[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 139 (Wednesday, July 20, 2011)]
[Notices]
[Pages 43298-43318]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-18082]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
[Docket No. EERE-2006-BC-0132]
RIN 1904-AC42
Building Energy Standards Program: Preliminary Determination
Regarding Energy Efficiency Improvements in the Energy Standard for
Buildings, Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings, ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA
Standard 90.1-2010
AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of
Energy.
ACTION: Notice of preliminary determination.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Department of Energy (DOE) has preliminarily determined
that the 2010 edition of the Energy Standard for Buildings, Except Low-
Rise Residential Buildings, American National Standards Institute
(ANSI)/American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning
Engineers (ASHRAE) Illuminating Engineering Society of North America
(IESNA) Standard 90.1-2010, (Standard 90.1-2010 or the 2010 edition)
would achieve greater energy efficiency in buildings subject to the
code, than the 2007 edition (Standard 90.1-2007 or the 2007 edition).
Also, DOE has preliminarily determined that the quantitative analysis
of the energy consumption of buildings built to Standard 90.1-2010, as
compared with buildings built to Standard 90.1-2007, indicates national
source energy savings of approximately 18.2 percent of commercial
building energy consumption. Additionally, DOE has preliminarily
determined site energy savings are estimated to be approximately 18.5
percent. If these determinations are finalized, States would be
required to certify that they have reviewed the provisions of their
commercial building code regarding energy efficiency, and as necessary,
updated their code to meet or exceed the energy efficiency of Standard
90.1-2010. Additionally, this notice provides guidance to States on
Certifications, and Requests for Extensions of Deadlines for
Certification Statements, should the preliminary determination be
adopted as final.
DATES: Comments on the preliminary determination must be provided by
August 19, 2011.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by any of the following
methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
E-mail: [email protected]. Include RIN
1904-AC42 in the subject line of the message.
Postal Mail: Michael Erbesfeld, U.S. Department of Energy,
Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Forrestal Building,
Mail Station EE-2J, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC
20585-0121, Please submit one signed paper original.
Hand Delivery/Courier: Michael Erbesfeld, U.S. Department
of Energy, Building Technologies Program, Room 6003, 1000 Independence
Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20585-0121.
Instructions: All submissions must include the agency name, Department
of Energy, and docket number, EERE-2006-BC-0132, or Regulatory
Information Number (RIN), 1904-AC42, for this preliminary
determination.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Michael Erbesfeld, U.S. Department of
Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Forrestal
Building, Mail Station EE-2J, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW.,
Washington, DC 20585-0121, (202) 287-1874, e-mail:
[email protected]. For legal issues contact Mrs. Kavita
Vaidyanathan, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of the General Counsel,
Forrestal Building, GC-71, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington,
DC 20585, (202) 586-0669, e-mail: [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Introduction
A. Statutory Requirements
B. Background
1. Publication of Standard 90.1-2010
2. Analysis Methodology
II. Summary of the Comparative Analysis
A. Qualitative Analysis
1. Discussion of Detailed Textual Analysis
2. Results of Detailed Textual Analysis
B. Quantitative Analysis
1. Discussion of Whole Building Energy Analysis
2. Results of Whole Building Energy Analysis
C. Preliminary Determination Statement
III. Filing Certification Statements With DOE
A. Review and Update
B. Certification
C. Requests for Extensions to Certify
IV. Regulatory Analysis
A. Review Under Executive Order 12866
B. Review Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act
C. Review Under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
D. Review Under Executive Order 13132, ``Federalism''
E. Review Under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
F. Review Under the Treasury and General Government
Appropriations Act of 1999
G. Review Under the Treasury and General Government
Appropriations Act of 2001
H. Review Under Executive Order 13211
I. Review Under Executive Order 13175
V. Public Participation
I. Introduction
A. Statutory Requirements
Title III of the Energy Conservation and Production Act, as amended
(ECPA), establishes requirements for the Building Energy Efficiency
Standards Program. (42 U.S.C. 6831 et seq.) Section 304(b), as amended,
of ECPA provides that whenever the ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-1989
(Standard 90.1-1989 or 1989 edition), or any successor to that code, is
revised, the Secretary must make a determination, not later than 12
months after such revision, whether the revised code would improve
energy efficiency in commercial buildings and must publish notice of
such determination in the Federal Register. (42 U.S.C. 6833 (b)(2)(A))
The Secretary may determine that the revision of Standard 90.1-1989 or
any successor thereof, improves the level of energy efficiency in
commercial buildings. If so, then not later than two years after the
date of the publication of
[[Page 43299]]
such affirmative determination, each State is required to certify that
it has reviewed and updated the provisions of its commercial building
code regarding energy efficiency with respect to the revised or
successor code. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(B)(i)) The State must include in
its certification a demonstration that the provisions of its commercial
building code, regarding energy efficiency, meet or exceed the revised
standard. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(B)(i))
If the Secretary makes a determination that the revised standard
will not improve energy efficiency in commercial buildings, State
commercial codes shall meet or exceed the last revised standard for
which the Secretary has made a positive determination. (42 U.S.C.
6833(b)(2)(B)(ii)). Published elsewhere in this Federal Register issue
is the DOE's final determination updating the reference code to
Standard 90.1-2007.
ECPA also requires the Secretary to permit extensions of the
deadlines for the State certification if a State can demonstrate that
it has made a good faith effort to comply with the requirements of
Section 304(c) of ECPA and that it has made significant progress in
doing so. (42 U.S.C. 6833(c))
B. Background
1. Publication of Standard 90.1-2010
ASHRAE and the Illuminating Engineering Society of North America
(IESNA) approved the publication of the 2010 edition of Energy Standard
for Buildings Except Low-rise Residential Buildings, in October 2010.
The Standard was developed under ANSI-approved consensus standard
procedures. Standard 90.1 is under continuous maintenance by a Standing
Standard Project Committee (SSPC) for which the ASHRAE Standard
Committee has established a documented program for regular publication
of addenda or revisions, including procedures for timely, documented,
consensus action on requests for change to any part of the standard.
The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) approves addenda prior
to their publication by ASHRAE and IESNA and prior to their inclusion
in a new version of Standard 90.1. ANSI approved the final addendum for
inclusion in Standard 90.1-2010 on July 24, 2010. Appeals were made to
several addenda and the results of the appeals process was not final
until October 15, 2010. The 2010 edition was published on October 28,
2010.
2. Analysis Methodology
In arriving at a preliminary determination, the DOE first reviewed
all significant changes between the 2010 edition and the 2007 edition
of Standard 90.1. Standard 90.1 is complex and covers a broad spectrum
of the energy related components and systems in buildings ranging from
simple storage buildings to complex hospitals and laboratories. The
size of buildings addressed range from those smaller than single family
homes to the largest buildings in the world. The approach to
development of the standard used in the 2010 edition was not changed
from that used for the 2007 edition, with no changes to the scope or
the way components are defined. DOE preliminarily determined that
because no significant changes were made to the structure, scope, or
component definitions of Standard 90.1-2007, a similar methodology used
for the analysis of Standard 90.1-2007 could be utilized for the
analysis of Standard 90.1-2010, consisting of a qualitative comparison
of the textual changes to requirements in Standard 90.1-2010 from
Standard 90.1-2007, and a quantitative estimate of the energy savings
developed from whole building simulations of a standard set of
buildings constructed to both Standards over a range of U.S. climates.
DOE used an extension of the procedure used for the Standard 90.1-2007
determination for the quantitative estimate of energy savings. The
extension was that additional building types were added to the
analysis. DOE used the same simulation tool and data for weighing the
results by building type and climate as used for the 90.1-2007
determination.
A discussion of the analysis methodology, which was subject to
public comment in 2009, can be found in the Notice of Preliminary
Determination for Standard 90.1-2007, which was published in the
Federal Register. 75 FR 54117 (Sept. 3, 2010)
DOE recognizes that the methodology proposed for the quantitative
analysis will be insufficient for determining an absolute
quantification of energy savings estimates associated with using
Standard 90.1-2010 (e.g., total quads of energy savings) and makes no
such claim for the analysis on which this preliminary determination
relies. DOE's quantitative analysis includes many of the changes
brought about in Standard 90.1-2010 that can be modeled, but this
quantitative analysis is not able to quantify accurately all the likely
effects of the new standard. In particular, the degree to which the
market may react to certain changes brought about following the
adoption of a new building code, and the degree to which different
requirements are currently being met or will be met in future
construction, are exceedingly difficult to ascertain and would affect
the absolute quantification of energy savings. However, DOE believes
that the quantitative determination process outlined does provide a
reasonable approach to establishing whether, in concert, the changes
brought about by ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2010 will result in improved
energy efficiency in buildings over ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2007.
DOE continues to believe that the preliminary determination should
rely on both quantitative and qualitative comparisons. While
quantitative estimates of energy savings are indeed a much preferred
method of comparison, it is not always possible to simulate or provide
appropriate weighting to many features in Standard 90.1. Therefore, DOE
will continue to note changes that individually or in net result in
increased energy efficiency, even where they could not be accurately
quantified. States can use this information when upgrading their energy
codes.
DOE continues to believe that the quantitative analysis should be
based on the minimum requirements of each standard that reflect the
minimum set of options available in new construction. In assessing the
impact of those requirements, DOE also believes that assessment should
be based on an estimate of typical construction practices. DOE believes
that this has been done in the quantitative analysis.
For this preliminary determination, DOE utilized 5 years of
previous building construction data, as developed using proprietary
F.W. Dodge building statistical data by building type and by location
down to the county level and purchased by DOE, to develop weighting
factors to weight the building simulation results. (A summary of the
data is available in a PNNL report--PNNL-19116--Jarnagin and
Bandyopodhyay, 2010, Weighting Factors for the Commercial Building
Prototypes used in the Development of ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-
2010 at http://www.pnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-19116.pdf.) Past determinations have relied on new
construction floor space growth estimates extracted from the Energy
Information Administration's (EIA) National Energy Modeling System
(NEMS) as the basis for weighting energy savings across building types
and regions. DOE believes that for the purpose of this analysis the
F.W. Dodge construction data provides better
[[Page 43300]]
mapping of actual construction by region and building type than could
be obtained using the EIA/NEMS data. In particular, the use of county-
level construction data allowed DOE to develop building construction
statistics directly reflecting construction in each of the ASHRAE
climate regions, avoiding many assumptions on regional construction
volume that would be necessary using the EIA/NEMS data.
