[From the U.S. Government Printing Office, www.gpo.gov]
HOOD CANAL COORDINATING COUNCIL JULY 15v 1988 FINAL REPORT G0088041 HOOD CANAL SHELLFISH AND RECREATION STUDY HOOD CANAL VIDEO PROJECT HD 1694 .w2 PUBLISHED BY H6 1988 kP COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT )IVISION STREET- PORT ORCHARD, WASHINGTON 9"66 Hood Canal Coordinating Council. STATUS REPORT/ HOOD CANAL COORDINATI`NG COUNCIL COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT GRANT Property of Library JULY 15, 1988 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE NO, COASTAL SERVICES CENTER 2234 SOUTH HOBSON AVENUE CHARLESTON, SC 29405-24 The preparation of this report was financially aided through a grant from the Washington State Department of Ecology with funds obtained from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and appropriated from Section 306 of Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972. Abstract Title: Hood Canal Project Completion Report Author: Hood Canal Coordinating Council Subject: This report summarizes the activities of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council toward accomplishing a Recreational opportunities study and a video tape presentation of the Coordinating Councils work toward development of a process by which three Counties and Two Tribal Nations should consider the care and development of land and water resources associated with Hood Canal. Date: June 30, 1988 Departments: Department of Ecology, Kitsap County, Jefferson County, Mason County , Clallam Indian Tribe, Skokomish Indian Tribe, and the Point No Point Treaty Council. Source of Copies: Copies may be obtained from the Kitsap County Department of Community Development, 614 Division, Port Orchard, Washington 98366. WDOE Project Number: G 0088041 Series Number: 03 Number of Pages: Abstract: The Priority Goal of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council is to preserve and maintain water quality within Hood Canal. The various jurisdictions that exist along the shores of Hood Canal realized that to accomplish the goal of preserving that water 2 quality a coordinated approach was going to have to be a priority for all of them. In addition to setting this goal the jurisdictions realized that the relation ship of a great many actions by the counties and tribes were involved and that goals and policies for each of these areas and concerns would be necessary to guide the jurisdictions along there collective path. This process and the associated resources they have sought to preserve and maintain is the subject of the Hood Canal video Tape presentation. During this process areas for more study were identified. One of which was to study commercial and recreational opportunities through out the Canal and identify areas where more use could compatibly occur. STATUS REPORT Project Title: Development of Hood Canal Resource Planning Video and Analysis of Economic and Environmental Impacts of Expanded Recreational Access and Related Shellfish Harvesting on the Canal. Project Description: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council's Grant Project consists of the following two work elements: Element 1: An analysis of economic and environmental impacts associated with increased recreational access and Commercial shellfish production. The intent of this work element is to determine the full economic value of both the recreational; and commercial shell fish harvest in Hood Canal and the environmental and economic impacts of increasing recreational access to the Canal. The Council will work with treaty tribes, local, state and federal agencies, economic development councils as well as private industry. Task 1: Work with the three county Economic Development Councils to develop guidelines for the study and its use, distribution and potential funding participation. Status: The program director of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council meet with representative of the Economic development Councils of Mason, Jefferson and Kitsap County to determine how much participation both financial and physical the Economic Development Councils desired after reviewing the scope of work for the project. The Economic Development Councils desired to act as an advisory committee to review the progress on the project and offered any information that was available from the Economic Development Council and their members for use by the student intern to be utilized. Guidelines for the study and its use were discussed with the student intern. Distribution of the study was agreed to be to members of the advisory group first before recommendation to the Council and broad distribution to the general public. The study was intended for distribution to the public as part of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council work program. The Economic Development council of Mason County volunteered their Council members to match the Grant to be used in kind and to assist in the gathering of new information, area surveys if necessary and for sample presentations of the study before release. The advisory committee has meet to review information presented by the student intern and has been polled by phone on critical concerns repeatedly. First, they reviewed and commented on the original scope of work and student intern's proposal to meet that scope of work. Secondly, they have reviewed the work as it has progressed in draft form. Finally they have commented on the final presentation of the study in conjunction with the Hood Canal Coordinating Council staff. Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15, 1988 Page 2 Task 2: Work with area colleges and/or available environmental intern programs to provide staff skilled in recreational economics and environmental issues. 0 Develop an agreement and hire by contract. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council staff advertized for services in the local paper and placed notices with the area colleges requesting students who might-be interested to contact the Hood Canal Coordinating Council Staff. The Puget Sound Water Quality Authority was also notified and the Department of go Ecology as well as The National Environmental Intern Program (EIP) Northwest. Four qualified applicants were reviewed by the Hood Canal Coordinating Council Staff and executive board and a recommendation made to the full Council to hire an Intern for the project. Attachment "A" includes the contract with Steven Boessow for the Study utilizing the Scope of Work Coordinated with the Economic Development Councils/ Tribal Advisory Committee. Task 3: Work with intern to develop an analysis of recreational and commercial shell fish activity on Hood Canal identifying where, when, how much and who uses these resources as well as dollars spent by categories direct and indirect. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council Program Director worked with the intern to develop and analysis of recreational and commercial shellfish activity on Hood Canal. Information from the Mason County Economic Development council as well as an Environmental Impact Statement prepared for an aquaculture project in Kitsap County greatly advanced this project. Inventories available from the Department of Fisheries, Department of Wildlife, and Department of Social and Health Services as well as information from the three County Planning and health departments was reviewed, compiled and digested in order to develop sufficient data to begin to identify where, when and how much these resources are used and by whom. Information from the Washington State Department of Trade and Economic Development was used to identify and estimate the amount of money spent by users of these resources. Local information by personal interview and on site survey by the intern and other persons was very helpful in establishing the where, when and how much of the cash flow that is direct or indirect within the Hood Canal region and that is attributable to the shellfish and recreational interest. Staff meet through out the period on at least a monthly basis to review progress reports of the intern during the completion of the project. Attachment "B" contains the outline of the draft report of the Intern presented to the Advisory committee. Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15, 1988 Page 3 Task 4: Identify conflicting uses of the Canal, locations, user and other interest groups, significant resource areas and review data with agencies and tribes in relationship to goals and policies of the HCCC. Status: Uses of the Canal were mapped by the intern and staff of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council early on in the process utilizing land use maps of the Counties, Department of Ecology Coastal Zone Atlas and personal knowledge of participants on the Advisory committee. The intern and Staff of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council then met with tribal representative to compare notes on land uses and to identify conflicting uses with tribal fishing and other resource activities. Staff also worked with boaters and recreational users including scuba divers, clam diggers, and oysters growers on a formal survey as well as an informal basis by doing personal interviews on conflicting activities at various locations during on site surveys of recreational opportunities. The intern then developed an analysis in relation to the Hood Canal Coordinating Council Goals and policies for presentation to the Council. Task 5: Identify and existing local and state programs and policies affecting Hood Canal resource management and analyze strengths and weaknesses and recommend improvements. Status: The Intern meet with representatives of the State Departments of Ecology, Parks, Fisheries, and Game to identify existing local and state programs and policies affecting Hood Canal resource management. Members of the local Oyster and Shellfish industries were more than willing to cooperate in a critique of programs and to provide individual insight. It is difficult from these comments to sort out the "stories" from the actual impacts but some conclusions about these programs and recommendations for improvements have been made and are included. The draft study outline is included as attachment "B". Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15, 1988 Page 4 Task 6: Identify economic and environmental impacts of shellfish harvesting by recreational and commercial users. Estimate impacts of increased recreational and commercial use and identify criteria for appropriate locations. Status: The intern utilized a number of County Environmental Impact studies as well as information from the Department of Ecology, Department of Social and Heath Services, and The Department of Agriculture and graduate papers available from the University of Washington, and Evergreen College. Comparing regional 0 figures with the slight amount of local information that is available from tribal and State sources that is directly attributable to the Hood Canal region. An estimate of impacts of harvesting of recreational and commercial users in a general way is possible. Increased use can then be estimated in a similar manner but with much less reliability due to the scarcity of specific information. What data is available has been noted and for future reference the sources identified so that as better information is made available the accuracy of the estimates tested and refined for future use. The final intern's report is attached by this reference as EXHIBIT "F". Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15. 1988 Page 5 ELEMENT 2: Development of a hood canal resources planning video The Hood Canal Coordinating Council will develop a video tape presentation depicting the unique role the Council has planned in dealing with the difficult regional problems at the local level. Emphasis will be on the environmental features (geology, hydrologic and habitat) and the benefits of local cooperation. Task 1: Identify consultant interested in preparing video. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council published a Request for proposal and received four written proposals which were reviewed by the full Council and a selection made. Task 2: Develop and execute contract for the production of video. Status: The Firm of North Pacific Film and Tape was selected by the full Council to provide a video tape. The Consultant Contract, budget and schedule is included as attachment "C". Task 3: Develop concept of video presentation and present to Hood Canal Coordinating Council including proposed visual and verbal concepts. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council requested that the Applicants for the video project include the proposed presentation and verbal concept for the consideration of receipt of the contract such that different concepts and ideas could be developed quickly and the decision as to both concept selection and consultant completed in a timely manner so that additional time would be available to the consultant to accomplish the final product. The visual and .verbal concept then became the scope of work of the consultant Contract. The scope of work is included in the contract attachment "C". 10 a Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15, 1988 Page 6 Task 4: Identify activities to be video taped and select appropriate visual presentation. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council Program Director worked with the Consultant to identify activities to be video taped which included activities of the tribes, and volunteers as well as those of the Council and Staff of the Jurisdictions as they went about the task of improving water quality and identifying resources important to the Council. Since emphasis is placed upon geology, hydrology and habitat the resources of tribal biologist and activities of the tribes toward habitat enhancement were of particular interest. The activities of community groups that were involved in monitoring, creek enhancement and establishing base line studies were thought to be most interesting if the tape is to be used for presentation for encouraging other groups to be actively involved in maintaining water quality in other areas or even to continue to encourage citizen participation among residents along and surrounding Hood Canal. Task 5: Develop Sound Track and Key to visual. Status: The preliminary sound tract was prepared by the Consultant and reviewed by members of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council's Education Committee. The Consultant then keyed the sound tract to the visual presentation and has shown the preliminary tape to the key persons on the Education Committee prior to final preparation of a draft to the Executive Committee of the Council. A written description of the draft tape is attached as attachment "D". Task 6: Review draft video with executive committee. Status: The Executive Board reviewed the draft video during June 1988 and developed a schedule for presentations to the full HCCC. The Education Committee was directed to establish a schedule for review of the final video with the Economic Development Councils of the Three Counties and to utilize the Video at Hood Canal Coordinating Council Exhibits at the Kitsap County Fair August 1988, Mason County Fair, August 1988, and Jefferson County Fair. The Shelton, Washington Oyster feast in October 1989 was also suggested as well as the Oceans Festival currently proposed for April, 1989 at the Kitsap Pavilion, Bremerton, Washington. Hood Canal Coordinating Council CZM Grant JULY 15, 1988 Page 7 Task 7: Present final video to Hood Canal Coordinating Council. Status: The Hood Canal Coordinating Council received the final video and six copies at the Hood Canal Coordinating Council July 1989 meeting. The Public was encouraged to attend and notices of the availability of the tape presentation were distributed such that additional community groups may utilize the video presentation. The Council has contracted under a separate program for the services of The Adopt A Beach program to identify and train volunteers for use in monitoring local streams, and for work with area farmers and tribal agencies in the Hood Canal Area such that the use of the video for such training and education purposes has received many screening. The video tape is attached by this reference as attachment "E" but is under separate cover. APPENDIX A STEVEN BOESSOW CONTRACT B DRAFT SHELLFISH AND RECREATION STUDY OUTLINE c NORTH PACIFIC FILM AND TAPE CONTRACT D DRAFT VIDEO SOUNDTRACK TEXT E ABSTRACT FOR VIDEO TAPE UNDER SEPARATE COVER F FINAL SHELLFISH AND RECREATION STUDY a APPENDIX A STEVEN BOESSOW CONTRACT 0 a a 0 a a NJ a a a AGREEMENT FOR CONSULTANT SERVICES THIS AGREEMENT, made by and between Kitsap County, 614 Division, Port Orchard, WA hereinafter referred to as "COUNTY", and STEVEN N. BOESSOW, hereinafter referred to as "CONSULTANT", residing at 1406 N. Puget Olympia, Washington 98506. WITNESSETH IN CONSIDERATION of the mutual covenants and conditions herein contained the parties do hereby agree as follows: 1. General COUNTY engages CONSULTANT to furnish the services hereinafter mentioned upon the covenants and conditions of this Agreement, at the compensation herein stipulated, and CONSULTANT accepts said engagement upon said terms. 2. Duties of CONSULTANT: Services to be Performed by CONSULTANT CONSULTANT shall perform such duties and services as are listed on EXHIBIT 'A' attached hereto, signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. Said services shall be performed in accordance with the time frame specified in EXHIBIT 'A'. 