[House Report 110-374]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
110th Congress Rept. 110-374
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
1st Session Part 1
======================================================================
PAUL WELLSTONE MENTAL HEALTH AND ADDICTION EQUITY ACT OF 2007
_______
October 15, 2007.--Ordered to be printed
_______
Mr. George Miller of California, from the Committee on Education and
Labor, submitted the following
R E P O R T
together with
MINORITY VIEWS
[To accompany H.R. 1424]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and Labor, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 1424) to amend section 712 of the Employee
Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, section 2705 of the
Public Health Service Act, and section 9812 of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 to require equity in the provision of
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits under
group health plans, having considered the same, report
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommend that the bill
as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Paul Wellstone
Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents of this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Amendments to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of
1974.
Sec. 3. Amendments to the Public Health Service Act relating to the
group market.
Sec. 5. Amendments to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986.
Sec. 5. Government Accountability Office studies and reports.
SEC. 2. AMENDMENTS TO THE EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT INCOME SECURITY ACT OF
1974.
(a) Extension of Parity to Treatment Limits and Beneficiary Financial
Requirements.--Section 712 of the Employee Retirement Income Security
Act of 1974 (29 U.S.C. 1185a) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by adding at the end the following new
paragraphs:
``(3) Treatment limits.--
``(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
does not include a treatment limit (as defined in
subparagraph (D)) on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits in any category of items or services,
the plan or coverage may not impose any treatment limit
on mental health or substance-related disorder benefits
that are classified in the same category of items or
services.
``(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes a treatment limit on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits in any category of items or
services, the plan or coverage may not impose such a
treatment limit on mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits for items and services within such
category that is more restrictive than the predominant
treatment limit that is applicable to medical and
surgical benefits for items and services within such
category.
``(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this paragraph
and paragraph (4), there shall be the following five
categories of items and services for benefits, whether
medical and surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all medical
and surgical benefits and all mental health and
substance related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
``(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services not described in clause (v) furnished
on an inpatient basis and within a network of
providers established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
``(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services not described in clause (v) furnished
on an inpatient basis and outside any network
of providers established or recognized under
such plan or coverage.
``(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items and
services not described in clause (v) furnished
on an outpatient basis and within a network of
providers established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
``(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services not described in clause (v) furnished
on an outpatient basis and outside any network
of providers established or recognized under
such plan or coverage.
``(v) Emergency care.--Items and services,
whether furnished on an inpatient or outpatient
basis or within or outside any network of
providers, required for the treatment of an
emergency medical condition (including an
emergency condition relating to mental health
and substance-related disorders).
``(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of this
paragraph, the term `treatment limit' means, with
respect to a plan or coverage, limitation on the
frequency of treatment, number of visits or days of
coverage, or other similar limit on the duration or
scope of treatment under the plan or coverage.
``(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this subsection,
a treatment limit or financial requirement with respect
to a category of items and services is considered to be
predominant if it is the most common or frequent of
such type of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
``(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
``(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If the
plan or coverage does not include a beneficiary
financial requirement (as defined in subparagraph (C))
on substantially all medical and surgical benefits
within a category of items and services (specified
under paragraph (3)(C)), the plan or coverage may not
impose such a beneficiary financial requirement on
mental health or substance-related disorder benefits
for items and services within such category.
``(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
``(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-pocket
limits, and similar financial requirements.--If
the plan or coverage includes a deductible, a
limitation on out-of-pocket expenses, or
similar beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual items
and services on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits within a category of items
and services (as specified in paragraph
(3)(C)), the plan or coverage shall apply such
requirement (or, if there is more than one such
requirement for such category of items and
services, the predominant requirement for such
category) both to medical and surgical benefits
within such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits within such
category and shall not distinguish in the
application of such requirement between such
medical and surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits.
``(ii) Other financial requirements.--If the
plan or coverage includes a beneficiary
financial requirement not described in clause
(i) on substantially all medical and surgical
benefits within a category of items and
services, the plan or coverage may not impose
such financial requirement on mental health or
substance-related disorder benefits for items
and services within such category in a way that
results in greater out-of-pocket expenses to
the participant or beneficiary than the
predominant beneficiary financial requirement
applicable to medical and surgical benefits for
items and services within such category.
``(iii) Construction.--Nothing in this
subparagraph shall be construed as prohibiting
the plan or coverage from waiving the
application of any deductible for mental health
benefits or substance-related disorder benefits
or both.
``(C) Beneficiary financial requirement defined.--For
purposes of this paragraph, the term `beneficiary
financial requirement' includes, with respect to a plan
or coverage, any deductible, coinsurance, co-payment,
other cost sharing, and limitation on the total amount
that may be paid by a participant or beneficiary with
respect to benefits under the plan or coverage, but
does not include the application of any aggregate
lifetime limit or annual limit.''; and
(2) in subsection (b)--
(A) by striking ``construed--'' and all that follows
through ``(1) as requiring'' and inserting ``construed
as requiring'';
(B) by striking ``; or'' and inserting a period; and
(C) by striking paragraph (2).
(b) Expansion to Substance-Related Disorder Benefits and Revision of
Definition.--Such section is further amended--
(1) by striking ``mental health benefits'' and inserting
``mental health or substance-related disorder benefits'' each
place it appears; and
(2) in paragraph (4) of subsection (e)--
(A) by striking ``Mental health benefits'' and
inserting ``Mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits'';
(B) by striking ``benefits with respect to mental
health services'' and inserting ``benefits with respect
to services for mental health conditions or substance-
related disorders''; and
(C) by striking ``, but does not include benefits
with respect to treatment of substance abuse or
chemical dependency''.
(c) Availability of Plan Information About Criteria for Medical
Necessity.--Subsection (a) of such section, as amended by subsection
(a)(1), is further amended by adding at the end the following new
paragraph:
``(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria for
medical necessity determinations made under the plan with
respect to mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits (or the health insurance coverage offered in
connection with the plan with respect to such benefits) shall
be made available in accordance with regulations by the plan
administrator (or the health insurance issuer offering such
coverage) to any current or potential participant, beneficiary,
or contracting provider upon request. The reason for any denial
under the plan (or coverage) of reimbursement or payment for
services with respect to mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits in the case of any participant or beneficiary
shall, upon request, be made available in accordance with
regulations by the plan administrator (or the health insurance
issuer offering such coverage) to the participant or
beneficiary.''.
(d) Minimum Benefit Requirements.--Subsection (a) of such section is
further amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-network
benefits.--
``(A) Minimum scope of mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits.--In the case of a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) that provides any mental
health or substance-related disorder benefits, the plan
or coverage shall include benefits for any mental
health condition and substance-related disorder for
which benefits are provided under the benefit plan
option offered under chapter 89 of title 5, United
States Code, with the highest average enrollment as of
the beginning of the most recent year beginning on or
before the beginning of the plan year involved.
``(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
``(i) In general.--In the case of a plan or
coverage that provides both medical and
surgical benefits and mental health or
substance-related disorder benefits, if medical
and surgical benefits are provided for
substantially all items and services in a
category specified in clause (ii) furnished
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage, the
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits shall also be provided for items and
services in such category furnished outside any
network of providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage in accordance with
the requirements of this section.
``(ii) Categories of items and services.--For
purposes of clause (i), there shall be the
following three categories of items and
services for benefits, whether medical and
surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all
medical and surgical benefits and all mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
shall be classified into one of the following
categories:
``(I) Emergency.--Items and services,
whether furnished on an inpatient or
outpatient basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency medical
condition (including an emergency
condition relating to mental health or
substance-related disorders).
``(II) Inpatient.--Items and services
not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an inpatient basis.
``(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an outpatient basis.''.
(e) Construction.--Subsection (a) of such section is further amended
by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(7) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to limit a group health plan (or health insurance
offered in connection with such a plan) from managing the
provision of medical, surgical, mental health or substance-
related disorder benefits through any of the following methods:
``(A) the application of utilization review;
``(B) the application of authorization or management
practices;
``(C) the application of medical necessity and
appropriateness criteria; or
``(D) other processes intended to ensure that
beneficiaries receive appropriate care and medically
necessary services for covered benefits;
to the extent such methods are recognized both by industry and
by providers and are not prohibited under applicable State
laws.''.
(f) Revision of Increased Cost Exemption.--Paragraph (2) of
subsection (c) of such section is amended to read as follows:
``(2) Increased cost exemption.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a group health
plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan), if the application of
this section to such plan (or coverage) results in an
increase for the plan year involved of the actual total
costs of coverage with respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits under the plan (as determined and
certified under subparagraph (C)) by an amount that
exceeds the applicable percentage described in
subparagraph (B) of the actual total plan costs, the
provisions of this section shall not apply to such plan
(or coverage) during the following plan year, and such
exemption shall apply to the plan (or coverage) for 1
plan year.
``(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a plan
(or coverage), the applicable percentage described in
this paragraph shall be--
``(i) 2 percent in the case of the first plan
year which begins after the effective date of
the amendments made by section 101 of the Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity
Act of 2007; and
``(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
``(C) Determinations by actuaries.--Determinations as
to increases in actual costs under a plan (or coverage)
for purposes of this subsection shall be made and
certified by a qualified and licensed actuary who is a
member in good standing of the American Academy of
Actuaries.
``(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group health plan
(or a health insurance issuer offering coverage in
connection with such a plan) seeks an exemption under
this paragraph, determinations under subparagraph (A)
shall be made after such plan (or coverage) has
complied with this section for the first 6 months of
the plan year involved.
``(E) Notification.--An election to modify coverage
of mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits as permitted under this paragraph shall be
treated as a material modification in the terms of the
plan as described in section 102(a) and notice of which
shall be provided a reasonable period in advance of the
change.
``(F) Notification of appropriate agency.--
``(i) In general.--A group health plan that,
based on upon a certification described under
subparagraph (C), qualifies for an exemption
under this paragraph, and elects to implement
the exemption, shall notify the Department of
Labor of such election.
``(ii) Requirement.--A notification under
clause (i) shall include--
``(I) a description of the number of
covered lives under the plan (or
coverage) involved at the time of the
notification, and as applicable, at the
time of any prior election of the cost-
exemption under this paragraph by such
plan (or coverage);
``(II) for both the plan year upon
which a cost exemption is sought and
the year prior, a description of the
actual total costs of coverage with
respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits
under the plan; and
``(III) for both the plan year upon
which a cost exemption is sought and
the year prior, the actual total costs
of coverage with respect to mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits under the plan.
``(iii) Confidentiality.--A notification
under clause (i) shall be confidential. The
Department of Labor shall make available, upon
request to the appropriate committees of
Congress and on not more than an annual basis,
an anonymous itemization of such notifications,
that includes--
``(I) a breakdown of States by the
size and any type of employers
submitting such notification; and
``(II) a summary of the data received
under clause (ii).
``(G) No impact on application of state law.--The
fact that a plan or coverage is exempt from the
provisions of this section under subparagraph (A) shall
not affect the application of State law to such plan or
coverage.''.
(g) Change in Exclusion for Smallest Employers.--Subsection (c)(1)(B)
of such section is amended--
(1) by inserting ``(or 1 in the case of an employer residing
in a State that permits small groups to include a single
individual)'' after ``at least 2'' the first place it appears;
and
(2) by striking ``and who employs at least 2 employees on the
first day of the plan year''.
(h) Elimination of Sunset Provision.--Such section is amended by
striking subsection (f).
(i) Clarification Regarding Preemption.--Such section is further
amended by inserting after subsection (e) the following new subsection:
``(f) Preemption, Relation to State Laws.--
``(1) In general.--This part shall not be construed to
supersede any provision of State law which establishes,
implements, or continues in effect any consumer protections,
benefits, methods of access to benefits, rights, external
review programs, or remedies solely relating to health
insurance issuers in connection with group health insurance
coverage (including benefit mandates or regulation of group
health plans of 50 or fewer employees) except to the extent
that such provision prevents the application of a requirement
of this part.
``(2) Continued preemption with respect to group health
plans.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect or
modify the provisions of section 514 with respect to group
health plans.
``(3) Other state laws.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to exempt or relieve any person from any laws of any
State not solely related to health insurance issuers in
connection with group health coverage insofar as they may now
or hereafter relate to insurance, health plans, or health
coverage.' ''.
(j) Conforming Amendments to Heading.--
(1) In general.--The heading of such section is amended to
read as follows:
``SEC. 712. EQUITY IN MENTAL HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE-RELATED DISORDER
BENEFITS.''.
(2) Clerical amendment.--The table of contents in section 1
of such Act is amended by striking the item relating to section
712 and inserting the following new item:
``Sec. 712. Equity in mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.''.
(k) Effective Date.--
(1) In general.--The amendments made by this section shall
apply with respect to plan years beginning on or after January
1, 2008.
(2) Special rule for collective bargaining agreements.--In
the case of a group health plan maintained pursuant to one or
more collective bargaining agreements between employee
representatives and one or more employers ratified before the
date of the enactment of this Act, the amendments made by this
section shall not apply to plan years beginning before the
later of--
(A) the date on which the last of the collective
bargaining agreements relating to the plan terminates
(determined without regard to any extension thereof
agreed to after the date of the enactment of this Act),
or
(B) January 1, 2010.
For purposes of subparagraph (A), any plan amendment made
pursuant to a collective bargaining agreement relating to the
plan which amends the plan solely to conform to any requirement
imposed under an amendment under this section shall not be
treated as a termination of such collective bargaining
agreement.
(l) DOL Annual Sample Compliance.--The Secretary of Labor shall
annually sample and conduct random audits of group health plans (and
health insurance coverage offered in connection with such plans) in
order to determine their compliance with the amendments made by this
Act and shall submit to the appropriate committees of Congress an
annual report on such compliance with such amendments.
(m) Assistance to Participants and Beneficiaries.--The Secretary of
Labor shall provide assistance to participants and beneficiaries of
group health plans with any questions or problems with compliance with
the requirements of this Act. The Secretary shall notify participants
and beneficiaries when they can obtain assistance from State consumer
and insurance agencies and the Secretary shall coordinate with State
agencies to ensure that participants and beneficiaries are protected
and afforded the rights provided under this Act.
SEC. 3. AMENDMENTS TO THE PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE ACT RELATING TO THE
GROUP MARKET.
(a) Extension of Parity to Treatment Limits and Beneficiary Financial
Requirements.--Section 2705 of the Public Health Service Act (42 U.S.C.
300gg-5) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by adding at the end the following new
paragraphs:
``(3) Treatment limits.--
``(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
does not include a treatment limit (as defined in
subparagraph (D)) on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits in any category of items or services
(specified in subparagraph (C)), the plan or coverage
may not impose any treatment limit on mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits that are classified
in the same category of items or services.
``(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes a treatment limit on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits in any category of items or
services, the plan or coverage may not impose such a
treatment limit on mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits for items and services within such
category that are more restrictive than the predominant
treatment limit that is applicable to medical and
surgical benefits for items and services within such
category.
``(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this paragraph
and paragraph (4), there shall be the following four
categories of items and services for benefits, whether
medical and surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all medical
and surgical benefits and all mental health and
substance related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
``(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient basis and
within a network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient basis and
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an outpatient basis and
within a network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services furnished on an outpatient basis and
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of this
paragraph, the term `treatment limit' means, with
respect to a plan or coverage, limitation on the
frequency of treatment, number of visits or days of
coverage, or other similar limit on the duration or
scope of treatment under the plan or coverage.
``(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this subsection,
a treatment limit or financial requirement with respect
to a category of items and services is considered to be
predominant if it is the most common or frequent of
such type of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
``(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
``(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If the
plan or coverage does not include a beneficiary
financial requirement (as defined in subparagraph (C))
on substantially all medical and surgical benefits
within a category of items and services (specified in
paragraph (3)(C)), the plan or coverage may not impose
such a beneficiary financial requirement on mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits for
items and services within such category.
``(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
``(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-pocket
limits, and similar financial requirements.--If
the plan or coverage includes a deductible, a
limitation on out-of-pocket expenses, or
similar beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual items
and services on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits within a category of items
and services, the plan or coverage shall apply
such requirement (or, if there is more than one
such requirement for such category of items and
services, the predominant requirement for such
category) both to medical and surgical benefits
within such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits within such
category and shall not distinguish in the
application of such requirement between such
medical and surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits.
``(ii) Other financial requirements.--If the
plan or coverage includes a beneficiary
financial requirement not described in clause
(i) on substantially all medical and surgical
benefits within a category of items and
services, the plan or coverage may not impose
such financial requirement on mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits for items
and services within such category in a way that
is more costly to the participant or
beneficiary than the predominant beneficiary
financial requirement applicable to medical and
surgical benefits for items and services within
such category.
``(C) Beneficiary financial requirement defined.--For
purposes of this paragraph, the term `beneficiary
financial requirement' includes, with respect to a plan
or coverage, any deductible, coinsurance, co-payment,
other cost sharing, and limitation on the total amount
that may be paid by a participant or beneficiary with
respect to benefits under the plan or coverage, but
does not include the application of any aggregate
lifetime limit or annual limit.''; and
(2) in subsection (b)--
(A) by striking ``construed--'' and all that follows
through ``(1) as requiring'' and inserting ``construed
as requiring'';
(B) by striking ``; or'' and inserting a period; and
(C) by striking paragraph (2).
(b) Expansion to Substance-Related Disorder Benefits and Revision of
Definition.--Such section is further amended--
(1) by striking ``mental health benefits'' and inserting
``mental health and substance-related disorder benefits'' each
place it appears; and
(2) in paragraph (4) of subsection (e)--
(A) by striking ``Mental health benefits'' and
inserting ``Mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits'';
(B) by striking ``benefits with respect to mental
health services'' and inserting ``benefits with respect
to services for mental health conditions or substance-
related disorders''; and
(C) by striking ``, but does not include benefits
with respect to treatment of substances abuse or
chemical dependency''.
(c) Availability of Plan Information About Criteria for Medical
Necessity.--Subsection (a) of such section, as amended by subsection
(a)(1), is further amended by adding at the end the following new
paragraph:
``(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria for
medical necessity determinations made under the plan with
respect to mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits (or the health insurance coverage offered in
connection with the plan with respect to such benefits) shall
be made available by the plan administrator (or the health
insurance issuer offering such coverage) to any current or
potential participant, beneficiary, or contracting provider
upon request. The reason for any denial under the plan (or
coverage) of reimbursement or payment for services with respect
to mental health and substance-related disorder benefits in the
case of any participant or beneficiary shall, upon request, be
made available by the plan administrator (or the health
insurance issuer offering such coverage) to the participant or
beneficiary.''.
(d) Minimum Benefit Requirements.--Subsection (a) of such section is
further amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-network
benefits.--
``(A) Minimum scope of mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits.--In the case of a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) that provides any mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits, the
plan or coverage shall include benefits for any mental
health condition or substance-related disorder for
which benefits are provided under the benefit plan
option offered under chapter 89 of title 5, United
States Code, with the highest average enrollment as of
the beginning of the most recent year beginning on or
before the beginning of the plan year involved.
``(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
``(i) In general.--In the case of a plan or
coverage that provides both medical and
surgical benefits and mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, if medical
and surgical benefits are provided for
substantially all items and services in a
category specified in clause (ii) furnished
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage, the
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits shall also be provided for items and
services in such category furnished outside any
network of providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage in accordance with
the requirements of this section.
``(ii) Categories of items and services.--For
purposes of clause (i), there shall be the
following three categories of items and
services for benefits, whether medical and
surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all
medical and surgical benefits and all mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
shall be classified into one of the following
categories:
``(I) Emergency.--Items and services,
whether furnished on an inpatient or
outpatient basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency medical
condition (including an emergency
condition relating to mental health and
substance-related disorders).
``(II) Inpatient.--Items and services
not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an inpatient basis.
``(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an outpatient basis.''.
(e) Revision of Increased Cost Exemption.--Paragraph (2) of
subsection (c) of such section is amended to read as follows:
``(2) Increased cost exemption.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a group health
plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan), if the application of
this section to such plan (or coverage) results in an
increase for the plan year involved of the actual total
costs of coverage with respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits under the plan (as determined and
certified under subparagraph (C)) by an amount that
exceeds the applicable percentage described in
subparagraph (B) of the actual total plan costs, the
provisions of this section shall not apply to such plan
(or coverage) during the following plan year, and such
exemption shall apply to the plan (or coverage) for 1
plan year.
``(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a plan
(or coverage), the applicable percentage described in
this paragraph shall be--
``(i) 2 percent in the case of the first plan
year which begins after the date of the
enactment of the Paul Wellstone Mental Health
and Addiction Equity Act of 2007; and
``(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
``(C) Determinations by actuaries.--Determinations as
to increases in actual costs under a plan (or coverage)
for purposes of this subsection shall be made by a
qualified actuary who is a member in good standing of
the American Academy of Actuaries. Such determinations
shall be certified by the actuary and be made available
to the general public.
``(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group health plan
(or a health insurance issuer offering coverage in
connection with such a plan) seeks an exemption under
this paragraph, determinations under subparagraph (A)
shall be made after such plan (or coverage) has
complied with this section for the first 6 months of
the plan year involved.
``(E) Notification.--A group health plan under this
part shall comply with the notice requirement under
section 712(c)(2)(E) of the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act of 1974 with respect to the a modification
of mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits as permitted under this paragraph as if such
section applied to such plan.''.
(f) Change in Exclusion for Smallest Employers.--Subsection (c)(1)(B)
of such section is amended--
(1) by inserting ``(or 1 in the case of an employer residing
in a State that permits small groups to include a single
individual)'' after ``at least 2'' the first place it appears;
and
(2) by striking ``and who employs at least 2 employees on the
first day of the plan year''.
(g) Elimination of Sunset Provision.--Such section is amended by
striking out subsection (f).
(h) Clarification Regarding Preemption.--Such section is further
amended by inserting after subsection (e) the following new subsection:
``(f) Preemption, Relation to State Laws.--
``(1) In general.--Nothing in this section shall be construed
to preempt any State law that provides greater consumer
protections, benefits, methods of access to benefits, rights or
remedies that are greater than the protections, benefits,
methods of access to benefits, rights or remedies provided
under this section.
``(2) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to affect or modify the provisions of section 2723
with respect to group health plans.''.
(i) Conforming Amendment to Heading.--The heading of such section is
amended to read as follows:
``SEC. 2705.''.
(j) Effective Date.--The amendments made by this section shall apply
with respect to plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2008.
SEC. 4. AMENDMENTS TO THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE OF 1986.
(a) Extension of Parity to Treatment Limits and Beneficiary Financial
Requirements.--Section 9812 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is
amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by adding at the end the following new
paragraphs:
``(3) Treatment limits.--
``(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan does not
include a treatment limit (as defined in subparagraph
(D)) on substantially all medical and surgical benefits
in any category of items or services (specified in
subparagraph (C)), the plan may not impose any
treatment limit on mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits that are classified in the same
category of items or services.
