[Congressional Record Volume 168, Number 183 (Tuesday, November 29, 2022)]
[Senate]
[Pages S6862-S6865]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]




                                UKRAINE

  Mr. PORTMAN. Madam President, I come to the floor today for the 26th 
consecutive week that the Senate has been in session to highlight the 
very latest from Russia's illegal, unprovoked, and deadly assault on 
Ukraine. This continues to be a critical time for Ukraine and Ukraine's 
freedom fighters, and it is a classic fight for freedom. At this 
critical juncture, as the winter months approach, Russia's morale is 
flagging and Ukrainians are making steady gains on the battlefield. It 
is absolutely vital that the United States and our allies continue to 
stand by the people of Ukraine. We can't pull back now.
  Ukraine, as you know, is a democracy. They are a great ally of ours. 
They just want to live in peace with their neighbors, including Russia.
  Over the objections of 140 countries in the United Nations, Russia 
launched a brutal invasion of Ukraine on February 24. That was 9 months 
ago, and they haven't let up. While we celebrated Thanksgiving holiday 
this past week here in America, Ukrainians endured a deadly week of 
Russian attacks and bombardments on civilian population centers far, 
far from the frontlines. They didn't get a Thanksgiving break from the 
war.
  Russia's military is actually continuing to bomb inside of Ukraine 
even today, civilian targets. What is interesting is that, at the same 
time, Ukraine is winning on the battlefield. Over half of Ukraine's 
Russian-occupied territory has now been liberated. Remember, at one 
point, Ukraine included the occupied territory up here near Kyiv, the 
capital, and all this area. Most of that area has now been liberated, 
and these are the areas where the Russians continue to occupy: Crimea, 
which they took back in 2014, parts of the Donetsk, and these 
additional areas. Even today, Ukrainians are making progress in these 
areas.
  So on the battlefield, the Ukrainians, with our help and the help of 
50 countries around the world, are making

[[Page S6863]]

progress. Yet, Russia continues to launch these missiles into Ukraine. 
Even in a place like Bakhmut, one place where the Russians were making 
some progress using mercenary forces--the Wagner Group, it is called--
the monthslong assault by these Russian forces has turned into a 
grinding battle of attrition, and Russia has made little to no gains. 
So in the Bakhmut region, which is right here, even there, where the 
Wagner Group is fighting, they are not making significant progress at 
all.
  By the way, back in April 2018, I visited Bakhmut. I was able to go 
there as part of a congressional factfinding trip, and the Ukrainian 
military allowed me to see the line of contact--actually go to that 
border area--the line of contact being between the occupied part in 
2014 and the rest of Ukraine.
  That is where I learned that the Ukrainians were going to fight, by 
the way, because I talked to a lot of the soldiers there about what was 
going on, and when there was discussion several years later about 
whether Ukrainians would fight if the Russians invaded, as it appeared 
clear they were going to do, I had no doubt that the Ukrainians were 
going to fight because I met these soldiers and talked to them, and 
they were hardened, and they knew what Russia had done to them and 
their families and their country and their freedom. And they have 
fought.
  Here is a photo of me back in 2018 in this area of Bakhmut. As you 
can see, you have Ukrainian soldiers walking around freely.
  Here is a photograph of Bakhmut today, to show you the difference. 
Back when I was there, there was sniper activity. You could hear some 
artillery being fired off in the distance, but today, months and months 
of Russia's brutal assault has led to Bakhmut looking like this.
  Here is the Ukrainian soldier today.
  It is a hellscape straight from the Western front of World War I, 
isn't it? Relentless artillery bombardments have forced soldiers into 
these trenches, just like they dug in France during World War I and 
World War II. This is the condition that Ukrainian soldiers are 
fighting in to defend their families, their freedom, and their country, 
and they are doing it as the temperature is falling and winter 
approaches. But they are undeterred, and they continue to fight hard.
  The response to Ukraine making progress on the battlefield by Russia 
is to launch these missiles into the interior. I really think it is out 
of frustration. It is a cowardly approach. They can't win on the 
battlefield, so instead they are sitting back in Russia and bombing 
these civilian targets.
  Here is one you can see. It is an energy grid in Ukraine. This is in 
western Ukraine. And it is just relentless bombing. They are killing 
people when they do this, by the way. They are not just taking out 
energy infrastructure; they are killing civilians, including energy 
workers. Again, it is a cowardly approach. They are killing civilians 
and noncombatants, needlessly slaughtering men, women, and children. 
They are attacking residential areas, and they have been all along--
apartment buildings, hospitals, community buildings--and, of course, 
causing cities to go dark as they go into winter, dark and cold.
  When we were in Ukraine just a few weeks ago--Senator Coons and 
myself--Senator Coons and I went to get some additional information on 
the ground in Ukraine, and we got to see this firsthand.
  This is in Kyiv, the capital of Ukraine. This is where the control 
center was for this energy utility, and this had happened just a few 
days before we got there. So the Russians are targeting very 
specifically energy to knock out electricity, knock out heating, knock 
out water.
  That night, by the way, we had dinner with Ukrainian 
Parliamentarians. It was a dinner meeting to talk about what we 
could do as Congress and they can do as Parliamentarians to help the 
Ukrainian people right now. We had to have the meal by flashlight and 
candles because there was no electricity.

