[Federal Register Volume 79, Number 7 (Friday, January 10, 2014)]
[Notices]
[Pages 1854-1861]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2014-00299]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
Record of Decision and Floodplain Statement of Findings for the
Lake Charles Carbon Capture and Sequestration Project
AGENCY: Department of Energy.
ACTION: Record of Decision.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announces its decision to
provide cost-shared funding to Leucadia Energy, LLC (Leucadia) for its
Lake Charles Carbon Capture and Sequestration project (Lake Charles CCS
project) under DOE's Industrial Carbon Capture Sequestration (ICCS)
Program. DOE prepared an environmental impact statement (EIS) to
evaluate the potential environmental impacts associated with DOE's
proposed action of providing financial assistance to the Lake Charles
CCS project. The EIS evaluated the impacts associated with construction
and operation of the proposed project and Leucadia's Gasification
Plant, which is a connected action. DOE's proposed action is to provide
financial assistance through a cooperative agreement with Leucadia to
capture carbon dioxide (CO2) from the Gasification Plant and
transport the CO2 via pipelines to the West Hastings oil
field, for use in existing, commercial enhanced oil recovery (EOR). The
West Hastings research monitoring, verification, and accounting (MVA)
program will provide an accurate accounting of approximately 1 million
tons of stored CO2.
ADDRESSES: The EIS and this Record of Decision (ROD) are available on
DOE's Web sites (www.energy.gov/nepa/or www.netl.doe.gov/publications/others/nepa/index.html). Copies of these documents may also be obtained
by contacting Ms. Pierina Fayish, M/S 922-342C, U.S. Department of
Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory, P.O. Box 10940,
Pittsburgh, PA 15236; telephone: 412-386-5428; or email:
[email protected].
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: To obtain additional information about
the project or the EIS, contact Ms. Pierina Fayish at the address
provided above. For general information on DOE's NEPA process, contact
Ms. Carol M. Borgstrom, Director, Office of NEPA Policy and Compliance
(GC-54), U.S. Department of Energy, 1000 Independence Avenue SW.,
Washington DC 20585; telephone: 202-586-4600; or toll free at 1-800-
472-2756.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: DOE prepared this ROD pursuant to the
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 (42 United States Code
[U.S.C.] 4321 et seq.), and in compliance with the Council on
Environmental Quality (CEQ) implementing regulations for NEPA (40 Code
of Federal Regulations [CFR] 1500 through 1508), DOE's NEPA
implementing procedures (10 CFR Part 1021) and DOE's Compliance with
Floodplain and Wetland Environmental Review regulations (10 CFR Part
1022). This ROD is based on DOE's EIS for the Lake Charles CCS Project
(DOE/EIS-0464, November 2013) and other program considerations.
Purpose and Need for Agency Action
The purpose and need for DOE action is to advance the ICCS program
by providing financial assistance to projects that have the best chance
of achieving the program's objectives as established by Congress:
Demonstrating the next generation of technologies that will capture
CO2 from industrial sources and either sequester or
beneficially use it. The proposed project was selected under the ICCS
program as one of a portfolio of projects that DOE determined were the
most appropriate ones to achieve programmatic objectives and meet
legislative requirements.
This proposed project would help the ICCS Program meet its
congressionally mandated mission of large-scale testing of
CO2 sequestration systems. The project would demonstrate the
use of advanced technologies to capture CO2 from an
industrial source and sequester it as part of an EOR operation. The
project would also provide information on the cost and feasibility of
deploying sequestration technologies. A successful demonstration of the
Rectisol[supreg]-based carbon-capture technology with beneficial use of
the CO2 at an existing oil field would also generate
technical, environmental, and financial data
[[Page 1855]]
regarding the design, construction, and operation of a CO2
capture facility, pipeline, and CO2 monitoring at the oil
field. These data would be used to evaluate whether these technologies
could be effectively implemented at a commercial scale.
DOE's Proposed Action
DOE's proposed action is to provide $261.4 million in cost-shared
funding through a cooperative agreement with Leucadia for its proposed
project. DOE has already provided $13.9 million to Leucadia for
preliminary design and related activities. The estimated total cost of
the Lake Charles CCS project is $435.6 million.
Project Description and Location
The Lake Charles CCS project would result in the construction and
operation of a Rectisol[supreg]-based facility to capture at least 75
percent of the CO2 from the treated stream which would
otherwise be released to the atmosphere from the Gasification Plant.
The CCS project includes:
(1) CO2 Capture and Compression--Two Lurgi Rectisol[supreg] Acid
Gas Removal (AGR) units and two compressors would pressurize the
CO2 to 2,250 pounds per square inch gauge (psig) for
transport and geologic sequestration. The project would be designed to
capture approximately 89 percent of the CO2 produced from
the Gasification Plant. Over the 30-year expected life, approximately
4.6 million tons of CO2 per year would be captured, on
average.
(2) CO2 Pipeline--A new pipeline, approximately 16 inches in
diameter, would carry the captured CO2 approximately 11.9
miles and connect to the existing Green Pipeline, which extends across
Louisiana into Texas.
(3) Research Monitoring Program--Denbury Onshore, LLC (Denbury) and
the Texas Bureau of Economic Geology (BEG) would jointly implement the
West Hastings research monitoring, verification, and accounting (MVA)
program aimed at providing an accurate accounting of approximately 1
million tons of stored CO2, and a high level of confidence
that the CO2 injected in the oilfield during existing EOR
operations will remain permanently sequestered. The West Hastings
research MVA activities would supplement Denbury's ongoing commercial
monitoring activities and regulatory requirements performed for
commercial CO2 EOR and would provide additional information
regarding the underground movement and confinement of CO2.
