[Congressional Record Volume 170, Number 63 (Friday, April 12, 2024)]
[House]
[Pages H2364-H2366]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]




              SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE LIVES LOST IN GAZA

  The SPEAKER pro tempore. Under the Speaker's announced policy of 
January 9, 2023, the Chair recognizes the gentleman from Texas (Mr. 
Green) for 30 minutes.
  Mr. GREEN of Texas. Mr. Speaker, and still I rise.
  I rise proud to be an American, proud to have the opportunity to 
stand here in the Congress of the United States of America and address 
issues of importance to the world.
  I am proud to say that as an American, I salute the flag. I say the 
Pledge of Allegiance. I sing the national anthem. I stand for the 
anthem, but, Mr. Speaker, as I always remind people, as a liberated 
Democrat, I remind them, the greatness of America will not be measured 
by whether the Al Green's of the world will stand and salute the flag 
or will stand and sing the national anthem.
  The greatness of America will be measured by whether the Al Green's 
of the world will defend those who choose not to stand, who choose not 
to sing, who choose not to salute. I will defend their rights as 
Americans not to participate in many things that I participate in.
  Mr. Speaker, I am proud to say that when I tell people I love my 
country, a good many would say to me, why would you love a country that 
segregated you? Why would you love a country that required you to sit 
in the back of the bus, the balcony of a movie? Why would you love a 
country that has treated you so badly and so poorly when you were a 
child?
  I was the son of a segregated South. The laws that the Constitution 
recognized for me, my friends and neighbors denied access to those 
laws, if you will.
  But I have found that the best opportunity to make a difference in 
the world and change these things resides here in the United States of 
America. I love the country because I love the ideals, the ideals, what 
it stands for in its Declaration of Independence, what it stands for in 
its Constitution. I know that the Constitution did not apply equally to 
all when initially written, but I also know that there have been 
changes and there is still much change to take place.
  I love my country, but I still believe that there must be things that 
we can do and there are things we can do to make the country a better 
place for all.
  Therefore, today, I rise, Mr. Speaker, to speak on behalf of the many 
persons who have lost their lives, who have suffered in Gaza. The 
United States funds, funds the country that has purchased the weaponry, 
much of it, that has been used to harm people in Gaza. We have our 
fingerprints on these weapons. We have our fingerprints on the 
destruction that is taking place in Gaza.
  I rise to stand with the innocent Palestinian men, women, and 
children, especially children, as well as others who were in Gaza who 
have suffered.
  I rise, Mr. Speaker, with a resolution that I will be filing, a 
resolution that will be commemorating the innocent civilian lives lost 
in Gaza.
  I plan to read this resolution, but before I read it, I will remind 
people, those who would think that I only commemorate the lives of 
Palestinians and those who lost their lives in Gaza who happen to be 
Palestinian. No. I was right here on the Capitol grounds just outside 
this building--you walk out, you walk over, you don't really walk down 
to the place where we stood to present our belief that we should bring 
back the hostages.
  I participated in this with the Honorable Frederica Wilson from 
Florida to bring back the hostages, to say to the world that we support 
bringing the hostages back. They should never have been taken. You 
don't take babies as hostages.
  I stood there, and before that, I was out in front of the Capitol 
with the Speaker of the House and many Representatives from this House 
to indicate that a certain number of days had passed and people were 
still being held hostage. I have spoken on the floor of this House on 
behalf of Israel. I have voted for more than $50 billion in support to 
Israel. So don't in any way conclude that I am a person who has not 
supported Israel and the people of Israel.
  But today, I have a resolution that deals with the innocent civilian 
lives lost in Gaza, and that would include, by the way, the seven 
people who were wounded, who were the World Central Kitchen workers. 
They were there to bring relief. It is a relief organization, but I say 
they were great humanitarians who lost their lives, and their lives 
have to be commemorated as well.
  Please, hear now the resolution commemorating innocent civilian lives 
lost in Gaza:
  ``Whereas, this resolution may be cited as the `Original Resolution 
Commemorating Innocent Civilian Lives Lost in Gaza.' ''
  By the way, it hasn't been filed. If someone wants to file a 
resolution similar to this before I file mine, please do so. I don't 
file it because I am trying to be first in time. I file it because 
there is a necessity to talk about the lives that have been lost in 
Gaza.
  ``Whereas, this resolution may be cited as the `Original Resolution 
Commemorating Innocent Civilian Lives Lost in Gaza.' ''
  By the way, one of the reasons that I filed this resolution, Mr. 
Speaker, is because I believe we must do more than statisticize these 
lives that were lost. We must do more to humanize the suffering that is 
taking place in Gaza. Statisticizing does not give you the essence of 
the human beings that have lost their lives and been wounded.
  I will say more about that as we progress.

