[Federal Register Volume 79, Number 14 (Wednesday, January 22, 2014)]
[Notices]
[Pages 3577-3583]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2014-01152]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
Record of Decision and Floodplain Statement of Findings for the
FutureGen 2.0 Project
AGENCY: Department of Energy.
ACTION: Record of Decision.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The United States (U.S.) Department of Energy (DOE) announces
its decision to provide financial assistance to the FutureGen
Industrial Alliance (the Alliance) for its FutureGen 2.0 Project. DOE
prepared an environmental impact statement (EIS) (DOE/EIS-0460) to
evaluate the potential environmental impacts associated with DOE's
proposed action of providing approximately $1 billion of financial
assistance for the project (the majority of which was appropriated
under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA)) through
cooperative agreements with the Alliance. The EIS evaluated the
potential impacts associated with construction and operation of the
proposed FutureGen 2.0 Project, which is a public-private partnership
formed for the purpose of developing the world's first commercial-
scale, oxy-combustion electric generation project integrated with
carbon capture and geologic storage. The Alliance, cooperating with
Ameren Energy Resources (Ameren), would upgrade one unit in a power
plant currently owned by Ameren near Meredosia, Illinois. The repowered
unit would include oxy-combustion and carbon capture technologies
designed to capture at least 90 percent of its carbon dioxide
(CO2) emissions during steady-state operation and reduce
other emissions to near zero. The captured CO2 would be
transported through an approximately 30-mile pipeline to wells where it
would be injected approximately 4,000 feet below ground into a geologic
saline formation for permanent storage. The project would be designed
to capture, transport, and inject approximately 1.2 million tons (1.1
million metric tons) of CO2 annually, and up to a total of
24 million tons (22 million metric tons) over approximately 20 years.
The Alliance would also construct and operate visitor, research, and
training facilities related to carbon capture and storage in the
vicinity of Jacksonville, Illinois. The DOE-funded demonstration period
would last for 56 months from the start of operations (approximately
2017) through 2022.
ADDRESSES: The EIS and this record of decision (ROD) are available on
DOE's National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Web site at http://energy.gov/nepa/nepa-documents and on the DOE National Energy
Technology Laboratory (NETL) Web site at http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/others/nepa/index.html. Copies of these documents may be
obtained from Mr. Cliff Whyte, M/S: I07, National Energy Technology
Laboratory, 3610 Collins Ferry Road, P.O. Box 880, Morgantown, WV
26507-0880, ATTN: FutureGen 2.0 Project; electronic mail:
[email protected]; telephone: 304-285-2098; or by toll-free
telephone at 1-800-432-8330, extension 2098.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: To obtain additional information about
the project, the EIS, or the ROD, contact Mr. Cliff Whyte as indicated
above under ADDRESSES. For general information about the DOE NEPA
process, contact Ms. Carol M. Borgstrom, Director, Office of NEPA
Policy and Compliance (GC-54), U.S. Department of Energy, 1000
Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20585; telephone: 202-586-4600;
fax: 202-586-7031; or leave a toll-free message at: 1-800-472-2756.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: DOE prepared this ROD and Floodplain
Statement of Findings pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act
of 1969 (42 United States Code [U.S.C.] 4321, et seq.), and in
compliance with the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) implementing
regulations for NEPA (40 Code of Federal Regulations [CFR] parts 1500
through 1508), DOE's implementing procedures for NEPA (10 CFR Part
1021), and DOE's Compliance with Floodplain and Wetland Environmental
Review (10 CFR part 1022). The decisions announced in this ROD are
based on DOE's final EIS for the FutureGen 2.0 Project (DOE/EIS-0460,
October 2013) and other program considerations.
Purpose and Need for Agency Action
DOE considers the advancement of carbon capture and storage
technology critically important to addressing CO2 emissions
and global climate change concerns associated with the use of fossil
fuels. The purpose of DOE's proposed action is to demonstrate the
[[Page 3578]]
commercial feasibility of an advanced coal-based technology (oxy-
combustion) that may serve as a cost-effective approach to implementing
carbon capture at new and existing power plants. The proposed project
would also demonstrate commercial-scale integration of transport and
permanent storage of captured CO2 in a deep geologic
formation. Implementation of the FutureGen 2.0 Project supports the
objectives of the FutureGen Initiative to establish the feasibility and
viability of producing low-carbon electricity from coal with near-zero
emissions of air pollutants.