In the context of NEPA, connected actions are actions dependent on
the proposed action, as set forth in 40 CFR 1508.25. The Lake Charles
CCS project cannot operate without the Gasification Plant, thus
construction and operation of the Gasification Plant is a connected
action and evaluated in the EIS. The Gasification Plant would convert
petroleum coke into syngas, which would be further processed to produce
methanol, hydrogen gas, and sulfuric acid, as well as CO2.
The Gasification Plant would provide raw syngas containing
CO2 to the Lake Charles CCS project, where the
CO2 would be separated from the syngas. The Gasification
Plant and Lake Charles CCS capture and compression facilities would be
located on an approximately 70-acre parcel of land leased from the Lake
Charles Harbor and Terminal District (Port of Lake Charles), on the
west bank of the Calcasieu River adjacent to Bulk Terminal No. 1, in
southern Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana. The Gasification Plant would
require new utility linears and pipelines for delivery of materials and
transport of products as described in the EIS.
Site preparation activities for the Gasification Plant, including
clearing and grading, began in January 2010. Site preparation work to
add approximately 12 feet of fill to raise the site elevations above
the local 100-year and 500-year base flood elevations also began in
November 2010. These activities were authorized under permits issued by
the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) (Lake Charles Harbor &
Terminal District Consent No. DACW29-9-08 [May 30, 2008] and MVN-1998-
03311-WY [August 18, 2008]). Construction of the Gasification Plant is
expected to begin in the first quarter of 2014 and take approximately
36 months to complete. Peak construction is expected in month 18 and
will involve approximately 2,500 workers, of which 900 would be at the
Gasification Plant site.
For the purposes of the EIS, DOE assumed that the CO2
capture system would continue to operate for 30 years. Petroleum coke
from local refineries is already stored at the Port of Lake Charles and
shipped to buyers overseas. The approximately 0.5 million tons per year
of petroleum coke needed for the Gasification Plant will come from the
port. Another approximately 2.1 million tons per year would come from
other ports in the Gulf of Mexico region. During operation of the
Gasification Plant, process-related chemicals would be transported to
and from the facility by truck, rail, barge or ship.
The Lake Charles CCS Project does not include the commercial
operation of the Green Pipeline or the existing EOR operations at the
West Hastings oil field. These activities are not connected actions as
defined by 40 CFR 1508.25.
Alternatives
Congress directed DOE to pursue the ICCS program by providing
federal financial assistance to projects owned and controlled by non-
federal sponsors. This statutory requirement places DOE in a much more
limited role than if it were the owner and operator of these projects.
Here, the purpose and need for DOE action is defined by the ICCS
program (and its enabling legislation, Public Laws 110-140 and 111-5).
As such, the reasonable alternatives available to DOE prior to the
selection of this project under the ICCS program were the other
projects that met the eligibility requirements of a competitive
solicitation. Other applications (and their potential environmental,
safety, and health impacts) were considered during the selection
process. Pursuant to 10 CFR 1021.216, a publicly-available synopsis of
the environmental review and critique developed for the selection
process was included in the EIS.
After DOE selects a project for an award, the range of reasonable
alternatives becomes the project as proposed by the applicant, any
alternatives still under consideration by the applicant, and the no
action alternative.
No Action Alternative
Under the no action alternative, DOE would not provide cost-shared
funding for the proposed Lake Charles CCS project. In the absence of
DOE cost-shared funding, Leucadia could reasonably pursue several
options. Leucadia could build both the Gasification Plant and the CCS
project with funding from other sources and these facilities would
include the same features, attributes, and impacts of the proposed
project and connected action. Alternatively, Leucadia could choose not
to build all or parts of the Gasification Plant and CCS project. For
the purpose of making a meaningful comparison between the impacts of
DOE providing and withholding financial assistance, DOE assumed that
all or part of the Gasification Plant and CCS project would not be
completed without DOE funding. Therefore, the following alternatives
were identified and analyzed in the EIS:
1. Neither the Gasification Plant nor the Lake Charles CCS project
would be built; or
2. The Gasification Plant would be built, but the captured
CO2 would be vented to the atmosphere rather than
sequestered in an ongoing EOR operation.
[[Page 1856]]
The ongoing commercial CO2 EOR operations and the West
Hastings research MVA program would continue under each of these no
action alternatives. Under these alternatives, the opportunity to
capture an average of 4.6 million tons of anthropogenic CO2
per year over the 30 year life of the Gasification Plant for use in EOR
would not be realized. These alternatives would not contribute to DOE's
goal of advancing the next generation of technologies that capture
CO2 from industrial sources for sequestration or beneficial
reuse. While the no action alternatives would not satisfy the purpose
and need for DOE action, these alternatives were analyzed to allow for
comparisons to the impacts of the proposed project as required by 40
CFR 15012.14. The no action alternatives reflect the baseline
conditions and serve as benchmarks against which the impacts of the
proposed action can be evaluated.
Leucadia has begun preparing the site for construction of the
Gasification Plant without DOE funding for other purposes not related
to the Lake Charles CCS project. The construction of the Gasification
Plant will receive no DOE funding.
NEPA Process
DOE published a Notice of Intent (NOI) for this proposed action in
the Federal Register (FR) on April 29, 2011 (FR Doc. 2011-10448). DOE
held public scoping meetings on May 16, 2011, in Pearland, Texas, and
May 17, 2011, in Westlake, Louisiana. The public scoping period ended
on May 29, 2011, after a 30-day comment period.