                              {time}  1400

  ``Whereas, on October 7, 2023, Hamas conducted a heinous attack on 
Israel, leading to Israel declaring war on Hamas.''
  This is not in the resolution, but you need to hear this: War on 
Hamas, Mr. Speaker. Not war on Palestinians, war on Hamas. Even the 
Prime Minister of Israel, Mr. Netanyahu himself, has said that the 
Palestinians are victims. War on Hamas declared by Israel, not war on 
Palestinians.
  Continuing with the resolution: ``Whereas, in 2020, the population of 
Gaza was over 2 million, with approximately half being children under 
the age of 18.''
  Half, more than half being children under the age of 18. I repeat a 
lot of things for emphasis. This is one of those things.
  ``Whereas, because of the war, homes, schools, businesses, and 
hospitals within Gaza have been decimated.''
  I will say more about that in a moment.
  ``Whereas, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilian men, women, and 
especially children in Gaza have suffered through the loss of mothers, 
fathers, brothers, and sisters''--family members, families have lost 
their lives in Gaza; innocent people, I might add--``while starving and 
suffering the mental anguish associated with war.''
  Can you imagine what it would be like for the persons who survive 
this war, what their lives will be like? Will there be counseling for 
them as we provide counseling for ourselves when we have suffered some 
sort of mental anguish? Or will they just have to suffer for the rest 
of their lives and never get the proper medical treatment that they 
richly deserve?

[[Page H2365]]

  ``Whereas, civilians in Gaza live in constant fear of the sudden loss 
of arms, legs, and life.''
  I will say more about this in just a moment.
  ``Whereas, tens of thousands of innocent civilians, including 
thousands of children, have been brutally killed in a war beyond their 
control: Now, therefore, be it resolved that the House of 
Representatives commemorates the tens of thousands of innocent civilian 
lives lost in Gaza, too many of whom were children; the lives lost 
should be viewed as more than statistics''--so far what I have done is 
give you statistics, for the most part, ``more than mere statistics''--
``an effort should be made to respect the humanity of the dead; the 
killing of innocents should be stopped with all possible haste; and the 
United States should do everything it can to address the humanitarian 
crisis in Gaza.''
  I thank the President for causing the necessary aid to be brought 
back into Gaza. I don't know that enough has been brought back to date, 
but I do know that because of this President, the gates have been 
opened such that more aid can get into Gaza. I am grateful for that.
  Now, let's go further into this because we have to humanize some of 
what I talked about. First, this poster that you see, my staff has 
written me a note that I have to remove. This poster that you see 
reads: Gaza's economy would not recover to its GDP levels of 2022 until 
2092, seven decades from now--2092--if the economy were to grow at the 
pace it has in previous years. 2092 before Gaza can recover if its 
economy grows at the pace that it grew in previous years.
  According to my staff, in 2022, Gaza's per capita income was $3,572, 
which is 4 percent of what ours was in the United States. Ours was 
$76,329. This simply says that to get back to a per capita income that 
was painful to suffer, it will take seven decades if it grows at the 
rate that it was growing in 2022.
  Now, this is a depiction of the destruction. You have seen it on 
television. I am still dealing with statistics, by the way. I haven't 
really gotten to the heart of the message. If you can, stay with me.
  This depicts the suffering visually in terms of property that has 
been destroyed. It says, ``Israel's destruction.'' I would have this 
read, ``the Government of Israel.'' The people of Israel I have no 
quarrel with. I do have a quarrel with the government. I have no 
quarrel with the people of Israel. I have had differences of opinion 
with my government and still love the people in the country. You can 
have people that you have no quarrel with, but you can have a 
difference with the government.
  I would say the destruction of homes--and this is by virtue of the 
government's mandate--has created almost 23 million metric tons of 
rubble--23 million metric tons. My staff has given me some intelligence 
on what 23 million metric tons would be the equivalent of for 
reference. One metric ton is roughly equal to the weight of a small 
compact car. If we lined up 23 million compact cars end to end, you 
would be able to circle the globe--this would be the Earth--twice.
  Now, I know that the fighting is not what it was. I understand that 
there is what we would call a cessation in fighting to some extent 
taking place at this time, but there is a possibility that it may 
return.
  Even if it never returns, we can't forget that this happened. We can 
never forget that this took place. Just as I will never forget that 
slavery took place in this country, I won't ever forget that this took 
place in Gaza.
  God gave us memory for a reason. You have a heart to forgive, but you 
have a head to remember. I won't forget this. If it ends now, I will 
still remember the suffering and pain and all the atrocities that took 
place in Gaza.
  Continuing, this is a representation that starts to get to where I am 
going. It reads: ``The catastrophic levels of hunger and starvation in 
Gaza are the highest ever recorded on the IPC scale, both in terms of 
number of people and percentage of the population.''
  This document will tell me what the IPC is, and I shall tell you. It 
is the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, the highest ever 
recorded happening in Gaza now. This is not something that happened 
ages ago.
  We are getting closer to the essence of my message: Of the thousands 
of Palestinians killed in Gaza, about 70 percent have been women and 
children. There are estimates out there of tens of thousands. If you 
give the estimate that is being quoted, someone will say that is a bad 
source that you got it from, but nobody disputes the fact that tens of 
thousands have been killed, tens of thousands. Seventy percent have 
been women and children in the war to date. I won't forget this.