``(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan includes a
treatment limit on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits in any category of items or services,
the plan may not impose such a treatment limit on
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits
for items and services within such category that are
more restrictive than the predominant treatment limit
that is applicable to medical and surgical benefits for
items and services within such category.
``(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this paragraph
and paragraph (4), there shall be the following four
categories of items and services for benefits, whether
medical and surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all medical
and surgical benefits and all mental health and
substance related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
``(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient basis and
within a network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient basis and
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an outpatient basis and
within a network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--Items and
services furnished on an outpatient basis and
outside any network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
``(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of this
paragraph, the term `treatment limit' means, with
respect to a plan, limitation on the frequency of
treatment, number of visits or days of coverage, or
other similar limit on the duration or scope of
treatment under the plan.
``(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this subsection,
a treatment limit or financial requirement with respect
to a category of items and services is considered to be
predominant if it is the most common or frequent of
such type of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
``(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
``(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If the
plan does not include a beneficiary financial
requirement (as defined in subparagraph (C)) on
substantially all medical and surgical benefits within
a category of items and services (specified in
paragraph (3)(C)), the plan may not impose such a
beneficiary financial requirement on mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits for items and
services within such category.
``(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
``(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-pocket
limits, and similar financial requirements.--If
the plan or coverage includes a deductible, a
limitation on out-of-pocket expenses, or
similar beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual items
and services on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits within a category of items
and services, the plan or coverage shall apply
such requirement (or, if there is more than one
such requirement for such category of items and
services, the predominant requirement for such
category) both to medical and surgical benefits
within such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits within such
category and shall not distinguish in the
application of such requirement between such
medical and surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits.
``(ii) Other financial requirements.--If the
plan includes a beneficiary financial
requirement not described in clause (i) on
substantially all medical and surgical benefits
within a category of items and services, the
plan may not impose such financial requirement
on mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits for items and services within such
category in a way that is more costly to the
participant or beneficiary than the predominant
beneficiary financial requirement applicable to
medical and surgical benefits for items and
services within such category.
``(C) Beneficiary financial requirement defined.--For
purposes of this paragraph, the term `beneficiary
financial requirement' includes, with respect to a
plan, any deductible, coinsurance, co-payment, other
cost sharing, and limitation on the total amount that
may be paid by a participant or beneficiary with
respect to benefits under the plan, but does not
include the application of any aggregate lifetime limit
or annual limit.''; and
(2) in subsection (b)--
(A) by striking ``construed--'' and all that follows
through ``(1) as requiring'' and inserting ``construed
as requiring'';
(B) by striking ``; or'' and inserting a period; and
(C) by striking paragraph (2).
(b) Expansion to Substance-Related Disorder Benefits and Revision of
Definition.--Such section is further amended--
(1) by striking ``mental health benefits'' and inserting
``mental health and substance-related disorder benefits'' each
place it appears; and
(2) in paragraph (4) of subsection (e)--
(A) by striking ``Mental health benefits'' in the
heading and inserting ``Mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits'';
(B) by striking ``benefits with respect to mental
health services'' and inserting ``benefits with respect
to services for mental health conditions or substance-
related disorders''; and
(C) by striking ``, but does not include benefits
with respect to treatment of substances abuse or
chemical dependency''.
(c) Availability of Plan Information About Criteria for Medical
Necessity.--Subsection (a) of such section, as amended by subsection
(a)(1), is further amended by adding at the end the following new
paragraph:
``(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria for
medical necessity determinations made under the plan with
respect to mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits shall be made available by the plan administrator to
any current or potential participant, beneficiary, or
contracting provider upon request. The reason for any denial
under the plan of reimbursement or payment for services with
respect to mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits in the case of any participant or beneficiary shall,
upon request, be made available by the plan administrator to
the participant or beneficiary.''.
(d) Minimum Benefit Requirements.--Subsection (a) of such section is
further amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-network
benefits.--
``(A) Minimum scope of mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits.--In the case of a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) that provides any mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits, the
plan or coverage shall include benefits for any mental
health condition or substance-related disorder for
which benefits are provided under the benefit plan
option offered under chapter 89 of title 5, United
States Code, with the highest average enrollment as of
the beginning of the most recent year beginning on or
before the beginning of the plan year involved.
``(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
``(i) In general.--In the case of a plan that
provides both medical and surgical benefits and
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits, if medical and surgical benefits are
provided for substantially all items and
services in a category specified in clause (ii)
furnished outside any network of providers
established or recognized under such plan or
coverage, the mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits shall also be
provided for items and services in such
category furnished outside any network of
providers established or recognized under such
plan in accordance with the requirements of
this section.
``(ii) Categories of items and services.--For
purposes of clause (i), there shall be the
following three categories of items and
services for benefits, whether medical and
surgical benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, and all
medical and surgical benefits and all mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
shall be classified into one of the following
categories:
``(I) Emergency.--Items and services,
whether furnished on an inpatient or
outpatient basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency medical
condition (including an emergency
condition relating to mental health and
substance-related disorders).
``(II) Inpatient.--Items and services
not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an inpatient basis.
``(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in subclause (I)
furnished on an outpatient basis.''.
(e) Revision of Increased Cost Exemption.--Paragraph (2) of
subsection (c) of such section is amended to read as follows:
``(2) Increased cost exemption.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a group health
plan, if the application of this section to such plan
results in an increase for the plan year involved of
the actual total costs of coverage with respect to
medical and surgical benefits and mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits under the plan (as
determined and certified under subparagraph (C)) by an
amount that exceeds the applicable percentage described
in subparagraph (B) of the actual total plan costs, the
provisions of this section shall not apply to such plan
during the following plan year, and such exemption
shall apply to the plan for 1 plan year.
``(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a plan,
the applicable percentage described in this paragraph
shall be--
``(i) 2 percent in the case of the first plan
year which begins after the date of the
enactment of the Paul Wellstone Mental Health
and Addiction Equity Act of 2007; and
``(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
``(C) Determinations by actuaries.--Determinations as
to increases in actual costs under a plan for purposes
of this subsection shall be made by a qualified actuary
who is a member in good standing of the American
Academy of Actuaries. Such determinations shall be
certified by the actuary and be made available to the
general public.
``(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group health plan
seeks an exemption under this paragraph, determinations
under subparagraph (A) shall be made after such plan
has complied with this section for the first 6 months
of the plan year involved.''.
(f) Change in Exclusion for Smallest Employers.--Subsection (c)(1) of
such section is amended to read as follows:
``(1) Small employer exemption.--
``(A) In general.--This section shall not apply to
any group health plan for any plan year of a small
employer.
``(B) Small employer.--For purposes of subparagraph
(A), the term `small employer' means, with respect to a
calendar year and a plan year, an employer who employed
an average of at least 2 (or 1 in the case of an
employer residing in a State that permits small groups
to include a single individual) but not more than 50
employees on business days during the preceding
calendar year. For purposes of the preceding sentence,
all persons treated as a single employer under
subsection (b), (c), (m), or (o) of section 414 shall
be treated as 1 employer and rules similar to rules of
subparagraphs (B) and (C) of section 4980D(d)(2) shall
apply.''.
(g) Elimination of Sunset Provision.--Such section is amended by
striking subsection (f).
(h) Conforming Amendments to Heading.--
(1) In general.--The heading of such section is amended to
read as follows:
``SEC. 9812.''.
(2) Clerical amendment.--The table of sections for subchapter
B of chapter 100 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is
amended by striking the item relating to section 9812 and
inserting the following new item:
``Sec. 9812. Equity in mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.''.
(i) Effective Date.--The amendments made by this section shall apply
with respect to plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2008.
SEC. 5. STUDIES AND REPORTS.
(a) Implementation of Act.--
(1) GAO study.--The Comptroller General of the United States
shall conduct a study that evaluates the effect of the
implementation of the amendments made by this Act on--
(A) the cost of health insurance coverage;
(B) access to health insurance coverage (including
the availability of in-network providers);
(C) the quality of health care;
(D) Medicare, Medicaid, and State and local mental
health and substance abuse treatment spending;
(E) the number of individuals with private insurance
who received publicly funded health care for mental
health and substance-related disorders;
(F) spending on public services, such as the criminal
justice system, special education, and income
assistance programs;
(G) the use of medical management of mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits and medical
necessity determinations by group health plans (and
health insurance issuers offering health insurance
coverage in connection with such plans) and timely
access by participants and beneficiaries to clinically-
indicated care for mental health and substance-use
disorders; and
(H) other matters as determined appropriate by the
Comptroller General.
(2) Report.--Not later than 2 years after the date of
enactment of this Act, the Comptroller General shall prepare
and submit to the appropriate committees of the Congress a
report containing the results of the study conducted under
paragraph (1).
(b) GAO Report on Uniform Patient Placement Criteria.--Not later than
18 months after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Comptroller
General shall submit to the appropriate committees of each House of the
Congress a report on availability of uniform patient placement criteria
for mental health and substance-related disorders that could be used by
group health plans and health insurance issuers to guide determinations
of medical necessity and the extent to which health plans utilize such
criteria. If such criteria do not exist, the report shall include
recommendations on a process for developing such criteria.
(c) DOL Biannual Report on Obstacles in Obtaining Coverage.--Every
two years, the Secretary of Labor, in consultation with the Secretaries
of Health and Human Services and the Treasury, shall submit to the
appropriate committees of each House of the Congress a report on
obstacles that individuals face in obtaining mental health and
substance-related disorder care under their health plans.
I. Purpose
Millions of Americans suffer from mental illness however
obstacles within our health care system prevent many from
getting the care they desperately need. The Paul Wellstone
Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act (H.R. 1424) will expand
the Mental Health Parity Act of 1996 \1\ to ensure that mental
illnesses are covered under similar terms as physical illnesses
for the millions of Americans who currently receive health care
through their employers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ P.L 104-204.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mental disorders are the leading cause of disability in the
U.S. for individuals ages 15-44. \2\ However, private health
insurers and employers generally provide less coverage for
mental illnesses than for other medical and surgical benefits
through the use of plan design features. H.R. 1424 seeks to
increase access to mental health treatment by prohibiting group
health plans (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with a group health plan) from imposing financial
requirements (including deductibles, co payments, coinsurance,
out-of-pocket expenses, and annual lifetime limits) or
treatment limitations (including limitations on the number of
visits, days of coverage, frequency of treatment, or other
similar limits on the scope and duration of treatment) on
mental health benefits that are more restrictive than those
restrictions applied to medical and surgical benefits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ The World Health Organization. The World Health Report 2004:
Changing History; Annex Table 3: Burden of disease in Disability-
Adjusted-Life-Years (DALY) by cause, sex, and mortality stratum in WHO
regions, estimates for 2002. Geneva (2004).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. Committee Action Including Legislative History and Votes in
Committee
102ND CONGRESS (1991-1992)
On May 12, 1992 during the 102nd Congress Senators Pete
Domenici and John Danforth first introduced mental health
parity legislation, Equitable Health Care for Severe Mental
Illnesses Act of 1992, S. 2696. The legislation garnered 24
bipartisan co-sponsors and was referred to the Committee on
Labor and Human Resources. S. 2696 prohibited discrimination in
the healthcare system based on an individual's severe mental
illness, and stated health care coverage. No action was taken
on S. 2696.
The Senate Appropriations Committee included language in
its Committee report \3\ to accompany the FY1993 Labor-HHS
appropriations bill that requested the National Advisory Mental
Health Council prepare a report on the cost of mental health
parity.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ S. Rept. 102-397 at 96.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
103RD CONGRESS (1993-1994)
Congress considered mental health parity during the debate
on the Clinton Administration's health care reform proposal in
the 103rd Congress. The Health Security Act (introduced as H.R.
3600 and S. 1757 respectively) included limited coverage of
mental illness as part of its initial benefit package, however
both bills provided for a phase-in of full parity by January 1,
2001. The Health Security Act was deliberated in the House \4\
and Senate \5\ Committees of jurisdiction however no further
action was taken on either bill.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ H.R. 3600 was referred to the: House Ways and Means Committee,
Subcommittee on Select Revenue Measures, Subcommittee on Health,
Subcommittee on Social Security; Armed Services Committee, Subcommittee
on Military Forces and Personnel; Education and Labor Committee,
Subcommittee on Labor Standards, Occupational Health and Safety,
Subcommittee on Postsecondary Education and Training, Subcommittee on
Elementary, Secondary, and Vocational Education, Subcommittee on Labor-
Management Relations, Subcommittee on Human Resources, Subcommittee on
Select Education and Civil Rights; Government Operations Committee,
Subcommittee on Information, Justice, Transportation, and Agriculture,
Subcommittee on Legislation and National Security, Subcommittee on
Human Resources and Intergovernmental Relations; Energy and Commerce
Committee, Subcommittee on Health and Environment, Subcommittee on
Commerce, Consumer Protection, and Competitiveness; Natural Resources
Committee, Subcommittee on Native American Affairs; Judiciary
Committee, Subcommittee on Economic and Commercial Law; Post Office and
Civil Service Committee; Rules Committee; Veterans' Affairs Committee,
Subcommittee on Hospitals and Health Care.
\5\ On April 26, 1994, the Senate Finance Committee held a hearing
on S. 1757.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
104TH CONGRESS (1995-1996)
On January 31, 1995 Senators Domenici and Wellstone re-
introduced the Equitable Health Care for Severe Mental
Illnesses Act, S. 298 which sought to provide full mental
health parity. The legislation had 7 co-sponsors and was
similar to language approved by the Senate on April 18, 1996 as
an amendment to S. 1028, the Health Insurance Reform Act. This
amendment was later dropped in conference. A partial parity
amendment offered by Senators Domenici and Wellstone was also
rejected by the conferees as part of the Health Insurance
Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). \6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ P.L. 104-191.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On August 2, 1996, Senators Pete Domenici and Paul
Wellstone introduced S. 2031, the Mental Health Parity Act
(MHPA). The bill had 16 bipartisan co-sponsors and was referred
to the Committee on Labor and Human Resources. MHPA required
parity for annual and lifetime dollar amounts; included an
exemption for employers with 25 or fewer employees; and applied
the parity provisions only to those group health plans that
provided mental health coverage.
Representative Marge Roukema introduced the House version
of the Mental Health Parity Act of 1996, H.R. 4058 on September
11, 1996. The MHPA garnered 22 bipartisan co-sponsors and was
referred to the Committee on Commerce, Subcommittee on Health
and Environment; the Committee on Economic and Educational
Opportunities, Subcommittee on Employer-Employee Relations; and
the Committee on Government Reform and Oversight, Subcommittee
on Civil Service.
MHPA was offered as an amendment to the FY 1997 VA-HUD
appropriations bill, H.R. 3666. On September 5, 1996, the
Senate approved the Domenici-Wellstone amendment, as amended
\7\ by an 82-15 vote. On September 11, 1996, the House voted
392-17 to adopt a motion to instruct conferees on H.R. 3666 and
among other things, to agree to the Senate mental health parity
provisions. The Domenici-Wellstone amendment was agreed to in
conference and MHPA became Title VII of the FY1997 VA-HUD
appropriations bill, which was signed into law on September 26,
1996. \8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ By voice vote, the Senate approved a second degree amendment
offered by Senator Gramm which exempted health plans from the MHPA
parity requirement if the cost of compliance exceeded the original cost
of coverage by 1 percent.
\8\ P.L 104-204. See also, Ramya Sundararaman, ``The Mental Health
Parity Act: A Legislative History,'' CRS Report for Congress, May 18,
2007 at 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
105TH CONGRESS (1997-1998)
During Congress' debate on the Balanced Budget Act of 1997
during the 105th Congress, Senators Domenici and Wellstone
successfully attached an amendment to the State Children's
Health Insurance Plan (SCHIP) which required plans offering
mental health benefits to provide full-parity coverage.
Although the language was later deleted in conference, the
conferees did accept language that required all SCHIP plans and
Medicaid managed care plans to meet the requirements of the
MHPA. The MHPA provisions were also added to the Internal
Revenue Code (IRC) through the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997. \9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ P.L. 105-34, Section 1531(a)(4), codified at 26 U.S.C. 9812.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 26, 1998, Representative Marge Roukema introduced
the Mental Health and Substance Abuse Parity Amendments of
1998, H.R. 3568. The bill had 26 Democratic and Republican co-
sponsors and was referred to the: Commerce Committee,
Subcommittee on Health and the Environment; Education and the
Workforce Committee, Subcommittee on Employer-Employee
Relations; Ways and Means Committee, Subcommittee on Health. No
further action was taken on H.R. 3568.
106TH CONGRESS (1999-2000)
On April 14, 1999, the Mental Health Equitable Treatment
Act, S. 796 was introduced by Senators Pete Domenici and Paul
Wellstone. S. 796 had 28 Democratic and Republican co-sponsors
and was referred to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor,
and Pensions.
On May 18, 2000, the Senate HELP committee held a hearing
entitled Examining Mental Health Parity Issues, including S.
796, To Provide for Full Parity with Respect to Health
Insurance Coverage for Certain Severe Biologically-based Mental
Illnesses and to Prohibit Limits on the Number of Mental
Illness-Related Hospital Days and Outpatient Visits that are
Covered for All Mental Illnesses. The hearing consisted of
three panels. The witnesses for the first panel included:
Senator Pete V. Domenici and Senator Paul D. Wellstone. The
second panel included: Kathryn G. Allen, Associate Director of
Health Financing and Public Health Issues of the U.S. General
Accounting Office and Dr. Steven E. Hyman, Director of the
National Institute of Mental Health of the National Institute
of Health. The third panel witnesses included: Ken Libertoff,
Director of the Vermont Association for Mental Health; Dr.
Kenneth Duckworth, Deputy Commissioner of the Massachusetts
Department of Mental Health; Tara Wooldridge, Manager of the
Employee Assistance Program of Delta Airlines; and Dean Rosen,
senior Vice President of Policy and General Counsel of the
Health Insurance Association of America.
Representative Marge Roukema re-introduced the Mental
Health and Substance Abuse Parity Amendments of 1999, H.R. 1515
on April 21, 1999. The bill which had 114 Democratic and
Republican co-sponsors was referred to the: Commerce Committee,
Subcommittee on Health and the Environment; Education and the
Workforce Committee, Subcommittee on Employer-Employee
Relations; Ways and Means Committee, Subcommittee on Health. No
further action was taken on H.R. 1515.
107TH CONGRESS (2001-2002)
On March 15, 2001, the Mental Health Equitable Treatment
Act of 2001 was introduced by Senators Pete Domenici and Paul
Wellstone. The bill garnered 66 Democratic and Republican
cosponsors and was referred to the HELP Committee.
Senate consideration of mental health parity legislation
On July 11, 2001 the Senate HELP Committee held a hearing
entitled Achieving Parity for Mental Health Treatment. The
witnesses included: Senator Paul Wellstone; Senator Pete
Domenici; Edward Flynn, Associate Director for Retirement and
Insurance of the Office of Personnel Management; Lisa Cohen;
Dr. Henry Harbin, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive
Officer of Magellan Health Services; and Dr. Darrel A. Regier,
Executive Director of the American Psychiatric Institute for
Research and Education.
On August 1, 2001, the Committee unanimously approved a
substitute version of S. 543. On October 30, 2001, Senators
Domenici and Wellstone offered S. 543, as reported, as an
Senate Amendment 2020 to FY 2002 Labor-HHS appropriations bill,
H.R. 3061, which the Senate approved by voice vote. The House
version of H.R. 3061 did not include any parity language and on
December 18, 2001, the House conferees rejected Representative
Kennedy's motion to accept the Domenici-Wellstone mental health
parity amendment. The conference did approve Representative
Duke Cunningham's motion to include language in the bill
reauthorizing the MHPA through December 31, 2002.
Consideration of mental health parity legislation in the House of
Representatives
On January 3, 2002, Representative Marge Roukema re-
introduced the Mental Health and Substance Abuse Parity
Amendments, H.R. 162. The bill was cosponsored by 202
Democratic and Republican members. H.R. 162 was referred to the
Energy and Commerce Committee, Subcommittee on Health; the
Education and the Workforce Committee, Subcommittee on
Employer-Employee Relations; and the Ways and Means Committee,
Subcommittee on Health.
Committee consideration of mental health parity
On March 13, 2002 the Subcommittee on Employer-Employee
Relations of the Committee on Education and the Workforce held
a hearing entitled, Assessing Mental Health Parity:
Implications for Patients and Employers. The witnesses before
this hearing included: Representative Marge Roukema;
Representative Patrick Kennedy; Representative Lynn Rivers; Kay
Nystul, Behavioral Health Nurse and Case Management Coordinator
of Wausau Benefits; Lee Dixon, Group Director of Health Policy
Tracking Service of the National Conference of State
Legislatures; Dr. Henry Harbin, Chairman of the Board of
Magellan Health Services Inc.; and Jane Greenman, Vice
President of Human Resources and Communications and Deputy
General Counsel of Honeywell International.
On July 23, 2002, the Subcommittee on Health of the
Committee on Energy and Commerce held a hearing entitled
Insurance Coverage of Mental Health Benefits. The witnesses
were Charles M. Cutler, Chief Medical Officer of the American
Association of Health Plans; James T. Hackett, Chairman,
President, and Chief Executive Officer of Ocean Energy Inc.;
Kay Nystul, Psychiatric Registered Nurse and Certified Case
Manager of Wausau Benefits Inc.; Darrel A. Regier, Director of
the Office of Research or the American Psychiatric Association;
and Neil E. Trautwein, Director of Employment Policy of the
National Association of Manufacturers.
Despite holding hearings, no further action was taken on
the mental health parity legislation introduced in the House of
Representatives. However, in two separate legislative actions,
Congress reauthorized MHPA through December 31, 2003. \10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ Section 610 of the Job Creation and Worker Assistance Act of
2002 (H.R. 3090, P.L. 107-147) amended MHPA provisions in the IRC, and
the Mental Health Parity Reauthorization Act of 2002 (H.R. 5716, P.L.
107-313) reauthorized the MHPA provisions in ERISA and the PHSA. H.R.
5716 was introduced by Representative John Boehner on November 13, 2002
and approved without objection by the House on November 15, 2002. On
the same day, the Senate received and passed the bill by unanimous
consent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
108TH CONGRESS (2003-2004)
On January 7, 2003 Senator Thomas Daschle introduced the
Health Care Coverage Expansion and Quality Improvement Act of
2003, S. 10. S. 10 required health plans treat mental illness
in a nondiscriminatory and equitable manner by covering
essential mental health treatment. The bill had 22 co-sponsors
and was referred to the Senate Finance Committee. No further
action was taken on the bill.
On February 27, 2003, Representatives Patrick Kennedy and
Jim Ramstad introduced the Senator Paul Wellstone Mental Health
and Equitable Treatment Act of 2003, H.R. 953. The bill
garnered 248 bipartisan co-sponsors and was referred to the
Energy and Commerce Committee, Subcommittee on Health; the
Education and the Workforce Committee, Subcommittee on
Employer-Employee Relations. There was no further consideration
of the bill in the house.
