[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 164 (Wednesday, August 24, 2011)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 52892-52899]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-21636]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
10 CFR Part 430
[Docket No. EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016]
RIN 1904-AB50
Energy Conservation Program: Energy Conservation Standards for
Fluorescent Lamp Ballasts
AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of
Energy.
ACTION: Notice of data availability and request for public comment.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: On April 11, 2011, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)
published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR) proposing new and
amended standards for fluorescent lamp ballasts (ballasts) pursuant to
the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1975 (EPCA). During the
subsequent public meeting and in written comments, stakeholders
provided additional data and raised concerns regarding the test data
DOE used in support of the NOPR and DOE's approach to accounting for
measurement variation and compliance certification requirements. In
response to several of those comments, DOE conducted additional testing
and is publishing this notice to: announce the availability of
additional data provided by the National Electrical Manufacturers
Association (NEMA) and additional DOE test data; address the
differences between the DOE test data and the data submitted by NEMA;
describe the methodological changes DOE is considering based on the
additional data and present efficiency levels developed using the
revised methodology and all available test data; and request public
comment on the updated analyses, as
[[Page 52893]]
well as the submission of data and other relevant information.
DATES: DOE will accept comments, data, and information regarding this
notice of data availability submitted no later than September 14, 2011.
See section VI, ``Public Participation,'' of this notice for details.
ADDRESSES: Any comments submitted must identify the notice of data
availability (NODA) for fluorescent lamp ballasts and provide the
docket number EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 and/or Regulatory Information
Number (RIN) 1904-AB50. Comments may be submitted using any of the
following methods:
1. Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov. Follow
the instructions for submitting comments.
2. E-mail: [email protected]. Include the Docket
Number EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016 and/or RIN number 1904-AB50 in the subject
line of the message.
3. Postal Mail: Ms. Brenda Edwards, U.S. Department of Energy,
Building Technologies Program, Mailstop EE-2J, 1000 Independence
Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20585-0121. If possible, please submit all
items on a compact disc (CD), in which case it is not necessary to
include printed copies.
4. Hand Delivery/Courier: Ms. Brenda Edwards, U.S. Department of
Energy, Building Technologies Program, 950 L'Enfant Plaza, SW., Suite
600, Washington, DC 20024. Telephone: (202) 586-2945. If possible,
please submit all items on a CD, in which case it is not necessary to
include printed copies.
No telefacsimilies (faxes) will be accepted. For detailed
instructions on submitting comments and additional information on the
rulemaking process, see section VI of this document (Public
Participation).
Docket: The docket is available for review at http://www.regulations.gov, including Federal Register notices, comments, and
other supporting documents/materials. All documents in the docket are
listed in the http://www.regulations.gov index. However, not all
documents listed in the index may be publicly available, such as
information that is exempt from public disclosure.
A link to the docket Web page can be found at: http://www.regulations.gov. The http://www.regulations.gov Web page contains a
link to the docket for this notice, along with simple instructions on
how to access all documents, including public comments, in the docket.
See section VI.A for further information on how to submit comments
through http://www.regulations.gov.
For further information on how to submit a comment or review other
public comments and the docket, contact Ms. Brenda Edwards at (202)
586-2945 or by e-mail: [email protected].
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Dr. Tina Kaarsberg, U.S. Department of
Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Building
Technologies Program, EE-2J, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington,
DC 20585-0121. Telephone: (202) 287-1393. E-mail:
[email protected].
Ms. Elizabeth Kohl, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of the
General Counsel, GC-71, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC
20585-0121. Telephone: (202) 586-7796. E-mail:
[email protected].
For information on how to submit or review public comments, contact
Ms. Brenda Edwards, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy
Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Building Technologies Program,
Mailstop EE-2J, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20585-
0121. Telephone: (202) 586-2945. E-mail: [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Table of Contents
I. Introduction
II. Additional Data
III. Comparison of NEMA-Provided Data and DOE Data
A. NEMA Reduction Factor
B. Sample Size
C. Lab Accreditation
D. Measured Versus Calculated BLE
E. Total Lamp Arc Power Approximations
IV. Accounting for Variation and Compliance Certification Procedures
A. Compliance Certification Requirements and Design Variation
B. Measurement Variation
V. Efficiency Levels
A. Functional Form
B. Preliminary Efficiency Levels
1. IS and RS Ballasts
2. PS Ballasts
3. Eight-Foot HO Ballasts
4. Sign Ballasts
5. Residential Ballasts
VI. Public Participation
A. Submission of Comments
B. Issues on Which DOE Seeks Comment
VII. Approval of the Office of the Secretary
I. Introduction
The EPCA establishes energy conservation standards for certain
ballasts and requires that DOE conduct two cycles of rulemaking to
determine whether to amend the standards for ballasts, including
whether to adopt standards for additional ballasts. (42 U.S.C.