  The systemic bombing of civilian infrastructure, throwing these 
Ukrainian cities in the dark and in the cold, without running water, 
has been met by heroic repair by Ukrainians. I imagine this is already 
repaired. But again, the Russians keep bombing. They need our help to 
be able to help prepare and provide more equipment as this equipment is 
being destroyed by the Russians.
  Today, I was pleased to see that Secretary of State Antony Blinken 
announced an additional $53 million from the United States to support 
efforts to rebuild this Ukrainian energy grid that keeps getting 
destroyed by the Russians. This package will include distribution 
transformers, circuit breakers, surge arresters, disconnectors, 
vehicles, and other key equipment. It brings U.S. support for Ukraine's 
energy infrastructure since February up to about $145 million.
  But again, it is not just us, and it shouldn't just be us. Our allies 
need to step forward to help Ukraine in this difficult moment as well, 
and they are. Finland, as an example I just saw, will send energy 
equipment to Ukraine this week. The EU, the European Union, will give 
Ukraine 200 transformers and 40 heavy generators to support the energy 
sector. The EU has probably given more than anyone else. This critical 
aid is needed because, again, these attacks just continue and continue.
  The recent attacks in Kyiv, by the way, that we saw earlier when I 
was there 3 weeks ago, 300,000 Ukrainian citizens in Kyiv had lost 
power when we were there. I am told that there are currently about 
130,000 Kyiv residents losing power, without electricity.
  The Ukrainian military, again, has been making progress. They have 
had a huge success here in Kherson. This city of Kherson in Ukrainian 
was the first provincial and only provincial capital the Russians 
occupied and the first major city that they took. The Ukrainian 
military carefully and over time orchestrated a great victory there, 
and about 3 weeks ago, it was liberated.
  As this photo shows, Ukrainian citizens have welcomed these soldiers 
as heroes. You have probably seen some of this on TV news. They have 
just embraced these soldiers, and they put the Ukrainian flags back up 
in all the buildings. They have told these soldiers and others, 
including the investigators from the International Criminal Court, of 
the war crimes, the unthinkable war crimes that were committed by the 
Russian occupiers while they were there.
  So the Russians were forced out of Kherson because of very effective 
work by the Ukrainians, using the weapons that we and the Europeans 
have provided them, including longer range missiles, taking out their 
supplies, taking out their ability to resupply themselves.
  So what has happened now is that Russia, once they had left Kherson, 
has now started their bombing campaign, just nonstop bombing in the 
very city they occupied only a few weeks ago. So they are saying: If we 
can't have it, we are just going to bomb it into oblivion. Ukrainians 
are having now, after having lived through the occupation, to try to 
live through this bombing.
  I saw the Deputy Prime Minister of Ukraine recently urge civilians to 
leave Kherson and go to other parts of Ukraine this winter due to these 
Russian attacks. That is what has to be done. The soldiers will stay 
and they will fight, but the Russians are just constantly attacking 
Kherson.
  In this area--this oblast, it is called--that provincial area, 10 
people have recently been killed and 54 injured. The Russians shelled 
this provincial area 49 times on Thanksgiving day, 49 missiles and 
bombs on Thanksgiving day, hitting residential buildings, a shipyard, 
the school grounds, gas pipelines, everything.
  The Russian shelling hit a school that was being used as a 
distribution point for humanitarian aid in the Zaporizhzhia area, up 
here. So in Zaporizhzhia, they had a school that was handing out 
humanitarian assistance, and it was attacked by a Russian missile. It 
killed a social worker and injured two other people.
  You probably saw that also in eastern Ukraine recently, the Russians 
attacked a maternity hospital, and again they killed innocent 
civilians. They actually killed a newborn baby, a baby boy. They 
critically injured a doctor. The overnight explosion left a smalltown 
hospital there in total disrepair, just a crumble of bricks and 
scattered metal. There were medical supplies, by the way, strewn all 
over the streets. The newborn who was killed was only 2 days old--2 
days old--but he had a name, Serhii, and his death will not be 
forgotten in Ukraine.