DOE prepared a draft EIS identifying and analyzing the potential
impacts of the proposed action and no action alternatives. Although DOE
funds would only go to the CCS project, DOE determined that the
Gasification Plant is a connected action in accordance with 40 CFR
1508.25(a), and its impacts are analyzed in the EIS, as well as DOE's
no action alternatives. DOE announced the availability of the draft EIS
in a Notice of Availability (NOA) published in the Federal Register
(FR) by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on May 10, 2013
(78 FR 28205). DOE published a separate NOA to announce its plans for
two public hearings, held in Westlake, Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana, on
June 4, 2013, and in Pearland, Brazoria County, Texas on June 5, 2013.
DOE received oral comments on the draft EIS at the public hearings
and listened to questions and concerns during informal sessions before
the hearings. During the 45-day public comment period, which ended June
25, 2013, DOE received comment letters from several organizations and
agencies. Comments included concerns about: (1) The economic benefit of
the project and the use of federal funds; (2) the amount of
CO2 that would be emitted and captured, and the monitoring
of the CO2 throughout the process; (3) the amount and types
of wastes generated; (4) the process for selecting projects for DOE
funding; (5) the impacts on the ozone non-attainment status of
Calcasieu Parish; (6) mitigation measures for construction-related
emissions; (7) the loss of forests and impacts on threatened and
endangered species; (8) adequacy of the environmental justice analysis;
(9) impacts to water resources and wetlands; and (10) safety of
chemical use and storage.
DOE considered these comments in preparing the final EIS. DOE
distributed the final EIS on November 14, 2013, and EPA published a NOA
in the FR on November 22, 2013 (78 FR 70041). DOE received no comments
on the final EIS.
Decision
DOE has decided to provide Leucadia with $261.4 million in cost-
shared funding for its proposed project through a cooperative agreement
under DOE's ICCS program.
Basis of DOE's Decision
DOE based its decision on the importance of achieving the
objectives of the ICCS program and a careful review of the potential
environmental impacts presented in the EIS. The proposed project would
help DOE meet its congressionally mandated mission of supporting
demonstration of the next generation of technologies that capture
CO2 from industrial sources for sequestration or beneficial
use. The proposed action would also generate technical, environmental,
and financial data regarding the design, construction, and operation of
a CO2 capture facility, pipeline, and monitoring facilities.
The data would contribute to DOE's evaluation of the effective and
economic implementation of these technologies at a commercial scale.
This decision incorporates all practicable means to avoid or
minimize environmental harm. DOE plans to verify the environmental
impacts predicted in the EIS and the implementation of appropriate
avoidance and mitigation measures.
Mitigation
DOE's decision incorporates measures to avoid and minimize adverse
environmental impacts during the design, construction and operation of
the project. DOE requires that recipients of financial assistance
comply with all applicable federal, state, and local environmental
laws, orders, and regulations. During project planning, Leucadia
incorporated various minimization measures and anticipated permit
requirements into its project. The analyses completed for the EIS
assumed that such measures would be implemented. These measures are
identified in Chapter 4 of the EIS and hereby incorporated into this
ROD as conditions for DOE's financial assistance under the cooperative
agreement between DOE and Leucadia. Additional mitigation measures or
measures specific to certain impacts or comments received are further
discussed below in the section entitled Potential Environmental Impacts
and Mitigation Measures.
Mitigation measures beyond those typically specified in permit
conditions will be addressed in a Mitigation Action Plan (MAP). DOE
will prepare the MAP, consistent with 10 CFR 1021.331, to establish how
the mitigation measures will be planned, implemented, and monitored.
The MAP is an adaptive management tool; therefore mitigation conditions
in it would be removed if equivalent conditions are otherwise
established by permit, license, or law. Compliance with permit, license
or regulatory requirements is not considered mitigation subject to DOE
control and therefore are not included in a MAP.
DOE will ensure that requirements in the MAP are met through
management of its cooperative agreement with Leucadia, which requires
that Leucadia fulfill the monitoring and mitigation measures specified
in this ROD. DOE will make copies of the MAP available for inspection
online and in appropriate locations for a reasonable time. Copies of
the MAP and any annual reports required under it will also be available
upon written request.
Potential Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
In making its decision, DOE considered the environmental impacts of
Leucadia's proposed project, DOE's proposed action, and the no action
alternative on potentially affected environmental resource areas. These
included: Climate and air quality, including greenhouse gas emissions;
geology and soils; surface water, wetlands, and floodplains;
groundwater; biological resources; cultural resources; land use;
socioeconomics and environmental justice; traffic and transportation;
noise; waste management; materials; and human
[[Page 1857]]
health and safety. The EIS also considered the impacts of the project
in combination with those from other past, present, and reasonably
foreseeable future actions. The following sections summarize the
potential impacts to the resource areas with mitigation requirements.
Detailed information for all resource areas is in the EIS.
Air Quality
Construction of the Gasification Plant and the CCS project's
CO2 capture and compression facilities would result in
short-term, localized increased fugitive dust and vehicle and
construction equipment emissions. In response to EPA's comments on the
draft EIS, Leucadia will implement additional best management practices
(BMPs) and mitigation measures. To control fugitive dust, Leucadia must
avoid open storage of dry material, install wind fencing as needed, use
water trucks to stabilize surfaces, prevent spillage when hauling
material and operating equipment, to the extent possible, and limit the
speed of vehicles on site to 15 miles per hour (mph) and earth-moving
equipment to 10 mph. To control mobile and stationary source emissions,
Leucadia must use remote parking with bus transport to the worksite,
maintain and tune engines per manufacturer's specifications to perform
at EPA certification levels, prevent tampering with engines, and use
new equipment where practicable. Leucadia also must limit idling of
heavy equipment; EPA recommends limiting idling to less than 5 minutes.