One of DOE's primary strategic goals is to protect our national and
economic security by promoting a diverse supply of reliable,
affordable, and environmentally sound energy. The development of carbon
capture and storage technologies through the FutureGen 2.0 Project
would support the ongoing and future use of the nation's abundant coal
reserves in a manner that addresses both aging power plants and
environmental challenges. Federal financial support reduces the risks
inherent in these first-of-a-kind projects, which without financial
assistance would be unlikely to occur.
DOE's Proposed Action
DOE's proposed action is to provide approximately $1 billion in
cost-shared ARRA and other funding through cooperative agreements with
the Alliance for its proposed FutureGen 2.0 Project. The estimated
total project cost is $1.68 billion.
Project Description and Location
The FutureGen 2.0 Project would result in the construction and
operation of a CO2 capture facility using oxy-combustion
technology to capture at least 90 percent (approximately 1.2 million
tons [1.1 million metric tons] annually) of CO2 during
steady-state operation of a repowered electricity generating unit at
the Meredosia Energy Center. This existing generating unit is located
on a 263-acre site adjacent to the east side of the Illinois River,
south of the village of Meredosia in Morgan County, Illinois. The
captured CO2 would be conditioned, compressed, and
transported approximately 30 miles via a new pipeline to a new well
that would inject into the Mt. Simon Formation (approximately 4,000
feet below ground surface), which is one of the Illinois Basin's major
deep saline formations. The primary components of the project are:
(1) Oxy-Combustion Large Scale Test--The Alliance would acquire
portions of the Meredosia Energy Center from Ameren and repower an
existing unit with oxy-combustion technology. Principal construction
features would include a new air separation unit to generate oxygen,
modifications to the power block (including a new boiler and gas
quality control system), a new compression and purification unit for
the flue gas, and additional modifications (reconstruction of the main
cooling tower, two new cooling towers, process water system upgrades,
new process water and wastewater treatment systems, and a new 450-foot
(maximum) concrete exhaust stack). The new oxy-combustion facility
would operate on a blended coal mixture of 60 percent Illinois No. 6
bituminous and 40 percent Powder River Basin sub-bituminous. The
repowered unit would generate 168 MWe of power (gross) and
CO2 suitable for transport by pipeline.
(2) CO2 Pipeline--The Alliance would construct a new
pipeline approximately 30 miles long to transport captured
CO2 to a new injection well site northeast of Jacksonville,
Illinois. The pipeline would be constructed of either a 12-inch or 10-
inch diameter pipe. The proposed pipeline route crosses mostly rural
and sparsely developed agricultural lands in Morgan County. The
Alliance plans to use existing rights-of-way (ROWs) to the extent
practicable to minimize environmental impacts and avoid sensitive
resources. The CO2 pipeline would have an operational ROW
with a width of 50 feet and a construction ROW of 80 feet (100 feet in
limited circumstances).
(3) CO2 Storage--The proposed project would convey
approximately 1.2 million tons (1.1 million metric tons) of
CO2 annually to a new injection site on 9.5 acres northwest
of the intersection of Beilschmidt Road and Martin Road in eastern
Morgan County. The CO2 would be injected via four
horizontally drilled injection wells into the Mt. Simon Formation
approximately 4,000 feet below the surface, and would be confined in
the geologic saline formation by an overlying impermeable caprock layer
(the Eau Claire Formation) approximately 480 feet thick. The maximum
extent of the subsurface CO2 plume after 20 years of
injection would be approximately 4,000 acres based on modeling results;
the Alliance has acquired the subsurface rights of 6,800 acres for the
modeled plume. The Class VI Underground Injection Control (UIC) permits
to be issued by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) for
the four horizontal injection wells require the implementation of a
monitoring, verification, and accounting (MVA) program to assess the
injection and geologic storage of CO2 and to verify that it
stays within the target formation. The MVA program, including
monitoring wells and other technologies, would proceed throughout the
planned injection period (20 years) and continue for another 50 years
or until such time as the USEPA is satisfied that the plume is stable
and no further monitoring is required.
(4) Educational Facilities - The Alliance would construct and
operate visitor, research, and training facilities (the educational
facilities) to support public outreach and communication, and to
provide training and research opportunities associated with near-zero
emissions power generation and CO2 capture and storage
technologies. The intended general location for the educational
facilities is the vicinity of Jacksonville, which is the largest
community in Morgan County. The Alliance has been working with local
stakeholders to identify a location that would be advantageous to the
FutureGen 2.0 Project and to the local community. Siting of the
facilities would require a maximum of 3.5 acres at a location that has
access to existing utility infrastructure and roadways.
