[From the U.S. Government Printing Office, www.gpo.gov]
;-t 5@%Wfy 1 4 & Regional 41f@lrf bmsion of Camm#* %Whs t3 -COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Phase I) U11 CITY OF HAINES1 ALASKA 61; " h17 5 VO Ilk--- a) HT 168 H35 C66 1976 J U N E 1976 phaseI R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. H A I N E S C 0 M P R E H E N S I.V E P L A N (Phase I) Consulting services provided to the Haines Pl-anning Commission with respect to the Economic Base Study by D. Eric McDowell, principal of Homan - McDowell Associates, Juneau, Alaska; professionally associated in this Phase I planning project with Bob Pavitt, President of the fi m of R. W. Pavitt and Associates, Inc, Juneau, Alaska. US Department of Commerce NOAA Coastal Services Center Library 2234 South Hobson Avenue Charleston, SC 29405-2413 The preparation of this report was financed in part through a Comprehensive Planning Grant from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, under the provisions of Section 701 of the Housing Act of 1954 as amended, and the Division of Community Plan- ning of theAlaska Department of Community and Reg- ional Affairs. June, 1976 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION I. BACKGROUND FOR PLANNING 3 A. NATURAL.ENVIRONMENT 3 (1) Geography (2) Geology (3) Topography (4) Soils (5) Hydrology (6) Climate (7) Vegetation (8) Fish and Wildlife (9) Mineral Resources (10) Geophysical Hazards B. MAN-MADE ENVIRONMENT (1) History Land Use (3) Land Status (4) Housi*ng (5) Community Facilities and Services (a) local government- 6d:,m6n1cipgl) 'offffibs", (b) water and sewer utilities (c) electric utility (d) solid waste collection and disposal (e) library facilities and services (f) museum facilities and services (g) public safety .(h) educiation ,(i) cultural.facilities and services 0) recreation and open space (k) health and social services. 0 ) cemeteries (m) communications (6) Transportation facilities and services (a) surface transportation (b) marine transportation (c) air transportation Ilk R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -ii- TABLE OF CONTENTS - continued Page II. ECONOMIC BASE STUDY 58 A. ANALYSIS OF THE PRESENT STATUS OF THE HAINES ECONOMY 58 (1) Average Annual Employment Survey (2) Other Surveys (3) Results of the Average Annual Employment Survey (4) Results of the Fisherman't Survey (5) Unemployment Compensation and Public Assistance (6) Sectors of the Haines Economy B. INDUSTRIES IN HAINES: PRESENT STATUS AND FUTURE OUTLOOK 83 (1) Timber (2) Fisheries (3) Tourism (4) Transportation (5) Mining (6) Outer Continental Shelf Oil Development (7) Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (8) Cottage Industry (9) Arts and Crafts (10) Agriculture (11) Natural Gas Pipeline C. POPULATION ANALYSIS AND FORECASTS (1) Causes of Population Change (2) Historic Population Trends (3) Estimating the Present Population (4) Future Population Projections (5) Summary of Population Projections III. ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION 128 IV. COMMUNITY GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 138 V. GENERAL COMMENTS 146 APPENDIX 148 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 153 POCKET PART Land Use Map - Overall Planning Area Community Area Soils Map Land Tenure - Overall Planning Area Water and Sewer Service Land Use Map - Community Planning Area Areas Map Land Tenure - Community Planning Area Transportation and Community Facilities Map 1@ k %I to Halt, unction 159 Miles, to Intersection with Alcan Hwy. % % % A Proposed Hw y. Re-route 0- P, PROPOSED KLONDIKE AL* NATION '01 V , PARK 49 t-off! Agism SAY Skagway N RI vvr ON, ... . ... V CITY OF HAINES LOCAI NIR, Utak rku AND PORT CHILIKOOT akh Mild 0.0 Haines Cut-Off Highway River N -14 & L Proposed Chilkat State ParK M QIN 7 M G L A C I E R Q, L 3 0 BAY Vol r N 14 0 N 0 Ilk @N A T 10 N A L aR berners Say M 0 N U M E N Ti, or- 0 0 01- o' CITY, AN (i.sq' 0 City and Borough of Juneau 0 Zq no G t us avus'@ STATE CAPITAL 'Itrid of ChIlkat Range Annexed March of 9,Z5 JUNEAU % 9 dmiralty Island . . . . . . . . . . SCALE: R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. HAINES COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (PHASE Il INTRODUCTION Scope Phase I of the Haines Comprehensive.Plan is basically an inventory of physical, social, economic and environmental factors which have influenced the community in the past, and will impact its future growth and development. The planning area included within the parameters of the study varies in accordance with the significance of the subject matter to the community. Whilethe City of Haines does not have extraterritorial planning powers, the recreational development of the Chilkat State Park, the ownership of the Lutak Inlet dock facility and the opera- tion of the Haines Airstrip are obviously of major importance to the people of the City. Similarly, the fish processing facilities at Excursion Inlet, the development of Canada's Kluane National Park and the acceleration of hard-rock mining activity in the Yukon will significantly impact the economic potential of Haines. Thus, while the elements of the Haines Comprehensive Plan will be limited to the City and immediately adjacent areas, the factors considered in preparation of this Phase I Report and Economic Base Study will range considerably broader. Purpose Planning is the process of assisting elected officials in understa n- ding the options available to them in making informed decisions in the public interest. It consists of research; analysis and evalua- tion; determination of goals and objectives; and development of alternative courses of action to achieve those goals. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -2- Haines and Port Chilkoot prepared a Comprehensive Plan with the assistance of the Alaska State Housing Authority in 1964. Since that time, the two cities have merged, the relationship of Haines to Southeast Alaska and the rest of the State has undergone a substantive change, and the economic and social change that has occurred in the intervening 12 year period combine to make that plan less useful as a guide to public decision-making. The Alaska Department of Community and Regional Affairs is assist-, ing the City in the development of a new comprehensive community plan. Financially aided by a grant obtained from.the U.S Depart- ment of Housing and Urban Development, this document, which comprises Phase I of the planning work program, is intended to provide the necessary data to proceed with the preparation of the plan. The Planning Commission, encouraged by the positive response exhibited by the people of Haines, has broadened the scope of the Phase I work program to include an active citizen participation element that will develop a meaningful.set of community planning goals and objectives intended to guide and facilitate the work of comprehensive plan preparation in Phase 11 of the project. In short, then, it is the purpose of this Phase I Report to identify, analyze and evaluate the issues and opportunities facing the community; and to articulate the needs and desires expressed by the citizens of Haines. R W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) I. BACKGROUND FOR PLANNING This chapter of the plan constitutes the inventory of natural and man-made features of the planning area, and provides the factual data on which sound planning projections and recommendations can be based. A. NATURAL ENVIRONMENT (1) Geography Located at Latitude 590-12.3' North, Longitude 135*-26.7' West, Haines is in the northern part of Southeast Alaska. It is approxi- mately 75 airline miles northwest of Juneau, and 16 milessouth of Skagway. The community is situated on the Deshu Isthmus of the Chilkat Peninsula at the head of Lynn Canal in Alaska's Panhandle. In 1970, the boundaries of Haines, the City of Port Chil-koot,and some@small adjacent areas were consolidated; the City of Haines now containing some 1700 acres (2.66 square miles) of area within its new limits. Haines lies within the Haines Borough, a juris- diction covering more than 2,600 square miles in northern Southeast Alaska. The City is nestled in a valley in that part of the Coast Mountains of the Pacific Mountain System known as the Chilkat Range, and is virtually surrounded by mountains, glaciers, inlets, fiords and spectacularly rugged terrain. (2) Geo'logy The Haines' area was probably covered by glacier ice several times during the Pleistocene Epoch (the time from about 2 million to R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -4- 10,000 years ago.) The.presence of marine deposits several hundred feet above sea-level indicates that the land has been substantially uplifted since the most recent deglaciation of the region about 10,000 years ago. The rate of uplift of the land at Haines (relative to .sea level) during the past 40 years has been 2.26 centimeters (about 9/10ths of an inch) per year, and is thought to be due to rebound as a result of the absence of the weight of glacial ice. Both bedrock and surficial deposits are present in the area. The exposed bedrock consists of metamorphic (metebasalt and p .yroxenite) rock, and igneous rocks@ which include diorite and tonalite (quartz diorite). The surficial'deposits range from drift,'outwash and . ice-.c.ontact deposits, to Chilkat River delta-deposits and man-made r fill. Chilkat, Chilkoot and Lutak Inlets are deep, glacially scoured fiords. East of Haines, Chilkoot Inlet reaches depths exceeding 50 fathoms (300 feet). Portage Cove slopes gently from shore to a depth of about 50 fathoms, while Chilkat I"nlet depths range from shoaling water in McClellan flats to over 100 fathoms (600 feet) near-Seduction Point at the south end of the Chilkat.Peninsula. Most of the built-up area of Haines has been constructed on an elevated beach whose crestline roughly parallels part of the present shore of Portage Cove., Deposits of thi,s former beach extend from an altitude of about 150 feet near the mountain front at the north edge of the City to about 60 feet elevation between Haines and Port Chilkoot. Fifteen feet of clean-bedded mixed sand and gravel with some cobbles and a few boulders are exposed in the northern part of Haines. The beach deposit on which Haines is built R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I)i -5- indicate that the land built up as'a spit during emergence, when shorelines parallel to the mountain front north of Haines were'de- veloping. If this interpretation is correct, it would indicate that there was a water connection between Chilkoot and Chilkat Inlets, and that the present Chilkat Peninsula was an island at that time. Haines lies in the circum-Pacific earthquake belt; one of the world's qreatest zones of seismic activity. Although it is.not. yet possible to scientifically predict the occurrence of-destructive earthquakes or their probable characteristics, there are indicators by which the degree of likelihood may be estimated:. (a) the seismicity or histori,cal record of earthquakes in a region or area.@ (b) the degree of tectonic activity of the region or area, as indicated,chiefly by the recency-of fault movement. -There are no recorded epicenters of earthquakes within the Haines area itself. The closest ' epicenter for any earthquake of magnitude 6 or greater is about .30 miles northwest of Haines in the Chilkat River valley. This earthquake occurred March 9, 1952, and had a magnitude of 6. Epicenters of only 12 other,earthquakes.are re-, corded as being within about 50 miles of Haines.. Magnitudes for these earthquakes were less than 5 or were not computed-Thirty nine earthquakes within 100 miles of Haines have been instrumentally re- corded. One of these, the Lituya earthquake of July 10, 1958, had a magnitude of 8, o ne had a magnitude of 6, six had magnitudes be- tween 5 and 6, and 31 had magnitudes less than 5 or were not com- puted. Felt earthquakes reported in the Haines area ha ve ranged from slight tremors to severe shocks. Although there are a substantial number of faults in the northern R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES.- INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -6-* Panhandle, those associated with the Fairweather Queen Charlotte Islands fault system and the connecting Chugach St. Elias fault appear to be more tectonically active than do the faults in the Haines area. The-number of earthquakes related to the Shagwak Va-Iley,,-Chilkat River, Lynn Canal, Chatham Strait segments of the Denali fault system is small as compared to the,number along the aforementioned systems. While it is not possible to assess with any great degree,of pre-- 'cision the'earthquake probability of the'Haines area, it must be remembered that@the area is in the second most seismically active region in Alaska, and-that the region constitutes a part@of the highly active circum-Pacific seismic belt where earthquakes of magnitude 8 or greater have occurred. The Haines area may well have a greater,earthqua'ke probability than that indicated solely by the historic seismic record'. The possibility of an earthquake as great as magnitude 8 in the general area of Haines cannot be, ruled out. For these reasons, the placing of Haines in seismic, zone 3, as assigned by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, seems reasonable. Moreover, it should be em phasized that intensities from fairly distant large earthquakes, such as may occur along the Fairweather-Queen Charlotte Islands fault-, will be attenuated With distance from the epicenter, but still may be sufficiently :high at Haines. to cause damage either directly or indirectly fr=shaking. (3)- Topography Haines lies within the Coast Mountains of the Pacific Mountain system. Northeast of the city, the Coast Mountains rise in scenic splendor in the vicinity of the Canadian border. The Takshanuk Mountains, with peaks nearing 6,000 feet, are located northwest R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. NEEMENWMM@ Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -7- of the community; and to the. southwest, the snow and clatier-clad peaks of the Chilkat Range rise to over 7,000 feet. Haines occupies low-lying land at the northern end of the Deshu Isthmus which is at the northern end of the,Chilkat Peninsula. The peninsula is bounded.on the southwest by Chilkat Inlet and.on the northeast by Chilkoot Inlet ... both of which waterways fom the northwest continuations Pf Lynn Canal. The Takshanuk,.Mountains immediately northwest ofthe community constitute a steep-sided ridge which rises 3,000 - 6,000 feet,above the'Chilkat River on the southwest and the Chilkoot River on the northeast., The,Chilkat River is a broad braided stream which empties into Chilkat Inlet about I mile southwest of Haines. The Chilkoot River flows into Chilkoot Lake which in turn empties into Lutak Inlet; a north- westerly continuation of Chilkoot Inlet. Steep slopes to over 1,000 feet are located in the northern part of the city, and the peak of Mt. Ripinski located 1 1/2.,iniles north of-the Haines Airstrip,looms over:the town at 3,563 feet. The major part of the city, however, ranges from 40 to 80 feet above sea level. The Chilkat River, Johnson Creek, Mink Creek, and several unnamed creeks along the southwest side of Lutak Inlet are the only sig- nificant drainage courses in the immediate area, although several small intermittent creeks drain from the mountain front northwest Of Haines. Much of the low area in Haines and to the west i's poorly drained. Tidal data for Haines reduced to mean values shows mean higher high water to be 16.8 feet; mean lower low water at 0A feet, with extreme high water level at 22.5 feet and the estimated R. W. PAVIT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. T Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase@I) 1owest1water levelzat -6.0 (six feet below mean lower low water). (4) Soils -.Mucn.of the immediate Haines area is covered with gravelly and stony dlacial deposits'. Bedro,.-k is exposed on a few steep slopes at low elevations, and in many places at higher elevations. Very st'on'y colluvial deposits occur on mountain footslopes in the northern part of the area, while layered sil't, sand,and clay de- posits are found on the floodplains bordering the [email protected] of the Chilkat River. Peat deposits are farly common in low-lying areas, in''depressions in the uplands, and on slopes affected by seepage. Major groupings of soil types in the area include: Ch and De gravelly sandy loam Kenai silt loam Lu very gravelly coarse sand Maybeso mucky peat Ro-ugh-,,' broken l'and (Tolstoi-complex) Tols.toi very stony silt loam Toqe#er.,,.. these groupings cover about 90"0' of the immediate.Hallnes area,., 4hile there-are several other soil types present, (gravelly beach, Ka silty clay loam, Kenai-Su complex, Kina peat, Moose. River fine sandy loam, and tidal marsh), the combined area of .th.ese occurrences total less than 10/10 of the planning area.. The. capabi,.lity. groupin,q,is a system of classification designed ,to sho.w.the.relative suitabilitv of soils for crops, grazina, forestry, and wildlife. It is a practical grouping based on the needs and limitations of thesoils, the risk of damage to them, and their response to management. There are eight of these general classes in-the system. In classes 1, 11, 111 and IV are soils that are suitable for annual or periodic,cultivation of annual or short live.d,,crops. Class I soils are those that have the-widest R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -9- range of,use and the least risk of damage.- Classes II an d III have increasingly narrow ranges of use. Class IV soils can be cultivated only under very.careful management. In classes V, VI and.VII are soils that normally:should not be cultivated for annual or short lived crops, but that can be used for pasture, for woodland, or for plants th at support or shelter wildlife. Soils in Class VIII have no agricultural value, but may be useful for watershed protection or for wildlife. The subclass designation is basedlon thedominant kind of limita- tion. The letter symbol 11 ell means that the main limiting factor is risk of erosion if the pl.ant cover is not maintained. The symbol "w" means that excess water retards..plant growth or inter- feres with cultivation. The symbol "s" means that the soils are shallow, droughty or low in nutrients. The symbol "c" indicates that the choice of.crops is limited by:cli.matic factors. In the Haines area, the range of uses for.soils is,limited primarily by slope, wetness or shallow depth. For t4ese reasons. nnne of the soils meet the requirements for capability classes I and 11. Kenai silt loam is the predominant.soil type over about 10% of the Haines area. When present in areas of up to 12% slopes, it falls into 'subclass Me - well drained, moderately deep, medium textured soils in rolling areas. Nearly all of this soil is in ,native forest. Growth rates of Sitka-spruce and western hemlock, .the principal timber species, are estimated to be relatively rapid. if cleared,.this soil is suitable for-growing all crops that are adapted to the area including vegetables, berries and hay crops. The erosion hazard is severe,.but washing and gullying can be prevented on fields if crops are planted on the countour and grasses are used in the-cropping sequence. Good yields can be R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _10- expected if@adequate amounts of fertilizer are applied as deter- mined by soil tests.. In addition, lime probably would be bene- ficial for most crops. In places, stones may interfere with cultivation unless they are removed. When slopes exceed 12%, Kenai silt loam-is placed in subclass IVe because of the very severe erosion hazard. Kina peat and Maybeso mucky peat which occupy about 5% of the area are in subclass IVw - poorly and very poorly drained peat soils on nearly level and gently sloping areas. Most of the soils in this subtlass are wet during the growing season. If cleared,areas of Kina and Maybeso soils can-be suitable for growing-vegetables-and berries, but in most places, artificial, drainage would be@required to remove excess water. The remainder of the@predominant soil types (Ch gravelly sandy .loam, De gravelly sandy loam and Kenai silt loam an slopes ex- ceeding 20%) are classed as well drained, shallow, gravelly soils on undulating to hilly slopes and moderately deep silty soils on moderately steep slopes (subclass Vle). Nearly all areas of these soils are forested. These soils are.generally too gravelly, stony or-steep for cropland. If-cleared, they should be seeded to perennial grass to prevent erosion. Subclass VIw - poorly drained, nearly level soils and land types, and complex areas with both well drained and poorly drained.soils, is the description and classification for Ka silty clay loam, Kenai-Su complex, Moose River fine-sandy loam and tidal marsh. Most of the soils in th e Haines area have features that limit or restrict their use for certain types of development. The Tolstoi soils, which are extensive on uplands, are very severely limited I .* , R. W. PAV,ITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) -il- for most kinds of construction or development because of steep gradients, shallow depth 'to bedrock,-and the presence of many large stones and boulders. In some areas, -these soils are in a complex pattern with rough broken land, which is usually too steep and rocky for most uses. The Ch, De, and Kenai soils with gradients of less than 12% Are generally the most suitable in the area for building sites, roads and similar uses. All of these soils, however, have slowly per- meable subsoils or substrata that may restrict or severely limit their use.for septic tank filter fields. The De soils are further limited for development by wetness, which is caused mainly by seepage from higher areas. In most places these soils can be ..drained by constructing open ditches designed to intercept and divert seep.water and runoff. All of the soils in the area, except for the Ch and Tolstoi series are highly susceptible to frost-heavi.ng. The Kina and Maybeso soils cons'ist of peaty and mucky materials, are very poorly drained, and are generally unsuitable for road or buildings unless the organic materials are removed and the: areas artificially drained. (5) Hydrology Surface water is water moving in streams or stored in lakes and glaciers. In'the Haines area, surface water consists of the Chilkat River and its tributaries, a few small streams that flow into 'Chilkat and Chilkoot Inlets,-and Lily Lake. Haska Creek, located across McClellan Flats from Kaskulu Point, is 'One of the few sig- nificant stream flows in the area which is free of glacial flour. 41 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -12- Ground water is defined as water that fills.openings in the rocks of the earth's crust, and thus forms a saturated zone. Where ground water is unconfined, the water table is free to move upward or downward as water is added to or removed':from the zone of sat- uration. Where ground water is confined by overlying less permeable materials, water rises in wells that penetrate the confining stratum and may even flow from the well. Surface water from streams, although abundant in the summer, is not readily available as a year-round source of water, as most of the.small springs and streams cease flowing during the cold winter months when snow melt ceases to be a source. Ground water availability is limited in the Haines area due to the close proximity of bedrock underlying most of the area, the poten- tial of salt water intrusion, and the drainage water from muskeg areas. Lily Lake, a 32 acre lake located on the northern part of the Chilkat Peninsula, has been determined by several technical and engineering studies to be the best year-round source of potable water for Haines. (6) Climate The climate at Haines, as in most of Southeast Alaska, is dominated principally by maritime influences. Although the prevailing wind direction during the winter months is from the west, bringing extreme- ly cold air down from the St. Elias Mountains, the impact of these frigid air masses is moderated substantially by the effects of the Lynn Canal and its warming influence. The combination of these occur- ences does, however, result in heavy snowfall, averaging over 125 inches for the five coldest months (November through March). Frost-free days average about 140 per year. Haines-extreme recorded R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -13- temperatures range from a high o f 91* (F) occurring in June, to,a record low in December of -17*.(F). The following climatological summary for Haines is based on Weather Bureau information covering 46 years of recorded data: TEMPERATURE PRECIPITATION MEANS EXTREMES TOTAL SNOW & SLEET 4j E E 44 CA 4-3 E 0) C Cn 0 0 x E f E 4-) 4j 4.) 4j 4J 4j U fa x x JAN 1 29.1 17.3 23.2 54 -15 1296 6.61 15.99 34.8 94.4 FEB 31.1 19.7 25.4 '53 -16 1109 4.10 9.14 -21.9 7.0.0 MAR 37.,6 '25.-5 '31.,6 -63 - 6. 1035 4.75 11.55 17.9 68.1 APR 1 46.7 31.8 39.3 72 6. 771 3.40 6.95 3.0. 14.0 MAY 56.8 39.9 48.4 83 24 515 1 2.12 4.08 0.4 10.6 JUN 64.3 46.2 55.3 91 30 291 1.43 3.91 0.0 0.0 JUL 65.5 49.7 57.6 90 35 229 1.94 5.49 0.0 0.0 AUG 63.0 48.2, 56.1. 86 .32 276 2.75 5.76 0.0 0.0 SEP @57.0' 43.4 50.2 6.38 13.93 76 24 444 T OCT 46.4 35.9 41.2 65 8 738 111.63 20.37 4.0 19.5, NOV 36.2 26.3 31.3 58 -11 1011 8.60. 17.47 19.9 90.5 DEC 30.1 19.8 25.0 57 -17 1240 6.93 1 16.68 30.7 67.5 8955 60.64 20.37- 132.6 94.4 Year 11 47. 33.6 40.4 91' -17 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. I'D Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -14- The prevailing wind direction from November through March is from the west. Prevailing direction for all other months is from the southeast except for September when it is from the south-southeast. (7) Vegetation The natural vegetative cover in the Haines area consists of forest., bush, and;alpine tundra. S.itka Spruce and@Western Hemlock are the predominant species that- make up much.of the forest, with concentrations of cottonwood near the Davidson Glacier, and some hardwood species (primarily birch) found on well-drained slopes abovd the spruce forests. Muskeg, frequently several feet deep, forms an organic mat in much. of the low-lying areas. Above 3,000 feet altitude, alpine tundra is the only vegetation found, while the areas below that level abound with the alder, dwarf maple, willow, berry bushes and devil club that form a dense underbrush in the forested areas. (8) Fish and Wildlife Goats, whose numbers are estimated at more than 2,500, are present throughout the high country surrounding Haines. These vegetarians move down the mountain slopes as winter snows accumulate, and are frequently found in the valleys during the winter seeking food and shelter. The Haines moose population, which accordInq to local hunters has been declining steadily for the past 5 or 6 years , is a relatively recent phenonenom; the moose first being sighted in the area after R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -15- the construction (during World War II) of the Haines Cutoff Highway. Wolves, common to Southeast Alaska, are estimate-d to number 50 in the area. Black bear is the most plentiful big game animal, num- bering over 4,500 while brown bears are somewhat rarer with about 300 residing in the area. Moose and bear habitat includes most of the Chilkat Peninsula, and the valley.and slopes adjacent to Chilkat Inlet and extending along both sides of the Chilkat River, as well as the shores of Lutak Inlet. Waterfowl, including many species of ducks and.geese, are common in the Chilkat River area, Chilkoot River and Lake, Lutak Inlet and Taiyasanka Harbor. The Chilkat River is a major chum salmon spawning stream. Spawning of Dolly Varden; sockeye, coho, chum and pink.salmon occurs also in the Chilkoot River. The Glory Hole, a clear water spring located at the northwest end of Chilkoot Lake provides a superb view of spawning sockeye (red) salmon. Eulachon are found in the Chilkat River., Sport fishing is good throughout the area; the more popular locations including Letnikof Cove, Lutak Inlet, Chilkoot Lake and the outlet, Chilkat Inlet, Mosquito Lake and Chilkat Lake (4 miles south of Klukwan). Herman Lake boasts a sub stantial population of freshwater'shrimp. (9) Mineral Resources The metallic minerals in the general area include gold, iron and titanium, copper, zinc, lead and silver. Gold; particularly large amounts of "flour".gold is present in the Porcupine district, while massive low grade iron and titanium deposits R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES' INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -16- are known to be located near Klukwan. Magnetic disturbance observed from the tip of the Chilkat Peninsula to Mt. Ripinski, and further diamond tore drilling investigations also indicate substantial iron ore to be-present in the immediate Haines area. Indications of copper-zinc-lead-silver prospects have been observed near Mt. Kashagnak, about 10 miles northwest of Haines, and at Sullivan Mountain located 4 mil-es south of Glacier Point. The most common non-metallic mineral resource is sand and gravel, which is abundant in the Haines area. Coarser cobble and boulder deposits are also available in the'immedfate vicinity- (10) Geophysical Hazards The four geophysical hazards most common in Southeast Alaska are flooding (both coastal and stream), mass wastage (rock and/or'mud slides),@s'now' avalanche, and earthquakes. Due to the physical location of Haines,' the community is relatively free of flooding, slide or avalanche dangers, although construction activity on the slopes north of the city center has caused some local drainage problems. Earthquakes, along with tsunamis, seiches,,and associated abnormal water wave activity constitute the major geophysical hazard to which Haines is exposed. The area is designated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers as being in Seismic Zone 3 ... a zone where the largest expectable earthquakes would have magnitudes greater than 6.0, and where major damage to manmade structures could be expected. @Strongest ground vibration (shaking) as a result of an earthquake could be expected to occur R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) on manmade fills; specifically the Haines Airstrip, Alaska Depart- ment of Highways shops near Kaskulu Point, and the Lutak dry cargo dock area. Settlement of the ground surface due to shaking could cause damage in the Haines area to roadbeds, buildings and other facilities whose foundations are wholly or partly on filled land. Because of the location of Haines on a long and complex fiord system of varying depth and configuration, it is not possible to predict With any certainty the height of wave runup and resultant damage at Haines in the event of an earthquake-caused tsunami or seiche, but it seems reasonable to assume that Haines has a fairly high potential for damage from earthquake: or earthslide-induced waves, particularly if such a wave were to arrive during a period of high tide. The flood of September, 19'67, caused by exceptionally h eavy rain- fall, damaged the road system extensively. Lutak Road, Mud Bay Road, and a 35 mile stretch of the Haines Cutoff Highway northwe st of Haines were most affected; although Klukwan was in extreme danger of inundation from a c reek at Mile 23 which dumped mud and rodks all around the village. 