Also on February 27, 2003, Senators Pete Domenici and
Edward Kennedy introduced the Senate version of the Senator
Paul Wellstone Mental Health Equitable Treatment Act of 2003,
S. 486. The Act had 69 bipartisan co-sponsors and was referred
to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions. No
further action was taken on this legislation.
On November 4, 2003 the Senate HELP Committee, Subcommittee
on Substance Abuse and Mental Health held a hearing on
``Recommendations to Improve Mental Health Care in America:
Report from the President's new Freedom Commission on Mental
Health.'' The witnesses included: Stephen W. Mayberg,
Commissioner of The President's New Freedom Commission on
Mental Health; Charles G. Curie, Administrator of the Substance
Abuse and Mental Services Administration on behalf of the
Campaign for Mental Health Reform; Dr. Paul S. Appelbaum,
Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Massachusetts
Medical School; Michael M. Faenza, President and Chief
Executive Officer, national Mental Health Association on behalf
of the Campaign for Mental Health Reform; Carlos Brandenberg,
Administrator of Nevada Division of Mental Health and
Developmental Services; and Ann Buchanan.
On November 17, 2003, Senator Judd Gregg introduced the
Mental Health Parity Reauthorization Act of 2003, S. 1875, with
Senator Edward Kennedy. However, on November 21, 2003, a new
version of the Mental Health Parity Reauthorization Act of
2003, S. 1929, was introduced by Senators Gregg and Kennedy. S.
1929 was approved in the Senate by unanimous consent on the
same day. On December 8, 2003 it was passed by the House by
unanimous consent and became Public Law 108-197 on December 19,
2003.
109TH CONGRESS (2005-2006)
On March 17, 2005, Representatives Patrick Kennedy and Jim
Ramstad reintroduced the Paul Wellstone Mental Health Equitable
Treatment Act, H.R. 1402. The bill had 231 co-sponsors and was
referred to the Committee on Education and the Workforce,
Subcommittee on Employer-Employee Relations; and the Committee
on Energy and Commerce, Subcommittee on Health. On September
28, 2006, Representative Patrick Kennedy filed a discharge
petition to request the bill be released from Committee and
brought to the floor for consideration. The discharge petition
gathered only 175 of the 218 member signature needed for
discharge and subsequently failed.
No further action was taken in either the House of
Representatives or the Senate however Congress extended MHPA
through the end of 2007. \11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ P.L. 109-151. In the first session of the 109th Congress, the
Employee Retirement Preservation Act, H.R. 4579 (P.L. 109-151),
extended the provisions requiring mental health parity in ERISA, the
PHS Act, and the IRC through 2006. H.R. 4579 passed the House by voice
vote on December 17, 2005, and passed the Senate by unanimous consent
on December 22, 2005. In the second session, Section 115 of the Tax
Relief and Health Care Act of 2006, H.R. 6111 (P.L. 109-432) extended
MHPA provisions in all three statutes through 2007.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
110TH CONGRESS (2007)
The Mental Health Parity Act of 2007, S. 558 was first
introduced by Senators Pete V. Domenici and Edward Kennedy on
February 12, 2007 with 53 bipartisan co-sponsors. It was
referred to the Senate HELP Committee and subsequently to the
Subcommittee on Health.
In the House of Representatives, the Paul Wellstone Mental
Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007 was first introduced by
Representatives Patrick Kennedy and Jim Ramstad as H.R. 1367 on
March 7, 2007 with 255 co-sponsors. Two days later, on March 9,
2007 a modified version of the bill was introduced and has
garnered 268 Democratic and Republican co-sponsors. H.R. 1424
was referred to the Committee on Energy and Commerce,
Subcommittee on Health; the Committee on Education and Labor,
Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions; and
the Committee on Ways and Means, Subcommittee on Health.
Senate action on mental health parity legislation
On February 14, 2007, the HELP Committee held an executive
session to markup S. 558. During the markup Senator Harkin
offered an amendment by Senator Dodd, which included a
technical change to clarify provisions relating to a GAO study.
This amendment required GAO to examine and report on the impact
of out-of-network coverage for mental health benefits. The
amendment was adopted by unanimous consent and the bill was
favorably reported to the full Senate by a vote of 18-3. On
March 27, 2007, the Committee met again and reported an amended
version of S. 558 with an amendment in the nature of a
substitute offered by Chairman Kennedy.
Hearings on mental health parity in the House of Representatives
Ways and Means Committee, Health Subcommittee
On March 27, 2007, the Subcommittee on Health of the Ways
and Means Committee held a three panel hearing entitled Mental
Health and Substance Abuse Parity. Witnesses testifying on
panel one included: Representatives Patrick Kennedy, and Jim
Ramstad; Witnesses on panel two included: David L. Shern,
Ph.D., President and CEO, Mental Health America, Kathryne L.
Westin, M.A., L.P., Eating Disorders Coalition for Research,
Policy and Action, and Michael Quirk, Ph.D., Director,
Behavioral Health Service, Group Health Cooperative. Panel
three included: Eric Goplerud, Ph.D., Director, Ensuring
Solutions to Alcohol Problems, George Washington University;
Ronald W. Manderscheid, Ph.D., Director of Mental Health and
Substance Use Programs Constella Group LLC; and Henry T.
Harbin, M.D.
Energy and Commerce Committee, Subcommittee on Health
On June 15, 2007, the Subcommittee on Health of the
Committee on Energy and Commerce held a hearing entitled H.R.
1424, the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act
of 2007. The witnesses included: Representative Patrick
Kennedy; Representative Jim Ramstad; James Purcell, President
and Chief Executive Officer of Blue Cross & Blue Shield of
Rhode Island; Marley Prunty-Lara; Howard Goldman, Professor of
Psychiatry of the University of Maryland; Edwina Rogers, Vice
President of Health Policy for the ERISA Industry Committee;
and James Klein, President of the American Benefits Council.
Education and Labor Committee, HELP Subcommittee
On July 10, 2007, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor, and Pensions of the Committee on Education and Labor
held a two-panel hearing entitled the Paul Wellstone Mental
Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007 (H.R. 1424). The first
panel included: Representative Patrick Kennedy and
Representative Jim Ramstad. The second panel included: Rosalynn
Carter, former First Lady and chairwoman of the Carter Center's
Mental Health Task Force; David Wellstone, son of the late
Senator Paul Wellstone and co-founder of Wellstone Action; Sean
Dilweg, Insurance Commissioner for the State of Wisconsin; Amy
Smith, Vice President of Mental Health Association of Colorado;
Steve Melek, actuary for Milliman Inc.; Neil Trautwein,
Employee Benefits Policy Counsel for the National Retail
Federation; and Jon Breyfogle, executive principal for the
Groom Law Group.
Education and Labor Committee full committee mark-up of the Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007
On July 18, 2007, the Committee on Education and Labor met
to markup H.R. 1424, the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and
Addiction Equity Act of 2007. The Committee adopted by voice
vote an amendment in the nature of a substitute offered by
Chairman Miller and reported the bill favorably as amended by a
vote of 33-9 to the House of Representatives.
The Miller amendment incorporates the provisions of H.R.
1424 with the following modifications:
Adds emergency care to the list of categories of
items and services that are subject to the treatment limit
parity requirements (other categories are inpatient in-network,
inpatient out-of-network, outpatient in-network, and outpatient
out-of-network).
Makes clear that the requirement that group health
plans make available to patients and providers their criteria
for medical necessity determinations and reasons for any denial
under the plan be provided in accordance with Department of
Labor regulations.
Adds a provision that group health plans may
utilize industry and provider recognized benefit management
practices for medical, surgical, mental health and substance
related disorder benefits.
Conforms preemption of state laws to existing
HIPAA standards with specific protection of state laws relating
to health insurance issuers including state laws providing for
external review, requiring minimum benefits, covering employers
with fewer than 50 employees, or solely related to health
insurance issuers.
Makes clear that collectively bargained plans
become subject to the Act upon the expiration of an existing
collective bargaining agreement.
Requires the Department of Labor to annually
sample and conduct random audits of group health plans to
ensure compliance with the Act.
Requires the Department of Labor to assist
individuals with any questions or problems under the Act and to
coordinate with state consumer protection agencies.
The Kline amendment in the nature of a substitute was
defeated by a vote of 16-27. The amendment incorporated an
amended version of S. 558, the Senate Mental Health Parity Act
of 2007.
The Kline amendment differed from H.R. 1424 in at least two
key areas. First, the Kline amendment would expressly permit
every employer or health insurance issuer to establish its own
definition of ``mental health benefits.'' In contrast, H.R.
1424 seeks to provide private sector employees the same mental
health coverage provided to federal employees by requiring
group health plans to utilize the definition of mental health
benefits under by the federal employee health plan with the
largest average enrollment of federal employees.
The Committee supported the need for a federal standard for
covered mental health benefits because of the long history of
employer and insurer denial of coverage for mental health
illnesses. As described elsewhere in this report, employers and
insurers, historically and currently, have not provided
comparable coverage of mental illnesses as they have of
physical illnesses. For example, employers and insurers
generally do not list covered and non-covered physical
illnesses, whereas such delineation of mental illnesses is
commonplace.
The Kline Substitute would have permitted employers to
create millions of definitions of mental health benefits
undermining the need for uniformity that employers claim to
seek. Employers would be free to eviscerate the intent of the
Act simply by defining mental health benefits to exclude
benefits the employer or insurer does not want to cover. This
would allow insurance companies and group health plans to
codify discrimination by diagnosis allowing plans to use
arbitrary, non-scientific criteria in determining what mental
illnesses and addiction disorders to cover.
The minority may argue that creation of a federal
definition of mental health benefits exceeds ``technical
parity'' since federal law does not define medical or surgical
benefits. But, there is no data or allegations that employers
or insurers narrowly define medical benefits, whereas there is
ample data that employers and insurers have used narrow mental
health definitions to evade coverage. Without a definition of
covered mental health benefits, mental health parity
legislation would continue to include loopholes that make
parity an illusory promise.
The minority also expresses concern that defining mental
health benefits would create a ``new mandate'' and could
increase employer costs and reduce employer health benefit
coverage. Again, the minority is ignoring the history and
evidence on this matter. Both federal and state law
traditionally and repeatedly set minimum standards for the
provision of health care benefits when public policy concerns
have warranted such. Experience has demonstrated that such
minimum standards do not lead to reduced coverage or increased
costs. Specifically with respect to mental health parity
legislation, neither the federal employee, state nor private
sector experience bears out the minority's fears. As noted
below, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), U.S. Government
Accountability Office (GAO), and numerous other actuarial
analyses have documented that expanded mental health coverage
does not significantly increase costs or reduce coverage.
Second, the Kline Substitute differed from H.R. 1424 in its
preemption of state health care laws. The Majority and minority
face fundamental differences on the issue of preemption.
Historically, states have had the primary responsibility for
protecting the public health of their citizens. States have
regulated the provision of insurance, including health
insurance, for hundreds of years. In fact, even into current
times, the insurance community has preferred state regulation
over federal regulation of insurance practices.
Congress' active involvement with national health care
primarily began with the enactment of Medicare and Medicaid in
1965 and Congress has struggled with the need for additional
national reforms ever since. Since 1996, a key principle for
Congress has been to incrementally reform private health
coverage by establishing a federal floor of protections for
workers and their families. Through a federal standard that is
a floor, not a ceiling, Congress has recognized that state
policymakers may determine that to protect patients in state-
regulated plans, a stronger set of standards are necessary than
those provided in federal law. In fact, many states now require
insurance companies to cover mental health services. This bill
recognizes and encourages states to enact stronger consumer
protections.
In addition to benefit requirements, many states have set
standards to improve the quality of coverage to ensure that
health insurance actually works for people who need it, while
establishing rules to combat abusive practices by some in the
health insurance industry. States have used a myriad of
strategies to accomplish that, including patient protections
and standards for medical management. Nothing in this bill is
intended to in any way to affect those (or future) state
efforts.
Understandably, large employers who operate in multiple
states prefer a single unified system--with one set of rules
with which they must comply and treat their employees. But,
large employers who once accepted the need for some federal
minimum health care standards, now generally want only minimal
rules at both the federal and state level. The employer
community has used the Employee Retirement Income Security Act
(ERISA) \12\ ERISA as a shield against both federal and state
health care protections. Only the most sophisticated legal and
health care experts know that ERISA contains few health care
standards. ERISA is primarily a pension law that establishes
detailed standards for information, coverage, and funding of
pension promises. While ERISA applies to all employer provided
employee benefits, it does not generally contain minimum health
care standards. Enacted in 1974, Congress expected that it
would shortly adopt comprehensive federal standards. Congress
has attempted to enact national health care standards on
several occasions, but without success.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ P.L. 93-406.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As a result, the United States has not created a national
system for providing health care to all citizens. Rather, it
has a patchwork of federal and state and local laws providing a
wide variety of health care requirements and protections for
employers, insurers, and citizens. The large employers argue
that only the federal government should set standards and
preferably minimal ones. Congress' choice is either to adopt
comprehensive federal standards, free the states to enact
comprehensive state standards or to continue dual federal and
state regulation.
Further complicating the issue is the illogical treatment
of ``insured'' versus ``self-insured'' plans. Under current
judicial interpretation of ERISA, if an employer establishes a
health plan and the employer is the insurer of the plan, then
the states are generally preempted from regulating the health
plan. However, if the employer contracts with a state licensed
insurance company or other state sanctioned health care entity,
then the state may directly regulate the behavior of the
insurer or other entity, and indirectly affect the actions of
the health plan. Despite the illogic of this regulatory scheme,
in the absence of broader Congressional direction on
comprehensive health care reform, H.R. 1424 continues this
existing system of split federal versus state oversight of
health plans and benefits.
However, solely with respect to mental health parity laws,
H.R. 1424 seeks to provide some improvement in the longstanding
morass created by ERISA's preemption of state laws. Thousands
of court cases and dozens of law review articles have argued
over the correct intent and interpretation of ERISA preemption
of state laws. On the whole, ERISA preemption has served to
take away legal protections for workers and consumers. Although
Congress' original intent had been strong federal standards
over state standards, judicial interpretation of ERISA has
created weak federal standards and minimal state protection.
Congress' long debate over what was known as the Patient's Bill
of Rights\13\ amply documented how ERISA preemption has harmed
consumers and undermined long term health care reform efforts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\ The Patient's Bill of Rights Act of 2005, H.R. 2259 was
introduced in the House on May 11, 2005 by Representative John Dingell.
Senator Edward Kennedy introduced the Senate version of the bill, S.
1012 on May 12, 2005.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1424 rejects the continuation of this unfair
preemption scheme. The bill adopts the model created by the
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of
1996.\14\ The bill generally would not preempt state laws that
do not ``prevent the application'' of federal mental health
parity standards. The bill also specifically enumerates types
of laws that Congress does not intend to preempt. Those laws
include state laws establishing, implementing or continuing
consumer protections, benefits, methods of access to benefits,
rights, external review programs, or remedies solely relating
to health insurance issuers. The bill also specifically does
not intend to preempt state laws containing benefit mandates,
regulation of small employer group health plans or state laws
solely related to health insurance issuers. Further, this bill
would not relieve a company--licensed or registered under state
law to perform utilization review--from its licensing or other
applicable standards and obligations under state law. Unlike
ERISA, HIPAA's preemption provisions have not been subject to
excessive litigation and have provided certainty to consumers,
employers and states.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ P.L. 104-191.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Both the House and Senate passed versions of the Genetic
Information Nondiscrimination Act, H.R. 493 used the HIPAA
model to coordinate between federal and state regulatory
policies.
In contrast, the Kline Substitute provides exceptions to
its general preemption that are ambiguous and likely would
invite innumerable ERISA litigation challenges.\15\ The first
exception seeks to clarify that portions of state law not
preempted will continue to apply and that individual and small
group coverage standards are not preempted. Yet, the language
in Kline Substitute does not clearly ensure protection of
existing individual and small group insurance market state
laws. If the Kline Substitute were to become law, then states
with one mental health coverage standard that applies to
policies sold in the large group, small group and individual
health insurance markets most likely can expect preemption
challenges to their individual and small group mental health
laws.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ See, Mila Koffman, Letter to Speaker Nancy Pelosi ( June 15,
2007). Mila Koffman is a nationally recognized expert on insurance
regulation, unauthorized insurance and ERISA. She previously served as
a federal regulator at the U.S. Department of Labor and as a special
assistant to the Senior Health Care Advisor to President Bill Clinton.
\16\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, the Kline Substitute would not preempt state
coverage laws for ``specific items, benefits, or services.''
These terms are not defined and thus the ambiguity of this
language makes it unclear as to what type of state law would
qualify as requiring ``specific items, benefits, or services.''
Furthermore, it is unclear as to whether a qualified law
coupled with ``parity requirements'' (e.g. requiring alcohol
abuse treatment) would be eligible under this exception. Again,
clarification would have to be determined through
litigation.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An example of how the Senate proposal would create
ambiguity can be demonstrated by California's mental health
parity law. California has a standard mental health parity law
which applies generally to health insurance coverage. Since
California does not apply a specific law to the individual and
small group markets, there is no guarantee that courts will
uphold the law under an ERISA preemption challenge. In
addition, Connecticut's mental health coverage law has elements
of ``parity'' and therefore may have to be litigated to
determine which, if any, requirements would survive
preemption.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to preempting stronger state parity laws and
allowing insurance companies and group health plans to
discriminate against an array of mental and substance abuse
illnesses, the Kline Substitute does not provide any legal
remedies for patients. Many Members of the Committee have long
supported meaningful remedies for violations of the law and
H.R. 1424 seeks to make clear that Congress never intended to
preempt state insurance laws that provide legal protections to
individuals covered by state regulated insurance products.
III. Summary of the Bill
The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act,
H.R. 1424 amends the ERISA and the Public Health Service Act
(PHSA) \19\ to prohibit employer group health plans offering
mental health benefits from imposing mental health treatment
limitations or financial requirements at a less comparable rate
to the requirements and limitations they impose on medical or
surgical benefits. The bill does not mandate group health plans
to provide any mental health coverage; however, if the group
health plan does offer mental health coverage then there must
be equity between mental health coverage and all comparable
medical and surgical benefits that the plan covers. H.R. 1424
makes clear that equity in financial requirements, treatment
limitations, and out of network coverage is essential to a
strong federal mental health parity law. Furthermore, the plan
must cover the same range of mental illnesses and addiction
disorders covered by the Federal Employee Health Plan that most
federal employees and Members of Congress use.\20\ As of July
18, 2007, H.R. 1424 had 268 co-sponsors, 230 Democrats and 38
Republicans.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ 42 U.S.C. Sec. 6A.
\20\ Summary of H.R. 1424, available at: http://www.thomas.gov/cgi-
bin/bdquery/z?d110:h.r.01424.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. Statement and Committee Views
The Committee on Education and Labor of the 110th Congress
is committed to improving access to health care, including
treatment for mental health and substance disorders. The Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act addresses the
inequities that those with mental illness experience in their
health care coverage. The bill would prohibit group health
plans from imposing financial requirements or treatment
limitations on the coverage of mental health conditions and
substance abuse that are more limited than those available for
medical and surgical benefits. The Act is a cost-effective way
of promoting increased access to mental health care.
To echo the words of former First Lady Rosalyn Carter, who
testified before the Education and Labor Committee's Health,
Employment, Labor, Pensions (HELP) Subcommittee:
it is unconscionable in our country and morally
unacceptable to treat 20 percent of our population (1 in every
5 people in our country will experience a mental illness this
year) as though they were not worthy of care . . . [t]hen we
pay the price for this folly in homelessness, lives lost,
families torn apart, loss of productivity.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\ The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007 (H.R. 1424), hearing before the Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, & Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) (written
testimony of Rosalyn Carter) [hereinafter Carter Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mental Illness: An Overview
An estimated 40 million American adults suffer from some
type of mental illness each year, while 5.5 million or 6
percent suffer from a severe mental illness such as
schizophrenia or major depression.\22\ Approximately 1 in 17
Americans suffer from a serious mental illness; about 12
million children suffer from mental disorders such as autism,
depression and hyperactivity; \23\ and every year, about 54
million Americans suffer from clearly diagnosable mental or
substance abuse disorders.\24\ Overall, approximately 26.2
percent of Americans are afflicted with mental illness or
substance abuse disorders; \25\ while 14.8 million Americans
suffer from depression; and 2.4 million suffer from
schizophrenic disorders.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\ The Government Accounting Office (GAO). ``Mental Health Parity
Act: Despite New Federal Standards, Mental Health Benefits Remain
Limited,'' (May 2000) at 7.
\23\ Colleen Barry et al., ``Design of Mental Health Benefits:
Still Unequal After All These Years,'' Health Affairs, September/
October 2003.
\24\ National Mental Health Association, ``Mental Illness in the
Family,'' 2005.
\25\ National Institutes of Mental Health, ``The Numbers Count:
Mental Disorders in America,'' 2006.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mental health is essential to leading a healthy life and to
the development and realization of a person's full
potential.\26\ For those who suffer from mental illness,
``mental disorders are treatable . . . there is generally not
just one but a range of treatments of proven efficacy.'' \27\
Despite proven treatments, due to the social stigma and lack of
understanding about the disease, mental illness often goes
untreated. As a result, mental illness and substance-abuse
disorders are leading causes of disability and premature
mortality.\28\ As scientific knowledge about mental health has
grown and analyses have proven a nominal economic impact on the
consumer, the employer, and the insurance company with respect
to mental health, coverage for mental illness continues to
expand. Nevertheless, stigma still remains; the result is that
many people in need of mental services are prevented from
receiving proper care.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\ Mental Health and Substance Abuse Parity, hearing before the
House Committee on Ways and Means, Subcommittee on Health, 110th Cong.,
1st Sess. (2007) at 1 (written testimony of David L. Shern)
[hereinafter Shern Testimony].
\27\ U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Svrs., Mental Health: A Report of
the Surgeon General 46, 179 (1999) hereinafter SGRMH].
\28\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The term mental illness refers collectively to all
diagnosable mental disorders. Mental disorders are health
conditions that are characterized by alterations in thinking,
mood, or behavior associated with distress and/or impaired
functioning.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Social stigma about mental illness dates as far back as the
17th Century.\30\ The stigmatization of mental illness is
manifested by bias, distrust, stereotyping, fear,
embarrassment, anger, and/or avoidance. It is this stigma that
leads people to avoid living, socializing or working with,
renting to, or employing people with mental disorders. Stigma
also reduces an individual's access to resources and
opportunities such as jobs and housing as well as leading to
low self-esteem, isolation, and hopelessness.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\ Patrick Kennedy. ``Policy Essay: Why We Must End Insurance
Discrimination Against Mental Health Care.'' Harvard Journal on
Legislation Vol. 44, No. 2. (Summer 2004) available at: http://
www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/jol/vol41_2/kennedy.php. The French
philosopher Rene Descartes' theory of dualism--the separation of mind
and body--is seen as the non-scientific basis as to why people continue
to believe having a mental illness is a personal failing, rather than a
treatable disease. Descartes believed that while physicians had the
ability to treat physical ailments, the mind, which implicated the
spirit, could only be ``treated'' through religion.
