[From the U.S. Government Printing Office, www.gpo.gov]
MASTER PLAN STUDY, JAMES ARMSTRONG MEMORIAL PARK PREPARED FOR BENSALEM TOWNSHIP PARKS & RECREATION BOARD JULY 1981 PREPARED BY CARROLL ENGINEERING CORPORATION 387 YORK ROAD HT WARMINSTER, PA. 168 B46 AND M37 1981 E. VAN RIEKER. AICP CONSULTANT LAND PLANNER ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This study.was prepared through the assistance, direction and cooperation of the following: Bensalem Township Parks and Recreation Board, Russell Manningr Chairman; Arthur Wilson; Robert Stahl; Rosemary Halloran, Ron Polakawski; members. Jerry A. Andree, Director of Parks and Recreation Natalie A. Strange, Township Manager Thomas Donnelly, Bensalem Township Citizen Advisor Jerry M. Sudick, Manager Coastal Zone Management office of the Department of Environmental Resources. @Michael A. Wolf, Chief Land Resources Planning, Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission. Ken Kugel, Chief Planner, Bucks County Planning Commission. A special acknowledgement is given to E. Van Rieker, AICP who @through Carroll Engineering was responsible for the planning aspects of this project. MASTER PLAN STUDY JAMES:ARMSTRONG MEMORIAL PARK TABLE OF CONTENTS Page General A. Introduction 1 B. Scope of Study 2 C. Data Used for this Study 3 D. Ownership of Land 4 E. Monumentation Plan 5 F. Existing Conditions- 5 Master Plan A. Plans and Policies 9 1. Park Features 9 2. Township Growth 10 3. Developmental Policies 11 B. Plan Development @14 C. Administration 15 D. Township Recreation Programs 16 E. Development Priorities, 17 Cost Estimates A. Devel opment 20 B. Cost Summary 21 LIST OF EXHIBITS AND FIGURES Exhibit No. 1 Location Plan Exhibit No. 2 Ownership of Land Exhibit. No.3 Monumentation Plan Exhibit No. 4 Topography and Existing Featu.res Exhibit No. 5 Master Plan Limited Development Exhibit No. 6 Master Plan Moderate Development. Exhibit No. 7 Master Plan Full Development Figure A Suitability of Natural Characteristics for Various Recreation Facilities Figure B Needs Identified From Various Studies Figure C Typical Township Recreation Programs Proposed MASTER PLAN STUDY JAMES ARMSTRONG MEMORIAL PARK GENERAL A. Introduction Due to national concern Over development pressures on the ocean, Great Lakes and estuarine shore lines, the.United States Cong ress in late 1972 enacted the Coastal Zone Management Act. The Act encourages states to develop comprehensive programs to ensure. effective management of their coastal resources. As a result of this, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, through the Department of Environmental Resources office of Resource Management developed and published the "Pennsylvania Coastal Zone Management Program Technical Record", in,December of 1978. This report addressed the Lake Erie water front and the.Delaware Estuary. Bensalem Township is designated a Coastal Zone Community within the Delaware Estuary due to its frontage along the Delaware River as well as its frontage on the Neshaminy Creek, a tributary to the Delaware River. James Armstrong Memorial.Park is a site which is situated along the Neshaminy Creek. The site has been identified as an area of "Significant recreational, historic, or cultural value" in the Pennsylvania Coastal Zone Management Program, Technical Report. As such, the park site is further identified as an area of existing open space where recreational needs can be served and public access to the water's edge exists. The Bensalem Township Parks and Recreation Board has undertaken the task of developing a Master Plan for the James Armstrong Memorial Park which is being funded by a grant from ,the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Resources, Coastal Zone Management Program. James Armstrong Memorial Park is a site of approximately 20 acres situated along the Neshaminy Creek in the easterly section of Bensalem Township, Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Refer to Ex- h4bit No. 1,.Location Map, foT more detail. The site also has frontage to Bensalem Boulevard at a poin t generally opposite the intersection with Bristol Road. The park is composed of the following properties: 17.0 Ac. Township owned 0.7 Bucks County Redevelopment Authority@ 0.7 Privately owned (to be acquired) 1.5 Land in vacant street ROW 19.9 Ac. Park Total B. Scope of Study The Bensalem.Township Parks and Recreation Board has retained the firm of Carroll Engineering Corporation to prepare a Planning Study to consist of a Master Plan, with three alternatives and a pro gram for the development of the James Armstrong Memorial Park. 0 THMP7:0 4D MID LETOWN:. 