3. Services or Materials to be Performed or Furnished by COUNTY COUNTY shall perform such services or furnish such materials to CONSULTANT in connection with the perfonpance of this Agreement as set forth on EXHIBIT 'B', attached hereto signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. If there are no entries on said EXHIBIT 'B' , it is agreed that COUNT y Ishall not be required to provide any services or furnish any materials to CONSULTANT in connection with this Agreement. Unless otherwise provided on EXHIBIT 'B', all said services and materials will be furnished by COUNTY to CONSULTANT without cost to CONSULTANT. 4. Pay-,qent by COUNTY, Time and Manner of Payment COUNTY shall pay CONSULTANT for all services to be rendered by it and all materials to be furnished by it under this Agreement, the amount specifically set forth and in the manner specifically set forth on EXHIBIT 'C', attached hereto, signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. CONSULTANT agrees to accept said sum as full compensation for all services due under this Agreement. 5. Additional Work The CONSULTANT shall be entitled to extra compensation for services or materials not otherwise required under this Agreement, provided the COUNTY shall first have requested such extra services or materials in writing, but in no event shall COUNTY be liable for payment unless the amount of such extra compensation shall first have been agreed to in writing by COUNTY. Agreement, Page 2 Consultant Services 6. Professional Skill_ CONSULTANT represents that he is skilled in the professional calling necessary to perform the work agreed to be done by it under this Agreement. COUNTY relies upon the skill of CONSULTANT to do and perform its vnrk in the most skillful manner, and CONSULTANT agrees to thus perform its work, and the acceptance of its work by COUNTY shall not operate as a release of CONSULTANT from said Agreement. 7. Prohibited Interest 8 No member, officer, or employee of COUNTY shall have any interest, direct or indirect, in this Agreement or in the proceeds thereof. 8. Equal Employment Opportunit CONSULTANT shall not discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, creed, color or national origin. 9. Compliance with Laws CONSULTANT shall endeavor to comply with all Federal, State and local laws, statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations and the orders and decrees of any 0 courts or administrative bodies or tribunals in any manner affecting the performance of the Agreement. 10. In-dependent Contractor CONSULTANT is acting as an independent contractor in furnishing the services or materials and performing the work required by this Agreement and is not an agent, servant or employee of COUNTY. 11. Indeminity CONSULTANT agrees to indemnify and save harmless COUNTY their officers and employees from any and all costs, expenses, claims, liabilities or damages, known or unknown, to persons or property heretofore or hereafter arising out of or in any way connected with the negligent acts, errors or omissions of the CONSULTANT, its officers, employees, agents, contractors, subscontractors or any officer, agenct, or employee thereof for work performed under this Agreement. 12. Insurance: Workers Compensation CONSULTANT agrees to comply with all State requirements relating to Workers' Compensation Insurance. Agreement. Page 3 Consultant Services 13. County_Representative The Planning Department of COUNTY, through Clyde Stricklin, shall represent COUNTY in all matters pertaining to the services to be rendered under this Agreement; all requirements of COUNTY pertaining to the services and materials to be rendered under this Agreement shall be coordinated through said COUNTY representative. 14. Consultant Representative The President of CONSULTANT shall represent CONSULTANT in all matters pertaining to the services and materials to be rendered under this Agreement all requirements of CONSULTANT pertaining to the services or materials to be rendered under this Agreement shall be coordinated through the CONSULTANT representative. 15. Notices Unless otherwise provided herein, all notices required hereunder shall be given by certified mail, postage prepaid and addressed to the party at the address indicated in the opening paragraph of this Agreement provided, however, that in lieu thereof, notice may be given by personal delivery to the party at said address. 16. Reports Unless otherwise provided herein, the CONSULTANT shall submit written progress reports to the COUNTY with each billing statement. 17. Title to Doc uments All original calculations, design notes, reports and other material or documents developed or used by the CONSULTANT and its subcontractors in connection with the performance of this Agreement shall be the property of the COUNTY and shall be made available to the COUNTY by the CONSULTANT as follows: A. Completion of Agreement: As provided in EXHIBIT 'A' and EXHIBIT 'C' and, upon completion of the terms of this Agreement, the CONSULTANT shall furnish the required number of copies of its Reports and quality reproducible transparencies of all drawings and maps in a form acceptable to the COUNTY. All reports, docuTients, and materials shall bear the name of the CONSULTANT. B. Termination of Agreement: Upon receipt of a notice of termination, pursuant to the terms of the Agreement, the CONSULTANT shall: (1) promptly discontinue all services Agreement, Page 4 Consultant Services affected (unless the notice directs otherwise); (2) promptly notify all subcontractors and/or others providing related services to discontinue those services accordingly; and, (3) deliver in a satisfactory form to the COUNTY copies of data, drawings, specifications, reports, estimates, summaries, and such other information and materials as may have been accumulated by the CONSULTANT and his subcontractors in performing this Agreement. C. Use of Documents: The intended use of these documents, reports, and materials is to provide CONSULTANT services, said work program more fully set forth in EXHIBIT 'A'. The CONSULTANT will not be liable for the re-use of these documents, reports, and materials for any use other than that intended use, without the expressed written consent of CONSULTANT. 18. Assignment: Neither party shall assign or sublet any portion of this Agreement without the written consent of the other party in writing. 19. Termination Without limitation to such rights or remedies as COUNTY shall otherwise have by law, COUNTY shall also have the right to terminate this Agreement for any reason upon written notice to CONSULTANT. In the event of such termination, CONSULTANT shall be compensated for the actual Services performed or materials furnished through the date of receipt of notification from COUNTY to terminate. 20. Schedule and Completion of Studies The CONSULTANT shall commence work authorized by this Agreement following its execution. All work authorized by this Agreement shall be satisfactorily completed five (5) months following its execution. 21. Best Professional Effort The CONSULTANT acknowledges that the performances and services provided herein are important elements of this Agreement; accordingly the CONSULTANT shall put forth its best professional effort to complete the work in accordance with the schedule provided. 22. Entire Agreement; Amendment This writing constitutes the entire Agreement between the parties relating to the services to be performed or materials to be furnished hereunder. No modification hereof shall be effective unless and until such modification is evidenced by writing signed by all parties to this Agreement. 23. Miscellaneous All covenants herein shall be conditions. Time shall be of the essence. Failure on the part of either party to enforce any provision of this Agreement Agreement, Page 5 Consultant Services shall not be construed as a waiver or the right to compel enforcement of such provision or any other provision. The singular number shall include the plural and the masculine gender shall include the feminine gender and neuter gender whenever the context of this Agreement permits. 24. In the event legal action is instituted between COUNTY and CONSULTANT arising out of this Agreement the prevailing party shall be entitled to recover, in addition to costs, a reasonable attorney fee to be determined by the court, including an appellate court. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands the day and year first above written. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS KITSAP COUNTY, WA Commissioner ATTEST: Holly a. Clerk Cimmissioner Holly Clark, Clerk of the Board CONSULTANT Attachments: EXHIBIT 'A' CONSULTANT Services BY: EXHIBIT 'B COUNTY Services EXHIBIT 'C' Compensation Amount and Manner The CONSULTANT certifies that it complies with all State requirements relating to Worker's Compensation Insurance as required in CONSULTANT Agreement. BY: CONSULTANT BLANK/AGREE #2 EXHIBIT 'A' SCOPE OF SERVICES A. RECREATION STUDY -- Consultant will conduct research on the environmental and economic impacts of water-based recreational activities In the Hood Canal watershed. Research will be presented to the full Council in June of 1988 in the form of a written report and oral testimony to the Council. Consultant will work with an advisory group of state, local and tribal governments, ports and economic development councils, in developing the research guidelines for the project. Particular attention shall be given to assisting counties in gathering information to UPDATE local parks and recreation plans. Consultant will keep a record of activities and expenses and will report weekly to the Program Director on the progress of the project. The following information will be included in the final report: Part I Abstract, overview and introduction. Part 11 Current recreational! uses of the Cana!. descriptions of activities, agencies with management /enforcement responsibilities; seasons; openings; access sites; Inventories of facilities. Part III -_ Economic impacts to the Watershed: licenses, fees, state funding, local businesses (convenience stores, lodging and services.) Included also in this section would be local costs to provide services, such as emergency services, road and public docK maintenance and repair, traffic control, garbage/sewage disposal, and enforcement activities. Part IV -- Environmental impacts from recreational activities. This probably will be based on theoretical impacts, more than specifically identified or documented impacts, and should include a discussion of both impacts and mitigative measures currently taken or indentified as successful. Closures, with possible causes, on recreational shellfish beaches should be discussed. Part V-- Questionnaire results. A questionnaire will be developed with the assistance of the advisory group to determine local recreational uses and needs. Results will be used in forming recommendations for long-term recreational planning.. Part VII.-- Findings and recommendations. To also be included in this section would be identification, if needeed, of additional access sites to the Canal, and potential funding sources; synthesis with HCCC Shellfish Study; and recommendations to the Council for further action/investigation. Part VIII -- Bibliography B. SHELLFISH STJDY -- Consultant will conduct research on the economic value -of commercial and recreational shellfish harvest in the Hood Canal watershed. Research will be presented to the full Council in June of 1988 in the form of a written report and oral testimony to the Council. Consultant will work with an advisory group of state, local and tribal governments, ports and economic development councils, in developing the research guidelines for the project. The Mason County EDC has conducted a similar study and has donated all findings and original research materials to the Council to assist in this study. The Point-no-Point Treaty Council also has data that will be used in the study. Consultant will conduct surveys of existing economic data and literature and survey/interview shellfish growers, tribal fishermen and people involved in recreational harvest. Consultant will Keep a record of activities and expenses and will report weekly to the Program Director on the progress of the project. Written monthly reports will be submitted with vouchers. The following information will be included in the final report: PART I -- Introduction: Abstract, statement of purpose and methodology. PART 11 -- Overview and narrative on historical use of the Canal for shellfish harvest. To be included would be a discussion of trit-al harvest activities, treaty rights and the Soldt decision. (Section on tribal activities to be the responsibility of HCCC Program Director.) PAPT III -- Present activity, harvest site identification, economic value and species. PART IV -- Physical properties of the Canal as they impact growing/harvest conditions. PART V -- Potential for increasing harvest, habitat enhancement and aquaculture techniques. PART VI -- Threats to resource, includirg water quality data 4rom county/tribal surveys, regulatory inadequacies and closures. PART VII Survey results and analysis. PAPT VIII Findings/recommendations. PART IX -- Bibliography C. END PRODUCTS AND TIMELINE 1. Preliminary advisory group meetings shall be held no 'later than March 30, i988. 2. Questionnaires shall be approved by advisory groups no later than April 15th. B. Draft reports shall be submitted to the Council no later than May 30th. 4. Minutes of all advisory board meetings shall be submitted along with regular monthly reports. EXHIBIT 'B' COUNTY SERVICES the COUNTY will provide the CONSULTANT with the resources necessary to perform the services outlined in this Agreement and which are agreed to by the Hood Canal Coordinating Council. These services to be provided by COUNTY may include the use of meeting rooms and access to information and staff. EXHIBIT 'C' -COMPENSATION AMOUNT AND MANNER I Upon submittal of products and progress reports by task on County forms, setting out actual hours worked and allowable expenses meeting the requirements set forth in the State of Washington's "Financial Guidelines for Grants Management', CONSULTANT shall be reimbursed as follows: The contract sum paid to the CONSULTANT shall be the total sum of Six Thousand Dollars($,6000.00). Payments shall be monthly for five months at One Thousand, Two Hundred Dollars. In addition, the CONSULTANT will be reimbursed by the COUNTY for all expenses incurred in the performance of the services outlined in this Agreement. This is not to be over Two Hundred Dollars($200.00) per month without advanced permission from the COUNTY. CONSULTANT agrees to maKe every effort to keep these expenses to a minimum. I APPENDIX B DRAFT SHELLFISH AND RECREATION STUDY OUTLINE z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 gh w PART 1: INTRODUCTION I. Contents II. Abstract III. Introduction IV. Methods PART 2: HISTORICAL N%RRATIVE I. Historical Uses of Hood Canal A. Tribal 1. Locations 2. Species B. Non-Indian 1. Locations 2. Species C. Changes in Species 1. Olympia>Pacific>01ympia Oyster 2. Manila and Softshell Clams II. Indian Rights A. Past Treaties B. Past Tribal Harvests C. Boldt and Boldt II Decision III. Geological history A. Formation of H C B. Current and Flushing Characteristics C. Substrate and Shorline Make-up PART' 3: PRESENT ACTIVITY 1. Harvest A. Site Identification 1. Sites presently under cultivation 2. Licensed, but not used 3. Unlicensed with potential 4. Traditional Indian Harvests 5. Decertified or Uncertifiable B. Economc Value 1. From Individual Species 2. Froin the Fishery as a Whole 3. To tne Surrounding areas C. Species- Descriptions/Life history 1. Manila Clams 2. Butter Clams 3. Horse Clams 4. Geoduc 5. Eastern Softshell Clams 6. Pacific Oyster 7. Olympia Oyster 8. Shrimp (cmTnercial?) D. Methods 1. Of harvest 2. Of Raising _4 3. Of Breeding/Seeding PART 4: FUPURE OUTLOOK I. Increasing Harvests A. Better Habitat Managment B. Efficient Aquaculture Technique c. inproved Species 1. Triploid oysters 2. Hardier, ftDre resilient Strains D. Additional species 1. Scallops 2. mussels II. Threats to Resource A. Water Quality B. Regulatory Inadequacies C. Predators D. Increasing Populations PART 5: SURVEY I. Survey Results PART 6: OONCLUSION (Same as for Recreation) I. Findings and Recomendations Il. Appendices A. Questionnaire B. Relevant Documents 1. Boldt and Boldt II 2. maps 3. Charts and Graphs III. Bibliography PART 1: INIRODUCrION I. Contents II. Abstract III. Introduction IV. Methods PART' 2: TYPES OF RE)MEATION I. Recreational uses of Hood Canal A. Shellfish 1. Oysters 2. manila Clams 3. Horse Claus 4. Butter Clams 5. Geoduc 6. Shrimp 7. Crab B. Boating C. Fishing 1. Salmon 2. Bottomfish 3. Freshwater D. Passive activities 1. Beachcombing 2. Hiking 3. Cwrp i ng II. Management/Enforcement A. Regulatory agencies 1. Shellfish 2. Fish 3. Boating a. licensing b. enforcement B. Seasons and Restrictions 1. All Marine Wildlife C. Laws and Requirements 1. Boats III. Facilities A. Mar i na s 1. Size and Scope of operation 2. Amenities 3. location B. Boat Ramps C. Carrpgrounds 1. Size 2. Amenities 3. Limitations 4. Location D. Access Sites 1. Type of access a. Boat only b. Walk/Boat only c. Nearby Parking 2. Location of Access 3. Discription 4. Limitations PART 3: TOURIST RELATED IMPACrS AND BENIFITS 1. Econcrrdc Benifits to the Region A. License Fees B. Direct travel related spending C. Taxes D. State Spending II. Economic Inpacts A. Road Maintenance B. Public Dock and Ranp Maintenance C. Traffic Control D. Garbage Disposal E. Sewage Disposal F. Emergency Services 1. Ambulance 2. Fire 3. Police G. Non-E7ergency Enforcement 1. Routine Police Calls 2. Fish and Shellfish Enforcement 3. Boating Enforcement III. Environmental Inpacts A. Septic Systezs B. Boats 1. Oil 2. Sewage 3. Garbage C. Marinas 1. Boat Pollution 2. Traffic 3. human Activity D. human Activity 1. Disturbing to Wildlife 2. Squashes and Trarriples E. Stormwater 1. Road Runoff a. oil b. toxins 2. Building Runoff 3. Agriculture/grounds Runoff a. fertilizer b. pesticides c. herbicides d. erosion F. Shellfish Closures 1. Fecal Choliform a. failing septic systems 2 b. inprcper waste disposal (boats) c. seals 2. Locations 3. Standards for Closure IV. Controlling Environmental Degradation A. Boater Education 1. Use ot MSDIs 2. Oil Disposal 3. Understanding Marine Ecosystems B. Adherance to Strict Planning Policy 1. Approved Septic Systems 2. Proper Placement of Shoreline Inprovements 3. Strict Zoning Codes C. Shoreline and Upland Land Owners Education 1. Dangers of Household Chemicals 2. Dangers of Yard Care Chemicals D. Tourist Education 1. Respect Wildlife 2. Understand H C's Ecosystems 3. Understand Game Regulations E. Consistent Enforcement 1. Shellfish and Fish Takes 2. Littering and Dumping (boats) 3. All Septic Systezs and Punp-out Stations PART 4: QUEST1044-IRE PART 5: COW-LUSION 1. Findings and Recomendations II. Appendices A. Bibliography B. Copies of Questionaires C. Copies of relevant Documents I 0 APPENDIX C NORTH PACIFIC FILM AND TAPE CONTRACT 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 z AGREEMENT FOR SERVICES FOR HOOD CANAL COORDINATION COUNCIL VIDEO THIS AGREEMENT, made this 0-'3 day of 1987 by and between Kitsap County, Port Or ard, Washington, 'hereinafter referred to as "COUNTY", and North Pacific Film and Tape, 108 South Jackson, Suite 201, Seattle, Washington 98104, hereinafter referred to as "CONSULTANT". WITNESSETH IN CONSIDERATION of the mutual covenants and conditions herein contained the parties do hereby agree as follows: 1. General COUNTY engages CONSULTANT to furnish the services hereinafter mentioned upon the covenants and conditions of this Agreement, at the compensation herein stipulated, and CONSULTANT accepts said engagement upon said terms. 