[Federal Register Volume 78, Number 114 (Thursday, June 13, 2013)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 35719-35742]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2013-13977]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Fish and Wildlife Service
50 CFR Part 17
[Docket No. FWS-R2-ES-2013-0056; FXES11130900000C2-134-FF09E32000]
RIN 1018-AY46
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Proposed Revision
To the Nonessential Experimental Population of the Mexican Wolf
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service), propose to
revise the existing nonessential experimental population designation of
the Mexican wolf (Canis lupus baileyi) under section 10(j) of the
Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended. This action is being taken
in coordination with our proposed rule in today's Federal Register to
list the Mexican wolf as an endangered subspecies and delist the gray
wolf (Canis lupus). The proposal to list the Mexican wolf as an
endangered subspecies and delist the gray wolf species necessitates
that we revise the nonessential experimental population designation of
Mexican wolves in order to correctly associate this designation with
the properly listed entity. In addition, we are proposing several
revisions to the section 10(j) rule. We are seeking comment from the
public on the proposed revisions and on additional possible
modifications that we may analyze and incorporate into our final
determination.
DATES: We will accept comments received on or before September 11,
2013. Comments submitted electronically using the Federal eRulemaking
Portal (see ADDRESSES section) must be received by 11:59 p.m. Eastern
Time on the closing date. We must receive requests for public hearings,
in writing, at the address shown in FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT by
July 29, 2013. We will schedule public hearings on this proposal, if
any are requested, and announce the dates, times, and places of those
hearings, as well as how to obtain reasonable accommodations, in the
Federal Register and local newspapers at least 15 days before any such
hearing.
ADDRESSES: You may submit written comments by one of the following
methods:
(1) Electronically: Go to the Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov. Search for FWS-R2-ES-2013-0056, which is the
docket number for this rulemaking. You may submit a comment by clicking
on ``Comment Now!''
(2) By hard copy: Submit by U.S. mail or hand-delivery to: Public
Comments Processing, Attn: FWS-R2-ES-2013-0056; Division of Policy and
Directives Management; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; 4401 N. Fairfax
Drive, MS 2042-PDM; Arlington, VA 22203.
We request that you send comments only by the methods described
above. We will post all comments on http://www.regulations.gov. This
generally means that we will post any personal information you provide
us (see the Information Requested section below for more information).
To increase our efficiency in downloading comments, groups providing
mass submissions should submit their comments in an Excel file.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mexican Wolf Recovery Program, U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service, New Mexico Ecological Services Field Office,
2105 Osuna Road NE., Albuquerque, NM 87113; by telephone 505-761-4704;
or by facsimile 505-346-2542. If you use a telecommunications device
for the deaf (TDD), call the Federal Information Relay Service (FIRS)
at 800-877-8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
[[Page 35720]]
Executive Summary
Why we need to publish a rule. This rule is being proposed for two
reasons: (1) To ensure this nonessential experimental population of
Mexican wolves will be associated with the Mexican wolf subspecies
listing, if finalized, rather than with the listing of the gray wolf at
the species level; and (2) to allow for public comment on our proposed
revisions and modifications to the 1998 final rule that established a
Mexican wolf nonessential experimental population (63 FR 1752, January
12, 1998) (1998 Final Rule) (Figure 1).
In our 1998 Final Rule, we established two recovery areas (the Blue
Range Wolf Recovery Area [BRWRA] and the White Sands Wolf Recovery
Area) within the Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Area [MWEPA]. We
established primary recovery zones within each of these recovery areas
where initial releases of Mexican wolves would occur, while dispersal
and translocations were allowed throughout the recovery areas. We also
established provisions to remove Mexican wolves that occupied
territories that were wholly outside of the recovery areas, or wolves
that depredated on livestock outside of the recovery areas. Since 1998,
we have only released Mexican wolves into the BRWRA; we have not
utilized the White Sands Wolf Recovery Area. On tribal lands within the
Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Area, we established provisions
where the Service in cooperation with tribal government would develop
management actions, including the capture and removal of Mexican
wolves, if requested by the tribe. In 2000, the White Mountain Apache
Tribe agreed to allow free-ranging Mexican wolves to inhabit the Fort
Apache Indian Reservation, in accordance with this provision of the
Final Rule. We recognize that continued occupancy of Mexican wolves on
the Fort Apache Indian Reservation is dependent upon tribal agreement.
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP13JN13.002
This proposal is necessitated by a related action we are taking to
propose the reclassification of the Mexican wolf (Canis lupus baileyi)
as an endangered subspecies and delist the gray wolf species (Canis
lupus). The Mexican wolf has been listed under the Endangered Species
Act of 1973, as amended (Act) (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.) under a species-
wide gray wolf listing since 1978; therefore, when we designated the
Mexican wolf nonessential experimental population in 1998 (63 FR 1752,
January 12, 1998), it corresponded to the gray wolf listing in the Code
of Federal Regulations (CFR) even though it was specific to our Mexican
wolf recovery effort. With the proposed removal of the gray wolf from
the List of Threatened and Endangered Wildlife and classification of
the Mexican wolf as an endangered subspecies, we recognize the need to
revise 50 CFR 17.11(h) such that the nonessential population will be
[[Page 35721]]
associated with the Mexican wolf subspecies listing rather than with
the gray wolf species.
In order to improve implementation and conservation, we are
proposing several changes to the section 10(j) rule and management
regulations of the Mexican wolves.
The basis for our action. The 1982 amendments to the Act included
the addition of section 10(j), which allows for the designation of
reintroduced populations of listed species as ``experimental
populations.'' Under section 10(j) of the Act and our regulations at 50
CFR 17.81, the Service may designate as an experimental population a
population of endangered or threatened species that has been or will be
released into suitable natural habitat outside the species' current
natural range (but within its probable historical range, absent a
finding by the Director of the Service in the extreme case that the
primary habitat of the species has been unsuitably and irreversibly
altered or destroyed). With the experimental population designation,
the relevant population is treated as threatened for purposes of
section 9 of the Act, regardless of the species' designation elsewhere
in its range. Treating the experimental population as threatened allows
us the discretion to devise management programs and special regulations
for such a population. Section 4(d) of the Act allows us to adopt any
regulations that are necessary and advisable to provide for the
conservation of a threatened species. When designating an experimental
population, the general regulations that extend most section 9
prohibitions to threatened species do not apply to that species, and
the section 10(j) rule contains the prohibitions and exemptions
necessary and appropriate to conserve that species.
We are preparing an environmental impact statement. We are
preparing a draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) pursuant to the
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA; 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.). To
ensure that we consider the environmental impacts associated with this
proposed rule, we are preparing a draft EIS to analyze the proposed
nonessential experimental population of Mexican wolves. From October
through December 2007, we conducted a public scoping process under NEPA
based on our intent to modify the 1998 Final Rule. We developed a
scoping report in April 2008, but we did not propose or finalize any
modifications to the 1998 Final Rule at that time. We will utilize all
information collected since that scoping process began in the
development of a draft EIS. We will use information from this analysis
to inform our final decision.
We will seek peer review. We will obtain opinions from
knowledgeable individuals with scientific expertise on our technical
assumptions, analysis, adherence to regulations, and whether or not we
used the best available information. These peer reviewers will analyze
our methods and conclusions and provide additional information,
clarifications, and suggestions to improve the final determination.
Because we will consider all comments and information we receive during
the comment period, our final determinations may differ from this
proposal.
Information Requested
We are seeking public comments on this proposed rule. We are
particularly interested in public comments on a number of specific
issues we are proposing, and on other options being considered that are
not included in today's proposed rule. We may include any of the
modifications discussed in this proposed rule in our final
determination. We particularly seek comments and information concerning
the following revisions being proposed in today's action:
(1) Expanding the area for direct initial release of captive-raised
Mexican wolves to include the entire BRWRA, thereby eliminating the
primary and secondary recovery zones of the BRWRA (Figure 2).
[[Page 35722]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP13JN13.003
(2) Allowing Mexican wolves to disperse naturally from the BRWRA
into the Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Area (MWEPA) and occupy
the MWEPA without the requirement to bring them back into the BRWRA
(Figure 2).
(3) Removing the portion of west Texas lying north of US Highway
62/180 to the Texas-New Mexico boundary from the MWEPA (Figure 2).
(4) Removing reference to possible reintroduction of Mexican wolves
to the White Sands Wolf Recovery Area (Figure 2).
(5) Developing and implementing management actions on private land
within the MWEPA by the Service or an authorized agency to benefit
Mexican wolf recovery in voluntary cooperation with private landowners,
including but not limited to initial release, proactive measures to
prevent conflicts, and translocation of wolves if requested by the
landowner.
(6) Developing and implementing management actions on tribal land
within the MWEPA by the Service or an authorized agency in voluntary
cooperation with tribal governments including but not limited to
initial release, translocation, proactive measures to prevent
conflicts, capture, and removal of Mexican wolves if requested by the
tribal government.
(7) Identifying section 6 of the Act as authorizing language for
take pursuant to 50 CFR 17.31 for State wildlife agencies with
authority to manage Mexican wolves under the nonessential experimental
population rule.
(8) Clarifying that an individual can be authorized to take Mexican
wolves under specific circumstances.
(9) Clarifying allowable take for Federal agencies and authorized
personnel.
[[Page 35723]]
(10) Revising the conditions that determine when we would issue a
permit to livestock owners or their agents to allow take of Mexican
wolves that are engaged in the act of killing, wounding or biting
livestock on public lands allotted for grazing from ``6 breeding
pairs'' to ``100 Mexican wolves'' to be consistent with our population
objective of establishing a population of at least 100 wolves.
(11) Modifying the prohibitions for take such that taking a Mexican
wolf with a trap, snare, or other type of capture device within
occupied Mexican wolf range is prohibited and will not be considered
unavoidable or unintentional take, unless due care was exercised to
avoid injury or death to a Mexican wolf. Due care includes: (1)
Following the regulations, proclamations, and/or laws within the State
where the trapping takes place; (2) if securely fastening traps, use
double stake traps, cable stakes (at least 18 inches (in) (46
centimeters (cm)) deep) or otherwise securely fasten traps to immovable
objects with aircraft cable or chain so that if captured, a Mexican
wolf is unable to pull the trap free; (3) if using drags, use one of
sufficient size and weight or grapples made from steel at least 0.5 in
(1.3 cm) in diameter of cross section attached to chains or cables; (4)
reporting the capture of a Mexican wolf (even if the wolf has pulled
free) within 24 hours to the Service; and (5) not taking a Mexican wolf
via neck snares.
Trappers can call the Interagency Field Team (IFT) (1-888-459-WOLF
[9653]) as soon as possible to arrange for radio-collaring and
releasing of the Mexican wolf. Per State regulations for releasing
nontarget animals, trappers may also choose to release the animal alive
and subsequently contact the Service or IFT. Taking a Mexican wolf by
shooting will not be considered unavoidable or unintentional take.
(12) Establishing a new provision to conduct a one-time overall
evaluation of the nonessential experimental population 5 years after
our final determination on this rule. We will still conduct a status
review of the listed species once every 5 years as required by section
4(c)(2) of the Act.
(13) Clarifying that the Service will consider State-owned lands
within the boundaries of the MWEPA in the same manner as we consider
lands owned and managed by other public land management agencies.
We are also taking comments on the following options being
considered for possible inclusion in the final rule, but not proposed
in today's action:
(14) Moving the southern boundary of the MWEPA in Arizona and New
Mexico from Interstate Highway 10 to the United States-Mexico
international border (Figure 3).
[[Page 35724]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP13JN13.004
(15) Expanding the BRWRA to include the entire Sitgreaves National
Forest in Arizona;
(16) Expanding the BRWRA to include the Payson, Pleasant Valley,
and Tonto Basin Ranger Districts of the Tonto National Forest in
Arizona (Figure 3).
(17) Expanding the BRWRA to include the Magdalena Ranger District
of the Cibola National Forest in New Mexico (Figure 3).
(18) Replacing the term ``depredation'' with the term ``depredation
incident'' and defining it as, ``the aggregate number of livestock
killed or mortally wounded by an individual Mexican wolf or single pack
of Mexican wolves at a single location within one 24-hour period,
beginning with the first confirmed kill or injury.''
(19) Including provisions for take by pet owners of any Mexican
wolf engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting pets on private
or tribal land anywhere within the MWEPA, provided that evidence of a
freshly wounded or killed pet by wolves is present. The take must be
reported to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or a
designated representative of the Service within 24 hours.
[[Page 35725]]
(20) Including provisions for the issuance of permits on private or
tribal land anywhere within the MWEPA to allow livestock owners or
their agents to take (including kill or injure) any Mexican wolf that
is present on private or tribal land and what conditions must be met
before such a permit is issued, such as a minimum population size or
population trend of Mexican wolves present in the MWEPA or other
established populations based on the most recently reported population
count; other relevant measures of population status such as genetic
diversity; documentation by the Service or our authorized agent of
previous loss or injury of livestock on the private or tribal land,
caused by wolves; implementation of agency efforts to resolve the
problem and determination that conflict is likely to continue; and
enactment of this provision by a formal statement from the Service.
Please note that submissions merely stating support for or
opposition to the action under consideration without providing
supporting information, although noted, will not be considered in
making a determination.
You may submit your comments and materials concerning this proposed
rule by one of the methods listed in the ADDRESSES section. We request
that you send comments only by the methods described in the ADDRESSES
section.