4C if.OWER SOUTHAMPTON J. ffAAfj A6 N-9ALF M 0- U. 0 t JAMES ARMSTRONG Z5 MEMORIAL PARK BENSALEM TOWNSHIP PARKS & RECREATIO JAMES ARMSTRONG. LAWA MEMORIAL- PARK LOCATION MAP RIVER NEWJERSEY DATE: JULY 28.1981, EXHIBIT,-N-0--@, The Planning Study has been prepared in close coordination with the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission (DVRPC)l the Bucks County Planning Commission (BCPC), the Bucks County Parks'Department, The Bensalem'Township Parks and Recreation Board as well as the general public which was invited to public presentations.April 28 and June 23,. 1981. The public meetings were held by the Township Parks and Recreation Board. In addition to the Planning Study, a monumentation plan was pre- pared and monuments were placed to specifically identify the. perimeter of the park property and to target those properties that could be acquired and as sembled to become a part of the park. C. Data Used for this Study The reports and studies listed below have been obtained from various sources and were reviewed inorder to determine recrea- tional needs and appropriate standards and cri teria for recrea- tional facilities. Bucks County Park Plan, Bucks.County Planning Commission; July 1974. Demand for Recreational Access to the Lower Delaware River, League.of Women Voters of,Pennsylvania; November 1980. Pennsylvania.Coastal Zone Management Program, Executive Summaryl Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and other; September 1979. 'Amended Redevelopment Proposals,for the Creek Road North and Creek Road South", Bensalem Township; Redevelopment Authority of the County of Bucks; July 1976. Recreation, Parks and Open Space Plan, Bensalem Township, Bucks, September 1976. County, Pennsylvania; Facilities Planning, Bensalem Township Park and Recreation@ .Plan; July 1976. The Comprehensive Plan, Bensalem Township; adopted and printed January 29, 1975.. Bensalem Towhship_ComprehensiVe Plan,'David M. Walker Associates, Inc.;. adopted and printed February 5, 1968. A Comprehensive Park and Recreation Study, Bristol Township, Bucks County, Pa.; George E. Patton, Inc., October 1, 1974. "Flood Hazard Maps of the Neshaminy Creek in Bensalem Township, Bucks County, Pa." Bensalem Township Engineer; April 6, Ownership of Land As previously noted, the township presently owns 18.5 acres or 93% of the park property between the southerly limit and Pennsylvania Avenue. There are ten properties within the site. areatnot presently owned by the township. Two of those proper- ties are owned by the Bucks County Redevelopment Authority and the remaining eight properties belong to four different owners. Exhibit No. 2 shows the properties, as recorded, at the time of this report., Some of the privately owned properties may have been acquired and not yet recorded. The site also contains approximately 1.5 acres of street which are no longer physically open'.. We.are proposing these.streets be stricken and vacated. When this is done by the Board of Supervisors, the ground..contained in the street right-of-way. will transfer,'to the adjacent property owners, which in most cases is the Township of Bensalem. The streets to be stricken atd vacated are also shown on Exhibit No,. 2. We do not see -4- the need to strike Creek Road or Maine Avenue since the access road for the park i.s coincides with these streets. Also, Creek Road contains an existing sanitary sewer belonging to the Bucks County Water and Sewer Authority. If this street was stricken,,. a right-of-way would have-to be established for the aforementioned sanitary sewer. E, Monumentation Plan As requiredin accordance with. the scope of work and proposal for this project,a monumentation plan along with the placement of monuments was required. Exhibit No. 3 shows where the monuments were placed to define the boundariesof the project. In addition to these monuments, pins were placed at certain locations which were requested by the park director. Exhibit No. 3 also shows the locations of these pins. P. Existing Conditions Natural Features There are five predominant natural features which characterize the project site'andlto a large measure"dictate the design and location of future facilities.. These features can be seen on Exhibit No 4 and are as follows: ,1. Neshaminy Creek The configuration of the park is generally rectangular with,thelong dime nsion parallel to the Neshaminy Creek for a distance of 1600 feet. The creek is between 70 ft. to 150 ft. in width and varies in depth between two and six feet depending upon the tidal influence and seasonal pre- cipitation. Most of the Creek edge consists of.a rugged bank which in places is perched eight to ten feet in elevation above the water level. This feature of extensive frontage to the Neshaminy Creekis the most significant and interesting natural feature which distinguishes this, park from most others in the Township.. 