6295(g)(5)-(8)) To complete the first of these rulemakings, DOE
published the 2000 Ballast Rule. 65 FR 56740 (Sept. 19, 2000). To
complete the second rulemaking, DOE is considering amendments to the
existing standards for ballasts and evaluating standards for additional
ballasts.
In April 2011, DOE published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR)
that proposed new and amended energy conservation standards for
fluorescent lamp ballasts (hereafter the April 2011 NOPR). 76 FR 20090.
In conjunction with the NOPR, DOE also published on its Web site the
complete technical support document (TSD) for the proposed rule, which
described the analyses DOE conducted and included technical
documentation for each analysis. The TSD also included the engineering
analysis spreadsheets, the life cycle cost (LCC) spreadsheet, the
national impact analysis spreadsheet, and the manufacturer impact
analysis (MIA) spreadsheet.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ The spreadsheets developed for this rulemaking proceeding
are available at: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOE held a public meeting on May 10, 2011, to hear oral comments on
and solicit information relevant to the proposed rule (hereafter the
May 2011 public meeting). At this meeting, NEMA presented test data
that they found inconsistent with the data collected by DOE and that
could affect the standards established in the final rule. In general,
NEMA's ballast luminous efficiency (BLE) values appeared to be lower
than those obtained by DOE. These observations caused NEMA to question
the validity of the data collected by DOE for the April 2011 NOPR. NEMA
specifically cited lab accreditation, sample size, and calculations of
BLE as potential sources of the discrepancies they observed. Other
stakeholders agreed that there were discrepancies between the two data
sets and emphasized the importance of identifying the source of the
differences. In addition, DOE received comments on the methodology used
to account for compliance certification requirements, design variation,
and measurement variation. DOE also received comments on the
appropriate shape of DOE's proposed efficiency level curves.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ Comments referenced here are available in the docket for
this rulemaking, which can be found at regulations.gov under docket
number EERE-2007-BT-STD-0016.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since the publication of the NOPR, DOE has analyzed NEMA's data and
conducted additional testing to enhance
[[Page 52894]]
its analysis. In order to incorporate these additional results, DOE has
modified slightly its approach to the engineering analysis and thus is
considering efficiency levels that differ from those presented in the
April 2011 NOPR.
DOE is publishing today's NODA to: (1) Announce the availability of
the additional NEMA test data and the additional test data developed by
DOE; (2) address the differences between test data obtained by DOE and
test data submitted by NEMA; (3) describe the methodological changes
DOE is considering based on the additional data and present efficiency
levels developed using the revised methodology and all available test
data; and (4) request public comment on these analyses, as well as the
submission of other relevant information. The following sections
describe the additional data and revised methodology in more detail.
After considering the comments received, DOE will publish a final rule
by October 28, 2011.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ Under the consolidated Consent Decree in New York v. Bodman,
No. 05 Civ. 7807 (S.D.N.Y. filed Sept. 7, 2005) and Natural
Resources Defense Council v. Bodman, No. 05 Civ. 7808 (S.D.N.Y.
filed Sept. 7, 2005), the U.S. Department of Energy was required to
publish a final rule amending energy conservation standards for
fluorescent lamp ballasts no later than June 30, 2011. The consent
decree was later modified, requiring DOE to publish a final rule no
later than October 28, 2011.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Additional Data
For the April 2011 NOPR, DOE tested more than 450 ballasts to
develop proposed energy conservation standards. At the time the NOPR
was published, DOE posted test data to its public Web site in Appendix
5C of the TSD. Appendix 5C contained a listing of all ballast models
tested at DOE's primary lab for the April 2011 NOPR, including
identifying characteristics such as lamp type operated, number of lamps
operated, starting method, ballast factor, input voltage, and catalog
performance value. For each ballast model, DOE also reported average
\4\ tested values for input power, total lamp arc power, and BLE.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ The average across several samples for each model number.
\5\ DOE obtained these values in accordance with the active mode
test procedure in Appendix Q1 of 10 CFR part 430.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the May 2011 public meeting, NEMA presented data collected from
several manufacturers. These test results were contained in a power
point presentation that was subsequently posted to the public meeting
Web site (http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_ballasts_nopr_public_meeting.html). NEMA's
data included average BLE values from three manufacturers that were
reduced by 0.8 percent to account for compliance certification
requirements. Attendees of the public meeting noted that the BLE values
of the most efficient ballast models tested by NEMA appeared to be less
than the most efficient ballast models tested by DOE. These
stakeholders emphasized the importance of identifying the reasons for
the differences between the two data sets. In addition, several
stakeholders requested that DOE provide more information, including
data for individual ballast samples and test results from other labs at
which testing was conducted. NEMA also noted that about 60 percent of
DOE's test data represented ballast models with less than four tested
samples, which is not consistent with the minimum number of samples
required to demonstrate compliance with DOE's standards. The California
Utilities (CA Utilities) stated that if possible, DOE should conduct
testing of four or more samples to more accurately reflect the testing
process that must be completed by manufacturers for certification
purposes.
