[Federal Register Volume 78, Number 115 (Friday, June 14, 2013)]
[Notices]
[Pages 35945-35950]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2013-14091]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
Transportation Security Administration
[Docket No. TSA-2013-0005]
RIN 1652-AA55
Request for Comments on Security Training Programs for Surface
Mode Employees
AGENCY: Transportation Security Administration (TSA), DHS.
ACTION: Notice; request for comments.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: TSA seeks comments and data on employee security training
programs and planned security training exercises currently provided by
owner/operators of freight railroads, passenger railroads, public
transportation systems (excluding ferries), and over-the-road buses.
While TSA is in the process of completing a notice of proposed
rulemaking (NPRM) that would fulfill requirements of the Implementing
Recommendations of the 9/11 Commission Act of 2007 (9/11 Act) to
mandate security training for frontline employees, additional data
would provide TSA with a more accurate understanding of the existing
baseline and potential costs associated with the proposed rule. In
particular, TSA is requesting information regarding programs currently
implemented--whether as a result of regulatory requirements, grant
requirements, in anticipation of a rule, voluntary, or otherwise--and
the costs associated with these training programs.
DATES: Submit comments by July 15, 2013.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by the TSA docket number
to this rulemaking, to the Federal Docket Management System (FDMS), a
government-wide, electronic docket management system, using any one of
the following methods:
Electronically: You may submit comments through the Federal
eRulemaking portal at http://www.regulations.gov. Follow the online
instructions for submitting comments.
Mail, In Person, or Fax: Address, hand-deliver, or fax your written
comments to the Docket Management Facility, U.S. Department of
Transportation, 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE., West Building Ground Floor,
Room W12-140, Washington, DC 20590-0001; fax (202) 493-2251. The
Department of Transportation (DOT), which maintains and processes TSA's
official regulatory dockets, will scan the submission and post it to
FDMS.
See SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION for format and other information
about comment submissions.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Virginia Wise, Office of Security
Policy and Industry Engagement, Surface Division, TSA-28,
Transportation Security Administration, 601 South 12th Street,
Arlington, VA 20598-6028; telephone (571) 227-1080; facsimile (703)
603-0230; email Ginny.Wise @dhs.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Comments Invited
TSA invites interested persons to participate in this action by
submitting written comments or views, supplemented with as much data as
possible. We also invite comments relating to the economic or
federalism impacts that might result from this action. See ADDRESSES
above for
[[Page 35946]]
information on where to submit comments.
With each comment, please identify the docket number at the
beginning of your comments. While not required, TSA encourages
commenters to provide their name and contact information so TSA can
engage in follow-up, if necessary. The most helpful comments reference
a specific portion of the document and include supporting data. You may
submit comments and material electronically, in person, by mail, or fax
as provided under ADDRESSES, but please submit your comments and
material by only one means. If you submit comments by mail or delivery,
submit them in an unbound format, no larger than 8.5 by 11 inches,
suitable for copying and electronic filing.
If you would like TSA to acknowledge receipt of comments submitted
by mail, include with your comments a self-addressed, stamped postcard
on which the docket number appears. We will stamp the date on the
postcard and mail it to you.
TSA will file all comments to our docket address, as well as items
sent to the address or email under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT, in
the public docket, except for comments containing confidential
information and sensitive security information (SSI).\1\ Should you
wish your personally identifiable information redacted prior to filing
in the docket, please so state. TSA will consider all comments that are
in the docket on or before the closing date for comments and will
consider comments filed late to the extent practicable. The docket is
available for public inspection before and after the comment closing
date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ ``Sensitive Security Information'' or ``SSI'' is information
obtained or developed in the conduct of security activities, the
disclosure of which would constitute an unwarranted invasion of
privacy, reveal trade secrets or privileged or confidential
information, or be detrimental to the security of transportation.
The protection of SSI is governed by 49 CFR part 1520.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Handling of Confidential or Proprietary Information and Sensitive
Security Information (SSI) Submitted in Public Comments
Comments containing trade secrets, confidential commercial or
financial information, other proprietary information, or SSI should be
appropriately marked as containing such information and submitted by
mail to the address listed in FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT section.