Alternatives
Alternatives considered by DOE during the original 2003 FutureGen
program originated as private-party (e.g., electric power industry)
applications submitted to the Department. The FutureGen 2.0 Project is
a continuation of the original FutureGen program. In addition to fully
analyzing the potential impacts of the FutureGen 2.0 Project and the no
action alternative, DOE considered alternatives for the proposed action
in the EIS, including alternative fuel sources, alternative advanced
electric generating technologies, alternative retrofitting
technologies, alternative sites for the oxy-combustion large scale
test, and alternative CO2 pipeline and storage locations.
These alternatives were dismissed from further analysis primarily
because they either were already addressed by other programs and
projects within DOE's diverse portfolio of energy research,
development, and demonstration efforts; because they did not meet the
Alliance's environmental, geologic, or siting criteria; or because they
would not meet the cost and technology-advancement objectives of the
FutureGen Initiative as effectively as the proposed project.
No Action Alternative
Under the no action alternative, DOE would not continue to fund the
FutureGen 2.0 Project into the final design, construction, and
operational
[[Page 3579]]
phases. Without DOE funding, it is unlikely that the Alliance (or the
U.S. industry in general) would undertake, in the near-term, the
commercial-scale integration of CO2 capture and geologic
storage with a coal-fueled power plant. Therefore, the no action
alternative represents a ``no-build'' alternative. Without DOE's
investment in this facility, the development of oxy-combustion plants
integrated with CO2 capture and geologic storage would be
delayed or not occur at all. While the no action alternative would not
satisfy the purpose and need for DOE's proposed action, this
alternative was analyzed to allow for comparisons to the effects of the
proposed project, as required under CEQ Regulations (40 CFR 1502.14).
The no action alternative reflects the current baseline condition and
serves as a benchmark against which the effects of the proposed action
can be evaluated. If the Alliance decided to pursue the project without
DOE funding, potential impacts would be similar to those evaluated
under DOE's proposed action.
EIS Process
DOE initiated the NEPA process by publishing a notice of intent
(NOI) to prepare an EIS in the Federal Register (FR) on May 23, 2011.
DOE stated in that notice that the EIS would analyze the potential
environmental impacts at each of three CO2 storage sites
proposed by the Alliance. These sites were located near Jacksonville,
Illinois; Taylorville, Illinois; and Tuscola, Illinois. DOE conducted a
scoping process that included three public scoping meetings and
consultations with interested governmental agencies and other
stakeholders. DOE held public scoping meetings in Taylorville, Tuscola,
and Jacksonville during the 30-day public scoping period, which ended
on June 22, 2011.
Following the public scoping period and after consideration of the
comments received, DOE prepared a draft EIS that analyzed the potential
environmental impacts of the construction and operation of the
FutureGen 2.0 Project and the no action alternative. During the
preparation of the document, the Alliance determined that
CO2 injection and storage at the Jacksonville site, located
in Morgan County, was the only suitable option as the quality of the
geologic storage site was acceptable and the prohibitive costs involved
in transporting the CO2 for substantial additional distances
to Taylorville and Tuscola made the other sites unreasonable. As a
result, the Taylorville and Tuscola sites were removed from further
consideration, and the draft EIS analyzed the potential environmental
impacts of CO2 injection and storage at the site near
Jacksonville only. DOE and the USEPA both published notices of
availability (NOAs) for the draft EIS on May 3, 2013. DOE's NOA (78 FR
26004) also announced its plans for a public hearing, which was held on
May 21, 2013, in Jacksonville.
DOE listened to questions and concerns during an informal session
before the hearing and received oral comments on the draft EIS at the
public hearing. During the 45-day public comment period, which ended
June 17, 2013, DOE received comment letters from the USEPA, U.S.
Department of the Interior, and Illinois Department of Agriculture.
Comments also were received from one local elected official, four non-
governmental or public-private organizations, and seven members of the
public.
Comments included concerns regarding: (1) The adequacy of technical
and financial information about the project; (2) potential
socioeconomic impacts and risks; (3) the suitability of the proposed
geologic formation for storage of CO2; (4) the effectiveness
of the project to mitigate potential climate change; (5) potential
health and safety risks associated with leakage from the CO2
storage formation or the pipeline; (6) the protection of threatened and
endangered species, forest habitat, bald eagles, and migratory birds;
(7) the adequacy of the NEPA analysis, definition of purpose and need,
and alternatives; (8) connected actions and cumulative impacts related
to coal use; (9) potential environmental justice impacts on low-income
populations; and (10) potential impacts on surface waters, wetlands,
groundwater, prime farmland, and public water utilities. USEPA rated
the draft EIS as LO--``Lack of Objections.''