2. Duties of CONSULTANT: Services to be Performed by CONSULTANT CONSULTANT shall perform such duties and services are listed on ATTACHMENT 'A, enclosed, signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. Said services shall be performed in accordance with the time frame specified. 3. Services or Materials to be Performed or Furnished by COUNTY COUNTY shall perform such services or furnish such materials to CONSULTANT in connection with the performance of this Agreement as set forth on ATTACHMENT 'B', enclosed, signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. If there are no entries on said ATTACHMENT 1B1, it is agreed that COUNTY shall not be required to provide any services or furnish any materials to CONSULTANT in connection with this Agreement, Unless otherwise provided on ATTACHMENT 'B', all said services and materials will be furnished by COUNTY to CONSULTANT without cost to CONSULTANT. 4. Payment by COUNTY, Time and Manner of Payment COUNTY shall pay CONSULTANT for all services to be rendered by it and all materials to be furnished by it under this Agreement, the amount specifically set forth and in the manner specifically set forth on ATTACHMENT 'C', attached hereto, signed by the parties, hereby referred to and made a part hereof by reference. CONSULTANT agrees to accept said sum as full compensation for all services due under this Agreement. VIDEV.1:PG 5. Additional Work The CONSULTANT shall be entitled to extra compensation for services or materials not otherwise required under this AGREEMENT, provided the COUNTY shall first have requested such extra services or materials in writing, but, in no event shall COUNTY be liable for payment unless the amount of such extra compensation shall first have agreed to in writing by COUNTY. 6. Skills to be Provided by CONSULTANT CONSULTANT represents that it is skilled in the calling necessary to perform the work agreed to be done by it under this Agreement. COUNTY relies upon the skill of CONSULTANT to do and perform its work in the most skillful manner, and CONSULTANT agrees to thus perform its work, and the acceptance of its work by COUNTY shall not operate as a release of CONSULTANT from said Agreement. 7. Prohibited Interest No member, officer, or employee of COUNTY shall have any interest, direct or indirectV in this Agreement or in the proceeds thereof. 8. Equal Employment Opportunity CONSULTANT shall not discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, creed, color or national origin. 9. Compliance with Laws CONSULTANT shall endeavor to comply with all Fedral, State and County laws, statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations and the orders and decrees of any courts or administrative bodies or tribunals in any manner affecting the performance of the Agreement. 10. Independent Contractor CONSULTANT agrees that it is acting as an independent contractor in furnishing the services or materials and performing the work required by this Agreement and is not an agent, servant or employee of COUNTY. 11. Indemnity CONSULTANT agrees to indemnify and save harmless COUNTY their officers and employees from any and all costs, expenses, claims liabilities or damages, known or unknown, to persons or property heretofore or hereafter arising out of or in any way connected with the negligent acts, errors or omissions of the CONSULTANT. 12. Insurance: Workers Compensation CONSULTANT agrees to comply with all State requirements relating to Workers' Compensation Insurance. -2 13. COUNTY representative The Kitsap County Department of Community Development, through Clyde Stricklin, shall represent COUNTY in all matters pertaining to the services to be 0 rendered under this Agreement; all requirements of COUNTY pertaining to the services and materials to be rendered under this Agreement shall be coordinated through the said COUNTY representative. 14. CONSULTANT representative Tom Putnam shall represent CONSULTANT in all matters pertaining to the services and materials to be rendered under this Agreement, all requirements of CONSULTANT pertaining to the services or materials to be rendered under this Agreement shall be coordinated through the CONSULTANT representative. 15. Notices Unless otherwise provided herein, all notices required hereunder shall be given by certified mail, postage prepaid and addressed to the party at the address indicated in the opening paragraph of this Agreement provided, however, that in lieu thereof, notice may be given by personal delivery to the party at said address: 16. Reports Unless otherwise provided herein, the CONSULTANT shall submit written progress reports to the County as set out in Attachment W. 17. Title to Documents All original reports and other material or documents developed or used by the CONSULTANT in connection with the performance of this Agreement shall be the property of the COUNTY and shall be made available to the COUNTY by the CONSULTANT. 18. Assignment Neither party shall assign or sublet any portion of this Agreement without the written consent of the other party. 19. Termination Without limitation to such rights or remedies as COUNTY shall otherwise have by law, COUNTY shall also have the right to terminate this Agreement for any reason upon written notice to CONSULTANT. In the event of such termination, CONSULTANT shall be compensated for the actual services performed or materials furnished through the date of receipt of notification from COUNTY representative. 20. Schedule and Completion of Studies The CONSULTANT shall commence work authorized by this Agreement following its execution. All work authorized by this Agreement shall be completed to the County's satisfaction by June 30, 1989. 3- 21. Best Professional Effort The CONSULTANT acknowledges that its performances and services are important elements of this Agreement; accordingly the CONSULTANT shall put forth its best professional effort to complete the work in accordance with the schedule provided. 22. Entire Agreement; Amendment This writing constitutes the entire Agreement between the parties relating to the services to be performed or materials to be furnished hereunder. No modification hereof shall be effective unless and until such modification is evidenced by writing signed by all parties to this Agreement. 23. Mi scel 1 aneous All covenants herein shall be conditions. Time shall be of the essence. Failure on the part of either party to enforce any provision of this Agreement shall not be construed as waiver or the right to compel enforcement of such provision or any other provision. The singular number shall include the plural, and the masculine gender shall include the feminine gender and neuter gender whenever the context of this Agreement permits. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands this,-?87i, day of 1987. KITSAP COUNTY BY: CKIRMAN L3,6-@Apz Or- Cow-miss"ERS EXHIBITS: EXHIBIT 'A' Consultant Services CONSULTANT EXHIBIT 'B' County Services BY: EXHIBIT 'C' Compensation The CONSULTANT certifies that it complies with all State requirements relating the Worker's Compensation Insurance as required in CONSULTANT'S Agreement. L Tom Putnam North Pacific Film and Tape VID67.4A w I Ift w ATTACHMENT 'A' SCOPE OF WORK a 0 HOOD CANAL VIDEO PROJECT RECOMMENDED APPROACH As described in the RFP, the Hood Canal Video is a hybrid. It will be primarily an informative piece, yet in order to capture the hearts and minds of the audience, a sense of place and ecology should be established. The primary goal will be to convey the history, organization, cooperative nature, and effectiveness of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council. This must be done in the context of ecological integrity of the region as a whole and the Hood Canal in particular. Attention must also be paid to the diverse interests and groups involved in this cooperative effort. These interests must be identified. A preliminary survey suggests communities, local governments, economic interests such as timber and fisheries, Indian tribes, and recreational interests as all having an important stake in decision-making around Hood Canal. We recommend attention to several specific details: 1. Watershed issues and impacts. A watershed analysis will tie together both east and west sides of the Canal, an dpromotes a holistic view. 2. One or two specific case studies of the work of the HCCC. It would be useful if they involved several of the previously mentioned interest groups, and if they emphasize first, how a cooperative approach was necessary to solve a problem, and second, how the HCCC assisted in the solution. Specific recommended procedures are as follows: 1. PRE-PRODUCTION a. Orientation- Producer learns the history of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council (and Hood Canal), attends one or more meetings, and visits sites for location shooting. b. Consultation- Identify primary issues and outlook for the video, primarily revolving around the watershed/nonpoint pollution concerns. As described in the RFP, focus should be on identifying geographical and environmental significance of the Hood Canal watershed and present issues threatening the Canal's ecosystem. Also identify major sources and resources: Local governments, tribes, timber, fish, and recreation interests, etc. Identify primary interviews, probably one from each interest group. Research one or two major case studies which illustrate the structure, operation, and issues the Council is involved with, and how it operates. c. Write script and production outline in consultation with Council members and staff. PRODUCTION: All material will be shot in high quality video or shot in film and transferred to video for final edit. 1. On-site footage and interviews 2. Survey existing footage resources for cost-effectiveness. North facific has some excellent footage of cost-effectiveness. North Pacific has some excellent .footage of Puget Sound in general and of watershed related items. We also have access to underwater footage which might be desirable. dk POST-PRODUCTION: Editing, mixing, and dubbing ow 1. Editing: Roughcut, finecut stages will be major points of review by Council and Staff. 2. Music and sound effects will be added at final sound mix. TIMELINE AND PRODUCTION SCHEDULE: MONTH 1 MONTH 2 MONTH 3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Orientation Research and script Location Photography Editing ----------- Roughcut Review Finecut Review Narration and Effects Dub Tape copies PRODUCTIONS FACTORS A. GOALS * educated the audience about the structure, activities and purposes of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council. * Provide general enlightenment on the integrity and complexity of the Hood Canal and its relationship to Puget Sound, to the forest ecosystern, and to local geomorphology and hydrology. stimulate local action in other watersheds by providing a model. recognize and perhaps enhance the cooperative effort among diverse groups mentioned earlier in promoting effective actions to help solve nonpoint pollution problems around Hood Canal. elucidate the management strategies used by the Council for cooperative resource planning. B. BUDGET: The bid for the video is $12,000. Comment: Producing a ten-to-twelve minute video for this budget will require precision, and dictates an expository rather than documentary approach. It 2 will have to be well scripted and conservatively shot, rather than a documentary approaqh which allows for shooting large amounts of material and lets the story tell itself. NONPOINT POLLUTION ISSUES Nonpoint pollution is the result of numerous individual and collective actions, most of which are not perceived by the public as having any connection to water quality. The problems of nonpoint pollution are both diffuse and overlapping. They are both urban and rural, and it is difficult to measure relative contributions from various sources as well as to prioritize strategies for prevention. It is a problem which must be attacked simultaneously on many fronts. Some factors: septic tanks, logging practices, farming practices, urban runoff, household hazardous wastes, and airborne pollution. It would seem probable that rural factors are more in evidence than urban-related ones in Hood Canal. The recently concluded Timber/Fish/Wildlife agreement suggests that much of the problem lies in factors rooted in awareness and communication. Integrative policies are just beginning to be adopted. Practices in diverse areas have not been aware of those in other areas. This is a feature in which communication in general can make the difference, and hopefully the video will point this out and promote such communication iteself. Due to the magnitude and complexity of the public education task involved in nonpoint pollution, and the technical, social, and political aspects of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council's activities, a primary factor in the effective production will be substantial research and coordination with the Council's technical staff. The producer should be chosen partially on the company's ability to do the research, on its background in environmental issues, and its familiarity with the complex factors involved in nonpoint pollution. North Pacific has demonstrated such capabilities in previous work. 3 ATTACHMENT 'B' COUNTY SERVICES The County has contracted with Lela Hilton-Perez to coordinate activities of the Hood Canal Coordination Council. Lela Hilton-Perez will work with the consultant to provide background information and to obtain information necessary to complete the project. 4 ATTACHMENT 'C' C014PENSATION AMOUNT AND SERVICES Contract sum to be paid to the consultant shall be the total sum of twelve thousand dollars ($12,000.00). Payments shall be made upon completion of each phase of the project. Phases are identified in the scope of work as: Phases: I. Start Up: $3,000 II. Orientation Research and Script* $3,000 III. Location Photography* Editing $3,000 IV. Rough Cut Review $3,000 Fine Cut Review* Narration and Effects Dub Tape Copies* T1-2,000 *Materials to be furnished Of I z APPENDIX D DRAFT VIDEO SOUND TRACT TEXT lb 0 0 0 0 0 0 NORTH PACIFIC FILM & TAPE 108 South Jackson Suite 201 Seattle, Washington 98104 (206) 623-2130 623-3151 HOOD CANAL VIDEO SCRIPT DRAFT WITH CORRECTIONS March 18, 1988 Contact: Tom Putnam North Pacific Film and Tape 108 South Jackson, Suite 201 Seattle, WA 98104 (206) 623-3151 3/18/88 page I DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT SCRIPT: HOOD CANAL VIDEO AUDIO VISUALS INTRODUCTION: NARRATOR: In the Hood Canal, water ties everything Wetlands with early together. Human activities- from morning sun reflected in aquaculture, fishing, and recreation- to the web of small agriculture and forestry, either affect or waterways are affected by the quality of water., Farmers, fishermen, tourists, residents, and Waterfall native peoples all have a vital interest in keeping Hood Canal's waters and watershed Shellfish gatherers at clean. low tide In a landscape which can include Logging conflicts between resource exploitation and Fishing boats habitat preservation, between shellfish growers and small farmers, between indigenous peoples and local governments, to name only a few, it is important to remember the common values of beauty and ecological integrity which bind residents of the Hood Canal region together. 