In assessing potential impacts during operations, DOE evaluated the
Lake Charles CCS project and the Gasification Plant as a single
facility, because together they make a single source for purposes of
air emissions. Leucadia completed air dispersion modeling in support of
the initial permit application for criteria pollutants and toxic air
pollutants. For all criteria pollutants, maximum modeled concentrations
in ambient air due to the proposed facility emissions would not violate
federal or Louisiana standards.
A General Conformity analysis is not required for the operations
phase as the Gasification Plant, which includes the Lake Charles CCS
project CO2 capture and compression facilities, requires a
permit under the Prevention of Significant Deterioration program. Under
the General Conformity rule, DOE evaluated the impact of construction
emissions because Calcasieu Parish has a maintenance plan effective
through 2014 for the 8-hour National Ambient Air Quality ozone
standard. Total NOX emissions would increase 1.9 percent and
total VOC emissions would increase 0.5 percent above the projected 2014
emission values in Calcasieu Parish. These increases in emissions from
construction would not obstruct Calcasieu Parish's efforts to maintain
attainment with the ozone standard.
Construction and operation of the CO2 pipeline, and
operation of the West Hastings research MVA program would result in
short-term, localized increased fugitive dust and vehicle emissions.
Denbury has indicated that it will implement BMPs including suppression
techniques to minimize dust and operate and maintain vehicles in
accordance with manufacturers' recommendations.
Climate
Construction of the Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS project
would generate up to approximately 31,300 tons per year (tpy) of
CO2 emissions over the construction period. Operation of the
Gasification Plant would result in approximately 5.8 million tpy of new
CO2 emissions. According to the terms of the cooperative
agreement, Leucadia must design and construct the Lake Charles CCS
project with the goal of capturing at least 75 percent of the
CO2 from the treated stream, comprising at least 10 percent
of CO2 by volume, which would otherwise be emitted to the
atmosphere. However, the proposed project is designed to capture
approximately 89 percent of the CO2 produced, or
approximately 4.6 million tpy, when averaged over 30 years.
Additionally, DOE compared the life cycle analysis (LCA) for the
proposed project and connected action against the greenhouse gas (GHG)
LCA for conventional production methods of the same quantities of
methanol (steam reformation of natural gas), hydrogen (pressure swing
absorption), and sulfuric acid (combustion of elemental sulfur and
catalysis reactions) that would be produced by Leucadia with these
facilities. The CCS project captures CO2 and prevents long-
distance exportation of petroleum coke, making the Gasification Plant
life cycle GHG emissions 56 percent lower than conventional production
methods generating the same quantities of methanol.
Geology and Soils
Construction and operation of the Gasification Plant and Lake
Charles CCS capture and compression facilities would result in
negligible impacts to geologic resources. The risk of seismic events is
minimal because the area is within the lowest seismic hazard category
(Seismic Zone 0). Potential minor impacts to soils during construction
of the project pipelines would include disturbance of soils and the
potential for increased soil erosion from both wind and water.
Construction of the CO2 pipeline would temporarily affect
approximately 107 acres of prime farmland. Construction of the water
supply and hydrogen pipelines would temporarily affect approximately
111 acres of prime farmland. As the pipelines would be located below
the surface, impacts on prime farmland would be minor and temporary.
Leucadia must restore surface conditions to their original state and
use following construction of the water supply and hydrogen pipelines.
Potential soil impacts in all construction areas would be avoided or
mitigated as described in a project-specific storm water pollution
prevention plan (SWPPP). Operational activities would have negligible
impacts on soil, primarily due to disturbance of soils from vehicle
traffic and minor spills or leaks from vehicles used during inspection
and maintenance activities.
The West Hastings research MVA program would occur in a seismically
stable area (Seismic Zone 0). None of the proposed MVA activities would
produce vibrations or forces that would result in seismic
destabilization, and no geologic hazards exist that would impact the
project or that would become more hazardous or be aggravated as a
result of those activities. Potential impacts on geologic resources
could result from seismic events or subsidence related to
CO2 injection; CO2 migration through a permeable
zone in the confining unit or through improperly plugged and abandoned
wells or unknown wells; or CO2 migration through an existing
injection, production, or monitoring well. Denbury has indicated that a
well integrity testing program would be conducted and any deficiencies
would be corrected prior to use of such wells. CO2 migration
from the target geologic units is unlikely, and ongoing monitoring and
modeling would provide an accurate accounting of the approximately 1
million tons per year of CO2 stored through the commercial
EOR process. Therefore, DOE expects adverse impacts on geologic
resources at the West Hastings oil field from the West Hastings
research MVA program to be unlikely and negligible to minor due to the
nature of the site and the activities being conducted. Furthermore, the
research MVA program could have the positive impact of helping to
ensure the long-term economic and financial
[[Page 1858]]
viability of CO2 capture by confirming storage of
CO2 injected during commercial EOR operations.
Surface Water, Wetlands, and Floodplains
The quantity of water needed for construction and operation of the
Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS capture and compression
facilities would have negligible impacts on water availability and
local water use.
Approximately 26.2 acres of wetlands were permanently impacted
during the site preparation for the Gasification Plant and were
addressed through off-site mitigation banking. Construction does not
conflict with applicable flood management plans or ordinances and would
not increase the potential for flooding. Potential surface water and
wetland impacts from the construction of the water supply and hydrogen
pipelines would occur during crossing of Bayou d'Inde, the Sabine River
Canal, and two additional water bodies. Construction of the water
supply and hydrogen pipelines could potentially impact 7.1 acres of
wetlands, but the final wetland delineation and permitting will be
conducted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). If a water body,
wetland, or floodplain is crossed by the water supply and hydrogen
pipelines and determined to be a jurisdictional water of the United
States and the construction impacts on wetlands exceed applicable
thresholds, Leucadia must obtain the necessary USACE permits. If
compensatory wetland mitigation becomes necessary under any USACE
permit, Leucadia must implement additional mitigation as required and
described in the permit(s). Leucadia must use horizontal directional
drilling (HDD) where appropriate to minimize the environmental impacts
of crossing surface waters.
