[Federal Register Volume 66, Number 128 (Tuesday, July 3, 2001)]
[Notices]
[Pages 35226-35230]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 01-16539]


-----------------------------------------------------------------------

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE

Office of the Secretary


U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces Proposed Rule Changes

ACTION: Notice of Proposed Changes to the Rules of Practice and and 
Procedure of the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This notice announces the following proposed changes to Rules 
13(c), 20 (b) and (c), 21 (b), 24, and 41(a) of the Rules of Practice 
and Procedure, United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces for 
public notice and comment:
Proposed Revision to Rule 13(c)

Attorneys

Rule 13. Qualifications to Practice

    (a) [Same]
    (b) [Same]
    (c) Each applicant shall file with the Clerk an application for 
admission on the form prescribed by the Court, together with an 
application fee in an amount prescribed by Court order, and a 
certificate from the presiding judge, clerk, or other appropriate 
officer of a court specified in (b) above * * *
    (d) [Same]
Proposed Revision to Rule 20(b) and (c)

Rule 20. Form of Petition for Grant of Review

* * * * *
    (b) Form to be used by an appellant's counsel. A petition for grant 
of review under Rule 18(a)(1) filed by counsel on behalf of an 
appellant will be substantially in the following form:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Signature of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Typed name of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Address of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Telephone no. of counsel)

(E-mail address, if any)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Date and manner of filing--see Rules 36 and 39))
    (c) An appellant or counsel on behalf of an appellant shall file a 
petition for grant of review in the manner and within the time limits 
set forth in Rule 19(a). Upon receipt, the Clerk shall stamp the 
petition indicating the date it was received and, if filed by mail 
under Rule 36(c), shall retain the envelope showing the postmark 
thereon.
Proposed Revision to Rule 21(b)

Rule 21. Supplement to Petition for Grant of Review

    (a) Review on petition for grant of review requires a showing of 
good cause. Good cause must be shown by the appellant in the supplement 
to the petition, which shall state with particularity the error(s) 
claimed to be materially prejudicial to the substantial rights of the 
appellant. See Article 59(a), UCMJ, 10 USC Sec. 859(a).
    (b) The supplement to the petition shall be filed in accordance 
with the applicable time limit set forth in Rule 19(a)(5)(A) or (B), 
shall include an Appendix required by Rule 24(a), shall conform to the 
provisions of Rules 24(b), 35A, and 37, and shall contain:
    (1) A statement of the errors assigned for review by the Court;
    (2) A statement of statutory jurisdiction, including:
    (A) the statutory basis of the Court of Criminal Appeals 
jurisdiction;
    (B) the statutory basis upon which this Court's jurisdiction is 
invoked;
    (3) A statement of the case setting forth a concise chronology, 
including all relevant dates. The chronology shall specify: (A) the 
results of the trial; (B) the actions of the intermediate reviewing 
authorities and the Court of Criminal Appeals; (C) the disposition of a 
petition for reconsideration or rehearing, if filed; and (D) any other 
pertinent information regarding the proceedings, [including, if set 
forth in the record, the date when service upon the accused of the 
decision of the Court of Criminal Appeals was effected.];
    (4) A statement of facts of the case material to the errors 
assigned, including specific page references to each relevant portion 
of the record of trial;
    (5) A direct and concise argument showing why there is good cause 
to grant the petition, demonstrating with particularity why the errors 
assigned are materially prejudicial to the substantial rights of the 
appellant. Where applicable, the supplement to the petition shall also 
indicate whether the court below has:
    (A) Decided a question of law which has not been, but should be, 
settled by this Court;
    (B) Decided a question of law in a way in conflict with applicable 
decisions of (i) this Court, (ii) the Supreme Court of the United 
States, (iii) another Court of Criminal Appeals, or (iv) another panel 
of the same Court of Criminal Appeals;
    (C) Adopted a rule of law materially different from that generally 
recognized in the trial of criminal cases in the United States district 
courts;
    (D) Decided the validity of a provision of the UCMJ or other act of 
Congress, the Manual for Courts-Martial, a service regulation, a rule 
of court or a custom of the service the validity of which was directly 
drawn into question in that court;
    (E) Decided the case (i) en banc or (ii) by divided vote;
    (F) So far departed from the accepted and usual course of judicial 
proceedings, or so far sanctioned such a departure by a court-martial 
or other person acting under the authority of the UCMJ, as to call for 
an exercise of this Court's power of supervision; or
    (G) Taken inadequate corrective action after remand by the Court 
subsequent to grant of an earlier petition in the same case and that 
appellant wishes to States; and
    (6) A certificate of filing and service in accordance with Rule 
39(e).
    (c)(1)Answer/reply in Article 62, UCMJ, appeals. An appellee's 
answer to the supplement to the petition for grant of review in an 
Article 62, UCMJ, 10 U.S.C Sec. 862 (1983), case shall be filed no 
later than 10 days after the filing of such supplement. A reply may be 
filed by the appellant no later than 5 days after the filing of the 
appellee's answer.
    (2) Answer/reply in other appeals. An appellee's answer to the 
supplement to the petition for grant of review in all other appeal 
cases may be filed no later than 30 days after the filing of such 
supplement, see Rule 21(e); as a discretionary alternative in the event 
a formal answer is deemed unwarranted, an appellee may file with the 
Clerk of the Court a short letter, within 10 days after the filing of 
the appellant's supplement to the petition under Rule 21, setting forth 
one of the following alternative positions: (i) that the United States 
submits a general opposition to the assigned error(s) of law and relies 
on its brief filed with the Court of Criminal Appeals; or (ii) that the 
United States does not oppose the granting of the petition (for some 
specific reason, such as an error involving an unsettled area of the 
law). A reply may be filed by the appellant no later than 10 days after 
the filing of the appellee's answer.
    (d) The Court may, in its discretion, examine the record in any 
case for the purpose of determining whether there appears to be plain 
error not assigned by the appellant. The Court may then

