[Congressional Record (Bound Edition), Volume 146 (2000), Part 8]
[Senate]
[Pages 10654-10655]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office, www.gpo.gov]



                       THE RIGHT TO SELF-DEFENSE

  Mr. CRAIG. Mr. President, I have come to the floor for the next few 
minutes to talk about something that is very important to our country. 
Last week, I rose in defense of the second amendment to our 
Constitution. Why? Because it is under relentless attack at this moment 
by our colleagues on the other side of the aisle. It is under 
relentless attack by the White House and has been now for nearly 8 
solid years. They want to deny that there is a second amendment, or 
that there are legitimate rights under that amendment, and they simply 
want to control or shape what many Americans believe to be their 
constitutional right under the second amendment, and that is the right 
to own a firearm in this Nation.
  The second amendment reads:

       A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security 
     of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear 
     Arms, shall not be infringed.
  It is a simple amendment, but, oh, what a powerful force it brings; 
and, oh, what important emotions it engenders in our country.
  The enemies of the right to keep and bear arms tell us that because 
the word ``militia'' is present, the second amendment only protects the 
right of the Government to keep and bear arms.
  If anyone in this body is a student of American history and 
understands the

[[Page 10655]]

thinking of our Founding Fathers, they recognize their hostility toward 
a central government and their willingness to control a central 
government and give the citizens the greater expression of freedom but, 
most importantly, power over that central government.
  Somehow, our colleague would like to ignore those thoughts and the 
mind set and the belief of the framers of our Constitution. But let me 
tell you that our framers knew what they were talking about. They said, 
``A well regulated Militia'' means, in the words of George Mason, ``the 
whole people''--``the whole people'' was the regulation militia--
``except a few public officers.''
  So never mind their restrictive reading of the Constitution. I think 
our scholars of history have widely recognized and rejected the idea 
that there is a narrow interpretation.
  They tell us the second amendment only protects hunting and sport 
shooting. Read the Constitution. It is so very clear. It doesn't even 
mention the words ``hunting and sport shooting.'' I don't believe the 
term ``sport shooting'' was something used in those days. Hunting 
certainly was perceived to be a right, and even a responsibility, and a 
necessary tool of many families to put food on the table.
  They cite Supreme Court cases--such as United States v. Miller--that 
state the second amendment protects private ownership of military-style 
weapons; then they try to ban private ownership of military-style 
weapons. How can you use the argument to argue its purpose and then 
turn and try to do quite the opposite?
  I will simply point out for a few brief moments this afternoon the 
real inconsistencies in the argument that is presented by my colleagues 
on the other side and the blatant ignoring of our Constitution by the 
White House. But then those of us who are observers of the White House 
are not terribly surprised by that.
  Am I being harsh? I don't think so, Mr. President. I think I am being 
very clear in what I say.
  Senate gun controllers have said they do not want to confiscate the 
guns of Americans. But then other leaders in other countries--including 
Great Britain, Nazi Germany, Cambodia, Australia, Cuba, and Soviet 
Georgia--have said the same, and they would only license and register, 
and not confiscate. And, of course, they did license, they did 
register, and then they confiscated.
  With my time remaining, let me point to a few examples as to why our 
Government said there was a right and why our Founding Fathers said 
under our Constitution there is a right.
  Every 13 seconds, the stories I am about to tell you are repeated 
across this Nation. Every 13 seconds in America, someone uses a gun--
not to kill someone else, but to stop a crime, to protect their 
property, to protect their life. Every 13 seconds across America, our 
citizens do what our Founding Fathers knew they must do as a free 
citizen; that is, protect themselves in the right of self-defense. That 
is so much what our second amendment is about.
  Let me tell you about this lady, whom I show here on the chart, from 
Spring Hill, FL, May 24 of this year. It says: ``A pistol-packing 
grandmother with a license to carry calmly approached a man with a 
knife who was scuffling with employees at a Wal-Mart and ordered him to 
drop'' the knife. He dropped the knife. She held him at bay. They 
called the cops, and the cops arrested him.
  Thank you, grandma, for being willing to defend your rights and the 
integrity of others.
  Let me talk about someone who invaded the home of one of our citizens 
in Benton Harbor in Berrien County.

       Prosecutor Jim Cherry announced Thursday he will not file 
     homicide charges against a man who shot and killed Rodney Lee 
     Moore last month at a Benton Harbor housing complex.

  Why? Because this man was defending his life and defending the life 
of his family. He had been attacked. He had been injured. And yet, he 
struggled, he found his gun, and he protected his person by taking the 
intruder's life.
  That is the right of a free citizen in a free society--to defend 
oneself and one's property.
  One more example. I know there are other colleagues on the floor who 
wish to speak on other issues. But it is an important example.
  It was the night of January 31 of this year in Apache Junction, AR, 
25 miles from Phoenix. It began when a woman was getting into her SUV 
in a Wal-Mart parking lot in nearby Chandler. She was approached by a 
man riding a bicycle. He pulled out a gun, forced her into her SUV, and 
made her drive to an isolated area 15 miles away. He raped her. Then he 
abandoned her in the desert.
  According to the Chandler Police Department sergeant, Ken Phillips, 
``He left her in a desert area and starts to drive away, but turns 
around, comes back, and he shoots her twice.'' The woman, suffering 
from bullet wounds in her face, her chest, and her arm, was 
miraculously able to walk a quarter of a mile for help.
  This dangerous criminal then drove his victim's SUV to the home of 
his former boss, Jeff Tribble. In that home, Mr. Tribble, his 28-year-
old wife Bricie, and their 9-year-old nephew resided. The criminal 
broke into their house. What happened? Sergeant Phillips said that this 
gentleman's wife, Mr. Tribble's wife, got her gun and shot the criminal 
twice--once in the face and once in the chest--and he dropped dead. 
Then she called 911 to report the shooting of an intruder who had just 
hours before raped and shot another person.
  Those are the stories that are not being told to America today. And 
they happen every 13 seconds across our Nation. Two and one-half 
million Americans annually use the second amendment right to protect 
themselves, their property, their children, and their spouses. That is 
the right of a free citizen. That is why the second amendment is in the 
Constitution.
  I do not in any way by these statements fail to recognize the 
tragedies that occur when a gun is misused in our society. It is 
misused much too often. But it is time we speak out.
  I have said several times to those who may be listening or who might 
read my statement to call me or write me. Tell me about your story. 
Tell me about what happened in your community. Literally, citizens are 
now doing that. Tell me about the right of the free citizen to protect 
themselves and their property.
  It is very simple. It is, Larry Craig, U.S. Senator, Washington, DC, 
20510.
  I would like to hear from you. I think it is time America is heard, 
about how other Americans use their sacred right of the second 
amendment to protect themselves and their loved ones.
  I yield the floor.
  The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Illinois.

                          ____________________