Consistent with the previous analysis for Standard 90.1-2007, DOE
compared versions of Standard 90.1 ``as a whole'' and did not issue
determinations for individual addenda. DOE interprets the language in
Section 304(b)(2) of ECPA to mean that when a comprehensive revision of
the ASHRAE Standard is published (which in this case is ASHRAE Standard
90.1-2010), then that revised or successor standard triggers the
Secretary's obligation to issue a determination as to whether the
revised standard improves energy efficiency. This determination is made
by comparing the revised or successor standard to the last predecessor
standard. While the addenda process is part of the ongoing maintenance
of the standard and thus continually modifies or revises the existing
standard over time, it would be an unreasonable reading of the statute
to categorize each addenda in this maintenance process as a ``revised
or successor standard'' within the meaning of Section 304(b)(2) of
ECPA, so as to require a determination by the Secretary. Such an
interpretation of the statute would put an unreasonable burden both on
the States and DOE. For the States, a determination by the Secretary
requires some State action, and what is required depends upon whether
the Secretary issues an affirmative or a negative determination. If the
Secretary were required to issue a determination after each addenda was
published, the States would be constantly required to change their
codes. This would affect the stability and certainty of State
commercial building codes.
The statutory language in Section 304(b) of ECPA states that the
Secretary is required to make a determination as to whether any
successor standard to ASHRAE Standard 90.1-1989 will improve energy
efficiency. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(A)) The Secretary must publish a
notice of this determination in the Federal Register. The language does
not require that DOE perform an independent economic analysis as part
of the determination process. Section 304(b) of ECPA does not include
any reference to language concerning economic justification.
However, Congress did address consideration of the technological
feasibility and cost effectiveness of the Voluntary Building Energy
Codes. Section 307 of ECPA requires DOE to participate in the ASHRAE
process and to assist in determining the cost effectiveness and
technical feasibility of the ASHRAE standard. (42 U.S.C. 6836) It also
requires DOE to periodically review the economic basis of the voluntary
building energy codes and participate in the industry process for
review and modification, including seeking adoption of all
technologically feasible and economically justified energy efficiency
measures. (42 U.S.C. 6836(b))
The fact that the Section 304 of ECPA determination process does
not require the Secretary to perform an economic analysis does not
diminish the importance that the ASHRAE standards be technologically
feasible and economically justified. However, the statute addresses
these issues by directing DOE to participate in the ASHRAE process
itself.
DOE has chosen to use the same DOE Reference Buildings (formerly
called Benchmark buildings) in the quantitative analysis for Standard
90.1-2010 as used in the Standard 90.1-2007 quantitative analysis. The
only significant difference is that one additional building model,
representing high-rise multi-family construction is now available for
use in the analysis.
DOE's preliminary quantitative determination was carried out using
the EnergyPlus building simulation tool. DOE switched to use of
EnergyPlus for the Standard 90.1-2007 analysis and has continued to use
Energy Plus since then. The current version of Energy Plus, EnergyPlus
version 4.0, was used for this preliminary determination.
II. Summary of the Comparative Analysis
DOE carried out both a detailed qualitative analysis and a broad
quantitative analysis of the differences between the requirements and
the stringencies in the 2007 and the 2010 editions of Standard 90.1.
A. Qualitative Analysis
1. Discussion of Detailed Textual Analysis
DOE performed a detailed analysis of the differences between the
textual requirements and stringencies of the 2007 and 2010 editions in
the scope of the standard, the building envelope requirements, the
building lighting and power requirements, and the building mechanical
equipment requirements.
The emphasis of DOE's detailed requirement and stringency analysis
was on looking at the specific changes that ASHRAE made in going from
Standard 90.1-2007 to Standard 90.1-2010. ASHRAE publishes changes to
their standards as addenda to the preceding standard and then bundles
all the addenda together to form the next edition. ASHRAE processed 109
addenda to Standard 90.1-2007 to create Standard 90.1-2010. Each of
these addenda was evaluated by DOE in preparing this preliminary
determination.
In addition, each standard has multiple ways to demonstrate
compliance, including a prescriptive set of requirements by section of
the standard, various tradeoff approaches within those same sections,
and a whole building performance method (Energy Cost Budget or ECB).
For each addendum DOE identified whether it applies to the prescriptive
requirements, or one of the tradeoff paths provided for in the
envelope, lighting, or mechanical sections, or the ECB whole building
performance path. For each addendum DOE identified the impact on the
stringency for that path to compliance.
Overall, DOE found that the vast majority of changes made to
Standard 90.1-2007 to create Standard 90.1-2010 were positive or
neutral (in the context of energy efficiency). Positive changes greatly
outweighed the negative energy efficiency changes. Specifically, of the
109 total changes:
56 were considered positive,
47 were considered neutral,
6 were considered negative.
The 56 positive changes greatly overwhelm the 6 negative changes in
terms of a simple numerical comparison. In addition, the 6 negative
changes were considered to be ``minor negatives'', with 19 of the
positive changes being considered ``major positive'' and an additional
37 positive changes being considered ``minor positive''. Not only do
the positive changes outweigh the negative changes in raw numbers, but
also in terms of the estimated impact.
2. Results of Detailed Textual Analysis
Table 1 presents the results of DOE's addendum-by-addendum analysis
of Standard 90.1-2010. Table 6 is a reformatted and slightly modified
version of a table in the preliminary qualitative analysis. The
complete preliminary qualitative analysis may be found on the DOE codes
Web site at http://www.energycodes.gov/status/determinations_com.stm.
[[Page 43301]]
Table 1--Results of Addendum-by-Addendum Analysis
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Impact on energy
No. Addendum to Section affected Description of efficiency and
Standard 90.1-2007 changes reason
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1................... a................... 6. Heating, Remove closed cooling 0 (clarifies that
Ventilating, and Air tower requirements requirements do not
Conditioning. from 6.8.1G. apply to closed
cooling towers).
2................... b................... 6. Heating, Revises exception a Minor - (allows
Ventilating, and Air to section 6.5.2.3 larger minimum
Conditioning. to allow for codes ventilation rates if
other than ASHRAE required by other
62.1 to dictate codes).
minimum ventilation
rates.
3................... c................... 6. Heating, Adds vivarium to list Minor - (allows
Ventilating, and Air of spaces that exception to
Conditioning. require specific dehumidification
humidity levels to controls for
satisfy process vivariums).
needs.
4................... d................... 3. Definitions, Adds exceptions for Major + (requires
Abbreviations, and Solar Heat Gain daylighting controls
Acronyms; 5. Building Coefficient (SHGC) under skylights and
Envelope; 9. Lighting. and Visible commissioning of
Transmittance (VT) daylighting
requirements for controls).
skylights; adds
requirement for
including visible
light transmittance
test results with
construction
documents; adds
information on
determining daylit
area under
skylights, automatic
daylighting controls
(with exceptions),
and submittal
requirements.
5................... e................... 6. Heating, Changes exhaust air Major + (increased
Ventilating, and Air energy recovery use of heat
Conditioning. requirements and recovery).
harmonizes
requirements in
simplified section
6.3.2 with
requirements in the
6.5 prescriptive
path.
6................... f................... 5. Building Envelope.. Requires high albedo Major + (requires
roofs in hot cool roofs in hot
climates. climates).
7................... g................... 3. Definitions, Updates building Minor + (increases
Abbreviations, and envelope criteria envelope
Acronyms; 5. Building for metal buildings. requirements for
Envelope. metal buildings).
8................... h................... 6. Heating, Adds another Minor + (allows
Ventilating, and Air exception to Section another exception
Conditioning. 6.5.2.1 Limitation that saves energy in
of Simultaneous some applications).
Heating and Cooling.
The exception
addresses apparent
conflict between
standards and allows
users to achieve
comfort, meet the
code, and save
energy.
9................... i................... 9. Lighting........... Applies a four-zone Major + (lowers
lighting power illuminance
density approach to requirements in
exterior lighting certain zones).
requirements.
Deletes the 5%
additional power
allowance in 9.4.5
and replaces it with
a base wattage
allowance per site.
Defines the four
zones and applies
the appropriate
requirements.
10.................. j................... 6. Heating, Updates the 0 (updating
Ventilating, and Air mechanical test references).
Conditioning; 12. procedures
Normative References; references in the
Appendix E. standard. The
Informative changes also modify
References. a reference in Table
6.8.1E, the
normative references
in Chapter 12, and
the informative
references in
Informative Appendix
E.
11.................. k................... 6. Heating, Updates Tables 6.8.1E 0 (updating tables to
Ventilating, and Air and 7.8 to identify reflect current
Conditioning. specific sections of federal standards).
referenced
standards. Table 7.8
also reflects the
current federal
efficiency levels
for residential
water heaters and
adds a requirement
for electric table-
top water heaters.
12.................. l................... 6. Heating, Adds minimum 0 (Requirement
Ventilating, and Air efficiency and codifies industry
Conditioning. certification standard practice).
requirements for
axial and
centrifugal fan
closed-circuit
cooling towers. Also
adds a reference to
ATC-105S, The
Cooling Technology
Institute test
standard for closed-
circuit cooling
towers to Section 12.
[[Page 43302]]
13.................. m................... 6. Heating, Updates chiller Major + (updates
Ventilating, and Air efficiency chiller efficiency
Conditioning. requirements. requirements).
Establishes
additional path of
compliance for water-
cooled chillers.
Combines all water-
cooled chillers into
one category and
adds a new size
category for
centrifugal chillers
at or above 600 tons.
14.................. n................... 6. Heating, Extends Variable Air Major + (extends
Ventilating, and Air Volume (VAV) fan control requirements
Conditioning. control requirements to another equipment
to large single-zone class).
units.
15.................. o................... 8. Power.............. Modifies the scope of 0 (implements Federal
Section 8 and adds efficiency standards
requirements for transformers).
specific to low
voltage dry-type
distribution
transformers.
16.................. p................... 6. Heating, Provides pressure Minor - (increases
Ventilating, and Air credits for allowable pressure
Conditioning. laboratory exhaust drop in laboratory
systems that allow exhaust systems).
prescriptive
compliance with the
standard.
17.................. q................... 5. Building Envelope.. Vestibules, remove Minor + (applies
CZ4 exception. vestibule
requirement in more
locations).
18.................. r................... Informative Appendix Changes Informative 0 (performance rating
G. Performance Rating Appendix G method only).
Method. Performance Rating
Method into a
Normative Appendix.
Additionally, some
language has been
modified to make the
Appendix Enforceable.
19.................. s................... 6. Heating, Updates the 0 (replaces
Ventilating, and Air Coefficient of Integrated Part Load
Conditioning. Performance (COP) at Value (IPLV) with
17 [deg]F efficiency Energy Efficiency
levels for Ratio (EER) to
commercial heat capture part load
pumps and introduces performance).
a new part-load
energy efficiency
descriptor (IEER)
for all commercial
unitary products
above 65,000 Btu/h
of cooling capacity.
20.................. t................... 6. Heating, Removes the term 0 (clarification of
Ventilating, and Air ``replacement'' and definitions).