If you submit information via http://www.regulations.gov, your
entire submission--including any personal identifying information--will
be posted on the Web site. If your submission is made via a hardcopy
that includes personal identifying information, you may request at the
top of your document that we withhold this information from public
review. However, we cannot guarantee that we will be able to do so. We
will post all hardcopy submissions on http://www.regulations.gov.
Comments and materials we receive, as well as supporting
documentation we used in preparing this proposed rule, will be
available for public inspection on http://www.regulations.gov, at
Docket No. FWS-R2-ES-2013-0056, or by appointment, during normal
business hours, at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, New Mexico
Ecological Services Field Office (see FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT).
We intend that any final action resulting from this proposed rule
will be based on the best scientific and commercial data available and
be as accurate and as effective as possible. Therefore, we request
comments or information from other concerned governmental agencies,
tribes, the scientific community, industry, or other interested parties
concerning this proposed rule. We request that you make your comments
as specific as possible and explain the basis for them. In addition,
please include sufficient information with your comments to allow us to
authenticate any scientific or commercial data you reference or
provide.
Previous Federal Actions
The Mexican wolf was listed under the Act as an endangered
subspecies in 1976 (41 FR 17736, April 28, 1976). In 1978, the Service
listed the entire gray wolf species in North America south of Canada as
endangered, except in Minnesota where it was listed as threatened (43
FR 9607, March 9, 1978). This 1978 listing at the species level
subsumed the previous Mexican wolf subspecies listing. However, the
1978 listing rule (43 FR 9607, March 9, 1978) stated that we would
continue to recognize the Mexican wolf as a valid biological subspecies
for purposes of research and conservation.
After the 1978 listing, the Service initiated recovery programs for
the gray wolf in three broad geographical regions of the country: the
Northern Rocky Mountains, the Western Great Lakes, and the Southwest.
In the Southwest, a recovery plan was developed specifically for the
Mexican wolf, acknowledging and implementing the regional gray wolf
recovery focus on the conservation of the Mexican wolf as a subspecies
(Service 1982). The 1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan did not provide
recovery criteria, but recommended an initial two-pronged approach to
recovery to establish a captive-breeding program and reintroduce
captive Mexican wolves to the wild (Service 1982, p. 28).
In 1996, we completed a final EIS, ``Reintroduction of the Mexican
Wolf within its Historic Range in the Southwestern United States,''
after assessing potential locations for reintroduction of the Mexican
wolf (Service 1996). On April 3, 1997, the Department of the Interior
issued its Record of Decision on the final EIS (62 FR 15915), and on
January 12, 1998, we published a final rule in the Federal Register to
establish the MWEPA in central Arizona and New Mexico, ``Establishment
of a Nonessential Experimental Population of the Mexican Gray Wolf in
Arizona and New Mexico'' (63 FR 1752).
Between 2003 and 2009, the Service published several rules revising
the 1978 conterminous listing for the gray wolf in an attempt to
recognize recovery progress achieved in the Northern Rocky Mountains
and Western Great Lakes populations but leave the Mexican wolf in the
southwestern United States and Mexico listed as endangered (except for
the nonessential experimental population in Arizona and New Mexico) (68
FR 15804, April 1, 2003; 72 FR 6052, February 8, 2007; 73 FR 10514,
February 27, 2008; 74 FR 15070 and 74 FR 15123, April 2, 2009).
However, these revisions were challenged in court, which left the 1978
listing unchanged through 2010 (Service 2012, pp. 3-4).
Effective January 27, 2012, the Service designated a Western Great
Lakes Distinct Population Segment (DPS) in Minnesota, Wisconsin,
Michigan, and portions of adjacent States, and removed this segment
from the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife (76 FR 81666,
December 28, 2011). The Service removed the Northern Rocky Mountain DPS
(Montana, Idaho, and portions of adjacent states, not including
Wyoming) from the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife pursuant
to Section 1713 of Public Law 112-10 on May 5, 2011 (76 FR 25590), and
subsequently removed gray wolves in Wyoming from the List of Endangered
and Threatened Wildlife on September 10, 2012 (77 FR 55530).
On August 4, 2010, we published a 90-day finding on two petitions
to list the Mexican wolf as an endangered subspecies with critical
habitat (75 FR 46894). In the 90-day finding, we determined that the
petitions presented substantial scientific information that the Mexican
wolf may warrant reclassification as a subspecies or DPS. As a result
of this finding, we initiated a status review. On October 9, 2012, we
published our 12-month finding in the Federal Register (77 FR 61375)
stating that the listing of the Mexican wolf as a subspecies or DPS was
not warranted at that time because Mexican wolves already receive the
protections of the Act under the species-level gray wolf listing of
1978.
During 2011 and 2012, we conducted a 5-year review of the gray wolf
finding that the entity currently described on the List of Endangered
and Threatened Wildlife should be revised to reflect the distribution
and status of gray wolf populations in the lower 48 States and Mexico
by removing all areas currently included in its range, as described in
the CFR, except where there is a valid species, subspecies, or DPS that
is threatened or endangered (Service 2012).
From October through December 2007, we conducted a public scoping
process under NEPA based on our intent to modify the 1998 Final Rule.
We developed a final scoping report in
[[Page 35726]]
April 2008, but we did not propose or finalize any modifications to the
1998 Final Rule at that time. We will utilize the information collected
during that scoping process in the development of a draft EIS.
Today, we concurrently proposed a rule in the Federal Register to
delist the gray wolf as a species and list the Mexican wolf subspecies
as endangered. The proposal to list the Mexican wolf as an endangered
subspecies necessitates that we propose a revision to the nonessential
experimental population of Mexican wolves in Arizona and New Mexico in
order to correctly document this population as an experimental
population of the Mexican wolf subspecies rather than the gray wolf
species found in the current CFR. We are also proposing and seeking
comment on a number of substantive modifications and technical
corrections to the regulation governing the Mexican wolf nonessential
experimental population designation.
Background
Our approach in this proposed rule is to refer to the 1998 Final
Rule as necessary to describe the current situation and the changes we
are proposing, and to propose new language where appropriate at this
time.
Species Information
The Mexican wolf is the smallest extant gray wolf subspecies in
North America. Adults weigh 50 to 90 pounds (lb) (23 to 41 kilograms
(kg)) with a length of 5 to 6 ft (1.5 to 1.8 m) and height at shoulder
of 25 to 32 in (63 to 81 cm) (Brown 1988, p. 119). Mexican wolves are
typically a patchy black, brown to cinnamon, and cream color, with
primarily light underparts (Brown 1988, p. 118). Solid black or white
coloration, as seen in other North American gray wolves, does not exist
in Mexican wolves. The basic life history for the Mexican wolf is
similar to that of other gray wolves (Mech 1970, entire; Service 1982,
p. 11; Service 2010, pp. 32-41).
Historically, Mexican wolves were distributed across portions of
the southwestern United States and northern and central Mexico. In the
United States, this range included eastern, central, and southern
Arizona; southern New Mexico; and western Texas (Brown 1983, pp. 10-11;
Parsons 1996, pp. 102-104). Maps of Mexican wolf historical range are
available in the scientific literature (Young and Goldman 1944, p. 414;
Hall and Kelson, 1959, p. 849; Hall 1981, p. 932; Bogan and Mehlhop
1983, p. 17; Nowak 1995, p. 395; Parsons 1996, p. 106). The
southernmost extent of the Mexican wolf's range in Mexico is
consistently portrayed as ending near Oaxaca (Hall 1981, p. 932; Nowak
1995, p. 395). Depiction of the northern extent of the Mexican wolf's
pre-settlement range among the available descriptions varies depending
on the authors' taxonomic treatment of several subspecies and their
interpretation of where reproductive interaction between neighboring
wolf populations occurred (see today's Federal Register publication of
the Proposed Rule Removing the Gray Wolf (Canis lupus) from the List of
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Maintaining Protections for the
Mexican Wolf (Canis lupus baileyi) by Listing it as Endangered).
Mexican wolves were associated with montane woodlands characterized
by sparsely to densely forested mountainous terrain consisting of
evergreen oaks (Quercus spp.) or pinyon (Pinus edulus) and juniper
(Juniperus spp.) to higher elevation pine (Pinus spp.), mixed-conifer
forests, and adjacent grasslands at elevations of 4,000 to 5,000 ft
(1,219 to 1,524 m) where ungulate prey were abundant. Mexican wolves
were believed to have preyed upon white-tailed deer (Odocoileus
virginianus), mule deer (O. hemionus), elk (Cervus elaphus), collared
peccaries (javelina) (Tayassu tajacu), pronghorn (Antilocapra
americana), bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis), jackrabbits (Lepus spp.),
cottontails (Sylvilagus spp.), and small rodents (Parsons and
Nicholopoulos 1995, pp. 141-142); white-tailed deer and mule deer were
believed to be the primary sources of prey (Brown 1988, p. 132; Bednarz
1988, p. 29).
Today, Mexican wolves in Arizona and New Mexico inhabit evergreen
pine-oak woodlands (i.e., Madrean woodlands), pinyon-juniper woodlands
(i.e., Great Basin conifer forests), and mixed-conifer montane forests
(i.e., Rocky Mountain, or petran, forests) that are inhabited by elk,
mule deer, and white-tailed deer (Service 1996, pp. 3-5; AMOC and IFT
2005, p. TC-3). Mexican wolves in the BRWRA show a strong preference
for elk compared to other ungulates (Adaptive Management Oversight
Committee (AMOC) and Interagency Field Team (IFT) 2005, p. TC-14, Reed
et al. 2006, pp. 56, 61; Merkle et al. 2009, p. 482). Other documented
sources of prey include deer and occasionally small mammals and birds
(Reed et al. 2006, p. 55). Mexican wolves are also known to prey and
scavenge on livestock (Merkle et al. 2009, p. 482; Breck et al. 2011,
entire; Reed et al. 2006, p. 1129; AMOC and IFT 2005, p. TC-15)).
Recovery Efforts
The United States and Mexico signed the Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan
in 1982 (Service 1982). The recovery plan did not contain objective and
measurable recovery criteria for delisting as required by section
4(f)(1) of the Act because the status of the Mexican wolf was so dire
that the recovery team could not foresee full recovery and eventual
delisting (Service 1982, p. 23). Instead, the recovery plan contained a
``prime objective'' to ensure the immediate survival of the Mexican
wolf. The prime objective of the 1982 recovery plan was: ``To conserve
and ensure the survival of Canis lupus baileyi by maintaining a captive
breeding program and reestablishing a viable, self-sustaining
population of at least 100 Mexican wolves in the middle to high
elevations of a 5,000-square-mi area (12,950-square-km) within the
Mexican wolf's historic range'' (Service 1982, p. 23). This objective
has since guided the recovery effort for the Mexican wolf in the United
States.
A binational captive-breeding program between the United States and
Mexico, referred to as the Mexican Wolf Species Survival Plan (SSP),
was initiated in 1977 to 1980 with the capture of the last remaining
Mexican wolves in the wild in Mexico and subsequent addition of wolves
from captivity in Mexico and the United States. Through the breeding of
the 7 founding Mexican wolves and generations of their offspring, the
captive population has expanded to its current size of close to 258
wolves in 52 facilities, including 34 facilities in the United States
and 18 facilities in Mexico (as of October 12, 2012) (Siminski and
Spevak 2012, p. 2).
The primary purpose of the SSP is to raise Mexican wolves for the
Service and the General del Vida Silvestre (in Mexico) for
reintroduction into the wild. This program is an essential component of
Mexican wolf recovery. Specifically, the purpose of the SSP is to
reestablish the Mexican wolf in the wild through captive breeding,
public education, and research. This captive population is the sole
source of Mexican wolves available to reestablish the species in the
wild and is imperative to the success of reintroduction efforts in the
United States and Mexico.
Reintroduction efforts to reestablish the Mexican wolf in the wild
have taken place in both the United States and Mexico. Mexico initiated
a reintroduction program with the release of five captive-bred Mexican
wolves
[[Page 35727]]
into the San Luis Mountains just south of the United States-Mexico
border in October 2011. As of February 2012, four of the five released
animals were confirmed dead due to ingestion of illegal poison. The
status of the fifth Mexican wolf is unknown. A sixth Mexican wolf was
released in March 2012; its fate is unknown as only its collar was
found in April 2012 (Service, our files). A pair of Mexican wolves was
released in October 2012 and was alive as of March 3, 2013. Mexico
plans to release additional Mexican wolves in this area, and possibly
several other identified locations (including Nuevo Leon and Coahuila)
in Mexico in 2013 and beyond; however, a schedule of releases is not
publicly available at this time. We expect the number of Mexican wolves
in Mexico to fluctuate from zero to several wolves or packs of wolves
during 2013 and into the future in or around Sonora and Chihuahua or
other Mexican States.
In the United States, we have focused our recovery efforts on the
reestablishment of Mexican wolves as a nonessential experimental
population under section 10(j) of the Act in Arizona and New Mexico. We
established the nonessential experimental population of Mexican wolves
in 1998 to pursue the prime objective of the 1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery
Plan (Figure 1). The reintroduction project is a collaborative effort
conducted by the Service, Forest Service, Arizona Game and Fish
Department, White Mountain Apache Tribe, and U.S. Department of
Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.
In March of 1998 we released 11 Mexican wolves from the captive-
breeding program to the wild. Additional individuals and family groups
have been initial-released or translocated into the BRWRA each year
through 2012. Initial-released refers to Mexican wolves released to the
wild that have only been in captivity, and translocated wolves are ones
with previous wild experience that were removed from the wild for
management reasons and subsequently rereleased into the wild at a later
time.