'Rock, mud and snowslides are not a serious threat to the occupied areas of the community, although there is potential for damaging water waves generated by rockslides moving down steep fiord walls such as are present at Taiyasanka Harbor. R. W. PAVITT AND AS80CIATES, INC. Ha,ines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) B. MAN-MADE ENVIRONMENT (1) History Thetime of arrival of the Tlingit people in the Haines area is lost in antiquity, but the earliest forays by non-Natives into the region reported the Chilkats as having a thriving and productive society in existence, with villages in Klukwan,,in Chilkoot, and along the Chil- kat delta. In addition to the ample availability of fish, game, berries and other subsistence resources, the Tlingits had, by the mid-1800's, already established an extremely profitable trading business with the Athaba.scan Indians.of the Yukon and interior Alaska. In 1852, concerned by the threat of possible competition for this trade, a party of Chilkats raided and destroyed the Hudson"s Bay Post at Fort Selkirk in the Yukon. After receiving permission from the Tlingi,t.chiefs to occupy the crossroads area known as Da-shu on the shore of Portage Cove, John Muir and S. Hall Young, at the request of Dr. Sheldon Jackson, marked off the site for a mission to serve the Native people of the area. The arrival of Presbyterian missionaries in 1881, the re- naming of Da-shu to Haines, and the establishment of a U.S. Post Office in 1882 were the beginnings of the Haines community in the form that we know it today. The Presbyterian Mission played an important and continuing role in the development of the community. The federal government a nd the mission worked closely to provide educational and boarding facilities. Following construction by the Bureau of Indian Affairs of a new school in 1907, the Presbyterian Board of Missions operated a hospital, and later an orphanage, on the site until 1960. A recent gift to the community by the Presbyterian Church is the tract of land on the original Mission property which will serve as the site of the Museum. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase1) _19- Although salmon cannerieswere already active,in the 1890's, the gold strike in the Klondike in 1896,;and the use of the Dalton Trail along the traditional Chilkat Indian trail fi rmly established Haines as an important termi,nal point for prospectors and supplies. In 1898, gold was discovered at Porcupine Creek., 36:miles from Haines, and the pop- ul ati on growth of th e area ac celerated. The establishment of Fort William Henry Seward.south of Haines in 1903 further stimulated the growth of thecommunity, and the 1910 federal decennial census counted 445,pe-rsons i-n Haines, 255 at'the new army installation, 245%in the ancestral TTingit village of " ' Klukwanj andS2 rural-settlers. At this time, there were several large farms in the area producing a good variety of vegetables which were sold4not only in Haines and atth6 Post, but were shipped.to Skagway, Juneau,,Sitka, and evento Seattle. Dairy cattle, goat herds and a few beef cattle rounded out the agricultural activity. Encouraged.by the economic stability, and expressing a desire for better schools and community services, the people of Haines voted overwhelmi-ngly to incorporate-the City on January 6, 1910. Copper was being mined in the area, and there were plans drafted and surveys made for a railroad to the interior of Alaska via the @Chilkat Valley, but*this project fell through when a government railroad was built through Seward. Although some gold-mining effort continued in the Porcupine-.Creek area until the mid-thirties, major activities ceased in 1916. The loss of these sources of employment and the gradual decline of the economic importance of the salmon fishery, along with.the consolidation of cannery facilities in more economical locations, had a negative impact on the population, and by 1920,@the official count showed a 30% decline from the'1910 figure of 19027. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -20- .The World War II,years saw the,deactivation of Chilkoot Barracks, (formerly Ft. William H.Seward), and a massive construction effort in connecting Haines to the new Alcan Highway via the Haines Cutoff. Following the war,, a-group of veterans purchased the Amy reservation, renamed it Port Chilkoot, and moved to incorporate as a City-.: Ferry service linking Haines with Skagway and Juneau was begun by one of those veterans in 1948 with the converted landing craft Chilkoot, and in 1954,was improved by the new Terri tori aI ..ferry M/V Chilkat. Transportation and construction-thrived in-this post-war:period as the Army built the pipeline to Fairbanks, the Tank Farm,. and the large cargo dock installation at Lutak Inlet. The '60's saw the timber industry flourish in Haines, and the, Schnabel Lumber Company, which had started in 1939, became a-major factor in the Haines economy. The advent of Statehood in 1959, and the foresight of the young state in its construction:of a fleet of 500-passenger vessels plying the Inside Passage stimulated a new industry; tourism. The": opening of the Haines Cutoff Highway to year-round travel added to the-potential of this sector of the economy; Port.Chilkoot became an integral part of-the City of.Haines in 1970; and in 1972 the-.old Army Post was designated as a National Historic Site, and again became Fort William H. Seward,. The closing of the tank farm facility in 1971 seemed to trigger a, series of economic setbacks forHaines which has persisted through- out the early '70's. Declines in the salmon fishery and the de- -pressed state of thetimber industry have seriously limited the range of job opportunities available to local people. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -21- In 1975, the State Legislature authorized the development of Chilkat State Park south of Haines. Also in 1975, Congress authorized funds to pave the Haines Cutoff Highway.. It is hoped that implementation of these legislative:actions, along with the improving economic pic- ture in Alaska as a result of petroleum development will'inure to the benefit of the people of Haines. (2) Land Use Note: - The "overall planning area" in this study includes aTT-of the Chil,ka.t Peninsula., Lutak'Inlet, Taiyasanka Har- bor, Chilkoot Lake, and about 67 square miles of land (in-, cluding the Rainbow and Davidson Glacters) lying southwest of.McClellan Flats and the Chilkat Inlet. The "Haines Community Planning Area" covers the area (including the Small Tract subdivision) of the Chilkat Peninsula within .a, mile,of the southern city limit;:.and about 1.3 square miles' of land west of the city. Jhe data regarding land use,and landzstatus reported herein will thus be divided into three parts;.(a) within city limits; (b) outside city limits; and (c) overall planning'. area. The data reported for each "unit" is mutually ex- clusive; that is, the land area for the overall planning area does not include the area within the Haines community planning area. Likewise, the number of dwelling units re- ported for the Haines community planning area does not include those located within-the city limits. Due to the differing intensity of I and use in each of the units, data regarding uses and ownership within the city limits is quite detailed, while that for the community planning area (outside city limits) is reportedl,less specifically. The overall planning'area, little of which Js in private ownership, is covered in very general terms. (a) within city limits - 1,700*acres (2.66 square miles)of are a is- within the boundaries of the City of Haines. Of this total area, 156.9 acres-is water area in Portage Cove, and 97.0 acres is tide- lands. Upland area totals 1,446A acres' (2.26 square miles). R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES', INC-. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -2Z- ,..Vacant land occupies-1,126.2 acres, or 77.9% of the total uplands area, although about 250'adres of the presently vacant property is: felt to be too steep for beneficial development. Deducting that.-.a-creage from the total vacant land indicates that ove'r"877 .acres of land is vacant and available for development. Street, road and highway rights-of-way occupy 133.5 acres, or 9.2% of the upland area. Single family residential I's the dominant private use of land in the City,at this'ti'me, with,'195 dwe lling units uti-lizing 64.6 acres of-.Iand,,or about 35% of the land'presently developed. Recreation and open space uses including parks, trails, school playgrounds, Parade Grounds at Port Chilkoot, State Fairgrounds, and the open space at the Presbyterian Mission,:amounts to 35.7 acres, or about.19% of the presently.utilized land. Light industrial and storage us-es.ac'count for 27 buildings.on, 21.0 acres of land. The 38 commercial buildings in the City occupy 13.4 acres of lanC,which is equfvalant to &little over 7% of present land utilization. Mobilehome parks, of which 4 are'located in Haines', use 12'.0 acres (6%) o f the developed 1and to accomodate 65 mobilehome dwelling units; while 10 individual mobilehomes (not in mobilehome parks) use 2.1 acres, or just over 1% of the land presently in use. The 7 gravel and rock quarry areas utilize 11.0 acres of land, while heavy industrial use, involving 18 structures, occupies 7.5 acres in the City. Together, these uses accoun t for just under 10% of the developed land area. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -23- The 20 multiple family residential buildings contain 77 dwelling units, and occupy almost 4% (7.0 acres) of the city's built-.up land. Churches and quasi-public facilities, including the ANB-ANS Building, occupy 13 buildings on 6.5 acres of land,,or a little over 3% of the developed area. Public facilities, which include schools, public safety'buildings, library, Customs station, public works shops and the Post Office, use 15.buildings which occupy 5.6 acres of1and. Residential uses, including single and multiple-family conven- tional buildings, individual mobilehomes, and mobilehomes located :.wi:thin parks, total 349 dwelling units, and occupy 85.7 acres of land, or almost 46% of the-developed property in Haines. Note: - The table on pages 26 and 27 details the re- !-ationship,between land use and land.status in the City. (b) outside of city.-.T.he Haines community planning area covers several areas offairly intensive land use not within the cor- porate Timits of the City of Haines. These areas contain,a total of 2.5 square miles, or 1,625 acres. Single family residential use includes,.66.dwelling units on 85 acres of land. There are 5 mobilehomes, occupying 6 acres, and a 4 unit apartment building on 1 acre of land. 1 commercial building is located on 1/2 acre, and another 1/2 acre is used for a light industrial/storage purpose. 41.5 acres is devoted to heavy industrial use (A lask a Forest Products). R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES,- INC. Haines Compr ehensive Plan (Phase 1) -24- 5.public facilities utilize 20 acres, while rights-of-way use 63 acres, and-a State-recreation area occupies,7 acres. Just,under-225 acres., or about 14%,of the 1,625 acre total land .area in the-community planning@area is-presently in active use. Of the 1,400 acres of vacant land, a little over 350.acres is felt to be located on slopes too steep for normal development practim.- (c) overall planning area The-overall planning area contains 101,169 acres, or 158 square miles of land area. .,175, acres, including 20 acres of fishing:camps., i s: currently in use, for- residentia-1, purposes. - Industrial use@, including:Schilabel Lumber,.the Lutak dry.cargo dock.. the tank farm, and 85-acres of rock and gravel quarry, presently utilizes about 210 acres. Public Facilities, including the Haines Airstrip and 2 cemetery sites make use of 40 acres; while recreational/open space uses (which 'are interpreted as, including the proposed Chilkat State Park and the federal Lighthouse Reservation as well as.the State-operated Chilkoot Lake Recreation Area) occupy 5',745 acres of land area. The land presently in use makes up barely 6% of the total land in the overall planning.area, leaving over 148 squa re miles undeveloped. (3) Land Status (a) within city limits To achieve a full understanding of land use potential in a community, it is necessary to determine the R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (phase 1) -25- nature of ownership of the land as well as the present uses. In the case of Haines, this study reveals a high percentag e of private land within the city limits. 976 acres (67.6%) of the 1,446.1 acres of upland area in the City is privately owned, althouqh only 12.8% (124.8 acres) is presently in use. Unlike the land tenure situation in many Alaskan communities, the federal government controls only the 0.6 acres on which the U.S. Customs station is built. The State of Alaska, exclusive of highway rights-of-way,%controls 243.7 acres; of which 70.9 acres is presently in use. The local governments (City and Borough) are the owners of 117 acres, in- cluding 69.7 acres of street rights-of-way, and are presently utilizing 87.3 acres, or 74.4% of this land. The remainder of the land in the City is exempt from taxation by reason of its ownership; either by religious organizations (32.95 acres), or in the form of Native Allotments which total 10.05 acres. Virt ually all of the Church holdings are presently in use, while about .50% of the Native holdings are developed. (b) outside of city In the Haines community planning area, land status research reveals more governmental ownership than in the City, but still indicates quite substantial private ownershi.p. -1,625 acres is privately. 967 acres, or 59.5% of the total of. controlled, while.40 acres.'(2.4%)'is devoted to Native allotments. The land tenure survey,@hows thatthe.remainder of the land is in LAND USE NATIVE PRIVATE LOCAL STATE FEDERAL QUASI-PUBLIC ALLOTMENTS TOTALS LAND GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT (EXEMPT) (EXEMPT) OWNERSHIP SINGLE FAMILY RESI, DENTIAL no. of dwelling units 165 27 1 197 units 0 4.6 acreage in use 60. 64.6 acres SINGLE FAMILY RESI. DENTIAL (MOBILEHOMES) number of units 10 10 units acreage in use 2J 2.1 acres MULTIPLE FAMILY RESI- DENTIAL bifldings 20 20tbldgs. dwe I I i ng . un i ts 77 77 units acreage in -use 7.0 7.0 acres MOBILEHOME PARKS number of parks 4 4 parks Ch number of units 65 acreage in use 12.0 65 ..units 12.-0 acres COMMERCIAL buildings 38 38 bldgs. acreage in use 13.4 13.4 acres LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND STORAGE buildings 22. 2 3 27 bldgs. acreage in use 11.6 3.0 6.4 21.0 acres HEAVY INDUSTRIAL structures 18 18 struct. acreage in use 7.5 7.5 acres CHURCH AND QUASI- PUBLIC FACILITIES buildings 12 1 13 bldgs. !,"'_@LAND acreage in use 6.0 .5 6.5 acres 0110 loilm-, RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE number of areas 2 3 6 areas acreage in use 10.0 0.7 25.0 35.7 acres GRAVEL AND ROCK . QUARRIES number of areas 7 7 areas acreage in use 11.0 11.0 acres ROAD & HIGHWAY RIGHTS-OF-WAY acreage in use 69.7 63.8 133.5 acres PUBLIC FACILITIES 2. no'. of buildings 1 .12 1.1 1 15 bldgs. acreage in use .24 4.6 .6 .12 5.6 acres VACANT LAND 853.2 29.7 236.6 -0- 1.8 4.9 1,126.2 acres TOTAL LAND AVAILABLE acreage (by owner) 978 .117 307.5 0.6 32.95 10.05 1,446.1 A. LAND NOW IN USE acreage 124.8 87.3 70.9 0.6 .31.12 5.1 319.9 A. 14 PERCENT OF LAND 12.8% 74.4% @23.1% 100% 94.4% 50.7% 22.1% IN USE 1. includes 5 dwelling units located in same building as commercial use 2. U.S. Post Office located in leased building R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES., INC.'@: Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -28- governmental ownership,.with,9.1 acres (5.6%) controlled by the. City of Haines, 338 acres or 20.8t in State ownership, and 190 acres, or 11.7% retained in federal ownership. W overall-planning area In the large (101,169 acre) planning area which adjoins the Haines.community, land tenure is more typi- cal of rural Alaska, with only 3% (3,155 acres) of the land in private ownership. All of the 84,464 acres of Public Domain Land has been selected by the State of Alaska under the Statehood Act selection provisions, and is shown on the Bureau..of Land Manage- ment Status Plats as having been "Tentatively Approved" for trans- fer to State ownership. (Prior to,the passage of the Alaska Native Claims [email protected] on-December 18, 1971-(P.L.92-203), Tentative Approval (TA) was.considered tantamount to ownership. The Claims Settlement@`Act, however, 'conveyed c6rtai'n selection rights to qualified Native groups on TA'd lands, and it is reasonable to assume that the status of this land will eventually be quite different from that reported here.) 12,290 acres, or about 12% of the land hasalready been transferred to the State, and is currently shown as StatePatented land. 480 acres are i-n:Native Allotments, and.780 acresare devoted to federal facilities @including the tank farm and POL facility, the Lutak dry cargo dock, And the Lighthou se Reservation,at.the north:end of the Chilkat?eninsula. (4) Housing. A survey was conducted. in May, 1976 to. a'tcertain the structural con- dition and general liveability of the 34.9 dwelling units within the ci ty I i mi ts.,. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -29- The housing inventory shows 197 single family residential units (in- cluding 5 units located above commercially-used space in business buildings); 77 dwelling units located in 20 separate multiple dwell-ing structures,.and 75.mobilehome units. Three classifications-were used in compiling the survey: 1. Standard- housing that ranges from ade@uate to excellent, including modern or well-maintained older buildings that@' appear to comply generally with the provisions of the Uni- form Building Code. 2. Substandard - housing that is habitable, but deteriorated beyond upgrading to standard without a 1-a rge investment ''which may exceed the value of the structure.. 3. Uninhabitable - housing that is beyond repair, and consti- tutes a hazard to other structures and/or a nuisance to.a neighborhood. Of the total (349)-,dwelling units, the survey revealed th e following da ta: Condition Number of Units-. Percent of Total Units Standard 255 73.1 Substandard 79 22.6 Uninhabitable 15 4.3 349 TOTALS 100.0 Single family residential units constitute about 57% of the total housing inventory. 'Of the 197 single family units, 83.7% (163) are in standard'condition, with 25 houses shown as substandard, and 9 units, or 4.5% in uninhabitable condition'. R. W. PAVITT.-AND ASSOCIATES., INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) ..-30- The-77 dwell'ing units in mUltiple family structures make up 22% of the inventory. -51, units, or 66.2% of these:units.are in standard, conditiont while22 (28.5%) w ere c1assed as substandard@. The 'one building containing 4 units considered uninhabitable1s not occupied at this time. Of the, 75 mobilehomes in the,City,...41 (54.7%). were.found to be in standard condition, 32 (42.7%).substandard, and only 2 units (2.6'/Q) were felt to-be uninhabitable.. Mobi.lehome,h.ousing.in Haines con- stitutes about 21% of the total housing inventory. (5) Community Facilities and Services: (a) Local government - Local government- in the. Haines area con- sists of'the two incorporated muni.tipalities;'the' City of Haines, and the Haines Borough. The City of Haines, incorporated in 1910, is a first class city governed-by an elected Mayor and'an elected Common 'Council of 6 members. A City Administrator is employed to act as chief of staff, and to assist with detailed administrative functions. The ..City.,has all. powers authorized to first class municipal itie.s -in. the Munic* al Code (Title 29 of the Alaska Statutes). ip The City's administrative offices are housed in leased space in the Gateway Building on Main Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. 1,060 square feet of second floor area is utilized by the City Administrator's Office, the City Clerk's Office,. the Treasurer's ,.Office, and a conference and map room that serves as the Council Chambers. The building, owned by the Lynn Canal Corporation of Haines, was built in 1954-of cast-in-place concrete construction, and is in good condition. Five off-street parking spaces are R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -31- available on the property behind the building adjacent to the alley. The Haines Borough, incorporated in 1968, is the only third class borough in Alaska. The elected Borough Assembly serves also as the School Board, and the primary function of the governmental unit is to provide the local financial support and administration for the school system. The Borough Mayor is also President of the School Board, and the functions of-the Borough include assessment and collection of taxes for school purposet. The Borough also leases space on the second floor of the Gateway Building, using 700 square feet to house the Borough Clerk., the Borough Assessor's Office, and a conference and meeting room some- times used for Assembly meetings. (b).Water and sewer utilities and public works - The principal water supply for the City of Haines is from Lily Lake located at an elevation of.about 600 feet above sea level in the high country South of the City on the Chilkat Peninsula. A new ductile iron supply line 15,000 feet in length brings water from the lake to the Port Chilkoot water tower. The 1,500 square foot concrete block Water Treatment Plant was constructed in 1975 on a 5 acre site 1/2 mile south of the city, and utilizes three filters capable of treating 200,000 gallons per day to the appropriate standards for potable water. The original 4,500 feet of 6 inch cast iron water mains in Port Chilkoot were constructed in 1906, and have since been supple- mented with additional steel and tra nsite mains. The Haines townsite system, constructed in 1951, includes 14,000 feet@of 6 inch transite mains, while another 6,000 feet of 6 inch transite serves several subdivision developments north of town. This system R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -32- was supplemented in 1975 when 8',000 feet of 6 inch p.v.c. dis- tribution supply lines were constructed. Fire hydrants are'located on the mains throughout the.City. ''A permanent easement'.30 feet wide has been acquired for maintenance of the supply main from Lily Lake, and for,the site ofthLi-treat- ment.plant. There@are currently.320 hookups to the Haines'water System.' The sewage treatment plant is located on a 15 acre City-owned parce1of land across the Haines Highway from the U.S. Customs station, an&adjacent to the State Fairgrounds. *A 150 ft. by .300 ft.@site houses the 1,200 square1oot structure built in' 1975 which includes a complete laboratory, a sludge dewaterinig system, and a digester and treatment plant with a 300,000 gallon per day:capacity. The plant, which provides primary and secondary :-treatment to sewage collected currently from 350,customers,.is a modern-facility utilizing a treatment technology designed to bring,the effluent, which is discharged into tidewater in Portage Cove@@-to state andfederal standards. -Also constructed in 1975,.were 80 new-manholes-and 27,000 lineal feet of.8 inch p.v- *c* sewer mains, two major lift stations with 2,250 feet of force main, and a 4,500 foot outfall line. The original Port Chilkoot sewer system, like the water system, was constructed in 1906, and i,ncluded 5,000 feet of terra cotta (clay) pipe and 14 hand-laid brick manholes. The system in the Haines town'site was constructed in 1951, and,consisted of 14,500 feet of concrete mains and 33 manholes. North of the townsite, privately constructed sewer mains consist of 4,500 feet of 6Anch transite main and 5 manholes. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -33- In addition.to the water and sewer utilities, the Haines Public Works Department is responsible for maintenance and construction of roads, parks, cemeteries, drainage improvements and the small boat'harbor; as well as vehicular maintenance and overhaul for .all @City departments. Public works facilities are located on Uni on Street between 5th 6th Avenues on each si'de of the street. A builtoing and-Iot located at 4th Avenue and Main Street have been declared surplus to the Department's needs. 'The'2.-27 acre parcel on the north side of Union Street ts used as a storage and equipment yard, and@has a 400 square foot'storage t-hed built in the 1950's. The 150' x 250' parcel on the south side of Union Street has'thelmain maintenance shop which is contained in a 3,575.square foot metal bui.1ding.'' The parcel is also usedifor equipment parking and storage. (c).Electric utility Electric power-is-supplied1n the Haines area by the Haines Light and Power Company, a privately owned utility located on the south side of Dalton Street between 2nd and 3rd Av6nu ,es.' The company is owned by George Schnabel.'of Haines.I The'power plant is on a .150' x'150' parcel of land, and is-in a reinforced concrete building first built in'1932., An' addition to the plant constructedin 1956 makes up part ofthe, 3,400 square feet@currently in use. Peak load capacity of 3,500"KW is produced by 7 diesel electrtc generators.' The Util'ity servestlectrical power to the entire Haines community With distribution lines extending as far 'as the Schnabel Mill on Lutak Road; 3 Mile on the Haines Highway, and 2@miles south of the City to serve the Small Tracts and Mud Bay Road-area.-There are,presently 519 service 'tonnections'served by the -.2-8 mi I es- of -tranimi s s i-on 1 i nes. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -34- The Schnabel Lumber Company mill has its own diesel generators, and at times is able to feed excess power back into the town plant. (d) Solid waste - Garbage and solid wastes are disposed of on a new 10 acre sanitary landfill site located about a mile south of the Haines city limit. The landfill operation as well as the refuse collection is con- ducted by a private operator, Haines Sanitation Company, as a City-franchised utility. The equipment used in the solid waste collection and disposal operation includes a compactor truck, a 0-4 Caterpillar tractor and a loader, all owned by the private contractor. Full refuse collection service is provided to the entire popu- lated portion of the Borough including the State Parks and Alaska Marine Highway facility at Lutak Inlet. A vehicle disposal area is being developed at the landfi-Il.site. (e) Library - The Haines Public Library.is located on a 50' x 100' lot on 3rd Avenue between Main Street and the Haines Highway. The facility is housed in a 1,750 square foot wood frame building constructed in 1958. The structure is in good condition, and there is off-street parking space for 4 vehicles on the site. The Haines Borough owns the land on which the library stands, but the building itself is owned by the Haines Women's Club, which operates the facility. The Haines borough, as part of its educational responsibility, funds the librarian, and acquisition of new books to add to the 10,000 volume collection currently available. The library provides R. W. PAVITT..AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase-I) -35- a lending service to the community, and has seating space for about fifteen persons in the Wilding. Additional book acqui- is available through the Inter-libraryLoan Service of the State Library in Juneau. M Museum - The Sheldon Museum is presently located on Main Street between 2nd and-3rd Avenues in 2,400 square feet of leased, space on the second floor of the Howser and Hyatt Building; a concrete block structure built in 1974. The museum houses the Sheldon Collection which*consists of 300 historical publicationt; many items of the gold rush period; 500 items of traditional Tlingit Native arts and crafts, and historic photographs dep'icting-Native and non-Native cultural 'development in the Haines'area'imthe period 1880-1930. The'museum is owned by the Chilkat Valley Historical Society, .,and is operated by its Curator and 6 part'-time volunteers. (,g) Public safety The important function of public safet@ in the Haines area is shared by'city* state and federal agencies. The Haines Police Department a 'he Alaska State Tro-o'pers' are nd t the law enforcement agencies, and there is a Magistrate, whose Court is similar to-a District Court-in the Alaska Judicial System. The State also maintains a Probation'Office-in;Haines. Because of the proximity of Haines to the Canadian border, a stati6n.is staffed by U.S. Custom'S'Service'and U.S. 1. 