[From the U.S. Government Printing Office, www.gpo.gov]
EVALUATION OF JUN 2 s 1297 SEAWEED MARICULTURE POTENTIAL ON GUAM. 1. AMMONIUM UPTAKE BY, AND GROWTH OF TWO SPECIES OF GRACILARIA (RHODOPHYTA) Stephen G. Nelson, Roy N. Tsutsui and.Bruce R. Best Property of CSC Library UNIVERSITY OF GUAM MARINE LABORATORY, Techni.cal Report No. 61 U . S - DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE NOAIA QK COASTAL SERVICES CENTER ZS 569 2234 SOUTH HOBSON AVENUE * R4 January 1980 CHARLESTON, SC 294.05-2413 N45 1980 -This publication was printed under the auspices of NOAA,Office of, Sea Grant, Department of Commerce, under Grant No. 04-8-MOl-178 to the University,of Hawaii (Contract Number.11--07121 to the' University of Guam). The U. S. Government is'authorized to produce and dis- tribute repFints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright notation that may -appe ar herein. UNIHI-SEAGRANT-CR-80-04 Project No. PM/M-1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ,LIST OF TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . LIST OF FIGURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ABSTRACT . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . iv INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... ... . . . . MATERIALS AND METHODS . . . . I. . . . . ... . . . . 2 Ammonium Uptake . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Growth in Tank Culture . ... . . . . . . . .. . . . . . 3 Growtfi in Reef-Flat Culture System . . . . . . . . . . 3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Ammonium Uptake . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . 7 Growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . 16 LITERATURE CITED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 APPENDIX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 LISTOF TABLES Page Table 1. Statistics.describing the regression of rate of ammonium uptake, V (pg-at NH4 +-N*g`l.h-l)9 on'the mean substrate concentration, S (jig-at NH4+-N-R.-l), for Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata at different salinities 10 Table 2. Means and standard deviations of nitrogen content of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata used in the uptake experiments,.' 12 Table 3. Specific growth rates (% increase in wet weight per day) of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata in both a tank culture system and a raft culture system on Guam 13 Table 4. Statistics describing the regression of specific growth rate (% increase in wet weight per day) on initial size of thalli of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata 15 7 LIS@ OF FIGURES Page Figure 1. Design of the bamboo rafts which were used to culture Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata in Pago Bay, Guam . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Figure 2. Map of Pago Bay showing the locations of the rafts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Figure 3. Plot of amm6nium-Initrogen uptake rate (V) on mean substrate concentration (S) for Gracilaria arcuata at 340/oo 230/oo (o) and 130/oo .8. Figure 4. Plot of ammonium-nitrogen uptake rate (V)-on mean substrate concentration (S) for Gracilaria edulis at 340/oo (-), 230/oo (o) and l3o/oo . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Figure A-1. Response of the Orion ammonia electrode. The relation between dissolved ammonium- nitrogen and electrical potential . . . . . . . 20 -ABSTRACT We examined the specifi@ growth rates of and ammonium uptake. by Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria. arcuata from Guam. Ammonium uptake kinetics were examined in the laboratory at salinities of 130/oo, 230/oo and 340/oo for each species. Ammonium uptake was. examined over a wide range of substrate concentrations with the highest concentration at 5 x 103 pg-at NH +-N-k-l. A strong dif- 4 fusion component was indicated in the ammonium uptake systems of both species. The nitrogen content of@the thalli used,in the experiments was variable but averaged 2.07% for G. edulis and 3.31% for G. arcuata. Specific growth rates for thalli of each species were compared in both an outdoor tank culture system and. a raft culture system in Pago Bay, Guam. Growth rates