[Congressional Record Volume 160, Number 38 (Thursday, March 6, 2014)]
[Senate]
[Pages S1360-S1362]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
DEAMONTE DRIVER'S PASSING
Mr. CARDIN. Mr. President, today I rise to mark the seventh
anniversary of Deamonte Driver's death.
Deamonte Driver was a 12-year-old child who lived in Prince George's
County, MD, whose border sits only a few miles from the U.S. Capitol
Building. He died 7 years ago at the Children's National Medical Center
in Washington, DC, from a brain infection caused by an untreated tooth
abscess.
The Driver family, like many other families across the country,
lacked dental insurance. At one time, the Drivers were covered by the
Medicaid Program, but they lost that coverage when they moved into a
shelter and their paperwork fell through the cracks. When advocates for
the family tried to help the Drivers locate a dentist to treat
Deamonte's cavities and tooth pain, it took more than 20 calls to find
a dentist who would see him.
Around mid-January in 2007, Deamonte began to complain of severe
headaches. A subsequent evaluation at Children's Hospital led beyond
the basic dental care that the family had anticipated to emergency
brain surgery. Deamonte later experienced seizures, and a second
operation was required. After additional treatment and
[[Page S1361]]
therapy, Deamonte appeared to be recovering, but medical intervention
had come too late. By the end of his treatment, the total cost to our
health care system exceeded one-quarter of a million dollars--more than
3,000 times the $80 cost of a tooth extraction.
Deamonte Driver passed away on Sunday, February 25, 2007. This
child's death was a national tragedy because it could have been
prevented had he received timely and proper basic dental care. It was a
tragedy because it happened right here in the United States, in a State
that is one of the most affluent in the Nation. It happened in the
State that is home to the first and one of the best dental schools in
the Nation, the University of Maryland's dental school. It happened in
Prince George's County, whose border is less than 6 miles from where we
are standing in the U.S. Capitol.
I have spoken on the Senate floor about Deamonte Driver several times
since his death, and in the intervening years, both in Maryland and
nationally, we have made tremendous progress. When Deamonte's story was
brought to light, I believe it was a wakeup call for our Nation. It
brought home the statement of former Surgeon General C. Everett Koop:
``There is no health without oral health.''
Medical research reinforces Dr. Koop's words. Scientists have
discovered the nexus between tooth plaque and heart disease, that
chewing stimulates brain cell growth, and that gum disease can signal
diabetes, liver ailments, and hormone imbalances. They have identified
the vital connection between oral health research and advanced
treatments like gene therapy, which can help patients with chronic
renal failure. They have found that investing in basic dental care for
children and adults can reduce health care expenditures down the road
for costly medical interventions related to other diseases.
But for all their research findings, we also know that without
insurance coverage and adequate access to providers, the needs of
millions of children and adults will remain unmet, and the
complications resulting from poor oral health will persist.
That is why the progress we have made over the past 7 years is so
important to America's health. I have come to the floor today to talk
about what has been achieved and how we can move forward as a nation to
ensure even greater access to oral health care.
Since Deamonte's passing, the State of Maryland has emerged as a
national leader in oral health--launching a $1.2 million oral health
literacy campaign, raising Medicaid reimbursement rates for dentists in
the program, and providing allied health professionals and hygienists
the opportunity to practice outside clinics. The Deamonte Driver Dental
Project Van, which was dedicated in front of the U.S. Capitol in May
2010, provides care in underserved neighborhoods in Prince George's
County, thanks to efforts conceived and launched by members of the
Robert T. Freeman Dental Society. An arm of the National Dental
Association, the society is named for Dr. Robert Tanner Freeman, who in
1869 became the first Black graduate of the Harvard School of Dental
Medicine.
It was 2 years after Deamonte's death, in 2009, that Congress
reauthorized the Children's Health Insurance Program. Some of my
colleagues recalled the difficulty that Deamonte's mother had finding
him care. Hers was not an isolated instance. For varied reasons, it is
difficult for Medicaid and CHIP enrollees to find dental providers, and
working parents whose children qualify for those programs are likely to
be employed at jobs where they can't afford to spend 2 hours a day on
the phone searching for a provider. So part of the CHIP Reauthorization
Act requires HHS to include on its Insure Kids Now Web site a list of
participating dentists and benefit information for all 50 States and
the District of Columbia.
Also in 2009, Congress passed the Edward M. Kennedy Serve America
Act, which created the Healthy Futures Corps--a program that provides
grants to States and nonprofit organizations so they can fund national
service in low-income communities. The law's goal was to put into
action key tools that can help close the gaps in health status--
prevention and health promotion. With the help of Senator Mikulski, we
added language to that law specifying oral health as an area of focus.
Now, the Healthy Futures Corps is recruiting young people to work in
the dental profession, where severe shortages of providers exist in
many urban and rural communities. The law is funding the work of
individuals who can help parents find oral health care for themselves
and their children. It is making a difference in the lives of the
Healthy Futures Corps members who work in underserved communities and
in the lives and health of those who can now get care.