Do not submit comments containing this type of information to the
public regulatory docket. TSA will not place comments containing SSI in
the public docket and will handle them in accordance with applicable
safeguards and restrictions on access. TSA will hold documents
containing SSI, confidential business information, or trade secrets in
a separate file to which the public does not have access, and place a
note in the public docket explaining that commenters have submitted
such documents. TSA may include a redacted version of the comment in
the public docket. If an individual requests to examine or copy
information that is not in the public docket, TSA will treat it as any
other request under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 U.S.C.
552) and the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS's) FOIA regulation
found in 6 CFR part 5.
Reviewing Comments in the Docket
Please be aware that anyone is able to search the electronic form
of all comments in any of our dockets by the name of the individual who
submitted the comment (or signed the comment, if an association,
business, labor union, etc., submitted the comment). You may review the
applicable Privacy Act Statement published in the Federal Register on
April 11, 2000 (65 FR 19477), or you may visit http://DocketInfo.dot.gov.
You may review TSA's electronic public docket on the Internet at
http://www.regulations.gov. In addition, DOT's Docket Management
Facility provides a physical facility, staff, equipment, and assistance
to the public. To obtain assistance or to review comments in TSA's
public docket, you may visit this facility between 9:00 a.m. to 5:00
p.m., Monday through Friday, excluding legal holidays, or call (202)
366-9826. This docket operations facility is located in the West
Building Ground Floor, Room W12-140 at 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE.,
Washington, DC 20590.
Availability of Document
You can get an electronic copy using the Internet by--
(1) Searching the electronic Federal Docket Management System
(FDMS) Web page at http://www.regulations.gov;
(2) Accessing the Government Printing Office's Web page at http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collection.action?collectionCode=FR to view
the daily published Federal Register edition; or accessing the ``Search
the Federal Register by Citation'' in the ``Related Resources'' column
on the left, if you need to do a Simple or Advanced search for
information, such as a type of document that crosses multiple agencies
or dates; or
(3) Visiting TSA's Security Regulations Web page at http://www.tsa.gov and accessing the link for ``Stakeholders'' at the top of
the page, then the link ``Research Center'' in the left column.
In addition, copies are available by writing or calling the
individual in the FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT section. Make sure to
identify the docket number of this rulemaking.
Requirements of the 9/11 Act
The ``Implementing Recommendations of the 9/11 Commission Act of
2007'' (9/11 Act) requires DHS to issue regulations requiring security
training for frontline employees in the public transportation, railroad
carrier, and over-the-road bus (OTRB) modes.\2\ In summary, the 9/11
Act specifies for each mode that regulations must (1) Require
preparation of a program to prepare employees, including frontline
employees, for potential security threats and conditions; (2) for each
mode, the 9/11 Act prescribes specific elements that must, at a
minimum, be included in the program; and (3) sets the schedule by which
all employees covered by the program must be trained. While TSA is in
the process of completing a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) that
would fulfill these requirements of the 9/11 Act, additional data would
provide TSA with a more accurate understanding of the existing baseline
and potential costs associated with the proposed rule. TSA will
consider comments and data submitted in response to this Notice to
inform the NPRM. There will be another opportunity for comment on the
proposed rule once it is published in the Federal Register.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ Public Law 110-53; 121 Stat. 266 (August 3, 2007).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
9/11 Act's Public Transportation Security Training Requirements.
Paragraph 1408(a) of the 9/11 Act directs the Secretary of Homeland
Security to develop and issue regulations ``for a public transportation
security training program to prepare public transportation employees,
including frontline employees, for potential security threats and
conditions.'' Paragraph 1408(c) directs DHS to include specific program
elements. Paragraph 1408(d) requires DHS to approve security training
programs. Paragraph 1408(b) directs DHS to consult with a range of
stakeholders, including appropriate law enforcement, fire service,
security, and terrorism experts; representatives of public
transportation agencies; and
[[Page 35947]]
nonprofit employee labor organizations representing public
transportation employees or emergency response personnel, before
issuing the regulation.