DOE distributed the final EIS in October 2013. The USEPA published
a NOA in the Federal Register on November 1, 2013 (78 FR 65643). In the
final EIS, DOE updated project information, refined analyses, and
responded to all comments on the draft EIS.
Comments Received on the Final EIS
DOE received comments on the final EIS from the USEPA and a
concerned citizen, Ms. Betty Niemann. DOE considered these comments
during preparation of this ROD.
USEPA, in a letter dated November 27, 2013, indicated that the
final EIS adequately clarified issues USEPA had posed on the draft EIS
except that USEPA had a remaining comment on fine particulate matter.
USEPA recommended that the ROD require either a more detailed and
refined analysis that demonstrates that FutureGen 2.0 is not a
significant contributor to ambient air quality violations or impose
controls/limitations to assure there would be no violations. In
response, the Alliance updated the air quality modeling analysis as
recommended and the results are discussed in this ROD under Air
Quality. The analysis demonstrates that the FutureGen 2.0 Project would
not significantly contribute to a modeled exceedance of the 24-hour
National Ambient Air Quality Standard for fine particulate matter. In a
letter dated December 16, 2013, USEPA stated that concerns raised in
the November 27, 2013 comment letter have been resolved, and that USEPA
has no additional recommendations.
Ms. Niemann, in a letter and subsequent electronic mail, expressed
concern about a range of topics, including among other things: The
cooperative agreement between DOE and the Alliance; potential impacts
on land use and aesthetics associated with the visitor center in
Jacksonville; apparent discrepancies in the acreage required for
CO2 storage, potential for leaks from the CO2
storage area, such as from characterization/stratigraphic wells;
adequacy of analysis of baseline impacts to landowners under the no
action alternative; whether the anticipated environmental benefits of
CO2 reduction are significant enough to justify the project
in view of costs and impacts to landowners; adequacy of site-specific
information in the EIS; liability issues; and whether the Alliance has
the expertise to carry out the FutureGen 2.0 Project. DOE has reviewed
the final EIS in light of these comments and determined the analyses in
the final EIS are adequate. Many of the issues in these comments were
also posed in comments from Ms. Niemann on the draft EIS; responses to
those comments are in Appendix I of the final EIS.
Decision
DOE has decided to proceed with cost-shared funding for the
FutureGen 2.0 Project, providing the Alliance with approximately $1
billion through cooperative agreements. The project, potential
environmental impacts, and required mitigation measures are described
below.
Basis of Decision
DOE based its decision on the importance of achieving the
objectives of the FutureGen Initiative and a careful review of the
potential environmental impacts presented in the EIS. Clean coal
[[Page 3580]]
is an essential component of the President's ``All of the Above''
energy strategy and the proposed project would help DOE meet its
congressionally-mandated mission to support advanced clean-coal
technology projects. Congress appropriated significant funds to enable
DOE to pursue large-scale demonstrations of clean coal technologies,
and the FutureGen 2.0 Project is expected to yield significant
scientific, commercial, and energy-production benefits. Studies by DOE
have identified oxy-combustion as a potentially cost-effective approach
to implementing carbon capture at existing coal facilities, including a
large cross-section of the world's existing pulverized coal power
plants. Oxy-combustion also has the potential for use in new power
plants. Oxy-combustion technology is inherently scalable, making it
possible to demonstrate the technology at a relatively small commercial
scale, such as the 168 megawatt electricity (MWe), FutureGen 2.0
Project, and then replicate it at larger-scale (e.g., 500+ MWe) power
plants. The ability to demonstrate the technology at a smaller but
commercially relevant scale offers substantial cost-saving benefits. An
important benefit of FutureGen 2.0 will be the data collected during
the demonstration period. These data may be used by DOE and others to
evaluate whether the project's technologies could be effectively and
economically implemented at a commercial scale.
DOE plans to verify the environmental impacts predicted in the EIS
and the implementation of appropriate avoidance and mitigation
measures.
