatory fish species such as brown trout and largemouth bass
throughout the Modoc sucker's range. In addition, CDFW has discontinued
stocking of the predatory brown trout into streams in the Pit River
basin, and the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (ODFW) does not
stock brown trout in the Goose Lake sub-basin. Based on current
policies and regulations, we do not expect additional predatory fish to
be introduced into Modoc sucker habitat in the future. Therefore, based
on the best available information, we conclude that introduced
predators do not constitute a substantial threat to the Modoc sucker
now or in the future.
Climate Change and Drought
Our analyses under the Endangered Species Act include consideration
of ongoing and projected changes in climate. The terms ``climate'' and
``climate change'' are defined by the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (IPCC). ``Climate'' refers to the mean and variability
of different types of weather conditions over time, with 30 years being
a typical period for such measurements, although shorter or longer
periods also may be used (IPCC 2007, p. 78). The term ``climate
change'' thus refers to a change in the mean or variability of one or
more measures of climate (e.g., temperature or precipitation) that
persists for an extended period, typically decades or longer, whether
the change is due to natural variability, human activity, or both (IPCC
2007, p. 78). Various types of changes in climate can have direct or
indirect effects on species. These effects may be positive, neutral, or
negative and they may change over time, depending on the species and
other relevant considerations, such as the effects of interactions of
climate with other variables (e.g., habitat fragmentation) (IPCC 2007,
pp. 8-14, 18-19). In our analyses, we use our expert judgment to weigh
relevant information, including uncertainty, in our consideration of
various aspects of climate change.
The listing rule did not identify drought or climate change as
threats to the continued existence of the Modoc sucker. However, the
northwestern corner of the Great Basin is naturally subject to extended
droughts, during which streams and even the larger water bodies such as
Goose Lake have dried up (Laird 1971, pp. 57-58). Regional droughts
have occurred every 10 to 20 years in the last century, and Goose Lake
went dry as recently as 1992 and 2010 (Reid 2008a, pp. 43-44; R.
Larson, KFFWO, personal communication). We have no records of how
frequently Modoc sucker streams went dry. Some reaches of occupied
streams have been observed to dry up (or flow goes subsurface through
the gravel instead of over the surface) nearly every summer under
current climatic conditions (Reid 2008, p. 42), indicating that
headwater reaches did stop flowing. In extreme droughts, the suckers
may have withdrawn to permanent main-stem streams, such as Rush, Ash,
and Turner Creeks, and later recolonized the tributaries. Suckers also
take refuge in natural spring-fed headwater reaches and in deeper,
headwater pools that receive subsurface flow even when most of the
stream channel is dry (Reid 2008, p. 43). Collections of Modoc suckers
from Rush Creek and Thomas Creek near the end of the ``dustbowl''
drought (Hubbs 1934, p. 1; Reid 2008a, p. 79) and the continued
persistence of Modoc suckers throughout its known range through
substantial local drought years since 1985 demonstrate the resiliency
of Modoc sucker populations to drought.
Human-induced climate change could exacerbate low-flow conditions
in Modoc sucker habitat during future droughts. A warming trend in the
mountains of western North America is expected to decrease snowpack,
hasten spring runoff, reduce summer stream flows, and increase summer
water temperatures (Poff et al. 2002, p. 11; Koopman et al. 2009, p. 3;
PRBO Conservation Science 2011, p. 15). Lower flows as a result of
smaller snowpack could reduce sucker habitat, which might adversely
affect Modoc sucker reproduction and survival. Warmer water
temperatures could lead to physiological stress and could also benefit
nonnative fishes that prey on or compete with Modoc suckers. Increases
in the number and size of forest fires could also result from climate
change (Westerling et al. 2006, p. 940) and could adversely affect
watershed function resulting in faster runoff, lower base flows during
the summer and fall, and increased sedimentation rates. It is
[[Page 8664]]
possible that lower flows may result in increased groundwater
withdrawal for agricultural purposes and thus reduced water
availability in certain stream reaches occupied by Modoc suckers. While
these are all possible scenarios, we have no data on which to predict
the likelihood or magnitude of these outcomes.
