[Federal Register Volume 77, Number 125 (Thursday, June 28, 2012)]
[Notices]
[Pages 38690-38692]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2012-15806]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
[Release No. 34-67242; File No. SR-FINRA-2012-023]
Self-Regulatory Organizations; Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority, Inc.; Order Granting Approval of a Proposed Rule Change
Relating to FINRA's Trading Activity Fee Rate for Transactions in
Covered Equity Securities
June 22, 2012.
I. Introduction
On May 2, 2012, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.
(``FINRA'') filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission
(``Commission''), pursuant to Section 19(b)(1) of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934 (the ``Act'') \1\ and Rule 19b-4 thereunder,\2\ a
proposed rule change relating to FINRA's Trading Activity Fee (``TAF'')
rate for transactions in covered equity securities. The proposed rule
change was published for comment in the Federal Register on May 10,
2012.\3\ The Commission received four comments on the proposal.\4\ On
June 19, FINRA responded to the comments.\5\ This order approves the
proposed rule change.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(1).
\2\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
\3\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 66924 (May 4, 2012),
77 FR 27527.
\4\ See Letters to the Commission from Leonard J. Amoruso,
General Counsel, Knight Capital Group, Inc., dated June 4, 2012
(``Knight Letter''); Kimberly Unger, Executive Director, The
Security Traders Association of New York, Inc., dated June 11, 2012
(``STANY Letter''); Daniel Keegan, Managing Director, Citigroup
Global Markets Inc., dated June 13, 2012 (``Citi Letter''); and John
C. Nagel, Managing Director and General Counsel, Citadel Securities,
dated June 13, 2012 (``Citadel Letter'').
\5\ See Letter to the Commission from Brant K. Brown, Associate
General Counsel, The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.,
dated June 19, 2012 (``FINRA Response Letter'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Description of the Proposal
FINRA's proposal would amend Section 1 of Schedule A to the FINRA
By-Laws to adjust the rate of FINRA's TAF for transactions in Covered
Securities that are equity securities.\6\ The TAF, along with the
Personnel Assessment and the Gross Income Assessment fees, is used to
fund FINRA's regulatory activities.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ Covered Securities are defined in Section 1 of Schedule A to
the FINRA By-Laws as: exchange-registered securities wherever
executed (except debt securities that are not TRACE-Eligible
Securities); OTC Equity Securities; security futures; TRACE-Eligible
Securities (provided that the transaction is a Reportable TRACE
Transaction); and all municipal securities subject to Municipal
Securities Rulemaking Board reporting requirements. The rules
governing the TAF also include a list of exempt transactions. See
FINRA By-Laws, Schedule A, Sec. 1(b)(2).
\7\ See FINRA By-Laws, Schedule A, Sec. 1(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The current TAF rate is $0.000095 per share for each sale of a
Covered Security that is an equity security, with a maximum charge of
$4.75 per trade. This rate, which was implemented by FINRA on March 1,
2012, represented a $0.000005 per share increase over the previously
effective rate of $0.000090 per share, while the per-transaction cap
for Covered Securities that are equity securities increased by $0.25,
from $4.50 to $4.75.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 66287 (February 1,
2012), 77 FR 6161 (February 7, 2012); Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 66276 (January 30, 2012), 77 FR 5613 (February 3, 2012).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the current proposal, FINRA would increase the TAF rate by an
additional $0.000024 per share, from $0.000095 per share to $0.000119
per share, while the per-transaction cap for transactions in Covered
Securities that are equity securities would increase by $1.20, from
$4.75 to $5.95. FINRA intends to make the proposal effective on July 1,
2012.
Additionally, FINRA seeks approval to submit future filings related
to the TAF rate under Section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Act \9\ and Rule 19b-
4(f)(2) thereunder,\10\ rather than under Section 19(b)(2) of the
Act.\11\ When the TAF was first proposed in 2002 to replace the former
NASD Regulatory Fee, several commenters at the time expressed concern
that the TAF rate could be raised at any time without notice and
comment and Commission approval.\12\ The Commission approved the TAF in
part based on representations by NASD that all future changes to the
TAF would
[[Page 38691]]
be filed under Section 19(b)(2) of the Act and thus subject to approval
by the Commission.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A).
\10\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4(f)(2).
\11\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(2).
\12\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 47946 (May 30,
2003), 68 FR 34021 (June 6, 2003).
\13\ See id. at 34024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Summary of Comments and FINRA's Response to Comments
a. Summary of Comments
The Commission received four comments on the proposal, all of which
objected to both the proposed increase in the TAF and FINRA's intention
to file future TAF adjustments under Section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Act.
