[Congressional Record Volume 167, Number 35 (Wednesday, February 24, 2021)]
[Senate]
[Pages S847-S848]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
Reopening Schools
Mrs. BLACKBURN. Madam President, I know that some of my colleagues
have been talking about schools, getting children back to school,
getting schools reopened. Indeed, in Tennessee, that is a topic that
has received a good bit of conversation. All but two of our school
systems have been open and working this entire school year, and those
other two systems have recently reopened since the first of the year.
Our school superintendents, our directors of school, our parents, our
teachers, and the students have all worked together as a team--a solid,
cohesive team--to make this happen.
I think there are two main points that we have seen, and as we are
holding meetings with our county elected officials and city officials
and as they talk about the efforts that they have made in getting
children back into the classroom, we hear a lot about one point. That
is that our Governor, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee, made it clear that
the school districts would be responsible for the ``how'' they were
going to open and the ``when'' they would be reopening. I really thank
him for listening and recognizing that local officials and individuals
in the community really do know what is best for their school districts
and their students.
The second point is that these plans didn't just drop out of the sky.
As I said, this has been a team effort in our communities, and it has
happened because there was this agreement between the administrators
and the parents and the teachers that they were going to make decisions
that were going to be best for the children. So when you look at
Tennessee and how they have approached this--indeed, the schools
reopening and how they proceeded--it was done with the children in
mind.
Last week, I had the privilege of speaking with school administrators
from West Tennessee, who played a part in developing their own
reopening plans. I cannot adequately describe to you with the time that
we have on the floor today the amount of work and the thoughtfulness
that they put into these schedules, from health and safety
considerations, to scheduling changes, to the complicated logistics of
social distancing and cramped classrooms. They thought it all through
by walking through the day and listening to what teachers and parents
had to say as to how they would walk through this day.
They took the millions of dollars in CARES Act funding that the area
received, and what did they do with that money? They invested in the
best possible plan for these kids--no Federal mandate or sweeping
litmus test required. They said: We are going to do what is right by
these children.
Then, of course, they turned on the TV, and they saw that the Biden
administration was busy walking back their own enthusiastic scientific
guidance on safely reopening schools--walking it back--and they didn't
have to flip too many channels to figure out why. Powerful teachers
unions had taken their own stands in refusing to make a plan, in
refusing to think things through, and in some cases in refusing to go
to work at all--not doing what is best for the children but doing what
was going to serve their interests first and, in their opinions, what
would best serve their interests. That, I think, they will see were
regrettable actions.
Educators in Tennessee were not just confused by what they saw; they
were insulted because they knew exactly what was happening. On January
26, CDC officials released a study showing that, if we were careful,
safe reopening was indeed possible. Administration officials touted
that report as a light at the end of a very long COVID pandemic, but
now, just a few weeks later, those same officials are defying their own
experts, insisting that safe reopening can only happen if Congress
approves additional funding contained in the Democrats' latest,
untargeted spending bill.
Students in this country are suffering. They are lonely, they are
bored, and many of them are struggling with clinical depression and
anxiety. Teen pregnancy, teen alcohol, and suicide rates are rising.
Children need to be in in-person school.
The American Academy of Pediatrics has repeatedly stated--bear in
mind, this isn't something that I am saying; it isn't something that is
partisan; it is the American Academy of Pediatrics--that it is not only
feasible but necessary for students to be back in school, back in the
classroom, back to seeing their friends, back to participating in
extracurricular activities and sports.
I would ask my colleagues across the aisle to keep this in mind when
they hear from so-called stakeholders who are willing to hold a child's
mental health hostage in exchange for a political win that will serve
their power and their purposes and not that of the child's. They might
have powerful voices in the cable news circuit, but those sound bites
will provide you no cover back home with the teachers and
administrators who have rolled up their sleeves, have gotten to work,
and have figured out a way to get schools open for the children.
I yield the floor
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Montana.
Mr. DAINES. Madam President, outrage--that is what American families
should be feeling right now, and many are. We are seeing President
Biden and the Democrats support opening the border, the southern
border, for illegal immigrants while bowing to political pressure and
keeping many of our Nation's schools closed for our students--opening
the southern border for illegal immigrants, closing our Nation's
schools for our students.
Schools across the Nation remain closed to in-person instruction
largely due to teachers unions and their influence on many of our local
and Federal leaders on the other side of the aisle--all, unfortunately,
to the detriment of the education and the health of our students.
In States and localities where schools remain closed, America's
youngest and brightest minds are posed with challenges that generations
before have never dealt with. Children are continuing to cope with the
unprecedented hardship of virtual classrooms, a lack of social
interaction with their peers, and other impediments to their education.
But this isn't because of the pandemic itself; it is because President
Biden, the Democrats, and local leaders have caved to the political
pressures of teachers unions and have kept many classrooms closed and
students at home despite what the available science and other experts
are telling us. The science is clear: Schools are not major COVID-19
spreading grounds, and younger students are a low-risk group. Studies
indicate that students across the country are months behind where they
should be academically.
The hardships our students face go beyond academics because the
mental and physical health of children has also taken a toll. We are
seeing depression and anxiety rates skyrocket among our young people. I
was on a call today, a Zoom call, with several elementary school
principals in Montana, hearing their firsthand, frankly, tragic
accounts of what is happening with the mental health of our students in
elementary school and hearing about elementary school students
assaulting teachers. A whole year without full-time, in-person learning
has done irreparable damage. The status quo is truly devastating to
many of our students. Despite this--despite the science, despite the
overwhelming data--schools across the country, in many parts of our
country, remain closed.
Frankly, it is unacceptable that many of my colleagues across the
aisle and the Biden administration are standing by while this happens
to our students across our country. They have chosen to play politics
with our Nation's students instead of ensuring that
[[Page S848]]
our children are getting the very best education possible, which is
full-time, in-person instruction. They are intent on jamming through
this partisan $1.9 trillion COVID package, which does include billions
of dollars for schools.
Incidentally, in working together, we have passed five bipartisan
COVID relief packages. Yes, it is harder to work in a bipartisan
fashion, but that is why we were sent back here to Washington--to work
together. Yet President Biden and the Democrats are saying: We are
going to do this one alone. It is going to be their way or the highway.
The sad reality is, the more the American people hear what is in this
$1.9 trillion package, the more they are not going to like it. Most of
the money in this package is not to be spent now. In fact, 95 percent
of it will be spent over the next 7 years, after the crisis. We should
not use this COVID crisis as a liberal wish list of items here wherein
95 percent of it gets spent in the out-years. How does this help our
students and our schools now? The answer is, it doesn't.
This is not how we solve the problems that our students are facing.
Fortunately, there is a pretty simple solution. It is this: Listen to
the experts. Listen to the science. Reopen our schools, and let's get
our students back in the classroom.
I yield the floor.
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Texas.