[Congressional Record Volume 151, Number 119 (Wednesday, September 21, 2005)]
[House]
[Pages H8229-H8233]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
U.S.-ISRAEL RELATIONS
The SPEAKER pro tempore (Mr. Sodrel). Under the Speaker's announced
policy of January 4, 2005, the gentlewoman from North Carolina (Ms.
Foxx) is recognized for 60 minutes as the designee of the majority
leader.
Ms. FOXX. Mr. Speaker, I think I will be joined by some colleagues
shortly, I hope.
Congress recently returned to Washington following a busy month of
work in the district. For a majority of August, I traveled throughout
North Carolina's 5th District and conducted scores of meetings with
veterans, teachers, and many other constituent groups.
During this time, I gained valuable insight into the needs of the
people I serve and look forward to continuing to address their
concerns. The needs of my home district have always been and continue
to be my number one priority.
However, as a Member of Congress, it is my duty to educate myself on
internal affairs and foreign policy, especially when it pertains to the
Middle East. While our foreign neighbors may be far away from northwest
North Carolina, our relationships with them affect everyone.
For 1 week in August, I was fortunate to have the opportunity to
travel to Israel with several colleagues. This educational trip gave me
the opportunity to witness how America's national security interests
are directly tied to developments in the Middle East, and specifically
to Israel's own security.
Strategic cooperation between our country and Israel, in
intelligence-sharing, fighting the war on terror, strengthening
homeland security, promoting democracy, and increasing technology
development is vital to the well-being of my constituents and, indeed,
all Americans.
For most of the 1,500 years before the Roman destruction of Jerusalem
in AD 70, the land of Israel was the independent home of the Jewish
people. Since then, it has been occupied by many powers, from the
Romans to conquering Arab armies to the Ottomans to the British.
Despite these periods of foreign occupation, there has always been a
continuous Jewish presence, and the land of Israel remained the focal
point for the Jewish people.
The United States and Israel have long maintained a strong friendship
since the modern Jewish state was founded in 1948. In fact, we were the
very first Nation to recognize Israel, just 11 minutes after its
founding.
Our two countries share much more in common than many realize. We
believe in freedom and equality and share many basic rights, such as
free elections, a free press, and freedom of religion. We were both
founded by people seeking freedom from tyranny, and we both continue to
serve today as symbols of liberty in a world plagued by oppression.
Mr. Speaker, I would like now to recognize my colleague, the
gentleman from Texas (Mr. Marchant), who has joined me and allow him to
share some of his perspectives on this trip that we took in August, and
then I will come back to the podium and speak some more.
Mr. MARCHANT. Mr. Speaker, last month I was fortunate as a Member of
Congress to travel to Israel and witness firsthand the peace process
that is currently taking place.
{time} 1900
The trip was a unique opportunity to learn more about relations
between the United States and Israel. This country has maintained a
longstanding friendship with the Jewish state since its creation in
1948. Today, cooperation between the U.S. and Israel is essential as we
fight the war on terror and promote peace in the Middle East. Israel
is, has been, and will continue to be an important ally in the goal to
spread democracy worldwide and promote peace in the Middle East.
I was privileged to have the opportunity to meet with many high-
ranking officials from the region, including Israeli Prime Minister
Ariel Sharon, as well as Former Prime Minister BiBi Netanyahu and Vice
Prime Minister Shimon Peres. Talking with these leaders provided me
with valuable insight into the ongoing peace process and plans for the
region. While their approaches are different, their common goal remains
the same: peace and fulfillment of the Jewish homeland.
[[Page H8230]]
On the final day I met with Mahmoud Abbas, Chairman of the
Palestinian Authority. I, along with my colleagues, stressed with him
how important it was to the United States that the terrorists be
disarmed and that peace be advanced within the region.
Mr. Speaker, my rigorous schedule included an extensive tour of this
country. Although Israel is smaller than the State of New Jersey, I was
thoroughly impressed with its infrastructure and potential for growth.
In just over 50 years of existence, Israel has developed a remarkable
highway system and infrastructure. As we visited universities, holy
sites, military bases, it was easy to tell how modern and highly
accomplished Israel is today and what an incredible potential that it
has with its people.
