[Congressional Record Volume 157, Number 51 (Friday, April 8, 2011)]
[Senate]
[Pages S2360-S2361]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]




                         SUBMITTED RESOLUTIONS

                                 ______
                                 

  SENATE RESOLUTION 138--CALLING ON THE UNITED NATIONS TO RESCIND THE 
                GOLDSTONE REPORT, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES

  Mrs. GILLIBRAND (for herself and Mr. Risch) submitted the following 
resolution; which was referred to the Committee on Foreign Relations:

                              S. Res. 138

       Whereas, on January 12, 2009, the United Nations Human 
     Rights Council passed Resolution S-9/1, authorizing a ``fact-
     finding mission'' regarding the conduct of the Government of 
     Israel during Operation Cast Lead between December 27, 2008, 
     and January 18, 2009;
       Whereas that resolution prejudged the outcome of the fact 
     finding mission by mandating that it investigate ``violations 
     of international human rights law and international 
     humanitarian law by the occupying power, Israel, against the 
     Palestinian people'';
       Whereas, on September 15, 2009, the ``United Nations Fact 
     Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict'' released its report, 
     now known as the ``Goldstone report'', named for its chair, 
     South African Jurist Richard Goldstone;
       Whereas the report made numerous unsubstantiated assertions 
     against Israel, in particular accusing the Government of 
     Israel of committing war crimes by deliberately targeting 
     civilians during its operations in Gaza;
       Whereas the report downplayed the overwhelming evidence 
     that Hamas deliberately used Palestinian civilians and 
     civilian institutions as human shields against Israel and 
     deliberately targeted Israeli civilians with rocket fire for 
     over eight years prior to the operation;
       Whereas the United Nations Human Rights Council voted to 
     welcome the report, to endorse its recommendations, and to 
     condemn Israel without mentioning Hamas;
       Whereas, as a result of the report, the United Nations 
     General Assembly has passed

[[Page S2361]]

     two resolutions endorsing the report's findings, the United 
     Nations Secretary-General has been requested to submit 
     several reports on implementation of its recommendations, and 
     the Human Rights Council is scheduled to follow up on 
     implementation of the report during future sessions;
       Whereas the findings of the Goldstone report and the 
     subsequent and continued United Nations member state actions 
     following up on those findings have caused and continue to 
     cause extensive harm to Israel's standing in the world and 
     could potentially create legal problems for Israel and its 
     leaders;
       Whereas Justice Richard Goldstone publicly retracted the 
     central claims of the report he authored in an op-ed in The 
     Washington Post on April 2, 2011;
       Whereas Justice Goldstone wrote in that article that if he 
     ``had known then what I know now, the Goldstone Report would 
     have been a different document'';
       Whereas Justice Goldstone concluded that, contrary to his 
     report's findings, the Government of Israel did not 
     intentionally target civilians in the Gaza Strip as a matter 
     of policy;
       Whereas, in contrast, Justice Goldstone states that the 
     crimes committed by Hamas were clearly intentional, were 
     targeted at civilians, and constitute a violation of 
     international law;
       Whereas Justice Goldstone also conceded that the number of 
     civilian casualties in Gaza was far smaller than the report 
     alleged;
       Whereas Justice Goldstone admitted that Israel investigated 
     the findings in the report, while expressing disappointment 
     that Hamas has not taken any steps to look into the report's 
     findings; and
       Whereas Justice Goldstone concluded that ``Israel, like any 
     other sovereign nation, has the right and obligation to 
     defend itself and its citizens'': Now, therefore, be it
       Resolved, That the Senate--
       (1) calls on the United Nations Human Rights Council 
     members to reflect the author's repudiation of the Goldstone 
     report's central findings, rescind the report, and reconsider 
     further Council actions with respect to the report's 
     findings;
       (2) urges United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon to 
     work with United Nations member states to reform the United 
     Nations Human Rights Council so that it no longer unfairly, 
     disproportionately, and falsely criticizes Israel on a 
     regular basis;
       (3) requests Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon to do all in his 
     power to redress the damage to Israel's reputation caused by 
     the Goldstone report;
       (4) asks the Secretary-General to do all he can to urge 
     member states to prevent any further United Nations action on 
     the report's findings; and
       (5) urges the United States to take a leadership role in 
     getting the United Nations and its bodies to prevent any 
     further action on the report's findings and limit the damage 
     that this libelous report has caused to our close ally Israel 
     and to the reputation of the United Nations.

                          ____________________