1mmigration and Naturalization'Service officers. Fire protection services are-the responsibility of the Haines Fire Department. [1] Haines Police Department this function is headquartered in a 450 square foot reinforced concrete.building constructed R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -36- in the 1950's which contains a minimal jail facility in addition to two office spaces. Off-street parking space is available for 4 vehicles on the site located on 2nd Avenue between Main and Dalton Streets. The department, which consists of*the Chief of Police and two Patrolmen, provides full law enforcement coverage to the City, and cooperates closely with the other public safety organizations. [21 Alaska State Troopers - The Troopers are headquartered in 450 square feet of leased space in the Howser and Hyatt Build- ing on Main Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. The office, which consists of.1 Trooper, 1 Fish and Game En- forcement Officer,, and a full-time secretary, serves the Haines and Skagway region of Southeast Alaska,in a law enforcement capacity as well as providing motor vehicle licensing services, subsistence fishing licenses, and assistance with search and rescue operations. The station-is well equipped with communi- FM cations gear which allows direct linkages wi,th Skagway and ,Juneau, as well as contact with mobile units and the Highway' Department. [3] Magistrate s Court - The Magistrate, similar to the District Court in larger communities, hears misdemeanors, civil cases to $100,000; and serves also as the local recording office, coroner, Registrar of Vital Statistics, Probate Court, and performs marri- ages. The Magistrate and a Court Clerk staff the office, which is located in 900 square feet of leased space in a cast-in-place concrete building located on Main Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. The space, which is leased from Haisler Hardware, Inc., is in good condition and provides 2 off-street parking spaces. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -37-. The space is utilized for a large courtroom, the Magistrate's office, a reception and map room, and a document reproduction room. [41 State Probation Office - The State maintains a Probation Office in 400 square feet of leased second floor space on Main Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. @The-office, which is staffed by aProbation Officer and-a sec- retary, provides probation and parole services with qUidance counseling for juvenile and adult offenders on probation. Federal customs and immigration services - A 400 square foot converted wood frame military structure-located at the -intersection of'Main Street and theflaines Cutoff Highway serves to house the functions of,the U.S. Customs Service of the Treas- ury Department, and the Immigration and Naturalization Service of the U.S. Department of Justice. 2 full time inspectors and 1 part time inspector staff the station, which serves to administer all U.S. laws and regula- tions regarding individuals, vehicles and materials crossing the U*S.4anadian border. U.S.@Department of Agriculture reg- ulations with respect to foodstuffs and animals are also en- forced, and records are kept on imported items and,volumes of traffic :by type. The Customs Station building, first constructed in the early 1930's, is. in fair condition ast result of good and timely maintenance work, and is located on a 0.6 acre site which pro- vides space for the off-street parking of.about 10 vehicles. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) @38- .[61 Haines Fire Department - The equipment of the Haines Fire Department is.housed in two locations; in downtown Haines on the same site as the Poli-ce Department, and on a 100' x 162' lot in Port Chilkoot on Fort Seward Drive across from the north corner of the Parade Field. The downtown station is in,a 500 square foot wood frame buil- dina constructed in 1948. The Port Chilkoot Station was con- structed of wood frame in 1906, and contains 840 square feet. Both stations are owned by the City of Haines. The fire protection function is staffed by 1 paid.Fireman, and a volunteer department of 34 trained.men; 1 Chief, 1 Assistant Chief, 3 Captains, 3 Lieutenants and 26 Firemen. The equip- ment includes 4 Engine Pump Trucks, a 1,000 gallon Fold-a-Tank, a jeep with a 300 gallon tank and pump, 2 station wagons, a modern fully-equipped ambulance and miscellaneous other equip- ment. Communications gear includes 25 plectron receivers, a VHF radio base station with mobile units in each vehicle, and three handsets. 10,000 feet of fire hose is available; 5,000 feet of which is held.in reserve. (h) Education - The Haines Borough School System provides educa- tional instruction from Kindergarten through 12th grade as well as special post-secondary instruction through the Univ ersity of Alaska and Sheldon Jackson College, and the Alaska Community College Vocational Education program. All Haines Borough School facilities are located on a 16 acre sfte bordered by the Haines Cutoff Highway, 3rd Avenue, and Allen Road. In addition to the school buildings, the site accomodates several outdoor recreation areas that include a R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -39- 100' x 100' play area with equipment for the primary children, a a 2.1 acre field for elementary and junior high use which includes a baseball diamond and swings; and a full.-size running track and athletic area currently under development which will serve the high school students as well as the younger students. The Primary school- is a wood frame structure built in 1969. It contains 10,000 square feet of instructional space including a multi-purpose room, and is staffedby 5 teachers and several aides and support personnel * The facility serves children from Kind erga rten through 2nd grade,- and is in good structural and working condition.- The Elementary school, serving pupils from*3rd through 6th grades, is housed-in a wood frame building,containing 28,000 square feet which was constructed in 1955. Extensive renovations were accom- plished in 1974, and the elementary structure is in good condition. .11 classrooms, 2 administrative offices, a media center and a multi- purpose room serve the instructional requirements of the school which is staffed by 4teachers, a Principal and his secretary, .and.support personnel including aides, physical education instruc- tion, music instruction, other supportive services and custodial care. The Junior High School facility is contained in a wing built on to,the Elementary school in 1974; and serves 7th and 8th grade students in its 16,000 square feet of space., Utilization of the space includes 7 classrooms and'a gymnasium, the use of which-is shared with the Elementary school. . 7 teachers and the necessary support personnel serve the needs of the,junior'high school program. The facility is in generally excellent condition, and has ' space adjoining the building for off-street parking for 40 vehicles. The new Haines High School is housed in a steel frame precast R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -40- concrete building completed in 1974. The high school facility includes,a fully equipped gymnasium in its 30,000 square feet. The modem, well-designed building has a.fully equipped wood- working shop, a typing room with 17 typewriters and other business machines, a language lab with console and 12 headphone stations, a home economics room with staves, sinks, refrigerator and sewing machines-and a music room with 30 instruments and storage lockers as well as four sound insulated practice rooms. The well-equipped gymnasium boasts a full size basketball court with 4 practice bas- kets and electric scoreboard, and folding bleachers capable of seating almost 700 people. A media center complete with video tape equipment, movie projectors, tape and phonograph equipment and library supplements the 5 classrooms and 7 instructional areas. The Principal's staff includes 13 teachers, and the necessary aides, media center personnel, maintenance and custodial cr'ews. Other than the school principals and their-secretaries, the admin- istrative staff of the Borough School System consists of the Super- intendant of Schools and his secretary. The overall educational program includes supervised summer recreation. School busses, ser- ving the entire populated area of the Haines Borough, are operated ,on contract by Westoursi Inc. A pre-school edu cational facility, which also provides some day care service.has served 50 children in the past year. It is lo- cated in a recently remodeled wood frame building built in the .20's on a 90' x 160' site located'on View Drive and First Avenue. The City of Haines leases the facility to the Haines Pre-School, which, in addition to a volunteer assistant, is staffed with a Director/Teacher, 1 Teacher Aide, a Cook and a Custodian. The 4,000 square feet presently in use serves 24 children, and an additional room is being remodeled to bring the capacity to 36. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES-INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -41- M Cultural facilities and services - While social, cultural and religious institutions of the type reported in this sub-section are generally not thought of as "community facilities" in the same sense as water and sewer utilities or public safety functions, they are A important part of the community, and contribute to the quality of 'life enjoyed by residents of Haines. The Chilkat Center for the Arts is located on a 1 acre parcel of land at Tower Road and Theatre Drive in Port Chilkoot. The building, which is the equivalent of 3 stories in height, was completely rebuilt in 1967 as an Alaska Centennial project and is owned by Alaska Indian Arts, Inc. It is operated jointly by that non-profit Alaska corporation and the Lynn Canal Community Players, Inc. Off-street parking is available for 40 cars. The center has a complete theatrical stage with seating, lobby space and services to handle up to 300 people. Local play pro- ductions, visiting concert artists, student performers and the famous Chilkat Dancers are 611 regular users of the building. The center is also the home of the biennial State of Alaska DramaFestival which features drama groups from at least 10 Alaskan communities. Alaska Indian Arts, Inc. is a non-profit Alaskan corporation dedicated to the perpetuation of Tlingit arts and crafts. The operation is housed in a recently remodeled 10,000 square foot wood frame building which was built in 1906 as the hospital for Fort William Henry Seward, and is located on a 90' x 218' lot in Port Chilkoot on Fort Seward Drive. As many as 20 artisans are @ometimes engaged in the design and production of Tlingit arts and crafts items, including totem poles, silver jewelry, carved doors and other graphic arts. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -42- The-Alaska Native Brotherhood and Alaska Native Sisterhood maintain a 2,400 square foot wood frame building at-the corner of lst. Avenue and Willard.Street.. The 115' x-153' site provides parking for 20 cars., and the facility, built in 1974, is irf excellent condition. The ANB-MS Hall is used for Native cultural events, and is frequently rented by other community organizations for recreational and assembly purposes. The American Legion Hall at the corner of 2nd Avenue and Dalton Street is a 2,000 square foot building that, in addition to housing the American Legion meetings and recreational activities, is also rented for assembly functions by numerous clubs.and orga- nization@. The Haines Bill's Club is the local chapter of the Elks Club, and serves as an assembly hall for the organization as well as a major recreation facility for local and visiting Elks. Religious groups which own and operate substantial facilities in Haines include the Presbyterian Church, the Port Chilkoot Bible Church, Assembly of God, Catholic Church-and the S alvation Army. Congregations which rent space for their regular worship services are the Church of Christ, the Baptist Church and Jehovah's Witnesses. Worshipping regularly in private homes of their members are the Mormons and the Baha'is. Service and civic organizations are also quite active in Haines, and include the Haines Chamber of Commerce, the Bicentennial Comm- ittee, The American Legion, iUJS-ANB, The Women's Club, the Elks, the Business and Professional Women's Club, the Haines Sportsmen's Association, P.T.A., Chilkat Snowburners, the Haines Arts Council FH a and the Lynn Canal Community Players. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -43- (j) Recreation and Open Space - Recreation opportunities abound in the Haines area, and many sectors of the community have assisted in the construction of the facilities that allow for enjoyment of the spectacular environnent by residents and visitors alike. The City of Haines has prepared and adopted a-5 year plan for the development of recreation areas and connecting trails. There are 2 privately-developed camper parks in the City of Haines, onewith 20 spaces adjacent to the Halsingland Hotel in Port Chil- koot, and one located at I Mile on the Haines Cutoff which also provides 20 spaces. Two other le ss formal camper parks are lo- cated on the Chilkat Peninsula, one at Letnikof Cove, and the other 8 miles south of the city at the end of Mud Bay Road. The Rainbow Glacier Camp is a Presbyterian-sponsored recreation camp with a major 1,800 square foot cor.Tnunity building, and several small cabins. This beautifully situated facility is located 6 miles south of the City on Chilkat Inlet, and provides a breathtaking vista of the Rainbow Glacier. The 8 acre Parade Field in the center of Fort William H. Seward, provides open space and an authentic Tlingit Indian Tribal House as well as a log cabin and elevated cache. The area is owned by Alaska Indian Arts, Inc., and is used for general community rec- reation as well as a tourist attraction. The Southeast Alaska State Fairgrounds consist of a 21 acre parcel. of land which has been under development since 1971. It presently has 2 large 60' x 120' fair buildings, a corral for horse shows, covered stalls and a loop access road providing good traffic cir- culation to and from the Haines Cutoff Highway. The Fair has be- come a major summer event in Southeast Alaska. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -44- Tlingit Park is a 2.1 acre parcel which was dedicated some 12 F years ago to the City of Haines. The area has been cleared, and a covered heavy timber bandstand constructed,. The park, which overlooks the Portage Cove waterfront between Main Street and the.Haines Cutoff also contains a'historic cemetery, which has been cleared and partially reconstructed. Development of Tlingit Park is continuing at this time. A system of walking trails is under construction in the City, the first phase of which will link the Tlingit Park with the boat har- bor and waterfront, the Presbyterian,Mission properties and Port Chilkoot. The City's system-of trails is designed to.tie in with trails;already constructed by the Borough and volunteer groups which are in the Battery Point, Riley Summit, Lily Lake and Mud Bay Road areas, as well as with an existing 3 mile trail which traverses the high.country north of the City to the summit of Mt. Ripinski. The Haines Borough is presently developing further recreational facilities on the school site. A parcel of waterfront property on the Chilkat River owned by-the Borough is used for a picnic and camping area. The Portage Cove Picnic Area and Campgrounds is a 7 acre facility operated by the State Division of Parks. The area, located on the south shore of Portage Cove is accessible by Beach Road, and has facilities for picnicking and tent camping. A large.facility -is located.at the.head of Chilkoot Lake, 8 miles north of Haines and is operated by the State as the Chilkoot Lake Picnic Area and Campgrounds. This substantial recreational development includes a parking area for 40 vehicles, a boat launching ramp, covered picnic areas, restrooms and well-developed sites for 60 campers. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -45- The State-operated Mosquito Lake Campgrounds is located near Mile 27 on the Haines Cutoff Highway, and has accomodations for pic- nicking and up to 15 camper vehicles. In addition to a small boat dock, the facility has a wood storage shed, restrooms and an en- closed shelter. A major effort is underway by the-Division of Parks of the Alaska Department of Natural Resources to complete the planning for the first phase of development of the proposed 6,000 acre Chilkat State Park, a facility that will occupy about 2/3 of the land area on the Chilkat Peninsula. This major State Park will in- clude a vehicle camper park, trails,'boat launching ramps, tent camping sites.' a visitor's interpretation center and a replica of a Native fishing village at Battery Point * Federal (Bureau of Outdoor Recreation) funding is presently being sought in connec- tion with this project; and by the City of Haines in order to pro- ceed with the development of Tlingit Park projects. M Health and Social Services The Chilkat Valley Medical Center located in Haines on First Avenue between Willard and Mission Steets, is the location of several significant health facilities. The Center is a'50' x 70' wood frame building with a full concrete basement constructed in 1971 on a 115' x 150' parcel of land which provides 15 off-street vehicle parking spaces. The facility is privately owned by Stanley Jones, M.D., who practices medicine in the building. Dr. Jones and another physician (General Practitioner) provide medical services in the diagnosis and treatment of physical prob- lems of their patients. A pharmacy, some laboratory analysis and some X-Ray services are available. Referral services to outside specia'l ists and medical facilities is provided as required. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -46- The U.S. Public Health Service contracts with Dr. Jones to pro- vide certai'n medical services to Native persons who qualify for Alaska Native Health Service care. The Medical Center also has a labor room and a delivery room for maternity patients, which provides the equivalent of a 3-bed emergency capability. The State Department of Health and Social Services leases 550 square feet of space in the basement of the Medical Center. This space is equip ped with examination tables, immunization supplies, audiometer, specimen sampling equipment and equipment needed for basic physical examination by the Public Health Nurse, about half of whose-time is spent in Haines. (The Nurse also serves Skagway, Yakutat and Klukwan). The leased space is also'utilized by the State Regional Psychologist and a State Social Worker, each of whom make monthly visits to Haines. The Haines Dental Clinic leases 1,000 square feet of space in the Medical Center. The.clinic includes two treatment rooms with com- plete basic dental equipment for provision,of dental services in- cluding fillings, cleaning, extractions, flouride treatment, root canals and minor oral surgery. The facility presently is without a dentist. (1) Cemeteries - The Haines cemetery facility is located on a 20 acre parcel on Sawmill Road, south of its intersection with 1 Mile on the Haines Cutoff Highway. 6.5 acres of the land has been de- veloped and used for burial purposes since 1925. The facility, which provides space for burial of local citizens and others desiring burial in Haines, is administered and owned R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -47- by the City of Haines, and is operated by an appointed volunteer Custodian/Administrator. In addition to the City Cemetery, there are three cemeteries in the Haines area. One of these is the Historical Cemetery located within Tlingit Park overlooking Portage Cove. This site was used at the turn of the century by the Presbyterian Mission. There are about 25 identifiable grave sites;-many with turned wooden fences and marble headstones with inscriptions. This historic site, which has suffered from lack of maintenance, has been partially cleared of underbrush, and is slated for reconstruction,by the Native comm- unity of Haines as their contribution to the development of the Park. A large cemetery site, which contains many well-maintained grave- -sites with turned wooden fences and headstones is located at 4 Mile on the Haines Highway on the Yendistucky Reservation. This site, which has been in use for several hundred years, is of considerable cultural and-historic significance. Of inestimable archeological and anthropological importance is the large Native Cemetery at Klukwan. Klukwan was the central village of the powerful Tlingit nation which at one time dominated much of Southeast Alaska and the Yukon, and the cemetery contains many hundreds.of identifiable grave sites and hundreds of other, unmarked graves. (m) Communications - The "system" of communications in Haines con- sists of telephone, cable television and radio, postal service, a weekly newspaper and a shoppers guide. Telephone service is provided out to 48 Mile on t he Haines Highway, to 3 miles south of the City on the Chilkat Peninsula and to 4 miles R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -48- along the Lutak Road. General Telephone Company of Alaska is the certificated company providing the service, which includes Direct Distance Dialing. 516 service connections are currently in use in Haines on a new,and comprehensive system which has provisions for up to 800 individual phone services, 8 incoming and 10 outgoing long distance trunk lines. General Telephone Co. operates its facilities from a 30' x 40' brick building located on a 50' x 100' lot at Main Street and 2nd Avenue. The building, constructed in 1973, contains a full concrete basement, and is in excellent condition. Off-street parking space for five vehicles is provided on the site. RCA Alaska Communications, Inc. provides long distance telephone and.teletype data communications services with a fixed, point-to- point station. 1 Technician and 1 Operator occupy a 1,600 square foot wood frame building on Main Street between 4th and 5th Avenues. The facility, built in 1954, and currently in good condition, pro- vides off-street parking space for 6 vehicles on its 125' x 280' site. Some 44 miles of underground cable owned by RCA, which provide ser- vice to the 42 Mile border station and to the tank farm at 3 Mile on the Lutak Road, is currently leased to General Telephone Company. Haines Network Television operates from 360 square feet of leased space in the basement of the Chilkat Valley Medical Clinic. Two channels provide 4 week-old television programming from cassette video tapes, and another channel provides local advertisements as well as radio programing as broadcast by Station KINY in Juneau. The Chilkat Valley News is aweekly newspaper (generally) which publishes local and statewide news items,-local feature stories, letters to the editor, some advertising, public service announce- R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -49- ments, legal ads, and a free advertising service for individuals in the community desiring to buy or sell itemscalled "unclassified advertisements".. The newspaper enjoys an excellent reputation statewide, as demonstrated by the fact that about half of the sub- scribers live outside the Haines area. The Chilkat Valley News has 10O.square feet of leased space in a large former barracks building, constructed in 1906, across from the east side of the Parade Grounds. The newspaper is currently in its eleventh year of publication. The Haines Shoppers Guide publishes business advertisements, want ads, public notices and other information from a 64 square foot office in the Tradewinds Building on Main Street. Both the Shoppers Guide and the Chilkat Valley News are printed in Haines by the Chilkat Press, a local printing service. The U.S. Postal Service maintains a Second Class Post Office in Haines in leased space. The building, constructed in the 1950's is a 36' x 80' wood frame with stucco building in good condition located on a 100' x 150' parcel-of land on 3rd Avenue between Main Street and the Haines Highway. Service consists of a Star Route Delivery one day p ier week up the Haines Highway, and two days per week to Klukwan. Distribution of Haines mail is by post office box, of which there are currently 512 in the postal facility, with 100 new boxes to be added this year. Mail is sent and received daily at the Post Office utilizing the services of chartered air carriers, and the facility also distrib- utes@ federal government forms and information bulletins, as well as posting state and local government notices. I Postmaster, 1 part-time Mailman, and 3 Mail Distribution Clerks are employed. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. - Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -50- A communications facility consisting of an unmanned radio direction finder transmitter, which broadcasts a continuous radio signal, is operated by the Federal Aviation Agency (FAA) on a 110 acre parcel of land located 112 mile southeast of the city limits.. The facility, which consists of a transmitter in a 1,200 square foot.wood frame building, and two steel transmission towers, is maintained periodi- cally by FAA inspection personnel, and is in good condition. (6) Transportation Facilities and Services Haines, because of its strategic position at the head of the Inside Passage, and its accessibility via the Haines Cutoff Highway to the Yukon and Interior Alaska, is an important transportation hub in Southeast Alaska. (a) Surface transportation - In the overall planning area, the State of Alaska maintains 26.5 miles of roadways which include; 9 miles of road to the Chilkoot Lake Campgrounds, about 1/2 of which is presently paved; 8 miles of improved gravel road south of Haines to the Mud Bay Road turnaround; 7.5 miles of the paved Haines Cutoff Highway, and 2 miles of gravel service roads to pub- lic facilities and subdivisions outside the city limits. The State Highway Department also maintains over 2 miles of roadways within the City, more than I mile of which is presently paved. A number of road improvements are scheduled for the summer of 1976 including the repaving of Lutak Road to the Ferry Terminal; Main Street in Haines; Union Street; a portion of Mud Bay Road south of the City, and the Haines Cutoff Highway from its terminus in Haines to Mile 5. State roadways are maintained by the Highway Department maintenance crew stationed at a 6.5 acre site located at Main and Union Streets. 2 large wood frame structures, built in the 40'sPand a 500 square R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines,Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -51- foot wood frame storage building house warm storage and equipment maintenance functions. Major road maintenance equipment operated from the Highway Department's Haines Maintenance facility include 2 road graders;'4 dump trucks with wing blade attachments for snow clearance; 2 loaders, 1 with a snowblower; 1 crane; a Cat tractor; 1 brushcutter and 2 pickup trucks. Services provided are mainten- ance, repair and minor construction on all State-maintained roads in the Haines area, as well as mechanical maintenance and repair to equipment operated by the Department and the other State aqencies in the area. The crew of 10, which includes a Foreman, 2 Mechanics, 1 Clerk and 6 Equipment Operators also maintains the Haines Airstrip on contract for the Alaska Division of Aviation. Nearly 9 miles of city streets are owned and maintained by the City of Haines. The maintenance and repair of these streets, as well as snow cl earance, is a respo nsibility of the Haines Public Works Department. Three bus companies provide surface transportation: [11 Mar-Air Bus Company Limousine service to and from the Airport and Ferry Terminal; sightseeing charter and Haines Highway charter as far as Whitehorse. 2 eleven passenger busses and 1 thirty-two passenger bus are presently operated, with a 41 passenger motor coach soon to be in service. [21 Alaska Yukon Motor Coaches - Operates between Haines and Anchorage three times weekly (summer schedule) as a common carrier transporting individuals as well as tour groups. 6 motor coaches are currently in service. [3] Westours, Inc. - School bus service on contract with the Haines. School system. 3 forty-four passenger school busses are operated during the school year, and are maintained and R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -52- stored at.a covered bus parking structure located at 1/2 Mile on the Haines Highway. Also providing surface transportation services in Haines are two freight transport companies: [11 Eagle Transfer - Freight-shipping and receiving ser- vices from the waterfront to the community for Foss Alaska Lines. 1 Owner/Operator, l' Office Manager and 2 Warehouse- men operate from a 22,000 square foot concrete block ware- house in good condition. 2 tractors, 1 van truck, a lowboy trailer and a fork lift are used in the companies operations. [2] Lynden Transport - Wallace Garage is the Haines-agent for this transport organization, which ships freight to and through Haines to all points. 