Throughout the country's history, the Israeli people have experienced
violence and terror on their home soil. Normal citizens' lives have
been threatened in schools, malls, and other public places at the hands
of suicide bombers. Israel, though, is committed to combating terrorism
and to world peace.
During my trip I was able to attend various briefings and got to see
the security fence that separates Israel from Palestine and other tools
that have been effectively used by Israelis to deter the terrorist
attacks.
I traveled also to the developing Negev Desert area. This region has
experienced a surge in development and opportunities with its diverse
residents. The community is composed of Israelis, Arabs, and Bedouins.
Its growing strength is vital to Israel's national security interests
as well as an excellent place for new settlement. The United States
needs to play a key role in the assistance of the development of this
desert area.
This trip was also especially important because it took place in the
midst of the disengagement of Gaza and the northern part of the West
Bank. I was one of the few Americans to be able to visit Israel during
this very historic time. Over 8,000 Israelis were relocated from the
Gaza Strip.
The courageous decision to withdraw from Gaza carries serious risks
for Israel. It proves the willingness of the Jewish state to take
enormous chances for peace. Withdrawal provides Palestinian leadership
the opportunity to curb terrorism and govern its people. Prime Minister
Sharon explained that he believed the painstaking process is the best
long-term decision for Israel. Only time will tell whether Gaza will
become a catalyst for peace or the new headquarters of terrorism.
Now more than ever, Israel needs America's support. Israel's
commitment to peace is vital in this time of war and oppression in the
Middle East. As America continues with its mission to spread freedom
and democracy, the Israeli people have to be, and will be, our very
important allies. They deserve our respect and our cooperation.
Ms. FOXX. Mr. Speaker, we had a distinguished group with us on our
trip, and I am very privileged to recognize the gentleman from Utah
(Mr. Bishop) who is going to share some of his observations of the trip
with us now.
Mr. BISHOP of Utah. Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the gentlewoman from
North Carolina (Ms. Foxx) giving me this opportunity of sharing a few
of the experiences that I had while visiting Israel with the
distinguished group this past summer.
I think there are four impressions that I will always take back from
my short trip to Israel. The first one is how wonderful it was to be in
a place where you saw a specific pro-American attitude from everyone,
from the leaders of the country down to the people on the street, with
whom you spoke.
Secondly, I have to admit that even though I was in Israel, I felt
like I was back in Utah because the topography is very similar. The
mountains of Judea, I was right on the Wasatch Front again. Going to
the desert was like going to Price, to Moab back in Utah. Whereas in
Israel they have the Sea of Galilee that empties into the Jordan River
and empties into a Dead Sea, the saltiest sea in the world, in my home
State we have Utah Lake which empties into the Jordan River which
empties into the saltiest sea in this hemisphere, the Great Salt Lake.
So I was back home.
Third, and perhaps for me most important, the ability of buying Dr.
Pepper on the market in Jerusalem told me that I was in a country that
was purely cultured and progressive, and I was extremely grateful for
that.
Finally, I was truly impressed by the size. I think one of the things
that we Americans do not realize so fully is how our size has always
been a defense. Perhaps as somebody from the West, I recognize that as
well, when my county is the size of Rhode Island. Sometime we take size
for granted. It is part of our mentality.
But it is very clear in this country where you can go in a matter of
hours from the mountains of the Golan down to the desert in Negev, that
is not a large area. In fact, it takes me longer to drive from one end
of my district to the other end than it does to go through the country
of Israel.
When I realized, as you were looking out at the horizon, you will see
one mountain top that is Palestinian and the next mountain top is
Israeli. And how close they are. We understand that security becomes
the major concern of this people. And once again we have kind of a
cavalier attitude in the United States about how important security is
to those people who live in this particular area. We also understand it
is very clear that if there is ever going to be a lasting peace between
the Palestinians and Israelis, if there is ever going to be a permanent
government between the Palestinians and Israelis in this area of the
world, then terrorism has to stop, and that has to be the first and
foremost priority.