11. DESCRIPTION OF HOOD CANAL: dk Three interview segments: 1. Aesthetic/Recreational- e.g., resident on Resource groups beach: Wildlife "we have a special place here. It's natural, it's quiet-- it's a reminder of how Scenic Beauty, perhaps beautiful nature can be..." Walker Mountain overlook Resident on Beach 2.' Economic: e.g., shellfish grower: "There have been a number of closures of Commercial shellfish shellfish harvest areas in the past few years-that's something new. our industry grower/harvester at depends on clean water ... We have to work to workplace keep development and pollution from ruining the biological resources..." 3. Environmental/indigenous people: "In the space of a few years, we've seen the beginnings of damage to the environment and to the resources. With care and Native American in education, we can preserve the area for illustrative setting future generations..." A. PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION: NARRATOR: The Hood Canal is a 61-mile long fishhook-shaped fjord forming the westernmost Map showing Hood Canal boundary of the Puget Sound Basin. Location The canal possesses rich geological diversity. Forested and snowcapped mountains Aerial shot of Hood ranging up to 8,000 feet lie to the west. Canal, showing forests These mountains are drained by five major and mountains river systems. Low lying hills surround the water to the south and east, where a majority of River and river delta development has occurred. Bordering the Canal are: South Canal area showing bulkheads and homes two Indian Reservations, the Port Gamble/Klallam in the north, and the Skokomish in the south; Shots of reservations a large military installation-- the Navy's Submarine Base at Bangor; Bangor sub base if several fish hatcheries; available county, state and federal parks; shellfish growing and seed-producing Fish hatchery facilities; a Department of Fisheries shellfish Park laboratory; recreation facilities, a sawmill, Commercial shellfish hydroelectric installations, and permanent as operation well as vacation homes. Shellfish lab sawmill, Tacoma City Light installation, homes B. RESOURCES: The Hood Canal hosts a rich diversity of Scenery wildlife and biological resources. Estuarine areas function as scenic and recreation Wildlife areas, and provide flood reduction, pollution control, fish and wildlife support, storm and Fishing erosion control, water supplies, and education and research areas. River estuary, probably Economic resources include shellfish Dosewallips growing and harvesting, with the potential for doubling production. Oyster and clam harvest oysters, clams, shrimp, geoducks, crabs, and smelt are harvested both commercially and Shrimping recreationally. Timber harvest provides many jobs and contributes to the Hood Canal's economic base. Above all, Hood Canal is a watershed. The quality of water depends on activities Running water during from the crest of the mountains to the bottom rainstorm of the Canal. In the upland areas, development, farming, and timber practices Mountains all have effects on water quality. Stream near farm It is vital that all residents of the Canal understand the ways that everything is connected to everything else. 111. PROBLEMS: INTERVIEW: Compared to some other areas in greater Wetlands Puget Sound, Hood Canal is still in relatively good shape. But there are problems. South shore homes There is a growing awareness of the Canal's vulnerability to water pollution. Septic tank pumping Rapid population growth has led to nonpoint pollution from failing septic tanks, Erosion and siltation poor farming practices, and erosion and siltation from building sites. Shellfish closure sign Shellfish closures have increased, threatening recreation and commercial harvest. Declining populations of salmon and Mouth of Canal, open bottom fish have been noted. water Although the average depth of the Canal is between 500 and 600 feet, shallow sills located near the mouth prevent good circulation and vertical mixing of water. Hood Canal takes much longer than other Puget Sound embayments to complete an exchange of sea water. The economic base of Hood Canal depends largely on biological diversity, and on reconciling activities which are sometimes in conflict with each other. A. INTENSIVE POPULATION AND DEVELOPMENT - PRESSURES NARRATOR: The pristine beauty of the Hood Canal Tourist and recreation has made it a vacation and tourist activities - destination for many years. But more and more people are making it a permanent home. The conversion of vacation homes to permanent residences and the development of the tourist New Housing and industry are leading to increasing population construction pressures on the environment. Population doubled in the shoreline areas of Hood Canal between 1970 and 1980. Many places in'the Crowded shoreline homes Basin also have steep slopes and poor soils which increase the Canal's vulnerability to pollution. Septic tank maintenance The problems of failing septic systems are compounded by soil conditions, leading to increasing bacterial contamination of the Wetlands near river mouth waterways. The estuarine areas most affected are often the most fertile grounds for shellfish culture. Nine areas of the canal Polluted stream have been restricted for shellfish harvest. Poor farming practices, animal manure, Marinas siltation and household chemicals contribute to contamination of the Canal. Stream siltaion Untreated sewage and other wastes from boats and marinas is another problem. Another source of pollution is soil Trash on shore erosion, siltation and flooding from poor forest practices and road building. Besides threatening resource production, such conditions threaten wildlife habitat and degrade the qualities of the environment that make it attractive to tourism. IV. SOLUTIONS: Aerials of south shore NARRATOR: area showing development The Hood Canal is thus caught in the modern dilemma common to many areas of great beauty and productivity: economic development to provide homes and jobs leads to a degradation of the beauty which attracts people in the first place. 10 Ultimately, the problems are not entirely solvable. But aggressive actions are being taken to protect and enhance water Monitoring quality in the Canal, and to preserve its unique beauty and diversity. Fishing The complexity of the problems requires cooperative planning and resource management, and so the Hood Canal Coordinating Council was formed in 1985. The aims of the Council are long-range HCCC MEETING planning, intergovernmental coordination, and citizen involvement and education. The membership and history of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council reflect the region's diversity and some of its conflicts. Members Closeup of individual consist of representatives from county representatives to the governments, tribes, and the Puget Sound Council Water Quality Authority. It is the union of tribal, local and state government interests, and the determination to replace antagonism with communication and cooperation, that has made the Council unique. INTERVIEWS: What are some of the On-camera interview with accomplishments of the Council? (Possible Council member(s) answers: Communication and networking; Adoption of Hood Canal Planning Policy; Public Education and awareness.) Why has it been successful? (Possible answers: first time some members have worked together, from coordination of local government septic tank practices to discussion of tribal concerns.) ALSO: initiation of studies to gather more information to locate pollution sources Slides of early meetings, and speed clean-up. if available NARRATOR: The first phase of the Council's activities focused on self-education and Cover of HC Regional Plan evaluation of the Canal's problems. The second phase included setting priorities and making recommendations, culminating in the Hood Canal Regional Planning Policy. Some recommendations in the Planning Pumping and maintenance Policy included the following: of septic tanks -site sewage facilities in the 1. On Hood Canal Watershed should be inspected, and Houses and bulkheads on pumped if necessary, every three to five shore years. minimum standards should be developed by local governments for design, siting, 64 cohstruction, and maintenance of on-site sewage systems and alternative technologies. Existing systems should be upgraded when possible if they do not meet such standards. 2. Best-management practices for agriculture should be keyed to water quality protection as well as production. Measures may include fencing of animals away . from Best management practices streams and waterways, careful application of for agriculture, like fertilizers and pesticides, and minimal animals fenced away from interference of runoff with natural streams - waterways. 3. For forestry activities, Best Management Practices should be developed which emphasize protection of habitat, - wildlife, and instream and downstream Forest practices - resources. The recently concluded TIMBER/FISH/WILDLIFE agreement reinforces the illustrative of best Forest Practices Act as the source for Best management practices. Management Practices. 4. New and expanded marinas should be required to have pump-out facilities and disposal facilities for portable toilets. Marina scenes Incentives should be developed for installation and improvement of marine sanitation devices. Siting of new marinas and expansion of existing ones should CONSIDER impact on local shellfish resources and other sensitive areas. THE HOOD CANAL COORDINATING COUNCIL IS SPONSORING A BOATER EDUCATION PROGRAM TO HELP BOATERS UNDERSTAND Shoreline development HOW THEY CAN HELP PREVENT POLLUTION ON THE with water obvious in CANAL. shot 5. County Shoreline Master Plans should develop and incorporate minimum standards for protection of regional water quality and water-based resources and activities. shellfish gathering 6. in developing long range planning for Hood Canal, local agencies should pay particular attention to shellfish protection. wetlands, wildlife 7. The local planning process should also include emphasis on identification and preservation of wetlands and other biologically significant areas. PRIVATE LAND Oil recycling station TRUSTS LIKE THE HOOD CANAL LAND TRUST WETLAND HAVE A GREAT POTENTIAL FOR PROTECTING WILDLIFE HABITAT. APPENDIX A: SHOT/LOCATION LIST AQUACULTURE- Oysters, clams, shrimp, etc. Agriculture- animals near streams Fishing, shellfish harvest Recreation- boating, marinas, hiking Forestry- logging activities and impacts Monitoring- sampling, testing Rapid population development (near shoreline or waterway) Tribal activities, including fishing Sawmill at Port Gamble Shellfish Research Lab at Point Whitney, Dabob Bay Mt. Walker Scenic Overlook Aerial photography Seals, wildlife Wetlands, estuaries, rivers Land Trust at Lynch Cove Fish hatcheries Sign of shellfish closure Septic tank work, inspection and pumping Soil erosion HCCC meeting Naval Base at Bangor Hood Canal Bridge Olympic Mountains APPENDIX B: Potential Interviews (Partial List) County reps to HCCC Tribal Reps to HCCC Margery Redmond Steve Ralph Harold Wiktsen, oyster grower Indians: future generations/myth-allegory Timber Industry rep e.g. Mike Yeager- re; TFW Shoreline resident APPENDIX C: REQUIRED RESOURCES Contact with interest group reps like timber, fishing, developers, etc..-- will be more specific later 8. Alternatives should be investigated for disposal AND SOURCE CONTROL of household hazardous wastes such as motor oil, pesticides, insecticides, etc. 9. The achievement of these and other Shot showing crowd of goals will depend very heavily on the residents; e.g., opening education, involvement, and cooperation of day of shrimp season the residents of Hood Canal. The Hood Canal Coordinating Council, County governments, TRIBES, and local Conservation Districts will People on streets, in all work to educate citizens to voluntary parks, etc. compliance with good practices. INTERVIEW: "We need to take measures now to preserve and protect our environment. The Council's activities and the unprecedented effort at cooperation and coordination of local planning and management efforts give us On-camera interview the opportunity to take control of our own destiny. If we fail, we're going to see outside entities like the state and Federal Government come in and do it for us." V. SUMMARY: NARRATOR: Establishment of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council has been an innovative Cover in interview or attempt to address problems locally, in a location shots spirit of cooperation, among groups and interests that have traditionally been in conflict. Substantial progress has been made. But the very nature of the problems mean that they will be present virtually forever. The importance of local cooperation and communication is paramount. Sacrifices must be made, and at times individuals will be called on to work for the interests of the common good. This is the accommodation which nature demands; it is also a measure of the worth of the treasure that is the Hood Canal. APPENDIX E ABSTRACT FOR VIDEO TAPE UNDER SEPARATE COVER z e It .W Abstract Title: Hood Canal Video Project Author: North Pacific Film and Tape Subject: The Development of the Hood Canal Coordinating Council and the Resources they seek to preserve. Date: July 15,1988 Departments: Washington State Department of Ecology, Kitsap County, Mason County, Jefferson County, Clallum Indian Tribe, Skokomish Indian Tribe and the Point No Point Treaty Council. Source of Copies: Copies may be obtained from the Kitsap County Department of Community Development, 614 Division Street, Port Orchard, Washington 98366. WDOE Project Number: G 0088041 Series Number: V1 Number of Pages: N/A Abstract: An educational and yet very scenic video tape containing many photographic examples of the resources of Hood Canal that the jurisdictions that exist along the shore have chosen to preserve and the identified difficulties encountered along the way to a coordinated policy for growth and development. !o APPENDIX F FINAL SHELLFISH AND RECREATION STUDY ,.4 SHELLFISH AND RECREATION INDUSTRIES OF HOOD CANAL PREPARED FOR THE HOOD CANAL COORDINATING COUNCIL BY STEVEN BOESSOW AL The preparation of this report was financially aided through a grant from the Washington State Department of Ecology with funds obtained from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and appropriated from Section 306 of the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972. ABSTRACT Title: SHELLFISH AND RECREATIONAL RESOURCES OF HOOD CANAL Author: Steven Boessow Subject: This report identifies the available information on shellfish and recreation activities within Hood Canal. Date: July 15,1988 Departments: Department of Ecology, Kitsap County, Jefferson County, Mason County, Clallum County, Skokomish Indian Tribe, and the Point No Point Treaty Council. Source of Copies: Copies may be obtained from the Kitsap County Department of Community Development, 614 Division, Port Orchard, Washington 98366. z WDOE Project Number: G 0088041 Series Number: RI Number of Pages: 86 Abstract: The study of shellfish and recreational resources of Hood Canal is divided into two parts. PART I is titled the "ECONOMIC REVIEW OF THE SHELLFISH AQUACULTURE INDUSTRY". This report defines the current (1988) shell fish aquaculture industry and it's needs through use of a survey of the local aquaculturist, and previous studies and research. It is intended that this study be used in conjunction with other documents to assist local governments to help plan for shoreline and upland development. PART II is titled "THE RECREATION INDUSTRY : AN OVERVIEW". This report defines the water based recreational activities and identifies economic benefits and impacts related to these activities. Where possible, suggestions have been made as to what is needed to maintain the resources of the Canal and what specific information is needed to facilitate future study. 