We expect to pursue additional recovery efforts for the Mexican
wolf outside of the MWEPA in the future and to determine the capacity
of the nonessential experimental population to contribute to recovery.
We initiated the revision of the 1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan in
2010. The revised plan will provide information about suitable habitat
and population sizes for Mexican wolf recovery in the United States and
Mexico. A draft plan will be provided for public and peer review before
being finalized.
More information about the life history, decline, and current
status of the Mexican wolf in the southwestern United States can be
found in the ``Proposed Rule Removing the Gray Wolf (Canis lupus) from
the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Maintaining
Protections for the Mexican Wolf (Canis lupus baileyi) by Listing it as
Endangered'' (published elsewhere in today's Federal Register), the
1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan (Service 1982, pp. 5-8, 11-12), the
1996 FEIS (Service 1996, pp. 1-7), the 1998 Final Rule (63 FR 1752,
January 12, 1998), the Mexican Gray Wolf Blue Range Reintroduction
Project 5-Year Review (Mexican Wolf Blue Range Adaptive Management
Oversight Committee and Interagency Field Team 2005, pp. TC-1 to TC-2),
the Mexican Wolf Conservation Assessment (Service 2010, pp. 7-15, 20-
42), and Mexican Wolf Recovery Program Progress reports from 2001 to
2011. These documents are available on-line at http://www.fws.gov/southwest/es/mexicanwolf.
Why We Need to Revise the 1998 Final Rule
We are proposing to modify the MWEPA designation to improve our
ability to establish a viable, self-sustaining population of at least
100 Mexican wolves in the wild, which is the population objective
provided in the 1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan. Over time and through
project reviews, annual reports, monitoring, and communication with our
partners and the public, we recognize that elements of the 1998 Final
Rule designation need to be revised to help us enhance the growth,
stability, and success of the nonessential experimental population.
Specifically, the 1998 Final Rule currently restricts initial releases
of captive Mexican wolves to the wild to the Primary Recovery Zone,
which constitutes only 16 percent of the BRWRA. This has constrained
the number and location of Mexican wolves that can be released into the
wild. Also, the 1998 Final Rule has a requirement that Mexican wolves
stay within the BRWRA, which does not allow for natural dispersal
movements from the BRWRA or occupation of the MWEPA. Currently, we are
required to implement management actions that disrupt social structure
or lead to removal of wolves from the wild when a Mexican wolf
naturally disperses from the BRWRA into the MWEPA. In addition, we are
proposing a number of modifications that will improve our communication
and coordination implementing the nonessential experimental population
designation. We intend our actions to demonstrate an adaptive
management approach in which we utilize the lessons learned since we
began reestablishing Mexican wolves in 1998.
Statutory and Regulatory Framework
The Act provides that species listed as endangered are afforded
protection primarily through the prohibitions of section 9 and the
requirements of section 7. Section 9 of the Act, among other things,
prohibits the take of endangered wildlife. ``Take'' is defined by the
Act as harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture,
or collect, or attempt to engage in any such conduct. Section 7 of the
Act outlines the procedures for Federal interagency cooperation to
conserve federally listed species and protect designated critical
habitat. It mandates that all Federal agencies use their existing
authorities to further the purposes of the Act by carrying out programs
for the conservation of listed species. It also states that Federal
agencies must, in consultation with the Service, ensure that any action
they authorize, fund, or carry out is not likely to jeopardize the
continued existence of a listed species or result in the destruction or
adverse modification of designated critical habitat. Section 7 of the
Act does not affect activities undertaken on private land unless they
are authorized, funded, or carried out by a Federal agency.
The 1982 amendments to the Act included the addition of section
10(j), which allows for the designation of reintroduced populations of
listed species as ``experimental populations.'' Under section 10(j) of
the Act and our regulations at 50 CFR 17.81, the Service may designate
as an experimental population a population of endangered or threatened
species that has been or will be released into suitable natural habitat
outside the species' current natural range, but within its probable
historical range. With the experimental population designation, the
relevant population is treated as threatened, regardless of the
species' designation elsewhere in its range. Threatened status allows
us discretion in devising management programs and special regulations
for such a population through the use of section 4(d) of the Act.
Section 4(d) allows us to adopt any regulations that are necessary and
advisable to provide for the conservation of a threatened species. In
these situations, the general regulations that extend most section 9
prohibitions to threatened species do not apply to that species, and
the section 10(j) rule
[[Page 35728]]
contains the prohibitions and exemptions necessary and appropriate to
conserve that species.
Before authorizing the release as an experimental population of any
population (including eggs, propagules, or individuals) of an
endangered or threatened species, and before authorizing any necessary
transportation to conduct the release, the Service must find, by
regulation, that such release will further the conservation of the
species. In making such a finding, the Service uses the best scientific
and commercial data available to consider: (1) Any possible adverse
effects on extant populations of a species as a result of removal of
individuals, eggs, or propagules for introduction elsewhere; (2) the
likelihood that any such experimental population will become
established and survive in the foreseeable future; (3) the relative
effects that establishment of an experimental population will have on
the recovery of the species; and (4) the extent to which the introduced
population may be affected by existing or anticipated Federal or State
actions or private activities within or adjacent to the experimental
population area.
Furthermore, as set forth in 50 CFR 17.81(c), all regulations
designating experimental populations under section 10(j) must provide:
(1) Appropriate means to identify the experimental population,
including, but not limited to, its actual or proposed location, actual
or anticipated migration, number of specimens released or to be
released, and other criteria appropriate to identify the experimental
population(s); (2) a finding, based solely on the best scientific and
commercial data available, and the supporting factual basis, on whether
the experimental population is, or is not, essential to the continued
existence of the species in the wild; (3) management restrictions,
protective measures, or other special management concerns of that
population, which may include but are not limited to, measures to
isolate and contain the experimental population designated in the
regulation from natural populations; and (4) a process for periodic
review and evaluation of the success or failure of the release and the
effect of the release on the conservation and recovery of the species.
Under 50 CFR 17.81(d), the Service must consult with appropriate
State fish and wildlife agencies, local governmental entities, affected
Federal agencies, and affected private landowners in developing and
implementing experimental population rules. To the maximum extent
practicable, section 10(j) rules represent an agreement between the
Service, the affected State and Federal agencies, and persons holding
any interest in land that may be affected by the establishment of an
experimental population.
Based on the best scientific and commercial data available, we must
determine whether the experimental population is essential or
nonessential to the continued existence of the species. The regulations
(50 CFR 17.80(b)) state that an experimental population is considered
essential if its loss would be likely to appreciably reduce the
likelihood of survival of that species in the wild. All other
populations are considered nonessential.
For the purposes of section 7 of the Act, we treat a nonessential
experimental population as a threatened species when it is located
within a National Wildlife Refuge or unit of the National Park Service,
and Federal agency conservation requirements under section 7(a)(1) and
the Federal agency consultation requirements of section 7(a)(2) of the
Act apply. Section 7(a)(1) requires all Federal agencies to use their
authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of listed
species. Section 7(a)(2) requires that Federal agencies, in
consultation with the Service, ensure that any action authorized,
funded, or carried out is not likely to jeopardize the continued
existence of a listed species or adversely modify its critical habitat.
When a nonessential experimental population is located outside a
National Wildlife Refuge or National Park Service unit, then, for the
purposes of section 7, we treat the population as proposed for listing
and only section 7(a)(1) and section 7(a)(4) apply. In these instances,
a nonessential experimental population provides additional flexibility
because Federal agencies are not required to consult with us under
section 7(a)(2). Section 7(a)(4) requires Federal agencies to confer
(rather than consult) with the Service on actions that are likely to
jeopardize the continued existence of a species proposed to be listed.
The results of a conference are in the form of conservation
recommendations that are optional as the agencies carry out, fund, or
authorize activities. Because the nonessential experimental population
is, by definition, not essential to the continued existence of the
species, the effects of proposed actions affecting the nonessential
experimental population will generally not rise to the level of
jeopardizing the continued existence of the species. As a result, a
formal conference will likely never be required for Mexican wolves
established within the nonessential experimental population area.
Nonetheless, some agencies voluntarily confer with the Service on
actions that may affect a proposed species. Activities that are not
carried out, funded, or authorized by Federal agencies are not subject
to provisions or requirements in section 7.
Section 10(j)(2)(C)(ii) of the Act states that critical habitat
shall not be designated for any experimental population that is
determined to be nonessential. Accordingly, we cannot designate
critical habitat in areas where we establish a nonessential
experimental population.
Proposed Experimental Population Area
We are continuing our effort to establish a population of Mexican
wolves within the subspecies' historical range in Arizona and New
Mexico by proposing to revise the 1998 Final Rule (63 FR 1752, January
12, 1998). The current and proposed revision to the experimental
population area is the entirety of the species' current range in the
United States. The purpose of the nonessential experimental population
was, and remains, to accomplish the prime objective of the 1982 Mexican
Wolf Recovery Plan to establish a viable, self-sustaining population of
at least 100 Mexican wolves in the wild (Service 1982, p. 23).
With this rule, we propose to revise the geographic boundaries of
the MWEPA described in the 1998 Final Rule by removing the small
portion of the MWEPA in Texas. This area is not likely to contribute
substantially to our population objective based on habitat suitability.
The proposed MWEPA is the geographic area lying north of Interstate
Highway 10 and south of Interstate Highway 40 in Arizona and New Mexico
(Figure 2).
Also, we are proposing to maintain the geographic boundaries of the
BRWRA as described in our 1998 Final Rule (i.e., the Apache National
Forest in Arizona and the Gila National Forest in New Mexico), but to
eliminate the primary and secondary recovery zones inside the BRWRA
(Figure 2). We are proposing to modify the regulations associated with
initial releases within the BRWRA and the regulations associated with
natural dispersal of Mexican wolves from the BRWRA into the MWEPA; both
of these modifications are described below in Management of the
Reintroduced Population.
We are not carrying forward the recommendation from the 1998 Final
Rule to consider the White Sands Wolf Recovery Area as a possible
[[Page 35729]]
reintroduction site for Mexican wolves (Figure 2). Under the 1998 Final
Rule, initial releases and reintroduction of Mexican wolves into the
White Sands Wolf Recovery Area is authorized if the Service finds it
necessary and feasible in order to achieve the recovery goal of at
least 100 Mexican wolves occupying 5,000 square mi (12,950 square km)
(Service 1998). While this recovery area lies within the probable
historical range of the Mexican wolf, and could be an important
reestablishment site if prey densities increased substantially, it is
now considered a marginally suitable area for Mexican wolf release and
reestablishment primarily due to the low density of prey. For these
reasons the Mexican Wolf Blue Range Reintroduction Project 5-Year
Review recommended that any amended or new Mexican wolf nonessential
experimental population rule not include White Sands Missile Range as a
Mexican Wolf Recovery Area or as a reintroduction zone (AMOC and IFT
2005, p. ARC-3).
Additional Revisions to the Previous Experimental Population Area Under
Consideration
As stated above (see Information Requested section), we are also
taking comments on the following options being considered for possible
inclusion in the final rule, but not proposed in today's action. Thus,
depending upon the information we receive during the public comment
period and our own further analysis, our final rule may include these
actions.
We are considering expanding the MWEPA by moving the southern
boundary from Interstate Highway 10 to the United States-Mexico
international border across Arizona and New Mexico (Figure 3).
Expanding the MWEPA was a recommendation in the Mexican Wolf Blue Range
Reintroduction Project 5-Year Review (AMOC and IFT 2005, p. ARC-3). We
are considering this modification because a larger MWEPA would provide
additional habitat for dispersal while promoting management flexibility
and consistency in management over a larger area (as opposed to Mexican
wolves in this area having full endangered status).
We are also considering the expansion of the BRWRA to include the
entire Sitgreaves National Forest and the Payson, Pleasant Valley, and
Tonto Basin Ranger Districts of the Tonto National Forest in Arizona
and the Magdalena Ranger District of the Cibola National Forest in New
Mexico (Figure 3). This expansion would include the proposed
modification that would allow for initial releases and translocations
throughout the expanded BRWRA. Our proposed modification to eliminate
the primary and secondary recovery zones within the BRWRA and our
consideration of expanding the BRWRA to include the entire Sitgreaves
and three Ranger Districts of the Tonto National Forests in Arizona and
one Ranger District of the Cibola National Forest in New Mexico are
consistent with recommendations in the Mexican Wolf Blue Range
Reintroduction Project 5-Year Review (AMOC and IFT 2005, p. ARC-4).
These revisions would provide additional area and locations for initial
release of Mexican wolves to the wild from captivity beyond that
currently allowed by the 1998 Final Rule.
Reintroduction Procedures
In our 1998 Final Rule, we stated that we would release 14 family
groups of Mexican wolves into the BRWRA over a period of 5 years to
achieve our goal of establishing a population of at least 100 wild
Mexican wolves. Selection criteria for Mexican wolves that are released
include genetics, reproductive performance, behavioral compatibility,
response to the adaptive process, and other factors (63 FR 1754,
January 12, 2998). Since the end of that initial 5-year period in 2003,
we have continued to conduct initial releases of Mexican wolves from
captivity into the BRWRA and to translocate wolves with previous wild
experience back into the BRWRA.
We are proposing to revise selection criteria for Mexican wolves
that are released into the wild by including sex and age as selection
criteria, including specifying our reasons for conducting initial
releases, as follows in the paragraph below:
Captive Mexican wolves are selected for release based on genetic
contribution to the wild population, reproductive performance,
behavioral compatibility, prior behavior, sex, age, response to the
adaptation process, and other factors. Mexican wolves selected for
release may be acclimated in Service-approved prerelease facilities or
released directly into the BRWRA. Initial release of Mexican wolves
into the BRWRA will be conducted on an as-needed basis to assist with
population growth or maintenance, genetics management, and other
relevant considerations.