\31\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The public attitude toward mental illness has been surveyed
nationally since the 1950s.\32\ In the 1950s, many people
displayed an unscientific understanding of mental illness and
had difficulty distinguishing mental illness from ordinary
unhappiness. It was this misunderstanding of mental illness,
along with the fear of unpredictable and violent behavior that
perpetuated the social stigma behind it.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\ Id.
\33\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although Americans had achieved a better scientific
understanding of mental illness by 1996, social stigma had not
diffused. As the public's acceptance of classifying anxiety and
depression as mental disorders has grown so has their
perception that mental illness frequently incorporates violent
behavior.\34\ In 1996, 31 percent of the people surveyed
mentioned violence in their descriptions of mental illness, in
comparison with 13 percent in the 1950s.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\ Id.
\35\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the late 1990s, people with diagnosable mental disorders
did not seek treatment due to the social stigma surrounding
mental illness.\36\ Furthermore, the public was reluctant to
pay for less severe mental health conditions due in large part
to stigma but also due to their realization that higher taxes
and premiums would be necessary to offset these costs.\37\ As
former First Lady Carter testified, ``if insurance covered
mental illnesses, it would be right to have them. This may be
why the stigma has remained so pervasive. Because these
illnesses are treated differently from other health
conditions.'' \38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\ Id.
\37\ Id.
\38\ Carter Testimony at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mental health coverage today
Health insurance plans have long imposed barriers that
limit access to needed behavioral health care with far-reaching
and often tragic results.\39\ No comparable barriers limit
access to needed care for any other illness. The discriminatory
practices that have continued over forty years after the
adoption of the first modern civil rights' laws attest to the
deep-rootedness of stigma surrounding behavioral disorders.\40\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\ Shern Testimony at 2.
\40\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2004, more than 23 million people aged 12 or older
required treatment for alcohol or illicit drug use but only 2.3
million received it.\41\ For the 21.1 million who did not
obtain treatment, cost and insurance barriers were cited as the
primary obstacle.\42\ In 2002, the Kaiser Family Foundation/
Health Research and Educational Trust conducted an employer
survey which found that while 98 percent of workers with
employer-sponsored health insurance had coverage for mental
health care, 74 percent of those covered workers were subject
to an annual outpatient visit limit, and 64 percent were
subject to an annual inpatient days limits.\43\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\41\ National Institutes of Mental Health, supra note 25.
\42\ Id.
\43\ Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and
Educational Trust (KFF/HRET) national employer survey (2002).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In her testimony before the House Energy and Commerce
Committee hearing, Marley Prunty-Lara testified about her
struggle with bipolar disorder and the difficulty she
experienced when trying to get treatment. Prunty-Lara told of
how she experienced first-hand the ``harrowing, sinister,
suicidal depression no one talks about.'' \44\ However, as a
15-year-old with bipolar disorder, her mother struggled to find
her treatment. Her state of South Dakota had limited mental
health resources and the waiting list was four to five months
to simply get an initial appointment. Prunty-Lara had to go 350
miles away to finally get treatment, however her treatment
facility was not covered by her mother's insurance.
Consequently, her parents were forced to take out a second
mortgage on their home to pay for the life-saving
treatment.\45\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\ H.R. 1424, The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act, hearing before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce,
Subcommittee on Health, 110th Cong., 1st Sess., June 2007 (written
testimony of Marley Prunty-Lara) [hereinafter Prunty-Lara Testimony].
\45\ Id. at 1-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Evidence demonstrates without adequate treatment, mental
illnesses can continue or worsen in severity. Each year, 30,000
Americans take their lives, hundreds of thousands attempt to do
so, and in ninety percent of these situations, the cause is
untreated mental illness.\46\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\ The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007 (H.R. 1424), hearing before the Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, & Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) at 5
(written testimony of David Wellstone) [hereinafter Wellstone
Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first federal mental health parity law
Congress took a first step toward ending discriminatory
insurance practices with the enactment of the Mental Health
Parity Act of 1996. As the first mental health parity law, MHPA
sought to address the discrepancies in coverage between mental
and other illnesses. The new law required employer-sponsored
group health plans to abide by a set of new federal standards
on mental health coverage. Specifically, the law prohibits
employers from imposing annual or lifetime dollar limits on
mental health coverage that are more restrictive than those
imposed on medical and surgical coverage.\47\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\47\ General Accounting Office, supra note 22 at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Through its adoption, significant progress has been made in
the way of providing mental health coverage to those Americans
suffering from a mental illness. During his testimony before
the Education and Labor HELP Subcommittee on July 10, 2007,
John Breyfogyle, testifying on behalf of the American Benefits
Council, acknowledged that ``better medical evidence on
behavioral health conditions has become available and better
treatment options have advanced during this period.'' \48\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\48\ The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007 (H.R. 1424), hearing before the Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, & Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) at 1
(written testimony of John Breyfogyle) [hereinafter Breyfogyle
Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the 1996 Act represented an important milestone, it
has not produced fundamental changes.\49\ People with or at
risk of behavioral-health disorders continue to face arbitrary
discrimination in insurance plans. When reviewing the
implementation of MHPA, GAO reported that the vast majority of
issuers and group health plans it surveyed complied with the
law, but substituted new restrictions and limitations on mental
health benefits, thereby evading the letter of the law.\50\
While the MHPA moved most employer plans toward parity in
dollar limits for mental health coverage, the GAO reported that
87 percent of complying employers contained at least one other
plan design feature that was more restrictive for mental health
benefits than for medical and surgical benefits. Furthermore,
one-fourth of employers did not comply, leaving their dollar
limits unchanged.\51\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\49\ Shern Testimony at 2.
\50\ General Accounting Office, supra note 22 at 21.
\51\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Loopholes in MHPA have created a system where employers
routinely limit mental health benefits more severely than
medical and surgical coverage, most often by restricting the
number of covered outpatient visits and hospital days and by
imposing far higher cost sharing requirements.\52\ These
loopholes allow employers and insurance companies to deny
mental health coverage to individuals and families most in need
of it.\53\ Consequently, individuals and families with adequate
health care coverage will continue to watch their premiums
increase as the uninsured and those with limited coverage
continue to go to the emergency room to treat an illness that
could have been cured at a far less cost if treated earlier in
a doctor's office.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\52\ Id. at 13-14.
\53\ Kennedy, supra note 30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Need to expand access to mental health care
Parity in mental health is needed because of the enormous
impact that mental illness and substance abuse has on our
society. Mental illness and substance abuse result in
substantial lost productivity and absenteeism. It has been
determined that mental illness and substance abuse cause more
days of work loss and work impairment than many other chronic
conditions such as diabetes, arthritis, and asthma.
Approximately 217 million days of work are lost annually due to
productivity decline related to mental illness and substance
abuse disorders, costing employers approximately $17 billion
each year.\54\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\54\ Dr. Robin Hertz. ``The Impact of Mental Disorders on Work.''
Pfizer Pharmaceutical Group. (June 2002) available at http://
www.pfizer.com/pfizer/download/health/pubs__facts__workimpact.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to Congressman Patrick Kennedy, who testified at
the HELP Subcommittee hearing on the ``Paul Wellstone Mental
Health and Addiction Equity Act'' on July 10, 2007, it is
estimated that:
untreated mental health and addiction cost employers and
society hundreds of billions of dollars in lost productivity.
The World Health Organization has found that these diseases are
far and away the most disabling diseases, accounting for more
than a fifth of all lost days of productive life. Depressed
workers miss 5.6 hours per week of productivity due to
absenteeism and presenteeism, compared to 1.5 hours for non-
depressed workers. Alcohol-related illness and premature death
cost over $129.5 billion in lost productivity per year.\55\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\55\ The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act,
hearing before the Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, &
Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) (written testimony of Rep.
Patrick Kennedy) [hereinafter Kennedy Testimony].
Many U.S. business leaders fully understand the high
returns wielded when investing in full mental health benefits
for their employees. For example, James Hackett, the CEO of
Ocean Energy, said that the increase in annual health costs to
offer full parity between mental and physical health benefits
is ``more than offset by avoided costs of lost employee
productivity.'' \56\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\56\ Kennedy, supra note 30 at 367.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gaps in coverage due to insurance discrimination
While considerable scientific evidence supports the claim
that a separation between the mind and body does not exist,
stigma and insurance discrimination continue to stand in the
way for many Americans seeking access to adequate mental health
coverage.\57\ Despite the fact that former Surgeon General
David Satcher wrote in his report on mental health in 1999 that
the distinction between mind and body is arbitrary and not
supported by science \58\ and the National Institute of Mental
Health continues to provide scientific evidence of the
physiology of mental illness,\59\ our country's insurance
policies continue to perpetuate the stigma and discrimination
surrounding mental illness.\60\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\57\ Id.
\58\ SGRMH at 5-6.
\59\ See, e.g., Nat'l Inst. of Mental Health, Schizophrenia
Research 2 (May 2000) (noting that NIMH investigators have ``recently
discovered specific, subtle abnormalities in the structure and function
of the brains of patients with schizophrenia''); Nat'l Inst. of Mental
Health, Bipolar Disorder Research 4 (Apr. 2000), (concluding that
``[o]ne of the most consistent findings to date has been the appearance
of specific abnormalities, or lesions, in the white matter of the brain
in patients with bipolar disorder''); Nat'l Institute of Mental Health,
Anxiety Disorder Research 3 (August 1999) (finding that animal research
suggests ``different anxiety disorders may be associated with
activation in different parts of the amygdala [a structure in the
brain]'').
\60\ See GAO Report, supra note 22, at 12 (finding that more than a
quarter of private health plans require greater cost-sharing for mental
health care than physical health care); See also, Colleen L. Barry et
al., Design of Mental Health Benefits: Still Unequal After All These
Years, Health Affairs, Sept.-Oct. 2003, at 127, 129 (finding that 22%
of private health plans have greater cost-sharing for mental health
care).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employers and insurance companies routinely discriminate
against mental health coverage when it comes to reimbursing
individuals for their mental benefits. Insurers routinely
increase patients' costs for mental health treatment by
limiting inpatient days, capping outpatient visits, and
requiring higher co-payments than for physical illnesses. It is
estimated that over 90 percent of workers with employer-
sponsored health insurance are enrolled in plans that impose
higher costs in at least one of these ways. Furthermore, 48
percent are enrolled in plans that impose all three
limitations.\61\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\61\ Colleen Barry et al., ``Design of Mental Health Benefits:
Still Unequal After All These Years,'' Health Affairs, September/
October 2003.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2000, GAO found that issuers and group health plans
provide more limited mental health coverage primarily because
of cost concerns. Limits on hospital days, outpatient office
visits, and annual or lifetime dollar amounts may reflect an
issuer's concern about the high costs associated with long-
term, intensive psychotherapy and extended hospital stays.
Issuers may also restrict mental health benefits to protect
themselves from perceived fears of adverse selection based on
the argument that a plan with generous mental health benefits
is more likely to attract a disproportionate number of
individuals with a high demand for mental health services, and
thus may drive up claims and premium costs of the plan.\62\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\62\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In his testimony before the Education and Labor HELP
Subcommittee David Wellstone stated that in a ``recent study of
employer provided benefits . . . . the cost-sharing for
addiction benefits was 46% higher for addiction benefits than
for medical or surgical benefits and there were no out of
pocket spending caps for addiction spending in 44% of the plans
studied.'' \63\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\63\ Wellstone Testimony.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gaps in coverage due to the limited reach of state laws
The inequities in mental health coverage were first
addressed by the states in the 1970s. In 1991, Texas and North
Carolina were the first states to enact mental health parity
legislation.\64\ Today, 46 states have some type of mental
health law but they vary considerably and can be divided into
three categories: (1) mental health ``full parity'' or ``equal
coverage'' laws; (2) minimum mandated mental health benefit
laws; and (3) mandated mental health ``offering laws.'' \65\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\64\ Sundararaman, supra note 8.
\65\ The National Conference of State Legislatures, ``State Laws
Mandating or Regulating Mental Health Benefits,'' available at: http://
www.ncsl.org/programs.health.mentalben.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Full mental health parity laws prohibit insurers or group
health plans from discriminating between coverage offered for
mental illness, serious mental illness, substance abuse, and
other physical disorders or diseases, and requires them to
offer the same level of benefits across the board. ``Full
parity'' means that an individual receives the same health care
coverage for physical illnesses and mental health coverage,
including treatment limitations and financial requirements.
Today, 28 states have laws that mandate full-parity mental
health coverage.\66\ Although mental health parity laws have
increased coverage, they also have important limitations.
Besides the fact that they do not apply to self-insured group
health plans due to interpretations of ERISA's preemption
clause,\67\ these state full-parity laws seldom provide
catastrophic coverage against the financial risk of severe
mental illness.\68\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\66\ Sundararaman, supra note 8 at 7.
\67\ The National Conference of State Legislatures, ``State Laws
Mandating or Regulating Mental Health Benefits,'' available at: http://
www.ncsl.org/programs.health.mentalben.htm.
\68\ Sundararaman, supra note 8 at 15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, state laws mandating full-parity differ in the
types of mental illnesses and health plans they cover. In
twelve of the states offering full-parity, the laws only apply
to the treatment of all the conditions listed in the DSM-
IV,\69\ while the other state full-parity laws restrict
coverage to specified ``serious'' or ``biological based''
mental illness. In fifteen of the states that offer full
parity, the laws apply to both insured group and individual
health plans, compared to nine states where the laws only apply
to insured group health plans.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\69\ The DSM-IV is a categorization of psychiatric diagnoses for
all mental health disorders for both children and adults. The manual
also lists known causes of these disorders, statistics in terms of
gender, age at onset, and prognosis, as well as some research
concerning the optimal treatment approaches. Mental health
professionals use the DSM-IV when working with patients in order to
better understand their illness and potential treatment and to help 3rd
party payers (e.g., insurance providers) understand the needs of the
patient. The book is typically considered the `bible'' for any
professional who makes psychiatric diagnoses in the United States and
many other countries. See also: http://allpsych.com/disorders/dsm.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Six states have enacted minimum mandated benefit laws.
These laws require ``some'' level of coverage be provided for
mental illness, serious mental illness, substance abuse or a
combination thereof. This is not considered full parity because
these laws allow discrepancies in the level of benefits
provided between mental illnesses and physical illnesses. These
discrepancies can be in the form of different visit limits, co-
payments, deductibles and annual lifetime limits.\70\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\70\ Sundararaman, supra note 8 at 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fourteen states have enacted mandated offering laws.
Mandated offering laws differ from the full-parity and minimum
mandated benefit laws because they do not require that benefits
be provided at all. Rather, they require that: (1) an option of
coverage for mental illness, serious mental illness, substance
abuse or a combination, be provided to the insured (this option
can be accepted or rejected by the health service plan); and
(2) if benefits are offered they must be equal.\71\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\71\ The National Conference of State Legislatures, ``State Laws
Mandating or Regulating Mental Health Benefits,'' available at: http://
www.ncsl.org/programs.health.mentalben.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
States with full-parity laws include Arkansas, California,
Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa,
Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, New
Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Rhode Island,
South Carolina, South Dakota, Vermont, Virginia, Washington,
and West Virginia. States with minimum mandated benefits
include Alaska, Maryland, Michigan, Nevada, North Dakota,
Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and Texas. States providing
mandated offering law include Alabama, Arizona, District of
Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky,
Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, New Mexico, Utah
and Wisconsin.\72\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\72\ Sundararaman, supra note 8 at 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mental health parity is cost-effective
Fair and equitable mental health treatment can be offered
as part of a health benefit package without escalating costs.
However, opponents of mental health parity often cite cost and
an increased burden on employers as the reason to reject mental
health parity. But as Representative Jim Ramstad noted in his
testimony before the Education and Labor Committee, HELP
Subcommittee, ``expanding access to treatment is not only the
right thing to do; it's also cost-effective . . . for the price
of a cheap cup of coffee per month, sixteen million people in
health plans could receive treatment for their mental illness
or chemical addiction.\73\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\73\ The Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007 (H.R. 1424), hearing before the Subcommittee on Health,
Employment, Labor, & Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) at 5
(written testimony of Rep. Jim Ramstad) [hereinafter Ramstad
Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In his testimony before the Energy and Commerce Committee,
Subcommittee on Health, James Purcell, President and CEO of
Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island (``BCBSRI'') testified
about BCBSRI's efforts to integrate behavioral and physical
health, as it is the future and so fundamental to complete
care.\74\ Purcell testified that not only is this the right
thing to do, it is cost effective. The impact on claims costs
of limiting annual coverage to fifteen visits rather than 30
visits would be approximately 0.3 percent of total claims.''
\75\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\74\ H.R. 1424, the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act, hearing before the Energy and Commerce Committee,
Subcommittee on Health, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) (written
testimony of James E. Purcell) [hereinafter Purcell Testimony].
\75\ Id. at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Numerous studies support the conclusion that while mental
health parity imposes a nominal increase in costs to employers,
it greatly benefits society as a whole. Stephen Melek, Bruce
Pyenson, and Kathryn Fitch at Milliman Consultants and
Actuaries issued a report on July 5, 2007 entitled, An
Actuarial Analysis of the Impact of H.R. 1424. The study
analyzed the estimated cost of implementing H.R. 1424.\76\ By
evaluating the approximate cost of implementing mental health
parity in comparison to the cost of implementation if the
organization implements utilization management (UM), where all
benefit plans would choose to further tighten their degree of
behavioral healthcare management.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\76\ Stephen Melek, Bruce Pyenson, and Kathryn Fitch, An Actuarial
Analysis of the Impact of H.R. 1424, ``The Paul Wellstone Mental Health
and Addiction Equity Act of 2007,'' (July 2007). See also, The Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007 (H.R. 1424),
hearing before the Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, &
Pensions, 110th Cong., 1st Sess. (2007) at 5 (written testimony of
Stephen Melek) [hereinafter Melek Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Milliman study projected that the cost increase for
health insurance premiums would rise by between less than 0.1
percent and 0.6 percent, or between $0.03 and $2.40 per member
per month. Employer contributions for health costs would rise
by between less than 0.1 percent and 0.2 percent.\77\
Utilization of facility-based behavioral healthcare services
would increase by 9.7 percent, while professional services
would increase by 30.0 percent without UM.\78\ However, with
UM, it projects a 21.3 percent decrease in use of facility-
based services (the majority from mental health services) and a
3.1 percent increase for professional services. Member out-of-
pocket costs for behavioral health services would decrease by
18 percent or about $0.20 per member per month without UM,
reflecting balance between an increase in total out-of-pocket
costs from higher service use by members under the higher
parity benefit limits and a decrease in out-of-pocket costs per
unit due to lower parity cost-sharing. For every 100,000 fully
insured lives, member out-of-pocket costs are estimated to drop
by $240,000 annually. Finally, the study estimates that
administrative costs account for about 15 percent of the total
increase, or $0.36 or less per member per month.\79\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\77\ Id. at 3.
\78\ Id.
\79\ Id. at 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Howard Goldman testified before the Energy and Commerce
Committee \80\ about his work, including that contained within
the ``Surgeon General's Report on Mental Health,'' including
his analysis of the cost of implementing the parity policy in
the Federal Health Employee Benefit (FEHB) program. His
research concluded that the policy was implemented smoothly and
that plans did not drop out of the FEHB program. As a result,
he further found that there was a significant decline in out-
of-pocket spending in the FEHB plans compared to the non-parity
plans. Goldman testified that this indicates parity coverage
resulted in improved insurance protection against financial
risks--the principal objective of health insurance. This
savings to FEHB plan members was not associated with
significant increases in use and spending attributable to
parity. In fact, for the most part, increases in use and total
spending in the FEHB plans were no greater than use and total
spending increases in the comparison plans. This was true for
adults, as well as for children and adolescents. The study
concluded that parity of coverage of mental health and
substance abuse services, when coupled with management of care,
is feasible and can accomplish its objectives of greater
fairness and improved insurance protection without adverse
consequences for health care costs.\81\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\80\ H.R. 1424, the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act, hearing before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce,
Subcommittee on Health, 110th Cong., 1st Sess., June 2007 (written
testimony of Dr. Howard Goldman) [hereinafter Goldman Testimony].
\81\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 2000 GAO report on mental health parity, GAO found
that the federal parity law appears to have had a negligible
effect on claims costs. Only about 3 percent of responding
employers reported that compliance with the law increased their
claim costs, and virtually no employers had dropped their
mental health benefits or health coverage altogether since the
law was enacted.\82\ In addition, the CBO scored the Senate
parity bill, S. 558 and concluded that there will be a nominal
increase, approximately .4 percent,\83\ in cost to a group
health plan over the next ten years.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\82\ Government Accountability Office, supra note 22 at 6.
\83\ CBO anticipates that approximately 60 percent of the .4
percent cost increase will be offset by employers changing the scope of
benefits offered as a result of S. 558. The remaining 40 percent of the
cost increase is expected to be covered by employees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
V. Section-by-Section Analysis
Title of the bill
Section 1. Provides that the short title of H.R. 1424 is
the ``Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007.''
Amendments to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974
Section 2(a): Amends Employee Retirement Income Security
Act of 1974 (ERISA) to require group health plans offering
mental health and substance abuse coverage to apply the same
treatment limitations to mental health and substance benefits
as they do for medical and surgical benefits.
Section 2(a)(1) ``(3)(C)'': Categorizes the following items
and services subject to mental health and substance-related
treatment limit parity requirements (1) Inpatient, in-network;
(2) inpatient, out-of-network; (3) outpatient, in-network; (4)
outpatient, out-of-network. Section 2(a)(1) ``(3)(C)(v)'': Adds
emergency care to the list of categories of items and services
that are subject to the mental health and substance-related
treatment limit parity requirements.
Section 2(a)(1) ``(3)(D)'': Defines ``treatment limit''
under a health plan as limitation on the number of visits or
days of coverage, or other similar limit on the duration or
scope of treatment.
Section 2(a)(1) ``(4)(A)'': Requires group health plan
offering mental health benefits to apply the same financial
limitations to mental health benefits as they do to medical and
surgical benefits. This includes limits on deductibles, co-
payments, coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses, and annual and
lifetime limits. Plans are prohibited from establishing cost-
sharing requirements that are specific to mental health
benefits.
Section 2(a)(1) ``(4)(B)'': Requires group health plan
offering substance-related benefits, to apply the same
financial limitations to mental health benefits as they do to
medical and surgical benefits. This includes limits on
deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses,
and annual and lifetime limits. Plans are prohibited from
establishing cost-sharing requirements that are specific to
mental health benefits.
Section 2(a)(1) ``(4)(B)(iii)'': Clarifies that nothing in
this section prohibits a group health plan for waiving any
deductible for mental health benefits and/or substance-related
disorder benefits.