2. Flood Plain Most of the site is situated below the high elevation of the 100 year flood plain as determined by the Township Engineer. While this may not preclude recrea@ tional use it does suggest that overnight use along with expensive. permanent structures should be avoided. In general, the site will not be affected by smaller floods occuring at more frequent intervals along,the creek. 3. Woodland -.A large percentage (70%) of the site is wooded, consisting of large and moderate sized mature ash, oak and tulip trees with a deciduous canopy. This area covers pre- dominantly the northerly third and southerly one-half.of the site. This wooded characteristic provides fine protect- for picnicking, hiking trails, and is'quite conducive as a setting for a natural preserve. Woods also provide an excellent buffer along most of the perimeter of the park, especially along Bensalem Boulevard and behind the adjacent commercial property which is currently vacant. Thick vegetative understory will require clearing in those areas ,.where recreation use.is desired,.such as for picnicking or play. -6- In addition to woodland masses, there are over 50 large specimen shade trees with large caliper (12" to 3011 caliper) and.height (50 60 ft.). These individuals have been shown on the Master Plan and align the creek bank and' both sides.of the existing drive. These trees are of par- ticular benefit visually and privide shade as well as scale from.the overhead.canopy. ..4. Steep Slopes The entire westerly edge of the site has steep slopes, in some places so sever e that the escarpment land form prohibits access. This is especially true along Flushing Road and.behind the commercial parcel. Vehicular access must be carefully planned and it seems that the, present circulation pattern is the most-viable. The slopes in conjunction with the woodland reinfro-ces the natural barrier along the westerly perimeter. 5. Level Land The majority of the site is level to gentle sloping (slopes u nder 3%).particularly in the central meadow and along the creek edge. The level land some open and some wooded is particularly suitable for play, parking,, camping, bicycle/jogging trails and for play fields where not wooded. Man-Made Features There are four man-made features that should be considered in any park master plan for development: -7- Existing Drive Partially paved and suitably graded, this driveway extends from Bensalem Boulevard through the site and parallel to the creek and ultimately links to Creek Road which intersects at.Bridge Street just west of the Bridge. Presently, park visitors use the existing driveway in two- way fashion,but park cars indiscriminantly in the park facility, especially along the creek edge. 2. Sanitary Sewer An existing sewer line runs along Creek Road parallel to the Creek.and traverses the south easterly portion of the park. This existing utility provides an excellent opportunity for toilet facilities for park patrons. ,3. Existing Creek Edge Wall A concrete block wall tied into a fishing pier at one point runs along the edge of the Neshaminy Creek for a short distance. Although not a significant structure, the.walls nevertheless indicate how to popularize fishing piers and should be incorporated into. future plans for the park. 4. Existing Basketball Court An asphalt basketball court exists in a shaded location,on the gravel entrance drive.', This is the extent of active recreation presently provided., Its location and surface conditions are good and the basket- ball court should be planned into any future scheme for park development. MASTER PLAN A. Plans and Policies 1. Park Features The James Armstrong Memorial Park has a number of exciting, and diverse natural features'al1 of which are quite suit- able for active and passive recreation in a true park-like setting. Of these features, the extensive.frontage along the Ne shaminy Creek coupled with easy vehicular access to near- by roads provides the opportunity for excellent public ac- cess which is the foremost attribute of the park. This is enhanced by the woodland setting. Without exception, publications research, public input, suggestions from the Township Parks and Recreation Board, and other agencies all indicate that activities along the Neshaminy Creek such as creek bank fishing and non-powered aquatic activities should be emphasized. Figure A: Suitablity of Natural Characteristics for Various Recreation Facilites charts 21 recreation activities fro m those most passive to most active and ranks their suit-,, ability to nine basic natural features characteristic of the subject site. Figure B: Needs Identified-form Various Studies charts the same 2l.recreation activities,and ranks their preference as indicated in ten recreation and park planning studies. -9- -4) %Z4 . p'. k3l :r AS, N3 1 :31 :33 CIA M CU zi *tz Do ,CR 4b SIC, Co 4b 4b Da gob 4ft :10 X, 'z > Fnr 0 z 4:7 OQ zw co CQ co PL e Z.0 RZ3 "Z3 V%sz --4 --M CIA ip S@ zl@ "RN zD --q JAI it kill 4z) A29 Q1 -29i 4;:S Its- Z. L 0 ZIA.