0 1 z PART I: ECONOMIC REVIEW OF THE SHELLFISH AQUACULTURE INDUSTRY 0 9 -1 J -4 if INMDUCTION Shellfish aquaculture has been a major industry in some areas of Washington, including Hood Canal. In order to protect the industry from encroachment by developers, pollution, and restrictive aquaculture guidelines county and state agencies must have accurate, current information on the needs of the industry. There are few industries which rely so heavily on access to clean, unpolluted waters, and relatively rural settings. As the region grows and the economic climates change it becomes more and more difiicult to ensure that weter quality standards can be met. It will take the eftorts oi all concerned to draft a plan for the future that rreets the regions desire for growth while protecting the local shelltish industry. This report will define the current shellfish aquaculture industry and it's needs through use of results of a survey of the local a-4uaculturists, and through previous studies and research. It is intended that this study be used in conjunction with other documents to allow local governirpants access to information to help plan for shoreline and upland developement. HARVEST SITES In 1@87 there were 91 shellfish farms registered with the Washington State Department of Fisheries. This includes registration by tideland owners who do not or only sporadically market there shellfish. Most of the shellfish are grown in Dabob and Quilcene Bays, many others are located in the Brinnon area and across the canal around Seabeck. other growing areas include Belfair, Lilliwaup, Hama hasw-a, and Fishermens Harbor. The FarffLs have concentrated in these areas mainly because the tide flats are suitable to production level aquaculture, and because, in the case of Dabob bay, -water circulation prevents oyster spat from drifting far, increasing chances for large sets. According to the survey of growers done for this study, up to 21.5% ot the registered shellfisn growers do not market their sheiltisn. Some are willing but lack the information to get started, otners feel that registering their beaches gives them mra proLection or rights against poacning or trespassing, still others have had bad experiences in getting started or leasing out their tidelands. These registered tidelands represent a potential resource or presuri-kably productive beaches. As suitable bottom. culture grounds make up a minority ot Hooa Canal's coastline tnis is a resource to look into. If the selected growers are representational of all of the growers then there is perhaps some 3413 acres or more of tidelands- currently wider cultivation for one or more species in Hood Canal. The majorit-y of this land is privately owned. It is unknown how much land is available or suitable for aquaculture. A lot of Suitable tideland is held by the Department of Natural Resources (DNR), Washington State Department of Parks, and other local, state, and federal agencies, and is reserved for recreational harvest. Still more is either privately owned in small parcels, or part of community beaches and reserved for private use. Three areas on the canal have been restricted or have had commercial shellfish harvests closed altogether. Though this represents a small area compared to that of the canal it is significant because these areas are in or near some very rich, yet very sensitive shellfish beds. Closures or restrictions are the result of high levels of fecal choliform, an easily detected organism that is used by DSHS to indicate the presence of other, more harmful pathogens in the water. DSHS monitors all commercial shellf ish growing areas and several recreational sites. When a problem is discovered then closer, more frequent monitoring occurs. The tip ot Lynch Cove in southern Hood Canal is closed to all commercial shellfish harvesting. This has affected at least 2 growers and caused concern that the problem may spread. Adoitional monitoring of the water is being done to pin-point the sources and correct the problems. Several on site sewage system (septic tanks) were known to be malfunctioning and other possible sources were guessed at, including runoff from pastured livestocK, boating activity, and feces from marine birds and mammals. The headwaters of Quilcene Bay are also closed. The same types of sources (non-point source) are responsible here as in Lynch Cove. There are about six growers within close proximity of the closed area, and n-any more in the area just outside of Quilcene Bay. Unlike the closed areas, Dosewallips is restricted. This means shellfish may be harvested but must be transfered to an approved site for cleansing several weeks before being sold. Cleansing takes place as the shellfish eat in clean waters. Two comTiercial sites exist in the area, and the Point No Point treaty tribes harvest clams and oysters from the tidelands at Dosewallips State Park. -W LIFE RIMQRY & DISCRIPTION OF CU44ERCIIAL SPBCIM OYS.UER6- Olympia oyster- Ostrea lurida The Olympia oyster is in a class called the flat oysters. It is a small grayish oyster, about 5 cm long. Flat oysters have an unusual (among shellfish) life history, in that males release the sperm into the water column but fertilization occurs in the females shell and she later releases free swimming larvae. The larvae remain free swimming for several weeks and then settle onto a solid surface, usually a rock or another oyster shell. The Olympia oyster is susceptible to dessication and is f0und in tide pools, under rocks, and, when cultured, in diked pon(i s. Before the turn of the century Olympia oysters formed reefs along trie rmuthes of streams. These layers of oysters hel,?eo to control their teffperature and reduce water loss. These reefs were quickly destroyed by early settlers, who had to then build dikes and ponds- to raise suitable numbers of oysters. Pacific oyster- Crassostrea gigas The First Pacific oysters arrived in Washington State from Japan in the 1920's, after the decline of the Olympia oyster. The Pacific is a large, haray, cupped oyster, meaning it is about as different from an Olympia as oysters can get. In the Spring, as the water iAanns, the Pacific oysters "ripen". Then when the temperature rises suddenly, spawning is triggered, and this spawning triggers others to spawn. Unlike in the Olympia, 4 fertilization take.:; place in the water where the larvae quickly hatch and start their planktonic lifestyle. They reimin free swimming for about 3 weeks and then settle onto rocks or shell. Pacifics can survive nearly up to the mean high tide level, and can withstand temperature extremes and fluctuations, as well as brackish water. It's shell is all white and heavily fluted, often twisted and mishapen frcm growing in clumps with other oysters. It grows to over 25 crn, but it is harvested at many sizes depending on the intended use. CIAMS Tnough each species of clam differs slightly in its spawning time or teaperature requirements, their basic life cycle remains the same. wan-n spring temperatures ripen the sexually mature clams, and then a sudden rise in temperature or the spawn of other clams triggers the release of sperm and eggs in the water. Fertilization takes place in the water wiiere the eggs soon hatch into tree swimmiag larvae. Several weeks and several larval stages later the larvae loses the ability to swim and must find a suitable habitat to settle in. Proper substrate is only one consideration for site selection, as certain clams do not settle in areas ot high concentrations of adults of the same species. Manila clain- I-apees japonica The ivanila, or Japanese littleneck clam is an accidental import brought in with Pacific oyster seed. it is a hardshell clain about 7 cm. across, marked with dark patches on a grayish sheli. It has both radial and concentric ridges, with the radial ridges being the more prominent. Manila clams are founa right up to the mean high tide level in gravel or mixed mud, sand, and gravel. Although it does reproduce naturally in Washington waters, many growers suppliment nature with hatchery raised seed. Native littieneck- Protothaca staminea Tnis sinall nards-iiell clain resembles the Manila in looks and habitat. It has both radial and concentric ridges on the shell, which is a grayish white with no dark patches. The native littleneck is found below the mean high tide level of gravel and mixed gravel beaches. This clam was the mainstay of the steamer clam industry until the introduction of the Manila, and still is harvested and sold by some clam and oyster growers. Butter clam- Saxidomus qiqanteus The butter clam is found in mixed sand, mud, and gravel beaches fran about the +1 foot tide level, subtidally to about 60 feet deep. The shell is chalky white with only concentric lines marking the surface. It will dig as deep as 30 cm into the substrate, rmking harvesting butter clams more time consuming than llstewzrars", but offering them greater protection against predators and weather conditions. hor.-.ie clam- gaper clam- Tres capax This large clam is found as deep as 50 an in mud or sandy mud. Its' common name, gaper clam, refers to the gap present at the siphon when the shell is closed. The siphon, coarse and leathery at the tip, aliTiost, but not quite fits completely into the shell when retracted. Tne shell can reach about 20 cm across, and is chalky white with a brown periostracum (the thin flaky material present on the outer edges of the shell). Geoduck- Panopea generosa The shell or this giant ot a clam is no larger than that of the horse clam, but the siphon, when retracted my still extend out 25 cm or so. Consequently, the geoducK cdn be found as deep as 75 cm down in the mud. it is typically a subtidal clam, reacning depths of greater than 155 feet, though it may be found on the beach during extremely low tides. The shell is elongated and slighily squared looking. It is white with a yellowish periostracum. These clams are harvested in underwater lots, leased by the Department of Natural resources. SCAILOPS Though most scallops are hermaphroditic, the four species found in Hood Canal all have seperate sexes. They spawn, like many other bivalves, by releasing sperm and eggs into the water to be fertilized. They then go through a free swimming stage, in which the shell is forming, before settling on the bottom. After they settle they may renuin semi-mobile like the pink scallops or anchor themselves to a rock or other solid object like the rock scallop. Scallop aquaculture is very rare in this state. In fact the only scallop farm in Washington is in the weter oft Point Hannon in northern Hood Canal. They raise all four of the species of scallop common to the area, and are cooperating with State biologists and the University or Washington to help expand the undersLanding of scallops and to refine methods of culture in this relatively new industry. Pink scallops- Clamys hastata & C rubida Pink scallops are the smallest scallops in Washington waters. They have uneven "ears", one being larger than the other, and are usually encrusted with a light yellow sponge on their upper shell. Tney rest on the surface of sand or gravel substrates to about 180 feet. As juveniles they my attach themselves, by means ot bysuss thread.,--,, to the bottom. as they grow they release their anchors and becaue able to move, sort of, by rapidly opening and closing their shells. This "jet" propulsion is used wfien they sense danger. Weathervane scallop- Pectin caurinus Weathervane scallops are characterized by their even, or same sized "ears", and their large size (to 15 an). They rest on mud or sand bottoms to 300 feet and are only known in a few areas of the state, one of which is northern Hood Canal. Rock scallop- hinnites giganteus After the free swim-ning stage, the rock scallop cements itself to a boulder or rock ledge, and stays there for life. Rock scallops have a thick heavy shell often encrusted with other organisms, and partially eaten at by burrowing worms. It can grow to over 15 an and has a very large adductor mussel. The size of the adductor mussel and the relatively short time it takes to mature makes this scallop a likely candidate for swcessial aquaculture. AQUACULTURE TECHNIQUES Tne majority of oyster growers in Hood Canal use bottom culture and rely on hand harvesting. By virtue of operating on the canal, oyster growers are taking advantage of the large Pacific oyster sets that the area is known for. Some suppliment this by seeding their beach with hachery seed, and others set out cultch and collect their own seed. SE;ED: There are several ways of gathering oyster seed. The most comnon, and the most economical for the average grower, is setting out racks from wfiich oyster shells, or culch, are hung. The shells my be in net bags, or wired to ropes, and are then placed one the loweest parts of the tidelands when the oysters are spawning. 'Ibe oysters set on the shells at a rate of 10 to over 100 per shell, ana may then be set out on the beach, as is, or seperatea and grown individualy. Some iiood Canal growers specialize in selling just the seed to growers in and out of the canal. One grower uses permanently mounted racks to collect seed for his oyster farm in Skagit County, where the oysters grow much faster than in the canal. Several growers operate hatcheries, where seawater is pumped through tanks and teiTperature is controlled to bring the oysters into spawning condition. This method has the advantage of being able to raise specific species or strains of species, and to raise triploia, or sexless oysters, that have the advantage ot not spawning, thus being marketable all year long. BOTTOM CULTURE: Bottom culture is the term used for any shellfish grown on or in the beach itself. At its simplest the beach is simply harvested of whatever oysters happen to grow there. For higher production, or in marginal tidelands, the beach may be built up with gravel and shell. In the past, dikes were built to hold back water for Olympia oysters. Some beaches are even treated with the pesticide Sevin to kill ghost shrimp, which loosen the mudflats, and suffocate the oysters. There are several levels of intensity that bottom culture may represent. As a general rule, an increase in the level of intensity or complication should bring with it an increase in the density or size of the oyster in order to be worthwhile. STACKING TRAYS & RACK AND TRAY: In protected bays and areas where the substrate in not suitable for oyster production, rack and tray or stacking tray culture may be used. In rack and tray methods, a wooden or rebar rack is placed out on the beach at the desired tide level. Attached to the rack is either a mesh bag or tray filled with individual oysters of the sam size. This has the advantage of being up off of the beach, free from predators and situation. They are easily harvested and ideally will remain fairly even in size. Some of the drawbacks are that being up off the beach and held together in bags, they are susceptible to heavy wave action and being fouled with seaweeds and flotsam. They are also more time consuming, as the oysters must be transfered to different bags as they grow, and the bags must periodically be cleaned of algae, and other marine life that impedes water circulation. Stacking trays are similar in priciple to rack and tray culture. Thin trays are stocked with individual oysters and then I stacked 10 or so high and strapped together. these stacks of trays are set out at the desired tide level either on the surface or on a rack or support. Stacking trays offer the same advantages and drawbacks rack and tray culture. both methods offer benefits to those with beaches too soft or too irregular for bottom culture, and they allow an increase in production for the amount of land used. Like other types of aquaculture, an increase in the complexity and cost of the culture method should be balanced by an increase in productivity of the tidelands. RhFTS & LOW@LENES: i,-antern or pearl nets suspended from rafts or longlines otfer the ability to raise oysters offshore in areas with little or no beacIli. 1-hey also protect the oysters from predation, while producing a faster growing, very marketable oyster. ho;Aever tne aciditional equipment need-ed is expensive, and friuch ot the labor is done fran boats or floating platforms. ari-ey are more susceptible to bad we-ather and fouling by seaweeds, mussels, and other organisms. Special permits and leases are required, and there is often opposition to placing floating structures over fishing grounds or in navigation lanes. Floating oyster culture probably isn't practical for hood Canal for a variety of reasons; Much of the canal is unprotected fran high winds that can uproot floating structures, and due to the slow growth of Hood Canal oysters, the payback periou for the additional equipment is often extended beyond what is reasonable. srAKE cuuiuRE: stake culture has been used in this State, in muddy or silty tideflats. The method involves driving a wooden or plastic stake into the ground so that it extends abOut eight inches above the bottom. Then a single cultch shell with seed is secured to the top of the post where the oysters grow to size. an alternative method uses rows of stakes with a rope attached across the top of each stake, and cultch shells inserted into the strands of the rope. precautions must be taken to properly position and secure the ropes, as the weight of tne rope and growing oysters are susceptible to wind and waves. Although both of these methods keep the oyster off of the bottom they are still able to be taken by predators, either from above by diving birds, or from below by oyster drills and sea stars that are still able to climb the stakes. Tnere are many variations ot all or these methods in use tilrougnout the world. Many local growers have ri-odified these, or invented their own inethods to fit the species and the region. also, as technology advances and shellfish beomies more in demand, we can expect to see more and better ways to raise more oysters. CLAMS Although several species of clams are harvested in hood Canal, only the manila is cultured intensively. Also the Manila is the only clam with readily available hatchery seed. Experiments with floating and suspended clam culture have been done, but so far the only mthod practiced in Washington is bottom culture. To increase the yeild trom a piece of land growers use two basic practices, control the predators, and enhance the habitat. Predators such as ffcon snails and sea stars, and competetors such as mussels are usually picked oft the beach by hand. Crows, gulls, scoters, anQ others are detered by placing netting over newly seedecl beach. Manila and littleneck beds- are also regularly turned over to aerate and clean out the gravel. If needed pea gravel may be brought in to produce a suitable habitat for the clams. one method of increasing the numbers of some species ot clams is to harvest the larger ones. Geoduck spat in particular will not settle where there are already large concentrations ot adult geoducks. The same may also be true of other species as well. Because clams live in, rather than on the substrate, they are less suited to the various methods employed in oyster aquaculture. The most probable areas for advancement will come from improving hatchery methods for seed production, and perhaps in the developeinent ot improved strains of clam that grow faster or live longer out of the water. Except for the geoduck, harvesting clams is done by hand. in the case of shallow clams like the Manila and the littleneck a rake, or clam, fork may be used. deeper clams like the horse and butter must be dug out. Geoduck harvesting employs more axnplicated methods. Divers, working from a boat, use water jets to dig out the geoducks, and then pick them out by hand. Rather than harvesting owned tracts of land, geoduck harvestors must obtain leases on subtidal lots controled by the Department of Natural Resources. SCAL60PS Scallops are currently being raised in lantern nets and pearl net9 attached to lines and bouys (longlines). Though the project is small, the owners have net with some success and have plans for improving and enlarging their operation. There is definitely the potential for greater yeilds, as methods of ML raising spat in tanks, and collecting them in the wild are improved. ARVESTS- 1981 SPECiEs AREA TYPE LBS EACH WASHINGrON Butter Clam upper 1 3091 13482 Geoduck upper 1 147353 116268 3924074 lower 1 591 435 Native upper 1 18005 107974 littleneck upper 2 860 central 1 1055 central 2 2321 lower 1 0 lower 2 526 manila upper 1 155274 upper 2 402 central 1 0 central 2 1291 1 owe r 1 637 lower 2 0 Pacitic upper 1 71257 8143 1562862 oyster central 1 112234 12826 lower i 2566 293 1- Coirmercial harvests from registered shellfish farms. 