Conditioning. ``new construction''
from the product
classes listed in
Table 6.8.1D and
replaces them with
the terms
``nonstandard size''
and ``standard
size'' to clarify
that one product
class is intended
for applications
with nonstandard
size exterior wall
openings while the
other is intended
for applications
with standard size
exterior wall
openings. Also
amends section
6.4.1.5.2 and
footnote b to Table
6.8.1D to clarify
that nonstandard
size packaged
terminal equipment
have sleeves with an
external wall
opening less than 16
in. high or less
than 42 in. wide to
reflect existing
applications where
the wall opening is
not necessarily less
than 16 in. high and
less than 42 in.
wide. However, to
avoid a potential
abuse of the
definition,
nonstandard size
packaged terminal
equipment are
required to have a
cross-sectional area
of the sleeves less
than 670 in\2\.
21.................. u................... 6. Heating, Adds a new section Minor + (applies
Ventilating, and Air requiring cooling tower
Conditioning. centrifugal fan open- requirements more
circuit cooling broadly).
towers over 1100 gpm
at the rating
conditions to meet
efficiency
requirements for
axial fan units
found in 6.8.1G.
[[Page 43303]]
22.................. v................... 6. Heating, Revises section 0 (updates
Ventilating, and Air 6.4.2.1 to reference references).
Conditioning; 12. ANSI/ASHRAE/ACCA
Normative References. Standard 183-2007
for sizing heating
and cooling system
design loads. Adds
requirements for
calculating pump
head.
23.................. w................... Normative Appendix G. Changes footnote to 0 (performance rating
Performance Rating Table G3.1.1A to method)
Method. make it clear that
Exception a to
Section G3.1.1 also
applies here.
Changes the
exception to
G3.1.2.10 on Exhaust
Air Energy Recovery
for multifamily
buildings because
they are unlikely to
have a centralized
exhaust air system
needed to
effectively recover
heat.
24.................. x................... 9. Lighting........... Updates requirements Major + (adds
for automatic occupancy sensor
lighting shutoff, requirements for
adds specific many specific
occupancy sensor applications).
applications, and
provides additional
clarification.
25.................. y................... 7. Service Water Establishes ARI 1160 Minor + (requires COP
Heating. as the test be met at lower
procedure for heat temperature).
pump pool heaters
and requires that
the minimum COP of 4
be met at the low
outdoor temperature
of 50 [deg]F.
26.................. aa.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds space exceptions Minor + (limits
for automatic automatic-on
lighting controls. controls to specific
space types).
27.................. ab.................. 3. Definitions, Adds definitions and Major + (adds
Abbreviations, and provides daylighting daylighting control
Acronyms; and 9. control requirements requirements for
Lighting. for side-lighted side-lighted
spaces. spaces).
28.................. ac.................. 3. Definitions, Adds incentives to 0 (alternate
Abbreviations, and use advanced compliance path).
Acronyms; 9. Lighting. lighting controls.
29.................. ad.................. 6. Heating, Includes 0 (documentation
Ventilating, and Air certification only).
Conditioning. requirements for
liquid-to-liquid
heat exchangers to
benefit both
manufacturers and
consumers, allow
product comparisons,
and provide
incentives to
manufacturers to
improve efficiency
in order to gain
market share.
30.................. ae.................. 6. Heating, Adds a requirement Minor + (reduced heat
Ventilating, and Air for insulating the loss in radiant
Conditioning. surfaces of radiant panels).
panels that do not
face conditioned
spaces.
31.................. af.................. 6. Heating, Provides requirement Minor + (requires
Ventilating, and Air for designers, proper hydronic
Conditioning. contractors, and system sizing).
owners to properly
size system piping
(hydronic systems)
to balance ongoing
energy costs and
first costs.
32.................. ag.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Adds requirement for Minor + (reduces
rigid board potential for
insulation overlap. thermal bridging).
33.................. ai.................. Normative Appendix G. Removes requirement 0 (alternative
Performance Rating for comparing compliance path).
Method. proposed buildings
utilizing chilled
water with a
baseline building
with on-site
chillers, and
instead requires a
baseline that also
uses purchased
chilled water.
Details
modifications to be
made to the baseline
HVAC systems when
purchased chilled
water or heat are
included.
34.................. aj.................. 10. Other Equipment... Updates the text and 0 (implements Federal
table of Chapter 10 motor requirements).
to comply with new
federal law for
motors rated at 1.0
horsepower and
greater. Adding this
information will
help designers, end-
use customers, and
code officials with
motor specifications
and verifications.
[[Page 43304]]
35.................. ak.................. 6. Heating, Adds a pump isolation Minor + (reduces
Ventilating, and Air requirement for pumping energy).
Conditioning. systems with
multiple chillers
and boilers and
temperature reset
requirement for
equipment with a
minimum Btu/h.
Revises wording to
have requirements of
6.5.4.1 apply only
to cooling systems.
Changes threshold of
variable speed
systems to 7.5 HP.
Adds requirement for
differential
pressure reset. Does
not preclude also
implementing chilled
water supply
temperature setpoint
reset. Includes
requirements for
hydronic Heat Pump
and Water-Cooled
Unitary Air
Conditioners.
36.................. al.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Adds skylight Major + (requires
requirements in skylights and
certain space types daylighting in some
(enclosed spaces) to building types.
promote daylighting
energy savings.
37.................. am.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Revise air leakage Minor + (decreased
criteria for air leakage).
fenestration and
doors.
38.................. an.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Expands table of 0 (updates default
default U-values for tables).
single-digit rafter
roofs.
39.................. ao.................. 6. Heating, Repairs know errata 0 (editorial only).
Ventilating, and Air to Table 6.8.1E and
Conditioning. re-orders the notes
to properly organize
them. Corrects the
error of identifying
EC, which should be
listed as Et under
``Warm Air Furnaces,
Gas-Fired'' and also
eliminates incorrect
and redundant
footnotes.
40.................. ap.................. 6. Heating, Includes demand Major + (reduces
Ventilating, and Air controlled ventilation energy).
Conditioning. ventilation in the
simplified approach.
41.................. aq.................. Title, 1. Purpose, and Modify Title Purpose 0 (no impact now, but
2. Scope. & Scope of ASHRAE does allow future
90.1. positive additions
to Standard 90.1).
42.................. ar.................. 9. Lighting........... Corrects an oversight 0 (editorial only).
in previous versions
where expanded
exterior lighting
power limits were
put in place but the
details of how to
calculate the
installed power and
compare it to the
limits was not
included. This
language revision
puts the needed
details in the
standard.
43.................. as.................. 6. Heating, Removes exception for Minor + (saves large
Ventilating, and Air VAV turndown amount of fan and
Conditioning. requirements for reheat energy in
zones with special hospitals).
pressurization
requirements.
Reduces laboratory
threshold where VAV
or heat recovery is
required.
44.................. at.................. 6. Heating, Clears up 0 (editorial only).
Ventilating, and Air inconsistencies and
Conditioning. conflicts regarding
damper requirements
in Chapter 6.
45.................. au.................. 6. Heating, Updates efficiency 0 (alternate
Ventilating, and Air tradeoff table for compliance path).
Conditioning. eliminating
economizers.
46.................. av.................. 9. Lighting........... Changes Section 9.1.2 Major + (expansion of
to require that in new lighting power
all spaces where densities to more
alterations take retrofits).
place, all
requirements of
Section 9 are met.
Changes exception so
that the lighting
power density (LPD)
requirements of the
standard are met in
the altered space if
less than 10% of
luminaries are
replaced.
[[Page 43305]]
47.................. aw.................. 9. Lighting........... Recognizes practical Minor - (adds
design application additional lighting
of excluding allowance).
bathroom lighting
from ``master''
switch control in
hotel/motel guest
rooms and adds a
requirement to
eliminate wasted
light in guest room
bathrooms. Adds a 5W
allowance for night
lights that
recognizes the
practical current
design application
of guest room
bathroom night light
use but at a
reasonable low level.
48.................. ax.................. 3. Definitions, Expands requirements Minor + (more
Abbreviations, and for Kitchen Exhaust stringent kitchen
Acronyms; 6. Heating, Systems (formerly exhaust
Ventilating, and Air Kitc8.4.1hen Hoods). requirements).
Conditioning. Includes addition of
definitions for
transfer air,
replacement air, and
makeup air. Add
Table 6.5.7.1.3
defining the maximum
exhaust flow rate
through various hood
types (CFM/Linear
Foot of Hood
Length). Include
provisions for hoods
with flows greater
than 5,000 CFM.
Require performance
testing to evaluate
design airflow rates
and demonstrate
capture and
containment
performance.
49.................. ay.................. 9. Lighting........... Change that requires Minor + (requires
users to identify users to use proper
spaces by function. LPDs).
50.................. az.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds requirements for Minor + (requires
lighting controls to testing of lighting
be functionally systems).
tested to ensure
proper use and
appropriate energy
savings.
51.................. ba.................. 6. Heating, Allows a system 0 (alternative
Ventilating, and Air performance option compliance path).
Conditioning. that allows for
compensating for the
insulating value of
the piping while
maintaining the same
net thermal
requirements.
52.................. bc.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Clarifies that the 0 (clarification
requirements in only).
Section 5.5.4.2.3
are also specified
for unconditioned
spaces.
53.................. bd.................. 8. Power.............. Removes emergency 0 (removes emergency
circuits not used circuits from
for normal building requirements, but
operation from the only impact is when
requirements which emergency circuits
will lead to are activated).
increased
compliance. Allows
for an increased
conformance/use of
90.1 standard by
eliminating issues
of impracticality of
feeder drop
requirements for
emergency circuits
and provides
significant initial
cost savings.
54.................. bf.................. 3. Definitions, Modifies language to Minor + (reduces air
Abbreviations, and include performance leakage allowances
Acronyms; 4. requirements for air in opaque envelope).
Administration and leakage of the
Enforcement; 5. opaque envelope.
Building Envelope.
55.................. bg.................. 6. Heating, Establishes a product Minor + (adds
Ventilating, and Air class for water-to- requirement where no
Conditioning; 12. water heat pumps. requirement
Normative References. Intent is to previously existed).
recognize the
technology in 90.1
by requiring minimum
energy efficiency
standards. Cooling
Energy Efficiency
Ratios (EERs) and
heating COPs are
proposed for
products with
cooling capacities
below 135,000 Btu/h
at standard rating
conditions listed in
International
Organization for
Standardization
(ISO) standard 13256-
2.
[[Page 43306]]
56.................. bh.................. 6. Heating, Provides requirements Major + (requires
Ventilating, and Air for multiple zone supply air
Conditioning. HVAC systems (that temperature reset
include simultaneous for non-peak
heating and cooling) conditions).
to include controls
that automatically
raise the supply air-
temperature when the
spaces served are
not at peak load
conditions. Allows
an override of the
temperature reset if
a maximum space
humidity setpoint is
exceeded. There is
an exception from
this requirement for
warm and humid
climate zones 1a,
2a, and 3a.
57.................. bi.................. 6. Heating, Updates requirements Minor + (reduced
Ventilating, and Air for piping piping heat loss/
Conditioning. insulation, gain).
including
incorporation of new
90.1 SPPC economic
criteria used in
developing standard
requirements. Adds
footnotes to address
constrained
locations and
clarify requirements
for direct buried
piping.