Following the May 2011 public meeting, DOE posted to the public
meeting Web site a more comprehensive set of test data used to develop
the April 2011 NOPR, which specified ballasts by serial numbers, added
round robin test results, and included results for each sample tested,
rather than the average across several samples for each model number.
DOE also purchased and tested additional ballasts to increase tested
models' sample size to a minimum of four samples consistent with
compliance certification requirements in 10 CFR 429.26. DOE also tested
additional ballast models, particularly for sign ballasts and
residential ballasts, to gain more market information about these
ballasts. This NODA announces the availability of all available test
data--the NEMA-provided data, the data utilized for the April 2011
NOPR, and the results of additional testing conducted after publication
of the April 2011 NOPR--on DOE's Web site: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts.html.
III. Comparison of NEMA-Provided Data and DOE Data
At the May 2011 public meeting, NEMA presented test results for its
highest efficiency NEMA Premium products. NEMA explained that the data
contained in the presentation represented the mean of four or five
samples that was then decreased by 0.8 percent to account for
compliance requirements. NEMA stated that this reduction, consistent
with DOE's proposed reduction to efficiency levels in the April 2011
NOPR, was calculated using the same methods that are required to
certify with new standards.
In addition to their observation that the manufacturer-provided
data was lower in efficiency than DOE's data, NEMA expressed concern
regarding DOE's data collection methods. NEMA commented that the number
of samples DOE tested for several ballast models was too small,
potentially resulting in test data not representative of the mean
efficiencies of the ballast model's population. They pointed out that
for the majority of ballast models included in the analysis, DOE tested
fewer than four samples, which is not consistent with the minimum
number of samples required to demonstrate compliance with DOE's
standards. NEMA also commented that the difference between the data it
collected and DOE's results may be due to DOE's labs not having proper
accreditation. Furthermore, NEMA stated that the measured BLEs reported
in appendix 5C of the NOPR TSD were not consistent with the BLEs
calculated by NEMA (using data from the same appendix).
Following the May 2011 public meeting, several manufacturers
provided the model numbers and corresponding efficiencies for the
ballasts included in NEMA's data set. Upon receiving this information,
DOE conducted a comparative analysis and evaluated potential sources
for the apparent discrepancies between the DOE and NEMA data sets: The
reduction factor NEMA applied to its average BLE values, sample size,
lab accreditation, the calculation of BLE, and the arc powers reported
for NEMA's results.
After considering all of the potential sources, discussed in the
following sections, DOE preliminarily concludes that, after removing
NEMA's reduction factor as discussed in section III.A., the remaining
differences between the two data sets arise primarily from normal
measurement variation. This remaining variation generally falls within
the expected measurement variation of 2.5 percent of the
mean efficiency, suggested by NEMA. Additional testing has increased
sample size such that it is consistent with compliance certification
requirements. DOE has also confirmed that its testing was conducted in
accordance with the active mode test procedure and that its
calculations of BLE are accurate.
[[Page 52895]]
A. NEMA Reduction Factor
As stated earlier, the ballast efficiencies presented by NEMA at
the May 2011 public meeting represent the mean of four or five samples
decreased by 0.8 percent. To calculate this 0.8 reduction factor, NEMA
referred DOE to an analysis NEMA conducted and submitted as a comment.
In that analysis, NEMA calculated the 0.8 percent reduction factor
based on an application of the certification equation described in 10
CFR 429.26. NEMA assumed that each sample set's three standard
deviation spread was equal to five percent of the mean efficiency (2.5
percent for design variation and 2.5 percent for measurement
variation). NEMA then calculated a mean efficiency adjustment factor
(for sample sizes of four and five) by inserting this standard
deviation into the certification equation. This adjustment factor
represented an estimate of the percent difference between the sample
mean and the value NEMA anticipated reporting to DOE for certification.
To understand potential discrepancies between NEMA and DOE's test
data, it is necessary to ensure that similar calculation methodologies
have been undertaken for the two data sets. Therefore, for the purpose
of comparing the efficiency data, DOE removes the 0.8 percent reduction
from NEMA's presented ballast efficiencies, resulting in values that
represent mean tested efficiencies. These efficiency values are
analogous to DOE's mean tested efficiencies presented in the NOPR.
