[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 141 (Friday, July 22, 2011)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 43808-43819]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-18478]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Office of Energy Policy and New Uses
7 CFR Part 2902
RIN 0503-AA36
Designation of Biobased Items for Federal Procurement
AGENCY: Departmental Management, USDA.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is amending the
Guidelines for Designating Biobased Products for Federal Procurement,
to add 14 sections to designate items within which biobased products
will be afforded Federal procurement preference, as provided for under
section 9002 of the Farm Security and Rural Investment Act of 2002, as
amended by the Food, Conservation, and Energy Act of 2008 (referred to
in this document as ``section 9002''). USDA is also establishing
minimum biobased contents for each of these items.
DATES: This rule is effective August 22, 2011.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ron Buckhalt, USDA, Office of
Procurement and Property Management, Room 361, Reporters Building, 300
7th St. SW., Washington, DC 20024; e-mail: [email protected]; phone
(202) 205-4008. Information regarding the Federal biobased preferred
procurement program (one part of the BioPreferred Program) is available
on the Internet at http://www.biopreferred.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The information presented in this preamble
is organized as follows:
I. Authority
II. Background
III. Summary of Changes
IV. Discussion of Public Comments
V. Regulatory Information
A. Executive Order 12866: Regulatory Planning and Review
B. Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA)
C. Executive Order 12630: Governmental Actions and Interference
With Constitutionally Protected Property Rights
D. Executive Order 12988: Civil Justice Reform
E. Executive Order 13132: Federalism
F. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
G. Executive Order 12372: Intergovernmental Review of Federal
Programs
H. Executive Order 13175: Consultation and Coordination With
Indian Tribal Governments
I. Paperwork Reduction Act
J. E-Government Act
K. Congressional Review Act
I. Authority
These items are designated under the authority of section 9002 of
the Farm Security and Rural Investment Act of 2002 (FSRIA), as amended
by the Food, Conservation, and Energy Act of 2008 (FCEA), 7 U.S.C. 8102
(referred to in this document as ``section 9002'').
II. Background
As part of the BioPreferred Program, USDA published, on November
23, 2010, a proposed rule in the Federal Register (FR) for the purpose
of designating a total of 14 items for the preferred procurement of
biobased products by Federal agencies (referred to hereafter in this FR
notice as the ``preferred procurement program''). This proposed rule
can be found at 75 FR 71492. This rulemaking is referred to in this
preamble as Round 7 (RIN 0503-AA36).
In the proposed rule, USDA proposed designating the following 14
items for the preferred procurement program: Animal repellents; bath
products; bioremediation materials; compost activators and
accelerators; concrete and asphalt cleaners; cuts, burns, and abrasions
ointments; dishwashing products; erosion control materials; floor
cleaners and protectors; hair care products, including shampoos and
conditioners as subcategories; interior paints and coatings; oven and
grill cleaners; slide way lubricants; and thermal shipping containers,
including durable and non-durable thermal shipping containers as
subcategories.
Today's final rule designates the proposed items within which
biobased products will be afforded Federal procurement preference. USDA
has determined that each of the items being designated under today's
rulemaking meets the necessary statutory requirements; that they are
being produced with biobased products; and that their procurement will
carry out the following objectives of section 9002: to improve demand
for biobased products; to spur development of the industrial base
through value-added agricultural processing and manufacturing in rural
communities; and to enhance the Nation's energy security by
substituting biobased products for products derived from imported oil
and natural gas.
When USDA designates by rulemaking an item (a generic grouping of
products) for preferred procurement under the BioPreferred Program,
manufacturers of all products under the umbrella of that item, that
meet the requirements to qualify for preferred procurement, can claim
that status for their products. To qualify for preferred procurement, a
product must be within a designated item and must contain at least the
minimum biobased content established for the designated item. When the
designation of specific items is finalized, USDA will invite the
manufacturers and vendors of these qualifying products to post
information on the product, contacts, and performance testing on its
BioPreferred Web site, http://www.biopreferred.gov. Procuring agencies
will be able to utilize this Web site as one tool to determine the
availability of qualifying biobased products under a designated item.
Once USDA designates an item, procuring agencies are required generally
to purchase biobased products within these designated items where the
purchase price of the procurement item exceeds $10,000 or where the
quantity of such items or of functionally equivalent items purchased
over the preceding fiscal year equaled $10,000 or more.
Subcategorization. Most of the items USDA is considering for
designation for preferred procurement cover a wide range of products.
For some items, there are subgroups of products within the item that
meet different requirements, uses and/or different performance
specifications. Where such subgroups exist, USDA intends to create
subcategories within the designated items. In sum, USDA looks at the
products within each item category to evaluate whether there are
subgroups of products within the item that have different
characteristics or that meet different performance specifications and,
where USDA finds these types of differences, it intends to create
subcategories with the minimum biobased content based on the tested
products within the subcategory.
For some items, however, USDA may not have sufficient information
at the time of designation to create subcategories within an item. In
such instances, USDA may either designate the item without creating
subcategories (i.e., defer the creation of subcategories) or designate
one subcategory and defer designation of other subcategories
[[Page 43809]]
within the item until additional information is obtained. Once USDA has
received sufficient additional information to justify the designation
of a subcategory, the subcategory will be designated through the
proposed and final rulemaking process.
Within today's final rule, USDA has subcategorized three of the
items being designated. The first item is hair care products and the
subcategories are (1) shampoo products, and (2) conditioner products.
The second item is interior paints and coatings and the subcategories
are (1) interior latex and waterborne alkyd paints and coatings, and
(2) interior oil-based and solventborne alkyd paints and coatings. The
third item is thermal shipping containers and the subcategories are (1)
durable thermal shipping containers, and (2) non-durable thermal
shipping containers.
Minimum Biobased Contents. The minimum biobased contents being
established with today's rulemaking are based on products for which
USDA has biobased content test data. Because the submission of product
samples for biobased content testing is on a strictly voluntary basis,
USDA was able to obtain samples only from those manufacturers who
volunteered to invest the resources required to submit the samples.
In addition to considering the biobased content test data for each
item, USDA also considers other factors including public comments
received on the proposed minimum biobased contents and product
performance information. USDA also considers the overall range of the
tested biobased contents within an item, groupings of similar values,
and breaks (significant gaps between two groups of values) in the
biobased content test data array. USDA evaluates this information to
determine whether some products that may have a lower biobased content
also have unique performance or applicability attributes that would
justify setting the minimum biobased content at a level that would
include these products. USDA believes that this evaluation process
allows it to establish minimum biobased contents based on a broad set
of factors to assist the Federal procurement community in its decisions
to purchase biobased products.
USDA makes every effort to obtain biobased content test data on
multiple products within each item. For most designated items, USDA has
biobased content test data on more than one product within a designated
item. However, in some cases, USDA has been able to obtain biobased
content data for only a single product within a designated item. As
USDA obtains additional data on the biobased contents for products
within these designated items and their subcategories, USDA will
evaluate whether the minimum biobased content for a designated item or
subcategory will be revised.
USDA anticipates that the minimum biobased content of an item that
is based on a single product is more likely to change as additional
products within that designated item are identified and tested. In
today's final rule, the minimum biobased contents for both
subcategories under the thermal shipping containers designated item are
based on a single tested product. Given that only three biobased
products have been identified in this item, and only one manufacturer
of products within each subcategory supplied a sample for testing, USDA
believes it is reasonable to set minimum biobased contents for these
subcategories based on the single data point for each subcategory.