In summary, droughts may be a concern because they could likely
constrict the amount of available habitat and reduce access to spawning
habitat. However, the species has not declined in distribution since
the time of listing in 1985, even though the region where it exists has
experienced several pronounced droughts since listing when total annual
precipitation was approximately half of the long-term average (Western
Regional Climate Center, http://www.wrcc.dri.edu/cgi-bin/cliMONtpre.pl?ca0161, accessed 23 January 2013). And, although we
cannot predict future climatic conditions accurately, the persistence
of Modoc sucker across its range through the substantial droughts of
the last century suggests that the species is resilient to drought and
reduced water availability. Because we are unable at this time to
predict how climate change will exacerbate the effects of drought
within the Modoc sucker's range, we cannot make meaningful projections
on how the species may react to climate change or how its habitat may
be affected. Therefore, based on the best available information, we
conclude that droughts and climate change, while likely affecting Modoc
sucker populations, do not constitute substantial threats to Modoc
sucker now and are not expected to in the future.
Hybridization and Genetic Introgression
The listing rule identified hybridization with the Sacramento
sucker as a threat to the Modoc sucker. Hybridization can be cause for
concern in a species with restricted distribution, particularly when a
closely related, nonnative species is introduced into its range, which
can lead to loss of genetic integrity or even extinction (Rhymer and
Simberloff 1996, p. 83). At the time of listing, it was assumed that
hybridization between Modoc suckers and Sacramento suckers had been
prevented in the past by the presence of natural physical barriers, but
that the loss of these stream barriers was allowing interaction and
hybridization between the two species (see Elimination of Natural
Barriers above). However, the assumption that extensive hybridization
was occurring was based solely on the two species occurring in the same
streams, and the identification of a few specimens exhibiting what were
thought to be intermediate morphological characters. At the time of
listing in 1985, genetic and complete morphological information to
assess this assumption was not available.
The morphological evidence for hybridization in the listing rule
was based on a limited understanding of morphological variation in
Modoc suckers and Sacramento suckers, derived from the small number of
specimens available at that time. The actual number of specimens
identified as apparent hybrids by earlier authors was very small, and
many of these specimens came from streams without established Modoc
sucker populations. Subsequent evaluation of variability in the two
species was based on a larger number of specimens. It showed that the
overlapping characteristics (primarily lateral line and dorsal ray
counts) that had been interpreted by earlier authors as evidence of
hybridization, are actually part of the natural meristic (involving
counts of body parts such as fins and scales) range for the two
species. As a result, this variability is no longer thought to be the
result of genetic introgression between the two species (Kettratad
2001, pp. 52-53).
We initiated a study in 1999 to examine the genetics of suckers in
the Pit River basin and determine the extent and role of hybridization
between the Modoc and Sacramento suckers using both nuclear and
mitochondrial genes (Palmerston et al. 2001, p. 2; Wagman and Markle
2000, p. 2; Dowling 2005, p. 3; Topinka 2006, p. 50). The two species
are genetically similar, suggesting that they are relatively recently
differentiated or have a history of introgression throughout their
range that has obscured their differences (Dowling 2005, p. 9; Topinka
2006, p. 65). Although the available evidence cannot differentiate
between the two hypotheses, the genetic similarity in all three sub-
basins, including those populations shown to be free of introgression
based on species-specific genetic markers (Topinka 2006, pp. 64-65),
suggests that introgression has occurred on a broad temporal and
geographic scale and is not a localized or recent phenomenon.
Consequently, the genetic data suggest that introgression is natural
and is not caused or measurably affected by human activities.