9/11 Act's Railroad Carrier Security Training Requirements. Section
1517 of the 9/11 Act sets similar requirements for railroad carriers.
Paragraph 1517(a) directs the Secretary of Homeland Security to develop
and issue regulations for a security training program ``to prepare
railroad carrier frontline employees for potential security threats and
conditions.'' DHS must consider ``any current security training
requirements and best practices'' in these regulations. Paragraph
1517(b) requires DHS to consult with stakeholders including appropriate
law enforcement, fire service, emergency response, security, and
terrorism experts; railroad carriers; railroad shippers; and nonprofit
employee labor organizations representing railroad employees or
emergency response personnel. Paragraph 1517(c) specifies program
elements. Paragraph 1517(d) requires DHS to approve security training
programs. Within 90 days after DHS issues the regulations, each
railroad carrier must develop a security training program and submit it
to DHS for approval.
9/11 Act's Over-the-Road Bus Security Training Requirements.
Section 1534 of the 9/11 Act contains similar requirements for OTRBs.
Paragraph 1534(a) directs DHS to develop and issue regulations for an
OTRB program ``to prepare over-the-road bus frontline employees for
potential security threats and conditions'' and to ``take into
consideration any current security training requirements or best
practices.'' Paragraph 1534(b) directs DHS to consult with OTRB owner/
operators, first responders, labor representatives, and security
experts before issuing the rule. Paragraph 1534(c) specifies program
elements. Paragraph 1534(d) requires DHS to approve security training
programs. Within 90 days after DHS issues the regulations, each OTRB
owner/operator must develop a security training program and submit it
to DHS for approval.
Specific requirements for all modes. The 9/11 Act prescribes
specific elements that must, at a minimum, be included in the security
training program required by the regulations. Table 1 identifies the
specific elements as prescribed for each of the three modes specified
in the Act.
Table 1--Required Training Program Elements From 9/11 Act
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1408(c)--Public transportation 1517(c)--Freight and passenger railroads 1534(c)--OTRB
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) Determination of the seriousness of (1) Determination of the seriousness of (1) Determination of the
any occurrence or threat. any occurrence or threat. seriousness of any
occurrence or threat.
(2) Crew and passenger communication and (2) Crew and passenger communication and (2) Driver and passenger
coordination. coordination. communication and
coordination.
(3) Appropriate responses to defend (3) Appropriate responses to defend or (3) Appropriate responses
oneself, including using nonlethal protect oneself. to defend or protect
defense devices. oneself.
(4) Use of personal protective devices (4) Use of personal and other protective (4) Use of personal and
and other protective equipment. equipment. other protective
equipment.
(5) Evacuation procedures for passengers (5) Evacuation procedures for passengers (5) Evacuation procedures
and employees, including individuals and railroad employees, including for passengers and over-
with disabilities and the elderly. individuals with disabilities and the the-road bus employees,
elderly. including individuals with
disabilities and the
elderly.
(6) Training related to behavioral and (6) Psychology, behavior, and methods of (6) Psychology, behavior,
psychological understanding of, and terrorists, including observation and and methods of terrorists,
responses to, terrorist incidents, analysis. including observation and
including the ability to cope with analysis.
hijacker behavior, and passenger
responses.
(7) Live situational training exercises (7) Training related to psychological (7) Training related to
regarding various threat conditions, responses to terrorist incidents, psychological responses to
including tunnel evacuation procedures. including the ability to cope with terrorist incidents,
hijacker behavior and passenger including the ability to
responses. cope with hijacker
behavior and passenger
responses.
(8) Recognition and reporting of (8) Live situational training exercises (8) Live situational
dangerous substances and suspicious regarding various threat conditions, training exercises
packages, persons, and situations. including tunnel evacuation procedures. regarding various threat
conditions, including
tunnel evacuation
procedures.