Mitigation
DOE's decision incorporates measures to avoid or minimize adverse
environmental impacts during the design, construction, and operation of
the project. DOE requires that recipients of financial assistance
comply with all applicable federal, state, and local environmental
laws, orders, and regulations. During project planning, the Alliance
incorporated various mitigation measures and permit requirements into
its project, and the analyses completed for the EIS assumed that such
measures would be implemented. These measures are identified in the EIS
and incorporated into this ROD as conditions for DOE's financial
assistance under the cooperative agreements between DOE and the
Alliance. All practicable means to avoid or minimize environmental harm
from the project have been adopted.
Mitigation measures beyond those specified in permit conditions
will be addressed in a Mitigation Action Plan (MAP). DOE will prepare
the MAP, consistent with 10 CFR part 1021.331, to establish how the
mitigation measures will be planned, implemented, and monitored. The
MAP will be an adaptive management tool; therefore, mitigation
conditions in it would be removed if equivalent conditions are
otherwise established by permit, license, or law. Permit, license, or
regulatory requirements are not mitigation actions subject to DOE
control and, therefore, would not be included in the MAP. Through
management of its cooperative agreements with the Alliance, DOE will
ensure that the Alliance fulfills the monitoring and mitigation
requirements specified in this ROD and in the MAP, which is under
development. DOE will make the MAP available for inspection in
appropriate locations for a reasonable time. Copies of the MAP and any
annual reports required by the MAP will also be available upon written
request.
Potential Environmental Impacts
In making its decision, DOE considered the environmental impacts of
the FutureGen 2.0 Project (DOE's proposed action) and the no action
alternative. The potentially affected environmental resources evaluated
included: Air quality; climate and greenhouse gases; physiography and
soils; geology; groundwater; surface water; wetlands and floodplains;
biological resources; cultural resources; land use; aesthetics;
materials and waste management; traffic and transportation; noise;
utilities; community services; human health and safety; socioeconomics;
and environmental justice. For analytical purposes, DOE evaluated
potential impacts using current baseline conditions where the energy
center is no longer in operation, as well as using historical baseline
conditions prior to the 2011 suspension of operations at the energy
center. DOE also considered the impacts from construction and operation
of the FutureGen 2.0 Project in combination with those from other past,
present, and reasonably foreseeable future actions (i.e., cumulative
impacts).
Best management practices (BMPs) would be implemented and all
necessary permits would be obtained to minimize potential impacts and
to comply with regulatory requirements during construction and
operation. The following sections discuss the key potential impacts of
the project.
Air Quality
Construction of the FutureGen 2.0 Project would result in short-
term, minor, localized increased tailpipe and fugitive dust emissions.
Emissions would be concentrated at the construction sites and would
steadily decrease with distance. Construction-related emissions would
be reduced with the implementation of industry standard BMPs, including
control of vehicle speeds, minimizing or stabilizing exposed areas to
reduce wind erosion, wetting exposed areas and roads with water or
appropriate surfactants, reducing or eliminating equipment idling time,
and using properly maintained equipment. The proposed project would
occur in an area listed as either in ``attainment'' or ``unclassified''
for all criteria pollutants. Clean Air Act conformity requirements are
not applicable and thus there are no emissions thresholds that pertain
to the construction phase of this project.
Air dispersion modeling, using USEPA's model AERMOD, was performed
to assess the potential air quality impacts of the proposed FutureGen
2.0 Project during operations and to demonstrate compliance with the
National Ambient Air Quality Standards. The modeling results indicated
that emissions of criteria pollutants or hazardous air pollutants
during operations would not exceed relevant air quality or health
standards when analyzed as an isolated project or when analyzed
cumulatively with applicable regional sources. In response to a
recommendation from the USEPA based on its review of the final EIS, the
Alliance updated the air quality modeling analysis regarding the
potential impacts of the proposed FutureGen 2.0 Project on the region's
ability to meet the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard for
particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in diameter (PM 2.5). This
updated modeling analysis corrects the State of Illinois' emissions
inventory to account for an over-prediction in PM 2.5 impacts and
therefore provides a more accurate assessment of the project's
potential PM 2.5 impacts. The results of this updated analysis
demonstrate that the FutureGen 2.0 Project would not significantly
contribute to a modeled exceedance of the 24-hour PM 2.5 standard. (See
final EIS at pages 3.1-23). Emissions would be well within the limits
of the facility's air permit issued by the Illinois Environmental
Protection Agency on December 13, 2013. The project would not
jeopardize the attainment status of the region for any criteria
pollutant; nor would the project impact the air quality
[[Page 3581]]
or visibility at any Class I areas. During normal operations of the
oxy-combustion facility, the gas quality control system would
incorporate state-of-the-art flue gas scrubbing technology to minimize
criteria pollutant emissions from the stack. Beneficial impacts could
result from overall lower emissions, as electricity generated by this
project may displace electricity generated by traditional coal-fired
power plants that emit significantly higher levels of pollutants.