Section 2(b): Changes the term ``mental health benefits''
to ``mental health or substance abuse-related disorder
benefits.''
Section 2(c): Makes available to a plan administrator the
criteria for what is considered a medically necessary treatment
for a mental illness or substance abuse disorder.
Section 2(d): Provides a minimum mental health and
substance-related benefits package. If a group health plan
offers mental health or substance-related benefits then it must
cover the same range of mental illnesses and addiction
disorders covered by the Federal Employee Health Benefit
(FEHBP) plans with the highest average enrollment as of the
beginning of the most recent year beginning on or before the
beginning of the plan year involved.
Section 2(d) ``(6)'': With respect to out-of-network
coverage, requires group health plans offering mental health
and substance-related benefits, to apply the same coverage they
offer for medical and surgical services to mental health and
substance-related benefits
Section 2(e): Makes clear that group health plans may
utilize benefit management practices for medical, surgical,
mental health and substance related disorder benefits to the
extent that these methods are recognized both by the industry
and by providers and are not prohibited under applicable State
laws.
Section 2(f): Provides an exemption to group health plans
whose costs exceed 2% in the first plan year after initiation
or 1% in each subsequent year.
Section 2(g): Provides an exemption for small employers
with 50 or fewer employees, as well as employers who experience
an increase in claim costs of at least 2% in the first plan
year and 1% in subsequent years.
Section 2(i): Clarifies that nothing in this section
preempts any State law that provides consumer protections,
benefits, methods of access to benefits, rights, external
review programs, or remedies solely related to health insurance
issuers except to the extent that such provision prevents the
application of a requirement of this part.
Section 2(j): Conforms section 712 heading.
Section 2(k)(1): Makes the effective date of this section
on or after January 1, 2008.
Section 2(k)(2): Makes clear that collectively bargained
plans become subject to the act upon the expiration of the
collective bargaining agreement or by January 1, 2010.
2(l): Requires the Department of Labor to annually sample
and conduct random audits of group health plans to ensure
compliance with the Act.
Section 3 amendments to the Public Health Service Act
Section 3(a)(1): Amends the Public Health Service Act to
require group health plans offering mental health and substance
abuse benefits to apply the same treatment limitations on
mental health and substance abuse benefits as they do for
medical and surgical benefits.
Section 3(a)(1) ``(3)(C)'': Categorizes the following items
and services subject to mental health and substance-related
treatment limit parity requirements (1) Inpatient, in-network;
(2) inpatient, out-of-network; (3) outpatient, in-network; (4)
outpatient, out of network. Section 3(a)(1) ``(3)(D)'': Defines
``treatment limit'' under a health plan as limitation on the
number of visits or days of coverage, or other similar limit on
the duration or scope of treatment.
Section 3(a)(1) ``(4)(A)'': Requires group health plan
offering mental health to apply the same financial limitations
to mental health benefits as they do to medical and surgical
benefits. This includes limits on deductibles, co-payments,
coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses, and annual and lifetime
limits. Plans are prohibited from establishing cost-sharing
requirements that are specific to mental health benefits.
Section 3(a)(1) ``(4)(B)'': Requires group health plan
offering substance-related coverage, to apply the same
financial limitations to substance abuse benefits as they do to
medical and surgical benefits. This includes limits on
deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses,
and annual and lifetime limits. Plans are prohibited from
establishing cost-sharing requirements that are specific to
mental health benefits.
Section 3(b): Changes the term ``mental health benefits''
to ``mental health or substance abuse related disorder
benefits.''
Section 3(c): Makes available to a plan administrator the
criteria for what is considered a medically necessary treatment
for a mental illness or substance abuse disorder.
Section 3(d): Provides a minimum mental health and
substance-related benefits package. If a group health plan
offers mental health or substance-related benefits, then it
must cover the same range of mental illnesses and addiction
disorders covered by the Federal Employee Health Benefit
(FEHBP) plans.
Section 3(d) ``(6)(B)'': With respect to out-of-network
coverage, requires group health plans offering mental health
and substance-related benefits, to apply the same coverage they
offer for medical and surgical services to mental health and
substance-related benefits.
Section 3(e): Provides an exemption for employers who
experience an increase in claim costs of at least 2% in the
first plan year and 1% in subsequent years.
Section 3(f): Provides an exemption for small employers
with 50 or fewer employees.
Section 3(h): Clarifies that nothing in this section
preempts any State law that provides greater consumer
protections, benefits, methods of access to benefits, or rights
or remedies.
Section 3(i): Conforms section 712 heading.
Section 3(j): Makes the effective date of this section on
or after January 1, 2008.
Section 4 amendments to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986
Section 4(a): Amends the Internal Revenue Code to require
group health plans offering mental health and substance abuse
benefits to apply the same treatment limitations on mental
health and substance abuse benefits as they do for medical and
surgical benefits.
Section 4(a)(1) ``(3)(C)'': Categorizes the following items
and services subject to mental health and substance-related
treatment limit parity requirements (1) Inpatient, in-network;
(2) inpatient, out-of-network; (3) outpatient, in-network; (4)
outpatient, out of network.
Section 4(a)(1) ``(3)(D)'': Defines ``treatment limit''
under a health plan as limitation on the number of visits or
days of coverage, or other similar limit on the duration or
scope of treatment.
Section 4(a)(1) ``(4)(A)'': Requires group health plan
offering mental health to apply the same financial limitations
to mental health benefits as they do to medical and surgical
benefits. This includes limits on deductibles, co-payments,
coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses, and annual and lifetime
limits. Plans are prohibited from establishing cost-sharing
requirements that are specific to mental health benefits.
Section 4(a)(1) ``(4)(B)'': Requires group health plan
offering substance-related coverage, to apply the same
financial limitations to substance abuse benefits as they do to
medical and surgical benefits. This includes limits on
deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses,
and annual and lifetime limits. Plans are prohibited from
establishing cost-sharing requirements that are specific to
mental health benefits.
Section 4(b): Expands coverage of substance-related disorder benefits
under the Internal Revenue Code.
Section 4(c): Makes available to a plan administrator the
criteria for what is considered a medically necessary treatment
for a mental illness or substance abuse disorder.
Section 4(d) ``(6)(A)'': Provides a minimum mental health
and substance-related benefits package. If a group health plan
offers mental health or substance-related benefits, then it
must cover the same range of mental illnesses and addiction
disorders covered by the Federal Employee Health Benefit
(FEHBP) plans.
Section 4(d) ``(6)(B)'': Requires group health plans
offering mental health and substance-related benefits, to apply
the same out-of-network coverage they offer for medical and
surgical services to mental health and substance-related
benefits.
Section 4(e): Provides an exemption to employers who
experience an increase in claim costs of at least 2% in the
first plan year and 1% in subsequent years.
Section 4(f): Provides an exemption for small employers
with 50 or fewer employees.
Section 4(h): Conforms section 712 heading.
Section 4(i): Makes the effective date of this section on
or after January 1, 2008.
Section 5 Government Accountability Office studies and reports
Section 5(a): Requires the Comptroller General of the
United States to conduct a study that evaluates implementation
of the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act.
The study will analyze: (1) access to health insurance
coverage; (2) the quality of such coverage, Medicare, Medicaid,
and State and local mental health and substance abuse treatment
spending; (3) the number of individuals with private insurance
receiving publicly funded healthcare for mental health and
substance-related disorders; (4) spending on public services
such as the criminal justice system, special education, and
income assistance programs; (5) the use of medical management
of mental health and substance-related disorder benefits and
medical necessity determinations by group health plans; (6) and
any other matters the Comptroller General thinks appropriate.
The report must be submitted to Congress two years after the
enactment of H.R. 1424.
VI. Explanation of Amendments
The Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute is explained in
the body of this report. Representative Kline introduced an
amendment which would have substituted the Mental Health Parity
Act (S. 558) for the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act (H.R. 1424). The amendment was defeated 16-27.
VII. Application of Law to the Legislative Branch
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1, the Congressional
Accountability Act, requires a description of the application
of this bill to the legislative branch. The Committee has
determined that there is no legislative impact, since the
Federal Employee Health Benefits (FEHB) program already
provides parity for mental health care coverage pursuant to
administrative rule making.
VIII. Regulatory Impact Statement
The Committee has determined that H.R. 1424 will have
minimal impact on the regulatory burden.
IX. Unfunded Mandate Statement
Section 423 of the Congressional Budget and Impoundment
Control Act (as amended by Section 101(a)(2) of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act, P.L. 104-4) requires a statement of
whether the provisions of the reported bill include unfunded
mandates. This issue is addressed in the CBO cost estimate
letter.
X. Earmark Statement
H.R. 1424 does not contain any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9(d), 9(e) or 9(f) of rule XXI.
XI. Roll Call
XII. Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the
Committee
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
the Committee's oversight findings and recommendations are
reflected in the body of this report.
XIII. New Budget Authority and CBO Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the House of Representatives and section 308(a) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect to
requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the House of
Representatives and section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act
of 1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for
H.R. 1424 from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
U.S. Congress,
Congressional Budget Office,
Washington, DC, September 7, 2007.
Hon. George Miller,
Chairman, Committee on Education and Labor,
House of Representatives, Washington, DC.
Dear Mr. Chairman: The Congressional Budget Office has
prepared the enclosed cost estimate for H.R. 1424, the Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007.
If you wish further details on this estimate, we will be
pleased to provide them. The CBO staff contact is Shinobu
Suzuki.
Sincerely,
Peter R. Orszag,
Director.
Enclosure.
H.R. 1424--Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of
2007
Summary: H.R. 1424 would prohibit group health plans and
group health insurance issuers that provide both medical and
surgical benefits and mental health benefits from imposing
treatment limitations or financial requirements for coverage of
mental health benefits (including benefits for substance abuse
treatment) that are different from those used for medical and
surgical benefits.
Enacting the bill would affect both federal revenues and
direct spending for Medicaid, beginning in 2008. The bill would
result in higher premiums for employer-sponsored health
benefits. Higher premiums, in turn, would result in more of an
employee's compensation being received in the form of
nontaxable employer-paid premiums, and less in the form of
taxable wages. As a result of this shift, federal income and
payroll tax revenues would decline. The Congressional Budget
Office estimates that the proposal would reduce federal tax
revenues by $1.1 billion over the 2008-2012 period and by $3.1
billion over the 2008-2017 period. Social Security payroll
taxes, which are off-budget, would account for about 35 percent
of those totals.
The bill's requirements for issuers of group health
insurance would apply to managed care plans in the Medicaid
program. CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 1424 would increase
federal direct spending for Medicaid by $310 million over the
2008-2012 period and by $820 million over the 2008-2017 period.
In addition, assuming appropriation of the necessary amounts,
CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 1424 would have
discretionary costs of $20 million in 2008, $143 million over
the 2008-2012 period, and $322 million over the 2008-2017
period.
CBO has reviewed the non-tax provisions of the bill
(sections 2, 3, and 5) and has determined that sections 2 and 3
contain intergovernmental mandates as defined in the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act (UMRA). The bill would preempt state laws
governing mental health coverage that conflict with those in
this bill. However, because the preemption only would prohibit
the application of state regulatory law, CBO estimates that the
costs of the mandate to state, local, or tribal governments
would not exceed the threshold established by UMRA ($66 million
in 2007, adjusted annually for inflation).
As a result of this legislation, some state, local, and
tribal governments would pay higher health insurance premiums
for their employees. However, these costs would not result from
intergovernmental mandates, but would be costs passed on to
them by private insurers who would face a private-sector
mandate to comply with the requirements of the bill.
The bill would impose a private-sector mandate on group
health plans and group health insurance issuers by prohibiting
them from imposing treatment limitations or financial
requirements for mental health benefits that differ from those
placed on medical and surgical benefits. Under current law, the
Mental Health Parity Act of 1996 requires a more-limited form
of parity between mental health and medical and surgical
coverage. That mandate is set to expire at the end of 2007.
Thus, H.R. 1424 would both extend and expand the existing
mandate requiring mental health parity. CBO estimates that the
direct costs of the private-sector mandate in the bill would
total about $1.3 billion in 2008, and would grow in later
years. That amount would significantly exceed the annual
threshold established by UMRA ($131 million in 2007, adjusted
for inflation) in each of the years that the mandate would be
in effect.
Estimated cost to the Federal Government: The estimated
budgetary impact of H.R. 1424 is shown in the following table.
The costs of this legislation fall within budget function 550
(health).
ESTIMATED BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF H.R. 1424
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, in millions of -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
dollars-- 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2008-2012 2008-2017
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CHANGES IN REVENUES
Income and HI Payroll Taxes -20 -120 -170 -190 -210 -230 -250 -260 -280 -300 -710 -2,030
(on-budget)..................
Social Security Payroll Taxes -10 -70 -100 -100 -110 -120 -130 -140 -150 -160 -390 -1,090
(off-budget).................
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total Changes............. -30 -190 -270 -290 -320 -350 -380 -400 -430 -460 -1,100 -3,120
CHANGES IN DIRECT SPENDING
Medicaid:
Estimated Budget Authority 30 60 70 70 80 90 90 100 110 120 310 820
Estimated Outlays......... 30 60 70 70 80 90 90 100 110 120 310 820
CHANGES IN SPENDING SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATION
Implementation costs for DOL:
Estimated Authorization 25 30 30 30 35 35 35 35 35 40 150 330
Level....................
Estimated Outlays......... 20 29 30 30 34 35 35 35 35 39 143 322
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: HI=Hospital Insurance (Part A of Medicare); DOL=Department of Labor.
Basis of estimate: H.R. 1424 would prohibit group health
plans and group health insurance issuers who offer mental
health benefits (including benefits for substance abuse
treatment) from imposing treatment limitations or financial
requirements for those benefits that are different from those
used for medical and surgical benefits. For plans that offer
mental health benefits through a network of mental health
providers, the requirement for parity of benefits would be
established by comparing in-network medical and surgical
benefits with in-network mental health benefits, and comparing
out-of-network medical and surgical benefits with out-of-
network mental health benefits. The provision would apply to
benefits for any mental health condition that is covered under
the group health plan.
The bill would not require plans to offer mental health
benefits. It would, however, require that the mental health
benefits of plans that choose to offer such benefits be at
least as generous as the Federal Employees Health Benefits Plan
(FEHBP) with the highest average enrollment as of the beginning
of the most recent plan year involved. Existing laws in some
states, however, require that plans cover all types of mental
health services or ailments, which would reduce the potential
impact of this bill on health plan premiums.
Revenues
The provisions of the bill would apply to both self-insured
and fully insured group health plans. Small employers (those
employing fewer than 50 employees in a year) would be exempt
from the bill's requirements, as would individuals purchasing
insurance in the individual market. The bill also would exempt
group health plans for whom the cost of complying with the
requirements would increase total plan costs (for medical and
surgical benefits and mental health benefits) by more than 2
percent in the first plan year following enactment, and 1
percent in subsequent plan years. In general, H.R. 1424 would
not preempt state laws regarding parity of mental health
benefits except to the extent that state laws prohibit the
application of a requirement of the bill.
CBO's estimate of the cost of this bill is based in part on
published results of a model developed by the Hay Group. That
model relies on data from several sources, including the claims
experience of private health insurers and the Medical
Expenditure Panel Survey. CBO adjusted those results to account
for the current and future use of managed care arrangements for
providing mental health benefits and the increased use of
prescription drugs that mental health parity would be likely to
induce. Also, CBO took account of the effects of existing state
and federal rules that place requirements similar to those in
the bill on certain entities. (For example, the Office of
Personnel Management implemented mental health and substance
abuse parity in the FEHBP in January 2001.)
CBO estimates that H.R. 1424, if enacted, would increase
premiums for group health insurance by an average of about 0.4
percent, before accounting for the responses of health plans,
employers, and workers to the higher premiums that would likely
be charged under the bill. Those responses would include
reductions in the number of employers offering insurance to
their employees and in the number of employees enrolling in
employer-sponsored insurance, changes in the types of health
plans that are offered (including eliminating coverage for
mental health benefits and/or substance benefits), and
reductions in the scope or generosity of health insurance
benefits, such as increased deductibles or higher copayments.
CBO expects that those behavioral responses would offset 60
percent of the potential impact of the bill on total health
plan costs.
The remaining 40 percent of the potential increase in
costs--less than 0.2 percent of group health insurance
premiums--would occur in the form of higher spending for health
insurance. Those costs would be passed through to workers,
reducing both their taxable compensation and other fringe
benefits. For employees of private firms, CBO assumes that all
of that increase would ultimately be passed through to workers.
State, local, and tribal governments are assumed to absorb 75
percent of the increase and to reduce their workers' taxable
income and other fringe benefits to offset the remaining one-
quarter of the increase. CBO estimates that the resulting
reduction in taxable income would grow from $400 million in
2008 to $4.5 billion in 2017.
Those reductions in workers' taxable compensation would
lead to lower federal tax revenues. CBO estimates that federal
tax revenues would fall by $30 million in 2008 and by $3.1
billion over the 2008-2017 period if H.R. 1424 were enacted.
Social Security payroll taxes, which are off-budget, would
account for about 35 percent of those totals.
Direct spending
The bill's requirements for issuers of group health
insurance would apply to managed care plans in the Medicaid
program. CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 1424 would increase
Medicaid payments to managed care plans by about 0.2 percent.
That is less than the 0.4 percent increase in the estimated
increase in spending for employer-sponsored health insurance
because Medicaid programs offer broader coverage of mental
health benefits than the private sector. CHO estimates that
enacting H.R. 1424 would increase federal spending for Medicaid
by $310 million over the 2008-2012 period and $820 million over
the 2008-2017 period.
Spending subject to appropriation
H.R. 1424 would require the Secretary of Labor to provide
assistance to participants and beneficiaries of group health
plans and conduct random audits of plans to ensure that they
are in compliance with the requirements of the bill. The bill
also would require the Secretary to submit a biennial report on
obstacles that individuals face in obtaining care for mental
health and substance related disorders. Based on the costs of
implementing the Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act of 1996, and assuming appropriation of the
necessary amounts, CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 1424
would incur discretionary costs of $20 million in 2008 and $30
million to $40 million annually in subsequent years.
Estimated impact on state, local, and tribal governments:
H.R. 1424 would preempt state laws governing mental health
coverage that conflict with those in this bill. That preemption
would be an intergovernmental mandate as defined in UMRA.
However, because the preemption would simply prohibit the
application of state regulatory laws that conflict with the new
federal standards, CBO estimates that the mandate would impose
no significant costs on state, local, or tribal governments.
An existing provision in the Public Health Service Act
(PHSA) would allow state, local, and tribal governments, as
employers that provide health benefits to their employees, to
opt out of the requirements of this bill. Consequently, the
bill's requirements for mental health parity would not be
intergovernmental mandates as defined in UMRA, and the bill
would affect the budgets of those governments only if they
choose to comply with the requirements on group health plans.
Roughly two-thirds of employees in state, local, and tribal
governments are enrolled in self-insured plans.
The remaining governmental employees are enrolled in fully
insured plans. Governments purchase health insurance for those
employees through private insurers and would face increased
premiums as a result of higher costs passed on to them by those
insurers. The increased costs, however, would not result from
intergovernmental mandates. Rather, they would be part of the
mandate costs initially borne by the private sector and then
passed on to the governments as purchasers of insurance. CBO
estimates that state, local, and tribal governments would face
additional costs of about $10 million in 2008, increasing to
about $155 million in 2012. This estimate reflects the
assumption that governments would shift roughly 25 percent of
the additional costs to their employees.
Because the bill's requirements would apply to managed care
plans in the Medicaid program, CBO estimates that state
spending for Medicaid also would increase by about $235 million
over the 2008-2012 period.
Estimated impact on the private sector: The bill would
impose a private-sector mandate on group health plans and
issuers of group health insurance that provide medical and
surgical benefits as well as mental health benefits (including
benefits for substance abuse treatment). H.R. 1424 would
prohibit those entities from imposing treatment limitations or
financial requirements for mental health benefits that differ
from those placed on medical and surgical benefits. The
requirements would not apply to coverage purchased by employer
groups with fewer than 50 employees. For plans that offer
mental health benefits through a network of mental health
providers, the requirement for parity of benefits would be
established by comparing in-network medical and surgical
benefits with in-network mental health benefits, and comparing
out-of-network medical and surgical benefits with out-of-
network mental health benefits.
Under current law, the Mental Health Parity Act of 1996
prohibits group health plans and group health insurance issuers
from imposing annual and lifetime dollar limits on mental
health coverage that are more restrictive than limits imposed
on medical and surgical coverage. The current mandate is set to
expire at the end of calendar year 2007. Consequently, H.R.
1424 would both extend and expand the current mandate requiring
mental health parity.
CBO's estimate of the direct costs of the mandate assumes
that affected entities would comply with H.R. 1424 by further
increasing the generosity of their mental health benefits, Many
plans currently offer mental health benefits that are less
generous than their medical and surgical benefits. We estimate
that the direct costs of the additional services that would be
newly covered by insurance because of the mandate would equal
about 0.4 percent of employer-sponsored health insurance
premiums compared to having no mandate at all.
CBO estimates that the direct costs of the mandate in H.R.
1424 would be $1.3 billion in 2008, rising to $3.0 billion in
2012. Those costs would exceed the threshold specified in UMRA
($131 million in 2007, adjusted annually for inflation) in each
year the mandate would be in effect,
Previous CBO estimate: On March 20, 2007, CBO transmitted a
cost estimate for S. 558, the Mental Health Parity Act of 2007,
as ordered reported by the Senate Committee on Health,
Education, Labor, and Pensions on February 14, 2007. H.R. 1424
differs from S. 558 in several ways: (1) it would require
mental health benefits of plans that choose to offer such
benefits be at least as generous as FEHBP with the highest
average enrollment as of the beginning of the most recent plan
year involved; (2) it would exempt group health plans with
collective bargaining agreements from the requirements of the
bill until the later of the expiration of such agreements or
January 1, 2010; (3) it would make conforming modifications to
the Internal Revenue Code (IRC); and (4) the provisions of H.R.
1424 would apply to group health plans beginning January 1,
2008, while S. 558 specified that the policy would be effective
more than one year after the date of the enactment, affecting
plans beginning on or after January 1, 2009.
CBO estimates the minimum benefit requirement and exception
for the collective bargaining agreements would have no
significant budgetary effect, while the difference in the
effective dates would affect our estimate in 2008 and 2009. CBO
and the Joint Committee on Taxation estimate that conforming
modifications to the IRC would result in a negligible excise
tax revenue collected from employers who fail to comply with
the requirements of the bill.
Estimate prepared by: Federal Costs: Jeanne De Sa and
Shinobu Suzuki; Impact on State, Local, and Tribal Governments:
Lisa Ramirez-Branum; Impact on the Private Sector: Stuart
Hagen.
Estimate approved by: Peter H. Fontaine, Assistant Director
for Budget Analysis.