(9) Understanding security incident (9) Recognition and reporting of (9) Recognition and
procedures, including procedures for dangerous substances, suspicious reporting of dangerous
communicating with governmental and non- packages, and situations. substances, suspicious
governmental emergency response packages, and situations.
providers and for on scene interaction
with such emergency response providers.
(10) Operation and maintenance of (10) Understanding security incident (10) Understanding security
security equipment and systems. procedures, including procedures for incident procedures,
communicating with governmental and non- including procedures for
governmental emergency response communicating with
providers and for on scene interaction emergency response
with such emergency response providers. providers and for on scene
interaction with such
emergency response
providers.
(11) Other security training activities (11) Operation and maintenance of (11) Operation and
that the Secretary deems appropriate. security equipment and systems. maintenance of security
equipment and systems.
(12) Other security training activities (12) Other security
that the Secretary deems appropriate. training activities that
the Secretary deems
appropriate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2 identifies the frontline employees who, at a minimum, must
be trained pursuant to security training programs developed to meet the
requirements of the 9/11 Act. Some flexibility is allowed for the
training program to make adjustments as necessary based upon the work
performed by the employee. For example, a dispatcher's training would
likely have more focus on the appropriate protocols for sharing
[[Page 35948]]
information during an emergency while a maintenance-of-way worker may
have more training on identifying potential threats.
Table 2--Frontline Employees Identified in the 9/11 Act
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sec. 1402(4)--Public Sec. 1501(6)--
transportation frontline Sec. 1501(5)--OTRB Railroad frontline
employees frontline employees employees
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Transit vehicle driver or Drivers............. Locomotive
operator. engineers,
conductors,
trainmen, and other
onboard employees.
Maintenance and maintenance Maintenance and Maintenance,
support employee. maintenance support maintenance support
personnel. personnel, and
bridge tenders.
Dispatcher.................. Dispatchers......... Dispatchers.
Security employee, or Security personnel.. Security personnel.
transit police.
Station attendant, customer Ticket agents [and] Locomotive
service employee, and any other terminal engineers,
other employee who has employees. conductors, and
direct contact with riders other onboard
on a regular basis. employees.
Any other employee of a Other employees of Any other employees
public transportation an over-the-road of railroad
agency that the Secretary bus operator or carriers that the
determines should receive terminal owner or Secretary
security training. operator that the determines should
Secretary receive security
determines should training.
receive security
training.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Relation to Other Training Programs
The 9/11 Act includes requirements for TSA to consider ``any
current security training requirements or best practices'' before
issuing security training regulations.\3\ TSA is aware that many public
transportation agencies, railroads, and OTRB owner/operators have
implemented training that may satisfy some of the required security
training program elements outlined above. The impetus for development
of this training may include requirements of other Federal regulations;
pursuant to a grant, using materials developed and/or approved by TSA;
in anticipation of this rulemaking; voluntarily; or as a best practice.
A range of courses--including those sponsored by TSA and other Federal
agencies such as Federal Transit Administration (FTA), the Federal
Railroad Administration (FRA), Federal Motor Carriers Safety
Administration (FMCSA), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
(PHMSA)--may provide a means for covered entities to coordinate
training for their employees in many of the elements stipulated in the
9/11 Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ See 9/11 Act secs. 1517(a) and 1534(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For example, TSA is aware of security training programs that mass
transit and passenger rail agencies have implemented through courses
sponsored by FTA, TSA, FRA and FEMA. Some of this information has been
obtained by TSA as part of an ongoing effort under the Mass Transit
Security Grant Program (TSGP) to develop a user-friendly matrix on
training at basic and follow-on levels for particular categories of
transit employees. In the past, as part of the TSGP, DHS has provided
information to eligible agencies on training that would be pre-approved
for use of grant funds in order to help in developing grant
applications. TSA is also aware that many agencies have used funds
provided under the TSGP to obtain third-party training.