2- Coraiierciai tribal harvests. weights tor clams include the shell. Weights for oysters are meat only. HARVESTS- 1982 SPECIhS AREA TYPE Le* EA Butter Clain all 0 9174 Geoducks- all 0 331766 Native upper 1 2591 40589 littlenecks upper 2 198 central 1 0 middle 2 140 Manila upper 1 36015 1372880 upper 2 .0 central 1 0 central 2 553 Pacific upper 1 186506 21314 1830484 oyster central 1 110710 12652 loiAer 1 7277 831 J_ rcial harvests from registered shellfish growers corm e 2- coinnercial tribal narvests weignts for clactis include the shell. Weights for oysters are ineats only HARVESTS- 1983 SPECIES AREA TYPE LBS ENCH WASHING"TON Butter Clams upper 1 130U 24712 central 1 261 Geoduck all 0 3176653 Native upper 1 0 88607 littleneck upper 2 412 central 1 150 central 2 32 lower 1 0 lower 2 144 manila upper 1 38210 1637244 upper 2 0 Pacific upper 1 229706 26294 2272419 oysters central 1 180412 20617 lower 1 9338 1067 1- Commercial harvests frcin registered shellfish growers. 2- ccainercial tribal harvests. vveights for clams incl@Ae tne shell. Weights for oysters are ffeats only. HARVESr- 1984 SPECIES AREA TYPE LBS FACH WASHIN=N Butter clam all 0 3681 Geoducks all 0 3316391 Native upper 1 494 20595 littleneck upper 2 0 Manila upper 1 44518 2305244 upper 2 0 central 1 162 central 2 129 lower 1 0 lower 2 90 Pacific upper 1 570060 65147 2282855 central 1 149055 17034 lower 1 39311 4492 1- Commercial narvests from registered shellfish growers. 2- Commercial tribal harve3ts. 4eights for cla,,ms include snell. Weights for oysters are meats only. HARVESM- 1985 SPECIES AREA TYPE LBS FACH WP1SHI1%,1MN Butter clam central 1 7373 8740 Geoduck central 1 50558 21867 3358385 Native upper 1 2477 161712 littleneck upper 2 1672 central 1 0 central 2 196 lower 1 0 lower 2 1875 manila upper 1 36725 2831300 upper 2 73168 central 1 55791 central 2 537 lower 1 0 lower 2 430 Pacific upper 1 36725 53127 2327248 oyster upper 2 3763 429 central 1 165667 18932 central 2 0 lower 1 139016 15887 1- Coni-nercial harvests from registered shellfish growers. 2- Camercial tribal aarvests. HARVESTS- 1986 SPECIF.15 AREA TYPE POUNDS EAai WASHINGION butter cl&n upper 1 1180 3129 upper 2 71 central 1 1787 central 2 91 Horse cl&n upper 1 446 446 Geoduck central 1 119496 57346 1866605 Native upper 1 357 68652 littleneck upper 2 15838 central 1 0 central 2 8567 lower 1 0 lower 2 868 manila upper 1 95136 1413509 upper 2 168195 central 1 76757 centrai 2 62364 lower 1 0 lower 2 20880 Pacific upper 1 230648 26358 1289977 oyster Lipper 2 28265 3229 central 1 136412 15589 ce-nLral 2 5435 621 lower 1 29239 3341 lower 2 23890 2729 1- Ccmnercial narvests from registered shellfish growers. 2- Coru-nercial tribal narvests. ',Neights for cl&ns include shell. Weights for oysters are for ffeats only. FwuRE ourLooK R-)R SHELLFISH INDUSTRY ItCRI-ASIW3 HARVESTS As the demand for quality fresh seafood increases, so too will harvests. At least that is the plan of some of Hood Canals shellfish growers. For many of the small growers, increasing their tidelands yield means spending more time working the shellfish, or paying somebody else to do it. often they choose to under-produce just to keep tne business manageable. most of the oyster growers interviewed for this study felt that they could sell more than they currently grow, but what they are currently selling was planted three to five years ago. This means b-ot -they must predict up to five years in advance what the market conditions are -going to be. Also, growers who depend on natural sets to restock their beach may have a lot of shellfish from one year-class and very few frcm others. The latter can be overcome by seeding the beach with hatchery seed or culch, to offer a stable and consistent product to buyers. The former, predicting economic trends in advance, is more difficult but most reports show that Americans are eating more seafoods-, and demanaing fresher and higher quality seafoods. This translates into increased sales for those who are able to increase production. Because iiood Canal is so exposed to the weather, and because shellfish grow slower in the canal than in other areas, floating aquaculture is not a3 economical at this time. This means that production increases must come froin better management of bottcxn culture techniques, and frciii increasing the acreage devoted to aquaculture. The most roan for improvement is f ran the small part-time'operations. Typically they lack the funds, time, and expertise needed to keep their beds producing to their potential. A likely method for increasing the productivity of the canal is to expand the typical oyster and clam industry, and include other types of shellfish. Scallops are already being tried on a small scale, and have met with some success. Blue mussels, abundant in t-be northwest, are being raised in many areas throughout the world, including Puget Sound. It seems reasonable to assume they may have potential in Hood Canal. Oyster growers have available faster growing strains, able to withstand harsher conditions, and oftering better taste. Some of these strains, such as the KuTainoto oyster, will not spawn in the colder waters oi 4ashington, making them marketable year round. Another way to sell whole oysters year round is to raise triploid or "sexless" oysters. At present these are available only to growers with spawning tanxs, and none of these growers have made the seed available comercially. Per!-iaps a new industry could be developed supplying triploid seed to interested growers. if an increase in the productivity of the canal is desired or expected then the aquaculturists must feel secure that they can expand and invest time and money with a reasonable chance that they will not be forced out by increased fees, stricter regulations, or deteriorating water quality. Many of the smaller growers or licensed growers who are non-comnercial do not maximize the use ot their tidelands simply because they either do not undrestand the entire permit process, or they want better assurances f rom the state that they will be able to raise shellfish, and sell them, without the threat of land disputes, pollution, excess regulation, and shoreline development. THREATS TO THE RESOURCE POLLMION, Pollution is the nLraber one threat to cormiexcial shellfish growers in hood Canal, and elsewhere in the state. The effects of pollution go beyond the actual closing of beaches. As more attention is focused on polluted shellfish beds, and the subsiquent health risks, the public will become more wary of unprocessed or fresh seafood. Also, the harder growers must work to find clean water, either for grow-out or cleansing, the higher prices will have to go. in the past industrial wastes, mostly pulp mills, were the prime concern of shellfish growers. The pollutants killed the larvae, decimating some of the nust productive areas. Today the pollutants are from human and livestock wastes. Far from killing the shellfish, these wastes are a nutrient source on which the shellfish thrive and grow. However these shellfish nay then harbor pathogens dangerous if ingested. The Department of Social arid health services (DSHS) is the agency responsible for monitoring the @Aater and approving beaches for commercial harvests. They report that the most likely causes of the closures and restriction in hood Canal are from failing and improperly installed septic systems, high concentrations of boating activity, improper care of livestock and other farm animals, and marine fowl and marnals. Proper planning at the local level, and changing the publics attitudes toward the responsibilities of land ownership are critical to the long term success of any clean-up measures, and to preventing further 01 degradation. PRED-MRS Predators are a concern in any aquaculture site, though they are one of the mre controlable problem faced. The oyster drill is of state-wide concern. it was accidentaly imported, like the Manila clam, with Pacific oyster seed from Japan. Seed and oysters heading out of the canal -to be planted must have transport permits certifying that they are free from oyster drills. other predators, such as sea stars and moon snails my be picked oft of beds at low tide and disposed of. If population densities are too high, or too much land is involved netting and fencing can be used with measured success. Birds can be a problem, eating small oysters afid clams. Barrow's golaeneye, gulls, scoters, and crows have all been implicated in damaging shellfish beds. Netting can be placed down over freshly seedea clai-,k beas. The best protection for serious bira problem;ii is floating aquaculture using lantern or pearl wts or one of the methods involving mesh bags or trays. Crabs prey on small clams and oysters, and to sofre extent on larger clams wiien they can dig them out. Crabs, can be harder to control as rmst equaculturists will rarely see them up on the beach. Irapping them, or perhaps mesh fencing should keep the problem manageable. REGULnIORY PRLx:E_ss Smie of the people in the sarvey canplained that state and local governinents were over-regulating the shellfish industry. They voiced concerns that they were being needlessly subjected to long, often expensive permit and leasing requirements. An ex&nple of what some conplained was unfair and expensive was a policy requiring those leasing tidelands to pay to have the the lana surveyed and staked. Most felt this was the responsibility of the state, and that that was what sone of the lease payments should be going toward. The rising costs of permits is a concern to some growers. One report is that a Department of Ecology permit for discharge of seawater from hatching tanks- has risen 1400% to $1500 in one year. The irony of this situation, says the grower, is that his operation is considered the same, in terms of permits and requirements, as a pulp mill. Some policies and fees are in need of revision. But for the most part, the licensing, certification, and permit process does serve the best interests of the grower, the public, and the enviroruTent. Survey: Total Registered Shellfish Fanners- 91 Total Nunber Surveyed 51 Percentage Surveyed 56% Breakdown of surveyed license holders Out of Business 6 11.8% Non-Cminercial 11 21.5% Ccmmercial 34 66.7% NuTLber of growers for each species listed Pacific oyster 32 94.1% Kuyamoto oyster 1 2.9% Olympia oyster 2 5.9% manila Clam 8 23.5% Native Littleneck Clam 2 5.9% Butter Clam 1 2.9% Eastern Softshell Clam 1 2.9% Mussels 1 2.9% Scallops 1 2.9% Average ot 1.4 species per grower of species grown of growers Percent of growers 1 25 73.4% 2 4 11.7% 3 4 11.7% 4 0 5 2.6% ML DARKErs Countyl Washington U. S. Foriegn of Growers Supplying Market2 17 19 5 1 I- much of the product sold within the county is sold to larger growers acting as wholesalers, the ultimate destination being outside of the county. 2- Scme growers supply several markets Breakdown of primary (first round) sales markets. These percentages include growers supplying both wholesale and retail markets. Wholesale 73.9% Retail 26.1% Production Has production ijcr,@!ased or decreased over the past five years? of Growers Percentage increased 15 57.7% Decrease6 5 19.2% Same 6 23.1% Total mmiber ot respondents- 26 Problems Please indicate the major obstacles you have faced in trying to develope your aquaculture business? of Growers percentage Permits State Regs 14 28.6% DSHS Pollution 9 18.4% Poaching/Vandalism 7 14.3% Inaians 6 12.2% 'I'reaty Rights Climate 5 10.2% No Obstacles 4 8.1% Other 4 8.1% Tideland Area acres owned 806.9 of owners 22 acres Leased 215.1 of Leasors 5 Total acreage 1022.1 of Growers 25 Acreage Under 606.2/59.3% Cultivation Upland Acreage Used tor Processing, 34+/- Sales, etc... average 5.7 acres per grower of growers Utilizing 6 Upland Acreage 10 hhployees of Enployees; (FTE) of Growers Percentage < 1 15 44.1% 1-5 14 41.2% 6-lU 4 11.8% > 10 1 2.9% of arployees (actual) of Ehployers 0 1Pr 2 2Pf 2 3Pi, 2 1Fr 3 2Fi- 2 3FI' 2 5F1 6FI' 10 Fr 36 7S 2 7FI-6 S 4F11-8 PI-13 S 2F.L,'- 3 PI, Rit:=Full Time Pit---Part Time S=Seasonal BIBLOGRAPHY Chaiton, S.A. and S.K. Allen. "Early Detection of Troploidy in Larvae of Pacific Oysters, Crassostrea gigas, by flow Cytomoetry." Aquaculture, 48: 35-43, January 1985. Chaves, Linda. Experimental Mussels at Seabeck Bay. Washington Sea Grant, 1975. Cheney, Daniel P. and Thomas F. Mumford. Shellfish and Seaweed Harvests of Puget Sound. Seattle: Washington Sea Grant. 1986. Chew, Kenneth K. Prospects for Successful Manila Clam Seeding. Washington Sea Grant. 1975 Clam and Mussel Harvesting Industries in Washington State. Prepared by the Oceanographic Institute of Washington. 1981. Economic Development council of Mason County. Private Marine Aquaculture survey. Mason County, June 1987. Economic Development council of Mason County. Mason County's Aquaculture Industry. Mason County, September 1987. Glude, John B. " The Effect of Scoter Duck Predation on a Clam Population in Dabob Bay, Washington." Proceedings National Shellfish Association, 55: 73-86, 1864. Inveen, Daniel C. The Aquaculture Industry in Washington State: An Economic Overview. Prepared for the washington State Department of Trade and Economic Developement, Olympia. Washington, May 1987. Magoon, Charles, and Richard Vining. Introduction to Shellfish Aquaculture in the Puget Sound Region. Washington State Department of Natural Resources, Olympia. 1984. Recent Innovations in Cultivation of Pacific Molluscs. D.E. Morse, K.K. Chew, and R. Mann ed. New York: Elsevier Science Publishers B.V 1987. Saunders, Robert S. Shellfish Protection Strategy. Washington State Department of Ecology. Olympia, 1984. Van Pelt, Gretchen, The Mechanics of Clam Production. 1987 Washington Sea Grant, Small Scale Shellfish Farming Workshop. Olympia Center, Olympia. Februrary 6, 1988. Washington State Department of Agriculture, Governor's Aquaculture Conference. Tyee Hotel, Tumwater, Washington. January 30, 1988. t @4 ti 4 0 '7 14 R4 QW, 1 A W. f r ,W"W X N Aj Ot r wfA 'Xi y I n d 1cate be I ow A h emonths y om 4"3 you h ir eandIf they a r ef u I11,@'Al-toi"(FT) t.10t P T 9 JAN FEB MAR @APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC 10. Indicate the composition of your labor force. Use number and FT or PT. laborer technician (2 year vocational training) technologist Bachelor of Science Degree) Scientist (Masters or PhD) 11. How would you rate the availability of labor for aquaculture? Good Fair Poor 12. Has your production increased or decreased over the past five years? How much? 13- Please specify the reasons for growth or decline in production Cie. disease, unstable markets, regulations), 14. Do you see your production Increasi.ng or decreasing over the next five years? MR,7 ,WnA I At , - W@j At A 16. 