58.................. bj.................. Normative Appendix G. Adds an exception 0 (alternative
Performance Rating within Appendix G compliance path).
Method. that allows users to
claim energy cost
savings credit for
the increased
ventilation
effectiveness of
certain HVAC system
designs.
59.................. bk.................. 3. Definitions, Includes the minimum 0 (clarification
Abbreviations and efficiency only).
Acronyms; and 10. requirements for
Other Equipment. both Subtype I and
Subtype II motors as
well as clarifies
what specific motor
types these
requirements apply
to.
60.................. bl.................. 6. Heating, Corrects the intent Minor + (removes
Ventilating, and Air of the standard to exemption for some
Conditioning. not exempt all chillers).
chillers with
secondary coolants
for freeze
protection from
coverage by Table
6.8.1C and removes
ambiguity. Changes
footnote a to Table
6.8.1C in
recognition of lower
practical scope
limits for the lower
limit introduced in
Addendum M for
centrifugal chillers.
61.................. bm.................. 5. Building Envelope.. Coordinates 0 (terminology only).
terminology for
visible
transmittance with
NFRC 200.
62.................. bn.................. 5. Building Envelope; Limits use of poorly Minor + (limits poor
11. Energy Cost oriented fenestration
Budget Method. fenestration--compli orientation).
ance shown by having
more south-facing
than west-facing
fenestration.
Provides exceptions
for retail glass and
buildings
potentially shaded
from the south or
west. Exception also
provided for certain
additions and
alterations.
63.................. bo.................. Normative Appendix G. Effort to keep 0 (alternative
Performance Rating requirements of compliance path).
Method. Section 11 and
Appendix G
consistent with
other addenda. Makes
changes related to
Addenda E, S, and U.
64.................. bp.................. 9. Lighting........... Allows the use of Minor + (allows use
control that of additional energy
provides automatic saving control
50% auto on with the strategy).
capability to
manually activate
the remaining 50%
and has full auto-
off.
65.................. bq.................. 9. Lighting........... Retail lighting Minor + (lower retail
additional allowance lighting energy).
levels reduced.
66.................. br.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds an exterior zone Minor + (reduced
0 to cover very low exterior lighting
light requirement energy).
areas.
[[Page 43307]]
67.................. bs.................. 8. Power.............. Adds requirements to Minor + (reduces
provide a means for energy use during
non-critical unoccupied periods).
receptacle loads to
be automatically
controlled based on
occupancy or
scheduling without
additional
individual desktop
or similar
controllers.
68.................. bt.................. 6. Heating, Modifies equation for Minor + (chillers
Ventilating, and Air determining the that were previously
Conditioning. performance exempt are no longer
adjustment factor exempt).
for chillers under
nonstandard
conditions. Adds
labeling
requirements for
chillers to make
compliance
determinations
simpler.
69.................. bu.................. 3. Definitions, Modifies and adds to Major + (adds
Abbreviations, and requirements for efficiency
Acronyms; and 6. computer rooms. requirements for
Heating, Ventilating, data centers).
and Air Conditioning.
70.................. bv.................. Normative Appendix G. Effort to keep 0 (alternative
Performance Rating requirements of compliance paths).
Method. Section 11 and
Appendix G
consistent with
other addenda to
90.1. This addendum
includes changes to
Section 11 and
Appendix G due to
Addendum Y, AJ, BK,
and AX.
71.................. bw.................. 6. Heating, Amends minimum energy 0 (implements
Ventilating, and Air efficiency existing Federal
Conditioning. requirements for standards).
standard-size
package terminal
equipment to be
consistent with the
new federal
standards.
72.................. bx.................. 6. Heating, Supplements changes Minor + (limits
Ventilating, and Air made in addendums H reheat supply air
Conditioning. and AS. Attempts to temperatures).
bring into alignment
requirements of
ASHRAE 90.1 and
ASHRAE 62.1. Limits
the reheat supply
air temperature from
ceiling supply air
devices to achieve
better room air
distribution and
reduce short-
circuiting of air
into ceiling return
air inlets. Promotes
alternative methods
of heating perimeter
spaces with high
heat losses other
than use of a VAV
box with terminal
reheat.
73.................. by.................. 3. Definitions, Revision represents a Major + (lowered
Abbreviations, and complete review, lighting power
Acronyms;. update, correction, densities).
9. Lighting........... and restructuring of
the modeling and
calculation basis
for the space type
and resulting whole
building type
lighting power
densities.
74.................. ca.................. 6. Heating, Closes a loophole in Minor + (removes fan
Ventilating, and Air the fan power power allowance for
Conditioning. allowances for VAV systems without
single zone variable terminal units).
air volume (VAV)
systems.
75.................. cb.................. 6. Heating, Adds requirement for Major + (expansion of
Ventilating, and Air simple systems to automatic damper
Conditioning. meet prescriptive requirements).
outdoor air damper
requirements. Allows
backdraft dampers
only for exhaust and
relief dampers in
buildings less than
3 stories in height.
Requires backdraft
dampers on outdoor
air intakes to be
protected from wind
limiting windblown
infiltration through
the damper. Moves
climate zone 5a to
the category of
climates that
require low leak
dampers. Corrects a
mistake in Table
6.4.3.4.4. Reformats
Table 6.4.3.4.4 for
clarity.
76.................. cc.................. 6. Heating, Corrects a mistake in Minor - (increases
Ventilating, and Air the way 8'' pipe was allowable flow rate
Conditioning. analyzed. in 8'' pipe).
[[Page 43308]]
77.................. cd.................. 9. Lighting........... Additions to (1) Major + (requires
strengthen language control of exterior
to actually require lighting--savings
exterior control during night when
rather than just lights not needed).
require the control
capability, (2) add
bi-level control for
general all-night
applications such as
parking lots to
reduce lighting when
not needed, and (3)
add control for
fa[ccedil]ade and
landscape lighting
not needed after
midnight.
78.................. ce.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds requirements for 0 (manual control
multilevel control requirement).
capability (bi-level
switching) in all
spaces except those
specifically
exempted.
79.................. cf.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds requirements for Minor + (energy
automatic reduction savings through use
of stairway lighting of controls in
within 30 minutes of stairways).
occupants exiting
the zone.
80.................. ch.................. 11. Energy Cost Budget Clarifies baseline 0 (alternative
Method; Normative minimum setpoints compliance path).
Appendix G. for fan-powered
Performance Rating boxes and VAV reheat
Method. boxes. Modifies
exceptions to:
remove exception
originally intended
for hospitals and
laboratory type
spaces, clarify that
lab systems with
greater than 5000
cfm of exhaust air
use a single VAV
baseline system; and
add exception to the
50% lab VAV minimum
airflow to address
minimum ventilation
requirements lab
designers follow to
meet codes and
accreditation
standards.
81.................. ck.................. 6. Heating, Expands zone-level Minor + (expands
Ventilating, and Air demand controlled automatic zone reset
Conditioning. ventilation to in multizone
include various systems).
forms of system
level strategies. It
is being added to
the prescriptive
section, so that it
could be traded off
using the Energy
Cost Budget (ECB)
method.
82.................. cl.................. 3. Definitions, Clarifies how to 0 (alternative
Abbreviations, and interpret the use of compliance path).
Acronyms;. dynamic glazing
5. Building Envelope.. which are designed
to be able to vary a
performance property
such as Solar Heat
Gain Coefficient
(SHGC), rather than
having just a single
value.
83.................. cn.................. 9. Lighting........... Adds two versions of 0 (alternative
a combined advanced compliance path).
control to the
control incentives
table (9.6.2). These
control system
combinations involve
personal workstation
control and work-
station-specific
occupancy sensors
for open office
applications.
84.................. co.................. 6. Heating, This proposal makes Minor + (improves
Ventilating, and Air three amendments to efficiency of minor
Conditioning. Table 6.8.1A. First, market products).
it updates EER and
IEER values for all
condensing units and
water and
evaporatively cooled
air conditioners
with cooling
capacities greater
than 65,000 Btu/h.
Second, the proposal
establishes a
separate product
class for
evaporatively cooled
air conditioners
with different
energy efficiency
standards. Third,
the proposal
replaces the IPLV
descriptor for
condensing units
with the new IEER
metric and amends
the EERs with more
stringent values.
[[Page 43309]]
85.................. cp.................. 3. Definitions, Establishes 0 (not more stringent
Abbreviations, and efficiency than common
Acronyms;. requirements for practice).
6. Heating, Variable Refrigerant
Ventilating, and Air Flow (VRF) air
Conditioning. conditioners and
heat pumps including
heat pumps that use
a water source for
heat rejection.
86.................. cq.................. 6. Heating, Addendum is based on Minor + (reduced duct
Ventilating, and Air economic analysis leakage).
Conditioning; using the current
Informative Appendix scalar value. Nearly
E. Informative all classes are
References. economically
justified at seal
class A, allowing
for the removal of
two tables.
87.................. cr.................. 3. Definitions, Modifies definition 0 (alternative
Abbreviations, and of unmet load hour compliance paths).
Acronyms; 11. Energy and adds definition
Cost Budget Method for temperature
and Normative control throttling
Appendix G. range. Requires that
Performance Rating both baseline and
Method. proposed unmet hours
not exceed 300.
Removes language
allowing
modification of
system coil
capacities to reduce
unmet hours as
needed.
88.................. cs.................. 8. Power.............. Modifies automatic Major+ (minimizes
receptacle control exceptions to
requirements and switched receptacle
exemptions to requirement.
eliminate potential
practical
application issues.
89.................. ct.................. 9. Lighting........... Reduces the area Minor + (reduce area
threshold where side requirement for
daylighting requires occupancy sensors).
daylight sensor
control down to 250
square feet.
90.................. cv.................. 10. Other Equipment... Adds requirements for Minor + (adds
service water requirements for
pressure booster service water
systems. pressure booster
systems).
91.................. cw.................. 11. Energy Cost Budget Revises the Energy 0 (alternative
Method. Cost Budget for compliance path).
service hot water
heaters. Corrects
contradiction with
section 11.32(b).
Provides user
instruction for
situations where a
certain type of
service hot water
system is not listed
in Table 7.8.
92.................. cy.................. 6. Heating, Makes several Major + (expands use
Ventilating, and Air revisions to the of economizers).
Conditioning. economizer
requirements in
section 6.5.1 and
6.3.2. Updates Table
6.3.2 which allows
for the elimination
of economizers
through the use of
higher efficiency
HVAC equipment.
93.................. cz.................. 9. Lighting........... Incorporates bi-level Minor + (reduced
control for parking parking garage
garages to reduce lighting).
energy waste during
unoccupied periods.
94.................. da.................. Normative Appendix G. Establishes that an 0 (performance rating
Performance Rating Appendix G baseline method).
Method. shall be based on
the minimum
ventilation
requirements
required by local
codes or a rating
authority and not
the proposed design
ventilation rates.
95.................. db.................. Normative Appendix G. This addendum 0 (performance rating
Performance Rating modifies the design method).