There are also programs that have been developed to support testing
effectiveness of response capabilities, such as the National Exercise
Program managed by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA),
exercises and drills funded through the TSGP, and the Intermodal
Security Training and Exercise Program (I-STEP), both administered by
TSA.\4\ Some of these courses are identified in the example for a
security training matrix posted in the docket for this rulemaking (the
purpose of this example is discussed below).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ In FY 2008 and FY 2009, the TSGP included a Freight Rail
Security Grant Program (FRSGP) that focused on activities designed
to strengthen the nation's critical freight rail infrastructure
against risks associated with potential terrorist attacks. In FY
2009, the program awarded approximately $1.4 million for training
projects.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, under the Intercity Bus Security Grant Program (IBSGP),
which has funded security grants to ``eligible private operators
providing transportation by an over-the-road bus,'' TSA has managed
Operation Secure Transport (OST). Operation Secure Transport is a
training resource made available to train industry employees. Use of
this training is voluntary. This training includes a curriculum
intended to develop the ability of bus employees to recognize security
threats and respond appropriately to security incidents. Under other
grant programs, TSA has funded development of the First Observer\TM\
program, which includes training modules for OTRB drivers on the need
to be aware and vigilant for activities that could lead to terrorist
incidents, such as how terrorists operate and how drivers and others
can sharpen their powers of observation and be involved in preventing
terrorism.
Request for Comments
TSA is requesting public comment and data to assist TSA in
determining the current baseline of training that could meet some of
the security training program elements outlined above. In particular,
TSA is interested in receiving more data from owner/operators who are
currently providing security or related safety training to their
employees. While TSA has gathered significant information in these
areas as part of its rulemaking efforts, there are some areas where it
would be helpful to validate cost elements and ensure our understanding
of the existing baseline is current. The questions asked seek
information to close these gaps.
Commenters are asked to provide as much information as possible. In
some areas, very specific information is being requested. TSA
recognizes that providing detailed on every question could be
burdensome. All information received will be considered, regardless of
whether it is complete, and it is very much appreciated.
General information. Providing information on the nature of the
business operation of the person commenting will help TSA more fully
appreciate the information provided. Please include in your comments
information regarding the nature and size of the business for which the
other information is being provided. In addition, we would appreciate
receiving information about how training is normally delivered, for
example, through instructor-led training sessions,
[[Page 35949]]
web-based training, or other. Failure to provide this information will
not preclude the agency's full consideration of the comment.
Request to complete training matrix. To assist commenters, TSA has
provided tables in the docket for this rulemaking that identify the
requirements of the 9/11 Act. TSA is asking commenters to complete the
table and submit it to TSA. An example is provided, using courses known
to be provided through the TSGP, I-STEP and other programs previously
identified. If the training is being provided to comply with a Federal
or state requirement, please identify the source of that requirement.
Request to respond to specific questions. In addition, TSA is
asking owner/operators of one of the modes of transportation that fall
within the categories identified in the 9/11 Act (freight railroads,
public transportation systems, passenger railroads, over-the-road
buses) to respond to the following questions to help us identify the
baseline and potential costs for the proposed rule. When providing
comments, please explain the basis and reasoning underlying your
comment. Please provide citations and copies of any relevant studies or
reports on which you rely as well as any additional data which supports
your comment.
1. The 9/11 Act focuses the security training program requirements
on ``frontline'' employees. For the relevant business operation, or
component of a larger entity, that would be required to have a security
training program, what percentage of total employees are frontline
employees as identified in Table 2? Please include in the total all
frontline employees, including those employed through a contractor. If
the total includes personnel employed through a contractor, please
identify what percentage they are of the total.
1.1. Do you provide security awareness training to frontline
employees (see Table 1 for a description of the elements of security
awareness training and see Table 2 for an identification of frontline
employees), either through a formal security awareness training
program, or through some other type of employee training or exercise?
If so, please briefly describe. How long have you provided this
training? Did you change the training provided after passage of the 9/
11 Act? Please provide the number of hours, per employee and overall,
in preparing, attending, and implementing these training elements.