[[Page 35227]]

specify and grant review of any such errors as well as any assigned 
errors which merit review.
    (e) Where no specific errors are assigned in the supplement to the 
petition, the Court will proceed to review the petition without 
awaiting an answer thereto. See Rule 19(a)(5).
    (f) An appellant or counsel for an appellant may move to withdraw 
his petition at any time. See Rule 30. [Amended October 1, 1987; 
amended July 16, 1990, effective August 15, 1990; amended October 12, 
1994; amended January 20, 1999, effective February 1, 1999.]
Proposed Revision to Rule 24

Rule 24. Form, Content, and Page Limitations

    (a) Form and content. All briefs shall conform to the printing, 
copying, and style requirements of Rule 37, shall be legible, and shall 
be substantially as follows:

[[Page 35228]]

[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN03JY01.000


[[Page 35229]]


[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN03JY01.001


BILLING CODE 5001-08-C

[[Page 35230]]

Appendix

    [The brief of the appellant or petitioner shall include an 
appendix containing a copy of the Court of Criminal Appeals 
decision, unpublished opinions cited in the brief, and relevant 
extracts of rules and regulations. The appellee or respondent shall 
similarly file an appendix containing a copy of any additional 
unpublished opinions and relevant extracts of rules and regulations 
cited in the answer.]
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Signature of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Typed name of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Address of counsel)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Telephone no. of counsel)

Certificate of Filing and Service

    I certify that a copy of the foregoing was [mailed] [delivered] 
to the Court and [mailed] [delivered] to (enter name of each counsel 
of record) on
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(date)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Typed name and signature)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
(Address and telephone no.)

    (b) Page limitations. Unless otherwise authorized by order of 
the Court or by motion of a party granted by the Court (see Rule 
30), the page limitations for briefs filed with the Court, not 
including appendices, shall be as follows:
    (1) Briefs of the appellants/petitioners shall not exceed 50 
pages;
    (2) Answers of the appellees/respondents shall not exceed 50 
pages;
    (3) Replies of the appellants/petitioners shall not exceed 15 
pages.