Method. air flow rates for
laboratory systems
in the baseline
building in Appendix
G.
96.................. dc.................. 9. Lighting........... Removes information Minor - (tandem
related to tandem wiring no longer
wiring of lighting. used in practice--
possible small
increase in energy
usage).
97.................. dd.................. 5. Building Envelope; Reduces the area Major + (requires
and 9. Lighting. threshold where daylighting controls
skylights are in more spaces).
required to be
designed into
building spaces down
to 5000 square feet
and similarly
reduces the
threshold where
daylighting controls
must be applied to
900 square feet.
[[Page 43310]]
98.................. de.................. 9. Lighting........... Splits the ``generic 0 (allows more
lobby'' from common lighting power in
elevator lobbies and lobbies but less in
lighting power elevator lobbies).
densities were
adjusted to reflect
specific space
needs. Also removes
the fitness center
audience seating
because it's
considered a space
type that was
considered not used
and potentially
confusing.
99.................. df.................. 10. Other Equipment... Adds requirements Minor + (small
that address excess lighting and
energy use in ventilation
elevators due to savings).
ventilation fans and
cab lighting.
100................. dg.................. 3. Definitions, Adds a definition for 0 (clarification of
Acronyms, and the term ``field- definition).
Abbreviations; and fabricated
Normative Appendix G. fenestration'' used
Performance Rating in section 5.4.3.2
Method. consistent with
Interpretation IC
90.1-2007-01 and
similar language in
California's Title
24.
101................. di.................. 3. Definitions, Adds requirements for Minor + (reduced
Abbreviations, and enclosed parking parking garage
Acronyms; 6. Heating, garage ventilation. ventilation energy).
Ventilating, and Air
Conditioning.
102................. dj.................. 6. Heating, Limits the fan energy Minor + (limits fan
Ventilating, and Air allowance for energy energy allowance of
Conditioning. recovery devices to energy recovery
values that devices).
approximate the
results of the
economic analysis,
with some allowance
to permit adequate
pressure drop for
products near the
minimum recovery
effectiveness of
50%. A separate
allowance is also
created for coil
runaround loop
systems.
103................. dk.................. Normative Appendix C. Adds clarity and 0 (alternative
Methodology for instruction to the compliance path).
Building Envelope users of Appendix C,
Trade-Off Option in the envelope trade
Subsection 5.6. off option, for new
requirements that
were added in
addendums AL, BC,
and BN. AL required
skylights and
lighting controls in
certain occupancies.
BC required
skylights and
lighting controls in
unconditioned semi-
heated spaces. BN
dealt with
orientation specific
SHGC requirements.
104................. dl.................. Normative Appendix C. Gives instruction to 0 (alternative
Methodology for the users of compliance path).
Building Envelope Appendix C on how to
Trade-Off Option in model the base
Subsection 5.6. envelope design and
the proposed
envelope design on
how to comply with
the cool roof
provisions of
Section 5.
105................. dn.................. Normative Appendix G. This addendum adds 0 (performance rating
Performance Rating system types 9 and method).
Method. 10 for heated only
storage spaces and
associated changes.
106................. do.................. 4. Administration and Establishes the goals 0 (documentation
Enforcement; 9. and requirements of only).
Lighting. the lighting system
including controls
and ensures that
owners are provided
all the information
necessary to best
use and maintain
lighting systems.
107................. dp.................. 12. Normative Updates the 0 (updates
References. references in 90.1 references).
to reflect the
current edition of
the cited standard.
Substantive changes
in the referenced
documents did not
affect the
requirements in 90.1
or change the
stringency of the
requirements of 90.1.
108................. dq.................. Normative Appendix C. Modifies the 0 (alternative
Methodology for calculations found compliance path).
Building Envelope in Appendix C in
Trade-Off Option in order to reflect
Subsection 5.6. modifications to the
modeling assumptions.
[[Page 43311]]
109................. dr.................. 9. Lighting........... Original purpose of 0 (editorial only).
9.4.4 was to limit
the use of
inefficient lighting
sources for high
wattage applications
when there was not a
comprehensive table
of lighting power
density limits. With
such a table now in
place, section 9.4.4
is no longer
necessary
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2 is an overall summary of the addenda in terms of their
impact in the qualitative analysis. Overall, the sum of the major
positive and minor positive addenda (56) greatly overwhelms the number
of minor negative addenda (6), leading to the conclusion that the
overall impact of the addenda on the standard is positive.
Table 2--Overall Summary of Addenda Impact in Qualitative Analysis
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Major negative Minor negative Neutral Minor positive Major positive Total
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
None............................................................... 6 47 37 19 109
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 6 negative impacts on energy efficiency include:
1. Addendum b--allows larger than minimum ventilation rates if
required by other codes.
2. Addendum c--allows an exception to dehumidification for controls
for vivariums.
3. Addendum p--increases allowable pressure drop in laboratory
exhaust systems.
4. Addendum aw--adds an additional lighting allowance for
nightlights in hotel/motel bathrooms.
5. Addendum cc--allows higher flow rates in 8'' piping.
6. Addendum dc--eliminates tandem wiring requirement.
None of these negative impacts are judged to be significant.
Addendum b simply acknowledges that Standard 90.1 does not address
ventilation rates that are required in other codes. Addendum c simply
adds vivariums (spaces used for plant or animal growth) to the list of
spaces that may have more stringent humidity requirements than normal
spaces. Addendum p increases allowable pressure drop in laboratory
exhaust systems and addresses some noted shortcomings in the previous
version of Standard 90.1 with regard to fume hoods. Addendum aw
acknowledges the common practice of the use of bathroom lights as
``nightlights'' in hotel/motel guest rooms. Addendum cc corrects a
calculation error in the previous version of Standard 90.1. Addendum dc
eliminates a tandem wiring requirement for ballasts that is no longer
used with the widespread use of electronic ballasts.
The 19 major positive impacts on energy efficiency include:
1. Addendum d--requires daylighting controls under skylights and
commissioning of daylighting controls.
2. Addendum e--requires increased use of heat recovery.
3. Addendum f--requires cool roofs in hot climates.
4. Addendum i--lower illuminance requirements in certain exterior
zones.
5. Addendum m--updates chiller efficiency requirements.
6. Addendum n--extends VAV fan control requirements.
7. Addendum x--adds occupancy sensor requirements for many specific
applications.
8. Addendum ab--adds daylighting control requirements for side-
lighted spaces.
9. Addendum al--requires skylights and daylighting in some building
types.
10. Addendum ap--reduces ventilation energy.
11. Addendum av--expansion of new lighting power densities to more
retrofits.
12. Addendum bh--requires supply air temperature reset for non-peak
conditions.
13. Addendum bu--adds efficiency requirements for data centers.
14. Addendum by--required lower lighting power densities.
15. Addendum cb--expands automatic damper requirements.
16. Addendum cd--requires control of exterior lighting.
17. Addendum cs--minimizes exceptions to switched receptacle
requirement.
18. Addendum cy--expands use of economizers.
19. Addendum dd--requires daylighting controls in more spaces.
Many of these ``major positive'' addenda are self descriptive. The
high-level themes of the major positive addenda tend to be as follows:
Better lighting, daylighting, and controls (d, i, x, ab,
al, av, by, cd, cs, and dd).
Better mechanical systems and application to more systems
(e, m, n, ap, bh, bu, cb, and cy).
Better building envelope (f).
There are an additional 37 addenda that have minor positive
impacts. See the complete qualitative analysis for additional detail.
B. Quantitative Analysis
1. Discussion of Whole Building Energy Analysis
The quantitative comparison of Standard 90.1-2010 was carried out
using whole-building energy simulations of buildings built to both
Standard 90.1-2007 and Standard 90.1-2010. DOE simulated 16
representative building types in 15 U.S. climate locations, each
climate location selected to be representative of one of the 15 U.S
climate zones used in the definition of building energy code criteria
in Standard 90.1-2007 and Standard 90.1-2010. The simulations were
developed using specific building prototypes based on the DOE
commercial reference building models developed for DOE's
[[Page 43312]]
Net-Zero Energy Commercial Building Initiative. (These reference
building prototypes were formerly known as Benchmark building models.)
For each building prototype simulated in each climate the energy
use intensities (EUI) by fuel type and by end-use were extracted. These
EUIs by fuel type for each building were then weighted to national
average EUI figures using weighting factors based on the relative
square footage of construction represented by that prototype in each of
the 15 climate regions. These weighting factors were based on
commercial building construction starts data for a five year period
from 2003 to 2007. The source of data was the McGraw-Hill Construction
Projects Starts Database (MHC). The MHC database captures over 90% of
new commercial construction in any given year and the collection
process is independently monitored to ensure the coverage of most of
the commercial construction in the U.S. The data is used by other
Federal agencies such as the U.S. Census Bureau, the Federal Reserve
and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) for
characterizing building construction in the U.S. For the purpose of
developing construction weighting factors, the strength of this data
lies in the number of samples, the characterization of each sample in
terms of building end-use and size and number of stories, the frequency
of data collection, and the detailed location data. In addition, the
MHC database can be used to identify multifamily residential buildings
that would be covered under ASHRAE Standard 90.1.
DOE's prototypes reflect the use of two fuel types, electricity and
natural gas. Using the weighting factors, DOE was able to establish an
estimate of the relative reduction in building energy use, as
determined by a calculated reduction in weighted average site EUI for
each building prototype. Site energy refers to the energy consumed at
the building site. In a corresponding fashion, DOE was also able to
calculate a reduction in terms of weighted average primary EUI and in
terms of weighted average energy cost intensity (ECI) in $/sq. ft. of
building floorspace. Primary energy as used here refers to the energy
required to generate and deliver energy to the site. To estimate
primary energy, all electrical energy use intensities were first
converted to primary energy using a factor of 10,918 Btus primary
energy per kWh (based on the 2010 estimated values reported in Table 2
of the EIA 2010 Annual Energy Outlook, release date December 2009,
available at http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/archive/aeo10/aeoref_tab.html).
The conversion factor of 10,918 was calculated from Table 2 by
summing the commercial electricity value of 4.62 quads with the
electricity losses value of 10.17 quads and then dividing that sum by
the commercial value. ((4.62 + 10.17)/4.62 = 3.2) This yields an
electricity ratio of 3.2 for converting how much primary (source)
electricity is required per unit of site required electricity. This
ratio of 3.2 is then multiplied by 3,412 Btu per kWh, producing a value
of 10,918 Btus primary energy per kWh of site energy. Natural Gas EUIs
in the prototypes were converted to primary energy using a factor of
1.090 Btus primary energy per Btu of site natural gas use (based on the
2010 national energy use estimated shown in Table 2 of the AEO 2010).