XIV. Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause 3(c) of House rule XIII, the goal
of H.R. 1424 is to increase access to mental health treatment
and to prevent health insurance providers and employers from
discriminating against individuals on the basis of mental
illness.
XV. Constitutional Authority Statement
Under clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House
of Representatives, the Committee must include a statement
citing the specific powers granted to Congress in the
Constitution to enact the law proposed by H.R. 1424. The
amendments made by this bill increase access to mental health
treatment by prohibiting group health plans (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with a group health
plan) from imposing financial requirements (including
deductibles, co-payments, coinsurance, out-of-pocket expenses,
and annual lifetime limits) or treatment limitations (including
limitations on the number of visits, days of coverage,
frequency of treatment, or other similar limits on the scope
and duration of treatment) on mental health benefits that are
more restrictive than those restrictions applied to medical and
surgical benefits. The Committee believes these amendments are
within Congress' authority under Article I, Section 8, Clauses
1 and 3 of the Constitution.
XVI. Committee Estimate
Clause 3(d)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires an estimate and a comparison of the
costs that would be incurred in carrying out H.R. 1424.
However, clause 3(d)(3)(B) of that rule provides that this
requirement does not apply when the Committee has included in
its report a timely submitted cost estimate of the bill
prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office
under section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act.
XVII. Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italic, existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT INCOME SECURITY ACT OF 1974
* * * * * * *
SHORT TITLE AND TABLE OF CONTENTS
Section 1. This Act may be cited as the ``Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974''.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sec. 1. Short title and table of contents.
* * * * * * *
Part 7--Group Health Plan Requirements
Subpart A--Requirements Relating to Portability, Access, and
Renewability
Sec. 701. Increased portability through limitation on
* * * * * * *
Subpart B--Other Requirements
Sec. 711. Standards relating to benefits for mothers and newborns.
[Sec. 712. Parity in the application of certain limits to mental health
benefits.]
Sec. 712. Equity in mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
* * * * * * *
Part 7--Group Health Plan Requirements
* * * * * * *
Subpart B--Other Requirements
* * * * * * *
[SEC. 712. PARITY IN THE APPLICATION OF CERTAIN LIMITS TO
MENTAL HEALTH BENEFITS.]
SEC. 712. EQUITY IN MENTAL HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE-RELATED DISORDER
BENEFITS.
(a) In General.--
(1) Aggregate lifetime limits.--In the case of a
group health plan (or health insurance coverage offered
in connection with such a plan) that provides both
medical and surgical benefits and [mental health
benefits] mental health or substance-related disorder
benefits--
(A) No lifetime limit.--If the plan or
coverage does not include an aggregate lifetime
limit on substantially all medical and surgical
benefits, the plan or coverage may not impose
any aggregate lifetime limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits.
(B) Lifetime limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes an aggregate lifetime limit on
substantially all medical and surgical benefits
(in this paragraph referred to as the
``applicable lifetime limit''), the plan or
coverage shall either--
(i) apply the applicable lifetime
limit both to the medical and surgical
benefits to which it otherwise would
apply and to [mental health benefits]
mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits and not distinguish
in the application of such limit
between such medical and surgical
benefits and [mental health benefits]
mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits; or
(ii) not include any aggregate
lifetime limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health or substance-
related disorder benefits that is less
than the applicable lifetime limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan or coverage that is not
described in subparagraph (A) or (B) and that
includes no or different aggregate lifetime
limits on different categories of medical and
surgical benefits, the Secretary shall
establish rules under which subparagraph (B) is
applied to such plan or coverage with respect
to [mental health benefits] mental health or
substance-related disorder benefits by
substituting for the applicable lifetime limit
an average aggregate lifetime limit that is
computed taking into account the weighted
average of the aggregate lifetime limits
applicable to such categories.
(2) Annual limits.--In the case of a group health
plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) that provides both medical
and surgical benefits and [mental health benefits]
mental health or substance-related disorder benefits--
(A) No annual limit.--If the plan or coverage
does not include an annual limit on
substantially all medical and surgical
benefits, the plan or coverage may not impose
any annual limit on [mental health benefits]
mental health or substance-related disorder
benefits.
(B) Annual limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes an annual limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits (in this
paragraph referred to as the ``applicable
annual limit''), the plan or coverage shall
either--
(i) apply the applicable annual limit
both to medical and surgical benefits
to which it otherwise would apply and
to [mental health benefits] mental
health or substance-related disorder
benefits and not distinguish in the
application of such limit between such
medical and surgical benefits and
[mental health benefits] mental health
or substance-related disorder benefits;
or
(ii) not include any annual limit on
[mental health benefits] mental health
or substance-related disorder benefits
that is less than the applicable annual
limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan or coverage that is not
described in subparagraph (A) or (B) and that
includes no or different annual limits on
different categories of medical and surgical
benefits, the Secretary shall establish rules
under which subparagraph (B) is applied to such
plan or coverage with respect to [mental health
benefits] mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits by substituting for the
applicable annual limit an average annual limit
that is computed taking into account the
weighted average of the annual limits
applicable to such categories.
(3) Treatment limits.--
(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan or
coverage does not include a treatment limit (as
defined in subparagraph (D)) on substantially
all medical and surgical benefits in any
category of items or services, the plan or
coverage may not impose any treatment limit on
mental health or substance-related disorder
benefits that are classified in the same
category of items or services.
(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes a treatment limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits in any category
of items or services, the plan or coverage may
not impose such a treatment limit on mental
health or substance-related disorder benefits
for items and services within such category
that is more restrictive than the predominant
treatment limit that is applicable to medical
and surgical benefits for items and services
within such category.
(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this
paragraph and paragraph (4), there shall be the
following five categories of items and services
for benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits, and all medical and surgical
benefits and all mental health and substance
related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services not described in clause (v)
furnished on an inpatient basis and
within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services not described in
clause (v) furnished on an inpatient
basis and outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage.
(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items
and services not described in clause
(v) furnished on an outpatient basis
and within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services not described in
clause (v) furnished on an outpatient
basis and outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage.
(v) Emergency care.--Items and
services, whether furnished on an
inpatient or outpatient basis or within
or outside any network of providers,
required for the treatment of an
emergency medical condition (including
an emergency condition relating to
mental health and substance-related
disorders).
(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of
this paragraph, the term ``treatment limit''
means, with respect to a plan or coverage,
limitation on the frequency of treatment,
number of visits or days of coverage, or other
similar limit on the duration or scope of
treatment under the plan or coverage.
(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this
subsection, a treatment limit or financial
requirement with respect to a category of items
and services is considered to be predominant if
it is the most common or frequent of such type
of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If
the plan or coverage does not include a
beneficiary financial requirement (as defined
in subparagraph (C)) on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits within a category
of items and services (specified under
paragraph (3)(C)), the plan or coverage may not
impose such a beneficiary financial requirement
on mental health or substance-related disorder
benefits for items and services within such
category.
(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-
pocket limits, and similar financial
requirements.--If the plan or coverage
includes a deductible, a limitation on
out-of-pocket expenses, or similar
beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual
items and services on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits within a
category of items and services (as
specified in paragraph (3)(C)), the
plan or coverage shall apply such
requirement (or, if there is more than
one such requirement for such category
of items and services, the predominant
requirement for such category) both to
medical and surgical benefits within
such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits
within such category and shall not
distinguish in the application of such
requirement between such medical and
surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(ii) Other financial requirements.--
If the plan or coverage includes a
beneficiary financial requirement not
described in clause (i) on
substantially all medical and surgical
benefits within a category of items and
services, the plan or coverage may not
impose such financial requirement on
mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits for items and
services within such category in a way
that results in greater out-of-pocket
expenses to the participant or
beneficiary than the predominant
beneficiary financial requirement
applicable to medical and surgical
benefits for items and services within
such category.
(iii) Construction.--Nothing in this
subparagraph shall be construed as
prohibiting the plan or coverage from
waiving the application of any
deductible for mental health benefits
or substance-related disorder benefits
or both.
(C) Beneficiary financial requirement
defined.--For purposes of this paragraph, the
term ``beneficiary financial requirement''
includes, with respect to a plan or coverage,
any deductible, coinsurance, co-payment, other
cost sharing, and limitation on the total
amount that may be paid by a participant or
beneficiary with respect to benefits under the
plan or coverage, but does not include the
application of any aggregate lifetime limit or
annual limit.
(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria
for medical necessity determinations made under the
plan with respect to mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits (or the health insurance
coverage offered in connection with the plan with
respect to such benefits) shall be made available in
accordance with regulations by the plan administrator
(or the health insurance issuer offering such coverage)
to any current or potential participant, beneficiary,
or contracting provider upon request. The reason for
any denial under the plan (or coverage) of
reimbursement or payment for services with respect to
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits
in the case of any participant or beneficiary shall,
upon request, be made available in accordance with
regulations by the plan administrator (or the health
insurance issuer offering such coverage) to the
participant or beneficiary.
(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-
network benefits.--
(A) Minimum scope of mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--In the
case of a group health plan (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with
such a plan) that provides any mental health or
substance-related disorder benefits, the plan
or coverage shall include benefits for any
mental health condition and substance-related
disorder for which benefits are provided under
the benefit plan option offered under chapter
89 of title 5, United States Code, with the
highest average enrollment as of the beginning
of the most recent year beginning on or before
the beginning of the plan year involved.
(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
(i) In general.--In the case of a
plan or coverage that provides both
medical and surgical benefits and
mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits, if medical and
surgical benefits are provided for
substantially all items and services in
a category specified in clause (ii)
furnished outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage, the mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits shall also be provided for
items and services in such category
furnished outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage in
accordance with the requirements of
this section.
(ii) Categories of items and
services.--For purposes of clause (i),
there shall be the following three
categories of items and services for
benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits,
and all medical and surgical benefits
and all mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits shall be
classified into one of the following
categories:
(I) Emergency.--Items and
services, whether furnished on
an inpatient or outpatient
basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency
medical condition (including an
emergency condition relating to
mental health or substance-
related disorders).
(II) Inpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
inpatient basis.
(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
outpatient basis.
(7) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to limit a group health plan (or health
insurance offered in connection with such a plan) from
managing the provision of medical, surgical, mental
health or substance-related disorder benefits through
any of the following methods:
(A) the application of utilization review;
(B) the application of authorization or
management practices;
(C) the application of medical necessity and
appropriateness criteria; or
(D) other processes intended to ensure that
beneficiaries receive appropriate care and
medically necessary services for covered
benefits;
to the extent such methods are recognized both by
industry and by providers and are not prohibited under
applicable State laws.
(b) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
[construed--
[(1) as requiring] construed as requiring a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) to provide any [mental
health benefits; or] mental health or substance-related
disorder benefits.
[(2) in the case of a group health plan (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with such a
plan) that provides mental health benefits, as
affecting the terms and conditions (including cost
sharing, limits on numbers of visits or days of
coverage, and requirements relating to medical
necessity) relating to the amount, duration, or scope
of mental health benefits under the plan or coverage,
except as specifically provided in subsection (a) (in
regard to parity in the imposition of aggregate
lifetime limits and annual limits for mental health
benefits).]
(c) Exemptions.--
(1) Small employer exemption.--
(A) * * *
(B) Small employer.--For purposes of
subparagraph (A), the term ``small employer''
means, in connection with a group health plan
with respect to a calendar year and a plan
year, an employer who employed an average of at
least 2 (or 1 in the case of an employer
residing in a State that permits small groups
to include a single individual) but not more
than 50 employees on business days during the
preceding calendar year [and who employs at
least 2 employees on the first day of the plan
year].
* * * * * * *
[(2) Increased cost exemption.--This section shall
not apply with respect to a group health plan (or
health insurance coverage offered in connection with a
group health plan) if the application of this section
to such plan (or to such coverage) results in an
increase in the cost under the plan (or for such
coverage) of at least 1 percent.]
(2) Increased cost exemption.--
(A) In general.--With respect to a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage
offered in connection with such a plan), if the
application of this section to such plan (or
coverage) results in an increase for the plan
year involved of the actual total costs of
coverage with respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits under the plan (as
determined and certified under subparagraph
(C)) by an amount that exceeds the applicable
percentage described in subparagraph (B) of the
actual total plan costs, the provisions of this
section shall not apply to such plan (or
coverage) during the following plan year, and
such exemption shall apply to the plan (or
coverage) for 1 plan year.
(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a
plan (or coverage), the applicable percentage
described in this paragraph shall be--
(i) 2 percent in the case of the
first plan year which begins after the
effective date of the amendments made
by section 101 of the Paul Wellstone
Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act
of 2007; and
(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
(C) Determinations by actuaries.--
Determinations as to increases in actual costs
under a plan (or coverage) for purposes of this
subsection shall be made and certified by a
qualified and licensed actuary who is a member
in good standing of the American Academy of
Actuaries.
(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group
health plan (or a health insurance issuer
offering coverage in connection with such a
plan) seeks an exemption under this paragraph,
determinations under subparagraph (A) shall be
made after such plan (or coverage) has complied
with this section for the first 6 months of the
plan year involved.
(E) Notification.--An election to modify
coverage of mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits as permitted under this
paragraph shall be treated as a material
modification in the terms of the plan as
described in section 102(a) and notice of which
shall be provided a reasonable period in
advance of the change.
(F) Notification of appropriate agency.--
(i) In general.--A group health plan
that, based on upon a certification
described under subparagraph (C),
qualifies for an exemption under this
paragraph, and elects to implement the
exemption, shall notify the Department
of Labor of such election.
(ii) Requirement.--A notification
under clause (i) shall include--
(I) a description of the
number of covered lives under
the plan (or coverage) involved
at the time of the
notification, and as
applicable, at the time of any
prior election of the cost-
exemption under this paragraph
by such plan (or coverage);
(II) for both the plan year
upon which a cost exemption is
sought and the year prior, a
description of the actual total
costs of coverage with respect
to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and
substance-related disorder
benefits under the plan; and
(III) for both the plan year
upon which a cost exemption is
sought and the year prior, the
actual total costs of coverage
with respect to mental health
and substance-related disorder
benefits under the plan.
(iii) Confidentiality.--A
notification under clause (i) shall be
confidential. The Department of Labor
shall make available, upon request to
the appropriate committees of Congress
and on not more than an annual basis,
an anonymous itemization of such
notifications, that includes--
(I) a breakdown of States by
the size and any type of
employers submitting such
notification; and
(II) a summary of the data
received under clause (ii).
(G) No impact on application of state law.--
The fact that a plan or coverage is exempt from
the provisions of this section under
subparagraph (A) shall not affect the
application of State law to such plan or
coverage.
* * * * * * *
(e) Definitions.--For purposes of this section--
(1) * * *
* * * * * * *
(3) Medical or surgical benefits.--The term ``medical
or surgical benefits'' means benefits with respect to
medical or surgical services, as defined under the
terms of the plan or coverage (as the case may be), but
does not include [mental health benefits] mental health
or substance-related disorder benefits.
(4) [Mental health benefits] Mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--The term
``[mental health benefits] mental health or substance-
related disorder benefits'' means [benefits with
respect to mental health services] benefits with
respect to services for mental health conditions or
substance-related disorders, as defined under the terms
of the plan or coverage (as the case may be)[, but does
not include benefits with respect to treatment of
substance abuse or chemical dependency].
[(f) Sunset.--This section shall not apply to benefits for
services furnished after December 31, 2007.]
(f) Preemption, Relation to State Laws.--
(1) In general.--This part shall not be construed to
supersede any provision of State law which establishes,
implements, or continues in effect any consumer
protections, benefits, methods of access to benefits,
rights, external review programs, or remedies solely
relating to health insurance issuers in connection with
group health insurance coverage (including benefit
mandates or regulation of group health plans of 50 or
fewer employees) except to the extent that such
provision prevents the application of a requirement of
this part.
(2) Continued preemption with respect to group health
plans.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to
affect or modify the provisions of section 514 with
respect to group health plans.
(3) Other state laws.--Nothing in this section shall
be construed to exempt or relieve any person from any
laws of any State not solely related to health
insurance issuers in connection with group health
coverage insofar as they may now or hereafter relate to
insurance, health plans, or health coverage.
* * * * * * *
----------
SECTION 2705 OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE ACT
[SEC. 2705. PARITY IN THE APPLICATION OF CERTAIN LIMITS TO MENTAL
HEALTH BENEFITS.]
SEC. 2705.
(a) In General.--
(1) Aggregate lifetime limits.--In the case of a
group health plan (or health insurance coverage offered
in connection with such a plan) that provides both
medical and surgical benefits and [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits--
(A) No lifetime limit.--If the plan or
coverage does not include an aggregate lifetime
limit on substantially all medical and surgical
benefits, the plan or coverage may not impose
any aggregate lifetime limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits.
(B) Lifetime limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes an aggregate lifetime limit on
substantially all medical and surgical benefits
(in this paragraph referred to as the
``applicable lifetime limit''), the plan or
coverage shall either--
(i) apply the applicable lifetime
limit both to the medical and surgical
benefits to which it otherwise would
apply and to [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits and not distinguish
in the application of such limit
between such medical and surgical
benefits and [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits; or
(ii) not include any aggregate
lifetime limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits that is less
than the applicable lifetime limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan or coverage that is not
described in subparagraph (A) or (B) and that
includes no or different aggregate lifetime
limits on different categories of medical and
surgical benefits, the Secretary shall
establish rules under which subparagraph (B) is
applied to such plan or coverage with respect
to [mental health benefits] mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits by
substituting for the applicable lifetime limit
an average aggregate lifetime
limit that is computed taking into account the
weighted average of the aggregate lifetime
limits applicable to such categories.
(2) Annual limits.--In the case of a group health
plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) that provides both medical
and surgical benefits and [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits--
(A) No annual limit.--If the plan or coverage
does not include an annual limit on
substantially all medical and surgical
benefits, the plan or coverage may not impose
any annual limit on [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(B) Annual limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes an annual limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits (in this
paragraph referred to as the ``applicable
annual limit''), the plan or coverage shall
either--
(i) apply the applicable annual limit
both to medical and surgical benefits
to which it otherwise would apply and
to [mental health benefits] mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits and not distinguish in the
application of such limit between such
medical and surgical benefits and
[mental health benefits] mental health
and substance-related disorder
benefits; or
(ii) not include any annual limit on
[mental health benefits] mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits
that is less than the applicable annual
limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan or coverage that is not
described in subparagraph (A) or (B) and that
includes no or different annual limits on
different categories of medical and surgical
benefits, the Secretary shall establish rules
under which subparagraph (B) is applied to such
plan or coverage with respect to [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits by substituting for the
applicable annual limit an average annual limit
that is computed taking into account the
weighted average of the annual limits
applicable to such categories.
(3) Treatment limits.--
(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan or
coverage does not include a treatment limit (as
defined in subparagraph (D)) on substantially
all medical and surgical benefits in any
category of items or services (specified in
subparagraph (C)), the plan or coverage may not
impose any treatment limit on mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits that are
classified in the same category of items or
services.
(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan or coverage
includes a treatment limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits in any category
of items or services, the plan or coverage may
not impose such a treatment limit on mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
for items and services within such category
that are more restrictive than the predominant
treatment limit that is applicable to medical
and surgical benefits for items and services
within such category.
(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this
paragraph and paragraph (4), there shall be the
following four categories of items and services
for benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits, and all medical and surgical
benefits and all mental health and substance
related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient
basis and within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services furnished on an
inpatient basis and outside any network
of providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage.
(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items
and services furnished on an outpatient
basis and within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services furnished on an
outpatient basis and outside any
network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of
this paragraph, the term ``treatment limit''
means, with respect to a plan or coverage,
limitation on the frequency of treatment,
number of visits or days of coverage, or other
similar limit on the duration or scope of
treatment under the plan or coverage.
(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this
subsection, a treatment limit or financial
requirement with respect to a category of items
and services is considered to be predominant if
it is the most common or frequent of such type
of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If
the plan or coverage does not include a
beneficiary financial requirement (as defined
in subparagraph (C)) on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits within a category
of items and services (specified in paragraph
(3)(C)), the plan or coverage may not impose
such a beneficiary financial requirement on
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits for items and services within such
category.
(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-
pocket limits, and similar financial
requirements.--If the plan or coverage
includes a deductible, a limitation on
out-of-pocket expenses, or similar
beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual
items and services on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits within a
category of items and services, the
plan or coverage shall apply such
requirement (or, if there is more than
one such requirement for such category
of items and services, the predominant
requirement for such category) both to
medical and surgical benefits within
such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits
within such category and shall not
distinguish in the application of such
requirement between such medical and
surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(ii) Other financial requirements.--
If the plan or coverage includes a
beneficiary financial requirement not
described in clause (i) on
substantially all medical and surgical
benefits within a category of items and
services, the plan or coverage may not
impose such financial requirement on
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits for items and
services within such category in a way
that is more costly to the participant
or beneficiary than the predominant
beneficiary financial requirement
applicable to medical and surgical
benefits for items and services within
such category.
(C) Beneficiary financial requirement
defined.--For purposes of this paragraph, the
term ``beneficiary financial requirement''
includes, with respect to a plan or coverage,
any deductible, coinsurance, co-payment, other
cost sharing, and limitation on the total
amount that may be paid by a participant or
beneficiary with respect to benefits under the
plan or coverage, but does not include the
application of any aggregate lifetime limit or
annual limit.
(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria
for medical necessity determinations made under the
plan with respect to mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits (or the health insurance
coverage offered in connection with the plan with
respect to such benefits) shall be made available by
the plan administrator (or the health insurance issuer
offering such coverage) to any current or potential
participant, beneficiary, or contracting provider upon
request. The reason for any denial under the plan (or
coverage) of reimbursement or payment for services with
respect to mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits in the case of any participant or beneficiary
shall, upon request, be made available by the plan
administrator (or the health insurance issuer offering
such coverage) to the participant or beneficiary.
(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-
network benefits.--
(A) Minimum scope of mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--In the
case of a group health plan (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with
such a plan) that provides any mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits, the
plan or coverage shall include benefits for any
mental health condition or substance-related
disorder for which benefits are provided under
the benefit plan option offered under chapter
89 of title 5, United States Code, with the
highest average enrollment as of the beginning
of the most recent year beginning on or before
the beginning of the plan year involved.
(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
(i) In general.--In the case of a
plan or coverage that provides both
medical and surgical benefits and
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits, if medical and
surgical benefits are provided for
substantially all items and services in
a category specified in clause (ii)
furnished outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage, the mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits shall also be provided for
items and services in such category
furnished outside any network of
providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage in
accordance with the requirements of
this section.
(ii) Categories of items and
services.--For purposes of clause (i),
there shall be the following three
categories of items and services for
benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits,
and all medical and surgical benefits
and all mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits shall be
classified into one of the following
categories:
(I) Emergency.--Items and
services, whether furnished on
an inpatient or outpatient
basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency
medical condition (including an
emergency condition relating to
mental health and substance-
related disorders).