- ls@ M4 Itz, go@ Co. !I - The various recreation facilities were scored in Figure B and compared to their suitability index as ranked in Figure A. The uses were then examined to their special application to the site and various master plans were pre-' pared. This examiniation was performed in order to deter- mine which:ac,tivit-les should be encouraged. The plans presented in this report were developed as a stage or step toward what could be classified as full.de- velopment anticipated for the site? rather than totally different schemes. Emphasis should be on preservation of natural characteristics,where possible. 2. Township Growth Bensalem Township is one of the.fastest growing municipali- ties and has the second highest population in all of Bucks County. The U.S.. Census of Population figures are listed below. 1980 1970 % Change Bensalem Population 52,211 33,042 58.0 The growth of the Township has.been outstanding. During the previous ten year period 1970,.- 1980, Bensalem grew at four times the county rate. By 1980 Bensalem was the second most populated municipality in all of Bucks County. _10- Most importantly, the ten-year population increase of 19,169 was by far the greatest amount of increase by any municipality in Bucks County which is made even more re- markable by the fact that no other municipality in the seven county Delaware Valley Region had as large an in- creas.eas Bensalem Township. Bensalem Township added more people (1970 to 1980) than any other municipality in the seven county Delaware Valley Region. The township ranked first in absolute population increase among over three hundred nearby communities in Pennsylvania and New J ersey. There is an obvious need to provide awide range of re- creation opportunities for the burgeoning population gener- ally and for the residents.of townhouse and mobile home communities located nearby- The James Armstrong memorial Park privides a unique op- portunity to fulfill these needs.as a special purpose park. The broad goals are listed in the.Development Policies of this report. It should be noted that the park has been ranked as a Community Activity Area in the 1978 Township Facilities Planning Report. 3. Developmental Policies a. The scenic and passive recreation value of the frontage along the Neshaminy Creek should be emphasized and ex- ploited. b. Non-powered boating, canoeing and shore line fishing should be emphasized.. Also hiking and naturetrails should be provided at appropriate locations along the Neshaminy Creek. C.; Sightseeing (river-watching) should be an important part .,of the passive recreation aspects of.the park espec- ially for those not participating in boating and fishing which are popular active activiites.. Picniking is.a favorite ancillary activity recommended by all agencies surveyed. d. Local role in recreation should be amajor goal and thus bikeways, hiking, sledding, ice skating and play areas should be considered.in addition acquatic activi- ties. e. A flood plain is an ideal location for most outdoor re- creation but should not contain structures that could break loose or on-site sewage disposal. f. Automobile access is important since thereis no oppor- tunity for walk-in visitors., For this reason and be- cause any development of the park will serve as an at- traction, adequate on-site parking must be planned for and controlled. g. Circulation using existing access drives conforms to topography and should be continued. Surfaces.must be _12- graded and paved, and a one-wa y circulation pattern is recommended for safety and to eliminate short cutting. h. Existing improvements: utilities, basketball, driveway and:creek wall should be utilized where possible. i. Areas of debris and dumping must, be cleaned and removed. Areas.proposed for picnicking must have a cleared and graded understory. Natural features should be preserved and-incorporated into the design where ever possible. The perimeter woodland buffer should be maintained with new growth planted where needed to reduce sight and sound to ad- joining roads. k. The park boundary should be rounded outwith acquisition of all vacant properties south of Pennsylvania Avenue be- ing the- first priority. Additional