Overlap with EPA's Comprehensive Procurement Guideline program for
recovered content products under the Resource Conservation and Recovery
Act (RCRA) Section 6002. Some of the products that are biobased items
designated for preferred procurement under the preferred procurement
program may also be items the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has
designated under the EPA's Comprehensive Procurement Guideline (CPG)
for products containing recovered materials. In situations where it
believes there may be an overlap, USDA is asking manufacturers of
qualifying biobased products to make additional product and performance
information available to Federal agencies conducting market research to
assist them in determining whether the biobased products in question
are, or are not, the same products for the same uses as the recovered
content products. Manufacturers are asked to provide information
highlighting the sustainable features of their biobased products and to
indicate the various suggested uses of their product and the
performance standards against which a particular product has been
tested. In addition, depending on the type of biobased product,
manufacturers are being asked to provide other types of information,
such as whether the product contains fossil energy-based components
(including petroleum, coal, and natural gas) and whether the product
contains recovered materials. Federal agencies also may ask
manufacturers for information on a product's biobased content and its
profile against environmental and health measures and life-cycle costs
(the ASTM Standard D7075, ``Standard Practice for Evaluating and
Reporting Environmental Performance of Biobased Products,'' or the
Building for Environmental and Economic Sustainability (BEES) analysis
for evaluating and reporting on environmental performance of biobased
products). Federal agencies may then use this information to make
purchasing decisions based on the sustainability features of the
products. Detailed information on ASTM Standard D7075, and other ASTM
standards, can be found on ASTM's Web site at http://www.astm.org.
Information on the BEES analytical tool can be found on the Web site
http://www.bfrl.nist.gov/oae/software/bees.html.
Section 6002 of RCRA requires a procuring agency procuring an item
designated by EPA generally to procure such an item composed of the
highest percentage of recovered materials content practicable. However,
a procuring agency may decide not to procure such an item based on a
determination that the item fails to meet the reasonable performance
standards or specifications of the procuring agency. An item with
recovered materials content may not meet reasonable performance
standards or specifications, for example, if the use of the item with
recovered materials content would jeopardize the intended end use of
the item.
Where a biobased item is used for the same purposes and to meet the
same Federal agency performance requirements as an EPA-designated
recovered content product, the Federal agency must purchase the
recovered content product. For example, if a biobased hydraulic fluid
is to be used as a fluid in hydraulic systems and because ``lubricating
oils containing re-refined oil'' has already been designated by EPA for
that purpose, then the Federal agency must purchase the EPA-designated
recovered content product, ``lubricating oils containing re-refined
oil.'' If, on the other hand, that biobased hydraulic fluid is to be
used to address a Federal agency's certain environmental or health
performance requirements that the EPA-designated recovered content
product would not meet, then the biobased product should be given
preference, subject to reasonable price, availability, and performance
considerations.
This final rule designates one item for preferred procurement for
which there may be overlap with an EPA-designated recovered content
product. The interior latex and waterborne alkyd subcategory within the
interior paints and coatings item may overlap with the EPA-
[[Page 43810]]
designated recovered content products ``reprocessed latex paints'' and
``consolidated latex paints.'' EPA provides recovered materials content
recommendations for these recovered content products in a Recovered
Materials Advisory Notice (RMAN I). The RMAN recommendations for these
CPG products can be found by accessing EPA's Web site http://www.epa.gov/epaoswer/non-hw/procure/products.htm and then clicking on
the appropriate product name.
Federal Government Purchase of Sustainable Products. The Federal
government's sustainable purchasing program includes the following
three statutory preference programs for designated products: The
BioPreferred Program, the Environmental Protection Agency's
Comprehensive Procurement Guideline for products containing recovered
materials, and the Environmentally Preferable Purchasing program. The
Office of the Federal Environmental Executive (OFEE) and the Office of
Management and Budget (OMB) encourage agencies to implement these
components comprehensively when purchasing products and services.
Procuring agencies should note that not all biobased products are
``environmentally preferable.'' For example, unless cleaning products
contain no or reduced levels of metals and toxic and hazardous
constituents, they can be harmful to aquatic life, the environment,
and/or workers. Household cleaning products that are formulated to be
disinfectants are required, under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide
and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), to be registered with EPA and must meet
specific labeling requirements warning of the potential risks
associated with misuse of such products. When purchasing
environmentally preferable cleaning products, many Federal agencies
specify that products must meet Green Seal standards for institutional
cleaning products or that the products have been reformulated in
accordance with recommendations from the EPA's Design for the
Environment (DfE) program. Both the Green Seal standards and the DfE
program identify chemicals of concern in cleaning products. These
include zinc and other metals, formaldehyde, ammonia, alkyl phenol
ethoxylates, ethylene glycol, and volatile organic compounds (VOC). In
addition, both require that cleaning products have neutral or less
caustic pH.
In contrast, some biobased products may be more environmentally
preferable than some products that meet Green Seal standards for
institutional cleaning products or that have been reformulated in
accordance with EPA's DfE program. To fully compare products, one must
look at the ``cradle-to-grave'' impacts of the manufacture, use, and
disposal of products. Biobased products that will be available for
preferred procurement under this program have been assessed as to their
``cradle-to-grave'' impacts.
One consideration of a product's impact on the environment is
whether (and to what degree) it introduces new fossil carbon into the
atmosphere. Fossil carbon is derived from non-renewable sources
(typically fossil fuels such as coal and oil), whereas renewable
biomass carbon is derived from renewable sources (biomass). Qualifying
biobased products offer the user the opportunity to manage the carbon
cycle and reduce the introduction of new fossil carbon into the
atmosphere.
Manufacturers of qualifying biobased products designated under the
preferred procurement program will be able to provide, at the request
of Federal agencies, factual information on environmental and human
health effects of their products, including the results of the ASTM
D7075, or the comparable BEES analysis which examines 12 different
environmental parameters, including human health. Therefore, USDA
encourages Federal procurement agencies to consider that USDA has
already examined all available information on the environmental and
human health effects of biopreferred products, when making their
purchasing decisions.
Other Preferred Procurement Programs. Federal procurement officials
should also note that biobased products may be available for purchase
by Federal agencies through the AbilityOne Program (formerly known as
the Javits-Wagner-O'Day (JWOD) program). Under this program, members of
organizations including the National Industries for the Blind (NIB) and
the National Institute for the Severely Handicapped (NISH) offer
products and services for preferred procurement by Federal agencies. A
search of the AbilityOne Program's online catalog (www.abilityone.gov)
indicated that four of the items being designated today (concrete and
asphalt cleaners, dishwashing detergent, floor cleaners and protectors,
and hair care products) are available through the AbilityOne Program.
While there is no specific product within these items identified in the
AbilityOne online catalog as being a biobased product, it is possible
that such biobased products are available or will be available in the
future. Also, because additional categories of products are frequently
added to the AbilityOne Program, it is possible that biobased products
within other items being designated today may be available through the
AbilityOne Program in the future. Procurement of biobased products
through the AbilityOne Program would further the objectives of both the
AbilityOne Program and the preferred procurement program.
Outreach. To augment its own research, USDA consults with industry
and Federal stakeholders to the preferred procurement program during
the development of the rulemaking packages for the designation of
items. USDA consults with stakeholders to gather information used in
determining the order of item designation and in identifying:
Manufacturers producing and marketing products that fall within an item
proposed for designation; performance standards used by Federal
agencies evaluating products to be procured; and warranty information
used by manufacturers of end user equipment and other products with
regard to biobased products.