This natural gas source energy conversion factor was calculated by
dividing the natural gas subtotal of 23.15 quads (sum of all natural
gas usage, including usage for natural gas field production, leases,
plant fuel, and pipeline (compression) supply) by the delivered natural
gas total of 21.23 quads (sum of four primary energy sectors
(residential, commercial, industrial, and transportation).
a. Calculation of Energy Cost Index
To estimate the reduction in energy cost index, DOE relied on
national average commercial building energy prices of $0.1027/kWh of
electricity and $10.06 per 1000 cubic feet ($0.9796/therm) of natural
gas, based on EIA statistics for 2010 (the last complete year of data
available in Table 5.3 Average Retail Price of Electricity to Ultimate
Consumers: Total by End-Use Sector for the commercial sector--available
from EIA at http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/table5_3.html
and for 2009 (the last complete year of data available from the EIA
Natural Gas Annual Summary for the commercial sector available at
http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_dcu_nus_a.htm.) DOE
recognizes that actual fuel costs will vary somewhat by building type
within a region, and will in fact vary more across regions.
Nevertheless, DOE believes that the use of simple national average
figures illustrates whether there will be energy cost savings
sufficient for the purposes of the DOE determination.
b. Calculation of Energy Use Intensities
Energy use intensities developed for each representative building
type were weighted by total national square footage of each
representative building type to provide an estimate of the difference
between the national energy use in buildings constructed to the 2007
and 2010 editions of the Standard 90.1. Note that the 16 buildings
types used in the preliminary determination reflect approximately 80%
of the total square footage of commercial construction including multi-
family buildings greater than three stories covered under ASHRAE
Standard 90.1.
Note that only differences between new building requirements were
considered in this quantitative analysis. Changes to requirements in
the 2010 edition that pertain to existing buildings only are addressed
in the detailed textual analysis only.
c. Application to Additions and Renovations
Both the 2010 and 2007 editions address additions and renovations
to existing buildings. Since DOE has preliminarily found insufficient
data to characterize renovations in terms of what energy using features
are utilized, DOE has not determined that the results obtained from the
whole building prototypes used would reasonably reflect the EUI
benefits that would accrue to renovated floor space. For this reason,
renovated floor space is not included in the DOE weighting factors.
Building additions on the other hand are believed to be substantially
equivalent to new construction. For this reason, FW Dodge construction
data on additions has been incorporated into the overall weighting
factors. Floor space additions reflect approximately 13 percent of new
construction floor space based on data captured in the FW Dodge
dataset.
d. Ventilation Rate Assumptions
The preliminary quantitative analysis assumed the same base
ventilation level for buildings constructed to Standard 90.1-2007 and
Standard 90.1-2010. Neither edition of Standard 90.1 specifies
ventilation rates for commercial building construction. ASHRAE has a
separate ventilation standard for commercial construction, ASHRAE
Standard 62.1 Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality. This
standard is cited only in a few exceptions within the mechanical
sections of either Standard 90.1-2007 or Standard 90.1-2010, with each
edition referencing a different version of Standard 62.1. Standard
90.1-2007 lists Standard 62.1-2004 in its table of references. Standard
90.1-2010 lists Standard 62.1-2007 in its table of references.
Ventilation rates can have significant impact on the energy use of
commercial buildings. States and local jurisdictions
[[Page 43313]]
typically specify the ventilation requirements for buildings within
their respective building codes and can set these requirements
independent of the energy code requirements. Because of the limited
reference to ventilation within either the 2007 or the 2010 edition,
the requirements that States certify that their energy codes meet or
exceed the 2010 edition of Standard 90.1 would in general not require
modification of State ventilation code requirements. However, in many
cases, ventilation requirements can be traced back to requirements
found in one or another version of Standard 62.1. For the purpose of
the quantitative analysis, DOE assumed ventilation rates for the
simulation prototypes based on the requirements of Standard 62.1-2004.
2. Results of Whole Building Energy Analysis
The preliminary quantitative analysis of the energy consumption of
buildings built to Standard 90.1-2010, as compared with buildings built
to Standard 90.1-2007, indicates national primary energy savings of
approximately 18.2 percent of commercial building energy consumption
based on the weighting factors for the 16 buildings simulated. Site
energy savings are estimated to be approximately 18.5 percent. Using
national average fuel prices for electricity and natural gas DOE
estimated a reduction in energy expenditures of 18.2 percent would
result from the use of Standard 90.1-2010 as compared to Standard 90.1-
2007. As identified previously, these estimated savings figures do not
include energy savings from equipment or appliance standards that would
be in place due to Federal requirements regardless of their presence in
the Standard 90.1-2010.
Tables 3 and 4 show the aggregated energy use and associated energy
savings by building type for the 16 building prototypes analyzed and on
an aggregated national basis for the 2007 and 2010 editions,
respectively. For each edition of Standard 90.1, the national building
floor area weight used to calculate the national impact on building EUI
or building ECI is presented. National-average site energy use
intensities ranges from over five hundred Btu per square foot annually
for the Fast Food prototype to approximately 20 Btu per square foot
annually for the Non-refrigerated Warehouse type. Source energy use
intensities and building energy cost intensities ($/sf-yr) are also
presented. Further details on the preliminary quantitative analysis can
be found in the full preliminary quantitative analysis report available
at http://www.energycodes.gov/status/determinations_com.stm.
Table 3--Estimated Energy Use Intensity by Building Type--2007 Edition
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Whole building EUI data for building
Building type population
Building type Building floor area -----------------------------------------------
prototype weight % Site EUI kBtu/ Source EUI
ft2-yr kBtu/ft2-yr ECI $/ft2-yr
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office........................ Small Office.... 5.61 39.1 118.4 $1.11
Medium Office... 6.05 47.7 140.6 1.32
Large Office.... 3.33 42.8 123.3 1.16
Retail........................ Stand-Alone 15.25 65.0 179.5 1.69
Retail.
Strip Mall...... 5.67 68.3 186.0 1.75
Education..................... Primary School.. 4.99 63.4 170.2 1.60
Secondary School 10.36 54.2 149.7 1.41
Healthcare.................... Outpatient 4.37 162.0 438.0 4.11
Health Care.
Hospital........ 3.45 156.4 374.9 3.51
Lodging....................... Small Hotel..... 1.72 70.8 179.4 1.68
Large Hotel..... 4.95 157.1 315.8 2.95
Warehouse..................... Non-Refrigerated 16.72 24.2 58.6 0.55
Warehouse.
Food Service.................. Fast-Food 0.59 547.7 1068.0 9.98
Restaurant.
Sit-Down 0.66 382.4 810.7 7.59
Restaurant.
Apartment..................... Mid-Rise 7.32 44.2 123.7 1.16
Apartment.
High-Rise 8.97 44.2 129.3 1.22
Apartment.
National...................... ................ 100 67.5 174.0 1.63
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 4--Estimated Energy Use Intensity by Building Type--2010 Edition
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Whole building EUI data for building
Building type population
Building type Building floor area -----------------------------------------------
prototype weight % Site EUI kBtu/ Source EUI
ft2-yr kBtu/ft2-yr ECI $/ft2-yr
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office........................ Small Office.... 5.61 32.8 99.0 $0.93
Medium Office... 6.05 37.1 106.3 $1.00
Large Office.... 3.33 33.3 96.8 0.91
Retail........................ Stand-Alone 15.25 48.0 135.1 1.27
Retail.
Strip Mall...... 5.67 56.9 150.9 1.42
Education..................... Primary School.. 4.99 48.0 134.8 1.27
Secondary School 10.36 39.8 114.9 1.08
Healthcare.................... Outpatient 4.37 125.4 340.9 3.20
Health Care.
Hospital........ 3.45 118.1 299.5 2.81
Lodging....................... Small Hotel..... 1.72 66.6 165.7 1.55
Large Hotel..... 4.95 139.8 282.5 2.64
Warehouse..................... Non-Refrigerated 16.72 19.2 45.0 0.42
Warehouse.
Food Service.................. Fast-Food 0.59 519.9 976.5 9.12
Restaurant.
Sit-Down 0.66 330.9 654.1 6.12
Restaurant.
Apartment..................... Mid-Rise 7.32 41.2 118.3 1.11
Apartment.
[[Page 43314]]
High-Rise 8.97 41.0 123.5 1.16
Apartment.
National...................... ................ 100 55.5 142.4 1.34
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 5 presents the estimated percent energy savings (based on
change in EUI) between the 2007 and 2010 editions. Overall, considering
those differences that can be reasonably quantified, the 2010 edition
is expected to increase the energy efficiency of commercial buildings.
Numbers in Table 5 represent percent energy savings.
Table 5--Estimated Percent Energy Savings with 2010 Edition--by Building Type
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Percent savings in whole building energy use
Building Building type intensity (%)
Building type prototype floor area -----------------------------------------------
weight % Site EUI Source EUI ECI
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office........................ Small Office.... 5.61 16.1 16.4 16.4
Medium Office... 6.05 22.1 24.4 24.4
Large Office.... 3.33 22.3 21.5 21.5
Retail........................ Stand-Alone 15.25 26.1 24.7 24.7
Retail.
Strip Mall...... 5.67 16.8 18.9 18.9
Education..................... Primary School.. 4.99 24.2 20.8 20.8
Secondary School 10.36 26.7 23.3 23.2
Healthcare.................... Outpatient 4.37 22.6 22.2 22.2
Health Care.
Hospital........ 3.45 24.5 20.1 20.1
Lodging....................... Small Hotel..... 1.72 5.9 7.7 7.7
Large Hotel..... 4.95 11.0 10.5 10.5
Warehouse..................... Non-Refrigerated 16.72 20.7 23.1 23.1
Warehouse.
Food Service.................. Fast Food 0.59 5.1 8.6 8.6
Restaurant.
Sit-Down 0.66 13.5 19.3 19.4
Restaurant.
Apartment..................... Mid-Rise 7.32 6.8 4.4 4.4
Apartment.
High-Rise 8.97 7.2 4.5 4.5
Apartment.
National...................... ................ 100 18.5 18.2 18.2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Preliminary Determination Statement
DOE's review and evaluation indicates that there are significant
differences between the 2007 edition and the 2010 edition. DOE's
overall preliminary conclusion is that the 2010 edition will improve
the energy efficiency of commercial buildings.
However, DOE identified six changes in textual requirements that
taken alone appear to represent a reduction in stringencies and could
decrease energy efficiency. The six changes are:
Addendum b, which allows larger than minimum ventilation
rates if required by other codes;
Addendum c, which allows an exception to dehumidification
for controls for vivariums;
Addendum p, which increases allowable pressure drop in
laboratory exhaust systems;
Addendum aw, which adds an additional lighting allowance
for nightlights in hotel/motel bathrooms;
Addendum cc, which allows higher flow rates in 8'' piping;
and
Addendum dc, which eliminates tandem wiring requirements.
DOE believes that in these cases, the reduction in stringency was
not considered a major impact. For the other addenda, DOE preliminarily
determined that the remaining addenda either represented no change in
stringency, or indicated a positive change in stringency corresponding
to improved efficiency. Overall, DOE preliminarily concluded the
changes in textual requirements and stringencies are ``positive,'' in
the sense that they would improve energy efficiency in commercial
construction.