Activities during the operations period would not result in
additional structures in the floodplain, filling of wetlands, or
alteration of infiltration rates that would increase volumes
downstream.
During construction of the CO2 pipeline potential
impacts to surface water quality include increased sediment load,
alteration of flow rates and accidental spills of chemicals or
lubricants. Denbury has proposed HDD to minimize the environmental
impacts of crossing surface waters. In addition, USACE permits must be
obtained to cross waters of the United States, including associated
wetlands. Approximately 550,100 gallons of water for hydrostatic
testing would be obtained from local water bodies or purchased from
municipal supplies. No changes in the availability of surface water for
current or future uses are anticipated as a result of pipeline
construction. Construction of the CO2 pipeline could
permanently impact 14.98 acres and temporarily impact 13.23 acres of
100-year floodplain. Due to the narrow width of the permanent right-of-
way (ROW), no alteration of infiltration rates are expected and there
would be no substantial decrease in the volume of surface water flowing
downstream. Normal operation of the CO2 pipeline would not
affect surface waters. No impacts on wetlands or floodplains are
anticipated from operation of the CO2 pipeline.
The West Hastings Research MVA program would not involve the
removal or injection of any materials that would result in changes in
surface water availability or runoff or result in significant effluent
releases. Recompletion of proposed wells would be outside wetland
areas, and Denbury has proposed BMPs to prevent runoff from entering
wetlands outside of construction areas. MVA activities would not
increase the potential for floods, alter a floodway or floodplain, or
otherwise impede or redirect flows.
Biological Resources
Construction and operations activities at the Gasification Plant
and Lake Charles CCS Capture and Compression facilities are expected to
have negligible to moderate impacts on biological resources, which
include wildlife, habitat, plant life, threatened and endangered
species, and migratory birds. The loss of 70 acres within the 1,740
acres of forested habitat represents 4 percent of the total area.
Clearing and filling of the equipment laydown area could remove up to
40 acres of potential adjacent forested emergent wetland habitat. A
loss of 40 acres of forest in the equipment laydown and methanol/
sulfuric acid storage area represents a 14.5 percent loss within the
local 275-acre forested wetland area and 2.3 percent loss within the
1,740-acre forested area of the Bayou ecosystem, which is a part of the
Calcasieu estuary. The Port of Lake Charles consulted with the
Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries (LDWF) and Louisiana
Natural Heritage Program, regarding construction of the equipment
laydown area. The Louisiana Natural Heritage Program indicated that no
impacts on rare, threatened, or endangered species or critical habitats
are anticipated. Approximately 76 percent of the water supply pipeline
route and 99 percent of the hydrogen pipeline route follow existing
ROWs. The water supply pipeline and hydrogen pipeline corridor would
impact 18.47 and 62.74 acres, respectively, of forest habitat
potentially used by the red cockaded woodpecker. The USFWS's Louisiana
Ecological Services concurred that the proposed project is not likely
to adversely affect resources under the jurisdiction of Endangered
Species Act. Prior to construction of the pipelines, Leucadia must
contact LDWF to request another database review to identify any new
occurrences of nesting areas for migratory birds or colonial water
birds. Leucadia must perform site-specific surveys within 2 weeks of
project startup, in accordance with LDWF requirements, to determine
whether migratory birds or colonial water bird nesting areas are
present and the extent of any colonies. Leucadia must further consult
with LDWF if active nesting colonies are found within 400 meters of the
project site. Operations activities are expected to have negligible
impacts to biological resources.
The CO2 pipeline would be located along or within
existing utility ROWs to the extent practicable and construction would
result in minor impacts to biological resources. Pipeline construction
would affect 10.21 acres of forest, 17.65 acres of scrub-shrub, and 2.1
acres of herbaceous grassland habitats. Denbury has indicated that it
will obtain necessary federal and state permits, and associated site-
specific surveys and mitigation, if necessary, prior to construction.
The LDWF recommended that surveys of suitable nesting areas be
conducted no more than two weeks before construction begins to
determine whether breeding colonies are present. In addition, the USFWS
recommended informing on-site personnel of the need to identify
colonial wading birds and their nests, and to avoid affecting them
during the breeding season. Operations activities are expected to have
negligible impacts to biological resources.
Negligible impacts on aquatic ecology, terrestrial vegetation, or
wildlife, including threatened and endangered species, are expected as
a result of the West Hastings research MVA activities. Affected
habitats at these locations have been disturbed by past and ongoing
industrial and oil production activities. Operations activities are
expected to have negligible impacts to biological resources.
Cultural Resources
Construction of the Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS Capture
and Compression facilities would disturb a portion of one cultural
resource site located within the areas of potential
[[Page 1859]]
effects (APEs). The Louisiana Site Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO)
concurred with the determination that the site was not eligible for
listing on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) and that no
further investigations were necessary. Operation of the plant and
facilities would have no impacts on cultural resources or historic
properties. DOE initiated consultation with 13 federally recognized
Native American tribes in Louisiana, Texas, and other states in
accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act
of 1966, as amended. The Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma was the only tribe
to respond to the consultation letter for the proposed action. It
concurred with the finding of no historic properties affected at this
time and agreed that the project should move ahead as planned. Leucadia
must include a provision in its construction plans for its contractors
that require them to immediately notify LCCE if identifiable tribal
artifacts or remains are found during construction. If notified of any
such discoveries, Leucadia must inform the SHPO and the Choctaw Nation
to ensure the artifacts or remains are handled appropriately.