1 Freight Handler and 1 book- @keeper are the personnel of this operation which trucks northbound freight, and loads southbound materials on the State ferries. (b) Marine Transporta'tion - Haines'location at the northern end of the Inside Passage, and the sheltered deepwater natural har- bor potential of Lutak Inlet, make the community particularly appropriate for marine transportation activiti'es. Portage Cove, immediately adjacent to the townsite, also contains several marine facilities, although it is neither as sheltered or as deep a harbor location as.Lutak Inlet. The Lutak Dry Cargo Dock was constructed in the early 50's by the U.S. Army. The dock has a 1,000 foot long face and a heavy timber fender system. Ownership of the facility still rests with the federal government, although the State of Alaska, which utilizes the south 350 feet of the dock for its Marine Highway R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -53- terminal facilities, leases the entire property from the U.S. Government. Negotiations with the General Services Administra- tion (GSA) are currently underway which, if ultimately success- ful, would bring the northern 2/3 of the dock into the ownership of the City of Haines; and the Ferry facilities under State own- ership. The 650 foot of general cargo dock north of the Ferry facility is presently leased on contract to commercial users. Fender system improvements are needed to this section of the dock. The portion of the facility used by the Ferry System is now in excellent condition, with structural improvements and maintenance recently completed. The entire facility.is located about 5 miles north of Haines via the Lutak Road. The,Army also constructed in the early 50's, a POL Dock (Petro- leum - Oil - Lubricants) about 1 1/2 miles south of the Dry Cargo Dock. This facility, built in connection with the U.S. Government Tank Farm and the 8 inch diameter pressure pipeline for the transportation of petroleum products to military install- ations in Fairbanks, was deactivated by the federal government three years ago. The dock consists of a concrete and steel pier- head and approach structure, and 2 concrete and steel dolphins. Product pipelines run from the dock to the 12 large storage tanks located on the 80 acre reservation. Located on the reser- vation are a number of facilities including 10 major buildings which provided family housing; equipment maintenance and storage shops, and office space. While the facility is connected to the .electric power distribution system of Haines Light & Power Co., it is equipped/ with standby generating capacity, and has its own water source and distribution system. Port Chilkoot Dock is located on the shore of Portage.Cove at the foot of Portage Street. This venerable facility was built at the R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -54- time of great military activity at Fort Seward, and has undergone substantial modification, reconstruction and repair projects over the years; a major rebuilding in the 1950's being the most recent improvement. While the dock was, at one time, the principal fa- cility for cruise ships and freight, the only present user of the dock is the Standard Oil Company, whose petroleum products are off-loaded and transported through a pipeline to a tank farm lo- .cated on the waterfront some 800 feet from the dock. The facility, presently owned by the Haines Highway and Terminal Company, is in poor condition and will* require major structural rebuilding to again become an important marine transportation facility. Another privately-owned facility is the Schnabel Lumber Company dock located on Lutak Inlet at the company's mill. This 1,000 foot long dock is used for the loading of wood products, and has. an average water depth of 40 feet at the face. The Union Oil Dolphin and underwater P-6L pipeline at the Port Chilkoot waterfront on Portage Cove is owned by Gulf Oil of Canada, Limited; and is used by that company for the transport'of petroleum products from Vancouver, B.C. into the Yukon Territory. Union Oil Comp@ny utilizes this facility for local off-loading and distribu- tion of its petroleum products. The Haines Small Boat Harbor is located on the Portage Cove water- front at the foot of Main Street.. The 300' x 400' harbor area pro- tected by a rock filled and armored 900' long breakwater, was con- structed in 1958. Heavy timber floats with styrofoam flotation are sufficient to accomodate 18 stalls for small boats, 34 stalls for boats from 24 to 40 feet, and float-side moorage for 4 large boats up to 80 feet in length. A concrete ramp for boat launching is approached from Main Street, and the "grid" for minor maintenance R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -55- is located on-the northeast corner of the Harbor. Electrical and water utilities are available to boats in the harbor, and refueling is accomplished by hose and tanker truck. There is off-street parking for 20 vehicles adjacent to the Small Boat Harbor. The facility is owned by the State of Alaska, and is operated and main- tained by the City of Haines. The Harbormaster is the principal employee involved in administration of the facility, with backup from the Public Works Department for maintenance and repair. The Haines Small Boat Harbor is the primary community facility for moorage of fishing boats, pleasure craft, work boats and transient watercraft. L ightering facilities for cruise ship passengers are presently mini mal. The City and State join tly maintain a small boat moorage facility at Letnikof Cove, 5 miles south of the city on Mud Bay Road. This temporary facility has accomodated up to 200 fishing boats during stormy periods in the fall. The wood piles and floats have been severely damaged by storms and winter removal from the water, and beneficial use of this facility would necessitate a completely new installation. Foss Alaska, and Lynden Transport both provide marine transport of freight between Seattle and Haines by use of vans placed aboard the ships of the Alaska Marine Highway. Lynden Transport provides cus- tom freight service to Haines, while Foss Alaska redistributes freight to other points from its receiving station in Juneau. Both companies provide a basic weekly freight service, with more fre- quent service when required. The Royal Viking Line is scheduling three cruise ships into Haines in the summer of 1976. Several other lines operating in Southeast Alaska waters have landed in Haines in the past, but lack of R. W. PAVITTAND ASSOCIATES, INC. Raitnes Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) .-56- adequate dockside and on-shore facilities'in the community have caused a decline in landings.- .(c) Air Transportation The Haines Airport is located 3 miles northwest of the city on the Haines Highway. @The facility is on &'30 acre site owned by the State of ATaska. The State maintains 44,100' landing strip of asphalt treated gravel, 50' in-'width. There are 4:hangar structures With-me in use by commercial' air- craft, and the others-by private, owners. All of the hangars are on surveyed.lots owned'and leased by the State Division of@Aviation. A 25" x 40" Terminal building has been constructed at the, airport, but is not currently in use by either of the air services in Haines. Parking for vehicles is plentiful in terms of space, but the taxi- way used by aircraft 'is also'used foy-vehicle access which creates a dangerous:situation. Electric power is not presently available at:the airport,'and no landing strip li:ghting is present. The Division of Aviation has no personnellin Haines, but'contracts with the State Highway Department to provide snow removal and maintenance to the'runway. Two commercial.air services use the facility as well as about 10 private ai-rcraft owned by Haines residents.: [11 L A B_ Flying Service - Owned by Layton A. Bennett of Haines, LAB has an office on Main and 4th in Haines. Their airport fa- cility consists of a' refueling station and tie-down facilities on land leased from the Division ofAviation. LAB bases 2 pilots in Haines along with three aircraft and a local staff of 3 Dis- patchers and a Bookkeeper. The fi rm's 10 aircraft serve Haines and the remainder of Southeast Alaska on a charter flight basis, and provides scheduled mail service on c onract with the U.S. Postal Service. Charter flights for scenic Southeast tours and custom freight service is 'also provided. It is estimated that LAB is R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -57- currently carrying passenger traffic in excess of 6,000 per year. [21 Southeast Skyways _Inc. - This Juneau-based and owned fi rm serves Haines with regularly scheduled air carrier service on a daily basis. The normal summer schedule includes 4 flights per day, with.2 flights per day in winter. Freight service is also provided, and charter service is available. Southeast Skyways maintains an office in Haines on the Corner of Main St. and 3rd Avenue, and has I Pilot and 2 Agent/Dispatchers stationed locally. Close to 4,000 passengers per year are transported by this carrier. R. W. PAVITT AND A.SSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -58-' II.- ECONOMIC BASE STUDY This-chapter of.the plan studies the economic.aspects of the Haines area, and discusses the various sectors of the economy., It also provides population analysis and projections as necessary to @relate the current status of the community to the economic-development opportunities. A." ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT STATUS"OF THE HAINES ECONOMY (1) flaines-Average Annua1Employment-Survey (a) Purpose - The purpose of this survey is to provide,..in-formation on employment in the Haines area economy. Specific information on Haines has not been generated by the Alaska Department of Labor. Instead, since 1963, Haines has been recorded as part of the Lynn Canal-Icy Straits Labor Area which also,includes Skagway, Hoonah, Gustavus, and Yakutat. Attempts to use Lynn Canal-Icy Straits Labor Area data for the purpose of gaining knowledge and under- standing of Haines have been futile because the communities are very different in employment composition, and general infor- mation for all of them cannot accurately be applied to Haines. This survey provides information on the quality, type, and seasonality of employment in Haines for the first time, and establishes basic economic data for local planning. (b) Methodology_ - A questionnaire was designed to be answered by all employers in the Haines area. The questions sought information on current employment, employment by month for 1975 and 1976, full- time and part-time-work, manpower availability, use of non-' resident labor,-job titles, and some payroll information. The questionnaire also sought open-ended comments from employers concerning the local economy. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _59- A master list of all businesses and government units in the Haines area was prepared. In order that no source of employment was missed, the list was drawn up from four sources: 1. 1975 State of Alaska Business License Directory which lists everyone with a business license with a Haines zip code. There were 213 listings. Haines telephone directory. 3. Alaska Industrial Directory of Employers. 4. Local knowledge. After compiling this list,@several local people reviewed it and deleted businesses no longer in existence; made necessary name changes, and corrected other errors. The result was an up-to-date list of active businesses and government units which totalled 118. These were distributed to 12 volunteer interviewers in mid-April, 1976 who went out into the community and administered the question- naires to the businesses-and government units. 108 responses were received for almost complete coverage of the Haines area economy. Those not responding were questionable or marginal operations of little economic significance. it i.s judged that the employment shown for April 1976 is quite close to that which actually existed in Haines at the time. Employment figures for other months are slightly less accurate because they rely on past recall as far,back as January 1975. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -60-, The completed questionnaires were tallied and analyzed,,and the results are presented in this section. (2) Other Surveys In addition to the employment by local firms and government agencies there were two major sources of-employment which were accounted for with other methods. (a) Since fishermen were not includedith Department of Labor data, thei.r.number was estimated by surveying,one-thi,rd of the active gillnet entry permit holders residing in Haines. The questionnaire asked for months spent fishing, type of fish caught, persons assisting them@ areas fished and supplementary fncome sourcos.@ A master list of'permit and license holders was obtained"from the Commercial Fisheries Entry Commission so the number of permit holders was known. Local knowledge was used to identify which permit holders were actively engaged in the fishery. 'The survey provided i'nformation-to estimate the number of fishermen who' assist the permi't holders. The results of this survey are pre- sented in the fisheries section. The other source of employment not covered by the survey was employment of Haines residents on the trans-Alaska pipeline con- struction project. No state or-union'records- were available to res earch this, so local knowledge was relied on entirely. Several long-time area residents made a concerted effort to identify persons working on the pipeline in April, 1976. After an hour of discussion of each name, a total of 43 Haines residents was R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -61- positively identified as currently working on the pipeline. Thus, at the time of the survey the trans-Alaska pipeline project was revealed to be the third largest employer of Haines residents. (3) Results of Average Annual Employment Survey (a) Current Employment - At the time of the Haines employment survey, there were 472 persons employed by businesses and govern- ment un-its in the Haines area. An additional 43 persons were employed as construction workers on the trans-Alaska pipeline project. Major individual employers at the time were Ha ines School District (59 employees) and Schnabel Lumber Company (56 employees). The Alaska Department of Labor-reported Haines unemployment for April as 158. Thus at the time of the survey, the Hai,nes economy appea red this .way: Haines Economy April, 1976 Employment 472 Pipeline Employment 43 Total Haines Residents Working 515 Unemployment 158 Total Area Labor Force 673 Percent Unemployed 23.5 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -62- Self-employed persons accounted for just over 15 percent of those .working in Haines. Of the total. employees,, 76'percent were working in full-time jobs while 24 percent were part-time employees. The bulk of the part-time work was in the trade and service sector of the economy. 46 percent, or nearly half of the jobs in these twosectors were part-time jobs. -The largest concentration of self-employed people was-al,so in trade and service. 57 ofithe 72 self-employed persons work in these sectors. ..The largest emRloyer in terms of.sectors was the trade sector with .125 persons working.. Manufacturing was next with 92 followed by _:_-local,government.with 84,-the,bulk of which were school.employees. The service sector occupied 63 people, while transportation and state government each employed 32. 14 persons worked for the Federal@Government, 12 were.-employed in communications and public utilities, 10 in finance, insurance and real estate and 8-persons were engaged in construction-related work. Payroll information'was attempted but the question.was optional and too few persons el:ected to answer the pa roll-question to allow for meaningful statistics.. (b) 1975 Employment - One extremely important result of the survey was a fairly accurate reconstruction of the Haines economy for the entire year 1975. This is perhaps the.most enlightening infor- mation contained in this economic base study. Table No. 3 shows employment by sector and by month and allows us to see seasonal changes of each part of the economy. See Table 3 on page 67. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -63- The low month employment for the year 1975 was in January with 471 persons working. The high point was July with 736 employed, including fishermen. This constitutes a dramatic seasonal fluctuation with the peak 56.3 percent higher than the low. November employ- ment dropped to 510 from 725 in September; a drop of almost 30 percent in a period of just two months. The data for 1975 are likely to be somewhat underestimated because firms operated in 1975 which were not covered in the 1976 survey. Only firms an@ government agencies operating in Haines in April, 1976 were possible to survey. Construction, fishing and manufacturing were the major causes of the seasonal fluctuation. Only the local government sector operated in reverse, with less employment in the summer because of school being closed. Federal government, and finance, in surance and real estate employment remained the same each month. Com- munications and public utilities employment.-rose by only one person for the summer. Trade, service and transportation, which together comprise over 40 percent of the economy, had moderate seasonal changes. Table 1 shows total-employment; self-employment, full and part- time employment and the number of firms and government agencies in-the Haines area at the time of the survey, which was conducted in mid-April. Self-employed plus employees equals total employment. Full-time plus part-time employees equals the employees column. R. W. PAVITT AND. ASSOCIATES.. IN-C.- Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1), -64- TABLE I Haines Area Employment, April 1976 Self- Full- Part- Sector Firms Total Employed Employees Time Time Construction 4) 8 4 4 4 0 Manufacturing (.10) 92 5 87 78 .9 Transportation (-8) 32 4 28 19 9 Comm. & Pub. U. 5) 12,. 1 1.1 .9 2 Trade (38) 125 34 91 54, 37 Fin. Ins. & R.E.( 2) 10 1 9 8 1 Servi.ce, @(24) _63 23 40 17 23 Fed. Gov. 3) 1.4. .14 13 Local Gov. 4) 84. 0 -84 72, 12, State.Gov.. 32 0 32 31. 1 Total (108). 472 72: 305 95 Trans-Alaska- Pipeline 43 0 43 43 0 Total, Incl. Pipeline. 515 72 443 348 95 Source: Haines Average Annual Employment Survey, City of Haines, April.1976. Note:..There are differences between-these survey results.which show 472 persons employed and the employment by month which shows 496 persons employed. The difference of 24 is accounted'for by differences in employment between the week of the survey and in employer's estimates of employment for the whole month of April. Major differences were transportation, where no longshoremen were working at the time of the survey but 42 were estimated for the month; and in trade where 14 more people were actually working than were estimated for the month. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -65- We can see what changes have occurred in Haines employment by comparing the results of the April 1976 survey with information from the March 1975 Overall Economic Development Plan (OEDP) report. This comparison shows a drop of 151 jobs from 623 in 1975 to 472 in 1976. Almost all.of the loss was in manufacturing (lumber mills) and in transportation (longshoring). Table 2 shows these changes. (See Table 2 on page 66). A part of the Average Annual Employment Survey collected information from employers on monthly employment for 1975 and 1976 to date. The infor- mation which resulted provides the first accurate information on Haines seasonal employment patterns in each sector of the economy. Table 3 shows employment for each month in 1975 and the average for the year. Unemployment-data was available only for December, and that is shown at the bottom of Table 3. (See-Table 3 on page 67). The information is presented in Table 3 in a manner very similar to the way the Department of Labor will produce Haines Labor statistics in the future. This 1975 information can then be compared to future years and be useful for quite some time. We can identify the courses of seasonal employment change by combining similar types of employment. Table 4 does this for 1975, and shows that the combination of construction, manufacturing and fishing, is the most seasonal group of sectors in the Haines economy. Table 5 provides the statistics which are portrayed in the graph in Table 4. (See Tables 4 and 5 on page 68). Employment information from the survey is quite accurate for 1975 and up to April 1976. Beyond April 1976 are estimates which cannot be considered as accurate. They are estimates and are not taken from past R. W. PAYITT-AND ASSOCIATES. WC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -66-:- TABLE 2 Employment Changes,1975-1976 Haines'Area Economy March April 1 2 1975 1976 Change Construction: .19 8 -21* Manufacturing 221 92 -129 Transportation 65 32 - 33 comm. & PublJc Util. 17.: 1Z: 5. Trade 113.- 125 12 Fin@. Ins. &:R.-E. 11: 10 1 Service 56'.. @63 7 Fed. Gov.: @15 14:11, 1 -Local Gov.!: 68: 84, + 16 State Gov. 28,. 32 + 4, 623 472 -151 1. Source:.: 1975 OEDP report. The employment shown in the OEDP.report was sorted into the-appropriate.sector to make it.comparable to data from the 1976 survey. The two sets of Idata are similar but not entirely comparable. The 1975 survey was a phone survey which sought average annual employment based on estimates of employers. It is not entirely employment which existed in March, 1975. Construction and manufacturing are higher than actual for March because of high seasonal peaks. 'The two surveys agreed within 2% (373 vs.. 380) on.-the 19.75 average annual employment for all other sectors. 2._5ource: Haines.Average AnnualEmployment Survey,,April 1976. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -67- TABLE 3 Haines Monthly Employment, 1975 i F M A M J J A S 0 N D Avq. Const. 4 5 5 6 5 31 32 31 29 31 11 11 16 Mfg. 152 148 145 177 174 193 218 206 177 173 121 102 166 Transp. 42 74 77 69 47 75 90 78 87 55 60 '85 70 Comm. & - P.U. 11 11 11 11 11 12 12 12 11 11 11 11 11 Trade 100 101 102 108 116 129 133 132 125 121 .113 115 116 Fin.,Ins. & R.E. 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 1.0 10 10 10 10 10 Service 42 50 44 56 60 74 71 68 70 65 63 58 60 Gov. 116 111 111 -113- 80 85 100 136 127 121 135 112 Fed. 14 14 14 14 14 14 '14 14 14 14 14 14 14 Local 65 71 6.6 65 66 28 33 49 85 81 76 90 65 State 31 31 31 32 33 38 38 37 37 32 31 31 34 Total Empl. 471 515 505 548 536 604 651 637 645 593 510 527 561 Fishing 9 20 70 85 85 80 20 31 Total 471 515 505 557 556 674 736 722 725 613 510 527 593 Unempl oyment 157 Percentage 23.0% Source: Hain es Average Annual Employment Survey City of Haines, April 1976. R. W. PAVITTAND'ASSOCIATES-INC..- Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -68- TABLE 4 Seasonal Changes in Haines Employment, 1975 Selected.Sectors Month i F M A M J J A S 0 N D 900 All Employment 600 500 Construction,,Manufacturing & Fishing 400 Transp'n, Trade'& Service 300 200 lOO:-- Fin, Ins. &' R.E...; Comm. &'P.U.; Fed.: Gov t.- 0 J :F M A :@M --J J S 0 D Month TABLE 5 Seasonal Changes in Haines Employment, 1975 Selected Sectors, J F@ A M- J J A S 0 N :-D Avq. Const, Mfg & Fishing" 156 153 150' 192 '199-294 335 322 286 224 132 113 214 Fed, FIRE & Comm.,@& PU 35 35 35 35 35 35 36 36 36 35 35 35 35 Transp'n., Trade and 184 225 223 233 223 278 294 278 282 241 236 258 246 Service Total Empl. 471 515 505 557 556 674 736 722 725 613 510 527 593 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -69 records as was the 1975 information. Also, they include no new happenings such.as construction or mill reopening. Readers of Table 6 should consider the May-December statistics as only reporting the results of the survey and not as a realistic estimate of what may actually occur in the Haines economy for the balance of 1976. TABLE 6 Haines Monthly Employment, 1976 Estimated: Assuming no mills operate, Actual - no longshoring and no construction Const. 6 6 8 8 8 9 9 9 8 8 8 8 Mfg. 100 94 94 93 41 42 41 40 38 32 31 34 Transp. 71 64 71 74 70 47 47 47 48 47 45 44 Comm. & P.U. 11 11 11 11 11 12 12 12 11 11 11 11 Trade 100 102 108 111 120 130 '130 128 122 118 11-2 115 Fin.,Ins. & R.E. 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 Service 58 62 64 63 67 72 75 73 71 62 59 54 Gov. 139 139 124 126 125 126 73 89 131 126 125 125 Fed. 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 Local 94 94 80 80 78 74 21 38 80 80 80 80 State 31 31 30 32 33 38 38 37 37 32 31 31 Total Empl. 495 488 490 496 --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- Fishing 9 20 70 85 85 80 20 Total 495 488 490 505 Unempl. 198 281 75 158 % Unempl. 28.7 36.5 13.3 24.2 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES.' INC.- Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -70- (c) Business Starts -A summary of the results of the question '.which asked,@'year busi ness originafly established" is a sketch of -Ha-ines' growth. Not every business,replied to the question. 68 responded as did nine government units. The oldest unit was Klukwan Day School (1905) while Sourdough Pizza was theyoungest, starting in February 1976. Haines Packing Po.. was the,oldest responding business, originating in 19T7. ..Year,Business Originally Established Year No. Established -1976 4 1973-75 17 1970-72 15 -1965-69 TO 1960-64 10 1955-59 8 :1950-54 6 1940-49 .2 1930@39 I 1920-29 1 1910-19 2 1900-09 1 Total 77 Growth in busi ness was significant in the 1960's'when Schnabel Lumber Co. expanded early in the decade following a mill fire in 1960, while AF-P began operations in 1.965.. The most pronounced growth in new businesses which still operate was in the early R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -71- 1970's,- with 22 starts for 1970-75 compared to 20 for the entire decade of the 1960's. This was a result of additional mill employ- ment, excellent fishing years which made money available (several fishermen own"businesses locally), rapid increase in government employment, increased tourism and other ferry traffic and pipeline- related activity. A number of factors boosted the local economy in the early 70's. This rise was not caused solely by the timber industry, although the industry was certainly important in the economy of the area. (b) Manpower Availability - Almost all of the needs of the Haines economy are met by the local l,abor force. Most businesses and government agencies reported no difficulties filling their positions, and almost all drew from the local area even during peak seasonal needs. The timber industry--drew signi.fica-ntly from [email protected] logging employees, but most logging is actually conducted outside the.Haines area anyway. The mills, even at peak times, took 85% of their labor from the local area with only 15% from outside the area. There were several employers expressing a need for skilled or specifically trained people such as: --skilled mechanics --airplane pilots --trained motel employees --electronic technicians --beauty operators R. W. PAVITT AND -ASSOCIATES, INC... Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) .42-1 The demand appears -to be-for goodg wel-l-trained people in these areas, rath&`than just anyone workiing in these occupations.. The same:demand applies to jobs in less skilled.areas.. Bartenders, cooks, waitresses, tour bus drivers, sales personnel and dispatchers were jobs which employers reported difficulty filling w1th "good" people,.: Of cours'e some,of these are low paying,,and quality employees can't always be expected at low wages. Finally, s.ome jobs requiring extensive.education, training and exper-ience@were`hard:tG fill-from the local labor pool. Super- viso,ry and technical jobs in government and-accounting skills in business were needed., Also supervisory people for mill work were hard to find. In general, the Haines labor pool" does not meet all the area's d-emand:for-supervisory technical and@skilled jobs. Most of the jobs in-the Haines area do not require a-high degree of skill, training or education, according to the titles listed by employers. Similarly, most of the area's unemployment is accounted for by people having job experience in semi-ski1led or unskilled work, judging from an analysis of Haines employment requests in 1975-76. (4)_ Results of Fishermen's Survey A survey of one-third of the Haines area entry permit holders was taken to determine the importance of commercial fishing.to the local economy. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -73- Incom6\data is confidential and not available, but this survey and other research on fisheries provides this picture of the importance of fishing in Haines: There are 57 salmon gillnet entry permit holders residing in Haines who are actively engaged in the fishery. 20 of the salmon permit holders also hold licenses for halibut, but local sources indicate that perhaps only 8 of these make significant catches of halibut. The others participate during extended salmon closures, or only when halibut prices are exceptionally high. 8 fishermen are licensed for crab and only a few are licensed for the herring fishery, which is a very brief, limited fishery in the early spring. Commercial salmon trolling is nearly nonexistent in the Haines'area. In the survey, gillnetters indicated almost exclusive dependency on fish bound for river systems in the immediate area. None of the respondents to the questionnaire said they gillnetted outside the Lynn Canal area. Many other gillnetters in Southeast Alaska fish several areas with Haines being most heavily fished in the fall. There are,431 gillnet permits for fishing in Southeast Alaska of which 294 are resident Alaskans and 137 are non-residents. Thus, the Haines fleet is primarily a gillnet fleet fishing almost exclusively in the immediate Haines (Lynn.Canal) area. Any change in fishing-pressure, environmental factors and management policy in the Haines area would have heavy impact on Haines fishermen. It is critically important to the economic well being of the fishing fleet that the Chilkat and Chilkoot systems be managed wisely. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1)' -74- It is-estimated from the survey that a total of 80 to 90 Haines residents are engaged-in fishing each year. This is based on 57 gillnetters with permits who are known to be active. 59% of these fish alone for salmon while 41% have someone fishing with them. 40% of them also fish halibut and have someone helping them. 57 active permit holders plus 23 helpers gives. a total of 80 individuals fishing from as early as April for halibut and herring to.early October when the fall chum and coho seasons end. Obv-iously, there is some duplication and some instances of permit holders fishing together as partners or fami-lies. This would lower the actual number. By adding the few trollers, halibut,fishermen without gillnet permits and crabbers, the total number of fishermen is raised again. Our best estimate places the number of active fisher- men.living in Haines at a-low of80 and a high of 90. Their degree of economic dependency on fishing is unknown but it is very likely high for a couple of reasons. The 57 permit holders had to be historically dependent on fishing income in order to qualify for permits. Also the Lynn Canal catch has been one of the most con- sistent in Alaska during a period of skyrocketing fish prices which have enhanced fishermen's gross income considerably in recent years. About 1/3 of the fishermen surveyed had no other source of income while 2/3 worked at other jobs in the off-season. Based on questionnaire results', the following is an estimate of the number of Haines residents engaged in fishing of all kinds by month: R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -75- Estimated Number of Haines Month Fishermen Active April 9 May 20 June 70 July 85 August 85 September 80 October 20 (5) Unemployment and Public Assistance Programs Unemployment is a useful way to show the status of.a local economy such as Haines. It was difficult to-obtain Haines unemployment because it has not been recorded separately until December 1975. Furthermore, the method of reporting this i nformation is not entirely accurate but is expected to be refined in the future. Table 7 gives an approximate idea of the number of people in Haines receiving Unemployment Compensation. Based on this information, it is estimated that unemployment ranges between 150 and 200 in the winter and early spring. TABLE 7 Unemployment Claims, 1976 to Date Lynn Canal-Icy Straits Labor Area 1976 Haines Skagway-Yakutat Total January 198 231 429 February 281 150 431 March 75 211 286 April 158 264 422 Source: Alaska Department of Labor. (Unemployment is defined as the number of pers'ons claiming unemploy- ment compensation each month. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -76 It is important to consider the type of skills held by unemployed per- sons residing in Haines. This indicates the type of developmen 't which is most likely to aid employment in the area. Table 8 shows the skills reported by 111 employment applicants residing in the Haines area. The table shows that timber-related, transportation and construction skills are in surplus in the Haines area. Thus mill work, transportation and construction would help reduce unemployment. TABLE 8 Employment Applications of Haines Residents to Employment Office, 1975-1976 Timber Related Transportation Logging 9 Truck Driver 10. Sawmill Workers 9 Longshoring 8 Millwrights 2 Pilot 1 20 Cab Driver 1 20 Construction Service, Trade Fp-erating Engineer 15 Clerical, Sales 11 Mechanic 4 Janitorial, Main. 6 Oiler 4 Waitress 4 Electrician 2 Cook 2 Painters 2 Baker's Helper I Welders 2 24 29 Other General Labor 4 Fishermen 4 Agricultural Workers 2 Miscellaneous 8. 18 Total,-- Ill R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -77- The existence of public assistance programs in the Haines area was examined to show the impact on the income of Haines residents. The data is for October 1975, but there has been little change since then. according to state officials interviewed. Food stamp recipients are up from 1 a Year ago to an estimated 20-25 in April, 1976; about half of which stamp recinients are families. Table 9 shows public assistance recipients for Haines, Klukwan and the total area. TABLE 9 Public Assistance Program Monthly Payments Haines Area, October 1975 Haines Public Assistance Haines Klukwan Total Area Program ..No. Amt. No. Amt. No. Amt. Old Age Assista-nce $ 171 7 36 7 TO '$' 538 Aid to the Blind 1 167 1 2 247 Aid to the Disabled 4 475 2 199 6 674 Aid to Families w/ Dependent Children. 10 3,155 0 .0 10 3,155 Total 18 $3,968 10 $646 28 $4,614 Source: Alaska Department of Health and Social Services. Note: -- The purpose of this information is to show the extent of public assistance programs in the Haines area. The total appears quite small for an area of 2,000 persons. Public assistance plays only a very minor role in the local economy. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -78- (6) Sectors of the Haines Economy The following discussion looks at the Haines economy by employment sector. This is because all employment statistics are maintained by sector, and in turn the Haines Average Annual Employment Survey-was accomplished by sector. Much of this discussion is based on information from the survey. (a) Mining @ There is currently no active mining in the area which could be considered to have employment. Except for extensive gold activity in the Porcupine area from 1898 to 1917 little has trans- pired in the mining sector in the Haines area. The Klukwan iron deposit is thought to have enormous potential,, but it creates no employment at present. (b) Construction - There is a very small construction sector in Haines." There are no major contractors based there, although a few local men have construction related businesses. Construction employment drops to near zero except in summer. On the other hand, a large portion of the Haines labor force has construction skills, and works in construction when employment is available. Each season one or two public works projects (roads, streets, harbors, etc.) and some private construction (housing, new business buildings) occurs to stimulate this sector. (c) Manufacturing - Currently there are'no forest products mills operating, the two major mills having shut down within the last six months. No fish processing has occurred in the area for several years. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -79- Manufacturing employment in April totalled 93 of which 63 were associated with the lumber mills. 12 were involved in arts and crafts manufacture while the remainder were in bakery, printing and other small operations technically considered manufacturing. The current status of this sector is low compared to the peak employment in excess of 300 in the summer seasons of 1973 and 1974. The manufacturing sector has been and will continue to be volatile because it is based on the timber industry. The Haines mills, which are considered small operations as mills go in the industry, are the first to be affected by the frequent ups and downs of the timber business. (d) Transportation - The,largest employer is the longshoring activity associated with loading timberproducts. At times, over 50 men are involved in this operaiion. This employment is sharply curtailed by the mill shutdown. Otherwise it is steady because the mills operate year round when markets are good. The ferry system employs 10 Haines residents year round and as many as 16 in the summer season. Most of these are shipboard personnel, while 4-7 persons operate the terminal. Air transportation employment is steady and employs 9 to 14 persons depending upon the season. Freight and transfer companies employ several persons and there is an average of 3-5 involved in bus and taxi operations. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -80- The transportation sector is well-rounded with employment from several sources. It is.generally steady and not overly seasonal. With the exception of longshoring it is not directly dependent on the volatile timber industry. In 1975 transportation employment averaged 70 while varying between a low of 42 and a high of 90. Ce) Communications and Public Utilities This is a small sector with a steady year round employment of 11 persons with only one additional employee in the summer season. Haines Light and Power, RCA, General Telephone, Cable TV and the disposal service are the main.employers. In general, the communication and public utilities sectors are underdeveloped. M Trade - This is the largest sector in terms of employment with 126 at the-time@of the survey. This.sector appears to have grown in recent times. -It is important to note the type of employment here. Over 100 of the jobs are steady year round employment, but there is seasonal.fluctuati:on, especially in restaurants and service stations. A large portion of the employment is part-time which usually means it is supplemental income for a household. Wages paid in the trade sector are not particularly high so economically one trade sector job would not equal a full con- struction or manufacturing job in.terms of income. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -81- Almost all trade sector businesses are small ones. They employ 1 to 5 people, and many are "mom and pop" operations. The largest employer in the trade sector are the grocery stores, hardware and restaurants. The trade sector is well developed for the area's size with a large number and variety of businesses. From the analysis of the year of origin question we found that much of Haines trade and service sector development has occurred since 1970. (9 Finance, Insurance and Real Estate This' is a small but very stable sector in the Haines economy with an average employ- ment of 10 and no seasonal fluctuation. Some major functions such as construction, financing, special insurance needs and some real estate are performed outside Haines, usually in Juneau. Thus for the size of the area this sector could develop more. W Service - Haines' service sector, while not as large as the trade sector, can still be considered fairly well developed for the size of the town. Major service employers are hotels/ motels and medical services. As in trade, most service businesses are one and two person operations. The development of the service and trade sectors is probably attributable. to increased traffic through Haines in addition to the population residing there. The service sector also seems to have experienced recent growth as the Haines economy broadened from basic industry expansion in the early 1970's. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. J Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -82-. Average annual employment in service was 60 for 1975 and there were 63 working when the April survey was taken. Seasonal fluctuation ranged from 42 to 74 in 1975. Many jobs are part-time and the service sector includes many self-employed persons. 0) Federal Government - The federal government sector consists of 8 jobs at the tank farm, 4 in the post office and 2 at Customs and Immigration. This provides 14 year round jobs with no seasonal fluctuations. W Local Government - There are three basic categories of local government.. The schools accounted for 46 jobs in 1975,and for 59 jobs at the time.of the survey. This is about 80% of all local government employment.. Of the 59 positions, teachers accounted for 42, 3 were administrators, 3 secretaries, 5 aides and 6 were custodial and maintenance jobs. Regular local government is the second category and this includes the normal full-time staff of administrators, police, fire and maintenance persons. These numbered 14 in April, 1976. The third category are loca 1 government employees who are the result of special state and federally-financed programs such as NYC or impact fund programs. These averaged 4 to 6 jobs, mostly occurring in the su mmer. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -83- (k), State Government.- State government was a large employer in the area averaging 34 in 1975, and having 32 employees at the time of the April survey. The Marine Highway System employed 4 persons at the terminai and 6 aboard ship, for a total of 10 in April. This rises to about 17 in the summer season. The Highway Department employs 10 persons in Haines year round. Thus the ferry and highway transportation function account for 20 of 32 state government jobs in Haines. Several state agencies have from 1 to 3 persons including the 'State Troopers, Division of Lands, Public Health, Corrections, Deputy Magistrate, Fish and Wildlife Protection and Weights and Measures of the Commerce Department. These positions are all year round jobs with no sea sonal fluctuation. B. INDUSTRIES IN HAINES AND THEIR FUTURE OUTOOK (2) Timber Industry (a) Present Status - The status of the Haines timber industry since the shutdown of sawmill operations consists strictly of a machinery maintenance operation. At the time of this writing, there are no timber industry operations in the Haines area. Both sawmills, Alaska Forest Products (AFP and Schnabel Lumber Company (SLC), have shut down their production phases. AFP closed its operation at the beginning of 1976 and the employment R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. r Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -84- survey shows a.decrease from 70 employees in April 1975 to 6 in April 1976. These 6 employees represent a maintenance crew. SLC closed after the April employment survey and decreased employment from 57 to an estimated 5 employees. The beginning employment in April 1976 was similar to the April 1975 level of 60 employees. The peak employment.month in 1975 for AFP and SLC was 96 and 70 respectively. In addition, timber harvesting operations and associated support ..services@to the sawmills were decreased in 1976 or not required at all as in the case of AFP. The total manufacturing employment sec.tor decreased from 177 in April .1975 to 93 in-April 1976,: and.further decreased to 41 after closure of the,Schnabel.Lumber Company. The industry had the advantages of a favorable combination of low stumpage prices and growing Japanese market conditions since the mid-1960's. A combination of higher log prices, market slumps, operating cos.ts and transportation problems has brought a closure of both mills in 1976. The wood-products industry is volatile and cyclical world-wide. Any economy largely dependent upon the industry should expect ups and downs in cycles lasting 2-5 years. The Haines economy was held up for longer than that because the peak of world-wide inflation.drove market prices up for two years (1973 and 1974) before production and log costs caught up. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -85- Two factors that affect the timber industry are housing starts and the Japanese economy. Both are volatile and subject to extreme ups and downs. An example of increased log prices as a result of rising stumpage and logging costs is that paid by Schnabel Lumber Company from 1972 to 1975: Year Cost Per MBF 1972 $ 75 1973 100 1974 130 1975 145 AFP tried a domestic market supplying trans-Alaska pipeline con- struction needs, but ran into problems with transportation and international tariffs. The larger timber companies in Southeast A laska control much of the timber resource and industry financing and naturally-have a tendency to control them to their own maximum benefit. The smaller mills are the first to suffer and the last to benefit and that includes the two Haines mills. The most heavily financed, largest and most efficient mills survive the longest in the lumber business. (b) Future Outlook - In trying to look ahead at the future of the timber industry in the Haines area several factors appear to indicate some timber processing will continue in the long run. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -86- We are assuming that one mill will continue to operate in the 'future. This will probably be the Schnabel Lumber Company mill although it is not expected to operate full time in 1976. 1. Small Business Administrati-on "set-aside" sales will provide a log supply for smaller firms. This will make small mill operations more feasible, and will free these mills from the locked in market situation which they face. 2. The Haines location is desirable because of the excellent shipping dock facility and the existing investment in mills. 3. Chilkat Valley timber is marginal in quality, and could not support a major operator. In addition, the Valley has competing uses such as recreation. Many of the forested State Lands are thus not available for logging, yet Native Land Claims selections could provide more timber supply. 4. Another factor that may influence production in the Haines area is that in -expanding market con- ditions the larger mills in Southeast will want to increase production and can contract with the smaller mills to provide some of their production. Since the second timber mill in Haines changed its operation to cut domestic lumber, it is not expected that-they will replace that equipment to again cut cants for export. Based on this it is assumed that in the future one mill will operate in the Haines area and that timber production will remain at that level and not substantially increase. R. W. PAV.1TT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -87- (2) Fisheries Industry (a) Present Status.- The catch levels of the 1970's have been the highest since statehood in Lynn Canal. The Haines fishery is generally healthy, steady and of high value. The two economic impacts of fishing are income for fishermen living in Haines and some seasonal retail business from the transient gillnet fleet of 100 to 200 boats from June-September. There is currently no processing in Haines, and few if any Hainesites work in the nearest processing plant which is at Excursion Inlet. The last cannery to operate, Haines Packing Company closed about 1972. Antiquated equipmeh% pollution require- ments and the declining economics of standard,salmon canning combined to close the plant; probably permanently. The Haines area has salmon running from June to October with reds, cohoes and chums spawning primarily in the Chilkat and Chilkoot river and lake systems. This provides a longer season than many areas. In addition several local boats fish halibut in the spring and crab in the winter, and some troll for salmon to a minor extent. The effects of logging, population pressure and sport fishing have been very minor on the Haines area fish runs. This, plus the fact that seining in Icy Straits through which Haines-bound salmon travel, has been virtually closed the last few years, have aided the status of the Haines fishery. R. W.,PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -88- In spite of the recent decline of the salmon fishery i@n most of Alaska the Lynn Canal fishery has been good and consistent by comparison. The best three catches in history have been since 1971. The fishery does not depend on pink salmon which are the least valuable and the most volatile'specie of salmon. It is largely the pink which has caused Southeastern Alaska's low level catches of recent years. Lynn Canal depends on chums, 'reds and cohoes in that order of importance.. The fishermen who are active in the Haines area appear to be diversifying into other species of fish such as halibut, crab, .herring and even shrimp. This strengthens their income potential, and adds to the length of their fishing season. Gillnetting still accounts for the majority (perhaps 90%) of total fishing income but the trend into other species is important. It makes fishing a steadier livelihood, protects against salmon cycles and encourages a longer operating season for any prospective fish processing plant. Table 10 shows the catch of salmon in District 15, Upper Lynn Canal. The catch has been steady,'as fisheries go, ranging from 300,000 to- about 500,000 fish for 10 of the 13 years shown here. P, R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -89- TABLE 10 Catch of Salmon by Species District 15, Upper Lynn Canal 1963-1975 King Red Coho Pink Chum Total 1975 835 18,077 56,750 2,345 229,125 307,132 1974 1,649 152,238 64,891 5,010 443,900 667,688 1973 2,795 193,701 27,804 14,551 279,342 518,193 1972 1,762 84,063 61,386 14,719 353,981 515,911 1971 4,208 76,685 52,074 6,376 272,591 411,934 1970 3,889 82,940 52,442 24,085 274,485 437,841 1969 3,848 133,448 35,474 9,616 162,958 345,344 1968 3,279 84,399 47,565 8,700 175,713 319,656 1967 3,473 71,399 68,985 16,589 169,282 329,728 1966 2,687 115,829 43,727 7,538 247,690 417,471 1965 4,692 95,054 43,758 5,049 214,150 362,709 1964 3,586 70,918 36,145 7,611 107,145 225,405 1963 2,350 58,987 36,715 14,310 106,545 218,907 Source: Alaska Department of Fish and Game. To point out the Haines fishery's relative stability, Table 11 compares the year-to-year change in catch between Haines and all of Southeastern. Most Haines fluctuations are less than 30% up or down, while Southeastern catches vary from 331% up, to a 77% drop. 8 of the 12 years show changes of over 30% for Southeastern as a whole, while Haines changed that much only twice during that period. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -90- TABLE 11 Percent Annual Change in Salmon Catch Upper Lynn Canal (Haines) Compared to Total Southeastern Haines Total Only Southeast 1975 -54.0% - 26.6% 1974 +28.8 - 26.1 1973 + 0.4 - 41.9 1972 +25.2 + 37.2 1971 - 5.9 - 11.4 1970 +26.7 +107.6 @1969 + 0.8 - 76.5 1968 - 3.1 +331.2 1967 -21.0 - 73.2 1966 +15.1 + 71.9 1965 +60.9 34.6 1964 + 3.0 + 2.6 Source: Derived from Alaska Department of Fish and Game data. Table,12 shows the Southeast Alaska Salmon Catch since 1950 in order to trace the overall history of the industry. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -91- TABLE 12 Southeastern Alaska Total Salmon Catch 1950-1975 1975 5,680,000 1974 7,738,400 1973 10,478,759 1972 18,053,203 1971 13,162,519 1970 14,851,252 1969 7,153,165 1968 30,435,142 1967 7,060,417 1966 26,300,895 1965 15,274,617 1964 23,386,637 1963 22,834,954 1962 15,781,905 1961 17,060,213 1960 5,623,258 1959 11,327,936 .1958 14,852,516 1957 12,773,130 1956 18,303,416 1955 13,253,434 1954 16,527,234 1953 .11,559,986 1952 17,191,019 1951 30,938,340 1950 16,785,345 Source: Alaska Department of Fish and Game. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -92- In summary, fishing is still a very important economic source for Haines providing perhaps over 60 households with their major source of income. By comparison, Schnabel Lumber Company employed about 70 when operating at its 1975 peak. Commercial fishing remains a strong economic force and may play a larger role in the future of Haines. It is particularly important to the area's Native population, as 50% of the gillnet permit holders are Native, while Natives account for less than 1/3 of the area's popula- tion. (b) Future Outlook The future outlook for fisheries in the Haines area is for steady and possibly improved catches. In addition there is definit&potential for a freezer-type processing plant being established.in the area. One main fisheries firm has expressed tentative interest in a plant location at Ha'ines. The state's fisheries management policy under the Hammond adminis- tration has been conservative. This should result in an increase in the size of the runs, especially reds, and will benefit Haines area fishermen at least for the next cycle. If management remains conservative, the long run outlook for the Haines fishery is very good. There are many factors accounting for the salmon decline but overfishing, plain and simple is the major contributor. Limited entry will be beneficial to.Haines fishermen because the same number of fishermen will harvest increased runs when the conservative management policies begin paying off in the late 1970's. The Haines area is a good site location for a modern fish pro- cessing plant, and this would be the major source of economic R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -93- growth from the fisheries industry for the future. There will be little or no growth in the number of gillnet fishermen due to limited entry. There are several reasons favoring Haines as a fish plant location: 1. There is a substantial resident fishing f .leet in Haines con- sisting of about 60 boats. 2. There is an even more substantial non-resident fishing fleet especially in the fall fishery. 3. The catch is relatively steady from year to year. With the exception of 1974 when a record 667,688 salmon were caught, the lowest catch since 1965 was 307,132 (1975) and the next highest was 518,913 (1973). 4. There is a resident labor force available for seasonal fish processing work. Thus, little increase in population would be necessary to staff the plant, and Haines residen ts would reap the benefits. 5. Transportation routes and facilities are favorable. The northern Lynn Canal fishing grounds are within a few miles of any plant location, insuring freshness and inexpensive delivery, while the road system and ferry system could provide transportation to both Alaskan and outside markets. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I@ -94- 6. The existence of a cold storage facility may stimulate local custom fish products and other satellite industry. 7. A small scale operation would not be directly competitive with the major companies which control Southeast Alaska salmon pro- cessing. In summary, the potential for fish processing, based on the Haines fish- ing, is one of the most promising development possibilities found in the process of the study. (3) Tourism (a) Present Status Tourism has been the most discussed economic influence in the course of the study. There are several reasons for this: --tourists and other travelers pass through Haines in large numbers in the summer season. --the number of travelers has increased considerably in recent years and further growth is inevitable, barring a national depression. --recent downturns in the area's forest products industries and general economy, have focused attention on other economic influences for future development; especially touri'sm. --the economic impact of the large number of travelers is felt to some degree in most parts of the small local economy. Thus, many of the business people'have an interest in increased tourism. R. W. PAVITT, AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _95- --many Haines.people realize the effects of tourism can be enhanced by local action.. Special events, port development, cultural attractions, local tours and hotel/motel expansion are examples of local actions by the city, business and individuals which increase the economic impact of tourism in the area. People traveling on the Alaska Marine Highway are the dominant form of tourism in the Haines area. In the summer season the Haines terminal handles more passenger and vehicle traffic than any other Marine Highway port including Rrince Rupertand Seattle. Year round, Haines has more vehicle traffic than any other port and is a close second to Juneau in total passenger traffic. All travelers, not just tourists, are what Haines people and businesses are concerned with. Ferry traffic data shows consider- able volume even in winter, almost none of which is tourist traffic. Cruiseship traffic is much discussed but has had little impact in the last few years because Haines is bypassed'for several reasons: --nearly all the world's cruiseships are built outside the U.S. for economic,reasons. U.S. ships must have U.S.,crews.and their wage demands make cruiseship operation unfeasible. Foreign ships with foreign crews comprise.the entire Alaskan cruise trade. These ships are limited by the Jones Act to four stops at U,.S. ports. In the Alaska trade Juneau, Sitka and Skagway are It must" stops, and,Ketchik-an,receives almost all ships. .Wrangell is a port of call for smaller cruiseships, and Haines receives only the overflow when the port of Skagway is jammed. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -96- Juneau is a "must" port because it is the state capital, and has several local tours and the ability to handle large numbers of tourists. Skagway is a 11must" port because of its historic fame and the White Pass and Yukon Railroad excursions. Sitka is a "must" port because of its historic Russian America heritage, and excellent local tours. It is also a convenient location for southbound ships departing Glacier Bay. Ketchikan receives ships because it is the first major city in Alaska on the Inside Passage route, and has a good local tour and excellent shopping. Air Tourists - The air tourist is the most economically beneficial for a community. Whether independent or on a tour, the air tourist must purchase lodging and food locally, which cruise people don't do, and he must purchase transportation while most ferry passengers bring their own. However, only one tour-operator offers Haines as part of any package tour, so the volume of these type of tourists is limited. There are two main reasons package tours are limited in Haines: 1. Haines is not a frequent cruiseship stop, and most package air tours tie into cruiseship routes. 2. Motorcoach authority between Haines, Whitehorse and Fairbanks is a tangle of red tape and competing interests. This makes it difficult to schedule tours through Haines on a regular basis. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES.1 N C. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) 97- Air tourists of both the independent and package-tour types do not visit Haines in volume. Alaskan and CanadianTourists Juneau (population,20,000) and Whitehorse (population 13,000) are major cities within easy reach of Haines. The last several years have-seen an increase in pl6asure visitors-from these two areas. The Haines-Salmon Derby and the Southeast Alaska State Fair are-two examples of local@effort which attract people from these markets. The Haines area is the most convenient access to the seacoast for motorists coming from Whitehorse and other,points in the Yukon. Its popularity -is increasing for recreation,and,vacation purposes for the Canadians. (b) Fu ture Outlook -.Ferry,traffic has been and wilil continue to be the dominant tourist market for.Haines. Development of businesses,and,.public facilities oriented to this market are con- siderations for Haines. Som&time agoAn a 1972 survey cruiselines were asked,what.they look for in a -port of call. They responded: --The port should be within convenient running distance of the ..main route. --The port should have a good local tour, and entertainment capable of handling passengers efficiently and pleasantly. -The port should have adequate docking or 1-ightering facilities. --The port should have shopping opportunities. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -98- Haines meets several of these criteria but its main drawback is proximity to Skagway, a "must" port, It is unlikely that ships wiTl stop at both Haines and Skagway because they prefer a-day's cruising between stops for the most efficient use;of the ship. The cruise ship potential of Haines is limited because of this, and ft is not recommended that the community invest large amounts to attract them. Docks.are not.a requirement. All passengers are lightered into Sitka,for example., which will handle 89 ships in 1976. Haines does have some cruiseship potential due to its nearness to .Skagway. Skagway dock space is limited and there are no plans to expand just for cruiseships. The harbor is unsuitable for anchoring and lightering. Finally, Skagway can handle no more ships but more are scheduled to join the Alaska trade. It is our opinion that ships which cannot get into Skagway would stop at Haines if they could be assured of adequate lightering and passenger satisfaction from bus tours, entertainment and shopping. It i-s our understanding that the local tour was a failure in servicing the four ship calls-in 1975. One cruise line sails up Lynn Canal and back, stopping at neither Haines nor Skagway. Haines probably will not rival the "big four" in cruise stops but there is potential for a significant increase in cruise stops through local action.. Even if Haines could only attract 20% of the cruiseship volume, that would be 10,000 passengers. This would be equal to about half of the existing ferry traffic into Haines for the entire summer season of 1975. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _99- Clearly some effort would reap.economic benefits, and the*effort might best be.spent i.n promotion-, organization-and preparation for handling those people.. The main burden, as well as the main benefit, falls on the local bus,tour operators to "package" a local tour and market it to the cruise passengers. Chilkat State Park is 1 ikelyi-to be developed in the future. Park .:.development., Al:aska-style, means--additi,onal cAmpgrounds, picnic grounds, water in summer and perhaps a boat launch@area for boats on trailers. In other words look for more camper and fishing visitors.. Kluane National Park in Canada is a long range development which will attract visitor traffic. It is likely to aid Haines through traffic of the camper type. Air tourists to Kluane will go through Whitehorse,-most likely. In summary, the future tourism outlook calls for increasing ferry traffic, possible.increases in cruise traffic as an overflow port, and modest volume of air and package tour touri sts if motorcoach authority is not resolved. The largest increase is likely to be in the camper-type market. Tourism is not likely to become a year round industry complete with conventions and winter sports, but it is and will be a significant seasonal industry which can be enhanced by local effort. (4) Transportation (a) Present Status - The transportation industry in Haines is a combination of longshoring, ferry traffic, highway traffic, airline traffic, cruiseship traffic, barginig, busses, taxis and the dock and highway facilities of the area. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) _100- Several factors contribute to its existence as one of the larger -sectors of the economy. Longshoring is the largest employer and is severely affected by the timber industry slump. Most other transportation businesses are relatively unaffected. Extensive ferry traffic data is available and is portrayed in the following tables. As stated in the tourism discussion, Haines is the largest volume passenger port behind Juneau and is the largest volume vehicle.port on the entire system., Table 13 shows passenger and vehicle traffic a t Haines for the 1963-1975 period. 1975 traffic is nearly double that of 10 years before. TABLE 13 Alaska Marine Highway Traffic at the Port of Haines, 1963-1975 Passengers Vehicles Dis- Dis- Year Embarking embarking Embarking embarking 1975 Mainline 34,809 32,309 10,978 10,661 - LE CONTE 5,360 6,165 1,508 1,751 Total 40,169 38,474 12,486 12,412 1974 Mainline 29,247 28,079 9,125 9,381 LE CONTE 4,035 3,859 897 904 Total 33,282 31,938 10,022 10,285 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) -lol- TABLE 13 (continued) Passengers Vehicles Dis- Dis- Year Embarking embarking Embarking embarking 1973 34,947 31,270 10,378 9,379 1972 30,975 27,136 9,500 8,232 1971 28,123 24,185 8,885 7,964 1970 26,632 24,358 8 541 8,238 1969 24,579 22,247 .8,:104 7,631 1968 23,910 21,620 7,777 6,797 1967 25,505 23,378 7,381 6,415 1966 26,164 21,333 7,512 6,064 1965 24,477 19,355 6,600 5,128 1964 1 8,334 15,267 4,854 3,967 1963 15,346 12,535 41,209 3,086 Seasonal analysis of ferry traffic shown in Table 14 indicates that off- season traffic is increasing-'at a more rapid rate than summer season traffic. TABLE 14 Summer Season Ferry Traffic, Port of Haines Percent of Annual Traffic Occurring in June, July and August Passengers Vehicles Year Embarking Disembarkia Embarking Disembarking 1975 56% 53% 50% 44% 1974 54 52 50' 45 1973 59 59 54 52 1972 62 61 55 54 1971 60 59 55 54 1970 62 62 55 54 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -102- TABLE 14 (continued) Passengers Vehicles Year Embarking Disembarking Embarking Disembarking. 1966 68% 650/0' 64% 60% 1963 70 68 70 68 (b) Future Outlook - Haines' role as the connection between the ferry system and the Alaska Highway will continue to be important for tourism, freight, local traffic and business travel. An adequate lightering facility or float may encourage additional cruiseship stops. Air transportation is a function of the population size plus business, government and tourism activity. It will increase as these factors increase. The Skagway road should not dampen traffic through Haines but rather enhance it because it forms a driving loop for tourists. Trucking mileage through Haines to the interior will still be shorter and at gentler grade than the Skagway route. Depending on the final selection of the gas line route, Haines may play a major role as a transshipment point. The Haines area may play a minor transportation role in OCS development. In summary, the Haines transportation industry is expected to grow due to the influences discussed. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -103- (5) Mining (a) Present Status The Haines area currently contains no mining operations of economi-c significance. There are a few part-time gold miners in the area, but no operations that could be said to support employment of any kind. Like the rest of Alaska, Haines was active in gold prospecting and mining operations around the.turn of the century. Placer gold (about $1,000,000) was mined in the Porcupine district, but large scale mining ceased about 1917. The Klukwan iron ore deposit was discovered in 1899 and is an extremely large deposit of titaniferous magnetite ore in both lode and alluvial form. There are several billion tons of 13% magnetite iron. There are other deposits nearHaines estima ted at several billion tons but of lower grade ore, suspected to be less than 10%. The location of the Klukwan deposit is the east side of the Chilkat Valley north of town. (b) Future Outlook - The Klu*kwan deposit may not be mined in the foreseeable future due to several factors: titaniferous ore requires more expensive refining; other world deposits are cheaper in extracting and shipping; the site is environmentally sensitive, due to its location on the Chilkat River, and a huge mining operation would be traumatic to the existing lifestyle of nearby Klukwan. The technology of mining and primary processing simply has not been developed to the point where economic and environmental feasibility can be shown for development of the Klukwan deposit. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -104- There are several copper, copper/nickel and asbestos ore deposits in the Yukon Territory northeast of Kluane National Park. These deposits are all located nearer the Alaska Highway and the Haines Cutoff than to Whitehorse and the railroad to Skagway. If these deposits are developed then Haines may become the ship- ping seaport. The Canadian government has an aggressive northern development policy and the development of these deposits is more likely to occur than similar deposits in Alaska. r No mineral development is likely to occur in the Haines area in the foreseeable future. (6) Outer Continental Shelf Development (a)*-Present Status - The federal government has leased large offshore tracts in the Gulf of Alaska for exploration and develop- ment by petroleum companies. The prices paid for the leases indicate high interest and potential. Considerable activity is expected to begin in the very near future. In fact preparations have begun to some extent and the impact is beginnning to be felt in the Gulf Coast communities. Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) oil development in the Gulf of Alaska was examined for its possible impact on the Haines area. (b) Future Outlook - It was concluded that minor trucking and shipping activity could occur in Haines due to OCS development. In addition, it is quite possible that employment sim ilar to that of the trans-Alaska pipeline may result. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) '-105- Employment in OCS activity for Haines people is likely to be less obtainable than on the pi peline. Much of the work is specialized in offshore construction and oil field work. These are highly unionized. The activity will be located outside the legal boundaries of Alaska making enforcement of "Alaska Hire" provisions a question. There will also be a labor force surplus when the pipeline is completed, causing more competition for jobs. The Gulf of Alaska OCS operation will not be as large scale as the pipeline-which is the world's largest private construction project. The OCS activity will be serviced via Seward, Cordova, Valdez and Yakutat. Major supplies such as components of offshore platforms will be transported to these ports or directly-to the offshore sites. Other supplies will be stored at these ports or .,shipped to them from Anchorage, Fairbanks, Seattle and other west coast ports. Still; Haines has a good industrial port facility, ferry service, and highway connections to the interior of Alaska and the "lower 48"; and is reasonably close to Yakutat via water and air. For these reasons there will possibly be some transportation activity in Haines associated with OCS development, though it is not likely to be of major proportions. (7) Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (a) Present Status There has been much discussion of what the impact of the Native Claims land and money will be on the Haines area. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -106- The 23,040 acres to be selected by Klukwan, Inc. will be the largest private or corporate land,holdings in the area. This land will be@selected from the-Chilkat and Chilkoot drainages. Two groups of area Native people receive.per capita cash distri- bution of the Settlement.Act money. Klukwan,@Inc. with.133 enrollees, most of which reside in@the area, wi.11 receive $90, and $81 per year for years 3, 49 and.5, and have previously ..received $185 for the.first two years.. Additional per capita cash distribution is expected for the second five years. Haines-at-large enrollees number 153; the majority of whom are assumed to live in the area, receive no land. They do, however, receive a more substantial per capita cash distribution which started at-$500 per year and declines to $450 per year by the tenth and final year of per capita distribution. In Alaska, Alaska Natives will receive 2% of the state's mineral royalties up to a total-of $500,000,000. This may be in the form of per capita distribution and would be similar in amount to the present cash distribution. (b) Future Outlook Since Klukwan, Inc. is a profit making corporation, and-intends to serve the best economic interests of its stockholders, the lands selected are likely to be the most valuable in the area. This would assumably include timberlands and recreational lands. It may well be that the Klukwan land selections may contribute to a more sustained timber industry in the future of the Haines area. The corporation is interested in employment opportunities for its members, and the harvesting and processing of Native timber lands Would provide some local employment. J R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES.. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -107- In summary, the land selections are likely to have.significant long-term impact on the Haines area because it is very probable timber, fisheries and recreational ventures will occur. While the cash portion of the settlement is of lesser economic importance, it does slightly enhance the economit ability of the area's original people.. Finally, and perhaps most significa ntly, Klukwan, Inc. and the regional corporation, Sealaska, will have the economic ability to invest capital in substantial business ventures. If a solid prospect appears; a cold storage plant for example, then local interests have the ability to finance construction and operation. In.the.past, local interests have not had this ability. This is not to say that a cold storage is a good immediate prospect, nor..that Klukwan, Inc. or Sealaska would elect to invest. It is only to say that for the first time, some financial ability.exists, which is controlled by people who live in the area. (8) Cottage Industry (a) Present Status Cottage industry is generally-considered to be small, home-based manufacturing operations usually making specialty products such as arts, crafts and food items. The average annual employment survey was not designed to survey existing cottage industry. Yet, in,the course of this.study we came across some instances of it, and some people who felt cottage industry could be a more important factor in Haines. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -108- Alaska has many people who have parlayed special skills or ...talent into businesses.- But they have done this on their own and have succeeded by virtue of their effort and the saleability of their products. (b), Future-Outlook To "develop" cottage industry is probably not something which the city or an economic development committee could do. It simply isn't the kind of thing which can be* .regimented, or willfully developed. People i.n-Haines do carve, paint-and can'salmon for sale, but they are limited by their own skill an&effort, and the relatively small market.for some of these specialty products. We did find one instance where a cottage industry business could be expanded if a cold storage facility was available locally. Custom smoked and canned salmon could be produced year round if a supply.of fish could be made available by means of freezing. (9) Arts and Crafts (a) Present Status - The predominant arts and crafts operation in Haines is Alaska Indian Arts, Inc., a well-known operation which produces Tlingit art in various forms but primarily in wood carvings. In the spring of 1976, AIA employed twelve persons working in the arts. .In addition, several Native people in the area produce carvings in wood.or silver., and others do.beadwork and make clothing such as moccasins. There are two prominent and other less prominent local artists who paint. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _109- The volume of visitor traffic aids in sales of arts and crafts. Also a large number of Hainesites have used arts and crafts as a part-time source of income from time to time. Thus a considerable pool of talent currently exists. (b) Future Outlook - Because of location and because of the talent pool the.potential exists.in the Haines and Klukwan area for a cooperative of some sortwhich could assist with marketing. Perhaps it is more realistic for individual producers to sell through a coop, thus making a steady supply available to the markets; rather than attempt to change the lifestyle and prodUction habits of dozens of individuals in an attempt to achieve regular production. If coordinated marketing of Haines products were to occur, Haines could enhance its reputation as a supplier of quality arts and crafts. Were this to occur employment and personal income in arts and crafts woul,d increase.. Future employment is expected to remain at current levels or increase slightly (10) Agricul ture (a) Present Status - One small vegetable farm presently exists in the Haines area. Summer temperatures,and precipitation levels make Haines a better farming area than much of Southeastern Alaska. (b) Future Outlook According to soils information contained in this study the.Haines area is not a prospect for major farming efforts. However, some excellent land does exist, and development R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _110- of additional small scale operations is a future possibility. Land Use:Planning.should conside,r that,the best agricultural lands be,preserved and not'converted to other uses unless absolutely necessary. (11) Gas Pipeline (a) Present Status -'There has been much discussion of the possible use,of,the Hain;es-;-Fairbanks:'8-inch pipeline as 6 route for North Slope natural gas. 'Use of-the corridor for a new line is also an object of discussion@.'. the 25-year-old line is not in use and is reported to be in need of at least some repair. However the corridor is of most,value and the cost of line renovation vs.@new l1ne con- struction;may not be a deciding factor in line"location. There are several gas pipeline routes under consideration and the most serious routes are along the trans-Alaska oil pipeline corridor to Valdez or branching off to Cordova. Another route is through Canada to the Midwest and still another would parallel the Alaska Highway through Canada. No major firm or consortium has proposed a Haines route. Yet the facts that a corridor exists, a road adjacent to the corridor, tank farm facilities and a deep water port exist, keeps Haines in the running as a possible gas pipeline terminus or distribution point for Southeast Alaska. A processing plant would be part of the port terminal complex for a gas line. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) (b) Future Outlook - The simple fact that the Haines route is not one of the more prominent alternatives being promoted gives it only a distant chance of becoming the gas pipeline terminus. If Haines were selected it would be in the fairly near future and within the planning period covered in this report. Were the Alaska Highway route selected it would present the possi bility for tapping the line,,at Haines Junction for distri- bution to Haines and Southeast Alaska'.. Finally, if the Alaska Highway route were s elected, Haines would receive considerable transshipment activity during the con- struction stage. A trans-Alaska route would create minor tran.sportation activity'similar to that caused by the trans- Alaska'oil pipeline construction. C. P0PqLATI,QN FORECAS TS FOR 1980.AND 1985 The main task of the economic forecaster is assessing the probability of future events which affect the economic,base (and consequently the population dynamics) of a community. In the case of Haines, the con- cern is with questions such as: "how probable is it that the Klukwan iron ore deposit will be exploited?", how probable is it that there will be lumber mill activity in the future?", "how probable it it that tourism will become a viable year round industry?", and "how probable is it that a fish processing operation will be started?" These are examples of the evaluations made after investigating each of the major sources of economic c hange in Haines. Taken all together these assessments combine to form a picture of what is reasonable to expect for the future of Haines. R. W. PAVI.TT. AND ASSOCIATES.. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) 112 A range of projections is deve-loped based on those things.which could reasonably-be expected to happen- The high..proj.ection of population and.emplgyment assumes that most of the things which could reasonably happen actually will. The low projection assumes that only a few of those things will,actually occur. What.actually.will happen is most likely to be.,somewhere between the low.and the high projection. Economic,forecastingis not an.exact scJence. It is based on the best information.we have at the time., and if we doan intelligent, thorough job of looking at current information,and its. background, we should be able to make reasonable future projections which will provide general.guidance to, people, planning for the,future of their community. (1) Reasons for Changes in Haines.' POPUldtiOn and Employment Three factors which tend to impact changes in the,community,'S... population are analyzed for Haines as follows: (a) Natural Increase , which is simply births minus deaths. For ,example;,between 1970 and 1975 there were 152 births,and 70 deaths for a net natural increase of,82 persons in the Haines im census district. This accounted for only 14.5% of the total fncrease.of,565 persons according to Department of,Labor population estimates. (b) Economic Change results in changes, in the amount of employ- ment available in an area and consequently impacts the population. This is by far the most important factor in population change and has accounted for.,85.5% of the change.since 1970. There have been R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES.. INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -113- several sources of economic change since 1970 and these are: increased timber industry activity (until 1975); increased ferry system traffic and service; increased state budgets which result in state employment and public works constr uction as well as revenue sharing in local government; record salmon catches and prices in Lynn Canal; increased tourism (Alaskans, Canadians and Americans); Native Claims Act per capita cash distribution, and Tlingit-Haida housing program; and the side effects of the trans- Alaska pipeline construction on freight traffic, and as an employ- ment source for Hainesites. (c) "Lifestyle" is another cause of--@'population change; one which is not really measurable in terms of statistics. We know that people must have income to live, so lifestyle is not totally independent from*economf@ cs. Yet it is an important factor when we try to explain population -loss or gain in the area.' for example, the Haines area is analyzed strictly from an economic standpoint, it would be reasonable to predict a major exodus of population with the closure of both mills which employed over 200 persons in milling and related operations. Yet, this is not entirely so. Many persons prefer living in Haines and will do so almost regardless of economic conditions. They will live on less money, change jobs, work out of town, fish, colleCt unemployment, or hold several temporary or part-time jobs over a period of time. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -114- In other words, many people 's lifest yle in Haines is the dominant. motive for residing there; not their occupation. If we assumed all mill workers and their dependents woul'd move, we would be making the incorrectLassumption that their occupations were the primary reasons for-living in Haines in the first place. While many mill workers will leave and have already left, a significant proportion will stay and simply' change the ir source of income in some manner. Likewise, in good times when more and better paying jobs become available, many are taken by residents of the area who are "trading up" from part-time or lower paying jobs, unemployment, out of town work and so forth. This explains why gains in employment ha.ve not reflected'as high a gain in population asI one would expect from past economic growth. Lifestyle, then, is a major factor which cushions the effect of economic ups and downs in the Haines area. (2) Historic Population Trends The population of the Haines area has s hown substantial upward growth since the 1960 census. During this period, two Decennial U.S. Censuses have been conducted that provide a benchmark for analysis. The 1960 Census shows a total of 875 persons in the Haines area. By 1970 this figure had grown to 1,504, an increase of 71.9%. This increase occurred primarily as a result of extensive expansion of the timber industry in the area. T his growth approximated an annual rate R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -115- of 5.6% for the 10 year period. Continued and increased growth occurred between the 1970 Census of 1,504 persons and the July 1, 1975 Alaska Department of Labor estimate of 2,069 persons. This 37.6% growth was equivalent to a 6.5% annual rate or nearly 1% more than the annual rate between 1960 and 1970. The period 1960 to 1975 shows a 136.5% total growth or about 5.9% per year. Table 15 summarizes historical growth rates. TABLE 15 Haines Historical Growth Rates Years Annual-Increase 1960-1975- 5.9% 1960-1970 5.6 1970-1975 6.5 The Haines OEDP Report dated March 1975 estimat es a city population of 1,366 and an area population of 1,980. This compares favorably to the Alaska Department of Labor estimate of 2,069 for July 1, 1975 and may be closer to the actual 1975 population. A breakdown of the 1970 Census showing the distribution of population in the Haines area can be seen in the first table on the following page. The Appendix to this study contains an analysis of the Haines community planning area population with respect to age, sex and race character- istics. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -116- 1970 Census - Haines Area Haines City 463 Port Chilkoot 220 Haines Outskirts 442 TOTAL CITY AREA 1,125 Klukwan 103 Terminal Reservations 50 F Outlying Areas 226 TOTAL,HAINES DISTRICT 1,504 Source: U.S. Census 1970. The Haines population for each year since 1960 is estimated in the Teft hand column of Table 16. This gives us a year by year look at the growth of Haines in recent times. TABLE 16 Haines Population Estimates 1960-1975 Total Skagway Lynn Canal- Haines Yakutat Icy Straits 1960 875 2,070 2,945 J961 639 3,079 -2,718 1962 7551 2,088 2,843 1963 901 2,097 2,998 1964 1,004 2,106 3,110 1965 1,066 2,115 3,172 1966 1,070 2,124 3,194 19b7 1,233 2,133 3,366 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -117- TABLE 16 (continued) Total Skagway Lynn Canal- Haines Yakutat Icy Straits 1968 1,268 2,142 3,410 1969 1,469 2,151 3,620 1970 1,504 2,157 3,661 1971 1,637 2,144 3,781 1972 1,766 2,121 3,887 1973 1,902 2,205 4,107 1974 2,054 2,476 4,530 1975 2,069 2,732 4,801 Source: Alaska Department of Labor, Current'Population estimates by Census Division 1960-1975. Note: - Population estimates for the years 1961-1969 for Haines and Skagway-Yakutat are derived from Lynn Canal-Icy Straits total as follows: Skagway-Yakutat increase of 93 from 1960 to 1970 census was -prorated-over@'the period. The-total for each year was then subtracted from the Department of Labor estimate for total Lynn Canal-Icy Straits with the remainder being Haines' population. (3) Estimating Present Population The population growth and employment opportunities were all increasing during the period of 1960 to 1975 as all the data shows. At the begin- ning of 1976 however, a drastic event occurred in the Haines area that will have a significant effect on future population and employment projections. Both of the major employers, that is the two sawmills, shut down operations. The consequence of this event, in the absence R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -118- of other employment opportunities, is to bring a halt to-the growth rate. In fact, an out-migration occurred that will have a dampening effect on future projections. Employment data for the present from the Average Annual Employment F Survey is used to estimate present population. Historically the ratio between population and employment in Haines has varied between about 2.8 and 3.4 persons for every job. The 2.8 persons per job is from 1970 when times were good and the 3.4 is from 1960 when the economy was not as good. On this basis, it is assumed that 3.5 persons per Job applies to the present... a change reflecting less employment than in 1975 when the ratio was 3.3. @By estimating 1976 average annual employment to be 561 including 40 pipeline jobs (down from 633 in 1975), and then multiplying by 3.5 persons per job, we arrive at a.1976 population estimate for the Haines area of 1,964. Based on local observation and interviews, this figure appears reasonable. There has been.some population loss in recent months, but not a great amount. Table 17 shows the 1976 population estimate. TABLE 17 Population and Employment in Haines- 1960-1976 Pop./Emp. Population Employment Ratio 1960 875 256 est. 3.4 .1965 1,066 est. 347 est. 3.1 1970 1,504 542 est. 2.8 1975 2,069 593 3.5 1975 2,069 633 (pipeline) 3.3 1976 1,964 est. 521 3.8 1976 1,964 est. 561 (pipeline) 3.5 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) _119- Note: - The 1976 employment survey included 43 persons living in Haines but working on North Slope oil development projects in April. An average of 40 is assumed for all of 1976. The effect of the shutdown of the two mills was to reduce average annual employment (basic employment) by 72 persons. This has also had its effect on population. Using a 3.5 ratio,indicates a population of 1,964 or a decrease in population of just over 100 persons. It is not expected that there-will be a long term decline, as many persons will attempt to stay in the Haines area and take lower paying jobs or work out of town. However, wi th the completion of the trans- Alaska pipeline, those out of town jobs wil I become fewer, and it may force a further reduction in population. In projecting employment opportunities, it was not expected that all timber employment would be lost, but that only one mill would operate in the future and while both may be closed for most of 1976, one is expected to reopen in the near future. (4) Future Population Projections The 1964 Haines and-Port Chilkoot Comprehensive Plan projected a 1980 popul-ation range of 2,850 for an extreme low and 6,240 for an extreme high with 3,600 as.the most probable figure. The growth projecied was ,probably over optimistic, as the likely event appears to be near or below the low projection. The low projection however, is fairly close for having been made more than 10 years ago. The difficulty in projecting small numbers is that. one significant event can completely change the whole outlook. For example, development of the Klukwan iron ore would substantially change R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -120- .the population projections. On the same basis, c.losure of the Haines Cu toff would have a dramatic adverse effect on future population. It must be remembered that all population estimates are based on what is known today, and can be greatly affected by unseen future events. Three methods can be used to project Haines population and employment: --Projecting population based on the historic growth rates. --Projecting population based on Haines' population relationship to the regional population of Southeastern Alaska. --Projecting population based on expected future employment in the Haines a.rea. The first method results in high forecasts because the historical growth rates were calculated during periods of fairly rapid growth. We feel it is unlikely that these growth rates will be sustained through 1985. These forecasts will form the high side of our projections. After examining all the factors which could cause growth, it appears that Haines will experience a slower rate of growth than occurred during the 1960-75 period. Based on historic growth rates applied to the 1976 population figure, this first method results in a 1980 population of 2,443 to 2,527; and a 1985 population of 3,208 to 3,461. Table 18 shows the results of projecting historic growth rates: R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -121- .TABLE 18 Population Projections Based on Haines Historic Annual.