Future Designations. In making future designations, USDA will
continue to conduct market searches to identify manufacturers of
biobased products within items. USDA will then contact the identified
manufacturers to solicit samples of their products for voluntary
submission for biobased content testing. Based on these results, USDA
will then propose new items for designation for preferred procurement.
In the preamble to the first six items designated for preferred
procurement (71 FR 13686, March 16, 2006), USDA stated that it planned
to identify approximately 10 items in each future rulemaking. In an
effort to finalize the designation of more items in a shorter time
period, USDA now plans to increase the number of items in each
rulemaking, whenever possible. Thus, today's final rulemaking
designates 14 items for preferred procurement.
USDA has developed a preliminary list of items for future
designation and has posted this preliminary list on the BioPreferred
Web site. While this list presents an initial prioritization of items
for designation, USDA cannot identify with certainty which items will
be presented in each of the future rulemakings. In response to comments
from other Federal agencies, USDA intends to give increased priority to
those items that contain the highest biobased content. In addition, as
the program matures, manufacturers of biobased products within some
industry segments have become more responsive to USDA's requests for
technical information than those in other segments. Thus, items with
high biobased content and for which
[[Page 43811]]
sufficient technical information can be obtained quickly may be added
or moved up on the prioritization list. USDA intends to update the list
of items for future designation on the BioPreferred Web site every six
months, or more often if significant changes are made to the list.
III. Summary of Changes
As a result of the comments received on the proposed rule, USDA has
made several changes in finalizing the proposed rule. These changes are
summarized in the remainder of this section. A summary of each comment
received, and USDA's response to the comment, is presented in section
IV.
The definitions of three proposed items were revised to avoid
potential overlap with previously designated items. The definition of
the bath products designated item was revised to specifically exclude
products marketed as hand cleaners and/or hand sanitizers. The
definition of the concrete and asphalt cleaners designated item was
revised to include only those products marketed for use in commercial
or residential construction or industrial applications. The definition
of the floor cleaners and protectors designated item was revised to
include only those products marketed specifically for use on
industrial, commercial, and/or residential flooring.
The proposed item interior paints and coatings was subcategorized.
The subcategories are (1) interior latex and waterborne alkyd paints
and coatings, and (2) interior oil-based and solventborne alkyd paints
and coatings.
The discussion of potential overlap with the EPA recovered content
product re-refined lubricating oil was removed from the slide way
lubricants.
IV. Discussion of Public Comments
USDA solicited comments on the proposed rule for 60 days ending on
January 24, 2011. USDA received comments from five commenters by that
date. The comments were from three Federal government agencies and two
biobased product manufacturers.
In the remainder of this section, USDA first addresses two general
comments that relate to the overall designation process. Comments
related to the designation of specific items are presented next,
followed by USDA's response to those comments.
General
Comment: One commenter stated that the BioPreferred Web site might
imply to some that the listed products have been tested and meet all
Federal requirements, when the primary test of concern is for biobased
content. The commenter stated that, in numerous cases, the products
have not been tested/evaluated for DoD applications. The commenter
suggested that there should be some type of statement on the Web site
explaining that the item type meets USDA requirements but not
necessarily those of any other component of the Federal government.
Response: USDA agrees with the commenter that the functional
performance of biobased products is of great concern to procuring
agencies and that such performance is not guaranteed as a part of the
designation process. USDA attempts to gather performance information
from biobased product manufacturers during the designation process, but
does not have the statutory authority to require manufacturers to
provide such information. The absence of industry standards listed in
association with a catalog entry simply indicates that the company has
elected not to provide any information about performance testing
associated with their products. Purchasing officials interested in
performance data associated with a specific product are encouraged to
contact the listed contacts for further information. USDA will consider
the feasibility of including a symbol in the catalog (when the
performance standards record is null) so that purchasing officials can
quickly see which products have testing standards associated with their
products.
New Product Category
Comment: One commenter believes that it is important to have a
product category designation for automotive motor oils. The commenter
states that there are categories for 2-cycle engine oil, and bar and
chain lubricant, which are typically petroleum-based products. The
commenter believes there would be significant benefit in designating
automotive motor oils as a product category in the next round. The
commenter stated that this could lead to the creation of more effective
and environmentally friendly motor oil from biobased materials.
Response: USDA thanks the commenter for the recommendation and is
willing to work with the commenter to obtain valid information
regarding the potential for establishing a product category for
automotive motor oils. USDA would be especially interested in obtaining
information related to performance characteristics of biobased
automotive motor oils, including documentation of successful
performance testing by recognized testing organizations such as ASTM
and SAE.
Animal Repellents
Comment: One commenter stated that Federal agencies are
implementing integrated pest management (IPM) in place of the use of
pesticides. The commenter recommends USDA address whether the use of
biobased animal repellents is consistent with Federal IPM efforts.
Response: USDA contacted Dr. Martin Draper, the National Program
Leader--Plant Pathology, of USDA's National Institute of Food and
Agriculture to discuss whether the use of biobased animal repellents is
consistent with Federal IPM programs. Dr. Draper stated that IPM
encourages the use of diverse methods of mitigating pest pressures, in
most cases reducing pesticide use. He further stated that biorational
pesticides and biological controls would be welcome and encouraged
within the constructs of IPM. He stated that IPM programs are focused
on efficacious products and strategies that optimize economic advantage
while reducing potential deleterious effects on the environment and
human health and that if the products that can do that are biobased,
all the better. He further stated that pest repellents would be
included as a component of IPM if that was an appropriate strategy.
According to Dr. Draper, exclusion, the best option in managing
vertebrate pests, is impractical or illegal in some cases. In those
cases, repellents become very important in the management of some very
damaging pests. Dr. Draper concluded by saying that he did not see
where the use of biobased animal repellents would be a conflict with
IPM programs.
Bath Products
Comment: One commenter believes that the proposed designation of
bath products overlaps with the previous designation of hand cleaners.
The commenter stated that manufacturers and purchasers need clear
guidance as to which biobased content level applies, as the recommended
minimum biobased content level for hand cleaners is slightly higher
than that proposed for bath products. The commenter further recommends
that USDA provide a clear definition of bath products that
distinguishes it from hand cleaners.
Response: USDA does not believe that the designation of bath
products overlaps significantly with the previous designation of hand
cleaners and sanitizers. Hand cleaners and sanitizers are defined as
products formulated exclusively for use as human hand personal care
products. Bath products, as defined, are personal hygiene
[[Page 43812]]
products, including soaps and other cleansers. However, USDA does agree
that there may be some confusion regarding these differences and has
amended the definition of bath products to state that these exclude
products that are specifically marketed as ``hand cleaners'' and/or
``hand sanitizer'' products.
Bioremediation Materials and Compost Activators and Accelerators
Comment: One commenter stated that the designation of
bioremediation materials and compost activators could lead to
unnecessary addition of biobased components to these products in order
to qualify for Federal procurement preference.
The commenter stated that a review of the Technical Support
Document indicates that the overwhelming majority of the products
identified within these two product categories consist of active
biological microorganism cultures. The commenter further noted that
some product descriptions also indicate that the product contains
nutrients or organic materials. However, the active ingredient is
typically a culture of microorganisms.