In a later study, Topinka (2006, p. 50) analyzed nuclear DNA from
each of the two species and identified species-specific markers
indicating low levels of introgression by Sacramento sucker alleles
into most Modoc sucker populations. However, there was no evidence of
first generation hybrids, and it is not clear whether introgression
occurred due to local hybridization or through immigration by
individual Modoc suckers carrying Sacramento alleles from other areas
where hybridization had occurred.
Scientists who have studied suckers in western North America
consider that, throughout their evolutionary history, hybridization
among sympatric native fishes is not unusual and may provide an
adaptive advantage (Dowling and Secor 1997, pp. 612-613; Dowling 2005,
p. 10; Topinka 2006, p. 73; Tranah and May 2006, p. 313). Further,
despite any hybridization that has occurred in the past, the Modoc
sucker maintains its morphological and ecological distinctiveness, even
in populations showing low levels of introgression, and is clearly
distinguishable in its morphological characteristics from the
Sacramento sucker (Kettratad 2001, p. 3). The low levels of observed
introgression by Sacramento suckers in streams dominated by Modoc
suckers, even when there are no physical barriers between the two
species, suggests that either ecological differences, selective
pressures, or other natural reproductive-isolating mechanisms are
sufficient to maintain the integrity of the species, even after more
than a century of habitat alteration by human activities. Therefore,
given the levels of observed introgression in streams dominated by
Modoc suckers, the lack of evidence of first-generation hybrids, the
fact that Modoc suckers and Sacramento suckers are naturally sympatric,
and the continued ecological and morphological integrity of Modoc
sucker populations, we conclude that hybridization and genetic
introgression do not constitute threats to the Modoc sucker now and are
not expected to in the future.
Overall Summary of Factors Affecting Modoc Sucker
Threats to the Modoc sucker that were considered in the 1985
listing rule have been reduced or ameliorated or are no longer
considered to have been actual threats at the time of listing. Further,
climate change and drought are not considered substantial threats.
Habitat conditions on both public and private lands have benefited
since the time of listing as a result of improved livestock grazing
management practices and construction of fencing to exclude cattle from
riparian areas on several of the streams occupied by Modoc suckers. We
expect habitat conditions to remain stable or improve. Although recent
habitat surveys indicate erosion continues to be a problem along lower
Turner Creek and in Dutch Flat Creek,
[[Page 8665]]
these areas represent 4.1 percent (1.76 mi/42.5 mi) of Modoc sucker's
total occupied habitat. Habitat threats are addressed through multiple
Federal and State regulations, including NFMA, California and Oregon
State water regulations, and California Fish and Game Code. Therefore,
these impacts are not considered a substantial threat to the species.
Modoc suckers have coexisted with brown trout for more than 70
years, and the overlap in distribution of largemouth bass and Modoc
suckers is limited because bass are warm water fish that occur in
lower-elevation reaches downstream of many of the reaches occupied by
Modoc sucker, and reservoir outflows have been screened to reduce the
risk of bass being flushed into streams occupied by Modoc sucker.
Further, State regulations in both California and Oregon prohibit
transfer of fish from one water body to another. Thus, introduced
predators are not a significant risk to Modoc sucker populations. A
greater understanding of the genetic relationships and natural gene
flow between the Modoc suckers and Sacramento suckers has reduced
concerns over hybridization between the two naturally sympatric
species.
Although none of the factors discussed above is having a major
impact on Modoc sucker, a combination of factors could potentially have
a much greater effect. For example, effects of erosion on habitat
resulting from poor livestock grazing management practices could worsen
during periods of prolonged, severe drought when some water sources may
dry up, resulting in greater pressure on the remaining available water
sources, which would likely degrade Modoc sucker habitat. However, the
impacts of livestock grazing on Modoc sucker habitat has been greatly
reduced or eliminated by improved grazing management practices and
management plans, which are not expected to change. Although the types,
magnitude, or extent of cumulative impacts are difficult to predict, we
are not aware of any combination of factors that has not already or
would not be addressed through ongoing conservation measures. Based on
this assessment of factors potentially impacting the species, we
consider Modoc sucker to have no substantial threats now or in the
future (see Summary of Factors Affecting the Species section of the
Species Report (Service 2013, pp. 23-57).