However, DOE recognizes the importance of accounting for measurement
variation and certification requirements in establishing efficiency
levels. Additional discussion of these issues and how DOE is
considering addressing them is provided in section IV.
B. Sample Size
NEMA noted that less than 40 percent of DOE's test data for the
April 2011 NOPR represented ballast models with four or more tested
samples. They stated that the large standard deviation in efficiency
among DOE's samples, as well as the discrepancy in tested values versus
catalog reported values, indicates that DOE potentially did not use a
sufficient number of samples to calculate the mean efficiencies of the
ballast models analyzed. The California Utilities (CA Utilities) stated
that if possible, DOE should conduct testing of four or more samples
per ballast model to more accurately reflect the testing process that
must be completed by manufacturers for certification purposes.
Since the publication of the April 2011 NOPR, DOE has conducted
additional testing to increase the sample size of selected ballast
models. Over 90 percent of tested ballast models now have a minimum of
four samples. Only in those cases where models have been discontinued
or were unavailable for purchase was DOE unable to test a minimum of
four samples.
C. Lab Accreditation
NEMA also commented that the difference between the data it
collected and DOE's results may be due to DOE's labs not having proper
accreditation. DOE notes that 10 CFR 430.25 requires testing of
fluorescent lamp ballasts to be performed in accordance with Appendix
Q1 of 10 CFR part 430 subpart B by test laboratories accredited by
National Volunteer Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP) or a NVLAP-
recognized organization, Underwriter Laboratories, or Council of Canada
in accordance with ISO 17025. 76 FR 25211, 25219 (May 4, 2011). ISO
17025 is an international standard that outlines general requirements
for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. NVLAP
operates an accreditation system that requires applicant laboratories
to be assessed against all ISO 17025 requirements.
DOE has contacted both test laboratories utilized for DOE testing
and verified each is properly accredited and that all testing was
conducted in accordance with the active mode test procedure in Appendix
Q1. However, DOE recognizes that lab-to-lab variation can still be
present among NVLAP-accredited test labs following the prescribed test
procedure. DOE accounts for lab-to-lab variation in the establishment
of efficiency levels as described in section IV.B.
D. Measured Versus Calculated BLE
NEMA identified several samples in DOE's test data for which the
measured BLE reported in appendix 5C of the NOPR TSD was not consistent
with the BLE calculated by NEMA. Though some of the differences were
small, NEMA provided examples of four ballast models with differences
up to 8 percent.
To address the small discrepancies, DOE notes that the information
provided by NEMA is consistent with calculating the BLE values by
dividing the average arc power of all samples by the average input
power of all samples. NEMA's method is not consistent with the active
mode test procedure. In contrast, DOE's measured BLE reported in
appendix 5C of the TSD was determined, as required in the test
procedure, by averaging the BLE of each individual sample. Based on
DOE's analysis, this difference in methodology accounts for the small
discrepancies observed between the values reported in appendix 5C and
those calculated by NEMA.
DOE also worked to resolve the larger differences cited by NEMA in
their presentation at the May 2011 meeting. DOE identified six samples
with measured-versus-calculated BLE differences ranging from 7.8 to 8.0
percentage points, which included the specific examples cited by NEMA.
These six samples were all magnetic ballasts; in accordance with active
mode test procedure (see Table A, Appendix Q1 of 10 CFR part 430
subpart B), DOE calculated BLE by reducing the measured ballast
efficiency (lamp arc power divided by ballast input power) by a
frequency adjustment factor (1.00 for high-frequency ballasts and
values ranging from 0.93 to 0.95 for low-frequency ballasts). These
larger discrepancies are consistent with NEMA not including this
adjustment factor in its calculation of BLE. Thus, DOE believes its
measured BLE values are correctly calculated and consistent with the
active mode test procedure.
E. Total Lamp Arc Power Approximations
Due to the relationship between total lamp arc power and ballast
efficiency, in the NOPR, DOE proposed establishing efficiency levels as
logarithmic equations dependent on measured total lamp arc power. When
NEMA plotted their test data against the DOE proposed efficiency
levels, however, NEMA paired their ballast efficiency test data with
approximated total lamp arc powers rather than measured arc powers. DOE
found these approximations to be higher than typical test results for
similar ballast types in DOE's data set, with differences as high as
27.6 percent overall. As this discrepancy could potentially cause
NEMA's test data to appear to have artificially lower efficiencies
relative to DOE's efficiency levels, DOE has revised NEMA's approximate
lamp arc powers using American National Standards Institute (ANSI)
rated high frequency lamp arc powers to calculate total expected lamp
arc power. These lamp arc powers better align with expected total lamp
arc powers for similar ballast types.