were generally higher in the.raft culture system than in the tank culture system. Mean specific growth rates ranged from 2.02% per day for G. arcuata in tank culture in the fall to 5.11% per day for G. Julis in tank culture in the summer. INTRODUCTION Recently there has been an increasing interest in seaweeds and seaweed products on the world market (Michanek, 1978). Con- comitant with this growing interest, efforts have been directed toward the development of seaweed mariculture systems throughout the world. The major purposes for seaweed mariculture include phycocolloid production, wastewater purification and human con- pumption. Some seaweed culture systems have proven so .productive that they have also been suggested as a means of biomass produc- tion for energy conversion (Doelling, 1978). One genus of red algae (Rhodophyta) on Guam seems to have potential in each of these-:categories. This is the genus Gracilaria:which is represented by several species on the reef- flat habitats of Guam.' This genu� is the object of commercial harvest and culture in many areas of the world. In 1976 the worldwide value ofthe agar from Gracilaria:' and its direct con- sumption was valued at approximately US$2,7000,000 (Tsuda and Doty, 1978). One species of this genus, Gracilaria edulis (Gmel.)' Silva, is often found in the markets of Guam where it is sold as a fresh vegetable for human consumption. The two most common spe'eies'of Gracilaria on Guam are G. edulis and G. arcuata Zanard. Our preliminary studies to eval- uate the m'ariculture potential of seaweeds on Guam have focussed .on these two species. The objectives of the present study were 1) to examine the kinetics of ammonium uptake by the two species, and'2) to determine the growth of individual thalli of each speIcies in outdoor tank culture and in reef-flat culture systems. These objectives were chosen to aid us both in the design of future experiments and in the development of a strong research focus for evaluating the potential for the culture of Gracilaria on Guam. The data on ammonium uptake will also be of value in determining the potential value of these species for removal of ammonium from seawater enriched with wastewater., MATERIALS AND METHODS Specimens for the study were collected from two locations on Guam. Thalli of Gracilaria edulis were collected.frgm the reef margin near Talofofo Bay, while those of G. arcuata were collected from the reef flat at Hilaan Point. Ainmonium Uptake Thalli were acclimated at 320C from four to six days at salinities of either 13' 23 or 34 0 oo prior to determining uptake rates. For the uptake experiments, 0.4 to 1.0 gram dry weight of the seaweed were incubated in jars with 350 mZ of filtered (0. 45p) seawater in an environmental chamber. The temperature was main- tained at 320C �J0C and 200 foot candles of light were.supplied from banks of incandescent and fluorescent lights. Ammonium I.. chloride (NH4C0 was added to the jars as an ammonium source. 3 Mean substrate concentrations ranged from 3.0 x 100 to 5.0 x 10 jig-at All jars were aerated to ensure adequate mixing. Control jars without plants were also monitored under the same conditions over the range of ammonium concentrations. The dissolved ammonium levels were determined at the onset and after five hours of incubation, with an Orion ammonia electrode (Model 95-10) attached to a Beckman expanded-scale pH meter (Model 55-2). Gilbert and Clay (1973) found that the ammonia electrode compared favorably with the pheno1hypochlorite method (Solorzano, 1969) for determining levels of ammonia in sea- water. Since salinity is known to affect the probe, it was neces- sary to calibrate it using standard solutions consisting of.NH 4 Ck dissolved in each of the experimental salinities. Preparation of. the appropriate salinities was accomplished by diluting seawater with distilled'water. The response characteristics of the probe are,discussed in.the Appendix. After determination of the change in ammonium concentration in the jars, the-thalli were rinsed in distilled water and dried at 5 00C for 24 hours. Rates of uptake were calculated and expres- sed as jig-at NN+@N-g-71-h7l- A least-squares analysis (Snedecor and Cochran, 1967) was preformed for each regression of uptake rate on substrate concentration. Portions of.thalli from each experiment were analyzed for organic nitrogen content by a microkjeldahl procedure with replicate samples. 