Thus, according to the commenter, developing a formula for sale to
the government by adding more biobased organic materials that simply
dilute the microbiological active ingredient is a logical response to
USDA's contemplated biobased content minimum. The commenter stated that
the result of a ``successful'' USDA designation in this area might be
simply the wasting of biobased products into the compost pile or into
soils being remediated. The commenter further stated that the addition
of biobased organic materials would also increase the use of packaging
materials, fuels, etc. for product transport, having a negative effect
on the environment.
The commenter also noted that neither of these product classes
appears to have standardized tests to determine product effectiveness--
which increases the difficulty to the government to avoid procurement
of diluted products prepared to satisfy a biobased content mandate.
The commenter recommends that the ``bioremediation materials''
product category and the ``compost activators and accelerators''
product category not be designated under the biobased procurement
preference program.
Response: USDA disagrees with the commenter's recommendation that
bioremediation materials and compost activators and accelerators not be
included in the biobased procurement preference program. Based on the
information collected prior to proposing these items for designation,
available products within these two items are almost universally high
in biobased content. Also, because the microorganisms that are the
active ingredients in the products would be counted as biobased
content, reducing the percentage of the microorganisms in the product
and increasing the biobased nutrient, or carrier, content would not
increase the overall biobased content of a product. In addition,
reformulating the product to include fewer microorganisms would tend to
hurt the performance of the product. Thus, manufacturers would have no
reason to add inactive biobased ingredients to increase the biobased
content of the products. USDA held a meeting with the commenter to
clarify the comments/responses and explain the rationale for finalizing
the designation of these two items, but did not make any changes in the
final rule.
Concrete and Asphalt Cleaners
Comment: One commenter stated that the proposed designation of
concrete and asphalt cleaners overlaps with the previously designated
graffiti remover. The commenter believes that guidance is needed as to
which biobased content applies, as the proposed minimum biobased
content level for graffiti remover is significantly lower than that for
the concrete and asphalt cleaners. The commenter further stated that
concrete and asphalt cleaners should be clearly distinguished from
graffiti remover.
Response: USDA reviewed the product information collected on both
the proposed concrete and asphalt cleaners item and the previously
designated graffiti remover item to investigate clarifications that
could be made to the definitions. Based on the product descriptions
provided by manufacturers, USDA found that products within the proposed
concrete and asphalt cleaners item were predominantly described as
being intended for use in construction or industrial applications.
Graffiti and grease remover products were generally described as being
intended for use in janitorial and/or institutional applications. USDA
has, therefore, clarified the definition of concrete and asphalt
cleaners to specify that products within this item include only those
marketed for use in construction or industrial applications.
Comment: One commenter, in reference to the Boeing Spec D6-17487P
listed in connection with the proposed concrete and asphalt cleaners
item, asked if proprietary standards like these are readily available
to the purchasing agencies. The commenter stated that, if so, their
Hazardous Minimization/Green Products Community would like access to
them.
Response: USDA does not have access to individual performance
specifications such as Boeing Specification D6-17487P. USDA suggests
that interested parties contact biobased product vendors/manufacturers,
or the entity that established the performance standard, directly
regarding access to their specifications.
Dishwashing Products
Comment: One commenter, in reference to the Boeing Spec D6-7127
listed in connection with the proposed dishwashing products item, asked
if proprietary standards like these are readily available to purchasing
agencies. The commenter stated that, if so, their Hazardous
Minimization/Green Products Community would like access to them.
Response: As stated in the response to a similar comment related to
the concrete and asphalt cleaners item, USDA does not have access to
individual performance standards and recommends that interested parties
contact biobased product vendors/manufacturers, or the entity that
established the performance standard.
Floor Cleaners and Protectors
Comment: One commenter believes that the proposed designation of
floor cleaners and protectors overlaps with the previous designation of
bathroom and spa cleaners, as both types of products can be used to
clean similar surfaces. The commenter believes that guidance is needed
as to which biobased content applies, as the proposed minimum biobased
content level for floor cleaners is slightly higher than that
recommended for bathroom cleaning products. The commenter further
stated that a definition of floor cleaners that clearly distinguishes
it from bathroom cleaners is needed.
Response: USDA has revised the definition of the proposed floor
cleaners and protectors item to specify that products within this item
are marketed specifically for use on industrial, commercial, and/or
residential flooring. USDA agrees with the commenter that some products
that are marketed within the previously designated bathroom and spa
cleaners item may be used on floors. Those products are generally
marketed as multi-surface cleaners formulated specifically for use in
bathrooms and spa areas. By specifying that applicable floor cleaner
and protector products are
[[Page 43813]]
those marketed specifically for use on flooring, USDA believes that
most overlay issues will be eliminated.
Hair Care Products
Comment: One commenter recommends that USDA create a category of
``personal care products,'' with bath products, hand cleaners, and hair
care products listed as subsets. Each item should be clearly defined to
be distinguishable from each other.
Response: USDA agrees with the commenter that some of the proposed
and previously designated items include products that are functionally
similar and could be more clearly defined to avoid overlap. USDA has
developed the designation rulemakings in several individual ``rounds''
as new product information was gathered. In addition, biobased product
manufacturers have continued to introduce biobased alternatives that
are marketed in an increasing variety of applications, especially in
the category of ``multi-purpose'' cleaners and lubricants. USDA
recognizes that the potential for many biobased products to be marketed
under multiple designated items continues to increase. On one hand,
this is encouraging because it means that biobased alternatives are
becoming more widespread and more marketable. On the other hand, it
means that some of the items that were designated early in the process
are not organized and defined in the most practical way. Once the
initial designation of those items for which information is readily
available has been completed, USDA intends to revisit the entire list
of designated items and undertake a reorganization to streamline and
clarify the items and update the minimum biobased content requirements,
as applicable.
Interior Paints and Coatings
Comment: One commenter proposes that this item designation be
subcategorized based on differences in the requirements, uses, and
performance specifications. Based on the USDA definition of subgroups,
the commenter believes two subgroups exist for interior paints and
coatings, ``interior latex and latex-hybrid paints and coatings'' and
``interior oil-based and alkyd paints and coatings.'' Because
significantly different technologies and chemistries are used to meet
the requirements, uses, and performance specific to each of these
subgroups, different minimum biobased content levels should be set for
each of these.
The commenter stated that coatings within the first proposed
subcategory, interior latex and latex-hybrid paints and coatings, are
carried in water and are capable of meeting all national and regional
VOC regulations. The commenter also stated that it is important that
procurement officers have biobased options capable of meeting the VOC
regulations in their particular region. The commenter stated that they
currently sell products that would fall into this subcategory and can
provide them to the USDA for biobased content testing. The commenter
recommended that a minimum level of approximately 20 percent biobased
carbon would be appropriate for the latex and latex hybrid-paints and
coatings subcategory.
According to the commenter, latex paint is the dominant coating
type used in the interior paint and coatings market; used for typical
painting projects, such as wall paint. The commenter stated that users
of latex paints have very specific performance expectations, including
fast drying times and low odor. The commenter noted that these are very
important factors, because the paint cost accounts for only about 20-30
percent of the total paint-job cost, with the majority of costs being
related to labor. Faster drying paints significantly reduce labor costs
and allow office buildings and other interior spaces to be quickly
returned to service after painting. These coatings are also carried in
water which results in low odor, low VOC and significantly lower
contribution to indoor air quality issues.