1.2. Are there certain types of frontline employees that currently
do not participate in your company's training programs? If so, please
indicate which types of employees (from Table 2) do not currently
participate. Similarly, if you provide training on some of the elements
listed in Table 1 to frontline employees, please describe which
training elements and the types of employees who receive the training.
1.3. Do your frontline employees employed through a contractor
receive the same training as other frontline employees? If not, please
explain why.
1.4. What is the current cost per employee for your security
awareness training? If you do not provide training on all of the
elements listed in Table 1 to all frontline employees, please describe
in as much detail as possible the projected additional cost to your
organization of providing training on the Table 1 elements to all
frontline employees. When providing an estimate for the projected
additional costs, please include the assumptions you are using.
1.5. What is the curriculum delivery method used for your security
awareness training (for example, instructor-led in classroom, computer-
based, self-study, training exercises, a combination of those methods)?
1.6. What, if any, is the refresher training cycle for the training
elements outlined above (for example, annual, biennial, triennial)?
1.7. Rounded up to the nearest hour, what is the amount of time
spent in training related to the security elements in Table 1, per
employee? (Please indicate whether this includes travel time and, if
so, please provide any available data on how much.) Does this time
frame differ based on the employment type or classification of the
trainee? If so, please provide more detail on how your company
determines the appropriate level of training.
1.8. To the extent, either at the corporate headquarters or
subsidiary level, you have received federal grant funding for the
development, production, or delivery of security awareness training,
please indicate whether it was for developing specific training,
training specific employees, or both. In other words, please indicate
how the funding was allocated. In the absence of grant funding, would
you have instituted this training?
2. Does your organization conduct operational or ``live'' exercises
to test security training? To the extent possible, please provide
information regarding the exercise program that reflects whether it is
a phased or multi-tiered program. For example, some exercise programs
have frequent spot checks with employees while performing their duties,
less frequent table-top exercises for managers, and only conduct
``live'' exercises involving emergency responders and other
stakeholders every few years. If you have such an exercise program, in
answering the questions, please provide as much of a cost breakdown as
possible to reflect costs associated with scope, frequency, and number
of participating employees.
2.1. What employee populations participate in these exercises?
2.2. What number of or percentage of frontline employees, as listed
in Table 2, participate in the exercises?
2.3. What is the frequency of the exercises?
2.4. How many management hours are involved in conducting security
exercises including development time and coordination with contractors?
2.5. TSA is aware that owner/operators sometimes contract with
private vendors for the planning, preparation, execution, and
evaluation of exercises. TSA assumes that the fees charged by vendors
will depend on the size and scope of the exercise, including the phases
of an exercise, travel expenses for contractors, and other incidental
charges. TSA requests informed comments related to contractor fees and
the scope of services provided.
2.6. What types of existing tools or resources provided by TSA have
you used that you think would help your company meet the requirements
of the 9/11 Act? (For example, the Intermodal Security Training and
Exercise Program (I-STEP) and First Observer\TM\.)
2.7. Do you change the curriculum or format of your training
programs based upon the results of these exercises? How do you evaluate
whether a change is needed?
3. Additional data needed from owner/operators of freight
railroads.
3.1. TSA derived a 4 percent annual railroad employee turnover rate
from the Railroad Retirement Board.\5\ Is this turnover rate a good
approximation of the turnover rate for the freight railroad industry?
If no, TSA requests comments on the freight railroad industry employee
turnover rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ Railroad Retirement Board, Twenty-Fifth Actuarial Valuation
of Assets and Liabilities Under the Railroad Retirement Acts as of
December 31, 2010 with Technical Supplement, at p. 91, tbl. S-34
(under the ``All Ages, Crude 100'' column). See http://www.rrb.gov/pdf/act/valuation.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. Additional data needed from owner/operators of public
transportation systems.