[[Page S6864]]

  These are flagrant human rights abuses and war crimes. As a Zelenskyy 
Presidential adviser said, ``There is no military logic [here]: they 
just want to take revenge on the locals. This is a huge war crime.''
  I agree. Vladimir Putin is trying to bring Ukraine to its knees, but 
do you know what it is doing? It is only strengthening their resolve, 
the amazing resolve of the Ukrainian people.
  Russia is beginning to feel the negative impacts of this war more and 
more. The sanctions are beginning to bite more, and we should 
strengthen them even more, in my view. But it is having an impact. The 
Russian banking sector has been hit by this. The Russian central bank 
reported that a record $14.7 billion in hard currency was withdrawn 
from the Russian banking system last month, in October. People are 
taking their money and running. This was during the 300,000 troop 
mobilization of mostly untrained recruits.
  A November report by the central bank warned that Russia's GDP would 
face a sharper contraction of 7.1 percent in the fourth quarter of this 
year, after falling 4.1 percent and 4 percent compared with last year 
in the previous two quarters.
  So the economy is going the wrong way in Russia. Last week, the 
economy officially entered into a recession. So this war is having an 
impact on Russia, finally.
  The central bank chairwoman told the Russian lawmakers that next year 
the situation will get darker still. She said:

       We really need to look at the situation very soberly and 
     with our eyes open. Things may get worse, we understand that.

  I sure hope so. I sure hope so--that countries around the world see 
what is happening here and tighten these sanctions.
  For many Russian companies, the reality of war sank in with the 
latest desperate mobilization. This is according to the German 
Institute for International and Security Affairs. I think that is true.
  While there are a lot of Russians who still believe the propaganda 
and the disinformation from the Kremlin about Ukraine and, therefore, 
continue to fight innocent Ukrainians--their neighbors--other Russians 
now understand that this battle is not against an enemy; this battle is 
a failed ploy by Vladimir Putin to achieve his misguided ambitions to 
recreate the Russian Empire, the Russian Federation. That is what it is 
about. It is not about Ukraine.
  I want to take a moment to talk about the aid package that is being 
developed right now here on the floor to send to Ukraine to continue 
our help at this crucial moment and to make an important point, which 
is that oversight of our assistance to Ukraine is very important. It is 
important to me. It is important to my constituents. It is important to 
my colleagues. We need to be sure there are significant accountability 
measures in place. We have got to know where the aid is going. We need 
to know exactly where it is going and who is using it and how.
  No one is advocating that we give Ukraine a blank check; and, by the 
way, they have not gotten a blank check. There are spending safeguards 
in place already. President Zelenskyy agrees with that. He wants those 
kind of checks in the system because he knows that that transparency is 
critical to the continued aid--not just from us but from the 50 other 
countries around the world that are providing assistance or more.
  There is an accounting firm from the United States involved that 
follows all the aid to the government, as an example. Also, the World 
Bank sends a report about all the aid that goes to--the state aid, the 
government aid part, and they constantly audit that and report on that. 
So there are mechanisms in place already. Could they be strengthened? 
Probably so.
  With regard to military equipment, we have put in place unprecedented 
policies to be able to have what is called end-use monitoring of the 
military weapons that are going to Ukraine. I visited with the 101st 
Airborne in Poland a few weeks ago and talked a lot about how that end-
use monitoring is going. We finally have a military attache in country 
and some people who can help follow where these various weapons are 
going. And, honestly, so far, so good.
  I have to tell you, I am surprised by this, but there has been 
absolutely no documented instance yet of diversion of U.S.-supplied 
weapons--to Russia, to Belarus, to third parties. Now, that may happen 
in the future, but this end-use monitoring is carefully ensuring that 
you get the serial number and you find out where the thing is going and 
you check on it. And I think that is very important, and my colleagues 
need to know that. This is something that the Ukrainian Government 
wants to do. And they should want to do it, and our military certainly 
wants to do it.
  The Ukrainian Government has been transparent in terms of the funding 
because it is in their interest. It is in all of our interest. They 
hear questions about oversight coming from Members of Congress, and 
they understand the need to provide the accountability. So we need to 
continue the assistance at this crucial time, as we have said tonight, 
but we need to be sure it continues to be accountable.
  You know, Vladimir Putin, when he decided to initiate this invasion, 
which so many people around the world thought he would never do because 
it made no sense; there was no logic behind it. But when he did this, 
he thought it would be a walk in the park. He thought the Russian Army 
would roll in and the Ukrainians would roll over.
  It turned out to be a walk through Hell for his army and his 
government. Why? Because the Ukrainian people showed grit and 
determination and the military fought more effectively than anybody 
expected. It is because Ukraine's morale and leadership has not 
faltered, even against overwhelming odds, a much larger military, and 
many more missiles. They have not faltered.
  I have seen this mindset in Ukraine on my visits there. I think I 
have been there 8 or 10 times since 2014. It goes from President 
Zelenskyy all the way down to the soldiers we saw in the trenches, to 
the civilians who are doing their part.
  The Wall Street Journal recently reported that during the Russian 
occupation of Kherson, the area we talked about earlier, the 68-year-
old head doctor at the hospital there in Kherson refused to bow down to 
the Russian invaders, setting a tone for citywide resistance. He told 
the invaders: ``You can shoot me if you want,'' but I am not going to 
do what you want. I have a responsibility to this hospital, and I am 
going to carry it out for the citizens of Kherson.