The commenter also stated that subcategorization of interior latex
and latex-hybrid paint and coatings will also provide the requested
clarity on the potential overlap that was identified by the USDA, with
the EPA's Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). By
subcategorizing in this manner, there is no overlap for applications
that require a paint from the ``interior oil-based and alkyd paint and
coatings'' subcategory. The commenter stated that, in the case of
applications requiring paint from the ``interior latex and latex-hybrid
paints and coatings'' subcategory, the decision between a biobased
latex paint (USDA BioPreferred) or reprocessed/consolidated latex paint
(EPA RCRA) can be made by the procurement officer based on price,
availability, and performance considerations.
The commenter stated that the second proposed subcategory, interior
oil-based and alkyd paints and coatings are defined by the ACA as ``a
paint that contains drying oil, oil varnish or oil-modified resin as
the film-forming ingredient.'' The commenter explained that an alkyd
resin is defined by the ACA as ``synthetic resin modified with oil.''
Thus, alkyd paints and coatings are defined as ``coatings that contains
alkyd resins in the binder.'' The commenter also stated that these
coatings typically are carried in a natural or synthetic solvent and
therefore may not meet VOC regulations in certain geographical regions.
The commenter stated that the coating HC84-0015 tested by the USDA
qualifies for this subcategory and the coatings Q14G-0009, Q14G-0013,
and Q14G-0002, may qualify for this subcategory as well. The commenter
agrees with a 67 percent biobased content level for this subcategory.
The commenter explained that interior alkyd and oil-based paints in
the U.S. market are typically used for trim paint and as wood primers,
especially where tannin blocking is specifically required. The
commenter stated that users of alkyd and oil-based paints have very
specific performance expectations and that these coatings are used on
trim specifically for their hardness, smooth application, tannin
blocking ability, and the ability to achieve substantially higher gloss
levels. They can also be used for wall coatings when this type of
performance is required. In contrast to latex and latex hybrid, these
types of coatings are slow to dry and often have some odor associated
with them.
The commenter recommended the following changes to the proposed
designation of biobased interior paints and coatings for preferred
Federal procurement:
The subcategories should be based on their differentiated use and
performance specifications. Allowing for the inclusion of latex paints
will lead to wider adoption and use of biobased products in the
interior paints and coatings category.
The commenter believes that a level of 67 percent biobased content
is appropriate for the interior oil-based and alkyd paints and coatings
subcategory, but the level for the interior latex and latex-hybrid
paints and coatings should be approximately 20 percent biobased carbon
content.
The commenter also stated that the 100 percent biobased content
level found in product MXF6-0004 should not be used to determine the
minimum biobased content for interior paints and coatings or either of
the proposed subcategories because this type of coating is not feasible
for use and this product was not tested for biobased content as it is
intended to be used. The commenter stated that, when used as instructed
by the manufacture in the product description, the biobased content of
the full painting system will
[[Page 43814]]
be significantly lower. While the milk-paint base itself is biobased,
according to the product description provided by the USDA, it requires
mixing with an adhesive in order to adhere to non-porous surfaces (e.g.
any previously painted surfaces). Milk-paint manufactures also
typically recommend using an acrylic top-coat for durability. The
commenter stated that, since the adhesive is a necessary part of the
``coating'' to insure adhesion to the substrate, it must be included in
any determination of biobased content.
Response: USDA considered the information provided by the
commenter, reviewed the data previously collected on this proposed
item, and also researched other coating-related information available
on the Internet. USDA agrees with the commenter that the proposed item
should include at least two subcategories based on two fundamentally
different coating technologies.
USDA found that within the broad category of interior paints and
coatings all products can be categorized at the highest level as either
waterborne or solventborne. As the names imply, the products can be
divided into those that use water as the ``carrier'' liquid and those
that use a solvent other than water (e.g., typically petroleum-based
solvents). Waterborne coatings have traditionally been formulated as an
emulsion of petroleum based acrylic resins in water. These coatings
were low in VOC content, but did not contain biobased components.
Solventborne coatings have traditionally been formulated as plant based
(soy, linseed, castor) alkyd resins in petroleum based solvents. These
coatings have a much higher VOC content, but do include a biobased
component.
Recent advances in coating technology have resulted in the
formulation of waterborne coatings that include varying levels of plant
based alkyd resins. Thus, there are now biobased alternatives within
both the waterborne and solventborne coating types. While solventborne
alkyd coatings still generally contain a much higher biobased content,
waterborne coatings with a significant biobased content are becoming
increasingly popular. The commenter reported selling a line of
waterborne coating products with at least 20 percent biobased content.
USDA also contacted a major resin manufacturer who confirmed that their
products are used in waterborne alkyd coatings containing biobased
contents in the 20 to 30 percent range.
USDA agrees with the commenter that other types of coatings, such
as the milk-paint discussed by the commenter, are not generally
representative of the coating technologies that dominate the interior
coatings market. While various other types of coating technologies are
available, their use is very specialized and the volumes that would
potentially be purchased by Federal procurement officials is negligible
compared to waterborne and solventborne coatings. USDA has, therefore,
not considered these specialty coatings in establishing subcategories
for this item. However, to the extent that any of these specialty
coatings fall within the subcategories established in today's final
rule, they would be eligible for the same consideration for preferred
procurement as more traditional coatings.
For the reasons presented above, USDA has decided to create two
subcategories within the interior paints and coatings item. USDA
recognizes that there are many factors for purchasing officials to
consider when purchasing interior paints and coatings. Procurement
decisions must be made considering applicable VOC regulations as well
as a long list of necessary coating performance characteristics.
Creating two subcategories within the interior paints and coatings item
allows USDA to acknowledge the differences between the two basic
coating types and also to set minimum biobased contents that are
representative of each type. In the final rule, the two subcategories
are: (1) Interior latex and waterborne alkyd paints and coatings, and
(2) interior oil-based and solventborne alkyd paints and coatings. The
minimum biobased content of the first subcategory is 20 percent and the
minimum biobased content of the second subcategory is 67 percent. USDA
believes that these minimum biobased contents will result in procuring
officials being able to select from a sufficiently large number of
products to ensure that their performance needs can be met.
Comment: One commenter stated that, under E.O. 13423 and 13514,
Federal agencies are using interior paints with no or low VOC content
as part of their high performance sustainable building efforts. For
some agencies, the use of no- or low-VOC paints is necessary to help
meet air non-attainment area requirements. USDA should address the VOC
content of biobased paints and whether the use of these products is
consistent with agency efforts to reduce their use of VOC-containing
products.
Response: As discussed in the response to the previous comment,
USDA has subcategorized the interior paints and coatings item into two
subcategories. The two subcategories can generally be described as
being either waterborne (the latex and waterborne alkyds subcategory)
or solventborne (the oil-based and solventborne alkyds subcategory).
Waterborne coatings, as the name implies, use water as the carrier for
the resins and pigments. Solventborne coatings use an organic solvent
(typically a petroleum-derived solvent) as the carrier. The vast
majority of coatings used in the interior paints and coatings market
are waterborne coatings and one of the primary driving factors in the
emergence of waterborne technology was the low organic solvent content
of these coatings. Not only do these coatings meet VOC requirements,
they are fast drying and low in odor. Solventborne coatings are
typically used as primers and for wood trim, cabinets, and furniture.
They are used primarily for their hardness, smooth application, and
higher gloss levels. Because they contain organic solvents, however,
these coatings may not meet VOC regulations in some geographical
regions.