I think it is wonderful that we have this chance of exchanging ideas
and changing institutions. I just gave a speech on this floor a few
moments ago about the importance of foreign exchange students and
having exchange students understanding American life. Taking it back
becomes one of those things that will help us in the future in foreign
affairs. I think this is the same way.
There is much that we can learn about the experience of Israel. As we
are going through the issues of border security in the United States,
there is much that we can learn from how the Israelis have handled that
particular situation, much we can learn as far as technology that may
be one of those things that can help us in the future.
I was also feeling especially important to be there, as some have
mentioned, I think others will as well, to be there at the time of
pullout from the Gaza Strip. Nothing, I think, that could ever happen
has shown the commitment on the part of the Israeli Government to peace
more than that. And everything happened with an ability of doing things
in a peaceful and successful way. It showed that even though there was
some protest, it was an orderly disengagement. Even though it may be
strategic, it was still nonetheless a gamble on the part of the
Israelis. It clearly illustrated that the ball is now in the court of
the Palestinians and the Egyptians.
I am very pleased that the Egyptians seemed to have moved up and
stepped up to take their position in the patrolling of the Philadelphia
Corridor. And the amount of troops they have moved in there, though it
is still under 1,000, it still is a significant presence. I hope that
signals something that will be positive in the future.
It is also significant that the Palestinians have to make a positive
response in the future to this particular situation. If they do not, if
they simply say that permitting foreign civil war from taking place is
sufficient, then they deserve the criticism of the world, for there
will be no room for equivocation. Abbas has a choice in here of being a
true hero of the future and moving the peace process forward or being a
catalyst for the means of world chaos.
I was happy that before I went I also had the opportunity of reading
a history of the Six Day War. Once again we sometimes have illusions
and misconceptions as Americans. One of the misconceptions is the
Israeli Army and the Israeli defense forces are impregnable, they are
impenetrable, and they will always win in every situation.
Learning the details of the Six Day War and the places that we looked
at when I actually got there, I realized that the victory of the
Israelis in the Six Day War had as much to do with luck as it had to do
with military ability. There were decisions that were
[[Page H8231]]
made on both sides in that particular war, which if they had gone the
other way, would have had an entirely different outcome.
That also illustrated one more time how the Israeli situation is
indeed tenuous. We cannot place any blame on the Israelis for being so
concerned about their security in a land where an enemy sworn against
them is so close and has so many terrorist activities, killing over
1,000 people in the last 5 years. With those images coming back there,
I am proud to be able to see the people who, perhaps even better than
we do, understand the second amendment rights. And we need to fear the
bad guys with guns, not necessarily the good guys with guns and people
who are doing so much on their own for being responsible for their
security and their future.
It was a very positive experience. I think there is much to learn
from the good and the determination of our good friends in the State of
Israel. It was an enjoyable trip. I appreciate the opportunity of being
able to have enjoyed it with my good friend from North Carolina.
Ms. FOXX. Mr. Speaker, I thank the gentleman.
We all know that it is important to have people from very different
perspectives serving in the Congress, and I think that the points of
view that will be presented here sound very similar, but also each one
of us has our unique perspectives on what stayed with us as a result.
One of the people who was with us on our trip was our distinguished
deputy whip, the gentleman from Virginia (Mr. Cantor), and I would like
to ask the gentleman to share some of his views now.
Mr. CANTOR. Mr. Speaker, I thank the gentlewoman for organizing
tonight's Special Order. I congratulate her on her outstanding
leadership and her participation in the trip that we all were on.
I have been to Israel many times. I went on this trip, and this
particular trip was special, like most others, because there is always
something going on with the people of that land and their neighbors.
And there is a constant quest for peace and one that, unfortunately,
has not come to pass in the half a century or so that that country has
existed.
One thing that strikes me always and struck me this summer was that
Israel remains a beacon of freedom, remains our only democratic ally in
the Middle East, and is proof of the survival of a people that have
engaged in the war on terror that we here in America have found
ourselves in, especially since 9/11.