Management of the Experimental Population Area
The nonessential experimental designation enables the Service to
develop measures for management of the population that are less
restrictive than the mandatory prohibitions that protect species with
endangered status. This includes allowing limited take of individual
Mexican wolves under narrowly defined circumstances (50 CFR
17.84(k)(6)). Management flexibility is needed to make reintroduction
compatible with current and planned human activities, such as livestock
grazing and hunting. It is also critical to obtaining needed State,
tribal, local, and private cooperation. The Service believes this
flexibility has and will continue to improve the likelihood of success
of this reestablishment effort. Management of Mexican wolves in the
BRWRA and MWEPA may include any of the provisions herein or provided
for in Service-approved management plans, protocols, and permits.
We are proposing to allow for initial releases of captive-raised
Mexican wolves throughout the entire BRWRA, which would eliminate the
primary and secondary recovery zones defined in the 1998 Final Rule. We
previously defined a primary recovery zone to mean an area where the
Service: (1) Will release captive-raised Mexican wolves, (2) may return
and rerelease previously released Mexican wolves, (3) may release
translocated wild-born Mexican wolves, and (4) will actively support
recovery of the reintroduced population. We previously defined the
secondary recovery zone to be an area adjacent to a primary recovery
zone in which the Service allows released Mexican wolves to disperse,
where wolves captured in the wild for authorized management purposes
may be translocated and released, and where managers actively support
recovery (63 FR 1772, January 12, 1998). If this proposed rule is
finalized, the distinction between the primary and secondary recovery
zones related to initial releases and other management actions will be
eliminated, thereby eliminating the need to retain or define these
zones. With our current proposal, we would apply a consistent
management regime for all Mexican wolves in the BRWRA.
The purpose of this proposed change to allow initial releases
throughout the BRWRA is to expand the area and locations for potential
initial release sites. This flexibility will support our efforts to
achieve the prime objective of the 1982 Mexican Wolf Recovery Plan and
the specified reintroduction goal of the 1998 Final Rule to establish a
viable, self-sustaining population of at least 100 Mexican wolves in
the wild. That is, we expect that expanding the area and locations for
potential release sites will support population growth for several
reasons. First, allowing initial release of captive Mexican wolves into
the entire BRWRA will increase our opportunities to conduct initial
releases. Because Mexican wolf packs have established home ranges in
the primary recovery
[[Page 35730]]
zone, which encompasses only 16 percent of the BRWRA, we are
constrained in our ability to release additional family groups from
captivity into this occupied habitat. Only two captive-raised Mexican
wolves have been released into the BRWRA in the last 6 years for this
reason.
Second, this modification will allow us to conduct initial releases
into optimal release sites in remote locations such as the Gila and
Aldo Leopold Wilderness Areas. These large wilderness areas provide
roadless habitat, have very low human population density, and limited
livestock grazing, which are characteristics that support the
establishment of Mexican wolves while reducing the potential for wolf-
human conflict.
Third, this modification would also allow us to improve our ability
to support the genetic health of the population in that we would have
more opportunities to replace genetically important Mexican wolves that
die or are removed from the population with captive wolves with similar
genetic makeup.
Finally, this modification, assuming it led to a larger, more
viable population, would result in a population more tolerant of the
loss of individuals. Being able to lose individuals from a larger
population would have less effect on the subspecies, as a whole, and
support our ability to respond to Mexican wolf-livestock conflicts and
increase our overall management flexibility.
We are proposing to allow Mexican wolves in the BRWRA to disperse
throughout the BRWRA and into the MWEPA, and to occupy the MWEPA
(Figure 2). The 1998 Final Rule did not allow Mexican wolves to
disperse from the BRWRA into the MWEPA. Management of Mexican wolves in
the BRWRA and MWEPA may include hazing, translocations, lethal take,
and other necessary actions, as provided for in this proposed rule and
in Service-approved management plans and protocols. We are proposing to
allow Mexican wolves to disperse naturally from the BRWRA into the
MWEPA and to occupy the MWEPA because this modification will promote
numeric and spatial expansion of the population, assisting us in
reaching our population objective. We intend to capture and return
Mexican wolves originating from the nonessential experimental
population that disperse outside of the MWEPA.
There are two situations in which a Mexican wolf could occur in the
southwestern United States outside of the MWEPA: (1) A Mexican wolf may
disperse outside of the MWEPA without our knowledge; or (2) Mexican
wolves may disperse into the United States from Mexico. Any Mexican
wolf outside of the MWEPA will have full endangered status under the
Act. The public is encouraged to contact the Mexican Wolf Recovery
Coordinator or a designated representative of the Service to determine
if there is the potential for take in areas where Mexican wolves are
listed as endangered. Any trappers concerned that they might
incidentally take an endangered Mexican wolf can apply for a section
10(a) permit.
Within the MWEPA, we are proposing the development and
implementation of management actions to benefit Mexican wolf recovery
in cooperation with private landowners, including but not limited to
initial release and translocation of Mexican wolves on private land if
requested by the landowner, and on tribal land in cooperation with
tribal governments including but not limited to initial release,
translocation, capture, and removal of wolves if requested by the
tribal government.
On public land grazing allotments we will continue to offer permits
under the Act to allow livestock owners or their agents to take a
Mexican wolf engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting
livestock, but we propose to change the condition of requiring 6
breeding pairs in the population prior to issuance of a such a permit
to requiring 100 Mexican wolves in the MWEPA based on the most recent
population count. We originally established the 6 breeding pair metric
to serve as an indication that the overall size and status of the
population was appropriate to allow additional regulatory flexibility
in our management. However, we have learned that the number of breeding
pairs in the population does not necessarily serve as a surrogate for
population size. Therefore, we are proposing a more direct method of
deciding when to allow additional regulatory flexibility by basing our
determination on the number of Mexican wolves in the MWEPA population.
We will continue to track breeding pairs as a population metric, but
will not use this number as a basis for the level of regulatory
flexibility.
Additional Revisions to the Management of the Experimental Population
Area Under Consideration
As stated above (see Information Requested section), we are also
taking comments on the following options being considered for possible
inclusion in the final rule, but not proposed in today's action. Thus,
depending upon the information we receive during the public comment
period and our own further analysis, our final rule may include these
actions.
We are considering including provisions for take by pet owners of
any Mexican wolf engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting
pets on private or tribal land anywhere within the MWEPA, provided that
evidence of a freshly wounded or killed pet by wolves is present. Such
take must be reported to the Service or an authorized agent within 24
hours. We would modify our definition of ``engaged in the act of
killing, wounding, or biting livestock'' to also apply to pets. We are
considering this modification in order to provide the same provisions
for pets as we do for livestock on private and tribal land in an effort
to reduce wolf-related conflicts for humans and their animals. We
estimate that this may result in the take of at most two wolves per
year.
We are considering including provisions for the issuance of permits
on private land anywhere within the MWEPA to allow livestock owners or
their agents to take (including kill or injure) any Mexican wolf that
is present on private land. We would establish conditions that must be
met before such a permit is issued, such as a minimum population size
of Mexican wolves present in the MWEPA or other established populations
based on the most recently reported population count; other relevant
measures of population status such as genetic diversity; documentation
by the Service or our authorized agent of previous loss or injury of
livestock on the private land, caused by Mexican wolves; completion of
agency efforts to resolve the problem; and enactment of this provision
by a formal statement from the Service. We are considering this
provision to reduce wolf-livestock conflicts and provide livestock
owners and their agents with more options for resolving such conflicts.
Both of these considerations demonstrate a balanced approach to our
reestablishment efforts such that as we pursue measures to expand the
number and distribution of Mexican wolves in the experimental
population we also increase our management flexibility, including
identification of circumstances in which take may be appropriate. A
larger, more widespread population would be less affected by the
limited take under consideration than the small, restricted population
that currently exists entirely within the BRWRA.
[[Page 35731]]
Identification and Monitoring
Prior to release from captivity into the wild, adult-sized Mexican
wolves will receive permanent identification marks and radio collars,
as appropriate. Pups and uncollared adult Mexican wolves within the
current BRWRA population are routinely captured and given permanent
identification marks and radio collars. While not all Mexican wolves
are radio-collared, we attempt to maintain at least two radio collars
per pack in the wild. Radio collars allow the Service to monitor
reproduction, dispersal, survival, pack formation, depredations,
predation, and a variety of other important biological metrics. We do
not foresee a scenario where we would not continue an active monitoring
strategy for Mexican wolves. However, we also recognize that a majority
of wild Mexican wolves may not have radio collars as the population
grows, due to the difficulty of capturing them.
The Service will measure the success or failure of the releases by
monitoring, researching, and evaluating the status of released Mexican
wolves and their offspring. Using adaptive management principles, the
Service will continue to modify subsequent releases depending on what
is learned. We will prepare periodic progress reports, annual reports,
and publications, as appropriate, to evaluate release strategies.
The 1998 Final Rule contained requirements to conduct full
evaluations of the status of the nonessential experimental population
after 3 and 5 years. As part of the evaluations, a recommendation would
be made for continuation, modification, or termination of the
reintroduction project. Both evaluations were conducted and
recommendations were made to continue the nonessential experimental
population with modifications. These reviews were intensive efforts
that included Service staff, other Federal, State, and tribal agencies,
independent experts, and public involvement. In this proposed rule, we
propose a one-time full evaluation of the revised nonessential
experimental population rule 5 years after any final determination has
been made to revise the existing 10(j) regulation; the evaluation
should focus on modifications needed to improve the efficacy of
reestablishing Mexican wolves to the wild and the contribution the
nonessential experimental population is making to the recovery of the
Mexican wolf. We do not consider a 3-year review to be necessary, as we
included this provision in the 1998 Final Rule to address the
substantial uncertainties we had with reestablishing captive Mexican
wolves to the wild. Therefore, a one-time program review conducted 5
years after our final determination will provide an appropriate
interval to assess the effectiveness of the project. This one-time
program review is separate from the status review of the listed species
that we will conduct once every 5 years as required by section 4(c)(2)
of the Act.
Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Findings
As discussed in the Statutory and Regulatory Framework section,
several findings are required before establishing an experimental
population. Below are our findings.
Is the experimental population wholly separate geographically from
nonexperimental populations of the same species?
Prior to the first release of Mexican wolves in 1998, the Service
ensured that no population of naturally occurring wild wolves existed
within the recovery areas under consideration (in the United States) or
in Mexico. Currently, no populations or individuals of the Mexican wolf
subspecies are known to exist in the United States outside of the
BRWRA. Due to the active reestablishment effort Mexico initiated in
2011, two confirmed Mexican wolves are known to exist in the wild
approximately 130 mi (209 km) south of the United States-Mexico
international border. The two Mexican wolves in Mexico are
approximately 180 mi (290 km) straight-line distance from the southern
boundary of the current MWEPA. Thus, the two areas are neither adjacent
to nor overlapping each other.
The Mexican wolves in Mexico do not meet the definition of a
population that we have consistently used in our gray wolf experimental
population rules, which is, at least 2 breeding pairs of gray wolves
that each successfully raised at least two young annually for 2
consecutive years (59 FR 60252, November 22, 1994). This definition
represents what we have determined to be the minimum standards for a
gray wolf population (Service 1994). The courts have supported this
definition and thus upheld our interpretation that pairs must breed to
have a ``population'' (Wyoming Farm Bureau Federation v. Babbitt, 199
F.3d 1224, 1234 (10th Cir. 2000); U.S. v. McKittrick, 142 F. 3d 1170,
1175 (9th Cir. 1998), cert. denied, 525 U.S. 1072 (1999)). Based on the
results of Mexico's efforts in 2011 and 2012, we can only speculate
that the number of Mexican wolves in Mexico will fluctuate over the
next few years from zero to several wolves or packs of wolves depending
on mortalities, future releases, and successful breeding (in the wild)
of released wolves. Therefore, we consider it unlikely for a population
that meets our definition to be established in northern Mexico any time
soon and certainly no such population exists currently.
Based on the fact that there are currently no populations of
Mexican wolves in the United States or Mexico other than the BRWRA
population, we find that the nonessential experimental population is
wholly geographically separate. If a population is successfully
established in the future due to Mexico's efforts, it is possible that
an occasional Mexican wolf from Mexico may disperse into the United
States. Interconnectivity between Mexican wolves in Mexico and in the
MWEPA in the future could benefit recovery of the Mexican wolf by
providing genetic interchange between populations.
Is the experimental population area in suitable natural habitat outside
the species' current range, but within its probable historical range?
The experimental population area is within suitable natural habitat
in its probable historical range. Because Mexican wolves were
extirpated from the wild prior to protection by the Act, there is no
current range in the United States except that which is occupied by
this nonessential experimental population. The MWEPA is considered to
be probable historical range (Parsons 1996, p. 106; Bogan and Mehlhop
1983, p. 17).
Is the experimental population essential to the continued existence of
the species?
Our finding of whether a population is nonessential is made with
our understanding that Congress enacted the provisions of section 10(j)
to mitigate fears that reestablishing populations of threatened or
endangered species into the wild would negatively impact landowners and
other private parties. Congress also recognized that flexible rules
could encourage recovery partners to actively assist in the
reestablishment and hosting of such populations on their lands (H.R.
rep. No. 97-567, at 8 (1982)). Although Congress allowed experimental
populations to be identified as either essential or nonessential, they
noted that most experimental populations would be nonessential (H.R.