USDA agrees with the commenter that the use of low VOC coatings is
an important consideration in many Federal agency's environmental
programs. USDA recommends that purchasing officials first consider the
performance and environmental concerns when deciding whether to
purchase waterborne or solventborne coatings. Once that decision is
made, purchasing officials must determine whether the available
biobased alternatives within each coating type meet their performance
and cost criteria.
Slide Way Lubricants
Comment: One commenter stated that the proposed designation of
slide way lubricants does not overlap with EPA's designation of re-
refined lubricating oils. The commenter stated that the EPA designation
applies to engine lubricants, hydraulic fluids, and gear oils.
Response: USDA thanks the commenter for the comment. USDA
reconsidered the potential for an overlap and agrees that slide way
lubricants do not overlap with EPA's designated re-refined lubricating
oil. USDA has removed the discussion of the potential overlap for this
item from the final rule.
Thermal Shipping Containers
Comment: One commenter stated that this proposed category has two
subcategories with only one manufacturer and that USDA is proposing to
defer the compliance date until additional manufacturers are
identified. The commenter suggests that
[[Page 43815]]
in future rounds it may be preferable to hold off designating an item
until more than one manufacturer is identified.
Response: Section 9002 of the Farm Security and Rural Investment
Act of 2002 (FSRIA), as amended by the Food, Conservation, and Energy
Act of 2008 (FCEA), states that USDA shall ``* * * designate those
items (including finished products) that are or can be produced with
biobased products (including biobased products for which there is only
a single product or manufacturer in the category) that will be subject
to the preference described in paragraph (2) * * *''. Thus, USDA does
not agree that it should defer designating an item until more than one
manufacturer is identified.
V. Regulatory Information
A. Executive Order 12866: Regulatory Planning and Review
Executive Order 12866 requires agencies to determine whether a
regulatory action is ``significant.'' The Order defines a ``significant
regulatory action'' as one that is likely to result in a rule that may:
``(1) Have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more or
adversely affect, in a material way, the economy, a sector of the
economy, productivity, competition, jobs, the environment, public
health or safety, or State, local, or tribal governments or
communities; (2) Create a serious inconsistency or otherwise interfere
with an action taken or planned by another agency; (3) Materially alter
the budgetary impact of entitlements, grants, user fees, or loan
programs or the rights and obligations of recipients thereof; or (4)
Raise novel legal or policy issues arising out of legal mandates, the
President's priorities, or the principles set forth in this Executive
Order.''
Today's final rule has been determined by the Office of Management
and Budget to be not significant for purposes of Executive Order 12866.
We are not able to quantify the annual economic effect associated with
today's final rule. As discussed earlier in this preamble, USDA made
extensive efforts to obtain information on the Federal agencies' usage
within the 14 designated items, including their subcategories. These
efforts were largely unsuccessful. Therefore, attempts to determine the
economic impacts of today's final rule would require estimation of the
anticipated market penetration of biobased products based upon many
assumptions. In addition, because agencies have the option of not
purchasing designated items if price is ``unreasonable,'' the product
is not readily available, or the product does not demonstrate necessary
performance characteristics, certain assumptions may not be valid.
While facing these quantitative challenges, USDA relied upon a
qualitative assessment to determine the impacts of today's final rule.
Consideration was also given to the fact that agencies may choose not
to procure designated items due to unreasonable price.
1. Summary of Impacts
Today's final rule is expected to have both positive and negative
impacts to individual businesses, including small businesses. USDA
anticipates that the biobased preferred procurement program will
provide additional opportunities for businesses and manufacturers to
begin supplying products under the designated biobased items to Federal
agencies and their contractors. However, other businesses and
manufacturers that supply only non-qualifying products and do not offer
biobased alternatives may experience a decrease in demand from Federal
agencies and their contractors. USDA is unable to determine the number
of businesses, including small businesses, that may be adversely
affected by today's final rule. The final rule, however, will not
affect existing purchase orders, nor will it preclude businesses from
modifying their product lines to meet new requirements for designated
biobased products. Because the extent to which procuring agencies will
find the performance, availability and/or price of biobased products
acceptable is unknown, it is impossible to quantify the actual economic
effect of the rule.
2. Benefits of the Final Rule
The designation of these 14 items provides the benefits outlined in
the objectives of section 9002; to increase domestic demand for many
agricultural commodities that can serve as feedstocks for production of
biobased products, and to spur development of the industrial base
through value-added agricultural processing and manufacturing in rural
communities. On a national and regional level, today's final rule can
result in expanding and strengthening markets for biobased materials
used in these items.
3. Costs of the Final Rule
Like the benefits, the costs of today's final rule have not been
quantified. Two types of costs are involved: Costs to producers of
products that will compete with the preferred products and costs to
Federal agencies to provide procurement preference for the preferred
products. Producers of competing products may face a decrease in demand
for their products to the extent Federal agencies refrain from
purchasing their products. However, it is not known to what extent this
may occur. Pre-award procurement costs for Federal agencies may rise
minimally as the contracting officials conduct market research to
evaluate the performance, availability and price reasonableness of
preferred products before making a purchase.
B. Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA)
The RFA, 5 U.S.C. 601-602, generally requires an agency to prepare
a regulatory flexibility analysis of any rule subject to notice and
comment rulemaking requirements under the Administrative Procedure Act
or any other statute unless the agency certifies that the rule will not
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities. Small entities include small businesses, small organizations,
and small governmental jurisdictions.
USDA evaluated the potential impacts of its designation of these
items to determine whether its actions would have a significant impact
on a substantial number of small entities. Because the preferred
procurement program established under section 9002 applies only to
Federal agencies and their contractors, small governmental (city,
county, etc.) agencies are not affected. Thus, the proposal, if
promulgated, will not have a significant economic impact on small
governmental jurisdictions.
USDA anticipates that this program will affect entities, both large
and small, that manufacture or sell biobased products. For example, the
designation of items for preferred procurement will provide additional
opportunities for businesses to manufacture and sell biobased products
to Federal agencies and their contractors. Similar opportunities will
be provided for entities that supply biobased materials to
manufacturers.
The intent of section 9002 is largely to stimulate the production
of new biobased products and to energize emerging markets for those
products. Because the program is still in its infancy, however, it is
unknown how many businesses will ultimately be affected. While USDA has
no data on the number of small businesses that may choose to develop
and market biobased products within the items designated by this
rulemaking, the number is expected to be small. Because biobased
products represent a small emerging market, only a small percentage of
all manufacturers,
[[Page 43816]]
large or small, are expected to develop and market biobased products.
Thus, the number of small businesses manufacturing biobased products
affected by this rulemaking is not expected to be substantial.
