[Congressional Record Volume 142, Number 125 (Thursday, September 12, 1996)]
[Extensions of Remarks]
[Pages E1592-E1593]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]




    INTRODUCTION OF A CONCURRENT RESOLUTION REGARDING PATIENT RIGHTS

                                 ______
                                 

                            HON. LINDA SMITH

                             of washington

                    in the house of representatives

                      Thursday, September 12, 1996

  Mrs. SMITH of Washington. Mr. Speaker, today I will introduce a 
concurrent resolution regarding patient rights. As the nature of health 
care is rapidly changing, it is essential that we reaffirm the 
fundamental rights of all Americans when they are seeking quality 
medical care. Whether we are suffering from something as minor as a 
common cold or more serious like a terminal illness, we want to be sure 
that we are getting the best possible care available for ourselves and 
for our loved ones.
  But the reality is, we are growing increasingly uncertain about what 
our doctors are able to tell us in today's world of managed health care 
where the goal is to provide medical treatment while turning a profit 
for the insurers and providers. Health maintenance organizations, or 
HMO's, came about as means to help control skyrocketing costs in health 
care, and for the most part, they have been effective.
  However, the conflict between producing a profit and providing 
quality care is causing a strain between doctors and their patients and 
is threatening the fundamental element in their relationship: Trust. As 
patients, Americans want to feel like our doctors are giving us all the 
answers. Why should we consult with our insurance agent about treatment 
for a broken arm?
  Our doctors are also being put in an awkward position of balancing 
their patients' needs with those of their medical corporation. As 
health care professionals, their vocation is making people healthy and, 
while they have a responsibility to be cost conscious, fiscal prudence 
should not replace a patient's best interest.
  We need to clarify and emphasize patients' rights so that they feel 
secure when seeking medical attention. That is why I am introducing 
this concurrent resolution that is intended to

[[Page E1593]]

lay the groundwork and principles for legislation in the 105th 
Congress. Specifically, the legislation calls for health care plans to 
be written in plain language and to allow patients to consult with the 
physician of their choice. The bill also limits access to medical 
records to only those immediately involved in the case, and requires 
the patient to be fully briefed on their condition as well as the risks 
and benefits of treatment.
  Too much energy is spent on trying to wade through medical plans, 
finding ways around the bureaucracy and getting medical bills paid. 
Americans want to receive direct and honest answers from their doctors 
and then spend their energy on securing treatment and getting well.

                          ____________________