Conference Report No. 835, supra at 34; Service 1984)).
We make all determinations on essentiality prior to taking any
action to
[[Page 35732]]
reestablish a population of endangered or threatened species. It is
instructive that Congress did not put requirements in section 10(j) to
reevaluate the determination of essentiality after a species has been
reestablished in the wild. While our regulations require a ``periodic
review and evaluation of the success or failure of the release and the
effect of the release on the conservation and recovery of the species
(50 CFR 17.81(c)(4))'', this has not been interpreted as requiring
reevaluation and reconsideration of a population's nonessential
experimental status (Service 1991, 1994, 1996b).
Reestablishing a species is by its very nature an experiment for
which the outcomes are uncertain. However, it is always our goal to
successfully reestablish a species in the wild so that it can be
recovered and removed from the endangered species list. This is
consistent with the Act's requirements for section 10(j) experimental
populations. Specifically, the Act requires experimental populations to
further the conservation of the species. Conservation is defined by the
Act as the use of all methods and procedures which are necessary to
bring any endangered or threatened species to the point at which the
measures provided pursuant to the Act are no longer necessary. In
short, experimental populations must further a species' recovery.
The importance of an experimental population to a species' recovery
does not mean the population is ``essential'' under section 10(j) of
the Act. All efforts to reestablish a species are undertaken to move
that species toward recovery. If importance to recovery was equated
with essentiality, no reestablished populations of a species would
qualify for nonessential status. This interpretation would conflict
with Congress' expectation that ``in most cases, experimental
populations will not be essential'' (H.R. Conference Report No. 835,
supra at 34; Service 1984) and our 1984 implementing regulations, which
indicated an essential population will be a special case and not the
general rule (Service 1984).
In addressing essentiality, the Act instructs us to determine
whether a population is essential to the continued existence of an
endangered or threatened species. Our regulations define essential
experimental populations as those ``whose loss would be likely to
appreciably reduce the likelihood of the survival of the species in the
wild (50 CFR 17.80(b)).'' The Service defines ``survival'' as the
condition in which a species continues to exist in the future while
retaining the potential for recovery (Service and National Marine
Fisheries Service 1998). Inherent in our regulatory definition of
essential is the impact the potential loss of the experimental
population would have on the species as a whole (Service 1984). All
experimental populations not meeting this bar are considered
nonessential (50 CFR 17.80(b)).
The Service has previously determined that this experimental
population of Mexican wolves was nonessential in the 1998 Final Rule.
This proposal revalidates that conclusion. That is, even if the entire
experimental population died, this situation would not appreciably
reduce the prospects for future survival of the subspecies because
Mexican wolves are still maintained in the captive-breeding program.
Furthermore, the captive Mexican wolf population could produce enough
wolves that future reintroductions in the wild would be feasible and we
have a now proven capacity to successfully start a wild population from
captive stock. All Mexican wolves selected for release are genetically
redundant to the captive population, meaning their genes are already
well represented. This factor minimizes any adverse effects on the
genetic integrity of the remaining captive population in the event
Mexican wolves released to the wild do not survive.
Does the establishment of the experimental population and release into
the BRWRA and MWEPA further the conservation of the species?
(1) Are there any possible adverse effects on extant populations of
the Mexican wolf as a result of removal of individuals for introduction
elsewhere?
The only extant population of Mexican wolves other than those in
the BRWRA is in the captive-breeding program. The primary purpose of
Mexican wolves in the captive-breeding program is to supply wolves for
reestablishing Mexican wolves into the wild. Individual Mexican wolves
are selected from the captive-breeding program for release into the
BRWRA. As explained in our 1998 Final Rule, the Mexican wolves selected
for release are wolves that have genes that are well-represented in the
captive population, thus minimizing any adverse effects on the genetic
integrity of the remaining captive population. The Mexican Wolf SSP has
detailed lineage information on each captive Mexican wolf and
establishes annual breeding objectives to maintain the genetic
diversity of the captive population (Siminski and Spevak 2012, p. 2).
Our proposal to open the secondary recovery zone to initial releases
will allow for more captive Mexican wolves to be released to the wild
and can be accommodated by the captive-breeding program. We find that
the continuation of the BRWRA population and specifically the expansion
of the area into which initial releases can be conducted will not have
adverse effects on the captive-breeding program. Mexican wolf dispersal
from the BRWRA into the MWEPA will further the conservation of the
species by allowing wolves access to additional habitat for
reestablishment.
(2) What is the likelihood that any such experimental population
will become established and survive in the foreseeable future?
In our 1998 Final Rule we stated, ``The Service finds that, under
the Preferred Alternative, the reintroduced experimental population is
likely to become established and survive in the wild within the Mexican
wolf's probable historic range (63 FR 1754, January 12, 1998).'' We
have been reestablishing Mexican wolves into the BRWRA since 1998, and
the population has consistently demonstrated signs of establishment,
such as wolves establishing home ranges and reproducing. The progress
in meeting the population objective of at least 100 wild Mexican wolves
has been slower than projected, but we anticipate that making the
modifications proposed in this rule will support progress toward our
objective. As of 2012, of the Mexican wolves in the wild in Arizona and
New Mexico, 97 percent were conceived and born in the wild. Currently,
there are fourth generation pups whose great grandparents were also
born in the wild. We have also modified our management procedures
related to depredation response and other recommendations from the
Mexican Wolf Blue Range Reintroduction Project 5-Year Review to ensure
the success of the BRWRA population (Service 2010, p. 29). To promote
survival of the wild population we have utilized an adaptive management
framework to modify our approach to depredation management by removing
fewer Mexican wolves, focusing on proactive measures, and tasking an
interdiction stakeholder council to develop a comprehensive depredation
compensation, incentive, and proactive program.
(3) What are the relative effects that establishment of an
experimental population will have on the recovery of the Mexican wolf?
Continuing the effort to reestablish the nonessential experimental
population, and making modifications
[[Page 35733]]
to improve it, will substantially contribute to the recovery of the
species, as it is currently extirpated in the wild except for the
nonessential experimental population in the United States and a
fledgling reestablishment effort in Mexico. We recognize that more than
one population of Mexican wolves will need to be established for
recovery (Service 2010, pp. 68-70); therefore, achieving the objective
of at least 100 wolves for this population serves as a fundamentally
necessary component of Mexican wolf recovery.
(4) What is the extent to which the introduced population may be
affected by existing or anticipated Federal or State actions or private
activities within or adjacent to the experimental population area?
Now, as in the 1998 Final Rule (63 FR 1752, January 12, 1998), we
do not foresee that the introduced population would be affected by
existing or anticipated Federal or State actions or private activities.
Wolves are considered habitat generalists that can occupy areas where
prey populations and human tolerance support their existence (Mech
1970, p. 334; Mech 1995, entire; Fritts et al. 2003, pp. 300-301;
Fuller et al. 2003, pp. 170-171; Oakleaf et al. 2006, p. 560). We
expect Mexican wolves in the MWEPA to primarily occupy forested areas
on public lands due to the availability of prey in these areas and
supportive management regimes, although we recognize that wolves may
disperse through or occasionally occupy less-suitable habitat. We also
recognize that Mexican wolves may seek to inhabit tribal or private
lands with suitable habitat.
The current BRWRA as established in the 1998 Final Rule is
comprised of the Gila and Apache National Forests that are administered
by the Forest Service. The Forest Service manages these areas to
sustain the health, diversity, and productivity of the Nation's forests
and grasslands to meet the needs of present and future generations. The
Gila and Apache National Forests within the BRWRA are responsible for
developing and operating under a Land and Resource Management Plan,
which outlines how each of the multiple uses on the forest will be
managed. The Forest Service is a cooperator in the management and
recovery of the Mexican wolf.
The proposed revision to the MWEPA contains a mixture of many land
types, including Federal (Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management,
Department of Defense), State, private, and tribal lands. A variety of
actions and activities may occur throughout the MWEPA, such as
recreation, agriculture and ranching, development, and military
operations. Although we expect the majority of the Mexican wolf
population to occur within the BRWRA or other public lands in the MWEPA
due to habitat suitability, we also anticipate that the nonessential
experimental population may be affected by actions and activities
occurring on private or tribal land, such as ranching operations,
because we haze or remove wolves that depredate livestock or display
nuisance behavior. We are proposing to establish management actions in
cooperation with private landowners and tribal governments to support
the recovery of the Mexican wolf on private and tribal lands and will
continue our efforts to establish and support the Mexican Wolf
Livestock Interdiction Fund and proactive management activities aimed
at reducing wolf-livestock conflicts.
Road and human densities have been identified as potential limiting
factors for colonizing wolves in the Midwest and Northern Rocky
Mountains due to the mortality associated with these landscape
characteristics (Mladenoff et al. 1995, entire; Oakleaf et al. 2006,
pp. 558-561). Vehicular collision, in particular, is not identified as
having a significant impact on the Mexican wolf population, although it
may contribute to the overall vulnerability of the population due to
its small population size and the cumulative effects of multiple
factors, including inbreeding and illegal shooting of wolves. We
recognize that human and road densities in the BRWRA are within
recommended levels for Mexican wolf colonization, and are expected to
remain so in the future (see Proposed Rule Removing the Gray Wolf
(Canis lupus) from the List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and
Maintaining Protections for the Mexican Wolf (Canis lupus baileyi) by
Listing it as Endangered), Factor E--Other Natural or Manmade Factors
Affecting Its Continued Existence); therefore, we see the impact to the
population from actions related to human development as minimal within
the areas we expect Mexican wolves primarily to inhabit.
Both Arizona and New Mexico protect the Mexican wolf under State
law. In Arizona, Mexican wolves are managed as Wildlife of Special
Concern (Arizona Game and Fish Commission Rules, Article 4, R12-4-401)
and are identified as a Species of Greatest Conservation Need (Tier 1a,
endangered) (Species of Greatest Conservation Need 2006, pending). In
New Mexico, Mexican wolves are listed as endangered under the State's
Wildlife Conservation Act (NMSA 1978, pp. 17-2-37 through 17-2-46).
Based on these protective designations and regulations, we do not
foresee that actions on State land will significantly negatively affect
the nonessential experimental population.
We will continue to work with other agencies, tribes, and
landowners to ensure that their activities will not adversely affect
the nonessential experimental population of Mexican wolves. In
particular, we propose provisions within this rule to limit take of
Mexican wolves (see proposed 50 CFR 17.84(k)(4)). Based on our intent
to capture and return to the MWEPA Mexican wolves that disperse outside
of the MWEPA, we do not expect actions and activities adjacent to the
MWEPA to have a significant impact on the nonessential experimental
population.
Summary of Proposed Changes From the Previous Nonessential Experimental
Population Rule
The nonessential experimental population rule we are currently
proposing differs from the 1998 Final Rule in several substantive and
technical ways. Each of these modifications is being proposed to
improve the efficacy and clarity of our nonessential experimental
population designation and improve our progress toward reaching our
objective to establish a population of at least 100 wild Mexican
wolves. These modifications will also enhance our management
flexibility of the population. Below is a list of the proposed changes
from the previous nonessential experimental population rule:
(1) We are proposing to allow direct initial release of Mexican
wolves from captivity to the wild throughout the entire BRWRA (i.e.,
both the primary and secondary recovery zones designated in the 1998
Final Rule) rather than only in the primary recovery zone (Figure 2).
This modification will eliminate the need to define a primary and
secondary recovery zone within the BRWRA, as management of Mexican
wolves will be consistent throughout the BRWRA. Therefore, we are
discontinuing the definitions of primary and secondary recovery zones
in this proposal. This modification will promote population growth,
genetic diversity, and management flexibility by providing additional
area and locations for initial release of captive Mexican wolves to the
wild.
(2) We are proposing to allow Mexican wolves to disperse naturally
from the BRWRA into the MWEPA and to occupy the MWEPA (Figure 2).
Please note that if Mexican wolves travel outside the MWEPA, we will
capture
[[Page 35734]]
and return them to the MWEPA or put them in captivity. In the 1998
Final Rule, Mexican wolves were not allowed to disperse outside of the
BRWRA; we were required to capture dispersing Mexican wolves and return
them to the BRWRA or put them into captivity. Because natural dispersal
from the BRWRA was not allowed, population growth in the wild has been
limited. Therefore, we are proposing to allow for natural dispersal
outside the BRWRA so that the wild population can expand numerically
and spatially, assisting us in reaching our population objective. We
will manage Mexican wolves in the MWEPA by reducing conflicts with
humans and land uses through such means as hazing, trapping,
translocations, and removals.
(3) We are proposing to remove the portion of Texas included in the
1998 Final Rule (west Texas lying north of U.S. Highway 62/180 to the
Texas-New Mexico boundary) in our new designation of the MWEPA, as we
do not consider this area to be likely to contribute substantially to
our population objective (Figure 2).
(4) We are proposing to remove reference to possible reintroduction
of Mexican wolves to the White Sands Wolf Recovery Area. The 1998 Final
Rule included White Sands Wolf Recovery Area as a backup reintroduction
location to be utilized if determined necessary, but prey density has
since been determined to be too low in this area to support Mexican
wolves (Figure 2).
(5) We are proposing to provide for the development and
implementation of management actions on private land throughout the
MWEPA. The 1998 Final Rule did not contain this provision because
Mexican wolves were not allowed to inhabit the MWEPA outside of the
BRWRA.