The preferred procurement program may decrease opportunities for
businesses that manufacture or sell non-biobased products or provide
components for the manufacturing of such products. Most manufacturers
of non-biobased products within the items being designated for
preferred procurement in this rule are expected to be included under
the following NAICS codes: 324191 (petroleum lubricating oil and grease
manufacturing), 325320 (pesticide and other agricultural chemical
manufacturing), 325412 (pharmaceutical preparation manufacturing),
325510 (paint and coating manufacturing), 325611 (soap and other
detergent manufacturing), 325612 (polish and other sanitation goods
manufacturing), 325620 (toilet preparation manufacturing), 325998
(other miscellaneous chemical products and preparation manufacturing),
326150 (urethane and other foam product manufacturing), and 314999
(other miscellaneous textile mill products). USDA obtained information
on these 10 NAICS categories from the U.S. Census Bureau's Economic
Census database. USDA found that the Economic Census reports about
8,092 companies within these 10 NAICS categories and that these
companies own a total of about 9,255 establishments. Thus, the average
number of establishments per company is about 1.1. The Census data also
reported that of the 9,255 individual establishments, about 9,119 (98.5
percent) have fewer than 500 employees. USDA also found that the
overall average number of employees per company among these industries
is about 58, with only one segment reporting an average of more than
100 employees (the pharmaceutical preparation industry segment at about
250 employees per company). Thus, nearly all of the businesses fall
within the Small Business Administration's definition of a small
business (fewer than 500 employees, in most NAICS categories).
USDA does not have data on the potential adverse impacts on
manufacturers of non-biobased products within the items being
designated, but believes that the impact will not be significant. Most
of the items being designated in this rulemaking are typical consumer
products widely used by the general public and by industrial/commercial
establishments that are not subject to this rulemaking. Thus, USDA
believes that the number of small businesses manufacturing non-biobased
products within the items being designated and selling significant
quantities of those products to government agencies affected by this
rulemaking to be relatively low. Also, this final rule will not affect
existing purchase orders and it will not preclude procuring agencies
from continuing to purchase non-biobased items when biobased items do
not meet the availability, performance, or reasonable price criteria.
This final rule will also not preclude businesses from modifying their
product lines to meet new specifications or solicitation requirements
for these products containing biobased materials.
After considering the economic impacts of this final rule on small
entities, USDA certifies that this action will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
While not a factor relevant to determining whether the final rule
will have a significant impact for RFA purposes, USDA has concluded
that the effect of the rule will be to provide positive opportunities
to businesses engaged in the manufacture of these biobased products.
Purchase and use of these biobased products by procuring agencies
increase demand for these products and result in private sector
development of new technologies, creating business and employment
opportunities that enhance local, regional, and national economies.
C. Executive Order 12630: Governmental Actions and Interference With
Constitutionally Protected Property Rights
This final rule has been reviewed in accordance with Executive
Order 12630, Governmental Actions and Interference with
Constitutionally Protected Property Rights, and does not contain
policies that would have implications for these rights.
D. Executive Order 12988: Civil Justice Reform
This rule has been reviewed in accordance with Executive Order
12988, Civil Justice Reform. This rule does not preempt State or local
laws, is not intended to have retroactive effect, and does not involve
administrative appeals.
E. Executive Order 13132: Federalism
This final rule does not have sufficient federalism implications to
warrant the preparation of a Federalism Assessment. Provisions of this
final rule will not have a substantial direct effect on States or their
political subdivisions or on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various government levels.
F. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
This final rule contains no Federal mandates under the regulatory
provisions of Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
(UMRA), 2 U.S.C. 1531-1538, for State, local, and tribal governments,
or the private sector. Therefore, a statement under section 202 of UMRA
is not required.
G. Executive Order 12372: Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs
For the reasons set forth in the Final Rule Related Notice for 7
CFR part 3015, subpart V (48 FR 29115, June 24, 1983), this program is
excluded from the scope of Executive Order 12372, which requires
intergovernmental consultation with State and local officials. This
program does not directly affect State and local governments.
H. Executive Order 13175: Consultation and Coordination With Indian
Tribal Governments
Today's final rule does not significantly or uniquely affect ``one
or more Indian tribes, * * * the relationship between the Federal
Government and Indian tribes, or * * * the distribution of power and
responsibilities between the Federal Government and Indian tribes.''
Thus, no further action is required under Executive Order 13175.
I. Paperwork Reduction Act
In accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C.
3501 through 3520), the information collection under this final rule is
currently approved under OMB control number 0503-0011.
J. E-Government Act Compliance
USDA is committed to compliance with the E-Government Act, which
requires Government agencies, in general, to provide the public the
option of submitting information or transacting business electronically
to the maximum extent possible. USDA is implementing an electronic
information system for posting information voluntarily submitted by
manufacturers or vendors on the products they intend to offer for
preferred procurement under each designated item. For information
pertinent to E-Government Act compliance related to this rule, please
contact Ron Buckhalt at (202) 205-4008.
[[Page 43817]]
K. Congressional Review Act
The Congressional Review Act, 5 U.S.C. 801 et seq., as added by the
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996, generally
provides that before a rule may take effect, the agency promulgating
the rule must submit a rule report, that includes a copy of the rule,
to each House of the Congress and to the Comptroller General of the
United States. USDA has submitted a report containing this rule and
other required information to the U.S. Senate, the U.S. House of
Representatives, and the Comptroller General of the United States prior
to publication of the rule in the Federal Register.
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 2902
Biobased products, Procurement.
For the reasons stated in the preamble, the Department of
Agriculture is amending 7 CFR chapter XXIX as follows:
Chapter XXIX Office of Energy
PART 2902--GUIDELINES FOR DESIGNATING BIOBASED PRODUCTS FOR FEDERAL
PROCUREMENT
0
1. The authority citation for part 2902 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 8102.
0
2. Add Sec. Sec. 2902.61 through 2902.74 to subpart B to read as
follows:
Sec.
2902.61 Animal repellents.
2902.62 Bath products.
2902.63 Bioremediation materials.
2902.64 Compost activators and accelerators.
2902.65 Concrete and asphalt cleaners.
2902.66 Cuts, burns, and abrasions ointments.
2902.67 Dishwashing products.
2902.68 Erosion control materials.
2902.69 Floor cleaners and protectors.
2902.70 Hair care products.
2902.71 Interior paints and coatings.
2902.72 Oven and grill cleaners.
2902.73 Slide way lubricants.
2902.74 Thermal shipping containers.
Sec. 2902.61 Animal repellents.
(a) Definition. Products used to aid in deterring animals that
cause destruction to plants and/or property.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 79 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased animal repellents. By
that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for drafting
or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall ensure that
the relevant specifications require the use of biobased animal
repellents.
Sec. 2902.62 Bath products.
(a) Definition. Personal hygiene products including bar soaps,
liquids, or gels that are referred to as body washes, body shampoos, or
cleansing lotions, but excluding products marketed as hand cleaners
and/or hand sanitizers.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 61 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased bath products. By that
date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for drafting or
reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall ensure that the
relevant specifications require the use of biobased bath products.
Sec. 2902.63 Bioremediation materials.
(a) Definition. Dry or liquid solutions (including those containing
bacteria or other microbes but not including sorbent materials) used to
clean oil, fuel, and other hazardous spill sites.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 86 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased bioremediation
materials. By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility
for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
bioremediation materials.
Sec. 2902.64 Compost activators and accelerators.
(a) Definition. Products in liquid or powder form designed to be
applied to compost piles to aid in speeding up the composting process
and to ensure successful compost that is ready for consumer use.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 95 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased compost activators and
accelerators. By that date, Federal agencies that have the
responsibility for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be
procured shall ensure that the relevant specifications require the use
of biobased compost activators and accelerators.
Sec. 2902.65 Concrete and asphalt cleaners.
(a) Definition. Chemicals used in concrete etching as well as to
remove petroleum-based soils, lubricants, paints, mastics, organic
soils, rust, and dirt from concrete, asphalt, stone and other hard
porous surfaces. Products within this item include only those marketed
for use in commercial or residential construction or industrial
applications.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 70 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased concrete and asphalt
cleaners. By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility
for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
concrete and asphalt cleaners.