(II) Inpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
inpatient basis.
(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
outpatient basis.
(b) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
[construed--
[(1) as requiring] construed as requiring a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage offered in
connection with such a plan) to provide any [mental
health benefits; or] mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits.
[(2) in the case of a group health plan (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with such a
plan) that provides mental health benefits, as
affecting the terms and conditions (including cost
sharing, limits on numbers of visits or days of
coverage, and requirements relating to medical
necessity) relating to the amount, duration, or scope
of mental health benefits under the plan or coverage,
except as specifically provided in subsection (a) (in
regard to parity in the imposition of aggregate
lifetime limits and annual limits for mental health
benefits).]
(c) Exemptions.--
(1) Small employer exemption.--This section shall not
apply to any group health plan (and group health
insurance coverage offered in connection with a group
health plan) for any plan year of a small employer.
[(2) Increased cost exemption.--This section shall
not apply with respect to a group health plan (or
health insurance coverage offered in connection with a
group health plan) if the application of this section
to such plan (or to such coverage) results in an
increase in the cost under the plan (or for such
coverage) of at least 1 percent.]
(2) Increased cost exemption.--
(A) In general.--With respect to a group
health plan (or health insurance coverage
offered in connection with such a plan), if the
application of this section to such plan (or
coverage) results in an increase for the plan
year involved of the actual total costs of
coverage with respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits under the plan (as
determined and certified under subparagraph
(C)) by an amount that exceeds the applicable
percentage described in subparagraph (B) of the
actual total plan costs, the provisions of this
section shall not apply to such plan (or
coverage) during the following plan year, and
such exemption shall apply to the plan (or
coverage) for 1 plan year.
(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a
plan (or coverage), the applicable percentage
described in this paragraph shall be--
(i) 2 percent in the case of the
first plan year which begins after the
date of the enactment of the Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act of 2007; and
(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
(C) Determinations by actuaries.--
Determinations as to increases in actual costs
under a plan (or coverage) for purposes of this
subsection shall be made by a qualified actuary
who is a member in good standing of the
American Academy of Actuaries. Such
determinations shall be certified by the
actuary and be made available to the general
public.
(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group
health plan (or a health insurance issuer
offering coverage in connection with such a
plan) seeks an exemption under this paragraph,
determinations under subparagraph (A) shall be
made after such plan (or coverage) has complied
with this section for the first 6 months of the
plan year involved.
(E) Notification.--A group health plan under
this part shall comply with the notice
requirement under section 712(c)(2)(E) of the
Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974
with respect to the a modification of mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
as permitted under this paragraph as if such
section applied to such plan.
* * * * * * *
(e) Definitions.--For purposes of this section--
(1) * * *
* * * * * * *
(3) Medical or surgical benefits.--The term ``medical
or surgical benefits'' means benefits with respect to
medical or surgical services, as defined under the
terms of the plan or coverage (as the case may be), but
does not include [mental health benefits] mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits.
(4) [Mental health benefits] Mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--The term
``[mental health benefits] mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits'' means [benefits with
respect to mental health services] benefits with
respect to services for mental health conditions or
substance-related disorders, as defined under the terms
of the plan or coverage (as the case may be), but does
not include benefits with respect to treatment of
substance abuse or chemical dependency.
[(f) Sunset.--This section shall not apply to benefits for
services furnished after December 31, 2007.]
(f) Preemption, Relation to State Laws.--
(1) In general.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to preempt any State law that provides
greater consumer protections, benefits, methods of
access to benefits, rights or remedies that are greater
than the protections, benefits, methods of access to
benefits, rights or remedies provided under this
section.
(2) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
construed to affect or modify the provisions of section
2723 with respect to group health plans.
----------
INTERNAL REVENUE CODE OF 1986
* * * * * * *
Subtitle K--Group Health Plan Requirements
* * * * * * *
CHAPTER 100--GROUP HEALTH PLAN REQUIREMENTS
* * * * * * *
Subchapter B--Other Requirements
* * * * * * *
[Sec. 9812. Parity in the application of certain limits to mental health
benefits.]
Sec. 9812. Equity in mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
* * * * * * *
[SEC. 9812. PARITY IN THE APPLICATION OF CERTAIN LIMITS TO MENTAL
HEALTH BENEFITS.]
SEC. 9812. EQUITY IN MENTAL HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE-RELATED DISORDER
BENEFITS.
(a) In General.--
(1) Aggregate lifetime limits.--In the case of a
group health plan that provides both medical and
surgical benefits and [mental health benefits] mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits--
(A) No lifetime limit.--If the plan does not
include an aggregate lifetime limit on
substantially all medical and surgical
benefits, the plan may not impose any aggregate
lifetime limit on [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(B) Lifetime limit.--If the plan includes an
aggregate lifetime limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits (in this
paragraph referred to as the ``applicable
lifetime limit''), the plan shall either--
(i) apply the applicable lifetime
limit both to the medical and surgical
benefits to which it otherwise would
apply and to [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits and not distinguish
in the application of such limit
between such medical and surgical
benefits and [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits; or
(ii) not include any aggregate
lifetime limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits that is less
than the applicable lifetime limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan that is not described in
subparagraph (A) or (B) and that includes no or
different aggregate lifetime limits on
different categories of medical and surgical
benefits, the Secretary shall establish rules
under which subparagraph (B) is applied to such
plan with respect to [mental health benefits]
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits by substituting for the applicable
lifetime limit an average aggregate lifetime
limit that is computed taking into account the
weighted average of the aggregate lifetime
limits applicable to such categories.
(2) Annual limits.--In the case of a group health
plan that provides both medical and surgical benefits
and [mental health benefits] mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits--
(A) No annual limit.--If the plan does not
include an annual limit on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits, the plan may not
impose any annual limit on [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits.
(B) Annual limit.--If the plan includes an
annual limit on substantially all medical and
surgical benefits (in this paragraph referred
to as the ``applicable annual limit''), the
plan shall either--
(i) apply the applicable annual limit
both to medical and surgical benefits
to which it otherwise would apply and
to [mental health benefits] mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits and not distinguish in the
application of such limit between such
medical and surgical benefits and
[mental health benefits] mental health
and substance-related disorder
benefits; or
(ii) not include any annual limit on
[mental health benefits] mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits
that is less than the applicable annual
limit.
(C) Rule in case of different limits.--In the
case of a plan that is not described in
subparagraph (A) or (B) and that includes no or
different annual limits on different categories
of medical and surgical benefits, the Secretary
shall establish rules under which subparagraph
(B) is applied to such plan with respect to
[mental health benefits] mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits by
substituting for the applicable annual limit an
average annual limit that is computed taking
into account the weighted average of the annual
limits applicable to such categories.
(3) Treatment limits.--
(A) No treatment limit.--If the plan does not
include a treatment limit (as defined in
subparagraph (D)) on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits in any category of items
or services (specified in subparagraph (C)),
the plan may not impose any treatment limit on
mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits that are classified in the same
category of items or services.
(B) Treatment limit.--If the plan includes a
treatment limit on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits in any category of items
or services, the plan may not impose such a
treatment limit on mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits for items and
services within such category that are more
restrictive than the predominant treatment
limit that is applicable to medical and
surgical benefits for items and services within
such category.
(C) Categories of items and services for
application of treatment limits and beneficiary
financial requirements.--For purposes of this
paragraph and paragraph (4), there shall be the
following four categories of items and services
for benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits, and all medical and surgical
benefits and all mental health and substance
related benefits shall be classified into one
of the following categories:
(i) Inpatient, in-network.--Items and
services furnished on an inpatient
basis and within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(ii) Inpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services furnished on an
inpatient basis and outside any network
of providers established or recognized
under such plan or coverage.
(iii) Outpatient, in-network.--Items
and services furnished on an outpatient
basis and within a network of providers
established or recognized under such
plan or coverage.
(iv) Outpatient, out-of-network.--
Items and services furnished on an
outpatient basis and outside any
network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage.
(D) Treatment limit defined.--For purposes of
this paragraph, the term ``treatment limit''
means, with respect to a plan, limitation on
the frequency of treatment, number of visits or
days of coverage, or other similar limit on the
duration or scope of treatment under the plan.
(E) Predominance.--For purposes of this
subsection, a treatment limit or financial
requirement with respect to a category of items
and services is considered to be predominant if
it is the most common or frequent of such type
of limit or requirement with respect to such
category of items and services.
(4) Beneficiary financial requirements.--
(A) No beneficiary financial requirement.--If
the plan does not include a beneficiary
financial requirement (as defined in
subparagraph (C)) on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits within a category of
items and services (specified in paragraph
(3)(C)), the plan may not impose such a
beneficiary financial requirement on mental
health and substance-related disorder benefits
for items and services within such category.
(B) Beneficiary financial requirement.--
(i) Treatment of deductibles, out-of-
pocket limits, and similar financial
requirements.--If the plan or coverage
includes a deductible, a limitation on
out-of-pocket expenses, or similar
beneficiary financial requirement that
does not apply separately to individual
items and services on substantially all
medical and surgical benefits within a
category of items and services, the
plan or coverage shall apply such
requirement (or, if there is more than
one such requirement for such category
of items and services, the predominant
requirement for such category) both to
medical and surgical benefits within
such category and to mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits
within such category and shall not
distinguish in the application of such
requirement between such medical and
surgical benefits and such mental
health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(ii) Other financial requirements.--
If the plan includes a beneficiary
financial requirement not described in
clause (i) on substantially all medical
and surgical benefits within a category
of items and services, the plan may not
impose such financial requirement on
mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits for items and
services within such category in a way
that is more costly to the participant
or beneficiary than the predominant
beneficiary financial requirement
applicable to medical and surgical
benefits for items and services within
such category.
(C) Beneficiary financial requirement
defined.--For purposes of this paragraph, the
term ``beneficiary financial requirement''
includes, with respect to a plan, any
deductible, coinsurance, co-payment, other cost
sharing, and limitation on the total amount
that may be paid by a participant or
beneficiary with respect to benefits under the
plan, but does not include the application of
any aggregate lifetime limit or annual limit.
(5) Availability of plan information.--The criteria
for medical necessity determinations made under the
plan with respect to mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits shall be made available by
the plan administrator to any current or potential
participant, beneficiary, or contracting provider upon
request. The reason for any denial under the plan of
reimbursement or payment for services with respect to
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits
in the case of any participant or beneficiary shall,
upon request, be made available by the plan
administrator to the participant or beneficiary.
(6) Minimum scope of coverage and equity in out-of-
network benefits.--
(A) Minimum scope of mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--In the
case of a group health plan (or health
insurance coverage offered in connection with
such a plan) that provides any mental health
and substance-related disorder benefits, the
plan or coverage shall include benefits for any
mental health condition or substance-related
disorder for which benefits are provided under
the benefit plan option offered under chapter
89 of title 5, United States Code, with the
highest average enrollment as of the beginning
of the most recent year beginning on or before
the beginning of the plan year involved.
(B) Equity in coverage of out-of-network
benefits.--
(i) In general.--In the case of a
plan that provides both medical and
surgical benefits and mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits, if
medical and surgical benefits are
provided for substantially all items
and services in a category specified in
clause (ii) furnished outside any
network of providers established or
recognized under such plan or coverage,
the mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits shall also be
provided for items and services in such
category furnished outside any network
of providers established or recognized
under such plan in accordance with the
requirements of this section.
(ii) Categories of items and
services.--For purposes of clause (i),
there shall be the following three
categories of items and services for
benefits, whether medical and surgical
benefits or mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits,
and all medical and surgical benefits
and all mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits shall be
classified into one of the following
categories:
(I) Emergency.--Items and
services, whether furnished on
an inpatient or outpatient
basis, required for the
treatment of an emergency
medical condition (including an
emergency condition relating to
mental health and substance-
related disorders).
(II) Inpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
inpatient basis.
(III) Outpatient.--Items and
services not described in
subclause (I) furnished on an
outpatient basis.
(b) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be
[construed--
[(1) as requiring] construed as requiring a group
health plan to provide any [mental health benefits; or]
mental health and substance-related disorder benefits.
[(2) in the case of a group health plan that provides
mental health benefits, as affecting the terms and
conditions (including cost sharing, limits on numbers
of visits or days of coverage, and requirements
relating to medical necessity) relating to the amount,
duration, or scope of mental health benefits under the
plan, except as specifically provided in subsection (a)
(in regard to parity in the imposition of aggregate
lifetime limits and annual limits for mental health
benefits).]
(c) Exemptions.--
[(1) Small employer exemption.--This section shall
not apply to any group health plan for any plan year of
a small employer (as defined in section 4980D(d)(2)).
[(2) Increased cost exemption.--This section shall
not apply with respect to a group health plan if the
application of this section to such plan results in an
increase in the cost under the plan of at least 1
percent.]
(1) Small employer exemption.--
(A) In general.--This section shall not apply
to any group health plan for any plan year of a
small employer.
(B) Small employer.--For purposes of
subparagraph (A), the term ``small employer''
means, with respect to a calendar year and a
plan year, an employer who employed an average
of at least 2 (or 1 in the case of an employer
residing in a State that permits small groups
to include a single individual) but not more
than 50 employees on business days during the
preceding calendar year. For purposes of the
preceding sentence, all persons treated as a
single employer under subsection (b), (c), (m),
or (o) of section 414 shall be treated as 1
employer and rules similar to rules of
subparagraphs (B) and (C) of section
4980D(d)(2) shall apply.
(2) Increased cost exemption.--
(A) In general.--With respect to a group
health plan, if the application of this section
to such plan results in an increase for the
plan year involved of the actual total costs of
coverage with respect to medical and surgical
benefits and mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits under the plan (as
determined and certified under subparagraph
(C)) by an amount that exceeds the applicable
percentage described in subparagraph (B) of the
actual total plan costs, the provisions of this
section shall not apply to such plan during the
following plan year, and such exemption shall
apply to the plan for 1 plan year.
(B) Applicable percentage.--With respect to a
plan, the applicable percentage described in
this paragraph shall be--
(i) 2 percent in the case of the
first plan year which begins after the
date of the enactment of the Paul
Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction
Equity Act of 2007; and
(ii) 1 percent in the case of each
subsequent plan year.
(C) Determinations by actuaries.--
Determinations as to increases in actual costs
under a plan for purposes of this subsection
shall be made by a qualified actuary who is a
member in good standing of the American Academy
of Actuaries. Such determinations shall be
certified by the actuary and be made available
to the general public.
(D) 6-month determinations.--If a group
health plan seeks an exemption under this
paragraph, determinations under subparagraph
(A) shall be made after such plan has complied
with this section for the first 6 months of the
plan year involved.
* * * * * * *
(e) Definitions.--For purposes of this section:
(1) * * *
* * * * * * *
(3) Medical or surgical benefits.--The term ``medical
or surgical benefits'' means benefits with respect to
medical or surgical services, as defined under the
terms of the plan, but does not include [mental health
benefits] mental health and substance-related disorder
benefits.
(4) [Mental health benefits] Mental health and
substance-related disorder benefits.--The term
``[mental health benefits] mental health and substance-
related disorder benefits'' means [benefits with
respect to mental health services] benefits with
respect to services for mental health conditions or
substance-related disorders, as defined under the terms
of the plan, but does not include benefits with respect
to treatment of substance abuse or chemical dependency.
[(f) Application of section.--This section shall not apply to
benefits for services furnished--
[(1) on or after September 30, 2001, and before
January 10, 2002,
[(2) on or after January 1, 2004, and before the date
of the enactment of the Working Families Tax Relief Act
of 2004, and
[(3) after December 31, 2007.]
* * * * * * *
XIII. Committee Correspondence
None.
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
The goal of providing parity between mental health benefits
and other medical benefits provided under employer-sponsored
health coverage is something that all Members of the Committee
and, we believe, most Members of Congress, would endorse. In
the 110th Congress, competing legislative proposals in the
House and Senate offer substantially different approaches in
addressing this issue. It is our belief that the proposal
advancing in the Senate is a far superior one to that of the
House. Accordingly, we set forth these views to express our
concerns with the House bill, and urge that as the legislative
process moves forward, the House brings its efforts in line
with that of the other body.
As a principal committee of jurisdiction, the Committee on
Education and Labor has long been involved in the mental health
parity debate. Full mental health parity bills have been
introduced in prior Congresses but have not been enacted into
law, largely because of the serious concerns associated with
these proposals and the opposition to imposition of additional
federal coverage mandates on employers, who continue to
struggle to provide affordable, high-quality coverage to their
employees. In the 110th Congress, mental health parity
legislation is moving closer toward passage.
The current parity bills, H.R. 1424 in the House and S. 558
in the Senate, represent two significantly different approaches
to the issue of achieving mental health parity in employer-
sponsored coverage. H.R. 1424, as reported by the Committee,
more closely reflects prior failed efforts--it involved
virtually no input from those parties responsible for complying
with the mandates (employers, insurers, e.g.), and is, not
surprisingly, strongly opposed by those parties. In stark
contrast, the Senate bill, S. 558, reflects a carefully
negotiated consensus of all major stakeholders on all sides of
the mental health parity debate.
Members on both sides of the aisle can in good conscience
and good faith disagree on the merits of both pending bills.
However, there can be little legitimate debate that the Senate
bill, offered as the Republican Substitute at full Committee
markup on July 18, 2007 by Representative John Kline, is the
only proposal that achieves exactly what all parties
purportedly intend: full parity between mental health and other
medical benefits. H.R. 1424, in contrast, grants preferential
treatment for mental health benefits and as such, constitutes
bad policy. Accordingly, and for the reasons set forth below,
we oppose its passage.
FEDERAL LAW ON THE PROVISION OF MENTAL HEALTH BENEFITS
The provision of health benefits by employers to their
employees is generally governed by the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act (``ERISA''). In 1996, Congress enacted the
Mental Health Parity Act (``MHPA''), which amended ERISA and
established new federal standards for mental health coverage
offered by group health plans.\1\ The MHPA added section 712 of
ERISA to create certain requirements for mental health
coverage, if this coverage was offered by a health plan. Under
the MHPA, health plans are not required to offer mental health
benefits. However, plans that do choose to provide mental
health benefits are prohibited from imposing lower annual and
lifetime dollar limits on these benefits than the limits placed
on medical and surgical benefits. Under current law, the MHPA's
parity requirements do not apply to substance abuse or chemical
dependency treatment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ On the state level, all states except Wyoming have passed
mental health parity laws which require state law-governed health plans
to provide varying degrees of mental health coverage, subject these
plans to certain financial limits, or otherwise mandate mental health
benefits. Employers with fully-insured and self-insured plans that are
regulated under ERISA (and thus the MHPA) are not bound by these state
laws, and therefore not subject to these state mandates. Thus, actions
taken by the Committee to amend ERISA will, of necessity, have far-
reaching consequences.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The MHPA's standards apply only to private-sector,
employer-sponsored group health plans, including both fully-
insured and self-insured plans, but not to the individual (non-
group) health insurance market. Employers retain discretion
regarding the extent and scope of mental health benefits
offered to workers and their families, including cost sharing
and requirements relating to medical necessity. Also, certain
plans may be exempt from the MHPA. For instance, a small
employer exception provides that plans covering employers with
50 or fewer employees are exempt from compliance. In addition,
the MHPA permits employers to ``opt-out'' of the MHPA's
requirements if they experience an increase in claims costs of
at least one percent as a result of compliance. The provisions
of the MHPA were originally set to expire in 2001, but have
been routinely reauthorized on an annual basis, with the
current authorization expiring on December 31, 2007.
EXECUTIVE ACTION ON MENTAL HEALTH PARITY
In 1999, President Clinton issued an executive order that
implemented full parity for both mental health and substance
abuse benefits in health plans offered under the Federal
Employees Health Benefits Program (FEHBP) beginning in 2001.
These benefits cover all medically necessary treatments for all
categories of mental illnesses listed in the Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV).\2\ Under the
FEHBP, mental health parity is required only for services
provided on an in-network basis (i.e., through a specific group
of providers contracted by a managed health care organization
and/or an insurance carrier to provide services to participants
in that particular plan). Further, the FEHBP plans engage in
medical management practices to ensure appropriate diagnosis
and treatment of mental health conditions.\3\ The Office of
Personnel Management estimated that implementation of the order
resulted in an average premium increase of 1.64 percent for
fee-for-service plans and 0.3 percent for HMOs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders is
produced by the American Psychiatric Association and is a comprehensive
system of diagnosis for psychiatric conditions. The fourth (IV) edition
was published in 1995, and is the most current edition.
\3\ In general, the term ``medical management'' is used to describe
practices designed to ensure appropriate diagnosis and treatment of
medical conditions, and to improve efficiency and quality in the
delivery of medical services. Such practices include utilization
review, case management, disease management, and quality management.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While endorsing in principle the concept of mental health
parity, the current Administration has not yet endorsed any
particular bill, including H.R. 1424 or S. 558.
FEDERAL LEGISLATIVE ACTIVITY
Senate legislation
In the 110th Congress, the Mental Health Parity Act of
2007, S. 558, was introduced by Senators Pete Domenici (R-NM),
Ted Kennedy (D-MA), and Mike Enzi (R-WY) on February 12, 2007.
The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (``HELP'')
Committee approved the measure, as amended, on February 14,
2007. The Senate bill was the product of negotiations between
patient advocates, behavioral health providers, insurers, and
business groups (collectively, the ``Fairness Coalition''). \4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ Members of the Fairness Coalition include the following health
care provider and mental health advocacy groups: the American Hospital
Association, the American Medical Association, the American Psychiatric
Association, the American Psychological Association, the Association
for Behavioral Health and Wellness, the Federation of American
Hospitals, Mental Health America, National Alliance on Mental Illness,
and the National Association of Psychiatric Health Systems.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
S. 558 generally requires health insurance plans that offer
mental health coverage to provide that coverage on par with
financial and treatment coverage offered for other physical
illnesses, The Senate bill would not mandate that plans provide
specific mental health benefits; however, fully insured plans,
which remain subject to state insurance laws, would still be
required to comply with state-specific benefit requirements. S.
558 also would specifically ensure that medical management of
mental health benefits and negotiation of separate
reimbursement or provider payment rates is not prohibited,
meaning that employers and health plans could maintain
flexibility in forming behavioral health care provider
networks. Finally, the Senate bill, as introduced, would
preempt state parity laws that could impact fully-insured plans
governed by ERISA, but would largely leave benefit mandates
intact.