(6) We are proposing to provide for the development and
implementation of management actions on tribal land within the MWEPA by
the Service or an authorized agency in voluntary cooperation with
tribal governments including but not limited to initial release,
translocation, capture, and removal of Mexican wolves if requested by
the tribal government.
(7) We are proposing to identify section 6 of the Act as
authorizing State wildlife agencies to manage Mexican wolves pursuant
to 50 CFR 17.31 under the nonessential experimental population rule.
Section 6 of the Act authorizes the Service to cooperate to the maximum
extent practicable with the States on the conservation of endangered
species, including the development of cooperative agreements and
management agreements. This proposed modification clarifies that States
with which we have cooperative or management agreements for the Mexican
wolf reintroduction project can take Mexican wolves that are part of
the nonessential experimental population during the course of normal
management activities in accordance with 50 CFR 17.31.
(8) We are proposing to clarify the specific circumstances under
which individuals are authorized to take Mexican wolves that are part
of the nonessential experimental population. In the 1998 Final Rule, we
used the term ``personnel'' to describe those authorized to take
Mexican wolves in the nonessential experimental population pursuant to
a Service-approved management plan, special management measure, or a
valid permit issued by the Service under 50 CFR 17.32. We intended this
provision to extend to individuals, that is, not only those people who
are associated with an agency.
(9) We are proposing to clarify the allowable take for Federal
agencies and authorized personnel. We added language to the provisions
for allowable take for Federal agencies to clarify that take must be
non-negligent and incidental to a legal activity and must be reported
within 24 hours to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or
to a designated representative of the Service. We added language to the
provisions for allowable take for authorized personnel to clarify that
Wildlife Services personnel will not be in violation of the Act or this
rule for take of a Mexican wolf that occurs while conducting official
duties. Such take must be non-negligent, incidental to predator control
activities, and consistent with recommendations of a section 7(a)(4)
conference opinion with Wildlife Services that addresses their program
activities that may affect Mexican wolves. Wildlife Services personnel
must report the take within 24 hours to the Service's Mexican Wolf
Recovery Coordinator or to a designated representative of the Service.
We are proposing these modifications to provide clarity and consistency
in our take determinations.
(10) We are proposing to revise the conditions that determine when
we would issue a permit to allow take of Mexican wolves that are
engaged in the act of killing, wounding or biting livestock. The 1998
Final Rule included a definition of breeding pair as one of the
conditions for take of Mexican wolves by livestock owners or agents on
public land grazing allotments (i.e., that there must be six breeding
pairs present in order for a permit to take wolves to be issued by the
Service). We consider overall population size to be a better metric for
evaluating the appropriateness of providing such permits because it
provides a more consistent measure of the population's status.
Therefore, we are proposing to modify the provision ``6 breeding
pairs'' to a requirement that at least 100 Mexican wolves must be
present in the MWEPA before such a permit can be issued. With this
proposed modification, the definition of a breeding pair would be made
unnecessary.
(11) We are proposing to modify the prohibitions for take such that
taking a Mexican wolf with a trap, snare, or other type of capture
device within the occupied Mexican wolf range is prohibited and will
not be considered unavoidable or unintentional take, unless due care
was exercised to avoid injury or death to a Mexican wolf. Due care
includes: (1) Following the regulations, proclamations, and/or laws
within the State where the trapping takes place; (2) If securely
fastening traps, using double-stake traps, cable stakes (at least 18
inches (in) (46 centimeters (cm)) deep), or otherwise attaching traps
to immovable objects with aircraft cable or chain so that, if captured,
a Mexican wolf is unable to pull the trap free; (3) If using drags,
using one of sufficient size and weight or grapples made from steel at
least 0.5 in (1.3 cm) in diameter of cross section attached to chains
or cables; (4) Reporting the capture of a Mexican wolf (even if the
wolf has pulled free) within 24 hours to the Service; and (5) Not
taking a Mexican wolf via neck snares. We are proposing this
modification to provide clarity and consistency in our take
determinations.
(12) We are proposing to establish a new requirement to conduct a
one-time evaluation of the status of the nonessential experimental
population and its contribution toward recovery of the Mexican wolf 5
years after the final rule designation. The 1998 Final Rule contained
provisions for 3- and 5-year reviews, which were conducted in 2001 and
2005, respectively. We do not consider a 3-year review to be necessary,
as we included this provision in the 1998 Final Rule to address the
substantial uncertainties we had with reestablishing captive Mexican
wolves to the wild. Therefore, a one-time evaluation 5 years after the
final determination is made will provide the appropriate interval to
assess the effectiveness of the project. We will also be conducting
status reviews of the listed species every 5 years as required
[[Page 35735]]
by section 4(c)(2) of the Act, and will continue to produce annual
progress reports.
(13) We are proposing to consider State-owned lands within the
boundaries of the MWEPA in the same manner as we consider lands owned
and managed by other public land management agencies. The 1998 Final
Rule designated State-owned lands within the boundary of designated
wolf recovery area as public land. All State-owned lands within the
boundary of the MWEPA, but outside of designated wolf recovery areas
were subject to the provisions of private lands in the 1998 Final Rule.
We are proposing this change to allow consistent management of Mexican
wolves throughout the MWEPA, recognizing that State and other public
lands within the MWEPA are under control of the agency that owns those
lands, that this regulation gives the Service no additional authority
over those lands, and thus the Service's role is to work cooperatively
with those land management agencies to address conservation needs of
the Mexican wolf.
Additional Revisions to the Previous Nonessential Experimental
Population Rule Under Consideration
In this proposed rule, we also identify and seek comment on several
additional issues, none of which were included in the 1998 Final Rule.
We are not proposing these modifications at this time, but are
considering including them in our final determination:
(1) Moving the southern boundary of the MWEPA in Arizona and New
Mexico from Interstate Highway 10 to the United States-Mexico
international border (Figure 3);
(2) Expanding the BRWRA to include the entire Sitgreaves National
Forest in Arizona (Figure 3);
(3) Expanding the BRWRA to include the Payson, Pleasant Valley, and
Tonto Basin Ranger Districts of the Tonto National Forests in Arizona
(Figure 3);
(4) Expanding the BRWRA to include the Magdalena Ranger District of
the Cibola National Forest in New Mexico (Figure 3);
(5) Including provisions for take by pet owners of any Mexican wolf
engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting pets on private or
tribal land anywhere within the MWEPA, provided that evidence of a
freshly wounded or killed pet by wolves is present. Such take must be
reported to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or an
authorized agent within 24 hours; and
(6) Changing the term ``depredation'' to ``depredation incident''
and revising the definition to mean, ``The aggregate number of
livestock killed or mortally wounded by an individual Mexican wolf or
single pack of Mexican wolves at a single location within one 24-hour
period, beginning with the first confirmed kill or injury.''
(7) Including provisions for the issuance of permits on private or
tribal lands anywhere within the MWEPA to allow livestock owners or
their agents to take (including kill or injure) any Mexican wolf that
is present on private or tribal land, including establishing conditions
that must be met before such a permit is issued, such as a minimum
population size of Mexican wolves present in the MWEPA or other
established populations based on the most recently reported population
count; other relevant measures of population status such as genetic
diversity; documentation by the Service or our authorized agent of
previous loss or injury of livestock on the private or tribal land,
caused by Mexican wolves; completion of agency efforts to resolve the
problem; and enactment of this provision by a formal statement from the
Service.
Our intent in considering expansion of the BRWRA would be to
release or translocate wolves only into areas of suitable habitat,
likely in areas above 4,000 ft above sea level.
Peer Review
In accordance with joint policy published in the Federal Register
on July 1, 1994 (59 FR 34270), we will seek the expert opinions of at
least three appropriate and independent specialists regarding this
proposed rule. We have provided copies of this proposed rule to three
or more appropriate and independent specialists in order to solicit
comments on the scientific data and assumptions we utilized. The
purpose of such review is to ensure that the final determination is
based on scientifically sound data, assumptions, and analyses. We have
invited these peer reviewers to comment during the public comment
period and will consider their comments and information on the proposed
modifications during preparation of a final determination. Accordingly,
the final decision may differ from this proposal.
Public Hearings
Requests for public hearings must be received within 45 days after
the date of publication of this proposed rule in the Federal Register.
Such requests must be sent to the address shown in the FOR FURTHER
INFORMATION CONTACT section. If we schedule public hearings on this
proposal, we will announce the dates, times, and places of those
hearings, as well as how to obtain reasonable accommodations, in the
Federal Register and local newspapers at least 15 days before any such
hearing.
Required Determinations
Regulatory Planning and Review--Executive Order 12866
Executive Order 12866 provides that the Office of Information and
Regulatory Affairs in the Office of Management and Budget will review
all significant rules. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs
has determined that this rule is not significant.
Executive Order 13563 reaffirms the principles of E.O. 12866 while
calling for improvements in the nation's regulatory system to promote
predictability, to reduce uncertainty, and to use the best, most
innovative, and least burdensome tools for achieving regulatory ends.
The executive order directs agencies to consider regulatory approaches
that reduce burdens and maintain flexibility and freedom of choice for
the public where these approaches are relevant, feasible, and
consistent with regulatory objectives. Executive Order 13563 emphasizes
further that regulations must be based on the best available science
and that the rulemaking process must allow for public participation and
an open exchange of ideas. We have developed this rule in a manner
consistent with these requirements.
Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.)
Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (as amended by the Small
Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act (SBREFA) of 1996; 5 U.S.C.
801 et seq.), whenever a Federal agency is required to publish a notice
of rulemaking for any proposed or final rule, it must prepare, and make
available for public comment, a regulatory flexibility analysis that
describes the effect of the rule on small entities (i.e., small
businesses, small organizations, and small government jurisdictions).
However, no regulatory flexibility analysis is required if the head of
an agency certifies that the rule will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities. The SBREFA amended
the Regulatory Flexibility Act to require Federal agencies to provide a
statement of the factual basis for certifying that the rule will not
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities.
According to the Small Business Administration, small entities
include
[[Page 35736]]
small organizations such as independent nonprofit organizations; small
governmental jurisdictions, including school boards and city and town
governments that serve fewer than 50,000 residents; and small
businesses (13 CFR 121.201). Small businesses include such businesses
as manufacturing and mining concerns with fewer than 500 employees,
wholesale trade entities with fewer than 100 employees, retail and
service businesses with less than $5 million in annual sales, general
and heavy construction businesses with less than $27.5 million in
annual business, special trade contractors doing less than $11.5
million in annual business, and forestry and logging operations with
fewer than 500 employees and annual business less than $7 million. To
determine whether small entities may be affected, we considered the
types of activities that might trigger regulatory impacts under this
designation as well as types of project modifications that may result.
In general, the term ``significant economic impact'' is meant to apply
to a typical small business firm's business operations.
Importantly, the impacts of a rule must be both significant and
substantial to prevent certification of the rule under the RFA and to
require the preparation of an initial regulatory flexibility analysis.
If a substantial number of small entities are affected by the proposed
rule, but the per-entity economic impact is not significant, the
Service may certify. Likewise, if the per-entity economic impact is
likely to be significant, but the number of affected entities is not
substantial, the Service may also certify.
In the 1998 Final Rule, we found that the nonessential population
would not have significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities under the Regulatory Flexibility Act. The 1998 Final
Rule set forth management directions and provided for limited allowable
legal take of Mexican wolves within the MWEPA. We concluded that the
rule would not significantly change costs to industry or governments.
Furthermore, the rule produced no adverse effects on competition,
employment, investment, productivity, innovation, or the ability of
U.S. enterprises to compete with foreign-based enterprises in domestic
or export markets. We further concluded that no significant direct
costs, information collection, or recordkeeping requirements were
imposed on small entities by the action and that the rule was not a
major rule as defined by 5 U.S.C. 804(2) (63 FR 1752, January 12,
1998).
If this proposal is adopted, the area affected by this rule
includes the portion of the States of Arizona and New Mexico from
Interstate Highway 40 south to Interstate Highway 10. This rule
proposes an activity that has, in part, already been taking place
within the BRWRA. However, we are now proposing to allow initial
releases into a portion of the BRWRA in which initial releases were not
previously allowed and to allow Mexican wolves to disperse from the
BRWRA into the entire MWEPA.
This proposal to allow initial releases in the entire BRWRA will
not affect small businesses, organizations, or governments, as this
action will occur on the Gila National Forest and the Apache National
Forest (Federal land). Although conducting initial releases on the Gila
National Forest would be a new action (not currently allowed based on
the 1998 Final Rule), if this proposed revision is finalized, Mexican
wolves already inhabit the Gila National Forest.
In addition, section 7(a)(4) of the Act requires Federal agencies
to confer (rather than consult) with the Service on actions that are
likely to jeopardize the continued existence of a species. However,
because a nonessential experimental population is, by definition, not
essential to the survival of the species, conferencing will likely
never be required within the MWEPA. Furthermore, the results of a
conference are strictly advisory in nature and do not restrict agencies
from carrying out, funding, or authorizing activities. In addition,
section 7(a)(1) requires Federal agencies to use their authorities to
carry out programs to further the conservation of listed species, which
would apply on any lands within the nonessential experimental
population area. As a result, and in accordance with these regulations,
some modifications to the proposed Federal actions within the
nonessential experimental population area may occur to benefit the
Mexican wolf, but we do not expect projects on Federal lands to be
halted or substantially modified as a result of these regulations.
On the other hand, this proposed revision would allow Mexican
wolves to disperse outside the BRWRA into the MWEPA, which has the
potential to affect small entities in the area outside the BRWRA.