4.1. TSA obtained a 10.9 percent annual employee turnover rate for
public bus systems from a Transit Cooperative Research Program report
[[Page 35950]]
sponsored by the FTA.\6\ Is this turnover rate a good approximation of
the turnover rate for public transportation and passenger railroads? If
no, TSA requests comments on the public transportation and passenger
railroad employee turnover rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ Transportation Research Board, 2001, TCRP Synthesis 40, at
chpt. 5, p. 36. See http://onlinepubs.trb.org/Onlinepubs/tcrp/tsyn40.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4.2. TSA obtained a 0.92 percent annual growth rate for public
transportation and passenger railroad employees from American Public
Transportation Association (APTA).\7\ Is this growth rate a good
approximation of the industry growth rate for the public transportation
and passenger railroad industry? If no, TSA requests comments on the
public transportation and passenger railroad industry growth rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ APTA, 2010 Public Transportation Fact Book, at page vii,
App. A: Historical Tables (tbl. 11: Operating Employees by Mode).
TSA used the CAGR formula to derive the annual growth rate using
1984-2008 data, netting out the trolley and paratransit employees.
CAGR = ((End value/start value)[caret](1/periods-1)-1). See http://www.apta.com/resources/statistics/Documents/FactBook/2010_Fact_Book_Appendix_A.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. Additional data needed from owner/operators of over-the-road
buses.
5.1. TSA obtained a 32.3 percent annual employee turnover rate for
the OTRB industry using the BLS JOLTS hires rates for transportation,
warehousing, and utilities worker.\8\ Is this turnover rate a good
approximation of the turnover rate for the OTRB industry? If no, TSA
requests comments on the OTRB industry turnover rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ Bureau of Labor Statistics, Jobs and Labor Turnover Survey,
Transportation, warehousing, and utilities workers, Hires Rate,
Annual Jan-Dec 2010 (Series ID JTU48009900HIR).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.2. TSA obtained a 1.77 percent annual industry growth rate for
OTRB carriers from the U.S. Census Bureau.\9\ Is this growth rate a
good approximation of the industry growth rate for the OTRB industry?
If no, TSA requests comments on the OTRB industry growth rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ U.S. Census Bureau, Economic Census 1997 & 2007. Number of
establishments for the following NAICS code industries included:
4859 Other transit & ground passenger transportation (2,555 &
3,136), 4855 Charter bus industry (1,531 & 1,300), 485113 Bus &
motor vehicle transit systems (542 & 933), 4852 Interurban & rural
bus transportation (407 & 562). TSA then applied the constant annual
growth rate formula: CAGR: ((End Value/Start Value)[caret](1/
(periods-1))-1. See http://www.census.gov/epcd/ec97/us/US000_48.HTM#N485 and http://factfinder2.census.gov/bkmk/table/1.0/en/ECN/
2007--US/48A1//naics~485113%7C4852%7C4855%7CALL-4859.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.3. TSA obtained a 1.99 percent annual employee growth rate from
the U.S. Census Bureau.\10\ Is this growth rate a good approximation of
the employee growth rate for the OTRB industry? If no, TSA requests
comments on the OTRB industry employee growth rate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ U.S. Census Bureau, Economic Census, 1997 & 2007. Employee
data for the following NAICS codes included: 4859 (46,304 & 56,689),
4855 (31,483 & 31,343), 485113 (27,448 & 42,334), 4852 (19,900 &
17,690). CAGR = ((End Value/Start Value)[caret](1/(periods-1))-1).
See http://www.census.gov/epcd/ec97/us/US000_48.HTM#N485 and http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/IBQTable?_bm=y&-geo_id=&-fds_name=EC0700A1&-_skip=100&-ds_name=EC0748I2&-_lang=en.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion
As previously noted, TSA appreciates the information that
stakeholders have already provided during the consultation phase of
this rulemaking required by the 9/11 Act.\11\ We are also aware that a
great deal of focus has been placed on the issue of enhancing security
through training over the last decade. In finalizing a proposed rule,
TSA wants to ensure that we adequately reflect these efforts. Any
information that can be provided is appropriate and will be considered
by TSA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ See secs. 1408(b), 1517(b), and 1534(b).
Dated: June 8, 2013.
John S. Pistole,
Administrator.
[FR Doc. 2013-14091 Filed 6-13-13; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 9110-05-P