The quantitative analysis preliminarily shows that for the 16
prototype buildings, a weighted average national improvement in new
building efficiency of 16.5 percent, when considering source energy,
and by 17.1 percent, when considering site energy.
As both the 2007 and 2010 editions cover existing buildings, to the
extent that these standards are applied to existing buildings in
retrofits or in new construction addition, the 2010 edition should
improve the efficiency of the existing building stock.
DOE has, therefore, preliminarily concluded that Standard 90.1-2010
receive an affirmative determination under Section 304(b) of ECPA.
III. Filing Certification Statements With DOE
A. Review and Update
If today's determination is finalized, each State would be required
to review and update, as necessary, the provisions of its commercial
building energy code to meet or exceed the energy efficiency provisions
of the 2010 edition. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(B)(i)) This action would be
required to be taken not later than two years from the date of the
final determination notice, unless an extension is provided.
The DOE recognizes that some States do not have a State commercial
building energy code or have a State code that does not apply to all
commercial buildings. If local building energy codes regulate
commercial building design and construction rather than a State code,
the State must review and make all reasonable efforts to update as
authorized those local codes to determine whether they meet or exceed
the 2010 edition of Standard 90.1. States
[[Page 43315]]
may base their certifications on reasonable actions by units of general
purpose local government. Each such State must still review the
information obtained from the local governments and gather any
additional data and testimony for its own certification.
Note that the applicability of any State revisions to new or
existing buildings would be governed by the State building codes.
However, it is our understanding that generally, the revisions would
not apply to existing buildings unless they are undergoing a change
that requires a building permit.
States should be aware that the DOE considers high-rise (greater
than three stories) multi-family residential buildings, hotel, motel,
and other transient residential building types of any height as
commercial buildings for energy code purposes. Consequently, commercial
buildings, for the purposes of certification, would include high-rise
(greater than three stories) multi-family residential buildings, hotel,
motel, and other transient residential building types of any height.
B. Certification
If today's determination is finalized, Section 304(b) of ECPA, as
amended, requires each State to certify to the Secretary of Energy that
it has reviewed and updated the provisions of its commercial building
energy code regarding energy efficiency to meet or exceed the Standard
90.1-2010 edition. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)) If today's determination is
finalized before the 2 year deadline to file a certification for the
2007 positive determination then a state may file just one
certification to address both determinations. The certification must
include a demonstration that the provisions of the State's commercial
building energy code regarding energy efficiency meet or exceed
Standard 90.1-2010. If a State intends to certify that its commercial
building energy code already meets or exceeds the requirements of
Standard 90.1-2010, the State should provide an explanation of the
basis for this certification, e.g., Standard 90.1-2010 is incorporated
by reference in the State's building code regulations. The chief
executive of the State (e.g., the Governor) or a designated State
official, such as the Director of the State energy office, State code
commission, utility commission, or equivalent State agency having
primary responsibility for commercial building energy codes, would
provide the certification to the Secretary. Such a designated State
official would also provide the certifications regarding the codes of
units of general purpose local government based on information provided
by responsible local officials.
DOE does list the States that have filed certifications and those
that have or have not adopted new codes on the DOE Energy Efficiency
and Renewable Energy Web site at http://www.energycodes.gov/states/.
Once a State has adopted a new commercial code, DOE typically provides
software, training, and support for the new code as long as the new
code is based on the national model codes (in this case, ASHRAE
Standard 90.1).
Some States develop their own codes that are only loosely related
to the national model codes and DOE does not typically provide
technical support for those codes. However, DOE does provide grants to
these States through grant programs administered by the National Energy
Technology Laboratory (NETL). DOE does not prescribe how each State
adopts and enforces its energy codes.
C. Request for Extensions To Certify
Section 304(c) of ECPA, requires that the Secretary permit an
extension of the deadline for complying with the certification
requirements described above, if a State can demonstrate that it has
made a good faith effort to comply with such requirements and that it
has made significant progress toward meeting its certification
obligations. (42 U.S.C. 6833(c)) Such demonstrations could include one
or both of the following: (1) A plan for response to the requirements
stated in section 304; or (2) a statement that the State has
appropriated or requested funds (within State funding procedures) to
implement a plan that would respond to the requirements of Section 304
of ECPA. This list is not exhaustive.
IV. Regulatory Analysis
A. Review Under Executive Order 12866
Today's action is a significant regulatory action under section
3(f)(1) of Executive Order 12866, ``Regulatory Planning and Review''
(58 FR 51735; October 4, 1993). Accordingly, today's action was
reviewed by the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) in
the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).
B. Review Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) requires the
preparation of an initial regulatory flexibility analysis for any rule
that by law must be proposed for public comment, unless the agency
certifies that the rule, if promulgated, will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. As required
by Executive Order 13272, ``Proper Consideration of Small Entities in
Agency Rulemaking,'' (67 FR 53461 (Aug. 16, 2002)), DOE published
procedures and policies on February 19, 2003, to ensure that the
potential impacts of its rules on small entities are properly
considered during the rulemaking process (68 FR 7990). DOE has made its
procedures and policies available on the Office of General Counsel's
Web site: http://www.gc.doe.gov.
DOE has reviewed today's preliminary determination under the
provisions of the Regulatory Flexibility Act and the procedures and
policies published on February 19, 2003. If today's action on the
preliminary determination of improved energy efficiency between the
2007 and 2010 editions of Standard 90.1 is finalized by DOE then it
would require States to undertake an analysis of their respective
building codes. As such, the only entities directly regulated by this
preliminary determination would be States. DOE does not believe that
there will be any direct impacts on small entities such as small
businesses, small organizations, or small governmental jurisdictions.
On the basis of the foregoing, DOE certifies that this preliminary
determination would not have a significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities. Accordingly, DOE has not prepared
a regulatory flexibility analysis for this preliminary determination.
DOE's certification and supporting statement of factual basis will be
provided to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 605(b).
C. Review Under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969
DOE has preliminarily determined that today's action is covered
under the Categorical Exclusion found in DOE's National Environmental
Policy Act regulations at paragraph A.6. of Appendix A to subpart D, 10
CFR part 1021. That Categorical Exclusion applies to actions that are
strictly procedural, such as rulemaking establishing the administration
of grants. Today's action is required by Title III of ECPA, as amended,
which provides that whenever the Standard 90.1-1989, or any successor
to that code, is revised, the Secretary must make a determination, not
later than 12 months after such revision, whether the revised code
would improve energy efficiency in commercial buildings and
[[Page 43316]]
must publish notice of such determination in the Federal Register. (42
U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(A)) If the Secretary determines that the revision of
Standard 90.1-1989 or any successor thereof, improves the level of
energy efficiency in commercial buildings then no later than two years
after the date of the publication of such affirmative determination,
each State is required to certify that it has reviewed and updated the
provisions of its commercial building code regarding energy efficiency
with respect to the revised or successor code. (42 U.S.C.
6833(b)(2)(B)(i)) If the Secretary makes a determination that the
revised standard will not improve energy efficiency in commercial
buildings then State commercial codes shall meet or exceed the last
revised standard for which the Secretary has made a positive
determination. (42 U.S.C. 6833(b)(2)(B)(ii)) Therefore, DOE has
preliminarily determined that the Secretary's determination is not a
major Federal action that would have direct environmental impacts.
Accordingly, DOE has not prepared an environmental assessment or an
environmental impact statement.
D. Review Under Executive Order 13132, ``Federalism''
Executive Order 13132, 64 FR 43255 (Aug 4, 1999), imposes certain
requirements on agencies formulating and implementing policies or
regulations that pre-empt State law or that have federalism
implications. Agencies are required to examine the constitutional and
statutory authority supporting any action that would limit the
policymaking discretion of the States and carefully assess the
necessity for such actions.
DOE has reviewed the statutory authority. Congress found that:
(1) Large amounts of fuel and energy are consumed unnecessarily
each year in heating, cooling, ventilating, and providing domestic hot
water for newly constructed residential and commercial buildings
because such buildings lack adequate energy conservation features;
(2) Federal voluntary performance standards for newly constructed
buildings can prevent such waste of energy, which the Nation can no
longer afford in view of its current and anticipated energy shortage;
(3) The failure to provide adequate energy conservation measures in
newly constructed buildings increases long-term operating costs that
may affect adversely the repayment of, and security for, loans made,
insured, or guaranteed by Federal agencies or made by Federally insured
or regulated instrumentalities; and
(4) State and local building codes or similar controls can provide
an existing means by which to assure, in coordination with other
building requirements and with a minimum of Federal interference in
State and local transactions, that newly constructed buildings contain
adequate energy conservation features. (42 U.S.C. 6831)
Pursuant to Section 304(b) of ECPA, DOE is statutorily required to
determine whether the most recent versions of ASHRAE 90.1 would improve
the level of energy efficiency in commercial buildings as compared to
the previous version. If DOE makes a positive determination, the
statute requires each State to certify that it has reviewed and updated
the provisions of its commercial building code regarding energy
efficiency with respect to the revised or successor codes. (42 U.S.C.
6833(b)(2)(B)(i))
Executive Order 13132, 64 FR 43255 (August 4, 1999) requires
meaningful and timely input by State and local officials in the
development of regulatory policies that have federalism implications
unless ``funds necessary to pay the direct costs incurred by the State
and local governments in complying with the regulation are provided by
the Federal Government.'' (62 FR 43257) Pursuant to Section 304(e) of
ECPA, the DOE Secretary is required to ``provide incentive funding to
States to implement the requirements of [Section 304], and to improve
and implement State residential and commercial building energy
efficiency codes, including increasing and verifying compliance with
such codes. In determining whether, and in what amount, to provide
incentive funding under this subsection, the Secretary shall consider
the actions proposed by the State to implement the requirements of this
section, to improve and implement residential and commercial building
energy efficiency codes, and to promote building energy efficiency
through the use of such codes.'' (42 U.S.C. 6833(e)) Therefore,
consultation with States and local officials regarding this preliminary
determination was not required.
However, DOE notes that State and local governments were invited to
participate in the development Standard 90.1-2010. Standard 90.1-2010,
was developed in a national American National Standards Institute
consensus process open to the public and in which State and local
governments participate along with DOE and other interested parties. It
is the product of a series of amendments to the prior addition of the
standard. Each addendum is put out for national public review. Anyone
may submit comments, and in the process comments were received from
State and local governments. Comments on the addendum are received,
reviewed and resolved through a consensus process. Members of the
standards project committee have included representatives of State and
local governments.
DOE annually holds a national building energy codes workshop at
which the progress on development of the model energy codes are
presented, along with discussion and sharing of problems and successes
in adoption, implementation, and enforcement of building energy codes.
The predominate attendance of these workshops are State and local
officials responsible for building energy codes. They are consistently
encouraged and urged to participate in the model building energy code
processes, which will be the subject of DOE's next determinations under
section 304 of ECPA. Thus, State and local officials have had the
opportunity to participate in the development of the standard through
the ASHRAE process. Some have done so.