0, v 04 4 * '34A r t W. ,"I , I wml@ oii J 17. P I eas e I n d I a "t acf,,b@$ 4,1,64,V-4 A. r y I A.a c 6 d 1 n to develo.Re. y,o v a q:u a c u,,l t e b U S n e s s r 18. Please Indicate the major issues you feel aquaculturists on Hood Canal and in Washington will face in the future. Briefly explain why. 19. Are you familiar with the County's Shoreline Master Plan? Do you feel it promotes and protects aquaculture? give examples 20. Please comment on state environmental legislation, where you feel it is strong, where you feel it is weak, and what changes you would like to see 21. Please comment on land use regualtions, where they are strong and weak, and where you would make changes. I I PART II: THE RECREATION INDUSTRY: AN OVERVIEW ol 0 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 1. Introduction 2. Recreation on hOod Canal 5. Parks, Tidelands, and Public Access Sites 10. Moorage 13. Sport Fishing in the Hood Canal Region 16. Mason, Kitsap, and Jeffeson County Tourist Figures 20 Employment 25. Economic impacts of Tourism on County Services 27. Environmental impacts 32. Conclusion and Recomendations 34. Bibliography INMDUCTION hood Canal has long been a destination for travelers seeking an afternoon picnic, a weekend getaway, or a long vacation. Attracted by the pristine waters and undeveloped shorelines tourists now make up a large industry on the canal. It is important to know who chooses to visit the canal, why, and what effects they have upon the economy and the environment. This report will define the water based recreational activities on Hood Canal and explain the economic benefits and iffpacts related to these activities. Where possible, sixggestion have been rrade such a6 to how best to maintain the envirotinental integrity of the canal, and what specific information should the counties keep in order to facilitate future reports. RECREATION ON HMD CANAL Hood.Canal offers many miles of shoreline, hiking trails, a variety of lodging services, and scxa-- of the best shellfishing in the State. People using Hood Canal are drawn by its features, facilities, and the close proximity to Seattle, Tacoma, and Everett which make it convenient for day or weekend trips. iiood Canal has numerous public beaches with oysters and clams available for picking or digging. In addition there are crab and the hood Canal Spot Shrimp. The Spot Shrinp have become an industry for the canal, attracting thousands of people from all over t' northwest and beyond. The season he is short, usually about 5 vieeks-, but the numbers of people ano the services and equipment they require can mean economic survival to sirail marinas and resorts. Divers frequent hood Canal for the deep, clean water and the abundant fishes and invertebrates. Although divers a-re restricted fra-n taking oysters, they my collect scallops, crab, ana. bottomfish. Mary divers choose to not take fish or shellfish, but dive only tor the sites. one of the characteristics that make diving in the canal so interesting is the shear underwater cliffs formed by the same glaciation that carved out the canal. Divers can often find these walls within swimming distance from shore. Boating has always been a popular activity on Hood Canal. Any given sumn-er day one can see a variety of boats from sail ana rowboats to small outboards and large cabin 2 cruisers. Boaters can enjoy free moorage at several public parks as well as privately operated nmrage facilities complete with fuel, stores, and other amenities. Also available only to boaters are the numerous parks that are boat access only. These are often just tidelands without upland facilities, but they offer a more private or less populated area to gather shellfish and beachcomb. Fishing on Hood Canal is a popular sport encompassing many age and skill levels. By far the most exciting and alluring of the game fish is the Chinook or King Salmon. It's large size and excellent eating attract many anglers during their ii-LigraLion back to their home streams. Coho and steelhead are also fish that attract a lot of attention. Fish that are only recently caning into their own, in terms of anglers attention and recognition by Department of Fisheries, are bottomfish. Bottomfish consist of all cod, lingcod, greenling, flounder, sole, sculpins, rockfish, seapearch, and related species. 1988 is the first year that a license is needed for the taking of bottomfish. In the past size and limit restrictions were also much inore liberal or non-existant. Lately their has been the realization that the bottoinfish is a mjor sport fishery in need of protection anu regulation. The ricx-)d Canal watershed, consisting of much of tne upland area on the west sia-e of the canal, contains miles of hiking trails for day and overnight hikes. Olympic National Park and several other recreational areas hold numerous _4 3 rivers and streams for raf ting, kayaking, or f ishing. Many lakes ana Cushman Reservoir also offer boating and fishing. Tne variety of water based activities available on and around Hood Canal are broad enough to attract a wide range of people with different needs and interests. It's close proximity to major metropolotin areas and the long stretches of undeveloped shoreline add to the popularity of Hood Canal. As more developement takes place in other parts of Puget Sound, and more pressure is felt by growing populations it seems sure that Hood Canal will benefit frcm the increased market for year round customers. 10 4 PARKS, TIDEANDS, AND PUBLIC ACCESS SITES Hood'Canal has at least 45 public parks, ramps, or access sites directly on Hood canal. These range from full service caqp9rounds to limited access tidelands. Similarly the canal's upland areas also have recreational options that include backpacking, trailer camping, fishing and boating. About 35% of the public parks and tidelands aLre boat acces only. Most of these are tidelands managed by the Department of Natural Resources (DNR), some have upland areas and picnic or camping facilities and are maintained as State Parks. Limited access tidelands are not well known or well marked so that they don't always recieve the same volume ' other areas might, this makes them all the more inviting to those who use them. The majority of cauipgrounds and tidelands on the canal are accessible by car, bike, or boat and are well used during the summer months. During the shrimp season, and on some weekends, all cairpsites are full and cair@pers make use of some ol the roadside pull-outs as campgrounds. likewise, moorage stays full during peak season and weekends also. Public moorage is limited, with about 56 slips or bouys available throughout the carial. Many boats also anchor just offsnore of public beaches and park-s. On the other hand, private marinas offer over 350 wet, overnight slips. When transient anct dry moorage is taken into account the number jumps to 663 spaces. Because information was not available on one of the marinas it is likely that the number is somewhat greater. Figure 1. Parks, tidelands and public access sites- Mason County Acres Picnic Camp- Boat Launch Moorage Acoess* Shoreline sites (lanes) (ft) Port of Allyn 1 C 30 Boat Ramp Belfair State 59.8 47 184 C 3520 Park Twanoh State 174.7 ill 62 3 11 C 2867 Park Harvey 8.0 F 1405 Rendsland State Park hood Canal 4.7 30 2 C 1000 Recreational Park hood Canal 10.0 C 600 Salmon hatchery Hoodsport, C 2951 Beach 43 Potlatch State 57 82 37 5 C 9570 Park Union Public 1.0 2 C 30 Launching Area Dewatto Bay, beach 41A B 514 Beach 413 B 713 hood Canal, Beach 46 B 1643 Beach 47 B 900 Beach 48 B 9072 Jorsted Creek Beach Lilliwap C 4122 Public Beach Liliwaup Tide- C 4122 lands State Park B- Boat access only F= walk-in access only C= Accessible by car Figure 2. Parks-, tidelands, and public access sites- Kitsap County Acres Picnic Camp- Boat Launch Moorage Access* Shoreline sites (lanes) (ft) Foulweather B 3364 Bluff, Beach 64 Teekaleet 3 10 C Bluff Salisbury Point 5.6 10 3 C 520 County Park Kitsap memorial 57.6 72 56 C 1797 State Park Scenic Beach 71.2 78 50 C 1600 State Park Anderson Cove, B 2145 Beach 40 B- Boat access only C= Accessible by car Figure 3. Parks, tidelands, and public access sites- Jefferson County. Acres Picnic Camp- Boat Launch Moorage Access* Shoreline sites (lanes) (ft) Bolton Peninsula, B 2400 beach 56 Broad Spit 2 B 1000 Bywater State 134.6 C 21944 Park Case Shoal, B Beach 59A Hicks county 0.7 1 1 C 460 Park Mats Mats Bay 1 C 40 Boat Launch Quilcene 2 2 30 C 100 Boat riaven Shine Tidelands 20 3 C 1500 Squamish Harbor, B 1335 Beach 59 White Rack 71 C 1500 Jackson Cove, B 2791 Beach 55 Dosewallips 424.5 35 155 C 5250 State Park Flapjack Cove C 567 Tidelands, Beach 54 H.J. Carroll 2.8 C 650 State Park Pleasant Harbor 0.8 10 C 100 State Park Right Smart 2.8 C 100 Cove State Park Seal Rock 30 10 35 C 2700 Campground Triton Cove, B 2610 Beach 50 JEFFERSON COUNTY (Cont.) Acres Picnic Camp- Boat Launch Moorage Access* Shoreline sites (lanes) (ft) Point Whitney 10 1 C 2000 Tidelands Tabook Point, B 3280 Beach 57 Toandos Peninsula, B 12050 Beach 57B Toandos Tidelands B 10455 State Park * B= Boat access only C= Accessible by Car MOORAGE Hood-Canal offers a wide variety of moorage options, from full service slips to ffooring bouys. The summer boating season can easily fill all available facilities and create long lines at the boat launches. Resorts and marinas offering boat launches are rare, as are fuel and other necessessities. Another lack in tile area of services is a pump-out station. The nearest one is at Port Ludlow, and is reporedly little used. There are currently nine marinas open to the public, operating in the Canal. Services and size vary but most offer at least some slips, although a few have only dry storage. One con-knon cofnolaint, heard by boaters and local merchants alike, is the need for more boat launches on the canal. There are, in fact, ten boat ramps with a combined total of 19 lanes. There are also three boat hoists, all privately operated. By far the largest majority of ramps are in south iiood Canal, where between Port of Allyn Public Boat Ramp and iiood Canal Recrational Park there are four launches and 8 lanes. Outside of south hood Canal the nearest public launches are Salisbury Point County Park in Kitsap County, ana Point Whitney Tidelands in Dabob Bay. The boat launch at -Mats Miats Bay boat launch is actually just outside of Hood Canal, but it is close enough to be of use to the recreation sites in northern iiood Canal. It is possible that tfie need for more launches can, at least- in part-, be filled by expanding existing sites to include wre lanes. 10 Figure 4. Marinas and services on Hood Canal. [ MOORAGE ] RESORT NAME SLIPS TRANSIENT DRY RAMP* FUEL Pleasant Harbor 65 0 0 0 0 Marina Port of Hoodsport 10 10 0 0 0 Rest-A-While 0 0 46 H 0 Resort Sunrise Motel & 35 0 0 0 0 Resort Beacon Point 3 0 20 H 0 Boathouse Quilcene Boat unknown Launch Seabeck Marine 181 0 0 H Y Inc. Sandy's Tahuya 15 8 20 1 Y Resort Hood Canal 50 10 190 0 Y Marina Corp. * Numbers indicates numbers of lanes on boat ramp "H" indicates a boat lift facility Figure 5. County moorage figures for 1978. Wet Slips Dry Slips Average Price/ft. Revenues* Public Private Mason 198 330 $.69 $2.06 $72204 Kitsap 1787 149 $.96 $1.27 $667U40 Jefferson 851 90 $.68 $1.41 $311016 Estimated revenues for wet, open moorage only. Does not include transient reciepts, groceries, or services. 12 00 SPORT FISHING IN THE HOOD CANAL REGION LICENSES 4ND FEES Licenses are required for taking all fresh and saltwater fishes and shrimp. The fees and durations of each license vary according to the status of the license holder (resident, non- resident, senior, etc...). The following will give a brief description of each license, for further explanations please consult either SALMON, SHELLFISh, BOTIOMFISH SPORT FISHING GUIDE distributed by Washington State Department of Fisheries, or Game Fish Regulations distributed by Washinton Department of Wildlife. This year (1988), for the first time, Department of Fisheries (DDF) will require a license for taking of all saltwater foodfishess, including those taken while SCUBA diving. A seperate card is required for salmon, and another license for How Canal Spot shrimp. The Departinent of Wildlife (DOW) controls the licensing and management of treshwater fishes, landlocked salmon (Kokanee), and steelhead. in addition to the regular fishing license, a special permit is required to fish for steelnead. REGULATIONS The following is a list of species cor=nly sought in Hood Canal and it's tributaries, and the seasons and limits pertaining to each species. &kLIWAIER- DEPARIMENP OF KSHERIES Bottomfish- Open entire year. - 15 fish per day. - Not more than 5 my be rockfish. - Not more than 10 may be surfperch. - Lingcod count towards the limit. 13 Lingcod-- open April 15 to May 31. one fish per day. minimum size- 22 inches Any size for SCUBA divers. Salmon- Daily limit 3 Open year round except: - Dabob Bay open August 16 through April 14. - Waters within 100 feet of Finch Creek closed. - Waters within 100 feet of the Seabeck Highway ISM Big Beef Creek Bridge are closed August through Nox.,ember. - Walt-ers within 100 yards of the confluence of the Enetai Hatchery outfall creek and saltwater are closed at all times. Minimum size 22 inches- Chinook only. No minimum size on other salmon. Oysters- Daily limit 18 - Leave oyster shell on beach. - Do not take oysters in ihater two feet or deeper. - Open September 16 through July 14 except as follows - Bywater Bay State Tidelands-, part of the tidelands open May 16 through July 14. - Hoodsport Salmon Hatchery open May 16 through July 14. - Kitsap Memorial State Park open May 16 through J u;-ie 15. - Scenic Beach State Park closed until April 15, 1989. - Seal Rock Campground open May 16 through July 14. Clams- Geoduck- Daily limit of 3. - horse - Daily limit of 7 - Manila- Daily limit of 40 - minimum size of 1.5 inches. - Native Littleneck- Daily limit of 40 - Minimum size of 1.5 inches. - Butter- Daily limit of 40. Minimum size of 1.5 inches. All clamming is open year round except in Twanoh State Park w4iere the season is January 1 through June 15. Crab- Dungeness- upen year round except for pots. - Open July 15 to April 15 for crab pots. - Daily limit of six crabs. - Minimum size of Six inches. - No taking of sof tshell crabs. Rea Rock - Daily limit, 12 crabs. - No size limit. - No sex restriction. 14 HoOd Canal Shrimp- Season opens 3rd Saturday in May- 9 :00 Am. - Limit of 10 pounds in the shell. - Minimum mesh size for pots- /is Mussels- Daily limit 10 pounds in the shell. Pink scallops- Daily limit 20 pounds or- - 10 quarts in the shell. Weathervane scallops- daily limit of 12. - Must be over 4 inches. Rock scallops- Daily limit of 12. FRESHMTER- DEPARDlEN1 OF WILDLIFE Bass- Daily limit 10- not more than 3 over 17". rrout- Daily limit 8. - not more than 2 my be over 12" if taken from rivers, streams, or beaver ponds. - Minimum size 81, in rivers, streams, and beaver ponds. - No minimum size in lakes or ponds. - In addition to daily limit, 2 steelhead over 2011 may be kept. note- additional regulations for specific rivers and lakes should be read. Wnitefish- Daily limit 15. No minim= size. All Otner Fish- No restrictions. 15 MASON, KITSAP, AND JEFFEPMN aXJNN TURIST FIGLRES Travel and recreation figures for Hood Canal specifically are hard to come by. However information on the individual counties is available. Except for the Spot Shrimp fisheryt most activities on the canal could also be enjoyed in other parts of puget sound. Any figures that include the whole county are going to be misleading because each county has a different percentage of usable shoreline borkering Hood canal. Kit-sap County was the top county on the canal bringing in $33 million in travel related revenues. Presunably a significant portion of that money was spent on the east side of the county where the majority of tourist and recreational facilities are. It should not be overlooked however that the close proximity to Hood Canal of a large number of tourists is a potential market resource. Mason County rated second in tourist related expenses with $13.5 million. in the case of Mason County, a significant amount of" tiie revenue a-in be attributed to fiooa Canal. Much of the county's recreational shoreline extends through the most popular and well used portion of Hood Canal. Jefferson County followed Mason with $i2.8 million in tourist revenues. While Jef.Lerson county contains the largest number of public shoreline recreational parks and facilities it also has a lot oi shoreline outside of Hood Canal. part of Jefferson's tourist revenues come from the open coast, the Straits of Juan de Fuca, and Admiralty Inlet. wnen each county is analyzed for the number of tourist 16 facilities and ratio of Hood Canal shoreline to other shorelines, it ar4:)ear!9 that the figures change. Mason County and then Jefferson County make up the majority of income generating shoreline followed by Kitsap County whose primary travel facilities lie in the main part of Puget Sound. Tourism and travel are growing in Washington State, and across the nation. State Park attendance is iLo 4%, National Park attendance is up 17%. Olympic National Park recorded one of the largest increases in the nation with 16% for 1986. An estimated 3.5 million people used the park which resides partly in the Hood Canal watershed. This is gooa news for businesses on the canal who then have a ready market of travelers to cater to. Tourism is the fourth largest industry in Washinton, second largest in the nation. Witn 50% of northwest residents vacationing in the northwest, and travelers entering the state in record numbers it is fair to believe that with even mociest advertising and marketing Hood Canal can continue to offer exceptional recreational opportunities without losing it's rural flavor. 