The commenters shared concern that the proposed increase to the TAF
would disproportionately harm FINRA members that provide liquidity in
covered equity securities.\14\ One of these commenters observed that
the proposed new TAF rate would represent a 138% increase over the rate
that was first implemented in 2002.\15\ This commenter argued that,
because the fee is based on share transaction volume, liquidity
providers are assessed the greatest amount of fees.\16\ Furthermore,
this commenter expressed concern that the proposal would result in an
inequitable allocation of fees among FINRA members and therefore run
afoul of Section 15A(b)(5) of the Act.\17\ Specifically, the commenter
contended that, because 95% of the TAF is generated by transactions in
equity securities, the net result of the TAF is that liquidity
providers that deal in covered equity securities end up funding aspects
of FINRA's regulatory that do not apply to them.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ See Knight Letter at 2-3; STANY Letter at 2 (expressing
particular concern about FINRA members that make markets in OTC
equities securities); Citi and Citadel Letters (joining the Knight
and STANY Letters).
\15\ See Knight Letter at 2.
\16\ See id.
\17\ 15 U.S.C. 78o-3(b)(5).
\18\ See Knight Letter at 2-3. See also STANY Letter at 2
(expressing a similar concern); Citi and Citadel Letters (joining
the Knight and STANY Letters).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The commenters also questioned the structure of FINRA's funding.
One commenter noted that the revenues FINRA derives from the TAF are
subject to the volatility of trading in the equity markets; as a
result, according to this commenter, adequate funding for FINRA's
regulatory program is dependent on FINRA's transaction volume
projections.\19\ Additionally, this commenter believed increasing the
TAF at a time when transaction volume decreases places an especially
difficult burden on trading firms, which operate on thin margins and
are themselves dependent on volume.\20\ Thus, the commenter suggested
that FINRA consider alternatives to the TAF that would be more stable
and equitably apportioned among FINRA members.\21\ Another commenter
also suggested that FINRA consider a funding scheme for its regulatory
programs that more fairly allocates the financial burden of regulation
across asset classes and regulated members.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ See Knight Letter at 2.
\20\ See id. See also STANY Letter at 2 (stating that ``[a]t a
time when trading desks are seeing a marked decline in revenue due
to the decline in volume, we are concerned that an increase in there
[sic] per share fees may cause some firms to go out of business and
will serve as a further disincentive to other firms to continue
making markets or providing liquidity in the markets for OTC equity
securities'').
\21\ See Knight Letter at 3.
\22\ See STANY Letter at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, the commenters objected to FINRA's proposal to file future
adjustments to the TAF under Section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Act, as opposed
to Section 19(b)(2). According to the commenters, allowing FINRA to do
so would limit or eliminate the opportunity for public comment on such
future adjustments.\23\ One commenter stated that those most affected
by adjustments to the TAF rely on the opportunity for public comment as
an appropriate check on FINRA's rate-setting.\24\ Another commenter
contended that transparency is necessary in this context because FINRA
has no competitors and the TAF is not subject to competitive
forces.\25\ Thus, both commenters expressed their belief that a
reasonable period for notice and comment is important to allow FINRA
members the chance for meaningful input.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\ See Knight Letter at 3-4; STANY Letter at 2.
\24\ See Knight Letter at 3-4.
\25\ See STANY Letter at 2.
\26\ See also Citi and Citadel Letters (joining the Knight and
STANY Letters).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. FINRA's Response to Comments
FINRA responded that the proposed adjustment to the TAF is
necessary, reasonable, and equitably allocated among its members, and
by explaining its rationale for the TAF structure.
With respect to the commenters' concerns about the TAF's
disproportionate impact on covered equity security liquidity providers,
FINRA noted that there are three critical factors that it uses to
measure regulatory costs for a member firm: the overall size of the
firm, the level of a firm's trading activity, and the firm's number of
registered representatives. FINRA stated that it has sought to measure
these factors and assess fees accordingly by implementing regulatory
fees that line up with each factor: the Gross Income Assessment Fee,
the TAF, and Personnel Assessment Fee, respectively. According to
FINRA, trading in the equity markets drives a significant portion of
its regulatory costs, and therefore it is equitable to recover some of
those costs from fees generated from equity trading activity.\27\ FINRA
also noted that the TAF rate for other types of securities, like TRACE-
reportable debt securities, is similarly calibrated to be equitably
allocated in a way that corresponds to the costs of FINRA's regulatory
efforts.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\ See FINRA Response Letter at 4. FINRA also stated that it
is cognizant of the fact that its member firms may be experiencing
lower revenues themselves as a result of the decrease in volume, but
its statutory obligations continue to exist in difficult financial
and market environments and it needs adequate resources to
effectively carry out its responsibilities. See id. at 3.
\28\ FINRA noted that when the TAF was expanded to TRACE-
reportable debt securities, it set the rate so that the portion of
TAF revenue received on debt transactions reflected FINRA's
regulatory efforts in the fixed income market. See id. at 4-5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second, with respect to the structure of FINRA's funding, FINRA
noted that the TAF is one of three types of assessments--the other two
are the Gross Income Assessment and the Personnel Assessment. According
to FINRA, the Gross Income Assessment, which is not dependent on market
activity, is the most important component of FINRA's regulatory
funding, and in 2011 the TAF represented only 33% of FINRA's total
member regulatory fees and assessments.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ See id. at 2-3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FINRA stated that it strives to operate on a cash-flow-neutral
basis \30\ and routinely reexamines its fee structure to consider
alternative means to reasonably and equitably allocate fees in a method
that is efficient, sustainable, and predictable.\31\ FINRA stated that
in 2009, for example, it increased the Personnel Assessment fee and
revised its calculation of the Gross Income Assessment to achieve a
more consistent and predictable funding scheme, while also engaging in
cost-control measures.\32\ According to FINRA, the currently proposed
adjustment--an increase to the TAF--is necessary in light of current
market conditions so that FINRA can properly fund its regulatory
mission.\33\ FINRA represents, however, that if market volume were to
increase, it would decrease the TAF rate accordingly.\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\ See id. at 3.
