[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 133 (Tuesday, July 12, 2011)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 40820-40822]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-17231]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
49 CFR Part 190
[Docket No. PHMSA-2011-0161]
Pipeline Safety; Enforcement Proceedings Involving an Informal
Hearing
AGENCY: Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA);
DOT.
ACTION: General policy statement; informal hearing process.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: PHMSA is issuing this document to notify operators of natural
gas and hazardous liquid pipeline facilities of the creation of a
dedicated ``Presiding Official'' for informal pipeline enforcement
hearings and the process operators can expect when requesting an
informal hearing. Hearings in pipeline safety enforcement cases are
conducted by a hearing officer in accordance with certain procedures
designed to ensure a fair and impartial decision on the merits. This
document explains those procedures and includes a description of the
dedicated hearing officer's roles and responsibilities, the process for
requesting a hearing, and the manner in which a case will proceed once
a hearing has been requested.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Sherri Pappas, Deputy Chief Counsel,
at 202-366-4400. Information about PHMSA may be found at http://phmsa.dot.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
The Federal safety statute and regulations for natural gas and
hazardous liquid pipeline facilities provide a description of the
enforcement authority and sanctions exercised by the Associate
Administrator for achieving and maintaining pipeline safety. Pursuant
to chapter 601 of Title 49, United States Code, after notice and an
opportunity for a hearing, the Associate Administrator may order an
operator of a pipeline facility to take necessary corrective action,
including revisions to
[[Page 40821]]
its procedures, and may assess a civil penalty for a violation of a
pipeline safety regulation or order (49 U.S.C. 60108(a), 60112,
60117(l), 60118(b), and 60122). The regulations also prescribe the
procedures governing the exercise of that authority and the imposition
of those sanctions. In general, subpart B of 49 CFR part 190 (190.201-
190.239) provides an opportunity for a pipeline operator to submit a
written answer and/or request a hearing prior to the issuance of any
order that makes a finding of violation, assesses a civil penalty, or
requires corrective measures to be taken.
Effective immediately, and to the extent practical, all timely
requested hearings will be held before the designated hearing officer
or ``Presiding Official'' within PHMSA.
II. Hearing Officer
The person within PHMSA who conducts hearings relating to civil
penalty assessments, compliance orders, or safety orders is the
designated hearing officer. The person is a senior attorney within the
Office of Chief Counsel, on the staff of the Deputy Chief Counsel. To
ensure the fairness and impartiality of the proceeding, the hearing
officer is outside the line of authority of the Associate Administrator
as well as any staff involved in the investigation and prosecution of
the enforcement case. The dedicated hearing officer is not engaged
personally in any investigative or prosecutorial functions with regard
to enforcement matters, such as preparation of notices of probable
violation relating to civil penalty assessments and compliance orders,
and notices relating to corrective action orders and safety orders.
The roles and responsibilities of the hearing officer are
consistent with current statutory and regulatory authority. They
include scheduling the hearing, holding pre-hearing conferences as
necessary, disposing of procedural requests or similar matters,
regulating the course of the hearing, ensuring an opportunity for a
full and complete record to be established, making a recommended
decision in the matter, and taking any other authorized action where
appropriate.
III. Separation of Functions
Formerly, hearings were held before several different attorneys
from the Office of Chief Counsel and were assigned to an attorney who
had no role in the investigation and prosecution of the case being
heard. Now, all hearings will be held, to the extent practical, before
the designated hearing officer, who will have no role in the
investigation and prosecution of any enforcement cases.
To ensure the impartiality and fairness of the decision-making
process, a hearing officer is (and has been) held to certain standards
regarding ``ex parte'' communications. An ex parte communication is any
informal communication between a party in a pending case and the
hearing officer regarding an issue in that case, occurring outside the
presence of the other parties and without notice and opportunity for
all parties to provide comment or rebuttal. If an enforcement case is
pending before a hearing officer, ex parte communications with the
hearing officer are not permitted by the operator, its counsel, or
agency staff involved in the investigation and prosecution of the case.
This applies to communications regarding information, facts, and
arguments regarding an issue in the case, but not routine
administrative matters, such as scheduling the hearing or providing
clarification about the enforcement process. This restriction also does
not apply to communications between the parties themselves.
In addition, an individual engaged in the performance of
investigative or prosecuting functions for the agency in a case may
not, in that or a factually related case, participate in the attorney's
recommended decision, but may participate at the hearing as a witness
or counsel and submit a recommendation pursuant to Sec. 190.213(b)(4).
IV. Requesting a Hearing
Section 190.209 provides that upon receipt of a notice of probable
violation, proposed civil penalty, or proposed compliance order, an
operator may respond within 30 days by paying the proposed penalty,
agreeing to the proposed compliance order, submitting written
information in answer to the notice, or requesting a hearing. Sections
190.233 and 190.239 also provide for responding to a notice of proposed
corrective action order or notice of proposed safety order, including
the option of requesting a hearing.
Pursuant to Sec. 190.211, any request for a hearing must be
accompanied by a statement of the issues that the respondent intends to
raise at the hearing. The issues may relate to the allegations in the
notice, proposed corrective actions, or the proposed civil penalty
amount. The request should also indicate whether or not the operator
will be represented by counsel at the hearing.