Similarly, the comments of States and local governments about
provisions of the developing Standard 90.1-2010 were received in formal
comment periods and heard and addressed in ASHRAE committee
deliberations open to the public. In addition, concerns and issues
about adoption, implementation and enforcement issues were presented
and discussed at informal sessions at the Department's annual national
workshops on building energy codes. DOE believes that the above process
has given State and local jurisdictions extensive opportunity to
comment on and express their concerns on Standard 90.1-2010, the
subject of this determination.
On issuance of a final determination that Standard 90.1-2010 would
improve the energy efficiency of commercial buildings, ECPA requires
the States to certify to the Secretary that it has reviewed and updated
the provisions of its commercial building code regarding energy
efficiency to meet or exceed the requirements of Standard 90.1-2010.
DOE notes that ECPA sets forth this requirement for States. (42 U.S.C.
6833(b)(2)(B)(i)) States are given broad freedom to either adopt
Standard 90.1-2010 or develop their own code that meets equivalent
energy efficiency.
[[Page 43317]]
E. Review Under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (Pub. L. 104-4) generally
requires Federal agencies to examine closely the impacts of regulatory
actions on State, local, and Tribal governments. Subsection 101(5) of
Title I of that law defines a Federal intergovernmental mandate to
include any regulation that would impose upon State, local, or Tribal
governments an enforceable duty, except a condition of Federal
assistance or a duty arising from participating in a voluntary Federal
program. Title II of that law requires each Federal agency to assess
the effects of Federal regulatory actions on State, local, and Tribal
governments, in the aggregate, or to the private sector, other than to
the extent such actions merely incorporate requirements specifically
set forth in a statute. Section 202 of that title requires a Federal
agency to perform a detailed assessment of the anticipated costs and
benefits of any rule that includes a Federal mandate which may result
in costs to State, local, or Tribal governments, or to the private
sector, of $100 million or more. Section 204 of that title requires
each agency that proposes a rule containing a significant Federal
intergovernmental mandate to develop an effective process for obtaining
meaningful and timely input from elected officers of State, local, and
Tribal governments.
If today's determination is finalized, each State would be required
under Section 304 of ECPA to review and update, as necessary, the
provisions of its commercial building energy code to meet or exceed the
provisions of the 2010 edition of Standard 90.1. (42 U.S.C.
6833(b)(2)(B)(i)) Section 304 of ECPA requires State action in response
to a positive determination by DOE. The statutory requirements of ECPA
require DOE to provide a determination irrespective of costs. While the
processes that States may undertake to update their codes vary widely,
as a general rule a State at a minimum would need to:
Evaluate Standard 90.1-2010 using the background material
provided by DOE.
Compare the existing State commercial building energy code
to Standard 90.1-2010 to see if an update is needed.
Update the State commercial building energy code to meet
or exceed Standard 90.1-2010.
DOE evaluated the potential for State activity to exceed $100
million in any one year. The approach looked at the three steps for
minimum activity listed in the previous paragraph--evaluate, compare
and update. A fourth potential step of providing training on the new
code was also considered as some States may consider training on the
new code to be an integral part of adopting the new code. For the three
steps of minimum activity, DOE estimated the following:
Evaluate Standard 90.1-2010--DOE estimated a minimum of 8 hours of
review per State and a maximum review time of 500 hours of review per
State (12.5 work weeks). The minimum review time of 8 hours (one day)
is the estimated minimum amount of time DOE can see States taking to
review Standard 90.1-2010. Reading and reviewing the Federal Register
notice, the qualitative analysis document and the quantitative analysis
document will take the average person several hours. Deciding on
whether or not to upgrade to Standard 90.1-2010 may take another couple
of hours. The maximum review time of 500 hours (62.5 days, 3 working
months) upper limit was estimated as the amount of time that a State
that was not familiar with energy codes at all or which has a
particularly arduous review process within the State would take to
review these documents.
(1) A cost per hour of $100 per hour was assumed based on actual
rates proposed in subcontracts associated with compliance studies
funded by DOE. The average rate calculated from these subcontracts for
10 types of building officials from 6 states was $93.41, so DOE chose
to round this up to $100 per hour.
a. Low estimate--8 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour = $40,000
b. High estimate--500 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour =
$2,500,000
(2) Compare Standard 90.1-2010 to existing state code--Assuming the
State is familiar with its code and has performed an effective
evaluation of Standard 90.1 in the first step, the range of potential
costs should be similar to Step 1. (See Step 1 for discussion of 8 hour
and 500 hour times and $100 per hour cost estimate).
a. Low estimate--8 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour = $40,000
b. High estimate--500 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour =
$2,500,000
(3) Update the State Codes to meet or exceed Standard 90.1-2010--
Adopting a new energy code could be as simple as updating an order
within the State, or it could be very complex involving hearings,
testimony, etc. Again, the range of potential costs should be similar
to Step 1. (See Step 1 for discussion of origin of 8 hour and 500 hour
times and $100 per hour cost estimate).
a. Low estimate--8 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour = $40,000
b. High estimate--500 hours * 50 states * $100 per hour =
$2,500,000
The potential range of total costs to States to under these
assumptions would be $120,000 to $7.5 million. This range is well below
the $100 million threshold in the Unfunded Mandates Act. DOE has also
considered potential costs were States to provide training on the new
code.
(4) Train Code officials on New Code--Assuming every jurisdiction
has at least one person that needs to be trained on energy code. There
are roughly 40,000 general purpose local governments, or jurisdictions,
in the U.S. The total number of jurisdictions in the U.S. that enforce
energy codes is not known with any degree of certainty. The National
League of Cities publishes an estimate of the number of local
governments in the U.S. at http://www.nlc.org/about_cities/cities_101/142.aspx. Their summary indicates the following:
19,429 Municipal governments;
16,504 Town or Township governments;
3,034 County governments;
13,506 School districts; and
35,052 Special district governments.
DOE believes it is reasonable to assume that all of the municipal
governments, town or township governments, and county governments could
be required to acquire training on Standard 90.1-2010 in order to
enforce this standard as an adopted energy code. In addition, the 50
state governments would be required to acquire training. This number
adds up to 19,429 + 16,504 + 3,034 + 50 = 38,667. Another widely
mentioned estimate of the total number of code adopting jurisdictions
in the U.S. is 44,000. This number is based on the National Conference
of States on Building Codes and Standards (NCBCS). See, for example,
http://www.ncsbcs.org/newsite/New%20Releases/RW_Presentation_060602.htm. Both these estimates are in reasonable agreement and so DOE
assumed that there are 40,000 potential jurisdictions that potentially
would need training on a new energy code.
Based on training experiences of the Building Energy Codes Program
staff, with conducting training sessions for jurisdictional staff
regarding Standard 90.1, one full-day (8 hours) of training is normally
sufficient . Therefore, DOE has used 8 hours as a low estimate and 16
hours as a high estimate for training hours required if a jurisdiction
were to adopt Standard 90.1-2010.
[[Page 43318]]
a. Low estimate--8 hours * 40,000 jurisdictions * $100 per hour =
$32,000,000
b. High Estimate--16 hours * 40,000 jurisdictions * $100 per hour =
$64,000,000
Adding the potential training costs of $32 million to $64 million
to the costs for the three steps indicates a potential total costs
ranging from $32.12 million to $71.5 million. The high end of this
estimate is less than the $100 million threshold in the Unfunded
Mandates Act. Accordingly, no further action is required under the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995.
F. Review Under the Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act
of 1999
Section 654 of the Treasury and General Government Appropriations
Act of 1999 (Pub. L. 105-277) requires Federal agencies to issue a
Family Policymaking Assessment for any rule that may affect family
well-being. Today's action would not have any impact on the autonomy or
integrity of the family as an institution. Accordingly, DOE has
concluded that it is not necessary to prepare a Family Policymaking
Assessment.
G. Review Under the Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act
of 2001
Section 515 of the Treasury and General Government Appropriations
Act, 2001 (44 U.S.C. 3516, note) provides for agencies to review most
disseminations of information to the public under guidelines
established by each agency pursuant to general guidelines issued by
OMB. OMB's guidelines were published at 67 FR 8452 (Feb. 22, 2002), and
DOE's guidelines were published at 67 FR 62446 (Oct. 7, 2002). DOE has
reviewed today's action under the OMB and DOE guidelines and has
concluded that it is consistent with applicable policies in those
guidelines.
H. Review Under Executive Order 13211
Executive Order 13211, ``Actions Concerning Regulations That
Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use,'' 66 FR 28355
(May 22, 2001), requires Federal agencies to prepare and submit to the
OMB a Statement of Energy Effects for any proposed significant energy
action. A ``significant energy action'' is defined as any action by an
agency that promulgated or is expected to lead to promulgation of a
final rule, and that: (1) Is a significant regulatory action under
Executive Order 12866, or any successor order; and (2) Is likely to
have a significant adverse effect on the supply, distribution, or use
of energy; or (3) Is designated by the Administrator of the Office of
Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) as a significant energy
action. For any proposed significant energy action, the agency must
give a detailed statement of any adverse effects on energy supply,
distribution, or use, should the proposal be implemented, and of
reasonable alternatives to the action and their expected benefits on
energy supply, distribution, and use.
Today's action would not have a significant adverse effect on the
supply, distribution, or use of energy and is therefore not a
significant energy action. Accordingly, DOE has not prepared a
Statement of Energy Effects.
I. Review Under Executive Order 13175
Executive Order 13175. ``Consultation and Coordination with Indian
tribal Governments'' (65 FR 67249 (Nov. 9, 2000)), requires DOE to
develop an accountable process to ensure ``meaningful and timely input
by tribal officials in the development of regulatory policies that have
tribal implications.'' ``Policies that have tribal implications''
refers to regulations that have ``substantial direct effects on one or
more Indian tribes, on the relationship between the Federal Government
and Indian tribes, or on the distribution of power and responsibilities
between the Federal Government and Indian tribes.'' Today's regulatory
action is not a policy that has ``tribal implications'' under Executive
Order 13175. DOE has reviewed today's action under Executive Order
13175 and has determined that it is consistent with applicable policies
of that Executive Order.
V. Public Participation
The public is invited to submit comments on the preliminary
determinations. Comments must be provided by August 19, 2011 using any
of the methods described in the ADDRESSES section of this notice. If
you submit information that you believe to be exempt by law from public
disclosure, you should submit one complete copy, as well as one copy
from which the information claimed to be exempt by law from public
disclosure has been deleted. DOE is responsible for the final
determination with regard to disclosure or nondisclosure of the
information and for treating it accordingly under the DOE Freedom of
Information regulations at 10 CFR 1004.11.
Issued in Washington, DC, on July 13, 2011.
Kathleen Hogan,
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Energy Efficiency, Office of Technology
Development, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.
[FR Doc. 2011-18082 Filed 7-19-11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450-01-P