2 Growth in Tank Culture Freshly collected thalli of G. edulis and G. arcuata were drained to remove excess water an-d tagged with -a 1-5cm piece of electrical wire attached to a mylar tag.. The thalli and tags were weighed to the nearest O.-Ol g on a triple beam balance. The thalli were then attached to the bottoms of 30 x 45 x 10 cm polypropylene mesh baskets'and placed in a shallow wooden tank outdoors. Ten to fifteen thalli were placed in each basket.@.The tank was supplied with a constant and vigorous flow of seawater from Pago Bay. The baskets floated in th tank and the thalli were maintained at 10 cm below the surface. At approximatelyweekly intervals, the tagged thalli were reweighed. At the end of the experi- ments, the'tags and wires were removed and weighed and these values were-substracted to obtain the actual wet weight of each thallus. The specific growth rate of each thallus was calculated according to the following expression. 100 [In (Nt/No)] t where V specific growth rate as per cent increase in wet weight per day. Nt final weight on day t. and No initial weight A least-squares analysis (Snedecor and Cochran, 1967) was performed on:the regression of specific growth rate on the initial size of thallus for each.species. .Growth in Reef-Flat Culture System To determine the growth of thalli in a reef-flat culture system, two bamboo rafts were constructed and fastened in position in Pago Bay. Weighed thalli were attached between the strands of 3-ply polypropylene rope. The strands of rope were weighted with pieces of iton rebar and suspended from the bamboo rafts. The raft-culture system is depicted in Figure I and the locations of the rafts in Pago Bay are shown in Figure 2. 3. To p View f i oat Side View .7LM Fig. 1. Design of the bamboo rafts which were used to culture Gracilaria edulis and Gracilari a arcuata in Pago Bay, quam. f I oat /F 4 0 road 0 200 raft 1 m Northeast Reef Flat < @raft Pacific Fig. 2. Map of Pago Bay showing the locations of the rafts. One raft system and some thalli from the second raft system were lost as a result of wave action when Typhoon Tip passed south of Guam in October 1979. The remaining thalli were used to calculate specific growth rates as described above. 6 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Ammonium Uptake The uptake of ammonium by both species of Gracilaria was linearly related to the mean substrate concentration. Figures 3 and 4 indicate the relation between the rate of ammonium uptake and the mean substrate concentration for each species. Statistics describing the regression of uptake rate (V) on mean substrate concentration (S) are shown in Table 1. The correlation coeffi- cients for these regressions ranged from 0.94 to 0.98. This suggests that a diffusion component in addition to a process of active transport is responsible for ammonium uptake by these species. The studies of D'Elia and DeBoer (1978) also indicated a strong diffusion component in ammonium uptake by the red algae Gracilaria foliifera (Forsskal) Borgesen and Neog.@rdhi6lla baileyi (Harvey ex K;Rzing) Wynne and Taylor. In studies of other marine macrophytes, NH +uptake could 4 be adequately described by the Michaelis-Menton equation. This suggests an active transport mechanism is involved. Topinka (1978) showed that the ammonium uptake kinetics of the brown alga, Fucus spiralis L. could b'e described by the Michaelis- Menton expression and that the rate of.uptake was influenced by temperature. Studies of the green alga Codium. fragile subsp. tomentosoides (Van Goor) Silva (Hanisak and Harlin, 1978) indicated saturation kinetics of ammonium uptake which were influenced by both light and temperature. The data of D'Elia and DeBoer (1978) showed that-ammonium. uptake kinetics for Gracilaria foliifera and Neogardhiella: baileyi were probably the result of two uptake systems. The first was characterized as a high affinity system which could be described by the Michaelis-Menton expression. This system predominated at substrate concentrations below 10 VM of NH4 (7.8 Vg-at NH4 +-N - Z-1.) .Above.this concentration, a strong.