Specifically, small businesses involved in animal production on private
or tribal land, such as beef cattle and sheep ranching, may be affected
by Mexican wolves depredating on livestock. Efforts to reduce
depredation on livestock are additional expenses to ranching
operations, such as employing range riders or modifying fencing or
livestock grazing rotation schedules. However, these types of proactive
activities may already be conducted for other predators like black
bears (Ursus americanus), coyotes (Canis latrans), or mountain lions
(Puma concolor). We will further assess these types of impacts to small
entities in the area outside the BRWRA in the draft EIS.
At this time, we lack the available economic information necessary
to provide an adequate factual basis for the required RFA finding.
Therefore, we defer the RFA finding until completion of the EIS. Upon
completion of a draft EIS, we will announce availability of the draft
EIS in the Federal Register and reopen the public comment period for
the proposed revision. We will include with this announcement, as
appropriate, an initial regulatory flexibility analysis or a
certification that the rule will not have a significant economic impact
on a substantial number of small entities accompanied by the factual
basis for the determination. We have concluded that deferring the RFA
finding until completion of the EIS is necessary to meet the purposes
and requirements of the RFA. Deferring the RFA finding in this manner
will ensure that we make a sufficiently informed determination based on
adequate economic information and provide the necessary opportunity for
public comment.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (2 U.S.C. 1501 et seq.)
In accordance with the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (2 U.S.C. 1501
et seq.), we make the following findings:
(1) Because we lack the available economic information necessary to
provide an adequate factual basis for the required RFA finding, we
defer our finding on whether this rule will ``significantly or
uniquely'' affect small governments until completion of the EIS. At
that time, we will determine and certify pursuant to the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act, 2 U.S.C. 1502 et seq., whether or not this
rulemaking will impose a cost of $100 million or more in any given year
on local or State governments or private entities. A Small Government
Agency Plan is not required. As explained above, we do not expect that
small governments will be affected because the nonessential
experimental population designation will not place additional
requirements on any city, county, or other local municipalities.
However, we will analyze this further in the final rule.
(2) We do not expect that this rule will produce a Federal mandate
of $100 million or greater in any year (i.e., it is not a ``significant
regulatory action''
[[Page 35737]]
under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act). Also, we do not expect that
this nonessential experimental population designation for Mexican
wolves will impose any additional management or protection requirements
on the States or other entities. However, we will analyze this further
in the final rule.
Takings--Executive Order 12630
In accordance with Executive Order 12630 (Government Actions and
Interference with Constitutionally Protected Private Property Rights),
this rule does not have significant takings implications. When
reestablished populations of federally listed species are designated as
nonessential experimental populations, the Act's regulatory
requirements regarding the reestablished listed species within the
nonessential experimental population are significantly reduced. In the
1998 Final Rule, we stated that one issue of concern is the depredation
of livestock by reintroduced Mexican wolves, but such depredation by a
wild animal would not be a taking under the 5th Amendment. One of the
reasons for the experimental nonessential designation is to allow the
agency and private entities flexibility in managing Mexican wolves,
including the elimination of a wolf when there is a confirmed kill of
livestock.
A takings implication assessment is not required because this rule
will not effectively compel a property owner to suffer a physical
invasion of property and will not deny all economically beneficial or
productive use of the land or aquatic resources. This rule
substantially advances a legitimate government interest (conservation
and recovery of a listed species) and does not present a barrier to all
reasonable and expected beneficial use of private property.
Federalism--Executive Order 13132
In accordance with Executive Order 13132 (Federalism), this
proposed rule does not have significant Federalism effects. A
Federalism assessment is not required. This rule will not have
substantial direct effects on the States, on the relationship between
the Federal Government and the States, or on the distribution of power
and responsibilities among the various levels of government. In keeping
with Department of the Interior policy, we requested information from
and coordinated development of this rule with the affected resource
agencies in New Mexico and Arizona. Achieving the recovery goals for
this species will contribute to its eventual delisting and its return
to State management. No intrusion on State policy or administration is
expected, roles or responsibilities of Federal or State governments
will not change, and fiscal capacity will not be substantially or
directly affected. The special rule operates to maintain the existing
relationship between the State and the Federal Government. Therefore,
this rule does not have significant Federalism effects or implications
to warrant the preparation of a Federalism Assessment under the
provisions of Executive Order 13132.
Civil Justice Reform--Executive Order 12988
In accordance with Executive Order 12988 (February 7, 1996; 61 FR
4729), the Office of the Solicitor has determined that this rule will
not unduly burden the judicial system and will meet the requirements of
sections (3)(a) and (3)(b)(2) of the Order.
Government-to-Government Relationship With Tribes
In accordance with the President's memorandum of April 29, 1994
(Government-to-Government Relations with Native American Tribal
Governments; 59 FR 22951), Executive Order 13175 (Consultation and
Coordination With Indian Tribal Governments), and the Department of the
Interior's manual at 512 DM 2, we intend to notify the Native American
tribes within and adjacent to the nonessential experimental population
area about the proposed rule. They will be advised through written
contact, including informational mailings from the Service, and will be
provided an opportunity to comment on the draft EIS and proposed rule.
If future activities resulting from this rule may affect tribal
resources, the Service will communicate and consult on a Government-to-
Government basis with any affected Native American tribes in order to
find a mutually agreeable solution.
Paperwork Reduction Act
Office of Management and Budget (OMB) regulations at 5 CFR part
1320, which implement provisions of the Paperwork Reduction Act (44
U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), require that Federal agencies obtain approval
from OMB before collecting information from the public. This rule does
not contain any new collections of information that require approval by
the Office of Management and Budget under the Paperwork Reduction Act
of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.). This rule would not impose
recordkeeping or reporting requirements on state or local governments,
individuals, businesses, or organizations. The OMB has approved our
collection of information associated with reporting the taking of
experimental populations (50 CFR 17.84) and assigned control number
1018-0095, which expires May 31, 2014. An agency may not conduct or
sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of
information unless it displays a currently valid Office of Management
and Budget control number.
National Environmental Policy Act
We are preparing a draft EIS pursuant to the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA; 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.) in connection with the
proposed revision to the nonessential experimental population of the
Mexican wolf section 10(j) rule. As part of this process, we will
analyze a range of alternatives for implementation of a nonessential
experimental population pursuant to NEPA.
From October through December 2007, we conducted a public scoping
process under NEPA based on our intent to modify the 1998 Final Rule.
We developed a final scoping report in April 2008, but we did not
propose or finalize any modifications to the 1998 Final Rule at that
time. We will utilize the information collected during that scoping
process in the development of a draft EIS for this proposed revision to
the nonessential experimental population of the Mexican wolf.
Information about additional scoping opportunities is available on our
Web site, at http://www.fws.gov/southwest/es/mexicanwolf/NEPA.cfm. When
the draft EIS is complete, we will announce its availability for public
review, and we will reopen the public comment period on this proposed
rule for additional review and comment. After full consideration of all
information and comments received on this proposed rule and the draft
EIS, our final determination will be made based on the best available
information and may include any of the modifications discussed in this
proposed rule.
Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use--Executive Order 13211
Executive Order 13211 (Actions Concerning Regulations That
Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use) requires
agencies to prepare Statements of Energy Effects when undertaking
certain actions. This rule is not expected to significantly affect
energy supplies, distribution, and use. Because this action is not a
significant energy action, no Statement of Energy Effects is required.
[[Page 35738]]
Clarity of the Rule
We are required by Executive Orders 12866 and 12988 and by the
Presidential Memorandum of June 1, 1998, to write all rules in plain
language. This means that each rule we publish must:
(1) Be logically organized;
(2) Use the active voice to address readers directly;
(3) Use clear language rather than jargon;
(4) Be divided into short sections and sentences; and
(5) Use lists and tables wherever possible.
If you feel that we have not met these requirements, send us
comments by one of the methods listed in the ADDRESSES section. To
better help us revise the rule, your comments should be as specific as
possible. For example, you should tell us the numbers of the sections
or paragraphs that are unclearly written, which sections or sentences
are too long, the sections where you feel lists or tables would be
useful, etc.
References Cited
A complete list of all references cited in this proposed rule is
available at http://www.regulations.gov at Docket No. FWS-R2-ES-2013-
0056, or upon request from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, New
Mexico Ecological Services Field Office (see ADDRESSES section).
Authors
The primary authors of this notice are the staff members of the New
Mexico Ecological Services Field Office (see FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT).
Authority
The authority for this action is the Endangered Species Act of 1973
(16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.) and the National Environmental Policy Act of
1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.).
Proposed Regulation Promulgation
Accordingly, we propose to amend part 17, subchapter B of chapter
I, title 50 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as set forth below:
PART 17--[AMENDED]
0
1. The authority citation for part 17 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1361-1407; 1531-1544; 4201-4245; unless
otherwise noted.
0
2. Amend Sec. 17.11(h) in the List of Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife under Mammals by:
0
a. Removing both entries for ``Wolf, gray (Canis lupus)''; and
0
b. Adding two entries for ``Wolf, Mexican (Canis lupus baileyi)'' in
alphabetic order to read as follows:
Sec. 17.11 Endangered and threatened wildlife.
* * * * *
(h) * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Species Vertebrate
-------------------------------------------------------- population where Critical Special
Historic range endangered or Status When listed habitat rules
Common name Scientific name threatened
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mammals
* * * * * * *
Wolf, Mexican.................... Canis lupus baileyi. Southwestern United Entire, except E ........... NA NA
States and Mexico. where included in
an experimental
population as set
forth in 17.84(k).
Wolf, Mexican.................... Canis lupus baileyi. Southwestern United U.S.A. (portions of XN ........... NA 17.84(k)
States and Mexico. AZ and NM)--see
17.84(k).
* * * * * * *
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0
3. Amend Sec. 17.84 by revising paragraph (k) to read as follows:
Sec. 17.84 Special rules--vertebrates.
* * * * *
(k) Mexican wolf (Canis lupus baileyi). This paragraph (k) sets
forth the provisions of a rule to establish an experimental population
of Mexican wolves.
(1) Purpose of the rule: The Service finds that reestablishment of
an experimental population of Mexican wolves into the subspecies'
probable historical range will further the conservation of the Mexican
wolf subspecies. The Service also finds that the experimental
population is not essential under Sec. 17.81(c)(2).
(2) Determinations: The Mexican wolf population reestablished in
the Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Area, including the Blue Range
Wolf Recovery Area, identified in paragraph (k)(4) of this section, is
one nonessential experimental population. This nonessential
experimental population will be managed according to the provisions of
this rule. The Service does not intend to change the nonessential
experimental designation to essential experimental, threatened, or
endangered. Critical habitat cannot be designated under the
nonessential experimental classification, 16 U.S.C. 1539(j)(2)(C)(ii).
(3) Definitions--Key terms used in this rule have the following
definitions:
Affect game populations in ways that may inhibit further Mexican
wolf recovery means affect a particular species of ungulate in a game
management unit or distinct herd segment by cumulatively decreasing
population or hunter harvest estimates by 35 percent during 2
consecutive years compared to the herd's 5-year average prior to
Mexican wolf occupancy (the unit or herd must contain an average of
greater than 100 animals). This definition does not apply to Service-
approved State and tribal Mexican wolf management plans that define
unacceptable impacts from wolf predation on game populations.
Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area means the entirety of the Gila
National Forest in New Mexico and the Apache National Forest in Arizona
in which Mexican wolves may be initially released from captivity,
translocated, and managed to reduce conflicts with humans and other
land uses to achieve recovery.
Depredation means the confirmed killing or wounding of lawfully
present domestic livestock by one or more wolves. The Service, Wildlife
Services, or other Service-authorized agencies will confirm cases of
wolf depredation on domestic livestock.
Disturbance-causing land-use activity means any land-use activity
that the Service determines could adversely
[[Page 35739]]
affect reproductive success, natural behavior, or survival of Mexican
wolves. Such activities may include, but are not limited to--timber or
wood harvesting, prescribed fire, mining or mine development, camping
outside designated campgrounds, livestock drives, off-road vehicle use,
hunting, and any other use or activity with the potential to disturb
wolves. The following activities are specifically excluded from this
definition:
(i) Legally permitted livestock grazing and use of water sources by
livestock;
(ii) Livestock drives if no reasonable alternative route or timing
exists;
(iii) Vehicle access over established roads to private property and
to areas on public land where legally permitted activities are ongoing
if no reasonable alternative route exists;
(iv) Use of lands within the national park or national wildlife
refuge systems as safety buffer zones for military activities;
(v) Fire-fighting activities associated with wildfires; and
(vi) Any authorized, specific land use that was active and ongoing
at the time Mexican wolves chose to locate a den or rendezvous site
nearby.
Engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting livestock means
in the pursuit of and grasping, biting, attacking, or wounding, or
feeding upon, livestock that are alive. The term does not include
Mexican wolves feeding on a livestock carcass.
Harass means intentional or negligent actions or omissions that
create the likelihood of injury to wildlife by annoying it to such an
extent as to significantly disrupt normal behavioral patterns, which
include, but are not limited to, breeding, feeding, or sheltering.
Livestock means cattle, sheep, horses, mules, burros, llamas, and
alpacas, or other domestic animals defined as livestock in Service-
approved State and tribal Mexican wolf management plans.
Mexican Wolf Experimental Population Area (MWEPA) means an area in
Arizona and New Mexico that lies south of Interstate Highway 40 to
Interstate Highway 10 into which Mexican wolves are allowed to disperse
from the Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area and establish, but are managed
by reducing conflicts with humans and land uses through such means as
hazing, trapping, translocations, and removals.