The right to a hearing is waived if not requested within 30 days of
receipt of the notice. An operator that submits a written response
without specifically requesting a hearing will be deemed to have waived
the right to a hearing, but the written material timely submitted will
be fully considered in the rendering of a decision in the matter. An
operator that requests only to ``reserve its right to a hearing'' will
be subject to the scheduling of a hearing unless the hearing request is
withdrawn.
V. Pre-Hearing Matters
Within a reasonable time after the request for a hearing, the
hearing officer will ensure that the respondent has an opportunity to
review all materials in the enforcement record pertinent to the issues
to be determined. The enforcement record includes the notice and the
violation report with exhibits that are comprised of documents gathered
during the inspection and any other information included by the
inspector that is relevant to the allegations.
The hearing officer will schedule the hearing, provide written
confirmation to the parties of the date, time and location, and request
a list of anticipated attendees. The hearing officer will also instruct
parties that all documents, evidence, or exhibits in support of the
case should be exchanged by furnishing a copy to all parties and
submitted at least ten days prior to the hearing. Any party intending
to introduce documents, evidence, or exhibits during the hearing will
also be directed to furnish copies to all parties.
The hearing officer will address all procedural matters, including
but not limited to, motions for extensions of time, stipulations in
lieu of a hearing on particular issues, or withdrawal of a hearing
request. The hearing officer may direct that a request contain
sufficient detail, be specific as to the reason(s) for the request, and
be served on the appropriate PHMSA regional office.
VI. Hearing
All hearings are held in accordance with Sec. 190.211 and are
conducted in an informal manner. The informal nature of the hearing
alleviates the need for the parties to strictly comply with formal
rules of evidence and rules of procedures. While the hearings are not
``formal,'' the hearing officer will take appropriate actions to
maintain an appropriate level of fairness and efficiency during the
proceeding. In addition, and with the assistance of the parties, the
hearing officer will ensure the hearing is conducted cordially and that
the parties maintain proper decorum at all times.
Hearings are currently held either telephonically or in person.
They may
[[Page 40822]]
also be held by video teleconference in the future. During the hearing,
the operator can expect the region issuing the notice to introduce the
allegations and provide an explanation as to the evidence gathered in
support. The operator will then have the opportunity to present its own
information, facts, evidence, explanations, and arguments in response.
The operator may submit any material relevant to the issues under
consideration, and may call witnesses on its behalf and examine the
evidence and witnesses presented by the region. At the close of the
operator's presentation, the hearing officer may allow the presentation
of any rebuttal information by the region, and respondents may then
respond to that information.
The hearing officer ensures that all parties have an ample
opportunity to present their position and supporting evidence, and will
end discussion on a topic only once it is clear that all the issues
have been fully examined. Questions may be asked by the hearing officer
during either party's presentations. In addition, the informal nature
of the proceeding allows the parties to ask questions of one another,
although parameters may be established to ensure the parties have
sufficient uninterrupted time to make their presentations. The hearing
officer ensures that discussion stays focused on the relevant and
determinative matters in the case and avoids allowing tangential issues
to become a distraction. The hearing will last as long as necessary to
ensure the parties have ample opportunity to present their case,
although the hearing officer will attempt to accommodate the parties'
schedules to the extent practicable.
Written materials and evidence presented at the hearing will be
collected by the hearing officer for insertion into the record.
Hearings are not recorded and are not transcribed, but if requested in
advance of the hearing, the respondent may make arrangements for the
hearing to be transcribed at its own expense, provided that a copy of
the final transcript is submitted for the record. The hearing officer
may take notes, including electronic notes and recordings during the
hearing, but such personal notes are not part of the official record or
maintained by the agency.
At the close of the hearing, the respondent may request an
opportunity to submit further written material for inclusion in the
record. The hearing officer will allow a reasonable time for the
submission of the material, but if the material is not submitted within
the time prescribed, the case will proceed to final action without the
material.
VII. After the Hearing
If post-hearing documents contain new evidence or new arguments,
the hearing officer will provide written notification to all parties
and direct the parties to respond within a certain amount of time. The
hearing officer may also request that additional documents be submitted
after the hearing, if necessary, to fully develop the record.
The hearing officer will ensure that all material submitted before
and during the hearing is placed in the record. At this stage, the
record will include the notice, violation report, written statements by
the parties, evidence submitted, list of hearing attendees, any hearing
transcript, and any other pre-hearing or post-hearing documents
submitted by the parties.
Upon the close of a hearing and receipt of all post-hearing
submissions, the hearing officer will prepare a recommended decision to
be issued by the Associate Administrator. The restriction on ex parte
communications discussed above is especially applicable at this stage
of the proceeding, and the hearing officer will not engage in such
discussions or communications regarding the case with anyone involved
in the prosecution or defense of the notice. The hearing officer's
recommended decision may be reviewed by the Deputy Chief Counsel and
staff of the Associate Administrator prior to issuance by the Associate
Administrator.
Upon signature of the decision by the Associate Administrator,
PHMSA will serve the decision upon the respondent and the applicable
region in accordance with Sec. 190.5. Decisions by the Associate
Administrator are also made publicly available on the PHMSA Enforcement
Transparency Web site.
Issued in Washington, DC, on July 1, 2011.
Bizunesh Scott,
Chief Counsel.
Jeffrey D. Wiese,
Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety.
[FR Doc. 2011-17231 Filed 7-11-11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4910-60-P