Finding
An assessment of the need for a species' protection under the Act
is based on whether a species is in danger of extinction or likely to
become so because of any of five factors: (A) The present or threatened
destruction, modification, or curtailment of its habitat or range; (B)
overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or
educational purposes; (C) disease or predation; (D) the inadequacy of
existing regulatory mechanisms; or (E) other natural or manmade factors
affecting its continued existence. As required by section 4(a)(1) of
the Act, we conducted a review of the status of this species and
assessed the five factors to evaluate whether Modoc sucker is
endangered or threatened throughout all of its range. We examined the
best scientific and commercial information available regarding the
past, present, and future threats faced by the species. We reviewed
information presented in the 2011 petition, information available in
our files and gathered through our 90-day finding in response to this
petition, and other available published and unpublished information. We
also consulted with species experts and land management staff with the
USFS, CDFW, and ODFW, who are actively managing for the conservation of
Modoc sucker.
In considering what factors might constitute threats, we must look
beyond the mere exposure of the species to the factor to determine
whether the exposure causes actual impacts to the species. If there is
exposure to a factor, but no response, or only a positive response,
that factor is not a threat. If there is exposure and the species
responds negatively, the factor may be a threat and we then attempt to
determine how significant the threat is. If the threat is significant,
it may drive, or contribute to, the risk of extinction of the species
such that the species warrants listing as endangered or threatened as
those terms are defined by the Act. This determination does not
necessarily require empirical proof of a threat. The combination of
exposure and some corroborating evidence of how the species is likely
impacted could suffice. The mere identification of factors that could
impact a species negatively is not sufficient to compel a finding that
listing is appropriate; we require evidence that these factors are
operative threats that act on the species to the point that the species
meets the definition of an endangered species or threatened species
under the Act.
Significant impacts at the time of listing that could have resulted
in the extirpation of all or parts of populations have been eliminated
or reduced since listing. We conclude that the previously recognized
impacts to Modoc sucker from the present or threatened destruction,
modification, or curtailment of its habitat or range (specifically,
erosion due to poor cattle grazing management) (Factor A); elimination
of natural barriers (Factor A); predation by nonnative species (Factor
C); and hybridization or genetic introgression (specifically, from
Sacramento sucker) (Factor E) do not rise to a level of significance,
such that the species is in danger of extinction now or in the
foreseeable future.
As a result of the discovery of five populations not known at the
time of listing and the documentation of the genetic integrity of
populations considered in the 1985 listing rule to have been lost due
to hybridization, the known range of the Modoc sucker has increased and
it currently occupies its entire known historical range. Additionally,
the distribution of occupied stream habitat for populations known at
the time of listing has remained stable or expanded slightly since the
time of listing, even though the region has experienced several
droughts during this time period. Additionally, the relevant recovery
objectives outlined in the Recovery Plan for the Modoc sucker have been
met, indicating sustainable populations exist throughout the species'
range. Finally, an assessment of factors that may be impacting the
species did not reveal any significant threats to the species, now or
in the future. We have carefully assessed the best scientific and
commercial data available and determined that Modoc sucker is no longer
in danger of extinction throughout all of its range, nor is it likely
to become so in the future.
Significant Portion of the Range
Having examined the status of Modoc sucker throughout all its
range, we next examine whether the species is in danger of extinction
in a significant portion of its range. The range of a species can
theoretically be divided into portions in an infinite number of ways.