- diffusive component predominated. A similar pattern of NR4 uptake was described for corals which contained.symbiotic algae (Muscatine and D'Elia, 1978)., The mathematical expression derived to describe the uptake kinetics'is as fQIIQws,: V = Vmax S -(K'+S )-1 +(K D -S) where V and S represent the rate of uptake.and the mean substrate conceiitration)respectively;'Vmax represents the maximum rate of uptake, K represents the substrate concentration when V 1/2 Vmax, and KD is equal to the slope of the linear portion of the plot of V on S. 7 0 0. 0 0 000 U) o + + 4- TO + z 0. 0 U) ++ + 10 100. + 00 S (Ag a t N H4- N C.I)O Fig. 3. Plot of ammonium-nitrogen uptake rate (V) on mean substrate concentration (S) for Gracilaria. arcuata at 340/oo 230/oo (o) and 130/oo 8 0 0. 0 +++ CP CP 0. 190 OD T 0. L-- z 4- + + +0 + 08 0 U) 0 OqD 00 0 0 10 100 + 1000 S (Ag-at NH 4- N-I Fig. Plot of anmonium-nitrogen uptake rate (V) on mean substrate concentration (S) for Gracilaria edulis at 340/oo H, 230/00 (0) and 130/00 Table 1. Statistics describi @g the regression of rate of ammonium uptake, V (pg-at NH4-N *g-l-h-1), on the mean substrate concentration, S (pg-at NH +- N-k-1), for Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata at aifferent salinities. Salinity Correlation Species 0/00 Slape y-intercpt Coefficient N G. edulis 13 0.089 8.529 0.9816 38 G. edulis 23 0.051 @3.754 0.9826 40 G. edulis 34 0.188 24.703 0.9818 24 'G. arcuata 13 0.089 -0.303 0.9448 20 G. arcuata 23 0.114 1.050 0.9849 16 G. arcuata 34 0.060 7.910 0.9395 60 10 At high substrate concentrations, the rate of uptake (V) is essentially determined by the diffusion component (KD-S). This was the prevailing situation in the present study and is evidenced by the high degree of correlation between V and S for both G. edulis and G. arcuata. Since the study of D'Elia and DeBoer (1978) was limi7ted to substrate concentrations below 50 11M of NH4 (38.9.pg-at + . - I ) V NH.4.-N Z we have demonstrated that non-saturation kinetics are evident even+at very high substrate concentrations (up to 5.0 x 103 Vg-at NH4-N-X-l). Since D'Elia and DeBo.er (1978) found a strong dependence of ammonium uptake on.the C:N ratio of the thalli, we analyzed our specimens for organic nitrogen content. The results ar e displayed in Table 2. There was a considerable amount of variability in the .nitrogen content of the thalli, which we suspect was the result of individual variation. There were no apparent seasonal differences. The percentage of organic nitrogen ranged from 2.20 to 4.23% for G. arcuata and from 1.02 to 3.95% for G. edulis with means of 3.31% and 3.07%, respectively. Our data cover a wide range of substrate concentrations. We were able to monitor uptake rates at very high substrate concentra- tions through the use of an Orion ammonia electrode. Many studies of ammonium uptake utilize the method of Solorzano (1969) for determination of dissolved ammonium (Topinka, 1978; Hanisak and Harlin, 1978; D'Elia And DeBoer, 1978). This method is generally limited to ammonium concentrations below 50 pg-at NH _'_ L-1. With the ammonia 4- probe, we were able to monitor uptake rates at substrate concentra- -1 of NH +_ tions greater than 103 vg-at-t 14 Of course., 4 - trations are much greater than those which.would be found in natural Gracilaria. habitats, but the data are interesting in light of the potential of Gracilaria for stripping ammonia from wastewater. It appears, from our data, that both species of Gracilaria we studied would be well suited for removal of NH@-N from seawater. Growth The specific growth rates of-G. edulis thalli in tank culture during September and.October of 1977-9 ranged up to 6% per day with a mean of 2.6% per day. This species had a higher growth rate during Juneand July 1979 when specific growth rates averaged 5.1% per day. In tank culture, the mean specific growth rate of G. arcuata during September and October of 1979 was 2.02% per day. In field culture during September and October, mean specific growth rates for G. edulis and G. arcuata were 4.8 and 3.5% per day, respec- tively @Fhe -mean specitlic growth rates for each species and culture system@are shown in Table 3. Table 2. Means and standard deviations of nitr ogen content of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata used in the uptake experimeints. MeAn % Nitrogen Species Date Standard Deviation Sample Size G. edulis 9/13/79 1.02 0.00 2 G. edulis 9/28/79 2.87 0.22 2 G. edulis 10/26/79 .1.45 0.02 2 G.,edulis 10/26/79 1.88 0.116 2 .G. edulis ll/ 9/79 1.99 0.12 2 -G. edulis 12/ 9/79 3.95 0-00 2 G. edulis 12/16/79 1.33.