For example, NEMA associated the efficiency of a ballast with a
normal ballast factor that operates two 4-foot medium bipin (MBP) T8
lamps with an arc power of 55 W. To correct the
[[Page 52896]]
approximated arc power, DOE calculated the typical arc power (51 W) by
multiplying the ANSI-specified high frequency arc wattage for an F32T8
lamp (29 W) by the number of lamps operated (2) and the most common
normal ballast factor (0.88). DOE used this calculated arc power when
comparing its efficiency levels to the manufacturer-provided data as
discussed in section V.
IV. Accounting for Variation and Compliance Certification Procedures
In the April 2011 NOPR, DOE accounted for measurement variation and
certification requirements by calculating reduction factors for each
and adjusting the efficiency levels accordingly. DOE calculated a 0.6
percent reduction factor for measurement variation by comparing the
data from the primary laboratory, which conducted the majority of DOE's
testing, with data from its secondary laboratory, which tested a
limited number of identical samples. DOE applied the 0.6 percent
measurement variation reduction to the efficiency curves so that the
standard level could, on average, be met by ballasts tested at the less
efficient lab. To account for certification requirements, DOE
calculated the difference between the output of the compliance
certification equation in 10 CFR 429.26 and the sample mean of DOE's
test data to be 0.2 percent. As DOE's certification requirements at 10
CFR 429.26 require manufacturers to report the lower of these two
values, DOE reduced the efficiency levels, based on average BLEs, by
this value. Using the data that DOE made available immediately
following the May 2011 public meeting, both NEMA and the CA Utilities
submitted analyses to determine how DOE's data should be adjusted to
account for certification requirements and measurement variation.
NEMA's analysis used an assumed design variation and a calculated
measurement variation in the compliance certification equation to
adjust each ballast efficiency data point. NEMA then suggested that DOE
base its efficiency levels on these adjusted data points rather than
mean efficiency values. Specifically, NEMA determined the mean BLE for
each ballast model by averaging all tested values of that particular
model. NEMA then calculated the maximum measurement variation across
labs for each category of fluorescent lamp ballast (e.g., 4-foot MBP,
4-foot miniature bipin (MiniBP), or 8-foot recessed double contact
(RDC) high output (HO)). NEMA added this highest calculated measurement
variation for each ballast type to a 2.5 percent assumed design
tolerance to characterize the total variation. NEMA then entered these
variations into the compliance equation to calculate a reduction factor
based on sample size of each tested model.
The CA Utilities also conducted an analysis on the data DOE
provided following the May 2011 public meeting. They agreed with NEMA
that compliance certification requirements should be considered when
assessing whether products will meet each standard level. However, they
pointed out that NEMA had employed methods to characterize the reported
value that were not consistent with the requirements specified in 10
CFR 429.26. Instead, the CA Utilities used individual samples of DOE's
efficiency data to calculate both the sample mean and the value
determined by the compliance certification equation in 10 CFR 429.26.
Then, as directed by the compliance certification regulations, they
represented reported efficiency as the lower of the two values. They
suggested that DOE base its efficiency levels on these reported values.
Consistent with the April 2011 NOPR, DOE recognizes the importance
of considering the variation present in the test data when developing
efficiency levels. DOE acknowledges that due to design variation, the
reported value for compliance certification may deviate from the sample
mean and must be accounted for. As described in the following sections,
DOE is considering modifying its approach to account for variation and
compliance certification procedures based on the comments provided.
A. Compliance Certification Requirements and Design Variation
DOE agrees with both NEMA and the CA Utilities that standard levels
should account for the procedures manufacturers must follow to certify
compliance with standards. As stated earlier, 10 CFR 429.26 requires
manufacturers to test a minimum of four fluorescent lamp ballasts and
report the minimum of either the mean efficiency of the samples or the
output of a compliance certification equation based on the lower 99
percent confidence limit of the sample. The lower 99 percent confidence
limit equation requires a calculation of the standard deviation of the
sample set to account for design variation.
Both the NEMA and CA Utilities approaches recommend that, in order
to develop efficiency levels, DOE should adjust its mean efficiency
data points to represent values similar to those manufacturers would
report to DOE for compliance certification. However, their approaches
differ in how they computed the standard deviation to input into the
compliance certification equation. The CA Utilities calculated the
standard deviation among all samples of a particular ballast model
tested at a single lab. NEMA, however, calculated the standard
deviation by assuming a 2.5 percent design variation and then adding an
additional measurement variation based on DOE's lab-to-lab test data
for each ballast category.