However, there is no purpose in analyzing portions of the range that
have no reasonable potential to be significant or in analyzing portions
of the range in which there is no reasonable potential for the species
to be endangered or threatened. To identify only those portions that
warrant further consideration, we determine whether there is
substantial information indicating that: (1) The portions may be
``significant'' and (2) the species may be in danger of extinction
there or likely to become so within the foreseeable future. Depending
on the biology of the species, its range, and the threats it faces, it
might be more efficient for us to address
[[Page 8666]]
the significance question first or the status question first. Thus, if
we determine that a portion of the range is not ``significant,'' we do
not need to determine whether the species is endangered or threatened
there; if we determine that the species is not endangered or threatened
in a portion of its range, we do not need to determine if that portion
is ``significant.'' In practice, a key part of the determination that a
species is in danger of extinction in a significant portion of its
range is whether the threats are geographically concentrated in some
way. If the threats to the species are essentially uniform throughout
its range, no portion is likely to warrant further consideration.
Moreover, if any concentration of threats to the species occurs only in
portions of the species' range that clearly would not meet the
biologically based definition of ``significant,'' such portions will
not warrant further consideration.
We consider the ``range'' of Modoc sucker to include an estimated
42.5 miles (68.4 kilometers) of occupied habitat in 12 streams in the
Turner Creek, Ash Creek, and Goose Lake sub-basins of the Pit River.
This amount has improved greatly since the time of listing, when its
known distribution was limited to an estimated 12.9 miles (20.8
kilometers) of occupied habitat in seven streams in the Turner Creek
and Ash Creek sub-basins. This distribution represents its entire known
historical range, with the exception of Willow Creek within the Ash
Creek sub-basin. Previous reports of Modoc suckers in Willow Creek are
based on limited and unverifiable reports (Reid 2009, p. 14), and their
present existence in Willow Creek remains questionable (Reid 2008a, p.
25). Therefore, we consider the confirmed historical range to be
occupied.
We considered whether any portions of the Modoc sucker range might
be both significant and in danger of extinction or likely to become so
in the foreseeable future. One way to identify portions would be to
identify natural divisions within the range that might be of biological
or conservation importance. Modoc sucker inhabit three sub-basins of
the Pit River, one of which, the Goose Lake sub-basin, is disjoined
from the other two sub-basins (Turner Creek and Ash Creek sub-basins).
These sub-basins have the potential to be significant areas to the
species due to potential geographic isolation. Although the sub-basins
have the potential to be significant, the populations of the species
within the sub-basins are not in danger of extinction or likely to
become so within the foreseeable future due to lack of significant
threats. Another way to identify portions would be to consider whether
any threats are geographically concentrated in some way that would
indicate the species could be threatened or endangered in that area. As
noted above, erosion due to poor grazing management still occurs within
approximately 4.1 percent of the Modoc sucker range, and has the
potential to adversely affect Modoc sucker in those areas. These two
sites are within different sub-basins and, both collectively and per
sub-basin, represent a very small fraction of the Modoc sucker's range.
These areas, individually or collectively, are therefore unlikely to
constitute a significant portion of the species' range. No other
natural divisions occur, and no other potential remaining threats have
been identified. Therefore, it is our conclusion, based on our
evaluation of the current and potential threats to Modoc sucker, that
these threats are neither sufficiently concentrated nor of sufficient
magnitude to indicate the species is in danger of extinction or likely
to become so in the foreseeable future in any of the areas that support
the species, and thus, it is likely to persist throughout its
historical range.
We have carefully assessed the best scientific and commercial data
available and determined that the Modoc sucker is no longer in danger
of extinction throughout all or significant portions of its range, nor
is it likely to become so in the future. As a consequence of this
determination, we are proposing to remove this species from the list of
endangered and threatened species under the Act.
Effects of This Rule
If this proposed rule is made final, it would revise 50 CFR
17.11(h) to remove the Modoc sucker from the List of Endangered and
Threatened Wildlife and would revise 50 CFR 17.95(e) to remove
designated critical habitat for the species. The prohibitions and
conservation measures provided by the Act, particularly through
sections 7 and 9, would no longer apply to this species. Federal
agencies would no longer be required to consult with the Service under
section 7 of the Act in the event that activities they authorize, fund,
or carry out may affect Modoc sucker.