acquisition to maintain the insulative qualities of the Park while pro- viding for possible expansion should also be considered. This action would also ensure a link park system.with the ult imate goal.of providing low density uses such as trails, biking and fishing along the creek bank of the N.eshaminy Creek. -13- B. Plan Developmen Three alternatives for development have been prepared and the Master Plans are shownin this report. Rather than having differentapproaches, general unanimity of development policies especially when evaluated incon- junction with site constraints, suggest that one direction should be followed,this to emphasize the attributes of the. park. Therefore, each Master Plan is a progression of development with Master Plan 3 constituting the,final stage plan. The three Master Plans are: MP-1: Limited Development, Exhibit No. 5 MP-2: Moderate Development, Exhibit No. 6 MP-3: Full Development, Exhibit No. 7 In each case, the design will emphasize the recreational opportunity (active and passive) of,the Neshaminy Creek while also providing for 6 day use neighborhood park. The schemes are accumulative. Each phase of design is con7 ceived to fit into subsequent future phases which reflect a more complete park witha wide range of facilities. None of the options should be considered high intensity, i.e.: imper- vious surfaces and active playground type uses are minimal. -14- C. Administration, In addition to the costs of site acquisition and facility development, the costs of maintaining such facilities are important to insure continued enjoyment. Standards forestimating average maintenance costs suggest that.roughly 10% of the construction costs.of a project will be expended yearly for maintenance. The average cost for the maintenance of open space related areas is approxi- mately $500 $1,000 per acre per year. The more natural the area the lower thecost range. Costs for equipment rental and instructional staff if.re- quired are normally offset by users fees which may be charged for special ororganized events. As the number of new facilities and thus the construction costs increase, as in.the MP-1 through MP-3, then so will the average annual maintenance costs. Thus, as park develop_ ment advances beyond,the initial stage, it should follow that the Parks.and Recreation Board.budget for appropriately higher maintenance and operation costs. The Township.Parks and Recreation Board-may also desire to control night use for security reasons by installation of gates along the entrance drives in order to limit the hours of operation., Gates could also be used to control traffic -15- and limit the number of visitors should overcrowded con-,. ditions, become a problem. This is an administrative de-, cision. In addition, there may be the opportunity to use a part of the vacant property parallel to the westerly edge of the Park and having frontage to Bensalem Boulevard for overflow parking. This area has been identified on the plan. .The Parks and Recreation Board should initiate ne- gotiations with the present owner in order to negotiate permission to use a part of the property - one half acre should be sufficient for additional parking should this become necessary during crowded times in the summer. This need would likely occur only in the case of MP-2 or MP-3 where more facilities are contemplated. It is important to note that the overflow parking may be required only dur- ing, special events and not on a regular basis. A summer weekend could be considered-a special event in the context of this discussion. D. Township Recreation Programs Inaddition to.facilities that could be used for unstructured play and recreation, there is theopportunity to institute various recreation programs to enhance the physical, social and intellectual well being of Bensalem Township residents. During the summer, organized activities could include a Town- ship sponsored 5 day/week day camp program for children be- -16- tween the ages of 6 13. These camps normally run between 7 10 weeks. This day camp could include a minimal fee with a program of activities to include: arts and crafts, archery, field @sports (limited), and nature study. A support staff would be required. This program is Appropriate only in Master Plan 3 since this stage prQvidesfor toilets and drinking water. During the winter, once the ice skating pond is established, an ice hockey club and/or skating club could be organized by the Township, the operation costs of which could be self supported. Figure C indicatesseasonal local Township programs which could beimplemented as part of the Township Parks and Recrea- tion Program for the James Armstrong Memorial