-Growth Rates @1977-1985 1960-70 1960-75 1970-75 Historic Rate 'Rate Rate 5.6% 5.9% 6.5% 1960 875 1965 1,066 1970 1,504 1975 2,069- 1976 1,964 1,964 1,964 1,964 Projected 1977 2,074 2j080 2,092 1978 2,190 2,203 2,228 1979 2,313 2,333 2,373 1980 2,443 2,471 2,527 1981 2, 580 2,617 2,691 1982 2,724 2,771 2,866 1983 2,877 2,934 3,052 1984 3,038. 3,107 3,250 1985 3,208 3,290 3,461 The second method used was based on the historic relationship of the Haines population to the population of Southeast Al.aska. The 1970 percentage of Haines' population to that of Southeast Alaska (3.5%) was R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -122- 4 used as an average because the 4.1% of the last few years was felt to be too high with the closure of the mills.@ The Alaska Department of Labor projects a total population of 661900 for the year 1980 in Southeast Alaska. If the 1970 relationship of 3.5% is applied, this results in a 1980 population of 2,342 for the Haines area, which falls into the same range as the previous projections. If we assume that Southeast Alaska will continue growing at the tame rate, our 1985 projection for Haines would be 3,104. Table 19 shows the past relationship between Haines and Southeast regional population plus projections for 1980 and 1985. TABLE 19 Population Projections Based on Haines Population as a Percent of Southeast Regional Population 1980-1985 Southeast Haines As A Alaska Percent Of. Historic Region Haines Southeast 1960 35,403 875 2.5% 16 1970 42,565 1,504. 3.5 1971 43,088 1,637 3.8 1972 44,475 1,766 4.0 1973 46,417 1,902 4.1 1974 50,232 2,054 4.1 1975 .50,438 2,069 4.1 Projected 1980 66,900 2,342 3.5 FHai 1985 88,700 3,104 3.5 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -123- Source: 1960-1975 Alaska Department of Labor. 1980 Southeast is Labor estimate. 1985 Southeast assumes same growth for.1980-85 as estimated for 1975-80. The third method of forecasting uses'the relationship between population and employment. The projections developed here are intended to provide a low side to our series of estimates of futurepopulation. In this projection we assume that no additional',economic development occurs to 1980. Employment will remain at the 1976 level except that pipeline work will cease in 1977, causing a loss of 40 jobs from the 1�76 level of 561 employed. Thus, 1980 employment is placed at 521. Using our maximum ratio of 3.5 people for every job, this projects to a population of 1,824 in 1980; (a loss of 140 persons from 1976). Employment changes more rapidly than population, which must be con- sidered when projecting population based on employment. From 1960 to 1970, for example, a period of increase in the Haines economy, employ- ment rose at a rate slightly over 8% per year while,population rose by only 5.6% per year. We are anticipating the 1980-85 period to be one of growth for the Haines area. If the 1960-70 employment growth rate of 8% is projected, employment will total 765. Assuming the population/emplo,yment ratio will drop to a more normal 3.0 by 1985, the popu'lati6n would.be 2,295 persons. Table 20 shows thes'e'projections of population based on employment. R. W. PAVITT.AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -124- TABLE 20 @Population and Employment Projections Based on No Additional Economic Development to 1980, Moderate Development to 1985 Historical, Population Employment Ratio 1960 875 256 3.4 1965 1,066 .347 3.1 1970 1',-504 542 2'. 8 1975 2iO67 633 3.3 1976 .1,964 3.5a Projected 1977 1,964 561 3. 5' 1978 --- --- --- 1979 --- --- 1980 T,824 521b 3.5 1985 2,295- d 3.Oc a. Assumes people-are reluctant to move, and will stay as long as possible without additional employment. b. No pipeline workers. c. Assumes population/employment ratio will decrease to become more in line with past trends. d. Assumes 8% employment growth rate, 1980-85. (5) Population Projection Summary The closure of the two mills has had a serious dampening effect on future population growth in the Haines area. J R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -125- The results of the 1976 employment survey shows a definite decrease in employment from the 1975 level. The longer the mills are closed, the more population will be lost as workers are forced to move to seek other employment opportunities. Several methods of projecting population were used and the results show a wide range depending on which assumptions are accepted. Historic growth rates were applied to the 1976 population, as.estimated from the employment survey. These projections, ranging from 2,443 to 2,527 for 1980, and from 3,208 to 3,461 for 1985 assume that there will be no change in the historic growth rate in the Haines area. Since the.closure of the two sawmills, however, this growth rate cannot be expected to apply in the absence. of other employment. The next step was to attempt to project future employment based on the 1976 survey. The survey shows 561 persons employed in 1976, with 40 of those being pipeline workers. This employment level was expected to continue through 1977 but would decrease by 40 after 1977 because of completion of the pipeline. Without these jobs, and with no replacements, the 1980 population', based on that level of employment, would be 1,824 persons. This establishes a broad range of population for 1980 of between 1,824 and 2,443 persons. Another method shown earlier which projects Haines as a percentage of Southeast Alaska.population, calculates a 1980 population of 2,324, and a 1985 level of 3,104. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -126- With the high and low range now established, any increase in employment opportunities such as the opening of one:of the mills or some new operations will tend to increase the population level. From the low range, for example, the addition of 50 employees would cause the 1980 population to be approximately 2,000 persons. The lowest 1985 population projection is 2,295 based on a 1980 base population of 1,824 and an 8% employment growth from 1980 to 1985. The highest projection is 3,461, which would be the population if the 6.5% annual growth rate for 1970-75 is applied to the 1976 population estimate. The difficulty with these projections is that one major event can pro- duce dramatic changes because the size of the total population is small. These figures provide the best estimates available from existi.ng information. TABLE 21 Summary of Population Projections Percent of Historic Growth Southeast Population/ Rate Method Region Employment 5.6% 5.9% 6.5% Method Method 1976 1,964 1,964- 1,964 .1,964 1,964 1980 2,443 2,471 2,527 2,342 1,824 1985 3,208 3,290 3,461 3,104 2,295 R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -127- Employing a balance of these three methods, it is our considered opinion that the most likely population for Hai'nes will fall in-the ranges shown below for 1980 and 1985: 1980 - 2,050 (low) to 2,250 (high) 1985 - 2,500 (low) to 3,000 (high) At best, population projection for a small community, even for periods of less than 10 years, is more of-an art than a science. Even so, there are some indicators that will produce a range of projections that is, at least, in the ballpark; and the conclusions of this section as to the 1980 and 1985 ranges have utilized the most reliable of these indicators. Beyond 10 years, population projection is neither an art nor a science, and cannot claim even the dignity of an educated guess. The accelera- tion of social, economic and technological change in the world today is so rapid that one simply cannot foresee with any degree of certainty events 15 or 20 years hence. Nevertheless, a requirement of the con- tract for Phase I planning services calls for population projections to 1986 and 1996, in order to facilitate longer range capital improve- ment considerations, and for the purpose of complying with that regula- tion, the following range of projections, which constitute an adjusted extrapolation of the three methods employed in the 1980 and 1985 pro- jectibns is offered: 1986 - 2,600 (low) to 3,100 (high) 1996 - 3,700 (low) to 4,200 (high) R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -128- III. ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION This chapter of the plan provides a discussion, analysis and evaluation of the factual matters researched and presented in Chapters 1. and II. It points out the needs,.deficiencies,.issues and opportunities of the Haines area, and pro- vides direction to the development of Phase II of the Haines Comprehensive Plan. The nat ural environment of the Haines area is conducive to a broad range of human activities. The physical location of the community provides spectacular scenery, and the magnificent combination of waterfront, mountains, glaciers, fiords and forests that is unique to Southeast Alaska. The soils of the area are basically satisfactory for building con- struction purposes; although prudent engineering practice calls for soil and foundation material testing to be accomplished prior to de- sign and construction of substantial structures. Neither the Soil Conservation Service nor the University of Alaska Agricultural Ex- tension Service share the enthusiasm of many local people with re- spect to the potential for economically feasible agricultural opera-: tions in the Haines area. Yet traditional and recent successful ex- periences seem to confi m that while the Haines area is certainly not a verdant and fertile valley, small-scale gardening and specialty ag- ricultural production can be pursued with moderate success. Clearly, the land use planning process must recognize even this limited poten- tial, and carefully examine the need for protection of appropriate areas from incompatible exploitation. The Haines area lies in an active earthquake zone; and while the FHa- community has not suffered a damaging quake in modern times, the po- tential for such an occurrence should be kept in mind, and sound R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -129- engineering practices observed with regard to major construction or public works projects. Within the City of Haines, population density is found to be about 575 persons per square mile, assuming a current City population of approximately 1,300. Considering that the density for the Haines Borough is estimated to be 0.75 persons per square mile, the City, which. contains about 2/3 of the Borough's population, is obviously the.established base of human settlement. The population density of a community is an indicator of the nature of the town... literally where it falls on a scale that might range from a sparsely populated rural hamlet to a crowded urban center. In the case of Haines, both the.density and the analysis of land use indicate an active small urban area that Contains ample space for growth and development without sacrifice of its pleasant small town characteristics. The total population of the area is not large enough to attract major trade.outlets which depend on high volume sales, but is suffi- cient to sustain local retail outlets providing a fairly comprehen- sive range of goods and services. A land use plan contemplated as a major element of the Haines Com- prehensive Plan (Phase II) will address the task of balancing exist- ing patterns of community land use with the goals and objectives of Hainesites in the preparation of a practical guide to the growth and development of the community. Evaluation of the land status shows a very favorable balance of pub- lic and private land ownershi-p in both the Ci ty and the Haines Commun- ity Planning area, indicating a broad range of development potential that will be complementary to and compatible with existing and proposed R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -130- governmental projects such as the Chilkat State Park and the enlarge- ment of the Haines Small Boat Harbor. The housing in Haines, considering the age of the community and the marginal economic conditions that have prevailed over much of its history, is in surprisingly sound condition, with less than 5% of the 349 dwelling units found to be so deficient as to be considered uninhabitable. The units classed as substandard constitute over 22% of the inventory, but improvement is likely to be directly proportion- ate to the state of the local economy, as maintenance of a safe and decent home is normally a high priority for most people. Investiga- tion of the various federal and/or state programs that can be of assistance in residential rehabilitation efforts is also an indicated element of Phase II of the planning program. With respect to community facilities and services; although many de- ficiencies were noted and will be discussed here, the range and qual- ity of facilities and services provided is outstanding for a community the size of Haines, and indicates that the City's public officials have seriously attempted to meet the needs of the people of the community. Phase II will provide a Community Facilities Plan which will relate the needs to the City's overall revenues and fiscal ability to make improvements to its facilities and services. City and Borough administrative office space is adequate for the present operations. The Police and Fire Departments, however, are operating under crowded and inefficient conditions. Research should be conducted with respect to the feasibility of a municipal building to accomodate these public safety functions and the administrative offices in a central location. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -131- The Public Works Department has broad responsibilities for mainten- ance-and operation of the sewer andwater untilities, as well as maintenance and construction of roads, parks, cemeteries,'drainage structures and the boat harbor. The needs of this function for additional vehicle housing, covered storage space for materials, and a secure storage space for materials, and a secure storage structure for valuable equipment should be addressed in the Community Facilities Plan. The inflow and infiltration problems currently being experien- ced by the sewer facility will require careful engineering, and most likely a major rehabilitation effort to,sections of the old sewer collection 1ines to correct. The privately-owned electric utility plant and equipment, although old, are maintained in good condition, and the utility is currently adequate to serve the power needs of the community. For several, years, the Schnabel Lumber Company,has been working on the construc- tion of a wood-fired steam/electric generating facility at its Lutak Inlet Mill-with an output sufficient to supply the electrical power requirements of the entire community@, This generator, Waddition to ameliorating the fossil fuel consumption of the diesel units now in use, would serve to lessen the problems currently experienced by the lumber company in meeting air quality standards. Haines Light an-d Power would, under such an arrangement, purchase power from Schnabel Lumber Company for distribution to its customers, and would maintain its generators as "stand-by" capacity. The current depressed condition of the timber industry and consequent shut-down of the mill makes the completion and viability of this unique power system less probable at this time, but research into this and other alternative power sources should continue, as development of the downtown commercial area will be inhibited by the current location, noise and industrial appearance of the in-town power plant. Reloca- tion of the present plant should be a long-range objective of Haines. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -132- The new sanitary landfill site is a well planned facility, and should adequately serve the community for 5 10 years before expansion will be required. rhe over 10,000 volumes available at the Haines Public Library con- stitutes a good collection for a community of this size, but the physical space used by the library has become totally inadequate to serve the needs of' the users. The Sheldon Museumt with its excellent collections and enthusiastic volunteers is one of Haines most impresssive cultural fac-ilities. Actual construction of the new building for the Museum is now under way and should continue to enjoy broad and enthusiastit community support. The small but efficient police force does a capable job of meeting its responsibilities. The depressed state of the local-economy does not make it likely that an increase in personnel strength will be a current priority of the City, but the need for future expansion of the police function-and the relocation of its office and jail facility to a central municipal building should be a consideration in community facilities planning. The Haines Volunteer Fire Department has long been one of Southeast Alaska's most highly respected fire-fighting organizations. While two of the pump trucks are 14 and 17 years old and will eventually need replacement, the real pressing need of the Fire Department at this time is for more adequate fire station space for parking and maintenance of vehicles and storage of equipment. The devel'opment of a new fire station facility, perhaps in a combined public safety and administrative building as discussed previously, should be a high priority item in the Community Facilities Plan. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -133- School system facilities are all in sound condition, and except for an expressed need by school officials for additional office and storage space, and improvements to the High School heating and ventilating system, are adequate for present educational needs. A vocational education facility is desired to expand the scope of ser- vices offered by the educational system, and such a structure, along with the'athletic and track areas currently being developed, would essentially use up the*balance of the 16 acre in-town site owned by the Haines Borough. A broadly-based Community Education Program is currently bei ng developed. Such programs in other communities have resulted in many benefits in addition to making school facilities more available to"non-students in the community. These benefits have been particularly evident in improved communications among people in a town which, in turn, works toward a better and more cohesive commu- nity. An unusually active group of cultural, religious and civic organiza- tions serves the community well, and, adds much to the quality of life -in Haines. Recreational facilities opportunities are another outstanding feature in the Haines area, and show evidence of participation by many sectors of the community. Good advantage is being taken of the scenic setting and historic aspects of Haines in the development of parks and trails, and the upcoming work on the proposed Chilkat State Park will further enhance the open-spa ce use opportunitiesfor residents and visitors alike. Besides being esthetically pleasing additions to a community, scenic trails, adequate camping locations and pleasant parks are a major factor in'attracting and retaining visitor interes .t and desire to return. Haines, as a marine/surface transportation hub, should take maximum advantage of the opportunities created by the many trav- elers that visit each year. The City has adopted a plan for the R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, I.NC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -134- development of recreation areas and connecting trails, and the coordi- nation of this@ plan'with the plans of other agencies and groups will be one of the tasks involved in the preparation,of the Community Facilities' Plan. The recent departure of the Dentist from Haines leaves a gap in the otherwise impressive health services locally available, and it is hoped that the recruiting efforts currently underway will shortly remedy this deficiency. The Public Health Nurse has stated the need fo,rlsome additional equipment; and various members of the community have expressed concern.for a more active and regular mental health pfogram than is presently possible considering that the Re- gional Psychologist visits the community-only on a monthly basis. The 6.5 acres of developed area in the City Cemetery is felt to be adequate for at least another 10 years. Both the Haipes Cemetery on Sawmill Road, and the Historical Cemetery in Tlingit Park are in need of restoration, clean-up, landscaping and adjustment of headstones to facilitate mowing as well as more regular maintenance. Te lephone service, both local and lon g distance appears to be ade- quate for the present, and has excess capacity sufficient to accomo- date community expansion. The Chilkat Valley News is a weekly (gen- erally) newspaper that does an excellent job of covering local news and providing a forum for the discussion and debate of community issues. Many local persons have expressed the desire for the paper to be published more regularly; that is, closer to the "weekly" than to the "g enerally" stated in themasthead, but the paper is well re- spected statewide as well as locally. the Haines Shoppers Guide also helps to fill the desire for news of local events and upcoming pro- grams. Although the Haines Network Television, through its network R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -135- television programming and Juneau radio statfon rebroadcasting does a good job of keeping Hainesites aware of regional, statewide, national and worldwide news and current events,;there is an obvious need for additional dissemination of local news, issues and "gossip" than is currently available. Much discussion has.been conducted with regard to the establishmentof a small FM public-broadcast radio station in Haines to achieve the frequently stated objective of improving local communications. It,is hoped.that further pursuit of this practicalidea will be incorporated both into the Community Education.Program and the Phase.II planning program so that expedi- tious deci sions can be made and the necessary actions taken. In general, the surface transportation (road) network i.s in good condition and adequate to handle present community and traveling public needs,, and the Highway Department and City Public Works personnel do a generally competent job of snow clearance and main- tenance, of the.area's roads. Phase II of the planning program whould address the question of re-routin,g of the Haines.Cutoff High- way on the U.S. side before paving in order to reduce grades and make the.route more attractive to freight carriers. The protected deepwater characteristics of the Lutak Inlet give Haines the potential of being the finest port in Southeast Alaska. The nego- tia.tions regarding acquisition of the Haines.Dry Cargo Dock (Lutak .d.oc,k facility) appear to be coming to. fruition at this time, and will do much to enhance-the community's opportunities in marine transporta- tion activity. Once under local control, conside ration should be given to fender replacement as well as the necessary dredging to increase the 30 to 35 foot depth of water now available.,at the dock face at low tide. Phase II will address the feasibility of further implementing the.recommendations recently made in the Port Development Slydy. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC.'- Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -136- Fishing fleet and small boat activity has increased dramatically in the Haines-area in re cent years,'and the small boat harbor has become totally inadequate to serve the needs of the cornmunity and transient watercraft. Work 'is currently underway on a new breakwater and dred- ging project which will effectively triple the area available for floats and other facilities in the harbor. The Division of Waters and Harbors of the Alaska Department of Public Works is currently de- signing the layout of improvements within the protected area; the con- struction of which will be dependent on the availability Of funding. When completed, the Haines Small Boat Harbor will be a modern and adequate facility. One program which need not await-massive state or federal qrant funding, however, is a general cleanup of the Portage Cove waterfront area. Such an undertaking could be accomplished by a combination of civic organiza- tions, volunteers and City forces and equipment, and would go a long way toward upgrading the visual impact of this naturally beautiful area for-residents and visitors alike. The Haines Airport, while well located and situated on an adequate tract of land is actually not an airport, but rather a landing facility. The air traffic is steadily increasing and the potential for attracting airborne tourists would be greatly enhanced by upgrading of the airstrip facilities.. Runway lighting, construction of an adequate terminal buil- ding with adjacent parking, separation of landside and airside traffic ways and preparation of an overall airport development,plan are matters that-should be actively pursued with the State Division of Aviation. Much of the economic analysis and evaluation is contained within the body of the Economic Base Study as it pertains to each sector of industry within the Haines economy. Several items of special economic interest, however, @eserve particular mention: R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) A fish processing facility in the Haines area appears to be one of the most promising economic development prospects. There,are several fac- tors favoring such a development including interest expressed by a major fisheries fi m. Local par ticipation and interest could aid in the establishment of such a facility. Interest has also been expressed locally in a fish hatchery in the upper Lynn Canal area. While the runs in the Chilkat and Chilkoot drainages .have not deteriorated sig- nificantly, anything that would aid in maintaining good levels of re- turning,salmon to the@area-would naturally enhance the continued via- bility of the Haines fishery and should be encouraged. Tourist -traffic will increase, but the economic benefit will be largely dependent.on.the actions taken by local businesses to provide.tours, services and amenities attractive to the various types of tourists and travelers. Tourism in Klukwan has.traditionally been i.nhibited by the location.of the U.S. Customs and Immigration station in Haines. Traffic is hesitant to stop between the CanadiAn-border.and the station because of Customs regulations. This situation will.be corrected with construction of the new.station at the border. Thus, tourism could be more@significant if the people of Klukwan wish,to encourage visitors. The transportation industry is so diverse that it is affected by vir- tually every economic activity. It will continue to grow from influ- ences such as gas pipe.line activity, timber, tourism, timber, fish processing, freight and other activities. Local control and planning of waterfront facilities can aid in the development of thi-s important. sector of the Haines economy. It now appears that the possibility of an Alaska Highway natural. gas pipeline route is coming under more serious consideration in Washington, D.C. The community should stay carefully aware of@this matter in order to plan for construction impact and development possibilities that might occur were an Alaska Highway route eventually selected. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -138- IV. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The purpose of this chapter is to provide an abstract of the.,citizen participation that has been a part of Phase I; and from the input of local citizens, to articulate a set of goals and,objectives for Haines that will provi-de direction to the preparation of the Comprehen- sive Plan in Phase II of'the planning process. F One,of the most important aspects of the Phase I project involved the community questionnaires; the 3 public mee'tings; the establishment of 3 study groups which devoted many hours of discuss-ion and deliberation to the topics of economic development, social development and community services; and-the conversations with community leaders and ordinary citizens ... in short; the gaining of a degree of insight as to what the local people want to happen in Haines. The three volunteer Study-Groups met for a total'of almost 200 It person/hours", and discussed a broad range of physical, social, eco- nomic and environmental issues that bear on the future growth and de- velopment of Haines. Some of the ideas discussed involved topics of immediate and practical application, while others were more esoteric and concerned with long-range future potential. Each,is 'equally val- uable to the study, however, as they represent a cross-section of opinion in Haines, and an important indication of the types of policy direction that the local people desire to see their ele cted offic ials pursue for their community- The following is a brief summary (by major topic) of the discussicns, addressed at the 8 individual meetings of the groups: Education - Th e community education concept was advanced as well as the need for vocational education geared to community eMDloyment R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC.. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) @-139- opportunities; the possibilities.of a skill center; a municipal po- lice academy; a !folk.school" with respect to arts and crafts*, and an increased effort in day-care for pre-school-children. Transportation Discussion included a broad range of transportation issues ranging from the development of a.snow removal plan to the ad- vantages that might.accru.e to Haines as a result of an express (Haines to Seattle) State ferry run. Also deliberated were such topics as an lion-call" bus service for local transportation, charter boat and lightering services, airport improvements and expansi.on, year-round trails4 and local control'of the major dock facility at Lutak Inlet. Fisheries,.