As the gentleman from Utah (Mr. Bishop) before me stated, we were
able to travel to or near the Gaza Strip as the pullout, disengagement,
was taking place. One of the visions that I remember was one that will
go down in history, I imagine, with the settlers that were leaving Gush
Katif, the area of the Gaza Strip in which many Israeli communities
existed. They were actually at one of the junctions in the road and
were pulling down the traffic directional signs pointing to their
community and putting the signs in the back of their truck, knowing
probably that there would never be such a sign that existed again,
because the community will not exist again. A very tragic moment in
many families' lives, but I think something that reflects the bold move
by Prime Minister Sharon in conducting the disengagement and
formulating the policy of disengagement. It was a tremendous step. It
was a tremendous step to create an environment where peace can
flourish.
The problem is, and I am troubled by the Palestinian response to Mr.
Sharon's move, because as we saw the Israeli Army pull out of the Gaza
Strip, we then saw gunshots from the Palestinians in so-called
celebration in what they had termed a ``victory'' that they had driven
Israel out. We saw the transfer of arms across the border with Egypt
into Gaza.
{time} 1915
We saw the Palestinians conducting the burning of synagogues there in
the communities that had been abandoned, and we saw and we read in the
news while we were there that there were rockets being launched from
the Gaza Strip into Israel, all in response or all coinciding with the
Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip.
So it just troubles me that we did not see an in-kind gesture by the
Palestinian Authority, by Mahmoud Abbas and others in his
administration, that would show some type of gesture of goodwill to
reflect the Israeli disengagement and withdrawal from the Gaza Strip;
but if we look throughout what has happened over the past decade or
more, we see that there is a continued pattern of this type of response
from the Palestinian Authority.
Way back in the beginning of the last decade, in the early 1990s,
with the formulation of Oslo, there was a lot of hope, hope among a lot
of people that the Oslo process would bring a long-sought-after peace
between Israelis and the Palestinians. In fact, what happened after the
devolution of that period was the intifada which was the killing of
many innocent people on both sides.
We saw the occurrence of the Wye Accords in 1998 with Arafat and
then-Prime Minister Netanyahu, where Israel agreed to withdraw from
Hebron, and it was a very holy place for the Jewish people; and the
Palestinians responded with violence.
We saw in the year 2000, Camp David, potential of the accords between
then-Prime Minister Barak and Mr. Arafat. It was at that time that
Israel offered nearly 90 percent of the West Bank, offered sovereignty
to the Palestinian people, offered east Jerusalem and the Temple Mount.
What happened? Mr. Arafat walked away, and we have seen nothing but
continued violence, continued terrorist attacks on the people of
Israel.
Yet, after all of that, we see Prime Minister Sharon conducting the
policy of disengagement, again taking one last stab at trying to
achieve peace between the Israeli and Palestinian people. So I think
that we must recognize that bold step.
Our President, who has been a terrific champion of a strong U.S.-
Israel relationship, understands the importance that Israel plays in
our national security strategy, the fact that Israel is fighting the
war on terror on the front lines while we, our young men and women in
uniform, are fighting that same war on terror, not too far away in that
region in Iraq and Afghanistan. This President understands the
importance that Israel plays and has supported Mr. Sharon in his moves
to try and move the peace process forward.
Unfortunately, we just are not seeing any reciprocation on the part
of the Palestinians. We now hear and read of the reports where Hamas is
taking a part and intending to participate in the Palestinian elections
that will occur soon. How in the world can we respect the participation
of a professed terrorist group whose aim is to remove Israel from the
map? How in the world does that help the Palestinian cause for peace?
I am here tonight to express some serious dismay at the response by
the Palestinian Authority and to reflect and congratulate the policies
of Israel and what they are trying to do to secure peace.
Unfortunately, there again has been nothing in return that Israel has
received, and I just encourage my colleagues to continue to monitor
what is going on in that region and how it affects our security here in
America and to, once again, commit ourselves to helping the security of
Israel in its democratic way and to ensure its survival as our only
democratic ally in the Middle East.
Ms. FOXX. Mr. Speaker, I thank the gentleman from Virginia (Mr.
Cantor) so much. He has helped put many things that a lot of us are
concerned about into perspective, and we are grateful to him for that.