DOE disagrees with NEMA's method of applying the compliance
certification requirements. Firstly, the test procedure's compliance
requirements direct manufacturers to calculate the standard deviation
of the tested sample, rather than an assumed population standard
deviation. Secondly, this calculation would likely not include data
from more than one lab unless manufacturers chose to test their samples
of a single ballast model at more than one location. DOE is considering
accounting for measurement (specifically lab-to-lab) variation as a
separate adjustment to efficiency levels as discussed below in section
IV.B.
The CA Utilities evaluated both the sample mean and compliance
equation for each ballast model and compared the lower of the two, the
reported value, to the standard level. DOE believes the CA Utilities
approach for accounting for compliance certification requirements is
more consistent with the procedures laid out in 10 CFR 429.26 and is
therefore considering using this methodology in the final rule. To
facilitate this approach, as discussed earlier, DOE conducted
additional testing since publication of the NOPR to increase the sample
size of several ballast models in accordance with compliance
certification requirements. To account for both certification
requirements, DOE has calculated a new data set which represents the
reported value for all ballast models. DOE used these reported values
to develop the efficiency levels described in section V of today's
NODA.
B. Measurement Variation
DOE is also considering revising its methodology to account for
measurement variation, specifically lab-to-lab variation. DOE received
test data from NEMA following the May 2011 public meeting and also
received test data from NEMA-member manufacturers. The data from
manufacturers allowed DOE to match NEMA test data with the same ballast
models tested at DOE's primary and
[[Page 52897]]
secondary labs. Using the model-specific test data supplied by several
manufacturers (representative of three different manufacturer labs) and
DOE's BLE data (representative of the two labs used by DOE), DOE
determined that on average, the BLE test data from DOE's primary lab
was 0.7 percent more efficient than the average test lab. DOE
attributes this offset to systematic lab-to-lab variation and therefore
is considering reducing the efficiency levels by 0.7 percent so that
they are representative of ballasts tested at the average test lab.
This approach is slightly different than that taken in the April 2011
NOPR, which applied a 0.6 percent reduction to efficiency levels,
representing the average offset between DOE's primary lab and the least
efficient lab (in that case, DOE's secondary lab). DOE believes that
adjusting efficiency levels so that they represent the average test lab
better characterizes the mean performance of products currently being
sold.
V. Efficiency Levels
A. Equation
In the NOPR, DOE proposed establishing efficiency levels as
logarithmic equations dependent on total lamp arc power. DOE developed
this logarithmic relationship by empirically fitting curves to
manufacturer product lines present in DOE's test data. DOE is
considering changing the contour of the efficiency levels for the final
rule to better fit all of the available data. Upon analysis, NEMA's
test data show a larger efficiency decrease at lower powers than DOE's
data indicate. Although DOE and NEMA generally tested the same types of
ballasts, NEMA tested more permutations of ballast factor and number of
lamps for each product line, particularly at lower wattages. For
example, NEMA's data contained BLE values for 1-lamp 4-foot MBP
ballasts with both low and high ballast factors, whereas DOE's data
included 1-lamp 4-foot MBP ballasts with only normal ballast factors.
Therefore, based on an application of several equation forms of
efficiency levels, DOE concluded that a power law equation fits both
the NEMA data and DOE's data better than the logarithmic relationship
proposed in the April 2011 NOPR. A power law equation takes the form:
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TP24AU11.001
Where: Power = total measured lamp arc power
Because the NEMA data represents the most complete product lines
and thus may represent a more accurate depiction of a BLE-lamp arc
power relationship than DOE's initial test data, DOE fit power law
regressions to the NEMA test data to calculate the exponent ``C.'' For
the instant start and rapid start (IS/RS) ballasts, DOE found the
exponent ``C'' to be 0.25. The exponent 0.25 is also a quantity used in
relating power to relative losses (analog of efficiency) for
distribution transformers, and fluorescent lamp ballasts similarly
employ transformers and inductors. The programmed start (PS) NEMA data,
however, suggested a different exponent for ballasts that use the PS
starting method. DOE believes that this alternate shape is attributable
to the PS ballasts' higher fixed losses due to internal control
circuitry and heating of lamp electrodes (cathode heating). As these
losses are a larger proportion of total losses at lower powers, the PS
product classes have a steeper slope across the range of wattages.
Using NEMA's data for PS ballasts, DOE found the exponent ``C'' to be
0.37.
With exponents set for the two starting method categories, DOE fit
the power law equation to the reported value data (calculated in
accordance with 10 CFR 429.26 as discussed in section IV.A) by
adjusting the coefficient ``B'' to delineate among criteria such as
different product lines, ballasts that operate different lamp types,
and other clusters in efficiency data. The most efficient (maximum
technologically feasible) efficiency levels closely approximate the
NOPR proposals for the highest wattages, but better follow product line
efficiency trends at lower wattages.