The Congressional Budget Office (``CBO'') scored S. 558 and
concluded that it would result in a 0.4 percent increase in
employer-sponsored premiums. This was estimated to amount to
$1.5 billion in 2009 and $3.4 billion in 2013. Also, for the
five-year period 2008-2012, CBO estimated a $1 billion decrease
in direct revenues (resulting from increased premium
deductions), $280 million in increased direct spending
(Medicaid managed care), and $150 million in increased
appropriations.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ See, Congressional Budget Office, Cost Estimate, S. 558 Mental
Health Parity Act of 2007, dated March 20, 2007.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additional discussions and negotiations involving S. 558
have continued subsequent to the HELP Committee's markup, and
have resulted in slight revisions to S. 558 as reported out of
committee in the form of a proposed ``manager's amendment'' for
Senate Floor consideration. However, this has not changed the
support of the Fairness Coalition for that bill. In fact, the
parties that negotiated the manager's amendment sent the
following letter to Senators Kennedy, Enzi, and Domenici:
All but two of the provider and advocacy groups of the
Fairness Coalition involved in the negotiation of the Senate
manager's amendment--Mental Health America and the American
Medical Association--signed the June 14 letter above; however,
those two groups have not withdrawn their support for the
Senate manager's amendment.
House Legislation
On March 7, 2007, Representatives Patrick Kennedy (D-RI)
and Jim Ramstad (R-MN) introduced H.R. 1424, the Paul Wellstone
Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007. This bill
amends ERISA, the Public Health Service Act, and the Internal
Revenue Code, and was referred to the Committees on Education
and Labor, Energy and Commerce, and Ways and Means, As a matter
of policy, the bill raises a number of substantive concerns.
As introduced, H.R.. 1424 purports to achieve mental health
parity by prohibiting treatment limits or the imposition of
financial requirements on mental health and substance-related
disorder benefits within group health plans if those
requirements and limitations are not similarly imposed on
medical and surgical benefits under such plans. The bill would
impose a further, broad mandate by requiring that where a plan
covers any behavioral health disorder, it must cover all
currently recognized conditions listed in the DSM-IV. This
mandate would include requiring coverage for certain disorders,
such as ``caffeine intoxication'' and ``circadian rhythm sleep
disorder (jet lag).'' H.R. 1424 eliminates a plan's flexibility
to determine covered benefits. Under the bill, plans would not
be specifically permitted to engage in medical management
practices and negotiate separate reimbursement or provider
payment rates. H.R. 1424 would mandate out-of-network coverage
for mental health and substance-related disorders, if such
coverage is provided for emergency, inpatient or outpatient
services.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, on the issue of
ERISA preemption, H.R. 1424 would give states the authority to
enact greater consumer protections, benefits, methods of access
to benefits, rights or remedies than those contained in the
federal bill. The bill, if enacted, would establish a benefit
``floor'' while permitting states to impose broader mental
health coverage mandates, creating inconsistent and confusing
regulatory schemes. At the same time, this provision allows
state enforcement and remedy schemes to be established which
would apply to certain fully-insured plans, only for mental
health benefits but not other medical benefits. Such plans have
operated under the exclusive jurisdiction and remedies set
forth under ERISA, which has existed and has been interpreted
by the courts for over three decades.
CBO has not scored H.R. 1424. However, considering the CBO
score for S. 558 and the broader employer mandate set forth in
H.R. 1424, it is likely that H.R. 1424's costs would meet or
exceed those of the Senate bill.
Legislative hearing on H.R. 1424
On July 10, 2007, the Committee on Education and Labor
Subcommittee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions held a
legislative hearing on H.R. 1424. At that hearing,
Representatives Kennedy and Ramstad testified, as did Former
First Lady Rosalyn Carter, mental health advocates, an economic
analyst, and the Commissioner of Insurance for the State of
Wisconsin. Additional witnesses included Jon Breyfogle, an
attorney that represented the American Benefits Council, and E.
Neil Trautwein, who represented the National Retail Federation
(``NRF''). The hearing focused on the specific provisions of
the House bill, but also featured robust discussion of the
Senate proposal.
Mr. Trautwein testified as to why the NRF opposes H.R.
1424, but also as to the reasons why that group supports the
proposed manager's amendment to S. 558. In his testimony, Mr.
Trautwein raised a number of concerns regarding the provisions
of H.R. 1424, including its broad coverage mandate, ERISA
preemption and the role of the states, inadequate medical
management protections, and the mandate to provide out-of-
network coverage. Importantly, he outlined the collaborative
Senate process that resulted in a balanced parity bill. In his
own words:
The mental health parity debate has been both long and
fierce. have been an advocate in this debate for a number of
years, both before and after the 1996 law addressing parity in
annual and lifetime limits. We all have contributed heated
rhetoric to this debate. Unfortunately, it has really obscured
our shared objective of helping individuals get the coverage
and care they needed.
It is this last point that has encouraged a running
dialogue between the advocates and Senate sponsors. I have been
privileged to have participated over a number of years as a
principal representative of the employer community in intense
discussions and negotiations with both the Senate sponsors as
well as advocates for the mental health and addiction
communities. I would like to give special thanks to Senators
Ted Kennedy (D-MA), Michael Enzi (R-WY) and Pete Domenici (R-
NM) for their longstanding advocacy on this legislation as well
as for their willing ear and fair and responsive negotiations
through the years.
The Senate compromise that I have highlighted throughout
this testimony is the product of those negotiations. It has
also created a broad coalition among erstwhile opponents--
surely somewhat of a distinction.
NRF is joined in this coalition not only by traditional
allies like the American Benefits Council, Aetna, the U.S.
Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of
Manufacturers (among others) but also by the National Alliance
on Mental Illness, the American Psychiatric and the American
Psychological Associations and the American Hospital
Association and the Federation of American Hospitals (among
others). I have attached a copy of our joint letter at the
conclusion of my testimony. I respectfully ask that it be made
part of the hearing record.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\ Testimony of E. Neil Trautwein, testifying on behalf of the
National Retail Federation, Committee on Education and Labor,
Subcommittee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Hearing, ``The
Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007 (H.R.
1424),'' (July 10, 2007) at 3-4 (emphasis added).
Mr. Breyfogle, an employment benefits practitioner with
decades of experience, explained to the Subcommittee the
reasons underlying support for the Senate bill, and specific
concerns with the House bill. In particular, Mr. Breyfogle
expressed concerns with H.R. 1424's ERISA preemption
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
provisions. As Mr. Breyfogle testified:
We have significant concerns with the provisions in the
House parity bill which would authorize States to provide
``greater consumer protections, benefits, methods of access to
benefits, rights or remedies'' than the provisions set out in
the legislation. Clearly, this language gives States the
ability to develop parity laws, at least for fully insured
health plans, that are more extensive than the federal
standards provided in the House bill. We prefer the approach
adopted in the Senate bill, which would establish uniform
federal parity rules applicable to treatment limitations and
financial requirements for both self-insured and insured plans
while preserving the traditional authority of States to require
fully insured plans to provide mental health coverage.
The more troubling aspect of this provision in the House
bill is that it opens the door for greater State law remedies
for disputes involving mental health benefits for participants
in insured plans. The Supreme Court has issued numerous rulings
making clear that ERISA's enforcement scheme is exclusive for
both fully insured and self-insured plans and completely
preempts alternative State remedial schemes. It makes no sense
whatsoever to allow access to State law remedies for one
category of benefits--i.e., participants in fully insured plans
for disputes over mental health benefits. To the extent the
House bill is interpreted to revise remedies for all types of
benefit disputes, H.R. 1424 is certainly not the vehicle to do
so. The debate over ERISA's remedies has occurred over many
years, generally in the context of the Patients' Bill of
Rights. Such a fundamental issue as ERISA's remedial scheme
should not be an adjunct to a bill whose purpose is to address
mental health parity.
The uniformity that ERISA establishes for employer-
sponsored coverage, including its enforcement and remedies
scheme, is sound public policy and is something employers
consider crucial to their voluntary decision to offer health
coverage to their employees. If Congress believes that changes
are needed in this area, such changes should be debated on
their own merits rather than included as one of many provisions
of a mental health parity bill.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\ Testimony of Jon W. Breyfogle, Esq., testifying on behalf of
the American Benefits Council, Committee on Education and Labor,
Subcommittee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Hearing, ``The
Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007 (H.R.
1424),'' (July 10, 2007) at 7 (emphasis added).
Although testimony was received from other witnesses at the
hearing in favor of mental health parity legislation, the main
points raised by Mr. Trautwein and Mr. Breyfogle regarding the
differences and impacts of the House and Senate bills remained
largely unrebutted, or at best were the subject of legitimate
disagreement among experts. Accordingly, credible testimony at
the July 10, 2007 hearing established that H.R. 1424 did not
accomplish mental health parity in a balanced and thoughtful
manner, and that significant concerns remained regarding the
imposition of mandated benefits. Notwithstanding (or possibly
because of) these legitimate concerns, on July 12 the Democrat
majority scheduled a full committee markup of H.R. 1424 for
July 18, 2007. The Majority provided the final draft of the
Chairman's Amendment to H.R. 1424 approximately twelve hours
before the full committee markup.
Full Committee markup
On Wednesday, July 18, 2007, eight days after the
Subcommittee hearing, the full Committee on Education and Labor
met to consider and mark up H.R. 1424. An Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 1424 was offered by Chairman
Miller (the ``Miller Amendment'') and was adopted without
objection. A Substitute Amendment to the Miller Amendment was
offered by Representative Kline which was rejected on a
rollcall vote of 16 to 25. The Committee favorably reported
H.R. 1424, as amended by the Miller Amendment, on a rollcall
vote of 33 to 9.
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 1424,
offered by Mr. George Miller of California
At the full Committee markup, Chairman Miller offered an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 1424 (``the
Miller Amendment''). The Miller Amendment set forth minor
revisions primarily to Section 2 of H.R. 1424. The late evening
of July 17 was the first time that Minority Members and staff
were afforded the opportunity to review legislative text
purporting to address concerns associated with H.R. 1424.
Among its provisions, the Miller Amendment adds ``emergency
care'' to the categories of items and services for application
of treatment limits and beneficiary financial requirements. In
an apparent attempt to address testimony received at the July
10 Subcommittee hearing, the Miller Amendment includes a new
provision regarding medical management which provides that
nothing in the bill shall limit a group health plan from
managing, using certain methods, the provision of medical,
surgical, mental health or substance-related disorder benefits,
to the extent the methods are recognized and not prohibited
under state laws. The Amendment makes modest revisions to the
notice requirements under the cost exemption section.
The Miller Amendment appears to seek to clarify the bill's
preemption section relating to state laws, ostensibly to
address concerns raised regarding the impact of H.R. 1424's
broad provision permitting state laws to supersede the federal
ERISA law. Specifically, section 2(i) of the Miller Amendment
provides that the bill shall not be construed to supersede
``any provision of State law which establishes, implements, or
continues in effect any consumer protections, benefits, methods
of access to benefits, rights, external review programs, or
remedies solely relating to health insurance issuers in
connection with group health insurance coverage (including
benefit mandates or regulation of group health plans of 50 or
fewer employees) except to the extent that such provision
prevents the application of a requirement of this part.'' It is
further stated that nothing in the section would affect or
modify the provision of ERISA Section 514 with respect to group
health plans.
The Miller Amendment adds a special rule for collective
bargaining agreements that would generally preclude application
of the bill's requirements until after expiration of the
agreement or January 1, 2010, whichever is later. It adds a
requirement on the Department of Labor to randomly sample group
health plan compliance with the parity bill's requirements, and
to provide ``assistance'' to participants and beneficiaries who
have any questions or problems with compliance with the bill's
requirements. Finally, in a revision to section 5 of H.R. 1424,
the Miller Amendment directs the Department of Labor, rather
than the Comptroller General, to prepare biannual reports to
Congress on access to coverage.
The Miller Amendment attempts to address some of the
significant concerns raised with H.R. 1424. Despite good
intent, however, the original bill remains largely unchanged,
and the Miller Amendment does not provide sufficient clarity
necessary to resolve some of the most troubling substantive
concerns with the House legislation.
Kline Substitute Amendment
As discussed above, over the last two years significant
progress on the issue of mental health parity has been made
through the efforts of a bipartisan group of Senators (Kennedy,
Enzi, and Domenici, among others) and a diverse and
representative group of mental health advocates, health care
providers, business groups and insurers. The unprecedented
agreement reached among this bipartisan group is reflected in
S. 558, with subsequent minor changes contained in the proposed
manager's amendment to that bill.
In order to support the good policy and balanced compromise
between all parties interested in achieving true mental health
parity, which is and should be the goal of any legislation, Mr.
Kline offered a substitute amendment at the full committee
markup of H.R. 1424 (the ``Kline Substitute''). The Kline
Substitute embodies the proposed manager's amendment to S. 558.
The Kline Substitute addresses many of the concerns raised
by the House bill. The Kline Substitute does not mandate that
health plans cover specific mental health benefits, makes clear
that medical management of mental health benefits and core
payment and contracting issues necessary for success are not
prohibited, and does not mandate costly out-of-network
coverage. Further, the Kline Substitute ensures that ERISA
preemption requirements are maintained and strengthened, in
order to assure a uniform federal rule for the comprehensive
and strong parity benefits provided by the bill. As such, it
provides broad new parity requirements to participants in
insured plans in approximately eight states that currently have
no parity requirement and expands upon the parity requirements
applicable to insured plans in approximately seventeen other
states. It does this while ensuring that states can continue
their tradition role of regulating benefits provided under
insurance policies in all other respects.
It is important to note that, regardless of whether they
support or oppose H.R. 1424, all of the parties involved in the
Senate negotiations strongly support enactment of the manager's
amendment of S. 558 into law this year.
The Kline Substitute was rejected on a rollcall vote of 16
to 25, with every Democrat present voting against it. The
Democrats' rejection of a broad-based and well-balanced
substitute, which is publicly supported by mainstream mental
health advocates and providers, threatens to undo the careful
balance struck among all parties interested in this issue, and
will make passage of meaningful mental health parity
legislation this year exceedingly difficult.
REPUBLICAN VIEWS
Committee Republicans are united in their desire to achieve
parity between mental health and other medical benefits.
However, the significant differences in current legislative
efforts, as discussed herein, may only serve to frustrate this
goal.
Notwithstanding the rhetoric from supporters of H.R. 1424
and the Miller Amendment (hereafter collectively, unless
specified otherwise, ``H.R. 1424'') which purports to
characterize that legislation as providing ``parity,'' H.R.
1424 does nothing of the sort. In fact, largely because of the
defined benefit and preemption provisions, H.R. 1424 would
create a situation in which employer-sponsored plans would
likely have to provide significantly greater mental and
behavioral health benefits as compared to other medical
benefits. This, for example, raises a question of fundamental
fairness, left unanswered by the Majority: Why should those who
potentially suffer from mental and behavioral illnesses be
entitled to greater employer-sponsored benefits than an
individual suffering from another medical condition, such as
cancer?
As set forth below, H.R. 1424's flaws are numerous. As
such, it should be rejected by the House.
H.R. 1424 imposes a benefit mandate that defines covered illnesses too
broadly
Under H.R. 1424, every mental illness identified by the
mental health profession through the DSM-IV would be required
to be covered by health plans. Even the vast majority of states
currently do not mandate this type of coverage. Further, H.R.
1424 applies no similar requirement on any other category of
medical benefits covered by a plan (hospital services,
physician services, drug benefits, or any other category of
benefits), many of which involve serious medical conditions. At
the same time, an employer is obligated to provide coverage for
disorders such as ``caffeine intoxication'' and ``jet lag,''
which raises serious questions about the validity of the
conditions to be covered by this bill. The Majority apparently
believes that ``caffeine intoxication'' and ``jet lag'' are the
types of disorders that are worthy of a federal coverage
mandate on employer-sponsored plans.
Beyond the questionable nature of some of the ``disorders''
that would be required to be covered, H.R. 1424 does not create
parity between medical/surgical and mental health conditions
which must be covered by a plan. Rather, at bottom, it is a
preferential benefit mandate in favor of mental health
conditions, which would override many existing state mandates
for insurance plans that require coverage of a specific list of
behavioral health and substance abuse conditions.
The Majority may argue that beneficiaries in private,
employer-sponsored plans should be entitled coverage for the
same illnesses covered by the FEHBP. However, this argument is
misleading. Simply because the federal government, through an
executive order issued by then-President Clinton, chose to
provide such coverage does not mean all employer-sponsored
plans should be mandated by the federal government to do the
same. Employers, like the federal government, are in the best
position to assess the needs of their covered populations, and
should be permitted to exercise their discretion to voluntarily
assume which illnesses they choose to cover. It was for that
reason that the Kline Substitute preserved the ability of group
plans to use their discretion in determining covered benefits,
and preserved the ability of states to mandate benefits only in
certain circumstances.
H.R. 1424 significantly weakens ERISA preemption
Under the House bill as introduced, states would be
authorized to enact ``greater consumer protections, benefits,
methods of access to benefits, rights or remedies'' than the
provisions set out in the legislation. This would give states
the ability to develop parity laws, at least for fully insured
health plans, that are more extensive than the federal
standards provided in the House bill. A further concern is that
virtually limitless state law remedies could be available to
participants in insured plans for disputes involving mental
health benefits.
The Miller Amendment appears to attempt to correct these
flaws by inserting new language relating to ERISA preemption,
and its relation to state laws. The Majority may attempt to
argue that this new language is consistent with provisions of
the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act that
have been in effect for many years. However, a close reading of
the language reveals the potential for a substantial weakening
of ERISA preemption. For example, the new language fails to
clarify Congressional intent with sufficient specificity, as
set forth in the Kline Substitute, that if any provision of a
state law is preempted, any remaining provision of such law
shall remain in effect and not be preempted. In addition, the
claim by the Majority that the new language provides no new
litigation rights for participants is questionable at best, if
not simply incorrect. The new language specifically provides
that any provision of state law that establishes, implements or
continues ``any consumer protections, benefits, methods of
access to benefits, rights, external review programs, or
remedies'' is not superseded. Although the new language limits
the provision to group health insurance, and ostensibly
continues ERISA preemption with respect to group health plans,
this point will undoubtedly be the subject of litigation, and
raises the substantial possibility of a significant erosion of
ERISA preemption developed by court precedent over more than 30
years, Accordingly, the Miller Amendment creates the potential
for confusing and conflicting state laws, and makes employer-
sponsored plans subject to increased costs.
If the Majority is truly interested in preserving ERISA
preemption and not creating more expansive rights and remedies
only for mental health benefits, as they stated at the full
Committee markup, they simply would have sought to adopt the
preemption language of the Kline Substitute, which is
acceptable to interested stakeholders on both sides of this
debate.\8\ The failure to do so suggests that the Majority is
more interested in expanding rights and remedies and fueling
litigation for a specific and narrow class of benefits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ We note that there has been significant debate regarding the
impact of S. 558 on ERISA preemption. See, Mila Kofman, Letter to
Speaker Nancy Pelosi (June 15, 2007) and Sara Rosenbaum, JD, Letter to
Senators Pete Domenici, Edward Kennedy and Michael Enzi (June 27,
2007). Negotiations over this particular provision continue, and will
hopefully be resolved to the satisfaction of all stakeholders.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1424 does not adequately address medical management of claims
Apparently in response to testimony received from
Republican witnesses at the Subcommittee hearing, H.R. 1424 as
reported contains specific language which appears to attempt to
authorize the use of medical management practices for mental
health benefits. However, it still omits a key component that
helps improve the effectiveness of medical management
practices, which is contained in the Kline Substitute.
Specifically, H.R. 1424 does not make clear that under its
provisions group health plans are not prohibited from
negotiating separate reimbursement or provider payment rates
and service delivery systems for different benefits. This
provision, combined with the specific authorization of medical
management practices, would serve to provide group health plans
with the tools necessary to appropriately manage and deliver
mental and behavioral health care benefits. Further, given that
such contracting practices are in use in the FEHBP, the
Majority's failure to include this specific authorization is
inexplicable. As such, H.R. 1424 fails to protect the core
payment and contracting practices that are essential to
successful medical management programs that control cost and
quality of benefits, and is therefore deficient.
H.R. 1424 mandates out-of-network coverage
H.R. 1424 mandates out-of-network coverage if a plan
provides coverage for substantially all medical and surgical
services in either emergency, inpatient or outpatient services.
This is not ``parity,'' since it limits the ability of
employer-sponsored plans to design benefit programs. Also, it
exceeds the FEHBP requirement to provide parity only for in-
network services. Although the Majority references the FEHBP
program as the standard by which private plans should operate,
they selectively exclude those portions of the FEHBP program
which do not further the Majority's goals. This provision
should be rejected.
Employer mandates will increase costs and decrease coverage
There is no debate over whether H.R. 1424 will increase the
costs of employer-sponsored group health plan premiums. It
will, and testimony from the Majority's own witnesses confirm
this fact. The only question involves how much will premium
costs increase as a result of this mandate. At the Subcommittee
hearing, the Majority cited testimony from an allegedly
independent analysis of H.R. 1424 that found a premium cost
increase of approximately 0.6 percent for ``typical'' plans,
and 0.1 percent if medical management practices are adopted.
However, this analysis was not prepared by CBO, and can by no
means be considered ``independent'' in that it was prepared by
a paid actuarial consultant for several behavioral health
organizations interested in passage of H.R. 1424. Also, the
Miller Amendment fails to fully authorize medical management
practices. Further, even under this analysis many group health
plans, especially smaller plans, may experience cost increases
significantly above the increase for a ``typical'' plan.
Although there can be legitimate debate over the extent of
cost increases, there should be no debate that imposing
mandates increases costs and likely decreases the affordability
and quality of coverage provided. Although when viewed in
isolation, coverage mandates may appear to be more economically
feasible and desirable, we remain concerned that the Majority
will continue to consider the future imposition of additional
coverage mandates. The cumulative costs associated with these
mandates will have a detrimental impact on the quality and
affordability of health care benefits. This appears to be
contrary to the shared goal of all Members to expand access to
affordable, high quality coverage.
CONCLUSION
As we noted at the outset, the goal of providing parity
between mental health benefits and other medical benefits
provided under employer-sponsored health coverage is something
that all Members of the Committee, and many in Congress, would
likely endorse. There have been significant advances in
diagnosis and treatment of mental and behavioral health
disorders, and Committee Republicans generally believe that
mental health benefits should be provided on the same terms as
medical and surgical benefits. We recognize the two current
legislative proposals, H.R. 1424 and S. 558, offer
substantially different approaches toward achieving parity.
However, only one bill, S. 558, before this Committee as
the Kline Substitute at markup, achieves true parity and
represents the product of two years of negotiation and
agreement among a diverse group of interested stakeholder in
this debate. The authors of H.R. 1424 did not involve all
interested stakeholders, and the legislation appears to place
mental health benefits in a more favored posture than all other
medical benefits. Further, although attempts were made at full
Committee markup to improve the bill, despite these efforts, it
remains fundamentally flawed. If passed by the House, H.R.
1424, which differs substantially with legislation that could
pass the Senate, will only serve to complicate enactment of
mental health parity legislation this year.
For all of the reasons stated above, we oppose the passage
of H.R. 1424.
Howard P. ``Buck'' McKeon.
Thomas E. Petri.
Peter Hoekstra.
Mark E. Souder.
Judy Biggert.
John Kline.
Luis G. Fortuno.
Charles W. Boustany, Jr.
David Davis.
Timothy Walberg.