I am going to talk a little bit more about Israel and give some facts
about what is happening in Israel in its short history, but let me say
that we know that Israel is one of the only countries in the Middle
East that the United States can truly count on. It is not a fair
weather friend. When terrorists strike American targets in the Middle
East, Israel always stands by our side. We are truly fortunate to have
a strong friend in Israel.
During our trip, we had the opportunity to travel to the countryside,
visit military bases, universities, children's homes, holy sites, and
strategic locations. One of the first things that struck me was just
how much has been accomplished by the Israeli people in
[[Page H8232]]
their nation's short history. I witnessed capitalism at work and saw
how it has enabled the country to prosper. Israel has an amazing
network of roads, a national water system, and has developed other
impressive infrastructure. It is really hard to believe that they have
accomplished so much in just 55 years.
So often when we hear about Israel, it is only in conjunction with
conflicts affecting Israel. My visit made me aware of so many facts
that are never mentioned or discussed by the media. I want to share a
few of those with my colleagues.
The Middle East has been growing date palms for centuries. The
average tree is about 18 to 20 feet tall and yields about 38 pounds of
dates a year. Israeli date trees are now yielding 400 pounds a year and
are short enough to be harvested from the ground or a short ladder.
Israel, the 100th smallest country, with less than 1,000th of the
world's population, can lay claim to the following: The cell phone was
developed in Israel by Israelis working in the Israeli branch of
Motorola which has its largest development center in Israel. Most of
the Windows NT and XP operating systems were developed by Microsoft
Israel. The Pentium MMX chip technology was designed in Israel at
Intel. Both the Pentium 4 microprocessor and the Centrino processor
were entirely designed, developed, and produced in Israel.
Voice mail technology was developed in Israel. Both Microsoft and
Cisco built their only R&D facilities outside the United States in
Israel. The technology for the AOL Instant Messenger ICQ was developed
in 1996 by four young Israelis. Israel has the highest percentage in
the world of home computers per capita.
According to industry officials, Israel designed the airline
industry's most impenetrable flight security. U.S. officials now look,
finally, to Israel for advice on how to handle airborne security
threats.
Israel has the highest ratio of university degrees to the population
in the entire world. Israel produces more scientific papers per capita
than any other nation by a large margin.
In proportion to its population, Israel has the largest number of
start-up companies in the world. In absolute terms, Israel has the
largest number of start-up companies of any country in the world except
the United States.
Israel is ranked number two in the world for venture capital funds,
right behind the United States. Outside the United States and Canada,
Israel has the largest number of NASDAQ-listed companies. It has the
highest average living standards in the Middle East. The per capita
income in 2000 was over $17,500, exceeding that of the United Kingdom.
Twenty-four percent of Israel's workforce holds university degrees,
ranking third in the industrial world, after the United States and
Holland. Twelve percent hold advanced degrees.
In 1984 and 1991, Israel airlifted a total of 22,000 Ethiopian Jews,
called Operation Solomon, at risk in Ethiopia, to safety in Israel.
Relative to its population, Israel is the largest immigrant-absorbing
nation on Earth. Immigrants come in search of democracy, religious
freedom, and economic opportunity.
Israel is the only country in the world that entered the 21st century
with a net gain in its number of trees, made more remarkable because
this was achieved in an area considered mainly desert.
Israel has more museums per capita than any other country. Israeli
scientists developed the first fully computerized, no radiation,
diagnostic instrument for breast cancer. An Israeli company developed a
computerized system for ensuring administration of medications,
removing human error from medical treatment. Every year in U.S.
hospitals, 7,000 patients die from treatment mistakes.
Israel leads the world in the number of scientists and technicians in
the workforce with 145 per 10,000 as opposed to 85 in the U.S., over 70
in Japan, and less than 60 in Germany. With over 25 percent of its
workforce employed in technical professions, Israel places first in
this category as well.
An Israeli company was the first to develop and install a large-scale
solar-powered and fully functional electricity generating plant in
Southern California's Mojave Desert; and as other people have alluded
to, all of the above things have been done while Israel has been
engaged in creating a very strong national defense with an implacable
enemy that seeks its destruction and an economy continuously under
strain by having to spend more per capita on its own protection than
any other country on Earth.