Proposed Revision to Rule 41(a)

Rule 41. Photographing, Televising, Recording, or Broadcasting of 
Hearings

    (a) The photographing, televising, recording, or broadcasting of 
any session of the Court or other activity relating thereto is 
prohibited within the confines of the courthouse unless authorized 
by the Court.
    (b) Any violation of this rule will be deemed a contempt of this 
Court and, after due notice and hearing, may be punished 
accordingly. See 18 U.S.C Sec. 401.

DATES: Comments on the proposed changes must be received by (60 days 
from date of publication).

ADDRESSES: Forward written comments to William A. DeCicco, Clerk of 
the Court, United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, 450 
E Street, Northwest, Washington, DC 20442-0001.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: William A. DeCicco, Clerk of the 
Court, telephone (202) 761-1448 (Ext. 600).

Rules Advisory Committee Comment on Rule 13(c)

    The current rule requires payment of $25.00 for admission to the 
Court's Bar. Due to an increase in the cost of printing bar 
admission certificates, the fee needs to be changed. Rather than 
simply changing the amount in the Rule, however, an easier solution 
is to allow the Court to modify the amount of the fee by court order 
instead of a formal rule change. This procedure is similar to that 
of other courts and will make future changes less cumbersome. It 
will also give the Court more flexibility.

Rules Advisory Committee Comment on Rule 20(b) and (c)

    The proposed revision to Rule 20(b) will require counsel to 
include on the petition for grant of review an e-mail address, if 
any, and information regarding the date and manner of filing. Having 
counsel's e-mail address will aid the Court in contacting counsel 
should questions arise while the case is pending. Requiring the date 
and manner of filing will clarify exactly when the petition was 
filed and whether it was mailed or delivered by hand to the Court. 
The proposed revision to Rule 20(c) requires the Clerk to stamp the 
petition with the date it was received and, for petitions filed by 
mail, to retain the envelope showing the postmark thereon. This 
change will better enable the Court to record the filing date of the 
petition in case the timeliness of filing becomes an issue in the 
case.

Rules Advisory Committee Comment on Rule 21(b)

    Revised subsection (b)(2) is based upon Supreme Court Rule 
14(e)(iv) and Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 28(a)(4). Its 
purpose is to demonstrate that the petition is based upon a decision 
or order from which review may be sought and that the petition falls 
within the ambit of the Court's jurisdictional authority to grant 
review.
    An example of a statement of statutory jurisdiction under this 
subsection would read as follows:
    The jurisdictional of the [service] Court of Criminal Appeals 
rested upon Article 66(b)(1), UCMJ. This Court's jurisdiction is 
revoked under Article 67(a)(3), UCMJ.
    The purpose of the revision to the extent subsection (b)(2) is 
to provident a concise but comprehensive summary of the history of 
the case with respect to which review is sought. The changes will 
make more information available to the Court, including the 
statutory basis for invoking the jurisdiction of the Court. To the 
extent that dates relevant to the jurisdiction of the Court are 
established in the record, they are to be included in this section.

Rules Advisory Committee Comment on Rule 24

    This revision is based upon Supreme Court Rule 24(e) and Federal 
Rule of Appellate Procedure 28(a)(4). As in the case of the 
amendment to Rule 21(b), its purpose is to set out the statutory 
authorities vesting this Court with jurisdiction.
    The ``Statement of the Case'' is modified to require a brief but 
comprehensive summary of the prior disposition of the case.

Rules Advisory Committee Comment on Rule 41

    This revision adds a prohibition on the recording of appellate 
sessions within the confines of the courthouse unless authorized by 
the Court. This is consistent with the practice of other appellate 
courts and includes both video and audio record of proceedings.

    Dated: June 25, 2001.
L.M. Bynum,
Alternate OSD Federal Register Liaison Officer, DoD.

[FR Doc. 01-16539 Filed 7-2-01; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 5001-08-M