� 0.00 2 G. arcuata 7/26/79 4.23 0.17 2 G. arcua@a 7/28/79 3.50 1.02 2 G. arcuata 7/29/79 2.20 0.06 2 G. edulis all data 2.07 0.95 14 G..arcuata all data 3.31 1.03 6 12 Table 3. Specific growth rates (% increase in wet weight per day) of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata in both a tank culture system and a raft culture system on Guam. Mean Specific Culture Growth Rate Standard Species System Date W Deviation N G. edulis tank 6/79 j.11 0.23 30 G. edulis tank 9/79 2.56 2.58 .60 G. arcuata tank 9/79 2.021- 1.16 19 G. edulis raft 9/79 4@. 80 3.53 15 G. arcuata raft 9/79 3.50 0.72 V 13 Table 4 displays the statistics which describe the regression of specific growth rate on initial weight of the thallus for each species, in both the tank culture and the reef-flat culture systems. With the exception of G. arcuata in reef-flat culture, there was a negative correlation (r ranged from -0.3075 to -0.4298) between initial size and specific growth rate. In the case of G. arcuata from:the reef-flat culture systein, there was no significant correlation (r.= 0.2353, p < 0.05). However, because of the small sample size (n = 8), we feel that the data, in this case, are inconclusive. Most of the reef-flat-grown G. arcuata thalli were lost as a result of storm damage from Typ7hoon Tip. The specific growth rates found in the present study for G. edulis and G. arcuata are similar to those described by other investigators for other species of Gracilaria. Causey et al. (1946) showed that growth rates of Gracilaria confervoides (L.) .Greville [now known as G. verrucosa (Hudson) Papenf.] in North _i@t - Carolina.were greatest depths of less than four feet (1.2 m). They found also that growth rates were most rapid at temperatures between 250 and 300 and were unaffected by salinity within the normal range of fluctuation. At depths of less than 1.2 m, plants doubled in weight within 10 days., In raceway culture systems at Woods Hole, Massachusetts, DeBoer et al. (1978) reported specific growth rates of 3-5% for Gracilaria foliifera in unenriched seawater. In the same studies, specific growth rates of over 12% were obtained by enrichment of the media with ammonia. DeBoer and Ryther (1977) reported potential yields of Gracilaria foliifera from tank culture in Massachusetts of 28.0 tons (dry weight) ha-1--yr-1 while production of up to 46 tons (dry weight) -ha-1-yr-1 were reported from culture systems for Cracilaria in Florida (Lapointe et al., 1976). Hoyle (1978) reported mean growth rates of 12.24% and 6.41% per day for G. bursapastoris (Cmelin) Silva and G. coronopifolia J. Ag., respec- tively, in tank culture in Hawaii. It is most likely that the growth rates of G. edulis and' G. arcuata on Guam can be enhanced by-nutrient enrichment. This, could be accomplished by the addition of nutrients to tank cul- ture systems or by the suspension of bags of nutrients near raft culture systems. 14 Table 4. SEatistics describing the regression of specific growth rate (% increase.in wet weight per day) on initial size of thalli of Gracilaria edulis and Gracilaria arcuata. Culture Correlation Species System Date Slope y-intercept Coefficient N G. edulis tank 6/79 -0.047 5.77 -0.368 30 G. edulis tank 9/79 -0.069 2.56 -0.303 60 G., arcuata tar)k 9/79 -0.048 2.29 -0.365 19 @.G. edulis raft 9/79 -0@.)377 7.572 -0.430 15 G. arcuata raft 9/79 0.057 3.035 0.2353 8 15 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank'Dr. Roy T. Tsuda and Dr. Jack R. Davidson, of the Universities of Guam and Hawaii, respectively, for arranging the funding for this preliminary study. We are also grateful to Mr. Steve Hedlund who allowed us to use his data on growth rates of Gracilaria edulis for the summer of 1979. Thanks go to Dr. James A. Marsh, Jr. and Dr. R. T. Tsuda for reviewing the manuscript, and to Mrs. Teresita C. Balajadia and Mrs. Maria C.