  Other Ukrainian workers at the hospital were just as heroic and 
clever. The Journal reports that their resistance lasted 8 months. They 
faked a COVID outbreak to keep Russians from stealing their equipment, 
coming into the hospital and taking equipment. They spied for Ukrainian 
forces.
  The fighting spirit of the Ukrainians should come as no surprise. 
They are a proud, patriotic, and tough people. For perhaps one of the 
best illustrations of this courage, I am reminded of the grandmother 
who gave sunflower seeds to invading Russian soldiers way back in 
February when they first started coming in. She gave them the 
sunflowers and said: Give these to somebody to plant at your burial 
place because you are going to die for invading our country and you 
might want to have something beautiful being grown at your gravesite.
  That was a brave Ukrainian grandmother. I remember the photograph of 
a woman about 5 feet tall telling this to a Russian soldier a foot or 
so taller.
  And who can blame the patriotic defiance that they have shown. Today, 
half of Ukraine's energy infrastructure is gone. Kyiv is operating on 
scheduled blackouts that last 4 hours. This is the capital. Civilians 
are being killed every day. Ukraine's economy continues to suffer 
catastrophic consequences. War crimes continue to be revealed day after 
day.
  The actions by the Kremlin to knowingly destroy and attack civilian 
areas and kill innocent Ukrainians, of course, are meant to dampen 
Ukrainians' resolve, but, instead, these actions encourage fortitude 
among the ranks of Ukraine's freedom fighters against the barbaric 
enemy that has invaded their homeland. That is how they feel.
  When I have come down to the floor each week to discuss the status of 
this

[[Page S6865]]

war on Ukraine's land, I have pointed out that this is where the battle 
is occurring for freedom over tyranny, of democracy over 
authoritarianism. This is where it is being waged here, in our 
generation, now. This is why we need to stand up and be counted.
  If we don't join allies throughout the world in condemning it and 
helping Ukraine defend itself, what happens? Well, the world becomes a 
much more dangerous and volatile place. Trust me, people are watching--
our enemies and our adversaries. Iran is watching. China is watching. 
Others are watching.
  This is not the time for the United States and the allies around the 
world--more than 50 of them who have provided military assistance--to 
pull back. At a meeting in Romania today, the NATO Secretary General 
reaffirmed that NATO's door to membership remains open to Ukraine. It 
has been open since 2008.
  I found this to be very welcome news, something I have called for, 
for years. I don't think Russia would be in Ukraine if it had happened.
  Ukraine is making gains on the battlefield, as I said. Russian forces 
and equipment are being destroyed and depleted. Russian war crimes 
continue to be committed as they punish Ukrainian civilians, and the 
Russian people are beginning to feel the negative effects of this 
failed war.
  I think, frankly, that Vladimir Putin believes his supply of missiles 
will outlast the patience of the free world. I think that is what he 
believes. That is why he continues this senseless war. I think he 
believes he will continue to be able to have enough missiles to outlast 
the patience of the Western World, of us, the freedom-loving people.
  I don't think that is accurate, but we need to prove him wrong. We 
need to keep the pressure up to end with a resolution to this 
senseless, brutal war. I believe, with the help of the United States 
and our allies, democracy can and will prevail over tyranny and 
authoritarianism. And that, of course, would send the right message 
echoed across the world, a message that tyranny and authoritarianism 
must not triumph.
  I yield the floor.

                          ____________________