B. Preliminary Efficiency Levels
Using the methodology described in the previous section, DOE
developed a complete set of efficiency levels for this NODA, which are
being considered for the final rule. DOE developed power law curve-fits
based on the DOE test data. Then to develop efficiency levels, DOE
applied a lab-to-lab adjustment factor (derived from all available test
data) to these curve-fits (as discussed in section IV.B). In addition,
DOE compared the resulting efficiency levels against the NEMA data to
confirm the impacts of the efficiency levels on product availability
indicated by the analysis of the DOE data. The following sections
describe the efficiency levels considered for each representative
product class. An Excel spreadsheet summarizing these levels is
available on DOE's Web site: http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_lamp_ballasts.html. The
final rule and accompanying TSD will include the complete downstream
analyses on these levels and results.
1. IS and RS Ballasts
DOE developed three efficiency levels for the IS/RS product class.
EL1 was designed to eliminate 4-foot MBP T12 ballasts while allowing 4-
foot MBP T8 ballast and 8-foot slimline ballasts to comply with energy
conservation standards. EL2 corresponds to a level which allows the
highest-efficiency product lines from each of the four major ballast
manufacturers to comply. DOE defines a full product line as spanning a
sufficient diversity of products (spanning several ballast factors,
numbers of lamps per ballast, and types of lamps operated). EL3 is the
maximum technologically feasible (max tech) level which DOE defines for
fluorescent lamp ballasts as the highest level, regardless of
manufacturer, that is technologically feasible for a sufficient
diversity of commercially available products. Use of those criteria
results in an EL3 with which nearly two manufacturer product lines
comply.
2. PS Ballasts
DOE developed three efficiency levels for the PS product class. The
least efficient level (EL1) was designed to eliminate the lowest
efficiency 4-foot MBP, 4-foot T5 high output, and 4-foot T5 standard
output PS ballasts. This also corresponds to a level at which each of
the four major fluorescent lamp ballast manufacturers maintain a
diversity of products. EL2 allows full product lines from two major
manufacturers. Finally, EL3, the maximum technologically feasible
level, was designed to represent the most efficient PS ballasts tested
by DOE. EL3 is the highest level that allows one full line of products,
regardless of manufacturer.
3. Eight-Foot HO Ballasts
For the 8-foot HO IS/RS product class, DOE developed three
efficiency levels. For this product class, DOE tested ballasts that
operate two lamps, the most common lamp-and-ballast combination. EL1
was designed to just allow the least efficient T12 electronic ballasts,
eliminating magnetic ballasts. EL2 allows the least efficient T8
ballast tested and eliminates the vast majority of T12 electronic
ballasts. Finally, EL3 was designed to just allow the most efficient T8
ballast tested by DOE.
[[Page 52898]]
4. Sign Ballasts
The sign ballast market comprises primarily magnetic and electronic
ballasts that operate T12 HO lamps. DOE tested sign ballasts that
operate up to one, two, three, four, or six 8-foot T12 HO lamps. The
test data showed that sign ballasts exist at two levels of efficiency.
Therefore, DOE analyzed a baseline and one efficiency level above that
baseline. EL1 was designed to allow a full line of electronic sign
ballasts, including ballasts that operate one through six lamps.
5. Residential Ballasts
In the April 2011 NOPR, DOE had proposed that both residential and
commercial ballasts could achieve similar levels of efficiency at the
highest levels analyzed. Based on the similarity in efficiency, DOE
included both ballast types in the same product class. However, for the
final rule, after conducting additional testing which indicate that 4-
lamp residential ballasts may not be able to achieve the same levels as
commercial ballasts, DOE is considering a separate product class for
residential ballasts. The additional data for residential ballasts is
also available at http://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/fluorescent_ballasts_nopr_public_meeting.html. Consequently, DOE has derived and is considering two
separate efficiency levels for residential ballasts to incorporate the
new data. EL1 was designed to just allow the least efficient T8
ballasts, eliminating T12 residential ballasts. EL2, the maximum
technology feasible level, is the highest level that allows a full
range of T8 products (including both two- and four-lamp ballasts) to
comply.
VI. Public Participation
A. Submission of Comments
DOE will accept comments, data, and information regarding this NODA
no later than the date provided in the DATES section at the beginning
of this notice. Interested parties may submit comments, data, and other
information using any of the methods described in the ADDRESSES section
at the beginning of this notice.
Submitting comments via http://www.regulations.gov. The http://www.regulations.gov Web page will require you to provide your name and
contact information. Your contact information will be viewable to DOE
Building Technologies staff only. Your contact information will not be
publicly viewable except for your first and last names, organization
name (if any), and submitter representative name (if any). If your
comment is not processed properly because of technical difficulties,
DOE will use this information to contact you. If DOE cannot read your
comment due to technical difficulties and cannot contact you for
clarification, DOE may not be able to consider your comment.