Peer Review
In accordance with our joint policy on peer review published in the
Federal Register on July 1, 1994 (50 FR 34270), we will seek the expert
opinions of at least three appropriate and independent specialists
regarding this proposed rule and the draft post-delisting monitoring
(PDM) plan. A thorough review of information that we relied on in
preparing this proposed rule--including information on taxonomy, life-
history, ecology, population distribution and abundance, and potential
threats--is presented in the Modoc Sucker Species Report (Service 2013)
available at www.regulations.gov (Docket Number FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133).
The purpose of peer review is to ensure that decisions are based on
scientifically sound data, assumptions, and analyses. A peer review
panel will conduct an assessment of the proposed rule, and the specific
assumptions and conclusions regarding the proposed delisting. This
assessment will be completed during the public comment period.
We will consider all comments and information we receive during the
comment period on this proposed rule as we prepare the final
determination. Accordingly, the final decision may differ from this
proposal.
Post-Delisting Monitoring Plan
Section 4(g)(1) of the Act requires us, in cooperation with the
States, to implement a monitoring program for not less than 5 years for
all species that have been recovered and delisted (50 CFR 17.11,
17.12). The purpose of this post-delisting monitoring (PDM) is to
verify that a species remains secure from risk of extinction after it
has been removed from the protections of the Act. The PDM is designed
to detect the failure of any delisted species to sustain itself without
the protective measures provided by the Act. If, at any time during the
monitoring period, data indicate that protective status under the Act
should be reinstated, we can initiate listing procedures, including, if
appropriate, emergency listing under section 4(b)(7) of the Act.
Section 4(g) of the Act explicitly requires us to cooperate with the
States in development and implementation of PDM programs, but we remain
responsible for compliance with section 4(g) and, therefore, must
remain actively engaged in all phases of PDM. We also seek active
participation of other entities that are expected to assume
responsibilities for the species' conservation post-delisting.
Post-Delisting Monitoring Plan Overview
The Service has developed a draft PDM plan for the Modoc sucker.
The PDM plan is designed to verify that Modoc sucker remains secure
from risk of extinction after removal from the Federal List of
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife by detecting
[[Page 8667]]
changes in its status and habitat throughout its known range.
Although the Act has a minimum PDM requirement of 5 years, we will
monitor Modoc sucker for a 10-year monitoring period to account for
environmental variability (for example, drought) that may affect the
condition of habitat and to provide for a sufficient number of surveys
to document any changes in the abundance of the species. Based on the
life history of Modoc suckers, in which individuals mature at age 2+
years, a complete survey of previously surveyed areas should be
conducted every 2 years within the 10-year monitoring period. This will
allow us to assess changes in abundance or the extent of the species'
range over time; changes in the level of recruitment of reproducing
fish into the population; and any potential changes in threats to the
species. However, if a decline in abundance is observed or a
substantial new threat arises, post-delisting monitoring may be
extended or modified as described below.
A multi-state occupancy approach (MacKenzie et al. 2009, entire)
will be used to estimate the proportion of sites occupied, change in
site occupancy, and change in abundance of Modoc suckers. Surveys for
Modoc suckers will be completed following a modified version of a
sampling protocol developed for Modoc sucker (Reid 2008b) that is
consistent with the approach used in surveys conducted since 2008. This
approach will allow for monitoring population status over time as it
permits the estimation of the proportion of sites (within a stream and
among all streams) that are occupied and that are in each state of
abundance (low and high). During occupancy and abundance surveys, we
will also monitor threats and recruitment. To measure recruitment, we
will estimate the size of individuals to the nearest centimeter.
Examination of fish sizes will allow a determination to be made if
recruitment is occurring over time. Ideally, surveys will result in
diverse size classes of fish, indicating recruitment is occurring.