Park. The number and extent of such programs is dep endent upon the act- ual facilities constructed. Figure C: Typical Township Recreation Programs is intended to serve as a guide for Town- ship program de,,velopment.once..,adequate facilities and staff are realized. E. Development Priorities The unique characterisitics of the subjec t park, including extensive creek-frontage in a natural setting along with good vehicular access,' indicate a special opportunity to mix scenic and shore line activities with other facilities.nor- mally associated with.a neighborhood park. -17- TYPICAL TOWNSHIP RECREATION PROGRAMS PROPOSED FOR JAMES ARMSTRONG MEMORIAL PARK PROGRZ04 SEASON MPI MP2 MP3 Active/Physical Basketball Sp, Su, F X X X Bicycle Marathon Sp, Su, F X Run-A-Thon Sp, Su, F X Jogging All X X Exercise/Calisthenics Sp, Su, F X X Canoeing Su X Skating W X Cookouts Su X X X Parties Su, F X X X Passive/Intellectual Picnicking Su X X X Fly Tying/Fishing Su X X X Wildflower Walks. Sp X X X Nature Walks All X X X Arts & Crafts Su X X X Contests/Exhibits 2 Su X X X Notes: 1. Sp Spring., Su= Summer, F Pall, W Winter, All All Seasons 2. Including photography.. art, coins, ceramics, other hobbies. FIGURE C Acquisition of unowned properties within the 20 acre en- velope previously described is a first priority. .After initial park development is undertaken, then the Town- ship should consider acquisition of additional lands as their sale or acquisition.funds become available along the westerly and northerly perimeter. Ideally, ownership of all or most of the land situated be- tween the Neshaminy Creek and Bensalem Boulevard north to- Bridge Road would be an excellent goal. 'This is justified by the unique opportunity to create public access to the water's edge.4long with the need to ensure long range insula- tion/buffer from the nearby urban environment. A second major priority must be to enhance the potential use and enjoyment of the Park by undertaking the development of James Armstrong Memorial Park to a level no less than that illustrated on Master Plan MP-2. It shouldbe noted that MP-1, Limited Developmentis pre- sented as the least amount of improvement necessary to accom- plish a first phase of park development. Furthermore, MP-3, Full Development,is intended to accomplish the wide variety of.facilities providing the greatest service in terms of programs and activities (active and passive) to a growing population. -18- In Master Plan MP-3 these facilities serve more ages through more seasons in.greater comfort and provide op- portunity for structured programsto more people than any other alternative. Therefore, MP-3, Full Development', is preferred and highly recommended as being in the best inter ests of.Bensalem Township. It should be recognized that the Master Plan is conceived to preserve as much of the natural quality of the park as possible while creating the opportunity for user enjoyment in the areas of both active and passive recreation. _19- COST ESTIMATES A. Development Cost Estimated cost for 1982 construction have been used are tabulated below for each Master Plan alternative. James Armstrong Memorial Park Estimated Cost (1982 Construction) MP-2 MP-3 New Paving for Access 10,000.00 ----- ------ -- New Buff.or Landscaping .6,000.00 - ----- - ------ Parking for 50 cars 101000.00 ----- ------ 65 cars ------ 3,000.00 ------ *Picnic Tables & fire- places 6,000.00 6,000.00 ------ - 'General Clean-up 3,000.00 ----- ------- Clear & Thin Under Story 7,000.00 ----- ------ 'Rehab. Existing Fishing - Fier 1,500.00 ------ -- ------ Clear & Seed Free Play Area 15,000.00 ------ ------ construct 2 New Fishing Piers - ------- 7,000.00 ------ Tot Lot ------- 25,000.00 ------ Horseshoe Pits (2) ------ 11000.00 ------ Exercise Trail, (300OLF) (gravel) ------- 32,000.00 (paving) ------ ------ 131000.00 **Canoe Stand & Launch ------ ------ 2,000.00 ***Ice Skating Pond ------ - 35,000.00 Warming Shelter ------ - ------ 8,000.00 Rest Rooms ------ ------ 20,000.00 Public Water Fountain ------ ------ 3,000.00 Resurface Basketball Court ------ ------ 4,000.00 Miscellaneous Site Im- provements .(Signs, Bal- lards, Fencing, Gates,etc.)10,000.00 10,000.00 15,000.00 Totals $ 68,50U.00 $84,000.00$100,000.00 12 picnic tables and 3 fireplaces per,phase Assumes canoe stand is provided by concessionaire Includes clear.ing of trees and natural base pond only -20- B. Cost Summary MP-1 $ 68,500.00 mp-2 84,000.00 MP-3 100,000.00 $252,500.00 Engineering J15%) 37,875.00 $290,375.00 Itshould be noted that some of the items above are based on contracting prices. Saving in some areas may be found if township forces perform the work. -21- 3 6668 14101 3443