Then in 2010, Congress passed the Affordable Care Act, which
guarantees pediatric dental coverage as part of each State's Essential
Benefits health care package. The ACA also established an oral health
care prevention education campaign at the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention, which is targeted toward key populations, including
children and pregnant women, and it created demonstration programs to
encourage innovation in oral health delivery. The law also
significantly expanded workforce training programs for oral health
professionals.
Moving forward, the States have a critical role to play in ensuring
that the ACA benefit is designed to incentivize prevention, recognize
that some children have greater risk of dental disease than others, and
deliver care based on their level of risk.
Among the most cost-effective ways to improve children's dental
health are investments in prevention. Dental sealants, clear plastic
coatings applied to the chewing surface of molars, have been proven to
prevent 60 percent of tooth decay at one-third the cost of filling a
cavity. So it is essential that prevention be part of every State's
benefit package.
Further, in 2010, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
launched its Oral Health Initiative, based on a bill I introduced with
Senator Susan Collins. The initiative establishes a coordinated
multiagency effort to improve access to care across the Nation.
One of the most effective organizations in tracking access to care is
the Pew Children's Dental Campaign, which produces report cards that
grade the States on eight policies that are evidence-based solutions to
the problem of tooth decay. In 2011, Maryland received an ``A'' grade
in both reports for meeting or exceeding these benchmarks, which
include dental sealant programs, community water fluoridation, Medicaid
reimbursement and enrollment, and collection of data on children's
dental health. Maryland's grade is significant because in the late
1990s, my State had one of the worst records in the Nation with respect
to oral health care for its underserved population. Now it is one of
the top-ranked States for oral health care.
Our State has just received even more good news. The number of
children in Maryland with untreated tooth decay dropped 41 percent from
2001 to 2011, and the overall oral health status of Maryland children
has dramatically improved, according to a 2014 report conducted by the
University of Maryland's School of Dentistry. The State assessment
looked at 1,723 students in 52 schools from the five regions of the
State. About 33 percent of the children had at least one dental sealant
on their permanent first molars, and this milestone exceeded Federal
goals by 5 percent. About 14 percent of students had untreated dental
caries, a drop from 23 percent in 2000, and the State's achievement
exceeded Federal goals by 12 percent. According to the assessment, 75
percent of the children surveyed had a regular dentist.
Another key player in our State's effort is the Baltimore Oral Health
Impact Project, which provides care to children in Baltimore's public
schools. Since February 2010, its providers have seen more than 3,500
children and treated more than 1,500 for dental disease. The program
places a high value on delivering comprehensive and compassionate oral
health care.
This organization has also launched the Baltimore Oral Health
Academy, offering scholarships to students who choose to pursue careers
as a clinical dental professional including dental assistants and
hygienists, and who agree to serve in a public health setting.
Nationally, HRSA's National Health Service Corps addresses the
nationwide shortage of primary care oral health
[[Page S1362]]
providers in dental health professional shortage areas--HPSA--by
offering incentives in the form of scholarships and loan repayments to
primary care dentists and registered dental hygienists to practice in
underserved communities. The Corps has awarded more than 1,100 new loan
repayment awards to dentists and nearly 300 new loan repayment awards
to registered dental hygienists. But this is not nearly enough to erase
the shortages. The NHSC has also implemented a part-time service
program for providers who did not wish to make a full-time commitment,
and I am hopeful that this new option will increase participation in
the coming years.
Our Nation has made significant progress in improving children's
dental health in the 7 years since Deamonte died, but there is still
much work to be done. The access problem in some communities has become
so severe that many people are forced to seek treatment for tooth pain
in the Nation's emergency rooms, increasing the overall cost of care
and receiving uncoordinated care in the least cost-efficient setting.
In fact, more people seek treatment in emergency rooms for tooth pain
than they do for asthma.
I will continue to work to increase funding for grants to States and
expand training opportunities for dentists. We do not have enough
professionals who are trained and available to treat children and
adults with dental problems, and it is our responsibility to fix that.
We must improve public reimbursement to dental providers in offices and
clinics so that no one who needs treatment will be turned away.
Soon, Congress will turn again to the Reauthorization of the CHIP
program, and I will be once again fighting for the strongest possible
language we can get to promote children's oral health. For my
colleagues who may not be familiar with CHIP's track record on oral
health, I would like to leave you with three facts:
First, tooth decay is the single most common chronic disease of
childhood, and it is five times more common than asthma. The
complications of dental disease, which we now know can be fatal, are
completely and easily preventable if we give children the care they
need. Second, because of Congress's passage of the 2009 Children's
Health Insurance Program Reauthorization Act, in 2013, more than 8
million American children had comprehensive dental coverage through
CHIP. Third, CHIP has kept comprehensive coverage affordable. Under
CHIP, families cannot pay more than 5 percent of their annual income in
out-of-pocket costs for their children's medical and dental care.
What we have been able to achieve for children is due to support in
Congress and also to the efforts of the many nonprofit organizations,
universities, and providers who are also working across the Nation to
make sure that we will never forget Deamonte and never forget our
responsibility to improving oral health care for America's children.
On this sad anniversary, in Maryland and throughout the Nation there
are signs of hope for the future of oral health care. I thank my
colleagues for the role they have played in this process and look
forward to working with them in the months to come to strengthen oral
health care access for our Nation's children.
____________________