Construction of the CCS CO2 pipeline would destroy one
archaeological site. However, the SHPO reviewed the results of the
Phase I cultural resources survey within the APE and concluded that the
site was not eligible for the NRHP. Construction of the CO2
pipeline also has the potential to result in direct, permanent,
negative impacts on the Hardey Family Cemetery. Denbury proposes to
avoid the direct impacts by directionally drilling beneath the cemetery
to avoid physical disturbance. Cemetery owners have indicated no
objection to construction of the proposed pipeline if there are no
surface operations and the HDD method is employed to a depth of at
least 25 feet below the surface of the cemetery.
Construction and operation of the CO2 pipeline would
have minor impacts on cultural resources. Operation of the West
Hastings research MVA program would have no impacts on cultural
resources because none were identified within the MVA area.
Leucadia, in coordination with DOE, must continue consultation with
the SHPO for areas not previously surveyed for cultural resources. This
may occur if the currently proposed pipeline route needs to be altered
or for other unforeseen areas of ground disturbance not analyzed in the
EIS. Leucadia must complete any additional surveys prior to
construction in such areas.
Land Use
Construction and operation of the Gasification Plant and
CO2 Capture and Compression facilities would not conflict
with current and future land use plans and/or zoning ordinances of
Calcasieu Parish. Impacts on residences would be negligible due to the
distance between residential areas and the construction site.
Construction of the raw water pipeline would impact a total of 122
acres of land, including 24 acres of permanent ROW and 98 acres of
temporary ROW. Construction of the hydrogen pipeline would impact a
total of 77 acres of land, including 51 acres of permanent ROW and
approximately 26 acres of temporary ROW. To reduce impacts on
surrounding land and properties, approximately 76 percent of the water
supply pipeline route and 99 percent of the hydrogen pipeline route
would follow existing ROWs. Temporary visual impacts would result due
to construction and ground disturbance. Impacts on cropland would be
temporary, and active cropland would revert to preconstruction use for
the full width of the ROWs. Construction would not impact special land
uses such as recreation areas, public lands, historic sites, and
protected water bodies. Leucadia must use BMPs including dust
suppression techniques to control the dust generated by construction.
Leucadia must revegetate the pipeline ROWs and adjacent properties to
pre-construction conditions and vegetate and maintain new ROW areas.
Operation of the Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS CO2
Capture and Compression facilities would be compatible with the
surrounding industrial properties and would have no or negligible
impacts on surrounding land uses. Occasional maintenance of the water
supply and hydrogen pipelines may require access to buried portions of
the lines. Leucadia would coordinate with property owners to minimize
potential disturbances. The ROWs and adjacent properties would be
restored to pre-construction conditions and maintained.
Construction of the CCS CO2 pipeline would cause short
term impacts on 50.62 acres of temporary ROW and long term impacts to
56.34 acres of permanent ROW. Construction activities would include use
of a 12.4 acre site for a warehouse yard and a 6.9-acre site at the
pipe storage yard. Construction of the CO2 pipeline would
result in the permanent conversion of 8.27 acres of forested land,
including 2.98 acres of forested wetland. Small areas of other
vegetation (i.e., scrub/shrub, pasture, and grassland) within the
construction ROW could be permanently impacted. Following construction,
approximately 50.62 acres of land within the temporary ROW would be
restored to previous conditions and uses. Active cropland would be
allowed to revert to preconstruction use in the full width of the ROW.
No special land uses such as recreation areas, public lands, historical
sites, or protected water bodies would be impacted by construction
activities. Denbury would avoid or minimize adverse impacts on land use
by locating the proposed CO2 pipeline within or adjacent to
existing utility ROWs with compatible land uses to the extent
practicable. Denbury has indicated that it would use BMPs to supplement
applicable regulatory requirements in order to minimize impacts on land
use during construction. Operation of the CO2 pipeline would
require that landowners not construct or place any structures within
the permanent ROW. Occasional maintenance may require access to buried
portions of the pipeline. Denbury would use BMPs during maintenance to
avoid or minimize impacts on adjacent land uses and residences.
Operation of the pipeline would have temporary and negligible impacts
on surrounding land uses during maintenance. The West Hastings Research
MVA activities are consistent with the existing commercial EOR
operations and would have negligible impacts on land uses in the
immediate and surrounding areas.
Traffic and Transportation
A temporary increase in traffic during construction of the
Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS Capture and Compression
facilities is expected from approximately 900 workers accessing the
off-site construction parking area and approximately 150 off-site
construction vehicles entering the LCCE Gasification site daily during
peak construction. No major short or long-term impacts to interstate,
multi-lane highway or two lane highway transportation resources are
expected to occur, although certain segments of local roadways
currently are in degraded conditions. Based on the estimated existing
and projected future level of service (LOS) of Ruth Street, the use of
this street during peak construction would degrade its LOS. For the
offsite construction parking area, Leucadia must operate shuttle buses
to reduce traffic congestion on local roadways and may be required to
obtain a temporary construction access permit from the Louisiana
Department of Transportation and Development (DOTD). To the extent
practicable, Leucadia must schedule heavy
[[Page 1860]]
equipment deliveries during off peak hours, start work shifts at non-
peak hours, stagger arrival times at the off-site construction parking
area, request that personnel use roadways with LOS of A, B, or C, and
coordinate traffic congestion with Louisiana DOT District 7.