  Now, to the heart of my message, this says more than 10 children lose 
a limb, on average, per day in Gaza. Now, that was a while ago. That 
was as of January 7, 2024, so it may be a lot different today because 
of the cessation in hostilities--not the complete stop. They haven't 
ceased, but there is not as much, not nearly as much, taking place 
currently.
  What you see here is a child, this child I shall read about, and this 
gets to what I was saying about humanizing. We have to humanize not 
statisticize. This is more than a number. This is an actual child. We 
must humanize this baby.
  I will read to you now from The New Yorker. The article is styled: 
``The Children Who Lost Limbs in Gaza,'' subtitled, ``More than a 
thousand children who were injured in the war are now amputees. What do 
their futures hold?''
  This is by Eliza Griswold, March 21, 2024. It reads: ``Gazal''--her 
name is Gazal, we are not saying Gaza, her name is Gazal, this baby--
``was wounded on November 10, when, as her family fled Gaza City's Al-
Shifa hospital, shrapnel pierced her left calf. To stop the bleeding, a 
doctor, who had no access to antiseptic or anesthesia, heated the blade 
of a kitchen knife''--she was bleeding as a result of shrapnel, and the 
doctor took a kitchen knife and heated the knife, it says here--
``heated the blade of a kitchen knife and cauterized the wound.''
  Now, this baby has to be more than a piece of statistical 
information. This is a human being suffering, and she had the wound 
cauterized with a heated kitchen knife.
  It says: ``Within days, the gash ran with pus and began to smell.''
  Now, this is somebody's child. The gash ran with pus and began to 
smell. Can you imagine what your life would be like if your child had 
suffered this kind of wound and you had to use a kitchen knife to 
cauterize, to try to save your baby's life, and then, within days, the 
gash starts to smell?
  ``By mid-December, when Gazal's family arrived at Nasser Medical 
Center, then Gaza's largest functioning healthcare facility''--by the 
way, it was rendered dysfunctional; if it has been brought back up, it 
was done so as of late; it was rendered dysfunctional during the war--
``then Gaza's largest functioning medical facility, gangrene had set 
in.''
  So, we have a baby wounded. Her leg is cauterized, and she is then 
taken to a hospital because of pus. The cauterized leg is smelling. We 
have to make sure that you understand that there was an odor that this 
family detected. It said that gangrene set in, necessitating amputation 
at the hip. This is a human being.

                              {time}  1415

  We have got to do more to humanize. We can't say that children are 
losing their limbs. A baby lost her leg up to her hip. We have got to 
do more to humanize. This baby had purpose. She had a life.
  Now, someone will say, well, this is not Gaza. It doesn't look like 
Gaza. If the baby was wounded in Gaza, why is she in this environment? 
I will get to that. I will get to that.
  ``On December 17 a projectile''--now remember, she is at this medical 
center. ``On December 17, a projectile hit the children's ward of 
Nasser.'' That is the hospital. ``Gazal and her mother watched it enter 
their room . . . `' They are in the hospital now to receive attention 
to the wound that this baby suffered earlier, and they watched--this is 
amazing to me--watched it enter the room. They are saying the 
projectile came into the room, and they saw it as it was coming in.
  Can you imagine the fear? Can you imagine the kind of counseling and 
psychiatric help you need when you see this?
  So this projectile comes into the room, and here is what follows: `` 
. . .