- In addition to:dis-cussion of the pros and'cons of 1imited entry, discussion included questions of the feasibility of a hatchery, a cooperative cold storage and a fish,processing facility. Suggested also.was a local tax on non-resident.commercial fishermen. While timber and mi ning were discussed, the present uncertainties re- garding these industries lead the study group to conclude that the market.con.ditions and@other factors impacting these economic sectors were not matters that could be altered by local action.. Tourism received agreat amount of discussion, and included a number of attitudinal- suggestions that could hopefully-improve the image of Haines as a pleasant place to visit., These comments involved town cleanup and spruce-up activities., friendly and hospitable treatment. of visitors and adoption@of anvoverall "theme" that would.enhance visitor interest in the.community. Other topics touched on the Chi,lk at State.Park, local bus tours, -crafts workshops, Chilkat Dancers, a "living.vil.lage", entertainment, and other attractions and amenities that might heighten the appeal,of Haines to.tours and individual travelers. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -140- Energy and petroleum were well discussed from a number of varying viewpoints. Interest ranged from exploration of alternative elec- trical power sources (including tidal power, hydro, wind power, and Schnabel Lumber's unique wood-fired steam/electric possibility) to expressions of support for an Alaska Highway route for Prudhoe Bay natural gas, which might open up several possibilities for Haines through utilization of the military pipeline corridor, tank farm and POL dock facilities. Health and social services discussions; besides expressing concern for recruiting a dentist for Haines, stated the need for better men- tal health programs, including marriage, family, alcohol and drug counseling; a "crisis line", and a preventative medicine program. Library deliberations indicated a desire for the Borough, under its educational power, to.assume responsibility for library services in order that the facility might be expanded and coordinated with the other library services available. Broadening of service to include satellite facilities and/or a bookmobile was also suggested along with the desire to have records, films, tapes, microfilm and other media more readily available. Discussions that related to the Museum and historic preservation en- couraged community support of the new building, and better utilization of the excellent collections contained in the facility. Within this general topic, thought was also given to the creation of a "historic district" which might include the Mission property, Tlingit Park, Fort William H. Seward and the intervening waterfront areas. Restoration and development of the historic Dalton Trail came in for discussion, as well as identification and restoration of key archeological sites, cannery properties and historic cemeteries. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. 1NC- Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -141- Communications discussions centered on the need to keep local people informed as to what was happening in the community, and included suggestions regarding a community bulletin board, local informational programming on the cable television channels, addition of a local radio channel to the system, and the need for more frequent publica- tion of the local newspaper. Educational t.v., use of the Canadian satellite and a civil defense radio network were also topics of dis- cussion, but therecurring theme that ran through each of the study groups deliberati-ons favored the establishment of a small FM public broadcasting facility inflaines for the.dissemination of local news and announcements, and the' forum.it would provide for discussion and -debate of local issues as-well as general interest non-commercial radio programming. Native affairs discussion brought out the.-need for improved communi- cations between the Native and=n4ative 'communities. The potential for the community-education@program to assist in building this "bridge" and the importance of the older Tlingit people passing on their skills, crafts and traditions were major topics of discussion, as was the de- sirability of more active Native participation in civi,c and political affairs in Haines.: Deliberation of the subject of trade and services revealed concern over the continuing shortages of dairy products and fresh produce ,during the tourist season, and included discussion oftooperative buying ventures., and the need in the school system for courses in retailing and distributive trades. Also touched on in these discuss- ions.was the question of desirability of gift shops or outlets for local arts And crafts work being located in the proximity of cruise ship docking or lightering facilities4', R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -142- Recreation was discussed in considerable depth by two of the study groUDS with a host of ideas emerging including a clearinghouse for the 'krade, sale or loan.of sports and recreational equipment, and- some improved method of desseminating information on recreation ac- tivities in the community. Interest- was high in develooment of the- trail system for year-round use. and a-center for winter youth activi- ties. Social and recreational programs for the senior citizens was a.topic of discussion, as was the potential for community education to be effective-in devising programs of this.type including arts and crafts and a broad parks and recreation program., Protection of wild- .life habitat to maintain recreational quality-, the need for a youth hostel; scuba diving and the desire-for an indoor swimming pool. were the other subjects touched on in this broad-ranging discussion. In the field of kublic safety, crime prevention and the need for dis- patcher services; along wi-th the Fire Department's pressing need for vehicle and equipment.housing and storage, were the principal.topics of discussion. The need for additional fire hydrants was also stated. Water and sewer facilities as well as solid waste disposal were topics of discussion, and brought forth suggestions for energy conservation through use of methane gas; use of sewer sludge for fertilizer and other "recycling" ideas. Segregation of materials or incineration at the landfill site to reduce the volume of buried matter and to aid in recycling efforts was also deliberated. Community facilities discuss- ions also produced concern at the condition of the City Cemetery, and the desire for the development of a site plan for the facility as well as a general cleanup and landscaping program to be pursued'. Renewal of the Tlingit Park Historical Cemetery and other significant burial grounds was also addressed in this discussion. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensi ve Plan (Phase 1) -143- The desirability of home rule for the' City of Haines was the recurring theme of the discussions concerning local government. More efficient use of personnel, improvement of'the tax base and annexation of the tank farm and Lutak Inlet dock facilities were brought up in this dis- cussion, as was the need for Native representation on local governmen- tal bodies. An interesting suggestion was concerned with the develop- ment of a "file." ofspecial skills possessed by local citizens who might volunteer-to make their specialized knowledge.available to the City Council as a civic contribution from time to time as required; the intent being to make more knowledgeable public input available to the City government.. Goals and objectives are statements of needs, directions and desired trends that are Used to develop public policies, Plans and programs in a community. The definitions used in this study are as follows: GOALS - are broad, general statements of,desirable ends. They are targets, or ideals to work toward. OBJECTIVES - are more specific statements of intent. They es- tablish direction toward a goal, and are capable of achievement within a foreseeable time span. The citizen participation element of the,Phase I planning.program in- cluded 3 public meetings, 8 meetings of the study groups,, 3 Planning Commission work sessions, analysis of 45 completed community question- naires, and conversations with many local citizens. It is estimated that over 120 individual Haines residents participated in these delib- erations. The following planning goals and objectives a re felt to be the sum of the public input achieved during the citizen participation effort: COMMUNITY GOAL TO MAINTAIN AND ENHANCE THE QUALITY OF LIFE IN HAINES THAT MAKES THE COMMUNITY A GOOD PLACE TO LIVE. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -144- Economic Development GOAL A HEALTHY, VIABLE AND STABLE ECONIOMY OBJEECTIVES* 1. Achieve local control of the major port facilities 2.' Strengthen and encourage the tourism sector of the economy 3. Encourage the development of fish processing facilities 4. Investigate the feasibility of economically beneficial us es of locally available limestone and clay deposits 5. Develop a positive local position regarding an Alaska Highway natural gas pipeline route 6. Seek timber processing opportunities 7. Develop-a broader range of locally.available goods and services Social Development GOAL A GOOD COMMUNITY IN WHICH TO LIVE, WORK, PLAY AND RAISE FAMILIES OB JECTIVES* 1. Develop a strong and comprehensive community education program 2. Improve health care services 3. Assist and encourage preservation of the historical assets of the community, including Native culture and artifacts, Fort William Henry Seward, and the permanent home of the Sheldon Museum. 4. Encourage expansion of library facilities and services 5. Improve social relations between the N.ative and non-Native peoples 6. Assist and encourage arts, drama and music activities in Haines 7. Develop broader year-round recreational opportunities for all. age groups 8. Improve day-care facilities and services The numbers shown by the individual objectives are for convenience of discussion only, and DO NOT indicate any order of priority. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -145- Community Services GOAL A FULL RANGE'OF NECESSARY AND DESIRABLE COMMUNITY SERVICES OBJECTIVES* 1. Continue to improve public safety programs,facilities and services 2.. Improve and redevelop local.cemeteries- 3. Develop local-public-broadcast,radio 4. Encourage vocational education facilities and-programs 5. Work toward home-rule (governmental) status 6. Improve the water and sewer utilities 7. Maintain and continue to develop the parks/trails system 8. Seek increased efficiency and economy in local governmental operations Phase II of the planning program will continuethe public participation that provided the@basis of the.,se goals and ohjectives,and will further detail the objectives. Recommendations will include alternative policy determinations that the City.Council may consider which will be designed to work toward the accomplishment of these detailed objectives. It should be remembered that all sectors of.the community have a stake in and a respon.sibili.ty for the type of community that Haines will become in the 5 10 year period coming up. PhaseJI will make recommendations not.only to,the local governmental unit, but to the business community, civic organizations, special.interest groups and others that can assist in achieving the overall goal of making Haines_a good place to live. The numbers shown by the individual objectives are for convenience of discuss ion'only, and DO NOT indi cat6-any order of priority. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) @-146- V. GENERAL COMMENTS In the course of the Phase I study, several subjects were touched upon that are felt to be worthy of some additional mention. These matters are narratively discussed herein. Probably the greatest "need" found in Haines.is not physical, economic or environmental, but is the social need for a stronger "sense of commu- nity". Broad participation fn the Community Education Program, en- couraqement of civic organization assistance in project&such as water- front cleanup, museum construction, [email protected] restoration, etc. and continued efforts to improve communications between the Native and non-Native communities can help in developing,this overall civic con.- science.. Despite the fact that home rule status for the Haines Borough was de- feated in a recent referendum on the subject, much interest was in'di- cated during the course of this study for the City of Haines to achieve home rule status. This possibility should be thoroughly investigated, and should be one of the important areas addressed in Phase II of the planning program. The importance of the po tential of the Haines Cutoff Highway cannot be emphasized too strongly. The development by the,Canadian government of the Kluane National Park, and the establishment by Congress of the Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park, along with the scheduling of develop ment work in the proposed Chilkat State Park will open up a number of possibilities for maximizing the benefits of tourism in the Haines area. In addition to the attractiveness of a Parks Tour po- tential, the transportation sector of the Haines economy can look fo r- ward to continued development of mining activity in the Yukon, much of which will in the future find it more expedient to ship primary-processed R. W. PAVITT AND A SSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -147- mineral concentrates over the highway to the Port of Haines than going through Whitehorse and the narrow-guage railroad to Skagway. The building in which the library is housed has become totally in- adequate, and the Haines Borough should be urged to assume the re- sponsibility for the library under its educational power, and move to fully integrate the service into an areawide function. During the final Phase I public meeting, the subject of retirement of senior citizens in Haines was brought up as a possibility. A glance at the population analysis contained in the Appendix to this report will confi m'the fact that the tendency of older Aliskans.-to leave the state upon retirement is not as prevalent in Haines as in most Alaskan communities. Adoption of a positive community attitude to- wards visitors and travelers goes a long way towards impressing people with the friendliness of a town, and encourages thinking of the commu- nity as a nice place to spend ones retirement years. A"final comment ... Haines is a well-located commun'ity with a spectacular physical setting, a favorable natural environment, a wealth of cultural and historical attractions, and a nucleus of civic minded citizens. Desp ite the present depressed state of the local economy, the potential exists for a sound fisheries sector, an improved transportation and tourism sector, and other advances in the viability and stability of Haines' economic base. Enthusiasm alone will not achieve these goals, but working together to reach the objectives expressed in this report and agreeing on the policies that will emerge from the planning process will go a long way towards making Haines into the kind of community that it has the potential to become. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -148- APPENDICES Appendix 1 Analysis of Haines population data derived from the 1970 decennial Census and.State and University sources. Appendix 2 Maps.indicating.major faults and other lineaments for (a') the Haines area, and (b) S-outheastern Alaska. Appendix 3 Not available at the time of publication of this report; will consist of a detailed topographic map ofthe City of Haines. R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) APPENDIX 1 -149- The following table is interpolated from information contained in the U.S. Census Bureau PC(l)-B3 Alaska (General Population Characteristics report of the 1970 decennial Census for the Haines Census Division. This data covers Enumeration Districts 02,(Haines), 03 (Port Chilkoot), and 05 (Haines outskirts); the sum of which is basically equivalent to the Haines Community Planning Area. Not included are ED 04 (Eldred Rock, Letnikof Cove, Moose Valley, Pleasant Camp, Mosquito Lake, St. James Bay), ED 06 (Klukwan) or ED 07 (Terminal Reservation). Haines Community Planning Area Resident Age and Sex Characteristics; 1970 AGE MALE FEMALE TOTALS % OF-TOTAL Under 5 yrs. 58 52 ill 10 9 63 61 125 11 10 - 14 77 58 136 12 15 - 19 46 54 100 9 20 - 24 32 40 72 6 25 - 29 42 38 80 8 30 - 34 37 40 77 7 35 - 39 38 35 73 6 40 - 44 32 28 60 5 145- 49 44 28 73 6 50 - 54 39 32 71 6 55 - 59 41 20 61 5 60 - 64 18 16 34 3 65 - 69 10 11 21 2 70 - 74 8 8 16 2 75 and over 5 14 19 2 Under 18 yrs. 237 218 455 40 Over 65 yrs. 23 33 56 5 MEDIAN AGE 27.'2 25.1 26.2 The 1970 Census data indicates that 328 Alaskan Natives resided in the Haines Census Division, but does not give the distribution of the Native population by ED's. The Institute of Social, Economic and Government Research of the University of Alaska, in its publication Aqe and Race by Sex Characteristics of Alaska's Village Population., indicates 109 Natives in Haines, 52 in Port Chilkoot and 92 in Klukwan. (Those are R. W. PAVITT AND, ASSOCIATES. -INC. Haines Comprehensive Plw(Phase I) APPENDIX 1- -150- the only places covered in the Oublication within the Haines Census Division)'. Assuming the correctness of both publica Itions, the Native people comprised 21.9m of the total- population of the Census Division. @The Native,population'of 109 in Haines was 23.5% of th e total population and the-52 Natives in Port Chilkdot made up 23.6 of that community's total residents. -Eliminating Klukwan, which is 92% Native, and assum- ing a small Native count for Eldred Rock, St. James Bay, Letnikof Cove and other areas not*included,- it is concluded that the Native population of the Haines Community Planning Area in 1970 was 252, which is equiva- lent to 22.4% of the 1,125 total residents in the area at that time. The Haines population, both Native and non-Native, is significantly older than that of.the State as a"whole. In the Haines Census Divis- ion, 6.4% of the people are 62 years of age or.older, while only 1.8% of the State's population is in that age group. Similarly, the median age of 26.2 years in Haines is exceeded only by Valdez (27.7), Prince of Wales (27.2) and Seward (28.7) Census Divisions; and is substantially higher than the statewide median age of 22.9 Phase II will address the significance of this population analysis as it relates to land use, employment opportunities and needs, and commu- nity facilities in the community. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) APPENDIX 2* -151- R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. V Untit o tin study ="\ res L.a*v 20* Limit of TIONO study orac o-tv at GLA r? C% Cops ego EXPLANATION 10' Major fault or other lineament,* Uml of linao .location generalized study ore rn Minor fault or other lineament -7e DAVIDSON 4@1-A LF le 0 1 2 3 4 5 041LE3 C*# o 1 2 3 4 5 KILO)AZTE"31 Map of Haines area and vicinity showing faults or other lineaments. Takenfrom Twenhofel and Sainsbury (1958), Robertson (1959; unpub. data), G r ab ielse and Wheeler (1961); with additions by Lemke and Yehle (1972) based upon airphoto and map interpretations. R. !: W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase I) APPENDIX 2 -152- 140* 620 136* 1320 -7 U, 5 "OR wE3T fit 01II&S. L P11614 0194 YUN2!L J Zw i*, T. rr, op a" IFAWAw Wv loo 0 10 - , . :. " ' , .II b 150 MiLE3 Ao"AU Jq 0 .100 too KIL01"R5 NO A Sisk OPIANATTON 6 pn Well-defined. -Inferred.. Fault or other lineament A A a A Thr'ust fault WALES Dashed where inferred; IV I sawteeth on upper plate 0 -(D Queen Charlotte' Islands: fault powrLAMO Fairweather fault Chilkoat Inlet fault Chilkat River fault Shakwak Valley fault 540 (9) Chatham Strait fault (D Lynn Canal fault (5) Totschunda fault system' QUEEN CHARLOTTE G Chuga.ch-St. Elias fault IS.LANOS flap of Southeastern Alaska and adjacent Canada showing major faults and selected other lineaments interpreted to be probable or possiblefaults, shear zones, or joints. Taken from St. Amand (1957), Twenhofel and Sainsbury (1958), Gabrielse and Wheeler (1961), Brew and others (1966), Tobin and Sykes (1963), Geological Survey of Canada (1969a;--1969b), King (1969), Plafker (l969,-1"9'7-1)', Souther (1970), Richter and Matson (1971) with addi-tions andLmodifications by Lemke & Yehle (1972) R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -153- ACKNOWLEDGEMENT& The outstanding public participation in the preparation of this study in- dicates a strong interest among the citizens of Haines.in maintaining an active voice in the growth and development of their community. The excel- lent support of the Haines City Council and the continuing and enthusiastic participation of the Haines Planning Commission provided the leadership for this Phase I planning project. HAINES CITY COUNCIL HAINES PLANNING COMISSION Gail Wallace, Mayor Tom Haisler, Chairman Dave Berry Patricia Blank* David Foulke Steve.Homer, John Halliwell Harold Horton Harold Hannon Florence Lammers* Nicki Hopper Bob Laurie Charles Pardee David Nanney *retired Terry Pardee The assistance of the following individuals in the Phase I planning program is gratefully acknowledged: Layton Bennett Mary Hinman Tom Quinlan Dave Black Bud Hooker Belle Sage Dan Bockhorst Harold Hopper Frank Schierenb6ck Marge Busby Dick Jackson Deborah Schnabel George,Cannelos Maisie Jones George Schnabel Allie Cordes Stan Jones John Schnabel, Marty Cordes Harriett Jurgeleit Bob Schwalbach Connie Fairbanks Neil King Rick Shabo Pat Goebel Leo Land Sue Shabo Mimi Gregg Ed Lapeyri Randy Smith Rita Gregg Fred March Joan Snyder Ted Gregg Vivian March Bill Sparks Frank Haas Marge Matthews Mildred Sparks Henry Hall Elsie Mellott Ran Stone ' Polly Hall Vivian Menaker Dick Turner Gordon Hamer Beth McCradey Carl Ward Bill Hartman Steve McPhetres Doris Ward Edna Hatch Dave Olerud Susie Williams Lee Heinmiller Faith Pease Retha Young Ray:Hermann, Charles Pease Bill Zufelt A special debt of gratitude is acknowledged to the following Hainesites who gave tirelessly of their talents, time, and the love of their community Tom Haisler Wendy Hyde Terry Pardee Elizabeth Hakkinen Ray Menaker Vera Smith Carl Heinmiller David Nanney Annette Viertel R. W. PAVITT AND ASSOCIATES. INC. Haines Comprehensive Plan (Phase 1) -154- BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SOURCE DOCUMENTS OEDP REPORT, City, and Borough of Haines.11975 THE FOREST ECONOMY OF HAINES, ALASKA,,'M.. R'. C. Massey & R'. C. Haring, University of Alaska; ISEGR Report No.'20. .1969% COMPREHENSIVE PLAN; HAINES AND PORT CHILKOOT, Alaska.St. Housing Auth. 1964 HAINES COMMUNITY PROFILE, Alaska Dept. of Economic Development, Division of Economic Enterprise. 1975 WATER SUPPLY ANDSEWERAGESYSTEM STUDY, Haines,..Alaska, Engineering Sci- ence of Alaska. 1970 COMPREHENSIVE AREAWIDE WATER AND SEWER PLAN, Haines,, Alaska; 'Engineering Science of Alaska. 1972 PORT DEVELOPMENT STUDY@, George W. Davidson & William L. Gute. 1976 MINERAL RESOURCES OF SOUTHEASTERN ALASKA, University'of Alaska,' Mineral Industry Research Laboratory. Report No.. 28. 1, 1971 POPULATION AND ECONOMY OF TH; HAINES-PORT CHILKOOT REGION, Dr. Richard Cooley for ASHA. 1963 RECONNAISSANCE ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE HAINES AREA, Lemke & Yehle, U.S. Geological Survey (Open File Report) 1972 RECONNAISSANCE OF WATER RESOURCES IN THE HAINES-PORT CHILKOOT AREAV ALASKA; James A.@RcConaghy, U.S. Geological Survey. 1970 SOILS.OF THE HAINES AREA; B. Schoephorster & M. L. Dixon', U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service.- -1967 PROCEEDINGS: FIFTH NORTHERN RESOURCES.CONFERENCE; Yukon Chamber of Mines, Whitehorse, Y.T. Canada. 1975 ALASKA'S AGRICULTURAL POTENTIAL; Alaska Rural :Development Council. 1974 GENERAL POPULATION,CHARACTERISTICS,. ALASKA;.U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Census Bureau. 1,971 ALASKA 1970 CENSUS ATLAS; Alaska Dept of;Labor, Research & Analysis Sec- tion. 1974 AGE AND RACE 'BY SEX CHARACTERISTICS OF ALASKA'S VILLAGE POPULATION; Univ- ersity of Alaska, ISEGR. 1973 PART I AND PART II: HAINES-SKAGWAY AREA LAND USE PLANNING STUDY; Alaska Dept. of Natural Resources, Div. of Lands (Unpublished data) 1975 R. @9 E. A T A. State lez 161 T. state S 695 @tS chnabel Mill -6tak Dock PRO U tS PIPEL14F ,Uq 0 D FROMIJOROUG TOI--Z 14 NATIONAL FOREST L 4- ly 23 INES COM NIT-// 7 V, -PLAN G AR HILKOOr IN6 ALASKA SU FOR THIS TICN lial .9 a + 16 1 17 Liss, 160A 22 Z 24 2C i.A. State +; Ir@ 25 14 L E G E N 0 4 PRIVATE STATE GOVERNMENT FEDERAL GOVERNMENT 18 11% 15 NATIVE (EXEMPT) + 21 22 us;& aS5 Tal,.ni 1,10.d LAND TENURE MAP 30 a\ @0, HAINES OVERALL A + + PLANNING AREA T paration of th s report was fi %4jp part SCALE: I" = 8000' roug a grant from the Department of Ho bWtg and rban IS elopment, under th Section HausQX Act qS_1W4rWks _J_ - ----------- __4_4---- t- 77 0 7 z 0 WU T 31 S L E G E N 0 PRIVATE + LOCAL GOVERNMENT INN STATE GOVERNMENT 01 FEDERAL GOVERNMENT 2 CHURCH & QUASI-PUBLIC (EXEMPT) NATIVE (EXEMPT) @11M_NOIM MI'm LAND TENURE MAP HAINES COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA SCALE: I" a 1500' SEC's 26.27,28,31,34.34 T 30 S SEC*S 2.3.4 T 31 5, R SO E, C.R.M. The preparation of this report was financed In part through a grant from the Department of Housing and Urban Development. under the provisions of Section ,701 of the Housing Act of 1954, as amended. -7-71F- 77 255 0 253 C 256 0 2 _13 253 C 1256 C1 -2 2iiio ,3 53 '256 J i@ 235 D 260 A i j . j - 258 A 258 A 53 2 a 256 A 2 10 239 A 2 X C is 255 C Is 55 253 255 C. is 259 A 3313 7--T 31 S 31 S 255 B Ch Gra :::y 5 ndy Lo:m, 3to 7% So es L E G E N D i 255 C Ch Gra y S:ndy Lo m, 7to 12% :.Ppes 255 0 Ch Gravvel IySandy Loam, 12 to 20% Slopes -.62 255 E Ch Gravelly Sandy Loam. 20 to 30% Slopes 255 F Ch Gravelly Sandy Loam, 30 to 60% Slopes 255 V, 256 A De Gravelly Sandy Loam, 0to 3% Slopes 256 B De Gr:vel:y Sandy Lo:m, 3to 7% Slopes 261 Ei r t 256 C De G vel y Sandy Lo m, 7 o(2% Slopes 256 0 De Gravelly Sandy Loam, 12 to 20% Slopes 259 A 255 F 258 A Ka Silty Clay Loam 18 259 A Kina Peat of 260 A Maybeso Mucky Peat, 0to 3% Slopes 260 8 Maybeso Mucky Peat, 3to 7% Slop s 261 A Lu Very Gravelly . Coarse Sand, 0 to 3% Slopes 261 3 Lu Very Gravelly Coarse Sand, 3 to 7% Slopes Is a 262 EF Tolstoi Very Stony Silt Loam, 20 to 60% 119 A 9-262 Rough Broken Land Tolstoi Complex 255 c 9 Rough Broken Land source: "Soil$ of the H.i- Are.. Al..-" bY the Soil C.--tl- S-i-.. 18 Gravelly/Rocky Beach U.S. Departrrant Olt Agriculture, 1967, 53 Tidal Marsh SOILS MAP HAINES COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA SCALE: I" = 1500' The preparation of this report was financed in part through a grant from the Department of Housing and Urban Development, under the provisions of Section 201 of the Housing Let of 1954, as amended. R. 56 E@.@ -7--L + + + i- -USS. 654 USA 96 Uss. 967 -USS 3995 U@ 07 --US.S. 374 U&S 94 IIZZ 7- x I /USS 946- @7 + +1 + U. S 695 3 49-.... Schnab I Mill 49 AOL Lutak Dock + 4_ PRoourts PIPELj1A.F- U.S.S+ 906 4- U;@ 17.-" EXCLUDED FROM @OROUG + +c@ AISS.3394 14 t 14 Us& 1492,,@ ronefli + 80y 4- 4- 2 A: @4 . 3 20 21-__. 23 2 U 27 -0,4 @Er-,,H At NES C TY/ MAPS PLANN G AR 36,CKILK00% [email protected] S..I 74-- 7: F 0: :11@ ;T.." jTION gal 6 16 pr@ 7 * IS 20 Chilkat :0,: P.,k 4a .9 sa 11 11 North U n It r I 4<. + Ir LJ-S5. 160 ACI 22 24 1 2 7. 41 T 14 4-1 25 + 1243 jr Kmhu + IM- -4- 4 4 L E G E N D -rr1o posed RESIDENTIAL + + Chilkat State Park 12 7 -7 INDUSTRIAL South Unit ROCK/Ci RAVEL + QUARRY 3 L- 18 15 RECREATION + + + f + 10 PUBLIC FACIL+ES D. @. 2 19 21 22 VACANT 3 US,& 865 TW-i + + + + 4 + + + 7. as,- 00 LAND USE -MAP 25 L 30 a$' + IL HAINES OVERALL a PLANNING AREA reparation of hi a report was in zglIML in part gh a grant from t e Department Ltning and SCALE: I" = 8000' rb opnent, un er '0 Of. Se.!fn o k 59 ;@. @--L@01 e H 1@@-g Ac f d Z 7 30 S AREA SERVED BY BOTH WATER AND SEWER AREA NOT SERVED BY CITY SEWER AREA NOT SERVED BY CITY WATER AREA,NOT SERVED BY EITHER C TY WATER OR SEWER - - - - - - - - - - - - - - WATER & SEWER SERVICE AREAS HAINES COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA SCALE: I" = 15001 The preparation of this report was financed in part through a grant from the Department of Housing and Urban Developnent, under the provisions of Section '701 of the Hous ing Act of 1954, as amended. .4 42' (A 3EM _LL @OIIOIITI ... -------- is LA 0 d CORPO@@TE LIMITS st.. ...................................... , P-1. ,Chilk Or Lin on Oil Tanks chill, C, "ll, for in. T 30_S T 31 LIMITS L_ E G E N D 0 TRANSPORTATION STATE ROAD, PAVED FAA Stall. STATE ROAD.. GRAVEL CITY ROAD, GRAVEL ................... SERVICE ROAD OR TRAIL COMMUNITY FACILITIES PRIVATE FACILITY FAA 0 T- QUASI-PUBLIC FACILITY PUBLIC FACILITY -h - - - - - - - - - - - - TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNITY FACILITIES MAP The preparatian o through a grant f HAINES COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA Urban Developnent SCALE: I" = 1000' 701 of the Housin L A N D U S E L I M I T S 2 2@ -- --------- @-Ma Xl tj 2. :,I RIr, .2 p k 0 F1 IM - - _11 M -.1 N RUM, ..... : Wi@ ! .................. Ir H. ON. ......... . INUM: 3 2 T 30 S T 31 S 4+3 LIMITS L E G E N D .......... SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MOBILE HOME MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MOBILE HOME PARK COMMERCIAL .... .. LIGHT INDUSTRIAL & STORAGE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL A CHURCH & QUASI-PUBLIC . .......... RECREATION/OPEN SPACE GRAVEL & ROCK QUARRY UNDEVELOPED LAND W" - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 4 LAND USE MAP The preparation o through a grant f HAINES COMMUNITY PLANNING AREA Urban Devel0pnent 701 of the Housin SCALE: I" - 1000' SECIS 26.27.20.3 3,34,3 5 T 30 S SEC'S 2.3,4 T 31 5. R 59 E, C.R.M. CIOIIA-.1411 IIMITS.@ 1101121111111k 36668 141048126 I