Climate and Greenhouse Gases
Construction-related impacts resulting from tailpipe emissions of
greenhouse gases would be minimized by the use of appropriate BMPs,
such as maintaining engines according to manufacturers' specifications,
minimizing idling of equipment while not in use, and using electricity
from the grid if available to reduce the use of diesel or gasoline
generators for operating construction equipment.
The capture and geological storage of greenhouse gas emissions by
the project would contribute to beneficial cumulative effects on a
national and global scale. The proposed project would capture and
sequester approximately 1.2 million tons per year (1.1 million metric
tons per year) of CO2 emissions from the generation of 168
MWe of electric power, which would generate approximately 90 percent
less greenhouse gas emissions than a similar conventional coal-fired
power plant, or approximately 70 percent less than a natural-gas fired
power plant. The reduction in CO2 emissions resulting from
the project would incrementally reduce the rate of their accumulation
in the atmosphere and help to incrementally mitigate climate change
related to atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases. On a broader
scale, successful implementation of the project may lead to widespread
acceptance and deployment of oxy-combustion technology with geologic
storage of CO2, thus fostering a long-term reduction in the
rate of CO2 emissions from power plants.
The Alliance must design and construct the FutureGen 2.0 Project to
capture a minimum of 90 percent of the CO2 in the treated
stream when operating under normal conditions, and use best efforts to
achieve at least a 90 percent capture rate during the demonstration
period.
Physiography and Soils
Construction of the proposed FutureGen 2.0 Project would increase
the potential for soil erosion and compaction, increase the amount of
impermeable surfaces, and withdraw some prime farmland soils from
agricultural production. Construction of the FutureGen 2.0 Project
would temporarily disturb up to 418 acres and permanently alter up to
233 acres. Much of the land at the energy center that would be impacted
has been previously disturbed, and all of the agricultural land along
the pipeline ROW would be restored for agricultural use after
construction. The permanent loss of prime farmland for the entire
FutureGen 2.0 Project would be approximately 14 acres located at the
injection site.
Impacts to prime farmland soils and agricultural uses resulting
from the construction and operation of the FutureGen 2.0 Project would
be minimized through compliance with an Agricultural Impact Mitigation
Agreement and pollution prevention requirements included in the
project's National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permits and
Spill Prevention, Control, and Countermeasures plans.
The Alliance signed an Agricultural Impact Mitigation Agreement
with the Illinois Department of Agriculture (included in Appendix H,
Agricultural Mitigation, in the final EIS). The Illinois Farm Bureau
also participated in the development of the agreement by reviewing and
providing comments that were incorporated. The agreement specifies the
activities the Alliance would undertake to mitigate any adverse impacts
to farmland associated with the construction of the CO2
pipeline.
Geology
Construction at the Meredosia Energy Center and in the
CO2 pipeline corridor may require excavation of glacial
materials. Construction of the injection wells would result in removal
of geologic media through the drilling process. This process would not
be unique to the area and would not affect the availability of local
geologic resources.
Operation of the oxy-combustion facility and CO2
pipeline would not affect geologic resources. At the injection wells,
the potential for CO2 to migrate out of the injection zone
is considered highly unlikely. Computer modeling conducted by the
Alliance for their proposed injection well configuration of four
horizontal wells installed at one injection well site predicted that
the CO2 plume would expand to encompass an area of
approximately 4,000 acres within the CO2 storage study area
over the 20-year injection period. During injection, the Alliance would
monitor the formation pressure to ensure that injection-induced
seismicity would not occur. The Alliance would also follow a USEPA-
approved MVA plan and conduct studies and monitoring to minimize this
potential. As required by the UIC permits, appropriate mitigation
strategies would be implemented should CO2 migration be
identified.
On November 13, 2013, the Alliance received a Nationwide Permit 12
(NWP-12--Utility Line Activities) from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(USACE) which authorizes the Alliance to conduct trenching activities
within two ephemeral streams located within the pipeline ROW.