[[Page H2366]]

decapitating Gazal's 12-year-old roommate and causing the ceiling to 
collapse.'' Gazal had a roommate in that facility. This person, 12 
years of age, is decapitated.
  By the way, Israelis were decapitated, too. I denounced it. I 
denounced it. I don't believe you can condemn the killing of Israeli 
babies and then condone the killing of Palestinian babies. I can't do 
that. The God that I worship doesn't let me do that.
  This projectile decapitated Gazal's 12-year-old roommate and caused 
the ceiling to collapse. ``Multiple news reports have described the 
event as an Israeli attack. The IDF claimed the incident could have 
been caused by a Hamas mortar or the remnant of an Israeli flare.'' 
Now, IDF says it could have been caused by Hamas or Israel. ``Gazal and 
her mother managed to crawl out of the rubble.'' Here is a baby with 
one leg amputated up to the hip in a facility to get help, and she has 
to crawl out. ``Gazal's mother was 9 months pregnant; she gave birth to 
a baby girl while awaiting the airlift to Doha.
  ``UNICEF estimates that a thousand children in Gaza have become 
amputees since the conflict began in October. `This is the biggest 
cohort of pediatric amputees in history,''' it says, and it is taking 
place in Gaza.
  My time is nearly up, so I have to rush to my close, and I am going 
to do so, Mr. Speaker, so I beg you would bear with me. This closing 
has to be heard.
  Mr. Speaker, how much time do I have remaining.
  The SPEAKER pro tempore. The gentleman has 3 minutes remaining.
  Mr. GREEN of Texas. Mr. Speaker, we have statisticized, I have tried 
to humanize, and forgive me for not enunciating some of these words, 
the verbiage, properly, but my heart was speaking today so my head 
sometimes gets distorted.
  We have humanized this baby. We have talked about what is happening 
and what has happened.
  Now I want to talk to you about something that will give us hope. 
This is from the speech of the Prime Minister of Japan. He spoke where 
the Speaker is standing right now. Why would I go to the speech of the 
Prime Minister from Japan? Well, here is why. Listen to his words. He 
says--and this is his conclusion--``Let me close with this final 
thought. I want you to know how seriously Japan takes its role as the 
United States' closest ally.''
  Somebody remembers that the United States was the first country in 
the world to use nuclear power against a perceived enemy. An enemy, if 
you will--some would say perceived, I am going to say an enemy at the 
time. We dropped two atomic bombs, Nagasaki and Hiroshima, and you have 
got the Prime Minister of Japan standing where the Speaker is now 
saying that we are their closest ally, they are our closest ally.
  He goes on to say: ``Together we carry a large responsibility. I 
believe that we are essential to peace, vital to freedom, and 
fundamental to prosperity.''
  This is the Prime Minister of Japan. Notwithstanding all that has 
happened, notwithstanding what we did in dropping atomic bombs on 
Japan, the Prime Minister proclaims that we are friends.
  He goes on to say: ``Bonded by our beliefs, I pledge to you Japan's 
firm alliance and enduring friendship.''
  Why did I bring this up? I brought this up because those who say that 
we cannot have a two-state solution, I say to you remember that Japan 
is the country that we dropped atomic bombs on, and we now have a 
friendship with Japan. We have the Prime Minister coming here and 
speaking to a joint session of Congress.
  Don't tell me we can't have a two-state solution. I know that Mr. 
Netanyahu's behavior is not that of a person who seeks a two-state 
solution because if it were, you wouldn't decimate Gaza, you wouldn't 
kill tens of thousands of people, many of them babies.
  I understand that he doesn't want a two-state solution. I understand 
that Hamas doesn't want a two-state solution. But we cannot be guided 
by what Hamas and Mr. Netanyahu, Prime Minister of Israel, what they 
want.
  We should be guided by our conscience and do the right thing, and a 
two-state solution is the right solution.
  Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.

                          ____________________