\31\ See id. at 6.
\32\ See id.
\33\ See id. at 3.
\34\ See id. at 3, 7-8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 38692]]
Finally, with respect to filing future amendments to the TAF under
Section 19(b)(3)(A), FINRA stated that Section 19(b)(3)(A) and Rule
19b-4(f)(2) thereunder specifically contemplate such types of fee
filings. Furthermore, FINRA noted that filing adjustments to the TAF
under Section 19(b)(3)(A) would allow it to adjust rates in response to
market volatility--both up and down--more efficiently, and would not
run afoul of the rulemaking system's set of checks and balances
established in the Act and the SEC's rules thereunder.
IV. Discussion and Commission's Findings
After carefully considering the proposed rule change, the comments
submitted, and FINRA's response to the comments, the Commission finds
that the proposed rule change is consistent with the requirements of
the Act and the rules and regulations thereunder applicable to a
national securities association.\35\ In particular, the Commission
finds that the proposal is consistent with Section 15A(b)(5) of the
Act,\36\ which requires, among other things, that FINRA rules provide
for the equitable allocation of reasonable dues, fees, and other
charges among members and issuers and other persons using any facility
or system that FINRA operates or controls. The Commission believes that
the proposal is reasonably designed to secure adequate funding to
support FINRA's regulatory duties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\ In approving the proposal, the Commission has considered
the proposed rule's impact on efficiency, competition, and capital
formation. See 15 U.S.C. 78c(f).
\36\ 15 U.S.C. 78o-3(b)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FINRA has represented that its proposed increases to the TAF rate
and per-transaction cap are necessary to adequately fund FINRA's member
regulatory obligations, and that the proposed increase to the TAF, like
prior adjustments, seeks to remain revenue neutral to FINRA. Although
commenters argue that the proposal would disproportionately harm firms
that provide liquidity in covered equity securities and that the TAF is
subject to volatility in the equity markets, the Commission agrees with
FINRA that adjusting the TAF rate and the per-transaction cap as
proposed is warranted. FINRA represented that trading in equity markets
drives a significant portion of its regulatory costs, and therefore it
is equitable to recover some of those costs from fees generated from
equity trading activity. Moreover, as the Commission stated in 2009,
Adequate regulatory funding is critical to FINRA's ability to
meet [its] statutory requirements. While some member firms
understandably question whether it is reasonable for FINRA to
increase regulatory fees at a time when the securities industry has
faced declining revenues as a result of the economic downturn, it is
incumbent on FINRA to continue to support a robust regulatory
program irrespective of market events.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\ Securities Exchange Act Release No. 61042 (November 20,
2009), 74 FR 62616, 62818 (November 30, 2009).
Furthermore, the Commission notes that the TAF constitutes only a
portion of the fees that FINRA charges members to support its
regulatory function. FINRA also charges a Gross Income Assessment Fee
and a Personnel Assessment Fee, which are not directly correlated to
equity trading volumes.
Finally, the Commission finds that FINRA may, consistent with the
Act, submit future filings to adjust the TAF rate and the per-
transaction fee cap for immediate effectiveness under Section
19(b)(3)(A) of the Act. Section 19(b)(3)(A)(ii) allows an SRO to file
an immediately effective proposed rule change if such filing is
designated as ``establishing or changing a due, fee, or other charge
imposed by the self-regulatory organization.'' \38\ Proposed
adjustments to the TAF rate and per-transaction fee cap clearly fall
within the scope of this provision.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A)(ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Commission notes that commenter concerns regarding the
opportunity to comment on proposed TAF adjustments are mitigated by the
fact that such filings would still be subject to comment and Commission
review even when filed under Section 19(b)(3)(A). The Commission
summarily may temporarily suspend such a proposed rule change within 60
days of filing ``if it appears to the Commission that such action is
necessary or appropriate in the public interest, for the protection of
investors, or otherwise in furtherance of the purposes of [the Act].''
\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(C).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the reasons stated above, the Commission finds that the
proposed rule change is consistent with the Act and the rules and
regulations thereunder.
V. Conclusion
It is therefore ordered, pursuant to Section 19(b)(2) of the
Act,\40\ that the proposed rule change (SR-FINRA-2012-023) be, and
hereby is, approved.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\40\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(2).
For the Commission, by the Division of Trading and Markets,
pursuant to delegated authority.\41\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\ 17 CFR 200.30-3(a)(12).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kevin M. O'Neill,
Deputy Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2012-15806 Filed 6-27-12; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P