Sec. 2902.66 Cuts, burns, and abrasions ointments.
(a) Definition. Products designed to aid in the healing and
sanitizing of scratches, cuts, bruises, abrasions, sun damaged skin,
tattoos, rashes and other skin conditions.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 84 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
[[Page 43818]]
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased cuts, burns, and
abrasions ointments. By that date, Federal agencies that have the
responsibility for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be
procured shall ensure that the relevant specifications require the use
of biobased cuts, burns, and abrasions ointments.
Sec. 2902.67 Dishwashing products.
(a) Definition. Soaps and detergents used for cleaning and clean
rinsing of tableware in either hand washing or dishwashing.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 58 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased dishwashing products. By
that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for drafting
or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall ensure that
the relevant specifications require the use of biobased dishwashing
products.
Sec. 2902.68 Erosion control materials.
(a) Definition. Woven or non-woven fiber materials manufactured for
use on construction, demolition, or other sites to prevent wind or
water erosion of loose earth surfaces, which may be combined with seed
and/or fertilizer to promote growth.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 77 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased erosion control
materials. By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility
for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
erosion control materials.
Sec. 2902.69 Floor cleaners and protectors.
(a) Definition. Cleaning solutions for either direct application or
use in floor scrubbers for wood, vinyl, tile, or similar hard surface
floors. Products within this item are marketed specifically for use on
industrial, commercial, and/or residential flooring.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 77 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased floor cleaners and
protectors. By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility
for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
floor cleaners and protectors.
Sec. 2902.70 Hair care products.
(a) Definitions. (1) Personal hygiene products specifically
formulated for hair cleaning and treating applications, including
shampoos and conditioners.
(2) Hair care products for which Federal preferred procurement
applies are:
(i) Shampoos. These are products whose primary purpose is cleaning
hair. Products that contain both shampoos and conditioners are included
in this subcategory because the primary purpose of these products is
cleaning the hair.
(ii) Conditioners. These are products whose primary purpose is
treating hair to improve the overall condition of hair.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The minimum biobased content for all
hair care products shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased
carbon in the product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total
organic carbon in the finished product. The applicable minimum biobased
contents for the Federal preferred procurement products are:
(1) Shampoos--66 percent.
(2) Conditioners--78 percent.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased hair care products. By
that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for drafting
or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall ensure that
the relevant specifications require the use of biobased hair care
products.
Sec. 2902.71 Interior paints and coatings.
(a) Definition. (1) Pigmented liquids, formulated for use indoors,
that dry to form a film and provide protection and added color to the
objects or surfaces to which they are applied.
(2) Interior paints and coatings products for which Federal
preferred procurement applies are:
(i) Interior latex and waterborne alkyd paints and coatings.
(ii) Interior oil-based and solventborne alkyd paints and coatings.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The minimum biobased content for all
interior paints and coatings products shall be based on the amount of
qualifying biobased carbon in the product as a percent of the weight
(mass) of the total organic carbon in the finished product. The
applicable minimum biobased contents for the Federal preferred
procurement products are:
(1) Interior latex and waterborne alkyd paints and coatings--20
percent.
(2) Interior oil-based and solventborne alkyd paints and coatings--
67 percent.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased interior paints and
coatings. By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility
for drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
interior paints and coatings.
(d) Determining overlap with an EPA-designated recovered content
product. Qualifying biobased products within the interior latex and
waterborne alkyd paints and coatings subcategory may, in some cases,
overlap with the EPA-designated recovered content products: Reprocessed
latex paints and consolidated latex paints. USDA is requesting that
manufacturers of these qualifying biobased products provide information
on the USDA Web site of qualifying biobased products about the intended
uses of the product, information on whether or not the product contains
any recovered material, in addition to biobased ingredients, and
performance standards against which the product has been tested. This
information will assist Federal agencies in determining whether or not
a qualifying biobased product overlaps with EPA-designated reprocessed
latex paints and consolidated latex paints and which product should be
afforded the preference in purchasing.
[[Page 43819]]
Note to paragraph (d): Biobased interior latex and waterborne alkyd
paints and coatings products within this subcategory can compete with
similar reprocessed latex paint and consolidated latex paint products
with recycled content. Under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
of 1976, section 6002, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
designated reprocessed latex paints and consolidated latex paints
containing recovered materials as items for which Federal agencies must
give preference in their purchasing programs. The designation can be
found in the Comprehensive Procurement Guideline, 40 CFR 247.12.
Sec. 2902.72 Oven and grill cleaners.
(a) Definition. Liquid or gel cleaning agents used on high
temperature cooking surfaces such as barbeques, smokers, grills,
stoves, and ovens to soften and loosen charred food, grease, and
residue.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 66 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased oven and grill cleaners.
By that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for
drafting or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall
ensure that the relevant specifications require the use of biobased
oven and grill cleaners.
Sec. 2902.73 Slide way lubricants.
(a) Definition. Products used to provide lubrication and eliminate
stick-slip and table chatter by reducing friction between mating
surfaces, or slides, found in machine tools.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The Federal preferred procurement
product must have a minimum biobased content of at least 74 percent,
which shall be based on the amount of qualifying biobased carbon in the
product as a percent of the weight (mass) of the total organic carbon
in the finished product.
(c) Preference compliance date. No later than July 23, 2012,
procuring agencies, in accordance with this part, will give a
procurement preference for qualifying biobased slide way lubricants. By
that date, Federal agencies that have the responsibility for drafting
or reviewing specifications for items to be procured shall ensure that
the relevant specifications require the use of biobased slide way
lubricants.
Sec. 2902.74 Thermal shipping containers.
(a) Definitions. (1) Insulated containers designed for shipping
temperature-sensitive materials.
(2) Thermal shipping containers for which Federal preferred
procurement applies are:
(i) Durable thermal shipping container. These are thermal shipping
containers that are designed to be reused over an extended period of
time.
(ii) Non-durable thermal shipping containers. These are thermal
shipping containers that are designed to be used once.
(b) Minimum biobased content. The minimum biobased content for all
thermal shipping container products shall be based on the amount of
qualifying biobased carbon in the product as a percent of the weight
(mass) of the total organic carbon in the finished product. The
applicable minimum biobased contents for the Federal preferred
procurement products are:
(1) Durable thermal shipping containers--21 percent.
(2) Non-durable thermal shipping containers--82 percent.
(c) Preference compliance date--(1) Durable thermal shipping
containers. Determination of the preference compliance date for durable
thermal shipping containers is deferred until USDA identifies two or
more manufacturers of biobased durable thermal shipping containers. At
that time, USDA will publish a document in the Federal Register
announcing that Federal agencies have one year from the date of
publication to give procurement preference to biobased durable thermal
shipping containers.
(2) Non-durable thermal shipping containers. Determination of the
preference compliance date for non-durable thermal shipping containers
is deferred until USDA identifies two or more manufacturers of biobased
non-durable thermal shipping containers. At that time, USDA will
publish a document in the Federal Register announcing that Federal
agencies have one year from the date of publication to give procurement
preference to biobased non-durable thermal shipping containers.
Dated: July 15, 2011.
Pearlie S. Reed,
Assistant Secretary for Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture.
[FR Doc. 2011-18478 Filed 7-21-11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410-93-P