Wetlands and Floodplains
In accordance with 10 CFR part 1022 (DOE regulations for Compliance
with Floodplain and Wetland Environmental Review Requirements), DOE
assessed the potential impacts of the proposed project and its
connected actions on wetlands and floodplains in the affected area. The
Alliance selected sites and a pipeline route that would minimize
impacts to wetlands and floodplains and has committed to implementing
methods designed to further reduce impacts.
No impacts to wetlands would occur at the Meredosia Energy Center
as a result of the proposed project. If the Alliance undertakes
activities related to the proposed barge unloading facility, then
temporary impacts could occur resulting in potential increased
sedimentation of the Illinois River from disturbance of the river
bottom.
The operational ROW for the CO2 pipeline contains no
National Wetland Inventory-mapped wetlands, but may contain up to 0.5
acre of freshwater wetlands based on a wetland delineation performed by
the Alliance in spring 2013. While all perennial streams, intermittent
streams, and the majority of wetland areas would be avoided using
trenchless technologies, trenching could occur during pipeline
construction at certain ephemeral streams that are seasonally dry at
the time of construction, as well as within a 0.03-acre wetland swale
identified during a wetland delineation by the Alliance. This 0.03-acre
area of hydric soils is located in an active agricultural field within
the proposed pipeline ROW and was originally assumed to be a non-
regulated feature. However, a Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination
(PJD) received by the Alliance from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(USACE) indicated that, based on a significant nexus to the Illinois
River, the 0.03-acre wetland area is considered to be a regulated
wetland
[[Page 3582]]
feature of ordinary resource value. Concurrently with the PJD, the
Alliance received an approved Nationwide Permit--12 ``Utility Line
Activities'' (NWP-12) that authorizes trenching activities within this
wetland area as well as two ephemeral streams along the pipeline route.
The NWP-12 includes numerous permit conditions which must be followed
by the Alliance, one of which requires that these features be restored
to their original, pre-construction conditions after construction
activities are completed. Since the Alliance would comply with all
permit conditions, no permanent impacts to wetlands would occur.
Construction within the 100-year floodplain would occur only in
areas that are currently developed at the Meredosia Energy Center;
therefore, additional impacts are not expected. If the Alliance
undertakes activities related to the proposed barge unloading facility,
temporary placement of facilities within the 100-year floodplain would
occur during construction, and the area would be returned to pre-
construction conditions after construction activities are completed.
Construction of the CO2 pipeline unavoidably would cross
100-year floodplains and may result in small ancillary structures being
placed in the 100-year floodplain, resulting in minor impacts.
Construction at the CO2 injection well site would avoid
floodplains.
Potential Environmental Impacts of the No Action Alternative
Under the no action alternative, DOE assumed that the FutureGen 2.0
Project would not be constructed and that the current suspension of
operations at the Meredosia Energy Center would continue. The impacts
under the no action alternative (i.e., ``no build'') were evaluated in
the EIS and compared to the proposed action. Under the no action
alternative, the Meredosia Energy Center, pipeline corridor, and the
CO2 storage site would remain in their current condition
with respect to all of the environmental resources evaluated. There
would also be no commercial-scale demonstration of the oxy-combustion
technology to capture and geologically store CO2. The
development of oxy-combustion repowered plants integrated with
CO2 capture and geologic storage would be delayed or not
occur at all, and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from coal-
fueled power plants would not be advanced.
Environmentally Preferred Alternative
From a local perspective, the no action alternative is the
environmentally preferable alternative, because it would result in no
changes to existing environmental conditions. However, from a national
perspective, DOE's proposed action is the environmentally preferred
alternative. Successful demonstration of the proposed FutureGen 2.0
Project could facilitate the deployment of oxy-combustion, carbon
capture, and geologic storage technologies at power plants and other
industrial facilities in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions that
would otherwise occur from the continued combustion of fossil fuels,
especially coal, by large conventional facilities.
Floodplain Statement of Findings
DOE prepared this floodplain statement of findings in accordance
with DOE's regulations entitled ``Compliance with Floodplain and
Wetland Environmental Review Requirements (10 CFR Part 1022). DOE
completed the required floodplain and wetland assessment in
coordination with development and preparation of the EIS, and
incorporated the results and discussion in Sections 3.6, 3.7, and
Appendix D of the final EIS. DOE determined that the placement of some
project components within floodplains would be unavoidable. However,
the current design for the project minimizes floodplain impacts to the
extent practicable. Figures 3.7-2, 3.7-3 and 3.7-4 of the final EIS
depict the locations of floodplains that cannot be avoided and
therefore would be impacted by the construction and operation of the
project.