*Flores for typing the draft and final report, respectively. 16 LITERATURE CITED Causey, N. B., J. P. Prytherch, J. McCaskill, H. J. Humm and F. A. Wolf. 1946. Influence of environmental factors upon the growth of Gracilaria confervoides. Duke Univ. Marine Lab. Bull. 3:19-24. DeBoer, J. A.$ H. J. Guigli, T. L. Israel and C. F. D'Elia. 1978. Nutritionalstudies of two red algae. I. Growth rate as a function of nitrogen source and concentration. J. Phycol. 14:261-266. DeBoer, J. A.,and J. H. Ryther. 1977. Potential yields trom a waste-recycling algal mariculture system. pp. 231-249. In: R. Krauss ted.], The Marine Plant Biomass of the Pacific Northwest Coast. Oregon State University Press. D'Elia,- C. F.,and J. @. DeBoer. 1978. Nutritional studies of two red algae. II. Kinetics of ammonium and nitrate uptake. J. Phycol. 14:266-272. Doelling, N. 1978. The economics and engineering of large-scale algae biomass energy systems. MIT/Marine Industry Opportunity Brief No. 11, Mass-lust. Technol. Sea Grant Program. Cambridge, Mass. 20 pp. Gilbert, T. R.,and A. M. Clay. 1973. Determination of ammonia in aquaria and sea water using the ammonia electrode. Analyt. Chem. 45:1757-1759. Hanisak, M. D.,and M. Harlin. 1978. Uptake of.inorganic nitrogen by Codium fra&ile subsp. tomentosoldes (Chlorophyta). J. Phycol. 14:450-454. Hoyle, M. D. 1978. Reproductive phenology and growth rates in two species of Gracilaria.from Hawaii. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 35:273-283. Lapointe, B. E., L. D. Williams, j. C. Goldman and J. H. Ryther. 1976. The mass outdoor culture of macgoscopic marine algae. Aquaculture 8:@-24. Michanek, G. 1978. Trends in applied phycology with a literature ,review: Seaweed farming on an industrial scale. Bot. Mar. 21:469-475. Muscatine, L.,and C. K. D'Elia. 1978. The uptake and retention of ammonium-N by reef corals. Limnol. Oceanogr. 23:725-734. 17 Snedecor, G. W.,and W. G. Cochran. 1967. Statistical methods. Iowa State Univ. Press, Ames. Iowa. 539 pp. Solorzano, L. 1969. Determination of ammonia in natural waters by the pheno1hypochlorite method. Limnol. Oceanogr. 14:799- 801. Topinka, J. A. 1978. Nitrogen uptake by Fucus spiralis (Phaeophyceae). J. Phycol. 14:241-247. Tsuda, R. T.,and M. S. Doty. 1978. Summary report of the advisory seminar for the Republic of China-United States of America Cooperative Science program on cultivation and utilization of economic algae (Guam Reef Hotel, June 5-7, 1978). Unpublished report to the National Science Foundation. Re Project FCS-022. APPENDIX Ammonia is present in solu'tion Ln seawater in two forms, ionized (NH +)and un-ionized (NH The equilibrium equation . 4. for ammonia in aqueous solution is: NH + + H 0 NH + H 0 4 2 3 3 The relative proportions of NH +to NH are strongly dependent 4 3 on pH. Increased pH shifts the equilibrium curve to the right. The Orion ammonia probe was used to determine the amount of total ammonia dissolved in seawater by treating the samples with NaOH to convert the NH + 4 to the un..4ionized form (NH3). The hydrophobic membrane on the ammonia probe is permeable to NH3. When NH3 diffuses from.the sample across the membrane the pH of the internal solution of the probe is changed. This pH change was read as millivolts on a Beclanan expanded scale pH meter. The change in millivolts can be converted to Vg-at- 9,-l of NH +-N or other convenient units by recording the probe's 4 31 response to a series of standard solutions. A typical calibra- tion curve is shown in Figure A-1. The probe response is very precise. The response curve is linear at substrate concentrations greater than approximately 5 pg-at NH4 +-N- Cl. At.lower concentrations:thexesponse is curvilinear. The response of the probe is affected by temperature and salinity so the calibration curve should be constructed prior to each group of samples. We found that the ammonia probe was a convenient method for monitoring ammonium uptake by seaweeds. 19 0 0. 0 0 0- + m 0. z CT) 150 9 .30 POTENTIAL M V Fig. A-1. Response of the Orion ammonia electrode. The relation between dissolved ammonium-nitrogen and electrical potential. 20