Threats, both biotic (for example, nonnative predatory fish) and
abiotic (for example, excessive sedimentation) will also be assessed
during surveys (both day and night). Prior to completing surveys, sites
(pools) within streams will be landmarked and georeferenced to allow
relocation for subsequent surveys.
After each complete survey (conducted once every 2 years), the
Service and its partners will compare the results with those from
previous surveys and consider the implication of any observed
reductions in abundance or threats to the species. Within 1 year of the
end of the PDM period, the Service will conduct a final internal review
and prepare (or contract with an outside entity) a final report
summarizing the results of monitoring. This report will include: (1) A
summary of the results from the surveys of Modoc sucker occupancy,
states of abundance, recruitment, and change in distribution; and (2)
recommendations for any actions and plans for the future. The final
report will include a discussion of whether monitoring should continue
beyond the 10-year period for any reason.
With this notice, we are soliciting public comments and peer review
on the draft PDM Plan including its objectives and procedures (see
Public Comments Solicited). All comments on the draft PDM plan from the
public and peer reviewers will be considered and incorporated into the
final PDM plan as appropriate. The draft PDM plan will be posted on our
Endangered Species Program's national Web page (http://endangered.fws.gov) and the Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office Web
page (http://fws.gov/klamathfallsfwo) and on the Federal eRulemaking
Portal at http://www.regulations.gov. We anticipate finalizing this
plan, considering all public and peer review comments, prior to making
a final determination on the proposed delisting rule.
Required Determinations
Clarity of the Rule
We are required by Executive Orders 12866 and 12988 and by the
Presidential Memorandum of June 1, 1998, to write all rules in plain
language. This means that each rule we publish must:
(a) Be logically organized;
(b) Use the active voice to address readers directly;
(c) Use clear language rather than jargon;
(d) Be divided into short sections and sentences; and
(e) Use lists and tables wherever possible.
If you feel that we have not met these requirements, send us
comments by one of the methods listed in ADDRESSES. To better help us
revise the rule, your comments should be as specific as possible. For
example, you should tell us the names of the sections or paragraphs
that are unclearly written, which sections or sentences are too long,
the sections where you feel lists or tables would be useful, etc.
National Environmental Policy Act
We determined we do not need to prepare an Environmental Assessment
or an Environmental Impact Statement, as defined under the authority of
the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.),
in connection with regulations adopted pursuant to section 4(a) of the
Act. We published a notice outlining our reasons for this determination
in the Federal Register on October 25, 1983 (48 FR 49244).
References Cited
A complete list of all references cited in this proposed rule is
available on the Internet at http://www.regulations.gov under Docket
No. FWS-R8-ES-2013-0133 or upon request from the Field Supervisor,
Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office (see FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT).
Author
The primary author of this proposed rule is the Pacific Southwest
Regional Office in Sacramento, California, in coordination with the
Klamath Falls Fish and Wildlife Office in Klamath Falls, Oregon (see
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT).
List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 17
Endangered and threatened species, Exports, Imports, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements, Transportation.
Proposed Regulation Promulgation
Accordingly, we propose to amend part 17, subchapter B of chapter
I, title 50 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as set forth below:
PART 17--ENDANGERED AND THREATENED WILDLIFE AND PLANTS
0
1. The authority citation for part 17 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1361-1407; 1531-1544; 4201-4245, unless
otherwise noted.
Sec. 17.11 [Amended]
0
2. Amend Sec. 17.11(h) by removing the entry for ``Sucker, Modoc''
under ``Fishes'' in the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife.
Sec. 17.95 [Amended]
0
3. Amend Sec. 17.95(e) by removing the entry for ``Modoc Sucker
(Catostomus microps)''.
Dated: December 30, 2013.
Stephen Guertin,
Acting Director, Fish and Wildlife Service.
[FR Doc. 2014-01526 Filed 2-12-14; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4310-55-P