17 MASON KITSAP JEFFERSON WASHINGTON '85-86 CHANGE Hotels 15 25 15 1300 UP 12% Eating/ 69 218 58 8000 UP 5% Drinking est. Service 15 41 11 1800 N/C Stations Recreation 12 36 0 2400 UP 8% services Figure 6. Travel related businesses- 1986. MASON KITSAP JEFFERSON WASHINGTON Travel Expenditures $13.5 m $33 m $12.8 m $3.4 b Travel-Generated $3.2 m $7.7 m $2.2 m $680 m Payroll Travel-Generated 375 1000 325 85000 Employment (FTE) State Tax $730 t $2 m $670 t $135 m Receipts Local Roam Tax $26 t $5 $84 t $8.0 M t= Thousand m-- Million b-- Billion Figure 7. Economic figures from travel related business- 1986. 19 EWLADYMENr Employment in the Hood Canal region is in par-t dependant upon the tourist industry. An estimated 1700 (FIE) travel related jobs are held in the three counties bordering Hood Canal. While this sound--, impressive it does not give the complete picture of employment in the area. Enployment figures given in full time equivilence (FrE) actually indicate a larger workforce. Many service industry jobb are seasonal, serving boaters and other vacationers during the peak summer season. The summer months see a large increase in restaraunt staff, maids, sales clerks, resort and park attendants, and other unskilled jons. Many of these jobs are held by non-resident students, and others from outside the county. Some of the economic benifits of increased employment in the county are lost a8 the emloyees leave the area to spend their money. Employment Security records show a consistent pattern of increased employment during the summer, and decreased employrient during the winter. They also show an increase in the labor force inconsistent with local unemployment figures. This inconsistency would account for non-resideents and high school students entering the labor force temporarily. Kitsap Dounty is the one exception to this trend. Part of that is due to the much larger work force, and the nature of the jobs available in Kitsap county. Many residents camute to Seattle and vicinity, or vAork for one of the two Naval Bases in Kitsap County. For this reason employment statistics do 20 not show any significant seasonal variation there. Seas;nal labor is not limited to the tourist industry. In Mason County aquaculture and logging also require some seasonal help. The fact that part of the employment figures for tourism are for part-time and seasonal help does not diminish the positive in-pact tourism has on the Hood Canal region. However it needs to be noted that seasonal and low level jobs are not as beneficial to the region or the people as some emloyment f igures would indicate. 21 14 Figure 8., MA60N CDUNrY EMPLOYMENr- 1986 Labor Force Eniployment Unemployment Percent JAN 12130 1002 1410 11.6% FEB 12070 10740 1330 11.0 MAR 12220 10970 1250 10.2 APR 12560 11320 1240 9.9 MAY 12530 11360 1170 9.3 JUN 12790 11640 1150 9.0 JUL 13130 11910 1220 9.3 ALG 13220 12070 1150 8.7 SEP 12950 11840 1110 8.6 Ocr 13320 12210 1110 8.3 @Dv 13570 12400 1170 8.6 DEC 13170 11900 1270 9.6 ANMIAW 12810 11590 1220 9.5 AVERAGE go 22 Ot Figure 9., KIISAP CL)L)NrY Er4PLOYMENr- 1986 Labor Force Employment Ur*rployment Percent JAN 69900 65500 4400 6.3% FEB 690OU 64700 4300 6.2 MAR 69400 65000 4400 6.3 APR 69600 65200 4400 6.3 MAY 69600 65500 4300 6.2 JUN 70300 65800 4500 6.4 JUL 70900 66200 4700 6.6 AUG 70900 66400 4500 6.3 SEP 70600 66200 4400 6.2 Ocr 70900 66400 4500 6.3 NDV 70500 66200 4300 6.1 DEC 70400 66100 4300 6.1 ANNUAL 70200 65800 4400 6.3 AVhRAGE 23 Figure 10. JEFFERSON CDUN1'Y EMPLOYMENr- 1986 Labor Force Employment Unemployment Percent JAN 7080 6360 720 10.2% FEB 7030 6340 690 9.8 MAR 7130 6450 680 9.5 APR 7410 6760 6-5-0 8.8 MAY 7670 7U50 620 8.1 JLN 7780 7210 570 7.3 JLL 8360 7780 580 6.9 ALIG 8520 7920 600 7.0 SEP 8530 7980 550 6.4 Ocr 8160 7530 630 7.7 11r)v 8060 7360 700 8.7 DEC 7600 6920 6BU 8.9 AMUAi, 7780 7140 640 8.2 AVERAGE; 24 EMNDMIC NPACM OF TOURISM ON MUNN SERVICES 7 StS Tourl passing Through the Hood Canal area, or staying for a weekend or longer use to some extent the services provided by the counties. Usually this is in the form of garbage disposalt road use, county park use, or other common uses. occasionally police, fire, emergency medical, search and rescue or other major services are required. The establishment and maintenance of these services is paid for mostly by county residents through local taxes. I could not determine the number of emergency responses attributed to non-residents as these figures are not collected. Also un-attainable are figures on the percentage of use of roads and parks by non-residents, and their relative maintenance costs. lt could be presuned that the taxes and salaries generated by the local travel industry helps compensate for the cost of providing police, fire, and medical services to non-residents. Garbage disposal is becoming a major issue in the 180's. Landfills are filling up. Toxic chemicals are leaching out. Costs for transporL and disposal are going up. Often the businesses who are paying for disposal of the garbage did not sell products bei-lg thrown away. Weekend travelers often pack food, soft drinks, disposable diapers, etc... specifically to avoid having to purchace these iteims while on their trip. These costs are born both by the businesses w1hO pay to have their trash disposed ot and the counties who must find reasonably safe and available areas to use as landfiiis. Because such intormation is usefull to the Hood Canal 25 Coordinating Council, and potentialy to individual counties and businesse@, I feel there is a need for a system of recording the costs to provide county services by area. This would allow, for instance, information on park maintenance costs from the Hood Canal area of Jefferson County to be considered seperately fran the ocean beaches area. It would also be helpful to have a breakdown of the number of emergency responses related to residents and non-residents. With this information real figures on the price the county pays for tourism could be more accurately tallied. 26 ENVIRONMENIAL IMPACrS Envirom-ental Impacts directly related to recreational activitie@ are not easy to identify, and even less easy to document. Human activity on and near the water may have detrimental effects ranging from the obvious, such as discarded waste, to the less obvious but often equally important effects of disturbing breeding or feeding wildlife soley by the volume of people present in an area. HUMN ACTIWTY Boating, beachcombing, shelifishing, even the mare presence of humans can have some impact on wildlife. disturbing traditional feeding or breeding grounds of some birds has been implicated in lower birth rates, causing stress on already threatened species. one of the attractions of jjood Canal is the pristine shorelines and variety of wildlife. An understanding of the biology of the areas sensitive wildlife and the identification of important feeding and breeding grounds are significant steps in keeping the canal diverse and productive. BOATS One of trie most visible forms of pollution is garbage thrown from cars, boats, docrs, and almost anyplace else people congregate. Besides being an eyesore, most garbage contains a large &nount of plastic. Plastic, in the form of bags, packing material, six-pack rings, and other containers has been iinplicated in tne deaths of marine nrc@mmals, birds, and even some fishes. Unlike other forms of garbage, plastic floats, and may take years to break down at all. 27 Oil from 2 cycle outboards, and bilgewater is a continuing problem tfiat grows as recreational boating increases in popularity. Besides being unsitely, the oil coats the water with a thin layer which blocks the transfer of oxygen frcrn the atmosphere to the water, thus choking off some surface dwelling organisms. Scn-Pe of the most sensitive to this type of pollution are plankton and planktonic larvae. The effects of this are twofold, nany fish and invertebrates depend on these tiny organisms as a food source, and some of the plankton are the larvae of convercially and recreationaly irrportant organisms such as crabs, shellfish, and some fishes. Engine oil also contains metals and other particles toxic to marine life that are picked up in the process of lubricating and cleaning the moving parts of the engine. Some of these toxins can enter from the sediments into plant and then into the bodies ot wtiatever eats those plants. The dangers of this become appearant as the toxins move up the food web into secondary carnivores such as seals and birds of prey. Toxins stored in their fat tissues and released into their blood stream can create significant drops in the birth rates, and can decimate entire populations of animals. Boater education and services concerning the dangers and proper disposal oi waste oil are ityportant steps in reducing the levels of oil and related products entering into the water. Marine toilets with holding tanks, porta-potties, and Marine Sanitation devices (MSD's) are common on many mid to large size boats. One of the primary concerns with most on board toilets is 28 the lack of treatment and the lack of control over where the sewage is released. ideally holding tanks and porta-potties, are emptieu at a pump-out station at a marina or port, however the only pump-out facilities in Hood Canal are in Port Ludlow and Pleasant fiartbor marina, and both are reported to be used very little. Second to a pump-out station would be to empty the holding tank into deep fast moving water where it can be quickly diluted. Unfortunately, many boaters find it more convenient to empty the holding tank when at anchor, or to by-pass the holding tank altogether, and just flush out the sewage every time the head is used. When this happens in protected bays or shallow waters (co(anon areas for shellfish sites) then the pathogens are able to survive long enough to be ingested by organisms, sometimes shellfish, and can make their way back. to a human host. Detection of boaters as a source of bacterial pollution is ditticult at best because boats are so mobile, and bacterial pollution can have many sources. Marine Sanitation Devices (14SD's) are an alternative to either duTping polluting wastes, or having to find and use a working punp-out facility. MSU's offer treatment. of sewage, using clorine or other chemicals, before it is released into the water. The cost of such systems is beyond the means of most boat owrers but for those who can afford them the benifits are worth the cost. The problem of improper use of on board sewage requires more than just more pump-out stations. The boating public needs to be informed and reminded of the dangers of bacterial pollution. 29 Pressure from boating clubs, magazines, and even fellow boaters is needed to change the perception that boaters wastes don't contribute to the overall pollution of our waters. STORMATER Water entering into roadside ditches, storm drains, or running off the land into streams or other waterways is typically termed stormwater. Ideally the precipitation from which the runoff came is clean and pure. when the water flows over roads, parking lots, pastures, agricultural lands, and yards, it picks up anything light enough or sinall enough and carries it along. The danger comes when the substances picked up are harmful to the environment. Runoff from roads and parking lots carries oil and other petrolium, products, heavy metals such as lead, and whatever refuse my have been dumped along the road. Car finishes and paints, chrome plating, and tire wear also contribute to the overall buildup in stormwater. Buildings also can conLribute to the impurities in stormwater. Zinc from galvanized roofing nails, gutters, and downspouts are potential sources of pollution. Exterior paints, whether or not they contain lead, can contain coloring agents that are highly toxic and can enter into the water in the process of weathering. Runoit from agricultural lands, pastures holding livestock, ana from yards and gardens can contain large quantities of chemical and bacterial pollutants. Fertilizers and pesticides 30 applied to fields, gardens, and yards can be washed out through the soil and into ditches or streams. These chemicals remain unseen, only being detected by specialized labratory tests, or at times by the damage they do. Like harw&ul chemicals, bacterial pollution also must be detected by labratory tests. The main sources of bacterial pollution are feces from warm blooded animals- livestock, chicxens, family pets, marine mmals and birds, and humans. The bacterial contamination itself is not a threat to marine organisms, in fact many thrive on it, but once in the food web it becorries a danger to people who may inadvertantly eat contaminated seafood. Proper animal husbandry, such as fencing st .reams and controlling runoft, should reduce the chances of livestock related contamination. Proper installation and maintenance of septic systems will do much to reduce the risk of contamination due to human wastes. In hood Canal bacterial pollution, identified by the presence of fecal choliforms, is the sole source of shellfish beach closures. All of the above mentioned forms of pollution fall under the term "non-point source" meaning that their is no single source or outfall frcta which they originate. Non-point source pollution is the harciest to act against because it is the 'hardest to identify. When sources are identified, the results are often clouded in arguments and blame. in truth it is the responsibility of all residents and visitors to act responsibly with regards to public and environmental health. 31 10 CUNCLUSION AND RBOOMENDATIONS tiood'Canal faces some pivotal choices at this time. Demand for the canal is up. The surrounding area is seeing growth in population ana employment. But at the same time Beaches are being closed to shellfishing due to pollution. The number one problem faced by the region today is non- point source pollution. Rising numbers of full-time residents and tourists are operating cars and boats, and using overworked, out-of-date septic systems. This is combined with stormwater runoff and agricultural/livestock runoff to produce unsafe levels of bacteria along the shorelines. It cannot be stressed enough that public education is a key step in reducing the problem. But it should not stop there, the counties and the state need to set firm sLandards- for septic systems, shoreline development, and animal control, and enforce and abide b those standards. y Regional Sewage Teatment plants would help to correct some oi the problem by Treating wastes betore they enter into the water. The cost for such systezc-, however, is very high, especially vkien servicing a largely rural area. Another option is to re-exan-dne the septic tank regulations and how they are implemented. Much of the canal is set on basalt flows that do not perk. Permits should be withheld froin unsatisfactory areas until arrangements can be made to find other types of sewage treatinent or disposal methods. Shorelines are especially sensitive to development. county zoning currently limits shoreline development. Where attention should be focused is on areas already developed, monitoring the 32 septic tanks- and ensuring safe standards are met. The tourist industry is growing, and Hood Canal is sharing in that growth, but local businesses and governments should not be too complacent. Identifying the needs of boaters and Campers and targeting changes directly at those needs is going to be the the challenge in the coming years. It is appearant that more moorage and boat launch facilities are needed. That need now needs- to be turned into numbers and locations so that boat ramps and slips can keep up with demand. I would like to conclude that more pxxnp-out stations are neeckad on the canal, and they are, but the ones that already exist are not being used. Boater education and peer pressure are key steps before more pump-out stations will be effective. The Hood Canal region nas reached a crossroads. where choices about the economic and enviroriLw-ntal integrity must be made. Tourism and recreation can exist side by side with a clean environavent, But not without the cooperation of businesses, government, and the people. The tiood canal Coordinating Council and the Boaters Task Force axe prime exmnples of multi-level involvement that can iTake real changes in the course of events in the region. 33 BMIOGRAPHY Fox, Nancy and Susan Heikkala. horeline Master Program kiandbook. Washington State Department of Ecology, September, 1983. Goodwin, Robert F. Recreational Boating In Washington's Coastal Zone: The Market For Moorage. Seattle: Washington Sea Grant. May, 1982. Goodwin, Robert F. ana Robert Stokes. The Mooracre Industry In Washinton's Coastal Zone. Seattle: Washington Sea Grant. December, 1980. Hood Canal Regional Planning Policy. hood Canal Coordinating Council. September, 1986. Jefferson County Revenue Ledger. 1987. Mason County Revenue Ledger. 1987. Scott, James W. and Melly A. Reuling. Washington Public Shore Guide: Marine Waters. Seattle: University of vVashington Press. 1986. Washington Deparbnent of Wildlife. 1988-90 Game Fish Regulations- Washington. 1988. Washington State Department of Fisheries. Salmon, Shellfish, Bottomfish Sportfishing Guide. 1988. Wahington State Departinent of Fisheries. Puget Sound Public Shellfish Sites. Revised by Eric hurlburt and Albert J. Scholz. Octooer, 1983. Washington State rilTployment Security Department. Annual Demographic information- July 1987: Service Area I. September, 1987. Washington State E2TVloyment Security Department. Annual Demographic information- July 1987: Service Area 11. September, 1987. "washington Travel Facts." and General Travel Information. Wasnington State Deparblient of Trade and Economic DeVE-11opement. 34 10 DATE DUE GAYLORD No. 2333 PRINTED IN U S A i: I'll 011