Occupied Mexican wolf range means an area of confirmed presence,
based on the most recent annual report, of resident breeding packs or
pairs of Mexican wolves or an area consistently used by at least one
resident Mexican wolf over a period of at least 1 month in the MWEPA,
described as:
(i) A radius of 5 mi (8 km) around all locations of Mexican wolves
and wolf sign confirmed as described above (non-radio-monitored);
(ii) A radius of 5 mi (8 km) around radio locations of resident
Mexican wolves when fewer than 20 radio locations are available (for
radio-monitored wolves only); or
(iii) A radius of 3 mi (4.8 km) around a scientifically developed
home range (fixed kernel or other appropriate method) from more than 20
radio locations of a pack, pair, or single Mexican wolf acquired over a
period of at least 6 months (for radio-monitored wolves).
Opportunistic, noninjurious harassment means scaring a Mexican wolf
observed on private land or near livestock from the immediate area by
taking actions such as discharging firearms or other projectile-
launching devices in proximity to but not in the direction of the wolf,
throwing objects at it, or making loud noise in proximity to it,
without causing bodily injury or death to the wolf.
Problem wolves means Mexican wolves that--
(i) Are members of a group or pack (including adults and yearlings)
that were directly involved in livestock depredation on lawfully
present domestic livestock on Federal land;
(ii) Have depredated domestic animals other than livestock on
private or tribal lands, two times in an area within 1 year; or
(iii) Are habituated to humans, human residences, or other
facilities.
Public land means land owned, managed, or under the administration
of a State or aFederal agency, including, but not limited to, the
Service, National Park Service, Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Forest
Service, Department of Energy, or Department of Defense
Rendezvous site means a gathering and activity area regularly used
by a litter of young Mexican wolf pups after they have emerged from the
den. Typically, the site is used from about 1 week to 1 month during
the period from June 1 to September 30. Several sites may be used in
succession.
Take means to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap,
capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in any such conduct (16
U.S.C. 1532(19)).
Unavoidable and unintentional take means take that occurs despite
the use of due care, is incidental to an otherwise lawful activity, and
is not done on purpose. Taking a Mexican wolf by shooting will not be
considered unavoidable and unintentional take.
(4) Designated area: The designated experimental population area
for Mexican wolves classified as a nonessential experimental population
by this rule is described in this paragraph (k)(4). The designated
experimental population area is within the subspecies' probable
historical range and is wholly separate geographically from the current
range of any known Mexican wolves or other gray wolves.
(i) The Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area includes all of the Apache
National Forest and all of the Gila National Forest in east-central
Arizona and west-central New Mexico. Mexican wolves may be initially
released from captivity into the Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area,
translocated, and managed to reduce conflicts with humans and other
land uses. Mexican wolves will be allowed to disperse from this area
into the MWEPA and to occupy the MWEPA.
(ii) A map of the MWEPA follows:
[[Page 35740]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP13JN13.005
(5) Prohibitions: Take of any Mexican wolf in the wild within the
MWEPA is prohibited, except as provided in paragraph (k)(6) of this
section. In addition, the following actions are prohibited by this
rule:
(i) No person may possess, sell, deliver, carry, transport, ship,
import, or export by any means whatsoever, any Mexican wolf or wolf
part from the experimental population except as authorized in this rule
or by a valid permit issued by the Service under Sec. 17.32. If a
person kills or injures a Mexican wolf or finds a dead or injured wolf
or wolf parts, the person must not disturb them (unless instructed to
do so by an authorized agent of the Service), must minimize disturbance
of the area around them, and must report the incident to the Service's
Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or a designated representative of the
Service within 24 hours.
(ii) No person may attempt to commit, solicit another to commit, or
cause to be committed, any offense defined in this rule.
(iii) Taking a wolf with a trap, snare, or other type of capture
device within occupied Mexican wolf range is prohibited (except as
authorized in paragraph (k)(6)(iv) of this section) and will not be
considered unavoidable and unintentional take, unless due care was
exercised to avoid injury or death to a wolf. Due care includes:
(A) Following the regulations, proclamations, and/or laws within
the State where the trapping takes place;
(B) If securely fastening traps, using double-stake traps, cable
stakes (at least 18 inches (in) (46 centimeters (cm)) deep), or
otherwise attaching traps to immovable objects with aircraft cable or
chain so that, if captured, a Mexican wolf is unable to pull the trap
free;
(C) If using drags, using one of sufficient size and weight or
grapples made from steel at least 0.5 in (1.3 cm) in diameter of cross
section attached to chains or cables;
(D) Reporting the capture of a Mexican wolf (even if the wolf has
pulled free) within 24 hours to the Service; and
(E) Not taking a Mexican wolf via neck snares.
(6) Allowable take: Take of Mexican wolves in the MWEPA is allowed
as follows:
(i) Any person or other entity: (A) Throughout the MWEPA,
unavoidable and unintentional take of a Mexican wolf is not a violation
of the Act or this rule. Such take must be reported within 24 hours to
the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or to a designated
representative of the Service.
(B) Throughout the MWEPA, any person may use opportunistic,
noninjurious harassment at any time for Mexican wolves that are within
500 yards of people, buildings, facilities, pets, livestock, or other
domestic animals, and no permit is required--provided that wolves are
not purposefully attracted, tracked, searched out, or chased and then
harassed. Such harassment of Mexican wolves must be reported within 7
days to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or to a
designated representative of the Service.
(C) A person may take (which includes killing as well as nonlethal
actions such as harassing, harming, and wounding) a Mexican wolf in
self-defense or defense of the lives of others, provided that the take
is reported within 24 hours to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery
Coordinator or a designated representative of the Service. If the
Service or an authorized agency determines that a Mexican wolf presents
a threat to human life or safety, the Service or the authorized agency
may kill the wolf or place it in captivity.
(ii) Federal agencies: (A) Throughout the MWEPA, excluding areas
within the National Park System and National Wildlife Refuge System, no
Federal agency or their contractors will be in violation of the Act or
this rule for
[[Page 35741]]
unavoidable and unintentional take of a Mexican wolf resulting from any
action authorized by that Federal agency or by the Service, including,
but not limited to, military training and testing. Such take must be
nonnegligent and incidental to a legal activity and must be reported
within 24 hours to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or
to a designated representative of the Service. This provision does not
exempt agencies and their contractors from complying with sections
7(a)(1) and 7(a)(4) of the Act, the latter of which requires a
conference with the Service if they propose an action that is likely to
jeopardize the continued existence of the Mexican wolf.
(B) In areas within the National Park System and National Wildlife
Refuge System, Federal agencies must treat Mexican wolves as a
threatened species for purposes of complying with section 7 of the Act.
(iii) Livestock owners or their agents: (A) On private land
anywhere within the MWEPA, livestock owners or their agents may take
(including kill or injure) any Mexican wolf actually engaged in the act
of killing, wounding, or biting livestock--provided that evidence of
livestock freshly wounded or killed by Mexican wolves is present. The
take must be reported to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery
Coordinator or a designated representative of the Service within 24
hours.
(B) On tribal lands anywhere within the MWEPA, livestock owners or
their agents may take (including kill or injure) any Mexican wolf
actually engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or biting livestock--
provided that evidence of livestock freshly wounded or killed by wolves
is present. The take must be reported to the Service's Mexican Wolf
Recovery Coordinator or a designated representative of the Service
within 24 hours.
(C) On public lands allotted for livestock grazing anywhere within
the MWEPA, including the Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area, livestock
owners or their agents may be issued a permit under the Act to take
Mexican wolves actually engaged in the act of killing, wounding, or
biting livestock. Before such a permit is issued, the following
conditions must be met: Livestock must be legally present on the
grazing allotment; at least 100 Mexican wolves must be present in the
MWEPA based on the most recently reported population count; previous
loss or injury of livestock on the grazing allotment, caused by Mexican
wolves, must be documented by the Service or our authorized agent; and
agency efforts to resolve the problem must be completed. Permits issued
under this provision will be valid for 45 days or less and will specify
the maximum number of Mexican wolves for which take is allowed. If a
livestock owner or his or her agent takes a Mexican wolf under this
provision, evidence of livestock freshly wounded or killed by Mexican
wolves must be present. Livestock owners or their agents must report
this take to the Service's Mexican Wolf Recovery Coordinator or a
designated representative of the Service within 24 hours.
(D) Throughout the MWEPA, take of Mexican wolves by livestock
guarding dogs, when used in the traditional manner to protect livestock
on public, tribal, and private lands, is permitted. If such take by a
guard dog occurs, it must be reported to the Service's Mexican Wolf
Recovery Coordinator or a designated representative of the Service
within 24 hours.
(iv) Authorized personnel: Individuals or personnel authorized by
the Service may take any Mexican wolf in the nonessential experimental
population in a manner consistent with a Service-approved management
plan, special management measure, conference opinion pursuant to
section 7(a)(4) of the Act, section 6 of the Act as authorized pursuant
to Sec. 17.31 for State wildlife agencies with authority to manage
Mexican wolves, or a valid permit issued by the Service under Sec.
17.32.
(A) This take may include, but is not limited to, capture and
translocation of Mexican wolves that: Prey on livestock; attack pets or
domestic animals other than livestock on private or tribal land; affect
game populations in ways that may inhibit further Mexican wolf
recovery; are considered problem wolves; endanger themselves by their
presence in a military impact area; need aid or veterinary care; or
must be taken for authorized scientific, research, or management
purposes. If Mexican wolf predation is shown to be a primary cause of
ungulate population declines (greater than 50 percent of documented
adult or young mortality), then wolves may be moved to reduce ungulate
mortality rates and assist in herd recovery, but only in conjunction
with application of other common, professionally acceptable, wildlife
management techniques.
(B) The Service encourages those authorized to take wolves to use
nonlethal means when practicable and appropriate prior to any lethal
take of a Mexican wolf. Lethal methods of take may be used when
reasonable attempts to capture wolves alive have failed and when the
Service determines that immediate removal of a particular Mexican wolf
or wolves from the wild is necessary.
(C) Authorized personnel may use leghold traps and any other
effective device or method for capturing or controlling Mexican wolves
to carry out any measure that is a part of a Service-approved
management plan, notwithstanding any conflicts with State law. Trappers
can call the Interagency Field Team (IFT) (1-888-459-WOLF [9653]) as
soon as possible to arrange for radio-collaring and releasing of the
wolf. Per State regulations for releasing nontarget animals, trappers
may also choose to release the animal alive and subsequently contact
the Service or IFT. The disposition of all Mexican wolves (live or
dead) or their parts taken as part of a Service-authorized management
activity must follow provisions in Service-approved management plans or
interagency agreements or procedures approved by the Service on a case-
by-case basis.
(D) As determined by the Service to be appropriate, the Service or
any agent authorized by the Service may capture, kill, subject to
genetic testing, place in captivity, or euthanize any feral wolflike
animal, feral wolf hybrid, or feral dog found within the MWEPA that
shows physical or behavioral evidence of: Hybridization with other
canids, such as domestic dogs or coyotes; being an animal raised in
captivity, other than as part of a Service-approved wolf recovery
program; or being socialized or habituated to humans. If determined to
be a pure Mexican wolf, the wolf may be returned to the wild.
(E) The Wildlife Services division will discontinue use of M-44's
and choking-type snares in occupied Mexican wolf range. Wildlife
Services may restrict or modify other predator control activities
pursuant to a cooperative management agreement or a conference opinion
between that division and the Service. Wildlife Services personnel will
not be in violation of the Act or this rule for take of a Mexican wolf
that occurs while conducting official duties. Such take must be
nonnegligent, incidental to predator control activities, and consistent
with a section 7(a)(4) conference opinion addressing Wildlife Services
program activities that may affect Mexican wolves. Wildlife Services
personnel must report the take within 24 hours to the Service's Mexican
Wolf Recovery Coordinator or to a designated representative of the
Service.
(7) Land-use restrictions: (i) No land-use restrictions will be
imposed on private lands pursuant to this rule or for
[[Page 35742]]
Mexican wolf recovery without the concurrence of the landowner.
(ii) No land-use restrictions will be imposed on tribal lands
pursuant to this rule or for Mexican wolf recovery without the
concurrence of the tribal government.
(iii) On public lands, the Service will work with cooperating
public land management agencies to use their authorities to temporarily
restrict human access and disturbance-causing land-use activities
within a 1-mi (1.6-km) radius around release pens when Mexican wolves
are in them, around active dens between March 1 and June 30, and around
active Mexican wolf rendezvous sites between June 1 and September 30,
as necessary.
(8) Management: (i) On private land within the MWEPA, the Service
or an authorized agency will develop and implement management actions
to benefit Mexican wolf recovery in cooperation with willing private
landowners, including initial release and translocation of wolves on
private land if requested by the landowner.
(ii) On tribal land within the MWEPA, the Service or an authorized
agency will develop and implement management actions in cooperation
with willing tribal governments, including initial release,
translocation, capture, and removal of Mexican wolves on tribal land if
requested by the tribal government.
(9) Evaluation: The Service will evaluate Mexican wolf
reestablishment progress and prepare periodic progress reports and
detailed annual reports. In addition, the Service will prepare a one-
time overall evaluation of the nonessential experimental population
program 5 years after [EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE FINAL RULE] that focuses
on modifications needed to improve the efficacy of this rule,
reestablishment of Mexican wolves to the wild, and the contribution the
nonessential population is making to the recovery of the Mexican wolf.
* * * * *
Dated: May 29, 2013.
Rachel Jacobson,
Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife and Parks.
[FR Doc. 2013-13977 Filed 6-12-13; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4310-55-P