Others have alluded to Israel's size. The entire country is smaller
than the State of New Jersey. In fact, Israel is only 9 miles wide at
its most narrow point. This helps illustrate how vulnerable the country
is in terms of its security.
This point was also emphasized when we visited the Golan Heights.
Israel became painfully aware of the location's strategic importance
during the Yom Kippur War in 1973 when over 2,000 Israelis were killed.
From atop this high mountain, enemies can launch rockets and artillery
fire on the villages below. Israel's control of this piece of real
estate is vital to its security interests.
We also had opportunities to walk the streets of Jerusalem and
witness how closely the Jews and Arabs live together. This particular
journey was also personally meaningful because I experienced the rich
spiritual heritage of the Holy Land. It was humbling to see firsthand
where Jesus Christ, King David, and King Solomon walked. I was also
able to visit the sites of the Last Supper and Christ's crucifixion.
These were very moving experiences.
As my colleagues have mentioned, we met with a broad spectrum of
Israeli and Palestinian officials, including Prime Minister Sharon and
Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. By talking to these
leaders, we were able to gain fundamental insights on security, peace
negotiations, and defense cooperation.
Israel has proved that it is willing to form a lasting peace with any
country that has extended its hand in friendship. Indeed, one of the
things that struck me most is that Israel does not say that it has an
army. The media says it has an army; but in Israel, the people who
protect Israel are called the Israeli Defense Force. Defense force. I
think that is so important. Words are significant, and by calling folks
who protect the country its defense force, it emphasizes that it wants
peace and is not a country that is bent on fighting with its neighbors.
In the war on terror, American and Israeli interests are the same. We
are both committed to stopping the proliferation of weapons of mass
destruction and curbing state-sponsored terrorism.
{time} 1930
For years, we have worked together for a more stable and peaceful
Middle East.
Unfortunately, Israel has had to deal with war and terrorism since it
was established in 1948, and has recently suffered through 4 intense
years of violence that has targeted innocent civilians through suicide
bombings on buses, in restaurants, and in shopping malls. I am saddened
to report that Israel has endured more terrorist attacks than any other
country in the entire world. The perseverance of the Israeli people,
who constantly live their lives in the face of hatred and terrorism, is
truly an inspiration to all of us who love freedom and democracy. The
United States can learn a great deal from Israel's experience in
fighting terror.
As we have already spoken of, just prior to my arrival in Israel,
Prime Minister Sharon made the decision to disengage from Gaza and the
northern West Bank. Israel has withdrawn thousands of citizens from
their homes and communities and relocated them at tremendous emotional
and financial cost to the Israeli Government. Disengagement from Gaza
and parts of the West Bank hold enormous potential in advancing the
peace process if the Palestinians demonstrate they can govern
themselves and curb terrorism. Yet, while this movement has been
supported by a majority of the public, it has been an emotionally
painful undertaking that carries great political and security risks for
Israel. Prime Minister Sharon explained that he was willing to take
these risks because he believes that disengagement is in the best long-
term interest of Israel.
[[Page H8233]]
After my rigorous and informative experiences overseas, I am more
convinced than ever that it is crucial that the United States continue
our strong support for Israel. The country is a beacon of democracy in
a sea of violence and hostility. Both of our nations have a mutual
interest in deterring terror, promoting democracy and stability
throughout the world, and seeking peace in the Middle East. Israel's
ability to function and defend itself against terrorism is in no small
part due to unwavering support from the United States. Our country has
a moral obligation to strengthen our fellow democracies, especially
when they are in turbulent and dangerous regions in the world. It is in
our national security interest to continue to support Israel
financially and morally.
I want to end my remarks by quoting from a speech given by Prime
Minister Sharon to the United Nations General Assembly on September 5,
2005. His final remarks are those that I think all Americans can agree
with. ``In a few days time on the Hebrew calendar, the New Year will
begin, the 5,766th year since the Creation. According to Jewish belief,
the fates of people and nations are determined at the New Year by the
Creator, to be spared or to be doomed. May the Holy One, blessed be He,
determine that this year, our fate and the fate of our neighbors is
peace, mutual respect, and good neighborly relations.''
That is a hope that all of us can share.
____________________