DOE determined that all practicable design layouts at the Meredosia
Energy Center would affect the 100-year floodplain associated with the
Illinois River and that no wetlands would be affected. Since portions
of the existing facility lie within the 100-year floodplain and the
project requires the use and reconstruction of these facilities, DOE
and the Alliance did not consider alternate sites outside of the
floodplain. However, the Alliance developed the project design to
minimize impacts to floodplains to the greatest extent practicable.
Based on the current design, 15 acres of 100-year floodplain would be
impacted, including 7.6 acres of permanent impact areas and 7.4 acres
of temporary impact areas (limited to the construction period).
Development of approximately 10 acres of impervious surfaces in areas
that were previously pervious (e.g., grassy areas) could result in
increased flow velocity and a reduction in infiltration rates in these
areas. Certain beneficial aspects of floodplains, such as groundwater
recharge and water quality maintenance, could also be reduced by an
increase in impervious cover within the floodplain. However, these
effects would be minor in terms of the size of the newly paved areas
relative to the remaining unpaved areas. The structures associated with
the proposed oxy-combustion facility would be constructed at the
existing energy center within an area that is outside of mapped
floodplains. As a result, the proposed structures would not affect the
natural or beneficial values of the floodplain.
One of the primary factors in the design of the CO2
pipeline route was the avoidance of streams, wetlands, and floodplains.
Other factors, such as negotiations with land owners, utilization of
existing ROWs, and pipeline security and safety concerns were also
considered. In addition, the Alliance has committed to using trenchless
technologies to install the pipeline beneath all perennial and
intermittent streams, as well as most wetland areas, along the pipeline
route. By employing trenchless methods to avoid these areas, the
Alliance would also concurrently avoid impacting immediately adjacent
or co-located floodplains and wetlands in these areas.
The designated pipeline route for the FutureGen 2.0 Project
(referred to as the southern route), would cross 13.2 acres of 100-year
floodplain. The majority of floodplain impacts along the pipeline route
would be temporary, as the pipeline would be buried and the surface
restored to its pre-construction conditions, resulting in only
temporary disturbance. Although the pipeline itself would be buried,
certain aboveground features associated with the pipeline (e.g.,
mainline block valves) would be necessary and could result in potential
permanent floodplain impacts. However, the impact from these features
would be minimal, as they would be limited in number, have small
footprints, and would be widely scattered along the 30-mile route.
While the exact placement of these small features has not yet been
determined, the Alliance has indicated that all surface features would
be placed outside of floodplains to the extent possible. As a result,
the construction and operation of the pipeline would have a negligible
impact on the natural or beneficial values of the floodplains.
The Alliance sited the injection wells and associated
infrastructure by selecting areas that did not contain floodplains or
wetlands. As a result,
[[Page 3583]]
these project features would not affect the natural or beneficial
values of floodplains or wetlands. The Alliance has not yet determined
the location of the educational facilities, which could involve new
construction, rehabilitation of existing structures, or a combination
of both types of construction. If development requires new
construction, it would most likely occur on previously disturbed land
that avoids wetlands and floodplains. Therefore, the construction and
operation of the educational facilities are not expected to affect the
natural or beneficial values of floodplains or wetlands.
The Alliance has committed to performing all project activities in
accordance with all applicable local, state, and federal regulations.
The Alliance would ensure that all construction within floodplains is
performed in accordance with the requirements of the Illinois
Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) and the Morgan County Floodplain
Ordinance. The USACE issued a NWP-12 to the Alliance for installation
of the CO2 pipeline. Depending on the types and locations of
other proposed construction activities, the Alliance may also be
required to obtain additional permits from IDNR prior to any
construction activities. In addition to any minimization or mitigation
measures required by regulation, DOE and the Alliance have incorporated
measures to minimize potential adverse impacts to floodplains into the
project design from construction through operation. These measures
include, but are not limited to, minimum grading requirements, runoff
controls, design and construction constraints and other measures as
described in Table 4.2-1 of the final EIS. By incorporating these
measures into project designs, DOE and the Alliance would avoid and
minimize anticipated adverse impacts to the natural or beneficial
values of floodplains and wetlands.
Issued in Washington, DC, on this 13 of January 2014.
Christopher A. Smith,
Acting Assistant Secretary for Fossil Energy.
[FR Doc. 2014-01152 Filed 1-21-14; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P