Construction of the water supply and hydrogen pipelines may cause
short-term, minor traffic delays from large, slow-moving heavy
equipment and delivery trucks. Leucadia must ensure adequate notice to
landowners and drivers to maintain access to public roads.
During operations, additional traffic from 187 personnel and
approximately 127 material deliveries would be negligible compared to
the current traffic. The estimated total ship traffic for the
Gasification Plant is 12 trips per year or approximately 1.2 percent of
the current vessel traffic at the Port of Lake Charles.
A temporary minor increase in traffic during construction of the
CO2 pipeline is expected from an average of approximately
100 personnel and 10 trucks accessing the route daily. Denbury has
indicated that it would minimize impacts through various measures that
ensure adequate notice to landowners and drivers to maintain access to
public roads. Periodic maintenance of the ROW would include slow-moving
mowers and occasional maintenance vehicles. Impacts on local traffic
related to 14 new personnel hired by Denbury to perform the MVA
activities, as well as personnel that would conduct temporary site
visits, would be negligible.
Noise
Sound levels for general construction of the Gasification Plant and
Lake Charles CCS Capture and Compression facilities at the closest
noise-sensitive, residential receptor are expected to be 58 average-
weighted decibels [dBA], which exceeds the 55 dBA EPA guideline.
However, a noise study indicated that the current background noise
level at the nearest receptor (60 dBA) also exceeds the EPA guideline.
As a temporary daytime occurrence, construction noise of this magnitude
would likely be imperceptible, and impacts would be negligible.
Increased truck traffic during daytime hours would cause a temporary
increase in noise at a limited number of residences and the impacts are
expected to be negligible. Residences within 500 to 1,000 feet of
construction of the water supply and hydrogen pipelines would
experience a short-term increase in ambient noise and vibrations from
construction activity. Receptors near HDD locations could experience
elevated temporary ambient noise levels as high as 78 dBA. Noise
minimization measures would be used to reduce levels by approximately
10 dBA. Leucadia must minimize noise levels by limiting construction
activities to daylight hours, as practicable, requiring contractors to
minimize construction noise and maintain equipment in good working
order, and utilizing temporary sound barriers. If necessary, Leucadia
must obtain a variance from Calcasieu Parish for operating HDD
equipment during evening and weekend hours. Typical sound levels for
the equipment to be used during operation of the LCCE Gasification
plant and CO2 capture and compression facilities can exceed
120 dBA. Leucadia must implement engineering design and noise
minimization measures to limit the levels such that the combination of
noise from the plant and existing ambient noise would not exceed 58 dBA
at the nearest noise-sensitive receptor during operation.
During the CCS CO2 pipeline construction, noise levels
may exceed the EPA guideline of 55 dBA at some residences. HDD
activities may need to be conducted in the evening or weekends within
165 feet of a residence or noise sensitive area, which is prohibited by
Calcasieu and Cameron Parishes without a variance. Noise minimization
measures would be implemented to achieve up to a 10 dBA reduction. As a
temporary daytime occurrence, noise from construction of the
CO2 pipeline would have short-term, minor impacts on noise
receptors. The impacts from traffic noise during construction would be
negligible because a majority of the pipeline route traverses rural
areas. No noise above ambient levels would be generated by operation of
the CO2 pipeline. Noise impacts from equipment and vehicles
used during inspection and maintenance activities would be negligible.
Noise produced by equipment during conversion and reworking of
wells for the West Hastings Research MVA Program is not expected to
exceed the EPA guideline more than 1,000 feet from the equipment.
Construction noise of this magnitude would likely be imperceptible,
given the industrial setting, and the on-going commercial EOR
operations. Therefore, the potential noise from the research MVA well
reworking would result in negligible impacts. Traffic noise may
increase for additional periodic sampling and monitoring activities,
but the increase would not be distinguishable from ambient noise levels
and would be negligible.
Waste Management
Approximately 2,640 cubic yards of nonhazardous waste and small
quantities of hazardous waste would be generated annually during the 3-
year construction period of the Gasification Plant and Lake Charles CCS
Capture and Compression facilities, or less than 0.0002 percent of the
available landfill capacity in Calcasieu Parish. Leucadia must require
construction contractors to develop a Waste Management Plan that
includes specifications for handling, containment, and disposal of all
wastes generated during construction of the Gasification Plant and CCS
Capture and Compression facilities. Approximately 65,000 tons (75,000
cubic yards) of nonhazardous waste generated annually during operation
represents 0.6 percent of the total landfill capacity in Calcasieu
Parish. Approximately 1,500 cubic yards of potentially hazardous waste
would be generated annually during operation, or less than 0.03 percent
of the capacity of the hazardous waste landfills in Calcasieu Parish.
Leucadia must implement a program to reduce, reuse, and recycle waste
materials to the extent practicable.
Portions of the CCS CO2 pipeline would be constructed
using HDD and a bentonite slurry that would be recycled, spread in
upland areas as a soil supplement, if permitted, or removed and
disposed of at a local permitted solid waste landfill. Construction and
operation would not create hazardous wastes in quantities that would
require a RCRA permit. Disposal of nonhazardous and potentially
hazardous wastes generated by construction and operation of the
proposed CO2 pipeline would have a negligible impact on the
capacity or management of hazardous or solid waste services and
landfills in the area.
The West Hastings research MVA activities would involve drilling
equipment to plug back, recondition, and re-complete existing wells.
Research MVA activities could generate waste streams, including
drilling mud and produced water during well construction. Produced
water and light sediment would be pumped into trucks and hauled off-
site by a licensed contractor for disposal. Excess drilling mud would
be collected and stabilized in steel tanks and transported off-site to
a designated local solid waste landfill. No hazardous waste would be
generated as a result of the research MVA activities. Impacts related
to the disposal of drill cuttings and treatment of the produced water
generated during
[[Page 1861]]
the reworking of existing wells would not require the use of unique
waste disposal or treatment technologies and would result in negligible
impacts on the capacity and management of landfills and disposal
facilities in the area.