However, your contact information will be publicly viewable if you
include it in the comment itself or in any documents attached to your
comment. Any information that you do not want to be publicly viewable
should not be included in your comment, nor in any document attached to
your comment. Otherwise, persons viewing comments will see only first
and last names, organization names, correspondence containing comments,
and any documents submitted with the comments.
Do not submit to http://www.regulations.gov information for which
disclosure is restricted by statute, such as trade secrets and
commercial or financial information (hereinafter referred to as
Confidential Business Information (CBI)). Comments submitted through
http://www.regulations.gov cannot be claimed as CBI. Comments received
through the Web site will waive any CBI claims for the information
submitted. For information on submitting CBI, see the Confidential
Business Information section below.
DOE processes submissions made through http://www.regulations.gov
before posting. Normally, comments will be posted within a few days of
being submitted. However, if large volumes of comments are being
processed simultaneously, your comment may not be viewable for up to
several weeks. Please keep the comment tracking number that http://www.regulations.gov provides after you have successfully uploaded your
comment.
Submitting comments via e-mail, hand delivery/courier, or mail.
Comments and documents submitted via e-mail, hand delivery, or mail
also will be posted to http://www.regulations.gov. If you do not want
your personal contact information to be publicly viewable, do not
include it in your comment or any accompanying documents. Instead,
provide your contact information in a cover letter. Include your first
and last names, e-mail address, telephone number, and optional mailing
address. The cover letter will not be publicly viewable as long as it
does not include any comments.
Include contact information each time you submit comments, data,
documents, and other information to DOE. E-mail submissions are
preferred. If you submit via mail or hand delivery/courier, please
provide all items on a CD, if feasible, in which case, it is not
necessary to submit printed copies. No facsimiles (faxes) will be
accepted.
Comments, data, and other information submitted to DOE
electronically should be provided in PDF (preferred), Microsoft Word or
Excel, WordPerfect, or text (ASCII) file format. Provide documents that
are not secured, that are written in English, and that are free of any
defects or viruses. Documents should not contain special characters or
any form of encryption and, if possible, they should carry the
electronic signature of the author.
Campaign form letters. Please submit campaign form letters by the
originating organization in batches of between 50 to 500 form letters
per PDF or as one form letter with a list of supporters' names compiled
into one or more PDFs. This reduces comment processing and posting
time.
Confidential business information. Pursuant to 10 CFR 1004.11, any
person submitting information that he or she believes to be
confidential and exempt by law from public disclosure should submit via
e-mail, postal mail, or hand delivery/courier two well-marked copies:
one copy of the document marked ``confidential'' that includes all the
information believed to be confidential, and one copy of the document
marked ``non-confidential'' with the information believed to be
confidential deleted. Submit these documents via e-mail or on a CD, if
feasible. DOE will make its own determination about the confidential
status of the information and treat it according to its determination.
Factors of interest to DOE when evaluating requests to treat
submitted information as confidential include: (1) A description of the
items; (2) whether and why such items are customarily treated as
confidential within the industry; (3) whether the information is
generally known by or available from other sources; (4) whether the
information has previously been made available to others without
obligation concerning its confidentiality; (5) an explanation of the
competitive injury to the submitting person which would result from
public disclosure; (6) when such information might lose its
confidential character due to the passage of time; and (7) why
disclosure of the information would be contrary to the public interest.
[[Page 52899]]
It is DOE's policy that all comments may be included in the public
docket, without change and as received, including any personal
information provided in the comments (except information deemed to be
exempt from public disclosure).
B. Issues on Which DOE Seeks Comment
Although DOE welcomes comments on any aspect of this notice, DOE is
particularly interested in receiving comments and views of interested
parties concerning the following issues:
(1) The conclusion that after removing 0.8 percent NEMA's reduction
factor and recalculating lamp arc powers, the remaining differences
between DOE and NEMA-provided data are likely due to normal measurement
variation;
(2) The methodology used to account for compliance certification
requirements and measurement variation in developing efficiency levels;
(3) The appropriateness of using a power law equation to develop
efficiency levels and the chosen values for the exponent ``C''; and
(4) The efficiency levels considered.
VII. Approval of the Office of the Secretary
The Secretary of Energy has approved publication of this notice of
data availability.
Issued in Washington, DC, on August 18, 2011.
Timothy Unruh,
Program Manager, Federal Energy Management Program, Energy Efficiency
and Renewable Energy.
[FR Doc. 2011-21636 Filed 8-23-11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P