Potential Environmental Impacts of the No Action Alternative
Under no action sub-alternative 1, Leucadia would build neither the
Gasification Plant nor the Lake Charles CCS project. The resources
necessary for construction would be available for construction of other
industrial projects in this area or elsewhere. The Port of Lake Charles
would continue to ship pet coke worldwide for use as fuel in power
plants. The use of pet coke in conventional power plants would likely
emit more air emissions than its use in the Gasification Plant because
of the stringent emission requirements imposed on the plant compared to
conventional power plants. Environmental conditions would not change.
The impacts to the community from noise, traffic, air emissions, and
disruption of land use, jobs, and economic development would not occur.
The impacts on the environment from air emissions, disruption of
wildlife, use of surface water, discharge of wastewater, and loss of
wetlands would not occur. Denbury would continue to inject
CO2 obtained from geologic sources in its ongoing EOR
operations. The Lake Charles CCS project would not fund a research MVA
program at the West Hastings oil field. Sub-alternative 1 of the no
action alternative would not contribute to the demonstration of the
next generation of technologies to capture CO2 from
industrial sources.
Under no action sub-alternative 2, Leucadia would build the
Gasification Plant and vent the CO2 to the atmosphere. The
impacts from the construction and operation of the Gasification Plant
would still occur. Leucadia would still capture the CO2 from
the syngas using Rectisol[supreg]. Leucadia would route the
CO2 stream to discharge to the atmosphere under the current
air permit issued by LDEQ. Approximately 5.2 million tons of
CO2 would be emitted per year from the carbon capture
technology that would otherwise be captured. Emissions produced by the
construction of the pipeline, and indirect emissions associated with
electricity use by the CO2 capture and compression facility,
would not occur. No impacts related to construction of the
CO2 pipeline would occur. Denbury would continue to inject
CO2 obtained from geologic sources in its ongoing EOR
operations. The Lake Charles CCS project would not fund a research MVA
program at the West Hastings oil field. If the CCS project is not
built, the opportunity to capture an average of 4.6 million tons of
anthropogenic CO2 per year over the 30 year life of the
Gasification Plant for use in EOR would be lost. Sub-alternative 2
would not contribute to DOE's goal of demonstrating the next generation
of technologies that capture CO2 emissions from industrial
sources.
Environmentally Preferred Alternative
From a local perspective, no action sub-alternative 1 is the
environmentally preferable alternative because it would result in no
changes to existing environmental conditions. However, from a national
perspective, DOE's proposed action is the environmentally preferred
alternative. Successful operation of the proposed project could
facilitate the deployment of advanced technology integrated with an
industrial source to capture CO2 that would otherwise be
emitted to the atmosphere.
Floodplain Statement of Findings
DOE prepared this floodplain statement of findings in accordance
with its regulations entitled ``Compliance With Floodplain and Wetland
Environmental Review Requirements'' (10 CFR 1022). DOE completed the
required floodplain assessment in coordination with development and
preparation of the EIS, and incorporated the results and discussion in
Sections 3.4, 4.4, and Appendix E of the final EIS.
Based on the FEMA Flood Insurance Map and Rita Recovery Maps, the
Gasification Plant and the CO2 Capture and Compression
facilities site's Advisory Base Flood Elevation (ABFE) is 10 feet above
mean sea level (MSL). The Gasification Plant and Capture and
Compression site would be filled to an elevation that is above the
ABFE. The 120-acre area, which would include 40 acres for equipment
laydown during construction and methanol/sulfuric acid storage during
operation, is within the 100-year floodplain of the Calcasieu River.
DOE assumes that the site would continue to be filled above the base
flood elevation set by FEMA. Given the relative size of the 70-acre
site and the 40-acre site compared to the designated floodway of 8
miles along the Calcasieu ship channel and 3,976 acres drainage area,
the fill would not result in a measurable increase in the upstream base
flood elevation as determined by FEMA, nor have a measurable effect on
the performance of the designated floodway. The proposed water and
hydrogen pipelines associated with Gasification Plant would be
installed below ground within the 100-year floodplain of Bayou d'Inde
and Calcasieu River.
The proposed CCS CO2 pipeline route is located in
proximity to the floodplains of Bayou d'Inde, the Houston River, and
the Calcasieu River, and much of the proposed route is located within
100-year floodplains of the Calcasieu River and its tributaries. The
proposed pipeline would be installed below ground, therefore no
alteration of infiltration rates and no substantial decrease in the
volume of surface water that flows downstream would result.
Approximately one-third of the West Hastings research MVA area,
including two proposed well locations, is within the 100-year
floodplain of Chigger Creek. However, research MVA activities would not
increase the potential for floods, alter a floodway or floodplain, or
otherwise impede or redirect flows such that human health, the
environment, or personal property could be affected. Activities would
be conducted on existing wells and no new construction would occur.
As a result of location requirements, i.e., being adjacent to
navigable waters and existing rail, road, and pipeline infrastructure,
the proposed project and connected action were found to have no
practicable siting alternatives. Based upon DOE's review and the
project proponents' coordination with the local floodplain
administrator and local USACE District, and adoption of minimization
measures, DOE's proposed action would not result in potential harm to
or within floodplains.
Issued in Pittsburgh, PA on this 28 day of December 2013.
Scott M. Klara,
Acting Director, National Energy Technology Laboratory.
[FR Doc. 2014-00299 Filed 1-9-14; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P